67 FR 45194 Noise Certification Standards for Subsonic Jet Airplanes and Subsonic Transport Category Large Airplanes
The FAA is amending the noise certification standards for subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes. These changes are based on the joint effort of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), the European Joint Aviation Authorities (JAA), and Aviation Rulemaking Advisory Committee (ARAC), to harmonize the U.S. noise certification regulations and the European Joint Aviation Requirements (JAR) for subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes. These changes will provide nearly uniform noise certification standards for airplanes certificated in the United States and in the JAA countries. The harmonization of the noise certification standards will simplify airworthiness approvals for import and export purposes.
Part II
14 CFR Parts 21, 36, and 91
Noise Certification Standards for Subsonic Jet Airplanes and Subsonic Transport Category Large Airplanes; Final Rule
and Regulations DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
14 CFR Parts 21, 36, and 91
[Docket No. FAA-2000-7587 Amdt No. 21-81, 36-54 & 91-275] RIN 2120-AH03
Noise Certification Standards for Subsonic Jet Airplanes and Subsonic Transport Category Large Airplanes
Agency
AGENCY: Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), DOT.
ACTION: Final rule; requests for comments.
SUMMARY: The FAA is amending the noise certification standards for subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes. These changes are based on the joint effort of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), the European Joint Aviation Authorities (JAA), and Aviation Rulemaking Advisory Committee (ARAC), to harmonize the U.S. noise certification regulations and the European Joint Aviation Requirements (JAR) for subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes. These changes will provide nearly uniform noise certification standards for airplanes certificated in the United States and in the JAA countries. The harmonization of the noise certification standards will simplify airworthiness approvals for import and export purposes.
Dates
DATES: Effective Date: August 7, 2002. Comments Date: Comments on revised 36.2 concerning the applicable noise requirements are due on or before September 6, 2002.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: James Skalecky, AEE-100, Office of Environment and Energy (AEE), Federal Aviation Administration, 800 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC 20591; telephone (202) 267-3699; facsimile (202) 267-5594; or e-mail at [email protected].
Supplementary Information
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Comments Invited
This final rule is being adopted with prior notice and prior public comment. In response to a comment received during the comment period the FAA is proposing a change to section 36.2. Considering the degree of the change from what was noted in Notice No. 00-08 and the requirement that is being implemented, this final rule includes a request for comments only on revised section 36.2.
Comments Invited
Interested persons are invited to participate in this rulemaking by submitting such written data, views, or arguments as they may desire. Comments must include the regulatory docket or amendment number and must be submitted in duplicate to the address above. All comments received, as well as a report summarizing each substantive public contact with FAA personnel on this rulemaking, will be filed in the public docket. The docket is available for public inspection before and after the comment closing date.
The FAA will consider all comments received on or before the closing date for comments. Late filed comments will be considered to the extent practicable. This final rule may be amended in light of the comments received.
Availability of Rulemaking Documents
Availability of Rulemaking Documents
You can get an electronic copy using the Internet by taking the following steps:
(1) Go to the search function of the Department of Transportation's electronic Docket Management System (DMS) web page (http://dms.dot.gov/search).
(2) On the search page type in the last four digits of the Docket number shown at the beginning of this notice. Click on "search."
(3) On the next page, which contains the Docket summary information for the Docket you selected, click on the document number for the item you wish to view.
You can also get an electronic copy using the Internet through the Office of Bulemaking's web page at http://www.faa.gov/avr/armhome.htm or the Government Printing Offices's web page at http://www.access.gpo.gov/su_docs/aces/aces140.html.
You can also get a copy by submitting a request to the Federal Aviation Administration, Office of Rulemaking, ARM-1, 800 Independence Avenue SW., Washington, DC 20591, or by calling (202) 267-9680. Make sure to identify the amendment number of docket number of this rulemaking.
Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act
Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act
The Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act (SBREFA) of 1996 requires FAA to comply with small entity requests for information or advice about compliance with statutes and regulations within its jurisdiction. Therefore, any small entity that has a question regarding this document may contact its local FAA official, or the person listed under FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT. You can find out more about SBREFA on the Internet at our site, http://www.faa.gov/avr/arm/sbrefa.htm. For more information on SBREFA, e-mail us [email protected].
Background
Background
Current Regulations
Under 49 U.S.C. 44715, the Administrator of the Federal Aviation Administration is directed to prescribed "standards to measure aircraft noise and sonic boom;...and regulations to control and abate aircraft noise and sonic boom." Part 36 of Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations contains the FAA's noise standards and regulations that apply to the issuance of type certificates for all types of aircraft. Subpart A, B, and C and appendices A, B, and C of part 36 contain the requirements and standards and apply to subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes. Appendices A, B, and C of part 36 specify the test conditions, procedures, and noise levels necessary to demonstrate compliance.
Government and Industry Cooperation
Government and Industry Cooperation
In June 1990 at a meeting of the JAA Council, which consists of JAA members from European countries and the FAA, the FAA Administrators committed the FAA to support the harmonization of U.S. regulations with the Joint Aviation Regulations (JAR). The JARs are developed for use by the European authorities that are member countries of the JAA.
In January 1991, the FAA established the Aviation Rulemaking Advisory Committee to serve as a forum for the FAA to obtain input from outside the government on major regulatory issues facing the agency. The FAA tasked ARAC with noise certification issues. These issues involve the harmonization of 14 CFR part 36 with JAR 36, the harmonization of associated guidance material including equivalent procedures, and interpretations of the regulations. On October 17, 1995, the ARAC established the FAR/JAR Harmonization Working Group for Subsonic Transport Category Large Airplanes and Subsonic Turbojet Powered Airplanes (60 FR 53824). The working group task included reviewing the applicable provisions of subparts A, B, and C, and appendices A, B, and C part 36, and harmonizing them with the corresponding applicable provisions of JAR 36. The FAA asked the working group to consider the current international standards and recommended practices, as issued under International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), Annex 16, Volume 1, and its associated Technical Manual, as the basis for development of these harmonization proposals. The working group forwarded a recommendation to amend part 36 to the ARAC. After due consideration, including a meeting open to the public on May 18, 2000, ARAC forwarded this recommendation, in the form of a draft NPRM, to the FAA for consideration.
On July 11, 2000, the FAA published Notice No. 00-08 entitled "Noise Certification Standards for Subsonic Jet Airplanes and Subsonic Transport Category Large Airplanes" (65 FR 42796). The FAA solicited comments on the proposals, which are discussed in the following section. This final rule is based on Notice No. 00-08.
Discussion of Comments
Discussion of Comments
Four commenters responded to Notice No. 00-08. These comments and the FAA responses are discussed below.
General Comments
The Air Line Pilots Association (ALPA) comments that it had reviewed both the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) (Notice No. 00-08) and draft Advisory Circular 36-4C (65 FR 48794). In its comments, ALPA compliments the FAA and JAA for pursuing the harmonization of noise certification standards and concurred with both documents. ALPA also states that certification standards are the appropriate means of reducing noise, and that aviation noise reduction should be accomplished primarily through technological advances in engine and aircraft design/certification, and not with the development of special pilot procedures.
General Comments
The Aerospace Industries Association (AIA) endorses the FAA's efforts to harmonize the U.S. and European regulations. The AIA also comments that the proposed rule would improve the compatibility of part 36 with the noise standards prescribed in ICAO Annex 16, Volume 1. However, AIA also urges FAA to eliminate the language differences that would remain between part 36 and ICAO Annex 16 and its associated guidance material. The AIA identified several sections where it believes that these differences would cause the typical noise certification applicant to question whether the two standards (i.e., part 36 and ICAO Annex 16) have the same meaning. The AIA comments that these differences could make it more difficult and costly for applicants that might want reciprocal approvals by different certificating authorities.
FAA Response
FAA Response
While recognizing AIA's concern about potential misinterpretations that might result from the language differences between part 36 and ICAO Annex 16, harmonization of part 36 with JAR 36 and ICAO Annex 16 is not contingent upon these standards being identical, word for word. These language differences resulted primarily from the need to (1) ensure that the terminology used in part 36 is consistent with that which is commonly used in U.S. regulations, and (2) more precisely define several JAR 36 and ICAO Annex 16 provisions that were incorporated into part 36. The FAA believes that, rather than leading to misinterpretation, as suggested by AIA, more precise definitions of these regulatory provisions will result in less chance of misinterpretation. Accordingly, the FAA has not changed the proposed rule to eliminate these language differences.
Calibration
Calibration
The AIA notes the inconsistent use of the term "changes" in section A36.3.9.5 of the proposed rule, compared to "any changes," used in section A36.3.9.7 to refer to calibration requirements.
FAA Response
The FAA agrees. The word "any" has been removed from section A36.3.9.5.
Sound Propagation Effects on the Lateral Noise Measurement
Sound Propagation Effects on the Lateral Noise Measurement
The AIA comments that the material in section A36.9.3.2(b)(1) concerning sound propagation effects on the lateral noise measurement would be more appropriate in section A36.9.3.2(b)(2)(ii).
FAA Response
The FAA agrees and the material has been moved to section A36.9.3.2(b)(2)(ii). This text is now designated as a "note," since it is advisory in nature. This change is also included in section A36.9.4.2(b)(2)(ii), which contains the same material.
Compatibility With ICAO Standards
Compatibility With ICAO Standards
The AIA comments that the proposed rule preamble discussion under "Compatibility With ICAO Standards" suggests that the FAA is willing to simply file differences between the 14 CFR part 36 noise standards and ICAO noise standard and maintain that status because it had not been possible to reach agreement on some items in the ARAC Harmonization Working Group. The AIA urges the FAA to review the proposed rule to re-assess the FAA's position on achieving full compatibility with ICAO noise standards. The AIA further urges that all items that have not been agreed upon by the Harmonization Working Group should be identified as technical issues to be studied and resolved by appropriate task groups within ICAO committee on Environmental Protection (CAEP) Working Group 1.
FAA Response
FAA Response
Those items identified in the proposed rule as items for which the FAA intends to file differences were placed in that category after considerable review by the Harmonization Working Group indicated that the differences could not realistically be resolved prior to publication of the proposed rule. The FAA fully intends to continue to work toward resolution of these remaining differences, and is currently participating in ICAO CAEP Working Group 1 task groups that are addressing each of these differences.
Special Retroactive Requirements
Special Retroactive Requirements
The AIA expresses support for the FAA's recognition of the incompatibility of current 14 CFR part 36, ICAO Annex 16, and JAR 36 on the date used in determining the applicable noise standards relative to the date of type certificate application. The AIA comments, however, that simply removing section 36.2, as proposed, would not solve the incompatibility problem. Further, given the text contained in ICAO Annex 16 (i.e., date of application for the certificate of airworthiness for the prototype), AIA does not view the proposed rule as meeting the FAA's stated intent to "harmonize with the applicability designation of part 36 with that contained in section 1.7 of ICAO Annex 16, Chapter 1."
The AIA comments that the proposed rule did not make clear how the FAA would handle the date for applicable noise standards for type design changes if reference to part 36 is removed from part 21.
Further, considering the proposal to revise section 36.2, the AIA questions whether section A36.1.1 should continue to specify that the procedures used for noise certification are those in effect on the effective date of this final rule.
FAA Response
The FAA agrees that removing and reserving section 36.2 and deferring to part 21 as proposed is not adequate to determine the applicable noise certification basis. Accordingly, section 36.2 has been retained and revised to address the concerns expressed by AIA in its comment, while maintaining the FAA's intent to use the date of certification application as a basis for part 36 applicability. The heading of section 36.2 is also changed to "Requirements as of date of application." The revisions made to section 36.2 are within the scope of Notice No. 00-08; the FAA is not proposing a new standard. The change was made because of the comment that was received relative to section 36.2. Given the change from Notice No. 00-08 in the manner in which this requirement is implemented, however, this final rule includes a request for comments on the revised section 36.2.
FAA Response
The FAA recognizes that revised section 36.2 in this final rule does not correspond word for word with section 1.7 of ICAO Annex 16, Chapter 1. The FAA believes, however, that the revised section 36.2 is in agreement with the intent of section 1.7 to use the date of certification application as the basis for noise certification standard applicability.
The change to section 36.2 specifies that the part 36 requirements applicable to a specific certification project are those in effect on the date of application for the new, amended, or supplemental type certificate. The FAA also agrees with the AIA's comment that a date need not be specified in section A36.1.1. Accordingly, since section 36.2 will determine the applicable noise certification requirements, no date is specified in section A36.1.1.
Measurement of Airplane Noise Received on the Ground
Measurement of Airplane Noise Received on the Ground
Transport Canada comments that the calibration adjustments of proposed section A36.3.9.1 be applied to the measured sound levels at the output of the analyzer, rather than within the analyzer, as permitted by the current rule. The commenter states that because the algorithms for adjustments are defined and pre-programmed into the analyzer by the applicant, the impact on the final result can be predicted with a high degree of accuracy. The commenter further states that, provided that these correction algorithms are discussed and agreed upon with the certificating authority, it should not make much difference whether they are programmed internally or applied externally to the analyzer. The commenter recommends that the current rule requirement be retained.
FAA Response
FAA Response
The FAA disagrees with the comment. There have been instances in which certification applicants have either not applied, or have incorrectly applied, calibration adjustments to acoustic data. Although such adjustments are usually of small magnitude, their effect can be significant, especially when calculated noise levels are close to the noise level limits specified in part 36.
As the commenter suggests, the effect of applying these adjustments will be the same, whether performed internally or externally to the analyzer. Other adjustments to acoustic data, however, such as microphone and system response corrections, are required to be applied externally to the analyzer, even though it is technically possible with many current systems to apply them internally.
External application of these corrections enables the reconstruction of calculated noise levels from raw acoustic data, if such need should arise. Therefore, even though the internal or external application of these calibration adjustments will have the same effect, the requirement to apply the calibration adjustments externally to the analyzer will remain as proposed to enable the FAA to determine whether these adjustments have been applied correctly. Moreover, the requirement to apply these calibration adjustments externally was included in the revision to ICAO Annex 16 that was approved by the ICAO Council on June 27, 2001.
Reporting of Airplane Center of Gravity
Reporting of Airplane Center of Gravity
Transport Canada recommends that the FAA provide a more detailed explanation of why information on center of gravity is needed and how it will benefit aircraft definition for noise certification purposes.
Airbus (U.K.) also comments that section A36.5.2.5(c), would require noise certification applicants to report the center of gravity range for each series of test runs. The commenter states that it already reports center of gravity in the flight manual, but notes that it currently reports the takeoff center of gravity as being "mid center of gravity" and the approach center of gravity as being "forward center of gravity." The commenter hopes that this reporting practice would continue to be sufficient and that no greater detail would be required.
FAA Response
FAA Response
In section A36.5.2.5, the FAA proposed specific airplane configuration items and engine operating parameters that must be reported to the FAA in the applicant's noise certification compliance report. The FAA explained that each of the proposed configuration items and parameters can affect the airplane noise signature, and that the reporting requirements for these items and parameters already exist under current section A36.5, which specifies that the aircraft configuration and engine performance parameters relative to noise generation be reported.
The FAA proposed in section A36.5.2.5(c) that the test airplane's center of gravity be reported. Transport Canada requests that the FAA provide more detail to explain why reporting is needed. In response to Transport Canada's comment, the airplane center of gravity is an example of an identifying characteristic of the airplane test configuration and an item that could influence measured noise levels. The center of gravity will affect the performance of the airplane and is therefore an integral part of the noise certification flight test and reference procedure. For example, for the approach noise certification, where part 36 requires that the reference airplane configuration be the noisiest configuration, the forward center of gravity position is usually associated with the noisiest airplane configuration. The forward center of gravity position forces the airplane's elevator to push down on the tail thereby increasing airframe drag and, in turn, the power required to maintain the required 3 degree glideslope. Both the increase in airframe drag and required power result in a higher approach noise level.
The final rule specifically identifies the requirement to report center of gravity. Accordingly, the current practice identified by Airbus (U.K.) of reporting center of gravity as "forward" or "mid" for each series of test runs will still be acceptable after the effective date of this final rule. Further, the center of gravity used in demonstrating compliance with part 36 is not required to be reported in the Airplane Flight Manual for noise certification purposes, as Airbus (U.K.) implies. This final rule only specifies that the center of gravity range must be reported in the applicant's noise certification compliance report.
Reporting of Propeller Pitch Angle
Reporting of Propeller Pitch Angle
Transport Canada comments on the requirement to report propeller pitch angle proposed in section A36.5.2.5(d). Because the pitch angle at which a propeller operates is a function of torque demand and propeller revolutions per minute (RPM) the commenter recommended that torque and propeller RPM be reported as a substitute for propeller pitch angle. The commenter stated that Stage 3 noise compliant turboprops generally operate on the principle of governed propeller speed. In other words the propeller RPM is held constant by varying the pitch angle based on torque demand. The commenter further stated that, while torque is a measured parameter, propeller pitch angle is not.
FAA Response
FAA Response
The FAA agrees that torque and propeller RPM are an acceptable substitute for propeller pitch angle. The source noise (i.e., the noise generated by the airplane) adjustments required by section A36.9.3.4 can be made using torque and propeller RPM, and torque and propeller RPM can be more readily determined than propeller pitch angle. Engine torque and propeller rotational speed reporting requirements were proposed and reporting of these parameters is required by section A36.5.2.5(h)(2). Therefore, the proposed requirement to report propeller pitch angle has been removed in this final rule.
Adjustment of Airplane Flight Test Results
Adjustment of Airplane Flight Test Results
Transport Canada comments that section A36.9.1.1 needs an explanatory note to identify the components that are the likely noise sources that must typically be addressed in accounting for the effect that airspeed has on source noise.
FAA Response
FAA Response
The FAA agrees with the commenter's recommendation to identify the components that are the likely noise sources to typically be addressed in accounting for the effect of airspeed on source noise. This type of information is, however, more appropriate for inclusion in guidance material associated with part 36 rather than in part 36 itself. Therefore, information on the components to typically be addressed in accounting for the effect of airspeed on source noise have been included in Advisory Circular 36-4C, which is being published concurrently with this final rule.
Noise Certificates
Noise Certificates
In the proposed rule discussion of compatibility with ICAO standards, the FAA stated that the agency is not authorized to issue Noise Certificates. The proposed rule also notes that while section 36.1581 of part 36 requires that the certificated noise levels be included in the Airplane Flight Manual (AFM), the FAA does not require the AFM to be carried in the airplane. An operations manual that may not contain certificated noise levels is carried in some airplanes. The FAA invited comments on the extent of any problems encountered because noise compliance data are not on board the airplane.
We received one comment concerning this subject. Airbus (U.K.) comments that it has received occasional queries from British Aircraft Corporation (BAC) 1-11 operators who have had difficulties with certain airport authorities when approved noise data have not been available. The commenter states that in the absence of a noise certificate, the AFM is the only FAA-approved manufacturer's document that is, or may be, available to provide substantiation of the noise levels. If the AFM is not carried on board, the commenter recommends that the FAA consider issuing noise certificates.
FAA Response
FAA Response
Because only one comment was received, there is no indication that a widespread problem exists. The FAA, however, is continuing to pursue solutions that would result in sufficient noise data being carried on board aircraft to assist carriers in certain situations.
Noise Certification Reference Procedures
Noise Certification Reference Procedures
Airbus (U.K.) comments on proposed section B36.7(c)(5). Airbus (U.K.) states that the landing approach certification is already done at a range of aircraft configurations in case specific airports need it.
FAA Response
No change is made to the final rule based on this comment. The proposed rule did not propose to change the current section C36.9(b) requirement that bases the approach noise certification on the airplane landing configuration that is the most critical from a noise standpoint. The proposed rule moves the requirement from current section C36.9(b) to section B36.7(c)(5) to more closely align the formatting of part 36 with JAR 36 and ICAO Annex 16. Further, this requirement is consistent with that contained in JAR 36 and ICAO Annex 16.
Noise Certification Test Procedures
Noise Certification Test Procedures
Airbus (U.K.) comments that the approach glide path angle (3 degrees ± 0.5 degrees) proposed in section B36.8(e) does not allow for designs for steeper approaches, despite the existing use of steeper approaches at specific airports. The commenter further states that if an aircraft was now designed specifically for steeper approach and was not capable of the 3 degree approach it might be uncertifiable, or difficult to certify, for noise purposes.
FAA Response
FAA Response
The proposed rule did not propose any change to the current section A36.5(c)(2)(ii) 3 degree approach reference glide path angle or the current section C36.9(c) glide path angle test tolerance. The proposed rule moves the current requirement for approach glide path angle from the current sections to sections B36.7(c)(1) and B36.8(e) to more closely align the formatting of part 36 with JAR 36 and ICAO Annex 16. The approach glide path angle requirements are also consistent with those contained in JAR 36 and ICAO Annex 16.
In addition, while the 3 degree reference glide path angle is currently used to establish the part 36 approach noise certification level, part 36 requirements for noise tests have no bearing on the use of other glide path angles during normal operation of an airplane. The FAA believes, however, that a glide path angle of 3 degrees is the nominal glide path angle that is generally used during normal operations by the class of airplanes to which part 36, subpart B is appropriate. In the case of an airplane that is designed with steep approach capability such that it may not be capable of a 3 degree approach, the FAA may determine that part 36, subpart B is not the appropriate noise certification standard for that airplane. If such a determination were made, an appropriate noise certification basis for the airplane would be developed using U.S. rulemaking procedures including a public comment period. No change to the glide path requirement proposed in sections B36.7(c)(1) and B36.8(e) of the proposed rule is being made.
Corrections and Other Minor Changes to the Proposed Rule
Corrections and Other Minor Changes to the Proposed Rule
This final rule includes some corrections and other minor changes from the proposed rule.
Typographical errors, word omissions, etc., that appeared in the proposed rule have been corrected. Incorrect section and appendix designations have also been corrected. For example, the change in appendix designation from "C" to "B" was not changed in all of the sections that it should have been. Corrections to terminology have been made. For example, in some sections of part 36 the proposed change in terminology from "sideline" to "lateral", or from "turbojet" to "jet" was not carried through in all of the sections that needed to be changed. Errors in the section cross reference table have been corrected.
Sections 36.1(f)(4) and 36.1(f)(6) have been changed to reflect the relocation of the tradeoff provision from current section C36.5(b) to section B36.6.
In section 36.103(a) the reference to the "flight test conditions" of section B36.8 has been changed to "test procedures" to be consistent with the title of section B36.8.
In section B36.4(b), the phrase "* * * obtain a sufficient number * * *" has been changed to "* * * use a sufficient number * * *" since the word "use" more appropriately defines the requirement of this section for a sufficient number of noise measurement points (i.e., locations) to be used in demonstrating the maximum lateral noise level.
The title of section B36.7 has been changed from "Noise certification reference procedures" to "Noise certification reference procedures and conditions" to be consistent with the content of section B36.7.
Section B36.7(b)(3) now contains reference to section B36.7(b)(2) rather than B36.7(b)(1). This change was made because section B36.7(b)(2) is a more appropriate reference to the thrust cutback requirements.
The symbol "EPNLr" meaning "Effective perceived noise level adjusted for reference conditions", has been added to section A36.6. This symbol is used in section A36.9.4.3.1.
In order to reflect the section formatting used by ICAO, the ambient noise requirements of proposed sections A36.4.9.11 and A36.3.9.12 have been adopted in this final rule as a part of a new section A36.3.10, "Adjustments for Ambient Noise". This formatting was used by ICAO in the amendment to ICAO Annex 16 that was approved by the ICAO Council on June 27, 2001.
Draft Advisory Circular 36-4C
Draft Advisory Circular 36-4C
The FAA made draft Advisory Circular (AC) 36-4C available for public comment and published a notice of availability in the Federal Register on August 9, 2000 (65 FR 48794). In the proposed rule, the FAA stated that it intended to publish AC 36-4C concurrently with this final rule. The AIA comments that its review of the draft AC indicates that it encompasses much more explanation and interpretation of the regulatory requirements than the current ICAO Environmental Technical Manual guidance material, which is focused primarily on the use of equivalent procedures. The AIA encourages the FAA to take two important steps regarding AC 36-4C. As a first step, the AIA suggests that there is important work to be done in coordination with manufacturers for buy-in of the document concept before it is published, followed by integration of all sections of the document so that it can be easily used by readers and applicants. Second, the AIA suggests that the FAA recommend to ICAO Working Group 1 that it study the document and consider development of similar internationally accepted guidance material concerning compliance with the ICAO Annex 16 overall noise certification process.
FAA Response
FAA Response
The FAA agrees with the AIA's observation that AC 36-4C encompasses more than the current ICAO Environmental Technical Manual. AC 36-4C was developed to provide comprehensive guidance on implementing the part 36 noise certification standards. In meeting this objective, AC 36-4C covers many more subjects than the ICAO Environmental Technical Manual.
Given that the AIA members constitute a significant segment of the intended users of AC 36-4C, the FAA accepted the assistance of the AIA in editing the draft AC to make it more useful to the intended users. These changes eliminated redundancies and improved the integration of the guidance material with its associated regulatory text. These changes have been incorporated into the final version of AC 36-4C, which is being published concurrently with this final rule.
The FAA agrees with AIA's suggestion that the FAA recommend to ICAO Working Group 1 that it study the document and consider development of similar internationally accepted guidance material concerning compliance with the ICAO Annex 16 overall noise certification process. In fact, ICAO CAEP Working Group 1 has begun development of such a document under its current work program.
Synopsis of the Final Rule
Synopsis of the Final Rule
Part 36 contains noise standards for aircraft type and airworthiness certification. Subparts A, B, and C, and the related appendices A, B, and C, of part 36 prescribe noise levels and test procedures for subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes, including rules governing the issuance of original, amended, or supplemental type certificates.
This final rule adopts changes to part 36 in three major categories. First, there are substantive changes to technical material, such as a revised method for demonstrating the lateral noise certification level for propeller-driven airplanes. These changes are discussed individually in this preamble. Second, there are many changes to regulatory text that will serve to minimize the language differences between part 36 and JAR 36, while having no substantive effect on the regulatory standards of part 36. These text changes are not specifically discussed in this preamble. Third, there are numerous changes to the section designations of current Appendices A, B, and C of part 36 that will more closely align part and JAR 36 formats. Changes in this category will have no substantive effect on the regulatory standards of part 36. The changes in part 36 section designations are shown in a tabular format that identifies current part 36 sections and the corresponding sections of the revision. This redesignation table appears at the end of the section-by-section discussion.
Section-by-Section Discussion
Section-by-Section Discussion
The following is a section-by-section discussion of the substantive changes to 14 CFR part 36 and its appendices. Throughout the final rule, the term "jet" has been used when referring to turbojet and turbofan engines. This changes the terminology in current part 36, which uses the term "turbojet" when referring to both turbojet and turbofan engines. This change will result in the same term being used in 14 CFR part 36 and JAR 36, when referring to turbojet and turbofan engines. For consistency with part 36, this change in terminology has also been included in the aircraft noise related sections of parts 21 and 91. This change to parts 21 and 91 is discussed in the following section-by-section discussion.
Sections 21.93 and 21.183
Sections 21.93 and 21.183
Section 21.93(b)(2) and section 21.183(e)(1), which pertain to the part 36 noise certification requirements, are revised to add the term "jet" and retain the term "turbojet powered" when referring to turbojet or turbofan engines. This change is made to reflect the use of the term "jet" in part 36 and does not change the meaning of the term turbojet as it is used in either the noise certification related sections, or other sections of 14 CFR chapter 1.
Section 36.1
This final rule removes section 36.1(d)(3). Amendments 36-10 (43 FR 28406, June 29, 1978) should have removed this section when it redesignated section 36.1(d)(3) as section 36.1(d)(1)(iii).
Section 36.1(f) and its subparagraphs are revised to incorporate changes in terminology, i.e., from "takeoff" to "flyover," "sideline" to "lateral," and "turbojet" to "jet," and the changes to part 36 appendix and section designations that result from this final rule. Several of these changes were inadvertently omitted from the proposed rule, but are necessary to correctly reflect the changes in part 36 formatting and terminology.
Sections 36.1(f)(4) and 36.1(f)(6) are revised to reflect the relocation of the tradeoff provision from current section C36.5(b) to Section B36.6. These changes are necessary to reflect the change in past 36 formatting.
Section 36.2
The context of section 36.2, "Special retroactive requirements" is revised, and the heading of this section is changed to "Requirements as of date of application". As discussed under the Discussion of Comments section of this preamble, this final rule retains and revises section 36.2, rather than removing this section, as proposed. Revised section 36.2 maintains the intent of the proposal (i.e., to base applicability on the date of certification) while addressing the comments submitted by the AIA.
Current section 36.2 requires that the noise certification applicant show compliance with the part 36 requirements that are in effect on the date of certification. This provision was included in part 36 before the FAA had the authority to prevent the issuance of a type certificate for an aircraft design that did not include reasonable noise reduction design practices. The FAA subsequently received this authority under the Noise Control Act of 1972; the retroactive requirement contained in section 36.2 is no longer necessary. Therefore, this final rule revises section 36.2 to specify compliance with the noise certification requirements that are effective on the date of application for the type certificate, amended type certificate, or supplemental type certificate. This change will harmonize the applicability designation of part 36 with the intent of section 1.7 of ICAO Annex 16, Chapter 1. Given the change from Notice No. 00-08 in the manner in which this requirement is implemented, the FAA invites comments on revised section 36.2.
Section 36.6
This final rule updates the incorporation by the reference form the new measurement requirements specified in section A36.3. These specifications are referred to under new section A36.3, which updates requirements for measurement and analysis systems to address the latest standards and equipment technology. Updated addresses for the International Electrotechnical Commission, American National Standards Institute, and FAA Regional Headquarters are also included in section 36.6.
Section 36.7
Section 36.7 is revised to incorporate changes in terminology, i.e., from "takeoff" to "flyover," "sideline" to "lateral," and "turbojet" to "jet". Section 36.7 is also revised to reflect the changes to part 36 appendix and section designations that result from the changes adopted in this final rule. Several of these changes were inadvertently omitted from the proposed rule, but are included in this final rule to correctly reflect the changes in part 36 formatting and terminology.
Sections 36.101 and 36.103
Two sections, 36.101, Noise measurement, and 36.103, Noise evaluation, were combined to become a new section 36.101, Noise measurement and evaluation. New section 36.101 reflects the combination of current Appendix A and Appendix B into revised Appendix A. These changes more closely align part 36 and JAR 36 formats without introducing any substantive changes. For the same reasons, section 36.201 is redesignated as section 36.103.
Subpart C
Subpart C
The text in subpart C has been reincorporated in subpart B and A and the title for subpart C is reserved.
Section 36.301 is revised by replacing the reference to "Appendix C" with a reference to "Appendix B". This revision reflects the changes in part 36 formatting.
Section 36.1581
Section 36.1581 is revised to incorporate changes in terminology, i.e., from "takeoff" to "flyover," "sideline" to "lateral," and "turbojet" to "jet". Section 36.1581 is also revised to reflect the appendix designation changes. The change in terminology from "takeoff" to "flyover" and from "sideline" to "lateral," and the replacing of the reference to part 36 Appendix C with a reference to Appendix B reflects the changes in part 36 formatting and terminology.
Appendix A--Aircraft Noise Measurement and Evaluation Under § 36.101
Appendix A--Aircraft Noise Measurement and Evaluation Under § 36.101
Revised Appendix A to part 36, Aircraft Noise Measurement and Evaluation under section 36.101 replaces current Appendices A and B. The revised Appendix A to part 36 was developed to maintain a section format consistent with JAR 36, Appendix A, and with ICAO Annex 16, Appendix 2. The text of JAR 36, Appendix A, mirrors ICAO Annex 16, Appendix 2.
Section A36.1 Introduction
Section A36.1 Introduction
Section A36.1.2 is added to state that the noise certification instructions and procedures are intended to ensure uniform results and to permit comparison between tests of various types of aircraft conducted in different geographical locations.
Section A36.2 Noise Certification Test and Measurement Conditions
Section A36.2 Noise Certification Test and Measurement Conditions
Section A36.2 replaces current section A36.1. This new section describes the conditions under which noise certification testing is conducted and the measurement procedures that are required.
The note in section A36.2.1.1 references the guidance material on the use of equivalent procedures contained in Advisory Circular 36-4C, "Noise Standards: Aircraft Type and Airworthiness Certification." Current AC 36-4B, "Noise Certification Handbook," contains guidance material on the use of equivalent procedures. AC 36-4C revises and significantly changes the format and content of the advisory material and is not titled, "Noise Standards: Aircraft Type and Airworthiness Certification." The FAA is issuing new AC 36-4C concurrently with this final rule. The AC 36-4C is referred to as "the current advisory circuit for this part" throughout the regulatory text in this final rule.
Under this final rule, the material in current section A36.1(c)(1) is moved to section A36.2.2.2(a) and revised to remove the word "rain," since rain is included in the term "precipitation."
The material in section A36.1(c)(2) is moved to section A26.2.2.2(b) and the minimum test temperature limit decreased from 36 deg.F (2.2 deg.C) to 14 deg.F (-10 deg.C). The current 36 deg.F (2.2 deg.C) temperature limit is considered unnecessarily restrictive, given that no higher levels of atmospheric absorption, compared with those existing in the current test window, could be encountered by lowering the test day temperature. Under this revised minimum test temperature limit, testing must be conducted in conformance with the operational temperature limit for the noise measuring equipment used.
In Notice No. 00-08, new section A36.2.2.2(c) did not include the current section A36.1(c)(3) provision that permits expanded atmospheric attenuation rates when the dew point and dry bulb temperatures used for obtaining relative humidity are measured with a device which is accurate to within ±0.5 deg.C. As explained in Notice No. 00-08, the allowance for expanded atmospheric attenuation rates was not included because it would continue to be permitted as an equivalent procedure. Subsequent to the publication of Notice No. 00-08, however, the FAA determined that it is more appropriate to retain the allowance for expanded atmospheric attenuation rates as an alternative procedure in the rule text of part 36. Therefore, this allowance is contained in section A36.2.2.2(c) of this final rule.
In addition, the allowance for expanded atmospheric attenuation coefficients has been revised to be consistent with the ICAO Environmental Technical Manual allowance by (1) eliminating the 14 dB/ 100 meter limit on the allowable extension, (2) requiring the use of atmospheric layering in accordance with the requirements of new section A36.2.2.3, and (3) adding an alternative allowance for cases where the peak noy values at the time of tone-corrected perceived noise level (PNLT) occur at frequencies of less than or equal to 400 hertz (Hz). The effect of this change is a further expansion of the allowable test weather conditions, but with the requirement that atmospheric layering be used.
The requirements to obtain meteorological measurements within "25 minutes" of each noise test measurement as required in current section A36.9(b)(3) is changed to "30 minutes" in section A36.2.2.2(g). Thirty minutes is the established international standard in ICAO Annex 16. The FAA was unable to find a technical reason why the meteorological measurement time was originally set at 25 minutes. Based on technical and application considerations, an increment of 5 minutes does not constitute a substantive difference. No known technical criteria exist to assess this minimal time increment. This change will achieve harmonization by adopting a single international standard.
Current section A36.9(d)(3) is revised and moved to section A36.2.2.3. This final rule changes the method used to establish layer depth to reflect the international standard. Current part 36 does not provide specific criteria for determining layer depth, except to require that it be no greater than 100 feet. The criteria for determining layer depth that is adopted by this final rule is the same as that used to specify the onset of required layering, i.e., under weather conditions where the atmospheric attenuation rate changes by more than ±1.6 dB/1000 ft (±0.5 dB/100m) over the sound propagation distance. Under this final rule, the minimum layer depth is established as 100 feet (30 meters). Thus, the layer depth would be 100 feet (30 meters) in cases where the atmospheric rate change criteria would limit the layer depth to less than 100 feet (30 meters).
Section A36.3 Measurement of Aircraft Noise Received on the Ground
Section A36.3 Measurement of Aircraft Noise Received on the Ground
The changes to this section update the requirements for measurement and analysis systems to include the latest standards and equipment technology. These changes were drafted by an international task group having years of knowledge and experience in the noise certification of airplanes. This task group was assembled under Working Group 1 of the ICAO Committee on Aviation Environmental Protection (CAEP) to draft changes that would update the ICAO Annex 16 requirements for measurement and analysis systems. On June 27, 2001, the ICAO Council approved the revision to ICAO Annex 16 that includes the updated requirements.
The primary purpose of the international task group was to address considerations related to the use of digital equipment. Many of these considerations are addressed in the International Electro-Technical Commission (IEC) Standard 61265 and IEC Standard 61260. Accordingly, much of the pertinent text from these standards has been included in the requirements developed by the international task group. These IEC standards also reflect general improvements to instrumentation technology that have occurred over the past decade, although they are not necessarily related to the advent of digital technology. In addition to improvements tied to the IEC standards, several changes that resulted from the work of the task group are linked to general advancements in noise measurement instrumentation.
Revised section A36.3 includes the following specific changes. Current section A36.3 does not include definitions. Section A36.3.1, Definitions, is added to define the terms used in section A36.3. Section A36.3.2, Reference environmental conditions, is added in this final rule to specify the performance of a measurement system.
Section A36.3.3.2 is added and specifies anti-alias requirements for measurement systems that include analog-to-digital signal conversion.
Section A36.3.4.1 adds a requirement that windscreen insertion loss not exceed ±1.5 dB. Section A36.3.9.10 also limits the change in windscreen insertion loss calibration to 0.4 dB from the previous calibration.
Sections A36.3.5.3 and A36.3.5.4 specify microphone sensitivity requirements only at the midband frequencies. This is a simplification of the current part 36 requirement contained in sections A36.3(c)(2)(ii) and A36.3(c)(2)(iii). The new sections also specify more stringent tolerances on microphone sensitivity. Typical microphones that are currently used in part 36 noise certification testing comply with this more stringent microphone sensitivity requirement.
Section A36.3.6.3 adds a tolerance for frequency response of the measurement system.
Section A36.3.6.4 adds a ±0.5 dB tolerance for amplitude fluctuations of a recorded 1 kHz signal on analog tape.
Section A36.3.6.5 adds a tolerance for amplitude linearity, at several specific frequencies, for the measurement system (exclusive of the microphone).
Section A36.3.6.6 requires that the electronic signal level corresponding to the calibration sound pressure level be from 5 db to 30 dB less than the upper boundary of the measurement system level range. This replaces the 10 dB requirement in current part 36, section A36.3(c)(3)(i).
Section A36.3.6.8 adds a requirement for an overload indicator in the recording and reproducing system.
Section A36.3.6.9 allows for measurement system attenuators to operate in known intervals of decibel steps, rather than in equal interval steps, as in current part 36 section A36.3(b)(6).
Section A36.3.7.2(e) adds a requirement that the analyzer operate in real time from 50 Hz through at lease 12 kHz.
Section A36.3.7.3 specifies IEC 61260 class 2 electrical performance requirements as the minimum standard for analyzers. This change updates the specifications for analyzers used in conjunction with part 36 noise certification. Section A36.3.7.3 also includes a note stating that IEC 61260 specifies procedures for testing one-third octave band analysis systems for relative attenuation, anti-aliasing filters, real time operation, level linearity, and filter integrated response (effective bandwidth). The IEC filter bandwidth adjustment method requires that the adjustment be based on more frequencies than are required under current part 36.
Section A36.3.7.4 contains a correction to the slow time-weighting characteristics in current section A36.3(d)(5) (ii) and (iii). Section A36.3.7.6 specifies that the instant in time at which a slow time-weighted sound pressure level is characterized should be 0.75 seconds earlier than the actual readout time. The current requirement specifies that the instant in time at which a sound pressure level is characterized must be the midpoint of the averaging period.
Section A36.3.7.5 specifies a continuous exponential averaging process equation through which simulated slow time-weighted sound pressure levels can be obtained. Section A36.3.7.5 also specifies an equation that results in an approximation of continuous exponential averaging.
Section A36.3.7.7 requires that the analyzer resolution be 0.1 dB or finer. The current requirement, in section A36.3(d)(7) specifies that the amplitude resolution of the analyzer must be at least ±0.25 dB.
Section A36.3.9.1 requires that calibration adjustments be applied to the measured sound levels determined from the output of the analyzer; the current rule permits these calibrations to be applied within the analyzer. As discussed in the disposition of comments, this change is necessary to enable the FAA to determine whether these calibration adjustments have been applied correctly.
Section A36.3.9.3 allows the free-field corrections based on grazing incidence to be applied when the sound incidence angle is within ±30 degrees of grazing incidence.
Section A36.3.9.4 requires that at lease 30 seconds of pink noise be recorded for analog tape recorders; the current section A36.3(e)(4)(ii) requirement is for at lease 15 seconds of pink noise. This change will result in a more accurate pink noise correction and will be the same as the Annex 16 requirement.
Section A36.3.9.6 requires that attenuator accuracy be within 0.1 dB. Section A36.3(b)(6) currently requires that attenuator accuracy be within 0.2 dB. This final rule requires that calibration be checked within six months of each test series, while the current rule does not specify a time period.
Sections A36.3.9.5 and A36.3.9.7 change calibration requirements for the pink noise generator and sound calibrator. This change allow calibration to occur within six months before or after the test instead of requiring it to be within the preceding six months as required by current section A36.3(e)(7).
Section A36.3.9.7 adds a new calibration requirement that limits the change in output of the sound calibrator to not more than 0.2 dB.
Section A36.3.9.8 allows the use of sound calibrators other than pistonphones, as specified by current section A36.3(e)(4). Section A36.3.8.1 specifies the class 1L requirements of IEC 60942, entitled "Electroacoustics--Sound calibrators," as the minimum standard for the sound calibrator.
Section A36.3.9.9 adds a requirement for the recording medium (e.g., tape reel) to carry at least a 10-second duration sound pressure level calibration at its beginning and end. This change more precisely defines the current section A36.3(e)(4) sound pressure level calibration requirement.
Section A36.4 Calculations of Effective Perceived Noise Level From Measured Data
Section A36.4 Calculations of Effective Perceived Noise Level From Measured Data
To further harmonize the formats of part 36 and JAR 36, Table B-1, "Perceived Noisiness (NOYs) as a Function of Sound Pressure Level," referenced in current section B36.13(a), is moved to AC 36-4C. The final rule now uses the equation to obtain the values. The noy values contained in Table B-1 can be calculated for the equations contain in section A36.4.7.3.
A minor technical change is made to the Perceived Noise Level (PNL) equation in section A36.4.2.1(c) (current section B36.3(c)). The more exact term 10/log 2 is replacing the rounded-off term 33.22. The difference between PNL values that are determined using the current and changed equations is not expected to be significant.
To harmonize the formats of part 36 and JAR 36, Figure B1, "Perceived noise level as a function of noys", is moved from current section B36.3(c) to AC36-4C. The perceived noise level values contained in figure B1 can be calculated from the equations contained in section A36.4.2.1(c).
Section A36.4.5.2 changes the value of "d" in the equation for the duration correction factor from 1.0 seconds to 0.5 seconds to reflect current standard practice. The same changes are included in section A36.4.5.4 and section A36.6. This change is a text update to reflect the current practice of using 0.5 second data samples, and has no substantive effect.
To harmonize the formats of part 36 and JAR 36, the material in section B36.5(m) addressing methods for removing the effects of tones resulting from ground plane reflections is moved to AC 36-4C.
Current section B36.9(e), which specifies the duration time interval when the value of PNLT(k) at the 10 dB-down points is 90 PNdB or less, is removed. This provision was eliminated for applications made after September 17, 1971, by Amendment 36-5 (41 FR 35053, August 19, 1976). The text permitting the use of this provision was retained in part 36 unnecessarily.
Section B36.9(f) is also removed. The text contained in current section B36.9(f) was added to part 36 in 1976 to distinguish between the procedure for determining duration for applications made before and after September 17, 1971. This distinction is no longer necessary since current section B36.9(e) is removed. The section B36.9(f) requirement for the aircraft testing procedures to include the 10 dB-down points is contained in section A36.2.3.2 of this final rule.
Section A36.5 Data Reporting
Section A36.5 Data Reporting
Section A36.5.2 requires that the data specified in that section be reported to the FAA in the applicant's noise certification compliance report. While current part 36 does not specifically identify a requirement for the applicant to submit a noise certification compliance report, these reports represent the standard practice that is used by applicants for submitting this information to the FAA. This final rule now requires a report be submitted. Section A36.5.2.5 also identifies the specific airplane configuration items and engine operating parameters that must be reported. Each of these configuration items and parameters can affect airplane noise. The reporting requirement for these items and parameters exists under current section A36.5 which specifies that the aircraft configuration and engine performance parameters relative to noise generation be reported. Further, these configuration items and parameters are also included in the international standard.
Section A36.5.2.5(c) requires that the test airplane's center of gravity be reported to the FAA. Airplane center of gravity is an example of an identifying characteristic of the airplane test configuration, and is an item that could influence measure noise levels. Section A36.5.2.5(d) requires that the airbrake position also be reported. Sections A36.5.2.5(e), (f), and (j), respectively, require reporting of whether the auxiliary power unit (APU) is operating, the status of pneumatic engine bleeds and engine power take-offs, and non-standard airplane test configurations.
Section A36.5.2.5(h)(2) requires reporting of engine performance parameters specifically related to propeller-driven airplanes.
Current section A36.5(d)(3) does not permit an effective perceived noise level (EPNL) to be computed or reported from data from which more than four one-third octave bands in any spectrum within the 10 dB-down points have been excluded from the EPNL computation. This section is removed since correction (adjustment) methods for removing the effects of ambient noise from airplane noise data must be used in lieu of excluding one-third octave bands. Section A36.3.10.2 will specify the ambient noise level limitations that require corrections (adjustments) to be made, and also will reference AC 36-4C, which contains a procedure for removing the affects of ambient noise.
Current section A36.5(e)(4), that addresses the use of equivalent procedures, is removed. The key requirement of the section, that the FAA must approve equivalent procedures, is already addressed in section 36.101. Additional information on the use of equivalent procedures is provided in the note contained in section A36.2.1.1.
Section A36.6 Nomenclature: Symbols and Units
Section A36.6 Nomenclature: Symbols and Units
Section A36.6, Nomenclature: Symbols and units replaces current section A36.7, symbols and units. Section A36.6 incorporates ICAO Annex 16 symbols and units, while retaining the English units. This change is made to more closely align part 36 with JAR 36. No substantive technical changes are anticipated to result from incorporation of the ICAO Annex 16 symbols and units.
Section A36.7 Sound Attenuation in Air
Section A36.7 Sound Attenuation in Air
Currently, atmospheric attenuation rates of sound with distance must use be determined in accordance with Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. (SAE), Aerospace Recommended Practice (ARP) 866A (SAE ARP 866A), as specified in current section A36.9(c). In this final rule, section A36.7.2 contains the actual formulation (equations) from SAE ARP 866A. These equations are provided in both the International System of Units and the English System of Units. Whereas equations are continuous and provide consistent values, tables and graphs can provide minor differences. Accordingly, the tables are being removed and applicants must use the equation. This change will further harmonize part 36 and JAR 36 and is not expected to result in any substantive difference in attenuation rates.
Section A36.9 Adjustment of Airplane Flight Test Results
Section A36.9 Adjustment of Airplane Flight Test Results
The current distinction between allowable/required positive and negative correction procedures, contained in current sections A36.11(a)(1) and (2), is not included in new section A36.9.1. This distinction is no longer relevant given: (1) The evolution of data correction procedures since part 36 was originally promulgated in 1969 and, (2) the need for noise certification levels to reflect airplane noise characteristics as accurately as possible. Prior to any noise certification compliance test, a noise certification applicant is required to identify, and obtain FAA approval of, any planned or anticipated data correction that is not a mandatory correction procedure under part 36.
Current section A36.1(b)(3) is deleted because it is obsolete. This section requires that the corrections prescribed in current section A36.5(d) be made when the height of the ground at a noise measuring station differs from that of the nearest point on the runway by more than 20 feet. A 20-foot height allowance/tolerance could change the final EPNL value by several tenths of a dB under some circumstances. Under current noise certification practices, corrections (adjustments) are made over the sound propagation path from the microphone to airplane height as part of normal data corrections (adjustments). These corrections (adjustments) are specified in current section A36.11 and new section A36.9.
Section A36.9.1.1(d) will require that the effect that airspeed has on source noise be considered with regard to the difference between test day airplane speed and the airplane reference flight profile speed.
The symbols and figures used to described the takeoff and approach profiles in current sections A36.11(b) and (c), are replaced by the JAR 36 symbols and figures that have been incorporated into section A36.9.2. There are no substantive changes to the takeoff and approach profile technical requirements as a result of these changes.
Section A36.9.3.2.1 provides equations that enable data adjustments to be made using either the English System of Units or International System of Units.
The material in current section B36.11(c) will be moved to section A36.9.3.2.2 and revised to specify the adjustment for multiple peak values of PNLT. This adjustment is based upon the difference in corrected PNLT values, rather than upon APNL as in the current part 36. This change more clearly defines the intent of the multiple peak correction.
Under section A36.9.3.3.2 a correction term is added to account for the difference between (1) the measured airspeed during the noise certification flight test and (2) the airspeed calculated for the noise certification reference flight procedure. This correction term is added to the duration correction ([Delta]2) contained in current section A36.11(e). The speed correction term is defined as 10 log (V/ Vr), where V is the airplane test speed and Vr is the airplane reference speed. This change specifies the speed correction that is required by current section A36.11(f)(1).
Appendix B--Noise Levels for Transport Category and Jet Airplanes Under § 36.103
Appendix B--Noise Levels for Transport Category and Jet Airplanes Under § 36.103
Appendix B will include the material from current appendix C. This will make Appendix B essentially the same as JAR 36, section 1, subpart B.
Section B36.3 Reference Noise Measurement Points
The material in current section C36.3 is moved to section B36.3 and revised as follows. The term "takeoff" in current section C36.3(a) is replaced with the term "flyover" in section B36.3(b). The term "sideline" in current section C36.3(c) is replaced with "lateral" in section B36.3(a). These terminology changes harmonize the part 36 terminology with that used in JAR 36 and ICAO Annex 16.
Section B36.3 Reference Noise Measurement Points
Section B36.3(a)(2) will include a simplified test procedure that may be used in determining the sideline (lateral) noise certification level for propeller-driven airplanes. This procedure is also contained in JAR 36 and ICAO Annex 16. For propeller-driven airplanes, it can be difficult to establish the maximum lateral noise level specified under current section C36.3(c) because this noise level may occur at a very low height. There is usually a significant difference in noise levels between the port and starboard sides of a propeller-driven airplane. By measuring full-power noise at a predetermined point (650 meters) below the takeoff flight path, many of the difficulties that arise because of the directional nature of the noise from propeller-driven airplanes when measured at the conventional lateral site will be eliminated. Ground effects that distort measurements will also be reduced.
Under the current requirement, it is difficult to judge the airplane altitude at which the peak noise level occurs, and in the past this has required applicants to conduct as many as 30 flight tests to satisfy certifying authorities, an expensive process. Moreover, the current method for testing propeller-driven airplanes has generally resulted in low confidence in accuracy and repeatability of measurements. The simplified test procedure is available as an alternative to the current section C36.3(c) method for tests conducted before August 7, 2002, after which it will become the sole method for demonstrating sideline (lateral) noise level compliance.
Current section C36.3(b) is moved to section B36.3(c) and text is added to define the approach measurement point relative to the runway threshold. This change will clearly describe the geometric relationship between the test airplane and the ground, and will harmonize part 36 and JAR 36.
Current section A36.1(b)(7), allows (when approved) for the sideline (lateral) noise certification level demonstration for jet airplanes to be based on the assumption that the peak sideline (lateral) noise level occurs at an airplane altitude of 1,000 feet (1,440 feet for Stage 1 or Stage 2 four-engine airplanes). Notice No. 00-08 proposed to move this procedure to the guidance material in AC 36-4C. Subsequent to the publication of Notice No. 00-08, however, the FAA determined that it is more appropriate to retain this procedure in part 36 as an alternative procedure for determining the maximum lateral noise level. This procedure is included in section B36.3(a)(1). In addition, the target altitude and target altitude tolerance requirements of this section are adjusted so that they are now consistent with those of the similar procedure contained in section 2.1.3.2 of the ICAO Environment Technical Manual.
Section B36.4 Test Noise Measurement Points
Section B36.4 Test Noise Measurement Points
Most of the requirements of current section A36.1(b)(7) are moved to section B36.4.
Section B36.4(b) requires that, in demonstrating the sidelines (lateral) noise certification level for propeller-driven airplanes, noise measurements be made at symmetrically located noise measurements points on either side of the runway for each and every noise measurement point along the main sideline (lateral) noise measurement line. This change is made because of the asymmetric nature of propeller noise. Part 36 has required simultaneous measurement at one test measurement point opposite the main lateral measurement line to account for the possibility of lateral noise asymmetry. In the case of propeller-driven airplanes, however, whose noise field is known to be asymmetrical, having only one measuring point opposite the main lateral measurement line is not adequate to define the peak lateral noise on the other side of runway from the main lateral line. This change will further harmonize part 36 and JAR 36.
Section B36.5 Maximum Noise Levels
Section B36.5 Maximum Noise Levels
The material in current section C36.5 is moved to section B36.5 and revised to include minor format and language changes to harmonize with JAR 36. Amendment 36-15 "Standards Governing the Noise Certification of Aircraft" (53 FR 26360, May 6, 1988) removed section C36.5(c); the references to section C36.5(c) in current section C36.5(a) should have been removed under that amendment but was not. The reference is removed in this final rule.
In order to further harmonize part 36 and JAR 36, the term "sideline" has been changed to "lateral" in each place that it appears throughout section B36.5. This change in terminology does not affect the noise measurement/analysis procedures or noise limits. Similarly, the term "takeoff" has been changed to "flyover." No change in test procedures should be inferred from this change.
Section B36.6 Trade-offs
Section B36.6 Trade-offs
The requirements of current section C36.5(b) are moved to section B36.6. The reference to section 367(d)(3)(i)(B), in current section C36.5(b), is changed to section 36.7(d)(1)(ii) in the new section. This section reference should have been changed in 1988 by Amendment 36-15.
Section B36.7 Noise Certification Reference Procedures
Section B36.7 Noise Certification Reference Procedures
The takeoff and approach reference and test limitation in current sections C36.7 and C36.9 are moved to sections B36.7 and B36.8. This material is also revised as follows.
Section B36.7(b)(1) requires the use of "average engine" performance in defining the takeoff thrust for the reference takeoff procedure. Specifying the use of "average engine" performance further harmonizes the part 36 takeoff reference procedure with JAR and ICAO Annex 16, and will eliminate confusion in compliance with the requirement.
Section B36.7(b)(1) also specifies "Takeoff thrust/power" as the maximum available for normal operations given in the performance section of the airplane flight manual for the reference atmospheric conditions given in section B36.7(a)(5).
Currently section C36.7(b)(2) specifies different minimum cutback altitudes for jet and propeller-driven airplanes. Section B36.7(b)(1)(ii) contains the same minimum cutback altitude for all airplanes, which is the altitude specified in current section C36.7(b)(2) for jet airplanes. Since the selection of the minimum cutback altitude is determined by the minimum safe altitude for cutback initiation, there is no reason to distinguish between propeller-driven and jet airplanes. It is the FAA's understanding that this change will not have a substantive effect in practice.
Since cutback initiation heights greater than 1,500 feet are generally chosen for propeller-driven airplanes and this height is greater than both the current and revised part 36 minimum requirements, the FAA has determined that there will be no change in practice.
In this final rule, the requirements of section A36.1(b)(2) are moved to section B36.7(b)(3) and revised to require that, for tests conducted on or after August 7, 2002, the lateral (sideline) noise level be demonstrated using full takeoff power throughout the takeoff flight path. Before that date, the lateral noise level may be demonstrated using the current section A36.1(b)(2) procedure, under which both the takeoff (flyover) and sideline (lateral) noise certification levels are determined using a single reference flight path that may include a thrust cutback. This change reflects the intent of the international standard that the lateral measurement be based on the full-power condition. Since the revised lateral procedure might result in increased stringency, the use of this procedure is optional for tests conducted before August 7, 2002. This change will mainly affect three and four engine airplanes.
The takeoff reference speed requirement specified in current section C36.7(e)(1) is revised to be consistent with the takeoff reference speed contained in JAR 36 and ICAO Annex 16. The all-engine operating climb speed range (V2+10 to V2+20 kts) specified in section B36.7(b)(4) represents the typical range of takeoff initial climb speed seen in normal operation for most airplanes. For some airplanes, this change to part 36 could result in an increase of up to 10 knots in the noise certification reference takeoff speed relative to the current part 36 reference takeoff speed requirements. For the affected airplanes, the increased takeoff speed could result in some noise level reduction at the sideline (lateral) noise measurement point with a resulting increase in noise level at the takeoff (flyover) noise measurement point. The FAA has found the change in takeoff reference speed to be acceptable because of this tradeoff of sideline (lateral) and takeoff (flyover) noise levels, although it might not be a one-to-one tradeoff.
In section B36.7(b)(5) the FA is adding a definition of configuration, which includes specific configuration elements, based on certification experience, that can have a effect on source noise. There is no change in takeoff configuration requirement.
Section B36.7(b)(7) defines "average engine" as the average of all the certification compliant engines used during the airplane flight tests up to and during certification when operating within the limitations and according to the procedures given in the Flight Manual.
Current section C36.9(d) requires that all engines must operate at approximately the same power or thrust for approach tests conducted to demonstrate compliance with part 36. In this final rule, this specific requirement is removed, and instead, section A36.9.3.4 will require that source noise adjustments be applied to account for any differences between test and reference conditions, in engine parameters that affect engine noise (e.g., corrected low pressure rotor speed). This change will meet the intent of the current part 36 requirement and also further harmonizes with JAR 36.
Current section C36.9(e)(1), reference approach speed, is revised to incorporate the use of 1-g stall-based approach speeds by basing the approach noise certification reference speed on the reference landing speed (VREF) that is used for the airworthiness certification. In Notice No. 95-17, published on January 18, 1996 (61 FR 1260), the FAA proposed to redefine the reference stall speeds for transport category airplanes as the 1-g stall speed instead of the minimum speed obtained in the stalling maneuver. Notice No. 95-17 proposed that a definition of VREF would be added to 14 CFR part 1. Since a final rule based on Notice No. 95-17 has not been published, the definition of VREF has been included in this final rule. The definition of VREF is the only element of Notice No. 95-17 that has been included in this final rule. In section B36.7(c)(2), VREF is defined as "the speed of the airplane, in a specified landing configuration, at the point where it descends through the landing screen height in the determination of the landing distance for manual landings." The change to section C36.9(e)(1) is also consistent with a change to ICAO Annex 16 that was approved by the ICAO Council on June 27, 2001. Current section C36.9(e)(1) is redesignated as section B36.7(c)(2).
Section B36.8 Noise Certification Test Procedures
Section B36.8 Noise Certification Test Procedures
Current sections A36.1(d)(5) and A36.1(d)(7), which contain limitations on the difference between the test weight and the maximum takeoff/approach weight for which noise certification is requested, are replaced by section B36.8(d). The current limitations help insure the integrity of the final certification results by indirectly limiting the magnitude of the EPNL adjustments that may be applied to the test data in normalizing to the noise certification reference conditions. Section B36.8(d) will directly limit the magnitude of the correction by specifying a limitation on the EPNL adjustment that can be made when correcting between test weight and maximum certification weight.
The current requirements of section A36.5(d)(5) are revised and moved to section B36.8(f). The amounts of adjustment permitted when equivalent test procedures are different from the reference procedures remain unchanged, except that the amended requirements do not specify that tradeoffs are permitted when comparing adjusted levels against the appendix B noise level limits, for the purpose of determined adjustment limits. Several interpretations of the current requirement are possible as to whether this final rule represents a more stringent or less stringent adjustment limitation as compared with the current limitation. The FAA believes that the change to remove the tradeoff provision from the current limitation and base the limitation solely on the difference between the adjusted noise levels and the maximum noise levels in section B36.5 meets the intent of the adjustment limitation, as stated above, and clarifies ambiguity in its interpretation. The change also results in harmonization of the adjustment limitation with that in JAR 36 and ICAO Annex 16.
Section B36.8(g) will revise the test speed tolerance specified in current sections C36.7(e)(1) and C36.9 (e)(3). Current section C36.7(e)(1) specifies that takeoff tests must be conducted at the test day speeds ±3 knots. Current section C36.9(e)(3) specifies that a tolerance of ±3 knots may be used throughout the approach noise testing. Section B36.8(g) will specify that during takeoff, lateral, and approach tests, the airplane variation in instantaneous indicated airspeed must be maintained within ±3% of the average airspeed between the 10 dB-down points. In the final rule, the instantaneous indicated airspeed is determined from the pilot's airspeed indicator. If the instantaneous indicated airspeed exceeds ±3 kt (±5.5 km/h) of the average airspeed over the 10 dB-down points, and is determined by the FAA representative on the flight deck as the result of atmospheric turbulence, then that flight must be rejected for noise certification purposes.
Appendix G--Noise Requirements for Propeller-Driven Small Airplanes and Commuter Category Airplanes Under Subpart F
Appendix G--Noise Requirements for Propeller-Driven Small Airplanes and Commuter Category Airplanes Under Subpart F
Section G36.105 Sensing, Recording, and Reproducing Equipment
To maintain the correct cross reference, this final rule changes the references in paragraph (f) from section A36.3(e) to A36.3.8 and A36.3.9.
Section G36.105 Sensing, Recording, and Reproducing Equipment
Appendix H--Noise Requirements for Helicopters Under Subpart H Section H36.101 Noise Certification Test and Measurement Conditions.
To maintain the correct cross reference, this final rule amends section H36.101(d)(1) by removing the reference to "appendix B" and adding "appendix A."
Section H36.111 Reporting and Correcting Measured Data
Section H36.111 Reporting and Correcting Measured Data
To maintain the correct cross reference, this final rule amends section H36.111(c)(3) by removing the reference "A36.3(f)(3)" and adding "A36.3.10.1."
Section H36.201 Noise Evaluation in EPNdB
To maintain the correct cross reference, this final rule amends section H36.201 by: (1) Removing the reference to "appendix B" in paragraph (a) of this section and adding "appendix A," and (2) removing the reference to "B36.5(a)" in paragraph (b) of this section and adding "A36.4.3.1(a)."
Sections 91.801 and 91.851
Section 901.801(a)(1), 91.801(a)(2), 91.801(c), 91.801(d), and 91.851, which are related to the part 36 noise certification requirements, are revised to incorporate the term "jet" in addition to "turbojet" when referring to turbojet or turbofan engines. This change is made to reflect the use of the term "jet" in part 36 and does not change the meaning of the term turbojet as it is used in either the noise certification related sections, or other sections of 14 CFR chapter 1.
Redesignation Table for Appendices A and B
Cross Reference Table
Old section New section
A36.1 A36.1, A36.2
A36.1(a) A36.1.1, A36.2.1.1
A36.1(b) A36.2.2
A36.1(b)(1) A36.2.3.2, B36.3
A36.1(b)(2) A36.7(b)(3)
A36.1(b)(3) Deleted
A36.1(b)(4) A36.2.2.1
A36.1(b)(5) A36.2.2.4
A36.1(b)(6) A36.2.2.1
A36.1(b)(7) A36.9.3.5, A36.9.3.5.1, B36.4(b)
A36.1(c) A36.2.2.2
A36.1(c)(1) A36.2.2.2(a)
A36.1(c)(2) A36.2.2.2(b)
A36.1(c)(3) A36.2.2.2(c)
A36.1(c)(4) A36.2.2.2(e)
A36.1(c)(5) A36.2.2.2(f)
A36.1(d)(1) B36.8(b), B36.2
A36.1(d)(2) A36.2.3.1
A36.1(d)(3) A36.2.3.2, A36.2.3.3
A36.1(d)(4) B36.7(b), B36.8
A36.1(d)(5) B36.8(d)
A36.1(d)(6) B36.7(c), B36.8(e)
A36.1(d)(7) B36.8.(d)
A36.1(d)(8) A36.2.3.3
A36.3 A36.3
A36.3(a) A36.3.3
A36.3(b) A36.3.3.1
A36.3(c)(2)(i-iv), A36.3(f)(1) A36.3.5
A36.3(c)(2)(v) A36.3.4
A36.3(c)(3) A36.3.6
A36.3(d) A36.3.7
A36.3(e)(1-6), A36.3(f)(2) A36.3.9
A36.3(f)(2-4) A36.3.10.1
A36.3(e)(7) A36.3.8
A36.5(a) A36.5.1.1, A36.5.1.2, A36.5.1.3
A36.5(b)(1) A36.5.2.1
A36.5(b)(2) A36.5.2.2
A36.5(b)(3) A36.5.2.3
A36.5(b)(4) A36.5.2.4
A36.5(b)(5)(i-vi) A36.5.2.5
A36.5(b)(vii) A36.5.2.5(i)
A36.5(b)(6) A36.2.3.2, A36.2.3.3
A36.5.2.5(i)
A36.5(c) A36.5.3
A36.5(c)(1) B36.7(a)(5)
A36.5(c)(2) B36.3(c), B36.7(b)(6), B36.7(c)(1),
B36.7(c)(4)
A36.5(d)(1) A36.5.3.1, A36.9, B36.8(c)
A36.5(d)(2) A36.9.1
A36.5(d)(2)(i)-(iv) B36.8(d)
A36.5(d)(3) A36.3.10.2
A36.5(d)(4) A36.3.10.2
A36.5(d)(5) B36.8(f)
A36.5(e)(1) A36.5.4.1
A36.5(e)(2) A36.5.4.2
A36.5(e)(3) A36.5.4.3
A36.5(e)(4) Deleted
A36.7 A36.6, A36.9.5, A36.9.6
A36.9(a) A36.9.1.1
A36.9(b)(1) A36.2.2.4
A36.9(b)(2) A36.2.2.2(b)
A36.9(b)(3) A36.2.2.2(g)
A36.9(c) A36.7
A36.9(d)(1) A36.9.1, A36.9.1.1
A36.9(d)(2) A36.2.2.2(d)
A36.9(d)(3) A36.2.2.3
A36.11(a) A36.9.1
A36.11(a)(1) Deleted
A36.11(a)(2) Deleted
A36.11(a)(3)(i) A36.9.1, B36.7
A36.11(a)(3)(ii) A36.9.1.1
A36.11(a)(3)(iii) A36.9.1.1
A36.11(a)(3)(iv) A36.9.1.1, A36.9.3.4
A36.11(a)(3)(v) A36.9.1
A36.11(b)(1)(i-ii) A36.9.2.1
A36.11(b)(2) A36.9.3.1, A36.9.4.1
A36.11(b)(3) A36.9.3.2(a)
A36.11(c) A36.9.2.2
A36.11(c)(1) A36.9.3.2(a-c)
A36.11(c)(2) A36.9.3.2(a)
A36.11(d)(1-3) A36.9.3, A36.9.3.1, A36.9.3.2.1,
A36.9.3.2.1.1, A36.9.3.2.1.2
A36.11(e)(1-2) A36.9.3.3.1, A36.9.3.3.2
A36.11(f) B36.4(a), AC 36-4C
A36.11(f)(1) A36.9.1.2
A36.11(f)(2) A36.9.1.2
A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii) A36.9.4
B36.1 A36.1, A36.1.1, A36.4.1.3
B36.1(a) B36.4.1.3(a)
B36.1(b) A36.4.1.3(b)
B36.1(c) A36.4.1.3(c)
B36.1(d) A36.4.1.3(d)
B36.1(e) A36.4.1.3(e)
B36.3 A36.4.2.1
B36.3(a) A36.4.2.1(a)
B36.3(b) A36.4.2.1(b)
B36.3(c) A36.4.2.1(c), AC 36-4B
B36.5 A36.4.3.1
B36.5(a) A36.4.3.1(a)
B36.5(b) A36.4.3.1(b)
B36.5(c) A36.4.3.1(c)
B36.5(d) A36.4.3.1(d)
B36.5(e) A36.4.3.1(e)
B36.5(f) A36.4.3.1(f)
B36.5(g) A36.4.3.1(g)
B36.5(h) A36.4.3.1(h)
B36.5(i) A36.4.3.1(i)
B36.5(j) A36.4.3.1(j)
B36.5(k) A36.4.3.1(j)
B36.5(l) A36.4.3.1(j)
B36.5(m) A36.4.3.1(j), AC 36-4C
B36.5(n) A36.4.4.2
B36.7 A36.4.4
B36.7(a) A36.4.4.1, A36.4.4.1 Note 1
B36.7(b) A36.4.4.1-Note 2
B36.9 A36.4.5.1
B36.9(a) A36.4.5.2
B36.9(b) A36.4.5.3
B36.9(c) A36.4.5.4
B36.9(d) A36.4.5.5
B36.9(e) Deleted
B36.9(f) Deleted
B36.11(a) A36.4.6
B36.11(b) Deleted
B36.11(c) A36.9.3.2.2
B36.13(a) A36.4.7.1, Table A1 moved to AC 36-4C
B36.13(a)(1), (2), (3) A36.4.7.2(a-c)
B36.13(b) A36.4.7.3
B36.13(c) A36.4.7.4
C36.1
B36.1
C36.3(a) B36.3(b)
C36.3(b) B36.3.(c)
C36.3(c) B36.3(a)
C36.5(a) B36.5
C36.5(a)(1) B36.5(a)
C36.5(a)(2) B36.5(b)
C36.5(a)(2)(i) B36.5(b)(1)
C36.5(a)(2)(ii) B36.5(b)(2)
C36.5(a)(3) B36.5(c)
C36.5(a)(3)(i)(A) B36.5(c)(1)(i)
C36.5(a)(3)(i)(B) B36.5(c)(1)(ii)
C36.5(a)(3)(i)(C) B36.5(c)(1)(iii)
C36.5(a)(3)(ii) B36.5(c)(2)
C36.5(a)(3)(iii) B36.5(c)(3)
C36.5(b)(1) B36.6
C36.5(b)(2) B36.6
C36.5(b)(3) B36.6
C36.7(a) B36.7(a)(3)
C36.7(b) B36.7(b)(1)(i)
C36.7(b)(1) B36.7(b)(1)(i)
C36.7(b)(2) B36.7(b)(1)(ii)
C36.7(c) B36.7(b)(2)
C36.7(d) B36.7(b)(5)
C36.7(e)(1) B36.7(b)(4)
C36.7(e)(1) Next to last B36.8(g)
sentence
sentence
C36.7(e)(2) B36.7(b)(4)
C36.7(e)(3) B36.7(a)(5), A36.9.1
C36.9.(a) B36.7(a)(3), B36.7(c)(1)
C36.9(b) B36.7(c)(3) & B36.7(c)(4)
C36.9(c) B36.7(c)(1), B36.7(c)(3)
C36.9(d) Deleted
C36.9(e)(1) B36.7(c)(2)
C36.9(e)(2) B36.7(c)(2)
C36.9(e)(3) B36.8(g)
Cross Reference Table
New section Old section
A36.1 … A36.1, B36.1
A36.1.1 … A36.1(a), B36.1
A36.1.2 … New section
A36.1.3 … New section
A36.2 … A36.1
A36.2.1 … A36.1(a)
A36.2.1.1 … A36.1(a)
A36.2.2 … A36.1(b)
A36.2.2.1 … A36.1(b)(4), A36.1(b)(6)
A36.2.2.2 … A36.1(c)
A36.2.2.2(a) … A36.1(c)(1)
A36.2.2.2(b) … A36.1(c)(2), A36.9(b)(2)
B36.2.2.2(c) … A36.1(c)(3)
B36.2.2.2(d) … A36.9(d)(2)
A36.2.2.2(e) … A36.1(c)(4)
A36.2.2.2(f) … A36.1(c)(5)
A36.2.2.2(g) … A36.9(b)(3)
A36.2.2.3 … A36.9(d)(3)
A36.2.2.4 … A36.1(b)(5), A36.1(d)
A36.2.3 … A36.1(d)
A36.2.3.1 … A36.1(d)(2)
A36.2.3.2 … A36.1(b)(1), A36.1(d)(3),
A36.5(b)(6)
A36.2.3.3 … A36.1(d)(8), A36.5(b)(6)
A36.3 … A36.3
A36.3.1 … New
A36.3.2 … New
A36.3.3 … A36.3(a)
A36.3.3.1 … A36.3(b)
A36.3.3.2 … New
A36.3.4 … A36.3(c)(2)(v)
A36.3.5 … A36.3(c)(2)(i-iv),
A36.3(f)(1)
A36.3.6 … A36.3(c)(3)
A36.3.7 … A36.3(d)
A36.3.8 … A36.3.(e)(7)
A36.3.9 … A36.3(e)(1-6), A36.3(f)(2)
A36.3.10.1 … A36.3(f)(2-4)
A36.3.10.2 … A36.5(d)(3-4)
A36.4 … B36.1
A36.4.1 … B36.1
A36.4.1.1 … B36.1
A36.4.1.2 … B36.1
A36.4.1.3 … B36.1
A36.4.2 … B36.3
A36.4.2.1 … B36.3; AC 36-4C
A36.4.3 … B36.5
A36.4.3.1 … B36.5(a-m)
A36.4.3.2 … B36.5(n)
A36.4.4 … B36.7
A36.4.4.1 … B36.7 (a) & (b)
A36.4.4.2 … B36.5(n)
A36.4.5 … B36.9
A36.4.5.1 … B36.9
A36.4.5.2 … B36.9(a)
A36.4.5.3 … B36.9(b)
A36.4.5.4 … B36.9(c)
A36.4.5.5 … B36.9(d)
A36.4.6 … B36.11
A36.4.6 … B36.11(a)
A36.4.7 … B36.13
A36.4.7.1 … B36.13(a)
A36.4.7.2 … B36.13(a) (1-3)
A36.4.7.3 … B36.13(b)
A36.4.7.4 … B36.13(c)
A36.5 … A36.5
A36.5.1 … A36.5(a)
A36.5.1.1 … A36.5(a)
A36.5.1.2 … A36.5(a)
A36.5.1.3 … A36.5(a)
A36.5.2 … A36.5(b)
A36.5.2.1 … A36.5(b)(1)
A36.5.2.2 … A36.5(b)(2)
A36.5.2.3 … A36.5(b)(3)
A36.5.2.4 … A36.5(b)(4)
A36.5.2.5 … A36.5(b)(5)
A36.5.3 … A36.5(c)
A36.5.3.1 … A36.5(d)(1)
A36.5.4 … A36.5(e)
A36.5.4.1 … A36.5(e)(1)
A36.5.4.2 … A36.5(e)(2)
A36.5.4.3 … A36.5(e)(3)
A36.6 … A36.7
A36.7.1-A36.7.3 … A36.9(c)
A36.8 … New section--Reserved
A36.9 … A36.5(d)(1), A36.11
A36.9.1 … A36.5(d)(2), A36.9(d)(1),
A36.11(a), A36.11(a)(3)(i)
& (v)
A36.9.1.1 … A36.9(a), A36.9(d)(1),
A36.11(a)(3)(ii-iii),
A36.11(a)(3)(iv)
A36.9.1.2 … A36.11(f) (1-2)
A36.9.2 … A36.11(b) & (c)
A36.9.2.1 … A36.11(b)(1)(i-ii)
A36.9.2.2 … A36.11(c)
A36.9.3 … A36.11
A36.9.3.1 … A36.11(a), A36.11(f)(1)
A36.9.3.2(a) … A36.11(b)(3), A36.11(c)(2)
A36.9.3.2.(b) … New section
A36.9.3.2.1 … A36.11(d)(1-3)
A36.9.3.2.1.1 … A36.11(d)(1)(ii)
A36.9.3.2.1.2 … A36.11(d)(1)(ii)
A36.9.3.2.2 … A36.11(c)
A36.9.3.3 … A36.11(e)
A36.9.3.3.1 … A36.11(e)(1)-(2)
A36.9.3.3.2 … A36.11(e)
A36.9.3.4 … A36.11(a)(3)(iv)
A36.9.3.4.1 … A36.11(a)(3)(iv)
A36.9.3.4.2 … A36.11(a)(3)(iv)
A36.9.3.5 … A36.1(b)(7)
A36.9.3.5.1 … A36.1(b)(7)
A36.9.4 … A36.11(f)(2) (i-ii)
A36.9.4.1 … A36.11(b)(2), A36.11(f)(2)(i-
ii)
A36.9.4.2 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)
A36.9.4.2.2 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)
A36.9.4.2.3 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)
A36.9.4.3 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)
A36.9.4.4 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)
A36.9.4.4.1 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)
A36.9.5 … A36.7
A36.9.6 … A36.7
B36.1 … C36.1
B36.2 … A36.1(d)(1)
B36.3(a) … C36.3(c)
B36.3(b) … C36.3(a)
B36.3(c) … A36.5(c)(2), C36.3(b)
B36.4(a) … A36.11(f)
B36.4(b) … A36.1(b)(7)
B36.5 … C36.5(a)
B36.5(a) … C36.5(a)(1)
B36.5(b) … C36.5(a)(2)
B36.5(b)(1) … C36.5(a)(2)(i)
B36.5(b)(2) … C36.5(a)(2)(ii)
B36.5(c) … C36.5(a)(3)
B36.5(c)(1)(i) … C36.5(a)(3)(i)(A)
B36.5(c)(1)(ii) … C36.5(a)(3)(i)(B)
B36.5(c)(1)(iii) … C36.5(a)(3)(i)(C)
B36.5(c)(2) … C36.5(a)(3)(ii)
B36.5(c)(3) … C36.5(a)(3)(iii)
B36.6 … C36.5(b)(1)-(3)
B36.7(a)(1) …
B36.7(a)(2) … A36.11(a)(3)(i)
B36.7(a)(3) … C36.7(a), C36.9(a)
B36.7(a)(4) … New section--Reserved
B36.7(a)(5) … A36.5(c)(1), C36.7(e)(3)
B36.7(b)(1) … C36.7(b)
B36.7(b)(2) … C36.7(c)
B36.7(b)(3) … A36.1(b)(2)
B36.7(b)(4) … C36.7(e)(1-2)
B36.7(b)(5) … C36.7(d)
B36.7(b)(6) … A36.5(c)(2)
B36.7(b)(7) … New section
B36.7(c) … C36.9
B36.7(c) … C36.9(a)
B36.7(c)(1) … C36.5(c)(2), C36.9(c)
B36.7(c)(2) … C36.9(e)(1), C36.9(e)(2)
B36.7(c)(3) … C36.9(b-c)
B36.7(c)(4) … C36.5(c)(2)
B36.7(c)(5) … C36.9(b)
B36.8(a) … New section
B36.8(b) … A36.1(d)(1)
B36.8(c) … A36.5(d), A36.11(a)
B36.8(d) … A36.1(d)(2)(i-iv)
B36.8(e) … A36.1(d)(6)
B36.8(f) … A36.5(d)(5)
B36.8(g) … C36.7(e)(1), C36.9(e)(3)
Paperwork Reduction Act
Paperwork Reduction Act
Notice No. 00-08, Noise Certification Standards for Subsonic Jet Airplanes and Subsonic Transport Category Large Airplanes, contained proposed information collection requirements. As required by the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3507(d)), the FAA submitted a copy of the proposed rule to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) for its review.
The agency did not receive any comments concerning this collection of information. The collection of information was approved and assigned OMB Control Number 2120-0659.
Compatibility With ICAO Standards
Compatibility With ICAO Standards
In keeping with the U.S. obligations under the Convention on International Civil Aviation, it is FAA policy to comply with International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Standards and Recommended Practices to the maximum extent practicable. The FAA has reviewed the corresponding ICAO Standards and Recommended Practices and has identified the following differences with these proposed regulations. The FAA is participating in an effort, sponsored by the ICAO Committee on Aviation Environmental Protection (CAEP) Working Group 1, that is aimed at resolving these differences. Any remaining differences with Annex 16 Recommended Standards and Practices after conclusion of these efforts will be filed with ICAO. Differences will not be filed for those items that are "notes" in Annex 16.
Wind Speed. Section A36.2.2.2(e) of this final rule requires that tests be carried out under atmospheric conditions where the average wind velocity 10 meters above ground does not exceed 12 knots and the crosswind velocity for the airplane does not exceed 7 knots. Section A36.2.2.2(e) of the final rule also specifies that maximum wind velocity 10 meters above ground is not to exceed 15 knots and the crosswind velocity is not to exceed 10 knots during the 10 dB-down time interval. Section A36.2.2.2(e) of ICAO Annex 16, Appendix 2 contains a similar average wind speed limitation, but specifies a maximum windspeed limitation only in cases where an anemometer with a built-in detector time constant of less than 30 seconds is used. The FAA has not agreed to adopt this ICAO Annex 16 provision because it could result in tests being conducted in windspeed conditions that exceed those currently permitted under part 36; based on the information that was available to it, the harmonization working group could not determine the effect that these higher wind conditions might have on the resulting noise levels.
Adjustments to PNL and PNLT. In adjusting measured sound pressure level data to reference conditions, a note in Annex 16, Appendix 2 section 9.3.2.1 suggests that when a sound pressure level value is equal to zero (for example, as a result of applying a background noise correction) the adjusted sound pressure level must be kept equal to zero in the adjustment process. The FAA does not agree with this provision. The FAA has determined that the sound pressure level values should be carried through the adjustment process regardless of whether they are greater than zero, equal to zero, or less than zero. It is entirely possible for a negative or zero sound pressure level value that results from the background noise correction process to become positive when adjusted to account for the difference between the test and reference airplane heights above the noise measurement point.
Design characteristics that requires different reference procedures. Section 3.6.1.4 of ICAO Annex 16, Chapter 3 permits the certificating authority to approve reference procedures that are different from those contained in sections 3.6.2 and 3.6.3 of ICAO Annex 16 when design characteristics of an airplane would prevent flight from being conducted in accordance with sections 3.6.2 and 3.6.3 of ICAO Annex 16. The FAA will not adopt this ICAO Annex 16 provision. The FAA recognizes that there may be a need for changes to the specified reference procedures when part 36 may not be appropriate for a particular airplane. In cases where part 36 is not appropriate, the rulemaking process, which includes a public comment period, would be followed to develop an appropriate noise certification standard. Accordingly, although the provision is not being adopted, the section reference will be reserved to preserved the ICAO format as much as possible.
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 288 passages shown