Order 1050.1D Policies and Procedures for Considering Environmental Impacts
This document is cancelled. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.
Text read by OCR from a scanned file (1 of 69 pages). Check the original, as some words may be misread.
ORDER 1050.1D
ORDER 1050.1D
REPRINT INCLUDES CHANGES 1 thru 3
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR CONSIDERING ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS
12/ 5/86
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION
Cistribution: A-W-1(minus VS/PP/AT/PM/ES/LG/EE); Initiated By: AEE-110 A-W(VS/PP/AT/PM/ES/LG/EE)-3; A-XE-1; A-X(AS/AT/AF/FS/LG)-3; A-FOF-O(Ltd)
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION
FOHI':WORIJ
ThLs order est;lhli1;;heH policy ilnd procedure and assigns responsibil it.y for assllt"ing agency compliance with environmental procedures as set forth in lilt' Councll. on Environmental (InaLity (CEq) regulation for implementing th~ procedural provisions of the National Environmental Polley Act (NEI'A).
-)t'~
J .• Lynn II .. 1 ms Admi,ni str.1tor
I050.11J
Page i (and ii)
12/5/86 1050.10 CHG 3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
1. Purpose 2. Distribution 3. Cancellation 4. Explanation of Changes 5. Definitions 6. Policy 7. Regulatory Actions 8. Applicability 9. Policy, Plan and Program Statements (Formerly "Class Actions") 10. FAA Responsibilities * 11. NEPA Point of Contact 12. Incorporation of CEQ Regulations
CHAPTER 1. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Page -No.
1
1 1 1 1 2 4 t, 8 8 8 9 9 9 9 13. Changes to this Directive 14-15. Reserved 10 (thru 12)
CHAPTER 2. PRELIMINARY PROCEDURES AND CONSULTATION 13
16. Planning and Development 13 17. Initial Review 13 18. Identification of Issues and Problems 13 19. Early Coordination 13 20. Budgetary Requirements 13 21. Research 13 22. Consultation 14 23. Role of Lead and Cooperating Agencies 14 24. Public Requests for FAA Action 14 25. Use of Contractors 14 26. Land Acquisition and Construction of
CHAPTER 2. PRELIMINARY PROCEDURES AND CONSULTATION 13
Facilities 14 27. Intergovernmental Review of Federal
Programs 28. Public Hearing 29. Citizen Involvement
15 15 17 30. Reserved 17 (thru 18)
CHAPTER 3. ENVIRONMENTAL ACTIONS
31. Categorical Exclusions 32. Extraordinary Circumstances 33. Advisory Actions 34. Cumulative Impact 35. Environmental Asse~sment
CHAPTER 3. ENVIRONMENTAL ACTIONS
19
19 20 21 21 21
Page iii
*
1050.1D I':HG 3
36. 37.
38. 39.
Content of Environmental Assessment Actions Requiring Environmental Impact
Statements Overview of Environmental Actions Reserved
Page No.
22
22 23 24
CHAPTER 4. FINDINGS OF NO SIGNIFICANT IMPACT 25
40. General 25 41. Scope of Documentation 25 42. Responsible Officials .26 43. Coordination 26 44. Distribution 27 45. Availability for Public Information 27 46. Approval 27 47. Reserved 27 (thru 28)
CHAPTER 5. PREPARATION OF DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
CHAPTER 5. PREPARATION OF DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
STATEMENTS OR FINDINGS OF NO SIGNIFiCANT IMPACT 29
48. Timing of Draft Statement Preparation 29 49. Applications 29 50. Notice of Intent to Prepare an EIS 29 51. Scoping 29 52. Use of Contractors in Preparation of an EIS 30 53. Incorporation by Reference 31 54. Inclusion of Environmental Determinations 31 55. Interdisciplinary Approach 31 56. Internal Review Process 31 57. Regulations 31 58. Legislative Proposals 31 59. Reserved 31 (thru 34)
CHAPTER 6. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT CONTENTS 35
CHAPTER 6. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT CONTENTS 35
60. General 61. Format 62. Cover Sheet and Summary 63. Purpose and Need for-the Action 64. Alternatives 65. Affected Environment 66. Environmental Consequences 67. Mitigation Measures 68. List of Preparers 69.-70. Reserved
35 35 35 35 36 36 37 38 38 38
CHAPTER 7. PROCESSING DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS 39
CHAPTER 7. PROCESSING DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS 39
71. General 72. Public Notice
Page iv
39 39
12/5/86
73. Copies 74. Circulation and Availability of DEIS 75. Comments on the DEIS
1050.1D CHG 3
39 39 40 41 76. Comment Periods 77.-79. Reserved 41 (thru 44)
CHAPTER 8. PREPARATION, APPROVAL AND DISTRIBUTION OF FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS
CHAPTER 8. PREPARATION, APPROVAL AND DISTRIBUTION OF FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS
80. Utilization of comments 81. Approval of Final EIS's 82. Availability Pending Approval 83. Distribution of Approved Environmental Impact Statements 84. Referrals to CEQ 85.-87. Reserved
CHAPTER 9. TIERING, TIME LIMITS, WRITTEN REEVALUATION, AND SUPPLEMENTAL ACTIONS
88. Tiering 89. Reducing Paperwork 90. Reducing Delay 91. Time Limits on Environmental Documents 92. Written Reevaluation 93. Supplemental or Amended Statements 94. Implementation of Commitments in
CHAPTER 9. TIERING, TIME LIMITS, WRITTEN REEVALUATION, AND SUPPLEMENTAL ACTIONS
Environmental Statements 95. Limitations of Actions 96. Record of Decision 97. Public Record 98. Use of Information 99.-100. Reserved
CHAPTER 10. ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS
45
45 45 46
46 48 48
49
49 49 49 49 50 50
50 51 51 52 52 52
53
101. Review of EIS Prepared by Other Agencies 53 102. Emergency Action Procedures 54 103. Application of Section 102(2) (C) Procedures
CHAPTER 10. ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS
to Existing Projects and Programs 54 104. Environmental Assessment or Finding of No
Significant Impact on Request from Foreign Sources 54 105,-106. Reserved 54
APPENDIX 1. PROGRAM ENGINEERING AND MAINTENANCE (5 pages)
(Regional Airway Facilities/Research and
Development) 1 APPENDIX 2. SYSTEMS ENGINEERING SERVICE (2 pages)
APPENDIX 1. PROGRAM ENGINEERING AND MAINTENANCE (5 pages)
(Regional Research and Development) 1
Page v
1050.1D CHG 3
. APPENDIX 3.
APPENDIX 4.
APPENDIX 5.
APPENDIX 6.
APPENDIX 7.
ATTACHMENT 1. ATTACHMENT 2. ATTACHMENT 3. ATTACHMENT 4.
Page vi
AIR TRAFFIC (2 pages)
AVIATION STANDARDS (2 pages)
LOGISTICS (1 page)
AIRPORTS (1 page)
ENVIRONMENT AND ENERGY (2 pages)
Flow Chart of Environmental Action (5 pages) Environmental Analyses Procedures (18 pages) Order DOT 5610.1C. Change 1 (37 pages) CEQ Regulations for Implementing the Provisions of the National Environmental Policy Act ·(44 pages)
Page No.
1
1
1
1
1
1 1 1
1
12/21/83 1050.10
CHAPTER 1. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
CHAPTER 1. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
1. PURPOSE. This order establishes Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) policies and procedures for the preparation of Environmental Impact Statements (EISs) and Findings of No Significant Impact (FONSls) and for preparing and processing environmental assessments of FAA actions. This order implements the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA),
Order DOT 56l0.lC, Procedures for Considering Environmental Impacts, and 27 other statutes, directives and orders. The complete list is given in paragraph 7 of this order.
2. DISTRIBUTION. This order is distributed to the director level in Washington with a branch level distribution in Aviation Standards, the
Office of Airport Planning and Programming, the Air Traffic Service, Program Engineering and Maintenance Service, Systems Engineering Service, Logistics, and the Office of Environment and Energy; to the director level in the regions with a branch level distribution in the Airports, Air Traffic, Airway Facilities, Flight Standards, and Logistics Divisions; to the director level in the overseas area offices; a limited distribution to field offices and facilities.
3. CANCELLATION. Order lOSO.lC, Policies and Procedures for Considering Environmental Impacts is canceled.
4. EXPLANATION OF CHANGES.
a. This order implements DOT Order S6l0.lC, Change 1. In doing so. Order lOSO.lC, paragraphs 377 and 378 are eliminated because concurrence of
the Assistant Secretary for Policy and International Affairs (P-l) is no longer required. Paragraph 81 of this order states that for highly controversial final EISs, p-l and the Office of the General Counsel (C-l) will be provided a copy of the summary section contained in the final EIS. p-l and C-l will also be given at least 2 weeks notice before approval of the final EIS.
b. Paragraph 27 of this order is based" on DOT's regulations implementing E.O. 12372, .. Intergovernmental Review of Federal Programs," which replaces paragraph 212 on A-9S Review in Order lOSO.lC.
c. Paragraph 401, "Quarterly Lists of Environmental Information" is no longer needed since CEQ removed the requirement.
d. An overview of environmental actions is explained by a flow chart in Attachment 1.
e. This order has been reorganized to place all the specifics of the environmental analyses procedures for environmental documents in Attachment 2.
1050.1D 12/21/83
f. Service Appendices 1-7 have been updated. Also, the Office of Airport Planning and Programming has its own environmental handbook, Order 5050.4, which is consistent with Federal environmental procedures contained in this order. Appendix 6 refers Aircports personnel to that order.
5. DEFINITIONS.
a. Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) Terminology. CEQ terminology implementing the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA) was published in
their regulation. CEQ sec. 1508.1 states "The terminology of this part shall be uniform throughout the Federal Government."
b. Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Terms. Order lOOO.15A, FAA Glossary, dated December 18, 1975, contains terms-which recur most often in agency communications.
c. Envirpnmental Assessment (EA). CEQ sec. 1508.9 states an "Environmental Assessment: (a.) Means a concise public document for which a Federal agency is responsible that serves to: (1) Briefly provide sufficient evidence and analysis for determining whether to prepare an environmental impact statement or a findings of no significant impact. (2) Aid an agency's compliance with the Act when no environmental impact statement is necessary. (3) Facilitate preparation of a statement when one is necessary. (b) Shall include brief discussions of the need for the proposal of alternatives as required by section 102(2)(E), of the environmental impacts of the proposed action and alternatives, and a listing of agencies and persons consulted."
d. Environmental Impact Statement. CEQ Section 1508.11 states "Environmental Impact Statement means a detailed written statement as required by Section 102(2)(C) of the Act."
e. Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) is the document that reflects FAA's initial evaluation of the environmental impact of a proposed action. The agency makes its own evaluation and assumes responsibility for the DElS. It is distributed by FAA to the EPA and other appropriate Federal, State, and local agencies for comment and is made available to teh public.
f. Final Environmental Impact Statement is the document that reflects FAA's final evaluation of the environmental impact of a proposed action. Reports cited as references in the statement need not be included in the documentation. This EIS shall accompany the proposed action through the Federal decisionmaking process.
g. Findings of No Significant Impact (FONSI) means "a document by a Federal agency briefly presenting the reasons why an action, not otherwise excluded, will not have a significant effect on the human environment and for which an environmental impact statement therefore will not be prepared. It shall include
the environmental assessment or a summary of it and shall note any other environmental documents related to it. If the assessment is included, the finding need not repeat any of the discussion in the assessment but may incorporate it by reference" - CEQ sec. 1508.13.
Page 2 Cr.ap 1 Par 4
12/10/84 1050.1D CRG I
h. Noise·Sensitive Area. An area in which aircraft noise may interfere with the normal activities associated with use of the land. Noise sensitive areas may include residential neighborhoods, educational, health, and religious structures and sites and outdoor recreational,
cultural, and historic sites. Whether noise interfers with a particular use depends upon the level of noise exposure received and the type.of activities involved. A site which is unacceptable for outside use may be acceptable for use inside a structure, if adequate noise attenuation features are built into that structure. (Reference Attachment 2, Section 1 - Noise Analysis).
1. Record of Decision (ROD) is "a concise public record of decision." See CEQ sec. 1505.2 and 1506.1 for requirements. * j. Responsible Official is an FAA employee designated with overall responsibility to furnish guidance and participate in the preparation of environmental impact statements, to independently evaluate the statements
prior to approval, and to take responsibility for the scope and content of the statements. This person may be authorized to evaluate and accept environmental assessments and may direct scoping activities for the FAA.
k. Sponsor is any public agency or private owner of a public use airport, as defined in the 1982 Airport Act, which applies to receive Federal financial assistance under the Act or anyone proposing an airport action for which Federal authorization is required.
1. Scoping is "An early and open process for determining the scope of issues to be addressed and for identifying the significant issues related to a proposed action." - CEQ sec. 1501.7.
m. Tiering. CEQ sec. 1508.28 states "Tiering" refers to the coverage of general matters in broader environmental impact statements (such as national program or policy statements) with subsequent narrower statements or environmental analyses (such as regional or basin wide program
statements or ultimately site-specific statements) incorporating by reference the general discussions and concentrating solely on the issues specific to the statement subsequently prepared. Tiering is appropriate when the sequence of statements or analyses is:
(1) From a program, plan, or policy environmental impact statement to a program, plan, or policy statement or analysis of lesser scope or to a site-specific statement or analysis.
(2) From an environmental impact statement on a specific action at an early stage (such as need and site selection) to a supplement (which is preferred) or a subsequent statement or analysis at a later stage (such as environmental mitigation). Tiering in such cases is appropriate when it helps the lead agency to focus on the issues which are ripe for decision and exclude from consideration issues already decided or not yet ripe.
Chap 1 Par 5
o
*
1050. ID CHG I 12/10/84
1050. ID CHG I 12/10/84
6. POLICY.
a. FAA will comply with both the procedures and the policies of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (hereafter NEPA) and related orders, statutes, and regulations. This requires that the FAA decisionmaking process facilitate public understanding and scrutiny by
including a consideration of: the effects of the proposed actions and the alternatives; the avoidance or minimization of adverse effects of proposed actions; the restoration and enhancement of resources and environmental quality of the nation. The FAA shall integrate these NEPA considerations as early in the agency planning processes as possible.
b. The environmental review process outlined in this order shall be the focal point to assure that NEPA considerations are taken into account. Environmental Impact Statements (EISs) and Findings of No Significant
Impact (FONSls) service to document compliance with these considerations and to reflect a thorough review of all relevant environmental factors, utilizing a :~ystematic, interdisciplinary approach.
c. These policies are supplementary to other agency policies established under other statutes and directives.
7. REGULATORY ACTIONS. This order implements agency actions required by the statutes and directives (as amended) as follows:
a. NEPA (P.L. 91-190, 42 u.S.C. 4321) establishes a broad national policy to, improve the relationship betwee'n humans and their environment, and sets out policies and goals to ensure that environmental considerations are given careful attention and appropriate weight in all decisions of the Federal Government.
b. The Clean Air Act as amended by P.L. 91-604 provides that the Administrator shall review and comment in writing on the air quality
impacts of actions taken under his cognizance.
c. The Noise Control Act of 1972 (P.L. 92-574, 42 U.S.C. 4901) provides for Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) consultation on noise standards and also permits EPA to propose aviation noise regulations to the FAA.
* d. The Airport and Airway Improvement Act of 1982 (Known as the 1982 Airport Act) P.L. 97-248, 49 U.S.C. 2201et. seq. * e. Section 4(f) of the Department of Transportation Act of 1966 (recodified at 49 U.S.C. 303) states, "The Secretary may approve a transportation program or project requiring the use of publicly owned land of a public park, recreation area, or wildlife and waterfowl refuge of national, State, or local significance or land of an historic site '" only if (1) there is no prudent and feasible alternative to using that land, and (2) the program or project includes all possible planning to minimize harm to the park, recreational area, wildlife and waterfowl refuge, or historic site resulting from the use."
Chap 1
Par 6
*
12/5/86 1050.1D CHG 3
f. Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of J966 (P.L. 89-665 hereinafter, the Historic Preservation Act, 16 U.S.C. 470(f)) requires the head of any Federal agency having jurisdiction over a Federal or Federally-assisted undertaking to take into account, prior to approving
the undertaking, its effect on any district, site, building, structure, or object that is included in or eligible for the National Register of Historic Places, and to give the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation a reasonable opportunity to comment on the undertaking.
g. The Archaeological and Historic Dsta Preservation Act of 1974 (P.L. 86-253. as amended by P.L. 93-291, 16 U.S.C. 469) is directed to the preservation of historic and archaeological data that would otherwise be
lost as a result of Federal construction or other Federally licensed or funded activities.
h. The Endangered Species Act of 1973 (P.L. 93-205, 16 U.S.C. 1531 as amended) and Interagency Cooperation Regulation (50 CFR Part 402) require that all Federal agencies shall, in consultation with the Secretaries of Interior and Commerce, carry out programs for the conservation of endangered or threatened species listed by the Department of the Interior and ensure that actions authorized, funded, or carried out by them dp not jeopardize the continued existence of the endangered species or result in the destruction or modification of the habitat of such species to sn extent which is determined by the Secretary (of the Interior or Commerce) to be critical.
i. Section 2 of the Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act (P.L. 85-624, 16 U.S.C. §§ 661, 664 note, 1008 note) requires, with certain limited exceptions, that "whenever the waters of any stream or other body of water are proposed or authorized to be ••• impounded, diverted, the channel deepened, or the stream or other body of water otherwise controlled or modified for any purpose whatever • • • by any department or agency of the
United States, or by any public or private agency under Federal permit or
licen~e, such department or agency shall first consult with the United States Fish and Wildlife Service, Department of the Interior, and with the head of the agency exercising administration over the wildlife resources of the particular State wherein the • • • control facility is to be constructed ••• " (Subsection (2)).
j. Section 404 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act Amendments for 1972 (P.L. 92-500, 33 U.S.C. 1344), as amended by the Clean Water Act of 1977 (P.L. 95-217, 33 U.S.C. 1251) establishes a permit procedure for activities involving dredging and filling of navigable waters. The Secretary of the Army, acting through the Army Corps of Engineers, is responsible for issuing such permits.
k. The Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972 (P.L. 92-583, 16 U.S.C. §§ 1451-1464) states that "it is national policy (a) to preserve, protect, develop, and where possible, to restore or enhance, the resources of the Nation's coastal zone ••• " (Section 303), and requires all Federal or
Federally supported activities affecting the zone to be carried out in a
1050. 10 CHG 3 12/5/86
manner consistent with State coastal zone management programs (Section
307). Federal Consistency with Approved Coastal Management Programs (15 CFR Part 930) establishes procedures for determining consistency.
1. Coastal Barrier Resources Act of 1982 (P.L. 97-348, 16 U.S.C. 3501-3510) restricts future Federal expenditures and financial assistance which have the effett of encouraging development of coastal barriers by
establishing a Coastal Barrier Resources System consisting of undeveloped coastal barriers along the Atlantic and Gulf coasts.
m. Section 2 of the Water Bank Act (P.L. 91-559, 16 U.S.C. § 1301 note) declares that " ••• it is in the public interest to preserve, restore, and improve the wetlands of the Nation ••• "
n. Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real Property Acquisition Policies Act of 1970 (P.L. 91-528, 42 U.S.C. 4601) requires consideration of the costs and impacts of residential dislocations in judging alternatives in the acquisition of real property. * o. Farmland Protection Policy Act (P.L. 97-98 and 7 CFR Part 658) establishes criteria for identifying and considering the effects of Federal programs on the conversion of farmland to nonagricultural uses and
identifying technical assistance to agencies of Federal, state, and local governments that will be provided by the Department of Agriculture, *
p. Section 201(a) of the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976 (P.L. 94-579, 43 U.S.C. 1701 et. seq.) requires Federal agencies to consult the Bureau of Land Management to determine if land to be used for
a Federal action is land which is being considered for inclusion in the National Wilderness System.
* q. Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976 (P.L. 94-580, 42 U.S.C. 6901 et. seq.), as amended by the Solid Waste Disposal Act of 1980
(P.L. 96-482); and the 1984 Hazardous and Solid Waste Amendments (P.L. 98-616) provide environmental requirements in handling solid and hazardous waste>disposals. RCRA directed EPA to promulgate regulations to protect human health and the environment from improper management of both hazardous (Subtitle C) and nonhazardous wastes (Subtitle D). As specified by RCRA, "solid" wastes may be solid, liquid, or gaseous, or any variation of the physical state; however, not all solid wastes are hazardous wastes. Hazardous wastes are defined by the degree or ignitability, corrosivity,
reactivity and/or toxicity. Also, RCRA was enacted to give EPA authority to regulate the generation, transport, and disposal of hazardous wastes, not simply their disposal. *
r. 40 CFR Parts 1500-1508 (43 FR 55978, November 29, 1978) CEQ implementation of NEPA procedural provisions establishes uniform procedures, terminology, and standards for implementing the procedural requirements of NEPA's section 102(2). * s. 14 CFR Part 150 (49 FR 49260, December 18, 1984), Airport Noise Compatibility Planning, prescribes requirements for airport operators who *
Chap 1 Par 7
12/0;/86 1050. 1D CHG 3
choose to submit noise exposure maps and to develop and submit airport noise compatibility planning programs to the FAA. This regulation implements portions of the Aviation Safety and Noise Abatement Act of 1979, as amended (49 U.S.C. 2101 et seq.). It supersedes the interim rule adopted on January 19, 1981 (46 FR 8316). The revisions reflect, in part, comments invited and received following promulgation of the interim rule. * t. 36 CFR Part 800 (39 FR 3365, January 25, 1974, and 51 FR 31115, September 2, 1980) Protection of Historic Properties, establishes procedures to ensure that historic properties are given proper consideration in the preparation of environmental assessments or impact statements, when carrying out FAA actions.
u. 7 CFR Part 657 (43 FR 4030, January 31, 1978), Prime and Unigue Farmlands requires the responsible official to consult with the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Land Use Committee to determine whether land
to be affected by agency action is prime and unique farmland.
v. Executive Order 11514, Protection and Enhancement of Environmental Quality, dated March 4, 1970, orders all Federal agencies to "initiate measures needed to direct their policies, plans, and programs so as to meet national environmental goals."
w. Executive Order 11593, Protection and Enhancement of the Cultural Environment, dated May 13, 1971, requires that Federal plans and programs contribute to the preservation and enhancement of sites, structures, and objects of historic, architectural, or archaeological significance.
x. Executive Order 12114, Environmental Effects Abroad of Major Federal Actions, dated January 4, 1979, provides pertinent environmental considerations with respect to proposed actions outside the United States,
its territories and possessions.
y. Executive Order 11988, Floodplain Management 43 FR 6030 and Order DOT 5650.2, April 23, 1979, Floodplain Management and Protection link the need to protect lives and property with the need to restore and preserve natural and beneficial floodplain values. Agencies are required to make a finding that there is no practicable alternative before taking action that would encroach on a floodplain.
z. Executive Order 11990, Protection of Wetlands and Order DOT 5660.1A, Preservation of the Nation's Wetlands, dated August 24, 1978, require action to minimize the destruction, loss or degradation of wetlands and to assure the protection, preservation, and enhancement of
the Nation's wetlands to the fullest extent practicable during the planning, construction, and operation of transportati.on facilities and projects.
aa. Executive Order 12372, Intergovernmental Review of Federal Programs, dated July 14, 1982, and 49 CFR Part 17, Intergovernmental Review of DOT Programs and Activities require Federal agencies to provide
the opportunity for state and local elected officials to revi.ew and
*
1050. 1D CHG 3 12/5/86
comment on Federal actions for Federal assistance or actions affecting them. FAA shall comply with DOT procedures implementing this E.O. contained in 49 CFR Part 17.
bb. President's 1979 Environmental Message Directive on Wild and Scenic Rivers, dated August 2, 1979, directs Federal agencies to take care to avoid or mitigate adverse effects on rivers identified in the Nationwide Inventory as having potential for designation under the Wild
and Scenic Rivers Act (P.L. 90-542).
cc. Order DOT 5610.1C, Procedures for Considering Environmental Impacts, (44 FR 56420, October I, 1979), and Order DOT 5610.1C, Change 1,
(7/13/82), provide guidelines for considering environmental impacts of transportation actions.
dd. Order 1053.1, Policies and Procedures for Energy Planning "and Conserv"tion, provides for assessing energy demands.
8. APPLICABILITY. The requirements in this order apply to, but are not limited to, the following: all grants, loans, contracts, leases, construction, research activities, rulemaking and regulatory actions, certifications, licensing, permits, plans submitted to the agency by state or local agencies which require FAA approval, and legislation proposed by FAA. Exceptions to these requirements are listed in paragraph 31, Categorical Exclusions.
9. POLICY, PLAN, AND PROGRAM STATEMENTS (FORMERLY "CLASS ACTIONS"). A general policy, plan, or program may be covered by a single ErS or FONSI when the environmental impacts of all related actions, alternatives
thereto, and measures to mitigate adverse environmental impacts, are substantially similar. (See CEQ sec. 1508.18).
10. FAA RESPONSIBILITIES.
a. Compliance with the policies and procedures of this order is the responsibility of the regional directors for all actions orfginating fn
the regions, heads of offices and services for all actions originating at headquarters, and center directors for all actions originating at centers.
b. Heads of offices and services are responsible for revising their appendices of this order, as appropriate; providing supplemental guidelines for implementing this order in their program areas, as appropriate; consulting with and advising responsible officials on matters within their operational areas, and evaluating and appraising the activities to implement the requirements,of NEPA.
c. Regional directors are responsible for preparing and filing ElS's and FONSI's as necessary and assuring appropriate internal coordination of actions that cross program lines; assigning personnel and other resol.\rce's to assess and document all relevant environmental factors, including" assignment of an office or officer for coordinating all NEPA related activities.
Chap 1 Par 7
12/5/86 1050. 10 CHG 3
d. The Office of Environment and Energy (hereinafter AEE) is responsible for overall review of FAA's environmental policies and procedures including NEPA compliance; developin~ and coordinating policies
and procedures under this order; assisting services in developing guidance for their program areas; consulting with and advising responsible officials in their implementation of this order; developing training programs in cooperation with the Office of Personnel and Trainin~ and the Services, and evaluating and appraising the activities to implement the requirements of NEPA.
e. The Office of the Chief Counsel (hereinafter AGC) and regional and center counsels provide legal advice to all elements of FAA regarding the legal sufficiency of environmental documents.
f. Other responsibilities regarding specific program areas are set forth in Appendices 1-7 of this order.
* 11. NEPA POINT OF CONTACT. Regional Directors shall designate an office or officer as the NEPA point of contact. The point of contact will serve as a focal point, specifically to receive and disseminate within the region NEPA-related information from Washington headquarters or outside the agency. The NEPA point of contact is not intended to replace the responsible official for specific environmental documents or otherwise change existing lines of responsibility. The region will inform AEE-l of the name, routing symbol, and telephone number of the NEPA point of contact.
12. INCORPORATION OF CEQ REGULATIONS. The uniform procedures, terminology, and standards adopted by the CEQ for implementation of the procedural provisions of NEPA (40 CFR Parts 1500-1508; 43 FR 230, November
29, 1978) are herewith incorporated by reference. This order furnishes additional material as explanatory guidance anrl as an aid to implement these regulations. (Hereinafter, references to the CEQ Regulations shall simply identify the paragraph; e.g., CEQ sec. 1508.1.)
13. CHANCES TO THIS DIRECTIVE. The Director of Environment and Energy (AEE-1) may issue changes to Chapters 1 through 10 of this order after coordinating the change with the concerned organization elements, and each office and service may issue changes to the appropriate appendix
(i.e., Air Traffic for Appendix 3) after coordinating the change with the concerned organizational elements, including AEE and AGC, provided:
a. The change does not affect policy, delegation of authority, or assignment of responsibilities outside the office's or service's authority;
b. The Administrator has not specifically reserved authority to make the change; and
c. Substantial changes are not made without the concurrence of the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Policy and International Affairs
1050.10 CHG 3 12/5/86
(hereinafter P-l) and the Office of the General Counsel (hereinafter C-l) and are published- for comment in the Federal Register after consultation with CEQ.
14. - 15. RESERVED.
Page 10 (thru 12) Chap 8 Par 13
12/21/83 JOSO.ID
12/21/83 JOSO.ID
CHAPTER 2. PRELIMINARY PROCEDURES AND CONSULTATION
16. PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT. The environmental impacts of proposed actions shall be based on appropriate environmental consideration at the
systems planning level and shall be assessed and considered concurrently with initial planning, development, or site considerations.
CHAPTER 2. PRELIMINARY PROCEDURES AND CONSULTATION
17. INITIAL REVIEW. An environmental review will indicate whether the proposed action could significantly affect the human environment with respect to noise, land, air and water quality; whether it is located in wetlands, coastal zones, historic or archeological sites, areas inhabited
by endangered species, or areas protected under DOT Section 4(f); whether the action would be highly controversial on environmental grounds. At this stage, documentation is required to alert program officers to foreseeable environmental impacts and controversies. (A proposed Federal action is considered highly controversial when the action is opposed on environmental grounds by a Federal, State, or local government agency or by a substantial number of the persons affected by such action.)
18. IDENTIFICATION OF ISSUES AND PROBLEMS. Based on the initial reView described in paragraph 17, the program officer(s) shall identify issues and
problems having environmental significance to Federal, State, or local officials in the performance of their duties, or to the public. Further,
the program officer(s) shall determine whether such issues and problems, as they pertain to the proposed action, have been addressed already in a broad system, program, or regional assessment.
19. EARLY COORDINATION. CEQ sec. 1501.4(b) states, "The agency shall involve environmental agencies, applicants, and the public, to the extent practicable, in preparing (environmental) assessment ••• " and in CEQ sec. 1506.2(b) "Agencies shall cooperate with State and local agencies to the fullest extent possible to reduce duplication between NEPA and State and local requirements, unless the agencies are specifically barred from doing so by some other law."
20. BUDGETARY REQUIREMENTS. The Office of Budget is responsible for assuring appropriate environmental consideration and documentation at the budget stage. Criteria for environmental consideration in the Airways Facilities budget process are in Program Engineering and Maintenance Service, Appendix 1, paragraph 6. Funding requirements resulting from the implementation of this order shall be justified and requested in accordance with existing budgetary and fiscal policies.
21. RESEARCH. Criteria for environmental consideration of research activities are in Appendix 2.
1050. ID eRG I 12/10/84
22. CONSULTATION. The affected local units of Government, and pertinent Federal and State agencies should be consulted early in the process of preparing a DEIS, FONSI, or environmental assessment. Comments on the environmental impacts of the proposed action shall be considered, as appropriate, in determining whether the proposed action requires an EIS or FONSI and in preparing the DEIS or FONSI.
23. ROLE OF LEAD AND COOPERATING AGENCIES. The various roles of the lead agency are described in CEQ 1501.5 through 1501.8. CEQ 1501.5 generally describes the role of the lead agency when more than one agency is involved in an action. CEQ 1501.6 describes the relationship with cooperating agencies. CEQ 1501.7 and 1501.8 define the role of the lead agency in the scoping process and in setting time limts.
* a. Federal agencies which shall be invited by the responsible official to become cooperating agencies are those with jurisdiction by law in areas which may be affected by FAA actions or whose actions, plans, or developments may affect the proposed FAA action or limit proposed alternatives.
b. Federal agencies with special expertise may also be asked to be cooperating agencies.
c. The definition of a cooperating agency in CEQ Sec. 1508.5 also includes any "State or local agency of similar qualifications (Le., with jurisdiction by law or special expertise with respect to any environmental impact involved in a proposal), or when the effects are on a reservation, an Indian Tribe may, by agreement with the lead agency, become a cooperating agency." *
24. PUBLIC REQUESTS FOR FAA ACTION. When an FAA action is requested from the public there may be particular situations such as, issuance of various certificates, approval of airline operating specifications or amendments, establishment of new or revised instrument approach/departure procedures affecting noise sensitive areas, etc., which will require FAA to do an environmental assessment. Whenever this situation occurs, FAA act10n may be delayed unless assistance in the development of pertinent environmental data is furnished by the applicant or other interested persons.
25. USE OF CONTRACTORS. Contractor consulting services may be used to prepare environmental assessments and impact statements. They may also be used to prepare background or supplemental material and otherwise assist in preparing a draft or final environmental document for which FAA takes responsibility.
26. LAND ACQUISITION AND CONSTRUCTION OF FACILITIES. Public sponsors, other aviation agencies or private parties have the authority to acquire land or to construct facilities for operation by the FAA without prior approval by the FAA." Such action, if inconsistent with the policies of
this order, could prejudice a decision by the FAA on proposed changes in an airport which would use the land thus acquired, or on request for reimbursement for the property, or construction or operation of the facility.
Chap 2 Par 22
o
a. When FAA is notified or becomes aware of a possibility situation may be occurring, FAA will advise the public sponsor, aviation agency or private party that:
1050.1D
that such a other
(1) Such actions must be consistent with pertinent environmental policy as expressed in this order.
(2) The manner in which the particular property was acquired or the facility constructed will be carefully considered by the FAA prior to approval of any future FAA action involving it.
b. FAA, will give particular attention to i~s responsibilities under DOT Section 4(f) to insure that a special effort is made to preserve the natural beauty of countryside, public parks, and recreation lands, wildlife and waterfowl refuges, and historic sites. FAA will not approve actions requiring the use of DOT Section 4(f) properties unless there is no
feasible and prudent alternative and the program includes all possible planning to minimize harm.
c. FAA also will give particular attention to actions involving properties included in or eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places and the provisions of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real Properties Acquisition Policies Act of 1970.
d. An action by a sponsor, other aviation agency or private party which has acquired land or constructed a facility for operation by FAA, but without prior approval by FAA, will be reviewed to determine whether the action was consistent with the policies of this order and has not limited
full and objective consideration of alternatives.
27. INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVIEW OF FEDERAL PROGRAMS. In accordance with Executive Order 12372, "Intergovernmental Review of Federal Programs," Federal agencies shall provide opportunities for review and comment by elected officials of State and local governments that will be affected by
planned Federal assistance and direct Federal development actions. Also, FAA should provide copies of FONSls and draft EISs to elected state and local officials. FAA shall comply with DOT procedures implementing this Executive Order contained in 49 CFR Part 17. Executive Order 12372 and DOT regulations are intended to replace the intergovernmental consultation system developed under the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Circular A-9S'. Under Executive Order 12372 State and local elected officials, not the Federal government, will determine what Federal programs and activities to review and the procedures by which the review will take place.
28. PUBLIC HEARING.
a. The following elements are to be considered in deciding whether a public hearing is appropriate in cases where it is not statutorily mandated .:'
1050.1D 12/21/83
(1) The magnitude of the proposal in terms of environmentdl impact or controversy, economic costs, the size and location of the geographic area involved, and the uniqueness or amount of the resources to . be committed.
(2) The degree of interest in the proposal, as evidenced by requeBts from the public of Federal, State, and local authorities that a hearing be held.
(3) !he complexity of the issue and the likelihood that information presented at the hearing will be of assistance to the agency in fulfilling its responsibilities.
(4) The extent to which public involvement already has been achieved through other means, such as earlier public hearings, meetings
with citizen representatives, or written comments on the proposed action.
b. The following shall be included in the notice for a public hearing:
(1) A description of the proposed action.
(2) The scheduling of the public hearing (time, date, and place) •
. (3) The availability and location of a DElS, FONSI, or environmental assessment.
c. Notice of the hearing shall be in an areawide or local newspaper of s"neral circulation. In CEQ sec. 1506.6 states that, "In all cases the agency s;1i~11 mail notice to those who have requested it on an individual e"::tlor) ~ In the case of an action with effects of national concern notice B:121: ''lc;'ude publication in the Federal Register and notice by mail to lld'Ciolla.J.. organizations reasonably expecte(f"t'()be interE!sted in the matter
Co A. draft EIS, FONSI, or environmental assessment shall be available to ttl". public 30 days prior to the public hearing.
For FAA hearings, the responsible official may assign program e. officerb officer.
the responsibility for convening a hearing and serving as hearing
f. Records of public hearings will be maintained in the docket of the General Counsel's office.
Chap 2 Par 28
29. CITIZEN INVOLVEMENT. Citizen involvement, where appropriate, shall be initiated at the earliest. practical time and continued throughout the development of the proposed project in order to obtain meaningful input.
Such citizen involvement may be appropriate in defining the scope of work of an environmental assessment developed by an applicant for aid or by a consultant, or of a DEIS being developed by FAA. Comments from individuals and groups shall be considered in preparing an EIS or FONSI. A summary of citizen involvement and the environmental issues raised shall be documented where practical in the Ers or FONSI. Reference FAA.Report FAA-EE-79-06, "Community Involvement Manual" for further information. A copy of FAA-EE-79-06 can be obtained from the Office of Environment and Energy, Federal Aviation Administration, 800 Independence Avenue, S.W., Washington, D.C. 20591.
30. RESERVED.
1050.1D
Chap 2 Par 29 Page 17 .and I8
12/21/83 10,)0.lD
CHAPTER 3. ENVIRONMENTAL ACTIONS
CHAPTER 3. ENVIRONMENTAL ACTIONS
31. CATEGORICAL EXCLUSIONS.
a. Categorical Exclusions from the Requirement for an EIS or FONSI.
(1) Administrative and operating actions, such as procurements, organizational changes, personnel actions, and legislative proposals not originating in FAA.
(2) Emergency measures regarding air or ground safety,
(3) Planning grants which do not imply a project commitment.
(4) Project amendments (e.g., increases in costs) which do not alter the environmental impact of the action.
(5) Policy and planning documents not intended for or which do not cause direct implementation of project or system actions.
(6) Agreements with foreign governments. international. organizations, or U.S. Government departments calling for the provision of technical assistance, advice or services in foreign countries, such as votes or other similar actions in international conferences and organizations.
(7) The planning and development of projects and programs leading to Aeromedical Applications and Standards; personnel efficiency and performance.
(8) The approval or issuance of certificates covering medicals for airmen. delegated authority. ground schools. out-of-agency training, and aircraft repair or maintenance not affecting noise, emissions. or wastes.
(9) All facility decommissionings unless an extraordinary environmental circumstance exists.
(10) Take over of non-Federal facilities by the FAA.
(11) In addition to the exceptions noted above, each of the Service Appendices may provide for categorical exclusions of specific types of projects or categories of actions carried out by that. service (see CEQ sec. 1508.4 for requirements).
1050.10 12/21/83
b. Documentation. Categorical exclusions from this order and actions for which final EISs including any Record of Decision have been
filed do not require further documentation. Program FONSIs also do not require further documentation.
c. An action which has been categorically excluded in this order but which in a particular case significantly affects the quality of the human environment, requires the preparation of an EI8.
32. EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES. Proposed Federal actions, normally categorically excluded, which have any of the following characteristics shall be the subject of an environmental assessment.
a. An action that is likely to have an effect that is not minimal on properties protected under section 106 of the Historic preservation Act of 1966, as amended, or section 4(f).
b. An action that is likely to be highly controversial on envi ronmerital ground s.
c. An action that is likely to have a significant impact on natural, ecological, cultural, or scenic resources of national, state, or local
significance, including endangered species, wetlands, floodplains, coastal zones, prime, unique or state or local-important farmlands, energy supply and natural resources, or resources protected by the Fish and Wildlife Coordina tion Ac t.
d. An action that is likely to be highly controversial with respect to the availability of adequate relocation housing. In an action involving relocation of persons or businesses, a controversy over the amount of the acquisition or relocation payments is not considered to be a controversy with respect to availability of adequate relocation housing.
e. An action that is likely to:
(1) Cause substantial division or disruption of an established community, or disrupt orderly, planned development, or is likely to be not reasonably consistent with plans or goals that have been adopted by the community in which the project is located; or
(2) Cause a significant increase in surface traffic congestion.
f. An action that is likely to:
(1) Have a significant impact on noise levels of noise ~ensitive areas.
(2) Have a significant impact on air quality or violate the local, state, or Federal standards for air quality.
(3) Have a significant impact on water quality or contaminate a public water supply system.
Chap 3 Par 31
(4) Be inconsistent with any Federal, State, or local law or administrative determination. relating to the environment.
1050.1D
g. Other action that is likely to directly or indirectly affect human beings by creating a significant impact on the environment.
33. ADVISORY ACTIONS. Some Federal actions, such as airspace determinations are of an advisory nature and are neither permissive nor enabling. Actions of this type are not major Federal actions, and environmental assessments or statements are not required as a condition for accomplishing the action. If it is known or anticipated that some subsequent Federal action would require processing in accordance with environmental procedures, the FAA shall so indicate in the advisory action.
34. CUMULATIVE IMPACT. In determining whether an environmental impact statement is required for a proposed Federal action, it is necessary to consider the overall cumulative impact of the proposed action and the consequences of subsequent related actions. CEQ sec. 1508.7 states that "'Cumulative impact' is the impact on the environment which results from the incremental impact of the action when added to other past, present, and reasonably foreseeable future actions regardless of what agency (Federal or non-Federal) or person undertakes such other actions. Cumulative impacts can result from individually minor but collectively significant actions taking place over a period of time." ( See par a g rap h 37 (b) )
35. ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT. An environmental assessment (EA) is a concise document describing the environmental impacts of a proposed action and its alternatives. If a decision has not been made to prepare an EIS and a proposed action has not been classified as a categorical exclusion, an EA shall be prepared. If it is concluded from the EA that the proposed action is a major impact significantly affecting the quality of the human environment, the responsible official shall prepare and process a draft
EIS. If it is concluded that the action is not a major impact significantly affecting the quality of the human environment, the responsible official shall prepare and file a FONSI. It is FAA's intention to adhere strongly to this instruction and to require only enough analysis in the environmental assessment for the following purposes:
a. To understand the problem and identify reasonable alternative solutions, including the proposed action. The CEQ Regulations include specific directions on the consideration of alternatives. While these directions are concerned with the EIS, they are also applicable to an EA, although less detail than in an EIS. See paragraph 64 on Alternatives for the applicable CEQ sections.
b. To determine whether any potential impacts are significant, which would trigger the environmental impact statement process.
1050.1D 12/21/83
c. To provide the" basis for the FAA's findings of no significant "impact if the proposed action has no significant impacts.
d. To identify and satisfy special purpose Federal laws, regulations, and executive orders.
e, To identify and satisfy State and local laws and regulations applicable to the proposal.
f. In completing the above, to "indicate agencies consulted (and to identify cooperating agencies for environmental impact statement" preparation purpose).
36. CONTENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT. The environmental assessment shall incorporate Some selected items of information required for an
environmen~al impact statement in CEQ sec. 1502.10. The information in the environmental assessment will, however, be in more abbreviated form than in an" environmental impact statement. The information required includes the purpose and need for the proposal, alternatives including proposed action (see paragraph 64), Affected Environment (see para. 65), Environmental Consequences (see paragraph 66 and Attachment 2 for applicable potential impact areas), listing of agencies and persons consulted and appendices (if any).
37. ACTIONS REQUIRING ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS.
a, After an EA has been prepared, an EIS shall be prepared if an FAA action:
(1) Has" an effect that is not minimal On properties protected under Section 4(f) of the DOT Act, or Section 106 of the Historic Preservation Act.
(2) Has a significant impact on natural, ecological, cultural, or scenic resources of National, State, or local significance, including endangered species or wetlands, floodplains, and coastal zones.
(3) Is highly controversial with respect to the availability of adequate relocation housing. (A controversy over the amount of acquisition or relocation payments is not a controversy with respect to the availability of relocation housing).
(4) Causes substantial division or disruption of an established community, or disrupts orderly, planned development, or is determined not to be reasonably consistent with plans or goals that have been adopted by the community in which the project is located.
areas.
(5) Causes a significant increase in surface traffic congestion.
(6) Has a significant impact on noise levels of noise sensitive
Chap 3 Par 35
12/21/83 1050.1D
(7) Has a significant impact on air quality or violates the standards for air quality of the Environmental Protection Agency or an affected locality or State.
(8) Has a significant impact on water quality or may contaminate a public water supply system.
(9) Is inconsistent with an Federal, State, or local law or determination relating to the environment.
(10) Directly or indirectly affects human beings by creating a significant impact on the environment.
(11) Has a significant impact on prime or unique farmlands or farmlands of state or local importance.
b. An EIS is required not only when the impact of the proposed project itself is significant, but also when the cumulative impact of the proposed project and other past, present and reasonably foreseeable future actions is significant. A series of actions considered on an individual bases may have a limited environmental impact, yet, when considered together, may have a significant, cumulative impact.
(1) If approval of the proposed action would permit further contemplated actions, the impacts of those contemplated actions and the proposed action must both be considered in determining whether to prepare an EIS.
(2) The actions which are related to the proposed action may be undertaken by any Federal or non-Federal agency or person.
(3) If an EIS is required because of the cumulative impact of the proposed action and future, related actions, no commitment may be made with respect to the future actions prior to the processing of the EIS if such commitment would foreclose or limit the choice of alternatives or mitigating measures which may ~e taken. (See CEQ sec. 1506.1).
c. In case of doubt as to whether an EIS is necessary for a particular action, the responsible official or program officer should consult with AEE-l and AGC-l. Regional Airport Divisions consultation under Order 5050.4 should be with APP-600.
38. OVERVIEW OF ENVIRONMENTAL ACTIONS.
a. The process for consideration of the environmental effects of a proposed action involves a number of steps, beginning with assessment by the FAA or applicant of actions not categorically excluded. The relative responsibilities of the FAA are summarized in the following paragraphs.
1050.1D 12/21/83
b. For a better understanding of the process, a flow chart (Attachment 1) is presented at the end of this order. Attachment 1 is broken down into four sheets:
(1) Sheet 1 depicts the initial FAA review of actions not categorically excluded. The FAA must determine, based on the environmental assessment review, whether the action requires preparation of a FONSl or an EIS.
(2) Sheet 2 describes the process if it is determined that an EIS is not necessary. It shows the procedure for the processing and approval of a FONSI.
(3) Sheet 3 describes the FAA procedure in processing a draft ErS in accordance with NEPA l02(2)(C). It outlines the process of scoping, preparing and circulating the draft, and receiving and reviewing comments.
(4) Sheet 4 explains FAA's approval process for a final EIS.
39. RESERVED.
Chap 3 Par 38
12/21/83 1050.1D
CHAPTER 4. FINDINGS OF NO SIGNIFICANT IMPACT
CHAPTER 4. FINDINGS OF NO SIGNIFICANT IMPACT
40. GENERAL. CEQ sec. 1501.4(e) provides that the Federal agency shall "Prepare a findings of no significant impact (CEQ sec. 1508.13), if the agency determines on the basis of the environmental assessment not to prepare a statement." CEQ sec. 1508.13 defines a findings of no significant impact as … a document by a Federal agency briefly presenting the reasons why an action, not otherwise excluded (CEQ sec. 1508.4), will not have a significant effect on the human environment and for which an environmental impact statement therefore will not be prepared." The FAA shall evaluate the environmental assessment to determine if an alternative which provides a good solution to the problem has no significant impacts. Unless there is an overriding reason for not selecting such an alternative, the FAA shall then proceed with the preparation of a findings of no significant impact.
41. SCOPE OF DOCUMENTATION.
a. The FONSI may be attached to an EA or the EA and FONSI may be combined into a single document.
b. Depending on the complexity and degree of impact of a proposed accion, a FONSI may range in content from a simple conclusion, supported
with pertinent facts, that the action is not a major impact significantly affecting the quality of the human environment, to an analysis involving
the format and content necessary for environmental statements.
c. The FONSI shall include a brief description of the proposed action and its purpose.
d. The FONSI shall assess and document all relevant matters necessary to support the conclusion that the action is not a major impact significantly affecting the quality of the human environment. The attention given to different environmental factors will vary according to
the nature, scale, and location of the proposed action. The FONSI shall include any measures to minimize adverse impacts on the environment.
e. The FONSI shall identify and discuss the alternatives considered, particularly those which mitigate environmental impacts, including the alternative of no action.
f. The FONSI Shall determine the proposed action's consistency or inconsistency with community planning, and shall document the basis for the determination.
Chap 4 ·Par 40 Page 25
10SO.lD 12/21/83
g. If the FONSI includes a Section 4(f) determination, it shall also include the material called for in DOT Order 5610.IC. AGC, or a designee, shall review the Section 4(f) determination for legal sufficiency. The document must reflect consultation with the Department of the Interior and, where appropriate, the Department of Agriculture or the Department of Housing and Urban Development.
h. Where a Federal action affects wetlands, the FONSI shall document the opportunity for early public review, the agency's conclusion that there is no practicable alternative to the proposed action, and that the proposed action includes all practicable measures to minimize harm. The FONSI shall document the outcome of consultations with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service and the pertinent State resources agency.
i. Where affected properties are included in or eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places, the FONSI shall include documentation and outcome of consul.tations with the State Historic prese'rvatio'; Office and evidence that the Advisory Council on Hi,storic Preservation'reviewed the determination of no adverse effect.
j. Where Federally assisted activities affect the coastal zone in a state with an approved coastal management program, ,the FONSI should reflect FAA's views on the relationship to the approved coastal zone management program and the state's determination of the proposal's consistency with the program.
k. Where an action affects prime or unique farmlands or farmlands of state or local importance, the FONSI shall document coordination with the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
42. RESPONSIBLE OFFICIALS.
a. At the field level, FONSIs shall be reviewed by pertinent staff and program offices and may be approved by the Regional or Center Director or their designees.
b. Responsible officials shall send FONSIs originating in FAA headquarters to AEE-I and to AGC-I for review. After review for legal sufficiency by AGC, the Service or Office Director may sign the FONSI.
43. COORDINATION. Usually FONSIs are required to be coordinated outside of the FAA only where coordination is required by law or administrative directive (e.g., actions involving a section 404 permit, (with Corps of
Engineers, EPA and FWS), Section 4(f) of the DOT Act, Section 106 of the Historic Preservation Act, Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act, or wetlands impact).
Chap 4 Par 41
12/21/83 1050.1D
44. DISTRIBUTION. A copy of the FONSI is filed in the office of the responsible official and a copy forwarded to the appropriate Service or Office Director for review for consistency with the policy and procedures of this order. Service Directors may waive this requirement, subject to AEE-l concurrence. AEE maintains the FAA-wide files of FONSIs and EISs and should receive one copy of each.
45. AVAILABILITY FOR PUBLIC INFORMATION. FONSIs are public information, and shall be made available upon request pursuant to FAA procedures. State and local officials designated by the Intergovernmental Review Plan for the
state should be notified of the availability of the FONSI. For actions with effects primarily of local concern, this complies with the public notice requirement of CEQ sec. 1506.6(b)(3)(i). For actions with effects of national concern, the notice shall include publication in the Federal Register and notice by mail to national organizations interested in the matter. In certain limited circumstances FONSls will be made available, through such state and local officials, for public review for 30 days before the agency makes it final determination whether to prepare an EIS and before the action may begin. These circumstances include situations where the proposed action is similar to that requiring an EIS or where the proposed action is unprecedented. (See CEQ sec. l501.4(e)(2».
46. APPROVAL. The Federal approval shall include the following:
.. After careful and thorough consideration of the facts contained herein, the undersigned finds that the proposed Federal action is consistent with existing national environmental policies and objectives as set forth in Section 101(a) of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA) and that it will not significantly affect the quality of the human environment or otherwise include any condition requiring consultation pursuant to Section 102(2)(C) of NEPA.
APPROVED:
DISAPPROVED:
47. RESERVED.
Chap 4
Par 44
DATE:
DATE:
Page 27 and 28
12/21/83 lOSOolD
CHAPTER 5. PREPARATION OF DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS OR FINDINGS OF NO SIGNIFICANT IMPACT
48. TIMING OF DRAFT STATEMENT PREPARATION. DEISs and FONSIs shall be prepared at the earliest practical time prior to the first significant decision point in the prog"ram or project development process.
49. APPLICATIONS. The program officer may require each applicant for a grant, loan, permit, or other approval to which this order applies, to
submit, with the original application, an environmental assessment. Regardless of the nature of participation, responsible officials or program officers must furnish guidance, actively participate in preparing the DEIS, EIS, and FONSI, and make their own evaluation prior to approval. The responsible official shall take responsibility for the scope and content of an EIS or FONSI. The responsible official shall appropriately limit the actions an applicant may take prior to completion and approval of Erss and
subsequent approval of the application. (CEQ sec. 1506.1)
SO. NOTICE OF INTENT TO PREPARE AN EIS.
a. The first step is described in CEQ sec. 1501.7 as follows: "As soon as practicable after its decision to prepare an environmental impact statement and before the scoping process the lead agency shall publish a notice of intent (CEQ sec. 1508.22) in the FEDERAL REGISTER … This procedure is accomplished by the responsible official sending the notice of intent through AGC-204 with a copy to AEE-I.
b. The notice of intent in CEQ sec. 1508.22 … means a notice that an environmental impact statement will be prepared and considered." The notice shall briefly:
"(1) Describe the proposed action and possible alternatives."
.. (2) Describe the agency's proposed scoping process including whether, when, and where any scoping meeting will be held."
.. (3) State the name and address of a person within the agency who can answer questions about the proposed action and the environmental impact
statement ...
c. Delay. If for some reason there is a lengthy period between the time a decision is made to prepare an environmental impact statement and the actual preparation, CEQ sec. 1507.3(e) provides that … the notice of intent ••• may be published at a reasonable time in advance of preparation of the draft statement."
51. SCOPING.
a. Scoping is an important process. (See CEQ sec. 1501.7). be an early and open process for
Chap 5 Par 48
and early integral part of the EIS
This section provides that "There determining the scope of issues to
shall be
1050.1D 12/21/83
addressed and for identifying the significant issues related to a proposed action." The responsible official must take the lead in the scoping process, including issuance of the notice of intent, inviting the participation of other agencies, determing the issues to be analyzed in depth, and assigning responsibilities for inputs to the environmental impact statement. Scoping, however, is not required if it has been determined that an EIS is not required •.
b. CEQ sec. l501.7(b)(4) states that an agency may "hold an early scoping meeting or meetings, which may be integrated with any other early planning meetings the agency has. Such a scoping meeting will often be appropriate when the impacts of a particular action are confined to
specific si tes. .. Ho'Wever, there is no requirement for a seoping meeting J per se, on every project requiring an environmental impact statement. . Depending on the nature and complexity or the project, some of all of the information needed during the scoping process may be obtained by letter or telephone.
c. CEQ sec. 1501.7 further provides that the lead agency shall "Determine the scope (CEQ sec. 1508.25) and the significant issues to be analyzed in depth in the environmental impact statement." Scope as defined in CEQ sec. 1508.25 " ••• consists of the range of actions, alternatives, and impac ts to be considered … To de termine the range of actions, the problems as described in the environmental assessment should be carefully reviewed. The proposed action and any action functionally related to it should be clearly understood. Alternatives should be reviewed in this context, identifying those which need to be rigorously explored and objectively evaluated as well as those which can be eliminated (CEQ sec. 1502.14(a». Those impact categories which fall below the threshold of significant in the environmental assessment normally do not need further study or description In the environmental impact statement. Establishing a clear definition of the Federal action, the alternatives, and the impact needing detailed study (as well as those which do not) early in the scoping
process should help considerably in managing the environmental impact statement preparation process.
52. USE OF CONTRACTORS IN PREPARATION OF AN EIS.
a. CEQ Sec. l506.5(c) provides that "any environmental impact statement prepared pursuant to the requirements of NEPA shall be prepared directly by or by a contractor selec ted by the lead agency or where appropriate under CEQ sec; 1501.6(b), a cooperating agency."
b. Contractor Preparation. Where a contractor prepares an environmental impact statement, CEQ sec. 1506.5(c) requires that
"Contractors shall execute a disclosure statement prepared by the lead agency, or where appropriate the cooperating agency (for its portion),
specifying that they have no financial or other interest in the outcome of
the pro jec t." Furthermore,"... the responsible Federal official shall furnish guidance and participate in the preparation and shall independently evaluate the statement prior to its approval and take responsibility for its scope and contents."
Chap 5 Par 51
12/21/83 l050.1D
53. INCORPORATION BY REFERENCE. CEQ sec. 1502.21 states that: "Agencies shall incorporate material into an environmental impact ~tatement by reference when the effect will be to cut down on bulk without impeding agency and public review of the action. The incorporated material shall be cited in the statement and its content briefly described. No material may be incorporated by reference unless it is reasonably available for inspection by potentially interested persons within the time allowed for comment. Material based on proprietary data which is itself not available for review and comment shall not be incorporated by reference."
54. INCLUSION OF ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATIONS. EIS or FONSIs shall include relevant documentation for environmental determinations under Section 4(f) of the DOT Act and other environmental findings and determinations."
55. INTERDISCIPLINARY APPROACH. CEQ sec. 102(2)(A) of NEPA requires each Federal agency to apply a systematic, interdisciplinary approach in planning and decisionmaking which may impact the environment. (See CEQ sec. 1502~6.) To assure that all environmental impacts are identified and assessed, all relevant disciplines should be represented. If the office or service does not contain the necessary disciplines, use of professional services available in other Federal,
State, or local agencies, universities, or consulting firms is appropriate. (See paragraph 50 of this order). A listing of the preparers and their qualifications is required under paragraph 68 of this order and CEQ sec. 1502.10 and 1502.17.
56. INTERNAL REVIEW PROCESS.
a. Draft EISs and FONSIs shall be reviewed by affected FAA program divisions and staff officers at the regional or office level prior to filing for public
review. DOT Act Section 4(f) determinations are subject to review as stated in Attachment 2 of this order. This internal review is to assure that related foreseeable agency actions by other FAA elements are properly covered in the statement or finding and are coordinated with the appropriate action office so
that commitments which are the responsibility of other divisions or offices will be carried out.
b. Regional Directors are responsible for designating a lead division or office to carry out this internal review.
57. REGULATIONS. For regulations or rulemaking, the DEIS or FONSI shall be available to reviewing agencies and the public prior to or concurrently with the notice of proposed rulemaking.
58. LEGISLATIVE PROPOSALS.
a. Before the FAA submits to the Congress a legislative proposal, the office which originates the legislation shall prepare, circulate, and file with EPA an environmental impact statement or prepare a FONSI. (See paragraph 74 on circulation In this order).
b. The Office of the Secretary shall review legislative environmental statements and submit them to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) for circulation in the normal legislative clearance process.
59. RESERVED.
Chap 5 Par 53 Page 31 (thru 34)
12/21/B3 1050.10
CHAPTER 6. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT CONTENTS
CHAPTER 6. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT CONTENTS
60. GENERAL. Each EIS shall be prepared in accordance with Attachment 2 of DOT order 56l0.1C.
61. FORMAT. CEQ sec. 1502.10 contains a standard format, which is to be followed for environmental impact statements, as follows:
(a) Cover Sheet (b) Summary (c) Table of Contents (d) Purpose and Need for the Action (e) Alternatives Including the Proposed Action (f) Affected Environment (g) Environmental Consequences (h) List of Preparers (1) List of Agencies, organizations, and Persons to I,hom Copies of the Statement are Sent (j) Index (k) Appendices (if any)
62. COVER SHEET AND SUMMARY.
a. The cover sheet shall include the information required in CEQ sec. 1502.11 plus a heading as follows:
"DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION Draft (or Final) Environmental Impact Statement
This statement is submitted for review pursuant to the following public law requirements: [List those applicable; e.g., section 102(2)(C) of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, section 4(f) of the Department of Transportation Act of 1966]."
b. The summary shall include the information required in CEQ sec. 1502.12 which states "Each environmental impact statement shall contain a summary which adequately and accurately summarizes the statement. The summary shall stress the major conclUSions, areas of controversy (including issues raised by agencies and the public), and the issues to be resolved
(including the choice among alternatives). The summary will normally not exceed 15 pages.
63. PURPOSE AND NEED FOR THE ACTION. CEQ sec. 1502.13 states "The statement shall briefly specify the underlying purpose and need to which
the agency is responding in pro-posing the alternatives including the proposed action."
1050.1D 12(21/83
64. ALTERNATIVES (INCLUDING PROPOSED ACTION). CEQ sec. 1502.14 states that "This section is the heart of the environmental impact statement." Further, it is to be "Base4 on the information an4 analysis presente4 in the sections on the Affected Environment (paragraph 65) ••• and the Environmental Consequences (paragraph 66) ••• ". The FAA responsible official shall apply the applicable CEQ sections below for EISs and in less detail for environmental assessments:
a. Section 1502.1. The environmental impact statement " ••• shall inform decisionmakers and the public of the reasonable alternatives which would avoid or minimize adverse impacts or enhance the quality of the human
environment ...
b. Section l502.2(e). "The range of alternatives discussed in environmental impact statements shall encompass those to be considered by
the ultimate agency decisionmaker."
c. Section 1502.14. The environmental impact statement" ... should present the environmental impacts of the proposal and the alternatives in comparative form, thus sharply defining the issues and providing a clear basis for choice among options by the decisionmaker and the public."
d. Section 1502.14(a). Agencies shall "Rigorously explore and objectively evaluate all reasonable alternatives, and for alternatives which were eliminated from detailed study, briefly discuss the reasons for
their having been eliminated."
e. Section 1502.l4(b). Agencies shall "Devote substantial treatment to each alternative considered in detail including the proposed action so
that reviewers may evaluate their comparative merits."
f. Section 1502.14(10). Agencies shall "Include reasonable alternatives not within the jurisdiction of the lead agency."
g. Section 1502.14(d). Agencies shall "Include the alternative of no ac.tion ...
h. Section 1502.14(0. Agencies shall "Include appropriate mitigation measures not already included in the proposed action or alternatives."
65. AFFECTED ENVIRONMENT. The EIS shall precisely describe the environment of the area(s) to be affected or created by the alternatives under consideration. The descriptions shall be no longer than is necessary to understand the effects of the alternatives (CEQ sec. 1502.15).
a. The amount of detail provided in descriptions of the affected environment shall be commensurate with the amount of information required at the particular level of decisionmaking.
Chap 6 Par 64
12/21/83 1050.1D
b. The statement shall identify, as appropriate, population and growth characteristics of the affected area, and any populstion and growth assumptions used to justify the project or program or to determine secondary population and growth impacts resulting from the proposed action and its alternatives.
c. The statement shall describe other related activities (past, present or foreseeable future actions) in the area, their
interrelationships, and cumulative environmental impact (See CEQ sec. 1508.7 on cumulative impact).
d. The statement shall discuss the relationship of the proposed action to adopted or proposed land use plans, policies, controls, and goals and objectives of affected communities, including communities outside the
jurisdiction in which the proposed project is located. Any participated consultations, permits or authorizations required by Federal law or regulation should be identified.
66. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSEQUENCES. Per CEQ sec. 1502.16, "This section forms the scientific and analytic basis for the comparisons under CEQ sec. 1502.14 (alternatives, as described in paragraph 64). It shall consolidate the discussions of those elements required by CEQ sec. 102(2)(C)(i), (ii),
(iv), (v) of NEPA which are within the scope of the statement and as much of CEQ sec. 102(2)(C)(iii) [alternatives] as is necessary to support the comparisons. The discussion will include the environmental impacts of the alternatives including the proposed action, any adverse .environmental
effects which cannot be avoided should the proposal be implemented, the relationship between short-term uses of man's environment and the maintenance and enhancement of long-term productivity, and any irreversible
or irretrievable commitments of resources which would be involved in the proposal should it be implemented. This section should not duplicate discussions in CEQ sec. 1502.14. It shall include discussions of:
a. "Direct effects and their significance [reference CEQ sec. 1508.18 for definition of 'effects' both direct and indirect] •••
b. "Indire.ct effects and their significance •••
c. "Possible conflicts between the proposed action and the objectives of Federal, regional, State, and local (and in the case of a reservation,
Indian tribe) land use plans, policies and controls for the area concerned. (See CEQ sec. l506.2(d) [Elimination of duplication with State and local procedures] .)
d. action.
"The environmental effects of alternatives including the proposed The comparisons under CEQ sec. 1502.14 will be based on this discussion.
1050.1D
e. ··Energy requirements and conservation potential of various alternatives and mitigation measures.
f. "Natural or depletable resource requirements and conservation potential of various alternatives and mitigation measures.
g. "Urban quality, historic and cultural resources, and the design of the built environment, including the reuse and conservation potential of various alternatives and mitigation measures.
h. covered
"Means to mitigate adverse environmental under CEQ sec. l502.l4(f»)."
impacts (if not fully
Specific environmental impact areas to be discussed "as much as is necessary to support the comparisons [of alternatives]'" are described in Attachment 2 of this order.
, 6 7. MITIGATION MEASURES. Draft EISs should describe measures under consideration or planned to minimize harm from the proposed action. Heasures which will increase the benefits of the proposed action should also be discussed. The following types of measures should be considered:
(1) Design and construction actions. These include alternative locations which avoid or reduce impacts, design measures which reduce impacts, for example, reduced scale facilities, alternative airport runway configurations, aircraft and airway technology which reduces noise, and construction of noise barriers"
(2) Management actions which reduce impacts during operation of the facility. These include aircraft operating procedures for noise abatement, maintaining open areas to enhance their usefulness as wildlife habita t.
(3) Replacement, restoration, and compens.ation. These measures include functional replacement of public facilities, residential or business relocation aSSistance, and restoration of natural areas disturbed by construction.
68. LIST OF PREPARERS. CEQ sec. 1502.17 states ·'The environmehtal impact statement shall list the names, together with their qualifications (expertise, experience, professional disciplines), of the persons who were , primarily responsible for preparing the EIS or significant, background
papers, including basic components of the statement. Where possible the persons who are responsible for a particular analysis including analyses in background papers, shall be identified. Normally the list will not exceed two pages."
69.-70. RESERVED.
Chap 6 Page 38 Par 66
12/21/83 1050.1D
CHAPTER 7. PROCESSING DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS
CHAPTER 7. PROCESSING DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS
71. GENERAL. Environmental impact statements shall be reviewed by affected FAA program divisions and staff officers at the regional level
prior to filing for public review. This internal review is to assure that related foreseeable agency actions by other FAA elements are properly covered in the draft statement and are coordinated with the appropriate action office so that commitments which are the responsibility of other divisions or offices will be carried out. For adoption of another agency's environmental impact statement, refer to CEQ sec. 1506.3.
72. PUBLIC NOTICE. Each responsible official shatl assure that press releases, official notices, or other appropriate media announce to the public that a DEIS has been prepared and is being circulated and that comments on the environmental impact of the proposed action are being solicited. The announcement shall contain information on the availability of the DEIS and should be distributed to local media concurrent with distribution for notice in Federal Register; with request for immediate publication or other appropriate media coverage.
73. COPIES. The responsible official shall have printed sufficient copies of DEISs to meet anticipated demand. A fee, not to exceed reproduction costs, may be charged for copies requested by the public if the original
set of copies is exhausted.
74. CIRCULATION AND AVAILABILITY OF DEIS.
a. Distribution and Coordination for Intergovernmental Review.
(1) Per CEQ sec. 1503.1, comments on the draft environmental impact statement shall be obtained from or requested of appropriate Federal, State, and local agencies.
(2) For instructions on circulation of the summary in lieu of the full environmental impact statement, see CEQ sec. 1502.19.
(3) All draft environmental impact statements will be coordinated with the appropriate regional offices of other Federal agencies having
jurisdiction by law or special expertise, except that statements to be coordinated with any component of the Department of the Interior (DOl), Department of Commerce (DOC), or .Department of Energy (DOE) shall be sent directly to the Washington headquarters of these departments.
b. Circulate the DEIS to agencies which have "jurisdiction by law or special expertise with respect to any environmental impact involved" or "which are authorized to develop and enforce environmental standards." In addition, provide copies to:
1050.1D 12/21/83
(1) EPA headquarters (5 copies), EPA region (5 copies), P-l (2 copies), Office of Environment and Energy (1 copy), Office of Chief Counsel or designee (1 copy), the service director, other elements of DOT, and other FAA services as appropriate; U.S. Department of the Interior headquarters (12 copies; except for projects in North and South Dakota, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma, and Texas, 13 copies; and for Alaska, Arizona,
California, Colorado, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah, Washington, and Wyoming 14 copies); Ecology and Conservation Division of
the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (1 copy); only for transportation proposals having major energy-related consequences, DOE
(1 copy); and
(2) State and local agencies, including' cooperating agencies, agencies that commented substantively on the Intergovernmental Review of
Federal Programs, affected cities and counties, and others known to have an interest in the action. The Intergovernmental Review of Federal Programs process may be used, by mutual agreement, for securing review of DEISs by State and local agencies.
c. Availability to the Public. The draft environmental impact statement shall be made available for public review per CEQ sec. 1506.6.
d. Filing with EPA. The draft environmental impact statement shall be filed with EPA per CEQ sec. 1 ';06.9. The EPA will subsequently publish a notice in the Federal Register per CEQ sec. 1506.10 which will begin the
90-day period after which the Federal action can be taken. Five copies of the draft statement shall be sent to: Office of Federal Activities, EIS Filing Section (A-I04), u.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 401 M Street, S.W., Washington, D.C. 20460.
75. COMMENTS ON THE DEIS.
a. CEQ sec. 1503 addresses specificity of comments. If the responsible official considers that the comments received from a commenting agency have not been made in accordance with the intent of this section, consultation with that agency should be undertaken to rectify discrepancies.
b. CEQ 1503.3(a) states, "Comments on the environmental impact statement or on the proposed action shall be as specific as possible and address either the adequacy of the statement or the merits of the alternatives discussed or both."
c. Comments from EPA are categorized according to the following criteria:
(1) The impact is rated by EPA as: LO (Lack of Objections), ER (Environmental Reservations), or EU (Environmentally Unsatisfactory).
(2) The statement adequacy is categorized by EPA as: 1 (Adequate), 2 (Insufficient Information), or 3 (Inadequate).
Chap, 7 Page 40 Par 74
12/21/83 1050.10
76. COMMENT PERIODS. A time period for comment may not be fewer than 45 days from publication of the notice by EPA per paragraph 74d above. Requests for reasonable extensions of time, when warranted by magnitude and complexity of the statement or the extent of citizen interest, shall be granted.
77 .-79.
Chap 7 Par 75
RESERVED.
Page" 41 (thru 4L
CHAPTER 8.
PREPARATION, APPROVAL, AND DISTRIBUTION OF FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS
PREPARATION, APPROVAL, AND DISTRIBUTION OF FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS
80. UTILIZATION OF COMMENTS.
a. Comments received on the DEIS and inputs (in summary form if appropriate) from citizen participation, and public hearings shall accompany the EIS through the normal internal review process.
b. In preparing an EIS the DE IS shall be revised, as appropriate, to reflect comments received, issues raised through the community involvement and public hearing process, or other considerations" An appropriate response, or reference to subject's discussion in the statement shall be made. Copies of all substantive commenting letters shall be included. If the number of comments is too voluminous to include, a summary may be prepared in accordance with CEQ sec. l503.4(b).
c. Every effort shall be made to resolve environmental issues prior to final EIS preparation. Any unresolved environmental issues and efforts to resolve them through further consultation shall be identified and discussed. For instance, where an agency comments that the statement contains inadequate analysiS or that the impacts are too adverse for approval, either the issue shall be resolved, or efforts to resolve the
issue shall be documented, and any action that will result shall be noted.
d. Compliance with other Requirements. The final EIS shall reflect that there has been compliance with the requirements of all applicable environmental laws and orders, such as section 4(f) of the DOT Act. If such compliance is not possible by the time of final EIS preparation, the EIS shall reflect consultation with the appropriate agencies and provide reasonable assurance that the requirements can be met.
e. The final EIS must reflect mitigation measures which will be included as part of the proposed action.
81. APPROVAL OF FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS.
a. For EISs which originate at headquarters, the Office or Service Director shall send one copy of each EIS to AEE-l and AGC-l for review. After the Office or Service Director approves the EIS, file it with EPA. (See para. 83)
1050. 1 D 12/21/83
b. For Erss originating in the field, not subject to headquarters' concurrence, the Regional or Center Director shall approve and file the ErS with EPA, following review for legal sufficiency by the Regional Counsel.
c. For EISs originating in regions or centers, but when headquarters concurrence is requested, the Regional or Center Director shall approve the
EIS and submit it to the appropriate service or office director. Following approval, the EIS must be filed with EPA. (See para. 83)
d. For ErSs originating in regions or centers, but where authority to approve the ElS is retained in headquarters, (see FAA Order 5050.4), the region or center shall send the proposed EIS to the appropriate service or office director. The service or office shall send copies to the Office of Environment and Energy and to the Chief Counsel for review. Following approval, the EIS must be filed with EPA. (See para. 83)
e. All statements involving Section 4(f) of the DOT Act are subject to AGC review for legal sufficiency in headquarters.
f • ,For highly controversial final EISs requiring headquarters I review and concurrence, P-I and C-I shall be notified that the final EIS is under review and be provided with a copy of the summary section contained in the final EIS. P-l and C-I will also be given at least 2 weeks notice before approval of the final EIS.
g. Approval. After appropriate internal review, a approximately as follows shall be added to the summary. blocks shall be added for the concurrence of appropriate approval or disapproval of the approving official.
declaration
Signature and date offices and
"After careful and thorough consideration of the facts contained herein and following consideration of the views of those Federal agencies having jurisdiction by law or special expertise with respect to the environmental impacts described, the undersigned finds that the proposed Federal action is consistent with existing national environmental policies and objectives as set forth in
Section lOI(a) of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969.··
82. AVAILABILITY PENDING APPROVAL. In addition to the availability and distribution of approved final ErSs, final statements proposed for approval
shall norm&lly be made available upon request in FAA offices for inspection by the public and Federal, State, or local agencies prior to final approval and filing with EPA. Such statements should carry a notation that they have not been approved and filed.
83. DISTRIBUTION OF APPROVED ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS. The originating FAA region, center, or service shall simultaneously distribute
the EIS as follows:
Chap 8 Par 81
12/5/86 10SO.1D CRG 3
12/5/86 10SO.1D CRG 3
a. Five copies to:
Office of Federal Activities Environmental Protection Agency (A-lOt» 401 M Street, SW Washington, DC 20460
b. Five copies to the appropriate regional office of EPA (one copv if categorized as LO-I per paragraph 75 of this order).
c. One copy of the EIS to the Office of Environment and Energy (AEE-l) and to the Service or Office Director.
* d. One copy of the approved final EIS shall be sent to the Office of Transportation Regulatory Affairs, Environmental Division, P-14. *
e. A copy of the EIS shall also be sent to each Federal, state, and local agency, to private organizations which made substantive comments on the draft statement and to individuals who requested a copy of the final statement or who made substantive comments on the draft. D.OI copies shall be sent to the Director, Environmental Project Review, U.S. Department of
the Interior, Washington, D.C. 20240. DOl shall be sent seven copies for proposals in all states except that eight copies would be sent for proposals in North and South Dakota, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma, and Texas; nine for projects in Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah, Washington, and Wyoming. For
transportation proposals having major energy-related consequences, one copy should be sent to DOE headquarters.
f. One copy to any sponsor, applicant or grantee.
g. One copy to appropriate state-designated single point of contact (or specific agency contacted when states have not designated a single contact point), unless otherwise designated by the governor.
h. Additional copies shall be sent to accessible locations to be made available to the general publiC, including headquarters and regional offices; state, metropolitan, and local public libraries.
i. Pursuant to CEQ sec. 1506.6, environmental statements, comments received, and underlying documents will be made available to the public without charge to the fullest extent practical or at a reduced charge which is not more than the actual cost of reproducing copies.
1050.1D 12/5/86
84. REFERRALS TO CEQ. The Council on Environmental Quality may serve as a mediator in interagency disagreements over proposed Federal actions that might cause unsatisfactory environmental effects (see CEQ sec. 1504).
a. If a commenting agency determines that an action is environmentally unsatisfactory, the matter may be referred to CEQ.
b. When the responsible official receives a notice of intended referral from the commenting agency, this official shall provide P-l and AEE-l with a copy of the notice.
c. In the event of referral to CEQ by a commenting agency, the responsible official shall forward a proposed response to AEE-l within 10 days of referral. The response shall address fully the issues raised in the referral and be supported by evidence. AEE-l shall obtain P-l's concurrence in the proposed response. The response shall be sent to CEQ within 20 days of the referral.
85.-87.
Pali'e 48
RESERVED.
Chap 8
Par 84
12/21/83 1050.1D
CHAPTER 9. TIERING, TIME LIMITATIONS, WRITTEN REEVALUATION, AND SUPPLEMENTAL ACTIONS
CHAPTER 9. TIERING, TIME LIMITATIONS, WRITTEN REEVALUATION, AND SUPPLEMENTAL ACTIONS
88. TIERING. Program offices shall, to the extent practicable, build upon broad prior assessments, whether EIS or FONSI. For example, long-term development statements and broad system, program, or regional statements may be incorporated by specific project EISs. The purpose of tiering is to eliminate repetition and allow discussion of issues at the appropriate level of detail. (See CEQ sec. 1500.4, 1502.4, 1502.20, and 1508.28.)
89. REDUCING PAPERWORK. Environmental documentation prepared under this order shall be concise and clear. Length of documentation shall be reduced by avoidance of needless detail and by other means such as setting appropriate page limits. (See CEQ sec. 1500.4.)
90. REDUCING DELAY. Envi~onmental documentation prepared under this order shall be integrated into the decisionmaking process and shall be carried on in a timely manner. (See CEQ sec. 1500.5).
91. TIME LIMITS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENTS. The time limits below have been established for all DOT EISs.
a. A draft EIS may be assumed valid for a period of 3 years. If the proposed final EIS is not submitted to the approving official within 3 years from the date of the draft EIS circulation, a written reevaluation of
the draft shall be prepared by the responsible Federal official to determine whether the consideration of alternatives, impacts, existing environment, and mitigation measures set forth in the draft EIS remain applicable, accurate, and valid. If there have been changes in these factors which would be significant in the consideration of the proposal, a supplement to the draft EIS or a new draft EIS shall be prepared and circulated.
b. lVith regard to approved final ErSs, three sets of conditions Mve been established:
(1) If major steps toward implementation of the proposed action (such as the start of construction, substantial acquisition, or relocation activities) have not commenced within 3 years from the date of approval of
the final EIS, a written reevaluation of the adequacy, accuracy, and validity of the final EIS shall be prepared by the responsible Federal official (unless EIS tiering is being used). If there have been significant changes in the proposed action, the affected environment, anticipated impacts, or proposed mitigation measures, a new or supplemental
EIS shall be prepared and circulated.
(2) If the proposed action is to be implemented in stages or requires successive Federal approvals, a written reevaluation of the continued adequacy, accuracy, and validity of the final EIS shall be made at each major approval point which occurs more than 3 years after approval of the final EIS and a new or supplemental EIS prepared, if necessary;
1050.10 12/21/83
(3) If the proposed action has been restrained or enjoined by court order or legislative process after approval of the final EIS, the 3 year period may be extended by the time equal to the duration of the injunction, restraining order, or legislative delay.
92. WRITTEN REEVALUATION. The preparation of a new EIS or FONSI is not necessary when it can be documented that: the proposed action conforms of plans or projects for which a prior ~IS or FONSI has been filed; the data and analyses contained in the previous EIS or FONSI are still substantial19 valid; and that all pertinent conditions and requirements of the prior
approval have or will be met in the current action. This evaluation, signed by the FAA responsible offic~al, will either conclude the contents of previously prepared environmental documents remain valid or that
significant changes require the preparation of a supplement or new environmental document.
93 •. .5UPPl.EMENTAL OR AMENDED STATEMENTS. CEQ sec. l502.9(c) states that "Agencies:
a. Shall prepare supplements to either draft or final EISs if:
(1) The agency makes substantial changes in the proposed action that are relevant to environmental concerns; or
(2) There are significant new circumstances or information relevant to environ.mental concerns and bearing on the proposed action or its impacts.
b. May also prepare supplements when the agency determines that the purposes of the Act will be furthered by doing· so.
c. Shall adopt procedures for introducing a supplement into its formal administrative record, if such a record exists.
d. Shall prepare, circulate, and file a supplement to a statement in the same fashion (exclusive of scoping) as a draft and final statement unless alternative procedures are approved by the Council."
e. If there are compelling reasons to shorten time periods, FAA may consult with CEQ.
94. IMPLEMENTATION OF COMMITMENTS IN ENVIRONMENTAL STATEMENTS. In accordance with CEQ sec. 1505.3, "Mitigation ••• and other conditions established in the environmental impact statement or during its review and committed as part of the decision shall be implemented by the lead agency or other. appropriate consenting agency." This section of the CEQ Regulations further specifies actions which the lead agency shall take to implement environmental commitments. The FAA shall take steps as
Chap 9 Par 91
12/21/83 lOSO.lD
appropriate to the action, through special conditions, funding agreements, contract specifications, preferential arrival and departure procedures, directives, other project review or implementation procedures, and other appropriate follow-up actions that the agency and applicants carry out any actions to minimize adverse environmental effects set forth in the approved
statement. Any proposed deviation from prescribed action that may reduce protection to the environment shall be submitted to the Office of Environment and Energy.
95. LIMITATIONS ON ACTIONS. In accordance with CEQ sec. 1506.1, actions concerning the proposal shall not be taken until the responsible office
issues the Record of Decision.
96. RECORD OF DECISION.
a. Following the review periods prescribed in CEQ sec. 1506.10, the FAA decisionmaker may make a decision on the Federal action. CEQ sec. 1505.2 requires a Record of Decision (ROD) and specifies information to be included in the Record of Decision. The draft ROD should accompany the proposed final statement during the internal review prior to EIS approval only when headquarters' concurrence is required.
b. Any mitigation measures which were made a condition of the approval of the EIS shall be included in the ROD. Proposed changes in or deletions of mitigation measures which were a condition of approval of the
EIS must be reviewed by the same FAA offices which reviewed the final statement and must be approved by the EIS approving official.
c. If the responsible official wishes to take an action which was included within the range of alternatives of an approved EIS but was neither the environmentally preferable alternative or alternatives nor the agency's preferred alternative as identified in the final statement, the decisionmaker must first coordinate a draft ROD for concurrence with the
same FAA offices which reviewed the final statement. These offices may concur without comment, may concur on the condition"that specific mitigation measures be incorporated in the ROD, may request that a
supplement to the EIS be prepared and circulated, or may nonconcur. The responsible official shall not approve the Federal action over a nonconcurrence.
d. If the alternative the responsible official wishes to take action on involves a special interest (e.g., Section 4(f) land, endangered
species, wetlands, historic sites, or others), the FAA must first complete any required evaluation and consultation that has not been done, including
supplementing the original EIS, prior to taking the action. Supplements to EISs shall be reviewed and approved in the same manner as the original document, and a new ROD shall be prepared and approved. If a ROD is prepared, a copy should be forwarded with the EIS to AEE-l for their files.
1050.10 12/21/83
97. PUBLIC RECORD. Relevant environmental documents, comments, and responses are part of the agency's public record and shall be made availaole to the public through appropriate regional, office or service
procedures.
98. USE OF INFORMATION.
a. CEQ sec. 1506.5(c) specifically provides "Nothing ••• is intended to prohibit any agency from requesting any person to submit information to it or to prohibit any person from' submitting information. to any agency."
b. The use of information obtained in the m~nner set forth above may obviate the need for extensive contractual efforts in preparing an environmental impact statement. It must be cautioned, however, that any information so received may only be used after thorough analysis and acceptability of its contents by the FAA. To the extent that the qualifications of those persons primarily responsible for .its preparation and the identification of persons responsible for particular analyses
should be listed for incorporation in the list of preparers of the environmental impact statement (see paragraph 68 of this order).
99.-100. RESERVED.
Chap 9 Page 52 Par 97
12/21/83 l050.1D
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 164 passages shown