Radar Vectors
FAA Order Cancelled Issued Oct 1, 2007 AGC-300 340 pages Copy saved Nov 18, 2026

Order 2150.3B FAA Compliance and Enforcement Program (with Change 13)

This order describes the authority, responsibilities, policies, guidelines, procedures, objectives, and legal aspects of the Federal Aviation Administration’s compliance and enforcement program. The policies and procedures described in this order explain how the FAA generally intends to exercise its discretion in carrying out statutory and regulatory enforcement responsibilities.

This document is cancelled. Cancelled by 2150.3C. Check the official source before relying on it.

Official source ↗ Open PDF

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

National Policy

ORDER 2150.38 CHG 13

Effective Date:

08/27/18

SUBJ: Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 2018-13: Guidance on Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS) operations that interfere with wildfue suppression, law enforcement, or emergency response efforts.

1. Purpose. This change to FAA Order 2150.3, as amended, provides guidance on actions applicable to persons who operate Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS) that interfere with wildfire suppression, law enforcement, or emergency response efforts.

2. Who this change affects. The change affects all agency personnel who investigate, report, or process enforcement actions involving the operation of UAS in the National Airspace System.

3. Explanation of Policy Change. The change contained herein provides guidance for handling cases involving persons who operate UAS that interfere with wildfire suppression, law enforcement, or emergency response efforts.

4. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the directive is cancelled by a new directive.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pa!!:es NIA

Dated NIA

Insert Pa!!:es Appendix H, H-6 and H-7

Dated 08/27/18

5. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regions, and centers and to all field offices and facilities.

Daniel K. Elwell Acting Administrator

Distribution: Electronic Initiated By: AGC-300

ORDER 2150.38 U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHG12 CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

National Policy Effective Date:

02/02/17

SUBJ: Changes to FAA Order 2150.3B

1. Purpose. This change to FAA Order 2150.3B amends chapters 2 and 5 to identify the voluntary disclosure program that the FAA Aircraft Certification Service ("AIR") is implementing under Advisory Circular 00-68. This change also amends Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 2016-1, Sanctions for persons who aim a laser beam at an aircraft operating in the air or on the ground in violation of14 C.FR. §§ 91.11, 121.580, 125.328, and

135.120, to comply with section 2104(b) ofThe FAA Extension, Safety, and Security Act of 2016, and to align with the FAA Compliance Philosophy.

2. Who this change affects. The change affects AIR personnel, and all agency personnel who investigate, report, or process enforcement actions involving laser-related interference with crewmember violations ofthe Federal Aviation Regulations.

3. Explanation of Policy Change. This change amends chapters 2 and 5 to identify the voluntary disclosure program that AIR is implementing. In addition, this change amends C&E Bulletin 2016-1 to implement section 2104(b) ofThe FAA Extension, Safety, and Security Act of 2016, which increased the maximum civil penalty that may be imposed on an individual who aims the laser beam ofa laser pointer at "an aircraft in the airspace jurisdiction ofthe United States," or at the flight path of such an aircraft, to $25,000. The amendment to C&E Bulletin 2016-1 allows for compliance or administrative action in the exceedingly rare circumstance of a first-time, single, inadvertent violation covered under C&E Bulletin 2016-1.

4. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the directive is cancelled by a new directive.

5. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regions, and centers and to all field offices and facilities.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pa2es Dated Insert Pa2es Dated 2-7 10/01/07 2-7 02/02/17 5-13 09/03/15 5-13 02/02/17 Appendix H, H-1 thru H-2 02/24/16 Appendix H, H-1 thru H-2 02/02/17

Administrator Distribution: Electronically Initiated By: AGC-300

CHANGE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

National Policy

ORDER 2150.38

Effective Date:

02/24/16

SUBJ: WithdrawaJ of Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 2014-1 from FAA Order 2150.3B, Appendix H.

1. Purpose. This change to FAA Order 2150.3B withdraws Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin No. 201 4-1 from Appendix H. This change also deletes Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 2010-1, which has expired by its terms.

2. Who this cha nge affects. The change affects Aviation Safety (A VS). Flight Standards Service (AFS), and all agency legal counsel who process enforcement actions originating from A VS and AFS.

3. Explanation of Policy Change. The FAA has determined that cases formerly covered under Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin No. 2014-1 are to be evaluated by FAA personnel under the

FAA Compliance Philosophy.

4. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the Order directive is cancelled by a new directive.

5. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regions, and centers and to all field offices and facilities.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Paees Dated Insert Pae:es Dated H-1 thru H-1 0 H-1 thru H-3: 03/30/10; H-1 thru H-5 02/24/16 H-4 thru H-5: 05/01/12; H-6 thru H-7: 06/ 11/14; H-8 thru H-10: 10/ 10/ 14

Administrator

CHANGE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

National Policy

ORDER 2150.3B CHG10

Effective Date:

10/30/15

SUBJ: Clarification on the Applicability of Change 9 Regarding the Implementation of the

FAA Compliance Philosophy

1. Purpose. On September 3, 2015, Chapter 5 of FAA Qrder 2150.3B was changed to adopt new guidance for carrying out the FAA's compliance and enforcement program in connection with the FAA Compliance Philosophy.

2. Who.this change affects. The change affects all agency legal counsel who process enforcement actions and all lines of business and program offices having an oversight function.

3. Explanation of Policy Change. Change 10 is being issued to clarify the applicability of the guidance in Change 9. As of September 3, 2015, regulatory noncompliance is to be evaluated by FAA personnel under the guidance in Change 9. The guidance in Change 9 does not apply to regulatory noncompliance that was the subject of enforcement investigative reports that were referred to the Office of the Chief Counsel for legal enforcement action before September 3. 2015.

4. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the Order directive is cancelled by a new directive. No pages are being added or deleted.

5. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regionst and centers.and to all field offices and facilities.

Administrator

Distribution: Electronic Initiated By: AGC-300

Distribution: Electronic Initiated by: AGC-300

CHANGE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

ORDER 2150.3B CHG 9 National Policy Effective Date:

09/03/15

SUBJ: Guidance for Implementing the FAA Compliance Philosophy

1. Purpose. This change to Chapter 5 of FAA Order 2150.3B adopts new guidance for carrying out the FAA’s compliance and enforcement program in connection with the FAA Compliance Philosophy. In addition, this change removes: the remedial training program guidance from Chapter 5 and Appendix A; Appendix F (Enforcement Decision Process); and C&E Bulletin No. 2014-3. 2. Who this change affects. The change affects all agency legal counsel who process enforcement actions and all lines of business and program offices having an oversight function.

3. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the directive is cancelled by a new directive.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated vi-vii viii xv

10/01/07 01/20/15 05/13/11

vi thru viii and xv 09/03/15

1-5 thru 1-6 10/01/07 1-5 thru 1-6 09/03/15 5-1 thru 5-18 10/01/07 & 10/23/09 5-1 thru 5-19 09/03/15

8-3 10/23/09 8-3 09/03/15 8-7 10/23/09 8-7 09/03/15 i (Appendix A: Sample Documents Table of Contents)

10/01/07 i (Appendix A: Sample Documents Table of Contents)

09/03/15

A-20 thru A-32 10/01/07 A-20 thru A-21 09/03/15 Appendix F (EDP), F-1 thru F-10 10/23/09 NA Compliance & Enforcement Bulletin No. 2014-3, H-11 thru H-13

01/05/15 NA

09/03/15 2150.38 Chg 9

4. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regions, and centers and to all field offices and facilities. i~1<D

Administrator

CHANGE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

National Policy

ORDER 2150.3B

Effective Date:

01/20/15

SUBJ: Settlement Guidance

1. Purpose. This change to FAA Order 2150.3B adopts new guidance for closing legal enforcement actions pursuant to a settlement agreement.

2. Who this change affects. The change affects all agency legal counsel who process enforcement actions.

3. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the directive is cancelled by a new directive.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pae:es Dated Insert Pa2es Dated viii thru xii 10/01/07 viii thru xii 01/20/15 6-5 thru 6-49 10/01/07 6-5 thru 6-50 01/20/15

4. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regions, and centers and to all field offices and facilities. ?A/k'~ b.... Reginald C. Govan u· Chief Counsel

Distribution: Electronic Initiated by: AGC-300

CHANGE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

ORDER 2150.3B CHG 7 National Policy Effective Date:

01/05/15

SUBJ: Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 2014-3: Use of Informal Actions to Address

Regulatory Non-Compliance; Aircraft Certification Service (AIR) Compliance and Enforcement Process

1. Purpose. This change to FAA Order 2150.3B, Compliance and Enforcement Program, implements a new decision process for informal actions for the Aircraft Certification Service (AIR).

2. Who this change affects. The change affects all agency personnel who investigate, report, or process enforcement actions involving regulations governing the design, production, and airworthiness of civil aeronautical products.

3. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the directive is cancelled by a new directive.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

Appendix H, H-11 through H-13 01/05/15

4. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regions, and centers and to all field offices and facilities.

Distribution: Electronic Initiated by: AGC-300

CHANGE

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

National Policy

SUBJ: Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 2014-2:

ORDER 2150.38

Effective Date:

10/10/14

1. Purpose. This change to FAA Order 2150.3B provides guidance on actions applicable to persons who operate: (I) an Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS) in violation of the Federal Aviation Regulations (14 C.F.R.); or (2) a Model Aircraft that endangers the safety of the National Airspace System (e.g., in violation of 14 C.F.R. §§ 91.13-91.15, 91.113, 91.126-135,

91.137-145, and 14 C.F.R. part 73).

2. Who this change affects. The change affects all agency personnel who investigate, report, or process enforcement actions involving the operation ofUAS in the NAS.

3. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the directive is cancelled by a new directive.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pae:es Dated Insert Pae:es Dated Appendix H, H-8 thru H-10 10/10/14

4. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regions, and centers and to all field offices and facilities. ~t!c:[;V

Administrator

Distribution: Electronic Initiated By: AGC-300

CHANGE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

National Policy

SUBJ: Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 2014-1:

ORDER 2150.3B

Effective Date:

06/11/14

I. Purpose. This change to FAA Order 2150.3B provides sanctions applicable to a special emphasis enforcement program for certificate holders who commit violations of 14 C.F.R. §§ 91.133, 91.137, 91.139, 91.141, 91.143, 99.7 and 14 C.F.R. part 93, subpart V and other regulations used to limit operations or to establish conditions for operating in airspace in the United States in the interest of national security.

2. Who this change affects. The change affects all agency personnel who investigate, report, or process enforcement actions involving regulations used to restrict or establish conditions for operation in airspace in the United States in the interest of national security.

3. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the directive is cancelled by a new directive.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated Appendix H, H-6 thru H-7 06/11 /14

4. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regions, and centers and to all field offices and facilities.

Administrator

Distribution: Electronic Initiated By: AGC-300

CHANGE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

National Policy

ORDER 2150.38

Effective Date

05/01/12

Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 2012-1 : Sanction Guidance for Violations of SUBJ: Federal Aviation Regulations in Laser-Related Interference Cases

1. Purpose. This change to FAA Order 2150.3B provides sanction guidance to agency enforcement personnel in initiating and processing laser-related interference with crewmember cases involving violations of 14 C.F.R. §§ 91.11, 121.580, 125.328, and 135.120.

2. Who this change affects. The change affects all agency personnel who investigate, report, or process enforcement actions involving laser-related interference with crewmember violations of the Federal Aviation Regulations.

3. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the directive is cancelled by a new directive.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART

' Remove Pa2es Dated 1 Insert Pa2es Dated Appendix H, H-4 thru H-5 05/01/12

4. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regions, and centers and to all field offices and facilities. J:(/!Jify A=~~chninistrator

Distribution: Electronic Initiated By: AGC-300

CHANGE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

2150.3B CHG 3 Effective Date: National Policy 5/13/2011

SUBJ: Sanction Guidance for Violations of Drug and Alcohol Testing Regulations

1. Purpose. This change to FAA Order 2150.3B amends the sanction guidance for violations of the industry drug and alcohol testing requirements under 14 CFR part 120 (formerly codified at 14 CFR part 121 Appendices I and J). The change provides more specific guidance for determining sanctions in cases where there are multiple violations of certain industry drug and alcohol regulations and amends the prescribed ranges for certain types of violations set forth in Appendix B.

2. Who this change affects. The change affects all agency personnel who investigate, report, or process enforcement actions involving violations of the industry drug and alcohol testing requirements in the Federal Aviation Regulations.

3. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the directive is cancelled by a new directive.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

xiii thru xv 10/01/07 xiii thru xiv 05/13/2011 7-14 thru 7-21 10/01/07 7-14 thru 7-26 05/13/2011 Appendix B, B-31 thru B-52 10/01/07 Appendix B, B-31 thru B-53 05/13/2011

4. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regions, and centers and to all field offices and facilities.

Distribution:A-W-1;A-W (AT/PS/SM)-2; A-W (PP/AM/SF/GCIFS/IA/VS)-3;A-XYZ (A T/AF/CS)-2; Z-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3;A-Y(AM/ARIGC)-3;A-Z(AM/AN/GC)-3; A-FAC/FACIFCS-O;A-F AF/FA T/FIA-O(L TD); ZFS-325

Initiated By: AGC-300

CHANGE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

ORDER 2150.3B CHG 2 Effective Date: National Policy 03/30/2010

SUBJ: Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 2010-1

1. Purpose. This Bulletin is issued in connection with FAA policy statement, “Special Issuance Medical Certificates to Applicants Being Treated with Certain Types of Antidepressants,” [Docket No. FAA-2009-0773], published in the Federal Register on April 1, 2010. In this policy statement, the Federal Air Surgeon has announced that he is now prepared to consider, on a caseby-case basis, applicants who take select antidepressant medications for the special issuance of all classes of medical certification. The FAA wants to encourage airmen to make a complete disclosure regarding a history of or current use of antidepressant medications, the underlying condition for which the antidepressant medication was prescribed, and associated visits to health professionals so that they can be considered for special issuance medical certification. Therefore, the FAA, per the terms of Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 2010-1, will not initiate legal enforcement action against applicants for violations of 14 C.F.R. § 67.403 regarding past medical applications if the applicant discloses a history of antidepressant use, the underlying condition for which the medication was prescribed, and visits to health professionals in connection with the antidepressant use or underlying condition on an application for medical certification made between April 1, 2010 and September 30, 2010.

2. Who this change affects. The change affects all agency personnel who investigate, report, or process enforcement actions regarding holders of airman medical certificates.

3. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 2010-1 is cancelled.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated Appendix H, H-1 thru H-3 03/30/2010

4. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regions, and centers and to all field offices and facilities.

1 Distribution:A-W-1;A-W (AT/PS/SM)-2; A-W (PP/AM/SF/GCIFS/IA/VS)-3;A- Initiated By: AGC-300 XYZ (A T/AF/CS)-2;Z-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3;A-Y(AM/ARIGC)-3;A-Z(AM/AN/GC)-3; A-FAC/FACIFCS-O;A-F AF/FA T/FIA-O(LTD); ZFS-325

CHANGE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

ORDER 2150.3B CHG 1 Effective Date: National Policy 10/23/09

SUBJ: Enforcement Decision Process

1. Purpose. This change to FAA Order 2150.3B modifies the Enforcement Decision Tool (EDT), which agency enforcement personnel use to determine the appropriate action (legal, administrative, informal) to take for noncompliance with regulatory requirements. The change simplifies the enforcement decision process, eliminates redundancies, and provides flexibility to allow program offices to develop specific worksheets and guidance for their organizations.

2. Who this change affects. The change affects all agency personnel who investigate, report, or process enforcement actions.

3. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. Retain this transmittal sheet until the directive is cancelled by a new directive.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

5-1 (and 5-2) 10/01/07 5-1 (and 5-2) 10/23/09 5-5 (and 5-6) 10/01/07 5-5 (and 5-6) 10/23/09 5-11 (and 5-12) 10/01/07 5-11 (and 5-12) 10/23/09 5-14 (and 5-13) 10/01/07 5-14 (and 5-13) 10/23/09 8-3 (and 8-4) 10/01/07 8-3 (and 8-4) 10/23/09 8-7 (and 8-8) 10/01/07 8-7 (and 8-8) 10/23/09 Appendix F, F-1 thru F-15 10/01/07 Appendix F, F-1 thru F-10 10/23/09

4. Administrative Information. This Order change is distributed to divisions and branches in Washington headquarters, regions, and centers and to all field offices and facilities.

J. Randolph Babbitt Administrator

Distribution:A-W-1;A-W (AT/PS/SM)-2;A-W (PP/AM/GC/FS/IA/VS)-3; Initiated By: AGC-300 A-XYZ (AT/)-2;Z-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3;A-Y(AM/GC)-3;A-Z(AM/GC)-3 A-FAC/A-FAF/FAT/FIA-O(LTD); ZFS-325 - -

This order contains policies, procedures, and guidelines for the Federal Aviation Administration's compliance and enforcement program. The order also articulates the FAA's philosophy for using various remedies, including education, corrective action, informal action, remedial training, administrative action, and legal enforcement action, to address noncompliance with statutory and regulatory requirements enforced by the FAA. It provides for the public a written statement of the Administrator's policy guidance for imposing sanctions for violations of such requirements.

The order is used at all levels by agency personnel who are engaged in the investigation, reporting, and processing of enforcement actions. It applies to all offices with regulatory responsibilities.

This revision of the order comprehensively updates policies, procedures, guidance, and assignments of responsibility. It reorganizes the order in a manner more useful for agency personnel and is available electronically to agency personnel and the public. The revision amends agency sanction guidance to conform to statutory changes resulting from Vision 100Century of Aviation Reauthorization Act and incorporates guidance into the agency's compliance and enforcement program order on policies and programs that have developed since the last comprehensive order revision in 1988. Those include policies relating to the FAA's exercise of its authority to administratively assess civil penalties and guidance on the agency's voluntary safety programs.

A workgroup of agency personnel from the field and headquarters with extensive experience in statutory and regulatory enforcement reviewed the agency's policies and programs in this area to produce this comprehensive revision of the agency order on its compliance and enforcement program.

Distribution: A-W-l;A-W (AT/PS/SM)-2;A-W (PP/AM/SF/ Initiated By: AGC-300 GCIFS/IA/VS)-3;A-XYZ (A T/AF/CS)-2;Z-X (AS/AM/GC/FS)-3; A-Y (AM/ARlGC)-3;A-Z (AM/AN/GC)-3;A-FAC/FACIFCS-O; A-F AF/FA T/FIA-O(L TD);ZFS-325

Table of Contents

Chapter 1. Introduction 1. Purpose of this Order … 1-1 2. Whom this Order Affects … 1-1 3. Distribution … 1-1 4. Public Availability … 1-2 5. Cancellations … 1-2 6. Explanation of Changes … 1-2 7. Forms … 1-2 8. Changes to this Order … 1-3 9. Supplemental Compliance and Enforcement Documents … 1-3 10. Compliance and Enforcement Bulletins … 1-3 11. Definitions … 1-3 Chapter 2. Compliance and Enforcement Policy and Objectives 1. Purpose … 2-1 2. The Reason for a Compliance and Enforcement Program … 2-1 a. FAA’s Mission and Authority … 2-1 b. Objective of Compliance and Enforcement Program … 2-1 c. Applicability … 2-1 3. Compliance and Enforcement Philosophy … 2-2 a. Voluntary Compliance … 2-2 b. Education … 2-2 c. Surveillance and Detection … 2-2 d. Notifying Persons of Potential Violations … 2-2 e. Investigation and Reporting … 2-2 f. FAA Responses to Violations and Purposes for Compliance and Enforcement Actions … 2-2 g. Fairness … 2-3 h. Timeliness … 2-3 i. Recommendations of Inspectors, Special Agents, Field Offices, and Regional Offices … 2-4 j. FAA Legal Enforcement Actions; Sanction Guidance Policy … 2-4 4. Responsibility for Determining Legal Enforcement Action … 2-4 a. General … 2-4 b. Responsibilities of FAA Investigative Personnel … 2-4 c. Responsibilities of Regional and Washington Headquarters Program Office Personnel … 2-5 d. Responsibilities of Legal Counsel … 2-6 e. Sanction Determinations in Significant Cases … 2-6 5. Voluntary Safety Programs … 2-6 a. Background … 2-6 b. Voluntary Disclosure Reporting Program … 2-7 c. Flight Operational Quality Assurance (FOQA) Programs … 2-7

i

d. Aviation Safety Action Program (ASAP) … 2-8 e. NASA Aviation Safety Reporting Program (ASRP) … 2-8 6. Enforcement Priorities … 2-9 a. Legal Enforcement Case Reviews … 2-9 b. Special Emphasis Enforcement Programs … 2-10 7. Formal Complaints … 2-11 a. Authority to Investigate Violations of 49 U.S.C. subtitle VII, Part A………… 2-11 b. Procedures … 2-11 c. Contents of the Formal Complaint … 2-11 d. Response to the Complaint … 2-11 e. Disposition of the Formal Complaint … 2-12 f. Complaints against Members of the U.S. Armed Forces … 2-12 8. Public Disclosure of Enforcement Action Documents … 2-12 a. Actions against Individuals … 2-12 b. Actions against Entities … 2-13 c. Release to Alleged Violator or Counsel … 2-13 d. Information Generally Not Released … 2-13 e. Copies of Initial Enforcement Action Documents … 2-13 f. Protection of Voluntarily Submitted Information … 2-14 9. Publicizing Enforcement Actions … 2-14 a. General … 2-14 b. Monthly Reports … 2-14 c. News Releases … 2-14 d. Advance Notice of a News Release … 2-15 e. Releasing Information before Issuance of Release … 2-15 f.

Negotiating a News Release … 2-15 g. Providing Information to the Office of Public Affairs … 2-15 h. Coordinating News Releases and Monthly Reports … 2-15 i. Quarterly Reports … 2-15 10. Expunction Policy … 2-15 a. General … 2-15 b. Expunction Periods for Certain Enforcement Actions … 2-15 c. Certificate Revocation Actions … 2-16 d. Applicability … 2-16 e. Expunction from EIS … 2-17 f. Expunction of Records of Individuals Not Located … 2-17 g. Effect of Subsequent Enforcement Actions … 2-17 h. Expunction of Combined Enforcement Actions … 2-18 i. Requests to Expunge Records … 2-18 j. Negotiations … 2-18 11. Enforcement Document Destruction Requirements … 2-18 12. Release of Investigative Material … 2-18 Chapter 3. Enforcement Responsibilities of FAA Offices 1. Purpose and Authorities … 3-1 a. Statutory Authorities … 3-1

ii

b. Delegations of Authority … 3-3 2. Coordination and Delegation within FAA … 3-3 a. Cooperation and Communication within FAA … 3-3 b. Early Agency Coordination in Emergency Actions … 3-3 c. Coordination of an Investigation … 3-3 3. Investigating and Processing Enforcement Cases under the Geographic Concept … 3-3 a. Explanation of Geographic Concept … 3-3 b. Supporting Field Offices and Regions … 3-4 c. Transfer of Cases by Investigating Field Office … 3-4 d. Transfer of Cases by Regional Office … 3-5 e. Notification of Case Closure … 3-5 4. Complex or Controversial Enforcement Cases … 3-5 a. General … 3-5 b. How to Identify a Complex or Controversial Case … 3-5 c. Notification of Complex or Controversial Case … 3-6 d. Participation by FAA Legal Counsel … 3-6 5. Specific FAA Office and FAA Employee Responsibilities … 3-6 a. Compliance and Enforcement Responsibilities of All FAA Employees……… 3-6 b. Headquarters Offices … 3-7 c. Regional Offices … 3-7 d. Drug Abatement Division Branches and Centers … 3-8 e. Field Offices … 3-8 f. Air Traffic Organization … 3-8 6.

Coordination with Other Agencies outside FAA … 3-8 a. General … 3-8 b. DOT Office of Inspector General … 3-9 c. Department of Labor – Whistleblower Protection Program … 3-9 d. Investigation of Stolen Aircraft … 3-10 e. Notification to DOD and DOT when Air Carrier Operating Certificate is Suspended or Revoked … 3-10 7. Liability of FAA Employees … 3-10 a. Background … 3-10 b. Constitutional Torts … 3-10 c. Indemnification of Agency Employees … 3-11 d. Scope of Employment … 3-11 e. Notification to Counsel … 3-11 Chapter 4. Investigation of Violations 1. Purpose … 4-1 2. Role of FAA Investigative Personnel … 4-1 a. Enforcement Investigations … 4-1 b. Aircraft Accident Investigations … 4-1 3. Authority to Conduct Inspections or Investigations on Private Property … 4-3 a. General … 4-3

iii

b. Constitutional Protections for Inspections or Investigations on Private Property … 4-3 c. Open-Fields Exception … 4-3 d. Non-Public Commercial Premises … 4-3 e. Regulatory Requirements to Permit Inspection … 4-3 f. Remedies if Access Denied … 4-4 g. Administrative Inspection Warrant … 4-4 4. Planning and Coordinating the Investigation … 4-4 a. Planning the Investigation … 4-4 b. EIR Number … 4-5 c. Coordination with Supporting Offices … 4-5 d. Communications with Counsel during Investigation … 4-5 e. Timeliness Goals … 4-5 5. Time Limitations in Cases Involving Certificate Suspensions or Revocations…. 4-5 a. Exceptions to Stale Complaint Rule … 4-5 b. Definitions … 4-6 c. Examples … 4-6 6. Time Limitations in Cases Involving Civil Penalties (CP) … 4-7 a. Civil Penalty Cases against Persons Acting as Pilots, Flight Engineers, Mechanics, and Repairmen … 4-7 b. Civil Penalties against a Person (Except an Individual Acting as a Pilot, Flight Engineer, Mechanic, or Repairman) for Violations Occurring before December 12, 2003 … 4-7 c.

Civil Penalties against a Person (Except an Individual Acting as a Pilot, Flight Engineer, Mechanic, or Repairman) for Violations Occurring on or after December 12, 2003 … 4-8 d. Action Required to Comply with 5-Year Statute of Limitations … 4-8 7. Practical Considerations Relating to Time Limitations for FAA Investigative Personnel … 4-8 a. Special Requirement for NTSB Cases … 4-8 b. Diligence and Documentation … 4-8 8. Principles for Applying Investigative Findings to Regulations Believed Violated … 4-10 a. Enforceable Regulations … 4-10 b. Elements of Regulations … 4-10 c. Burden and Standard of Proof … 4-10 d. Relevance and Materiality … 4-10 9. Letter of Investigation and Response … 4-10 a. General … 4-10 b. Preparation of the LOI … 4-11 c. Sending the LOI to the Apparent Violator … 4-12 d. Distribution of LOI … 4-12 10. Evidence … 4-12 a. General … 4-12 b. Hearsay Evidence … 4-13 c. Types of Evidence … 4-13

iv

d. Evidence that Cannot be Used in an Enforcement Action … 4-23 e. Submission of Additional Evidence before Final Disposition of Enforcement Action … 4-24 11. Analysis of Careless or Reckless Operations … 4-24 12. Special Enforcement Consideration—Immunity for Persons Who Provide Information about Violations … 4-24 a. General … 4-24 b. Background … 4-25 c. Policy … 4-25 d. Factors to be Considered … 4-25 e. Criminal Violations … 4-26 f. Receipt of Request for Special Enforcement Consideration or Immunity … 4-26 g. Role of Headquarters or Regional Division Office … 4-26 h. Role of Legal Counsel … 4-27 i. Preparation of Request for Special Enforcement Consideration … 4-27 13. Investigation of Crewmembers for Operating under the Influence of Alcohol or Drugs … 4-27 a. General … 4-27 b. Applicable Regulations … 4-28 c. Notifications … 4-28 d. Conducting the Investigation on the Scene … 4-29 e. Conducting the Investigation Not on Scene … 4-31 f. Gathering Evidence … 4-31 g. Making Evaluations and Recommendations … 4-32 h. Privacy Act Considerations … 4-32 14.

Violations by Unruly Passengers … 4-32 a. General … 4-32 b. The Scope of the Interference Regulations vs. the Scope of the Statute … 4-33 c. When to Charge a Violation Under the Provisions of the Interference Regulations and 49 U.S.C. § 46318 … 4-33 15. Special Considerations for Investigations of Hazardous Materials Violations…… 4-34 a. Written Hazardous Materials Incident Reports … 4-34 b. Violation by an Operator under a DOT Exemption … 4-34 c. Violations Involving Air Transportation outside the U.S … 4-34 16. Formal Fact-Finding Using Order of Investigation … 4-35 a. Purpose … 4-35 b. Authority … 4-35 c. Use of the Formal Fact-Finding Investigation … 4-35 d. Requests for Formal Fact-Finding Investigations … 4-35 e. Initiating the Formal Fact-Finding Investigation and Issuance of Order of Investigation … 4-35 f. Investigative Procedures and Conduct of the Formal Fact-Finding Investigation … 4-35 17. Administrative Subpoenas … 4-36

v

09/03/15 2150.3B Chg 9

vi

a. Use of Administrative Subpoenas … 4-36 b. General Guidelines for the Use of Administrative Subpoenas … 4-36 c. Requesting an Administrative Subpoena … 4-36 d. Service of an Administrative Subpoena … 4-37 e. Information Required to be Produced … 4-37 f. Judicial Enforcement … 4-37 18. Criminal Investigations … 4-37 a. Coordination of Possible Criminal Violations … 4-37 b. Concurrent Civil and Criminal Investigations … 4-38 c. Examples of Criminal Violations … 4-39 19. Public Aircraft Operations … 4-40 a. Analysis for Determining Public Aircraft or Civil Aircraft Status … 4-40 b. Definition of a Public Aircraft Operation … 4-40 c. Circumstances when a Government-Owned Aircraft is subject to Civil Aircraft Requirements … 4-40 d. Enforcement Actions against Airmen for matters involving Public-Owned Aircraft … 4-41 e. Evidence of Civil Aircraft Status … 4-41 f. Additional Guidance on Public Aircraft … 4-41 20. Investigations for Referral to the Military … 4-41 a. General … 4-41 b. Investigation of Violation involving Member of Military … 4-41 c. Processing of EIR for Referral … 4-42 d.

Incidents Requiring Complete Investigation … 4-42 21. Investigations of Violations of Foreign Aviation Regulations … 4-42 a. General … 4-42 b. Conducting an Investigation … 4-42 22. Investigations of Violations of FAA Regulations by Persons Residing in Foreign Countries … 4-43 23. Investigations of Drug Positive Test Results and Alcohol Violations … 4-43 Chapter 5. Compliance and Enforcement Actions and Enforcement Actions and Responsibilities of the FAA Lines of Business 1. Purpose … 5-1 2. FAA Responses to Non-Regulatory Noncompliance … 5-1 3. Compliance Action … 5-2 a. Noncompliance … 5-2 b. Non-Regulatory Compliance Action Determinations … 5-3 4. Administrative Action … 5-3 a. Criteria … 5-3 b. Types of Administrative Actions … 5-4 c. Follow-Up Inspection to Verify Completed Corrective Action … 5-4 d. Failure to Fulfill Agreement To Take Corrective Action … 5-4 e. Streamlined No Action and Administrative Action Process (SNAAP)………… 5-5 5. Legal Enforcement Action … 5-5 a. Intentional Conduct … 5-5 b. Reckless Conduct … 5-5

09/03/15 2150.3B Chg 9

vii

c. Failure to Complete Corrective Action … 5-5 d. Conduct Creating or Threatening to Create an Unacceptable Risk to Safety.… 5-5 e. Legal Enforcement Action Required by Law … 5-5 f. Justified Exception … 5-5 6. Repeated Noncompliance … 5-6 7. Accurate Data … 5-6 8. Matters Pertaining to Certificate Holder’s Competency or Qualification … 5-7 9. Law Enforcement-Related Activities … 5-7 10. FAA’s Office of Security and Hazardous Materials Safety (ASH) Program (HMSP): Treatment of Non-Certificated Persons … 5-7 a. Informal Action … 5-8 b. Administrative Action … 5-8 c. Safety Risk … 5-9 d. Justifiable Deviations … 5-9 11. Reinspection and Reexamination … 5-9 a. General … 5-9 b. Procedures for Reexamination … 5-10 c. Failure to Submit to Reexamination or Reinspection … 5-10 d. Unsuccessful Reexamination or Reinspection … 5-11 12. Voluntary Disclosure Reporting Program for Certain Violations of the Federal Aviation Regulations … 5-12 a. General … 5-12 b. Internal Evaluation Procedures … 5-12 c. Applicability of Voluntary Disclosure Reporting Program … 5-13 d.

Guidance for Program Participation … 5-13 e. Criteria for Acceptance of Voluntary Disclosure … 5-13 f. Investigation of Voluntary Disclosure … 5-13 g. EIR for a Voluntary Disclosure … 5-13 h. Letter of Correction under Voluntary Disclosure Reporting Program … 5-14 13. Voluntary Disclosure Reporting Program for Certain Violations of the Hazardous Materials Regulations … 5-14 a. General … 5-14 b. Applicability … 5-14 c. Guidance for Program Participation … 5-14 d. Criteria for Acceptance of Voluntary Disclosure … 5-14 14. Voluntary Surrender of Certificate … 5-15 a. Purpose … 5-14 b. Surrender of FAA Certificate for Cancellation … 5-15 15. Legal Enforcement Actions … 5-15 a. General … 5-15 b. Certificate Actions … 5-16 c. Deferred Suspension of Certificates … 5-16 d. Suspension or Revocation of Airman Medical Certificates … 5-16 e. Emergency Certificate Action … 5-17 f. Civil Penalties … 5-17 g. Informal Conferences … 5-18 h. Liens on Aircraft … 5-18

09/03/15 2150.3B Chg 9

viii

i. Seizures of Aircraft … 5-18 j. Injunctions … 5-18 k. Cease and Desist Orders, Orders of Compliance, and Other Orders … 5-19 l. Airman Medical Certificate Denials … 5-19 m. Other Airman Certificate Denials … 5-19 Chapter 6. Legal Enforcement Actions and Legal Counsel Responsibilities 1. Purpose … 6-1 2. Prosecutorial Discretion … 6-1 3. Coordination with Headquarters through Enforcement Alerts … 6-1 a. General … 6-1 b. Coordination of Initial Legal Enforcement Action with Headquarters………. 6-1 c. How to Coordinate a Significant Initial Legal Enforcement Action … 6-2 4. Coordination of Appeals … 6-2 a. Contacting AGC-300 … 6-2 b. FAA Appeals … 6-2 c. Handling of Appeal … 6-3 5. Informal Conferences … 6-3 a. Purpose and Policy … 6-3 b. Procedure … 6-4 6. Consolidating Civil Penalty Actions … 6-5 7. Closing Cases … 6-5 a. Closing Cases Before Initiation of Legal Action … 6-5 b. Closing Cases after Initiation of Legal Action … 6-5 c. Closing Cases Pursuant to a Settlement Agreement … 6-5 d. Downgrading from Legal Enforcement Action to Administrative Action…… 6-6 8.

Certificate Actions Reviewable by the NTSB … 6-7 a. General … 6-7 b. Hearings before NTSB Administrative Law Judges … 6-7 c. Appeals of Initial Decisions … 6-7 d. Time Limitations in NTSB Cases … 6-7 e. NTSB Deference to FAA … 6-8 9. Emergency Suspension or Revocation of Certificates … 6-8 a. Authority … 6-8 b. Limitation … 6-8 c. Form and Content of Emergency Order … 6-9 d. Criteria for Emergency Action … 6-9 e. Timeliness of Emergency Action … 6-10 f. Emergency Suspension Pending Reexamination … 6-10 g. Prohibition against Combination of Emergency and Nonemergency Actions … 6-10 h. Petition for Review of Emergency Determination … 6-10

01/20/15 2150.3B, Chg 8

Nonemergency Actions … 6-10 h. Petition for Review of Emergency Determination … 6-10 i. Petition for Review of Immediately Effective Orders … 6-10 j. Hearings before NTSB in Cases Involving Emergency and Other Immediately Effective Orders … 6-11 k. Appeal on the Merits to the NTSB … 6-11 l. Judicial Appeals … 6-11 10. Nonemergency Certificate Actions … 6-11 a. Notice of Proposed Certificate Action … 6-11 b. Attachments to the Notice … 6-12 c. Alternatives for Responding to Notice … 6-12 d. Notice of Proposed Certificate Action in Deferred Suspension Cases … 6-12 e. Reevaluating the Case … 6-13 f. Orders of Suspension or Revocation … 6-13 g. Service of Notice or Order … 6-13 h. Voluntary Surrender of Certificate Pending the Appeal of an Order of Suspension … 6-14 11. Airman Medical Certificate Denials Process … 6-14 a. General … 6-14 b. Appeals to the NTSB … 6-14 12. Airman Certificate Denials (Other than Medical) … 6-15 a. Legal Processing … 6-15 b. NTSB Appeals and Judicial Review of NTSB Decisions … 6-15 13. Suspension or Revocation of Airman Medical Certificates … 6-15 a.

Responsibility … 6-15 b. Refusal to Submit to Reexamination … 6-15 c. Failure to Release Medical Information … 6-15 d. Medical Disqualification … 6-15 e. Intentional Falsification of Application or Certificate … 6-15 f. Incorrect Statement on Application … 6-16 14. Civil Penalty Action under 49 U.S.C. § 46301(d) (5) Involving an Amount in Controversy Not Exceeding $50,000 against an Individual Acting as a Pilot, Flight Engineer, Mechanic, or Repairman … 6-16 a. General … 6-16 b. Initiation of Civil Penalty Action … 6-16 c. Time for the Alleged Violator to Respond to a Notice … 6-16 d. Alternatives for Responding to Notice … 6-17 e. Reevaluating the Case … 6-17 f. Compromise Order … 6-17 g. Order of Assessment … 6-17 h. Service of Notice or Order … 6-18 i. Appeals to the National Transportation Safety Board … 6-18 j. Judicial Review … 6-18 15. Aircraft Registration Violations … 6-18 a. General … 6-18 b. Pink Slip … 6-18

ix

01/20/15 2150.3B, Chg 8

c. Effectivity of Registration Certificate … 6-19 d. Requirements … 6-19 e. Certificate Action … 6-19 f. Enforcement Responsibilities … 6-19 g. Appeals … 6-19 16. Civil Penalty Actions under 49 U.S.C. § 46301 Reviewable by FAA Decisionmaker … 6-19 a. General … 6-19 b. Separation of Functions … 6-19 c. Notice of Proposed Civil Penalty … 6-20 d. Attachments to the Notice … 6-20 e. Time for Submission of a Response by the Respondent … 6-20 f. Alternatives for Responding to Notice … 6-20 g. Reevaluating the Case … 6-20 h. Compromise Order … 6-21 i. Final Notice of Proposed Civil Penalty … 6-21 j. Order Assessing Civil Penalty … 6-21 k. Service of Notice, Final Notice, or Order … 6-22 l. Hearings … 6-22 m. Appeals to the FAA Decisionmaker … 6-22 n. Judicial Review of Decisions of the FAA Decisionmaker … 6-22 17. Legal Enforcement Actions under the Commercial Space Launch Act of 1984 (49 U.S.C. §§ 70101, et seq.) … 6-22 a. General … 6-22 b. License Actions … 6-23 c. Civil Penalty Actions … 6-23 18.

Civil Penalty Actions under the Federal Hazardous Materials Transportation Law (49 U.S.C. §§ 5101, et. seq.) … 6-26 a. General … 6-26 b. Civil Penalty Guidelines … 6-26 c. Criminal Actions … 6-27 d. Investigation and Reporting of Possible Violations; Processing of EIRs…….. 6-27 e. Sanction Guidance … 6-27 f. For Commercial Purposes … 6-27 g. Determining the Type of Enforcement Action and Sanction Required………. 6-28 19. Civil Penalties in Excess of Assessment Authority Limits of $50,000 or $400,000 … 6-30 a. General … 6-30 b. Initial Civil Penalty Action … 6-30 c. Alternatives for Responding to Civil Penalty Letter … 6-31 d. Settlement … 6-31 e. Referral to U.S. Attorney … 6-31 20. Other Enforcement Actions Reviewable by U.S. Courts of Appeal … 6-31 a. Authority … 6-31 b. Procedures … 6-32 c. Cease and Desist Orders, Orders of Compliance, and Injunctions … 6-32

x

01/20/15 2150.3B, Chg 8

d. Injunctions … 6-32 e. Seizure of Aircraft … 6-33 f. Judicial Proceedings … 6-35 g. Release of Seized Aircraft … 6-35 21. Orders of Compliance, Consent Orders of Compliance, Civil Actions to Require Compliance as Authorized under the Federal Hazardous Materials Law … 6-36 a. Authority … 6-36 b. Responsibility of Legal Counsel … 6-36 c. Procedures for Filing a Civil Action … 6-36 d. Order of Compliance Involving Other than Imminent Hazard … 6-36 e. Imminent Hazard … 6-38 22. Criminal Penalties for Hazardous Materials Violations … 6-38 a. Handling of Criminal Cases … 6-38 b. Parallel Civil Case … 6-39 23. Certificate Actions in Response to a Security Threat … 6-39 24. Oral or Written Emergency Orders in Alcohol and Drug Cases … 6-39 25. Timeliness Goals … 6-39 26. Procedures for Bankrupt Respondents … 6-40 a. Purpose … 6-40 b. General … 6-40 c. Automatic Stay … 6-40 d. Pre-Petition Claims … 6-40 e. Post-Petition Administrative Claims … 6-42 f. The Role of the Enforcement Division, AGC-300 … 6-42 g. Bankruptcy Impact on Active Civil Penalty Cases … 6-42 h.

Settlement of Pre-Petition Claims … 6-43 i. Setoff Funds Owing to Debtors … 6-43 j. Bankruptcy Petitions Filed by Foreign Persons … 6-43 k. Debtor’s Emergence from Bankruptcy … 6-43 27. Consent Orders … 6-43 28. Documenting Changes in Proposed Sanctions … 6-44 29. Application of Servicemembers Civil Relief Act … 6-44 30. Waiver of Mandatory 49 U.S.C. § 44710 and 49 U.S.C. § 44726 Certificate Revocations or 49 U.S.C. § 44703(f) and 49 U.S.C. § 44726(a) Certificate Denials … 6-44 a. Authority … 6-44 b. Processing a Request for a Waiver of Revocation or Denial … 6-45 31. Procedures for Recovering Certificates and Related Enforcement Actions………. 6-46 a. Issuance of a Demand Letter … 6-46 b. Civil Penalty Action for Failure to Surrender … 6-46 c. Continued Failure to Surrender … 6-46 32. Procedures for the Collection of Administratively Assessed Civil Penalties…….. 6-46 a. Applicability … 6-46 b. Procedures for Cases Where Hearing is Not Requested … 6-46 c. Procedures for Cases Where Hearing is Requested … 6-47

xi

01/20/15 2150.3B, Chg 8

d. Opening an Account Receivable … 6-48 e. Compromise Orders … 6-48 f. Installment Payments … 6-49 g. Handling of Debt after an Account Receivable is Opened … 6-49 h. Actions to Collect Debts … 6-49 i. Referrals to the Department of Justice … 6-49 j. Payments Received by Legal Counsel … 6-50 33. Violations of Foreign Regulations by U.S. Citizens or Companies … 6-50 34. Violations of FAA Regulations by Foreign Persons … 6-50 a. General … 6-50 b. Preparation of Referral to Foreign Authority … 6-50 c. Notification of Legal Enforcement Action Taken … 6-50 Chapter 7. Sanction Guidance Policies 1. Purpose … 7-1 2. General Guidelines … 7-1 a. Certificate Suspension Action and Civil Penalty Action: Sanctions for Punitive and Deterrent Purposes … 7-1 b. Legal Sanctions for Remedial Purposes … 7-1 3. Applicability and Exclusions … 7-3 a. Decisions to Take Administrative Action (Warning Notices or Letters of Correction) … 7-3 b. The FAA’s Exercise of Prosecutorial Discretion … 7-3 c. Hazardous Materials Violations … 7-3 d. Violations by Members of the U.S. Armed Forces … 7-3 4.

Mitigating or Aggravating Factors and Elements … 7-4 a. Nature of the Violation … 7-4 b. Whether the Violation was Inadvertent or Not Deliberate … 7-5 c. Certificate Holder’s Level of Experience … 7-5 d. Attitude of the Violator … 7-5 e. Degree of Hazard … 7-6 f. Action Taken by Employer or Other Authority … 7-6 g. Use of a Certificate … 7-7 h. Violation or Incident History … 7-7 i. Decisional Law … 7-7 j. Ability to Absorb Sanction … 7-8 k. Consistency of Sanction … 7-8 l. Whether the Violation was Reported Voluntarily … 7-8 m. Corrective Action … 7-8 5. Use of the Table of Sanctions … 7-9 a. General … 7-9 b. Single, First-time, Inadvertent Violations … 7-9 c. Types of Sanction … 7-10 6. General Guidance on Multiple Acts or Multiple Violations … 7-10 a. Description of Multiple Violations … 7-10 b. General Sanction Guidance … 7-10

xii

05/13/11 2150.3B, Chg 3

c. Single Act of Noncompliance Resulting in Multiple Violations … 7-10 d. Type of Legal Enforcement Action … 7-11 7. Special Considerations for Numerous Multiple Violations Resulting from an Initial Act or Omission … 7-11 a. Determining Proposed Penalty … 7-11 b. Limitations on Total Civil Penalty Amounts for Numerous Multiple Violations … 7-12 c. Penalties Outside the Ranges … 7-13 d. Intentional Violations … 7-13 e. Civil Complaints … 7-14 8. Modification … 7-14 a. Type of Sanction … 7-14 b. Amount of Sanction … 7-14 9. Special Emphasis Enforcement Programs … 7-14 10. Small Entities … 7-14 a. General … 7-14 b. FAA’s Policy under the SBREFA … 7-15 c. The Small Business Ombudsman … 7-16 11. Remedial Sanction Guidance Policy … 7-16 a. General … 7-16 b. Misconduct Generally Warranting Revocation … 7-17 c. Intentionally False or Fraudulent Statements … 7-18 12. General Guidance for Using the Sanction Guidance Table for Unruly Passenger Conduct Under 49 U.S.C. § 46318 … 7-19 a. General Purpose and Policy … 7-19 b. Additional Aggravating Factors to Consider … 7-19 c.

Additional Mitigating Factors to Consider … 7-20 d. When to Apply the Sanction Range for Acts Posing an “Imminent Threat” to Safety of the Aircraft or Others on Board the Aircraft… 7-20 e. Applicable Sanction Ranges for Security Officers or Others Assigned a Law Enforcement Function on a Flight (for example, Federal Air Marshals Assigned to the Flight) … 7-21 f. Applying Unruly Passenger Sanction Guidance Tables to Multiple Acts……. 7-21 Chapter 8. Enforcement Investigative Report 1. Purpose for EIR … 8-1 2. EIR Recommendations … 8-1 3. Organization of an EIR … 8-1 a. Section A. FAA Form 2150-5 … 8-1 b. Section B. Statement of Case and Factors Affecting Sanction … 8-1 c. Section C. Items of Proof … 8-3 4. Preparation of Form 2150-5 … 8-3 a. EIR Number … 8-3 b. Instructions for Completing Blocks 1-33 on Form 2150-5 … 8-4 5. Entry of Information in the EIS to Track Enforcement Actions Against Small Business Concerns … 8-7

xiii

05/13/11 2150.3B, Chg 3

5. Sections of EIR Required for Types of Action … 8-7 a. Legal Enforcement Action … 8-7 b. Administrative Action … 8-7 c. No Action Cases … 8-8 d. Criminal Enforcement Action … 8-8 6. Processing an EIR … 8-8 a. Administrative Action EIRs … 8-8 b. Legal Enforcement Action EIRs … 8-8 7. Reports Requiring Special Processing … 8-10 a. Violations Involving Members of the U.S.Armed Forces … 8-10 b. Requests for Emergency Action Based on Partial EIR … 8-10 c. Processing of EIRs for Noise Violations … 8-10 8. Use of For Official Use Only Designation … 8-10 Chapter 9. Enforcement Information System (EIS) and Distribution Requirements 1. Purpose … 9-1 2. Enforcement Information System Overview … 9-1 a. General … 9-1 b. EIS Capabilities … 9-1 c. Data Entry … 9-1 d. Access to Data … 9-1 e. Security … 9-1 f. Annual EIS Database Review and Reconciliation … 9-1 3. EIS Entries … 9-1 a. Initiating EIS Records … 9-1 b. Data Entry … 9-2 c. Pending Status … 9-3 d. Closing an EIS Record … 9-3 4. Operations … 9-3 a. System Design … 9-3 b. Code Tables … 9-4 c. Error Checking … 9-4 d. Online Help … 9-4 e. Standard Reports … 9-4 f. Ad-Hoc Reports … 9-5 5. EIS Database … 9-5 a. General … 9-5 b. Functions … 9-5 c. Regional Tracking System … 9-5 d. Assistance for Statistical Analysis … 9-5 6. Distribution of Enforcement Documents … 9-5 a. General … 9-5 b. Administrative Enforcement Actions … 9-6 c. Legal Enforcement Actions or Referrals … 9-6 d. Legal Enforcement Documents … 9-6

xiv

09/03/15 2150.3B Chg 9

xv

7. System Support … 9-7 a. EIS System Manager … 9-7 b. AVR Support Central … 9-7 c. User Comments … 9-7 Appendixes Appendix A: Sample Documents Appendix B: Table of Sanctions for All Enforcement Programs, Except Hazardous Materials Appendix C: Sanction Guidance—Hazardous Materials Enforcement Appendix D: Selected Statutes Appendix E: Examples Appendix F: (Deleted) Appendix G: FAA Form 2150-5, Codes for Blocks 19-24 Appendix H: Compliance and Enforcement Bulletins

Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin No. 2010-1: Forgoing enforcement action for persons who disclose previous falsification on applications for airman medical certification regarding the use of antidepressant medication, the underlying condition for which the antidepressant was prescribed, and visits to health professionals in connection with the antidepressant use or underlying condition. H-1

Chapter 1. Introduction

1. Purpose of this Order. This order describes the authority, responsibilities, policies, guidelines, procedures, objectives, and legal aspects of the Federal Aviation Administration’s compliance and enforcement program. The policies and procedures described in this order explain how the FAA generally intends to exercise its discretion in carrying out statutory and regulatory enforcement responsibilities.

2. Whom This Order Affects.

a. This order applies to the compliance and enforcement programs and activities of all FAA offices that have regulatory responsibilities. These offices include the Flight Standards Service, Aircraft Certification Service, Office of Aerospace Medicine, Office of Airports, Office of Security and Hazardous Materials, and Office of Commercial Space Transportation.

b. This order is a staff manual. It guides FAA enforcement personnel in the exercise of their discretion in handling compliance and enforcement matters. However, it does not cover every situation, and there will be situations where deviation is warranted, and FAA personnel are expected to use their experience and sound judgment in carrying out their compliance and enforcement responsibilities.

c. This order does not create any right or benefit, substantive or procedural, enforceable at law by any party against the FAA, its officers, or its employees.

3. Distribution. The FAA distributes this order as follows:

a. To the associate administrator and assistant administrator level in Washington, D.C., the regional administrator level, the center director level, and the Chief Operations Officer of the Air Traffic Organization.

b. To the director level in the offices of the Associate Administrator for Aviation Safety; the Associate Administrator for Airports; the Assistant Administrator for Security and Hazardous Materials; the Assistant Administrator for Aviation Policy, Planning, and Environment; and the Assistant Administrator for International Aviation, and the Vice President level in the Office of the COO, Air Traffic Organization.

c. To the division level in the regional Air Traffic Organization offices and the field offices of the ATO.

d. To the branch level in the regional Airports, Aerospace Medicine, Security and Hazardous Materials, and Flight Standards Divisions, and Aircraft Certification Directorates.

e. To the branch level at the Civil Aerospace Medical Institute, Airmen and Aircraft Registry, FAA Academy, and in the Security and Investigations Division at the Aeronautical Center.

f. A maximum distribution to all Airports field offices, Flight Standards field offices, Manufacturing Inspection District offices, Security and Hazardous Materials field offices, and the Offices of the Regional and Center Counsel.

g. A limited distribution to all field offices of the Air Traffic Organization and International Field Offices.

4. Where can I find this order? You can find this order at https://employees.faa.gov/tools_resources/orders_notices. This order is available to the public on the internet at http://rgl.faa.gov. Interested persons may obtain copies by contacting the Office of the Chief Counsel, Enforcement Division, AGC-300, 800 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC 20591.

5. Cancellations. This order cancels all parts of FAA Order 2150.3A, Compliance and Enforcement Program, December 14, 1988, except Appendix 4 and any other guidance about determining sanction amounts.

6. Explanation of Changes. This order substantially edits FAA Order 2150.3A. The following major changes have been made:

a. Sanction guidance has been revised to conform to new statutory maximum civil penalty amounts under Vision 100—Century of Aviation Reauthorization Act.

b. Policies previously issued by memorandums have been incorporated into FAA Order 2150.3B.

c. Expired policies have been removed from the order.

d. Programs, policies, or procedures that applied only to security matters and responsibilities transferred to the Transportation Security Administration have been removed.

e. Guidance has been added about the aviation safety action programs and the flight operational quality assurance programs.

f. Policies about the voluntary surrender of certificates have been added.

g. The policy on publicizing enforcement actions has been revised.

h. The responsibilities of agency personnel relating to the determination of sanctions have been revised.

7. Forms. The FAA uses the forms identified in chapter 1, subparagraphs 7.a.-c. in the agency’s compliance and enforcement program. Form 2150-5 is available electronically on the Enforcement Information System. Forms 5280-6 and 1600-70 are available at the FAA Depot at the Mike Monroney Aeronautical Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma.

a. FAA Form 2150-5, Enforcement Investigative Report, unit of issue: Sheet, NSN: 0052­ 00-875-8000. All FAA program offices use this form for reporting enforcement investigations.

b. FAA Form 5280-6, Letter of Correction, unit of issue: 5-page set, NSN: 0052-00-881­ 2000. FAA airport certification offices use this form to report and gain correction of violations of part 139 of the FAA’s regulations.

c. FAA Form 1600-70 (1-90), Chain of Custody Form. FAA investigative personnel use this form to track the chain of custody of physical evidence in enforcement cases.

8. Changes to This Order.

a. Authority to Approve Changes. The Administrator approves changes to Chapter 1, Introduction; Chapter 2, Enforcement Objectives and Policy; and Chapter 3, Enforcement Responsibilities, that involve policy, a delegation of the Administrator’s authority, or an assignment of responsibility. The Chief Counsel approves all other changes to the order. The Administrator’s and Chief Counsel’s authorities to approve changes may not be delegated.

b. Submission of Comments and Proposed Changes. Any FAA employee may send proposed changes to, or provide comments on, this order by electronic mail (e-mail) to the Assistant Chief Counsel for Enforcement (AGC-300). AGC-300 considers any proposed changes or comments when reviewing and revalidating this order.

9. Supplemental Compliance and Enforcement Documents. To assure uniformity in policy and instructions, headquarters offices and the regions must, before issuance, provide AGC-300 for coordination and concurrence a copy by e-mail of all compliance and enforcement guidance, instructions, or other documents that are intended to supplement this order.

10. Compliance and Enforcement Bulletins. The FAA may issue short-term or urgent directives of fixed duration or special emphasis programs as Compliance and Enforcement Bulletins (C&E Bulletins). Appendix H of this order contains any current C&E Bulletins. C&E Bulletins will state when they supersede sections of this order.

11. Definitions. The following abbreviations, acronyms, or identifiers and associated definitions are applicable to this order unless otherwise indicated:

“AC” means Advisory Circular.

“ADP” means Automatic Data Processing.

“AGC-1” means Chief Counsel of the Federal Aviation Administration.

“AGC-300” means Assistant Chief Counsel for Enforcement.

“AIDS” means Accident/Incident Data System.

“ALJ” means Administrative Law Judge.

“ASAP” means Aviation Safety Action Program.

“ASAS” means Aviation Safety Analysis System.

“ASRP” means Aviation Safety Reporting Program.

“ASRS” means Aviation Safety Reporting System.

“ATO” means Air Traffic Organization.

“AVS” means the Office of Aviation Safety

“CHDO” means Certificate Holding District Office.

“CMO” means Certificate Management Office.

“CVR” means Cockpit Voice Recorder.

“DFDR” means Digital Flight Data Recorder.

“DOD” means Department of Defense.

“DOJ” means Department of Justice.

“DOT” means Department of Transportation.

“EIR” means Enforcement Investigative Report.

“EIS” means Enforcement Information System.

“FAA Decisionmaker” means for commercial space civil penalty actions, the Associate Administrator for Commercial Space Transportation and for all other civil penalty assessment cases, the Administrator.

“FAA enforcement personnel” means legal counsel and inspectors, special agents, aviation safety technicians, and any other FAA personnel who carry out enforcement activities for the FAA.

“FAA investigative personnel” means inspectors, special agents, aviation safety technicians, and any other FAA personnel who conduct regulatory enforcement investigations.

“FBI” means Federal Bureau of Investigation.

09/03/15 2150.3B, Chg 9

―FDR‖ means Flight Data Recorder.

―FLEA‖ means Federal Law Enforcement Agency.

―FMS‖ means Department of Treasury Financial Management Services.

―FOIA‖ means Freedom of Information Act.

―FOQA‖ means Flight Operational Quality Assurance. ―FSDO‖ means Flight Standards District Office. ―Hazmat‖ means hazardous materials. ―HMR‖ means Hazardous Materials Regulations. ―IOP‖ means Item of Proof. ―LEA‖ means law enforcement agency.

―LOI‖ means Letter of Investigation. ―MIDO‖ means Manufacturing Inspection District Office

―NASA‖ means National Aeronautics and Space Administration.

―NAS‖ means National Airspace System.

―NTSB‖ means National Transportation Safety Board.

―OIG‖ means Office of Inspector General.

―OST‖ means Office of the Secretary of Transportation. ―PAH‖ means Production Approval Holder.

―Person‖ means an individual or entity, firm, partnership, corporation, company, association, joint stock association, or governmental entity. It includes a trustee, receiver, assignee, or similar representative of any of them. ―PMA‖ means Parts Manufacturer Approval. ―Program Office‖ means the Flight Standards Service, the Aircraft Certification Service, the Office of Aerospace Medicine, the Office of Security and Hazardous Materials, the Office of Airports, or the Office of Commercial Space Transportation.

09/03/15 2150.3B, Chg 9

―Regional Counsel‖ means Regional Counsel and Aeronautical Center Counsel.

―Regions‖ means all regions and the Aeronautical Center. ―SNAAP‖ means Streamlined No Action and Administrative Action Process.

―SPAS‖ means Safety Performance Analysis System.

―TSOA‖ means Technical Standard Order authorization.

Chapter 2. Compliance and Enforcement

Policy and Objectives

1. Purpose. This chapter states the general policies and objectives of the FAA’s compliance and enforcement program.

2. The Reason for a Compliance and Enforcement Program.

a. FAA’s Mission and Authority. The FAA’s central mission is to promote safety in civil aeronautics. To achieve this, the agency establishes regulatory standards and requirements, found in 14 C.F.R. parts 1-199 under the statutory authority in 49 U.S.C. subtitle VII. Under 49 U.S.C. § 40113, the FAA Administrator has broad authority to take action the Administrator considers necessary to carry out his or her statutory responsibilities and powers relating to safety in air commerce, including conducting investigations; prescribing regulations, standards, and procedures; and issuing orders. The FAA also establishes regulatory standards and requirements governing commercial space transportation, found in 14 C.F.R. chapter III under the statutory authority in 49 U.S.C. subtitle IX, which the Secretary of Transportation has delegated to the FAA. In addition, the Administrator has delegated authority to investigate violations and enforce the Department of Transportation Hazardous Materials rules, 49 C.F.R. parts 100-185.

b. Objective of Compliance and Enforcement Program. The FAA’s compliance and enforcement program is designed to promote compliance with statutory and regulatory requirements. The program provides a wide range of options for addressing noncompliance. These options include educational and remedial training efforts, administrative action in the form of either a warning notice or letter of correction, certificate suspensions for a fixed period of time, civil penalties, indefinite certificate suspensions pending compliance or demonstration of qualifications, certificate revocations, injunctions, and referrals for criminal prosecution. When violations occur, whether they involve operating an airport; producing aircraft, products, or parts; performing aircraft maintenance; operating aircraft; or shipping hazardous materials, FAA enforcement personnel must take that action most appropriate to promote safety and compliance with the regulations. The initial priority of FAA investigative personnel is to correct any ongoing noncompliance. FAA personnel then determine what action to take by evaluating, among other things, the seriousness and safety risk imposed by the noncompliance. Elements of the FAA’s compliance and enforcement program also seek to promote safety and greater compliance by encouraging regulated persons to disclose their own violations and the circumstances surrounding those violations. Based on information provided through such disclosures, the agency’s compliance and enforcement program fosters the implementation of permanent corrective measures to improve overall safety.

c. Applicability. The compliance and enforcement program is applicable to all activities regulated or enforced by the FAA.

3. Compliance and Enforcement Philosophy.

a. Voluntary Compliance. Civil aviation safety depends on voluntary adherence to legal requirements. Therefore, the FAA administers programs to promote a clear awareness and understanding of the governing statute and regulations.

b. Education. FAA investigative personnel should take advantage of opportunities during their surveillance and inspection activities to strengthen a regulated person’s understanding of the statutory and regulatory requirements. The FAA also promotes education through public awareness programs and other special aviation educational efforts.

c. Surveillance and Detection. An important element of an effective compliance and enforcement program is the prompt discovery of noncompliance. Although the agency has programs to encourage self-disclosure, surveillance remains the primary method of detecting violations. Consistent with its statutory mandate, the FAA maintains a high level of surveillance of air carrier operations and manufacturing facilities.

d. Notifying Persons of Potential Violations. In any situation where FAA enforcement personnel identify a potential violation, they take appropriate steps immediately to notify a responsible person who can take appropriate action to prevent it. For example, FAA investigative personnel may counsel a regulated party and ensure that it takes immediate action to prevent a violation from happening, or ground aircraft under 49 U.S.C. § 44713(c) when air carrier aircraft are not in condition for safe operation. Any FAA employee who receives information about a crewmember’s operation of an aircraft in violation of the FAA’s alcohol and drug regulations must immediately contact and pass on that information to a flight standards inspector. If the crewmember is an air carrier employee, the inspector quickly notifies the air carrier’s management of all relevant information about the matter so the air carrier can take appropriate action. The inspector requests the air carrier to help the FAA in its investigation, and if appropriate, to take action to ensure the crewmember does not serve on a flight.

e. Investigation and Reporting. FAA investigative personnel must conduct investigations promptly. They must gather, and accurately and completely report all facts, and conduct their investigations in an unbiased and focused manner. A violation report without all the facts only leads to delays that compromise the objectives of fair and responsive enforcement. An incomplete or inaccurate enforcement investigative report can mislead reviewing officials and FAA legal counsel and result in wrong or inappropriate actions being taken.

f. FAA Responses to Violations and Purposes for Compliance and Enforcement Actions. FAA enforcement personnel must investigate and appropriately address every apparent or alleged violation.

(1) Responses. The agency has a wide range of options available for addressing apparent violations, such as oral or written counseling; administrative action, including remedial training; legal enforcement action; and referral for criminal prosecution. Under 14 C.F.R. § 13.11, FAA investigative personnel issue an administrative action in the form of either a warning notice or a letter of correction for an apparent violation. FAA legal counsel amends, suspends, modifies, or revokes certificates under 49 U.S.C. §§ 44105, 44106, 44709, 44710, 44726, 44924, and 46111;

seeks civil penalties primarily under 49 U.S.C. § 46301; seizes aircraft under 49 U.S.C. § 46304; and issues judicially enforceable orders under 49 U.S.C. § 40113. FAA enforcement personnel also refer apparent violations to foreign governments or to the Department of Defense (DOD) for appropriate handling, and in cases where there is possible criminal conduct, to the Office of Inspector General (OIG) for criminal investigation. Generally, under 49 U.S.C. § 40113, FAA enforcement personnel take actions believed necessary to carry out the Administrator’s statutory safety duties and responsibilities. Regulations governing the transportation of hazardous materials are enforceable by civil and criminal penalties, orders directing compliance, and equitable judicial relief (49 U.S.C. §§ 5121, 5122, 5123, and 5124). Regulations governing commercial space transportation are enforceable by civil penalties and licensing actions (49 U.S.C. §§ 70107, 70115).

(2) Purposes. FAA enforcement personnel take compliance and enforcement action to prevent future actions that would violate the regulations (for example, immediate corrective action after counseling or a letter of correction; cease and desist orders; injunctions). They also take enforcement actions for remedial purposes (for example, administrative remedial training; immediate corrective action and comprehensive fixes under the voluntary disclosure reporting programs; certificate suspension pending demonstration of qualifications; or revocation for lack of qualification or competency). They also take enforcement actions to deter future violations by the subject of the enforcement action and those similarly situated (for example, punitive certificate actions or civil penalties).

g. Fairness. To be effective, the agency’s compliance and enforcement program must be fair and reasonable and should be perceived as fair by those subject to regulation. This does not and should not imply an unwillingness to apply the full force of statutory sanctions where warranted. It does encompass the right of an apparent violator to be given objective, evenhanded consideration of all circumstances surrounding the allegations before final action is taken. It also requires good faith efforts to understand the apparent violator’s position and take it into account, as well as to apprise the apparent violator of the agency’s position in a timely manner.

h. Timeliness.

(1) The agency’s discovery of, and response to, violations should be timely. Delays in investigation or processing of enforcement investigative reports can adversely affect the effectiveness of the agency’s compliance and enforcement program in several ways. Delays may let an unsafe condition continue if prompt corrective action is not taken. Delays also may de-emphasize the seriousness of a given violation and lessen the deterrent value of any enforcement action taken. The deterrent quality of enforcement action, and effective linking of the enforcement sanction to objective change in compliance behavior, can be best realized if the FAA investigates diligently and promptly and administers the appropriate sanction within a reasonable time period. If the allegations of violation are not sustained, any unwarranted delay in processing the case may impose an unjustified hardship. The time needed for investigation and processing will vary depending on the complexity of each case. Certain cases, because of their effect on safety, including the need for emergency action, will sometimes demand immediate involvement of the entire investigative and legal team to effect timely agency action, sometimes in only a matter of hours or a few days.

(2) To promote the prompt and diligent processing of enforcement cases, the FAA has timeliness goals for completing investigations and associated EIRs and processing legal enforcement actions. The timeliness goals for completing investigations and EIRs are in chapter 4, subparagraph 4.e. The timeliness goals for processing legal enforcement actions are in chapter 6, paragraph 25.

i. Recommendations of Inspectors, Special Agents, Field Offices, and Regional Offices. FAA investigative personnel recommend initially the appropriate type of response to address an apparent violation. Often, they are in the best position to evaluate various subjective considerations, such as the apparent violator’s compliance attitude and whether an alternative to legal enforcement action may be sufficient to achieve compliance. If FAA investigative personnel prepare an enforcement investigative report (EIR), program office management reviews it to determine consistency with agency compliance and enforcement policy. In this review, field and regional program office personnel consider the recommendations of FAA investigative personnel, if they properly justify and explain their recommendations. FAA legal counsel who reviews the EIR considers the recommendations of the program office.

j. FAA Legal Enforcement Actions; Sanction Guidance Policy. After determining that legal enforcement action is necessary, FAA enforcement personnel consult the sanction guidance policies in chapter 7 and tables of sanctions in Appendix B or C to determine the appropriate sanction. FAA enforcement personnel must fully explain and justify in the EIR deviations from the sanction guidance policy.

4. Responsibility for Determining Legal Enforcement Action.

a. General. If FAA enforcement personnel select legal enforcement action (for example, certificate action or civil penalty action), they determine the type and amount of sanction under agency sanction guidance policy. The program office and legal counsel jointly determine the type and amount of sanction sought in a legal enforcement action. The roles of the various enforcement personnel with regard to sanction determination are outlined below. Disagreements within a program office or between legal counsel and the program office are generally resolved following discussion among, as appropriate, the inspector or other investigative personnel; field office, regional, or Washington headquarters program office personnel; and legal counsel.

b. Responsibilities of FAA Investigative Personnel.

(1) In all legal enforcement actions except those recommended by the security and hazardous materials program office, FAA investigative personnel recommend only the type of legal enforcement action (for example, civil penalty action, fixed-period suspension (for example, 30-day suspension)), indefinite suspension, revocation) that should be taken. Except in security or hazardous materials EIRs, FAA investigative personnel do not recommend a specific amount of sanction (that is, specific number of dollars or days) or a range of sanction in cases that warrant either civil penalty action or a fixed-period certificate suspension. For security and hazardous materials EIRs, FAA special agents recommend a range of sanction and a specific amount of sanction in cases that warrant legal enforcement action.

(2) All FAA investigative personnel include a written analysis supporting the type of legal enforcement action, and in security and hazardous materials EIRs the sanction range and specific amount of sanction, they recommend in section B of the EIR. In the written analysis, FAA investigative personnel explain the reasons why they recommend a type of legal enforcement action and for each violation address the factors described in chapter 7, paragraph 4, or Appendix C that are relevant to that alleged violation. FAA investigative personnel explain how each of the relevant factors applies to each alleged violation and why it may warrant mitigation or aggravation of the sanction amount for the case.

(3) To determine the type of legal enforcement action, FAA inspectors first consult the sanction guidance table in Appendix B. The table provides the type of legal enforcement action that usually is taken for an alleged violation. (If a particular violation is not listed in the table, FAA investigative personnel refer to an analogous or similar violation for guidance.) FAA special agents follow the guidance in Appendix C to recommend a specific amount of sanction for a hazardous materials case or Appendix B for their other cases. FAA investigative personnel document their recommendation and the reasons for it in section B of the EIR.

c. Responsibilities of Regional and Washington Headquarters Program Office Personnel.

(1) For civil penalty actions and fixed-period certificate suspensions in cases other than those opened by the Office of Security and Hazardous Materials, regional or Washington headquarters program office personnel recommend a specific amount of sanction, that is, the number of days or dollars the FAA will seek for a case. Regional or Washington headquarters program office personnel base this recommendation on FAA investigative personnel’s analysis of the relevant factors and elements affecting sanction and their recommendation. Regional or Washington headquarters program office personnel apply the agency’s sanction guidance policy in determining a specific sanction amount for the case. For cases involving multiple violations, regional or Washington headquarters program office personnel follow the guidance in chapter 7, paragraphs 6 and 7 in determining the specific amount of sanction for the case. When the regional program office division manager and the Regional Counsel, or the Washington headquarters program office division manager and the Assistant Chief Counsel for Enforcement, agree, program office personnel and legal counsel may collaborate in determining the specific amounts of sanction for cases before the program office forwards the EIR to legal counsel for processing. Program office personnel document in the EIR when they determine a specific sanction recommendation collaboratively with legal counsel.

(2) If the EIR does not contain a sufficient sanction analysis for regional or Washington headquarters program office personnel to recommend a specific sanction amount, then those personnel may return the EIR to FAA investigative personnel for further sanction analysis. Regional and Washington headquarters program office personnel document their recommended specific sanction amount or the amount determined collaboratively with legal counsel, and the reasons for that amount, in section B of the EIR. If that sanction recommendation differs from

the recommendation of FAA investigative personnel, then regional or Washington headquarters program office personnel and legal counsel, if appropriate, discuss the difference with FAA investigative personnel. Regional or Washington headquarters program office personnel must document the reasons for the difference in section B of the EIR.

d. Responsibilities of Legal Counsel.

(1) If legal counsel and the program office do not collaborate on determining a specific sanction amount before receipt of that case by the legal office, then legal counsel reviews the sanction recommendation of regional or Washington headquarters program office personnel. If legal counsel believes the sanction sought should differ from the regional or Washington headquarters program office recommendation, then legal counsel discusses the proposed change to the sanction type or amount with appropriate program office personnel, including FAA investigative personnel, if practicable. If legal counsel seeks a sanction type or amount different from the recommendation of regional or Washington headquarters program office personnel, then legal counsel documents in the EIR the reasons why legal counsel sought that sanction.

(2) After legal enforcement action is initiated, legal counsel consults with appropriate regional or Washington headquarters program office personnel before proposing any changes to the sanction sought. If such a change also differs from the type of sanction recommended by FAA investigative personnel, then regional or headquarters program office personnel consults, if practicable, with FAA investigative personnel before legal counsel changes the sanction sought. Legal counsel documents in the EIR the reasons for any changes to the sanction sought.

e. Sanction Determinations in Significant Cases. Significant cases defined in paragraph 3 of chapter 6 require coordination with Washington headquarters through AGC-300. FAA enforcement personnel determine the type of sanction and specific sanction amount for such cases in accordance with the guidance in chapter 2, subparagraphs 4.a.-d. If Washington headquarters personnel involved in coordinating a significant case have a different opinion about the sanction the FAA should seek in that case, then they convene a meeting or teleconference with FAA investigative personnel, regional and Washington headquarters personnel, and regional and Washington headquarters legal counsel. The purpose of the meeting or teleconference is to discuss the case and to resolve any differences that exist among FAA enforcement personnel about the type and amount of sanction that should be sought.

5. Voluntary Safety Programs.

a. Background. The threat to regulated persons of incurring punitive legal enforcement actions is a traditional and often effective incentive to promote compliance. While these actions have deterrent value, they do not necessarily improve a person’s ability to assure future compliance. The public interest in aviation safety is served in appropriate circumstances by positive incentives to promote and achieve compliance. To this end, the FAA has established several programs to improve compliance and increase safety by offering incentives to regulated persons to disclose their own violations, other safety discrepancies, and general safety information to the FAA and take corrective action to preclude future safety problems, if appropriate. These programs include the voluntary disclosure reporting programs, the aviation

· 02/02/17 2150.38, Chg. 12

safety action program, the flight operational quality assurance programs, and the aviation safety reporting program.

b. Voluntary Disclosure Reporting Programs.

(1) General. The voluntary disclosure reporting program is intended to improve safety compliance by forgoing a civil penalty when a regulated entity has promptly disclosed to the FAA an apparent violation and has taken prompt action satisfactory to the FAA to correct the violation and preclude its recurrence. The FAA regulates entities' performance through setting regulatory standards, issuing guidance, and monitoring compliance through periodic inspections. Regulated entities, which have the ultimate responsibility for compliance, have a superior vantage point for monitoring thei.r own performance. Therefore, voluntary disclosure reporting programs can serve an important role in achieving compliance and improving aviation safety.

(2) Information about the programs. Furtherinformation about the programs is in chapter 5. Advisory Circulars 00-58, as amended, and 00-68 provide guidance for disclosing certain violations ofthe Federal Aviation Regulations. (Both ACs may be found online at http://rgl.faa.gov). Advisory Circular 121-37 provides guidance for disclosing certain violations ofthe hazardous material regulations found in 49 C.F.R. part 175.

c. Flight Operational Quality Assurance (FOQA) Programs.

(1) General. FOQA is a voluntary safety program for the routine collection and analysis of digital flight data generated during normal line operations. FOQA programs provide information about, and insight into, the total flight operations environment. FOQA data can provide objective information that is not available through other methods. FOQA's primary purpose is to identify adverse safety trends, and to proactively initiate corrective action before such trends can lead to accidents. Its purpose is also to enhance safety by improving training effectiveness, operational procedures, maintenance and engineering procedures, and air traffic control procedures.

(2) Applicability. FOQA programs mostly are developed by air carriers that operate under 14 C.F.R. parts 121 or 135, but operators under other parts ofthe regulations may also develop FOQA programs.

(3) Development ofa FOQA program. The development of a FOQA program occurs in stages. During the planning stage, the policy and direction for the FOQA effort are developed and necessary resources are committed to implement the program. The policies, procedures, resources, and operational processes for collecting, managing and using FOQA data are laid out in the implementation and operations (I&O) plan as the program blueprint, which an air carrier submits to the FAA for approval. Once the FAA has approved the FOQA I&O plan, the air carrier implements the program for analyzing, validating, and taking corrective actions based on FOQA data. It is the responsibility ofthe air carrier to set up procedures for identifying operational deficiencies and taking corrective action.

(4) Limitation on use of FOQA data. Under 14 C.F.R. § 13.401(e), except for criminal and deliberate acts, the FAA may not use an operator's FOQA data in an enforcement action

against that operator or its employees when that data is obtained from an FAA-approved FOQA program.

(5) Collection of data. In a FOQA program, the air carrier collects data from the aircraft using either special acquisition devices, such as quick access recorders (QAR) or directly from the flight data recorder (FDR). Using one of several available transmission methods, the air carrier periodically retrieves the data and sends it to the air carrier’s FOQA office for analysis. Data collected can then be used in trend identification, determination of corrective actions, and monitoring of effectiveness of those actions.

(6) Regulatory requirements. Regulatory requirements applicable to FOQA programs are found in 14 C.F.R. § 13.401.

(7) Guidance for FOQA participation. Guidance about FOQA programs is contained in Advisory Circular No. AC 120-82. (AC 120-82 may be found online at http://rgl.faa.gov).

d. Aviation Safety Action Program (ASAP).

(1) General. The objective of the ASAP is to encourage air carrier and repair station employees to voluntarily report safety information that may be critical to identifying potential precursors to accidents. An air carrier or repair station takes part in the ASAP by entering into a memorandum of understanding with the FAA and usually the labor organization for the participating employee group. Under an ASAP, participating employees can report safety issues to management, the FAA, and the employee union for resolution without fear the FAA will use reports accepted under the program to take legal enforcement action against them, or that companies will use such information to take disciplinary action, provided program criteria are met.

(2) Applicability. Air carriers that operate under 14 C.F.R. part 121 and major domestic repair stations certificated under 14 C.F.R. part 145 may participate in the ASAP.

(3) Guidance for ASAP participation. Guidance about participating in the ASAP is contained in Advisory Circular AC 120-66, as amended. (AC 120-66, as amended, may be found online at http://rgl.faa.gov).

e. NASA Aviation Safety Reporting Program (ASRP).

(1) General. The FAA established the ASRP to encourage individuals to report any information they believe discloses an unsafe condition in the national airspace system (NAS). Under the ASRP, the FAA waives the imposition of a sanction for a violation if an individual other than a passenger files a timely report and meets the other criteria in chapter 2, subparagraph 5.e.(3). FAA investigative personnel do not query the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) and do not ask an alleged violator if he or she filed a report under the ASRP, at any time during an investigation of an alleged violation. Under 14 C.F.R. § 91.25, the FAA does not use the aviation safety reporting system (ASRS) reporting form, that is, both

the identification strip and the body of the report, in any enforcement action, except information concerning accidents or criminal offenses which are excluded from the ASRP.

(2) Guidance for ASRP participation. Guidance about the ASRP is contained in Advisory Circular AC 00-46, as amended. (AC 00-46, as amended, may be found online at http://rgl.faa.gov).

(3) Criteria for waiver of imposition of sanction. An individual in a legal enforcement action receives a waiver of imposition of sanction under the ASRP provided --

● The violation was inadvertent and not deliberate; ● The violation did not involve a criminal offense, or accident, or a lack of qualification or competency to hold a certificate;

● The individual has not been found in any prior FAA enforcement action to have committed a violation of 49 USC subtitle VII, or of any regulation promulgated under that statute for a period of 5 years prior to the date of the occurrence; and

● The individual proves that, within 10 days after the violation, he or she completed and delivered or mailed a written report of the incident or occurrence to the NASA ASRS.

(4) Legal enforcement actions under ASRP. When FAA legal counsel determines that an individual qualifies for a waiver of imposition of sanction under the ASRP, the FAA issues an order of suspension or order of civil penalty, as appropriate, that includes the factual findings, the findings of any regulatory violations supported by the evidence, the sanction, a statement that the sanction associated with the finding of violations is waived under ASRP, and appropriate appeal rights.

6. Enforcement Priorities.

a. General. Enforcement case priorities focus agency enforcement efforts on those violations that have the greatest safety impact. The agency’s highest priorities among enforcement cases are emergency actions, and generally those that involve certificate holder qualifications. Following those cases, the agency’s priority enforcement actions are those types of cases identified by program offices as warranting aggressive, swift prosecution.

b. Legal Enforcement Case Reviews.

(1) Each Regional Counsel and the Assistant Chief Counsel for Enforcement meet at least quarterly with the respective lines of business to review the status of cases referred for legal enforcement action. This review is a joint legal counsel-program office assessment of caseload management, with an emphasis on the timeliness and effectiveness of case selection, investigation, initiation, and processing. In addition, the review includes an analysis of: trends; inconsistent case handling; lack of uniform sanctions; repeat violations; and any other significant evaluative factors. At this review, legal counsel and program office personnel consider the need to reprioritize and process cases warranting the greatest urgency.

(2) If an assessment shows that the program offices are submitting more cases for legal handling than legal counsel can reasonably be expected to initiate and process, without incurring

a backlog, legal counsel and program office personnel redistribute cases for processing by other regions or headquarters staff with greater available enforcement resources or reevaluate the cases that are backlogged and determine if any alternative enforcement action would be appropriate and warranted.

(3) The reconsideration or reassessment of a given sanction is not to be considered a weakening or lack of enforcement resolve. On the contrary, enforcement resolve is most evident when FAA enforcement personnel take corrective and deterrent actions in a timely manner. For example, sometimes an administrative action, taken immediately after a violation occurs, can serve as a more effective deterrent than a long-delayed legal action. There is a wide range of effective tools available to FAA legal counsel and program office personnel, and they consider all of them in light of the circumstances of each individual case. Legal counsel and program office personnel select the tool that most effectively and timely serves to correct the noncompliance and deter future violations.

(4) When EIRs are returned to investigating field offices, the field offices carefully reevaluate and quickly respond to each returned legal enforcement case in light of the explanation provided by the program office division manager. Field office personnel consider the nature of the violation and other relevant mitigating and aggravating factors and elements, and whether safety and the public interest continue to require that legal enforcement action be taken. If the investigating field office determines that the recommended legal enforcement action should be taken, then it coordinates this decision with the respective program office division manager and legal counsel.

c. Special Emphasis Enforcement Programs. The FAA generally avoids creating mandatory sanction programs. At times, special situations arise, however, that dictate the need for increased sanctions or other measures stricter or more focused than existing methods to bring about compliance in certain areas. In such circumstances, the FAA may set up a special emphasis enforcement program, designed to focus on a particular area of noncompliance, on a national or local geographical basis and the following procedures apply.

(1) Generally, a special emphasis enforcement program is used only when other methods of gaining compliance have not been sufficiently effective. Normally, such a program is established with a fixed expiration.

(2) The appropriate program office and the Office of the Chief Counsel jointly determine whether to institute a national special emphasis enforcement program. The appropriate regional program office division and the Regional Counsel jointly recommend a regional special emphasis enforcement program. A regional program is set up only with the concurrence of the Chief Counsel and the director of the appropriate program office. The regional program office division manager advises the Regional Administrator about the implementation of a regional special emphasis enforcement program.

(3) Before instituting a special emphasis enforcement program, FAA legal counsel and the program office determine what public notice, if any, is needed. Sometimes, publicity may not be appropriate; for example, where only increased surveillance is needed. In other cases,

letters to airmen, pilot forums, and even press releases may be appropriate. The program office maintains a tracking method to evaluate the effectiveness of the special emphasis enforcement program on a continuing basis until termination of the program.

7. Formal Complaints.

a. Authority To Investigate Violations of 49 U.S.C. Subtitle VII, Part A. Under 49 U.S.C. § 46101(a)(1), a person may file a written complaint with the Administrator about violations of 49 U.S.C. subtitle VII, part A, or a requirement prescribed under part A. Under 49 U.S.C. § 46101(a)(2), the Administrator, on his or her initiative, may investigate, if the Administrator determines that reasonable grounds exist regarding a person’s violation. If the Administrator determines the complaint does not state facts that warrant an investigation or further action, the Administrator may dismiss the complaint without a hearing (49 U.S.C. § 46101(a)(3)). The Administrator, after notice and opportunity for hearing, must issue an order to compel compliance with part A if he or she finds, after the investigation, that a person is violating part A (49 U.S.C. § 46101(4)).

b. Procedures. 14 C.F.R. § 13.5 prescribes procedures for persons filing formal complaints. Under that section, any person may file a complaint with the Administrator about anything done or not done by any person in contravention of any provision of any statute, or regulation or order issued under it about matters within the jurisdiction of the Administrator. 14 C.F.R. § 13.5, however, does not apply to complaints against the Administrator or any employee of the FAA acting within the scope of his or her employment.

c. Contents of the Formal Complaint. Formal complaints are sent to the FAA, Office of the Chief Counsel, Attention: Enforcement Docket (AGC-10), 800 Independence Avenue, SW, Washington D.C. 20591. The Assistant Chief Counsel for Enforcement or his or her delegate determines whether the complaint meets the criteria for being docketed as a formal complaint. Complaints that do not meet the criteria set forth below are not docketed as a formal complaint. Rather, the FAA treats them as reports under 14 C.F.R. § 13.1. Complaints that meet the criteria set forth below are docketed, and a copy is mailed to each person named in the complaint. Each formal complaint must:

(1) Be submitted in writing and identified as a complaint filed for the purpose of seeking an appropriate order or other enforcement action.

(2) Set forth the name and address, if known, of each person who is the subject of the complaint and, for each person, the specific terms of the statute, regulation, or order the person violated.

(3) Contain a concise statement of the facts relied on to substantiate each allegation.

(4) State the name, address, and telephone number of the person filing the complaint. That person or a duly authorized representative signs the complaint.

d. Response to the Complaint. Within 20 days after service of the complaint, the person named in the complaint must file an answer.

e. Disposition of the Formal Complaint. After the complaint has been answered or the period to respond has expired, the steps in paragraphs 7.e.(1)-(5) occur.

(1) The Assistant Chief Counsel for Enforcement or his or her delegate sends a copy of the complaint and answer to the appropriate program office with a request that the program office determine whether the complaint states facts that warrant further investigation or other action.

(2) If the program office determines that no further action is warranted, the program office dismisses the complaint without a hearing and prepares a record of decision that informs the person who filed the complaint and the person named in the complaint of the reasons for the dismissal.

(3) If the program office determines that reasonable grounds for investigating the complaint exist, an informal investigation may be initiated by the program office or an order of investigation may be issued under 14 C.F.R. part 13, subpart F. The Assistant Chief Counsel for Enforcement or his or her delegate informs each person named in the complaint of the name of the FAA official who is conducting the investigation.

(4) If the investigation substantiates the allegations set forth in the complaint, the FAA may issue a notice of proposed order or may proceed with other enforcement action under 14 C.F.R. § 13.5(j).

(5) The complaint, other pleadings, and official FAA records involving the disposition of the complaint are maintained in the Enforcement Docket (AGC-10), Office of the Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration, 800 Independence Avenue, SW, Washington, DC 20591. Interested persons may examine any docketed material at that office, during business hours, at any time after the docket is established, except material that is ordered withheld from the public under applicable law or regulation. Interested persons may obtain a copy of the docketed material upon paying for the cost of photocopying.

f. Complaints against Members of the U.S. Armed Forces. Under 49 U.S.C. § 46101(b) and 14 C.F.R. § 13.21, the FAA refers complaints against a member of the U.S. Armed Forces acting in the performance of official duties to the Secretary of the appropriate department in the Department of Defense for action. The appropriate military authority concerned, within 90 days of receipt of the complaint, is required to inform the Administrator of the action taken on the complaint, including any corrective or disciplinary action.

8. Public Disclosure of Enforcement Action Documents. The public has a legitimate interest in the FAA's enforcement program and a general right to obtain records of the FAA's enforcement actions, subject to established privileges and exceptions from required disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and the Privacy Act. .

a. Actions against Individuals. The voluntary or unsolicited disclosure of any enforcement action (initial or final) against an individual is prohibited under the Privacy Act. These records may be released only in response to a written request under the FOIA, in

accordance with a routine use under the Privacy Act, or as required by the Pilot Records Improvement Act (PRIA).

(1) FOIA and routine uses. The FAA may disclose enforcement records in response to a FOIA request or under a routine use published in the Federal Register pertaining to DOT/FAA System of Records 847, Aviation Records on Individuals. Where disclosure is sought under FOIA, the agency releases information only when the public interest in disclosure outweighs the privacy interest involved. Disclosure under the routine-use provision as it is currently published requires a written request and is treated the same as a FOIA request.

(2) PRIA. In response to written requests by air carriers under 49 U.S.C. § 44703(h), the FAA discloses summaries for the past five years of legal enforcement actions resulting in the Administrator’s finding of violation that was not subsequently overturned against an applicant seeking employment as a pilot.

b. Actions against Entities. An initial or final enforcement action document is sometimes made available within a reasonable time after issuance regardless of whether there has been a request for it. This is particularly true when the case involves air carriers or major aircraft and aircraft engine manufacturers because of the public interest in such actions. Otherwise, except for the release of other information of a public nature, such as the scheduling of a public hearing, the FAA releases information on the action in response to a request for the information, subject to established privileges and exemptions from required disclosure under the FOIA.

c. Release to Alleged Violator or Counsel. Once FAA legal counsel initiates an enforcement action, FAA legal counsel may release documents pertaining to the enforcement action to an alleged violator or counsel representing the alleged violator without requiring a request under the FOIA. Privileged documents, for example, those involving deliberative process or attorney work product, are withheld.

d. Information Generally Not Released. Before releasing any enforcement records, FAA personnel carefully review them and withhold documents from release, or redact portions of documents that are privileged. The FAA normally does not release records or portions of records that are deliberative in nature. In a typical enforcement case, information usually withheld includes:

(1) Recommendations about sanction and violations to be alleged; (2) Analysis of the case; and (3) Attorney work product.

e. Copies of Initial Enforcement Action Documents. Copies of initial enforcement action documents (for example, notices of proposed certificate action, civil penalty letters, notices of proposed civil penalty) are not made available to the public before the alleged violator has had an adequate opportunity to review the document. This should generally not be longer than one to three days after receipt. Where emergency certificate action is taken, the documents may be made available the same day the action is taken, but only after the alleged violator has been notified of the action.

f. Protection of Voluntarily Submitted Information. Certain information, which might otherwise be disclosed, is prohibited from disclosure if it is protected by an order issued under 14 C.F.R. part 193. FAA Order 8000.81 designates information provided to the FAA from an approved FOQA program as protected under 14 C.F.R. part 193. FAA Order 8000.82 designates information provided to the FAA from an Aviation Safety Action Program as protected under 14 C.F.R. part 193. FAA Order 8000.89 designates information provided to the FAA from a Voluntary Disclosure Reporting Program as protected under 14 C.F.R. part 193.

9. Publicizing Enforcement Actions.

a. General.

(1) Publicizing enforcement actions serves many interests. The public has a right to know how the FAA is conducting its responsibilities on the public’s behalf. In addition, enforcement information about a regulated party may be useful in making consumer choices. Publicizing enforcement actions also serves the government’s strong interest in ensuring, through deterrence, compliance with the FAA’s regulations. Often the adverse publicity and concomitant public reaction to regulatory violations serve more effectively to deter future violations by an entity than the loss of funds caused by a civil penalty. And while an unpublicized civil penalty or certificate action operates to deter future violations by the entity subjected to the enforcement action, publicizing the action acts as a deterrent for others similarly situated. The FAA does not publicize the identity of individuals against whom it takes enforcement actions.

(2) Because any publicity of an enforcement action alleging or finding statutory or regulatory violations has the potential to affect significantly the public's confidence in an entity’s ability and commitment to comply with safety regulations, the FAA takes care in ensuring the accuracy and fairness of the publicity it gives such actions. Such care is especially important when the publicity concerns enforcement actions that are not final determinations made by the FAA or adjudicative bodies.

b. Monthly Reports. The Office of Communications posts a monthly report on its web site about civil penalty cases against entities in which the proposed penalty is $50,000 or more, and certificate suspensions or revocations involving businesses other than housekeeping actions (that is, certificate actions against certificate holders that have effectively ceased doing business). The report contains an introduction in news release form highlighting such items of interest as the number of cases and total of the proposed civil penalties.

c. News Releases. The Office of Communications issues news releases on cases against entities that it finds would be of particular interest to the public or otherwise promote the government’s interest in deterring violations. A news release should:

(1) Be factual and objective.

(2) Avoid comparisons of a particular alleged violator or enforcement case with other alleged violators or enforcement cases. Such comparisons often are subjective, and might give the appearance that the FAA harbors a bias or favors a particular entity. However, the release

may contain statements concerning any precedent that is set or unique circumstances, as long as they are factual.

(3) Provide the current status of the enforcement action and state whether the subject of the action disputes the allegations or has filed an appeal, if either is known.

(4) Be consistent with requirements of the FOIA and the Privacy Act.

d. Advance Notice of a News Release. A copy of the release is not provided to the alleged violator or its contents disclosed before it is disseminated to the public.

e. Releasing Information before Issuance of Release. FAA offices do not disseminate any information regarding the subject of a news release until that news release has been issued, except in special circumstances directed by the Office of Communications in consultation with legal counsel.

f. Negotiating a News Release. The FAA does not negotiate the contents of a news release or whether it will issue one.

g. Providing Information to the Office of Communications. The legal office initiating an action provides to its regional Office of Communications upon issuance a copy of any civil penalty letter or notice of proposed civil penalty that involves a penalty of $50,000 or more, and any emergency order of suspension or revocation or notice proposing certificate action against an entity except in housekeeping actions. The regional Office of Communications drafts a news release and sends it and the enforcement document to AOC-2A. If the FAA does not issue a news release, it uses the information in the draft news release for the monthly report.

h. Coordinating News Releases and Monthly Reports. Before issuance of any news release or monthly report, AOC-2A obtains the concurrence of AGC-300, the affected Associate or Assistant Administrator, and any other concerned agency officials, including, where appropriate, the Administrator.

i. Quarterly Reports. At the end of each quarter, AGC-300 posts on the web site of the Office of the Chief Counsel, a compilation of all enforcement actions taken against aviation entities that the FAA closed during that period. The report may be found online at http:www.faa.gov/agc/enforcement/index.htm.

10. Expunction Policy.

a. General. The FAA has a policy for expunging certain records of enforcement actions against individuals. (See FAA Enforcement Records; Expunction Policy, 56 Fed. Reg. 55788 (October 29, 1991)).

b. Expunction Periods for Certain Enforcement Actions. In general, the FAA expunges records of certain enforcement actions in accordance with the time periods in chapter 2,

subparagraphs 10.b.(1)-(5). A record is eligible for expunction once no further action is required in the enforcement case and the appropriate FAA office has closed the case.

(1) Fixed-period certificate suspensions. Records of legal enforcement actions involving fixed-period suspensions of airman certificates against individuals are expunged five years after the following dates, unless at the time they are due to be expunged, one or more other legal enforcement actions are pending against the same individual:

 The date the airman surrenders his or her airman certificate;  The date the airman submits an affidavit of certificate loss; or  The date of the order of suspension with waiver of sanction.

(2) Civil penalties. In civil penalty cases against individuals, where an order assessing a civil penalty or a civil penalty letter has been issued, the records are expunged five years after the following dates, unless at the time they are due to be expunged, one or more other legal enforcement actions are pending against the same individual:

 The date the civil penalty has been paid; or  The date of the civil penalty letter that provides for a waiver of sanction.

Where a civil penalty is determined to be uncollectible, the record is not expunged.

(3) Indefinite certificate suspensions. Indefinite suspensions of airman certificates for reexamination or proof of qualification are expunged one month after the airman successfully completes a reexamination or demonstrates qualifications, unless at the time it is due to be expunged, one or more other legal enforcement actions are pending against the same individual.

(4) Administrative actions. Administrative actions against individuals for apparent violations committed in their individual capacities are expunged two years following the issuance of the administrative action.

(5) No action cases. Cases closed with no enforcement action are expunged within 90 days. In no action cases, if an investigation results in the termination of the case without enforcement action, the record is expunged within 90 days after the termination. If legal enforcement action has been initiated and is subsequently withdrawn, the record is expunged within 90 days after the withdrawal, unless an administrative action is subsequently issued in which case the record is expunged in the same manner as other administrative action records.

c. Certificate Revocation Actions. The EIS records of enforcement actions resulting in revocation of certificates are not expunged.

d. Applicability. The expunction policy applies to all enforcement actions closed with no action and to legal enforcement actions referenced in chapter 2, subparagraph 10.b., and administrative actions against individuals whose apparent violations were committed in their

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 931 passages shown