Order 8120.23B Certificate Management of Production Approval Holders
This Order explains the Aircraft Certification Service (AIR)certificate management program. Note: This order is available to the public for information purposes only. Its content is not legally binding on the public in its own right and will not be relied upon by the Department as a separate basis for affirmative enforcement action or other administrative penalty. Public conformity with the guidance document is voluntary only; nonconformity will not affect rights and obligations under existing statutes and regulations.
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION
ORDER 8120.23B
National Policy 05/20/2026
SUBJ: Certificate Management of Production Approval Holders
This order provides guidance and assigns responsibility for implementing the Aircraft Certification Service (AIR) certificate management related to production activities of manufacturers and their suppliers that produce products and articles in accordance with Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR).
This order has been organized into seven chapters covering five functional components. Chapters 1 and 2 include general information and describe the certificate management overview and process. Chapter 3 describes ongoing certificate management responsibilities, including production approval holder (PAH) risk assessment and risk within a facility. Chapter 4 describes the types of certificate management audits. Chapter 5 describes additional oversight responsibilities. Chapter 6 and Chapter 7 describe the oversight information system and administration information. The appendices to this order provide additional information for conducting certificate management oversight.
DANIEL J.
Digitally signed by DANIEL J. ELGAS ELGAS
Date: 2026.05.20 12:44:29 -04'00' Daniel J. Elgas Aviation Safety Director, Policy and Standards Division, Aircraft Certification Service
Distribution: Electronic Initiated By: AIR-634
Table of Contents
Paragraph Page
Chapter 1. General … 1-1
1-1. Purpose of This Order … 1-1
1-2. Audience … 1-1
1-3. Where to Find This Order … 1-1
1-4. What This Order Cancels … 1-1
1-5. Explanation of Policy Changes … 1-1
1-6. Effective Date … 1-3
Chapter 2. Certificate Management Overview … 2-1
2-1. Purpose of This Chapter … 2-1
2-2. FAA’s Authority to Perform Certificate Management … 2-1
2-3. Certificate Management Program Overview … 2-1
Chapter 3. Ongoing Certificate Management Responsibilities … 3-1
Section 1. Introduction … 3-1
3-1. Purpose of This Chapter … 3-1
3-2. Audit Basics … 3-1
3-3. Assignment of Certificate Management Coordinator … 3-1
3-4. Status of a PAH … 3-1
Section 2. Certificate Management Scheduling … 3-3
3-5. General … 3-3
3-6. Risk Assessment … 3-3
3-7. Risk Assessment Preparation … 3-3
3-8. Exposure Within the National Airspace System (NAS) … 3-3
3-9. Organizational Risk Assessment … 3-5
3-10. Minimum Audit Requirements … 3-5
3-11. Agreement of Risk Assessment … 3-6
3-12. Modification of Risk Assessment … 3-6
3-13. Overview of Facility Selection and Scheduling … 3-6
3-14. Facility Selection Process … 3-7
3-15. Supplier Risk Indicators … 3-8
3-16. Scheduling Certificate Management Audits … 3-9
i
Table of Contents
Paragraph Page 3-17. Hand-off Procedures … 3-10
Section 3. Certificate Management Planning … 3-11
3-18. Risk Within a Facility … 3-11
3-19. Facility Plan … 3-12
3-20. Audit Plan … 3-12
Section 4. Conducting and Documenting Audits … 3-13
Part 1. Overview … 3-13
3-21. Product-Based System Audits … 3-13
Part 2. Product Audits … 3-13
3-22. What Is a Product Audit? … 3-13
3-23. Selection of Product Audit Characteristics … 3-13
3-24. Product Audit Areas … 3-14
3-25. Product Audit Criteria … 3-14
3-26. Recording Product Audit Results … 3-15
3-27. Recording Completion of a Product Audit … 3-15
Section 5. Post-Audit Activities and Processing Noncompliances … 3-16
3-28. General … 3-16
3-29. Documenting Noncompliances … 3-16
3-30. Processing Noncompliances … 3-16
3-31. Obtaining Corrective Action … 3-17
3-32. Performing Post-Audit Activities … 3-17
Chapter 4. Types of Audits … 4-1
Section 1. Introduction … 4-1
4-1. General … 4-1
Section 2. PI Audits … 4-1
Part 1. Overview … 4-1
4-2. What Is a PI Audit? … 4-1
Part 2. Scheduling PI Audits … 4-1
4-3. Scheduling a PI Audit … 4-1
Part 3. Conducting PI Audits of a PAH’s Supplier Control … 4-1
4-4. Review of PAH Supplier Control System Element During PI Audits … 4-1
ii
Table of Contents
Paragraph Page 4-5. Verification of PAH’s Supplier Control Procedures … 4-2
4-6. Use of Risk-Based Oversight for Supplier Control … 4-2
Part 4. Conducting PI Audits with SMS Compliance Audits … 4-2
4-7. SMS Compliance Audits Integrated with PI Audits … 4-2
Part 5. Documenting PI Audit … 4-3
4-8. Recording a PI Audit … 4-3
Section 3. Supplier Control Audits … 4-3
Part 1. Overview … 4-3
4-9. What Is a Supplier Control Audit? … 4-3
4-10. Purpose of a Supplier Control Audit … 4-3
4-11. General PAH Supplier Control Responsibilities … 4-3
4-12. Coordination of Requests for Supplier Oversight Assistance With Other CAAs … 4-5
Part 2. Scheduling of Supplier Control Audits … 4-6
4-13. Division Supplier Control Audit Schedule … 4-6
4-14. Coordination of SCAs … 4-6
4-15. Notifying a PAH … 4-7
Part 3. Conducting Supplier Control Audits … 4-10
4-16. Audit Criteria … 4-10
4-17. Recording a Supplier Control Audit … 4-10
Section 4. Quality System Audits … 4-10
Part 1. Overview … 4-10
4-18. What Is a QSA? … 4-10
Part 2. Selection and Scheduling of QSAs … 4-11
4-19. QSA Intervals … 4-11
4-20. Selection of Facilities to Be Audited … 4-11
4-21. Scheduling of QSAs … 4-11
4-22. Selection of QSA Auditors … 4-13
4-23. Notification of Facilities To Be Audited … 4-15
4-24. Modifications to Scheduled Audits … 4-16
Part 3. QSA Roles and Responsibilities … 4-16
4-25. Lead Audit Office … 4-16
4-26. Assigned Certification Branch and CM Sections … 4-16
iii
Table of Contents
Paragraph Page 4-27. Audit Team Leader or Principal Auditor … 4-16
4-28. Audit Team Member … 4-18
Part 4. Conducting the QSA … 4-18
4-29. Team Leader or Principal Auditor Coordination With Facility Representative … 4-18
4-30. Pre-Audit Team Meeting … 4-18
4-31. Pre-Audit Conference … 4-19
4-32. Audit of Quality System Elements … 4-20
4-33. Recording Noncompliances … 4-21
4-34. Audit Meetings. … 4-22
4-35. Post-Audit Conference … 4-23
Part 5. Post-QSA Activities … 4-24
4-36. Preparing the QSA Report … 4-24
4-37. Quality Review of the Report … 4-25
4-38. Sending the QSA Report … 4-25
4-39. Requesting Corrective Action … 4-26
Chapter 5. Additional Oversight Responsibilities … 5-1
Section 1. Introduction … 5-1
5-1. Purpose of This Chapter … 5-1
Section 2. Review of Changes to a PAH’s Quality System … 5-1
5-2. General CM Section Responsibilities … 5-1
5-3. Prioritization of Review … 5-1
5-4. Review of Changes … 5-1
5-5. Post Review Actions … 5-1
Section 3. Reserved … 5-4
Section 4. Investigation of § 21.3, Failures, Malfunctions and Defects Reports … 5-4
5-6. General Information … 5-4
5-7. Investigation … 5-5
5-8. Corrective Action … 5-5
5-9. Processing an Investigation of a § 21.3 Report … 5-5
5-10. Foreign Manufacturers … 5-6
Section 5. Unscheduled Audits and Investigations … 5-6
iv
Table of Contents
Paragraph Page 5-11. General Unscheduled Audit Information … 5-6
5-12. Unscheduled Audits … 5-6
5-13. Special Audit Items (SAI) … 5-8
Section 6. Providing Guidance to a PAH … 5-8
5-14. Guidance … 5-8
Chapter 6. The Oversight Information System … 6-1
6-1. Purpose of This Chapter … 6-1
6-2. Initial Activation of a New PAH in the Oversight Information System … 6-1
6-3. Forms … 6-1
6-4. Database Management … 6-1
6-5. Periodic Review of Risk Assessment Tools … 6-1
6-6. Use of the Database … 6-2
Chapter 7. Administrative Information … 7-1
7-1. Distribution … 7-1
7-2. Delegation of Authority … 7-1
7-3. Authority to Change This Order … 7-1
7-4. Definitions … 7-1
7-5. Related Publications … 7-1
7-6. Deviations … 7-1
7-7. Forms … 7-1
7-8. Suggestions for Improvements … 7-1
7-9. Records Management … 7-1
Appendix A. Category Parts List … A-1
Appendix B. Audit Plan … B-1
Appendix C. Preparation Instructions for FAA Form 8120-14, Production Approval/Certificate Management Activity Report … C-1
Appendix D. Preparation Instructions for FAA Form 8100-6, Noncompliance Record … D-1
Appendix E. Standardized Noncompliance Codes for PAHs … E-1
Appendix F. QSA Auditor Appointment and Training … F-1
v
Table of Contents
Paragraph Page Appendix G. Preparation of the QSA Notification Letter to a PAH … G-1
Appendix H. Preparation Instructions for FAA Quality System Audit Executive Summary … H-1
Appendix I. Preparation Instructions for Quality System Audit Special Emphasis Items … I-1
Appendix J. Preparation Instructions for FAA Form 8100-3, Quality System Audit Report, Cover Pages … J-1
Appendix K. Acronyms … K-1
Appendix L. Definitions … L-1
Appendix M. Directive Feedback Information … M-1
vi
List of Tables Table Page
3-1. Ongoing Certificate Management Audit Minimum Requirements … 3-5
4-1. Selecting a PI or AE as an Auditor … 4-15
E-1. Quality System Elements … E-1
E-2. Noncompliance Codes … E-2
List of Figures Figure Page
2-1. Certificate Management Life Cycle Process … 2-3
3-1. Four Pillars of Risk Assessment … 3-3
3-2. Risk Level Determination Process … 3-4
4-1. Sample Supplier Control Audit Notification Letter … 4-9
5-1. Sample Letter of Approval for Quality System Changes … 5-3
A-1. Sample Part Catergorization Memo for Requesting a Change to the CPL … A-4
C-1. Sample FAA Form 8120-14 (Front) … C-3
C-2. Sample FAA Form 8120-14 (Back) … C-4
D-1. Sample FAA Form 8100-6 … D-4
F-1. Criteria for Candidate Selection and Team Member Appointment … F-2
F-2. Criteria for Team Leader Appointmemt … F-6
G-1. Sample Paragraphs for the Notification Letter … G-2
H-1. Sample Executive Summary for Facilities with Noncompliances … H-2
H-2. Sample Executive Summary for Facilities With No Noncompliances … H-3
I-1. Sample Quality System Audit Special Emphasis Items for PAHs … I-2
J-1. Sample FAA Form 8100-3 (Front) … J-2
J-2. Sample FAA Form 8100-3 (Back) … J-4
vii
1-5. Explanation of Policy Changes. › a. Organizes the ongoing certificate management process into four…
Chapter 1. General
1-1. Purpose of This Order. This Order explains the Aircraft Certification Service (AIR) certificate management program.
Note: This order is available to the public for information purposes only. Its content is not legally binding on the public in its own right and will not be relied upon by the Department as a separate basis for affirmative enforcement action or other administrative penalty. Public conformity with the guidance document is voluntary only; nonconformity will not affect rights and obligations under existing statutes and regulations.
1-2. Audience. All Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) employees who participate in certificate management activities conducted at a production approval holder (PAH) and its suppliers.
Note: As used in this order, the term PAH encompasses both a PAH and its associate facilities.
1-3. Where to Find This Order. You can find this order on the FAA employee website, on the FAA public website, and in the FAA Dynamic Regulatory System (DRS). Unless stated otherwise, please refer to the latest version.
1-4. What This Order Cancels. This revision cancels the following order, deviations, and policy memorandums:
a. FAA Order 8120.23A, CHG 2, Certificate Management of Production Approval Holders, dated June 6, 2025.
b. AIR-600-DM43, Deviation to FAA Order 8120.23, CH2, Certificate Management of Production Approval Holders, Implementation of Risk Within a Facility Assessment at AIR-582 Production Approval Holders, dated September 25, 2025.
c. AIR-600-DM34, Deviation to FAA Order 8120.23, CHG 1, Certificate Management of Production Approval Holders, to Allow for Additional Team Members-in-Training for Quality System Audits (QSA), dated April 10, 2025.
d. AIR-600-GM-09, Revision to FAA 8100-3, Quality System Report No.: FAA 8100-6, Approval/Certificate Management Activity Report, dated February 21, 2024.
e. AIR-100-14-140-GM13, Clarification of QSA Credit Received for Participation During MIDO Audits, dated July 21, 2017.
1-5. Explanation of Policy Changes. This revision:
a. Organizes the ongoing certificate management process into four sections: scheduling audits, planning audits, conducting and documenting audits, and post-audit activities including processing noncompliances.
b. Introduces the fourth pillar of the risk assessment: the process for determining risk within a facility and preparing the facility plan.
p. Updates or revises the following figures, tables, and form: › (2) Figure 3-1, Three Pillars of Risk Assessment to Figure 3-1, Four…
c. Integrates Safety Management System (SMS) compliance audits and their applicability to oversight of a PAH with a required or voluntary SMS (VSMS) into the order.
d. Emphasizes the selection of subtier suppliers and refines the selection of facilities for audits.
e. Establishes supplier risk indicators for suppliers and subtier suppliers as higher, moderate, or lower risk to factor into the facility selection process.
f. Adds guidance for auditing the PAH’s supplier control procedures during principal inspector (PI) audits.
g. Requires a documented audit plan for performing all PI audits, supplier control audits (SCA), and quality system audits (QSA).
h. Defines first article inspections (FAI) and emphasizes FAI under two product audit criteria (Inspection and Documentation) during the performance of a product audit.
i. Emphasizes the importance of reviewing previous findings as part of ongoing certificate management, and adds a step detailing when to determine if a finding is systemic or isolated for PI audits, SCAs, and QSAs.
j. Revises the definitions for systemic and isolated and updates instructions for completing FAA Form 8100-6, Noncompliance Record, with those revised definitions.
k. Adds noncompliance codes for SMS compliance audits.
l. Replaces Aircraft Certification Audit Information System (ACAIS) with the “oversight information system” as the certificate management (CM) automation tool.
m. Moves the QSA Auditor Appointment and Training subpart to a separate appendix.
n. Removes Table 3-3, Applicability of Product Audit Criteria to Product Audit Areas (Minimum).
o. Removes Chapter 4, Section 7, Determining Undue Burden or No Undue Burden to Align with FAA Order 8100.11, Requirements for Finding Undue Burden and No Undue Burden Under 14 CFR Part 21
p. Updates or revises the following figures, tables, and form:
(1) Figure 2-1, Certificate Management Life Cycle Process;
(2) Figure 3-1, Three Pillars of Risk Assessment to Figure 3-1, Four Pillars of Risk Assessment;
Chapter 1. General › 1-6. Effective Date.
(3) Figure 3-2, Risk Level Determination Process;
(4) Table 3-1, Ongoing Certificate Management Audit Minimum Requirements;
(5) Table D-1, Quality System Elements to Table E-1, Quality System Elements and;
(6) FAA Form 8120-14, Production Approval/Certificate Management Activity Report.
1-6. Effective Date. This revision is effective on .
05/29/2026
a. Ongoing Certificate Management. Ongoing certificate management… › (2) Planning certificate management,
Chapter 2. Certificate Management Overview
2-1. Purpose of This Chapter. This chapter provides an overview of the AIR certificate management program. It describes our statutory responsibilities to perform certificate management and explains how our policies fulfill those responsibilities.
Note: References to “Certificate Management Branch” or “CM branch” include branches responsible for the production approval and oversight aspects of this policy within the Integrated Certificate Management Division (AIR-500) and the System Oversight Division (AIR-800). References to “certificate management section” or “CM section” include sections responsible for the production approval and oversight aspects of this policy within AIR-500 and AIR-800. References to “certification branch” include branches and sections responsible for design approval and oversight aspects of this policy within the Compliance and Airworthiness Division (AIR-700) and AIR-500.
2-2. FAA’s Authority to Perform Certificate Management. Title 49 of the United States Code (49 U.S.C.) subtitle VII provides the general statutory authority for the AIR certificate management program and allows the FAA to perform oversight of PAHs at any time and take appropriate actions in the interest of safety. FAA inspectors may enter a PAH’s facility at any time to perform oversight. FAA inspectors must document oversight activities in accordance with paragraph 4-8, 4-17, 4-34(b), and 4-36 of this order and notify a PAH of noncompliances in accordance with Chapter 3, Section 5 of this order. Part 21 of 14 CFR includes specific requirements for PAHs to produce duplicate products or articles. Specifically, 14 CFR 21.137 requires a PAH to describe in writing a quality system that ensures each product and article conforms to its approved design and is in a condition for safe operation. Holders of production certificates (PC), parts manufacturer approvals (PMA), and technical standard order authorizations (TSOA) must meet the responsibilities of a holder as described in 14 CFR 21.146, 21.316, and 21.616, respectively.
2-3. Certificate Management Program Overview. The certificate management program consists of the policies, procedures, and associated information technologies by which the FAA fulfills its statutory responsibilities to ensure a PAH remains in compliance with those regulations that govern the manufacturing of its products or articles. It is a system approach to monitoring a PAH’s compliance with regulations that ensures appropriate corrective actions are taken. The applicable FAA CM section is responsible for all activities associated with the certificate management of PAHs. This program does not impose additional requirements on PAHs.
a. Ongoing Certificate Management. Ongoing certificate management consists of a fourstep closed-loop process that is consistent with safety management system best practices. Figure 2-1 below provides a flowchart of this process. The process consists of the following four steps—
(1) Scheduling certificate management,
(2) Planning certificate management,
d. Additional Oversight Responsibilities. The following tasks are… › (4) Provide guidance to a PAH.
(3) Conducting and documenting audits, and
(4) Performing post-audit activities and processing noncompliances.
b. Approach to Reviewing Previous Findings. Scheduling and planning activities must also include reviewing and analyzing findings and noncompliances from previous audits and other oversight activities to identify and address systemic issues that occur at a PAH and its points of manufacture. A comprehensive review of findings from multiple past audits and other activities, rather than a review only during the audit, is essential to the FAA fulfilling its statutory responsibilities to ensure that a PAH remains in compliance with those regulations that govern the manufacturing of its products or articles.
c. Types of Audits. The FAA performs the following audits as part of its ongoing oversight of PAHs:
(1) Principal Inspector (PI) audits,
(2) Supplier control audits (SCA), and
(3) Quality system audits (QSA).
d. Additional Oversight Responsibilities. The following tasks are accomplished on an as-required basis by the CM section responsible for a specific PAH within its assigned responsibilities. Any tasks required to be scheduled and conducted at a PAH or supplier facility located in another assigned CM section should be handled in accordance with paragraph 3-17 of this order.
(1) Review any changes to a PAH’s quality system,
(2) Investigate any § 21.3 reports,
(3) Perform unscheduled audits and investigations, and
(4) Provide guidance to a PAH.
Figure 2-1. Certificate Management Life Cycle Process
e. Certificate Management Website. The certificate management website… › (3) Any other information to support the certificate management process.
e. Certificate Management Website. The certificate management website is an informational site on which the FAA can add, delete, or change material as required. The certificate management website provides both current and historical information related to aspects of certificate management and may include the following:
(1) Links to certificate management-related—
(a) Data collection and analysis sites;
(b) Work tools;
(c) FAA publications, Quality Management System (QMS) documents, and correspondence;
(d) Briefings, presentations, and articles;
(2) Lessons learned, and
(3) Any other information to support the certificate management process.
3-4. Status of a PAH. › c. Inactive. The FAA has determined that the PAH has not produced…
Chapter 3. Ongoing Certificate Management Responsibilities
Section 1. Introduction
3-1. Purpose of This Chapter. Sections 2 through 5 of this chapter provide detailed guidance for accomplishing ongoing certificate management responsibilities.
3-2. Audit Basics. Auditing is the key component of the certificate management program. An audit (PI audit, SCA, or QSA) is a systematic, independent, and focused data-driven, product based examination of an established PAH’s manufacturing system based on the quality system elements as defined in § 21.137 (refer to Appendix E to this order). Its purpose is for the CM section to validate that the PAH is effectively complying with regulations, and to determine conformity to approved design, quality system requirements, and safety management system (SMS) requirements, as required. An audit is conducted at the location of the PAH or its supplier/subtier supplier. The audit should be conducted at the point of manufacturing, on areas with the highest risk, as identified in the audit plan (refer to Appendix B to this order). All audit activities are documented and maintained in the oversight information system. The oversight information system contains all audit related forms and templates to be used by the CM section when scheduling, planning, conducting, and documenting audits (refer to Chapter 6 of this Order).
3-3. Assignment of Certificate Management Coordinator. Many of the tasks identified in this chapter for the CM branch and the CM sections are primarily administrative. A high degree of operational efficiency may be achieved by assigning many of these tasks to a designated certificate management coordinator. CM branch managers should consider whether such an assignment would be beneficial for their organizations. A CM coordinator may be responsible for the following tasks:
a. Facilitate QSA candidate and auditor appointment and training.
b. Schedule audits and QSA team selection; obtain additional resources when required.
c. Maintain a supplier control audit list.
d. Provide general certificate management-related information.
3-4. Status of a PAH. For purposes of certificate management, the administrative status in the OIS of a PAH and its applicable projects can be identified as one of the following:
a. Pending. The FAA has received the production approval application and is in the approval process; however, no production approvals have been issued.
b. Active. The FAA has issued a new production approval, or the PAH has produced products or articles within the past 12 months.
c. Inactive. The FAA has determined that the PAH has not produced products or articles within the past 12 months. While in an inactive status, the PAH must maintain its
3-4. Status of a PAH. › d. Canceled. The administrative status in the OIS indicating the PAH…
FAA-approved quality system in accordance with 14 CFR Part 21. A PAH may be placed in an inactive status, and noted in the oversight information system, under the following conditions:
(1) The PI may make the determination to keep the PAH inactive up to 36 months from the initial inactive date.
(2) To keep the PAH inactive beyond the 36th month, it must be approved by the PI’s office manager.
(3) To keep the PAH inactive beyond the 48th month, it must be approved by the CM branch manager.
(4) An inactive PAH’s production approval will be cancelled in the 60th month unless approved by a deviation to the order signed by the Policy and Standards Division, AIR-600.
(5) If an inactive PAH resumes production and becomes active, the PI will conduct a risk assessment in accordance with paragraph 3-7 of this order to initiate FAA certificate management.
d. Canceled. The administrative status in the OIS indicating the PAH has surrendered their production approval, or the FAA has completed action to revoke or otherwise terminate the PAH’s production approval.
Note: If the PAH does not surrender its production approval and has no plans for future production, the FAA must follow specific due process procedures outlined in 49 U.S.C. Particularly, 49 U.S.C. 44709 (b)(1)(A) grants the Administrator the authority to revoke various certificates, including production certificates, if, after investigation, the Administrator deems it necessary for safety and public interest. Revocation may require a formal legal enforcement action, which is handled by the Office of Chief Counsel (AGC).
Chapter 3. Ongoing Certificate Management Responsibilities › 3-8. Exposure Within the National Airspace System (NAS).
Section 2. Certificate Management Scheduling
3-5. General. Scheduling activities include conducting an annual in-depth risk assessment of each PAH and scheduling the audit activities based on the results of that risk assessment. AIR’s certificate management policy and its scheduling activities are designed to focus audits on the PAH and its points of manufacture that pose the greatest risk.
3-6. Risk Assessment. To ensure resources are being applied to the appropriate areas of risk and the correct level of oversight is being conducted, each active PAH is subject to a risk assessment. Each assessment employs four pillars, if applicable, to provide a consistent and justifiable basis for effective use of FAA resources when performing certificate management:
a. Exposure within the National Airspace System (NAS), in accordance with paragraph 3-8 of this order;
b. Organizational risk assessment, in accordance with paragraph 3-9 of this order;
c. Facility selection, in accordance with paragraph 3-13 of this order; and
d. Risk within a facility, in accordance with paragraph 3-18 of this order.
Figure 3-1. Four Pillars of Risk Assessment
3-7. Risk Assessment Preparation. The CM section must conduct an annual risk assessment of each PAH between January 1 and March 31, to support the audit schedule for the following fiscal year. Holders of a letter of a technical standard order (TSO) design approval, and PAHs in an inactive status are not subject to a risk assessment. The risk assessment must be conducted in accordance with the instruction provided in the oversight information system and paragraphs 3-8, 3-9, and 3-11 through 3-14 of this order. The PI must collect and verify all information needed to complete the risk assessment before entering the information into the oversight information system. When appropriate, the PI will contact each PAH to obtain current or clarifying information relevant to the risk assessment. The PI must contact each PAH previously designated as inactive to determine whether the PAH’s status has changed.
3-8. Exposure Within the National Airspace System (NAS). The first pillar of the PAH’s overall risk assessment determines the PAH’s risk exposure in the NAS, using the Risk Level Determination Process, located in the oversight information system. The Risk Level Determination Process places the PAH in one of three risk levels, based on a series of questions. Refer to Figure 3-2 of this chapter for the level determination decision flow:
3-8. Exposure Within the National Airspace System (NAS). › c. PAHs placed in Level 3 have the least risk exposure in the NAS.…
a. PAHs placed in Level 1 have the highest risk exposure in the NAS. These PAHs manufacture products, as defined by § 21.1, at high production rates, with greater complexity, and significantly outsource production to its suppliers. These products do not include unmanned aircraft (UA) produced as low-risk. Low-risk UAs, as identified within their type certificate data sheets (TCDS), are considered a Level 3 PAH.
b. PAHs placed in Level 2 manufacture either a product designated as a lesser risk than Level 1 or a critical article.
Note: For Level 1 and Level 2 PAHs, the CM section may change the level determination one level, to either Level 1 or Level 2. If this type of change is made by the CM section, the rationale must be documented in the oversight information system.
c. PAHs placed in Level 3 have the least risk exposure in the NAS. Unlike PAHs placed in Level 1 or Level 2, these PAHs do not manufacture products or articles located on the category parts list (CPL) or designated as critical by the PAH. In addition, PAHs that only manufacture products or articles for low-risk UAs are placed in Level 3.
Note: When using the Risk Level Determination Process, the PI may use the PAH’s critical parts list in lieu of the AIR CPL, when approved by the assigned certification branch.
Figure 3-2. Risk Level Determination Process
Risk Level Determination
Level 1 Determination Decision The PAH must meet all three of the
question criteria or use the option listed below:
Question #1: Does the PAH produce annually more than 100 aircraft, 500 engines (to include rebuilt engines), or 1500 propellers annually?
Question #2: Does the PAH have 2 or more models in production?
Question #3: (a) Does the PAH have 20 or more external suppliers of critical parts/major assemblies
Chapter 3. Ongoing Certificate Management Responsibilities › 3-10. Minimum Audit Requirements.
3-9. Organizational Risk Assessment. Following the determination of the risk level, the second pillar of the PAH’s overall risk assessment utilizes the risk-based resource targeting (RBRT) assessment tool to determine the organizational risk. The tool includes several factors that result in the identification of quality systems and complexities according to their potential to produce nonconforming products or articles and the consequential results associated with introducing those products or articles into the system. As a result of the RBRT assessment, a PAH is assigned one of the following organizational risk levels:
a. High. A PAH with the greatest potential to produce nonconforming products or articles.
b. Medium. A PAH with a moderate potential to produce nonconforming products or articles.
c. Low. A PAH with low potential to produce nonconforming products or articles.
Note: The RBRT assessment questions and the guidance for completing the assessment are in the oversight information system.
3-10. Minimum Audit Requirements. The output of the PAH’s exposure to the NAS and the organizational risk assessment, specifically the risk level determination and the organizational RBRT designation, is used to define the CM section’s certificate management minimum audit requirements. Table 3-1 provides the minimum audit requirements and corresponding frequencies associated with the ongoing certificate management of PAHs.
Table 3-1. Ongoing Certificate Management Audit Minimum Requirements
Level
3 Low
Level 3 Medium
Level 2
Low
Level 2 Medium
Level 2
High
Level 1
Low
Level 1 Medium
Level 1
High
1+ PI Audit within every 3 fiscal years (FYs)
1+ PI Audit within every 2 FYs
1+ point of manufacturing (POM) Audit within every FY
1 QSA NTE 48 months
2+ POM Audits within every FY
1 QSA NTE 36 months
4+ POM Audits within every FY
1 QSA NTE 24 months
6+ POM Audits within every FY
1 QSA NTE 36 months
12+ POM Audits within every FY
1 QSA NTE 24 months
18+ POM Audits within every FY
1 QSA NTE 24 months
Note 1: All audits in the table above are only “minimum” audit requirements. The plus symbol (+) indicates that management of the CM section may determine that additional audits are required.
Note 2: Product audits must be conducted during all audits.
Note 3: SMS Compliance audits, when applicable, are integrated with PI and QSAs.
Chapter 3. Ongoing Certificate Management Responsibilities › 3-13. Overview of Facility Selection and Scheduling.
3-11. Agreement of Risk Assessment. The RBRT assessment tool requires an approving official, usually the CM section manager or their delegate, to review the calculated risk level and the recommended certificate management requirements. To the greatest extent possible, the PI and the CM section manager or their delegate should agree on the final risk level. The CM section manager or their delegate will indicate approval in the oversight information system.
3-12. Modification of Risk Assessment. When any of the following conditions occur at a PAH the PI should complete a new level determination and a new RBRT assessment:
a. Changes in a product or article’s criticality;
b. Significant quality system changes;
c. Significant turnover of key staff;
d. Significant increases or reductions in workforce;
e. Deliberate nonresponsiveness to corrective action requests;
f. Significant service difficulties attributed to manufacturing or quality system problems;
g. Addition or modification of a complex manufacturing process (e.g., additive manufacturing, composite fabrication, friction stir welding);
h. Addition or significant modification of a complex product or article(s);
i. Significant changes in the use of suppliers/outsourcing;
j. Significant increases in the use of international suppliers;
k. Movements or shifts of production locations or volumes;
l. Expiration of a labor contract or potential labor unrest; or
m. Changes in the SMS maturity assessment completed under FAA Order 8120.25, Safety Management Oversight of Design and Production Approval Holders, if applicable.
Note: When the audit schedules are impacted by a change in the assigned risk level, the PI should adjust the certificate management schedule accordingly.
3-13. Overview of Facility Selection and Scheduling. The third pillar of the PAH’s overall risk assessment is the CM section’s determination of which of the PAH’s manufacturing facilities, suppliers and subtier suppliers should be audited. The facility selection determination is a risk-based decision that determines how the required number of audits will be distributed among the PAH’s manufacturing facilities, suppliers and subtier suppliers. To aid in this decision, a facility selection process has been developed that prioritizes a PAH’s manufacturing facilities based on risk. Refer to paragraph 3-14 of this order. The third pillar also includes
3-14. Facility Selection Process. › g. Has the facility been relocated to a new address within the last 12…
low-risk UAs, as identified within their TCDS. These UAs are considered low-risk, Level 3 PAHs. CM sections will not select a point of manufacturing audit at the UA’s supplier location. All certificate management of low-risk UAs will be conducted at the PAH’s location or flight test area.
3-14. Facility Selection Process. After determining the results of a PAH’s exposure to the NAS and completing the organizational risk assessment (i.e., the number and frequency of certificate management audits), the CM section must select the specific point of manufacturing locations (whether PAH, supplier, or subtier supplier facilities) where the required audits will be conducted. This facility selection process is based on a review of the PAH and its supplier manufacturing activities, level determination, RBRT assessment, and the distribution of production responsibilities. As part of the facility selection process, the CM section must evaluate available information regarding the PAH’s suppliers and subtier suppliers, including articles produced and critical processes performed.
Once the CM section determines the minimum number of audits and frequency, the PAH/supplier manufacturing ratio may guide the facility selection process, ensuring that the distribution of audits reflects the proportion of manufacturing between PAHs and their suppliers (e.g., if 80% of production is conducted by the PAH, approximately 80% of the audits should be allocated to PAH facilities). This approach ensures that certificate management audits are strategically assigned to facilities representing the highest risk and impact to the production system. The CM section may use a facility selection process other than the process described in this section, provided the alternate process is equivalent to or better than the facility selection process described in this section. Before its use, the CM section will submit its alternative facility selection process to the CM branch for review and acceptance.
When a PAH has multiple facilities listed on the production approval, numerous suppliers producing critical articles, or both, the CM section will prioritize their audit locations by validating the following criteria:
a. Will the facility produce any aircraft, aircraft engine, propeller, or article thereof in the next twelve months?
b. Does the facility perform any final testing for an aircraft, aircraft engine, propeller, or critical article?
c. Is the facility solely an assembler/ integrator?
d. Are special processes being performed on a critical article (e.g., heat treat, welding, composite, friction stir welding, chemical etching, additive manufacturing, etc.)?
e. Have key inspections or authorizations been delegated to this facility? (e.g., receiving inspection, supplier control, testing, first article inspection (FAI), in-process inspection, nondestructive inspection (NDI), final inspection, dock to stock, Material Review Board (MRB), etc.)?
f. Has the facility been added to the production approval or the supplier listing within the last 12 months?
g. Has the facility been relocated to a new address within the last 12 months?
h. Does evidence indicate that no on-site evaluations have been performed at this facility in the last 12 months?
i. Have any FAA-documented noncompliances at the facility resulted in compliance and enforcement action within the last 2 years?
b. Moderate Risk. Suppliers with one or more of the following… › (4) Suppliers with a history of FAA oversight, however no recent FAA…
j. Has the facility had any quality escapes events within the last 24 months?
k. Is the facility located in a non-bilateral country or a bilateral country where the foreign civil aviation authority (CAA) cannot support the FAA?
l. Is there new or novel manufacturing being implemented at the facility?
m. How many quality systems elements are applicable to the facility (refer to Appendix E to this order)?
n. Other criteria, as applicable.
3-15. Supplier Risk Indicators. The following risk indicators, including any information from paragraph 4-6 of this order, should factor into the facility selection process for suppliers and subtier suppliers:
a. Higher Risk. Suppliers with two or more of the following characteristics should be assigned a higher risk level:
(1) New critical suppliers.
(2) Suppliers that produce critical parts or perform special processes.
(3) Suppliers with known noncompliances or documented quality escapes.
(4) High supplier activity (active purchase orders)
(5) Suppliers that have not undergone a recent FAA audit.
(6) Suppliers that produce parts not inspectable upon receipt.
b. Moderate Risk. Suppliers with one or more of the following characteristics should be assigned a moderate risk level:
(1) Suppliers that produce fewer critical parts or perform fewer special processes than higher risk suppliers.
(2) Moderate supplier activity (active purchase order within the past 12 months)
(3) Suppliers with a history of noncompliances.
(4) Suppliers with a history of FAA oversight, however no recent FAA audit.
b. At a minimum, the certificate management schedule will include the… › (4) A list of hand-offs or CAA requests sent, including, as a minimum,…
c. Lower Risk. Suppliers with one or more of the following characteristics should be assigned a lower risk level:
(1) Suppliers that produce minimal critical parts or perform minimal special processes.
(2) Low supplier activity (no active purchase order within the past 12 months)
(3) Suppliers with a recent FAA audit.
(4) Suppliers with a consistent history of compliance.
Note: The CM section will not select PAHs as suppliers for an SCA unless a special justification exists, or the supplied articles are not part of that PAH’s production approval. If the supplier is a PAH and the supplied articles are listed on the PAH’s production approval, the CM section will conduct the audit following the applicable PAH audit procedures in Chapter 4, Section 2 of this order.
3-16. Scheduling Certificate Management Audits. A certificate management schedule assists the CM section in scheduling and tracking audits and the performance of PAHs and its applicable suppliers and subtier suppliers.
a. After facility selections have been completed, the CM section will develop a certificate management schedule annually for those PAHs that have oversight activities scheduled for the upcoming fiscal year. The CM section will adjust the certificate management schedule when changes occur that affect any of the four pillars of risk.
b. At a minimum, the certificate management schedule will include the following:
(1) The name and location of the PAH or applicable supplier subjected to an audit.
(2) Schedules for the audits to be conducted by the CM section.
(3) Prioritization of the locations to be audited based on the level determination, the RBRT assessment, and the facility selection process. For the number of audits to be conducted at the PAH or supplier locations, refer to table 3-1 of this order. The objective is to conduct oversight at the facilities with the greatest risk. Additional audits at a manufacturing facility may be warranted if the FAA’s confidence in the PAH’s quality system has diminished.
(4) A list of hand-offs or CAA requests sent, including, as a minimum, the name of the assigned office that has accepted the hand-off or the CAA that has accepted the oversight request from the CM section. Also include the type of audit requested, the name of the manufacturing facility receiving the audit, and the name of the responsible PAH. Refer to paragraph 3-17 of this order for more information about hand-off procedures.
Note: Hand-off activity duration can be for any given period of time from a one-day event to multiple days or trips in a given fiscal year. Example: The hand off CM section can request the CAA or other assigned office to perform the audit once a year or once a quarter per year, or multiple years until cancelled.
(6) In the case of an SCA— › (d) Any authority permitting direct shipment.
(5) A list of hand-offs or CAA requests received, including, as a minimum, the name of the CM section or CAA that has requested the hand-off, the type of audit or oversight requested, and the name of the applicable manufacturing facility.
(6) The scheduling function in the oversight information system is intended to provide a starting point in the development of the certificate management schedule. Should an inconsistency develop between the number generated in the oversight information system, frequencies, or scheduled dates of certificate management activities and the requirements in table 3-1 of this order, table 3-1 will take precedence. If the number of audits exceeds the certificate management chart minimums, additional certificate management tasks should be considered at the discretion of the CM section.
3-17. Hand-off Procedures. The following hand-off procedures are applicable to QSA, PI audits, SCAs, and product audits:
a. The requesting CM section will submit, in the oversight information system, a memorandum to the assigned office no later than May 1 of each year. The memorandum will indicate the type of audit that should be conducted and will include all pertinent information regarding the audit, including—
(1) The name and address (including country, as applicable) of the PAH or supplier, the actual address where the audit will occur, as well as the PAH’s project number;
(2) The name, title, and telephone number of the accountable manager at the PAH’s facility or the person to contact at the supplier who can furnish purchase orders, quality system data, technical data, and other pertinent information;
(3) Notification from the CM section to the assigned office, if a PI audit with no advance notice is requested as described in paragraph 4-3 of this order;
(4) Any other information regarding specific PAH or supplier activities that should be audited, such as a new process or new technology;
(5) Information pertinent to a product or article to be audited, such as part number and description, next level of assembly, or service difficulty or warranty return history; and
(6) In the case of an SCA—
(a) Notification from the CM section to the assigned office to provide reduced notice to the PAH, if reduced notice is requested as described in paragraph 4-15 of this order,
(b) A copy of the PAH’s or supplier’s quality system procedures that are required to be implemented at the particular supplier’s facility, unless these documents are available to the FAA at the supplier’s facility,
(c) Any delegation of MRB or technical data change control authority, and
(d) Any authority permitting direct shipment.
a. This assessment: › (5) Supports understanding of the facility’s manufacturing processes,…
b. When an assigned office receives a request to conduct an audit, it will—
(1) Acknowledge the receipt of the request in the oversight information system,
(2) Add the audit to its certificate management schedule, if applicable, and
(3) Provide updated audit lists to the other CM branch managers.
c. At the completion of the audit, the assigned office will document the audit in accordance with Chapter 3, Section 4, to include a memorandum that summarizes the results of the audit. All applicable objective evidence will be provided to the requesting CM section. This memorandum will also close-out the hand-off audit.
Section 3. Certificate Management Planning
3-18. Risk Within a Facility. The fourth pillar, risk within a facility, provides a systematic approach for determining and identifying areas or processes within the facility with the highest risk, those that have the greatest impact on producing critical parts or processes, or both.
a. This assessment:
(1) Is required for all Level 1 and Level 2 High PC holders, however, the CM section may use this assessment to determine risk within a facility for all other PAHs.
(2) When required, must be conducted quarterly and when significant changes are identified within the facility.
(3) Directs evaluation of the facility to determine which areas require targeted oversight, recognizing that some areas may be excluded due it being outside the scope of FAA oversight. The PI will exercise discretion to consider elements such as complexity, critical processes, production impact, historical findings, and other relevant factors.
(4) Requires the collection and use of necessary facility information. PIs are not limited to these sources and may gather any relevant data needed to accurately assess risk. Examples include, but not limited to:
(a) PAH internal data such as statement of work, production nonconformances, quality escapes, and internal audit results.
(b) FAA data such as compliance and enforcement history and prior audit noncompliances, observations from previous oversight, and interviews with PAH employees.
(c) Emerging risk such as new technologies, process changes, production increases, or organizational instability.
(5) Supports understanding of the facility’s manufacturing processes, design approval, and any special processes.
Chapter 3. Ongoing Certificate Management Responsibilities › 3-20. Audit Plan.
Note: The PI or auditor should be familiar with all audited manufacturing areas. If an inspector is not familiar with an area, the CM section should develop and document a plan to ensure that the PI has the experience and knowledge of the manufacturing areas.
(6) Should identify hazards that may affect conformity of part(s), if any, and any mitigation factors associated with the hazards, such as hazards associated with work transfers, relocation of parts, line movements, out of work sequences, etc.
b. The PI will analyze the collected data using a structured, standardized, and documented method. Tools or methods (e.g., matrix, spreadsheet, scoring system) may vary based on facility characteristics, but must allow identification and comparison of high-risk areas.
c. The determination of risk within a facility will support a facility plan as described in paragraph 3-19 of this order.
3-19. Facility Plan. Once the risk within a facility has been determined, the PI must prepare a facility plan identifying areas to target oversight, which may include programs, processes, parts, departments, or physical locations. This plan is particularly important when multiple audits are scheduled at the same facility. If there are changes associated with the risk within a facility determination, the PI should update the plan or conduct an unscheduled audit in accordance with Chapter 5, Section 5 of this order. The CM section should track manufacturing processes previously audited and consider processes or areas that have not been audited. The plan should take into consideration the following:
a. If a process is only performed during non-duty hours, e.g., night shift or weekend, the plan should include auditing during non-duty hours.
b. If an area or process that was planned for an audit is not available, the PI should reschedule the audit or follow up with an unscheduled audit.
c. Areas of highest risk to target oversight, those that have the greatest impact on producing critical parts or processes (e.g., additive manufacturing, heat-treat, composite layup, and noncompliances/quality escapes, etc.), or both.
3-20. Audit Plan. For all audits, the PI must prepare an audit plan before each PI audit and SCA, and the audit Team Leader must prepare an audit plan before each QSA. The audit plan should be scalable to the facility, using guidance found in Appendix B to this order. Audit planning should support the PI’s familiarity with the audited facility. If an audit is handed off per paragraph 3-17 of this order, the requesting CM section and assigned CM section should coordinate who is responsible for developing the audit plan. An audit plan may be found in the OIS, however the division may use an alternate plan not found in the OIS and include a copy in the OIS.
Section 4. Conducting and Documenting Audits
Part 1. Overview
3-21. Product-Based System Audits.
a. AIR employs a product-based system audit approach when conducting audits. A product-based system audit is a planned and recorded activity that relies on using selected products and articles for determining—
(1) Whether that product or article conforms to approved data,
(2) Whether a PAH complies with quality system requirements, including procedures and special processes established to meet those requirements, and
(3) Whether a supplier is furnishing products, articles, or services that conform to the PAH’s requirements.
b. Two types of audits are conducted:
(1) Audits using the point of manufacturing methodology. This is a focused, data driven audit of an article or process performed in the manufacture of a product or article, conducted at any location where the product or article is manufactured or where the process is being performed (that is, the PAH, associate facility, supplier, or subtier supplier location). This methodology uses a combination of a PI audit and a product-based SCA. The PI assigned certificate management responsibility normally performs this activity. These audits focus on areas of high risk within the PAH’s or supplier’s facilities.
(2) QSAs. A QSA is a comprehensive product-based system audit designed to ascertain whether a PAH meets the applicable requirements of 14 CFR and complies with the procedures established to meet those requirements. It applies standardized noncompliance codes that are described in Appendix E to this order.
Note: Though PI audits, SCAs, and QSAs are product-based system audits, a product audit must still be conducted during all scheduled audits and whenever determined to be necessary by the CM section.
Part 2. Product Audits
3-22. What Is a Product Audit? A product audit evaluates the effectiveness of the PAH’s quality system and the airworthiness of products using critical and certain noncritical characteristics, processing attributes generated during the manufacturing process, or both. A product audit is required to be conducted during all audits and whenever determined to be necessary by the PI or CM section, and may be initiated at any point in the manufacturing process after inspections have been completed. The product audit is conducted at a PAH, supplier, or subtier supplier facility where a product or article is manufactured. If specific expertise is required during this audit, the PI should advise the CM section manager.
3-23. Selection of Product Audit Characteristics. The product audit will be conducted using critical characteristics, critical processing attributes generated during the manufacturing process, or both. The product audit may also be conducted using certain non-critical characteristics, non-critical processing attributes, or both. These characteristics and attributes are defined as follows:
a. Critical characteristics are those where failure to maintain conformity could cause loss of function and create an unsafe condition. Critical process attributes are those where lack of conformity directly affects the product or article(s) and could cause failure or create an unsafe condition. The selection of the critical characteristics, critical process attributes, or both, is determined by reviewing the following (this review does not need to be documented):
(1) Known service problem areas.
(2) Characteristics/attributes that are operator controlled. Operator-controlled characteristics/attributes are controlled by people rather than machines or computers.
(3) Characteristics/attributes classified as critical as defined by the PAH’s engineering drawings, process specifications, test specifications, and quality system procedures.
(4) Service difficulty reports (SDR). Information related to service difficulty reports (SDR) can be found on the Service Difficulty Reporting System website.
(5) Characteristics/attributes that are highly process-driven. Process-driving characteristics/attributes are those dictated by precise and often automated processes in the manufacturing process (e.g., additive manufacturing, composite fabrication, friction stir welding, etc.)
b. The PI may select certain noncritical characteristics, noncritical processing attributes, or both. These attributes could include radii, surface finishes, machine to cast features, cad plating, or nondestructive inspection.
3-24. Product Audit Areas. The product audit may be divided into one or more of the following:
a. Product (aircraft, aircraft engine, or propeller)
b. Article (material, part, component, process, or appliance)
3-25. Product Audit Criteria. The audit criteria used in the performance of a product audit to establish conformity to approved design are listed below. These audit criteria are a minimum and not all inclusive.
Note: A product audit is not a reinspection by the FAA representative. Rather, it is the FAA witnessing the reinspection by the PAH or applicable supplier. The PAH’s or applicable supplier’s personnel are responsible for the handling of the articles during the product audit.
a. Operational/functional. Verify that the product or article conforms to the functional/operational test criteria (for example, revalidating test results, test setup, software
revision, software checksum, rig approval, certified equipment, use of approved procedures, certified test parameters, use of required rig, and calibration).
b. Dimensional. Compare actual recorded measurements of the selected characteristic with the approved design data. Verify that characteristics are inspected using the correct calibrated tooling, gauging, fixtures, etc., surface finish dimensions and radius meet drawing tolerances, inspections are performed in proper sequence (following work instructions); for example, review or revalidate inspection records.
c. Inspections. Verify visual inspections of articles for obvious external defects, for example, corrosion, burrs, handling damage, and scratches. Verify key inspections of production processes to ensure they meet approved design requirements, such as, but not limited to, receiving inspection, random sampling, FAI, in-process inspection, NDI, and final inspection.
d. Identification. Compare actual identification plates, tags, markings, etc., with approved design data or purchase order requirements and verify that identification is maintained throughout the product line; for example, part numbers, serial numbers, lot numbers for raw material, and inspection stamps. For software revision verification, verify that the software number can be displayed on screen or software load verified by documentation review.
e. Documentation. Verify the latest revision level or changes, and that the product audit area meets the approved procedures and design requirements. This may include verifying applicable FAI records, proper use of work instructions, completed operations, and proper authorizations. Also verify proper use of statistical sampling, certificate of conformance, work travelers, blueprints, and specifications.
f. Special Processes. Verify that special processes are in accordance with approved process specifications. Verify operator qualification/certification, training requirements for operators, test set ups and test coupons, and oven surveys/calibration. For a chemical process such as plating, verify that control has been established over tank cleanliness and chemical concentration.
g. Material. Verify that the PAH has verified that incoming raw material meets its specification requirements.
3-26. Recording Product Audit Results. All product audit results will be recorded on FAA Form 8100-1, Conformity Inspection Record. When unsatisfactory conditions are identified, also prepare FAA Form(s) 8100-6 (refer to Appendix D to this order). The PI will retain all applicable objective evidence to support unsatisfactory conditions in accordance with FAA Order 2150.3.
3-27. Recording Completion of a Product Audit. The completion of a product audit will be recorded on FAA Form 8120-14 by the person conducting the audit. However, FAA Form 8120- 14 is not required for a QSA unless an onsite supplier audit is done as a part of the QSA. When a product audit is conducted in conjunction with a PI audit or SCA, one form should be completed for all product audits. Prepare this form in accordance with Appendix C to this order.
d. If the PI determines, after the audit is finalized, that the… › (2) Obtain approval from their manager.
Section 5. Post-Audit Activities and Processing Noncompliances
3-28. General. FAA certificate management responsibilities often result in identifying PAH noncompliances. The PI will record all identified noncompliances, including those reported by a CAA while performing certificate management activities for the FAA, on FAA Form 8100-6. FAA Form 8100-6 includes determining the scope of the noncompliance: systemic or isolated. The FAA will notify a PAH of noncompliances found at its supplier. The FAA will not reveal noncompliances to anyone other than the particular PAH involved unless a formal request has been processed in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act (refer to FAA Order 1270.1, Freedom of Information Act Program).
Note: SMS noncompliances identified in a VSMS are not formally documented through enforcement records, and resolution is managed through collaborative corrective actions. The aviation safety inspector (ASI) or aviation safety engineer (ASE) requests that VSMS participants initiate corrective action to address noncompliances identified during oversight of the VSMS participant’s SMS. VSMS participants that do not implement requested corrective action may have their SMS acceptance letter revoked (Refer to FAA Order 8120.25).
3-29. Documenting Noncompliances. All noncompliances are documented and maintained in the oversight information system. If a noncompliance is substantiated, the PI must process the noncompliance in accordance with FAA Order 2150.3, FAA Compliance and Enforcement Program, and the AIR Compliance and Enforcement Process, as described in Technical Business Process AIR-002-035.
3-30. Processing Noncompliances. The PI must review each item on FAA Form 8100-6 to determine if the noncompliance is substantiated. The following are additional considerations when determining the proper means to document a noncompliance:
a. If a facility provides objective evidence subsequent to the issuance of an FAA Form 8100-6 that justifiably negates the basis of the reported noncompliance, a request for corrective action of that noncompliance will not be required. The PI must retain the negated FAA Form 8100-6, justification, and any applicable objective evidence in the oversight information system.
b. If the noncompliance meets the definition of a suspected unapproved part (SUP), as described in FAA Order 8120.16, Suspected Unapproved Parts Program, the PI must report the SUP in accordance with FAA Order 8120.16.
c. If the noncompliances identified on FAA Form(s) 8100-6 are found during an audit conducted as the result of a hand-off, the FAA Form(s) 8100-6 must be transmitted to the requesting CM section for action.
d. If the PI determines, after the audit is finalized, that the noncompliance recorded on FAA Form 8100-6 is incorrect and should be changed, the PI must—
(1) Prepare a justification for changing the type of noncompliance through a memorandum or the oversight information system.
(2) Obtain approval from their manager.
3-32. Performing Post-Audit Activities. › c. Update data for scheduling and planning. The PI must ensure that the…
(3) Inform the team leader or principal auditor of the change, if applicable.
(4) Complete a revised FAA Form 8100-6, corresponding to the changed type of noncompliance.
(5) Retain the original FAA Form 8100-6, the approved justification, the revised FAA Form 8100-6, and any applicable objective evidence.
3-31. Obtaining Corrective Action. Corrective action for all noncompliances must be performed in accordance with FAA Order 2150.3 and the AIR Compliance and Enforcement Process, as described in Technical Business Process AIR-002-035.
3-32. Performing Post-Audit Activities. Post-audit activities are performed to—
a. Validate the PAH’s corrective actions.
b. Update the PAH’s profile in the oversight information system.
c. Update data for scheduling and planning. The PI must ensure that the outcome of the noncompliance and corrective action are incorporated into certificate management scheduling and planning. This includes integration into the PAH’s organizational risk assessment, facility selection process, and risk within a facility, when applicable.
Chapter 4. Types of Audits › 4-4. Review of PAH Supplier Control System Element During PI Audits.
Chapter 4. Types of Audits
Section 1. Introduction
4-1. General. Sections 2 through 4 of this chapter provides guidance for accomplishing the following types of ongoing certificate management audits: PI audits, SCAs, and QSAs.
Section 2. PI Audits
Part 1. Overview
4-2. What Is a PI Audit? A PI audit employs a product-based system approach to evaluate whether a PAH is complying with its approved quality procedures. It is conducted at a PAH’s facility by the CM section having the assigned certificate management responsibility for that PAH. When PAHs are required to comply with 14 CFR Part 5 or are participating in the VSMS program, an SMS compliance audit is integrated with the PI audit, as outlined in Section 2, part 4 of this chapter. The CM section will:
a. For PAHs designated Level 1 and Level 2:
(1) Audit the top five systemic noncompliant quality system elements annually, as identified by each division through an analysis of data in the oversight information system; and
(2) audit all quality system elements between QSAs.
b. For PAHs designated Level 3, at a minimum, audit the top five systemic noncompliant quality system elements, as identified by each division through an analysis of data in the oversight information system.
Part 2. Scheduling PI Audits
4-3. Scheduling a PI Audit. The PI audit will be scheduled by the CM section based on the PAH’s risk assessment in accordance with paragraph 3-6 of this order. A CM section may schedule additional PI audits at specific facilities when required to ensure continued operational safety. CM sections may conduct PI audits with no advance notice to ensure continued operational safety, to facilitate oversight, or to facilitate compliance, or a combination of the previous. The duration of the PI audit may be one day or multiple days, depending on factors such as the PAH’s size, location, production lines, buildings, etc. If specific expertise is required during a PI audit, the PI should advise the manager of the CM section.
Part 3. Conducting PI Audits of a PAH’s Supplier Control
4-4. Review of PAH Supplier Control System Element During PI Audits. The PI may determine whether the PAH is controlling its suppliers by reviewing the PAH’s supplier procedures, any results of prior audits and any corrective actions required by the PAH. During the review, the PI should look for evidence that may indicate a system breakdown in supplier control by the PAH. If the PI identifies evidence of a system breakdown, the PI must ensure that
Chapter 4. Types of Audits › 4-7. SMS Compliance Audits Integrated with PI Audits.
the outcome of the review is incorporated into the facility selection process as identified in paragraph 3-14 of this order, including suppliers and subtier suppliers, and risk within a facility as identified in paragraph 3-18 of this order, when applicable.
Note: The PAH is solely responsible for all supplier-furnished articles and services. Therefore, certificate management activity will focus on how well the PAH controls its suppliers. The FAA does not approve suppliers. However, the PI should review a PAH’s list of suppliers to verify that any suppliers outside the United States have been previously evaluated for undue burden determination as required by FAA Order 8100.11.
4-5. Verification of PAH’s Supplier Control Procedures. The PI should verify that the PAH is implementing and complying with its documented supplier control procedures. This verification should focus on confirming that the PAH has established, documented, and is effectively executing processes that address supplier control. This includes reviewing:
a. The PAH’s documented process for supplier selection, approval, and ongoing control.
b. The PAH’s procedures for identifying, documenting, and resolving supplier-related nonconformances.
c. The PAH’s process for evaluating or auditing suppliers to ensure continued compliance with PAH-established quality and design flow-down requirements.
4-6. Use of Risk-Based Oversight for Supplier Control. Using information obtained from verification activities, prior audits, and other oversight data, the PI should apply a risk-based approach to determining the scope, depth, and prioritization of supplier-related oversight. This approach ensures FAA resources are directed toward areas presenting the greatest risk. In addition, the following should be considered for the facility selection process as identified in paragraph 3-14 of this order. When determining oversight priorities, the PI should consider the following risk indicators:
a. Supplier control noncompliances identified during previous FAA audits.
b. Repeat or systemic supplier-related nonconformances indicating ineffective corrective action or weak supplier controls.
c. The PAH’s response and effectiveness in addressing known supplier-related quality escapes.
Note: When systemic supplier control issues are identified at a PAH, the PI should coordinate with the CM section manager to determine if increased oversight is necessary.
Part 4. Conducting PI Audits with SMS Compliance Audits
4-7. SMS Compliance Audits Integrated with PI Audits. When PAHs are required to comply with 14 CFR Part 5 or are participating in the VSMS program, an SMS compliance audit is scheduled, planned and conducted with the PI audit. Refer to FAA Order 8120.25 and QMS document AIR-002-600-005-F12 for PI/SMS audit data collection tool (DCT).
a. This responsibility is applicable regardless of— › (4) Whether materials or equipment are supplied by the end product…
Part 5. Documenting PI Audit
4-8. Recording a PI Audit. Record a PI audit on FAA Form 8120-14 (refer to Appendix C to this order). Complete one form for each PI audit conducted. Prepare this form in accordance with Appendix C to this order. Document noncompliances on FAA Form 8100-6 (refer to Appendix D to this order). At the conclusion of the audit, determine if the noncompliances should be categorized as isolated or systemic.
Note: When performing a PI audit that includes a review of a PAH’s supplier records, the PI will record the information required in paragraph 4-32d(2) of this order on FAA Form 8100-1.
Section 3. Supplier Control Audits
Part 1. Overview
4-9. What Is a Supplier Control Audit? An SCA is a systematic and independent examination, employing a product-based system audit approach, to determine supplier compliance with the PAH’s purchase order, quality requirements, technical data, or specifications. An SCA is conducted to evaluate the PAH’s established supplier control system to control the articles, materials, supplies, and services provided by outside sources. This audit is conducted by the CM section assigned certificate management responsibility for the PAH or as handed off per paragraph 3-17 of this order. An SCA is applicable to suppliers and subtier suppliers of a PAH as determined by the selection process identified in paragraphs 3-14 and 3-15 of this order.
4-10. Purpose of a Supplier Control Audit. The purpose of the SCA is to determine whether a PAH is satisfactorily controlling its suppliers. The SCA will determine whether the supplier complies with PAH’s requirements, including any statistical sampling that may be used. An SCA is not conducted to audit the performance of the suppliers. However, specific supplier issues or corrective action implementation should be audited when identified.
4-11. General PAH Supplier Control Responsibilities. A PAH may use suppliers when it has established an FAA approved quality system that provides assurance that all articles or services furnished by its suppliers are in compliance with its particular production approval and 14 CFR. The PAH must ensure each supplier-provided product, article, or service conforms to the PAH’s requirements.
a. This responsibility is applicable regardless of—
(1) Where the suppliers may be located;
(2) Whether the products or articles received by the PAH are also FAA approved (PMA or TSOA);
(3) Whether materials are accompanied by airworthiness approval tags, or their equivalent, issued by the CAA of a bilateral country;
(4) Whether materials or equipment are supplied by the end product purchaser (customer furnished equipment, buyer furnished equipment, or government furnished equipment);
4-11. General PAH Supplier Control Responsibilities. › d. Make available to the FAA a current list of its suppliers.
(5) Whether the FAA performs an audit at the supplier;
(6) Whether the articles received by the PAH are commercial or standard parts;
(7) Whether the supplier has been delegated major inspection authority; or
(8) Whether the quality system data received from the supplier are in English.
b. Place special emphasis on controlling those suppliers that the PAH has authorized to ship directly to a user/operator. Suppliers may ship replacement and modification articles directly to the user/operator without the articles first being processed through the PAH’s receiving inspection facilities only if the PAH—
(1) Authorizes to the supplier, in writing, the authority to ship directly to a user/operator. An individual written authorization is not required for each direct shipment. The authorization may include limitations such as specific part numbers, time periods, or particular user/operators. This authorization will be maintained by the PAH for review by the assigned CM section.
(2) Includes, in its FAA approved quality system, controls to compensate for the absence of inspection normally conducted at the PAH’s location—for example, receiving inspection and test. Compensating factors should include onsite audits of the supplier and the inspection of the article at the supplier by—
(a) The PAH, or
(b) The supplier under a delegated inspection authority from the PAH.
(3) Ensures that each of these shipped articles is accompanied by a shipping ticket, invoice, or other document containing a declaration that the individual article was produced under the terms of the production approval, and that inspection/acceptance has been accomplished by either the PAH or by delegated inspection authority. The shipping document for subcomponents manufactured for TSO articles should contain the TSO number. When FAA Form 8130-3, Authorized Release Certificate, is used for this purpose, the direct ship authorization will be annotated in accordance with FAA Order 8130.21, Procedures for Completion and Use of the Authorized Release Certificate, FAA Form 8130-3, Airworthiness Approval Tag.
(4) Provides the appropriate article marking information to the supplier.
(5) Advises its assigned CM section of each direct ship authorization.
c. Take measures to prevent suppliers from manufacturing articles without proper authority. For example, the PAH could limit projected overruns and request, in its contract with the supplier, that any unnecessary overrun articles be scrapped. The PAH may also include a clause in its contract that no articles are to be sold under any circumstances other than those described in the contract.
d. Make available to the FAA a current list of its suppliers.
(1) Notify the responsible CAA and invite CAA participation as an… › (d) Number of FAA auditors participating in the scheduled activity.
e. Notify its suppliers that its facilities are subject to FAA certificate management.
4-12. Coordination of Requests for Supplier Oversight Assistance With Other CAAs.
a. When a supplier to a U.S. PAH is located in a country or jurisdiction having an applicable bilateral agreement with the United States, the FAA may seek supplier oversight assistance from the bilateral CAA. Such assistance requests may take various forms at the PAH’s supplier (for example, ongoing oversight, SCAs, or product audits), and may or may not be agreed to by the CAA, depending on factors such as its availability of resources and common production approval facilities. Requests for one-time or ongoing supplier oversight assistance should be transmitted from the CM branch or division manager to a counterpart CAA production contact. If the CAA agrees to the request and the assistance is recurring, a management plan must be formulated between the FAA and the supporting CAA. The management plan must outline information such as the details of the type of audit/inspection support requested, the methodology by which it will be performed (this is usually the normal audit/inspection procedures, and documentation of the local CAA), the frequency of the audit/inspection activity, and documentation expectations (that is, data and evidence that is useful to the compliance and enforcement program).
Note: Most of the FAA’s bilateral agreements include provisions for technical assistance between authorities. Certain CAAs may charge a fee for oversight activities performed on behalf of the FAA at a PAH’s facility located in its country or jurisdiction. A PAH should be aware that, though CAA fees may not have been charged in the past, fees may be incurred in the future. This change in the charging of fees for oversight activities is partly due to the scarcity of resources brought about by the globalization of aircraft manufacturing. In any case, any CAA oversight activity fees incurred are solely the responsibility of the PAH.
b. If the FAA must conduct the supplier oversight activity itself in another country or jurisdiction, for any reason, the PI will perform the following activities:
(1) Notify the responsible CAA and invite CAA participation as an observer through a formal letter signed by the division/CM branch manager or delegated signatory. The letter should be addressed to the production contact for the CAA. A list of CAAs and respective contacts is available from the AIR International Office. Send an electronic facsimile (fax), scanned copy, or email of the letter at least 50 days before the audit, followed by mailing the formal letter. Notify the CAA of any changes in the audit’s schedule. The CAA’s participation in the audit is not mandatory, and the choice to provide an observer is at its discretion. The letter should, as a minimum, include the following information:
(a) Identity of the supplier facility to be audited.
(b) Type of supplier oversight activity to be conducted (such as an SCA, a product audit, or ongoing oversight). Provide a general outline of what will be included in the scheduled activity.
(c) Dates of the scheduled activity.
(d) Number of FAA auditors participating in the scheduled activity.
4-14. Coordination of SCAs. › a. SCAs To Be Conducted by the FAA at International Suppliers. CM…
(e) Name, address, telephone number, and email address of the responsible PI.
(2) Provide the PAH’s CM section with details of any noncompliance encountered during the oversight activity. For example, if there is a trend showing recurring test failures or nonconforming articles, it may be evidence of a system breakdown or a compliance problem at that facility. The PAH’s CM section will determine if there are any system issues or major problems that should be forwarded to the applicable CAA for its consideration because the PAH’s supplier may coincidentally hold a local production approval.
Part 2. Scheduling of Supplier Control Audits
4-13. Division Supplier Control Audit Schedule. Subsequent to the supplier selection process described in paragraph 3-14 of this order, the divisions will develop a supplier control audit schedule annually. The divisions should coordinate their schedules, to the greatest extent possible.
a. The division supplier control audit schedule will include the name of the selected supplier, the name of the responsible PAH, the scheduled date of SCAs to be conducted by the CM section, and identification of any SCAs that may be handed off to other divisions or may require the assistance of a CAA in a bilateral country.
b. Each CM section will maintain supplier control audit data in accordance with the instructions provided in the oversight information system. This data will be used to plan resource allocation in the next fiscal year. The CM branch manager will ensure the data submitted by each CM section is reviewed for completeness and for identification of duplicate suppliers. When the same supplier is selected by multiple CM sections, the CM branch manager should coordinate with the CM sections to conduct a single audit at that supplier; however, the audit should address the applicable requirements of all relevant PAHs. The CM branch manager should also determine which CM section will conduct the audit, and whether representation from other CM section is required. When all potential discrepancies with the data are resolved, the CM branch manager will ensure the consolidated division supplier control audit data is prepared and made available in the oversight information system in the applicable PAHs’ files.
c. The completed division data, described in paragraph 4-13b of this order, must be available in the oversight information system to all other CM branch managers. All CM branch managers should ensure supplier control audit data received from other divisions are reviewed to identify duplicate suppliers, potential hand-offs that affect their offices and supplier control audits to be conducted by the FAA at multiple international suppliers in the same country.
4-14. Coordination of SCAs. Coordination between assigned offices and the CM section should ensure only one audit is scheduled at a supplier and that all affected PAHs will be audited as part of the audit, as well as to identify audit participants. During the audit, the PAHs with the higher risk assessment results will have priority over PAHs with lower risk assessment results.
a. SCAs To Be Conducted by the FAA at International Suppliers. CM branch managers should identify one FAA office as a lead office to coordinate all international audit activities, which includes notifying the responsible CAA and inviting its participation.
4-15. Notifying a PAH. › a. Before conducting an SCA, the assigned office that will be…
b. Coordination of Corrective Action Validation. Occasionally, it may be necessary to validate corrective actions at a supplier facility located outside of the area of the responsible CM section. When a hand-off to the CM section is appropriate for this purpose, the following handoff procedures will be used:
(1) The CM section will forward a memorandum to the assigned office with responsibility of the area in which the supplier is located. The memorandum will identify whether the corrective action to be validated is a short term or long-term action and will include all pertinent information regarding the corrective action to be validated. The memorandum also will specify a date for responding to the corrective action validation request. The memorandum should include as a minimum—
(a) The name and address of the supplier and the responsible PAH, including the PAH’s project number,
(b) The name, title, and telephone number of the person to contact at the supplier and accountable managers at PAH facilities that can furnish purchase orders, quality system data, technical data, or other pertinent information,
(c) A copy of the PAH’s or supplier’s quality system procedures that are required to be implemented at the particular supplier’s facility, unless these documents are available to the FAA at the supplier’s facility,
(d) A copy of the noncompliance record,
(e) A copy of the PAH’s corrective action response, and
(f) A copy of the supplier’s corrective action response to the PAH.
(2) When a CM section receives a request for a corrective action validation at a facility located within its assigned responsibilities, it will—
(a) Advise the requesting CM section of receipt of the request within 30 days.
(b) Submit a memorandum to the requesting CM section upon completion of the corrective action validation. This memorandum should summarize the results of the corrective action validation and include all applicable FAA Form(s) 8100-6 or 8100-1, as well as all true copies of supporting objective evidence. The requesting CM section will consider its hand-off request complete upon receipt of this memorandum.
4-15. Notifying a PAH.
a. Before conducting an SCA, the assigned office that will be conducting the audit will notify the responsible PAH. The assigned office will notify the PAH, in writing, no more than 14 days before the audit. However, the assigned office may, at its discretion, provide no more than 7 days’ notice to the PAH before conducting an SCA. For international SCAs, the assigned office will notify the PAH, in writing, no more than 30 days before the audit. This reduced notice
4-15. Notifying a PAH. › b. The PAH is responsible for notifying the supplier of the scheduled…
is applicable when urgent action is necessary in the interest of safety or to facilitate oversight, to facilitate compliance, or both.
b. The PAH is responsible for notifying the supplier of the scheduled SCA. If changes occur after the written notification has been sent, notify the PAH by appropriate means. If an SCA has been handed off as described in paragraph 3-17 of this order, the PAH will be advised accordingly, and the requesting office will be provided a copy of the written notification through the oversight information system. Figure 4-1 of this order contains a sample notification letter.
Figure 4-1. Sample Supplier Control Audit Notification Letter
U.S. Department of Transportation
Federal Aviation Administration
July 13, 2016
Molly Brown c/o Tight Weave Manufacturing 1600 Lind Ave SW Fort Worth, TX 76137
Dear Ms. Brown:
The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), in accordance with its responsibilities under Title 49 of the United States Code, Subtitle VII, part A, and applicable regulations, has selected Structural Components located in Seattle, Washington, for a supplier control audit. The audit is scheduled to be conducted on November 12, 2016, by an FAA representative from the Seattle CM section. This audit will determine that your supplier complies with purchase order and/or quality requirements, including any statistical sampling that may be used.
The FAA requests that you inform a representative at Structural Components of this audit. Also, please inform the Seattle CM section at (425) 227-2170 of any security requirements so that we may obtain the appropriate clearance. In addition, please provide the name, title, address, and telephone number of an individual at Structural Components who will serve as the company point of contact for this audit.
If you have any questions concerning the scheduling or conducting of this audit, please contact the undersigned at the above telephone number.
Sincerely,
Julia Gotta
Julia Gotta
Seattle CM Section cc: Fort Worth CM Section
West CM Branch Aircraft Certification Service Seattle CM Section 2500 East Valley Road, Ste C2 Renton, Washington 98055
Part 3. Conducting Supplier Control Audits
4-16. Audit Criteria. The SCA will be conducted using the PAH’s quality flow-down requirements noted on the applicable purchase order or working agreement. Quality flow down requirements may include, but are not limited to, purchase orders, contracts, drawings, specifications, the control of raw and nonconforming materials, records, sampling plans, inspection systems, calibration systems, certificates of conformance, software, age controlled products, special processes, FAIs, subtier suppliers, design data, and all applicable regulatory requirements. The following are also considerations when conducting an SCA:
Chapter 4. Types of Audits › 4-18. What Is a QSA?
a. To the greatest extent practicable, an SCA should be conducted when the supplier has an active purchase order or working agreement from the PAH. If circumstances arise and an active purchase order, working agreement or product or article is not available, an SCA may be rescheduled to facilitate the audit. If the audit cannot be rescheduled it may be accomplished using historical records that are traceable to the PAH’s quality flow down requirements noted on an applicable purchase order or working agreement.
Note: Appendix E to this order should not be used as a checklist during SCAs. However, for data collection and analysis purposes, the PI must select the most appropriate noncompliance codes when documenting noncompliances on FAA Form 8100-6.
b. If specific expertise is required during this audit, the PI should advise the CM section manager. The PI should prepare an audit checklist for each supplier to be audited based on the applicable purchase order, quality requirements from the PAH, or both.
4-17. Recording a Supplier Control Audit. Record an SCA on FAA Form 8120-14 (refer to Appendix C to this order). Complete one form for each SCA conducted. Each hand-off is considered a separate SCA. Document noncompliances on FAA Form 8100-6 (refer to Appendix D to this order). At the conclusion of the audit, determine if the noncompliances should be categorized as isolated or systemic.
a. If an SCA discovers a noncompliance that may involve other PAHs, the team leader and PI must consider the potential systemic impact of the noncompliance, and accordingly, identify those additional PAHs also affected. The PI will verify the affected PAHs and notify and apprise the appropriate PIs of the encountered condition.
b. A product audit will be conducted in accordance with Chapter 3, Section 4, Part 2 of this chapter and recorded on FAA Form 8100-1.
Section 4. Quality System Audits
Part 1. Overview
4-18. What Is a QSA? A QSA is a comprehensive system audit program employing a product based system audit approach. It is a vital element within the FAA’s mission of continued operational safety. When PAHs are required to comply with 14 CFR Part 5 or are participating in the VSMS program, an SMS compliance audit is integrated with the QSA. The QSA—
a. Estimate the onsite duration of each QSA according to the following… › (4) Very large facility with 2,000 or more total full time persons
a. Ascertains whether PAHs meet the applicable requirements of 14 CFR and comply with procedures established to meet those requirements.
b. Evaluates the continued integrity of the approved data. However, the QSA does not reevaluate the approval of previously approved data.
c. Populates a database for analyzing audit results and reporting trends.
d. Provides continuous improvement for the FAA by continually monitoring stakeholder feedback, entered in the oversight information system, and considers proposed improvements by FAA internal and external customers.
Part 2. Selection and Scheduling of QSAs
4-19. QSA Intervals. Audit intervals for PAHs are identified in table 3-1 of this order.
4-20. Selection of Facilities to Be Audited. Procedures for selecting a PAH’s facilities to be audited are identified in paragraph 3-14 of this order.
4-21. Scheduling of QSAs. After all facilities have been selected for audit in accordance with Chapter 3 of this order, each division will be responsible for scheduling QSAs at the selected facilities. Use the following procedures:
a. Estimate the onsite duration of each QSA according to the following information. Consider the quality procedures and processes, the engineering procedures and processes, or both, required to be in place; the number of applicable quality system elements, when known (refer to Appendix E to this order); the size and physical layout of the facility to be audited (single or multiple locations); and product complexity. Allow enough time to ensure compliance to the applicable 14 CFR and FAA approved data will be fully audited. Use the following list as a guide for estimating, in terms of facility size only, the onsite duration of the QSA (excluding travel times):
(1) Small facility with fewer than 100 total full time persons: 1 to 5 working days.
(2) Medium facility with 100 to fewer than 400 total full time persons: 3 to 5 working days.
(3) Large facility with 400 to fewer than 2,000 total full time persons: 5 to 10 working days.
(4) Very large facility with 2,000 or more total full time persons: 7 to 15 working days.
Note 1: When estimating the onsite duration, include only those persons who directly support the PAH activity.
Note 2: The onsite duration may be extended when conducting an SMS compliance audit in conjunction with a QSA.
b. Assign all scheduled audits a distinct QSA number, consisting of the fiscal year, division or CM branch office code, and the audit order sequence. Do not reassign QSA numbers from canceled audits. Each scheduled audit must be uniquely identified.
d. Prepare an audit schedule based on the facility selection criteria… › (3) The certification branch and CM section should schedule approval…
c. Identify the lead audit office for each audit. That office is usually the one that performs certificate management responsibility at the facility to be audited. The lead audit office is responsible for—
(1) Coordinating the notification letter (refer to paragraph 4-23 of this order), and
(2) Notifying the selected team leader and team members (refer to paragraph 4-25 of this order).
Note: For an associate facility subject to certificate management under the hand-off procedure, the lead audit office is the CM section receiving the hand-off.
d. Prepare an audit schedule based on the facility selection criteria in paragraph 3-14 of this order and the duration of each audit.
(1) Prepare the schedule using the following guidelines:
(a) QSA number.
(b) Scheduled start date of each audit.
(c) Duration of each audit.
(d) Facilities and types of approvals to be audited.
(e) Assigned risk level.
(f) Product lines or authorized functions at the facilities to be audited.
(g) Number and disciplines of auditors assigned to each audit.
(h) Additional auditors required beyond the division’s resources.
(i) Number and disciplines of auditors in training and team leaders in training.
(j) Total number of audits scheduled for the fiscal year.
(k) Applicable project numbers.
(2) All division QSA schedules will be entered into the oversight information system.
(3) The certification branch and CM section should schedule approval holders with multiple approvals, such as a PC and a PMA, so as to evaluate all approvals during one audit.
(2) Use the following as a guide for estimating the number of QSA… › (a) Small facility with fewer than 100 full time persons
(4) When an approval holder has multiple facilities that require significant resources and time to audit, the certification branch and CM section should consider scheduling the facilities individually.
e. Designate an assigned engineer (AE). CM section will coordinate with the certification branch to determine the need to assign an FAA engineer. The AE must coordinate any corrective action required regarding the FAA approved design or the design approval system.
4-22. Selection of QSA Auditors. The assigned certification branch and CM section select appointed QSA auditors to perform each scheduled audit. To broaden expertise, whenever possible, managers are encouraged to permit auditors to participate in QSAs scheduled within the jurisdiction of other divisions. Determine the number and types of auditors required for each audit according to the following criteria:
a. Number of Auditors Required. Determine the total number of auditors required to ensure compliance to the applicable 14 CFR and FAA approved data.
(1) Estimate the number of auditors required according to the following minimum criteria:
(a) PAH’s assigned risk level based on the level determination and the organizational risk assessment;
(b) Number and complexity of applicable quality, engineering, flight test, and facility procedures and processes in place;
(c) Number of applicable quality system elements, when known (refer to Appendix E to this order);
(d) Number of PAH suppliers expected to receive an onsite visit as part of the PAH QSA supplier control system element, when known;
(e) Size and physical layout of the facility to be audited (single or multiple locations);
(f) Product or design approval system complexity; and
(g) SMS, as applicable.
(2) Use the following as a guide for estimating the number of QSA auditors required. Increase or decrease the number of estimated auditors shown below depending on your review of the criteria contained in paragraph 4-22a(1) of this order and your confidence that compliance to the applicable 14 CFR and FAA approved data will be fully audited:
(a) Small facility with fewer than 100 full time persons: 1 to 3 auditors (including team leader).
(b) Medium facility with 100 to fewer than 400 total full time persons: 1 to 5 auditors (including team leader).
(c) Large facility with 400 to fewer than 2,000 total full time persons: team leader plus 5 to 10 auditors.
4-22. Selection of QSA Auditors. › c. Selection of PI and AE as Team Leaders or Auditors. To the greatest…
(d) Very large facility with 2,000 or more total full time persons: team leader plus up to 10 auditors.
Note 1: When estimating the number of auditors required, include only those full time persons who are used to support the PAH facility activity.
Note 2: When necessary, the appropriate certification branch and CM section will assign additional auditors as needed.
(3) If it is determined that one auditor is required, select an appointed team leader to perform the audit; this auditor is referred to as the principal auditor. If two or more auditors are selected for an audit, they will constitute a QSA team. Select an appointed team leader and the required number of appointed team members.
b. Types of Auditors Required. Use the criteria identified in paragraph 4-22a(1) of this order and the following criteria to determine the types of auditors required. Select appointed QSA auditors who have appropriate knowledge of the noncompliance codes identified in Appendix E to this order applicable to the facility to be audited and, as appropriate, to the products authorized by the approval (for example, select a propulsion engineer when an engine manufacturer is to be audited, and select a flight test pilot when a flight test program is to be audited). When making this determination, consider the following:
(1) It is not necessary to select both engineers and inspectors for a small facility that does not have both engineering and manufacturing capabilities.
(2) Select appointed QSA auditors, as appropriate, to maintain continued appointment in accordance with Appendix F to this order.
(3) Do not include any appointed auditors who were previously employed by the facility to be audited within 2 years of the scheduled audit.
(4) Determine whether auditors will be made available throughout the duration of the audit. Each auditor is expected to fully participate in the audit. Base any decision to limit participation on the established AIR priorities. Notify the team leader of any limited participation by auditors.
c. Selection of PI and AE as Team Leaders or Auditors. To the greatest extent practicable, the PI and the AE will not be selected as team leaders on QSAs of facilities for which they have certificate management or oversight responsibilities. Use the guidelines in table 4-1 to select the PI as an auditor, the AE as an auditor, or both:
Chapter 4. Types of Audits › 4-23. Notification of Facilities To Be Audited.
Table 4-1. Selecting a PI or AE as an Auditor
Number of Persons Performing the Audit PAH Facility Procedure
One to four persons Do not select the responsible certificate management PI as a team member. The AE may be selected as a team member. Five persons or more The certificate management PI or the AE, or both, may be selected as team members.
d. Selection of Auditors in Training and Team Leaders in Training.
(1) Determine the number of appointed auditors required for the QSA before assigning auditors in training. Assign auditors in training only to audits for which a team is required. Do not assign auditors in training to a principal auditor. Auditors in training will supplement appointed auditors. Do not substitute auditors in training for appointed QSA auditors, or audit team leaders in training for appointed QSA team leaders.
(2) Do not assign more than two auditors in training and more than one team leader in training to any one audit. For QSAs occurring at large or very large facilities (as defined in paragraphs 4-22a(2)(c) and (d) of this order), up to four auditors-in-training may be assigned. Try to assign each auditor in training or team leader in training to different team leaders during the participation phase of the training. A single team member should not be assigned to train multiple auditors-in-training.
(3) When proposing to use auditors-in-training or team-leaders-in-training from other divisions, coordinate with their appointing managers to establish their eligibility.
e. Additional Resource Requirements. Additional auditors beyond the division’s available resources may be required depending on the size of the facility; type and complexity of product, service, or design approval system; and overall audit objectives. Each division should identify the need for these additional resources before the release of the QSA master schedule for the next fiscal year and coordinate the auditors’ participation with the appropriate division office and oversight information system coordinators. Additional support may also be available from AIR-600, if requested.
f. Scheduled Changes. Each division must update schedule changes in the oversight information system. Audits added to the master schedule will be assigned a new QSA number in accordance with paragraph 4-21b of this order.
4-23. Notification of Facilities To Be Audited. The lead audit office identified in accordance with paragraph 4-21c of this order will notify facilities of a scheduled audit using the sample formats in Appendix G to this order. Coordinate with the responsible PI to ensure the letter does not arrive during scheduled shutdown periods or during any other extended periods when the letter may not be acted upon. For notifications of first time QSAs, inform the facility that QSA reference material is available on the FAA’s website. If the facility cannot access the website, provide the reference material to the facility. Notify facilities as follows:
4-27. Audit Team Leader or Principal Auditor. › a. Upon receipt of a copy of the notification letter, contact the lead…
a. PAH. The lead audit office will perform these tasks:
(1) Prepare the notification letter and send it to the facility to be audited no more than 30 days before the audit.
(2) Provide a copy of the notification letter to the designated audit team leader or principal auditors, the PI, and the AE.
b. Changes After Notification Letter Is Sent. If there are changes to the audit schedule or team composition after the notification letter has been sent, notify the facility, responsible PAH, requesting CM section, and the team leader or principal auditor.
4-24. Modifications to Scheduled Audits. Every effort will be made to maintain established audit schedules. However, modifications to the audit schedule should be considered under special circumstances. The assigned certification branch and CM section will jointly reschedule any affected audit in coordination with the PI, AE, and team leader or principal auditor, and update the schedule in the oversight information system. Special circumstances that may warrant modifications to the audit schedule include—
a. Risk to auditors’ safety,
b. Change in a facility’s production or delegation status from active to inactive,
c. Involvement of the FAA in a labor management dispute at a facility, and
d. Reduction in the effectiveness of the audit.
Part 3. QSA Roles and Responsibilities
4-25. Lead Audit Office. Perform, at a minimum, the following QSA preparations:
a. Using the oversight information system, notify the selected audit team leader and team members, or the principal auditor, at least 60 days before each division QSA.
b. Ensure logistical support for an audit within the assigned area.
4-26. Assigned Certification Branch and CM Sections. Using the oversight information system, notify at least 60 days before the audit, all selected auditors within the division that have been selected to support QSAs in another division.
4-27. Audit Team Leader or Principal Auditor. Coordinate QSA preparation to enable the audit team to make the most of limited time in the facility. The team leader provides orientation and assigns quality system elements to team members. These actions, as appropriate, require coordination with the PI, the AE, and the facility to be audited. The team leader or principal auditor will perform the following, as appropriate:
a. Upon receipt of a copy of the notification letter, contact the lead audit office to identify the responsible PI and AE and obtain from the PI and AE items such as the following:
a. Upon receipt of a copy of the notification letter, contact the lead… › (4) Findings and noncompliances from previous audits and other…
(1) Applicable FAA approved procedures, including engineering and quality manuals, procedures manuals, and handbooks, when practical. Obtain documentation in electronic format, if available, to simplify copying and distribution to team members. If applicable data is not available electronically, work with the PI or AE to identify relevant documents and to obtain printed copies of only those pages necessary to support the QSA.
(2) Current facility data available in the oversight information system.
(3) Known or suspected problem areas, including any areas the PI and AE would like special emphasis on during the QSA, such as requests to conduct a product audit. The team leader should also confer with the PI to identify and become familiar with the following quality system attributes as applicable:
(a) Critical processes (including special processes) and critical suppliers;
(b) Recent design changes;
(c) Significant changes in suppliers, manufacturing personnel, procedures, or inspections;
(d) Rework and scrap data;
(e) MRB history;
(f) Quality escapes;
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 276 passages shown