Order 6820.10 VOR, VOR/DME and VORTAC Siting Criteria
Text read by OCR from a scanned file. Check the original, as some words may be misread.
ORDER 6820.10
VOR, VOR/DME, AND VORTAC SITING CRITERIA
FEDERAL
APRIL 17, 1986
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION
Distrlbutlon: Selected Alrway Facilltles Fleld and Reglonal offlces; ZAF-601 Inltlated By: APM-420
4/17/86 6820.10
FOREWORD
This order provides guidance and reference material to be used in certain practical applications of the very high frequency omnidirectional radio range (VOR), VOR distance measuring equipment (VOR/DME), and VOR tactical air navigation (VORTAC) in the Federal Aviation Administration's (FAA's) National Airspace System. It deals with the procedures and techniques that apply to the initial evaluation, selection, and acquisition of sites for these navigational aids. It also deals with site improvement and the minimization of performance degradation due to multipath. Finally, it provides guidance for the consolidation of
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION
buildings and antenna structures when such consolidation involves VOR, VOR/DME, or VORTAC installations.
Where the facilities consolidation program requires the relocation, consolidation, or establishment of a new VOR, VOR/DME, or VORTAC installation, this order provides technical guidance for the selection and acquisition of a site for the installation. It also provides technical guidance for improving the performance of VOR, VOR/DME, or site conditions. VORTAC installations where performance degradation can be attributed to
The guidance provided in this order applies to new establishments, relocated facilities, and consolidated facilities as specified by the facilities consolidation program. The guidance may also be applied to
levels by siting factors. existing installations where performance is degraded to unacceptable
Thomas J. O'Brien Acting Director, Program Engineering and Maintenance Service
Page i
Pag
F
METRIC CONVERSION FACTORS
METRIC CONVERSION FACTORS
Approximate Conversions to Metric Measures Approximate Conversions from Metric Measures
Symbol When You Know
in inclies feet yd yards mi miles
in2
Multiply by
LENGTH
-2.5 30 0.9 1.6
AREA
6.5
To Find
contimctors contimators maters kilometars
Symbol
cm m km
cm2
N
21
20
19
2
17
Symbol
mm cm m m k5m
When You Know
millimeters centimelers maters metors kilometors
square centimctors
Multiply by
LENGTH
0.04 0.4 3.3
0.6
AREA
0.16
To Flnd Symbal
inches in Inchos in foct yards miles mi
squaro Inches in2 ro
#quaro contimetors
square inches 12 squara feet
0.09
square malers
squara metors squaro kilometers
1.2 0.4
iquare yards square miles mi2
hectares {10,000 m2}
squaro yards mi2
0.8
squaro meters
km2
h
2.6
acres
square kilomoters
square miles acreo
2.6 0.4
hectares
h
s
MASS MASS (weight)
02 ounces 1b pounds short tons (2000 (b)
15p teaspoons TbsP tablespoone 1f or fluid œunces c cups pt pints q1 quarts gallons cubic feat
(weight)
28 0.45 0.9
VOLUME
5 15 30 0.24 0.47 0.95 3.8 0.03
grams kilograms tonnes
milliliters milliliters millilitors liters liters liters liters cubic metors
kg t
ml ml u 1 1 1 1
10
6
9 kg t
m 1
1
grams kilograms tonnes (1000 kg)
millititers litors liters liters cubic maters cubic moters
0.035 2.2 1.1
VOLUME
0.03 2.1 1.06 0.26
1.3
ounces or pounds Ib short tons
Iluld ounces 1l oz pints pt quorts qt gallons cubic foat it cubic yards
TEMPERATURE (exact)
cubic yards
0.76
cubic meters
s
TEMPERATURE (exact)
Fahrenheit temperaturo
5/9 (afto* subtracting 32)
Celzlus temporature
2
•c
Colsius temperature
32
9/5 (then add 32)
986 80
Fahrenheit f tcmporature
*F 22 160 20
-40 120
0 40 T
20 40
50 80 105
Units of Weights and Moasures, Price $2.25, 50 Catlog No. C13,10:286. 1 in 2.54 iemactlyt, fur other exoct conversions and more detaled toblos, se NBs Misc, Publ, 286. -40
inchies]
-20 •c
37
4/17/86
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1. GENERAL.
1. Purpose. 2. Distribution. 3. Cancellation. 4. Background. 5. Application. 6. Definitions. 7. System Concepts.
Page
1 1 1 1 1 1 4
CHAPTER 2. OVERVIEW OF LOCATION AND COVERAGE CONSIDERATIONS.
8. General. 9. Considerations of Longitudinal Multipath. 10. Considerations of Lateral Multipath.
CHAPTER 3. SITE EVALUATION.
11. General. 12. Considerations of Longitudinal Multipath. 13. Considerations of Lateral Multipath. 14.-15. RESERVED.
CHAPTER 4. SITE SELECTION AND ACQUISITION.
16. Procedure for Site Selection. 17. Site Survey, Analysis, and Testing. 18. Land Acquisition. 19. RESERVED.
CHAPTER 5. SITE IMPROVEMENT.
20. General. 21. Site Improvement for VOR. 22.-23. RESERVED.
CHAPTER 6. CONSIDERATIONS OF LONGITUDINAL MULTIPATH.
24. General. 25. Propagation Considerations in General. 26. Longitudinal Multipath for VOR. 27. Longitudinal Multipath for TACAN.
CHAPTER 7. CONSIDERATIONS OF LATERAL MULTIPATH.
28. General. 29. Amplitude of Course Scalloping. 30. Frequency of Course Scalloping.
15 21 23
25 25 33 37
39 43 46 47
49 50 61
65 65 77 84
153 159 172
iii
6820.10 4/17/86
Page
CHAPTER 8. SCATTERING SIMULATIONS.
32. Long-Wire Computation Program (LONGSY). 33. Bodies-of-Revolution Computation Program (CYLPI and CYLP2). 34. Short Wire Computer Program (FRANK). 31. General. 188 187 191 193
APPENDIX 1. LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS, ACRONYMS, AND COMMONLY 1 USED TERMS (4 pages) APPENDIX 2. INPUT AND OUTPUT EXAMPLES FOR COMPUTER SIMULATIONS (14 pages) 1 APPENDIX 3. LOCATION SOURCES OF SCALLOPING BY THE THEORETICAL METHOD (12 pages) 1
APPENDIX 4. LOCATING VOR SCALLOPING SOURCES (30 pages) 1 APPENDIX 5. DESCRIPTION OF SITE DRAWINGS (2 pages) 1 APPENDIX 6. PANORAMIC MOSAIC PHOTOGRAPHS OF VOR SITES (5 pages) 1 APPENDIX 7. TYPICAL VOR SITES (50 pages) 1
iv
Figure 1-1 Figure 1-2 Figure 1-3 Figure 1-4 Figure 1-5 Figure 1-6 Figure 1-7 Figure 1-8 Figure 1-9 Figure 2-1 Figure 2-2 Figure 2-3 Figure 2-4
LIST OF FIGURES
LIST OF FIGURES
Short Range Navaid Ground Station Arrangements Components of the VOR Radiation Pattern Typical Integral VORTAC Facility Typical DVOR Facility DME X-Mode Pulse Characteristics Housing for Coaxially Mounted Navaid Antennas The TACAN Antenna Concept Components of the TACAN Radiation Pattern Illustrating Geographic Bearing from Beacon Types of Multipath The Vanishing of Reflections at Brewster's Angle Two Level Longitudinal Multipath
Page
3 5 8 9 10 11 13 13 14 17 17 18
Effects of Terrain in Producing Specular and Diffuse
Figure 2-5 Figure 2-6 Figure 2-7 Figure 2-8
Reflection Effect of Periodicity in Surface Roughness The Rayleigh Roughness Criterion Vertical Multipath
19 19 20 21
Showing Effect of the Counterpoise in Limiting Ground
Figure 3-1 Figure 3-2 Figure 3-3 Figure 3-4
Illumination Ground Slope Considerations Growth of VOR Fresnel Zone Length With Distance Range of Sizes for First Fresnel Zone
22 27 28 29
Radiated and Reflected Electric Field at Counterpoise
Figure 3-5
31
Growth of TACAN/DME Fresnel Zone Length with Distance
Figure 3-6
32
Maximum Scalloping Amplitude Caused by Single Tree and
Figure 4-1 Figure 5-1 Figure 5-2 Figure 5-3
by Forest Site Selection Procedure Utility and Shortcomings of the VOR Counterpoise Counterpoise Boundary Range of Elevations Within Which VOR Destructive
35
41 51 52
Longitudinal Multipath (Vertical Nulls) Can Occur
Figure 5-4 Figure 5-5 Figure 5-6 Figure 5-7 Figure 5-8 Figure 6-1 Figure 6-2 Figure 6-3 Figure 6-4 Figure 6-5 Figure 6-6 Figure 6-7 Figure 6-8
Geometry for Wave Cancellation The Fresnel Zone Concept Techniques for Trapping Null Producing Rays Reflective Screen Configuration Use of Reflective Screen Reflection from a Perfect Earth Radio Horizon Geometry Typical Fading Characteristics Diffraction Across a Hill Standard High Altitude Service Volume Standard Low Altitude Service Volume Standard Terminal Service Volume
53 56 59 60 62 63 66 66 67 68 70 70 71
Definition of the Lower Edge of the Standard T (Terminal)
Figure 6-9
Service Volume
71
Definition of the Lower Edge of the Standard H (High) and
L (Low) Service Volumes
71
6820.10 4/17/86
Page
Figure 6-10 Line of Sight Relationships 72 Figure 6-11 Radio Line of Sight (Aircraft Bélow 2OK) 73 Figure 6-12 Radio Line of Sight (Aircraft Below 1O0K) 74 Figure 6-13 VOR Signal Strength in Space - Short Range 75 Figure 6-14 VOR Signal Strength in Space - Long Range 76 Figure 6-15 Cardion DME Signal Strength in Space - Short Range 78 Figure 6-16 Cardion DME Signal Strength in Space - Long Range 79 Figure 6-17 TACAN (RTB-2) Signal Strength in Space - Short Range 80 Figure 6-18 TACAN (RTB-2) Signal Strength in Space - Long Range 81 Figure 6-19 Radiation Pattern of a Two-Path Interference Phenomena 84 Figure 6-20 Two-Path Propagation Geometry 86 Figure 6-21 Contours of Surface Refractivity Reduced-To-Sea- Level Values (No) for the United States 88 Figure 6-22 Contours of Surface Refractivity Reduced-To-Sea- Level Values (No) for the World 89 Figure 6-23 Reflection Coefficient for Sea Water 92 Figure 6-24 Reflection Coefficient for Fresh Water 93 Figure 6-25 Reflection Coefficient for Glacial Ice 94 Figure 6-26 Reflection Coefficient for Average Land, ε = 15 95 Figure 6-27 Reflection
Coefficient for Average Land, ε = 30 96 Figure 6-28 Reflection Coefficient for Marsh Land 97 Figure 6-29 Reflection Coefficient for Tundra 98 Figure 6-30 Vector Sum of Direct and Reflected Field Components 99 Figure 6-31 Earth-Gain Function, g(θ), of an Isotropic Radiator 100 Figure 6-32 Geometry for the Solution of Radiation Angle chi, X 117 Figure 6-33 Typical Normalized Free Space Directivity Pattern 119 Figure 6-34 Profile Chart Showing First Fresnel Zone Ellipses 122 Figure 6-35 Grazing Angles for Nulls as a Function of Antenna Height (For Sea Water, Frequency = 1000 Mc) 123 Figure 6-36 Grazing Angles for Nulls as a Function of Antenna Height (For Sea Water, Frequency = 1180 Mc) 124 Figure 6-37 Grazing Angles for Nulls as a Function of Antenna Height (For Fresh Water, Frequency = 1000 Mc) 125 Figure 6-38 Grazing Angles for Nulls as a Function of Antenna Height (For Fresh Water, Frequency = 1180 Mc) 126 Figure 6-39 Grazing Angles for Nulls as a Function of Antenna Height (For Average Land, Frequency = 1000 Mc) 127 Figure 6-40 Grazing Angles for Nulls as a Function of Antenna
Height (For Average Land, Frequency = 1180 Mc) 128 Figure 6-41 Distance to Mean Reflection Point for Nulls as a Function of Antenna Height (For Sea Water, Frequency = 1000 Mc) 130 Figure 6-42 Distance to Mean Reflection Point for Nulls as a Function of Antenna Height (For Sea Water, Frequency = 1180 Mc) 131 Figure 6-43 Distance to Mean Reflection Point for Nulls as a Function of Antenna Height (For Fresh Water, Frequency = 1000 Mc) 132 Figure 6-44 Distance to Mean Reflection Point for Nulls as a Function of Antenna Height (For Fresh Water, Frequency = 1180 Mc) 133
vi
4/17/86 6820.10
Page
Figure 6-45 1 Distance to Mean Reflection Point for Nulls as a Function of Antenna Height (For Average Land, Frequency = 1000 Mc) 134 Figure 6-46 Distance to Mean Reflection Point for Nulls as a Function of Antenna Height (For Average Land,
Figure 6-47 Free Space Directivity Pattern for the AT-1056/ Frequency = 1180 Mc) 135
Figure 6-48 Free Space Directivity Pattern for the OA-592/URN-3 GRA-60 At 992 Mc 136
at 992 Mc 137 Figure 6-49a Divergence Factor for an Earth-Radius Factor of 1.166 138 Figure 6-49b Divergence Factor for an Earth-Radius Factor of 1.333 139 Figure 6-49c Divergence Factor for an Earth-Radius Factor of 1.766 140 Figure 6-50a Beacon Distance as a Function of Grazing Angle (Antenna Height 5 to 35 Feet, Earth-Radius Factor of 1.166) 141 Figure 6-50b Beacon Distance as a Function of Grazing Angle (Antenna Height 35 to 80 Feet, Earth-Radius Factor of 1.166) 142 Figure 6-50c Beacon Distance as a Function of Grazing Angle (Antenna Height 80 to 130 Feet, Earth-Radius Factor of 1.166) 143 Figure 6-50d Beacon Distance as a Function of Grazing Angle (Antenna Height 130 to 200 Feet, Earth-Radius Factor of 1.166) 144 Figure 6-51a Beacon Distance as a Function of Grazing Angle (Antenna Height 5 to 35 Feet, Earth-Radius Factor of 1.333) 145 Figure 6-51b Beacon Distance as a Function of Grazing Angle (Antenna Height 35 to 80 Feet, Earth-Radius Factor of 1.333) 146 Figure 6-51c Beacon Distance as a Function of Grazing Angle (Antenna Height 80 to 130 Feet, Earth-Radius Factor of 1.333)
147 Figure 6-51d Beacon Distance as a Function of Grazing Angle (Antenna Height 130 to 200 Feet, Earth-Radius Faotor of 1.333) 148 Figure 6-52a Beacon Distance as a Function of Grazing Angle (Antenna Height 5 to 35 Feet, Earth-Radius Factor of 1.766) 149 Figure 6-52b Beacon Distance as a Function of Grazing Angle (Antenna Height 35 to 80 Feet, Earth-Radius Factor of 1.766) 150 Figure 6-52c Beacon Distance as a Function of Grazing Angle (Antenna Height 80 to 130 Feet, Earth-Radius Factor of 1.766) 151 Figure 6-52d Beacon Distance as a Function of Grazing Angle (Antenna Height 130 to 200 Feet, Earth-Radius Factor of 1.766) 152 Figure 7-1 Reflector Surface Dimensions (Fresnel First Zone) Contributing to Scalloping 154
v1i
4/17/86 6820.10
Page
Figure 7-2 Graphic Values of PD 155 Figure 7-3 Graphic Values of PE 156 Figure 7-4 Graphic Values of PF 157 Figure 7-5 Directional Reflector (Short Length) 160 Figure 7-6 Directional Reflector (Long Length) 160 Figure 7-7 Scalloping Amplitude Versus Angle of Incidence 161 Figure 7-8 Spread of Course Scalloping Amplitude 162 Figure 7-9 Relative Scalloping Amplitude Due to Long Reflectors 163 Figure 7-10 Scalloping Amplitude Versus Azimuth Angle Between Aircraft and Re-Radiator 165 Figure 7-11 Non-Directional Re-Radiator 166 Figure 7-12 Scalloping as a Function of Geometry 166 Figure 7-13 Relative Scalloping Amplitude Versus Height and Distance of Interfering Object 167 Figure 7-14 Relative Scalloping Amplitude Versus Aircraft Elevation Angle 168 Figure 7-15 Relative Scalloping Amplitude Versus Aircraft Elevation Angle and Height of Interfering Object 169 Figure 7-16 Relationships Between Distances and Scalloping Amplitude 170 Figure 7-17 Relationships Between Interfering Objects Heights and Scalloping Amplitude 171 Figure 7-18 Non-Directional Re-Radiator 172 Figure 7-19 Variation in
Scalloping Frequency with Change in Value of ro/d1 174 Figure 7-20 Further Variation in fs with Change in Value of ro/d 174 Figure 7-21 Scalloping Frequency Variation with Change in Aircraft Azimuth 175 Figure 7-22 Scalloping Frequency Variation Along Line of Maximum Scalloping Amplitude 176 Figure 7-23 Directional Reflector 177 Figure 7-24 Scalloping Frequency on Orbital Flight as a Function of Angle of Incidence 177 Figure 7-25 Variation in Scalloping Frequency for Various Angles of Incidence 178 Figure 7-26 Variation in Scalloping Frequency at the Angle of Incidence of 55 Degrees 179 Figure 7-27 Variation in Scalloping Frequency at the Angles of Incidence of 45 Degrees and 73 Degrees 180 Figure 7-28 Nondirectional Re-Radiator 181 Figure 7-29 Scalioping Frequency Along Radial of Maximum Scalloping Amplitude; ro/d1 = 10 to 100 182 Figure 7-30 Scalloping Frequency Aiong Radial of Maximum Scalloping Amplitude; ro/d, = 1 to 10 183 Figure 7-31 Typical Scalloping Response for VOR Receiver 184 Figure 7-32a Scalloping Amplitude 186 Figure 7-32b Scalloping Frequency 186 Figure 8-1 Sample
Wire Problem 188 Figure 8-2a Length of Wire Segments (Segment 1) 190 Figure 8-2b Length of Wire Segments (Segment 2) 190 Figure 8-3 Body of Revolution 191 Figure 8-4 Short Wire in a VOR Field 194
viii
Table 1-1
LIST OF TABLES
Page
Summary Definitions of Short Distance Navigation Systems
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1-2
Table 2-1 Table 2-2 Table 3-1 Table 5-1 Table 5-2 Table 5-3 Table 6-1 Table 6-2 Table 6-3
Table 6-4
Summary Comparison of Basic Characteristics of Conventional VOR and DVOR Useful Parameters in Site Evaluation Types of Multipath and Reflection Longitudinal Multipath: TACAN Compared with VOR Exploration of Multipath Causes Minimization of VOR Lateral Multipath Ground Clearance Required for First Fresnel Zone Standard Service Volume Designator Elimination of VOR Longitudinal Multipath Brewster's Angle,ψ B, and Number of Nulls for Selected Surface Conditions (3 pages)
2
7 18 20 32 52 58 60 69 83
102
Null Numbers Below and Above Brewster's Angle at 1000 and
1180 Mc for Selected Surface·Conditions and k = 1.333 (12 pages)
105
ix (and x)
4/17/86 6820.10
CHAPTER 1. GENERAL
CHAPTER 1. GENERAL
1. PURPOSE. This order provides guidance and reference material to be used in certain practical applications of the very high frequency omnidirectional radio range (VOR), VOR with distance measuring equipment (VOR/DME), and VOR with tactical air navigation (VORTAC) in the Federal Aviation Administration's (FAA's) National Airspace System (NAS). The order deals with the procedures and techniques that apply to the initial evaluation, selection, and acquisition of sites for these navigational aids. It deals with site improvement and the minimization of performance degradation due to multipath. Finally, the order provides guidance for the colocation of equipments and antenna structures when such colocation involves VOR, VOR/DME, or VORTAC installations.
2. DISTRIBUTION. This order is distributed to division level in the Program Engineering and Maintenance and Systems Engineering Services, in the Offices of Airport Standards and Flight Operations, and the Aviation Standards National Field divisions in Washington headquarters; to branch level in the regional Airway Facilities divisions and to the Airway Facilities sectors, sector field offices, sector field office units, and sector field units.
3. CANCELLATION. Order 6700.11, VOR/VORTAC Siting Criteria dated August 7, 1968, is canceled.
4. BACKGROUND. The first two chapters in this order provide an introduction and an overview of the subject matter. Chapters 3, 4, and 5 deal with site evaluation, acquisition, and improvement, respectively. These are intended to be the "how-to-do-it" chapters. Chapters 6, 7, and 8 represent in-depth presentations of technical information useful in the siting process. Chapters 6 and 7 present results from analysis of wave propagation and interference. These results have been used in summary fashion or by reference in the earlier chapters. Chapter 8 presents information on computer simulation models that have proven to be useful in the applications of interest here.
5. DEFINITIONS.
a. VOR, as its name indicates, is a navigational aid that operates in the very high frequency (vhf) band of the radio spectrum and that radiates uniformly in azimuth. Specifically, this facility operates between 108 MHz and 118 MHz and provides azimuth guidance to the pilot in the form of a visual display. There are two general types of VOR systems being used by the FAA, namely, the conventional VOR and the Doppler VOR.
b. DME is used for measuring the slant range between the aircraft and spectrum. the facility. It operates in the 960- to 1215-MHz portion of the radio
Chap 1 Par 1 Page 1
6820.10 4/17/86
c. VOR/DME refers to associated VOR and DME systems. VOR and DME are the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) standard for navigation.
d. Tactical air navigation (TACAN) was developed by the military, which accounts for the term "tactical." It operates in the same frequency range as DME and provides omnidirectional azimuth information primarily for military users of the NAS and distance information to all users of NAS. The distance measuring portion of the TACAN is compatible with the DME described above.
e. VORTAC refers to associated VOR and TACAN navigational facilities providing both azimuth and distance information to all users of the NAS.
f. The systems to be considered are presented in table 1-1. The VORTAC combination of systems is also referred to as the VOR/DME/TACAN system and is the short distance navigation system providing navigational signals to properly equipped civil and military aircraft (see also figure 1-1). For further details refer to FAA Order 9840.1, U.S. National Aviation Standard for the VOR/DME/TACAN Systems, September 9, 1982.
TABLE 1-1. SUMMARY DEFINITIONS OF SHORT DISTANCE NAVIGATION SYSTEMS
TABLE 1-1. SUMMARY DEFINITIONS OF SHORT DISTANCE NAVIGATION SYSTEMS
Designation Type of Facility
VOR vhf navigational facility, omnidirectional azimuth only
DME uhf navigational facility, distance only
TACAN uhf navigational facility, omnidirectional azimuth and distance
VOR/DME associated VOR and DME navigational facilities
VORTAC associated VOR and TACAN navigational facilities
6. APPLICATION. The criteria set forth in this order apply only to new establishments or relocated facilities. Changes to existing facilities for the sole purpose of obtaining compliance with this criteria are not required.
Chap 1 Page 2 Par 5
VOR-equipped
Fig. 1-I(a) VOR Service
VOR/DME-equipped
Azimuth
Tig. 1-1(b) VOR/DHE Service
VOR/DHE-equipped
Azimuth
VOR
Distance
DHE
VOR
TACAN-equipped
Distance
TACAN-equipped
Diatance
Asimuth
Fig. 1-1(c) vORTAC Service
VOR/DHE-equipped
Dietance
Pig. 1-H(d) TACAN Service
TACAN
VOR
TACAN
Azimuth & Distance
TACAN-equipped
Azimuth & Distance
FIGURE 1-1. SHORT RANGE NAVAID GROUND STATION ARRANGEMENTS
FIGURE 1-1. SHORT RANGE NAVAID GROUND STATION ARRANGEMENTS
Chap 1 Par 6
6820.10 4/17/86
7. SYSTEM CONCEPTS.
a. VOR.
(1) Both conventional VOR and Doppler VOR operate in the 108- to 118-MHz frequency band. Both VORs provide separate 30-Hz am and fm signals to the airborne avionics for phase comparison to determine the azimuth of the aircraft from the vOR site at a given time. The phase difference between the two 30-Hz modulation components is equal to the azimuth (in degrees clockwise from magnetic North) from the VOR site.
(2) Conventional VOR provides a 996O-Hz subcarrier modulated with a fixed-phase 30-Hz fm and a 30-Hz am whose phase is lagging the 30-Hz fm component proportional to the azimuth of the avionics from the vOR. Doppler VOR provides a 9960-Hz subcarrier modulated with a fixed 30-Hz am and a 30-Hz fm advancing counterclockwise, which also produces a phase difference proportional to the azimuth of the avionics from the VOR.
(3) The aircraft avionics is indifferent to whether its input signal is conventional or Doppler vOR. The avionics simply recovers the 30-Hz am and the 30-Hz fm, determines how much the am lags the fm, and displays that phase difference as azimuth from the VOR.
b. Conventional VOR.
(1) The VOR operates on the principle that measurement of the phase difference between two signals can be employed to determine azimuth if one of the signals maintains a fixed phase through 360 degrees and serves as a reference, and the phase of the second signal is made to vary as a direct function of azimuth. In practice, two 30-Hz signals are used and are termed the "reference phase" signal and the "variable phase" signal.
(2) The analogy used to describe VOR is that of a light bulb in the center of a large circle with 360 light bulbs each one degree apart on the circumference. The center bulb and the one due north are pulsed to light at the same time; then each bulb clockwise is pulsed to light in turn so that in 1/30th of a second the complete circle of bulbs is traversed and, once more, the center bulb and the north bulb light simultaneously. An observer, located on the north radial, would establish his direction by observing that the two bulbs in his line of vision were illuminated simultaneously. An observer on another radial would establish his azimuth by measuring the time delay between the illumination of the two bulbs in his line of vision.
(3) A pair of dipole antennas placed close together along the northsouth line in a common equatorial plane and fed with electromagnetic (em) energy of equal amplitude but opposite phase will radiate a cosine pattern in that plane.
Chap 1 Page 4 Par 7
4/17/86 6820.10
Consider such a pair of dipoles oriented along a northwest-southeast line. If the radio frequency (rf) carrier is modulated with a sinusoid of angular frequency, then the radiated pattern can be expressed as:
e NW-SE = E, cos 0 cos W t
A second pair of dipoles mounted concentric and coplanar with the first pair but aligned along the northeast-southwest line can, with proper adjustment be made to provide the pattern:
e NE-SW = E, sin 0 sin W_t m
The resultant field is a double sideband suppressed-carrier signal, with the sidebands in phase quadrature:
e e NW-SE e NE-SW E1 cos 0 cos Wt - sin 0 sin Wt m
= E1 cos W t
Thus the envelope of the carrier has a phase delay that varies one degree electrically for each degree of physical azimuth. To eliminate the symmetry, which is added to yield the final field amplitude of: causes a 180-degree ambiguity, an omnidirectional signal of constant amplitude
e TOT E E cos (Wmt + 0) m
which yields a limacon rotating at the angular frequency W m See figure 1-2.
b) Pattern of second set of dipoles Pattern of one set of dipoles
00 00
c) Rotation field from the two dipole d) Effect of addition of omnidirectional field NOTE: Shape of pstteros is approxioste.
FIGURE 1-2. COMPONENTS OF THE VOR RADIATION PATTERN
Chap 1 Par 7 Page 5
4/17/86 6820.10
(4) In conventional VOR, the variable-phase 30-Hz signal is radiated as a double sideband suppressed carrier (DSB-SC) modulation. The composite modulated signal, made up of a carrier and two sidebands in quadrature, is structured as three separate signals radiated independently which are combined in the receiver detector. This technique of space modulation is susceptible to multipath interference, since each radiated signal component may take a slightly different path to the receiver. Space modulation contrasts with the more conventional modulation techniques wherein the complete composite signal is created within the transmitting equipment, and the components travel together to the receiver.
FIGURE 1-2. COMPONENTS OF THE VOR RADIATION PATTERN
(5) In the 4-loop antenna array, the modulated rf carrier containing the 30-Hz reference signal is fed, through a bridge network, to each of the four loops in phase. This provides the desired composite carrier circular (omnidirectional) radiation pattern. For the variable-phase signal, two separate sets of 30-Hz sidebands are generated by a rotating capacitor goniometer. The phase of one sideband varies as the sine of the goniometer angle. The phase of the second varies as the cosine of the goniometer angle. In the most recent equipment, the goniometer has been replaced with solid-state circuitry which performs the same function. The combination of the relationship of sideband signals and antenna geometry results in a radiated signal whose phase angle is a direct measure of azimuth as illustrated in figure 1-2 and the associated discussion. In the aircraft, presuming no distortions from multipath, the phases of the reference and the variable signals are compared to determine a line of position along which the phase difference is constant.
(6) Phase coherence in the 30-Hz reference and variable signals is obtained in the older equipment through electromechanical coupling and, in more recent equipment, through solid-state circuitry.
c. Doppler VOR.
(1) The Doppler VOR, DVOR uses a completely different method from that of conventional vOR for generating the azimuth information but, nevertheless, may be used with the conventional VOR aircraft receiver. If a distant radiating source is rotating sufficiently rapidly to create a noticeable Doppler shift, an aircraft properly instrumented can determine when the radiating source is in line with the aircraft and the center of rotation by the disappearance of the Doppler shift.
(2) The generation of the radiated variable-frequency DVOR signal is usually explained in terms of an analogy. Imagine a single radiating antenna located at the end of a 22-foot beam and rotating about a central point at the rate of 30 revolutions per second (rps). At the midfrequency of the 108- to 118-MHz VOR band, 113 MHz, this rotational motion causes a frequency deviation of +/-480 Hz due to the Doppler effect. An antenna located at the center of rotation radiates a signal which differs in frequency by 9960 Hz from the center frequency of the rotating radiator. The beating of these two frequencies in the receiver produces a 9960-Hz subcarrier which is frequency modulated at a 30-Hz rate by the +/-480-Hz deviation in the radiation from the rotating antenna. The deviation ratio of 16 of the 30-Hz fm is the variable signal in DVOR which fm capture effect protects from the interfering effects of multipath or noise.
Chap 1 Page 6 Par 7
4/17/86 6820.10
(3) In the DVOR, the antenna field which simulates the single rotating antenna is made up of 50 separate antennas equally spaced in a circle of 22-foot radius. The 50 antennas are fed em energy sequentially to simulate the rotation. In older models of DVOR, the energy distribution is by means of an electromechanical distributor rotating at 30 rps. More recent models achieve the same effect with solid-state circuitry and electronic switching.
(4) The 30-Hz am reference phase signal for DVOR is carried as DSB-SC modulation on the carrier frequency and radiated from a centrally located antenna. The signal is less susceptible to multipath than is the equivalent DSB-SC space modulated signal in conventional VOR. The DVOR 30-Hz reference signal, however, should be carefully filtered in the airborne receiver if the best performance is to be achieved from DVOR.
(5) DVOR exists in the double sideband Doppler VOR (DSBDVOR) and single sideband Doppler VOR (SSBDVOR) versions. If the rotating distributor feeds rf energy simultaneously to oppositely located circumferential antennas, a double sideband Doppler signal is produced. Tests have revealed. that DSBDvOR is much less susceptible to errors due to a coaxially located VOR and TACAN antennas than is SSBDVOR and, hence, may be superior for some applications.
(6) A summary comparison of the basic characteristics of conventional VOR and DVOR is contained in table 1-2. The conventional VOR and DVOR sites are generally similar but readily distinguished because of the multiple DVOR sideband antennas. See figures 1-3 and 1-4.
TABLE 1-2. SUMMARY COMPARISON OF BASIC CHARACTERISTICS OF CONVENTIONAL VOR AND DVOR
TABLE 1-2. SUMMARY COMPARISON OF BASIC CHARACTERISTICS OF CONVENTIONAL VOR AND DVOR
Parameter Conventional VOR Doppler VOR
Reference Signal 30-Hz fm, β of 16, modula- 30-Hz, DSB-SC amplitude tion of 9960-Hz subcarrier modulation of rf carrier
Variable Signal 30-Hz, DSB-SC amplitude 30-Hz fm, β of 16 modumodulation of rf carrier lation of 9960-Hz subcarrier
Rotation of Intelligence Peak amplitude rotates clockwise at rate of 30 Peak frequency deviation rotates counter-clockwise
rps at rate of 30 rps
Counterpoise 52' or 21' diameter SSBDVOR - 150' diameter DSBDVOR - 100' diameter
Chap 1 Par 7 Page 7
6820.10 4/17/86
Chap 1 Page 8 Par 7
4/17/86 6820.10
Chap 1 Par7 Page 9
d. DME.
(1) The DME operates in the 960- to 1215-MHz band to enable a properly equipped aircraft to determine its slant range to the DME site by measurement of the travel time of pulse-modulated radio waves. The aircraft transmits a radio signal to a ground station. The ground station transmits a response signal to the aircraft on a second frequency, and the DME equipment in the aircraft measures the time interval between the transmission of the interrogation signal and the reception of the reply signal. Knowing that the time delay for the round trip is proportional to distance and allowing for the delay in the groundbased equipment, the airborne instrument displays the slant distance on the distance indicator.
(2) The x-mode interrogation signal from the aircraft itself consists of two pulses spaced 12 microseconds apart, each pulse being 3-1/2 microseconds in width. The reply is very similar: an identical pair of pulses having the same pulse width and spacing but on a different frequency 63 MHz from the interrogation signal (see figure 1-5). There are a hundred DME channels allocated in the frequency range of 1041 to 1150 MHz. These are in 1-MHz steps and, of course, there are likewise 100 reply frequencies which are in the two bands, 978 to 1020 MHz and 1157 to 1215 MHz, the frequency difference being in al1 cases 63 MHz between the aircraft transmitted frequency and the reply frequency. These frequency channels, incidentally, are paired on a channel-for-channel basis with the ILS (108-112) or VOR (112-118) navigation channels between 108 and 118 MHz.
(3) The pulse replies from the ground station are mixed with many others which are replies to other aircraft. The appropriate replies must be distinguished and identified at the aircraft by their phase coherence with the original interrogation pulses.
(4) The DME antenna generally is mounted above and coaxially with the VOR antenna in the center antenna housing on the VOR counterpoise (figure 1-6).
INTERROGATION 12 us
(X-MODE)
(Reply separated 63 MHz from REPLY (X-MODE) 12 us Interrogation frequency) TIME DELAY
PROPORTIONAL TO DISTANCE
PROPORTIONAL TO DISTANCE
FIGURE 1-5. DME X-MODE PULSE CHARACTERISTICS
Chap 1 Page 10 Par 7
One Version of DME Antenna
Spin Motor Compartment TACAN Antenna Base
Double Construction Lights
DME Antenna
16-Foot VOR Plastic Cone
FIGURE 1-6.
TACAN Antenna
Cable Entrance Box Top Mounting Fixture w/cover Louver on Two Sides
FIGURE 1-5. DME X-MODE PULSE CHARACTERISTICS
NOTE: An actual installation would have either a TACAN antenna or a DME antenna, but not both.
VOR Antenna
VOR Polarization Pedestal
Counterpoise Deck
fguipment Ceiling
Transition Line Monitor Line Power Cable
HOUSING FOR COAXIALLY MOUNTED NAVAID ANTENNAS
Chap 1 Par 7
4/17/86 6820.10
HOUSING FOR COAXIALLY MOUNTED NAVAID ANTENNAS
The TACAN Azimuth Determining Subsystem.
(1) The azimuth-determining TACAN subsystem, operating in the same frequency range as DME, utilizes a single radiated pattern rotating at 15 rps to provide a signal variable with azimuth in a scheme similar to that of conventional vOR. Superimposed upon this pattern is one rotating at 135 rps which provides a fine structure for a more accurate determination of azimuth than could be obtained from the 15-rps signal alone. The 15-Hz and 135-Hz signals appear as amplitude modulation of the train of DME pulse pairs. See figure 1-5. When such pulse pairs are not sufficiently frequent to support the am signals, additional randomly spaced pulse pairs called squitter pulses must be generated. A reference signal, called the North reference burst, is transmitted for each revolution of the director elements. Eight additional signals, called auxiliary reference bursts, are transmitted between North reference bursts, dividing each North reference burst cycle into nine equal parts. Since the coded characteristics of the different signals are not relevant to siting problems, they are not presented herein. For details on the signal coding, see MIL-STD-219A, Standard Tactical Air Navigation (TACAN) Signals.
(2) The 15-Hz and 135-Hz modulation signals are developed by mechanically rotating passive elements within the TACAN antenna assembly. See figure 1-7. The resulting radiation pattern developed in terms of the various contributing elements in the radiating antenna structure is shown graphically in figure 1-8. For a more detailed discussion, refer to the text by Greco and Reed entitled, TACAN - Principles and Siting Criteria published in 1968 by the Naval Electronic Systems Test and Evaluation Facility (renamed Naval Electronic Systems Engineering Activity, Code 0242, St. Inigoes, MD 20684).
(3) Figure 1-9 illustrates the bearing location of a receiver with respect to the TACAN beacon. The TACAN antenna assembly is aligned so that the omnidirectional reference burst is emitted when the maximum of the cardiod pattern is pointed to the geographic east. Figure 1-9 is a simplification to the extent that the 135-Hz fine structure is suppressed. As shown in the figure, the observer located due north of the TACAN antenna receives the coded reference burst on the 15-Hz sinusoid on its negative slope halfway between the maximum and minimum points.
(4) In practice, most TACAN airborne equipments utilize the North reference burst and the 15-Hz am to determine the azimuth of the TACAN transmitter within a 40-degree section ("coarse" bearing), and then utilize the auxiliary reference bursts and the 135-Hz am to determine the actual station azimuth within the 40-degree sector ("fine" bearing). The "fine" bearing provides a 9-to-1 improvement over the "coarse" 40-degree sectors in determining the azimuth.
Chap 1 Page 12 Par 7
4/17/86 6820.10
135-CYCLE MODULATION DIRECTOR ELEMENTS MECHANICAL ROTATION AT 15 RPS CENTRAL ANTENNA ARRAY
135-CYCLE MODULATION DIRECTOR ELEMENTS MECHANICAL ROTATION AT 15 RPS CENTRAL ANTENNA ARRAY
15-CYCLE MODULATION PERSPECTIVE VIEW PLAN VIEW REFLECTOR ELEMENT
FIGURE 1-7.. THE TACAN ANTENNA CONCEPT
N
CEKTRAL ANTEHHA ARRAT
ROTATION
E FUNDIMONTAL PARLSITIC
Sth HAROHIC PARASITIC LLDOITS S S
Sth HAROHIC PARASITIC LLDOITS S S
HORIZONTAL PATTERY OF HOOULATIOH b. HORIZOHTAL PLTTTFI OF HOCUAT1CH BY ISHZ FUNOLOHTAL FRLCUDICT 8T 135 -KZ 1REQUEXT 191A KAROHIC αf 15 H2) N
E
C. HOR1ZOA PATTERH C-BIN111OH DF d. RADIATIOH PATTLRY OF THE ANTD HOOULATIOH BY FUHDHOHNAL AND 9Ih HURHONIC
FIGURE 1-8. COMPONENTS OF THE TACAN RADIATION PATTERN
FIGURE 1-8. COMPONENTS OF THE TACAN RADIATION PATTERN
Chap 1 Par 7 Page 13
NORTH
NORTHEAST
45°
WEST
270°
NORTH SIGNAL
NORTHEAST SIGNAL
WEST SIGNAL
EAST
TRANSMISSION OF OMNIDIRECTIONAL REFERENCE PULSE
NORTH BURST MID-AMPLITUDE LINE
090* 270• 180• 090 0.
NORTH BURST .707 AMPLITUDE MID-AMPLITUDE LINE
45·0° 270° 180 90° 45 0• SQUITTER PULSES
NORTH BURST
NORTH BURST
90 270° 180° 90 0• 270° REF BEARING ANGLE
FIGURE 1-9. ILLUSTRATING GEOGRAPHIC BEARING FROM BEACON
Chap 1 Par 7
4/17/86 6820.10
CHAPTER 2. OVERVIEW OF LOCATION AND COVERAGE CONSIDERATIONS
8. GENERAL. This chapter provides general background on the subject of the siting of VOR, VOR/DME, and VORTAC as an introduction to chapters 3, 4, and 5 which deal with site evaluation, acquisition, and improvement, respectively.
CHAPTER 2. OVERVIEW OF LOCATION AND COVERAGE CONSIDERATIONS
a. When a TVOR or VORTAC is installed on an airport, the facility should be located, if possible, in an area adjacent to the intersection of the principle runways in order to provide approach guidance to the ends of these runways. To prevent the facility from being an obstruction to aircraft, it should not be located closer than 500 feet to the centerline of any runway or 250 feet to the centerline of a taxiway. Additionally, no part of the facility shall penetrate any surface defined in paragraphs 77.25, 77.28, or 77.29 of the Federal Aviation Regulations.
b. When located off an airport, consideration shall be given to selecting a site so that one or more of the course radials will provide an approach procedure to the primary bad weather runway in accordance with chapter 4 or chapter 5 of FAA Order 8260.3B, United States Standard for Terminal Instrument Procedures.
c. TVOR/VORTAC facilities on airports come under paragraph 77.15(c) of the Federal Aviation Regulations and do not require submission of a Notice of Construction or Alteration.
d. All of the navaids under consideration use either the phase difference between sinusoids of the same modulating frequercy, or the time difference between pulses, or in the VORTAC azimuth determination a hybrid of the two. DVOR may be considered a special case of phase difference determination. In brief, the information is contained in the modulation rather than in the carrier. The modulation is at a much lower frequency than is the carrier. It follows that phase, amplitude, or frequency distortion of the modulation will usually cause performance errors, and similarly, momentary phase, amplitude, or frequency distortions of the rf carrier are not ordinarily of concern. An exception to this statement is noted below.
e. The one situation where interactions at rf are of critical importance is that where the combination of the direct ray and the interfering ray due to longitudinal multipath results in destructive interference causing a null in the radiation pattern at a specific elevation angle. The complete destruction of the carrier destroys the modulation information as well.
f. Lateral multipath can, in certain of the navaids, cause rays emitted from the navaid ground station at different azimuth angles to meet and combine at the airborne equipment. The combination of two different modulating signals yields a resultant generally containing false bearing information.
Chap 2 Par 8 Page 15
4/17/86 6820.10
g. Note that longitudinal multipath cannot ordinarily cause errors in the modulating intelligence except, as mentioned, when it causes the serious weakening of the total signal. Similarly, lateral multipaths cannot cause nulls in the vertical radiation pattern. Figure 2-1 illustrates the two different categories of multipath. The objective of successful siting is that of avoiding the harmful effects of either type of multipath within the required coverage volume of the navaid.
h. The DME and TACAN radiations are vertically polarized. By contrast, VOR and DVOR radiations are horizontally polarized. For vertical polarization there is an angle of incidence on a smooth earth at which the reflected component, the longitudinal multipath, vanishes. This is the angle of incidence at which the radiation refracted into the ground and the reflected radiation, if it existed, would be at right angles (see figure 2-2). Related to the Brewster's angle effect is the much smaller coefficient of reflection from the ground for vertically polarized rays compared to horizontally polarized rays.
i. As shown in figure 2-3, the longitudinal multipath can result from reflection from the counterpoise and from the earth. Additionally, the diameter of the counterpoise can be selected so as to set a lower limit to the grazing angle of the radiation illuminating the earth.
j. In the material which follows and in the remainder of the order, certain parameters associated with the radiated energy will be useful. These parameters are summarized in table 2-1. Note that the quantities provided are often only approximates. For site evaluation and improvement activities, the quantities of table 2-1 will usually be found to be both convenient and sufficient. In applications requiring greater accuracy, the actual wavelength should be used and antenna heights should be determined by measurement.
k. As illustrated in figure 2-4, reflection can be specular or diffuse. Specular reflection provides a stronger signal in a specific direction than does diffuse reflection. Hence, if specular reflection causes undesirable interference, the interference can be expected to be relatively strong. Diffuse reflection from a rough surface is unpredictable in its effects. If the reflecting area is sufficiently large it can cause multipath problems. See figure 2-5 for an example of directional reflection due to periodicity in the roughness.
l. Judgement is required to determine whether or not a particular ground will be seen as rough or smooth by the electromagnetic energy. The criterion that is usually used is the Rayleigh criterion. See figure 2-6 and note that for small grazing angles a very irregular ground can act as a smooth reflective surface.
m. The brief review of the discussion of multipath is summarized in table 2-2.
Chap 2 Page 16 Par 8
4/17/86 6820.10
lateral multipath
direct ray longitudinal multipath
north-south line east-west line
FIGURE 2-1. TYPES OF MULTIPATH
FIGURE 2-1. TYPES OF MULTIPATH
Type of Earth Brewster's Angle at 1000 MHz (Approx)
Marshland 100 Average Desert 150 30 0
reflected incident π/2(vanishes)
refracted
FIGURE 2-2. THE VANISHING OF REFLECTIONS AT BREWSTER'S ANGLE
Chap 2 Par 8 Page 17
6820.10 4/17/86
direct ray reflected
FIGURE 2-2. THE VANISHING OF REFLECTIONS AT BREWSTER'S ANGLE
reflected
FIGURE 2-3. TWO LEVEL LONGITUDINAL MULTIPATH
TABLE 2-1. USEFUL PARAMETERS IN SITE EVALUATION
Ht Above Max. Freq. rf Nominal rf Counter- of System Carrier Wavelength Polarization poise* Modulation Modulation
VOR/ 108-118 8 ft Horizontal 4.0 ft Sinusoid 10,540 Hz DVOR MHz (DSB-SC)
TABLE 2-1. USEFUL PARAMETERS IN SITE EVALUATION
DME 962-1213 1 ft Vertical 11.5 ft Pulse 1 MHz#* MHz
TACAN 962-1213 1 ft Vertical 20.5 ft Pulse & 1 MHz*# MHz Sinusoid
Height of effective radiating center above counterpoise. The figures given here are only approximate and should be checked for a specific installation. Counterpoise height is usually 12' but it also may vary; typical diameters are 52 feet and 21 feet (VOR), 150 feet (SSBDVOR), and 100 feet (DSBDVOR).
Estimated on the basis of pulse rise time of 2.5 + 0.5 - 1.0 microseconds.
Chap 2 Page 18 Par 8
SPECULAR REFLECTION
SPECULAR REFLECTION
DIFFUSE REFLECTION
EFFECTS OF TERRAIN IN PRODUCING SPECULAR & DIFFUSE REFLECTION
FIGURE 2-4.
NON-UNIFORM ROUGHNESS
ROUGHNESS WITH A PERIODIC STRUCTURE (INTERFEROMETER EFFECT)
EFFECT OF PERIODICITY IN SURFACE ROUGHNESS
FIGURE 2-5.
Chap 2 Par 8
4/17/86 6820.10
30†
EFFECT OF PERIODICITY IN SURFACE ROUGHNESS
h h 28.7 2 14.3 3 9.6 20 4 7.2 5 5.7 Rayleigh Roughness Criterion = 6 4.8
in 8 7 3.6 4.1 h > 16 Sin γ
h 10 9 3.2 2.9 NOTE: Curve based on a VOR λ 8'. For TACAN Radiation (λ≈1')
the height of boundary 10 between rough and smooth is smaller by a factor of 8. smooth ground Luugh grouna
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
γ in degrees
FIGURE 2-6. THE RAYLEIGH ROUGHNESS CRITERION
FIGURE 2-6. THE RAYLEIGH ROUGHNESS CRITERION
TABLE 2-2. TYPES OF MULTIPATH AND REFLECTION
Type or Parameter Consideration
Longitudinal Causes nulls in the vertical radiated pattern
Lateral Causes interference in modulated information
Horizontal Angular location of destructive longitudinal multi- Polarization path is a matter of geometry
TABLE 2-2. TYPES OF MULTIPATH AND REFLECTION
Vertical Brewster angle effect eliminates some longitudinal Polarization multipath
Specular Strong interference at specific angles
Diffuse Interference weaker generally but occurs over a wide range of angles than does specular reflection
Chap 2 Page 20 Par 8
4/17/86 6820.10
9. CONSIDERATIONS OF VERTICAL MULTIPATH.
a. General. Vertical multipath causes nulls in the vertical pattern of radiation and this in turn causes loss of signal in the airborne receiver. Hence, it is important in site analysis to identify those features that may lead to excessive multipath problems. Because of the different wavelengths, geometries, and problem details, vertical multipath for VOR, DME, and TACAN are considered separately.
b. Vertical Multipath in VOR.
(1) Refer to figure 2-3. Vertical multipath in VOR can result from reflection from the counterpoise and from the ground. Counterpoise reflections cause a null in the vertical pattern at an elevation angle of approximately 60 degrees. Since primary interest is in elevation angles of less than 10 degrees, this is of little importance. The elevation angles at which destructive muitipath takes place due to ground reflection can be determined (see figure 2-7) from:
E(γ) = cos [γ + kh sin γ] - sin [γ - kh sin γ]
= 1/2 cos γ sin [kh sin Y]
where the first term represents the antenna radiation pattern and the second term, the effect of the multipath.
Direct
Reflected A = Source of radiation.
B = Apparent source of reflected radiation.
C = Source of combined radiation as seen by dfstant (Assuzad perfect Ground receiver. conductor) D = Point of reflection. hsin Y
FIGURE 2-7. VERTICAL MULTIPATH
FIGURE 2-7. VERTICAL MULTIPATH
Chap 2 Par 9 Page 21
6820.10 4/17/86
The pattern has nulls where
sin [kh sin γ ]= 0
γ = sin -1 [2] [n]
when n = 1, 2, ....
(2) The usual 52-foot diameter counterpoise prevents DME antenna rays at angles greater than about 24 degrees from illuminating the ground. Similarly, the counterpoise prevents TACAN antenna rays greater than about 38 degrees from illuminating the ground. Because of the short wavelength of the TACAN and the height of the TACAN and DME antennas above the counterpoise, longitudinal multipath cannot be entirely prevented. As an example, DME destruction multipath will occur at about 1/2 degree if the ground is only 30 feet below ground level at the antenna site. See figure 2-8.
TACAN 38
DME 24
VOR
FIGURE 2-8. SHOWING EFFECT OF THE COUNTERPOISE IN LIMITING GROUND ILLUMINATION
FIGURE 2-8. SHOWING EFFECT OF THE COUNTERPOISE IN LIMITING GROUND ILLUMINATION
Consideration of Longitudinal Multipath for DME and TACAN.
(1) It is readily seen from paragraph 5.b.(1) that for the shorter wavelengths of DME and TACAN there will be many more possibilities for destructive longitudinal multipath than there were for VOR. The vertical pattern has nulls when
n = 1, 2, 3, …
For a given h and for the smaller wavelength there is a greater range of the integer n before [nλ/2h] > 1, and for each such integer there is an angle γn at which a null can occur.
Chap 2 Page 22 Par 9
4/17/86 6820.10
(2) From figure 2-8, the counterpoise provides less angular blocking of DME and VORTAC rays from the ground. Hence, destructive longitudinal multipath can occur for a greater range of vertical angles for these two navaids.
(3) The first Fresnel zone for DME and TACAN is much smaller than for VOR. The width and length are reduced to approximately 1/3 the values for VOR and the total area is reduced by a factor of approximately 8. (See Chapter 3, figure 3-3.)
(4) The single favorable factor, of those discussed, which would make it more difficult to have destructive longitudinal multipath with DME and TACAN, is that greater ground smoothness is required for these shorter wavelength navaids. Note, for example that at nine degrees, a ground height variation of only 0.4 foot or about 5 inches makes the ground too rough for specular DME or TACAN reflection.
10. CONSIDERATIONS OF LATERAL MULTIPATH.
a. Lateral multipath involves the mutual interference between signals radiated at two different azimuth bearings. One is the direct ray. The second, the interfering ray, contains different navigational information than does the direct ray. The mix of the two modulations in the airborne receiver results in incorrect information being presented to the pilot.
b. In an idealized environment in which the ground based antenna site was surrounded by a smooth earth, it would be possible to have destructive longitudinal multipath. It would not, however, under these circumstances, be possible to have destructive lateral multipath. The requirement for lateral multipath to exist is that there be obstacles in the radiation field that accept radiation at one azimuth angle and reflect it off in a different direction either in a specular or a diffuse fashion.
c. Obstacles will exist in the radiation field and may consist of buildings that cannot be removed, telephone wires, power lines, and antennas for other FAA equipments. This order provides information on how to determine the effects caused by obstacles and how to minimize or eliminate such effects.
Chap 2 Par 9 Page 23 (and 24)
4/17/86 6820.10
CHAPTER 3. SITE EVALUATION
CHAPTER 3. SITE EVALUATION
11. GENERAL.
a. This chapter provides information to aid in the process of evaluating a site as a candidate Ipcation for any combination of the VOR, TACAN, and DME. It also provides information which may be used to evaluate the effect that physical changes proposed in the area of a site may be expected to have on the performance of existing navigational aids. Such changes can occur as areas evolve from rural to urban characteristics. Additionally, antenna systems of various kinds may be brought into the vicinity of the VORTAC/DME site as part of site consolidation efforts. The presence of these additional facilities can impact on navaids performance. This chapter also deals with the practical application of the technical material available in chapters 6, 7, and 8 to the problem of site evaluation. These chapters should be consulted for additional details.
b. In this order, the antenna systems are considered only as metallic objects in the radiation field of the navigational aids. Considerations of the mutual electromagnetic interference problems that may develop as a variety of radiators are brought into close geographic proximity are beyond the scope of this order.
12. CONSIDERATIONS OF LONGITUDINAL MULTIPATH.
a. General.
(1) Ground slope and ground smoothness in the vicinty of the VOR site determines the extent to which the ground will sustain reflections that, by interfering with the direct rays, cause nulls in the vertical radiated pattern. Since there are always some vertical angles for which such destructive interference can exist, the beam is shaped to avoid illuminating the ground. VOR and DVOR radiation is inhibited from illuminating the ground by the presence of the counterpoise. This is true only for a small area less than 10 to 20 feet from the VOR. The DME radiation pattern is shaped to attenuate ground illumination through use of multiple radiating elements. The site itself is not to be expected to completely inhibit destructive reflection. Considerable judgement is required in selecting sites with satisfactory properties, and no simple rules exist for concluding that one site is superior to another insofar as longitudinal multipath is concerned.
(2) The site evaluator should determine how far from the radiating antenna position his interest should extend. There is no simple answer. Areas close to the antenna location are relatively more important than distant areas because the close-in Fresnel zones are smaller. A distant rough area will, however, look smooth to the radiation traveling at a small grazing angle. This makes it easier for the large Fresnel zone to exist. A possible rule of thumb is that primary attention should be focused on the first 1,000 feet, with secondary attention given to the surrounding mile. In addition, a cursory examination of the first five miles is required to ensure the identification of geographic areas that might cause particular difficulty.
Chap 3 Par 11 Page 25
(3) Any site can be made to be satisfactory in its longitudinal multipath performance provided that sufficient care is taken in the selection and installation of the radiating system. Although such systems are nonconventional, it is possible to use site modifications such as oversized counterpoises or additional grounding elements. Accordingly, the investigator may consider preparing qualified recommendations for sites. One site, for example, may be attractive for a number of reasons but be characterized by unusually poor ground conductivity which could result in an abrupt discontinuity in electric field boundary conditions at the perimeter of the counterpoise. A recommendation regarding this site which identified the potential problem and its implication for wavefront binding would allow the next level of management to make tradeoffs between technical, financial, and acquisition problems in choosing between alternative possibilities.
b. Longitudinal Multipath and the VOR Equipment.
(1) It was pointed out in chapter 2, in connection with figure 2-7 and the associated discussion, that nulls in the vertical radiation pattern of the VOR will appear where:
sin [kh sin γn]= 0
where -1 [2n] [nλ]
n = 1, 2, ....
Using this relationship one may develop an approximate range within which the surrounding terrain can sustain destructive multipath. See figure 3-1.
(2) Note from figure 3-1 that, in order to minimize the possibility of longitudinal multipath from the VOR antenna, the ground in the vicinity of the VOR site must be level or must fall away gently from the ground level at the base of the antenna structure. If the ground falls away too sharply, geometry necessary for destructive multipath may exist. If the ground .falls away precipitously, however, it becomes impossible to have destructive multipath because the counterpoise prevents ground illumination at angles of depression greater than 8 degrees. Finally, if the ground falls away and slopes away from the VOR, the ground slope can direct the multipath away from the direct ray. Note that the results of figure 3-1 are based on the assumption that the ground is level in the area of ground reflection. The action of a slope in reflecting energy downward cannot be relied upon since the reflection can be expected to be partly diffuse and partly specular in many cases. Regardless of how fast the terrain falls away from the VOR, there will be some terrain visible to the VOR within the service volume which will support vertical multipath.
(3) While there is no clear-cut boundary around the VOR site beyond which one is not required. to be interested in the terrain, as the distance from the site increases, the terrain features become less important. As distance from the VOR site increases, the size of the first Fresnel zone increases. Since contributions from most of the first Fresnel zone are required to obtain substantial multipath, it is evident that there is smaller probability of finding a reflecting area as large as the first Fresnel zone at a large distance from the VOR site than is the case closer in. The growth of the VOR Fresnel zone with distance is shown in figure 3-2.
Chap 3 Page 26 Par 12
4/17/86 6820.10
Distance of point of reflection "r" from VOR site.
200 407 009 008 000 000 2 000 3 0007 0005
Lower limit set by geometric 25 requirements for first null.
50 NOTE: Change of scale for Region of closer in region. 75 Destructive Multipath
oof 100
tuod 125-
Upper limit set by above 200 by counterpoise blocking of rays Region of
at angle of depres- Destructive approximatley 8°. sion greater than Multipath,
400 VOR NOTES: 1. Elevation of antenna
jo measured from center of radiation. See
600 table 2-1.
2. Land at point of multipath reflection assumed to be level. 800 3. Values are approximate.
FIGURE 3-1. GROUND SLOPE CONSIDERATIONS
(4) Figure 3-3 illustrates this point in more detail and shows that the first Fresnel zone for small angles of reflection is several miles in length at a distance of a mile from the VOR site. Considerable judgement is required when using this figure, since the Rayleigh criterion shows that, at shallow grazing angles, even very rough terrain can look smooth to the incident radiation (see figure 2-6). The large Fresnel zones required may in fact exist.
FIGURE 3-1. GROUND SLOPE CONSIDERATIONS
Chap 3 Par 12 Page 27
Page 28
5°
-500 -1000
2000
3000
4000
5000:
1796' 2308
3090'
(NOT TO SCALE)
3710'
4242
4712
FIGURE 3-2. GROWTH OF VOR FRESNEL ZONE LENGTH WITH DISTANCE
Par Chap
4/17/86
4/17/86 6820.10
Distance Range Dimensions of Fresnel Zone of Reflection of Area from Angles Range of Widths Range of Lengths VOR Site of (Feet) (Feet) in Feet Reflection (W) (x1 + x2)
FIGURE 3-2. GROWTH OF VOR FRESNEL ZONE LENGTH WITH DISTANCE
3000 4000 5000 2000 1000 2.60 3.80 2.2 2.0 1.7 0 0 to to to to to 8 8 8 8 8 0 0 0 0 0 345 - 365 389 - 409 175 - 183 251 - 258 302 - 316 2,661 - 11,871 2,978 - 15,936 2,314 - 9,579 1,377 - 3,197 1,904 - 6,743
6000 1.5 to 80 428 - 448 3,257 - 20,086
W= 2 Sin Y λ h x1 -λ Cos γ + 12 Cos Sin 2 2 γ + 4 h λ Sin γ Y
+λ Cos γ + V 12 Cos 2 γ + 4 h λ Sin γ
x2 2 Sin 2 Y.
FIRST /RESNEL ZONE T
FIRST /RESNEL ZONE T
^2 VOR ARRAY
h
FIGURE 3-3. RANGE OF SIZES FOR FIRST FRESNEL ZONE
c. Longitudinal Multipath and the DVOR Equipment.
(1) The effect of longitudinal multipath on DVOR equipment performance will be discussed in terms of a comparison between VOR, SSBDVOR, and DSBDVOR. The diameter of the counterpoise is different for the three different pieces of equipment. The height above the counterpoise of the radiating center of the antennas is four feet in all three cases. The VOR antenna, for purposes of the discussion of longitudinal multipath, can be considered to be located at the center of the counterpoise. The DVOR antennas which generate the azimuth information are located in a circle of 22-foot radius, concentric with the counterpoise center. Additionally, the VOR signal containing the
FIGURE 3-3. RANGE OF SIZES FOR FIRST FRESNEL ZONE
Chap 3 Par 12 Page 29
4/17/86 6820.10
azimuth information is a form of amplitude modulation called space modulation. Refer to figure 1-2 and the associated discussion. For both variations of DVOR, the azimuth information is carried as fm modulation with a deviation ratio, β, of 16.
(2) The DVOR azimuth information-bearing signal should be less susceptible to multipath interference because of the well-known fm threshold effect. By contrast, the VOR azimuth signal, since it involves three separately radiated amplitude-modulated signals, should be comparatively more vulnerable to multipath interference. The DVOR requires a larger counterpoise than does VOR. From any azimuth, the different antennas in the 22-foot DVOR circle experience different amounts of counterpoise, which results in a cyclic modulation on the radiated signal. In the nonlinear elements in the airborne receiver, this undesirable modulation can be transferred to other signals. The larger DVOR counterpoises diminish this asymmetrical effect, and DSBDVOR is less susceptible to the asymmetrical effects of the counterpoise than is SSBDVOR.
(3) The counterpoise's primary purpose is the sharp attenuation of the vertical radiation pattern for angles of radiation negative with respect to the horizon. The counterpoise weakens the radiated field in the direction of the horizon (see figure 3-4). There is some evidence that for every 15 feet in VOR counterpoise diameter, there is a loss of range at 1,O00-foot altitude of approximately 15 miles. Since the same effect should exist in DVOR, it is reasonable to expect the DVOR low altitude coverage to be less than that of VOR.
(4) It may be thought that the large DVOR counterpoise could itself be a reflecting surface for multipath signals. At angles of 30 degrees or more, the Fresnel zone dimensions are 20 feet or less in their longest dimension. The DVOR geometry will not sustain destructive longitudinal multipath. Presuming a good conducting counterpoise which is properly grounded, longitudinal multipath should not be a problem with DVOR installations.
(5) The reduced range of the DVOR as compared with VOR suggests that DVOR is more appropriate for terminal area applications. See table 6-1 and the associated discussion. This does not preclude the use of DVOR for enroute applications when it is determined that the DVOR will satisfy and/or improve coverage requirements. A second characteristic of DVOR supports this conclusion. The simulated doppler signal decreases with the cosine of the angle of elevation so that at 60 degrees above the horizon, the effective β of the fm modulation is only 8 rather than 16. Some airborne receivers will release the malfunction flag at this low a value of β. Additionally, because of this cosine behavior, the cone of confusion whose center is directiy above the navaid site is much larger in angular extent for DVOR than for VOR.
d. Longitudinal Multipath and the TACAN Equipment,
(1) Three factors make the analysis of longitudinal multipath effects for DME and TACAN differ from those of VOR:
(a) The wavelength for DME and TACAN is much shorter than for VOR (see table 2-1) making the Fresnel zone much smaller but requiring greater surface smoothness for specular reflection.
Chap 3 Page 30 Par 12
4/17/86 6820.10
Direction of Radiation.
3 Centerline of Antenna
2
VOR Antenna Structure
3 Centerline of Antenna
Counterpoise E
E 0
E
NOTES: Indicates vector pointing out of page.
Indicates vector pointing into page.
FIGURE 3-4. RADIATED AND REFLECTED ELECTRIC FIELD AT COUNTERPOISE
(b) The DME and TACAN radiations are vertically polarized, whereas that of VOR is horizontally polarized. Ground reflections are generally much weaker for vertical polarization. See figure 6-1.
FIGURE 3-4. RADIATED AND REFLECTED ELECTRIC FIELD AT COUNTERPOISE
(c) The effect of the counterpoise is weaker for DME and TACAN because the antennas are mounted higher above the counterpoise, both in number of wavelengths and in absolute distance, than is the VOR antenna.
(2) These factors and their effects upon longitudinal multipath are summarized in table 3-1.
(3) The smaller dimensions of the Fresnel zone for TACAN are seen by developing a figure (similar to figure 3-2) which shows the growth of the Fresnel zone with distance, figure 3-5.
(4) Consider now the ground smoothness characteristic. At 5 degrees, the variation in ground elevation within the Fresnel zone should be less than 6 feet for the ground to be considered smooth to the VOR radiation. For the TACAN or DME, however, at the same angle the variation would have to be less than 9 inches (see figure 2-6). Hence, although the smaller Fresnel zone areas of TACAN and DME make it easier to produce longitudinal multipath, the greater ground smoothness required partly compensates for the reduced area.
Chap 3 Par 12 Page 31
4/17/86 6820.10
TABLE 3-1. LONGITUDINAL MULTIPATH: TACAN COMPARED WITH VOR
TABLE 3-1. LONGITUDINAL MULTIPATH: TACAN COMPARED WITH VOR
NOTE: For purposes of this comparison DME may be associated with TACAN
Parameter Differences Effect
λ (VOR)=8 feet Total area of Fresnel zone reduced by λ (TACAN)≈1 foot a factor of 8 for TACAN compared to VOR thus facilitating TACAN longitudinal multipath.
Ground must be much smoother in the Fresnel zone area to sustain specular reflection for TACAN as compared to VOR.
Polarization VOR-Horizontally Vertically polarized radiation of TACAN of Radiation Polarized is much less strongly reflected from the TACAN-Vertically ground than is horizontally polarized Polarized radiation.
Height of VOR - 4 feet Below the horizon radiation from TACAN Radiator TACAN - 20.5 feet is not as sharply attenuated by the Above counterpoise as is that of vOR. Addi- Counterpoise tionally, counterpoise is less effective in its blocking action. See figure 2-8.
Distance (Feet) 5 200
500 530 136 50 1000 738 192 20 2000 1036 270 3000 1266 330
500' 136' 530' 4000 5000 1630 1460 428 382
1000' 192 738'
2000' 270' 1036
3000 330' 1266
4000' 382 1460
5000' 428 1630'
NOTE: Compare with figure 3-2.
FIGURE 3-5. Growth of TACAN/DME Fresnel Zone Length with Distance
Chap 3 Page 32 Par12
4/17/86 6820.10
(5) The use of vertical polarization for TACAN and DME aids in reducing the ground reflection, particularly in the angular region of the Brewster's angle. Unfortunately the Brewster's angle varies over a range of 5 to 30 degrees for various types of terrain and, in a particular geographic area, will vary with the season. Nevertheless, the effect is generally favorable to reducing longitudinal multipath. See detailed discussion in paragraph 23.f, chapter 6.
(6) The counterpoise is much less effective for TACAN and DME than it is for VOR. On the other hand, the antennas of TACAN and DME are multiple-element radiators designed to shape the pattern of radiation in the vertical plane so that energy directed toward the ground is sharply attenuated.
(7) A smooth, flat ground surface within approximately 25 feet of the navaids antenna complex will sustain longitudinal multipath from the DME at the angle of 24 degrees if the surface is smooth to within about two inches over a range of 27 feet. In most cases, the radiation at 24 degrees below the horizon will be sharply attenuated; however, the smooth, flat surface characteristic in the vicinity of the antenna complex is to be avoided.
13. CONSIDERATIONS OF LATERAL MULTIPATH.
Genera1.
(1) Lateral multipath involves the mutual interference between signals radiated at two different azimuth angles from the same antenna. These signals contain different azimuth information in their modulations.
The resultant signal, if the interference is sufficiently strong, will contain erroneous azimuth information. The interference effects arise from the combining of two modulations which are not of the same phase angle.
(2) Existing sources of lateral multipath, such as permanent structures, often cannot be removed. The investigator should consider the option of preparing qualified recommendations for such sites, identifying the potential sources of multipath and his reasons for believing that such sources may be problems. Using the techniques for minimizing lateral multipath discussed in chapter 6, the cost and probability of success of such techniques can be factored into the overall evaluation.
b. Lateral Multipath and the VOR Equipment.
(1) Lateral multipath is caused generally by objects and structures rather than by the ground itself. Hence, a discussion of lateral multipath includes such objects as long wires, trees, cylinders, planes, and combinations of these. The general guidance provided here is suppiemented by additional technical material provided in chapter 7 and, for wires and cylinders, by computer simulation techniques described in chapter 8.
(2) The previous discussion of Fresnel zones reveals that it is angular size, measured from the antenna site, rather than absolute dimensions. This is significant in determining the effect of a reradiating surface. Thus from figure 3-2, a ground surface of 1800 feet in extent can be as large in its effect as a surface extending over a mile at a longer distance. Hence, an appropriate measure of objects in the VOR field is the angle subtended by such objects at the VOR antenna.
Chap 3 Par 12 Page 33
6820.10 4/17/86
(3) A second important consideration in evaluating the potential effect of objects in the VOR field is the azimuth at which the possible lateral multipath will be experienced. At some installations, notably terminal areas, some azimuths are relatively more important than others. It is characteristic of lateral multipath that the effect is most pronounced at azimuths other than the one at which the causing object is located.
(4) A useful reference for comparison purposes is the TACAN antenna monitor and support mast. · This monitor structure will always be present in those situations where the navaids antenna complex is already installed and the site is being evaluated for possible modification. It subtends an angle of approximately 1.4 degrees at the VOR antenna and, as a reflecting re-radiator, causes a scalloping error in the VOR of about 0.2 degree at azimuths ±55 degrees from its location. See paragraph 25.b. for a more detailed discussion of directional re-radiators. Directional re-radiators of the same angular width as the TACAN antenna monitor, even though at a greater distance, can be expected to cause similar scalloping effects.
(5) Figure 3-6 is a qualitative guide to estimating the possible effect in causing lateral multipath of objects in the area of the VOR antenna. Several conclusions may be drawn from an examination of the figure, but judgement must be used in the application of these conclusions:
(a) Single trees and objects of similar angular dimensions can cause substantial lateral multipath if located within a few hundred feet of the VOR antenna. Because the VOR radiation is horizontally polarized, it is the angular extent of the tree in the horizontal plane that is significant. The height of the tree, however, enables it to project above the plane of the counterpoise.
(b) Cleared forest areas can cause scalloping.
(c) VOR does discriminate against objects which may cause severe lateral multipath.
(6) Specular reflectors and other directional reflectors have maximum scalloping amplitudes when the angle of incidence is in the region of 55 degrees. The half-power scalloping amplitudes occur for angles of 35 and 73 degrees. See figure 7-7 and the associated discussion in chapter 7.
(7) The scalloping amplitude for diffuse radiators is maximum when the azimuth of the re-radiator and the azimuth of the aircraft are at 90 degrees one to another. See figure 7-10 and the associated discussion in chapter 7.
c. Lateral Multipath and the DVOR Equipment
(1) Lateral multipath is known to involve interference for the 30-Hz modulating signal which carries the azimuth information. Lateral multipath of the reference signal cannot cause problems since the direct and multipath signals are essentially in the same phase and hence add constructively. In the Chap 3 Page 34 Par 13
Par 13 Chap
±o
SINGLE TREE CONVENTIONAL VOR
SINGLE TREE CONVENTIONAL VOR
(SRGS)
SCG MUODE tr t4 SINGLE TREE REMOVED O
RESIDUAL SCALLOPING WAIXW
100 200
FIGURE 3-6.
CLEAREO FOREST AREA CONVENTIONAL VOR
CLEARED FOREST AREA DOPPLER VOR
300 400 800 DISTANCE TO VOR ANTENNA
4/17/86
EXPERIMENTAL POINTS - SINGLE TREE EXPERIMENTAL POINTS - CLEARED AREA
EXPERIMENTAL POINTS - SINGLE TREE EXPERIMENTAL POINTS - CLEARED AREA
600 700 100
MAXIMUM SCALLOPING AMPLITUDE CAUSED BY SINGLE TREE AND BY FOREST
Page
4/17/86 6820.10
doppler VOR, the variable azimuth information is protected from interference because of the nature of fm modulation. It follows that DVOR is inherently resistant to lateral multipath.
MAXIMUM SCALLOPING AMPLITUDE CAUSED BY SINGLE TREE AND BY FOREST
(2) Site evaluation involves the identification of potential problems associated with the site and the recognition of approaches to the resolution of such problems. For sites with severe multipath problems, the DVOR may appear to be a reasonable candidate solution. DVOR has specific characteristics that should be taken into account in the development of such recommendations. The doppler shift decreases directly with the cosine of the angle of elevation, resulting in a large "cone of confusion" centered on the 90-degree angle of direct overhead. The very large DVOR counterpoise serves to reduce low angle coverage. The amount of the reduction is a function of the site elevation over average terrain in the direction of propagation. Finally, the cost and complexity of DVOR makes this equipment the practical candidate only for those sites for which few other alternatives exist. DVOR was developed originally for terminal areas, and its use has been largely restricted to such locations.
d. Special Considerations for Mountain Top Sites.
(1) It is usual to locate the VOR counterpoise directly at ground level at mountain top sites. One reason for this practice is that the low conductivity of the ground at such sites requires particular emphasis upon the best obtainable electrical connectivity between the ground and the counterpoise. A second reason is that the radiating wavefront tends to cling to the counterpoise at the counterpoise perimeter and so bend downward and direct some energy into the ground. The effect is less serious when the antenna is not elevated.
(2) Siting a VOR on a mountain top several thousand feet above surrounding terrain may result in VOR bearing errors which exceed flight check tolerances. Even with the large counterpoise on mountain top VORs, portions of the valleys may be illuminated by the VOR antenna. When this occurs, vertical lobing (longitudinal multipath) of the signal will cause nulls in the VOR vertical radiation pattern. When aircraft fly through these vertical nulls, the direct signal from the VOR is reduced compared to the reflections (lateral multipath) received from surrounding objects. This may result in bearings which are out of flight check tolerance and subsequent restrictions or shutdown of the VOR. If this condition exists, little or no improvement will be gained by installing a DVOR. A DVOR will provide significant signal improvement when lateral multipath is from relatively close objects; however, at mountain top sites where the source of the multipath may be several miles away, little improvement is gained.
e. Lateral Multipath and TACAN.
(1) Lateral multipath is more readily generated for the TACAN than for VOR because the shorter wavelength of TACAN requires a smaller Fresnel zone.
(2) Vertical wires that cause only slight multipath problems for the horizontally polarized VOR signal can cause substantial problems for the vertically polarized TACAN signal. Conversely, horizontal wires that cause serious multipath problems for VOR may have a much smaller effect on TACAN.
Chap 3 Page 36 Par 13
4/17/86 6820.10
f. Wind Turbine Generators. The recent growth of alternative energy sources has led to an increasing number of wind turbine generators and to increasing complaints of electromagnetic interference from these generators. A study at the University of Michigan (D. Sengupta and T. Senior, "Electromagnetic Interference by Wind Turbine Generator," Report No. 014438-2-F, March 1978) indicates that VOR and DVOR facilities will experience no significant degradation of performance due to the presence of wind turbine generators if the generators are sited in accordance with FAA standard guidelines for objects near VOR and DVOR facilities.
14.-15. RESERVED.
Chap 3 Par 13 Page 37 (and 38)
4/17/86 6820.10
CHAPTER 4. SITE SELECTION AND ACQUISITION
CHAPTER 4. SITE SELECTION AND ACQUISITION
16. PROCEDURE FOR SITE SELECTION.
a. General. The selection of a suitable site for a navigation facility (VOR, VOR/DME, TACAN, or VORTAC) is primarily a function of performance and cost. No candidate site shall be selected that does not satisfy the minimum performance requirement at a cost commensurate with the benefit to be received. Primarily, this order provides the siting engineer with techniques for estimating site performance and the effect on performance of various corrective measures. This chapter presents a methodology for selecting a VOR, VOR/DME, TACAN, or VORTAC site which meets the performance requirements of the system and the cost limitations of the program. Although detailed performance or cost estimates are beyond the scope of this order, a good first approximation is required for site selection and acquisition. See figure 4-1 for a flowchart of the selection process.
b. Initial Locality. The general location of a navigation facility (VOR, VOR/DME, TACAN, or VORTAC) is initially determined by its type; whether it is 3 terminal facility or an en route facility (see paragraph 21.b). The location of a terminal facility is constrained by the actual location of the airport and by the orientation of the primary instrument landing runway. The location of en route facilities is determired largely by the location of the airways which they serve and, to a lesser extent, by the distance to other facilities serving the same airways.
C Office Survey.
(1) Once the general location has been determined, candidate sites may be identified from topographic maps readily obtained from the U.S. Geological Survey of the Department of the Interior. These map studies will identify, as accurately as possible, the coordinates of the candidate sites and the locations of triangulation points or other control points. These points will permit establishment of an accurate baseline and verification of coordinates in the field.
(2) The initial office survey should develop a candidate site and several alternative sites, if possible. This will save the cost and time of additional field trips if the primary candidate is determined to be unsuitsble or unavailable. Maps of each area should be acquired, and if the installation is to be within an existing facility, all available engineering drawings describing the site should also be assembled. Other information that does not require a site visit may also be compiled at this time. This includes some or all of the following:
(a) Ownership characteristics of the land, particularly name and address of owner(s); easements, rights-of-way, or other use limitations; and zoning cr use restrictions imposed by the local political jurisdictions.
Chap 4 Par 16 Page 39 (and 40)
4/17/86 PRELIMINARY & OFFICE SURVEY
4/17/86 PRELIMINARY & OFFICE SURVEY
Identily type at tacllity required VOR, OVOR, VOR/DUE, OVOR/DME., TACAN (See, 17.h.) en route. or torminal
aeceptahle for sirr locat ton Detertar general locatty (5rr 12.b.)
Acqate tapographc map, of srea (ser. 12.c.)
petermiae three or sore occeptable lucar tons and theit coortinates. Ar this time the possihtliry of (5ee. 12.c.(2) ant uslng governoent-owned land should 14..(2)) he consudered,
Acqulre addittonal mpn of spectfic aiten (up-to-date locnl mrpn.i (See 1.r.(2)) USDA acrial photoe, caginecring drautngn of (nciiitirn, etc.)
Reseatch local land Deretmine local Land use. records of sites zontag or planning district and ad jaceat areas restrletions an ppteorial sites as required
(See. 12.r.(2)(a)) (See. 17.c.(2)(a))
De:ctminr loration of presenr and proposed torsl utlltetes, pover Linei, telephone tines, and ather construcrion rhat may affert siting
(See. 12.e.(2)(e))
Obtain vettren permission to cnter and trst sttes. This Includes coad use and access riphts
(See. 13.e)
Chap 4 Par 16
SITE SURVEY, ANALYSIS 6 TESTING
SITE SURVEY, ANALYSIS 6 TESTING
Site Sur vey:
Gather information tor sttr draulngt: (5ee. 11.4.)
• Pho(0s Harizon Prolsie Terrata fratures Structures à arat tons Sucvey Ceordliates "te
Make site dravings (Sec. 11.a. and Appendix 5)
For each candtdate site: {Sec. 13,b, and Chapter 3) • Estimate prrtorm,nce "as is" Potent ia! perlareence smprovrtents possthle Cast of implementiog acccptable taciliry
SEL,EGT CANDIDATE FOR TESTING
SEL,EGT CANDIDATE FOR TESTING
Obrain teopacary Agrrement (Ser. 13.c.(2) to caver test
PERFORH ONSITE TESTING
SELECTION & ACQUISITION 6820.10
RECOMMEND SELICTION or SIt
= Reguited Dererminatinn.
Preparacion of teguured rovironmental impact tarement
• Fundinp
(Ser. t4.)
Acquite the land rights aecessary ro butld faciltry. This includes "zoning restricrions" necded to cesure continued faclliry elfertiveness
SELECTION & ACQUISITION 6820.10
(5rr. 1.r.)
FIGURE 4-1. SITE SELECTION PROCEDURE
Page 41 (and 42)
4/17/86 6820.10
(b) The possibility of using Government-owned land should be investigated at this time. See FAA Order 4660.1, Real Property Accountability Handbook.
(c) Location of the proposed facility with respect to any nearby town or airport, roads, utility lines, and boundary lines in the vicinity.
FIGURE 4-1. SITE SELECTION PROCEDURE
(d) Local utilities' plans for new or upgraded lines near the proposed sites and local planning districts' long-range plans that might impact on these sites.
17. SITE SURVEY, ANALYSIS, AND TESTING.
General.
(1) The primary purpose of the site survey is to obtain sufficient information to prepare site drawings (see appendix 6). The site drawings should include a vicinity sketch, site plan, plot layout plan, and horizon profile. The survey will establish (and document in the various drawings) a dimensional description of the site, including the locations and heights of prominent adjacent natural and man-made terrain features and obstructions. Distant terrain features that represent potential obstructions should also be identified. See paragraph 13.c(2) below for information concerning permission to enter the land.
(2) Features to be noted in the survey will include such details as trees, fences, drainage, existing buildings, utility lines, and obstructions within the vicinity of the antenna position out to a distance of 2000 feet. During the survey, other features that may be noted are topographical characteristics, particularly surface variations, that may have an impact on the propagation of signals from the site.
(3) Accurate measurements are required for the coordinates of the location and the horizon profile. The latitude and longitude of the location must be determined to the nearest 15 seconds of arc. The coordinates will later be refined to an accuracy of ±40 feet by the U.S. Geological Survey. The horizon profile is obtained by setting up a transit or theodolite at the correct antenna height and location for the site, and recording the vertical angle of all obstructions in a full circle around the site. These measurements must be accurate to +0.1 degree in vertical angle and should be given for each 10 degrees around the circle, unless elevation changes warrant more frequent measurements. If the profile taken for an antenna height of 4 feet does not show any object above 0.5 degree, then the profile at 16 feet does not need to be made. A set of accurately registered panoramic photos are an alternative to the horizon profile.
b. Site Evaluation.
(1) After preparation of the site drawings, the techniques discussed throughout chapter 3 should be applied to analyze the characteristics associated with each site under consideration. The evaluation should include:
Chap 4 Par 16 Page 43
4/17/86 6820.10
(a) Estimates of performance that can be expected from each
unimproved site.
(b) Improvement of the above performance that can be expected if corrective measures are taken. Such techniques are discussed at length in chapter 5.
(c) Estimated cost of implementing a facility that will provide acceptable performance.
(2) Selection of a tentative VOR, VOR/DME, TACAN, or VORTAC site is then made, based on the above analysis, with the objective of meeting the required performance at the least possible cost. This site should then be field tested to verify the predicted performance. In unusual cases where the site test is unsatisfactory and the performance deviates greatly from expectations, the site should be reanalyzed in light of the new data. If, as a result of a complete reevaluation, one of the alternative sites previously ruled out is now found to be most promising, a new site test will be required. Successful completion of a site test(s) will provide data for the site selection. If more than one site is technically satisfactory, then relative costs will be the determining factor.
Preliminary Considerations Before Testing.
(1) At the time of the office survey, it is of prime importance to establish the identity of the owners of the land for all candidate sites and the addresses through which they may be contacted. The legal description of land can usually be obtained locally from city, township, or county clerk's office. If possible, a copy of the deed(s) or other appropriate documentation showing land ownership should be attached to the Site Survey Report. In addition, there may be land adjacent to the proposed sites which would be affected by the site zoning restrictions. These restrictions, discussed in detail in paragraph (3) below, may be determined during the office survey, so that the ownership information of this type land, if required, may also be included in the Site Survey Report.
(2) Once the site surveys are completed and it has been decided to field test a specific candidate site, a temporary agreement must be entered into with the property owner(s). This agreement (Permit to Test, Testing License, etc.) will secure entry and access to the property for setting up a portable VOR and testing the site. These agreements, and the initial permission to enter the land for the site surveys, are governed by FAA Order 4660.1, Real Property Accountability Handbook.
(3) At the time that the temporary agreement is secured, the landowner(s) should be made aware that the following zoning restrictions will be required if the site is actually selected. This will reduce the possibility of complications in this regard at the time of lease negotiations. The restrictions are:
Chap 4 Page 44 Par 17
4/17/86 6820.10
(a) General. All obstructions within 1000 feet of the antenna are to be removed except as noted below. Normal crop raising and grazing operations may be permitted in this area, except at mountain top facilities where antennas are 4-feet high. In these instances, crop raising and grazing must be restricted to areas below and off the counterpoise. No grazing should be permitted in the vicinity of the monitor detectors.
(b) Trees and Forests. Trees close to the VOR antenna can cause severe scalloping. Single trees of moderate height (up to 30 feet) may be tolerated beyond 500 feet, but no closer. No groups of trees should be within a 1000-foot radius or subtend a vertical angle of more than 2 degrees. At mountain top sites, no trees within 1000 feet should be visible from the antenna array.
(c) Wire Fences. Ordinary farm-type wire fences about 4-feet high are not permitted within 200 feet of the antenna; fences of the chain type (6 feet or more in height) are not permitted within 500 feet of the antenna; beyond these distances no wire fence should extend more than 0.5 degree above the horizontal, measured from the antenna. These requirements may be relaxed for fences essentially radial to the antenna. Since there is a large number of possible combinations of fence height and orientation with terrain configuration of various types, each of which may produce a different effect, the foregoing must serve as a general guide only. At many sites, a special study by experienced engineering personnel will be required to permit a judgement as to what fences can be tolerated. At mountain top sites, wire fences may be permitted within 200 feet of the antenna, provided they do not extend above the line of sight from the top of the antenna to the edge of the level area (that is, they are within the shadow area of the ground counterpoise).
(d) Power and Control Lines. Power and control line extensions should be installed underground for a minimum distance of 600 feet from the antenna. Overhead power and control lines may be installed beyond 600 feet but should be essentially radial to the antenna for a minimum distance of 1200 feet. No overhead conductors (including possible future construction), except for extensions serving the site, should be permitted within 1200 feet of the antenna. If a nonradial conductor is so oriented that it does not come within 1200 feet of the antenna, but the perpendicular distance to the antenna from its imaginary extension is less than 1200 feet, then the vertical angle subtended by the uppermost conductor and/or the top of the pole (measured from ground elevation at the antenna
horizontal plane of the antenna. site) should not exceed 1 degree; also no conductor should extend above the
Other than the foregoing, there should be no lines or supporting structures so located that they subtend a vertical angle (measured from ground elevation at the site) of greater than 1.5 degrees. In addition, no conductor should extend more than 0.5 degree above the horizontal plane containing the antennas, unless they are essentially radial (within ±10 degrees) to the antenna array. At mountain top sites, the conductors will be permitted within 1200 feet of the antenna, provided they do not extend above the conical surface formed by the top of the antenna and the edge of the leveled area.
Chap 4 Par 17 Page 45
(e) Structures. No structures should be permitted within 1000 feet of the antenna, except for buildings such as the transmitter building at a mountain top site located on a slope below the ground level of the antenna so that they are not visible from the antenna. All structures ti:at are partly or entirely metallic shall subtend vertical angles of 1.2 degrees or less, measured from ground elevation at the antenna site. Wooden structures with negligible metallic content and little prospect of future metallic additions (such as roofs and wiring) may be tolerated if subtending vertical angles of less than 2.5 degrees. However, at airports, where a single hangar or line of hangars, administrative buildings, etc., may have considerable length, it is necessary to look upon such structures as producing interference in the same manner (only more severe) as power and telephone lines, and the criteria for power, control, and telephone lines will apply.
(4) Temporary permits to utilize access roads of adjacent property owners shall also be obtained prior to site testing. Easements are very often all that are required to install a permanent access road to a facility after it is established, and the actual purchase of land for this purpose is not necessary. Leases or other agreements, as required, should be entered into with appropriate governing agencies or property owner(s) for the use of existing roads. Appropriate procedures for entering into such agreements are given in FAA Order 4660.1, Real Property Accountability Handbook.
14. LAND ACQUISITION
14. LAND ACQUISITION
a. When a site has finally been selected as appropriate for permanent installation of a VOR/DME/TACAN facility, a legal description and plat of the site, access road, utility easements, and zoning restrictions must be obtained prior to requesting the acquisition of the property rights. All transactions for acquiring an interest in property, whether purchase, lease, or use restriction, are governed by FAA Order 4660.1, Real Property Accountability Handbook, and are handled by Real Estate Office personnel. As an aid to planning, several excerpts as well as references to certain sections, are given below:
(1) Funding. When land is to be purchased for a new facility site, funds for the purchase shall be included in the region or center Facilities and Equipment (F&E) budget in the same fiscal year as the funds for the facility equipment, installation, and building, as applicable. This amount will only be an estimate of the value of the land rights to be acquired, plus acquisition costs, plus a 15- to 20-percent contingency. Instructions for including land acquisition funds in the annual F&E budget submission are found in Order 2500.24, Call For Estimates - Facilities and Equipment (RIS: BU-2500-4).
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 541 passages shown