Radar Vectors
Advisory Circular Current Issued Aug 16, 2006 AIR-120 233 pages Copy saved Nov 18, 2026

AC 20-73A Aircraft Ice Protection

This advisory circular (AC) tells type certificate and supplemental type certificate applicants how to comply with the ice protection requirements of Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) parts 23, 25, 27, 29, 33, and 35. It also provides guidance for aircraft type certificate holders on how to maintain the aircraft’s airworthiness when operating in an icing environment. Applicants seeking an FAA type certificate for their aircraft, aircraft engines, or propellers, or a supplemental type certificate for an existing aircraft model or an aircraft component must adhere to ice protection regulations. You will find these requirements embedded throughout 14 CFR parts 23, 25, 27, 29, 33, and 35. (Ice protection regulations are listed in tables 1 through 4 in section 6 of this AC.) This AC also directs you to other ACs providing guidance for compliance with specific icing-related regulations.

Official source ↗ Open PDF

Text read by OCR from a scanned file (16 of 233 pages). Check the original, as some words may be misread.

Advisory. Circular.

Advisory Circular

Subject: AIRCRAFT ICE PROTECTION Date: 8/16/06 AC No: 20-73A

Initiated by: AIR-120

FOREWORD

This advisory circular (AC) describes an acceptable means, but not the only means of showing compliance with the ice protection requirements of Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) parts 23, 25, 27, 29, 33, and 35. It also offers applicants guidance on how to maintain the aircraft’s airworthiness when operating in an icing environment.

/s/

Susan J. M. Cabler Acting Manager, Aircraft Engineering Division Aircraft Certification Service

CONTENTS

Section Page

1. PURPOSE 1

2. CANCELLATION 1

3. APPLICABILITY 1

4. RELATED ADVISORY CIRCULARS, DOCUMENTS, READING MATERIAL, AND NOMENCLATURE 2

5. ICE PROTECTION REGULATORY DEVELOPMENT BACKGROUND 2

6. APPLICABLE AIRFRAME, ENGINE, AND PROPELLER ICE PROTECTION REQUIREMENTS 2

6.1 Ice Protection Requirements: Unintended Exposure to Icing Conditions 3

6.2 Ice Protection Requirements: Intentional Operations in Known and Forecast Icing Conditions 4

6.3 Ice Protection Requirements: Operating Safely in Icing Conditions 5

7. CERTIFICATION PROCEDURES 5

7.1 Certification Procedures: General 5

7.2 Certification Procedures: Airframe Manufacturer 6

7.3 Certification Procedures: Engine Manufacturer 7

8. COMPLIANCE MEANS 7

8.1 Compliance Means: Analysis 9

8.1.1 Compliance Means: Airframe Analysis 10

8.1.2 Compliance Means: Engine and Propeller Systems Analyses 13

8.1.3 Compliance Means: Engine Inlets Analysis 14

8.1.4 Compliance Means: Ice and Icing Conditions Detection Systems Analyses 15

8.1.5 Compliance Means: Windshield Analysis 15

iii

8.1.6 Compliance Means: Air Data System Sensors and Probes Analyses 16

8.1.7 Compliance Means: Ice Protection System Failure Analysis 16

8.1.8 Compliance Means: Flutter Analysis 16

8.1.9 Compliance Means: Power Sources Analysis 17

8.2 Compliance Means: Tests 17

8.2.1 Compliance Means: Natural Icing Flight Tests 17 8.2.2 Compliance Means: Dry Air Flight Tests 20 8.2.3 Compliance Means: Artificial Icing Flight Tests 24 8.2.4 Compliance Means: Wind Tunnel Tests 25

8.3 Compliance Means: Surfaces Without Ice Protection 25

8.4 Compliance Means: Ice Inspection Lights and Cues 25

8.5 Compliance Means: Reference to Previously Accomplished Tests 26

8.6 Compliance Means: Perform Intended Function in Icing Conditions 27

8.6.1 Compliance Means: Engines and Equipment Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions 27

8.6.2 Compliance Means: Engine Alternate Induction Air Sources Performance of Intended Functions in Icing Conditions 27

8.6.3 Compliance Means: Fuel System Venting Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions 27

8.6.4 Compliance Means: Landing Gear Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions 27

8.6.5 Compliance Means: Stall Warning and Protection Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions 27

8.6.6 Compliance Means: Icing Conditions 28

8.6.7 Compliance Means: Primary and Secondary Flight Control Surfaces Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions 28

8.6.8 Compliance Means: Ram Air Turbine Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions 28

8.6.9 Compliance Means: Pilot Compartment View Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions 28

iv

9. AIRPLANE FLIGHT MANUAL (AFM) 28

9.1 AFM: Limitations 28

9.2 AFM: Operating Procedures 29

9.3 AFM: Performance Information 30

9.4 AFM: Airworthiness Directives for Severe Icing Conditions 30

10. ROTORCRAFT 31

10.1 Rotorcraft: General 31

10.2 Rotorcraft: Compliance 32

10.2.1 Rotorcraft: Compliance: Analyses 35 10.2.2 Rotorcraft: Compliance: Tests 36

10.3 Rotorcraft Flight Manual 37

11. AIRCRAFT FROST AND CLEAR ICE CONSIDERATIONS 38

12. AIRPLANE DE/ANTI-ICING BEFORE TAKEOFF 38

13. EXTENDED RANGE OPERATION WITH TWO-ENGINE AIRPLANES (ETOPS) ICING CONSIDERATIONS 39

14. REFERENCES 41

APPENDIX A. RELATED REGULATIONS AND DOCUMENTS A-1

A.1 Regulations A-1

A.2 Advisory Circulars A-6

A.3 Related Reading Material A-8

APPENDIX B. NOMENCLATURE B-1

B.1 Terms B-1

B.2 Acronyms and Symbols B-11

B.3 References B-15

APPENDIX C. BACKGROUND OF ICE PROTECTION REGULATORY DEVELOPMENT C-1

C.1 Transport Category Airplanes (14 CFR Part 25) C-1

v

C.2 Normal, Utility, Acrobatic, and Commuter Category Airplanes (14 CFR Part 23) C-5

C.3 Aircraft Engines (14 CFR Part 33) C-10

C.4 Rotorcraft (14 CFR Parts 27 and 29) C-11

C.5 References C-12

APPENDIX D. COMPONENT ICE PROTECTION SYSTEM DESIGN AND CERTIFICATION PROCESS FLOWCHARTS D-1

APPENDIX E. METEOROLOGICAL CONDITIONS E-1

E.1 Icing Cloud Specifications E-1

E.2 Using 14 CFR Parts 25 and 29, Appendix C E-6

E.3 References E-7

APPENDIX F. OPERATIONAL FACTORS F-1

F.1 Airplane Operational Factors F-1

F.2 Rotorcraft Operational Factors F-1

F.3 Engine Operational Factors F-1

APPENDIX G. ICING CONDITIONS EXPOSURE TIME G-1

APPENDIX H. ICE PROTECTION SYSTEMS H-1

H.1 Ice Protection Technologies and Operating Modes H-1

H.1.1 Ice Protection Technologies H-2 H.1.2 Ice Protection System Operation H-9

H.2 References H-11

APPENDIX I. DROP IMPINGEMENT AND WATER CATCH I-1

I.1 Drop Impingement and Water Catch I-1

I.2 References I-5

APPENDIX J. PROPELLER ICE PROTECTION J-1

J.1 Propeller Ice Protection J-1

J.2 References J-3

vi

APPENDIX K. ICE AND ICING CONDITIONS DETECTION K-1

K.1 Ice and Icing Conditions Detection K-1

K.1.1 AFIDS K-2 K-2 K-2 K-3 K-4

K.1.2 PFIDS K.1.3 Ice Detector Sensor Characteristics K.1.4 Freezing Fraction ( n) Considerations K.1.5 Drop Splashing, Runback, and Shedding

K.2 Installation Location K-4

K.3 System Considerations K-5

K.4 Certification of Ice Detectors K-6

K.4.1 Certification of an AFIDS K-6 K.4.2 Certification of a PFIDS K-7

K.5 References K-8

APPENDIX L. WINDSHIELD ICE PROTECTION L-1

APPENDIX M. FINDING NATURAL ICING CONDITIONS FOR TEST PURPOSES M-1

M.1 Background M-1

M.2 Statistical Guidance M-1

M.2.1 Natural Probabilities for LWC Averages in Stratiform Icing

Conditions M-1 M.2.2 Natural 99 Percent LWC Limits vs. Altitude M-2 M.2.3 Probability of Finding Large MVDs M-3

M.3 Experience M-4

M.3.1 Continuous Maximum Conditions M-4 M.3.2 Intermittent Maximum Conditions M-4 M.3.3 Glaciated Conditions M-5 M.3.4 Mixed-Phase Conditions M-5 M.3.5 Large Drop Conditions M-5

M.4 Using Forecasts of Icing Conditions M-6

M.5 Professional Guidance M-6

M.6 References M-7

vii

APPENDIX N. INSTRUMENTATION N-1

N.1 Instrumentation N-1

N.2 References N-2

APPENDIX O. WAYS TO EVALUATE ICING EXPOSURES RELATIVE TO APPENDIX C O-1

O.1 Background O-1

O.2 Appendix C Converted to Distance- or Time-Based Envelopes O-1

O.3 References O-3

APPENDIX P. USING ICING RATE TO DOCUMENT ICING EXPOSURES P-1

P.1 Background P-1

P.2 Data From an Icing Rate Sensor P-1

P.3 Converting Icing Rate to Icing Intensity P-2

P.4 Data Sheet for Documenting Icing Exposures P-3

P.5 References P-8

APPENDIX Q. ICE SHEDDING Q-1

Q.1 Ice Shedding Q-1

Q.2 References Q-2

APPENDIX R. ICE SHAPES R-1

R.1 Protected Surfaces R-1

R.1.1 Preactivation Ice Roughness R-1 R.1.2 Intercycle Ice Roughness R-6 R.1.3 Runback Ice R-12

R.2 Unprotected Surfaces R-14

R.3 Ice Protection System Failure Ice Shapes R-14

R.4 Critical Ice Shapes R-15

R.4.1 Considerations for Critical Ice Shapes R-15 R.4.2 Aerodynamic Considerations for Determining Critical Ice Shapes R-21

viii

R.5 Methods for Determining (Predicting) Ice Shapes R-31

R.5.1 Natural Icing Flight Tests R-31 R.5.2 Use of Icing Tankers to Predict Unprotected Surfaces Ice Shapes R-31 R.5.3 Use of Icing Wind Tunnels to Predict Unprotected Surfaces Ice

Shapes R-31 R.5.4 Drop Impingement and Ice Accretion Computer Codes and Other

Analytical Methods R-35 R.5.5 Prediction of Landing Gear and Strut Ice Shapes R-38 R.5.6 Prediction of Protected Surfaces Ice Shapes R-38

R.6 Correlation of Predicted (Simulated) and Natural Ice Shapes R-38

R.7 References R-40

APPENDIX S. ICE-CONTAMINATED HORIZONTAL STABILIZER (TAILPLANE) STALL S-1

S.1 Ice-Contaminated Horizontal Stabilizer (Tailplane) Stall S-1

S.2 References S-3

APPENDIX T. ARTIFICIAL ICING FLIGHT TESTS: ICING TANKERS AND SPRAY RIG TESTS

T.1 Icing Tanker Tests T-1

T.2 Spray Rig Tests T-1

T.3 References T-1

APPENDIX U. ICING WIND TUNNEL TESTS U-1

U.1 Icing Wind Tunnel Tests U-1

U.2 References U-1

APPENDIX V. AIRCRAFT FROST AND CLEAR ICE CONSIDERATIONS V-1

V.1 Aircraft Frost and Clear Ice Considerations V-1

V.2 References V-4

ix

List of Figures

Figure Page

B-1 Gridding of a NACA 0012 Wing Into a Mesh of Finite Volumes for Flow Field Analysis, Drop Impingement Computation, and Ice Accretion Analysis (See Reference B1.) B-3

B-2 Definition of Local Impingement Efficiency Parameter, E B-6

B-3 Definition of Horn Maximum Thickness Angle (See Reference B1.) B-6

D-1 Typical Aircraft Inflight Icing Certification Process D-2

D-2 Typical Inflight Icing Certification Processes for Wings, Horizontal and Vertical Stabilizers, and Rotor Blades D-3

D-3 Typical Inflight Icing Certification Process for Engine Induction Systems D-6

D-4 Typical Inflight Icing Certification Process for Propellers D-10

D-5 Typical Inflight Icing Certification Process for Windshields D-13

D-6 Typical Inflight Icing Certification Process for Air Data Probes and Sensors D-14

D-7 Typical Inflight Icing Certification Process for Antenna, Tanks, Fairings, Masts, Struts, and Other Miscellaneous Protuberances D-15

E-1 14 CFR Parts 25 and 29 Appendix C Continuous Maximum (Stratiform Clouds) Atmospheric Icing Conditions, Liquid Water Content vs. Mean Effective Drop Diameter (14 CFR Parts 25 and 29 Appendix C, Figure 1) E-2

E-2 14 CFR Parts 25 and 29 Appendix C Continuous Maximum (Stratiform Clouds) Atmospheric Icing Conditions, Ambient Temperature vs. Pressure Altitude (14 CFR Parts 25 and 29, Appendix C, Figure 2) E-3

E-3 14 CFR Parts 25 and 29 Appendix C Continuous Maximum (Stratiform Clouds) Atmospheric Icing Conditions, Liquid Water Content Factor vs. Cloud Horizontal Distance (14 CFR Parts 25 and 29, Appendix C, Figure 3) E-3

E-4 14 CFR Parts 25 and 29 Appendix C Intermittent Maximum (Cumulus Clouds) Atmospheric Icing Conditions, Liquid Water Content vs. Mean Effective Drop Diameter (14 CFR Parts 25 and 29, Appendix C, Figure 4) E-4

E-5 14 CFR Parts 25 and 29 Appendix C Intermittent Maximum (Cumulus Clouds) Atmospheric Icing, Ambient Temperature vs. Pressure Altitude (14 CFR Parts 25 and 29, Appendix C, Figure 5) E-4

x

E-6 14 CFR Parts 25 and 29 Appendix C Intermittent Maximum (Cumulus Clouds) Atmospheric Icing Conditions, Liquid Water Content Factor vs. Cloud Horizontal Distance (14 CFR Parts 25 and 29, Appendix C, Figure 6) E-5

J-1 Propeller Ice Accretion During an SLD Encounter With the Propeller Ice Protection System Operating (See Reference J1.) J-3

M-1 Natural Probabilities for LWC Averages in Stratiform Cloud Icing Conditions at

32oF to 14oF, With an Average MVD of 15 Pm M-1

M-2 Natural 99 Percent LWC Limit Envelopes at the Highest Icing Temperatures

Available at Indicated Altitude as a Function of Cloud Horizontal Extent (for all clouds containing supercooled water drops with MVD = 15-20 Pm) M-2

M-3 Natural Cloud Horizontal Extent Limits and 99 Percent LWC Limits for Selected,

Sustained Cloud Drop MVDs in Stratiform Clouds at Ambient Temperatures of 32oF to 14oF M-3

O-1 14 CFR Parts 25 and 29, Appendix C Icing Envelopes Converted to a Distance- Based Format (for MVD=15 Pm) O-2

P-1 Actual Example of the Analog Output Voltage From a Model 871FA Ice Detector During an Icing Encounter P-1

P-2 High Resolution Example of Analog Output Voltage From an 871FA Ice Detector P-2

R-1 Hybrid NACA 23012 2D (Simulating a 72-inch Chord Airfoil) Model Leading Edge Ice Roughness Before Activation of the IPS. Exposure time included 11 seconds for an ice detector alert and 30 seconds for the flight crew to activate the IPS. The test was performed in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C Continuous Maximum Icing Conditions. (Static temperature = 14qF, LWC = 0.45 g/m3, MVD = 20 micrometers, spray time = 41 sec., tunnel airflow speed = 195 mph, Model AOA = 4q.) (See Reference R1.) R-2

R-2 Hybrid NACA 23012 2D (Simulating a 72-inch Chord Airfoil) Model Leading Edge Ice Roughness Before Activation of the IPS. Exposure time included allowing 3 seconds for an ice detector alert and 30 seconds for the flight crew to activate the IPS. The test was performed in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C Intermittent Maximum Icing Conditions. (Static temperature = 14qF, LWC = 1.95 g/m3, MVD = 20 micrometers, spray time = 33 sec., tunnel airflow speed = 195 mph, model AOA = 4q.) (See Reference R1.) R-4

xi

R-3 Hybrid NACA 23012 2D Model (Simulating a 72-inch Chord Airfoil) Leading Edge Ice Roughness Before Activation of the IPS. Exposure time included the time required for an observation of ¼ inch of ice and 30 seconds for the flight crew to activate the IPS. The test was performed in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C Continuous Maximum Icing Conditions. (Static temperature = 14qF, LWC = 0.45 g/m3, MVD = 20 micrometers, tunnel airflow speed = 195 mph, model AOA = 4q.) (See Reference R1.) R-5

R-4 Typical Surface Roughness on the Leading Edge of a NACA 23012 Resulting from Normal Operation of Wing Pneumatic Deicing Boots. (See Reference R1.) R-7

R-5 Intercycle Ice Roughness for a 2D 36-inch NACA 0012 Airfoil Wind Tunnel Model R-9

R-6 Wing Deicing Boots Residual and Intercycle Ice Buildups R-10

R-7 Aerodynamic Effects Resulting From Deicing Intercycle Ice Shapes for a 2D 36-inch NACA 23012 Airfoil Wind Tunnel Model at a Reynolds Number of 7.5x106 R-11

R-8 Aerodynamic Effects of Distributed Roughness Along the Leading Edge of a NACA 23012 Airfoil (c = 36 inches, Re = 7.5x106, M = 0.21). (See Reference R2.) R-12

R-9 Lower Surface Runback Ice on a 36-inch NACA 0012 Airfoil Model. The model was equipped with an electro-thermal IPS. The IPS ran wet with a constant protection surface temperature of about 50qF. The mixed-phase icing cloud exposure time was 5 minutes. (Static Temperature = 0qF, LWC = 0.35 g/m3, MVD = 20 micrometers, IWC (shaved ice) = 0.35 g/m3, tunnel airflow speed = 120 mph, model AOA = 0q.) R-13

R-10 Aerodynamic Effects of Continuous and Segmented 0.25-inch, Forward-Facing,

Quarter-Round Simulated Ice Shapes on the Upper Surface of an 18-inch Chord NACA 23012m Airfoil 2D Model (Re = 1.8x106, M = 0.185). (See Reference R5.) R-20

R-11 Comparison of NACA 23012m and NLF 0414 Clean Airfoil Model Experimental

Pressure Distributions (Cl ~ 0.6, Re = 1.8x106, M = 0.185). See Reference R5.) R-21

R-12 Effect of an Upper Surface Simulated Quarter-Round Ice Shape at Various

Chordwise Positions on Lift for Forward- (NACA 23012m) and Aft-Loaded (NLF 0414) Airfoils (k/c = 0.0139, Re = 1.8x106, M = 0.185). (See Reference R5.) R-22

xii

R-13 Variation of C l max for NACA 23012m and NLF 0414 Airfoils With and Without

an Upper Surface 0.25-inch, Forward-Facing, Quarter-Round Simulated Ice Shape at Various Chord Positions (Re = 1.8x106, M = 0.185). (See Reference R5.) R-22

R-14 Drag Increase for NACA 23012m and NLF 0414 Airfoils With a 0.25-inch,

Forward-Facing, Quarter-Round Simulated Ice Shape Located on the Upper Surface at Various Chord Positions (Re = 1.8x106, M = 0.185). (See Reference R5.) R-23

R-15 Reynolds and Mach Numbers Effects on Lift and Drag for a NACA 23012 Airfoil

With and Without Simulated Ice Shape 290. (See Reference R2.) R-25

R-16 Comparison of Computed Flow Fields Using Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes

(RANS) and Detached Eddy Simulation (DES) Navier-Stokes CFD Codes (NLF 0414 airfoil at an AOA of 7˚ and a Reynolds number of 1.8x106 with a 0.034 k/c simulated ice shape horn.) (See Reference R8.) R-29

R-17 Time-Dependent Vortex Shedding (Vorticity Contours) From an NLF 0414

Airfoil With a 0.034 k/c Simulated Ice Shape Horn Calculated Using a DES Navier-Stokes CFD Code. (See Reference R8.) R-29

R-18 Vorticity Contours for 2D and 3D DES Navier-Stokes Computational Fluid

Dynamics Code Analysis of the Flow Field Around a NACA 23012m Airfoil With a k/c = 0.0139 Forward-Facing, Quarter-Round Simulated Ice Shape at the Same Time Instant (Re = 1.8x106). (See Reference R8.) R-30

R-19 Correlation of Full-Model (55 cm NACA 0012 Airfoil) and Half-Model Ice

Shapes by Holding the Full Model K0, Ac, n, I, and Weh Constant. (See Reference R17.) R-33

R-20 Comparison of Natural and Icing Wind Tunnel Ice Shapes. (See

Reference R19.) R-33

R-21 Comparison of Drop Impingement and Ice Accretion Code Results With

Experimental Ice Accretion Produced in the NASA IRT (V = 135.8 kts, TS = -15.8°C, LWC = 1.16 g/m3, MVD = 50.0 ȝm, icing duration = 517.1 s, GLC305-836-23 airfoil model chord = 0.9144 m). (See Reference R21.) R-35

R-22 Comparison of Drop Impingement and Ice Accretion Code Results With

Experimental Ice Accretion Produced in the NASA IRT (V = 179.8 kts, TS = -15.6°C, LWC = 0.33 g/m3, MVD = 20.0 ȝm, icing duration = 1224.0 s, NLF0414-611 airfoil model chord = 0.9144 m). (See Reference R21.) R-36

xiii

R-23 Comparison of Drop Impingement and Ice Accretion Code Results With

Experimental Ice Accretion Produced in the Boeing Research Aerodynamic and Icing Wind Tunnel (V = 130.2 kts, TS = -7.2°C, LWC = 1.0 g/m3, MVD = 24.8 ȝm, icing duration = 1200.0 s, airfoil model chord = 0.914 m). (See Reference R21.) R-36

R-24 Comparison of Drop Impingement and Ice Accretion Code Results With

Experimental Ice Accretion Produced in the Boeing Research Aerodynamic and Icing Wind Tunnel (V = 130.2 kts, T = -7.2°C, LWC = 1.0 g/m , 3 S MVD = 38.8 ȝm, icing duration = 1200.0 s, airfoil model chord = 0.914 m). (See Reference R21.) R-37

S-1 Airplane Forces and Pitching Moments S-1

S-2 Aerodynamic Effects of Standard Roughness (0.011-inch Carborundum Grains) for a NACA 652-215 Airfoil. (The Carborundum grains were uniformly distributed at a density of 5 to 10 percent of the area that extended from the airfoil’s leading edge to 0.08c of the 24-inch model.) (See Reference S1.) S-2

xiv

List of Tables

Table Page

1 Required Carburetor and Fuel System Ice Protection 2

2 Ice Protection Requirements for Aircraft not Certified for Operations in Known or Forecast Icing Conditions 3

3 Other 14 CFR Requirements Applicable for all Ice Protection Equipment and Systems 4

4 Additional Ice Protection Equipment and System Requirements for Aircraft Certified for Flight into Known and Forecast Icing Conditions 5

5 Means of Compliance for IPS Requirements 8

6 Continuous and Intermittent Maximum Icing Conditions 12

A-1 Related 14 CFR Parts 23, 25, 27, and 29 Regulations A-2

A-2 Related 14 CFR Part 33 – Airworthiness Standards: Aircraft Engines Regulations A-6

A-3 Related 14 CFR Part 35 – Airworthiness Standards: Propellers A-6

A-4 Related Operating Rules A-6

C-1 Chronology of 14 CFR Part 25 Icing Certification Requirements C-4

C-2 Chronology of 14 CFR Part 23 Icing Certification Requirements C-9

C-3 Chronology of 14 CFR Part 33 Engine Icing Certification Requirements C-11

I-1 Langmuir Distributions I-3

P-1 Measurable Definitions of Icing Intensity P-3

P-2 Suggested Data Sheet for Documenting Icing Exposures P-5

P-3 Effects on Aircraft P-6

P-4 Checklist of Items to be Evaluated in Icing Conditions P-7

R-1 Ranking of Ice Shape Evaluation Parameters R-39

R-2 Ranking of Water Catch Evaluation Parameters R-39

xv (and xvi)

1. PURPOSE.

1. PURPOSE.

a. This advisory circular (AC) tells type certificate and supplemental type certificate applicants how to comply with the ice protection requirements of Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) parts 23, 25, 27, 29, 33, and 35. It also provides guidance for aircraft type certificate holders on how to maintain the aircraft’s airworthiness when operating in an icing environment. Applicants seeking an FAA type certificate for their aircraft, aircraft engines, or propellers, or a supplemental type certificate for an existing aircraft model or an aircraft component must adhere to ice protection regulations. You will find these requirements embedded throughout 14 CFR parts 23, 25, 27, 29, 33, and 35. (Ice protection regulations are listed in tables 1 through 4 in section 6 of this AC.) This AC also directs you to other ACs providing guidance for compliance with specific icing-related regulations.

b. This AC is not mandatory and does not constitute a regulation. It describes acceptable means, but not the only means to: (1) gain FAA approval of aircraft ice protection equipment and systems; (2) determine two-engine airplane airworthiness in icing conditions during Extended Range Operation with Two-engine Airplanes (ETOPS)); and (3) evaluate aircraft airworthiness following deicing and anti-icing before takeoff. It also provides guidance on operating aircraft in an icing environment that may affect the airworthiness of the aircraft. However, if you use the means described in this AC, you must follow the guidance in its entirety.

2. CANCELLATION. This AC cancels AC 20-73, Aircraft Ice Protection, dated April 21, 1971.

3. APPLICABILITY. This AC provides guidance to:

a. Applicants for approval of aircraft, aircraft engines, propellers, and airframe ice protection equipment and systems. This guidance applies to applicants seeking certification approval of their aircraft or aircraft engine for flight into known or forecast icing conditions and those applicants not seeking approval for flight in icing conditions. See appendix A of this AC for a list of 14 CFR parts 23, 25, 27, 29, 33, and 35 regulations applicable to aircraft, aircraft engines, and propeller icing certification.

b. FAA personnel accepting information that shows compliance.

c. Type certificate holders seeking ETOPS approval of their airplanes. Guidance provided in this AC addresses airframe ice accretion following a cabin depressurization or engine failure. AC 120-42A, Extended Range Operation with Two-Engine Airplanes (ETOPS), provides additional information on the approval of extended range operations of two-engine airplanes.

d. Operators seeking assurance that their aircraft continues to comply with airworthiness requirements and operating rules that allow the use of deicing and anti-icing fluids to prevent ice, snow, and frost from adhering to the wing.

e. Applicants seeking approval under 14 CFR parts 23, 25, 27, or § 29.1419 for new type certificates, supplemental type certificates, and an amendment to existing type certificates for aircraft certificated under the Civil Aviation Regulations (CAR) parts 3 and 4b.

4. RELATED ADVISORY CIRCULARS, DOCUMENTS, READING MATERIAL, AND NOMENCLATURE.

See appendix A, sections A.2 and A.3, of this document, for additional icing approval information, related guidance material, and reading material. The FAA Aircraft Icing Handbook, DOT/FAA/CT-88/8-1, dated March 1991, provides comprehensive information on weather, icing physics, icing analysis, ice protection system design, ice detection systems, and certification of these systems. See also the Electronic Aircraft Icing Handbook (a subset of the Aircraft Icing Handbook) at: http://aar400.tc.faa.gov/Programs/FlightSafety/icing/eaihbk.htm. Appendix B of this AC defines terms, abbreviations, and symbols used in this document.

5. ICE PROTECTION REGULATORY DEVELOPMENT BACKGROUND.

Appendix C of this AC provides information for type design and supplemental type design applicants to determine the icing regulations that were applicable during the original type design certification of their aircraft. (See 14 CFR § 21.101 for icing requirements that apply to modified products.) Appendix C of this AC also provides background information on the historical development of aircraft, aircraft engine, and propeller icing regulatory requirements.

6. APPLICABLE AIRFRAME, ENGINE, AND PROPELLER ICE PROTECTION REQUIREMENTS.

a. Ice contamination on aircraft surfaces and components, aircraft engines, and propellers may cause unsafe operation of the aircraft. Type certificate applicants may seek approval for operating their aircraft in known or forecast icing conditions. However, if the applicant does not obtain approval, the applicant must protect the aircraft engine and specific aircraft components against ice ingestion and ice contamination during unintended exposure to atmospheric icing conditions. Sections 6.1, 6.2, and 6.3 of this AC discuss these requirements. (See appendix A of this AC for a more detailed listing of icing regulations.)

b. Applicants for certification of an aircraft and an aircraft engine must comply with certification requirements addressing ice accumulation that may form in aircraft engine carburetors, fuel tanks, and fuel lines systems, for all atmospheric conditions. Table 1 lists these requirements.

Table 1. Required Carburetor and Fuel System Ice Protection

Affected Area 14 CFR part 23

14 CFR part 25

14 CFR part 27

14 CFR part 29

14 CFR part 33 Fuel tank and carburetor vapor vents

§ 23.975 § 25.975 § 27.975 § 29.975

Fuel tanks and fuel lines § 23.951(c) § 25.951(c) § 27.951(c) § 29.951(c) § 33.67(b)(4)(ii) Fuel strainers and filters § 23.997(e) Carburetor icing § 23.1093 § 23.1095 § 23.1097 § 23.1099 § 23.1101 § 23.1157 § 23.1189

§ 25.1093 § 25.1101 § 25.1157 § 25.1189

§ 27.1093 § 29.1093 § 29.1101 § 29.1157 § 29.1189

§ 33.35(b)

6.1 Ice Protection Requirements: Unintended Exposure to Icing Conditions. For aircraft not certificated for operation in known or forecast icing conditions, airframe and aircraft engine type certificate applicants must provide ice protection for aircraft engines, the airframe, and airframe components to address unintended flight operations into icing conditions. (See table 2 below.) The exceptions to some of these requirements are those 14 CFR part 23 and 27 aircraft not certificated for instrument flight rule (IFR) operations. See appendix A, table A.1 of this AC for a detailed list of the applicable regulatory requirements.

Table 2. Ice Protection Requirements for Aircraft not Certified

for Operations in Known or Forecast Icing Conditions

Affected Area 14 CFR part 23

14 CFR part 25

14 CFR part 27

14 CFR part 29

14 CFR part 33 In-flight icing Appendix C of Appendix C Appendix C of 14 CFR Appendix C of 14 CFR conditions 14 CFR part 25

part 29 (AC 29-2C provides a 10,000-foot altitude-limited envelope for rotorcraft use. For rotorcraft limited to a flight envelope more restrictive than 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C, you may reduce the icing conditions used for approval of the ice protection equipment and systems to that of the limited flight envelope.)

part 29 (AC 29-2C provides a 10,000-foot altitude-limited envelope for rotorcraft use. For rotorcraft limited to a flight envelope more restrictive than 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C, you may reduce the icing conditions used for approval of the ice protection equipment and systems to that of the limited flight envelope.) Aeroelastic stability (structural vibration and flutter)

§ 25.629(d)(3)

Control system design

§ 23.685(a) § 25.685(a) § 27.685(a) § 29.685(a)

Engine, engine § 23.901(d)(2) § 25.901(c) § 27.939 § 29.901(c) § 33.68 installation, and § 23.903 § 25.939 § 27.1093 § 29.939 § 33.77 air induction § 23.905 (e) § 25.941 § 27.1041 § 29.1041 (as systems for § 23.929 § 25.1093 § 29.1093 required engines and § 23.939 § 25.1093 § 29.1105 by 14 CFR engine § 23.975(a)(1) § 25.1105 part 25) accessories § 23.1093 cooling § 23.1105 Indication of powerplant IPS or fuel system(s) heater operation installed to prevent ice

§ 23.1305(c)(7) § 25.1305(c)(5) § 27.1305(p) § 29.1305(a)(17)

Air data systems § 23.1323(d) § 23.1325 § 23.1326

§ 25.1323(i) § 25.1325(b) § 25.1326

§ 27.1325(b) § 29.1323(f) § 29.1325(c)

IPS = Ice protection system

Table 3 lists 14 CFR regulations that apply to ice protection equipment and systems.

Table 3. Other 14 CFR Requirements Applicable for all Ice Protection Equipment and Systems

Affected Area 14 CFR part 23

14 CFR part 25

14 CFR part 27

14 CFR part 29

14 CFR part 33

14 CFR part 35 Ice protection equipment § 23.859(i)(2) § 25.859(i)(2) § 27.859(k)(2) § 29.859(i)(2) and systems design and § 23.601 § 25.601 § 27.601 § 29 .601 construction § 23.603 § 25.603 § 27.603 § 29.603 § 23.605 § 25.605 § 27.605 § 29.605 § 23.607 § 25.607 § 27.607 § 29.607 § 23.609 § 25.609 § 27.609 § 29.609 § 23.611 § 25.611 § 27.611 § 29.611 § 23.613 § 25.613 § 27.613 § 29.613 Influence of the IPS on § 23.863 § 25 .863 § 27 .863 § 29 .863 operation of other § 23.1013(d)(2) § 25.1013(d)(2) § 27.1307(d)(2) § 29.1013(d)(2) systems, components, § 23.1199(b) § 25.1199(b) § 27.1309 § 29.1199(b) and requirements (e.g., § 23.1309 § 25.1307(c) § 27 .1327 § 29.1309 flammability protection § 23.1307 § 25.1309 § 27.1351 § 29.1351 and strong electrical § 23.1327 § 25 .1327 § 29.1353 fields and § 23.1351 § 25.1351 electromagnetic § 23.1357 § 25.1353 interference effects produced by the IPS).

§ 25.1357

Fuel tank ignition prevention

§ 25.981

IPS equipment proper function and installation

§ 23.1301 § 23.1309

§ 25.1301 § 25.1309

§ 27.1301 § 27.1309

§ 29.1301 § 29.1309 Miscellaneous equipment § 25.1455 Pilot information and § 23.1525 § 25.1525 § 27.1525 § 29 .1525 operating limitations. § 23.1559(b) § 25.1583 § 27.1559 § 29 .1559 § 23.1583(h) § 25.1585 § 27.1583 § 29.1583 § 23.1585 § 27.1585 § 29.1585 Information on continuing airworthiness of the IPS (may include IPS inspection and maintenance information).

§ 23.1529 § 25.1529 § 27.1529 § 29.1529 § 33.4 § 35 .4

6.2 Ice Protection Requirements: Intentional Operations in Known and Forecast Icing Conditions. Aircraft engine and airframe type certificate and supplemental type certificate applicants must provide ice protection for aircraft engine, airframe, and airframe components to ensure the aircraft and aircraft engines operate safely in known or forecast icing conditions. Table 4 contains ice protection requirements for aircraft certificated for flight into known or forecast icing conditions. You must comply with the requirements in table 4 below and those requirements in section 6.3 of this AC.

Table 4. Additional Ice Protection Equipment and System Requirements for Aircraft Certificated for Flight

into Known and Forecast Icing Conditions

Affected Area 14 CFR part 23

14 CFR part 25

14 CFR part 27

14 CFR part 29

14 CFR part 33 Aeroelastic stability (structural vibration

and flutter)

§ 23.629 § 27.629 § 29.629

Windshield and pilot compartment view § 23.775 § 25.773(b)(1)(ii)

§ 25.775(d)

§ 29.773(b)(1)(ii)

Engines and their installation (reevaluated § 23.901(d)(2) § 25.903 § 27.1093 § 29.1093 § 33.65 for ice ingestion resulting from extended § 23.903 § 25.1093 § 33.77 exposures to icing conditions), and air induction systems for engines and engine

accessories cooling

§ 23.1093

Acceptable engine operability with bleed § 33.66 air required for ice protection, engine ice § 33.68 protection, and indication of engine ice

protection operation.

§ 33.89(b)

Propellers § 23.905(e)

§ 23.929

§ 25.929

Airframe icing and safe in-flight

operations in icing conditions

§ 23.1416 § 23.1419

§ 25.1403 § 25.1419

§ 27.1419 § 29.1419

Air data system § 23.1323(d)

§ 23.1325 § 23.1326

6.3 Ice Protection Requirements: Operating Safely in Icing Conditions. In order for airplanes certificated to 14 CFR part 23 to operate as safely as possible in icing conditions, applicants must demonstrate their airplane’s performance, controllability, maneuverability, and stability is at least equal to the requirements of 14 CFR part 23, Subpart B, as defined in 14 CFR § 23.1419(a). (For additional guidance, see AC 23-8B, AC 23.143-1, and AC 23.1419-2C.) To be able to operate as safely as possible in icing conditions, compliance with specific sections of 14 CFR part 25, Subpart B must be demonstrated. Acceptable means of showing compliance with the certification requirements for flight operations into icing conditions may be found in AC 25-7A and AC 25.1419-1A. Acceptable means of showing compliance with the certification requirements for rotorcraft flight operations into icing conditions may be found in AC 27-1B and AC 29-2C.

7. CERTIFICATION PROCEDURES.

7.1 Certification Procedures: General. At the beginning of the type certification process, applicants should coordinate their icing certification plan with their aircraft certification office (ACO) or engine certification office (ECO). Appendix D of this AC contains typical ice protection equipment design and certification flow charts. Also, when seeking approval for a modified product, you need to comply with 14 CFR § 21.101, commonly known as the “Change Product Rule.” You may choose to use AC 21.101-1 as a means of showing compliance with 14 CFR § 21.101.

You should present your certification plan (checklist) for FAA approval at the start of the IPS design and development efforts. Your certification plan should describe all planned tests and evaluations intended to lead to the certification of your IPS. Further, your certification plan should identify specific items to be certificated, relevant certification requirements, and proposed methods of compliance. Your certification plan should clearly identify analyses and tests, or references to similarity of designs, you intend to use for the certification of the IPS. To help you save time and certification cost, it is important to get FAA concurrence before conducting certification tests. At a minimum, your certification plan should include:

a. An aircraft or aircraft engine systems description.

b. The IPS description.

c. A detailed description of aircraft IPS changes.

d. The certification basis for the requested approval.

e. The certification checklist, including the names of specific designated engineering representatives (DER). The checklist should also include the reports documenting compliance with the regulations.

f. Certification schedules for both the applicant and the FAA.

g. Description of existing analyses or tests.

h. Conformity inspection plans, including the conformity demonstration location.

i. Hazard assessments.

j. Software considerations.

k. High intensity radiated fields and lightning considerations.

l. A list of icing certification test results, if complete, requiring special operating procedures.

m. If the ice protection or detection systems contain complex electronic hardware (such as programmable logic devices (PLD) or application specific integrated circuits (ASIC)), provide plans showing the level of design assurance of these devices. The level of design assurance should be equal to the PLD or ASIC’s potential contribution to aircraft hazards and system failures that could result from electronic hardware faults or malfunctions.

7.2 Certification Procedures: Airframe Manufacturer.

a. Applicants for part 23 type certificates should follow the IPS certification procedures described in AC 23-8B and AC 23.1419-2C. See AC 25-7A and AC 25.1419-1A for similar guidance for 14 CFR part 25 type certificated applicants. Rotorcraft applicants should follow the

guidance in AC 27-1B and AC 29-2C. Supplemental type certificate applicants should also follow the guidance in AC 21-40.

b. Airframe type certificate applicants should present their ACO with a certification plan and checklist showing compliance with the applicable regulatory requirements. This plan should include documented evidence of compliance with the certification requirements. Your design analysis should identify the critical design points and predict the IPS performance for the icing conditions defined in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C. Present your test proposals to the ACO for their approval before testing. As a reminder, you are responsible for showing compliance with applicable 14 CFR parts 23, 25, 27, or 29 regulations, including those covering the aircraft engine and propeller.

7.3 Certification Procedures: Aircraft Engine Manufacturer.

a. Aircraft engine type certificate applicants should review the regulatory guidance material in AC 20-147 and AC 33-2B, and submit their icing certification plan and checklist to their ECO for acceptance. Those applicants seeking supplemental type certification for their aircraft engines should consult AC 21-40 for guidance material. Aircraft engine manufacturers should present a design analysis showing enough critical design points to ensure the engine will function adequately in icing conditions described in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C. Your design analysis must also address freezing fog, falling snow, and blowing snow conditions. See 14 CFR §§ 23.1093, 25.1093, 27.1093, and 29.1093. Aircraft engine type certificate applicants should consider guidance provided in this AC when performing the engine ice protection system design analysis. You should present your test proposal and test procedures to the FAA and get approval from the FAA before testing.

NOTE: 14 CFR part 33 tests are typically conducted in icing wind tunnels or on outdoor test stands to simulate in-flight icing envelopes defined in 14 CFR parts 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C. Compliance with 14 CFR §§ 23.1093(b) or 25.1093(b) tests is typically shown in either natural icing conditions or in simulated icing conditions. Simulated icing conditions may include flight behind an icing tanker or testing in climatic test chambers.

b. Your test proposal should include enough data points throughout the engine power or thrust range to show the engine operates satisfactorily under the proposed test conditions.

8. COMPLIANCE MEANS. Airframe type certificate applicants must perform an analysis and testing to show the acceptability of the aircraft’s ice protection system. See 14 CFR §§ 23.1419, 25.1419, 27.1419, and 29.1419. You should address all flight configurations of the aircraft. To verify your analysis and icing anomalies, and to show the IPS and associated components are effective for safe operations in icing conditions, you must flight test the aircraft or its components in measured natural atmospheric icing conditions. With prior ACO approval, you may use laboratory dry air or simulated icing tests, dry air flight tests, or flight tests in measured simulated icing conditions to supplement flight tests in measured natural icing conditions. The ACs listed in table 5 provide guidance on means of compliance with the FAA regulations pertaining to IPS certification. For further guidance on supplemental type certificates

and amended type certificates, see sections 8.5 and 10.2 of this AC.

Table 5. Means of Compliance for IPS Requirements

Advisory Circular

14 CFR Regulation

Advisory Circular

14 CFR Regulation

Advisory Circular

14 CFR Regulation AC 20-147 § 23.901(d)(2) AC 23.1309-1C § 23.1309 AC 25.1419-1A § 25.773 § 23.903 § 25.929 § 23.1093 § 25.975 § 25.903 § 25.1093 § 25.1093 § 25.1323 § 27.1093 § 25.1325 § 29.1093 § 25 .1326 § 33.68 § 25.1403 § 33.77 § 25.1419 § 25.1419 (safe operation in icing conditions – 14 CFR part 25, Subpart B) AC 23-8B and § 23.1419 (safe AC 23.1419-2C § 23.773 AC 27-1B §27.629 AC 23-143.1 operation in icing conditions – 14 CFR part 23, Subpart B)

§ 23.775 § 23.929 § 23.975 § 23.1093 § 23.1309 § 23.1323 § 23.1325 § 23.1419 § 23.1419 (safe operation in icing conditions – 14 CFR part 23, Subpart B)

§27.975 §27.1093 §27.1301 §27.1309 §27.1325 §27.1419 §27.1419 (safe operations in icing conditions – 14 CFR part 27, Subpart B)

AC 23-16A § 23.901(d)(2) AC 25-7A § 25.1419 (safe AC 29-2C § 29.629 § 23.905(e) operation in icing § 29.773 § 23.929 conditions – 14 CFR § 29.975 § 23.975 part 25, Subpart B) § 29.1093 § 23.1093 § 29.1301 § 29.1309 § 29.1325 § 29.1419 § 29.1419 (safe operation in icing conditions – 14 CFR part 29, Subpart B) § 29.1323 AC 23-17A § 23.1301 § 23.1323 § 23.1326

AC 25.629-1A § 25.629 AC 33-2B § 33.75

AC 23.629-1B § 23.629 AC 25.1309-1A § 25.1309

8.1 Compliance Means: Analysis.

a. The certification applicant should perform analyses to show compliance with the applicable regulations listed in table 5 of this AC.

b. Information defining the icing conditions in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C may be found in appendix E of this AC. Appendix F of this AC contains operational factors you should consider in your compliance analyses. For operational purposes, fixed-wing airplanes should operate safely in icing conditions for a 45-minute destination “hold” flight segment in the continuous maximum icing conditions as defined in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C. See appendix G of this AC for guidance on the 45-minute hold in icing conditions. Note that each turbine engine must operate throughout its flight power range (including idling) without accumulation of ice on the engine and its inlet system, or on airframe components that would adversely affect engine operation, or cause a serious loss of engine power or thrust. (See 14 CFR §§ 23.1093, 25.1093, 27.1093, and 29.1093.) (See section 10 of this AC for guidance applicable for rotorcraft.)

c. When determining compliance with the applicable regulations, you and the ACO personnel should closely review the analyses used to show compliance with the requirements discussed in section 6 of this AC. This scrutiny is necessary because verification of the ice protection equipment and system analyses are typically demonstrated over limited flight test conditions.

d. Airframe and powerplant (aircraft engine or aircraft engine and propeller) IPSs may require different analysis methods. Aircraft surfaces may be more tolerant of ice accretion than the aircraft engine and aircraft engine inlet surfaces. Airframe IPS design methods may also differ somewhat from those applied to the IPS designs for an engine. Note that although the operating envelope can be determined precisely for a specific powerplant/aircraft combination, the powerplant analysis needs to consider the installation of the engine on several airplane models with different required operating envelopes.

e. The IPS design margins are dependent on meteorological factors, airplane-engine operational, and other relevant factors. For an example, the availability of engine bleed air for airframe thermal ice protection systems must be sufficient for safe operation during descent when the engine power may be at idle.

f. Engine and aircraft type certificate applicants should determine the most critical conditions applicable to the aircraft engine inlet and propeller systems’ design, after considering all the meteorological and operational conditions within the operational envelope of the engine. This information will assist the ACO in determining the adequacy of the method used to establish the criticality of those factors. You should define the design points in meteorological and operational terms, for example, in terms of liquid water content (LWC), temperature, drop size, and engine power setting, or propeller pitch and rpm. When you determine the most critical conditions, you should have a specific design objective in mind, with the understanding that some ice buildup may be acceptable for running-wet ice protection systems if it does not risk flight safety.

g. For compliance purposes, be aware that different areas of the aircraft will have different tolerances to ice accumulation and may require different analysis approaches.

8.1.1 Compliance Means: Airframe Analysis.

a. As the applicant, you must select the critical surfaces requiring ice protection for safe operation in icing conditions. These surfaces may include:

(1) Airframe/fuselage ice impact areas.

(2) Leading edges of wings, winglets, and wing struts.

(3) Leading edges of horizontal and vertical stabilizers, and other lifting surfaces and

control surfaces.

(4) Leading edges of control surface balance areas, if not shielded (such as aileron and

elevator horns).

(5) Accessory cooling air intakes that face the airstream and could become restricted due

to ice accretion.

(6) Antennas and masts.

(7) External tanks and fairings.

(8) External hinges, tracks, door handles, and entry steps.

(9) Instruments, including pitot tubes (and masts), static ports, angle-of-attack (AOA)

sensors, and stall warning sensors.

(10) Forward fuselage nose cone and radome.

(11) Windshields (cockpit).

(12) Landing gear.

(13) Retractable forward landing lights.

(14) Ram air turbines.

(15) Ice detection lights, if required.

(16) Vortex generators and other flow control devices like stall strips, vortilons, and

fences.

(17) Other structural protuberances that are exposed to icing conditions.

(18) Fuel tank vents.

(19) Auxiliary power units (APU) inlet, exhaust, and drainpipe.

(20) Propellers.

(21) Engine air induction system.

b. Leading edges of wings are critically sensitive aerodynamically to surface roughness, especially those wings that are not equipped with leading edge high-lift devices (hard wings). Flying in icing conditions with trailing edge flaps extended reduces the wings’ angle of attack. This reduced angle of attack causes ice to build up further aft on the wing’s upper surface, increasing the aerodynamic sensitivity of the wing to icing. For example, ice further aft on the wing may affect the effectiveness of the ailerons and the airplane handling qualities. The aerodynamic effects depend on the airfoil’s aerodynamic characteristics. You must evaluate adverse aerodynamic effects of surface roughness that occur during normal operation of the wing’s ice protection system to ensure safe operation of the aircraft (14 CFR §§ 23.1419 and 25.1419). You should consider protecting the leading edges of high-lift devices because, in addition to ice accretion on the leading edge of the wing, the leading edges of slotted trailingedge flaps may accrete ice during approach and landing. Ice protection is typically not provided for trailing-edge flaps. Ice buildup along the leading edge of the trailing edge flaps may reduce their aerodynamic effectiveness (reduced lift at a fixed angle of attack). This buildup may be evident by airframe buffeting resulting from turbulent airflow over the flaps, and the ice on the flaps may prevent their retraction.

c. You should select the surfaces that require ice protection after careful consideration of icing and operating conditions and the icing requirements discussed in section 6 of this AC.

d. Appendix H of this AC contains information and guidance on ice protection technologies, operating modes, and associated analyses.

e. You should perform a drop impingement and water catch analysis to evaluate the impingement limits and water collection characteristics of aircraft surfaces and components. This analysis also provides the ice collection efficiencies of aircraft surfaces and components. The analysis should consider all the airplane’s flight configurations, phases of flight, and operating envelopes (including airspeeds, aircraft configurations, and angles of attack). The analysis should provide information to determine the extent of ice protection required to protect a surface or component from ice accretion, using the icing conditions defined in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C. Also, determine in your analysis the quantity of heat required for thermal IPSs. Appendix I of this AC provides information about drop impingement and water catch analyses and determining the ice protection coverage.

f. The ice protection for air intakes must ensure satisfactory performance of essential systems that they support.

g. Table 6 shows the meteorological conditions you should consider for a typical compliance analysis for operating in continuous and intermittent maximum icing conditions.

Table 6. Continuous and Intermittent Maximum Icing Conditions

Continuous Maximum Icing Conditions Intermittent Maximum Icing Conditions MVD (Pm)

Temperature (qF)

Liquid Water Content

3 (g/m )

MVD (Pm)

Temperature (qF)

Liquid Water Content

3 (g/m ) 15 32 0.8 15 32 2.925 14 0.6 14 2.5 -4 0.3 -4 1.925 -22 0.2 -22 1.1 25 32 0.5 -40 0.25 14 0.3 25 32 1.75 -4 0.15 14 1.45 -22 0.1 -4 1.125 40 32 0.15 -22 0.7 14 0.10 -40 0.15 -4 0.06 40 32 0.75 -22 0.04 14 0.50 -4 0.35 -22 0.25 -40 0.05 50 32 0.40 14 0.30 -4 0.20 -22 0.10 -40 0.05

h. Section 6.3 of this AC describes how to determine whether your airframe IPS can support safe operation of the aircraft in icing conditions.

i. Select pressure altitudes that cover the range of altitudes associated with each temperature from figures E-2 and E-5 in appendix E of this AC.

j. In addition to the meteorological conditions, your ice protection system design analysis should consider appropriate operational parameters such as aircraft attitude, airspeed, altitude, and engine power settings for the aircraft’s operating envelope. Those operating parameters will identify the combination(s) of meteorological and operating parameters that result in the most critical conditions. Because of the large number of variables involved, more than one critical condition may exist for both intermittent maximum and continuous maximum meteorological conditions.

k. The ice protection system design analysis should show that no hazardous quantity of ice forms on the surfaces that are critical for safe operation of the aircraft when exposed to the intermittent maximum and continuous maximum icing conditions of 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C.

8.1.2 Compliance Means: Aircraft Engine and Propeller Systems Analyses. When defining the most severe conditions for the compliance analyses of aircraft engine, propeller, and related components ice protection systems, the applicant should consider the icing envelopes in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C, Figures 1, 2, 4, and 5, and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C, Figures 1, 2, 4, and 5. The applicant should also consider the entire environmental and operational envelopes of the aircraft on which the propulsion system will be installed. (You should consult with your FAA ACO or ECO for guidance on the applicable environmental and operational envelopes.)

8.1.2.1 Compliance Means: Aircraft Engine Analysis.

a. The applicant should design the aircraft engine and its IPS to protect against the most critical meteorological conditions occurring simultaneously with the most critical aircraft engine (if applicable) operational conditions. For the aircraft engine compliance analysis, you should determine critical design points for both continuous maximum and intermittent maximum conditions. The procedures for determining water catch rate, impingement data, heat available (QA), and heat required (QR) are similar to those discussed for airframe surfaces in section 8.1.1 of this AC. The flow field around engine surfaces is dependent on the mass of air flowing through the engine.

b. Engine reliability during all icing encounters is essential. The design approaches that apply to airframe and aircraft engine systems are different. Aircraft engines must not experience any serious loss of power or thrust because of induction system ice buildup. (See 14 CFR § 33.68.)

c. The aircraft engine manufacturer may know the make and model of some of the aircraft on which the engine will be installed. You cannot be sure that a future application will not differ from planned installations. Therefore, you should not limit the IPS to a specific airplane installation or to a specific airplane operational envelope.

d. Ice buildup on the aircraft’s unprotected surfaces and the aircraft operational conditions during an icing encounter emphasize the need for reliable engine performance. Unprotected aircraft engine struts, spinner cones, and inlet guide vanes may be subject to ice buildup. Therefore, when you use heat to keep these surfaces ice-free, you must guard against the possibility of water runback refreezing inside the air induction system. You should also evaluate the first-stage fan or compressor blades of axial flow engines for possible ice buildup, with the IPS operating. Without the ice protection system operating, ice buildups on these engine components may distort or adversely affect the airflow intake and cause adverse effects on engine operability or thrust. The ice may also shed and damage downstream engine components. Minimizing the ice buildup on an operating engine prevents possible damage from ice ingestion and helps to ensure reliable engine operation. You must demonstrate that the level of ice buildup on the engine permits acceptable engine handling and performance.

e. You should consider a buildup of ice on any aircraft engine surface unsafe, if the ice buildup:

(1) Causes a significant loss of power or thrust;

(2) Causes airflow disturbances that excite harmonic compressor or fan blade

frequencies;

(3) Becomes large enough to cause serious engine damage when ingested;

(4) Causes damage to adjacent structure or engine components when shed by centrifugal

force from rotating surfaces;

(5) Causes an imbalance of rotating components that produces vibrations greater than

those for which the engine had been approved;

(6) Causes damage due to reduced clearance between rotating and stationary

components; or

(7) Causes any other hazardous engine operation.

8.1.2.2 Compliance Means: Propeller Analysis. Aircraft type certificate applicants installing propellers on their aircraft can find more information on compliance with aircraft requirements associated with propeller IPSs in appendix J of this document. A buildup of ice on a propeller is considered unsafe if the ice causes:

a. A serious loss of thrust;

b. An unsafe engine condition;

c. Damage to adjacent structure when detached by centrifugal force;

d. Vibrations resulting in engine or propeller structural failure; or

e. Any other hazardous engine, propeller, or aircraft operation.

8.1.3 Compliance Means: Aircraft Engine Inlets Analysis.

a. Ice buildup on the engine inlet nose cowl, spinner cones, and other areas of the aircraft that may affect engine operation is generally more critical to safety of flight than ice buildup on aircraft surfaces discussed in paragraph 8.1.1 of this AC. Even though meteorological design conditions may be the same, operational conditions that affect engine operation (particularly local surface flow conditions) may vary significantly. Although a fixed-engine operational condition is assumed for certification of the airframe icing system, engine airflow may vary considerably because of changes in engine thrust or power during normal flight maneuvers. These changes in engine thrust or power must be considered when determining the most critical conditions for these airplane areas. Nacelle inlet surfaces are susceptible to slush and ice crystal buildup during operations in glaciated or mixed phase icing conditions. Also, you must evaluate the effects of ice buildups on vortex generators or other boundary-layer control devices, if they are used in or on the engine air induction system, to ensure that these devices continue to perform their intended functions.

b. Design of the airframe ice protection is based on the most probable engine operating condition for a specific airplane operational mode, therefore you should consider the need for increased reliance on engine thrust or power during icing conditions. You should also take into consideration these needs during the design of nacelle inlet ice protection systems because the engine must be able to operate through a wide range of power settings.

c. When determining the most critical design points for engine air inlets, use guidance provided in paragraphs 8.1.1.a(21), 8.1.1.d, 8.1.1.e, 8.1.1.j, and 8.1.1.k of this AC.

(1) The inlet design compliance analysis should show the engine inlet IPS prevents ice formations that adversely affect continued safe engine operation or cause serious power loss. In your analysis, use the meteorological conditions described in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C and engine operations that meet the aircraft operational needs.

(2) Engine inlet IPSs are often designed to “run dry” (impinging moisture is evaporated) under continuous maximum icing conditions and “run wet” under intermittent maximum icing conditions. Service experience shows that this approach is satisfactory when the formation of hazardous runback ice is prevented.

d. Your analysis should include evaluations of ice collection on inlets for the APU, accessory cooling, and fuel vent areas. The analysis should determine whether ice will collect on the inlets and affect the APU’s performance. Improperly located NACA inlet scoops may collect ice, so you should include their location and ice collection potential in the analysis. Results obtained during natural icing flight tests of NACA inlet scoops range from small amounts of ice collection on turboprop engine cooling inlet lips (located on the engine cowling or nacelles) to complete blockage of electronic cooling inlets located on the radome.

e. 14 CFR part 23 airplane type certificate applicants can find guidance on the approval of turbine engine induction system ice protection in AC 23-16A. This AC also includes guidance for testing IPS in falling and blowing snow and in freezing fog.

8.1.4 Compliance Means: Ice and Icing Conditions Detection Systems Analyses. Aircraft instrumentation may alert the flight crew or aircraft systems (or both) to the presence of icing conditions or ice buildup on aircraft surfaces. These ice detection systems may be primary or advisory. Appendix K of this document contains guidance for airframe type certificate applicants on obtaining approval of ice detection systems.

8.1.5 Compliance Means: Windshield Analysis. Airframe type certificate applicants must provide a means to prevent, or to clear accumulations of, ice from the windshields during icing conditions to ensure pilots’ field of vision is not restricted during flight into icing conditions (14 CFR §§ 23.775(f), 25.773(b)(1)(ii), and 29.773(b)(1)(ii)). These surfaces are usually protected by electric heat elements. Your analysis should confirm that the windshield surface temperature is sufficient to prevent ice accumulation without causing structural damage to the windshield. Appendix L of this AC provides added guidance for windshield ice protection.

8.1.6 Compliance Means: Air Data System Sensors and Probes Analyses.

a. Airframe type certificate applicants should provide ice protection for flight essential instrument sensors that may be affected by flight into icing conditions. Confirm that instrument surfaces and drainage cavities are protected against ice buildups and blockage by frozen drained water that may adversely affect the instrument.

b. You must provide compliance analyses showing static and pitot pressure ports are either protected against or not affected by ice buildup, frozen runback water from forward surfaces, and water and slush from the landing gear during takeoff and landing. Slush and water ingested into static and pitot pressure ports during takeoff or at a lower altitude might freeze when the airplane climbs to higher altitudes and lower temperatures. Instruments that could be affected include pitot tubes, engine-pressure-ratio total pressure probes, and certain types of stall warning system sensors. These instruments are typically electrically heated.

c. When drafting your compliance analyses for instrument sensing elements or probes located on or near the fuselage, consider varying the water drop concentration to account for a variety of icing conditions. As the aircraft flies through icing clouds, small cloud drops may not impinge directly on the fuselage, but may be carried over the fuselage surface by the airflow. While these diverted drops reduce the collection efficiency in the stagnation regions of the fuselage, the diverted drops can increase water concentration near the fuselage’s surface, and significantly increase the water catch of probes, such as pitot tubes and other sensor probes. The resultant ice buildup may adversely affect the probe’s function.

8.1.7 Compliance Means: Ice Protection System Failure Analysis. Applicants must perform system failure analyses as a means of showing compliance with the applicable certification rules (14 CFR §§ 25.901(c), 27.901(b)(1), 29.901(c), and 14 CFR §§ 23.1309, 25.1309, 27.1309, and 29.1309). You should use the guidance provided in AC 23.1309-1C, AC 25.1309-1A, AC 27-1B, AC 29-2C, or AC 33-2B, to determine the hazardous system failures for your product. You must perform failure modes and effects analyses to ensure that single failures do not result in unsafe conditions. Perform fault-tree analysis of system failures to ensure safety objectives of combined failures are met. Separation, cascading, and common cause analyses ensure system independence if there are various airplane failures. For example, you should consider leading edge wing slat failure conditions and bird-strike conditions for a wing leading edge thermal anti-ice system. Also, under certain failure conditions, the hot air of a thermal IPS may approach temperatures that can affect the integrity of nearby structure and may ignite leaking fuel. You should evaluate these and similar conditions to ensure aircraft safety. When system failures result in unsafe operations, the aircraft must exit icing conditions and be capable of continued safe flight and landing.

8.1.8 Compliance Means: Flutter Analysis. Aircraft must be free of flutter and control reversals. (See 14 CFR §§ 23.629(a), (b), (c), or (d), 25.629(a), 27.629, and 29.629.) You may show compliance with the applicable certification rules by following the guidance contained in AC 23.629-1A, AC 25.629-1A, AC 27-1B, and AC 29-2C. For transport category airplanes not approved for operation in icing conditions, you must consider the maximum likely ice accumulation expected, as a result of an inadvertent encounter, to show compliance with 14 CFR § 25.629(d)(3).

8.1.9 Compliance Means: Power Sources Analysis. Applicants should evaluate the power (energy) source needs of their IPS (electrical, engine bleed air, pneumatic pumps, etc.). Compliance analyses or tests should show that each power source requirement is adequate for each IPS. You must ensure an IPS component failure does not affect the power available to operate other essential equipment (14 CFR §§ 23.1309, 25.1309, 27.1309, and 29.1309). All power sources that affect engine or engine IPSs for multiengine aircraft must comply with engine isolation requirements contained in 14 CFR §§ 23.903(b) and (c), 25.903(b), and 29.903(d).

8.2 Compliance Means: Tests.

a. Applicants must perform tests to show their aircraft can operate safely in the icing conditions as specified in 14 CFR §§ 23.1419, 25.1419, 27.1419, and 29.1419, and 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C. You must perform flight and ground tests to verify the analyses, and you may use other means to support test data that show your aircraft will perform satisfactorily in icing conditions. You must determine that there are no icing anomalies associated with your design. Flight testing must be performed in measured natural icing conditions. Flight testing may also be performed in dry air, dry air with simulated ice shapes, or in measured simulated icing conditions. (See AC 23-8B, AC 23.1419-2C, AC 25-7A, AC 25.1419-1A, AC 27-1B, and AC 29-2C.)

b. Typically, applicants perform icing flight tests in three stages: (1) dry air tests with the IPS operating, (2) dry air tests with predicted simulated ice shapes, and (3) natural icing flight tests.

8.2.1 Compliance Means: Natural Icing Flight Tests.

a. Applicants must show the effectiveness of the ice protection equipment and systems by flight testing in measured natural atmospheric icing conditions. (See 14 CFR §§ 23.1419(b), 25.1419(b), 27.1419(b), and 29.1419(b).) During the natural icing flight tests, you should target the critical design point icing conditions you identified in your compliance analyses. Because natural icing characteristics are probable, performing natural icing tests at each critical design point may be impractical (See appendix M of this AC.) Icing tests should also investigate the effects of runback ice buildups aft of protected surfaces and the buildup of ice on unprotected surfaces to determine whether the ice poses a hazard to continued safe flight. Engine operational characteristics and the aircraft handling qualities and performance should be acceptable when runback ice, buildup ice on unprotected surfaces, or intercycle ice roughness exist on deice protected surfaces.

b. You should use data from the natural icing tests to validate analytical methods used for showing compliance with the icing regulations. You should also use the natural icing tests data to validate the results of simulated ice shape and simulated icing tests used during your icing certification.

c. You must test in natural icing to evaluate the effectiveness of the propeller IPSs and to check for icing anomalies not addressed by laboratory tests and analyses. You should provide a means of measuring aircraft performance with the propeller, and propeller and engine vibration. Also, record propeller ice accretion and shed-ice trajectories.

8.2.1.1 Compliance Means: Natural Icing Flight Test Icing Conditions Considerations.

a. You should record the parameters that measured the icing conditions encountered during certification testing in the same units as those used in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29 Appendix C. This will assist you in understanding the effectiveness of the IPS. You may use these measurements to verify analyses of the IPS, to understand icing anomalies, and to extrapolate the IPS effectiveness to icing conditions you did not encounter. The parameters (LWC, mean drop diameter, temperature, cloud extent, and altitude) used in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C are important for thermal IPS designs. The water catch and the required heat density on thermally protected surfaces are dependent on these icing condition parameters. Measure these parameters and airspeed during natural and simulated icing flight tests to characterize the icing environment. You may also use the icing cloud drop median volume diameter (MVD) to determine IPS coverage. (See appendix I of this AC.) You should evaluate the operation of deicing boots at cold temperatures. The LWC and icing intensity are important parameters for defining preactivation and intercycle ice accretion on deicing boots. You should refer to appendix N of this AC for information on measuring natural and simulated icing conditions.

b. Appendix M of this AC contains information on finding meteorological conditions for natural icing flight-testing.

c. Perform flight tests in icing conditions that are within icing condition envelopes described in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C. Appendix O of this AC provides procedures for converting the contents of 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C icing envelopes to a distance-based format. The quality of an icing event includes the size of the aircraft ice buildups and the rate of ice buildup (icing intensity). Appendix P of this AC describes how to determine the icing intensity of an icing event.

d. Flight testing in convective air currents of cumulus clouds may lead to severe turbulence and hail encounters, and may cause structural damage to test aircraft. Flight testing in intermittent maximum icing conditions may not be necessary when your compliance analyses show the critical ice protection design points in these icing conditions (heat loads, critical ice shapes, ice accretion, and ice accretion rate, etc.) are acceptable and enough test data exist to verify the analyses.

8.2.1.2 Compliance Means: Natural Icing Flight Test IPS Evaluation.

a. For non-automatic IPS systems, the flight crew must activate the IPS according to the Airplane Flight Manual (AFM) procedures. You should conduct icing flight tests with delayed IPS activation to simulate icing events when the pilot may unintentionally delay activation of the IPS. You must determine the delay interval based on the icing recognition means and crew procedures. Ice buildup resulting from delay intervals greater than 2 minutes may shed and be ingested into an engine. Per 14 CFR § 33.77, you must ensure acceptable engine operation after ingesting the maximum in-service ice mass that can be shed from the airframe. Determine the delayed-activation ice buildup in the continuous maximum icing conditions of 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C. Include the time required for the IPS to perform its intended function as part of the delayed activation interval. Aircraft handling qualities with

the delayed activation ice buildup should remain acceptable and the aircraft must operate safely. You are not required to test for delayed activation of IPSs that use a primary automatic ice detection system.

b. You should evaluate the effects of preactivation ice accretion (ice accumulated before the IPS becomes fully effective). Preactivation ice includes ice buildups that occur before thermal IPSs achieve their operating temperatures, fluid IPSs clear ice accretions, and ice buildups that occur before completion of a deicing cycle. Aircraft handling qualities should remain acceptable, and the aircraft must operate safely with the preactivation ice accretion.

c. Applicants for certification of fluid IPSs should show acceptable distributions of the system’s fluid over the protected surfaces. Acceptable distributions of the fluid determined in dry air may result in freezing of the IPS fluid at cold temperatures. You should test windshield fluid anti-ice systems to show the fluid does not become opaque at cold temperatures. A clear and legible means should be used to show fluid flow rates and the fluid quantity remaining. You should provide shutoff valves for systems using flammable fluids. The AFM should include information describing how long it will take to exhaust the fluid.

8.2.1.3 Compliance Means: Natural Icing Flight Test Ice Detector Evaluation. Applicants should perform natural icing flight tests of primary and advisory ice detectors to show they detect ice before hazardous ice builds up on aircraft surfaces. The flight test should also demonstrate the intended functions of the ice detector, such as automatic operation of the IPS. Conduct flight tests at near-freezing ambient conditions to evaluate the ice detector’s functional reliability. This testing should also evaluate the possible accumulation of hazardous airframe ice in airplane (local) surface areas that have high airspeeds (for example, airfoil or engine inlet surfaces) before the ice detector detects icing conditions. You may determine temperatures for this testing by evaluating conditions when the water catch on critical aircraft surfaces freezes because of high local air velocities while only a small fraction of the water catch on the ice detector’s sensor surface freezes. Determining the critical temperatures may require testing the ice detector and critical aircraft surfaces in an icing wind tunnel.

8.2.1.4 Compliance Means: Natural Icing Flight Test Ice Shedding.

a. Ice shed from the airframe may be ingested into the engine and may cause engine damage that may result in unsafe operability and thrust loss. This ice may also damage downstream aircraft structure and components. Ice shedding from the forward fuselage and wings may cause significant damage to fuselage-mounted engines and pusher propellers. Airframe type certificate applicants should show by analysis or flight testing that ice shedding from aircraft components (including antennas) does not cause engine or propeller damage that would adversely affect engine or propeller operation. (See 14 CFR §§ 23.1093 and 25.1093.) You should also consider airframe damage that may result from propeller ice shedding.

b. Currently available trajectory and impingement analyses may not accurately predict damage caused by ice shedding. Experience has shown that analyses are unable to accurately predict the trajectories of ice shed from aircraft forward areas, such as from the radome, wing, wing fairings, and control surfaces. Therefore, trajectory analyses are unacceptable predictors of shed ice trajectories. Your damage analysis should conservatively consider the most critical ice

mass that shed and its impact with the areas of concern. Also, when predicting the ice trajectories, assume all shed ice is ingested into the engines or propellers, independent of the trajectories. In lieu of a conservative analysis, flight testing has been used for aircraft certificated under 14 CFR part 23 to show that ice shedding does not impact critical areas (see AC 23.1419-2C). Appendix Q of this AC provides information and guidance on ice shedding. AC 33-2B provides guidance on flight-test procedures for engine induction system icing and engine ice ingestion test procedures.

c. You should evaluate failures of the IPS and the resultant hazards from ice shedding (14 CFR §§ 23.1309 and 25.1309). Perform this analysis using the probability of the failure occurrence versus resultant hazard levels.

8.2.1.5 Compliance Means: Natural Icing Flight Test Additional Guidance and Information. Information on natural ice testing is in AC 23-8B; AC 23.143-1; AC 23.1419-2C; AC 25-7A; AC 25.1419-1A; AC 27-1B; AC 29-2C; AC 33-2B; and appendix M of this AC.

8.2.2 Compliance Means: Dry Air Flight Tests.

a. Dry air flight tests are usually conducted before natural icing tests to evaluate the aircraft with the IPS operating. The initial dry air tests are conducted to verify the IPS (for example deicing boots) operates as intended and does not affect the aircraft’s flying qualities, and to measure thermal characteristics for verifying analyses of thermal IPSs.

b. You may use dry air flight tests to verify significant portions of the IPS analyses and to demonstrate the aerodynamic effects of predicted ice shapes. You should perform these tests before conducting natural icing tests. These tests check the function, performance, and compatibility of all systems components. During the dry air flight tests, you can verify the effects of engine bleed air used by the IPS on engine thrust settings. Data collected during dry air tests allow you to analyze heat requirements and availability during various operational conditions. You can also get information about the effects of the local environment on the installed components of the IPS during these dry air flight tests. Examples of the local environments are propeller wash on the wing and empennage and wing downwash on the horizontal stabilizer. You should use these tests to evaluate the aircraft’s handling qualities using simulated ice shapes on unprotected and protected surfaces to show compliance with Subpart B of 14 CFR parts 23, 25, 27, and 29.

c. Compliance means for several commonly used IPSs and components are discussed below. They illustrate typical dry air flight test practices. However, you should evaluate your IPS for compliance as your IPS design dictates.

8.2.2.1 Compliance Means: Dry Air Flight Test Thermal Ice Protection Systems Evaluation.

a. Dry air flight tests are conducted to verify the system design parameters and thermal performance analysis.

b. Normally, the IPS components are instrumented to measure the heat energy distributed to the heated surfaces and the temperature of the heated surfaces. You can use these measurements to validate your IPS thermal analyses by comparing the predicted with the measured parameters. The test ambient temperature and altitude should cover the temperature-altitude envelope limits of 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C for fixed-wing and rotary-wing aircraft, respectively. You can use measured dry-air surface temperatures to determine the maximum possible surface temperatures and heat transfer characteristics. You can also use the measured surface temperatures to evaluate the adequacy of the heat source. You may use dry air testing to verify that the temperatures measured on the IPS component surfaces are within those allowed for the structure.

8.2.2.2 Compliance Means: Dry Air Flight Test Pneumatic Ice Protection Systems. For aircraft designs using pneumatic deicing boots, applicants should perform tests to demonstrate the pneumatic characteristics of the IPS. This includes the deicing boots’ inflation and deflation pressure rates and the inflated dwell intervals and pressures. You should evaluate these inflation and deflation rates and air pressures throughout the altitude range defined in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C, and the aircraft and IPS performance envelopes. The deicing boots must operate effectively within the Continuous Maximum and Continuous Intermittent Envelopes of 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C. Cycling of the pneumatic IPS should have no hazardous effect on the aircraft’s performance and handling qualities. Operate the pneumatic IPS in flight at the coldest temperature (-22°F) required by 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C, Continuous Maximum Icing Conditions. Cycling of the boots at the coldest temperature should show acceptable boot performance and that no damage occurs to the boots. Include all airspeed and temperature limitations on use of the deicing boots in the Limitation Section of the AFM. For transport category airplanes, you must show acceptable IPS alerts and cautions required by 14 CFR § 25.1419(c) during dry air testing. For transport category rotorcraft, 14 CFR § 29.1419(e) requires a means be provided to identify or determine the formation of ice on critical parts of the aircraft.

8.2.2.3 Compliance Means: Dry Air Flight Test Propeller Thermal Ice Protection Systems Evaluation.

a. For propulsion systems that include propeller thermal IPSs, applicants may perform dryair flight-tests to show compliance with 14 CFR § 23.903(c) and 14 CFR §§ 25.901(c), 25.903(b), and 25.1419(c).

b. You may perform initial evaluations of the electrothermal IPS power requirements at critical propeller operating and icing conditions during dry air testing. You may accomplish this evaluation by using suitable instrumentation to measure the electrical power consumed.

c. During dry air flight tests, you should monitor various propeller IPS parameters to confirm proper operation of the IPS. Also, monitor the IPS current, brush block voltage between each input brush and the ground brush, and IPS duty cycles to ensure that the IPS power remains within limits.

d. You should check the propeller IPS operation throughout the propeller’s expected revolutions per minute (rpm) and cyclic pitch ranges during flight in icing conditions. You should investigate and correct all vibrations deemed unacceptable.

8.2.2.4 Compliance Means: Dry Air Flight Test Windshield Ice Protection Evaluation. Airframe type certificate applicants should conduct dry-air flight tests to verify thermal analyses used to show compliance with 14 CFR §§ 23.775(f), 25.773(b)(1)(ii), and 29.773(b)(1)(ii). You may need to measure the inner and outer windshield surface temperatures to verify your thermal analysis. With the windshield IPS on, you should evaluate the visibility, including distortions through the protected windshield area, for both day and night operations. Also, evaluate the size and location of the protected area for adequate visibility during the approach and landing phases of flight. (See appendix L of this AC.)

8.2.2.5 Compliance Means: Dry Air Flight Test Air-data Instrumentation Ice Protection Evaluation. Applicants should measure the surface temperature of air-data instruments (for example, pitot tubes, pitot-static pressure probes, and angle-of-attack probes (if ice protected)) during dry air flight tests or icing wind tunnel tests to verify thermal analyses used to show compliance with 14 CFR §§ 23.1323(d), 23.1325(b)(3), 25.1323(i), 25.1325(b), 27.1325(b), and 29.1325(c). You should evaluate the acceptability of the air data instruments’ ice protection during natural or simulated icing tests. You must also ensure the acceptability of an indication system for alerting the flight crew when the pitot tube IPS is not heated. (See 14 CFR §§ 23.1326(b)(1)(and (2) and 25.1326(b) (1) and (2).) An acceptable indication system may consist of separate lights or crew alert signals on an electronic display for each pitot source. Further guidance on acceptable means of compliance is in AC 23-17A and AC 25-11.

8.2.2.6 Compliance Means: Dry Air Flight Test Safe-flight Evaluation with Simulated Ice Shapes.

a. Airframe type certificate applicants may flight test their aircraft with simulated ice shapes to show safe aircraft performance and handling qualities during flight into icing conditions. (See section 6.3 of this AC.) Using simulated ice shapes will allow you to evaluate the aircraft’s flying qualities in stable, dry air. It also allows you to evaluate the flying qualities without melting, sublimation, shedding, and erosion of ice buildups, as would occur with natural ice accretions. Also, dry-air flight testing of aircraft with simulated ice shapes facilitates demonstration of compliance with the required regulations and results in significant decreases in flight test costs, compared to flight testing in natural icing conditions.

b. You should develop and substantiate the simulated ice shape and surface texture using methods acceptable to the FAA. Use conservative methods, and address 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C icing conditions. The ice shapes and texture should represent those for the critical conditions for the flight characteristic and phase of flight under investigation. Alternatively, you can select a single, most critical ice shape and texture for all flight characteristics and phases of flight. Consider ice shapes and textures that form on protected and unprotected aircraft surfaces during the different phases of flight, including a 45-minute destination hold for your airplane.

c. You should determine the effect of the 45-minute hold in continuous maximum icing conditions of 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C. You should assume the airplane remains in a rectangular “racetrack” pattern, with all turns made within the icing cloud. Therefore, you should not use a horizontal extent correction for this analysis. You should also consider ice buildups that may form on protected surfaces before the ice protection system becomes fully effective after activation and during normal operation of the protection system. For example, consider the intercycle ice roughness on deicing IPS surfaces. If the failure analysis required by 14 CFR §§ 23.1309, 25.1309, 27.1309, and 29.1309 shows the need for continued safe flight following a failure in the IPS, such as for a portion of a wing or horizontal stabilizer, flight test the ice shape that results from the critical IPS failure to show the required performance and handling qualities are acceptable.

d. Appendix R of this AC provides information on how to determine ice shapes and textures of protected and unprotected surfaces and how to select critical ice shapes.

e. Information about testing methods and procedures may be found in AC 23-8B, AC 23.1419-2C, AC 25.1419-1A, AC 27-1B, and AC 29-2C.

f. You should conduct flight tests in measured natural icing conditions to evaluate the adequacy of simulated ice shapes used during dry air testing. Icing conditions that result in the simulated critical ice shape may not occur during natural icing testing. Also, the selected critical ice shape may be a composite of different ice features resulting in conservative degradation of performance and handling qualities for several phases of flight, and may not be a shape that would occur during natural icing. Therefore, effects of the simulated ice shapes during testing should be acceptably similar to that of natural ice shapes to provide assurance that the simulated ice shapes are conservative and properly derived. The corroboration should include confirmation that surfaces predicted to be free of ice, do in fact, remain ice-free. Guidance for determining the adequacy of the ice shapes is in appendix R of this AC.

g. Evaluations of performance and handling qualities results with natural ice accretions should be similar to the aircraft’s flying qualities with simulated ice shapes. Dissimilarity of results between the natural and simulated ice shape testing may require reevaluation of the simulated ice shapes and retesting, or added testing in natural icing conditions.

h. You should evaluate the effects of ice buildups on unprotected surfaces, such as on the radome or fuselage nose, and on air data system measurements, such as pitot and static pressures, angle-of-attack, stall warning, and airflow conditions. No adverse effects on the air data system measurements should occur. You may perform this evaluation using simulated ice shapes. Record and correct all adverse air data system effects that occur during natural icing tests.

i. You must adjust the aircraft’s operating speeds, stall protection system activation schedules, and performance and operating procedures and limits to ensure compliance with the requirements discussed in section 6 of this AC. You should consider thrust losses resulting from the use of engine bleed air for ice protection and from reduced propeller efficiency caused by ice buildups on the propeller blades. Provide this information in the AFM.

j. You should approach simulated-ice-shape flight testing with extreme caution. Pre-flight analyses and flight test planning should result in a safe buildup to the full simulated-ice configuration.

8.2.2.7 Compliance Means: Dry Air Flight Test Ice-Contaminated Tailplane Stall (ICTS). Ice accretion on the horizontal stabilizer may cause early airflow separation over the lower horizontal stabilizer surface, resulting in loss of airplane pitch control, loss of elevator authority, and pitch control force anomalies (reversed control forces and high upset recovery control forces). Adverse airplane pitch control and stability resulting from the reduced horizontal stabilizer stall angle (caused by the ice contamination) may occur during airplane configuration changes, such as when wing flaps are extended. This may also occur when engine power settings are changed and during changes in the airspeed. Airframe type certificate applicants should investigate ice-contaminated tailplane stall (ICTS) for all airplane designs, including those with powered controls. Applicants should determine whether this condition is likely to occur, resulting in an unsafe flight operation. Airplanes susceptible to ICTS are those having a near zero or negative tailplane stall margin. This evaluation typically is performed using simulated ice shapes along the leading edge of the horizontal stabilizer. An acceptable flight test procedure for determining susceptibility to ICTS is in AC 25-7A and AC 23.143-1. Appendix S of this AC provides guidance on ice-contaminated horizontal stabilizer stall.

8.2.3 Compliance Means: Simulated Icing Flight Tests.

a. Flight-testing in simulated icing conditions has successfully verified analyses required for approval of IPSs. You may use icing tankers or spray rigs installed on the test aircraft to spray supercooled water drops to simulate icing conditions. Use these simulated icing flight tests to verify drop impingement limits and to determine or verify simulated ice shapes. You may also use the testing to measure heat transfer coefficients, and to show ice shedding from selected aircraft components. Because of the limited size of the icing spray plume, testing is typically limited to small surface areas and components: for example, heated air-data probes, antennas, air inlets (including engine induction air inlets), windshields, and local areas on the wing and empennage.

b. You must measure simulated icing conditions as required by 14 CFR §§ 23.1419, 25.1419, 27.1419, and 29.1419. (See appendix N of this AC for information on instrumentation to measure icing conditions.) Your measurements should characterize icing condition parameters that are useful for understanding the test objectives. Calibrate simulated icing plumes before testing, including the plume’s LWC and uniformity and the spectra of the water drop diameters. Alternatively, provide information that shows current calibration of the icing plume relative to parameters used to produce the plume (spray array water and air pressures, mass flow of the water, water temperature, etc.).

c. Producing the LWC defined in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C for small and large drop diameters may be difficult with some spray nozzles. Therefore, the water catch and resulting ice shapes may differ from that resulting from the icing conditions described in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C. Test results from simulated icing flight tests with icing conditions other than those defined in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C, should be conservative when compared

with results that are in 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C and 14 CFR part 29, Appendix C. Conservatism should be based on the most adverse results expected from an investigation; larger ice buildups may not lead to conservative test results.

d. See appendix T of this AC for information on simulated icing flight-testing.

8.2.4 Compliance Means: Wind Tunnel Tests.

a. The applicant may use laboratory dry air or simulated icing tests of the components or component models, as necessary, with flight tests in natural icing conditions to verify the ice protection system analyses required by 14 CFR §§ 23.1419(b)(3), 25.1419(b)(3), 27.1419(b)(3), and 29.1419(b)(3). You may also use these compliance means to check for icing anomalies, and to show the effectiveness of the IPS. Appendices R and U of this AC provide guidance on the use of icing wind tunnels. See appendix R, section R.4.2, of this AC for guidance on the use of dry air wind tunnels for determining the aerodynamic effects of ice shapes.

b. You should design icing wind tunnel tests, test conditions, and models to ensure that scaling parameters, such as Reynolds number and Weber number, are similar to those for fullscale flight conditions. If scaling parameters are not similar, you should clearly show how you extrapolated the small-scale test results to full-scale. The extrapolation procedure must be validated. Install the model in the icing wind tunnel to simulate the flight attitude and airplane configuration associated with the most critical flight condition. If you use flaps or other devices on the model to produce the proper flow field conditions, show an agreement between test and full-scale flow conditions.

c. You should address tunnel effects, such as those from the tunnel walls, model blockage, and model support effects, in your analysis.

d. Fluid ice protection systems tested in an icing tunnel should prevent ice formation on the protection surfaces for the designed period of protection. Also, the flow rate of freezing-pointdepressant fluids should be within the design value.

8.3 Compliance Means: Surfaces Without Ice Protection. Ice buildup may be tolerated on some unprotected aircraft surfaces. The aircraft must have acceptable flying qualities and enough power or thrust to offset the added ice-related drag forces. Ice buildup on control surfaces may be more critical than other airframe surfaces. Provide an analysis and reason for leaving these surfaces unprotected from ice buildup. This analysis must show the aircraft will operate safely in icing conditions without ice protection for these surfaces. If there is doubt about the lack of protection and the adequacy of the provided IPS, you should verify the acceptability of the IPS by flight tests.

8.4 Compliance Means: Ice Inspection Lights and Cues.

a. Unless your aircraft is restricted from flight into known or forecast icing conditions at night, 14 CFR §§ 23.1419(d) and 25.1403 require means for identifying hazardous ice buildups on critical airplane surfaces. You should provide satisfactory lighting for ice inspection during night operation unless you provide another acceptable means of ice inspection (such as a primary

flight ice detector system (PFIDS)). (See Reference 2 of section 14 for wing inspection light design criteria.) Evaluate ice inspection lights in and out of clouds during flight in darkness to determine that the target area is illuminated without excessive glare, reflections, or other distractions to the flight crew. You may perform these tests during other airplane certification flight tests. You may use airplane-mounted illumination to comply with these requirements. The FAA does not consider use of a handheld flashlight acceptable because of the associated additional flight crew workload. The AFM should describe the expected airframe icing cues and the flight crew action associated with the cues.

b. You should provide the flight crew with a means to determine when to activate the ice protection system. Ice buildup on a reference surface, observable by the flight crew, may be an acceptable means, providing you can confirm the airplane will operate safely with ice buildup on the airplane. You should show acceptable ice inspection cues during natural icing flight tests for the applicable aircraft operation, configurations, and phases of flight. The AFM should identify the icing cues and provide the flight crew action associated with the cues.

c. For some airplanes, the critical control surface for ice accretion may not be the wing, but a control surface on the empennage, which is not observable by the flight crew. If the flight crew cannot see the wings or critical empennage control surface, one acceptable means of compliance with 14 CFR §23.1419(d) and §25.1403 is to install an ice evidence probe in a location visible to the flight crew. You should show that formation of ice on this device precedes or occurs simultaneously with ice accretion on the critical surface. You should consider illuminating this device. Another means of compliance is the use of primary inflight icing detectors, where the ice detector sensor becomes the reference surface. See appendix K of this AC for guidance on using ice detectors.

8.5 Compliance Means: Reference to Previously Accomplished Tests.

a. Approval of an IPS by similarity is allowed if other aircraft have been certificated with an IPS that includes components that are functionally and aerodynamically equivalent. (See 14 CFR § 23.1419(c) and AC 23-1419-2C.)

b. If you are seeking approval of ice protection equipment and systems based on previously approved IPSs, you must specify the aircraft model and the component to which the referenced approval applies. Similarity certification may also apply to replacing an IPS component by supplemental type certificate. You must have all the regulatory compliance information from the referenced certification. You should show specific similarities in the physical, functional, thermodynamic, pneumatic, aerodynamic, and environmental exposure. You should perform analyses to show that the component’s installation, operation, ice-protection effectiveness, and the resulting effects on the aircraft’s performance and handling are equivalent to those of the previously approved configuration. You should validate the analysis by test. The analysis may include comparative results from icing and aerodynamic wind tunnel tests, flight tests, engineering simulator laboratory tests, service history, materials laboratory tests, and engineering judgment. However, you should carefully review these analyses to ensure that flight safety remains acceptable and the ice-protection effectiveness, integrity, and operating procedures are acceptable.

c. If the similarity certification is brought about by a change to the airplane type design, you should consider whether the changes in the IPS and associated aircraft behavior are sufficient to require flight-crew training or affect the aircraft’s airworthiness or operational approvals. An assessment of a new installation should consider changes affecting the aircraft and the operation of other aircraft systems. If there is doubt about the effects of the changes, conduct additional tests and analyses to resolve any issues. If there is doubt about resolution of the effects of the differences, conduct flight tests in measured natural icing conditions.

8.6 Compliance Means: Perform Intended Function in Icing Conditions. All aircraft systems and components should function as intended when the aircraft encounters icing conditions.

8.6.1 Compliance Means: Engines and Equipment Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions. During icing tests, you must monitor engines and their accessories, such as generators and alternators operating under maximum ice protection load, to ensure that they remain within their limits. (See 14 CFR §§ 23.1041, 25.1041, 27.1041, and 29.1041.)

8.6.2 Compliance Means: Engine Alternate Induction Air Sources Performance of Intended Functions in Icing Conditions. Engine alternate induction air sources should remain functional to ensure satisfactory operation of essential engine subsystems.

8.6.3 Compliance Means: Fuel System Venting Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions. Ice accumulation should not adversely affect fuel venting system.

8.6.4 Compliance Means: Landing Gear Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions. A retractable landing gear should operate as intended following exposure to icing conditions. Retraction or extension of the landing gear should not cause an unsafe condition or pilot alert because of ice accretion.

8.6.5 Compliance Means: Stall Warning and Protection Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions. Ice can form on unprotected stall warning and AOA sensors. Therefore, the airframe type certificate applicant should evaluate the performance of these sensors during flight in icing conditions. You should ensure acceptable stall warning (aerodynamic or artificial) for ice accumulations on the aircraft. Also, you should provide the same type of stall warning in icing conditions as you provide in non-icing conditions, except the type of stall warning may differ during the brief period between the initial ice buildup and the time that the ice protection system becomes fully effective. You should ensure acceptable stall warning with ice buildups on aircraft surfaces, including the ice buildup occurring before the first activation of the IPS, the ice buildup occurring between the ice protection activation cycles (intercycle ice), the ice buildup remaining after one cycle of the IPS (before landing), and ice buildups on unprotected surfaces. You may need to change the schedules for activating the artificial stall warning, stall identification, and stall protection, if installed, for operations in icing conditions to provide acceptable stall warning margins and to prevent a stall during flight in icing conditions.

8.6.6 Compliance Means: Icing Conditions. You should ensure that ice detection cues used by the pilot to activate the IPS are acceptable at expected aircraft flight attitudes.

8.6.7 Compliance Means: Primary and Secondary Flight Control Surfaces Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions. Primary and secondary flight control surfaces should operate normally during and after flight into icing conditions. The airframe type certificate applicant should ensure that aerodynamic- and weight-balanced control surfaces are not subject to icing throughout the aircraft’s operating envelope (weight, center of gravity, and speed). Ensure that any ice buildup on these surfaces does not interfere with the surface actuation, including the operation of high-lift devices, such as slats and trailing edge flaps for safe landing go-around maneuvers.

8.6.8 Compliance Means: Ram Air Turbine Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions. The ram air turbine should remain operational during flight in icing conditions. You may not need to perform natural icing tests if the ram air turbine tested satisfactorily in an icing wind tunnel.

8.6.9 Compliance Means: Pilot Compartment View Performance of Intended Function in Icing Conditions. Note any obstruction of the pilot’s view because of ice buildup to support compliance with 14 CFR §§ 23.773, 25.773(b)(1)(ii), 27.773, and 29.773(b)(1)(ii).

9. AIRPLANE FLIGHT MANUAL (AFM). The AFM must provide the pilot with the information needed to operate the IPS. (See 14 CFR §§ 23.1525 and 23.1583(h), 25.1525 and 25.1583(e), 27.1525 and 27.1583(e), and 29.1525 and 29.1583(e), and 14 CFR §§ 23.1559(c), 27.1559, and 29.1559.)

9.1 AFM: Limitations.

a. You must state in the limitations section of the AFM the atmospheric environments in which the aircraft is approved to operate, including flight into icing conditions. (See 14 CFR §§ 23.1583(h), 25.1583(e), 27.1583(e), and 29.1583(e).)

b. The limitations section of the AFM should include, as applicable, a statement similar to the following: “In icing conditions, the airplane must be operated and its ice protection systems used as described in the operating procedures section of this manual. Where specific operational speeds and performance information have been established for such conditions, this information must be used.” Include in the limitations section of the AFM the following, as appropriate. (See 14 CFR §§ 23.1583(e), 25.1583(a), 27.1581(a)(2), and 29.1581(a)(2).)

(1) The minimum operating airspeed for each normal aircraft configuration whenever ice

exists on the critical surfaces.

(2) Instructions to activate the engine anti-ice system when the aircraft encounters

Instrument Meteorological Conditions (IMC) at an altitude near or above the freezing level.

(3) Landing weight limits that include the effects on aircraft performance when the IPS is

activated. You should consider the effects of residual ice on the aircraft lift and drag, thrust loss associated with operation of the IPS, and the airplane performance at the recommended operating speeds. You may present these weight limits in the performance information section of the AFM and include them as aircraft limits by specific reference in the AFM’s FAA-approved limitations section.

(4) Limits on operating time for ice protection equipment, if these limitations are based

on fluid anti-ice/deice systems capacities and flow rates.

(5) Airspeed limits (if any) and the minimum temperature at which the deicing boots may

be operated.

(6) Environmental limits for operating deicer boots, such as minimum temperature and

maximum altitude for boot operation.

(7) Minimum engine rpm or power setting necessary for the airframe IPS to function

properly.

(8) A list of required placards.

(9) Severe icing warnings. (See AC 23.1419-2C and AC 25.1419-1A.)

9.2 AFM: Operating Procedures.

a. The AFM operating procedures for flight in icing conditions should include instructions for normal operation of the airplane, including operation of the aircraft when the IPS fails. In the AFM, you must also include procedures for managing other airplane system failures that will affect the IPS of the airplane in icing conditions.

(1) You must provide the pilot with recommended procedures that are unique to your aircraft for safe flight. (See 14 CFR §§ 23.1585(a), 25.1585(a), 27.1585(b), and 29.1585(a).) These procedures should include any necessary preflight action that minimizes the potential for enroute emergencies associated with the IPS. You should describe the system components with enough clarity and depth so the pilot can understand the component’s function. Unless flight crew actions are accepted as normal airmanship, such as maintaining situational awareness, you should include the appropriate procedures in the FAA-approved AFM or AFM supplement. These procedures should include proper pilot response to cockpit warnings, a way to diagnose system failures, and how to use system(s) safely.

b. Normal operating procedures.

(1) Normal operating procedures in the AFM should reflect the procedures used to certificate the airplane for flight in icing. This includes configurations, speeds, ice protection system operation, and power plant and systems operation. You should provide this information for all phases of flight, including takeoff, climb, cruise, descent, holding, go-around, and landing.

(2) You should provide procedures to optimize aircraft operation during flight in icing conditions. You should provide these procedures for flight phases in which icing conditions are commonly encountered, including climb, holding, and approach, and ETOPS diversions. The AFM should define when the flight crew must activate the ice protection equipment.

(3) For fluid IPSs, provide information and method(s) for determining the remaining flight operation time.

c. Abnormal and emergency procedures.

(1) The AFM must contain an emergency or abnormal operating procedures section describing flight crew actions if annunciated IPS failures and suspected unannunciated failures occur. Also, include any changes to other AFM abnormal procedures resulting from flight in icing conditions.

(2) For aircraft that cannot supply enough electrical power for all systems with an electrical system failure or engine failure, give the pilot load-shedding instructions.

9.3 AFM: Performance Information. You must provide performance information in the AFM for all flight phases affected by flight into icing conditions (14 CFR parts 23 Subpart B, 25 Subpart B, 27 Subpart B, and 29 Subpart B). Provide information to allow the flight crew to determine climb-limited aircraft weight, altitude, and temperature (WAT) limits in icing conditions. These data should include the effects of drag resulting from ice buildups (including ice buildups on unprotected surfaces and intercycle ice on protected surfaces), the power extraction associated with IPS operation, and any changes in operating speeds due to icing. Show the effect on landing distance due to the increased landing speeds and for all landing configurations when landing in icing conditions.

9.4 AFM: Airworthiness Directives for Severe Icing Conditions.

a. In October 1994, an accident occurred involving a transport category airplane operating in severe icing conditions. The accident airplane’s loss of control profile was replicated by ice shapes developed during extensive flight testing in simulated large-drop icing conditions. The simulated cloud water drop diameters were consistent with freezing drizzle. This condition created a ridge of ice aft of the wing’s upper surface deicing boots and forward of the ailerons, resulting in an uncommanded motion of the ailerons, control force anomalies, and the rapid roll of the aircraft.

b. Following this accident, the FAA determined flight crews are not provided the information necessary to determine when they are likely to experience icing conditions for which the airplane is not certificated. As a result of these findings, the FAA determined that flight crews must be provided the information on current weather conditions, and be made aware of specific visual cues that may indicate when their airplane is operating in atmospheric conditions outside the 14 CFR part 25, Appendix C icing envelopes.

c. The FAA issued a series of airworthiness directives (AD) for airplanes equipped with pneumatic deicing boots and non-powered roll control systems in April 1996 and February 1998.

The ADs required revising the AFM to provide the flight crew with recognition cues and procedures for exiting from severe icing conditions, and to limit or prohibit the use of trailing edge flaps and the autopilot.

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 505 passages shown