Radar Vectors
Proposed Rule Proposed Issued Jul 11, 2000 37 pages Copy saved Nov 17, 2026

65 FR 42796 Noise Certification Standards for Subsonic Jet Airplanes and Subsonic Transport Category Large Airplanes

The FAA is proposing changes to the noise certification standards for subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes. These proposed changes are based on the joint effort of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), the European Joint Aviation Authorities (JAA), and Aviation Rulemaking Advisory Committee (ARAC), to harmonize the U.S. noise certification regulations and the European Joint Aviation Requirements (JAR) for subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes. These proposed changes would provide nearly uniform noise certification standards for airplanes certificated in the United States and in the JAA countries. The harmonization of the noise certification standards would simplify airworthiness approvals for import and export purposes.

This document is proposed. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.

Official source ↗ Official PDF ↗

Part III

14 CFR Parts 21 and 36

Noise Certification Standards for Subsonic Jet Airplanes and Subsonic Transport Category Large Airplanes; Proposed Rule DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

14 CFR Parts 21 and 36

[Docket No. FAA-2000-7587; Notice No. 00-08] RIN 2120-AH03

Noise Certification Standards for Subsonic Jet Airplanes and Subsonic Transport Category Large Airplanes

Agency

AGENCY: Federal Aviation Administration, DOT.

ACTION: Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM).

SUMMARY: The FAA is proposing changes to the noise certification standards for subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes. These proposed changes are based on the joint effort of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), the European Joint Aviation Authorities (JAA), and Aviation Rulemaking Advisory Committee (ARAC), to harmonize the U.S. noise certification regulations and the European Joint Aviation Requirements (JAR) for subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes. These proposed changes would provide nearly uniform noise certification standards for airplanes certificated in the United States and in the JAA countries. The harmonization of the noise certification standards would simplify airworthiness approvals for import and export purposes.

Dates

DATES: Comments must be received on or before October 10, 2000.

ADDRESSES: Address your comments to the Docket Management System, U.S. Department of Transportation, Room Plaza 401, 400 Seventh Street, SW., Washington, DC 20590-0001. You must identify the docket number FAA-2000-7587 at the beginning of your comments, and you should submit two copies of your comments. If you wish to receive confirmation that FAA received your comments, include a self-addressed, stamped postcard.

Addresses

You may also submit comments and you may review public dockets through the Internet at http://dms.dot.gov. You may review the public docket containing comments to these proposed regulations in person in the Dockets Office between 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m., Monday through Friday, except Federal holidays. The Dockets Office is on the plaza level of the NASSIF Building at the Department of Transportation at the above address.

For Further Information Contact

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: James Skalecky, AEE-100, Office of Environment and Energy (AEE), Federal Aviation Administration, 800 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC 20591; telephone (202) 267-3699; facsimile (202) 267-5594; or email at [email protected].

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Comments Invited

Comments Invited

Interested persons are invited to participate in this rulemaking by submitting written comments, data, views, or arguments. Comments on the possible environmental, economic, and federalism or energy related impact of the adoption of this proposal are welcomed.

Comments should carry the regulatory docket or notice number and should be submitted in triplicate to the Rules Docket address specified above. All comments received and a report summarizing any substantive public contact with FAA personnel on this rulemaking will be filed in the docket. The docket is available for public inspection both before and after the closing date for receiving comments.

Before taking any final action on this proposal, the Administrator will consider the comments made on or before the closing date for comments, and the proposal may be changed in light of the comments received.

The FAA will acknowledge receipt of comments if commenters include a self-addressed, stamped postcard with the comments. The postcards should be marked "Comments to Docket No. FAA-2000-7587." When the comments are received by the FAA, the postcards will be dated, time stamped, and returned to the commenters.

Availability of the NPRM

Availability of the NPRM

An electronic copy of this document may be downloaded using a modem and suitable communications software from the FAA regulations section of the FedWorld electronic bulletin board service (telephone: (703) 321-3339) or the Government Printing Office (GPO)'s electronic bulletin board service (telephone: (202) 512-1661).

Internet users may reach the FAA's web page at http://www.faa.gov/avr/arm/nprm/nprm.htm or the GPO's web page at http://www.access.gpo.gov/nara for access to recently published rulemaking documents.

Any person may obtain a copy of this document by submitting a request to the Federal Aviation Administration, Office of Rulemaking, ARM-1, 800 Independence Avenue SW., Washington, DC 20591, or by calling (202) 267-9680. Communications must identify the notice number or docket number of this NPRM.

Persons interested in being placed on the mailing list for future rulemaking documents should request from the above office a copy of Advisory Circular No. 11-2A, Notice of Proposed Rulemaking Distribution System, which describes the application procedure.

Background

Background

Current Regulations

Under 49 U.S.C. 44715, the Administrator of the Federal Aviation Administration is directed to prescribe "standards to measure aircraft noise and sonic boom; . . . and regulations to control and abate aircraft noise and sonic boom." Part 36 of Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (part 36) contains the FAA's noise standards and regulations that apply to the issuance of type certificates for all types of aircraft. Subparts A, B and C and appendices A, B and C of part 36 contain the requirements and standards that apply to subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes. Appendices A, B and C of part 36 specify the test conditions, procedures, and noise levels necessary to demonstrate compliance.

Government and Industry Cooperation

Government and Industry Cooperation

In June 1990 at a meeting of the Joint Aviation Authorities (JAA) Council, which consists of JAA members from European countries and the FAA, the FAA Administrator committed the FAA to support the harmonization of the U.S. regulations with the Joint Aviation Regulations (JAR). The Joint Aviation Regulations are being developed for use by the European authorities that are member countries of the JAA.

In January 1991, the FAA established the Aviation Rulemaking Advisory Committee to serve as a forum for the FAA to obtain input from outside the government on major regulatory issues facing the agency. The FAA has tasked ARAC with noise certification issues. These issues involve the harmonization of part 36 with JAR 36, the harmonization of associated guidance material including equivalent procedures, and interpretations of the regulations. On October 17, 1995, the ARAC established the FAR/JAR Harmonization Working Group for Subsonic Transport Category Large Airplanes and Subsonic Turbojet Powered Airplanes (60 FR 53824). The working group task included reviewing the applicable provisions of subparts A, B, and C, and appendices A, B, and C of part 36, and harmonizing them with the corresponding applicable provisions of JAR 36. The working group was asked to consider the current international standards and recommended practices, as issued under International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), Annex 16, Volume 1, and its associated Technical Manual, as the basis for development of these harmonization proposals. A recommendation for amending part 36 was forwarded to the ARAC. After due consideration including a meeting open to the public on May 18, 2000, this recommendation agreed to by ARAC was forwarded, in the form of a draft NPRM, to the FAA for consideration.

Synopsis of the Proposal

Synopsis of the Proposal

Part 36 contains noise standards for aircraft type and airworthiness certification. Subparts A, B, and C, and the related appendices A, B, and C, of part 36 prescribe noise levels and test procedures for subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes, including rules governing the issuance of original, amended, or supplemental type certificates.

This notice of proposed rulemaking includes changes to part 36 in three major categories. First, there are substantive changes to technical material, such as proposing a revised method for demonstrating the lateral noise certification level for propeller-driven large airplanes. These changes are discussed individually in this preamble. Second, there are many proposed changes to regulatory text that would serve to minimize the language differences between part 36 and JAR 36, while having no substantive effect on the regulatory standards of part 36. These text changes are not specifically discussed in this preamble Third, there are numerous proposed changes to the section designations of current Appendices A, B, and C of part 36 that would more closely align part 36 and JAR 36 formats. Changes in this category would have no substantive effect on the regulatory standards of part 36. The changes in part 36 appendices designation are shown in a tabular format that identifies current part 36 appendices sections and the corresponding section of the proposed revision. This redesignation table appears at the end of the section-by-section discussion.

Section-by-Section Discussion

Section-by-Section Discussion

The following is a section-by-section discussion of the proposed amendments that will cover the substantive changes being proposed for the regulatory standards of part 36 and its appendices. Sections that are proposed for redesignation, but not substantively changed, will not be discussed, but will appear only in the redesignation table that follows the section-by-section discussion. Throughout the proposed amendment, the term "jet" has been used when referring to turbojet and turbofan engines. This would change the terminology in current part 36, which uses the term "turbojet" when referring to both turbojet and turbofan engines. This change would result in the same terminology usage by both part 36 and JAR 36, when referring to turbojet and turbofan engines.

Section 36.1

Section 36.1

The FAA is proposing to remove § 36.1(d)(3). This section should have been removed by Amendment 36-10 (43 FR 28406, June 29, 1978), which redesignated § 36.1(d)(3) as § 36.1(d)(1)(iii).

In § 36.1(f)(1), the terms "takeoff" and "sideline" are proposed to be replaced with the terms "flyover" and "lateral", respectively. This change would harmonize the terminology based on the international standard.

Section 36.2

Section 36.2

Section 36.2, "Special retroactive requirements" would be removed. Section 36.2 requires that the noise certification applicant show compliance to the part 36 amendment that is in effect on the date of certification. This requirement was included in part 36 when the FAA did not have the authority to prevent the issuance of a type certificate for an aircraft for which available and reasonable noise reduction design practices had not been incorporated. The FAA subsequently received this authority under the Noise Control Act of 1972; the retroactive requirement contained in § 36.2 is no longer necessary. This change would harmonize the applicability designation of part 36 with that contained in § 1.7 of ICAO annex 16, Chapter 1. In conjunction with the proposed removal of the special retroactive requirements of part 36 § 36.2, this notice proposes changes to §§ 21.17 and 21.101(a) of part 21 of this chapter to remove references to part 36 that are contained in these sections of part 21.

Section 36.6

Section 36.6

The FAA proposes to add five specifications to the incorporated matter under § 36.6. These specifications are referred to under proposed section A36.3, which would update requirements for measurement and analysis systems to address the latest standards and equipment technology. Updated addresses for the International Electrotechnical Commission, American National Standards Institute, and FAA Regional Headquarters are also included in proposed § 36.6.

Sections 36.101 and 36.103

Sections 36.101 and 36.103

Two sections, 36.101, Noise measurement, and 36.103, Noise evaluation, would be replaced with a new § 36.101, Noise measurement and evaluation. The proposed § 36.101 reflects the proposal to combine the material contained in current Appendix A and Appendix B into proposed Appendix A. This proposed change would more closely align part 36 and JAR 36 formats without any substantive effect. Also for the purpose of aligning the formats of part 36 and JAR 36, the FAA proposes to redesignate § 36.201 as § 36.103. Current subpart C would be reserved.

Appendix A--Aircraft Noise Measurement and Evaluation Under § 36.101

Appendix A--Aircraft Noise Measurement and Evaluation Under § 36.101

The proposed Appendix A to part 36, Aircraft Noise Measurement and Evaluation under § 36.101, would replace current Appendix A, Aircraft Noise Measurement under § 36.101, and Appendix B, Aircraft Noise Evaluation under § 36.103. The harmonization objective is to develop seamless part 36 and JAR 36 regulations that reflect ICAO Annex 16 to the extent possible. The text of JAR 36, Appendix A, is essentially a copy of Annex 16, Appendix 2. The proposed Appendix A to part 36 was developed with the intent of maintaining a section format consistent with JAR 36, Appendix A and ICAO Annex 16, Appendix 2.

Appendix A36.1 Introduction

Appendix A36.1 Introduction

A new section A36.1.2 would be added to state that the noise certification instructions and procedures given are intended to ensure uniform results and to permit comparison between tests of various types of aircraft conducted in various geographical locations.

Appendix A36.2 Noise Certification Test and Measurement Conditions

Appendix A36.2 Noise Certification Test and Measurement Conditions

Proposed section A36.2 would replace current section A36.1. This proposed section describes the conditions under which noise certification testing would be conducted and the measurement procedures that would be required.

Under the proposal, current section A36.5(e)(4), that addresses the use of equivalent procedures, would be deleted. The key requirement of the section, that equivalent procedures must be FAA-approved, is already addressed in the regulatory text of § 36.101. Additional information on the use of equivalent procedures would be provided in the note contained in section A36.2.1.1. Therefore, section A36.5(e)(4) would be deleted since its content would be addressed in § 36.101.

A note in section A36.2.1.1 would reference the guidance material on the use of equivalent procedures contained in Advisory Circular 36-4C, "Noise Standards: Aircraft Type and Airworthiness Certification". Current AC36-4B, "Noise Certification Handbook", contains guidance material on the use of equivalent procedures. AC36-4B will be revised and significantly changed in format and content, and will be designated AC36-4C, "Noise Standards: Aircraft Type and Airworthiness Certification." The FAA intends to issue the new AC36-4C concurrently with the final rule that results from this notice. The AC36-4C is referred to as "the current Advisory Circular for this part" throughout the proposed regulatory text in order to avoid the need for formal rulemaking any time the Advisory Circular is revised. Throughout this preamble, however, the Advisory Circular is referred to as Advisory Circular 36-4C.

Most of proposed section A36.2 is moved from sections A36.1, A36.5 and A36.9. Under the proposal, the material in current section A36.1(c)(1) would be moved to proposed section A36.2.2.2(a) and revised to remove the word "rain", since rain is included in the term "precipitation." The material in section A36.1(c)(2) would be moved to proposed section A36.2.2.2(b) and the minimum test temperature limit decreased from 36 deg.F (2.2 deg.C) to 14 deg.F (-10 deg.C). The current 36 deg.F (2.2 deg.C) temperature limit is considered unnecessarily restrictive, given that no higher levels of atmospheric absorption, compared with those existing in the current test window, could be encountered by lowering the test day temperature. Under this revised minimum test temperature limit, testing would still be required to be conducted in conformance with the operational temperature limit for the noise measuring equipment being used.

Proposed section A36.2.2.2(c), does not contain the current section A36.1(c)(3) provision that permits expanded atmospheric attenuation rates when the dew point and dry bulb temperatures used for obtaining relative humidity are measured with a device which is accurate to within ±0.5 deg.C. This allowance for expanded atmospheric attenuation rates is already permitted as an equivalent procedure by AC36-4B, and will continue to be permitted as an equivalent procedure in the revision to AC36-4B (i.e., AC36-4C). The result would be no change in the allowance of expanded atmospheric attenuation rates. This change is proposed to meet the harmonization objective to more closely align part 36 and JAR 36 formats.

The requirement to obtain meteorological measurements within "25 minutes" of each noise test measurement as required in current section A36.9(b)(3) would be changed to "30 minutes" in proposed section A36.2.2.2(g). Thirty minutes is the established international standard in ICAO Annex 16. The FAA was unable to find a technical reason why the meteorological measurement time was originally set at 25 minutes. Based on technical and application considerations, an increment of 5 minutes does not constitute a substantive difference. No known technical criteria exist with which to assess this minimal time increment. This change is being proposed to achieve harmonization by adopting a single international standard.

Current section A36.9(d)(3) would be revised and moved to section A36.2.2.3. This amendment would change the method used to establish layer depth to a single international standard. Part 36 does not provide specific criteria for determining layer depth, except to require that it be no greater than 100 ft. The proposed criteria for determining layer depth is the same as that used to specify the onset of required layering, i.e. under weather conditions where the atmospheric attenuation rate changes by more than +/-1.6 dB/1000 ft (+/ -0.5 dB/100m) over the sound propagation distance. Under this proposal, the minimum layer depth would be established as 100 feet (30 meters). Thus, the layer depth would be 100 feet (30 meters) in cases where the atmospheric rate change criteria would limit the layer depth to less than 100 feet (30 meters).

Section A36.3 Measurement of Aircraft Noise Received on the Ground

Section A36.3 Measurement of Aircraft Noise Received on the Ground

The proposed changes to this section are intended to update the requirements for measurement and analysis systems to address the latest standards and equipment technology. The changes were drafted by an international task group, that has years of knowledge and experience in the noise certification of airplanes, and was assembled to update the ICAO Annex 16 requirements for measurement and analysis systems. The proposed changes in section A36.3 incorporates the international task group's recommendations, which were agreed to by Working Group 1 of the ICAO Committee on Aviation Environmental Protection (ICAO/CAEP). Further, the proposed changes are intended to harmonize with the international standard, Annex 16. The primary purpose of this work was to address considerations related to the use of digital equipment. Many of these considerations are addressed in the International Electro-Technical Commission (IEC) Standard 61265 and IEC Standard 61260. Accordingly, much of the pertinent text from these standards has been included in the requirements developed by the international task group. These IEC standards also reflect general improvements to instrumentation technology that have occurred over the past decade, although they are not necessarily related to the advent of digital technology. In addition to improvements tied to the IEC standards, several changes that resulted from the work of the task group are linked to general advancements in noise measurement instrumentation overall.

Proposed section A36.3 includes the following specific changes to current section A36.3. Current section A36.3 does not include definitions. Section A36.3.1, Definitions, would be added to define the terms used in proposed section A36.3. Under the proposal, section A36.3.2, Reference environmental conditions, would be added for specifying the performance of a measurement system.

Section A36.3.3.2 would specify anti-alias requirements for measurement systems that include analog to digital signal conversion.

Proposed section A36.3.4.1 would add a requirement that windscreen insertion loss not exceed ±1.5 dB. In addition, proposed section A36.3.9.10 would specify allowable changes in windscreen insertion loss.

Proposed sections A36.3.5.3 and A36.3.5.4 would specify microphone sensitivity requirements only at the midband frequencies. This is a simplification of the current part 36 requirement contained in sections A36.3(c)(2)(ii) and A36.3(c)(2)(iii). Sections A36.3.5.3 and A36.3.5.4 would also specify more stringent tolerances on microphone sensitivity. Typical microphones that are currently used in part 36 noise certification testing comply with this more stringent microphone sensitivity requirement.

Proposed section A36.3.6.3 would add a tolerance for frequency response of the measurement system.

For analog tape, proposed section A36.3.6.4 would add a ±0.5 dB tolerance for amplitude fluctuations of a recorded 1 kHz signal.

Proposed section A36.3.6.5 would add a tolerance for amplitude linearity, at several specific frequencies, for the measurement system (exclusive of the microphone.)

Proposed section A36.3.6.6 would require that the electronic signal level corresponding to the calibration sound pressure level be from 5 dB to 30 dB less than the upper boundary of the measurement system level range. A similar requirement in current part 36, section A36.(c)(3)(i), is 10 dB.

Proposed section A36.3.6.8 would add a requirement for an overload indicator in the recording and reproducing system.

Proposed section A36.3.6.9 would allow for measurement system attenuators to operate in known intervals of decibel steps, rather than in equal interval steps, as in current part 36 section A36.3(b)(6).

Proposed section A36.3.7.2(e) would add a requirement that the analyzer operate in real time from 50 Hz through at least 12 kHz.

Proposed section A36.3.7.3 would specify IEC 61260 class 2 electrical performance requirements as the minimum standard for analyzers. This change updates the specifications for analyzers used in conjunction with part 36 noise certification. Proposed section A36.3.7.3 would also require that filter bandwidth adjustments be determined in accordance with IEC 61260. The IEC method requires that the adjustment be based on more frequencies than are required under current part 36.

Proposed section A36.3.7.4 would contain a correction to the slow time-weighting characteristics in current section A36.3(d)(5)(ii) and (iii). Section A36.3.7.6 would specify that the instant in time at which a slow time weighted sound pressure level is characterized should be 0.75 seconds earlier than the actual readout time. The current requirement specifies that the instant in time at which a readout is characterized must be the midpoint of the averaging period.

Proposed section A36.3.7.5 would specify a continuous exponential averaging process equation through which simulated slow weighted sound pressure levels can be obtained. Section A36.3.7.5 would also specify an equation that results in an approximation of continuous exponential averaging.

Section A36.3.7.7 would require that the analyzer resolution must be 0.1 dB or finer. The current requirement, in section A36.3(d)(7) specifies that the amplitude resolution of the analyzer must be at least ±0.25 dB.

Proposed section A36.3.9.1 would require that calibration adjustments be applied to the measured sound levels determined from the output of the analyzer; the current rule permits these calibrations to be applied within the analyzer. This change is necessary to enable the FAA to determine whether these calibration adjustments have been applied correctly.

Proposed section A36.3.9.3 would allow the free-field corrections based on grazing incidence to be applied when the sound incidence angle is within ±30 degrees of grazing incidence.

Proposed section A36.3.9.4 would require that at least 30 seconds of pink noise be recorded for analog tape recorders; the current section A36.3(e)(4)(ii) requirement is for at least 15 seconds of pink noise. This change would result in a more accurate pink noise correction and would harmonize with the international standard.

Proposed section A36.3.9.6 would require that attenuator accuracy be within 0.1 dB. Section A36.3(b)(6) currently requires that attenuator accuracy be within 0.2 dB. The proposed rule would require that calibration be checked within six months of each test series. The current rule does not specify a time period within which calibration must be checked.

Proposed sections A36.3.9.5 and A36.3.9.7 would change calibration requirements for the pink noise generator and sound calibrator to allow calibration to occur within six months preceding or succeeding the test instead of requiring it to be within the preceding six months as required by current section A36.3(e)(7).

Proposed section A36.3.9.7 would add a new calibration requirement that limits the change in output of the sound calibrator to not more than 0.2 dB, as compared to the previous calibration.

Proposed section A36.3.9.8 would allow for the use of sound calibrators other than pistonphones, as specified by current section A36.3(e)(4). Section A36.3.8.1 would specify the class 1L requirements of IEC 60942, entitled "Electroacoustics--Sound calibrators", as the minimum standard for the sound calibrator.

Proposed section A36.3.9.9 would add a requirement for the recording medium (e.g., tape reel) to carry at least a 10-second sound pressure level calibration at its beginning and end. This proposed change would more precisely define the current section A36.3(e)(4) sound pressure level calibration requirement.

Section A36.4 Calculations of Effective Perceived Noise Level From Measured Data

Section A36.4 Calculations of Effective Perceived Noise Level From Measured Data

To further harmonize the formats of part 36 and JAR 36, Table B-1, "Perceived Noisiness (NOYs) as a Function of Sound Pressure Level", referenced in current section B36.13(a) would be moved to AC36-4C. The noy values contained in Table B-1 can be calculated from the equations contained in proposed section A36.4.7.3.

A minor technical change is proposed for the Perceived Noise Level (PNL) equation in proposed section A36.4.2.1(c) (current section B36.3(c)). The more exact term 10/log 2 is replacing the rounded-off term (33.22). The difference between PNL values that are determined using the current and proposed equations is not expected to be significant.

To harmonize the formats of part 36 and JAR 36, Figure B1, "Perceived noise level as a function of noys", would be moved from current section B36.3(c) to AC36-4C. The perceived noise level values contained in Figure B1 can be calculated from the equations contained in proposed section A36.4.2.1(c).

Proposed section A36.4.5.2 would change the value of "d" from 1.0 seconds to 0.5 seconds to reflect current standard practice. Parallel changes are proposed for section A36.4.5.4 and section A36.6. This change is a text update to reflect the current practice of using 0.5 second data samples, and would have no substantive effect.

To harmonize the formats of part 36 and JAR 36, the material in section B36.5(m) addressing methods for removing the effects of tones resulting from ground plane reflections would be moved to AC36-4C.

The FAA is proposing the deletion of current section B36.9(e), which specifies the duration time interval when the value of PNLT(k) at the 10 dB-down points is 90 PNdB or less. This provision was eliminated for applications made after September 17, 1971 by Amendment 36-5 (41 FR 35053, August 19, 1976). The text permitting the use of this provision has erroneously remained in part 36.

In addition, current section B36.9(f) would also be deleted. The text contained in current section B36.9(f) was added to part 36 in Amendment 36-5 to distinguish between the procedure for determining duration for applications made before and after September 17, 1971. This distinction is no longer necessary if current section B36.9(e) is deleted as proposed.

Section A36.5 Data Reporting. Proposed section A36.5.2 would require that the data specified under section A36.5.2 be reported to the FAA in the applicant's noise certification compliance report. While current part 36 does not specifically identify a requirement for the applicant to submit a noise certification compliance report, these reports represent the standard practice that is used by applicants for submitting this information to the FAA. Proposed section A36.5.2.5 would also identify the specific airplane configuration items and engine operating parameters that must be reported. Each of these configuration items and parameters can affect the airplane noise signature. The reporting requirement for these items and parameters already exist under current section A36.5 which specifies that the aircraft configuration and engine performance parameters relative to noise generation be reported. Further, these configuration items and parameters are also included in the international standard. Their addition to part 36 would promote harmonization.

Proposed section A36.5.2.5(c) would require that the test airplane's center of gravity be reported to the FAA. Airplane center of gravity is an example of an identifying characteristic of the airplane test configuration and an item that could influence measured noise levels. Proposed section A36.5.2.5(d) would require that airbrake and propeller pitch angle also be reported. Proposed sections A36.5.2.5(e), (f), and (j) would, respectively, require reporting of whether the auxiliary power unit (APU) is operating, the status of pneumatic engine bleeds and engine power take-offs, and non-standard airplane test configurations.

Proposed section A36.5.2.5(h)(2) would require reporting of engine performance parameters specifically related to propeller-driven large airplanes.

Current section A36.5(d)(3) does not permit an effective perceived noise level (EPNL) to be computed or reported from data that more than four one-third octave bands in any spectrum within the 10 dB-down points have been excluded from the EPNL computation. This section would be removed since correction (adjustment) methods for removing the effects of ambient noise from airplane noise data must be used in lieu of excluding one-third octave bands. Proposed section A36.3.9.12 specifies the ambient noise level limitations that would require corrections (adjustments) to be made, and also references AC36-4C, which contains an acceptable procedure for removing the affects of ambient noise.

Section A36.6 Nomenclature: Symbols and Units

Section A36.6 Nomenclature: Symbols and Units

Under the proposal, current section A36.7, Symbols and units, would be replaced by revised section A36.6, Nomenclature: Symbols and units. The proposed section would incorporate Annex 16 symbols and units, while retaining the English units. This change is proposed to more closely align part 36 with JAR 36. No substantive technical changes to the regulatory standards of part 36 are anticipated to result from incorporation of the Annex 16 symbols and units.

Section A36.7 Sound Attenuation in Air

Section A36.7 Sound Attenuation in Air

Currently, atmospheric attenuation rates of sound with distance must be determined in accordance with Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. (SAE), Aerospace Recommended Practice (ARP) 866A, (SAE ARP 866A) as specified in current section A36.9(c). Under the proposal, section A36.7.2 would contain the actual formulation (equations) from SAE ARP 866A. These equations are provided in both the International System of Units and the English System of Units. Whereas equations are continuous and provide consistent values, tables and graphs can provide minor differences. This proposed change would further harmonize part 36 and JAR 36 and is not expected to result in any substantive difference in attenuation rates.

Section A36.9 Adjustment of Airplane Flight Test Results

Section A36.9 Adjustment of Airplane Flight Test Results

The current distinction between allowable/required positive and negative correction procedures contained in current sections A36.11(a)(1) and (2) are not included in proposed section A36.9.1. The distinction is no longer relevant, given the evolution of data correction procedures since part 36 was originally promulgated in 1969 and the need for noise certification levels to reflect airplane noise characteristics as accurately as possible. Prior to any noise certification compliance test, a noise certification applicant is required to identify and gain FAA approval of any planned or anticipated data correction that is not a mandatory correction procedure under part 36.

Under the proposal, current section A36.1(b)(3), which requires that the corrections prescribed in current section A36.5(d) be made when the height of the ground at a noise measuring station differs from that of the nearest point on the runway by more than 20 feet, would be deleted because it is obsolete. A 20-foot height allowance/tolerance could change the final EPNL value by several tenths of a dB under some circumstances. Under current practices, corrections (adjustments) are made over the sound propagation path from the microphone to airplane height as part of normal data corrections (adjustments). These corrections (adjustments) are specified in current section A36.11 and proposed section A36.9.

Proposed section A36.9.1.1(d) would require that the effect that airspeed has on source noise be considered with regard to the difference between test day airplane speed and the airplane reference flight profile speed. Thus, the proposed section would specify that, "in addition to the effect on duration, the effects of airspeed on component noise sources must be accounted for as follows: For conventional airplane configurations, when differences between test and reference airspeeds exceed 15 knots (28 km/h) true airspeed, test data and/or analysis approved by the FAA must be used to quantify the effects of the airspeed adjustment on resulting certification noise levels."

The symbols and figures used to describe the takeoff and approach profiles in current sections A36.11(b) and (c), would be replaced by the JAR 36 symbols and figures that have been incorporated into proposed section A36.9.2. There would be no substantive changes to the takeoff and approach profile technical requirements as a result of these changes.

Proposed section A36.9.3.2.1 provides equations that would enable data adjustments to be made using either the English System of Units or International System of Units.

The material in current section B36.11(c) would be moved to section A36.9.3.2.2 and revised to provide that the adjustment for multiple peak values of tone-corrected perceived noise level (PNLT) is based upon the difference in corrected PNLT values, rather than upon EPNL as in the current part 36. This change would more clearly define the intent of the multiple peak correction.

Under proposed section A36.9.3.3.2, a correction term to account for the difference between test and reference airplane airspeeds would be added to the duration correction (<greek-D>2) contained in current section A36.11(e). The speed correction term would be defined as 10 log (V/Vr), where V is the airplane test speed and Vr is the airplane reference speed. This proposed change specifies the speed correction that is a requirement of current section A36.11(f)(1).

Appendix B--Noise Levels for Transport Category and Jet Airplanes Under § 36.103

Appendix B--Noise Levels for Transport Category and Jet Airplanes Under § 36.103

Proposed appendix B would include the material from current appendix C. The objective is to harmonize proposed appendix B, and JAR 36, Section 1, Subpart B. The proposed appendix B is essentially the same as JAR 36, section 1, subpart B.

Section B36.3 Reference Noise Measurement Points.

Under the proposal, the material in current section C36.3 would be moved to section B36.3 and revised as follows. The term "takeoff" in current section C36.3(a) would be replaced with the term "flyover" in proposed section B36.3(b).) The term "sideline" in current section C36.3(c) would be replaced with "lateral" in proposed section B36.3(a). These terminology changes would harmonize the part 36 terminology with that used in JAR 36 and Annex 16.

Proposed section B36.3(a)(2) includes a simplified test procedure that may be used in determining the sideline (lateral) noise level for propeller-driven large airplanes in demonstrating the sideline (lateral) noise certification level. This procedure is also contained in JAR 36 and ICAO Annex 16. For propeller-driven airplanes, it can be difficult to establish the maximum lateral noise level specified under current section C36.3C, because this noise level may occur at a very low height. There is usually a significant difference in noise levels between the port and starboard sides of a propeller-driven large airplane. By measuring full-power noise at a predetermined point (650meters) below the takeoff flight path, many of the difficulties which arise because of the directional nature of the noise from propeller-driven airplanes when measured at the conventional lateral site will be eliminated. Ground effects that distort measurements will also be reduced. Under the current requirement, it is difficult to judge the airplane altitude at which the peak noise level occurs, and in the past this has required applicants to conduct as many as 30 flight tests to satisfy certification authorities, an expensive process. Moreover, the current method for testing propeller-driven airplanes has generally resulted in low confidence in accuracy and repeatability of measurements. The simplified test procedure is proposed to be available as an alternative to the current section C36.3(c) method for tests conducted before March 20, 2002, after which it would become the sole method for demonstrating sideline (lateral) noise level compliance.

Current section C36.3(b) would be moved to section B36.3(c) and text would be added to define the approach measurement point relative to the runway threshold. This change would more clearly describe the geometric relationship between the test airplane and the ground, and would further harmonize part 36 and JAR 36.

Section B36.4 Test Noise Measurement Points

Section B36.4 Test Noise Measurement Points

As proposed, most of the requirements of current section A36.1(b)(7) would be moved to proposed section B36.4(b). Current section A36.1(b)(7), allows (when approved) for the sideline (lateral) noise certification level demonstration for jet airplanes to be based on the assumption that the peak sideline (lateral ) noise level occurs at an airplane altitude of 1,000 feet (1,440 feet for Stage 1 or Stage 2 four-engine airplanes). Under the proposed rulemaking, this procedure would be moved to the guidance material in AC 36-4C as an equivalent procedure for demonstrating the sideline (lateral) noise certification level. This change would further harmonize part 36 and JAR 36 and would have no substantive effect.

Proposed section B36.4(b) would require that, in demonstrating the sideline (lateral) noise certification level for propeller-driven airplanes, noise measurements be made at symmetrically located noise measurements points on either side of the runway for each and every noise measurement point along the main sideline (lateral) noise measurement line. This change is proposed because of the asymmetric nature of propeller noise. Because of the possibility of lateral noise asymmetry, part 36 has required simultaneous measurements at one test measurement point opposite the main lateral measurement line. In the case of propeller-driven airplanes, whose noise field is known to be asymmetrical, having only one measuring point opposite the main lateral measurement line is not adequate to define the peak lateral noise on the other side of the runway from the main lateral line. This change would further harmonize part 36 and JAR 36.

Section B36.5 Maximum Noise Levels

Section B36.5 Maximum Noise Levels

The material in current section C36.5 would be moved to proposed section B36.5 and revised to include minor format and language changes to harmonize with JAR 36. Amendment 36-15 (53 FR 16360, May 6, 1988) removed section C36.5(c); the reference to section C36.5(c) in current section C36.5(a) should have been removed under that amendment but it was not. The reference to section C36.5(c) is not included in this proposal.

In order to further harmonize part 36 and JAR 36, the term "sideline" has been changed to "lateral" in each place that it appears throughout section B36.5. This is a change in terminology that does not affect the noise measurement/analysis procedures or noise limits. Similarly, the term "takeoff" has been changed to "flyover." No change in test procedures should be inferred from this change.

Section B36.6 Trade-Offs

Section B36.6 Trade-Offs

The material in current section C36.5(b) would be moved to proposed section B36.6 and the reference to section 36.7(d)(3)(i)(B), in current section C36.5(b), would be changed to section 36.7(d)(1)(ii). This section reference should have been changed by Amendment 36-15 (53 FR 16360, May 6, 1988). This error is corrected by this proposed revision.

Section B36.7 Noise Certification Reference Procedures

Section B36.7 Noise Certification Reference Procedures

The material addressing takeoff and approach reference and test limitations in current sections C36.7 and C36.9 would be moved to section B36.7, addressing takeoff and approach reference procedures, and section B36.8, addressing takeoff and approach test procedures. This material would also be revised as discussed in the following paragraphs.

Proposed section B36.7(b)(1) requires the use of "average engine" performance in defining the takeoff thrust for the reference takeoff procedures. This revision of current section C36.7(b)(2) would further harmonize the takeoff reference procedure, and would serve to eliminate confusion in compliance with the requirement. This change would also further standardize part 36 and JAR 36 regulations.

Proposed section B36.7(b)(1) would also specify "Takeoff thrust/ power" as the maximum available for normal operations as scheduled in the performance section of the airplane flight manual for the reference atmospheric conditions given in proposed section B36.7(a)(5).

Currently section C36.7(b)(2) specifies different minimum cutback altitudes for jet powered and non-jet powered airplanes. Proposed section B36.7((b)(1)(ii) would contain the same minimum cutback altitude for all airplanes, the same altitude specified in current section C36.7(b)(2) for jet airplanes. Since the selection of the minimum cutback altitude is determined by the minimum safe altitude for cutback initiation, there is no reason to distinguish between propeller-driven and jet airplanes. It is the FAA's understanding that this change would not have a substantive effect in practice, since cutback initiation heights greater than 1,500 feet are generally chosen for propeller-driven airplanes. Thus, the cutback initiation heights generally chosen are greater than both the current and proposed part 36 minimum cutback height requirements.

Under the proposal, the requirements of section A36.1(b)(2) is moved to section B36.7(b)(3) and revised to require that, for tests conducted after March 19, 2002, the lateral (sideline) noise level be demonstrated using full takeoff power throughout the takeoff flight path. Before that date, the lateral noise level may be demonstrated using the current section A36.1(b)(2) procedure, under which both the takeoff (flyover) and sideline (lateral) noise certification levels are determined using a single reference flight path that may include a thrust cutback. This change is proposed to reflect the intent of the international standard that the lateral measurement be based on the full-power condition. Since the revised lateral procedure might result in increased stringency, the use of this procedure would be optional for tests conducted before March 20, 2002. This change would mainly effect three and four engine airplanes.

The takeoff reference speed requirement specified in current section C36.7(e)(2) would be revised to be consistent with the takeoff reference speed contained in JAR 36 and Annex 16. The all-engine operating climb speed range (V2+10 to V2+20 kts) specified in proposed section B36.7(b)(4) represents the typical range of takeoff initial climb speeds seen in normal operation for most airplanes. For some airplanes, this proposed change to part 36 could result in an increase of up to 10 knots in the noise certification reference takeoff speed relative to the current part 36 reference takeoff speed requirements. For the affected airplanes, the increased takeoff speed could result in some noise level reduction at the sideline (lateral) noise measurement point with a resulting increase in noise level at the takeoff (flyover) noise measurement point. The FAA has found the change in takeoff reference speed to be acceptable because of this tradeoff of sideline (lateral) and takeoff (flyover) noise levels, although it might not be a one-to-one tradeoff.

Proposed section B36.7(b)(5) adds the meaning of configuration. This is not a change in requirement. Proposed section B36.7(b)(5) is intended to clarify the meaning and includes specific configuration elements, based on certification experience, that can have an effect on noise source.

Proposed section B36.7(b)(7) defines "average engine" as the average of all the certification compliant engines used during the airplane flight tests up to and during certification when operating within the limitations and according to the procedures given in the Flight Manual.

Under the proposal, current section C36.9(e)(1), reference approach speed, would be revised to incorporate the use of 1-g stall-based approach speeds by basing the approach noise certification reference speed on the reference landing speed (VREF) that is used for the airworthiness certification. This proposal was included in Notice 95-17, published on January 18, 1996 (61 FR 1260), in which the FAA proposed to redefine the reference stall speeds for transport category airplanes as the 1-g stall speed instead of the minimum speed obtained in the stalling maneuver. Under Notice 95-17, a definition of VREF would be included in 14 CFR part 1. Notice 95-17 has not been issued as a final rule. If a final rule based on Notice 95-17 is not issued before this notice becomes a final rule; the definition of VREF (i.e., the speed of the airplanes, in a specified landing configuration, at the point where it descends through the landing screen height in the determination of the landing distance for manual landings) would be added to part 36. The proposed change to section C36.9(e)(1) would also be consistent with an anticipated change to ICAO/Annex 16 that is expected to be recommended by Working Group 1 of the ICAO Committee on Aviation Environmental Protection (CAEP) in conjunction with the current CAEP work program cycle. Under this proposed change, existing section C36.9(e)(1) would be redesignated as section B36.7(c)(2).

Current section C36.9(d) requires that all engines must operate at approximately the same power or thrust for approach tests conducted to demonstrate compliance with part 36. Under the proposal, this specific requirement would be removed, and instead, proposed section A36.9.3.4 would require that source noise adjustments be applied to account for any difference, between test and reference conditions, in engine parameters that affect engine noise (e.g., corrected low pressure rotor speed). This proposed change would meet the intent of the current part 36 requirement and would also further harmonize with JAR 36.

Section B36.8--Test Procedures

Section B36.8--Test Procedures

The current section A36.1(d)(5) and A36.1(d)(7), limitations on the difference between the test weight and the maximum takeoff/approach weight for which noise certification is requested, would be replaced by the limitation in proposed section B36.8(d). The current section A36.1(d)(5) and A36.1(d)(7) limitations help insure the integrity of the final certification results by indirectly limiting the magnitude of the EPNL adjustments that may be applied to the test data in normalizing to the noise certification reference conditions. Proposed section B36.8(d) would directly limit the magnitude of the correction by specifying a limitation on the EPNL adjustment that can be made when correcting between test weight and maximum certification weight.

Under the proposal, current section A36.5(d)(5) would be revised and moved to section B36.8(f). The amounts of adjustment permitted when equivalent test procedures are different from the reference procedures remain unchanged, except that the amended requirements do not specify that tradeoffs are permitted when comparing adjusted levels against the appendix C noise levels, for the purpose of determining adjustment limits. Several interpretations of the current section A36.5(d)(5) requirement are possible as to whether the proposal represents a more stringent or less stringent adjustment limitation as compared with the current limitation. The FAA believes that the proposed change to remove the tradeoff provision from the current limitation and base the proposed limitation solely on the difference between the adjusted noise levels and the maximum noise levels in proposed B36.5 meets the intent of the adjustment limitation, as stated above, and clarifies ambiguity in its interpretation. The proposed change would also result in harmonization of the adjustment limitation with that in JAR 36 and ICAO Annex 16.

Proposed section B36.8(g) would revise the test speed tolerance specified in current sections C36.7(e)(1) and C36.9(e)(3). Current section C36.7(e)(1) specifies that takeoff tests must be conducted at the test day speeds ±3 knots. Current section C36.9(e)(3) specifies that a tolerance of ±3 knots may be used throughout the approach noise testing. Proposed section B36.8(g) would specify that during takeoff, lateral, and approach tests, the airplane variation in instantaneous indicated airspeed must be maintained within +/-3% of the average airspeed between the 10dB-down points. Under the proposal, the instantaneous indicated airspeed is determined by the pilot's airspeed indicator. However, if the instantaneous indicated airspeed exceeds +/ -3 kt (+/-5.5 km/h) of the average airspeed over the 10dB-down points, and is determined by the FAA representative on the flight deck to be due to atmospheric turbulence, then the flight so affected must be rejected for noise certification purposes.

Appendix G Noise Requirements for Propeller-Driven Small Airplanes and Commuter Category Airplanes Under Subpart F

Appendix G Noise Requirements for Propeller-Driven Small Airplanes and Commuter Category Airplanes Under Subpart F

Current Section G36.105(f)

The proposal would change the designation of the reference to current part 36 section A36.3(e) to A36.3.8 and A36.3.9 to maintain the correct cross-reference.

Appendix H Noise Requirements for Helicopters Under Subpart H

Appendix H Noise Requirements for Helicopters Under Subpart H

Current Section H36.111(c)(3)

The proposal would change the designation of the reference to current part 36 section A36.3(f)(3) to A36.3.9.11 to maintain the correct cross-reference.

Current section H36.201

The proposal would change the designation of the reference to current part 36 section B36.5(a) to A36.4.3.1(a) to maintain the correct cross-reference.

Redesignation Table for Proposed Appendices A and B

Redesignation Table for Proposed Appendices A and B

Cross Reference Table

Old Section New Section

A36.1 … A36.1, A36.2

A36.1(a) … A36.1.1, A36.2.1.1

A36.1(b) … A36.2.2

A36.1(b)(1) … A36.2.3.2, B36.3

A36.1(b)(2) … B36.7(b)(1)(iii)

A36.1(b)(3) … Deleted

A36.1(b)(4) … A36.2.2.1

A36.1(b)(5) … A36.2.2.4

A36.1(b)(6) … A36.2.2.1

A36.1(b)(7) … A36.9.3.5, A36.9.3.5.1,

B36.4(b)

A36.1(c) … A36.2.2.2

A36.1(c)(1) … A36.2.2.2(a)

A36.1(c)(2) … A36.2.2.2(b)

A36.1(c)(3) … A36.2.2.2(c)

AC36-4C

A36.1(c)(4) … A36.2.2.2(e)

A36.1(c)(5) … A36.2.2.2(f)

A36.1(d)(1) … B36.8(b), B36.2

A36.1(d)(2) … A36.2.3.1

A36.1(d)(3) … A36.2.3.2, A36.2.3.3

A36.1(d)(4) … B36.7(b), B36.8

A36.1(d)(5) … B36.8(d)

A36.1(d)(6) … B36.7(c), B36.8(e)

A36.1(d)(7) … B36.8(d)

A36.1(d)(8) … A36.2.3.3

A36.3 … A36.3

A36.3(a) … A36.3.3

A36.3(b) … A36.3.3.1

A36.3(c)(2)(i-iv), A36.3(f)(1) … A36.3.5

A36.3(c)(2)(v) … A36.3.4

A36.3(c)(3) … A36.3.6

A36.3(d) … A36.3.7

A36.3(e)(1-6), A36.3(f)(2) … A36.3.9

A36.3(f)(2-4) … A36.3.9.11

A36.3(e)(7) … A36.3.8

A36.5(a) … A36.5.1.1, A36.5.1.2,

A36.5.1.3

A36.5(b)(1) … A36.5.2.1

A36.5(b)(2) … A36.5.2.2

A36.5(b)(3) … A36.5.2.3

A36.5(b)(4) … A36.5.2.4

A36.5(b)(5)(i-vi) … A36.5.2.5

A36.5(b)(vii) … A36.5.2.5(i)

A36.5(b)(6) … A36.2.3.2, A36.2.3.3

A36.5.2.5(i)

A36.5(c) … A36.5.3

A36.5(c)(1) … B36.7(a)(5)

A36.5(c)(2) … B36.3(c),

B36.7(b)(1)(vi),

B36.7(c)(1)(i),

B36.7(c)(1)(iv)

A36.5(d)(1) … A36.5.3.1, A36.9, B36.8(c)

A36.5(d)(2) … A36.9.1

A36.5(d)(2)(i)-(iv) … B36.8(d)

A36.5(d)(3) … A36.3.9.12

A36.5(d)(4) … A36.3.9.12

A36.5(d)(5) … B36.8(f)

A36.5(e)(1) … A36.5.4.1

A36.5(e)(2) … A36.5.4.2

A36.5(e)(3) … A36.5.4.3

A36.5(e)(4) … Deleted

A36.7 … A36.6, A36.9.5, A36.9.6

A36.9(a) … A36.9.1.1

A36.9(b)(1) … A36.2.2.4

A36.9(b)(2) … A36.2.2.2(b)

A36.9(b)(3) … A36.2.2.2(g)

A36.9(c) … A36.7

A36.9(d)(1) … A36.9.1, A36.9.1.1

A36.9(d)(2) … A36.2.2.2(d)

A36.9(d)(3) … A36.2.2.3

A36.11(a) … A36.9.1

A36.11(a)(1) … Deleted

A36.11(a)(2) … Deleted

A36.11(a)(3)(i) … A36.9.1, B36.7

A36.11(a)(3)(ii) … A36.9.1.1

A36.11(a)(3)(iii) … A36.9.1.1

A36.11(a)(3)(iv) … A36.9.1.1, A36.9.3.4

A36.11(a)(3)(v) … A36.9.1

A36.11(b)(1)(i-ii) … A36.9.2.1(c)

A36.11(b)(2) … A36.9.3.1, A36.9.4.1

A36.11(b)(3) … A36.9.3.2(a)

A36.11(c) … A36.9.2.2

A36.11(c)(1) … A36.9.3.2(a-c)

A36.11(c)(2) … A36.9.3.2(a)

A36.11(d)(1-3) … A36.9.3,

A36.9.3.1,

A36.9.3.2.1,

A36.9.3.2.1.1,

A36.9.3.2.1.2

A36.11(e)(1-2) … A36.9.3.3.1,

A36.9.3.3.2

A36.11(f) … B36.4(a), AC36-4C

A36.11(f)(1) … A36.9.1.2

A36.11(f)(2) … A36.9.1.2

A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii) … A36.9.4

B36.1 … A36.1, A36.1.1,

A36.4.1.3

B36.1(a) … B36.4.1.3(a)

B36.1(b) … A36.4.1.3(b)

B36.1(c) … A36.4.1.3(c)

B36.1(d) … A36.4.1.3(d)

B36.1(e) … A36.4.1.3(e)

B36.3 … A36.4.2.1

B36.3(a) … A36.4.2.1, Step 1

B36.3(b) … A36.4.2.1, Step 2

B36.3(c) … A36.4.2.1, Step 3,

AC 36-4B

B36.5 … A36.4.3.1

B36.5(a) … A36.4.3.1, Step 1

B36.5(b) … A36.4.3.1, Step 2

B36.5(c) … A36.4.3.1, Step 3

B36.5(d) … A36.4.3.1, Step 4

B36.5(e) … A36.4.3.1, Step 5

B36.5(f) … A36.4.3.1, Step 6

B36.5(g) … A36.4.3.1, Step 7

B36.5(h) … A36.4.3.1, Step 8

B36.5(i) … A36.4.3.1, Step 9

B36.5(j) … A36.4.3.1, Step 10

B36.5(k) … A36.4.3.1, Step 10

B36.5(l) … A36.4.3.1, Step 10

B36.5(m) … A36.4.3.1, Step 10

Note, AC36-4C

B36.5(n) … A36.4.4.2

B36.7 … A36.4.4

B36.7(a) … A36.4.4.1,

A36.4.4.1 Note 1

B36.7(b) … A36.4.4.1-Note 2

B36.9 … A36.4.5.1

B36.9(a) … A36.4.5.2

B36.9(b) … A36.4.5.3

B36.9(c) … A36.4.5.4

B36.9(d) … A36.4.5.5

B36.9(e) … Deleted

B36.9(f) … Deleted

B36.11(a) … A36.4.6.1

B36.11(b) … Deleted

B36.11(c) … A36.9.3.2.2

B36.13(a) … A36.4.7.1, Table A1 moved to

AC 36-4C

B36.13(a)(1),(2),(3) … A36.4.7.2(a-c)

B36.13(b) … A36.4.7.3

B36.13(c) … A36.4.7.4

C36.1 … B36.1

C36.3(a) … B36.3(b)

C36.3(b) … B36.3(c)

C36.3(c) … B36.3(a)

C36.5(a) … B36.5

C36.5(a)(1) … B36.5(a)

C36.5(a)(2) … B36.5(b)

C36.5(a)(2)(i) … B36.5(b)(1)

C36.5(a)(2)(ii) … B36.5(b)(2)

C36.5(a)(3) … B36.5(c)

C36.5(a)(3)(i)(A) … B36.5(c)(1)(i)

C36.5(a)(3)(i)(B) … B36.5(c)(1)(ii)

C36.5(a)(3)(i)(C) … B36.5(c)(1)(iii)

C36.5(a)(3)(ii) … B36.5(c)(2)

C36.5(a)(3)(iii) … B36.5(c)(3)

C36.5(b)(1) … B36.6

C36.5(b)(2) … B36.6

C36.5(b)(3) … B36.6

C36.7(a) … B36.7(a)(3)

C36.7(b) … B36.7(b)(1)(i)

C36.7(b)(1) … B36.7(b)(1)(i)

C36.7(b)(1)(i) … B36.7(b)(1)(i)

C36.7(b)(1)(ii) … B36.7(b)(1)(i)

C36.7(b)(2)(i) … B36.7(b)(1)(i)

C36.7(b)(2)(ii) … B36.7(b)(1)(i)

C36.7(b)(2)(iii) … B36.7(b)(1)(i)

C36.7(b)(2)(iv) … B36.7(b)(1)(i)

C36.7(c) … B36.7(b)(1)(ii)

C36.7(d) … B36.7(b)(1)(v)

C36.7(e)(1) … B36.7(b)(1)(iv)

C36.7(e)(1) Next to last sentence … B36.8(g)

C36.7(e)(2) … B36.7(b)(1)(iv)

C36.7(e)(3) … B36.7(a)(5), A36.9.1

C36.9(a) … B36.7(a)(3), B36.7(c)(1)

C36.9(b) … B36.7(c)(1)(iii) &

B36.7(c)(1)(v)

C36.9(c) … B36.7(c)(1)(i),

B36.7(c)(iii)

C36.9(d) … Deleted

C36.9(e)(1) … B36.7(c)(1)(ii)

C36.9(e)(2) … B36.7(c)(1)(ii)

C36.9(e)(3) … B36.8(g)

CROSS REFERENCE TABLE

New Section Old Section

A36.1 … A36.1, B36.1

A36.1.1 … A36.1(a), B36.1

A36.1.2 … New section

A36.1.3 … New section

A36.2 … A36.1

A36.2.1 … A36.1(a)

A36.2.1.1 … A36.1(a)

A36.2.2 … A36.1(b)

A36.2.2.1 … A36.1(b)(4), A36.1(b)(6)

A36.2.2.2 … A36.1(c)

A36.2.2.2(a) … A36.1(c)(1)

A36.2.2.2(b) … A36.1(c)(2), A36.9(b)(2)

B36.2.2.2(c) … A36.1(c)(3)

B36.2.2.2(d) … A36.9(d)(2)

A36.2.2.2(e) … A36.1(c)(4)

A36.2.2.2(f) … A36.1(c)(5)

A36.2.2.2(g) … A36.9(b)(3)

A36.2.2.3 … A36.9(d)(3)

A36.2.2.4 … A36.1(b)(5), A36.9(b)(1)

A36.2.3 … A36.1(d)

A36.2.3.1 … A36.1(d)(2)

A36.2.3.2 … A36.1(b)(1),

A36.1(d)(3),

A36.5(b)(6)

A36.2.3.3 … A36.1(d)(8), A36.5(b)(6)

A36.3 … A36.3

A36.3.1 … New

A36.3.2 … New

A36.3.3 … A36.3(a)

A36.3.3.1 … A36.3(b)

A36.3.3.2 … New

A36.3.4 … A36.3(c)(2)(v)

A36.3.5 … A36.3(c)(2)(i-iv),

A36.3(f)(1)

A36.3.6 … A36.3(c)(3)

A36.3.7 … A36.3(d)

A36.3.8 … A36.3(e)(7)

A36.3.9 … A36.3(e)(1-6),

A36.3(f)(2)

A36.3.9.11 … A36.3(f)(2-4)

A36.3.9.12 … A36.5(d)(3-4)

A36.4 … B36.1

A36.4.1 … B36.1

A36.4.1.1 … B36.1

A36.4.1.2 … B36.1

A36.4.1.3 … B36.1

A36.4.2 … B36.3

A36.4.2.1 … B36.3; AC 36-4C

A36.4.3 … B36.5

A36.4.3.1 … B36.5(a-m)

A36.4.3.2 … B36.5(n)

A36.4.4 … B36.7

A36.4.4.1 … B36.7(a) & (b)

A36.4.4.2 … B36.5(n)

A36.4.5 … B36.9

A36.4.5.1 … B36.9

A36.4.5.2 … B36.9(a)

A36.4.5.3 … B36.9(b)

A36.4.5.4 … B36.9(c)

A36.4.5.5 … B36.9(d)

A36.4.6 … B36.11

A36.4.6.1 … B36.11(a)

A36.4.7 … B36.13

A36.4.7.1 … B36.13(a)

A36.4.7.2 … B36.13(a)(1-3)

A36.4.7.3 … B36.13(b)

A36.4.7.4 … B36.13(c)

A36.5 … A36.5

A36.5.1 … A36.5(a)

A36.5.1.1 … A36.5(a)

A36.5.1.2 … A36.5(a)

A36.5.1.3 … A36.5(a)

A36.5.2 … A36.5(b)

A36.5.2.1 … A36.5(b)(1)

A36.5.2.2 … A36.5(b)(2)

A36.5.2.3 … A36.5(b)(3)

A36.5.2.4 … A36.5(b)(4)

A36.5.2.5 … A36.5(b)(5)

A36.5.3 … A36.5(c)

A36.5.3.1 … A36.5(d)(1)

A36.5.4 … A36.5(e)

A36.5.4.1 … A36.5(e)(1)

A36.5.4.2 … A36.5(e)(2)

A36.5.4.3 … A36.5(e)(3)

A36.6 … A36.7

A36.7.1-A36.7.3 … A36.9(c)

A36.8 … New section--Reserved

A36.9 … A36.5(d)(1), A36.11

A36.9.1 … A36.5(d)(2),

A36.9(d)(1),

A36.11(a),

A36.11(a)(3)(i) & (v)

A36.9.1.1 … A36.9(a), A36.9(d)(1),

A36.11(a)(3)(ii-iii),

A36.11(a)(3)(iv)

A36.9.1.2 … A36.11(f)(1-2)

A36.9.2 … A36.11(b)&(c)

A36.9.2.1 … A36.11(b)(1)(i-ii)

A36.9.2.2 … A36.11(c)

A36.9.3 … A36.11

A36.9.3.1 … A36.11(a), A36.11(f)(1)

A36.9.3.2(a) … A36.11(b)(3), A36.11(c)(2)

A36.9.3.2(b) … New section

A36.9.3.2.1 … A36.9(d)(1-3)

A36.9.3.2.1.1 … A36.11(d)(1)(ii)

A36.9.3.2.1.2 … A36.11(d)(1)(ii)

A36.9.3.2.2 … B36.11(c)

A36.9.3.3 … A36.11(e)

A36.9.3.3.1 … A36.11(e)(1)(2)

A36.9.3.3.2 … A36.11(e)

A36.9.3.4 … A36.11(a)(3)(iv)

A36.9.3.4.1 … A36.11(a)(3)(iv)

A36.9.3.4.2 … A36.11(a)(3)(iv)

A36.9.3.5 … A36.1(b)(7)

A36.9.3.5.1 … A36.1(b)(7)

A36.9.4 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)

A36.9.4.1 … A36.11(b)(2),

A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)

A36.9.4.2 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)

A36.9.4.2.2 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)

A36.9.4.2.3 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)

A36.9.4.3 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)

A36.9.4.4 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)

A36.9.4.4.1 … A36.11(f)(2)(i-ii)

A36.9.5 … A36.7

A36.9.6 … A36.7

B36.1 … C36.1

B36.2 … A36.1(d)(1)

B36.3(a) … C36.3(c)

B36.3(b) … C36.3(a)

B36.3(c) … A36.5(c)(2), C36.3(b)

B36.4(a) … A36.11(f)

B36.4(b) … A36.1(b)(7)

B36.5 … C36.5(a)

B36.5(a) … C36.5(a)(1)

B36.5(b) … C36.5(a)(2)

B36.5(b)(1) … C36.5(a)(2)(i)

B36.5(b)(2) … C36.5(a)(2)(ii)

B36.5(c) … C36.5(a)(3)

B36.5(c)(1)(i) … C36.5(a)(3)(i)(A)

B36.5(c)(1)(ii) … C36.5(a)(3)(i)(B)

B36.5(c)(1)(iii) … C36.5(a)(3)(i)(C)

B36.5(c)(2) … C36.5(a)(3)(ii)

B36.5(c)(3) … C36.5(a)(3)(iii)

B36.6 … C36.5(b)(1)-(3)

B36.7(a)(1)

B36.7(a)(1)

B36.7(a)(2) … A36.11(a)(3)(i)

B36.7(a)(3) … C36.7(a), C36.9(a)

B36.7(a)(4) … New section--Reserved

B36.7(a)(5) … A36.5(c)(1), C36.7(e)(3)

B36.7(b)(1) … C36.7(b), C36.7(b)(2)

B36.7(b)(2) … C36.7(c)

B36.7(b)(3) … A36.1(b)(2)

B36.7(b)(4) … C36.7(e)(1-2)

B36.7(b)(5) … C36.7(d)

B36.7(b)(6) … A36.5(c)(2)

B36.7(b)(7) … New section

B36.7(c) … C36.9

B36.7(c) … C36.9(a)

B36.7(c)(1) … A36.5(c)(2), C36.9(c)

B36.7(c)(2) … C36.9(e)(1), C36.9(e)(2)

B36.7(c)(3) … C36.9(b-c)

B36.7(c)(4) … A36.5(c)(2)

B36.7(c)(5) … C36.9(b)

B36.8(a) … New section

B36.8(b) … A36.1(d)(1)

B36.8(c) … A36.5(d), A36.11(a)

B36.8(d) … A36.1(d)(5-7)

B36.8(e) … A36.1(d)(6)

B36.8(f) … A36.5(d)(5)

B36.8(g) … C36.7(e)(1), C36.9(e)(3)

Paperwork Reduction Act

Paperwork Reduction Act

In this NPRM, Noise Certification Standards for Subsonic Jet Airplanes and Subsonic Transport Category Large Airplanes, Part 36, proposed Secs. A36.5.2 and A36.5.2.5 contain information collection requirements. As required by the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3507(d)), the FAA has submitted a copy of these proposed sections to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) for its review.

The information to be collected is needed for the applicant's noise compliance report that is required by the Aircraft Noise Abatement Act of 1968. This statute authorized FAA to prescribe standards for the measurement of aircraft noise and to prescribe regulations providing for the control and abatement of aircraft noise. The noise compliance report information is part of the aircraft certification test. The collected information is incorporated into the noise compliance report that is provided to and approved by the FAA. The annual burden for Sec. A36.5.2 is estimated to range from $80 x 80 hours at $6,400 per noise certification project to $100 x 160 hours at $16,000 per noise certification project. The annual burden for Sec. A36.5.2.5 is estimated to range from $500 (5 hours x $100 per hour) to $2,000 (25 hours x $80 per hour) per certification. If proprietary information is submitted, it will be protected in accordance with appropriate laws.

The agency is soliciting comments to (1) evaluate whether the proposed collection of information is necessary; (2) evaluate the accuracy of the agency's estimate of the burden; (3) enhance the quality, utility, and clarity of the information to be collected; and (4) minimize the burden of the collection of information on those who are to respond, including through the use of appropriate automated, electronic, mechanical, or other technological collection techniques or other forms of information technology (for example, permitting electronic submission of responses).

Individuals and organizations may submit comments on the information collection requirement by September 11, 2000 and should direct them to the address listed in the ADDRESSES section of this document.

According to the regulations implementing the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, (5 CFR 1320.8(b)(2)(vi)), an agency may not conduct or sponsor, and a person is not required to respond to, a collection of information unless it displays a currently valid Office of Management and Budget (OMB) control number. The public will be notified of the OMB control number when it is assigned.

Compatibility With ICAO Standards

Compatibility With ICAO Standards

In keeping with the U.S. obligations under the Convention on International Civil Aviation, it is FAA policy to comply with International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Standards and Recommended Practices to the maximum extent practicable. The FAA has reviewed the corresponding ICAO Standards and Recommended Practices and has identified the following differences with these proposed regulations. If this proposal is adopted, the FAA intends to file these differences with ICAO.

Wind Speed. Section A36.2.2.2(e) of the proposal requires that tests be carried out under atmospheric conditions where the average wind velocity 10 meters above ground does not exceed 12 knots and the crosswind velocity for the airplane does not exceed 7 knots. Section A36.2.2.2(e) of the proposal also specifies that maximum wind velocity 10 meters above ground is not to exceed 15 knots and the crosswind velocity is not to exceed 10 knots during the 10 dB down time interval. Section 2.2.2(e) of ICAO Annex 16, Appendix 2 contains a similar average wind speed limitation, but specifies a maximum windspeed limitation only in cases where an anemometer with a built-in detector time constant of less than 30 seconds is used. The FAA does not agree to adopt this Annex 16 provision because it could result in tests being conducted in windspeed conditions that exceed those currently permitted under part 36; the effect of these higher wind conditions might have on the resulting noise levels could not be determined based on the information that was available to the harmonization working group.

Adjustments to PNL and PNLT. In adjusting measured sound pressure level data to reference conditions, section 9.3.2.1 of Annex 16 Appendix 2 requires that when a sound pressure level value is equal to zero (for example, as a result of applying a background noise correction) the adjusted sound pressure level must be kept equal to zero in the adjustment process. The FAA did not agree to adopt this provision. The FAA's view is that the sound pressure level values should be carried through the adjustment process regardless of whether they are greater than zero, equal to zero, or less than zero. It is entirely possible for a negative or zero sound pressure level value that results from the background noise correction process to become positive when adjustments are applied to account for the difference between the test and reference airplane heights above the noise measurement point.

Design characteristics that require different reference procedures. Section 3.6.1.4 of ICAO Annex 16, Appendix 2 permits the certificating authority to approve reference procedures that depart from those contained in section 3.6.2 and 3.6.3 of Annex 16 Appendix 2 when design characteristics of an airplane would prevent flight from being conducted in accordance with the 3.6.2 and 3.6.3 reference procedures. FAA did not agree to adopt this provision since it views the need to depart from the specified reference procedures due to airplane design characteristics as an indication that part 36 may not be appropriate for a given airplane. In this case, under U.S. procedures, the exemption or rulemaking processes, which include a public comment period would be followed to develop an appropriate noise certification basis.

Noise Certificates. Section 1.2 of ICAO Annex 16, Chapter 1 specifies that the documents attesting noise certification may take the form of a separate Noise Certificate or a suitable statement contained in another document approved by the State of Registry and required by that State to be carried in the aircraft. However, under 49 U.S.C. 44702, the FAA is not authorized to issue Noise Certificates. Section 36.1581 of part 36 requires that the certificated noise levels be included in the Airplane Flight Manual. However, the FAA does not require the Airplane Flight Manual to be carried in the airplane. An operations manual that does not contain certificated noise levels is carried in some airplanes. The FAA is aware of a number of cases in which airplane operators had difficulty in substantiating airplane noise compliance status to the satisfaction of airport authorities. The FAA invites comments on the extent of any problems encountered due to the absence of noise compliance substantiation when the Airplane Flight Manual is not on board the airplane.

Economic Evaluation

Economic Evaluation

Proposed changes to Federal regulations undergo several economic analyses. First, Executive Order 12866 directs that each Federal agency propose or adopt a regulation only upon a determination that the benefits of the intended regulation justify its costs. Second, the Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980 requires agencies to analyze the economic impact of regulatory changes on small entities. Third, the Trade Agreements Act (19 U.S.C. section 2531-2533) prohibits agencies from setting standards that create unnecessary obstacles to the foreign commerce of the United States. In developing U.S. standards, this Trade Act also requires agencies to consider international standards and, where appropriate, use them as the basis of U.S. standards. And fourth, the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 requires agencies to prepare a written assessment of the costs, benefits and other effects of proposed or final rules that include a Federal mandate likely to result in the expenditure by State, local or tribal governments, in the aggregate, or by the private sector, of $100 million or more annually (adjusted for inflation.)

In conducting these analyses, the FAA has determined that this rule (1) has benefits which do justify its cost, is not a "significant regulatory action" as defined in the Executive Order and the Department of Transportation's (DOT) Regulatory Policies and Procedures; (2) will not have a significant impact on a substantial number of small entities; (3) reduces barriers to international trade; and (4) does not impose an unfunded mandate on state, local, or tribal governments, or the private sector. These analyses, available in the docket, are summarized below.

Costs

Costs

Many of the changes in the proposed rule are either editorial or procedural in nature. These types of proposed revisions would not add any new requirements or impose costs. However, 38 sections of the proposed changes to part 36 entail changes, which warranted further evaluation to determine whether they involve changes in criteria or could impose additional costs. The key factor in evaluating the proposed changes in criteria was assessing whether an applicant could pass the noise certification test under the proposed change but fail the test under the current rule or vice versa, indicating a change in the stringency of the existing standard.

Eight sections that would be removed by the proposed rule warranted further evaluation. These include sections that had previously been eliminated by an earlier amendment but the text had erroneously remained in part 36, as well as sections that are no longer relevant given improvements in test equipment and the enhancement of data correction procedures since the time part 36 was originally promulgated. The deletion of these sections has no cost impact.

The FAA evaluated the remaining items to determine whether costs would be incurred and examined the magnitude of the cost. The sections of the proposed rule with potential cost fall into four categories: (1) Software costs, (2) additional testing procedures, (3) additional or new measuring provisions, and (4) additional reporting requirements.

Software Costs--Five proposed provisions address the maintenance of the computer programs used to correct as-measured noise certification data to 14 CFR part 36 reference conditions. Such maintenance often times involves administrative cost. However, based on discussions with staff at the Volpe National Transportation Center, which work under contract to the FAA and evaluate certification software, the FAA has determined that four of these proposed changes would have no cost impact. The fifth, Section A36.3.7.6, would deal with technical differences in the "readout" time of the time-weighted measurement of the sound pressure level between the test data and the reference data. Implementation of this change would require modifying the computer software used by the applicants. The estimated times required for each applicant to implement the software change and for the FAA to verify correct implementation the change are 40 and 20 hours, respectively at hourly wage rates of $85 and $75, respectively. The FAA estimates that 39 applicants would incur this one-time cost, and that these software costs would be incurred in the first 3 years after the proposed rule's implementation. The total cost to industry and the FAA are $132,600 and $58,500 ($116,000 and $51,200 discounted), respectively.

Testing Costs--Three proposed changes relate to the operating specifications of test aircraft, but none have any cost impacts.

Measurement Costs--The FAA has determined that of the ten proposed changes that could affect the allowable test conditions and correction of test results to reference conditions, only one would have a cost impact. Under the proposed changes to Appendix B36.4(b), a special requirement would be added for propeller-driven airplanes that would require the placement of symmetrical positioned microphones at each and every test measurement point. However, most applicants already take advantage of FAA-approved equivalent test procedures that require only one set of symmetrical microphones for sideline noise measurements. Changing part 36 would not result in increased costs for most applicants. However, an applicant choosing to use multiple pairs of microphones could incur additional costs ranging up to an estimated $28,000 per test. These costs would involve an increase in the number of microphone systems, including cable, calibration, site surveys, and data recording, analysis and reporting. The FAA has calculated costs assuming that two domestic large-propeller applicants would conduct 4 tests meeting this requirement over the next 10 years. The total cost would be $112,000, or $79,200, discounted.

Reporting Costs--Section A36.5.2 would require applicants to include test results in their noise certification compliance report. While part 36 currently does not specifically require applicants to submit a compliance report it is a standard practice for applicants to do so, since applicants already address these data elements under JAR 36 or ICAO Annex 16. The addition of this provision would codify industry practice. Since the information is already provided, the FAA does not believe there will be additional costs to comply with this requirement. The FAA requests comments on this assumption and requests that all comments be accompanied by clear documentation supporting any proposed changes.

The FAA has determined that one proposed change, to section A36.5.2.3, would add new data elements to the required test report. There would be five new elements. All of these are test airplane operating configuration items that could effect the airplanes noise signature and are already a part of the international standard. Additional labor costs for documenting data not previously reported are estimated to range from $500 (5 hours x $100 per hour) to $2,000 (25 hours x $80 per hour) per test. These estimates are based on the number of additional items to be reported and on the assumption of a lower and upper range of required labor hour increases of 5 to 8 hours and 20 to 25 hours, respectively, at hourly labor rates that range from $80 to $100 per hour.

Based on FAA estimates, 14 noise certification projects involving flight tests are undertaken each year. Four of these projects are conducted among the 15 foreign firms which already comply with these proposed reporting requirements under JAR 36 or ICAO Annex 16 and thus would not incur additional reporting costs. Ten projects are conducted from among 24 domestic firms engaged in flight-testing and the FAA estimates that these firms would conduct 100 tests over the next 10 years. The FAA further estimates that some domestic firms will incur additional reporting costs of $1,250 per test based on the midpoint of the estimated additional labor costs. Domestic firms with a large international presence are estimated to conduct 40 of the 100 tests to be conducted over the next 10 years, based on the composition of the industry. Since these larger firms already frequently comply with the existing international reporting standard, the FAA estimates that only 10 of the 40 tests to be conducted by these firms would incur the additional reporting costs of $1,250 each, or a total of $12,500. The FAA estimates that of the 60 tests to be conducted by smaller domestic firms 24 tests would incur the additional reporting costs of $1,250 per test or a total of $30,000 over the next 10 years. Thus, the additional labor costs for reporting the additional information would total $42,500 ($30,000 plus $12,500) for these affected firms.

However, it is possible that some applicants might accrue additional costs. If an applicant was required to invest in new instrumentation or data recording equipment to comply with these requirements, the estimated total reporting costs could increase to between $5,000 and $10,000 per test. This is based on a range of estimates and scenarios involving purchasing and installing additional instrumentation, and labor for adding recording capability, data analysis, etc. For example, one possible scenario would entail the purchase and installation of instrumentation hardware at $4,200 ($2,500 for hardware and $1,700 for labor [20 hours x $85 per hour]), plus the labor cost for adding recording capability and data recording/ analysis at $3,400 (40 hours x $85 per hour) for a total of $7,600 of additional cost. The FAA estimates that only three firms would incur this additional cost of $7,600 per test and that these firms would conduct a total of 12 tests over the next 10 years at a total cost of $91,200. Thus, the total additional reporting costs to the industry would be $133,700, or $93,900 discounted, based on the minimal additional reporting costs of $42,500 incurred by some firms and $91,200 incurred by the three firms requiring additional instrumentation/data recording.

Summary of Costs

Summary of Costs

The total costs for this proposed rule are $436,800, or $340,300 discounted. Of this total, industry costs are $378,300, or $289,100 discounted, and FAA costs are $58,500, or $51,200 discounted. Comments are invited on these additional cost elements; the FAA requests that all comments be accompanied by clear economic documentation.

Cost Savings

Cost Savings

Several of the proposed changes could result in cost savings to applicants, depending upon the current inventory of the applicant's test equipment and the particular weather circumstances of the flight test. However, given the uncertainty in the annual number and duration of flight tests, it is difficult to accurately quantify these savings. For example, Section A36.2.2.2(b) would lower the minimum test temperature from 36 degrees Fahrenheit to 14 degrees Fahrenheit. This proposed change is based on technical data from extensive noise testing experience and is within the operational temperature limit of the noise measuring equipment. One of the largest cost elements of the test certification process is the cost associated with airplane down time; by extending the temperature range, down time could be minimized. Down time occurs when the test aircraft, crew, equipment and technicians are ready to commence testing but testing is delayed or postponed because the weather conditions specified in Section A36.2 are not met. While airplane noise testing is not normally planned for cold weather, circumstances may dictate that the test be conducted under conditions which could take advantage of this new lower temperature. Under this circumstance, assuming various scenarios of daily temperature warming patterns that could result in reduced hours of airplane down time, an applicant might reduce total on-site test time of a typical certification flight test conducted under these conditions by 10 to 15 percent.

As an example of the impact of permitting testing to be conducted at a lower temperature, assuming an on-site test time of 5 to 7 days to complete a typical certification flight test under these conditions, the applicant might reduce the total test time between half a day to one full day by testing during a time period when the lower temperature condition prevailed. Assuming a cost factor of $150,000 to $200,000 per day for larger planes and $70,000 to $140,000 per day for smaller airplanes, cost reductions per test made possible by this change in minimum test temperatures could range between approximately $75,000 and $200,000 for larger airplanes and manufacturers and between $35,000 and $140,000 for smaller airplanes and manufacturers. The number of such tests conducted under cold weather conditions might be, at most, one per applicant over a 10 year period. Some applicants might not encounter this situation during a 10 year period.

The FAA estimates that 24 larger applicants would each derive cost savings of $137,500 per test and 13 smaller firms would save $87,500 each per test. The estimated industry cost savings over ten years totals $4.44 million, or $3.12 million discounted. Comments on these estimates are invited; the FAA requests that all comments be accompanied by clear documentation supporting any proposed changes.

Proposed section B36.3(a) includes a simplified test procedure that may be used in determining the sideline (lateral) noise level for propeller-driven large airplanes. This test procedure would allow the full power noise measurement to be obtained at a point (650m) below the takeoff flight path and thus eliminate the problems associated with obtaining this measurement from the conventional sideline site. According to industry sources, 40 to 45 fly-bys per test could be eliminated and between 2 and 8 microphone systems could be eliminated depending on the size of the array used by the applicant. (Many applicants currently use a 2-microphone sideline array. In addition to the significant savings resulting from the reduction in the number of fly-bys and the number of microphone systems, further cost savings could result from a reduction in site surveying and field set-up expenses in addition to the analysis and reporting savings that result from fewer fly-bys.

The total cost savings of these changes are estimated at $200,000 to $350,000 per test for manufacturers of propeller-driven large planes. These estimates are based on a range of potential scenarios involving combinations of the above elements (the number of fly-bys and the number of microphones used, flight test costs, etc.). As an example, based on a reduction of 42 fly-bys, the midpoint of the estimated range, and an example cost factor of $6,000 per fly-by, cost savings of $252,000 would be realized. In addition, assuming a reduction of 4 microphone systems, including surveying, setup, recording analysis and reporting at an assumed cost factor of $7,000 per system, another $28,000 (4 systems x $7,000 per system) in savings would be realized, for a total example savings of $280,000 per test under this example.

Given the increasing demand for regional jets, and the financial status of large propeller-driven manufacturers, the FAA estimates that no more than 10 tests would be conducted over the next 10 years and that the derived cost savings would total $2.80 million or $1.97 million discounted.

Industry sources estimate that cost savings on the order of $37,500 per year for those applicants with considerable certification activity would be realized by the harmonization of testing, data measurement and analysis, reporting and documentation. Industry sources also claim that these cost savings would be achieved by a reduction in the confusion and the multiple interpretations that lead to delays, duplicate effort and costly negotiation caused by the existing dual certification standards. The FAA estimates that 10 firms engaged in noise certification activities would achieve cost savings of $375,000 annually for the industry. The estimated industry cost savings over ten years totals $3.75 million, or $2.63 million discounted.

Total quantifiable cost savings over ten years would be $10.99 million, or $7.72 million discounted. The FAA has not been able to quantify other potential savings made possible by the greater efficiencies and flexibility resulting from the uniformity that the proposed rule would provide. Comments are invited; the FAA requests that all comments be accompanied by clear documentation. The FAA would particularly appreciate specific cost savings data.

Benefits

Benefits

Currently, airplane manufacturers must satisfy both the FAA and the European noise certification standards in order to market their aircraft in both the United States and Europe. Meeting two sets of noise certification requirements raises the cost of developing a new transport category airplane, often with no increase in safety or environmental benefit. Adoption of these proposed changes to the noise certification standards of part 36 will foster international trade, lower the cost of aircraft development, and make the certification process more efficient.

Cost-Benefit Analysis

Cost-Benefit Analysis

If the proposed rule becomes effective, U.S. noise certification procedures would be nearly uniform with the JAA procedures. This harmonization between the test conditions, procedures, and noise levels necessary to demonstrate compliance with certification requirements for subsonic jet airplanes and subsonic transport category large airplanes would result in significant cost savings without compromising the environmental benefits of the noise certification standards.

The proposed rule's cost savings, over ten years (attributable to specific proposed changes to part 36 and achieving near uniformity of the standards), would be $7.24 million, $5.08 million discounted. In addition, $3.75 million, $2.63 million discounted, would be derived from overall efficiencies attributable to the harmonization effort in achieving near uniformity of the FAA and JAA standards for a total savings of $10.99 million, $7.72 million, discounted which exceeds the proposed rule's cost of $436,800 ($340,300, discounted). Since the potential cost savings exceed the additional costs, the proposed rule would be cost beneficial.

Initial Regulatory Flexibility Act

Initial Regulatory Flexibility Act

The Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980 (Act) establishes "as a principle of regulatory issuance that agencies shall endeavor, consistent with the objective of the rule and applicable statues, to fit regulatory and informational requirements to the scale of the business, organizations, and governmental jurisdictions subject to regulation." To achieve that principle, the Act requires agencies to solicit and consider flexible regulatory proposals and to explain the rational for their actions. Agencies must perform a review to determine whether a proposed or final rule will have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities. If the determination is that it will, the agency must prepare a regulatory flexibility analysis (RFA) as described in the Act.

However, if an agency determines that a proposed or final rule is not expected to have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities, section 605(b) of the 1980 act provides that the head of the agency may so certify and an RFA is not required. The certification must include a statement providing the factual basis for this determination, and the reasoning should be clear.

Enactment of this proposal would impose costs of $436,800 on the FAA and noise certification applicants over the ten year period of which $250,400 would be incurred by smaller applicants. The FAA has assumed that two smaller applicants which is not a substantial number of applicants would each incur measurement costs of $56,000, or a total of $112,000. Additional reporting costs requiring additional instrumentation/data recording totaling $60,800 over the ten year period would be incurred by 2 other smaller applicants or $30,400 each. Additional labor costs for new reporting requirements totaling $30,000 over the 10 year period would be incurred by 6 smaller applicants at a cost to each of these smaller applicants over the 10 year period of $5,000.

All the small (14) applicants at a cost of $3,400 each or a total of $47,600 would incur one time software costs and for four of these firms this would be the only cost they incur. The first-year cost to each of the six small applicants incurring both software and additional labor reporting costs would be $4,650. In this case, the FAA has determined this would not be a significant cost to a substantial number of small noise certification applicants. Therefore, the FAA had determined that this proposed rule would not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities.

International Trade Impact Assessment

International Trade Impact Assessment

The Trade Agreement Act of 1979 prohibits Federal agencies from engaging in any standards or related activity that create unnecessary obstacles to the foreign commerce of the United States. Legitimate domestic objectives, such as safety, are not considered unnecessary obstacles. The statute also requires consideration of international standards and where appropriate, that they be the basis for U.S. standards. In addition, consistent with the Administration's belief in the general superiority and desirability of free trade, it is the policy of the Administration to remove or diminish, to the extent feasible, barriers to international trade, including both barriers affecting the export of American goods and services to foreign countries and barriers affecting the import of foreign goods and services into the U.S.

In accordance with the above statute and policy, the FAA has assessed the potential effect of this proposed rule and has determined that it will impose the same costs on domestic and international entities and thus has a neutral trade impact.

Executive Order 13132, Federalism

The FAA has analyzed this proposed rule under the principles and criteria of Executive Order 13132, Federalism. The FAA has determined that this action would not have substantial direct effects on the States, on the relationship between the national Government and the States, or on the distribution of power and responsibilities among the various levels of government. Therefore, the FAA has determined that this notice of proposed rulemaking would not have federalism implications.

Unfunded Mandates

Unfunded Mandates

The Unfunded Mandates reform Act of 1995 (2 U.S.C. 1532-1538) requires the FAA to assess the effects of Federal Regulatory actions on state, local, and tribal governments, and on the private sector of proposed rules that contain a Federal intergovernmental or private sector mandate that exceeds $100 million in any one year. This action does not contain such a mandate.

Environmental Assessment

Environmental Assessment

FAA Order 1050.1D defines FAA actions that may be categorically excluded from preparation of a National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) environmental assessment (EA) or environmental impact statement (EIS). In accordance with FAA Order 1050.1D, appendix 4, paragraph 4(j), regulations, standards, and exemptions (excluding those, which if implemented may cause a significant impact on the human environment) qualify for a categorical exclusion. The FAA proposes that this rule qualifies for a categorical exclusion because no significant impacts to the environment are expected to result from its finalization or implementation.

Energy Impact

Energy Impact

The energy impact of the notice has been assessed in accordance with the Energy Policy and Conservation Act (EPCA) Pub. L. 94-163, as amended (42 U.S.C. 6362) and FAA Order 1053.1. It has been determined that the notice is not a major regulatory action under the provisions of the EPCA.

List of Subjects in 14 CFR Part 21 and 36

List of Subjects in 14 CFR Part 21 and 36

Aircraft, Noise control.

The Proposed Amendment

In consideration of the foregoing the Federal Aviation Administration proposes to amend 14 CFR parts 21 and 36, as follows:

PART 21--CERTIFICATION PROCEDURES FOR PRODUCTS AND PARTS

1. The authority citation for part 21 continues to read as follows:

PART 21--CERTIFICATION PROCEDURES FOR PRODUCTS AND PARTS

Authority: 42 U.S.C. 7572; 49 U.S.C. 106(g), 40105, 40113, 44701-44702, 44707, 44709, 44711, 44713, 44715, 45303.

§ 21.17 [Amended]

2. Amend paragraph (a) of § 21.17 by removing the word "parts" and adding the word "part" and removing the words "and 36".

§ 21.101 [Amended]

3. Amend paragraph (a) of § 21.101 by removing the word "parts" and adding the word "part" and removing the words "and 36".

PART 36--NOISE STANDARDS: AIRCRAFT TYPE AND AIRWORTHINESS CERTIFICATION

PART 36--NOISE STANDARDS: AIRCRAFT TYPE AND AIRWORTHINESS CERTIFICATION

1. The authority citation for part 36 continues to read as follows:

Authority: 42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.; 49 U.S.C. 106(g), 40113, 44701-44702, 44704, 44715; sec. 305, Pub. L. 96-193, 94 Stat. 50, 57; E.O. 11514, 35 FR 4247, 3 CFR, 1966-1970 Comp., p. 902.

§ 36.1 [Amended]

§ 36.1 [Amended]

2. Amend § 36.1 as follows:

a. In paragraph (a)(1) remove the words "turbojet powered" and add the word "jet" in its place.

b. In paragraph (d), introductory text, remove the words "turbojet powered" and add the word "jet" in its place.

c. Remove paragraph (d)(3).

d. In paragraph (f) remove the words "turbojet powered" and insert the word "jet" in its place.

e. In paragraph (f)(1) remove the reference to "C36.5(a)(2)" and add "B36.5(b)" in its place; remove the word "takeoff" and add the word "flyover" in its place; and remove the word "sideline" and add the word "lateral" in its place;

f. In paragraph (f)(3) remove the reference to "C36.5(a)(2)" and add "B36.5(b)" in its place and remove the reference to "C36.5(a)(3)" and insert "B36.5(c)" in its place;

g. In paragraph (f)(4) remove the reference to "C36.5" and add "B36.5(b)" in its place;

h. In paragraph (f)(5) remove the reference to "C36.5(a)(3)" and add "B36.5(c)" in its place;

i. In paragraph (f)(6) remove the reference to "C36.5" and add "B36.5(c)" in its place; and.

j. In paragraph (g) remove the word "turbojet" and add the word "jet" in its place.

§ 36.2 [Removed and reserved]

3. Remove and reserve § 36.2.

§ 36.6 [Amended]

* * * * *

4. Amend § 36.6 as follows:

a. Add paragraphs (c)(1)(vi) through (x);

b. Revise paragraphs (d)(1)(i) and (ii), (e)(3)(ii), (e)(3)(vii), and (e)(3)(ix).

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 244 passages shown