AC 36-4D Noise Standards: Aircraft Type and Airworthiness Certification
This advisory circular (AC) is intended to promote uniformity of implementation of part 36 of the noise certification requirements of the United States Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Title 14. It provides (1) guidance to certificating authorities and applicants regarding the intended meaning and stringency of the Standards in part 36 as amended through October 4, 2017 (Amendment 36-31), and (2) the specific procedures that are deemed acceptable in demonstrating compliance with those Standards.
Advisory U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration Circular
Subject: NOISE STANDARDS: AIRCRAFT Date: 10/12/2017 AC No: 36-4D TYPE AND AIRWORTHINESS CERTIFICATION
Initiated by: AEE-100 Change:
1. PURPOSE This advisory circular (AC) is intended to promote uniformity of implementation of part 36 of the noise certification requirements of the United States Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Title 14. It provides (1) guidance to certificating authorities and applicants regarding the intended meaning and stringency of the Standards in part 36 as amended through October 4, 2017 (Amendment 36-31), and (2) the specific procedures that are deemed acceptable in demonstrating compliance with those Standards.
Note.— All references in this AC to parts such as part 36, part 21, etc. refer to parts of Title 14 of the United States Code of Federal Regulations.
a. Contents: This AC provides FAA policies for implementation of the regulatory language in the form of guidance material and technical procedures relating to the requirements of Appendices A, B, G, J, H and K of part 36 as appropriate. Those appendices describe the noise evaluation methods for compliance with the corresponding chapters of part 36 for jet airplanes, propeller-driven heavy and light airplanes, helicopters, and tiltrotor aircraft. Guidelines are also provided on flight test windows and adjustment of land-use planning data for rotorcraft.
The document also includes general information (including administrative information), general and technical references, definitions and bibliographies related to part 36. Information is also provided on equivalent procedures and demonstrating “no acoustical change” for jet airplanes, propeller-driven heavy and light airplanes, and helicopters.
b. Scope: This AC provides information for interested parties (such as regulatory authorities, aircraft manufacturers, acoustic consultants, airline and airport operators and others) on compliance with the part 36 noise certification regulations, including FAA policies and interpretations of regulatory language and other technical guidance applicable to noise certification processes for airplane and rotorcraft classes of aircraft. It is applicable for noise certification of normal, utility, acrobatic, commuter and transport category airplanes and normal and transport category rotorcraft as defined in part 21. Information is also provided on flight test windows and adjustment of landuse planning for rotorcraft as developed by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO).
This AC does not change regulatory requirements and does not authorize changes in, or deviations from, regulatory requirements. This document contains some mandatory language, where it is appropriate, as well as language that is permissive and advisory in nature. Mandatory language (e.g., the term “must”) is used in the AC for “Explanations of regulatory language”. Mandatory language is also used for certain “Guidance material” and “Technical procedures” to reflect FAA policies regarding compliance with the intent of regulatory language. Permissive language (e.g., the term “should”) is used in this AC, to identify conditions and/or methods and procedures that may be acceptable to the FAA for purposes of aircraft noise certification based upon experience to date, but where an applicant is not constrained from considering or validating and proposing alternatives for compliance with part 36.
c. Document structure: The basic framework of this AC is structured to provide various forms of noise certification guidance material for these aircraft. To a major extent this document follows the structure of the ICAO Environmental Technical Manual (ETM) document 9501 (Reference G5). Chapter 1 provides information on noise certification requirements in part 21. Chapter 2 provides information on FAA regulatory policies. Chapter 3 provides guidance applicable for all aircraft types and subsequent chapters provide guidance unique to different aircraft types. The general format of Chapters 1 through 8 includes one or more of three types of information: explanatory information, equivalent procedures and technical procedures which are described as follows:
Explanatory information
Explanatory information has the following purpose:
a) explains the language of part 36 noise Standards;
b) states current policies of the FAA regarding compliance with part 36; and
c) provides information on critical issues concerning approval of applicants’ compliance methodology
proposals.
Explanatory information may take the form of either:
a) guidance material (GM) which helps to illustrate the meaning of a specification or requirement; or
b) acceptable means of compliance (AMC) which illustrates a means, but not the only means, by which a
requirement specified in part 36, can be met. It may contain reference to an equivalent procedure described in this AC.
In the Explanatory sections of Chapters 4 through 8, a heading is provided for each AC section, including a subject or title, and the part 36 appendix and section number to which it refers. For example, GM §A36.2.1.1 is guidance material concerning §2.1.1 of Appendix A. Adjacent to this heading is a bracketed reference to the corresponding section of the ICAO ETM. For this example, “[ETM GM A2 2.1]” is guidance material concerning §2.1 of Appendix 2 of ICAO Annex 16, Volume I (Reference G7). Similarly, AMC §A36.2.1.1 presents an acceptable means of compliance concerning §2.1.1 of Appendix A and “[ETM AMC A2 2.1]” is an acceptable means of compliance concerning §2.1.1 of Appendix 2 of Annex 16, Volume 1.
Equivalent procedures
The FAA Office of Environment and Energy (AEE) (located in Washington DC) has approved a substantial number of equivalent procedures proposed by applicants. An equivalent procedure is by definition a test or analysis procedure which, while differing from one specified in part 36, in the technical judgment of the FAA, yields effectively the same noise levels as the specified procedure. Therefore, equivalent procedures provide some flexibility for the applicant in conducting noise certification in accordance with part 36, and may be approved for the convenience of an applicant in conducting measurements that are not strictly in accordance with the part 36 procedures, or when a departure from the specifics of part 36 is necessitated by field conditions.
Many of these equivalent procedures are referred to in this document because, through their extensive usage by applicants, they have become acceptable practices for aircraft noise certification applications. The acceptability of an equivalent procedure for an aircraft noise certification application is subject to FAA review and approval on a project by project basis. Equivalent procedures such as flight intercept need FAA approval as all other equivalencies, but may not require AEE involvement.
Equivalent procedures fall into two broad categories:
a) those which are generally applicable; and
b) those which are applicable to a particular aircraft type; for example, some equivalencies dealing with
measurement equipment may be used for all types of aircraft, but a given test procedure may be appropriate only for jet airplanes and not for turboprop airplanes.
Typical applications of equivalent procedures requested by applicants are to:
a) use previously acquired certification test data for the aircraft type;
b) permit and encourage more reliable demonstration of small level differences among derived versions of
aircraft; and
c) minimize the cost of demonstrating compliance with the requirements of part 36 by keeping aircraft test
time, airfield usage, and equipment and personnel costs to a minimum.
Technical procedures
A technical procedure is a test or analysis procedure not defined in detail in part 36 but which the FAA have approved as being acceptable for compliance with the general provisions of part 36.
The procedures described in part 36 must be used unless an equivalent procedure or alternative technical procedure is approved by the FAA. Procedures should not be considered as limited only to those described herein, as this AC will be expanded as new procedures are developed. Also, their presentation does not infer limitation of their application or commitment by the FAA to their further use.
Chapter 9 provides guidelines for recertification of airplanes to Stage 4 or Stage 5 based upon assessment of those with approved existing noise levels or those specially “modified” to achieve compliance with Stage 4 or Stage 5.
Conversion of units
Conversions of some non-critical numerical values between U.S. Customary (English) and SI units are shown in the context of acceptable approximations.
2. CANCELLATION
Advisory Circular 36-4C, Noise Standards: Aircraft Type and Airworthiness Certification, dated July 15, 2003, is cancelled.
3. REFERENCES
General references
References that identify FAA Orders, Advisory Circulars, and Reports that provide direction and/or guidance on acceptable processes and procedures for aircraft noise certification are listed in Appendix 1. GENERAL REFERENCES of this AC. These references also include current ICAO noise standards and are noted as Reference G1, Reference G2, etc. in the text. As these documents are referenced in this AC, information is also provided as to the extent that their provisions apply to a given type of aircraft noise certification process. Applicants are encouraged to contact FAA AEE to determine if more recent editions are available and applicable to noise certification actions that are being considered for FAA approval.
Technical references
References that identify technical documents other than part 36 are listed in Appendix 2. TECHNICAL REFERENCES of this AC. These documents include international instrumentation standards incorporated by reference in part 36 and are noted as Reference T1, Reference T2, etc. in the text.
Bibliography
A suggested bibliography relating to certain texts of this AC is provided in Appendix 3. BIBLIOGRAPHY.
FAA/DOT addresses
Appendix 4. DOT/FAA ADDRESSES lists current addresses of U.S. Department of Transportation and FAA organizations (and noise certification specialists) that might provide assistance to an applicant.
4. DEFINITIONS
This section contains two categories of definitions that are used within the regulatory language, policies or other guidance information of this Advisory Circular. The first category defines general terms or organizational designations that depict FAA and applicant roles in the part 36 noise certification process. The second category defines specific aircraft types that must comply with part 36 regulations and other items related to those aircraft. References to part 1 are to the definitions of 14 CFR Part 1.
General definitions:
Administrator: The Federal Aviation Administrator or any person to whom he has delegated his authority in the
matter concerned. (Ref: part 1)
Aircraft certification office (ACO): The (FAA) office that administers the type certificate and production approval
of products in the area where the manufacturer is located.
Applicant: Section 21.13 of part 21, states: “Any interested person may apply for a type certificate”. The person that
applies to the FAA for an aircraft type certificate, whether a new (original), amended, supplemental or provisional type certificate, is identified as the “applicant” and is the entity that must comply with the procedural, certification and production requirements of part 21.
Noise certification specialist (NCS): The Directorate (Transport, Small Airplane, or Helicopter) Noise Certification
Specialist.
Person: An individual, firm, partnership, corporation, company, association, joint-stock association, or government
entity. It includes a trustee, receiver, assignee, or similar representative of any of them. (Ref: part 1).
Type inspection authorization (TIA): The TIA is the official FAA document that provides direction and
communication between the local ACO engineering group and the FAA flight test crew. The TIA usually mandates the provisions of an applicant’s approved demonstration compliance plan and any additional restrictions, inspections, tests, limitations, procedures, etc., that are required by the ACO to be observed during the conduct of the flight or ground testing.
Definitions related to aircraft:
Acrobatic category airplane: The acrobatic category is limited to airplanes that have a seating configuration,
excluding pilot seats, of nine or less, a maximum certificated takeoff weight of 12,500 pounds or less, and intended for use without restrictions, other than those shown to be necessary as a result of required flight tests. Acrobatic category airplanes are required to show compliance with part 23.
Aircraft: A device that is used or intended to be used for flight in the air. (Ref: part 1)
Aircraft engine: An engine that is used, or intended to be used, for propelling aircraft. It includes turbosuperchargers,
appurtenances, and accessories necessary for its functioning, but does not include propellers. (Ref: part 1)
Airplane: An engine-driven fixed-wing aircraft heavier than air that is supported in flight by the dynamic reaction of
the air against its wings. (Ref: part 1)
Airport: An area of land or water that is used or intended to be used for the landing and takeoff of aircraft, and
includes its buildings and facilities, if any. (Ref: part 1)
Civil aircraft: Aircraft other than a public aircraft. (Ref: part 1)
Commuter category airplanes: The commuter category is limited to propeller-driven, multiengine airplanes that have
a seating configuration, excluding pilot seats, of 19 or less, and a maximum certificated takeoff weight of 19,000 pounds or less, intended for non-acrobatic operations. Commuter category airplanes are required to show compliance with part 23.
Helicopter: A rotorcraft that, for its horizontal motion, depends principally on its engine-driven rotors. (Ref: part 1)
Large aircraft: Large aircraft means aircraft of more than 12,500 pounds, maximum certificated takeoff weight. (Ref:
Normal category airplane: The normal category is limited to airplanes that have a seating configuration, excluding
pilot seats, of nine or less, a maximum certificated takeoff weight of 12,500 pounds or less, and intended for nonacrobatic operation. Normal category airplanes are required to show compliance with part 23.
Normal category rotorcraft: A normal category rotorcraft is a rotorcraft with a maximum weight of 7000 pounds or
less and that meets the regulatory requirements of part 27.
Primary category aircraft: A primary category aircraft is an aircraft that (1) is unpowered, or is an airplane powered
by a single, naturally aspirated engine with a 61-knot or less stall speed, or is a rotorcraft with a 6-pound per square foot main rotor disc loading limitations, and (2) weighs not more than 2700 pounds, and (3) has a maximum seating capacity of not more than four persons, including the pilot, and (4) has an unpressurized cabin. A primary category aircraft is required to meet the regulatory requirements of §21.24 of part 21.
Propeller: A device for propelling an aircraft that has blades on an engine-driven shaft and that, when rotated,
produces by its action on the air, a thrust approximately perpendicular to its plane of rotation. It includes control components normally supplied by its manufacturer, but does not include main and auxiliary rotors or rotating airfoils of engines. (Ref: part 1).
Public aircraft: Aircraft used only in the service of a government, or a political subdivision. It does not include any
government-owned aircraft engaged in carrying persons or property for commercial purposes. (Ref: part 1)
Restricted aircraft: Used for special purpose operations as defined in §21.25 of part 21.
Rotorcraft: A heavier-than-air aircraft that depends principally for its support in flight on the lift generated by one or
more rotors (Ref: part 1).
Small aircraft: Small aircraft means aircraft of 12,500 pounds or less, maximum certificated takeoff weight. (Ref:
Subsonic airplane: A subsonic airplane means an airplane for which the maximum operating limit speed, MMO, does
not exceed a Mach number of 1.
Supersonic airplane: A supersonic airplane means an airplane for which the maximum operating limit speed, MMO,
exceeds a Mach number of 1.
Transport category aircraft: Those aircraft (large or small) that are demonstrated to meet and are certificated to the
regulatory requirements of part 25 for transport category airplanes or part 29 for transport category rotorcraft.
Jet Airplane: Any fixed wing airplane that is powered by a turbojet or turbofan engine regardless of whether it is an
airplane certificated to part 23 (small or commuter aircraft) or part 25 (transport category aircraft).
Turbo-propeller airplane: An airplane whose primary source of thrust is from a propeller driven by a gas turbine
engine.
Utility category airplane: The utility category is limited to airplanes that have a seating configuration, excluding pilot
seats, of nine or less, a maximum certificated takeoff weight of 12,500 pounds or less, and intended for limited acrobatic operation. Utility category airplanes are required to show compliance with part 23.
5. ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS
The following abbreviations and acronyms are used within the text of this AC
AC = FAA advisory circular ACO = Local FAA aircraft certification office AEE = FAA Office of Environment and Energy AFM = Airplane Flight Manual AMC = Acceptable means of compliance APU = Auxiliary power unit C/A = Coarse/Acquisition CAEP = Committee on Aviation Environmental Protection CDI = Course deviation indicator CG = Center of gravity CFR = Code of Federal Regulations CPA = Closest point of approach DAT = Digital audiotape dB = Decibel DER = Designated Engineering Representative DGPS = Differential global positioning system DMU = Distance measuring unit EPNL = Effective perceived noise level ETM = Environmental Technical Manual (“ICAO Environmental Technical Manual. Volume 1, Procedures
for the Noise Certification of Aircraft”) FAA = Federal Aviation Administration GDI = Glide-slope deviation indicator GM = Guidance material GPS = Global positioning system Hz = Oscillatory frequency, cycles per second IAS = Indicated airspeed ICD = Inflow control device INS = Inertial navigation system ICAO = International Civil Aviation Organization ILS = Instrument landing system IOD = Issue of data
lRIG lRIGB ISA LAAS
LArnax log LUP MAP MLW MSL MTOW NAC NCS NIST NMEA NPD OAT RFM RH rms rpm SAE SBV SR STC TIA TC TSPI UTC VLA VNTSC
VREF
10/12/2017
=Inter-Range Instrumentation Group =Inter-Range Instrumentation Group Standard Serial Time Code Format B =International standard atmosphere = Local area augmentation system = Maximum A-weighted sound level =Logarithmic value to base 10 = Land-use planning = Manifold air pressure = Maximum landing weight = Mean sea level altitude, feet = Maximum takeoff weight =No acoustical change =Noise Certification Specialist =National Institute ofStandards and Technology =National Marine Electronics Association = Noise-power-distance = Outside air temperature = Rotorcraft Flight Manual = Relative humidity, % =Root-mean-square = revolutions per minute =Society ofAutomotive Engineers =Surge bleed valve (engine internal operating valves) =Slant range = Supplemental Type Certificate = Type Inspection Authorization =Type Certificate =Time-space-position information =Coordinated universal time =Very Light Aircraft =Volpe National Transportation System Center (DOT) =Reference Landing Speed
u isH Acting Director of Environment and Energy
Page 7
Table of Contents
Page 1. PURPOSE … 1 2. CANCELLATION … 3 3. REFERENCES … 3 4. DEFINITIONS … 4 5. ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS … 6 6-7. RESERVED … 7
CHAPTER 1. CERTIFICATION PROCEDURES FOR PRODUCT AND PARTS 14 CFR PART 21
101 EXPLANATORY INFORMATION … 10
CHAPTER 2. NOISE STANDARDS: AIRCRAFT TYPE AND AIRWORTHINESS
201 EXPLANATORY INFORMATION … 32
CHAPTER 3. TECHNICAL PROCEDURES APPLICABLE FOR NOISE CERTIFICATION OF ALL AIRCRAFT TYPES
301 NOISE MEASUREMENT PROCEDURES … 58 302 FLIGHT PATH MEASUREMENT … 65 303 ON-BOARD FLIGHT DATA ACQUISITION … 80 304 TIME SYNCHRONIZATION OF MEASURED DATA … 82 305 CALCULATION OF CONFIDENCE INTERVALS … 84 306 ADJUSTMENT OF AIRCRAFT NOISE LEVELS FOR THE EFFECTS … 97 307 NOISE REDUCTION SYSTEMS … 105 308 CALCULATION OF THE SPEED OF SOUND … 107 309 REFERENCE TABLES USED IN THE MANUAL CALCULATION OF … 107
CHAPTER 4. GUIDELINES FOR TRANSPORT CATEGORY LARGE AIRPLANES, SUBSONIC JET AIRPLANES, AND HELICOPTERS EVALUATED UNDER APPENDIX A OR H OF 14 CFR PART 36
401 EXPLANATORY INFORMATION … 116 402 EQUIVALENT PROCEDURES INFORMATION … 160 403 TECHNICAL PROCEDURES INFORMATION … 192
CHAPTER 5. GUIDELINES FOR PROPELLER-DRIVEN SMALL AIRPLANES AND PROPELLER-DRIVE COMMUTER CATEGORY AIRPLANES EVALUATED UNDER APPENDIX G OF 14 CFR PART 36
501 EXPLANATORY INFORMATION … 218 502 EQUIVALENT PROCEDURES INFORMATION … 226 503 TECHNICAL PROCEDURES INFORMATION … 232
CHAPTER 6. GUIDELINES FOR HELICOPTERS NOT EXCEEDING 7000 LB EVALUATED UNDER APPENDIX J OF 14 CFR PART 36
601 EXPLANATORY INFORMATION … 237 602 EQUIVALENT PROCEDURES INFORMATION … 245
CHAPTER 7. GUIDELINES FOR TILTROTOR AIRCRAFT EVALUATED UNDER APPENDIX K OF 14 CFR PART 3
701 EXPLANATORY INFORMATION … 247
CHAPTER 8. GUIDELINES ON FLIGHT TEST WINDOWS AND ADJUSTMENT OF LAND-USE PLANNING NOISE DATA MEASURED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ATTACHMENT H TO ANNEX 16, VOLUME I
801 EXPLANATORY INFORMATION … 253 802 EQUIVALENT PROCEDURES INFORMATION … 260 803 TECHNICAL PROCEDURES INFORMATION … 260
CHAPTER 9. GUIDELINES FOR AIRCRAFT RECERTIFICATION
901 INTRODUCTION … 266 902 ASSESSMENT CRITERIA … 267 903 RECERTIFICATION GUIDELINES FOR “MODIFIED”AIRPLANES … 271
Appendix 1. GENERAL REFERENCES … 273
Appendix 2. TECHNICAL REFERENCES … 274
Appendix 3. BIBLIOGRAPHY … 276
Appendix 4. DOT/FAA ADDRESSES … 277
Chapter 1
CERTIFICATION PROCEDURES FOR PRODUCT AND PARTS 14 CFR PART 21
CHAPTER TABLE OF CONTENTS
101 EXPLANATORY INFORMATION … 10 101(a) Part 21 General … 10 101(b) Airworthiness Certification … 10 101(c) Changes in Type Design … 10 101(d) No acoustical changes (NAC) … 11 101(e) Methods for Demonstrating No Acoustical Change (NAC) … 14 101(f) Acquisition of In-duct and/or Near-field Data for Demonstration of NAC … 29
101 EXPLANATORY INFORMATION
101(a) Part 21 General
As part of the overall aircraft certification requirements identified in part 21, applicants must comply with the noise certification requirements of part 36. Section 21.17 of part 21 specifies that an applicant for a type certificate must show that the aircraft meets the applicable requirements of part 36. In addition, §§21.21 and 21.25 of part 21 specify that an applicant is entitled to a type certificate for an aircraft if the applicant submits the type design, test reports, and computations necessary to show that the product to be certificated meets the applicable airworthiness and aircraft noise requirements. Similar requirements are imposed for aircraft manufactured in a foreign country for import into the United States (§21.29 of part 21). Refer to the part 21 regulations for specific regulatory language.
101(b) Airworthiness Certification
All aircraft requiring noise certification by the FAA are required to meet the applicable airworthiness requirements of part 21, which identifies the specific airworthiness standards for each aircraft type and product, such as:
a) part 23 for normal, utility, acrobatic, and commuter category airplanes;
b) part 25 for transport category airplanes;
c) part 27 for normal category rotorcraft;
d) part 29 for transport category rotorcraft;
e) part 33 for aircraft engines;
f) part 35 for propellers;
g) primary category aircraft; and
h) JAR-VLA aircraft.
101(c) Changes in Type Design
(1) General
Section 21.93(b) of part 21 requires compliance with the appropriate part 36 “acoustical change” requirements for a voluntary type design change of an aircraft that may increase the noise levels of that aircraft, regardless of whether the change in type design is classified as a minor or major change in §21.93(a) of part 21.
(2) Voluntary changes
A general description of FAA handling of various forms of voluntary changes in the type design of an aircraft is addressed in 201(a)(3) of this AC. Procedures for demonstration of compliance with part 21 for specific types of “no acoustical change” (NAC) are presented in 101(d) & (e).
101(d) No acoustical changes (NAC)
(1) NAC definition
Aircraft/engine model design changes and airframe/engine performance changes may result in very small changes in aircraft noise certification levels that are not acoustically significant. These changes are referred to as no acoustical changes (NACs). For this AC NACs, which do not result in modification of an aircraft’s noise certification levels, are defined as:
a) changes in airplane noise certification levels approved by the FAA which do not exceed 0.10 dB at any
noise measurement point and which an applicant does not track;
b) cumulative changes in airplane noise certification levels approved by the FAA whose sum is greater than
0.10 dB but not more than 0.30 dB at any noise measurement point and for which an applicant has an approved tracking procedure;
c) for helicopters certificated according to the standards of Appendix H, changes in any one of the noise
certification levels approved by the FAA which do not exceed 0.30 EPNdB; and
d) for helicopters certificated according to the standards of Appendix J, changes in the noise certification
level approved by the FAA which does not exceed 0.30 dB(A).
(2) Tracking procedures
With respect to the tracking procedure referred to in 101(d)(1)(b), noise certification approval has been given based upon the following criteria:
a) ownership by the certification applicant of the noise certification database and tracking process on an
aircraft/engine model basis;
b) when the 0.30 dB cumulative change in the airplane noise certification level is exceeded, compliance
with the part 36 requirements is required; the aircraft noise certification levels may not be based upon summation of NAC noise increments;
c) decreases in noise levels should not be included in the tracking process unless the type design change
will be retrofitted to all aircraft in service and included on newly produced aircraft;
d) aircraft/engine design changes resulting in noise level increases should be included in the tracking
process regardless of the extent of retrofit to aircraft in service;
e) tracking of an aircraft/engine model should, in addition to engine design changes, include airframe and
performance changes;
f) tracked noise increments should be determined on the basis of the most noise-sensitive condition and be applied to all configurations of the aircraft/engine model;
g) the tracking should be revised to account for a tracked design change increment that is no longer
applicable;
h) changes should be tracked to two decimal places (i.e., 0.01 dB). Round-off should not be considered
when judging an NAC (e.g., 0.29 dB = NAC; 0.30 dB = NAC; 0.31 dB = acoustical change); and
i) an applicant should maintain formal documentation of all NACs approved under a tracking process for an airframe/engine model; the tracking list will be reproduced in each noise certification demonstration document.
Due to the applicability dates, some light propeller-driven airplanes are not required to have noise certification levels. However some modifications to these aircraft can be applied which may impact the noise characteristics. In this case, the NAC criteria application should be treated with a procedure approved by the FAA.
(3) Criteria for helicopter certification
Noise certification approval of modified helicopters should be granted according to the following criteria:
a) an NAC approval for a derived version can be made only if the parent “flight datum” helicopter was
flight tested to obtain the noise certification levels;
b) noise levels for a helicopter designated as an NAC design cannot be used as the “flight datum” for any
subsequent design changes; and
c) for changes exceeding 0.30 dB, compliance with part 36 requirements may be achieved either by testing
or, subject to approval of the FAA, by analytical means; if analytical means are employed, the noise certification levels cannot be used as the “flight datum” for any subsequent design changes.
Note.— Definition for parent “flight datum” aircraft is shown in Table 1.
A flow chart illustrating the criteria for dealing with modified helicopters is presented in Figure 1.
Due to the applicability dates, some helicopters are not required to have noise certification levels. However some modifications to these helicopters can be applied which may impact the noise characteristics. In this case, the NAC criteria application should be treated with a procedure approved by the FAA.
(4) Helicopters modifications defined as NACs
Changes in helicopter noise level(s) arising from modifications associated with the installation or removal of external equipment are defined as NACs and thus need not be determined. For the purposes of this section “external equipment” means any instrument, mechanism, part, appurtenance, or necessary accessory that is attached to, or extends from, the helicopter exterior but is not used, nor is intended to be used, in operating or controlling the helicopter in flight and is not part of an airframe or engine.
The following examples are considered to be no acoustical changes:
a) the addition or removal of external equipment;
b) changes to the airframe made to accommodate the addition or removal of external equipment, to provide
for an external load attaching means, to facilitate the use of external equipment or external loads, or to facilitate the safe operation of the helicopter with external equipment mounted to, or external loads carried by, the helicopter;
c) reconfiguration of the helicopter by the addition or removal of floats and skis;
d) flight with one or more doors and/or windows removed or in an open position; or
e) any changes in the operational limitations placed on the helicopter as a consequence of the addition or
removal of external equipment, floats, skis, or flight operations with doors and/or windows removed or in an open position.
(5) Helicopters with variable noise reduction systems (VNRS)
Aircraft can incorporate variable systems, primarily intended to reduce the takeoff/approach noise. Such aircraft can be noise certificated using the guidance provided for aircraft with VNRS. For such changes to existing type designs, the guidelines provided for NAC are applicable.
Figure 1. “No-acoustical change” criteria for modifications to noise certificated helicopters
101(e) Methods for Demonstrating No Acoustical Change (NAC) for Propeller-Driven Small Airplanes and Commuter Category Airplanes
(1) Procedures
The methods, as referred to in this section, are aircraft measurement, flight test, analytical or evaluation methods that differ from the methods specified in the text of Appendix G of part 36. The particular method(s) employed must be approved by the FAA. These methods differ from equivalent procedures in that they are used for a finding of NAC under §21.93(b) of part 21 and are not pertinent to part 36.
(2) Acoustical changes
The regulatory need to evaluate all voluntary changes for acoustical change is found in §21.93(b) of part 21. An acoustical change in the type design of an airplane is defined in §21.93(b) as “…any voluntary change in the type design of an aircraft that may increase the noise levels of that aircraft is an acoustical change…”; note that a change in design that decreases the noise level is not an acoustical change in terms of the rule. There are four categories of small propeller-driven airplanes excluded from this evaluation of voluntary changes: 1) Airplanes designated for “agricultural aircraft operations” as defined in §137.3 of part 137; 2); Designated for dispensing firefighting materials; 3) U.S. registered and had flight time prior to January 1, 1955; and 4) Land configured airplanes reconfigured with floats or skis (non-permanent seasonal changes to the landing gear). The exclusions noted in §21.93(b) differ from an earlier definition that applied to propeller-driven small airplanes certificated under Appendix F of part 36. In the earlier definition, acoustical changes were restricted to (1) any change or removal of a muffler or other component of an exhaust system designed for noise control, or (2) any change to an engine or propeller installation which would increase maximum continuous power or propeller tip speed.
The current definition of acoustical change in §21.93(b) for propeller-driven small airplanes and commuter category airplanes is more in line with that for all other aircraft categories. For example, an increase in takeoff weight without any change in engine/propeller installation would not be considered an acoustical change under the earlier definition. Now it would be, since the reference height for noise level measurement would be lower with the increased weight, which would result in a higher noise level.
Section 36.9 defines the noise compliance requirements for propeller-driven small airplanes and commuter category airplanes for which an acoustical change approval is applied for under §21.93(b). Section 36.9 recognizes two airplane categories: those that have previously been shown to comply with part 36, and those that have not. For the first group, any acoustical change must not increase noise levels beyond the limits stated in Part D of Appendix G. For the second group, noise levels may not exceed either these same limits, or "the noise level created prior to the change in type design, measured and corrected as prescribed in §36.501 of this part," whichever is greater. This may require that two noise certification tests need be run. The first is to establish the unmodified noise level standard and the second is to measure the modified noise level. Section 36.501(c) also requires that "compliance must be shown with noise levels as measured and prescribed in Parts B and C of Appendix G, or under approved equivalent procedures."
The FAA considers any change in type design that will increase the noise level by more than 0.10 dB(A) an acoustical change. However, no acoustical change results as long as any change that can be expected to increase the noise level is offset by other changes in design or performance that will decrease the noise level in such a way that the sum of the changes does not increase the expected noise level by more than 0.10 dB(A).
The purpose of this section is to examine methods for calculating changes in noise level introduced by common type design changes and methods for showing compensating noise level effects that will result in a demonstration of NAC.
(3) Factors that change noise level
Noise levels under Appendix G test procedures are affected by both the basic noise producing properties of the propeller/engine installation and by the takeoff and climb performance of the airplane. Regardless of what mechanical change is made to the airplane, noise levels can be expected to increase if any of the following conditions results from a type design change (without compensating changes):
a) decrease in the height of the airplane at the reference distance of 8200 ft (2500 m) from brake release;
b) increase in engine horsepower;
c) removal or alteration of exhaust mufflers;
d) increase in propeller helical tip Mach number;
e) increase in propeller tip thickness;
f) decrease in airplane climb path angle;
g) increase in airplane drag;
h) increase in propeller inflow angle; or
i) change in the number of propeller blades.
Increases expected in the Appendix G noise levels caused by any of the above changes must be offset by a compensating change to achieve NAC, and an appropriate analysis of the effects of such a change must be provided. Removal of exhaust mufflers or other changes in the exhaust system may require some form of testing to determine the acoustical effect. Similarly, increasing propeller tip thickness, such as by cutting the tips off an existing propeller to decrease its diameter, may cause an increase in noise level (which might be offset by the decrease in the propeller rotational Mach number at the same rpm). In both the case of the altered exhaust system and that for the cut-down propeller, a comparison test, during which noise levels are measured for the modified and the unmodified airplanes utilizing part 36 Appendix G flyovers at the same height and airspeed, may be approved as a satisfactory method to determine whether an acoustical change has occurred.
Comparison tests are not generally cost saving methods since they may become as complex as a full part 36 Appendix G test.
(3.1) Parent aircraft definition
Before making any analysis or conducting any test it is necessary to determine what defines the Parent (unmodified) airplane. The Parent airplane represents the noise characteristics existing prior to the change in type design. Table 1 will help identify the Parent aircraft for use in no-acoustical change evaluations.
Table 1. Definition for parent “flight datum” aircraft
Modification Parent Aircraft
STC/Field Approval/Type Design Change (All changes contained in the same approval).
Aircraft defined on the dataplate (Original T.C. configuration)
Multiple STC’s/Field Approvals/Type Design Changes (None of which provided noise levels)
Aircraft defined on the dataplate (Original T.C. configuration)
Multiple STC’s/Field Approvals/Type Design Changes Aircraft defined on the (Where at least one* provides new noise levels and including any dataplate previously approved changes that provided noise levels). (Original T.C. configuration)
* The approval that provides new noise values (STC, Service Bulletin, Field Approval, etc.) must be listed in the approval
plus the modification that included noise value(s).
documentation as required to be previously or concurrently installed. [Should more than one of the included changes contain noise value(s), the approval that provides the lowest value(s), in all applicable reference profiles, will be used.
For approvals with more than one reference profile (e.g., Appendix B & H), when one modification does not provide lower, or equal, noise levels in all three profiles, then only one of the previously approved changes may be used as the acoustic parent definition. All other alterations are treated as acoustical changes.]
Conversion from one aircraft model into another with no change to the aircraft dataplate.
Aircraft defined on the dataplate (Original T.C. configuration)
Conversion from one aircraft model into another with a new or additional dataplate being added.
Aircraft defined on the later installed dataplate.
(3.2) Definitions
Following are definitions used in this section:
c = Speed of sound at reference height
CD = Airplane coefficient of drag CL = Airplane coefficient of lift D = Diameter of propeller D50 = Distance from brake release to and aircraft height of 50 feet at sea
level conditions. H = Reference height over the prescribed measurement location HP = Horsepower F = Force (thrust) M = Mach number RC = Rate of climb at Vy rpm = Revolutions per minute T = Standard temperature at reference altitude V = Airspeed Vy = Best rate of climb airspeed. W = Maximum gross takeoff weight = Propeller inflow angle = Pressure ratio at reference height. γ = Climb angle θ = Temperature ratio at reference height σ = Density ratio at reference height. Subscripts P = Parent M = Modified R = Rotational A = Airplane TAS = True Airspeed h = Helical tip
(4) Examples of type design changes that may affect noise levels
Typical applications for type design changes that require an evaluation of the effect of the change on noise levels include:
a) increase in maximum takeoff weight without any change in engine or propeller installation;
b) change from a fixed pitch propeller to a variable pitch propeller;
c) change in propeller diameter;
d) change in number of blades;
e) increase in engine horsepower; and
f) modification that increases drag without any change in engine or propeller installations. Examples include installation of external cargo containers, larger tires on fixed gear, or advertising light arrays.
In many cases, changes in noise level introduced by these modifications can be determined analytically by using existing data for the unmodified airplane, or by supplementing the existing data with additional performance
information when that performance is approved by the FAA. If that performance is “equal to” or “better” the applicant CANNOT take credit for “better” performance (e.g., shorter takeoff distance, increased rate of climb, etc.) when evaluating a modification for acoustical change unless the new performance is subsequently published in an approved Airplane Flight Manual Supplement (AFMS) or Supplemental Airplane Flight Manual (SAFM) for the modification. Most requests for supplemental type certificates (STC) are made by applicants that do not have access to manufacturer's data used to determine noise levels, even if these data exist. Since part 36 Appendix G applies to noise certification tests completed after December 1988, much of the existing fleet of small propeller airplanes do not have noise level data evaluated according to part 36 Appendix G. In order to obtain an STC, an applicant must demonstrate an NAC or conduct an entire Appendix G test. Several examples are given here of ways to substantiate a no acoustical change using the adjustment factors described previously.
There are, however, some design changes which an applicant may propose that Appendix G compliance is not required, based on similarity to previously approved type certificates (TC) or STCs. Examples of this are older airplanes in a series where the series has several different engine sizes certified in the same basic airframe. Converting an airplane from one engine power to higher engine power by an applicant for an STC will require the applicant to do a noise analysis, possibly including noise measurements, even though the same engine/airframe combination exists in a production series. The reason for this is that the manufacturer is very unlikely to have demonstrated part 36 Appendix G compliance with any of his production airplanes. Even if the manufacturer has demonstrated compliance and the certificated noise level is published in an FAA Advisory Circular, the data used to demonstrate compliance, including the 90 percent confidence level for the certificated noise level, is proprietary to the manufacturer.
Before the adoption of Appendix G, certain changes to an airplane were accepted as an NAC by the FAA without any analysis. Two examples are the replacement of a two-blade propeller with a three-blade propeller, and an increase of less than 2 percent takeoff weight. For the reasons described below, these two types of changes are no longer accepted as an NAC unless the it is substantiated by analysis and/or test data.
In the case of propeller replacements with increased number of blades, the change in noise generating mechanisms cannot be simply accounted for by tip Mach number and engine power corrections. Also, the increase in the number of propeller blades shifts the blade passage to higher frequency, which has a smaller A-weighing filter adjustment. In STC applications with propeller changes, the FAA may require a comprehensive NAC analysis to account for the modified noise generation mechanisms, and the A-weighing filter effects or flyover tests have to be conducted.
Increasing the maximum certificated takeoff weight over the base airplane (or aerodynamic changes which increase drag of the aircraft such that its takeoff performance deteriorates) would cause it to fly at a lower height over the noise measurement location, which results in a higher noise level. An increase in takeoff weight without any change in engine/propeller performance would be an acoustical change unless the noise increase is offset by performance gains or reduction in airplane noise generation, any of which must be substantiated by analysis and/or test data. It is possible to show an NAC condition analytically as given in Example 1 of this chapter, without actual flight or ground testing.
(4.1) Increase in weight
For a change in airplane takeoff weight without any change in engine/propeller installation, the following factors influence the noise level under part 36 Appendix G procedures.
a) As a reasonable first approximation, the takeoff distance to a height of 50 ft (15 m) is increased by a
factor equal to the square of the ratio of the weight after the change to the weight before the change. However, the final determination must be done using the FAA approved takeoff distance from the Approved Airplane Flight Manual (AFM), AFMS, or SAFM.
b) The best-rate-of climb speed will increase essentially as the square root of the ratio of the weight before
and after the change. However, the climb speed (and related performance) in the AFM may not be at the
best rate of climb speed (Vy) for aircraft type certificated after February 9, 1996. As of this date the climb speed may be dependent on cooling or other airworthiness minimum requirements and not the best rate of climb for the airplane.
c) The climb angle at the increased weight will be lower.
The noise level produced at the higher weight will be greater than at the lower weight because these items combine to generate a lower reference height. The increase in airspeed can also cause a modest change in the reference helical tip Mach number, which may increase noise level.
The incremental change in noise level, if nothing else is done, can be shown by an example. Note that the subscript “P” (Parent) is used to denote the "before" conditions and the subscript “M” (Modified) is used to denote the "after" condition.
The following examples are provided to give applicants guidance for NAC analysis. The performance calculations used in the examples are for demonstration purposes only; they are not FAA approved performance calculation procedures. Any change in performance data (takeoff or climb) that is to be utilized in the determination of NAC must be published in the aircraft flight manual.
Example 1: Calculate the change in noise level expected if the weight of an airplane increases from 3000 lb to 3200 lb, without any other changes, given the following (note that all of the data given is readily available or is calculable from virtually all aircraft operations handbooks):
Step 1 Calculate the parent aircraft reference conditions:
From the AFM/AFMS/SAFM/POH:
D50= 2220 ft Vy = 90 kt RC = 970 ft/min D = 84 in. rpm= 2600
Calculate:
P = sin-1(RC/Vy) = sin-1[970/(60 × /times 1.688 × 90)] = 6.11° equation (1)
HP = tan (D50) + 50 = tan ( 6.11°) (8200 – 2220) + 50 = 690 ft equation (2) DP = 84 in = propeller diameter rpm = 2600 rpm TP = 59(°F) – lapse rate × HP = 59(°F) – 0.003566 × 690 = 56.5°F equation (3) cP = 49.025 × ( T + 459.67)1/2 = 1113.8 ft/s equation (4)
P= (1 – 0.0000068753 × HP)5.2561 = 0.97532 equation (5)
P= (T+459.67) / (59(°F) + 459.67) = 0.99518 equation (6)
P= P/P= 0.98004 equation (7)
VTAS = Vy / P1/2 = 90.9 knots (True airspeed of parent aircraft) equation (8) MPA = VTAS/cP = 1.688 × 90.9 / 1113.8 = 0.1378 (Mach speed of parent aircraft) equation (9) MPR = DP × rpm × π / (60 × 12 × cP) = 0.8556 (Parent rotational Mach number) equation (10) MPh = (MPA2 + MPR2)1/2 = 0.8666
Equation (11) Step 2: Calculate the modified aircraft reference height for a weight of 3200 lb.
a) The takeoff distance before the change, D50P, is 2220 ft. After the weight increase the takeoff distance is
given by:
D50M = 2220 (3200 / 3000)2 = 2526 ft equation (12)
b) The new best rate-of-climb speed at sea level, standard day, VYM, is given by:
VYM = 90 (3200 / 3000)1/2= 93.0 kt equation (13)
Note.— This is only a first approximation. Final determination of VY must be done using FAA approved methods. Unless approved and published in the AFMS/SAFM the applicant must use the VY value published in the original AFM/POH.
c) Calculating the climb angle at the increased weight can be done by several methods, depending upon the
data available from the aircraft operations handbook or flight manual. Where handbook or flight manual data are not available, data such as climb rate or sink rate may be obtained by performing a limited amount of climb tests. Any such performance tests must be conducted with FAA approval.
Method 1:
A general equation for calculating climb performance can be obtained if best rate-of-climb data are available in the aircraft operations handbook for different airplane weights. These data can be used to calculate an effective thrust during takeoff, and the effective ratio of drag to lift. For stable climb conditions at moderate climb angles where the cosine of the climb angle may be assumed to be essentially equal to unity, the sine of the climb angle , which is also the ratio of rate-of-climb to climb speed, is determined from:
sin (= RC / (101.3 × Vy) = F / W – CD / CL equation (14)
Note.— The published climb speed in the AFM/AFMS may not be the actual aircraft Vy. The applicant is responsible for determining what VY is. See previous note concerning the appropriate speed.
where F is the thrust developed by the propeller, and CD/CL is the ratio of drag to lift coefficients. Thrust is the product of propeller efficiency and engine power, divided by airspeed, with appropriate unit conversions. If it is assumed that the ratio of propeller efficiency to airspeed is approximately constant for airspeeds used for bestrate-of climb, then it can be assumed that thrust remains approximately constant for a given horsepower rating for takeoff. By obtaining RC and Vy for two different weights, two simultaneous equations are obtained using equation 14. These may then be solved for F and the ratio of CD/CL, since only the ratio is required.
In addition to the data for a weight of 3000 lb, the flight manual gives a rate-of-climb of 1140 ft/min at 2700 lb. The best rate-of-climb speed for a weight of 2700 lb will be the speed for 3000 lb times the square root of the ratio of the two weights, or 85.4 kt. Writing two equations with these values, and by subtracting one from the other, the effective thrust, F, is found to be 686 lb, and the drag/lift coefficient ratio is 0.1222.
Substituting the values for thrust, drag/lift ratio, and airspeed for the desired weight of 3200 lb yields climb angle of 5.29°. For a climb airspeed of 93.0 kt, the rate-of-climb is obtained as 868 ft/min.
Method 2:
Rate of climb, RC, in ft/min, is:
RC = (33000 P) / W – RS equation (15)
where P is engine horsepower, is propeller efficiency, W is airplane weight in pounds, and Rs is airplane power off sink rate in ft/min.
Some aircraft operations handbooks give a power off glide ratio and speed, from which a sink rate can be calculated. The sink rate calculated using these values is not the same as is obtained when operating at best rateof-climb speed and propeller rpm. The best power off glide condition for an airplane with a variable pitch propeller is obtained with the propeller at low rpm (i.e., a blade pitch angle that provides minimum drag, and usually at an airspeed that is higher than that for best rate-of-climb). Note that in equation (14), if thrust is zero in glide, then the sine of the glide angle is just equal to the ratio of the drag to lift coefficients. For best glide distance this ratio will be lower than the ratio obtained during takeoff climb. For example, for the airplane in Example 1, the aircraft operations handbook states that the airplane will glide 1.7 nautical miles while losing 1000 ft in height, at an airspeed, V, of 105 knots. The glide angle, g, is calculated by observing that its tangent is given by the ratio of the height lost to the distance traveled. Thus:
g = –tan-1[1000 / (1.7 × 6076.1)] = –5.53° equation (16)
In this mode of operation CD/CL is equal to the sine of 5.53°, or 0.0964. In the calculation above, it was found that CD/CL was 0.1222 for takeoff with the propeller operated at maximum rpm.
The rate of sink in takeoff configuration can be obtained by conducting glide tests at the speed for best rate-ofclimb with the propeller at high rpm. The time required to lose a fixed altitude, 1000 ft or more, while holding constant airspeed, will give a sink rate that can be used in equation (15). At 90 kt and high rpm, the sink rate for the example airplane is approximately 1125 ft/m.
Propulsive efficiency, that is the product of propeller efficiency and installed power, can be calculated from equation (15) by using this sink rate, in conjunction with the flight manual value for climb rates at a given weight. Once these factors have been obtained, the climb rate at a different weight can be calculated, and this, coupled with the new climb speed, will allow the climb angle to be computed as in Example 1.
In Example 1 the best rate-of-climb was 970 ft/min at sea level at a weight of 3000 lb. Substituting these values into equation (15), along with the sink rate of 1125 ft/min, gives a product of propeller efficiency and horsepower, for this airplane, of 190. With no change in horsepower or propeller efficiency, substituting these values in equation (15) gives an equation for rate-of-climb at any weight, W:
RC = (6.285 × 106 / W) – 1125 ft/m
At a weight of 3200 lb, the rate-of-climb becomes 839 ft/m. At an airspeed of 93 kt, the climb angle is given by:
= sin-1 [839 / (101.3 × 93)] = 5.11°
Method 3:
An empirical expression for calculating the rate-of-climb, RC(2), at one weight, W(2), when the rate-of-climb, RC(1), at a different weight, W(1), is known is given by:
RC(2) = RC(1) [W(1) / W(2)]1.5 equation (17)
Substituting 3000 lb for W(1), 3200 lb for W(2), and 970 ft/m for RC(1), RC(2) is calculated to be 880 ft/m. In turn, climb angle by this method is given by:
= sin-1 [880 / (101.3 × 93)] = 5.36°
Reference height for the 3200 lb takeoff weight can now be calculated with each of the three rate-of-climb values by using the equation:
HM = 50 + (8200 – D50M) × tan (
From the rate-of-climb of Method 1:
HM = 50 + (8200 – 2526) tan (5.29°) = 575 ft
From the rate-of-climb of Method 2:
HM = 50 + (8200 – 2526) tan (5.11°) = 557 ft
From the rate-of-climb of Method 3:
HM = 50 + (8200 – 2526) tan (5.36°) = 582 ft
The modest discrepancies among the three calculated values are related to the erroneous assumption that the ratio of propeller efficiency to airspeed is essentially constant. To be conservative, the lower value for HM may be used in the analysis, or alternatively, the average of the three methods, 571 ft.
Step 2. Calculate reference Mach number.
Speed of sound at height h = 571 ft, from equations (3) and (4) is:
cM = 1114.4 ft/s at 571 ft above sea level
b) Air density ratio at 571 ft is given by equations (5-7):
= 0.97954 / 0.99614 = 0.98334
c) Best rate-of-climb speed of 93.0 kt at sea level becomes true airspeed at 571 ft of:
VTAS = 93 / 0.983341/2 = 93.8 kt
d) Airplane Mach number at 93.8 kt is:
MM = (1.688 × 93.8) / 1114.4 = 0.1421
e) Propeller rotational Mach number is given by equation (10):
MRM = 0.8551
f) Helical tip Mach number is given by the square root of the sum of the squares of the airplane and propeller rotational Mach numbers.
MhM = [(0.1421)2 + (0.8551)2]1/2 = 0.8668
Step 3. Reference horsepower remains essentially constant.
Step 4. Calculate the increment in noise level under part 36 Appendix G operating conditions when the airplane is operated at a weight of 3200 lb instead of at 3000 lb, without further changes.
a) Increase in noise level due to decrease in height from 690 ft to 571 ft:
H = 22 log (690 / 571) = 1.81 dB
b) Increase in noise level due to increase in helical Mach number:
From Example 1, Mh = 0.8666.
M = 150 log (0.8668 / 0.8666) = 0.02 dB
Note.— Use of “150” for a “k” factor in the tip mach correction is restricted for use only when the Modified mach number is higher than the Parent mach number. Only an approved “k” determined experimentally for the particular propeller airplane combination may be used when the Modified configuration is lower than the Parent.
c) Change in noise level due to change of inflow angle:
In Example 1 the climb angle (γP) was 6.11° with an assumed pitch angle (P) of 4.25°. Using the average climb angle (γM) obtained from the three methods described above, 5.25° with an assumed pitch angle (M) of 3.00°. Tests conducted by FAA under controlled conditions in a wind tunnel show that for typical small propeller airplane, sound levels increase as climb angle increases due to the change in air-inflow angle to the propeller. On average an increase of 0.5 dB per degree increase of inflow angle was observed in the tests then, the change due to climb angle is given by
= 0.5 (M – P) = 0.5 (3.00° – 4.25°) = –0.63 dB equation (18)
d) Total change in noise level:
The total change in noise level, L, is the algebraic sum of the three adjustments.
L = 1.81 + 0.02 – 0.63 = 1.21 dB
Clearly, a substantial acoustical change is created if the weight for this airplane is increased to 3200 lb without any other change to the engine/ propeller installation or other operating conditions. Once it has been determined that an acoustical change has occurred the applicant must develop new noise levels for the modified airplane. This may mean a full part 36 Appendix G noise test must be conducted. If the original data used to determine the aircraft noise levels is available to the applicant then additional adjustments might be made (if within limits) to create new noise levels. The noise levels published in the AFM (if available) CANNOT be adjusted using these calculations.
(4.2) Change from fixed to variable pitch propeller
If no other change is made to the airplane, such as increasing horsepower, the primary effect of changing from a fixed to variable pitch propeller of the same diameter is a change in Mach number. Typically, fixed pitch propellers are designed to operate optimally under cruise conditions where the propeller is designed to reach its maximum continuous rated rpm. During climb at the speed for best rate-of-climb the propeller cannot develop anywhere near its maximum rpm. Typically, takeoff rpm is approximately 85 percent of maximum rpm. For example a 150 hp engine having a maximum propeller rpm of 2700 will develop about 2300 rpm at takeoff. A 235 hp engine with a maximum rated rpm of 2575 typically develops about 2200 rpm in takeoff climb.
One of the primary reasons for changing from a fixed to variable pitch propeller is to shorten takeoff distance and to improve takeoff climb rate. An examination of aircraft operations handbooks for airplanes certified with both fixed and variable pitch propellers, at the same horsepower and takeoff weight, indicates the following nominal characteristics:
a) takeoff distances to a height of 50 ft with variable pitch propellers are approximately 88-90 percent of
the distance required with a fixed pitch propeller; and
b) at the same takeoff weight and airspeed, the rate-of-climb with a variable pitch propeller is approximately
9-10 percent greater than with a fixed pitch propeller.
The incremental difference in noise level between an airplane equipped with a variable pitch propeller and a fixed pitch propeller can be estimated by using the same adjustment equations used before for height, Mach number, engine power, and climb angle.
Example 2: The aircraft operations handbook for a representative fixed gear airplane with a takeoff weight of 2900 lb has the following performance data with fixed and variable pitch propellers:
Fixed Variable Takeoff distance, ft 1510 1350 Rate-of-climb, 825 900 ft/min Climb speed, Vy, kt 87 87 Propeller diameter, 80 80 in. Propeller rpm in 2200 2575 climb
Using the equations provided in Section 4.1 above, the following calculated quantities are obtained:
Reference height, ft 679 753 Climb angle, 5.37 5.86 degrees Inflow angle (est.), 5.25 6.15 degrees Speed of sound, ft/s 1113.9 1113.6 True airspeed, kt 87.9 88.0 Airplane Mach 0.1332 0.1334 number Rotational Mach 0.6894 0.8072 number Helical Mach 0.7021 0.8181 number
The difference in engine horsepower developed with the two propellers in climb can be calculated by using equation (15) to write two equations for the rate-of-climb in terms of horsepower and sink rate, since the sink rate is the same and thus the only difference in rate-of-climb in the two situations is the actual propulsive power. For the fixed pitch case:
825 = (33000Pf) / 2900 – Rs
For the variable pitch case:
900 = (33000Pv) / 2900 – Rs
Subtracting the first equation from the second results in a difference of about 7 horsepower. The nominal maximum continuous power for the engine is 235.
All the information necessary to calculate the difference in noise levels between the two propeller installations is now available. The difference in the noise levels for the two cases is the algebraic sum of the following adjustments:
a) Decrease in noise level due to increase in reference height:
H = 22 log (679/753) = –0.99 dB
b) Increase in noise level due to increase in helical Mach number:
M = 150 log (0.8181 / 0.7021) = 9.96 dB
c) Increase in noise level due to increase in engine power:
The rated maximum continuous power for the engine is 235 horsepower. The incremental change in noise level is approximately:
P = 17 log [(235+7)/(235)] = 0.22 dB
d) Increase in noise level due to increase in inflow angle:
= 0.5 × (4.15°–3.25°) = 0.45 dB
e) Total change in noise level:
L = –0.99 + 9.96 + 0.22 + 0.45 = 9.64 dB
Clearly, an acoustical change exists between the fixed and variable pitch propeller installations unless some other changes are made to the airplane.
(4.3) Change in propeller diameter
Calculating the effect on Appendix G noise level of changing propeller diameter without any other change in power or performance is a straightforward application of the following equation:
M= k log (MM/MP)
where k equals a constant dependent on the propeller design and Mach number range. A nominal value of 150 is permitted in G36.201 of part 36 if MP is smaller than MM (Parent and Modified respectively).
Although a change in propeller diameter will usually also change performance, if it can be shown that no degradation in takeoff distance or climb performance is created, the airplane performance before the change can be stipulated as the performance after the change. It is clear that an increase in diameter, considered alone, will increase the noise level. It is sometimes desirable to increase propeller diameter to improve climb performance, sometimes at the sacrifice of some cruise capability. The increased noise level caused by the greater diameter can be offset by a reduction in rpm, if the resulting airplane performance is satisfactory. Where this method is used to show "no acoustical change," it will be necessary to perform FAA approved takeoff and climb tests to verify
performance. The following two examples illustrate the effect that changes in propeller diameter have on the noise level.
Example 3: The airplane in Examples 1 and 2 is normally equipped with a two-blade propeller having an 84 inch diameter. The same propulsive efficiency is claimed when using the same engine, same propeller rpm, if the propeller is replaced with a propeller of 86 inches diameter. For the same reference height and airplane speed, the difference in noise level between the two installations may be calculated as follows. In Examples 1 and 2, the airplane Mach number was 0.1378 and the propeller rotational Mach number was 0.8556 for an 84 inch diameter propeller. For the same altitude and rpm, the rotational Mach number is directly proportional to the propeller diameter, so the rotational Mach number for the 86 inch diameter propeller is 86/84 times 0.8556, or 0.8760. The corresponding Parent and Modified helical Mach numbers before the change and after the change become 0.8666 and 0.8868. The noise level difference is:
M = 150 log (0.8868 / 0.8666) = 1.50 dB
If the new propeller has three blades, which would cause a shift in the blade passage frequency, the above analysis would not be adequate to determine the entire effect of the change. The analysis would have to be extended to account for the noise delta caused by the ground reflections and A-weighing filter effects, or flyover tests would have to be conducted.
Example 4: An applicant wishes to replace an existing variable pitch propeller with a diameter of 76 inches for a different pitched propeller with a diameter of 80 inches. The new propeller is designed to provide a somewhat shorter takeoff distance and better rate-of-climb for the airplane. The applicant does not want to go to the trouble of determining the improvement in takeoff distance or climb rate, and is willing to use the existing handbook data to determine reference height.
The applicant has demonstrated to the FAA that, in flight during reference climb conditions, his existing propeller develops 2600 rpm. He believes that, even with a modest limitation on climb rpm to negate the increase in noise level that a larger diameter propeller would normally generate, the larger propeller will still be advantageous. The rpm limitation that would have to be imposed for "no acoustical change" to result, assuming the reference height of 700 ft and true airspeed of 74 kt do not change and the propeller tip shape and thickness are identical, is determined as follows.
Since the airplane climb speed remains the same, the helical Mach number will be the same if the rotational Mach numbers for the two propellers are held constant. The actual reference height and airspeeds are not relevant to this determination. It is not even necessary to calculate the actual Mach numbers, since the rotational Mach numbers will be the same if the products of propeller diameter and rpm remain constant for the two cases. For the original 76 inch propeller, the product is 76 times 2600 or 197,600. The rpm limitation with an 80 inch propeller is therefore 197,600 divided by 80, or 2470 rpm. If this rpm gives satisfactory takeoff and climb performance, limiting climb rpm to 2470 will result in no acoustical change when the larger propeller is installed. Other airworthiness considerations (e.g., engine cooling, stalling, etc.) may need further consideration.
(4.4) Change in engine power
Increasing the size of an engine without changing the takeoff weight of an airplane will change the Appendix G noise level. If no change in performance were involved, the level would increase by 17 times the logarithm of the ratio of the increased horsepower to the original horsepower. However, clearly a change in performance does take place. Takeoff distance is shortened, and climb rate is increased. Often, but not always, a propeller change is also made. If the increase in performance offsets the effect on noise level of the change in engine horsepower, no acoustical change occurs. The following example illustrates the required analysis.
Example 5: The airplane in Example 1 is originally equipped with an engine rated at 225 horsepower at 2600 rpm. The desired installation is for an engine rated at 250 horsepower at 2650 rpm. The same 84 inch two-blade propeller is used in each case. The acoustical effect of this change is evaluated as follows.
Step 1. If propeller efficiency remains the same, takeoff distance varies inversely with engine power and directly as the square of takeoff weight. The takeoff distance to 50 ft height after the increase in horsepower, D50M, without any weight increase, is the original takeoff distance, D50P, times the ratio of the original horsepower to the increased horsepower:
D50M = D50P × (HPP/HPM) ft
In this example:
D50M = 2220 (225) / (250) = 1998 ft
Note.— This is an approximation and the final determination for no acoustical change must use FAA approved data from the AFM or the AFMS for the modified airplane. If the applicant chooses not to take credit for (and thus determine per FAA flight test guidelines) the improved takeoff distance, they cannot take credit for the decrease in distance in the acoustical change determination.
Step 2. From equation (15), rate-of-climb for a given airplane configuration is directly proportional to the ratio of engine power to airplane weight, minus the power off sink rate. The constant of proportionality is the unit conversion factor of 33,000 times the propeller efficiency. In Example 1, the product of propeller horsepower developed in climb is less than the rated horsepower due to installation effects and air density less than at sea level. It can be assumed that the same ratio of losses will apply to a slightly higher rated horsepower engine. Assuming these losses cancel each other out, the apparent propeller efficiency for Example 1 can be stated as the propulsive efficiency, 190, divided by the rated horsepower, 225, for an apparent efficiency of 0.844. Equation (15) can then be used to determine the rate-of-climb at the increased horsepower:
RCM = (33000) (0.844) (250) / 3000 – 1125 = 1197 ft/m
Step 3. Climb angle is given by:
= sin-1 [RC / (1.688 × 60 × Vy)]
M = sin-1[1197/(101.3)(90)] = 7.55°
Step 4. The reference height after the change, HM, is:
HM = 50 + (8200–1998) tan (7.55) = 872 ft
Step 5. Determine reference helical Mach number:
a) At 872 ft the speed of sound is:
cP = 1113.2 ft/s
True airspeed is calibrated airspeed divided by the square root of the density ratio:
P= 0.97472
b) Best rate-of-climb speed of 90 kt at sea level becomes a true airspeed at 872 ft of:
VTAS = 90 / 0.97472 1/2 = 91.2 kt
c) Airplane Mach number at 91.2 kt is:
M = (1.688 × 91.2) / 1113.2 = 0.1383
d) Propeller rotational Mach number is:
MR = 0.8725
e) Helical tip Mach number is:
Mh = [(0.1383)2+ (0.8725)2]1/2 = 0.8834
Step 6. Reference horsepower is now 250.
Step 7. Calculate the increment in noise level under part 36 Appendix G operating conditions:
a) Change in noise level due to increase in height:
From Example 1, HP = 690 ft, and from above HM = 872 ft.
H = 22 log (690 / 872) = –2.24 dB
b) Increase in noise level due to increase in helical Mach number:
From Example 2, Mh = 0.8666:
M = 150 log (0.8834 / 0.8666) = 1.25 dB
c) Increase in noise level due to increase in horsepower:
P = 17 log (250 / 225) = 0.78 dB
d) Change in noise level due to change in inflow angle:
In Example 1 the inflow angle was 6.11 degrees with an assumed inflow angle of 4.25°. From equation (18):
= 0.5 × (4.25°–3.11°) = 0.57 dB
e) Total change in noise level:
The total change in noise level, L, is the algebraic sum of the four adjustments.
L = –2.24 + 1.25 + 0.78 + 0.57 = 0.36 dB
The change in noise level due to an increase in horsepower, in this example, is not offset by the effect of improved takeoff performance, resulting in an "acoustical change" of 0.36 decibel. In order to become an NAC situation, some change in rating should take place. A small reduction in allowable takeoff rpm might be reasonable. Several iterations of the above calculations might be necessary to determine the optimum conditions. Any changes in performance where credit is being claimed must be FAA approved, determined using FAA approved methods,
and published in the FAA approved AFM or AFMS (e.g., improved climb rates, shorter takeoff distances, change in Vy, etc.). Additional airworthiness criteria may need to be reestablished.
(4.5) Increase in drag with no other changes
Any modification to an airplane that increases its drag during takeoff and initial climb will increase the Appendix G noise level unless other changes are also introduced. If takeoff distance is increased, or rate-of-climb decreased, or both, the reference height will decrease. The change in level can be calculated from the adjustment equations provided previously if the change in performance can be determined. If an applicant wants to show compliance with the noise regulation via the NAC method, they will probably have to conduct takeoff distance and climb tests. If it looks as though the proposed modification will increase drag sufficiently to make a measurable performance change, then an offsetting change will be required. The amounts of increase or decrease in noise level involved can be calculated by the methods use in the previous examples.
(4.6) Acoustical effects of combined changes
Many proposed airplane modifications involve several changes. Examples are replacing an engine and fixed pitch propeller with a higher power engine and a variable pitch propeller, or increasing engine power and takeoff weight at the same time. The acoustical consequences of these combined effects can be calculated by combining the methods used in the examples. The sequence for calculating these effects is as follows:
a) Determine the effect changes in takeoff distance and rate-of-climb will have on reference height.
b) Determine the effect of helical Mach number caused by any changes in airplane speed, propeller
rotational speed, or change in speed of sound because of change in reference height.
Note.— The default value of 150 for “k” in the correction equations is only valid when used to determine an increase in helical mach number. It CANNOT be used to reduce the noise level. The 150 factor is a generalized conservative value for simplified calculations where the true “k” value is not determined. Thus it is inherently inaccurate.
c) Determine the effect of any changes in engine power.
d) Determine any change in noise level due to change in airplane climb angle.
e) Obtain the algebraic sum of the four incremental changes in sound level.
f) If the sum is greater than zero, there are two choices:
— Conduct Appendix G tests as described in the regulation; or
— Evaluate different operating conditions to obtain an incremental noise level that is not greater than
that of the original airplane. This may be accomplished by derating the engine, reducing fuel/payload, and/or limiting maximum takeoff rpm. One or a combination of these modifications may be iterated until a negative noise increment is obtained by the methods used in the examples. The cost of not performing an Appendix G noise test should be balanced against the loss of airplane performance or takeoff weight limitations during the lifetime of operation.
101(f) Acquisition of In-duct and/or Near-field Data for Demonstration of NAC
(1) General
The FAA has found it acceptable for applicants to conduct engine or component only noise tests to evaluate minor engine changes. Frequently the objective for these tests is to provide evidence that the changes involved produce
negligible impact on EPNL noise values and may therefore be categorized as NACs relative to the certificated aircraft configuration. Such testing includes component tests, static engine tests in a test cell, near-field microphone measurements, and in-duct dynamic pressure measurements.
(2) Guiding principles
The overall guiding principles to be followed in providing acceptable evidence for substantiation of engine NACs are:
a) the measurements and analyses should adequately model the noise such that small changes in aircraft
noise levels can be quantified; and
b) the noise measurement technique and the test environment should not introduce changes to the noise
sources that invalidate the predicted small changes in aircraft noise levels.
These guiding principles should be applied in all cases, with details of the approach being justified on a case-bycase basis as appropriate.
Note 1.— It is important that the near-field or in-duct measurements enable a sufficiently accurate prediction of the changes to engine noise in the far field.
Note 2.— It is important that the noise-generating mechanisms of interest are not significantly affected by the test cell environment. The test cell should have an exhaust collector to minimize re-circulation. There should be insignificant inlet distortion or inflow turbulence, or a turbulence control screen or ICD should be employed to minimize such distortions or turbulence. Test cell measurements might not be appropriate for assessing jet noise changes because of the influence of the test cell on the jet development.
Note 3.— Care must be taken to ensure the noise source under investigation is not masked by other unrepresentative noise components. While a reduced acoustic standard of components not under investigation might be acceptable in many cases, there are examples where such differences might invalidate the premise of an NAC (e.g., noise from the intake being masked by a hard-walled bypass duct, or significant noise from an overboard air dump contaminating the measured noise).
(3) Measurement systems
Typical measurement systems used to acquire data for substantiation of an engine NAC include:
a) near-field microphones, either in test cells or outdoor facilities;
b) in-duct transducer measurements in the fan inlet or exhaust duct; and
c) core probes to assess combustor or low pressure turbine design changes.
4) Measurement and data analysis procedures
The measurement and data analysis process should be accomplished on the basis of the following criteria:
a) an adequate array of transducers should be used to ensure that the measurements adequately model the
noise (To determine overall changes in sound pressure level, the measured noise levels will typically need to be averaged azimuthally, radially and/or axially in order to avoid false conclusions being drawn from anomalous readings from single transducers.);
b) environmental conditions in the test setup should be monitored to demonstrate that the local environment
(e.g., test cell temperature) do not cause significant anomalies in the measured noise differences;
c) microphones should be mounted on the test cell wall or on the ground or floor but not in the shadow of
any support structures or other test hardware;
d) in-duct transducers should be flush-mounted with minimal loss of area of acoustic treatment. Rake-
mounted transducers in the flow path should be avoided if they shed wakes that impinge on downstream structures and thereby create significant noise;
e) core probes should be fixed securely to the pylon, boat-tail fairing or other support and not be excessively
buffeted by the flow;
f) the specifications of the measurement system and calibration procedures for microphones, recording and reproducing systems should be in accordance with A36.3 of part 36 (Laboratory calibrations of in-duct transducers and core probes should be conducted before and, if possible, after each test. The dynamic range of the transducers should be sufficient to avoid overload.);
g) data should be acquired over the relevant engine operating speeds and for all relevant combinations of
engine variables, as specified in the latest version of Reference T13;
h) the interpretation of in-duct measurements should take into account the possibility that decaying or cut
off acoustic waves may be present that may mask changes sensed in the far field of the propagating wave; and
i) two alternative methods could be used in the subsequent analysis of the measured noise levels to demonstrate an NAC:
1) the measured component noise changes could be incorporated into a noise model that predicts the aircraft EPNL. This method has the added value of taking into account in-flight effects and the relative significance of the different noise sources; or
2) in some circumstances, it might be possible to reach the conclusion of an NAC without the need to incorporate the measured component noise changes into a noise model that predicts aircraft EPNL. The measured noise changes could be examined to see if there is no increase in noise levels at any relevant frequency or engine condition.
Generally, noise models that predict the aircraft noise level expressed in EPNL are based on far-field static test data. Consequently, in either analysis it will be necessary to agree with the FAA on the method for calculating the impact on far-field static noise resulting from near-field microphone measurements or in-duct transducer measurements. This will normally require sound engineering judgment, seeking out patterns in the data and technical explanations for any observed differences.
Furthermore the statistical uncertainty in the data should be considered. For example if statistical analysis shows that the uncertainty in the data is large and the differences are small, then no conclusions can be drawn from the data. On the other hand if the tests show large decreases in noise levels that outweigh the uncertainty in the data it may be possible to conclude, with reasonable certainty, that the changed engine is indeed quieter than the original engine.
Chapter 2
NOISE STANDARDS: AIRCRAFT TYPE AND AIRWORTHINESS
CHAPTER TABLE OF CONTENTS
201 EXPLANATORY INFORMATION … 32 201(a) Part 36 - Subpart A - General … 32 201(a)(1) Applicability and definitions … 32 201(a)(2) Aircraft configuration … 34 201(a)(3) Voluntary changes … 34 201(a)(4) Airworthiness certificates … 36 201(a)(5) Airworthiness certificates … 36 201(a)(6) One-Stage limit … 36 201(a)(7) Stage 1/ Stage 2 limits … 37 201(a)(8) Date of application … 37 201(a)(9) Airworthiness compatibility … 38 201(a)(10) Limitations of part … 38 201(a)(11) Configuration consistency … 39 201(a)(12) Dual stage certification … 39 201(a)(13) Exempt helicopter modifications … 39 201(a)(14) Helicopter compliance with part 36 … 39 201(a)(15) Noise limits … 40 201(a)(16) Stage 2 helicopters … 40 201(b) Subpart B- Transport Category Large Airplanes and Jet Airplanes … 40 201(b)(1) Noise measurement and evaluation … 40 201(b)(2) Noise measurement constraints … 41 201(b)(3) Flight manual statement of Chapter 4 equivalency … 42 201(c) Subpart H – Helicopters … 42 201(c)(1) Noise limits … 42 201(d) Subpart 0 – Operating Limitations; and Information … 43 201(d)(1) Procedures, noise levels, and other information … 44 201(d)(2) Non-flight test data … 50 201(d)(3) Manuals, markings and placards … 50 201(d)(4) Supplemental information … 53 201(d)(5) Index of acceptability … 53 201(d)(6) Airplane limitations … 53 201(d)(7) Non-complying agricultural and fire fighting airplanes … 54 201(d)(8) Operating limitations … 54
201 EXPLANATORY INFORMATION
201(a) Part 36 - Subpart A - General
201(a)(1) Applicability and definitions §36.1(a)
(1) Applicable requirements
Unless otherwise specified, the date to be used for determining the applicability of the appropriate part 36 standards for an aircraft type design is the date on which application for a type certificate was made. An application for type certification is effective for the time periods specified in §21.17(c) of part 21.
(2) Noise related type certification requirements
See paragraph 7-8 of Reference G4.
(3) Supplemental type certificates
See paragraph 7-8 of Reference G4.
(4) Definitions of terms
Section 4 of the preamble of this AC provides definitions of terms (see Table 2) related to the aircraft types and categories within Items (1) – (4) of §36.1(a).
Table 2. Aircraft terminology and categories
AIRCRAFT TERMINOLOGY AIRCRAFT TERMINOLOGY
Aircraft Large Aircraft Airplane Small Aircraft Jet Airplane Turboprop Airplane (Note 3)
Propeller
AIRCRAFT CATEGORIES (Note 1) AIRCRAFT CATEGORIES (Note 1)
Airplane Helicopter Acrobatic Normal Commuter Transport Normal Primary Restricted (Note 2)
Transport
Utility
Note 1.— Airplane Categories and Aircraft Classes: Part 1 recognizes a distinction between Airplane Categories (e.g., acrobatic, commuter, normal, primary, restricted, transport and utility) and Aircraft Classes (e.g., Conventional Takeoff and Landing (CTOL), Vertical Takeoff and Landing (VTOL), Short Takeoff and Landing (STOL), Reduced Takeoff and Landing (RTOL), and Supersonic Transports (SST)). The noise certification requirements contained in part 36 are specified for several Airplane and Helicopter Categories but not for STOL, RTOL, SST (except for Concorde), or VTOL Aircraft Classes.
Note 2.— Restricted Category Propeller-Driven Large Airplanes: Propeller-driven large airplanes that have been type certificated in the restricted category (see §21.25 of part 21) are not required to demonstrate compliance with the requirements of part 36. In the absence of part 36 applicability, an Environmental Assessment is required (see paragraph 7-4 of Reference G4 for additional information).
Note 3.— Turboprop Airplanes: Turboprop-powered airplanes are included under the part 36 requirements applicable to propeller-driven airplanes (i.e., subsonic transport category large airplanes; propeller-driven small airplanes, including acrobatic, normal, restricted, and transport categories; or propeller-driven
201(a)(2) Aircraft configuration §36.1(b)
An applicant’s proposal for an aircraft configuration to be certified under the requirements of part 36 must include any type design changes that may be a result of airworthiness standards testing and analysis, and which would result in acoustical changes. (See §36.1(c) for FAA criteria on when aircraft type design changes represent an acoustical change). If an applicant does not propose the appropriate aircraft configuration, additional noise certification testing and analysis may be required.
201(a)(3) Voluntary changes §36.1(c)
(1) Examples of voluntary changes in type design
A voluntary change in the configuration of an aircraft means a change in the type design of that aircraft. Examples of voluntary changes in aircraft type design that may affect part 36 certificated noise levels are as follows:
a) increased engine thrust (power) to improve aircraft performance;
b) maximum gross weight changes;
c) limitations on operational flap settings related to noise;
d) hardware revisions (e.g., vortex generators, flap configuration, wing tip stabilizers, wing tip fuel tanks,
etc.);
e) engine modifications to improve engine performance, acceleration, deceleration, or surge margin
protection;
f) addition of wing or body hardware to improve aerodynamics;
g) external nacelle changes to improve air flow patterns;
h) engine inlet changes to improve ice protection;
i) reduction of engine blade tip clearances to improve inlet flow characteristics, and;
j) modifications to engine/nacelle acoustic treatments.
(2) Acoustical change criteria
A voluntary change in the type design of an aircraft that may result in an increase in its certificated noise levels is defined as an “acoustical change.” A type design change that does not result in an “acoustical change” as defined in section§21.93(b) of part 21 is referred to as a “no acoustical change” (NAC). The numerical criteria used by the FAA in defining an acoustical change for airplanes and helicopters are provided in 101(d) and (e) of this AC and are established to limit the cumulative effects of multiple small changes.
(3) NAC cumulative effects
When type design changes result in reduced noise levels, an applicant may elect not to provide the full part 36 substantiation, but instead provide FAA with data and/or information to substantiate an NAC. However subsequent type design changes may require full part 36 certification because of cumulative acoustical effects. Example: An applicant proposes a configuration change which will reduce the noise levels by approximately 2.1 dB for the flyover noise measurement point, 1.1 dB for the lateral noise measurement point, and with no
change in noise level at the approach noise measurement point. FAA verifies that the noise levels were reduced, and the applicant accepts the pre-change configuration certificated noise levels as published in the AFM to apply to this change in type design. The applicant may not make another type design change as an NAC that increases the flyover noise level and the lateral noise level without providing substantiation of the cumulative effects of this type design change on AFM noise certificated levels. Multiple type design changes must be evaluated on a cumulative basis (as a combined single configuration) for each noise measurement point for the purposes of determining whether there is an acoustical change.
(4) NAC approvals
FAA may approve results of component laboratory demonstrations, back to-back noise comparisons from ground tests or flight tests of each configuration, acoustical analyses, etc as acceptable for substantiating that an applicant’s proposed changes to an aircraft type design is an NAC. The results from these evaluations must be applicable to an aircraft’s certificated noise levels at the part 36 reference noise measurement points.
(5) Non-standard jet airplane configurations
Sections 21.93(b)(2)(i) and (ii) specify exceptions under which certain changes in jet airplane type design are not subject to compliance with part 36 requirements because such configurations are not intended for normal operations, but are typically required for maintenance operations (e.g., ferry flights, transporting engines to aircraft that cannot be ferried, etc.).
(6) Time-limited changes
Time-Limited engine or nacelle changes on jet airplanes for periods of up to 90 days (as specified in §21.93(b)(2)(iii) of part 21) may be necessary for continued airplane operation until maintenance can be performed on the original engines or nacelles that were changed. These changes must comply with applicable airworthiness standards and the maintenance, preventative maintenance, rebuilding and alteration inspection requirements of part 43. Such changes do not require compliance with part 36 requirements even though they may result in an increase in airplane noise levels, relative to the certificated noise levels. FAA policy (see Federal Register Vol. 64, No. 225, Page 65655, dated November 23, 1999) permits the 90 day period allowed by §21.93(b)(2)(iii)of part 21 to continue to be used after December 31, 1999, but only for maintenance-related purposes. It cannot be used for meeting Stage 3 requirements due to lack of an adequate number of spare engines or nacelles, or insufficient number of engines or nacelles to operate a Stage 3 fleet at a given time. Section 21.93(b)(2)(iii) may only be used to intermix engines when maintenance is required and no conforming engine or nacelle for the configuration is available.
(7) Special purpose aircraft
Type design changes to propeller-driven small airplanes and helicopters do not need to comply with the provisions of part 36 when they are operated for special purposes as specified in §§21.93(b)(3)(i-iv) and §21.93(b)(4) of part 21.
(8) Applicant’s responsibility
Pursuant to §21.93(b), an applicant must identify type design changes that affect an aircraft’s certificated noise levels by aircraft serial number and must demonstrate part 36 compliance for those aircraft. The noise levels approved by the FAA for the modified aircraft must be documented in an FAA Approved AFM or RFM by either a revision to the AFM or RFM (typically an option only available to the aircraft manufacturer), an AFM or RFM Supplement (for Supplemental Type Certificates and Field Approvals), or a Supplemental AFM or RFM (for aircraft that do not have a FAA Approved AFM or RFM). Configurations and modifications for which noise approval is required must be found to comply with applicable airworthiness requirements specified in part 21 as well as the requirements of §36.3 of part 36.
201(a)(4) Airworthiness certificates §36.1(d)
(1) Requirements for Issuance of Airworthiness Certificates
An airworthiness certificate is issued for each airplane produced, and is a means of distinguishing (by date of issuance) airplanes within a production run that comply with the noise certification requirements of part 36. Prior to the original issuance of a standard airworthiness certificate (see §21.183 of part 21) and regardless of the date of application for certification, compliance with the regulatory requirements of part 36 (including Appendix B) is required for a transport category large airplane, or for a jet airplane regardless of category (see paragraph 7-11(a) of Reference G4). The following table summarizes the requirements of §36.1(d) of part 36.
Table 3. Requirements of §36.1(d) of part 36
Maximum Airplane
Weight
Airplane
Type
Engine Configuration Effective Date of
Compliance Date for Airplanes With
Initial Flight Time
on or After 75,000 pounds or less Subsonic All engines December 1, 1969 December 31, 1974 Greater than 75,000 Subsonic Without Pratt &Whitney JT3D engines
December 1, 1969 December 1, 1973
Greater than 75,000 Subsonic With Pratt & Whitney JT3D engines
December 1, 1969 December 31, 1974
Concorde – all weights
Supersonic All engines October 13, 1977 January 1, 1980
(2) “Grandfathered” airplanes
Airplane types not identified above are “grandfathered” airplanes and are permitted to continue normal operations without showing compliance with the requirements of part 36. For example, the twin-engine propeller-driven Convair 580 or Douglas DC-3 airplanes that first logged flight time before December 31, 1974, did not have to comply with the noise provisions of part 36 and may have received a standard airworthiness certificate under the provisions of §21.183 of part 21, or may have received a standard airworthiness certificate under the provisions of the regulations in effect at the time of certification without compliance with part 36.
201(a)(5) Airworthiness certificates §36.1(e)
(1) Requirements for issuance of airworthiness certificates:
An applicant must show compliance of individual airplanes with the requirements of part 36 prior to issuance of airworthiness certificates, as prescribed in §21.183 or 21.185 of part 21 (see paragraph 7-11 of Reference G4).
2) Commuter category airplanes:
Since airworthiness standards for commuter category airplanes became effective February 17, 1987, (under part 21, Amendment 21-59) there are no airplanes in this category with initial flight time before January 1, 1980. All commuter category airplanes are thus required to show compliance with the noise certification requirements of part 36.
201(a)(6) One-Stage limit §36.1(g)
(1) In-flight configuration changes:
In-flight changes in an airplane configuration (including changes in maximum gross weight) that could result in multiple certificated noise levels for a given noise measurement point or stage classification are not permitted. They are changes in the airplane type design and therefore require a change in operating limitations. A change in maximum gross weight requires an applicant to remove an airplane from service, and comply with the approval procedures of part 43.5 and 43.7. The type design approval procedures under part 21 must be followed if the change does not have prior certification approval.
201(a)(7) Stage 1/ Stage 2 limits §36.1(h)
(1) The Stage 1 noise limits apply to all helicopters for which application for a type certificate or a change in type
design was made prior to March 6, 1986.
(2) The Stage 2 noise levels apply to all helicopters for which application for a type certificate or a change in type
design is made on or after March 6, 1986, with the following exception. For helicopters for which application for issuance of an original type certificate in the normal, transport or restricted category is made on or after March 6, 1986, and which the FAA finds to be the first civil version of a helicopter which was designed and constructed for, and accepted for operational use by an Armed Force of the U.S. or the U.S. Coast Guard on or before March 6, 1986, it must be shown that the noise levels of the helicopter certificated under the provisions of Appendix H are no greater than Stage 2 levels plus 2 EPNdB at each measuring point. There is no corresponding provision under Appendix J. The tradeoff provision of H36.305(b) of part 36 may not be used to show compliance with Stage 2 levels plus 2 EPNdB, nor may they be used to increase any noise level beyond these limits. Subsequent civil versions (acoustical changes) must meet the Stage 2 requirements without the extra 2 EPNdB at each measuring point. The tradeoff provisions of H36.305(b) of part 36 may be used in showing stage 2 compliance for these subsequent versions.
(3) Helicopters excepted
Helicopters that are designated exclusively for agricultural aircraft operations, as defined in §137.3 of part 137, for dispensing firefighting materials, or for carrying external loads, as defined in §133.1(b) of part 133, are excluded from the noise certification requirements.
(4) Stage 1/Stage 2
A helicopter, with a maximum takeoff weight of 7000 lb (3175 kg) or less, that fails to comply with the Stage 2 noise limit prescribed in J36.305 of part 36 has the alternative to comply with the Stage 2 noise limit of H36.305 of part 36.
Note.— The Appendix J noise limit uses a sound exposure level (SEL) that was defined more stringent by approximately 2 dB than the corresponding average of the three Appendix H noise limits in EPNL. However, this is no guarantee that subsequent Appendix H noise certification testing will comply, especially for a military helicopter seeking civil certification.
201(a)(8) Date of application §36.2
(1) Requirements
a) Section 36.2 specifies the applicable part 36 requirements to be those in effect on the date of application for
the a) aircraft type certificate or b) change in type design. If the time interval between application for the type certificate (or change in type design) and the issuance of the type certificate (or amended or supplemental
type certificate) exceeds 5 years, the applicable part 36 requirements are those in effect, on a date to be selected by the applicant, not earlier than 5 years before the date of issuance of the type certificate, amended type certificate, or supplemental type certificate.
b) Section 36.2(c) permits the applicant to elect to demonstrate compliance with a later part 36 standard than is
required by §36.2(a) or (b). For the purposes of §36.2, “standard” refers to any of the requirements contained in part 36. As specified in §§36.2(c)(1) and (2), an applicant’s election of a later standard is subject to FAA approval, and the election must include standards adopted between the date of application and the effective date of the standard that the applicant has elected to comply with. Thus, an applicant’s election to demonstrate compliance with a particular later standard would also require that compliance be demonstrated with all other part 36 standards (applicable to the aircraft type) adopted between the date of application and the effective date of the standard that the applicant has elected to comply with. Further, in accordance with §36.2(c)(3), the FAA may require compliance with other standards that were adopted after the date of the elected standard. For the purposes of §36.2(c)(3), “other standards” refers to other part 36 standards. For example, if the compliance standard elected under §36.2(c)(3) had later been revised, the FAA may determine that it is appropriate for compliance to be demonstrated with the revised standard. Such a determination would also require that compliance be demonstrated with all other part 36 standards (applicable to the aircraft type) adopted between the date of application and the effective date of the standard that the FAA has determined to be the appropriate compliance basis.
201(a)(9) Airworthiness compatibility §36.3
(1) Requirements
Aircraft certification tests and analyses must be conducted using configurations, procedures and information that are consistent with the airworthiness regulations applicable to that aircraft. For example, noise tests or analyses may not be conducted with landing flap settings that could not meet the applicable airworthiness regulation requirements.
201(a)(10) Limitations of part §36.5
Part 36 requires compliance with U.S. Government noise standards for aircraft type and airworthiness certification but does not include noise standards related to aircraft operations, such as is provided in part 91. Part 36 certificated noise levels are achieved using procedures that can be duplicated practicably in normal operations by flight crews with safe reserves of thrust (power) and speed. Public Law 103-272 (Reference G2), mandates that the Administrator of the FAA prescribe standards to measure and evaluate aircraft noise. Under this law, an original type certificate may be issued for an aircraft for which substantial noise abatement can be achieved only after the FAA Administrator prescribes standards and regulations that apply to that aircraft. Consideration must be given to relevant information on aircraft noise, consultations with appropriate US and State authorities, whether the standards or regulations are consistent with the highest degree of safety and are economically reasonable, technologically practical, and appropriate for the type of aircraft to which they apply.
(2) Compatability with ICAO Annex 16 Standards
Part 36 does not contain the Annex allowance to depart from the required reference procedures specified in Annex chapters. For example, §3.6.1.4 of Chapter 3 of Annex 16 permits the certificating authority to approve reference procedures that are different from those contained in §§ 3.6.2 and 3.6.3 of Annex 16, when design characteristics of an airplane would prevent flight from being conducted in accordance with §§ 3.6.2 and 3.6.3 of Annex 16. The FAA recognizes that there may be a need for changes to the specified reference procedures when part 36 may not be appropriate for a particular airplane when design characteristics of an airplane would prevent flight from being
conducted in accordance with the reference procedures described in part 36. In cases where part 36 is not appropriate, the rulemaking process, which includes a public comment period, would be followed to develop an appropriate noise certification standard. Thus, the main difference between the U.S. and ICAO requirements is that under part 36, the reference procedures would be changed through the rulemaking process rather than solely at the discretion of the certificating authority.
201(a)(11) Configuration consistency §36.7(c)
(1) Quietest airworthiness approved configuration
This requirement was established to show that an acoustical change resulting from an approved type design change must be determined consistently. The FAA policy does not require an applicant to determine the quietest airworthiness approved configuration at the flyover or lateral noise measurement points by noise measurement and evaluation. However, FAA requires consistent evaluations between derivative and originally certificated configurations. For example, an applicant might choose an approved takeoff flap setting of 5 degrees. Later a type design change may be requested that would increase the flyover and lateral noise levels (an acoustical change). The FAA may not require the applicant to measure and evaluate all airworthiness approved takeoff flap settings (e.g., 0, 1, 2, 5, 10 degrees) to determine the quietest configuration, but may, in this example, require appropriate evaluations for a flap setting of 5 degrees.
201(a)(12) Dual stage certification §36.7(e)
(1) “Dual-Stage” certificated airplanes
Some older airplane models have been certificated to Stage 2 for one configuration and to Stage 3 for another configuration (e.g., airplane takeoff flap setting or maximum allowable gross weights). These airplanes are classified as “Dual-Stage” certificated airplanes. No new dual certifications will be considered.
201(a)(13) Exempt helicopter modifications §36.11
Modifications excluded from compliance with part 36, as listed in part 21, §21.93(b)(4)(ii) “Classification of Changes in Type Design” include:
a) addition or removal of external equipment (This means any instrument, mechanism, part, apparatus,
appurtenance, or accessory that is attached to or extends from the helicopter exterior but is not used nor is intended to be used in operating or controlling a helicopter in flight and is not part of an airframe or engine.);
b) changes in the airframe made to accommodate the addition or removal to facilitate the use of external
equipment, to provide for an external load attaching means, to facilitate the safe operation of the helicopter with external equipment mounted to, or external loads carried by, the helicopter;
c) reconfiguration of the helicopter by the addition or removal of floats and skis;
d) flight with one or more doors and/or windows removed or in an open position; or
e) any changes in the operational limitations on the helicopter as a consequence of the addition or removal of
external equipment, floats, and skis, or flight operations with doors and/or windows removed or in an open position.
201(a)(14) Helicopter compliance with part 36 §36.11(a)
(1) Equivalent procedures
Subject to prior approval by the FAA, equivalent procedures may be used to measure, evaluate and calculate noise levels (see 1(c) of the preamble of this AC). Some commonly used equivalent procedures relating to helicopter noise certification are included in Chapters 4 and 6 of this AC.
(2) Noise level tradeoffs
Tradeoffs between the adjusted noise levels for flyover, takeoff and approach defined in H36.305(b) of part 36 may be used to show compliance with the maximum noise levels (noise limits) of Appendix H of part 36. Since Appendix J of part 36 only includes a flyover procedure, no tradeoff is possible.
(3) Compliance
The procedure used to show compliance under Appendix H or Appendix J of part 36 must follow the applicable parts of the regulation. Compliance with the maximum noise levels (noise limits) prescribed in H36.305 or J36.305 of part 36 must be shown.
201(a)(15) Noise limits §36.11(b)
(1) Stage 1 helicopters
The maximum noise levels (noise limits) associated with a Stage 1 helicopter certificated under Appendix H of part 36 after a change in type design are dependent on the noise levels of the original Stage 1 helicopter. Unless the Stage 1 helicopter after the change meets the Stage 2 maximum noise levels (noise limits), or Stage 2+ 2 EPNdB levels at each measurement point, it will be necessary to show that the helicopter has no increase in the noise levels at any of the measurement points. This will require determination of the noise levels associated with the original Stage 1 helicopter using Appendix H procedures. If this is not possible an applicant must obtain FAA approval for another procedure.
201(a)(16) Stage 2 helicopters §36.11(c)
(1) Helicopter under 7000 lb (3175 kg)
If after a change in type design a helicopter previously certificated under Appendix J of part 36, fails to meet the Appendix J Stage 2 maximum noise levels (noise limits) prescribed in J36.305 of part 36 an applicant may attempt to show compliance by electing the use of Appendix H procedures and the Appendix H Stage 2 maximum noise levels (noise limits) specified in H36.305 of part 36.
(2) Noise levels
Section 36.11 requirements apply to helicopters certificated under both Appendix H and Appendix J of part 36.
201(b) Subpart B- Transport Category Large Airplanes and Jet Airplanes
201(b)(1) Noise measurement and evaluation §36.101
(1) Appendix A
Appendix A prescribes methodologies for conducting airplane noise certification tests and for measurement and evaluation of noise data for comparison with maximum noise levels specified in Appendix B (see Note 1). Specific requirements include:
a) specifications of various physical and environmental conditions under which airplane noise certification
measurements are permitted; these conditions are related to the noise test site, wind velocity/direction and atmospheric sound attenuation;
b) procedures for measurement of atmospheric parameters;
c) methods for synchronization of airplane position and performance measurements with noise
measurements;
d) specifications for noise certification measurement and analysis systems (see Note 2);
e) methods to calculate atmospheric sound attenuation coefficients and effective perceived noise level (in
units of EPNdB);
f) methods for adjustment of measured flight test data to reference conditions;
g) nomenclature for symbols and units; and
h) specification of data to be reported to FAA.
Note 1.— Part 36 Appendix A requirements are nearly identical to those of Appendix 2 of Annex 16 Volume 1, Amendment 7. Subsequent changes to Annex 16 Volume 1 after Amendment 7 have not created any significant differences between the requirements of part 36 Appendix A and Annex 16 Volume 1 Appendix 2 at the time of publication of this AC.
Note 2.— Some provisions of Appendix A may also apply to the noise certification of helicopters as prescribed in Appendix H of part 36.
(2) Equivalent procedures
Equivalent Procedures are described in 1(c) of the introductory purpose section of this AC. Section 402 of this AC identifies several potential applications of equivalent procedures for jet and heavy prop airplanes. The ICAO ETM (Reference G5) also provides general and technical guidance on equivalent procedures that have been accepted as a technical means for demonstrating compliance with the noise certification requirements of ICAO Annex 16, Volume 1. Equivalent procedures provided in the ICAO ETM are incorporated into this AC to the extent applicable to the U.S. regulations.. FAA has not approved these procedures for any current or future aircraft noise certification actions. (See Supplemental Information Items in Subpart O, §1501, regarding the FAA’s approval process for equivalent procedures).
(3) Applicant’s responsibility
Applicants must prepare noise compliance demonstration plans for FAA approval that include proposed methods for compliance with the requirements of B36.1 of part 36. Equivalent procedure proposals in these plans must include substantiation of their technical validity and feasibility of application to the airplane type for which noise certification is requested. (See Subpart O §1501, Supplemental Information, of part 36 for noise compliance demonstration plan documentation requirements.)
201(b)(2) Noise measurement constraints §36.103(a)
(1) Noise measurement points
The locations of test noise measurement points frequently do not coincide with the reference noise measurement point locations specified in B36.3 of part 36. For example, locations of flyover noise measurement points may be subject to test site anomalies that would make it impractical to set up microphones at the reference locations. An applicant that has an approved equivalent procedure to measure airplane noise data for generation of NPD plots using the Flight Path Intercept procedure may select test noise measurement points (particularly the flyover point) so as to optimize the noise recording system signal-to-noise ratios.
(2) Equivalent procedures
The FAA does not consider equivalencies that modifies reference flight conditions (see 201(a)(10) paragraph 2 of this AC) without following public process.
(3) General approved flight test procedures, principles, methods and flight crew operational practices are included in
AC 25-7A, Flight Test Guide (Reference G3).
201(b)(3) Flight manual statement of Chapter 4 or Chapter 5 equivalency §36.105, §36.106
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 802 passages shown