AC 150/5190-4B Airport Land Use Compatibility Planning
This AC is intended to help a broad audience understand the effects of land use on the safety and utility of airport operations and identify compatible land use development tools, resources and techniques to protect surrounding communities from adverse effects associated with airport operations.
U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory Circular
Subject: Airport Land Use Compatibility Planning
Date: 9/16/2022 Initiated By: APP-400
AC No: 150/5190-4B
1 Purpose.
This Advisory Circular (AC) is intended to help a broad audience understand the effects
of land use on the safety and utility of airport operations, and identify compatible land use development tools, resources and techniques to protect surrounding communities from adverse effects associated with airport operations.
This AC describes the major incompatible land uses that conflict with or are impacted by
operations at local public-use airports. These include residential use within airport noise contours; airspace obstructions and hazards to safe navigation to and from the airport such as tall structures, light, glare, electronic/radio, smoke, steam, or other atmospheric interference emanating from nearby land uses; land uses that attract birds and other wildlife hazards to the airport and its immediate environs; and land uses with concentrations of people or property within airport runway protection zones.
Airport-compatible land uses are defined as those uses that can coexist with a nearby
airport without constraining the safe and efficient operation of the airport, or exposing people living or working nearby to potential negative environmental or safety impacts.
The intent of this document is to inform, educate, and increase awareness about land use
compatibility issues related to airports and community development. This AC provides broad, general guidance to communities across the country on airport compatible land use planning. Because the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) does not have the authority to directly control off-airport land uses and because land use decisions are often made at the local level, it is important that local land use planners understand the implications of land use compatibility between airports and their local communities. The guidance in this AC does not replace any local land use regulations that may be in place.
Through federal grant assurances, airport sponsors and owners are obligated to pursue all
reasonable and appropriate actions to secure and promote compatible land use and development within their local areas. Airports owned and operated by the same jurisdiction that is the land use authority (e.g. city or county owned airport) are expected to adequately control land use near the airport and prevent new incompatible development. Airports that are located within multiple jurisdictions or have no land use
ii
authority are expected to remain vigilant of incompatible development proposals within the airport environs, and take reasonable and appropriate action to mitigate incompatible land use and promote compatible development.
Nothing in this AC creates or modifies existing airport planning or design standards, or
creates new requirements for airports, communities or FAA personnel. Rather, it consolidates and updates previous guidance on these matters, including information on tools and resources that the FAA has created since the preceding AC was published in 1987. For additional information and resources, refer to the Advisory Circulars and other documents referenced throughout this AC.
2 Application.
This document is intended for a diverse audience. This includes airport sponsors, airport
management, real estate developers, local and regional land use planners that are focused on transportation, economic development, natural resource conservation, and related topics; local elected and appointed officials; FAA officials and other governmental agencies (federal, state and local); and others who play a role in achieving and maintaining airport land use compatibility.
This AC provides resources to assist airport and state and local community planning
efforts with the development of effective airport land use compatibility plans. Sample airport land use compatibility plan content, and airport overlay and compatibility zoning ordinances, are included in the AC appendices.
The information contained in this AC is not all-inclusive. Applicability will vary on a
case-by-case basis due to state and local land use planning regulations.
This AC does not constitute a regulation, and is not legally binding in its own right. It
will not be relied upon as a separate basis by the FAA for affirmative enforcement action or penalty. Conformity with this AC is voluntary, and nonconformity will not affect rights and obligations under existing statutes and regulations, except for the projects described in subparagraphs 2 and 3 below:
1. The standards and processes contained in this AC are specifications the FAA considers essential for the fidelity of Residential Sound Insulation Programs.
2. Use of these standards and guidelines is mandatory for projects funded under Federal grant assistance programs, including the Airport Improvement Program (AIP). See Grant Assurances #34 and #21.
3. This AC is mandatory, as required by regulation, for projects funded by the Passenger Facility Charge program. See PFC Assurance #9.
3 Cancellation. This AC cancels AC 150/5190-4A, A Model Zoning Ordinance to Limit Height of Objects around Airports, dated December 14, 1987. It also cancels FAA Memorandum, “Interim Guidance on Land Uses Within a Runway Protection Zone,” dated September 27, 2012.
iii
4 Feedback on this AC. If you have suggestions for improving this AC, you may use the Advisory Circular Feedback form at the end of this document.
Robert J. Craven Director, Office of Airport Planning and Programming
i
CONTENTS
Paragraph Page
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION … 1-1
1.1 Need for Guidance … 1-1
1.2 Organization of the AC … 1-1
1.3 History of Land Use Compatibility … 1-2
1.4 Value of Aviation … 1-3
1.5 Benefits of Compatible Land Use Planning … 1-4
1.6 Consequences of Incompatible Development … 1-9
CHAPTER 2. LAND USE COMPATIBILITY CONCERNS … 2-1
2.1 Definition of Compatible Land Use … 2-1
2.2 Evaluation of Airport Land Use Compatibility … 2-1
2.3 Compatibility of Land Use Types near the Airport … 2-21
CHAPTER 3. ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF COMPATIBLE
LAND USE STAKEHOLDERS … 3-1
3.1 Overview of Stakeholders … 3-1
3.2 Local Government Stakeholders … 3-2
3.3 Airport Related Stakeholders … 3-5
3.4 Non-Aviation Stakeholders … 3-7
3.5 State Government Stakeholders … 3-9
3.6 Federal Government Stakeholders … 3-11
CHAPTER 4. AIRPORT AND LOCAL LAND USE PLANNING
COORDINATION … 4-1
4.1 Coordination of Local and Regional Land Use Planning … 4-1
4.2 Airport-Sponsored Plans … 4-4
4.3 Military-Sponsored Plans … 4-6
4.4 Regional Plans … 4-7
4.5 Local Governments Plans and Activities … 4-9
CHAPTER 5. TOOLS AND TECHNIQUES FOR LAND USE
COMPATIBILITY … 5-1
5.1 Overview of Tools and Techniques … 5-1
ii
5.2 Land Use Regulations … 5-4
5.3 Land Acquisition Techniques … 5-12
5.4 Noise Mitigation … 5-17
5.5 Wildlife and Habitat Management … 5-20
5.6 Notification Tools and Techniques … 5-22
5.7 Education and Communication … 5-26
APPENDIX A. GLOSSARY … A-1
APPENDIX B. FAA LAND USE-RELATED REGULATIONS AND
GUIDANCE … B-1
APPENDIX C. SAMPLE AIRPORT LAND USE COMPATIBILITY
PLAN … C-1
APPENDIX D. EXAMPLE AIRPORT LAND USE COMPATIBILITY
OVERLAY ZONING ORDINANCE … D-1
CHAPTER 1. Introduction › 1.2 Organization of the AC.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Need for Guidance.
1.1.1 FAA encourages and assists local airport sponsors and their community land use planning authorities with undertaking their best efforts to secure compatible land use development and planning within the airport environs. Airports that accept federal money through the Airport Improvement Program (AIP) must comply with all FAA Grant Assurances. These include but are not limited to Assurances 19, Operation and Maintenance; 20, Hazard Removal and Mitigation; and 21, Compatible Land Use. These assurances are based on statutory requirements. Because these assurances require airports to take appropriate and reasonable actions to promote and maintain airport land use compatibility, the FAA is publishing this Advisory Circular (AC) to provide guidance to airports and other stakeholders on how to accomplish these actions.
1.1.2 Although there are various federal resources on the topic of land use compatibility, historically there is no single, comprehensive land use guidance tool for airports and local communities. This AC is intended to serve as a resource to help airports comply with their grant assurances (see FAA Order 5190.6, Airport Compliance Manual) concerning all the compatible land use issues, including obstructions and hazard to airport navigation, airport noise, wildlife attractants and protection of persons and property on the ground. It references FAA regulations and guidance concerning compatible land use and development within the airport environs, such as Part 77 and Part 150 of Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) and FAA Advisory Circulars (AC) 150/5300-13, Airport Design, and 150/5020-1, Airport Noise Control and Compatibility Planning for Airports.
1.1.3 This AC should be used as a starting point in addressing land use compatibility issues. Because land use planning and regulation is a power reserved to the states and political subdivisions of states, readers should refer to appropriate state legislation and guidance before formulating land use compatibility plans and programs. This AC is also instrumental in educating local land use planning professionals in understanding the development and operation of airports and potential impacts that could occur. Local municipalities should review relevant ordinances, and other national and local guidance for a comprehensive understanding of each airport scenario relative to local land use regulations.
1.2 Organization of the AC. This AC is organized into the following chapters:
Chapter 1: Introduction – Defines the concept of land use compatibility and its
importance.
Chapter 2: Land Use Compatibility Concerns – Identifies the land uses that may
cause concern near airports.
1.3 History of Land Use Compatibility. › 1.3.3 This AC supersedes AC 150/5190-4A, which focused primarily on…
Chapter 3: Roles and Responsibility of Stakeholders – Addresses the various
stakeholders at all levels and their responsibilities in achieving compatible land use.
Chapter 4: Airport and Local Land Use Planning Coordination – Describes the
various methods for planning coordination at the local level.
Chapter 5: Tools and Techniques for Land Use Compatibility – Provides numerous
methods and resources that can be employed to promote and achieve land use compatibility.
Appendices – Includes additional resources related to airport land use compatibility:
o Appendix A – Glossary
o Appendix B – FAA Land Use-Related Regulations and Guidance
o Appendix C – Sample Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan
o Appendix D – Example Airport Land Use Compatibility Overlay Zoning Ordinance
1.3 History of Land Use Compatibility.
1.3.1 Airport land use compatibility has been a topic of discussion ever since flight began. It was formally recognized as an issue in 1952 when President Harry S. Truman commissioned the development of a report entitled “The Airport and its Neighbors” (commonly known as the Doolittle Report). The Doolittle Report documented the need to protect and preserve airports from incompatible land uses and protect people on the ground within the vicinity of airports from nuisances caused by airport and aircraft operations. Since that publication, guidance documents and programs have been created with the goal of supporting compatible land use near airports. As time has passed and development pressures have increased, the need for planning that addresses noise impacts to homes near airports and airport land use compatibility has grown between the 1960’s and the present day.
1.3.2 National guidance on land use has historically been provided through three primary ACs:
AC 150/5050-6, Airport Land Use Compatibility Planning, published in December
1977 (cancelled);
AC 150/5020-1, Noise Control and Compatibility Planning for Airports, published
originally in August 1983; and
AC 150/5190-4, A Model Zoning Ordinance to Limit Height of Objects around
Airports, published in December 1987.
1.3.3 This AC supersedes AC 150/5190-4A, which focused primarily on height limitations. This revised AC accounts for both height and broader land use compatibility considerations. Appendix B includes a brief summary of federal land use regulation and guidance.
1.4 Value of Aviation. › 1.4.5 While the value of aviation can be evaluated in a number of ways…
1.3.4 Other topics (such as wildlife attractants, noise, and airport and airspace design-related issues) are addressed in other FAA documents. This results in airport sponsors and local land use planners cross-referencing a number of resources to obtain a comprehensive picture of the issues related to compatible land use planning.
1.4 Value of Aviation.
1.4.1 The value of the U.S. air transportation network is evident on and off-airport, and at the local, regional, and national levels. Several national studies have been conducted to quantify this value, both directly and indirectly, across the aviation industry. According to the 2016 FAA report, Economic Impact of Civil Aviation on the U.S. Economy, civil aviation was responsible for nearly 11 million jobs, with over $446 billion in earnings and $1.6 trillion in total economic activity in 2016.
1.4.2 The economic impact of airports in the U.S. was evaluated in Airport Cooperative Research Program (ACRP) Report 132, The Role of U.S. Airports in the National Economy. According to the report, airports directly support over two million jobs that total nearly $148 billion in labor income. When multiplier effects are considered, U.S. airports support $768 billion in total value added to the national economy.
1.4.3 In 2020, the General Aviation Manufacturers Association (GAMA) published an economic study on the value of general aviation (GA) in the U.S. entitled Contributions of General Aviation to the U.S. Economy in 2018. This study found that GA supports nearly 1.2 million jobs, with $77 billion in labor income and $247 billion in national economic output.
1.4.4 In addition to the economic value, airports provide qualitative benefits to a local community. This includes efficient trade, tourism accessibility, transportation safety, and expanded national and global health and research resources.
1.4.5 While the value of aviation can be evaluated in a number of ways (quantitatively and qualitatively), it is clear that the aviation system within the U.S. is significant to economies and communities at the local, regional, and national levels.
AIRPORT OPERATIONS/ACTIVITIES
Airports support a wealth of operations beyond general leisure and business travel and air cargo movement. Some examples include:
Remote access Medical transport Surveillance Aerial firefighting Law enforcement International protection Research News reporting Visitation by VIP
1.5.4 Benefits to the Aviation System. › 1.5.4.1 Opportunities for Airport Development.
1.5 Benefits of Compatible Land Use Planning.
1.5.1 FAA guidance can help state, county, and local governments improve compatible land use planning. Increasing demand for land use development near airports will continue to impact airport operations and planned development. Consequently, it is important that airport sponsors act proactively with their local communities to promote compatible land use planning. Application of the tools and techniques described in this AC and the referenced FAA directives will help airport sponsors develop the coordinated compatible land use planning methods with their communities.
1.5.2 Compatible land use planning can benefit both the airport and the local community. Effective land use planning can prevent expensive and problematic incompatible land uses from developing in the first place and can help mitigate issues associated with historically incompatible uses. Many stakeholders outside of airport property benefit from these planning efforts. The FAA encourages local communities/municipalities to consider these benefits when assessing the value of compatible land use planning.
1.5.3 Benefits range from continued value of the transportation infrastructure and transportation system, to continued support for business, leisure travel, and tourism, to reduction in noise-sensitive uses near airports, among many others. These benefits are recognized at all levels (local, regional, statewide, and national) and by many interest groups. Discussion of compatibility planning benefits is divided into the following sections:
Benefits to the aviation system
Benefits to people near airports
Benefits to local and regional jurisdictions
1.5.4 Benefits to the Aviation System. The opportunity for increased development, both on and near an airport, can benefit an airport and the local community financially. Likewise, protecting an airport’s approaches and complying with design standards provides clear operating areas for aircraft utilizing an airport.
1.5.4.1 Opportunities for Airport Development. Planning for compatible development can provide more opportunities for the efficient development of on-airport property (both aeronautical and nonaeronautical) and expansion of airport facilities. When incompatible uses are developed near airports, the airport may not be able to develop facilities to meet increasing airport user needs or take advantage of beneficial onairport development. Mitigating these incompatible developments after the fact to make room for an airport expansion can be extremely expensive. Instead, airport sponsors are urged to work proactively with local jurisdictions to plan for the airport’s future development needs by identifying (early in the planning process for the proposed development)
1.5.4.4 Reduced Potential for Litigation. › 1.5.4.4.2 In general, airport sponsors may expect litigation costs to…
land use patterns and growth that are compatible with both current and anticipated airport use and local community needs.
1.5.4.2 Preservation of Airport and Aircraft Operations.
1.5.4.2.1 Incompatible land use has the potential to impact airports and aircraft operations in several negative ways. Incompatible land use planning can introduce aeronautical safety hazards that require operational mitigations to address, potentially limiting the utility of airport facilities. For example, incompatible land uses, such as structures, that encroach into protected airspace may eventually cause displacement of a runway’s threshold in order to maintain safety margins. A displaced threshold shortens the usable length of the runway and therefore limits the types of aircraft that can operate on a runway.
1.5.4.2.2 In addition to preserving airport facilities, encouraging the development of compatible uses at and around an airport can eliminate or reduce the need for pilots to follow modified flight paths or other costly noise abatement procedures if nearby development is in noise-sensitive areas.
1.5.4.3 Protection of Airport Approaches and Departures. The most critical areas surrounding an airport are the approach and departure zones for airport runways. Because aircraft landing or departing from an airport frequently occupy this airspace, it is important to assess land uses directly underneath these zones for compatibility with aircraft operations. Continually monitoring and evaluating land uses in these areas can ensure the airport continues to operate safely and efficiently.
1.5.4.4 Reduced Potential for Litigation.
1.5.4.4.1 Another benefit of compatibility planning is a reduced potential for litigation. Litigation that stems from land use compatibility issues can be costly for all parties involved, including an airport’s sponsor (which is often the local municipality). If airport administration/management makes diligent efforts to encourage a compatible environment (existing and future), the risk of entering litigation to resist or prevent land use incompatibility can be reduced. Coordinated airport and land use compatibility planning works to prevent potential site development conflicts that could otherwise result in costly and wasteful litigation to prevent incompatible development.
1.5.4.4.2 In general, airport sponsors may expect litigation costs to include attorney’s fees, staff time, and the amount of settlement (if any). The magnitude of costs depends upon the type of litigation, duration and outcome, and can vary drastically from one scenario to the next. Case studies in ACRP Report 27 indicate there have been cases that have cost thousands of dollars on the low-end to millions of dollars on the high-end.
1.5.5 Benefits to People near Airports. › 1.5.5.1 Community Awareness of Airport Compatible Land Use Planning.
1.5.4.5 Compliance with Airport Design Standards.
1.5.4.5.1 Encouraging compatible uses near an airport can help maintain or protect runways of the appropriate dimensions for use by the most critical aircraft. Airport design standards are addressed in FAA AC 150/5300-13, Airport Design. These should be considered when looking at compatible land use issues. When incompatible development surrounds an airport, it can be challenging for the airport sponsor to provide a runway that complies with airport design safety standards.
1.5.4.5.2 Sponsor implementation of compatible land use controls and monitoring for incompatible development will help mitigate and prevent hazards to flight. It will also help protect people and property on the ground near airport runways.
1.5.4.6 Avoidance of Hazardous Wildlife Attractants.
1.5.4.6.1 FAA AC 150/5200-33, Hazardous Wildlife Attractants on or Near Airports, advises that specific land use developments such as wastewater treatment facilities, wetlands mitigation, dredge spoil containment areas, and solid waste landfills be located at least 5,000 feet away from the end of a runway at an airport that primarily serves piston-type aircraft, and at least 10,000 feet away if the airport serves turbojet aircraft. Airport sponsors who are actively involved with their local planning entity are more likely to be aware of proposals for these types of uses, and can work to maintain compliance with AC 150/5200-33 and applicable regulations. See Section 2.2.4 for a discussion of the land use location and land use characteristics that contribute to wildlife attractant hazard conditions, and require sponsor evaluation and actions to prevent or mitigate hazards.
1.5.4.6.2 Not only do wildlife strikes pose a risk to aircraft occupants and people on the ground, they are almost always fatal to the wildlife. Because of this, land use compatibility planning can also protect wildlife by encouraging habitat preservation or development away from airports.
1.5.5 Benefits to People near Airports. An efficient airport contributes to the well-being of the public it serves, both economically and by providing essential and desired aviation services. The benefits of land use compatibility planning extend beyond an airport’s property line and into the surrounding community. Compatible land uses help protect the people who live and work near the airport by moderating potential negative effects. Using the tools in this AC and referenced resources, airports and local jurisdictions can evaluate land use compatibility on an individual basis.
1.5.5.1 Community Awareness of Airport Compatible Land Use Planning. To fully realize the benefits of compatible land use planning, the local community needs to understand the concept of compatibility. Raising
1.5.6.2 An example of compatibility planning benefits at the local and… › 1.5.6.2.1 The new airport and redevelopment of the closed airport was…
awareness in the local community about the effects of incompatibility and the benefits of compatibility can foster a collaborative relationship between the community and the airport in which thoughts and concerns from both perspectives are shared.
1.5.5.2 Reduced Noise Exposure. Planning that reduces or prevents noise-sensitive uses around an airport benefits the community by reducing the number of people exposed to aircraft noise and by improving the quality of life for nearby residents. When noise-sensitive uses already exist around an airport, techniques such as noise abatement and noise mitigation can help reduce the effects of airport noise. 14 CFR Part 150, Airport Noise Compatibility Planning and FAA AC 150/5020-1 also provide valuable guidance and resources.
1.5.5.3 Opportunities for Compatible Community Development. Collaboration between airports, local jurisdictions, and private property owners/developers during long-term planning can identify compatible uses that support economic development on and around an airport. By keeping compatibility concerns in mind during planning phases, stakeholders can be more confident about proposed investment and development, and avoid costly investment in incompatible uses.
1.5.6 Benefits to Local and Regional Jurisdictions.
1.5.6.1 Local and regional jurisdictions are often the owners and sponsors of public airports. Therefore, they have a responsibility to maintain compatibility between the airport and the local community. Coordinated land use compatibility planning greatly benefits local and regional jurisdictions over the long-term. Developing the needed coordination structures and relationships can be challenging, and may require several years of continued effort, but it can result in mutually desired compatible land use plans and development results.
1.5.6.2 An example of compatibility planning benefits at the local and regional level is in Panama City, Florida, with the construction of the Northwest Florida Beaches International Airport (ECP). This airport replaced the former Bay County International Airport.
1.5.6.2.1 The new airport and redevelopment of the closed airport was planned jointly by the State of Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA), Bay County, and the Panama City – Bay County Airport Authority and Industrial District (Airport Authority). The new airport location was largely undeveloped. These entities developed a new land use sector plan to identify the location of planned airport infrastructure and defined an Airfield Compatibility Use Special Treatment Zone (ACUSTZ) around the airport. Under the land use sector plan, incompatible uses (according to FAA criteria) are located outside of the defined ACUSTZ.
1.5.6.3 Compatible land use planning at existing airport locations also… › 1.5.6.3.3 Reduced Mitigation Cost for Incompatible Development.
1.5.6.2.2 Stakeholder efforts (especially the Airport Authority, in cooperation with the state and local jurisdictions) resulted in a coordinated land use plan and framework for development that meets the community’s vision and protects the new airport for planned operations to serve the community.
1.5.6.3 Compatible land use planning at existing airport locations also greatly benefits the local community and their airport facilities. Zoning and development permitting and planning that precludes introduction of incompatible development provides long-term benefits and cost savings to a community (versus the cost of incompatible development). To secure these benefits, airports that are owned by the local land use jurisdiction should ensure effective land use controls are enforced within the airport environs under their jurisdiction. The FAA encourages airports without land use authority within the airport environs to remain vigilant and advocate for compatible development and land use controls whenever opportunities arise.
1.5.6.3.1 Reduced Potential for Complaints. Compatibility planning to minimize noise-sensitive uses near airports is one of the most effective way to reduce complaints from the local community. Planning for mitigation or prevention of noise sensitive uses is the key consideration for effective coordinated land use planning. This applies to both airport development and off-airport land uses in areas affected by aircraft noise.
1.5.6.3.2 Development Revenues and Taxes. In many instances, compatible land uses provide higher property tax payments and demand fewer services. For example, industrial uses often have a higher tax rate than residential uses. Open space and agricultural uses demand fewer services (subject to wildlife attractant evaluation). Evaluation of potential land use options may create a potential win-win situation where development is both more compatible and lucrative for the local municipality. Airport compatibility planning can encourage this kind of development. It can also reduce the potential that infrastructure investment may not be usable when land use compatibility is ultimately considered.
1.5.6.3.3 Reduced Mitigation Cost for Incompatible Development.
It is usually less costly for local jurisdictions to plan and prevent the development of incompatible land uses than to mitigate problems later. Airport owners and operators, as well as other jurisdictions, can be held liable, directly or indirectly, for at least a portion of mitigation costs stemming from effects of incompatible land uses near the airport.
ACRP Report 27, Enhancing Airport Land Use Compatibility, explored the impact of mitigation measures on local
1.6 Consequences of Incompatible Development. › 1.6.2 The effects of airport operations on incompatible land…
municipalities/entities/airports through several case studies. In some cases, airports proposed strategies to reduce hours of operation as a mitigation effort to reduce noise impacts. However, the impact on the economic viability of the airport by limiting its utility may not be acceptable. There are also legal impediments to airport use restrictions for federally obligated airports. Other airports (such as the Fort Lauderdale Executive Airport in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida) have implemented preferential runway and flight track use to move noisy operations away from the most noise-sensitive areas, which can also limit airport utility.
In other cases, airports (such as the Indianapolis International Airport) have implemented noise compatibility programs that include mitigation such as sales assistance, sound insulation, land acquisition, and other measures to mitigate incompatible development.
In conclusion, when incompatible development is not prevented, higher costs are being incurred locally: (1) for property acquisition and other mitigation measures, (2) due to reduced tax revenue from devalued incompatible land use, and (3) local economic impacts due to reduced airport utility and efficiency.
1.6 Consequences of Incompatible Development.
1.6.1 Incompatible land uses such as those that pose physical obstructions, create visual distractions, and attract wildlife can threaten the safety of aircraft operations. They can also affect the safety of persons located near the airport environs. In addition, encroachment of incompatible land uses around airports may create physical constraints to safe and efficient aircraft operations, and challenges for airport capacity expansion or other needed airport development.
1.6.2 The effects of airport operations on incompatible land uses—especially noise impacts on residential areas—can create a negative perception of the airport in the local community. Airport operations can be perceived as generating negative effects on the local community, especially noise disturbances on incompatible land uses. Community opposition generated by off-site airport effects can:
Lead to delays in airport development or require redevelopment;
Constrain capacity expansion;
Restrict airport operations;
Result in more stringent environmental requirements (including greater
environmental impact analysis and mitigation requirements);
Increase public outreach requirements; and
In some cases, lead to litigation.
1.6.4 Off-Airport Economic Considerations. › 1.6.4.2 Coordinated compatible land use planning on the airport and in…
1.6.3 On-Airport Economic Considerations. When incompatible land uses result in community opposition to airport operation and expansion, there are economic consequences, such as project delays, which may result in additional costs to implement a project. For example, a delayed capacity expansion project leads to a variety of costly outcomes. These include persistent aircraft delays; diversion of aircraft to other airports; or, in extreme cases, the need to build a replacement airport at another site.
1.6.4 Off-Airport Economic Considerations.
1.6.4.1 Airports are local economic engines. They stimulate local economic activity, create employment, and generate income for local residents. When incompatible land uses around airports constrain airport use and efficient air service, local and regional jurisdictions cannot realize the full potential of airports to generate positive regional economic impacts. In addition, incompatible land use development can increase the risk of exposure to aviation accidents and expose neighboring residents to adverse environmental effects. These impacts are another cost of incompatible land uses near airports.
1.6.4.2 Coordinated compatible land use planning on the airport and in the airport environs seeks to balance development demands to optimize the benefit of the airport location to the community, and preclude hazards and adverse impacts of incompatible development on local airport and aviation facilities.
2.2.1 Aviation Noise. › 2.2.1.2 Several factors influence the perceived noise impact of…
CHAPTER 2. LAND USE COMPATIBILITY CONCERNS
2.1 Definition of Compatible Land Use. Airport-compatible land uses are those that can coexist with a nearby airport without constraining the safe and efficient operation of the airport, or exposing people living or working nearby to significant environmental impacts. Occasionally, a land use may not be easily classified by type as compatible or incompatible. It may need to be more closely evaluated on a case-by-case basis. Although this chapter outlines the general characteristics of land uses that influence compatibility, individual state, regional, and local sources should be consulted. Various municipalities have adopted guidance that may provide more specific detail on airport land use compatibility issues.
2.2 Evaluation of Airport Land Use Compatibility. There are six core characteristics (or areas of consideration) to evaluate when assessing the compatibility of a specific land use. These include aviation noise, airspace, visual/atmospheric interference, wildlife (includes protected species), protection of people and property, and development density. In addition to assessing a land use against these base characteristics, state and local criteria (if applicable) need to be considered when addressing land use compatibility. Because the FAA has a limited regulatory role in land use planning, the local, regional, and state provisions will likely take precedence in local land use decision making.
2.2.1 Aviation Noise.
2.2.1.1 Aviation noise is a primary concern when addressing airport land use compatibility. Airport operations can create sound levels that produce noise-induced annoyance in communities near airports, as well as specific effects such as speech interference and sleep disturbance. Research regarding aircraft noise has and continues to be conducted within FAA and in the aviation industry. For example, there are numerous ACRP reports such as the following that can provide additional information on aircraft noise:
ACRP Report 27: Enhancing Airport Land Use Compatibility
ACRP 11-01/Topic 01-05 Legal Research Digest 5: Responsibility for
Implementation and Enforcement of Airport Land-Use Zoning Restrictions
ACRP 11-01/Topic 03-01 Legal Research Digest 12: Fair Disclosure of
Airport Impacts in Real Estate Transfers
ACRP Report 15: Aircraft Noise: A Toolkit for Managing Community
Expectations
2.2.1.2 Several factors influence the perceived noise impact of aircraft operations near an airport. Common factors include:
2.2.1 Aviation Noise. › 2.2.1.4 Figure 2-1 illustrates the noise level (dB(A)) of some common…
Proximity of a land use to an airport’s flight patterns;
Residents/occupants noise sensitivity: noise annoyance and interference
to daytime and nighttime activities;
Building materials used to reduce interior noise levels;
The surrounding environment ambient noise level;
Perception and acceptance of the necessity of existing aircraft noise;
The typical day/night hours of aircraft operations;
The number and frequency of aircraft operations; and
The type of aircraft using an airport.
2.2.1.3 Aircraft noise effects are of concern as they can affect the quality of life for residents in their homes, and affect those using or residing in noise-sensitive facilities near airports. These include schools, places of worship, hospitals, parks, and recreational facilities.
2.2.1.4 Figure 2-1 illustrates the noise level (dB(A)) of some common indoor noise sources, and how they compare to common outdoor sound levels.
Figure 2-1. Noise Level of Common Sounds
Source: FAA
Figure 2-1 · page 17Picture of the page from the copy saved here
2.2.2.3 Structure Height – 14 CFR Part 77/Obstruction Evaluation (OE)… › 2.2.2.3.1 The FAA has a system of standards and notification procedures…
2.2.1.5 As described in 14 CFR Part 150, Airport Noise Compatibility Planning, exterior noise levels at or above Day-Night Average Sound Level (DNL) 65 decibels (dB) are considered incompatible with residences and some other noise sensitive land uses. For more information about specific land uses with various levels of aircraft noise, refer to Table 1, Appendix A in 14 CFR Part 150.
2.2.2 Airspace.
2.2.2.1 The most common airport land use compatibility concerns are the need to: maintain unobstructed space for aircraft to maneuver above ground; protect; navigational facilities; and protect existing and future airport capacity. Airspace can be physically obstructed by tall structures and vegetation; visually obstructed by glare, light emissions, dust, smoke, etc.; and atmospherically disrupted by thermal plumes.
2.2.2.2 The following sections discuss these airspace issues and the applicable standards and regulations that protect the nation’s airspace. Appendix B includes a detailed description of land use guidance resources and applicable regulations, some of which are specific to airspace protection.
2.2.2.3 Structure Height – 14 CFR Part 77/Obstruction Evaluation (OE) Processes and Surfaces.
2.2.2.3.1 The FAA has a system of standards and notification procedures to protect the national airspace from physical obstructions. 14 CFR Part
AIRSPACE TERMS
Obstruction: An object of greater height than any of the heights or surfaces presented in Subpart C of 14 CFR Part 77, Standards for Determining Obstructions to Air Navigation or Navigational Aids or Facilities.
Obstacle: An existing object at a fixed geographical location or which may be expected at a fixed location within a prescribed area with reference to which vertical clearance is or must be provided during flight operation.
Approach Minimum: The height above ground at which a pilot must have the airfield in sight to continue on approach to land. To mitigate obstructions that exist in runway approaches, the approach minimums are raised, which can limit the utility of the airport in times of reduced visibility or low cloud cover.
Imaginary Surfaces: Threedimensional airspace areas that surround a runway and are used by the FAA through 14 CFR Part 77 to evaluate whether a structure or vegetation is or could be a hazard to air navigation. The dimensions of the imaginary surfaces are dependent upon individual runway characteristics.
Hazard: An existing or proposed object that the FAA, as a result of an aeronautical study, determines will have a substantial adverse effect upon the safe and efficient use of navigable airspace by aircraft, operation of air navigation facilities, or existing or potential airport capacity. Objects that are considered obstructions under the standards described in Part 77 are presumed hazards to air navigation unless further aeronautical study concludes that the object is not a hazard.
77, “Safe, Efficient Use and Preservation of Navigable Airspace,” establishes standards for determining and defining objects that may pose potential obstructions to air navigation. 14 CFR Part 77 was developed by the FAA to promote safety, and the efficient use and preservation of the navigable airspace. The airspace areas governed by 14 CFR Part 77 are called “imaginary surfaces.” Figure 2-2 illustrates the imaginary surfaces in plan and isometric views.
Figure 2.2 Part 77 Imaginary Surfaces
Source: https://www.ngs.noaa.gov/AERO/oisspec.html
2.2.2.3 Structure Height – 14 CFR Part 77/Obstruction Evaluation (OE)… › 2.2.2.3.4 Figure 2-3 shows an example of a tree that penetrate an…
2.2.2.3.2 When objects (existing or proposed) such as structures or vegetation penetrate the imaginary surfaces, they are considered “obstructions” to air navigation. Objects that are considered obstructions are presumed hazards to air navigation unless further aeronautical study concludes that the object is not a hazard. The FAA has the authority to evaluate obstructions to determine whether they are or could be a “hazard” to air navigation. Federal airport grant assurances require the airport owner/sponsor to take all reasonable actions to remove, mitigate and prevent the introduction of obstructions to airport navigation approaches (see Grant Assurance 20).
2.2.2.3.3 The presence of tall structures near an airport may be a hazard to air navigation. Tall structures include man-made objects (such as buildings, cell/radio/TV/MET towers, and wind farms), natural objects (such as tall trees), and terrain (high ground in airport approaches). Tall structures can reduce the utility of an airport and increase the chances of an aircraft collision with the structures. Aircraft approaching an airport under instrument flight conditions (periods of low visibility, such as low cloud ceilings) follow a defined set of flight procedures. The height of objects along a runway approach course and in the missed approach segment has a direct effect on these procedures. Figure 2-3 illustrates a tall tree that is penetrating a runway approach surface (specific surface as defined by FAA AC 150/5300-13). A tall structure may prompt an increase in the minimum visibility and cloud ceiling criteria that a pilot must follow. These changes may increase the likelihood that aircraft will not be able to land at an airport during inclement weather.
Figure 2-3 · page 21Picture of the page from the copy saved here
2.2.2.3.4 Figure 2-3 shows an example of a tree that penetrate an imaginary approach surface and are thus obstructions. A federally obligated or certificated airport would need address these obstructions, most likely by trimming or removing the tree. If left unmitigated, these obstructions may necessitate FAA actions to ensure the safety of flight, such as increasing runway approach minimums, resulting in the reduced utility and use of the affected runway. Coordination with the FAA Flight Procedures Team is necessary for a complete assessment of instrument runways.
2.2.2.3 Structure Height – 14 CFR Part 77/Obstruction Evaluation (OE)… › 2.2.2.3.7 For proposed development off airport property, and for…
Figure 2-3. Penetration of an Approach Surface by a Tall Tree
2.2.2.3.5 Pursuant to 14 CFR Part 77, proponents of various construction and site alteration projects, on or off airport, must file notice with FAA to determine if the proposed construction or alteration creates a hazard to air navigation.
2.2.2.3.6 During Airport Layout Plan (ALP) review processes, FAA reviews and approves proposed development and construction on federally obligated airports that the FAA finds would materially impact the safe and efficient operation of aircraft at, to, or from the airport or that would adversely affect the safety of people or property on the ground adjacent to the airport as a result of aircraft operations, or that would adversely affect the value of prior federal investments to a significant extent. FAA’s approval to the ALP does not relieve proponents from filing under Part 77.
2.2.2.3.7 For proposed development off airport property, and for proposed development on airport property that does not fall within the FAA’s ALP approval or other regulatory authority, FAA does not approve or disapprove the construction of a structure. Rather, FAA comments on the possible impact to the national airspace system.
Source: ACRP Report 38, Understanding Airspace, Objects, and Their Effects on Airports.
2.2.2.4 New Airports/Landing Fields. › 2.2.2.4.2 FAA Form 7480-1, “Notice of Landing Area Proposal ,” works in…
2.2.2.3.8 The FAA launched a notice criteria tool (https://oeaaa.faa.gov/oeaaa/ external/gisTools/gisAction.jsp?action=showNoNoticeRequiredToolForm) that allows the user (airport sponsor, developer, and local municipality) to input location and dimensional information about a proposed development to determine if they are required to file notice with FAA. If a notice is required, the proponent will submit FAA Form 7460-1, “Notice of Construction or Alteration,” to FAA for review.
2.2.2.3.9 In addition to evaluation of the imaginary surfaces in 14 CFR Part 77, airport and aircraft operators also consider whether obstructions exist to the airspace surfaces created by Terminal Instrument Procedures (TERPS) (see FAA Order 8260.3, United States Standard for Terminal Instrument Procedures (TERPS)).
2.2.2.3.10 The FAA evaluation usually results in one of three determinations on proposed construction:
Determination of Hazard to Air Navigation;
Determination of No Hazard to Air Navigation; or
Determination of No Hazard to Air Navigation with Conditional
Provisions.
2.2.2.3.11 As stated, though developers must submit FAA Form 7460, FAA does not have the authority to stop off-airport construction. Therefore, it is critical for local communities to create the height restrictions that prevent and/or mitigate structures that could be obstructions or hazards to air navigation.
2.2.2.4 New Airports/Landing Fields.
2.2.2.4.1 The airport owner/sponsor needs to consider and evaluate potential local land use impacts when planning and developing a new airport.
2.2.2.4.2 FAA Form 7480-1, “Notice of Landing Area Proposal1,” works in conjunction with 14 CFR Part 157, Notice of Construction, Alteration, Activation and Deactivation to identify potential incompatibility. The regulation requires notification to the FAA 90-days prior to constructing or establishing a new airport (along with construction, alteration, deactivation, or change to the use of an existing airport). As stated in the regulation (14 CFR Part 157.1, “Applicability”), notice is not required for temporary or intermittent use of a site that is not established as an airport. In addition, notice under Part 157 is not applicable to an airport subject to conditions of
1 See https://www.faa.gov/forms/index.cfm/go/document.current/documentNumber/7480-1.
2.2.2 Airspace. › 2.2.2.7 Visual, Atmospheric and Electronic Interference.
a Federal agreement that requires an approved current ALP to be on file with the FAA.
2.2.2.4.3 When completing a Form 7480-1, the project proponent must identify any obstructions (buildings, power line wires, roads, railroads, towers, etc.) within the vicinity of the runway(s). Existing or planned incompatible development such as schools, churches and residential communities that may be impacted by noise, and waste disposal sites within a five-mile radius (see “Wildlife and Bird Attractants,” Section 2.2.4), may affect development. FAA will consider and comment on potential hazards to air navigation due to land use compatibility conflicts. However, the local municipality is ultimately responsible for permitting development through local zoning, and other state or local land use and development ordinances and processes.
2.2.2.5 Military Airspace Areas.
2.2.2.5.1 In addition to the areas defined for civil airports, airport sponsors and communities should consider military installations, ranges, special use air space, military operations areas or military training routes when planning for land use compatibility. The Department of Defense (DOD) implements two primary programs to promote land use compatibility near military installations.
2.2.2.5.2 The Air Installation Compatibility Use Zones (AICUZ) Program. This is a DOD discretionary program designed to promote development compatible with military aircraft operations. However, AICUZ is a land use planning program not a land acquisition or land management program.2
2.2.2.6 The Military Sustainability Program3 through the Office of Local Defense Community Cooperation (OLDCC)4 provides technical and financial assistance to state and local governments to plan and implement strategic plans that support civilian growth and development that is compatible with military operations.5
2.2.2.7 Visual, Atmospheric and Electronic Interference. Airport visibility can be impacted due to various factors. There are some land uses that are located around airports that can potentially impact visibility for aircraft operations and pilots. Maintaining an unobstructed
2 The DOD AICUZ policy (DOD Instruction 4165.57) is available on the Internet at: https://www.esd.whs.mil/Portals/54/Documents/DD/issuances/dodi/416557p.pdf?ver=2019-04-15-094510-673 3 Formally the Joint Land Use Study Program (JLUS)
4 Formally called the Office of Economic Adjustment (OEA) 5 Additional information is available on the Internet at https://oldcc.gov/our-programs/military-installationsustainability
2.2 Evaluation of Airport Land Use Compatibility. › 2.2.3 Visual Obstructions.
view for pilots is a critical element of land use compatibility. In addition to physical obstructions, visual obstructions, electronic interference, or atmospheric disturbances can also pose hazards to flight. Many aircraft operations take place without navigational aids and operate under Visual Flight Rules (VFR). Maintaining visual clarity as the pilot transitions to the visual segment of an Instrument Flight Rule (IFR) flight plan (i.e. transitioning from looking at flight instruments to looking outside the cockpit windows) is critical for pilot control and a safe airport approach. Limiting atmospheric interference (such as the air turbulence from thermal plumes) near airports is critical to maintaining aircraft control. Electronic interference is also a compatible land use consideration. This includes high-energy use, production or transmission facilities, or installations on an institutional, commercial, or industrial property that may affect navigational aids (NAVAIDs). The following sections discuss the concerns related to visual, atmospheric, and electronic interference. ACRP Report 108, Guidebook for Energy Facilities Compatibility with Airports and Airspace, provides research findings on some of these land use concerns.
2.2.3 Visual Obstructions.
Open mining and construction activities can produce dust or other particulate matter
that impact airport visibility. Dust can be picked up by the wind and create a dangerous situation for pilots trying to navigate through the area without instrumentation.
Glare reflecting into and impacting flight approaches to an airport may be caused
by the reflection of light off water bodies and shiny building materials used in proposed or existing development. Glare reflected back to the airport approaches at a particular angle can temporarily impair a pilot’s vision during low-level flight operations, and can therefore be dangerous.
Light emissions are also a potential concern, especially when large light
concentrations shine upward in a flight path or towards the runway environment. These concentrated emissions can adversely affect a pilot’s visual ability during evening hours, storm events, fog/smog, and other periods of reduced visibility.
Other sources of light emissions include lighting in linear patterns that could be
mistaken by pilots for airport operational areas. Furthermore, bright lights can cause momentary visual impairment for pilots as they pass between darkness into well-lit areas. Additionally, certain colors of neon lights (especially red and white) are a concern near airports and military installations because they can interfere with night vision goggles used by pilots.
Large billboards using flashing/changeable message LED-illuminated signs near
airports are a concern because they may distract pilots. Airport and zoning officials should carefully evaluate the potential impacts before approving these proposals. Some state and local jurisdictions have enacted sign and structure lighting use controls/standards (in their zoning and permitting ordinances) to protect against direct, intense light near airport approaches.
2.2.3 Visual Obstructions. › 2.2.3.2 Electronic Interference.
Laser light shows or devices used in amusement parks, stadium events, or other
outdoor productions should be regulated within the airport environs. This includes preventing lasers from being directed towards the flight pattern or airport approaches where they could affect aircraft. In addition, local awareness and law enforcement against inadvertent or malicious direction of lasers towards airport approaches, or at aircraft, is important. More information can be found here: https://www.faa.gov/about/initiatives/lasers/laser_education
Smoke, steam and smog can hinder a pilot’s ability to navigate aircraft due to
reduced visibility. Smog is hard to control because it is common over large cities (it is usually present as a blanket of blurriness), but source-points of smoke and steam can be better controlled. Smoke and/or steam stacks are a typical element of industrial operations or large institutional facilities. Local land use authorities should carefully consider placement of these elements in an airport’s environs.
2.2.3.1 Atmospheric Interference.
Land use planning around an airport should account for impacts to aviation from facilities that produce atmospheric interference, such as thermal exhaust plumes. FAA has determined thermal exhaust plumes can disrupt flight in the vicinity of an airport. The effect can vary greatly depending on several factors: local winds, ambient temperatures, stratification of the atmosphere, size, height, and number of the stack(s) emitting the plume(s), proximity to airport and flight paths, temperature and vertical speed of the effluent, and the size and speed of aircraft. When evaluating the potential impact of the exhaust plume(s), airport owners/operators should consider the traffic pattern, approach and departure corridors, and any existing or planned flight procedures.
To aid review of the potential location of thermal exhaust plume facilities, the FAA contracted with MITRE Corporation to develop a thermal exhaust plume model. The model predicts the size and severity of the plume(s) in order to better understand potential atmospheric interference. The “Exhaust-Plume-Analyzer” is available at https://www.mitre.org/our-impact/intellectual-property/exhaust-plumeanalyzer.
2.2.3.2 Electronic Interference.
Land uses that can produce electronic interference should be carefully considered when located near an airport. Electronic interference can affect navigational aids used by pilots during takeoff and landing. Interference can be direct interference with the navigation signal (i.e. transmitting locally on a frequency that is close to the NAVAID frequency or a harmonic of that frequency) or indirect interference (through adverse reflections, blocking of the signal by structures, or some interfering activity at a location).
2.2.4 Wildlife & Bird Attractants. › 2.2.4.4 ACRP Report 32, Guidebook for Addressing Aircraft/Wildlife…
For example, alternative energy sources are being used near or on airport property. Wind energy generated by turbines is a concern due to adverse effects to radio aids to navigation and radar (as well as the height of the turbines, which can become an obstruction to flight).
2.2.4 Wildlife & Bird Attractants.
2.2.4.1 From 1988 to 2021, reported wildlife strikes killed more than 301 people and destroyed over 298 aircraft worldwide. According to the FAA report, Wildlife Strikes to Civil Aircraft in the United States, 1990-2021, the number of annual wildlife strikes reported to FAA has increased over seven-fold: from 1,851 in 1990 to 15,556 in 2021. From 1990 to 2020, 608 species of birds, 52 species of terrestrial mammals, 44 species of bats, and 29 species of reptiles were identified as struck by aircraft. Over this 32-year period, civilian aircraft strikes in the US resulted in 41 human fatalities. Seventy-seven aircraft were destroyed or damaged beyond repair.
2.2.4.2 Of the wildlife strikes reported to FAA, the majority happened at or below 500 feet above ground level (AGL). Nearly twice as many strikes occurred during the landing (final approach or landing roll) phase of flight than during takeoff run and climb.
2.2.4.3 Based on the preceding, aircraft collisions with wildlife are steadily increasing each year and threaten aviation safety. Factors that contribute to this increasing threat include:
Populations of large bird and mammal species commonly involved in
strikes have increased over the last few decades and are adapting to living in urban environments, including airports.
Older three and four engine aircraft are being replaced with newer,
more efficient two-engine aircraft. In the event of multiple engine ingestion, aircraft with two engines may have vulnerabilities not shared by three or four engine aircraft. Additionally, the newer, quieter engines may not be as easily detected by birds to avoid collision.
2.2.4.4 ACRP Report 32, Guidebook for Addressing Aircraft/Wildlife Hazards at General Aviation Airports, identifies the six most hazardous species or species groups for fixed-wing aircraft having one or two engines weighing less than 59,525 pounds:
Deer
Gulls/Terns
Geese
Ducks
2.2.5.1 The purpose of the Runway Protection Zone (RPZ) is to enhance… › 2.2.5.1.1 Control is preferably exercised through acquisition of…
Raptors
Vultures
2.2.4.5 Minimizing land uses near airports that attract wildlife reduces the likelihood of wildlife strikes. With the majority of strikes occurring at or below 500 feet AGL, it is critical for airport owners/operators and local land use authorities to plan for compatible uses near airports and avoid uses that attract wildlife. There are typically three categories of attractants: food, shelter/cover, and water. Common attractants include certain agricultural or aquaculture activities, architectural features, landscaping, surface mining, waste disposal sites, wastewater treatment facilities, and wetlands. ACRP Report 32 includes a more detailed discussion of the uses considered attractive to wildlife.
2.2.4.6 FAA AC 150/5200-33, Hazardous Wildlife Attractants on or Near Airports, defines wildlife attractants as “any human-made structure, land use practice, or human-made or natural geographic feature that can attract or sustain hazardous wildlife within the landing or departure airspace, or Airport Operations Area (AOA).”
2.2.5 Runway Protection Zones (RPZs).
2.2.5.1 The purpose of the Runway Protection Zone (RPZ) is to enhance the protection of people and property on the ground.6 This is best achieved through airport owner control over RPZs. Airport owner control over RPZs may be achieved through:
Ownership of the RPZ property in fee simple;
Possessing sufficient interest in the RPZ property through easements,
deed restrictions, etc.;
Possessing sufficient land use control authority to regulate land use in
the jurisdiction containing the RPZ;
Possessing and exercising the power of eminent domain over the
property; or
Possessing and exercising permitting authority over proponents of
development within the RPZ (e.g., where the sponsor is a State).
2.2.5.1.1 Control is preferably exercised through acquisition of sufficient property interest and includes clearing RPZ areas (and keeping them clear) of objects
6 H.R. 302 Section 163(d) Amendments to Airport Layout Plans, reinforced the FAA’s authority to “review and approve or disapprove…portions of the plan (or any subsequent revision to the plan)…that would adversely affect the safety of people or property on the ground adjacent to the airport as a result of aircraft operations.”
2.2.5.5 Existing Incompatible Land Uses. › 2.2.5.5.2 Table 2-2 outlines expectations of airport sponsors for…
and activities that would impact the safety of people and property on the ground. The FAA recognizes, however, that land use compatibility within RPZs is often complicated by land ownership, environmental, geographical and other considerations.
2.2.5.2 RPZs are trapezoidal in shape, centered about the extended runway centerline, and typically located off each runway end. The full standards and dimensions for RPZs are in FAA Advisory Circular 150/5300-13, Airport Design.
2.2.5.3 Expectations of Airport Sponsors.
2.2.5.4 The FAA requires all federally obligated airport sponsors to comply with FAA Grant Assurances. This includes, but is not limited to, Assurance 21, Compatible Land Use. Sponsors should take appropriate measures to protect against, remove, or mitigate land uses that introduce incompatible development within RPZs. For projects proposed by the sponsor, such as runway extensions or new runways, that would result in moving the RPZ into an area that has incompatible land uses, the FAA expects the sponsor to have or secure sufficient control of the RPZ, ideally through fee simple ownership, including any off-airport property within the RPZ.
2.2.5.5 Existing Incompatible Land Uses.
2.2.5.5.1 The FAA expects airport sponsors to seek all possible opportunities to eliminate, reduce, or mitigate existing incompatible land uses. Examples may include land acquisition, land exchanges, right-of-first-refusal to purchase, agreements with property owners on land uses, easements, or other such measures. The FAA also expects sponsors to actively consider and evaluate available options anytime there is an ALP update or master plan update, and to be vigilant for any other opportunities that may arise from time to time (especially to purchase land) to eliminate or minimize existing incompatibilities. The FAA expects airport sponsors to document their efforts to demonstrate they are complying with relevant FAA Grant Assurances.
2.2.5.5.2 Table 2-2 outlines expectations of airport sponsors for existing incompatible land uses within RPZs.
2.2.5 Runway Protection Zones (RPZs). › 2.2.5.6 Proposed Incompatible Land Uses.
Table 2-1. Expectations of Airport Sponsors - Existing Incompatible Land Uses
Type of Land Use
Control
Expectations of Airport Sponsors
If the airport sponsor owns the land
Because the sponsor has total land use control, the FAA considers it a reasonable expectation that the sponsor will establish and enforce the necessary zoning controls or lease terms to enable it to address existing incompatible land uses when the opportunity arises.
(Please refer to Appendix F for an example airport land use compatibility overlay zoning ordinance.)
Property is off-airport, but the sponsor has land use authority or the local jurisdiction and land use regulatory authority is owned by the same governing body
Because the sponsor has at least some influence over land use control, the FAA considers it a reasonable expectation that the sponsor will seek to establish the necessary zoning controls to enable it to address existing incompatible land uses when the opportunity arises.
If the sponsor has no land use control (i.e., RPZ land falls in another jurisdiction)
Even though the sponsor has no land use control, the FAA still considers it a reasonable expectation that the sponsor will actively seek opportunities to establish the necessary zoning controls to enable it to address existing incompatible land uses when the opportunity arises.
FAA will consider financial assistance to a public-sector airport sponsor for land acquisition even if the airport sponsor has no land use control, but only if the sponsor demonstrates that the airport sponsor is taking all appropriate steps available to enhance control and mitigate existing risks.
2.2.5.5.3 The FAA will consider requests from eligible airport sponsors for AIP funding, in accordance with the AIP handbook, to help secure ownership or land use control if it helps eliminate existing incompatible land uses, and prevent future ones. FAA also expects airport sponsors to consider RPZ protection an “airside need,” a high priority for financial planning purposes.
2.2.5.6 Proposed Incompatible Land Uses. The FAA expects the airport sponsor to take active steps to prevent or mitigate proposed incompatible land uses. The FAA expects the airport sponsor to actively seek opportunities to prevent or mitigate risks associated with proposed incompatible land uses within the RPZ. The FAA expects the Airport Sponsor to secure control of land within the RPZ if a sponsor initiated project results in incompatible land use within the newly defined RPZ. This is expected, regardless of the funding source(s) involved. Sponsors should actively monitor conditions and object publicly to proposed incompatible land uses, and to make it a high priority (financially or otherwise) to acquire land or otherwise establish land use controls that
prevent incompatible uses. The FAA expects airport sponsors to document their efforts so that they can demonstrate that the airport is complying with its grant assurances. Table 2-3 summarizes expectations of airport sponsors for new/proposed incompatible land uses within RPZs.
Table 2-2. Expectations of Airport Sponsors - New Incompatible Land Uses
Type of Land Use
Control
Expectations of Airport Sponsors
If the airport sponsor owns the land
Because the sponsor has total land use control, the FAA expects that the sponsor will establish all necessary protections to prevent new incompatible land uses.
Property is off-airport, but the sponsor has land use authority or the local jurisdiction and land use regulatory authority is owned by the same governing body
FAA expects the sponsor to take all appropriate steps available to establish and exercise zoning controls necessary to prevent any new incompatible land uses. 7
The FAA recognizes that the standard of “appropriate action, to the extent reasonable” does not mean in this case that the sponsor can always prevail. Rather, the FAA expects the sponsor to demonstrate and document a reasonable effort.
If the sponsor has no land use control (i.e., RPZ land falls in another jurisdiction)
Even if the sponsor has no land use control, FAA still expects the sponsor to actively pursue and consider all possible steps to secure land necessary to prevent any new incompatible land uses.
The FAA recognizes that the standard of “appropriate action, to the extent reasonable” may not succeed. Even so, the FAA expects the sponsor to demonstrate and document a reasonable effort.
FAA expects the airport sponsor to adopt a strong public stance to oppose incompatible land uses and to communicate the purpose of the RPZ and associated risks to the proponent, and to actively consider measures such as land acquisition, land exchanges, right-of-first-refusal to purchase, agreements with property owners regarding land uses, or other such measures.
For a privately owned reliever in such circumstances, the FAA will still consider helping with land acquisition, but the sponsor needs to demonstrate a viable long-term plan that these measures will ultimately protect the airport against encroachment.
7 This applies if the new incompatible land use is a new development. If it is an existing land use that will now fall within a modified RPZ, then zoning is not a sufficient means of control. The FAA expects the sponsor to secure control through either fee-simple acquisition or through acquisition of easements.
2.2.5.7 Airport Sponsor’s Alternatives Evaluation Process. › 2.2.5.7.2 Potential new incompatible land uses within an RPZ might be…
2.2.5.6.1 Additionally, if the airport sponsor is the project proponent (e.g., proposed project is a runway extension or new runway) the FAA expects the airport sponsor to secure ownership or easements sufficient to control all land uses within the RPZs.
2.2.5.6.2 FAA will consider requests from eligible airport sponsors for AIP funding, in accordance with the AIP Handbook, to help prevent new incompatible land uses. However, FAA also expects sponsors to identify these opportunities early enough for land acquisition at a reasonable cost (i.e., not waiting until there is a proposed development that artificially increases the cost of the land). If the airport sponsor acquires land within an RPZ, but does not intend on clearing land uses other than those described in Section 2.2.5.7.3, an Alternatives Evaluation is required.
2.2.5.7 Airport Sponsor’s Alternatives Evaluation Process.
2.2.5.7.1 As stated, the FAA expects the airport sponsor to take active steps (in accordance with Grant Assurance 21) to prevent or mitigate any new incompatible land use within the RPZ. Because Assurance 21 requires sponsors to take “appropriate action, to the extent reasonable,” the FAA expects sponsors to proactively identify a full range of alternatives and prepare a sufficient evaluation to be able to draw a conclusion about what is “appropriate and reasonable.” The evaluation may include the development of a long-term, strategic land acquisition plan.
2.2.5.7.2 Potential new incompatible land uses within an RPZ might be caused by one or more circumstances. Some of these circumstances result from airport sponsor proposed projects, including (but not limited to):
An airfield project (e.g., runway extension, runway shift, or new runway);8
A change in the critical design aircraft that increases the RPZ dimension; or
A new or revised instrument approach procedure that increases the RPZ dimension.
Other proposed projects that could potentially introduce new incompatible land uses within an RPZ, but not typically proposed by the airport sponsor include (but not limited to):
Roadway construction, relocation, or improvements
A local development proposal in the RPZ; or
8 The FAA would not support incompatible uses in RPZs for new airports or new runways.
2.2.5.8 Items Typically Included in the Airport Sponsor’s Alternatives… › 2.2.5.8.2 The following items are typically necessary for the FAA to…
Other circumstances.
2.2.5.7.3 The FAA has higher expectations for the airport sponsor to mitigate potential incompatible land uses within the RPZ when the introduction of the incompatible land use is the result of an airport sponsor-initiated project (regardless of funding source).The sponsor should submit an alternatives evaluation to the FAA unless the land use is permissible. These are the permissible land uses requiring no further evaluation:
Farming that meets airport design clearance standards in FAA AC 150/5300-13 and guidance as outlined in AC 150/5200-33;
Irrigation channels meeting the standards of AC 150/5200-33 and FAA/USDA manual, Wildlife Hazard Management at Airports;
Airport service roads, as long as they are not public roads and are directly controlled by the airport operator;
Underground facilities, as long as they meet other design criteria, such as Runway Safety Area (RSA) standards, as applicable;
NAVAIDs and aviation facilities, such as equipment for airport facilities considered fixed-by-function in regard to the RPZ; or
Above-ground fuel tanks associated with back-up generators for unstaffed NAVAIDs.
2.2.5.8 Items Typically Included in the Airport Sponsor’s Alternatives Evaluation.
2.2.5.8.1 Airport sponsors should submit an alternatives evaluation to FAA early in the planning process for any on-airport development within the RPZ. When the proposed land use development is not on airport property, the sponsor should engage and coordinate with the Airports District Office (ADO) as soon as they are aware of proposed development. The sponsor should begin the process of evaluating alternatives within 30 days of becoming aware of the development within the RPZ.
2.2.5.8.2 The following items are typically necessary for the FAA to assess a sponsor’s alternatives evaluation. The FAA acknowledges, however, that the scope of the analysis will likely vary depending on the size of the airport, the type/number of operations, and any other unique considerations. The airport sponsor is encouraged to meet with the FAA before conducting the evaluation to discuss the appropriate level of evaluation needed.
Sponsor’s statement of the purpose and need of the proposed action (airport project, land use change or development).
Identification of any other interested parties and proponents.
Identification of any federal, state and local transportation agencies involved.
Analysis of sponsor control of the land within the RPZ.
2.2.5.9 FAA Assessment of the Airport Sponsor’s Alternatives Evaluation. › 2.2.5.9.3 It is not the FAA’s decision whether the sponsor should…
Summary of all alternatives considered including:
o Alternatives that preclude introducing the incompatible land use
within the RPZ (e.g., zoning action, purchase, and design alternatives such as the implementation of declared distances, displaced thresholds, shifting the runway, shortening the runway, raising minimums)
o Alternatives that minimize the impact of the land use in the RPZ
(e.g. routing a new roadway through less of the RPZ, etc.)
o Alternatives that mitigate risk to people and property on the ground
(e.g., tunneling, depressing and/or protecting a roadway through the RPZ, implementing operational measures to mitigate any risks, etc.)
Narrative discussion and exhibits or figures depicting the alternative.
Rough order of magnitude cost estimates associated with each alternative, regardless of potential funding sources.
A practicability assessment based on the feasibility of the alternative in terms of cost, constructability, operational impacts, and other factors.
2.2.5.9 FAA Assessment of the Airport Sponsor’s Alternatives Evaluation.
2.2.5.9.1 The FAA expects the airport sponsor to submit their alternatives evaluation to the ADO (or Airports Regional Office for regions that do not have ADOs). The ADO will review and provide a response to the evaluation. However, for any unusual cases, the ADO will consult with the Regional Office and, if necessary, FAA’s Airport Planning and Environmental Division (APP-400) for FAA Headquarters review. Depending on the circumstances, APP-400 will also include the Airport Engineering Division (AAS-100) and the Compliance Division (ACO-100) in Headquarters review.
2.2.5.9.2 The ADO must assess the sponsor’s alternatives evaluation and recommendations for any ALP change or airspace determination that involve new incompatible use or development within an airport RPZ. The ADO’s assessment ensures that the sponsor provides a comprehensive evaluation that includes the appropriate items from Section 2.2.5.8.2, and that the sponsor has met the expectations described in Table 2-2 or Table 2-3, as applicable.
2.2.5.9.3 It is not the FAA’s decision whether the sponsor should accede to a new incompatible land use. Rather, FAA’s assessment is limited to whether the airport has made an adequate effort to pursue and give full consideration to
appropriate and reasonable alternatives. The FAA will not approve or disapprove the airport sponsors preferred alternative. The FAA only evaluates whether the sponsor has completed an acceptable level of alternatives analysis before the sponsor makes the decision to allow or not allow the proposed land use within the RPZ; however, Section 163 of H.R. 302 reinforced the FAA’s authority to review portions of the ALP that would adversely affect the safety of people and property within the RPZ. In some cases, coordination with other federal, state, or local agencies may be necessary. In other cases, the sponsor may be bound by other legal strictures (e.g., within environmental determination documents, deed covenants, special conditions within grants, etc.).
2.2.6 Local Regulation of Concentrations of People (Development Density). › 2.2.6.3 Concentrated populations increase the risk for severe…
2.2.5.9.4 If the FAA agrees that the sponsor’s alternative analysis is acceptable, then the FAA’s ALP approval, if any, or airspace determination must include the following statement:
“This ALP approval (and/or airspace determination) does not constitute FAA approval of incompatible land uses within any Runway Protection Zone. Nor does it relieve the airport sponsor of its obligations under Assurance 21. Rather, it represents a conclusion by the FAA that the sponsor conducted a sufficient level of analysis to make its own decision about the risks associated with the proposal.”
2.2.5.9.5 If the FAA determines that the sponsor’s alternatives analysis is insufficient, then the FAA will provide the appropriate feedback and guidance.
2.2.6 Local Regulation of Concentrations of People (Development Density).
2.2.6.1 The number of people concentrated in an area near an airport is the land use characteristic tied most closely to the consequences of aircraft accidents. The most direct method of reducing the potential severity of an aircraft accident to the people and property in proximity to an airport is to limit the maximum number of structures and/or people in areas close to an airport. Limiting the number of structures around airports may also reduce the severity of an aircraft accident to passengers on board the aircraft.
2.2.6.2 There are two types of accidents that have the potential to impact land uses near the airport. One is an accident where the aircraft is descending, but is flying largely under directional control of the pilot. The other is one involving a loss of control. Limits on usage density—the number of structures/people per acre—are most effective when they account for both types of potential aircraft accidents.
2.2.6.3 Concentrated populations increase the risk for severe consequences in the event of an uncontrolled accident at that location. The risk is even greater when the land use includes occupants with limited mobility or who need
supervision or assistance in evacuating, such as hospital patients or schoolchildren.
2.2.6 Local Regulation of Concentrations of People (Development Density). › 2.2.6.5 In general, the lower the density, the greater the level of…
2.2.6.4 Limiting the average usage density over a site, coupled with designated areas of open space, reduces the risks associated with either type of accident. Land use compatibility policies need to address both of these circumstances. In some instances, states have published airport land use compatibility measures, including allowable density levels. Figure 2-8 illustrates the densities within the 2016 California Airport Land Use Planning Handbook, which is often the most widely referenced document for land use compatibility densities. For military airports, safety recommendations are included as part of the AICUZ (Air Installation Compatibility Use Zones) program (see Section 2.2.2.5.2).
Figure 2-8. Typical Use Densities
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Persons per Acre
Common Land Uses
Typical Use Densities (Persons Per Acre)
Source: Based on California Airport Land Use Planning Handbook, 2011.
Figure 2-8 · page 35Picture of the page from the copy saved here
2.2.6.5 In general, the lower the density, the greater the level of compatibility a use will have with aircraft operations. An airport and the local community should evaluate density near an airport, taking into account the density of the overall area. For example, if a GA airport is located well outside of a developed area and there are expanses of open space that border the airport, it is important to establish land use controls that will maintain this open area and establish low permissible densities for the area around the airport. In comparison, in most developed areas where large amounts of development
CHAPTER 2. Land Use Compatibility Concerns › 2.3 Compatibility of Land Use Types near the Airport.
may have already taken place and higher residential densities and nonresidential intensities are more likely, the goal would be to require any ensuing development to be at or below the current levels. This essentially focuses on making the current situation no worse. Figure 2.9 illustrates some general levels of density – high, medium, and low - as it relates to residential land uses.
Figure 2-9. Residential Samples of Densities
2.2.6.6 In instances where structures and development can be relocated on a parcel to allow for optimal open space within the approach and departure areas of an airport, the more compatible a use will be with aircraft operations. Maintaining or creating open space within areas of aircraft movement is critical, as it provides clear areas where aircraft can land in the event of an emergency.
Figure 2-9 · page 36Picture of the page from the copy saved here
2.3 Compatibility of Land Use Types near the Airport. In community planning documents, land uses are generally classified into one of seven major categories. These include residential, commercial, industrial and mining, institutional, infrastructure/utilities/energy production, agricultural and open space, and parks and recreational land use. Table 2-4 depicts the seven major categories of land uses and the associated potential level of impact. A general discussion of each land use type is provided in the following sections. Because individual communities can categorize these in different ways, it will be important for specific communities to tailor their use of this information to their specific needs.
Table 2-3. Example Land Use Compatibility Chart with Major Catgories and Potential
Level of Impact
Land Uses Noise Sensitivity
Concentration
of
People
Tall Structures
Visual Obstructions
Wildlife &
Bird Attractants
Residential Uses I I P P P
2.3.1 Residential Uses. › 2.3.1.2 Developments for temporary or short-term occupancy (not…
Land Uses Noise Sensitivity
Concentration
of
People
Tall Structures
Visual Obstructions
Wildlife &
Bird Attractants
Commercial Activities I I P P P
Industrial and Mining Activities N P P P P
Institutional Activities I I I I I
Infrastructure/Utilities/ Energy Production Activities
N N I I P
Agriculture and Open Space Activities N N N I I
Parks and Recreation Activities I P P P P
Key: I = Impact P = Possible Impact N = No Impact
2.3.1 Residential Uses.
2.3.1.1 A residential use includes dwellings used to house people as their residence/domicile. Typically, residential use includes single-family homes (detached, attached, condominium) and multifamily developments such duplexes through four-plex, apartment complexes, dormitories, transient housing, and mobile home parks. As the nation’s population continues to increase, residential development often encroaches upon what was once open space surrounding airport property. Some airports are now completely surrounded by residential development. In planning for new residential development in proximity to an airport, local interagency coordination is vital, especially within an airport’s approaches, departure areas, and areas of greater noise exposure.
2.3.1.2 Developments for temporary or short-term occupancy (not permanent residence or domicile) such as hotels, motels, and campgrounds are considered commercial land use. Although these uses may differ from conventional residential use and housing in their sensitivity to noise, they pose similar concerns relative to concentrations of people (also see commercial uses in Section 2.3.2, below).
2.3.2 Commercial Uses. › 2.3.2.2 Sample factors to consider when determining compatibility of a…
2.3.1.3 In instances where residential uses cannot be prevented near an airport, there are techniques that can be used to minimize or mitigate the effects of such incompatible development. A few of these include:
Placement of residential structures on the outer edge of a parcel rather than directly underneath a runway’s approach or departure path outside of RPZs (see Section 2.2 for further information).
Disclosing noise impact and discouraging residential development within 65 dB DNL noise contour.
Decreasing the allowable density in residential uses near an airport.
Minimizing the development of multi-family residential units (apartments, etc.).
Requiring developers to use sound-insulating building materials to minimize aircraft noise effects.
Purchasing vacant property within runway noise contours that are under threat of residential development.
2.3.2 Commercial Uses.
2.3.2.1 Land uses classified as commercial involve the sale of products or services for profit. The most common land use compatibility issues with commercial uses are safety impacts to the commercial use, visual interference, and wildlife attractant impacts to aircraft and the airport. Commercial uses are specifically discouraged from RPZs due to the density issues that they can pose. Using the tools in this AC and other referenced resources, the compatibility of a specific commercial use may be evaluated on an individual airport basis. Because there are a wide variety of commercial uses, the actual activities onsite often require special review and evaluation by local planners to determine compatibility with airport influence areas. Because diverse compatibility issues can arise between an airport and nearby commercial land uses, it is difficult to summarize the benefits or detriments created by commercial development.
2.3.2.2 Sample factors to consider when determining compatibility of a commercial use include, but are not limited to:
The time of operation and occupancy (e.g., all day, evenings only, 24
hours, etc.).
The size of the commercial buildings and their lighting, height and
facility characteristics (e.g., boutique shop, big-box stores, mega-mall, etc.).
Anticipated occupancy (e.g., a few employees, waves of customers,
sustained large crowds, etc.).
2.3.3 Industrial and Mining Uses. › 2.3.3.3 Some of the main concerns typically associated with industrial…
Method of trash containment for large commercial uses (e.g., evaluate
if wildlife attractant, holds hazardous materials, or benign).
Parking lot lighting patterns for large commercial uses (e.g., use of
LED, shielding, zoning allowances, etc.).
Outdoor uses (e.g., assembly of people, patios where aircraft noise may
be an issue).
Amount of open space around the structures (e.g., approach clearances,
parking lots, green space, etc.).
2.3.3 Industrial and Mining Uses.
2.3.3.1 Industrial development can include materials processing, materials assembly, product manufacturing, and storage of finished products. The most common land use compatibility issues with industrial uses are height of structures, visual interferences, and wildlife attractant impacts to aircraft and the airport. Industrial/manufacturing uses are specifically discouraged from RPZs due to the assembly of persons/occupancy density issues that they can pose. Using the tools in this AC and other referenced resources, the compatibility context and specific use may be evaluated on an individual airport basis. A range of uses are classified in this land use type from heavy manufacturing plants with tall smoke stacks to a small product distribution center. Historically, industrial parks were composed solely of industrial uses, however now they often include a mix of industrial businesses, manufacturing facilities, office parks, and research and development complexes within the same geographic area. Occasionally, hotels, restaurants, and retail activities develop along the fringes of industrial parks to provide necessary support facilities and stimulate economic development within these areas. Light manufacturing or research and development facilities are often less of a concern with reduced staff levels and partial, traditional hours of operation.
2.3.3.2 Mining and natural resource extraction (minerals, petroleum, natural gas, etc.) can cause visual obstructions with the generation of dust at the extraction sites, as well as intense lighting used to illuminate areas for night work. Tall structures can also be a concern, depending on the type of equipment used. FAA AC 150/5100-20, Guidance for Oil and Gas Development at Obligated Airports, describes existing FAA requirements concerning oil and gas development on or nearby airports.
2.3.3.3 Some of the main concerns typically associated with industrial and/or mining uses include:
Number of employees on site;
Hours of operation (manufacturing plants that run 24 hours a day with
three shifts);
2.3.5 Infrastructure/Utilities/Energy Production Uses. › 2.3.5.1 Infrastructure activities include a variety of land uses such…
Tall towers or stacks that can obstruct flight;
The presence of smoke or steam from processing facilities;
Thermal plumes that can cause turbulence;
Intense lighting around facilities;
Dust generation;
Storage of flammable materials; and
Water retention/detention areas.
2.3.4 Institutional Uses.
2.3.4.1 Institutional uses include educational facilities (preschool through college), health care facilities (hospitals, clinics, nursing homes, assisted living facilities), and religious assemblies (churches, tabernacles, mosques). Because the majority of these facilities are used by individuals who may not be able to respond to an emergency situation without assistance, they are generally considered to have a lower level of compatibility and are discouraged in proximity to an airport.
2.3.4.2 The most common land use compatibility issues with institutional uses are safety and noise impacts to institutional uses. Institutional uses are specifically discouraged from RPZs due to the density issues that they can pose. The largest difference between institutional uses and all other land use types is based on the assumption that many of the people who utilize an institutional use may need additional assistance to respond to an aircraft emergency, including the evacuation of a facility. An example of this issue is evacuating patients from a hospital. These users are most often present in concentrations, which makes it even more difficult to respond to an emergency situation.
2.3.4.3 In addition to concerns regarding evacuation and other emergency response procedures, institutional uses are typically more sensitive to aircraft noise. Disruption in a classroom, hospital, or worship environment may be considered an impact to students, patients, and congregations.
2.3.5 Infrastructure/Utilities/Energy Production Uses.
2.3.5.1 Infrastructure activities include a variety of land uses such as above ground utilities, cellular communication towers, water towers, water treatment plants, wastewater treatment plants, streets and highways, sanitary landfills, and energy production uses such as wind turbines and solar panels. One of the most common land use compatibility issues with infrastructure uses is the height impacts to aircraft, such as cellular towers, wind turbines, and large-scale power transmission structures that can be hundreds of feet tall and can create an obstruction to flight in their vicinity. Depending on their
2.3.5 Infrastructure/Utilities/Energy Production Uses. › 2.3.5.4 State and local planning and design of infrastructure…
location and height, proponents may need to submit an aeronautical study to the FAA through the 7460 Form –Notice of Proposed Construction or Alteration (see Section 2.2.2.3 for additional information on the 7460 Form). As stated earlier, through this process, the FAA has the opportunity to find the proposed use either a hazard or not a hazard to air navigation, recommend appropriate marking and lighting to make objects visible, identify obstacles on aeronautical charts, and revise published data and issue a Notice to Airmen (NOTAM) if necessary.
2.3.5.2 In addition to height concerns, some of these uses can be attractive to wildlife (such as landfills and water treatment plants). This could increase the risk of wildlife strikes if placed within the approach or departure corridors or traffic pattern around an airport. Electronic interference can be generated by uses such as wind turbines that can impact radio aids to navigation and RADAR signals when clustered together in large concentrations. Industrial uses emitting thermal plumes above their smoke/exhaust stack heights may impact safe flight near airports. The aeronautical impacts in addition to the height of structures are still being discovered that may warrant compatible land use evaluation.
2.3.5.3 Limiting concentrations of people associated with transportation infrastructure in proximity to an airport is ideal. When possible, limiting transportation modes within the approach or departure zones can minimize the potential for catastrophic effects should an aircraft incident occur. Because many airports are already located in developed areas, citing a specific distance between an airport and these other modes becomes unrealistic, as they may already exist in proximity to the airfield. Although some of these uses may not be able to be relocated, techniques such as down shielding lighting along highways and railroads can help to mitigate some of their impact (visual obstructions). Additional techniques such as adding roadway signage alerting vehicles to the RPZ, or prohibiting stopping and standing in the RPZ is recommended. Airports should also work with their local transportation department to avoid locating stoplights near the edge of the RPZ to prevent queues from building into the RPZ. The goal is to minimize the overall impact based upon the various issues discussed in this chapter (visual obstructions, concentrations of people, etc.).
2.3.5.4 State and local planning and design of infrastructure development away from airport operating environs is encouraged. Due to the wide variety of land uses that fall within the infrastructure/utilities/energy production category, there are a number of concerns related to infrastructure land uses that vary depending on the individual use at a location near an airport. Therefore, FAA recommends that each proposed development or improvement of infrastructure within the vicinity of an airport be assessed for compatibility issues prior to construction.
2.3.7 Parks and Recreation/Entertainment Uses, including Sports Arenas. › 2.3.7.3 Another factor to consider is the density of the use.
2.3.6 Agriculture and Open Spaces.
2.3.6.1 Agriculture and open space activities are most commonly defined as any use related to farming, including both man-made and naturally occurring water resources. The most common land use compatibility issues with agriculture and open space uses are wildlife attractant impacts to aircraft and the airport. These uses are often perceived as the most compatible of land use types near an airport due to the limited populations associated with them and reduced noise sensitivity. However, they can have significant wildlife management concerns.
2.3.6.2 Certain crops can be very attractive to wildlife for both food sources as well as roosting habitats. The USDA bulletin, “Plants Attractive to Wildlife,” provides a list of cultivated plants that can attract wildlife. Wildlife can be attracted to specific cultivated plants as a food source and may be attracted to plants for shelter. Agricultural activities are not uncommon near airports, especially in the Midwestern and plains states. Open water such as rivers, lakes, and detention/retention ponds can be attractive to wildlife and are cause for concern.
2.3.7 Parks and Recreation/Entertainment Uses, including Sports Arenas.
2.3.7.1 A wide variety of public and commercial recreational land uses can be classified here, including (as but a few illustrative examples) public parks, public use and access national monuments, wildlife refuges, wilderness areas, community tennis centers, drive-in theaters, and professional race tracks. These uses typically take place outdoors, although some take place indoors such as skating rinks, health clubs, and sports arenas. The most common land use compatibility issues with parks and recreation uses are safety impacts to recreational uses. Due to the wide variety of uses, development sizes can play an important role in the level of compatibility. For example, a neighborhood park that has open space would typically be considered more compatible than an aquatic center that has large areas for parking and limited open space. Uses such as golf courses that include water or wildlife habitat features need to be prevented or mitigated for any potential wildlife attractants that may pose a hazard to a nearby airport. Public areas that are used for educational or performance purposes may also be noise sensitive uses.
2.3.7.2 In addition to the size and use of the development, lighting can be a concern for recreational uses because associated parking lots are often lit with highdensity lights. Moreover, facilities that are used at night such as baseball fields and tennis courts are also illuminated with bright lights that can create visual challenges for pilots.
2.3.7.3 Another factor to consider is the density of the use. For example, a casino will often have a greater density because customers and staff occupy the
facility 24 hours a day, compared to a golf course which has a larger footprint but is operational only during daylight hours and at a lower density.
3.1 Overview of Stakeholders. › 3.1.3 Federal and state agencies develop guidelines and recommendations…
CHAPTER 3. ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF COMPATIBLE LAND USE STAKEHOLDERS
3.1 Overview of Stakeholders.
3.1.1 This Chapter discusses the roles and responsibilities for land use compatibility as they relate to the multiple levels of government and interested community groups involved in planning for land development around airports. Airport land use compatibility planning requires coordination among diverse groups, including public agencies, airport leaders, and community members.
3.1.2 The responsibility for airport land use compatibility planning does not normally rest with one agency or a single group. The tasks, authority, and responsibilities are divided between federal, state, regional, and local groups and organizations. In addition, the airport influence area will often encompass several jurisdictions that may or may not have a sponsor or ownership interest in the airport. Airport and community planners have unique stakeholder relationships locally that can be used to develop effective coordination agreements for their compatible land use planning efforts (also see Chapter 4).
3.1.3 Federal and state agencies develop guidelines and recommendations to protect airports and the associated airspace, while local government officials, planners, airport sponsors, and community members implement and enforce the land use programs. Other groups, including regional transportation agencies, local economic development corporations and transit services, all make plans and financial investments that drive land development and land use patterns. Table 3-1 is a more complete listing of the various stakeholders.
Table 3-1. Summary of Airport Related Stakeholders
Section Category Description
3.2 Local Government
Stakeholders
Elected and appointed bodies from cities, villages, townships and counties
Planning and zoning officials
Regional/Metropolitan Agencies (transportation, economic development, planning coordination)
3.3 Airport Related
Stakeholders
Governing Body / Airport Sponsor
Airport Manager
Airport Users (airlines, FBOs, local pilots)
3.4 Non-Aviation Stakeholders
Shipping companies
Rental car companies
Cargo handling services
3.2 Local Government Stakeholders. › 3.2.2 Local land use decisions that promote airport land use…
Section Category Description
Local residents living near airports
Chamber of Commerce
Civic and volunteer organizations
Community leaders
Business travelers
Local business owners
Real Estate and Development Interests
3.5 State Government
Stakeholders
State Aeronautical Departments
Department of Agriculture
Department of Economic Development
Department of Environmental Quality
Department of Historic Preservation
Department of Community Health and Human Resources
3.6 Federal Government
Stakeholders
Department of Transportation (DOT) Federal Aviation Administration (FAA)
Army Corps of Engineers
Department of Defense
Department of the Interior
Department of Transportation
Environmental Protection Agency
Federal Communication Commission
Department of Agriculture
3.2 Local Government Stakeholders.
3.2.1 Whether it is passing a local airport zoning ordinance or coordinating with nearby municipalities that may be affected by airport operations within their jurisdiction, numerous planning and permitting entities and individuals in local government are in a position to regulate land use. They can also be stakeholders in land use compatibility planning at an airport. In fact, the responsibility for implementing land use compatibility plans rests with local officials and authorities to enact and enforce land use development and zoning regulations. Airport stakeholders can work with these individuals and bodies, as well as with planning and zoning staff, to provide input on land use compatibility through the comprehensive planning process that will help with decisions about zoning districts, densities, and airport overlay zones.
3.2.2 Local land use decisions that promote airport land use compatibility have a bearing on continuing federal support of needed airport improvements. Federal grant dollars come
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 336 passages shown