Order 9120.1A Federal Aviation Administration Anti-Drug Compliance Program Inspection Handbook
This document is cancelled. Cancelled by 9120.1B. Check the official source before relying on it.
Text read by OCR from a scanned file (1 of 270 pages). Check the original, as some words may be misread.
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION ORDER FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION NUMBER Aerospace Medicine Policy 9120.1A
Effective Date: 05-23-2008
SUBJ : Drug and Alcohol Compliance and Enforcement Inspector Handbook
The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Office of Aerospace Medicine (AAM) has prepared this order for Drug Abatement Division (AAM-800) personnel to follow when inspecting and investigating the drug and alcohol testing programs of aviation industry employers, contractors, and individuals for compliance with the provisions of 49 CFR part 40, “Procedures for Transportation Workplace Drug Testing Programs;" 14 CFR part 121, appendix I, “Drug Testing Program;" and appendix J “Alcohol Misuse Prevention Program."
Unless otherwise directed by the Drug Abatement Division Manager, inspectors and investigators must adhere to the procedures in this order. The FAA invites comments and suggestions from those who use the order. Input should be submitted to:
Federal Aviation Administration Office of Aerospace Medicine Drug Abatement Division (AAM-800) 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. Washington, D.C. 20591
TEilton Frederick E. Tilton, M.D.
Federal Air Surgeon
Distribution: A-WXY (Drug Abatement) 3 Initiated By: AAM-820
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Table of Contents Chapter 1. General Information 1. Purpose of this Order … 4 2. Audience … 4 3. Where Can I Find this Order? … 4 4. What this Order Cancels … 4 5. Inspection Authority … 4 6. Objectives of the Inspection and Investigation Process … 4 7. Who Do We Inspect? … 4 Chapter 2. Inspections 1. General … 7 2. Inspection Scheduling … 7 3. Preparation for the Inspection … 9 4. Travel Requirements … 10 5. Inspection Work Plan … 10 6. Pre-Inspection Team Meetings … 11 7. On-Site Inspection Activities … 11 8. Evidence Collection … 16 9. Documentation of Inspection Results … 17 10. Inspection Conclusion … 17 11. Reporting Inspection Activities … 18 Figure 2-1. Sample Letter of Notification (LON) … 21 Figure 2-2. Inspection Lead Guide … 29 Figure 2-3. Sample Work Plan … 30 Figure 2-4. Inspection Inbriefing/Outbriefing Guide … 32 Figure 2-5. Meeting Attendance List … 33 Figure 2-6. Document/Record Review Guide … 34 Figure 2-7. Sample Certifications of Authenticity … 37 Figure 2-8. Return-to-Duty Process Flowchart … 38 Figure 2-9.
Federal Drug Testing Custody and Control Form (CCF) Process Flowchart … 39 Figure 2-10. Employee Interview Guide … 40 Figure 2-11. Sample Witness Statement Form … 42 Figure 2-12. Sample Outbriefing Report … 44 Figure 2-13. Inspection Correspondence Flowchart … 46 Figure 2-14. Sample Letter of Investigation (LOI) … 47 Figure 2-15. Sample Letter of Correction (LOC) … 49 Figure 2-16. Sample Warning Notice (WN) … 52 Figure 2-17. Sample Letter of No Action (Insufficient Evidence) … 53 Figure 2-18. Sample Letter of No Action (Stale Complaint) … 54 Chapter 3. Investigation 1. General … 55 2. Sources of Allegations … 55 3. Investigations of a Company … 56 4. Investigations of Individuals Who Perform Safety-Sensitive Functions … 56
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Chapter 4. Voluntary Disclosures 1. General … 57 2. Procedures … 57 Figure 4-1. Sample Letter to Certificate Holder (Disclosed Issue Was Not a Violation) … 59 Figure 4-2. Sample Letter of Acknowledgment (LOA) … 60 Figure 4-3. Sample Letter of Correction (LOC) … 62 Figure 4-4. Sample Letter #1 Denying Voluntary Disclosure … 63 Figure 4-5. Sample Letter #2 Denying Voluntary Disclosure … 64 Figure 4-6. Sample Inspector/Investigator Analysis … 65 Chapter 5. Administrative Information 1. Authority to Change this Order … 66 2. Background … 66 3. References … 66 Appendix A. Inspection Checklist … A-1 Appendix B. Standard Operating Procedures (SOP) For Conducting Review of Service Agents ....B-1 Appendix C. Random Testing Job Aid … C-1 Appendix D. Acronyms … D-1
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Chapter 1. General Information 1. Purpose of this Order. This order documents the procedures used by Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) drug and alcohol compliance and enforcement inspectors and investigators to assess the compliance of aviation industry employers with the requirements in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR). Specifically, the regulatory requirements including the Department of Transportation’s (DOT) 49 CFR part 40, “Procedures for Transportation Workplace Drug and Alcohol Testing Programs;” the FAA’s 14 CFR part 121, appendix I, “Drug Testing Program,” and appendix J, “Alcohol Misuse Prevention Program;” and other relevant Federal Aviation Regulations. This order is used in conjunction with FAA’s “Compliance and Enforcement Program” (Order 2150.3B) to ensure that inspections and investigations are conducted accurately, fairly, and consistently throughout the Drug Abatement Division. 2. Audience. All Drug Abatement Division personnel. 3. Where Can I Find this Order?
You can find this order on the MyFAA Employee Web site: https://employees.faa.gov/tools_resources/orders_notices/. This order is available to the public at http://rgl.faa.gov. 4. What this Order Cancels. This order cancels Order 9120.1, FAA Anti-Drug Program Compliance Inspector Order, dated January 26, 1994. 5. Inspection Authority. The Omnibus Transportation Employee Testing Act of 1991 (49 USC §§ 45101-45107) and the FAA’s general statutory safety authority outlined in 49 USC §§ 106(g) and 44701 provide the authority to conduct the inspections and investigations described in this order. 6. Objectives of the Inspection and Investigation Process. Ensuring compliance with the drug and alcohol testing regulations is the primary objective of the inspection and investigation process. The safety of the traveling public and integrity of the inspection and investigation process form the foundation of every inspection.
The regulations and the inspection and investigation processes balance the privacy interests of aviation employees with the safety mandate to detect and deter illegal drug use and alcohol misuse. Inspections and investigations must be conducted in a constructive, ethical, unbiased, and professional manner. Implementation of the procedural safeguards within Federal regulations and this order will ensure these objectives. 7. Who Do We Inspect? We inspect the following parties in accordance with the drug and alcohol testing regulations, 14 CFR part 121, appendices I and J, and 49 CFR part 40:
a. Employers. Part 40 defines an employer as “A person or entity employing one or more employees (including an individual who is self-employed) subject to DOT agency regulations requiring compliance with this part. The term includes an employer’s officers, representatives, and management personnel. Service agents are not employers for the purposes of this part.” Appendices I and J define an employer as:
(1) A part 119 certificate holder with authority to operate under parts 121 and/or 135;
(2) Sightseeing operators conducting flights under 14 CFR § 91.147; and
05/23/2008 9120.1A
(3) Air traffic control facilities not operated by the FAA, or by or for the U.S. Military. An employer must ensure that individuals hired to perform safety-sensitive functions, directly or by contract (including subcontract at any tier), are subject to drug and alcohol testing. Employers are responsible for all actions of its officials, representatives, and service agents in carrying out the requirements of the testing regulations.
b. Contractors. The appendices define a contractor as, “an individual or company that performs a safety-sensitive function by contract for an employer or another contractor.” There are two options for drug testing contractors: (1) The contractor obtains and implements its own drug and alcohol testing programs. If the contractor chooses this option, it must implement the programs as if it were the employer.
(2) The employer includes the contractor under its own drug and alcohol testing programs.
c. Service Agents. Part 40 defines a service agent as, “Any person or entity, other than an employee of the employer, who provides services specified under this part to employers and/or employees in connection with DOT drug and alcohol testing requirements.”
(1) A Consortium/Third-Party Administrator (C/TPA) is a service agent that may implement all or portions of the testing program for an employer.
(2) Service agents may provide the following services:
(a) Urine drug collections, as specimen collectors
(b) Breath alcohol testing, as breath alcohol technicians (BAT)
(c) Alcohol saliva testing, as screening test technicians (STT)
(d) Laboratory1
(e) Medical review officer (MRO) functions
(f) Substance abuse professional (SAP) functions As part 40 prescribes, service agents are required to comply with all aspects of the regulations. The roles and responsibilities of a service agent are addressed under subpart Q of part 40. Inspections or investigations of any employer may include a review of its service agent’s practices and procedures. The employer is responsible for compliance with the regulations even when using a service agent. Therefore, a service agent’s failure to comply with the regulations may result in violations against the employer.
1 The Department of Health and Human Services is responsible for monitoring certified laboratories.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
A service agent may be subject to a public interest exclusion (PIE), as described under subpart R of part 40, for egregious violations of the regulations. If an inspection or investigation results in allegations of egregious violations of the regulations by a service agent, the inspector must immediately report this information to his/her Compliance and Enforcement (C&E) Center Manager. The C&E Center Manager must forward the information to the Special Investigations and Enforcement Branch Manager in Washington, DC.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Chapter 2. Inspection
1. General. A successful inspection entails accomplishing a sequence of five interrelated activities. This sequence begins with inspection scheduling; proceeds through detailed planning, completion of on-site inspection activities, and reporting of inspection results; and concludes with post-inspection follow-up activities. Inspections are executed according to this chapter and the procedures established under the Quality Management System (QMS) of ISO AAM-800-003. Failure to follow these procedures may result in a corrective action report, as described in the ISO procedure. The Drug Abatement Division has established an inspection checklist, which contains the drug and alcohol regulations in question format. The checklist may be found under Appendix A of this order and in the Compliance and Enforcement Tracking Subsystem (CETS). This checklist must be followed by all inspectors and investigators during each inspection. Deviations from the inspection checklist, including the creation of a personal checklist, are prohibited. 2. Inspection Scheduling.
The FAA employs a variety of inspection activities to ensure companies comply with the drug and alcohol testing regulations. Prior to the beginning of the calendar year, the inspection weeks are published in CETS. Before every quarter, the Drug Abatement Division’s management team composes a quarterly inspection schedule based on ISO process AAM-800-004, Drug Abatement’s Strategic Compliance Monitoring Plan1 (SCMP), and recommendations from Division personnel. The C&E Center Managers and Field Operations Branch Manager are responsible for assigning inspectors to an inspection team and appointing the team’s inspection lead. When scheduling, the C&E Center Manager will identify whether the inspection is required to be comprehensive (full) or focused and announced or unannounced. Additionally, inspectors and investigators will be assigned to participate in high impact, special emphasis, and service agent inspections. Inspectors and investigators are required to access his/her schedule in CETS.
a. Comprehensive (Full) Inspections. Comprehensive inspections are thorough reviews of all aspects of employers’ drug and alcohol testing programs. Although we may sometimes focus emphasis on specific areas based on information concerning potential problems, the overall format of such inspections is standardized in accordance with this order. In some cases, the comprehensive inspection may be conducted without advance notice to the employer. The determination as to whether a comprehensive inspection will be announced or unannounced is made by the Drug Abatement Division, Field Operations Branch, or C&E Center Manager.
b. Focused Inspections. Under certain circumstances, focused inspections, which are narrow or limited in scope, may be conducted in response to a specific problem. Problems may be identified from any of a variety of information sources, including analyses of prior inspection results, annual testing reports, individual or union complaints, or other alternative means. For example, FAA headquarters may receive complaints concerning improper collection procedures. In that case, an inspection focusing on the employer’s collection procedures may be conducted. Focused inspections may involve a single employer or entity, as in the example above, or a representative group of employers if information indicates that a problem is widespread.
1 The Strategic Compliance Monitoring Plan (SCMP) is the Drug Abatement Division’s policy for scheduling inspections.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
A focused inspection must include the employer’s administrative and quality assurance activities and mandatory testing (i.e., pre-employment, random, post-accident, reasonable cause/suspicion, return to duty, and follow-up). The determination as to whether a focused inspection will be announced or unannounced is made by the Drug Abatement Division, Field Operations Branch, or C&E Center Manager.
c. Announced Inspections. An announced inspection requires advance notification to employers. This notification is accomplished when the inspection lead faxes or mails a letter of notification (LON) informing an employer/contractor of an upcoming inspection (see sample LON in Figure 2-1). E-mail notification is not permitted. All LONs and attachments must be generated using the CETS template, and they must also be documented in CETS. Send LONs to the employer as far in advance as possible, but no later than two weeks before the inspection. The inspection lead encloses the following documents with the LON:
(1) A list of records and documents that should be available for review. (2) A request for the employer’s points of contact (POCs). (3) The anticipated on-site schedule of inspection activities. Prior to the inspection, the inspection lead ensures that the POC information has been received from the employer and updated in CETS. The inspection team is prohibited from coaching employers or distributing unauthorized documents to them at anytime.
There may be instances in which an employer, after receiving an LON, will question the need for an inspection, because it has ceased operations under 14 CFR § 119.63, but continues to hold a certificate (i.e., 121 or 135). Regardless of whether an employer that holds a certificate is exercising the privileges of its certificate, it must be available for inspection. If the employer advises the FAA that it has ceased its operations, the inspector/investigator must contact the employer’s Principal Operations Inspector (POI)/Principal Maintenance Inspector (PMI) to determine whether the employer has surrendered its certificate. That information must then be given to the C&E Center Manager for a determination as to whether the employer will be inspected. If an employer, which has ceased operations under 14 CFR § 119.63 but has retained its certificate, is unwilling to be inspected, it must contact its POI/PMI to surrender its certificate. The inspector/investigator must follow-up with the POI/PMI to ensure that this has been accomplished.
d. Unannounced Inspections. Unannounced inspections are essential to an effective compliance program. Each inspector is responsible for conducting unannounced inspections during the fiscal year.
(1) C&E Center Managers may schedule an unannounced inspection for any inspector during any inspection week.
(2) Inspection teams may conduct an unscheduled unannounced inspection, as time allows, which require the inspector to locate employers/contractors or service agents in their assigned geographical areas to inspect on an unannounced basis.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
(3) Preparations for unannounced inspections might include contact with the local Flight Standards District Office (FSDO) to ascertain that the employer is still operating and has an active certificate.
(4) Inspection leads inform the C&E Center Manager(s) and other teams in the geographical area, if possible, before conducting unscheduled inspections, to preclude multiple inspection attempts at the same employers/contractors.
(5) For all unannounced inspections, the inspection lead or team must not contact the employer in advance of the inspection.
e. High Impact Inspections. High impact inspections are conducted by multiple teams of inspectors and investigators from two or more Drug Abatement offices during a one or two week period. This approach permits the concentration of inspector and investigator resources in a planned geographic area and maximizes visibility for the Drug Abatement Program. By involving inspectors and investigators from two or more offices, high impact inspections promote consistency within the inspection process and the application of the regulations, provide cross-training, and permit managers to directly observe and assess an inspector’s/investigator’s performance. During high impact inspection weeks, a meeting is scheduled for inspectors, investigators, and managers to meet and discuss program issues. These discussions provide management with topics to be covered in future inspector and investigator training or identify a need for guidance and/or policy development.
f. Special Emphasis Inspections. Special emphasis inspections are defined as inspections that are scheduled to focus on one element of the regulations at a national level.
g. Service Agent Inspections. Service agent inspections specifically focus on MROs, C/TPAs, collectors, and BATs. Service agent inspections are independent inspections and are not related to a specific company inspection. The standard operating procedures (SOP) for service agent inspections are in Appendix B of this order.
h. Inspection Schedule Changes and Cancellations. While all efforts are made to maintain the schedule as is, at times it is essential to the program to make necessary changes. All requests to change the final inspection schedule must be submitted through the C&E Center Manager to the Field Operations Branch Manager in Washington, DC. Once an inspector’s schedule is established, the inspection planning must begin. Prior to canceling an inspection, the inspector must contact the C&E Center Manager. When a scheduled inspection is cancelled, the cancellation must be documented in CETS. 3. Preparation for the Inspection. The inspection lead is responsible for all planning of the assigned inspections. He/she has a critical role in accomplishing the goals of the inspection, ensuring that all critical aspects of an inspection, including planning and reporting, are accomplished according to established procedures (see inspection lead guide in Figure 2-2).
a. The inspection lead examines CETS and the drug and alcohol enforcement history of each employer to find past noncompliance issues.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
b. At a minimum, each inspection will include a review of mandatory testing records (i.e., pre- employment and random testing; positive drug tests, alcohol violations, and refusals) and the records specified in 49 CFR § 40.25. The inspection lead determines if additional areas require evaluation, based on the past enforcement history of the employer, such as previous investigations, voluntary disclosures, legal enforcement actions, etc.
c. Each team member must bring the following inspection tools:
• Copy of the regulations • Inspection checklist • Forms (in/outbriefing sheet, witness form) • Laptop • Evidence certification stamp • Office supplies (note pads, paper clips, stapler, etc.) d. The inspection lead notifies the C&E Center Manager if additional personnel are needed or if a comprehensive inspection is necessary.
4. Travel Requirements. Although the inspection lead is responsible for making travel arrangements, such as lodging and rental cars, for each of their assigned inspections, each inspector and investigator is responsible for adhering to the following travel requirements:
a. Inspectors and investigators must adhere to the FAA Travel Policy (FAATP), which is available on the FAA’s Employee Web site.
b. Whenever possible, inspectors and investigators will arrive in the inspection city at approximately the same time. All travel and lodging preparations must be confirmed at least one week prior to the inspection, unless schedule changes preclude this.
c. Inspectors and investigators will conserve time and fiscal resources. For instance, inspectors and investigators will lodge near inspection sites, when possible. The FAATP states, “You must exercise the same care in incurring expenses that a prudent person would exercise if traveling on personal business.” The Policy further states, “You are responsible for excess costs and any additional expenses that you incur for personal preference or convenience. FAA will not pay for excess costs resulting from circuitous routes, delays, or luxury accommodations or services unnecessary or unjustified in the performance of official business.”
d. Travel must be arranged so that inspections begin Monday at 1:00 PM and end at noon on Friday. Consequently, it may be necessary for the inspector/investigator to travel on the Sunday prior to and the Saturday after the inspection. 5. Inspection Work Plan. Each inspector must submit an inspection work plan to the C&E Center Manager, Team Coordinator(s), and secretary/program assistant of his/her center no later than Wednesday of the week prior to inspections (see sample work plan in Figure 2-3). The work plan will contain businesses to be inspected, along with their POCs and telephone numbers. Service agent information will include the name of the employer associated with them.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
6. Pre-Inspection Team Meetings. The inspection lead will hold a meeting before the inspection to help ensure a smooth, professional inspection. These meetings must occur prior to arriving at the inspection site. During the pre-inspection team meeting, the inspection lead will:
a. Provide the past enforcement history of the employer to all members of the inspection team; b. Assign one or more of the following inspection areas to each inspection team member: Administrative and Quality Assurance; Specimen Collection; Breath Alcohol Collection; MRO Activities; SAP Activities; Employee Assistance Program (Education and Training); and Recordkeeping and Reporting;
c. Establish his/her responsibility for the inbriefing, outbriefing, CETS entry, and record reviews; and
d. Confirm each inspection team member’s responsibility to inform the inspection lead immediately of any out-of-compliance issues or evidence. 7. On-Site Inspection Activities. It is critical, and mandatory under ISO procedures, to ensure that each inspection is conducted according to the Drug Abatement Division’s inspection protocol. During each inspection, the following requirements must be adhered to:
a. Conduct. All division personnel will conduct themselves professionally and must:
(1) Maintain decorum in speech, dress, and behavior; (2) Treat their team members and employer representatives with respect; (3) Avoid socializing with any individual associated with an employer’s inspection, including service agents, in accordance with the Ethics Regulations (5 CFR part 2635);
(4) Avoid discussing internal FAA activities, e.g., anticipated changes in policy, procedures, or rulemaking, with employers and service agents;
(5) Avoid discussing pending enforcement matters pertaining to current or previous inspections and investigations;
(6) Avoid conversations regarding other operators; and (7) Bring inspection issues to the attention of the inspection lead. b. Inbriefing. The inspection lead will conduct the inbriefing with the employer and the inspection team members (see inspection inbriefing/outbriefing guide in Figure 2-4).
(1) The inspection lead makes introductions, circulates a sign-in sheet (see Figure 2-5), and explains the inspection process.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
(2) At the conclusion of the inbriefing, the inspection lead should invite questions or comments from the employer and other inspection team members.
c. Administrative and Quality Assurance Interview. At the conclusion of the inbriefing, the inspection lead begins the interview with the company representative (program manager or designated employer representative (DER)) regarding the drug and alcohol testing programs. Using the checklist, the questions must include, but are not limited to, the following:
(1) Types of employees subject to testing; (2) Procedures for conducting all types of testing; (3) Notification procedures; (4) Employer responsibilities; (5) Use of service agents; and (6) Actions following verified positive drug tests, alcohol violations, and refusals.
All information provided during the interview must be verified during the record review and evidence collection.
d. Drug and Alcohol Testing Records Review. Records are the most common form of evidence used to verify the statements of the employer’s representative (see document/record review in Figure 2-6). As an example, an employer may provide the inspection team with a spreadsheet that includes dates of hire, transfer, and pre-employment testing. The inspection team must verify the spreadsheet information by assembling the source documents (personnel action forms, custody and control forms (CCF), etc.) that pertain to each item on the spreadsheet. The inspection team must not request the employer to generate a spreadsheet for the purpose of the inspection.
(1) Inspection leads and team members will take part in record review activities and enter their findings in the inspection results section of CETS.
(2) Inspectors/investigators are responsible for reviewing, copying, and certifying documents, as assigned by the inspection lead. The inspector/investigator certifies a document by noting on the back of each page when, where, and from whom the document was obtained. This can be accomplished with the certification of authenticity (see Figure 2-7). Documents should be certified at the inspection site whenever possible.
(3) All testing records must be reviewed for the time period established by the C&E Center Manager and inspection lead prior to the inspection. Depending on the circumstances, the time periods may include the past two years, since the last inspection, or the last six months.
(4) Records to review and document, if applicable, include the following categories:
05/23/2008 9120.1A
(a) Positive Drug Test and Alcohol Violation Records. Inspectors/investigators must review all verified positive drug test results and alcohol violation results, except those that have already been investigated by the Special Investigations and Enforcement Branch (AAM-830) or should have been reported to AAM-830. Inspectors/investigators must also review the records that document the employee’s removal from a safety-sensitive function. The employer has the authority to terminate or rehabilitate the employee prior to his/her return to safety-sensitive functions. If the employee is returned to safety-sensitive functions, the inspection team must review all return-to-duty records. These records may include the SAP reports, return-to-duty test result, and follow-up test results.
(b) Part 67 Medical Certificate Holders. If the employer fails to report a refusal, a violation involving the misuse of alcohol, or a verified positive test result by a part 67 medical certificate holder to the Federal Air Surgeon (through the Drug Abatement Division), the inspection lead will contact the C&E Center Manager immediately and the C&E Center Manager will notify the Special Investigations and Enforcement Branch Manager. Inspectors must not investigate, comment, or discuss the alleged violation with the company or individual.
(c) Refusal Records. Inspectors must review all records concerning refusals to submit to testing, including walk-aways, adulterations, substitutions, etc., as defined in 49 CFR part 40. However, if the refusal was by an individual who holds a part 61, 63, 65, or 67 certificate, the matter must be referred to the Special Investigations and Enforcement Branch for investigation. The employer has the authority to terminate or rehabilitate the employee prior to his/her return to safety-sensitive functions. If the employee is returned to safety-sensitive functions, the inspection team must also review all return-to-duty records. It is important that the C&E Center Manager be immediately notified about a suspected failure on the part of the employer to report a refusal by an airman who holds a part 61, 63, or 65 FAA certificate. The C&E Center Manager will, in turn, report this information to the Special Investigations and Enforcement Branch Manager.
(d) Return-to-Duty Testing Records. Return-to-duty tests are conducted prior to returning an employee to a safety-sensitive function after a verified positive drug test, an alcohol misuse violation, or a refusal. The objective of these tests is to ensure that those who have committed such violations are alcohol or drug-free prior to returning to the performance of safety-sensitive functions. These tests occur after the SAP reports that the individual has successfully complied with the prescribed education and/or treatment. Inspectors/investigators must conduct a thorough review of these records, including: (1) documentation of the triggering event (drug positive, alcohol misuse violation, or refusal to submit to testing), (2) SAP reports (initial and follow-up evaluations, including the follow-up testing schedule), (3) return-to-duty CCFs/breath alcohol testing forms and verified drug test results/confirmed alcohol test results, and (4) documentation that the employee was returned to safety-sensitive functions and placed into the random drug and alcohol testing pools. A flowchart of the return-to-duty process is shown in Figure 2-8.
(e) Follow-up Testing Records. The SAP establishes a written follow-up testing plan after the individual successfully complies with his/her education and/or treatment. The required follow-up tests are conducted after an employee passes the return-to-duty test and has been returned to the performance of safety-sensitive functions. Similar to the return-to-duty testing, the objective of these tests is to ensure that individuals, who have committed violations involving
05/23/2008 9120.1A
the misuse of alcohol, a verified positive drug test result, or the refusal to submit to a drug or alcohol test, are compliant with the regulations governing the use of alcohol or prohibited drugs. Inspectors/investigators must conduct a thorough review of these records, including: CCFs/breath alcohol testing forms and verified drug test results/confirmed alcohol test results.
(f) Pre-employment Testing Records. Pre-employment testing is directly tied to aviation safety, in that it is the gateway to safety-sensitive positions. Historically, preemployment testing has resulted in the highest rate of verified positive results, demonstrating that such tests are effective in detecting illegal drug use. Pre-employment alcohol testing is optional, but if an employer orders an alcohol pre-employment test for one potential hire, all other new hires/transfers to safety-sensitive functions must also be pre-employment alcohol tested.
Pre-employment testing records could include personnel position descriptions, personnel action forms, payroll records, internal company hiring and transfer reports, CCFs, and MRO reports. In addition to reviewing the records, the inspector/investigator should interview any individual whose records, if questionable, need to clarified or confirmed. Interviews may be the only evidence available to prove a hire/transfer date, or identify other evidence to be gathered, such as maintenance logs, flight logs, or other performance documentation showing the date safetysensitive functions were performed. Documentation of performance would be used to show aggravating circumstances in an impending legal enforcement action.
(g) Random Testing Records. It is essential for inspectors and investigators to have a thorough knowledge of what comprises a random testing program. Appendix C of this order further explores random testing regulations, including minimum annual rate, selection methodology, excusal policies and over-selection, notification and testing procedures, and testing frequency. Records that could be of use when inspecting an employer’s random testing program are: (1) random drug and alcohol selection lists, (2) a listing of who was, or is, in the random pool during the covered period, (3) documentation that employees in the pool perform safetysensitive functions, (4) dates employees were added or deleted, (5) notification procedures, including notifications to out-lying locations, (6) documentation of whether employees proceeded immediately to the collection site after notification of selection, (7) CCFs, (8) verified drug test results, (9) breath alcohol testing forms with the alcohol test results, and (10) verification that the employer is satisfying the minimum testing rate that is published in the Federal Register.
(h) Reasonable Cause/Reasonable Suspicion Testing Records. Reasonable cause/suspicion testing is critical in the detection of employees reporting for or performing duties while under the influence of drugs and/or alcohol. Employers/contractors must ensure that supervisors are trained to make a testing determination. Inspectors/investigators must review all reasonable cause/suspicion testing records, including: (1) documentation of the event that led to testing, (2) documentation of supervisory training and the material covered, (3) CCFs, (4) verified drug test results, and (5) breath alcohol testing forms with the alcohol test results.
(i) Post-Accident Testing Records. A post-accident test occurs when an employee’s performance may have contributed to an aviation accident or cannot be completely discounted as a contributing factor to the accident. Inspectors/investigators must review all post- accident testing records including: (1) documentation of the accident, (2) information regarding the circumstances that led to the determination whether or not to test the employee, (3) CCFs,
05/23/2008 9120.1A
(4) verified drug test results, (5) breath alcohol testing forms with the alcohol test results, (6) documentation on why alcohol testing was not conducted within 2 hours and/or 8 hours of the accident, and (7) documentation that drug testing was conducted within 32 hours of the accident.
(j) Drug and Alcohol Records Check. Inspectors/investigators must examine all drug/alcohol records check forms during inspections, e.g., records relating to 49 CFR § 40.25(j), regarding whether applicants for safety-sensitive functions had a previous positive test result or refusal at another DOT employer during the past two years. In addition, the inspectors/investigators should make all attempts to interview any individual whose records, if questionable, need to be clarified.
e. Other Elements of an Inspection. In addition to the above elements, the inspection is divided into the following remaining sections:
(1) Collector and BAT. Collector and BAT evaluations may include:
(a) A simulated collection (both drug and alcohol) (see Figure 2-9 for a description of the CCF process);
(b) Review of collector, SST, and BAT records pertaining to qualification training and proficiency demonstration;
(c) Review of CCFs and alcohol testing forms; (d) Review of areas of noncompliance or concerns noted in previous inspections; (e) Inspection of all of the employer’s collection sites, which may include a medical facility, a mobile facility (e.g., a van), a dedicated collection facility, or any other location that meets the requirements of the regulation; and
(f) Records of equipment checks and calibrations.
(2) MRO. MRO evaluations may include:
(a) An interview with the MRO to verify his/her knowledge of the regulations; (b) Records pertaining to credentials, qualification training, and continuing education; and (c) Records pertaining to non-negatives (such as positives, refusals, and invalid tests) and negatives.
(3) SAP. SAP evaluations must include:
(a) The SAP's records pertaining to credentials, qualification training, and continuing education; and
(b) Records for compliance with the return-to-duty requirements.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
f. Service Agent Issues Discovered. If any collector, laboratory, MRO, or SAP issues/discrepancies are discovered, regardless of the employer, the inspector/investigator should collect all the evidence and report to the C&E Center Manager. Any egregious noncompliance discoveries should be reported to the C&E Center Manager, who then notifies the Special Investigations and Enforcement Branch Manager. 8. Evidence Collection. Evidence collection is the most critical element of the inspection. Inspectors/investigators must review all evidence relevant to an alleged noncompliance issue whether it proves or disproves a suspected item of noncompliance by the employer. This evidence must answer the questions about what happened, who was involved, and where, when, and why it occurred. The following describes different types of evidence and how each type of evidence should be handled, per Order 2150.3B.
a. Physical evidence consists of tangible objects, such as specimen collection materials or computer software programs relating to random testing. Inspectors/investigators must exercise care in handling physical evidence so that damage, loss, or alteration does not occur.
b. Witness interviews may be used to prove noncompliance and may be helpful in leading the inspector/investigator to other people who have direct knowledge or documentation of the issue.
(1) When possible, interview all witnesses who may be aware of a noncompliance issue.
(2) Witness accounts should be written and signed by the author, who may be the witness or the inspector/investigator. Witnesses should be informed that they are not under oath.
(3) The interview must be conducted in a professional manner with consideration for the following (see employee interview guide in Figure 2-10 and sample witness statement in Figure 2-11):
(a) Plan the interview and questions in advance.
(b) Be attentive and take notes.
(c) Maintain control of the interview.
(d) Ask direct, relevant, and open-ended questions.
(4) Inspectors and investigators will prepare a record of interview when outlining the interview/conversation conducted with witnesses or alleged violators (Note: The record of interview job aid is located in Appendix A (Figure A-3) of FAA Order 2150.3B). It should only state what the witness provided and it must not include the inspector’s/investigator’s personal views and/or opinions. A record of interview is necessary if a witness declines to provide a statement.
(5) Inspector/investigator statements are used to document findings that are not available in witness statements, technical publications, logbooks, and manuals, etc. They are also used to document a violation that is observed by the inspector/investigator or to capture an interview when a witness is unwilling to sign a record of interview. Inspector/investigator statements must
05/23/2008 9120.1A
include the date, time, location, and contact information of those present. They must be personally signed and dated by the inspector/investigator and must not include his/her personal views and/or opinions.
9. Documentation of Inspection Results. In preparation for the outbriefing, each inspection lead will, as soon as possible, enter his/her documentation of the inspection results into CETS. The following documentation must be entered into CETS in full detail:
a. Update of Company Profile. Any new information concerning the company, such as additional locations, company representatives, service agents, etc., must be added to its profile.
b. Outcome of Areas Reviewed and Discovered Issues. The results of an inspection should be noted with the following:
(1) Out-of-compliance items are noted when it is established that an alleged violation occurred. It is not sufficient to document only a few noncompliance items to show a pattern. All discovered issues must be documented. For example, if one checklist item was out of compliance on multiple occasions, then each occasion must be listed. Documentation of each out-of-compliance item must include a full description of what happened, who was involved, where and when it occurred, and any information on why it occurred.
(2) Concerns are noted when there are issues discovered that are not a violation, but may lead to a violation if the employer and/or service agent fails to resolve the issue. For example, if a collector has never dealt with a shy-bladder situation, he/she may be asked to explain the shy-bladder procedures as described in 49 CFR § 40.193. If the collector is unfamiliar with these procedures, this will be noted as an area of concern.
(3) Open items are noted when the issue cannot be resolved without clarification from management, or the team cannot agree on a specific item. These items are revisited after a determination is made in coordination with the C&E Center Manager and the inspection lead. 10. Inspection Conclusion. The inspection lead will meet with the inspection team to assure that all applicable items on the inspection checklist were covered and appropriate documentation was gathered, in accordance with this chapter. At this time the team will review and agree on all issues of noncompliance, concerns, or open items. If there is disagreement between the team on a particular item(s), the inspection lead must inform the employer at the outbriefing that the item(s) will be left open and addressed later. The inspection lead should document the inspection results in CETS prior to the outbriefing, if possible.
a. Outbriefing. The inspection lead is responsible for the outbriefing (see inspection inbriefing/outbriefing guide in Figure 2-4 and the sample outbriefing report in Figure 2-12).
(1) All members of the inspection team should attend and actively participate. (2) The inspection lead circulates a sign-in sheet (see Figure 2-5).
05/23/2008 9120.1A
(3) The inspection lead apprises the employer of the noncompliance items and concerns that were found. The inspection lead resolves any discrepancies between the information the inspectors/investigators have gathered and the employer’s understanding of the issue(s). There will be no display of disagreement among team members at the outbriefing.
(4) The inspection lead should encourage the employer to institute immediate corrective action(s) or agree that corrective action will be taken by a specific date.
(5) Inspectors/investigators must not discuss any possible enforcement actions related to the inspection.
(6) The inspection lead should also use this opportunity to educate the employer if it appeared during the inspection that there was a lack of understanding about the regulations. Inspectors/investigators will refrain, however, from interpreting regulations or discussing possible enforcement actions.
b. Following the outbriefing, the inspection team should gather all records and materials and leave the company.
(1) Do not leave anything behind, for instance, papers, folders, extraneous copies of documents.
(2) It is not appropriate to socialize with employers’ representatives or service agents, as this might give the appearance of a conflict of interest.
c. The inspection lead must hold a post-inspection meeting with the inspectors/investigators to discuss lessons learned and to ascertain that all documentation has been gathered and certified. If the outbriefing report has already been entered into CETS, the inspection lead should have each inspector/investigator approve and initial the outbriefing report. 11. Reporting Inspection Activities.
a. No later than 4 in-office working days after the inspection, each inspection lead must ensure that the information gathered is entered into CETS thoroughly and accurately. Specifically:
(1) Resources tab (i.e., date and time of inspection); (2) Updates to company information (i.e., contacts, locations, etc.); (3) Identifying out-of-compliance items, areas of concern, and undecided items; (4) Violation description(s); (5) Evidence collected; (6) Programs tab (i.e., drug and alcohol program self-administered or C/TPA and random protocol information); and
05/23/2008 9120.1A
(7) Interviews (all interviewees identified and a synopsis of their statements).
b. When an inspection results in no items of noncompliance, this is indicated in CETS and no further correspondence is sent to the employer. In this event, the inspection lead should let the company representative know that no further documentation will be sent.
c. When an inspection identifies items of noncompliance, further correspondence is prepared by the inspection lead using CETS (see inspection correspondence flowchart in Figure 2-13).
(1) Letter of Investigation (LOI). When an inspection results in an LOI, it must be prepared through CETS. This will generate an enforcement investigative report (EIR) file number. The LOI, which is the first step in preparing an EIR, must describe the items of noncompliance (see sample LOI in Figure 2-14). The inspection lead must provide a draft LOI and the outbriefing report to the Team Coordinator and/or C&E Center Manager within 4 in-office working days of returning from the inspection. The LOI and outbriefing report are either returned to the inspection lead for changes or approved. If the correspondence is returned to the inspection lead for changes, the review is documented under the Milestones Section in CETS and the process begins again. After the Team Coordinator and/or C&E Center Manager approves the LOI, he/she must enter the final sign-off into CETS in accordance with the Team Coordinator/C&E Center Manager Standards. Once the LOI is sent, the inspection lead prepares the 2150-5 form, except for the final action, and enters it into the EIS through CETS.
(2) Enforcement Decision. Once the LOI response is received, the inspection lead must determine the appropriate type of enforcement action to be taken by using the Enforcement Decision Tool (EDT), which is in Appendix F of FAA Order 2150.3B. If the evidence gathered during the inspection will not support an administrative or a legal enforcement action, the inspection lead would recommend that no action is taken. The inspection lead should discuss his/her recommended action with the Team Coordinator or C&E Center Manager.
(a) Administrative Action. A letter of correction (LOC) or warning notice (WN) is used when an administrative action is appropriate. An LOC serves the same purpose as a WN, except the LOC is used when there is agreement with the company that corrective action acceptable to the FAA has been taken, or will be taken, within a reasonable time (see samples of an LOC in Figure 2-15 and a WN in Figure 2-16). The inspection lead must provide a draft of the LOC/WN to the Team Coordinator and/or C&E Center Manager within 45 in-office working days of returning from the inspection. The LOC/WN is either returned to the inspection lead for changes or approved. If it’s returned for changes, the review is documented under the Milestones Section in CETS and the process begins again. After the Team Coordinator and/or C&E Center Manager approves the LOC/WN, he/she must enter the final sign-off into CETS in accordance with Team Coordinator/C&E Center Manager Standards. Once the LOC/WN is sent, the inspection lead enters the completed 2150-5 form, including the final action, into the EIS through CETS.
(b) Legal Enforcement Action. Legal enforcement action includes circumstances where serious safety issues are involved or there is a pattern of noncompliance that indicates an inability or unwillingness to comply with regulatory requirements. The Team Coordinator and/or C&E Center Manager should be consulted before preparing a legal enforcement report. Legal enforcement actions may include civil penalties or certificate actions. All follow-up activities are entered into CETS. The
05/23/2008 9120.1A
inspection lead must provide a draft legal enforcement report to the Team Coordinator and/or C&E Center Manager within 30 in-office working days of returning from the inspection. The legal enforcement report is either returned to the inspection lead for changes or approved. If it’s returned for changes, the review is documented under the Milestones Section in CETS and the process begins again. After the Team Coordinator and/or C&E Center Manager approves the legal enforcement report, he/she must enter the final sign-off into CETS in accordance with Team Coordinator/C&E Center Manager Standards. Once the legal enforcement report is approved, the inspection lead enters into CETS the date that it was sent to the Office of the Chief Counsel (AGC). He/she then enters the completed 2150-5 form into the EIS through CETS. There’s additional information on this subject in “Legal Enforcement Report Guidance,” which is located on the Drug Abatement Division (AAM- 800) QMS Web site. (c) No Action.
The inspection lead will close out an issue with no action when there is insufficient evidence to prove the alleged violation or when the alleged violation is considered a stale complaint. A complaint is considered stale when the FAA is unable to meet its statutory time requirements for pursuing legal enforcement action. Either situation will result in the issuance of a no action letter (see samples of a no action letter in Figures 2-17 and 2-18). The inspection lead must provide a draft of the no action letter to the Team Coordinator and/or C&E Center Manager within 45 in-office working days of returning from the inspection. The no action letter is either returned to the inspection lead for changes or approved. If it’s returned for changes, the review is documented under the Milestones Section in CETS and the process begins again. After the Team Coordinator and/or C&E Center Manager approves the no action letter, he/she must enter the final sign-off into CETS in accordance with Team Coordinator/C&E Center Manager Standards.
Once the letter is sent, the team lead enters the completed 2150-5 form, including the final action, into the EIS through CETS.
d. The inspection lead ensures that all follow-up activities are entered into CETS. He/she must also ensure that any follow-up information, such as documentation of corrective action by the employer, and incoming and outgoing communication, is obtained and documented in CETS.
Federal Aviation Administration
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-1. Sample Letter of Notification (LON)
U.S. Department of Transportation
Federal Aviation Administration
September 30, 2005 Certified Mail - Return Receipt Requested Brian Smith One Twenty One Airways, Inc. 12 Air Carrier Ave. Green Valley, VA 20004 Dear Mr. Smith: The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) will be conducting an inspection of your drug and alcohol testing programs beginning at 1:00 PM on October 31, 2005. The members of the inspection team will be John King and Vicky Lacy. The purpose of this inspection is to determine whether One Twenty One Airways Inc.’s drug and alcohol testing programs comply with 49 CFR part 40 and 14 CFR part 121, appendices I and J. The inspection will include your collection site, Medical Review Officer (MRO), and Substance Abuse Professional (SAP). Please make the following arrangements for the inspection: Collection Site – Tuesday, November 1, 2005 at 8:30 AM. MRO – Tuesday, November 1, 2005 at 11:00 AM. SAP – Tuesday, November 1, 2005 at 2:00 PM. Please review the following documentation to facilitate the inspection: Records for Review (please provide the information upon our arrival.) Points of Contact Form (please complete and return it to me by October 19, 2005.) My fax number is (202) 355-6001. Inspection Schedule. If you have any questions about this inspection, please contact me at (202) 355-6000. Sincerely, John King, Inspector Drug Abatement Division Office of Aerospace Medicine Attachments
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-1. Sample LON (cont’d)
RECORDS/DOCUMENTS REQUIRED FOR REVIEW To facilitate the inspection, please be prepared to discuss your Drug and Alcohol Testing Programs and have the following records available for review during the inspection. NOTE: Some items on this list are required only if those events have occurred or if that practice is followed. Other documents listed may not be required by regulation, but if available, will assist our review of your program. RECORDS RETAINED BY THE COMPANY: 1. Total number of covered employees: … 2. Please tabulate the following for the previous 24 months: Number of safety-sensitive employees hired: … Number of verified positive drug tests: … Number of alcohol tests of .02 or greater: … Number of refusals to submit to a required drug test: … Number of refusals to submit to a required alcohol test: …
3. List of all covered employees hired or transferred into covered positions, with hire date and date person began performing covered functions, for the past 24 months. Include terminated employees. Please provide two copies of this list.
4. List of all employees currently in the random testing pool, including the dates that employees were added to the pool.
5. Verification of notification to applicants of FAA required drug testing.
6. Drug and alcohol testing information released by new employees’ previous employers.
7. Random selection lists for the previous 24 months.
8. Instructions provided to donors prior to collection.
9. Negative drug test results for the last 12 months.
10. Alcohol testing results for the last 12 months (with results of less than .02).
11. Documentation of post-accident drug and alcohol testing or decision not to test.
12. Documentation of reasonable cause/reasonable suspicion testing.
13. Verification of Blind Testing for companies with 2000 or more covered employees.
14. Documentation that the MRO reviewed 5% of all negative drug test results. Copy of the MRO’s certification and proof of continuing education.
15. Copies of materials that are displayed and distributed to all covered employees (informational material on drug abuse, community service hotline number, and company drug policy).
16. Supervisory drug and alcohol reasonable cause/suspicion training documentation and materials.
17. Employee drug training documentation and materials.
18. Documentation that alcohol educational materials and employer’s alcohol testing policies and procedures were distributed to covered employees. Copy of the alcohol educational materials.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-1. Sample LON (cont’d)
19. Drug and/or alcohol logbooks.
20. Semi-annual laboratory reports for the last 12 months.
21. Drug and Alcohol Management Information System (MIS) Reports for the previous calendar year.
22. List of contractors as required by 14 CFR part 121.369(a) or part 135.427(a) and other contractors providing covered services (e.g., ground security coordinators, maintenance providers).
23. Please note that inspectors may ask to look at pilot, flight attendant, and maintenance records as part of this inspection. Please be prepared to facilitate a review of those records. REGARDING EMPLOYEE DRUG AND ALCOHOL VIOLATONS:
1. Positive drug test results (and refusals) for the last 60 months to include Federal Drug Testing Custody and Control Form, Medical Review Officer notification of results, and supporting documentation for the reason for testing.
2. Alcohol testing results for the last 60 months with results equal to or greater than 0.02, including BAT forms and supporting documentation for the reason for testing.
3. Verification that employees testing positive or refused a drug and/or alcohol test were immediately removed from a safety-sensitive function.
4. Notification to FAA of refusals for drug or alcohol testing for parts 61, 63, 65 and 67 certificate holders.
5. Notification to FAA of drug positives or alcohol violations for part 67 medical certificate holders.
6. List of Substance Abuse Professional (SAP) used, including their address and telephone numbers.
7. Documentation that return-to-duty requirements (e.g., SAP evaluation reports) were followed.
8. Follow-up testing schedule and Federal Drug Testing Custody and Control Forms/Alcohol Testing Forms for all follow-up tests during the last 60 months.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-1. Sample LON (cont’d)
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION AVIATION DRUG AND ALCOHOL PROGRAM COMPLIANCE INSPECTION
EMPLOYER POINTS OF CONTACT
Program Area Points of Contact
Name/Title
Address/Phone/Fax No.
1. Employer Administrative and Quality Assurance Activities • Types of Testing • Random Selection Method • Laboratory Quality Assurance
2. Primary Specimen Collection Site, Primary Alcohol Testing Site
3. Medical Review Officer
4. Substance Abuse Professional
5. Training and Education Records • Training for Supervisors • Training for Employees • Informational Material Displayed and Distributed to Employees
6. Remaining record keeping & reporting
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-1. Sample LON (cont’d)
Inspection Schedule
Day 1 October 31, 2005
FAA INSPECTION LEAD: John King, Phone Number: (202) 355-6000.
Employer POC: Brian Smith, Phone Number: (703) 111-2222
Time Activity FAA Staff Employer Staff
Federal Aviation Administration › Inspection Schedule
1:00-1:45 PM 1:50-3:00 PM 3:10 –4:45 PM 4:45-5:00PM
Inbrief Q & A Review of Records Wrap up
Lead: J. King Lead: J. King Lead: J. King Lead: J. King
Brian Smith and other company representatives as determined by the company.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-1. Sample LON (cont’d)
Inspection Schedule
Inspection Schedule › Inspection Schedule
Day 2 November 1, 2005
FAA INSPECTION LEAD: John King, Phone Number: (202) 355-6000.
Employer POC: Brian Smith, Phone Number: (703) 111-2222
Time Activity FAA Staff Employer Staff
8:30-10:45 AM 11:00- 12:30 PM 12:30-1:30 PM 1:30-2:30 PM 2:45-4:45 PM 4:45-5:00 PM
Inspect Collection Site Inspect MRO Lunch Inspect MRO Inspect SAP Wrap Up
Lead: J. King Lead: J. King Lead: J. King Lead: J. King Lead: J. King
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-1. Sample LON (cont’d)
Inspection Schedule
Day 3-4 November 2-3, 2005
FAA INSPECTION LEAD: John King, Phone Number: (202) 355-6000.
Employer POC: Brian Smith, Phone Number: (703) 111-2222
Time Activity FAA Staff Employer Staff
8:30-12:30PM 12:30 –1:30PM 1:30 – 4:45PM 4:45-5:00PM
Review of Records Lunch Review of Records Wrap up
Lead: J. King Lead: J. King Lead: J. King
Brian Smith and other company representatives as determined by the company.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-1. Sample LON (cont’d)
Inspection Schedule
Day 5 November 4, 2005
FAA INSPECTION LEAD: John King, Phone Number: (202) 355-6000.
Employer POC: Brian Smith, Phone Number: (703) 111-2222
Time Activity FAA Staff Employer Staff
8:30-11:30PM 11:30 –12:30PM
Review of Records Outbriefing
Lead: J. King Lead: J. King
Brian Smith and other company representatives as determined by the company.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-2. Inspection Lead Guide
Pre-Inspection ___ Mail/Fax LON, with enclosures, to the employer as far in advance as possible, but no later than two weeks before the inspection.
Inspection Schedule › Post-Inspection
___ Records/Documents Required for Review ___ Points of Contact Form
___ Aviation Employer Inspection Schedule** (**OPTIONAL FOR 1 DAY INSPECTIONS) ___ Confirm date of inspection with employer. ___ Discuss logistical arrangements with employer, get directions from POC. Inquire about the availability of:
___ Copier ___ Team meeting room ___ Ensure documentation is received from employer.
___ Research enforcement history.
___ Provide history to team. ___ Notify C&E Center Manager if additional resources are
needed.
___ Provide travel and lodging info to team.
___ Ensure that appropriate management representatives will be available to discuss: ___ Employer Administrative and Quality Assurance Activities ___ Specimen Collection ___ Breath Alcohol Testing Procedures ___ Medical Review Officer Activities ___ Substance Abuse Professional Activities ___ Drug Testing and Alcohol Information, Training, and Referral ___ Recordkeeping and Reporting ___ Ensure relevant documents will be available. ___ Complete inspection plan and assign areas of
responsibility to team members. ___ Submit work plan to C&E Center Manager, Team
Coordinator(s), and secretary/program assistant.
Inspection ___ Conduct initial team meeting. ___ Coordinate inspection team members’ activities
during the inspection. ___ Conduct inbriefing w/ sign-in sheet. ___ Conduct review meetings with team
members during inspection and prior to outbriefing. ___ Contact C&E Center Manager if team is
undecided about issues during the review process. ___ Interview safety-sensitive employees. ___ Ensure that all evidence is gathered, verified, &
certified during the on-site inspection. ___ Document findings in CETS (if possible). ___ Conduct outbriefing w/ sign-in sheet. ___ Conduct final team meeting to discuss good
points, problem areas, and lessons learned. Post-Inspection ___ Enter inspection activity and follow-up actions
in CETS. ___ Team members concur. ___ Forward documentation to C&E Center
Manager/Team Coordinator for final review and approval. ___ Send correspondence to employer as
appropriate and track corrective actions. ___ Update CETS as activities occur. ___ Prepare and process enforcement actions (legal
and administrative).
___Close out or complete CETS record.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-3. Sample Work Plan
Inspection Week Work Plan SECTION I Team Members: John King, Vicky Lacy
SECTION II Inspection Workload › Planned
Dates of Inspection: 01/08/2007-01/12/2007
Hotel Info:
Name: R&R Hotel Street Address: 345 Hotels Blvd. City, State: Dallas, TX Telephone: (214)123-6789
SECTION II Inspection Workload Planned
Company Name: Fast Jet Airlines, Inc. POC: Mary Smith POC Telephone: (214)222-3333 Date of Inspection: 1/8/2007 Team Lead: John King Start Time: 1:00 PM
Planned
Company Name: Fast Jet Airlines, Inc. POC: Mary Smith POC Telephone: (214)222-3333 Date of Inspection: 1/9/2007 Team Lead: John King Start Time: 8:30 AM Planned
Company Name: Turboprop Airlines, Inc. POC: John Smith POC Telephone: (214)777-8888 Date of Inspection: 1/9/2007 Team Lead: Vicky Lacy Start Time: 1:00 PM
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-3. Sample Work Plan (cont’d)
Planned
Company Name: Mega Wrench Mechanics, Inc. POC: Steve Jones POC Telephone: (214)345-6789 Date of Inspection: 1/10/2007 Team Lead: John King Start Time: 8:30 AM Planned
Company Name: XYZ Avionics, Inc. POC: Kathy Dean POC Telephone: (214)111-7777 Date of Inspection: 1/10/2007 Team Lead: John King Start Time: 1:00 PM Planned
Company Name: 135 Commuter Air, Inc. POC: Ron Baker POC Telephone: (214)222-4444 Date of Inspection: 1/11/2007 Team Lead: Vicky Lacy Start Time: 8:30 AM Planned
Company Name: Flight Plan Scenic Tours, Inc. POC: Jeff Smith POC Telephone: (214)999-1111 Date of Inspection: 1/11/2007 Team Lead: Vicky Lacy Start Time: 1:00 PM Planned
Collection Site: Collections 101, Inc. Company Name: Fast Jet Airlines, Inc. POC: Bob David POC Telephone: (214)432-9876 Date of Inspection: 1/12/2007 Team Lead: John King Start Time: 8:30 AM
Instructions: One Inspection week work plan per team must be completed. Complete Section I and II and email to the Team Coordinator, Center Manager, and the Secretary/Program Assistant of your center no later than the Wednesday prior to the inspection.
Planned › Outbriefing
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-4. Inspection Inbriefing/Outbriefing Guide
Inbriefing … Introduce team members to employer representatives and pass a sign-in sheet. … Explain the purpose and scope of the inspection. … Review the inspection schedule. … Confirm employer POCs, C/TPAs and document/record locations. … Describe the outbriefing that is to be held at the end of the inspection. Outbriefing … Thank employer for cooperation and assistance, as applicable, and pass the sign-in sheet. … Inspection lead may request that employer hold questions and comments until end of
briefing. … If there are no out-of-compliance issues, advise employer that this concludes the
inspection and there will be no further correspondence. … Review scope of inspection and activities conducted and state that there will be a written
follow-up to the inspection. … Describe items that are allegedly out of compliance with the regulations. … Review any open items, if applicable. An open item is an item that requires guidance
from Management. … State areas of concern, if applicable. Concerns are any item that is not out of compliance
but could lead to an out-of-compliance issue if not addressed. … Negotiate with a time limit with the employer for completing corrective actions. … Describe review process, but do not discuss possible enforcement … Do not leave written inspection materials or results with employer.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-5. Meeting Attendance List
MEETING ATTENDANCE LIST
Company: … Date: …
Name
Title/Organization
Telephone
Number
Email Address
Attendance In briefing
Out briefing
In briefing
Out briefing
In briefing
Out briefing
In briefing
Out briefing
In briefing
Out briefing
In briefing
Out briefing
In briefing
Out briefing
In briefing
Out briefing
In briefing
Out briefing
In briefing
Out briefing
In briefing
Out briefing
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-6. Document/Record Review Guide
Documents/
Records
Reviewed By (Inspector’s/Investigator’s
Name) 1. Drug Program Training Records
2. Alcohol Program Training Records
3. Federal Drug Testing Custody & Control Forms
4. DOT Alcohol Testing Forms
5. Specimen Collection Logs
6. MRO Records – Records of Notification & Determination
7. Blind Testing Results
8. Part 67 Positives and Notifications to the FAA Federal Air Surgeon
9. Refusal Documentation (drug and/or alcohol)
10. Verified Positive Drug Test Results
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-6. Document/Record Review Guide (cont’d)
Documents/
Records
Reviewed By (Inspector’s/Investigator’s
Name) 11. Alcohol Misuse Violations
12. Disposition of Verified Positive Drug Test Cases and Alcohol Misuse Violation Cases
13. Documents Pertaining to Drug Testing Arbitration or Litigation
14. Random Selection Documentation
15. Reasonable Cause & Reasonable Suspicion
16. Reportable Accident Records & Post- Accident Tests
17. Calibration logs for Evidential Breath Testing Devices
18. Laboratory Correspondence – Include Semi-annual Summaries
19. Documentation to Verify Contractor Compliance
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-6. Document/Record Review Guide (cont’d)
20. Maintenance Records
21. Pilot Flight Records/Logs
22. Flight Attendant and Other Job Category Work Records
23. Personnel Records (include hire dates)
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-7. Sample Certifications of Authenticity
1. Documents copied from originals held by individuals or companies: I certify that this is a true and accurate copy of the original {insert description of document} held by {insert name of source}. … {Name of FAA Investigative Personnel} 2. Documents secured by FAA Investigative Personnel from sources outside the FAA upon request: I certify that this copy of {insert description of document} was provided to me upon request by {insert name of source}. … {Name of FAA Investigative Personnel} 3. Photographs either taken or secured by FAA Investigative Personnel: I certify that this photograph fairly and accurately depicts {describe the image of the photograph} on {insert date and time it was taken}. … {Name of FAA Investigative Personnel}
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-8. Return-to-Duty Process Flowchart
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-9. Federal Drug Testing Custody and Control Form (CCF) Process Flowchart
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-10. Employee Interview Guide
Employer … Date/Time … Interviewer Name … Employee Name … Employee Job Title … Length of Service with Employer … Total Experience … This interview is voluntary. Its purpose is to help evaluate the drug and alcohol testing programs mandated by the FAA. What type of work do you do and when were you hired? Explain your duties/assignments. Are you a supervisor? When did you first perform safety-sensitive duties? Have you submitted to any drug tests? When? If a pre-employment test is not mentioned, ask: Did you have a pre-employment drug test? When? If the employee cannot recall when he/she received a pre-employment test, ask: Was this before or after you first performed safety-sensitive functions? Do you know how your name was selected for a drug test or tests after you were hired? After you were notified of your selection, when did you have to appear for your test? Have you submitted to any alcohol tests? When? After you were notified of your selection, when did you have to appear for your test? Have you received training regarding the drug and alcohol testing program of your employer? What are some of the effects and consequences of drug use on personal health, safety, and the work environment?
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-10. Employee Interview Guide (cont’d)
Can you name some of the behavioral indicators that may indicate drug use? What are some of the effects and consequences of abusing alcohol on personal health, safety, and the work environment? Can you name some of the behavioral indicators that may indicate alcohol abuse? Have you received any informational materials on the drug and alcohol testing programs? If so, what types of materials have you received? Have you received a community service hotline telephone number for employee assistance? If so, when and where did you receive the number? Have you received a copy of your employer’s policy regarding drug use in the workplace? (When interviewing Supervisors Only)
Have you received training concerning reasonable cause and reasonable suspicion testing? Describe the training you received. When did you receive this training? How often have you received training? When was the last time you received this training? Did the training include specific contemporary physical, behavioral, and performance indicators of drug and alcohol use? How long was the training? (If necessary, ask:) Was the training at least 60 minutes in length for both the alcohol and drug portions? Do you have any general comments, concerns, or complaints regarding the drug and alcohol testing
programs?
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-11. Sample Witness Statement Form
Inspection Witness Statement Form
(PRINT)
Name of Employer or C/TPA: … Witness Name: … Date: … Mailing Address: … Time: … Telephone:(Home) … (Work) … Place: … Inspector’s/Investigator’s Name: … Others Present: … Narrative: Witness Signature: … Date: … Signature(s) of others present … , … , … Inspector/Investigator Signature: … Page ____of …
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-11. Sample Witness Statement Form (cont’d)
Witness Statement Form (cont’d)
(PRINT)
Witness Name: … Date: …
Narrative:
Witness Signature: … Date: …
Inspector/Investigator Signature: … Page … of …
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-12. Sample Outbriefing Report
Outbriefing Report Company Name: One Twenty One Airways, Inc. Certificate Number: Z888888L Type of Company: 121 Inspection Date: 12/30/2005 Type of Inspection: Full Team Leader: John King (202) 355-6000 Team Members: Vicky Lacy (330) 599-4444 Inspection Findings: Inspected Location: Green Valley, VA OUT-OF-COMPLIANCE ITEM(S): 1. 1.04.01 - Employer must conduct a pre-employment test and receive a verified negative drug test result prior to hiring an individual to perform a safety-sensitive function. (14 CFR part 121, appendix I, V, A, 1) Months Of Review: N/A Violation Details: Date of Occurrence: 08/30/2005 Employee Name: Adam Jackson Employee Number: 555-22-5555 Safety-Sensitive Function: Pilot Violation Description: On August 30, 2005, Adam Jackson was hired as a pilot for One Twenty One Airways, Inc. Prior to that date, on August 17, 2005, One Twenty One Airways, Inc. sent Mr. Jackson to Drug Testing, Inc., its testing site, for a pre-employment drug test.
Drug Testing, Inc., failed to properly conduct a DOT pre-employment drug test on Mr. Jackson in that the laboratory used a non-Federal chain of custody form instead of a Federal Custody and Control Form (CCF). Additionally, the records review revealed that One Twenty One Airways, Inc. did not have in its records a verified negative drug test result pertaining to a pre-employment drug test for Mr. Jackson. Therefore, One Twenty One Airways, Inc. did not conduct a DOT pre-employment drug test or receive a verified negative drug test result prior to hiring Mr. Jackson to perform a safety-sensitive function. Evidence Found: 1) Adam Jackson's non-Federal pre-employment chain of custody form dated August 17, 2005. 2) One Twenty One Airways, Inc.'s list of new hires indicating Adam Jackson was hired on August 30, 2005.
Date of Occurrence: 11/15/2005 Employee Name: Bob Horn Employee Number: 555-11-5555 Safety-Sensitive Function: A&P Mechanic Violation Description: On November 15, 2005, Bob Horn was hired as a mechanic for One Twenty One Airways, Inc. Prior to that date, on November 11, 2005, One Twenty
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-12. Sample Outbriefing Report (cont’d)
One Airways, Inc. sent Mr. Horn to Drug Testing, Inc., its testing site, for a preemployment drug test. Drug Testing, Inc., failed to properly conduct a DOT preemployment drug test on Mr. Horn in that the laboratory used a non-Federal chain of custody form instead of a CCF. The records review revealed that One Twenty One Airways, Inc. was in possession of the confirmed negative laboratory report from Drug Testing, Inc. The program manager wasn't sure if the laboratory report came directly from the lab or the MRO. Based upon the data gathered, One Twenty One Airways, Inc. failed to conduct a DOT pre-employment drug test and receive a verified negative drug test result prior to hiring Mr. Horn to perform a safety-sensitive function. Evidence Found: 1) Bob Horn's non-Federal pre-employment chain of custody form dated November 11, 2005. 2) Drug Testing's confirmed negative laboratory report for Bob Horn dated November 15, 2005. 3) One Twenty One Airways, Inc.'s list of new hires indicating Bob Horn was hired on November 15, 2005.
Corrective Action: One Twenty One Airways, Inc. agreed at the inspection outbriefing to take corrective action immediately to ensure that Drug Testing, Inc. will use a Federal Drug Testing CCF for all DOT drug testing. One Twenty One Airways, Inc. will also develop a pre-hire checklist to ensure that it possesses a negative drug test result on a Federal CCF prior to hiring an individual for a safety-sensitive function.
2. 1.06.02.a - Met minimum annual testing rate. (14 CFR part 121, appendix I, V., B., 6., and appendix J, III, C., 6) Months Of Review: N/A Violation Details: Date of Occurrences: 12/31/2003, 12/31/2004 Violation Description: In accordance with the data provided on One Twenty One Airways, Inc.'s 2003 MIS report, the company had a total of 65 safety-sensitive employees. The company was required to conduct 16 random drug tests and 6 random alcohol tests. The company randomly conducted 12 alcohol tests and 12 drug tests. The company failed to meet the minimum annual drug testing rate for calendar year 2003. Furthermore, in calendar year 2004, the company had a total of 83 covered employees. The company was required to conduct 20 random drug tests and 8 random alcohol tests. The company did not conduct any random drug or alcohol tests in 2004. The current program manager indicated that the computer-based number generator system broke, and the previous program manager resigned in August/September of 2004. Therefore, testing was not accomplished in 2004.
Based upon the data gathered, the company failed to meet the minimum annual drug and testing rate for calendar years 2003 and 2004. Evidence Found: 1) Copies of all random drug and alcohol tests conducted in calendar year 2003 and 2004. 2) One Twenty One Airways, Inc.'s MIS report for calendar years 2003. 3) One Twenty One Airways, Inc.'s MIS report for calendar year 2004. Corrective Action: One Twenty One Airways, Inc. agreed at the inspection outbriefing to take corrective action immediately following the outbriefing to conduct random drug and alcohol testing in accordance with the minimum annual testing rate in the future calendar years.
CONCERN(S): UNDECIDED ITEM(S):
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-13. Inspection Correspondence Flowchart
Federal Aviation Administration
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-14. Sample Letter of Investigation (LOI)
U.S. Department 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. of Transportation Washington, DC 20591
Federal Aviation Administration
Certified Mail – Return Receipt Requested File Number: 2007XXXXXXX Mr. Charles Benson, President Fast Jet Airlines, Inc. 123 Airport Road Dallas, TX 70012 Dear Mr. Benson: On December 4, 2006, we inspected Fast Jet Airlines, Inc.’s drug and alcohol testing programs to determine its compliance with 49 CFR part 40 and 14 CFR part 121, appendices I and J. As a result of this inspection, we discovered the following apparent violations: 1. Fast Jet Airlines, Inc. did not ensure that the Federal Drug Testing Custody and Control Form were not used for non-Department of Transportation urine collections on pre-employment tests for the following non-safety-sensitive employees: Nicholas Johnson - 1/26/05, Emily Thomas – 2/26/05, and Brian Peters - 3/1/05. 2. Fast Jet Airlines, Inc’s Medical Review Officer (MRO), Dr. Michael Jenkins, did not include the date that the MRO verified the test results on each written report of drug test results for the following employees:
EMPLOYEE NAME DATE MRO VERIFIED
RESULTS WRITTEN DRUG TEST
REPORT
DATE MRO VERIFIED
RESULTS STEP 6 ON COPY 2 OF CCF
Larry Jacobs 4/21/2005 4/22/2005 Ann Smith 7/11/2006 7/19/2006 Karen Jones 1/6/2006 1/9/2006 Brenda Stevens 8/3/2006 8/5/2006 Donald Tyler 4/20/2006 4/21/2006 Barry Parker 9/7/2006 9/8/2006 Mark Lincoln 4/4/2006 4/11/2006 Kelly Peterson 7/12/2006 7/19/2002
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-14. Sample LOI (cont’d)
We are currently investigating these matters. You may discuss these matters with me or submit a written statement, or both, within 10 days after you receive this letter. Please contact me at (202) 355- 6000 if you have questions about these matters. A written statement should include all pertinent facts and mitigating circumstances that you believe may have a bearing on these matters. Send your written statement to: Federal Aviation Administration Office of Aerospace Medicine Drug Abatement Division 800 Independence Ave, SW Washington, DC 20591 If we do not hear from you within 10 days, we will process our report without the benefit of your statement. Sincerely, John King, Inspector Drug Abatement Division Office of Aerospace Medicine cc: Mary Smith, Drug and Alcohol Program Manager
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-15. Sample Letter of Correction (LOC)
U.S. Department 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. of Transportation Washington, DC 20591
Federal Aviation Administration
Certified Mail – Return Receipt Requested File Number: 2006XXXXXXXXX Ms. Elizabeth Spencer, President One Twenty One Airways, Inc. 12 Air Carrier Ave. Green Valley, VA 20004 Dear Ms. Spencer, On July 20, 2006, we inspected One Twenty One Airways, Inc’s drug and alcohol testing programs to determine its compliance with 49 CFR part 40 and 14 CFR part 121, appendices I and J. This letter confirms that you have satisfactorily corrected the apparent violations identified in your August 24, 2006, letter of investigation (file number: 2006XXXXXXXX). We have reviewed the evidence collected during the July 20, 2006 inspection and the documentation submitted on July 20, 2006, and in your October 28, 2006, response letter. We have concluded that the issues detailed below with the described corrective actions do not warrant legal enforcement action. Instead, we are issuing this letter of correction, which is a matter of record. 1. One Twenty One Airways, Inc. did not perform drug and alcohol record checks in accordance with 49 CFR § 40.25. Specifically:
• One Twenty One Airways, Inc. did not perform drug and alcohol record checks on employees prior to the first day they performed safety-sensitive duties for you.
Corrective Action: At the outbriefing, One Twenty One Airways, Inc. agreed to immediately ensure that it performs drug and alcohol record checks on all new employees prior to the first day they perform safetysensitive duties for One Twenty One Airways, Inc. During the inspection, the company had Mr. Smith complete the release and the questionnaire was hand-carried to BCD, Inc. where Raymond Johnson, VP and ADPM, completed the questionnaire and returned it to One Twenty One Airways, Inc.
2. One Twenty One Airways, Inc. did not develop and distribute alcohol educational materials in accordance with 14 CFR part 121, appendix J, VI, A. Specifically:
• One Twenty One Airways, Inc. did not distribute a copy of the educational materials that explain the alcohol misuse requirements and the employer's policies and procedures with respect to meeting those requirements to each person subsequently hired for or transferred to a covered position.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-15. Sample LOC (cont’d)
Corrective Action: At the inspection outbriefing, One Twenty One Airways, Inc. agreed to immediately ensure that it distributes a copy of the educational materials that explain the alcohol misuse requirements and One Twenty One Airways, Inc.’s policies and procedures with respect to meeting those requirements to Barbara Perez and all future covered employees when they are hired for a covered position.
In the response, One Twenty One Airways, Inc. submitted a copy of the alcohol informational materials distributed to Ms. Perez and a sign-off sheet documenting its receipt. In addition, the company stated that it will distribute these materials to all future covered employees.
3. One Twenty One Airways, Inc. did not develop, display, and distribute drug informational materials in accordance with 14 CFR part 121, appendix I, VIII, A. Specifically:
• One Twenty One Airways, Inc. did not display and distribute its employer’s policy regarding drug use in the workplace to all covered employees.
Corrective Action: One Twenty One Airways, Inc. agreed to immediately ensure that it distributes its policy regarding drug use in the workplace to Barbara Perez, and all future covered employees. Prior to the end of the inspection, Ms. Perez was provided with a copy of the company's policy regarding drug use in the workplace and the policy was displayed in the company’s office.
In the response, One Twenty One Airways, Inc. re-stated that it continues to display and distributed One Twenty One Airways, Inc.’s policy regarding drug use in the workplace to all covered employees.
4. One Twenty One Airways, Inc. did not implement a reasonable program of initial drug training for all covered employees in accordance with 14 CFR part 121, appendix I, VIII, B. Specifically:
• One Twenty One Airways, Inc. did not document initial drug training given to employees.
Corrective Action: One Twenty One Airways, Inc. agreed to immediately ensure that it documents initial drug training given to Ms. Perez and all future covered employees. Ms. Perez will complete and forward the form as soon as practicable.
In the response, One Twenty One Airways, Inc. submitted a copy of a sign-off sheet documenting initial employee drug training provided to Ms. Perez.
We continue to expect compliance with all applicable drug and alcohol regulations.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-15. Sample LOC (cont’d)
Please direct any future questions relating to your drug and alcohol testing programs to: Federal Aviation Administration Office of Aerospace Medicine Drug Abatement Division, AAM-800 Washington, DC 20591 Tel: (202) 355-6000 Fax: (202) 355-6001 Sincerely, John King, Inspector Drug Abatement Division Office of Aerospace Medicine
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-16. Sample Warning Notice (WN)
U.S. Department 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. of Transportation Washington, DC 20591
Federal Aviation Administration
Certified Mail – Return Receipt Requested File Number: 2006XXXXXXXX Ms. Elizabeth Spencer, President One Twenty One Airways, Inc. 12 Air Carrier Ave. Green Valley, VA 20004 Dear Ms. Spencer: On September 26, 2006, we inspected One Twenty One Airways, Inc.’s drug and alcohol testing programs to determine its compliance with 49 CFR part 40 and 14 CFR part 121, appendices I and J. This letter constitutes a warning notice for the following apparent violations identified in our October 17, 2006, letter of investigation (file number: 2006XXXXXXXX): 1. Require each covered employee notified of selection for random drug and/or alcohol testing, proceeds to the testing site immediately, or if employee is performing safety-sensitive function, he/she ceases to perform function and proceeds to testing site as soon as possible.
2. Keep DOT tests and non-DOT tests completely separate.
3. Employer's policy regarding drug use in workplace.
4. Employer must maintain documentation of training given to employees and supervisory personnel.
We have reviewed all available information collected during the September 26, 2006, inspection and your correspondence submitted on November 1, 2006. We have decided not to take legal enforcement action for these apparent violations. Instead, we are issuing this warning notice, which is a matter of record. We continue to expect compliance with all applicable drug and alcohol regulations. Sincerely, John King, Inspector Drug Abatement Division Office of Aerospace Medicine cc: Brian Smith, Drug and Alcohol Program Manager
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-17. Sample Letter of No Action (Insufficient Evidence)
U.S. Department 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. of Transportation Washington, DC 20591
Federal Aviation Administration
Certified Mail – Return Receipt Requested File Number: 2006XXXXXXXX Ms. Mary Smith, President One Thirty Five Airlines, Inc. 789 Airport Road Blue Harbor, FL 33142 Dear Ms. Smith: On June 27, 2006, we informed you that we were investigating One Thirty Five Airlines, Inc.’s drug and alcohol testing programs for apparent violations of 49 CFR part 40 and 14 CFR part 121, appendices I and J. This letter (file number: 2006XXXXXXX) addresses the following item that was included in our June 27, 2006, letter of investigation (file number: 2006XXXXXXXX):
Alcohol informational materials distributed to covered employees including an explanation of what constitutes a refusal to submit to alcohol testing and the attendant regulatory consequences.
We reviewed all available information and concluded that there is insufficient evidence to support this allegation. You may consider this allegation closed. Please direct any questions relating to your drug and alcohol testing programs to: Federal Aviation Administration Office of Aerospace Medicine Drug Abatement Division, AAM-800 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. Washington, DC 20591 Sincerely, John Doe, Inspector Drug Abatement Division Office of Aerospace Medicine
Administration
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 2-18. Sample Letter of No Action (Stale Complaint)
U.S. Department 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. of Transportation Washington, DC 20591 Federal Aviation Administration Certified Mail – Return Receipt Requested File Number: 2006XXXXXXXX Ms. Mary Smith, President One Thirty Five Airlines, Inc. 789 Airport Road Blue Harbor, FL 33142 Dear Ms. Smith: On January 16, 2006, we inspected One Thirty Five Airlines, Inc.’s drug and alcohol testing programs to determine compliance with 49 CFR part 40 and 14 CFR part 121, appendices I and J.
This letter addresses your apparent violations of the regulations described in our January 31, 2006 letter of investigation (file number: 2006XXXXXXXX). We have reviewed the evidence collected during the inspection and the documentation your company submitted on February 21, 2006. We have concluded that you are in apparent violation of these regulations. However, we are precluded by statutory time limits from pursuing legal enforcement action in these matters. You may consider the matter closed. We continue to expect compliance with all applicable drug and alcohol regulations. Sincerely, John Doe, Inspector Drug Abatement Division Office of Aerospace Medicine
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Chapter 3. Investigations
1. General. All Drug Abatement Division activities involve some element of an investigation in which the facts of an issue are examined. The majority of these investigations pertain to alleged violations of the drug and alcohol testing regulations by companies or individuals who perform safety-sensitive functions. The purpose of these investigations is to determine whether a violation exists and warrants the need for legal enforcement action (i.e., civil penalty or certificate action) or administrative action (i.e., WN or LOC) to ensure future compliance with the drug and alcohol testing regulations.
Each inspector/investigator is responsible for reporting an alleged violation to his/her manager. Based on the source and subject of the alleged violation, the investigation will be conducted by an inspector in the field or an investigator in the Special Investigations and Enforcement Branch (AAM-830).
Investigations are categorized as investigations of a company (i.e., employers, contractors, service agents) or investigations of individuals who perform safety-sensitive functions. This chapter will describe the sources of allegations, categories of investigations, and the Branch or C&E Center responsible for the investigation.
2. Sources of Allegations. An allegation may come from any of the following sources: FAA Aviation Safety Hotline, noncompliance transmittals (NCT), Congressional inquiries, refusal reports, part 67 reports, and complaints. Under each company’s profile in CETS, there is a tab titled “Special Issues.” This tab allows for the documentation of the source and allows for the initiation of an investigation, inspection, or a decision not to conduct a further inquiry. If an investigation is necessary, it will be initiated under the company’s activity record.
a. FAA Aviation Safety Hotline. These allegations are received through the FAA’s Aviation Safety Hotline office and directed to the Drug Abatement Division for action and may involve individuals and/or companies. Issues involving individuals are referred to AAM-830 for investigation. However, some issues involving companies may be assigned to the C&E Centers for inspection or investigation.
b. NCT. An NCT is an internal process that inspectors, investigators, managers, or anyone within the Drug Abatement Division may use to document issues that emerge during an inspection, an investigation, or through the course of normal duties. These issues typically involve possible noncompliance by another company or an individual. The majority of these will be handled by the C&E Centers, unless circumstances require action by AAM-830.
c. Congressional Inquiries. Congressional inquiries are correspondence requesting information regarding constituents. Congressional inquiries are referred to the Program Administration Branch (AAM-810) for action, but may be coordinated with the other Branches and the C&E Centers where necessary.
d. Refusal Reports. An employer is required to report all refusals to submit to drug or alcohol testing by an individual who holds an airman certificate issued in accordance with 14 CFR parts 61, 63, or 65. These refusals are investigated by AAM-830.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
e. Part 67 Reports. An employer is required to report all verified positive drug test results, confirmed alcohol misuse violations, or refusals to submit to testing by any individual who holds a medical certificate issued in accordance with 14 CFR part 67 or refusals to submit to testing. These cases are also investigated by AAM-830.
f. Complaints. Complaints are the result of an individual or company requesting an investigation of an event, or information received from other FAA sources (e.g., Flight Standards Service). These allegations may be against a company or individual. These issues are referred to AAM-830 for review. AAM-830 may conduct the investigation and coordinate with the C&E Centers for assistance where necessary. It is possible that the issue may be referred to the C&E Center for inspection or investigation. 3. Investigations of a Company. These investigations include similar procedures established for an inspection, as described in Chapter 2 of this order. An LOI is issued alleging the violation. The response may result in administrative action (i.e., WN or LOC) or legal enforcement action (civil penalty or certificate action). An on-site investigation at the company or, one of its locations, may or may not be necessary and this determination is made by your Branch or Center Manager.
4. Investigations of Individuals Who Perform Safety-Sensitive Functions. Investigations involving individuals who perform safety-sensitive functions are critical and require an immediate investigation. All investigations of individuals are the responsibility of AAM-830. These investigations most often result from the following:
a. Report of an individual’s refusal to submit to a drug or alcohol test;
b. Report of a verified positive drug test or an alcohol misuse violation by an individual who holds a medical certificate issued in accordance with 14 CFR part 67;
c. An individual performing safety-sensitive functions after testing positive or refusing to submit to a drug and/or alcohol test without complying with the return-to-duty process;
d. An FAA Aviation Safety Hotline complaint; or
e. A complaint received based on the activities of an employee as they relate to drug and alcohol testing.
If an inspection team finds, during the normal course of an inspection, any issues that relate to violations by an individual who performs safety-sensitive functions, the inspection lead will notify the C&E Center Manager, who will subsequently notify AAM-830. The Manager of AAM-830 will provide further directions/actions and the matter should be left open.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Chapter 4. Voluntary Disclosures
1. General. One of the elements of the FAA’s compliance and enforcement philosophy is that aviation safety depends primarily on voluntary adherence to the regulations. The FAA has developed programs to encourage companies to examine their own compliance efforts. Holders of part 121 and 135 air carrier certificates and part 145 repair station certificates are eligible to participate in the Voluntary Disclosure Reporting Program, which is described in Advisory Circular (AC) 00-58A. This program allows certificate holders to report inadvertent violations to the FAA along with a description of the corrective action taken, and the comprehensive fix for preventing future violations.
2. Procedures. When processing voluntary disclosure cases, each inspector/investigator must use the information in this chapter, in conjunction with AC 00-58A, and adhere to the procedures established under the Quality Management System of ISO AAM-800-007. Failure to follow these procedures may result in a corrective action report, as described in the ISO procedure.
a. Once a certificate holder discovers an apparent violation, the company may voluntarily disclose it to the FAA within 24 hours. The process for documentation when a disclosure is received is critical to whether it is accepted or denied. Each Drug Abatement employee is responsible for ensuring that a disclosure is reported immediately to the appropriate C&E Center Manager.
b. Initial notification can be accomplished by the following means:
(1) By phone, through contacting any Drug Abatement employee. Once the notification is received, the Drug Abatement employee must refer the certificate holder to the appropriate C&E Center Manager and then prepare a detailed statement of the conversation to transmit to the C&E Center Manager.
(2) Written correspondence via regular mail or electronic mail. All written correspondence must be referred to the appropriate C&E Center Manager.
c. After receipt of the disclosure, the assigned manager must determine if there is a violation of the regulations or not. If there is not, the certificate holder is advised in writing that its disclosure was not a violation (see Figure 4-1).
d. Issuance of the Letter of Acknowledgment (LOA). If the disclosure describes a violation of the regulations or if it's unknown as to whether a violation exists, the inspector/investigator must issue an LOA through CETS (see sample LOA in Figure 4-2). The LOA serves two purposes. First, it acknowledges receipt of the initial notification. Second, it identifies, in accordance with AC 00-58A, the information that the certificate holder must submit in writing to the FAA, if not already provided. This information should be provided to the FAA, within 10 working days after the initial notification was made.
e. Upon receipt of the response to the LOA, the inspector/investigator must analyze the violation and the discovery information, obtain the evidence to show the violation has been corrected, and determine whether the comprehensive fix is acceptable. The determination to deny or accept a voluntary disclosure is based on specific factors of the violation and the
05/23/2008 9120.1A
certificate holder’s actions. When making this determination, it is important for the inspector/investigator and C&E Center Manager to follow the procedures established under AC 00-58A. Additionally, it’s imperative to coordinate with the Drug Abatement Division Manager and Chief Counsel’s Office for disclosures that are complex or require legal guidance.
(1) If the FAA accepts the voluntary disclosure, the inspector/investigator must send the certificate holder an LOC (see sample LOC in Figure 4-3). The LOC is assigned an EIR File Number. At the conclusion of the disclosure process, the employer is referred for inspection in CETS. The inspection team will evaluate the comprehensive fix and annotate the results in CETS.
(2) If the voluntary disclosure is denied, the inspector/investigator must generate a letter of denial (see sample denial letters in Figures 4-4 and 4-5) and refer the employer for inspection or investigation in CETS. Ultimately, the issue will be handled via the inspection results or the investigative action.
f. Once the disclosure is complete, it must be included under the employer’s enforcement record in its C&E Center and CETS profile. In addition to the correspondence and evidence, the C&E Center record must include the following:
(1) Inspector/Investigator Analysis. The inspector/investigator analysis must include the following (see sample analysis in Figure 4-6):
(a) Summary of the voluntary disclosure. This is a chronological summary, including affiliated dates, of the voluntary disclosure. This includes a summary of the written and verbal communications to and from the certificate holder.
(b) Summary of the certificate holder’s comprehensive fix.
(c) Analysis and recommendation to deny or accept voluntary disclosure.
(d) Final action.
(2) Copy of the 2150-5 Form. Refer to the Drug Abatement Division’s EIS Manual for completing the 2150-5 form for a voluntary disclosure. Some of the certificate holder’s information, such as its name and address, certificate number, etc. is not included on the 2150-5. Records submitted to the FAA under the Voluntary Disclosure Program are protected from release to the public.
Federal Aviation Administration
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 4-1. Sample Letter to Certificate Holder
(DISCLOSED ISSUE WAS NOT A VIOLATION)
U.S. Department 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. of Transportation Washington, DC 20591 Federal Aviation Administration
Certified Mail – Return Receipt Requested Mr. Brian Smith One Twenty One Airways, Inc. 12 Air Carrier Ave. Green Valley, VA 20004 Dear Mr. Smith: This is in response to your November 7, 2006 correspondence to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) where you voluntarily disclosed an apparent violation of FAA’s drug and alcohol testing programs regulations (14 CFR part 121, appendices I and J) and the Department of Transportation (DOT) Procedures for Transportation Workplace Drug and Alcohol Testing Program (49 CFR part 40). In your correspondence you indicated that One Twenty One Airways, Inc. failed to receive a preemployment drug-screen result from its MRO prior to hiring an individual for a safety-sensitive function.
This issue is not a violation because, according to the employee’s job description, he is not performing a safety-sensitive function as defined in 14 CFR part 121, appendices I and J. Therefore, One Twenty One Airways, Inc. was not required to pre-employ drug test and receive a verified negative drug result prior to hiring that employee. You may consider this matter closed.
Please contact me at (202) 355-0000 if you have any questions about this matter. Sincerely, Mary Bradford Drug Abatement Division Office of Aerospace Medicine
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 4-2. Sample Letter of Acknowledgment (LOA)
U.S. Department 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. of Transportation Washington, DC 20591 Federal Aviation Administration
Certified Mail – Return Receipt Requested Mr. Brian Smith One Twenty One Airways, Inc. 12 Air Carrier Ave. Green Valley, VA 20004 Dear Mr. Smith: This is to confirm your initial verbal notification of a voluntary disclosure to John King, Drug Abatement Division on March 9, 2006, of possible violations of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) drug and alcohol testing regulations (14 CFR part 121, appendices I and J) and the Department of Transportation (DOT) Procedures for Transportation Workplace Drug and Alcohol Testing Program (49 CFR part 40). During your conversation with Mr. King, you voluntarily disclosed that One Twenty One Airways, Inc.’s collector did not use the Federal Drug Testing Custody and Control Form (CCF) to document a safety-sensitive employee (flight attendant) pre-employment urine collection required by the Department of Transportation (DOT) drug testing program. FAA Advisory Circular, 00-58A, Voluntary Disclosure Reporting Program, dated September 8, 2006, provides the criteria and guidance for self-disclosure of apparent violations of regulations.
In accordance with this advisory circular, please provide the following information to this office within 10 days of receipt of this letter: • Date of the violation(s) and when the violation(s) were discovered. • Duration of time the apparent violation(s) remained undetected. • A summary of the apparent violation(s) including numbers of individuals involved. • When immediate action was initiated and a description of immediate actions taken to preclude a recurrence of the violation(s). • The name, position, and phone number of the company official responsible for immediate action. • Analysis including a summary of evidence showing reasons the violation(s) were inadvertent.
Include any supporting documentation. • Comprehensive long-term proposal including immediate actions taken, procedural and/or organizational actions necessary, monitoring/measuring methods to ensure effectiveness of the proposed fixes, a review schedule, who will review progress, and how progress will be monitored. • The name, position, and phone number of the company official responsible for monitoring the implementation of the comprehensive fix.
05/23/2008 9120.1A
Figure 4-2. Sample LOA (cont’d)
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 488 passages shown