Order 6820.14 Siting Criteria For Distance Measuring Equipment
This order provides guidance to personnel engaged in the siting of Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Distance Measuring Equipment (DME). This order also provides guidance to FAA personnel responsible for protecting and mitigating possible adverse effects on the DME Signal-in-Space (SIS) from proposed construction around the DME facility. This order provides guidelines that are used in conjunction with a thorough understanding of DME facility operations to arrive at the optimum facility location. The guidelines and criteria in this order are designed to be applicable to all installations, but are not required to be applied retroactively to existing installations. Application of these guidelines may be used to reduce the real estate requirements for certain existing installations. Deviations from these criteria may be permitted provided the results of a site-specific analysis indicate that operationally acceptable performance will be achieved with such deviations in place.
FAA Order 6820.14
SITING CRITERIA
FOR DISTANCE MEASURING
EQUIPMENT
Date: 10/19/2023
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION
Distribution: Electronic Initiated By: AJM-3231
Distribution: Electronic Initiated By: AJM-3231
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION ORDER
6820.14
Effective date: 10/19/2023
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION
SUBJ: SITING CRITERIA FOR DISTANCE MEASURING EQUIPMENT
This order provides guidance to personnel engaged in the siting of Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Distance Measuring Equipment (DME). This order also provides guidance to FAA personnel responsible for protecting and mitigating possible adverse effects on the DME Signal-in-Space (SIS) from proposed construction around the DME facility.
This order provides guidelines that are used in conjunction with a thorough understanding of DME facility operations to arrive at the optimum facility location. The guidelines and criteria in this order are designed to be applicable to all installations, but are not required to be applied retroactively to existing installations. Application of these guidelines may be used to reduce the real estate requirements for certain existing installations. Deviations from these criteria may be permitted provided the results of a site-specific analysis indicate that operationally acceptable performance will be achieved with such deviations in place.
REBECCA Digitally signed
by REBECCA ELLEN ELLEN GUY
… GUY
Date: 2023.10.19 10:14:41 -04'00'
Rebecca Guy Vice President, Program Management Organization, AJM-0
DME Program DME Siting Criteria Document
ii
Table of Contents
Chapter 1. General Information … 1 Chapter 2. The DME System … 4 Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations … 10 Chapter 4. Antenna Considerations … 46 Chapter 5. DME Siting Requirements … 78 Chapter 6. Site Selection, Project Engineering and Facility Establishment … 94 Appendix A. Acronyms … 98 Appendix B. Reference Documents … 100 Appendix C. DME Performance … 103 Appendix D. Antenna Performance … 192 Appendix E. Echo Location … 220 Appendix F. DME Math Modeling … 237
List of Figures
Figure 2-1. FAA DME/DME RNAV Service Architecture … 5 Figure 2-2. DME Two-way Ranging Concept … 7 Figure 2-3. Effects of Terrain in Producing Specular and Diffuse Reflection … 8 Figure 2-4. DME Siting Roughness Criterion … 9 Figure 3-1. Terminal DME SSV … 12 Figure 3-2. High Altitude (H) and Low Altitude (L) DME SSVs … 12 Figure 3-3. DME Low (DL) and DME High (DH) Service Volumes … 13 Figure 3-4. A Hypothetical LOS Blockage Scenario … 15 Figure 3-5. Illustration of DME Multipath Sources … 16 Figure 3-6. DME Object Consideration Area (OCA) … 18 Figure 3-7. Diffraction Gain … 20 Figure 3-8. Knife Edge Diffraction Geometry … 21 Figure 3-9. Shadowing Silhouette Used When Performing Ray Tracing … 22 Figure 3-10. Level Run Flight Measurement Profile … 24 Figure 3-11. Example Fading Data Produced by Level-run Flight Measurement Profile … 24 Figure 3-12. Radiation Through an Electrically Large Rectangular Aperture … 25 Figure 3-13. Diffraction Silhouette Used When Performing Ray Tracing … 27 Figure 3-14. TOA Processing With and Without Multipath … 29 Figure 3-15. Multipath Pulses From Same Reply Cycle Arriving Slightly Later Than Direct
Pulses … 30 Figure 3-16. Example of Pulse Deformation for Late-arrival Multipath … 30 Figure 3-17. Multipath Pulse and Direct Pulse Parameters … 32 Figure 3-18. Multipath Pulse Influence on Direct Pulse Time-of-Arrival Threshold … 33 Figure 3-19. Early and Late Multipath Pulse to Direct Pulse Timing Regions … 35 Figure 3-20. DME/N Error vs. Relative τ-delay, M/D ratio, In-phase Case … 36 Figure 3-21. DME/N Error vs. Relative τ-delay, M/D ratio, Out-of-phase Case … 36 Figure 3-22. Early and Late Arrival Zone Summary for -6.5 dB and -20 dB M/D Ratios … 38
DME Program DME Siting Criteria Document
iii
Figure 3-23. Examples of Resonant Antennas … 44 Figure 4-1. Annotated DME Antenna Vertical Pattern … 47 Figure 4-2. Annotated DME Antenna Omni-directional Horizontal Pattern … 48 Figure 4-3. Annotated DME Antenna Uni-directional Horizontal Pattern … 49 Figure 4-4. Annotated DME Antenna Bi-directional Horizontal Pattern … 50 Figure 4-5. Illustration of Longitudinal Multipath … 51 Figure 4-6. Illustration of Lateral Multipath … 51 Figure 4-7. Signal-In-Space Results from Adding Direct and Reflected Signals … 52 Figure 4-8. Worst-Case: Signal-In-Space Is at Minimum Amplitude … 53 Figure 4-9. Best-Case: Signal-In-Space Is at Maximum Amplitude … 53 Figure 4-10. More Realistic Vertical Representation of DME High Service Volume … 54 Figure 4-11. dB Systems, Inc. DME Antenna Directivities … 56 Figure 4-12. dB Systems, Inc. DME Antennas Minimum Directive Gain … 56 Figure 4-13. dB Systems, Inc. DME Antennas Minimum Directive Gain - Detail View … 57 Figure 4-14. dB Systems, Inc DME Antennas Minimum Directive Gain for 5100A, 510A, and
5100A/7° Models … 57 Figure 4-15. dB Systems, Inc. DME Antennas Minimum Directive Gain for 540 and 900E
Models … 58 Figure 4-16. Generic Two-ray Model for Signal Reflections from the Ground … 60 Figure 4-17. Pictorial Depiction of Surface Roughness Criteria … 61 Figure 4-18. Example Output for the Rough Surface Analysis, Including Results for All
Scenarios … 62 Figure 4-19. Fading Results for Commonly Used DME Antennas, Typical Antenna Site … 63 Figure 4-20. dBs 5100A Worst-case Fading for Water Only Surface Conditions … 64 Figure 4-21. Example of Corrugated Surface Profiles … 65 Figure 4-22. Application of Particular Surfaces to Earth Only Fading Bounds … 65 Figure 4-23. Example Fading Results for Worst-Case and Best-Case Conditions … 66 Figure 4-24. Level Run Flight Test Profile with Example Simulated and Measured Signal-
strength Results … 69 Figure 4-25. Example of Migrating Nulls with Increased Antenna Height … 70 Figure 4-26. Alignment of Level Run and Fading Bound Plots … 71 Figure 4-27. Illustration of Migrating Peak/Nulls with Stationary Fading Bound Envelope … 72 Figure 4-28. Correlation Between Level-run and Fading Bound Plots … 73 Figure 4-29. Fading Bound Equation Symmetry About Horizon … 75 Figure 4-30. Vector Wheel Diagrams for Figure 4-31 … 75 Figure 4-31. DME/N Time Delay vs. Multipath Error for an In-phase and Out-of-phase
Multipath Conditions … 76 Figure 5-1. Vertical Subtending Angle Illustration … 80 Figure 5-2. Horizontal Subtending Angle Illustration … 80 Figure 5-3. Lateral Multipath Illustration … 81 Figure 5-4. Longitudinal Multipath Illustration … 84 Figure 5-5. Two-level Flat Terrain … 85 Figure 5-6. Two-level Up-Slant Terrain … 86 Figure 5-7. Two-level Down-Slant Terrain … 87 Figure 5-8. One-level Up-Slant Terrain … 88 Figure 5-9. One-level Down-Slant Terrain … 89
DME Program DME Siting Criteria Document
iv
Figure 5-10. Illustration of Obstruction of Longitudinal … 92 Figure C-1. A Hypothetical LOS Blockage Scenario … 106 Figure C-2. Illustration of DME Multipath Sources … 107 Figure C-3. Illustration of Longitudinal Multipath … 109 Figure C-4. Illustration of Lateral Multipath … 110 Figure C-5. Roughness Criterion … 112 Figure C-6. Pictorial Depiction of Rayleigh and Fraunhofer Criteria for Surface Roughness . 112 Figure C-7. Signal-In-Space Results from Adding Direct and Reflected Signals … 113 Figure C-8. Worst-Case: Signal-In-Space at Minimum Amplitude … 114 Figure C-9. Best-Case: Signal-In-Space at Maximum Amplitude … 114 Figure C-10. Scenario for Calculating Radius of the First Fresnel Zone … 116 Figure C-11. Scenario for Calculating Radius of First Fresnel Zone When Distance to Receiver
is Much Larger than Distance to Structure … 117 Figure C-12. Reflection and Refraction at Smooth Plane Surfaces … 119 Figure C-13. Ray Tracing from Many Points on an Illuminated Surface … 119 Figure C-14. Ray Tracing Showing the Boundaries for Incident and Reflected Rays … 120 Figure C-15. Ray Tracing for a 3D Building … 121 Figure C-16. Example of Echo Ellipsoids for a Given Time-delay … 122 Figure C-17. Geometry for Echo Ellipse … 123 Figure C-18. Plan View Showing a Building Near a Potential DME Antenna Site … 124 Figure C-19. Time Delay Calculations Scenario … 125 Figure C-20. Geometrical Relationship for Multipath Scalloping Equation … 127 Figure C-21. Example Error Trace with Scalloping Effect Illustrated … 127 Figure C-22. Bode Plot of Generic DME Interrogator Output Filter … 128 Figure C-23. Half Amplitude Find Function Used in DME/N for TOA Determination … 130 Figure C-24. DAC Function Used in DME/P for TOA Determination … 131 Figure C-25. DME Object Consideration Area (OCA) … 133 Figure C-26. Diffraction Gain … 135 Figure C-27. Knife Edge Diffraction Geometry … 136 Figure C-28. Signal Blockage/Clearance Scenarios … 137 Figure C-29. Flight profile and Signal Strength Analysis, Part 1 … 139 Figure C-30. Flight Profile and Signal Strength Analysis, Part 2 … 140 Figure C-31. Qualitative Zonal Assessment of Signal Attenuation Due to Shadowing … 141 Figure C-32. Shadowing Silhouette used when Performing Ray Tracing … 143 Figure C-33. Level Run Flight Measurement Profile … 144 Figure C-34. Example Fading Data Produced by Level-run Flight Measurement Profile … 145 Figure C-35. Example Fading Results for Worst-Case-Phase and Best-Case-Phase Conditions
… 146 Figure C-36. Shadowing and Reflection Multipath Signal Strength Relationships … 147 Figure C-37. Radiation Through an Electrically Large Rectangular Aperture … 148 Figure C-38. Qualitative Zonal Assessment for Signal Attenuation Due to Fading … 150 Figure C-39. Diffraction Silhouette Used When Performing Ray Tracing … 151 Figure C-40. TOA Processing With and Without Multipath … 153 Figure C-41. Multipath Pulses From Same Reply Cycle Arriving Slightly Later than Direct
Pulses … 154 Figure C-42. Example of Pulse Deformation for Late-arrival Multipath … 155
DME Program DME Siting Criteria Document
v
Figure C-43. Multipath Pulse and Direct Pulse Parameters … 156 Figure C-44. Multipath Pulse Influence on Direct Pulse Time-of-arrival Threshold … 157 Figure C-45. Early and Late Multipath Pulse to Direct Pulse Timing Regions … 159 Figure C-46. Pulse Deformation Snapshots In-phase for an M/D Ratio of -6.5 dB … 161 Figure C-47. Pulse Deformation Snapshots Out-of-phase for an M/D Ratio of -6.5 dB … 162 Figure C-48. DME/N Error versus Relative τ-delay, M/D Ratio, In-phase Case … 163 Figure C-49. DME/N Error versus Relative τ-delay, M/D Ratio, Out-of-phase Case … 164 Figure C-50. In-phase Multipath Arrival Zones with Indications for -6.5 dB M/D Ratio … 166 Figure C-51. In-phase Multipath Arrival Zones with Indications for -20 dB M/D Ratio … 167 Figure C-52. Out-of-phase Multipath Arrival Zones with Indications for -6.5 dB M/D Ratio 168 Figure C-53. Out-of-phase Multipath Arrival Zones with Indications for -20 dB M/D Ratio . 169 Figure C-54. Early and Late Arrival Zone Summary for -6.5 dB and -20 dB M/D Ratios … 170 Figure C-55. DME Transponder Receives and Replies to a Sequence of Aircraft Interrogations
… 171 Figure C-56. Downlink and Uplink Sequences … 171 Figure C-57. Multipath TOA Relative to Direct Pulse Scenarios for First Pulse Timing … 174 Figure C-58. Interpretation of Time Diagram for Computing Absolute Time-delay Values ... 176 Figure C-59. Multipath Case – 1st Pulse of Same Reply Interfering with 2nd Pulse of User
Aircraft Reply … 178 Figure C-60. Multipath Case – 2nd Pulse of Earlier Reply Interfering with 1st Pulse of User
Aircraft Reply … 179 Figure C-61. Multipath Case – 1st Pulse of Earlier Reply Interfering with 1st Pulse of User
Aircraft Reply … 179 Figure C-62. Multipath Case – 2nd Pulse of Earlier Reply Interfering with 2nd Pulse of User
Aircraft Reply … 180 Figure C-63. Multipath Case – 1st Pulse of Earlier Reply Interfering with 2nd Pulse of User
Aircraft Reply … 180 Figure C-64. Uplink Echo Ellipsoids Based on Aircraft B Geometry … 182 Figure C-65. Interrogation Replies are Jittered (Asynchronously) to Prevent Multipath
Interference … 184 Figure C-66. Multipath Object Locations of Interest within Echo Ellipsoid 1 … 185 Figure C-67. Plan View Showing a Building Near a Potential DME Antenna Site … 187 Figure C-68. Time Delay Calculations Scenario … 188 Figure C-69. Determining Vertical Profile Factor … 190 Figure D-1. dBs 5100A Directivity vs. Elevation Angle … 197 Figure D-2. dBs Antenna Model 5100A Fading Analysis Best Case/Worst Case Phase - Earth
Only Surface Conditions … 198 Figure D-3. dBs 5100A/7° Directivity vs. Elevation Angle … 201 Figure D-4. dBs Antenna Model 5100A/7° Fading Analysis … 202 Figure D-5. dBs 510A Directivity vs. Elevation Angle … 204 Figure D-6. dBs Antenna Model 510A Fading Analysis … 205 Figure D-7. dBs 540 Directivity vs. Elevation Angle … 207 Figure D-8. dBs Antenna Model 540 Fading Analysis … 208 Figure D-9. dBs 900E Directivity vs. Elevation Angle … 210 Figure D-10. dBs Antenna Model 900E Fading Analysis … 211 Figure E-1. Multipath Overview … 221
DME Program DME Siting Criteria Document
vi
Figure E-2. Examples of Multipath Delay (Big Picture) … 222 Figure E-3. Combined Pulse (In-phase) … 223 Figure E-4. Combined Pulse (Out-of-phase) … 223 Figure E-5. Ellipsoid Overview … 224 Figure E-6. Vertical Slice through an Ellipsoid … 225 Figure E-7. Difference in Distance to Ellipse vs Ellipsoid Intersection with Terrain … 226 Figure E-8. Ellipse Variation as Function of Pulse Delay Variation … 227 Figure E-9. Ellipse Variation as Function of Transmitter to Multipath is Varied … 228 Figure E-10. Ellipse Variation Ensemble … 229 Figure E-11. Ellipse Parameters … 233 Figure E-12. Locating Possible Reflection Source … 235 Figure F-1. Sample Model Scenario to Describe Plots … 238 Figure F-2. Sample 2-dimensional (a) Range Error, (b) Lock Status Plot, and (c) Signal Strength
… 239 Figure F-3. Sample Heatmap (a) Range Error, (b) Lock Status, and (c) Signal Strength Plot . 240 Figure F-4. Wind Turbine (a) Dimensions and (b) Model Set-up … 242 Figure F-5. (a) Range Error, (b) Lock Status and (c) Signal Strength for Case 1 at 1,000 feet 243 Figure F-6. (a) Range Error, (b) Lock Status, and (c) Signal Strength Results for Case 2 at 3,000
feet … 243 Figure F-7. (a) Range Error, (b) Lock Status, and (c) Signal Strength Results for Case 3 at 5,000
feet … 244 Figure F-8. Solar Panel Array Dimensions … 244 Figure F-9. (a) Range Error, (b) Lock Status, and (c) Signal Strength Results of Solar Array
Above Antenna Base … 245 Figure F-10. Solar Panel Array Model Scenario Signal Strength Results at 1,000 feet … 245 Figure F-11. Longitudinal Multipath of Solar Panel Array … 246 Figure F-12. Signal Strength along Radials 15 and 60 at 1,000 feet … 247 Figure F-13. Irrigation Equipment Dimensions … 248 Figure F-14. Screen Capture of Irrigation Equipment in Model … 248 Figure F-15. Illustration of Irrigation System Model Set-up … 249 Figure F-16. (a) Range Error, (b) Lock Status, and (c) Signal Strength Results of Irrigation
System at 500 feet Distance … 249 Figure F-17. Dimensions of Model ATCT … 250 Figure F-18. Illustration of ATCT Model Set-up … 250 Figure F-19. (a) Range Error, (b) Lock Status, and (c) Signal Strength Results of 1,000 feet
Distance … 251 Figure F-20. Lock Status of (a) 6,000 and (b) 7,000 feet ATCT Distance … 251 Figure F-21. Lock Status of (a) 15º and (b) 30º at 6,000 feet ATCT Distance … 252 Figure F-22. Diagram of Model Communication Towers … 253 Figure F-23. Illustration of Communication Tower Model Set-up … 254 Figure F-24. (a) Range Error, (b) Lock Status, and (c) Signal Strength of Monopole at 1,000
feet … 254 Figure F-25. (a) Range Error, (b) Lock Status, and (c) Signal Strength of Lattice Tower at 1,000
feet … 255 Figure F-26. Illustration of Cylindrical Structure Model Set-up … 256 Figure F-27. (a) Range Error, (b) Lock Status, and (c) Signal Strength of Fuel Tank at 2,000 feet
DME Program DME Siting Criteria Document
vii
… 256 Figure F-28. Lock Status of Fuel Tank at 6,000 feet for (a) X and (b) Y-channel Transmitter 257
List of Tables
Table 3-1. Summary of DME Service Volumes … 13 Table 4-1. Minimum Gain Values for dB Systems, Inc. DME Antennas … 55 Table 5-1. Antenna Length and Near-field Protection Cylinder Distance … 79 Table 5-2. Scattering Object Distance and Subtending Angle Criteria … 82 Table D-1. DME Environmental Specification for dBs Antennas … 193 Table D-2. Characteristics Common to dBs DME Antenna Models … 194 Table D-3. Characteristics Common to Configurations of the dBs Antenna Model - dBs 5100A
… 195 Table D-4. Characteristics Unique to Configurations of the dBs Antenna Model - dBs 5100A
… 195 Table D-5. Characteristics Common to Configurations of the dBs Antenna Model - dBs
5100A/7° … 199 Table D-6. Characteristics Unique to Configurations of the dBs Antenna Model - dBs 5100A/7°
… 200 Table D-7. Characteristics Common to Configurations of the dBs Antenna Model - dBs 510A
… 203 Table D-8. Characteristics Unique to Configurations of the dBs Antenna Model - dBs 510A 203 Table D-9. Characteristics of the dBs Antenna Model - dBs 540 … 206 Table D-10. Characteristics of the dBs Antenna Model - dBs 900E … 209
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 1. General Information
Chapter 1. General Information › 6. Application
Chapter 1. General Information
1. Purpose of This Order This order provides guidance to personnel engaged in the siting of Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Distance Measuring Equipment (DME). This order also provides guidance to FAA personnel responsible for protecting and mitigating possible adverse effects on the DME Signal-in-Space (SIS) from proposed construction around the DME facility. This order provides guidelines that are used in conjunction with a thorough understanding of DME facility operations to arrive at the optimum facility location. The guidelines and criteria in this order are designed to be applicable to all installations, but are not required to be applied retroactively to existing installations. Application of these guidelines may be used to reduce the real estate requirements for certain existing installations. Deviations from these criteria may be permitted provided the results of a site-specific analysis indicate that operationally acceptable performance will be achieved with such deviations in place. 2. Audience This order provides guidance for all personnel responsible for planning the installation or troubleshooting of existing DME facilities in the National Airspace System (NAS).
3. Where Can I Find This Order?
a. On the Technical Library website at:
https://nas.amc.faa.gov/phoenix/views/technicalLibrary.xhtml b. On the Directives website at:
https://employees.faa.gov/tools_resources/orders_notices/
4. Cancellation This order does not cancel an existing order.
5. Explanation of Policy Changes There are no changes to an existing order. 6. Application The criteria in this order apply to new DME-only establishments or relocated DME facilities. These criteria may also be used to predict the impact of changes to the local environment (e.g., construction) on the performance of existing facilities. Changes to existing facilities for the sole purpose of obtaining compliance with these criteria are not required, but may be implemented to reduce the real estate requirements associated with decommissioned Very High Frequency Omni-directional Range (VOR)/DME and Tactical Air Navigation (TACAN) sites where the DME is to remain in use (see Chapter 5 for more details). For all other instances, FAA Order 6820.10, “VOR, VOR/DME, and VORTAC Siting Criteria” will apply to those facilities.
Chapter 1. General Information › 10. Siting Effects on DME Operations
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 1. General Information
7. Directive Verbs The material in this order contains FAA criteria, recommended practices, and other guidance materials, which require the use of certain directive verbs such as, MUST, SHOULD, WILL, and MAY. In this order the explicit meaning of the verbs are as follows:
a. MUST. The action is mandatory. For example: “The DME must provide accurate range
information along all published procedures where the DME is used for position information.”
b. SHOULD. The action is desirable or recommended. For example: “The vertical
subtending angle from the DME antenna to any obstruction should be below 1° for all objects to minimize shadowing.”
c. WILL. The action is to be taken in the future. For example: “The report will
recommend the appropriate DME system and antenna type.”
d. MAY. The action is permissible. For example: “Buildings beyond 5 nmi need not be
evaluated unless, based on engineering judgement, it is deemed the structure may impact system performance."
8. Procedures
a. Standards and Tolerances (Ground Equipment). The standards and tolerances for
the DME are contained in FAA Order JO 6730.2, “Maintenance of Distance Measuring Equipment (DME) Facilities,” and the applicable instruction books. Note that for installation purposes, the initial tolerances and limits must apply.
b. Airborne Signal-in-Space (SIS) Performance Requirements. The airborne SIS
requirements in this order are based on information available at the time of publication in FAA Order 8200.1, “United States Standard Flight Inspection Manual (USSFIM).”
9. DME Siting and Installation The goal of any DME installation is to provide a DME signal which will provide information sufficient to assist aircraft in navigating to their desired location in the Area Navigation (RNAV), en route, or terminal environment. The ability to attain this objective depends to a great extent on the proper siting and performance of each DME system. If the DME is collocated with another facility, that facility siting order must also be considered when siting the DME.
10. Siting Effects on DME Operations The ability of the DME system to provide reliable and accurate slant range information depends primarily upon the un-obstructed propagation of the SIS. The greatest detriment to the DME SIS is the presence of reflecting and signal blocking objects such as terrain, vegetation, irrigation equipment, Air Traffic Control Towers (ATCTs), communication towers, and cylindrical structures. The guidance presented in this order will enable the siting engineer to choose the optimum site for installation. Math modeling techniques may be employed to predict the probable location, magnitude, and duration of DME
Chapter 1. General Information › 12. DME Components as Obstructions
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 1. General Information
disturbances caused by multipath and shadowing conditions. 11. DME Establishment Criteria
a. DME Establishment. A DME may be established to support en route or terminal
procedures. The FAA performed DME coverage analysis to estimate the total number of DMEs necessary to meet the DME/DME RNAV goals from the Performance Based Navigation (PBN) NAS Navigation Strategy 2016. This analysis resulted in a solution set which relies on existing high power FAA DMEs, Canadian DMEs, and Military DMEs. b. Physical Requirement Considerations. The ground based equipment of the DME
system requires land and infrastructure sufficient to support the DME installation. The land required for a typical installation should be adequate to assure DME SIS is not impacted by obstructions in the vicinity of the antenna and guard against future growth or development. Infrastructure required for a DME installation includes roads, utilities and communication lines. The shelter where the DME equipment is installed must also be located close enough to the DME antenna so as not to exceed the limitations set forth by any particular DME’s installation manual. c. Equipment Type and Configuration Considerations. Equipment type and antenna
configurations used in DME establishments, either en route or terminal, should be chosen to fit the need for which the DME is intended to fill. Consideration should be given not only to siting DME equipment to account for current terrain, obstructions, and multipath predictions, but also for future vegetation growth and planned development around the DME facility.
12. DME Components as Obstructions For DME installations on or near airports, the siting engineer must consider the effects of the DME components themselves as obstructions. These considerations should include guidance given in FAA Order 8260.3 “United States Standard for Terminal Instrument Procedures (TERPS)”, 14 CFR Part 77, and applicable FAA Advisory Circulars (ACs) such as AC 150/5300-13 “Airport Design”, and AC 70/7460-1 “Obstruction Marking and Lighting”.
Chapter 2. The DME System › 2. DME Service Requirements
DME Siting Criteria Document
Chapter 2. The DME System
Chapter 2. The DME System
1. Introduction The purpose of this chapter is to introduce the DME Siting Engineer to the basic operating principles of the DME system, describing, at a high level, Normal DME (DME/N) system operation, the DME facility and its components.
2. DME Service Requirements DME range information is used to support en route, arrival, and departure operations, as well as approach, landing, and missed-approach operations. For these applications, DME is used in conjunction with other navigational aids (NAVAIDs) such as VOR and the Instrument Landing System (ILS). RNAV operations can also be supported through the use of multiple DME signals and appropriately equipped aircraft. This service is called DME/DME RNAV and can be used as a robust backup to Global Positioning System (GPS) navigation during GPS outages.
a. Procedure Support. DMEs provide procedure support to a number of instrument
approach procedures throughout the NAS. Support may include, but is not limited to, defining a fix along an ILS or defining a DME arc for a procedure. DMEs may be installed solely for procedure support or they may be used for both procedure support and en route guidance.
b. DME/DME RNAV Service Requirements. The FAA is expanding the existing
DME/DME RNAV service across the Contiguous United States (CONUS) to enable DME/DME RNAV equipped aircraft to continue PBN operations during Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) disruptions without the need for an Inertial Reference Unit (IRU). This service minimizes additional pilot and controller workload and maintains NextGen capacity and efficiency benefits in Class A airspace, as well as at the busiest Navigation Service Group (NSG)-1 and select NSG-2 airports during GNSS disruptions. To further aid in the expansion of the DME/DME RNAV Service, the FAA is also increasing the standard service volumes of existing and future DME installations. The resulting DME/DME RNAV service architecture will provide a resilient navigation service for the NAS in CONUS. DME/DME RNAV Service will be required in 99% of the airspace above 18,000 feet Mean Sea Level (MSL) in eastern CONUS and above 24,000 feet MSL in the Western United States Mountainous Area (WUSMA) and up to Flight Level (FL) 450. The RNAV Service area also includes airspace from 1500 feet Above Ground Level (AGL) to 18,000 feet east and 24,000 feet in WUSMA around NSG-1 and select NSG-2 airports. Figure 2-1 below depicts the DME/DME RNAV Service Architecture.
Chapter 2. The DME System › 3. DME System Components
DME Siting Criteria Document
Chapter 2. The DME System
Figure 2-1. FAA DME/DME RNAV Service Architecture
3. DME System Components
a. Ground Equipment. The DME ground equipment consists of four major components:
a transponder, an antenna, a monitor, and a control unit.
i. Transponder. The transponder is the ground based radio transceiver that sends out broadcast replies to aircraft in the area that are interrogating on its frequency. There are several DME types currently in use by the FAA, these include: Cardion model FA-9639 and FA-9783 DME, ASII model 1118 DME, Selex models FA-30600 and FA-30601 DME, Thales models FA-18200 and 415SE DME, and Wilcox models FA-9996, and FA-10391 DME.
ii. Antenna. There are currently three types of antenna systems available for installation with the DME depending on site requirements: omni-directional, unidirectional, and bi-directional. The antenna system is composed of a collinear stack of dipoles. Arrangement of those dipoles determine the vertical radiation pattern. The main lobe of the vertical pattern generally occurs at an elevation angle between 3° to 5°. An alternate antenna that has been approved for use in the NAS on a caseby-case basis through local NAS Change Proposal (NCP) has the main lobe at 7°. Antenna Considerations provide greater detail on the antenna types referenced above.
iii. Monitor. The DME monitors the following parameters: reply delay, reply efficiency, pulse spacing, pulse count, identification, radiated power, receiver sensitivity, and transmitter frequencies. Reply delay and reply efficiency are measured by using only the transponder replies to interrogations from the signal generator section of the monitor. Reply delay is the fixed delay (usually 50 or 56 microseconds (µs)) of the DME station, the time between the reception of a valid interrogation and the transmission of a reply to that interrogation. Reply efficiency is the ratio of transponder replies to a given number of interrogations, expressed as
Chapter 2. The DME System › 4. DME Theory of Operation
DME Siting Criteria Document
Chapter 2. The DME System
a percentage. The signal monitor portion of the monitor, which is used with the monitor signal generator to measure system delay and reply efficiency, also measures pulse spacing, pulse count, identification, and power output of all transponder replies. The monitor also supplies signals to the test unit for pulse viewing and measurements during testing and alignment. If one of the parameters exceeds a preset limit, a fault signal is sent to the station control unit.
iv. Control Unit. The DME control unit provides manual and automatic control of the DME station. It also provides manual station turn on or turn off; and, if a dualtransponder-equipped station is used, the manual selection allows a choice of equipment, No. 1 or No. 2. For a single-equipment station, any alarm will alert personnel at the remote monitoring point and result in a station shutdown. For a dual-equipment station the same is true, except that the initial alarm results in a transfer from main to standby equipment. Alarms at the remote site, such as an air traffic control tower, are indicated by the remote status indicator or Remote Monitoring and Logging System (RMLS). Signals from the DME station are transmitted to the status indicator via a telecommunication line or to a radio transceiver. The status indicator will indicate the exact status of the DME station.
b. Airborne Equipment
i. Interrogator. The aircraft interrogator decodes its own distance replies from transmissions to other aircraft by locating a time-delay period that remains essentially constant between a group of its own interrogation pulses and a series of reply pulses transmitted by the ground station. The aircraft uses an automatic process, which sets up a search pattern each time the aircraft interrogator is tuned to a new station. The process tests various delay intervals by checking the number of successive replies received within a uniform period. At some particular interval, the repetition rate of the reply matches the repetition rate of the interrogations. Reply pulse-pairs are the only ones that have the same spacing between pairs as the random interrogation pulses from the aircraft. When the two kinds of pulses are determined to be synchronous, the airborne receiver locks on to the reply pulses and automatically tracks the ground station.
4. DME Theory of Operation
a. Basic Principle of Operation. An interrogator in the aircraft transmits signals to the
DME ground station. A transponder at the ground station receives the signals, and after a fixed time delay has elapsed transmits replies to the aircraft. The aircraft interrogator measures the elapsed time for the exchange, which is proportional to the slant range distance between the aircraft and the ground station. b. DME Radio Frequencies (RFs). DMEs operate on frequencies between 960
Megahertz (MHz) and 1215 MHz. The interrogator in the aircraft transmits between 1025 MHz and 1150 MHz, with the DME ground station transmitting on a frequency that is 63 MHz higher or 63 MHz lower than the aircraft interrogator frequency.
DME Siting Criteria Document
Chapter 2. The DME System
c. DME Frequency Channels. DME frequencies are divided in to 252 channels,
consisting of 126 X-channels (1X-126X), and 126 Y-channels (1Y-126Y). The main difference between the X and Y-channels is the spacing of the pulse-pairs and the reply delay of the DME ground station.
d. DME Pulse-Pair Spacing and Delay. The DME transmits pulse-pairs at specific
pulse-pair spacing depending on if it is an X-channel or a Y-channel. The pulse-pair spacing for an X-channel is 12µs, and the spacing for a Y-channel is 36µs. Ground station reply delay is also channel dependent. For X-channel this delay is 50µs and for Y-channel the delay is 56µs. e. DME Slant Range Measurements. Figure 2-2 depicts the standardized two-way
ranging technique used by the DME. When the aircraft pilot or flight management computer selects a ground station, the airborne interrogator sends out distance interrogation pulses on the receiving channel frequency assigned to the ground station. These airborne pulses are received by the ground station receiver, delayed a fix amount, and distance replies are transmitted back to the aircraft on the assigned channel. Since radio energy travels at a known and constant speed, the distance between the aircraft and ground station is determined by the elapsed time between the initial transmission of the interrogation and the reception of the reply from the ground station. There is a 50 µs delay or a 56 µs delay (for X or Y-channel, respectively) between reception of the aircraft signal and transmission of the reply. Timing circuits on the aircraft measure the time intervals between the interrogation and reply, subtract the 50 or 56 µs delay, and convert the remaining time difference to distance. Distance is displayed on an indicator and/or digitally transmitted to other devices.
Figure 2-2. DME Two-way Ranging Concept
DME Siting Criteria Document
Chapter 2. The DME System
f. Station Ident. The ground station transmits an international Morse code approximately
every 30 seconds. Pulse coding allows an audio signal to be generated which enables the aircraft to identify the station.
g. Distance Replies. The distance replies are the DME signals which provide the slant
range distance from the DME ground station to the interrogating aircraft.
h. Squitter. Squitter is a pulse-pair transmitted by the transponder, which are not in
response to interrogations. The squitter pulse-pairs are identical to standard reply pulsepairs and occur random in time. Since they are not synchronous with an interrogator’s interrogation, it is not decoded as a reply and is ignored. The number of squitter pulsepairs transmitted is varied to maintain a minimum number of pulse-pairs transmitted by the transponder. Variations occur as the number of aircraft interrogating a facility varies. Airborne interrogators use the ensemble of transmitted pulse-pairs to detect presence of a DME facility without interrogating the ground station and to set the receiver gain.
i. Precedence of Signals. To prevent interference between various components of the
ground station output, there is an order of precedence for each signal in the overall train of pulses. In the DME equipment, the order of priority is identification, distance replies, and squitter pulses. During the identification cycle key down period, distance reply pulses are not transmitted.
j. Signal-In-Space (SIS) Propagation. The objective of successful siting is to avoid the
harmful effects of multipath within the required service volume of the DME. In general terms multipath is the condition where the receiving antenna gets the radio transmission via two or more paths. Radio signals reflected off the ground or a counterpoise is called longitudinal multipath, and signals reflected off objects such as buildings and trees is called lateral multipath.
As illustrated in Figure 2-3, reflection can be specular or diffuse. Specular reflection provides a stronger signal in a specific direction than does diffuse reflection. Hence, if specular reflection causes undesirable interference, the interference can be expected to be relatively strong. Diffuse reflection from a rough surface is unpredictable in its effects. If the reflecting area is sufficiently large it may cause multipath problems.
Figure 2-3. Effects of Terrain in Producing Specular and Diffuse Reflection
DME Siting Criteria Document
Chapter 2. The DME System
Judgement is required to determine whether or not a particular ground will be seen as rough or smooth by the electromagnetic energy. The Rayleigh and Fraunhofer criteria are established standards used to characterize surface roughness. Both criteria classify a surface as rough or smooth based on the phase difference between signals reflected from two different points on the surface. The Rayleigh criterion classifies a surface as rough when the value for “h” exceeds λ/(8sinγ), whereas the Fraunhofer criterion classifies a surface as rough when the value for “h” exceeds λ/(32sinγ). The Fraunhofer criterion is less conservative from a fading analysis perspective and, realistically, many sites may not present that way. Conversely, the Rayleigh criterion is more conservative and may exclude some sites that are slightly rough. As such, an intermediate criterion for DME siting – which falls in the middle of both criteria previously mentioned – was established and is shown by the red trace in Figure 2-4. Note that for small grazing angles (i.e., γ approaching zero) a very irregular ground can still act as a smooth reflective surface.
Figure 2-4. DME Siting Roughness Criterion
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
1. Introduction The purpose of this chapter is to provide key background material on DME performance characteristics and RF concepts relevant to the analysis of such characteristics. The discussion addresses DME service provisioning, signal characteristics of interest, system performance, and performance considerations, as well as the related performance analysis techniques.
Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations › 2. DME Service Provisioning Overview
Appendix C provides a more detailed discussion of the topics mentioned in the following sections. Additionally, Appendix C provides tutorial information, and discusses topics not presented or summarized in this chapter because they pertain to DME system design concepts and related background information. 2. DME Service Provisioning Overview This section discusses high-level DME functions and service provisioning, as well as ranging and identification functionality in terms of signal strength and quality.
a. DME Functions and Service Provisioning
i. DME Functions. DME performs the following three high-level functions: Ranging, Identification, and Interfacing with the RMLS. The usability of the Ranging and Identification functions are dependent on the SIS and its characteristics. Typically, the Identification functionality is assured when the SIS provides operationally acceptable Ranging accuracy performance, i.e., signal strength and accuracy performance that meet DME system-level requirements, such as those in FAA Order FAA-E-2996, “Performance Specification for Distance Measuring Equipment (DME)”. Thus, the focus hereafter addresses concepts and parameters related to achieving such Ranging performance, as well as the means to assess the impact of a specific siting condition on such performance. RMLS functionality relies on modern, reliable telecommunication services. If such services are available, RMLS performance is not considered to be a major factor in siting a DME system.
ii. DME Service Provisioning. The goal of DME Service Provisioning is to provide DME service within the prescribed service volumes. This goal implies that Ranging and Identification are the essential, navigation-enabling functionalities that are to be provided. Ranging and Identification support the pilot’s situational awareness and position location for conventional flight operations, as well as lateral guidance for DME/DME RNAV flight operations. It is important to note that DME service may be adversely impacted if the guidance in this document is not applied correctly. The impacts that could be experienced by the user include degradation of accuracy performance, service outages within portions of the service volume due to inadequate signal strength, and insufficient ground station reply rate. In such cases, the service may not fully support en route, arrival, approach, missed-approach, departure, and DME/DME RNAV flight operations within the intended service volume.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
b. DME Signal Coverage and Accuracy. DME Ranging and Identification functionality
are dependent on signal coverage and signal accuracy. To ensure adequate DME signal coverage for the user the DME must meet the minimum signal strength requirements. This minimum signal strength is required at the DME receiver to ensure proper operation in terms of pulse-pair decoding and ranging accuracy as well as to ensure frequency protection and acceptable immunity to noise effects. The DME signal is considered to be of sufficient accuracy if: (1) the DME pulse-pairs incident at the user receiver result in range accuracy performance that meets the minimum distance accuracy requirement and result in the interrogation continuously operating in track mode (i.e., no loss of lock); and (2) the Morse code and voice identification are correct, clear, and identifiable.
The minimum signal strength and minimum distance accuracy requirements are specified in the USSFIM to ensure sufficient signal coverage and signal accuracy within the prescribed service volumes. Flight inspection will restrict the use of the DME in areas of the service volume, or may remove a facility from service, if the facility does not meet any of the signal accuracy requirements. Failure to meet signal coverage requirements is not used as a sole determination for restricting or removing a facility from service if a solid stable DME lock is present. DME ground station equipment is designed to provide acceptable signal coverage and accuracy throughout the DME service volumes. DME ground station transmitters are typically specified at either 1,000W or 100W. An output power of 1,000W is generally used to support the High Altitude (H), Low Altitude (L), DME Low (DL) and DME High (DH) service volumes. The reduced high altitude requirement of the DL service volume provides additional flexibility in making channel assignments for supporting DME/DME RNAV network coverage. An output power of 100W is typically used to support Terminal (T) service volumes and is generally sufficient to support Standard Instrument Approach Procedures. The DME ground stations also employee signal processing techniques such as echo suppression to improve the signal accuracy of the replies. c. DME Service Volumes. DME service volumes are defined by the cylindrical volume
of airspace where the DME signal is expected to be received by an aircraft from a particular DME. There are five defined service volumes for DMEs in the NAS, three defined Standard Service Volumes (SSVs), and two defined DME/DME RNAV SSVs. The three SSVs are:
1. Terminal (T) (Figure 3-1) 2. Low Altitude (L) (Figure 3-2) 3. High Altitude (H) (Figure 3-2)
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
The two DME/DME RNAV SSVs are:
1. DME Low (DL) (Figure 3-3) 2. DME High (DH) (Figure 3-3) Most SSVs are serviced by 1000W transmitters, with the exception of the T class DME SSV which is usually serviced by a 100W transmitter. A detailed description of these service volumes can be found in Table 3-1.
Figure 3-1. Terminal DME SSV
Figure 3-2. High Altitude (H) and Low Altitude (L) DME SSVs
Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations › 3. DME Signal Characteristics of Interest
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-3. DME Low (DL) and DME High (DH) Service Volumes
Table 3-1. Summary of DME Service Volumes
3. DME Signal Characteristics of Interest This section introduces the DME signal characteristics of interest. The material includes definitions of terms such as signal strength and ranging accuracy, as well as the parameters that can affect them. Discussions of these parameters and their effects are presented in subsequent sections of this chapter.
a. Signal Strength Factors. The discussion above established that signal coverage is
directly tied to signal strength. Insufficient signal strength can also affect accuracy performance in the real world, primarily in terms of susceptibility to noise effects and
130 NM
100 NM
60,000 ft ATH
45,000 ft
Station Elevation
(MSL)
130 NM 12,900 ft
18,000 ft
DME High (DH) DME Low (DL)
Service Volume Designator
Altitude and Range Boundaries
T (Terminal) From 1,000 feet AGL up to and including 12,000 feet AGL at radial distances out to 25 nmi. L (Low Altitude) From 1,000 feet AGL up to and including 18,000 feet AGL at radial distances out to 40 nmi. H (High Altitude) From 1,000 feet AGL up to and including 14,500 feet AGL at radial distances out to 40 nmi. From 14,500 feet AGL up to and including 60,000 feet AGL at radial distances out to 100 nmi. From 18,000 feet AGL up to and including 45,000 feet AGL at radial distances out to 130 nmi. DL (DME Low) From 1,000 feet AGL up to and including 18,000 feet AGL at radial distances out to 130 nmi. DH (DME High) From 1,000 feet AGL up to and including 45,000 feet AGL at radial distances out to 130 nmi. From 45,000 feet AGL up to and including 60,000 feet AGL at radial distances out to 100 nmi.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
RF interference. The equipment design, the associated installation and configuration practices, and the environment surrounding the transmitter/receiver antenna all influence the signal strength required or achieved within the service volume.
The relevant equipment design characteristics include ground station receiver sensitivity, decoder performance, pulse shape attributes, transmitter output power, and three-dimensional antenna gain properties. Signal attenuation due to cable (type and length) and connector losses is the primary concern when it comes to the equipment installation and configuration process. These factors are addressed during the equipment design and installation procedure approval process, and thus they are not of concern to the siting engineer. Signal attenuation due to cable (type and length) and connector losses affect the transmitted power incident at the ground station antenna and only need to be considered by the siting engineer when the proposed site includes a large distance between the ground equipment and the antenna. Lastly, signal strength can be affected by the environment surrounding the ground station antenna.
Environmental or site-specific factors include Line-of-Sight (LOS) blockage issues, which occur when the direct or visible path between the antenna and a reception point is blocked by a structure, hill, or wooded area. Equipment must therefore be located such that it provides for sufficient LOS clearance over or around objects in the vicinity of the ground station antenna. Figure 3-4 shows a hypothetical LOS blockage situation. If the direct line between the antenna and the receiver passes through the structure, as shown with the red line, then it is assumed that there is a LOS blockage. If, however, there is enough clearance over or around the structure, as shown with the green line, then it is presumed that the LOS is not blocked. In the practical sense, the effective blockage is determined by how much of the first Fresnel Zone around the LOS line falls on the structure. This concept is discussed further in Section 4 of this chapter.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-4. A Hypothetical LOS Blockage Scenario Aside from signal blockage, signal scattering (reflections and diffractions) from the terrain can also result in signal nulling and fading, which can adversely affect signal strength.
b. Ranging Accuracy Factors. DME equipment design errors and limitations are factors
that can adversely affect ranging accuracy. Specifically, equipment intrinsic errors in the signal transmission and receiver processing can induce ranging errors. However, it is assumed that the ground and airborne equipment have already been properly designed and qualified according to DME equipment requirements (per FAA-E-2996, RTCA DO-189, and TSO-C66) such that the contribution of DME equipment to ranging error is within acceptable limits.
Ranging accuracy can also be affected by environmental or site-specific factors that cause signal blockage (as discussed above), multipath, or both. As shown in Figure 3-5, the signal radiated by the DME antenna can also be reradiated (or “scattered”) by objects in the environment including buildings, trees, and mountains. Because these scattered signals traverse different signal paths to the receiver, they are commonly referred to as “multipath.” Multipath can cause DME signal pulse-shape deformations, which can translate to ranging error during DME receiver processing. Multipath can be categorized as longitudinal, lateral, or a combination of the two.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-5. Illustration of DME Multipath Sources
Parameters that affect ranging accuracy are as follows:
1. Multipath-to-Direct (M/D) Signal Ratio: The ratio between the magnitude of the multipath signal and the magnitude of the direct signal. 2. Relative Time Delay (τ): The difference between the Time of Arrival (TOA) of the multipath signal relative to the TOA of the direct path signal. 3. Relative Phase: The phase of the multipath signal relative to the phase of the direct signal. 4. Motion Averaging: The reduction in the magnitude of both sinusoidal-like and noiselike multipath induced errors caused by the motion of an aircraft when flying through a multipath interference region.
5. TOA Technique: The measurement method used to determine the TOA of a detected DME pulse (i.e., pulse envelope). The interrogator uses this arrival time to determine the range from the transponder, whereas the transponder uses TOA to initiate the reply delay timing function.
Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations › 4. DME System Performance
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
4. DME System Performance The application of the siting criteria presented herein is intended to identify an antenna site that satisfies all the siting criteria presented in this order. The first step in finding such a site is to identify a location that will enable adequate SIS performance in terms of coverage and accuracy. Only when it has been determined that a candidate site enables such performance to be achieved within the required service volume should compliance with the remaining criteria be pursued. Enabling adequate SIS performance in terms of coverage and accuracy is achieved by finding locations where the site-specific environmental effects (aka multipath) will be sufficiently controlled. In developing this Order, analyses were performed to characterize the effect on SIS performance due to multipath caused by objects near the DME ground station antenna. These characterizations were used to generate general guidance criteria that is denoted as the Object Consideration Area (OCA), which is shown in Figure 3-6.
It should be noted that the OCA consists of the following two components: 1) a near-field protection cylinder surrounding the DME antenna that was established to protect the nearfield radiation pattern of the ground station antenna; and 2) a conical sloped surface that is defined by a vertical 1° subtending angle that extends upward from the base of the DME antenna. All objects should be below this surface to control the effects of multipath and shadowing within the DME service volume. In some cases, it may not be possible to identify such a site at the designated facility location, and it becomes necessary to consider sites that result in an object or objects being located within the OCA. In this case, the effect on signal strength and ranging accuracy caused by multipath from each object must be evaluated.
Additional guidance on application of these criteria is provided below in Section 5 of this chapter, as well as Chapter 5.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-6. DME Object Consideration Area (OCA)
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
The balance of this section discusses the factors that influence DME system performance from a SIS perspective. First, signal attenuation due to either blockage of the LOS signal path by objects in the environment (aka shadowing) or fading effects caused by multipath are discussed in Section 4.a. Second, discussions in Section 4.a focus on characterizing the effects multipath can have on ranging accuracy. In each section, methods for estimating the magnitude of the impact are presented.
a. Signal Strength. The signal radiated by the DME ground station should meet minimum
signal strength requirements to the greatest extent possible within the applicable service volume, which will normally be one of the volumes shown in Figure 3-1. Service volumes are used when assigning the transmit frequency for a facility to ensure frequency protection from co-channel and adjacent channel interference and that the DME interrogator (i.e., the airborne avionics) can receive and properly process ground station replies to interrogations. The primary factor addressed during the site selection process is the control of multipath effects by the proper application of siting criteria. The effects of longitudinal multipath (Figure 4-5) on signal strength are primarily controlled by the DME antenna design. Information regarding DME antenna performance is provided in Chapter 4 and Appendix D. The effects of signal blockage (Figure 3-4) and lateral multipath (Figure 4-6) are controlled by selecting a suitable antenna site. i. Evaluating Signal Attenuation Due to Blockage/Shadowing. Three terms must be defined before discussing signal attenuation due to blockage and shadowing:
1. LOS: the geometrical straight-line path between a transmitter and receiver antenna.
2. Fresnel Zone: the locus of points surrounding the LOS path where the path length difference from the transmitter to receiver antenna is an integer multiple of the half-wavelength compared to the direct LOS path.
3. LOS Region: the three-dimensional region defined by the first Fresnel Zone surrounding the LOS between the transmitter antenna and the receiver antenna where most of the radiated power is concentrated. In order to ensure that sufficient signal strength exists at a given receiver location, the LOS region must be free of objects. When an object or structure exists within or penetrates this region, the potential for excessive signal attenuation within the service volume should be evaluated. This section describes a qualitative method for performing such an evaluation based on the amount of LOS region obstruction caused by an object.
Analysis of the diffraction gain for an obstruction within the LOS region has shown that the strength of the signal received is a function of the obstruction size, its proximity to the LOS path, and the size of the Fresnel Zone at the obstruction
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
location. The amount of obstruction caused depends on both the dimensions of the object and its orientation with respect to the direct LOS path. For example, a rectangular object having a width and depth each of 10 feet can create an obstruction zone 14 feet wide when the vertical faces of such an object are oriented 45° to the LOS path. The diagram in Figure 3-7 depicts the normalized electric field received as a function of the Fresnel-Kirchhoff Parameter (FKP) for the case of normal incidence edge diffraction (aka knife edge diffraction) of the DME signal by an infinite half plane (see Figure 3-8). Because the analysis considers a normalized electric field, the trace shown in Figure 3-7 can be interpreted as diffraction gain, where a value of less than one denotes attenuation of the received signal compared to that received for the unobstructed case. Likewise, a value greater than one signifies amplification of the signal.
Figure 3-7. Diffraction Gain
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-8. Knife Edge Diffraction Geometry
The FKP is a function of the Fresnel Zone size and the amount of clearance between the LOS path and the closest edge of the obstruction. That is, the portion of the obstruction that penetrates the Fresnel Zone around the LOS path to the reception point determines the amount of signal attenuation or amplification that results. The “Blockage/Shadowing” area shown in Figure 3-7 is the area where most of the Fresnel Zone is penetrated by the object, including blockage of the geometrical LOS between the transmitter and receiver antennas. In this case, significant obstruction of the LOS region occurs, which results in shadowing (i.e., significant signal attenuation) because only the diffracted field is received at the reception point. In the “Clearance/Scattering/Multipath” area, the amount of obstruction clearance determines the magnitude of the total field that is received at the obstruction point. Again, the amount of signal attenuation or amplification is in comparison to the unobstructed case.
Initially, signal strength behavior as the LOS region transitions from the full signal blockage case to the full signal clearance case is discussed. That is, the FKP transitions from minus one to plus one, respectively. The discussion then progresses to analyzing the signal strength behavior during a level-run flight profile that passes behind a rectangular shadowing object. Initially, the height of the profile is well below the top edge of this object, which results in the aircraft passing through the deeply shadowed region caused by
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
a structure. This portion of the analysis focuses on characterizing the effect on signal strength as a function of the horizontal location of the aircraft relative to the shadowed region. The next portion of the analysis characterizes the effect on signal strength as a function of the vertical location of the level run flight profile relative to the top of the rectangular shadowing object. Both characterizations are done in terms of the diffraction gain curve of Figure 3-7. Finally, the two one-dimensional analyses are combined to formulate a rudimentary approach that can be used to make qualitative assessments when performing a site survey, which in its simplest form is shown in Figure 3-9.
As illustrated in Figure 3-9, the volume of space in which signal strength may be adversely affected by a shadowing structure can quickly be identified by adding a shadowing silhouette around the structure and performing ray tracing as shown. The idea to be conveyed is that once LOS clears the shadowing object by at least one Fresnel Zone radii, the full signal clearance condition occurs and the signal strength approaches that of the unobstructed case as depicted in Figure 3-6. This approach provides a basic analysis of the shadowing caused by the structure.
Figure 3-9. Shadowing Silhouette Used When Performing Ray Tracing
ii. Evaluating Signal Attenuation Due to Fading. As previously stated, meeting the coverage requirement throughout the service requires the DME design to incorporate characteristics that provide resistance to, or sufficient control of, signal fading caused by multipath effects. Similarly, it was noted that multipath can be categorized as longitudinal, lateral, or a combination of the two.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
(a) Longitudinal Multipath: The scattering geometry that causes longitudinal
multipath is illustrated in Figure 4-5 which depicts signal reflection from the ground as an ever-present source of longitudinal multipath. An antenna counterpoise, or center-pivot irrigation equipment located radially from the DME facility antenna are other examples of multipath objects that can cause longitudinal multipath.
A straight-level-run flight test maneuver (i.e., a level run), or simulated flight path towards or away from a ground-based transmitting antenna, can be used for collecting signal strength data that enable the assessment of signal coverage. For example, the level run profile illustrated in Figure 3-10 can be used to produce signal strength plots like that shown in Figure 3-11. The signal reflected from the ground will interact with the direct signal to cause fading (i.e., attenuation) and/or amplification. The relative phase between the direct and reflected signal (i.e., multipath) determines if attenuation or amplification occurs, and this phase is a function of the geometry between the transmitter antenna, scatterer, and receiver antenna. Because the aircraft is in motion, the relative phase is constantly changing and the signal strength will cycle through maximums and minimums as shown in Figure 3-12.
The required vertical pattern characteristics for approved DME antennas provide resistance to, or sufficient control of, signal fading caused by multipath effects for typical ground plane situations and antenna heights. Therefore, a signal fading analysis to determine the effects of ground reflection on signal strength is not required in such cases. Atypical situations may require analysis, either via manual calculations or computer modeling. A full analysis of ground reflection effects is documented in “Development of Ground Reflection Multipath Allocations for Supporting a DME Link Budget Analysis”, Ohio University, May 2020 (Reference Z).
Level Run
Profile
DME Antenna
Ground Plane
Direct
Reflected
Profile View
Realized Vertical Pattern
Signal Strength
Lobe
ᶲ Line-of-Sight (LOS) Elevation Angle ᶲ
∆=
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-10. Level Run Flight Measurement Profile
Figure 3-11. Example Fading Data Produced by Level-run Flight Measurement Profile
(b) Lateral Multipath: Multipath from structures in the vicinity of the DME antenna
can also cause signal fading. Again, multipath from such structures can be categorized as longitudinal, lateral, or a combination of the two, which primarily affects where the multipath will be projected into the service volume. The important distinction of this situation compared to that of the ground reflection case is that the dimensions of the structure are finite, unlike that of the ground plane (i.e., Earth surface) the antenna is mounted above. Among other properties, the size of a reflecting surface greatly influences the strength of the multipath, which in turn determines the depth of fading that may occur. The dimensions of a structure also influence the location and size of the multipath region produced. While ray tracing can be used to define the geometrical boundaries of a multipath region, additional analysis is required to evaluate the depth of signal fading (i.e., signal attenuation) that may occur within a given multipath region.
One such analysis method is developed using two different approaches as described in Appendix C. The first approach examines the relationship between signal attenuation in a shadowed region and the strength of the signal reflected into the corresponding multipath and diffraction regions. Assuming that this structure does not absorb that energy (or absorbs very little of it), conservation of energy is applied to determine (or approximate) the strength of the reflected signal within the multipath region. That is, areas of strong signal attenuation in the shadowed region have a corresponding area of strong multipath reflections in the opposite direction. Likewise, areas of minimal or no attenuation have corresponding areas of minimal or essentially zero diffracted signal energy. To identify the signal fading regions in this case, the source antenna location is used in combination with Snell’s Law of Reflection and ray tracing. This approach should be sufficient to enable one to
0
15
30
45
60
75
90
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 -115
-105
-95
-85
-75
Elevation (deg)
Distance (nm)
Signal Strength (dB)
dBs 5100A
Signal Strength Elevation
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
perform qualitative analysis of fading effects.
The Physical Optics technique used for calculating radiation through an electrically large aperture can be applied for calculating the multipath and diffracted signal levels as shown in Figure 3-12. While the numerical calculations required are not trivial, the application of this technique to the case of signal reflection provides an intuitive understanding of signal reflection behavior. To apply this technique to the case of signal reflection by a rectangular object, the multipath object is replaced by its complementary aperture, and image theory is applied to determine the location of the source, which is shown as a “DME Image Antenna” in the figure. Strong multipath signals are present in the area where a direct LOS path exists from the image antenna to the reception point, and this area is denoted as the “Multipath Reflection Region” in the figure. Outside this region, the multipath signal present is due to energy diffracted by the aperture edges. The magnitude of this signal falls off as a function of Fresnel Zone radii much like that for the knife edge diffraction case. To identify the signal fading regions in this case, the image antenna location is used in combination with the complementary rectangular aperture plus ray tracing.
Figure 3-12. Radiation Through an Electrically Large Rectangular Aperture
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
As done for the case of shadowing by a rectangular object, the two one-dimensional analyses for each approach are separately combined to formulate two rudimentary approaches. These approaches can be used to make qualitative signal fading assessments when performing a site survey, which in their simplest form are shown in Figure 3-9. As illustrated in this figure, the volume of space in which signal strength may be affected by fading caused by a multipath structure can quickly be identified by adding a diffraction silhouette around the structure and performing ray tracing as shown in Figure 3-13. The idea to be conveyed is that once LOS clears the shadowing object by at least one Fresnel Zone radii, the diffracted signal strength is about 14 decibel (dB) below the direct signal and at this point fading effects will become minimal. These two approaches provide a basic analysis of the fading caused by the structure. Also, the analysis will also identify the volume of space where ranging errors may exceed desired levels or even be out-of-tolerance, depending on the dimensions of the structure. Conversely, outside of this volume of space, the magnitude of the multipath signals diffracted from structure edges is expected to be at least 14 dB below the direct signal (i.e., M/D ratio ≤ -14 dB). As discussed further in Section 4.b.iv, the magnitude of the resulting ranging errors are expected to be on the order of 100 feet (see Figure 3-20 and Figure 3-21) in most cases.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-13. Diffraction Silhouette Used When Performing Ray Tracing
a. Evaluating ranging error due to multipath. This section characterizes multipath and
how it affects the SIS. The discussion includes information about how the SIS is processed to make a TOA determination, how this processing influences multipath error magnitudes, and multipath arrival zones. The section closes with an example multipath analysis.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
i. Overview. This section starts with a discussion of TOA signal processing and how multipath affects the TOA measurement. A foundational discussion follows regarding how multipath can deform the shape of the pulse used by the DME receiver for the TOA measurements and how this deformation results in ranging error. Plots of worst-case error magnitudes as a function of M/D ratio, relative phase, and relative time delay are presented. These plots are then analyzed to define relative time-delay bounds that describe early and late multipath arrival zones about the direct-signal pulse used for the TOA measurement (i.e., the TOA measurement pulse). Multipath arriving within these zones has the potential to generate measurable ranging errors, including errors with magnitudes large enough to impair operational performance in some cases.
ii. TOA Processing and Multipath. It is important to understand how the DME SIS is processed and how multipath is analyzed. In the absence of multipath interference, the DME pulse-pairs arrive at the reception point without deformation. When a multipath-free signal is processed as illustrated in Appendix C, Figure C-23, the half amplitude find function processing that is used for the TOA determination (DME/N) outputs waveforms as shown in Figure 3-12(A). This represents the processed DME signal in the SIS domain. When multipath interference is present, the DME pulse-pairs could arrive at the reception point with or without deformation. When this signal is processed as illustrated in Figure C-23, the half amplitude find function processing that is used for the TOA determination (DME/N) outputs waveforms as shown in Figure 3-14(A). As with Figure 3-14(A), this represents the processed signal in the SIS domain. It should be noted that Figure 3-14(A) and Figure 3-14(B) appear similar and in the SIS domain the receiver cannot de-construct the composite pulse into the direct and multipath signal components. Therefore, when the impact of multipath effects on the DME signal is analyzed, it is necessary to do so in the Multipath Analysis Domain. In this domain, the direct and multipath components are combined to produce the composite signal, which is then analyzed to determine the resulting range error.
Figure 3-14(D) shows how the composite pulse is made up of the direct pulse (dotted-line) and the multipath pulse (red-line). By examining how the direct and multipath signals combine to form the resultant composite pulses in the Multipath Analysis Domain, a better understanding of how multipath can impact the DME signals is gained. Therefore, the Multipath Analysis Domain will be used in this chapter to illustrate multipath effects on the DME signal. Figure 3-14(D) further shows the half-amplitude points of the Direct and Composite Pulses (Td Direct, Td Composite) and therefore how the multipath can affect the TOA. The way the multipath pulse affects the direct pulse (pulse deformation) as well as its impact on the TOA is discussed next.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-14. TOA Processing With and Without Multipath
iii. Pulse Deformation Fundamentals. This section examines when and how a multipath pulse affects the shape of the composite pulse that is used for making the TOA determination. The concept presented is applicable whether the first pulse or second pulse of the pair is used for the range measurement. This independence is achieved because the multipath pulse parameters (i.e., amplitude, phase, and arrival time) are defined relative to the direct pulse that is used for the measurement. That is, they are defined by an M/D signal ratio, relative time delay (τ), and relative phase as previously discussed.
Multipath pulses may be a result of direct pulses that are reflected from objects as small as an outdoor equipment enclosure, or as large as a mountain range. Because they initially propagate to an intermediate location, they travel a longer propagation path from the transmitter to the receiver antenna than the corresponding direct pulses. Regardless of their amplitude or relative phase, the multipath pulses will not interfere with the direct pulses unless the multipath path pulse arrives at the receiver antenna while the direct pulse is also being received; this interference condition is depicted in Figure 3-15 below. The discussion that follows validates this condition and provides the background necessary for quantifying the range of time-delay values that constitute a “same time” arrival.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-15. Multipath Pulses From Same Reply Cycle Arriving Slightly Later Than Direct Pulses
Figure 3-16 illustrates the manner in which the multipath scenario of Figure 3-15 results in a deformed pulse in the Multipath Analysis Domain. This scenario results from the simplest multipath case, which is when the multipath of the same interrogation or reply cycle arrives slightly later than the direct signal. The deformed pulse in this case results from the in-phase multipath combining with the direct signal to form the composite signal, which has a different TOA point than the direct signal. The way in which deformed pulses are formed is examined later in this section.
Figure 3-16. Example of Pulse Deformation for Late-arrival Multipath
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
As previously discussed, the half-voltage point of the leading edge of the timing pulse is used for TOA determination for DME/N. The pulse used for making the TOA determination has changed over time as previously discussed in Section 4.b.ii with early generation equipment using the second pulse of the pair while modern designs use the first pulse. In either case, the way in which the composite timing pulse is deformed can change the TOA location, thus inducing ranging error due to multipath. Next, it is necessary to examine how the multipath pulse can deform a direct pulse. Figure 3-17 depicts a multipath pulse and a direct pulse. In this scenario the time delay between the two pulses is large enough that the multipath pulse does not deform the direct pulse. This is because the multipath pulse in the area to the right of point B does not have sufficient energy to deform the direct pulse enough to affect the location of the TOA point. This same situation is true for the area to the left of point A, which will become relevant as the discussion progresses.
Because the TOA location is unchanged, this case does not induce any ranging error. In layman terms, this “no effect on ranging” condition holds true for two cases: either the multipath pulse arrives “too early”, or it arrives “too late” in time relative to the direct pulse. That is, they are two distinct pulses as far as the receiver is concerned. While this condition may not pose a problem for range measurement, it can still cause performance problems. Specifically, the pulse decoder in the receiver may reject the unaffected direct pulse due to a pulse spacing issue when the amplitude of the multipath path pulse is close (≈ 1 dB) to that of the direct. If this condition persists long enough, it can cause a receiver unlock condition, which causes the ranging service to become unavailable until the condition ceases.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-17. Multipath Pulse and Direct Pulse Parameters
The next step is to illustrate how the TOA location shifts when the multipath pulse overlays the direct pulse. As discussed above, the magnitude of the multipath pulse can add to (in-phase condition) or subtract from (out-of-phase condition) the magnitude of the direct pulse. In either case, the result may be a deformed composite pulse, meaning deformed in the sense that the TOA location is shifted from that of the direct pulse only location. The in-phase condition where the multipath pulse adds to the magnitude of the direct pulse is illustrated in Figure 3-16. The out-of-phase condition, where the magnitude of the multipath pulse is subtracted from the direct pulse, is addressed in the following section. The analysis illustrating the shift in the TOA location is conducted in the Multipath Analysis Domain by moving the multipath pulse shown in Figure 3-17 from left to right while the direct pulse stays fixed. Figure 3-18 illustrates this progression by showing three cases as the multipath pulse moves from left to right. Figure 3-18(A) depicts the multipath arriving earlier than the direct pulse. In this case, the time delay is such that the two pulses combine to create a deformed composite pulse having a TOA location noticeably shifted from that of the direct pulse. When part of the multipath pulse inside the yellow box shown in Figure 3-18(A) begins to combine with the direct pulse, the magnitude of the multipath pulse adds to the magnitude of the direct pulse, resulting in a deformed pulse. Furthermore, it should
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
be noted that the yellow box shown in Figure 3-18(A) identifies the portion of the multipath pulse that has an amplitude large enough to generate a deformed composite pulse when it is added to the direct pulse. The exact location of points A and B on the multipath pulse depends on the M/D ratio and relative phase, which is explored further in the subsections that follow.
The red and blue vertical lines at the top of Figure 3-18(A) run through the halfamplitude (half-voltage) points of the deformed composite pulse and the direct pulse, respectively. These lines illustrate that the deformed composite pulse has a TOA that is shifted to the left compared with the direct pulse, which induces range error because the TOA has changed. It is important to note that the TOA will be out-of-tolerance if its location falls outside of the ellipsoid boundary (as shown at the top in Figure 3-18(A)).
Figure 3-18. Multipath Pulse Influence on Direct Pulse Time-of-Arrival Threshold
As the multipath pulse continues to move to the right, it gets to a point where the multipath pulse completely overlays the direct pulse. This situation is shown in Figure 3-18(B). The magnitude of the multipath pulse adds to the magnitude of the direct pulse, again creating a composite pulse. As previously explained, the red and blue vertical lines shown at the top of Figure 3-18(B) run through the halfamplitude (half-voltage) points of the composite pulse and the direct pulse, respectively. These lines illustrate that, in this case, the composite pulse has a TOA that is same as the direct pulse, which results in zero range error. That is, no deformation occurred in terms of a range error being introduced, and the effect in this case is analogous to amplification of the direct pulse. For the out-of-phase case, the effect is analogous to attenuation of the direct pulse. It is important to note that when the time delay is zero, a multipath pulse does not cause a range error to occur.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
As the multipath pulse continues to move to the right, it gets to a point where the multipath arrives later than the direct pulse, and the time delay is just enough for the two pulses to continue to combine. As with Figure 3-18(A), part of the multipath pulse inside the yellow box shown in Figure 3-18(A) is still combining with the direct pulse. The magnitude of the multipath pulse adds to the magnitude of the direct pulse, resulting in a deformed composite pulse. The red and blue vertical lines shown at the top of Figure 3-18(C) run through the half-amplitude (halfvoltage) points of the composite/deformed pulse and the direct pulse, respectively. These lines illustrate that this deformed composite pulse has a TOA that is shifted to the right as compared with the direct pulse, which induces range error. Based on the preceding discussion, three multipath arrival zones about the direct pulse have been developed, and these zones are classified as “early”, “late-short”, and “late-long” as illustrated in Figure 3-19.
Time delay is the parameter that determines if a multipath pulse will arrive within one of these three zones. Multipath that has an "early" time delay will distort the portion of the pulse used to estimate the TOA and therefore has the potential to result in significant range error. Multipath categorized as “late-short” results in a deformed pulse, but with less range error than an “early” pulse. The “long-delay” multipath does not cause ranging errors, since it does not distort the portion of the direct-signal pulse that is processed to estimate the pulse TOA. The above characterization assumes that the magnitude of the direct pulse is larger than that of the multipath pulse. The magnitude of the range error is a function of the M/D ratio, the TOA of the multipath relative to the direct signal (time-delay), the phase of the multipath signal relative to the direct, and the multipath scalloping frequency resulting from receiver motion in the dynamic case.
While the discussion to this point focused on describing the conditions where multipath may cause ranging error, the presence of multipath can also cause a receiver unlock condition as previously noted. The DME receiver is required to validate each pulse-pair by confirming that the pulse width and spacing fall within prescribed tolerances. Multipath having an amplitude very similar to that of the direct pulse, but arriving outside the arrival zones discussed above, can cause pulse spacing violations. Similarly, multipath arriving within these zones may cause pulse width violations, even when arriving within the “late-long” arrival zone. If any of these conditions, or a combination thereof, persists long enough, it can cause a receiver unlock condition, which causes the ranging service to become unavailable until the condition ceases.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-19. Early and Late Multipath Pulse to Direct Pulse Timing Regions
iv. Characterization of Multipath Error Magnitudes. A worst-case analysis was performed to characterize ranging error magnitudes as a function of M/D ratio and time delay. The results of this analysis are presented in Figure 3-20 and Figure 3-21, which show the multipath range error (aka multipath error) resulting from deformed pulses for both in-phase and out-of-phase conditions. The M/D ratios in these figures vary from -6.5 dB to -20 dB.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-20. DME/N Error vs. Relative τ-delay, M/D ratio, In-phase Case
Figure 3-21. DME/N Error vs. Relative τ-delay, M/D ratio, Out-of-phase Case
It is important to note that Figure 3-20 and Figure 3-21 illustrate curves with a range of M/D ratios from -20 dB to -6.5 dB for analytical purposes. Paragraph 2.2.14.a in RTCA DO-189 states: “…the interrogator shall operate normally, including decoding and ranging accuracy in the presence of echo or multipath conditions where the reflected signal level is not greater than -10 dB with respect to the desired
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
signal.” Thus, when the results of a fading or error analysis yield a M/D ratio greater than -10 dB, it should be realized that this situation is likely problematic from a performance perspective. In this case, further action may be required to mitigate the impact and the action required will depend on the particulars of the situation (i.e., consider a different antenna location, change in new construction plan, et cetera). v. Defining Multipath Arrival Zone. A worst-case analysis was performed to quantify the time-delay values that define the multipath arrival zones shown qualitatively in Figure 3-17. These values are a function of M/D ratio, relative phase, and the error threshold used to define what constitutes a “measurable” range error. The M/D ratios and relative phase conditions used to generate Figure 3-20 and Figure 3-21 were also used for this analysis, and an error threshold of 50 feet was adopted.
The results are summarized in Figure 3-22. Depending on the M/D ratio, the multipath pulse can affect the thresholding point of the direct pulse when arriving as early as 5.6 μs before the direct pulse arrival, or as late as 3.3 μs after the direct pulse arrival. Larger M/D ratios result in wider arrival zones.
Given that the requirement to use the first pulse of the pair for TOA determination was adopted on January 1, 1989 (Reference DD), the primary concern for DME site selection purposes is the Late-Short Arrival Zone for ranging error considerations. Particularly, the case when an object is present in the DME OCA, large enough in size to generate multipath with M/D ratios greater than -20 dB, and the portion of the multipath region having time-delay values falling within the Late-Short Arrival Zone is operationally significant. It is important to be mindful of cases where the M/D ratio exceeds -10 dB because multipath arriving in the Late-Long Arrival Zone can cause receiver unlock conditions to occur as previously discussed.
The Early Arrival Zone shown in Figure 3-22 is included for completeness. Given the DME system design concept, this arrival zone is only relevant when second pulse timing is used. In this case, TOA determination is susceptible to range measurement errors due to the effects of multipath from first pulse echoes on the second pulse of the pair. This situation is not a factor considered during the site selection process given that more than 30 years have passed since the use of first pulse timing became the requirement.
Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations › 5. DME Performance Considerations
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Figure 3-22. Early and Late Arrival Zone Summary for -6.5 dB and -20 dB M/D Ratios
c. Site Testing Using Mobile DME. Mobile DME systems are also available. These
systems can be utilized by siting engineers to provide a facility/signal to be used at a proposed site or to provide an interfering signal to test an operational installation. When used as a proposed facility/signal the mobile unit can be modified (physical position or operational parameter) to directly assess the effect of the modification on the DME SIS for a proposed site. The mobile unit can also be used as a potential interference source to assess operational site irregularities. A fully operational mobile DME can be deployed quickly and can be utilized to verify if a particular DME siting location will provide an acceptable DME SIS. Once operational, FAA flight check can be utilized to evaluate the SIS and determine if it is within the evaluation tolerances.
5. DME Performance Considerations This section discusses DME performance considerations related to the OCA, antenna types, antenna performance, signal blockage and shadowing, multipath, and resonant structures.
a. Object Consideration Area (OCA). The DME OCA (see Figure 3-6) is the area
centered about the DME antenna where, ideally, all objects and structures are removed. A cylindrical volume surrounding the DME antenna has been established to protect the near-field radiation pattern of the DME antenna since objects within this area can alter the antenna’s radiation pattern. The electromagnetic properties of the radiated signal are more complex in the near-field compared to those in the far-field, and consequently, the analysis of signal scattering by objects in the near-field is a complex undertaking.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Therefore, the near-field should be free of all objects, except for the DME equipment shelter, antenna, and security fence.
Also, a subtending angle of 1.0° extending upward from the base of the DME antenna is used to define a conical, sloped surface. All objects should be below this surface to control the effects of multipath and shadowing within the DME service volume. If the removal of all objects is not practical, then any objects located within the OCA should have their possible impact evaluated to determine the objects’ effect on the DME SIS. Additional information regarding the OCA and its application is provided in Section 3 of Chapter 5.
b. Antenna Types. This section gives an overview of antennas that are available for use
in the NAS. A review of antenna terminology as well as additional performance information on the antennas listed below can be found in Chapter 4 and Appendix D.
i. Standard Antenna(s). The standard antenna type deployed within the NAS is the omni-directional antenna. Examples of this type of antenna are the dBs Model 5100A and the dBs Model 510A. The omni-directional horizontal pattern and achieved gain (≥ 8 dBi) of these antenna models, as well as other FAA-approved antenna models, makes them capable of providing adequate signal coverage throughout the DME service volumes shown in Figure 3-1. Therefore, these models are well suited for supporting terminal and en route DME flight operations. The vertical pattern of these antenna models typically have a beamwidth of greater than 5.0° and a nominal beam tilt (area of maximum radiated energy) between 2.0° and 5.0° above the horizon.. These characteristics, combined with other vertical pattern performance requirements, provide resistance to signal fading caused by ground reflections.
ii. Special Purpose Antenna(s). Special purpose antennas are available for deployment within the NAS when unique siting conditions exist. Uni-directional and bi-directional antennas each utilize unique horizontal patterns. The bidirectional antenna pattern has two primary lobes of energy in the horizontal plane, whereas the uni-directional has just one primary lobe. These antennas can be used for terminal and en route DME applications and can be used to provide maximum DME signal coverage in special/unique situations. These antennas are similar to the omni-directional antenna mentioned above in the sense that the vertical pattern of this antenna has a nominal beam tilt (area of maximum radiated energy) between 2.0° and 5.0° above the horizon. Antennas with a higher vertical beam tilt are also available as a solution when unique siting conditions exist. This type of antenna is typically utilized in instances where additional radiation tilt is needed to minimize ground reflections (multipath). An example of this antenna is the dBs 5100A/7°. High performance antennas that provide increased gain and vertical pattern shaping are available for siting conditions that require improved fading control. An example
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
of this antenna is the ultra-high gain dBs 540.
c. Antenna Performance
i. Antenna Height. Both the free-space vertical pattern characteristics and the height of the antenna above the ground affect the realized vertical pattern of an installed antenna. The height determines the number of nulls or minima that are introduced into the pattern. The region between two nulls is commonly referred to as a (signal strength) lobe. The number of lobes introduced into the vertical pattern is proportional to antenna height, so with increased height, more lobes are generated. Additional information on how antenna height affects performance can be found in Chapter 4 and Chapter 5.
ii. Fading. As previously discussed, fading results when multipath signals arrive at the receiver antenna out-of-phase with the DME direct signal. This situation ultimately reduces the signal strength and therefore signal coverage may be adversely impacted. The parameters that affect fading are: surface conditions, such as water or soil; surface roughness height; and the phase relationship of the multipath signal to the direct signal (i.e., the relative phase).
Signal reflection from the ground below the DME antenna is an ever-present source of longitudinal multipath. Therefore, meeting the coverage requirement throughout the service requires the DME antenna design to incorporate characteristics that provide resistance to, or sufficient control of, signal fading caused by such multipath effects. Performance considerations relevant to providing resistance to, or sufficient control of, signal fading caused by multipath effects include: sufficient vertical pattern slope in the vicinity of the horizon; relatively low-level below horizon sidelobes; and relatively high-level above the horizon sidelobes (i.e., shoulders). The required vertical pattern characteristics for FAA-approved DME antennas provide sufficient control of signal fading for typical antenna heights and ground plane situations.
Fading effects may be more pronounced for situations where the DME antenna is mounted over a smooth ground plane, such as when a large sector of water surrounds the antenna. Conversely, fading effects will be diminished when installing the antenna over a rough ground plane, such as furrowed earth or a corrugated surface. The presence of dense vegetation on the ground plane may cause the signal reflected from the ground to be more diffuse in nature, and thus fading effects will be less prominent than fading for the typical ground plane situation. It should be realized that the presence of such vegetation may be a seasonal or temporary situation.
The presence of trees may result in a situation where the signal reflected from the ground is blocked by the tree line while the direct signal from the antenna is unobstructed because the treetops are just below the subtending angle. In this case, fading due to ground reflections may be mitigated, or substantively reduced, in the
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
portion of the service volume where shadowing of the reflected signal occurs. The magnitude of the reduction can depend on the types of trees, the size of the wooded area, and the density of the trees within this area; the reduction may also be a seasonal or temporary situation.
The presence of a tilted, sloped, or a slowly undulating ground plane typically affects the location of the maxima and minima of the fading pattern compared to the level ground case. A ground plane is considered slowly undulating when the length of the swells and troughs are many Fresnel Zones wide.
Additional information on fading and how fading affects SIS performance can be found in Chapter 4.
d. Signal Blockage and Shadowing. Signal blockage (aka shadowing) occurs when the
LOS region between the DME ground station antenna and the reception point is blocked by a stationary or moving object. A stationary object can be a permanent object or a moving object that has temporarily stopped.
Examples of permanent objects include equipment enclosures and shelters; antenna or antenna arrays; towers; buildings and hangars; above ground storage tanks; trees and vegetation; and hilly or mountainous terrain. These objects must be clear of the OCA, meaning outside of the near-field cylindrical volume and below the conical surface defined by the subtending angle (see Figure 3-6). Objects located within this area should have their impact evaluated through data analysis, or math modeling, or both, to determine the shadowing effect each object has on the DME SIS. Examples of moving objects include vehicles and aircraft; mobile irrigation systems; construction, agricultural, snow removal, and landscape equipment; and construction cranes. Moving objects should keep clear of the near-field cylinder when in motion and clear of the OCA when parked or stationary. Otherwise, their impact must be evaluated through data analysis, or math modeling, or both, to determine the shadowing effect each object has on the DME SIS.
When an evaluation is required, it should determine and consider the amount of signal attenuation expected to occur within the shadowed region. The portion of the shadowed region where the amount of attenuation poses a threat to achieving the minimum signal strength requirement should be identified and noted. A conservative approach is to assume that this threat exists whenever a full signal blockage condition exists, see Appendix C, Figure C-28. The duration of time that the receiver is likely to be exposed to this condition should be evaluated as well. While the volume of space shadowed by an object must be determined and considered, the shape of the volume influences the duration of time that the DME receiver is likely to be subjected to reduced signal strength. This exposure time determines if the effects of passing through a shadowing region will be observable in the receiver output or cause an unlock condition. For example, consider a shadowed
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
region to be a tunnel in the sky. When the tunnel is long and narrow, it is less likely that any particular flight path will align with the tunnel for a given amount of time (i.e., receiver coast period) compared to the case when the tunnel is long and wide. In the end, the nature of the impact is determined by considering the amount of signal attenuation expected to occur; the location of the shadowed region within the service volume; the duration of time that the receiver may be exposed to an inadequate signal level condition; the impact to conventional procedures to be supported by the facility; and the effect of coverage gaps on the DME/DME RNAV network performance. In some cases, the outcome of such an evaluation may indicate that the identification of a more suitable antenna location should be pursued because the impact to flight operations is undesirable. Note: The DME RNAV Service Map (DRSM) can be applied to assess the effect of coverage gaps on DME/DME RNAV network performance. See Site Selection, Project Engineering and Facility Establishment for additional information on the DRSM. Additional information regarding the effect of signal shadowing on system performance can be found in Chapter 5 and Appendix F.
e. Multipath. As previously discussed, the signal radiated by the DME antenna can also
be reradiated (or “scattered”) by objects in the environment. The reradiated signals traverse different signal paths to the receiver, thus they are commonly referred to as “multipath.” Multipath can cause DME signal pulse-shape deformations, which can translate to ranging error during DME receiver processing. Also, multipath can cause signal fading and receiver unlock conditions. As previously discussed, multipath can be categorized as longitudinal, lateral, or a combination of the two.
Both stationary and moving objects within the vicinity of the DME ground station antenna can generate multipath. The examples of stationary and moving objects given in Section D above can also be sources of multipath. Permanent objects must be clear of the OCA. Moving objects should keep clear of the near-field cylindrical volume when in motion and clear of the OCA when parked or stationary. Otherwise, their impact must be evaluated through data analysis, or math modeling, or both, to determine the multipath effect each object has on the DME SIS. When an evaluation is required, it should determine and consider the range of M/D ratios expected to occur within the multipath and diffraction regions shown in Appendix C, Figure C-26. The M/D ratio will vary within these regions and the ratio at any particular reception point determines the possibility of operationally significant signal fading, receiver unlock conditions, and operationally significant ranging accuracy degradation. For the purpose of this discussion, a fading condition is considered operationally significant when the usable distance for the ground station is reduced by 10 percent or more.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Similarly, an accuracy degradation of 200 feet or more is considered operationally significant. The portion of the multipath and diffraction regions where the amount of signal fading poses a threat to achieving the minimum signal strength requirement should be identified and noted. A conservative approach is to assume that this threat exists whenever ray tracing indicates that the projection of the first Fresnel Zone lies entirely within the diffraction silhouette shown in Figure 3-13. In this case, the M/D ratio would be expected to exceed -9 dB, which is sufficient for causing operationally significant signal fading. The -9 dB value assumes that the minimum signal strength requirement can be met within the service volume with that ground station operating at the -3 dB power alarm limit. The duration of time that the receiver is likely to be exposed to this condition should be evaluated as well. The portion of the multipath and diffraction regions where the M/D ratio poses a threat of a receiver unlock condition occurring should be identified and noted.
A receiver unlock condition is possible whenever the M/D ratio equals or exceeds -10 dB. A conservative approach is to assume that this threat exists whenever ray tracing indicates that the projection of the first Fresnel Zone lies entirely within the diffraction silhouette shown in Figure 3-13. The duration of time that the receiver is likely to be exposed to this condition should be evaluated as well. The portion of the multipath and diffraction regions where the M/D ratio poses a threat of a range accuracy degradation condition occurring should be identified and noted. Such a threat is considered possible when the M/D ratio equals or exceeds -10 dB (see Appendix C, Figure C-50 and Figure C-51). It is reasonable to assume that this threat exists whenever ray tracing indicates that the projection of the first Fresnel Zone lies entirely within the diffraction silhouette shown in Figure 3-13. When such a threat exists, the Late-Short Arrival Zone boundary shown in Figure 3-19 should be determined using the appropriate time-delay values from Figure 3-20.
A time-delay value of 3.3 µs can be used as the default value for this part of the analysis. The sector from the multipath object to the Late-Short Arrival Zone boundary identifies the portion of the multipath and diffraction regions where ranging accuracy may be impacted. The duration of time that the receiver is likely to be exposed to this condition should be evaluated as well.
In the end, the nature of the impact is determined by considering the amount of airspace where operationally significant signal fading, receiver unlock conditions, and operationally significant ranging accuracy degradation conditions may occur; the location of the airspace within the service volume; the duration of time that the receiver is likely to be exposed to any of these conditions; the impact to conventional procedures to be supported by the facility; and the effect of coverage gaps and accuracy degradation on the DME/DME RNAV network performance. In some cases, the outcome of such an evaluation may indicate that the identification of a more suitable antenna location should be pursued because the impact to flight operations is undesirable.
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
Additional information regarding the effect of multipath on system performance can be found in Chapter 5 and Appendix C.
f. Resonant Structures. A resonant structure will radiate electromagnetic energy very
efficiently when stimulated at its resonant frequency. The stimulus could result from a directly applied voltage or induced voltage caused by an incident electromagnetic field. An antenna is an example of a resonant structure that radiates electromagnetic energy when a sinusoidal voltage is applied at its input, and examples of resonant antennas are shown in Figure 3-23. In this case, it is intended that these structures broadcast a desired signal. As illustrated in this figure, there is a distinct relationship between the physical size of the antenna structure and its resonant frequency (or very narrow band of frequencies).
Figure 3-23. Examples of Resonant Antennas
However, when exposed to an external electromagnetic field, these same types of structures can reradiate that field, which may be unintended. That is, the reradiated field becomes a source of multipath that can adversely impact the DME SIS. In this case, resonant structures can be metal strips (e.g., wire), isolated metallic patches, slotted surfaces, or cavities. During a site survey, it is challenging to identify such structures because their physical size is on the order of inches at DME frequencies. A single resonant
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 3. DME Signal Characteristics and Performance Considerations
structure is rarely a threat in terms of signal shadowing or multipath because of its finite physical size at DME frequencies unless it is in very close proximity to the DME antenna. In some cases, the effects of resonant structures may not be identified until flight tests are performed, or user complaints are received. When the application of conventional location techniques identifies an area that does not contain an obvious (i.e., large) multipath object, it should be realized that a resonant structure may be the cause.
Chapter 4. Antenna Considerations › 2. DME Antenna Performance Characteristics
DME Siting Criteria Document Chapter 4. Antenna Considerations
Chapter 4. Antenna Considerations
1. Introduction The purpose of this chapter is to provide key background material on DME antenna performance characteristics for antenna models currently used in the United States NAS. This material will assist the siting engineer in choosing the appropriate antenna configuration and location to maintain the integrity and quality of the DME service. As previously discussed in Chapter 3, Ground Based NAVAIDs are classified according to their intended use and each classification has a designated service volume. The FAA has engineered the correct signal strength and frequency protection within the service volumes; therefore the DMEs, like all NAVAIDs, are available for use only within their service volume. For information on service volumes for co-located facilities please refer to the specific facility type siting order. The discussion that follows focuses on those performance characteristics that are relevant to the installed system performance, specifically the vertical and horizontal antenna pattern characteristics.
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 503 passages shown