AC 150/5100-14E Architectural, Engineering, and Planning Consultant Services for Airport Grant Projects
This AC provides guidance for airport sponsors in the selection and engagement of architectural, engineering, and planning consultants. It also discusses services that normally would be included in an airport grant project, types of contracts for these services, contract format and provisions, and guidelines for determining the reasonableness of consultant fees. Please see the Principal Changes paragraph for a list of major changes from the last version of this AC.
U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory Circular
Subject: Architectural, Engineering, and Planning Consultant Services for Airport Grant Projects
Date: 9/25/2015 Initiated By: AAS-100
AC No: 150/5100-14E Change: 1
1 Purpose. This advisory circular (AC) provides guidance for airport Sponsors in the selection and engagement of architectural, engineering, and planning consultants. It also discusses services that normally would be included in an airport grant project, types of contracts for these services, contract format and provisions, and guidelines for determining the reasonableness of consultant fees.
2 Cancellation. This AC cancels AC 150/5100-14D, Architectural, Engineering, and Planning Consultant Services for Airport Grant Projects, dated August 30, 2005.
3 Applicability. A Sponsor is required to award each contract for program management, construction management, planning studies, feasibility studies, architectural services, preliminary engineering, design, engineering, surveying, land acquisition services, mapping or related services with respect to the project in the same manner as a contract for architectural and engineering services is negotiated under Title IX of the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act of 1949 (40 U.S.C. Chapter 11, Selection of Architects and Engineers), or an equivalent qualifications-based requirement prescribed for or by the Sponsor of the airport. See 49 U.S.C. § 47107(a) (17) and the grant assurances.
Title 2 of the Code of Federal Regulations (C.F.R.), part 200, establishes uniform administrative rules for Federal grants. The FAA prepared this guidance to assist Sponsor compliance with the procurement requirements of §§200.317-200.326.
This AC does not apply to airport projects that are fully funded with passenger facility charge (PFC) funds.
Consolidated AC Includes Change 1
ii
4 Principal Changes. The AC incorporates the following principal changes. The revisions made by Change 1 are marked by horizontal bars in the outside margins.
1. Clarified Independent Fee Estimates processes.
2. Clarified multiple consultant selection process.
3. Added “Specific Rates of Compensation” method of contracting.
4. Revised and expanded discussion of Alternative Project Delivery Methods, moved to Appendix G.
5. Updated the advisory circular format to the decimal numbering system.
6. The Office of Management and Budget published the Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards; Final Rule, in 78 Federal Register Notice 78590, December 26, 2013. This final guidance contains the administrative requirements formerly contained in (A-110 and A-102), cost principles (A-21, A-87, and A-22), and audit requirements (A-50, A-89, and A-133) for federal awards. As of December 26, 2014, a Sponsor must implement applicable the requirements of 2 CFR §200 to remain allowable for federal assistance.
7. Further clarified multiple consultant selection processes.
8. Clarified allowable costs, applicability of profit and pass-through costs.
Michael J. O’Donnell Director of Airport Safety and Standards
CONTENTS
Paragraph Page
iii
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION … 1-1
1.1 Overview … 1-1
1.2 Definitions … 1-1
1.3 Referenced Documents … 1-1
1.4 Types of Consultant Services … 1-1
1.5 Special Services … 1-4
CHAPTER 2. PROCEDURES FOR SELECTION OF CONSULTANTS … 2-1
2.1 General … 2-1
2.2 Procurement Standards … 2-1
2.3 Competition … 2-2
2.4 Qualifications Based Selection Procedures … 2-3
2.5 Other Services … 2-4
2.6 Selecting Organization … 2-5
2.7 Policy for Selection … 2-6
2.8 Selection Criteria … 2-7
2.9 Selection Procedures … 2-8
2.10 Alternate Selection Procedures … 2-12
2.11 Selection Procedures for Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) Preparation … 2-13
2.12 Scope of Services … 2-14
2.13 Independent Fee Estimate … 2-15
2.14 Negotiations … 2-16
CHAPTER 3. CONTRACT FORMAT AND PROVISIONS … 3-1
3.1 General … 3-1
3.2 Contract Format … 3-1
3.3 Division of Responsibility and Authority … 3-1
3.4 Mandatory Contract Provisions … 3-2
3.5 Time Overruns Beyond Control of the Consultant … 3-2
3.6 Ownership of Drawings and Contract Documents … 3-2
3.7 Contract Checklist … 3-3
3.8 FAA Contract Review … 3-3
CONTENTS
Paragraph Page
iv
3.9 FAA Contract Approval … 3-4
CHAPTER 4. METHODS OF CONTRACTING AND ALLOWABLE COSTS … 4-1
4.1 General … 4-1
4.2 Direct Personal Services … 4-1
4.3 Retainer … 4-3
4.4 Cost-Plus-a-Fixed-Fee (Not to Exceed (NTE)) … 4-4
4.5 Fixed Lump-Sum Payment … 4-6
4.6 Cost-Plus-a-Percentage-of-Cost … 4-7
4.7 Specific Rates of Compensation (Not to Exceed (NTE)) … 4-7
4.8 Sponsor Force Account Projects … 4-8
4.9 Phasing of Work … 4-8
4.10 Allowable Costs … 4-9
4.11 Non-Allowable Costs … 4-10
4.12 Pass-Through Costs … 4-10
APPENDIX A. DEFINITIONS … A-1
APPENDIX B. BIBLIOGRAPHY … B-1
APPENDIX C. SCOPE OF SERVICES SAMPLES … C-1
APPENDIX D. CONSULTANT SERVICES FEE/COSTS SAMPLE … D-1
APPENDIX E. DETAILED FEE/COST ANALYSIS SAMPLE … E-1
APPENDIX F. RECORD OF NEGOTIATIONS SAMPLE … F-1
APPENDIX G. ALTERNATIVE PROJECT DELIVERY SYSTEMS … G-1
1.4 Types of Consultant Services. › 1.4.1 Aviation Planning Services.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Overview. This advisory circular (AC) provides guidance for airport Sponsors in the selection and engagement of architectural, engineering, and planning consultants. This AC discusses services normally included in an airport grant project, types of contracts for these services, contract format, and guidelines for determining the reasonableness of consultant fees.
1.2 Definitions. Definitions of the terms used in this AC are listed in Appendix A.
1.3 Referenced Documents. Documents and regulations referenced throughout this circular are listed in Appendix B.
1.4 Types of Consultant Services. There are two separate and distinct categories of consultant services that are typically utilized for projects conducted under airport grant programs. The first category involves planning services. The second category involves professional services for the design and construction administration/inspection of airport development projects and for land acquisition projects.
1.4.1 Aviation Planning Services. This category includes studies under the broad headings of airport system and master planning, airport noise compatibility planning and environmental assessments and related studies. These studies include, but are not limited to, the following activities:
1. Design study to establish the framework and detailed work program.
2. Airport data collection and facility inventories.
3. Aeronautical activity forecasts and demand/capacity analyses.
4. Facility requirements determination.
5. Airfield modeling for capacity and delay.
6. Airport layout and terminal area plan development.
7. Airport noise studies under 14 CFR Parts 150 and 161.
8. Compatible land-use planning in the vicinity of airports.
9. Airport site selection studies.
10. Airport development schedules and cost estimates.
11. Airport financial planning and benefit cost analysis.
1.4.2 Architectural/Engineering Services for Airport Development Projects. › 1.4.2.2 Design Phase.
12. Participation in public information and community involvement programs and/or public hearings relating to airport development and planning projects.
13. Environmental Assessments (EA), Environmental Impact Statements (EIS), and other studies in accordance with FAA Orders 5050.4 and 1050.1.
14. Preparation of or updating of the airport layout plan.
15. Airspace analysis.
16. GIS data collection, entry, and analysis and other electronic graphical/mapping efforts.
1.4.2 Architectural/Engineering Services for Airport Development Projects. This category includes the basic A/E services normally required for airport development projects. It involves services generally of an architectural, civil, geotechnical, structural, mechanical, and electrical engineering nature. In addition, there may be some services outside those normally considered basic that are discussed in paragraph 1.5. The basic services are usually conducted in, but are not limited to, the five distinct and sequential phases summarized below:
1.4.2.1 Preliminary Phase. This phase involves those activities required for defining the scope of a project and establishing preliminary requirements. Some examples of activities within this phase of a project include, but are not limited to:
1. Coordinating with the Sponsor on project scope requirements, finances, schedules, operational safety and phasing considerations, site access and other pertinent matters.
2. As applicable, coordinating project with local FAA personnel and other interested stakeholders to identify potential impacts to their operations.
3. Planning, procuring, and/or preparing necessary surveys, geotechnical engineering investigations, field investigations, and architectural and engineering studies required for design considerations.
4. Developing design schematics, sketches, environmental and aesthetic considerations, project recommendations, and preliminary layouts and cost estimates.
5. Preparing project design criteria and other bridging documents commonly used for alternative project delivery methods such as designbuild contracting.
1.4.2.2 Design Phase. This phase includes all activities required to undertake and accomplish a full and complete project design. Examples include, but are not limited to, those below:
1. Conducting and attending meetings and design conferences to obtain information and to coordinate or resolve design matters.
1.4.2 Architectural/Engineering Services for Airport Development Projects. › 1.4.2.4 Construction Phase.
2. Collecting engineering data and undertaking field investigations; performing geotechnical engineering studies; and performing architectural, engineering, and special environmental studies.
3. Preparing necessary engineering reports and recommendations.
4. Preparing detailed plans, specifications, cost estimates, and design/construction schedules.
5. Preparing Construction Safety and Phasing Plan (CSPP).
6. Printing and providing necessary copies of engineering drawings and contract specifications.
1.4.2.3 Bidding and Negotiation Phase. These activities are sometimes considered part of the construction phase. They involve assisting the Sponsor in advertising and securing bids, negotiating for services, analyzing bid results, furnishing recommendations on the award of contracts, and preparing contract documents.
1.4.2.4 Construction Phase. This phase may include all basic services rendered after the award of a construction contract, including, but not limited to, the following activities:
1. Providing consultation and advice to the Sponsor during all phases of construction.
2. Representing the Sponsor at preconstruction conferences.
3. Inspecting work in progress periodically and providing appropriate reports to the Sponsor.
4. Reviewing and approving shop and erection drawings submitted by contractors for compliance with design concept/drawings.
5. Reviewing, analyzing, and accepting laboratory and mill test reports of materials and equipment.
6. Assisting in the negotiation of change orders and supplemental agreements.
7. Observing or reviewing performance tests required by specifications.
8. Determining amounts owed to contractors and assisting Sponsors in the preparation of payment requests for amounts reimbursable from grant projects.
9. Making final inspections and submitting punch-lists and a report of the completed project to the Sponsor.
10. Reviewing operations and maintenance manuals.
1.5 Special Services. › 1.5.2 Consultants performing special services may be employed directly…
1.4.2.5 Project Closeout Phase. This phase includes all basic services rendered after the completion of a construction contract, including, but not limited to, the following activities:
1. Making final inspections and submitting punch-lists and a report of the completed project to the Sponsor.
2. Providing record drawings.
3. Preparing summary of material testing report
4. Preparing summary of project change orders
5. Preparing grant amendment request and associated justification, if applicable.
6. Preparing final project reports including financial summary.
7. Obtaining release of liens from all contractors.
1.5 Special Services.
1.5.1 The development of some projects may involve activities or studies outside the scope of the basic design services routinely performed by the consultant. These special services may vary greatly in scope, complexity, and timing and may involve a number of different disciplines and fields of expertise.
1.5.2 Consultants performing special services may be employed directly by the Sponsor to implement one or more phases of a project or may be employed by the principal consultant via a subcontract agreement. In certain instances, these services may be performed by the principal consultant. Some examples of special services that might be employed for airport projects include, but are not limited to, the following:
1. Soil investigations, including core sampling, laboratory tests, related analyses, and reports.
2. Detailed mill, shop, and/or laboratory inspections of materials and equipment.
3. Land surveys and topographic maps.
4. Field and/or construction surveys.
5. Photogrammetry surveys.
6. Onsite construction inspection and/or management involving the services of a fulltime resident engineer(s), inspector(s), or manager(s) during the construction or installation phase of a project. This differs from the periodic inspection responsibilities included as part of the basic services.
7. Special environmental studies and analyses.
8. Expert witness testimony in litigation involving specific projects.
9. Project feasibility studies.
10. Public information and community involvement surveys, studies, and activities.
11. Preparation of record drawings.
12. Assisting the Sponsor in the preparation of necessary applications for local, State, and Federal grants.
13. Preparation of an as-built airport layout plan.
14. Preparation of property maps.
15. Preparation of quality control plan.
16. Preparation of final report.
Page Intentionally Blank
2.2 Procurement Standards. › 2.2.2 Consultants employed for work on projects involving airport…
CHAPTER 2. PROCEDURES FOR SELECTION OF CONSULTANTS
2.1 General. The procedures included in this chapter provide guidance for Sponsors in the selection and engagement of architectural, engineering, environmental, and planning consultants on projects funded wholly or in part under Federal airport grant programs. Adherence to these procedures will assure a Sponsor of compliance with the requirements of 49 USC § 47107(a) (17) and 2 CFR §200.320, as amended.
2.1.1 49 USC § 47107(a) (17) states: “Each contract and subcontract for program management, construction management, planning studies, feasibility studies, architectural services, preliminary engineering, design engineering, surveying, mapping, and related services will be awarded in the same way that a contract for architectural and engineering services is negotiated under Chapter 11 of Title 40 or an equivalent qualifications based requirement prescribed for or by the Sponsor.” In addition to the services described in this statute, the professional and incidental services listed under A/E Services in Appendix A, must also be procured using qualifications based procedures.
2.1.2 2 CFR § 200.320 establishes that procurement by competitive proposal, where price is not a factor, may only be used for procurement of architectural/engineering (A/E) services. It may not be used for other services even though an A/E firm may be a potential source to perform the service. If a conflict exists between 49 USC § 47107(a) (17) and 2 CFR 200, the statute will prevail.
2.1.3 Title IX of the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act of 1949 requires that qualifications based selection procedures be used for the selection of firms to perform architectural and engineering services. Qualifications based procedures require that a contract for A/E services be awarded pursuant to a fair and open selection process based on the qualifications of the firms. The fees for such services are established following selection of a firm through a negotiation process to determine a fair and reasonable price.
2.2 Procurement Standards.
2.2.1 The selection of qualified consultants must be made on the basis of fair negotiations and equitable fees and through selection procedures that are professionally acceptable, ensure maximum open and free competition, and avoid any suggestion of unfair or unethical conduct.
2.2.2 Consultants employed for work on projects involving airport grants must be responsible and possess the ability to perform successfully under the terms and conditions of the proposed procurement. Consideration should be given to such matters as integrity, record of past performance, extent of experience with the type of services required by the Sponsor, technical resources, and accessibility to other necessary resources.
2.3.2 An unfair competitive advantage may exist when one firm has… › 2.3.2.2 There are situations where an unfair competitive advantage can…
2.2.3 The Sponsor’s procurement action must be void of individual and organizational conflicts of interests both real and/or perceived.
2.2.3.1 Individual conflicts of interest may exist whenever a Sponsor’s employee, officer, agent or family member thereof has a financial or other interest in the firms competing for the work.
2.2.3.2 Organizational conflicts of interest may exist when there is a lack of impartiality, impaired objectivity or an unfair advantage with one or more of the firms competing for the work.
2.2.4 Sponsors must maintain sufficient records, made available at the FAA’s request, to detail the significant history of their procurement action. This includes the rationale for the procurement method; the selection considerations; contract type and basis for contract price.
2.3 Competition
2.3.1 Per § 200.319, all procurement transactions must be conducted in a manner providing full and open competition. It is the responsibility of the Sponsor to assess whether their procurements conform to the requirements of §200.318 for addressing conflict of interest and the standards of §200.319 for full and open competition.
2.3.2 An unfair competitive advantage may exist when one firm has access to source selection information that competing firms do not have similar access to.
2.3.2.1 To ensure objective contractor performance and eliminate unfair competitive advantage, 2 CFR part §200.319 requires entities that develop or draft specifications, requirements, statements of work, invitations for bids, or requests for proposals must be excluded from competing for such procurements. However, once selected, the successful consultant may participate in further definition of the scope of work. For purposes of full disclosure, Sponsors that seek external assistance with preparation of Statements of Work (SOW) for a request for qualifications (RFQ) are encouraged to make the restrictions of §200.319 known to the firm providing the assistance. For additional discussion on this please refer to the latest version of Order 5100.38.
2.3.2.2 There are situations where an unfair competitive advantage can be mitigated or neutralized. For example, the consultant who performs master plan services for a Sponsor or assists a Sponsor with preparation of their Capital Improvement Program would have an apparent unfair competitive advantage when competing for follow-on engineering design services. A Sponsor can mitigate this unfair advantage through full and open disclosure of the source selection information to all competing firms. The restrictions of 2.3.2.1 however, cannot be mitigated or neutralize.
Chapter 2. Procedures for Selection of Consultants › 2.4 Qualifications Based Selection Procedures.
2.3.3 Objective consultant performance can be compromised whenever a firm is in a position where they could apply undue influence on Sponsor decisions that ultimately benefit the consultant. Sponsors that combine the selection of a planning consultant and engineering consultant create the potential for a problematic situation that may jeopardize AIP participation in the Sponsor’s professional services expenses. This is primarily due to conflicts with the AIP procurement requirements, found in Order 5100.38, such as the following:
1. Objectivity of the planning consultant’s performance may be compromised because the firm is in a position to establish development objectives for which the same firm will be tasked with engineering design services. This is an apparent lack of impartiality that may influence the planning initiative and the identification of preferred development objectives.
2. There is diminished transparency of the procurement action for engineering design services given that the development objectives are not established at the time the Sponsor conducts that selection process.
3. Firms that specialize in one type of service may be unfairly excluded from competing for a project when the Sponsor combines distinct types of services.
4. Per FAA Order 5050.4B,, consultants that prepare an Environment Impact Statement may not compete for future work the EIS addresses until such time the FAA has issued a Record of Decision.
2.3.4 Sponsors can mitigate these apparent concerns regarding procurement transparency and objective contractor performance by separating the procurement of a planning consultant from that of an engineering design consultant. With the exception of the restrictions established under 2 CFR §200.319 (See 2.3.2.1), a consultant that performs planning services may compete for follow-on engineering provided the Sponsor properly mitigates any situations of unfair competitive advantage (See 2.3.2.2).
2.3.5 It may be permissible under certain circumstances for a Sponsor to combine the selection for certain planning type services and design type services provided there is no loss of objectivity of the planning action or loss of transparency in the procurement process. For example, the update of an airport layout plan for which no new development objectives are established could be combined with design services.
2.4 Qualifications Based Selection Procedures. Consultants must be selected on the basis of their qualifications and experience, with fees determined through negotiations following selection. The qualifications of consultants are evaluated and the best qualified consultant is selected, subject to a mutual understanding of the scope of services and negotiation of a fair and reasonable fee. Figure 2-1 is an overview of the recommended Qualifications Based Consultant Selection process.
Figure 2-1 · page 14Picture of the page from the copy saved here
2.5 Other Services. › 2.5.2 Where services such as feasibility studies, construction…
Figure 2-1. Qualifications Based Selection Process
Flowchart showing the Qualificat
ion Based Selection Process descr
ibed above
2.5 Other Services.
2.5.1 Where services are to be performed in conjunction with the architectural, planning, environmental, or engineering services, they must be contracted for in the course of procuring the A/E services.
2.5.2 Where services such as feasibility studies, construction management, program management and other services as defined in 49 USC § 47107(a) (17) and A/E services as defined in Appendix A are to be performed, they must be procured using qualifications based procedures.
2.6 Selecting Organization. › 2.6.2 The typical procedure for selecting a consultant is to use a…
2.5.3 Where services are to be performed that are not in conjunction with A/E and planning services and do not require performance by a licensed architect or engineer, the services should be acquired using local procurement procedures. An example of this type of special service would be soil borings, whereby the boring layout plan and interpretations of tests are not performed by the boring contractor. Soil borings conducted as part of a geotechnical engineering investigation or for which an independent engineer is responsible must be procured either in the course of procuring A/E services or by using qualifications based procedures.
2.5.4 Where services are to be performed in assisting the FAA in preparing an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), they must be procured using qualifications based selection procedures (see paragraph 2.11).
2.5.5 Where a Sponsor decides to utilize an Alternative Project Delivery System (APDS) such as design-build (DB) or construction manager-at-risk (CMAR), the Sponsor may use the competitive proposal approach (as defined in 2 CFR §200.320) for selection provided price and other factors such as qualifications, skill, experience, and design approach are considered when selecting a firm to perform this service. The selection of an A/E services firm is the only instance where prices must be excluded as a consideration under a competitive proposal selection. Please reference Appendix G, Alternative Project Delivery Systems, of this Advisory Circular for guidance in procuring these types of services.
2.6 Selecting Organization.
2.6.1 Within the Sponsor's organization, an administrative policy should be established for designating persons authorized to select or recommend consultants for various assignments. The persons designated may include the administrator or the department head to be supplemented by others making up a selection board. The persons empowered to make the selection of one consultant over another must be kept free of pressures, both internal and external. 2 CFR § 200.318(c) requires that Sponsors maintain a written code of standards of conduct governing the performance of their employees engaged in the award and administration of contracts. They must not participate in selection or in the award or administration of a contract supported by Federal funds if a conflict of interest, real or apparent, would be involved.
2.6.2 The typical procedure for selecting a consultant is to use a selection board composed of at least three persons, with at least one being an engineer, airport planner, or other professional knowledgeable of the service required. For projects that have special design requirements or are particularly complex, the selection board should have additional technical members with the appropriate expertise in those required disciplines. The board should be prepared to evaluate potential consultants, i.e., conduct interviews and inquiries as desired and make recommendations to the governing body in accordance with paragraph 2.9.14.
2.7 Policy for Selection. › 2.7.2 Sponsors may procure a consultant for several projects through…
2.7 Policy for Selection.
2.7.1 The selection of a consultant must be based on a comparative analysis of the professional qualifications necessary for satisfactory performance of the service required. Moreover, the selection process must satisfy requirements for open and free competition.
2.7.2 Sponsors may procure a consultant for several projects through one procurement action provided the following conditions are met:
1. The consultant is selected using the qualifications based selection procedures described in paragraph 2.9.
2. The parties competing for the work must be advised that the work may be accomplished during the course of multiple grants. The expected schedule of projects must be defined, together with a statement of work and the required services. The statement of work must be described in sufficient detail so that all parties may adequately establish the type of services required to accomplish the work. Avoid generic statements of work.
3. All parties are advised that some of the services may not be required and that the Sponsor reserves the right to initiate additional procurement action for any of the services included in the initial procurement.
4. The services are limited to those specific projects that the Sponsor reasonably expects to initiate within five (5) years (See Para. 3-59, FAA Order 5100.38) of the effective date of the initial contract. With mutual and written agreement between the Sponsor and the FAA, additional projects or work elements may be added after the original selection if all of the following conditions exist:
1. The Sponsor can provide acceptable justification for not initiating a new procurement action (Note: Convenience of the Sponsor is not an acceptable justification to forgo a separate procurement action).
2. Added project(s) or work element(s) is (are) similar in character to the statement of work the Sponsor used in the original selection.
3. Added projects or work elements do not require services or qualifications not previously included in the original selection.
4. The cumulative cost of services for the added projects or work elements is not expected to exceed the simplified acquisition threshold as defined in Para. U-12 of FAA Order 5100.38.
If the above-listed conditions do not exist, Sponsors that want to add work elements not specifically included in the original procurement action must conduct a separate and new procurement action. Projects initiated within the first five (5) years may continue beyond the duration of the initial contract; however once 5-year duration has ended no new projects should be initiated without a new procurement action.
5. If more than one party is selected, the expected projects to be performed by each party must be defined, together with the statement of work and the required services, at the time of the initial procurement action. The Sponsor must provide
2.8 Selection Criteria. › 2.8.2 Based on a Sponsor’s goals/objectives for each project, the list…
notification to each firm of the projects they were awarded. Sponsors must avoid the practice of selecting multiple firms and assigning project responsibility at a later date.
6. The negotiation of the fee is limited to the services expected to be performed under the first grant or project after the initial procurement action. The contract must be limited to the services covered by the negotiated fee. The negotiation of the fee for subsequent services, i.e., services included in the procurement action but not in the initial contract, must occur at the time those services are needed. A fee estimate must be performed for each of these negotiations (See paragraph 2.13 for information on fee estimate.). If a fee cannot be agreed upon between the Sponsor and the selected firm, then negotiations are terminated with that firm. If the Sponsor identified and ranked multiple firms for the project at the time of the initial procurement action, then the Sponsor may enter into negotiations with the firm ranked next. If no additional firms were identified and ranked or agreement is not reached with any selected firms, then the Sponsor must initiate a new procurement action.
7. In the case of an unforeseen project as in Paragraph 4, the Sponsor and the FAA may mutually agree on the ranking of the selected consultants by evaluating their capabilities and the scope of the unforeseen project. However, if the scope of the unforeseen project does not match the capabilities of the selected consultants, a new procurement action must be conducted.
2.7.3 Unless there is a compelling reason that there is a benefit to the FAA to combine eligible and ineligible projects in a single solicitation, Sponsors are discouraged from doing so. See Order 5100.38 for additional information.
2.8 Selection Criteria.
2.8.1 Based on the proposed scope of service(s) and prior to evaluating consultants, a Sponsor(s) must develop a list of selection criteria to be used in evaluating potential consultants. Numerical rating factors (ranges) should be assigned to each criterion on the basis of the Sponsor's priorities and conception of the importance of each factor in the attainment of a successful project. The Sponsor(s) should include the criteria with a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) in advance of the selection process.
2.8.2 Based on a Sponsor’s goals/objectives for each project, the list of selection criteria will vary for each RFQ and must be appropriate for the proposed scope of services. Suggested selection criteria include, but are not limited to, the following:
1. Capability to perform all or most aspects of the project and recent experience in airport projects comparable to the proposed task.
2. Key personnel’s professional qualifications and experience and availability for the proposed project; their reputation and professional integrity and competence; and their knowledge of FAA regulations, policies, and procedures.
3. Capability to meet schedules or deadlines.
4. Quality of projects previously undertaken and capability to complete projects without having major cost escalations or overruns.
Chapter 2. Procedures for Selection of Consultants › 2.9 Selection Procedures.
5. Qualifications and experience of sub-consultants regularly engaged by the consultant under consideration.
6. Capability of a branch office that will do the work to perform independently of the home office, or conversely, its capability to obtain necessary support from the home office. The use of geographic location may be a selection criteria provided its application leaves an appropriate number of qualified firms, given the nature and size of the project, to compete for the contract.
7. Ability to furnish qualified inspectors for construction inspection if applicable.
8. Understanding of the project’s potential challenges and the Sponsor’s special concerns.
9. Degree of interest shown in undertaking the project and their familiarity with and proximity to the geographic location of the project.
10. Capability to incorporate and blend aesthetic and architectural concepts with the project design while accomplishing the basic requirements that transportation facilities be functional, safe, and efficient.
11. In meeting the Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) contract goal, evidence documenting that the consultant met the DBE goal, or by documenting that it made adequate good faith efforts to meet the DBE goal. (See 49 CFR, § 26.53)
12. Capability to conduct a Value Engineering (VE) study for projects that are particularly complex or have unique features. Order 5100.38, Chapter 3, Subsection 3-57; AC 150/5300-15, Use of Value Engineering for Engineering and Design of Airport Grant Projects; and AC 150/5370-10, Standards for Specifying Construction of Airports, contain additional guidance on VE studies.
2.9 Selection Procedures. The Sponsor must use the following selection procedures or equivalent State/Sponsor qualifications based selection for individual project selections involving Federal airport grants (see Figure 2-1 and Figure 2-2). However, the requirement for both an RFQ and an RFP should be evaluated based on the complexity of the project as these steps may be combined into a single request.
Figure 2-2. Consultant Selection Process for a Single Project
Yes
No
Figure 2-2 · page 19Picture of the page from the copy saved here
Consultant submits cost proposal
and detailed project proposal
Par. 2.12 Perform independent fee
estimate
Par. 2.14 Conduct Negotiations
Return to Figure 2-1
Flowchart illustrat
ing Consultant Sele ction Process for a Si
ngle Project des
cribed above.
2.9.1 The selection board should review the nature of the proposed project and the general scope of services to be procured in order to ensure an understanding of the project requirements and the qualifications needed by the consultant.
2.9 Selection Procedures. › 2.9.6 FAA Airports field offices may also furnish the names of…
2.9.2 As discussed in paragraph 2.8, the selection board must develop the selection criteria and the evaluation system used in preparing a pre-selection short-list of consultants who are best qualified for the project as well as in determining the final selection.
2.9.3 To obtain experience and qualification data from potentially qualified consultants, the Sponsor should issue an RFQ inviting consultants to submit their experience and qualifications data relating to the proposed project usually in the form of a Statement of Qualifications (SOQ). To ensure the broadest publicity concerning Sponsor interest in obtaining consultant services, public announcements for all projects should be advertised in local newspapers with a wide circulation, national trade journals and magazines, and through electronic media. Public announcements should include information such as a description of the proposed project and its location, a description of the services, and the estimated range of construction costs. The public announcement should allow sufficient time for submission of the statement of qualifications.
2.9.4 Sponsors may also send the public announcements directly to known, potentially qualified consultants to determine their interest in the project and to request their experience and qualification data.
2.9.5 Affirmative steps pursuant to 2 CFR §200.321 and good faith efforts should be taken to assure that small and minority firms are used whenever possible, consistent with 49 CFR part 26. These steps and efforts should include, but not be limited to, the following:
1. Include qualified small business and minority firms on solicitation lists.
2. Assure that small business and minority firms are solicited whenever they are potential sources. Consultation with regional Airports Divisions, Office of Civil Rights, and/or State transportation offices is encouraged.
3. Divide the total requirements into small tasks, when economically feasible, to permit maximum small business and DBE firm participation.
4. Use the services and assistance of the Small Business Administration, the Minority Business Development Agency of the Department of Commerce, and the Minority Resource Center Regional Centers of the Department of Transportation (http://osdbu.dot.gov).
5. Arrange solicitations, time for presentation of offers and delivery schedules to facilitate DBE and other small business participation.
6. Encourage consultants to subcontract portions of the work, even when they might otherwise perform the work with their own forces.
2.9.6 FAA Airports field offices may also furnish the names of consultants who have engaged in projects of similar nature in their areas of jurisdiction. However, with the exception
of an EIS, FAA personnel will not recommend consultants or participate in the selection process. The addresses of FAA Airports Regional/District Offices having jurisdiction over specific geographic areas are available at: http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/arp/regional_offices/
2.9.7 From the experience and qualification data obtained from consultants, the selection board should prepare a pre-selection short-list of the best qualified consultants for further consideration. With adequate response to the RFQ, the typical pre-selection short-list should consist of between three and five consultants.
2.9.8 At this point, consultants who expressed an interest in the project but were not included on the pre-selection short-list should be notified that they were unsuccessful.
2.9.9 Detailed information on the qualifications and performance data of each of the consultants on the pre-selection short-list should be obtained. This can be achieved by contacting former clients identified by the consultant in their statement of qualifications to ascertain the quality of work, ability to meet schedules, cost control, and consultantclient relationship.
2.9.10 At this point, the selection organization may elect to obtain a general project proposal from each of the firms on the pre-selection short-list, typically by issuing a Request for Proposal (RFP) to each consultant on the pre-selection short-list. The RFP should include a detailed description of the project and the proposed scope of services required. The selection criteria, including their relative importance that will be used to evaluate the proposals must also be made available to each of the firms on the pre-selection short-list. The RFP shall not contain a request for any cost information, such as total cost, cost per hour, work hours, or other pricing data. Requests for cost or pricing information, prior to discussions with the best qualified firm, to define the scope of services is contrary to 49 USC § 47107 (a) (17) and 2 CFR § 200.320(d). The general project proposal will help the selection board recommend a consultant who can achieve design excellence, while successfully controlling time and costs and who has the ability to understand and accomplish the specialized requirements of the project. The elements of a typical general project proposal should include, but are not limited to, the following:
1. Team members, other key personnel, previous experience, and the role they will fill on the project. The qualifications and time commitment of the project manager proposed for the project.
2. Current workload.
3. Proposed project schedule, including major tasks and target completion dates.
4. Technical approach – a brief discussion of the tasks or steps that the consultant will take to accomplish the work described in the scope of services.
5. Value engineering – when a value engineering study is included in the selection criteria, a brief discussion of the consultant’s capability, training, and experience to carry out such a study.
2.10.2 Informal Procedures. › 2.10.2.1 Informal Qualifications Based Selection procedures may be used…
2.9.11 Conduct interviews with each consultant on the pre-selection short-list. On small projects, a telephone interview may be sufficient. Careful consideration of time and cost should be given to the need for formal interviews. If Sponsor has received sufficient information included in the qualification submission to make a selection, then formal interviews may not be necessary.
2.9.12 Review the experience and qualifications data, the general project proposal, the interview results, and other relevant data. Using the selection criteria developed for the project; rank the qualified consultants in order of preference.
2.9.13 Initiate discussion with the first-ranked consultant to fully define the scope of work and services to be provided (see paragraph 2.12). After agreement on a detailed scope of services has been reached, the Sponsor initiates actions to prepare an Independent Fee Estimate (IFE) in conformance with 3 CFR §200.323 and Table 3-67 of FAA Order 5100.38. Simultaneously, instruct the selected consultant to prepare and submit their cost proposal along with a detailed draft contract agreement. To ensure the integrity of the negotiation process, the Sponsor should not receive the fee proposal ahead of the IFE. The consultant should submit their cost proposals together with a detailed project proposal. Negotiations should then be conducted to reach a fair and reasonable fee, subject to the procedures indicated in paragraphs 2.13 and 2.14.
2.9.14 Prepare a report that documents the Sponsor’s procurement actions and the selection of the consultant they deem most qualified. The report must contain sufficient detail to indicate the extent of the review and the considerations used for the recommendations. The report should be forwarded to the Sponsor's administrator or governing body authorized to review the recommendations of the selection board. The recommendations of the selection board should normally be accepted unless the report does not adequately support the recommendations. This will help to ensure complete fairness and open competition. If the recommendations are not accepted, the selection board should reconvene until acceptable recommendations have been agreed upon.
2.10 Alternate Selection Procedures.
2.10.1 Proposals Requested with Qualification Data. The selection procedure recommended in paragraph 2.9 should normally be followed in the procurement of consulting services. For small projects where the scope of work and services can be clearly defined or the Sponsor anticipates receipt of less than four proposals, the Sponsor may wish to solicit proposals at the time of advertising for experience and qualification data. In this case, the announcement must contain a detailed scope of services and indicate where the selection criteria can be obtained. The advertisement cannot request pricing information.
2.10.2 Informal Procedures.
2.10.2.1 Informal Qualifications Based Selection procedures may be used for A/E procurements estimated to be less than $100,000. However, this does not
Chapter 2. Procedures for Selection of Consultants › 2.11 Selection Procedures for Environmental Impact Statement (EIS)…
relieve the Sponsor from the obligation to perform a cost analysis and prepare an independent fee estimate (see paragraph 2.13). Sponsors must consult with FAA Airport personnel before using informal procedures to assure that the circumstances justify their use.
2.10.2.2 Under this procedure, a Sponsor must contact at least three firms and discuss their qualifications to perform the work. Negotiations must then be conducted with the best-qualified firm to arrive at a fee. These negotiations may be conducted via telephone or e-mail. After selection, using this procedure, the Sponsor must document their procurement action and then submit a statement to the FAA explaining the basis for the selection and method used to determine reasonableness of the fee.
2.10.2.3 The informal selection process may not be used to select a firm for multiple projects.
2.10.3 Non-competitive Procedures. The FAA may authorize non-competitive negotiation for services if the cost of the contract is not expected to exceed $10,000 and the services are incidental to the grant project. When this procedure is used, the Sponsor must submit a statement to the FAA explaining the basis used to determine reasonableness of cost as discussed in 2.10.2 above.
2.11 Selection Procedures for Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) Preparation. The procurement of consultant services to assist the FAA in preparing an EIS is somewhat unique because the regulations implementing the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) (42 USC § 4321 et seq.), require Federal agencies to prepare the EIS or select the contractor that prepares the EIS (Orders 5050.4 and 1050.1 provide additional guidance). Selection of a consultant must, therefore, be made by the FAA from a short-list of qualified consultants submitted by the Sponsor. The Sponsor and the FAA must follow the selection procedures recommended in paragraph 2.9 with the following exceptions:
1. The proposed scope of work is to be provided by the FAA.
2. The FAA must concur with the selection and evaluation criteria prepared by the Sponsor.
3. The FAA will be invited to participate with the Sponsor in the interviews with consultants on the pre-selection short-list.
4. The Sponsor may indicate to the FAA their ranking of the consultants on the preselection short-list after the interview process has been concluded. The FAA, however, is under no obligation to make a selection based on this ranking.
5. Using the Sponsor selection and evaluation criteria previously agreed to and established by the Sponsor and the FAA, the FAA will independently evaluate and rank the consultants on the pre-selection short-list in order of preference, based on qualifications.
2.12 Scope of Services. › 2.12.2 The scope of service(s) must be sufficiently detailed so that…
6. The FAA must advise the Sponsor of the FAA's ranking in order of preference, and the Sponsor must advise and initiate discussions with the consultant ranked first.
7. The FAA will be invited to discussions on the scope during any IFE process conducted by the Sponsor or their consultant, as necessary.
8. The FAA's involvement in the negotiation of the project cost must be limited to making a reasonableness determination once a satisfactory cost proposal has been reached between the Sponsor and the consultant.
9. The FAA must prepare a selection report for its records.
2.12 Scope of Services.
2.12.1 An important step in the negotiation process is to reach a complete and mutual understanding of the scope of services to be provided. The general scope of services developed during initiation of the procurement process is of necessity too broad to serve as the basis for a contractual agreement. A well-defined project description and scope of services should be developed between the Sponsor and first-ranked consultant prior to negotiating a project design fee. This may be accomplished in a scoping meeting or separate investigation or study to clearly define the extent of the project. The Sponsor's engineer or independent consultant (see paragraph 2.13) should attend the meeting so they will have a complete understanding of the scope of services prior to developing a detailed fee estimate. Such a meeting offers the opportunity for refinement, amendment, and complete definition of the services to be rendered.
2.12.2 The scope of service(s) must be sufficiently detailed so that the consultant can make a reasonable fee estimate (see Appendix E). Although the scope of service(s) will vary from project to project (see samples in Appendix C), the following items are typical of those that should be considered in developing the scope of services:
1. List of meetings the consultant is expected to attend.
2. Design schedule.
3. Special services required.
4. Complexity of design.
5. Safety and operational considerations.
6. Environmental considerations.
7. Survey and geotechnical testing requirements.
8. Sponsor representation services during construction.
9. Quality control during construction.
10. Preparation of forms, letters, documents, and reports.
11. Airport Layout Plan updates.
12. Property map preparation.
2.13 Independent Fee Estimate. › 2.13.3 The level of detail needed to satisfy the requirements of an IFE…
13. Quality control during design.
14. Coordination with other consultants and agencies.
15. Deliverables.
16. Data and material furnished by the Sponsor.
17. Testing and commissioning requirements.
18. City/county requirements.
19. Number of bid packages.
20. Complexity of construction phasing to minimize impacts on airport operations.
21. Public Outreach.
2.13 Independent Fee Estimate.
2.13.1 A Sponsor must perform a price or cost analysis for every A/E contract (2 CFR § 200.323). The method and degree of analysis is dependent on the facts surrounding the contract. To properly evaluate the cost of professional services an independent fee estimate (IFE) is required, prior to receiving the consultant’s proposal, as part of the cost analysis for all A/E contracts and contract modifications. The IFE is intended to be used as a negotiation tool by the Sponsor. The word “independent” does not imply that the IFE has to be performed by someone other than the Sponsor. Preparation of an IFE can be completed in a number of ways, such as the following, or as approved by your local ADO:
1. A Sponsor having a staff with experience in estimating the professional services and negotiating contracts for these services can develop its own IFE for the services, based on the scope of services agreed upon in paragraph 2.12.
2. Sponsors having no staff with this expertise or having minimal or no previous experience may engage the services of a consultant on retainer for preparation of the IFE provided the consultant has experience with the services involved and who is not being considered for the project.
3. Alternatively, an independent engineering, architecture, or planning consultant may be retained to prepare an IFE provided this consultant was not on the pre-selection short-list. The consultant must have recent experience in airport work similar to that proposed and be familiar with FAA requirements and procedures. The Sponsor should request evidence that the consultant meets the above requirements.
2.13.2 State aviation personnel who have experience with the services involved may also prepare the IFE for the Sponsor’s use.
2.13.3 The level of detail needed to satisfy the requirements of an IFE varies and is dependent on the anticipated value of the A/E contract. For contracts with an anticipated value less than $100,000 the Sponsor can satisfy the IFE requirement by comparing the A/E contract with previous contracts of a similar nature, or preparing a detailed fee/cost
2.14 Negotiations. › 2.14.3 When evaluating the reasonableness of a consultant’s fee…
analysis (see Appendix E). At a minimum, the independent estimate must address direct labor work hours, labor rates, general and administrative overhead, non-salary expenses and a reasonable profit. For contracts anticipated to be greater than $100,000 a detailed fee/cost analysis is required.
2.13.4 If the Sponsor hires a consultant to perform any of these functions, that consultant may be retained using informal or non-competitive qualifications based procedures (see paragraphs 2.10.2 and 2.9.3) as applicable; however, the IFE consultant will not be eligible for consideration to perform work on the project.
2.13.5 Another source on estimating consultant’s cost can be found in ASCE Manuals and Reports on Engineering Practice No. 45, “How to Work Effectively with Consulting Engineers.” However, these graphs must be used with judgment and within their stated limitations. Other resources include project history files, previous contracts, etc.
2.13.6 Sponsors have an obligation to obtain a fair and reasonable fee in all cases. Prior to initiating further discussions with the first-ranked consultant, the Sponsor must accept the IFE and retain it for their records. Appendices D and E present sample formats for consultant services fee/cost and detailed fee/cost analysis respectively, however any format that meets this purpose is acceptable. The FAA retains the right to disallow negotiated fees that the FAA determines to be unreasonable.
2.14 Negotiations.
2.14.1 After developing a detailed scope of services and after the IFE requirements have been satisfied per Par. 2.12, the Sponsor may enter into negotiations with the consultant given first preference by the selection board. Once the rankings have been established, the Sponsor shall inform the other firms on the pre-selection shortlist that negotiations have been initiated with the first ranked firm. If an independent firm has been retained by the Sponsor for the purpose of preparing an independent fee estimate, the firm may be consulted by the Sponsor during negotiations, to clarify problem areas, but not to review the consultant’s fee proposal or attend any negotiating sessions.
2.14.2 Based on the scope of services agreed upon in paragraph 2.12, the Sponsor must request the consultant to submit the proposed fee and supporting cost breakdown. The consultant must prepare a detailed estimate of the hours and cost required for each of the major tasks. In addition to charges for labor, the consultant should, if appropriate, indicate the costs for subcontractors, travel, living expenses, reproduction, and other out-of-pocket expenses expected to be incurred.
2.14.3 When evaluating the reasonableness of a consultant’s fee proposal, a general review standard used within the FAA and industry is whether the total fee proposal, as well as individual tasks within the proposal, is within 10% of the IFE. When differences exceed 10%, the Sponsor and IFE preparer should review those areas with the consultant to determine if there is a misunderstanding of the scope of services or level of effort required to complete the work. While this should not be construed as policy,
2.14 Negotiations. › 2.14.9 If requested by the FAA, the Sponsor must submit the record of…
the use of the 10% standard is one method to help identify areas of significant difference between the consultant’s fee proposal and the IFE.
2.14.4 Negotiations should be based upon the data submitted by the consultant and an evaluation of the specific work hours required for each task. The Sponsor should subject the consultant's data to a technical/engineering analysis. Based on this analysis, the Sponsor should identify differences in the work-hour estimates. Significant differences, either positive or negative, between the estimate submitted by the consultant and the estimate developed by the Sponsor should be resolved, and revisions should be made to the work hours or scope of services as required. The fee should then be evaluated, taking into consideration the experience level required by the engineer working on each task. A sample fee/cost analysis form is shown in Appendix E.
2.14.5 If a mutually satisfactory contract cannot be negotiated with the first-ranked consultant, the negotiations must be terminated and the consultant notified. Negotiations must then be initiated with the consultant given second preference by the selection board. This procedure must be continued with recommended consultants in the sequence of ranking established by the selection board until a mutually satisfactory contract has been negotiated. Once negotiations have been terminated with a firm and begun with another, they cannot be reopened with the former firm.
2.14.6 A record of negotiations must be prepared by the Sponsor and included in the contract file. This record must contain sufficient detail to reflect any changes in the scope of services controlling the establishment of the cost and other terms of the contract. An explanation must be provided for any significant differences between the Sponsor's original estimate and the final fee agreed upon. The scope of services, draft contract, Sponsor's independent fee estimate, consultant’s fee proposal with any revisions, and detailed fee analysis must be attached to the report. A sample Record of Negotiations is contained in Appendix F.
2.14.7 Upon completion of successful negotiations, all consultants interviewed by the selection board should be informed of the consultant selected for the project.
2.14.8 FAA personnel will not be present and will not participate in the negotiation process. The FAA's role is to make a judgment on the reasonableness of the compensation for the services to be furnished and to ensure that all services required for a particular project have been included in the proposal.
2.14.9 If requested by the FAA, the Sponsor must submit the record of negotiations and all attachments to the FAA for a reasonableness of cost determination (Order 5100.38, Chapter 3, Section 14).
Page Intentionally Blank
3.3 Division of Responsibility and Authority. › 3.3.2 The contract between the Sponsor and consultant is based on the…
CHAPTER 3. CONTRACT FORMAT AND PROVISIONS
3.1 General.
3.1.1 The relationship of the consultant with the Sponsor should be clearly defined by a written agreement before commencement of actual work. All of the terms should be clearly defined in the agreement. It should state the parties to the contract and define the complete extent and character of the work to be performed as well as conditions relating to any time limitations that may be involved. The terms and payments for various services should be included. The scope of the consultant effort should be described in complete detail to determine the sufficiency of the supervisory and inspection staff and to determine whether some services will need to be otherwise contracted for or be provided by the Sponsor.
3.1.2 Consultant contracts usually cover highly technical services. Therefore, to assure the soundness of a legal document, it is essential that someone who has thorough knowledge of the project prepare the sections describing services to be performed, sequence of work, information to be furnished by the Sponsor, and terms of payment.
3.2 Contract Format. Many government agencies, business firms, and engineering organizations have developed standardized forms for engineering and planning contracts. The American Council of Engineering Companies, the National Society of Professional Engineers, and the American Society of Civil Engineers have developed such standardized forms. Some State aviation departments have developed standardized forms for engineering services provided in their own states. The American Institute of Architects has standardized forms for architectural contracts. It is often necessary to modify these standard agreements to reflect the specific terms and conditions applicable to a particular project, as well as the mandatory contract provisions in paragraph 3.4.
3.3 Division of Responsibility and Authority.
3.3.1 It is common to have one firm provide the basic services and one or more firms provide special services. In these cases, the firm providing the basic consultant services is considered the primary engineer or principal consultant as defined in Appendix A. As such, the principal consultant represents the Sponsor in coordinating and overseeing the work of other engineering/consultant firms and has the overall responsibility to coordinate the work and to review the work products for general conformance to the requirements of the Sponsor. Therefore, it is extremely important that the contract documents clearly specify the division of responsibility and authority between all parties involved in carrying out elements of the project.
3.3.2 The contract between the Sponsor and consultant is based on the scope of services established earlier in the process (see paragraph 2.12) and involves carrying out professional duties under the requirements of law. The contract must not attempt to
3.6 Ownership of Drawings and Contract Documents. › 3.6.2 When a contract is only for preliminary plans, no commitment that…
make the consultant an indemnitor of the Sponsor such as in the event of the Sponsor's negligence or the absence of any wrongdoing by the consultant. The consultant must fully stand behind their services and indemnify the Sponsor for damages and expenses caused by their own errors, omissions, and negligent or wrongful acts.
3.3.3 Expanding the consultant’s liability beyond the scope or purpose of a contract could affect the competitive process of contract award in a way that conflicts with the requirements of 2 CFR §200.319 and may impact Federal eligibility.
3.4 Mandatory Contract Provisions.
3.4.1 Federal laws and regulations prescribe that certain provisions be included in federally funded contracts. For purposes of this section, the term "contract" includes subcontracts. The type of contract must be appropriate for the particular procurement.
3.4.2 Specific wording of Federal contract provisions is available on the FAA website at http://www.faa.gov/airports/aip/procurement/.
3.5 Time Overruns Beyond Control of the Consultant. Frequently, the consultant is called upon to continue technical inspection services on construction contracts overrunning the program schedule contemplated at the time of negotiation. In most instances, the time element is beyond the control of the consultant. To provide for the contingency of overrun of time, the agreement between the Sponsor and the consultant should state the period for which the compensation applies and that the consultant must be reimbursed for services in excess of the specified period of time at a mutually acceptable fee negotiated at the time all the pertinent circumstances are known. The cost of additional consultant technical inspection services that would result from contractor caused construction delays should be included in the liquidated damages established for construction contracts.
3.6 Ownership of Drawings and Contract Documents.
3.6.1 Original documents, such as tracings, plans, specifications, maps, basic survey notes and sketches, charts, computations, and other data prepared or obtained under the terms of the contract, are instruments of service and remain the property of the consultant unless otherwise agreed to by both parties. Reproducible copies of drawings and copies of other pertinent data should be made available to the Sponsor upon request. Electronic copies containing all drawings should be furnished to the Sponsor. Terms and conditions for Sponsor’s reuse of documents/data on other projects should be addressed in the contract.
3.6.2 When a contract is only for preliminary plans, no commitment that would constitute a limitation on the subsequent use of the preliminary plans or ideas incorporated therein
3.8 FAA Contract Review. › 3.8.1 FAA Airports field office personnel are available to assist the…
should be stated or implied. The owner shall hold harmless the consultant against claims arising out of any reuse of the preliminary plans.
3.7 Contract Checklist. The following checklist identifies important items and provisions to be considered in preparing any contract for consultant services. It is not all-inclusive because each contract will vary based on the unique requirements of the project scope of services.
1. Effective date of contract.
2. Names and descriptions of the parties to the agreement with their addresses and, in the case of a corporate body, the legal description of the corporation.
3. Nature, extent, and character of the project, the location thereof, and the time limitations.
4. Services, including performance and delivery schedules, to be rendered by the consultant.
5. Delineation of responsibilities of the consultant, the Sponsor, and other consultants and parties involved in the performance of the project, particularly key personnel such as the project manager.
6. Delineation of the duties and responsibilities of the resident engineer/inspector.
7. Inclusion of mandatory contract provisions identified in paragraph 3.4.
8. Provision for renegotiation of the contract on the basis of change in the scope of the project, changes in conditions, additional work, etc.
9. Provision that reproducible copies of planning and design drawings and specifications be made available to the Sponsor upon request.
10. Compensation, including methods of payment and payment schedules, for services to be rendered by consultants.
11. Provision for the termination of the consultant services before completion of work.
12. Provision for preparation of a Quality Control Plan as required by the special provisions of the grant agreement.
13. Provision for preparation of an Engineer's Design Report and Final Report.
3.8 FAA Contract Review.
3.8.1 FAA Airports field office personnel are available to assist the Sponsor and provide guidance on:
1. The scope of services to be provided;
2. The appropriate type of contract;
3. The mandatory contract provisions to be included; and
4. Sponsor certification requirements.
Chapter 3. Contract Format and Provisions › 3.9 FAA Contract Approval.
5. For EIS contracts please refer to Section 2.10.
3.8.2 If deemed necessary by the FAA, a draft of the contract will be submitted to ensure that:
1. The scope of the engineering is described completely;
2. The fees and reimbursements are reasonable and eligible as shown by a cost/price analysis;
3. The type of contract is appropriate; and
4. The engineering/consulting firm and the proposed contract terms are acceptable.
3.8.3 The FAA may elect to conduct a pre-award review of proposed contracts under certain circumstances. Additional guidance is available in Order 5100.38, Section 10.
3.9 FAA Contract Approval. FAA Airports offices are authorized to accept certifications from Sponsors that they will comply with statutory and administrative requirements. Use of Sponsor certifications for selection of engineering, architectural, professional services, and planning consultants is encouraged. Acceptance by the FAA of the Sponsor’s certification does not limit the FAA’s ability to request and review documentation to ensure the accuracy of the certification. Reference Order 5100.38, Chapter 5, Subsection 5-23(g), Sponsor Certification Forms, “Selection of Consultants;” and 49 USC 47105 (d).
Page Intentionally Blank
4.2 Direct Personal Services. › 4.2.5 On occasion, the urgency of the engagement requires the…
CHAPTER 4. METHODS OF CONTRACTING AND ALLOWABLE COSTS
4.1 General. The method of contracting selected for consultant services is dependent on the types of services required and specific circumstances relating to the individual project. The permissible types of contracts are established within 2 CFR part 200 and Appendix U of FAA Order 5100.38D .The various types of contracts and methods of compensation are discussed in this chapter and listed in Table 4-1. Contracts may be negotiated to include a combination of two or more of these methods.
4.1.1 The Sponsor must negotiate profit as a separate element of the price for each contract and supplemental agreement. When negotiating a fair and reasonable profit, the Sponsor shall give due consideration to the complexity of the work being performed; the risk borne by the firm; the firm’s investment; the amount of sub-consultants; the firm’s record of past performance; and industry profit rates in the surrounding geographical area for similar work.
4.2 Direct Personal Services.
4.2.1 Direct personal services are usually charged on a per diem basis. This method is particularly suited to court work or similar efforts involving intermittent personal service.
4.2.2 When such consulting or expert services are furnished, the consultant is compensated for the time devoted to the work and travel. The per diem charge should be based on the complexity of the work involved and the experience of the consultant. In addition to the compensation based on per diem, the consultant is reimbursed for travel and other out-of-pocket expenses incurred while away from the normal place of business provided they are reasonable, allocable, and of a generally allowable nature. Additionally, reimbursable expenses at the normal place of business may be reimbursed, such as special computer work, rendering, exhibits, provided they are reasonable, allocable, and of a generally allowable nature.
4.2.3 Each direct personal services contract must include a ceiling price that the contractor exceeds at their own risk. Furthermore, the Sponsor must assert oversight in order to obtain reasonable assurance that the contractor is using efficient methods and effective cost controls.
4.2.4 For services in court or on other engagements in which the consultant appears as an expert, a per diem charge is considered to be earned for each day of such appearance, although the consultant may not be called to testify or, if called, may finish his/her testimony in a fraction of a day.
4.2.5 On occasion, the urgency of the engagement requires the consultant to work longer than the normal day. In some instances, this requirement is a necessary feature of the services, and an understanding should be made with the Sponsor as to what constitutes a
4.2 Direct Personal Services. › 4.2.7 If public hearings are involved in the consultant services,…
day. In such cases, the per diem rate may be based on the normal number of working hours per day, or the per diem rate may be increased to take into consideration the extended work day.
4.2.6 For certain kinds of work, compensation based on hourly rates is an equitable arrangement. Compensation for consultant service on an hourly basis demands a higher rate per hour than would be represented in a per diem rate. Also, the hourly rates should apply to time for travel involved, plus reimbursement for travel costs, subsistence, and other out-of-pocket expenses. Depending on the duration of the services, compensation on an hourly basis may include an agreement on a preset minimum amount or retainer in addition to the payments based on the hourly rates.
4.2.7 If public hearings are involved in the consultant services, determination of the fee could present a problem since extensive hearings and follow-up work may be required. In these instances, the per diem approach may be considered as an appropriate method of payment for services rendered subsequent to the initial hearing. An estimated upper limit should be set forth in the contract. The contract should provide for renegotiation of the upper limit if unforeseeable conditions are encountered.
4.3 Retainer. › 4.3.2 The retainer fee varies with the character and value of the…
Table 4-1. Contracting Methods and Allowable Costs
Contracting
Method Compensation Allowable Cost
§4-2. Direct Personal Services
Per Diem. Hourly Rate (§4-2.6).
Costs must be allowable, reasonable, and allocable to the project. Costs must be consistent with 2 CFR 200.459, FAA Order 5100.38 and 48 CFR Part 31.
§4-3. Retainer
Fixed sum. Paid monthly. Some other mutually
agreeable basis.
§4-4. Cost-Plus-a-
Fixed-Fee (NTE) Fixed sum.
§4-5. Fixed Lump-
Sum Payment Fixed sum.
§4-6. Cost-Plus-a- Percentage-of-Cost Prohibited method. Prohibited.
§4-7. Specific Rates
of Compensation Hourly Rate
Costs must be allowable, reasonable, and allocable to the project. Costs must be consistent with 2 CFR 200 .459, FAA Order 5100.38 and 48 CFR Part 31.
§4-8. Phasing of
Work
May include two or more of the above methods of compensation.
Costs must be allowable, reasonable, and allocable to the project. Costs must be consistent with 2 CFR 200.459, FAA Order 5100.38 and CFR Part 31.
Note: See Paragraph 4.10 for non-allowable costs for all types of service.
See Appendix G for Alternative Project Delivery Systems.
4.3 Retainer.
4.3.1 The engagement of consultants on a retainer basis is a common practice. This practice assures the Sponsor of always having the services of a certain individual engineer or organization available for future work. This method is used in cases of protracted litigation or for work over the years when the services of the consultant may be intermittent. It is also used in the development of undertakings for which the services of a consultant specialist are not required on a full-time basis. On large projects, this method enables the Sponsor to have the specialists who prepared the original plans and specifications on hand for maintenance or additions.
4.3.2 The retainer fee varies with the character and value of the services to the Sponsor and with the reputation and standing of the consultant in his/her profession.
4.4 Cost-Plus-a-Fixed-Fee (Not to Exceed (NTE)). › 2. The estimate must detail the direct labor costs by categories of…
4.3.3 The terms of agreement for services on a retainer basis vary widely. Compensation may be based on a fixed sum, paid monthly, or on some other mutually agreeable basis, with per diem or hourly rates in addition to time spent at the request of the Sponsor. In any case, the same principles, explained previously for per diem or hourly charges, govern under retainer contracts.
4.3.4 This type of contract is rarely used for grant projects. However, it is permissible to use a firm on retainer for projects without further procurement action if:
1. The retainer contract was awarded as a result of competition.
2. The parties competing for the retainer were advised that subsequent grant funded projects (including the scope of work for those projects) would be performed under the retainer contract.
3. The price for the work performed under the grant will be fair and reasonable and supported by a price or cost analysis.
4.3.5 Detailed records should be kept to identify the work that is part of a Federal grant project and eligible for reimbursement.
4.4 Cost-Plus-a-Fixed-Fee (Not to Exceed (NTE)).
4.4.1 The cost-plus-a-fixed-fee contract is appropriate when the Sponsor and consultant cannot fully define the scope, complexity, character or duration of effort at the time negotiations take place. This method places a risk on the Sponsor. Because the consultant’s fee is fixed, there is an added incentive for the consultant to control cost.
1. Sponsors should consider using the cost-plus-fixed fee contract type for construction phase services. These services are generally dependent upon the construction contractor’s performance. For this reason, the necessary level of effort for the consultant’s services cannot always be fully established at the time of contract negotiation.
4.4.2 If the design services have a high level of variability of effort (e.g., evaluation of design alternatives), the use of a cost-plus-fixed-fee method may be justified. The fixed lump sum is the more appropriate contract method when the level of effort can be fully defined at the time of contract negotiations.
4.4.3 This type of contract provides for reimbursement of allowable costs such as salary, overhead, and direct non-salary expenses, plus a fixed fee.
1. A copy of the detailed fee estimate (see sample in Appendix D) must accompany the fee proposal.
2. The estimate must detail the direct labor costs by categories of employees, work hours, and hourly rate; overhead; direct non-salary expenses; and the fixed fee.
4.4 Cost-Plus-a-Fixed-Fee (Not to Exceed (NTE)). › 4.4.7 Additional Costs
4.4.4 Fixed Fee: The fixed-fee is a dollar value the Sponsor negotiates with the consultant at inception of the contract. It is in addition to reimbursement for salary, overhead, and direct non-salary expenses.
1. The fixed fee represents an amount for profit, willingness to serve, and assumption of responsibility and risk. The fixed fee does not vary with actual costs.
2. The Sponsor and consultant may apply customary industry practices to negotiate a fair and reasonable value for the fixed fee. However, the resulting agreement must convey the fixed fee as a dollar value. The cost-plus-percentage of cost payment method prohibits the use of a percentage payment for the contract fee.
3. The fixed fee value may not be modified unless there is a change in the scope of the work. This includes both additions and subtractions to the scope of service.
4.4.5 The establishment of a not-to-exceed contract value is a Sponsor cost control measure that provides a ceiling level for the overall contract. The Sponsor should consider the risk to the consultant when establishing this upper limit.
4.4.6 Agreements with a cost-plus-a-fixed-fee payment method must contain provisions that provide for renegotiation of both the contract upper limit and the fixed fee. Sponsor
1. The agreement should include a requirement for the consultant to alert the Sponsor when the consultant’s cumulative costs approach the upper limit.
2. The Sponsor and consultant should assess whether the remaining work effort can be completed within the remaining contract limits.
3. The consultant must obtain Sponsor approval before exceeding the upper limit.
4.4.7 Additional Costs: An increase in costs over the original contract value can occur for several reasons. These include, but are not limited to:
1. Poor performance of construction contractor may result in additional inspection and oversight effort.
2. Ineffective control of costs by the consultant resulting in an over-run of expenses.
3. Poor estimate of the necessary level of effort at inception of contract.
4. Increase in construction contract time due to weather events that exceed the norm for the location.
5. Added scope of work or services.
If the additional costs are due to a construction contractor’s failure to perform per the terms of the contract, the Sponsor may address the additional costs to the consultant by applying liquidated damages on the construction contractor to the extent that liquidated damages have been included in the contract with the contractor.
4.5.2 The fixed lump-sum contract method places most of the risk upon… › 3. The estimate must detail the direct labor costs by categories of…
If the additional costs are due to the consultant’s failure to effectively control their costs per the agreement, the original fixed fee and not-to-exceed contract value become the final contract costs the Sponsor is obligated to pay.
If the additional costs are due to reasons outside the control of both the Sponsor and the consultant, the Sponsor and consultant should enter into negotiations to address the anticipated additional costs. This negotiation must occur prior to the consultant incurring the additional costs. The opportunity to negotiate does not necessarily mean that both the contract ceiling value and the fixed fee value require upward revision. The circumstances of the situation will dictate whether just the ceiling rate is revised or if the fixed-fee value requires revision as well. Due to the prohibition of the cost-pluspercentage of cost payment method, an increase in costs does not automatically equate to an increase in the fixed fee.
If the increased costs are due to additions to the contract scope of services, the Sponsor and consultant should enter into negotiations to determinate a fair and reasonable price for the additional level of effort.
4.4.8 Overhead charges will vary according to the nature, type, diversity, size of firm, and number/amount of contracts currently held by the firm. Such charges are defined by multiplying the approved certified overhead rate by the direct labor costs. Refer to section 4.10 for additional guidance on the allowability of overhead costs.
4.5 Fixed Lump-Sum Payment.
4.5.1 The fixed lump-sum payment contract is appropriate when the Sponsor and consultant can fully define the scope, complexity, character and duration of effort at the time negotiations take place.
1. Sponsors should consider using the fixed lump sum contract type for design services when the necessary level of effort for the consultant’s services can be clearly established at the time of contract negotiation.
4.5.2 The fixed lump-sum contract method places most of the risk upon the consultant. Most consultants will address this risk in their profit markup. Once the fixed lump sum contract is established, the consultant has incentive to control their costs to maximize their actual margin.
1. The fixed amount of compensation is determined by estimating the allowable costs such as salary, overhead, and direct non-salary expenses, plus a reasonable margin of profit.
2. A copy of the consultant's detailed fee estimate must accompany a consultant’s lump-sum fee proposal during the negotiation phase.
3. The estimate must detail the direct labor costs by categories of employees, work hours, and hourly rate; overhead; direct non-salary expenses; and profit..
4.7 Specific Rates of Compensation (Not to Exceed (NTE)). › 4.7.1 The "specific rates of compensation" contracting method should…
4.5.3 The final agreement may express all these costs as a single lump sum for the entire project or as individual lump sum elements per the various tasks (e.g. Preliminary design, final design, bidding, etc.).
4.5.4 Non-salary direct expenses may be included in the lump sum value only if it is certain that such costs will be incurred on the project. If there is uncertainty that non-salary direct expenses will be necessary for the project, such costs should not be a part of a lump sum payment item. Instead, these costs should be handled as pass through cost with a not-to-exceed ceiling.
4.5.5 Where consultation is undertaken on a lump-sum basis, the agreement must contain a clearly stated time limit during which the services will be performed. In design contracts, there should be a provision for changes required after the approval of preliminary designs with a clear understanding as to where the final approval authority lies.
4.5.6 Lump-sum contracts must contain a clause that provides for renegotiation if the scope of work described in the contract has changed.
4.5.7 Overhead charges will vary according to the nature, type, diversity, size of firm, and number/amount of contracts currently held by the firm. Refer to section 4.10 for additional guidance on the allowability of overhead costs.
4.6 Cost-Plus-a-Percentage-of-Cost. In accordance with 2 CFR §200.323, cost-plus-a-percentage-of-cost (CPPC) methods of contracting are prohibited for consultant services under airport grant programs. CPPC contracts may be defined as a payment formula based on a fixed predetermined percentage rate of actual performance costs by which the sum of the consultant's entitlement, uncertain at the time of agreement, increases commensurately with increased performance costs. The types of contracts discussed below are based on the CPPC methods of contracting and, therefore, are prohibited:
1. Salary Cost Times a Percentage Multiplier, Plus Direct Non-salary Expense. This type of contract contains CPPC methods of contracting because the consultant's indirect cost and profit are not fixed at the time the contract is signed.
2. Percentage of Construction Costs. This type of contract contains CPPC methods of contracting since a portion of the consultant's fee that does not reflect actual costs constitutes a profit that is not fixed at the time the contract is executed.
4.7 Specific Rates of Compensation (Not to Exceed (NTE)).
4.7.1 The "specific rates of compensation" contracting method should only be used when it is not possible at the time of procurement to estimate the extent or duration of the work or to estimate costs with any reasonable degree of accuracy. Sponsor must get advanced approval from the FAA for all work conducted under this method.
Chapter 4. Methods of Contracting and Allowable Costs › 4.9 Phasing of Work.
4.7.2 The "specific rates of compensation" contracting method provides for reimbursement for consultant services on the basis of direct labor hours at specified fixed hourly rates (including direct labor costs, indirect costs, and fee (profit)) plus any other direct expenses/costs, subject to an agreed maximum amount.
4.7.3 While the inclusion of fee (profit) in the loaded hourly rate(s) established for a contract allows the fee earned to be based on the labor hours worked on the project, this is not considered a "cost plus a percentage of cost" contracting method. A key distinction for the "specific rates of compensation" contracting method is that indirect costs and fee must be recovered as a component of the established, fixed hourly billing rates for labor hours worked. The negotiated rate is typically fixed for the life of the project, however, the Sponsor must reserve the right (by contract) to audit and adjust multiplier rates.
4.7.4 Use of this contracting method requires close monitoring to ensure efficient methods and cost controls are employed by the consultant.
4.8 Sponsor Force Account Projects. Per FAA Order 5100.38, proposals to accomplish airport engineering with the Sponsor’s own personnel or by its agent must be approved by the FAA. Proposals must be submitted in writing and subjected to a review similar to that for engineering contracts. The Sponsor’s proposal to use force account rather than contract-engineering services must be fully documented and should contain as a minimum:
1. Justification for doing the work by force account rather than by contract;
2. Estimate of costs, including detailed data on estimated work hours, hourly rates, non-salary expenses, and indirect costs;
3. Names and engineering qualifications of personnel that will be accomplishing specific tasks;
4. Statements concerning the capability of the Sponsor to perform the various tasks of design, supervision, inspections, testing, etc., as applicable to the project with arguments to support the decision to use force account;
5. Summary of Sponsor’s experience with airport engineering pertaining to projects with similar design scopes; and
6. Statement by the Sponsor on the ability of its personnel to integrate the project into their workload, with a schedule of accomplishment of tasks, date by which the work will be completed, or dates within which it will take place.
4.9 Phasing of Work. Design projects may be negotiated to be performed in phases and include two or more of the foregoing methods of compensation. For example, the first phase of a project might cover the development of the precise scope of work for a project and be paid for under a cost-plus-fixed-payment contract. The follow-on work could then be negotiated
Chapter 4. Methods of Contracting and Allowable Costs › 4.10 Allowable Costs.
on the basis of information developed in the first phase and might be accomplished under a lump-sum contract.
4.10 Allowable Costs. Costs incurred must be consistent with the Federal cost principles contained in 48 CFR part 31, 2 CFR §200 Subpart E, and FAA Order 5100.38 to be reimbursable under an airport planning or development grant. The following are typical expenses allowable under the above regulations:
1. Direct Salary Costs.
a. Direct salary costs include the cost of salaries of engineers, planners, computer aided design and drafting (CADD) technicians, surveyors, stenographers, administrative support etc., for time directly chargeable to the project.
b. Salaries or imputed salaries of partners or principals, to the extent that they
perform technical or advisory services directly applicable to the project, are to be added to salary cost.
2. Overhead Costs. Overhead costs include overhead on direct salary costs and general and administrative overhead. 48 CFR Part 31establishes the allowability of indirect costs. Consultants must be capable of validating their applied overhead rates by providing the Sponsor a copy of their audit certification that conforms to acceptable industry audit standards such as the Government Auditing Standards (GAGAS) or the Generally Accepted Auditing Standards (GAAS). Unless explicitly requested, the FAA does not require a copy of this audit certification. The Sponsor should retain a copy of this certification for purpose of future independent audit.
a. Duplication of costs: Consultants must avoid claiming similar costs both as direct and indirect.
b. Field Rates: Consultants often have tasks that require employment of field
personnel for extended periods. The application of a home rate to field personnel direct labor hours may result in indirect costs that are in excess of the benefit realized by the field personnel. If field personnel are not receiving the day-to-day benefit of the home rate, it may be appropriate and necessary for the consultant to establish a field office indirect rate. Such rates are generally lower than the home rate due to the omission of costs that do not benefit the field personnel.
3. Direct Non-salary Expenses. Direct non-salary expenses usually incurred may include the following (detailed records must be kept to support charges and allow auditing):
a. Living and traveling expenses of employees, partners, and principals when away from the home office on business connected with the project. (Records must include employee name, dates, points of travel, mileage rate, lodging, and meals.)
Chapter 4. Methods of Contracting and Allowable Costs › 4.12 Pass-Through Costs
b. Identifiable communication expenses such as long-distance telephone,
telegraph, cable, express charges, and postage, other than for general correspondence.
c. Services directly applicable to the work such as special legal and accounting expenses, computer rental and programming costs, special consultants, borings, laboratory charges, commercial printing and bindings, and similar costs not applicable to general overhead.
d. Identifiable computer and office supplies and stenographic supplies and
expenses charged to the Sponsor's work as distinguished from such supplies and expenses that are applicable to two or more projects.
e. Identifiable reproduction costs applicable to the work.
f. Advertising costs that are solely for the recruitment of personnel required for the performance by the consultant of obligations arising under the contract.
g. Sub-consultant and outside services including administrative costs associated
with managing said services
4.11 Non-Allowable Costs. Costs incurred must be consistent with the Federal cost principles contained in 48 CFR part 31, 2 CFR §200 Subpart E, and FAA Order 5100.38 to be reimbursable under an airport planning or development grant.
4.12 Pass-Through Costs Consultant markup of pass-through costs is a cost element that is subject to Sponsor negotiation. The determination on whether a markup of non-salary expenses is appropriate relies on the benefit and value the consultant adds to the pass through expense.
Mark up of expenses for which the consultant’s effort adds negligible or no value are not reasonable. Such expenses should pass through to the Sponsor without any markup by the consultant (See Section 14 of FAA Order 5100.38 for Cost Reasonableness). Examples of this include travel expenses, supplies, mailing costs, per diem expenses, etc.
A consultant’s effort in managing sub-consultants represents expenses that may add value to the contract performance. The extent of this benefit may vary based on factors including but not limited to task complexity, assumption of liability, task duration, schedule issues, and risk management. The value and benefit of consultant effort may vary per sub-consultant.
Sponsors must be careful in how they address consultant markup on pass-through expenses in their contracts. Sponsors must avoid situations where the agreement addresses the markup by simply applying a percentage markup on any pass-through costs. This is due to the regulatory prohibition on cost-plus-percentage of costs payment methods found in 2 CFR 200 Subpart D.
Generally, the consultant’s administration expenses associated with sub-consultant management should be addressed as direct labor hours in the consultant fee derivation. Other sub-consultant management expenses must be addressed as a dollar value, as opposed to an applied percentage. The consultant’s fee estimate must identify the markup value for other subconsultant management expenses within the non-salary expense section. Sponsors and consultants must also avoid situations where costs for managing sub-consultant agreements are duplicated within the agreement.
Page Intentionally Blank
Appendix A. Definitions
9/25/2015 AC 150/5100-14E Change 1 Appendix A
APPENDIX A. DEFINITIONS
Some common terms used in this AC are defined below. Additional definitions of terms and phrases are available in Order 5100.38, Airport Improvement Program Handbook, current version.
1. Architectural/Engineering (A/E) Services. The term “architectural and engineering services” means:
a. Professional services of an architectural or engineering nature, as defined by State law, if applicable, which are required to be performed or approved by a person licensed, registered, or certified to provide such services as described in this paragraph;
b. Professional services of an architectural or engineering nature performed by contract that are associated with research, planning, development, design, construction, alteration, or repair of real property; and
c. Such other professional services of an architectural or engineering nature, or incidental services, which members of the architectural and engineering professions (and individuals in their employ) may logically or justifiably perform, including studies, investigations, surveying and mapping, tests, evaluations, consultations, comprehensive planning, program management, conceptual designs, plans and specifications, value engineering, construction phase services, soil engineering, drawing reviews, preparation of operating and maintenance manuals, land acquisition services and other related services.
2. Consultant. A firm, individual, partnership, corporation, or joint venture that performs architectural, engineering or planning services as defined in paragraphs 1 and 4, employed to undertake work funded under an FAA airport grant assistance program.
3. Fee. Compensation paid to the consultant for professional services rendered.
4. Planning Services. Professional services of a planning firm include: airport master and system plan studies, airport noise compatibility plans (14 CFR part 150 studies), and environmental assessments and related studies.
5. Primary Engineer or Principal Consultant. A firm that is held responsible for the overall performance of the service, including that which is accomplished by others under separate or special service contracts.
6. Sponsor. A public agency or private Sponsor of a public-use airport that submits to the Secretary an application for financial assistance for the airport (49 USC § 47102(19)).
7. Bridging Documents. Preliminary engineering documents intended to define a scope of work for a subsequent design and construction efforts. These documents are typically prepared by a professional services firm who is not eligible to participate in further procurements on the project.
9/25/2015 AC 150/5100-14E Change 1 Appendix A
Page Intentionally Blank
Appendix B. Bibliography › B.2 Code of Federal Regulations.
9/25/2015 AC 150/5100-14E Change 1 Appendix B
APPENDIX B. BIBLIOGRAPHY
This bibliography covers Public Law, FAA Orders, Advisory Circulars (ACs), and Code of Federal Regulations (CFRs) referenced within this AC.
B.1 Public Law.
1. Brooks Act: Federal Government Selection of Architects and Engineers. Public Law 92-582, 92nd Congress, H.R. 12807, October 27, 1972. (See http://www.usa.gov/.)
2. United States Code. Title 40 Subtitle I, Chapter 11 Selection of Architects and Engineers. (See http://uscode.house.gov.)
3. United States Code. Title 42 Chapter 55 USC 4321 National Environmental Act of 1969. (See http://uscode.house.gov.)
4. United States Code. Title 49 Subtitle VII, Aviation Programs, USC §47123 Nondiscrimination. (See http://uscode.house.gov.)
5. United States Code. Title 49 Subtitle VII, Aviation Programs, §47107(a) (17), Project Grant Application Approval Conditioned on Assurances About Airport Operations. (See http://uscode.house.gov.)
6. United States Code. Title 49 Subtitle VII, Chapter 471 USC §47102 Definitions. (See http://uscode.house.gov.)
7. United States Code. Title 49 Subtitle VII, Chapter 471 USC §47105 Project Grant Applications. (See http://uscode.house.gov.)
B.2 Code of Federal Regulations. Access the Code of Federal Regulations online at http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/browse/collectionUScode.action?collectionCode=USCODE.
1. Airport Noise Compatibility Planning. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 14 CFR part 150.
2. Contract Cost Principles and Procedures. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 48 CFR part 31.
3. Labor Standards Provisions Applicable to Contracts Covering Federally Financed and Assisted Construction. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 29 CFR part 5.
4. New Restrictions on Lobbying. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 49 CFR part 20.
5. Nondiscrimination in Federally-Assisted Programs of the Department of Transportation–Effectuation of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 49 CFR part 21.
Appendix B. Bibliography › B.3 FAA Orders and Advisory Circulars. Please refer to current versions.
9/25/2015 AC 150/5100-14E Change 1 Appendix B
6. Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs, Equal Employment Opportunity, Department of Labor. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 41 CFR part 60.
7. Participation by Disadvantaged Business Enterprises (DBE) in Department of Transportation Financial Assistance Programs. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 49 CFR part 26.
8. Uniform Administrative Requirements for Grants and Cooperative Agreements to State and Local Governments. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 2 CFR part 200.
B.3 FAA Orders and Advisory Circulars. Please refer to current versions.
1. U.S. Department of Transportation. Federal Aviation Administration. Order 1050.1, Environmental Impacts: Policies and Procedures. (See http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/orders_notices/.)
2. U.S. Department of Transportation. Federal Aviation Administration. Order 5050.4, Airport Environmental Handbook. (See http://www.faa.gov/airports/resources/publications/orders/.)
3. U.S. Department of Transportation. Federal Aviation Administration. Order 5100.38, Airport Improvement Program Handbook. (See http://www.faa.gov/airports/resources/publications/orders/.)
4. U.S. Department of Transportation. Federal Aviation Administration. Advisory Circular 150/5300-15, Use of Value Engineering for Engineering and Design of Airport Grant Projects. (See http://www.faa.gov/airports/resources/advisory_circulars/.)
Appendix C. Scope of Services Samples › C.2 Example 1. Design Services Scope.
APPENDIX C. SCOPE OF SERVICES SAMPLES
C.1 This appendix contains three different examples of Scope of Services. Example 1 is a Design Services scope, Example 2 is a Planning Services scope, and Example 3 is a Construction Services scope. Samples may not necessarily include all provisions and terms required by this AC. If a conflict exists between these examples and the AC, the AC will prevail.
C.2 Example 1. Design Services Scope.
TAXIWAY A SOUTH AND HOLDING APRON RECONSTRUCTION AND NEW HARDSTAND
ABC INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
The consultant will provide the required professional services to design the reconstruction of Taxiway A South and holding apron and the proposed hardstand (attach a drawing or exhibit if necessary). This work will be performed and constructed under a Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Airport Improvement Program (AIP) grant to the airport.
Taxiway A South will be constructed in Portland Cement concrete and will be widened to 100 feet and have new 40-feet-wide asphalt shoulders added. The South Holding Apron will be reconstructed to essentially the same configuration as presently exists. Centerline taxiway lighting will be added to the taxiway and through the holding apron to Runway 18L/36R. Control panels in the FAA tower and field lighting electrical vault will also be modified for the new centerline lighting.
The new hardstand will be located north of the Airlift Airlines Maintenance Facility (currently under construction) south of the northeast Cargo Taxilane and west of the flying Bears hardstand. The hardstand will be a Portland Cement concrete apron with lighting similar to other hardstands, drainage to the Industrial Waste Sewerage System (IWS), and other utilities including fire protection. No downstream IWS changes are anticipated. It is anticipated that utilities are immediately available for fire protection adjacent to hardstand.
Professional services to be provided by the consultant will include civil, electrical and structural, and geotechnical engineering services required to accomplish the following items:
PHASE 1 - PRELIMINARY DESIGN
The preliminary design phase is intended to identify and evaluate alternatives to assure cost effective and practical solutions for the work items identified. The consultant will complete its evaluation of alternatives through contacts with local authorities and review of the preapplication, field investigations, and a practical design approach. The design will take advantage of local knowledge and experience and utilize expertise from recent construction projects to design a cost-effective project and ensure competitive construction bids. Activities include:
1. Coordinate with airport operations, FAA tower, and the airlines to minimize impacts in dayto-day operations of the airlines and air cargo lines. Also coordinate with facilities and
maintenance and fire department. (This will require four coordination meetings throughout the design.)
2. Prepare a preliminary estimate of probable construction costs and schematic design for each element of the project.
3. Provide all geotechnical investigation and analysis and pavement and other nondestructive testing and analysis required for the design.
4. Coordinate with the airport's project manager for required survey information.
5. Prepare an overall construction phasing plan in order to maximize project constructability and minimize interference with airport operations. The consultant’s phasing plan must take into account other airport construction projects.
6. Determine aircraft usage through coordination with Airport staff and information furnished by the Sponsor. Design the pavements to meet the anticipated aircraft traffic.
PHASE 2 - ENGINEERING PHASE ACTIVITIES
1. Evaluate local conditions.
a. Evaluate local material suppliers, sources, and capabilities.
b. Evaluate drainage alternatives.
c. Review electrical lighting layouts and determine system relocation capacities.
2. Review and evaluate project layout.
a. Verify master plan dimensions and data.
b. Review findings and recommendations with airport personnel.
3. Complete a soils investigation, soils report, and recommendations including:
a. Field Exploration.
i. Conduct test pit explorations with a rubber-tired backhoe at various locations to a maximum depth of 8 feet in the runway, taxiway, and apron areas. Log and field classify soils and obtain samples for laboratory testing.
b. Laboratory Testing.
i. Perform laboratory index and strength tests as follows:
(1) Compacted CBR test (3 compaction points/test).
(2) Standard Proctor (4 point) compaction tests.
(3) Atterberg limit determinations.
(4) Sieve analysis.
(5) Unit weight and water content determinations.
(6) FAA soil classifications for all samples.
4. Complete necessary topography and site surveying, including establishment of project control points.
5. Complete pavement section alternatives analysis and provide recommendations including:
a. Conduct an initial cost analysis, life-cycle cost analysis, and analysis of locally available resources for up to three alternatives.
b. Strategize bidding procedures and pavement section alternatives to provide a basis for competitive bidding.
6. Complete preliminary plan and profile design for the runway, taxiway, and apron area.
7. Complete preliminary runway lighting, signing, and system circuitry layout.
8. Provide recommendations for construction phasing to the Sponsor for their review.
9. Complete estimates of probable construction costs for the recommended alternatives.
10. Provide five sets of review documents.
11. Complete the preliminary design report including:
a. Geotechnical investigation.
b. Topographical survey.
c. Preliminary plans.
d. Pavement section design and analysis.
e. Drainage design analysis.
f. Estimates of probable construction costs.
g. Final summary and recommendations.
h. Phasing and scheduling recommendations.
12. Solicit comments on preliminary design from airport personnel and the FAA.
PHASE 3 - FINAL DESIGN
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 208 passages shown