AC 21.101-1A Establishing the Certification Basis of Changed Aeronautical Products
The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) wrote this advisory circular (AC) to provide guidance for establishing the certification basis for changed aeronautical products in accordance with Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) § 21.101 and to help identify if it will be necessary to apply for a new type certificate (TC) under 14 CFR § 21.19. The guidance describes the process for establishing the certification basis for amended TCs, supplemental type certificates (STC) and amended STCs, detailing evaluations, classifications, and decisions made throughout the process.
This document is cancelled. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.
U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory Circular
Subject: Establishing the Certification Basis of Changed Aeronautical Products
Date: 9/3/2010 Initiated by: AIR-110
AC No: 21.101-1A Foreword This advisory circular (AC) provides guidance for the application of the Changed Product Rule, Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) §§ 21.101 and 21.19, for changes made to type certificated aeronautical products.
David W. Hempe Manager, Aircraft Engineering Division AIR-100
ii
Contents Paragraph Page
Chapter 1. Introduction … 1
Chapter 1. Introduction … 1
1. Purpose and Content of this Advisory Circular … 1 2. Audience … 2 3. Applicability … 2 4. Definitions … 2
Chapter 2. Overview of 14 CFR §§ 21.19 and 21.101 … 3
1. 14 CFR § 21.19 … 3 2. 14 CFR § 21.101 … 3
Chapter 3. The Process for Establishing the Certification Basis for Changed Products 14 CFR § 21.101(a) and (b) … 5
Chapter 2. Overview of 14 CFR §§ 21.19 and 21.101 … 3
1. Overview … 5 2. Step 1 of Figure 1. Identify The Proposed Type Design Change To An Aeronautical Product … 7 3. Step 2 of Figure 1. Is the Change Substantial? (14 CFR § 21.19) … 9 4. Step 3 of Figure 1. Will the Latest Requirements be Used? (14 CFR § 21.101(a)) … 10 5. Step 4 of Figure 1. Relation of Changes … 10 6. Step 5 of Figure 1. Is the Proposed Change/Grouping Significant? (14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)) … 11 7. Proposing an Amendment Level for a Significant Change … 13 8. Proposing an Amendment Level for a Not Significant Change … 15 9. Step 6 of Figure 1. Is the Area Affected By the Proposed Change? (14 CFR § 21.101(b)(2)) … 16 10. Step 7 of Figure 1. Are the New Requirements Practical and Do They Contribute Materially to the Level of Safety? (14 CFR § 21.101(b)(3)) … 18 11. Step 8 of Figure 1. Is the Proposed Type Certification Adequate? … 20
Chapter 4. Other Considerations … 22
Chapter 4. Other Considerations … 22
1. Design Related Operating Requirements … 22 2. Excepted Products under 14 CFR § 21.101(c) … 22 3. Special Conditions, 14 CFR § 21.101(d) … 22 4. Effective Period for an Application to Change a Type Certificate. (14 CFR § 21.101(e)) … 23 5. Other Category Aircraft (14 CFR § 21.101(f)) … 23 6. Clarification of 14 CFR 21.101 (g) (Part 26 Requirements) … 25 7. Documentation … 25
Appendix A. Classification of Changes … A-1
Appendix A. Classification of Changes … A-1
Appendix B. Procedure for Evaluating Impracticality of Applying Latest
Requirements to a Changed Product … B-1
1. Introduction … B-1 2. Procedure for Evaluating Impracticality of Applying Latest Requirements to a Changed Product … B-2
iii
3. Examples of How to Certify Changed Aircraft … B-6
3. Examples of How to Certify Changed Aircraft … B-6
Appendix C. The Use of Service Experience in the Certification Process … C-1
1. Introduction … C-1 2. Guidelines … C-1 3. Example: 14 CFR § 25.1141(f) Powerplant Controls for Transport Airplanes … C-3
Appendix D. Definitions and Terminology … D-1
Appendix E. Related Code of Federal Regulations Sections … E-1
Appendix E. Related Code of Federal Regulations Sections … E-1
1. Related Code of Federal Regulations Paragraphs … E-1 2. How to Get Publications … E-1
Chapter 1. Introduction 1. Purpose and Content of this Advisory Circular.
a. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) wrote this advisory circular (AC) to provide guidance for establishing the certification basis for changed aeronautical products in accordance with Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) § 21.101 and to help identify if it will be necessary to apply for a new type certificate (TC) under 14 CFR § 21.19. The guidance describes the process for establishing the certification basis for amended TCs, supplemental type certificates (STC) and amended STCs, detailing evaluations, classifications, and decisions made throughout the process.
b. The content of this AC is divided into 4 chapters and 5 appendices:
(1) Chapter 1 explains the purpose of this AC, describes its content, specifies the intended audience, and clarifies which changes are within the scope of applicability of this AC.
(2) Chapter 2 provides a general overview of 14 CFR §§ 21.101 and 21.19, clarifies the principals and safety objectives and directs applicants to the applicable guidance contained in subsequent chapters of this AC.
(3) Chapter 3 contains guidance for implementation of 14 CFR § 21.101(b) to establish the type-certification basis for changed aeronautical products. Chapter 3 describes in detail the various steps of the “top-down” certification basis development approach. Chapter 3 also addresses 14 CFR § 21.19 considerations to identify conditions under which an applicant for a type design change is required to submit application for a new TC and provides guidance at which stage of the process this assessment is to be performed.
(4) Chapter 4 contains considerations for design related operating requirements, approach for changes on certain small airplanes and rotorcraft under specified maximum weight (“excepted products”), use of special conditions under 14 CFR § 21A.101 (d), the effective period of an application, 14 CFR part 26 requirements, documentation of revisions to the typecertification basis and approach to ‘other category aircraft’ under 14 CFR § 21.101 (f).
(5) Appendix A contains examples of typical type design changes for small airplanes, transport category airplanes, rotorcraft, engines, and propellers which are categorized by the FAA into individual tables according to the classifications to the level of design change - substantial, significant, and not significant.
(6) Appendix B provides detailed guidance with examples for evaluating when compliance to the rule would be impractical under the “impracticality” exception in the rule.
(7) Appendix C provides guidance with examples on use of relevant service experience in the certification process as one way to show that a later amendment may not
contribute materially to the level of safety, allowing the use of earlier requirements.
(8) Appendix D lists the applicable definitions, and terminology for application of the rule.
(9) Appendix E contains cross references to the requirements of 14 CFR §§ 21.19 and 21.101.
c. This AC is not mandatory and is not a regulation. This AC describes an acceptable means, but not the only means, to comply with 14 CFR § 21.101. However, if you use the means described in this AC, you must follow it entirely. 2. Audience. This AC is for applicants applying for STCs, amended type certificates (ATCs), or amended STCs. 3. Applicability.
a. This document supersedes AC 21.101-1 Change 1, dated April 28, 2003. This document was revised to clarify current policy for complying with 14 CFR § 21.101.
b. This AC applies to major type design changes under 14 CFR § 21.101 for aeronautical products certificated under 14 CFR §§ 21, 23, 25, 27, 29, 31, 33, and 35.
c. Minor type design changes are automatically considered not significant under 14 CFR § 21.101(b) and the existing type certification basis is considered adequate for their approval under 14 CFR § 21.95.
d. This AC also applies to aircraft certificated under 14 CFR §§ 21.17(b), 21.19, 21.24, 21.25, and 21.27.
e. The term aeronautical products, or products, means type certificated aircraft, aircraft engines, and propellers.
f. This AC is not intended to be used to determine the applicable aircraft noise, fuel venting, and exhaust emission requirements for changed products. 4. Definitions. See appendix D in this AC for a list of definitions.
Chapter 2. Overview of 14 CFR §§ 21.19 and 21.101
Chapter 2. Overview of 14 CFR §§ 21.19 and 21.101
1. 14 CFR § 21.19.
a. Title 14 CFR § 21.19 requires that as an applicant, you apply for a new TC for a changed product if the change in design, power, thrust, or weight is found by the FAA to be so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
b. Changes that require a substantial re-evaluation of the product’s compliance findings are referred to as “substantial changes”. For guidance see paragraph 3 of chapter 3. Appendix A in this AC provides examples of type design changes that will require application for a new TC.
c. If the FAA has determined through 14 CFR § 21.19 that your proposed design change does not require a new TC, see 14 CFR § 21.101 for the applicable requirements to develop the certification basis for your proposed design change. For guidance, see chapter 3 and the examples in appendix A in this AC. 2. 14 CFR § 21.101.
a. Title 14 CFR § 21.101(a) requires a change to a TC to comply with the latest requirements, unless the change meets the criteria for the exceptions identified in 14 CFR §§ 21.101(b) and (c). The intent of 14 CFR § 21.101 is to enhance safety through the incorporation of the latest regulatory standards in the type certification basis for changed products to the greatest extent practicable.
b. You can comply with the earlier requirements consistent with the requirements of 14 CFR § 21.101(b), when:
A change is not significant (see 14 CFR § 21.101 (b) (1)), or
An area, system, component, equipment or appliance are not affected by the
change (see 14 CFR § 21.101 (b) (2)), or Compliance with a later amendment for a significant change does not contribute
materially to the level of safety (see 14 CFR § 21.101 (b) (3)) , or Compliance with a latest amendment would be impractical (see
c. Note that earlier amendments may not precede either the corresponding amendment of the regulation incorporated by reference in the type certification basis and any requirement found in 14 CFR §§ 23.2, 25.2, 27.2, and 29.2. For transport category airplanes only, the provisions of
part 26 that is related to the change is also required.
d. Title 14 CFR § 21.101(b) allows a changed product to comply with an earlier amendment of a regulation, provided the earlier amendment is considered adequate and meets the criteria in 14 CFR §§ 21.101(b)(1), (2) or (3). However, when a proposed design change involves features or characteristics considered novel and unusual and the proposed airworthiness standards do not contain adequate or appropriate safety standards for this feature, later amendments and/or special conditions will be applied.
e. Title 14 CFR §§ 21.101(b)(1)(i) and (ii) describe the automatic criteria establishing that a change is significant.
f. Title 14 CFR § 21.101(c) provides an exception from the requirements of 14 CFR § 21.101(a) for a change to certain aircraft with less than a specified maximum weight. If you apply for a type design change to an aircraft (other than rotorcraft) with a maximum weight of 6,000 pounds or less maximum weight, or to a non-turbine powered rotorcraft with a maximum of 3,000 pounds or less maximum weight, you can show that the changed product complies with the regulations incorporated by reference in the TC. You can also elect to comply, or may be required to comply, with the later regulations. See chapter 4, section 2 in this AC for specific guidance on this provision.
g. Title 14 CFR § 21.101(d) provides for the use of special conditions, under 14 CFR § 21.16, when the proposed certification basis and any later regulations do not provide adequate standards to the proposed change because of a novel or unusual design feature.
h. Title 14 CFR § 21.101(e) prescribes the effective period an application will remain valid for a change. This section is consistent with the requirements of 14 CFR § 21.17 for a new TC.
i. Title 14 CFR § 21.101(f) pertains to aircraft certificated in certain categories and special classes (e.g. gliders, airships, and other nonconventional aircraft), including the engines and propellers installed on them, under the requirements of 14 CFR §§ 21.17(b), 21.24, 21.25, and 21.27 airworthiness requirements.
j. Title 14 CFR § 21.101(g) pertains to regulatory compliance for transport category airplanes with applicable provisions of 14 CFR part 26 and/or corresponding later amendments to 14 CFR part 25. For transport category airplanes, you must comply with each applicable provision of 14 CFR part 26 for the change, unless you have elected or are required to comply with a corresponding amendment to 14 CFR part 25 that was issued on or after the date of the applicable 14 CFR part 26 provisions.
Chapter 3. The Process for Establishing the Certification Basis for Changed
Chapter 3. The Process for Establishing the Certification Basis for Changed
Products 14 CFR § 21.101(a) and (b) 1. Overview.
a. The applicant and the FAA each have a responsibility under 14 CFR § 21.101(a) and (b). As an applicant for the certification of a type design change, you must show that the change complies with the latest applicable airworthiness requirements unless you propose an exception per 14 CFR § 21.101(b). If you are proposing exception, you should make a preliminary classification whether the change is significant or not significant, and propose an appropriate certification basis. The FAA determines whether your classification of the change and proposal for the certification basis are consistent with the applicable rules and their interpretation, but should not be dependent on whether the TC holder or applicant for a STC is originating the change. The certification basis can vary depending on the magnitude and scope of the change. The steps below present a streamlined approach for making this determination. In addition to assisting in the determination of significance and establishing the certification basis, this guidance will help to establish the appropriate amount of coordination required between the applicant and the FAA.
b. Classifications of typical type design changes are in appendix A, Classification of Changes. See paragraph 6 (c), of this chapter for instructions on how to use appendix A.
c. In cases where the examples in appendix A are not applicable for the proposed change, use the following steps in conjunction with figure 1, on the next page, to develop the appropriate certification basis for the type design change.
Figure 1. Establishing the Certification Basis for Changed Product
Step 2. Is the change
substantial?
(§ 21.19)
Step 1. Propose major type design change - Identify type design to be changed - Identify proposed change - Use high level descriptors
Step 4. Arrange changes into related & unrelated groups
Step 3. § 21.101(a) Will the latest requirements be
used?
Figure 1 · page 9Picture of the page from the copy saved here
NEW TYPE CERTIFICATE
NEW TYPE CERTIFICATE
Step 5. Is the proposed change/grouping
significant? § 21.101(b)(1)
Will the latest requirements
be used?
Step 6. For every area, is the area affected
by the proposed
change?
Step 7. Are the latest requirements practical
or do they contribute materially to the level
of safety? § 21.101(b)(3)
Latest airworthiness requirements
Earlier airworthiness requirements
but not earlier than the existing
certification basis
Unaffected areas
Impractical or not
contributing materially to the
level of safety
Not significant
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
No
PROPOSED CERTIFICATION BASIS FOR THE
PROPOSED CERTIFICATION BASIS FOR THE
CHANGE
CONTINUED COMPLIANCE
WITH THE EXISTING TC
BASIS
STOP A
A
PROPOSED CERTIFICATION BASIS FOR THE
CHANGE
Step 8. Is the proposed
TC basis adequate?
Proposed certification basis
requires later airworthiness requirement(s) and/or special
conditions
Proposed certification basis
completed
Yes No
2. Step 1 of Figure 1. Identify The Proposed Type Design Change To An Aeronautical Product.
a. Prior to describing the proposed change(s), it is important to clearly identify the type design configuration to be changed. A series of derivative aircraft, engines, or propellers (for example, x -100, x-200, x-300) may evolve based on predecessor type designs, each with its own design change that make it distinct from the other series. You should identify which model or series within that model the specific configuration that will be modified.
Note: An STC is not a product; it is a change to a product. When changing or amending an STC the starting point is the existing modified product (TC with existing STC installed). For example, if you were amending an STC for an external cargo locker and you proposed changing the configuration of the locker, then your starting point would be the existing TC with the existing cargo locker installed by STC. You would then compare that configuration (TC with existing STC installed) to the changed product (TC with proposed amended STC installed).
b. Changes to a product can include physical design changes, changes to an operating envelope, and/or performance changes. The change can be a single change or a collection of changes. The purpose of this process step is to identify and describe the change to the aeronautical product. As an applicant for a type design change you must consider all previous related design changes and the amendment level of the certification basis used for these changes.
Note 1: By definition all previously incorporated changes will have been approved. The purpose of step 1 is to consider the net cumulative effect of the changes since the last time the certification basis for the changed/affected area was upgraded from that of the original type design. Note 2: For the purpose of classifying the proposed design change, previously approved design data are still considered part of the proposed design and must be considered part of the proposed design change classification. c. When identifying the changes being proposed as part of a modification, consider previous relevant changes that create a cumulative effect, as these may influence the decisions regarding substantial and significant changes later in the process. By previous relevant changes we mean design changes whose effects accumulate, such as successive thrust increases, incremental weight increases, or sectional increases in fuselage length. Any previous relevant design changes in the area affected by the current change that did not involve an upgrade of the existing certification basis must be taken into account in the next design change proposal.
(1) Example 1: A 5% weight increase is currently being proposed, but a previous 10% and another 15% weight increase has been incorporated into this aircraft without upgrading the existing certification basis. In the current proposal for a 5% weight increase, the cumulative effects of the two previous weight increases that did not involve upgrade of the certification basis will now be accounted for as an approximately 30% increase in weight, for the purpose of making the substantial and/or significant decisions. Note that the cumulative effects to be considered are those incremental increases since the last time the airworthiness requirements, in the type certification basis applicable to the area affected by the current change, were upgraded.
(2) Example 2: The TC for airplane model X lists three series, namely X-300, X-200, and X-100. The X-300 is a derivative of the X-200 which is a derivative of the original X-100 series. An applicant proposes a design change to the X-300 series airplane. During the review of the X-300 certification basis and the regulations affected by the proposed change, it was identified that one regulation, 14 CFR § 25.571 (damage tolerance requirements), remained at the same amendment level as the X-100 original certification basis (exception was granted). Since the amendment level for this particular regulation was not changed for the two subsequent airplane series (X-200 and X-300), the cumulative effects of these two previous design changes that are related to the proposed change and the damage tolerance requirements must now be addressed.
d. To identify and describe the proposed changes to any aeronautical product, use a high level description of the design change that characterizes the intent of, or the reason for, the change. No complex technical details are necessary at this stage. For example, a proposal to increase maximum passenger-carrying capacity may require an addition of a fuselage plug, and as such, a “fuselage plug” becomes one possible high level description of this design change. Similarly, a thrust increase, a new or complete interior, an avionics system upgrade, or a passenger-to-cargo conversion are all high level descriptions that characterize typical changes to the aircraft, each driven by a specific goal, objective or purpose.
e. Evolutionary Changes. Evolutionary changes that occur during the course of a certification program may require re-evaluation of the certification basis and may result in reclassification of the change. That is, any evolution in the proposed design change after the certification basis has been agreed to (or established) will necessitate a revisit of the certification basis to ensure that “evolved” aspects of the design change are still covered by the agreed upon certification basis. 3. Step 2 of Figure 1. Is the Change Substantial? (14 CFR § 21.19)
a. Title 14 CFR § 21.19 requires that you apply for a new TC for a changed product if the proposed change in design, power, thrust, or weight is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required. A new TC could be required for either a single extensive change to a previously type certificated product or for a changed design derived through the cumulative effect of a series of design changes from a previously type certificated product.
b. A “substantially complete investigation” of compliance is required when most of the existing substantiation is not applicable to the changed product. A substantial change proposal will require the need to comply with all requirements applicable to a particular category of product. The number of requirements to which compliance must be re-established for the changed product may not necessarily be the sole determination as to whether the change is substantial, but rather it is the extent of effort to establish compliance, or the depth of investigation required to be done. In other words, the proposed design change may be considered substantial if it is so extensive (making the product sufficiently different from its predecessor) that the design models, methodologies, and approaches used to demonstrate a previous compliance finding could not be used.
c. To address if a change is substantial at the beginning of the process, you must evaluate the total or combined effect of all the proposed changes identified in step 1, including the cumulative effects of previous relevant design changes since the last update of the certification basis (as explained in step 1).
d. If it is not initially clear if a new TC is required, appendix A provides some examples of substantial changes to aid in this classification. A substantial change requires application for a new TC under 14 CFR §§ 21.17 and 21.19. If the change is not substantial, then follow the 14 CFR § 21.101 process.
4. Step 3 of Figure 1. Will the Latest Requirements be Used? (14 CFR § 21.101(a))
You can use the latest requirements for your proposed type design change. If you use the latest requirements you will meet the intent of 14 CFR § 21.101 and no further classification (significant or not-significant) and justification is needed. However, the decision to voluntarily comply with the latest certification standards for a design change sets a new regulatory baseline for all future related changes in the same affected area. Even though one applicant elects to use the latest certification requirements, another applicant could apply 14 CFR § 21.101 for a similar design change proposal, and use the exceptions in accordance with 14 CFR § 21.101(b). If you are not using the latest requirements then proceed as follows. 5. Step 4 of Figure 1. Relation of Changes.
a. Once the proposed changes are identified using high level descriptions, the next step is to determine if any of these changes are related to each other. Related changes are those that cannot exist without another, are co-dependent, or a pre-requisite of another. For example, a need to carry more passengers could require the addition of a fuselage plug, which will result in a weight increase, and may necessitate a thrust increase. Thus the fuselage plug, weight increase and thrust increase are all related high level changes that will be needed to achieve the goal of carrying more passengers. A decision to upgrade the cockpit to more modern avionics at the same time as these other design changes may be considered unrelated, as the avionics upgrade is not necessarily needed to carry more passengers (it has a separate purpose, likely just modernization). The proposed avionics upgrade could then be considered an unrelated (or a stand alone) change. However, the simultaneous introduction of a new cabin interior would be considered related since a cabin length change will have an impact on occupant safety considerations. Even if a new cabin interior is not included in the product level change, the functional effect of the fuselage plug has implications on occupant safety (e.g., the dynamic environment in an emergency landing, emergency evacuation, etc.), and thus the cabin interior becomes an affected area.
b. Once the change(s) are organized into groupings of those that are related and those that are unrelated (or stand alone), you are ready for step 5 of figure 1. The grouping of related and unrelated changes is particularly relevant to the significant Yes/No decision, (14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)), described in step 5 of figure 1. Each group of related changes and each unrelated (stand alone) change is evaluated on its own merit for significance.
c. After describing the design change groupings and the associated or supporting technical details for each change, you must identify areas, systems, components, equipment, or appliances of the product that are affected by the design change and the corresponding regulatory standards associated with these areas. For each group, you must assess the physical and/or functional effects of the change on other areas, systems, components, equipment, or appliances of the product. The characteristics affected by the change are not only physical changes, but also functional changes brought about by the physical changes. Examples of physical aspects are: structures, systems, equipment, component and appliances, and software in combination with the affected hardware. Examples of functional characteristics are performance, handling qualities, aeroelastic characteristics, and emergency egress. The intent is to encompass all aspects where there is a need for re-evaluation, that is, where the substantiation presented for the product being changed should be updated or rewritten.
6. Step 5 of Figure 1. Is the Proposed Change/Grouping Significant? (14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1))
a. In step 5 it is your responsibility to justify that a grouping of related changes or an unrelated change does not qualify as a significant change. Significant changes are product level changes which are distinct from the vast majority of major changes. In general, these changes are either the result of an accumulation of changes or occur through an isolated extensive change that makes the changed product distinct from its predecessors. Step 1 explains the accumulation of changes that must be considered. Title 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1) defines a significant change as existing when one or more of three automatic criteria apply:
(1) Changes where the general configuration is not retained (significant change to general configuration). A change to the general configuration at the product level that distinguishes the resulting product from other product models, for example, performance or interchangeability of major components. Typically, for these changes, an applicant will designate a new aircraft model or series number, although this is not required. For examples see appendix A.
(2) Changes where the principles of construction are not retained (significant change to principles of construction). A change at the product level to the materials and/or construction
methods that affect the overall products’ operating characteristics or inherent strength and would require extensive reinvestigation to show compliance. For examples see appendix A in this AC.
(3) Changes that invalidate the assumptions used for certification (significant change to the assumptions used for certification). A change to the assumptions at the product level associated with the compliance demonstration, performance, or operating envelope that by itself is so different that the original assumptions or methodologies of demonstrating compliance are invalidated. For examples see appendix A in this AC.
b. The above criteria are used to determine if each change grouping and each stand-alone change is significant. These three criteria are assessed at the product level. In applying the automatic criteria you should focus on the design change itself. Consideration of only the regulatory importance or safety benefit of the latest certification requirements is not a justification by itself to cause a design change to be classified or re-classified as a significant change.
c. Appendix A includes tables of typical changes for transport airplanes, small airplanes, rotorcraft, engines, and propellers that meet the definition of significant. In these tables, one or more of the three automatic criteria in 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1) apply for each case where the changes are identified as significant. Experience has shown the concept of having only the three automatic criteria seems to fit most projects. The examples also include typical changes that do not achieve the significant level. The tables can be used in one of two ways:
(1) To classify a proposed change that is listed in the tables of the appendix, or (2) In conjunction with the three automatic criteria, to help classify a proposed change not listed in the tables of the appendix by comparing the proposed change to changes which are similar in type and/or magnitude.
d. Design changes can trigger one or more of the automatic criteria listed in 14 CFR §§ 21.101(b)(1)(i) and (ii) for the proposed design change. When assessing the design change grouping, consider the cumulative effect of previous relevant design changes. Design changes may have been incorporated over time with no change in the certification basis and the final product may be significantly different than would be represented by the existing certification basis.
e. Each grouping of related changes and each unrelated (stand alone) change, identified using high level descriptions, will be evaluated on its own merit to determine if it is a significant or not significant change. Use the tables in appendix A as guidance to make the classification of significant, or not significant. Only when one or more of the three criteria is met can the type design change be considered significant for that grouping or unrelated change. The starting point for assessing the cumulative effects of previous relevant design changes is from the last time the applicable requirements in the certification basis for the affected area, system, component, equipment, or appliance was upgraded.
f. Typically, a change to a single area, system, component, or appliance may not result in a product level change. However, there may be distinct cases where the change to a single system or component may, in fact, result in a significant change due to its effect on the product overall. Examples may include addition of winglets, leading edge slats or change in primary flight controls to fly-by-wire system.
g. A secondary change is a physical change (which may include physical aspects as referenced in paragraph 9 in this chapter) that is part of and consequential to an overall significant change. A secondary change is a physical change that does not change the system, structural capacity, or functionality, but is necessary to support a significant change. Based on this description, a secondary change is not required to comply with the latest requirements because it is considered “not contributing materially to the level of safety”, and therefore eligible for an exception under14 CFR § 21.101. Determining whether a change meets the description for a secondary change, and thus eligible for an exception, should be straightforward. Hence the substantiation or justification need only be minimal. If this determination is not straightforward, then your proposed change is very likely not a secondary change.
(1) In some cases, however, the change which restores functionality may in fact contribute materially to the level of safety by meeting a later amendment. If this is the case it would not be considered a secondary change.
(2) An example of secondary change is lengthening existing control cables passing through the new fuselage plug, to restore existing functions to systems that could be situated within or beyond the new plug. The lengthening of these cables can be accepted as not adding system capacity or capability, so these changes can be identified as secondary changes and not be required to meet the latest amendment.
h. A new model number designation to a changed product is not necessarily indicative that the design change is significant under14 CFR § 21.101. Conversely, retaining the existing model designation does not mean that the design change is not significant. All changes are considered in light of the magnitude of the type design change.
i. Making the determination. The final determination of whether a design change is significant or not significant is retained by the FAA. To assist you in your assessment, the FAA has predetermined the classification of several typical design changes that can be used for reference. These examples are listed in appendix A in this AC.
j. At this point, the determination of significant or not significant for each of the groupings of related changes and each stand alone change has been made. For significant changes, if you propose to comply with an earlier requirement, use the procedure outlined in paragraph 7 below. 7. Proposing an Amendment Level for a Significant Change. a. If an unrelated (stand alone) change or a grouping of related changes is classified as significant (14 CFR § 21.101(a)), you will comply with the latest regulatory requirements for
certification of the changed product, unless you justify use of one of the exceptions provided in 14 CFR §§ 21.101(b)(2) and/or (3) to show compliance with earlier amendment(s). The final certification basis may consist of a combination of the regulatory requirements ranging from the original aircraft certification basis to the most current regulatory amendments.
b. If the classification of the change is significant, all areas, systems, components, parts or appliances affected by the change must comply with the regulatory requirements at the amendment level in effect on the date of application for the change. You can justify use of one of the exceptions in 14 CFR §§ 21.101(b)(2) and (3) to comply with an earlier amendment, but no earlier than the existing certification basis. You must comply with any retroactive requirement found in 14 CFR §§ 23.2, 25.2, 27.2, and 29.2 applicable on the date of the application for the change.
c. For transport category airplanes only, you must also comply with any applicable provision of 14 CFR part 26 (related to the change) which is applicable on the date of the application for the change, unless you elected or were required to comply with later corresponding 14 CFR part 25 requirements.
d. Title 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(3) provides two more exceptions applicable to areas, systems, parts or appliances which are affected by the significant change. For a group of related design changes or an unrelated design change that has been determined to be significant, 14 CFR §§ 21.101(b)(2) and (3) provide exceptions from the requirement of 14 CFR § 21.101(a). You can comply with an earlier amendment level or with the existing certification basis for areas not affected by the change, and any areas affected by the change for which compliance with the latest requirements would not contribute materially to the level of safety or would be impractical.
e. The earlier amendments may not precede the corresponding requirements in the existing certification basis or any requirement found in 14 CFR §§ 23.2, 25.2, 27.2, 29.2, or for transport category airplanes only, 14 CFR part 26, that is related to the change. It is important when seeking to use earlier amendments that you demonstrate that compliance with the latest requirements does not contribute materially to the level of safety, or is impractical.
f. You must provide acceptable justification for the application of earlier amendments for areas affected by a significant change. Your justification must show that compliance with later requirements in these areas would not contribute materially to the level of safety or would be impractical. Such justification should address all the aspects of the area, system, component, equipment, or appliance affected by the significant change.
g. The final certification basis may combine latest, earlier (intermediate), and existing regulations, but cannot contain regulations preceding the existing certification basis.
h. Note that should you decide to use the latest airworthiness standards without any exceptions, no further evaluations and justifications are needed. In such a case, proceed to step 8 (section 11).
8. Proposing an Amendment Level for a Not Significant Change.
a. When a change is classified not significant, the rule (14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)) allows the use of the earlier regulatory requirements, but not dated prior to the existing certification basis. Within this limit, you are allowed to propose an amendment level for each certification standard for the affected area. However, you should be aware that your proposal for the type certification basis will be reviewed by the FAA to ensure that the certification basis is adequate for the proposed change (see paragraph 8.d). You must also comply with the retroactive requirements found in 14 CFR §§ 23.2, 25.2, 27.2, 29.2 applicable on the date of the application for the change.
b. For transport category airplanes only, you must comply with any 14 CFR part 26 requirements related to the change applicable on the date of the application for the change, unless you elected, or were required, to comply with later corresponding 14 CFR part 25 requirements.
c. When choosing the above option of the existing type certification basis, you can elect to comply with a specific airworthiness requirement or a subset of airworthiness requirements at later amendments. In such a case, you should consult with the FAA to ensure the certification basis includes other airworthiness requirements that are directly related. Some later regulatory requirements may be less restrictive; therefore, you may see advantage in using them on the elect to comply basis. However, it is recommended you do not make a final decision until you learn from the FAA which other airworthiness requirements are found directly related.
d. For a design change that contains features which are not covered in the existing certification basis, the FAA will designate the applicable airworthiness standard at the appropriate amendment level, beginning with the existing certification basis and progressing to the most appropriate later amendment level for the change. For a change that contains new design features that are novel and unusual, for which there is no later applicable airworthiness requirement, the FAA will designate special conditions. For new design features or characteristics which may pose a potential unsafe condition for which there are not later applicable airworthiness requirements, new requirements may be imposed per 14 CFR § 21.21(b)(2). e. Adequacy of Certification Basis: The certification basis for a changed product under 14 CFR § 21.101 is considered adequate when the FAA determines that the prescribed airworthiness requirements (existing, later, or latest amendments, including special conditions, or new requirements per 14 CFR § 21.21(b)(2)) provide an appropriate level of safety for the changed product and do not result in any unsafe design features or characteristics for the intended use of the product.
9. Step 6 of Figure 1. Is the Area Affected By the Proposed Change? (14 CFR § 21.101(b)(2))
a. A not affected area is any area, system, component, equipment, or appliance that is not affected by the proposed type design change. For a type design change, it is important that the effects of such change on other areas, systems, components, equipment, or appliances of the product are properly assessed because areas that have not been physically changed may still be considered part of the affected area. If a new compliance finding is required, regardless of its amendment level, it is an affected area. If the significant change does not affect the area, then the certification basis of that area need not be revisited, in other words, the unaffected area continues to comply with the existing amendment level without further substantiation.
b. To determine whether an area is affected or not, consider the following aspects of a type design change:
(1) Physical aspects. The physical aspects include direct changes to structures, systems, equipment, components, and appliances (physical aspects may include software/airborne electronic hardware changes and the resulting effect on systems functions).
(2) Performance/functional characteristics. The less obvious aspect of the word “areas” covers general characteristics of the type certificated product, such as performance features, handling qualities, emergency egress, structural integrity, aeroelastic characteristics, or crashworthiness. These characteristics may be affected by a product level change. For example, adding a fuselage plug could affect performance and handling qualities, and thus regulations associated with these aspects would be considered part of the affected area. Another example is the addition of a fuel tank and new fuel conditioning unit. This change affects the fuel transfer and fuel quantity indication system resulting in the airplane’s unchanged fuel tanks being affected. Thus, the entire fuel system (changed and unchanged areas) becomes part of the affected area due to the change in functional characteristics.
Note: Substantiating data for the affected area for your proposed type design change can include compliance findings from a previously approved design change, in supporting compliance findings for your proposal. However, your proposal to use previously approved compliance data must be considered part of the entire proposed type design change and should be approved as part of your proposed design change.
c. All areas affected by the proposed design change must comply with the latest requirements, unless you show that demonstrating compliance with the latest amendment of a requirement would not contribute to the level of safety or would be impractical. Step 7 provides further explanation.
10. Step 7 of Figure 1. Are the New Requirements Practical and Do They Contribute Materially to the Level of Safety? (14 CFR § 21.101(b)(3))
a. Compliance with the latest requirements could be considered to “not to contribute materially to the level of safety” if the existing type design and/or relevant experience demonstrates a level of safety comparable to that provided by the latest requirements. You must provide sufficient justification to allow us to make this determination. This exception could be applicable in the situations described in the paragraphs below:
Note: Compliance with later requirements would not be required where the amendment is of an administrative nature and has been made only to correct inconsequential errors or omissions, consolidate text, or clarify an existing requirement.
(1) Design features that exceed the existing certification basis requirements, but do not meet the latest requirements, can be used as a basis for granting an exception under the “does not contribute materially” exception. These design features, if accepted as a justification for an exception, must be incorporated in the amended type design configuration and recorded, where necessary, in the certification basis. The description of the design feature would be provided in the type certificate data sheet (TCDS) or STC at a level that allows the design feature to be maintained, but does not contain proprietary information. For example, an applicant proposes to install winglets on a 14 CFR part 25 airplane. Part of the design involves adding a small number of new wing fuel tank fasteners. The latest 14 CFR § 25.981 at amendment 25-102 requires structural lightning protection. The applicant proposes an exception from these latest structural lightning protection requirements because the design change uses new wing fuel tank fasteners with cap seals installed. The cap seal is a design feature that exceeds the requirement of 14 CFR § 25.981 at a previous amendment level, but does not meet the latest amendment 25- 102. If the applicant can successfully substantiate that compliance with amendment 25-102 would not materially increase the level of safety of the changed product, then this design feature can be accepted as an exception to compliance with the latest amendment.
(2) Consistency of design should be considered when applying the latest requirements. Below, an airplane example is provided for describing how this provision may be used; however, the rationale in this example may be applied to any product covered by this AC.
For example, when a small fuselage plug is added, additional seats and
overhead bins are likely to be installed, and the lower cargo hold extended. These components may be identical to the existing components. The level of safety may not materially increase by applying the latest requirements. However, if a fuselage plug is large enough relative to the original certificated
aircraft structure, seats, bins, doors, and cargo compartment, the change may require compliance with the latest requirements, comparable with what will be required for a new airplane. In these circumstances, the proposed certification basis should encompass the requirements in effect on the date of application for the change. (3) Service experience: Relevant service experience, such as fleet performance or utilization over time (relevant flight hours or cycles), is one way of showing that a later amendment may not contribute materially to the level of safety, so the use of earlier requirements could be appropriate. Appendix C provides additional guidance on the use of service experience, along with examples.
There may be cases for rotorcraft and small airplanes where relevant data
may not be sufficient or not available at all because of the reduced utilization and the different amount and type of data available. In such cases, other service history information may provide sufficient data to justify the use of earlier requirements, such as: warranty, repair, and parts usage data; accident, incident, and service difficulty reports; service bulletins; airworthiness directives; or other pertinent and sufficient data collected by the manufacturers, authorities, or other entities.
The service experience necessary to demonstrate the appropriate level of
safety as they relate to the proposed design change would have to be reviewed and agreed to by the FAA.
b. Impractical. Compliance with the latest requirements may be considered impractical if you can justify that it would result in additional resource requirements that are not commensurate with the incremental safety benefit (difference between the latest and proposed certification basis). The additional resource requirements could include those arising from design changes required for compliance and the effort required to demonstrate compliance, but excludes resource expenditures for prior product changes.
(1) Support your position that compliance is impractical with substantiating data and analyses. While evaluating your position and your substantiating data regarding impracticality, we may consider other factors (for example, the costs and safety benefits for a comparable new design).
(2) A review of transport category projects showed that in certain cases, where an earlier amendment to applicable requirements was allowed, design changes were made to nearly
comply with the latest amendments. In these cases, the applicants were able to successfully demonstrate that full compliance would require a substantial increase in the outlay or expenditure of resources with a very small increase in the level of safety. These design features can be used as a basis for granting an exception under the “impracticality” exception.
(3) Appendix B provides additional guidance and examples for determining procedures for evaluating impracticality of applying latest requirements to a changed product rule.
(a) The exception of impracticality is a qualitative and/or quantitative cost/safety benefit assessment for which it is difficult to specify clear criteria. Experience to date with applicants has shown that justification of impracticality is more feasible when both applicant and FAA agree at an earlier discussion that the effort (in terms of cost, changes in manufacturing, etc.), required to comply would not be commensurate with a small incremental safety gain. This would be clear even without the need to perform any detailed cost/safety benefit analysis (although cost analysis could always be used to support an appropriate amendment level). However, there should be enough detail in the applicant’s rationale to justify the exception.
Note: The impractical exception should not be based on the size of the applicant’s company or their financial resources. Costs to comply with a later amendment must be evaluated against the safety benefit of complying with the later amendment. Applicants that may not be able to afford the cost because of reasons such as fewer resources, will not be granted the impractical exception when the cost is comparable to the safety benefit achieved by complying with a later amendment. (b) For example, a complex redesign of an area of the baseline aircraft may be required to comply with a new requirement, and that redesign may make the changed product uncommon with respect to design and manufacturing processes from the existing family of derivatives. Relevant service experience of the existing fleet of the baseline aircraft family would be required to show that there has not been a history of problems associated with the hazard that the new amendment in question was meant to address. In this way, the incremental cost/impact to the applicant is onerous and the incremental safety benefit that would be realized by complying with the later amendment would be minimal. This would be justified with a demonstrated acceptable service experience in relation to the hazard that the new rule addresses. 11. Step 8 of Figure 1. Is the Proposed Type Certification Adequate?
a. Regardless of whether the change is significant or not, your proposed type certification basis may be deemed inadequate – that is, the change includes features or characteristics that were
not foreseen during the initial (or previously approved) type certification. These features or characteristics, if not adequately addressed, may make the product unsafe for the uses for which certification is requested. This would obstruct issuance of the requested approval for the change. The change must comply with later regulations (such as, a later amendment or a special condition). An example is adding a flight critical system such as an electronic air data display on a 14 CFR part 25 airplane whose existing certification basis did not have lightning protection requirements. In this case, compliance with the regulations for lightning protection will be required, even though this is not a significant change.
b. In cases where inadequate or no airworthiness standards exist for the change in the existing type certification basis, but adequate standards exist in a subsequent amendment of the applicable airworthiness code, the subsequent amendment will be made part of the type certification basis to assure its certification basis is adequate.
c. In cases where no adequate standard exist in any subsequent amendment of the applicable airworthiness code because of novel or unusual design features, the FAA will prescribe special conditions under 14 CFR § 21.16. Title 14 CFR § 21.101(d) allows for the application of special conditions, or for changes to existing special conditions, to address the changed designs where the proposed certification basis does not provide adequate standards for an area, system, component, equipment or appliance related to the change. Reference section 3 of chapter 4 for additional information pertaining to special conditions.
d. For new design features or characteristics which may pose a potential unsafe condition for which there are not later applicable airworthiness requirements, new requirements may be imposed per 14 CFR § 21.21(b)(2).
e. The final type certification basis may consist of a combination of the certification standards, ranging from the original aircraft type certification basis to the most current regulatory amendments, and special conditions.
Chapter 4. Other Considerations 1. Design Related Operating Requirements. The use of exceptions under 14 CFR § 21.101 is not intended to alleviate or preclude compliance with operating regulations (such as 14 CFR part 121) that prescribes compliance with a specific or later amendment of the airworthiness (design-related) requirements. 2. Excepted Products under 14 CFR § 21.101(c).
a. As an applicant for a design change to an excepted product, you may show that the changed product complies with the existing certification basis incorporated by reference in the TC. If we, the FAA, find that the change is significant “in an area”, we will require compliance with a later amendment to the existing certification basis in the TC that applies to that affected area and any regulation we find is directly related. For excepted products, changes that meet one of the following criteria, in the area of change, are considered significant if:
The general configuration or the principles of construction are not retained, or
The assumptions used for certification of the area to be changed do not remain valid.
b. However, we may allow you to comply with an earlier amendment to the requirement initially designated or with the existing certification basis if we agree to your justification.
c. For a design change to an excepted product that contains new features, which are not covered in the existing certification basis, we will designate the applicable airworthiness requirements at the appropriate amendment level, beginning with the existing certification basis and progressing to the most appropriate later amendment level for the change. For a change that contains new design features that are novel and unusual for which there are no later applicable requirements at a later amendment level, we will designate special conditions per 14 CFR § 21.101(d).
d. The exception provided for excepted products under 14 CFR § 21.101(c) applies at the aircraft level only. Design changes to type certificated engines and propellers installed on these excepted aircraft are assessed as separate products using 14 CFR §§ 21.101(a) and (b). 3. Special Conditions, 14 CFR § 21.101(d). Title 14 CFR § 21.101(d) allows for the application of special conditions, or for changes to existing special conditions, to address the changed designs where the proposed certification basis does not provide adequate standards for an area, system, component, equipment, or appliance related to the change. The objective is to achieve a level of safety consistent with that provided for other areas, systems, components, equipment, or appliances affected by the change by the other requirements of the proposed certification basis. The application of special conditions to a design change is not, in itself, a reason for it to be classified as either a substantial change or a significant change. When the change is significant with earlier requirements allowed through exceptions, or not significant, the
level of safety intended by the special conditions must be consistent with the agreed certification basis. 4. Effective Period for an Application to Change a TC. (14 CFR § 21.101(e)) Per 14 CFR § 21.101(e), an application for, or a change to, a TC for transport category aircraft is effective for 5 years, and an application for a change to any other TC is effective for 3 years. This is intended to ensure that the certification basis for the changed product is as current as practical. This is consistent with the requirements of 14 CFR § 21.17 for a new TC and defines the process of updating the certification basis if these time limits are exceeded.
a. If a design change has not been approved, or if it is clear that the change will not be approved, within the time limit, you may do either of the following: (1) File for a new application, or (2) File for an extension to the original application.
b. If you request an extension to the application date, and the product change is significant, a new certification basis is required. The new certification basis requires the additional latest regulations effective through the new application extension date. However, you may use earlier regulations by documenting justification that the latest regulations for the change would not contribute materially to the level of safety or would be impractical.
c. If the product change is not significant, the existing certification basis can continue to be used as the basis for product certification. However, if additional design changes are made to the product, and the existing certification basis for the change is found to be inadequate, the new certification basis will require later appropriate standards.
5. Other Category Aircraft (14 CFR § 21.101(f)). For aircraft type certificated under 14 CFR §§ 21.17(b), 21.24, 21.25, and 21.27, the certification basis for the changed product will consist of the amendment levels of the applicable regulations that we find appropriate for the change in effect on the date of application for the change. When selecting a certification basis for a change, you can propose compliance to an earlier amendment using the provisions of 14 CFR § 21.101(b). The exceptions in 14 CFR § 21.101(c) do not apply to categories of products defined in 14 CFR § 21.101(f). a. Special Classes Aircraft. For special classes of aircraft (for example, gliders, airships, etc.) including any installed engines and propellers certificated in accordance with 14 CFR § 21.17(b), the applicable requirements will be portions of those other airworthiness requirements in 14 CFR parts 23, 25, 27, 29, 31, 33, and 35 we find appropriate for the aircraft and applicable to the specific type design, or such airworthiness criteria that provide an equivalent level of safety to those parts.
b. Primary Category Aircraft. For primary category aircraft certificated under 14 CFR § 21.24, the applicable airworthiness requirements are in 14 CFR parts 23, 27, 31, 33, and 35, or such other requirements as we may find appropriate. These requirements must be
applicable to the specific design and intended use of the aircraft and provide a level of safety acceptable to us.
c. Restricted Category Aircraft – Civil Derived. For aircraft certificated in the restricted category under 14 CFR § 21.25(a)(1), the application of the latest regulations typically would be considered not to contribute materially to the level of safety or be practical for its intended use. However, if the regulations incorporated by reference in the TC do not provide an adequate level of safety for its intended use, the application of a later regulation will be required.
(1) Features of the changed product that are “novel” or “unusual” to the original certificated restricted category product may be assessed against a later requirement that addresses the feature. In this case, the requirements in effect at the time of the existing restricted category TC may be viewed as a starting point, with subsequent amendments being examined, if necessary, to arrive at a requirement that provides an appropriate level of safety.
(2) For the installation of turbo propeller engines instead of reciprocating engines, either in a restricted category aircraft that was originally certificated based on satisfactory military service experience or in a restricted category aircraft for which the original certification basis did not contain regulations for turbine engine installations, later amendments will be used to provide an appropriate level of safety for its intended operation.
d. Restricted Category Aircraft - Military Derived. Aircraft type certificated in the restricted category under 14 CFR § 21.25(a)(2) are accepted on the basis of U.S. Military use instead of showing compliance with airworthiness standards in 14 CFR Chapter 1. Many of these aircraft were not certificated to a specific set of airworthiness standards, therefore, an appropriate equivalent civilian certification basis could be determined using the table in 14 CFR § 21.27 for surplus military aircraft. Title 14 CFR § 21.101(f) requires the application of the latest amendments to significant changes to these products. However, since the latest amendments may not be appropriate for the aircraft’s intended use, earlier regulations are acceptable. They may not predate the equivalent certification basis. If these regulations do not include design standards applicable to the change, later regulations appropriate to the product category will be applied. The goal is to maintain a level of safety appropriate for the aircraft’s intended use.
e. Surplus military aircraft. Aircraft type certificated under 14 CFR § 21.27 are entitled to a TC in the normal, utility, acrobatic, commuter, or transport category, except those certified under 21.27(b). These aircraft were designed and constructed in the United States, accepted for operational use, and declared surplus by the U.S. Armed Forces. These aircraft may be counterparts, and are considered equivalent, to the previously civil certificated aircraft. Product changes or modifications to these aircraft, including their engines, propellers, and related accessories, are certificated in the same manner as their civil counterparts.
f. Limited category aircraft. Limited category aircraft are surplus military aircraft, mostly from World War II, that were type certificated under Civil Aviation Regulation (CAR) part 9 for use other than air transport. These aircraft were not intended to carry persons or property for hire, and normally were accepted based on their previous military qualifications and
service record. A change to aircraft not supported by the military service history must comply with appropriate airworthiness standards. The level of safety associated with earlier standards may be acceptable for limited category aircraft.
6. Clarification of 14 CFR 21.101 (g) (Part 26 Requirements).
a. Title 14 CFR part 26 establishes requirements for support of continued airworthiness of and safety for transport category airplanes. If you are an applicant, you must comply with each applicable provision of 14 CFR part 26, unless you have elected or were required to comply with a corresponding amendment to 14 CFR part 25 that was issued on or after the date of the applicable part 26 provision. Title 14 CFR § 21.101(g) does not allow you to use an exception under 14 CFR § 21.101(b) for relief from complying with the applicable provisions of 14 CFR part 26.
b. The language in 14 CFR § 21.101(g) also recognizes that future 14 CFR part 25 amendments will be issued after the requirements in 14 CFR part 26 are established. Note that you could be required to comply with a later amendment to 14 CFR part 25 per 14 CFR § 21.101(a). However, earlier part 25 requirements, but not earlier than those established in the existing certification basis that include part 26 requirements, could be justified using the exceptions in 14 CFR § 21.101(b).
7. Documentation. All changes that result in a revision to the product’s certification basis must be reflected on the amended TCDS or STC. The resulting certification basis must be retained as it forms part of the compliance record required by FAA Order 8110.4, Type Certification.
Appendix A. Classification of Changes The following examples of substantial, significant and not significant changes are adopted by the FAA, European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) and Transport Canada Civil Aviation (TCCA) through an international collaboration. The classification may change due to cumulative effects and/or combinations of individual changes. The “NA” in the substantial example tables indicates that the automatic classification criteria in the heading are “Not Applicable” at the “21.19 Substantial Evaluation” phase.
Table 1. Examples of Changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23)
The following examples are for SUBSTANTIAL changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Change in wing location (tandem, forward, canard, high/low)
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
Fixed wing to tilt wing
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
Increase or decrease in the number of engines from one to two
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
The following examples are for SUBSTANTIAL changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Replacement of piston or turbo-prop engines with turbojet or turbofan engines
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
Change in engine configuration (tractor/pusher)
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
Increase from subsonic to supersonic flight regime
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
Change from an all metal airplane to all composite primary structure (fuselage, wing, empennage)
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Conventional tail to T-tail or V-tail, or vice versa
Yes No Yes Change in general configuration. Requires extensive structural, flying qualities and performance reinvestigation. Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM) to address performance and flight characteristics.
Changes in wing configuration such as change in dihedral, changes in wing span, flap or aileron span, addition of winglets, or increase of more than 10 percent of the original wing sweep at the quarter chord
Yes No Yes Change in general configuration. Likely requires extensive changes to wing structure. Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM) to address performance and flight characteristics. Note: Small changes to wingtip are not significant changes. See table for not significant changes.
Changes to tail configuration such as the addition of tail strakes or angle of incidence of the tail
Yes No Yes Change in general configuration. Likely requires extensive changes to tail structure. Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM) to address performance and flight characteristics. Note: Small changes to tail are not significant changes.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Tricycle/tail wheel undercarriage change or addition of floats
Yes No No Change in general configuration at product level. Principles of construction and certification assumptions remain valid.
Passenger to freighter configuration conversion which involves the introduction of a cargo door or an increase in floor loading of more than 20 percent, or provision for carriage of passengers and freight together.
Yes No Yes Change in general configuration affecting load paths, aeroelastic characteristics, aircraft related systems, etc. Change in design assumptions.
Replace reciprocating engines with the same number of turbo-propeller engines where the operating envelope is expanded.
No No Yes Invalidates certification assumptions. Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM) to address performance and flight characteristics.
Addition of a turbocharger that changes the power envelope, operating range, or limitations.
No No Yes Invalidates certification assumptions due to changes in operating envelope and limitations. Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM) to address performance and flight characteristics.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
The replacement of an engine of higher rated power or increase thrust would be considered significant if it would invalidate the existing substantiation, or would change the primary structure, aerodynamics, or operating envelope sufficiently to invalidate the assumptions of certification.
No Yes Yes Invalidates certification assumptions. Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM) to address performance and flight characteristics. Likely changes to primary structure. Requires extensive construction reinvestigation.
A change in the type of material, such as composites in place of metal, or one composite fiber material system with another (e.g., carbon for fiberglass), for primary structure would normally be assessed as a significant change.
No Yes Yes Change in principles of construction and design from conventional practices. Likely change in design/certification assumptions.
Change involving appreciable increase in design speeds Vd, Vmo, Vc, or Va
No No Yes Certification assumptions invalidated. Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM) to address performance and flight characteristics.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Short take off and landing (STOL) kit.
No No Yes Certification assumptions invalidated. Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM) to address performance and flight characteristics.
A change in the rated power or thrust is likely to be regarded as significant if the design speeds are thereby changed so that compliance needs to be rejustified with a majority of requirements.
No No Yes Certification assumptions invalidated. Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM) to address performance and flight characteristics.
Fuel state: such as compressed gaseous fuels, or fuel cells. This could completely alter the fuel storage and handling systems and possibly affect the airplane structure.
No No Yes Changes in design/certification assumptions. Extensive alteration of fuel storage and handling systems.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
A design change that alters the aircraft flight characteristics or performance from the type design would normally be significant if it appreciably changes the kinematics or dynamics of the airplane.
No No Yes Certification assumptions invalidated. Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM) to address performance and flight characteristics.
A change in the flight control concept for an aircraft, for example, to fly by wire (FBW) and sidestick control, or a change from hydraulic to electronically actuated flight controls, would in isolation normally be regarded as a significant change.
No No Yes Changes in design and certification assumptions. Requires extensive systems architecture and integration reinvestigation. Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM).
Change to airplane’s cabin operating altitude, or operating pressure
No
No Yes An increase greater than 10% in maximum cabin pressure differential invalidates certification assumptions and the fundamental approach used in decompression, structural strength, and fatigue.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Increase in cabin pressurization.
No No Yes Typically, a change greater than 10% in operational cabin pressure differential. May require extensive airframe changes affecting load paths, fatigue evaluation, aeroelastic characteristics, etc. Invalidates design assumptions.
Addition of cabin pressurization system.
No Yes Yes Extensive airframe changes affecting load paths, fatigue evaluation, aeroelastic characteristics, etc. Invalidates design assumptions.
Changes in types and number of emergency exits or an increase in maximum certificated passenger capacity.
Yes No Yes Emergency egress requirements exceed those previously substantiated. Invalidates assumptions of certification.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
A change in the required number of flight crew, which necessitates a complete cockpit rearrangement, and/or an increase in pilot workload would be a significant change.
No No Yes Extensive changes to avionics and aircraft systems. Invalidates certification assumptions. Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM).
Expansion of an aircraft’s operating envelope.
No No Yes An appreciable expansion of operating capability would normally be a significant change (e.g., an increase in maximum altitude limitation, approval for flight in known icing conditions, or an increase in airspeed limitations). Merely operating a product to an expanded envelope for which it was originally designed is generally not a significant change. In this case, the assumptions used for certification of the basic product remain valid and the results can be applied to cover the changed product with predictable effects or can be demonstrated without significant.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Replacement of an aviation gasoline engine with an engine of approximately the same horsepower utilizing diesel fuel.
No No Yes A major change to the airplane. The general configuration and principles of constructions will usually remain valid; however, the assumptions for certification are invalidated.
Comprehensive flight deck upgrade, such as conversion from entirely federated, independent electromechanical flight instruments to highly integrated and combined electronic display systems with extensive use of software and/or complex electronic hardware.
No No Yes Affects avionics and electrical systems integration and architecture concepts and philosophies.
Introduction of autoland
No No Yes Invalidates original design assumptions
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Airframe life extension
No No Yes This modification pertains to fuselage and/or wing limits, and aging airplane concerns. An increase from the original life limit which constitutes a reevaluation of certification design assumptions.
Extensive structural airframe modification, such as a large opening in fuselage
Yes No No Requires extensive changes to fuselage structure, affects aircraft systems, and requires a new airplane flight manual to address performance and flight characteristics.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Fuselage stretch or shortening in the cabin or pressure vessel
Yes No Yes Cabin interior changes are related changes since occupant safety considerations are impacted by a cabin length change. Even if a new cabin interior is not included in the product level change, the functional effect of the fuselage plug has implications on occupant safety (e.g., the dynamic environment in an emergency landing, emergency evacuation, etc.), and thus the existing cabin interior becomes an affected area.
Conversion from normal category to commuter category airplane
Yes No Yes In many cases this change could be considered to be a substantial change to the type design. Therefore, a proposed change of this nature would be subject to an FAA determination under 14 CFR § 21.19.
The following examples are for NOT SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Addition of wingtip modifications (not winglets)
No No No A major change to the airplane. Likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid.
Installation of skis or wheel skis
No No No Although a major change to the airplane, likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid.
FLIR or surveillance camera installation
No No No Additional flight or structural evaluation may be necessary, but the change does not alter basic airplane certification.
Litter, berth and cargo tie down device installation
No No No
Increased tire size, including tundra tires
No No No
Replacement of one propeller type with another (irrespective of increase in number of blades)
No No No Although a major change to the airplane, likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid.
The following examples are for NOT SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Addition of a turbocharger that does not change the power envelope, operating range, or limitations (e.g., a turbonormalized engine, where the additional power is used to enhance high altitude or hot day performance)
No No No
Substitution of one method of bonding for another (e.g., change in type of adhesive)
No No No
Substitution of one type of metal for another
No No No
Any change in construction or fastening not involving primary structure
No No No
A new fabric type for fabric skinned aircraft
No No No
The following examples are for NOT SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Increase in flap speed or undercarriage limit speed
No No No Although a major change to the airplane, likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid.
Structural strength increases
No No No Although a major change to the airplane, likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid.
Instrument flight rules (IFR) upgrades involving installation of components (where the original certification does not indicate that the airplane is not suitable as an IFR platform, e.g., special handling concerns)
No No No
The following examples are for NOT SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Fuel lines, where engine horsepower is increased but fuel flow is not increased beyond the certificated maximum amount
No No No
Fuel tanks, where fuel is changed from gasoline to diesel fuel and tank support loads are small enough that an extrapolation from the previous analysis would be valid. Chemical compatibility would have to be substantiated.
No No No
Limited changes in a pressurization system, e.g., number of outflow valves, type of controller, or size of pressurized compartment, but the system must be resubstantiated if the original test data are invalidated.
No No No Although a major change to the airplane, likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid.
The following examples are for NOT SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Install a quieter exhaust system
No No No
Changes in engine cooling or cowling
No No No
Changing fuels of substantially the same type: such as AvGas to AutoGas, AvGas (80/87) to AvGas (100LL), ethanol to isopropyl alcohol, Jet B to Jet A (although Jet A to Jet B may be considered significant due to the fact that Jet B is considered potentially more explosive).
No No No Although a major change to the airplane, likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid.
Fuels that specify different levels of “conventional” fuel additives that do not change the primary fuel type. Different additives (MTBE, ETBE, ethanol, amines, etc.) in AvGas would not be considered a significant change.
No No No Although a major change to the airplane, likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid.
The following examples are for NOT SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
A change to the maximum take-off weight of less than 5 percent unless assumptions made in justification of the design are thereby invalidated.
No No No Although a major change to the airplane, likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid. (Unless this weight increase would result in a shift to commuter category.)
An additional aileron tab (e.g., on the other wing)
No No No Although a major change to the airplane, likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid.
Larger diameter flight control cables with no change in routing, or other system design
No No No
Autopilot installation (for instrument flight rules (IFR) use, unless the original certification indicates that the airplane is not suitable as an IFR platform)
No No No Although a major change to the airplane, likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid.
Increased battery capacity or relocate battery
No No No
The following examples are for NOT SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Replace generator with alternator
No No No
Additional lighting (e.g., navigation lights, strobes)
No No No
Higher capacity brake assemblies
No No No
Increase in fuel tank capacity
No No No Not a product level change, unless it is tied with an increase in gross weight.
Addition of an oxygen system
No No No
Relocation of a galley
No No No
Passenger to freight (only) conversion with no change to basic fuselage structure
No No No Although a major change to the airplane, likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid. Requires certification substantiation applicable to freighter requirements.
New cabin interior with no fuselage length change
No No No
The following examples are for NOT SIGNIFICANT changes for Small Airplanes (Part 23): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Installation of new seat belt or shoulder harness
No No No
A small increase in c.g. range
No No No At a product level, no change in general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions.
APU installation that is not flight essential
No No No Although a major change to the airplane level, likely the original general configuration, principles of construction, and certification assumptions remain valid.
An alternative autopilot
No No No
Addition of Class B terrain awareness and warning systems (TAWS)
No No No
Table 2. Examples of Changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25)
The following examples are for SUBSTANTIAL changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Change in the number or location of engines, e.g., four to two wing-mounted engines or two wingmounted to two body-mounted engines
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
Change from a highwing to low-wing configuration
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
Change from an all metal airplane to all composite primary structure (fuselage, wing, empennage)
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
Change of empennage configuration for larger airplanes (cruciform vs. ‘T’ or ‘V’ tail)
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
The following examples are for SUBSTANTIAL changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Increase from subsonic to supersonic flight regime
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Reduction in the number of flight crew (In conjunction with flight deck update)
No No Yes Extensive changes to avionics and aircraft systems. Impact to crew workload and human factors, pilot type rating.
Modify an airplane for flight in known icing conditions by adding systems for ice detection and elimination
Yes No Yes New aircraft operating envelope. Requires major new systems installation and aircraft evaluation. Operating envelope changed.
Conversion – passenger or combination freighter/passenger to all freighter, including cargo door, redesign floor structure and 9g net or rigid barrier
Yes No Yes Extensive airframe changes affecting load paths, aeroelastic characteristics, aircraft related systems for fire protection, etc. Design assumptions changed from passenger to freighter.
Increase in cabin pressurization
No No Yes Typically, a change greater than 10% in operational cabin pressure differential. May require extensive airframe changes affecting load paths, fatigue evaluation, aeroelastic characteristics, etc. Invalidates design assumptions.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Addition of leading edge slats
Yes No No Requires extensive changes to wing structure, adds aircraft systems, and requires a new airplane flight manual to address performance and flight characteristics.
Fuselage stretch or shortening in the cabin or pressure vessel
Yes No Yes Cabin interior changes are related changes since occupant safety considerations are impacted by a cabin length change. Even if a new cabin interior is not included in the product level change, the functional effect of the fuselage plug has implications on occupant safety (e.g., the dynamic environment in an emergency landing, emergency evacuation, etc.), and thus the cabin interior becomes an affected area.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Extensive structural airframe modification, such as installation of a large telescope with large opening in fuselage
Yes No No Requires extensive changes to fuselage structure, affects aircraft systems, and requires a new airplane flight manual to address performance and flight characteristics.
Changing the number of axles or number of landing gear done in context with a product change that involves changing the airplane gross weight
Yes No No Requires extensive changes to aircraft structure, affects aircraft systems, and requires new aircraft flight manual changes.
Primary structure changes from metallic material to composite material
No Yes No Change in principles of construction and design from conventional practices.
Airframe life extension
No No Yes This modification pertains to fuselage and/or wing limits, and aging airplane concerns. It results in an increase from the original life limit which constitutes a reevaluation of certification design assumptions.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Typically, an increase in design weight of more than 10 percent
No No Yes Requires extensive resubstantiation of aircraft structure, aircraft performance and flying qualities and associated systems.
Installation of winglets
Yes No Yes
Wing changes in span, sweep, tip designs or wing chord
Yes No Yes When it requires extensive changes to wing structure, adds aircraft systems, and requires a new airplane flight manual to address performance and flight characteristics. (Note: Potentially substantial if it is a change from a high wing to a low wing, or a new wing.)
Change in type or number of emergency exits or an increase in the maximum certificated number of passengers
Yes No Yes The new emergency egress requirements exceed those previously substantiated.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Comprehensive flight deck upgrade, such as conversion from entirely federated, independent electromechanical flight instruments to highly integrated and combined electronic display systems with extensive use of software and/or complex electronic hardware.
No No Yes Affects avionics and electrical systems integration and architecture concepts and philosophies.
Change in primary flight controls to fly by wire (FBW) system. (Some airplanes have some degree of FBW. Achieving full FBW may be a not significant change on some airplanes.)
No No Yes When the degree of change is so extensive that it affects basic aircraft systems integration and architecture concepts and philosophies. This drives a complete reassessment of flight crew workload, handling qualities, and performance evaluation, which are different from the original design assumptions.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Replace reciprocating with turbo-propeller engines
Yes No No Requires extensive changes to airframe structure, addition of aircraft systems, and new airplane flight manual to address performance and flight characteristics.
Typically a thrust increase of more than 10 percent
No No Yes Requires resubstantiation of powerplant installation, and has a marked affect on aircraft performance and flying qualities.
Initial installation of an autoland system
No No Yes Baseline airplane not designed for autoland operation, potential crew workload and systems compatibility issues.
Installation of a new fuel tank, (horizontal stabilizer tank or auxiliary fuel tank in the fuselage outside the wing in conjunction with increased maximum takeoff weight and takeoff thrust)
No No Yes Requires changes to airframe, systems and Requires a new aircraft flight manual (AFM). Results in performance changes.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Main deck cargo door installation
Yes No No Redistribution of internal loads, change in aeroelastic characteristics, system changes.
Expansion of an aircraft’s operating envelope
No No Yes An appreciable expansion of operating capability would normally be a significant change (e.g., an increase in maximum altitude limitation, approval for flight in known icing conditions, or an increase in airspeed limitations). Merely operating a product to an expanded envelope for which it was originally designed is generally not a significant change. In this case, the assumptions used for certification of the basic product remain valid and the results can be applied to cover the changed product with predictable effects or can be demonstrated without significant physical changes to the product.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25): Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Conversion from a passenger floor to a cargo floor and installation of a cargo handling system
No No Yes Completely new floor loading and design. Redistribution of internal loads, change in cabin safety requirements, system changes.
Initial installation of an auxiliary power unit (APU) essential for aircraft flight operation
No No Yes Changes emergency electrical power requirements, change in flight manual and operating characteristics.
Conversion from hydraulically actuated brakes to electrically actuated brakes
No No Yes Assumptions of certification for airplane performance are changed.
Change to airplane’s cabin operating altitude, or operating pressure
No
No Yes An increase greater than 10% in maximum cabin pressure differential invalidates certification assumptions and the fundamental approach used in decompression, structural strength, and fatigue.
Installation of engine thrust reversers
Yes No Yes
The following examples are for NOT SIGNIFICANT changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Alternate engine installation or hush kit at same position
No No No Typically it is not significant so long as there is not more than a 10 percent increase in thrust or a change in the principles of propulsion.
A small change in fuselage length due to refairing the aft body or radome
No No No For cruise performance reasons, where such changes do not require extensive structural, systems, aerodynamic, or aircraft flight manual (AFM) changes. Refairing of wing tip caps (for lights, fuel dump pipes) and addition of splitter plates to the trailing edge thickness of the cruise airfoil
No No No Does not require extensive structural, AFM, or systems changes.
Additional power used to enhance high altitude or hot day performance
No No No Usually no change in basic operating envelope. Existing certification data can be extrapolated. Could be significant product change if the additional power is provided by installation of a rocket motor or additional, on demand engine due to changes in certification assumptions.
The following examples are for NOT SIGNIFICANT changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Installation of an autopilot system
No No See note It may be possible that the modification is adaptive in nature, with no change to original certification assumptions. However, in certain cases the installation of an autopilot may include extensive changes and design features which change both the general configuration and the assumptions for certification (i.e., installation of the autopilot may introduce a number of additional mechanical and electronic failure modes and change the hazard classification of given aircraft level failures).
Change from assembled primary structure to monolithic or integrally machined structure
No No No Method of construction must be well understood.
Modification to ice protection systems
No No No Recertification required, but certification basis is adequate.
Brakes: design or material change, e.g., steel to carbon
No No No Recertification required, but certification basis is adequate.
The following examples are for NOT SIGNIFICANT changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Redesign floor structure
No No No By itself, not a significant product change. It is significant if part of a cargo conversion of a passenger airplane.
New cabin interior with no fuselage length change
No No No A new cabin interior includes new ceiling and sidewall panels, stowage, galleys, lavatories, and seats. New and novel features in the cabin interior may require special conditions. Many interior related requirements are incorporated in operational rules. Even though the design approval holder may not be required to comply with these requirements, the operator may be required to comply.
A rearrangement of an interior (e.g. seats, galleys, lavatories, closets, etc)
No No No Rearrangement requires the use of the existing floor structure.
Novel or unusual method of construction of a component
No No No The component change does not rise to the product level. Special conditions could be required if there are no existing regulations that adequately address these features.
The following examples are for NOT SIGNIFICANT changes for Transport Airplanes (Part 25):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Initial installation of a non-essential auxiliary power unit (APU)
No No No A stand-alone initial APU installation on an airplane originally designed to use ground/airport supplied electricity, and airconditioning. In this case, the APU would be an option to be independent of airport power.
A rearrangement of an interior (e.g. seats, galleys, lavatories, closets, etc)
No No No Requires the use of the existing mounting structure.
mm/dd/yyyy AC 21.101A
Appendix A
Appendix A
Table 3. Examples of Changes for Rotorcraft (Parts 27 and 29) The following examples are for SUBSTANTIAL changes for Rotorcraft (Parts 27 and 29):
Description of change
Is there a change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Change from the number and or configuration of rotors (e.g., main & tail rotor system to two main rotors)
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
Change from an all metal rotorcraft to all composite rotorcraft
NA NA NA Proposed change in design is so extensive that a substantially complete investigation of compliance with the applicable regulations is required.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Rotorcraft (Parts 27 and 29):
Description of change Is there a
change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Comprehensive flight deck upgrade, such as conversion from entirely federated, independent electromechanical flight instruments to highly integrated and combined electronic display systems with extensive use of software and/or complex electronic hardware.
No No Yes Affects avionics and electrical systems integration and architecture concepts and philosophies.
Certification for flight into known icing conditions
No No Yes
(Fixed) flying controls from mechanical to fly by wire
No No Yes This drives a complete reassessment of the rotorcraft controllability and flight control failure.
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Rotorcraft (Parts 27 and 29):
Description of change Is there a
change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Addition of an engine; e.g., from single to twin or reduction of the number of engines; e.g., from twin to single
Yes Yes Yes May be a substantial change depending upon project details.
A change of rotor drive system primary gearbox splash type lubrication system to a pressure lubricated system due to an increase in horsepower of an engine or changing a piston engine to a turbine engine
No
Yes
Yes
A fuselage or tail boom modification that changes the primary structure, aerodynamics, and operating envelope sufficiently to invalidate the certification assumptions
Yes No Yes
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Rotorcraft (Parts 27 and 29):
Description of change Is there a
change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Application of an approved primary structure to a different approved model (e.g., installation on a former model of the main rotor approved on a new model that results in increase performance)
No Yes Yes
Extensive primary structure changes from metallic material to composite material
No Yes Yes Change in principles of construction and assumptions used for certification for the product level change. Changes of a few individual elements from metal to composite are not typically considered a significant change.
Emergency medical service (EMS) configuration with primary structural changes sufficient to invalidate the certification assumptions.
No No Yes Many EMS configurations will not be classified as significant. Modifications made for EMS are typically internal, and the general external configuration is normally not affected. These changes should not automatically be classified as significant.
Skid landing gear to wheel landing gear or wheel landing to skid
Yes No Yes
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Rotorcraft (Parts 27 and 29):
Description of change Is there a
change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Have the assumptions used for certification been invalidated? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(ii)
Notes
Change of the number of rotor blades
Yes No Yes
Change tail anti-torque device (e.g., tail rotor, ducted fan or other technology)
Yes Yes No
Passenger configured helicopter to a Firefighting equipment configured helicopter
Yes No Yes Depends on the firefighting configuration.
Passenger configured helicopter to a agricultural configured helicopter
Yes No Yes Depends on the agricultural configuration.
A new Category A certification approval to an existing configuration
No No Yes
Instrument flight rules (IFR) upgrades involving installation of upgraded components for new IFR configuration
No No Yes
The following examples are for SIGNIFICANT changes for Rotorcraft (Parts 27 and 29):
Description of change Is there a
change to the general configuration? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Is there a change to the principles of construction? 14 CFR § 21.101(b)(1)(i)
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 177 passages shown