Order 5190.6A Airport Compliance Requirements
This document is cancelled. Cancelled by 5190.6B. Check the official source before relying on it.
Text read by OCR from a scanned file (10 of 100 pages). Check the original, as some words may be misread.
ORDER ls19o.aAI
AIRPORT COMPLIANCE
REQUIREMENTS
OCTOBER 2, 1989
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION
Distribution: A-W(PP/~)-37 A-X(AS)-4; A-FAS-l(MAX) Initiated By: AAS-300
RECORD OF CHANGE~ '---s-1_9_o_. 6-A------'
CHANGE 8lPPI.EMENTS CHANGE SUPPlEMENTS TO OPTIONAL TO OP'OONAI.. BASIC BASIC
FAA Form 1320-5 (6-80) Use PreviousEdition
Foreword
10/2/89 Order 5190.6A
FOREWORD
1. PURPOSE. This Order provides the policies and procedures to be followed in carrying out the Federal Aviation Administration's (FAA) functions related to airport compliance. It is of interest to other Government agencies, both Federal and state, who are concerned with actions associated with Federal real and personal property.
2. DISTRIBUTION. This Order is distributed to the branch level of the Office of Airport Safety and Standards, the Office of Airport Planning and Programming, to the section level of all regional Airports division, and all Airport District Offices/Field Offices.
3. CANCELLATION. Order 5190.6, Airports Compliance Requirements, dated August 24, 1973, is canceled, except for the enforcement provision (see Chapter 6, Section 2 of this Order).
Leonard E. Mudd Director, Office of Airport Safety & Standards
Table of Contents
10/2/89 Order 5190.6A
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1. SCOPE AND AUTHORITY
1-1. General … l 1-2. Scope … 1 1-3. Background of Airport Obligations … 1 1-4. Sources of Obligations … 1 1-5. Authority … 1
CHAPTER 2. TYPES OF AGREEMENTS
Section 1. Grant Agreements
2-1. Sponsor's ·obligations … 3 2-2. Duration of Grant Agreements … 3 2-3. Physical Life of Facilities … 3 2-4.-2-5. RESERVED … 3
Section 2. Surplus Property Instruments
2--6. Background … 3 2-7. Types of Instruments of Disposal … 4 2-8. Duration of Obligations … 4 2-9.-2-10. RESERVED … 5
Section 3. Conveyance of NonSurplus Federal Land
2-11. Background … 5 2-12. Covenants … 5 2-13. Reverter Provision … • … •.•..• … •••••..•...••••• … 5 2-14. Duration of Covenants and Obligations … 6 2-15.-2-17. RESERVED … 6
Section 4. AP-4 Agreements
2-18. Background … 6 2-19. Continuing Obligation … 6
CHAPTER 3. EXCLUSIVE RIGHTS
Section 1. Background
3-1. General … 7 3-2. Legislative History … 7 3-3. Development of Agency Policy … 7 3-4.-3-7. RESERVED … 8
Section 2. Polley
3-8. Basis of Policy … 8 3-9. Interpretation … 8
Ill
Order 5190.6A 10/2/89
3-10. Implementation of Policy … 11 3-11. ImproveJD.ents by Other Federal Agencies … • ...• .• … • … 11 3-12. Administration of Policy … 12 3-13.-3-16. RESERVED … 12
Section 3. Qualifications and Standards
3-17. Use of Minimum Standards … 12
CHAPTER 4. OBLIGATIONS OF AIRPORT OWNERS
Section 1. General
4-1. Purpose … •..• … ···········-········ … 13 4-2. Assigrunent of Obligations … 13 4-3.-4-4. RESERVED … 14
Section 2. Maintenance and Operation
4-S. Scope of Maintenance Obligation … 14 4-6. Physical Maintenance … 14 4-7. Req_uirenlent to Operate the Airport … ~ … 15 4-8. Restrictions on Aeronautical Use of Airport … 16
Section 3. Approach Protection and Compatible Land Use
4-9. Protection of APIJr08.ches … •..• … • … •.•• … 19 4-10. Compatible Use Of Adjacent I...and … 20 4-11.-4-12. RESERVED … 20
Section 4. Availability on Fair and Reasonable Terms
4-13. General … 20 4-14. Terms Applied to Airport Users … 20 4-15. Availability of Leased Space … 22 4-16. Civil Rights … 23
Section 5. Use of Airport Property
4-17. Adherence to Airport I..ayout Plall and Airport Property Map … 23 4-18. Use of Surplus "Property … 28 4-19. Use of Lands Transferred from the United States … 29 4-20. Income Accountability … 30 4-21. Management of Grant Acquired Personal ~rty ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••.•••.•••....•.•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• 32
Section 6. Use by the Government
4-22. Joint Use by Federal Government Aircraft … 33 4-23. Space for Air TraffiC Control Activities, Communications, Weather and Navaids … 33 4-24. Government Use During a National Emergency or War … 34
CHAPTER 5. THE AIRPORT COMPLIANCE PROGRAM
5-1. Basis aild Objectives … 35 5-2. Progran Elements … 35 5-3. Priorities and Emphasis … 36 S-4. Responsibilities … 37 5-S. Types of Compliance Status … 37
lv
10/2/89 Order 5190.6A
5-6. Analyzing Compliailce Status … 37 5-7. Compliance Determination … 37 5-8. Record of C010pliailce Status •••. ••• •••.•••••••••• ••••••••••••••••••• .•••••.••.•.•••••••••• •••••••••••••••••• … •••••••••• ••••••••••••••••• 38
CHAPTER 6. ANALYSIS AND ENFORCEMENT
Section 1. Analysis of Leases and Use Agreements 6-1. General … 41 6-2. Basic Air'J>ort Relationships … 41 6-3. Review of I..eases and Use Agreements … 41 6-4. Agreements Covering Services to the Public … 42 6-5. Use Agreemen.ts Involving an Entire Airport … 43 6-6. Agreements Granting Access to Landing Area from Adjacent Property (Through-the-Fence Operator). 44 6-7. Air Carrier Agreements and Leases .. •..•..•••••.•••••••• … ••.•••••...•..•.••••••.••.•••.•••••• … 44 6-8.-6-30. RESERVED … 45
Section 2. Enforcement RESERVED … 45
CHAPTER 7. RELEASE, MODIFICATION, REFORMATION OR AMENDMENT OF
AIRPORT AGREEMENTS
Section 1. General Guidance 7-1. Authority to Release, Modify, Reform, or Amend … 47 7-2. General.Principles … 47 7-3.-7-5. RESERVED … 47
Section 2. Surplus Property Agreements
7-6. General … 4 7 7-7. Release 11om Specific Conditions … 48 7-8. Releases for Sale or Disposal … 48 7-9. Application of Proceeds … 50 7-10. Releases Involving Personal Property, Structures or Facilities … 50 7-11.-7-15. RESER.VED … 51
Section 3. Grant Agreements
7-16. General … 51 7-17. Release from SpecuiC Conditions or Assurances … 51 7-18. Total Release to Permit Sale and Disposal … 52 7-19. Sale or Other Disposal of Airport Land Acquired with FAAP/ADAP Funds … 52 7-20. Release of Entire Airport … 53 7-21.-7-25. RESER.VED … 53
Section 4. Release of Section 16, 23,and 516
7-26. General … 54. 7-27. J>rocedures ••• • •• •• •••• ••• • ••••••••• ••••• •• •• ••• •• ••• •• •• ••••• ••••• •• • •••• ••• ••••••••• ••• •• ••••••• ••• •••• •• ••• ••• •• •• ••• •• ••• •••• ••••• •••••••• •• •• ••••• •• ••••••••• 54 7-28.-7-35. RESERVED … - … 54
Section 5. Procedures
7-36. Documen.tation … • … - … 54 7-37. FAA Action on Owner Requests·········································································-····································· 55
y
Order 5190.6A 1012/89
CHAPTER 8. REVERSION OF AIRPORT PROPERTY - REVESTMENT OF TITLE IN
THE UNITED STATES
Section 1. General Guidance
8-1. General … ············································· 59 8-2. Right to Revert … 59 8-3. Authority to Exercise Reverter … ·-··········································································· 59 8-4. Instruments of Conveyance Involved … 59 8-S. Consttuctive Severance … 59 8-6. Forfeiture by Voluntary Reconveyance … 59 8-7. Transfer of Title by Grantee … 59 8-8. Piecemeal Reversions … 6() 8-9. Effect of Outstanding I..eases of Airj;Jort Prl:Jj;)erty … ••••• •••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• 6() 8-10. I..egai Pf()ceedings to Effect Reversion················-········ … 6() 8-11. Contact witb. tile ReversiOiler Fe<leral Agency … 6() 8-12. Contact with the General Services Achn.inistratio (GSA) … 60 8-13. FAA as ReversiOiler Federal Agency … 6() 8-14. Repossession … 60 8-15.-8-20. RESER.VED … ·-················································································ 60
Section 2. General Procedures
8-21. I>eterminalion of Default … 60 8-22. Notice of Intent to Revert Property … 6() 8-23. Voluntary Reconveyance to Correct a I>efault ••.••••••.•••••••••.•.•••...••••...••• … • … • … •..• … • … • 61 8-24. Voluntary Reconveyance I>ocumentation … 61 8-25. Notice of Reverter of Property and Revestment of Tide in tbe United States … 61 8-26. R.ecord.ing Notice of Reverter of Property and Revesunent of Title in the United States … 61 8-27. Certificate of lnsJ>ection and Possession … 62 8-28. Posting or Marking of Prl:Jj;)erty … 62
FIGURES
Figure 1. Summary Status of Airj;Jort Compliance … 40
APPENDICES
Appendix 1. Instrument of Reconveyance (1 page) Appendix 2. Certificate of Inspection and Possession ( 1 page) Appendix 3. Notice of Reversion of Title ( 4 pages) Appendix 4. Form of Release Deed (3 pages) Appendix 5. Defmitions (3 pages) Appendix 6. Formal Compliance Inspection (5 pages) Appendix 7. Federal Land Inventory (2 pages) Figure A-1. Compliance Worksheet (FAA Form 5190-7) Appendix 8. Flying Club (1 page)
vi
Chapter 1. Scope and Authority
10/2189 Order 5190.6A
CHAPTER 1. SCOPE AND AUTHORITY
1-1. GENERAL. The airport compliance function is a contractually-based program. It does not attempt to control and direct the operation of airports. Rather it is a program to administer valuable rights obtained for the people of the United States at a substantial cost in direct grants of funds and in donations of Federal property.
Such grants and donations are made in exchange for binding commitments designed to assure that the public interest would be served. The FAA bears the important responsibility of seeing that these commitments are met. What these commiunents are~ how they apply to airports, and what FAA personnel are required to do about them are discussed in the following chapters.
1-2. SCOPE. A. description of the several types of basic obligating documents is contained in Chapter 2. The background and guidance for implementing the statutory prohibition against exclusive rights at airports are covered by Chapter 3. An analysis of the various compliance obligations is contained in Chapter 4 together with guidance as to how they will be interpreted and applied. Chapter 5 outlines the procedures for car· rying out an effective compliance program. Chapter 6 covers review of leases and enforcement procedures. Chapter 7 provides guidance for amending or releasing airport obligations, and Chapter 8 covers the reverting of airport lands to the Federal Government.
1-3. BACKGROUND OF AIRPORT OBLIGA· TIONS. The Federal Aviation Act of 1958 and the Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938 which preceded it charges the Administrator with broad responsibilities for the regulation of air commerce in the interests of safety and national defense and for the promotiont encouragement, and development of civil aeronautics. Under these broad powers the FAA seeks to achieve safety and efficiency of the total airspace system through direct regulation of airman, aircraft, and the airspace. The Federal interest in promoting civil aviation has been augmented by various legislative actions which authorize programs for granting property, funds, and other assistance to local communities for the development of airport facilities. In each program the recipient assumes certain obligations, either by contract or by restrictive covenants in property deeds~ to maintain and operate its airport facilities safely and effi· ciently and in accordance with specified conditions. Commitments assumed by airport owners in deeds or grant agreements have been generally successful in maintaining a high degree of safety and efficiency in
airport design, constiuction, operation and maintenance. The Airports Compliance Program embraces the policy and guidelines of the FAA for monitoring the performance of airport owners tmder its obligations to the Federal Government
1-4. SOURCES OF OBUGATIONS. The obligations that airport owners assume in consideration of Federal aid flow from various agreements and statutes, including but not limited to:
a. Grant agreements issued under the various Federal grant programs.
b. Surplus airport property instruments of transfer issued under the provisions of Section 13g of the Surplus Property Act of 1944.
c. Deeds of conveyance issued under Section l(i of the Federal Airpott Act of 1946, under Section 23 of the Airport and Airway Development Act of 1970, or under Section 516 of the Airport and Airway Improvement Act of 1982 (AAIA).
d. Section 308(a) of the Federal Aviation Act of 1958 (exclusive rights).
e. Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
1-S. AUTHORITY. Responsibility to ensure com .. pliance with airport owner obligations is vested in, or imposed on. the FAA by law or through FAA conttac- UJal authority.
a. Surplus Property Transfers. Surplus property instruments of transfer were, and are, issued by the War Assets Administration (WAA) and its successor, the General Services Administration (GSA). However, Public Law (PL.) 81-311 specifically imposes upon FAA the sole responsibility for determining and enforcing compliance with the tenns and conditions of all instruments of transfer by which surplus airport property is or has been conveyed to non-Federal public agencies pursuant to the 3urpius Property Act of 1944.
b. Section 16/23/516 Conveyances. Deeds of conveyance issued under Section 16t Section 23, or Section 516 are also issued by agencies other than ta'te FAA. The conveyance document places the administration and enforcement responsibility on the FAA Ad· ministrator.
c. Grant Agreements. FAA is vested with jurisdiction over grant agreements because such agree·
ments are executed for and on behalf of the United States by the FAA and its predecessor, the Civil Aeronautics Administration (CAA).
. d. Exdusive Right. The FAA is also charged wtth the responsibility of bringing about or enforcing compliance with the exclusive right provision of Section 308 of the Federal Aviation Act of 1958 and Section 303 of the Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938. Responsibility for enforcement of this provision is vested in FAA by incorporation of the provisions in both stat-
10/2/89
utes under the tide captioned ''Powers and Duties of the Administrator.''
e. To Release, Modify or Amend. The authority of the FAA to release or modify the terms and conditions of airport agreements is variable among the respective types of agreements. PL. 81-311 prescribes specific circwnstances and conditions under which the FAA may release, modify or amend the tenns and
conditions of smplus property deeds.
Chapter 2. Types of Agreements
1 0/2/89 Order 5190.6A
CHAPTER 2. TYPES OF AGREEMENTS
SECTION 1. GRANT AGREEMENTS.
2-1. SPONSOR'S OBLIGATIONS.
a. Under the various Federal grant programs, the sponsor of a project agrees to assume certain obligations pertaining to the operation, use and maintenance of the airport. These obligations are embodied in the application for Federal assistance as sponsor's assurances and become a part of the grant offer, and bind the grant recipient upon acceptance. The grant assurances in the several development programs (Federal Airpon Aid Program (F AAP)~ Airpon Development Aid Program (ADAP), and Airpon Improvement Program (AlP)) are somewhat varied; therefore, each grant agreement should be reviewed in order to determine the airpon owner~ s obligations.
b. Some agreements contain special covenants or conditions directed to an individual situation. This Order is generally not concerned with any special conditions under which the project is to be carried out; such as withholding of funds due to nonacquisition of clear zone areas, acquisition of additional land within a prescribed time limit, etc. However, in unusual circumstances where an assurance was contained as a special covenant or condition, the interpretation in this Order will apply.
2-2. DURATION OF GRANT AGREEMENTS.
a. Obligations relating to the use, operation, and maintenance of the airpon remain in full force and effect throughout the useful life of the facilities developed under the project but in no event to exceed 20 years. However, there shall be no limit on the duration of the assurance against exclusive rights or the terms,
conditions, and assurances with respect to real property acquired with Federal funds. These provisions remain in effect so long as the airpon is used as an airport. The Chief Counsel has indicated that the useful life of an airpon or airpon facility may be determined to have expired if it is no longer used or needed for the purpose for which it was developed, as well as if the physical life of the facility has expired. Furthermore, the duration of the Civil Rights assurances shall be as specified in the assurance.
b. The preceding subparagraph a. also applies to a private sponsor except that the useful life of project items installed within a facility or the useful life of fa· cilities developed or equipment acquired under an airpan development or noise program implementation project shall be no less than 10 years from the date of acceptance of Federal aid for the project.
2-3. PHYSICAL LIFE OF FACILITIES. The physical, useful life of a facility extends only for the period of time during which it is serviceable and usable with ordinary day-to-day maintenance. Reconstruction, rehabilitation, or major repair of a facility without Federal aid does not extend the duration of its useful life within the meaning of that term as used in grant agreements. When a facility needs reconstruction, rehabilitation or major repair in order that it may continue to serve the purpose for which it was developed, its useful life has expired. Regional Airports offJ.Ces will make this determination. If new grants are issued for reconstruction, rehabilitation, or major repair, a new useful life period begins.
2-4.-2-S. RESERVED'
SECTION 2. SURPLUS PROPERTY INSTRUMENTS
2-4i. BACKGROUND. Surplus property instruments of disposal are issued under Section 13 of the Surplus Property Act of 1944. The Act authorizes conveyance of property surplus to the needs of the Federal Government. The FAA (or its predecessor CAA) recommends to the GSA which property should be transferred for ai.rpon purposes to public agencies. Such deeds are issued by the GSA which has jurisdiction over the disposition of properties that are declared to be surplus to the needs of the Federal Government.
Prior to the establishment of the GSA in 1949, instruments of disposal were issued by the W AA.
a. Statutory Authority. P.L. 80-289, approved July 30, 1947 t amended Section 13 of the Surplus Property Act of 1944. This authorized the Administrator of W AA (now GSA) to convey to any state, political subdivision, municipality or tax-supported institution, surplus real and personal property for airport purposes without monetary consideration to the United States. These conveyances are subject to the terms, conditions, reservations and restrictions prescribed
therein. Real property cannot be transferred for airport use if a determination bas been made by GSA that the highest and best use of the land is industrial. In order for any surplus real or personal property ro be transferred, tbe FAA must detennine that it is essen~ suitable or desirable for the development, improve· ment, operations or maintenance of a public airport. This includes property needed to develop sources of revenue from nonaviation businesses at a public air- }X)It. Refer to Order 5150.2, Federal Surplus Property for Public Airport Purposes, for guidance on transferring Federal surplus property for public airport purposes.
Prior to the enactment of P.L. 80-289 surplus airport properties were conveyed to public agencies under general authority granted W AA by the Surplus Property AcL 1be terms and conditions subject to which sura plus airport properties were conveyed under this authority were administtatively established by W AA and prescribed in its Regulation No. 16, generally referred to as W AA- Reg. 16.
b. Nonairport Property Prior to P .L. 80-289. Prior to the enactment of P.L. 80-289, the WAA took
the position that it had no authority to convey to public agencies any property other than that which had been and was intended to be used solely for operation and maintenance of the airport. This precluded the transfer of some types of buildings, facilities, and other nonairport properties comprising parts of an air base as operated by the Government
c. Revenue-Producing Property. The provision in P.L. 80-289 that includes among the types of airpon property, property needed to develop sources of revenue from nonaviation businesses at a public airport, constitutes specific authorization for the transfer of such properties. This is authorized where it has been determined that they are needed and will be used as sources of revenue to defray the cost of operation, maintenance and development of the airport. Originally the form of instrument used to transfer surplus airport properties under PL. 80-289 made no distinction between obligations imposed where property was conveyed for airport use and those imposed with respect to property conveyed for revenue purposes. The FAA takes the position that each convey&nce of revenueproducing property obligates the transferees to use the revenues derived from nonairpon use of the property for operation, maintenance or development of the airport. H the land has been identified and agreed upon by the FAA as revenue-producing property (even if it was not so identified on the transfer document) then the revenue must be used on the ai:rpon or put into the airport fund.
Z-7. TYPES OF INSTRUMENTS OF DISPOSAL. Three basic fonns of instruments of disposal have been used to convey surplus airport properties: (1) the fonn used under W AA - Reg 16 prior to the amendment of the Surplus Property Act of 1944 by P.L. 80-289; (2) the form issued under PL. 80-289 to convey real or a combination of real and related personal property; and (3) the form issued to convey only personal property. Each individual instrument of disposal must be examined to determine the particular obligations of the grantee or rights of the Government
a. Conditions Peculiar to Various Instruments. Instruments of disposal under PL. 80--289 are all substantially similar. In a few cases the National Emergency Use Provision (NEUP) has been omitted (see paragraph c. below). One or more special conditions or restrictions other than those required by Jaw may have been included in some instruments. The instruments of disposal issued under W AA - Regulation
16, however, are not unifonn. One variation in W AA - Regulation 16 instruments is the provision relating to joint military use of the airport. Some give the Gov-
ernment the right to unlimited use without charge, and in others the Government use may not exceed a specified percentage of the capacity of the airport if such use interferes with other authorized use of the airport.
b. Obligation to Operate and Maintain Airport. Practically all the W AA - Regulation 16 and P .L. 80-289 instruments conveying real and related personal property contain provisions obligating the grantees to operate and maintain the entire airport where the property is located, regardless of the amount of property conveyed by the instrument However, instruments of disposal (SF-123) for only personal property contain provisions obligating the grantee only with respect to the use and maintenance of the specific property conveyed.
c. National Emergency Use Provision (NEUP). Practically all WAA- Regulation 16 and P.L. 80-289 instruments of disposal of real and related personal property also contain the NEUP under which the United States has the right to make exclusive or nonexclusive use of the airport or any portion thereof during a war or national emergency. This provision is similar in all such instruments.
2-8. DURATION OF OBLIGATIONS. The duration of the obligation depends upon the properties conveyed.
a. Real Property. All surplus airport property instruments of disposal~ except those conveying only personal property, provide that the covenants assumed by the grantee regarding tile use, operation and maintenance of the airport and ~e property transferred shall
be deemed to be covenants running with the land. Accordingly, such covenants continue in full force and effect until released under P.L. 81-311 or other applicable law.
b. Related Personal Property. In most cases instruments conveying real property also convey related personal property. Accountability for this property shall be its useful life not to exceed 1 year.
c. Personal Property (Donable). The term of a surplus airport property instrument of disposal (SF-
123) conveying only personal property extends for the
Order 5190 .. 6A
period of time during which it is serviceable and usable with ordinary day-to-day maintenance but no longer than 1 year. Reconstruction. rehabilitation or major repair does not extend its useful life within the meaning of that term as used in surplus property instruments. Smplus personal property that has outlived its useful life should be removed from the inventory. Such property may be disposed of by tradein on new equipmenL If this is done, accountability for the new property is not required.
2-9.-2.10. RESERVED.
SECTION 3. CONVEYANCES OF NONSURPLUS FEDERAL LAND
2-11. BACKGROUND. While Federal land which has been declared surplus is conveyed under the Surplus Property Act, federally-owned or controlled land which is not surplus may be conveyed for airport purposes under authority contained in Section 516 of the
AAIA. Prior to the effective date of this Act, similar authority existed in Section 16 of the Federal Airport Act and Section 23 of the Airport and Airway Development Act of 1970. Unlike surplus property, this land may not be transferred for the specific purpose of revenue production.
2-12. COVENANTS. Instruments of conveyance executed under Section 516~ Section 23, or Section 16 impose upon the grantees certain obligations regarding the use of the lands conveyed and the airport involved. Covenants included in the deeds or other instruments by which interests in lands are conveyed under these sections require~ among other things that
a. The grantee will use the property interest for airport pUI]Xlses, and will develop that interest fcx airport pmposes within 1 year or as set forth in the deed.
b. The airport, together with its appurtenant
areas~ buildings and facilities, whether or not on the 1and being conveyed, will be operated as a public airport on fair and reasonable terms and without discrimination.
c. The grantee will not grant or permit any exclusive right forbidden by Section 308 of the Federal Aviation AcL
d. Any subsequent ttansfer of the property interest conveyed will be subject to the covenants and conditions in the instrument of conveyance.
e. For Section 16 transfers the whole or any part of the property interest conveyed shall revert to the United States in the event the lands in question are not
Par 2~
developed for airport purposes or used in a manner consistent with the tenns of the conveyance.
f. In the event of a breach of any covenant or condition the grantee will, on demand, take such action as may be necessary to evidence ttansfer of title to the premises to the United States.
In some instances, special conditions or obligations may be imposed upon the grantee by the Government agency issuing the conveyance instrument. Therefore, it will be necessary in each case to consult the particu· lar deed by which the lands are conveyed to determine all the conditions and covenants.
2-13. REVERTER PROVISION. Section 16{1.3/ 516 deeds provide for reversion to the United States in the event the lands are not developed or cease to be used for airport purposes.
a. Section 16 Deeds. The Federal Airport Act required that conveyances made under Section 16
" ••• be made on the condition that the property intelest conveyed shall automatically revert to the United States ... '' if the land is not developed as an airport or ceases to be used for airport purposes. This provision was difficult to administer during the early years since no time limits were specified for beginning use or after ceasing use which would make the reverter operable. Beginning in the early 1960's the deeds provided that the property interest aL1t:Omatically reverts if the land is not developed or used for airport purposes within 3 years or if airport use ceases for a period of 6 months. The 3-year development time was changed to 5 years in 1968. At the same time, the covenants were amended to introduce a right of the Administrator, exercisable 1 year after conveyance, to repossess any part not developed for airport use. In requesting the conveyance of land for approach protection for an existing airport the provision that the Jand will revert automati-
Page s
cally unless it is used for airport purposes nonnally was omitted. This exception was made for the reason that immediately upon acquisition the land became a part of the airport and served the approach protection purpose.
b. Section .23/516 Conveyances. Section 23/ 516 does not continue the automatic reversion of property interests contained in Section 16 but places reversion at the option of the Secretary. Section 16 transfers were made under the provisions of Federal Aviation Regulation (FAR) Part 153. The implementing regula-
tions (FAR Part 154) require that the land be developed for airport purposes within 1 year of the conveyance. If the property is not so developed or used in a manner consistent with the terms of the conveyance, the Administrator may, at his discretion, enter and on behalf of the United States take title to all or any part of the property interests conveyed.
c. Determination as to Exercise or Reverter. In detennining whether the reverter provision has become operable in any particular case (because of failure to develop or use the land for airport pmposes or because of cessation of airport use) the deed should be examined to ascertain whether it contains applicable
time limitations. If the deed does not contain such time periods, as a general rule, 1 year can be considered a reasonable time for developing or using the property for airport pmposes and that 6 months of nonairpon use a reasonable time for the exercise of the reverter.
10/2/89
The regional Airports division can justify the allowance of additional time in this connection when the grantee is able to show that definite effort is being made to conform to requirements. Before a region Airports division decides to revert Section 16/23/516 property, they shall contact the Airport Safety and Operations Division (AAS--300) to discuss the proposed reversion. (See Chapter 8 for Reversion Procedures.)
2-14. DURATION OF COVENANTS AND OBLI- GATIONS. Covenants and other provisions of Section 16/23/516 deeds continue in force and effect so long as the land is held by a public agency grantee, its successors or assigns. The FAA has no authority to release land transferred under Sections 16/23/516. If the land conveyed under a Section 16/23/516 deed is no longer used or needed for any airport purpose, FAA has no recourse but to invoke the reverter provision in accordance with the tenns of the deed unless the grantee willingly agrees to its voluntary reconveyance. This does not mean. however, that land transferred for approach protection cannot be used for some secondary nonairport purpose (such as road or highway, fanning, etc.) so long as such use does not interfere with the airport purposes for which it is needed. However, if the property is used for some secondary nonaeronautical purpose, a fair market value (FMV) should be received for such use and the proceeds used only for airport pmposes.
2-15.-2-17. RESERVED
SECTION 4. AP-4 AGREEMENTS
2-18. BACKGROUND.
a. The Development of Landing Areas National Defense (DLAND) and the Development Civil Landing Areas (DCLA) Programs were authorized by various acts during the period 1939 to 1944.
b. Airports developed or improved under these programs were subject to the terms and conditions of an instrument known as an AP-4 Agreement. This was an agreement between the Government and the airport sponsor under which the sponsor provided the land and the Government planned and constructed the airport improvements. Based on consideration of the type of improvements, design standards, construction methods
and normal deterioration, the FAA has administtatively determined that the useful life of all AP-4 improvements has expired.
2-19. CONTINUING OBLIGATION. Although all AP-4 Agreements have expired, such airports continue to be subject to the statutory exclusive rights prohibition (SectiOn 308(a), Federal Aviation Act). Termination of the agreement relieves the airport owner of only the conttactual obligations imposed by it. Since the airport is still one upon which Federal funds have been expended, it is subject to the exclusive rights prohibition for as long as it is operated as an airport, whether or not it remains under the control and jurisdiction of the same public agency.
Chapter 3. Exclusive Rights
10/2189 Order 5190.6A
CHAPTER 3. EXCLUSIVE RIGHTS
SECTION 1.
3-1. GENERAL. Chapter 4 of this Order describes the responsibilities assumed by the owners of public use airports developed with Fedeml funds. Among these is the obligation to make all aiiport facilities and services available on fair and reasonable tenns without unjust discrimination. This covenant enjoins the airport owner from granting any special privilege or monopoly in the use of public use airport facilities. The grant of an exclusive right to provide aeronautical services at an airport on which Federal funds have been expended is specifically forbidden by the Federal Aviation Act of 1958. Because of the widespread interest and involvement of this statutory prohibition, this entire Chapter is devoted to guidance on the application of law and FAA policy regarding exclusive rights at public use airports.
3-2. LEGISLATIVE ffiSTORY.
a. Origin. The Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938 contained language (Section 303) restricting the use of Federal funds for airport development (other than mili-
tary) to those landing areas certified by the Administrator as being reasonably needed for air commerce or national defense. The same section of the Act also provided that uthere shall be no exclusive right for the use of any landing area or air navigation facility upon which Federal funds have been expended.'' This identical language has since been incorporated as Section 308(a) of the Federal Aviation Act of 1958. This provision also applies to surplus and nonsurplus property transferred for public use airport purposes.
b. Recognition or Statutory Prohibition in Agreements. The AP-4 Agreements (see Section 4, Chapter 2) under which many civil airports were improved with Federal funds during the World War ll period contained a covenant that such airports would be operated without the grant or exercise of any exclusive right for use of the airport within the meaning of Section 303 of the Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938. Similar language is now used in airport grant agreements to specifically require conformity to this statute as part of the sponsor's assurances. Whether referenced in an agreement or not, the prohibition against exclusive right contained in Section 308 applies to any airport on which any Federal funds have been expend· ed since August 28, 1938, the effective date of the Civil Aeronautics Act.
c. Prohibition Applied to Aeronautical Activities. In 1941, the Attorney General of the United
BACKGROUND
States was called upon to interpret the application of Sec. 303 of the Civil Aeronautics Act. In an opinion dated June 4, 1941, the Attorney General stated u •• .it is my opinion that the grant of an exclusive right to use an airport for a particuJar aeronautical activity, such as an air cauier, falls within the provision of Section 303 of the Civil Aeronautics Act precluding any exclusive right for the use of any landing area.'' Significantly, the Attorney General did not defme what an aeronautical activity was other than to cite as an example one type of activity commonly known in 1941-
"such as an air carrier!' This opinion, however, made it clear that a monopoly covering one activity would not be tolerated merely because the landing area was also available to those engaged in other types of aeronautical activity.
d. Restrictions in Surplus Property Deeds. Following World War ll, large numbers of fonner military installations were conveyed without monetary consideration to local public agencies under the provisions of the Surplus Property Act of 1944. Initially the deeds of conveyance included a covenant that there would be no exclusive right contrary to the provisions of Section 303 of the Civil Aeronautics Act. Subsequently, however, in 1947, the Surplus Property Act was amended by PL. 80-289 to require the following specific language:
No exclusive right for the use of the airport at which the property disposed of is located shall be vested (either directly or indirectly) in any person or persons to the exclusion of others in the same class. For the purpose of this cOndition, an exclusive right is defmed to mean-{1) any exclusive right to use the airport for conducting any particular aeronautical acti.v· ity requiring opemtion of a.b:craft; (2) any exclusive right to engage in the sale or supplying of a.irciaft, aircraft accessories, equipment, or supplies (excluding the sale of gasoline and oil), or aircraft services necessary for the operation of a.b:craft (including the maintenance and repair of aircraft, aircraft engines, propellers, and appliances.
3-3. DEVELOPMENT OF AGENCY POLICY.
a. Implementation or Federal Airport Act. During the immediate post war years, the CAA (ihe predecessor of the FAA) was simultaneously engaged in processing the fust F AAP development projects and in recommending the conveyance of former military
installations under the surplus property laws. Many of the surplus property conveyances did not literally re· quire conformity to the prohibition against exclusive rights in Section 303 of the Civil Aeronautics Act, but they contained the far more specific restrictions quoted in paragraph 31d above.
b. Early Interpretations or Aeronautical· Ac· ti.vity. In approving grants of funds for airport development the CAA/FAA has always insisted that there could be no exclusive right for the use of such airports. Any activity which involved use of the landing
at'C3 (e.g., flight school, airline, charter service, etc.) was considered to be subject to the statutory prohibition. However, a nonaeronautical activity, such as a restaurant or ground transportation service, was viewed as not subject to the prohibition. In early policy interpretations there were many activities which cater to or support flight operations, but which do not actually use the landing area (such as storage hangars, repair servw ices, aircmft parts sales, and especially the sale of fuel
SECTION 2.
3-8. BASIS OF POLICY
a. Agency Position. The FAA has concluded that the existence of exclusive right to conduct any aeronautical activity at an airport limits the usefulness of the airport and deprives the using public of the benefits of a competitive enterprise. Apart from legal considerations, the FAA considers it inappropriate to provide Federal funds for improvements to airports where the benefits of such improvements will not be fully realized due to the inherent restrictions of an exclusive monopoly on aeronautical activities.
b. Application or Law. The grant of an exclusive right to conduct an aeronautical activity at an airpon on which Federal funds have been expended is considered a violation of Section 308(a) of the Federal Aviation Act, whether such exclusive right results from an express agreement, from the imposition of unreasonable standards or requirements, or by any other means. As an exception, the existence of an exclusive right to sell only fuel and oil will not be considered to be in vio1ation of Section 308(a) where such right is specifically exempted from the activities prohibited by a deed under the Surplus Property Act of 1944, as amended (P.L. 80-289). However, presence of such an exclusive right would preclude issuance of a grant under the AAIA Act of 1982, as amended. (See Chapter 6, Section 2.)
c. Duration or Prohibition Against Exclusive Rights. Once any Fedeml funds have been expended
10/2/89
and oil) and were viewed as not being subject to the prohibition. The FAA, as a matter of policy, advised against monopolies for such activities. However, in
1962 the FAA Policy on Exclusive Rights was pub· lished in the Federal Register and it declared the exclusive rights of these activities to be in violation of the law.
c. Definition of Aeronautical Activity. On July 17, 1962, the FAA issued Order OA 5250.1 which defmed those aeronautical activities prohibited on an exclusive basis by Section 308(a) of the Federal Aviation Act. On October 12, 1965, this Order was superseded by Order 5190.1, Exclusive Rights at Airports, to further clarify the application of the statutory prohibition. Section 2 of this Chapter explains in detail the types of aeronautical activity covered by the prohibition and the FAA policies for interpreting and applying Section 308(a).
3-4.-3-7. RESERVED.
POLICY
at an airport, including a surplus property conveyance, the exclusive rights prohibition is applicable for as long as it is operated as an airport.
3-9. INTERPRETATION.
a. Single Activity Not Necessarily an Exdusive Right. The presence on an airpon of only one enterprise engaged in any aeronautical activity will not be considered a violation of this policy if there is no understanding, commitment, express agreement, or apparent intent to exclude other reasonably qualified enterprises. In many instances, the volume of business may not be sufficient to attract more than one such enterprise. As long as the opponunity to engage in an aeronautical activity is available to those meeting reasonable qualifications and standards relevant to such activity, the fact that only one enterprise takes advantage of the opportunity does not constitute the grant of an exclusive right.
b. Single Activity as Treated by Law. The AAIA (P.L. 97-248) includes the following sponsor assurance under Section 511(a)(2):
u ••• There will be no exclusive right for the use of the airport by any person providing, or intending to provide~ aeronautical services to the public. For purposes of this paragraph, the providing of services at an airport by a single fiXed-based operator shall not be construed as an exclusive right if it would be unreasonably costly, burdensome, or impractical for more
10/2/89
than one fixed-based operator to provide such serv-
ices~ and if allowing more than one fixed-based operator to provide such services would require the reduction of space leased pursuant to an existing agreement between such single fiXed-based operator and such airpan. ~' ..
The Chief Counsel rendered an opinion dated December 21, 1982, which concludes that this amendment to Section 308(a) applies to those airports previously obligated under Section 308(a) where a single fiXedbased operator (FBO) now exists. This assurance obligates the grant recipients to the same terms and conditions of amended Section 308(a). (Reference Order 5190.1.)
The exclusive rights policies that are outlined herein remain unchanged except for those airports which have a single FBO whose lease agreement with the airport owner must be amended to delete space for a second FBO to do business on the aiJ:port. In these cases, it must be detennined if it would be unreasonably costly, burdensome, or impractical for more than one FBO to provide such services on the airport. This does not apply where the lease is being amended to delete space due to lack of demonstrable need (see below).
c. Single Activity Due to Space Limitation. The leasing to one enterprise of all available airport land and improvements planned for aeronautical activities will be construed as evidence of an intent to exclude others unless: (1) the lease meets the criteria of and contains the special provisions described in paragraph 6-5c; or (2) it can be demonstrated that the entire leased area is presently required and will be immediately used to conduct the activities contemplated by the lease.
(1) The complete saturation of space available for the service, storage, and repair of aircraft is prima facie evidence of a serious imbalance iD the development of airport facilities. At a new or recently developed airport such saturation reflects poor planning and amrealistic forecasts of need. However, an arbitrary division or restriction to create an opportunity for a competitive enterprise is not required merely to comply with the exclusive rights policy.
{2) A single aeronautical enterprise although meeting all reasonable standards and qualifications should be limited, as a result of this policy, to the lease of such space as is demonstrably needed. If the need for additional space becomes apparent at a later date, such space, as well as any new areas developed for the service and support of aeronautical activities, must be made available to all qualifted proponents or bidders, including the incumbent The advance grant of options or preferences (including right of ftrSt refusal)
on all future sites to the incumbent enterprise must be viewed as an exclusive right. On the other hand, nothing in this policy should be construed as limiting the expansion of such an enterprise when space requirements become critical and where the proposed lease area will be immediately used to conduct activities, even though it could ultimately result in complete satu· ration of all space by the one enterprise.
d. Aeronautical Activities Conducted by the Airport Owner (Proprietary Exclusive). The owner of a public-use airport (public or private owner) may elect to provide any or all of the aeronautical services needed by the public at the airport. In fact, the statutory prohibition against exclusive rights does not apply
to these owners and they may exercise but not grant the exclusive right to conduct any aeronautical activity. However, these owners must engage in such activities as principals using their own employees and resources. An independent commercial enterprise that has been designated as agent of the owner may not exercise nor be granted an exclusive right (Reference Chief Counsel opinion dated Aprill3, 1984.) ~
(1) As a practical matter most public agencies recognize that these services are best provided by profit-motivated private enterprise. The exceptions are usually those instances in which a municipality or other public agency elects to provide fuel service or aircraft parking. If it does so, whether on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis, it may not refuse to permit an air carrier, air taxi, or flight school to fuel its own aircraft.
(2) The airport owner may establish reasonable standards covering the refueling, washing, painting, repairing, etc., of aircraft, but it may not refuse to negotiate for the space and facilities needed to meet such standards by an activity offering aeronautical services to the public. H the airport owner reserves unto itself the exclusive right to sell fuel, it can prevent an airline or air taxi from selling fuel to others but it must deal reasonably to permit such operators to refuel their own aircraft. The self-service fueling by such flight operatorst however, must be done with their own employees and equipment.
(3) An aircraft operator dc~s not bave a right to bring a third party, such as an oil company, on the airport to refuel his aircraft. This would be an aeronau· tical activity undertaken by t..,_e fue! company which has only such rights as !he ~Jrport owner may confer. It should be noted t.~at air carriers invariably insist on a standard condition in t'i-teir ai.,ort cont."3.Cts reserving
the right to obtain fuel from a supplier of their choice. However, this is not a right guaranteed by the terms of a grant agreement.
e. Restrictions on Self-Servke.
(1) Any unreasonable restriction imposed on the owners or operators of aircraft regarding the servicing of their own aircraft and equipment may be construed as a vio1ation of this policy. Where no attempt has been made to perform such services for others, aircraft owners should be pennitted to fuel, wash, repair, paint and otherwise take care of their own aircraft. A restriction which has the effect of divening such business to a commercial operator amounts to an exclusive monopoly of an aeronautical activity contrary to law.
(l) Servicing one's own aircraft is not an aeronautical activity that can be preempted by the airport owner which elects to exercise the exclusive right to sell fuel. Quite apart from the prohibition against exclusive rights, the sponsor of an obligated airport is required to operate the airport for the use and benefit of the public on fair and reasonable tenns. It may not, as a condition for the use of its airport, impose unreasonable requirements on aircraft operators to procure parts, supplies or services from specified sources. It can however, require the self-fueler, both individuals and operators, to pay the same fuel flowage fee as those operators on the airport who provide fueling services to the public. As long as the aircraft operators do not attempt to offer commodities or services to others, they have a right to furnish their own supplies and to do what is necessary to their aircraft in order to use the facilities of a public use airport.
(3) An airport owner is under no obligation to pennit aircraft owners to introduce on the airport equipment, personnel or practices which would be unsafe, unsightly, detrimental to the public welfare, or which would affect the effiCient use of airport facilities by others. Reasonable rules and regulations should be adopted to confine aircraft maintenance and fueling operations to appropriate locations with equipment commensurate to the job being done. Unless the aircraft owner is in a position to meet such standards with his own equipment and personnel, his right to service his own aircraft does not override the prerogative of the airport owner to control the sources of providing fuel and other aeronautical senrir-~s. For exam· pie, airport agreements do not pennit the owner of a private aircraft to contract with an off-airport company to enter upon the airport and refuel his aircrafL This would clearly be the conduct of an aeronautical acti.vity, not by the aircraft owner, but by the fuel company. Also, the airport owner is under nc obligation by the tenns of the grant assurances to recognize &. ''CO- OP'' (an organization fonned by several aircraft owners for the purpose of self fueling) as a single aircraft owner for self fueling purposes. However, fueling activities by a ''CO-OP'' could be allowed by the air-
10/2/89
port owner provided appropriate agreements (safety standards, fees, conditions, etc.) were consummated. Where the sponsor has retained, on an exclusive basis, this right to fuel or service the aircraft of others it may prohibit such entries. With respect to fuel, therefore, the aircraft owner may assert the right to obtain fuel where he pleases and bring it onto the airport to service his own aircraft, but only with his own employees and only in conformance with the reasonable safety standards or other reasonable requirements of the airport. This policy also applies to aircraft owners who have obtained supplemental type certificates authorizing the use of automotive gasoline (mogas) in their aircraft and who wish to self service their aircraft with mogas.
(4) Local airport regulations may and should include such restrictions as are reasonably necessary for safety. preservation of facilities and protection of the public interesL For example:
(a) The use of paints, dopes, and thinners should be confmed to structures meeting appropriate safety criteria.
(b) Storage and transport of aviation fuel, though not procured for resale, should be subject to reasonable restrictions and minimum standards for equipment, location and handling practices.
{c) Restraints should be placed on the use of aircraft washing solvents to protect sewage and drainage facilities.
(d) Weight limitations should be imposed on delivery trucks (including fuel ttucks) and special purpose vehicles such as cranes where needed to pro-
tect airport roads and paving.
(e) Time limits should be placed on the open storage of nonairworthy aircraft, wreckage, or unsightly major components.
(f) Such restrictions as may be required by appropriate F~eral or state agencies to protect the environment and mini..rnize pollution or other adverse effects.
(g) Restraints should be placed on tlie s~0rage of nonaeronautical vehicles such as boats, cars, trailers and mobile homes, etc., in hangars or on the aeronautical facilitie areas.
f. Licenses Not Controlled by Airport Owner. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) authorizes use of special UNICOM frequencies for airto-ground communication at airports. The primary purpose of the communications station is to disseminate aeronautical data, such as weather, wind direction, runway information, etc. To preclude the issuance of
conflicting reports, the FCC will not license more than one UNICOM station at the same airport An aeronautical activity having a UNICOM station or similar exclusive privilege has an advantage over competitors in attracting aeronautical users. However, since such an exclusive right is not subject to the airport owner's control, it does not constitute a grant of exclusive rights to which the statutory prohibition of Section 308(a) applies. Airport owners should be encouraged to obtain the UNICOM license in their own names. Through droplines they can make the facility available to all FBO's on an equal basis.
g. Flying Clubs. Flying clubs are nonprofit entities (corporations, associations or partnerships) organized for the express pmpose of providing its members with an ailcraft or aircraft for their personal use and enjoyment only. The ownership of the aircraft, or aircraft, must be vested in the name of the flying club (or owned ratable by all its members). The property rights of the members of the club shall be equal and no part of the net earnings of the club will inure to the benefit of any form (salaries, bonuses, etc.). The club may not derive greater revenue from the use of its a.Ucraft than the amount for the operation, maintenance and replacement of its aircraft. A flying club qualifies as an individual under the grant assurances and, as such, has the right to fuel and maintain the aircraft with its members. The airport owner has the right to require the flying club to furnish such docwnents, insurances policies, and maintain a current list of members as reasonably necessary to assure that the flying club is a nonprofit organization rather than a FBO masquerading as a flying club. (See Appendix 8, Sample Flying Club Lease.)
~10. IMPLEMENTATION OF POLICY.
a. Voluntary Compliance. The FAA will consider as a breach of compliance obligations by the airport owner, any grant of an exclusive right in violation of the policy outlined herein at any airport obligated to the United States as a result of a grant agreement {FAAP/ADAP/AIP), AP-4 agreement, or a conveyance of Federal property under the Surplus Property Act, or under Section 16, 23, or 516. Every reasonable effort shall be made to influence a voluntary tennination of the objectionable exclusive right using the guidance and techniques suggested in Chapter 5.
b. Remedies. At any airport where there has been a grant of an exclusive right contrary to law and this policy. that airport and any other airport owned or controlled by the offending airport owner will be ineligible for assistance under AlP and the FAA will not expend Facilities and Equipment (F&E) funds for installations designed to benefit traffic at such airports unless necessary to remedy a safety problem. See
Chapter 6, Section 2 for discussion of procedural enforcement matters.
c. Exceptions. Nothing herein shall be construed as precluding the grant of Federal funds where required for the national defense, or when detennined by the Administrator to be essential to the national interest.
~11. IMPROVEMENTS BY OTHER FEDERAL AGENCIES.
a. Expenditures on Civil Airports. From time to time various Federal agencies and activities other than the FAA have expended Federal funds to bring about pennanent or temporary improvement of civil airports, usually in furtherance of essential Federal programs for which they are responsible. The Chief Counsel of the FAA has detennined that any such expenditures which result in the improvement of airport facilities constitute an expenditure of funds within the meaning of the Federal Aviation Act Consequently, such action has the effect of imposing the prohibition against the grant of exclusive rights at such an airport. In instances of this kind, the Chief Counsel has concluded that the FAA has primary responsibility for enforcing the prohibition regardless of the somce of the Federal funds.
b. Statutory Requirement. As noted in paragraph 3Ia of this Order the language of Section 308(a) of the Federal Aviation Act not only prohibits exclusive rights but restricts the use of Federal funds for airport development (other than military) to those landing areas certified by the FAA Administrator as being reasonably needed for air commerce or national defense. FAA approval of the National Plan of Integrated Airport System (NPIAS) satisfies this requirement for federally-funded airport development projects. Federal agencies proposing to expend Federal funds on airport improvements not included in the NPIAS are responsible for obtaining a Certificate of Air Navigation Facility Necessity.
c. FAA Responsibility. Whenever consulted, FAA personnel will advise the representatives of other Federal agencies contemplating the improvement of airport facilities as to the applicability of the above described statutory provision. Both the airport owner and the Federal agency involved should understand that the expenditure of such funds will result in the imposition of the prohibition against exclusive rights at such airports.
d. Federally-Owned Airports.
(1) Military and Special Purpose Airports. The prohibition against exclusive rights contained in the Federal Aviation lt;,ct does not apply to the actions
of the Federal Government itself. Most federallyowned airports are maintained and opemted with funds appropriated for purposes other than the support of civil avialion, usually to accommodate a military or defense related mission. Many of these installalions grant operating rights to airlines and other aeronautical activities in order to meet the transportation and civil aviation requirements of on-base activities and residents. This · is a secondary use of the ai.rJx>rt facilities incidental to their prime mission.
(2) Joint-Use Arrangements. At many locations, arrangements are in effect to accommodate the civil avialion requirements of a local community at a military or other federally-owned airport. These arrangements usually involve a lease of space at the Govemment installation to a non-Federal public agency or private concern. Such a lessee, in granting privileges to conduct aeronautical activities, is subject to applicable Federal statutes and may not grant an exelusive right in violation of Section 308(a) of the Federal Aviation Act'
(3) Agency Actions. If a local public agency which operates civil airport facilities under a
joint-use lease at a Federal installation is also a party
to an agreement with the FAA for development of such facilities, the FAA has the same monitoring and enforcement responsibilities as at locally owned air- JX>11S with similar agreements.
3-12. ADMINISTRATION OF POLICY. The foregoing policies are not intended to expose purveyors of aeronautical services to irresponsible competition. A prudent airport management should establish minimum standards to be met by all who would engage in a commercial aeronautical enterprise at the airport. It is the prerogative of the ai.r}x>rt owner to impose conditions on users of the airport to ensure its safe and efficient operation. Such conditions must, however, be fair, equal and not unjustly discriminatory. That is to say, they must be relevant to the proposed activity, reasonably attainable, and uniformly applied. FAA's position is that the opportunity to offer those aeronautical services not provided by the airport owner must be available to those who meet acceptable standards.
3-13.-3-16. RESERVED.
SECTION 3. QUALIFICATIONS AND STANDARDS
3-17. USE OF MINIMUM STANDARDS.
a. Ai!port owners should be encouraged to develop and publish minimum standards to be met by commercial operators in advance of negotiations with any prospective tenant or operator. (See Advisory Circular (AC) 150/5190-1, Minimum Standards for Commercial Aeronautical Activities on Public Airpons) This will establish a basis for practical negotiations.
b. Where minimum standards are proposed, the FAA representative may comment on the relevance and/or reasonableness of the standards. However, it should be made clear that such opinions are not to be consttued as an official endorsement of the proposed minimum standards. The FAA should make an official detennination only when the effect of a standard denies access to a public-use airport, and the determi-
nation should be limited to a judgment as to whether failure to meet the qualifications of the standard is a reasonable basis for such denial or the standard results in an attempt to create an exclusive right.
c. In the early stages of airport development the community may encounter difficulty in attracting a competent service agency and it may be necessary to waive standards which, after a period of initial development, would be perfectly reasonable. As a practical matter, the airport owner may quite properly increase the standards from time to time in order to ensure a higher quality of service to the public. Manipulating the standards solely to protect the interest of an existing tenant is incompatible with this objective. A standard which a tenant operator is required to meet must be uniformly applicable to all operators seeking the same franchise privileges.
Chapter 4. Obligations of Airport Owners
10/2189 Order 5190.6A
CHAPTER 4. OBLIGATIONS OF AIRPORT OWNERS
SECTION 1. GENERAL
4-1. PURPOSE. This Chapter contains basic guid· ance for FAA personnel in interpreting and administering the various continuing commitments made to the United States by airport owners as a condition for the grant of Federal funds or the conveyance of Federal property for airpon purposes. It does not cover the standards to be met by those airports certificated Wlder FAR Part 139. Generally, it does not apply to special conditions incorporated in a grant agreement since these usually reflect specific actions to be accomplished before a project can be closed out.
4-2. ASSIGNMENT OF OBLIGATIONS. The airpon obligations discussed in this Chapter apply to the recipients including private owners of public use airports that are signatory parties to an agreement with the Federal Government. The actual release of these parties from any such obligations is treated in Chapter
7. However, the various agreements contemplate that under certain conditions there may be a transfer of the obligations to another eligible party.
a. Transfer to Another Eligible Recipient
(1) Grant agreements provide that the owner/ sponsor will not enter into any transaction which would deprive it of any of the rights and powers necessary to perfonn all of the conditions in the agreement unless the obligation to perfonn all such conditions is assumed by another recipienL In the case of grant agreements, the recipient must specifically be found eligible by the FAA.
(2) Surplus property instruments of disposal pennit conveyance of the property but only to another transferee who assumes all of the obligations imposed on the original grantee. The airpon owner must obtain FAA approval of all such transfers of obligations.
(3) Deeds of Conveyance under Section 16, 23, or 516 are made to public agencies only, but do not specifJCally restrict reassignments or retransfers of the property conveyed The original donor (Federal agency) may reassign or retransfer the property to another public agency for continued airport use. The FAA should assume the lead in coordination between the affected parties.
b. Transfer to the United States.
(1) The FAA cannot legally prohibit an airport owner from conveying to a Federal agency any aiiport property which was transferred under the Surplus Property Act of 1944, as amended. The Chief
Counsel has indicated that such a conveyance, whetla voluntary or otherwise, does not p1ace the conveying airport owner in default of any obligation to the United States. Such a conveyance has the effect of a complete release of the conveying owner. The procedures applicable to such ttansfers are covered in Chapter 7.
(2) When such a conveyance is proposed, or has been accomplished without prior notice to the FAA, and it is detennined there would be or is an ad· verse effect on civil aviation, FAA objections should immediately be made known to both the airport ownf:l' and the Federal agency involved. If a satisfactory solution to an adverse effect on civil aviation cannot be obtained at the field office level, a full and complete report should be submitted to the Office of Aiipcxt Safety and Standards (AAS-1) without delay.c The FAA shall make appropriate objection and take timely action with the Federal agency involved.
e. Delegation of Obligations. Aiipcxt owners subject to continuing obligations to the Federal Government may enter into arrangements which have the effect of delegating certain of these obligations to other parties. For example, an airpon authority may arrange with the Public Works Department of a local mWlicipality to meet certain of its maintenance commitments, or an airport owner may contract with a utility company to maintain airfreld lighting equipmenL More prevalent at small airports are arrangements in which the OWDel' relies upon a commeiCial tenant or franchised operator to cover a broad range of airpon operating, maintenance and management responsibilities. None of these contractual delegations of responsibility absolve or relieve the airpon owner from the primary obligations to the GovernmenL As principal party to the agreement the ownel' alone is accountable for confonnity to its terms and conditions. Particular attention should be directed to ensure that such delegations to a proprietary enterprise do not result in a conflict of interest or a violation of the statute prohibiting certain exclusive rights. The airpon owner shall oot delegate its authority to one FBO to negotiate an operating agreement (lease) with another FBO. (See paragraph 6-5.)
d. Subordination of Title.
(1) The subordination of airport property by mortgage, easement, or other encumbrance will normally be considered as a transaction which would de-
prive the owner of the rights and powers necessary to perfonn the covenants in the agreement with the Government However, the prior existence of such an encumbrance may under certain circumstances be considered as not inconsistent with the eligibility requirement for Jand interest in connection with the development of airport facilities tmder the grant program.
The Secretary is authorized to determine whether a specific encumbrance might create an undue risk of depriving the potential sponsor of the rights and powers otherwise required. Wherever it is proposed to subsequently encumber obligated airport property, a complete summary of the pertinent facts, together with teCOIIllllendations of the appropriate regional Ailports office, should be forwarded to the regional Ailports division for determination on a case-by-case basis. The
detennination should be consistent with criteria for determining good land tide set forth in appropriate FAA directives (see Order 5100.38, Airport Improvement Program (AlP) Handbook). A legal review of the case may be appropriate.
(2) FAA concurrence as to any such lien, mortgage or other encumbrance of airport obligated property should be predicated on a factually based and
thoroughly documented detennination. The possibility of foreclosure or other action adverse to the airport
should be so remote to reasonably preclude the possibility that such lien, mortgage or other encumbrance will prevent the owner from fulfilling its assurances and obligations under applicable airport instruments.
4-3.-4-4. RESERVED.
SECTION 2. MAINTENANCE AND OPERATION
4-S. SCOPE OF MAINTENANCE OBLIGATION.
a. Agreements Involved. Most airport agreements impose on the airport owner a continuing obligation to preserve and maintain aiJport facilities in a safe and serviceable condition. An exception is the transfer document conveying Federal lands under the authority of section 16, 23, or 516. These transfers normally contemplate further development of the property involving a grant agreement imposing maintenance obligations. It is preferred that such obligations · be imposed as a conuactual commitment rather than a covenant running with the land. However, where a Section 516 conveyance is made under circumstances that do not involve a follow-on development agree· ment, the maintenance and operation assurances should be inc<xporated into the transfer document.
b. Facillties to be Maintained. This Section applies to an airport facilities shown on a current Airport Layout Plan (ALP) which were initially dedicated to aviation use (see defmition in Appendix 5) by an instrument of transfer or agreement with the United States. This means that the airport owner cannot discontinue maintenance of a taxiway stub or any part of the airport until fonnally relieved of the maintenance obligation. The obligations of the owner under a grant agreement remain in force throughout the useful life of the facility but no longer than 20 years, except for land which is obligated for the life of the airport When a facility is no longer needed for the purpose for which it was developed. the regional Airports division may make the detennination that its useful life has expired in less than 20 years and authorize its abandon-
ment or conversion to another compatible purpose. For
private airports, the obligation extends for a minimum of 10 years. (The procedure for obtaining release from these maintenance obligations is explained in Chapter 7.)
4-6. PHYSICAL MAINTENANCE.
a. Maintenance Procedures. Generally, airport agreements require the owner or grantee to carry out a continuing program of preventive maintenance and minor repair activities which will ensure that the airport facilities are at all times in a good and serviceable condition for use in the way they were designed to be used. Such requirements may be expressed or implied in the agreement and include such things as:
(1) All structures should be checked frequently for deteriorations. Where necessary, repairs should be made.
(2) Runways, taxiways, and other commonuse paved areas should be inspected at reguJar intervals for compliance with operational and maintenance standards. Routine repairs including crack filling and sealing shall be made to prevent progressive deterioration of the pavement
(3) Gravel runways, taxiways, and other common-use paved areas should be inspected at regu- Jar intervals for compliance with operational and maintenance standards. Routine repairs including hole filling and grading shall be performed to prevent progressive deterioration of the operational areas.
(4) All turfed areas should be preserved through clearing, seeding, fertilizing and mowing. Turfed landing areas which are used for aircraft oper-
ations should be inspected at regular intervals to assure that there are no holes or depressions.
(S) Field lighting and V ASr s must be maintained in a safe and operable condition at all times. The VASI' s must be aligned on a regular basis and at times when conditions dictate.
(6) Segmented circles and wind cones should be inspected on a regular basis to ensure proper serviceability.
(7) All drainage structures should be inspected, particularly sub-drain outlets, to ensure unobstructed drainage.
(8) All approaches must be checked to assure conformance with the approach obligations incurred.
b. Criteria for Satisfactory CompHance.
(1) What constitutes an acceptable level of maintenance is difficult to express in measurable units. A standard yardstick of satisfactory maintenance effort will not apply in all circumstances. Grass cut to a height of 8 inches may be acceptable at some airports but it could impair safety and effiCiency at others. A one-half inch crack in runway paving may be inconsequential under certain circumstances. Depending on its location, the volume of traffic, the age of the pavement, climatic and other conditions, it could be the forenmner of serious pavement failure implying an obligation to apply immediate corrective measures. The degree of maintenance effort required of an airport owner is a matter of professional judgment.
(2) Compliance with this maintenance obligation is considered satisfactory when the airport owner:
(a) Fully understands that airport facilities must be kept in a safe and serviceable condition;
(b) Has adopted and implemented a sufficiently detailed program of cyclical preventive maintenance that in the judgment of FAA is adequate to carry out this commitment; and
(c) Has available the equipment, personnel, funds and other resources including contract arrangements to effectively implement such a program.
c. Major Repair.
(1) The obligation to maintain the airport does not extend to major rehabilitation of a facility that bas become unusable due to normal and unpreventable deterioration or through acts of God. Therefore, the restoration of a building destroyed by frre or windstorm or a major rehabilitation of a portion of the landing area inundated by floods is not included in the sponsor·s maintenance obligations. Likewise, the complete resurfacing of a runway, unless it is the result of obvi-
ous neglect of routine maintenance,. is not included in the sponsor's obligations. Failure to perform day-today maintenance may have a cumu1ative effect resulting in major repairs and reconstruction.
(2) The airport owner has a commilment to prevent gross overstressing of the airport pavemeoL If the owner is not prepared to strengthen the pavement, then its use must be limited to aircraft operations which will preclude overstressing the pavement. Should pavement failure occur because the sponsor failed to take timely corrective action after being advised of the pavement limitations, any cost required to restore the failed pavement to a satisfactory condition will not be eligible for AIP funding. Strengthening of the pavement,. after correction of the failure, would be eligible for consideration for AlP funding.
4-7. REQUIREMENT TO OPERATE THE AIR· PORT.
a. GeneraL The owner of an airport developed with Federal assistance is more than a passive Jandlord of specialized real estate. The obligation to maintain the airport includes the responsibility to opera1e the aeronautical facilities and common use areas for the benefit of the public. This means, for example, tbat
(1) If field lighting is installt-<1 the owner is responsible for making mangements for it and the as-
sociated airport beacon and lighted wind and Iandin& direction indicators to be operated throughout each night of the year or when needed in accordance with subparagraph 4-7e below.
(2) H any part of the airport is closed or hazardous to use, the owner is responsible for providing warning to users, such as adequate marking and issuing a Notice to Ainnen (NOTAM) to advise pilots of the condition.
(3) The owner should adopt and enforce adequate rules, reguJations, or ordinances as necessary to ensure safety and efficiency of flight operations and to protect the public using the airport.
b. Local Regulations. The prime requiremau for local regulations is to conuol the use of the airport in a manner that will eliminate hazards to aircraft and to people on the ground. For example, aircraft them· selves become a hazard to other ah-craft if allowed to park too close to an active runway. There should be adequate controls such as fencing and other facilitie'8 to keep motorists, cyclists, pedestrians, and animals from inadvertently wandering onto the landing area or areas designated for aircraft maneuvering. Frequendy local air traffic patterns are needed to establish unifonn and orderly approaches and departures from the airport. As in the operation of any public service facil ..
ity, there sbould be adequate rules cova.ing vehicuJar traffiC, sanitation, security, crowd control, access to certain areas and fire protection. The fueling of aircraft, storing of hazardous materials, spray painting, etc., at a public airp<Xt sbould be controlled by the air· port owner in the interests of protecting tbe public.
c. Operatloas iD Inclement Weather. The obligation to maintain the airp<Xt does not impose any specific responsibility to remove snow or slush, or to provide sanding of icy pavements. 1be owner is re-- spoosible for providing a safet .usable facility, and where climatic conditions render airp<Xt unsafe, the owner will promptly notify ainnan by proper notices 8lld, if necessary, to close an or a pan of the aitport mJtil die conditions are corrected. However, the conditions should be corrected within a reasonable amount fl. time.
d. Aircraft Rescue and Flretlghtlng Responsi· bOlt,. The agreementS under which airports are acquired or developed with Federal assistance do not specificaDy impose a responsibility to provide MSCUe or firefighdng capabilities. Beginning in 1988 aircraft … , Md fireftghting (ARFF) equipment became eli- Jfble under AlP for airports being served by air carriers using aircraft designed for more tban 20 passenger - 81 not certificated. under FAR Part 139. Such an aitport tJWDC!I' acquiriDa ARFF equipment under AlP must assure that it will maintain sufficiently trained pcnonnel to operate the equipment; have the equip- - available during scheduled operations of the air carrier; and to notify die air carriers using the airp<Xt wlae8 1be equipment is not available due to being out d. Jetvice for mainteDance or repair.
e. Pan-Tbae Operadoa of Airport Lf&btlq.
(1) As noted in subparagraph 4-7a above, field .tights must be operated whenever needed. This means that the lights must be on during the hours of darknea (dusk to dawn) every night, <X" be available for use upon demand. One effective arrangement is an at1endaDt with aUibority and capability to tum on tbe proper liJhts when requested to do so by the radio or other signal. An ~ceptable altemative is the installati.oft of an electronic device which permits remote acti· vatioll of field lighting by radio equipment in an aircraft. (See AC 150/5340-14, Economy Approach Light· ing Aids. and AC 150/5340-27, Air to Ground Radio Coetrd. of Airp<xt Ligbting Systems.)
(2) At some locations it may not be necessary to operate the lights all nighL This might occur where abe aaonautical demand is seasonal, or where it ceases after a certain hour each night because the airport's off airway location is not likely to be needed for emergency use. In very rare cases it may be undesirable to
permit use of an airport during certain hours of darkness. An example might be where air traffte control is suspended dming some part of the night and the local environment (such as obstructions or heavy enroute traffic) makes use of the airp<Xt hazardous during that period. Under such circmnstance FAA may consent to a part-time operation of fteld lights.
4-8. RESTRICTIONS ON AERONAUTICAL USE OF AIRPORT.
a. Safety and Emciency.
(1) While the airp<Xt owner must allow its use by all typest kinds, and classes of aeronautical activity as wen • by the general public (passengers, visitors, etc.), the obligation agreements do provide for exceptions as discussed in this paragraph. When complaints are filed with FAA regarding restrictioos imposed by the aitport owner in the interest of safety and/or efficiency, assistance of the appropriate local Flight Standards and Air Traffic representatives should be oblaiDed in determining the reasonableness of the restrictions. It may be appropriate to initiate an FAA aitspace study to dettnnine the efficiency and utility of the aitport when considering the proposed restriction. In all cases the FAA will make the final determination of 1he reasonablene'8S of the aitport owner's restrictions which denied or restricted use of the airport.
(2) In the interest of safety, the airport owner may p-ohibit or limit any given type, kind, or class of aeronautical use of the airport if such action is necessary for the safe operation of the aitport or ~ to serve the civil aviation needs of the public. This allows the imposition of reasonable rules or reguladons (see paragraph 4-7b) to restrict use of the aitport. For example, they may prohibit aircraft not equipped with a reasonable minimum of communications equipment from using the airport. They may restrict or deny use of the airport for student training, for taking off with towed objects, or for some other pmpose deemed to be incompatible with safety under the local conditions pe· culiar to that airport. Agricultural operations may be excluded due to conflict with other types of operations or Jack of facilities to safely handle the pesticides used in this specialized operation. (The regional eDforcement office of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) should be contacted in cases pesticide use and control problems.) Also, designated runways, taxiways. and other paved areas may be restric:ed to aiJaaft of a specified maximum gross weight or wheel loading. Likewise, use of aitport facilities by the general public may be restricted by vehicular~ security, and crowd control regulations. In cases where complaints are filed with FAA, Flight St:mdards and Air Traffic should be consulted to help determine the reasonableness of the
10/2/89
airport owner's restrictions. It may be appropriate to initiate an FAA airspace study to detennine the efficiency and utility of the airport when considering the proposed restriction. In aJ1 cues the FAA will make the final determination of the reasonableness of the airport owner's restrictions which denied or restricted use of the airport.
b. Parachute Jumping. Parachute jumping is an aeronautical use and requests to airport owners from parachute jumping clubs. organizations. or individuals to establish a drop zone within the boundaries of an airport should be evaluated on the same basis as other aeronautical uses of the airport. Any restriction. limitation. or ban against parachute jumping on the airport must be based on the grant assurance which provides that the sponsor may prohibit or limit an aeronautical use ufor the safe operation of the airport or when necessary to serve the civil aviation needs of the public'' (see paragraph 4-8a). Among the reasonable limitations on parachute jumping that an airport owner might require are:
(1) The airport owner designate reasonable time periods for jumping and specific areas for drop zones.
(2) Jumpers (or requesting organization) agree to pay a reasonable fee that is not unjustly discriminatory.
(3) Jumpers hold a general liability insunmce policy that names the airport owner as an additional ensured party, with the amount of insurance to be reasonable and not unjustly discriminatory. The airport owner is not required to permit this activity if, in his judgment. it creates a safety hazard to the nonnal operations of aircraft arriving or departing from tbe airport, nor is the airport owner required to close the air-
port to provide a safe environment for the parachute jumpers. In cases where complaints are filed with FAA. Flight Standards and Air Traffic should be con-
sulted to help determine the reasonableness of the airport owner's restrictions. It may be appropriate to initiate an FAA airspace study to determine the effiCiency and utility of the airport when considering the pro-- posed restriction. In all cases the FAA will make the final determination of the reasonableness of the airport owner's restrictions which denied or restricted use of the airport.
c. Ultralight Vehides. Ulttalight vehicle operations are considered an aeronautical activity (FAR Part 103) and, as such, must be normally accommodated on airports which have been developed with Federal assistance. This doesn•t necessarily mean that they must be operated on conventional runways if ulttaligbt operations can be safely accomplished at a designated
ullmlight opemtions area on the airport. An airport operator may make the detennination that proposed ultralight operations are unsafe and not allow them to conduct flight operations on the airpM. In C&1eS where complaints are filed with FAA. Flight Standards and Air Traffic should be consulted to help determine the
reasonable~ of the aiiport owner's resttictioos. It may be appropriate to initiate an FAA airspace study to determine the efficiency and utility of the airport when considering the proposed restriction. In all cases the FAA will make the final detennination of the reasonableness of the airport owner's resttictions which denied or restticted use of the airport.
Another obligation of the airport operator is to ensure that users of the airport contribute a fair sbare towards the operation of the airport. The operator of an obligated airport should impose a fee for the use of airport facilities by ulttalight vehicle operators. This is consistent with FAA policy provided the charges and fees are not discriminatory.
d. Congestion. Where the volume of air traffic is approaching or exceeding the maximum practical alpacity of an airport. an airport owner may designate a certain airport in a multiple airport system (under the same ownership and serving the same community) for use by a particular class or cla.es of aircraft. The owner must be in a position to assure that an classes of aeronautical needs can be fully accommodated within the system of airports under the oWIIC2"' s control and without unreasonable penalties to any class and that the restriction is fully supportable as being beneficial to overall aviation system capacity. For example. a reliever general aviatioo airport in a community whac the same airport sponsor owns and operates anotllez full-service aiiport could restrict regularly scheduled air carrier services from the general aviation reliever airpM. This might be justifiable as a means of ensuring the reliever airport's attractiveness as a general aviation facility.
However, in no case may an airport receiving air carrier service use this concept to support a total ban or prohibition on general aviation access to primary air canier airport(s). The right for general aviation access at an air carrier airport is a long established interpretation of the assurance relating to the prohibition against discrimination of classes or types of aeronautical activities.
Any application of this specific provision should be coordinated with the Assistant Chief Counsel in the region for applicability, given a specific case under review.
Additionally. an airpon does have the right to designate certain runways or other aviation use areas at the
airport to a particular class or classes of aircraft as a means of enhancing airport capacity or ensming safety. Any such restrictions should be clearly supportable based on operational considerations and not instituted as a means of deliberately discriminating against a particu.Ja" class.
e. Temporary CkJsing or an Airport.
(1) Closing for Hazardous Conditions. Airport owners are required to physically made any temporary hazardous conditions and to adequately wmu users tbrough the use of NOTAMS. This implies a duty to provide similar warning ootices when an airport is completely clostA:l to air traffic as a result of temporary field conditions that make use of the airport bazardous. The basic obligation requires that prompt 8CiioD be taken to restore the airport facilities to a aviceable condition as soon as possible.
(2) Clming for Special Events. Section 511 (a) (3) of the AAIA requires that any ptqJOSa1 to temporarily close the airport for nonaeronautical purposes must be approved by the FAA. For example, an airport developed or improved with Federal funds may not be closed for the pmpose of using the airport facilities for special outdoor events, such as sports car races, county fain, parades, etc., without FAA approval. However, in certain circumstances where promoting aviation awareness through such activities as model airplane flying, etc., the FAA does support the limited use of airport facilities so long as there is not total closure of the airport. In these cases safeguards need to be established to protect the aeronautical use of the airport wblle the nonaeronautical activities are in progress. There will be occasions when airports may be closed for brief periods of time for aeronautical purposes. Examples are: an air show designed to promote a particular segment of aviation; to celebmte an official occasion held in connection with an aviation activity such a exhibits; or annual fly-ins and aviation conventions. In such cases, airport management should be encouraged to limit the period the airport will be closed to the minimum time consistent witb the activity. Such closing should be well publicized in advance including issuance of NOT AM to minimize any inconvenience to the flying public.
(3) ClosJna or a Part or an Airport. In some instances, rtaSODS may be presented to justify the temporary use of a part of an airport for an unusual event of local significance which does not involve closing the entire airport. In such cases, all the following conditions must be met:
(a) The event is to be held in an area of the airport which is DOt required for the normal operation of aircraft and where the event would not interfere
with the airport's normal use; or in a limited operational area of an ai.Jport having a reJatively small uaffic volume and where it has been determined that the event can be conducted in the area without interference with aeronautical use of the airport.
(b) Adequate facilities for the landing and takeoff of aircraft will remain open to air traff1c and satisfactory arrangements are made by the owner to ensure the safe use of the facilities remaining open.
(c) Proper NOTA...\iS are issued in advance.
(d) Necessary steps are taken by the airport owner to ensure the proper marking of the portion of the airport to be temporarily closed to aeronautical use.
(e) The airport owner notifies in advance the appropriate Flight Standards office and any air carrier using the airport.
· (f) The airport owner agrees to remove all madcings and repair all damage, if any, within 24 hours after .the termination of the event, or issues such additional NOT AMS as may be appropriate.
(g) The airport owner coordinates beforehand the special activities planned for the event with local users of the airport and with the Deparunent of Defense (DOD) if there are any military activities at the airport.
(h) No obstructions determined by FAA to be hazards, such as roads, timing poles, or barricades, will be constructed for the remaining operational area of the airport.
t. Noise and Environmental Restrictioos. Proposed airport use restrictions are becoming more common as airports respond to community concern over environmental issue& and noise problems. Airport owners often propose such restrictions as a means of reducing noise impacts when they are considering alternatives to improve compatibility. This is generally done as part of an FAR Pan 150, Airport Noise Compab"bility Program study, or in some cases as part of an environmental impact assessment report.
Airport use restrictions: (1) must be reasonably consistent with reducing noncompatibility of land uses around the airport; (2) must not create an undue bwden on interstate or foreign commerce; (3) must not be _unjustly discriminatory; (4) must not derogate safety or advcnely affect the safe and effteient use of airspace; (5) meet both local needs and the needs of the national air transportation system to the extent practicable; and (6) must not adversely affect any other p:>wers or responsibilities of the FAA Administtator prescribed by the law or any other program established in accordance with the Jaw.
Proposed Part 150 airport use restrictions will be reviewed by FAA in Washington for consistency with Federal agreements. Where there is a potential for inconsistency with a Federal agreemen~ the Community and Environmental Needs Division, APP~, will coordinate the proposed restriction with AAS-300 for input A determination on compatibility with Federal agreements will be made by AAS-300 and the Chief Counser s office.
The airport operator is expected to analyze fully in a Part 150 program the anticipated burden on commerce of a proposed airport use restriction. FAA will make the detennination on whether the burden is undue. Similar restrictions may have little impact at one airpan and a great deal of impact at others, such as occurs when a restriction adversely affects airport capacity an<Vor excludes or limits certain users from the airport. Tbe magnitude of both impacts must be clearly presented. An airport owner for certain justifmble envi-
ronmental reasons may designate a certain airport in a multiple airport system ooder the same ownership and serving the same community for use by a particular class or classes of aircraft. 'The same concepts as discussed in subparagraph 4-8d will apply. If this is being contemplated, it must be conside.red on a caseby-case basis in coordination with APP-600 and AAS-300.
If Airports offices are confronted with a proposed en-
vironmental or noise restriction outside of the FAR Part 150 process where those restrictions have the potential to be contrary to a Federal agreement, the proposed restriction must be fully reviewed to determine its compatibility with Federal agreements. If there is any concern about potential incompatibility, coordination with AAS-300 and APP-600 is necessary.
An airport owner subject to Federal agreements cannot simply use environmental ex noise reasons as a means not to comply with specific Federal grant agreements.
SECTION 3. APPROACH PROTECTION AND COMPATIBLE LAND USE
4-9. PROTECTION OF APPROACHES.
a. Obstructions/ Airport Hazard. Tbe airports developed by or improved with Federal funds are obligated to prevent the growth or establishment of obstructions in the aerial approaches to the airport. The term "obstruction u refers to natural or man made objects which actually penetrate that surfaces defmed in FAR Part 77 ~ Objects Affecting Navigable Airspace, or other appropriate citation applicable to the agreement as applied to the particular airport. In agreements issued prior to December 31, 1987, airport owners agreed that insofar as it is within their power and reasonably possible, to prevent the construction, erection, alteration or growth of an obstruction. This was to be done either by obtaining the control of the land involved through the acquisition and retention of easements ex other land interests or by the adoption and the enfcxcement of zoning regulations. Effective with the Airport and Airway Safety and Capacity Expansion Act of 1987 (P. L. 100-223) the standard approach protection assurance was changed to read:
ult will take appropriate action to assure that such terminal airspace as is required to protect instrument and visual operations to the airport (including established minimum flight altitudes) will be adequately cleared and protected by removal, lowering, relocating, ma.J.t.ing, or lighting or otherwise mitigation of existing airport hazards and by preventing the establishing or creation of future airport hazards.u (See Appendix 5 for u Airport Hazard.")
The airspace allocated will vary from airport to airport. The Regional Air Traffic, Airspace and Procedures Branch, should be contacted for guidance on application of this provision when an issue is raised.
b. PreexistiDg Obstructions.
(1) Historically, some airports were developed at locations where preexisting structures or natural terrain (for example, hill tops) would constitute an obstruction by currently applicable standards. If such obstructions were not required to be removed as a condition for a grant agreement, the execution of the agreement by the Government constitutes a recognition that the removal was not reasonably within the power of the sponsor.
(2) Also, there are many former military airportS that were acquired as public airports under the Swplus Property Act, where the existence of obstructions at the time of development was considered acceptable. At such airports where obstructions in the approach cannot feasibly be removed, relocated, ex lowered, and where FAA has detennined them to be a hazard, consideration may be given to the disp1acement or relocation of the threshold
e. Zoning Ordinances. One method of meet· ing the obligation to protect airport approaches involves app1opdate height restriction zoning. Any airport owner who has the authority to adopt an ordinance restticting the height of sttuctures in the ap-
proaches according to the standards prescribed in FAR Part 17 as applied to the particular airport should do so.
4-10. COMPATIBLE USE OF ADJACENT LAND. All grants issued after the enactment of PL. 80-289 (78 Stat. 161)~ an amendment to the Surplus
Property Act of 1944~ contain an assurance ~ to the extent reasonable, appropriate action including zoning will be taken to restrict the use of lands in the vicinity of the airport to activities and purposes compatible with normal airport operations.
4-11.-4-12. RESERVED.
SECTION 4. AVAILABILITY ON FAIR AND REASONABLE TERMS
4-13. GENERAL. a. The owner of any airport develor...d with Federal grant assistance is req_uired to operate it for the use and benefit of the public and to make it available to all types, kinds and classes of aeronautical activity on fair and reasonable tenns and without unjust discrimination. A paralld obligation is implicit in the terms of conveyance of Federal property for airport purposes under the Surplus Property Act. Land transfers under Sectioo 16, Section 23, or Section 516 are authorized by the same statutes and for the same purp:>ses as grants under FAAP, ADAP, and AlP and the same obligations will apply.
b. Grant obligations involve several distinct requirements. rJJ'St, the airport and its facilities must be available for public use. The terms imposed on those who use the airport and its services, including rates and charges, must be fair, reasonable, and applied without unjast discrimination. whether by the owner or by a licensee or tenant who has been granted rights to offer services or commodities normally required at the airport. The terms and conditions which the owner imp;>ses on those offering services and commodities to the public which are related to aeronautical activity mast be fair and reasonable and applied without unjust discrimination. (See paragraph 4-15d.)
4-14. TERMS APPLIED TO AIRPORT USERS. a. Rentals Fees and Charges. The obligation of airport management to make an airpon available for public use does not preclude the owner from recovering the cost of providing the facility through fair and reasonable fees. rentals or other ~.er charges · •' ... which will make the airport as self-sustaining as possible under the citcumstances existing at the particular airport. .•. ''
(1) Each air carrier using such airpon (whether as a tenant, nontenant, or subtenant of another air carrier tenant) shall be subject to such nondiscriminatory and substantially comparable rates, fees, rentals. and charges with respect to facilities directly and substantially related to providing air 1r8.llSportation and other such nondiscriminato and substantially compa-
rable rules, regulations, and conditions as are applicable to all such air carriers which make similar use of such airport and which utilize similar facilities, subject to reasonable classifications such as tenant or nontenant, and signatory carriers and nonsignatory carriers. Such classification or status as tenant or signatory shall not be unreasonably withheld by any airport provided an air carrier assumes obligations substantially similar to those already imposed on air carriers in such classification or status.
{2) Each FBO at any airport sball be subject to the same rates, fees, rentals, and other charges as are unifonnly applicable to all other FBO's making the same or similar uses of such airport utilizing the same or similar facilities.
(3) Each air carrier using such airpon shall have the right to service itself or to use any FBO that is authorized by the airport or permitted by the airport to serve any air carrier at such airport.
(4) Normally, the FAA will not question the fairness of rates and charges established by the owner or the comparability of the rates, fees, rentals and other charges as applied to and among air carriers, FBO's and other tenants for the same or similar space and/or services unless complaints have been made alleging that specific practices are unfair or unreasonable. Before an investigation is initiated by the FAA, the charge should be supported by factual evidence produced by the complainant .
(S) The basis for rates and charges is usually related to costs incurred by the airport owner. Rarely can it be established that an actual or proposed rate is so high that it would recover to the owner an amount unreasonable and in excess of costs. More often the FAA will be required to detennine whether the rate structure, as applied, will result in discrimination.
(6) In evaluating established fees, rates, and charges for users of an airport no part of the Federal share of an airport development project for which a grant is made shall be included in the rate base.
Par4-9
b. Methods of Assessing User Charges. The collection of a fee or charge for public use of a runway,. tiedown area, or other facility may be accomplished through a direct toll or landing fee imposed on individual users or through indirect means. The airport owner may fmd it practical to grant use privileges simultaneouSly by contract, pennit, or the direct assessment of fees. In most instances, an indirect recovery of fair use charges i..."l the form of fuel flowage, hangar rentals, percentages of gross volume of business, or through other arrangements may be the most practical method for many collections. A locally based aviation enterprise may have a lease,. or contract, under which it will pay an agreed rental for the hangars and other premises it occupies plus a variable payment (related to fuel gallonage, volwne of business, flight operations, etc.) for the use of the landing area by its own aircraft and those of its customers. Other visiting aircraft, such as scheduled or unscheduled air taxis, which are not covered by such a contract may be required to pay a fee or charge to cover their use of public facilities.
c. Charges Made by Airport Tenants and Concessionaires. At most airports the provision of fuel, storage, aircraft service, etc., is best accomplished by profit motivated private enterprise. It is the responsibility of the airport owner, in negotiating the privilege to offer th~ services and commodities at the airport, to retain sufficient control over the operation to guarantee that the patrons will be treated fairly. The owner may not have this control if, by contract or otherwise, he/she surrende...""S the right to approve rates, fees, and charges imposed for essential aeronautical services. In this connection, note the discussion of leasing principles in Section 1, Chapter 6. It should be undeiStood that the obligation of the airport owner to ensure availability of services to the public on fair and reasonable terms is limited to aeronautical activities. There is no commitment in a grant agreement or deed with the United States that the prices charged by taxis, limousines, restaurants, motels, and other terminal area nonaeronautical concessions will be controlled.
d. Terms and Conditions Applied to Tenants Offering Aeronautical Ser:3c~. Apart from the Civil Rights Assurances and the a~urances relating to the offering of aeronautical services to the public, the FAA is not normally involved with the establishment of rates and fees to be paid by a tenant or concessionaire to an airport owner. However, in overseeing the airport owner's implementation of the assurance in subparagraph a. above, the FAA sball ensure that
(1) At air carrier airports:
(a) As a tenant, the air carrier shall enjoy the same classification and status as any other tenant
air carrier serving that airport as to rates, fees, charges, rules, regulations, and conditions covering all aeronautical activities at that airport provided the air carrier asswnes obligations similar to those already imposed on the other tenant air cmi.ers.
(b) An air carrier who is willing to sign a contract (signatOry carrier) with the airport and assmne appropriate fmancial obligations may be granted a lower fee schedule. H an air carrier is unwilling or if it is infeasible because of infrequent operations or other reasons to sign such a contract, the air carrier may then be charged the higher nonconttact rates.
(e) In respect to a contmctual commitment, a sponsor may charge different rates to simi1ar users of the airport if the differences can be justified as nondiscriminatory and such charges are substantially compa· rable. These conclusions must be based upon the facts and citcumstances involved in every case.
(d) Differences in values of properties involved and the extent of use made of the common use facilities are factors to be considered. Seldom will each user have properties of the same value nor will their use of the common facilities be the same. How· every the airport in order to justify noncomparable rates must show that the differences are substantial.
(e) All leases with a tenn of 5 years or more should contain an escalation provision for periodic adjustments based on a recognized economic index. Future lessees may expect like treatment in that their leases will have a built-in escaJation provision. This is in accordance with the sponsor assurance " ••• to mate the airport as self-sustaining as possible under the circumstances ..•• "
(I) Each air canier using the airport shall have the right to service itself or to use any FBO tbat is authorized by the airport or pennitted by the airport to serve any air carrier at the airport.
(2) At general aviadon airports:
(a) If one operator rents offiCe and/or hangar space and another builds its own facilities, 1his would provide justification for different rental and fee sttuctures. These two operators would not be considered essentially similar as to rates and charges even though they offer the same services to the public.
(b) If one FBO is in what is considered a prime location and another FBO is in a less advantageous area, there could logically be a diffenmtial in the fees and charges to reflect this advantage of location. This factor would also influence the rental value of the property:
(e) If one FBO is providing primary commcm:ial services (sale of aviation fuel and oil, providing tiedown and aircraft parking facilities. ramp services and some capability for minor aircraft repairs) and another FBO is conducting a flight training program, or aircraft sales, or a specialty such as avionics repair and service, these FBO's may not be considered essentially similar. They may have dissimilar requirements, i.e., space requirements, building construction, or location. Therefore, different rates may be acceptable, although the rates must be equitable.
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 383 passages shown