Order 8000.85A FAA Program for the Establishment of a Mip Under the Provisions of a Basa
This document is cancelled. Cancelled by 8000.85B. Check the official source before relying on it.
4. Background. › c. In the absence of a BASA and corresponding MIP, a repair facility in…
Distribution: Electronic Only Initiated By: AFS-300
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION
National Policy Effective Date: 12/20/07 SUBJ: FAA Program for the Establishment of A MIP Under the Provisions of a BASA 1. Purpose. This order sets forth the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) program for the establishment of Maintenance Implementation Procedures (MIP) under the provisions of a Bilateral Aviation Safety Agreement (BASA). This order provides FAA personnel and National Aviation Authorities (NAA) information on the procedures and requirements for developing a MIP.
2. Audience. The primary audience for this order is Flight Standards District Office (FSDO) aviation safety inspectors. The secondary audience includes Flight Standards branches and divisions in the regions and in headquarters.
3. Where You Can Find This Order. Inspectors can access this order through the Flight Standards Information Management System (FSIMS) at http://fsims.avr.faa.gov. Operators may find this information on the Web site at: http://fsims.faa.gov/.
4. Background.
a. The FAA certificates repair stations located outside the United States that operate under the provisions of Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 145. The certification of foreign repair stations responds to the need to perform maintenance, alteration, or modification of aeronautical products subject to U.S. airworthiness regulations in foreign countries. Maintaining aircraft and components outside the United States has continued to expand with the corresponding increase in international air travel and rise in the number of foreign-manufactured aeronautical products used by U.S. operators.
b. Similarly, foreign countries have also experienced an increase in the use of U.S. facilities to perform maintenance, alteration, or modification of aeronautical products subject to foreign national requirements. NAAs in countries where certificated maintenance facilities are located have also developed their own extensive inspection, surveillance, evaluation, and certification programs. The NAAs have developed these programs to ensure that repair facilities accomplish maintenance, preventive maintenance, and modification/alteration of aeronautical products subject to their airworthiness regulations according to specific national standards.
c. In the absence of a BASA and corresponding MIP, a repair facility in a foreign country that performs work on aeronautical products subject to the airworthiness regulations of that country and on aeronautical products subject to the airworthiness regulations of the United States may be required to be inspected, surveilled, and evaluated by the FAA and the NAA. Therefore, the repair facility must conform to two sets of standards—the FAA’s and the NAA’s. A repair station located in the United States that performs work on aeronautical products subject to U.S.
ORDER 8000.85A
5. Definitions. The following definitions apply: › c. Bilateral Aviation Safety Agreement (BASA). Reference the current…
and foreign airworthiness regulations may also be required to conform to two or more sets of standards.
d. The conclusion of a MIP provides for either:
(1) The reciprocal acceptance of recommendations for certification and renewal, and documentation of surveillance findings, when the NAA issues certificates to U.S.-based repair stations; or
(2) FAA acceptance of NAA recommendations for certification and renewal, and documentation of surveillance findings, when the NAA does not issue certificates to U.S.-based repair stations.
(3) Either case results in increased efficiency by reducing or eliminating duplicative surveillance, evaluation, and inspection of repair facilities conducted by the FAA and NAA. The FAA and NAA achieve program goals when they reduce or eliminate duplicative activities while maintaining equivalent levels of safety.
e. The FAA and NAA base MIPs on an evaluation of 14 CFR part 145 and foreign national regulations governing repair stations or Approved Maintenance Organizations (AMO). This evaluation is designed to determine the areas where these regulations and requirements harmonize and identify areas where they differ. The evaluation also determines the FAA’s and NAA’s ability to carry out surveillance on each other’s behalf.
5. Definitions. The following definitions apply:
a. Alteration or Modification. A change to the construction, configuration, performance, environmental characteristics, or operating limitations of the affected civil aeronautical product.
Note: The above definition is consistent with wording in current MIPs. Additional description of alteration/modification/environmental characteristics may be considered.
(1) Alteration. A change, using technical data that has been approved by the FAA or NAA, to the construction, configuration, performance, environmental characteristics, or operating limitations of the affected civil aeronautical product.
(2) Modification. A change, using technical data that is being presented to the FAA Administrator or NAA for approval, to the construction, configuration, performance, environmental characteristics, or operating limitations of the affected civil aeronautical product.
b. Approved Maintenance Organization (AMO). A maintenance organization certificated by the NAA.
c. Bilateral Aviation Safety Agreement (BASA). Reference the current edition of Advisory Circular (AC) 21-23, Airworthiness Certification of Civil Aircraft, Engines, Propellers, and Related Products Imported to the United States.
5. Definitions. The following definitions apply: › i. Geographic Authorization. An approval provided to a foreign repair…
(1) A BASA is a government-to-government agreement, consisting of one Executive Agreement and one or more implementation procedures, to facilitate the recognition of procedures for the reciprocal acceptance in technical areas that may include:
(a) Airworthiness approvals of civil aeronautical products.
(b) Environmental approvals and environmental testing.
(c) Approval and monitoring of maintenance facilities and alterations or modification facilities.
(d) Approval and monitoring of maintenance personnel.
(e) Approval and monitoring of crews.
(f) Approval and monitoring of flight operations.
(g) Approval and monitoring of aviation training establishments.
(2) The term National Aviation Authority (NAA) refers to the authority of a contracting State that has responsibility for the establishment, implementation, and oversight responsibilities of aviation regulation within their country.
(3) These agreements are replacing Bilateral Airworthiness Agreements (BAA).
Note: BAA are also a government-to-government agreement, consisting of one Executive Agreement, normally dealing with specific areas of agreement but do not include Implementation procedures.
d. Civil Aeronautical Product. Any civil aircraft, aircraft engine, propeller, subassembly, appliance, material, part, or component to be installed thereon.
e. Compliance with Part 145. Compliance with the latest issue of NAA requirements and guidance material plus the FAA Special Conditions as set forth in a MIP.
f. Compliance with National Aviation Authority Requirements and Guidance. Compliance with the latest issue of part 145 and the NAA Special Conditions as set forth in a MIP recognizing that ACs provide additional guidance in this area.
g. Data Approved by the FAA. Data approved by the Administrator or the Administrator’s designated representative.
h. Data Approved by the NAA. Data approved by the NAA or an organization/person approved by the NAA for that purpose.
i. Geographic Authorization. An approval provided to a foreign repair station to perform maintenance support under contract for a U.S. air carrier, or operator of U.S.-registered aircraft under 14 CFR part 129, at a location other than the repair station facility. A geographic authorization is issued by the FAA to respond to the need of a U.S. air carrier or part 129
5. Definitions. The following definitions apply: › s. Special Conditions. Conditions in a MIP that specify the…
operator for maintenance at a station where the frequency and scope of that maintenance does not warrant permanently staffing and equipping the station for its accomplishment.
j. NAA Procedures. NAA application of regulation and procedures in its national systems, rules, practices, and policies.
k. NAA Regulations and Guidance. A uniform set of regulations issued by the NAA. They are interpreted and implemented by the NAA policy guidance in the form of written administrative and guidance material.
l. Main Base. The primary location of a repair station that includes the facilities where all aspects of maintenance under its rating can be performed and records are maintained.
m. Maintenance. The performance of inspection, overhaul, repair, preservation, and replacement of parts, materials, appliances, or components of a civil aeronautical product to ensure the continued airworthiness of that product, excluding alterations, or modifications.
n. Maintenance Implementation Procedures (MIP), or Other Negotiated Term. The procedural document authorized by the BASA Executive Agreement related to the performance of maintenance, alterations, and modifications on civil aeronautical products. This document defines the process for reciprocal acceptance of each authority’s recommendations for certification, renewal, and acceptance of eligible repair stations and maintenance organizations. (Ref. the current edition of AC 21-23, for engineering and certification agreements, and the current edition of AC 145-7, Issuance of Repair Station Certificates to Foreign Approved maintenance Organizations under the Maintenance Implementation Procedures of a Bilateral Aviation Safety Agreement. It may be necessary to develop individual ACs for each MIP.)
o. National Aviation Authority (NAA). The aviation regulatory authority of a foreign country or body.
p. Overhaul. A process that ensures the aeronautical article is in complete conformity with the applicable service tolerances specified in the type certificate holder’s, or equipment manufacturer’s instructions for continued airworthiness, or in the data which is approved or accepted by the Authority. No person may describe an article as being overhauled unless it has been at least disassembled, cleaned, inspected, repaired as necessary, reassembled, and tested in accordance with the above specified data.
q. Perceived Need. A current or future operational or economic necessity for the maintenance, preventive maintenance, or alteration of aeronautical products subject to the regulatory oversight of the FAA at a facility located outside the United States.
r. Required Inspection Items (RII). The items of maintenance and alterations that must be inspected by a person other than the one that performed the work, to include at least those items that could result in a failure, malfunction, or defect endangering the safe operation of the aircraft, if not performed properly, or if improper parts or materials are used.
s. Special Conditions. Conditions in a MIP that specify the requirements in 14 CFR parts 43 and 145 that the FAA has determined are not in NAA requirements (FAA Special
6. Related Publications (current editions). › l. Part 145, Repair stations.
Conditions) and the NAA requirements that an NAA has determined are not in part 145 (NAA Special Conditions).
t. Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR). United States aviation regulations consisting of parts 1 through 199 for Aeronautics and Space.
u. Unapproved Part. A part that does not meet the requirements of an “approved part” as specified in the current edition of AC 21-29, Issuance of Repair Station Certificates to Foreign Approved maintenance Organizations under the Maintenance Implementation Procedures of a Bilateral Aviation Safety Agreement.
v. Repair Station Manual, Quality Control Manual/Section and Training Program. This manual explains the inspection system and internal procedures of a part 145 certificated repair station. It describes how the repair station will comply with the quality control and overall operational requirements contained in part 145 as well as how the repair station will train its employees, and monitor its employees training requirements.
6. Related Publications (current editions). Copies of these documents may be obtained from the U.S. Department of Transportation, Subsequent Distribution Office, Ardmore East Business Center, 3341 Q 75th Avenue, Landover, Maryland 20785.
a. AC 20-62, Eligibility, Quality, and Identification of Aeronautical Replacement Parts.
b. AC 21-2, Export Airworthiness Approval Procedures.
c. AC 21-23, Airworthiness Certification of Civil Aircraft, Engines, Propellers, and Related Products Imported to the United States.
d. AC 43-10, United States – Canadian BASA/MIP Maintenance.
e. AC 140-7, FAA Certificated Repair Station Directory.
f. AC 145-7, Issuance of Repair Station Certificates to Foreign Approved Maintenance Organizations Under the Maintenance Implementation Procedures of a Bilateral Aviation Safety Agreement.
g. AC 145-9, Guide for Developing and Evaluating a Repair Station Quality Control Manual.
h. AC 145-10, Repair Station Training Program.
i. AC 187-1, Flight Standards Service Schedule of Charges Outside the United States.
j. Order 8900.1, Flight Standards Information Management System.
k. Title 14 CFR, part 43, Maintenance, preventive maintenance, rebuilding, and alteration.
l. Part 145, Repair stations.
7. Applicability. This order applies to FAA personnel involved in the development of a MIP with an NAA under the terms of a BASA. This order also allows for the development of a MIP while a BASA is being formally pursued by the requesting country. However it should be noted that a MIP may not be concluded without a signed BASA in place. Adherence to the procedures in this order is necessary for uniform administration of this directive material. Any deviations from this guidance material must be coordinated with, and approved by, the Aircraft Maintenance Division, AFS-300. Any such approvals will be communicated in writing to the appropriate entity.
d. Once a MIP is concluded, the authorities will be able to recommend: › (3) Amendment to a repair station certificate; or
Note: The development of a MIP between the FAA and an NAA requires a long-term commitment of considerable resources by both authorities. Past experience has demonstrated that it may take 3 to 5 years for completion of an agreement. An NAA wishing to undertake such an initiative should have a viable aircraft maintenance surveillance and certification program, including competent personnel capable of finding compliance with national aircraft maintenance standards, practices, and procedures. The FAA prioritizes requests for a MIP based on the FAA’s strategic goals and the results of a capability assessment of the NAA. The NAA may develop its own process of evaluating the FAA’s ability to comply with the NAA’s needs and requirements for concluding a MIP.
8. Description of MIPs. A MIP is a technical implementation agreement between the FAA and the executive agent of another country or body under the provisions of the BASA, which pertain to maintenance, alterations, and modifications of aeronautical products.
a. If a country’s aviation regulations for issuing certificates to facilities for the maintenance and alteration of aeronautical products and the general operating rules for holders of those certificates are harmonized with the requirements of 14 CFR, then compliance with NAA regulations satisfies compliance with the intent of the requirements of parts 43 and 145.
b. In those instances where the regulations are not equivalent, the MIP will include special conditions that address those requirements of an authority that may not be addressed in the other authority’s regulations. In this case, compliance with the regulations of one authority and any special conditions contained in the MIP will be equivalent to compliance with the other authority’s regulations.
c. Greater harmonization of regulations can reduce the number of special conditions. Changes to either authority’s regulations after entry into the MIP could result in changes to special conditions in the MIP. Regulatory changes should be coordinated to the greatest extent possible.
d. Once a MIP is concluded, the authorities will be able to recommend:
(1) Issuance of initial certification of repair stations;
(2) Renewal of a repair station certificate with all of its current ratings;
(3) Amendment to a repair station certificate; or
(4) Denial of the renewal of a repair station certificate.
g. A MIP includes the following: (See Appendix E for sample MIP… › (11) Requirements guaranteeing that the signatories will provide mutual…
e. Under the terms of the MIP, FAA-certificated repair facilities located in the MIP partner country performing maintenance on products under the regulatory authority of the FAA are certificated by the FAA, but are surveilled, evaluated, and inspected by the NAA. The FAA, however, retains the right to participate in these actions and, if necessary, to suspend or revoke its certification of the repair facility. The FAA also retains the authority to inspect an FAA-certificated repair facility and its contractors at any time.
f. Under the terms of the MIP, repair facilities located in the United States performing maintenance on products under the regulatory authority of another country are certificated, approved, or accepted by that NAA, but are surveilled, evaluated, and inspected by the FAA. The NAA, however, retains the right to participate in these actions and, if necessary, to suspend or revoke its certification, approval, or acceptance of the repair facility. The NAA also retains the authority to inspect an NAA-certificated repair facility and its contractors at any time.
g. A MIP includes the following: (See Appendix E for sample MIP documents.)
(1) The terms and conditions by which the results of the signatories’ surveillance, evaluation, and inspections will be accepted by each signatory.
(2) An indication that the MIP is drafted in accordance with a BASA and pursuant to a mutual assessment of the signatory NAAs.
(3) Procedures for initiating, terminating, and amending the MIP.
(4) The designation of a specific individual as the responsible party within the executive agencies implementing the agreement.
(5) A specific dispute resolution procedure.
(6) Definitions of terms critical to the MIP.
(7) The specific requirements for a signatory to certificate or approve a repair facility located in the other signatory country.
(8) Procedures by which each signatory may audit the surveillance, evaluations, and inspections conducted by the other signatory.
(9) The specification that the signatories retain the right to initiate enforcement action against any repair facility that it certificates in the other signatory country.
(10) Any special conditions which ensure that the surveillance, evaluation, and inspections conducted by one signatory ensure compliance with requirements equivalent to those in parts 43 and 145 (for actions taken by the NAA) and the NAA’s equivalent of parts 43 and 145 (for FAA actions).
(11) Requirements guaranteeing that the signatories will provide mutual assistance in implementing the provisions of the agreement. This assistance will include: technical evaluation
10. MIP Flowchart.
assistance, exchanging of information pertaining to each country’s regulations and policies, guidance, practices, interpretations, and amendments to the regulations; exchanging of findings of regulatory noncompliance and information critical to flight safety; and assistance in investigations or enforcement actions.
h. Additional information required for implementation and compliance with the MIP is included in guidance materials such as the current edition of AC 145-7 and Order 8900.1.
9. Selection of NAAs for Potential MIP.
a. NAAs seeking to conclude a MIP with the FAA should submit a written request to the Director, Flight Standards Services, AFS-1, 800 Independence Ave., SW., Washington, DC 20591.
b. AFS-300, maintains a prioritized list of NAAs under consideration for a MIP. FAA priorities are based on strategic goals, priorities, resource requirements, and perceived need.
c. Participation in a regional aviation organization or coordinating group should be looked upon by the NAA seeking to enter into a MIP with the United States as an important (though not mandatory) step in securing an agreement. Harmonizing the standards, regulations, and policies among a group of similarly situated countries greatly simplifies the FAA’s task of determining the level of similarity between the aviation regulations of a group of NAAs seeking MIPs and compliance with 14 CFR. The adoption of common regulations facilitates the ability of the FAA and the NAA to agree on the basis of a MIP, because the parties can conduct one regulatory comparison that applies to all members. The FAA can therefore concentrate its evaluation efforts on determining the ability of each NAA to certificate and surveil maintenance organizations to a standardized set of regulations.
10. MIP Flowchart. Figure 1, MIP Flowchart contains the process for concluding a MIP, as described in paragraphs 11 though 14.
Note 1: Throughout the process, in the event that the FAA and NAA teams cannot agree to mutually acceptable terms and conditions, the FAA team will refer to AFS-1 to either continue or terminate the process.
Note 2: If the country does not have a BASA signed, the team may continue, provided the country initiates the process.
Figure 1. MIP Flowchart
11. Phase 1—NAA System Familiarization. › e. The team will evaluate the completed assessment job aid and copies…
11. Phase 1—NAA System Familiarization.
Note: Normally the first country inquiry with the FAA regarding opening MIP discussions is made with AFS-1 or AFS-300 informally to discuss the methods, procedures and purpose of developing a MIP. If the country elects to pursue a MIP, AFS-1 or AFS-300 will advise the country of the method to submit a formal request to AFS-1 who will forward the request to the International Programs and Policy Division, AFS-50 for internal FAA coordination.
a. Once the country submits a formal request, AFS-300 and AFS-1 review the impact of a formal request and forward it to AFS-50 for internal coordination.
b. Upon receipt of the initial formal request, AFS-50 will notify the appropriate desk officer in the Office of International Aviation (API) and Office of the Chief Counsel (AGC) of the request. AFS-50 will review the International Aviation Safety Assessment (IASA) program status of the NAA (if applicable) and, in coordination with API, determine if there are any U.S. policy concerns that would affect the FAA’s ability to enter into an agreement with the requesting NAA. AFS-50 should respond to AFS-300 within 30 days from receipt of the formal request.
c. After receiving the formal request from AFS-50, AFS-300 will form a team within 90 days. This team may include representatives (or designees) from AFS-300, AFS-50, and the appropriate regional office and/or International Field Office (IFO), as necessary. Team composition is designed to provide a standardized approach to the development of a MIP. The team is responsible for implementing the process below to determine whether it would be feasible to enter into a MIP with the NAA. With the approval of AFS-300, the team composition detailed above may differ depending on the complexity of the assignment. AFS-300 is responsible for assembling the team at an appropriate location to brief the team on the content of this order stressing the importance of treating each country in a standard manner. AFS-300 will advise the team of the sensitivity relating to assessments. The briefing will also provide the team with the FAA philosophy on using a system approach when assessing the NAA as well as a description of the FAA international goals.
Note: At no point in the process should a team member express personal views or indicate to the NAA that they are ready for a MIP. This is a management decision that will be made at the conclusion of the process.
d. If there are no policies or other concerns preventing the pursuit of a MIP with the requesting NAA, the team will provide the NAA a copy of this order. The appropriate assessment job aid and sample documents can be found in the appendices of this order. The NAA should complete and submit its portions of the assessment job aid as well as a copy of their applicable regulations in the English language to the designated team lead within 90 days of receipt of the assessment job aid. However, the FAA recognizes the difficulties associated with language differences and the time needed for translation to the English language. Since additional time may be needed, the 90-day time period is a recommendation.
e. The team will evaluate the completed assessment job aid and copies of NAA regulations and procedures to determine whether there is sufficient compatibility between FAA and NAA
systems to progress with the MIP process. Depending on the complexity of the NAA response to the assessment job aid and regulations, the team should complete the preliminary review within 90 days of receipt of the submitted material by the NAA.
a. If the FAA determines that a MIP with the NAA is feasible based on… › (3) Gain a working knowledge of the practical application of…
Note: If after 120 days the NAA has not provided the FAA with their assessment job aid and regulations, AFS-300 will notify the NAA in writing that negotiations may be suspended if progress is not made within a negotiated time frame. The FAA recognizes that language barriers and resource availability can affect the time needed by an NAA. A request for a time extension is in the best interest of all concerned, when necessary.
f. If the team determines there is sufficient compatibility, it will prepare a detailed action plan including projected timelines, budget requirements, and availability of personnel. The plan may require some prior contact with NAA contacts/team, as applicable. The FAA action plan should be established 60 days after review of the NAA submitted material.
g. The team will prepare a decision memorandum (see Appendix B of this order), from AFS-300 to AFS-1 summarizing the action plan, costs, timelines, and a request for concurrence on whether to proceed to Phase 2. The memorandum and action plan will be prepared for signature by the team lead, coordinated with AFS-300 and AFS-50 for concurrence, and submitted to AFS-1 for a written decision within 30 days of establishing the action plan.
h. If AFS-1 decides to proceed, the team will continue to Phase 2. If AFS-1 decides not to proceed, the team will prepare a letter from AFS-1 to the NAA stating the reasons and recommendations for possible future MIP cooperation.
i. If AFS-1 decides to proceed with an NAA whose government has not concluded a BASA with the United States, the FAA will advise the NAA to contact API-1 and formally initiate the diplomatic process to negotiate a BASA in accordance with this order.
Note: This process may be time consuming, but a MIP cannot be concluded until a BASA is in effect.
12. Phase 2—NAA System Evaluation.
a. If the FAA determines that a MIP with the NAA is feasible based on the preliminary review in Phase 1, the FAA and NAA will enter into Phase 2, NAA System Evaluation. The FAA team must consider this MIP process as a system approach. The NAA system may not be identical to the FAA system; however, the NAA system should meet the objectives and surveillance goals of the FAA. The NAA System Evaluation phase permits the FAA to do the following:
(1) Observe and document the NAA’s evaluation procedures and assess the NAA’s regulatory basis for certificating and surveilling a repair station;
(2) Conduct an in-depth comparison of FAA/NAA regulations and procedures;
(3) Gain a working knowledge of the practical application of regulations and procedures by the NAA and repair stations under its authority; and
(2) Simple differences in wording should not automatically be… › (d) Certification of foreign manufacturers’ maintenance facilities as…
(4) Confirm differences that could result in special conditions.
b. Capability Assessment of NAA. The FAA team will use the completed NAA assessment job aid (see Appendix A of this order), and other documentation submitted by the NAA to perform an in-country capability assessment. The purpose of the in-country capability assessment is to confirm the NAA’s responses to the assessment job aid. The visit should take place in the NAA’s headquarters, and may include visits to regional and field offices, as applicable. At the conclusion of the visit, the team leader will submit a capability assessment letter (see Appendix D of this order), to the NAA point of contact identifying the results of the assessment and any issues that need to be resolved, under the team leader’s signature.
c. The team leader will prepare a capability assessment memorandum, (see Appendix C of this order) based on assessment of the job aid completed by the team, and any other associated documentation provided by the NAA. The memorandum will identify any areas of concern that need to be addressed by the NAA. The memo will be submitted to AFS-300 for review and concurrence. Once AFS-300 has concurred with the assessment memo a copy will be forwarded to AFS-50 to be placed in the country file.
d. Regulatory Comparison.
(1) The FAA team will conduct a comparison in conjunction with AGC, between part 145 and applicable sections of part 43, as well as applicable procedures and guidance materials for the counterpart NAA regulations. The team will complete three columns of the comparison matrix, indicating FAA requirements, NAA requirements, and potential differences. The fourth column of the matrix is reserved for the Joint Repair Station Evaluation below (Appendix E includes a sample matrix). The matrix will note any differences between the regulations, and how they should be applied.
Note: The team leader may request AFS-300 to provide contractor services to develop the regulatory comparison.
(2) Simple differences in wording should not automatically be considered substantive differences in standards or regulations. If the intent of the respective regulations is equivalent and compliance with the local regulation would result in compliance with the corresponding section of 14 CFR, the comparison should state that no substantive differences exist. Differences from compliance with the procedures specified in part 145 should, however, be specifically noted. The team should consider, but not give excessive weight, to guidance material. AFS-300 will make the final determination of equivalency or differences between regulations. Differences could include the following:
(a) The use of approved replacement parts.
(b) The use of approved data for major repairs and major alterations.
(c) Contracting of certain functions to another repair facility.
(d) Certification of foreign manufacturers’ maintenance facilities as repair stations.
12. Phase 2—NAA System Evaluation. › e. Joint Assessment of Repair Stations.
(e) Compliance with the recordkeeping requirements of part 43, §§ 43.5, 43.9, and 43.11.
(f) Compliance with the required inspection function specified in § 145.205.
(g) Compliance with change of address requirements specified in part 145, § 145.51.
(h) Possession of equipment and materials appropriate to a repair station’s rating.
(i) Differences between ratings issued by the FAA and the NAA.
(j) Additional personnel qualifications.
(k) Incoming inspection system.
(l) English language capability requirements for certain personnel as specified in §§ 145.151, 145.153, 145.155, and 145.157.
(m) Reporting of serious defects or unairworthy conditions to the FAA per §§ 145.219 and 145.221.
(n) The use of FAA Form 337, Major Repair and Alteration (Airframe, Powerplant, Propeller, or Appliance), and the completion of FAA Form 8130-3, Airworthiness Approval Tag, in English.
(o) Training requirements.
(p) Hazmat training requirements.
(q) Quality System requirements.
Note: After the regulatory comparison is completed, if the number of differences are greater than 15, AFS-300 will decide if continuing the MIP would be in the best interest of the FAA. Normally, the joint assessment will provide enough information to reduce or minimize the differences by observing the practical application of the rules as well as accepting each other’s policy and procedures. The NAA is entitled to refer the differences to their appropriate management to reach a decision to proceed or not. The intent of a MIP is to recognize as much of each other’s system as possible. A large amount of differences defeats the purpose of the agreement. Administrative differences should not be considered as special conditions but may be addressed in other areas of the agreement such as procedural requirements.
e. Joint Assessment of Repair Stations.
Note: Countries or regional organizations that the FAA has had a long standing working relationship with may have limited joint assessment inspections. The MIP development team will make the decision to conduct joint assessment inspections based on historical working relationships with the organization and/or
(2) NAA System Evaluation Report. › (a) An indication of whether the NAA has demonstrated the requisite…
countries involved. For example: The FAA and the European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) and its predecessor the Joint Aviation Authority (JAA) have had a long standing involvement in each other’s quality systems. Joint repair station assessments were deemed not necessary.
(1) The focus of the joint assessment is not directed specifically at the repair stations, but rather observing and documenting the NAA’s surveillance process and procedures, noting the techniques and practices used in normal surveillance. The team will work with the NAA to identify a representative assessment of repair stations. The assessments will include FAA, and non-FAA-certificated repair stations. The repair stations should vary in size, complexity, and ratings. The number of repair stations in the assessment group should be based on the number of FAA-certificated repair stations and the amount and type of aeronautical maintenance activity. If the NAA uses a rolling surveillance system, each repair station in the assessment should be in a different phase of the surveillance system. The NAA should involve the individual NAA inspectors responsible for the surveillance of each identified repair station during the joint assessment. This will ensure a broad overview of the NAA surveillance process, procedures, and standardization. NAAs with many regions and/or repair stations spread over a large geographical area may require an extended visit or more than one visit.
(2) The FAA team should request the NAA to contact the repair stations to establish an itinerary for the joint visits within a specified timeframe. The FAA team, along with the NAA, will visit the agreed upon repair stations to observe NAA oversight in various areas. The team will utilize the 4 column regulatory comparison chart in Appendix E. The team should complete the 4th column of the chart, thereby confirming or eliminating previously identified differences, or adding additional differences identified during the visit. The FAA team will complete the 4th column of the regulatory comparison matrix (see Appendix E of this order) to finalize the identification of differences.
f. Discussion.
(1) Following the joint assessments, the FAA team will hold discussions with the NAA to resolve or confirm differences identified in paragraph 12c above. The team should avoid applying personal interpretations to the evaluations.
Note: Resolution of differences between 14 CFR and the NAA’s regulations before the drafting of a MIP facilitates the adoption of the agreement and simplifies the drafting of any special conditions to the MIP.
(2) NAA System Evaluation Report. The team analyzes the results of the capability assessment, the regulatory comparison and the joint assessment (including a list of assessed repair stations visited). Any issues identified in the Capability Assessment Memorandum (see Appendix C of this order), should be resolved by this point. Once the NAA has demonstrated the requisite capability to conduct oversight on behalf of the FAA, the team will submit an NAA System Evaluation report (see Appendix F of this order) to AFS-300 within 30 days, which includes the following:
(a) An indication of whether the NAA has demonstrated the requisite capability to issue certification recommendations and conduct surveillance on behalf of the FAA.
a. Scope of a MIP. › (2) In order to maintain a standard process, follow the template…
(b) An analysis of the NAA’s regulatory system and highlight areas in NAA regulations, standards, practices, and procedures that may result in special conditions.
(c) Identify areas of existing inspector guidance material that might need to be modified to accommodate a MIP with the NAA.
(d) Identify basic surveillance procedures, documentation, and reporting requirements that would be required of the NAA under a MIP.
Note: The team may take into consideration information and knowledge about the practices of an NAA with which the FAA has a close, long-term working relationship.
(3) Once AFS-300 reviews and concurs with the report, a copy must be provided to AFS-50. AFS-50 will file the report in the appropriate country or organization file and retain the report in accordance with FAA policy.
(4) Once AFS-300 receives the final System Evaluation Report, the FAA team will proceed to Phase 3, the development of a MIP.
13. Phase 3—Development of a MIP.
Note: In the absence of a BASA, the team should ensure that adequate progress toward the conclusion of a BASA is being made before initiating formal MIP discussions with the NAA. AFS-50 should provide AFS-300 with a formal BASA progress report. AFS-1 will make any final decision to suspend or delay continued discussions on the MIP if the BASA progress has not met expectations.
a. Scope of a MIP.
(1) The FAA team and the NAA will discuss the technical provisions that will form the basis for the development of the MIP. Using the template MIP (see Appendix G of this order), the team will discuss the following technical areas with the NAA as described in the template MIP:
(a) Chapter 1—definitions;
(b) Chapter 2 – reciprocal acceptance of findings;
(c) Chapter 3—special conditions;
(d) Chapter 4—mutual cooperation and technical assistance; and
(e) Chapter 5—transfer and continuing validation provisions.
(2) In order to maintain a standard process, follow the template language to the greatest extent possible. All other chapters of the MIP contain standard-approved language and are not open for negotiation at the team level. However, any potential deviations should be noted, discussed with AFS-300 management, and coordinated as appropriate.
(14) Quality control and monitoring. › (a) Quality Control Manual (QCM).
(3) If necessary, the FAA team and NAA may discuss and recommend the addition of definitions that are not included in the MIP template to address terminology that is unique to the NAA’s system.
b. Preparation of Special Conditions. The team meets with NAA representatives to discuss their individual comparisons of the regulations under which the repair stations operate. After joint evaluations and joint discussions of the comparisons, the FAA and NAA should agree to any FAA or NAA special conditions for inclusion in the MIP. The MIP should state any special conditions the repair facility must meet when performing work on an aeronautical product maintained under the airworthiness regulations of the NAA of another country. The MIP should state that the NAA is responsible for performing surveillance of the FAA special conditions. Special conditions may relate, but are not limited, to one or more of the following areas:
(1) Approval for return to service procedures.
(2) Compliance statement regarding approved data.
(3) Defect reporting.
(4) Enforcement.
(5) Facility requirements.
(6) Inspection procedures and access.
(7) Investigation procedures.
(8) Language requirements.
(9) Manual requirements.
(10) Major/minor repairs/alteration and/or modifications documentation.
(11) Personnel requirements.
(a) Training program requirements.
(b) Training program approval.
(c) Qualification of management personnel.
(12) Procedures for contracting/subcontracting work.
(13) Quarterly Utilization Reports (QUR).
(14) Quality control and monitoring.
(a) Quality Control Manual (QCM).
(4) Surveillance and Enforcement. › (a) The FAA must retain the ability to enforce U.S. regulations…
(b) Internal Evaluation Program.
(15) Records to document the acceptability of parts.
(16) Records and recordkeeping.
(17) Repair facility certification.
(18) Repair facility requirements.
(19) Rating system.
(20) Capability list.
(21) Suspected unapproved parts (SUP) program.
c. Issues for Discussion with NAA. The FAA team and NAA representatives must address the procedures contained in the MIP and associated guidance material that the FAA and NAA must follow to comply with the provisions of the MIP or any significant considerations that could affect the implementation of the agreement. A number of significant considerations that must be resolved before implementing a MIP are discussed in the sections that follow:
(1) Implementation of the Agreement. The FAA and the NAA will perform all duties necessary to ensure compliance with the provisions of the MIP. These actions will include the certification of repair facilities recommended to the FAA to perform work under the provisions of the agreement, a program for maintaining confidence in each other’s system, surveillance of selected repair facilities, and the enforcement of the agreement’s provisions.
(2) Publication of Guidance. AFS-300 will develop appropriate guidance material explaining the privileges and limitations placed upon repair facilities as set forth in each agreement as well as any special conditions that may apply to work performed under the agreement. AFS-300 will also issue guidance material to FAA personnel specifying how to comply with the terms of the MIP (e.g., Order 8900.1 and the current edition of AC 145-7, as applicable).
(3) Accident/Incident Investigation Assistance. Maintenance records for an aeronautical product that was repaired by a facility approved under a BASA and MIP could be an important factor in an accident/incident investigation. The FAA has determined that the MIP must include provisions for the expeditious transfer of information that may be relevant to an accident/incident between the FAA and an NAA.
(4) Surveillance and Enforcement.
(a) The FAA must retain the ability to enforce U.S. regulations governing FAA-certificated repair facilities located in a country with which the United States has concluded a BASA and MIP. To retain this authority, all repair stations certificated as a result of evaluations conducted pursuant to a BASA and MIP will be issued certificates in accordance with the provisions of § 145.53 and will be required to comply with the term and conditions of the agreement when performing maintenance on U.S. aeronautical products. All MIPs will
14. Phase 4—Coordination Process. › a. Preliminary Coordination Meeting. AFS300 will request AFS50 to…
include procedures for the FAA to take enforcement action against an FAA-certificated foreign repair station that is evaluated by the NAA. If the NAA or the FAA determines that a repair station is not in compliance with the terms of the MIP, the FAA will retain the authority to suspend or revoke a repair facility’s FAA certificate and/or take any enforcement actions that the FAA deems appropriate.
(b) All MIPs must include provisions for the FAA and the NAA to surveil any repair facility that is certificated, approved, or accepted under the terms of a MIP. The MIP allows the FAA and the NAA to use its own enforcement resources and to enlist each other’s support to ensure compliance with all applicable regulatory requirements.
(5) FAA and NAA Surveillance Reporting Requirements. The FAA and the NAA should discuss and agree to the reporting requirements and forms to be used by each authority during the conduct of required surveillance. These documents should contain any special conditions identified by the FAA and/or the NAA, as well as any other specific procedural requirements for initial certification and ongoing surveillance. The FAA and NAA should agree to the frequency of the submission of these documents.
(6) Language Requirements. The language in which maintenance records are retained is an important element in any maintenance agreement. The FAA will specify those records that are required to be retained in English, to include those portions of the repair station’s manual that are currently required by 14 CFR. The repair station’s maintenance manuals do not need to be in English. The release and approval for return to service documents should meet the requirements of §§ 43.9 and 43.11 and describe the work performed in English; however, work cards are not required to be retained in English. A MIP and any special conditions should include provisions that require supervisory personnel to read, write, and understand English. Details of which records must be in English will be included in the MIP and special conditions. Normally, a MIP would have a generic statement that requires any record required by the owner/operator of a U.S.-registered aircraft to be in English.
(7) Training. The FAA and NAA should discuss and agree to conduct training for the FAA and NAA inspector workforce. Both parties should develop a plan including timeframes (training should be completed prior to the turnover process), curriculum, and MIP procedures. Initial training should occur prior to the commencement of the turnover process referred to in chapter 5 of the template MIP.
Note: In the event that the FAA and NAA teams cannot agree to mutually acceptable terms and conditions, the FAA team will refer the issues to AFS-1.
14. Phase 4—Coordination Process. Once a satisfactory working draft has been developed by the FAA and the NAA, the MIP must be coordinated with all responsible parties. The coordination process should start within 30 days from completion of the working draft.
a. Preliminary Coordination Meeting. AFS-300 will request AFS-50 to schedule a preliminary coordination meeting with AGC, the appropriate API desk officer, U.S. Department of State (DOS), and any other organizations as necessary to discuss the draft MIP. The team should highlight any deviations from the standard text for review by AGC and API. The AFS-300 team will disposition all comments from the review.
14. Phase 4—Coordination Process. › e. Turnover Process. Once the MIP has been signed, the FAA regional…
b. Resolution of any Issues with NAA. The NAA should conduct its own informal internal review of the draft MIP. Any issues affecting the document raised by either party should be noted and brought to the other party’s attention. Any issues raised between the FAA and NAA may require a meeting to resolve the issues.
c. Formal Coordination. When the FAA team and NAA have agreed with the draft MIP, each party will forward the draft MIP through their individual coordination process. For the FAA, AFS-50 will send the final MIP for coordination. The clearance grid typically includes: AGC-7, AGC-200, API, AFS-50, AFS-300, relevant AFS field offices and AIR-40. API will send a copy of the MIP to the DOS.
d. U.S. DOS Concurrence. If the DOS concurs with the document, it will be presented to the NAA for final approval. If approved by the NAA, the FAA and NAA representatives will sign the final document. These organizations will serve as the executive agencies for the implementation of the MIP under the BASA. In many cases the MIP must be translated into our bilateral partner’s native language before it can be signed. Both the English and the translated versions must be signed. API coordinates the translation with the DOS.
Note: API-1 holds signature authority for international agreements. API may delegate this to other FAA officials, as necessary.
e. Turnover Process. Once the MIP has been signed, the FAA regional office having geographic responsibility for the MIP, will schedule a meeting with the NAA to discuss the implementation of the turnover process as described in Order 8900.1, or included as part of the agreement. It must be noted that the turnover process may not begin until the MIP is signed by both parties.
ORIGINAL SIGNED by Carol E. Giles for James J. Ballough Director, Flight Standards Service
Appendix A. Assessment Job Aid—FAA Auditors Assessment Checklist of
National Aviation Authority Requesting a BASA/MIP
1.00—National Aviation Authority Complexity General Information Objective: To aid in the collection of information needed to assess a National Aviation Authority’s (NAA) maintenance oversight of operations for consideration of a MIP under a BASA. Information gathered will assist the FAA in determining the system, procedures, and regulatory basis for certification, inspection, enforcement, and continuing surveillance of approved maintenance organizations. It contains specific information proprietary to the FAA. Completed job aid responses should be analyzed to determine assessment resource needs. Instructions: This job aid was developed for computer use and is printable as a Word document. When completing this job aid, tab to each field and fill in the information requested. If more space is needed, indicate in the comment field “attachments are provided”. Attachments should reference the question number being addressed. If referencing an NAA document while completing a question, please indicate if the document is available in the English language and provide the document number, and if possible attach the applicable section(s) of the document.
Appendix A.
Country to be assessed:
Assessment checklist sent to NAA for completion: Received:
Assessment planned date: Assessment completed date:
FAA to complete- What are the names and positions of the FAA officials on the Assessment team: (Select team leader and members)
Names Positions
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7. 1.01 What are the names and positions of the NAA officials with whom the assessment will be conducted? Names Positions
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
1.02 Who are the specific persons to whom the FAA should direct all correspondence regarding findings / questions noted during the assessment?
Names Title Telephone # Facsimile #
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
3. 1.03 Who is the specific person (or persons) in the NAA authorized to sign official correspondence to the FAA regarding the NAA’s compliance with national, international, and FAA aviation safety requirements? Names Title Telephone # Facsimile #
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
3.
1.04 NAA Headquarters office(s). Provide complete address and location information.
Address
Comments
Name and title of person in charge of the maintenance section: FAA to complete—NAA headquarters office(s) visited. Attach information for offices visited. 1.05 Regional office(s). Provide complete address and location information for each Regional office. If more space is needed please attach. Address
Comments
FAA—Regional office(s) visited. Attach information for offices visited. 1.06 Field office(s). Provide complete address and location information for each Field office. If more space is needed, please attach. Address
Comments
Name and title of person in charge of maintenance section: FAA—Field office(s) visited. Attach information for offices visited.
Comments
FAA—Is the country a member of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO)?
Yes. No. If no, explain why.
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.07 Has the country being assessed signed a BAA/BASA with the United States? Yes No If yes, Auditor must identify the type of agreement in place, BAA or BASA, and area covered under the agreement, i.e., IPA, MIP, SIM, etc. Comments 1.08 Is the country a member of a multi-national organization or coordinating group seeking to harmonize the national aviation regulations of its members?
Yes No If yes, with whom?
1.09 If yes, to question 1.08, Is the multi-national organization or coordinating group undertaking efforts to harmonize its regulations or recommended practices with 14 CFR?
Yes No If yes, describe at what level of harmonization or completion the process is at. Comments
1.10 How many maintenance organizations hold valid maintenance certifications?
Comments
1.11 How many new applicant certifications for AMOs are in process or planned?
Comments
FAA—How many Air Agencies are FAA certified under part 145? Provide total amount of employees working at each agency and the types of ratings held. (List 5 largest FAA-certificated Air Agencies and check appropriate boxes.)
Operator Name Number of personnel
Rating Airframe
Rating Powerplant
Rating Avionic/ ACC
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
1. Yes 2. Yes 3. Yes 4. Yes 5. Yes
1. Yes 2. Yes 3. Yes 4. Yes 5. Yes
1. Yes 2. Yes 3. Yes 4. Yes 5. Yes
FAA- Review FAA materials for background information on the NAA and list / attach any findings. Mast inspection reports Yes No International Field Office (IFO) inspection reports Yes No IFO Country Assessment Reports Yes No Accident/incident investigation reports Yes No Enforcement reports Yes No Review of information should be limited to 2 years prior to this assessment Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.00—National Aviation Authority Complexity Organizational Structure and Safety Oversight Functions
1.12 Provide a description of the organization and legal structure governing civil aviation, e.g., ministry/department, aviation authority.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.13 Has a master organizational structure for the National Aviation Authority been established? Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. (Attach Organizational Chart)
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.14 Describe the mission and functions for which the NAA is responsible. (Attach copy of functional statement outlining duties and responsibilities.)
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.15 Is the Maintenance inspection organization integrated by: a) Maintenance only (stand alone): Yes No b) Operations and maintenance: Yes No c) Different specialties: Yes No d) Certification and maintenance: Yes No (Describe the mission and function from the selection made above.) Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.16 If the maintenance inspection organization is not a combined one, what provisions are made for communicating with other departments responsible for safety regulations, i.e., the communications between operations, engineering, certification, maintenance? (Describe how the system works.) Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.17 Describe the responsibilities of the maintenance inspection organization regarding: a) Recommendations regarding issuance of AMO certificates. b) Development of regulations for maintenance and AMOs. c) Recommendations regarding enforcement. d) Surveillance of AMOs. (If more space is needed provide attachments and documents.) Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.18 Does the NAA delegate any of its maintenance oversight responsibilities to other organizations or personnel that are not directly affiliated with the NAA such as: a) Other State bodies: Yes No b) Private agencies: Yes No c) Designated persons to include inspectors, auditors, surveyors: Yes No d) Other countries: Yes No e) Other: Yes No (Where applicable, provide reference documents by number and attachments.)
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.19 If yes to any selection in question 1.18, what is the relationship with the NAA?
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.20 If yes to any selection in question 1.18, what mechanism is in place to keep these delegated organizations/persons under supervisory and technical control?
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.21 If yes to any selection in question 1.18, what are the requirements and procedures for designation?
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.22 Are regional office(s) responsible for maintenance safety oversight? Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning.
Comments
1.23 If yes to question 1.22, what is the extent of their responsibility and has the NAA established a system for coordination and/or control of the regional offices? (Please describe the policy) Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.24 Is the NAA independent from entities subject to its regulatory oversight? Yes If yes, verify separation of NAA from industry. No If no, explain reasoning.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.00—National Aviation Authority Complexity Staffing and Resources 1.25 Provide over-all staffing resources in the following areas: Staffing at Headquarters:
• Maintenance section: Directors, managers, supervisors:
• Technical staff: Development of policy, procedures, regulations:
• Training staff: Staffing at Regional Offices:
• Maintenance section: Directors, managers, supervisors:
• Technical staff: Application of policy, procedures, regulations:
• Training staff:
Staffing at Field Offices:
• Management/supervisor:
• Inspectors/surveyors:
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.26 Are sufficient inspection personnel available for maintaining oversight responsibility of certificated maintenance organizations?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.27 Describe methods/policy in place on how the NAA determines appropriate inspection personnel levels and allocation.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.28 Describe the NAA’s average attrition rate for inspection personnel. For example, retirements, transfers, etc.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
1.29 Are NAA inspectors responsible for oversight of manufacturing facilities? Yes If yes, how many manufacturing facilities are located in your country? No Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.00—Primary Aviation Legislation and Regulation Content and Amendment Procedure
2.00 Describe the primary aviation legislation rules of maintenance for AMOs.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.01 At what level was the primary aviation legislation established? a) Head of State b) Prime Minister c) Parliament d) Council of Ministers e) Minister f) Other (specify) Describe the policy used to establish the legislation.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.02 Describe NAA procedures for the amendment of its primary aviation legislation.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.03 Describe how the NAA issues AMO certificates and limitations for: AMO Certificates, operations specifications/scope of work.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.04 Describe the primary aviation legislation and/or specific maintenance regulations authorizing the NAA to develop specific orders, directives, and instructions (guidance materials). Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.05 Describe the legal status (mandatory vs. advisory) of such orders, directives and/or instructions.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.06 Are the maintenance regulations, orders, directives, and amendments readily available to all users?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. (Describe how the NAA provides this information to Regional and Field offices.) Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.07 If part of a multinational organization, are there differences between the national regulations and the multinational regulation.
Yes No If yes, explain how the NAA complies with the regulation set forth by the multinational organization. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.00—Primary Aviation Legislation and Regulation Enforcement of Civil Aviation Regulations—General/Maintenance 2.08 Who is responsible for the enforcement of the maintenance regulations? Describe the policy in place used by the NAA.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.09 Describe how enforcement is implemented.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.10 Provide an overview of enforcement action(s) taken on maintenance organizations in the last twelve months (e.g., certificates, ratings, noncompliance, etc.).
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.11 Does the NAA have adequate resources to enforce its regulations? Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.12 Describe NAA regulations for providing unrestricted access to inspect AMOs.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.13 Describe the NAA policy on who has the authority to refuse, withdraw, revoke, or vary any maintenance operations of AMOs.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.00—Primary Aviation Legislation and Regulation Aircraft Maintenance Organizations (AMO)—Approval
2.14 Describe NAA policy requirements for approval of maintenance organizations.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.15 Do regulations require that a maintenance organization procedures manual be submitted to the NAA?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.16 Does the NAA review the maintenance procedures manual to ensure that it provides users with the necessary policy guidance and instructions in a clear and concise manner?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.17 Describe whether the maintenance procedures manual is approved or accepted by the NAA as part of the AMO approval process.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.18 Do procedures require the NAA to review and accept revisions to the maintenance organization procedures manual?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.19 Do NAA regulations define what must be included in the maintenance organization procedures manual?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.20 Do NAA regulations require a system for qualifying and or certification of AMO personnel?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.00—Primary Aviation Legislation and Regulation Exchange of Continuing Airworthiness Information 2.21 Has the NAA established a mandatory system whereby information on faults, malfunctions, and defects is reported to the organization responsible for the design of the aircraft or article?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.22 Are regulations established requiring AMOs to report faults, malfunctions, and defects to the NAA?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
2.23 Does the NAA have a system for alerting owners and operators of items that are of critical importance to aviation safety (e.g., Airworthiness Directives (AD))?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
3.00—Technical Guidance Maintenance Division—Maintenance Inspection 3.00 Is the NAA prepared to implement surveillance procedures and make recommendations to the FAA? Yes No Specific examples: a) certification of AMOs: Yes No b) FAA Special Conditions from MIP/current edition of AC 145-7: Yes No c) Approval of FAA AMO manual supplements on behalf of the FAA: Yes No d) AMO maintenance procedures manual revisions on behalf of the FAA: Yes No Explain NAA plan. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
3.00—Technical Guidance Maintenance Division—Maintenance documentation 3.01 Is there an airworthiness technical library available for maintenance personnel? Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
3.02 Does the NAA retain up-to-date copies of the AMO maintenance organization procedures manual? Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
3.03 Are there requirements for the maintenance organization procedures manual to contain an inspection system and/or quality control procedures?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
4.00—Qualified Technical Personnel Personnel/Training 4.00 Describe how NAA personnel are trained and qualified in the implementation of inspection and surveillance policies. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
4.01 Does the NAA operate a training center to satisfy its need for trained and qualified personnel? Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
4.02 Does the NAA have a policy on qualifications, experience, and minimum standard requirements for inspection personnel?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
4.03 Are inspection personnel provided with initial training and recurrent training? Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
5.00—Aircraft Maintenance Organizations (AMO)—Surveillance
5.00 Does the NAA maintenance inspection organization carry out inspections of the maintenance organizations on an ongoing basis?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
5.01 Does the NAA certificate and inspect facilities that are outside its domestic jurisdiction?
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
5.02 Is a formal schedule established for conducting inspections? Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
5.03 Is there official guidance material for certification and surveillance of maintenance organizations?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
5.04 What forms or checklists, if any, are used during surveillance/inspections of AMOs?
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
5.05 Does the NAA require that repair organizations inspection systems ensure all maintenance, preventive maintenance, repairs, and alterations are performed in accordance with approved or acceptable manuals/data?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
5.06 Does the NAA require maintenance records to be retained for the work performed? Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning.
Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
5.07 Do NAA regulations have requirements for determining acceptability of parts? (i.e., suspected unapproved parts program)
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
5.08 Does the NAA have an internal evaluation program/quality control system for internal evaluation of its systems?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
5.09 Do NAA field office procedures require retaining current and past inspection surveillance documents and vital information on the AMO?
Yes If yes, describe NAA policy. No If no, explain reasoning. Comments
Finding: FAA Finding
Satisfactory Not satisfactory Not implemented
Followup action: Date: Initials:
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix B
Appendix B. Sample Decision Memorandum
Federal Aviation Administration
Memorandum
Date: [Type date here]
To: AFS-1, THRU: AFS-300, AFS-50
From: Team Lead
Prepared by: [Type who prepared memo here]
Appendix B. Sample Decision Memorandum › Joint Sampling of Repair Stations
Subject: ACTION: Decision to Pursue MIP with [NAA]
The FAA is considering the pursuit of Maintenance Implementation Procedures (MIP) with the [NAA] of [country]. AFS-50 has reviewed [NAA]’s IASA standing and has coordinated the proposal with API. A team of AFS experts has reviewed the [NAA]’s completed assessment checklist and maintenance regulations, and has determined that there is a sufficient basis for pursuing a MIP with [NAA]. The team has prepared an action plan detailing the process for developing and concluding a MIP with [NAA]. The following highlights from the action plan address major milestones and resource requirements. Please indicate your concurrence/non-concurrence with the proposal to pursue a MIP with [NAA].
FAA Capability Assessment of [NAA] System: A team consisting of [number] representatives from AFS-300, AFS-50, [name] International Field Office, and [name] Region will conduct an in-country assessment of the [NAA] between [date] and [date]. The team will visit [NAA] headquarters and [number] regional offices in [country] and, using the checklist as completed by [NAA], assess the ability of [NAA] to conduct repair station surveillance on behalf of the FAA. The team estimates the cost of the in-country assessment to be $[xxxxx].
Regulatory Comparison: AFS-300, in conjunction with the team, will review all [NAA] regulations, procedures, and guidance pertaining to the certification of repair stations. Contract support for this activity will be necessary and is estimated to cost $[xxxx]. The comparison is estimated to be completed by [date].
Joint Sampling of Repair Stations: Upon completion of the regulatory comparison, the team will meet with the [NAA] in [country] to review the comparison table and address items that were identified as potential differences. In addition, the FAA, together with the [NAA], will visit [number] repair stations throughout [country] in order to observe the practical application of [NAA]’s regulations by the industry, and to verify the comparison table. At the conclusion of the
Appendix B. Sample Decision Memorandum › Please indicate below whether you concur with the total resource…
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix B
visits, the FAA and the [NAA] will discuss the FAA observations and resolve any remaining questions. The cost of the Joint Sampling is estimated to be $[xxxx].
Development of MIP: The team will develop a proposed draft MIP with [NAA] based on the MIP template and conclusions from the regulatory comparison and joint samplings. The team estimates that it will be necessary to hold [number] discussion sessions with [NAA] at an estimated cost of $[xxxx]. In addition to addressing the content of the MIP, periodic discussions provide the FAA with an opportunity to ensure that conditions, regulations, and processes at the [NAA] have not changed during the development of the MIP. In addition, the FAA and [NAA] will discuss the eventual implementation of the MIP, including necessary forms, guidance, training, regular meetings, etc. The team estimates these discussions can be concluded by [date].
Please indicate below whether you concur with the total resource commitment of $[xxxx] that this project will require.
Concur … Nonconcur … File:
BACKGROUND › The FAA team conducted an indepth assessment of [NAA] competencies in…
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix C
Appendix C. Sample Capability Assessment Memorandum
Federal Aviation Administration
Memorandum
Date: [Type date in here}
To: Manager, Aircraft Maintenance Division AFS-300
From: Team Lead, FAA Maintenance Assessment Team
Prepared by: [Type who prepared memo here]
Subject: INFORMATION: [Name of Country] [NAA] Assessment Report
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The FAA has conducted a Capability Assessment of the [NAA] of the [name of country] and observed that it is a competent authority with a skilled and well-trained inspector workforce and adequate resources.
BACKGROUND
From [date to date], the FAA conducted an assessment of the [NAA] to determine their ability to perform surveillance and certificate management responsibilities of Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 145 repair stations based in [name of country] on behalf of the FAA.
The FAA team consisted of [names of FAA team].
The team conducted an in-briefing with the following [NAA] officials:
• [Names of NAA officials]
On [date] the FAA team conducted an out-briefing with the same [NAA] officials.
The FAA team conducted an in-depth assessment of [NAA] competencies in the following areas:
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix C
1. National Aviation Authority Complexity
The FAA team conducted a thorough review of the internal and external organizational structure, staffing, and resources of the [NAA].
4. Personnel Qualifications and Training › The FAA found the [NAA] personnel requirements and training procedures…
[Insert description of NAA]
The FAA found this organizational structure to be independent and empowered, with adequate internal controls. In addition, the [NAA] was found to have adequate resources and personnel to conduct oversight of repair stations.
2. Primary Aviation Legislation and Regulation
[Insert description of legislative and regulatory structure of NAA].
Overall, the FAA was satisfied with the [NAA]’s legislative and regulatory structure.
The FAA also conducted a review of the [NAA] regulations and procedures for approval, surveillance, and enforcement of aircraft maintenance organizations (AMOs). The FAA evaluated information on the [NAA] overall policy of certificating an AMO, maintenance procedures manual policies, and approval/acceptance requirements of manuals required, and AMO personnel qualifications. In addition, the FAA reviewed enforcement policies, procedures, and recent actions. Finally, the FAA reviewed the [NAA] procedures for the exchange of airworthiness information, including incident reporting and mechanisms for alerting operators of critical safety information. The FAA found the [NAA]’s policies and procedures to be adequate.
3. Technical Guidance
This section required the [NAA] to clarify their position on the ability to implement surveillance procedures and make recommendations to the FAA regarding certification of AMOs, MIP special conditions, and approval of FAA supplements and revisions. The [NAA] indicated some reluctance regarding the burden this could create, depending on what terms are negotiated under an eventual MIP. This did not bring into question the ability of the [NAA] to oversee U.S. repair stations, but it did foretell an area of negotiations that will require special attention.
Additionally, the [NAA] demonstrated their policy and procedures for the retention of documents, the use of a technical library, revision capabilities for regulatory materials, and the requirements for inspection procedures manuals to contain an inspection system/quality control procedures. [NAA] retention of documents (both electronically and in hard copy) was adequate, as well as their database of certifications and regulations. They were also able to demonstrate adequate policy and procedures for the repair station manual and the quality program/section (RSM/QPM) requirements.
4. Personnel Qualifications and Training
The FAA found the [NAA] personnel requirements and training procedures to be adequate to maintain a highly capable management structure and cadre of surveyors. In addition to high initial educational and training requirements, surveyors have on-the-job training and are required
CONCLUSION › The FAA team found no technical areas of concern that would prevent the…
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix C
to participate in surveillance activities of other teams for purposes of cross-training. The FAA will need to ensure that the [NAA] maintains adequate personnel levels to oversee part 145 repair stations.
5. Maintenance Surveillance of AMOs
This section required the [NAA] to demonstrate adequate policy and procedures for the surveillance of AMOs. Specifically, questions were asked in the following areas: scheduling of inspections, audit procedures, reporting and retention requirements, frequency of inspections, and other associated questions pertaining to the surveillance of AMOs. Because of the NAA audit system, many larger repair stations had surveyors on the premises many times per year. In addition, surveyors are rotated among approval holders every 2-3 years. No findings or concerns were noted in this area.
CONCLUSION
The FAA team found no technical areas of concern that would prevent the [NAA] from surveilling and certificating part 145 repair stations on behalf of the FAA, once the FAA has determined that the NAA rules and procedures will not alter that assessment. Following the completion of a comparison of the applicable Federal aviation regulations and the NAA regulations, the FAA will make a final determination as to whether a further review of the [NAA] would be necessary.
Appendix D. Sample Capability Assessment Letter to NAA › We look forward to the completion of this process.
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix D
Appendix D. Sample Capability Assessment Letter to NAA
[Name] [Title] [Name of NAA] [Street Address] [Street Address 2][City][Country]
Dear [Name]:
Thank you for accommodating the visit of the FAA maintenance assessment team from [Date to Date]. The information and access you provided was very helpful toward establishing an understanding of the [NAA] of [name of country] system, processes, and procedures for repair station certification.
[Additional questions/issues that need resolution]
The FAA will now conduct a comprehensive comparison of [NAA] and FAA regulations, procedures, and guidance for repair station certification and surveillance to determine those areas where FAA and [NAA] rules and procedures may differ. After the comparison, the FAA and [NAA] will discuss the comparison and visit several repair stations in [name of country] in order to observe the practical application of [NAA]’s regulations. Following this system evaluation, the FAA will propose a draft MIP and suggest timeframes for further discussions.
We look forward to the completion of this process. In the meantime, we should remain in contact and exchange any information that is relevant to maintaining an understanding of each other’s repair station oversight system.
Sincerely, Team Lead
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix E
Appendix E. Sample Regulatory Comparison Matrix
Appendix E. Sample Regulatory Comparison Matrix
SAMPLE REGULATORY COMPARISON FOR THE PURPOSES OF DETERMINING
FAA SPECIAL CONDITIONS TO BE MET BY REPAIR STATIONS UNDER A BASA/MIP
NAA’s Part 145 14 CFR Parts 43 and 145 Comparison Indicators Joint Sampling
145.A.10, Scope
This section establishes the
requirements to be met by an
organization to qualify for the
issuance or continuation of an
approval for the maintenance of
aircraft and components.
§ 145.1, Applicability
This part describes how to obtain a
repair station certificate. This part
also contains the rules a certificated
repair station must follow related to
its performance of maintenance,
preventive maintenance, or
alterations of an aircraft, airframe,
aircraft engine, propeller,
appliance, or component part to
which part 43 applies. It also
applies to any person who holds, or
is required to hold, a repair station
certificate issued under this part.
There is not a difference.
Intent of the regulations is
the same. National Aviation
Authority’s (NAA) part 145
uses the term “scope” in the
same manner as the § 145.1,
Applicability.
Implementing Regulation, Article 2,
Definitions
In par.2(c), “component” means any
engine, propeller, part, or appliance
§ 145.3 (b), Article
An aircraft, airframe, aircraft
engine, propeller, appliance, or
component part.
There is not a difference.
Intent of the regulations is
the same. FAA and NAA
use “component”
differently; and NAA does
not use the term “article.”
FAA “article” = NAA
“component” + aircraft +
airframe. Appears to be no
effect since each side, when
using its own terms to
define a class of
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix E
SAMPLE REGULATORY COMPARISON FOR THE PURPOSES OF DETERMINING
FAA SPECIAL CONDITIONS TO BE MET BY REPAIR STATIONS UNDER A BASA/MIP
NAA’s Part 145 14 CFR Parts 43 and 145 Comparison Indicators Joint Sampling
applicability of a
requirement, uses them
consistently with the other’s
definition of a class and the
applicable ratings.
145.A.20, Terms of approval
The organization shall specify the
scope of work deemed to constitute
approval in its exposition (Appendix
annex II to this Part Annex contains
a table of all classes and ratings).
§ 43.1, Applicability
This part prescribes rules governing
the maintenance, preventative
maintenance, rebuilding, and
alteration of any aircraft having a
U.S. airworthiness certificate,
Foreign registered civil aircraft
used in common carriage or
carriage of mail under the
provisions of part 121 or 135 of this
chapter…, etc.
§ 145.5, Certificate and operations
specifications requirements
(a) No person may operate as a
certificated repair station without,
or in violation of, a repair station
certificate, ratings, or operations
specifications issued under this
part.
Regulations are the same.
Applies to aircraft having an
airworthiness certificate
issued by the country of
registration and may be
operated by another
operator in a different
country but must meet the
country of registration’s
requirements.
145.A.15, Application
An application for the issue or
variation of an approval shall be
§ 145.51, Application for certificate
(a) An application for a repair
station certificate and rating must
No major differences here.
The 14 CFR is slightly more
prescriptive.
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix E
SAMPLE REGULATORY COMPARISON FOR THE PURPOSES OF DETERMINING
FAA SPECIAL CONDITIONS TO BE MET BY REPAIR STATIONS UNDER A BASA/MIP
NAA’s Part 145 14 CFR Parts 43 and 145 Comparison Indicators Joint Sampling
made to the competent authority in a
form and manner established by
such authority.
be made in a format acceptable to
the FAA…, etc.
(d) An application for an additional
rating, amended repair station
certificate, or renewal of a repair
station certificate must be made in a
format acceptable to the FAA. The
application must include only that
information necessary to
substantiate the change or renewal
of the certificate.
§ 145.53, Issue of certificate
(a) Except as provided in
paragraph (b) of this section, a
person who meets the requirements
of this part is entitled to a repair
station certificate with appropriate
ratings prescribing such operations
specifications and limitations as are
necessary in the interest of safety.
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix E
SAMPLE REGULATORY COMPARISON FOR THE PURPOSES OF DETERMINING
FAA SPECIAL CONDITIONS TO BE MET BY REPAIR STATIONS UNDER A BASA/MIP
NAA’s Part 145 14 CFR Parts 43 and 145 Comparison Indicators Joint Sampling
145.A.85, Changes to the organization
The organization shall notify the
competent authority of any proposal
to carry out any of the following
changes before such changes take
place to enable the competent
authority to determine continued
compliance with this part, and to
amend, if necessary, the approval
certificate….
1. the name of the organization;
2. the main location of the organization
* * *
(b) If the holder of a repair station
certificate sells or transfers its assets,
the new owner must apply for an
amended certificate in accordance
with § 145.51.
§ 145.57, Amendment to or transfer
of certificate
(a) The holder of a repair station
certificate must apply for a change
to its certificate in a format
acceptable to the FAA. A change to
the certificate is necessary if the
certificate holder—
(1) Changes the location of the
repair station, or
(2) Requests to add or amend a
rating.
Regulations are the same,
with the following
exception:
Neither the NAA nor the
guidance material
specifically address this
situation. Need discussion.
145.A.90, Continued validity
(a) An approval shall be issued for
an unlimited duration. It shall
remain valid subject to:
* * *
§ 145.223, FAA inspections
(a) A certificated repair station
must allow the FAA to inspect that
repair station at any time to
determine compliance with this
chapter.
§ 145.223(a) provision for
entering “at any time” is
more specifically forceful
than 145.A.90.
Would not impede FAA
access. Intent of the
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix E
SAMPLE REGULATORY COMPARISON FOR THE PURPOSES OF DETERMINING
FAA SPECIAL CONDITIONS TO BE MET BY REPAIR STATIONS UNDER A BASA/MIP
NAA’s Part 145 14 CFR Parts 43 and 145 Comparison Indicators Joint Sampling
2. the competent authority being granted access to the organization to
determine continued compliance
with this Part…,etc.
(b) A certificated repair station may
not contract for the performance of
a maintenance function on an
article with a noncertificated person
unless it provides in its contract
with the noncertificated person that
the FAA may make an inspection
and observe the performance of the
noncertificated person’s work on
the article.
(c) A certificated repair station may
not return to service any article on
which a maintenance function was
performed by a noncertificated
person if the noncertificated person
does not permit the FAA to make
the inspection described in
paragraph (b) of this section.
regulations are the same.
145.A.45, Maintenance data
(a) The organization shall hold and
use applicable current maintenance
data in the performance of
maintenance, including
modifications and repairs.
”Applicable” means relevant to any
aircraft, component or process
specified in the organization’s
approval class rating schedule and in
§ 145.109, Equipment, materials,
and data requirements
(d) A certificated repair station
must maintain, in a format
acceptable to the FAA, the
documents and data required for the
performance of maintenance,
preventive maintenance, or
alterations under its repair station
certificate and operations
The 14 CFR only requires
data to be current and
accessible when the work is
being done. It also does not
require a specific procedure
for keeping data current as
NAA’s § 145.45(h).
Major difference: NAA’s
part 145 requires
NAA-approved or
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix E
SAMPLE REGULATORY COMPARISON FOR THE PURPOSES OF DETERMINING
FAA SPECIAL CONDITIONS TO BE MET BY REPAIR STATIONS UNDER A BASA/MIP
NAA’s Part 145 14 CFR Parts 43 and 145 Comparison Indicators Joint Sampling
any associated capability list.
In the case of maintenance data
provided by an operator or customer,
the organization shall hold such data
when the work is in progress, with
the exception of the need to comply
with 145.A.55(c).
(b) For the purposes of this Part,
applicable maintenance data shall be
any of the following:
1. Any applicable requirement, procedure, operational directive or
information issued by the authority
responsible for the oversight of the
aircraft or component;
2. Any applicable airworthiness directive issued by the authority
responsible for the oversight of the
aircraft or component;
3. Instructions for continuing airworthiness, issued by type
certificate holders, supplementary
type certificate holders, any other
organization required to publish
such data by Part 21, and in the case
of aircraft or components from third
countries, the airworthiness data
specifications in accordance with
part 43. The following documents
and data must be current and
accessible when the relevant work
is being done:
(1) Airworthiness directives,
(2) Instructions for continued
airworthiness,
(3) Maintenance manuals,
(4) Overhaul manuals,
(5) Standard practice manuals,
(6) Service bulletins, and
(7) Other applicable data acceptable
to or approved by the FAA.
acceptable data for
NAA-registered aircraft or
components.
FAA difference:
FAA-approved or
acceptable data for
U.S.-registered aircraft or
article to be installed on
U.S.-registered aircraft.
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix E
SAMPLE REGULATORY COMPARISON FOR THE PURPOSES OF DETERMINING
FAA SPECIAL CONDITIONS TO BE MET BY REPAIR STATIONS UNDER A BASA/MIP
NAA’s Part 145 14 CFR Parts 43 and 145 Comparison Indicators Joint Sampling
mandated by the authority
responsible for the oversight of the
aircraft or component;
4. Any applicable standard, such as but not limited to, maintenance
standard practices recognized by the
agency as a good standard for
maintenance;
5. Any applicable data issued in accordance with paragraph (d).
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix F
Appendix F. Sample NAA System Evaluation Report
BACKGROUND › The focus of the joint sampling is not on the repair stations, but…
Federal Aviation Administration
Memorandum Date: [DATE]
To: Manager, Aircraft Maintenance Division AFS-300
From: Team Lead, [COUNTRY] Maintenance Assessment Team
Prepared by: [Team Lead]
Subject: FAA Maintenance Implementation Procedures (MIP) Development Team System Evaluation Report of the [COUNTRY] National Aviation Authority (Joint Sampling of Repair Stations)
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
During the week of [DATE], the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) maintenance implementation procedures (MIP) development team conducted a joint system evaluation with [NAME OF COUNTRY’S NATIONAL AVIATION AUTHORITY (NAA)]. The purpose of the joint evaluation is designed to confirm what FAA special conditions would be applied to the MIP document. The FAA team identified the differences between Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) parts 43 and 145. The FAA confirmed the difference between 14 CFR and [COUNTRY] Civil Aviation Regulations as directly applied by [COUNTRY NAA] inspection staff. The FAA team found that development of a MIP with [COUNTRY NAA] should continue to Phase 3 in accordance with FAA Order 8000.85. Phase 3 is development of the actual written agreement. The FAA team and the [COUNTRY NAA] have agreed to put a strong effort into having a draft agreement ready for management review by [DATE, QUARTER, and FISCAL YEAR (FY)].
BACKGROUND
After completing the regulatory comparison and identifying the potential special conditions IAW FAA Order 8000.85 Phase 2, the FAA and [COUNTRY] team leader scheduled the next section of Phase 2 in the MIP development process. Phase 2 consists of [COUNTRY NAA] system evaluation. This process required the FAA team to sample FAA-certificated repair stations as well as non-FAA-certificated maintenance organizations located in [COUNTRY].
The focus of the joint sampling is not on the repair stations, but rather it is directed at observing and documenting the [COUNTRY NAA] surveillance process and procedures, as well as noting the techniques and practices in normal surveillance. The team worked with the [COUNTRY
The FAA team conducted an evaluation of [COUNTRY NAA] competencies in… › (2) Analysis of [COUNTRY NAA] regulatory system
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix F
NAA] to identify a representative sampling of repair stations. [COUNTRY] currently has [Number] FAA-certificated repair stations. The sampling included FAA-certificated and non-FAA-certificated repair stations. The FAA and [COUNTRY NAA] agreed to sample [NUMBER] facilities that varied in ratings and size. [Number] facilities were selected because of the number of FAA-certificated repair stations located within [COUNTRY]. The [COUNTRY NAA] uses a rolling type surveillance system. Each repair station in the sampling was in a different phase of the NAA’s surveillance system. The repair stations selected were in different cities:
(1) Name, address. FAA Certificate Number as applicable and number of employees.
(2) Name, address. FAA Certificate Number as applicable and number of employees.
The [COUNTRY NAA] facilitated the assessment by contacting the repair stations to establish an itinerary for the joint visits within a specified timeframe. The FAA team, along with the [COUNTRY NAA], observed [COUNTRY NAA] inspectors perform oversight in various areas, which allowed the team to confirm previously identified differences. In some areas the team was able to identify areas where differences may be reduced due to internal NAA guidance. The FAA team completed the fourth column of the comparison work sheet identified in FAA Order 8000.85, Appendix E, and identified proposed differences.
The FAA team consisted of:
• (List FAA team members)
The team conducted an in-briefing with the following [COUNTRY NAA] officials:
• (List NAA officials)
On [DATE], the FAA team conducted an out-briefing with the same [COUNTRY NAA] officials. [COUNTRY NAA] management agreed to expedite the development of the agreement and make every effort to have a draft agreement ready for management review by [DATE, QUARTER, and FY].
The FAA team conducted an evaluation of [COUNTRY NAA] competencies in the following areas:
(1) The [COUNTRY NAA] inspection staff competency: The FAA team conducted a thorough review of the internal and external organizational structure, staffing, and resources of the [COUNTRY NAA]. The [COUNTRY NAA] was found to have adequate resources and personnel to conduct oversight of repair stations, provide the FAA with certification recommendations, and conduct surveillance on behalf of the FAA.
(2) Analysis of [COUNTRY NAA] regulatory system: FAA legal council, along with the FAA team, completed a regulatory comparison identifying the differences between 14 CFR parts 43 and 145 and [COUNTRY NAA] part 145. The joint evaluation confirmed the practical application of [COUNTRY NAA] part 145, thereby confirming the differences. (See attached four column work sheet used during the joint assessment.)
BACKGROUND › Administrative Issues
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix F
(3) Identifying technical guidance changes:
(a) The FAA team recommends the FAA develop an advisory circular (AC) similar to AC 145-7. This will aid industry and the [COUNTRY NAA] in applying a new agreement. The FAA should also revise or develop internal FAA inspector guidance to accommodate a new agreement.
(b) The [COUNTRY NAA] will need to revise internal guidance, as well as provide the FAA with guidance, to meet their requirements in the United States.
(4) The FAA team will develop the reporting and documentation requirements to be included in the agreement. The FAA team expects that similar reporting and documentation requirements identified in the NAA agreement can be used by re-identifying the documents in the [COUNTRY] agreements.
Short description of FAA special conditions:
(1) Show a need for FAA certification.
(2) FAA-approved data major repairs and major alterations.
(3) Compliance with air carriers Continuous Airworthiness Maintenance Program (CAMP) including Required Inspection Items (RII).
(4) FAA Airworthiness Directives (AD).
(5) Compliance with manufacturers’ manuals and deviation thereto.
(6) Personnel requirements: Chief Inspector, English language, (address not accepting applications from a person that has been involved in certification revocation).
(7) FAA-approved training program.
(8) Capabilities list/scope of work.
(9) Malfunction or defect (M or D)/Service Difficulty Report (SDR) reporting requirements to FAA.
(10) Recognition of [COUNTRY NAA] Form 1 for return to service.
(11) Hazardous material (hazmat) letter from applicant.
(12) Contract Maintenance Quarterly Utilization Report (QUR), FAA inspection of noncertificated subcontractors.
Administrative Issues: 24-month renewal, fees, forms, and reporting requirements.
NEXT STEPS › Phase 3, development of the agreement
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix F
CONCLUSION
The FAA team found no technical areas of concern that would prevent the [COUNTRY NAA] from surveilling and making recommendation for certificating 14 CFR part 145 repair stations to the FAA. The FAA will make a final determination as to whether further review of the [COUNTRY NAA] is necessary once the appropriate management officials and the U.S. Department of State have reviewed the draft agreement.
NEXT STEPS
Phase 3, development of the agreement: After the conclusion of an agreement, there will be a turnover process during which the FAA will work with the [COUNTRY NAA] to ensure the appropriate personnel are trained to oversee FAA certificates under the agreement.
Appendix G. Template MIP
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix G
Appendix G. Template MIP
MAINTENANCE IMPLEMENTATION
PROCEDURES
under the
Agreement for the Promotion of Aviation Safety
between the
Government of the United States of America
and the
Government of [INSERT APPLICABLE COUNTRY]
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix G
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Paragraph … Page CHAPTER 1. GENERAL … G-3 1.0. Purpose … G-3 1.1. Authorization … G-3 1.2. Entry into Force and Termination … G-3 1.3. Amendments … G-3 1.4. Membership in a Regional Organization [if applicable] … G-4 1.5. National Requirements … G-4 1.6. Accountability … G-4 1.7. Resolution of Disagreements … G-5 1.8. Definitions … G-5 CHAPTER 2. RECIPROCAL ACCEPTANCE OF FINDINGS OF COMPLIANCE….. G-7 2.0. General … G-7 2.1. Eligibility Requirements … G-7 CHAPTER 3. SPECIAL CONDITIONS … G-9 3.0. [NAA] Special Conditions Applicable to U.S.-Based Repair Station … G-9 3.1. FAA Special Conditions Applicable to EU-Based Approved Maintenance Organizations (AMO) … G-10 CHAPTER 4. MUTUAL COOPERATION AND TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE … G-12 4.0. Periodic meetings … G-12 4.1. Information … G-12 4.2. Technical Evaluation Assistance … G-12 4.3. Exchange of Information … G-12 4.4. Establishing and Amending Regulations, Policies, and Guidelines … G-12 4.5. Urgent or Unusual Situations … G-12 4.6. Notification of Noncompliance and Safety Issues … G-13 4.7. Protection of Proprietary Data and Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Requests.... G-13 4.8. Accident/Incident Investigation Requests … G-13 CHAPTER 5. TRANSFER AND CONTINUING VALIDITY PROVISIONS … G-14 5.0. Transfer Provisions … G-14 5.1. Continuing Validity … G-14 CHAPTER 6. AUTHORITY … G-15
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix G
CHAPTER 1. GENERAL
1.0. Purpose.
(a) This document sets forth the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and the [National Aviation Authority (NAA)] procedures for implementing the maintenance and alteration or modification provisions of the Agreement for the Promotion of Aviation Safety between the Government of the United States and the Government of [INSERT APPLICABLE COUNTRY] signed [insert date of BASA signature]. The Agreement provides, in pertinent part, that the FAA and the [NAA] will pursue mutual cooperation and technical assistance in evaluation and acceptance of each other’s systems, including recommendations for FAA certification and renewal of certification, [NAA] [acceptance] [approval] [certification], and continued monitoring of maintenance and alteration or modification facilities.
(b) In accordance with the Agreement, the objective of these Maintenance Implementation Procedures (MIP) is to outline the terms and conditions under which the FAA and the [NAA] can accept each other’s inspections and evaluations of maintenance facilities for findings of compliance, thereby reducing redundant regulatory oversight, without adversely affecting aviation safety.
1.1. Authorization. The authorization for this MIP is Article III of the Agreement for the Promotion of Aviation Safety. In that respect, the FAA and the NAA have assessed each other’s standards and systems relating to the approval of repair stations/ maintenance organizations that perform maintenance and alterations or modifications on civil aeronautical products. This cooperation has established an understanding of each other’s standards and systems.
1.2. Entry into Force and Termination. This MIP shall enter into force sixty (60) days after the date of the last signature and shall remain in force until terminated. They may be terminated upon sixty (60) days’ written notice by either the FAA or the [NAA]. Termination of these MIPs will not affect the validity of activity conducted under their provisions prior to termination.
1.3. Amendments.
(a) This MIP may be amended by mutual consent of the FAA and the NAA. They may also be supplemented by appendices. The details of the amendment or appendix shall be recorded and signed by the representatives identified in paragraph 1.6(b), or their designees.
(b) Suggestions for improvement are welcome and can be addressed to either of the offices described in paragraph 1.6.
(c) The FAA and the [NAA] recognize that significant revision by either authority to its organization, regulations, procedures, or standards may affect the basis on which this MIP is executed. Accordingly, each authority agrees to promptly advise the other of plans for these changes, and to give an opportunity for comment. Upon notice of these changes by one authority, the other authority may request consultation to review the need for amendment to this MIP.
12/20/07 8000.85A Appendix G
1.4. Membership in a Regional Organization [if applicable].
(a) The FAA recognizes that the [NAA] is a member of [insert name of regional organization] and that membership includes obligations of the [NAA] to other [insert name of regional organization] members with respect to development of regulations, procedures, and standards, and that the [NAA] has adopted [insert name of regional organization] regulations, procedures, and standards, including standards for approval of maintenance organizations.
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 148 passages shown