Order 9120.1E Drug and Alcohol Compliance and Enforcement Surveillance Handbook
This Order documents the surveillance procedures used by Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Drug Abatement Division (AAM-800) to assess the compliance of aviation industry employers, contractors, and service agents with the drug and alcohol testing requirements in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR). Specifically, the regulatory requirements including the Department of Transportation’s (DOT) 49 CFR part 40, “Procedures for Transportation Workplace Drug and Alcohol Testing Programs;” the FAA’s 14 CFR part 120, “Drug and Alcohol Testing Program;” and other relevant Federal Aviation Regulations. This Order is used in conjunction with FAA’s Compliance and Enforcement Program Order 2150.3, as amended, and Safety Risk Management Policy Order 8040.4, as amended, to ensure that inspections, investigations, and voluntary disclosure decisions are conducted accurately, fairly, and consistently throughout the Drug Abatement Division.
Pages from FAA_Order_9120.1E - Final Clean Copy (March 21 2023) (003)
Distribution: Electronically Initiated By: AAM-820
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION
ORDER
9120.1E
National Policy Effective Date:
April 1, 2023
SUBJ: Drug and Alcohol Compliance and Enforcement Surveillance Handbook
The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Office of Aerospace Medicine (AAM) has prepared this Order for Drug Abatement Division (AAM-800) personnel to follow when assessing drug and alcohol testing programs of aviation industry employers, contractors, service agents, employees, and individuals for compliance with the Department of Transportation’s (DOT) 49 CFR part 40, “Procedures for Transportation Workplace Drug and Alcohol Testing Programs;” the FAA’s 14 CFR part 120, “Drug and Alcohol Testing Program;” and other relevant Federal Aviation Regulations.
Unless otherwise directed by the AAM-800 Director, all program personnel must adhere to the procedures in this order. The FAA invites comments and suggestions from those who use the order. Input should be sent via email to [email protected] or in writing to:
Federal Aviation Administration Office of Aerospace Medicine Drug Abatement Division (AAM-800) 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. Washington, D.C. 20591
Susan E. Northrup, M.D. Federal Air Surgeon Aviation Safety
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Table of Contents
Chapter 1. General Information … 4
Purpose of this Order … 4
Audience … 4
Where Can I Find this Order? … 4
What this Order Cancels … 4
Explanation of Policy Changes … 4
Inspection Authority … 4
Objectives of the Inspection and Investigation Process … 4
Responsibilities … 5
Who Do We Surveil? … 5
Chapter 2. Inspection … 8 1. Purpose … 8
2. General … 8
3. Inspection Activities … 8
4. Inspection Scheduling … 9
5. Travel Requirements for On-Site Inspections … 12
6. Final Inspection Work Plan … 12
7. Preparation for the Inspection … 13
8. Pre-Inspection Team Meetings … 14
9. Inspection Procedures … 14
10. Evidence Collection … 25
11. Documentation of Inspection Results … 27
12. Inspection Conclusion … 28
13. Post-Inspection Activities … 30
Figure 2-1. On-Site Inspection Process Guide … 38
Figure 2-2. Virtual Inspection Process Guide … 39
Figure 2-3. Inbriefing/Outbriefing Guide for On-Site Inspection … 40
Figure 2-4. Inbriefing/Outbriefing Guide for Virtual Inspection … 41
Figure 2-5. Meeting Attendance List … 42
Figure 2-6. New Hire/Transfer Guide … 43
Figure 2-7. Inspection Finding of Noncompliance Issue Guide … 44
Figure 2-8. Sample Inspector’s Statement of Authenticity … 45
Figure 2-9. Employee Interview Guide … 46
Figure 2-10. Witness Statement Form … 48
Figure 2-11. Record of Interview … 50
Figure 2-12. Inspection Correspondence Flowchart … 51
Figure 2-13. Sample FOUO Coversheet … 52
Chapter 3. Investigations … 53 1. Purpose … 53
2. General … 53
3. Sources of Allegations … 53
4. Initiating an Investigation of an Employer … 54
5. Initiating an Investigation of a Safety-Sensitive Employee … 55
6. Individual Violations Discovered During Inspection … 55
7. Pilot’s Bill of Rights … 55
Figure 3-1. Sample Investigator’s Statement of Authenticity … 57
Chapter 4. Voluntary Disclosures … 58 1. Purpose … 58
2. General … 58
3. Procedures … 58
Figure 4-1. Sample Voluntary Disclosure Analysis … 61
Chapter 5. Administrative Information … 63 1. Authority to Change this Order … 63
2. Background … 63
3. References … 63
Appendix A. Inspection Guide … A-1
Appendix B. Service Agent Inspection Guide … B-1
Appendix C. Random Drug and Alcohol Testing Job Aid … C-1
Appendix D. Acronyms … D-1
Appendix E. Inspection Scheduling Procedures … E-1
Appendix F. Electronic Inspection File Documentation … F-1
Pages from FAA_Order_9120.1E - Final Clean Copy (March 21 2023) (003) › Chapter 1. General Information
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Chapter 1. General Information
Purpose of this Order. This Order documents the surveillance procedures used by Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Drug Abatement Division (AAM-800) to assess the compliance of aviation industry employers, contractors, and service agents with the drug and alcohol testing requirements in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR). Specifically, the regulatory requirements including the Department of Transportation’s (DOT) 49 CFR part 40, “Procedures for Transportation Workplace Drug and Alcohol Testing Programs;” the FAA’s 14 CFR part 120, “Drug and Alcohol Testing Program;” and other relevant Federal Aviation Regulations. This Order is used in conjunction with FAA’s Compliance and Enforcement Program Order 2150.3, as amended, and Safety Risk Management Policy Order 8040.4, as amended, to ensure that inspections, investigations, and voluntary disclosure decisions are conducted accurately, fairly, and consistently throughout the Drug Abatement Division.
Audience. All AAM-800 personnel.
Where Can I Find this Order? You can find this Order on the MyFAA Employee Web site: https://employees.faa.gov/tools_resources/orders_notices/. This Order is available to the public at: https://drs.faa.gov.
What this Order Cancels. This Order cancels Order 9120.1D, FAA Drug and Alcohol Compliance and Enforcement Inspector Order, dated August 9, 2018.
Explanation of Policy Changes.
a. This Order was revised to reflect program policy and guidance changes, including the addition of a permanent virtual method of inspecting and new electronic file documentation process.
b. This Order was changed to reflect the new AAM-800 Director’s title and add organization responsibilities.
c. This Order was changed to streamline and reformat for consistency and clarity, including removing repetitive information and improving grammar and plain language.
d. This Order was changed to refer to the location of tools, templates, and other references from AAM-800’s QMS to AAM-800’s SharePoint.
Inspection Authority. The Omnibus Transportation Employee Testing Act of 1991 (49 USC §§ 45101-45107) and the FAA’s general statutory safety authority outlined in 49 USC §§ 106(g), 40113(a), and 44701 provide the authority to conduct the inspections and investigations described in this order.
Objectives of the Inspection and Investigation Process. Ensuring compliance with the drug and alcohol testing regulations is the primary objective of the Drug Abatement Division’s surveillance program. The safety of the traveling public and integrity of the inspection and investigation process and voluntary safety reporting program form the foundation of our program. The regulations and oversight processes described in this Order balance the privacy interests of aviation employees with the FAA’s safety mandate to detect and deter illegal drug use and alcohol misuse. We must conduct our inspections, investigations, and voluntary disclosure report analyses in a constructive, ethical,
8.
9.
unbiased, and professional manner. Implementation of the procedural safeguards within Federal regulations and this Order will ensure these objectives.
Responsibilities. The following personnel are responsible for conducting the surveillance activities described in this Order:
a. The Drug Abatement Division Director (AAM-800 Director) is responsible for all surveillance activities and directly involved in some parts of the inspection process.
b. The Program Administration Branch Manager (AAM-810 Manager) and AAM-810 program analysts are responsible for the inspection scheduling process and management of the Division’s Voluntary Disclosure Reporting Program as described in this Order.
c. The Special Investigations Branch Manager (AAM-830 Manager) and investigators are responsible for the investigations of individuals who perform safety-sensitive functions as described in Chapter 3 of this Order.
d. The Compliance and Enforcement Center Managers (Center Managers), Team Coordinators, and inspectors are responsible for conducting inspections and investigations of employers and service agents as described in this Order.
Who Do We Surveil? We inspect and investigate employers, contractors, service agents, and individuals or employees to verify their compliance with the drug and alcohol testing regulations under 14 CFR part 120 and 49 CFR part 40. For purposes of this Order, we use the term “employer” to include an employer or contractor, unless otherwise specified.
a. Employers. Part 120 defines an employer as “a part 119 certificate holder with authority to operate under parts 121 and/or 135, an operator as defined in 14 CFR § 91.147, or an air traffic control facility not operated by the FAA or by or under contract for the U.S. Military.” 14 CFR § 120.7(i). Part 40 defines an employer as “[a] person or entity employing one or more employees (including an individual who is self-employed) subject to DOT agency regulations requiring compliance with this part. The term includes an employer’s officers, representatives, and management personnel. Service agents are not employers for the purposes of this part.” 49 CFR § 40.3.
(1) An employer must ensure that individuals hired to perform safety-sensitive functions, directly or by contract (including subcontract at any tier), are subject to drug and alcohol testing.
(2) Employers are responsible for all actions of their officials, representatives, and service agents in carrying out the requirements of the testing regulations.
b. Contractors. Part 120 defines a contractor as, “an individual or company that performs a safety-sensitive function by contract for an employer or another contractor.” A contractor may be non-certificated or hold an FAA certificate issued under 14 CFR part 145. There are two options for drug and alcohol testing contractors:
(1) The contractor obtains and implements its own drug and alcohol testing program. If the contractor chooses this option, it must implement the program as if it were the employer.
(2) The employer includes the contractor under its own drug and alcohol testing program.
c. Service Agents. Part 40 defines a service agent as, “[a]ny person or entity, other than an employee of the employer, who provides services to employers and/or employees in connection with DOT drug and alcohol testing requirements.” 49 CFR § 40.3.
(1) A Consortium/Third-Party Administrator (C/TPA) is a service agent that may implement portions of the testing program for an employer. Program elements may include random testing and/or education or training for employees or supervisors.
(2) Other service agents may provide services including but not limited to the following:
(a) Urine drug collections, as specimen collectors
(b) Breath alcohol testing, as breath alcohol technicians (BAT)
(c) Alcohol saliva testing, as screening test technicians (STT)
(d) Laboratory1
(e) Medical review officer (MRO) functions
(f) Substance abuse professional (SAP) functions.
(3) The roles and responsibilities of service agents are prescribed in 49 CFR part 40, subpart Q and Appendix F. Inspections or investigations of any employer may include a review of its service agent’s practices and procedures. The employer is responsible for compliance with the regulations even when using a service agent. Therefore, a service agent’s failure to comply with the regulations may result in violations against the employer.
A service agent may be subject to a public interest exclusion (PIE), as described under subpart R of part 40, if the service agent, by serious noncompliance with 49 CFR part 40 or other DOT agency drug and alcohol testing regulations (including 14 CFR part 120), has shown that it is not currently acting in a responsible matter.
d. Covered Employees or Employees.2 Part 40 defines an employee under 49 CFR § 40.3 as “[a]ny person who is designated in a DOT agency regulation as subject to drug testing and/or alcohol testing. The term includes individuals currently performing safety-sensitive functions designated in DOT agency regulations and applicants for employment subject to pre-employment testing.” Part 120 lists the following types of safety-sensitive functions that must be subject to drug and alcohol testing under 14 CFR §§ 120.105 and 120.215:
(1) Flight crewmember duties
1 The Department of Health and Human Services is responsible for oversight of all certified laboratories.
2 A covered employee is defined in 14 CFR § 120.7(f) as an individual who performs either directly or by contract, a safety-sensitive function listed in §§ 120.105 or 120.215 for an employer. For purposes of pre-employment testing only, the term ‘covered employee’ includes an individual applying to perform a safety-sensitive function. An employee is defined in 14 CFR § 120.7(h) as an individual who is hired, either directly or by contract, to perform a safety-sensitive function for an employer. An employee is also an individual who transfers into a position to perform a safety-sensitive function for an employer.
(2) Flight attendant duties
(3) Flight instruction duties
(4) Aircraft dispatcher duties
(5) Aircraft maintenance or preventive maintenance duties
(6) Ground security coordinator duties
(7) Aviation screening duties
(8) Air traffic control duties, and
(9) Operations control specialist duties.
Pages from FAA_Order_9120.1E - Final Clean Copy (March 21 2023) (003) › Chapter 2. Inspection
Chapter 2. Inspection
1. Purpose. This chapter provides the Compliance and Enforcement Drug and Alcohol Inspectors, Team Coordinators, and Center Managers with policies and procedures for conducting inspections of employers’ drug and alcohol testing programs.
2. General. The Compliance and Enforcement Centers are responsible for conducting employer or service agent inspections. A successful inspection entails accomplishing a sequence of five interrelated activities. This sequence begins with inspection scheduling, proceeds through detailed planning, conducting the inspection activity, reporting of inspection results, and concludes with postinspection follow-up activities. Inspections are executed according to the procedures established in this chapter. The Drug Abatement Division has established an Inspection Guide (Guide), which is found under Appendix A of this Order. All inspectors must follow the Guide during each inspection. Deviations from the Guide are strictly prohibited and failure by AAM-800 personnel to follow the procedures in this chapter may result in a nonconformity and corrective action (NCA). Drug Abatement Personnel must use the Compliance and Enforcement Tracking Subsystem (CETS) Reference List when entering noncompliance issues or concerns. The CETS Reference List is available on AAM-800’s SharePoint.
3. Inspection Activities. The FAA employs a variety of inspection activities to determine whether employers are in compliance with the drug and alcohol testing regulations. Inspections are conducted based on AAM-800’s priorities defined in its Strategic Compliance Monitoring Plan (SCMP) and resources. To use its resources to their fullest capacity, AAM-800 uses two different methods to conduct an inspection, employs different types of inspection activities, and determines the scope of the inspection based on the size and complexity of the employer. Inspection activities are conducted by an inspection lead, working independently or with a team of inspectors.
a. Methods of Inspecting. The method of inspecting an employer depends on the size and complexity of the employer, and the availability or limits of our inspector resources. Based on recent events, AAM-800 conducted virtual inspections that were effective and allowed continued surveillance while inspectors were working virtually. It has proven to be a beneficial improvement to AAM-800’s surveillance activities, both for the employer and inspection workforce. There are small differences between inspecting on-site, the traditional way to conduct an inspection, and virtually. The differences include the scheduling of the inspection, obtaining the records, and the employer’s cooperation.
(1) On-Site Inspection. An on-site inspection requires the inspection lead and team members to travel to the location where the employer operates and/or maintains its program records. While on-site, the inspection team interviews the employer representatives, reviews the records, and conducts all inspection procedures in accordance with this Order.
(2) Virtual Inspection. A virtual inspection requires the inspection lead and team member(s), if applicable, to conduct the inspection from an alternate workplace and not onsite at an employer’s location. Travel requirements do not apply in this situation, and scheduling requires cooperation by the employer to provide records prior to the scheduled inspection date and time. The inspection lead follows the same inspection procedures in accordance with this Order.
b. Other Types of Inspection Activities. Additionally, inspectors will be assigned to participate in
high impact, special emphasis, and service agent inspections.
(1) High Impact Inspections. A high impact inspection focuses on promoting consistency within the inspection process and the application of the regulations, provides an opportunity for crosstraining, and allows a manager to directly observe and assess an inspector’s performance. High impact inspections are conducted on-site by multiple teams of inspectors from two or more Drug Abatement centers during a one or two-week period. This approach permits the concentration of inspector resources in a planned geographic area and maximizes visibility for the Drug Abatement Program. During high impact inspection weeks, a meeting is scheduled for inspectors and managers to meet and discuss program issues. These discussions provide management with topics to be covered in future inspector training or identify a need for guidance and/or policy development.
(2) Special Emphasis Inspections. An on-site or virtual special emphasis inspection is scheduled to focus on one part of the regulations (e.g., MRO, SAP, or collection site review) at a national level.
(3) Service Agent Inspections. An on-site or virtual inspection of a service agent will focus directly on a C/TPA, MRO, SAP, or collection facility. It is not typically related to an employer inspection. The standard operating procedures (SOP) for service agent inspections are in Appendix B of this Order.
c. Scope of an Inspection. Whether an inspection is conducted on-site or virtually, the scope of the inspection is determined by the AAM-810 Manager or Center Manager.
(1) Comprehensive Inspections. Comprehensive inspections are thorough reviews of all aspects of an employer’s drug and alcohol testing program. Although we may sometimes focus on specific areas based on information concerning potential problems, the overall format of such inspections is standardized in accordance with this Order. In some cases, the comprehensive inspection may be conducted without advance notice to the employer.
(2) Focused Inspections. Under certain circumstances, focused inspections, which are narrow or limited in scope, may be conducted in response to a specific problem. Problems may be identified from various information sources, including analyses of prior inspection results, annual testing reports, individual or union complaints, or other alternative means. For example, FAA headquarters may receive complaints concerning improper collection procedures. In that case, Drug Abatement may conduct an inspection focusing on the employer’s collection procedures. Focused inspections may involve a single employer or entity, as in the example above, or a representative group of employers if information indicates that a problem is widespread. A focused inspection must include the employer’s administrative and quality assurance activities (e.g., Medical Review Officer (MRO) verification) and mandatory testing (i.e., pre-employment, random, post-accident, reasonable cause/suspicion, return to duty, and follow-up).
4. Inspection Scheduling. Prior to the beginning of the fiscal year, the inspection weeks are published in CETS. Before every quarter, the Drug Abatement Division composes a quarterly inspection schedule based on this chapter, Drug Abatement’s Strategic Compliance Monitoring Plan3
(SCMP), and the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between the FAA and the National Air
3 The Strategic Compliance Monitoring Plan (SCMP) is the Drug Abatement Division’s policy for scheduling inspections.
Traffic Controllers Association (NATCA). The AAM-810 Manager is responsible for scheduling inspection activities that meet the requirements of the SCMP and MOU. Once the priorities are set, an AAM-810 program analyst assembles the teams of employers and pre-inspection materials (located on the AAM-800’s SharePoint) for the national inspection schedule. These procedures are found in Appendix E of this Order.
a. The inspection team assignments are made in conjunction with the existing MOU. The AAM 810 Manager or designated program analyst is responsible for appointing the inspection lead and identifying whether the inspection will be comprehensive or focused. Additionally, inspectors will be assigned to participate in high impact, special emphasis, and service agent inspections. Inspectors must access their schedules in CETS.
(1) Announced Inspections. An announced inspection requires advance notification to the employer. To announce an inspection, the inspection lead must contact the employer by phone or email to notify it of its scheduled inspection and obtain information in accordance with the procedures in Appendix E of this Order (e.g., the employer’s size, service agents, new hires, affiliations with other employers, etc.). If the inspector discovers the employer is affiliated with another employer, the inspector must verify whether the two employers are managing a combined drug and alcohol program or conducting testing under two separate programs. If managing a combined program, the inspector must review the employers’ information in CETS and verify that the records are properly annotated.4 The inspector must notify their Team Coordinator and Center Manager if the employer is affiliated and not properly annotated. Refer to Appendix E of this Order for further instructions. The inspector must update the Activity Narrative in the inspection profile with the date and time they communicated with the employer representative to schedule the inspection.
Once the inspector finalizes the schedule with the employer, he/she must send an email to his/her Center Manager, Team Coordinator, and [email protected] indicating the employers have been notified of their inspections. An AAM-810 designated program analyst retrieves the information in CETS and sends the letter of notification (LON) to the employer’s President, CEO, or Designated Employer Representative via electronic mail, copying [email protected] and the inspection lead/inspection team, to confirm the pending inspection. The AAM-810 designated program analyst must request and confirm a delivery receipt from the employer. If the analyst is unable to confirm receipt by the employer, he/she must contact the AAM-810 Manager for further instructions. The LON template is contained on AAM-800’s SharePoint. The AAM-810 designated program analyst must follow the AAM-810 Manager’s procedures to prepare the LON and attachment and document the notification in the employer’s inspection profile in CETS. In cases where an employer is added to the schedule after the work plan is sent to the inspector, the inspector and the AAM-810 designated program analyst must follow the same scheduling and notification procedures as outlined above and in Appendix E of this Order.
(a) The LON package, sent by AAM-810, includes a list of records and documents necessary for inspection (to cover 12, 18, or 24 months, or since the employer’s last inspection) and a request for the employer’s points of contact. After sending the LON, the AAM-810 designated program analyst will provide an initial work plan to the inspectors, Center Manager, Team Coordinators, Administrative Officer, and [email protected]. The union
4 A drug and alcohol paragraph (A449) or Letter of Authorization (A049) in the employer’s Operations Specifications (OPSPEC) must be annotated with an “A2” or ”A3” if affiliated with another operator.
representative may request and receive a copy of the work plan(s), and it must be provided upon request.
(b) Prior to the inspection, the inspection lead ensures that the point of contact information has been received from the employer and updated in CETS. During any pre-inspection contact with an employer, inspectors must refrain from initiating an inspection prior to on-site arrival or the commencement of the virtual inspection. All inspectors are strictly prohibited from coaching employers or distributing unauthorized documents at any time.
(c) There may be instances in which an employer, after receiving an LON, will question the need for an inspection because it has ceased operations under 14 CFR § 119.63, but continues to hold a part 119 certificate with authority to conduct part 121 or 135 operations. Regardless of whether an employer that holds a certificate is exercising the privileges of its certificate, it must be available for inspection. If the employer advises the inspector that it has ceased its operations, or the employer does not respond to the inspector’s email or follow-up phone calls, the inspector must contact the employer’s Principal Operations Inspector (POI) or Principal Maintenance Inspector (PMI) to determine whether the employer has surrendered its certificate. That information must then be given to the AAM-810 Scheduling Team for a determination as to whether the employer will be inspected. If an employer has ceased operations under 14 CFR § 119.63 but has retained its certificate and is unwilling to be inspected, the employer must contact its POI/PMI to surrender its certificate. The inspector must follow-up with the POI/PMI to ensure that this has been accomplished.
(2) Unannounced On-Site Inspections. Unannounced inspections are essential to an effective compliance program. Each inspector may be responsible for conducting unannounced inspections during the fiscal year.
(a) Center Managers may schedule an unannounced on-site inspection for any inspector during any inspection week.
(b) Inspection teams may conduct an unscheduled, unannounced inspection, as time allows, which requires the inspectors to locate employers in their assigned geographical areas.
(c) Preparations for unannounced inspections might include contact with the local Flight Standards District Office (FSDO) to ascertain that the employer is still operating and has an active certificate.
(d) Inspection leads must inform their Center Manager and other teams in the geographical area, if possible, before conducting unscheduled inspections, to preclude multiple inspection attempts at the same employer. The Center Manager will notify and consult with the AAM-810 Manager accordingly.
(e) For all unannounced inspections, the inspection lead or team must not contact the employer in advance of the inspection.
(3) Inspection Schedule Changes and Cancellations. While all efforts are made to maintain the inspection schedule as is, at times it is essential to the program to make necessary changes or cancel a scheduled inspection. During the inspection scheduling process, the inspector sends the Notification of FAA Drug Abatement Inspection email (template located on AAM-800’s SharePoint)
to the employer. If the employer fails to contact or acknowledge the inspector’s notification that was completed in accordance with Appendix E of this Order, the inspection is not scheduled and the inspector must notify [email protected] and copy their Center Manager and Team Coordinator.
AAM-810 will verify whether there are known or suspected problems that require the employer’s inspection in accordance with the SCMP. Once AAM-810 makes a determination about the status of the employer’s inspection, AAM-810 will update the schedule and notify the inspector by email that the employer was or was not removed from his/her inspection schedule, and if a new employer was added to his/her schedule (if applicable). AAM-810 will copy the Center Manager and Team Coordinator in their communication with the inspector.
Once an employer is notified of its inspection and the schedule is established, an inspector must notify their Center Manager if there is a need to cancel the inspection. The Center Manager must notify the AAM-810 Manager to allow AAM-810 an opportunity to approve or deny the cancellation after verifying there are no known or suspected problems that required the inspection in accordance with the SCMP. AAM-810 must make a determination and notify the Center Manager to cancel the inspection and may assign a new employer for the inspector. The Center Manager must notify the inspector and provide further instructions. When a scheduled inspection is cancelled, the inspector must document the cancellation in CETS.
5. Travel Requirements for On-Site Inspections. Each inspector is responsible for adhering to the following requirements when travel for an on-site inspection is required:
a. Inspectors must adhere to the FAA Travel Policy (FAATP), which is available on the FAA’s Employee Web site, and the Bargaining Unit Contract.
b. Whenever possible, inspectors will arrive in the inspection city at approximately the same time. All travel and lodging preparations must be confirmed at least one week prior to the inspection, unless precluded by schedule changes.
c. Inspectors must conserve time and fiscal resources. For instance, inspectors will lodge near inspection sites, when possible. The FAATP states, “You must take the same care in incurring expenses a prudent person would take if traveling on personal business.” The Policy further states, “You must pay for all costs you incur for personal preference or convenience. We will not pay for excess costs resulting from indirect routes, delays, or luxury accommodations or services unnecessary or unjustified in the performance of official business.”
d. Inspectors must arrange travel according to the inspection team’s work plan. When exceptions occur, the inspector must notify his/her Center Manager or Team Coordinator. This notification may occur prior to or during travel.
6. Final Inspection Work Plan. Each inspector must submit a final inspection work plan to his/her Center Manager and Team Coordinator no later than the Wednesday of the week prior to inspections. The work plan must contain all employers to be inspected, along with their POCs, telephone numbers, and associated service agents (e.g., MRO and/or C/TPA). Service agent information must include the associated employer’s name unless the service agent is a C/TPA. For on-site inspections, the work plan must include the hotel and transportation information (if applicable). The current work
plan tool is available electronically on AAM-800’s SharePoint.
7. Preparation for the Inspection. The inspection lead is responsible for planning his/her assigned inspections for accomplishing the goals of the inspection. The inspection leads ensures that his/her team accomplishes all critical aspects of an inspection, including planning and reporting, according to established procedures (see on-site inspection guide in Figure 2-1, or the virtual inspection guide in Figure 2-2).
a. The inspection lead must examine CETS and the drug and alcohol history of each employer to find past noncompliance issues and any cases of known or suspected problems. This includes previous inspections, open or closed voluntary disclosures, legal enforcement actions, and other special issues (including noncompliance transmittal reports as defined in Chapter 3 of this Order). This information will help the inspection team identify repeated noncompliance. The inspection lead must review the employer’s drug and alcohol paragraph (A449), Letter of Authorization (A049) or registration to ensure accuracy of required information.
b. Each inspection must include a review of the mandatory testing records, which includes the following:
(1) Hiring records (including the pre-employment results and records checks);
(2) Random testing records;
(3) Reasonable cause/suspicion, post-accident, return-to-duty, and follow-up test results;
(4) Any positive drug test results, alcohol violations, and refusal determinations;
(5) Verification by the MRO; and
(6) Latest Management Information System (MIS) report.
The inspection lead determines whether additional areas require evaluation, based on the progress of the inspection, or an employer’s compliance history (e.g., previous inspections, investigations, voluntary disclosures, compliance actions, administrative actions, legal enforcement actions, etc.).
c. Each team member must bring the following inspection tools to, or have them available during, all inspection activities:
(1) Copy of the regulations (14 CFR part 120 and 49 CFR Part 40);
(2) Copy of this Order (including Appendices A and C);
(3) Forms (e.g., meeting attendance list, employee interview guide, witness statement form, record of interview, Small Business Information and Best Evidence Checklist5);
(4) Laptop; and
5 The Small Business Information Sheet and Best Evidence Checklist are located on AAM-800’s SharePoint.
(5) Office supplies (e.g., pens, note pads, paper clips, stapler, etc.).
d. The inspection lead must notify his/her Center Manager if additional personnel are needed or if a change in scope (e.g., comprehensive or expanded focus) is necessary.
e. Inspectors must ensure voluntary disclosure issues are addressed in accordance with Chapter 4 of this Order.
8. Pre-Inspection Team Meetings. The inspection lead must hold a meeting before the inspection to ensure a smooth, professional and quality inspection. These meetings must occur prior to arriving at the inspection site or before the virtual inspection begins. During the pre-inspection team meeting, the inspection lead must:
a. Provide the employer’s compliance history to the inspection team members;
b. Assign one or more of the following inspection areas to each inspection team member: Administrative and Quality Assurance; Collection Site Review; MRO Review; SAP Review; and specific areas for Record Review.
c. Establish each inspection team member’s responsibility for the inbriefing, outbriefing, and CETS entry; and
d. Confirm each inspection team member’s responsibility to inform the inspection lead immediately of any findings of noncompliance and supporting evidence or areas of concern.
9. Inspection Procedures. It is critical, and mandatory under ISO procedures, to ensure that each inspection is conducted according to the Drug Abatement Division’s inspection protocol. During each inspection, inspectors must adhere to the following requirements:
a. Conduct. All AAM-800 personnel will conduct themselves professionally and must:
(1) Maintain decorum in speech, dress, and behavior;
(2) Treat team members and employer representatives with respect;
(3) Avoid socializing with any individual associated with an employer’s inspection, including service agents, to ensure there is no appearance of loss of impartiality in the performance of your official duties in accordance with the Ethics Regulations (5 CFR part 2635);
(4) Avoid discussing internal DOT or FAA activities (e.g., anticipated changes in policy, procedures, or rulemaking) with employers;
(5) Avoid discussing pending enforcement matters pertaining to current or previous inspections and investigations;
(6) Avoid conversations regarding other operators; and
(7) Bring inspection issues to the attention of the inspection lead.
b. Inbriefing. The inspection lead must start the inspection by conducting an inbriefing with the employer and inspection team members (if applicable). The inbriefing/outbriefing guide is available in Figure 2-3 (for on-site inspections) and Figure 2-4 (for virtual inspections).
(1) The inspection lead must make introductions, and circulate a sign-in sheet for on-site inspections or document the attendees for a virtual inspection using the meeting attendance list in Figure 2-5. If the employer is a small business, the inspector must provide the employer with the Small Business Information. If the inspection is virtual, the inspector must email the Small Business Information. The Small Business Information sheet is located on AAM-800’s SharePoint.
(2) At the conclusion of the inbriefing, the inspection lead must announce that the next step in the process (the Administrative and Quality Assurance Interview) specifically includes the program manager and/or DER. The inspection lead may request others in attendance to leave, if their presence is not necessary.
c. Administrative and Quality Assurance Interview. The inspection lead begins the interview phase with the employer’s representative (e.g., program manager and/or DER) regarding the drug and alcohol testing program. To conduct the interview, each inspector must use the inspection guide found in Appendix A, Part 1 of this Order. During the subsequent record review and evidence collection phase of the inspection, inspectors must verify all information provided during the interview.
d. Drug and Alcohol Testing Records Review. Records are the most common form of evidence used to verify the statements of the employer’s representative. As an example, an employer may provide an inspector with a spreadsheet that includes dates of hire, transfer, and pre-employment testing. Inspectors must verify the spreadsheet information by assembling the source documents (e.g., personnel action forms, custody and control forms (CCF), etc.) that pertain to each item on the spreadsheet. Inspectors must not request the employer to generate a spreadsheet for the purpose of the inspection. Inspectors must collect all documents provided by the employer to support the inspection. All collected records must be maintained as part of the inspection record and in accordance with Appendix F of this Order.
(1) Inspection leads and team members will take part in record review activities and enter their findings in the inspection results section of CETS. Inspectors must review and address every known apparent violation of or noncompliance with FAA statutes and regulations. Worksheets are available to assist inspectors during the record review and interview phases of the inspection (see New Hire/Transfer Guide in Figure 2-6, Inspection Noncompliance Issue Guide in Figure 2-7, Employee Interview Guide in Figure 2-9, Witness Statement Guide in Figure 2-10, and Record of Interview Guide in Figure 2-11).
(2) Inspectors are responsible for reviewing, copying, and certifying the authenticity of documents, as assigned by the inspection lead. The inspection lead must ensure each assigned portion of the review process is completed. Each inspector must initial the records review guide in the area of their assignments (see Part 2 of the Inspection Guide in Appendix A of this Order) to demonstrate completion. The inspection lead will enter this information into the official inspection record in CETS, and will add the documents to the inspection record (in accordance with Appendix F of this Order).
(3) To support the elements of a statutory or regulatory violation in a legal enforcement
action, the inspection lead must provide a statement indicating the evidence collected is a true and authentic copy of the original. To certify the authenticity of the evidence collected, the inspection lead must provide a single inspector statement as an Item of Proof in the legal enforcement action case file (see Figure 2-8 for a Sample Statement of Authenticity). If the inspection lead did not collect and/or compare the document or evidence with the original version, the inspection lead cannot certify it is true and accurate. The inspection lead must obtain a second statement from the individual who can testify that the document or evidence is a true and authentic copy of the original. A statement is not required for some documents, (e.g., FAA-generated records, manuals in the FAA’s possession, emails and/or letters to inspectors that indicate the sender and date of transmission). For more information, refer to Order 2150.3, as amended, Chapter 4.
(4) The inspection team must review all mandatory testing records for the time period established by his/her Center Manager and inspection lead prior to the inspection. Depending on the circumstances, the time periods may include the past 24-months, 18-months, or 12-months, or since the employer’s last inspection.
(5) Inspectors must make all attempts to interview any safety-sensitive employee whose records need to be clarified.
(6) Records to review and document, if applicable, include the following categories:
(a) Positive Drug Tests, Refusals, and Alcohol Violation Records.6 Inspectors must review all verified positive drug test results, refusals to submit to drug or alcohol testing, and misuse of alcohol, except those that have already been investigated by or reported to AAM-830. Inspectors must review the records for each employee who failed or refused a DOT drug and/or alcohol test to verify that:
(1) The employee was not hired or was removed from safety-sensitive duties after the violation.
(2) The employer provided the employee with a listing of DOT-qualified SAPs readily available to the employee.
(3) The employer sent the report to the Federal Air Surgeon (or Drug Abatement Division) within 2 days if the employee tested positive for drugs and/or 0.04 or greater on an alcohol test or refused a drug or alcohol test and holds a part 67 medical certificate, or holds a part 61, 63, or 65 certificate and refused a drug or alcohol test. See paragraph (b) below for more instructions if you find any noncompliance related to reporting.
(4) The employer properly performed the return-to-duty process following an employee’s drug or alcohol misuse violation. Inspectors must review the employee’s return-to-duty records, which include the SAP reports and followup testing plan; SAP credentials; return-to-duty test result(s); records that
6 A violation includes: a verified positive drug test result; refusal to submit to a drug test as defined under 49 CFR § 40.191 (including adulterated and substituted tests); a confirmed alcohol test with a breath alcohol concentration of 0.04 or greater; a refusal to submit to an alcohol test as defined under 49 CFR § 40.261; on-duty drug or alcohol use; pre-duty alcohol use; and alcohol use following an accident.
document the employee’s return to a safety-sensitive function; and all follow-up test results. See paragraphs (c) and (d) below for a more detailed list of records to review.
An inspector must document an employer’s violation of failing to ensure that an employee completed the return-to-duty process prior to allowing the employee to perform safety-sensitive functions. The inspector must insist that the employer immediately remove the employee from duty and take the steps to correct the unacceptable risk associated with the violation.
Due to Privacy Act implications and stringent restrictions for certificate holders subject to the Pilot’s Bill of Rights (PBR), inspectors are prohibited from discussing an employee’s violation with the individual or his/her employer. If an inspector learns of an employer using an employee who is performing safety-sensitive work for one or more employers and did not complete the return-to-duty procedures, it must be reported to his/her Center Manager immediately. Refer to the next section for instructions about reporting safety-related issues for investigation by AAM-830. Inspectors, Team Coordinators, and Center Managers are prohibited from sharing information about an individual with another employer in accordance with our Privacy Act System of Records published in the Federal Register on November 9, 2010.
(b) Reporting Violations by Certificated Airmen to AAM-830. Inspectors who discover that an employer failed to report a part 61, 63, 65, or 67 certificate holder’s violation to the Federal Air Surgeon must report the information immediately to their Center Manager and [email protected]. The inspector’s report must include a statement of the details regarding the noncompliance and any evidence available. Inspectors must not investigate, comment, or discuss the certificate holder’s violations with the employer or employee.
Inspectors must advise the employer to immediately report the information to the Federal Air Surgeon via the Drug Abatement Division at [email protected] and document the noncompliance for failure to report a violation to the Federal Air Surgeon. The AAM-830 Manager will notify the inspection lead and Center Manager when and how to address any noncompliance regarding the employer’s failure to report the information to the FAA in accordance with the regulation.
(c) Return-to-Duty Testing Records. An employer may allow an applicant or employee to return to performing safety-sensitive duties after the SAP determines that the employee successfully completed the education and/or treatment. To do so, the employer must conduct a return-to-duty drug and/or alcohol test and have a negative result prior to allowing an employee to return to performing safety-sensitive functions to ensure the employee is drug-free and is not violating alcohol misuse provisions in 14 CFR part 120. During the records review, inspectors must complete the procedures below:
(1) Inspectors must ensure the employer obtained the information from the SAP, including the reports and follow-up testing plan, and conducted the necessary return-to-duty testing.
(2) Inspectors must verify the employer notified the collection site prior to the test that the test was for return-to-duty and confirmed that it was collected using direct-observation procedures.
(3) Inspectors must verify that all return-to-duty test results are verified negative by the MRO or resulted in a breath alcohol concentration of below 0.02.
(4) Inspectors must conduct a thorough review of all return-to-duty records, including:
(a) Documentation of the triggering violations;
(b) SAP reports (initial and follow-up evaluations, including the follow-up
testing plans) and qualifications;
(c) Return-to-duty CCFs/breath alcohol testing forms (ATFs) and verified drug
test results/confirmed alcohol test results;
(d) Evidence that new airmen medical certificates have been issued, when
applicable; and
(e) Documentation that the employees were returned to safety-sensitive
functions and placed into the random drug and alcohol testing pools.
(5) If an inspector discovers an employee’s return-to-duty testing or collection of records are not acceptable, he/she must insist the employer take immediate actions to correct the safety risk.
(d) Follow-up Testing Records. After an employee returns to work following a violation, the employer must conduct the follow-up testing as directed by the SAP. The objective of the followup testing is to ensure the employee has stopped using controlled substances or misusing alcohol. During the records review, inspectors must complete the following procedures:
(1) Inspectors must verify that for each follow-up drug test, the employer notified the collection site prior to the test that it was a follow-up test and confirmed that it was collected using direct-observation procedures.
(2) Inspectors must verify that all follow-up test results are verified negative by the MRO or resulted in a breath alcohol concentration of below 0.02.
(3) Inspectors must conduct a thorough review of all follow-up testing records to ensure the employer followed the SAP’s directions.
(4) If there is a lapse in employment or breaks in service, e.g., a furlough, leave of absence, or new employment, the timeline for testing stops in accordance with 49 CFR § 40.307(e). The inspector must ensure the follow-up testing properly restarted if it was stopped.
(5) If an inspector discovers the employer did not conduct any follow-up testing or they failed to follow the SAP’s directions, the inspector must insist the employer take immediate action to correct the safety risk. The inspector must contact his/her Center Manager immediately for further instructions.
(e) Pre-employment Testing Records. An employer must conduct a pre-employment drug test and receive a verified negative result prior to hiring any individual or transferring an employee to perform safety-sensitive functions. The pre-employment drug test is directly tied to aviation safety, in that it is a gateway to safety-sensitive positions. Failing a pre-employment drug test is a direct barrier to an individual’s entry into a safety-sensitive position. It is considered particularly critical because it is the source of the largest number of positive drug test results in the aviation industry. Therefore, an inspector must be diligent in reviewing the pre-employment test results to verify the employee was tested prior to hire or transfer into a safety-sensitive position.
Pre-employment alcohol testing is optional, and an employer must conduct it prior to the first time a safety-sensitive employee performs, but after making a contingent offer of employment or transfer. An employer must treat all individuals seeking to perform safety-sensitive functions the same for the purpose of pre-employment alcohol testing (i.e., they must not test some employees and not others). An employer must not allow an employee to begin performing safety-sensitive functions unless the result of the employee's test indicates an alcohol concentration of less than 0.04. If a pre-employment alcohol test result indicates an alcohol concentration of 0.02 or greater but less than 0.04, the employer must follow the provisions of 14 CFR § 120.221(f). Failing a pre-employment alcohol test is also a direct barrier to an individual’s entry into a safety-sensitive position. Therefore, an inspector must verify the employer tested all new hires or transfers if its policy requires pre-employment alcohol testing.
During the records review, inspectors must complete the following procedures:
(1) Inspectors must verify the hire or transfer records, pre-employment testing
results, and performance records to determine there are no deviations or unacceptable risks to aviation safety;
(2) Inspectors must conduct a thorough review of an employer’s pre-employment
testing records, including:
(a) Test results (either using a CCF, ATF, or written result);
(b) Hire/transfer records to include payroll, personnel action forms, internal
employer hiring or transfer reports, training records;
(c) Safety-sensitive position records (e.g., personnel position descriptions);
(d) Work records, such as pilots logs, maintenance logs, timesheets, etc.; and
(e) Witness statements from employer officials or actual safety-sensitive
employees.
(3) If an employer failed to conduct a pre-employment test prior to hiring or
transferring an employee, inspectors must collect all evidence to support the finding. The work records become critical to determine if there is an unacceptable risk to aviation safety that would indicate the need to support a legal enforcement action.
(f) Random Testing Records. An employer must conduct random testing as part of its
FAA-mandated drug and alcohol testing program, and it is imperative that the employer ensures the random pool is accurate and up-to-date. Random testing has three purposes:
(1) To detect illegal drug use and alcohol misuse;
(2) To deter employees from using illegal drugs and misusing alcohol; and
(3) To remove employees engaged in such use from the performance of safety-
sensitive functions.
Random testing is considered critical because failure to conduct testing and/or include all safetysensitive employees in a DOT random testing pool could potentially create a significant risk to safety by allowing employees to perform safety-sensitive work who use prohibited drugs or misuse alcohol without risk of detection. Therefore, it is essential for inspectors to have thorough knowledge of what comprises a random testing program. Appendix C of this Order further explores random testing regulations, including minimum annual random testing rate, selection methodology, updating the random pool, notification procedures, excusal policies and over-selection, frequency of selection and testing, and inspecting a random program. During the records review, the inspector must be diligent in reviewing the employer’s random program and must complete the following procedures:
(1) The inspector must verify that the employer uses a scientifically valid random
selection methodology, such as a random number table or a computer-based random number generator;
(2) The inspector must verify that all safety-sensitive employees are included in the
employer’s DOT random pool;
(3) The inspector must verify that the employer added new hires or transfers into
safety-sensitive positions to the random testing pool in a timely manner and prior to the next random selection;
(4) The inspector must verify that the employer removed all employees who are no
longer in a safety-sensitive position (for reasons such as termination, resignation, transfer to a non safety-sensitive position, or assigned solely outside the territory of the U.S.) from the pool prior to the next random selection;
(5) If the employer opted to remove employees from the random pool when
employees were unavailable to perform safety-sensitive duties for the length of the selection period, the inspector must verify that the employee was removed from the random testing pool prior to the next random selection;
(6) If the employer removed employees from the pool for any reason, the inspector
must ensure that the employer placed the employees back into the random pool before they started performing safety-sensitive duties again and prior to the next random selection; and
(7) The inspector must verify that all safety-sensitive employees selected for
random testing were tested as indicated on the selection list.
Records that could be of use when inspecting an employer’s random testing program include:
(1) Random drug and alcohol selection lists;
(2) Random selection methodology, if documented;
(3) A listing of who was, or is, in the random pool during the covered period;
(4) Documentation that employees in the pool perform safety-sensitive functions
(such as maintenance logs, flight logs, or other performance documentation);
(5) Dates employees were added or deleted;
(6) Notification procedures, including notifications to out-lying locations;
(7) Documentation of whether employees proceeded immediately to the collection
site after notification of selection;
(8) CCFs;
(9) Verified drug test results;
(10) Breath ATFs with the alcohol test results; and
(11) Verification that the employer is satisfying the minimum testing rate that is
published in the Federal Register.
(g) Reasonable Cause/Reasonable Suspicion Testing Records. Reasonable cause/suspicion testing is critical in the detection of employees reporting for or performing duties while having a prohibited drug in his or her system or misusing alcohol. Employers are required to test their employees when there is a reasonable and articulable belief that the employee is using a prohibited drug or has violated the alcohol misuse prohibitions. A decision to drug test based on reasonable cause is based on the employer’s observation of the specific contemporaneous physical, behavioral, or performance indicators of probable drug use. A decision to conduct reasonable suspicion alcohol testing is based on the employer’s specific, contemporaneous, articulable observations concerning the employee’s appearance, behavior, speech or body odors. Employers must ensure that supervisors are trained to make a testing determination. Inspectors must review all reasonable cause/suspicion testing records, including:
(1) Documentation of the event that led to testing (if available) or to the decision
not to test;
(2) Documentation that the tested employee reported for or performed safety-
sensitive duties (such as maintenance logs, flight logs, or other performance documentation);
(3) Documentation of supervisory training and the material covered;
(4) CCFs;
(5) Verified drug test results; and
(6) ATFs with the alcohol test results.
(h) Post-Accident Testing Records. Post-accident drug and alcohol testing occurs when an employee’s performance may have contributed to an aviation accident or cannot be completely discounted as a contributing factor to the accident. A decision to not administer post-accident drug and alcohol testing must be based on a determination, using the best information available at the time of the determination that the employee’s performance could not have contributed to the accident. Such testing can only occur when the accident meets the definition under 14 CFR § 120.7(a). While testing must occur as soon as possible following an accident, employees must be tested for drugs not later than 32 hours after the accident, and for alcohol not longer than 8 hours after the accident. If an alcohol test is not administered within 2 hours of the accident, the employer must prepare and maintain on file a record stating the reasons the test was not promptly administered. If the alcohol test is not administered within 8 hours following the accident, the employer shall cease attempts to administer an alcohol test and shall prepare and maintain the same record. Inspectors must thoroughly review all post-accident testing records, including:
(1) Documentation of the accident;
(2) Documentation of the determination whether to test the employee, including
whether the accident meets the definition in 14 CFR § 120.7(a);
(3) CCFs;
(4) Verified drug test results;
(5) ATFs with the alcohol test results;
(6) Documentation on why alcohol testing was not conducted within 2 hours and/or
8 hours of the accident; and
(7) Documentation on why drug testing was not conducted within 32 hours of the
accident.
(i) Drug and Alcohol Records Check. Employers must conduct the drug and alcohol records check on all employees seeking to begin performing safety-sensitive duties, who previously worked for a DOT-regulated employer (as defined in 49 CFR § 40.3), to ensure employees with prior testing violations have complied with all return-to-duty and follow-up testing requirements. In accordance with 49 CFR § 40.25(b), employers must request the following information from DOTregulated employers who employed the employee at any time during the two years before the date of the employee’s application or transfer:
(1) Alcohol tests with a result of 0.04 or higher alcohol concentration;
(2) Verified positive drug tests;
(3) Refusals to be tested (including verified adulterated or substituted drug test
results);
(4) Other violations of DOT agency drug and alcohol testing regulations; and
(5) For any employee who violated a DOT drug and alcohol regulation,
documentation of the employee's successful completion of DOT return-to-duty requirements (including follow-up tests). If the previous employer does not have information about the return-to-duty process (e.g., an employer who did not hire an employee who tested positive on a pre-employment test), the employer must seek to obtain this information from the employee.
When reviewing an employer’s requests for drug and alcohol records, inspectors must determine whether the employer complied with 49 CFR § 40.25(d). Section 40.25(d) provides that, if feasible, an employer must obtain and review the information required under 49 CFR § 40.25(b) before the employee first performs safety-sensitive functions. If this is not feasible, the employer must obtain and review the information as soon as possible. However, the employer must not permit the employee to perform safety-sensitive functions after 30 days from the date on which the employee first performed safety-sensitive functions, unless the employer had obtained or made and documented a good faith effort to obtain this information. Sending the request to a previous employer and not making a good faith effort to obtain the information is unacceptable. A good faith effort consists of one documented attempt to obtain drug and alcohol testing records from a former employer (e.g., certified mail receipt, fax confirmation, time-stamped email). Information indicating that the former employer did not receive the attempt (e.g., mail returned “undeliverable as addressed,” fax did not transmit, email returned as undeliverable) may require an additional attempt. Sending a request to a former employer and not making an additional attempt when circumstances call for it is not a good faith effort. Allowing an employee to continue to perform safety-sensitive duties after 30 days from the date they first performed without conducting the records check is a violation of 49 CFR § 40.25(d).
Inspectors must examine all records relating to the drug and alcohol records check under 49 CFR § 40.25 and (for certain employers hiring pilots) the Pilot Records Improvement Act of 1996 (PRIA). The Pilot Records Database (PRD) is gradually replacing the paper-based PRIA process, but during the transition employers must continue to comply with PRIA (and must in any case comply with § 40.25).7 Inspectors must review individual resumes and/or job applications of personnel working in safety-sensitive functions to identify the employee’s previous employers and determine whether the employer conducted the required records checks.
Not every employer that must comply with 49 CFR § 40.25 must also comply with the PRIA. To meet the requirements under 49 CFR § 40.25, employers that operate under 14 CFR part 121 or 135 or § 91.147 and are hiring a pilot must conduct a PRIA record check. Unlike § 40.25, a PRIA record check goes back five years from the date of the PRIA request and requires previous employers to provide all negative and non-negative results, cancelled drug test results, and confirmed alcohol test
7 The FAA published the regulations implementing the PRD on June 10, 2021, which are codified at 14 CFR part 111. Under part 111, subpart C, previous and current employers must begin entering pilot drug and alcohol data (including verified positive drug test results, confirmed alcohol results of 0.04 or greater, refusals, pre- and on-duty use, use following an accident, and return-to-duty and follow-up testing results) on June 10, 2022. Employers required to make PRD record checks must begin doing so for previous employers’ records on June 10, 2022 per 14 CFR § 111.100(b).
results of less than 0.039. PRIA and § 40.25 have similar provisions (49 U.S.C. § 44703(h)(14)(B) and 49 CFR § 40.25(d) & (i), respectively) allowing an employer to start using an individual in a safety-sensitive position if the employer has made a documented good faith effort to obtain the required records. The FAA’s PRD and PRIA Advisory Circular (AC 120-68) states that, for drug and alcohol testing records, three documented attempts to obtain the records within a 30-day period would be considered reasonable.
In accordance with 49 CFR § 40.25(h), a previous employer responding to a written § 40.25 request must review the former employee’s specific, written consent and immediately release the requested information to the employer making the inquiry. PRIA requires a previous employer to obtain a copy of the pilot’s written consent before responding to a PRIA request and furnish the requested records no later than 30 calendar-days after receiving the request. In either case, inspectors must verify that the previous employer provided a timely response and included all appropriate records (e.g., negative and non-negative results, cancelled drug test results, and confirmed alcohol test results with an alcohol concentration of less than 0.039 for pilots in response to a PRIA request).
In accordance with 49 CFR § 40.25(j), inspectors must also ensure that the employer asked each employee whether they tested positive, or refused to test, on any pre-employment drug or alcohol test administered by an employer to which they applied for, but did not obtain, safety-sensitive transportation work covered by DOT agency drug and alcohol testing rules during the past two years. Inspectors must examine documentation of this question, if the employer documents it. If the employer does not document the employee’s response to this question, inspectors must document the employer’s policy for asking the question verbally.
(j) Management Information Systems (MIS). The inspector must verify that the drug and alcohol testing data on the annual MIS reports are accurate and the reports are complete and certified. If errors are discovered, the inspector must report this as a finding and notify his/her Center Manager and the AAM-810 Manager.
(k) Safety Management Systems (SMS) Records. The Flight Standards Service is responsible for regulatory oversight of part 121 employers’ safety management systems (SMS). The part 121 SMS rule (14 CFR part 5) made no changes to the drug and alcohol testing regulations, so SMS records have no bearing on a part 121 carrier’s drug and alcohol testing program. However, if the employer cites its SMS as a reason or factor in an out-of-compliance item, or if the inspector believes SMS records may be relevant to a particular out-of-compliance item, they may be reviewed. In this situation, the inspector must notify his/her Center Manager for guidance before taking further action.
e. Other Elements of an Inspection. In addition to the previous elements, the inspection is divided into the following remaining sections when inspectors review a service agent as part of the employer inspection:
(1) Collection site and personnel. Before inspecting a collection site as part of an employer inspection, the inspection team must first check CETS to see if the site has already had a comprehensive inspection within the previous 90 days. If so, the inspection team need only confirm that the collection site conducts DOT drug and alcohol collections for that employer. If not, or if an issue is discovered during record review at the employer, the team must proceed to do a collection site inspection according to Appendix A, Part 3 of this Order. The inspector must document the collection site interview in CETS.
(2) MRO. Before inspecting an MRO as part of an employer inspection, the inspection team must first check CETS to see if the employer’s MRO has already had a comprehensive inspection within the previous 2 years. If the MRO has been inspected within this period, the inspector must check whether the MRO’s certification expired since the last interview. If the MRO was interviewed and his/her qualifications are current, the inspection team need only confirm that the MRO works with that employer. If not, or if an issue is discovered during record review at the employer, the team must proceed to do an MRO inspection according to Appendix A, Part 4 of this Order. The inspector must document the verification of the MRO’s work for his/her inspection in CETS and, if applicable, the MRO interview in CETS.
(3) SAP. If the employer has records of return-to-duty and follow-up testing, the inspection team must contact the SAP to conduct an inspection according to Appendix A, Part 5 of this Order. The inspector must document the SAP interview in CETS.
f. Service Agent Issues Discovered. If any collector, laboratory, MRO, or SAP issues/discrepancies are discovered, regardless of the employer, the inspector must collect all the evidence and report it to his/her Center Manager. If the issue indicates a serious noncompliance, for example a consortium owner verifying drug test results on behalf of the MRO and using the MRO's stamp, the inspector must report it to his/her Center Manager. The Center Manager will consult with the AAM-800 Director, Deputy Director, and other AAM-800 managers to determine if the matter is a national issue that warrants an inspection or investigation. Based on the determination, the Center Manager must enter a Non-compliance Transmittal report in CETS under the Service Agent’s profile. A determination of whether to initiate an inspection or investigation of the service agent is determined by the Center Manager in coordination with the AAM-800 Director. If an inspection/investigation activity is initiated, the Center Manager and AAM-810 Manager must coordinate with the assigned inspector to schedule the inspection/investigation of the Service Agent. Refer to Appendix B of this Order for service agent inspections.
10. Evidence Collection. Evidence collection is the most critical element of the inspection to support a statutory or regulatory violation. To prove or disprove compliance by the employer, and to support the type of action and sanction, sufficient documentation must be reviewed and gathered. Inspectors must review all evidence relevant to an alleged finding of noncompliance whether it proves or disproves the suspected noncompliance by the employer. Inspectors must gather all available evidence to support the finding of noncompliance. When there are multiple findings of the same regulatory citation (e.g., failure to perform drug and alcohol record checks on several covered employees), inspectors must collect evidence relevant to each finding. This evidence must answer the questions about what happened, who was involved, and where, when, and why it occurred. The Best Evidence Checklist tool (available on AAM-800’s SharePoint) provides guidance to inspectors when collecting evidence. When using this tool, inspectors must consider the type of employer and gather the evidence necessary to establish the finding of noncompliance for that type of employer. For more information concerning types of evidence typically most applicable in Drug Abatement investigations, see Order 2150.3, as amended.
The following describes different types of evidence and how each type must be handled according to Order 2150.3, as amended.
a. Physical evidence. Physical evidence consists of tangible objects, such as specimen collection materials or computer software programs relating to random testing. Inspectors must exercise care in
handling physical evidence so that damage, loss, or alteration does not occur. (For more information concerning physical evidence, see Order 2150.3, as amended.)
b. Witness interviews and statements. Inspectors may use witness interviews to prove noncompliance and identify other people who have direct knowledge or documentation of the issue.
(1) When possible, interview all witnesses who may be aware of a noncompliance issue.
(2) Witness accounts must be written and signed by the author, who may be the witness or the inspector. Witnesses must be informed that they are not under oath.
(3) Inspectors must conduct the interview in a professional manner with consideration for the following (see Employee Interview Guide in Figure 2-9 and Witness Statement Form in Figure 2-10):
(a) Plan the interview and questions in advance;
(b) Be attentive and take notes;
(c) Maintain control of the interview;
(d) Ask direct, relevant, and open-ended questions; and
(e) Request a signed and dated statement from the witness.
(4) Inspectors will prepare a record of interview when outlining the interview/conversation conducted with witnesses or alleged violators. It must only state what the witness provided and it must not include the inspector’s personal views and/or opinions. A record of interview is necessary if a witness declines to provide a statement. Inspectors are encouraged to try to obtain witness statements that are written, signed, and dated by the interviewee. If the interviewee is unwilling to write his/her own statement, the inspector must write the interviewee’s statement and then ask the interviewee to review it for accuracy and sign and date it. If the interviewee is unwilling to do any of the above, the inspector must write the interviewee’s statement as an inspector statement and ask the interviewee to review the statement to ensure its accuracy. In the last circumstance, the inspector must document that the interviewee either affirmed the accuracy of the statement or declined to do so and that the interviewee refused to sign the statement. (For more information concerning witness interviews and statements, see Order 2150.3, as amended.)
(5) Inspector statements (see Record of Interview in Figure 2-11) are used to document findings that are not available in witness statements, technical publications, logbooks, and manuals, etc. They are also used to document a finding of noncompliance that is observed by the inspector or to capture an interview when a witness is unwilling to sign a record of interview. Inspector statements must include the date, time, location, and contact information of those present. They must be personally signed and dated by the inspector and must not include his/her personal views or opinions.
c. Other General Categories of Proof (i.e., Electronic Evidence, Photographs, Video, etc.). For a discussion of other common forms of evidence and how to prepare that evidence as an IOP (when necessary for an on-site inspection), see Order 2150.3, as amended.
11. Documentation of Inspection Results. In preparation for the outbriefing, each inspection lead will, as soon as possible but not later than the timelines indicated under Section 13 of this Order, enter his/her documentation of the inspection results into CETS. The following documentation must be entered into CETS in full detail and according to current guidance in the System Rules for CETS Data Entry:
a. Update of Employer Profile. Any new information concerning the employer, such as additional locations, employer representatives, email addresses, service agents, etc., must be added to the appropriate tab of the employer’s CETS profile. It is critical that the information you enter is accurate, specifically the employer representatives’ information and the number of safety-sensitive employees for each job category.
b. Outcome of Areas Reviewed and Discovered Issues. Inspectors must conduct inspections that support Aviation Safety’s core values and critical safety work. Each inspector must conduct a quality review of the employer’s program to verify compliance with the regulations. Inspectors must collect the evidence to report the results of the inspection, whether there are findings of noncompliance or not. Inspectors must follow the expectations described in this Order when reporting inspection results:
(1) Inspectors must document all findings of noncompliance when it is established that an employer or its service agent deviated from the regulations. It is not sufficient to document only a few findings of noncompliance to show a pattern or leave out noncompliance that exceed the time limit defined in Order 2150.3, as amended.8 For example, if one regulatory item was out of compliance on multiple occasions, then each occasion must be documented. When documenting the findings of noncompliance, inspectors must include a full description of what happened, who was involved, where and when it occurred, the root cause of the event (e.g., why it occurred), and whether any of the noncompliance are stale.
(2) Inspectors must document concerns when there are issues discovered that are not deviations from the regulation, but that may lead to noncompliance if the employer or its service agent fails to resolve the issue. For example, if a collector has never dealt with a shy bladder situation, he/she may be asked to explain the shy bladder procedures as described in 49 CFR § 40.193. If the collector is unfamiliar with these procedures, this will be noted as an area of concern. It is important that the inspection lead educate the collector as to the proper shy bladder procedures.
(3) Inspectors must document open items when the issue cannot be resolved without clarification from their Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager, or the team cannot agree on a specific finding during the inspection. The inspection lead must contact his/her Team Coordinator or Center Manager prior to the inspection outbriefing, if possible, to explain the details and/or provide documentation. If contact is not possible, the matter is left open and the inspection lead continues to coordinate with his/her Team Coordinator or Center Manager. Once the determination is made about how to handle the issue, either as a finding of noncompliance or not, the inspection lead outbriefs it.
8 According to Order 2150.3, as amended, certain statutes and regulations provide time limits after the date of a violation within which FAA may bring legal enforcement action. For matters involving compliance action or administrative action, FAA personnel must ensure that applicable time limits do not adversely affect the FAA’s ability to take legal enforcement action in the event the corrective action is not complete or sufficient. Civil penalty actions associated with alleged violations have a time limit of two or five years from the date of the violation, depending on the size of the civil penalty amount or size of the business. Refer to Order 2150.3, as amended, Chapter 4, paragraph 5 for specific exceptions and other information.
If the inspection is over, the inspector and Team Coordinator must conduct a telephonic out-briefing with the employer to describe whether the matter is closed or considered a finding of noncompliance and requires corrective action. If it is a finding of noncompliance, the inspector must include the issue as part of the Outbriefing Report (OBR) and Report of Inspection (ROI).
(4) Inspectors must document and gather sufficient documentation or evidence to support compliance when an inspection does not result in a finding of noncompliance. After reviewing an employer’s drug and alcohol testing records during the focus or full inspection and determining the employer is compliant, inspectors must ensure the inspection file contains the following records:
(a) Pre-employment records that include:
(1) A new hire list, including the dates of hire, for the last 24 months or since the last
inspection; and
(2) Copies of verified MRO reports and performance records (e.g., copies of
aircraft/engine/propeller logbook, invoices/work orders/repair orders and/or flight/pilot logbook) for 1% of the new hire employees or covered employees listed.
(3) If no new hires for the last 24 months or since the last inspection, you must
gather performance records (e.g., copies of aircraft/engine/propeller logbook, invoices/work orders/repair orders and/or flight/pilot logbook) for two safetysensitive employees in the current random testing pool.
(b) Random testing records that include the eligibility and selection lists for the last four
quarters.
(c) Medical Review Officer’s qualification and training documentation.
(d) If the last MIS report indicates a verified positive drug test result and/or alcohol result
with a breath alcohol concentration of 0.04 or greater, you must include a copy of one verified positive drug test result and/or confirmed alcohol test result.
(e) If the MIS report indicates testing for follow-up drug and/or alcohol test, reasonable
cause and/or suspicion test, or post-accident drug and/or alcohol test, you must include a copy of one verified drug test result and/or confirmed alcohol test result for each type of test conducted.
12. Inspection Conclusion. The inspection team must ensure that all applicable items on the inspection guide were covered and appropriate documentation was gathered, in accordance with this chapter. Inspectors must gather sufficient documentation to either demonstrate compliance or support any findings of noncompliance.
The inspection lead must review the inspection results (including any findings of noncompliance, areas of concern, or open items) with their team member, if applicable, to obtain his/her agreement. If there is disagreement between the team on a particular item(s), the inspection lead must inform the employer at the outbriefing that the item(s) will be left open and addressed later. The inspection lead
may document the inspection results in CETS prior to the outbriefing, if time permits.
a. Outbriefing. The inspection lead must end the on-site or virtual inspection by conducting an outbriefing with the employer. The inbriefing/outbriefing guide is available in Figure 2-3 (for on-site inspections) and Figure 2-4 (for virtual inspections). All inspectors who participated in the inspection must attend.
(1) The inspection lead circulates the meeting attendance sheet for those individuals who were not part of the inbriefing or documents the names of anyone participating using the Meeting Attendance List in Figure 2-5.
(2) If the inspection resulted in no findings of noncompliance or areas of concern, the inspection lead must advise the employer that no further documentation will be provided by the FAA Drug Abatement Division.
(3) When an inspection results in findings of noncompliance and/or areas of concern, the inspection lead must clearly and briefly identify the issues. Inspectors should not linger on the issues, but must explain them and obtain the employer’s agreement to initiate immediate corrective action. If there are issues related to serious risk, e.g., failing to conduct return-to-duty or follow-up testing, the inspector must insist that the employer take immediate action and other corrective actions to ensure the same issues do not happen in the future. The inspector must advise the employer that a report of inspection (ROI) letter will be sent by email to the employer’s President/CEO and DER documenting the results of the inspection and requesting written corrective action for each finding of noncompliance. The inspector must advise the employer that they must confirm receipt of the ROI by replying to the email or calling the inspector. The inspection lead must verify the email address for the President/CEO and the DER/ADPM.
(4) If there are items that need to be resolved with the employer that were not clarified during the actual inspection, the inspection lead must do this during the outbriefing. Similarly, the inspection lead must use this opportunity to clarify any misunderstandings about the regulations and help to educate the employer. While we are responsible for training and educating the employer representative, that does not remove the finding of noncompliance. Remember not to linger on the topic, but be clear and concise.
(5) Inspectors must not display any disagreement on the issues or discuss how the findings of noncompliance will be addressed (e.g., with compliance or enforcement action) in front of the employer.
(6) The inspection team must not tell the employer representative how to respond to the findings of noncompliance. An inspector may describe best practices for corrective action, for example, recommend the employer use a checklist for hiring or training. The inspection lead may refer the employer to our web site or the DOT’s web site for sample checklists, policies, service agent audit tools, etc. It is up to the employer to decide on how to take corrective action; however, it is important to make it clear that correction action is required to address all findings of noncompliance.
b. Post-outbriefing. At the conclusion of the outbriefing, inspectors must gather all records and materials and leave the employer premises or disconnect from the virtual inspection call or video meeting. Do not leave anything behind, including papers, folders, extraneous copies of documents. If the employer created reports or documents to support your inspection, take them with you to include
Chapter 2. Inspection › 13. Post-Inspection Activities.
in the inspection file.
Inspectors are prohibited from socializing with employer representatives or service agents, as this might give the appearance of a conflict of interest.
13. Post-Inspection Activities.
a. Post-inspection team meeting for an inspection team. Inspectors must conduct a postinspection meeting to discuss lessons learned and to ensure that all appropriate documentation has been collected and authenticated as appropriate. If the outbriefing report has already been entered into CETS, the inspection lead must have each inspector approve the outbriefing report in CETS.
b. CETS. No later than twenty-four (24) calendar days after the inspection, or within the deadline assigned by the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager, the inspectors must ensure that the information is entered into CETS thoroughly and accurately, following the guidance described in the System Rules for CETS Data Entry. Specifically, inspectors must:
(1) Enter a brief description of the type of operation in the employer’s profile tab (e.g., the
employer is a part 135 and conducts charter flights along the west coast; the employer is a staffing employer that provides pilots to charter employers operating under part 135). Include information regarding any affiliated employers, e.g., the part 135 is part of an XYZ corporation with another part 135 operating under certificate number XXX;
(2) Update the employer’s information (i.e., contacts, email address, locations, etc.) in the
contact tab;
(3) Enter the activity narrative information in the inspection profile;
(4) Document the employer’s safety-sensitive and operation data in the inspection profile
(i.e., total number of employees, number of aircraft, and number of safety-sensitive employees by function);
(5) Add the random drug and alcohol protocol information to the inspection programs tab;
(6) Update the date and time of the inspection, name of each inspector who participated in
the inspection on the inspection resources tab;
(7) Document all inspection findings of noncompliance, areas of concern, and undecided or
open items in the inspection regulations tab. Inspectors must include the following details for each inspection finding:
(a) Description of each finding of noncompliance item (what happened, who was
involved, where it happened, and when it happened);
(b) Analysis of the root cause of each finding of noncompliance (what did you
determine was the cause or why it happened); and
(c) Identify the evidence collected to support the finding of noncompliance.
(8) Document inspection findings of special issues that triggered the inspection, if applicable,
under the inspection regulations tab – special issues report;
(9) Complete the records reviewed guide and/or close-out summary in the inspection
regulations tab;
(10) Enter any communications information regarding the inspection, incoming and outgoing,
in the inspection correspondence tab;
(11) Document all interviews, including the name of the witness and a synopsis of their
statement, in the inspection interview tab;
(12) If there are additional details you think are important for anyone reviewing the inspection
or about the employer, enter the information in the inspection additional notes tab; and
(13) When an inspection results in no findings of noncompliance, it should be noted in the
closeout summary under the inspection regulations tab in CETS.
c. Inspection reporting and correspondence. The inspector prepares the inspection reports and correspondence using CETS (see Inspection Correspondence Flowchart in Figure 2-12).
(1) Outbriefing Report (OBR). Once the inspection results are entered in CETS, the inspector must generate the OBR. If necessary, inspectors must obtain concurrence from their inspection team on the final OBR. If the inspection results in no findings, the inspector must notify his/her Team Coordinator to review the OBR closeout in CETS. The inspector must provide their completed inspection file in accordance with Appendix F of this Order within twenty-four (24) calendar days of the inspection, or within the deadline assigned by the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager.
If an inspection finding indicates a potential for legal enforcement action, it is important for the Team Coordinator to notify his/her Center Manager as soon as possible. The Center Manager is required to alert the POI/PMI or AAM-810 via email that a legal enforcement action is pending to ensure any attempt to surrender the certificate or registration to avoid legal enforcement action is averted in accordance with Order 2150.3, as amended, Chapter 7, paragraph 7.a. If the risk analysis later determines legal enforcement action is no longer applicable, the Center Manager must update the POI/PMI or AAM-810 via email.
(2) Report of Inspection (ROI) Letter. For inspections that result in findings of noncompliance, inspectors must generate the ROI in CETS using the template on AAM-800’s SharePoint. The ROI must include all findings of noncompliance, and it must be addressed to the employer’s President/CEO, with a copy sent to the DER/ADPM. Once the ROI is prepared, inspectors, Team Coordinators and/or Managers must follow the procedures below:
(a) Inspectors must provide the OBR, all records collected from the inspection, and the
draft ROI letter to his/her Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager within twentyfour (24) calendar days of the inspection, or within the deadline assigned by the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager;
(b) Inspectors must enter the date they ‘approved’ their OBR/ROI in CETS prior to
notifying the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager in writing (via email) the OBR/ROI is ready for review and the inspection records are available on the shared network;
(c) The Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager must approve the OBR and ROI letter
or return them to the inspector for changes. If returned for changes, the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager must document the review in the milestones in the inspection correspondence tab in CETS;
(d) After the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager approves the OBR/ROI, the
inspector must document and enter the date the ROI is sent to the employer in CETS, in accordance with the Team Coordinator/Center Manager standards;
(e) Inspectors must send the ROI letter to the employer’s President/CEO and DER via
electronic mail, copying the Team Coordinator and Center Manager; and
(f) Inspectors must request a delivery receipt of the letter and confirm receipt if they are
not notified by the employer. If the inspector is unable to confirm receipt by the employer, they must contact their Team Coordinator or Center Manager for further instructions.
d. Risk Analysis. To conduct a risk analysis, inspectors must select the checklist reference number and answer the data points for each finding of noncompliance under the Automated Risk Calculation (ARC) tab in the inspection profile in CETS. The ARC system uses an employer’s compliance history, the inspection finding, evidence of noncompliance gathered during the inspection, the employer’s response to immediate corrective action, system-wide data, and other relevant information. These factors calculate the risk level using the safety risk management (SRM) principles identified in Order 8040.4, as amended. For matters that are not determined to be an unacceptable risk to safety, the ARC incorporates guidelines, principles, and factors identified in the SCMP, Order 2150.3, as amended, and FAA Compliance Program Order 8000.373, as amended. The following are examples of factors used in the risk analysis:
(1) Corrective action and likelihood of the consequences reoccurring;
(2) Type of behavior that resulted in noncompliance (e.g., intentional or reckless);
(3) Compliance history (is it a repeat finding of noncompliance); and
(4) Potential severity of the consequence of noncompliance.
Upon receiving the response to the ROI, inspectors must evaluate the corrective actions to determine if they address the root cause, bring the employer into compliance, and ensures the noncompliance does not reoccur. If the employer does not respond to the ROI letter within 10 calendar days, the inspector must contact the employer and encourage a response to provide corrective action. If the employer continues not to respond or provide corrective action, the circumstances might indicate an uncooperative attitude toward compliance or an unwillingness/inability to take appropriate corrective action. A failure to respond to the ROI letter is one factor that must be taken into account as part of the risk analysis.
Taking these and other factors relevant to risk analysis into consideration, the system provides the recommended action (compliance, administrative, or legal enforcement action) for each finding of noncompliance. If the inspection evidence will not support compliance, administrative, or legal enforcement action, the inspection lead must recommend that no action be taken.
Inspectors must discuss the recommended action with his/her Team Coordinator or Center Manager. If an inspector proposes deviating from the action recommended by the final ARC analysis due to mitigating factors, aggravating factors, better risk controls (e.g., the employer did not have authority to operate), or other information, he/she must discuss the proposed deviation with his/her Team Coordinator or Center Manager. Inspectors must provide their justification and evidence to support a deviation, especially when they deviate from legal enforcement action to compliance action. The justification and evidence must support an acceptable (low) or controllable (medium) risk of the violation at the time it occurred, which makes it no longer an unacceptable (high) risk to aviation safety. A Center Manager may approve or disapprove a deviation; however, the inspector may elevate the request to the AAM-800 Director if he/she does not agree with the Center Manager’s decision. The AAM-800 Director will make the final decision to accept or deny the deviation. Through all steps, each person who reviews the file (i.e., Inspection Lead, Team Coordinator or Center Manager) must sign and date the final ARC analysis.
e. Types of Recommended Action. According to Order 2150.3, as amended, a finding of noncompliance must be addressed using one or more of the following types of actions.
(1) Compliance Action. Compliance action is appropriate when the inspector determines that future compliance can reasonably be ensured through compliance action alone, the employer displays a willingness and ability to comply, and the ARC analysis confirms that the noncompliance does not represent a high safety risk. Compliance action is not appropriate if the conduct that caused the noncompliance disclosed a lack of, or reasonable basis to question, the employer’s qualifications. Compliance action is not appropriate if the criteria for enforcement action in Order 2150.3, as amended, Chapter 5, are met, or may not always be appropriate when the employer’s record shows past or repeated noncompliance, especially when such noncompliance is similar or related to the current noncompliance. Compliance action is not appropriate if the employer has failed to respond to the ROI letter and/or did not return to full compliance and provide acceptable corrective action.
Inspectors must determine whether compliance action may be appropriate by reviewing the facts and circumstances of the noncompliance, evaluating the corrective action to determine if it is sufficient, and completing the final ARC analysis. When the final ARC analysis supports compliance action for one or more findings of noncompliance, the inspector must determine whether the employer’s corrective actions during the inspection or provided in response to the ROI letter are acceptable to resolve the issue and ensure the noncompliance does not reoccur. When reviewing the employer’s corrective actions, inspectors must conduct a methodical, in-depth root cause analysis focused on the cause of the noncompliance. This analysis must include what went wrong and why, as well as the identification of any contributing factors. Once the inspection lead understands the problem and the system/environment in which the noncompliance occurred, he/she must collect and analyze the data and look at causes and effects, focusing on whether proposed solutions effectively eliminate the problem and mitigate future risk. Inspectors must document a detailed description of the regulated person’s corrective actions to come into full compliance and avoid recurrence. This documentation must include any action taken, whether the corrective actions have been fully implemented, and whether such actions have returned the person to full compliance. Compliance
actions closed out using an Action Letter (AL) are described below. Compliance actions are not assigned an Enforcement Investigative Report (EIR) file number or entered into the Enforcement Information System (EIS); however, they are maintained in CETS.
If the response to the ROI and evidence indicates there is no longer a finding of noncompliance or administrative or legal enforcement action is required for one or more issues, inspectors must note this in the AL. For actions that are no longer a finding of noncompliance, it is noted in the AL and closed.
(2) Administrative Enforcement Action. Administrative enforcement action is appropriate when the criteria for legal enforcement action in Order 2150.3, as amended, Chapter 5, are not met, and an inspector reasonably and in good faith determines that compliance action will not remediate the noncompliance and ensure future compliance. Inspectors make this determination by reviewing the facts and circumstances of the noncompliance and completing the final ARC analysis. When the administrative action criteria and/or ARC analysis support administrative action as the appropriate action for an apparent violation, inspectors must consult with the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager before preparing the administrative action report and letter of correction or warning notice. When administrative action is decided, CETS will assign an EIR File Number and the action is entered into EIS. The EIR File Number should be referenced in the AL if compliance actions are associated with the same inspection.
(3) Legal Enforcement Action. Legal enforcement action for an employer violation is appropriate when the criteria in Order 2150.3, as amended, Chapter 5, paragraph 5.a. are met. The criteria that would apply to legal action for an employer includes the following:
(a) Intentional Conduct: A deliberate act (or failure to act) while knowing that such
conduct is contrary to a regulation or statute, or is otherwise prohibited;
(b) Reckless Conduct: An act (or failure to act) demonstrating a gross disregard for or
deliberate indifference to safety or a safety standard;
(c) Failure to Complete Corrective Action: Failure to complete corrective action on
terms satisfactory to the FAA; and
(d) Conduct Creating or Threatening to Create an Unacceptable Risk to Safety: Conduct
that creates or threatens to create a high level in the likelihood and/or severity of significant risk to safety, when the director of the program office determines that alternative means to address the noncompliance and to effectuate immediate and future compliance would not be sufficient.
The AAM-800 Director determines specific types of violations that represent an unacceptable risk to safety based on analysis of system-wide enforcement data. Inspectors must make a legal enforcement action determination by reviewing the facts and circumstances of the noncompliance and completing the final ARC analysis. When the legal action criteria and/or ARC analysis support legal enforcement action for an apparent violation, inspectors must consult with his/her Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager before preparing an EIR. When legal action is decided, CETS will assign an EIR File Number and the action is entered into EIS. According to Order 2150.3, as amended, the Office of Chief Counsel makes the final determination whether to proceed with legal enforcement
action. The EIR File Number should be referenced in the AL if compliance actions are associated with the same inspection.
f. Inspection Outcome Procedures. Once an inspector determines the inspection result(s) after considering the employer’s response to the ROI letter, completing the ARC analysis, and assessment of the corrective action, the inspector must generate the appropriate outcome in CETS. For compliance actions, inspectors must generate an AL. Order 2150.3, as amended, remains the source for reporting and processing of administrative and legal enforcement actions which require an EIR. Legal enforcement action EIRs are referred to FAA legal counsel for further action. Refer to the templates for all inspection outcome options in CETS or AAM-800’s SharePoint for reference.
The procedures below will explain how and when to generate the outcome, and the coordination steps to follow:
(1) Action Letter (AL). The AL is used to notify the employer of how the findings of noncompliance were resolved, and which findings of noncompliance will be handled with administrative or legal enforcement action, or closed with no further action (if applicable). Once the AL is prepared, inspectors, Team Coordinators, and/or Managers must follow the procedures below:
(a) Inspectors must provide the draft AL to his/her Team Coordinator and/or Center
Manager and update the milestone in the inspection correspondence tab in CETS;
(b) Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager must approve the AL or return it to the
inspector for changes. If returned for changes, the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager must document the review in the milestone in the inspection correspondence tab in CETS;
(c) Inspectors must begin the milestone process again for the review in the inspection
correspondence tab in CETS;
(d) After the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager approves the AL, the inspector
must document and enter the date the AL is sent to the employer in CETS, in accordance with the Team Coordinator/Center Manager standards;
(e) Inspectors must send the approved AL to the employer within 120 calendar days
from the date of the inspection or within the deadline assigned by the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager;
(f) Inspectors must send the AL to the employer’s President and DER via electronic
mail, copying the Team Coordinator and Center Manager; and
(g) Inspectors must request a delivery receipt of the letter and confirm receipt if they
are not notified by the employer. If the inspector is unable to confirm receipt by the employer, he/she must contact his/her Team Coordinator or Center Manager for further instructions.
(2) Administrative Action. To address noncompliance issues with administrative action for an inspection, inspectors may send a letter of correction (LOC) or warning notice (WN). While an LOC serves the same purpose as a WN, it also memorializes a specific agreement with the employer
as to the particular corrective action taken or to be taken within a specified time to effectuate compliance. In addition to the letter, inspectors must complete an EIR that includes Section B (Summary of Case) and Section C (Items of Proof) using the template contained in CETS or AAM 800’s SharePoint. Once the LOC/WN is prepared, inspectors, Team Coordinators, and/or Managers must follow the procedures below:
(a) Inspectors must submit the draft LOC/WN and Section B to his/her Team
Coordinator and/or Center Manager within 75 calendar days from the date of the inspection or within the deadline assigned by the Team Coordinator or Center Manager, and update the milestone in the inspection correspondence tab in CETS;
(b) The Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager must approve the LOC/WN and/or
EIR or return it to the inspector for changes. If returned for changes, the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager must document the review in the milestone in the inspection correspondence tab in CETS;
(c) The milestone process starts again for the review in the inspection correspondence
tab in CETS;
(d) After the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager approves the LOC/WN and
EIR, the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager signs and submits the 2150-5 to EIS;
(e) The inspector must enter the date the LOC/WN is sent to the employer in CETS;
(f) Inspectors must send the approved LOC/WN to the employer within 120 calendar
days from the date of inspection or within the deadline assigned by the Team Coordinator or Center Manager;
(g) Inspectors must send the LOC/WN to the employer’s President and DER via
electronic mail, copying the Team Coordinator and Center Manager;
(h) Inspectors must request a delivery receipt of the letter and confirm receipt if they
are not notified by the employer. If the inspector is unable to confirm receipt by the employer, they must contact their Team Coordinator or Center Manager for further instructions; and
(i) Inspectors prepare the final assembled inspection files, including Section B, for
archiving.
(3) Legal Enforcement Action. For violations that meet the legal enforcement action criteria in Order 2150.3, as amended, Chapter 5, inspectors must generate a legal EIR using the template in CETS or AAM-800’s SharePoint. All legal enforcement action EIR files must follow the requirements of “Protecting Sensitive Unclassified Information,” Order 1600.75, involving “For Official Use Only” (FOUO) designations (see Figure 2-13). The FOUO cover sheet template is available on AAM-800’s SharePoint and must be included in the legal enforcement action EIR before the Section A tab and after the last item of proof. The inspection lead must ensure the EIR is factual, well-reasoned, and contains sufficient proof to substantiate the action. Once the EIR is
prepared, inspectors, Team Coordinators, and/or Managers must follow the procedures below:
(a) Inspectors must provide the legal enforcement action electronic EIR (eEIR) to
his/her Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager within 75 calendar days from the date of inspection or within the deadline assigned by the Team Coordinator or Center Manager;
(b) Inspectors must update the milestone in the inspection correspondence tab in CETS;
(c) The Team Coordinator and Center Manager must approve the legal enforcement
action eEIR or return it to the inspector for changes;
(d) If returned for changes, the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager documents
the review under the Milestones Section in CETS and the process begins again;
(e) After the Team Coordinator and/or Center Manager approve the eEIR, the Team
Coordinator and/or Center Manager must enter the final sign-off into CETS;
(f) The Team Coordinator or Center Manager sends the 2150-5 form to EIS through
CETS and includes a copy of the signed 2150-5 form in the eEIR;
(g) The Center Manager or Team Coordinator prepares the transmittal memorandum
describing the type of legal enforcement action recommended for each eEIR;
(h) Once the eEIR is approved, the Team Coordinator or Center Manager electronically
transfers the transmittal memorandum and eEIR to the Office of the Chief Counsel and enters into CETS the date it was sent to the Office of Chief Counsel; and
(i) The investigating office must retain a complete copy of the electronic inspection
file, including a copy of the eEIR transmitted to the Office of the Chief Counsel for legal enforcement actions, and make it available to enforcement counsel upon request.
The Office of the Chief Counsel may return the case for further investigation, closure, or downgrade to an appropriate action (see Order 2150.3, as amended). If the case is returned and needs further action, the Branch Manager, Center Manager, or Team Coordinator will provide further instructions.
g. Inspection Follow-Up Documentation. Inspectors must ensure that all follow-up activities, information, documentation of additional corrective action by the employer, and incoming and outgoing communication are documented in CETS.
h. Inspection File Documentation. The final step in the inspection process is for the inspection lead to compile the electronic inspection file documentation according to Appendix F of this Order. Before submitting the electronic inspection folder for review to the Team Coordinator or Center Manager, the lead inspector must ensure that all paper (e.g., mail or fax) and electronic records are included in the electronic inspection folder. The lead inspector is responsible for scanning any physical records received into PDF format for inclusion in the electronic inspection file.
Chapter 2. Inspection › Figure 2-1. On-Site Inspection Process Guide
Figure 2-1. On-Site Inspection Process Guide
This document is available electronically on the Drug Abatement Division’s (AAM-800) SharePoint.
Pre-Inspection
Confirm date of inspection and logistical arrangements with employer.
Ensure documentation is received from employer.
Research enforcement and program history, i.e., CETS, A449s, LOAs and registrations.
Provide history to team.
Notify Center Manager (CM) if additional resources are needed.
Provide travel and lodging information to team.
Ensure that appropriate management representatives will be available to discuss:
Employer Administrative and Quality Assurance Activities
Drug Testing and Alcohol Information, Training, and Referral
Recordkeeping and Reporting Specimen Collection Breath Alcohol Testing Procedures Medical Review Officer Activities Substance Abuse Professional Activities
Ensure relevant documents will be available. Complete inspection plan and assign areas of responsibility to team members. Submit completed work plan to CM and Team Coordinator (TC).
Inspection
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 272 passages shown