AC 25-7C Flight Test Guide For Certification Of Transport Category Airplanes
This advisory circular (AC) provides guidance for the flight test evaluation of transport category airplanes. This AC includes flight test methods and procedures to show compliance with the regulations contained in subpart B of Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 25, which address airplane performance and handling characteristics. This revision, AC 25-7C, is a complete revision to reduce the number of differences from the European Aviation Safety Agency’s Flight Test Guide, provide acceptable means of compliance for the regulatory changes associated with amendments 107, 109, 113, 115, 119, and 123 to part 25, respond to National Transportation Safety Board recommendations, and to provide a general update to reflect current FAA and industry practices and policies.
This document is cancelled. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.
U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory Circular
Subject Flight Test Guide For Certification Of Transport Category Airplanes
Date: 10/16/12 Initiated by: ANM-110
AC No: 25-7C Change:
This advisory circular (AC) provides guidance for the flight test evaluation of transport category airplanes. This AC includes flight test methods and procedures to show compliance with the regulations contained in subpart B of Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 25, which address airplane performance and handling characteristics. This revision, AC 25-7C, is a complete revision to reduce the number of differences from the European Aviation Safety Agency’s Flight Test Guide, provide acceptable means of compliance for the regulatory changes associated with amendments 107, 109, 113, 115, 119, and 123 to part 25, respond to National Transportation Safety Board recommendations, and to provide a general update to reflect current FAA and industry practices and policies.
John Piccola Acting Manager, Transport Airplane Directorate Aircraft Certification Service
i
Table of Contents Paragraph Page No.
Introduction … 1
1. Purpose … 1
2. Applicability … 1
3. Cancellation … 1
4. Background … 1
5. Related Publications … 2
Chapter 1 - General … 3
1. Applicability - § 25.1. [Reserved] … 3
2. Special Retroactive Requirements - § 25.2. [Reserved] … 3
Chapter 2 - Flight … 4
Section 1. General … 4
3. Proof of Compliance - § 25.21 … 4
4. Load Distribution Limits - § 25.23. [Reserved] … 17
5. Weight Limits and Center of Gravity Limits - §§ 25.25 and 25.27. [Reserved] ____ 17
6. Empty Weight and Corresponding Center of Gravity - § 25.29. [Reserved] … 17
7. Removable Ballast - § 25.31 … 17
8. Propeller Speed and Pitch Limits - § 25.33 … 18
Section 2. Performance … 19
9. General - § 25.101 … 19
10. Takeoff and Takeoff Speeds - §§ 25.105 and 25.107 … 21
11. Accelerate-Stop Distance - § 25.109 … 31
12. Takeoff Path - § 25.111 … 58
13. Takeoff Distance and Takeoff Run - § 25.113 … 65
14. Takeoff Flight Path - § 25.115 … 69
15. Climb: General - § 25.117. 71
ii
Table of Contents (continued) Paragraph Page No.
16. Landing Climb: All-Engines-Operating - § 25.119 … 72
17. Climb: One-Engine-Inoperative - § 25.121 … 73
18. En Route Flight Paths - § 25.123 … 76
19. Landing - § 25.125 … 76
Section 3. Controllability and Maneuverability … 86
20. General - § 25.143 … 86
21. Longitudinal Control - § 25.145 … 99
22. Directional and Lateral Control - § 25.147 … 104
23. Minimum Control Speed - § 25.149 … 107
Section 4. Trim … 114
24. Trim - § 25.161 … 114
Section 5. Stability … 115
25. General - § 25.171. [Reserved] … 115
26. Static Longitudinal Stability and Demonstration of Static Longitudinal Stability -
27. Static Directional and Lateral Stability - § 25.177 … 119
28. Dynamic Stability - § 25.181 … 124
Section 6. Stalls … 126
29. Stall Testing … 126
Section 7. Ground and Water Handling Characteristics … 140
30. General … 140
Section 8. Miscellaneous Flight Requirements … 144
31. Vibration and Buffeting - § 25.251. 144
iii
Table of Contents (continued) Paragraph Page No.
32. High Speed Characteristics - § 25.253 … 148
33. Out-Of-Trim Characteristics - § 25.255 … 153
Chapter 3 - Structure … 158
Chapter 4 - Design and Construction … 159
Section 1. General [Reserved] … 159
Section 2. Control Surfaces [Reserved] … 159
Section 3. Control Systems … 159
34. General - § 25.671 … 159
35. - 45. [Reserved] … 159
46. Flap and Slat Interconnections - § 25.701 … 159
47. Takeoff Warning System - § 25.703. [Reserved] … 160
Section 4. Landing Gear … 160
48. - 51. [Reserved] … 160
52. Retracting Mechanism - § 25.729 … 160
53. Wheels - § 25.731 … 161
54. Tires - § 25.733. [Reserved] … 163
55. Brakes - § 25.735 … 163
56. Skis - § 25.737. [Reserved] … 176
Section 5. Floats and Hulls … 176
57. - 59. [Reserved] … 176
Section 6. Personnel and Cargo Accommodations … 176
60. - 61. [Reserved] … 176
62. Pilot Compartment View - § 25.773 … 176
63. - 72. [Reserved] … 176
iv
Table of Contents (continued) Paragraph Page No.
Section 7. Emergency Provisions … 176
73. Ditching - § 25.801 … 176
74. Emergency Egress Assist Means and Escape Routes - § 25.810 … 176
75. - 83. [Reserved] … 177
Section 8. Ventilation and Heating … 177
84. Ventilation - § 25.831 … 177
85. Cabin Ozone Concentration - § 25.832. [Reserved] … 178
86. Combustion Heating Systems - § 25.833. [Reserved] … 178
Section 9. Pressurization … 178
87. Pressurized Cabins - § 25.841 … 178
88. Tests For Pressurized Cabins - § 25.843 … 180
Section 10. Fire Protection [Reserved] … 182
Section 11. Miscellaneous [Reserved] … 182
Chapter 5 - Powerplant … 183
Section 1. General … 183
89. Installation - § 25.901. [Reserved] … 183
90. Engines - § 25.903 … 183
91. Automatic Takeoff Thrust Control System (ATTCS) - § 25.904 … 187
92. Propellers - § 25.905. [Reserved] … 188
93. Propeller Vibration and Fatigue - 25.907. [Reserved] … 188
94. Propeller Clearance - § 25.925. [Reserved] … 188
95. Propeller Deicing - § 25.929 … 189
96. Reversing Systems - § 25.933 … 189
97. Turbojet Engine Thrust Reverser System Tests - § 25.934. [Reserved] 192
v
Table of Contents (continued) Paragraph Page No.
98. Turbopropeller-Drag Limiting Systems - § 25.937 … 192
99. Turbine Engine Operating Characteristics - § 25.939 … 194
100. Inlet, Engine, and Exhaust Compatibility - § 25.941. [Reserved] … 194
101. Negative Acceleration - § 25.943 … 194
102. Thrust or Power Augmentation System § 25.945. [Reserved] … 195
Section 2. Fuel System … 195
[103. - 108.] [Reserved] … 195
109. Unusable Fuel Supply - § 25.959 … 195
110. Fuel System Hot Weather Operation - § 25.961 … 197
[111. - 116.] [Reserved] … 200
117. Fuel Tank Vents and Carburetor Vapor Vents - § 25.975 … 200
[118. - 120.] [Reserved] … 201
Section 3. Fuel System Components … 201
[121. - 126.] [Reserved] … 201
127. Fuel Jettisoning System - § 25.1001 … 201
Section 4. Oil System [Reserved] … 204
Section 5. Cooling … 204
[128. - 129.] [Reserved] … 204
130. Cooling Test Procedures - § 25.1045 … 204
Section 6. Induction System … 210
131. Air Induction - § 25.1091 … 210
132. Induction System Icing Protection - § 25.1093 … 212
[133. - 136.] [Reserved] … 215
Section 7. Exhaust System … 215
vi
Table of Contents (continued) Paragraph Page No.
137. General - § 25.1121 … 215
[138. - 140.] [Reserved] … 215
Section 8. Powerplant Controls and Accessories … 215
[141. - 154.] [Reserved] … 215
Section 9. Powerplant Fire Protection … 215
[155. - 158.] [Reserved] … 215
159. Drainage and Ventilation Of Fire Zones - § 25.1187 … 215
[160. - 164.] [Reserved] … 216
165. Fire Extinguishing Systems - § 25.1197 … 216
[166. - 169.] [Reserved] … 217
Chapter 6 - Equipment … 218
Section 1. General … 218
170. Equipment - Function and Installation - § 25.1301 … 218
171. Flight and Navigation Instruments - § 25.1303 … 251
172. Powerplant Instruments - § 25.1305. [Reserved] … 252
173. Miscellaneous Equipment - § 25.1307. [Reserved] … 252
174. Equipment, Systems, and Installations - § 25.1309 … 252
Section 2. Instruments: Installation … 253
175. Arrangement and Visibility - § 25.1321. [Reserved] … 253
176. Warning, Caution, and Advisory Lights - § 25.1322. [Reserved] … 253
177. Airspeed Indicating System - § 25.1323 … 253
178. Static Pressure Systems - § 25.1325(d) and (e) … 256
179. Pitot Heat Indication Systems - § 25.1326. [Reserved] … 257
180. Magnetic Direction Indicator - § 25.1327. [Reserved] 257
vii
Table of Contents (continued) Paragraph Page No.
181. Flight Guidance System - § 25.1329 … 257
[182. - 185.] [Reserved] … 281
Section 3. Electrical Systems and Equipment … 281
186. General - § 25.1351 … 281
187. Electrical Equipment and Installations - § 25.1353 … 284
188. Distribution System - § 25.1355 … 284
189. Circuit Protective Devices - § 25.1357. [Reserved] … 284
190. Electrical System Tests - § 25.1363 … 284
Section 4. Lights … 285
191. Instrument Lights - § 25.1381 … 285
192. Landing Lights - § 25.1383 … 285
193. Position Light System Installation - § 25.1385 … 285
[194. - 200.] [Reserved] … 286
201. Anti-Collision Light System - § 25.1401 … 286
202. Wing Icing Detection Lights - § 25.1403 … 286
Section 5. Safety Equipment … 287
[203. - 207.] [Reserved] … 287
Section 6. Miscellaneous Equipment … 287
208. Electronic Equipment - § 25.1431 … 287
[209. - 215.] [Reserved] … 288
216. Equipment Standards for Oxygen Dispensing Units - § 25.1447 … 288
[217. - 223.] [Reserved] … 289
Chapter 7 - Operating Limitations and Information … 290
Section 1. General. [Reserved] … 290
viii
Table of Contents (continued) Paragraph Page No.
Section 2. Operating Limitations [Reserved] … 290
Section 3. Markings and Placards [Reserved] … 290
Section 4. Airplane Flight Manual … 290
224. General - § 25.1581 … 290
[225. - 227.] [Reserved] … 290
Chapter 8 - Airworthiness: Miscellaneous Items … 291
228. Design and Function Of Artificial Stall Warning and Identification Systems. __ 291
229. Reduced and Derated Power or Thrust Takeoff Operations … 295
230. Runway Gradients Greater Than ± 2 Percent … 296
231. Criteria For Approval Of Steep Approach To Landing … 297
232. Takeoff and Landing On Unpaved Runways … 300
233. Accounting for Performance Effects of Minor Design Changes and Configuration
Deviation List (CDL) Items … 304
234. Configuration Deviation List … 305
235. Spare Engine Pod … 307
236. Authorization For Ferry Flight With One Engine Inoperative - § 91.611 … 307
237. Instrument Landing System Weather Minima … 308
238. Takeoff Performance Credit for Alternate Forward Center Of Gravity Limits. __ 309
239. Airplane Backing Using Reverse Thrust … 311
ix
Table of Contents (continued)
Figures
Figure Page No.
Figure 3-1. Weight Tolerance Limits … 7
Figure 3-2. Equivalent Weight Extrapolation … 9
Figure 3-3. Test Parameters That Normally Can Be Corrected … 10
Figure 3-4. Wind Profile Variation … 11
Figure 11-1. Accelerate-Stop Time Delays … 38
Figure 11-2. Accelerate-Stop Speed vs. Distance … 40
Figure 11-3. Anti-Skid System Response Characteristics … 45
Figure 11-4. Anti-Skid System Response Characteristics … 46
Figure 11-5. Anti-Skid System Response Characteristics … 48
Figure 11-6. Instantaneous Brake Force and Peak Brake Force … 51
Figure 11-7. Anti-Skid Efficiency – Wheel Slip Relationship … 53
Figure 11-8. Substantiation of The Optimal Slip Value … 54
Figure 13-1. Takeoff Distance On a Dry Runway … 66
Figure 13-2. Takeoff Distance … 66
Figure 13-3. Takeoff Distance On A Wet Runway … 67
Figure 13-4. Takeoff Run … 68
Figure 13-5. Takeoff Run … 68
Figure 13-6. Clearway Profiles 69
x
Table of Contents (continued)
Figures
Figure Page No.
Figure 14-1. Takeoff Segments & Nomenclature … 70
Figure 14-2. Net Takeoff Flight Path … 71
Figure 19-1. Landing Time Delays … 83
Figure 20-1. Sample Pitch Tracking Task … 94
Figure 20-2. PIO Rating Criteria and Comparison To MIL Standard … 95
Figure 20-3. Example of Acceptable HQ Rating For PIO Tendencies … 96
Figure 26-1. Longitudinal Static Stability … 118
Figure 26-2. Local Reversal … 119
Figure 29-1. Thrust Effect On Stall Speed … 129
Figure 29-2. CLMAX and Load Factor … 131
Figure 29-3. CLMAX vs Weight and Flap Setting … 132
Figure 29-4. Stall Speed vs Weight and Flap Setting … 133
Figure 31-1. Maneuvering Characteristics at Speeds up to VMO/MMO … 148
Figure 33-1. Mistrimmed Maneuvering Characteristics … 156
Figure 181-1 Altitude Loss Versus Altitude At Go-Around Mode Initiation … 269
Figure 181-2 Deviation Profile Method … 278
Figure 181-3 Height Loss Method … 279
xi
Table of Contents (continued)
Tables
Table Page No.
Table 170-1 Radio Line-of-Sight Distance vs. Flight Level or Altitude … 221
Table 170-2 Marker Beacon System … 227
Table 170-3 Classification of LF/MF Radio Beacons in U.S. National Service … 228
Table 170-4 Types of Aural Warnings … 245
Appendices
Appendix Page No.
Appendix 1 … A1-1
Acronyms, Abbreviations, Symbols, and Definitions … A1-1
Appendix 2 … A2-1
Function and Reliability Tests - § 21.35(b)(2) … A2-1
Appendix 3 … A3-1
Historical Development of Accelerate-Stop Time Delays … A3-1
Figure 1. Accelerate-Stop Time Delays … A3-2
Figure 2. Accelerate-Stop Time Delays … A3-3
Appendix 4 … A4-1
History Of Jet Transport Performance Standards … A4-1
Special Civil Air Regulation No. SR-422 … A4-2
Performance A4-5
xii
Table of Contents (continued)
Appendices (continued)
Appendix Page No.
Airplane Flight Manual … A4-13
Operating Rules … A4-14
Special Civil Air Regulation No. SR-422A … A4-17
Performance … A4-23
Airplane Flight Manual … A4-33
Operating Rules … A4-34
Special Civil Air Regulation No. SR-422B … A4-38
Performance … A4-41
Airplane Flight Manual … A4-53
Operating Rules … A4-53
Appendix 5 … A5-1
FAA Handling Qualities Rating Method (HQRM) … A5-1
Figure 1. Overall HQRM Process … A5-2
Figure 2. Handling Qualities Ratings … A5-2
Figure 3. Sample Tasks for Evaluating Airplane Handling Qualities … A5-4
Figure 4. Probability of Occurrence Guidelines … A5-5
Figure 5. Flaps UP Flight Envelopes … A5-7
Figure 6. Flaps DOWN Flight Envelopes … A5-9
Figure 7. Combining Values … A5-10
Figure 8. Probability Guidelines to Determine HQ Requirements … A5-11
Figure 9. Minimum HQ Requirements A5-12
xiii
Table of Contents (continued)
Appendices (continued)
Appendix Page No.
Appendix 6 … A6-1
Correction Of Air Minimum Control Speed To Standard Conditions … A6-1
Theoretical Basis … A6-1
Constant Cn Method … A6-2
Graphical Method … A6-3
Equation Method … A6-6
Appendix 7 … A7-1
Rudder Pedal Force-Limited Air Minimum Control Speed … A7-1
4. Background.
Introduction 1. Purpose. a. This AC provides updated guidance for the flight test evaluation of transport category airplanes. These guidelines provide an acceptable means of demonstrating compliance with the pertinent regulations of Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 25. The methods and procedures described herein have evolved through many years of flight testing of transport category airplanes and, as such, represent current certification practice. This AC is not mandatory and does not constitute a regulation. It describes acceptable means, but not the only means, for demonstrating compliance with the applicable regulation(s). The FAA will consider other methods of demonstrating compliance that an applicant may elect to present. If we become aware of circumstances that convince us that following this AC would not result in compliance with the applicable regulations, we will not be bound by the terms of this AC, and we may require additional substantiation or design changes as a basis for finding compliance.
This material does not change, create any additional, authorize changes in, or permit deviations from existing regulatory requirements. b. See Appendix 1 for a list of acronyms and abbreviations used in this AC. 2. Applicability. These methods and procedures are provided in the interest of certification approval for use during all transport category airplane flight test certification activities. This material is not to be construed as regulatory or having a mandatory effect. The procedures set forth herein are one acceptable means of compliance with applicable sections of part 25. Any alternative means proposed by the applicant should be given due consideration. Applicants are encouraged to use their technical ingenuity and resourcefulness in order to develop more efficient and less costly methods of complying with the requirements of part 25. Since these methods and procedures are only one acceptable means of compliance, individuals should be guided by the intent of the methods provided in this AC.
As deviations from the methods and procedures described in this AC may occur, FAA certification personnel will coordinate what they consider to be major deviations with the Transport Standards Staff (ANM-110) of the Transport Airplane Directorate. If in their judgment, however, a deviation is considered to be minor, coordination with ANM- 110 may not be necessary. 3. Cancellation. AC 25-7B, Change 1, “Flight Test Guide for Certification of Transport Category Airplanes,” dated December 7, 2011, is cancelled. 4. Background. a. Since AC 25-7 was released on April 9, 1986, it has been the primary source of guidance for flight test methods and procedures to show compliance with the regulations contained in subpart B of part 25, which address airplane performance and handling
characteristics. AC 25-7 has been revised several times to reflect changes in the part 25 regulatory requirements, changes in guidance and policy, and advances in technology. b. The first revision, AC 25-7A, updated the original AC to incorporate the policy and guidance material applicable to all sections of part 25, not just subpart B. The material related to regulations outside of subpart B superseded that contained in Order 8110.8, which was cancelled when AC 25-7A was issued. c. Change 1 to AC 25-7A added acceptable means of compliance for the regulatory changes associated with amendments 92 and 98 to part 25. d. AC 25-7B added acceptable means of compliance for the regulatory changes associated with amendments 108, 109, and 115 to part 25, and revised guidance for expanding takeoff and landing data for airport elevations higher than those at which flight testing was conducted. Means of compliance associated with flight in icing conditions were removed as this material is now contained in AC 25-25. e.
Change 1 to AC 25-7B added acceptable means of compliance for the regulatory changes associated with amendment 25-135. f. This revision, AC 25-7C, is a complete revision to reduce the number of differences from the European Aviation Safety Agency’s Flight Test Guide, provide acceptable means of compliance for the regulatory changes associated with amendments 107, 109, 113, 115, 119 and 123 to part 25, to respond to FAA and National Transportation Safety Board safety recommendations, and to provide a general update to reflect current FAA and industry practices and policies. 5. Related Publications. Certification personnel should be familiar with FAA Order 8110.4C, “Type Certification,” and FAA Order 8100.5A, “Aircraft Certification Service Mission, Responsibilities, Relationships, and Programs. In this AC, reference is made to other FAA ACs that provide guidance on various aspects of type certification and supplemental type certification.
2. Special Retroactive Requirements - § 25.2. [Reserved]
Chapter 1 - General 1. Applicability - § 25.1. [Reserved] 2. Special Retroactive Requirements - § 25.2. [Reserved]
Chapter 2 - Flight
Section 1. General 3. Proof of Compliance - § 25.21. a. Explanation. In an effort to provide the necessary guidelines for the flight test evaluation of transport category airplanes, without producing a cumbersome document, this AC assumes a conventional transport airplane configuration. In general, a conventional airplane configuration is one with distinct wing and fuselage elements that are joined together, aftmounted horizontal and vertical stabilizers that are attached to the fuselage, and propulsion provided either by turbojet/turbofan engines that do not provide any significant increase in lift due to their operation or engine-driven propellers. The effects of non-conventional airplane configurations (e.g., blown flaps) on the compliance methods should be evaluated and determined based on the intent of the guidelines presented for conventional airplane configurations.
Section 1. General
(1) Section 25.21(a) - Proof of Compliance.
(a) The burden of showing compliance with the flight requirements for an airworthiness certificate or a type certificate rests with the applicant. The applicant should, at his own expense and risk, conduct such official flight tests as required by the FAA to demonstrate compliance with the applicable requirements. During the certification process, the applicant should make available the airplane, as well as all of the personnel and equipment necessary to obtain and process the required data.
(b) If the airplane flight characteristics or the required flight data are affected by weight and/or center of gravity (c.g.), the compliance data must be presented for the most critical weight and c.g. position per § 25.21(a). Unless the applicant shows that the allowable c.g. travel in one or more axes (e.g., lateral fuel imbalance) has a negligible effect on compliance with the airworthiness requirements, the applicant must substantiate compliance at the critical c.g.
(c) The gross weight and c.g. tolerances specified in paragraphs 3a(3)(b)1 and 3 are test tolerances and are not intended to allow compliance to be shown at less than critical conditions.
(d) Section 21.35(a)(3) requires that the test airplane be in conformity with its type design specifications.
1 This means that the test airplane must be in conformity with its type design specification as relates to the particular test being conducted.
2 Any deviation from conformity must be clearly shown to be of no consequence to the particular test being conducted. For example, if the slip resistant escape surface required by § 25.810(c) is not installed when conducting airplane performance and flight
characteristics tests, the applicant must show that its presence would have no effect on measured airplane performance and flight characteristics.
(e) Section 21.35(b)(2) requires the applicant to conduct sufficient flight testing the FAA finds necessary to determine whether there is reasonable assurance that the airplane, its components, and its equipment are reliable and function properly. Appendix 2 to this AC provides guidance for showing compliance with this requirement.
(f) Acceptable use of simulation in lieu of flight testing. It is difficult to establish guidance for using simulation in lieu of flight testing that applies in all situations. However, the following general principles can be used as guidance for determining the acceptability for using simulation in lieu of flight testing:
1 In general, flight test demonstrations are the preferred method to show compliance.
2 Simulation may be an acceptable alternative to flight demonstrations in certain situations, such as the following: (aa) A flight demonstration would be too risky even after attempts are taken to mitigate these risks (e.g., by mock takeoffs/landings in the air at a safe altitude); (bb) The required environmental or airplane conditions are too difficult to attain, such as in the examples listed below: (i) validation of system safety analyses failure cases involving high crosswinds, (ii) development of crosswind guidance for slippery runway operations; and (iii) conditions involving minimum allowable weight where the minimum allowable weight cannot be achieved because of the weight of required test equipment. In this case, simulation data can be used to supplement flight test data obtained at the minimum practicable test weight.
(cc) The simulation is used to augment a reasonably broad flight test program; or
(dd) The simulation is used to demonstrate repeatability, or to demonstrate performance of a specific scenario for a range of pilots. 3 Simulation Criteria. If it is agreed that a simulation will be used to establish compliance, to be acceptable for use in showing compliance with the performance and handling qualities requirements, the simulation should:
(aa) Be of a type and fidelity that is appropriate for the task. For example, is motion or an exterior view needed, or is the fidelity or customizability of an engineering simulator needed? (bb) Be suitably validated by flight test data for the conditions of interest. (i) This does not mean that there must be flight test data at the exact conditions of interest. The reason simulation is being used may be that it is too difficult or risky to obtain flight test data at the conditions of interest. (ii) The level of substantiation of the simulator to flight correlation should be commensurate with the level of compliance (i.e., the closer the case is to being noncompliant, the higher the required fidelity of the simulation). (cc) Be conducted in a manner appropriate to the case and conditions of interest. (i) If closed-loop responses are important, the simulation should be piloted by a human pilot. (ii) For piloted simulations, the controls/displays and cues should be substantially equivalent to what would be available in the real airplane (unless it is determined that not doing so would provide added conservatism).
(2) Section 25.21(c) - Proof of Compliance (Altitude Effect on Flight Characteristics).
(a) Any of the flying qualities affected by altitude, including controllability, stability, trim, and stall characteristics, must be investigated at the most adverse altitude conditions approved for operations.
(b) Consideration should be given in the test program to any aerodynamic control system changes that occur with changes in altitude (e.g., maximum control surface displacement or auto slats that may be inhibited by Mach number above a specific altitude).
(3) Section 25.21(d) - Proof of Compliance (Flight Test Tolerances).
(a) To allow for variations from precise test values, acceptable tolerances during flight testing must be maintained. The purpose of these tolerances is to allow for small variations in flight test values of certain variables from the targeted value. They are not intended for compliance tests to be planned for other than the critical condition, nor are they to be considered as an allowable measurement error.
(b) Where variation in the parameter for which a tolerance is allowed will have an effect on the results of the test, the results should be corrected to the most critical value of that parameter within the approved operating envelope. If such a correction is impossible or
impractical, the average test conditions should assure that the measured characteristics represent the actual critical value.
1 Weight limits. Figure 3-1, below, presents weight tolerances that have been found acceptable for the specified flight tests. Many flight tests need to be conducted at or very near the maximum operating weight for the airplane configuration, particularly those tests used to establish airplane flight manual (AFM) performance information. As noted in paragraph (a) above, the purpose of the test tolerances is to allow for variations in flight test values, not to routinely schedule tests at less than critical weight conditions or to allow for compliance to be shown at less than the critical weight condition. In addition, the tolerances can be used to help determine when to interrupt a series of test conditions in order to refuel the airplane if necessary to remain within the acceptable weight tolerance.
Figure 3-1. Weight Tolerance Limits
Flight Test Conditions Weight
Tolerance Limit
±5% ±10%
Stall Speeds X
Stall Characteristics X
All Other Flight Characteristics X
Climb Performance X
Takeoff Flight Paths X
Landing Braking Distance X
Landing Air Distance X
Takeoff Distance & Speed X
Accelerate-Stop Distance X
Maximum Energy RTOs X
Minimum Unstick Speed X
Minimum Control Speed X
NOTE: A -5 percent tolerance limit means that the weight for the particular test may be up to 5 percent less than the test target value. A +5 percent tolerance limit means that the weight for the particular test may be up to 5 percent higher than the test target value. (aa) It can be difficult or impossible to conduct testing at the airplane’s minimum allowable weight with an airplane configured for conducting a flight test program. If the minimum weight cannot be obtained (within the specified tolerance limit) and compliance at the minimum weight cannot be clearly deduced from the results at the tested weight, the testing
should be conducted on a production airplane (or other airplane on which the minimum weight can be obtained). If the instrumentation or equipment needed to conduct safe testing cannot be installed on the production airplane configuration, or the weight of such instrumentation still prevents the minimum weight from being obtained, consider the use of simulation to extend the results obtained at the minimum practical test weight. (See paragraph 3a(1)(f).)
(bb) For follow-on airplane certification programs involving an increase in the maximum allowable gross weight, the test weight limits of Figure 3-1 have been applied as extrapolation limits on the original test data in order to minimize additional testing. For the test weight tolerance limits to be applied in this manner, the original test data must be from an existing certificated database for an aerodynamically similar model of the same airplane type. The tolerance limit should be applied to the maximum weight at which the original testing was conducted, not to the maximum certified weight.
(cc) Equivalent weight extrapolation limits. For follow-on airplane certification programs where it is desired to increase a maximum operating weight based on existing certified performance parameters that have weight as one of their independent terms, those parameters should be examined for equivalent compliance with the weight tolerance limits of Figure 3-1. An example would be the reduction of an airplane’s landing flap position, to one approved on a similar model of the same airplane type, which would incur an increase in landing speeds and brake energy, relative to the original certificated landing flap, at any given weight. The brake energy, at the maximum certificated landing weight, should be calculated for the reduced landing flap. This brake energy should account for the increased landing speeds and reduced aerodynamic drag associated with the reduced flap setting. It should then be determined what equivalent gross weight would have rendered that brake energy with the original landing flap. (See Figure 3-2 for an example of how this can be done.) If the resulting equivalent gross weight does not exceed the certificated maximum landing weight by more than the five percent weight extrapolation limit specified in Figure 3-1, the reduced flap certification may be eligible for a reduced flight test program (e.g., limited to stall speed verification, handling characteristics, and a qualitative landing demonstration). Further limitations may be imposed by the criteria of technical standard order (TSO) C135a (“Transport Airplane Wheels and Wheel and Brake Assemblies,” dated July 1, 2009).
Figure 3-2. Equivalent Weight Extrapolation
∆ G.W. Not greater than 5%
Gross Weight - Pounds
∆ KE
Max. Landing Wt.
“Equivalent” Gross Wt.
Flap
Brake Energy
Ori ginal Reduced
Flap
2 Wind Limits. A wind velocity limit of 10 knots (from any direction) or 0.11 VSR1 (whichever is lower) is considered the maximum acceptable for obtaining valid takeoff and landing flight test data. Takeoff and landing performance data obtained under runway wind conditions greater than 5 knots may be inconsistent and unreliable because winds of that magnitude are likely to be unsteady. However, performance data obtained with winds between 5 and 10 knots should not necessarily be discarded. Their validity should be checked against data obtained in conditions with lesser winds. Wind velocity should be measured at the height of the wing mean aerodynamic chord (MAC), as determined with the airplane in a static ground attitude. When measuring test wind velocity at the wing MAC height, a height of six feet above the ground should be considered as a minimum measurement height to avoid possible measurement inaccuracies due to surface interference.
3 C.G. Limits. A test tolerance of +7 percent of the total c.g. range is intended to allow for inflight c.g. movement. This tolerance is only acceptable when the test data scatter is on both sides of the limiting c.g. or when adjusting the data from the test c.g. to the limit c.g. is acceptable. If compliance with a requirement is marginal at a test condition that is inside of the c.g. limits, the test should be repeated at the c.g. limits.
4 Airspeed Limits. Normally, tests conducted within 3 percent or 3 knots (whichever is the higher) of the desired test speed are considered acceptable.
5 Thrust/Power Limits. Thrust critical tests, such as minimum control speeds, should be conducted at the highest thrust (or power) allowable on the engine given the constraints of temperature and altitude. It is then permitted to calculate further corrections to allow extrapolation of data to cover the entire operating envelope. These thrust (or power) corrections should be limited to 5 percent of test day thrust (or power), unless a detailed analysis is performed.
(c) It is not the purpose of these tolerances to allow flights at values in excess of those authorized in the type design. If such flights are to be conducted, adequate structural
substantiation for the flight conditions should be available. These flights should always be conducted under controlled conditions and with the flight test crew’s full knowledge of the situation. Examples of such flights are:
1 Takeoff at greater than maximum takeoff weight to reach a test area at the maximum takeoff weight.
2 Landing at greater than maximum landing weights during the course of conducting takeoff tests.
3 Flights to obtain data for future approvals beyond that substantiated for the initial type design.
(d) The table in Figure 3-3 indicates the cases for which corrections are normally allowed. Any corrections to flight test data should be made by methods that are agreed to by the FAA.
Figure 3-3. Test Parameters That Normally Can Be Corrected
Flight Test
Condition
Correctable Parameters
Wt. C.G. Airspeed Altitude Power/
Thrust
Wind
Airspeed calibration X --- --- --- --- ---
Stall speeds X X --- --- X ---
Climb performance X X X X X ---
Landing performance X --- X X --- X
Takeoff performance X X --- X X X
Accelerate-stop perf. X X --- X X X
Minimum control speed --- --- --- --- X ---
Minimum unstick speed X X X --- X ---
Buffet boundary X X --- X --- ---
(e) All instrumentation used in the flight test program should be appropriately calibrated and acceptable to the FAA test team.
(4) Section 25.21(f) - Proof of Compliance (Wind Measurement and Corrections). The relationship between the wind measured at one height and the corresponding wind at another height may be obtained by the following equation:
VW2 = VW1(H2/H1)1/7
Where: H = Height above the runway surface
VW2 = Wind velocity at H2 VW1 = Wind velocity at H1 This equation is presented graphically below. Values of H less than 5 feet should not be used in this relationship.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
WIND VELOCITY - KNOTS
HEIGHT ABOVE FIELD ELEVATION - FEET
10 meters
Figure 3-4. Wind Profile Variation
(5) Wind Profile Variation for Test Data. The performance data of airplanes should be obtained in such a manner that the effect of wind on the test data may be determined. The test wind velocity should be corrected from the recorded height above the test surface to the height of the airplane wing mean aerodynamic chord. If the wind profile variation is not measured, the variation may be calculated using the equation in paragraph (4) above. The following examples are methods of handling wind profile variation data. Other methods have also been found acceptable.
Example: Test Data
Given:
o Height of mean-aerodynamic-chord with airplane on surface 8.0 ft. o Height of wind measurement 6.0 ft. o Measured wind velocity 4.8 kts. Results: o Test wind velocity with airplane 50 ft. above landing surface 4.8((50 + 8)/6)1/7 = 6.6 kts. o Test wind velocity with airplane 35 ft. above takeoff surface 4.8((35 + 8)/6)1/7 = 6.4 kts. o Test wind velocity with airplane on surface 4.8(8/6)1/7 = 5.0 kts.
(6) Wind Profile Variation for AFM Data. When expanding the data to the AFM conditions, the result should include the effective velocity, at the airplane’s wing mean aerodynamic chord, which corresponds to the wind condition as measured at 10 meters (32.81 ft.) above the takeoff surface, and corrected for the wind factors of § 25.105(d)(1).
Example: AFM Data Given: o Height of mean aerodynamic chord with airplane on surface 8.0 ft. o Reported headwind at 10 meters 40.0 kts. o Section 25.105(d)(1) wind factor 0.5 Results: o Factored wind velocity with airplane 50 ft. above landing surface (0.5)(40)((50 + 8)/32.81)1/7 = 21.7 kts. o Factored wind velocity with airplane 35 ft. above takeoff surface (0.5)(40)((35 + 8)/32.81)1/7 = 20.8 kts. o Factored wind velocity with airplane on surface (0.5)(40)(8/32.81)1/7 = 16.3 kts.
(7) Airplane Airspeed Variation Due to Wind Profile Variation Combined With Speed Changes Due to Airplane Dynamic Performance. In the reduction of test data and in the expansion of such data to AFM conditions, the increase or decrease of speed due to the dynamic effect of the forces on the airplane are shown only by the change in ground speed. These
changes in ground speed may be generalized either as speed increments or speed ratios. The changes in airspeed due to wind profile variation are superimposed on these speed changes.
Example: Determination of True Airspeed from Ground Speed -- Takeoff Test Data Given: o Ground speed at liftoff, VLOF 139.0 kts. o Ground speed at 35 ft. above takeoff surface 140.6 kts. o Speed change due to airplane dynamic performance 1.6 kts. o Test headwind at liftoff 5.0 kts. o Test headwind with airplane 35 ft. above takeoff surface 6.4 kts.
Results: o True airspeed at liftoff, VLOF 139.0 + 5.0 = 144.0 kts. o True airspeed at 35 ft. above takeoff surface 140.6 + 6.4 147.0 kts. Example: Determination of Rotation Speed from True Airspeed at 35 ft. Height -- AFM Data
Given: o Factored headwind at liftoff 16.3 kts. o Factored headwind with airplane 35 ft. above takeoff surface 20.8 kts. o Ground speed change, (V35-VLOF) 1.6 kts. o Ground speed change, (VLOF-VR) 0.5 kts. o True airspeed required at 35 ft. 150.0 kts. Results: o Ground speed required at 35 ft. 150 - 20.8 = 129.2 kts. o Ground speed at liftoff 129.2 - 1.6 = 127.6 kts. o True airspeed at liftoff 127.6 + 16.3 = 143.9 kts. o Ground speed at rotation 127.6 - 0.5 = 127.1 kts. o True airspeed at rotation (for AFM speed and distances) 127.1+16.3 = 143.4 kts.
Example: Landing — AFM Data Given: o Factored headwind with airplane 50 ft. above landing surface 21.7 kts. o Factored headwind with airplane on landing surface 16.3 kts. o Ground speed change for 50 ft. to touchdown (V50 – VTD) 4.0 kts. o True airspeed required at 50 ft. 130 kts. Results: o Ground speed at 50 ft. 130 - 21.7 = 108.3 kts. o Ground speed at touchdown 108.3 - 4.0 = 104.3 kts. o True airspeed at touchdown 104.3 + 16.3 = 120.6 kts.
(8) Expansion of Takeoff and Landing Data for a Range of Airport Elevations.
(a) These guidelines apply to expanding AFM takeoff and landing data above and below the altitude at which the airplane takeoff and landing performance tests are conducted.
(b) Historically, limits were placed on the extrapolation of takeoff data. In the past, takeoff data could generally be extrapolated 6,000 feet above and 3,000 feet below the test field elevation when proven testing and data reduction methods were used. For extrapolations beyond these limits, a 2 percent takeoff distance penalty was to be applied for every additional 1,000 feet extrapolation. Such limitations were generally not applied to extrapolation of landing data, provided the effect of the higher true airspeed on landing distance was taken into account.
(c) Since then, considerably more experience has since been gained both in terms of modeling airplane and propulsion system (i.e., turbine engines and propellers, where appropriate) performance and in verifying the accuracy of these models for determining high (and low) altitude takeoff and landing performance. This experience has shown that the soundness of the extrapolation is primarily a function of the accuracy of the propulsion system performance model and its integration with the airplane drag model. The basic aerodynamic characteristics of the airplane do not change significantly with altitude or ambient temperature, and any such effects are readily taken into account by standard airplane performance modeling practices.
(d) As a result, with installed propulsion system performance characteristics that have been adequately defined and verified, airplane takeoff and landing performance data obtained at one field elevation may be extrapolated to higher and lower altitudes within the limits of the operating envelope without applying additional performance conservatisms. It should be noted, however, that extrapolation of the propulsion system data used in the determination and validation of propulsion system performance characteristics is typically limited to 3,000 feet above the highest altitude at which propulsion system parameters were evaluated for the pertinent power/thrust setting. (See paragraph 9 of this AC for more information on an
acceptable means of establishing and verifying installed propulsion system performance characteristics.)
(e) Note that certification testing for operation at airports that are above 8,000 feet should also include functional tests of the cabin pressurization system in accordance with paragraph 87b(3) of this AC. Consideration should be given to any sensitivity to, or dependency upon airport altitude, such as: engine and auxiliary power unit (APU) starting, passenger oxygen, autopilot, autoland, autothrottle system power/thrust set/operation.
(9) Tailwind Takeoff and Landing.
(a) Wind Velocities of 10 Knots or Less - Approval may be given for performance, controllability, and engine operating characteristics for operations in reported tailwind velocities up to 10 knots without conducting additional flight tests at specific wind speeds.
(b) Wind Velocities Greater than 10 Knots.
1 Performance. It is considered that takeoff, rejected takeoff, and landing distances, measured in tailwind conditions greater than 10 knots, are unreliable for use in determining airplane performance. Wind conditions of such magnitude are generally not sufficiently consistent over the length of the runway or over the time period required to perform the test maneuver. The 150 percent operational tailwind factor, required by §§ 25.105(d)(1) and 25.125(f), provides a satisfactory level of safety for operation in tailwinds up to 15 knots when using AFM data based on flight tests in nominally calm wind conditions.
NOTE: The design requirements of § 25.479 (Level landing conditions) also require the effects of increased contact speeds to be investigated if approval for landings with tailwinds greater than 10 knots is desired.
2 Control Characteristics. The test tailwind velocity for demonstrating handling qualities should be equal to the proposed limit tailwind factored by 150 percent. The intent of the 150 percent factor is to provide adequate margin for wind variability in operations, including currency of the wind data, averaging of the data by the measuring and reporting method, and the highly variable nature of higher wind conditions. Therefore, the test wind condition of 150 percent of the proposed tailwind limit should be an averaged or smoothed wind speed, not a peak wind speed. Airplane control characteristics should be evaluated under the following conditions with the c.g. at the aft limit and the test mean tailwind velocity equal to the proposed limit tailwind factored by 150 percent:
(aa) Takeoff. Both all-engines-operating and one-engine-inoperative (i.e., with a simulated failure of the critical engine at the engine failure speed, VEF) takeoffs should be evaluated at a light weight with maximum approved takeoff flap deflection.
(bb) Landing. Approach and landing at light weight with maximum approved landing flap deflection.
(cc) Determination of the increased ground speed effect on gear vibration or shimmy, and flight director, or autopilot instrument landing system (ILS) approaches, terrain awareness warning system (TAWS) sink rate modes, etc.
(dd) If engine idle power or thrust is increased to account for the increased tailwind velocity, ensure that deviations above the glideslope are recoverable.
3 Weight Limits. Consistent with the requirements of §§ 25.105(d)(1) and 25.125(f), the maximum takeoff and maximum quick turnaround weights should be determined using brake energies and tire speeds, as appropriate, calculated with the limit tailwind velocity factored by 150 percent.
4 Engine Operating Characteristics. Satisfactory engine operation should be demonstrated at the limit tailwind velocity factored by 150 percent. The demonstrations should include:
(aa) Zero groundspeed operation. (bb) Takeoff power or thrust setting procedure used for AFM performance (typically completed by approximately 80 knots), both manually and automatically (autothrottle).
(cc) Reverse thrust operations. 5 Airplane Flight Manual. The AFM should contain a statement that the limitation for tailwinds greater than 10 knots reflects the capability of the airplane as evaluated in terms of airworthiness but does not constitute approval for operation in tailwinds exceeding 10 knots.
b. Procedures. (1) The performance-related flight test procedures are discussed in each of the following paragraphs of this AC:
10. Takeoff and Takeoff Speeds 11. Accelerate-Stop Distance 12. Takeoff Path 13. Takeoff Distance and Takeoff Run 14. Takeoff Flight Path 15. Climb: General 16. Landing Climb 17. Climb: One Engine Inoperative 18. En Route Flight Path 19. Landing
7. Removable Ballast - § 25.31.
(2) Performance Data for Multiple Flap or Additional Flap Positions. If approval of performance data is requested for flap settings at which no test data are available, the data may be obtained from interpolation of flight data obtained at no less than four flap settings that are within a constant configuration of other lift devices. If the span of flap settings is small and previously obtained data provide sufficient confidence (i.e., the shape of the curves are known and lend themselves to accurate interpolation), data from three flap settings may be acceptable.
(3) Flight Characteristics for Abnormal Configurations (Ref. § 25.671(c)).
(a) For purposes of this AC, an abnormal configuration is an operational configuration that results from any single failure or any combination of failures not shown to be improbable.
(b) Flight characteristics for abnormal configurations may be determined by test or analysis to assure that the airplane is capable of continued safe flight and landing. Flight tests, if required, should be conducted at the critical conditions of altitude, weight, c.g., and engine power or thrust associated with the configuration, and at the most critical airspeed between the speed reached one second after stall warning occurs (see paragraph 29e(2)(h) of this AC) and the maximum operating airspeed for the configuration. 4. Load Distribution Limits - § 25.23. [Reserved] 5. Weight Limits and Center of Gravity Limits - §§ 25.25 and 25.27. [Reserved] 6. Empty Weight and Corresponding Center of Gravity - § 25.29. [Reserved] 7. Removable Ballast - § 25.31.
a. Explanation. None. b. Procedures. Ballast may be carried during the flight tests whenever it is necessary to achieve a specific weight and c.g. location. Consideration should be given to the vertical as well as horizontal location of the ballast in cases where it may have an appreciable effect on the flying qualities of the airplane. The strength of the supporting structures should be considered in order to make sure they do not fail as a result of the anticipated loads that may be imposed during the particular tests. As required by § 21.35(a), applicants must show that these structures comply with the applicable structural requirements of part 25 before conducting flight tests with these structures in place.
8. Propeller Speed and Pitch Limits - § 25.33.
8. Propeller Speed and Pitch Limits - § 25.33.
a. Explanation. None. b. Procedures. The tachometers and the airspeed indicating system of the test airplane should have been calibrated within the last six months. With that prerequisite satisfied, the following should be accomplished:
(1) Determine that the propeller speeds and pitch settings are safe and satisfactory during all tests that are conducted in the flight test program within the certification limits of the airplane, engine, and propeller. This includes establishing acceptable low pitch (flight idle) blade angles on turbopropeller airplanes and verifying that propeller configurations are satisfactory at VMO/MMO to prevent propeller overspeed.
(2) Determine that the propeller speeds and pitch settings are safe and satisfactory during all tests that are conducted to satisfy the performance requirements.
(3) With the propeller governors operative and the propeller controls in full high revolutions per minute (r.p.m.) position, determine that the maximum takeoff power settings do not exceed the rated takeoff r.p.m. of each engine during takeoff and climb at the best rate-ofclimb speed.
(4) With the propeller governors made inoperative by mechanical means, determine the maximum power, no-wind, static r.p.m.’s. With the propeller governors operating on the low pitch stop, the engine speeds must not exceed 103 percent of the maximum allowable takeoff r.p.m. or 99 percent of an approved maximum overspeed, as required by § 25.33(c). On turbopropeller engines, the engine speeds should not exceed the maximum engine speeds allowed by engine and propeller type designs. Note which systems were disabled and how the disablement was done. If maximum takeoff power torque or sea level standard conditions cannot be obtained on the test day, correct the data to these conditions by an acceptable means. A nowind condition is considered to be a wind of 5 knots or less. The static r.p.m. should be the average obtained with a direct crosswind from the left and a direct crosswind from the right.
(5) If the above determinations are satisfactory, then measure the low-pitch stop setting and the high-pitch stop setting. These data may have been obtained from the propeller manufacturer and may be used, provided the pitch stops have not been changed since the manufacturer delivered the propeller. If measured, the blade station should be recorded. Include these blade angles in the type certificate data sheet.
9. General - § 25.101.
Section 2. Performance 9. General - § 25.101. a. Explanation - Propulsion System Behavior. Section 25.101(c) requires that airplane “performance must correspond to the propulsive thrust available under the particular ambient atmospheric conditions, the particular flight conditions....” The propulsion system’s (i.e., turbine engines and propellers, where appropriate), installed performance characteristics are primarily a function of engine power or thrust setting, airspeed, propeller efficiency (where applicable), altitude, and ambient temperature. Determine the effects of each of these variables to establish the thrust available for airplane performance calculations.
b. Procedures.
(1) The intent is to develop a model of propulsion system performance that covers the approved flight envelope. Furthermore, it should be shown that the combination of the propulsion system performance model and the airplane performance model is validated by the takeoff performance test data, climb performance tests, and tests used to determine airplane drag. Installed propulsion system performance characteristics may be established via the following tests and analyses:
(a) Steady-state engine power (or thrust) setting vs. power (or thrust) testing. Engines should be equipped with adequate instrumentation to allow the determination of thrust (or power). Data should be acquired in order to validate the model, including propeller-installed thrust, if applicable, over the range of power or thrust settings, altitudes, temperatures, and airspeeds for which approval is sought. Although it is not possible to definitively list or foresee all of the types of instrumentation that might be considered adequate for determining thrust (or power) output, two examples used in past certification programs are: (1) engine pressure rakes, with engines calibrated in a ground test cell, and (2) fan speed, with engines calibrated in a ground test cell and the calibration data validated by the use of a flying test bed. In any case, the applicant should substantiate the adequacy of the instrumentation to be used for determining the thrust (or power) output.
(b) Lapse rate takeoff testing to characterize the behavior of power or thrust setting, rotor speeds, propeller effects (i.e., torque, R.P.M., and blade angle), or gas temperature as a function of time, thermal state, or airspeed, as appropriate. These tests should include the operation of an automatic takeoff thrust control system (ATTCS), if applicable, and should cover the range of power or thrust settings for which approval is sought.
1 Data for higher altitude power or thrust settings may be acquired via overboost (i.e., operating at a higher than normal power or thrust setting for the conditions) with the consent of the engine and propeller manufacturer(s), when applicable. When considering the use of overboost on turbopropeller propulsion system installations to stimulate higher altitude and ambient temperature range conditions, the capability to achieve an appropriate simulation should be evaluated based on the engine and propeller control system(s) and aircraft performance and structural considerations. Engine (gearbox) torque, rotor speed, or gas temperature limits,
including protection devices to prohibit or limit exceedances, may prevent the required amount of overboost needed for performance at the maximum airport altitude sought for approval. Overboost may be considered as increased torque, reduced propeller speed, or a combination of both, in order to achieve the appropriate blade angle for the higher altitude and ambient temperature range simulation. Consideration for extrapolations will depend on the applicant’s substantiation of the proper turbopropeller propulsion system simulated test conditions.
2 Lapse rate characteristics should be validated by takeoff demonstrations at the maximum airport altitude for which takeoff approval is being sought. Alternatively, if overboost (see paragraph 1 above) is used to simulate the power or thrust setting parameters of the maximum airport altitude for which takeoff approval is sought, the takeoff demonstrations of lapse rate characteristics can be performed at an airport altitude up to 3,000 feet lower than the maximum airport altitude.
(c) Power/Thrust calculation substantiation. Installed power or thrust should be calculated via a mathematical model of the propulsion system, or other appropriate means, adjusted as necessary to match the measured inflight performance characteristics of the installed propulsion system. The propulsion system mathematical model should define the relationship of power or thrust to the power or thrust setting parameter over the range of power or thrust settings, airspeeds, altitudes, and temperatures for which approval is sought. For turbojet airplanes, the propulsion system mathematical model should be substantiated by ground tests in which thrust is directly measured via a calibrated load cell or equivalent means. For turbopropeller airplanes, the engine power measurement should be substantiated by a calibrated dynamometer or equivalent means, the engine jet thrust should be established by an acceptable engine model, and the propeller thrust and power characteristics should be substantiated by wind tunnel testing or equivalent means.
(d) Effects of ambient temperature. The flight tests of paragraph 9b(l)(a) above will typically provide data over a broad range of ambient temperatures. Additional data may be obtained from other flight or ground tests of the same type or series of engine. The objective is to confirm that the propulsion system model accurately reflects the effect of temperature over the range of ambient temperatures for which approval is being sought (operating envelope). Because thrust (or power) data can usually be normalized versus temperature using either dimensionless variables (e.g., theta exponents or a thermodynamic cycle model), it is usually unnecessary to obtain data over the entire ambient temperature range. There is no needed to conduct additional testing if:
1 The data show that the behavior of power or thrust and limiting parameters versus ambient temperature can be predicted accurately, and
2 Analysis based upon the test data shows that the propulsion system will operate at rated power or thrust without exceeding propulsion system limits.
(2) Extrapolation of propulsion system performance data to 3,000 feet above the highest airport altitude tested (but no higher than the maximum takeoff airport altitude to be approved). is acceptable, provided the supporting data, including flight test and propulsion
system operations data (e.g., engine and propeller control, limits exceedance, and surge protection devices scheduling), substantiates the proposed extrapolation procedures. Considerations for extrapolation depend upon an applicant’s determination, understanding, and substantiation of the critical operating modes of the propulsion system. This understanding includes a determination and quantification of the effects that propulsion system installation and variations in ambient conditions have on these modes. 10. Takeoff and Takeoff Speeds - §§ 25.105 and 25.107.
10. Takeoff and Takeoff Speeds - §§ 25.105 and 25.107.
a. Explanation. Section 25.105 specifies the conditions that must be considered in determining the takeoff speeds, accelerate-stop distances, takeoff path, takeoff distance, and takeoff run in accordance with part 25 requirements. The primary objective of the takeoff tests required by § 25.107 is to determine the takeoff speeds for all takeoff configurations at all weight, altitude, and temperature conditions within the operational limits selected by the applicant. b. Procedures. (1) Section 25.105(c)(1) requires the takeoff performance data to be determined for smooth, dry and wet, hard-surfaced runways. Paragraph 11 of this AC describes methods for determining the accelerate-stop distances required by § 25.109. Paragraph 13 describes methods for determining the takeoff distance and takeoff run required by § 25.113. (2) In accordance with § 25.101(f), testing for determining the accelerate-stop distances, takeoff flight paths, and takeoff distances should be accomplished using procedures established by the applicant for operation in service.
In accordance with §25.101(h), these procedures must be able to be consistently executed in service by crews of average skill, use methods or devices that are safe and reliable, and include allowances for any time delays in the execution of the procedures that may reasonably be expected in service. These requirements prohibit the use of exceptional piloting techniques, such as higher control force inputs or higher pitch rates than would occur in operational service, from being used to generate unrealistic takeoff distances. The intent of these requirements is to establish takeoff performance representative of that which can reasonably be expected to be achieved in operational service.
(3) Attention should be paid to all potential sources of airspeed error, but special consideration should be given to airplanes with electronic instruments in the cockpit that apply electronic filtering to the airspeed data. This filtering, which causes a time delay in the airspeed indication, can be a source of significant systematic error in the presentation of airspeed to the flightcrew. With normal takeoff acceleration, the airplane will be at a higher speed than is indicated by the cockpit instrument, which can result in longer distances than are presented in the AFM, particularly in the event of a rejected takeoff near the indicated V1 speed. The effects of any time delays caused by electronic filtering, pneumatic system lag, or other sources should be adequately addressed in the AFM speed and distance presentations. Further explanation of airspeed lag, particularly pertaining to airplanes with electronic instruments in the cockpit, and procedures for calibrating the airspeed indicating system (§ 25.1323(b)) are presented in paragraph 177 of this AC.
(4) Section 25.107(a)(1) - Engine Failure Speed (VEF). The engine failure speed (VEF) is defined as the calibrated airspeed at which the critical engine is assumed to fail and must be selected by the applicant. VEF cannot be less than the ground minimum control speed (VMCG).
(5) Section 25.107(a)(2) - V1. V1 may not be less than VEF plus the speed gained with the critical engine inoperative during the time interval between VEF and the instant at which the pilot takes action after recognizing the engine failure. This is indicated by pilot application of the first deceleration means such as brakes, throttles, spoilers, etc. during accelerate-stop tests. The applicant may choose the sequence of events. Refer to paragraph 11 of this AC, addressing § 25.109, for a more complete description of rejected takeoff (RTO) transition procedures and associated time delays.
(6) Section 25.107(b) - Minimum Takeoff Safety Speed (V2MIN).
(a) V2MIN, in terms of calibrated airspeed, cannot be less than:
1 1.1 times the VMC defined in § 25.149.
2 1.13 times VSR for two-engine and three-engine turbopropeller and reciprocating engine-powered airplanes and for all turbojet airplanes that do not have provisions for obtaining a significant reduction in the one-engine inoperative power-on stalling speed (i.e., boundary layer control, blown flaps, etc.). The value of VSR to be used in determining V2MIN is the stall speed in the applicable takeoff configuration, landing gear retracted, except for those airplanes with a fixed landing gear or for gear-down dispatch.
(b) V2MIN may be reduced to 1.08 times VSR for turbopropeller and reciprocating engine-powered airplanes with more than three engines, and turbojet powered airplanes with adequate provisions for obtaining significant power-on stall speed reduction through the use of such things as boundary layer control, blown flaps, etc.
(c) For propeller-driven airplanes, the difference between the two margins, based upon the number of engines installed on the airplane, is because the application of power ordinarily reduces the stalling speed appreciably. In the case of the two-engine propeller-driven airplane, at least half of this reduction is eliminated by the failure of an engine. The difference in the required factors therefore provides approximately the same margin over the actual stalling speed under the power-on conditions that are obtained after the loss of an engine, no matter what the number of engines (in excess of one) may be. Unlike the propeller-driven airplane, the turbojet/turbofan powered airplane does not show any appreciable difference between the poweron and power-off stalling speed. This is due to the absence of the propeller, which ordinarily induces a slipstream with the application of power causing the wing to retain its lift to a speed lower than the power-off stalling speed. The applicant’s selection of the two speeds specified will influence the nature of the testing required in establishing the takeoff flight path.
(7) Section 25.107(c) - Takeoff Safety Speed (V2). V2 is the calibrated airspeed that is attained at or before the airplane reaches a height of 35 ft. above the takeoff surface after an
engine failure at VEF using an established rotation speed (VR). From the liftoff point, the takeoff surface extends to the end of the takeoff distance continuing at the same slope as the runway. During the takeoff speeds demonstration, V2 should be continued to an altitude sufficient to assure stable conditions beyond the 35 ft height. V2 cannot be less than V2MIN. In addition, V2 cannot be less than the liftoff speed, VLOF, which is defined in § 25.107(f). In accordance with § 25.107(c), V2 in terms of calibrated airspeed may not be less than VR plus the speed increment attained before reaching a height of 35 feet above the takeoff surface and a speed that provides the maneuvering capability specified in § 25.143(h). In addition, § 25.111(c)(2) stipulates that the airplane must reach V2 before it is 35 feet above the takeoff surface and continue at a speed not less than V2 until it is 400 feet above the takeoff surface. These requirements were first expressed in Special Civil Air Regulation No. SR-422, Turbine-Powered Transport Category Airplanes of Current Design (SR-422A), paragraphs 4T.114(b)(4) and (c)(3) and 4T.116(e). The concern that the regulation change was addressing was the overshoot of V2 after liftoff under the previous requirement that the airplane attain V2 on, or near, the ground. The intent of the current requirement is to allow an acceleration to V2 after liftoff but not to allow a decrease in the field length required to attain a height of 35 feet above the takeoff surface by attaining a speed greater than V2, under low drag ground conditions, and using the excess kinetic energy to attain the 35 foot height.
(a) In the case of turbojet powered airplanes, when most of the one-engineinoperative data have been collected using throttle chops, V2, and its relationship to VR, should be substantiated by at least a limited number of fuel cuts at VEF. For derivative programs not involving a modification that would affect thrust decay characteristics, demonstrations of fuel cuts may be unnecessary.
(b) For propeller-driven airplanes, the use of fuel cuts can be more important in order to ensure that the takeoff speeds and distances are obtained with the critical engine’s propeller attaining the position it would during a sudden engine failure. The number of tests that should be conducted using fuel cuts depends on the correlation obtained with the throttle chop data and substantiation that the data analysis methodology adequately models the effects of a sudden engine failure.
(8) Section 25.107(d) - Minimum Unstick Speed (VMU).
(a) Section 25.107(d) states, “VMU speeds must be selected by the applicant.” An applicant can either determine the lowest possible VMU speeds or select a higher speed that supports the takeoff performance targets of the airplane. Regardless of how the applicant selects the VMU speeds, compliance must be shown with § 25.107(d), (e)(1)(iv), (e)(3), and (e)(4) to show that the selected VMU speeds allow the airplane to safely lift off the ground and continue the takeoff.
(b) An applicant should comply with § 25.107(d) by conducting minimum unstick speed (VMU) tests with all engines operating and also with one engine inoperative. During these tests, the takeoff should be continued until the airplane is out of ground effect. The airplane pitch attitude should not be decreased after liftoff.
(c) VMU testing to demonstrate the lowest VMU speed is a maximum performance flight test maneuver, and liftoff may occur very near the angle-of-attack for maximum lift coefficient. Also, even though pitch attitude may be held fairly constant during the maneuver, environmental conditions and transiting through ground effect may result in changes in angle-ofattack. It is permissible to lift off at a speed that is below the normal stall warning speed, provided no more than light buffet is encountered.
1 It is important for the flight test team to understand the control laws and any transitions between control laws during takeoff (e.g., based on weight on wheels) for an electronic flight control system that may present unique hazards that should be taken into account.
2 An artificial stall warning system (e.g., a stick shaker) may be disabled during VMU testing, although doing so will require extreme caution and depend upon a thorough knowledge of the airplane’s stall characteristics, both in and out of ground effect.
3 If the airplane is equipped with a stick pusher, angle-of-attack limiter, or other system that may affect the conduct of the test, the angle of attack setting for activation of the system may be selected by the applicant and differ from the nominal setting. The system may alternatively be disabled or its activation delayed for test purposes until a safe altitude is reached. However, for airplanes equipped with a stick pusher that is not designed to be inhibited during takeoff, the VMU test demonstrations will need to be assessed and will only remain valid if the stick pusher would not have activated with the angle-of-attack indication means set at the lowest angle within production tolerances.
(d) In lieu of conducting one-engine-inoperative VMU tests, the applicant may conduct all-engines-operating VMU tests if all pertinent factors that would be associated with an actual one-engine-inoperative VMU test are simulated or otherwise taken into account. To take into account all pertinent factors, it may be necessary to adjust the resulting VMU test values analytically. The factors to be accounted for should include at least the following:
1 Thrust/weight ratio for the one-engine-inoperative range.
2 Controllability (may be related to one-engine-inoperative free air tests, such as VMCA).
3 Increased drag due to use of lateral/directional control systems.
4 Reduced lift due to use of devices such as wing spoilers for lateral control.
5 Adverse effects of use of any other systems or devices on control, drag, or lift.
(e) The number of VMU tests needed may be minimized by testing only the critical all-engines-operating and one-engine-inoperative thrust/weight ratios, provided the VMU speeds determined at these critical conditions are used for the range of thrust/weights appropriate
to the all-engines-operating and one-engine-inoperative configurations. The critical thrust/weight is established by correcting, to the VMU speed, the thrust that results in the airplane achieving its limiting one-engine-inoperative climb gradient at the normally scheduled speed and in the appropriate configuration.
(f) Amendment 25-42, effective March 1, 1978, revised §§ 25.107(d) and 25.107(e)(1)(iv) in order to permit the one-engine-inoperative VMU to be determined by allengines-operating tests at the thrust/weight ratio corresponding to the one-engine-inoperative condition. As revised, § 25.107(d) specifies that VMU must be selected for the range of thrust/weight ratios to be certificated, rather than for the all-engines-operating and one-engineinoperative conditions as was previously required. In determining the all-engines-operating thrust/weight ratio that corresponds to the one-engine-inoperative condition, consider trim and control drag differences between the two configurations in addition to the effect of the number of engines operating. The minimum thrust/weight ratio to be certificated is established by correcting, to the VMU speed, the thrust that results in the airplane achieving its limiting engineout climb gradient in the appropriate configuration and at the normally scheduled speed.
(g) To conduct the VMU tests, rotate the airplane as necessary to achieve the VMU attitude. It is acceptable to use some additional nose-up trim over the normal trim setting during VMU demonstrations. If additional nose-up trim is required, the additional considerations of paragraph (g), below, apply. VMU is the speed at which the weight of the airplane is completely supported by aerodynamic lift and thrust forces. Some judgment may be necessary on airplanes that have tilting main landing gear bogies. Determining the liftoff point from gear loads and wheel speeds has been found acceptable in past programs. After liftoff, the airplane should be flown out of ground effect. During liftoff and the subsequent climbout, the airplane should be fully controllable.
(h) VMU Testing for Airplanes Having Limited Pitch Control Authority.
1 For some airplanes with limited pitch control authority, it may not be possible, at forward c.g. and normal trim, to rotate the airplane to a liftoff attitude where the airplane could otherwise perform a clean flyaway at a minimum speed had the required attitude been achieved. This may occur only over a portion of the takeoff weight range in some configurations. Though generally associated with the inability of the pitch control surfaces to provide adequate pitching moment to rotate the airplane to the desired pitch attitude at low thrust/weight ratio conditions, the same phenomenon may occur at high thrust/weight ratio conditions for airplanes with high thrust lines (e.g., aft engines mounted high on the fuselage). When limited pitch control authority is clearly shown to be the case, VMU test conditions may be modified to allow testing aft of the forward c.g. limit and/or with use of more airplane nose-up trim than normal. The VMU data determined with this procedure should be corrected to those values representative of the appropriate forward limit; the variation of VMU with c.g. may be assumed to be like the variation of free air stalling speed with c.g. Although the development of scheduled takeoff speeds may proceed from these corrected VMU data, additional tests are required (see paragraph 2 below) to check that the relaxed VMU criteria have not neglected problems that might arise from operational variations in rotating airplanes with limited pitch control authority.
2 In the following assurance test, the airplane should demonstrate safe flyaway characteristics.
(aa) Minimum speed liftoff should be demonstrated at the critical forward c.g. limit with normal trim. For airplanes with a cutback forward c.g. at heavy weight, two weight/c.g. conditions should be considered. The heavy weight tests should be conducted at maximum structural or maximum sea level climb-limited weight with the associated forward c.g. The full forward c.g. tests should be conducted at the highest associated weight. Alternatively, testing may be conducted at a single weight if an analysis is provided that identifies the critical weight/c.g. combination with regard to limited pitch attitude capability for liftoff.
(bb) These assurance tests should be conducted at the thrust/weight ratio that is most critical for attaining a pitch attitude that will provide a minimum liftoff speed.
(i) For airplanes that are limited by low thrust/weight conditions, tests should be conducted at the minimum thrust/weight ratio for both the simulated one-engineinoperative test (i.e., symmetrical reduced thrust) case and the all-engines-operating case.
(ii) For airplanes that are limited by high thrust/weight conditions, tests should be conducted at the highest thrust/weight ratio within the airplane’s operating envelope for both the simulated one-engine-inoperative case (i.e., symmetrical reduced thrust) and the all-engines-operating case.
(cc) One acceptable test technique is to hold full nose-up control column as the airplane accelerates. As pitch attitude is achieved to establish the minimum liftoff speed, pitch control may be adjusted to prevent over-rotation, but the liftoff attitude should be maintained as the airplane flies off the ground and out of ground effect.
(dd) The resulting liftoff speeds are acceptable if the test proves successful and the liftoff speed is at least 5 knots below the normally scheduled liftoff speed.
(ee) This minimum 5 knot margin from the scheduled liftoff speed provides some leeway for operational variations such as mis-trim, c.g. errors, etc., that could further limit the elevator authority. The reduced VMU margins arising from this test, relative to those specified in § 25.107(e)(1)(iv), are considered acceptable because of the reduced probability of a pitch control authority-limited airplane getting into a high drag condition due to over-rotation.
(i) VMU Testing for Geometry Limited Airplanes.
1 For airplanes that are geometry limited (i.e., the minimum possible VMU speeds are limited by tail contact with the runway), § 25.107(e)(1)(iv)(B) allows the VMU to VLOF speed margins to be reduced to 108 percent and 104 percent for the all-engines-operating and one-engine-inoperative conditions, respectively. The VMU demonstrated should be sound and repeatable.
2 An airplane that is deemed to be geometry limited at the conditions tested is expected to be geometry limited over its entire takeoff operating envelope. If this is not the case, the airplane is not considered geometry limited and the reduced VMU to VLOF speed margins do not apply.
3 One acceptable means for demonstrating compliance with §§ 25.107(d) and 25.107(e)(1)(iv) with respect to the capability for a safe liftoff and fly-away from the geometry limited condition is to show that at the lowest thrust-to-weight ratio for the all-enginesoperating condition:
(aa) In the speed range from 96 to 100 percent of the actual liftoff speed), the aft under-surface of the airplane should be in contact with the runway. Because of the dynamic nature of the test, it is recognized that contact will probably not be maintained during this entire speed range, so some judgment is necessary. It has been found acceptable for contact to exist approximately 50 percent of the time that the airplane is in this speed range.
(bb) Beyond the point of liftoff to a height of 35 feet, the airplane’s pitch attitude should not decrease below that at the point of liftoff, nor should the speed increase more than 10 percent.
(cc) The horizontal distance from the start of the takeoff to a height of 35 feet above the takeoff surface should not be greater than 105 percent of the distance determined in accordance with § 25.113(a)(2) without applying the 115 percent factor.
(j) VMU for a Stretched Version of a Tested Airplane.
1 VMU speeds obtained by flight testing one model of an airplane type may be used to generate VMU speeds for a geometry-limited stretched version of that airplane. If the short body airplane met the criteria for the 104/108 percent VMU/VLOF speed margin for geometry limited airplanes as permitted by § 25.107(e)(1)(iv)(B) and discussed in paragraph 10b(8)(i)1, the flight tests described in paragraph 10b(8)(i)3 should be performed on the stretched derivative. Otherwise, the flight tests described in paragraph 10b(8)(j)2(bb) should be performed on the stretched derivative.
2 Since the concern for tail strikes is increased with the stretched airplane, the following should be accomplished, in addition to normal takeoff tests, when the VMU schedule of the stretched derivative is derived from that of the shorter body parent airplane:
(aa) The minimum unstick speed (VMU) of the stretched derivative airplane should be determined by correcting the VMU of the shorter body tested airplane for the reduced runway pitch attitude capability and revised c.g. range of the stretched airplane. Alternatively, stretched airplane VMU speeds not determined in this manner should be substantiated by flight testing or a rational analysis. Scheduled rotation speeds (VR) for the stretched airplane should result in at least the required liftoff speed margins above the corrected
VMU required by § 25.107(e)(1)(iv) for the one-engine-inoperative and all-engines-operating takeoff conditions.
(bb) At both the forward and aft c.g. limits, and over the thrust-to-weight range for each takeoff flap, the following takeoff tests should be accomplished. The tests described in paragraphs (i) and (ii), below, should be accomplished with not more than occasional, minor (i.e., non-damaging) tail strikes.
(i) All-engines-operating, early rotation tests specified in paragraph 10b(9)(c)2, including both the rapid rotations and over-rotations as separate test conditions. (ii) One-engine-inoperative, early rotation tests specified in paragraph 10b(9)(b).
(iii) All-engines-operating, moderate rotation rate (i.e., more rapid than normal) takeoff tests, using the scheduled VR and normal pitch attitude after liftoff. Tail strikes should not occur for this condition.
(9) Section 25.107(e) - Rotation Speed (VR). (a) The rotation speed, (VR) in terms of calibrated airspeed, must be selected by the applicant. VR has a number of constraints that must be observed in order to comply with § 25.107(e):
1 VR may not be less than V1; however, it can be equal to V1 in some cases. 2 VR may not be less than 105 percent of the air minimum control speed (VMCA).
3 VR must be a speed that will allow the airplane to reach V2 at or before reaching a height of 35 ft. above the takeoff surface.
4 VR must be a speed that will result in liftoff at a speed not less than 110 percent of VMU (unless geometry limited) for the all-engines-operating condition and not less than 105 percent of the VMU (unless geometry limited) determined at the thrust/weight ratio corresponding to the one-engine-inoperative condition for each set of conditions such as weight, altitude, temperature, and configuration when the airplane is rotated at its maximum practicable rate.
(b) Early rotation, one-engine-inoperative test.
1 In showing compliance with § 25.107(e)(3), some guidance relative to the airspeed attained at the 35 ft. height during the associated flight test is necessary. As this requirement only specifies an early rotation (VR-5 knots), it is interpreted that pilot technique is to remain the same as normally used for a one-engine-inoperative condition. With these considerations in mind, it is apparent that the airspeed achieved at the 35 ft. point can be
somewhat below the normal scheduled V2 speed. However, the amount of permissible V2 speed reduction should be limited to a reasonable amount as described below.
2 These test criteria apply to all unapproved, new, basic model airplanes. They also apply to previously approved airplanes when subsequent testing is warranted. However, for those airplanes where these criteria are more stringent than those previously applied, consideration will be given to permitting some latitude in the test criteria.
3 In conducting the flight tests required by § 25.107(e)(3), the test pilot should use the normal/natural rotation technique associated with the use of scheduled takeoff speeds for the airplane being tested. Intentional tail or tail skid contact is not considered acceptable. Non-damaging contact due to inadvertent over-rotation is acceptable provided there is a prompt recovery to the normal one-engine-inoperative takeoff pitch attitude. Further, the airspeed attained at the 35 ft. height during this test should not be less than the scheduled V2 value minus 5 knots. These speed limits should not be considered or used as target V2 test speeds, but rather are intended to provide an acceptable range of speed departure below the scheduled V2 value.
4 In this test, the simulated engine failure should be accomplished sufficiently in advance of the VR test speed to allow for engine spin-down, unless this would be below the VMCG, in which case VMCG should govern. The normal one-engine-inoperative takeoff distance may be analytically adjusted to compensate for the effect of the early power or thrust reduction. Further, in those tests where the airspeed achieved at the 35-ft. height is slightly less than the V2-5 knots limiting value, it will be permissible, in lieu of conducting the tests again, to analytically adjust the test distance to account for the excessive speed decrement.
(c) All-engines-operating tests.
1 Section 25.107(e)(4) states that there must not be a “marked increase” in the scheduled takeoff distance when reasonably expected service variations such as early and excessive rotation and out-of-trim conditions are encountered. This has been interpreted as requiring takeoff tests with all engines operating with:
(aa) A lower than scheduled rotation speed, and (bb) Out-of-trim conditions, but with rotation at the scheduled VR speed.
NOTE: The expression “marked increase” in the takeoff distance is considered to be any amount in excess of 1 percent of the scheduled takeoff distance. Thus, the tests should not result in field lengths more than 101 percent of the takeoff field lengths calculated in accordance with the applicable requirements of part 25 for presentation in the AFM.
2 For the early rotation condition with all engines operating, and at a weight as near as practicable to the maximum sea level standard day takeoff weight limit, it should be shown by tests that when the airplane is rotated at a speed below the scheduled VR, no “marked
increase” in the scheduled AFM field length will result. For these tests, the airplane should be rotated at a speed equal to the scheduled VR minus 7 percent or the scheduled VR minus 10 knots, whichever results in the higher rotation speed. Tests should be conducted at: (1) a rapid rotation rate to the normal takeoff attitude, and (2) an over-rotation of 2 degrees above normal attitude after liftoff at the normal rotation rate. For tests using over rotations, the resulting increased pitch attitude should be maintained until the airplane is out of ground effect. Tail strikes during this demonstration are acceptable if they are minor and do not result in unsafe conditions.
3 For reasonably expected out-of-trim conditions with all engines operating and as near as practicable to the maximum weight allowed under sea level standard day conditions, it should be shown that there will not be a “marked increase” in the scheduled AFM takeoff distance when rotation is initiated in a normal manner at the scheduled VR speed. The amount of mistrim should be the maximum mistrim that would not result in a takeoff configuration warning, including taking into account the takeoff configuration warning system rigging tolerance. It is permissible to accept an analysis in lieu of actual testing if the analysis shows that the out-of-trim condition would not present unsafe flight characteristics or a “marked increase” in the scheduled AFM field lengths.
4 Section 25.107(e)(4) also states that the reasonably expected variations in service from the established takeoff procedures for the operation of the airplane may not result in unsafe flight characteristics. For example, for an airplane loaded to obtain a forward c.g. position and mistrimmed for an aft c.g. loading, it may not be possible to rotate at the normal operating speeds due to excessive control force or lack of primary pitch control authority. This may result in an excessive delay in accomplishing the rotation. Such a condition would be considered an unsafe flight characteristic. Similarly, for an airplane loaded to obtain an aft c.g. position and mistrimmed for a forward c.g. loading, it may not be possible to readily arrest a selfrotating tendency. This rotation, if abrupt enough and rapid enough, could lead to stall. Qualitative assessments should be made by the test pilot in the following takeoff tests with all engines operating:
(aa) The test pilot should determine that no unsafe characteristics exist with the airplane loaded to the forward c.g. limit and the stabilizer mistrimmed in the airplane nose-down direction. The amount of mistrim should be the maximum mistrim that would not result in a configuration warning (including taking into account takeoff warning system tolerances). Rotation should be initiated at the scheduled rotation speed for the airplane weight and ambient conditions. Unsafe characteristics include an excessive pitch control force to obtain normal airplane response or an excessive time to achieve perceptible rotation.
(bb) The test pilot should determine that no unsafe characteristics exist with the airplane loaded to the aft c.g. limit and the stabilizer mistrimmed in the airplane nose-up direction. The amount of mistrim should be the maximum mistrim that would not result in a configuration warning (including taking into account takeoff warning system tolerances). The airplane should be rotated at the scheduled rotation speed for the airplane weight and ambient conditions. Unsafe characteristics include: an abrupt self rotating tendency that cannot be checked with normal control input, or an excessive pitch control force required to maintain the
11. Accelerate-Stop Distance - § 25.109.
airplane in the normal pitch attitude prior to the scheduled rotation speed or during rotation and initial climb.
(cc) For the tests described in paragraphs (aa) and (bb) above, the flight characteristics should be assessed at the most critical combinations of airplane weight, wing flap position and engine power or thrust for the out of trim position being considered.
(d) Stall Warning During Takeoff Speed Tests. The presumption is that if an operational pilot was to make an error in takeoff speeds that resulted in an encounter with stall warning, the likely response would be to recover aggressively to a safe flight condition rather than trying to duplicate the AFM takeoff flight path. Therefore, the activation of any stall warning devices, or the occurrence of airframe buffeting during takeoff speed testing, is unacceptable.
(e) Stick Forces During Takeoff Speed Tests. Per § 25.143(a)(1) and (b), stick forces to initiate rotation and continue the takeoff during takeoff flight testing must comply with the control force limits of § 25.143(d). This includes the mistrim takeoff tests described in paragraphs 10b(9)(c)4(aa) and (bb) to show compliance with § 25.107 (e)(4), which are considered to represent probable operating conditions under § 25.143(b). Stick forces should be those that result from using the takeoff procedures established by the manufacturer for use in operational service in accordance with § 25.101(f) and must comply with § 25.101(h).
(10) Section 25.107(f) - Liftoff Speed (VLOF).
(a) The liftoff speed (VLOF) is defined as the calibrated airspeed at which the airplane first becomes airborne (i.e., no contact with the runway). This allows comparison of liftoff speed with tire limit speed. VLOF differs from VMU in that VMU is the minimum possible VLOF speed for a given configuration, and depending upon landing gear design, VMU liftoff is shown to be the point where all of the airplane weight is being supported by airplane lift and thrust forces and not any portion by the landing gear. For example, after the VMU speed is reached, a truck tilt actuator may force a front or rear wheel set to be in contact with the runway, even though the liftoff is in progress by virtue of lift being greater than weight.
(b) The maximum ground speed at liftoff, considering the entire takeoff operating envelope and taking into account 50 percent of the headwind and 150 percent of the tailwind, in accordance with § 25.105(d)(1), must not exceed the tire speed rating established under § 25.733(a) or (c).
11. Accelerate-Stop Distance - § 25.109.
a. Explanation.
(1) The accelerate-stop distance is the horizontal distance from a reference point on the airplane at initial brake release to that same reference point after the airplane is brought to a stop.
(2) This section describes test demonstrations and data expansion methods necessary to determine accelerate-stop distances for publication in the FAA AFM, as required by § 25.1583(h) (by reference to § 25.1533). Amendment 25-92 revised some aspects of the part 25 accelerate-stop criteria and added new requirements related to the stopping capability of the airplane as affected by brake wear and wet runways. The changes imparted to the acceleratestop requirements by Amendment 25-92 are listed below. (For other material related to the use of accelerate-stop distances, see parts 121 and 135 of the Code of Federal Regulations)
(a) Section 25.101(i) was added to require accelerate-stop distances to be determined with all the airplane wheel brake assemblies at the fully worn limit of their allowable wear range.
(b) Section 25.105(c)(1) was revised to require takeoff data to be determined for wet, in addition to dry, hard surfaced runways. At the applicant’s option, takeoff data may also be determined for wet runways that have grooved or porous friction course surfaces.
(c) Section 25.107(a)(2) was revised to remove the reference to “takeoff decision speed” from the definition of V1. V1 is the speed by which the pilot has already made the decision to reject the takeoff and has initiated the first action to stop the airplane.
(d) Section 25.109 was revised to add a requirement to determine accelerate-stop distances for wet runways. Additionally, the requirement for the AFM expansion to include two seconds of continued acceleration beyond V1, with the operating engines at takeoff power or thrust, as introduced by Amendment 25-42, was replaced with a distance increment equivalent to two seconds at V1. Also, the text of § 25.109(a) was modified to clarify that the accelerate-stop distances must take into account the highest speed reached during the rejected takeoff maneuver, including, as applicable, speeds higher than V1.
(e) Section 25.109(f) was added to permit credit for the use of reverse thrust in determining wet runway accelerate-stop distances (subject to the requirements of § 25.109(e)) and to explicitly deny reverse thrust credit for determining dry runway accelerate-stop distances.
(f) Section 25.109(i) was added to require a maximum brake energy acceleratestop test to be conducted with not more than 10 percent of the allowable brake wear range remaining on each individual wheel-brake assembly.
(g) Section 25.735(h) was added to require the maximum rejected takeoff brake energy absorption capacity rating used during qualification testing to the applicable Technical Standard Order to be based on the fully worn limit of the brake’s allowable wear range.
NOTE: Section 25.735, has been more recently revised by Amendment 25-107, which moved the rejected takeoff kinetic energy rating requirements into § 25.735(f).
(h) Section 25.1533(a)(3) was revised to add runway surface condition (dry or wet) as a variable that must be accounted for in establishing minimum takeoff distances. Section 25.1533(a)(3) was also revised to allow wet runway takeoff distances on grooved and porous friction course (PFC) runways to be established as additional operating limitations, but approval to use these distances is limited to runways that have been designed, constructed, and maintained in a manner acceptable to the FAA Administrator. b. The applicable part 25 regulations are § 25.109, and the following:
§ 25.101(f) Airplane configuration and procedures
§ 25.101(h) Pilot action time delay allowances
§ 25.101(i) Worn brake stopping performance
§ 25.105 Takeoff configuration and environmental and runway conditions
§ 25.107(a)(l) & (2) V1 and VEF speed definitions
§ 25.735 Brakes and braking systems
§ 25.1301 Function and installation
§ 25.1309 Equipment, systems, and installation
§ 25.1533 Additional operating limitations - maximum takeoff weights and minimum takeoff distances
§ 25.1583(h) AFM - operating limitations
§ 25.1587 AFM - performance information c. Procedures. The following paragraphs provide guidance for accomplishing acceleratestop flight tests and expanding the resulting data for the determination of AFM performance information.
(1) Accelerate-stop testing. The following guidance applies to turbine-powered airplanes with and without propellers. Guidance regarding flight testing applies only to dry runway accelerate-stop distances. Guidance for expanding the flight test data to determine AFM distances applies to both dry and wet runways, unless otherwise noted. Further guidance for determining wet runway accelerate-stop distances is provided in paragraph 11c(4).
(a) In order to establish a distance that would be representative of the distance needed in the event of a rejected takeoff, where the first action to stop the airplane is taken at V1, a sufficient number of test runs should be conducted for each airplane configuration specified by the applicant. (For intermediate configurations, see paragraph 3 of this AC.)
(b) The guidance outlined in paragraph 11c(3) describes how to include allowances for any time delays, as required by § 25.101(h)(3), for the flightcrew to accomplish the rejected takeoff operating procedures.
(c) Section 25.101(i) states that the accelerate-stop distances must be determined with all the airplane wheel-brake assemblies at the fully worn limit of their allowable wear range. The fully worn limit is defined as the maximum amount of wear allowed before the brake is to be removed from the airplane for overhaul. The allowable wear should be defined in terms of a linear dimension in the axial direction, which is typically determined by measuring the wear pin extension.
1 The only accelerate-stop test that must be conducted at a specific brake wear state is the maximum brake kinetic energy demonstration, which must use brakes that have no more than 10 percent of the allowable brake wear range remaining, as required by § 25.109(i). (See paragraph 11c(2)(c) of this AC). The remainder of the accelerate-stop tests may be conducted with the brakes in any wear state as long as a suitable combination of airplane and dynamometer tests is used to determine the accelerate-stop distances corresponding to fully worn brakes. For example, dynamometer testing may be used to determine whether there is a reduction in brake performance from the wear state used in the airplane tests to a fully worn brake. The airplane test data could then be adjusted analytically for this difference without additional airplane testing.
2 Either airplane-worn or mechanically-worn brakes (i.e., machined or dynamometer worn) may be used. If mechanically-worn brakes are used, it should be shown that they can be expected to provide similar results to airplane-worn brakes. This comparison can be based on service experience on the test brake or an appropriate equivalent brake, or on dynamometer wear test data when service data are unavailable.
(d) Section 25.109(f)(1) denies credit for the use of reverse thrust as a decelerating means in determining the accelerate-stop distance for a dry runway. This provision applies to both turbine engine and propeller engine reverse thrust (but not to any drag resulting from the ground idle power setting for a propeller engine). Credit for the additional deceleration available from reverse thrust is permitted for wet runway accelerate-stop distances, provided the thrust reverser system is shown to be safe, reliable, capable of giving repeatable results, and does not require exceptional skill to control the airplane. (See paragraph 11c(4)(e) for guidance related to obtaining accelerate-stop performance credit for reverse thrust on wet runways.)
(e) The accelerate-stop test runs should be conducted at weight/speed combinations that will provide an even distribution of test conditions over the range of weights, speeds, and brake energies for which takeoff data will be provided in the AFM. The effects of different airport elevations can be simulated at one airport elevation, provided the braking speeds employed are relevant for the range of airplane energies to be absorbed by the brakes. The limiting brake energy value in the AFM should not exceed the maximum demonstrated in these tests or the maximum for which the brake has been approved. (See paragraph 11c(2) for further guidance related to tests and analyses for the demonstration of the maximum brake energy absorption capability.)
(f) The V1 speeds used in the accelerate-stop tests need not correspond precisely to the AFM values for the test conditions since it may be necessary to increase or decrease the AFM V1 speed to investigate fully the energy range and weight envelope.
(g) A total of at least six accelerate-stop flight tests should be conducted. Unless sufficient data are available for the specific airplane type showing how braking performance varies with weight, kinetic energy, lift, drag, ground speed, torque limit, etc., at least two tests should be conducted for each configuration when the same braking coefficient of friction is being claimed for multiple aerodynamic configurations. These tests should be conducted on smooth, hard surfaced, dry runways.
(h) For approval of dispatch capability with anti-skid inoperative, nose wheel brakes or specified main wheel-brake(s) inoperative, automatic braking systems, etc., a full set of tests, as described in paragraph (g) above, should normally be conducted. A lesser number of tests may be accepted for “equal or better” demonstrations, to establish small increments or if adequate conservatism is used during testing.
(i) Either ground or airborne instrumentation should include means to determine the horizontal distance time-history.
(j) The wind speed and direction relative to the test runway should be determined and corrected to a height corresponding to the approximate height of the mean aerodynamic chord. (See paragraph 3 of this AC.)
(k) The accelerate-stop tests should be conducted in the following configurations:
1 Heavy to light weight as required.
2 Most critical c.g. position.
3 Wing flaps in the takeoff position(s).
4 Tire pressure: before taxi and with cold tires, set to the highest value appropriate to the takeoff weight for which approval is being sought.
5 Engine idle power or thrust: set at the recommended upper limit for use on the ground or the effect of maximum ground idle power or thrust may be accounted for in data analyses. For maximum brake energy and fuse plug no-melt tests, data analysis may not be used in place of maximum ground idle power or thrust.
(l) Engine power or thrust should be appropriate to each segment of the rejected takeoff and should include accounting for power or thrust decay rates (i.e., spin down) for failed or throttled back engines.
1 Turbojet powered airplanes. For AFM calculation purposes, the critical engine failure accelerate-stop data may be based on the failed engine spinning down to a windmilling condition.
NOTE: If, due to the certification basis of the airplane, all-engine-accelerate-stop distances are not being considered, the one-engine-inoperative AFM distances should be based on the critical engine failing to maximum ground idle power or thrust rather than the windmilling condition.
2 The power or thrust from the operative engine(s) should be consistent with a throttle chop to maximum ground idle power or thrust. For determining the all-enginesoperating dry runway accelerate-stop AFM distances, the stopping portion should be based on all engines producing maximum ground idle power or thrust (after engine spin down), as noted in paragraph 11c(1)(k)5. The accelerate-stop tests may be conducted with either concurrent or sequential throttle chops to idle power or thrust as long as the data are adjusted to take into account pilot reaction time, and any control, system, or braking differences (e.g., electrical or hydraulic/mechanical transients associated with an engine failing to a windmilling condition resulting in reduced braking effectiveness). Test data should also be analytically corrected for any differences between maximum ground idle power or thrust and the idle power or thrust level achieved during the test. For the criteria relating to reverse thrust credit for wet runway accelerate-stop distances, see paragraph 11c(4)(e).
3 Turbopropeller-powered airplanes. For the one-engine-inoperative accelerate-stop distances, the critical engine’s propeller should be in the position it would normally assume when an engine fails and the power levers are closed. For dry runway oneengine-inoperative accelerate-stop distances, the high drag ground-idle position of the operating engines’ propellers (defined by a pitch setting that results in not less than zero total thrust, i.e., propeller plus jet thrust, at zero airspeed) may be used provided adequate directional control is available on a wet runway and the related operational procedures comply with § 25.101(f) and (h). Wet runway controllability may either be demonstrated by using the guidance available in paragraph 11c(4)(e)6 at the appropriate power level, or adequate control can be assumed to be available at ground idle power if reverse thrust credit is approved for determining the wet runway accelerate-stop distances. For the all-engines-operating accelerate-stop distances on a dry runway, the high drag ground-idle propeller position may be used for all engines (subject to § 25.101(f) and (h)). For the criteria relating to reverse thrust credit for wet runway acceleratestop distances, see paragraph 11c(4)(e).
(m) System transient effects (e.g., engine spin-down, brake pressure ramp-up, etc.) should be determined and properly accounted for in the calculation of AFM accelerate-stop distances (see paragraph 11c(3)(i)).
(2) Maximum Brake Energy Testing. The following paragraphs describe regulatory requirements and acceptable test methods for conducting an accelerate-stop test run to demonstrate the maximum energy absorption capability of the wheel brakes.
(a) The maximum brake energy accelerate-stop demonstration should be conducted at not less than the maximum takeoff weight. It should be preceded by at least a 3mile taxi with all engines operating at maximum ground idle power or thrust, including three full stops using normal braking. Following the maximum brake energy stop, it will not be necessary to demonstrate the airplane’s ability to taxi.
(b) Section 25.735(f)(2) requires the maximum kinetic energy accelerate-stop absorption capability of each wheel, tire, and brake assembly to be determined. It also requires dynamometer testing to show that the wheel, brake, and tire assembly is capable of absorbing not less than this level of kinetic energy throughout the defined wear range of the brake. The calculation of maximum brake energy limited takeoff weights and speeds, for presentation in the AFM performance section, therefore should be based on the most critical wear range of the brake.
(c) Section 25.109(i) requires a flight test demonstration of the maximum brake kinetic energy accelerate-stop distance to be conducted with not more than 10 percent of the allowable brake wear range remaining on each of the airplane wheel-brakes. The 10 percent allowance on the brake wear state is intended to ease test logistics and increase test safety, not to allow the accelerate-stop distance to be determined with less than fully worn brakes. If the brakes are not in the fully worn state at the beginning of the test, the accelerate-stop distance should be corrected as necessary to represent the stopping capability of fully worn brakes.
(d) The maximum airplane brake energy allowed for dispatch should not exceed the value for which a satisfactory after-stop condition exists, or the value documented under the applicable TSO (or an acceptable equivalent), whichever value is less. A satisfactory after-stop condition is defined as one in which fires are confined to tires, wheels, and brakes, such that progressive engulfment of the rest of the airplane would not occur during the time of passenger and crew evacuation. The application of fire fighting means or artificial coolants should not be required for a period of 5 minutes following the stop.
(e) Landings are not an acceptable means for demonstrating the maximum rejected takeoff brake energy. Though permitted in the past, service experience has shown that methods used to predict brake and tire temperature increases that would have occurred during taxi and acceleration, as specified in paragraph 11c(2)(a), were not able to accurately account for the associated energy increments.
(3) Accelerate-Stop Time Delays. Section 25.101(h) requires allowance for time delays in the execution of procedures. Amendment 25-42 (effective March 1, 1978) amended the airworthiness standards to clarify and standardize the method of applying these time delays to the accelerate-stop transition period. Amendment 25-42 also added the critical engine failure speed, VEF, and clarified the meaning of V1 with relation to VEF. The preamble to Amendment 25-42 states that “V1 is determined by adding to VEF (the speed at which the critical engine is assumed to fail) the speed gained with the critical engine inoperative during the time interval between the instant at which the critical engine is failed and the instant at which the test pilot recognizes and reacts to the engine failure, as indicated by the pilot’s application of the first retarding means during accelerate-stop tests.” Thus it can be seen that V1 is not only intended to be at the end of the decision process, but it also includes the time it takes for the pilot to perform the first action to stop the airplane. (See Appendix 3 for further discussion on the historical development of accelerate-stop time delays.) The purpose of the time delays is to allow sufficient time (and distance) for a pilot, in actual operations, to accomplish the procedures for stopping the airplane. The time delays are not intended to allow extra time for making a decision
to stop as the airplane passes through V1. Since the typical transport category airplane requires three pilot actions (i.e., brakes-throttles-spoilers) to achieve the final braking configuration, amendment 25-42 defined a two-second time period, in § 25.109, to account for delays in activating the second and third deceleration devices. Amendment 25-92 (effective March 20, 1998) redefined, and reinterpreted the application of that two-second delay time as a distance increment equivalent to two seconds at V1. No credit may be taken for system transient effects (e.g., engine spin-down, brake pressure ramp-up, etc.) in determining this distance. The following paragraphs provide guidance related to the interpretation and application of delay times to show compliance with the accelerate-stop requirements of Amendment 25-92. (a) Figure 11-1 presents a pictorial representation of the accelerate-stop time delays considered acceptable for compliance with § 25.101(h) as discussed above.
Figure 11-1. Accelerate-Stop Time Delays
Initiation of
first pilot
action
Initiation of second pilot
action
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 1088 passages shown