AC 120-28D Criteria for Approval of Category III Weather Minima for Takeoff, Landing, and Rollout
States an acceptable means, not the only means, for obtaining approval of Category III Landing Weather Minima and low visibility takeoff, including the installation and approval of associated aircraft systems.
This document is cancelled. Cancelled by 20-191. Check the official source before relying on it.
AC 120-28D
July 13, 1999
CRITERIA FOR APPROVAL OF CATEGORY III WEATHER MINIMA FOR TAKEOFF, LANDING, AND ROLLOUT
1. Purpose. This advisory circular (AC) provides an acceptable means, but not the only means, for obtaining and maintaining approval of operations in Category III Landing Weather Minima and low visibility takeoff including the installation and approval of associated aircraft systems. It includes additional Category III criteria or revised Category III criteria for use in conjunction with Head-up Displays, satellite navigation systems, low visibility takeoff guidance systems, Wide-body Fail Passive operations and use of Category III during certain engine inoperative operations. This revision also updates and incorporates provisions of the former AC 20-57 into AC 120-28.
This revision incorporates changes resulting from the first steps toward international all weather operations (AWO) criteria harmonization taken by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), European Joint Aviation Authorities (JAA), and several other regulatory authorities. Subsequent revisions of this AC are planned as additional all weather operations harmonization items (AHI) are agreed and completed by FAA JAA, and other regulatory authorities.
L. Nicholas Lacey Director, Flight Standards Service
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SEC # SECTION TITLES
1 PURPOSE
2 RELATED REFERENCES AND DEFINITIONS 2.1 Related References 2.2 Definitions
3 BACKGROUND 3.1 Major Changes Addressed in this Revision 3.2 Relationship of Operational Authorizations for Category III and Airborne System Demonstrations 3.3 Applicable Criteria
1 PURPOSE
4 OPERATIONAL CONCEPTS 4.1 Classification and Applicability of Minima 4.2 Takeoff 4.3 Landing 4.3.1 Concepts and Objectives 4.3.2 Fail Operational Category III Operations 4.3.3 Alert Height 4.3.4 Fail Passive Category III Operations 4.3.5 Decision Altitude (Height) 4.3.6 Go-Around Safety 4.3.7 Category IIIa 4.3.8 Category IIIb 4.3.9 Runway Field-Length 4.3.10 Landing System Sensors (NAVAIDs) and Aircraft Position Determination 4.3.10.1 Instrument Landing System(ILS) 4.3.10.2 Microwave Landing System (MLS) 4.3.10.3 GNSS Landing System (GLS) 4.4 RNAV/Flight Management Systems (FMS) 4.5 Required Navigation Performance (RNP) 4.5.1 Standard RNP Types 4.5.2 Non-Standard RNP Types 4.6 Flight Path Definition 4.7 Engine Inoperative Category III Capability
5 AIRBORNE SYSTEMS 5.1 General 5.1.1 Airborne Systems 5.1.2 Non-Airborne Systems 5.1.3 Takeoff Guidance Systems 5.2 Airborne Systems for Category III Minima Not Less Than RVR600 5.3 Airborne Systems for Category III Minima Less Than RVR600 5.3.1 Airborne Systems for Category III Minima Not Less Than RVR400
ii
5.3.2 Airborne Systems for Category III Minima Not Less Than RVR300 (75 m) 5.3.3 Airborne Systems for Category III Minima Less Than RVR300 5.4 Automatic Flight Control Systems and Automatic Landing Systems 5.5 Flight Director Systems 5.6 Head-up Display Systems 5.7 Enhanced/Synthetic Vision Systems 5.8 Hybrid Systems 5.9 Instruments and Displays 5.10 Annunciations 5.11 Automatic Aural Alerts 5.12 Navigation Sensors 5.13 Supporting Systems and Capabilities 5.13.1 Flight Deck Visibility 5.13.2 Rain and Ice Removal 5.13.3 Miscellaneous Systems 5.14 Go-Around Capability 5.15 Excessive Deviation Alerting 5.16 Rollout Deceleration Systems or Procedures for Category III 5.16.1 Stopping Means 5.16.2 Antiskid Systems 5.17 Engine Inoperative Category III Capability 5.18 Airborne System Assessment for Irregular Pre-Threshold Terrain 5.19 Airworthiness Demonstrations of Airborne System Capability for Category III
6 PROCEDURES 6.1 Operational Procedures 6.1.1 Application of AFM Provisions 6.1.2 Crew Coordination 6.1.3 Monitoring 6.1.4 Use of the Decision Height or Alert Height 6.1.5 Call-outs 6.1.6 Aircraft Configurations 6.1.7 Compatibility with Category I and Category II Procedures 6.1.8 Flight Crew Response to Non-Normal Events 6.2 Category III Instrument Approach Procedures and Low Visibility Takeoff 6.2.1 Takeoff Guidance System Procedures 6.2.2 Acceptable Procedures for Category III Approach 6.2.3 Standard Obstacle Clearance for Approach and Missed Approach 6.2.4 Special Obstacle Criteria 6.2.5 Irregular Terrain Airports 6.2.6 Airport Surface Depiction for Category III Operations 6.2.7 Continuing Category III Approaches in Deteriorating Weather Conditions 6.2.8 Low Visibility Taxi Procedures 6.2.9 Navigation Reference Datum Compatibility (e.g.,WGS-84/Other Datum)
7 TRAINING AND CREW QUALIFICATION 7.1 Ground Training 7.1.1 Ground System and NAVAID’s for Category III
iii
7.1.2 The Airborne System 7.1.3 Flight Procedures and Associated Information 7.2 Flight Training (Aircraft or Simulator) 7.2.1 Initial Qualification 7.2.2 Recurrent Qualification 7.2.3 Recency of Experience 7.2.4 Re-qualification 7.2.5 Cockpit or Aircraft System Differences 7.2.6 Category III Operations with an Inoperative Engine 7.2.7 Training in Conjunction with Advanced Qualification Programs (AQP) or Exemptions for “Single Visit Training” 7.2.8 Credit for “High Limit Captains” (Reference section 121.562) 7.2.9 Enhanced or Synthetic Vision Systems (Independent Landing Monitor) 7.3 Checking or Evaluations 7.4 Experience with Line Landings 7.5 Crew Records 7.6 Dual Qualification 7.7 Interchange 7.8 Training For Use of Foreign Airports for Category III Operations or Low Visibility Takeoff 7.9 Line Checks
8 AIRPORTS, NAVIGATION FACILITIES AND METEOROLOGICAL CRITERIA 8.1 Use of Standard Navigation Facilities 8.2 Use of Other Navigation Facilities or Methods 8.3 Lighting Systems 8.4 Marking and Signs 8.5 Low Visibility Surface Movement Guidance and Control (SMGC) Plans 8.6 Meteorological Services and RVR Availability and Use 8.6.1 Meteorological Services 8.6.2 RVR Availability and Use 8.6.2.1 RVR Availability 8.6.2.2 RVR Use 8.6.3 Pilot Assessment of Takeoff Visibility Equivalent to RVR 8.7 Critical Area Protection 8.8 Operational Facilities, Outages, Airport Construction, and NOTAM’s 8.9 Use of Military Facilities 8.10 Special Provisions for Facilities Used for ETOPS or EROPS Alternates 8.11 Alternate Minima 8.12 Flight Planning to Airports That Have Weather Conditions Below Landing Minima
9 CONTINUING AIRWORTHINESS/MAINTENANCE 9.1 Maintenance Program 9.2 Maintenance Program Provisions 9.3 Initial and Recurrent Maintenance Training 9.4 Test Equipment/Calibration Standards 9.5 Return to Service Procedures 9.6 Periodic Aircraft System Evaluations 9.7 Reliability Reporting and Quality Control
iv
9.8 Configuration Control/System Modifications 9.9 Records 9.10 FAR 129 Foreign Operator Maintenance Programs 9.10.1 Maintenance of FAR 129 Foreign Registered Aircraft 9.10.2 Maintenance of FAR 129 Foreign Operated U.S. "N" Registered Aircraft
10 APPROVAL OF UNITED STATES OPERATORS 10.1 Operations Manuals and Procedures 10.2 Training Programs and Crew Qualification 10.3 Flight Planning (e.g., Dispatch, MEL, Alternate Airports, ETOPS or EROPS) 10.4 Formulation of Operations Specification 10.5 Operational/Airworthiness Demonstrations 10.5.1 Airborne System Suitability Demonstration 10.5.2 "Operator Use Suitability" Demonstration 10.5.2.1 Data Collection For Airborne System Demonstrations 10.5.2.2 Data Analysis 10.5.2.3 Approval of Landing Minima 10.6 Eligible Airports and Runways 10.7 Irregular Pre-Threshold Terrain and Other Restricted Runways 10.8 Engine-Inoperative Operations and ETOPS or EROPS Alternates based on Category III 10.8.1 General Criteria for Engine Inoperative Category III Authorization 10.8.2 Engine Inoperative "Flight Planning" 10.8.3 Engine Inoperative En Route 10.8.4 Engine Failure During Approach, Prior to Alert Height or Decision Height 10.8.5 Engine Failure After Passing Alert Height or Decision Height 10.9 New Category III Operators 10.10 Credit for Experienced Category III Operators for New
Authorizations 10.10.1 New Airports/Runways 10.10.2 New or Upgraded Airborne System Capabilities 10.10.3 Adding a New Category III Aircraft Type 10.11 Category III Program Status Following Operator Acquisitions/Mergers 10.12 Initiating New Combined Category II and Category III Programs 10.13 United States Carrier Category III Operations at Foreign Airports 10.14 Category III Operations on Off-Route Charters 10.15 Approval of Category III Minima and Issuance of Operations Specifications 10.16 Operations Specification Amendments 10.17 Use of Special Obstacle Clearance Criteria (e.g., RNP Criteria) 10.18 Proof-of-Concept Demonstration for New Systems/Methods
11 FOREIGN AIR CARRIER CATEGORY III AT UNITED STATES AIRPORTS (Part 129 OPERATIONS SPECIFICATIONS)
11.1 Use of ICAO or FAA Criteria 11.1.1 Acceptable Criteria 11.1.2 Foreign Operator AFM Provisions 11.1.3 Foreign Operator Category III Demonstrations 11.2 Issuance of Part 129 Operations Specifications 11.3 Use of Certain United States Facilities
v
12 OPERATOR REPORTING, AND TAKING CORRECTIVE ACTIONS 12.1 Operator Reporting 12.2 Operator Corrective Actions
APPENDIX 1 DEFINITIONS AND ACRONYMS
APPENDIX 2 AIRWORTHINESS APPROVAL OF AIRBORNE SYSTEMS USED DURING A
TAKEOFF IN LOW VISIBILITY WEATHER CONDITIONS
1 APPENDIX 2 PURPOSE
2 APPENDIX 2 GENERAL
2 APPENDIX 2 GENERAL
3 APPENDIX 2 INTRODUCTION
4 APPENDIX 2 TYPES OF TAKEOFF OPERATIONS
5 APPENDIX 2 TYPES OF TAKEOFF SERVICES 5.1 APPENDIX 2 ILS 5.2 APPENDIX 2 MLS 5.3 APPENDIX 2 GNSS [PoC] 5.3.1 APPENDIX 2 GNSS Flight Path Definition [PoC] 5.3.2 APPENDIX 2 GNSS Airplane Position Determination [PoC] 5.4 APPENDIX 2 Other 5.4.1 APPENDIX 2 Datalink [PoC]
4 APPENDIX 2 TYPES OF TAKEOFF OPERATIONS
6 APPENDIX 2 AIRWORTHINESS 6.1 APPENDIX 2 General Takeoff System 6.1.1 APPENDIX 2 Takeoff Performance Prior to 35 Ft. AGL 6.1.1.1 APPENDIX 2 ILS 6.1.1.2 APPENDIX 2 MLS 6.1.2 APPENDIX 2 Workload Criteria 6.2 APPENDIX 2 Takeoff System Integrity 6.3 APPENDIX 2 Takeoff System Availability 6.4 APPENDIX 2 Flight Deck Information, Annunciation and Alerting 6.4.1 APPENDIX 2 Flight Deck Information 6.4.2 APPENDIX 2 Annunciation 6.4.3 APPENDIX 2 Alerting 6.4.3.1 APPENDIX 2 Warnings 6.4.3.2 APPENDIX 2 Cautions 6.4.3.3 APPENDIX 2 Advisories 6.4.3.4 APPENDIX 2 System Status 6.4.3.5 APPENDIX 2 Engine Failures
7 APPENDIX 2 TAKEOFF SYSTEM EVALUATION 7.1 APPENDIX 2 Performance Evaluation 7.2 APPENDIX 2 Safety Assessment
8 APPENDIX 2 AIRBORNE SYSTEM
8 APPENDIX 2 AIRBORNE SYSTEM
vi
8.1 APPENDIX 2 General 8.2 APPENDIX 2 Peripheral Vision Guidance Systems [PoC] 8.3 APPENDIX 2 Head Up Display Takeoff System 8.4 APPENDIX 2 Satellite Based Systems [PoC] 8.4.1 APPENDIX 2 Flight Path Definition 8.4.2 APPENDIX 2 On Board Database 8.4.3 APPENDIX 2 Datalink 8.5 APPENDIX 2 Enhanced Vision Systems [PoC]
9 APPENDIX 2 AIRPLANE FLIGHT MANUAL
9 APPENDIX 2 AIRPLANE FLIGHT MANUAL
APPENDIX 3 AIRWORTHINESS APPROVAL FOR AIRBORNE SYSTEMS USED TO LAND
AND ROLLOUT IN LOW VISIBILITY CONDITIONS
1 APPENDIX 3 PURPOSE
2 APPENDIX 3 GENERAL
3 APPENDIX 3 INTRODUCTION
4 APPENDIX 3 TYPES OF LANDING AND ROLLOUT OPERATIONS
5 APPENDIX 3 TYPES OF LANDING AND ROLLOUT SERVICES 5.1 APPENDIX 3 ILS 5.1.1 APPENDIX 3 ILS Flight Path Definition 5.1.2 APPENDIX 3 ILS Airplane Position Determination 5.2 APPENDIX 3 MLS 5.2.1 APPENDIX 3 MLS Flight Path Definition 5.2.2 APPENDIX 3 MLS Airplane Position Determination 5.3 APPENDIX 3 GNSS [PoC] 5.3.1 APPENDIX 3 GNSS Flight Path Definition [PoC] 5.3.2 APPENDIX 3 GNSS Airplane Position Determination [PoC] 5.3.3 APPENDIX 3 Datalink [PoC]
4 APPENDIX 3 TYPES OF LANDING AND ROLLOUT OPERATIONS
6 APPENDIX 3 AIRWORTHINESS 6.1 APPENDIX 3 General 6.2 APPENDIX 3 Approach Systems 6.3 APPENDIX 3 Landing and Rollout System Performance 6.3.1 APPENDIX 3 Landing System Performance 6.3.2 APPENDIX 3 Speed Control Performance 6.3.3 APPENDIX 3 Rollout System Performance 6.3.4 APPENDIX 3 Variables Affecting Performance 6.3.5 APPENDIX 3 Irregular Approach Terrain 6.3.6 APPENDIX 3 Approach and Automatic Landing with an Inoperative Engine 6.3.7 APPENDIX 3 Inoperative Engine Information 6.4 APPENDIX 3 Landing and Rollout System Integrity 6.4.1 APPENDIX 3 Landing System Integrity 6.4.2 APPENDIX 3 Rollout System Integrity
vii
6.4.3 APPENDIX 3 On Board Database Integrity [PoC] 6.5 APPENDIX 3 Landing and Rollout System Availability 6.5.1 APPENDIX 3 Landing System Availability 6.5.2 APPENDIX 3 Rollout System Availability 6.6 APPENDIX 3 Go-around 6.7 APPENDIX 3 Automatic Braking System 6.8 APPENDIX 3 Flight Deck Information, Annunciation and Alerting 6.8.1 APPENDIX 3 Flight Deck Information 6.8.2 APPENDIX 3 Annunciation 6.8.3 APPENDIX 3 Alerting 6.8.3.1 APPENDIX 3 Warnings 6.8.3.2 APPENDIX 3 Cautions 6.8.3.3 APPENDIX 3 Advisories 6.8.3.4 APPENDIX 3 System Status 6.9 APPENDIX 3 Multiple Landing Systems 6.9.1 APPENDIX 3 General 6.9.2 APPENDIX 3 Indications 6.9.3 APPENDIX 3 Annunciations 6.9.4 APPENDIX 3 Alerting
7 APPENDIX 3 LANDING AND ROLLOUT SYSTEM EVALUATION 7.1 APPENDIX 3 Performance Evaluation 7.1.1 APPENDIX 3 Validation of the Simulator 7.1.2 APPENDIX 3 Simulations for Automatic System Performance Demonstration 7.1.3 APPENDIX 3 Flight Test Performance Demonstration 7.1.4 APPENDIX 3 Demonstration of Approach and Automatic Landing with an Inoperative Engine 7.2 APPENDIX 3 Safety Assessment
8 APPENDIX 3 AIRBORNE SYSTEMS 8.1 APPENDIX 3 Automatic Flight Control Systems 8.2 APPENDIX 3 Autothrottle Systems 8.3 APPENDIX 3 Head Up Guidance 8.4 APPENDIX 3 Hybrid HUD/Autoland System [PoC] 8.4.1 APPENDIX 3 Hybrid HUD/Autoland System Fail Operational Equivalency Concept 8.4.2 APPENDIX 3 Hybrid System Go Around Capability 8.4.3 APPENDIX 3 Hybrid System Transition From Automatic to Manual Flight 8.4.4 APPENDIX 3 Hybrid System Pilot Not Flying (PNF) 8.5 APPENDIX 3 Satellite Based Landing Systems [PoC] 8.5.1 APPENDIX 3 Flight Path Definition 8.5.2 APPENDIX 3 Aircraft Database 8.5.3 APPENDIX 3 Differential Augmentation 8.5.4 APPENDIX 3 Datalink 8.6 APPENDIX 3 Enhanced Vision Systems [PoC]
9 APPENDIX 3 AIRPLANE FLIGHT MANUAL
9 APPENDIX 3 AIRPLANE FLIGHT MANUAL
APPENDIX 4 WIND MODEL FOR APPROACH AND LANDING SIMULATION
viii
APPENDIX 5 [RESERVED]
APPENDIX 6 AFM PROVISIONS AND SAMPLE AFM WORDING
6.1 APPENDIX 6 Example Provision – AFM “Certificate Limitation” Section 6.2 APPENDIX 6 Example Provision - AFM “Normal Procedures” or “Normal Operation” [Typical Aircraft Type with Fail Operational and Fail Passive FGS] 6.3 APPENDIX 6 Example Provision - AFM “Normal Procedures” or “Normal Operation” [Typical Aircraft Type with Fail Passive FGS Capability]
APPENDIX 7 STANDARD OPERATIONS SPECIFICATIONS - GENERAL
APPENDIX 7 STANDARD OPERATIONS SPECIFICATIONS - GENERAL
APPENDIX 7 OPERATIONS SPECIFICATIONS - GENERAL APPENDIX 7 Para. A002 APPENDIX 7 Para. C051 APPENDIX 7 Para. C055 APPENDIX 7 Para. C056 APPENDIX 7 Para. C060 APPENDIX 7 Para. C078
APPENDIX 8 IRREGULAR TERRAIN ASSESSMENT
APPENDIX 9 TAKEOFF SYSTEM PERFORMANCE AFTER LIFTOFF
APPENDIX 9 TAKEOFF SYSTEM PERFORMANCE AFTER LIFTOFF
Page 1
1. PURPOSE. This advisory circular (AC) provides an acceptable means, but not the only means, for obtaining and maintaining approval of operations in Category III Landing Weather Minima and low visibility takeoff including the installation and approval of associated airborne systems. This AC is applicable to Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 121, 135 and 125 operators. Certain aspects of this AC are applicable to 14 CFR part 129 operators. Many of the principles, concepts and procedures described also may apply to 14 CFR part 91 operations and are recommended for use by those operators when applicable. Mandatory terms used in this AC such as "shall" or "must" are used only in the sense of ensuring applicability of these particular methods of compliance when the acceptable means of compliance described herein is used. This AC does not change, add or delete regulatory requirements or authorize deviations from regulatory requirements.
CANCELLATION. AC 120-28C, dated March 9, 1984, and AC 20-57A dated January 12, 1971, are canceled.
2. RELATED REFERENCES AND DEFINITIONS.
2.1. Related References. Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 23, section 23.1309; part 25, sections 25.1309, 25.1322, 25.1581, and 25.1583; part 91, sections 91.175 and 91.189; part 121, sections 121.579, and 121.651; part 125, sections 125.379, and 125.381; part 129, section 129.11; and part 135, section 135.225.
Unless a specific reference is made to a particular version of a rule or AC, current editions of the following AC’s should be used:
AC 23.1309-1, Equipment, Systems, and Installation in Part 23 Airplanes
AC 25-7A, Flight Test Guide for Certification of Transport Category Airplanes
AC 25.1309-1, System Design Analysis
AC 120-29, Criteria for Approving Category I and Category II Landing Minima for 14 CFR Part 121 Operators
Standard Operations Specifications Parts A and C,
FAA Order 8400.8, Procedures for Approval of Facilities for FAR Part 121 and Part 135 Category III Operations
FAA Order 8400.10, Air Transportation Operations Inspector’s Handbook
2.2. Definitions. A comprehensive set of definitions pertinent to Category III approach and landing and low visibility takeoff is included in Appendix 1.
Page 2
Within this AC, Runway Visual Range (RVR) values are specified in units of feet (ft.) unless otherwise noted (e.g., meters (m)).
Where visibility minima are stated in both feet and meters (e.g., RVR300 (75m)) using values other than those identified as "equivalent" in standard operations specifications, it is intended that the RVR value in feet apply to minima specified in feet, and the value in meters apply in states specifying their minima in meters.
Minima typically used for low visibility operations including a minima conversion table where applicable are provided in the operations specifications shown in Appendix 7.
In this AC, where the term “RNP Level” is used, it may be considered to be equivalent to the term “RNP Type” typically used in some current ICAO and other authority references. The term “RNP Level” is used in the U.S. to match various RNP approval documents (e.g., AFM’s) already in widespread use, and to reserve use of the term “RNP Type” for future anticipated RNP applications.
3. BACKGROUND.
3.1. Major Changes Addressed in this Revision. This AC includes additional Category III criteria or revised Category III criteria for use in conjunction with Head-up Displays, satellite navigation systems, low visibility takeoff guidance systems, Wide-body Fail Passive operations and use of Category III during certain engine inoperative operations.
This revision also updates and incorporates provisions of the former AC 20-57 into AC 120-28, since provisions of the former AC 20-57 are directly related to and dependent on criteria provided in this AC.
This revision incorporates changes resulting from the first steps toward international all weather operations (AWO) criteria harmonization taken by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), the European Joint Aviation Authorities (JAA), and several other regulatory authorities. Subsequent revisions of this AC are planned as additional all weather operations harmonization items (AHI) are agreed and completed by FAA and JAA, or internationally.
3.2. Relationship of Operational Authorizations for Category III and Airborne System Demonstrations. Takeoff and landing weather minima are approved through applicable operating rules, use of approved instrument procedures and issuance of operations specifications. Airworthiness demonstration of airborne equipment and systems is usually accomplished in support of operational authorizations on a one time basis at the time of Type Certification (TC) or Supplemental Type Certification (STC). Since operating rules continuously apply over time and may change after airworthiness demonstrations are conducted, or may be updated consistent with safety experience, additional Category III credit or constraints may apply to operators or aircraft as necessary for safe operations. Airworthiness demonstrations are based on the particular operational and airworthiness criteria in effect at the time a type design certification basis is established for a particular TC or STC.
Page 3
Subsequent operational authorizations may constrain capabilities originally demonstrated based on current operational regulatory policy and experience. The main body of this AC contains criteria related to operational approval and Appendix 2 and Appendix 3 are the primary source of airworthiness criteria. Nothing in this AC is intended to preclude an operator from proposing and demonstrating to the FAA the ability to operate to Category III minima with a different equipment configuration; or alternatively to an RVR minima lower than that presently described in this document.
3.3. Applicable Criteria. AC 120-28C, dated March 9, 1984, and AC 20-57A dated January 12, 1971 are canceled. Except as described below, new airworthiness demonstrations or operational authorizations should use criteria of AC 120-28D. Airworthiness demonstrations may use equivalent JAA criteria where agreed by FAA through the FAA/JAA criteria harmonization process.
In general, the provisions of the main body of this AC outline concepts, objectives, and provisions necessary for operators. The appendices contain definitions, abbreviations, airworthiness demonstration provisions typically applied in conjunction with type certification, technical information necessary for airworthiness or operational assessments (e.g., atmospheric/wind models, obstacle clearance criteria) and examples of operational authorizations (e.g., sample Operations-Specifications (OpSpecs)). Certain criteria related to airworthiness assessment are included in the main body of the AC primarily to address the status and eligibility of previously certificated in-service aircraft for current authorizations (e.g., status of service bulletin compliance for continued or new authorizations, demonstration provisions applicable to "inservice" aircraft).
Operators electing to comply with this AC's revised criteria may receive the applicable additional credit(s). Aircraft manufacturers, operators or modifiers may elect to demonstrate that their aircraft meet the revised criteria to seek additional credit for any particular operation (e.g., HUD installation) or for all operations addressed by this AC (e.g., incorporation of a general compliance statement related to AC 120-28D, instead of reference to the former canceled criteria of AC 120-28C). However, aircraft demonstrated to earlier criteria may continue to be approved for Category III operations in accordance with that earlier criteria, and applicants may continue to make reference to the fact that an earlier demonstration was based on that previous criteria (e.g., in the AFM). Aircraft manufacturers, modifiers or operators seeking authorization provided for only in this AC must, however, use applicable criteria of this AC (e.g., for RNP based missed approach obstacle criteria, meet pertinent provisions of Appendix 9). To get a particular authorization cited by this AC, the operator need only meet the provision or provisions applicable (e.g., RVR600 fail passive landing minima may be authorized per 4.3.8 for presently authorized airborne systems meeting previous criteria without regard to Appendix 3 criteria).
4. OPERATIONAL CONCEPTS.
4.1. Classification and Applicability of Minima. Landing minima are generally classified by Category I, Category II and Category III (e.g., see ICAO Annex 6 references, and the associated
Page 4
ICAO Manual of All Weather Operations DOC 9360/AN910, 2nd Edition, 1991). AC 120-29 (as amended) addresses Category I and II. This AC addresses Category III.
Takeoff minima are usually classified by RVR or meteorological visibility, and other factors (e.g., aircraft characteristics).
Although a wide variety of normal and non-normal situations are considered in the design and approval of systems used for Category III, Category III minima are primarily intended to apply to normal operations.
For non-normal operations, flightcrews are expected to take the safest course of action appropriate for the situation, including consideration of normal landing weather minima. When aircraft systems have been demonstrated to account for certain non-normal configurations (e.g., an approach with an engine inoperative) flightcrew may take into account this information in assessing the safest course of action.
4.2. Takeoff. Takeoff minimums are included in standard operations specifications. This AC addresses criteria for takeoff in low visibility conditions where additional aircraft equipment is provided to assist the pilot in a low visibility takeoff, or is required to assure safe operations when using minima below values acceptable for exclusive use of visual reference.
Standard OpSpecs list minima acceptable to FAA for manual control based exclusively on visual reference.
Authorization of takeoff minima below the level supported by use of visual reference alone requires use of a guidance system which has been demonstrated to provide an acceptable level of performance and satisfactory workload for the minima approved, with or without use of visual reference. The performance and workload assessment of such a system must have considered any compensation that may be introduced by the pilot for particular guidance system characteristics (e.g., coping with a slight localizer signal offset during initial runway alignment) or concurrent pilot use of the guidance system with limited or patchy visual references.
Systems intended to be used at or above the minima authorized for visual reference alone (e.g., as a supplement to manual control) may be used if demonstrated to be:
1) Safe in normal use, and
2) If there is no unacceptable increase in pilot workload or significant adverse effect on crew coordination, and
3) If the system is unlikely to introduce a significant hazard if a failure or degradation of the system itself occurs, and
Page 5
4) If the system is unlikely to introduce a significant additional hazard if other potential failures in the aircraft occur (e.g., engine failure, electrical component failure), and
5) A failure or anomaly in a NAVAID(s) used does not introduce a significant hazard.
Authorized minima for such systems may be no lower than that specified for manual control using visual reference alone.
If low visibility takeoff operations are predicated on the use of RNP, then the provisions applicable to RNP apply only following liftoff, after passing 35 ft. above the published elevation of the runway.
A proof of concept demonstration is necessary for initial authorization of takeoff minima less than RVR300 ft./75m.
Criteria for demonstration of systems eligible for takeoff minima below the level supported by use of visual reference alone are found in section 5.1.3 for operational authorization or Appendix 2 for systems proposed for airworthiness demonstration.
4.3. Landing.
4.3.1. Concepts and Objectives. Category III landing minima are classified as Category IIIa, Category IIIb or Category IIIc. Definitions of these categories are provided in Appendix 1. Visual conditions encountered in Category III operations range from visual references being adequate for manual control during rollout (e.g., Category IIIa) to visual references being inadequate even for taxi operations without special visual reference enhancements or suitable synthetic references. For any Category III operation, the airplane and external system requirements established (e.g., position fixing) should be compatible with any visual reference requirements that are specified.
Category III operations may be conducted manually using Flight Guidance Displays, or automatically using approved autoland system or with Hybrid Systems which employ both automatic and flight guidance elements. If the particular Flight Guidance Display depicts flight director or other command guidance it may be approved in accordance with this AC, or equivalent. Situational Flight Guidance Displays may be used if the Proof of Concept (PoC) is satisfactorily demonstrated. When an automatic system is to be the primary means of control the use of that system should not require pilot intervention. The means for crew intervention must be provided, however, in the unlikely event the pilot detects or strongly suspects inadequate system performance (e.g., the pilot determines that an automatic landing cannot be accomplished within the touchdown zone). If a Hybrid system is employed, then the primary mode of operation must be automatic to touchdown, with manual control used only as an alternate means to complete the operation.
To be approved for Category III operations, the airplane and its associated systems should be shown to be capable of safely completing an approach, touchdown, and rollout and permitting a safe go-around from any altitude to touchdown following any failure condition not shown to be extremely improbable.
Page 6
Cockpit design, instrumentation, annunciations and warning systems, should be adequate in combination to assure that the pilot can verify that the aircraft should touch down within the touchdown zone and safely rollout if the controlling visibility is reported at or above applicable minima. Systems based on automatic control to touchdown, or touchdown and rollout and manually flown flight guidance system (e.g., HUD), have been approved by FAA. Other concepts may be acceptable if Proof of Concept [PoC] testing can demonstrate an equivalent or greater level of safety as presently specified for approval of automatic systems (e.g., hybrid systems or vision enhancement systems).
To be approved for Category III operations, the airplane and its associated systems should be shown to be able to perform to the necessary level of accuracy, integrity, and availability. This is typically shown initially during airworthiness demonstration, is confirmed during the operational authorization process, and is monitored by the operator on a continuing basis.
Category III operations are predicated on meeting requirements for Category II, or equivalent, for that portion of the approach prior to 100' HAT (see the current version of AC 120-29 for approval of Category II).
If Category III operations are predicated on the use of RNP, then the provisions of this AC or any subsequent current version of AC120-29A, or other suitable FAA criteria for application of RNP are considered to be acceptable to apply to definition of any instrument approach procedure segment down to 100 ft. HAT.
Below 100 ft. HAT, the provisions of this or any subsequent version of AC120-28 are considered to be the applicable criteria to assure the necessary performance for landing, flare and rollout.
For a go-around and missed approach from DA(H), Alert Height (AH), or the end of the touchdown zone for a rejected landing, RNP provisions may be applied from the point of initiation of a go-around to completion of the applicable missed approach procedure, in accordance with provisions of this version of AC 120-29, any subsequent current version, or any other RNP criteria found acceptable to the FAA.
4.3.2. Fail Operational Category III Operations. A Fail Operational System is a system which after failure of any single component, is capable of completing an approach, flare and touchdown, or approach, flare, touchdown and rollout by using the remaining operating elements of the Fail Operational system. The failure effects of single components of the system, airplane or equipment external to the airplane which could have an effect on touchdown or rollout performance must be considered when evaluating Fail Operational systems. Fail Operational systems may be used to touchdown for Category IIIa (e.g., without a rollout system) or Category IIIb through rollout to a full stop. Use of a failoperational system to touchdown in conjunction with a rollout system that is not fail-operational is acceptable as long as a suitable minimum RVR is specified in the operations specifications, for rollout.
Page 7
This AC contains criteria for approval of minima as low as RVR150 using a fail-operational system for landing and rollout. Approval of minima less than RVR150 would require a proof of concept [PoC] demonstration.
Note: A landing system is considered to include each of the elements in the aircraft which are necessary to perform the landing and rollout function (e.g., flight control, hydraulic system(s), electrical system(s), sensors).
The required redundancy may be provided by multiple automatic landing systems, by multiple automatic landing and rollout systems, by redundant manual flight guidance systems, or by suitably redundant hybrid systems.
The reliability and performance of the required operational systems should be such that continued safe operation to landing, or landing and rollout, can be achieved following any failure condition occurring below the Alert Height that is not shown to be extremely improbable. Systems identified below and in 4.3.3 through sections 4.3.8, or equivalent, are considered to meet the intent of this provision.
Failure conditions which result in the loss or disconnect of all the redundant landing, or landing and rollout systems, occurring below the Alert Height, are permissible if the occurrence of these failure conditions is extremely remote and the loss or disconnect is accompanied by acceptable warning indications for the pilots. Airplanes which are demonstrated to meet the airworthiness assessments of Appendix 3 for fail operational systems are considered to meet these reliability and performance criteria.
The following are typical arrangements which may be acceptable for Fail Operational Systems:
1. Two or more monitored fail passive autopilots or integrated autopilot flight director systems each with dual channels making up an automatic fail operational system designed so that at least one autoflight system remains operative after the failure of one system, and the failed system is not used or cannot cause unacceptable autoflight system performance.
Note: Following a failure with this configuration, it is not intended that a landing be continued with flight director alone, unless a successful Proof of Concept demonstration has been completed.
2. Three autopilots or integrated autopilot flight director systems designed so that at least two remain operative after failure to permit comparison and provide necessary monitoring and protection while continuing to a landing.
3. A monitored fail passive automatic flight control system with automatic landing capability to touchdown and rollout, if applicable, plus an independent and adequately failure protected manual flight guidance system, suitable for landing and rollout with guidance provided for the flying pilot and monitoring displays for the non-flying pilot. A proof of concept demonstration would be necessary for this arrangement.
Page 8
4. Two independent and adequately monitored manual flight guidance systems with independent displays for the pilot flying and the pilot not flying, each capable of supporting a landing and rollout. A proof of concept demonstration would be necessary for this arrangement.
Aircraft meeting fail-operational requirements of Appendix 3 of this AC, or equivalent, for landing and rollout may be authorized for fail-operational Category III to the lowest currently applicable minima specified in Operations-Specifications for this type of system. As of the publication of this AC, the lowest authorized minima for U.S. operators are Touchdown, Mid, and Rollout RVR of 300ft within the U.S., or 75m internationally.
Aircraft previously demonstrated to meet acceptable fail-operational criteria of earlier AC’s or alternate criteria (e.g., suitable JAR criteria) may receive additional credit beyond those already authorized, as specified in provisions of this AC, through appropriate showing of compliance with applicable operational provisions of this AC, and subsequent amendment of applicable operations specifications. An example of aircraft in this category are those B767 or B757 aircraft having statements in the FAA approved AFM indicating they met all fail-op rollout provisions of AC 120-28B or AC 120-28C, except for certain rollout disconnect provisions. Since criteria of AC 120-28D are now revised to alternately address this condition, these aircraft are considered eligible to fully meet Appendix 3 provisions for fail-operational rollout and may be operationally authorized for landing minima accordingly (also see 4.3.8).
Aircraft with a fail operational landing system but without a rollout system, that were originally approved in accordance with AC 120-28, AC 120-28A, AC 120-28B or AC 120-28C, may typically be approved for minima not less than Touchdown Zone, Mid and Rollout RVR600. Eligibility for RVR600 requires compliance with appropriate current service bulletins in accordance with the manufacturer’s recommendations, and a determination by FAA that “in-service” operational performance of the system is acceptable.
Aircraft with a fail operational landing system and a rollout system, or a fail operational landing system and a fail passive rollout system originally approved in accordance with FAA “Special Conditions” for a rollout system, or criteria of AC120-28, AC120-28A, or AC120-28B are now considered to have rollout capability equivalent to fail operational and may typically be approved for minima not less than Touchdown Zone, Mid, and Rollout RVR300. Current models in this group found acceptable include the L1011, A300, DC10-30, certain DC10-10s or DC10-40s with suitably upgraded avionics equipment equivalent to currently FAA approved DC10-10s or -30s, and late model B747-200 or - 300 aircraft with appropriate versions of the triple channel SPZ-1 autopilot and a rollout system. For these aircraft, appropriate current service bulletin compliance should be reviewed and completed, and line operational performance of the system must be shown to be acceptable. However it is important to note that, as with other aircraft types, Category III authorization for some of these aircraft may be restricted to certain runway facilities since landing or rollout performance may not necessarily be
Page 9
acceptable due to site specific irregular underlying approach terrain, touchdown zone slope, or ILS beam characteristics.
4.3.3. Alert Height. Fail-operational Category III is based on use of an Alert Height (see Appendix I). An Alert Height is the height above a runway based on characteristics of the airplane and its Fail Operational System, above which a Category III approach must be discontinued and a missed approach initiated if a failure occurred in one of the redundant parts of the flight control or related aircraft systems, or if a failure occurred in any one of the relevant ground systems. Use of an Alert Height is consistent with the design philosophy which requires that an aircraft be capable of safely completing a touchdown and rollout (if applicable) following a failure occurring after passing the point at which the Alert Height is specified.
Operational Alert Heights must always be equal to or lower than that specified in the airworthiness demonstration, and may be specified at or below 200 ft. HAT. The Alert Height is specified by an operator of an aircraft and approved by the FAA. The operational Alert Height used must be consistent with the aircraft design, training, ground facilities, and other factors pertinent to the air carriers operation. Typically a minimum usable operational alert height is 50’HAT. However lower Alert Heights may be approved if there is an appropriate reason to do so (e.g., for certain types of hybrid systems).
Airworthiness demonstration of an Alert Height is as specified in Appendix 3. In order to assure the necessary reliability of aircraft systems, airworthiness demonstrations of Alert Height should be from an altitude of at least 200 ft. above the touchdown zone elevation.
4.3.4. Fail Passive Category III Operations. A Fail Passive System is a system which in the event of a failure, causes no significant deviation of aircraft flight path or attitude. The capability to continue the operation may be lost and an alternate course of action (e.g., a missed approach) may be required. A fail-passive system is the minimum capability system acceptable for Category III operation with a Decision Height not less than 50 ft. HAT.
Fail Passive Approach Operations are conducted with a decision height not lower than 50 ft., and are limited to RVR values which provide suitable visual reference to address normal operations as well as failure contingencies. Since a Fail Passive Category III system does not necessarily provide sufficient redundancy to successfully continue the approach and landing to touchdown following any failure in the flight control system not shown to be extremely remote, a DH is specified. A DH is established to assure that prior to passing that point the pilot is able to determine that adequate visual reference exists to allow verification that the aircraft should touchdown in the touchdown zone. If this visual reference is not established prior to passing DH, a missed approach must be initiated. After passing DH, a missed approach will also be initiated if visual cues are lost, or a reduction in visual cues occurs which prevents the pilot from continuing to verify the aircraft is in a position which will permit a landing in the touchdown zone. In the event of a failure of the airborne system at any point in the approach to touchdown, a
Page 10
missed approach is required. However, this provision does not preclude a pilot's authority to continue an approach if continuation of an approach is considered by the pilot to be a safer course of action.
Such a failure however, does not preclude continuation to a Category I or Category II minima if the necessary remaining elements of the aircraft system are operational and if the crew qualification addresses necessary action to continue such an approach are met. Any adjustments to approach minima or procedures made on final approach should be completed at a safe altitude (e.g., above 500 ft. HAT).
The need to initiate a go-around below 100 ft. AGL due to an airplane failure condition should be infrequent. In addition, an aircraft using a Fail Passive system for Category III should be shown to provide the capability to touch down in the touchdown zone or to complete a safe manual or automatic go-around from any altitude to touchdown following any failure condition not shown to be extremely improbable.
Typical arrangements which may be used to meet the requirements for Category III fail passive operations using a 50 ft. Decision Height include the following:
1. A single monitored automatic flight control system with automatic landing capability.
2. A fail operational automatic flight control system with automatic landing which has reverted to a Fail Passive configuration or has been dispatched in a fail-passive configuration.
3. A monitored flight guidance system (e.g., HUD) designed for manual control by the pilot flying, and for monitoring by the pilot not flying. Aircraft intended for Fail Passive Category III operations should have aircraft systems which meet the criteria specified in Appendix 3. Aircraft previously demonstrated to meet earlier Fail Passive criteria may continue to operate using Category III minima in accordance with approved operation specifications.
4.3.5. Decision Altitude (Height). For Category II and certain Category III procedures (e.g., when using a Fail-Passive landing system) a Decision Height (or an equivalent IM position fix) is used as the controlling minima. The "Altitude" value specified is considered as advisory. The altitude value is available for cross reference. Use of a barometrically referenced DA for Category III is not currently authorized for part 121, 129 or 135 operations at U.S. facilities.
A Decision Height is applied to all Fail Passive operations and is specified at certain locations where fail operational minima is authorized. For Category III, a Decision Height is usually based on a specified radio altitude above terrain on the final approach or touchdown zone. The Decision Height is established to assure that prior to passing that point the pilot is able to determine that adequate visual reference exists to allow verification that the aircraft should touch down in the touchdown zone.
For Category I, a DA(H) is specified as the minimum altitude in an approach by which a missed approach must be initiated if the required visual reference to continue the approach has not been
Page 11
established. The "Altitude" value is typically measured by a barometric altimeter or equivalent (e.g., Middle Marker) and is the determining factor for minima for Category I Instrument Approach Procedures. The "Height" value specified in parenthesis is typically a radio altitude equivalent height above the touchdown zone (HAT) used only for advisory reference and does not necessarily reflect actual height above underlying terrain. The DA element of a DA(H) is applicable to Category III only in the event that an approach is considered to revert to Category I or Category II minima following airborne equipment failure, ground facility status, or other similar condition permitting an approach to be conducted to pertinent Category I or II minima.
4.3.6. Go-Around Safety. An aircraft approved for Category III should be capable of safely executing a go-around from any point in an approach prior to touchdown with the aircraft in a normal configuration, or specified non-normal configuration (e.g., engine out if applicable). It is necessary to provide for go-around due to Air Traffic Services contingencies, rejected landings, loss of visual reference, or missed approaches due to other reasons. The evaluation of this capability is based on normal, or specified non-normal, Category III operations at the lowest controlling RVR authorized and should account for factors related to geometric limitations during the transition to go around, limited visual cues, auto-pilot mode switching and other pertinent factors. For aircraft in which a go-around from a very low altitude may result in an inadvertent touchdown, the safety of such a procedure should be established considering its effect on related systems, such as operation of auto spoilers, automatic braking systems, autopilot mode switching, autothrottle mode, reverse thrust initiation and other systems associated with, or affected by, a low altitude go-around.
Except for failure conditions shown to be extremely improbable, a safe go-around must be possible from any point on the approach to touchdown.
If an automatic go-around capability is provided, it should be demonstrated that a go-around can be safely initiated and completed from any altitude to touchdown. If the automatic go-around mode can be engaged at or after touchdown, it should be shown to be safe. The ability to initiate an automatic goaround at or after touchdown is not required.
4.3.7. Category IIIa. In accordance with ICAO definitions of Category III, Category IIIa operations may be conducted with either Fail Operational or Fail Passive systems. The lowest approvable landing minima for Category IIIa is RVR700 or a foreign equivalent of 200 meters.
Note: For certain Category III operations using fail passive systems that were formerly limited to RVR700, but now are eligible for authorization to RVR600, see paragraph 4.3.8 (Most Category III operations authorized for RVR700 prior to issuance of this AC are now eligible for authorization to RVR600, upon request of the operator for issuance of a revision to that operator's pertinent OpSpecs).
Category IIIa operations with fail passive systems are conducted using a 50 ft. Decision Height.
Page 12
Category IIIa operations using a fail operational system with a rollout control system are generally conducted using an Alert Height, and not a Decision Height. Visual reference is not a specific requirement for continuation of the approach or touchdown.
Category IIIa operations using a fail operational system without a rollout control system installed require establishment of suitable visual reference with the touchdown zone prior to touchdown.
For any of the above systems there should be a sufficient combination of information from flight instruments, annunciations, and alerting systems to assure that the pilot can verify that the aircraft should touch down within the touchdown zone, and safely initiate rollout.
Unless otherwise specified by FAA, aircraft having operation specifications authorizing RVR700 as of the effective date of this AC, may continue to use those minima without additional demonstration.
Aircraft demonstrated to meet airworthiness provisions of AC 120-28B or AC 120-28C for Fail Passive systems remain eligible for any previously approved operational authorization under provisions of this AC and do not require additional airworthiness demonstration. Aircraft previously having completed an airworthiness demonstration in accordance with AC 120-28C remain eligible for any operational authorization that was permitted by AC 120-28C.
Aircraft demonstrated to meet airworthiness criteria prior to AC 120-28B, and not currently authorized in operations specifications for Category III may be approved for new Fail Passive Category III operations on a case-by-case basis depending on facilities to be used, service bulletin compliance status and other relevant safety factors.
Aircraft, including wide body aircraft such as the DC-10, L1011 and B 747, which are authorized for fail-operational Category III, but have not been demonstrated to meet the provisions for Fail Passive systems shown in Appendix 3, may be approved for Fail Passive operations with landing minima limited to RVR1000 provided the following criteria are met:
1. The aircraft must be shown to be in compliance with relevant service bulletins for the applicable flight control system and displays.
2. An auto throttle system must be installed and operational.
3. The system must be shown to provide reliable auto land performance in line operations.
4. A demonstration using a simulator or aircraft must be completed for that operator and aircraft type, showing that the system and procedures applicable to Fail Passive operations can be practically applied for that air carrier’s operation.
Page 13
Wide body aircraft types not previously authorized or currently authorized by FAA to use minima less than RVR1000 based on a fail passive system must meet the airworthiness requirements of Appendix 3 or equivalent for any new authorization of minima less than RVR1000.
New aircraft types or derivative aircraft with new flight control system designs should be demonstrated in accordance with Appendix 3 for Fail Passive systems, or equivalent requirements, if fail passive authorization is sought.
4.3.8. Category IIIb. Category IIIb operations are usually conducted with fail operational systems. Fail passive landing systems may be used, but are limited to Category IIIb minima not less than touchdown zone RVR600 (175 m). Airborne systems used for Category IIIb authorized for landing below touchdown zone RVR600 (175 m) must include either a manual flight guidance or automatic rollout or control system for lateral steering which provides the means to control the aircraft until the aircraft slows to a safe taxi speed. Category IIIb operations based on fail operational systems require the use of systems which after passing Alert Height, are capable of the safe completion of the approach, touchdown, and rollout, following any failure conditions not shown to be extremely remote. When fail operational systems are used, they do not necessarily require that operating procedures specify that the approach must necessarily be continued after a failure.
Category IIIb operations based on fail passive landing systems meeting provisions of Appendix 3 of this AC, or equivalent, must use a decision height not less than 50 ft. HAT.
For Category IIIb operations based on fail operational systems, the availability of visual reference is not a specific requirement for continuation of an approach to touchdown. The design of flight instrument systems, annunciations, and alerting systems should be adequate to assure that the pilot can verify the aircraft should touch down within the touchdown zone, and rollout.
Category IIIb operations may be conducted to a touchdown zone RVR and relevant mid or rollout RVR not less than 600 ft. with a fail operational or fail passive landing system without a rollout control system.
Category IIIb operations may be conducted to a touchdown zone RVR of not less than 600 ft. and an relevant mid or rollout RVR not less than RVR400 with a fail operational or fail passive landing system and with any FAA approved rollout control system.
Category IIIb operations may be conducted to a touchdown zone, and relevant mid, and rollout RVR minima not lower than RVR400 (125 m) when using a fail operational landing system and a rollout control system shown to meet Fail Passive criteria of Appendix 3 (or earlier FAA criteria applicable to a rollout system).
Page 14
Category IIIb operations may be conducted to a touchdown zone RVR, and relevant mid, and rollout RVR minima not less than RVR150 (50 meters) with a fail operational landing system and a rollout control systems shown to meet the Fail Operational criteria of Appendix 3, or earlier equivalent criteria.
See NOTE below for criteria, and Section 4.3.2 above for examples of various aircraft types, systems, and minima which may be authorized.
NOTE: Since amended criteria is specified for fail operational rollout control systems in Appendix 3 of this circular, certain systems previously certificated using earlier criteria of AC120-28C or AC120-28B that at the time of certification were not considered fail operational due to certain conditions that were noted in the AFM as exceptions, but now are considered to meet fail operational criteria, may now be considered as fail operational for the purpose of authorizations under this paragraph.
Accordingly, systems considered to be eligible for this credit are those systems which otherwise previously met all provisions for a fail operational rollout control system as described in Appendix 3 of AC120-28C (or earlier AC 120-28A or B equivalent) except for provisions related to inadvertent control wheel autopilot disconnect and level of redundancy required for nosewheel steering function. Each of these provisions are now revised in Appendix 3.
Operators seeking additional allowable credit for these newly re-classified fail-operational rollout control systems may apply for corresponding minima adjustment through amended operations specifications. "Relevant" or "applicable" mid or rollout RVR is considered to be any transmissiometer report (or equivalent instrumentally derived RVR measurement) considered to be covering a portion of the runway where the aircraft is operating at a speed above a safe taxi speed.
A summary of the minima that may now be authorized based on the above criteria are shown below in table 4.3.8-1.
Landing System Type Rollout System Type TDZ RVR (ft)** Mid RVR (ft)** Rollout RVR (ft)** Fail Op or Fail Passive* No Rollout system 600 600 600
Fail Op or Fail Passive* Any FAA Approved
Rollout System
600 400 400
Fail Op* Fail Passive* 400 400 400
Fail Op* Fail Op* 150 150 150
Lowest Minima Authorized for Fail Operational or Fail Passive Landing Systems, or
Landing and Rollout Systems
Table 4.3.8 -1
Table 4.3.8-1 Notes:
Page 15
* Note: Fail Op denotes a Fail Operational Flight Guidance System Fail Passive denotes Fail Passive Flight Guidance System
** Note: RVR values are shown in U.S. facility units of feet and as Touchdown zone, Mid, and Rollout RVR values, but corresponding metric values or other designated RVR reporting locations may be applied internationally, if acceptable to the State of the Aerodrome.
Equivalent minima may be specified for systems demonstrated to meet earlier airworthiness criteria of AC 120-28B or AC 120-28C. Credit for systems demonstrated prior to AC 120-28B will be as designated in approved operations specifications or as designated by AFS-400 for new Category III applications using such aircraft.
4.3.9. Runway Field-Length.
a. The Runway Field-Length for Category III is as specified by section 121.195 for a wet runway, if each of the following conditions are met:
1. Anti-skid systems are operative (if installed for the aircraft type).
2. The runway surface braking action is expected to be at least "fair" or better (or equivalent Runway Condition Reading, James Brake Devise, or Tapley reading).
In the event that either of the above conditions are not met, the factor to be applied to the section 121.195b distance is 1.3, unless otherwise demonstrated to the FAA that a factor less than 1.3 is acceptable (e.g., due to other factors, such as the required use of an auto brake system).
b. Once airborne, additional consideration of Category III landing field length by the flightcrew is not required for normal operations. In the event of un-forecast adverse weather or if failures occur, the crew and aircraft dispatcher should consider any adverse consequences that may result from a decision to make a Category III landing (e.g., braking action reports). Category III operations should not normally be conducted with braking action less than "fair".
c. When auto brake systems are used for Category III, information must be available to the flightcrew to assist in making the proper selection of a suitable auto brake setting consistent with the field length available for landing and the runway condition, including braking action.
4.3.10. Landing System Sensors (NAVAID’s) and Aircraft Position Determination. Various landing system sensors (NAVAID’s) or combinations of sensors may be used to provide the necessary position fixing capability to support authorization of Category III landing weather minima. While certain navigation sensors (NAVAID’s) are installed and classified primarily based on landing operations, the sensors described in this section may also be used for takeoff, missed approach, or other operations (e.g., RNAV position determination). Regardless of the sensors, NAVAID’s, or combination of
Page 16
NAVAID’s used, the NAVAID’s and sensors must provide coverage for the intended flight path and for anticipated displacements from that flight path for normal operations, rare normal operations (e.g., winds and wind gradients), and for specified non-normal operations where applicable (e.g., "engine-out go-around" flight path). In addition, Category III authorizations should be consistent with the provisions or characteristics for specific sensors listed below in 4.3.10.1 through 4.3.10.3 unless otherwise accepted or approved by FAA.
4.3.10.1. Instrument Landing System (ILS). The ILS provides a reference signal aligned with the runway centerline and deviation signals when the airplane is displaced left or right of the extended runway centerline. The linear coverage area for this signal is approximately 3 degrees either side of the extended runway centerline from a point emanating at the far end of the runway. The ILS also provides a vertical flight path (nominally 3 degree descent angle) to a point in the landing zone of the runway. The vertical coverage is approximately 0.7 degrees on either side of the vertical reference path. ILS characteristics should be considered as defined in ICAO Annex 10, unless otherwise specified by FAA. U.S. ILS systems are classified by Type, as defined in FAA Order 6750.24 as amended (e.g., II/D/2).
4.3.10.2. Microwave Landing System (MLS). The MLS provides a reference signal aligned with the runway centerline and deviation signals when the airplane is left or right of the extended centerline. The linear coverage area is approximately 40 degrees either side of the extended runway centerline emanating from a point at the far end of the runway. The MLS provides a vertical flight path to the runway similar to ILS. MLS characteristics should be considered as defined in ICAO Annex 10, unless otherwise specified by FAA. U.S. MLS systems are classified by Type, similar to ILS.
4.3.10.3. GPS/GNSS Landing System (GLS). GLS is a landing systems based upon the Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS). For Category III operations the landing system typically includes a local area differential augmentation system in the vicinity of the runway for which a Category III procedure is specified. The local area system may serve one or more runways, or nearby airports, depending on its classification for each particular runway. The classification of a GLS service may be different for different runway ends (e.g., III/E/3 for Runways 14L and 14R, but I/D/1 for RW 22L). Desired path, centerline, and deviation signals as applicable, are computed by airborne avionics. The coverage area for GLS is typically at least within a 25 mile radius of a primary airport, but extended service volumes are permitted. GLS provides for both vertical and lateral flight path specification to the touchdown zone of the runway(s) served, and a lateral path for rollout or takeoff guidance. GLS characteristics should be considered as defined in ICAO Annex 10, unless otherwise specified by FAA (e.g., FAA accepted references to RTCA SC-159 MASPS).
U.S. GLS systems should be operationally classified by "Type" for each runway end served, similar to ILS (e.g., GLS II/D/2). The operational classification is intended to address at least the service provided in terms of “Type of service or performance level”, “area of service” relative to each specific runway served, and level of availability or continuity. As with ILS, the classification schema should not be specified in terms of specific minima Categories (e.g., Category III), since onboard aircraft equipment capability or other factors may determine actual minima to be authorized.
Page 17
GLS systems are intended to provide equivalent or better service to that provided by a U.S. Type I ILS, including: 1) Adequate guidance over the runway for takeoff or landing rollout (e.g., autoland), and 2) Vertical guidance on approach down to at least 100’HAT. GBAS local area augmentation systems (e.g., LAAS) are usually considered to support this objective. Wide area augmentation systems (e.g., WAAS, EGNOS) are typically considered to be RNAV systems, and are not alone considered to be GLS.
Authorization for use of GLS is for each specific air carrier, aircraft, and GLS system type until pertinent GLS international standards accepted by FAA are promulgated.
4.4. RNAV/Flight Management Systems (FMS). RNAV/Flight Management Systems (FMS) are typically used in conjunction with Category III Instrument Approach Procedures only for initial or intermediate approach segments, or for missed approach.
For departure, RNAV/Flight Management Systems (FMS) may be used for non-visual takeoff guidance after passing the height at which LNAV or VNAV may respectively be engaged or made active, or above 35' AGL, whichever is higher. Other applicable FAA criteria (e.g., section 121.189) must be addressed for takeoff. For development or authorization of departure procedures which follow completion of a low visibility takeoff, FAA Orders 8260.40A, 7100.1, or other applicable RNAV/RNP criteria should be consulted.
Procedures based on 3D or 2D RNAV may or may not include use of RNP. For RNP operations, see section 4.5 below.
4.5. Required Navigation Performance (RNP). A definition for Required Navigation Performance (RNP) is specified in Appendix 1. Standard Levels of RNP typically used for various initial, intermediate approach and missed approach segments for Category III procedures may be based on specific landing systems (e.g., ILS, MLS, or GLS), on multisensor RNAV (e.g., FMS with IRS, VOR, DME inputs), or on other aircraft navigation systems having FMS like capabilities (e.g., GPS Navigation Systems).
RNP applications used for a final approach segment supporting a Category III procedure are typically be based on use of a specific landing system sensor (e.g., ILS, MLS, or GLS), or on multisensor RNAV systems having suitable flight critical performance.
Aircraft/systems RNP capability is typically determined by assessing RNP total system error components, Path Definition Error (PDE), Position Estimation Error (PEE) and Flight Technical Error (FTE). In additional to total system error (TSE) components, associated assurance limits are considered to determine what levels of navigation performance may actually be achieved with integrity. Assessment may specify that certain RNP levels may only be achieved with flight director or autopilot coupled operation, or that for particular applications availability must be based on use of dual independent navigation systems (e.g., as with the/E equipment classification).
Page 18
4.5.1. Standard RNP Types. Standard values of RNP supporting initial, intermediate, or final approach segments, or missed approach segments applicable to Category III procedures are as specified in Table 4.5.1-1 below.
Table 4.5.1-1 STANDARD RNP TYPES APPLICABLE TO Category III
RNP Type Applicability/Operation
(Approach segment)
Normal Performance
(95%)
Containment
Value RNP 1 Initial/Intermediate/
Missed approach
+/- 1 nm +/- 2 nm
RNP 0.5 Initial/Intermediate/
Missed approach
+/- 0.5 nm +/- 1 nm
RNP 0.3 Initial/Intermediate/
Missed approach
+/- 0.3 nm +/- 0.6 nm
RNP levels as specified for lowest Category I
Final approach/ initial missed approach (but not below 200' HAT)
(See AC 120-29,
as amended
(See AC 120-29,
as amended)
RNP levels as specified for Category II
Final approach/ initial missed approach (but not below 100' HAT)
(See AC 120-29,
as amended)
(See AC 120-29,
as amended)
RNP 0.003/15 Final approach/ initial missed approach
(any altitude)
+/- 0.003 nm
+/- 15 ft. (*)
+/- 0.006 nm
+/- 30 ft. (*)
(*) Note: vertical accuracy does not apply below 100 ft. HAT - below 100 ft. HAT vertical performance is determined by applicable standards for touchdown performance.
RNP is a required navigation performance level described by the specification of a numeric value indicating the required navigation accuracy for a specific operation, typically specified laterally in nautical miles - e.g., RNP 1 is a Required Navigation Performance of ± 1 nautical mile (95% Probability).
RNP containment is specified as RNP(X) times two (i.e., RNP(X) x 2).
Standard RNP Levels are defined for lateral performance, or lateral and vertical performance, if applicable.
Regarding containment, the probability of exceeding the containment value without annunciation should be assessed by some acceptable method. If assessed during an airworthiness demonstration program during type design or STC, this probability should be considered to be at least remote (e.g., a major failure
Page 19
condition). If based on “fleet qualification” (e.g., use of criteria such as contained in RTCA DO-236 Appendix D for RNP) alternative methods, procedures or buffers may be used to assure protection of containment.
Operationally, containment is typically used in procedures or separation standards in conjunction with other operational verification procedures, other systems (e.g., TCAS, EGPWS), or operational buffers to satisfactorily address assurance of safe operations and contingencies. This is to provide for safety in the unlikely event operation within the containment region cannot be maintained.
In the event that operational procedures or other technical methods are not available to assure safety in the event of loss of containment, then potential for loss of containment situations may need to be addressed in a hazard assessment specifically keyed to an example of the intended application or operation. More demanding uses of containment may require a higher level of assurance or a more complex or comprehensive backup or contingency mechanism (e.g., use of an RNP Level for specification of a lateral path for Category III flare and rollout).
4.5.2. Non-Standard RNP Types. Non-Standard RNP Types are those RNP values other than as specified in paragraph 4.5.1. Non-Standard RNP Types are authorized by FAA on a case by case basis where an applicant has a demonstrated need for such use.
4.6. Flight Path Definition. The following parameters, path points, or definitions may be used as a technical basis for a variety of other references or terms eventually necessary to prepare or implement procedures or development criteria. This section is intended to provide a technical basis for preparation of operational concepts for use with RNAV and RNP based systems (e.g., to serve as a technical basis for preparation of procedures criteria, operations concepts, operational manuals, or operational authorizations). Actual procedural information, manuals, training materials and other documents used by operators, pilots, procedure developers or others who may need to apply this information may use simplified or summarized forms of this information, as necessary, to satisfy their particular operational requirements.
Note: The path points and segments addressed below are those considered necessary to support definition and operational use of systems intended for Category III. For commonality, their definition and use are intended to be consistent with Category I and Category II. It should be noted, however, that various GNSS or other RNAV applications or criteria currently use or propose use of other similar points or waypoints, use different terminology, or use different definitions for points (e.g., Landing Threshold Waypoint). Accordingly, since U.S. and international terminology and definitions for such points are evolving, it is important to confirm and assure suitability of each point used, for consistency of terminology, suitable definition, and suitable application.
Page 20
Landing and Rollout Flight Path - The following criteria specifies certain reference points and other criteria necessary to effectively implement landing and rollout operations using a landing system where the required flight path is not inherent in the signal structure of the navigation aid (e.g., satellite systems). The location of points used to describe the landing and rollout flight path are shown in Figure 4.6-1.
Runway Datum Point (RDP) - The RDP is used in conjunction with the FPAP and a vector normal to the WGS-84 ellipsoid at the RDP to define the geodesic plane of a final approach flight path to the runway for touchdown and rollout. It is a point at the designated lateral center of the landing runway defined by latitude, longitude, and ellipsoidal height. The RDP is typically a surveyed reference point used to connect the approach flight path with the runway. The RDP may or may not necessarily be coincident with the designated runway threshold.
Flight Path Alignment Point (FPAP) - The FPAP is used in conjunction with the RDP and a vector normal to the WGS-84 ellipsoid at the RDP to define the geodesic plane of a final approach and landing flight path. The FPAP may be the RDP for the reciprocal runway.
Flight Path Control Point (FPCP) - The FPCP is a calculated point located above the RDP in a direction normal to the WGS-84 ellipsoid. The FPCP is used to relate the vertical descent of the final approach flight path to the landing runway.
Datum Crossing Height [DCH] - The height (feet) of the FPCP above the RDP.
Glide Path Angle [GPA] - The glide path angle is an angle, defined at the FPCP, that establishes the descent gradient for the final approach flight path of an approach procedure. It is measured in the geodesic plane of the approach (defined by the RDP, FPAP, and WGS-84 ellipsoid’s center). The vertical and horizontal references for the GPA are a vector normal to the WGS-84 ellipsoid at the RDP and a plane perpendicular to that vector at the FPCP, respectively.
Glidepath Intercept Reference Point [GIRP] - The GIRP is the point at which the extension of the final approach path intercepts the runway.
Figure 4.6-1
Page 21
Datum Crossing Height (DCH)
Runway Datum Point (RDP)
Glidepath Intercept Reference Point (GIRP)
Flight Path Control Point (FPCP)
Flight Path Alignment Point (FPAP) η
η = Glide Path Angle
The locations established for, and the values assigned to, the RDP, FPCP, DCH and GPA should be selected based upon the operational need to establish the GIRP. Operational considerations include:
1. Path of wheels over threshold,
2. Need for coincidence with other aids and systems - visual and non-visual, or markings
2. Need for coincidence with other aids and systems - visual and non-visual, or markings
3. Runway characteristics (e.g., local slope in the touchdown zone, general runway upslope or downslope, runway lateral crown),
4. Actual displaced thresholds or multiple runway thresholds,
5. Actual clearways or stopways
6. Construction temporary requirements
6. Construction temporary requirements
Takeoff Flight Path. The flight path for low visibility takeoff (while on the runway) should be defined by the RDP and FPAP.
4.7. Engine Inoperative Category III. The basic concept addressing expected flightcrew response to non-normal situations, such as typically represented by an engine failure, is described in Section 6.1.8.
Page 22
Engine Inoperative Category III is specifically addressed because for some modern aircraft and systems it is possible to retain and address Category III operating capability, as an alternate configuration. This is to aid operators and pilots in planning for and selecting more desirable and fully considered landing airports that may be closer in distance or time, have less adverse weather in terms of icy or short runways with adverse winds, are better equipped to handle a diversion or emergency, or provide a timely return to land at a takeoff airport or a closer takeoff alternate airport, in the unlikely event of engine failure or other serious problem related to the engine failure.
With pre-planned engine inoperative Category III capability, airports and minima that otherwise may not be considered acceptable for use could be selected by the pilot or operator without having to subsequently justify its use based on emergency authority. This capability also has the advantage of allowing for full pre-assessment of the aircraft capability, and engine inoperative aircraft configurations (e.g., flap settings, electrical system capability, hydraulic system capability), approach procedure characteristics, missed approach performance and other factors that may be difficult to assess in real time if not previously assessed.
This capability also can permit an operator some additional flexibility in selecting alternate airports.
Accordingly Section 5.17 describes aircraft and airborne system criteria for credit for engine inoperative Category III capability. Sections 7.1.3 item 10, and 7.2.6 address crew qualification. Section 10.8 addresses operational authorization and selection and use of alternates.
5. AIRBORNE SYSTEMS.
5.1. General.
5.1.1. Airborne Systems. Airworthiness criteria for airborne systems intended to meet criteria in this AC are specified in paragraph 5.1.3 through 5.19 below for operational authorizations, or Appendix 2 for takeoff, or Appendix 3 for landing and rollout for airworthiness demonstration of new or modified aircraft types or systems.
Aircraft shown to meet provisions of Appendix 2 or 3 respectively, are considered to meet provisions of this section.
For aircraft approved using earlier versions of this AC, airworthiness criteria for airborne systems intended for Category III operations are as specified in criteria referenced by the approved AFM.
Airborne equipment listed in this section needs to be operative for Category III, in accordance with provisions of applicable standard Operations Specifications (OpSpecs) and Operations Specifications for that operator. Airframe manufacturers and individual operators may also include other optional equipment as part of the Category III configuration, however, that equipment does not need to be operative to conduct a Category III approach unless required by that operator's OpSpecs.
Page 23
Airborne systems making use of RNP capability for approach segments or missed approach segments should be approved in accordance with or consistent with any one or more of the following criteria or processes:
1) FANS I or FANS A systems approved through a certification program acceptable to FAA, or
2) Through reference to an acceptable standard such as RTCA DO-236 for RNP, or
3) Through reference to RTCA DO-236 Appendix D for “fleet qualification” of existing aircraft, or
4) Through other FAA or FAA accepted equivalent criteria for intended for application or approval of RNP (e.g., TERPS or PANS-OPS RNP provisions as adopted).
5.1.2. Non-Airborne Systems. Unless otherwise specified in the Appendices to this AC, NAVAID/landing system characteristics, including facility classification, should be considered as specified in Section 4.3.10 above and AC 120-29 for ILS, MLS or GLS (e.g., U.S. use of ICAO Annex 10 Criteria, FAA Order 6750.24 as amended, and the applicable NAVAID facility classification for Category III). NAVAID facility use is predicated on applicable ILS, MLS, or GLS Type classifications (e.g., ILS III/E/2, GLSII/D/2) or equivalent classification at non-U.S. facilities. Specific Navigation Services are addressed in Section 5.12.
5.1.3. Takeoff Guidance Systems. When takeoff minima are predicated on use of a takeoff guidance system, the takeoff guidance system should be demonstrated to meet provisions of this paragraph or provisions specified in Appendix 2 by an airworthiness demonstration. Takeoff guidance systems which have been shown to meet Appendix 2 by airworthiness demonstration and have a corresponding AFM reference are typically considered to meet requirements of this paragraph.
A takeoff guidance systems shall be demonstrated to show that the airplane will not deviate significantly from the runway centerline during takeoff while the system is being used within the limitations established for it. Compliance may be demonstrated by flight test, or by a combination of flight test and simulation. Flight testing must demonstrate repeatable performance, and cover those factors affecting the behavior of this airplane (e.g., wind conditions, ILS characteristics, weight, center of gravity). Compliance with the performance envelope should be demonstrated with pilots appropriately qualified to use the airborne system, and should not require extraordinary skill, training or proficiency.
Demonstrated winds should be 150% of the winds for which credit is sought, but not less than 15 knots of headwind or crosswind.
In the event that the airplane is displaced from the runway centerline at any point during the takeoff or rejected takeoff, the system must provide sufficient guidance to enable the "pilot flying", or the pilot in command who may assume control and become the "pilot flying", to control the airplane smoothly back to the runway centerline without significant overshoot or any sustained nuisance oscillation.
Figure 5.1.3-1 provides the performance envelope for evaluating takeoff command guidance systems for the following scenarios:
Page 24
a. Takeoff with all engines operating
b. Engine Failure at Vef - continued takeoff
c. Engine Failure just prior to V1 - rejected takeoff
d. Engine Failure at a critical speed prior to Vmcg rejected takeoff: (Vef < Vmcg)
Note: For that portion of the flight path following liftoff, the demonstrated lateral path may be adjusted for any effect of wind drift when showing compliance with the performance envelope below.
Airplane Speed
Failure/Continued Take-off
Runway
Centerline
VFAILURE
+ 7m
0
+ 14m
Airplane Speed
All Engines Take-off
Runway
Centerline
V1
VLOF
+ 7m
0
Airplane Speed
Failure/Rejected Take-off
Runway
Centerline
VFAILURE
+ 7m
0
+ 14m
h=35'
+ 14m
h=35'
STOP
FIGURE 5.1.3-1.
5.2. Airborne Systems for Category III Minima Not Less than RVR600. The following equipment in addition to the instrument and navigation equipment required by 14 CFR part 91 for IFR flight is the minimum aircraft equipment considered necessary for Category III:
Page 25
1. A redundant flight control or guidance system, demonstrated in accordance with Appendix 3, or for aircraft types previously demonstrated acceptable earlier criteria described in previous versions of AC 120-28 as amended, or acceptable international criteria, such as the JAR AWO.
Acceptable flight guidance or control systems include the following:
a. A Fail Operational or Fail Passive automatic landing system at least to touchdown, or
b. A Fail Operational or Fail Passive manual flight guidance system providing suitable head-up or head-down command guidance, and suitable monitoring capability at least to touchdown, or
c. A hybrid system, using automatic landing capability as the primary means of landing at least to touchdown.
d. Other system which can provide an equivalent level of performance and safety.
NOTE: For system concepts not currently approved by FAA or system concepts not addressed by Appendix 3, a proof of concept demonstration is required prior to either airworthiness or operational consideration for approval.
2. An automatic throttle or automatic thrust control system which meets Appendix 3, or appropriate earlier criteria as specified in an FAA-approved AFM. However, for operations with a 50 foot Decision Height, or other operations that have specifically been evaluated such as for engine inoperative landing capability, automatic throttles may not be required if it has been demonstrated that operations can safely be conducted, with an acceptable work load, without their use.
3. At least two independent navigation receivers/sensors providing lateral and vertical position or displacement information, typically with the first pilot's station receiving information from one and the second pilot's station receiving information from the other. The navigation receivers/sensors must meet the criteria specified in Appendix 3 or equivalent, or must meet an earlier acceptable criteria as specified in an FAA AFM (e.g., 2 ILS localizer and glide slope receivers meeting performance requirements of AC 120-28C; Appendix 1, paragraph 7a & b).
4. At least two approved radio altimeter systems which meet the performance requirements outlined in Appendix 3, or acceptable earlier criteria, as specified in an FAA AFM, typically with the first pilot's station receiving information from one and the second pilot's station receiving information from the other.
5. Failure detection, annunciation, and warning capability, as described in Appendix 3, or as determined acceptable by earlier criteria, such as 120-28C; Appendix 1, paragraph 7c & 7g, and specified in an FAA AFM.
6. Missed approach guidance provided by one or more of the following means:
Page 26
a. Attitude displays which include suitable pitch attitude markings, or a pre-established computed pitch command display.
b. An approved flight path angle display, or
c. An automatic or flight guidance go-around capability.
7. Suitable forward and side flight deck visibility for each pilot, as specified in 5.13.1.
8. Suitable windshield rain removal, ice protection, or defog capability as specified in 5.13.2.
5.3. Airborne Systems for Category III Minima Less Than RVR600.
5.3.1. Airborne Systems for Category III Minima Not Less than RVR400. The following equipment in addition to the instrument and navigation equipment required by part 91 for IFR flight is the minimum aircraft equipment considered necessary for Category III operations to minima less than RVR600 but not less than RVR400:
1. A redundant flight control or guidance system, demonstrated in accordance with Appendix 3, or for aircraft types previously demonstrated acceptable earlier criteria described in previous versions of AC 120-28 as amended, or acceptable international criteria, such as the JAR AWO.
Acceptable flight guidance or control systems include the following:
a. A Fail Operational landing system with a Fail Operational or Fail Passive automatic rollout system, or
b. A Fail Passive landing system (limited to touchdown zone RVR not less than RVR600) with Fail Passive rollout provided automatically or by a flight guidance system providing suitable head-up or head-down guidance, and suitable monitoring capability, or
c. A Fail Operational hybrid automatic landing and rollout system with compatible manual flight guidance system, using automatic landing capability as the primary means of landing.
d. Other system which can provide an equivalent level of performance and safety.
NOTE: For system concepts not currently approved by FAA or system concepts not addressed by Appendix 3, a proof of concept demonstration is required prior to either airworthiness or operational consideration for approval.
2. An automatic throttle or automatic thrust control system which meets Appendix 3, or appropriate earlier criteria as specified in an FAA-approved AFM. However, for operations with a 50
Page 27
foot Decision Height, automatic throttles may not be required if it has been demonstrated that operations can safely be conducted, with an acceptable work load, without their use.
3. At least two independent navigation receivers/sensors providing lateral and vertical position or displacement information, typically with the first pilot's station receiving information from one and the second pilot's station receiving information from the other. The navigation receivers/sensors must meet the criteria specified in Appendix 3 or equivalent, or must meet an earlier acceptable criteria as specified in an FAA AFM (e.g., 2 ILS localizer and glide slope receivers meeting performance contained in AC 120-28C; Appendix 1, paragraph 7a & b).
4. At least two approved radio altimeter systems which meet the performance criteria outlined in Appendix 3, or acceptable earlier criteria, as specified in an FAA AFM, typically with the first pilot's station receiving information from one and the second pilot's station receiving information from the other.
5. Failure detection, annunciation, and warning capability, as described in Appendix 3, or as determined acceptable by earlier criteria, such as 120-28C; Appendix 1, paragraph 7c & 7g, and specified in an FAA AFM.
6. Missed approach guidance provided by one or more of the following means:
a. Attitude displays which include calibrated pitch attitude markings, or a pre-established computed pitch command display,
b. An approved flight path angle display, or
c. An automatic or flight guidance go-around capability.
7. Suitable forward and side flight deck visibility for each pilot, as specified in 5.13.1.
8. Suitable windshield rain removal, ice protection, or defog capability as specified in 5.13.2.
5.3.2. Airborne Systems for Category III Minima Not Less than RVR300 (75 m). Visibility minima of RVR300 is applicable to those facilities reporting RVR in feet and which have appropriate reporting increments in feet. Visibility minima of 75m is applicable to those facilities reporting RVR in meters and which have appropriate reporting increments in meters.
In addition to the aircraft equipment specified in 5.3.1 above, the following equipment is required for Category III minima not less than RVR300 (75m):
1. A Fail Operational Automatic Flight Control System, or manual flight guidance system designed to meet fail operational system criteria, or a hybrid system in which both the fail-passive automatic system and the monitored manual flight guidance components provide approach and flare guidance to touchdown, and in combination provide full fail operational capability, and
Page 28
2. A fail operational rollout guidance or control system that can assure safe rollout to taxi speed consisting of either:
a. A fail operational automatic rollout control system or fail operational manual flight guidance rollout system, or
b. A hybrid system consisting of at least a fail passive automatic rollout system and a compatible Fail Passive manual flight guidance rollout control system demonstrated in accordance with Appendix 3; (may be approved for operations not less than RVR300), or
3. Suitable flight instruments, annunciations, or crew procedures which can reliably detect and alert the flightcrew to abnormal lateral or vertical flight path performance during an approach to touchdown, or abnormal lateral performance during rollout.
5.3.3. Airborne Systems for Category III Minima Less than RVR300 (75 m). In addition to the aircraft equipment specified in 5.3.2 above, the following equipment is required for Category III minima less than RVR300 (75m):
1. A Fail Operational Automatic Flight Control System, or manual flight guidance system designed to meet fail operational system criteria, or a hybrid system in which both the fail-passive automatic system and the monitored manual flight guidance components provide approach and flare guidance to touchdown, and in combination provide full fail operational capability, and
2. A fail operational automatic, manual, or hybrid rollout control system.
5.4. Automatic Flight Control Systems and Automatic Landing Systems. Automatic Flight Control Systems or Autoland Systems considered acceptable for Category III, include:
1) Those systems meeting pertinent criteria of Appendix 3,
2) Those systems meeting acceptable earlier FAA criteria which have already been and currently are approved for use through operations specifications (whether or not specifically referenced in AFM provisions), or
3) Those systems meeting other equivalent criteria (e.g., JAR AWO), found acceptable to the FAA.
5.5. Flight Director Systems. Characteristics of Flight Director Systems (head down or head up) used for aircraft authorized for Category III should be compatible with any characteristics of the autopilot or autoland system used. Flight control systems which provide both autopilot control and flight director information may or may not display flight director commands as appropriate for the system design and operator requirements. Regardless of whether Flight Director commands are provided,
Page 29
situational information displays of navigation displacement must also be provided to both flightcrew members. To assure that unacceptable deviations and failures can be detected, the displays must be appropriately scaled and readily understandable in the modes or configurations applicable.
"Flight director systems" may be considered as "fail passive" if after a failure, the flight path of the aircraft does not experience a significant immediate deviation due to the pilot following the failed guidance before the pilot detects the failure and discontinues using the guidance.
5.6. Head-up Display Systems. Head-up Display systems used as the basis for a suitable Category III authorization must provide guidance for one or both pilots as appropriate for the system design. If information is provided to only the flying pilot, then appropriate monitoring capability must be established for the non flying pilot. Monitoring tasks must be identified, and the non flying pilot must be able to assume control of the aircraft in the event of system failure or incapacitation of the pilot using the Head-up Display (e.g., for a safe go-around or completion of rollout). Head-up Display Systems acceptable for Category III must meet provisions of Appendix 3, or acceptable earlier criteria specified by the FAA and referenced in an AFM.
"Head-up Display systems" may be considered as "fail passive" if:
1. After a failure, the pilot using the system or pilot monitoring the system is made aware of the failure in a timely manner, and
2. The flight path of the aircraft does not experience a significant immediate deviation from the intended path due to the pilot following the failed guidance before the pilot flying or pilot monitoring detects the failure, and the pilot flying discontinues using the guidance.
5.7. Enhanced/Synthetic Vision Systems. Enhanced/Synthetic Vision Systems based on millimeter wave radar or other such sensors may be used to assure the integrity of other flight guidance or control systems in use during Category III operations. They must be demonstrated to be acceptable to FAA in a proof of concept evaluation and they must otherwise be in accordance with Appendix 3. Use of Enhanced/Synthetic Vision Systems for purposes other than establishing the accuracy or integrity of flight guidance system performance must be demonstrated to be acceptable through proof of concept testing prior to identification of specific airworthiness and operation criteria.
5.8. Hybrid Systems. Hybrid systems (e.g., a fail passive autoland system used in combination with a monitored HUD flight guidance system) may be acceptable for Category III if each element of the system alone is shown to meet its respective suitability for Category III, and if taken together, the components provide the equivalent performance and safety to a non-hybrid system as specified for the minima sought (e.g., fail operational Category IIIb).
Hybrid systems with automatic landing capability should be based on the concept of use of the automatic landing system as the primary means of control, with the manual flight guidance system serving as a backup mode or reversionary mode.
Page 30
Manual rollout flight guidance capability must be provided for hybrid systems which do not have automatic rollout capability. Such manual rollout capability must have been shown to have performance and reliability at least equivalent to that of a fail passive automatic rollout system.
Any transition between hybrid system elements (e.g., control transition from autoland use to manual control HUD use, or for response to failures) must be acceptable for use by properly qualified flightcrews (e.g., qualified in accordance with part 121, SFAR 58, or equivalent JAA criteria, as applicable, and standard industry practices). Transitions should not require extraordinary skill, training, or proficiency.
For any system which requires a pilot to initiate manual control near or shortly after touchdown, the transition from automatic control prior to touchdown to manual control using the remaining element of the hybrid system (e.g., HUD) after touchdown must be shown to be safe and reliable.
For hybrid systems, operational procedures following failure of the automatic system or flight guidance system prior to touchdown may require that the pilot initiate a go-around, even though the aircraft using a hybrid system must have been demonstrated as being capable of safely completing a landing and rollout following a failure of one of the hybrid system elements below alert height.
A hybrid system may be approved for Category III if it is shown to meet the criteria specified in Appendix 3 when approved through an airworthiness demonstration process. Alternately, a hybrid system may be acceptable for Category III if it is determined to meet applicable airworthiness criteria for each element of the system separately (e.g., separately meets Category III criteria for autoland and HUD), and in addition, a successful operational suitability demonstration is completed using the individual system elements together as a hybrid system. If acceptability is determined through an operational demonstration process, the individual elements of the hybrid system must be shown to be compatible for both normal and nonnormal operations, and the combined system must be shown to have the necessary performance, integrity, and availability appropriate for the operations intended.
An operator may receive approval to use an automatic landing system and a manual flight guidance system as a Hybrid System provided, (a) each system individually meets appropriate airworthiness assessments, and (b), that operator conducts a successful operational demonstration showing the hybrid system's capability to meet applicable provisions of this section.
For hybrid systems used for Category III an Alert Height of 50' or higher should be used unless otherwise approved by the FAA AFS-400.
5.9. Instruments and Displays. Flight instrument and display presentations related to Category III, including attitude indicators, EADI’s, primary flight displays, EHSI’s, HIS’s, or other such navigation displays must provide pertinent, reliable and readily understandable information for both normal and nonnormal conditions related to Category III landing and missed approach.
Page 31
Alert Height and/or Decision Height indications must be readily understandable, appropriately highlighted, and not be compromised by effects such as typical underlying terrain on the final approach path, and other annunciations or automatic audio call-outs. In addition, instruments and displays should provide appropriate indications considering terrain characteristics identified in Appendix 3 Section 6.3.4. Controls for altitude or height alerts used for minima determination or alert heights should use standard indications such as RH for radio height (or RA for radio altitude) and BARO for barometric altitude, rather than operational designations such as DH or MDA. Use of the designation RH or RA for height referenced values, or BARO for barometric altitude referenced values for controls or displays do not preclude related use of display symbology color changes or use of flashing alphanumeric symbology as the aircraft descends below a specifically referenced height or altitude value.
Situation information displays of navigation displacement must be available to both flightcrew members, and must be appropriately scaled and readily understandable in presentations or mode of display used. Instrument and panel layouts must follow accepted principles of flight deck design.
5.10. Annunciations. Annunciations must be clear, unambiguous, and appropriately related to the flight control mode in use. The mode annunciation labels should not be identified by landing minima classification. For example, LAND 2, LAND 3, Single Land, Dual Land, etc., are acceptable mode annunciation labels, whereas, Category II, Category III, etc., should not be used. Aircraft previously demonstrated for Category III which do not meet this criteria may require additional operational constraints to assure the correct use of minima suited to the aircraft configuration. In addition, mode annunciation labels must be consistent with other annunciations in the cockpit, and with the airplane documentation.
5.11. Automatic Aural Alerts. Automatic Aural Alerts (e.g., automatic call-outs, voice callouts) of radio altitude, or call-outs approaching landing minimums, or call-outs denoting landing minimums must be consistent with the design philosophy of the aircraft in question. However, any automatic call-outs used should not be of a volume or frequency that interferes with necessary flightcrew communications or normal crew coordination procedures. Recommended automatic call-outs include a suitable alert or tone as follows:
1. At 500 ft. (radio altitude), approaching minimums and at minimums, and
2. Altitude call-outs during flare, such as at "50" ft., "30" ft. and "10" ft., or altitudes appropriate to aircraft flare characteristics. Low altitude radio altitude call-outs, if used, should appropriately address the situation of higher than normal sink rate during flare, or an extended flare which may be progressing beyond the touchdown zone.
5.12. Navigation Sensors. Various navigation sensors may be acceptable to support Category III operations as specified in Section 4.3.10. ILS localizer and glideslope signals are the primary means currently used for the determination of deviation from the desired path for Category III operations. Criteria for acceptable ILS and MLS localizer and glide-slope receivers are included in Appendix 3 or in earlier acceptable criteria used by FAA for previous demonstrations of systems for Category III. Other
Page 32
navigation sensors, such as GNSS, or DGNSS, may be used individually or in combination to satisfy the necessary accuracy, integrity and availability for Category III if proof of concept demonstrations are successfully completed and operational experience at Category I and Category II minimums is acceptable. Navigation sensors other than ILS must meet equivalent ILS performance or appropriate RTCA or EUROCAE criteria, unless otherwise authorized.
Appropriate marker beacon information, or equivalent, must be displayed to each pilot for the outer, middle and inner markers. Appropriate substitutes for marker beacons may be authorized by the FAA for Category III based upon the use of suitable GNSS/DGNSS capabilities, or DME.
5.13. Supporting Systems and Capabilities.
5.13.1. Flight Deck Visibility. Suitable forward and side flight deck visibility for each pilot should be provided as follows:
a. The aircraft should have a suitable visual reference cockpit cutoff angle over the nose for the intended operations, at the intended approach speeds, and for the intended aircraft configurations, as applicable (e.g., flap settings),
b. The aircraft's flight deck forward and side windows should provide suitable visibility for taxi and ground operations in low visibility, and
c. Placement of any devices or structure in the pilots visual field which could significantly affect the pilot's view for low visibility operations must be acceptable (e.g., HUD drive electronics, sunvisor function or mountings).
5.13.2. Rain and Ice Removal. Suitable windshield rain removal, ice protection, or defog capability should be provided as specified below:
a. Installation of rain removal capability is required (e.g., windshield wipers, windshield bleed air).
b. Installation and use of windshield hydrophobic coatings, or use of equivalent rain repellent systems which meet pertinent environmental standards are recommended.
c. Installation of windshield anti-ice or de-ice capability is required for aircraft intended to operate in known icing conditions during approach and landing.
d. Installation of at least forward windshield defog capability is recommended for aircraft subject to obscuration of the pilot's view during humid conditions.
Page 33
Aircraft subject to obscuration of the windshield due to rain, ice, or fogging of the pilot's view which do not have protection, or which do not have adequate protection may require operational limitations on the conditions in which low visibility operations are conducted.
5.13.3. Miscellaneous Systems. Other supporting systems should meet appropriate criteria compatible with Category III Operational Objectives. Applicable criteria may include criteria as specified in Appendix 3, criteria as specified in basic airworthiness requirements applicable to U.S. certificated aircraft, or equivalent, or operational criteria for IFR flight. Regarding supporting systems, “In-service aircraft” or “new production” aircraft may meet or continue to meet criteria previously found acceptable for Category III operation for supporting systems for those aircraft. Supporting systems for Category III are considered to include, as applicable: Instruments, radar altimeters, air data computers, inertial reference units, attitude and heading gyros, instrument switching, flight deck night lighting, landing lights and taxi lights, position lights, turnoff lights, recognition lights, GPWS or EGPWS, flight data recorders or other low visibility related aircraft systems pertinent to a particular type.
Any GPWS or EGPWS systems interfaces (e.g., glide slope deviation warning) should be compatible with and should not interfere with the Category III Operations to be conducted (e.g., for engine inoperative Category III Configurations). For multimode capable systems for Category III (e.g., MMR), interfaces with GPWS or EGPWS for each MMR mode (e.g., ILS, MLS or GLS) should be consistent.
For Flight Data Recorders (FDR’s) or Quick Access Recorders (QAR’s), it is recommended that operators consider appropriate flight data recorder requirements for incident or event analysis when addressing provisions for Category III. It is recommended that any data recorders installed provide sufficient capability for recording of parameters applicable to flight guidance system performance for use with Category III operations. Typical parameters of interest and appropriate sample rates are those found in Appendix 8 applicable to Irregular Terrain Assessment.
5.14. Go-Around Capability. Regardless of the flight guidance system used an appropriate goaround mode/capability should be provided. A go-around mode/capability must be able to be selected at any time during the approach to touchdown. The go-around mode/capability should provide information for a safe discontinuance of the approach at any point to touchdown, if activated prior to touchdown. If activated at a low altitude where the aircraft inadvertently touches the ground, the goaround mode should provide adequate information to accomplish a safe go around and not exhibit unsafe characteristics as a result of an inadvertent touchdown. Inadvertent selection of go-around after touchdown should have no adverse effect on the ability of the aircraft to safely rollout and stop.
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 311 passages shown