AC 150/5320-6F Airport Pavement Design and Evaluation
This advisory circular provides guidance to the public on the design and evaluation of pavements used by aircraft at civil airports.
This document is no longer current. Cancelled by 5320-1. Check the official source before relying on it.
U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory Circular
Subject: Airport Pavement Design and Evaluation
Date: 11/10/2016 Initiated by: AAS-100
AC No: 150/5320-6F Change:
Purpose. 1. This advisory circular (AC) provides guidance to the public on the design and evaluation of pavements used by aircraft at civil airports. For reporting of pavement strength, see AC 150/5335-5C, Standardized Method of Reporting Airport Pavement Strength – PCN.
Cancellation. 2. This AC cancels AC 150/5320-6E, Airport Pavement Design and Evaluation, dated September 30, 2009.
Application. 3. The FAA recommends the guidance and standards in this AC for airport pavement design and evaluation. In general, use of this AC is not mandatory. However, use of the standards in this AC is mandatory for all projects funded under the Airport Improvement Program (AIP) or with revenue from the Passenger Facility Charge (PFC) Program.
This AC does not apply to the design of pavements that are not used by aircraft, i.e., roadways, parking lots, and access roads.
Principal Changes. 4. This AC contains the following changes:
Reformatted to comply with FAA Order 1320.46, FAA Advisory Circular System. 1.
Revised text and design examples to incorporate changes in FAARFIELD v1.41 2. pavement design software. Also added general guidance on how to use FAARFIELD.
Simplified and moved guidance on economic analysis to Chapter 1. 3.
ii
Included all pavement design in Chapter 3, including previous guidance on 4. pavement design for airplanes weighing less than 30,000 pounds (13 610 kg).
Defined “Regular use” for pavement design as at least 250 annual departures, 5. which is equivalent to 500 annual operations.
Removed information on embedded steel and continuously reinforced concrete 6. pavement.
Added table on allowable modulus values and Poisson’s Ratios used in 7. FAARFIELD.
Added tables for minimum layer thickness for flexible and rigid pavement 8. structures.
Added detail on reinforcement at a reinforced isolation joint. 9.
Added detail for transition between PCC and HMA pavement sections. 10.
Added appendix, Nondestructive Testing (NDT) Using Falling-Weight Type 11. Impulse Load Devices in the Evaluation of Airport Pavements.
Related Reading Material. 5. The publications listed in Appendix F provide further guidance and detailed information on the design and evaluation of airport pavements.
Units. 6. Through this AC, customary English units will be used followed by “soft” (rounded) conversion to metric units for tables and figures and hard conversion for the text. The English units govern.
Feedback on this AC. 7. If you have suggestions for improving this AC, you may use the Advisory Circular Feedback form at the end of this AC.
Michael O’Donnell Director of Airport Safety and Standards
Contents
Paragraph Page
iii
Chapter 1 . AIRPORT PAVEMENTS—THEIR FUNCTION AND PURPOSES … 1-1
General … 1-1 1.1 Construction Specifications and Geometric Standards … 1-1 1.2
Specifications … 1-1 1.2.1 Geometric Standards … 1-2 1.2.2
Airfield Pavements … 1-2 1.3
Types of Pavement … 1-2 1.3.1 Selection of Pavement Type … 1-2 1.3.2 Cost Effectiveness Analysis … 1-2 1.3.3 Pavement Structure … 1-4 1.3.4
Skid Resistance … 1-6 1.4 Staged Construction … 1-7 1.5 Design of Structures … 1-7 1.6
Chapter 2 . SOIL INVESTIGATIONS AND EVALUATION … 2-1
General … 2-1 2.1
Soil … 2-1 2.1.1 Classification System … 2-1 2.1.2 Subgrade Support … 2-1 2.1.3 Drainage … 2-1 2.1.4
Soil Conditions … 2-2 2.2
Site Investigation … 2-2 2.2.1 Procedures … 2-2 2.2.2 Soil Maps … 2-2 2.2.3 Aerial Photography … 2-2 2.2.4
Surveying and Sampling … 2-3 2.3
Subsurface Borings and Pavement Cores of Existing Pavement … 2-3 2.3.1 Number of Borings, Locations, and Depths … 2-3 2.3.2 Boring Log … 2-4 2.3.3 In-place Testing … 2-4 2.3.4 Number of Cores … 2-5 2.3.5
Soil Tests … 2-5 2.4
Soil Testing Requirements … 2-5 2.4.1 Moisture-Density Relations of Soils … 2-5 2.4.2
Soil Strength Tests … 2-6 2.5 Subgrade Stabilization … 2-8 2.6 Seasonal Frost … 2-10 2.7
Contents (CONTINUED)
Paragraph Page
iv
Frost Susceptibility … 2-10 2.7.1 Depth of Frost Penetration … 2-11 2.7.2 Free Water … 2-11 2.7.3 Frost Design … 2-11 2.7.4
Permafrost … 2-11 2.8
Depth of Thaw Penetration … 2-11 2.8.1 Muskeg … 2-12 2.8.2
Chapter 3 . PAVEMENT DESIGN … 3-1
Design Considerations … 3-1 3.1 FAA Pavement Design … 3-1 3.2 Flexible Pavements … 3-1 3.3 Full-Depth Asphalt Pavements … 3-1 3.4 Rigid Pavements … 3-1 3.5 Stabilized Base Course … 3-2 3.6 Base or Subbase Contamination … 3-2 3.7 Drainage Layer … 3-2 3.8 Subgrade Compaction … 3-3 3.9 Swelling Soils … 3-4 3.10 Pavement Life … 3-5 3.11 Pavement Design Using FAARFIELD … 3-6 3.12
Application … 3-7 3.12.1 Cumulative Damage Factor (CDF) … 3-7 3.12.2 Current Version FAARFIELD … 3-7 3.12.3 Overview of FAARFIELD Program … 3-7 3.12.4 FAARFIELD Pavement Design Process … 3-8 3.12.5 Aircraft Traffic Considerations … 3-9 3.12.6 Non-Aircraft Vehicles … 3-10 3.12.7 Pass-to-Coverage Ratio … 3-11 3.12.8 Annual Departures … 3-13 3.12.9 Cumulative Damage Factor … 3-13 3.12.10 FAARFIELD Material Properties … 3-15 3.12.11 Minimum Layer Thickness … 3-16 3.12.12 Typical Pavement Sections … 3-18 3.12.13 Frost and Permafrost Design … 3-20 3.12.14 Seasonal Frost … 3-20 3.12.15 Complete Frost Protection … 3-20 3.12.16 Limited Subgrade Frost Penetration … 3-20 3.12.17 Reduced Subgrade Strength … 3-21 3.12.18 Permafrost … 3-21 3.12.19
Flexible Pavement Design … 3-22 3.13
Contents (CONTINUED)
Paragraph Page
v
General … 3-22 3.13.1 Hot Mix Asphalt (HMA) Surfacing … 3-22 3.13.2 Base Course … 3-23 3.13.3 Subbase … 3-24 3.13.4 Subgrade … 3-25 3.13.5 FAARFIELD Flexible Pavement Design Failure Mode … 3-26 3.13.6 Flexible Design Example … 3-26 3.13.7 Detailed Example FAARFIELD Compaction Table … 3-38 3.13.8
Rigid Pavement Design … 3-40 3.14
General … 3-40 3.14.1 Concrete Surface Layer … 3-40 3.14.2 Base / Subbase Layers … 3-41 3.14.3 Subgrade: Determination of Modulus (E Value) for Rigid Pavement 3.14.4 Subgrade … 3-41 Frost Effects … 3-42 3.14.5 FAARFIELD Calculation of Concrete Slab Thickness … 3-42 3.14.6 Concrete Flexural Strength … 3-43 3.14.7 Jointing of Concrete Pavements … 3-44 3.14.8 Joint Type Categories and Details … 3-44 3.14.9 Dowels and Tie Bars for Joints … 3-50 3.14.10 Joint Sealants and Fillers … 3-51 3.14.11 Joint Layout and Spacing … 3-51 3.14.12 Joint Spacing … 3-53 3.14.13 Jointing Considerations for Future Pavement Expansion … 3-56 3.14.14 Transition Between PCC and HMA … 3-56 3.14.15 Rigid Design Example … 3-57 3.14.16
Pre-stressed, Precast, Reinforced and Continuously Reinforced Concrete 3.15 Pavement … 3-66 Aggregate Turf Pavements … 3-66 3.16
Materials … 3-66 3.16.1 Thickness … 3-66 3.16.2 Aggregate Turf Pavement Example … 3-66 3.16.3
Heliport Design … 3-67 3.17 Passenger Loading Bridge … 3-68 3.18
Chapter 4 . PAVEMENT REHABILITATION … 4-1
General … 4-1 4.1
Reason for Rehabilitation … 4-1 4.1.1 Full Width Section … 4-1 4.1.2 Transitions … 4-1 4.1.3
Contents (CONTINUED)
Paragraph Page
vi
Condition of Existing Pavement Structure … 4-1 4.2 Material Selection Considerations … 4-2 4.3 Overlay Design … 4-2 4.4 Overlays of Existing Flexible Pavements … 4-3 4.5
FAARFIELD Design HMA Overlay of an Existing Flexible Pavement … 4-3 4.5.1 Nonstructural HMA Overlays … 4-4 4.5.2 Concrete Overlay of an Existing Flexible Pavement … 4-5 4.5.3
Overlays of Existing Rigid Pavements … 4-6 4.6
Structural Condition Index (SCI) … 4-6 4.6.1 Cumulative Damage Factor Used (CDFU) … 4-7 4.6.2
Hot Mix Asphalt Overlays of Existing Rigid Pavements … 4-10 4.7 SCI Less Than 100 … 4-10 4.8
HMA Overlay Over PCC Example … 4-10 4.8.1
SCI Equal to 100 … 4-12 4.9 Concrete Overlays of Existing Concrete Pavements … 4-13 4.10
Fully Unbonded Concrete Overlay … 4-13 4.10.1 Bonded Concrete Overlays … 4-15 4.10.2 Jointing of Concrete Overlays … 4-16 4.10.3 Previously Overlaid Rigid Pavement … 4-16 4.10.4 Treatment of Thick HMA Overlays on Existing Rigid Pavements … 4-16 4.10.5
Alternatives for Rehabilitation of Existing Pavement … 4-17 4.11 Preparation of the Existing Pavement Surface for an Overlay … 4-19 4.12
Flexible Pavements … 4-19 4.12.1 Rigid Pavements … 4-20 4.12.2 Bonded Concrete Overlays … 4-21 4.12.3 Materials and Methods … 4-21 4.12.4
Chapter 5 . PAVEMENT STRUCTURAL EVALUATION … 5-1
Purposes of Structural Evaluation … 5-1 5.1 Evaluation Process … 5-1 5.2
Records Research … 5-1 5.2.1 Site Inspection … 5-1 5.2.2 Pavement Condition Index … 5-1 5.2.3 Sampling and Testing … 5-2 5.2.4 Evaluation Report … 5-3 5.2.5
Flexible Pavements … 5-3 5.3
Layer Thicknesses … 5-3 5.3.1 Subgrade CBR … 5-3 5.3.2
Contents (CONTINUED)
Paragraph Page
vii
Layer Properties … 5-4 5.3.3 Example of Flexible Pavement Evaluation Procedures … 5-4 5.3.4
Overlay Requirement … 5-6 5.4 Rigid Pavements … 5-7 5.5
Layer Thicknesses … 5-7 5.5.1 Concrete Flexural Strength … 5-7 5.5.2 Subgrade Modulus … 5-8 5.5.3 Back Calculated E Modulus Value or k Value in FAARFIELD … 5-8 5.5.4 Example of Rigid Pavement Evaluation Procedures … 5-8 5.5.5
Use of Results … 5-11 5.6 Reporting Pavement Weight Bearing Strength … 5-11 5.7
Aircraft Classification Number/Pavement Classification Number 5.7.1 (ACN/PCN) … 5-11
Chapter 6 . PAVEMENT DESIGN FOR SHOULDERS … 6-1
Purpose … 6-1 6.1 Shoulder Design … 6-1 6.2
The following steps are used for the shoulder design procedure: … 6-2 6.2.4
Shoulder Material Requirements … 6-3 6.3
Asphalt Surface Course Materials … 6-3 6.3.1 Portland Cement Concrete Surface Course Materials … 6-3 6.3.2 Base Course Materials … 6-3 6.3.3 Subbase Course Materials … 6-3 6.3.4 Subgrade Materials … 6-3 6.3.5
Shoulders Areas Susceptible to Frost Heave … 6-4 6.4 Reporting Paved Shoulder Design … 6-4 6.5
Appendix A. Soil Characteristics Pertinent to Pavement Foundations … A-1
Appendix B. Design of Structures … B-1
Appendix C. Nondestructive Testing (NDT) Using Falling-Weight Type Impulse Load
Devices in the Evaluation Of Airport Pavements … C-1
Appendix D. Reinforced Isolation Joint … D-1
Appendix E. Variable Section Runway … E-1
Appendix F. Related Reading Material … F-1
viii
FIGURES
Number Page
Figure 1-1. Typical Pavement Structure … 1-5 Figure 3-1. Overview of FAARFIELD Program … 3-8 Figure 3-2. Effective Tire Width … 3-12 Figure 3-3. CDF Contribution for Airplane Mix … 3-15 Figure 3-4. Typical Plan and Sections for Pavements … 3-19 Figure 3-5. Flexible Design Example Step 1 … 3-28 Figure 3-6. Flexible Design Example Step 2 … 3-28 Figure 3-7. Flexible Design Example Step 4 … 3-29 Figure 3-8. Flexible Design Example Step 4b … 3-30 Figure 3-9. Flexible Design Example Step 6 Perform Design Analysis … 3-31 Figure 3-10. Flexible Design Example Step 6 Results … 3-32 Figure 3-11. Flexible Design Example Options Screen … 3-33 Figure 3-12. Flexible Design Example Final Pavement Structure … 3-34 Figure 3-13. Airport Pavement Design Report … 3-35 Figure 3-13. Airport Pavement Design Report (continued) … 3-36 Figure 3-13. Airport Pavement Design Report (continued) … 3-37 Figure 3-14. FAARFIELD Pavement Structure for Compaction Example … 3-39 Figure 3-15a. Rigid Pavement Isolation Joint … 3-47 Figure 3-15b. Rigid Pavement Contraction and Construction Joints … 3-48 Figure 3-15c. Rigid Pavement Joint Sealant Details … 3-49 Figure 3-16. Typical Joint Layout Pattern for Runway, Parallel Taxiway and Connector … 3-54 Figure 3-17. (Optional) Joint Layout PCC Pavement – 75 Foot Runway Width (Pavements ≤ 9
Figure 1-1 · page 8Picture of the page from the copy saved here
inches)1 … 3-55 Figure 3-18. Transition between PCC and HMA Pavement Sections … 3-57 Figure 3-19. Rigid Design Example Step 2 … 3-59 Figure 3-20. Rigid Design Example Step 2C Modify Structure Information … 3-59 Figure 3-21. Rigid Design Example Step 3 … 3-60 Figure 3-22. Rigid Design Example Step 3 Airplane Data … 3-60 Figure 3-23. Rigid Design Example Step 4 Design Structure … 3-61 Figure 3-24. Rigid Design Example Step 4 Pavement Structure … 3-61 Figure 3-25. Rigid Design Example Step 6 Life/Compaction … 3-62 Figure 3-26. Airport Pavement Step 7 and 8 Design Report … 3-64 Figure 3-26. Airport Pavement Step 7 and 8 Design Report (continued) … 3-65 Figure 3-27. Aggregate Turf Pavement Structure … 3-67 Figure 4-1. Flexible Overlay Structure … 4-4 Figure 4-2. Rigid Overlay Pavement Structure … 4-6 Figure 4-3. Rigid Overlay Percent CDFU … 4-9 Figure 4-4. Flexible Overlay on Rigid Pavement … 4-11 Figure 4-5. HMA overlay of Rigid Traffic … 4-12 Figure 4-6. Flexible Overlay of Rigid … 4-13 Figure 4-7. Rigid Overlay on Existing Fully Unbonded Rigid Pavement … 4-15
ix
Figure 3-18 · page 8Picture of the page from the copy saved here
Figure 5-1. Existing Taxiway Pavement Structure … 5-5 Figure 5-2. Existing Taxiway Structure with User-Defined Surface Layer … 5-6 Figure 5-3. Flexible Pavement Evaluation … 5-7 Figure 5-4. Rigid Pavement Evaluation … 5-10 Figure C-1. Deflection Basin and Sensor Location … C-9 Figure C-2. Deflection Data Analysis and Design Flowchart … C-12 Figure C-3. ISM Plot Identifying Pavement Section Limits … C-14 Figure C-4. Normalized Deflection Plot Identifying Pavement Section Limits … C-14 Figure D-1. Type A-1 Joint Detail … D-1 Figure E-1. Variable Runway Cross-Section … E-2
TABLES
Number Page
Figure 5-1 · page 9Picture of the page from the copy saved here
Table 1-1. Typical Pavement Specifications for Pavement Layers1 … 1-6 Table 2-1. Typical Subsurface Boring Spacing and Depth1 … 2-4 Table 2-2. Soil Frost Groups … 2-10 Table 3-1. Recommended Treatment of Swelling Soils … 3-5 Table 3-2. Allowable Modulus Values and Poisson’s Ratios Used in FAARFIELD … 3-16 Table 3-3. Minimum Layer Thickness for Flexible Pavement Structures, Inches (mm) … 3-17 Table 3-4. Minimum Layer Thickness for Rigid Pavement Structures … 3-18 Table 3-5. Reduced Subgrade Strength Ratings … 3-21 Table 3-6. Computed Compaction Requirements for the Sample Section … 3-39 Table 3-7. Pavement Joint Types … 3-45 Table 3-8. Dimensions and Spacing of Steel Dowels … 3-51 Table 3-9. Recommended Maximum Joint Spacing - Rigid Pavement1 … 3-56 Table 6-1. Minimum Shoulder Pavement Layer Thickness … 6-4 Table C-1. ASTM Standards for Deflection Measuring Equipment … C-5 Table C-2. Recommended Sensor Configuration … C-7
1.2 Construction Specifications and Geometric Standards. › 1.2.1 Specifications.
CHAPTER 1. AIRPORT PAVEMENTS—THEIR FUNCTION AND PURPOSES
General. 1.1
An airport pavement is a complex engineering structure. Pavement analysis and design 1.1.1 involves the interaction of four equally important components: the subgrade (naturally occurring soil), the paving materials (surface layer, base, and subbase), the characteristics of applied loads, and climate.
Airport pavements are designed and constructed to provide adequate support for the 1.1.2 loads imposed by airplanes and to produce a firm, stable, smooth, skid resistant, yearround, all-weather surface free of debris or other particles that can be blown or picked up by propeller wash or jet blast. To fulfill these requirements, the quality and thickness of the pavement must not fail under the imposed loads. The pavement must also possess sufficient inherent stability to withstand, without damage, the abrasive action of traffic, adverse weather conditions, and other deteriorating influences. This requires coordination of many design factors, construction, and inspection to assure the best combination of available materials and workmanship.
The pavement design guidance presented in this AC is based on layered elastic theory 1.1.3 for flexible pavement design and three-dimensional finite element theory for rigid pavement design.. These methodologies address the impact of landing gear configurations and increased pavement load conditions on airport pavements without modifying the underlying design procedures. The failure curves have been calibrated with full scale pavement tests at the FAA National Airport Pavement Test Facility (NAPTF). The FAA has developed the computer program FAA Rigid and Flexible Iterative Elastic Layer Design (FAARFIELD) to assist with pavement design, see chapter 3 for detailed information on FAARFIELD.
Guidance on airport pavement structural evaluation necessary to assess the ability of an 1.1.4 existing pavement to support different types, weights, or volume of airplane traffic is presented this AC. Since the pavement failure models have been updated, current pavement design methodology may produce different pavement thicknesses than the methods used to design the original pavement. Engineering judgment must be used when evaluating results.
Construction Specifications and Geometric Standards. 1.2
Specifications. 1.2.1 Construction material specifications referenced by Item Number (e.g. P-401, Hot Mix Asphalt (HMA) Pavements; P-501, Portland Cement Concrete (PCC) Pavement, etc.) are contained in AC 150/5370-10, Standards for Specifying Construction of Airports.
1.3.3 Cost Effectiveness Analysis. › 1.3.3.1 When considering alternative pavement sections it is assumed…
Geometric Standards. 1.2.2 Airport design standards and recommendations including runway and taxiway geometric design, widths, grades, and slopes are contained in AC 150/5300-13, Airport Design; and lengths of runways is discussed in AC 150/5325-4, Runway Length Requirements for Airport Design.
Airfield Pavements. 1.3
Types of Pavement. 1.3.1 Pavements discussed in this AC include flexible, rigid, and flexible and rigid overlays. Various combinations of pavement types and stabilized layers result in complex pavements classified between flexible and rigid.
Flexible pavements are those in which each structural layer is supported by the
layer below and ultimately supported by the subgrade. Hot mix asphalt (HMA) and P-401/403 refer to flexible pavements. Rigid pavements are those in which the principal load resistance is provided by
the slab action of the surface concrete layer. Portland cement concrete (PCC) and P-501 refer to rigid pavements.
Selection of Pavement Type. 1.3.2
With proper design, materials, construction, and maintenance, any 1.3.2.1 pavement type can provide the desired pavement service life. Historically, airport pavements have performed well for 20 years as shown in Operational Life of Airport Pavements, (DOT/FAA/AR-04/46). However, no pavement structure will perform for the desired service life without using quality materials installed and maintained with timely routine and preventative maintenance.
The selection of a pavement section requires the evaluation of multiple 1.3.2.2 factors including cost and funding limitations, operational constraints, construction time-frame, cost and frequency of anticipated maintenance, environmental constraints, material availability, future airport expansion plans, and anticipated changes in traffic. The engineer must document the rationale for the selected pavement section and service life in the engineer’s report.
Cost Effectiveness Analysis. 1.3.3
When considering alternative pavement sections it is assumed that all 1.3.3.1 alternatives will achieve the desired result. The question is which design alternative results in the lowest total cost over the life of the project and what are the user-cost impacts of alternative strategies. Present worth or present value economic analyses are considered the best methods for evaluating airport pavement design or rehabilitation alternatives. Refer to
1.3.3 Cost Effectiveness Analysis. › 1.3.3.2 From a practical standpoint, if the difference in the present…
OMB Circular A-94, Appendix C, Discount Rates for Cost-Effectiveness, Lease Purchase, and Related Analysis, for real discount rates for the design analysis period. For federally funded projects, use the most recent discount rate published by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) appropriate for a cost effectiveness analysis. When applicable calculate residual salvage values on the straight-line depreciated value of the alternative at the end of the analysis period. The initial cost and life expectancy of the various alternatives should be based on the engineer’s experience with consideration given to local materials, environmental factors, and contractor capability. When considering the effectiveness of various routine and preventative maintenance alternatives, refer to Airfield Asphalt Pavement Technology Program (AAPTP) Project 05-07, Techniques for Prevention and Remediation of Non-Load Related Distresses on HMA Airport Pavements (Phase I).
The basic equation for determining present worth is shown below:
z n m
i
i r S r M C
i
1 1 1 1 PW
1 Where:
PW = Present Worth C = Present Cost of initial design or rehabilitation
activity m = Number of maintenance or rehabilitation
activities Mi = Cost of the ith maintenance or rehabilitation
alternative in terms of present costs, i.e., constant dollars r = Discount rate ni = Number of years from the present of the ith
maintenance or rehabilitation activity S = Salvage value at the end of the analysis period Z = Length of analysis period in years. The FAA
design period is 20 years. For federally funded projects, the FAA must approve other analysis periods.
n
r
1 1 is commonly called the single payment present worth factor in most engineering economic textbooks
From a practical standpoint, if the difference in the present worth of costs 1.3.3.2 between two design or rehabilitation alternatives is 10 percent or less, it is normally assumed to be insignificant and the present worth of the two alternatives can be assumed to be the same.
1.3 Airfield Pavements. › 1.3.4 Pavement Structure.
A cost effectiveness determination includes a life-cycle cost analysis 1.3.3.3 (LCCA). LCCA methodology includes the following steps:
1. Establish alternative design strategies;
2. Determine activity timing (analysis period should be sufficient to reflect long term cost differences including at least one rehab of each alternative); and
3. Estimate direct costs (future costs should be estimated in constant dollars and discounted to the present using real discount rate).
4. Note: Analysis period is period of time over which alternative pavement sections are compared and is not the design life used for the pavement design.
Routine maintenance costs, such as incidental crack sealing, have a 1.3.3.4 marginal effect on net present value (NPV). Focus should be on initial construction, preventative maintenance, and rehabilitation costs. Salvage value should be based on the remaining life of an alternative at the end of the analysis period.
Note: LCCA, at a minimum, should include a sensitivity analysis to address the variability within major analyses input assumptions and estimates. Traditionally, sensitivity analysis has evaluated different discount rates or assigned value of time. The ultimate sensitivity analysis is to perform a probabilistic analysis, which allows multiple inputs to vary simultaneously.
Just because a life cycle cost analysis supports a pavement section does 1.3.3.5 not ensure that funds will be available to support the initial construction. On federally funded projects coordination with and approval by the local FAA Region/ADO is required when considering design periods greater or less than 20 years.
For additional information on performing LCCA, refer to Airfield Asphalt 1.3.3.6 Pavement Technology Program (AAPTP) Report 06-06, Life Cycle Cost Analysis for Airport Pavements, and the Federal Highway Administration Life-Cycle Cost Analysis Primer. AIRCOST, an Excel based spreadsheet for performing LCCA analysis, can be downloaded from http://www.aaptp.us.
Pavement Structure. 1.3.4 Pavement structure consists of surface course, base course, subbase course, and subgrade as illustrated Figure 1-1 and described in Table 1-1.
Surface. Surface courses typically include Portland cement concrete (PCC) and 1. Hot-Mix Asphalt (HMA).
Base. Base courses generally fall into two classes: unstabilized and stabilized. 2.
a. Unstabilized bases consist of crushed and uncrushed aggregates.
b. Stabilized bases consist of crushed and uncrushed aggregates stabilized with
cement or asphalt.
Subbase. Subbase courses consist of granular material, which may be 3. unstabilized or stabilized.
Subgrade. Subgrade consists of natural or modified soils. 4.
Figure 1-1. Typical Pavement Structure
Chapter 1 . AIRPORT PAVEMENTS—THEIR FUNCTION AND PURPOSES › 1.4 Skid Resistance.
Table 1-1. Typical Pavement Specifications for Pavement Layers1
Pavement Layer Flexible Pavement Rigid Pavement
Surface Course P-401/P-4032 P-501
Stabilized Base Course P-401/403 P-401/403
P-3043 P-3043
P-3063 P-3063
Base Course P-2094 P-2085
P-211
P-2094 P-2085
P-211
Subbase Course P-154 P-154
P-2136 P-3016
P-2197 P-2197
Subgrade P-152 P-152
P-155 P-157
P-155 P-157
P-158 P-158
Notes: 1. Refer to AC 150/5370-10, Standards for Specifying Construction of Airports, for the individual specifications.
2. P-601 may be used for locations that need a fuel resistant surface.
3. P-304 and P-306 should be used with caution because it is susceptible to reflective cracking.
4. P-209, Crushed Aggregate Base Course, used as a base course is limited to pavements designed for gross loads of 100,000 pounds (45 360 kg) or less.
5. P-208, Aggregate Base Course, used as base course is limited to pavements designed for gross loads of 60,000 pounds (27 200 kg) or less.
6. Use of P-213 and P-301 as subbase course is not recommended where frost penetration into the subbase is anticipated.
7. P-219, Recycled Concrete Aggregate Base Course, may be used as base depending on quality of materials and gradation.
Skid Resistance. 1.4 Airport pavements should provide a skid resistant surface that will provide good traction during all weather conditions. Refer to AC 150/5320-12, Measurement, Construction, and Maintenance of Skid Resistant Airport Pavement Surfaces, for information on skid resistant surfaces.
Chapter 1 . AIRPORT PAVEMENTS—THEIR FUNCTION AND PURPOSES › 1.6 Design of Structures.
Staged Construction. 1.5 It may be necessary to construct the airport pavement in stages to accommodate changes in traffic, increases in aircraft weights, frequency of operation or to address funding limitations. The stages may be vertical (i.e. successive layer strengthening) or lateral (i.e. widening, lengthening, etc). When designing airport pavements, give consideration for planned runway/taxiway extensions, widening, parallel taxiways, and other changes to ensure that each stage provides an operational surface that can safely accommodate the current traffic. Consider alignments of future development when selecting the longitudinal grades, cross-slope grade, stub-taxiway grades, etc. Design each stage to safely accommodate the traffic using the pavement until the next stage is constructed. Initial construction must consider the future structural needs for the full service life of the pavement. Design and construction of the underlying layers and drainage facilities must be to the standards required for the final pavement crosssections. Refer to AC 150/5320-5, Airport Drainage, for additional guidance on design and construction of airport surface and subsurface drainage systems for airports.
Design of Structures. 1.6 Refer to Appendix B for recommended design parameters for airport structures such as culverts and bridges.
CHAPTER 2. SOIL INVESTIGATIONS AND EVALUATION
General. 2.1 Accurate identification and evaluation of pavement foundations is necessary. The following sections highlight some of the more important aspects of soil mechanics that are important to the geotechnical and pavement engineers.
2.1 General. › 2.1.4 Drainage.
Soil. 2.1.1 For engineering purposes, soil includes all natural deposits that can be moved and manipulated with earth moving equipment, without requiring blasting or ripping. The soil profile is the vertical arrangement of individual soil layers exhibiting physical properties different than the adjacent layer. Subgrade soil is the soil layer that forms the foundation for the pavement structure; it is the soil directly beneath the pavement structure. Subsurface soil conditions include the elevation of the water table, the presence of water bearing strata, and the field properties of the soil. Field properties include the density, moisture content, frost susceptibility, and typical depth of frost penetration.
Classification System. 2.1.2 Use ASTM D 2487, Standard Practice for Classification of Soils for Engineering Purposes (Unified Soil Classification System), to classify soils for civil airport pavements for engineering purposes. Appendix A provides a summary of general soil characteristics pertinent to pavements.
Subgrade Support. 2.1.3
The subgrade soil provides the ultimate support for the pavement and the 2.1.3.1 imposed loads. The pavement structure serves to distribute the imposed load to the subgrade over an area greater than the tire contact area. The available soils with the best engineering characteristics should be incorporated in the upper layers of the subgrade.
The design value for subgrade support should be conservatively selected 2.1.3.2 to ensure a stable subgrade and should reflect the long term subgrade support that will be provided to the pavement. The FAA recommends selecting a value that is one standard deviation below the mean. Where the mean subgrade strength is lower than a California Bearing Ratio (CBR) of 5, it may be necessary to improve the subgrade through stabilization or other means in order to facilitate compaction of the subbase. When the design CBR is lower than 3, it is required to improve the subgrade through stabilization or other means. See paragraph 2.6.
Drainage. 2.1.4 Soil conditions impact the size, extent, and nature of surface and subsurface drainage structures and facilities. General guidance on basic drainage layers is discussed in
Chapter 3. For detailed guidance on design of subsurface drainage layers, refer to AC 150/5320-5, Airport Drainage Design, Appendix G.
2.2 Soil Conditions. › 2.2.4 Aerial Photography.
Soil Conditions. 2.2
Site Investigation. 2.2.1 Soil type and properties for soils to be used on the project must be assessed. If sufficient soils are not available within the boundaries of the airport, identify and investigate additional borrow areas. Investigations should determine the distribution and physical properties of the various types of soil present. This, combined with site topography and climate data, provides the information necessary for planning the development of the airport pavement structure. An investigation of in-situ soil conditions at an airport site will typically include the collection of representative samples of the soils to determine the soil profile and properties identifying the arrangement of the different soils. The site investigation should also include an evaluation of local materials and their availability for possible use in construction of the pavement structure.
Procedures. 2.2.2 ASTM D 420, Standard Guide to Site Characterization for Engineering Design and Construction Purposes, can be used for sampling and surveying procedures and techniques. This method is based on the soil profile. In the field, ASTM D 2488, Standard Practice for Description and Identification of Soils (Visual-Manual Procedures), is commonly used to identify soils by such characteristics as color, texture, structure, consistency, compactness, cementation, and, to varying degrees, chemical composition.
Soil Maps. 2.2.3 Department of Agriculture, Natural Resources Conservation Service soils maps, United States Geological Survey (USGS) geologic maps, and engineering geology maps are valuable aids in the study of soils at and in the vicinity of the airport. The pedagogical classification determined from these maps does not treat soil as an engineering or construction material; however, the data obtained is useful for the engineer conducting preliminary investigations of site selection, development costs, and alignment, as well as for the agronomist in connection with the development of turf areas on airports. Much of this information is available on the respective agency websites.
Aerial Photography. 2.2.4 Relief, drainage, and soil patterns may be determined from aerial photography. A review of historical aerial site photographs may reveal prior drainage patterns and deposits of different soil types. Many websites now provide access to aerial photographs and maps useful for preliminary site investigations.
2.3 Surveying and Sampling. › 2.3.2 Number of Borings, Locations, and Depths.
Surveying and Sampling. 2.3
Subsurface Borings and Pavement Cores of Existing Pavement. 2.3.1
The initial step in an investigation of subsurface conditions is a soil survey 2.3.1.1 to determine the quantity and extent of the different types of soil, the arrangement of soil layers, and the depth of any subsurface water. Profile borings are usually obtained to determine the soil or rock profile and its lateral extent. The spacing of borings cannot always be definitely specified by rule or preconceived plan because of the variations at a site. Sufficient borings should be taken to identify the extent of soils encountered.
Additional steps that may be taken to characterize the subsurface include: 2.3.1.2 Nondestructive testing (NDT) and Dynamic Cone Penetrometer (DCP) tests. Nondestructive testing (NDT), as described in Appendix C, can be used to evaluate subgrade strength and to assist with establishing locations for soil borings as well as sampling locations for evaluation of existing pavements. Dynamic Cone Penetrometer (DCP) tests, per ASTM D 6951 Standard Test Method for Use of the Dynamic Cone Penetrometer in Shallow Pavement Applications, provide useful information. DCP tests can easily be run as each soil layer is encountered as a boring progresses or DCP tests can be run after taking pavement cores of existing pavements. DCP results can provide a quick estimate of subgrade strength with correlations between DCP and CBR. In addition, plots of DCP results provide a graphical representation of the relative strength of subgrade layers. Boring logs from original construction and prior evaluations can also provide useful information.
Cores of existing pavement provide information about the existing 2.3.1.3 pavement structure. It is recommended to take color photographs of pavement cores and include with the geotechnical report.
Number of Borings, Locations, and Depths. 2.3.2 The locations, depths, and numbers of borings should be sufficient to determine and map soil variations. If past experience indicates that settlement or stability in deep fill areas at the location may be a problem, or if in the opinion of the geotechnical engineer more investigations are warranted, additional and/or deeper borings may be required to determine the proper design, location, and construction procedures. Where uniform soil conditions are encountered, fewer borings may be acceptable. Suggested criteria for the location, depth, and number of borings for new construction are given in Table 2-1. Wide variations in these criteria can be expected due to local conditions.
2.3 Surveying and Sampling. › 2.3.4 In-place Testing.
Table 2-1. Typical Subsurface Boring Spacing and Depth1
Area Spacing Depth
Runways, Taxiways and Taxilanes
Random Across Pavement at 200-foot (60 m) Intervals
Cut Areas - 10' (3 m) Below Finished Grade Fill Areas - 10' (3 m) Below Existing Ground
Other Areas of Pavement
1 Boring per 10,000 Square Feet (930 sq m) of Area
Cut Areas - 10' (3 m) Below Finished Grade Fill Areas - 10' (3 m) Below Existing Ground
Borrow Areas Sufficient Tests to Clearly
Define the Borrow Material
To Depth of Borrow Excavation
Note: 1. Boring depths should be sufficient to determine if consolidation and/or location of slippage planes will impact the pavement structure.
Boring Log. 2.3.3
The results of the soil explorations should be summarized in boring logs. 2.3.3.1 A typical boring log includes location of the boring, date performed, type of exploration, surface elevation, depth of materials, sample identification numbers, classification of the material, water table, and standard penetration resistance. Refer to ASTM D 1586 Standard Test Method for Standard Penetration Test (SPT) and Split Barrel Sampling of Soils. Representative samples of the different soil layers encountered should be obtained and tested in the laboratory to determine their physical and engineering properties. If samples not obtained with split barrel, e.g. grab sample from flight auger extreme care should be used to assure that sample is representative and not a mixture of layers. In-situ properties, such as in-place moisture, density, shear strength, consolidation characteristics etc., may require obtaining “undisturbed” core samples per ASTM D 1587 Standard Practice for Thin-Walled Tube Sampling of Fine- Grained Soils for Geotechnical Purposes. Because test results only represent the sample being tested, it is important that each sample be representative of a particular soil type and not be a mixture of several materials.
Identification of soil properties from composite bag samples can lead to 2.3.3.2 misleading representation of soil properties.
In-place Testing. 2.3.4 Pits, open cuts, or both may be required for making in-place bearing tests, taking undisturbed samples, charting variable soil strata, etc. This type of soil investigation may be necessary for projects involving in-situ conditions that warrant a high degree of accuracy.
2.4 Soil Tests. › 2.4.2 Moisture-Density Relations of Soils.
Number of Cores 2.3.5 Sufficient cores should be taken to evaluate condition of existing pavement to help characterize extent and possible causes of distress. Cores of existing pavement structure aid in the determination of the extent of rehabilitation and/or reconstruction required to correct the distress.
Soil Tests. 2.4
Soil Testing Requirements. 2.4.1
The geotechnical engineer should identify the tests necessary to 2.4.1.1 characterize the soil properties for the project. Subsurface evaluations may include the following standards:
1. ASTM D 421 Standard Practice for Dry Preparation of Soil Samples for Particle-Size Analysis and Determination of Soil Constants. This procedure is used to prepare samples for particle-size and plasticity tests to determine test values on air-dried samples.
2. ASTM D 422 Standard Test Method for Particle-Size Analysis of Soils. This analysis covers the quantitative determination of the particle sizes in soils.
3. ASTM D 4318 Standard Test Methods for Liquid Limit, Plastic Limit, and Plasticity Index of Soils.
The plastic and liquid limits of a soil define the lowest moisture content at 2.4.1.2 which a soil will change from a semisolid to a plastic state and a solid passes from a plastic to a liquid state, respectively. The plasticity index is the numerical difference between the plastic limit and the liquid limit and indicates the range in moisture content over which a soil remains in a plastic state prior to changing into a liquid. The plastic limit, liquid limit, and plasticity index of soils are used with the Unified Soil Classification System (ASTM D 2487) to classify soils. They are also used, either individually or together, with other soil properties to correlate with engineering behavior such as compressibility, permeability, compactibility, shrink-swell, and shear strength.
Moisture-Density Relations of Soils. 2.4.2 For compaction control during construction, the following ASTM test methods can be used to determine the moisture-density relations of the different soil types:
Pavements Loads of 60,000 Pounds (27 216 kg) or More. For pavements 1. designed to serve airplanes weighing 60,000 pounds (27 200 kg) or more, use ASTM D 1557, Standard Test Methods for Laboratory Compaction Characteristics of Soil Using Modified Effort (56,000 ft-lbf/ft3 (2,700 kN-m/m3)).
2.5 Soil Strength Tests. › 2.5.6 California Bearing Ratio (CBR).
Pavement Loads Less than 60,000 Pounds (27 216 kg). For pavements 2. designed to serve airplanes weighing less than 60,000 pounds (27 200 kg), use ASTM D 698, Standard Test Methods for Laboratory Compaction Characteristics of Soil Using Standard Effort (12 400 ft-lbf/ft3 (600 kN-m/m3)).
2.5
2.5.1
2.5.2
2.5.3
2.5.4
2.5.5
2.5.6
Soil Strength Tests.
Soil classification for engineering purposes provides an indication of the suitability of the soil as a pavement subgrade. However, the soil classification does not provide sufficient information to predict pavement behavior. Performance variations can occur due to a variety of reasons including degree of compaction, degree of saturation (moisture content), height of overburden, etc.
For pavement design and evaluation, subgrade materials are characterized by a suitable strength or modulus parameter. For pavements to be designed with FAARFIELD, subgrade quality is best characterized by the Elastic Modulus (E), which is the material parameter used in internal FAARFIELD calculations. The value of E to be used in design or evaluation may be obtained by a variety of means.
For flexible pavements, the strength of the subgrade is typically measured by CBR tests. The elastic modulus E can be estimated from CBR using the following correlation: E (psi) = 1500 × CBR or E (MPa) = 10 × CBR. This is only an approximate relationship that is generally adequate for pavement design and analysis.
For rigid pavements, the strength of the subgrade is ideally measured by a plate load test, which gives the modulus of subgrade reaction (k-value). The elastic modulus E can be estimated from k-value using the following correlation: E (psi) = 20.15 × k1.284 (k in pci). This is only an approximate relationship that is generally adequate for pavement design and analysis. If plate-load test data are unavailable, then the elastic modulus E should be estimated from CBR using the formula in paragraph 2.5.3.
In some cases, for example when designing overlays on existing pavements, it is not possible to obtain estimates of E from CBR or plate load data. In these cases, an estimate of E may be obtained by back-calculation from falling-weight deflectometer (FWD) data or other nondestructive testing (NDT) using the methods described in Chapter 5 and Appendix C.
California Bearing Ratio (CBR). The CBR test is basically a penetration test conducted at a uniform rate of strain. The force required to produce a given penetration in the material under test is compared to the force required to produce the same penetration in a standard crushed limestone. The result is expressed as a ratio of the two forces (e.g., a material with a CBR of 15 means the material offers 15 percent of the resistance to penetration that the standard crushed limestone offers). Laboratory CBR tests should be performed in accordance with ASTM D 1883, Standard Test Method for California Bearing Ratio (CBR) of Laboratory-Compacted Soils. Field CBR tests should be conducted in accordance with
2.5.7 Plate Bearing Test. › 2.5.7.1 The plate bearing test measures the bearing capacity of the…
ASTM D 4429, Standard Test Method for CBR (California Bearing Ratio) of Soils in Place.
Laboratory CBR. Laboratory CBR tests are conducted on materials obtained 1. from the site and remolded to the density that will be obtained during construction. Pavement foundations tend to reach nearly complete saturation after about 3 years. The CBR test should be run at a moisture content that simulates the condition of a pavement that has been in service for time, typically this is what is referred to as a ‘soaked’ or ‘saturated’ CBR. Seasonal moisture changes also dictate the use of a soaked CBR design value since traffic must be supported during periods of high moisture such as spring thaw.
Field CBR. Field CBR tests provide information on foundation materials that 2. have been in place for several years. The materials should be in place for a sufficient time to allow for the moisture to reach an equilibrium condition, i.e. a fill that has been constructed and surcharged for a long period of time prior to pavement construction.
CBR Gravelly Materials. CBR tests are difficult to interpret on gravelly 3. materials. Laboratory CBR tests on gravel often yield CBR results that are too high due to the confining effects of the mold. The assignment of CBR values to gravelly subgrade materials may be based on judgment and experience. The FAA pavement design procedure recommends a maximum subgrade E value of 50,000 psi (345 MPa) (CBR=33) for use in design.
Lime Rock Bearing Ratio. If the lime rock bearing ratio (LBR) is used to 4. express soil strength, it may be converted to CBR by multiplying the LBR by 0.8.
Number of CBR Tests. The number of CBR tests required to establish a design 5. value cannot be simply stated. Variability of the soil conditions encountered at the site combined with the low reliability of CBR tests has a significant influence on the number of tests needed. From three to seven CBR tests on each different major soil type should be sufficient.
Plate Bearing Test. 2.5.7
The plate bearing test measures the bearing capacity of the pavement 2.5.7.1 foundation. The result, modulus of subgrade reaction (k value) is a measure of the pressure required to produce a unit deflection of the pavement foundation. The k value has the units pounds per cubic inch (Mega-newton per cubic meter). Plate bearing tests should be performed in accordance with the procedures contained in AASHTO T 222 Standard Method of Test for Non-repetitive Static Plate Load Test of Soils and Flexible Pavement Components for Use in Evaluation and Design of Airport and Highway. This method covers the making of non-repetitive static plate load tests on subgrade soils and flexible pavement components, in either the compacted condition or the natural state, and is intended to provide data for use in the evaluation and design of rigid and flexible-type airport and highway pavements.
2.6 Subgrade Stabilization. › 2.6.2 A geotechnical engineer should be consulted to determine what…
In lieu of the plate bearing test, the k value may be estimated from the 2.5.7.2 CBR per paragraph 3.14.4.
1. Plate Bearing Test Conditions. Plate bearing tests are conducted in the field on test sections constructed to the design compaction and moisture conditions. A correction to the k value is required to simulate the moisture conditions likely to be encountered by the inservice pavement.
2. Plate Size. The rigid pavement design presented in this AC is based on the elastic modulus (E) or resilient modulus (k value). The k value can be determined by a static plate load test using a 30-inch (762 mm) diameter plate. Using a smaller plate diameter may result in a higher k value.
3. Number of Plate Bearing Tests. Plate bearing tests are expensive to perform and the number of tests that can be conducted to establish a design value is limited. Generally only two or three tests can be performed for each pavement feature. The design k value should be conservatively selected.
Additional Soil Strength Tests. 2.5.8 Other tests that may be used to assist in evaluating subgrade soils include ASTM D 3080, Standard Test Method for Direct Shear Tests of Soils Under Consolidated Drained Conditions, ASTM D 2573, Standard Test Method for Field Vane Shear Tests in Cohesive Soil, or ASTM D 2166 Standard Test Method for Unconfined Compressive Strength of Cohesive Soil.
Subgrade Stabilization. 2.6
Where the mean subgrade strength is lower than a modulus of 7,500 psi (CBR 5), it may 2.6.1 be necessary to improve the subgrade chemically, mechanically, or by replacement with suitable subgrade material. When the design modulus is lower than 4,500 psi (CBR is lower than 3), it is necessary to improve the subgrade through stabilization or replacement with suitable subgrade material. Subgrade stabilization should also be considered if any of the following conditions exist: poor drainage, adverse surface drainage, frost, or need for a stable working platform. Subgrade stabilization can be accomplished through the use of chemical agents or by mechanical methods. It is often beneficial to stabilize the subgrade to create a stable construction working platform. When it is not possible to create a stable subgrade with either chemical or mechanical stabilization it may be necessary to remove and replace the unsuitable material.
A geotechnical engineer should be consulted to determine what long-term strength can 2.6.2 be achieved with stabilized layers. It is recommended to use a very conservative estimate of the benefit unless you have tests results to substantiate the long-term benefit. Note: Generally the stabilized layer should be 12 in (300 mm) or otherwise recommend by the geotechnical engineer. When designing pavements that include a layer of
2.6.5 Geosynthetics. › 2.6.5.3 Currently, the FAA does not consider any reductions in pavement…
stabilized material it may be necessary to model this layer as a user defined layer when performing pavement structural design in FAARFIELD, see Chapter 3
Chemical Stabilization. 2.6.3 Different soil types require different stabilizing agents for best results. The following publications are recommended to determine the appropriate type and amount of chemical stabilization for subgrade soils: Unified Facilities Criteria (UFC) Manual Pavement Design for Airfields, UFC 3-260-02; Soil Cement Construction Handbook, Portland Cement Association; The Asphalt Institute Manual Series MS-19, Basic Asphalt Emulsion Manual; and AC 150/5370-10, Items P-155, P-157, and P-158. See paragraph 3.13.5.5 for information regarding how to model chemical stabilized layers in FAARFIELD.
Mechanical Stabilization. 2.6.4 In some instances, subgrades cannot be adequately stabilized through the use of chemical additives. The underlying soils may be so soft that stabilized materials cannot be mixed and compacted over the underlying soils without failing the soft soils. To facilitate construction of the pavement section, extremely soft soils may require bridging of the weak soils. Bridging can be accomplished with the use of thick layers, 2-3 feet (600-900mm), of shot rock or cobbles. If open-graded aggregate layers are used for subgrade replacement, ensure that the layer is fully wrapped in geotextile fabric to prevent migration of fine soil particles into the layer. Thick layers of lean, porous concrete or geosynthetics may also be used as the first layer of mechanical stabilization over soft, fine-grained soils.
Geosynthetics. 2.6.5
The term geosynthetics describes a range of manufactured synthetic 2.6.5.1 products used to address geotechnical problems. The term is generally understood to encompass four main products: geotextiles, geogrids, geomembranes, and geocomposites. The synthetic nature of the materials in these products makes them suitable for use in the ground where high levels of durability are required. These products have a wide range of applications, including use as a separation between subbase aggregate layers and the underlying subgrade.
The need for geosynthetics within a pavement section depends on 2.6.5.2 subgrade soil conditions, groundwater conditions, and the type of overlying pavement aggregate. The geotechnical engineer should clearly identify what the geosynthetic is intended to provide to the pavement structure. The most common use on airports is as a separation layer to prevent migration of fines.
Currently, the FAA does not consider any reductions in pavement 2.6.5.3 structure for the use of any geosynthetics. The FAA is currently researching the use of geosynthetics with aircraft loadings.
Seasonal Frost. 2.7 The design of pavements in areas subject to seasonal frost action requires special consideration. The detrimental effects of frost action may include non-uniform heave and a loss of soil strength during warm periods and spring thaw. Other detrimental effects include possible loss of compaction, development of pavement roughness, restriction of drainage, and cracking and deterioration of the pavement surface. Three conditions must exist simultaneously for detrimental frost action:
2.7 Seasonal Frost. › 2.7.1 Frost Susceptibility.
The soil must be frost susceptible, 1.
Freezing temperatures must penetrate into the frost susceptible soil, and 2.
Free moisture must be available in sufficient quantities to form ice lenses. 3.
Frost Susceptibility. 2.7.1 The frost susceptibility of soils is dependent to a large extent on the size and distribution of voids in the soil mass. Voids must be of a certain critical size for the development of ice lenses. Empirical relationships have been developed correlating the degree of frost susceptibility with the soil classification and the amount of material finer than 0.02 mm by weight. Soils are categorized into four frost groups for frost design purposes as defined in Table 2-2: Frost Group 1 (FG-l), FG-2, FG-3, and FG-4. The higher the frost group number, the more susceptible the soil, i.e., soils in FG-4 are more frost susceptible than soils in frost groups 1, 2, or 3.
Table 2-2. Soil Frost Groups
Frost Group Kind of Soil
Percentage Finer
than 0.02 mm by
Weight
Soil Classification
FG-1 Gravelly Soils 3 to 10 GW, GP, GW-GM, GP-GM
FG-2 Gravelly Soils Sands
10 to 20 3 to 5 GM, GW-GM, GP-GM SW, SP, SM, SW-SM, SP- SM
FG-3 Gravelly Soils Sands, except very fine silty sands Clays, PI above 12
Over 20 Over 15
-
GM, GC SM, SC CL, CH
FG-4 Very fine silty sands All Silts Clays, PI = 12 or less Varved Clays and other fine grained banded sediments
Over 15
- -
-
SM ML, MH CL, CL-ML CL, CH, ML, SM
2.8 Permafrost. › 2.8.1 Depth of Thaw Penetration.
Depth of Frost Penetration. 2.7.2 The depth of frost penetration is a function of the thermal properties of the pavement and soil mass, the surface temperature, and the temperature of the pavement and soil mass at the start of the freezing season. In determining the frost penetration depth, give primary consideration to local engineering experience. Local construction practice, including the experience of local building departments, is generally a good guide to frost penetration depth, e.g. depth of water mains and depth of local foundation designs. The pavement design program PCASE includes a module to help evaluate the depth of frost penetration. PCASE is available at https://transportation.erdc.dren.mil/pcase/software.aspx.
Free Water. 2.7.3 For frost action to occur, there must be free water in the soil mass that can freeze and form ice lenses. Water can enter the soil from many different sources, e.g. by infiltration from the surface or sides of the pavement structure, by condensation of atmospheric water vapor, or drawn from considerable depths by capillary action. Generally speaking, if the degree of saturation of the soil is 70 percent or greater, frost heave will probably occur. The designer should assume that sufficient water will be present to cause detrimental frost action for any soil that may be susceptible to frost action. Edge drain systems may help reduce the amount of available water however the effectiveness of the edge drain system will be impacted by the type of subgrade soil present. Generally edge drain systems are most effective in removing free water when combined with a subsurface drainage layer. See AC 150/5320-5, Airport Drainage Design.
Frost Design. 2.7.4 The design of pavements to offset seasonal frost effects is discussed in Chapter 3. A more rigorous evaluation for frost effects is necessary when designing for pavement service life greater than 20 years. A discussion of frost action and its effects can be found in Research Report No. FAA-RD-74-030, Design of Civil Airfield Pavement for Seasonal Frost and Permafrost Conditions.
Permafrost. 2.8 In arctic regions, soils are often frozen to considerable depths year round. Seasonal thawing and refreezing of the upper layer of permafrost can lead to severe loss of bearing capacity and/or differential heave. In areas with continuous permafrost at shallow depths, utilize non-frost susceptible base course materials to prevent degradation (thawing) of the permafrost layer. The frost susceptibility of soils in permafrost areas is classified the same as in Table 2-2.
Note: In areas of permafrost, an experienced pavement/geotechnical engineer familiar with permafrost protection must design the pavement structure.
Depth of Thaw Penetration. 2.8.1 Pavement design for permafrost areas must consider the depth of seasonal thaw penetration. The thawing index used for design (design thawing index) should be based
on the three warmest summers in the last 30 years of record. If 30-year records are not available, data from the warmest summer in the latest 10-year period may be used.
2.8 Permafrost. › 2.8.2 Muskeg.
Muskeg. 2.8.2 Muskeg is a highly organic soil deposit that is essentially a swamp that is sometimes encountered in arctic areas. If construction in areas of muskeg is unavoidable, and the soil survey shows the thickness of muskeg is less than 5 feet (1.5 m), the muskeg should be removed and replaced with granular fill. If the thickness of muskeg is too great to warrant removal and replacement, a 5-foot (1.5 m) granular fill should be placed over the muskeg. These thicknesses are based on experience. Differential settlement will occur and considerable maintenance will be required to maintain a smooth surface. Use of a geosynthetic between the muskeg surface and the bottom of granular fill may be necessary to prevent migration of the muskeg up into the granular fill.
Chapter 3 . PAVEMENT DESIGN › 3.5 Rigid Pavements.
CHAPTER 3. PAVEMENT DESIGN
Design Considerations. 3.1 This chapter provides pavement design guidance for airfield pavements. Since the FAA computer program FAARFIELD is used for all pavement designs, there is no longer a differentiation between pavement design for light and aircraft greater than 30,000 pounds. Procedures for overlay design are covered in Chapter 4, and procedures for evaluating pavements are covered in Chapter 5.
FAA Pavement Design. 3.2 The design of airport pavements is a complex engineering problem that involves the interaction of multiple variables. This chapter presents mechanistic-empirical pavement design procedures that are implemented in the FAARFIELD computer program. FAARFIELD uses layered elastic and three-dimensional finite element-based design procedures for new and overlay designs of flexible and rigid pavements respectively. The structural design of pavements on federally funded projects must be completed using FAARFIELD, and a copy of the pavement design report must be included with the engineer’s report.
Flexible Pavements. 3.3 For flexible pavement design, FAARFIELD uses the maximum vertical strain at the top of the subgrade and the maximum horizontal strain at the bottom of all asphalt layers as the predictors of pavement structural life. FAARFIELD provides the required thickness for all individual layers of flexible pavement (surface, base, and subbase) required to support a given airplane traffic mix for the structural design life over a given subgrade.
Full-Depth Asphalt Pavements. 3.4 Full-depth asphalt pavements that contain asphaltic cement in all components above the prepared subgrade may be used for pavements less than 60,000 pounds (27215 kg). FAARFIELD has the ability to analyze full depth asphalt pavements by only including HMA surface layer and a subgrade layer; however the program will identify it as a nonstandard layer. The preferred method of analyzing a full-depth asphalt pavement is to use a 3-layer structure consisting of a HMA surface layer on top of a HMA flexible stabilized base. The Asphalt Institute (AI) has published guidance on the design of full depth asphalt pavements for light airplanes in Information Series No. 154 (IS 154) Thickness Design - Asphalt Pavements for General Aviation. Use of the AI design method requires approval by the FAA. On federally funded projects full-depth asphalt pavements may be used in other applications when approved by the FAA.
Rigid Pavements. 3.5 For rigid pavement design, FAARFIELD uses the maximum horizontal stress at the bottom of the PCC slab as the predictor of the pavement structural life. The maximum
horizontal stress for design is determined considering both PCC slab edge and interior loading conditions. FAARFIELD provides the required thickness of the rigid pavement slab required to support a given airplane traffic mix for the structural design life over a given base/subbase/subgrade.
3.8 Drainage Layer › 3.8.2 Pavements constructed in non-frost areas constructed on subgrade…
Stabilized Base Course. 3.6
If aircraft in the design traffic mix have gross loads of 100,000 pounds (45,359 kg) or 3.6.1 more, then use of a stabilized base is required. Crushed aggregates that can be proven to exhibit a remolded soaked CBR of 100 or greater may be substituted for a stabilized base course. In areas subject to frost penetration, the materials should meet permeability and non-frost susceptibility tests in addition to the CBR requirements. Other exceptions to the policy include proven performance under similar airplane loadings and climatic conditions comparable to those anticipated. Subbases used under stabilized bases should exhibit a remolded soaked CBR (per ASTM D1883) of at least 35. Suitable subbases for use under a stabilized base include P-209, P-208, or P-211. Other materials, such as P-219, may be acceptable with FAA approval.
Full scale performance tests have proven that pavements which include stabilized bases 3.6.2 have superior performance. Long term performance gains should be considered before making substitutions to eliminate stabilized base. Exceptions to use of stabilized base may be considered when less than 5% of the traffic is aircraft with gross loads of 100,000 pounds (45,359 kg) or more but all aircraft gross loads are less than 110,000 pounds (49,895 kg).
Base or Subbase Contamination. 3.7 Contamination of subbase or base aggregates may occur during construction and/or once pavement is in service. A loss of structural capacity can result from contamination of base and/or subbase elements with fines from underlying subgrade soils. The contamination reduces the quality of the aggregate material, thereby reducing its ability to protect the subgrade. Geosynthetic separation fabrics can be effectively used to reduce aggregate contamination (refer to paragraph 2.6).
Drainage Layer 3.8
General guidance on basic drainage layers is discussed below. For detailed guidance on 3.8.1 subsurface drainage layers, refer to AC 150/5320-5 Airport Drainage Design, Appendix G, Design of Subsurface Drainage Systems.
Pavements constructed in non-frost areas constructed on subgrade soils with a 3.8.2 coefficient of permeability less than 20 ft/day (6 m/day) should include a subsurface drainage layer. Pavements in frost areas constructed on FG2 or higher subgrade soils should include a subsurface drainage layer. For rigid pavements the drainage layer is usually placed immediately beneath the concrete slab. For flexible pavements the drainage layer is usually placed immediately above the subgrade. An effective drainage
3.9 Subgrade Compaction. › 3.9.4 The subgrade for new flexible and rigid pavements in cut areas…
layer will attain 85 percent drainage in 24 hours for runways and taxiways, and 85 percent drainage in 10 days for aprons and other areas with low speed traffic. In the structural design of the concrete slab the drainage layer along with the granular separation layer is considered a base layer. In flexible pavement structures when the required thickness of the granular subbase is equal to or greater than the thickness of the drainage layer plus the thickness of the separation layer, the drainage layer is placed beneath the aggregate base. Where the total thickness of the pavement structure is less than 12 inches (300 mm), the drainage layer may be placed directly beneath the surface layer and the drainage layer used as a base. When the drainage layer is placed beneath an unbound aggregate base, limit the material passing the No. 200 (0.075 mm) sieve in the aggregate base to less than 8 percent or less in accordance with AC 150/5370-10.
Subgrade Compaction. 3.9
FAARFIELD computes compaction requirements for the specific pavement design and 3.9.1 traffic mixture and generates tables of required minimum density requirements for the subgrade. The values in these tables denote the range of depths for which densities should equal or exceed the indicated percentage of the maximum dry density as specified in Item P-152. Since compaction requirements are computed in FAARFIELD after the thickness design is completed, the computed compaction tables indicate recommended depth of compaction as measured from both the pavement surface and the top of finished subgrade. FAARFIELD determines whether densities are in accordance with ASTM D 698 or ASTM D 1557 based on weight of aircraft. ASTM D 698 applies for aircraft less than 60,000 pounds (27 200 kg) and ASTM D 1557 applies for aircraft 60,000 pounds (27 200 kg) and greater.
The compaction requirements implemented in the FAARFIELD computer program are 3.9.2 based on the Compaction Index (CI) concept. More information may be found in U.S. Army Engineer Waterways Experiment Station, Technical Report No. 3-529, Compaction Requirements for Soil Components of Flexible Airfield Pavements (1959).
FAARFIELD generates two tables applicable to non-cohesive and cohesive soil types 3.9.3 respectively. The appropriate compaction controls should be used for the actual soil type. Note: Non-cohesive soils, for the purpose of determining the compaction requirement, are those with a plasticity index of less than 3.
The subgrade for new flexible and rigid pavements in cut areas should have natural in- 3.9.4 place densities equal to or greater than those computed by FAARFIELD for the given soil type. If the natural in-place densities of the subgrade are less than required, the subgrade should be (a) compacted to achieve the required densities (b) removed and replaced with suitable material at the required densities, or (c) covered with sufficient select or subbase material so the in-place densities of the natural subgrade meet the design requirements. It is a good practice to rework and recompact at least the top 12 inches (300 mm) in cut areas; however, depending upon the in-place densities, it may be necessary to rework and recompact additional subgrade material. The maximum
3.10 Swelling Soils. › 3.10.4 Additional information on identifying and handling swelling…
practical depth of compaction of soils in cut areas is generally limited to 72 inches (1,829 mm) below the top of finished pavement.
For cohesive soils used in fill sections, for new flexible and rigid pavements, the entire 3.9.5 fill must be compacted to 90 percent maximum density. For non-cohesive soils used in fill sections, the top 6 inches (150 mm) of fill must be compacted to 100 percent maximum density, and the remainder of the fill must be compacted to 95 percent maximum density, regardless of any lesser requirement indicated by FAARFIELD. When supported by a geotechnical engineers report lower compaction requirements may be justified to address unique local soil conditions.
Swelling Soils. 3.10
Swelling soils are clayey soils that exhibit a significant volume change caused by 3.10.1 moisture variations. Airport pavements constructed on swelling soils are subject to differential movements causing surface roughness and cracking. When swelling soils are present, the pavement design should incorporate methods to prevent or reduce the effects of soil volume changes. Local experience and judgment should be applied in dealing with swelling soils to achieve the best results.
The clay minerals that cause swelling, in descending order of swelling activity, are 3.10.2 smectite, illite, and kaolinite. These soils usually have liquid limits above 40 and plasticity indexes above 25.
Soils that exhibit a swell of greater than 3 percent when tested for the CBR, per ASTM 3.10.3 D 1883 Standard Test Method for California Bearing Ration (CBR) of Laboratory- Compacted Soils, require treatment. Treatment of swelling soils consists of removal and replacement, stabilization, and compaction efforts in accordance with Table 3-1. Adequate drainage is important when dealing with swelling soils.
Additional information on identifying and handling swelling soils is presented in FAA 3.10.4 Reports No. FAA-RD-76-066 Design and Construction of Airport Pavements on Expansive Soils, and DOT/FAA/PM-85115 Validation of Procedures for Pavement Design on Expansive Soils.
Table 3-1. Recommended Treatment of Swelling Soils
3.11 Pavement Life. › 3.11.1 Design Life in FAARFIELD refers to structural life.
Swell Potential (Based on Experience)
Percent Swell
Measured (ASTM D
1883)
Potential for
Moisture Fluctuation1 Treatment
Low 3-5 Low Compact soil on wet side of optimum (+2% to +3%) to not greater than 90% of
appropriate maximum density.2
High Stabilize soil to a depth of at least 6 in.
(150 mm)
Medium 6-10 Low Stabilize soil to a depth of at least 12 in.
(300 mm)
High Stabilize soil to a depth of at least 12 in.
(300 mm)
High Over 10 Low Stabilize soil to a depth of at least 12 in.
(300 mm)
High For uniform soils, i.e., redeposited clays,
stabilize soil to a depth of at least 36 in. (900 mm) or raise grade to bury swelling
soil at least 36 in. (900 mm) below pavement section or remove and replace
with non-swelling soil. For variable soil deposits depth of treatment should be increased to 60 in. (1
500 mm).
Notes: 1. Potential for moisture fluctuation is a judgment determination and should consider proximity of water table, likelihood of variations in water table, as well as other sources of moisture, and thickness of the swelling soil layer.
2. When control of swelling is attempted by compacting on the wet side of optimum at a reduced density, the design subgrade strength should be based on the higher moisture content and reduced density.
Pavement Life. 3.11
Design Life in FAARFIELD refers to structural life. Structural life for design is related 3.11.1 to the total number of load cycles a pavement structure will carry before it fails. Structural life is distinguished from functional life, which is the period of time that the pavement is able to provide an acceptable level of service as measured by performance indicators such as: foreign object debris (FOD), skid resistance, or roughness.
Chapter 3 . PAVEMENT DESIGN › 3.12 Pavement Design Using FAARFIELD.
The structural design of airport pavements consists of determining both the overall 3.11.2 pavement thickness and the thickness of the component parts of the pavement structure. A number of factors influence the required thickness of pavement including: the impact of the environment, the magnitude and character of the airplane loads it must support, the volume and distribution of traffic, the strength of the subgrade soils, and the quality of materials that make up the pavement structure. Pavements are designed to provide a finite structural life at design fatigue limits. It is theoretically possible to perform a pavement structural design for any service period. However, to achieve the intended life requires consideration of many interacting factors including: airplane mix, quality of materials and construction, and routine and preventative pavement maintenance.
Pavements on federally funded FAA projects are designed for a 20-year structural life. 3.11.3 Designs for longer periods may be appropriate at airfields where the configuration of the airfield is not expected to change and where future traffic can be forecast with relative confidence beyond 20 years. A longer design life may be appropriate for a runway at a large hub airport where the future aircraft traffic can be forecast and where both the location and size of the runway and taxiways is not anticipated to change. However, when designing a taxiway at a smaller airport, it may be more prudent to design for no more than 20 years than to forecast the composition and frequency of future activity. Similarly, a phased project may only require a temporary pavement for 1-2 years. Many airports have significant changes planned, but whether these plans ultimately become reality depends on local economic conditions (e.g., business upturns or downturns at the fixed base operator (FBO), or the number and composition of based aircraft). Typically a life cycle cost effectiveness analysis is utilized to support design periods other than 20 years. However, fiscal constraints (i.e., funds available) may dictate which pavement section(s) and design life are considered. On federally funded projects FAA approval is required to use a design period other than 20 years.
To achieve intended design life all pavements require quality materials and construction 3.11.4 combined with routine and/or preventative maintenance. To maximize a pavement’s life, routine crack sealing and applications of pavement seal coats will be required for flexible pavements, and crack sealing and joint sealant repair/replacement will be required for rigid pavement. In addition, isolated slab replacement may be needed for some rigid pavements as well as small patches for some flexible pavements. Due to deterioration from normal use and the environment, rehabilitation of surface grades and renewal of skid-resistant properties may also be needed for both flexible and rigid pavements. Functional life may be longer or shorter than structural life, but is generally much longer when pavements are maintained properly.
Pavement Design Using FAARFIELD. 3.12 The FAA developed FAARFIELD using failure models based on full-scale tests conducted from the 1940s through the present. FAARFIELD is based on layered elastic and three-dimensional finite element-based structural analysis developed to calculate design thicknesses for airfield flexible and rigid pavements respectively.
3.12 Pavement Design Using FAARFIELD. › 3.12.4 Overview of FAARFIELD Program.
Application. 3.12.1 The procedures and design software identified in this chapter provide standard pavement thickness designs meeting structural requirements for all airfield pavements. FAARFIELD currently does not take into account provisions for frost protection and permafrost discussed in paragraph 3.12.14. It is the responsibility of the user to check these provisions separately from FAARFIELD and to modify the thickness design if necessary to provide additional frost and or permafrost resistant materials. Functional failures in pavements (e.g., excessive roughness, FOD, or surface deformations) can often be traced to material or construction issues that are not addressed directly by FAARFIELD. FAARFIELD design assumes that all standard pavement layers meet the applicable requirements of AC 150/5370-10 for materials, construction, and quality control. Mix design requirements for HMA and PCC materials are covered in Items P- 401/403 and P-501 respectively.
Cumulative Damage Factor (CDF). 3.12.2 FAARFIELD is based on the cumulative damage factor (CDF) concept in which the contribution of each aircraft type in a given traffic mix is summed to obtain the total cumulative damage from all aircraft operations in the traffic mix. FAARFIELD does not designate a design aircraft; however, using the CDF method, it identifies those aircraft in the design mix that contribute the greatest amount of damage to the pavement. Thickness designs using FAARFIELD use the entire traffic mix. Using departures of a single “design” aircraft to represent all traffic is not equivalent to designing with the full traffic mix in the CDF method and will generally result in excessive thickness.
Current Version FAARFIELD. 3.12.3
The current version of FAARFIELD is designated Version 1.4. It has been 3.12.3.1 calibrated using the most recent full scale pavement tests at the FAA’s National Airport Pavement Test Facility (NAPTF). Due to updates to the failure models for both rigid and flexible pavements, computed pavement thicknesses using FAARFIELD v1.4 may be different than those computed using earlier versions of FAARFIELD.
The internal help file for FAARFIELD contains a user’s manual, which 3.12.3.2 provides detailed information on proper execution of the program. The manual also contains additional technical references for specific details of the FAARFIELD design procedure.
FAARFIELD can be downloaded from the FAA website 3.12.3.3 (http://www.faa.gov/airports/engineering/design_software/).
Overview of FAARFIELD Program. 3.12.4 FAARFIELD consists of five main forms linked as schematically shown in Figure 3-1. The primary forms are Startup, Structure and Aircraft. Startup establishes which job and section will be evaluated. Structure establishes the pavement structure to be analyzed. Aircraft establishes the aircraft operating weight and frequency of operation
Figure 3-1 · page 38Picture of the page from the copy saved here
3.12 Pavement Design Using FAARFIELD. › 3.12.5 FAARFIELD Pavement Design Process.
that will be used to apply loads to the pavement. Notes contains output data and other section information. Options contains analysis and output options. Note: The program may be operated with U.S. customary or metric dimensions, which can be selected on the Options form (see Figure 3-11).
Figure 3-1. Overview of FAARFIELD Program
FAARFIELD Pavement Design Process. 3.12.5 Pavement Design with FAARFIELD is an iterative process for both flexible and rigid design, see paragraphs 3.13 and 3.14 for specific information regarding flexible and rigid design including examples. The basic FAARFIELD design steps include:
Step 1: From Startup, create a new job and add the basic sections to analyze.
Step 2: From Structure, modify the pavement structure to be analyzed.
Step 3: From Airplane, add Airplane Load and Traffic Data.
Step 4: Return to Structure and Design Pavement Structure.
Step 5: Adjust Layer Thicknesses, Change Layer Types. Repeat Step 4.
Step 6: Select Life/Compaction, print out design report.
Step 7: Return to Startup and view pavement design report.
Step 8: Print pavement design report to be included in engineer’s report.
NOTES Additional Section
Information and Detailed Output Data
STARTUP Control and Organization
OPTIONS Pavement Structure Options and General
Options
STRUCTURE Structure Data Input
and Design
AIRCRAFT Aircraft Load and Traffic Data Input
AIRCRAFT DATA View Landing Gear Geometry, Load, and
Tire Pressure
3.12.6 Aircraft Traffic Considerations. › 3.12.6.4 Aircraft Traffic Volume.
Optional: Evaluate Life of Final Section to be Constructed. Disable automatic base design in options screen, return to structure screen and adjust layer thickness to match construction
Aircraft Traffic Considerations. 3.12.6
Load. 3.12.6.1 Pavements should be designed for the maximum anticipated takeoff weights of the airplanes in the fleet regularly operating on the section of pavement being designed. The design procedure generally assumes 95 percent of the gross weight is carried by the main landing gears and 5 percent is carried by the nose gear. FAARFIELD provides manufacturerrecommended gross operating weights and load distribution, for many civil and military airplanes. Using the maximum anticipated takeoff weight provides a conservative design allowing for changes in operational use and traffic, at airports where traffic regularly operates at less than maximum load. Where arrivals constitute 85% or greater of that runway’s operations, and for high-speed exit taxiways, the use of aircraft landing weights for design is permitted.
Landing Gear Type and Geometry. 3.12.6.2 Gear type and configuration dictate how airplane weight is distributed to a pavement and how the pavement responds to airplane loadings. Refer to Order 5300.7, Standard Naming Convention for Aircraft Landing Gear Configurations, for standard gear designations.
Tire Pressure. 3.12.6.3 Tire pressure varies depending on gear configuration, gross weight, and tire size. In FAARFIELD, the tire pressure is linked to the gross weight. An increase in gross weight causes a proportional increase in tire pressure, such that the tire contact area is maintained constant. Tire pressure has a more significant influence on strains in the asphalt surface layer than at the subgrade. For flexible pavements constructed with a high stability asphalt, tire pressures up to 254 psi (1.75 MPa) may be accommodated. Tire pressure has a negligible impact on rigid pavement design.
Aircraft Traffic Volume. 3.12.6.4 Forecasts of annual departures by airplane type are needed for pavement design. In general, pavements should be designed to accommodate regularly using aircraft, where regular use is defined as at least 250 annual departures (500 operations). However, in some cases seasonal or other non-regular use aircraft may have significant impact on the pavement structure required. A sensitivity analysis is recommended to compare the structure needed to accommodate all planes in the fleet to the structure needed for all planes that have at least 250 annual departures. On federally funded projects when occasional or seasonal use aircraft are
3.12.7 Non-Aircraft Vehicles. › 3.12.7.1 In some situations, non-aircraft vehicles such as aircraft…
included in the traffic, documentation verifying actual activity (as opposed to planned) must be submitted with the sensitivity analysis to the local FAA region/ADO office as part of the engineer’s report.
Departure Traffic. 3.12.6.5 Airfield pavements are generally designed considering only aircraft departures. This is because typically aircraft depart at a heavier weight than they arrive. If the aircraft arrive and depart at essentially the same weight, then the number of departures used for pavement design should be adjusted to reflect the number of times the pavement is loaded with each aircraft operation in the FAARFIELD pavement analysis.
Total Departures Over Design Life. 3.12.6.6 FAARFIELD evaluates the total number of departures over the design life period. For example, FAARFIELD considers 250 annual departures for a 20-year design life to be 5,000 total departures. Similarly, FAARFIELD considers 225 annual departures at a 1% annual growth rate to be 4,950 total departures.
Airplane Traffic Mix. 3.12.6.7 Nearly any traffic mix can be developed from the airplanes in the program library. The actual anticipated traffic mix must be used for the design analysis. Attempts to substitute equivalent aircraft for actual aircraft can lead to erroneous results.
Total Cumulative Damage. 3.12.6.8 FAARFIELD analyzes the damage to the pavement for each airplane and determines a final thickness for the total cumulative damage of all aircraft in the evaluation. FAARFIELD calculates the damaging effects of each airplane in the traffic mix based upon its gear spacing, load, and location of gear relative to the pavement centerline. Then the effects of all airplanes are summed under Miner’s law. Since FAARFIELD considers where each airplane loads the pavement, the pavement damage associated with a particular airplane may be isolated from one or more of the other airplanes in the traffic mix. When the cumulative damage factor (CDF) sums to a value of 1.0, the structural design conditions have been satisfied.
Non-Aircraft Vehicles. 3.12.7
In some situations, non-aircraft vehicles such as aircraft rescue and 3.12.7.1 firefighting, snow removal, or fueling equipment may place heavier wheel loads on the pavement than aircraft. FAARFIELD allows these types of vehicles to be included in the traffic mix. The “Non-Airplane Vehicles” airplane group includes several types of truck axles (single, dual, tandem, and dual-tandem) that may be used to represent common truck types. The
3.12 Pavement Design Using FAARFIELD. › 3.12.8 Pass-to-Coverage Ratio.
included truck axles should be adequate for most light-duty pavement designs.
For small GA airports, it may be necessary to consider one or more of the 3.12.7.2 following options: (1) limit the size of fuel trucks used for supply and refueling; (2) locate the fuel storage tanks in a location such that the trucks supplying fuel to the airport can access the storage tanks without entering the airfield; (3) strengthen the fuel truck access route; or (4) limit the size of maintenance vehicles (e.g., snow removal equipment).
Pass-to-Coverage Ratio. 3.12.8 An airplane seldom travels along a pavement section in a perfectly straight path or along the same path each time. This lateral movement is known as airplane wander and is modeled by a statistically normal distribution. As an airplane moves along a taxiway or runway, it may take several trips or passes along the pavement for a specific point on the pavement to receive a full-load application. The ratio of the number of passes required to apply one full load application to a unit area of the pavement is expressed by the pass-to-coverage (P/C) ratio. It is easy to observe the number of passes an airplane may make on a given pavement, but the number of coverages is mathematically derived internally in FAARFIELD. By definition, one coverage occurs when a unit area of the pavement experiences the maximum response (stress for rigid pavement, strain for flexible pavement) induced by a given airplane. For flexible pavements, coverages are a measure of the number of repetitions of the maximum strain occurring at the top of subgrade.
For rigid pavements, coverages are a measure of repetitions of the maximum stress occurring at the bottom of the PCC layer (see Report No. FAA-RD-77-81, Development of a Structural Design Procedure for Rigid Airport Pavements). Coverages resulting from operations of a particular airplane type are a function of the number of airplane passes, the number and spacing of wheels on the airplane main landing gear, the width of the tire-contact area, and the lateral distribution of the wheelpaths relative to the pavement centerline or guideline markings (see Report No. FAA- RD-74-036, Field Survey and Analysis of Aircraft Distribution on Airport Pavements). In calculating the P/C ratio, FAARFIELD uses the concept of effective tire width. For flexible pavements, the effective tire width is defined at the top of the subgrade. “Response lines” are drawn at a 1:2 slope from the edges of the tire contact surface to the top of the subgrade, as illustrated in Figure 3-2. Tires are considered to be either separate or combined, depending on whether the response lines overlap.
Figure 3-2 · page 42Picture of the page from the copy saved here
For rigid pavements, the effective tire width is defined at the surface of the pavement and is equal to a nominal tire contact surface width. All effective tire width and P/C ratio calculations are performed internally within the FAARFIELD program.
Figure 3-2. Effective Tire Width
(b) Flexible Effective Tire Width - Overlap
T
EFFECTIVE TIRE WIDTH
(W + T + H)
W W
W + T
2
1
2 BASE COURSE H
EFFECTIVE TIRE
WIDTH (W + H)
W
W W
T
1
EFFECTIVE TIRE
WIDTH (W + H)
W
(a) Flexible Effective Tire Width - No Overlap
W
T
W
(c) Rigid Effective Tire Width
TIRES (TYPICAL)
SUBGRADE
TIRES (TYPICAL)
HMA SURFACE COURSE
HMA SURFACE COURSE
H
H
EFFECTIVE TIRE WIDTH (W)
SUBGRADE
BASE COURSE
SUBGRADE
TIRES (TYPICAL)
H/2 H/2 H/2 H/2
EFFECTIVE TIRE WIDTH (W)
PCC SURFACE COURSE
H/2 H/2
3.12.10 Cumulative Damage Factor. › 3.12.10.2 In the program implementation, CDF is calculated for each…
Annual Departures. 3.12.9
Airport pavement design using FAARFIELD only considers departures 3.12.9.1 and ignores the arrival traffic when determining the number of airplane passes. This is because in most cases airplanes arrive at an airport at a significantly lower weight than at takeoff due to fuel consumption. During touchdown, remaining lift on the wings and the landing gear shock absorber alleviates most of the dynamic vertical force that is transmitted to the pavement through the landing gears.
When arrival and departure weights are not significantly different or when 3.12.9.2 the airplane must travel along the pavement more than once, it may be appropriate to adjust the number of annual departures used for thickness design to recognize that each departure results in multiple pavement loadings. For example, when an airplane is required to traffic a large part of the runway during the taxi movement (i.e., a runway with a central taxiway configuration), the airplane must travel along the same portion of the runway pavement twice during the take-off operation. In this case, it would be appropriate to double the number of departures in FAARFIELD. The pavement engineer must document all adjustments to traffic in the engineer’s report.
Cumulative Damage Factor. 3.12.10
In FAARFIELD, fatigue failure is expressed in terms of a cumulative 3.12.10.1 damage factor (CDF) using Miner’s rule. CDF represents the amount of the structural fatigue life of a pavement that has been used up. It is expressed as the ratio of applied load repetitions to allowable load repetitions to failure. For a new pavement design, the pavement structure is adjusted until the cumulative CDF=1 for the traffic mix applied over the structural design life period being evaluated. For a single airplane and constant annual departures, CDF can be expressed by the following:
failure to s repetition allowable of number
s repetition load applied of number CDF
or
failure to coverages ratio coverage pass
years in life departures annual CDF
or
failure to coverages
coverages applied CDF
In the program implementation, CDF is calculated for each 10-inch (254- 3.12.10.2 mm) wide strip along the pavement over a total width of 820 inches (20.8
3.12.10 Cumulative Damage Factor. › 3.12.10.4 To view the graph after the design is complete, return to the…
m). Pass-to-coverage ratio is computed for each strip assuming that traffic is normally distributed laterally, and that 75 percent of passes fall within a “wander width” of 70 inches (1,778 mm). Statistically, this results in a normally distributed wander pattern with a standard deviation of 30.435 inches (773 mm). The CDF for design is taken to be the maximum CDF computed over all 82 strips. Even with the same gear geometry, airplanes with different main gear track widths will have different pass-to-coverage ratios in each of the 10-inch (254 mm) strips and may show little cumulative effect on the maximum CDF. Removing the airplanes with the lowest stress or strain may have little effect on the design thickness, depending on how close the gear tracks are to each other and the number of departures.
In FAARFIELD, the ‘CDF Graph’ function displays plots of CDF versus 3.12.10.3 lateral effect for each gear in the design mix, as well as plot of cumulative CDF for all airplanes in the mix. For a completed design the peak value of cumulative CDF = 1.0. The following example illustrates the concept.
Given the following pavement structure:
Thickness Pavement Structure
4 inches P-401 HMA Surface Course
8 inches P-403 Stabilized Base Course
12 inches P-209 Crushed Aggregate Base Course
10 inches P-154 Aggregate Base Course
Subgrade CBR 5 (7,500 psi Modulus)
Designed for the following airplane traffic:
Airplane Gross Weight (lbs) Annual Departures
B747-8 990,000 50
B747-8 Belly 990,000 50
B767-200 361,000 3000
To view the graph after the design is complete, return to the Aircraft 3.12.10.4 screen and select CDF Graph. This provides a graph depicting the impact of each aircraft as well as the combined total contribution, showing that the critical location is between the main gear locations for the aircraft being evaluated. In this example even though the belly gear has a large
3.12.11 FAARFIELD Material Properties. › 3.12.11.3 On federally funded projects FAA standard materials as…
contribution, it does not contribute the controlling damage to the pavement as shown in Figure 3-3.
Figure 3-3. CDF Contribution for Airplane Mix
FAARFIELD Material Properties. 3.12.11
In FAARFIELD pavement layers are assigned a thickness, elastic 3.12.11.1 modulus, and Poisson’s ratio. The same layer properties are used in flexible and rigid analysis. Layer thicknesses can be varied, subject to minimum thickness requirements. Poisson’s ratio is fixed for all materials and the elastic moduli are either fixed or variable (within a permissible range) depending upon the material. Materials in FAARFIELD are identified by their corresponding specification designations as used in AC 150/5370-10; for example, crushed aggregate base course is identified as Item P-209. The list of materials also contains a user defined layer with variable properties that can be defined by the user. Table 3-2 lists the modulus values and Poisson’s Ratios used in FAARFIELD.
Figure 3-3 · page 45Picture of the page from the copy saved here
In a rigid analysis, FAARFIELD requires a minimum of 3 layers (PCC 3.12.11.2 Surface, base and subgrade) but allows up to a total of five (5) layers. A flexible design may have as few as 2 layers (HMA surface and subgrade), however an unlimited number of layers can be added.
On federally funded projects FAA standard materials as specified in 3.12.11.3 AC 150/5370-10 must be used unless use of other materials has been approved by the FAA as a modification to standards (see FAA Order 5100.1). When analyzing existing sections, user defined layers may be the most accurate way to model performance of existing material. The designer should utilize a modulus that reflects the weakest in service strength of the existing material.
3.12 Pavement Design Using FAARFIELD. › 3.12.12 Minimum Layer Thickness.
Table 3-2. Allowable Modulus Values and Poisson’s Ratios Used in FAARFIELD
Layer Type FAA Specified Layer
Rigid Pavement
psi (MPa)
Flexible Pavement
psi (MPa)
Poisson’s
Ratio
Surface
P-501 PCC 4,000,000 (30,000) NA 0.15
P-401/P-403/P-601 HMA NA 200,000 (1,380)1 0.35
Stabilized Base
and Subbase
P-401/P-403HMA 400,000 (3,000) 0.35
P-306 Lean Concrete 700,000 (5,000) 0.20
P-304 cement treated base 500,000 (3,500)
0.20
P-301 soil cement 250,000 (1,700) 0.20
Variable stabilized rigid
250,000 to 700,000 (1,700 to 5,000)
NA
0.20
Variable stabilized flexible NA
150,000 to 400,000 (1,000 to 3,000)
0.35
Granular Base
and Subbase
P-209 crushed aggregate Program Defined 0.35
P-208, aggregate Program Defined 0.35
P-219, Recycled concrete
aggregate Program Defined 0.35
P-211, Lime rock Program Defined 0.35
P-154 uncrushed aggregate Program Defined 0.35
Subgrade Subgrade 1,000 to 50,000 (7 to 350) 0.35
User-defined User-defined layer 1,000 to 4,000,000 (7 to 30,000) 0.35
Notes: 1. A fixed modulus value for hot mix surfacing is set in the program at 200,000 psi (1380 MPa). This modulus value was conservatively chosen and corresponds to a pavement temperature of approximately 90°F (32°C).
Minimum Layer Thickness. 3.12.12 Table 3-3 and Table 3-4 establish minimum layer thicknesses for flexible and rigid pavements respectively, applicable to different airplane weight classes. Minimum thickness requirements are determined by the gross weight of the heaviest aircraft in the design traffic mix, regardless of the traffic level. FAARFIELD automatically
establishes the minimum layer thickness requirements based on the traffic mix entered. However, the user should consult the applicable paragraphs of this AC and Table 3-3 and Table 3-4 to ensure that all minimum thickness requirements are met.
Table 3-3. Minimum Layer Thickness for Flexible Pavement Structures
Layer Type
FAA Specification
Item
Maximum Airplane Gross Weight Operating on
Pavement, lbs (kg)
<12,500
(5 670)
< 100,000
(45 360)
≥100,000
(45 360)
HMA Surface1, 2,3 P-401, Hot Mix Asphalt (HMA) Pavements
3 in. (75 mm) 4 in. (100 mm) 4 in. (100 mm)
Stabilized Base P-401 or P-403; P- 304; P-3064 Not Required Not Required 5 in. (125 mm)
Crushed Aggregate Base5,6 P-209, Crushed Aggregate Base Course
3 in. (75 mm) 6 in. (150 mm) 6 in. (150 mm)
Aggregate Base5,7,8 P-208,Aggregate Base Course
3 in. (75 mm) Not Used7 Not Used
Subbase5,8 P-154, Subbase Course
4 in. (100 mm) 4 in. (100 mm) (If required)
4 in. (100 mm) (if required)
Notes: 1. P-601-Fuel Resistant Hot Mix Asphalt may be used to replace the top 2 in (75 mm) of P-401 where a fuel resistant surface is needed; structurally, P-601 considered same as P-401.
2. Additional HMA surface above minimum typically in 0.5-inch (10-mm) increments.
3. P-403 may be used as surface course < 12,500 pounds (5,760 kg) or for HMA base or leveling course.
4. Use of P-306 requires FAA approval on federally funded projects to assure adequate measures taken to control potential for reflective cracking.
5. Use the larger of the thicknesses in this table or the thickness calculated by FAARFIELD rounded to the nearest 0.5 inch (10 mm). Additional thickness may be required for frost protection above minimums.
6. P-209, Crushed Aggregate Base Course, when used as a stabilized base course, is limited to pavements designed for gross loads of 100,000 pounds (45,360 kg) or less, except as noted in paragraph 3.6, Stabilized Base Course.
7. P-208, Aggregate Base Course, when used as a base course, is limited to pavements designed for gross loads of 60,000 pounds (27,220 kg) or less.
8. P-219 Recycled Concrete Aggregate Base Course may be used as an aggregate base or subbase. How P-219 will perform is related to the quality of the material it is made from combined with the method used to process it into an aggregate base.
3.12.13 Typical Pavement Sections. › 3.12.13.2 Since traffic on runways is distributed with majority of…
Table 3-4. Minimum Layer Thickness for Rigid Pavement Structures
Layer Type
FAA Specification
Item
Maximum Airplane Gross Weight Operating on Pavement,
lbs (kg)
<12,500
(5,670)
< 100,000
(45,360)
≥ 100,000
(45,360)
PCC Surface P-501, Portland Cement Concrete (PCC) Pavements
5 in. (125 mm) 6 in. (150 mm)1 6 in. (150 mm)1
Stabilized Base P-401 or P-403; P- 304; P-306 Not Required Not Required 5 in. (125 mm)
Base P-208, P-209, P-211, P-301
Not Required 6 in. (150 mm)2 6 in. (150 mm)
Subbase3,4 P-154, Subbase Course
4 in. (100 mm) As needed for frost or to create working platform
As needed for frost or to create working platform
Notes: 1. FAARFIELD thickness to be rounded to the nearest 0.5 inch (10 mm).
2. For pavements for aircraft greater than 30,000 lbs (13,610 kg), base may be replaced with subbase.
3. Subbase layer is required for pavements designed for gross loads of 12,500 pounds (5,670 kg) or less only when the following soil types are present: OL, MH, CH, or OH.
4. The following specification items may also be used as subbase: P-208, Aggregate Base Course; P-209, Crushed Aggregate Base Course; P-211, Lime Rock Base Course; P-219 Recycled Concrete Aggregate Base Course; P-301, Soil-Cement Base Course. If more than one layer of subbase is used, each layer should meet the minimum thickness requirement in this table.
Typical Pavement Sections. 3.12.13
The FAA recommends uniform full width pavement sections, with each 3.12.13.1 pavement layer constructed a uniform thickness for the full width of the pavement. See Figure 1-1. Typical Pavement Structure and Figure 3-4. Typical Plan and Sections for Pavements.
Figure 3-4 · page 49Picture of the page from the copy saved here
Since traffic on runways is distributed with majority of traffic in the center 3.12.13.2 (keel) portion of the runway, the runways may be constructed with a transversely variable section. Variable sections permit a reduction in the quantity of materials required for the upper pavement layers of the runway. However, construction of variable sections may be more costly due to the complex construction associated with variable sections and this may negate any savings realized from reduced material quantities (see Appendix E).
Figure 3-4. Typical Plan and Sections for Pavements
1.
2.
3.
RUNWAY, TAXIWAY AND SHOULDER WIDTHS; TRANSVERSE
36 INCHES [90 CM] BEYOND FULL STRENGTH PAVEMENT.
SLOPES, ETC. PER AC 150/ 5300-13, AIRPORT DESIGN
CONSTRUCT A 1.5 INCH [4 CM] DROP BETWEEN PAVED AND UNPAVED SURFACES.
SURFACE, BASE, PCC, ETC. THICKNESS PER AC 150/5320-6.
NOTES: LEGEND:
4.
BASE AND SUBBASE MINIMUM 12 INCHES [30 CM] UP TO
PI
A
30° A
HMA SURFACE
SHOULDER
STABILIZED BASE
BASE
SUB BASE
SUB GRADE
EDGE DRAIN
PCC SURFACE
SEE NOTE 4
RUNWAY WIDTH
SECTION A-A (NOT TO SCALE)
SEE NOTE 4
RUNWAY WIDTH
RUNWAY "CROWN" DEPICTION OMITTED FOR CLARITY. 5.
SLOPE (SEE NOTE 5)
SLOPE (SEE NOTE 5)
HMA SURFACE
SECTION A-A (NOT TO SCALE)
PCC SURFACE
Frost and Permafrost Design. 3.12.14 The design of an airport pavement must consider the environmental conditions affecting the pavement during its construction and service life. In areas where frost and permafrost impact pavements, the pavement design should address the adverse effects of seasonal frost and permafrost. The maximum practical depth of frost protection provided is normally 72 inches (180 cm) below the top of the finished pavement. Frost considerations may result in thicker base or subbase courses than needed for structural support.
3.12 Pavement Design Using FAARFIELD. › 3.12.17 Limited Subgrade Frost Penetration.
Seasonal Frost. 3.12.15 The adverse effects of seasonal frost are discussed in Chapter 2. Soil frost groups are described in Table 2-2. The design of pavements in seasonal frost areas can be based on either of two approaches: frost protection or reduced subgrade strength. The first approach is based on the control of pavement deformations resulting from frost action. Using this approach, the combined thickness of the pavement and non-frost-susceptible material must be sufficient to eliminate, or limit, the adverse effects of frost penetration into the subgrade. The second approach is based on providing adequate pavement load carrying capacity during the critical frost melting period and provide for the loss of load carrying capacity due to frost melting, ignoring the effects of frost heave. The procedures that address these design approaches are discussed below.
Complete Frost Protection. 3.12.16
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 357 passages shown