Radar Vectors
Advisory Circular Cancelled Issued Sep 30, 2005 AAS-100 86 pages Copy saved Nov 18, 2026

AC 150/5100-14D Architectural, Engineering, and Planning Consultant Services for Airport Grant Projects

Provides guidance for airport sponsors in the selection and employment of architectural, engineering, and planning consultants under Federal Aviation Administration airport grant programs.

This document is cancelled. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.

Official source ↗ Open PDF

U.S. Department of Transportation

Federal Aviation Administration

Advisory Circular

Subject: ARCHITECTURAL, ENGINEERING, AND PLANNING CONSULTANT SERVICES FOR AIRPORT GRANT PROJECTS

Date: 30 September 2005 Initiated by: AAS-100

AC No.: 150/5100-14D Change:

1. PURPOSE. This advisory circular (AC) provi des guidance for airport sponsors in the selection and engagem ent of architectur al, engineering, and planning consultants. It also discusses services that normally would be included in an airport grant project, types of contracts for these services, contract form at and pr ovisions, and guidelines for determ ining the reasonableness of consultant fees. 2. CANCELLATION. AC 150/5100-14C, Architectural, Engineering, and Planning Consultant Services for Airport Grant Projects, dated 2/16/94, is canceled. 3. APPLICATION. Airport sponsors must use qualifications based selection procedures in the selection and engagem ent of consultants in the sam e m anner as Federal contracts for architectural and engineering services negotiated under Title IX of the Federal Property and Administration Services Act of 1949, or equi valent State/sponsor qualifications based requirements. The guidelines contained in th is AC are recom mended by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) to comply with Title 49 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) § 18.36 when selecting consultants for airport projects funded under Federal grant programs. This AC does not apply to airport projects that are fully funded with passenger facility charge (PFC) funds. 4. PRINCIPAL CHANGES.

Subject: ARCHITECTURAL, ENGINEERING, AND PLANNING CONSULTANT SERVICES FOR AIRPORT GRANT PROJECTS

a. Clarified Broad Form Indemnification. Added a statement addressing the consequences

of expanding consultant liability beyond the scope or purpose of a contract.

b. Expanded selection criteria and the m ethod of evaluating potential consultants. Added

flowcharts.

c. Expanded Contractor Contractual Require ments section. Added new table sum marizing

Methods of Contracting and Allowable Costs.

d. Increased the limit for use of informal procedures from $25,000 to $100,000.

e. Clarified Independent Fee Estimates. Added methods of determining fair and reasonable

consultant fees to the Fee Estimate section.

f. Expanded discussion of analyzing fee estimates

g. Added Alternative Delivery Methods.

h. Updated contract provisions consistent with current laws and regulations.

i. Reorganized and expanded appendices to include referenced documents, definitions, and

scope of services and record of negotiation examples.

David L. Bennett Director of Airport Safety and Standards

ii

TABLE OF CONTENTS

TABLE OF CONTENTS

CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION … 1

1-1. OVERVIEW … 1 1-2. DEFINITIONS … 1 1-3. REFERENCED DOCUMENTS … 1 1-4. TYPES OF CONSULTANT SERVICES … 1 1-5. SPECIAL SERVICES … 3

CHAPTER 2. PROCEDURES FOR SELECTION OF CONSULTANTS … 5

2-1. GENERAL … 5 2-2. OBJECTIVE … 5 2-3. QUALIFICATIONS BASED SELECTION PROCEDURES … 6 2-4. OTHER SERVICES … 7 2-5. SELECTING ORGANIZATION … 7 2-6. POLICY FOR SELECTION … 8 2-7. SELECTION CRITERIA … 8 2-8. SELECTION PROCEDURES … 9 2-9. ALTERNATE SELECTION PROCEDURES … 13 2-10. SELECTION PROCEDURES FOR ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT (EIS) PREPARATION … 14 2-11. SCOPE OF SERVICES … 15 2-12. FEE ESTIMATE … 16 2-13. NEGOTIATIONS … 17 2-14. SPONSOR FORCE ACCOUNT PROJECTS … 18

CHAPTER 3. CONTRACT FORMAT AND PROVISIONS … 21

CHAPTER 3. CONTRACT FORMAT AND PROVISIONS … 21

3-1. GENERAL … 21 3-2. CONTRACT FORMAT … 21 3-3. DIVISION OF RESPONSIBILITY AND AUTHORITY … 21 3-4. MANDATORY CONTRACT PROVISIONS … 22 3-5. TIME OVERRUNS BEYOND CONTROL OF THE CONSULTANT … 22 3-6. OWNERSHIP OF DRAWINGS AND CONTRACT DOCUMENTS … 23 3-7. CONTRACT CHECKLIST … 23 3-8. FAA CONTRACT REVIEW … 24 3-9. FAA CONTRACT APPROVAL … 24

CHAPTER 4. METHODS OF CONTRACTING AND ALLOWABLE COSTS … 25

CHAPTER 4. METHODS OF CONTRACTING AND ALLOWABLE COSTS … 25

4-1. GENERAL … 25 4-2. DIRECT PERSONAL SERVICES … 25 4-3. RETAINER … 27 4-4. COST-PLUS-A-FIXED-FEE (Not To Exceed (NTE)) … 27 4-5. FIXED LUMP-SUM PAYMENT … 28 4-6. COST-PLUS-A-PE RCENTAGE-OF-COST … 29 4-7. PHASING OF WORK … 29 4-8. ALTERNATIVE DELIVERY METHODS … 29 4-9. ALLOWABLE COSTS … 31

iii

4-10. NON-AL LOWABLE COSTS … 33 4-11. FIXED FEE … 33

4-10. NON-AL LOWABLE COSTS … 33 4-11. FIXED FEE … 33

APPENDIX A. DEFINITIONS … 35

APPENDIX B. BIBLIOGRAPHY … 37

APPENDIX C. SOURCES OF CONSULTANTS … 41

APPENDIX D. FAA AND STATE AGENCY ADDRESSES … 43

APPENDIX E. SCOPE OF SERVICES SAMPLES … 51

EXAMPLE 1. DESIGN SERVICES SCOPE … 51 EXAMPLE 2. PLANNING SERVICES SCOPE … 57 EXAMPLE 3. CONSTRUCTION SERVICES SCOPE … 64

APPENDIX F. CONSULTANT SERVICES FEE/COSTS SAMPLE … 77

APPENDIX F. CONSULTANT SERVICES FEE/COSTS SAMPLE … 77

APPENDIX G. DETAILED FEE/COST ANALYSIS SAMPLE … 79

APPENDIX H. RECORD OF NEGOTIATIONS SAMPLE … 81

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 2-1. Qualifications Based Selection Process … 6 Figure 2-2. Consultant Selection Process … 10

LIST OF TABLES

Figure 2-1: picture of page 4Figure 2-1 · page 4
Picture of the page from the copy saved here

LIST OF TABLES

Table 3-1. Mandatory Federal Contract Provisions for Professional Services (A/E) Contracts ..22 Table 4-1. Methods of Contracting and Allowable Costs … 26

iv

CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION

1-1. OVERVIEW. This advisory circular (AC) provides guidance for airport sponsors in the selection and engagem ent of architectural, engi neering, and planning consultants. This AC discusses services that normally would be included in an airport grant project, types of contracts for these services, contract form at, and guide lines for determ ining the reasonableness of consultant fees.

CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION

1-2. DEFINITIONS. Definitions of the terms used in this AC are listed in Appendix A.

1-3. REFERENCED DOCUMENTS. Docum ents and regulations referenced and cited throughout this circular are listed in Appendix B.

1-4. TYPES OF CONSULTANT SERVICES. There are two separate and distinct categories of consultant services that are utilized for projects conducted under airport grant programs. The first category involves planning services. The second involves Architectural/ Engineering (A/E) services for the design and construction adm inistration/inspection of airport projects. These two categories of consultant services are discussed below.

a. Aviation planning services . This category includes studies under the broad headings of

airport system and m aster planning, airport noise com patibility planning and environmental assessments and related studies. These studies include, but are not limited to, the following activities:

1. Design study to establish the framework and detailed work program.

2. Airport data collection and facility inventories.

3. Aeronautical activity forecasts and demand/capacity analyses.

4. Facility requirements determination.

5. Airfield modeling for capacity and delay.

6. Airport layout and terminal area plan development.

7. Airport noise studies under 14 CFR parts 150 and 161.

8. Compatible land-use planning in the vicinity of airports.

9. Airport site selection studies.

10. Airport development schedules and cost estimates.

11. Airport financial planning and benefit cost analysis.

12. Participation in public inform ation a nd com munity involvem ent program s and/or public hearings relating to airport development and planning projects.

13. Environmental assessments (EA), environm ental impact statements (EIS), and other studies in accordance with FAA Orders 5050.4 and 1050.1.

14. Airspace analysis.

b. Architectural/engineering services for airport developm ent projects. This category includes the basic A/E services norm ally required for airport developm ent projects. It involves services generally of an architectural, civil, geotechnical, structural, mechanical, and electrical engineering nature. In additi on, there may be some services outside those normally considered basic that are discussed in paragraph 1-5. The basic services are usually conducted in, but are not lim ited to, the four distinct and sequential phases summarized below:

1. Preliminary Phase. This phase involve s those activities required for defining the scope of a project and establishing prelim inary requirem ents. Som e exam ples of activities within this phase of a project include, but are not limited to:

(a) Conferring with the sponsor on project requirements, finances, schedules, early phases of the project, and other pertinent matters and meeting with FAA and other concerned agencies and parties on matters affecting the project.

(b) Planning, procuring, and/or prepar ing necessary surveys, geotechnical engineering investigations, field investig ations, and architectural and engineering studies required for preliminary design considerations.

(c) Developing design schem atics, sketches, environm ental and aesthetic considerations, project recom mendations, and prelim inary layouts and cost estimates.

2. Design Phase. This phase includes all activities required to undertake and accomplish a full and com plete project design. Exam ples include, but are not lim ited to, those below:

(a) Conducting and attending meetings and design conferences to obtain inform ation

and to coordinate or resolve design matters.

(b) Collecting engineering data and undert aking field investigations; perform ing geotechnical engineering studies; and pe rforming architectural, engineering, and special environmental studies.

(c) Preparing necessary engineering reports and recommendations.

(d) Preparing detailed plans, specifications , cost estim ates, and design/construction

schedules.

(e) Preparing construction safety plans.

(f) Printing and providing necessary copies of engineering drawings and contract specifications.

3. Bidding and Negotiation Phase. These activities are sometimes considered part of the construction phase. They involve assisti ng the sponsor in advertising and securing bids, negotiating for services, analyzing bid results, furnishing recom mendations on the award of contracts, and preparing contract documents.

4. Construction Phase. This phase includes all basic services rendered after the award of a construction contract, including, but not limited to, the following activities:

(a) Providing consultation and advice to the sponsor during all phases of

construction.

(b) Representing the sponsor at preconstruction conferences.

(c) Inspecting work in progress periodically and providing appropriate reports to the

sponsor.

(d) Reviewing and approving shop and erec tion drawings subm itted by contractors

for compliance with design concept/drawings.

(e) Reviewing, analyzing, and approving laboratory and mill test reports of materials

and equipment.

(f) Preparing and negotiating change orders and supplemental agreements.

(g) Observing or reviewing performance tests required by specifications.

(h) Determining am ounts owed to contractors and assisting sponsors in the

preparation of payment requests for amounts reimbursable from grant projects.

(i) Making final inspections and submitting punch-lists and a report of the completed

project to the sponsor.

(j) Reviewing operations and maintenance manuals.

1-5. SPECIAL SERVICES. The development of som e projects m ay involve activities or studies outside the scope of th e basic design services routinely perform ed by the consultant. These special services m ay vary greatly in scope, complexity, and tim ing and m ay involve a number of different disciplines and fields of expertise.

Consultants performing special services m ay be employed directly by the sponsor to im plement one or more phases of a project or may be employed by the principal consultant via a subcontract agreement. In certain instances, these services may be perform ed by the principal consultant. Some examples of special services that m ight be employed for airport projects include, but are not limited to, the following:

a. Soil investigations, including core sam pling, laboratory tests, related analyses, and reports.

b. Detailed mill, shop, and/or laboratory inspections of materials and equipment.

c. Land surveys and topographic maps.

d. Field and/or construction surveys.

e. Photogram metry surveys.

f. Onsite construction inspection and/or m anagement involving the services of a full-tim e

resident engineer(s), inspector(s), or m anager(s) during the construction or installation phase of a project. This differs from the periodic inspection responsibilities included as part of the basic services.

g. Special environmental studies and analyses.

h. Expert witness testimony in litigation involving specific projects.

i. Project feasibility studies.

j. Public information and community involvement surveys, studies, and activities.

k. Preparation of record drawings.

l. Assisting the sponsor in the preparation of necessary applications for local, State, and Federal grants.

m. Preparation of or updating of the airport layout plan.

n. Preparation of property maps.

o. Construction management.

p. Preparation of quality control plan.

q. Preparation of final report.

CHAPTER 2. PROCEDURES FOR SELECTION OF CONSULTANTS

CHAPTER 2. PROCEDURES FOR SELECTION OF CONSULTANTS

2-1. GENERAL. The procedures included in this ch apter provide guidance for sponsors in the selection and engagem ent of architectur al, engineering, environm ental, and planning consultants on projects funded wholly or in part under Federal airport grant program s. Adherence to these procedures will assure a s ponsor of compliance with the requirem ents of 49 CFR 18 § 18.36 and 49 USC § 47107(a) 17, as amended.

a. 49 CFR § 18.36(t) requires that grantees and subgrantees extend the use of qualifications

based (e.g., architectural, environm ental, pl anning, and engineering services) contract selection procedures to certain other related areas and award such contracts in the sam e manner as Federal contracts for architectural and engineering services are negotiated under Title IX of the Federal Property a nd Adm inistrative Services Act of 1949, or equivalent State or sponsor qualifications based requirements. b. 49 USC § 47107(a) 17 states: “E ach contract and subcontract for program management,

construction m anagement, planning studies, f easibility studies, architectural services, preliminary engineering, design engineeri ng, surveying, m apping, and related services will be awarded in the same way that a contract for architectural and engineering services is negotiated under Chapter 11 of Title 40 or an equivalent qualifications based requirement prescribed for or by the sponsor.” In addition to the services described in this statute, the professional and incident al services listed under A/E Services in Appendix A, must also be procured using qualifications based procedures.

If a conflict exists between 49 CFR § 18.36 and 49 USC § 47107(a) 17, the statute will prevail. c. Title IX of the Federal Property and Adm inistrative Services Act of 1949 requires that

qualifications based selection procedures be used for the selection of firm s to perform architectural and engineering services. Qua lifications based procedures require that a contract for A/E services be awarded pursuan t to a fair and open selection process based on the qualifications of the firm s. The fees for such services are established following selection of a firm through a negotiation process to determine a fair and reasonable price.

2-2. OBJECTIVE.

a. The selection of consultants must be made on the basis of fair negotiations and equitable

fees and through selection procedures that are professionally acceptable, ensure maximum open and free com petition, and avoid any suggestion of unfair or unethical conduct. b. Consultants employed for work on projects involving airport grants m ust be responsible

and possess the ability to perform successfu lly under the term s and conditions of the proposed procurement. Consideration should be given to such matters as integrity, record of past perform ance, extent of experience with the type of services required by the sponsor, technical resources, and accessibility to other necessary resources.

2-3. QUALIFICATIONS BASED SELECTION PROCEDURES. Consultants m ust be engaged on the basis of their qualifications a nd experience, with fees determ ined through negotiations following selection. This can be accomplished by m eans of qualifications based selection procedures, whereby Statements of Qualifications (SOQ) are requested from a number of consultants. The qualifications of consulta nts responding are evaluated and the best qualified consultant is selected, subject to a mutual understanding of the scope of services and negotiation of a fair and reasonable fee. Figure 2-1 is an overview of the recommended Qualifications Based Consultant Selection process.

Does the selection satisfy the needs, objectives and

goals?

Determine the Scope of

Services

§ 2-5.b Sponsor establishes a Selection

Board

§ 2-6. Determine the

Selection Policy

§ 2-7. Develop Selection

Criteria and Weights

§ 2-8.c Develop a Request for Qualifications

§ 2-8 Selection

Procedures

§ 2-13.d Award Consultant

Contract

No

Yes

Go to Figure 2-2

Figure 2-1. Qualifications Based Selection Process

2-4. OTHER SERVICES.

a. Where services are to be perform ed in conjunction with the architectural, planning, environmental, or engineering services, they must be contracted for in the course of procuring the A/E services.

b. Where services such as f easibility st udies, construction m anagement, program management and other services as defined in 49 USC § 47107(a) 17 and A/E services as defined in Appendix A are to be perform ed, but are not included in the basic A/E services, they must be procured using qualifications based procedures.

c. Where services are to be perform ed that are not in conjunction with A/E services and do

not require perform ance by a licensed archit ect or engineer, the services should be acquired using local procurement procedures. An example of this type of special service would be soil borings, whereby the boring layout plan and interpretations of tests are not performed by the boring contractor. Soil bor ings conducted as part of a geotechnical engineering investigation or for which an independent engineer is responsible m ust be procured either in the course of procuring A/E services or by using qualifications based procedures.

d. Where services are to be perform ed in assisting the FAA in preparing an Environm ental

Impact Statem ent (EIS), they m ust be pr ocured using qualifications based selection procedures (see paragraph 2-10).

2-5. SELECTING ORGANIZATION.

a. Within the sponsor' s organization, an adm inistrative policy should be established for

designating persons authorized to select or recom mend consultants for various assignments. The persons designated m ay include the adm inistrator or the departm ent head to be supplemented by others making up a selection board. The persons empowered to make the selection of one consultant over another must be kept free of pressures, both internal and external. Section 18.36(b)3 requires that sponsors maintain a written code of standards of conduct governing the performance of their employees engaged in the award and administration of contracts. They must not participate in selection or in the award or administration of a contract supported by Federa l funds if a conflict of interest, real or apparent, would be involved. b. The typical procedure for selecting a consultant is to use a selection board composed of at

least three persons, with at least one bei ng an engineer, airport planner, or other professional knowledgeable of the service required. For projects that have special design requirements or are particularly com plex, the selection board should have additional technical m embers with the appropriate expe rtise in those required disciplines. The board should be prepared to evaluate potentia l consultants, i.e., conduct interviews and inquiries as desired and m ake recommendations. Based upon the recom mendations of the board, the adm inistrator or the govern ing body m akes the final selection of the consultant(s).

2-6. POLICY FOR SELECTION. The selection of a consu ltant m ust be based on a comparative analysis of the professional qualifications necessary for satisfactory perform ance of the service required. Moreover, the selection process must satisfy requirements for open and free competition. Sponsors may procure a consultant for severa l grant projects through one procurem ent action provided the following conditions are met (FAA Order 5100.38, Chapter 9):

a. The consultant is selected using the qualifications based selection procedures described in

paragraph 2-8. b. The parties com peting for the work m ust be advised that the work is expected to be

accomplished during the course of several gr ant projects. The expected schedule of projects must be defined, together with the Scope of Work and the required services. The scope of work should be described in sufficien t detail so that all parties are adequately informed of the items to be accomplished. c. All parties are advised that some of the services may not be required and that the sponsor

reserves the right to initiate additional pr ocurement action f or any of the services included in the initial procurement. d. The services are lim ited to those projects that can reasonably be expected to be initiated

within five (5) years of the date the contract is signed by the consultant.

e. The negotiation of the fee is limited to the services expected to be perform ed under the

initial grant (f irst grant negotiated during the contract period). The contract m ust be limited to the services covered by the negotia ted fee. The negotiation of the fee for subsequent services, i.e., services included in the procurement action but not in the initial contract, m ust occur at the tim e those serv ices are needed. A fee estim ate m ust be performed for each of these negotiations. (See paragraph 2-12 for inform ation on fee estimate.) If a fee cannot be agreed upon between the sponsor and the selected firm, then negotiations are term inated with that f irm. However, rather than entering negotiations with the firm ranked next in place at the time the initial contract was negotiated, a new procurement action must be initiated (Order 5100.38, Chapter 9). Unless there is a convincing reason to com bine eligible and ineligible work in a single solicitation, sponsors should be discouraged from doing so (Order 5100.38, Chapter 9). 2-7. SELECTION CRITERIA. Based on the proposed scope of service(s) and prior to evaluating consultants, a sponsor(s) m ust develop an agreed-upon list of selection criteria to be used in evaluating potential consultants. Numerical rating factors (ranges) should be assigned to each criterion on the basis of the sponsor' s priorities and conception of the im portance of each factor in the attainment of a successful project. The sponsor(s) should include the criteria with a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) in advance of the selection process. Based on a sponsor’s goals/objectives for each project, the list of selection criteria will vary for

each RFQ and m ust be appropriate for the propos ed scope of services. Suggested selection criteria include, but are not limited to, the following:

a. Capability to perform all or m ost aspects of the project and recent experience in airport

projects comparable to the proposed task.

b. Key personnel’s professional qualifications and experience and availability for the proposed project; their reputation and profe ssional integrity and com petence; and their knowledge of FAA regulations, policies, and procedures.

c. Current workload and demonstrated ability to meet schedules or deadlines.

d. Quality of projects previously undertaken and capability to com plete projects without having major cost escalations or overruns.

e. Qualifications and experience of outside c onsultants regularly engaged by the consultant

under consideration.

f. Capability of a branch office that will do the work to perform independently of the home

office, or conversely, its capability to obtai n necessary support from the hom e office. The use of geographic location may be a selection criteria provided its application leaves an appropriate num ber of qualified firm s, give n the nature and size of the project, to compete for the contract.

g. Ability to furnish qualified inspectors for construction inspection if applicable.

h. Demonstrated understanding of the project’s potential problems and the sponsor’s special

concerns.

i. Degree of interest shown in undertaking the project and their fam iliarity with and proximity to the geographic location of the project.

j. Capability to incorporate and blend aesthetic and architectural concepts with the project

design while accom plishing the basic require ments that transportation facilities be functional, safe, and efficient.

k. Evidence that the consultant has m ade good faith efforts in m eeting Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) goals (49 CFR, § 26.53).

l. Capability to conduct a Value Engineering (V E) study for projects that are particularly

complex or have unique features. Order 5100.38, Chapter 10, AC 150/5300-15, Use of Value Engineering for Engineering and Design of Airport Grant Projects, and AC 150/5370-10, Standards for Specifying Construction of Airports, contain additional guidance on VE studies.

2-8. SELECTION PROCEDURES. The sponsor m ust use the following selection procedures or equivalent State/sponsor qualifi cations based requirem ents for projects involving Federal airport grants (see Figures 2-1 and 2-2).

§ 2-8. Sponsor solicits interest

§ 2-8.c. Distribute the Request for

Qualifications (RFQ)

Notify unsuccessful

consultants

§ 2-7. Apply selection criteria

and weights Evaluate the pool of qualified consultants

§ 2-8.j. Issue request for proposal

General project proposal evaluation

Each firm submits a general project proposal

§ 2-8.c(7). Review experience

and qualification data § 2-8.c(6). Interview

§ 2-8.m. Initiate discussions with highest ranking

consultant to clarify the Scope of Services

§ 2-12.a. Perform independent fee analysis

Consultant submits cost

proposal and detailed

project proposal

§ 2-13. Conduct negotiations

Reject proposal

§ 2-13.d Award consultant contract

Does the proposal satisfy project needs, objectives

and goals?

No

Yes

§ 2-8.g. Preselection List (Short List) of Best Qualifed Consultants

Nonselected

§ 2-8.l. Rank qualified consultants

in order of preference

Return to Figure 2-1

Figure 2-2. Consultant Selection Process

a. The selection board should review the natu re of the proposed project and the general scope of services to be procured in orde r to ensure an understanding of the project requirements and the qualifications needed by the consultant.

b. As discussed in paragraph 2.7, the selection board must develop the selection criteria and

the evaluation system used in preparing a pr e-selection short-list of consultants who are best qualified for the project as well as in determining the final selection.

c. To obtain experience and qualification data from potentially qualified consultants, the

Figure 2-2: picture of page 14Figure 2-2 · page 14
Picture of the page from the copy saved here

sponsor should issue an RFQ inviting cons ultants to subm it their experience and qualifications data relating to the proposed project usually in the form of a Statem ent of Qualifications (SOQ). To ensure the broade st publicity concerning sponsor interest in obtaining consultant services, public announcements for all projects should be advertised in local newspapers with a wide circulation and national trade journals and m agazines. Public announcements should include inform ation such as a description of the proposed project and its location, a description of the services, and the estim ated range of construction costs. The public announcement should allow sufficient time for submission of the statement of qualifications.

d. Sponsors m ay also send the public announcem ents directly to known, potentially qualified consultants to determ ine their interest in the project and to request their experience and qualification data.

e. Affirmative steps pursuant to 49 CFR part 18 and good faith efforts should be taken to

assure that small and minority firms are used whenever possible, consistent with 49 CFR part 26. These steps and efforts should include, but not be limited to, the following:

1. Include qualified small business and minority firms on solicitation lists.

2. Assure that sm all business and m inority firm s are solicited whenever they are potential sources. Consultation with regiona l Airports Divisions , Office of Civil Rights, and/or State transportation offices is encouraged.

3. Divide the total requirements into small tasks, when economically feasible, to permit maximum small business and DBE firm participation.

4. Use the services and assistance of the Small Business Adm inistration, the Minority Business Development Agency of the Depa rtment of Com merce, and the Minority Resource Center Regional Centers of the Departm ent of Transportation (http://osdbu.dot.gov).

5. Arrange solicitations, tim e f or presentati on of offers and delivery schedules to facilitate DBE and other small business participation.

6. Encourage consultants to subcontract porti ons of the work, even when they m ight otherwise perform the work with their own forces.

f. There are many sources from which the names of consultants can be obtained. Appendix

C contains a partial list of potential sources of consultant firm s. FAA Airports field offices may also furnish the names of consultants who have engaged in projects of similar nature in their areas of jurisdiction. Ho wever, with the exception of an EIS, FAA personnel will not recom mend consultants or par ticipate in the selection process. The addresses of FAA Airports Regional/Distric t Offices having jurisdiction over specific geographic areas are available at http://www.faa.gov/airports/news_information/contact_info/regional/.

g. From the experience and qualification data obtained from consultants, the selection board

should prepare a pre-selection short-list of the best qualified consultants for further consideration. W ith adequate response to th e RFQ, the typical pre-selection short-list should consist of between three and five consultants.

h. At this point, consultants who expressed an interest in the project but were not included

on the pre-selection short-list should be notified that they were unsuccessful.

i. Detailed inform ation on the qualifications and perform ance data of each of the consultants on the pre-selection short-list s hould be obtained. This can be achieved by contacting former clients identified by the consultant in their statem ent of qualifications to ascertain the quality of work, ability to m eet schedules, cost control, and consultantclient relationship.

j. At this point, the selection board should obtain a general project proposal from each of

the firms on the pre-selection short-list, typically by issuing a Request for Proposal (RFP) to each consultant on the pre-selection shor t-list. The RFP should include a detailed description of the project and the proposed scope of services required. The selection criteria, including their relative im portance that will be used to evaluate the proposals must also be made available to each of the firms on the pre-selection short-list. The RFP may not contain a request for any cost information, such as total cost, cost per hour, work hours, or other pricing data. Requests for cost or pricing information, prior to discussions with the best qualified firm, to define the scope of services is contrary to 49 USC § 47107 (a) 17 and 49 CFR § 18.36(f). The general proj ect proposal will help the selection board recommend a consultant who can achieve design excellence, while successfully controlling tim e and costs and who has th e ability to understand and accom plish the specialized requirem ents of the project. Th e elem ents of a typical general project proposal should include, but are not limited to, the following:

1. Team members, other key personnel, previ ous experience, and th e role they will fill on the project. The qualifications and time com mitment of the project m anager proposed for the project.

2. Current workload.

3. Proposed project schedule, including major tasks and target completion dates.

4. Technical approach – a brief discussion of the tasks or steps that the consultant will take to accomplish the work described in the scope of services.

5. Value engineering – when a value engin eering study is included in the selection criteria, a brief discussion of the consulta nt’s capability, training, and experience to carry out such a study.

k. Conduct interviews with each consultant on the pre-selection short-list. On sm all projects, a telephone interview m ay be sufficien t. The selection board m ay also, at its discretion, bypass the interview process ranking the pre-selection short-listed consultants based on submitted material.

l. Review the experience and qualifications data, the general project proposal, the interview

results, and other relevant data. Using the selection criteria developed for the project; rank the qualified consultants in order of preference.

m. Initiate discussion with the f irst-ranked consultant to fully define the scope of work and

services to be provided (see paragraph 2-11) . After agreem ent on a detailed scope of services has been reached, the consultant should submit their cost proposals together with a detailed project proposal. Negotiations shoul d then be conducted to reach a fair and reasonable fee, subject to the procedures indicated in paragraph 2-12 and 2-13.

n. Prepare a report recom mending the consulta nt selected. The report should contain

sufficient detail to indicate the extent of the review and the considerations used for the recommendations. The report should be forwarded to the sponsor' s adm inistrator or governing body authorized to review the reco mmendations of the selection board. The recommendations of the selection board s hould normally be accepted unless the report does not adequately support the recom mendations. This will help to ensure com plete fairness and open com petition. If the reco mmendations are not accepted, the selection board should reconvene until acceptable recommendations have been agreed upon.

2-9. ALTERNATE SELECTION PROCEDURES.

a. Proposals Requested with Qualification Da ta. The selection procedure recom mended in

paragraph 2-8 should norm ally be followed in the procurement of consulting services. For small projects where the scope of work a nd services can be clearly defined or the sponsor anticipates receipt of less than four proposals, the sponsor m ay wish to solicit proposals at the time of advertising for experience and qualification data. In this case, the announcement must contain a detailed scope of services and indicate where the selection criteria can be obtained. The advertisement cannot request pricing information. b. Informal Procedures. Inform al Qualifications Based Selection procedures m ay be used

for A/E procurem ents estim ated to be less than $100,000. However, this does not preclude the sponsor from obtaining an inde pendent fee estim ate for A/E proposals less than $100,000 nor does it preclude the FAA from requiring independent cost estimates.

Under this procedure, a sponsor m ust call at least three firm s and discuss their qualifications to perform the work. Negotiati ons must then be conducted with the bestqualified firm to arrive at a fee. These negotiations m ay be conducted via telephone. Sponsors must consult with FAA Airport pers onnel before using inform al procedures to

assure that the circum stances justify their use. After selection, using this procedure, the sponsor must submit a statem ent to the FAA explaining the basis for the selection and method used to determine reasonableness of the fee. This may include:

1. Sponsor-prepared fee estimate. 2. Comparison with previous contracts of a similar nature. 3. Based on previous business experience.

c. Non-competitive Procedures. The FAA m ay authorize non-com petitive negotiation for

professional services if the cost of the contract is not expected to exceed $10,000 and the professional services are incidental to the gr ant project. When this procedure is used, the sponsor m ust subm it a statem ent to the F AA explaining the basis used to determ ine reasonableness of cost as discussed in 2-9b above. 2-10. SELECTION PROCEDURES FOR ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT (EIS) PREPARATION. The procurement of consultant services to assist the FAA in preparing an EIS is som ewhat unique because the regula tions implementing the National Environm ental Policy Act (NEPA) (42 USC § 4321 et seq.), require Federal agencies to prepare the EIS or select the contractor that prepares th e EIS (Orders 5050.4 and 1050.1 provide additional guidance). Selection of a consultant m ust, therefore, be m ade by the FAA from a short-list of qualified consultants subm itted by the sponsor. The sponsor and the FAA m ust follow the selection procedures recommended in paragraph 2-8 with the following exceptions:

a. The proposed scope of work is to be provided by the FAA.

b. The FAA must concur with the selection and evaluation criteria prepared by the sponsor. c. The FAA will be invited to participate with the sponsor in the interviews with consultants

on the pre-selection short-list. d. The sponsor may indicate to the FAA their ranking of the consultants on the pre-selection

short-list after the interview process has been concluded. The FAA, however, is under no obligation to make a selection based on this ranking. e. Using the previous sponsor/FAA agreed upon selection and evaluation criteria, the FAA

will independently evaluate and rank the cons ultants on the pre-selection short-list in order of preference, based on qualifications. f. The FAA m ust advise the sponsor of the FAA's ranking in order of preference, and the

sponsor must advise and initiate discussions with the consultant ranked first. g. The FAA's involvement in the negotiation of the project cost must be limited to making a

reasonableness determination once a satisfactory cost proposal has been reached between the sponsor and the consultant.

h. The FAA must prepare a selection report for its records.

2-11. SCOPE OF SERVICES.

a. An im portant step in the negotiation process is to reach a com plete and m utual understanding of the scope of services to be provided. The general scope of services developed during initiation of the procurem ent process is of necessity too broad to serve as the basis for a contractual agreem ent. A well-defined project description and scope of services should be developed between the s ponsor and first-ranked consultant prior to negotiating a project design fee. This m ay be accom plished in a scoping m eeting or separate investigation or study to clearly defi ne the extent of the project. The sponsor' s engineer or independent consultant (see pa ragraph 2-12c) should attend the m eeting so they will have a com plete understanding of th e scope of services prior to developing a detailed fee estimate. Such a meeting offers the opportunity for refinem ent, amendment, and complete definition of the services to be rendered. b. The scope of service(s) m ust be sufficiently detailed so that the consultant can m ake a

reasonable fee estim ate (see Appendix F). A lthough the scope of service(s) will vary from project to project (see sam ples in A ppendix E), the following item s are typical of those that should be considered in developing the scope of services:

1. List of meetings the consultant is expected to attend.

2. Design schedule.

3. Special services required.

4. Complexity of design.

5. Safety and operational considerations.

6. Environm ental considerations.

7. Survey and geotechnical testing requirements.

8. Inspection services during construction.

9. Quality control during construction.

10. Preparation of forms, letters, documents, and reports.

11. Airport Layout Plan updates.

12. Property map preparation.

13. Quality control during design.

14. Coordination with other consultants and agencies.

15. Deliverables.

16. Data and material furnished by the sponsor.

17. Testing and commissioning requirements.

18. City/county requirements.

19. Number of bid packages.

20. Complexity of construction phasing to minimize impacts on airport operations.

2-12. FEE ESTIMATE.

A sponsor m ust perform some form of fee analysis for every A/E contract (49 CFR § 18.36). The method and degree of analysis is dependent on the facts surrounding the contract. Sponsors have an obligation to obtain a fair and reasonabl e fee in all cases, and the FAA retains the right to disallow negotiated fees that are determined to be unreasonable.

a. In order to properly evaluate the consultant 's cost proposal, a sponsor having a staff with

experience in estim ating the professional se rvices and negotiating contracts for these services must develop its own fee estimate for the services, based on the scope of services agreed upon in paragraph 2-11.

b. Sponsors having no staff with this expertise or having minimal or no previous experience

may not be able to perform these services in-house. In these instances, if the sponsor has a consultant on retainer who has experience with the services involved and who is not being considered for the project, the sponsor may engage the consultant to develop the fee estimate. State aviation personnel who ha ve experience with the services involved may also be used.

c. Alternatively, an independent engineering, architecture, or planning firm may be retained

by the sponsor to aid in developing the sc ope of services and/or fee estim ate for professional services. A preliminary fee estimate should be made prior to advertising for an SOQ and experience and a detailed fee estim ate must be m ade after discussions to determine a detailed scope of service (see paragraph 2-11). The firm retained to make the detailed fee estim ate must not have been on the pre-selection short-list. The firm must have recent experience in airport work similar to that proposed and be familiar with FAA requirements and procedures. The sponsor s hould request evidence that the firm meets the above requirements.

d. The firm hired to perform any of these functions m ay be retained using inform al qualifications based procedures if the cost is under $100,000 (see paragraph 2-9b); however, that firm will not be eligible for consideration for work on the project.

e. The sponsor m ust have a detailed fee es timate to properly evaluate the cost of professional services. Appendices F and G present sam ple form ats for consultant

services fee/cost and detailed fee/cost anal ysis respectively, however any form at that meets this purpose is acceptable.

f. Prior to initiating further discussions with the first-ranked consultant, the sponsor m ust

sign and date the independent cost estimate and retain it for their records. When evaluating the reasonableness of a consulta nt’s fee proposal, a general review standard used within the FAA and industry is whether the total fee proposal, as well as individual tasks within the proposal, is within 10% of the inde pendent fee estim ate. In general, when the consultant’s fee proposal and the sponsor’s i ndependent fee estim ate are within 10% of each other, the fee can be determ ined to be reasona ble. When differences exceed 10%, however, the sponsor should review those areas with the consultant to determine if there is a misunderstanding of the scope of services or leve l of effort required and attem pt to resolve the differences. W hile this should not be construed as policy, the use of the 10% standard is one method to help identify areas of significant difference between the cons ultant’s fee proposal and the independent fee estimate.

Another source on estim ating consultant’s cost can be found in ASCE Manuals and Reports on Engineering Practice No. 45, “How to W ork Effectively with Consulting Engineers.” However, these graphs m ust be used with judgm ent and w ithin their stated lim itations. Other resources include project history files, previous contracts, etc.

2-13. NEGOTIATIONS.

a. After developing a detailed scope of serv ices and an independent fee estim ate, the sponsor m ust enter into negotiations with the consultant given first preference by the selection board. At this tim e the sponsor may elect to inform the other firms on the preselection shortlist that negotiations have been initiated with the f irst-ranked firm. If an independent firm has been retained by th e sponsor for the purpose of preparing an independent fee estimate, the firm may be consulted by the sponsor during negotiations, to clarify problem areas, but not to review the consultant’s fee proposal or attend any negotiating sessions.

b. Based on the scope of services agreed upon in paragraph 2-11, the sponsor m ust request

the consultant to submit the proposed fee and supporting cost breakdown. The consultant must prepare a detailed estim ate of the hour s and cost required for each of the m ajor tasks. In addition to charges for labor, the consultant should, if appropriate, indicate the costs for subcontractors, travel, living e xpenses, reproduction, and other out-of-pocket expenses expected to be incurred.

c. Negotiations should be based upon the data submitted by the consultant and an evaluation

of the specific work hours required for each task. The sponsor should subject the consultant's data to a technical/engineering analysis. Based on this analysis, the sponsor should identify differences in the work-hour estimates. Significant differences, either positive or negative, between the estim ate submitted by the consultant and the estim ate developed by the sponsor should be resolved, and revisions should be m ade to the work hours or scope of services as required. Th e fee should then be evaluated, taking into

consideration the experience level required by the engineer working on each task. A sample fee/cost analysis form is shown in Appendix G.

d. If a m utually satisfactory contract cannot be negotiated with the first-ranked consultant,

the negotiations must be terminated and the consultant notified. Negotiations m ust then be initiated with the consultant given sec ond preference by the selection board. This procedure must be continued with recom mended consultants in the sequence of ranking established by the selection board until a m utually satisf actory contract has been negotiated. Once negotiations have been term inated with a firm and begun with another, they cannot be reopened with the former firm.

e. A record of negotiations m ust be prepared by the sponsor and included in the contract

file. This record m ust contain sufficient de tail to reflect any changes in the scope of services controlling the establishm ent of the cost and other term s of the contract. An explanation m ust be provided for any signi ficant differences between the sponsor' s original estimate and the final fee agreed upon. The scope of services, draft contract, sponsor's independent fee estim ate, consulta nt’s fee proposal with any revisions, and detailed fee analysis must be attached to the report. A sample Record of Negotiations is contained in Appendix H.

f. Upon completion of successful negotiations, all consultants interviewed by the selection

board should be informed of the consultant selected for the project.

g. FAA personnel will not be present and will not participate in the negotiation process. The FAA's role is to make a judgment on the reasonableness of the compensation for the services to be furnished and to ensure that all services required for a particular project have been included in the proposal.

h. If requested by the FAA, the sponsor m ust subm it the record of negotiations and all attachments to the FAA for a reasonablen ess of cost determ ination (Order 5100.38, Chapter 9). 2-14. SPONSOR FORCE ACCOUNT PROJECTS. Proposals to accom plish airport engineering with the sponsor’s own personnel or by its agent m ust be approved by the FAA. Proposals must be submitted in writing and subjected to a review similar to that for engineering contracts. Most of the factors considered in the selection of a consultant would be applicable to approval of services to be done by force account . The sponsor’s proposal to use force account rather than contract-engineering services m ust be fully docum ented and should contain as a minimum:

a. Justification for doing the work by force account rather than by contract;

b. Estimate of costs, including detailed data on estim ated work hours, hourly rates, non-

salary expenses, and indirect costs;

c. Names and engineering qualifications of personnel that will be accom plishing specific

tasks;

d. Statements concerning the capability of the sponsor to perform the various tasks of design, supervision, inspections, testing, etc., as applicable to the project with argum ents to support the decision to use force account;

e. Summary of sponsor’s experience with air port engineering pertaining to projects with similar design scopes; and

f. Statement by the sponsor on the ability of its personnel to integrate the project into their

workload, with a schedule of accom plishment of tasks, date by which the work will be completed, or dates within which it will take place.

Intentionally left blank.

CHAPTER 3. CONTRACT FORMAT AND PROVISIONS

CHAPTER 3. CONTRACT FORMAT AND PROVISIONS

3-1. GENERAL.

a. The relationship of the consultant with the sponsor should be clearly defined by a written

agreement before com mencement of actual wo rk. All of the term s should be clearly defined in the agreem ent. It should state the parties to the contract and define the complete extent and character of the work to be perform ed as well as conditions relating to any tim e lim itations that m ay be involve d. The term s and paym ents for various services should be included. The scope of th e consultant effort should be described in complete detail to determine the sufficiency of the supervisory and inspection staff and to determine whether some services will need to be otherwise contracted for or be provided by the sponsor.

b. Consultant contracts usually cover highly tec hnical services. Therefore, to assure the soundness of a legal document, it is essential that someone who has thorough knowledge of the project prepare the sections describing services to be performed, sequence of work, information to be furnished by the sponsor, and terms of payment. 3-2. CONTRACT FORMAT. Many governm ent agencies, business firms, and engineering organizations have developed standardized form s for engineering and pl anning contracts. The American Council of Engineering Com panies, the National Society of Professional Engineers, and the Am erican Society of Civil Engineers have developed such standardized form s. Som e State aviation departments have developed standardized forms for engineering services provided in their own states. The American Institute of Architects has standardized forms for architectural contracts. It is often necessary to m odify these standard agreements to reflect the specific term s and conditions applicable to a particular project, as well as the mandatory contract provisions in paragraph 3-4.

3-3. DIVISION OF RESPONSIBILITY AND AUTHORITY.

a. It is common to have one firm provide the basic services and one or m ore firms provide

special services. In these cases, the firm providing the basic consultant services is considered the prim ary engineer or principal consultant as defined in Appendix A. As such, the principal consultant represents the sponsor in coordinating and overseeing the work of other engineering/consultant firm s and has the overall responsibility to coordinate the work and to review the wo rk products for general conform ance to the requirements of the sponsor. Therefore, it is extrem ely im portant that the contract documents clearly specify the division of re sponsibility and authority between all parties involved in carrying out elements of the project.

b. The contract between the sponsor and cons ultant is based on the scope of services established earlier in the process (see paragraph 2-11) and involves carrying out professional duties under the requirements of law. The contract must not attempt to make the consultant an indem nitor of the sponsor such as in the event of the sponsor' s negligence or the absence of any wrongdoing by the consultant. The consultant m ust

fully stand behind their services and indem nify the sponsor for dam ages and expenses caused by their own errors, omissions, and negligent or wrongful acts.

c. Expanding the consultant’s liability beyond the scope or purpose of a contract could

affect the com petitive process of contract award in a way that conf licts with the requirements of 49 CFR part 18 and may impact Federal eligibility. 3-4. MANDATORY CONTRACT PROVISIONS. Federal laws and regulations prescribe that certain provisions be included in federally funded contracts. For purposes of this section, the term "contract" includes subcontracts. The t ype of contract m ust be appropriate for the particular procurement.

The provisions that pertain to consultant contr acts, including the source of each requirem ent are listed in Table 3-1. Specific wording of Federa l contract provisions is available on the FAA website at http://www.faa.gov/airports/aip/procurement/.

Table 3-1. Mandatory Federal Contract Provisions for Professional Services (A/E)

Contracts

Provision Law/Statute Provisions for all A/E Contracts Civil Rights Act of 1964, Title VI - Contractor Contractual Requirements 49 CFR part 21 Airport and Airway Improvement Act of 1982, Section 520 49 USC § 47123 Disadvantaged Business Enterprise 49 CFR part 26 Lobbying and Influencing Federal Employees 49 CFR part 20 Access to Records and Reports 49 CFR § 18.36 Breach of Contract Terms 49 CFR § 18.36 Rights to Inventions 49 CFR § 18.36 Trade Restriction Clause 49 CFR part 30 Additional Provisions for A/E Contracts Exceeding $10,000 Termination of Contract 49 CFR § 18.36 Additional Provisions for A/E Contracts Exceeding $25,000 Certification Regarding Debarment, Suspension, Ineligibility and Voluntary Exclusion 49 CFR part 29 3-5. TIME OVERRUNS BEYOND CONTROL OF THE CONSULTANT. Frequently, the consultant is called upon to continue techni cal inspection services on construction contracts overrunning the program schedule contem plated at the time of negotiation. In m ost instances, the time element is beyond the control of the cons ultant. To provide for the contingency of overrun of time, the agreement between the sponsor and the consultant should state the period for which the compensation applies and that the consultant must be reimbursed for services in excess of the specified period of time at a mutually acceptable fee negotiated at the time all the pertinent circumstances are known. The cost of additional consultant technical inspection services that would result from contractor caused constructi on delays should be included in the liquidated damages established for construction contracts.

3-6. OWNERSHIP OF DRAWINGS AND CONTRACT DOCUMENTS.

a. Original documents, such as tracings, plans, specifications, maps, basic survey notes and

sketches, charts, computations, and other data prepared or obtained under the terms of the contract, are instrum ents of service and re main the property of the consultant unless otherwise agreed to by both parties. Reproducible copies of drawings and copies of other pertinent data should be m ade available to the sponsor upon request. Copies of disks containing all drawings should be furnished to the sponsor. Term s and conditions for sponsor’s reuse of documents/data on other projects should be addressed in the contract.

b. When a contract is only f or preliminary plans, no com mitment that would constitute a

limitation on the subsequent use of the prelim inary plans or ideas incorporated therein should be stated or implied. 3-7. CONTRACT CHECKLIST. The f ollowing checklist identif ies im portant item s and provisions to be considered in preparing any cont ract for consultant services. It is not allinclusive because each contract will vary based on the unique requirements of the project scope of services.

a. Effective date of contract. b. Names and descriptions of the parties to th e agreement with their addresses and, in the

case of a corporate body, the legal description of the corporation. c. Nature, extent, and character of the project, the location thereof, and the time limitations. d. Services, including performance and delivery schedules, to be rendered by the consultant. e. Delineation of responsibilities of the consu ltant, the sponsor, and other consultants and

parties involved in the perform ance of the project, particularly key personnel such as the project manager. f. Delineation of the duties and responsibilities of the resident engineer/inspector. g. Inclusion of mandatory contract provisions identified in paragraph 3-4. h. Provision for renegotiation of the contract on the basis of change in the scope of the project, changes in conditions, additional work, etc. i. Provision that reproducible copies of planning and design drawings and specifications be

made available to the sponsor upon request. j. Compensation, including methods of payment and payment schedules, for services to be

rendered by consultants. k. Provision for the termination of the consultant services before completion of work.

l. Provision for preparation of a Quality Cont rol Plan as required by the special provisions

of the grant agreement. m. Provision for preparation of an Engineer's Design Report and Final Report.

3-8. FAA CONTRACT REVIEW.

a. FAA Airports field office personnel are available to assist the sponsor and provide guidance on:

1. The scope of services to be provided;

2. The appropriate type of contract;

3. The mandatory contract provisions to be included; and

4. Sponsor certification requirements.

b. If deemed necessary by the FAA, a draft of the contract will be submitted to ensure that:

1. The scope of the engineering is described completely;

3. The mandatory contract provisions to be included; and

2. The fees and reim bursements are reasonable and eligible as shown by a cost/price analysis;

3. The type of contract is appropriate; and

4. The engineering/consulting firm and the proposed contract terms are acceptable.

c. Pre-award review of proposed contracts is required under certain circum stances. Additional guidance is available in Order 5100.38, Chapter 9.

3. The type of contract is appropriate; and

3-9. FAA CONTRACT APPROVAL.

FAA Airports offices are authorized to accept certif ications from sponsors that they will comply with statutory and adm inistrative requirements. Use of sponsor certifications for selection of engineering, architectural, professional services , and planning consultants is encouraged. Acceptance by the FAA of the sponsor’s certifica tion does not limit the FAA’s ability to request and review documentation to ensure the accuracy of the certification. Reference Order 5100.38, Chapter 10 and Appendix 5, Sponsor Certification Forms, “Selection of Consultants;” and 49 USC 47105 (d).

CHAPTER 4. METHODS OF CONTRACTING AND ALLOWABLE COSTS

CHAPTER 4. METHODS OF CONTRACTING AND ALLOWABLE COSTS

4-1. GENERAL. The method of contracting selected for consultant services is dependent on the types of services required and specific circum stances relating to the individual project. The various types of contracts and m ethods of compensation are discussed in this chapter and listed in Table 4-1. Contracts m ay be negotiated to include a com bination of two or m ore of these methods.

4-2. DIRECT PERSONAL SERVICES.

a. Direct personal services are usually char ged on a per diem basis. This m ethod is particularly suited to court work or similar efforts involving intermittent personal service.

b. When such consulting or expert services ar e furnished, the consultant is compensated for

the time devoted to the work and travel. The per diem charge should be based on the complexity of the work involved and the experi ence of the consultant. In addition to the compensation based on per diem, the consultant is reimbursed for travel and other out-ofpocket expenses incurred while away from the normal place of business provided they are reasonable, allocable, and of a generally allowable nature. Additionally, reimbursable expenses at the norm al place of business m ay be reimbursed, such as special com puter work, rendering, exhibits, provided they are reasonable, allocable, and of a generally allowable nature.

c. For services in court or on other engagem ents in which the consultant appears as an expert, a per diem charge is considered to be earned for each day of such appearance, although the consultant m ay not be called to testify or, if called, m ay finish his/her testimony in a fraction of a day.

d. On occasion, the urgency of the engagem ent requires the consultant to work longer than

the normal day. In some instances, this requirement is a necessary feature of the services, and an understanding should be m ade with the sponsor as to what constitutes a day. In such cases, the per diem rate may be based on the norm al number of working hours per day, or the per diem rate may be increased to take into consideration the extended work day.

e. For certain kinds of work, com pensation based on hourly rates is an equitable arrangement. Compensation for consultant service on an hourly basis dem ands a higher rate per hour than would be represented in a per diem rate. Also, the hourly rates should apply to tim e for travel involved, plus reim bursement for travel costs, subsistence, and other out-of-pocket expenses. Depending on th e duration of the services, com pensation on an hourly basis may include an agreement on a preset minimum amount or retainer in addition to the payments based on the hourly rates.

f. If public hearings are involved in the consu ltant services, determination of the fee could

present a problem since extensive hearings and follow-up work may be required. In these instances, the per diem approach may be considered as an appropriate method of payment for services rendered subsequent to the initial hearing. An estim ated upper limit should be set forth in the contract. The contract should provide for renegotiation of the upper limit if unforeseeable conditions are encountered.

Table 4-1. Methods of Contracting and Allowable Costs

Type of Service Compensation Allowable Cost

§4-2. Direct Personal

Services

ƒ Per Diem.

ƒ Hourly Rate (§4-2.e).

§4-3. Retainer

ƒ Fixed sum.

ƒ Paid monthly.

ƒ Some other mutually

agreeable basis.

§4-4. Cost-Plus-a-

Fixed-Fee (NTE) Fixed sum.

§4-5. Fixed Lump-Sum

Payment Fixed sum.

Costs must be allowable, reasonable, and allocable to the project. Costs must be consistent with 49 CFR § 18.36, FAA Order 5100.38 and OMB Circular A-87.

§4-6. Cost-Plus-a- Percentage-of-Cost Prohibited method. Prohibited.

§4-7. Phasing of Work

ƒ May include two or more

of the above methods of compensation.

§4-8. Alternative Delivery Methods

ƒ Construction Manager-

At-Risk.

ƒ Task Order

Contracting.

ƒ Design Build.

ƒ Negotiated ceiling

ƒ Annual ceiling w/

maximum/order

ƒ May include lump sum,

cost plus, cost w/ guaranteed maximum, etc.

Costs must be allowable, reasonable, and allocable to the project. Costs must be consistent with 49 CFR § 18.36, FAA Order 5100.38 and OMB Circular A-87.

NOTE: Non-allowable costs for all types of service:

a. Costs of amusement and social activities and incidental costs relating thereto such as meals, lodging, rentals,

transportation, and gratuities. b. Contributions and donations. c. Bad debts, including losses due to uncollectible customer's accounts and other claims, related collection costs,

and related legal costs, arising from other businesses of the consultant. d. Dividend provisions or payments and, in the case of sole proprietors and partners, distributions of profit. e. Interest on borrowed capital. f. Bonus payment for early completion of work.

4-3. RETAINER.

a. The engagement of consultants on a retainer basis is a com mon practice. This practice

assures the sponsor of always having the serv ices of a certain individual engineer or organization available for future work. This m ethod is used in cases of protracted litigation or f or work over the years when the services of the consultant m ay be intermittent. It is also used in the developm ent of undertakings for which the services of a consultant specialist are not required on a full-time basis. On large projects, this method enables the sponsor to have the specia lists who prepared the original plans and specifications on hand for maintenance or additions. b. The retainer fee varies with the character and value of the services to the sponsor and with the reputation and standing of the consultant in his/her profession. c. The terms of agreement for services on a re tainer basis vary widely. Com pensation may

be based on a fixed sum , paid monthly, or on some other mutually agreeable basis, with per diem or hourly rates in addition to tim e spent at the request of the sponsor. In any case, the sam e principles, explained previously for per diem or hourly charges, govern under retainer contracts. d. This type of contract is rarely used for gran t projects. However, it is permissible to use a

firm on retainer for projects without further procurement action if:

1. The retainer contract was awarded as a result of competition.

2. The parties com peting for the retainer we re advised that subsequent grant funded projects (including the scope of work for those projects) would be perform ed under the retainer contract.

3. The price for the work perform ed under th e grant will be fair and reasonable and supported by a price or cost analysis. e. Detailed records should be kept to identify the work that is part of a Federal grant project

and eligible for reimbursement.

4-4. COST-PLUS-A-FIXED-FEE (Not To Exceed (NTE)).

a. The cost-plus-a-fixed-fee contract is freque ntly used when the consultant is required to

start work before the cost and scope of the project can be accurately determ ined. It is recommended that services for the constructi on phase of a project be paid for under a cost-plus-a-fixed-fee type contract. b. This type of contract provides for reim bursement of allowable costs such as salary, overhead, and direct non-salary expenses, plus a fixed fee.

c. A cost-plus-a-fixed-fee proposal should be accom panied by the consultant' s estim ate. The estimate should detail the direct labor co sts by categories of employees, work hours, and hourly rate; overhead; direct non-salary expenses; and the fixed fee. d. The fee is fixed and does not vary no m atter what the costs turn out to be. In m ost instances, however, a ceiling is applied which establishes an upper limit on the allowable costs. In establishing the upper lim it, an allowance for contingencies should be included so that, as such contingencies are encountered, renegotiation of the upper limit will not be necessary. The intent of the upper lim it is to ensure that the allowable costs do not exceed an agreed-upon ceiling without prior approval of the sponsor. (If Federal participation is desired in the increased co st, the sponsor m ust obtain the prior approval of the FAA.) Such contracts should contain provisions that provide for renegotiation of both the upper lim it and the fixed fee if the scope of work described in the contract has changed. e. Any increase in costs should be fully justif ied by the consultant prior to approval by the

sponsor. As the consultant is approachi ng the upper lim it and it becom es apparent that the project cannot be com pleted within that limit, he should alert the sponsor. Approval must be obtained before the upper limit is exceeded. f. Overhead charges will vary according to th e nature, type, diversity, size of firm , and number/amount of contracts currently held by the firm . The consultant should be prepared to validate the overhead costs with a certified statem ent from the sponsor' s auditor, state's auditor, or consultant' s accountant. A firm can demonstrate that the nonallowable costs are not included in its ove rhead calculation rather than requiring a complete audit in advance of contracting. Otherwise, if the consulting firm has been audited by an agency of the Federal Govern ment within the previous 12 m onths, the overhead rate determined by this audit may be used. g. Fixed-fee is in addition to reim bursement for salary, overhead, and direct non-salary expenses. The consultant is paid a fixe d am ount for profit, willingness to serve, and assumption of responsibility. This m ay be an amount based on the estimated design cost of the project at the tim e the consultant is engaged and will vary with the scope of the services involved.

4-5. FIXED LUMP-SUM PAYMENT.

a. The fixed lum p-sum payment contract is nor mally used when the scope of work can be

clearly and fully defined at the time the agreement for services is prepared. b. The fixed amount of compensation is determined by estimating the allowable costs such

as salary, overhead, and direct non-salary expenses, plus a reasonable margin of profit all expressed as a single lum p sum . A lum p sum proposal m ust be accom panied by the consultant's estimate. The estim ate must detail the direct labor costs by categories of employees, work hours, and hourly rate; overhead; direct non-salary expenses; and profit.

c. Where consultation is undertaken on a lum p-sum basis, the agreem ent must contain a clearly stated time limit during which the services will be performed. In design contracts, there should be a provision for changes required after the approval of preliminary designs with a clear understanding as to where the final approval authority lies. d. Lump-sum contracts must contain a clause th at provides for renegotiation if the scope of

work described in the contract has changed. e. Overhead charges will vary according to the nature, type, diversity, size of firm , and number/amount of contracts currently held by the firm . Guidance is provided in paragraph 4-4f. 4-6. COST-PLUS-A-PERCENTAGE-OF-COST. Cost-plus-a-percentage-of-cost (CPPC) methods of contracting are prohibited for consu ltant services under airport grant program s. CPPC contracts may be defined as a payment formula based on a fixed predetermined percentage rate of actual performance costs by which the sum of the consultant's entitlement, uncertain at the time of agreem ent, increases com mensurately with increased perform ance costs. The types of contracts discussed below are ba sed on the CPPC m ethods of contracting and, therefore, are prohibited:

a. Salary Cost Tim es a Multiplier, Plus Direct Non-salary Expense. This type of contract

contains CPPC m ethods of contracting because the consultant' s indirect cost and profit are not fixed at the time the contract is signed. b. Percentage of Construction Costs. This t ype of contract contai ns CPPC m ethods of contracting since a portion of the consultant 's fee that does not reflect actual costs constitutes a profit that is not fixed at the time the contract is executed. 4-7. PHASING OF WORK. Design projects m ay be negotiated to be perform ed in phases and include two or more of the foregoing methods of compensation. For example, the first phase of a project m ight cover the deve lopment of the precise scope of work for a project and be paid for under a cost-plus-fixed-paym ent contract. The follow-on work could then be negotiated on the basis of inform ation developed in the first phase and m ight be accomplished under a lum psum contract. 4-8. ALTERNATIVE DELIVERY METHODS. There are three basic form s of alternative delivery methods (see FAA Order 5100.38, Chapter 9, Section 3, Alternative Delivery Methods):

a. Construction Manager-At-Risk (CM-A-R). The sponsor would engage a design firm for

the design of the project. At an early stage of design, a contract is let for the CM-A-R in which the contractor reviews designs as th ey evolve to provide expertise for the construction phase. The CM-A-R and the sponsor also negotiate a ceiling am ount for the construction beyond which the CM is “at risk.” b. Task Order Contracting. The sponsor woul d procure for an annual need and estim ate a

ceiling amount and m ost frequently a m aximum per order amount. The contract is also

procured on the basis of criteria such as standard fees or unit rates and provides the standard contract clauses.

c. Design Build. This is a m ethod of contracting in which two distinct phases of project

accomplishment, design phase and construction phase, are com bined into a seam less process perform ed by one contractor who re tains single-source responsibility for that entire process. Due to tim e savings in the contracting process as well as earlier commencement of construction, design build m ay provide cost savings. There are m any recognized forms of design build and the follo wing is a brief description. There m ay be hybrid types of design build that use variations of the basic philosophies.

1. Design build project delivery can be performed by a single company with both design and construction capability in-house or by a team of design firm s and contracting firms working under a single design build contract. The design build firm /team contracts to design and build the f acility and retains the risk f or overall project completion, budget, and schedule. There is no division of responsibility to the sponsor between the design organization and the construction organization.

2. Design build services can be perform ed under all of the contractual m ethods used for construction including lum p sum, cost plus (excluding cost-plus-percentage-of-costs which is unauthorized), cost with a guarant eed maximum, etc. Design fees can be included in the overall contract price or separated as a subset of the price.

3. Contracting for design build services can be done by either of two basic m ethods, Qualifications Based Selection or Competitive Proposal Selection.

(a) Qualifications based selection (QBS). In this m ethod, contracting for design-

build services is nearly identical to selection procedures com monly used for professional design services. The sponsor solicits proposals for the project, and design-build firm s and team s respond with qualification inform ation as prescribed in the solicitation. The spons or chooses a short list of the m ost qualified firm s/teams, and presentations/interviews are m ade by those firms/teams. The sponsor then selects the m ost qualified firm /team and negotiates a contract for professional services. The contract provides for subsequent establishment of a guaranteed m aximum price (or lum p sum, costplus fee or another approved form) and guaranteed completion date for the entire project at an agreed level of completion of the preliminary design work.

(b) Competitive Proposal Selection (CPS). The contracting process for design-build

services is accom plished in two steps. The sponsor first prepares a design criteria package for the project using inhouse staff or a retained design firm . Design-build firm s/teams respond to a solicitation, and are short-listed in the same process used for QBS. In the second step, a design criteria package is issued to the short-listed firm s/teams, who respond with separate technical and price proposals. Technical proposals ar e evaluated first, using a num erical “points earned” system . Then, pri ce proposals are opened and prices are factored into the “points earned” system to determ ine the final selection. A

common m ethod of “scoring” price inform ation is to divide the price by the technical points score and the resulting low score is selected.

(c) Under CPS, the sponsor m ust bear the cost of design criteria package preparation. Each short-listed design-bu ild firm /team m ust bear the cost of preparing a technical proposal with prelim inary drawings and outline specifications, along with a conceptual cost estimate to establish a price. To control this substantial cost, sponsors short-lists should not be longer than 3-4 firms/teams. Sponsors should also consider granting a stipend to each unsuccessful firm /team in return for the right to use any concepts from the unsuccessful firms/teams technical proposals for the project.

(d) Refer to FAA Order 5100.38, Chapter 9 for information on the limitations on the

approval of projects for design-build contracting

4-9. ALLOWABLE COSTS. Costs incurred m ust be consistent with the Federal cost principles contained in 48 CFR part 31, Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Circular A- 87, and FAA Order 5100.38 to be reim bursable under an airport planning or developm ent grant. The following are typical expenses allowable under the above regulations:

a. Direct Salary Costs.

1. Direct salary costs include the cost of sala ries of engineers, planners, computer aided design and drafting (CADD) technicians, su rveyors, stenographers, adm inistrative support etc., for time directly chargeable to the project.

2. Salaries or imputed salaries of partners or principals, to the extent that they perf orm technical or advisory services directly app licable to the project, are to be added to salary cost. b. Overhead Costs. Overhead costs include ove rhead on direct salary costs and general and

administrative overhead.

1. Labor Overhead. Overhead on direct sala ry costs includes sick leave, vacation, and holiday pay; unem ployment, excise and pa yroll taxes; contributions for social security, em ployment com pensation insurance, retirem ent benefits, and m edical insurance benefits; and any other benefits customarily paid to or available to all employees. The allowable percentage for labor overhead allocable to a project is the ratio of (a) a f irm's total direct labor overhead costs to (b) a f irm's total direct salary costs (excluding overtime) for a given period.

2. General and Administrative Overhead. General and administrative overhead includes the following indirect costs which are not directly attributable to specific projects:

(a) Provisions for office, light, heat, and sim ilar term s for working space, depreciation allowances or rental of furniture, com puter equipm ent and

engineering instruments, and office and computer/CADD supplies not identifiable to specific projects.

(b) Taxes and insurance other than those in cluded as salary cost, but excluding State

and Federal income taxes.

(c) Library and periodical expe nses and other m eans of keeping abreast of advances

in engineering such as attendance at technical and professional m eetings and subscriptions to trade, business, professional, or technical periodicals.

(d) Executive, administrative, accounting, legal, and adm inistrative support salaries

and expenses (other than identifiable salaries included in salary costs and expenses included in reim bursable non-salary expenses, plus salaries or im puted salaries of partners and principals) to the extent that they perform general executive and administrative services as di stinguished from technical or advisory services directly applicable to particular projects.

(e) Costs of m emberships in trade, business, technical, and professional organizations.

(f) Incentive com pensation for m anagement em ployees, cash bonuses except for

early com pletion of work, suggestion awards, safety awards, and incentive compensation based on production, cost re duction, or efficient perform ance are allowable to the extent that the overa ll com pensation is determ ined to be reasonable, and such costs are paid or accrued pursuant to an agreem ent entered into in good faith between the consultant and the em ployees before the services are rendered or pursuant to an established plan followed by the consultant so consistently as to im ply, in ef fect, an agreement to m ake such paym ent. The allowable percentage for general and adm inistrative overhead allocable to a project is the ratio of (a) all general a nd administrative costs to (b) total direct salary costs (excluding overtime) for a given period. c. Direct Non-salary Expenses. Direct non- salary expenses usually incurred m ay include

the following (detailed records must be kept to support charges and allow auditing):

1. Living and traveling expenses of employees, partners, and principals when away from the hom e office on business connected with the project. (Records m ust include employee name, dates, points of travel, mileage rate, lodging, and meals.)

2. Identifiable com munication expenses such as long-distance telephone, telegraph, cable, express charges, and postage, other than for general correspondence.

3. Services directly applicable to the work such as special legal and accounting expenses, com puter rental and program ming costs, special consultants, borings, laboratory charges, com mercial printing and bindings, and sim ilar costs not applicable to general overhead.

4. Identifiable com puter and office supplie s and stenographic supplies and expenses charged to the sponsor' s work as distinguish ed from such supplies and expenses that are applicable to two or more projects.

5. Identifiable reproduction costs applicable to the work.

6. Advertising costs that are solely for th e recruitm ent of personnel required for the performance by the consultant of obligations arising under the contract.

7. Sub-consultant and outside services. 4-10. NON-ALLOWABLE COSTS. The expenses listed below are not allowable for reimbursement under an airport grant:

a. Costs of am usement and social activities a nd incidental costs such as m eals, lodging, rentals, transportation, and gratuities.

b. Contributions and donations.

c. Bad debts, including losses due to uncoll ectible customer's accounts and other claim s, related collection costs, and related legal co sts, arising from other businesses of the consultant.

d. Dividend provisions or paym ents and, in the case of sole proprietors and partners,

distributions of profit.

e. Interest on borrowed capital.

f. Bonus payment for early completion of work. 4-11. FIXED FEE. To all the estimated costs, including overhead, a percentage rate is applied to determine payment for profit, willingness to serve, and assumption of responsibility.

Intentionally left blank.

APPENDIX A. DEFINITIONS

APPENDIX A. DEFINITIONS

Some common terms used in this AC are define d below. Additional definitions of term s and phrases are available in Order 5100.38.

a. Architectural/Engineering (A/E) Services. The term “architectural and engineering services” means:

1. Professional services of an architectural or engineering nature, as defined by State law, if applicable, which are required to be perform ed or approved by a person licensed, registered, or certified to provide such services as described in this paragraph;

2. Professional services of an architectural or engineering nature perform ed by contract that are associated with research, planning, developm ent, design, construction, alteration, or repair of real property; and

3. Such other professional services of an architectural or engineering nature, or incidental services, which m embers of the architectural and engineering professions (and individuals in their em ploy) m ay logi cally or justifiably perform , including studies, investigations, surveying and m apping, tests, evaluations, consultations, comprehensive planning, program m anagement, conceptual designs, plans and specifications, value engineering, construction phase services, soil engineering, drawing reviews, preparation of opera ting and m aintenance m anuals, and other related services.

b. Consultant. A firm , individual, partne rship, corporation, or joint venture that performs architectural, engineering or planning services as defined in paragraphs a and d, employed to undertake work funded under an FAA airport grant assistance program. c. Fee. Compensation paid to the consultant for professional services rendered.

d. Planning Services. Professional services of a planning firm include: airport master and

system plan studies, airport noise com patibility plans (14 CFR part 150 studies), and environmental assessments and related studies.

e. Primary Engineer or Principal Consultant. A firm that is held responsible for the overall

performance of the service, including th at which is accom plished by others under separate or special service contracts.

f. Sponsor. A public agency or private owner of a public-use airport that subm its to the Secretary an application for financial assistance for the airport (49 USC § 47102(19)).

Intentionally left blank.

APPENDIX B. BIBLIOGRAPHY

APPENDIX B. BIBLIOGRAPHY

This bibliography covers Public Law, FAA orde rs, Advisory Circulars (ACs), and Code of Federal Regulations (CFRs) referenced within this AC. PUBLIC LAW

a. Brooks Act: Federal Government Selection of Architects and Engineers. Public Law 92-

582, 92nd Congress, H.R. 12807, October 27, 1972.

(See http://www.firstgov.gov.)

b. United States Code. Title 40 Subtitle I, Chapter 11 Selection of Architects and Engineers.

(See http://uscode.house.gov or http://www.gpoaccess.gov/uscode.)

c. United States Code. Title 42 Chapter 55 USC 4321 National Environmental Act of 1969.

(See http://uscode.house.gov or http://www.gpoaccess.gov/uscode.)

d. United States Code. Title 49 Subtitle VII, Aviation Program s, USC §47123 Nondiscrimination.

(See http://uscode.house.gov or http://www.gpoaccess.gov/uscode.)

e. United States Code. Title 49 Subtitle VII, Aviati on Program s, §47107(a) 17, Project

Grant Application Approval Conditioned on Assurances About Airport Operations.

(See http://uscode.house.gov or http://www.gpoaccess.gov/uscode.)

f. United States Code. Title 49 Subtitle VII, Chapter 471 USC §47102 Definitions.

(See http://uscode.house.gov or http://www.gpoaccess.gov/uscode.) g. United States Code. Title 49 Subtitle VII, Chapter 471 USC §47105 Project Grant

Applications.

(See http://uscode.house.gov or http://www.gpoaccess.gov/uscode.)

CODE OF FEDERAL REGULATIONS (See http://www.gpoaccess.gov/cfr/.)

a. Airport Noise Compatibility Planning. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 14 CFR part

150.

b. Contract Cost Principles and Procedures. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 48 CFR

part 31.

c. Government-wide Debarm ent and Suspension (Nonprocurem ent). Code of Federal Regulations. Title 49 CFR part 29.

d. Labor Standards Provisions Applicable to Contracts Covering Federally Financed and Assisted Construction. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 29 CFR part 5.

e. New Restrictions on Lobbying. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 49 CFR part 20.

f. Nondiscrimination in Federally-Assisted Programs of the Department of Transportation--

Effectuation of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 49 CFR part 21.

g. Office of Federal Contract Com pliance Programs, Equal Em ployment Opportunity, Department of Labor. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 41 CFR part 60.

h. Participation by Disadvantaged Business Enterprises (DBE) in Departm ent of Transportation Financial Assistance Program s. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 49 CFR part 26.

i. Uniform Administrative Requirements for Gr ants and Cooperative Agreem ents to State

and Local Governments. Code of Federal Regulations. Title 49 CFR part 18.

FAA ORDERS AND ADVISORY CIRCULARS

FAA ORDERS AND ADVISORY CIRCULARS

a. U.S. Departm ent of Transportation. Federal Aviation Adm inistration. Order 1050.1,

Environmental Impacts: Policies and Procedures.

(See http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/orders_notices/.)

b. U.S. Departm ent of Transportation. Federal Aviation Adm inistration. Order 5050.4,

Airport Environmental Handbook.

(See http://www.faa.gov/airports/resources/publications/orders/.)

c. U.S. Department of Transportation. Federal Aviation Adm inistration. Order 5100.38,

Airport Improvement Program Handbook.

(See http://www.faa.gov/airports/resources/publications/orders/.)

d. U.S. Department of Transportation. Federal Aviation Administration. Advisory Circular

150/5300-15, Use of Value Engineering for Engineering and Design of Airport Grant Projects.

(See http://www.faa.gov/airports/resources/advisory_circulars/.)

Intentionally left blank.

APPENDIX C. SOURCES OF CONSULTANTS

APPENDIX C. SOURCES OF CONSULTANTS

Sources of consultants include, but are not limited to, the following professional societies. AIRPORT CONSULTANTS COUNCIL (ACC) 908 King Street, Suite 100 Alexandria, VA 22314 Telephone: 703-683-5900 FAX: 703-683-2564 http://www.acconline.org/ AMERICAN COUNCIL OF ENGINEERING COMPANIES (ACEC) 1015 15th Street 8th Floor, N.W. Washington, DC 20005-2605 Telephone: 202-347-7474 FAX: 202-898-0068 e-mail: [email protected] www.acec.org/ AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS (AIA) 1735 New York Ave., NW Washington, DC 20006-5292 Telephone: 800-AIA-3837 or 202-626-7300 FAX: 202-626-7547 www.aia.org

AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CIVIL ENGINEERS (ASCE) 101 Constitution Avenue, NW Suite 375 East Washington, DC 20001 Telephone: 800 548-2723 X7850 or 202-789-7850 FAX: 202-789-2501 www.asce.org NATIONAL SOCIETY OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERS (NSPE) 1420 King Street Alexandria, VA 22314-2794 Telephone: 703-684-2800 FAX: 703-836-4875 www.nspe.org

Other sources of consultants are available from:

• The professional services directories published in aviation magazines and trade journals. • Other airport operators having undertaken similar projects. • State boards of professional engineering registration. • State aviation agencies and local telephone directories. FAA Airports field offices m ay also furnish the nam es of consultants who have engaged in projects of sim ilar nature in their areas of jurisdiction. However, FAA personnel will not recommend consultants or participate in the selection process.

Intentionally left blank.

APPENDIX D. FAA AND STATE AGENCY ADDRESSES

APPENDIX D. FAA AND STATE AGENCY ADDRESSES

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION. The FAA Airports Regional or District/Development Office (ADO) addresses m ay be found by accessing http://www.faa.gov/news_information/contact_info/regional/. STATE AGENCY ADDRESSES. Information pertaining to the National Association of State Aviation Officials (NASAO), State aviation offices, and U.S. Territory aviation of fices is listed below.

NASAO

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF STATE AVIATION OFFICIALS (NASAO) 1010 Wayne Avenue - Suite 930 Silver Spring, MD 20910 Telephone: 301-588-0587 FAX: 301-585-1803 http://www.nasao.org State Aviation Offices

ALABAMA Alabama Department of Transportation Aeronautics Bureau 1409 Coliseum Blvd. Montgomery, AL 36130 Telephone: 334-242-6820 FAX: 205-240-3274 http://www.dot.state.al.us/Docs/Bureaus/Aerona utics

ALASKA Department of Transportation & Public Facilities Statewide Aviation 4111 Aviation Ave. P.O. Box 196900 Anchorage, AK 99519-6900 Telephone: 907-269-0730 FAX: 907-269-0489 http://www.dot.state.ak.us/

ARIZONA Division of Aeronautics Arizona Department of Transportation 255 E. Osborn Road, Suite 101 Phoenix, AZ 85012 or Mail Drop 426M Phoenix, AZ 85002-3588 Telephone: 602-294-9144 FAX: 602-294-9141 http://www.dot.state.az.us/Aviation/index.asp

ARKANSAS Department of Aeronautics Regional Airport Terminal Building 1 Airport Drive, 3rd Floor Little Rock, AR 72202 Telephone: 501-376-6781 FAX: 501-378-0820 http://www.ahtd.state.ar.us

CALIFORNIA Division of Aeronautics Program Department of Transportation 1120 N. Street-Room 3300 P.O. Box 942874 Sacramento, CA 94274-0001 Telephone: 916-654-4959 FAX: 916-653-9531 Postal Address: Division of Aeronautics, MS 40 P. O. Box 942874 Sacramento, CA 94274-0001 http://www.dot.ca.gov/hq/planning/aeronaut/htm lfile/index.php

COLORADO Colorado Department of Transportation Division of Aeronautics 5126 Front Range Parkway Watkins, CO 80137 Telephone: 303-261-4418 FAX: 303-261-9608 http://www.colorado-aeronautics.org

CONNECTICUT Bureau of Aviation and Ports Connecticut Department of Transportation 2800 Berlin Turnpike P.O. Box 317546 Newington, CT 06131-7546 Telephone: 860-594-2529 FAX: 860-594-2574 http://www.ct.gov/dot

DELAWARE Office of Aeronautics Delaware Transportation Authority Department of Transportation 800 Bay Road P.O. Box 778 Dover, DE 19903 Telephone: 302-760-2149 FAX: 302-739-2251 http://www.state.de.us/deldot/info/air.html

FLORIDA Aviation Office Florida Department of Transportation 605 Suwannee Street Mail Stop 46 Tallahassee, FL 32399-0450 Telephone: 850-414-4500 FAX: 850-412-4508 http://www.dot.state.fl.us/aviation/

GEORGIA Georgia Department of Transportation Office of Intermodal Programs-Aviation 276 Memorial Drive, SW Atlanta, GA 30303-3743 Telephone: 404-651-9221 FAX: 404-657-5209 http://www.dot.state.ga.us

HAWAII Airports Division Hawaii Department of Transportation Honolulu International Airport 400 Rodgers Blvd. Suite 700 Honolulu, HI 96819-1898 Telephone: 808-838-8600 FAX: 808-838-8734 http://www.hawaii.gov/dot/airports

IDAHO Division of Aeronautics Idaho Department of Transportation 3483 Rickenbacker Street P.O. Box 7129 Boise, ID 83705 Telephone: 208-334-8775 FAX: 208-334-8789 http://www.itd.idaho.gov/aero/

ILLINOIS Division of Aeronautics Department of Transportation Abraham Lincoln Capital Airport One Langhorne Bond Dr. Springfield, IL 62707-8415 Telephone: 217-785-8500 FAX: 217-785-4533 http://www.dot.state.il.us/aero/

INDIANA Aeronautics Section Indiana Department of Transportation 100 N. Senate Ave. Room N901 Indianapolis, IN 46204-2219 Telephone: 317-232-1496 FAX: 317-232-1499 http://www.in.gov/dot/modetrans http://www.state.in.us/dot/sitemap/#4

IOWA Office of Aviation Air and Transit Division Iowa Department of Transportation 800 Lincoln Way Ames, IA 50010 Telephone: 515-239-1659 FAX: 515-233-7983 www.iawings.com

KANSAS Division of Aviation Kansas Department of Transportation 700 SW Harrison Topeka, KS 66603-3754 Telephone: 785-296-2553 FAX: 785-296-3833 http://www.ksdot.org/divaviation/

KENTUCKY Division of Aeronautics Kentucky Transportation Cabinet 200 Mero Street W3-09-02 Frankfort, KY 40622 Telephone: 502-564-4480 FAX: 502-564-7953 http://www.kytc.state.ky.us/aviation

LOUISIANA Aviation Division Department of Transportation & Development 8900 Jimmy Wedell Drive P.O. Box 94245 Baton Rouge, LA 70804-9245 Telephone: 225-274-4112 FAX: 225-274-4181 http://www.dotd.louisiana.gov/intermodal/aviation

MAINE Office of Passenger Transportation Maine Department of Transportation 16 State House Station Augusta, ME 04333 Telephone: 207-624-3250 FAX: 207-624-3251 http://www.maine.gov/mdotstage/aviation/aviation-home.php

MARYLAND Maryland Aviation Administration Maryland Department of Transportation P.O. Box 8766 Baltimore/Washington Intl. Airport, MD 21240 Telephone: 410-859-7111 FAX: 410-850-4729 http://www.marylandaviation.com

MASSACHUSETTS Massachusetts Aeronautics Commission 10 Park Plaza, Suite 3510 Boston, MA 02116-3966 Telephone: 617-973-8881 FAX: 617-973-8889 http://www.massaeronautics.org

MICHIGAN Bureau of Aeronautics Department of Transportation 2700 East Airport Service Drive Capital City Airport Lansing, MI 48906-2160 Telephone: 517-335-9568 FAX: 517-321-6522 www.michigan.gov

MINNESOTA Aeronautics Office Minnesota Department of Transportation 222 East Plato Boulevard St. Paul, MN 55107-1618 Telephone: 651-296-8202 FAX: 651-297-5643 http://www.dot.state.mn.us/aero/

MISSISSIPPI Mississippi Department of Transportation Aeronautics Division 401 Northwest Street Jackson, MS 39201 Telephone: 601-359-7850 FAX: 601-359-7855 www.gomdot.com

MISSOURI Department of Highways & Transportation Aviation Section DOT Bldg. 2217 St. Mary’s Blvd P.O. Box 270 Jefferson City, MO 65102 Telephone: 573-751-2589 FAX: 573-526-4709 http://www.modot.state.mo.us/othertransportation/

MONTANA Aeronautics Division Department of Transportation P.O. Box 200507 Helena, MT 59620-0507 Telephone: 406-444-9547 FAX: 406-444-2519 http://www.mdt.state.mt.us/aeronautics

NEBRASKA Nebraska Department of Aeronautics P.O. Box 82088 Lincoln, NE 68501 Telephone: 402-471-2371 FAX: 402-471-2906 www.aero.state.ne.us

NEVADA Nevada Department of Transportation 1263 South Stewart Street Carson City, NV 89712 Telephone: 775-888-7464 FAX: 775-888-7207 http://www.nevadadot.com

NEW HAMPSHIRE Division of Aeronautics Municipal Airport 65 Airport Road Concord, NH 03301-5298 Telephone: 603-271-2551 FAX: 603-271-1689 http://www.nh.gov/dot/aeronautics

NEW JERSEY Division of Aeronautics and Freight Systems New Jersey Department of Transportation 1035 Parkway Avenue CN 610 Trenton, NJ 08625 Telephone: 609-530-2900 FAX: 609-530-4549 http://www.state.nj.us/transportation

NEW MEXICO Aviation Division State Highway and Transportation Department P.O. Box 1149 1550 Pacheco St. Santa Fe, NM 87504-1149 Telephone: 505-476-0930 FAX: 505-476-0942 www.nmshtd.state.nm.us/

NEW YORK Aviation Services Bureau New York State Department of Transportation 50 Wolf Rd. Albany, NY 12232-0414 Telephone: 518-457-8343 FAX: 518-457-9779 http://www.dot.state.ny.us/pubtrans/airhome.html

NORTH CAROLINA Division of Aviation 1050 Meridian Dr. RDU Airport, NC 27623 or North Carolina Department of Transportation Division of Aviation 1560 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699-1560 Telephone 919-840-0112 FAX 919-840-9267 http://www.dot.state.nc.us/transit/aviation

NORTH DAKOTA North Dakota Aeronautics Commission 2301 University Drive Bldg. 1652-22 Box 5020 Bismarck, ND 58502 Telephone: 701-328-9650 FAX: 701-328-9656 http://www.state.nd.us/ndaero/

OHIO Ohio Department of Transportation Division of Aviation 2829 West Dublin-Granville Road Columbus, OH 43235 Telephone: 614-793-5040 FAX: 614 761-9609 http://www.dot.state.oh.us/aviation

OKLAHOMA Oklahoma Aeronautics Commission Department of Transportation Building 3700 N. Classen Blvd. Suite 240 Oklahoma City OK 73118 Telephone: 405-604-6900 FAX: 405-604-6919 http://www.aeronautics.state.ok.us

OREGON Department of Aviation Oregon Department of Transportation 3040 25th Street, SE Salem, OR 97302 Telephone: 503-378-4880 FAX: 503-373-1688 http://www.aviation.state.or.us

PENNSYLVANIA Bureau of Aviation Pennsylvania Department of Transportation PO Box 3457 Harrisburg International Airport Middletown, PA 17057 Telephone: 717-705-1260 FAX: 717-705-1255 http://www.dot.state.pa.us

PUERTO RICO Puerto Rico Ports Authority P.O. Box 362829 San Juan, PR 00936-2829 Telephone: 809-723-2260 FAX: 809-722-7867 www.dtop.gov.pr

RHODE ISLAND Rhode Island Airport Corporation Department of Airports Theodore Francis Green Airport 2000 Post Road Warwick, RI 02886-1533 Telephone: 401-737-4000 FAX: 401-732-3034 http://www.pvdairport.com

SOUTH CAROLINA Division of Aeronautics 2553 Airport Blvd. P.O. Box 280068 Columbia, SC 29228-0068 Telephone: 803-896-6260 FAX: 803-922-0574 http://www.scaeronautics.com

SOUTH DAKOTA Office of Aeronautics Becker-Hansen Building 700 Broadway Avenue East Pierre, SD 57501-2586 Telephone: 605-773-7045 FAX: 605-773-3921 http://www.sddot.com/fpa/aeronautics/index.htm

TENNESSEE Aeronautics Division Tennessee Department of Transportation 607 Hanger Lane Bldg. 4219 P.O. Box 17326 Nashville, TN 37217 Telephone: 615-741-3208 FAX: 615-741-4959 http://www.state.tn.us

TEXAS Texas Department of Transportation Division of Aviation 125 E. 11th St. Austin, TX 78701-2483 Telephone: 512-416-4500 FAX: 512-416-4510 http://www.dot.state.tx.us

UTAH Aeronautical Operations Division Utah Department of Transportation 135 North 2400 West Salt Lake City, UT 84116 Telephone: 801-715-2260 FAX: 801-715-2276 http://www.dot.state.ut.us

VERMONT Agency of Transportation Maintenance and Aviation Division National Life Building, Drawer 33 Montpelier, VT 05633 Telephone: 802-828-2833 FAX: 802-828-2848 http://www.vermontairports.com/air.htm

VIRGINIA Department of Aviation 5702 Gulfstream Rd. Richmond, VA 23250-2422 Telephone: 804-236-3624 FAX: 804-236-3635 http://www.doav.virginia.gov

WASHINGTON Washington Department of Transportation WSDOT Aviation 3704 172nd St. NE Arlington, WA 98223-6336 Telephone: 360-651-6300 FAX: 360-651-6319 http://www.wsdot.wa.gov/aviation

WEST VIRGINIA Department of Transportation Aeronautics Commission 1900 Kanawha Blvd. East Building 5, Room A-503 Charleston, WV 25305 Telephone: 304-558-3436 FAX: 304-558-03333 http://www.wvdot.com/1_airports/1e_commissi on.htm

WISCONSIN Bureau of Aeronautics Wisconsin Department of Transportation P.O. Box 7914 Madison, WI 53707-7914 Telephone: 608-266-3351 FAX: 608-267-6748 www.dot.wisconsin.gov/modes/air.htm

WYOMING NORTHERN MARIANA ISLANDS Wyoming Department of Transportation Executive Director Aeronautics Division Commonwealth Ports Authority 5300 Bishop Boulevard Saipan International Airport Cheyenne, WY 82009-3340 P.O. Box 501055 Telephone: 307-777-3952 Saipan, MP 96950-1055 FAX: 307-637-7352 Telephone: 670-644-3500 FAX: 670-234-5962 www.dot.state.wy.us www.cpa.gov.mp US Territory Aviation Offices

PUERTO RICO

PUERTO RICO

Puerto Rico Ports Authority AMERICAN SAMOA

P.O. Box 362829 Director

San Juan, PR 00936-2829 Department of Port Administration

Telephone: 809-723-2260 American Samoa Government

FAX: 809-722-7867 P.O. Box 1539

www.dtop.gov.pr Pago Pago, American Samoa 96799 Telephone: 684-633-4251 VIRGIN ISLANDS FAX: 684-633-5281 Virgin Islands Port Authority www.asg-gov.net

P.O. Box 301707 St. Thomas, VI 00803-1707 GUAM

Telephone: 340-714-6601 Executive Manager

Fax: 340 774-0025 A.B. Won Pat Guam International

http://www.viport.com Airport Authority (GIAA)

P.O. Box 8770

Tamuning, GU 96931 Telephone: 671-646-0300 FAX: 671-646-8823 www.guamairport.com

Intentionally left blank.

APPENDIX E. SCOPE OF SERVICES SAMPLES

APPENDIX E. SCOPE OF SERVICES SAMPLES

This appendix contains three different exam ples of Scope of Services. Exam ple 1 is a Design Services scope, Exam ple 2 is a Planning Serv ices scope, and Exam ple 3 is a Construction Services scope. Sam ples may not necessarily in clude all provisions and term s required by this AC. If a conflict exists between these examples and the AC, the AC will prevail.

EXAMPLE 1. DESIGN SERVICES SCOPE TAXIWAY A SOUTH AND HOLDING AP RON RECONSTRUCTION AND NEW HARDSTAND ABC INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT The consultant will provide the required prof essional services to design the reconstruction of Taxiway A South and holding apron and the proposed hardstand (attach a drawing or exhibit if necessary). This work will be perform ed and constructed under a Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Airport Improvement Program (AIP) grant to the airport. Taxiway A South will be constructed in Portland Cem ent concrete and will be widened to 100 feet and have new 40-feet-wide asphalt shoulde rs added. The South Holding Apron will be reconstructed to essentially the sam e conf iguration as presently exists. Centerline taxiway lighting will be added to the taxiway and th rough the holding apron to Runway 18L/36R. Control panels in the FAA tower and f ield lighting electrical vault will also be m odified for the new centerline lighting.

The new hardstand will be located north of the Ai rlift Airlines Maintenance Facility (currently under construction) south of the northeast Car go Taxilane and west of the flying Bears hardstand. The hardstand will be a Portland Cement concrete apron with lighting similar to other hardstands, drainage to the Industrial W aste Sewerage System (IW S), and other utilities including fire protection. No downstream IWS changes are anticipated. It is anticipated that utilities are immediately available for fire protection adjacent to hardstand. Professional services to be provided by the consultant will include civil, electrical and structural, and geotechnical engineering services required to accomplish the following items: PHASE 1 - PRELIMINARY DESIGN The prelim inary design phase is intended to identif y and evaluate alternatives to assure cost effective and practical solutions f or the work ite ms identified.

The consultant will com plete its evaluation of alternatives through contacts with local authorities and review of the preapplication, field investigations, and a pr actical design approach. The design will take advantage of local knowledge and experience a nd utilize expertise from recent construction projects to design a cost-ef fective project and ensure competitive construction bids. Activities include:

a. Coordinate with airport operations, FAA tower, and the airlines to m inimize impacts in day-to-day operations of the airlines and ai r cargo lines. Also coordinate with f acilities and m aintenance and f ire departm ent. (This will require f our coordination m eetings throughout the design.)

b. Prepare a prelim inary estimate of probable construction costs and schem atic design for

each element of the project.

c. Provide all geotechnical investigati on and analysis and pavem ent and other nondestructive testing and analysis required for the design.

d. Coordinate with the airport's project manager for required survey information.

e. Prepare an overall construction phasing plan in order to maximize project constructability

and minimize interference with airport operati ons. The consultant’s phasing plan m ust take into account other airport construction projects.

f. Determine aircraft usage through coordi nation with Airport staff and inform ation furnished by the sponsor. Design the pavements to meet the anticipated aircraft traffic. PHASE 2 - ENGINEERING PHASE ACTIVITIES

a. Evaluate local conditions.

1. Evaluate local material suppliers, sources, and capabilities.

2. Evaluate drainage alternatives.

3. Review electrical lighting layouts and determine system relocation capacities.

b. Review and evaluate project layout.

1. Verify master plan dimensions and data.

2. Review findings and recommendations with airport personnel.

c. Complete a soils investigation, soils report, and recommendations including:

1. Field Exploration.

(a) Conduct test pit explorations with a rubbe r-tired backhoe at various locations to a

maximum depth of 8 feet in the runway, taxiway, and apron areas. Log and field classify soils and obtain samples for laboratory testing.

2. Laboratory Testing.

(a) Perform laboratory index and strength tests as follows:

(1) Compacted CBR test (3 compaction points/test).

(2) Standard Proctor (4 point) compaction tests.

(3) Atterberg limit determinations.

(4) Sieve analysis.

(5) Unit weight and water content determinations.

(6) FAA soil classifications for all samples.

d. Complete necessary topography and site su rveying, including establishm ent of project control points.

e. Complete pavem ent section alternatives analysis and provide recom mendations including:

1. Conduct an initial cost analysis, life-cycle cost analysis, and analysis of locally available resources for up to three alternatives.

2. Strategize bidding procedures and pavement section alternatives to provide a basis for competitive bidding.

f. Complete preliminary plan and profile design for the runway, taxiway, and apron area.

g. Complete preliminary runway lighting, signing, and system circuitry layout.

h. Provide recommendations for construction phasing to the sponsor for their review.

i. Complete estimates of probable construction costs for the recommended alternatives.

j. Provide five sets of review documents.

k. Complete the preliminary design report including:

1. Geotechnical investigation.

2. Topographical survey.

3. Prelim inary plans.

4. Pavement section design and analysis.

5. Drainage design analysis.

6. Estimates of probable construction costs.

7. Final summary and recommendations.

8. Phasing and scheduling recommendations.

l. Solicit comments on preliminary design from airport personnel and the FAA. PHASE 3 - FINAL DESIGN In the decision phase, the consultant will provide well-defined construction requirem ents, with selected bid alternatives as appropriate to pr ovide a basis f or com petitive construction bids. Construction schedules will be closely coordinated to assure the best possible weather conditions and the least possible interference with airpor t operations. Assist the airport with the advertisement, notification of local airport user s, and generally com plete the final construction contract documents for the project. The f ollowing outline describes in greater detail the tasks and products.

a. Incorporate prelim inary design com ments and respond as necessary to requests for

additional information.

b. Provide final design drawings, specifications, and final estimate of probable construction

costs and schedule for the project.

c. Provide Engineering Report.

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 204 passages shown