AC 150/5335-5B Standardized Method of Reporting Airport Pavement Strength - PCN
Provides guidance for using the standardized International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) method, called the Aircraft Classification Number – Pavement Classification Number (ACN-PCN) method, to report airport runway, taxiway, and apron pavement strength. Includes instructions for using the COMFAA program to calculate ACN values to determine PCN. Also provides guidance for reporting changes to airport data that is generally published on Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Form 5010, Airport Master Record, particularly those data elements associated with Gross Weight (Data Elements 35 through 38) and Pavement Classification Number (Data Element 39). Access COMFAA and related Support Spreadsheet on our Airport Design Software page.
This document is cancelled. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.
U.S. Department of Transportation
Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory Circular
Subject: Standardized Method of Reporting Airport Pavement Strength - PCN
Date: 8/26/2011 AC No: 150/5335-5B Initiated by: AAS-100 Change:
1. PURPOSE OF THIS ADVISORY CIRCULAR.
a. This advisory circular (AC) provides guidance for using the standardized International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) method to report airport runway, taxiway, and apron pavement strength. ICAO requires member states to report aerodrome-related aeronautical data, including pavement strength. The standardized method, known as the Aircraft Classification Number – Pavement Classification Number (ACN-PCN) method, has been developed and adopted as an international standard and has facilitated the exchange of pavement strength rating information.
b. The AC provides guidance for reporting changes to airport data that is generally published on Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Form 5010, Airport Master Record. The data elements associated with Gross Weight (Data Elements 35 through 38) and Pavement Classification Number (Data Element 39) are affected.
2. EFFECTIVE DATE.
Effective three years after the issue date of this AC, all public-use paved runways at primary airports serving air carrier aircraft should (will, if mandatory through the Applicability paragraph, below) be assigned gross weight and PCN data using the guidance provided in this AC. Effective five years after the issue date of this AC, all public-use paved runways at nonprimary commercial service airports serving air carrier aircraft should (will, if mandatory through the Applicability paragraph, below) be assigned gross weight and PCN data using the guidance provided in this AC.
3. APPLICABILITY.
The FAA recommends the guidelines and specifications in this AC for reporting airport pavement strength using the standardized method. In general, use of this AC is not mandatory. However, use of this AC is mandatory for all projects funded with Federal grant monies through the Airport Improvement Program (AIP) and with revenue from the Passenger Facility Charge (PFC) Program. See Grant Assurance No. 34, “Policies, Standards, and Specifications,” and PFC Assurance No. 9, “Standards and Specifications.”
4. WHAT THIS AC CANCELS.
This AC cancels AC 150/5335-5A, Standardized Method of Reporting Airport Pavement Strength – PCN, dated September 28, 2006.
AC 150/5335-5B 8/26/2011
ii
5. PRINCIPAL CHANGES.
a. Chapter 3 now incorporates the improvements to the COMFAA program.
b. Appendix 1 now introduces a cumulative damage factor method for computing PCN based on equivalent traffic.
c. A new Appendix 2 facilitates converting existing pavement cross-section information to a standard section required for PCN calculations.
d. Appendix 3 now includes examples using the new method for determining PCN.
e. Appendix 4 now uses the new PCN calculation method to consider pavement overloads.
f. New Appendices 5 and 6 revise the standard for reporting airport data for runway weight bearing capacity.
6. RELATED READING MATERIAL.
The publications listed in Appendix 7 provide further information on the development and use of the ACN-PCN method.
Michael J. O’Donnell
Director, Office of Airport Safety and Standards
8/26/2011 AC 150/5335-5B
iii
Table of Contents
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION … 1
1.0 BACKGROUND … 1 1.1 DEVELOPMENT OF A STANDARDIZED METHOD … 1 1.2 APPLICATION … 1 1.3 LIMITATIONS OF THE ACN-PCN SYSTEM … 2
CHAPTER 2. DETERMINATION OF AIRCRAFT CLASSIFICATION NUMBER … 3
2.0 DETERMINATION OF THE ACN … 3 2.1 SUBGRADE CATEGORY … 3 2.2 OPERATIONAL FREQUENCY … 3 2.3 RIGID PAVEMENT ACN … 4 2.4 FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT ACN … 4 2.5 ACN CALCULATION … 4 2.6 VARIABLES INVOLVED IN DETERMINATION OF ACN VALUES … 4
CHAPTER 3. DETERMINATION OF ACN VALUES USING COMFAA … 5
3.0 AVAILABILITY OF COMFAA SOFTWARE APPLICATION … 5 3.1 ORIGIN OF THE COMFAA PROGRAM … 5 3.2 COMFAA PROGRAM … 5 3.3 INTERNAL AIRCRAFT LIBRARY … 6 3.4 EXTERNAL AIRCRAFT LIBRARY … 6 3.5 USING THE COMFAA PROGRAM … 7
CHAPTER 4. DETERMINATION OF PCN NUMERICAL VALUE … 11
4.0 PCN CONCEPT … 11 4.1 DETERMINATION OF NUMERICAL PCN VALUE … 11 4.2 USING AIRCRAFT METHOD TO DETERMINE PCN … 11 4.3 TECHNICAL EVALUATION METHOD TO DETERMINE PCN … 12 4.4 LIMITATIONS OF THE PCN … 13 4.5 REPORTING THE PCN … 13
APPENDIX 1. EQUIVALENT TRAFFIC … A1-1
APPENDIX 2. TECHNICAL EVALUATION METHOD—EVALUATION
PAVEMENT PROPERTIES DETERMINATION … A2-1
APPENDIX 3. PCN DETERMINATION EXAMPLES … A3-1
APPENDIX 4. PAVEMENT OVERLOAD EVALUATION BY THE ACN-PCN
SYSTEM … A4-1
APPENDIX 5. REPORTING CHANGES TO CERTAIN AIRPORT RUNWAY DATA
ELEMENTS … A5-1
APPENDIX 6. MAXIMUM AIRCRAFT GROSS WEIGHT TABLES FOR FAA
FORM 5010 REPORTING BASED ON PCN DETERMINATION … A6-1
APPENDIX 7. RELATED READING MATERIAL … A7-1
AC 150/5335-5B 8/26/2011
iv
List of Figures
Figure 3-1. Computational Modes of the COMFAA Program … 8 Figure 3-2. Operation of the COMFAA Program in ACN Mode … 9 Figure 3-3. Operation of the COMFAA Program in PCN Batch Mode … 10 Figure A1-1. Traffic Load Distribution Patterns … A1-2 Figure A2-1. Flexible Pavement Stabilized Base Layer(s) Equivalency Discussion. (FAA
CBR method) … A2-4 Figure A2-2. Flexible Pavement Stabilized Base Layer(s) Equivalency Discussion
(Continued). (FAA CBR method) … A2-5 Figure A2-3. Rigid Pavement Stabilized Subbase Layer(s) Discussion. (FAA Westergaard
method) … A2-6 Figure A2-4. Rigid Pavement Stabilized Subbase Layer(s) Discussion (Continued). (FAA
Westergaard method) … A2-7 Figure A2-5. Subbase Layer Effect on Subgrade Support, k, for Rigid Pavement. (FAA
Westergaard method) … A2-8 Figure A2-6. Stabilized Subbase Layer Effect on Subgrade Support, k, for Rigid Pavement.
(FAA Westergaard method) … A2-9 Figure A2-7. Flexible Pavement quivalency to Rigid Pavement. (FAA Westergaard method)
Figure 3-1 · page 4Picture of the page from the copy saved here
… A2-10 Figure A2-8. Rigid Pavement k Value. (FAA Westergaard method) … A2-11 Figure A3-1. Example of COMFAA ACN Batch Results for Flexible and Rigid Pavements … A3-2 Figure A3-2. Flexible Pavement Example 1 Cross-Section … A3-10 Figure A3-3. Flexible Pavement Example 2 Cross-Section … A3-12 Figure A3-4. Rigid Pavement Example 1 Cross-Section … A3-18 Figure A3-5. Rigid Pavement Example 2 Cross-Section … A3-20 Figure A4-1. Flexible Pavement Overload Illustration 2 (Overlay Flexible Example 2 Cross-Section) … A4-4
List of Tables
Table 2-1. Standard Subgrade Support Conditions for Rigid Pavement ACN Calculation … 3 Table 2-2. Standard Subgrade Support Conditions for Flexible Pavement ACN Calculation . 3 Table 4–1. Pavement Codes for Reporting PCN … 14 Table 4–2. Tire Pressure Codes for Reporting PCN … 15 Table A2-1. FAA Flexible Pavement Layer Equivalency Factor Range … A2-2 Table A2-2. FAA Rigid Pavement Subbase Effect on Foundation k Value … A2-3 Table A3-1. Using Aircraft and Traffic for a Flexible Pavement … A3-4 Table A3-2. Using Aircraft and Traffic for a Rigid Pavement from COMFAA (Details
Window) … A3-5 Table A3-3. Excerpt From COMFAA PCN Batch Results File for Flexible Pavement ... A3-7 Table A3-4. Flexible Pavement Example 1 … A3-11 Table A3-5. Flexible Pavement Example 2 … A3-13 Table A3-6. Flexible Pavement Example 3 … A3-15 Table A3-7. Rigid Pavement Example 1 … A3-19 Table A3-8. Rigid Pavement Example 2 … A3-21
8/26/2011 AC 150/5335-5B
v
Table A3-9. Rigid Pavement Example 3 … A3-22 Table A4-1. Flexible Pavement Example 2 (from COMFAA Details Window) … A4-2 Table A4-2. Flexible Pavement Overload Illustration 2 … A4-5 Table A4-3. Flexible Pavement Overload Illustration 3 … A4-6 Table A4-4. Potential Overload Impact on Flexible Pavement PCN … A4-7 Table A4-5. Rigid Pavement Overload Illustration 1 … A4-8 Table A4-6. Rigid Pavement Overload Illustration … A4-9 Table A4-7. Potential Rigid Pavement Overload Illustration 2, Results … A4-11 Table A5-1. Flexible ACN Data Used to Establish Allowable Gross Weight … A5-2 Table A5-2. Rigid ACN Data Used to Establish Allowable Gross Weight … 3 Table A5-3. Excerpt From Listing of Maximum Gross Weight Data Based on PCN of
Pavement–Example 1 and 2 … A5-4 Table A6-A. Subgrade Strength Category A … A6-1 Table A6-B. Subgrade Strength Category B … A6-2 Table A6-C. Subgrade Strength Category C … A6-3 Table A6-D. Subgrade Strength Category D … A6-4
AC 150/5335-5B 8/26/2011
vi
This page intentionally left blank.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION › 1.2 APPLICATION.
8/26/2011 AC 150/5335-5B
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
1.0 BACKGROUND.
The United States is a contracting state of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) and, under 47 USC §40105(b), shall act consistently with the obligations of the United States Government under an international agreement. Annex 14 to the Convention of International Civil Aviation, Aerodromes, contains a standard that requires member states to publish information on the strengths of all public airport pavements in its own Aeronautical Information Publication (AIP). The FAA reports pavement strength information to the National Airspace System Resources (NASR) database and publishes pavement strength information in the Airport Master Record (Form 5010) and the Airport/Facility Directory (AFD).
1.1 DEVELOPMENT OF A STANDARDIZED METHOD.
In 1977, ICAO established a Study Group to develop a single international method of reporting pavement strengths. The study group developed, and ICAO adopted, the Aircraft Classification Number - Pavement Classification Number (ACN-PCN) method. Using this method, it is possible to express the effect of an individual aircraft on different pavements with a single unique number that varies according to aircraft weight and configuration (e.g. tire pressure, gear geometry, etc.), pavement type, and subgrade strength. This number is the Aircraft Classification Number (ACN). Conversely, the load-carrying capacity of a pavement can be expressed by a single unique number, without specifying a particular aircraft or detailed information about the pavement structure. This number is the Pavement Classification Number (PCN).
a. Definition of ACN. ACN is a number that expresses the relative effect of an aircraft at a given configuration on a pavement structure for a specified standard subgrade strength.
b. Definition of PCN. PCN is a number that expresses the load-carrying capacity of a pavement for unrestricted operations.
c. System Methodology. The ACN-PCN system is structured so a pavement with a particular PCN value can support an aircraft that has an ACN value equal to or less than the pavement’s PCN value. This is possible because ACN and PCN values are computed using the same technical basis.
1.2 APPLICATION.
The use of the standardized method of reporting pavement strength applies only to pavements with bearing strengths of 12,500 pounds (5 700 kg) or greater. The method of reporting pavement strength for pavements of less than 12,500 pounds (5 700 kg) bearing strength remains unchanged.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION › 1.3 LIMITATIONS OF THE ACN-PCN SYSTEM.
AC 150/5335-5B 8/26/2011
1.3 LIMITATIONS OF THE ACN-PCN SYSTEM.
The ACN-PCN system is only intended as a method of reporting relative pavement strength so airport operators can evaluate acceptable operations of aircraft. It is not intended as a pavement design or pavement evaluation procedure, nor does it restrict the methodology used to design or evaluate a pavement structure.
CHAPTER 2. DETERMINATION OF AIRCRAFT CLASSIFICATION NUMBER › 2.1 SUBGRADE CATEGORY.
8/26/2011 AC 150/5335-5B
CHAPTER 2. DETERMINATION OF AIRCRAFT CLASSIFICATION NUMBER
2.0 DETERMINATION OF THE ACN.
The aircraft manufacturer provides the official computation of an ACN value. Computation of the ACN requires detailed information on the operational characteristics of the aircraft, such as maximum aft center of gravity, maximum ramp weight, wheel spacing, tire pressure, and other factors.
2.1 SUBGRADE CATEGORY.
The ACN-PCN method adopts four standard levels of subgrade strength for rigid pavements and four levels of subgrade strength for flexible pavements. These standard support conditions are used to represent a range of subgrade conditions as shown in Tables 2-1 and 2- 2.
Table 2-1. Standard Subgrade Support Conditions for Rigid Pavement ACN
Calculation
Subgrade Strength Category
Subgrade Support
k-Value pci (MN/m3)
Represents pci (MN/m3)
Code Designation
High 552.6 (150) k > 442 ( >120) A
Medium 294.7 (80) 221<k<442 (60<k<120) B Low 147.4 (40) 92<k<221 (25<k<60) C Ultra Low 73.7 (20) k<92 (<25) D
Table 2-2. Standard Subgrade Support Conditions for Flexible Pavement ACN
Calculation
Subgrade Strength Category
Subgrade Support
CBR-Value Represents Code Designation High 15 CBR > 13 A Medium 10 8<CBR<13 B Low 6 4<CBR<8 C Ultra Low 3 CBR<4 D
2.2 OPERATIONAL FREQUENCY.
Operational frequency is defined in terms of coverages that represent a full-load application on a point in the pavement. Coverages must not be confused with other common terminology used to reference movement of aircraft. As an aircraft moves along a pavement section it seldom travels in a perfectly straight path or along the exact same path as before.
AC 150/5335-5B 8/26/2011
This movement is known as aircraft wander and is assumed to be modeled by a statistically normal distribution. As the aircraft moves along a taxiway or runway, it may take several trips or passes along the pavement for a specific point on the pavement to receive a full-load application. It is easy to observe the number of passes an aircraft may make on a given pavement, but the number of coverages must be mathematically derived based upon the established pass-to-coverage ratio for each aircraft.
2.3 RIGID PAVEMENT ACN.
For rigid pavements, the aircraft landing gear flotation requirements are determined by the Westergaard solution for a loaded elastic plate on a Winkler foundation (interior load case), assuming a concrete working stress of 399 psi (2.75 MPa).
2.4 FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT ACN.
For flexible pavements, aircraft landing gear flotation requirements are determined by the California Bearing Ratio (CBR) method for each subgrade support category. The CBR method employs a Boussinesq solution for stresses and displacements in a homogeneous, isotropic elastic half-space.
2.5 ACN CALCULATION.
Using the parameters defined for each type of pavement section, a mathematically derived single wheel load is calculated to define the landing gear/pavement interaction. The derived single wheel load implies equal stress to the pavement structure and eliminates the need to specify pavement thickness for comparative purposes. This is achieved by equating the thickness derived for a given aircraft landing gear to the thickness derived for a single wheel load at a standard tire pressure of 181 psi (1.25 MPa). The ACN is defined as two times the derived single wheel load (expressed in thousands of kilograms).
2.6 VARIABLES INVOLVED IN DETERMINATION OF ACN VALUES.
Because aircraft can be operated at various weight and center of gravity combinations, ICAO adopted standard operating conditions for determining ACN values. The ACN is to be determined at the weight and center of gravity combination that creates the maximum ACN value. Tire pressures are assumed to be those recommended by the manufacturer for the noted conditions. Aircraft manufacturers publish maximum weight and center of gravity information in their Aircraft Characteristics for Airport Planning (ACAP) manuals. To standardize the ACN calculation and to remove operational frequency from the relative rating scale, the ACN-PCN method specifies that ACN values be determined at a frequency of 10,000 coverages.
CHAPTER 3. DETERMINATION OF ACN VALUES USING COMFAA › 3.2 COMFAA PROGRAM.
8/26/2011 AC 150/5335-5B
CHAPTER 3. DETERMINATION OF ACN VALUES USING COMFAA
3.0 AVAILABILITY OF COMFAA SOFTWARE APPLICATION.
To facilitate the use of the ACN-PCN system, the FAA developed a software application that calculates ACN values using the procedures and conditions specified by ICAO. The software is called COMFAA and may be downloaded along with its source code and supporting documentation from the FAA website.1 The program is useful for determining an ACN value under various conditions; however, the user should remember that official ACN values are provided by the aircraft manufacturer.
3.1 ORIGIN OF THE COMFAA PROGRAM.
Appendix 2 of the ICAO Aerodrome Design Manual, Part 3, Pavements, provides procedures for determining the Aircraft Classification Number (ACN). The appendix provides program code for two FORTRAN software applications capable of calculating the ACN for various aircraft on rigid and flexible pavement systems. The computer program listings in Appendix 2 of the ICAO manual were optically scanned and the FORTRAN code translated into Visual Basic 6.0 for incorporation into COMFAA.
3.2 COMFAA PROGRAM.
The COMFAA software is a general purpose program that operates in two computational modes: ACN Computation Mode and Pavement Thickness Mode.
a. ACN Computation Mode.
• Calculates the ACN number for aircraft on flexible pavements.
• Calculates the ACN number for aircraft on rigid pavements.
• Calculates flexible pavement thickness based on the ICAO procedure (CBR method) for default values of CBR (15, 10, 6, and 3).
• Calculates rigid pavement slab thickness based on the ICAO procedures (Portland Cement Association method, interior load case) for default values of k (552.6, 294.7, 147.4, and 73.7 lb/in3 [150, 80, 40, and 20 MN/m3]).
Note: Thickness calculation in the ACN mode is for specific conditions identified by ICAO for determination of ACN. For flexible pavements, a standard tire pressure of 181 psi (1.25 MPa) and 10,000 coverages is specified. For rigid pavements, an allowable stress level of 399 psi is identified by ICAO. These parameters seldom represent actual design criteria used for pavement design. The thickness calculated in ACN mode has little meaning to pavement design requirements and should not be used for determining allowable pavement loading.
1 See http://www.faa.gov/airports/engineering/design_software/. This software is in the public domain.
CHAPTER 3. DETERMINATION OF ACN VALUES USING COMFAA › 3.4 EXTERNAL AIRCRAFT LIBRARY.
AC 150/5335-5B 8/26/2011
b. Pavement Thickness Mode (see Note).
• Calculates total flexible pavement thickness based on the FAA CBR method specified in AC 150/5320-62, Airport Pavement Design and Evaluation, for CBR values and coverage levels specified by the user.
• Calculates rigid pavement slab thickness based on the FAA Westergaard method (edge load analysis) specified in AC 150/5320-6 for k values and coverage levels specified by the user.
Note: The pavement thickness requirements associated with the ACN-PCN procedures are based upon historical procedures identified in previous versions of AC 150/5320-6. The FAA has replaced these procedures for pavement design with new procedures.
3.3 INTERNAL AIRCRAFT LIBRARY.
COMFAA contains an internal library of aircraft covering most large commercial and U.S. military aircraft currently in operation. The internal library is based on aircraft information provided directly by aircraft manufacturers or obtained from ACAP Manuals. The default characteristics of aircraft in the internal library represent the ICAO standard conditions for calculation of ACN. These characteristics include center of gravity at the maximum aft position for each aircraft in the ACN mode, whereas the pavement thickness mode center of gravity is fixed to distribute 95 percent of the maximum gross load to the main landing gear for all aircraft.
3.4 EXTERNAL AIRCRAFT LIBRARY.
COMFAA allows for an external aircraft library where characteristics of the aircraft can be changed and additional aircraft added as desired. Functions permit users to modify the characteristics of an aircraft and save the modified aircraft in the external library. There are no safeguards in the COMFAA program to assure that aircraft parameters in the external library are feasible or appropriate. The user is responsible for assuring all data is correct.
When saving an aircraft from the internal library to the external library, the COMFAA program will calculate the tire contact area based upon the gross load, maximum aft center of gravity, and tire pressure. This value is recorded in the external library and is used for calculating the pass-to-coverage (P/C) ratio in the pavement thickness mode. Since the tire contact area is constant, the P/C ratio is also constant in the pavement thickness mode. This fixed P/C ratio should be used for converting passes to coverages for pavement thickness determination and equivalent aircraft operations.
2 New FAA layered elastic and finite element pavement design procedures were adopted in AC 150/5320-6E. The pavement thickness mode uses the FAA CBR method and the FAA Westergaard method, identified in previous versions of AC 150/5320-6. These historical procedures are consistent with the ACN/PCN method, an internationally used standard published by ICAO. Data from the historical procedures relative to the existing ICAO standard are included in this AC.
CHAPTER 3. DETERMINATION OF ACN VALUES USING COMFAA › 3.5 USING THE COMFAA PROGRAM.
8/26/2011 AC 150/5335-5B
3.5 USING THE COMFAA PROGRAM.
Using the COMFAA program to calculate ACN values to determine PCN is visually interactive and intuitive.
a. ACN. The user—
• Selects the desired aircraft,
• Confirms the physical properties of the aircraft,
• Clicks on the “MORE” button, and
• Clicks on the ACN Flexible or ACN Rigid button to determine the ACN for the four standard subgrade conditions.
b. PCN. The user—
• Adds the runway traffic mix aircraft to an external file,
• Confirms the physical properties of each individual aircraft in the traffic mix,
• Inputs either annual departures or coverages of the aircraft,
• Inputs the evaluation thickness and the subgrade support strength,
• Inputs the concrete strength if analyzing a rigid pavement,
• Clicks on the “LESS” button to activate the PCN Batch computational mode, and
• Clicks on the PCN Flexible Batch or PCN Rigid Batch button to determine the PCN of the pavement.
The program includes a help file to assist users. Figures 3-1, 3-2, and 3-3 summarize the operation of the COMFAA program.
AC 150/5335-5B 8/26/2011
Default Computational Mode is PCN Batch Mode
Default Aircraft Group is the External Library File
Click MORE Button to Activate ACN Computational Mode
Available Calculations, Click Mode to Activate
Click LESS Button to Activate PCN Batch Computational Mode
Figure 3-1. Computational Modes of the COMFAA Program
8/26/2011 AC 150/5335-5B
Figure 3-2. Operation of the COMFAA Program in ACN Mode
1. Select Aircraft Group.
2. Select Aircraft from Library.
3. Confirm Aircraft Parameters.
4. Click ACN Calculation Button.
5a. Click to Calculate Flexible ACN.
5b. Click to Calculate Rigid ACN.
6a. Flexible ACN values for all Subgrade Codes
6b. Rigid ACN values for all Subgrade Codes
AC 150/5335-5B 8/26/2011
1. Select Aircraft Group.
2. Select aircraft from library.
3. Confirm all individual aircraft parameters.
Repeat Steps 2 and 3 for each aircraft in the traffic mix.
4. Enter the runway P/TC ratio.
7a. Click to generate flexible pavement PCN Results Table.
7b. Click to generate rigid pavement PCN Results Table.
6c. Click to enter concrete strength for rigid pavements.
Figure 3-2 · page 15Picture of the page from the copy saved here
6b. Click to enter subgrade k-value for rigid pavements.
6a. Click to enter subgrade CBR for flexible pavements.
5. Click to enter evaluation thickness.
8. Click to view results.
Figure 3-3. Operation of the COMFAA Program in PCN Batch Mode
8/26/2011 AC 150/5335-5B
CHAPTER 4. DETERMINATION OF PCN NUMERICAL VALUE
Figure 3-3 · page 16Picture of the page from the copy saved here
CHAPTER 4. DETERMINATION OF PCN NUMERICAL VALUE › 4.2 USING AIRCRAFT METHOD TO DETERMINE PCN
4.0 PCN CONCEPT.
The determination of a pavement rating in terms of PCN is a process of (1) determining the ACN for each aircraft considered to be significant to the traffic mixture operating of the subject pavement and (2) reporting the ACN value as the PCN for the pavement structure. Under these conditions, any aircraft with an ACN equal to or less than the reported PCN value can safely operate on the pavement subject to any limitations on tire pressure.
Note: PCN values determined in accordance with this AC depend upon the traffic model used to determine the PCN value. Airports should re-evaluate their posted PCN value if significant changes to the original traffic model occur.
4.1 DETERMINATION OF NUMERICAL PCN VALUE.
Determination of the numerical PCN value for a particular pavement can be based upon one of two procedures: the “Using” aircraft method or the “Technical” evaluation method. ICAO procedures permit member states to determine how PCN values will be determined based upon internally developed pavement evaluation procedures. Either procedure may be used to determine a PCN, but the methodology used must be reported as part of the posted rating.
4.2 USING AIRCRAFT METHOD TO DETERMINE PCN
The Using aircraft method is a simple procedure where ACN values for all aircraft currently permitted to use the pavement facility are determined and the largest ACN value is reported as the PCN. This method is easy to apply and does not require detailed knowledge of the pavement structure.
a. Assumptions of the Using Aircraft Method. An underlying assumption with the Using aircraft method is that the pavement structure has the structural capacity to accommodate all aircraft in the traffic mixture and that each aircraft is capable of operating on the pavement structure without restriction.
b. Inaccuracies of the Using Aircraft Method. The accuracy of this method is greatly improved when aircraft traffic information is available. Significant over-estimation of the pavement capacity can result if an excessively damaging aircraft, which uses the pavement on a very infrequent basis, is used to determine the PCN. Likewise, significant under-estimation of the pavement capacity can lead to uneconomic use of the pavement by preventing acceptable traffic from operating. Although there are no minimum limits on frequency of operation before an aircraft is considered part of the normal traffic, the reporting agency must use a rational approach to avoid overstating or understating the pavement capacity. Use of the Using aircraft method is discouraged on a long-term basis due to the concerns listed above.
CHAPTER 4. DETERMINATION OF PCN NUMERICAL VALUE › 4.3 Technical Evaluation Method to Determine PCN.
AC 150/5335-5B 8/26/2011
4.3 TECHNICAL EVALUATION METHOD TO DETERMINE PCN.
The strength of a pavement section is difficult to summarize in a precise manner and will vary depending on the unique combination of aircraft loading conditions, frequency of operation, and pavement support conditions. The technical evaluation method attempts to address these and other site-specific variables to determine reasonable pavement strength. In general terms, for a given pavement structure and given aircraft, the allowable number of operations (traffic) will decrease as the intensity of pavement loading increases (increase in aircraft weight). It is entirely possible that two pavement structures with different crosssections will report similar strength. However, the permissible aircraft operations will be considerably different. This discrepancy must be acknowledged by the airport operator and may require operational limitations administered outside of the ACN-PCN system. All of the factors involved in determining a pavement rating are important, and it is for this reason that pavement ratings should not be viewed in absolute terms, but rather as estimations of a representative value. A successful pavement evaluation is one that assigns a pavement strength rating that considers the effects of all variables on the pavement.
The accuracy of a technical evaluation is better than that produced with the Using aircraft procedure but requires a considerable increase in time and resources. Pavement evaluation may require a combination of on-site inspections, load-bearing tests, and engineering judgment. It is common to think of pavement strength rating in terms of ultimate strength or immediate failure criteria. However, pavements are rarely removed from service due to instantaneous structural failure. A decrease in the serviceability of a pavement is commonly attributed to increases in surface roughness or localized distress, such as rutting or cracking. Determination of the adequacy of a pavement structure must not only consider the magnitude of pavement loads but the impact of the accumulated effect of traffic volume over the intended life of the pavement.
a. Determination of the PCN Value. The PCN numerical value is determined from an allowable load rating. While it is important not to confuse the PCN value with a pavement design parameter, the PCN is developed in a similar fashion. An allowable load rating is determined by applying the same principles as those used for pavement design. The process for determining the allowable load rating takes factors such as frequency of operations and permissible stress levels into account. Allowable load ratings are often discussed in terms of aircraft gear type and maximum gross aircraft weight, as these variables are used in the pavement design procedure. Missing from the allowable load rating, but just as important, is frequency of operation. In determining an allowable load rating, the evaluation must address whether the allowable load rating represents the pavement strength over a reasonable frequency of operation. Once the allowable load rating is established, the determination of the PCN value is a simple process of determining the ACN of the aircraft representing the allowable load and reporting the value as the PCN.
b. Concept of Equivalent Traffic. The ACN-PCN method is based on design procedures that evaluate one aircraft against the pavement structure. Calculations necessary to determine the PCN can only be performed for one aircraft at a time. The ACN-PCN method does not directly address how to represent a traffic mixture as a single aircraft. To address this limitation, the FAA uses the equivalent annual departure concept to consolidate
CHAPTER 4. DETERMINATION OF PCN NUMERICAL VALUE › 4.5 REPORTING THE PCN.
8/26/2011 AC 150/5335-5B
entire traffic mixtures into equivalent annual departures of one representative aircraft. The procedure for evaluating equivalent annual departures for a given aircraft from a traffic mixture is based on the cumulative damage factor concept discussed in Appendix 1.
c. Counting Aircraft Operations. When evaluating or designing a pavement section, it is important to account for the number of times the pavement will be stressed. As discussed in paragraph 2.2, an aircraft may have to pass over a given section of pavement numerous times before the portion of pavement considered for evaluation receives one full stress application. While statistical procedures exist to determine the passes required for one full stress application, the evaluation of a pavement section for PCN determination must also consider how aircraft use the pavement in question. The FAA uses a conservative approach for pavement design procedures by assuming that each aircraft using the airport must land and take off once per cycle. Since the arrival or landing weight of the aircraft is usually less than the departure weight, the design procedure only counts one pass at the departure weight for analysis. The one pass at departure weight is considered as one annual departure and the arrival event is ignored. Appendix 1 provides a detailed discussion of traffic analysis.
4.4 LIMITATIONS OF THE PCN.
The PCN value is for reporting relative pavement strength only and should not be used for pavement design or as a substitute for evaluation. Pavement design and evaluation are complex engineering problems that require detailed analyses. They cannot be reduced to a single number. The PCN rating system uses a continuous scale to compare pavement strength where higher values represent pavements with larger load capacity.
4.5 REPORTING THE PCN.
The PCN system uses a coded format to maximize the amount of information contained in a minimum number of characters and to facilitate computerization. The PCN for a pavement is reported as a five-part number where the following codes are ordered and separated by forward slashes.
• Numerical PCN value,
• Pavement type,
• Subgrade category,
• Allowable tire pressure, and
• Method used to determine the PCN.
An example of a PCN code is 80/R/B/W/T, which is further explained in paragraph 4.5.f.
a. Numerical PCN Value. The PCN numerical value indicates the load-carrying capacity of a pavement in terms of a standard single wheel load at a tire pressure of 181 psi (1.25 MPa). The PCN value should be reported in whole numbers, rounding off any fractional parts to the nearest whole number. For pavements of diverse strengths, the
AC 150/5335-5B 8/26/2011
controlling PCN numerical value for the weakest segment of the pavement should normally be reported as the strength of the pavement. Engineering judgment may be required in that if the weakest segment is not in the most heavily used part of the runway, then another representative segment may be more appropriate to determine PCN.
b. Pavement Type. For the purpose of reporting PCN values, pavement types are considered to function as either flexible or rigid structures. Table 4-1 lists the pavement codes for the purposes of reporting PCN.
Table 4–1. Pavement Codes for Reporting PCN
Pavement Type Pavement Code Flexible F Rigid R
i) Flexible Pavement. Flexible pavements support loads through bearing rather than flexural action. They comprise several layers of selected materials designed to gradually distribute loads from the surface to the layers beneath. The design ensures that load transmitted to each successive layer does not exceed the layer’s load-bearing capacity.
ii) Rigid Pavement. Rigid pavements employ a single structural layer, which is very stiff or rigid in nature, to support the pavement loads. The rigidity of the structural layer and resulting beam action enable rigid pavement to distribute loads over a large area of the subgrade. The load-carrying capacity of a rigid structure is highly dependent upon the strength of the structural layer, which relies on uniform support from the layers beneath.
iii) Composite Pavement. Various combinations of pavement types and stabilized layers can result in complex pavements that could be classified as between rigid or flexible. A pavement section may comprise multiple structural elements representative of both rigid and flexible pavements. Composite pavements are most often the result of pavement surface overlays applied at various stages in the life of the pavement structure. If a pavement is of composite construction, the pavement type should be reported as the type that most accurately reflects the structural behavior of the pavement. The method used in computing the PCN is the best guide in determining how to report the pavement type. For example, if a pavement is composed of a rigid pavement with a bituminous overlay, the usual manner of determining the load-carrying capacity is to convert the pavement to an equivalent thickness of rigid pavement. In this instance, the pavement type should be reported as a rigid structure. A general guideline is that when the bituminous overlay reaches 75 to 100 percent of the rigid pavement thickness the pavement can be considered as a flexible pavement. It is permissible to include a note stating that the pavement is of composite construction but only the rating type, “R” or “F”, is used in the assessment of the pavement load capacity.
c. Subgrade Strength Category. As discussed in paragraph 2.1, there are four standard subgrade strengths identified for calculating and reporting ACN or PCN values. Tables 2-1 and 2-2 list the values for rigid and flexible pavements.
8/26/2011 AC 150/5335-5B
d. Allowable Tire Pressure. Table 4-2 lists the allowable tire pressure categories identified by the ACN-PCN system. The tire pressure codes apply equally to rigid or flexible pavement sections; however, the application of the allowable tire pressure differs substantially for rigid and flexible pavements.
Table 4–2. Tire Pressure Codes for Reporting PCN
Category Code Tire Pressure Range High W No pressure limit Medium X Pressure limited to 218 psi (1.5 MPa) Low Y Pressure limited to 145 psi (1.00 MPa) Very Low Z Pressure limited to 73 psi (0.50 MPa)
i) Tire Pressures on Rigid Pavements. Aircraft tire pressure will have little effect on pavements with Portland cement concrete (concrete) surfaces. Rigid pavements are inherently strong enough to resist tire pressures higher than currently used by commercial aircraft and can usually be rated as code W.
ii) Tire Pressures on Flexible Pavements. Tire pressures may be restricted on asphaltic concrete (asphalt), depending on the quality of the asphalt mixture and climatic conditions. Tire pressure effects on an asphalt layer relate to the stability of the mix in resisting shearing or densification. A poorly constructed asphalt pavement can be subject to rutting due to consolidation under load. The principal concern in resisting tire pressure effects is with stability or shear resistance of lower quality mixtures. A properly prepared and placed mixture that conforms to FAA specification Item P-401 can withstand substantial tire pressure in excess of 218 psi (1.5 Mpa). Item P-401, Plant Mix Bituminous Pavements, is provided in the current version of AC 150/5370-10, Standards for Specifying Construction of Airports. Improperly prepared and placed mixtures can show distress under tire pressures of 100 psi (0.7 MPa) or less. Although these effects are independent of the asphalt layer thickness, pavements with well-placed asphalt of 4 to 5 inches (10.2 to 12.7 cm) in thickness can generally be rated with code X or W, while thinner pavement of poorer quality asphalt should not be rated above code Y.
e. Method Used to Determine PCN. The PCN system recognizes two pavement evaluation methods. If the evaluation represents the results of a technical study, the evaluation method should be coded T. If the evaluation is based on “Using aircraft” experience, the evaluation method should be coded U. Technical evaluation implies that some form of technical study and computation were involved in the determination of the PCN. Using aircraft evaluation means the PCN was determined by selecting the highest ACN among the aircraft currently using the facility and not causing pavement distress. PCN values computed by the technical evaluation method should be reported to the NASR database and shown on the FAA Form 5010, Airport Master Record. Publication of a Using aircraft evaluation in the Airport Master Record, Form 5010, and the NASR database is permitted only by mutual agreement between the airport owner and the FAA.
f. Example PCN Reporting. An example of a PCN code is 80/R/B/W/T—with 80 expressing the PCN numerical value, R for rigid pavement, B for medium strength subgrade, W for high allowable tire pressure, and T for a PCN value obtained by a technical evaluation.
AC 150/5335-5B 8/26/2011
g. Report PCN Values to FAA (See Appendix 5). Once a PCN value and the coded entries are determined, the PCN code should be reported to the appropriate regional FAA Airports Division, either in writing or as part of the annual update to the Airport Master Record, FAA Form 5010-l. The regional office will forward the PCN code to FAA headquarters where it will be disseminated by the National Flight Data Center through aeronautical publications such as the Airport/Facility Directory (AFD) and the Aeronautical Information Publication (AIP). An aircraft’s ACN can then be compared with the published PCN to determine if the aircraft is restricted from operating on the airport’s pavements, subject to any limitation on tire pressure.
APPENDIX 1. EQUIVALENT TRAFFIC › 1.1 Equivalent Traffic Terminology.
APPENDIX 1. EQUIVALENT TRAFFIC
1.0 EQUIVALENT TRAFFIC.
A detailed method based on the cumulative damage factor (CDF) procedure allows the calculation of the combined effect of multiple aircraft in the traffic mix for an airport. This combined traffic is brought together into the equivalent traffic of a critical aircraft. This is necessary since the procedure used to calculate ACN allows only one aircraft at a time. By combining all of the aircraft in the traffic mix into an equivalent critical aircraft, calculation of a PCN that includes the effects of all traffic becomes possible.
The assessment of equivalent traffic, as described in this section, is needed only in the process of determining PCN using the technical method and may be disregarded when the Using aircraft method is employed.
In order to arrive at a technically derived PCN, it is necessary to determine the maximum allowable gross weight of each aircraft in the traffic mixture, which will generate the known pavement structure. This in turn requires that the pavement cross-section and aircraft loading characteristics be examined in detail. Consequently, the information presented in this appendix appears at first to apply to pavement design rather than a PCN determination. However, with this knowledge in hand, an engineer will be able to arrive at a PCN that will have a solid technical foundation.
1.1 EQUIVALENT TRAFFIC TERMINOLOGY.
In order to determine a PCN, based on the technical evaluation method, it is necessary to define common terms used in aircraft traffic and pavement loading. The terms arrival, departure, pass, coverage, load repetition, operation, and traffic cycle are often used interchangeably by different organizations when determining the effect of aircraft traffic operating on a pavement. It is important to determine which aircraft movements need be counted when considering pavement stress and how the various movement terms apply in relation to the pavement design and evaluation process. In general, and for the purpose of this document, they are differentiated as follows:
a. Arrival (Landing) and Departure (Takeoff). Typically, aircraft arrive at an airport with a lower amount of fuel than is used at takeoff. As a consequence, the stress loading of the wheels on the runway pavement is less when landing than at takeoff due to the lower weight. This is true even at the touchdown impact in that there is still lift on the wings, which alleviates the dynamic vertical force. Because of this, the FAA pavement design procedure only considers departures and ignores the arrival traffic count. However, if the aircraft do not receive additional fuel at the airport, then the landing weight will be substantially the same as the takeoff weight (discounting the changes in passenger count and cargo), and the landing operation should be counted as a takeoff for pavement stress loading cycles. In this latter scenario, there are two equal load stresses on the pavement for each traffic count (departure), rather than just one. Regardless of the method of counting load stresses, a traffic cycle is defined as one takeoff and one landing of the same aircraft, subject to a further refinement of the definition in the following text.
b. Pass. A pass is a one-time movement of the aircraft over the runway pavement. It could be an arrival, a departure, a taxi operation, or all three, depending on the loading magnitude and the location of the taxiways. Figure A1-1 shows typical traffic patterns for runways having either parallel taxiways or central taxiways. A parallel taxiway requires that none or very little of the runway be used as part of the taxi movement. A central taxiway requires that a large portion of the runway be used during the taxi movement.
Landing
Takeoff
Figure A1-1a. Runway with Parallel Taxiway
Takeoff
Landing
Taxi Taxi
Figure A1-1b. Runway with Central Taxiway
Figure A1-1. Traffic Load Distribution Patterns
i) Parallel Taxiway Scenario. In the case of the parallel taxiway, as shown in Figure A1-1a, two possible loading situations can occur. Both of these situations assume that the passenger count and cargo payload are approximately the same for the entire landing and takeoff cycle:
1) If the aircraft obtains fuel at the airport, then a traffic cycle consists of only one pass since the landing stress loading is considered at a reduced level, which is a fractional equivalence. For this condition only the takeoff pass is counted, and the ratio of passes to traffic cycles (P/TC) is 1.
2) If the aircraft does not obtain fuel at the airport, then both landing and takeoff passes should be counted, and a traffic cycle consists of two passes of equal load stress. In this case, the P/TC ratio is 2.
ii) Central Taxiway Scenario. For a central taxiway configuration, as shown in Figure A1-1b, there are also two possible loading situations that can occur. As was done for
the parallel taxiway condition, both of these situations assume that the payload is approximately the same for the entire landing and takeoff cycle:
1) If the aircraft obtains fuel at the airport, then both the takeoff and taxi to takeoff passes should be counted since they result in a traffic cycle consisting of two passes at the maximum load stress. The landing pass can be ignored in this case. It is recognized that only part of the runway is used during some of these operations, but it is conservative to assume that the entire runway is covered each time a pass occurs. For this situation, the P/TC ratio is 2.
2) If the aircraft does not obtain fuel at the airport, then both the landing and takeoff passes should be counted, along with the taxi pass, and a traffic cycle consists of three passes at loads of equal magnitude. In this case, the P/TC ratio is 3.
iii) A simplified, but less conservative, approach would be use a P/TC ratio of 1 for all situations. Since a landing and a takeoff only apply full load to perhaps the end third of the runway (opposite ends for no shift in wind direction), this less conservative approach could be used to count one pass for both landing and takeoff. However, the FAA recommends conducting airport evaluations on the conservative side, which is to assume any one of the passes covers the entire runway.
Table A1-1 summarizes the P/TC ratio discussion.
F i g u r e A 3 - 1 . P / T C R a t i o S u m m a r y
P/TC P/TC Taxiway Serving the
Runway
Fuel Obtained at the Airport (i.e. departure gross weight more
than arrival gross weight.)
No Fuel Obtained at the Airport (i.e. departure gross weight same as
arrival gross weight.) Parallel 1 2 Central 2 3
c. Coverage. When an aircraft moves along a runway, it seldom travels in a perfectly straight line or over the exact same wheel path as before. It will wander on the runway with a statistically normal distribution. One coverage occurs when a unit area of the runway has been traversed by a wheel of the aircraft main gear. Due to wander, this unit area may not be covered by the wheel every time the aircraft is on the runway. The number of passes required to statistically cover the unit area one time on the pavement is expressed by the pass to coverage (P/C) ratio.
Although the terms coverage and P/C ratio have commonly been applied to both flexible and rigid pavements, the P/C ratio has a slightly different meaning when applied to flexible pavements as opposed to rigid pavements. This is due to the manner in which flexible and rigid pavements are considered to react to various types of gear configurations. For gear configurations with wheels in tandem, such as dual tandem (2D) and triple dual tandem (3D), the ratios are different for flexible and rigid pavements, and using the same term for both types of pavements may become confusing. It is incumbent upon the user to select the proper value for flexible and rigid pavements.
Aircraft passes can be determined (counted) by observation but coverages are used by the COMFAA program. The P/C ratio is necessary to convert passes to coverages for use in the program. This ratio is different for each aircraft because of the different number of wheels, main gear configurations, tire contact areas, and load on the gear. Fortunately, the P/C ratio for any aircraft is automatically determined by the COMFAA program and the user only need be concerned with passes.
d. Operation. The meaning of this term is unclear when used in pavement design or evaluation. It could mean a departure at full load or a landing at minimal load. It is often used interchangeably with pass or traffic cycle. When this description of an aircraft activity is used, additional information should be supplied. It is usually preferable to use the more precise terms described in this section.
e. Annual Departure and Traffic Cycle Ratio. The FAA standard for counting traffic cycles at an airport for pavement design purposes is to count one landing, one taxi, and one take-off as a single event called a departure. For pavement evaluation related to determination of PCN, it may be necessary to adjust the number of traffic cycles (departures) based upon the scenarios discussed in paragraph 1.1b of this appendix. Similar to the discussion above regarding P/C ratio, the traffic cycle to coverage (TC/C) ratio is needed to finalize the equivalent traffic determination. The TC/C ratio differs when applied to flexible pavements as opposed to rigid pavements. The ratio in flexible pavement, rather than passes to coverages, is required since there could be one or more passes per traffic cycle. When only one pass on the operating surface is assumed for each traffic count, then the P/C ratio is sufficient. However, when situations are encountered where more than one pass is considered to occur during the landing to takeoff cycle, then the TC/C ratio is necessary in order to properly account for the effects of all of the traffic. These situations occur most often when there are central taxiways or fuel is not obtained at the airport.
Equation A1-1 translates the P/C ratio to the TC/C ratio for flexible and rigid pavements by including the previously described ratio of passes to traffic cycles (P/TC):
TC P C P C TC (Equation A1-1)
Where: TC = Traffic Cycles C = Coverages P = Passes
Since the COMFAA program will automatically determine passes to coverages and convert annual departures to coverages, the conditions described in paragraph 1.1b can be addressed by simply multiplying annual departures by the pass to traffic cycle (P/TC) ratio. COMFAA requires the P/TC ratio parameter and will automatically perform this multiplication.
1.2 EQUIVALENT TRAFFIC CALCULATIONS.
In order to complete the equivalent traffic calculations for converting one of the aircraft in the mix to another, a procedure based on cumulative damage factor (CDF) is used. The CDF
method is similar to the one used in the design procedures embodied in the design program FAARFIELD, required by AC 150/5320-6, and provides more consistent results than the wheel load method (as in FAA’s CBR and Westergaard methods) when the traffic mix contains a wide range of gear geometries and strut loads. The primary difference between the CDF procedure used here and the one in FAARFIELD is that in FAARFIELD, the CDF is summed over all aircraft to produce the criterion for design whereas in the procedure used here the CDF methodology is used to convert the traffic for the complete mix into an equivalent number of coverages of one of the aircraft in the mix. That aircraft is designated the “critical” aircraft or “most demanding” aircraft for PCN determination or the “design” aircraft for thickness design (FAA’s CBR and Westergaard methods). The wheel load method is briefly described before describing the CDF method.
In the wheel load method, select one of the aircraft in the mix to be the critical aircraft and then convert the traffic of the remaining aircraft into equivalent traffic of the critical aircraft. First, with equation A1-1, convert the traffic for the gear type of each of the conversion aircraft into equivalent traffic for the same gear type as the critical aircraft.
) (8.0 N M CNV CRTGE TC TC (Equation A1-2)
Where:
TCCNV = the number of traffic cycles of the conversion aircraft. TCCRTGE = the number of traffic cycles of the critical aircraft equivalent to the number of
traffic cycles of the conversion aircraft due to gear type equivalency.
N = the number of wheels on the main gear of the conversion aircraft.
M = the number of wheels on the main gear of the critical aircraft.
Second, with equation A1-3, convert the gear equivalency traffic cycles into equivalent traffic based on load magnitude.
CNV CRT W W CRTGE CRTE
CNV
CRT CRTGE CRTE
TC TC
W
W TC TC
Or
Log Log
(Equation A1-3)
Where:
TCCRTE = the number of traffic cycles of the critical aircraft equivalent to the number of
traffic cycles of the conversion aircraft due to gear type and load magnitude equivalencies. WCNV = the wheel load of the conversion aircraft.
WCRT = the wheel load of the critical aircraft.
Alternatively, both operations can be combined into a single equation:
CNV CRT W W N M CNV CRTE TC TC ) (8.0 (Equation A1-4)
Finally, the equivalent traffic cycles of all of the conversion aircraft are added to the original traffic cycles of the critical aircraft to give the total equivalent traffic cycles of the critical aircraft.
In the CDF method, the number of equivalent traffic cycles of the critical aircraft is defined as the number of traffic cycles of the critical aircraft that will cause the same amount of damage to the pavement as the number of traffic cycles of the conversion aircraft, where damage is defined by CDF.
CDF is derived from Miner’s Rule, which states the damage induced in a structural element is proportional to the number of load applications divided by the number of load applications required to fail the structural element. In airport pavement design, load applications are counted in coverages, so the relationship for calculating equivalent traffic is first derived in terms of coverages.
aircraft conversion the of coverages the from resulting factor damage cumulative
aircraft conversion by the loaded hen pavement w the fail to coverages
aircraft conversion the of coverages
CNVF
CNV CNV C
C CDF
aircraft critical the of coverages equivalent the from resulting factor damage cumulative
aircraft critical by the loaded hen pavement w the fail to coverages
aircraft critical the of coverages equivalent
CRTF
CRTE CRTE C C CDF
CDF is the fraction of the total pavement life used up by operating the indicated aircraft on the pavement. It therefore follows that the CDF for the equivalent critical aircraft is equal to the CDF for the conversion aircraft. Or:
and ,
CNVF
CNV
CRTF
CRTE
C
C C C
CNV CNVF
CRTF CRTE C C C C (Equation A1-5)
But:
CRTE CRT CRTE
CNV CNV CNV
C PC TC
C PC TC
and ,
Where:
TCCNV = the number of traffic cycles of the conversion aircraft. TCCRTE = the number of traffic cycles of the critical aircraft equivalent to the number of
traffic cycles of the conversion aircraft. PCCNV = pass-to-coverage ratio for the conversion aircraft.
PCCRT = pass-to-coverage ratio for the critical aircraft.
Therefore, the equivalent traffic cycles of the critical aircraft by the CDF method is given by:
CNV CNVF
CRTF
CNV
CRT CRTE TC C C PC
PC TC (Equation A1-6)
Equation A1-6 can be rewritten as:
CNVI CRTF CRTEI CDF C C
Where:
CCRTEI = the number of equivalent coverages of the Ith aircraft in the list, including the
critical aircraft. CDFCNVI = the CDF of the Ith aircraft in the list, including the critical aircraft.
Summing over all aircraft in the list gives the total number of equivalent coverages of the critical aircraft, CCRTETotal, as:
N
I
CNVI CRTF
N
I
CNVI CRTF
N
I
CRTEI CRTETotal CDF C CDF C C C
1 1 1
Where N = the total number of aircraft in the list, including the critical aircraft.
Defining the total CDF for the traffic mix, CDFT, as the total number of equivalent coverages of the critical aircraft divided by the number of coverages to failure of the critical aircraft, gives the equation:
N
I
CNVI CRTF
CRTETotal T CDF C C CDF
1 (Equation A1-7)
The total CDF for the traffic mix is therefore, by this definition, the sum of the CDFs of all of the aircraft in the traffic mix, including that of the critical aircraft.
Table A1-2 shows how the above calculations are combined, using the COMFAA Life calculation with the Batch option checked, to determine the equivalent traffic cycles of the critical aircraft. The pavement is assumed to be a flexible structure 33.80 inches thick on a CBR 8 subgrade. For this example, assume that the B747-400 is the critical aircraft. Also assume that the P/TC ratio is 1.0 so Traffic Cycles equals Annual Departures. Referring to the Top table, the CDF contribution of each aircraft on the pavement is calculated by dividing 20-year Coverages (Column 7) by Life (Column 9), with results shown in the Bottom portion of the table. The B747-400 is the assumed critical aircraft, so the operations of all other aircraft are equated to the B747-400. The results are shown in Column 11 of the Bottom portion of the table. Column 11 results use equation A1-6, i.e., (3000/0.6543)*Col. 10. The sum of the equivalent annual departures (Equation A1-7) indicates that all other aircraft are equivalent to 468 departures of the B747-400.
Figure A3-2. Example of COMFAA Batch Life Calculations
The Top portion of the table can be viewed in the Details window in the program after executing the Life function for Flexible pavement with the program in the “MORE” mode. Pavement thickness and subgrade strength must be entered in the program for this function to work correctly. Results for all aircraft in the list will be computed and displayed if the Batch box is checked. Otherwise, results for only one aircraft are displayed. Detailed instructions are given later for operating the program.
Coverages to failure for each individual aircraft is computed in the program by changing the number of coverages for that aircraft until the design thickness by the CBR method (for flexible pavements) is the same as the evaluation pavement thickness, in this case 33.8 inches. As explained above, CDF is the ratio of applied coverages to coverages to failure, and is a measure of the amount of damage done to the pavement by that aircraft over a period of 20 years (under the assumptions implicit in the design procedure). If the CDF for any aircraft is equal to one, then the pavement is predicted to fail in 20 years if it is the only aircraft in operation. If the sum of the CDFs for all aircraft in the list is equal to one, then the pavement is predicted to fail in 20 years with all of the aircraft operating at their assumed operating weights and annual departures. The sum of the CDFs in this example is 0.7564, indicating that the pavement is being operated under a set of conservative assumptions.
It should be noted that the sum of the CDFs as calculated in COMFAA do not strictly provide a prediction of pavement damage caused by the accumulation of damage from all of the aircraft because not all of the aircraft landing gears pass down the same longitudinal path. The summation given here would therefore provide a somewhat conservative result than
expected. In comparison with the FAARFIELD computer program, the COMFAA values correspond to the “CDF Max for Aircraft” values from FAARFIELD. The “CDF Contribution” values from FAARFIELD are summed along defined longitudinal paths and do not correspond to the values from COMFAA, except when the Contribution and Max for Aircraft values coincide. This discussion indicates how, all other things being equal, the equivalent critical aircraft concept used in FAA’s CBR and Westergaard methods and in COMFAA, produces more conservative designs than the procedure used in FAARFIELD, and why the two methodologies can never be made to produce the same predictions of pavement life for different traffic mixes.
This page intentionally left blank.
APPENDIX 2. › 1.1 FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT CROSS-SECTION PROPERTIES—EQUIVALENT THICKNESS…
APPENDIX 2. TECHNICAL EVALUATION METHOD—EVALUATION
PAVEMENT PROPERTIES DETERMINATION
1.0. TECHNICAL EVALUATION METHOD.
The Technical Evaluation method for determining a PCN requires pavement thickness and cross-sectional properties as well as traffic mix details.
1.1 FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT CROSS-SECTION PROPERTIES—EQUIVALENT THICKNESS DETERMINATION.
The thickness of the flexible pavement section under consideration must be referenced to standard flexible pavement sections for evaluation purposes. The standard section is the total thickness requirement calculated by the COMFAA program assuming minimum layer thickness for the asphalt surface, minimum base layer thickness of material with a CBR 80 or higher, and a variable thickness subbase layer with a CBR 20 or greater. Two reference pavement sections are used.
When no aircraft in the traffic mix have four or more wheels on a main gear, the minimum asphalt surface course thickness requirement is 3 inches and the minimum high quality crushed aggregate base course thickness requirement is 6 inches.
When one or more aircraft in the traffic mix have four or more wheels on a main gear, the minimum asphalt surface course thickness requirement is 5 inches and the minimum high quality crushed aggregate base course thickness requirement is 8 inches.
Structural Layer Thickness (inches)
Less than Four Wheels on Main Gear
Four or More Wheels
on Main Gear Asphaltic Concrete
(FAA Item P-401) 3 5
High Quality Granular Base (FAA Item P-209) 6 8
If the pavement has excess material or improved materials, the total pavement thickness may be increased according to the FAA CBR method summarized herein as Figures A2-1 and A2- 2 and Table A2-1. The pavement is considered to have excess asphalt, which can be converted to extra equivalent thickness, when the asphalt thickness is greater than the minimum thickness of asphalt surfacing of the referenced pavement section. The pavement may also be considered to have excess aggregate base thickness when the cross-section has a high quality crushed aggregate base thickness greater than the minimum thickness of high quality crushed aggregate base of the referenced pavement section or when other improved materials, such as asphalt stabilization or cement treated materials, are present. Likewise, additional improved base materials may also be converted to additional subbase material to add to the total pavement thickness.
APPENDIX 2. › 1.2 RIGID PAVEMENT CROSS-SECTION PROPERTIES—IMPROVED SUBGRADE SUPPORT…
If the evaluation pavement section is deficient for asphalt pavement surface course (i.e. less than 3 inches) and/or high quality crushed aggregate base course (i.e. less than 6 inches), the subbase thickness is reduced using a slightly more conservative inverse layer equivalency factor for surface course material and/or the subbase thickness is reduced using a slightly more conservative inverse layer equivalency factor for high quality crushed aggregate base material. This is shown in Table A2-1.
Table A2-1. FAA Flexible Pavement Layer Equivalency Factor Range
1.2 RIGID PAVEMENT CROSS-SECTION PROPERTIES—IMPROVED SUBGRADE SUPPORT DETERMINATION. The rigid pavement characteristics— including subgrade soil modulus, k, the concrete thickness, and flexural strength—are needed for PCN determination. The foundation modulus (k value) is assigned to the material directly beneath the concrete pavement layer. However, the k value for the subgrade is determined and then corrected to account for improved layers (subbases) between the subgrade and the concrete layer. There are k value corrections available for uncrushed aggregate subbases, crushed aggregate subbases, and subbases stabilized with asphalt cement or Portland cement. The k value may be increased according to the methods described in the FAA Westergaard method, summarized herein as Figures A2-3 through A2-6. The thickness of the concrete in a rigid pavement may be increased if an asphalt overlay has been placed on the surface. The thickness may be increased using the factor described in the FAA Westergaard method, summarized herein as Figure A2-7. Each 2.5 inches of asphalt may be
converted to 1.0 inch of concrete. The references for both improvement subgrade support guidance and additional thickness conversion guidance is summarized in Table A2-2.
Table A2-2. FAA Rigid Pavement Subbase Effect on Foundation k Value
FAA Pavement Layer
Effect When
Uncrushed Aggregate (Bank
Run Sand and Gravel) is Used as
the Subbase
Effect When Well-
Graded Crushed Aggregate is Used
as the Subbase
Effect When Asphalt
Cement or Portland
Cement Stabilized Materials are Used as
the Subbase
P-401 and/or P-403 Ref. Figure A2-6 P-306 Ref. Figure A2-6 P-304 Ref. Figure A2-6
P-209 Ref. Figure A2-5,
Upper Graph
P-208 and/or P-211 Ref. Figure A2-5,
Lower Graph
P-301 Ref. Figure A2-5,
Lower Graph
P-154 Ref. Figure A2-5,
Lower Graph
Effect on Rigid Pavement Thickness P-401 Overlay Ref. Figure A2-7
2.0 AVAILABILITY OF SUPPORT PROGRAM TO DETERMINE PAVEMENT CHARACTERiSTICS.
To facilitate the use of the ACN-PCN system, FAA developed a software application that incorporates the guidance in this appendix and determines the evaluation thickness for both flexible and rigid pavements and the foundation k value for rigid pavements. The software may be downloaded from the FAA website.
2.1 USING THE SUPPORT PROGRAM.
The support program is visually interactive and intuitive, as shown in Figures A2-8 and A2- 9.
Figure A2-1. Flexible Pavement Stabilized Base Layer(s) Equivalency Discussion. (FAA
CBR method)
Figure A2-2. Flexible Pavement Stabilized Base Layer(s) Equivalency Discussion
(Continued). (FAA CBR method)
Figure A2-3. Rigid Pavement Stabilized Subbase Layer(s) Discussion. (FAA
Westergaard method)
Figure A2-4. Rigid Pavement Stabilized Subbase Layer(s) Discussion (Continued).
(FAA Westergaard method)
Figure A2-5. Subbase Layer Effect on Subgrade Support, k, for Rigid Pavement. (FAA
Westergaard method)
Figure A2-6. Stabilized Subbase Layer Effect on Subgrade Support, k, for Rigid
Pavement. (FAA Westergaard method)
Figure A2-7. Flexible Pavement quivalency to Rigid Pavement.
(FAA Westergaard method)
Figure A2-8. Rigid Pavement k Value. (FAA Westergaard method)
This page intentionally left blank.
APPENDIX 3. PCN DETERMINATION EXAMPLES
1.0. The Using Aircraft Method.
The Using aircraft method of determining PCN is presented in the following steps. This procedure can be used when there is limited knowledge of the existing traffic and runway characteristics. It is also useful when engineering analysis is neither possible nor desired. Airport authorities should be more careful in the application of a Using aircraft PCN in that the rating has not been rigorously determined.
APPENDIX 3. PCN DETERMINATION EXAMPLES › 1.0. The Using Aircraft Method.
There are two basic steps required to arrive at a Using aircraft PCN:
Determine the ACN for each aircraft in the traffic mix currently using the pavement.
Assign the highest ACN value as the PCN.
These steps are explained below in greater detail. Figure A3-1 shows the steps needed to automatically perform the ACN calculations using COMFAA along with the results.
1. Load Ext file. 2. Click More to access ACN Computational Mode. 3. Check Batch. 4. Click Flexible Button or Rigid Button. 5. When calculations finish, click Details Button. 6. View results. 7. Select highest ACN for the pavement’s subgrade category.
Figure A3-1. Example of COMFAA ACN Batch Results
for Flexible and Rigid Pavements.
APPENDIX 3. PCN DETERMINATION EXAMPLES › 1.1 Using Aircraft Example for Flexible Pavements.
1. Assign the pavement surface type as code F or R.
2. From available records, determine the average strength of the pavement subgrade. If the subgrade strength is not known, make a judgment of High, Medium, Low, or Ultra Low.
3. Determine which aircraft has the highest ACN from a list of aircraft that are presently using the pavement, based on the surface type code assigned in Step 1 and the subgrade code in Step 2. ACN values may be determined from the COMFAA program or from ACN graphs found in the manufacturer’s published ACAP manuals. Use the same subgrade code for each of the aircraft when determining the maximum ACN. Base ACNs on the highest operating weight of the aircraft at the airport if the data is available; otherwise, use an estimate or the published maximum allowable gross weight of the aircraft in question. Report the ACN from the aircraft with the highest ACN that regularly uses the pavement as the PCN for the pavement.
4. The PCN is simply the highest ACN with appropriate tire pressure and evaluation codes added. The numerical value of the PCN may be adjusted up or down at the preference of the airport authority. Reasons for adjustment include local restrictions, allowances for certain aircraft, or pavement conditions.
5. The tire pressure code (W, X, Y, or Z) should represent the highest tire pressure of the aircraft fleet currently using the pavement. For flexible pavements, code X should be used if no higher tire pressure is evident from among the existing traffic. It is commonly understood that concrete can tolerate substantially higher tire pressures, so the rigid pavement rating should normally be given as W.
6. The evaluation method for the Using aircraft method is reported as U.
1.1 USING AIRCRAFT EXAMPLE FOR FLEXIBLE PAVEMENTS.
The following example illustrates the Using aircraft PCN process for flexible pavements:
An airport has a runway with the following traffic mix: (from COMFAA Open Aircraft Window)
The runway has a flexible (asphalt-surfaced) pavement with a subgrade strength of CBR 9 and flexible pavement ACNs shown in Table A3-1.
Table A3-1. Using Aircraft and Traffic for a Flexible Pavement
Since this is a flexible pavement, the pavement type code is F, (Table 4-1).
The subgrade strength under the pavement is CBR 9, or Medium category, so the
appropriate code is B (Table 2-2).
The highest tire pressure of any aircraft in the traffic mix is 216.1 psi, so the tire
pressure code is X (Table 4-2).
From the above list, the critical aircraft is the B747-400, because it has the highest
ACN of the group at the operational weights shown (59.3/F/B). Additionally, it has regular service.
Since there was no engineering analysis done in this example, and the rating was
determined simply by examination of the current aircraft using the runway, the evaluation code from Paragraph 4.5e is U.
Based on the results of the previous steps, the runway pavement should
tentatively be rated as PCN 59/F/B/X/U, assuming that the pavement is performing satisfactorily under the current traffic.
If this pavement was a taxiway, the airport could rate this taxiway as the same
PCN.
If the pavement shows obvious signs of distress, this rating may need to be adjusted downward at the discretion of the airport authority. If the rating is lowered, then one or more of the aircraft will have ACNs that exceed the assigned rating. This may require the airport to restrict the allowable gross weight for those aircraft or consider pavement strengthening. The rating could also be adjusted upward, depending on the performance of the pavement under the current traffic.
1.2 USING AIRCRAFT EXAMPLE FOR RIGID PAVEMENTS.
The following example illustrates the Using aircraft PCN process for rigid pavements:
An airport has a runway with the following traffic mix: (from COMFAA Open Aircraft Window)
The runway has a rigid (concrete-surfaced) pavement with a subgrade strength of k=200 pci and rigid pavement ACNs shown in Table A3-2.
Table A3-2. Using Aircraft and Traffic for a Rigid Pavement from COMFAA (Details
Window)
Since this is a rigid pavement, the pavement type code is R, (Table 4-1).
The subgrade strength under the pavement is k=200 pci, which is Low category,
so the appropriate code is C (Table 2-1).
The highest tire pressure of any aircraft in the traffic mix is 216.1 psi, so the tire
pressure code is X, as found in Table 4-2. However, since concrete can normally tolerate substantially higher tire pressures, the code W should be assigned.
The B777-200 has the highest ACN of the group at the operational weights shown
(82.6/R/C). However, the A300-B4 (ACN 66.9/R/C) or the B747-400 (ACN 74.6/R/C) also provide reasonable values since these aircraft have higher frequencies than the B777-200.
Since there was no engineering analysis done in this example, and the rating was
determined simply by examination of the current aircraft using the runway, the evaluation code from Paragraph 4.5e is U.
Based on these steps, the pavement should tentatively be rated as PCN
83/R/C/W/U in order to accommodate all of the current traffic.
If the pavement shows obvious signs of distress, this rating may need to be
adjusted downward at the discretion of the airport authority. If the rating is lowered, then one or more of the aircraft will have ACNs that exceed the assigned rating. This may require the airport to restrict the allowable gross weight for those aircraft or consideration of pavement strengthening. The rating could also be adjusted upward, depending on the performance of the pavement under the current traffic.
2.0 THE TECHNICAL EVALUATION METHOD.
Use the technical evaluation method of determining PCN when there is reliable knowledge of the existing traffic and pavement characteristics. Although the technical evaluation provides a good representation of existing conditions, the airport authority should still be somewhat flexible in its application since there are many variables in the pavement structure as well as the method of analysis itself. The objective of the technical method is to consolidate all traffic into equivalent annual departures, determine allowable gross weight, and assess the ACN for each aircraft in the traffic mixture so that a realistic PCN is selected.
2.1 TECHNICAL EVALUATION FOR FLEXIBLE PAVEMENTS.
The following list summarizes the steps for using the technical evaluation method for flexible pavements:
Determine the traffic volume in terms of type of aircraft and number of annual
departures/traffic cycles of each aircraft that the pavement will experience over its life.
Determine the appropriate reference section to use based on the number of wheels on
main gears.
Determine pavement characteristics, including the subgrade CBR and equivalent
pavement thickness.
Calculate the maximum allowable gross weight for each aircraft on that pavement at
the equivalent annual departure level.
Calculate the ACN of each aircraft at its maximum allowable gross weight.
Select the PCN from the ACN data provided by all aircraft.
These steps are explained in greater detail below. The steps are automated in the COMFAA software, with a results file presented in three tables: a table with input traffic data, a table with a table with the results of the PCN using the CDF analysis at the evaluation pavement thickness and subgrade CBR, and a table with ACN values for each aircraft in the traffic mix. Figure A3-2 shows an excerpt from a results file. Several examples using the same traffic mix with different pavement structures at the end of this section further illustrate the process.
Table A3-3. Excerpt From COMFAA PCN Batch Results File for Flexible Pavement
1. Determine the traffic volume in terms of annual departures for each aircraft that has used or is planned to use the airport during the pavement life period. Record all significant traffic, including non-scheduled, charter, and military, as accurately as possible. This includes traffic that has occurred since the original construction or last overlay and traffic that will occur before the next planned overlay or reconstruction. If the pavement life is unknown or undetermined, assume that it will include a reasonable period of time. The normal design life for pavement is 20 years. However, the expected life can vary depending on the existing pavement conditions, climatic conditions, and maintenance practices.
The information necessary for the traffic volume process is—
Past, current, and forecasted traffic cycles of each significant aircraft. Aircraft operational or maximum gross weights. Typical aircraft weight distribution on the main and nose gear. If unknown,
AC 150/5320-6 assumes 95 percent weight on the main gear. Main gear type (dual, dual tandem, etc.). Main gear tire pressure. Fuel-loading practices of aircraft at the airport (P/TC ratio). Type of taxiway system – parallel or central (P/TC ratio).
2. From field data or construction drawings, document the CBR of the subgrade soil. Alternatively, conduct field or laboratory tests of the subgrade soil in order to determine the CBR. Accurate portrayal of the subgrade CBR value is vital to the technical method because a small variation in CBR could result in a disproportionately large variation in the aircraft allowable gross weight and the corresponding PCN.
3. The COMFAA program calculates pavement thickness requirements based on annual departures. COMFAA allows the user to directly input either coverages or annual departures. Since the pass-to-coverage ratio for flexible pavement may be different than rigid pavement, the user must enter coverages in the appropriate location for each pavement type.
4. Determine the total pavement thickness and cross-sectional properties. The thickness of the pavement section under consideration must be converted to an equivalent pavement thickness based on a standard reference pavement section for evaluation purposes. The equivalent pavement thickness is the total thickness requirement calculated by the COMFAA program assuming minimum layer thickness for the asphalt surface, minimum base layer thickness of material with a CBR 80 or higher, and a variable subbase layer with a CBR 20 or greater. If the pavement has excess material or improved materials, the total pavement thickness may be increased according to the FAA CBR method as detailed in Appendix 2. The pavement is considered to have excess asphalt, which can be converted to extra equivalent thickness, when the asphalt thickness is greater than the minimum thickness of asphalt surfaced. The recommended reference section for this traffic mix is an asphalt surface course thickness of 5 inches. The pavement may also be considered to have excess aggregate base thickness when the cross-section has a high quality crushed aggregate base thickness greater than 8 inches or when other improved materials such as asphalt stabilization or cement treated materials, are present. Likewise, additional subbase thickness or improved subbase materials may also be converted to additional total pavement thickness. Using the support program to facilitates converting existing pavement structures to the requisite standard equivalent structure used in COMFAA.
5. Using the annual departures and P/TC ratio for the runway, the equivalent pavement thickness, and the appropriate CBR of the subgrade, compute the maximum allowable
gross weight for each aircraft using the COMFAA program in the pavement design mode.
6. Assign the subgrade CBR strength found in Step 2 to the appropriate standard ACN- PCN subgrade code as given in Table 2-2.
7. The ACN of each aircraft at the maximum allowable gross weight is may now be determined from the COMFAA program using the ACN mode. Enter the allowable gross weight of the aircraft, and calculate the ACN based on the standard subgrade code corresponding to the CBR found in Step 2. Alternatively, consult an “ACN versus Gross Weight” chart as published in the manufacturer’s ACAP manuals.
8. Assign the tire pressure code based on the highest tire pressure in the traffic mix from Table 4-2. Keep in mind the quality of the asphalt surface layer, as discussed in Section 2.1, when assigning this code.
9. As the evaluation method is technical, assign the code of T, as described in paragraph 4.5e.
10. The numerical value of the PCN is selected from the list of ACN values from all aircraft. COMFAA lists these values as PCN values. If all aircraft regularly use the airport, then select the highest ACN value and report it as the PCN. If some of the aircraft in the traffic mix use the airport infrequently, then further consideration must be given to the selection of the PCN. If an aircraft that operates infrequently at the airport generates a PCN value considerably higher than the rest of the traffic mix, then using this aircraft to determine the PCN will require a new PCN determination if this aircraft’s operations increase.
11. If the calculated maximum allowable gross weight is equal to or greater than the critical aircraft operational gross weight required for the desired pavement life, then the pavement is capable of handling the predicted traffic for the time period established in the traffic forecast. Accordingly, the assigned PCN determined in Step 10 is sufficient. If the allowable gross weight from is less than the critical aircraft gross weight required for the desired pavement life, then the pavement may be assigned a PCN equal to the ACN of the critical aircraft at that gross weight, but with a lower expected pavement life. Additionally, it may then be necessary to develop a relationship of allowable gross weight based on the assigned PCN versus pavement life. Any overload should be treated in terms of ACN and equivalent critical aircraft operations per individual operation. Allowance for the overload should be negotiated with the airport authority since pre-approval cannot be assumed. Specific procedures on how to relate pavement life and gross weight for flexible pavements are found in Appendix 4 of this document.
2.2 TECHNICAL EVALUATION EXAMPLES FOR FLEXIBLE PAVEMENTS.
The following four examples help demonstrate the technical evaluation method of determining a PCN for flexible pavements. The first example pavement has more than adequate strength to handle the forecasted traffic. The second example is for an under-
strength pavement with a traffic volume that has increased to such a level that pavement life is reduced from the original design. The third example pavement is the same as the first, except that the runway has a central rather than a parallel taxiway. Example 4 discusses the effect on pavement life when aircraft with a higher ACN the PCN uses the pavement without implementing allowable gross weight restrictions.
a. Flexible Pavement Example 1. An airport has a flexible (asphalt-surfaced) runway pavement with a subgrade CBR of 9 and a total thickness of 32.0 inches, as shown in the left graph of Figure A3-1 (5 inch asphalt surface layer, 4 inches of stabilized base, 6 inch base layer and 17 inches subbase layer). Additional fuel is generally obtained at the airport before departure, and the runway has a parallel taxiway. The pavement was designed for a life of 20 years. It is assumed for the purposes of this example that the traffic level is constant over the 20-year time period. The ACN for each aircraft in the traffic is shown in Table A3-3, which is similar to Table A3-1 but with the ACN for all subgrade categories shown. The thickness of the P-304 and P-209 exceeds the minimum standard for the CDF analysis method and is converted to additional P-154 as shown in Figure A3-2 for an equivalent pavement thickness of 33.9 inches.
Existing pavement: 5 inch asphalt surface layer (P-401) 4 inch base layer (P-304) 6 inch base layer (P-209) 17 inches subbase layer (P-154) Subgrade CBR 9
P-304 plus P-209 exceed P-209 requirements. Portion of P-304 is converted to P-209 and excess P-304 converted to P-154. This conversion results in 1.9 inches added to equivalent pavement thickness.
Equivalent Pavement: 5 inch asphalt surface layer (P-401) 8 inch base layer (P-209) 20.9 inch subbase layer (P-154) 33.9 inch total thickness Subgrade CBR 9
Figure A3-2. Flexible Pavement Example 1 Cross-Section
Table A3-4 shows the results of the COMFAA Batch PCN Flexible calculations. The Bottom portion of Table A3-4 shows traffic parameters and the ACN of the traffic aircraft for all subgrade categories. All traffic aircraft were added using the aircraft library embedded in COMFAA.
P-401 P-401
P-304
P-209
P-209
P-154 P-154
Subgrade
CBR 9.0
Subgrade
CBR 9.0
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Existing Pavement Equivalent Pavement
Depth from Surface, in.
Table A3-4. Flexible Pavement Example 1
The last four columns of the Bottom portion of Table A3-4 show the ACN for each aircraft at each subgrade strength category. The existing pavement has a CBR of 9, which is Category B subgrade strength, so the values in the column labeled B(10) are used for this analysis. The Top portion of Table A3-4 shows the required thickness using the CBR thickness design in accordance with the FAA CBR method for a flexible pavement with a CBR 9 subgrade. The B747-400 aircraft has the greatest individual pavement thickness requirement (30.26 inches) for its total traffic over 20 years. Note the thickness requirements for each individual aircraft are several inches less than the evaluation pavement thickness of 33.9 inches. This indicates that the pavement has sufficient thickness for existing traffic.
The Middle portion of Table A3-4 shows the results of the detailed method based on the cumulative damage factor (CDF) procedure that allows the calculation of the combined effect of multiple aircraft in the traffic mix. This combined traffic is brought together into equivalent traffic considering each aircraft as the critical aircraft.
The CDF analysis calculates a maximum allowable gross weight, equivalent coverage level, and corresponding thickness for each aircraft in the traffic mix at the evaluation thickness (33.9 in.) and support conditions (9 CBR).
Referring to the CDF calculation results shown in The Middle portion of Table A3-4, there are five aircraft that can load the pavement over 5,000,000 times before the pavement fails. These aircraft have little impact on this pavement’s structural performance. All aircraft can operate at gross weights higher than current levels. Note: the thickness requirement values in the third column are less than the evaluation thickness. This pavement has sufficient strength to accommodate existing traffic.
The last four columns of The Middle portion of Table A3-4 show ACN of each aircraft at its maximum allowable gross weight and 10,000 coverages. These values are labeled as PCN values and determine the load carrying capacity of the pavement. The values in the column labeled B(10) are used for this analysis since the existing CBR of 9 is within the standard range for Category B subgrade support. The PCN for this pavement can be reported as the highest PCN in the Category B column. The airport may report a PCN of 73/F/B/W/T or 73/F/B/X/T.
b. Flexible Pavement Example 2. This second example has the same input traffic parameters and pavement cross-section as Example 1, but with a CBR of 7.
Existing pavement: 5 inch asphalt surface layer (P-401) 4 inch base layer (P-304) 6 inch base layer (P-209) 17 inches subbase layer (P-154) Subgrade CBR 7
P-304 plus P-209 exceed P-209 requirements. Portion of P-304 is converted to P-209 and excess P-304 converted to P-154. This conversion results in 1.9 inches added to equivalent pavement thickness.
Equivalent Pavement: 5 inch asphalt surface layer (P-401) 8 inch base layer (P-209) 20.9 inch subbase layer (P-154) 33.9 inch total thickness Subgrade CBR 7
Figure A3-3. Flexible Pavement Example 2 Cross-Section
P-401 P-401
P-304
P-209
P-209
P-154 P-154
Subgrade
CBR 7.0
Subgrade
CBR 7.0
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Existing Pavement Equivalent Pavement
Depth from Surface, in.
Table A3-5 shows the results of the COMFAA Batch PCN Flexible calculations. The Bottom portion of Table A3-5 shows traffic parameters and the ACN of the traffic aircraft for all subgrade categories.
Table A3-5. Flexible Pavement Example 2
The existing pavement has a CBR of 7, which is Category C subgrade strength, so the values in the column labeled C(6) are used for this analysis.
The Top portion of Table A3-5 shows the required thickness using the CBR thickness design in accordance with the FAA CBR method for a flexible pavement with a CBR 7 subgrade. The B747-400 aircraft has the greatest individual pavement thickness requirement (36.87 inches) for its total traffic over 20 years. Note the thickness requirements for the B747-400 is greater than the evaluation pavement thickness and the thickness required for the A300-B4 (33.06 inches) is only slightly less than the evaluation thickness (33.9 inches). Since the thickness requirement exceeds the evaluation thickness for some of the traffic, the PCN will be less than the ACN values shown in the bottom table.
The Middle portion of Table A3-5 shows the results of the detailed method based on the cumulative damage factor (CDF) procedure that allows the calculation of the combined effect
of multiple aircraft in the traffic mix. This combined traffic is brought together into equivalent traffic considering each aircraft as the critical aircraft.
The CDF analysis calculates a maximum allowable gross weight, equivalent coverage level, and corresponding thickness for each aircraft in the traffic mix at the evaluation thickness (33.9 in.) and support conditions (7 CBR).
Referring to the CDF calculation results shown in The Middle portion of Table A3-5, the B737-300 and the A319-100 have little impact on this pavement’s performance, However, the B767-200 ER, the B777-200 ER, and the DC 8/63 contribute to the cumulative damage on this pavement’s performance. The reduced CBR from 9 to 7 has a substantial impact on the load carrying capacity of the pavement. The thickness requirement values calculated in the CDF analysis exceed the evaluation thickness. The pavement does not have sufficient strength to accommodate all existing traffic. The last four columns of the Bottom portion of Table A3-5 show ACN of each aircraft at its maximum allowable gross weight and 10,000 coverages. These values are labeled as PCN values and determine the load carrying capacity of the pavement. The values in the column labeled C(6) are used for this analysis since the existing CBR of 7 is within the standard range for Category C subgrade support. The PCN for this pavement can be reported as the highest PCN in the Category C column of the Middle portion of Table A3-5. The airport may report a PCN of 60/F/C/W/T or 60/F/C/X/T. The ACN of three aircraft exceed the pavement PCN and the airport should plan for a pavement strengthening project or consider placing restrictions on those aircraft.
c. Flexible Pavement Example 3. The only change in this example from the second example is that the taxiway is a central configuration rather than parallel, such as that shown in Figure A1-1b. Table A3-6 shows the effect when the P/TC ratio changes from 1 to 2, which results in double the number of coverages for each aircraft in the traffic mix. As expected, the required total pavement thickness for each aircraft in the traffic mix has increased. The B747-400 aircraft has the greatest individual pavement thickness requirement (38.06 inches) for its total traffic over 20 years. Note the thickness requirements for the A300-B4 STD now exceeds the evaluation thickness (33.9 in.) and the thickness requirements for two additional aircraft in the traffic approach the evaluation thickness.
Table A3-6. Flexible Pavement Example 3
Referring to the Middle portion of the table, only the B737-300 and the A319-100 std have little impact on this pavement’s performance. It is more apparent the pavement is not adequate to accommodate the existing traffic. As expected, changing the taxiway system from parallel to central has lowered the PCN of the pavement by effectively doubling traffic volume. The airport may report 58/F/C/W/T or 58/F/C/X/T. The ACN of four aircraft, the B747-400, the A300-B4 STD, and the B777-200 ER exceed the pavement PCN and the airport should plan for a pavement strengthening project or consider placing restrictions on those aircraft. The net effect of the change in taxiway configuration from that of Example 2 is the reduction in PCN by 2.
d. Flexible Pavement Example 4. As an alternate way of looking at the effect of a parallel versus central taxiway effects, consider how the pavement life would change instead of the PCN. If the reported PCN from Example 2 were to remain at 60/F/C/W/T or 60/F/C/X/T, then the pavement life would be reduced by one-half. This is due to the change in the P/TC ratio. A similar effect would be noticed if fuel was not obtained at the airport, (it was obtained in the second flexible pavement example case). With a P/TC ratio of 3, the
PCN is reduced to 57.With a P/TC ratio of 3, the pavement life would be one-third the pavement life of the same pavement with a P/TC ratio of 1.
2.3 TECHNICAL EVALUATION FOR RIGID PAVEMENTS. The following list summarizes the steps for using the technical evaluation method for rigid pavements:
Determine the traffic volume in terms of type of aircraft and number of annual
departures of each aircraft.
Determine the pavement characteristics, including subgrade soil modulus, k, and the
concrete thickness and flexural strength.
Perform the CDF calculations to determine the maximum allowable gross weight for
each aircraft on that pavement at the equivalent annual departure level.
Calculate the ACN of each aircraft at its maximum allowable gross weight. Select the
PCN from the ACN data provided by all aircraft.
The above steps are explained in greater detail:
1. Determine the traffic volume in the same fashion as noted in paragraph A3-2.1 for flexible pavements.
2. From field data or construction drawings, document the k value of the subgrade soil. Alternatively, conduct field or laboratory tests of the subgrade soil in order to determine the k value. Accurate portrayal of the subgrade k value is vital to the technical method because a small variation in k could result in a disproportionately large variation in the aircraft allowable gross weight and the corresponding PCN.
3. Using COMFAA, input annual departure level for each aircraft, input the Pass/Traffic cycle ratio (P/TC) for the runway.
4. The rigid design procedure implemented in the COMFAA program calculates pavement thickness requirements based on the concrete edge stress, which is in turn dependent on load repetitions of the total traffic mix. It is therefore a requirement to convert traffic cycles or passes to load repetitions by using a pass-to-load repetition ratio. P/C ratios for any aircraft on rigid pavement are calculated in the COMFAA program. COMFAA allows the user to directly input annual departures or coverages and will use aircraft-specific pass-to-coverage ratios to automatically convert to coverages for calculation purposes. Since the pass-to-coverage ratio for rigid pavement may be different than flexible pavement, the user must enter coverages in the appropriate location for each pavement type.
5. Obtain the pavement characteristics including the concrete slab thickness, the concrete modulus of rupture, and average modulus, k, of the subgrade. Concrete elastic modulus is set at 4,000,000 psi and Poisson’s ratio is set at 0.15 in the COMFAA program. Accurate subgrade modulus determination is important to the technical method, but small variations in the modulus will not affect the PCN results
in a disproportionate manner. This is in contrast to flexible pavement subgrade modulus in which strength variations have a significant effect on PCN. If the pavement has a subbase course and/or stabilized subbase layers, then the subgrade modulus is adjusted upwards in the rigid design procedure to an equivalent value in order to account for the improvement in support. Subgrade modulus adjustments are made based on the FAA CBR method guidance included herein as Figures A2-4 through A2-7 and summarized in Table A2-2.
6. Using the known slab thickness modified based on overlays (see Figure A2-7), subgrade modulus modified based on improvements gained from subbase course(s) (see Figures A2-4 and A2-6), P/TC ratio for the runway, each individual aircraft’s annual departure level, and each aircraft’s parameters, compute the maximum allowable gross weight of each aircraft using the COMFAA program in the pavement design mode.
7. Assign the subgrade modulus (k-value) to the nearest standard ACN-PCN subgrade code. The k-value to be reported for PCN purposes is the improved k-value seen at the top of all improved layers (k-value directly beneath the concrete layer). Subgrade codes for k-value ranges are found in Table 2-1.
8. The ACN of each aircraft may now be determined from the COMFAA program. Enter the allowable gross weight of each aircraft from Step 6, and calculate the ACN for the standard subgrade codes. Alternatively, consult an “ACN versus Gross Weight” chart as published in the manufacturer’s ACAP manual.
9. Assign the tire pressure code based on the highest tire pressure in the traffic mix from Table 4-2. As discussed previously, rigid pavements are typically able to handle high tire pressures, so code W can usually be assigned.
10. The evaluation method is technical, so the code T will be used as discussed in paragraph 4.5e.
11. The numerical value of the PCN is selected from the list of ACN values resulting from Step 6 from all aircraft. If all aircraft regularly use the airport, then select the highest ACN value and report it as the PCN. If some of the aircraft in the traffic mix use the airport infrequently, then further consideration must be given to the selection of the PCN. If an aircraft that operates infrequently at the airport generates a PCN value considerably higher than the rest of the traffic mix, then reporting the ACN of this aircraft as the PCN will require a change to the PCN if the aircraft’s usage changes.
12. The numerical value of the PCN is the same as the numerical value of the ACN of the critical aircraft just calculated in Step 11.
13. If the allowable gross weight of Step 11 is equal to or greater than the critical aircraft operational gross weight required for the desired pavement life, then the pavement is capable of handling the predicted traffic for the time period established in the traffic forecast. Accordingly, the assigned PCN determined in Step 12 is sufficient. If the
allowable gross weight from Step 11 is less than the critical aircraft gross weight required for the desired pavement life, then the pavement may be assigned a PCN equal to the ACN of the critical aircraft at that gross weight, but with a reduced pavement life. Additionally, it may then be necessary to develop a relationship of allowable gross weight based on the assigned PCN versus pavement life. Appendix 4 provides procedures on how to relate pavement life and gross weight for rigid pavements in terms of PCN. Any overload should be treated in terms of ACN and equivalent critical aircraft operations per individual operation. Allowance for the overload should be negotiated with the airport authority, since pre-approval cannot be assumed. Appendix 4 provides specific procedures on how to relate pavement life and gross weight for rigid pavements.
2.4 TECHNICAL EVALUATION EXAMPLES FOR RIGID PAVEMENTS.
The following three examples help explain the technical evaluation method of determining a PCN for rigid pavements. The first example pavement is under-designed and the traffic volume has increased to such a level that pavement life is reduced from the original design. The second pavement has more than adequate strength to handle the forecasted traffic. The third example pavement is the same as number two, except that the aircraft generally do not obtain fuel at the airport.
a. Rigid Pavement Example 1. An airport has a rigid (concrete-surfaced) runway pavement with a subgrade k-value of 100 pci and a slab thickness of 14 inches, with an existing cross section as shown in Figure A3-4. The concrete has a modulus of rupture of 700 psi, an elastic modulus of 4,000,000 psi, and a Poisson’s ratio of 0.15. The runway has a parallel taxiway, and additional fuel is generally obtained at the airport before departure. The pavement life is estimated to be 20 years from the original construction. The traffic shown in Table A3-7 is the same as in Table A3-6.
Existing pavement: 14 inch concrete layer (P-501) 5 inch stabilized subbase layer (P-304) 5 inch soil-cement subbase layer (P-301) Subgrade k-value 100 k-value improvement. 5 inch P-304 improves k-value to 241 5 inch P-301 improves k-value to 138 Equivalent Pavement: 14 inch concrete layer (P-501) k-value 241 pci. Concrete strength 700 psi.
Figure A3-4. Rigid Pavement Example 1 Cross-Section
P-501 flex strength =
700 psi.
P-501 flex strength =
700 psi.
Stabilized k=
241 P-304
P-301 Uncrushed k
= 138
Subgrade k=
100 Subgrade k=
100
0
5
10
15
20
25
Existing Pavement Equivalent Pavement
Depth from Surface, in.
The critical aircraft will be the one with the highest required thickness for its load magnitude and frequency. The thickness required for each aircraft is determined with the COMFAA program in the pavement design mode. The load repetitions must first be calculated for each aircraft by using Equation A1-1 and then converted to coverages for use in the COMFAA program. Since additional fuel is generally obtained at the airport, and there is a parallel taxiway, so—
P/TC = 1
Tables A3-7 shows the results from COMFAA. The Bottom portion of Table A3-7 shows traffic parameters and the ACN of the traffic aircraft for all subgrade categories. Columns 5 through 8 of the Bottom table show the ACN for each aircraft at each subgrade strength category. The equivalent pavement has a k-value of 241 pci., which is Category B subgrade strength, so the values in the column labeled B(295) are used for this analysis.
Table A3-7. Rigid Pavement Example 1
The Top portion of Table A3-7 shows the required thickness using the thickness design in accordance with the FAA Westergaard method for a concrete pavement with subgrade kvalue of 241 pci. The B747-400 aircraft has the greatest individual pavement thickness requirement (14.13 inches) for its total traffic over 20 years. Note the thickness requirements
P-501 flex strength =
700 psi.
P-501 flex strength =
700 psi.
Stabilized k=
241 P-304
P-301 Uncrushed
k = 138
Subgrade k=
100 Subgrade k=
100
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Existing Pavement Equivalent Pavement
Depth from Surface, in.
for the B747-400 exceeds the evaluation pavement thickness (14.0 in). This indicates the PCN values for the existing traffic will be less than the values shown in the Bottom portion of Table A3-7.
The Middle portion of Table A3-7 shows the results of the detailed method based on the cumulative damage factor (CDF) procedure that allows the calculation of the combined effect of multiple aircraft in the traffic mix. This combined traffic is brought together into equivalent traffic considering each aircraft as the critical aircraft.
The CDF analysis calculates a maximum allowable gross weight, equivalent coverage level, and corresponding thickness for each aircraft in the traffic mix at the evaluation thickness (14.0 in.) and support conditions (241 pci).
Referring to the CDF calculation results shown in the Middle portion of Table A3-7, the B737-300, the A319-100 std, the B767-200 ER, and the B777-200 contribute the least to the cumulative damage on this pavement. However, the required thickness in Column 3 is consistently greater than the evaluation thickness. The pavement does not have sufficient strength to accommodate all existing traffic. The values in the column labeled B(295) of the Middle portion of Table A3-7 are used for this analysis since the existing k-value of 241 pci. is within the standard range for Category B subgrade support. The PCN for this pavement can be reported as the highest PCN in the B(295) column. The airport may report a PCN of 56/R/B/W/T. The ACN (Bottom portion of Table A3-7) of the aircraft the pavement PCN and the airport should plan for a pavement strengthening project or consider placing restrictions on those aircraft.
b. Rigid Pavement Example 2. This second example has the same input parameters as the first, except the slab thickness is increased to 15 inches, as shown in Figure A3-5.
Existing pavement: 15 inch concrete layer (P-501) 5 inch stabilized subbase layer (P-304) 5 inch soil-cement subbase layer (P-301) Subgrade k-value 100 k-value improvement. 5 inch P-304 improves k-value to 241 5 inch P-301 improves k-value to 138 Equivalent Pavement: 15 inch concrete layer (P-501) k-value 241 pci. Concrete strength 700 psi.
Figure A3-5. Rigid Pavement Example 2 Cross-Section
Table A3-8 shows the results from COMFAA.
Table A3-8. Rigid Pavement Example 2
The Top portion of Table A3-8 shows the required thickness using the thickness design in accordance with the FAA Westergaard method for a concrete pavement with subgrade kvalue of 241 pci. The B747-400 aircraft has the greatest individual pavement thickness requirement (14.13 inches) for its total traffic over 20 years. Note the thickness requirements for each individual aircraft are less than the evaluation pavement thickness of 15.0 inches. This indicates that the pavement may have sufficient thickness for existing traffic, however, the results from the cumulative damage factor (CDF) procedure are needed for confirmation.
The Middle portion of Table A3-8 shows the results of the detailed method based on the CDF procedure that allows the calculation of the combined effect of multiple aircraft in the traffic mix. This combined traffic is brought together into equivalent traffic considering each aircraft as the critical aircraft.
The CDF analysis calculates a maximum allowable gross weight, equivalent coverage level, and corresponding thickness for each aircraft in the traffic mix at the evaluation thickness (15.0 in.) and support conditions (241 pci).
Referring to the calculation results shown in the Middle portion of the table, all aircraft can operate at gross weights higher than current levels. This pavement has more than sufficient strength to accommodate existing traffic. The values in the Column labeled B(295) in the Middle portion of the table are used for this analysis since the existing k-value is within the standard range for Category B subgrade support. The PCN for this pavement can be reported as the highest PCN in the B(295) column. The airport may report a PCN of 67R/B/W/T. The pavement will adequately accommodate the existing traffic within its design life, and no adjustments to the pavement cross-section or life will have to be made.
c. Rigid Pavement Example 3. The only change in this example from the second example is that the aircraft generally do not obtain fuel at the airport. Referring to Table A3- 9, the P/TC ratio changes from 1 to 2.
The change results in double the number of coverages for each aircraft in the traffic mix as shown in The Top portion of Table A3-9. As expected, the required total pavement thickness for each aircraft in the traffic mix has increased. The B747-400 aircraft has the greatest individual pavement thickness requirement (14.74) inches) for its total traffic over 20 years.
Table A3-9. Rigid Pavement Example 3
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 155 passages shown