Radar Vectors
Advisory Circular Current Issued Feb 23, 2004 ACE-100 199 pages Copy saved Nov 18, 2026

AC 23-16A Powerplant Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes and Airships

This advisory circular (AC) provides information and guidance about acceptable means, but not the only means of compliance with Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 23, subpart E, applicable to the powerplant installation in normal, utility, acrobatic, and commuter category airplanes. This AC consolidates existing policy documents, and certain AC’s that cover specific paragraphs of the regulations, into a single document. Material in this AC is neither mandatory nor regulatory in nature and does not constitute a regulation. The guidance in this AC has been reviewed for suitability as an acceptable means, but not the only means, of compliance with the Airship Design Criteria (ADC), document FAA-P-8110-2. This document notes when guidance is considered applicable to the ADC requirements and cross-references the applicable ADC paragraph with the 14 CFR part 23, subpart E paragraph. Applicability of this guidance to airship projects that do not use the ADC, or that are not noted as applicable, must be determined by the certifying office. Wherever there is no written policy or guidance material applicable to a specific paragraph, the phrase, “No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002,” is used. AC’s and policy memos approved after this date may be included as reference material only.

Official source ↗ Open PDF

AC No.: 23-16A

Subject: W POWERPLANT GUIDE FOR

CERTIFICATION OF PART 23 AIRPLANES AND AIRSHIPS

Date: 2/23/04 Initiated By: ACE-100

AC No.: 23-16A Change:

1. WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF THIS ADVISORY CIRCULAR?

a. This advisory circular (AC) provides information and guidance about acceptable means, but

not the only means of compliance with Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 23, subpart E, applicable to the powerplant installation in normal, utility, acrobatic, and commuter category airplanes. This AC consolidates existing policy documents, and certain AC’s that cover specific paragraphs of the regulations, into a single document. Material in this AC is neither mandatory nor regulatory in nature and does not constitute a regulation.

b. The guidance in this AC has been reviewed for suitability as an acceptable means, but not the

only means, of compliance with the Airship Design Criteria (ADC), document FAA-P-8110- 2. This document notes when guidance is considered applicable to the ADC requirements and cross-references the applicable ADC paragraph with the 14 CFR part 23, subpart E paragraph. Applicability of this guidance to airship projects that do not use the ADC, or that are not noted as applicable, must be determined by the certifying office. c. Wherever there is no written policy or guidance material applicable to a specific paragraph,

the phrase, “No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002,” is used. AC’s and policy memos approved after this date may be included as reference material only. 2. WHAT IS INCORPORATED IN THIS AC AND, THEREFORE, SUPERSEDED?

The following AC’s and policy statements have been incorporated into this revision in whole or in part and are superseded:

a. AC 23-16, Powerplant Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes, dated September 21,

1999.

b. Policy concerning Unusable Fuel Tests and Prolonged Sideslip Maneuvers (23.959), dated

November 17, 1999. c. PS-ACE111-2000-23.901(d)(2), Notice of Compliance with the Engine Ingestion

Requirements Applicable to Turbine Powered, 14 CFR Part 23, Normal, Utility, Acrobatic, and Commuter Category Airplanes, issued December 14, 2000, published in the Federal Register January 5, 2001. d. PS-ACE111-2001-23.1093(b), Compliance with Induction System Icing Protection for Part

23 Airplanes, issued October 23, 2001, published in the Federal Register November 7, 2001. e. PS-ACE111-2000-23.1155-01, In-Flight Operation of Propellers at Pitch Settings Below the

Flight Regime for 14 CFR Part 23/CAR 3 Airplanes, issued December 22, 2000, published in the Federal Register January 12, 2001.

f. Policy Guidance for Extrapolation of Propulsion Data for Showing Compliance with 14 CFR

Part 23, § 23.45(d) Thrust Lapse Rate and § 23.939 Powerplant Operability Requirements, dated December 1, 1998, applying to § 23.939 only. g. Policy on Fuel Tank Outlet Strainer (§ 23.977), dated April 9, 1996. h. Policy on Confirmation of Definition of Maximum Weight in § 23.1001, dated June 24, 1999. i. Policy on Certification of Small, Single-Engine Piston or Turbopropeller Airplanes used for

Special Purpose Agricultural Operations, dated December 1, 1997, pages 4 and 5, referring to §§ 23.954, 23.1043, 23.1093, 23.1141(e), and 23.1163(a)(1). 3. WHAT IS THE BACKGROUND FOR THIS AC AND WHAT TIME PERIOD DOES THIS AC COVER?

The AC is current through Amendment 23-55, effective February 22, 2002. Policy released before December 31, 2002 is included in this AC. This material spans nearly 38 years of Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) aviation history. 4. HOW SHOULD THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS AC BE APPLIED?

a. The guidance provided in this document is directed to airplane manufacturers, modifiers,

foreign regulatory authorities, and Federal Aviation Administration small airplane type certification engineers, and their designees. b. This material is neither mandatory nor regulatory in nature and does not constitute a

regulation. It describes acceptable means, but not the only means, for showing compliance with the applicable regulations. The Federal Aviation Administration will consider other methods of showing compliance that an applicant may elect to present. While these guidelines are not mandatory, they are drawn from extensive FAA and

ii

industry experience in determining compliance with the relevant regulations. If circumstances convince us that following this AC would not result in compliance with the applicable regulations, we will not be bound by the terms of this AC, and we may require more substantiation or design changes as a basis for finding compliance. c. This material does not change, create any, authorize changes in, or allow deviations from,

regulatory requirements. d. If the implementing office becomes aware of reasons that an applicant's proposal that

meets this guidance should not be approved, the office must coordinate its response with the office that issued the guidance. 5. HOW IS THE INFORMATION IN THIS ADVISORY CIRCULAR ORGANIZED AND ARRANGED?

This advisory circular (AC) is organized and arranged by section of 14 CFR part 23, subpart E, in a hierarchical format. This arrangement provides generally applicable information about each section under each major header and continues with information specific to each paragraph under a given section. The outline below shows the format and explains each portion of the information contained under each section heading. The advisory material is given in a question and answer format with each of the questions in bold text followed by the answer in plain text. Except for the section header and the CAR 3 Cross-reference, the other portions will only be shown as applicable. In general, this AC provides policy for the most recent amendment of a given section.

Section Header – Bold text banner that includes section number, section title, and current

amendment level

CAR 3 Cross-reference – The CAR 3 regulation the section was drawn from ADC Cross-reference – The Airship Design Criteria paragraph General Information – Advisory material that is generally applicable to the entire section Related Material – More sources of information generally applicable to the entire section

Paragraph – The number of the paragraph under the section

ADC Cross-reference – The Airship Design Criteria paragraph Paragraph Specific Information – Advisory material that is specific to the paragraph Related Material – More sources of information specific to the paragraph 6. WHAT OTHER REGULATIONS AND PUBLICATIONS ARE RELATED TO THIS AC?

a. Regulations: Part 23 through Amendment 23-55. While this AC specifically addresses only

those regulations in subpart E, the following additional regulations are commonly associated with the airplane powerplant and should be considered with the regulations in subpart E by the users identified in paragraph 4a above:

iii

Subpart B ⎯ Flight § 23.33 Propeller speed and pitch limits § 23.45 Performance § 23.55 Accelerate-stop distance § 23.75 Landing distance § 23.239 Spray characteristics

Subpart C ⎯ Structure § 23.307 Proof of structure § 23.361 Engine torque § 23.363 Side load on engine mount

Subpart D — Design and Construction § 23.611 Accessibility provisions § 23.771 Pilot compartment § 23.777 Cockpit controls § 23.779 Motion and effect of cockpit controls § 23.781 Cockpit control knob shape § 23.859 Combustion heater fire protection § 23.863 Flammable fluid fire protection § 23.865 Fire protection of flight controls, engine mounts, and other flight structure § 23.867 Electrical bonding and protection against lightning and static electricity

Subpart F ⎯ Equipment

§ 23.1305 Powerplant instruments § 23.1309 Equipment, systems, and installations § 23.1311 Electronic display instrument systems § 23.1321 Arrangement and visibility § 23.1322 Warning, caution, and advisory lights § 23.1337 Powerplant instruments installation § 23.1419 Ice protection § 23.1431 Electronic equipment § 23.1435 Hydraulic systems § 23.1437 Accessories for multiengine airplanes § 23.1461 Equipment containing high energy rotors

Subpart G ⎯ Operating Limitations and Information

§ 23.1501 General § 23.1521 Powerplant limitations

iv

§ 23.1522 Auxiliary power unit limitations § 23.1527 Maximum operating altitude § 23.1529 Instructions for Continued Airworthiness § 23.1541 General § 23.1543 Instrument markings: General § 23.1549 Powerplant and auxiliary power unit instruments § 23.1551 Oil quantity indicator § 23.1553 Fuel quantity indicator § 23.1555 Control markings § 23.1557 Miscellaneous markings and placards § 23.1581 General § 23.1583 Operating limitations § 23.1585 Operating procedures

b. Joint Aviation Requirements (JAR): The rules of the JAR part 23 have been harmonized

with those in Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) part 23 to the extent the powerplant installation requirements are essentially the same. The numbering scheme is the same between JAR and 14 CFR part 23 so they are easily cross-referenced. With the coming of the European Aviation Safety Authority (EASA), the rules will be embodied as Certification Specifications (CS), which, in the beginning, are created directly from the JARs with the same numbering scheme. c. FAA Orders, Advisory Circulars, and Technical Standard Orders: Copies of the current

FAA Orders and Advisory Circulars listed below can be obtained at no charge from:

U.S. Department of Transportation, Subsequent Distribution Office DOT Warehouse, SVC-121.23 Ardmore East Business Center, 3341Q 75th Avenue Landover, MD 20785 Telephone 301-322-4779 or by faxing your request to 301-386-5394 These documents are available for viewing via the Internet by following the aircraft certification links from the FAA homepage (www.faa.gov).

FAA Order 8100.5A Aircraft Certification Service Mission, Responsibilities, Relationships, and Programs

FAA Order 8110.4B Type Certification

AC 20-29B Use of Aircraft Fuel Anti-icing Additives

AC 20-32B Carbon Monoxide (CO) Contamination in Aircraft⎯Detection and Prevention

v

AC 20-43C Aircraft Fuel Control

AC 20-53A Protection of Aircraft Fuel Systems Against Fuel Vapor Ignition Due to Lightning

AC 20-66A Vibration and Fatigue Evaluation of Airplane Propellers

AC 20-73 Aircraft Ice Protection

AC 20-88A Guidelines on the Marking of Aircraft Powerplant Instruments (Displays)

AC 20-100 General Guidelines for Measuring Fire-Extinguishing Agent Concentrations in Powerplant Compartments

AC 20-107A Composite Aircraft Structure

AC 20-116 Marking Aircraft Fuel Filler Openings with Color Coded Decals

AC 20-119 Fuel Drain Valves

AC 20-122A Anti-misfueling Devices: Their Availability and Use

AC 20-124 Water Ingestion Testing for Turbine Powered Airplanes

AC 20-128A Design Considerations for Minimizing Hazards Caused by Uncontained Turbine Engine and Auxiliary Power Unit Rotor Failure

AC 20-135 Powerplant Installation and Propulsion System Component Fire Protection Test Methods, Standards, and Criteria

AC 20-136 Protection of Aircraft Electrical/Electronic Systems Against the Indirect Effects of Lightning

AC 20-144 Recommended Method for FAA approval of Aircraft Fire Extinguishing System Components AC 20-18A Qualification Testing of Turbojet Engine Thrust Reversers

AC 21-37 Primary Category Aircraft

AC 21.17-3 Type Certification of Very Light Airplanes Under FAR 21.17(b)

vi

AC 23-2 Flammability Tests

AC 23-10 Auxiliary Fuel Systems for Reciprocating and Turbine Powered Part 23 Airplanes

AC 23-11A 14 CFR Part 23 Type Certification of an Airplane Originally Certificated to Joint Aviation Regulations – Very Light Airplane (JAR-VLA) Standards

AC 23-14 Type Certification Basis for Conversion from Reciprocating Engine to Turbine Engine-Powered Part 23 Airplanes

AC 23-15 Small Airplane Certification Compliance Program

AC 23.1309-1C Equipment, Systems, and Installations in Part 23 Airplanes

AC 23.1311-1A Installation of Electronic Displays in Part 23 Airplanes

AC 23.1419-2B Certification of Part 23 Airplanes for Flight in Icing Conditions

AC 23.1521-1B Type Certification of Automobile Gasoline in Part 23 Airplanes with Reciprocating Engines

AC 23.1521-2 with Type Certification of Oxygenates and Oxygenated Gasoline Change 1 Fuels in Part 23 Airplanes with Reciprocating Engines

AC 25.939-1 Evaluating Turbine Engine Operating Characteristics

AC 33-2B Aircraft Engine Type Certification Handbook

AC 33.28-1 Compliance Criteria for 14 CFR § 33.28 Aircraft Engines, Electrical and Electronic Engine Control Systems

AC 33.28-2 Guidance Material for 14 CFR § 33.28, Reciprocating Engine, Electrical and Electronic Engine Control Systems AC 33.47-1 Detonation Testing in Reciprocating Aircraft Engines

AC 33.74/92-1A Turbine Engine Continued Rotation and Rotor Locking

AC 35.37-1A Composite Propeller Blade Fatigue Substantiation TSO-C80 Flexible Fuel and Oil Cell Material

Copies of the current Advisory Circulars listed below may be purchased from:

vii

Superintendent of Documents P. O. Box 371954 Pittsburgh, PA 15250–7954 These documents are also available for viewing via the Internet by following the aircraft certification links from the FAA homepage (www.faa.gov).

AC 23-8B Flight Test Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes AC 23-17A Systems and Equipment Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes

d. Policy Memoranda: Copies of the current Policy Memoranda listed below can be

obtained at no charge from the Small Airplane Directorate Regulations and Policy Branch, 901 Locust St., Room 301, Kansas City, MO 64106. These documents are available for viewing via the Internet by following the aircraft certification links from the FAA homepage (www.faa.gov).

PS-ACE100-2002-004, Diesel Engine Installation

PS-ACE100-2002-008, Propeller Testing Vd Versus VNE

e. Other Publications:

Copies of the Design Standards for Advanced Ultra-light Aeroplanes (DS10141) may be purchased from: L.A.M.A.C. ~ Light Aircraft Manufacturers Association of Canada 880 St-Fereol Les Cèdres, Québec Canada J7T 1N3

Tel.: (450) 452-4772 or 1-888-977-1447 Fax: (450) 452-2694

A copy of Airship Design Criteria (FAA-P-8110-2) is available for viewing via the Internet by following the aircraft certification links to airships from the FAA homepage (www.faa.gov).

Copies of the following Society of Automotive Engineers documents are available for purchase via the Internet by following the store link on the SAE homepage (www.sae.org). SAE ARP 5904, Airborne Icing Tankers

SAE ARP 5905, Calibration and Acceptance of Icing Wind Tunnels

viii

Cabin Pressurization Systems › The collection of components used to pressurize air for airf

7. WHAT ARE THE DEFINITIONS FOR THE COMMON TERMS USED IN THIS ADVISORY CIRCULAR?

This advisory circular uses the definitions listed below. Some of these terms are used throughout, and will only be defined here. Sometimes, the term definitions may be repeated in the relevant document section as an aid to the reader. More definitions and abbreviations are included in 14 CFR part 1, §§ 1.1 and 1.2, respectively. Aircraft Flight Manual (AFM)

The documentation detailing the operating limitations and instructions for an aircraft. Airship Design Criteria (ADC)

The design criteria for airships in document number FAA-P-8110-2. American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM) International

The ASTM is an international body of producers, consumers, and regulators that develops, maintains, and administers material standards. Auxiliary Power Unit (APU)

A device, separate from the aircraft propulsion system, that produces power (i.e., electrical, pneumatic, hydraulic) for aircraft systems. Cabin Pressurization Systems

The collection of components used to pressurize air for airframe services. These systems can have air supplied by any number of means (including turbochargers, engine bleed air, and ram air). Certificate Management Aircraft Certification Office (CMACO)

The CMACO is the office responsible for aircraft certification. The term is usually shortened to ACO. These offices are located throughout the United States and are each responsible for projects in different States. A listing of these offices can be found by following the certification and design approvals links from the FAA homepage (www.faa.gov). Civil Air Regulations (CAR)

The body of rules governing aviation before being recodified by final rule on September 28, 1964.

ix

Cabin Pressurization Systems › A device installed in the engine air induction system that l

CAR 3

Part 3 of the Civil Air Regulations as amended through March 25, 1964. Electronic Engine Control (EEC)

An EEC engine functions electronically in either a supervisory (electronic adjustments to manual inputs) or full authority capacity (see FADEC definition below). Full Authority Digital Engine Control (FADEC)

A FADEC contains all the engine control functions and exercises full control over engine operations within the pilot selected operating parameters. High Intensity Radiation Fields (HIRF)

HIRF is electromagnetic fields that emanate from electrical components and occur in nature that can induce current flows in aircraft systems. Instructions for Continued Airworthiness (ICA)

The documentation detailing “how to” maintain the aircraft, engine, or propeller. Intercooler

A device installed in the engine air induction system that lowers the intake air charge temperature. The intercooler can be approved either as part of the engine or the engine installation.

Maximum Continuous Power (MCP)

MCP is the maximum power setting the engine is certified to sustain. Normal Ground Attitude

“Normal ground attitude” is defined as “the aircraft ground attitude that would normally be expected in service.” Therefore, consideration of nose wheel strut, main gear strut, variation of all landing gear tires, and the apron gradient is necessary. Use a minimum ground slope of 1 percent. An appropriate slope for seaplanes/amphibian airplanes would have to be determined from the worst-case static in-water attitude of the aircraft at the most adverse center of gravity location(s). Reid Vapor Pressure (RVP)

The RVP is a measure of the tendency of a liquid to form vapor.

x

AC No.: 23-16A › Unusable fuel

RPM

Revolutions per minute Supercharger

A mechanically driven compressor used to provide and maintain a manifold pressure greater than sea level pressure to a critical altitude. Type Certificate Data Sheet (TCDS)

The TCDS is attached to the Type Certificate and contains information about the certification basis, design and operating parameters, and limitations for the product. Turbocharger

Any engine exhaust gas-driven compressor that is a component of a Turbonormalized Engine, Turbosupercharged Engine, or Cabin Pressurization System. Turbonormalized Engine

Turbocharger used to maintain sea level manifold pressure to a critical altitude.

Turbopropeller

A propeller driven by a turbine engine. Turbosupercharger

A turbocharger used to provide and maintain a manifold pressure greater than sea level pressure to a critical altitude. This term has been used interchangeably with the term turbocharger. Turbosupercharged Engine

Turbocharger used to provide and maintain a manifold pressure greater than sea level pressure to a critical altitude. Unusable fuel

The largest total quantity of fuel remaining in the fuel system when the first evidence of engine malfunction occurs because of fuel interruption. Engine malfunction normally occurs under the most adverse fuel feed conditions. Each intended operation and flight maneuver should be checked for each fuel tank.

xi

VD

Aircraft design diving speed. VFE

The maximum airplane flap extended speed.

VNE

Aircraft never-exceed speed VSO

The airplane stalling speed or the minimum steady flight speed in the landing configuration. VY

Aircraft best rate-of-climb speed James E. Jackson Acting Manager, Small Airplane Directorate Aircraft Certification Service

xii

CONTENTS

Subpart E⎯Powerplant

GENERAL Section PAGE 23.901 Installation … 1 23.903 Engines … 10 23.904 Automatic power reserve system … 17 23.905 Propellers … 18 23.907 Propeller vibration … 23 23.909 Turbocharger systems … 25 23.925 Propeller clearance … 35 23.929 Engine installation ice protection … 37 23.933 Reversing systems … 39 23.934 Turbojet and turbofan engine thrust reverser systems tests … 41 23.937 Turbopropeller-drag limiting systems … 42 23.939 Powerplant operating characteristics … 43 23.943 Negative acceleration … 45

FUEL SYSTEM 23.951 General … 46 23.953 Fuel system independence … 49 23.954 Fuel system lightning protection … 50 23.955 Fuel flow … 51 23.957 Flow between interconnected tanks … 63 23.959 Unusable fuel supply … 64 23.961 Fuel system hot weather operation … 71 23.963 Fuel tanks: General … 77 23.965 Fuel tank tests … 78 23.967 Fuel tank installation … 80 23.969 Fuel tank expansion space … 82 23.971 Fuel tank sump … 83 23.973 Fuel tank filler connection … 85 23.975 Fuel tank vents and carburetor vapor vents … 87 23.977 Fuel tank outlet … 89 23.979 Pressure fueling systems … 90

xiii

FUEL SYSTEM COMPONENTS 23.991 Fuel pumps … 91 23.993 Fuel system lines and fittings … 93 23.994 Fuel system components … 95 23.995 Fuel valves and controls … 97 23.997 Fuel strainer or filter … 99 23.999 Fuel system drains … 101 23.1001 Fuel jettisoning system … 102

OIL SYSTEM 23.1011 General … 104 23.1013 Oil tanks … 108 23.1015 Oil tank tests … 110 23.1017 Oil lines and fittings … 111 23.1019 Oil strainer or filter … 112 23.1021 Oil system drains … 113 23.1023 Oil radiators … 114 23.1027 Propeller feathering system … 115

COOLING 23.1041 General … 116 23.1043 Cooling tests … 117 23.1045 Cooling test procedures for turbine engine powered airplanes … 119 23.1047 Cooling test procedures for reciprocating engine powered airplanes … 120

LIQUID COOLING 23.1061 Installation … 121 23.1063 Coolant tank tests … 122

INDUCTION SYSTEM 23.1091 Air induction system … 123 23.1093 Induction system icing protection … 124 23.1095 Carburetor deicing fluid flow rate … 135 23.1097 Carburetor deicing fluid system capacity … 136 23.1099 Carburetor deicing fluid system detail design … 137 23.1101 Induction air preheater design … 138 23.1103 Induction system ducts … 139 23.1105 Induction system screens … 140

xiv

23.1107 Induction system filters … 141 23.1109 Turbocharger bleed air system … 142 23.1111 Turbine engine bleed air system … 143

EXHAUST SYSTEM 23.1121 General … 144 23.1123 Exhaust system … 147 23.1125 Exhaust heat exchangers … 149

POWERPLANT CONTROLS AND ACCESSORIES 23.1141 Powerplant controls: General … 150 23.1142 Auxiliary power unit controls … 152 23.1143 Engine controls … 153 23.1145 Ignition switches … 156 23.1147 Mixture controls … 157 23.1149 Propeller speed and pitch controls … 158 23.1153 Propeller feathering controls … 159 23.1155 Turbine engine reverse thrust and propeller pitch settings below the flight regime … 160 23.1157 Carburetor air temperature controls … 162 23.1163 Powerplant accessories … 163 23.1165 Engine ignition systems … 165

POWERPLANT FIRE PROTECTION 23.1181 Designated fire zones; regions included … 167 23.1182 Nacelle areas behind firewalls … 169 23.1183 Lines, fittings, and components … 170 23.1189 Shutoff means … 172 23.1191 Firewalls … 174 23.1192 Engine accessory compartment diaphragm … 176 23.1193 Cowling and nacelle … 177 23.1195 Fire extinguishing systems … 179 23.1197 Fire extinguishing agents … 182 23.1199 Extinguishing agent containers … 183 23.1201 Fire extinguishing systems materials … 184 23.1203 Fire detector system … 185

xv

THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK

xvi

POWERPLANT GUIDE FOR CERTIFICATION OF PART 23 AIRPLANES

Subpart E⎯Powerplant

GENERAL 23.901 Installation (Amendment 23-53)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: 3.411

ADC Cross-reference: 5.1 What guidance is there for the certification of powerplant electronic systems installations?

Electronic systems are increasingly used to control different airplane systems including powerplant systems. During certification of these installations, § 23.1309 must be used to determine the potential failure modes and the resulting severity of a failure event. A safety analysis is generated during the engine certification that covers engine and engineairplane interfaces. This engine level safety analysis should be used as input to the airplane level safety analysis. Software level requirements for the installed engine should be determined early in the process to ensure the software level certificated for the engine, according to part 33, is compatible with the installation. The engine manufacturer and the Airplane Certification Office should be coordinated with early in the project. According to § 11.19, special conditions, may be required for powerplant systems installations to comply with the requirements of § 23.1309. These special conditions should not require retesting of the engine or its certificated components except as part of the airplane.

What may be required by special conditions?

Examples of special condition requirements may include, but are not limited to, the following:

1. Lightning test; 2. High Intensity Radiated Fields (HIRF) testing; 3. Software level validation testing; and 4. Environmental testing.

What are some examples of powerplant electronic systems?

Examples of powerplant electronic systems may include, but are not limited to, the following:

1. Electronic Engine Controls (EEC); 2. Full Authority Digital Engine Controls (FADEC); 3. Electronic turbocharger wastegate controls; and 4. Electronic propeller speed, pitch, and feathering controls.

Related Material

AC 23.1309-1C, Equipment, Systems, and Installations in Part 23 Airplanes

AC 23.1311-1A, Installation of Electronic Displays in Part 23 Airplanes

AC 33.28-1, Compliance Criteria for 14 CFR § 33.28 Aircraft Engines, Electrical and Electronic Engine Control Systems

AC 33.28-2, Guidance Material for 14 CFR § 33.28, Reciprocating Engines, Electrical and Electronic Engine Control Systems Policy Memorandum ANE-2001-35.31-R0, Policy for Bird Strike, Lightning, and Centrifugal Load Testing for Composite Propeller Blades and Spinners Paragraph 23.901(a)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.1(a) What components should be included as part of the powerplant installation?

Examples of powerplant installation components may include, but are not limited to, the following:

1. Engines; 2. Propellers; 3. Gearboxes and engine driven accessories; 4. Nacelles and inlets; 5. Engine oil systems;

6. Fuel tanks, lines, manifolds, and controls; 7. Ignition system components; 8. Propulsion control and monitoring devices; 9. Exhaust nozzles, mufflers, plenums, etc.; 10. Fluid collectors and drain lines; 11. Pneumatic bleed valves and ducting; 12. Engine fire protection systems; 13. Engine and propeller icing protection systems; and 14. Thrust attenuating or reversing installations

Components that are part of an engine or propeller type design certificated under parts 33 or 35, respectively, are considered part of the powerplant installation. Any findings of compliance with part 23 requirements should take maximum advantage of the relevant findings made in support of part 33 or 35. What regulations should be considered for powerplant installations using technologies other than the typical spark ignition reciprocating and turbine engines?

In the future, designs using engines other than the typical spark ignition reciprocating and turbine engine cycles, such as fuel cell/electric motor, diesel cycle, or even rocket or jet assisted take-off, may be proposed. These designs will require careful selection of the applicable powerplant rules and may require special conditions depending on how similar they are to the typical engines. Related Material

PS-ACE100-2002-004, Diesel Engine Installation Paragraph 23.901(b)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.1(b) What are examples of potential inspection and maintenance items?

Examples of potential powerplant inspection and maintenance items may include, but are not limited to, the following:

1. Oil reservoir fill and quantity sight glasses; 2. Engine control linkages; 3. Oil, fuel, air filters; 4. Oil system chip detectors; 5. Engine mount inspections; 6. Engine exhaust system components; and 7. Firewalls.

What are the typical methods for showing compliance?

Compliance is typically shown using the following methods either alone or in combination:

1. Review of drawings, schematics, system descriptions, and safety analyses; 2. Mock-up inspections and demonstrations; 3. Laboratory and aircraft testing; 4. Comparison with the service experience on similar designs; and 5. Comparison with accepted design standards.

Related Material

AC 23-10, Auxiliary Fuel Systems for Reciprocating and Turbine Powered Part 23 Airplanes Paragraph 23.901(c)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.1(c) What are some of the considerations for complying with this rule?

To comply with this rule, the powerplant installation should be designed to provide access (cowling that is easily opened and closed) for the pilot to visually check the following:

1. Engine oil level;

2. Flammable fluid leaks; 3. If applicable, the exterior condition of the turbocharger and wastegate installation; 4. If applicable, tail pipe, multi-segmented V-band clamps, and firewalls; 5. Electrical wiring; 6. Fuel and oil lines and fittings; and, otherwise, make a cursory inspection of the engine installation; and 7. Other items as defined by the engine, propeller, or airplane manufacturer.

For more information refer to § 23.611, Accessibility provisions. Paragraph 23.901(d)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. What special considerations are there for turbine engine installations?

Paragraph 23.901(d) requires that carcass vibration and rain, hail, ice, and bird ingestion be considered for all turbine engine installations. This requirement ensures the installation does not degrade the certificated capability of the engine.

What considerations and methods of compliance are typical for the vibration requirements?

Compliance with rules concerning vibration usually involves instrumentation and testing. These tests may consist of a combination of bench vibration tests and full-scale airplane tests. Analysis can be used to support the placement of instrumentation and to identify the critical test conditions. Coordination with the engine manufacturer may be necessary to understand the engine vibration limits and to design the tests to show the installation vibration characteristics are within the engine certification limits throughout the airplane flight envelope.

What considerations and methods of compliance are typical for the ingestion requirements?

Compliance with the rain ingestion requirements of § 23.901(d)(2) is typically shown with design analysis that identifies areas of concern and tests for those areas of concern. Part 33 engine certification testing may be used for part 23 compliance if the engine certification testing addressed the areas of concern identified by the installation design analysis (for example, use of an installation representative test inlet system). Part 33

engine certification testing may also be used for part 23 compliance if specific conditions addressed in the rule were addressed during engine certification testing. For airplanes with a certification basis before Amendment 23-53, a test is typically required if the specific operating considerations contained in the part 23 rule were not addressed during engine certification.

When evaluating areas of concern with the installation, consider areas where water pooling with resulting ingestion or shed of localized “slugs” of water normally not addressed during engine certification might occur. Some examples are inlet system channels, indentations, and so forth. These are typical of turbopropeller or S-duct type inlets that have complex geometry that can allow water pooling. This consideration is usually not a concern with simple pitot style inlets typical of part 23 turbofan/jet engine installations. Part 23 turbine engine installations typically require testing since most of these are turbopropeller installations. However, if design analysis shows the installation will not affect the water ingestion characteristics and engine certification addressed the specific conditions addressed in the part 23 rule, this analysis combined with engine certification testing may be enough to demonstrate rain ingestion compliance. Because of the large diversity of turbine engine installations in part 23 airplanes, all installations should be evaluated to determine whether areas of concern exist. Since the rain ingestion requirements in part 33 were not added until Amendment 33-6, the airplane applicant needs to evaluate the engine's certification basis to determine whether the engine has been subjected to part 33 rain ingestion testing. If the engine does not have Amendment 33-6 or a later amendment as part of the certification basis, the engine must have a safe service history of rain ingestion in similar installations, under § 23.903(a)(2)(iv).

If it is determined that testing for rain ingestion should be performed, flight test is not required. The intent of the part 23 rule is to ensure the engine installation has not deteriorated the rain ingestion tolerance of the certificated engine. Since a ground static engine test normally demonstrates engine certification compliance, use of installation ground tests at the required power/thrust settings has been commonly accepted as a means of compliance. The applicant can use design analysis to determine critical configurations and conditions of the installation. This might reduce required installation tests to the critical configurations and conditions instead of repeating the entire part 33 test conditions. Engine certification should address the results of the critical point analysis for the engine; therefore, it is important for the engine installer to research the conditions and requirements used for engine certification.

What are some other examples of issues not addressed by engine certification that need to be addressed for installation compliance with § 23.901(d)?

Amendment 23-53 added requirements for ice, hail, and birds similar to those in part 33. Examples of installation issues normally not addressed by engine certification, but that should be addressed for installation compliance, include the following:

1. Ice build-up on areas where ice shed may be ingested by the engines (for example, ice shed from wings and airframe sources into aft mounted engines); and

2. Consideration of items such as inlet splitters, acoustic liners, and so forth, that may be damaged by impact with ice, hail, and birds. Paragraph 23.901(e)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.1(d) What instructions are typically provided under the engine and propeller type certificates?

Sections 33.5 and 35.3 list the requirements for engine and propeller installation instruction manuals. Examples of subjects typically provided under the engine and propeller type certificates may include, but are not limited to, the following:

1. Engine and propeller operating limitations;

2. Engine and propeller mounting provisions;

3. Allowable fuel and oil specifications;

4. Allowable fuel and oil temperatures;

5. Fuel inlet pressures;

6. Allowable accessory temperature limits;

7. Vibration limits;

8. Accessibility requirements;

9. Turbine engine inlet distortion limits; and

10. Abnormal engine failure load conditions such as turbine engine fan blade failure.

It is important to identify and accommodate all engine and propeller certification dependencies with the aircraft installation to ensure compatibility of the hardware and operational limitations.

Is it possible to certificate an airplane to use a fuel other than one certificated for use on the engine?

No, the fuel used in the airplane must be certificated for use in the engine as well as the airplane to comply with § 23.901(e). Other fuels such as automobile gasoline have been certificated for use in an airplane with a separate certification for using the fuel in the

engine. All applicable sections of 14 CFR part 33 and part 23 must be considered when certificating a fuel for use in an engine and in an airplane, respectively. Related Material

AC 23.1521-1B, Type Certification of Automobile Gasoline in Part 23 Airplanes with Reciprocating Engines AC 23.1521-2 with Change 1, Type Certification of Oxygenates and Oxygenated Gasoline Fuels in Part 23 Airplanes with Reciprocating Engines

AC 20-24B, Qualification of Fuels, Lubricants and Additives for Aircraft Engines AC 20-122A, Anti-misfueling Devices: Their Availability and Use Paragraph 23.901(f)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. What should be considered when determining the applicable parts of these regulations as applied to Auxiliary Power Units (APU)?

The typical Auxiliary Power Unit (APU) is a combustion cycle powerplant operated primarily to generate electrical, pneumatic, and hydraulic power for ground and limited flight operations and not thrust for flight. Each of the rules applicable to powerplant installations must be considered carefully relative to the design features and operating requirements for a given APU. Below are three examples.

1. APUs typically do not have propellers connected to them and, in such a case, it is obvious, the portions of this part that apply to propellers should not be considered for such an installation.

2. APUs generally have a much smaller operating envelope than do thrust producing powerplants and, as such, due consideration should be given to the requirements in areas such as induction system icing (§ 23.1093).

3. An APU that is used to provide emergency power to meet the requirements of § 23.1351 would be considered differently than an APU intended only for ground use.

What regulations should be considered for Auxiliary Power Units using technologies other than the typical combustion cycles?

In the future, designs using exotic technologies to produce auxiliary electrical, pneumatic, and hydraulic power, such as fuel cells, may be proposed. These designs will

require careful selection of the applicable powerplant rules and may require special conditions depending on how similar they are to the typical combustion cycle designs.

Related Material

AC 20-128A, Design Considerations for Minimizing Hazards Caused by Uncontained Turbine Engine and Auxiliary Power Unit Rotor Failure

23.903 Engines (Amendment 23-54)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: 3.415

ADC Cross-reference: 5.2 What guidance is available for replacing a reciprocating engine with a turbine engine?

Guidance for turbine engine airplane conversions is provided in AC 23-14, Type Certification Basis for Conversion from Reciprocating Engine to Turbine Engine- Powered Part 23 Airplanes. This AC highlights the differences between the two engine installations that must be accounted for including, but not limited to:

1. Fuel system compatibility with turbine fuel;

2. Fuel Gelling and icing;

3. Part 34 fuel and venting requirements for turbine engines; and

4. Inlet icing and falling and blowing snow requirements.

What guidance is available for certification of the installation of unique types of engines?

Typical airplane engines fall into two categories: spark ignition reciprocating and turbine engines. These types account for most airplanes in service today, but other types such as compression ignition reciprocating (diesel cycle) and sinusoidal cam spark ignition engines have been proposed. When certifying an airplane with engines that are different from the typical engines, the unique features of the new engines should be carefully considered relative to the rules of 14 CFR part 23. Special conditions may be necessary to account for these unique features. Suitable guidance material will be written as necessary to capture any certification experience and other considerations about these installations. For example, Policy Memo PS-ACE100-2002-004, Diesel Engine Installation, was released in May 2003 in response to current engine and airplane certification projects involving diesel engines.

Related Material

AC 23-14, Type Certification Basis for Conversion from Reciprocating Engine to Turbine Engine-Powered Part 23 Airplanes

PS-ACE100-2002-004, Diesel Engine Installation

Paragraph 23.903(a)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.2(a) Does an engine(s) require a type certificate if the airplane is to be certified under 14 CFR part 23?

Yes, the engine(s) must have an approved type certificate (according to 14 CFR part 33 or CAR Part 13) for normal, utility, acrobatic, and commuter category airplanes certificated under part 23. The airplane, with the engine(s) installed, must also comply with 14 CFR part 34, § 34.11.

Is it possible to certificate an airplane under 14 CFR part 23 with an engine(s) that does not have a type certificate?

No, it is not possible to certificate an airplane under 14 CFR part 23 with an engine(s) that does not have a type certificate under 14 CFR part 33. There are rules other than part 23 that do allow engines that are not certificated under part 33. Engines may be approved as part of the airplane for airplanes originally certificated in the Primary Category under 14 CFR part 21, § 21.17(b), or airplanes certificated under Joint Aviation Requirements―Very Light Airplane (JAR-VLA), or Sport Plane (Transport Canada Design Standard TP10141E).

Related Material

AC 21.17-3, Type Certification of Very Light Airplanes under § 21.17(b)

AC 21-37, Primary Category Aircraft

AC 23-11A, 14 CFR Part 23 Type Certification of an Airplane Originally Certificated to Joint Aviation Regulations – Very Light Airplane (JAR-VLA) Standards

Is it possible to affect the type certificate of the engine by its installation in an airplane?

This section requires compliance with the engine manufacturer’s installation drawing, installation manual, and engine specific operating instructions. Non-compliance with the engine manufacturer’s installation requirements can invalidate the type certification status of the engine, making the engine non-compliant with § 23.903(a)(1). This, in turn, would prevent certification of the airplane under part 23. Examples of engine requirements that could be affected by the airplane installation may include, but are not limited to, the following:

1. Fuel delivery flow and pressure requirements;

2. Allowable turbine engine inlet aerodynamic distortion; and

3. Compliance with 14 CFR part 34, Fuel Venting and Exhaust Requirements for Turbine Engine Powered Airplanes. Paragraph 23.903(b)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.2(b) What is the intent of this rule?

Airplanes with turbine engines should be designed to minimize the hazard to the airplane if a maximum energy rotor burst (typically the energy level associated with a one-third sector of the engine rotor at the critical rotating speed) occurs. Airplanes with turbine engines should also be designed to minimize the hazard to the airplane if any other uncontained turbine engine failure (i.e., fan blade), including engine case burn through, occurs. It is impossible to protect any design in an absolute sense, but good engineering judgment must be used to minimize the effects of these failures. This requires a design with features that protect structure, systems, and components from the adverse effects of heat, pressure, and loads associated with these failures. Minimizing the hazard has been interpreted through the years as allowing continued safe operation, with emergency procedures that allow for landing the airplane.

Airplanes using new technology materials or novel designs should be carefully evaluated for their ability to minimize the effects of engine rotor burst and case burn through. A Small Airplane Directorate policy letter dated April 7, 1989, defined the word “minimize” as used in § 23.903(b)(1) as “to reduce to a minimum, decrease to the least practical amount.” The “least practical amount” has to consider what is attainable with current technology and materials. In these cases, the standard has become the existing certificated airplanes. These airplanes used discrete source damage analysis to select the most effective and suitable design precautions and to substantiate that these precautions minimized the rotorburst hazard to the least practical amount. A typical design case minimizing the effects consists of a crown skin cut with a limit gust load that then is used as the ultimate load when analyzing the remaining structure. Advisory Circular 20-128A, in the Related Materials below, contains information on the discrete source damage analysis.

Information on engine case burn through is contained in the related material.

What compliance methods are generally acceptable?

At the most basic, a review of drawings, schematics, system descriptions, hazard assessments, and a rotor burst analysis with inspections of the installation are acceptable means of compliance. Design similarity and service experience can also be considered with the means above to comply with this rule provided a clear link to the similar airplane can be established. Advisory Circular 20-128A provides guidance on methods to mitigate the hazard to critical systems such as engine and airplane control cables and

wiring, flammable fluid tanks and lines, pneumatic ducts, and hydraulic lines if a rotor burst occurs. Related Material

AC 20-128A, Design Considerations for Minimizing Hazards Caused by Uncontained Turbine Engine and Auxiliary Power Unit Rotor Failure

AC 20-135, Powerplant Installation and Propulsion System Component Fire Protection Test Methods, Standards, and Criteria Paragraph 23.903(c)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.2(c) What do the words “…in at least one configuration…” mean?

The intent of this rule is to ensure that, during any one flight, any initial failure condition that could prevent the continued safe operation of one engine will not prevent the continued safe operation of the other engine(s). Compliance with this rule requires there should be no immediate crew intervention necessary for continued safe flight.

Related Material

AC 23.1419-2B, Certification of Part 23 Airplanes for Flight in Icing Conditions Paragraph 23.903(d)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.2(d) What concerns are there with starting and stopping a piston engine?

The intent of the rule relative to starting is to ensure the engine(s) can be started without creating a hazardous condition. Procedures and limitations must be established and documented in the Airplane Flight Manual and on proper airplane placards to cover all allowed conditions for starting engine. These conditions must include ground starts for all airplanes and in-flight restarts for multiengine airplanes.

The intent of the rule relative to stopping an engine is to ensure that any engine on a multiengine airplane can be stopped in flight if necessary to prevent a hazardous condition without creating an airplane hazard. According to § 23.901(d)(2), commuter category airplanes also require the stopping system components to be fire resistant. While the rule does not explicitly state any requirements for stopping an engine in normal conditions, such as ground shutdown at the end of operations, there should be no hazards associated with these conditions. Conditions that may require stopping an engine in flight include:

1. Engine compartment fires;

2. Turbocharger or exhaust system failures;

3. Engine or accessory failures resulting in excessive vibration; and

4. Propeller malfunction.

The design of the system should consider and minimize hazards during both starting and stopping, such as the following:

1. The collection of flammable liquids and vapors;

2. Any adverse affects on engine accessories from reduced rotation, starting and stopping;

3. Vibrations that adversely affect the structural integrity of the engine, its components, or aircraft structures; and

4. Any conditions that would prevent safely restarting the engine. Paragraph 23.903(e)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.2(e) What concerns are there with starting and stopping a turbine engine?

The intent of the rule relative to starting is to ensure the engine(s) can be started without creating a hazardous condition. Procedures and limitations must be established and documented in the Airplane Flight Manual and proper airplane placards to cover all allowed conditions for starting the engine. These conditions include ground starts as well as in-flight restarts. Provisions and procedures for in-flight restarts must be established and documented in the Airplane Flight Manual.

The intent of the rule relative to stopping an engine is to ensure that any engine on an airplane can be stopped in flight if necessary to prevent a hazardous condition without creating an airplane hazard. Conditions that may require stopping an engine in flight include:

1. Engine compartment fires;

2. Engine rotorburst; and

3. Engine or accessory failures resulting in excessive vibration.

The design of the system should consider and minimize hazards during both starting and stopping, such as the following:

1. The collection of flammable liquids and vapors;

2. Any adverse affects on engine accessories from windmilling;

3. Vibrations that adversely affect the structural integrity of the engine, its components, or aircraft structures; and

4. Any conditions that would prevent safely restarting the engine.

Related Material

AC 23-2, Flammability Tests

AC 33.74/92-1A, Turbine Engine Continued Rotation and Rotor Locking Paragraph 23.903(f)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.2(f) What differences are there between reciprocating and turbine engines when showing compliance with this rule?

The requirement to define the in-flight restart envelope applies to all normal, utility, acrobatic, and commuter category airplanes. A full complement of tests to define the inflight restart envelope may not be necessary. For example, normally aspirated reciprocating engine in-flight restart procedures typically only specify the airspeed to restart the engine. In this case, the “restart envelope” is the entire flight envelope for the selected airspeed. On the other hand, defining a turbine engine restart envelope typically requires data from a comprehensive altitude/airspeed envelope test program. Review the engine installation manual to understand the engine limitations relative to the starting envelope. We recommend you coordinate with the engine manufacturer to determine the start testing performed during the certification of the engine.

1. Airplanes powered by reciprocating engines.

The amount of in-flight restart envelope testing is dependent on the particular design features of the engine installation. Comprehensive in-flight restart envelope testing is not usually necessary for single-engine airplanes powered by conventional reciprocating engines. The service experience of these airplanes with typical reciprocating engine installations is that a reliable in-flight engine restart can be made, provided the airplane is equipped with an adequate engine starting system. Thus, in-flight restart envelope testing has not been necessary provided a mechanically sound engine can be restarted under typical power-off flight conditions.

However, if the engine installation contains new or non-conventional design features, more extensive in-flight restart envelope testing may be necessary. This is particularly the case when the flight conditions impact the ability to restart the engine in flight. For example, consider the effects of new or unusual engine designs or operating cycles, propeller feathering systems, engine control systems, fuels or fuel system arrangements, engine starting systems, etc. Any in-flight restart envelope limitations and/or starting procedures should be defined in the proper areas of the Airplane Flight Manual (AFM). This information is required for compliance with § 23.1585.

As with conventional designs, extensive in-flight restart envelope testing may not be required provided the applicant can substantiate this position on the new or nonconventional design features. Flight tests are generally the most appropriate means to develop this substantiating data.

2. Airplanes powered by turbine engines.

Turbine engine starting is sensitive to small differences in flight conditions, primarily pressure altitude, speed, temperature, and attitude. Therefore, it is necessary to test the engine restart envelope to ensure that turboprop or turbofan engines can be reliably restarted in flight. These flight conditions and the associated starting procedures (windmill, starter assisted, or otherwise) should be defined in the proper areas of the Airplane Flight Manual (AFM). This information is required for compliance with § 23.1585. Paragraph 23.903(g)

ADC Cross-reference: None

No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002.

Related Material

AC 23-8B, Flight Test Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes

23.904 Automatic power reserve system (Amendment 23-43)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: None

ADC Cross-reference: None

No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002.

23.905 Propellers (Amendment 23-43)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: 3.416

ADC Cross-reference: 5.3

Related Material:

AC 23-8B, Flight Test Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes

PS-ACE100-2002-008, Propeller Testing Vd Versus VNE Paragraph 23.905(a)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.3(a)(1)

What regulations cover propeller certification?

Propeller certification is covered under 14 CFR part 35. These rules set the minimum requirements for propellers in a manner similar to that for engines. Installation information from the propeller manufacturer is used to comply with § 23.901(e)(1).

Do the rules in 14 CFR part 35 cover propeller blades that are constructed of composite material?

The rules in 14 CFR part 35 were written to cover wooden and metal propeller blades, and do not, by themselves, address all issues unique to blades constructed of composite materials. The following airworthiness issues are typically addressed with special conditions, according to § 11.19, as part of the propeller certification under part 35.

1. Safety assessment 2. Centrifugal load tests 3. Fatigue limits and evaluation 4. Bird impact 5. Lightning strike Paragraph 23.905(b)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.3(a)(2)

What should be considered when determining compliance with this rule?

Evaluate the maximum propeller power and shaft rotational speed for each airplane installation throughout its normal operational envelope. The installed limits must be at or

below the certificated propeller and engine power and rotational speed limits (listed on the propeller and engine type certificate data sheets) that are typically based on static ground testing performed before flight test.

Engine power and propeller shaft rotational speed limits must not be exceeded during transient events.

14 CFR part 23, § 23.33, contains additional requirements pertaining to the installed propeller speed and pitch limits. Paragraph 23.905(c)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.3(a)(3)

No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002. Paragraph 23.905(d)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. How do I know if a propeller blade pitch control system has been approved for use with my propeller?

The propeller Type Certificate Data Sheet (TCDS) identifies operationally compatible components of the propeller blade pitch control system that may or may not be included in the propeller type design. If the propeller blade pitch control system components are included in the propeller type design (verify this with the propeller manufacturer or the FAA office controlling the propeller type design), the components have demonstrated compliance with 14 CFR part 35, § 35.42, Blade pitch control system component test.

How do I get approval for a propeller blade pitch control system if it has not been approved as part of the propeller type certificate?

The propeller manufacturer may not have tested components that are not included in the propeller type design according to § 35.42. For components that have not been previously tested, demonstrate compliance with § 35.42 either by testing or by similarity to prior approved components. Paragraph 23.905(e)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable.

Is an airplane required to comply with § 23.905(e) if it is not being certificated to fly in icing conditions?

Yes, compliance with § 23.905(e) for pusher propeller airframe icing protection is required for all normal, utility, acrobatic, and commuter category airplanes certificated under part 23 even if the airplane is not being certificated for flight in icing conditions (§ 23.1419 compliance). Service experience has shown that airplanes can inadvertently encounter icing conditions even if the airplane is not approved for flight into icing conditions. What type of icing encounter should be considered when showing compliance with § 23.905(e) if the airplane is not being certified to fly in icing conditions?

In the case where the airplane is not being certificated to fly in icing conditions, compliance with § 23.905(e) should be shown for an inadvertent encounter with icing conditions. Ice accumulations and shapes should be based on a typical inadvertent encounter of five minutes duration. The five minutes in the icing condition is broken down as follows: 1. 1 minute for detection of the icing condition. 2. 1 minute for the pilot to take actions necessary to exit the icing condition. 3. 1 minute to execute a 180-degree turn. 4. 2 minutes to exit the icing condition. Does the type certification of a propeller account for any foreign object damage requirements?

Propeller type certification does not include any type of foreign object damage requirements, unless accomplished with special conditions or special tests.

What foreign object damage concerns are unique for pusher propeller installations?

Most propeller installations are subject to ice being shed into them. The source of the ice for tractor propeller installations is the ice accumulated and shed from the propeller spinner. Typically, for tractor propellers, the amount of ice results in no significant propeller damage. Airplanes with pusher propellers that are very close to the fuselage and well back from the front of the airplane's nose can be subject to ice shed from the forward fuselage and from the wings. The ice from these areas may cause significant propeller damage.

Related Material:

AC 23.1419-2B, Certification of Part 23 Airplanes for Flight in Icing Conditions

Paragraph 23.905(f)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. Why are pusher propellers required to have visible markings and tractor propellers are not?

Visibility of the propeller disk is of concern during ground operations. Because ground personnel and boarding and deplaning passengers are accustomed to tractor propellers, there is a significantly higher probability of inadvertent contact with a turning pusher propeller. Increased visibility of tractor propellers could also enhance ground operations safety. However, any additional visual distractions in the pilot's normal viewing area could adversely affect collision avoidance. Paragraph 23.905(g)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. Do the requirements for propeller certification cover engine exhaust impingement?

Propeller type certification does not include any type of engine exhaust requirements, unless accomplished with special conditions or special tests.

What are the concerns for engine exhaust impingement on pusher propeller installations?

In most pusher propeller installations, the engine exhaust pass through the propeller disc. The affects of the exhaust temperatures and composition on the materials of the propeller are of major concern. Factors affecting the exhaust vary with the flight conditions and must be considered relative the propeller’s ability to withstand them. Paragraph 23.905(h)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. What other concerns are there for pusher propeller installations?

Similar to the concerns with ice in § 23.905(e), there is increased potential of foreign object damage because the propeller is aft of major portions of the airplane. Therefore,

the design of parts like those used to meet § 23.901(c) are required to ensure that they will not separate from the airplane such that they could contact the propeller.

23.907 Propeller vibration (Amendment 23-51)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: 3.417

ADC Cross-reference: 5.3

What should I consider when showing compliance with this rule?

For acceptable means of compliance, refer to AC 20-66A, Vibration and Fatigue Evaluation of Airplane Propellers.

The following applies to all propellers except conventional fixed-pitch wood propellers:

1. The most important part of approving a propeller installation is to demonstrate that the propeller steady and vibration stresses do not exceed the safe levels established by the propeller manufacturer. It is often beneficial to use approved propeller type design data (contact the propeller manufacturer) to approve a propeller for use on an aircraft.

2. Some propeller TC data sheets contain a section called Note 9. This note simplifies the vibration compliance for propellers under § 23.907 for normal category, single reciprocating engine airplanes in tractor configuration. The acceptable engine and propeller model combinations are listed in this note, and they can be used to determine compliance within the defined limitations. If the engine or airframe is modified such that the power of the stock engine model is increased during any phase of airplane operation, the potential exists to increase propeller stresses. Therefore, the Certificate Management Aircraft Certification Office (CMACO) should be contacted prior to using Note 9 as approval for § 23.907. Such modifications include, but are not limited to, the addition of a turbocharger, increased boost pressure, increased compression ratio, increased RPM, altered ignition timing, electronic ignition, full authority digital engine controls (FADEC), or tuned induction or exhaust.

3. Perform a flight-vibration stress survey. This test typically consists of placing instruments on the propeller hub, shanks, and blades with strain gauges and operating the airplane both on the ground and in flight to verify that the stress and vibration levels are within those certificated for the propeller.

Generally, reciprocating engines are the dominant contributor to any steady and vibration stress levels the propeller will experience in operation, but there are exceptions. For example, agricultural and acrobatic category airplane maneuvers may exceed the stress levels the engine produces during such operation. Additional testing may be needed to show compliance with § 23.907 for special use or unique

aircraft categories. Turbopropeller installations have stress levels that are generally driven by aerodynamic forces during ground and flight operations. The stress survey should identify any operational and maintenance limitations to note in either the airplane Instructions for Continued Airworthiness or the Airplane Flight Manual (AFM), or both. These limitations may also need to be incorporated into the propeller airworthiness limitations section. According to § 23.1549, operational limitations are to be made available to the crew by the use of appropriate placards and powerplant instrument markings (i.e., red and yellow arcs). 4. The vibratory stress levels in pusher propeller installations can be much higher than on tractor aircraft configurations. Any small change in the airplane configuration can influence the propeller stress levels, especially if the change is upstream and in the propeller inflow area. Engine exhaust locations and nozzle shapes can impact propeller-operating temperatures. Engine exhaust flows that impinge on the propeller blades can introduce potential corrosion issues and affect propeller blade life. Small changes to the propeller spinner shape and size can change the inboard propeller blade and hub operating temperatures. For these reasons, perform the vibration survey under the same caustic and high temperature environmental conditions identified in § 23.905(g).

5. The Airplane Instructions for Continued Airworthiness (ICA) should require regular calibration of the tachometer to ensure that the limits are not exceeded.

Related Material:

AC 20-88A, Guidelines on the Marking of Aircraft Powerplant Instruments (Displays)

AC 20-66A, Vibration and Fatigue Evaluation of Airplane Propellers

AC 35.37-1A, Guidance Material for Fatigue Limit Tests and Composite Blade Fatigue Substantiation Paragraph 23.907(a)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.3(b)

No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002. Paragraph 23.907(b)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.3(b)(4)

No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002.

Unusable fuel › Turbocharger System

23.909 Turbocharger systems (Amendment 23-43)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: None

ADC Cross-reference: 5.5

What paragraphs of § 23.909 apply to a turbocharger installation that is not certificated as part of the engine under part 33?

Apply § 23.909(a) through (e) to a turbocharger system (or portions of the system) that is not certificated as part of the engine under part 33.

What paragraphs of § 23.909 apply to a turbocharger installation that is certificated as part of the engine under part 33?

Apply § 23.909(b) through (e) to a turbocharger system (or portions of the system) that is certificated as part of the engine under part 33.

Related Material:

AC 23-8B, Flight Test Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes

AC 23.1521-2 with Change 1, Type Certification of Oxygenates and Oxygenated Gasoline Fuels in Part 23 Airplanes with Reciprocating Engines

AC 33-2B, Aircraft Engine Type Certification Handbook

AC 33.47-1, Detonation Testing in Reciprocating Aircraft Engines

What are the definitions of some of the common terms used relative to turbocharger systems?

Turbocharger System

Includes the following:

1. The turbocharger;

2. All components necessary to control the turbocharger and the associated engine/installation connections;

3. All ducting, heat exchangers, and other plumbing between the turbocharger to the engine intake and exhaust interface points;

Turbocharger System › Intercooler

4. All plumbing and control devices between the turbocharger and the aircraft; and

5. Mounting provisions for these components.

Turbocharger

Any engine exhaust gas-driven compressor that is a component of one or more of the following systems:

1. Turbonormalized Engine: Turbocharger used to maintain sea level manifold pressure to a critical altitude.

2. Turbosupercharged Engine: Turbocharger used to provide and maintain a manifold pressure greater than sea level pressure to a critical altitude.

3. Cabin Pressurization Systems: Turbocharger used to pressurize air for airframe services.

Intercooler

A device installed in the engine air induction system that lowers the intake air charge temperature. The intercooler can be approved either as part of the engine or the engine installation. Paragraph 23.909(a)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.5(a)

What engine affects should be considered when adding a turbocharger to a normally aspirated engine?

Adding a turbocharger to a normally aspirated engine will have the following affects on the engine.

1. A turbocharged engine will have different endurance and reliability characteristics than the non-turbocharged engine.

2. A turbocharged engine will have different overhaul characteristics and intervals than the non-turbocharged engine.

3. A turbocharged engine will have different detonation characteristics than the nonturbocharged engines. Detonation margin is affected by the following:

a. Induction air temperature and pressure;

b. Exhaust back pressure;

c. Ignition timing;

d. Fuel grade and flow;

e. Carburetor or injector metering characteristics;

f. Compression ratio;

g. Cooling; and

h. Exhaust gas temperature.

4. A turbocharger has high speed rotating components similar to a turbine engine. Consider the effects of low-cycle fatigue on turbocharger rotor integrity and durability. The installation should be designed to minimize the effects of an uncontained turbocharger rotor burst event.

5. Expect higher pressures and temperatures with a turbocharged engine induction system due to heat generated from adiabatic compression. An intercooler between the turbocharger and the engine will lower the induction air temperature.

6. Expect higher rates of oil consumption, contamination, and deterioration due to the more severe operating environment. These items may shorten oil change intervals.

7. Expect higher flow rates of hot exhaust gas with a turbocharged engine’s exhaust system, which will increase the temperature of the metal and raise internal pressure. Consequently, the durability of the exhaust system components is important. Increased or mandatory inspections of the exhaust system components may be necessary.

8. Both the engine and propeller vibration characteristics of the turbocharged engine installation might be altered by changes in horsepower and by changes in horsepower-to-altitude relations. Readdress the propeller vibration compatibility according to § 23.907 or determine if propeller recertification is necessary.

What are the typical means of compliance with § 23.909(a)?

Turbochargers certificated as part of the engine may use the findings of compliance from the engine certification.

Turbochargers that have not been certificated as part of the engine require analysis and testing. Endurance tests should be conducted to meet the reliability standards established by the 150-hour endurance test under § 33.49 for the engine and turbocharger combination. In addition, the engine and turbocharger combination should be tested to determine the effects on the service life of the engine and engine components as required

by § 33.7. Any component of the engine and turbocharger installation not substantiated by endurance testing as capable of operating in all normally anticipated flight and atmospheric conditions should be subjected to additional tests or investigations to substantiate this capability as required by § 33.53.

Affects of low-cycle fatigue on turbocharger rotor integrity and durability: A rotor without prior service history should be subjected to a 1,000-cycle start-stop test under the most adverse operating conditions to provide a basis for establishing initial service life.

The applicant should provide instructions for the installation, operation, service, maintenance, repair, and overhaul of the turbocharger and related items as required by § 33.4, Instructions for continued airworthiness, and § 33.5, Instruction manual for installing and operating the engine. Particular attention should be given to component life limits for both the engine and turbocharger.

The exhaust system and supports should be capable of withstanding all vibration and inertia loads at the higher temperatures and pressures to which they are subjected by the turbocharger installation as required by § 23.1123, Exhaust system. Tests or investigations, as necessary, should be conducted to substantiate that the exhaust system meets the standards of airworthiness established by the basic engine 150-hour endurance test as required by § 33.49.

Turbocharger mounts and supporting structure should withstand all vibration and inertia loads to which they are subjected in operation as required by § 23.307, Proof of structure.

Conduct calibration tests and investigations to establish the sea level and altitude power characteristics of the engine and turbocharger combination.

Conduct flight tests to demonstrate that the engine operates throughout its anticipated operating range without exceeding detonation limits at limit temperatures and fuel flow, using the minimum-grade fuel. If necessary, establish the minimum fuel flow required for proper operation. Also, consider the limitations specified in the installer's instructions and as required by § 33.47, Detonation test.

Turbocharger and engine mount provisions should have sufficient strength to withstand loads arising from the conditions prescribed in § 33.23, Engine mounting attachments and structure. Because of relative motion and fire concerns in the event of a failure, experience has shown that turbochargers should not be remotely mounted on the firewall. Paragraph 23.909(b)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.5(b)

What should be considered when certificating the turbocharger control system?

A turbocharged engine requires additional systems necessary to control the turbocharger, such as the wastegate and wastegate controller. The effects of cold oil on the operating characteristics of the turbocharger wastegate and any oil-operated flow control devices should be considered when certificating the turbocharger control system.

The design of the turbocharger control devices should be such that any probable failure does not result in engine or turbocharger limits being exceeded, which should preclude damage to the turbocharger compressor or turbine.

Guidance for electronic wastegate controllers is contained in AC 33.28-2.

Related Material

AC 33.28-2, Guidance Material for 14 CFR § 33.28, Reciprocating Engines, Electrical and Electronic Engine Control Systems Paragraph 23.909(c)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.5(c)

What guidance is available when determining compliance with § 23.909(c)?

A turbocharger has high speed rotating components similar to a turbine engine. Consider the possibility of damage from turbine or compressor rotor failure.

If the turbocharger case alone has not demonstrated compliance with § 23.909(c), then the installer may provide additional containment shielding to preclude damage due to rotor failure.

No additional containment shielding is required for turbochargers approved with the engine provided the following conditions are both met. Information concerning the testing for part 33 certification should be obtained from the engine manufacturer.

1. Containment has been demonstrated during part 33 certification.

2. The containment testing was performed at operating conditions appropriate to the airplane and its engine installation.

Related Material

AC 20-128A, Design Considerations for Minimizing Hazards Caused by Uncontained Turbine Engine and Auxiliary Power Unit Rotor Failure

Paragraph 23.909(d)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. What affect does a turbocharger have on the engine induction air temperature at altitude?

A turbocharged engine has higher induction air temperatures at altitude because of the increased compression required to maintain engine manifold pressure. Turbocharger speed and compressor discharge temperature increase up to critical altitude.

What should be considered relative to the turbocharger system discharge?

Turbochargers on engines with carburetors produce combustible mixtures (at elevated pressure and temperature) in portions of the induction system. Induction system leaks should be minimized. Consider the relation of the turbocharger to the point of fuel introduction into the induction system. For turbocharged engines with carburetors, a combustible mixture at elevated pressure and temperature exists in portions of the induction system and should require special precautions. Consider that engine backfire combined with combustible mixtures in the induction system might produce fire in the system.

What methods of compliance are typical for § 23.909(d)?

Demonstrate the strength of the intercooler and mounting provisions as required by § 33.23.

Evaluate the intercooler installation for adequacy of:

1. The intercooler and mounting provisions;

2. Vibration response;

3. Engine cooling;

4. Additional instrumentation required for the intercooler to ensure that the engine ratings are not exceeded; and

5. Any cowling or airframe protrusions located in front of the firewall for fire resistance.

Demonstrate that the induction system can withstand pressure differentials (positive and negative) and temperature levels resulting from the turbocharger under the most critical operating conditions expected.

Turbocharger System › Cooling

Determine the effect of turbocharger installation on ice accretion characteristics of the induction system according to § 33.35(b). The induction system should meet the requirements of § 23.1091 and incorporate means to prevent and eliminate ice accumulation within the engine and turbocharger induction system, as required by § 23.1093. Associated heat rise requirements should also be evaluated. Paragraph 23.909(e)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. What methods of compliance are typical for § 23.909(e)?

It is difficult to thermodynamically match a turbocharger to an engine by analysis alone. A combination of test data and analysis is required for performance predictions and correction factors.

Power (Performance)

For airplanes required to comply with the performance requirements of § 23.45, Amendment 23-21, establish the actual calibrated power available at all altitudes. If performance information is required by § 23.45, Amendment 23-50, determine the actual engine power at altitude.

Investigate each engine installation at all operating points to ensure engine power output at the specified manifold pressure.

On intercooled installations, evaluate the effects the intercooler has on the engineapproved limits. These installations may require redefining the engine ratings. For example, increased engine horsepower output at the same manifold pressure and engine speed would require a method of limiting engine horsepower.

The Maintenance Manual should identify any turbocharger control system calibration checks required to ensure that the engine is maintaining the approved power output. This is especially important on installations with automatic turbocharger control systems.

Cooling

If turbocharger lubrication is provided by the engine oil system, the capacity of that system should be adequate to serve the engine and turbocharger under the most adverse combination of oil temperature and bearing clearances.

External lines and fittings containing flammable fluids as part of the turbocharger installation should comply with §§ 23.1017 and 23.863.

Turbocharger System › Operating Procedures

If the turbocharger oil system is self-contained, the capacity should be adequate to provide lubrication and cooling under the most adverse conditions of turbocharger oil temperature and bearing clearance.

Powerplant cooling provisions should be capable of maintaining the temperature of all powerplant components, parts, and fluids at or below the maximum established safe values under all ground and flight operating conditions as required by § 23.1047.

All portions of the engine exhaust system and turbocharger should be isolated from lines or components carrying flammable fluids, the accessory section, and primary structure by firewalls and shrouds, or by adequate separation as required by § 23.1121. Where required, adequate cooling air should be provided so that there is no adverse change in service life or failure rate of adjacent components.

Any ducting that bypasses the firewall and/or cowling should be fireproof.

Operating Limits

Define all operating limitations or instructions in the AFM and revise placards as required.

Demonstrate, using an engine conforming to type design data, that the approved power is not exceeded at any altitude.

Demonstrate through test that engine and turbocharger limits are not exceeded under any intended operating condition. In particular, establish that the turbocharger is operating within its speed and turbine inlet temperature limits.

Establish turbocharger oil temperature and pressure limits according to § 33.39, Lubrication system.

Specify temperature limits for any components requiring special cooling as required by § 33.21, Engine cooling.

Determine whether propeller blade, crankshaft, and prop shaft stresses are within acceptable limits. The applicant should readdress the propeller vibration compatibility according to § 23.907. Additionally, propeller recertification may be required.

Demonstrate compliance with § 23.955 if the maximum fuel flow has increased or the operating condition where maximum fuel flow is required has changed.

Operating Procedures

Demonstrate compliance with § 23.939(b), which includes a demonstration that the engine installation is free from compressor surge at all operating points.

Investigate the in-flight restart characteristics of the turbocharged engine. Demonstrate engine in-flight restart procedures.

The fuel system should be free from vapor lock throughout the flight envelope as required by § 23.961.

Because additional moisture might be introduced into the engine crankcase, demonstrate that the engine crankcase breather is adequately protected from ice blockage.

If the turbocharger provides airplane cabin pressurization, a failure of the installation should not contaminate the cabin air. Refer to § 23.831 for cabin Carbon Monoxide (CO) contamination levels and § 23.1121(a) for design requirements to prevent engine exhaust leaks that would allow CO to enter into the cabin area.

Evaluate the propeller-engine-airplane vibration characteristics at altitude to provide continued compliance with § 23.907. Additionally, demonstrate that the engine crankshaft torsion characteristics are within the original engine certificated limits or other safe operational limits.

If the turbocharger installation can affect the windshield defogging system, demonstrate continued compliance with § 23.773(b).

What engine cooling conditions should be considered for a turbocharged engine?

The peak temperature for a turbocharged engine normally occurs at maximum rated power at the altitude above which maximum rated power cannot be maintained. This altitude is called the critical altitude. Cooling air is less effective at altitude due to its lower density. As a general rule, design the engine cooling capacity for the sea level power output, then check the flight envelope cooling capacity at various altitudes. The applicant should investigate enough of the operating envelope to ensure that engine cooling is adequate. The simplest means to determine compliance is by performing a cooling climb test.

What should be considered relative to the turbocharger effect on the engine fuel system?

The increased heating of the induction system for turbocharged engines can affect the vapor lock potential for the engine. In addition, diaphragm-type fuel pumps might be inadequate to supply fuel to the turbocharged engine under all operating conditions. It might become necessary to add a fuel boost pump or make other changes to the pumping system to ensure freedom from vapor lock. The critical conditions should be determined by test, and acceptable fuel system vapor lock characteristics should be demonstrated under all desired operating conditions.

What should be considered if the turbocharger is used to supply pressurized cabin air?

The possibility of contamination of the cabin air during normal operation and after a failure in the system should be considered.

Can the turbocharger lubrication system use pressurized engine oil?

Turbocharger lubrication systems may be self-contained or require oil from an external source. If pressurized engine oil is used, the following effects should be considered:

1. The additional oil requirements should not exceed the capacity of the engine oil pump.

2. Heat rejected by the turbocharger to the oil should not exceed the engine oil system cooling provisions.

3. Air entrained in the turbocharger scavenge oil should not exceed the capability of the engine breather or scavenge systems.

What should be considered relative to turbocharger failures?

The operating procedures to minimize the potential hazards relating to fire and/or loss of engine power due to a turbocharger failure should be specified in the AFM. In particular, the in-flight restart characteristics of the engine with a failed turbocharger should be considered.

23.925 Propeller clearance (Amendment 23-51)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: 3.422

ADC Cross-reference: 5.3(c) Paragraph 23.925(a)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.3(c) What is the basis for the minimum clearances specified for ground clearance?

The clearances of seven and nine inches have been in the rules since the 1930’s and are probably based on experience. The primary purpose of these minimums is to provide enough clearance to limit the amount of foreign object damage from debris kicked up from the runway surfaces by the propeller wash and no propeller strike probability. The rule sets out the minimums as well as the airplane and propeller configurations to limit the number of potential test conditions required to demonstrate compliance.

What is the purpose of the positive clearance at the end of the rule if the minimums are met?

The minimums are for normal operational conditions whereas the positive clearance portion of the rule applies with the critical tire deflated and deflected struts. This portion of the rule is used to ensure that in such a condition the propeller will not strike the runway surface. Although tire is singular, the intent of the rule is that the airplane be in the most critical condition necessary to prevent a propeller strike. Thus, for airplanes with more than one critical tire, the interpretation is that tire could be plural. Paragraph 23.925(b)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. If the positive ground clearance from § 23.925(a) is met, why are there additional requirements for aft-mounted propellers?

The positive ground clearance in § 23.925(a) is for a condition with a deflated tire, whereas this rule is used for normal takeoffs and landings. Propellers mounted aft of the center of gravity of the airplane will be naturally closer to the ground with the airplane nose pitched up as for takeoff and landing. Thus, this rule is used to ensure that aftmounted propellers will not contact the runway surface during these conditions. Compliance with this paragraph is required in addition to § 23.925(a).

Paragraph 23.925(c)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. What is the basis for the minimum clearances specified for water clearance?

The eighteen-inch clearance has been in the rules since the 1930’s and is probably based on experience. The primary purpose of these minimums is to provide enough clearance to limit the spray kicked up from the water by the propeller wash. The rule sets out the minimum to limit the number of potential test conditions required to demonstrate compliance with § 23.925(c) and § 23.239. Paragraph 23.925(d)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.3(c)(2) What is the basis for the minimum clearances specified for structural clearance?

These minimum clearances have been in the rules since the 1930’s and are probably based on experience. The purpose of these minimums is to provide enough clearance to prevent the propeller from striking any other part of the airplane during operations and to limit propeller induced fuselage fatigue. These are considered the minimums, but care should be taken to identify any propeller or structural vibration modes that occur during operations that may lead to propeller strikes.

23.929 Engine installation ice protection (Amendment 23-51)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: None

ADC Cross-reference: 5.4 What components of the engine installation does this apply to?

This section applies to propellers, and cooling inlets for oil, generators and other components, when the applicant has requested certification with the ice protection provisions of § 23.1419. This section does not apply to engine induction system icing protection, which is covered under § 23.1093.

Who is responsible for engine installation ice protection certification?

Ice protection is the responsibility of the type certificate applicant. Propeller type certification requirements do not include any type of propeller ice protection requirements, unless accomplished with special conditions or special tests. In most instances, the propeller ice protection components are not included in the propeller type design.

Since the ice protection equipment is normally mounted on the propeller, include the propeller manufacturer in the process of assuring that the installation or failure of ice protection equipment will not harm the propeller. For example, an electrical short on a deicing boot could burn a hole in a composite blade or locally change the heat treatment of an aluminum blade. The resulting damage could make the propeller un-airworthy.

Can a deicing system that is certificated as part of the propeller be used to show compliance with § 23.929?

Deicing systems that are certificated according to the requirements of 14 CFR part 35 do not fully meet the requirements of § 23.929. Part 35 requirements address only propeller structural and vibration characteristics and require that the system functions. System failure modes are not addressed with part 35 certification of deicing systems.

The typical analysis report from the deicing boot manufacturer is not sufficient by itself to show compliance to § 23.929. The typical report calculates intercycle ice thicknesses for various flight and icing conditions, but it does not calculate the effect on propeller efficiency, which must be done to show no appreciable loss of thrust. It would be acceptable to show that intercycle ice is equal to or less than the accretions obtained on the same propeller on an airplane that was flight-tested in icing conditions and shown to have no appreciable loss in thrust.

The typical deicing boot manufacturer report also contains a caveat that it does not address propeller runback ice. Similarity to another propeller that was flight tested in icing conditions is usually done to address runback. Similarity would include propeller and deicing boot aerodynamic and thermal similarity, deicing timer, propeller RPM, and flight conditions. Note that metal and composite propellers have different thermal masses.

As a final qualitative check for both intercycle and runback ice on new airplane programs, airplane performance is checked during flight tests in icing conditions.

Related Material

AC 20-73, Aircraft Ice Protection

AC 23-8B, Flight Test Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes

AC 23-1419-2B, Certification of Part 23 Airplanes for Flight in Icing Conditions

23.933 Reversing systems (Amendment 23-51)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: None

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. What are the origins of this rule?

This rule reads exactly the same as § 25.933, which was developed in response to uncommanded, in-flight deployments of thrust reversing systems in turbine powered transport airplanes. Paragraph 23.933(a)

If the reversing system can be restored to forward thrust, why must the airplane be capable of continued safe flight with the reverser in any possible position?

During uncommanded reversing system deployment, there is a possibility of damage to the system due to the dynamic nature of the deployment that might prevent the system from being restored to forward thrust. The nature of this damage is considered unpredictable, and it is necessary that the airplane be capable of continued safe flight in such an event. Paragraph 23.933(b)

Is propeller reversing system certification covered as part of the propeller certification?

The requirement of 14 CFR part 35, § 35.21, applies to components of the propeller reversing system. If the reversing system components are included in the propeller type design (this can be verified with the propeller manufacturer or the FAA office controlling the propeller type design), the components have demonstrated compliance with § 35.21. The compliance data used to certify the propeller may be used to support the demonstration of compliance with § 23.933(b).

Components that are not included in the propeller type design may or may not have demonstrated compliance with § 35.21. Those components that have not been certificated as part of the propeller are covered under and must show compliance with § 23.933(b).

Are there other rules in 14 CFR part 23 that are related to § 23.933?

Requirements related to the operation of propeller reversing systems are contained in 14 CFR part 23, § 23.1155.

Related Material

AC 23-8B, Flight Test Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes

23.934 Turbojet and turbofan engine thrust reverser systems tests (Amendment 23-43)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: None

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. Are there other rules in 14 CFR part 23 that are related to § 23.934?

Requirements related to the operation of thrust reverser systems are contained in 14 CFR part 23, § 23.1155.

Related Material

AC 20-18A, Qualification Testing of Turbojet Engine Thrust Reversers

23.937 Turbopropeller-drag limiting systems (Amendment 23-43)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: None

ADC Cross-reference: 5.6 Paragraph 23.937(a)

Is a failure probability analysis an acceptable means of showing compliance to § 23.937?

A failure probability analysis may be used to show compliance with this paragraph. Show that the probability of an accident occurring because of any failure of a propeller drag limiting system (either automatic or manual) is extremely improbable.

Related Material

AC 23.1309-1C, Equipment, Systems, and Installations in Part 23 Airplanes Paragraph 23.937(b)

Is there any policy available for compliance with § 23.937(b)?

This paragraph was added at Amendment 23-43 in 1993 to define a propeller drag limiting system as manual or automatic devices that, when actuated after engine power loss, can move the propeller blades toward the feather position to reduce windmilling drag to a safe level. This does not include negative torque sensing systems. Prior to this, there was confusion as to whether these systems included negative torque sensing systems or only propeller feathering systems.

23.939 Powerplant operating characteristics (Amendment 23-42)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: None

ADC Cross-reference: 5.7 Related Material

AC 23-8B, Flight Test Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes

AC 25.939-1, Evaluating Turbine Engine Operating Characteristics Paragraph 23.939(a)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.7(a) Is it possible to extrapolate engine operability compliance for airfields at higher elevations than those tested when showing compliance with § 23.939(a)?

There currently are no extrapolation procedures for showing compliance with the requirements of § 23.939(a) for airplanes certificated to part 23. Traditionally, testing up to the field elevation for which the airplane is to be approved has been used to show compliance. This is the most desirable method since it does not require parameter variation analysis to account for the higher airfield elevations. Extrapolations have been used for part 25 airplanes, and the same considerations may be used for part 23 airplanes.

When considering extrapolation for compliance with § 23.939(a), data must be presented that substantiates the proposed extrapolation procedures. This data should include supportive flight test and engine operations data. The applicant should determine, understand, and substantiate the critical operating modes of the engine including a determination and quantification of the effects the installation and variations in ambient conditions have on these modes. Advisory Circular 25.939-1 may be used for turbine engines to determine and evaluate the engine critical operating modes. If the proposal is appropriately substantiated, the extrapolation of the engine data for compliance with the operability requirements of § 23.939(a) may be performed up to a maximum of 3,000 feet above the airfield elevation tested. Paragraph 23.939(b)

ADC Cross-reference: None

No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002.

Paragraph 23.939(c)

ADC Cross-reference: None

No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002.

23.943 Negative acceleration (Amendment 23-43)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: None

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. What methods of compliance are acceptable?

This requirement can be satisfied by flight test demonstrations that consider critical airplane, engine, and APU configurations (for an APU approved for use in flight). Guidance concerning these tests is included in AC 23-8B. The durations of the tests specified in Chapter 196 of AC 23-8B are intended to represent anticipated abnormal operational events such as atmospheric upsets and collision avoidance maneuvers. Fuel, oil lubrication, and electrical systems are typically monitored during these tests. Fuel tanks should not be more than half full to allow room for fuel to lift and uncover fuel line inlets and boost pump pickups during the negative accelerations.

Related Material

AC 23-8B, Flight Test Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes

FUEL SYSTEM 23.951 Fuel System General (Amendment 23-43)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: 3.429, 3.430

ADC Cross-reference: 5.8 Related Material

AC 23-10, Auxiliary Fuel Systems for Reciprocating and Turbine Powered Part 23 Airplanes

AC 23.1521-2 with Change 1, Type Certification of Oxygenates and Oxygenated Gasoline Fuels in Part 23 Airplanes with Reciprocating Engines Paragraph 23.951(a)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.8(a)

No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002. Paragraph 23.951(b)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.8(b) Under what conditions can fuel be drawn from more than one tank at a time?

Section 23.951(b) allows fuel (for the purpose of direct engine feed) to be drawn from more than one tank at a time provided:

1. There are means to prevent introducing air into the fuel system; and

2. The pilot has a means to draw fuel from a single tank.

What are some of the considerations for such systems?

Fuel systems that supply engine fuel from more than one tank at a time do not consume fuel at the same rate from both tanks. This is attributable to differences in vents, filter condition, line losses, pumps, fuel return flow, fuel consumption rates (multiengine airplanes), etc. It is probable that one tank will run out of usable fuel while there is still usable fuel on board. To prevent air being drawn into the engine fuel supply line, use a method to seal the fuel tank outlets whenever the tank is out of usable fuel.

Substantiation tests are required for systems that draw fuel from more than one tank demonstrating that air is not drawn into the fuel system.

A series of fuel tanks can be interconnected to function as a single tank. For example, two left-handed wing tanks using gravity to feed from one to the other with interconnected vent lines function as a single tank provided that fuel is drawn from only one location. For the purposes of this discussion, these tanks may be treated as a single tank.

Interconnecting the vent lines on two independent tanks (i.e., left-hand and right-hand wing tanks feeding to a common fuel selector valve) does not cause the tanks to function as a single tank. As above, this configuration may allow air into the fuel system when either independent tank has consumed its usable fuel unless there is a means to prevent the introduction of air.

(Many in-service airplanes were certified under the Civil Air Regulations (CAR). For background, CAR § 3.430, which preceded § 23.951(b), required the fuel system arrangement to “permit any one fuel pump to draw fuel from only one tank at a time.” In the past, this has sometimes been interpreted (incorrectly) as “a fuel pump may only draw fuel from one tank at a time.” The CAR regulation is actually more permissive than § 23.951(b) as it did not address the possibility of introducing air into the fuel system.) Paragraph 23.951(c)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable. Is the use of fuel anti-icing additives an acceptable means of compliance for § 23.951(c)?

Yes, the fuel icing requirements of § 23.951(c) may be satisfied by using the anti-icing additives as specified in AC 20-29B, Use of Aircraft Fuel Anti-icing Additives.

Related Material

AC 20-29B, Use of Aircraft Fuel Anti-icing Additives Paragraph 23.951(d)

ADC Cross-reference: None

This guidance may be used for Airship Certification as applicable.

Is this requirement covered under § 23.903(a)(1)?

The portion of the fuel system that is certificated with the engine is covered under § 23.903(a)(1). The remainder of the airplane fuel system, including the tanks, pumps, fuel lines, and firewall shutoff valves, is covered under § 23.951(b).

23.953 Fuel system independence (Amendment 23-43)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: 3.431

ADC Cross-reference: 5.9 What parts of the fuel supply system should be considered when assessing its independence for each engine?

The independence of a fuel supply system for each engine should be assessed starting at the fuel supply pickup point within the tank and continue to the fuel inlet at the engine.

Related Material

AC 23-10, Auxiliary Fuel Systems for Reciprocating and Turbine Powered Part 23 Airplanes Paragraph 23.953(a)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.9(a) What is the intent of requiring no immediate action by the pilot to prevent the loss of thrust to more than one engine?

In the event a multiengine airplane experiences a loss of thrust on one engine as a result of a fuel system failure, the pilot will be occupied with flying the airplane in the new thrust configuration, as well as trouble shooting the problem engine. The intent of § 23.953(a) is that the system should be designed such that, in this event, the remaining engine(s) will not be affected by the failure so the pilot will not be required to deal with another engine thrust loss during this time of increased workload. Paragraph 23.953(b)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.9(b)

No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002.

23.954 Fuel system lightning protection (Amendment 23-7)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: None

ADC Cross-reference: 5.10 Is it possible to comply with § 23.954 with operational limitations only?

Operational limitations only are not acceptable means of compliance for standard category airplanes. However, this has been allowed for special purpose, restricted category, single-engine agricultural airplanes using the normal category requirements of part 23 as a certification basis. A limitation in the Airplane Flight Manual, such as “Operation of the airplane in and around thunderstorms is prohibited,” has been determined to be sufficient to address this regulation for these non-standard category airplanes.

Related Material

AC 20-53A, Protection of Aircraft Fuel Systems Against Fuel Vapor Ignition Due to Lightning

AC 23-15, Small Airplane Certification Compliance Program

AC 23.1521-2 with Change 1, Type Certification of Oxygenates and Oxygenated Gasoline Fuels in Part 23 Airplanes with Reciprocating Engines Paragraph 23.954(a)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.10(a)

No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002. Paragraph 23.954(b)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.10(b)

No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002. Paragraph 23.954(c)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.10(c)

No specific policy is available as of December 31, 2002.

23.955 Fuel flow (Amendment 23-51)

CAR 3 Cross-reference: 3.433, 3.434, 3.435, 3.436, 3.437(e)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.11 Paragraph 23.955(a)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.11(a) What are the acceptable means for showing compliance with § 23.955(a)?

Demonstrate fuel-flow characteristics with the entire fuel system installed in the airplane during the airplane type certification program. A suitable mock-up of the fuel system can also be used to demonstrate fuel-flow capacity. Analysis may be used to reduce the tests required, provided the analysis has been validated through appropriate tests.

Some applicants may modify their airplanes in such a way as to affect the original fuel system. Changes in the type of fuel used are also considered a change to the fuel system. In these cases, additional fuel-flow testing may be required to substantiate continued compliance of the fuel system with applicable regulations and engine manufacturer's requirements.

In-service fuel that has the correct physical properties and octane ratings should flow at the rate specified by regulation and at the pressure established in compliance with 14 CFR part 33, § 33.7, Engine ratings and operating limitations. This information is provided in the engine installation manual.

As stated in § 23.955(d), the test conditions and tests provided in this section are also applicable to auxiliary fuel systems and their associated fuel transfer systems.

What test conditions should be considered?

1. Airplane Attitude

Flow tests should be conducted at the critical attitude for the airplane. The critical attitude may be determined with the use of an inclinometer by flying the airplane at critical weight.

Conventional tractor airplanes normally have fuel tanks aft of the carburetor or engine injector inlet. Conditions grow less favorable for fuel flow as the airplane rotates in the “nose-up” attitude. Likewise, pusher airplanes normally have the fuel tanks forward of the carburetor or engine injector inlet making conditions less favorable for fuel flow as the airplane rotates in the “nose-down” attitude.

2. Minimum Inlet Pressure

The engine manufacturer typically establishes the minimum and maximum fuel pressure limits necessary to obtain acceptable engine operation during certification to 14 CFR part 33, §§ 33.7(b)(5)(i) and 33.7(c)(6)(i). These limits are on the applicable FAA Engine Type Certificate Data Sheet (TCDS).

The fuel pressure limits are shown in a number of different ways:

a. Minus or plus “x” pounds per square inch (psi);

b. “y” psi above true vapor pressure; and

c. “z” inches fuel head differential between carburetor fuel inlet fitting and float

bowl chamber.

Most of these inlet pressure limits require no conversions. Some turbine engine manufacturers specify either the minimum inlet fuel pressure as “x” psi above the true vapor pressure of the fuel used with a Vapor/Liquid (V/L) ratio of zero, or as the maximum V/L ratio for emergency use that should not exceed a specific value. These fuel pressure limits will require an analysis of the fuel to determine true vapor pressure of the fuel with the corresponding V/L. Alternatively, a laboratory test may be conducted to determine the engine minimum fuel inlet pressure.

3. Supercharged Engine Fuel System Inlet Pressure

This applies to engines using either a mechanical or an exhaust-driven (turbocharger) device to pressurize the intake air charge.

The required fuel pressure at the carburetor or injector inlet is stated on the engine TCDS and is normally referenced to the engine inlet air (manifold) pressure. The manifold pressure is an absolute pressure and is typically stated in inches of mercury (Hg). Be sure to use compatible units when calculating the (carburetor or injector) fuel pressure minimum limit.

The inlet air (or upper deck) pressure is maintained up to the critical altitude, while the fuel tank pressure decreases with increasing altitude. This usually results in the greatest difference between the fuel tank pressure and the inlet air pressure at the critical altitude. Therefore, conduct pressure and flow tests at conditions that account for the difference between the tank pressure at the actual test altitude and the critical altitude. The pressure and flow tests may be done in two ways:

a. Reduce the fuel tank pressure, or

b. Add the difference to the pressure that the engine TCDS indicates the pump is

required to deliver to the carburetor or injector. How can the minimum inlet fuel pressure for reciprocating engines be determined if it is not available from the engine manufacturer?

Should the minimum carburetor or injector-inlet fuel-pressure figure not be available from the engine manufacturer, the following process may be used to determine the acceptable inlet pressure:

1. Connect a gravity flow fuel tank to the engine inlet that can be varied in height in relation to the carburetor inlet. Large tubing may be used to minimize the effects of fluid friction;

2. With the airplane in the ground attitude position, run the engine at full takeoff r.p.m. and manifold pressure. Consider using a propeller that will allow full takeoff r.p.m. and satisfactorily cool the engine;

3. Start with the fuel tank high enough to permit proper operation of the engine. Vary the fuel level by lowering the tank until the first evidence of engine malfunction occurs, then measure and record the fuel head available to the engine. This measurement is to be made from the carburetor fuel inlet to the top of the fuel level in the tank;

4. Engine malfunction may be detected by use of an exhaust gas temperature indicator, which will indicate change in the fuel-air mixture. Any change in fuel-air mixture will result in an exhaust gas temperature change and impending engine malfunction. Also, any noticeable change in engine r.p.m. or manifold pressure will indicate a change in engine horsepower; and

5. Establish the minimum fuel pressure 10 percent above the measured fuel pressure (at the carburetor inlet) required for acceptable engine operation.

Are there any special considerations?

If a fuel flowmeter is installed, block the flowmeter during the flow test and measure the fuel flow through the bypass according to § 23.955(a)(2).

If a fuel filter with bypass provisions is installed, block the fuel filter during the flow test and measure the fuel flow through the bypass.

For engines operating on kerosene (jet) or diesel fuels, evaluate the effects of fuel density, low temperature, altitude, attitude, and water saturation.

Paragraph 23.955(b)

ADC Cross-reference: 5.11(b) How can I demonstrate the fuel flow rate compliance for a gravity fed fuel system?

This method is applicable only to airplanes with reciprocating engines. Use this method only if the airplane is being certificated without the use of airplane supplied fuel pumps for normal operation. The airplane may be equipped with optional auxiliary or emergency pumps provided they are installed but not used during this test.

This test demonstrates the adequacy of the engine fuel supply under the most adverse operating condition. Measure the flow directly at the carburetor inlet (for example, if a reducing nipple is used at the carburetor inlet, measure the fuel flow through the nipple).

Position the airplane on the ground with the thrust or fuselage level line at the most critical attitude for fuel flow. A bench test using the pertinent fuel system components located at relative elevations to represent actual airplane critical attitudes may be used. If the airplane is tested in the level flight attitude, determine the appropriate fuel head for the critical attitude by analysis and test, and add this fuel head to the fuel system in the level flight attitude.

Reduce the fuel pressure to the minimum operating pressure for an acceptable takeoff power mixture as recommended by the carburetor and engine manufacturer. An acceptable method of simulating the minimum pressure required at the carburetor inlet is to disconnect the fuel-feed line at the carburetor and raise the end of the line above the carburetor a distance equal to that of the required minimum operating pressure in inches of fuel.

Compensate for the differential pressure (calculated as shown below under Normally Aspirated, Carbureted, Reciprocating Engine Fuel System Pressure Differential), by subtracting it from the required minimum carburetor inlet pressure. For example, if the minimum permissible fuel inlet pressure is 19 inches of fuel and a system pressure differential is 7 inches (produced between the fuel tank vent space and the carburetor float bowl airspace), then run the test with the fuel line assembly raised 12 inches above the fuel inlet fitting of the carburetor. (The pressure, in psi, can be estimated at approximately one psi for each 40 inches head of fuel.)

Alternatively, compute the sum of the head pressure associated with best rate-of-climb and carburetor inlet requirements, and demonstrate (with the fuel restricted by a valve installed at the engine-end of the system to simulate this pressure) that fuel flow is at least equal to the regulatory minimum.

Completely drain the fuel system before beginning the test. Set the system to feed from one tank only. Slowly add fuel to the tank until a steady flow is established at the inlet to the carburetor or fuel injector unit. Steady flow should be established when slightly more

than the unusable fuel supply has been added. When steady flow has been established, add an additional gallon (or the fuel quantity necessary to complete the flow test) to the tank.

Record the time in seconds for at least one gallon of fuel to flow from the feed line. The time for one gallon of fuel to flow should not be more than the figure computed from the following equations:

1. For reciprocating engine powered airplanes, certificated under Part 3 of the CAR or 14 CFR part 23, at the rate of 150 percent of the actual fuel flow to the engine at maximum takeoff power:

Seconds per gallon = 14,400/(SFC)(TOHP)

Where SFC = Engine Specific Fuel Consumption (SFC)

(at Takeoff Power (TOPH)) expressed in (lb./bhp/hr.)

TOHP = Engine brake horsepower (bhp) at takeoff

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 278 passages shown