Order 1050.1F Environmental Impacts: Policies and Procedures
This document is cancelled. Cancelled by 1050.1G. Check the official source before relying on it.
This Order serves as the Federal Aviation Administration’s (FAA) policy and procedures for compliance with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and implementing regulations issued by the Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ). The provisions of this Order and the CEQ Regulations apply to actions directly undertaken by the FAA and to actions undertaken by a non-Federal entity where the FAA has authority to condition a permit, license, or other approval. The requirements in this Order apply to, but are not limited to, the following actions: grants, loans, contracts, leases, construction and installation actions, procedural actions, research activities, rulemaking and regulatory actions, certifications, licensing, permits, plans submitted to the FAA by state and local agencies for approval, and legislation proposed by the FAA. The Order was last revised in 2006.
This Order updates FAA Order 1050.1E to: 1) provide a clear, concise, and up-to-date discussion of the FAA’s requirements for implementing NEPA; and 2) clarify requirements in order to facilitate timely, effective, and efficient environmental reviews of FAA actions, including NextGen improvements.
Rich Swayze Assistant Administrator Policy, International Affairs & Environment
Effective Date:
7/16/15
SUBJ: Environmental Impacts: Policies and Procedures
ORDER
1050.1F
Distribution: Electronically Initiated By: AEE-400
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Chapter 1: General … 1-1
1-1. Purpose of This Order … 1-1
1-2. Audience … 1-1
1-3. Where to Find This Order … 1-1
1-4. How to Cite This Order … 1-1
1-5. Cancellation … 1-1
1-6. Related Publications … 1-1
1-7. The National Environmental Policy Act and the Council on Environmental Quality Regulations … 1-1
1-8. Federal Aviation Administration Policy … 1-2
1-9. Applicability and Scope … 1-3
1-10. Explanation of Policy Changes … 1-3
1-10.1. Appendix A … 1-3
1-10.2. Re-organization of Order … 1-3
1-10.3. Federal Aviation Administration Policy … 1-4
1-10.4. Roles of Lines of Business/Staff Offices … 1-4
1-10.5. Responsibilities … 1-4
1-10.6. Clarification of Policy that Applies to Environmental Assessments … 1-4
1-10.7. Mitigation … 1-4
1-10.8. Environmental Management System … 1-4
1-10.9. Actions Normally Requiring an Environmental Assessment … 1-4
1-10.10. Actions Normally Requiring an Environmental Impact Statement … 1-5
1-10.11. Programmatic National Environmental Policy Act Documents and Tiering … 1-5
1-10.12. NEPA Database. Adds a statement that … 1-5
1-10.13. Environmental Impact Categories … 1-5
1-10.14. Significance Determinations … 1-5
1-10.15. Extraordinary Circumstances … 1-5
1-10.16. Categorical Exclusion Documentation … 1-6
1-10.17. Categorical Exclusion Public Notification … 1-6
1-10.18. Categorical Exclusions … 1-6
1-10.19. Environmental Assessment Format and Process … 1-6
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued)
Page
1-10.20. Use of Errata Sheets … 1-6
1-10.21. Privacy … 1-6
1-10.22. Termination of Environmental Impact Statement Preparation … 1-6
1-10.23. Adoption of Other Agencies’ National Environmental Policy Act Documents .... 1-6
1-10.24. Actions within the United States with Potential Transboundary Impacts … 1-6
1-10.25. Environmental Effects of Major Federal Aviation Administration Actions Abroad … 1-7
1-10.26. Emergency Actions … 1-7
1-10.27. Written Re-evaluations … 1-7
1-10.28. Review and Approval … 1-7
1-10.29. Authority to Change This Order … 1-7
1-10.30. Explanatory Guidance … 1-7
1-10.31. Definitions … 1-7
1-11. -1-50. Reserved … 1-7
Chapter 2: National Environmental Policy Act Planning and Integration … 2-1
2-1. Applicability of National Environmental Policy Act Procedures to Federal Aviation Administration Actions … 2-1
2-1.1. Federal Aviation Administration Actions Subject to National Environmental Policy Act Review … 2-1
2-1.2. Federal Aviation Administration Actions Not Subject to National Environmental Policy Act Review … 2-1
2-2. Responsibilities … 2-2
2-2.1. Responsibilities of the Federal Aviation Administration … 2-2
2-2.2. Responsibilities of Applicants … 2-6
2-2.3. Responsibilities of Contractors … 2-7
2-3. Planning and Integration … 2-7
2-3.1. Early Planning … 2-7
2-3.2. Initial Environmental Review … 2-7
2-3.3. Environmental Management System Approach … 2-9
2-3.4. Reducing Paperwork … 2-9
2-3.5. Reducing Delay … 2-10
ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued)
Page
2-3.6. Mitigation … 2-10
2-4. Coordination … 2-10
2-4.1. Internal Federal Aviation Administration Coordination … 2-10
2-4.2. Lead and Cooperating Agencies … 2-11
2-4.3. Intergovernmental and Interagency Coordination … 2-11
2-4.4. Tribal Consultation … 2-12
2-5. Public Involvement … 2-12
2-5.1. Timing and Extent of Public Involvement … 2-12
2-5.2. Federal Aviation Administration Requirements for Public Involvement … 2-12
2-5.3. Public Meetings, Workshops, and Hearings … 2-14
2-6. Plain Language … 2-14
2-7. Limitations on Actions Involving Real Property Prior to Completing National Environmental Policy Act Review … 2-15
2-8. -2-50. Reserved … 2-15
Chapter 3: Levels of National Environmental Policy Act Review … 3-1
3-1. Three Levels of National Environmental Policy Act Review … 3-1
3-1.1. Categorically Excluded Actions … 3-1
3-1.2. Actions Normally Requiring an Environmental Assessment … 3-1
3-1.3. Actions Normally Requiring an Environmental Impact Statement … 3-3
3-2. Programmatic National Environmental Policy Act Documents and Tiering … 3-3
3-3. FAA NEPA Database … 3-4
3-4. -3-50. Reserved … 3-4
Chapter 4: Impact Categories, Significance, and Mitigation … 4-1
4-1. Environmental Impact Categories … 4-1
4-2. Consideration of Impacts … 4-1
4-3. Significance and Significance Thresholds … 4-3
4-3.1. General … 4-3
4-3.2. Context and Intensity … 4-3
4-3.3. Significance Thresholds … 4-3
4-4. Mitigation … 4-14
iii
TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued)
Page
4-5. -4-50. Reserved … 4-15
Chapter 5: Categorical Exclusions … 5-1
5-1. General … 5-1
5-2. Extraordinary Circumstances … 5-1
5-3. Categorical Exclusion Documentation … 5-3
5-4. Public Notification … 5-4
5-5. Other Environmental Requirements … 5-4
5-6. The Federal Aviation Administration’s Categorical Exclusions … 5-4
5-6.1. Categorical Exclusions for Administrative/General Actions … 5-5
5-6.2. Categorical Exclusions for Certification Actions … 5-7
5-6.3. Categorical Exclusions for Equipment and Instrumentation … 5-8
5-6.4. Categorical Exclusions for Facility Siting, Construction, and Maintenance … 5-10
5-6.5. Categorical Exclusions for Procedural Actions … 5-14
5-6.6. Categorical Exclusions for Regulatory Actions … 5-16
5-7. -5-50. Reserved … 5-17
Chapter 6: Environmental Assessments and Findings of No Significant Impact … 6-1
6-1. General … 6-1
6-2. Preparing Environmental Assessments … 6-2
6-2.1. Environmental Assessment Format … 6-2
6-2.2. Environmental Assessment Process … 6-3
6-2.3. Mitigation Considerations for Environmental Assessments … 6-6
6-3. Finding of No Significant Impact … 6-7
6-4. Decision Documents for Findings of No Significant Impact … 6-9
6-5. -6-50. Reserved … 6-9
Chapter 7: Environmental Impact Statements and Records of Decision … 7-1
7-1. Preparation of Environmental Impact Statements … 7-1
7-1.1. Environmental Impact Statement Format … 7-2
7-1.2. Environmental Impact Statement Process … 7-6
7-1.3. Decision Not to Prepare an Environmental Impact Statement … 7-12
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued)
Page
7-2. Environmental Impact Statement Record of Decision … 7-12
7-2.1. Record of Decision Process … 7-12
7-2.2. Record of Decision Content … 7-13
7-2.3. Environmental Commitments … 7-14
7-3. -7-50. Reserved … 7-14
Chapter 8: Federal Aviation Administration Actions Subject to Special Procedures … 8-1
8-1. Commenting on Other Agencies’ National Environmental Policy Act Documents … 8-1
8-2. Adoption of Other Agencies’ National Environmental Policy Act Documents … 8-2
8-3. Rulemaking … 8-3
8-4. Legislative Proposals … 8-4
8-5. Actions within the United States with Potential Transboundary Impacts … 8-4
8-6. Effects of Major Federal Aviation Administration Actions Abroad … 8-4
8-7. Emergency Actions … 8-7
8-8. Council on Environmental Quality Referrals … 8-8
8-9. -8-50. Reserved … 8-8
Chapter 9: Time Limits, Written Re-Evaluations, and Supplemental National Environmental Policy Act Documents … 9-1
9-1. Time Limits … 9-1
9-2. Written Re-evaluations … 9-1
9-3. Supplemental Environmental Assessments and Environmental Impact Statements … 9-3
9-4. -9-50. Reserved … 9-3
Chapter 10: Review and Approval of National Environmental Policy Act Documents … 10-1
10-1. General … 10-1
10-2. Review and Approval of Environmental Assessments, Findings of No Significant Impact, and Findings of No Significant Impact/Records of Decision … 10-1
10-3. Review and Approval of Draft Environmental Impact Statements … 10-2
10-4. Review and Approval of Final Environmental Impact Statements … 10-2
10-5. Review and Approval of Supplemental Environmental Impact Statements … 10-3
10-6. Review and Approval of Records of Decision … 10-3
v
TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued)
Page
10-7. -10-50. Reserved … 10-4
Chapter 11: Administrative Information … 11-1
11-1. Distribution … 11-1
11-2. Authority to Change This Order … 11-1
11-3. Process for Changing This Order … 11-1
11-4. Explanatory Guidance … 11-2
11-5. Definitions … 11-2
11-6. -11-50. Reserved … 11-4
Appendix A. Acronym List … 1
Appendix B. Federal Aviation Administration Requirements for Assessing Impacts Related to Noise and Noise-Compatible Land Use and Section 4(f) of the Department of Transportation Act (49 U.S.C. § 303) … 1
Appendix C. Federal Aviation Administration Guidance on Third Party Contracting for Environmental Impact Statement Preparation … 1
Appendix D. National Environmental Policy Act Process Flowcharts … 1
vi
1-7.
Chapter 1: General
1-1. Purpose of This Order. This Order provides the Federal Aviation Administration’s (FAA) policies and procedures to ensure agency compliance with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) (42 United States Code [U.S.C.] §§ 4321-4335), the requirements set forth in the Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ), Title 40, Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), parts 1500-1508, Regulations for Implementing the Procedural Provisions of the National Environmental Policy Act (CEQ Regulations), and Department of Transportation (DOT) Order 5610.1C, Procedures for Considering Environmental Impacts. The CEQ Regulations establish procedures for complying with NEPA. In accordance with 40 CFR § 1507.3 of the CEQ Regulations, this Order contains the FAA’s implementing procedures, which supplement those regulations.
1-2. Audience. All FAA employees who approve, manage, or otherwise participate in actions requiring FAA compliance with NEPA, the CEQ Regulations, or DOT Order 5610.1C, and all FAA contractors and applicants involved in such actions.
1-3. Where to Find This Order. This Order can be found on the FAA’s website at: https://employees.faa.gov/tools_resources/orders_notices/. This Order is available to the public at http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/orders_notices/ by clicking on the topic “Environment.”
1-4. How to Cite This Order. This Order should be cited as FAA Order 1050.1F. The body of the Order is organized by paragraphs. If citing a particular paragraph, the format “FAA Order 1050.1F, Paragraph ___” should be used. For example, if referencing the definition for Noise Sensitive Area, the proper citation is “FAA Order 1050.1F, Paragraph 11-5.b.(10).”
1-5. Cancellation. FAA Order 1050.1E, Environmental Impacts: Policies and Procedures, dated June 8, 2004 (as updated by Change 1, dated March 20, 2006), is cancelled.
1-6. Related Publications. The latest version of referenced publications should be used in conjunction with this order. The FAA Order 1050.1F Desk Reference (1050.1F Desk Reference) provides details on current guidance and updated technical information. This includes information about permits, licenses, consultations, and other forms of approval or review; up-todate details on technical information such as FAA-approved tools for analyzing noise and air emissions; overviews of special purpose laws and requirements; and specific responsibilities and guidance for gathering data, assessing impacts, consulting other agencies, and involving the public. The 1050.1F Desk Reference can be found on the FAA’s website at: http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/orders_notices/ by clicking on the topic, “Environment.”
1-7. The National Environmental Policy Act and the Council on Environmental Quality Regulations. NEPA and the CEQ Regulations establish a broad national policy to protect and enhance the quality of the human environment, and require Federal agencies to develop programs and measures to meet national environmental goals. Section 102(2) of NEPA provides specific direction to Federal agencies, sometimes called “action-forcing” provisions (see 40 CFR §§ 1500.1(a), 1500.3, and 1507, CEQ Regulations) on how to implement the goals of NEPA. The major provisions include the requirement to use a systematic, interdisciplinary approach and develop implementing methods and procedures. Section 102(2)(C) requires detailed analysis in the form of Environmental Impact Statements (EISs) for proposed major Federal actions
1-8. Federal Aviation Administration Policy.
significantly affecting the quality of the human environment. The CEQ Regulations additionally provide for Environmental Assessments (EAs) to assist agencies in determining whether potential environmental impacts are significant and Categorical Exclusions (CATEXs), which are categories of actions that the FAA has determined, based on previous experience, do not have significant individual or cumulative impact on the quality of the human environment except in extraordinary circumstances. The presence of extraordinary circumstances would preclude the use of a CATEX and would merit additional review in an EA or EIS. In addition to NEPA and the CEQ Regulations, other laws, regulations, and Executive Orders address aspects of the environment and require compliance by Federal agencies. The CEQ Regulations direct Federal agencies to list all Federal permits, licenses, and other approvals that must be obtained in implementing the proposed action, and, to the fullest extent possible, integrate compliance with such requirements with the NEPA process.
This Order implements the mandate of NEPA, as defined and discussed in the CEQ Regulations, within the programs of the FAA. The Order is not a substitute for the CEQ Regulations; rather, it supplements the CEQ Regulations for FAA programs. All FAA Lines of Business and Staff Offices (LOB/SOs) must comply with the CEQ Regulations as further implemented and supplemented by this Order.
1-8. Federal Aviation Administration Policy. The FAA’s primary mission is to provide the safest, most efficient aerospace system in the world. NEPA compliance and other environmental responsibilities are integral components of that mission. The FAA is responsible for complying with the procedures and policies of NEPA and other environmental laws, regulations, and orders applicable to FAA actions. The FAA decision-making process must consider and disclose the potential impacts of a proposed action and its alternatives on the quality of the human environment. In meeting its NEPA obligations, the FAA should seek to achieve the policy objectives of 40 CFR § 1500.2 to the fullest extent possible. The FAA must integrate NEPA and other environmental reviews and consultations into agency planning processes as early as possible. Funding requirements must be justified and requested in accordance with existing budgetary and fiscal policies. Each FAA LOB/SO is responsible for seeking sufficient funds through the budget process to implement the provisions of this Order.
The Next Generation Air Transportation System (NextGen) involves operational and infrastructure improvements that require the FAA’s environmental review in accordance with NEPA. The FAA’s goal is to ensure timely, effective, and efficient environmental reviews of proposed NextGen improvements, consistent with Executive Order 13604, Improving Performance of Federal Permitting and Review of Infrastructure Projects, 77 Federal Register 18887 (March 28, 2012). The FAA is using an environmental management system (EMS) approach to improve the integration of environmental performance into the planning, decisionmaking, and operation of NextGen in furtherance of the goal of environmental protection that allows sustained aviation growth.
It is FAA policy to ensure the integrity of environmental reviews while emphasizing and implementing instructions in 40 CFR §§ 1500.4 and 1500.5 of the CEQ Regulations to reduce excessive paperwork and environmental process delays. The FAA implements an expedited and coordinated environmental review process for aviation safety projects, aviation security projects, and airport capacity projects at congested airports in accordance with Title III of Vision 100- Century of Aviation Reauthorization Act, also cited as the Aviation Streamlining Approval Process Act of 2003, 49 U.S.C. §§ 47171-47175. The FAA has also established expedited
1-10.2. Re-organization of Order.
environmental review procedures and processes for area navigation (RNAV) and required navigation performance (RNP) that offer efficiency improvements. In addition, Section 213 of the FAA Modernization and Reform Act of 2012, Public Law 112-95, established two legislative CATEXs that are included in this Order.
For projects subject to expedited environmental review, the FAA must comply with this Order, maintain the integrity of the environmental process, and respect the environmental responsibilities of other agencies. Expedited environmental reviews will be used to give review priority to certain projects, manage timelines during the review process, improve and expedite interagency coordination, reduce undue delays, and emphasize accountability. Certain airport capacity projects, aviation safety projects, and aviation security projects may be subject to special designation and treatment in accordance with provisions of the Aviation Streamlining Approval Process Act. Airport infrastructure projects may also be selected for review under Executive Order 13274, Environmental Stewardship and Transportation Infrastructure Project Reviews, 67 Federal Register 59449 (September 23, 2002).
In addition, Executive Order 13604, Improving Performance of Federal Permitting and Review of Infrastructure Projects, 77 Federal Register 18887 (March 28, 2012) calls for the execution of Federal permitting and review processes, including environmental review processes, with maximum efficiency and effectiveness. The Implementation Plan for the Presidential Memorandum on Modernizing Infrastructure Permitting provides strategies for agencies to improve the Federal government’s role in permitting and review processes, including improved coordination and project planning, and increased use of programmatic approaches and information technology tools. It is the responsibility of the FAA office that has the primary responsibility for a proposed action and that is leading the environmental review to ensure that applicable special review provisions are applied effectively.
1-9. Applicability and Scope. The provisions of this Order and the CEQ Regulations apply to actions directly undertaken by the FAA and to actions undertaken by a non-Federal entity where the FAA has authority to condition a permit, license or approval. The requirements in this Order apply, but are not limited, to the following actions: grants, loans, contracts, leases, construction and installation actions, procedural actions, research activities, rulemaking and regulatory actions, certifications, licensing, permits, plans submitted to the FAA by state or local agencies for approval, and legislation proposed by the FAA. Exceptions to these requirements are listed in Paragraph 2-1.2. The procedures in this Order apply to the extent practicable to ongoing activities and environmental documents begun before the effective date. However, procedures contained in this Order should not apply to ongoing environmental reviews where substantial revisions to ongoing environmental documents would be required. This Order does not apply to decisions made and final environmental documents issued prior to the effective date of this Order.
1-10. Explanation of Policy Changes. This paragraph briefly highlights significant changes from FAA Order 1050.1E.
1-10.1. Appendix A. Moves the information in Appendix A of FAA Order 1050.1E, Analysis of Environmental Impact Categories, to the 1050.1F Desk Reference, which can be easily updated, as necessary.
1-10.2. Re-organization of Order. Restructures the Order to make environmental compliance more efficient and effective, and to focus the discussion, reduce redundancies,
Actions normally requiring an EA that were substantively amended are…
and provide FAA NEPA practitioners with a more user-friendly and clear document. Revises the numbering and structure to more closely follow FAA Order 1320.1, FAA Directives Management. Includes systematic editorial changes to ensure consistency with the FAA’s plain language guidelines as established in FAA Order 1000.36, FAA Writing Standards.
1-10.3. Federal Aviation Administration Policy. Expands and updates the FAA’s policy statement to include NextGen. The updated policy also includes an EMS approach to improve the integration of environmental performance into the planning, decision-making, and operation of NextGen in furtherance of the goal of environmental protection that allows sustained aviation growth. Finally, the policy reflects legislative provisions in FAA reauthorization to expedite the environmental review process for certain air traffic procedures and project delivery improvement.
1-10.4. Roles of Lines of Business/Staff Offices. Updates the titles and roles of FAA LOB/SOs to reflect changes to the FAA’s organizational structure and initiatives since publication of FAA Order 1050.1E (see Paragraph 2-2.1.b).
1-10.5. Responsibilities. Clarifies the FAA’s responsibilities (see Paragraph 2-2.1) and the role of applicants and contractors in the FAA’s NEPA process (see Paragraphs 2-2.2 and 2- 2.3). Includes a section on the state’s role in the State Block Grant Program (see Paragraph 2-2.1e).
1-10.6. Clarification of Policy that Applies to Environmental Assessments. Explains in more detail than FAA Order 1050.1E Paragraphs 405 d, e, and f the differences between EAs and EISs and the requirement to consider connected actions in EAs.
1-10.7. Mitigation. Reorganizes and clarifies provisions relating to mitigation (see Paragraphs 2-3.6, 4-4, 6-2.3, and 7-1.1.h). Updates the FAA’s policy regarding mitigation to be consistent with CEQ’s Guidance on Appropriate use of Mitigation and Monitoring and Clarifying the Appropriate use of Mitigated Findings of No Significant Impact, 76 Federal Register 3843 (January 21, 2011). Clarifies which projects warrant environmental monitoring and the type and extent of monitoring.
1-10.8. Environmental Management System. Adds a discussion of EMS to highlight the importance of EMS and its application to all FAA programs, including NextGen (see Paragraph 2-3.3).
1-10.9. Actions Normally Requiring an Environmental Assessment. Adds new and revises existing actions normally requiring an EA to more clearly and accurately describe those FAA actions which normally require preparation of an EA. The new actions normally requiring an EA (see Paragraphs 3-1.2.b(13) and (16)) are:
(13) Establishment or modification of an Instrument Flight Rules Military Training Route (IR MTRs).
(16) Formal and informal runway use programs that may significantly increase noise over noise sensitive areas.
Actions normally requiring an EA that were substantively amended are included in Paragraphs 3-1.2.b(2), (10)-(12), and (14)-(15). FAA Order 1050.1E Paragraph 401o has been omitted from FAA Order 1050.1F.
1-10.15. Extraordinary Circumstances.
1-10.10. Actions Normally Requiring an Environmental Impact Statement. Modifies and re-organizes the text in Paragraph 501 of FAA Order 1050.1E and adds specific examples of actions normally requiring an EIS (see Paragraph 3-1.3.b).
1-10.11. Programmatic National Environmental Policy Act Documents and Tiering. Combines the discussion of programmatic NEPA documents and tiering and revises the text to align with CEQ Regulations and guidance (see Paragraph 3-2).
1-10.12. NEPA Database. Adds a statement that FAA LOB/SOs should whenever possible, use the FAA NEPA Database to track projects and make final documents available to others in the FAA (see Paragraph 3-3).
1-10.13. Environmental Impact Categories. Adds a new Paragraph 4-1 to discuss the FAA’s Environmental Impact Categories, previously discussed in Appendix A of FAA Order 1050.1E and now found in the accompanying 1050.1F Desk Reference. Adds Climate to the list of impact categories that must be considered in FAA NEPA documents. Combines Noise and Noise-Compatible Land Use as it relates to noise compatibility into a single impact category and creates a separate category for non-noise land use issues. Renames Fish, Wildlife, and Plants as Biological Resources and renames Light Emissions and Visual Impacts as Visual Effects. Renames Water Quality as Water Resources, which includes Wetlands, Floodplains, Surface Waters, Groundwater, and Wild and Scenic Rivers under the new category. Removes construction impacts and secondary impacts as separate impact categories; instead, they are to be analyzed within each applicable environmental impact category.
1-10.14. Significance Determinations. Provides an exhibit in Paragraph 4-3.3 that summarizes the FAA’s Significance Thresholds formerly described under individual environmental impact categories in Appendix A of FAA Order 1050.1E. This table also includes Factors to Consider in making determinations of significant impacts. Adds “Contaminate a public drinking water supply such that public health may be adversely affected” as a threshold under Surface Waters, and “Contaminate an aquifer used for public water supply such that public health may be adversely affected” as a new threshold under Groundwater (see Exhibit 4-1, Significance Determination for FAA Actions). The FAA has also added clarifying language to the Air Quality significance threshold to include instances where the increase in frequency or severity of an existing violation would be significant.
1-10.15. Extraordinary Circumstances. Adds national marine sanctuaries and wilderness areas to the list of resources that must be considered in evaluating actions for extraordinary circumstances that would preclude the use of a CATEX for a proposed action. Makes other text revisions, including modifying: (1) the description of wild and scenic rivers to be consistent with CEQ’s August 10, 1980, memorandum, Interagency Consultation to Avoid or Mitigate Adverse Effects on Rivers in the Nationwide Inventory; and (2) the description of actions likely to cause environmental contamination by hazardous materials, or likely to disturb an existing hazardous material contamination site such that new environmental contamination risks are created.
1-10.23. Adoption of Other Agencies’ National Environmental Policy Act…
1-10.16. Categorical Exclusion Documentation. Updates the FAA’s policy regarding CATEX documentation to be consistent with CEQ’s Guidance on Establishing, Applying, and Revising Categorical Exclusions under the National Environmental Policy Act, 75 Federal Register 75628 (December 6, 2010) (see Paragraph 5-3). These updates include: clarifying when and what level of documentation is needed in the application of a CATEX and explaining what to include in CATEX documentation. Adds discussion of decision documents in connection with CATEXs (known as CATEX/Records of Decision [RODs]), which are not commonly used but may be advisable in unique circumstances.
1-10.17. Categorical Exclusion Public Notification. Adds discussion of public notification of CATEX use, consistent with CEQ’s Guidance on Establishing, Applying, and Revising Categorical Exclusions under the National Environmental Policy Act, 75 Federal Register 75628 (December 6, 2010) (see Paragraph 5-4).
1-10.18. Categorical Exclusions. Adds new CATEXs and revises existing CATEXs to accommodate actions that do not significantly affect the environment. The new CATEXs are in Paragraphs 5-6.3i, 5-6.4bb, 5-6.4cc, 5-6.4dd, 5-6.4ee, 5-6.4ff, and 5-6.5f. In addition, two legislative CATEXs, consistent with Section 213(c) of the FAA Modernization and Reform Act of 2012, are added (see Paragraphs 5-6.5q and 5-6.5r). CATEXs that are substantively amended are in Paragraphs 5-6.4e (formerly 310e), 5-6.4i (formerly 310i), 5-6.4u (formerly 310u), and 5-6.5l (formerly 311l).
1-10.19. Environmental Assessment Format and Process. Revises the discussion of EA format and process to make the process more efficient and effective, explain each element, and clarify that an EA does not have to be as detailed as an EIS (see Paragraph 6-2). Adds cross-references to the EIS section, and makes additional minor revisions.
1-10.20. Use of Errata Sheets. The Order clarifies when errata sheets may be used in lieu of a final EA (see Paragraph 6-2.2.i) and final EIS (see Paragraph 7-1.2.f).
1-10.21. Privacy. Requires language in notices soliciting public comment on draft EAs and draft EISs stating that personal information provided by commenters (e.g., addresses, phone numbers, and email addresses) may be made publicly available (see Paragraphs 6-2.2.g and 7-1.2.d(1)(a)).
1-10.22. Termination of Environmental Impact Statement Preparation. Adds a new paragraph to explain the conditions under which the FAA may choose to terminate preparation of an EIS and clarifies what steps the FAA must take when this situation occurs (see Paragraph 7-1.3).
1-10.23. Adoption of Other Agencies’ National Environmental Policy Act Documents. Clarifies and expands on requirements relating to FAA adoption of other agencies’ NEPA documents (see Paragraph 8-2). Adds requirements for legal sufficiency review of adopted documents to clarify when this review is required (see Paragraph 8-2.c). Also adds a discussion of recirculation requirements to highlight that in some circumstances adopted documents must be recirculated (see Paragraph 8-2.e).
1-10.24. Actions within the United States with Potential Transboundary Impacts. Adds discussion of FAA policy with respect to consideration of transboundary impacts resulting from FAA actions (see Paragraph 8-5).
1-10.25. Environmental Effects of Major Federal Aviation Administration Actions Abroad. Updates the discussion of international actions to include how to coordinate communication with foreign governments within the FAA to clarify the correct practice. (See Paragraph 8-6).
1-11. -1-50. Reserved.
1-10.26. Emergency Actions. Clarifies an alternative process to consider environmental impacts before taking emergency actions necessary to protect the lives and safety of the public. These alternative arrangements are limited to actions necessary to control the immediate impacts of an emergency. Adds text to provide for emergency procedures when a CATEX or an EA would be the appropriate level of NEPA review (see Paragraph 8-7). FAA Order 1050.1E only addressed emergency procedures for EISs.
1-10.27. Written Re-evaluations. Modifies and clarifies requirements relating to written re-evaluations. Adds a statement to explain that written re-evaluations may be prepared even when they are not required. Adds discussion of decision documents in connection with written re-evaluations (i.e., a “WR/ROD”). (See Paragraph 9-2)
1-10.28. Review and Approval. Consolidates and clarifies provisions relating to review, approval, and signature authority for FAA NEPA documents (see Chapter 10).
1-10.29. Authority to Change This Order. Revises text in Paragraph 11-2 to clarify the authority of various parties and to be consistent with other FAA Orders.
1-10.30. Explanatory Guidance. Clarifies provisions relating to explanatory guidance (see Paragraph 11-4).
1-10.31. Definitions. Adds definitions of “extraordinary circumstances,” “NEPA lead,” “special purpose laws and requirements,” and “traditional cultural properties.” Deletes definition of “Environmental Due Diligence Audit” because this term is no longer used in FAA Order 1050.1F. Revises the definitions of “environmental studies,” “approving official,” and “decisionmaker” to reflect current practice. Revises the definition of “human environment” to align with the CEQ Regulations. Changes “launch facility” to “commercial space launch site” to be consistent with 14 CFR part 420. Revises the definition of “noise sensitive area” to include a reference to Table 1 of 14 CFR part 150 rather than Appendix A of FAA Order 1050.1E, to provide context in light of the removal of Appendix A from this Order. “Major federal action” was added to the list of definitions as a cross reference to the CEQ Regulations. (See Paragraph 11-5.)
1-11. -1-50. Reserved.
Chapter 2: National Environmental Policy Act Planning and Integration
2-1. Applicability of National Environmental Policy Act Procedures to Federal Aviation Administration Actions.
2-1.1. Federal Aviation Administration Actions Subject to National Environmental Policy Act Review. Proposed actions and decisions by FAA officials are subject to NEPA review, except as provided in Paragraph 2-1.2 below. Specific FAA actions subject to NEPA review can include, but are not limited to, grants, loans, contracts, leases, construction and installation actions, procedural actions, research activities, rulemaking and regulatory actions, certifications, licensing, permits, plans submitted to the FAA that require the FAA’s approval, and legislation proposed by the FAA. Although emergency actions are subject to NEPA review, special procedures may apply (see Paragraph 8-7). The FAA will not approve a proposed action until any required NEPA review has been completed.
2-1.2. Federal Aviation Administration Actions Not Subject to National… › (3) Designation of alert areas and warning areas under FAA Order…
2-1.2. Federal Aviation Administration Actions Not Subject to National Environmental Policy Act Review.
a. General. Actions are not subject to NEPA review if applicable Federal law expressly prohibits or makes compliance with NEPA impossible.
b. Advisory Actions. Some Federal actions are of an advisory nature. Actions of this type are not considered major Federal actions under NEPA, and NEPA review is therefore not required. If it is known or anticipated that some subsequent Federal action would be subject to NEPA, the FAA must so indicate in the advisory action. Examples of advisory actions include:
(1) Determinations under 14 CFR part 77, Safe, Efficient Use, and Preservation of the Navigable Airspace;
(2) Determinations under 14 CFR part 157, Notice of Construction, Alteration, Activation, and Deactivation of Airports, which applies to civil or joint-use airports, helipads, and heliports; and
(3) Designation of alert areas and warning areas under FAA Order 7400.2, Procedures for Handling Airspace Matters.
c. Judicial or Administrative Civil Enforcement Actions. These actions do not require NEPA analysis (i.e., 14 CFR part 13, Investigative and Enforcement Procedures, and other administrative actions pursuant to the following: 14 CFR part 14, Rules Implementing the Equal Access to Justice Act of 1980; 14 CFR part 15, Administrative Claims Under Federal Tort Claims Act; 14 CFR part 16, Rules of Practice for Federally- Assisted Airport Enforcement Proceedings; and 14 CFR part 17, Procedures for Protests and Contracts Disputes).
d. Administrative Actions. NEPA review is not required for the promulgation of this Order or similar orders issued by the FAA Administrator or organizational elements as authorized by the FAA Administrator that provide supplemental instructions for agency compliance with NEPA procedures. NEPA review is also not required for administrative actions associated with a NEPA review (e.g., contractor selection).
(2) Each FAA Associate and Assistant Administrator, the Chief Counsel,… › (a) The Assistant Administrator for Civil Rights (ACR) is responsible…
2-2. Responsibilities.
2-2.1. Responsibilities of the Federal Aviation Administration.
a. General FAA Responsibilities:
(1) Ensuring compliance with NEPA, the CEQ Regulations, this Order, and other environmental requirements;
(2) Requesting appropriate environmental information and documents (including EAs, where appropriate) from applicants and providing guidance to applicants on providing such information;
(3) Independently and objectively evaluating applicant-submitted information and EAs and taking responsibility for content and adequacy of any such information or documents used by the FAA for compliance with NEPA or other environmental requirements;
(4) Selecting contractors to prepare environmental documents, guiding their work, and taking responsibility for contractor-prepared documents used by the FAA for compliance with NEPA or other environmental requirements; and
(5) Making CATEX determinations, approving EAs and EISs, and issuing Finding of No Significant Impact (FONSIs) and RODs.
b. Roles of Lines of Business/Staff Offices (LOB/SOs). The Chief Operating Officer and Assistant or Associate Administrators within the various FAA organizations must ensure their respective offices, regions, service areas, and centers comply with this Order. Responsibilities may be delegated in accordance with appropriate FAA orders, such as FAA Order 1100.154, Delegations of Authority.
(1) The FAA Administrator is responsible for managing the FAA with the assistance of the Deputy Administrator. Ultimately, the FAA Administrator is responsible for all NEPA compliance within the FAA.
(2) Each FAA Associate and Assistant Administrator, the Chief Counsel, and the Chief Operating Officer reports to the FAA Administrator and has specific responsibilities for complying with the NEPA process within their LOB/SO. These responsibilities are outlined below.
(a) The Assistant Administrator for Civil Rights (ACR) is responsible for determining whether projects receiving Federal financial assistance from the FAA comply with the appropriate civil rights laws, regulations, and Executive Orders, including those requirements under Executive Order 12898, Federal Actions to Address Environmental Justice in Minority Populations and Low-Income Populations, 59 Federal Register 7629 (February 16, 1994); the accompanying Presidential Memorandum, Environmental Justice for Minority Populations (February 11, 1994) (available at http://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice/resources/policy/index.html) concerning environmental justice; the Memorandum of Understanding on Environmental Justice and Executive Order 12898 (August 4, 2011), the revised Department of Transportation Environmental Justice Strategy, 77 Federal Register 18879 (March 28, 2012), and DOT Order 5610.2(a), 77 Federal Register
(2) Each FAA Associate and Assistant Administrator, the Chief Counsel,… › (e) The Assistant Administrator for Policy, International Affairs, and…
27534 (May 10, 2012), on environmental justice in the context of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended, 42 U.S.C. §§ 2000d-2000d-7.
(b) The Office of the Chief Counsel (AGC) consists of legal staff at FAA Headquarters, FAA regions, and the Mike Monroney Aeronautical Center and William J. Hughes Technical Center (collectively referred to as “Center”). AGC is responsible for providing legal advice on NEPA compliance and legal requirements. AGC reviews actions that involve determinations under Section 4(f), 49 U.S.C. § 303; counsels and assists headquarters staff and regional offices in accomplishing FAA environmental review; and advises on the legal sufficiency of environmental documents. Regional Counsel and Center Counsel are responsible for providing legal counsel, assistance, and review in the conduct of regional actions and environmental activities and advising on the legal sufficiency of regional and Center environmental documents.
(c) The Assistant Administrator for Human Resource Management (AHR) is responsible for supporting the training needs associated with this order by leveraging the resources in the Office of Talent Development (AHD). AHD will work collaboratively with the Office of Environment and Energy (AEE) to promote the training and education needed to reinforce the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA). AHD will work in partnership with the Mike Monroney Aeronautical Center (MMAC) and the LOB/SO learning professionals to deliver designated content.
(d) The Assistant Administrator for NextGen (ANG) provides leadership in planning and developing the Next Generation Air Transportation System (NextGen) and coordinates NextGen initiatives, programs, and policy development across the various FAA LOB/SOs.
(e) The Assistant Administrator for Policy, International Affairs, and Environment (APL) is responsible for providing policy guidance to the agency on implementing a wide range of environmental laws and regulations. Within APL, AEE provides policy oversight on FAA environmental actions; issues regulations for aircraft noise and emissions under 14 CFR parts 34 and 36; provides assistance in developing guidelines and procedures for FAA program areas; serves as the designated FAA NEPA liaison in accordance with 40 CFR § 1507.2, CEQ Regulations, “to be responsible for overall review of agency NEPA compliance” and Federal Preservation Officer in accordance with Section 110 of the National Historic Preservation Act, 54 U.S.C. §§ 306101(a) and 3061021; interprets policies established in this Order; provides assistance with computerized environmental tools, such as the Aviation Environmental Design Tool (AEDT) for aircraft noise and air quality; and provides advice to and supplements NEPA training programs in cooperation with AHT and other applicable organizational elements.
1 The National Historic Preservation Act was previously codified at 16 U.S.C. § 470 et seq.
(f) The Assistant Administrator for Office of Finance and Management (AFN) is responsible for considering the environmental impacts of actions arising out of Acquisition Management Operations.
(2) Each FAA Associate and Assistant Administrator, the Chief Counsel,… › (k) The Associate Administrator for Aviation Safety (AVS) is…
(g) The Associate Administrator for Airports (ARP) is responsible for considering the environmental impacts of proposed FAA approvals of Airport Layout Plan (ALP) modifications (regardless of funding sources), FAA-funded airport actions, and ensuring compliance with NEPA requirements and other Federal environmental laws, regulations, and orders. Airports personnel must comply with the NEPA requirements in this Order, supplemented by the current version of FAA Order 5050.4, National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) Implementing Instructions for Airport Projects. ARP’s Office of Airport Planning and Programming, APP-400, provides guidance to Regional and District Airports personnel, airport sponsors, and environmental consultants concerning Federal, Departmental, and agency environmental policy regarding airport development actions.
(h) The Assistant Administrator for Security and Hazardous Materials (ASH) is responsible for considering the environmental impacts for all actions arising out of ASH initiatives that require compliance with NEPA and Federal environmental laws, regulations, and orders. ASH initiatives involve ensuring and promoting aviation safety in support of national security and the national aerospace system.
(i) The Associate Administrator for Commercial Space Transportation (AST) is responsible for considering the environmental impacts for all actions arising out of AST initiatives that require compliance with NEPA and other Federal environmental laws, regulations, and orders. Such initiatives include issuing licenses for the operation of commercial launch sites and licenses and experimental permits for the launch and reentry of commercial space launch vehicles.
(j) The Chief Operating Officer for Air Traffic Organization (ATO) is responsible for evaluating the environmental impacts for all actions arising out of ATO responsibilities that require compliance with NEPA and all other relevant Federal environmental laws, regulations, and orders, including changes in airspace and air traffic control procedures and FAA-funded construction and operation of National Airspace System (NAS) facilities.
(k) The Associate Administrator for Aviation Safety (AVS) is responsible for considering the environmental impacts of all actions arising out of AVS initiatives that require compliance with NEPA and other Federal environmental laws, regulations, and orders. AVS initiatives include the certification, production approval, and continued airworthiness of aircraft; and certification of pilots, mechanics, and others in safety-related positions.
c. Actions Undertaken by the FAA. The FAA may prepare environmental documentation in-house (i.e., using agency personnel and resources) or use a contractor in accordance with Paragraph 2-2.1.f below. For projects directly undertaken by the FAA and requiring an EA or EIS, the EA or EIS must be prepared at the feasibility analysis (go/no-go) stage and may be supplemented at a later stage.
d. FAA Approval of Applicant Actions. When an applicant requests FAA approval for an action, the FAA may request that the applicant submit information and analysis to support the required NEPA review. The FAA must independently evaluate any information or analysis submitted by an applicant before using it to support a NEPA review. The FAA may also request that an applicant prepare an EA. If an applicant prepares an EA, the FAA must ensure that the applicant complies with all requirements set forth in Paragraph 2-2.2, Responsibilities of Applicants. The FAA must advise and assist the applicant during preparation of the EA, and must independently evaluate and take responsibility for the EA to ensure that: (1) the applicant’s potential conflict of interest does not impair the objectivity of the document; and (2) the EA meets the requirements of this Order.
The FAA may ask the applicant to correct any deficiencies in information, analysis, or an EA submitted by the applicant if the FAA is not satisfied with the original submittal or subsequent revisions. In such cases, the responsible FAA official will defer completion of the environmental review pending satisfactory correction of all identified deficiencies. Based on final review of an applicant submitted EA, the FAA determines whether to issue a FONSI or prepare an EIS. See Paragraph 6-2.1.a for a discussion on when an EA becomes a Federal document.
When an EIS is required, the FAA must prepare the EIS or select the contractor that will assist the FAA in preparing the EIS (see 40 CFR § 1506.5(c), CEQ Regulations). If “third-party contracting” is used to prepare an EIS, the FAA must select and supervise the contractor (see Paragraph 2-2.3). Third-party contracting refers to the preparation of an EIS by a contractor selected by the FAA and under contract to, and paid for by, an applicant (see Appendix C).2 The FAA must take responsibility for contractor-prepared documents used by the FAA and determine that they are in compliance with this Order.
e. State Block Grant Program Responsibilities for FAA Connected Actions. The State Block Grant Program participating states must ensure that they coordinate and obtain approval from the appropriate LOB/SO for any proposed action that involves aspects that are not authorized under the State Block Grant Program. Please see FAA Order 5050.4 for more information.
f. Use of Contractors.
(1) General. When contractors assist the FAA in preparing EAs or EISs, or when contractors directly assist applicants in preparing EAs, the FAA must ensure that the contractor complies with the provisions of this Order. When an EIS is required, the FAA must select the contractor that will assist the FAA in preparing the EIS (see 40 CFR § 1506.5(c), CEQ Regulations). If “third-party contracting” is used to prepare an EIS, the FAA must select and supervise the contractor (see Paragraph 2-2.3).
2 The FAA may use third-party contracting for an EA when there is a high potential that the action may require an EIS.
2-2.2. Responsibilities of Applicants.
(2) Conflict of Interest. In some circumstances, the FAA may choose to contract consulting services to prepare environmental documents for its direct Federal actions. Under FAA Acquisition Management System policy, procurements may not be awarded to contractors who have unacceptable actual or potential organizational conflicts of interest. Organizational conflicts of interest result when, because of activities or relationships with other persons, a person is unable or potentially unable to render impartial assistance to the agency, or the person’s objectivity in performing the contract work is or might be impaired, or the person has an unfair competitive advantage (the term “person” includes any legal entity including a partnership, corporation, limited liability company, or association). For example, a contractor selected to prepare an EA or EIS would have a potential conflict of interest if also selected to conduct final design work when the final design work is part of the construction contract.
"Final design work" means a bid-ready, site-specific design package containing drawings, design data handbook, and construction cost estimate. The FAA may select a contractor to prepare an EA or EIS and preliminary design work provided the design work is conceptual in nature. "Preliminary design work" means design to local criteria based on a national facility design. When an actual or potential conflict of interest is identified by either the contractor or the agency official, the agency official must consult with AGC or Regional Counsel to determine whether there is a conflict and, if so, whether the conflict can be avoided, mitigated, or waived at the FAA’s discretion. Such determinations are made on a case-by-case basis (see the FAA’s Procurement Toolbox Guidance, Section T3.1.7 Organizational Conflict of Interest, dated April 4, 2006).
(3) EIS Disclosure Statement. Before a contractor enters into a contract for preparation of an EIS, the FAA must obtain a “disclosure statement” from the NEPA contractor and subcontractors verifying that they have no financial interest in the outcome of the action (see 40 CFR § 1506.5(c), CEQ Regulations).
2-2.2. Responsibilities of Applicants. When an applicant seeks FAA approval for an action that does not require an EIS, the FAA may request that the applicant provide the required environmental analysis to the FAA or the FAA may hire a contractor to provide the analysis. Applicants and contractors may provide data and analysis to assist the FAA in determining whether a CATEX applies (including whether an extraordinary circumstance exists); however, applicants and contractors may not determine the applicability of CATEXs or approve CATEX documentation. Applicants may prepare EAs, but may not prepare EISs. However, applicants may fund preparation of EISs through third-party contracting. In such cases, the FAA must select the contractor and supervise the contractor’s duties and responsibilities. For applications to the FAA requiring an EA or EIS, preparation of the EA or EIS must begin immediately after the FAA receives the application or proposal. If required by the responsible FAA official, applicants must provide sufficient environmental information or analysis to ensure the environmental analysis meets the requirements of this Order. In a third-party contracting situation, the role of the applicant is limited to providing planning information, environmental studies (including studies to obtain incomplete information that the FAA finds to be required under the standards of 40 CFR § 1502.22, CEQ Regulations), other FAA-requested information, and financing for the EIS consultant’s costs. For the FAA’s role in applicant actions, see Paragraph 2-2.1.d.
2-3.2. Initial Environmental Review. › (3) Could significantly affect the quality of the human environment…
2-2.3. Responsibilities of Contractors. Contracted consulting services may be used to prepare environmental documents, technical reports, and other information. Contractors may also prepare background or supplemental material or otherwise assist in preparing draft or final environmental documents for the FAA. When a contractor assists the FAA in preparing an EA or EIS, the contractor must ensure that the EA or EIS meets the requirements of the CEQ Regulations, this Order, other FAA requirements applicable to contractors, and all other appropriate Federal, state, tribal, and local laws. The contractor for an EIS must also execute a disclosure statement specifying that it has no financial or other interest in the outcome of the action (see 40 CFR § 1506.5(c), CEQ Regulations). The disclosure statement must be prepared by the FAA or, where appropriate, a cooperating agency (e.g., where the contractor prepares a portion of an EIS for a cooperating agency under 40 CFR § 1501.6(b), CEQ Regulations).
2-3. Planning and Integration.
2-3.1. Early Planning. Environmental issues should be identified and considered early in a proposed action’s planning process to ensure efficient, timely, and effective environmental review. Initiating the appropriate level of environmental review at the earliest possible time facilitates the NEPA process. Preparation for any applicable permit application and other review process requirements should be part of the planning process to ensure that necessary information is collected and provided to the permitting or reviewing agencies in a timely manner. The FAA or applicant, as applicable, should identify known environmental impact categories that the proposed action and the alternatives could affect, including specially protected resources. These tasks should be completed at the earliest possible time during project planning to ensure full consideration of all environmental impact categories and facilitate the FAA’s NEPA process. Sufficient planning and project justification should be available to support the environmental review.
If the FAA is considering a request from an applicant, and the FAA is aware that the applicant is about to take an action within the agency’s jurisdiction that would have an adverse environmental impact or limit the choice of reasonable alternatives, the responsible FAA official will promptly notify the applicant that the FAA will take appropriate action to ensure that the objectives and procedures of NEPA are achieved (see number 11 in CEQ’s Forty Most Asked Questions Concerning CEQ’s National Environmental Policy Act Regulations, 46 Federal Register 18026 (March 23, 1981)). However, this does not preclude development by applicants of plans or designs or performance of other work necessary to support an application for Federal, state, or local permits or assistance.
2-3.2. Initial Environmental Review.
a. Review Proposed Action. The responsible FAA official should initially review whether the proposed action:
(1) Is within the scope of a CATEX;
(2) Has been addressed in an existing NEPA document, such as a broad system, program, or regional assessment (see Paragraph 3-2) or a NEPA document prepared by another Federal agency (see Paragraph 8-2);
(3) Could significantly affect the quality of the human environment with respect to noise; land; air; water; wildlife (e.g., threatened and endangered species, migratory
2-3.2. Initial Environmental Review. › (3) Similar actions.
birds); energy supply and natural resources; or cultural, historic, or archeological resources;
(4) Would be located in wetlands; floodplains; coastal zones; prime or important farmlands; habitat of federally listed endangered, threatened, or other protected species; wild and scenic river areas; areas protected under Section 4(f), 49 U.S.C. § 303,3 or Section 6(f) of the Land and Water Conservation Fund Act (16 U.S.C. §§ 460l-8(f)(3)); or in or adjacent to minority or low income populations (Executive Order 12898 and DOT Order 5610.2(a)); or
(5) Would be highly controversial on environmental grounds (see Paragraph 5- 2.b.(10)).
b. Scope of Proposed Action. To determine the scope of an EA or EIS, the responsible FAA official must consider:
(1) Connected actions. Connected actions are closely related actions that: (a) automatically trigger other actions; (b) cannot or will not proceed unless other actions are taken previously or simultaneously; or (c) are interdependent parts of a larger action and depend on the larger action for their justification (see 40 CFR § 1508.25(a)(1), CEQ Regulations). Connected actions and other proposed actions or parts of proposed actions that are related to each other closely enough to be, in effect, a single course of action must be evaluated in the same EA or EIS (see 40 CFR §§ 1502.4(a) and 1508.25(a)(1), CEQ Regulations). A proposed action cannot be segmented by breaking it down into small component parts to attempt to reduce impacts (see 40 CFR § 1508.27(b)(7), CEQ Regulations).
(2) Cumulative actions. Cumulative actions, when viewed with other proposed actions, have cumulatively significant impacts. Cumulative actions should be discussed in the same EIS (see 40 CFR § 1508.25(a)(2), CEQ Regulations). (See Paragraph 4-2.d(3) for a discussion of cumulative impacts).
(3) Similar actions. Similar actions, such as those with common timing or geography, should be considered in the same environmental document when the best way to assess their combined impacts or reasonable alternatives to such actions is in a single document (see 40 CFR §§ 1502.4(b) through (c) and 1508.25(a)(3), CEQ Regulations).
c. Special Purpose Laws and Requirements. In addition to NEPA compliance, the FAA must comply with all other applicable special purpose laws and requirements. The FAA and applicants must involve other agencies during the NEPA process and meet the public involvement needs specified in all applicable special purpose laws and requirements.
d. Permits and Consultations. Environmental permits, licenses, and other forms of approval, concurrence, consultation, or cooperation may be required from other agencies. Pertinent permit application and other review processes must be included in the planning process to ensure that the necessary supporting information is collected and provided to
3 49 U.S.C. § 303 was originally enacted as Section 4(f) of the Department of Transportation Act of 1966 and is still commonly referred to as "Section 4(f)".
the permitting or reviewing agencies in a timely manner, especially if the applicable special purpose laws and requirements specify timeframes for these processes.
2-3.4. Reducing Paperwork.
2-3.3. Environmental Management System Approach. EMSs provide a proactive systematic approach for managing and improving environmental performance and stewardship. Executive Order 13423, Strengthening Federal Environmental, Energy, and Transportation Management, 72 Federal Register 3919 (January 26, 2007), requires Federal agencies to use EMS as the primary management approach for addressing environmental aspects of agency operations and activities, including environmental aspects of transportation functions. The most common framework for an EMS is a plan-do-check-act process, with the goal of continual improvement in environmental performance. A strategic EMS approach provides the foundation for integrating environmental objectives into NextGen and other FAA initiatives in furtherance of the goal of environmental protection that allows sustained aviation growth.
The EMS approach may be used to support the early identification and consideration of potential environmental impacts and concerns in a proposed action’s planning phase. EMS data collection, tracking, and analysis may also be useful in the preparation of NEPA documentation, including providing input to the affected environment, assessment of potential impacts, and consideration of appropriate mitigation measures. An EMS approach may also be used for tracking and monitoring mitigation commitments. An EMS approach can produce projects that are better tailored to site-specific circumstances, can benefit from expedited reviews due to reduced impacts (and therefore less NEPA documentation), and experience less public controversy.
CEQ has recognized the potential benefits of aligning EMS with NEPA in the guide Aligning National Environmental Policy Act Processes with Environmental Management Systems – A Guide for NEPA and EMS Practitioner (April 2007). The CEQ guide includes examples of ways that an EMS can complement the NEPA process and support the various phases of NEPA review.
2-3.4. Reducing Paperwork. The CEQ Regulations (see 40 CFR § 1500.4, CEQ Regulations) encourage the reduction of excessive paperwork by, among other things:
a. Reducing the length of EISs;
b. Preparing analytic rather than encyclopedic EISs;
c. Discussing only briefly issues other than significant issues;
d. Writing EISs in plain language;
e. Following a clear format for EISs;
f. Emphasizing portions of EISs that are useful to decisionmakers and the public and reducing emphasis on background material;
g. Using the scoping process to identify significant environmental issues deserving of study and de-emphasize insignificant issues, narrowing the scope of the EIS accordingly;
h. Incorporating material by reference;
i. Integrating NEPA requirements with other environmental review and consultation requirements; and
2-4.1. Internal Federal Aviation Administration Coordination.
j. Eliminating duplication with (1) state and local procedures by providing for joint document preparation, and (2) with other Federal procedures by providing for joint preparation, incorporation by reference, or adoption of appropriate environmental documents prepared by another agency.
The FAA will apply these concepts to all NEPA reviews (analyses and documents).
2-3.5. Reducing Delay. The CEQ Regulations (see 40 CFR § 1500.5) encourage the reduction of delay while allowing for public involvement and interagency and intergovernmental consultation by, among other things:
a. Integrating the NEPA process into early planning;
b. Emphasizing interagency cooperation before an EIS is prepared;
c. Ensuring the swift and fair resolution of lead agency disputes;
d. Using the scoping process for early identification of what are and what are not the real issues;
e. Integrating NEPA requirements with other environmental review and consultation requirements; and
f. Eliminating duplication with state and local procedures and with other Federal procedures.
The FAA will apply these concepts to all NEPA reviews (analyses and documents).
2-3.6. Mitigation.
a. Incorporation into Project Design. Throughout the environmental analysis process, the responsible FAA official is encouraged to incorporate mitigation into project design (e.g., by modifying the project) to avoid and minimize environmental impacts. Appropriate mitigation incorporated into project design can also have the advantage of reducing the level of required environmental review from an EIS to an EA and FONSI, or avoiding extraordinary circumstances that would preclude application of a CATEX. Mitigation incorporated into project design should be consistent with the project’s purpose and need and must be clearly described in the appropriate alternatives. For projects involving an applicant, the FAA will coordinate proposed mitigation with the applicant for purposes of ascertaining the feasibility of the proposed mitigation and alternative mitigations. For further information on mitigation of project impacts see Paragraphs 4-4, 6-2.3, and 7-1.1.h.
b. Expertise. When identifying mitigation measures for specific environmental impact categories, the responsible FAA official must coordinate with subject matter experts that have expert knowledge, training, and experience related to the resource(s) potentially impacted by the proposed action.
2-4. Coordination.
2-4.1. Internal Federal Aviation Administration Coordination. The FAA’s internal review process is a means of coordinating NEPA reviews among appropriate management levels and across LOB/SOs. Internal review ensures effective coordination to (1) address the concerns of other offices in addition to the NEPA lead; (2) to include relevant actions of
2-4.3. Intergovernmental and Interagency Coordination.
other offices within the purview of the NEPA review; (3) to confirm any requirements or commitments of other offices; and (4) to provide for appropriate legal review. Additional information on the internal review and approval of NEPA documents is provided in Chapter 10 of this Order.
2-4.2. Lead and Cooperating Agencies. The CEQ Regulations describe (1) the role of the lead agency in preparing EISs when more than one agency is involved in a proposed action; (2) the relationship of the lead agency with cooperating agencies; and (3) the role of the lead agency in the scoping process and in setting time limits (see 40 CFR §§ 1501.5-1501.8, CEQ Regulations). The regulations also allow for joint lead agencies (see 40 CFR § 1501.6(b)).
a. Lead Agency. When the FAA acts as the lead agency, the FAA has the primary responsibility for preparation of an EA or EIS (see 40 CFR §1501.5, CEQ Regulations and CEQ Memorandum, Cooperating Agencies in Implementing the Procedural Requirements of the National Environmental Policy Act (January 30, 2002)). If more than one FAA office is involved in the same action, the approving FAA officials of the FAA offices involved in the action should determine the lead FAA office responsible for the NEPA process. The other FAA offices should assist the FAA NEPA lead as that office deems necessary to prepare the document.
b. Cooperating Agency Invitation. The FAA NEPA lead should invite Federal, state, tribal, and local agencies with special expertise or jurisdiction by law to be cooperating agencies (see 40 CFR §§ 1501.6 and 1508.5, CEQ Regulations, and CEQ Memorandum, Designation of Non-Federal Agencies to be Cooperating Agencies in Implementing the Procedural Requirements of the National Environmental Policy Act (July 28, 1999)). c. Role as a Cooperating Agency. If the FAA is acting as a cooperating agency, the responsible FAA official should ensure that the FAA's views are adequately reflected in the environmental document (see Paragraph 8-1.b). This should be facilitated by actively communicating with the lead agency early and often in the NEPA process.
2-4.3. Intergovernmental and Interagency Coordination. The responsible FAA official, when appropriate, must consult affected Federal and state agencies, tribes, and local units of government early in the NEPA process. Early coordination should include coordinating with operators of facilities (e.g., airport sponsors) affected by proposed FAA actions. Applicants may also engage in intergovernmental and interagency coordination, subject to protocols for government-to-government consultation with tribes. Consultation comments on the potential environmental impacts of the proposed action must be considered in determining whether the proposed action requires an EA or EIS, and can aid in the preparation of the EA or EIS. See Paragraphs 2-3.2.c and 2-3.2.d and the 1050.1F Desk Reference regarding requirements for coordination and consultation that may apply under special purpose laws and requirements.
In accordance with Executive Order 12372, Intergovernmental Review of Federal Programs, 47 Federal Register 30959 (July 16, 1982) (as supplemented by Executive Order 13132, Federalism, 64 Federal Register 43255 (August 10, 1999), and 49 CFR part 17, Intergovernmental Review of Department of Transportation Programs and Activities), the responsible FAA official must provide the opportunity for state and local officials to review and comment on Federal actions for Federal assistance or actions affecting them. A few states have established a point of contact, often within the governor’s office, to coordinate
2-5.2. Federal Aviation Administration Requirements for Public Involvement.
comments by state agencies. Otherwise, the responsible FAA official should contact appropriate state agencies directly.
2-4.4. Tribal Consultation. Government-to-government consultation must be conducted in accordance with the requirements of FAA Order 1210.20, American Indian and Alaska Native Tribal Consultation Policy and Procedures. In accordance with Executive Order 13175, Consultation and Coordination with Indian Tribal Governments, 65 Federal Register 67249 (November 9, 2000), the Federal government continues to work with tribes on a government-to-government basis to address issues concerning tribal self-government, trust resources, and tribal treaty and other rights. For regulations, legislative comments, or proposed legislation, and other policy statements or actions that have substantial direct effects on Federally Recognized Tribes, the appropriate FAA official should initiate consultation with the recognized leader of the Tribe and seek advice on how to proceed based on the tribal culture and the tribal organization as discussed in FAA Order 1210.20. Sources of information for addresses to contact tribes include, for example, State Historic Preservation Offices, the Bureau of Indian Affairs, the FAA’s Federal Historic Preservation Officer, and the FAA's National or Regional Tribal Consultation Officials. (See also Paragraph 2-4.3, Intergovernmental and Interagency Coordination).
2-5. Public Involvement. NEPA and the CEQ Regulations, in describing the public involvement process, require Federal agencies to: consider environmental information in their decision-making process; solicit appropriate information from the public; fully assess and disclose potential environmental impacts resulting from the proposed action and alternatives; and provide the public with this information and allow it to comment on these findings. Public involvement is also required when the FAA revises its rules, or proposes substantial changes to its NEPA implementing instructions. Strategic planning is needed to successfully integrate public involvement and NEPA. Failure to complete public participation can delay the process and, therefore, the proposed action.
2-5.1. Timing and Extent of Public Involvement. The FAA, or when applicable, the applicant, must provide pertinent information to the affected communities and agencies and consider their comments at the earliest appropriate time and early in the process of preparing an EIS. The extent of early coordination will depend on the complexity, sensitivity, degree of Federal involvement, and anticipated environmental impacts. Comments received during early coordination/scoping and during public review of a draft NEPA document on the potential impacts of the proposed action and any reasonable alternatives identified must be considered. Additional information regarding public involvement is discussed in Paragraphs 6-2.2 for EAs and 7-1.2 for EISs. The length of public comment periods is discussed in Paragraphs 6-2.2.g and 7-1.2.d.
2-5.2. Federal Aviation Administration Requirements for Public Involvement. The FAA’s Community Involvement Policy Statement (April 17, 1995) affirms the FAA’s commitment to make complete, open, and effective public participation an essential part of its actions, programs, and decisions.
a. Special Purpose Laws and Requirements. The FAA and applicant must involve, and are encouraged to work cooperatively with, other agencies during the NEPA process and meet the public involvement needs specified in all the special purpose laws and requirements applicable to a proposed FAA action. The FAA and applicant should use
available information technologies to inform the public about the progress of environmental reviews, the availability of draft environmental documents for review and the duration of public comment periods, where applicable, and the availability of final environmental documents. NEPA also serves as a framework statute for environmental compliance and the required public notice and comment period should, whenever possible, be completed in alignment with the public notice and participation requirements specified in other applicable special purpose laws and requirements, e.g., Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, 54 U.S.C. § 36108, 36 CFR part 800, Protection of Historic Properties, Executive Order 12898, Federal Actions to Address Environmental Justice in Minority Populations and Low-Income Populations, 59 Federal Register 7629 (February 16, 1994) and DOT Order 5610.2(a), Actions to Address Environmental Justice in Minority Populations and Low-Income Populations.
b. Environmental Justice. The responsible FAA official must, to the extent practicable, make every effort to notify potentially affected minority populations and low-income populations of proposed actions and their impacts. The FAA should make direct contact with minority and low-income community groups, organizations, and/or leaders in communities affected by the activity. If direct contact is not practicable, the responsible FAA official must take steps to provide the public, including members of minority populations and low-income populations, access to public information concerning the human health or environmental impacts of the proposed action, including information that will address the concerns of minority and low income populations regarding the health and environmental impacts of the proposed action. The responsible FAA official should notify the public at the earliest stages of project planning. The FAA will provide public involvement opportunities and consider the results thereof, including soliciting input from affected minority and low-income populations on the proposed action and any alternatives. The FAA can hold public hearings, meetings, or workshops on NEPA documents to involve the public in the process. Provisions should be made to ensure that non-English speaking populations receive proper notification of the proposed action and any public hearings, meetings or workshops that are held. (See Executive Order 12898 and DOT Order 5610.2(a)).
c. Other Agency Public Involvement Requirements. When another Federal agency disposing of land is the lead agency pursuant to NEPA, the FAA should defer to the public involvement requirements of the agency having jurisdiction over those lands when those requirements do not curtail the FAA requirements.
d. Rulemaking. When the FAA prepares a draft EIS for a rulemaking activity that could cause significant environmental impacts, the responsible FAA official should consult with the Office of Rulemaking (ARM-1) and AGC to coordinate public involvement.
e. Classified Information. When dealing with classified information, the responsible FAA official must consult FAA Order 1600.2, Safeguarding Classified National Security Information.
2-6. Plain Language.
2-5.3. Public Meetings, Workshops, and Hearings.
a. Holding Public Meetings, Workshops, and Hearings. The FAA should hold public meetings, workshops, or hearings, when appropriate. Such events can provide timely opportunities to discover potential controversial issues. Some factors that are helpful in deciding if a hearing, workshop, or meeting is appropriate include:
(1) The proposed action’s magnitude in terms of environmental impact, environmental controversy, cost, and/or extent of the affected geographical area;
(2) The degree of interest that Federal, state, tribal, or local authorities or the public exhibit; and
(3) The complexity of issues.
The CEQ Regulations also contain criteria for determining whether to hold public meetings or hearings (see 40 CFR § 1506.6(c), CEQ Regulations).
b. Obtaining Comments on a Draft EIS or EA. If the FAA conducts a public meeting or hearing for the purpose of obtaining public comment on a draft EIS or EA, the FAA should ensure that the draft document is available for public review at least 30 days before the event occurs. A public hearing is a formal process that has a designated public hearing officer who presides over the meeting and a court reporter present to compile a transcript of all oral comments. Notice of a public meeting or hearing (including a scoping meeting, see Paragraph 7-1.2.c) should be published (e.g., in local, general circulation newspapers) at least 30 days prior to the event. Notice of actions having national implications must be published in the Federal Register and mailed to national organizations having an interest in the matter. The notice should provide the following:
(1) Date, time, place, and interval during which written comments will be accepted;
(2) Description of the proposed action;
(3) Location and availability of the NEPA document; and
(4) Name and contact information of the responsible FAA official.
c. Accommodations. When holding a public meeting or hearing, accommodations must be made for the needs of the elderly, disabled, non-English speaking, minority, and lowincome populations in accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, 42 U.S.C. §§ 12101-12213, Executive Order 12898, and DOT Order 5610.2(a).
2-6. Plain Language. The CEQ Regulations at 40 CFR §§ 1500.4(d), 1502.1, 1502.2(c), and 1502.8, Paragraph 14 of DOT Order 5610.1C, and the Executive Orders on environmental justice and intergovernmental consultation encourage the availability of information to the public in a manner that will facilitate public involvement in decisions affecting the human environment. FAA NEPA documentation should be written in plain language and use appropriate graphics so that decisionmakers and the public can readily understand them. The FAA has plain language guidance in FAA Order 1000.36, FAA Writing Standards.
2-8. -2-50. Reserved.
2-7. Limitations on Actions Involving Real Property Prior to Completing National Environmental Policy Act Review.
a. Restrictions on Acquisitions of Property. The transfer of title or other interests in real property, including land, may occur prior to the completion of the environmental review for a proposed project unless the acquisition of land is inextricable to the proposed project or effectively limits the choice of reasonable alternatives. The acquisition of land is inextricable to the proposed project where the acquisition is part of one continuous project leading inevitably to the proposed Federal action.
b. Other Circumstances. If the proposed action is not categorically excluded under this Order and acquisition of property is inextricable to the proposed action, no formal action to acquire the property, including any offer, may be taken prior to filing a final EIS or issuance of a FONSI, except for:
(1) emergency situations (see Paragraph 8-7);
(2) obtaining rights-of-way for purposes such as preparation for site testing, obtaining data, property surveys, etc.; and
(3) those cases where the NEPA review process indicates that the proposed site warrants further engineering study. In such cases, the FAA may obtain an option for future purchase of the property. No transfer of title occurs as a result of the option, but the option ensures the availability of the property pending completion of the environmental review. In this event, the environmental document should state that: the FAA has entered into an option and the reason for the option; that alternative sites are being considered; and that a decision whether to exercise the option will not be made until completion of the environmental review.
c. FAA Review. The FAA will review a proposed action by an applicant that has acquired land or constructed a facility for operation by the FAA, but without prior approval by the FAA, to determine whether the action was consistent with the policies of this Order and whether it has limited full and objective consideration of alternatives.
2-8. -2-50. Reserved.
3-1.2. Actions Normally Requiring an Environmental Assessment. › (4) Authorization to exceed Mach 1 flight under 14 CFR § 91.817, Civil…
Chapter 3: Levels of National Environmental Policy Act Review
3-1. Three Levels of National Environmental Policy Act Review. Once the FAA determines that NEPA applies to a proposed action, it needs to decide on the appropriate level of review. The three levels of NEPA review are Categorical Exclusion (CATEX), Environmental Assessment (EA), and Environmental Impact Statement (EIS). Each of the three levels of review is briefly described in the following paragraphs.
3-1.1. Categorically Excluded Actions. A CATEX refers to a category of actions that do not individually or cumulatively have a significant effect on the human environment, and for which, neither an EA nor an EIS is required. A CATEX is not an exemption or waiver of NEPA review; it is a level of NEPA review. If a proposed action falls within the scope of a CATEX (see Paragraph 5-6, The Federal Aviation Administration’s Categorical Exclusions), and there are no extraordinary circumstances (see Paragraph 5-2, Extraordinary Circumstances), an EA or EIS is not required. The FAA may, at its discretion, decide to prepare an EA in order to assist agency planning and decision-making even if a proposed action fits within a CATEX and extraordinary circumstances do not exist, except for actions subject to categorical exclusion under Section 213 of the FAA Modernization and Reform Act (see Paragraphs 5-6.5.q and 5-6.5.r).
3-1.2. Actions Normally Requiring an Environmental Assessment. The purpose of an EA is to determine whether a proposed action has the potential to significantly affect the human environment (see Paragraph 4-3 for more information on determining significance). An EA is a concise public document that briefly provides sufficient evidence and analysis for determining whether to prepare an EIS or a FONSI. An EA may facilitate the preparation of an EIS, when one is necessary.
a. Environmental Assessments. An EA, at a minimum, must be prepared when the proposed action does not normally require an EIS (see Paragraph 3-1.3, Actions Normally Requiring an Environmental Impact Statement) and:
(1) does not fall within the scope of a CATEX (see Paragraph 5-6, The Federal Aviation Administration’s Categorical Exclusions); or
(2) falls within the scope of a CATEX, but there are one or more extraordinary circumstances (see Paragraph 5-2, Extraordinary Circumstances).
b. Examples. The following FAA actions normally require an EA:
(1) Acquisition of land greater than three acres for, and the construction of, new office buildings and essentially similar FAA facilities.
(2) Issuance of certificates for new, amended, or supplemental aircraft types for which (a) environmental regulations have not been issued; or (b) new, amended, or supplemental engine types for which emission regulations have not been issued; or (c) where a NEPA analysis has not been prepared in connection with a regulatory action.
(3) Establishment of aircraft/avionics maintenance bases to be operated by the FAA.
(4) Authorization to exceed Mach 1 flight under 14 CFR § 91.817, Civil Aircraft Sonic Boom.
(11) Approval of operations specifications or amendments that may… › (b) Amendment of operations specifications authorizing an operator to…
(5) Establishment of FAA housing, sanitation systems, fuel storage and distribution systems, and power source and distribution systems.
(6) Establishment or relocation of facilities such as Air Route Traffic Control Centers (ARTCC), Airport Traffic Control Towers (ATCT), and off-airport Air Route Surveillance Radars (ARSR), Air Traffic Control Beacons (ATCB), and Next Generation Radar (NEXRAD).
(7) Establishment, relocation, or construction of facilities used for communications (except as provided under Paragraph 5-6.3a) and navigation that are not on airport property.
(8) Establishment or relocation of instrument landing systems (ILS).
(9) Establishment or relocation of approach lighting systems (ALS) that are not on airport property.
(10) Unconditional Airport Layout Plan (ALP) approval of, or Federal financial participation in, the following categories of airport actions:
(a) Location of a new airport that would serve only general aviation;
(b) Location of a new commercial service airport that would not be located in a Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA);
(c) A new runway at an existing airport that is not located in an MSA;
(d) Runway strengthening having the potential to significantly increase offairport noise impacts (see Exhibit 4-1);
(e) Construction or relocation of entrance or service road connections to public roads that substantially reduce the level of service rating of such public roads below the acceptable level determined by the appropriate transportation agency (i.e., a highway agency); and
(f) Land acquisition associated with any of the items in (10)(a)–(f).
(11) Approval of operations specifications or amendments that may significantly change the character of the operational environment of an airport, including, but not limited to:
(a) Approval of operations specifications authorizing an operator to use aircraft to provide scheduled passenger or cargo service at an airport that may cause significant impacts to noise, air quality, or other environmental impact categories (see Exhibit 4-1); or
(b) Amendment of operations specifications authorizing an operator to serve an airport with different aircraft that may cause significant impacts to noise, air quality, or other environmental impact categories (see Exhibit 4-1).
(12) New air traffic control procedures (e.g., instrument approach procedures, departure procedures, en route procedures) and modifications to currently approved procedures that routinely route aircraft over noise sensitive areas at less than 3,000 feet above ground level (AGL) (unless otherwise categorically excluded under Paragraphs (procedures category) 5-6.5q and 5-6.5r).
3-2. Programmatic National Environmental Policy Act Documents and Tiering.
(13) Establishment or modification of an Instrument Flight Rules Military Training Route (IR MTR).
(14) Special Use Airspace (SUA) (unless otherwise explicitly listed as an advisory action (see Paragraph 2-1.2.b, Advisory Actions) or categorically excluded (see Paragraph 5-6, The Federal Aviation Administration’s Categorical Exclusions)).
(15) Issuance of any of the following:
(a) A commercial space launch site operator license for operation of a launch site at an existing facility on developed land where little to no infrastructure would be constructed (e.g., co-located with a Federal range or municipal airport); or
(b) A commercial space launch license, reentry license, or experimental permit to operate a vehicle to/from an existing site.
(16) Formal and informal runway use programs that may significantly increase noise over noise sensitive areas (see Exhibit 4-1).
3-1.3. Actions Normally Requiring an Environmental Impact Statement.
a. Environmental Impact Statements. Under NEPA, the FAA must prepare an EIS for actions significantly affecting the quality of the human environment (see Chapter 4 for additional information regarding significance of impacts). An EIS is a detailed written statement required under Section 102(2)(C) of NEPA when one or more environmental impacts would be significant and mitigation measures cannot reduce the impact(s) below significant levels. Direct, indirect, and cumulative impacts must be considered when determining significance (see Paragraphs 4-2.d and 4-3).
b. Examples. The following are actions that normally require an EIS:
(1) Unconditional ALP approval, or Federal financial participation in, the following categories of airport actions:
(a) Location of a new commercial service airport in an MSA;
(b) A new runway to accommodate air carrier aircraft at a commercial service airport in an MSA; and
(c) Major runway extension.
(2) Issuance of a commercial space launch site operator license, launch license, or experimental permit to support activities requiring the construction of a new commercial space launch site on undeveloped land.
3-2. Programmatic National Environmental Policy Act Documents and Tiering. A programmatic review should assist decisionmakers and the public in understanding the environmental impact from proposed large scope federal actions and activities. A programmatic EIS or EA may be prepared to cover (1) a broad group of related actions; or (2) a program, policy, plan, system, or national level proposal that may later lead to individual actions, requiring subsequent NEPA analysis. A programmatic document is useful in analyzing the cumulative impacts of a group of related actions and when the proposed actions are adequately analyzed can serve as the NEPA review for those actions. Programmatic documents may also be useful in
3-4. -3-50. Reserved.
providing the basis for subsequent project-level specific environmental review. A programmatic EIS or EA may contain a broader, less specific, analysis than is done for a specific proposed project. If a programmatic EIS or EA is prepared, the FAA will determine whether projectspecific EISs or EAs are needed for individual actions. Broad Federal actions analyzed in a programmatic EIS or EA may be evaluated geographically, generically, or by stage of technological development (see 40 CFR § 1502.4(c), CEQ Regulations).
When a programmatic EIS or EA has been prepared, any subsequent EIS or EA for proposed projects within the scope of the programmatic document only needs to incorporate by reference (40 CFR 1502.21) by summarizing the issues discussed in the programmatic document, providing access to the programmatic EIS or EA, and concentrating the subsequent project specific EIS or EA on site-specific impacts not covered by the programmatic document. The project specific document must state how to obtain a copy of the earlier programmatic document (i.e., a webpage or contact person/office).
The use of a programmatic EIS or EA, and subsequent preparation of a project specific EIS or EA is referred to as “tiering” the environmental review (see 40 CFR §§ 1502.20 and 1508.28, CEQ Regulations). Tiering can also be used to sequence environmental documents from the early stage of a proposed action (e.g., need for the action and site selection) to a subsequent stage (e.g., proposed construction) to help focus on issues that are ripe for decision and exclude from consideration issues not yet ripe or already decided. When this approach is used, the FAA must ensure that the proposed action is not being segmented by describing the independent utility of each stage. Programmatic and tiered EISs and EAs are subject to the same preparation and processing requirements as other EISs and EAs.
3-3. FAA NEPA Database. FAA LOB/SOs will whenever possible, use the FAA NEPA Database to track projects and make final documents available to others in the FAA.
3-4. -3-50. Reserved.
4-2. Consideration of Impacts.
Chapter 4: Impact Categories, Significance, and Mitigation
4-1. Environmental Impact Categories. Environmental impact categories that may be relevant to FAA actions are listed below. These categories are alphabetized below for ease of reference, but are not intended to impose an alphabetical order on the FAA’s NEPA documents. Detailed guidance on evaluating impacts in these categories is located in the 1050.1F Desk Reference.4 Construction and secondary (induced) impacts are addressed within the relevant environmental impact category chapters of the FAA 1050.1F Desk Reference. FAA-specific requirements for assessing impacts are highlighted in Appendix B of this Order and discussed in detail in the 1050.1F Desk Reference.
• Air quality
• Biological resources (including fish, wildlife, and plants)
• Climate
• Coastal resources
• Department of Transportation Act, Section 4(f)
• Farmlands
• Hazardous materials, solid waste, and pollution prevention
• Historical, architectural, archeological, and cultural resources
• Land use
• Natural resources and energy supply
• Noise and compatible land use
• Socioeconomics, environmental justice, and children’s environmental health and safety risks
• Visual effects (including light emissions)
• Water resources (including wetlands, floodplains, surface waters, groundwater, and wild and scenic rivers)
4-2. Consideration of Impacts.
a. Desk Reference. The 1050.1F Desk Reference provides details on current guidance and updated technical information for each environmental impact category that the FAA examines for its proposed actions and alternatives. The desk reference is available on the FAA website at http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/apl /environ_ policy_guidance/policy/. This includes references to current requirements; information about permits, licenses, certificates, or other forms of approval and review; an overview of specific responsibilities for gathering data, assessing impacts, consulting other
4 The Desk Reference is available on the FAA website at http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/apl/environ_policy_guidance/policy/
agencies, and involving the public; significance thresholds; and factors to consider in evaluating impact significance when there is no significance threshold.
b. FAA-Approved Models. The latest FAA-approved model must be used for both air quality and noise analysis. A list of approved models for each type of analysis is available in the 1050.1F Desk Reference. Prior approval from AEE is required to use other models or methodologies. At the completion of the NEPA process, all input files used in the analysis and corresponding output files must be provided to AEE. Details on requirements for noise analysis are located in Appendix B. In the event a model is updated or replaced after the environmental analysis process is underway, the updated or replacement model may be used to provide additional disclosure concerning noise or air quality impacts, but use of the updated or replacement model is not required.
c. Environmental Impact Category Not Affected. If an environmental impact category is not relevant to the proposed action or any of the reasonable alternatives identified (i.e., the resources included in the category are not present or the category is not otherwise applicable to the proposed action and alternatives), the reason why should be briefly noted and no further analysis is required. Consistent with 40 CFR § 1502.2(b), CEQ Regulations, the responsible FAA official should discuss impacts in proportion to their significance for each applicable environmental impact category.
d. Types of Impacts. Within each applicable environmental impact category, the EA or EIS must address the following types of impacts (for further details, see the 1050.1F Desk Reference):
(1) Direct impacts (see 40 CFR § 1508.8(a), CEQ Regulations);
(2) Indirect (including induced) impacts (see 40 CFR § 1508.8(b), CEQ Regulations); and
(3) Cumulative impacts (see 40 CFR §§ 1508.7, 1508.8, 1508.25, and 1508.27(b)(7), CEQ Regulations, and CEQ Guidance on Considering Cumulative Effects Under the National Environmental Policy Act (January 1997)). Cumulative impacts are those that result from the incremental impact of the action when added to other past, present, and reasonably foreseeable future actions, whether Federal or non-Federal. If the proposed action would cause significant incremental additions to cumulative impacts, an EIS is required.
e. Multiple FAA Actions. Some FAA projects involve actions by multiple FAA LOB/SOs; impacts of such actions, when viewed together, govern whether an EA or an EIS is required. Absent independent utility, such actions must be considered in the same EA or EIS.
f. Special Purpose Laws and Requirements. The responsible FAA official should include in the EA or EIS, under appropriate impact categories, the information required to demonstrate compliance with other applicable requirements and should identify any permits, licenses, other approvals, or reviews that apply and indicate any known problems with obtaining them. The EA or EIS must report on the status of any special consultation required (e.g., under Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act, 16 U.S.C. § 1536, Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, 54 U.S.C. § 306108, Section
4-3. Significance and Significance Thresholds.
4(f), 49 U.S.C. § 303, or the Coastal Zone Management Act, 16 U.S.C. §§ 1451-1466). Agency consultation(s) should occur concurrently with the NEPA process.
4-3. Significance and Significance Thresholds.
4-3.1. General. An EIS is required when any of the impacts of the proposed action, after incorporating any mitigation commitments, remain significant to the human environment.
4-3.2. Context and Intensity. The CEQ Regulations state that the determination of a significant impact, as used in NEPA, requires consideration of both context and intensity (see 40 CFR § 1508.27). The significance of an impact may vary with the context and setting of a proposed action. Depending on the proposed action, the context may be society as a whole, nationwide, an affected region, affected interests, or a locality. For a site-specific action, significance would usually depend upon local impacts. Both short and long-term impacts are relevant. According to the CEQ Regulations, intensity refers to the severity of the impacts and includes, but is not limited to, consideration of the following:
• Unique characteristics of the geographic area (e.g., proximity to historic or cultural resources, parks, prime farmlands, wetlands, wild and scenic rivers, ecologically critical areas);
• Adverse impacts on properties listed or eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places;
• Loss or destruction of significant scientific, cultural, or historical resources;
• Adverse impacts on endangered or threatened species or critical habitat;
• Whether an action threatens a violation of Federal, state, or local law or requirements imposed for the protection of the environment;
• Impacts that may be both beneficial and adverse. A significant impact may exist even if the Federal agency believes that on balance the impact will be beneficial;
• The degree to which the effects on the quality of the human environment are likely to be highly controversial; and
• Whether the action is related to other actions with individually insignificant but cumulatively significant impacts. Significance cannot be avoided by terming an action temporary or by breaking it down into component parts.
4-3.3. Significance Thresholds. The FAA uses thresholds that serve as specific indicators of significant impact for some environmental impact categories. FAA proposed actions that would result in impacts at or above these thresholds require the preparation of an EIS, unless impacts can be reduced below threshold levels. Quantitative significance thresholds do not exist for all impact categories; however, consistent with the CEQ Regulations, the FAA has identified factors that should be considered in evaluating the context and intensity of potential environmental impacts. If these factors exist, there is not necessarily a significant impact. Some impact categories may have both a significance threshold and significance factors to consider. In these instances, a conclusion of significance can be determined based on the factors to consider even if the impacts do not meet the significance threshold criteria. Depending on the proposed action and potential impacts, other factors may also need to be
evaluated to make a determination of significance. After consideration of all relevant factors, the FAA determines whether there would be a significant impact.
The responsible FAA official should use the most current FAA guidance on consideration of significant impacts for each applicable environmental impact category (identified below in Exhibit 4-1) in the 1050.1F Desk Reference. If the LOB/SO is uncertain whether a proposed action would have significant impacts, it should consult with AEE and AGC for guidance.
Exhibit 4-1 shows the FAA’s significance thresholds and factors to consider for each relevant environmental impact category.
Exhibit 4-1. Significance Determination for FAA Actions.
Environmental
Impact Category Significance Threshold Factors to Consider
Air Quality The action would cause pollutant concentrations to exceed one or more of the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS), as established by the Environmental Protection Agency under the Clean Air Act, for any of the time periods analyzed, or to increase the frequency or severity of any such existing violations.
Biological Resources (including fish, wildlife, and plants)
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service or the National Marine Fisheries Service determines that the action would be likely to jeopardize the continued existence of a federally listed threatened or endangered species, or would result in the destruction or adverse modification of federally designated critical habitat. The FAA has not established a significance threshold for non-listed species.
The action would have the potential for:
• A long-term or permanent loss of unlisted plant or wildlife species, i.e., extirpation of the species from a large project area (e.g., a new commercial service airport); • Adverse impacts to special status species (e.g., state species of concern, species proposed for listing, migratory birds, bald and golden eagles) or their habitats; • Substantial loss, reduction, degradation, disturbance, or fragmentation of native species’ habitats or their populations; or • Adverse impacts on a species’ reproductive success rates, natural mortality rates, non-natural mortality (e.g., road kills and hunting), or ability to sustain the minimum population levels required for population maintenance.
Environmental
Impact Category Significance Threshold Factors to Consider
Climate5 The FAA has not established a significance threshold for Climate.
Coastal Resources
The FAA has not established a significance threshold for Coastal Resources.
The action would have the potential to:
• Be inconsistent with the relevant state coastal zone management plan(s); • Impact a coastal barrier resources system unit (and the degree to which the resource would be impacted); • Pose an impact to coral reef ecosystems (and the degree to which the ecosystem would be affected); • Cause an unacceptable risk to human safety or property; or • Cause adverse impacts to the coastal environment that cannot be satisfactorily mitigated.
5 Please refer to the 1050.1F Desk Reference for the most up-to-date methodology for examining impacts associated with climate change.
Environmental
Impact Category Significance Threshold Factors to Consider
Department of Transportation Act, Section 4(f)
The action involves more than a minimal physical use of a Section 4(f) resource or constitutes a “constructive use” based on an FAA determination that the aviation project would substantially impair the Section 4(f) resource.6 Resources that are protected by Section 4(f) are publicly owned land from a public park, recreation area, or wildlife and waterfowl refuge of national, state, or local significance; and publicly or privately owned land from an historic site of national, state, or local significance. Substantial impairment occurs when the activities, features, or attributes of the resource that contribute to its significance or enjoyment are substantially diminished.
Farmlands The total combined score on Form AD-1006, “Farmland Conversion Impact Rating,” ranges between 200 and 260 points.
The action would have the potential to convert important farmlands to nonagricultural uses. Important farmlands include pastureland, cropland, and forest considered to be prime, unique, or statewide or locally important land.
6 A “minimal physical use” is part of the FAA’s significance threshold that has been continued from FAA Order 1050.1E. It is not the same as a de minimis impact determination established in Section 6009 of the Safe, Accountable, Flexible, Efficient Transportation Equity Act: A Legacy for Users (SAFETY-LU). A de minimis impact determination is described in Appendix B, B-2.2.3.
Environmental
Impact Category Significance Threshold Factors to Consider
Hazardous Materials, Solid Waste, and Pollution Prevention
The FAA has not established a significance threshold for Hazardous Materials, Solid Waste, and Pollution Prevention.
The action would have the potential to:
• Violate applicable Federal, state, tribal, or local laws or regulations regarding hazardous materials and/or solid waste management; • Involve a contaminated site (including but not limited to a site listed on the National Priorities List). Contaminated sites may encompass relatively large areas. However, not all of the grounds within the boundaries of a contaminated site are contaminated, which leaves space for siting a facility on non-contaminated land within the boundaries of a contaminated site. An EIS is not necessarily required. Paragraph 6- 2.3.a of this Order allows for mitigating impacts below significant levels (e.g., modifying an action to site it on non-contaminated grounds within a contaminated site). Therefore, if appropriately mitigated, actions within the boundaries of a contaminated site would not have significant impacts; • Produce an appreciably different quantity or type of hazardous waste; • Generate an appreciably different quantity or type of solid waste or use a different method of collection or disposal and/or would exceed local capacity; or • Adversely affect human health and the environment.
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 410 passages shown