Radar Vectors
FAA Order Current Issued Nov 15, 1984 APO-200 58 pages Copy saved Nov 17, 2026

Order 7031.2C Airway Planning Standard Number One Terminal Air Navigation Facilities and Air Traffic Services

This order contains the policy and criteria used in establishing the eligibility of terminal locations for terminal air navigation facilities and air traffic control services

Official source ↗ Open PDF

7031.2C CHG 13_Updated › 3. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph.

Distribution: Electronic Initiated By: APO-200

CHANGE

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

ORDER 7031.2C CHG 13 Effective Date:

12/19/2024

SUBJ:

Airway Planning Standard Number One Terminal Air Navigation Facilities and Air Traffic Services

1. Purpose. This change transmits revisions to Chapter 2, Section 2, Radar Services, and Appendix 2 Summary of Establishment and Discontinuance Criteria.

2. Who this change affects. This change pertains to the number of flight operations necessary for an FAA VFR control tower at an airport to become a candidate for a remoted radar display scope in the tower cab. The change lowers the number of flight operations from at least 30,000 annual itinerant operations to 15,000 itinerant operations. This change affects AJT and affiliated offices such as the Program Management Office and STARS office.

3. Disposition of Transmittal Paragraph. After filing the attached change, this transmittal should be retained.

PAGE CHANGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated 30 6/17/02 30 12/19/24 APPENDIX 2 page 7 11/15/84 APPENDIX 2 page 7 12/19/24

Natasha A. Durkins Executive Director Office of Aviation Policy and Plans

ORDER 7031. 2C

Reprint includes

Changes 1 - 11

AIRWAY PLANNING STANDARD NUMBER ONE­

TERMINAL AIR NAVIGATION FACILITIES

7031.2C.pdf

AND AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL SERVICES

NOVEMBER 15, 1984

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

Distribution: A-WYZ-2; A-X( except AF/AS/ AT/FSIPL)-2; A-X(AF/ AS/ AT/FS/PL)-3: Initiated By: AP0-200 A-FAF-2/3 (LTO); A-FAS-1 (LTD); A-FAT-1,2,5,6 (LTO)

ll/ 15/ 84 7031.2C

FOREWORD

Tllis order contains the policy and criteria used in establishlng the

eligi.l>ility of tcrmin.U. locations for terminal air navigation facilities and air traffic control services.

The safety and efficiency of air traffic determine requirements for air navigational facilities and air traffic control services, but these facilities and services should only be established at locations where the ~nefits of

service exceed ~~e cost to the government. Economic consider~tion of benefits and costs for both new establis~~ts and imprpvecents to existing facilities or service is related to air traffic activity levels . This order specifies m.lnilllum activity levels for torm.lnals to become candidates for, to qua.li.fy

for, or to retain primary terminal air navigation facilities and air traffic control services. For certain types of facilities, the order also establishes a requiramant for additio~al cost benefit and other analyccs prior to facility comm.issJ.oning or decommissioning. satisfying criteria specified herein does not constitute a commitment by t .he Feder&l. Aviation Administration to provide, modi.fy, or disconti.nue eliqiblo facilities or services.

~~~g~~,~

Administrator

" •

Page i (and ii)

7031. 2C Cl{G 12 8/17/99

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page No.

CHAPTER l . GENERAL 1

1. Pu;rpose 1 2. Distribution 1 3. Cancellation 1 4. Background 1 5. Explanation of Changes 2 6. Authority of Changes to t his order 2 7. Policy 2 8. Scope 5 9.-19. Reserved 6

CHAPTER 2. NAVIGATION AIDS 11

SECTION l. AIR NAVIGATION RI\DIO 1\IDS 11

20 . Microwav~ Landing System (MLS) with Approach Lights 11 21. I nstrument .Landing System (ILS) with Approach Lights 14- 2 22. Nonprecision Instrument Approach System 17 23 . VOR Test Signal (VOT) 24.- 25 . Reserved 24

SECTION 2. RI\DAR SERVI CES 27

26. Airport Surveillance Radar with Air Traffic Control Radar Beacon System and Automated Radar Te~~nal System (ASR/ATCRBS/ARTS) 27 27. Precision Approach Radar (PAR) 31 28. Non- Federally owned Airport surveil lance Radar (ASR) 32 29. Reserved 32 •

CHAPTER 3. AERONAUTICAL LIGHTING AND AIRPORT MARRING AIDS 35

30. Runway End Identification Lights (REIL) 35 31. Visua l Approach Slope I ndicator (VASil VFR Only 37 32. Retrofit of Runway Approach Lighting Systems 41 33.- 39. Reserved 42

Page iii

7031. 2C CHG 12 8/17/99 Page No.

C!IA.PTER 4 • AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL 41

40. FAA Airport Traffic Control Tower 47 41. Approach Control Service 47 42. Combined Stations/Towers 48 43. T~rrnina~ En Rout~ Conerol Service 51 44. Airport Surface Detection Equipment (ASDE) 51 4!'>. Automated T~rminal Info>:::mation Service (AT!S) 52 46. Automated Weather Observing System (AWOS) 52 47. Policy on Admini~trative Combination of Terminal Control Facilities 56 48. Low-Level Windshear Alert System (LLWAS) 56 4 9. Terminal Doppler Weather Radar !TDiqR) 59 SO. Airport Surveillance Radar (ASR) Modification

for Windshear Detection 51. Integrated Windshear Detection Systems: and Modified ASR 52. Mecropl~x control Facility (MCF) 53. Terminal Radar Approach Control (TRACON) 54. Precision Runway Monitor (PRM)

60 LLWAS, TDWR,

60 61 Facility 65 67

APPENDIX l. Rlll-IOTENESS-COMPENSATION FOR BENEE.IT/COST

CRITERIA (2 pages) 1

APPENDIX 2. SUMMARY OF ESTABLISHMENT AND DISCONTINUANCE

CRITERIA (18 pages) 1

Figure l - Criteria Summary for Chapter 2, Navigation Aids 3 Section 1 . Air Navigation Aid~ 3 • Section 2. Radar Services 3 • Fiqure 2 - Cri teria Summary for Chapter 3, Aeronautical

Lighting and Airport Ma~king Aids 9 Figure 3 - Criteria Summary for Chapter 4, Ai~ Traffic Control ll

APPENDIX 3. SUMMARY Of "CRITICAL VALUES" (5 pages) 1

APPENDIX ~. ESTABLISIIMENT }IJlO DISCONTINUANCE CRITERIA FOR AIRPORT

TRAFFIC CONTROL TOWER FACILlTI£5--FINAL RULE (6 paqes) l

Page iv

11 /15/84 7031.2C

CIUPTER 1. GENERAL

1. · PURPOSE. This order contains the policy and criteria used in establishing the eligibility of terminal locations for terminal air navigation facilities and air traffic control services.

2. DISTRIBtrnon. This order io distributed to the division level in WashiQgton, regions, and centers with a branch level distribution in the

regional Airway Facilities, Airports, Air Traffic, and Plight Standards Divhions aad the PlallDiag Staffa; a li.mited distribution to all Airway Facilities Sectors, Airports District Offices, Air Route Traffic Control Centers, Airport Traffic Control Towers, Flight Service Stations, and International Flight Service Stations.

3. CANCELLATION. Order 7031.28, Aitvay Planning Standard Number One ­ Terminal Air Naviga~ion Facilities and Air Traffic Control Services, dated Septe=ber 20, 1974, is cancelled.

4. BACKGROUND.

a. Since 1951, PAA and its predecessor organizacions have used the establhluent criteria published '-n the a.irwsy planni~ standards as the

primary means of allocating air navigation facilities and air traffic control services. The result has been an orderly distribution of facilities and services at l'ocations where theY' benefit the greatest number of users for the lowest cost to the government cona:l.atent with safety and operational · efficiency.

b. After the establishment of an operational requirement,: air traffic demand determines nearly all requirements for air·navigational facilities and air traffic control services. However, since the agency must operate, maintain, and improve the air navigation system within defined budgetary

li=itations, it is impossible, and it is' not economically feasibl~ to satisfy all operational requirements. The facilities and services must be allocated to locations where the greatest benefit will be derived from their cost . Therefore, a second consideration must necessarily be econord.es. This is a.lso the primary factor in considering improvements to existing facilities or services.·

c. Generally, the total present value of the benefits over the life cycle of an improvement t o· a prilllary f acilitY. or service must exceed the total

present value of· the Ufe cycle costs for eatabUsh:mcnt and maintenance of the improvement.

Chap 1 Par 1 Page 1

7031. 2C 11/15/84

~ . Activi ty levels at vhich the pr!nary terl"i nal a1.r navi r.a tior. facilities and air traffic control services either qual ify, beco~e cancli~n tt!s, or do not qualify for irnprovernents, additional facilities, an~/or services nre contained in the c r i teria . 'ihe prieary a t.r navigation facilit ies """ associate air traffic control services are:

(1) Airport ~nrveillance P.adnr System• .

(2) Airport !raffic Control Tower.

(3) l!icrowave Lanc:!ina Systea \11th Approach Lights.

(4) Instrument l~ncling System \11th ~ppronch Li~hts .

(5) Tcrainal Instrunent Approach Sy~tens.

a . 'Incorporates t he current panes of an<' all changes to r·r~er 70~1.2!: . Tha reviaed or~cr contains nc" pagin8tion and follows the current FAA.

c!irecti ves syste"' fc rl!at , but docs not revise previously apr>roved cstablislu:lent or dis continuance criteria nor i nclude any sul-st antive cn,.nces.

b. Updates Appendix 3, Su1111:1ary of "Critical Values", to also provit!e unit economic values in current <!ollars for l!.lP.l , 191'2, on( 1Nl3, in a~c!iti.on ttl l c;ec dollar s .

c. Croups sinilar subjects in cha pters that follou t~e content as published i n the Ff..A's Ainnan'o I nfol'1Mtion Hanuel.

~ . Contnir.s n ~clegation of authority fo r the ~!rector of AviatJon Policy and Plans to issue nonsuhstantive chances. . • &. AUTI;C'P.ITY TC' Cl:AJlGE TliiS c:r.!lr.r.. After coor c'in:otion trl.t,.,. affectetl 'Organizational elemenu , the Director of Aviation Policy and Plans is

author ized to issue changes to this order provltled thf' ehal'l!e& c!o not ·affect policy , a del~gation of authority, an assic~ent of rcsponcioility, or cont8in

stenlfieant unresolved issues .

7. PPLlC•. ";.A shall ~c tercine the eligibi lity of terninal lncatfone for t~e esta blishment, moclification, or discontinuance of t eroinal air navigation

facilities and air traffic control $erv1ccs ir. aceor~anee i•ith the folln.,fnr policy; however, e li81bility cleterninations do not constit ute a c~itrDnt t o

provide such facilities or services.

Public .1\irnor.ts , ns c\efined in the Airport and M.r!·ray 1.nprover.ent Act "· of· 19!!2, are eand!dates for tho various facilities a~ services provi~cd the~ aec t the criteria specifi~d !terein.

b. re"' Pnblie Airr'or ts :and C'thcr Public Airports l'-es1r.nate<' .<1s r.e;:!on~l f.!rports qualif)' for facilities and servic es provide<' t l>.e forec~sts of nctivity nac!e by 'the 'fAA indicate t hat the:! criteria specHied herei n I'Oulc' '1--e

~e t within ~years ~ f ter th~ o! rport hegins operation.

Chap 1 Page 2 Par 4

11/lli/84 7031. 2C

c . Privately=Owued Airport& open to and available for use by the Public which are recognized by and contained vithin the National Plan of Integrated Airport Systems are also candidates for the various facilities and services described herein provided that they meet the sane facility establishment

standards and implementation criteria as those specified for publicly-owned airports, and, in addition, that owner(s) of such airports enter into appropriate assurance& and covenants to guarantee:

(1) Compliance vith that portion of Section 308(a) of the Federal Aviation Act dealing with the prohibition of exclusive rights.

(2) Compliance With anti-discrimination regulations and practices in· · terus of race, color, religion, sex or national origin.

(3) That any fees charged for services shall be fair and reasonable for all typee, kinds and classes of aeronautical uses. ·

(4) Protection of the government invescment and public: interest through continuing operation as public use facilities for long enough periods to pexm1t the amortization of such investment .

(5) Compliance vith the same safety requirements and obstacle clearance c:r1~er1a applicabl e to publicly ovned airports.

(6) That FAA vill be furnished· land without · cost for the construction of facilities.

(7) That compatible land use Will be accomplished where feasible with the land in the immediate vicinity of the airport.

(8) That there will be compliance with the equal opportunity clause of Executive Order 11246.

NOTE: For additional details and the operations•agreement formnt, • refer to Order 6030.40, FAA Policy for Receiving Assurances When Establishing P&E Facilities at Privately O..aed Publlc-{)se Airports.

d. Military Facilities. FAA acquisition and operation of military facilities Will be covered by arrangements between DOD and FAA. No FAA facility vill be established where an existing military facility 'satisfies FAA operational requirenents.

·.

Chap 1 Par 7 Page 3

703l.2C 11/15/84

e. Establishment of Air Navigation Facilities and Air Traffic Control Servi ces.

(1) Candidacy and Qualification under Air Traffic De~ud Criteria. An airport that meets the criteria specified herein for one or more terminal ·air navigation facll1ties or air traffic control services becomes a candidat e location for those facilities or ~ervices . It becomes qualified ·for the

establishment of the particular facilities or servi ces ~hen :

(a) It meets the criteria specified herein for three consecutive FAA annual counts. ( An FAA annual count is a fiscal year or a calendar year activity SUilllary. Where actual traffic counts are unavailable or not recorded, adequate.ly docWlented FAA estimates of the demand for the facility or service may be used), and

(b) It is recommended by a regional director as necessary to satisfy an operational requirement and u economically just.ified by a · cost/benefit study, and

(c) The recommendation of the regional director is concurred with by the Administrator.

(2) Remote Locations . When the qualifying criterion is a benefit/cost ratio, and the proposed site is a remote location as defined in Appendix 1, Remoteness - Compensation for Benefit/Cost Criteria, t~e

evaluation required by paragraph 7e(l)(b) will be based on the remoteness- cocpensated benefit/cost ratio. This does not affect the candidacy standards, which apply equally to remote and non-remote sites .

(3) Exception to Air Traffic Demand Criteria. If the community served by an airport is identified in a federally approved economic devel opment program, such as the "ne~ communities" progran of the ~partment

of Housing and Urban Development, the airport may be considered fot establishment of a single-equipment instrument approach system, or may be considered a candidate for TVOR. or LDA without meeting the requirements set forth in the subsequent paragraphs of t his order.

(4) Reexamination Prior to Survey or Construction. FAA ~ill, prior to the start ·of surveys or construction for the establishment of a new facility or service, reexami.ne the basis on which the project ~s justified. If the eligibility factors have changed or are expected to change

significantly, such as discontinuance of air carrier services, closing of a military base, new airport plans, etc., either prior to or after budgetary . approval, the region shall advise the Office of Management and Budget of the

situation and its reeoaaendations promptly.

Cliap 1 Page 4 Par 7 ·.

---

11/15/84 7031. 2C

£. Discontinuance of Air Navigation Facilities and Air Traffic Control Services. Whenever the activity level of an air navigation facility or air traffic control service falls to or below the discontinuance criteria specified herein, or if factors other than activity level were used to justify establishment and these cease to exist or change significantly, the facility or service is a candidate for decommissioning. If the activity level remains at or goes below the discontinuance level for three consecutive FAA counts,

the facility or service shall be discontinued unless its retention can be specifically j ustified . If the discontinuance criterion is a benefit/cost ratio, and the facility is remote as defined in appendix 1, eYaluation will be based on the remoteness-compensated (benefit enhancement only) benefit/cost ratio.

8 . SCOPE.

a . The Federal Aviation Administrator is empowered to provide air navigation facilities and air traffic control services to insure efficient util ization of the navigable airspace and t he safe and expeditious flow o£ air

traffic. To discharge this r esponsibility the FAA provides terminal facilities and services at airports to assist aircraft i n starting and

terminating their flights. This· order contains criteria f or the establishment o£ the· various terminal air navigation facilities and air traffic control services provided by the agency and funded through the facility and equipment

(F&£) appropriation. Criteria for other air navigation facilities and air traffic control services are contained in the appropriate airway planning standard or agency directive. ·

b. The criteria contained herein are primaril y based on air traffic demand since volume of traffic is a tangible and measurable indication of the need for air navigation facilities and air traffic control services. They do not, however , cover all situations which may arise and shall not be used as a sole determination in denying a location a terminal facility or service for which there is a demonstrated operational or air traffic control requirement . Similarly, air traffic demand does not by i tself always constitute a requirement for an air navigation facility or air traffic control service .

c . A true aeronautical requirement may exist for facilities and/or services that cannot be measured with reference to the volume of air traffic activity alone. Other factors wherein a fixed requirement cannot be established which must also be considered are the general terrain features in the vicinity of the terminal, the nature of the operation, and the frequent and predictable occurrence of severe climatological phenomena such as heavy snow, ice, f og, or other local conditions that can adversely affect aircraft operations or the safety of the flying public.

Chap 1 Par 7 Page 5

ll/15/84 7031.2C

d. Non-Federal Terminal Facilities. Non-Federal terminal air navigation and approach aids and air traffic control faci lities purchased and installea by other than the Federal Government ~ay be eligible for inclusion in the National Airspace Syst em. FAA will assume ownership, operation, maintenance, and logistic support of equipment and facilities provided appropriate TAA standards and requirements, as out l ined in applicable agency directives, are met .

e. Criteria for Provision of Electrical Power. Criteria for the provision of electrical powe~ configurat i on at National Airspace System facilit ies is contained in Order 6030.20C, Electrical Power Policy. This order prescribes the power configuration and characteristics of power systems which are standard for various types of operating conditions, Guidance for t he uniform implementati on of Order 6030.20C is contained in ageocy Order 6950.28, Electric Power Policy lmpleaontation at National Airspace Systen Facilities.

·f. Summaries of Criteria and Critieal Econocic Values. The establishment and discontinuance criteria and the critical economic values utilized in the development of i nvestment criteria are summarized in the following appcndiceD

to this order:

( 1) Appendix 2, Summariy of Establishment and Discontinuance Criteria.

(2) Appendix 3 , SUlllllary of "Critical Values."

9.- 19, RESERVED.

Chap 1 Page 6 ( t hru 10) Par 8 -·

2/10/86 7031. 2C CHG 1

CHAPTER 2. NAVIGATION AIDS

SECTION 1. AIR NAVIGATION RADIO AIDS

20. MICROWAVE LANDING SYS"rEM ( HLS) lliTH APPROACH LIGHTS.

a. Establishment . A runway where scheduled turbojet operations are conducted on a sustained basis and are expected to continue without long periods of interruption, or any runway or heliport not currently equipped with an operating precision approach system and meets the annual instrument approach criteria in pa.ragraph 20b, is a candidate for MLS Iilith an approach light system

for Category I operation as provided 1n paragraphs 20a(l) through 20a(3) . * Note that Supplemental MLS Criteria apply to in.itial establishment at commercial service airports, paragraph 20d, and relt'ever airports, paragraph 20e. *

(1) A coaprebcnsive evaluation of the runway to be served by the MLS indicates that i t meets applicable FAA airport design and operational standards and that the opera.tions to b-e conducted will be safe and the cype( s) of aircraft vhich will use or are forecast to use ·the MLS can be accoamodated

safely. Furthermore, it must be technically feasible and practical for the airpor t sponsor ~o protect the MLS critical areas.

(2) Runway length and width dimensions are in accordance vith FAA policies and directives. At a minimum, a runway must be 4200 feet long and 75 feet wide in order to receive an MLS. these criteria do not apply to heliports or short-take-off-and-landing (StoL) runways . The required heliport or STOL runway dimensions will be in accordance with FAA policies and

directives.

(3) Approved runway and heliport l ights must be installed or programz>ed.

b. Annual Instrument Approach (AlA) Criteria. An airport that meets the provisions of paragraph 20a is a candidate for MLS with approach l i ghts when

the annual instrument approaches recorded for the runway on which the MLS is to be installed aeet or exceed the following cond1Uons :

Chap 2 Page ll Par 20

i; 7031. 2C 11/15/84

MLS Qualifying (R~quired) AlA Count for Stated

Non-Pr~cision A22roach Miutmums User Category 3oo-3/4 400- 3/4 400- 1 500- 1 600-1 800- 1

Ai.r Carrier

Hub 500 250 200 150 iOO so Non Hub 900 500 400 300 200 100

Ai.r Taxi 500 475 450 400 350 300

Oeneral Aviation 2700 2300 2000 1700 1400 900

Military 1100 1000 900 BOO 650 450

NOTE: The AIA levels apply only when the MLS vill give aiuiauas of 200-1/2 or the equival ent; i f other minimums are achi evable, consult with the Office of Aviation Policy and Plane (APO) to determine procedures

(criteria) that are applicable. ·.

(1) To determine whether an airport meets the Phase I or annual instrument approach (AIA) criteria contained in paragraph 20b:

(a) Determin~ the lowest non-precision approach minimums currently authoriud for the largest aircraft using the runway in question, e.g. , 50D-l.

(b) Reference the above table to seiect the qualifying number of AIA' s on the candidate runway for each uce.r category, e .g. , Air Carrier Hub-150 , Air Taxi- 400, General Aviatioa-1700 , Military-800.

(c) Estimate the number of recorded AIA' s on the candidate runway by one of tb~ following procedures:

1 An on-cite survey of lFR activity on the candidate runway.

2 Estimate the percentage of total airport AlA's on the candidate runway. Multiply total AlA's by this percentage to determine the runway AlA's. If specific data are not available, use 70 percent for the

initial precision approach runway, 25 percent for the second precision approach runway . For third and subsequent runways a cit• •urvey of projected lFR runway usage will be required .

l Use the AlA estimating model developed tu Report FM-AP0-83- 10, Establishlllent and Discontinuance Criteria for Precision Landing

Systems.

Chap i

Par 20 Page 12

7031.2C 11/15/84

(d) Enter estimated recorded and required AlA's for the candidate runway as indicated below. The contributions of each category to~~rd meeting the criteria are summed. A runway with a total ratio of 1.0 or more · meets the AlA Phase I criteria for MLS establishment.

User Category

Air Carrier Recorded AlA's *" X aX:X Required AIA's

Air Taxi Recorded AlA's a. x.xx Required AlA's

General Aviation Recorded AlA's c x.xx Required AIA's

Military Recorded AlA's = x.xx Required AlA 's

Total Ratio x.xx

c. Benefit/Cost Screening. MLS candidates identified by the criteria specified in paragraph 20a will be screened in FAA headquarters using the

benefit/cost technique described in Report FAA-AP0-83-10 , Establis~ent and Discontinuance Criteria for Precision Landing SyStems . FAA regional offices shall submit data required for screening purposes as specified in the Annual Call for Estimates. Establishment of MLS also may be justified when documented benefits exist. The justification and expected benefits of operations based on

the following additional capabilities must be documented for each location:

(1) Resolve airspace conflicts be~een two airports duri ng IFR operations.

(2) Reduce delays encountered in approach and/or departure operations under IFR conditions.

(3) Provide different approach paths for various aircraft weight classes to rel ieve Qake vortex restrictions.

(4) Provide for other operations which may increase airport capacity or significantly reduce noise impact.

(5) Provide , by establishment of MLS networks, demonstrabl e improvement in user operating reliability or operating efficiency.

Chap 2 Par 20 Page 13

'··

7031. 2C CliG 1 2/10/86

* d. Supple~~~ental MLS Criteria for Commercial Service Ai rporu.

(1) Establishment. A runway at a commercial service airport (defined by the Airport and Airway Improvement Act of 1982 to mean " .••a public airport which ic determined by the Secretary to enplane annually 2,500 or more passengers and receive scheduled passenger servico of aircraft.") wich meets the technical considerations of paragraphs 20a(l) , 20a(2), and 20a(3) but vhich fails to satisfy paragraph 20c ~~ay qualify for an initial MLS establisbllent under the conditions which follow.

(a) A commercial service airport is a candidate for KLS (meets Phase I Supplementa.l Criteria) wben the runway on which che MLS is co be

installed meets or exceeds the following requ~rements:

1 The commercial service airport has connecting scheduled passenger service to an associated major hub airport (small, medium, or large hub). Such service should have existed for at least the previous 3 consecutive years and be reasonably oxpect:ed to continue.

2 Agency forecasts for the commercial service airport should indicate that total annual enplaned passengers (in scheduled and nonscheduled service) are not: expected to fall below 2,500.

3 The commercial service airport does not have a precision landing system and has not been programmed for one.

~ The commercial cervice airport and its associated major hub a~rport have a combined Phase I total ratio greater than or equal to 1. To determine the combined total ratio:

(aa) Determine the Phase I total ratio for the commercial service airport according to paragraph 20b.

(bb) Determine the Phase I total ratio for the primary runway--runway with the most instrument approaches--at the associated major hub airport according to paragraph 20b.

(cc) Sua the ratios for the co~ercial service airport and its associated major hub airport and divide by 2.

(b) A commercial service airport identified in paragraph 20d(l) is qualified for an MLS (meetc Phase II Supplemental Criteria) when the com:aercial service airport and tbe priiiUiry run'ilBy of its aceociated major hub airport have a combined Phase II total ratio greater than or equal to 1, where

the combined ratio is defined as the sum of the benefits at the two airports (as calculated in Report FAA-AP0-83-10, Establishment and Discontinuance Criteria for Precision Landing Systems) divided by the sum of their life cycle costs.

( 2) Discontinuance. An MLS established under this paragraph shall be considered for discontinuance as follows. *

Chap 2 Page 11. Par 20

2/10/86 7031. 2C CBG 1

* (a) An KLS at an airport continuing to receive connecting scheduled passenger service to an asaociated aajor hub airport shall be a candidate for discontinuance if the combined Phaca t benefit/cost ratio drops

below .3 for 3 consecutive years. The decommissioning of an KLS shall be justified by a benefit/coat atudy which considers the combined benefits and coste generated by KLS at the commercial service airport and the primary instrument runway of its associated major hub airport.

(b) An KLS at an airport which baa not received scheduled passenger service for the pa1t 3 yeara ahall be a candidate for discontinuance as prescribed in paragraph 20g.

e. Supplemental KLS Criteria for Reliever Airporta.

(1) Establishment. A runvay at a reliever ai rport (as identified in the National Plan of lntegnted Airport Systems) which meets the technical condderatiou of paragrapha 20a(l), 20&(2), and 20&(3) but fails to satiety paragraph 20c may qualify for MLS provided that the benefits of the propoaed establishment exceed the costs. For purposes of this paragraph, benefitQ will be deemed to include not only those enumerated in Report FAA• AP0-83- 10, Establishment and Dhcontinuanee Criteria for Precidon tanding Systems, but also the value of reduced congestion and improved safety at the relieved major airport. Establishment& under this paragraph shall be supported by a staff

study baaed upon quantitative and qualitative analyses and conducted according with established FAA procedures.

(2) Discontinuance. An MLS ectabliabed under this paragraph shall be qualified for discontinuance Yhen the operations and maintenance costs of providing the aervice exceed the benefits derived including the value of reduced congestion and improved safety at the relieved airport. The decommissioning of an MLS ehall be justified by a benefit-cost study. *

!. tLS Replacement with MLS. All required cervices which are satisfied by the ILS Yill continue to be· provided after an MLS has replaced the ILS and for the duration of the requirement. ILS replacement with MLS will be accompliShed in accordance with proviaions aet forth in Report AP0-81-1, Microwave Landing System Transition Plan . Specific quantitative criteria are not provided at this time. BoYever, the Transition Plan recommends

implementation in user netvorka of city bub airports according to hub enpl anements.

g. MLS Discontinuance. The new MLS program must have sufficient opportunity tor implementation and growth that will not be hindered by a premature imposition of discontinuance criteria. The MLS program ohould be fully operational (i.e. , a significant number of HLS's are in operation and 98 percent of the general aviation fleet that flies IFR is equipped with HLS avionics) before MLS discontinuance criteria are enforced. I t is recogni:ed that in the earlier atagea of the program, avionics equipage would be mi~imal. However , as the number of MLS'a increases, the villingness of users to purchase

the necesaary. avionica should increase as well. The general aviation community

Chap 2

Par 20 Page 14- 1

…

7031. 2C 11/15/ 84

is usually alo""r about acquiring nev avionics than are co-ercial user

groupe. Given tbia point, it appears more useful to observe the general aviation equipage rate in evaluating widespread ayatem use. Once the program becomes fully operational 1t is then o:ore valid to put discontinuance criteria in force. The following discontinuance criteria would then apply.

(1) At a runway where scheduled turbojet operations are conducted , the MLS shall not be decommissioned, At a runway where turbojet operations are discontinued and are not expected to resume, the discontinuance criteria in paragraph 20g(2) shall apply.

(2) Runways having no scheduled turbojet operations are candidates for MLS decommissioning when instrument approach activity falls below 30 percent of the qualifying level (i. e . , Phase I sue ot ratio value leas than 0.30) and remain• below this level for 3 consecutive yeara. The decommisaioning of an MLS shall be justified by a benefit/coat study aa docUIIented in Report NUIIber FM-AP0-83-10, Establishment and Discont-inuance Criteria for Precision Landing Systems, and by a review and assess~ent of operational and envi ronmental factors pertinent to the affected locality or

local!t1es •

h. RVR with KLS. The criteri a of paragraph 2lc(l) ahall apply to MLS.

i. HLS Training lnstallationa. Regulations require pilots to conduct flight training on the KLS. to achieve and maintain a high level of proficiency. An airport vithin or convenient to a geographical area eerved by one or more

airports r ecording 200,000 or more annual total operations and 50,000 or more annual instrUIIIent operations aay be selected as a candidate for a training MLS provided the airport is capable of accommodating the types of aircraft uaed to conduct MLS training. Approach lights will not be established until the airport qualifies for an MLS in accordance vith the criteria specified in paragraph 20a.

j, MLS for Noise Abatement. Noioe abatement problems at aome airports, usua],ly .1et tenDinals, may sometimes be alleviated by an MLS to localize and minimize tbe noise created by arriving and departing aircraft. The problem

varies at different l ocations. Tbe j ustification and expected benefits aust be documented in a separate study for each locat ion.

k. KLS for Categorz II/III Operations . Reserved.

21. INSTRUMENT LANDING SYSTEM (ILS) WITH APPROACH LIGHTS.

a. Establishment. Reeerved.

b. Discontinuance. At a runway serviced by ceheduled turbojet aircraft , an n.s will not be decommiasioned unless it 1s to be replaced by a Microwave Landing System OILS) in accordance with Report AP0-81-l, Microwave Landing

System transition Plan. Otherwise, a runway is a candidate for ILS decommi&cioning vhen instrument approach activity on the runway fails to meet any combination of the following conditions:

Chap 2 page 14-2 Par 20

7031.2C 11/15/84

ILS Discontinuance Minimum AlA Count for Stated

Nonerecision Aeeroach Minima User Category 30()-,-3/4 . ,, 4UD-3/4 400-1 50D-l 600-1 80D-l

Air Carrier

Hub 200 100 80 50 40 20 Non Hub 400 200 170 120 85 40

Air Taxi 225 200 190 170 150 llO

General Aviation 1100 950 850 700 600 400

Military 500 400 375 325 275 200

NOTE: These AIA levels apply only when the ILS gives minimums of 200-1/2 or the equivalent; if lesser minimums are achievable, consult with

the Office of Aviation Policy and Plans to determine procedures (criteria) that are applicable.

(1) To determine whether a runway is a candidate for ILS discontinuance based upon Annual Instrument Approach (AlA) criteria:

(a) Determine the lowest nonprecision approach minimums currently authorized for the largest aircraft using the runway in question,

e.g., 500-1.

(b) Reference the above table to select the required minimum number of AlA's on the candidate runway for each user category, e.g . , Air Carrier Rub-50 , Air Taxi-170, General Avlation-700 , Mi!itary-325.

(c) Estimate the number of AlA's recorded on the candidate runway.

(d) Enter the recorded and required AlA's for the candidate runway as indicated below. The contributions of each user category toward meeting tbe criteria are summed. A runway with a total ratio below 1.0 is a candidate for discontinuance.

Chap Z Par 21 Page IS

7031. 2C CHG 2 3/2/87

User Category

Air Carrier •. Recorded AlA's Q x.xx '.Required AlA's

Air Taxi Recorded AlA's • x.xx Required AlA's

; General Aviation Recorded AlA's x.x:x Required AIA' s

Mllitary Recorded AlA's c x.xx Required AlA's

Total Ratio x .xx

(2) Recommendations to decommission an ILS shall be justified by a benefit/cost study similar to that documented in Report Number AP0-83-10,

Establishment and Discontinuance Criteria for Precision Landing Systems, and by a review and assessment of operational and environmental factors pertinent to the affected locality or localities.

c. Supplemental ILS Facilities.

(l) RVR with ILS. * (a) Establishment. A Category I precision instrumented runway (i.e., equipped with a Category I Instrument Landing System or Microwave Landing System) qualifies as a candidate for establishment of a Touchdown RVR

System provided the following requirements are met:

1. An acceptable method is available for immediate dissemination of RVR value data to pilots (e .g., airport traffic control tower, combined station/tower, or where appropriate, a remote approach control

facility); and

2. The provisions of Order 6560.10B, Runway Visual Range, and the siting and Installation standards of FAA-STD-008 can be met; and

3. A Phase I value, computed using t he methodology outlined 1n Table 2lc(l)(a),-equals or exceeds 1.00. *

Chap 2 Page 16 Par 21

3/2/87 7031. 2C CRG 2

* Table 2.1 c(1)(a)

Phase I Criteria For Touchdown RVR System at Category I

Precision Instrumented Runway

User Class Contribution

Air Carrier: ACU + ACITN 145 6,500 • x .xx

Air Taxi: ATAP + ATITN • x.xx 10,000 73,000

General GAAP x.x:x Aviati on : 8,900

Military: · MILAP e. + x.xx 1,900 Subtotal x.xx

x RVR System Design Factor X X.XX

Subtotal x.xx

x Runway Utili zation Factor X .xx

Phase I Val ue x .xx

For each of the first 3 years of operation: ACAP, ATAP, GAAP , and MILAP are the numbars of annual instrument approaches by user class; ACITN and ATITN are t he numbers of annual itinerant operations of the air carrier and air taxi user classes; the RVR system design factor is from Table 2lc(l){b) ; and the runway utilizati on factor is the percentage of total airport operations that can be ex:pected to use the cand.idate runway during instnment weather conditions . If a site-spec.ific runway utilization factor is unavailable and cannot be estimated, the appropriate nat.ional average default value from Table 2lc(l)(c) may be substituted. *

Chap 2 Par 21 Page 16-1

------------

7031. 2C CHC ,:z 3/2/87

* TABLE 2lc(l)(h) ' RVR System Design Factors

System Design No. of Currently of Proposed Existing RVR Systems* RVR Investment of ·this Design Type Factor

"New 0 : 1. 00 Generation" ~ 1 : 3.17 1 ---------------------------------1 I I I I Tasker 500 ~ 0 : 0.60 : * Category I, II, or III.

TABLE 2lc(l}(c) Default Runway Utilization Factors

{Use only i f site-speci fic value is unavailable and cannot be estimated)

Total Number of Precisi on Runway Utilization Instrumented Runways Factor per Runway {%) at Airport (All Categories) _1_ L ..1 … L 2._

1 100 2 61 39 3 45 35 20 4 42 32 18 8 ) 5 41 31 17 8 3

For example, if tbe airport has three precision instrumented runways vith one being Category II and two being Category I , the default

runway utilization factors for the f irst and second Category I runways would be 35 aod 20 percent, respectively.

(b) Discontinuance . An existing Touchdown RVR System installation at a Category I precision instrumented runway qualifies for discontinuance when the Phase I value, computed using the methodology outlined in Table 2lc(l)(a), falls beneath 0 . 40. Discontinuance of a Touchdown RVR' Syst em installation must be justified by a bene-fit/cost analysis (as provided in parasraph 21e(l){e)) and an assessment of operational and environmental factors pertinent to the affected runway. *

Chap 2 Page 16-2 Par 21

3/2/87 7031.2C CHG• 2

* (e) Benefit/Cost Screening. Candidate . ~ways which meet the requirements of paragraph 2le(l)(a) or 2lc(l)(b) will'be screened under the Phase 11 benefit/co~t criteria developed and outlined in Report Number FAA- AP0-87- , ·Establisliinent and Discontinuance Criteria for Runway Visual Rangeat Cat~gory I Precision ·4nding System R~way . · ·rn.

cases where unique site-speci fic operational factors exist that may ' . • I . . warrant special consideration .(e,g., tro~bles~~e terrain features,

significant remoteness of the runway from the tower, e~c,), narrative an~ explanatory reference should be included in' the Annual Call for Estimates .

~· . . *

22. NONl'RECISION IN'STRUMENT APPROACH SYSTEMS.

a. Establishment. An airport a~ which no scheduled air carrier .

turboj~t operations are conducted on a sustained basis which records 200 or 'more annual instrument approaches or 1;825 or more scheduled arinual passenger originations (~ recorded in validated counts acceptable 'co the FAA) is a candidate for one of the two following nonprec1s1on instrument

approach systems (single equipment) when the existing instrument approach procedure and associated navigation aids do not provide landing minimums

of a 400-foot minimum decision altitude (MDA) and one-mile visibility

(400 MDA/1) or better.

(1) Localizer Direction Aid (LDA) System. The basic IFR approach system consists of a localizer and a 75 HRz marker beacon. A basic IFR approach system may be established when:

(a) The existing instrument approach procedure is based on an adjacent VHF navigation aid.

(b) An adjacent VHF navigation aid can be used for transition to the localizer.

(c) A DME (single equipment) may be substituted for the marker beacon provided an individual justification indicates that th~ DME is necessary to achieve the 400 MDA/t minimums or to provide opposite direction approach capability Yhere needed because of wind or traffic considerations. L/MF facilities should not be considered for this requirement.

· (2) TVOR. A TVOR may be installed when:

(a) An instrument approach procedure is not possible from an adjacent VHF navigation aid.

(b) The exis~ing instrument approach procedure is based on an L/MF navigation aid.

Chap 2 Par 2l Page 17

7031.2C 11/15/84

(c) An adjacent VFR naviga~ion aid would not provide transition to a localizer.

(d) A 75MHz marker ba~con may be considered at new or existing TVOR locations provided an individual JU$tification indicat es

that it is necessary in order to achieve 400 MbA/1 minimums. A DKE (single equipment) may also be concidered for new or existing TVOR locations provided that an individual j ustif icatio~ indicates that i t will provide more efficient handling .of traffic, or a reduction of the .adverse effect of obstructions on l anding miminums , or an otherwise tangible improvement in the IFR capability of the airport.

(3) DKE with Localizer/Marker Beacon . . A runway having a localizer and marker beacon but no glide slope is a candidate for DME establishment (single equipment) when the annual instrument approach activity on the runway satis~ieo the activity formula below with a total ratio value of 1.0 or greater.

Chap 2 Par 21 Page 18

11/15/84 7031. 2C

(a) Tabl e 2'2a(3) contains the qualifying nl11llber of AlA's for the candidate runvay for each user category. Instructions are given below on how to use the table and the following activity formula.

User Cat:egory Activity Ratio

Air Carrier: AIA' s on Run<l8y • x.xx Qualifying AlA's

Air Taxi: AlA's on Runway = x.xx Qualifying AIA' s

General Aviation/military: AlA's on Runway = x.xx Qualifying AlA' s

Total Ratio Value x.xx

To determine whether a runway meets activity criteria:

1 ~pute the nbmber of AlA's on the candida~e runway fo r each user category by site survey or by estimating the percentage of airport AIA activity on the runway.

2 Determine: (a) the lowest approach localizer minimums currently authorized, and (b) minimums projected for use with DME for the

largest category of aircraft (i.e., A, B, C, D, or E) consis;ently using the runway .

3 Select hub desi gnation as c:Jetermined by enplanements at the candidate airport.

4 Table 22(a)(3) contains the qualifying number of AIA's on the candidate runway for each user category using the locnliier minimums and localizer/DME minimums developed'in paragraph. If appr oach minimums do not coincide with the values listed in the table, round off to the nearest entry.

5 Enter the computed and qualifying AlA's for the candidate runway in-the formula in paragr aph. The total ratio value is determined by summation. An ILS runway having a total rat:l,o value of 1 . 0 or greater meets the activity criteria.

(b) DHE candidates identified under this subparagraph will be evaluated in FAA Headquarters using the benefit/cost technique described in

Report FAA-ASP-78-7, Establishment Criteria for Distance Measuring Equipment with Instrument Landing System and/or Localizer Approach Aids •.

Chap 2 Par 22 Page 19

0 … , … .., T•ble 22a(l) , … "'

Qua1Jty1n9 ~ IA ' a et LOCal1%or Runways

N N 0 (") uacr HUb Local1%er Ki nta& c;roc2 Siz.e 400 ll2 401 1 ~oo I12 soo 1 600 l/2 600 1 600 1-1/2 'loo 1l 2 7 00 1 100· 1-ll4 700 l-ll2 700-2

LOC/OME

Kin - 300 1/2

AC t..tr9e 67 34 30 21 18 14 10. l1 10 8 7 s

AC Me4i... 92 46 u 29 24 19 14 lS 13 12 10 7

AC .... u 116 58 5l 36 30 24 18 19 17 15 u 9

AC ,.,. lS6 78 69 48 u 33 24 26 22 20 17 ' l2

AT All 1,105 554 488 342 289 232 168 186 158 139 123 ..;

OA/Mi1 All s,e.cs 2.931 %,580 1.8t2 1,527 '1,227 ••• 903 838 736 6$2 460

LOC/Dttll

Min - 300 1

AC Large 81 l4 20 u 12 10 9 6

AC MediUD 111 46 27 18 17 14 12 9

AC ....u 139 58 34 22 21 10 16 11

AC .... 188 79 45 30 26 24 21 ....

14

All 1,327 5$6 122 215 201 172 150 101

OA/Mil All 7,020 2,940 .

l,702 1,1]7 1,062 911 793 537

,

MorE< Localizer .Unim. are ce~ ing an4 prevailing v1e1bi l1ty aatoc!ated v lth the Height Above Toueh~own (HATl. - ... 9 -- …

… "' 00.,. N

~.

"' NN

. .

• •

~9 …

"d "' "'"' user

croup

Uub (au 400 _1/2__ 490 1 5_00 l/2 soo 1

Table 22a(S)4Cont1nued) Qualifylnq AIA't et. LOCalizer ttur.way•

t.oe.aHr.t~r Miniaa 600 1/2 600 1 _600 1 .. 1;.2 100 11~ ~--:?'_00_ )~ _ ?O() 1 - 1/4 700 1-l/2 70-,,-~2 - .... -....- "' -....

"' ~

LOC~

Kin - 400 1/2

AC L.at9• 71 56 32 2S u u 14 12 10 '

6

AC HediUift . 98 77 44 34 26 17 20 16 14 12 8

AC

AC

AT

-u

Non

All .

12)

16,

1,111

96

uo

921

ss ••

525

u

58

' U 3

n ••

310

22

30

209

25

33

236

20

28

196

18

24

169

15

21

141

10

14

100'

00>/KH -­

All 6,197 4,874 2,77S 2,18.$ 1,642 1,107 1,250 1,035 991 777 528

LOC/DNE

Kin - 4 00 1

AC Laq:o 61 21 16 15 13 11 7 .., ....u.... 83 31 22 21 17 15 10

•c ..,

At

GMUl

S.all …

All

All

104

Ul

,998

5,281

46

63 •••

2,152

28

38

269

1,421

26

35

248

1,31.0

22

29

207

1,096

18

25

177

ll6

lZ

16 us ,..

tKn'Et LOC:alher cdntaa are cetli.ng an4 prevailing vJt 1bUJty eaaoebte<l ,Jttl the Hei.9ht Above Touch~ovn (HAT).

.."' "0 00 w .. .... .... N "'

0

('>

7031. 2C C"dC 3 10/20/ 89 .

(4) Visua1 Approach Slope Indicator (VASt) for Straight-in Nonprecis1on Approach Procedure. A F.our-Box VAS! 1113Y be inGtolled as a component to an existing straight-in nonprecision approach facility when the candidate runway

satisfies the following criteria:

Landl"ngs + AlA' a • 1. 0 or nora

14.000 120

Where

Landings • Recorded annual landings on the candidate runvay.

Al A' • • Annual instrument approaches on t he candidat e runway.

(a) to deter=ine the number of l andings and AlA's on the candidate runway, uae actual runway utili zation of the runvay utilization table ehovn in paragraph 3lc(3) .

(b) To accommodate regular uae by long-bodi e• or jumbo aircraft such as the B-747 or C5A vhich are unable to use a standard Four-Box VASI because of their greater vheel-to-cockpit height , a t hird bar may be added, provided Four-Box criteria are aatiafied.

(5) Other Lighting Aids for Nonpreci sion Approach.

(a) An airport at which no scheduled air carrier turbojet operations are conducted on a sustained basis vith a nonpr ecision approach sysrem

installed or programmed which records 300 or more annual instrument approaches, or 2,725 annual passenger originations, i s a candidate for a Kedium Intensity Approach Light System (HALS) provided the instaLlation Yill reduce landing

visibility minlmwns.

(b) Alternatives. An Omni Directi onal Approach Light System (ODALS) may be installed in lieu of HALS if the nonpreci sion approach aid does not permit a straight-in approach or operational conditions require a curved flight path to a specific runway.

(6) RVR for Nonprecision Instrumented Runway.

* (a) Establishaent. A nonprecieion instrumented runway (i.e. , not equipped vith an Instrument Landing System or Kicrovave Landing System) qualifies as a candidate for establishment of an RVR provided the following requirements are met: · l· The airport has one or more RVR-equipped precision

.instrumented runways . To the extent that this includes Category I runways, the f irst and (if applicable) cecon~ Category I rnnvays must be equipped vith and satisfy the criteria for RVR at Category I runYays, as outlined in paragraph 22c(l).

The provisions of Order 6560.10B, Runway Visual Bange, and

the siting and installation sundards of FAA-STD-008 can be aet.

Chap 2 Page 22 Par 22

4/25/94 7031. 2C OlG 9

The ratio of life-cycle benefits co life-cycle costs

equals or exceeds one , based on the benefit/cost methodology outlined in Report PAA-AP0-88-14,

"Establishment Criteria for Runway Visual Range (RVR) System at Nonprecision Instrumented Runway."

(b) Discontinuance. Reserved. * (7) LQEAN-C Nonprecision Approach.

(a) Establishment. Establishment criteria have been promulgated through administrative regulation. The Final Rul e , published in che Federal Register on Augu~t 11, 1993, is reproduced in Appendi x 5, Establishment and Discontinuance Criteria for LORAN-e Nonpreciaion Approaches- -Final Rule . The benefit/cost analysis underlying the Final Rule is presented in Report

FAA-AP0 -90-5, "Establishment Criteria for LORAN-e Approach Procedures. " the regions shall submit site-specific data required to apply the criteria and validate candidacy with their response to the annual Call for Estimates. *

* (b) Discontinuance. A LOR~-C nonprecision approach is a candidate for discontinuance as specified in administrative regulations published in the Federal Regist er on August 11, 1993, and reproduced in appendix 5. *

b . Disc.ontinuance.

(l) An UDA (paragraph 22a(l )), TVOR· (pa ragraph 22a(2)), or lighting system for nonpreci sion approach (paragraph 22a(5) ) at an airport recording less than 100 annual instrument approaches and 1,095 scheduled passenger originations is a candidate for discont inuance.

(2) A DME wi th localizer/marker beacon i s a candidate for discontinuance when the total ratio value formula of paragraph 22a(3) is less than 0 . 6 and when justi fied by a benefit/cost analysis.

(3) A VASI , established as a component of a straight- in nonprecisio~ approach facility, is a candidate for decommissioning when the ratio value computed through use of the formula in paragraph 22a(4) is less than 0 . 50 for one annual count period.

c. Improvements and New facil ities. Existing terminal instrument approach systems frequently require improvements and/or additional facilities. s~ch improvements are usually made only when there Gxists a reasonable relationship between the operational benefit:s to be realized and che costs involved i n accordance with the following provisions:

Chap 2 Page 23 Par 22

703l.2C 11/15/84

(1) A terminal instrumen• approach system wi th 500 or more annual instrument appr oaches or 4,500 or more scheduled annual passenger originations qualifies for those improve&ents and/or new facilities that satisfy an operational requirement or facilitate the flow of IFR traffic at t he airport. A level of 500 or more annual i nstrumant approaches or 4,500 or more scheduled annual passenger originations normally assures a cost per instrument approach that is commensurate with the benefit derived

from the improvement and/or additional facility.

(2) A terminal i nstrument approach system with 200 t o 499 annual instrument approaches and 1,825 to 4,499 or more scheduled annual passenger originations is a candidate for improvements and/or additional facilities that satisfy an operational requirement or faci litate the flow of IFR traffic at the airport provided that the additional cost does not result in a cost per instrument approach that exceeds the benefit derived from the impr ovement and/or additional facilicy.

(3) A terminal instrument approach system with less than 200 annual instrument approaches and less than·l,82S scheduled annual passenger originations is not a candidate for improvements or additional facilities . At that activity level, the additional cost per instrument approach

resulting from the improvement or additional facility is not commensurate with the benef it derived. Any improvements to terminal instrument approach systems at ai rports i n this category will be l i mit ed to the correcti on of a critical situation and shall be justified by an individual staff study.

d. Dualization of lQcal i zer/Marker s or Terminal VORs. Dual equipment may be provided when a study confirms an operational requirement supported by cost versus benefi t analysi s.

23 . VOR TEST SIGNAL <VQTl.

a. Establishment . Installation of a VOR Test Signal (VOT) providing service to one or more airports is authorized when there is no other

reasonable means of complying with subparagraph b or c of Federal Aviation Regulation 91.25. The relocation of a VOT is authorized when consolidation (area concept) of exist ing VOT's can be achieved. However, this consolida­ .tion shall not deprive locations that continue co have a requirement for VOT

signals.

b. Discontinuance . The VQR Test Signal (VOT) shall be discontinued when the installation of a new VOR eliminates t he need for a VOT.

24.-25. RESERVED.

Olap 2 Page 24 ( thru 26) Par 23

11/15/84 7031.2C

SECTION 2. RADAR SERVICES

26. AIRPORT SURVEILLANCE RADAR WITH AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL RADAR BEACON SYSTBM AND AUTOMATED RADAR 'l'ERMINAL SYSTEM (ASR/ATCRBS/ARTS) .

a. Establishment. ASR establishment criteria for FAA approach control towers are two-phased. Phase I is a set of simple generalized criteria designed to initially identify potential candidates . under Phase I an airport ratio value is computed by summing the r elative contributory benefits of ASR. If the airport rati o value obtai ned i .s equal to or greater than 1.0, the

location satisfies the Phase I criteria for ASR/ATCRBS/ARTS establishment. If radar coverage will be provided at or below initial approach altitude at secondary or satellite airports, an area ratio value is computed by summing the airport· ratio values of the airports making up the radar servi ce area. The Office of the Associate Administrator for Air Traffic will determi ne eligible locations under the area concept on a c~se-by-case basis. ASR coveraqe encompassing two or more ai~orts may dictate changes in the operational responsibil~ties within the radar servi ce area. PrUdent management of resources may r equire that radar service ultimately be provided

from that location; regardless of its current facil ity status, which can be

rve the area. · ·

( l ) Phase I establishment criteria and nomenclature are outlined low.

Contributing Benefit Ratio Value

Delay Reduction:

ACPRIM 3,400- ( . 0013 X PRIM)

A'l'PRIM -

•

26,000- (.0096 x PRIM)

GAPRIM = 53, 300- (.0196 x PRIM)

= 8,600 - ( . 0032 x PRIM)

Safety :

ACITN 107,400

ATITN = lO(lO( 539,600

GAITN + GALCL = 847,200

st se

be

Chap 2 Pa<Je 27 Par 26

7031. 2C 11/15/84

MLITN + MI.LCL = x.xxx 376,200

If 1 or greater, location Sum of Ratio Values satisfies Phase I criteria

If the denominator for any user class Tesults in a value equal to or less than ~ero, disregard all denominators and use all of the following instead . For the air carrier user class: 9,300 - ( .0034 x PRIM); for the air taxi user class: 71,200 - ( .0262 x PRIM); for the general aviation user class: 146,000- ( .0538 x PRIM); and for th~ military user class: 23,400- ( .0066 x PRIM) .

(a) ACPRIM, Al'PRIM, GAPRIM, and MLPRDI, for a primary ~~oirport, are the numbers of annual primary instrument operations of the air carrier

(FAR 121, 127, and 129), air taxi (F~ 135), general aviation (PAR 91), and military (FAR 91) user classes, respe~tively. For a qualified secondary airport , these terms are the numbers of annual primary instrument operations of the secondary airport by user c1ass, or the respective numbers of secondary instrument operations by user class of the primary airport associated with or allocable to the secondary airport, whichever are greater.

(b) PRIM, for a primary airport, is t he number of total annual primar} instrument operations (i. e., the sum of ACPRIH, ATPRIH, CAPRIN, and MLPRIM • PRIM, for a qualified secondary airport, is tne n~ber of total annual primary instrument operations of tne secondary airport, ~ the number · of total annual secondary instrument operations of the primary airport associated with or allocable to the secondary airport, whichever is greater.

(c) ACITN, ATITN, CAITN, and MLITN are the numbers· of annual itinerant operations of the air carrier, air taxi, general aviation, and military user classes, respectively.

(d) GALCL and MLLCL are the numbers of annual local operations of the general aviation and military user classes, respectively.

(2) Phase I1 is a site-specific computerized benefit/cost screening process under which candidates identified under Phase 1 are· further evaluated. If an airport benefit/cost ratio or an area benefit/cost ratio of 1.0 or greater is computed, the location satisfies the Phase II criteria for ASR/ATCR.BS/ARTS establishment. The ASR subroutine, integrated into the Terminal Area Forecast Data System, requires the following manual input data:

(a) System acquisition and installation costs (F&A Form 2500- 40, F&E Cost Estimate Sumary).

Chap 2 Page 28 Par 26

11/15/84 70Jl.2c

(b) Percent of time that lFR weather prevails at the propoeed location, if available. For the purpose at hand, U'R weather is defined as weather in wiU.ch visibility is less than 3 miles and/or th" ceilinq below 1,500 feet.

(c) Fraction of the air carrier user class represented b¥ each of the following aircraft type categories:

TUrbofan, 4-engine, wide body Turbojet, 4-engine Turbofan, 4-ongine, regular body TUrbofan, 3-engine, wide body Turbofan, 3-eng;j.ne, reqular body TUrbofan, 2-enginc, wide body Turbofan, 2-engine, regular body Turboprop Piston

If this data is not available from local sources, the Official Airline Guide, or the Terminal Area Forecast Data System, national averages will b& uaod as dofault values in the Phase II screening process.

(d) Fraction of secondary instrwnont operations of each user .; class (air carrier, air taxi, general aviation, and military) of th~ pr~mary airport allocable to each secondary or satellite airport. .. ' NOTE: This data is required only for those secondary or satellite airports that are provided •qualified" radar coverage b¥ t;he proposed candidate airport at or below initial approach ~titude.

b . Oiscontinu<UlCe. Lil<e ASR establishment criteria, ASR discont.inuancet: criteria are t wo-phased. To determine whether an ASR facility mootG'".t!l>e ,.. Phase I discontinuanco critCiria, a ratio value is calculated bf the same sum-of-ratios approach descri.bed above tor Phase I esta}jlishlllent criteria. If the ratio value so obtained is less than 0.35, the location satisfies Phase I discontinuance criteria. ThCI 0.35 fiqurc is an appro~i.motion of the level where the benefits just offset recurring annual operations and maintenance

costs, after allowing for salvage value, relocation costs, etc. Initial aoquisit!on and installation costs arCI irrelevant when an ASR system is being considered for discontinuance since they are sunk costs. LOcations satisfying

Phase I discontinuance criteria will be further screened under the Phase II benefit/cost screening process. If tho benefit/cost ratio so obtained is less than 0.35, the ASR installation may be considered for discontinuance ,

Chap 2 Por 26 Page 29

'· ­

7031.2C_Change_13 Pages__ASP_Reviewed (nj)

12/19/24 7031.2C CHG 13

c. Improvements. Existing FAA approach control facilities equipped with ASR systems frequently require improvements (e.g., ARTS implementation, relocation of facilities to correct siting problems, component replacement, etc.). Such improvements are normally made when the operational benefits expected to be realized exceed the costs involved. Based on current practice:

(1) An FAA radar approach control facility recording 25,000 or more annual instrument operations qualifies for those improvements that satisfy an operational requirement and/or facilitate the provision of terminal area radar service. A benefit/cost study may be required for "major" improvements to terminal radar facilities in this category.

(2) An FAA radar approach control facility recording between 15,000 and 25,000 annual instrument operations may be a candidate for improvements. It qualifies for those improvements that satisfy an operational requirement and/or facilitate the provision of terminal area radar service. A benefit/cost study may be required for "major" improvements to terminal radar facilities in this category.

(3) An FAA radar approach control facility recording less than 15,000 annual instrument operations is not a candidate for improvements. Any improvement to terminal radar facilities in this category will be limited to the correction of a critical situation and shall be justified by an individual staff study.

NOTE: Improvements to FAA-staffed RAPCON's/RATCF's may be considered on an individual basis but the above criteria shall remain a major determinant in considering FAA civil facilities for improvement.

d. Remoted Radar Bright Display Scope. An FAA VFR control tower at an airport, which is a satellite of the primary airport of a radar approach control facility, is a candidate for a remoted radar display scope in the tower cab when:

(1) At least 15,000 annual itinerant operations are recorded; and

(2) Operationally adequate low altitude coverage is assured at the satellite airport.

11/15/84 7031. 2C

e . Termina l Radar Approach Control in Tower Cab (TRACAB) and Terminal Radar Approach Cont rol (TRACON).

(1) Establishment . An initial ASR/ATCRBS/ARTS installation shall be a TRACAB facility consisting of appropriate displays placed i n the tower cab eKcept when any of the fol low~ng situations prevail:

(a) If t he official agency forecasts indicate an ASR/ATCRBS/ARTS candidate location will eKceed 125, 000 annual i t inerant

operat i ons or 60,000 annual i nstrument operations within 2 years of t he year of budget s ubmission for the facilit y, the initial installation should be planned a~ a TRACON rather than a TRACAB, s ubject t o an operational

de~e~nation by t he Associate Administrator for ~r Traffic Services . I nstrument operations at secondary airports may be included in this forecast p rovided radar coverage at these locations is expected to exist at or below

i nitial approach al t itude.

(b ) I f an ASR/ATCRBS/ARTS candidate location cannot physically accommodate r adar approach control in the to>~er cab, then indi vi dual.

j ustification shall be required t o go directly to a TRACON facility.

(c) When t he complexit y of t he facility operation warrants , individual j ustification and consideration shall be given t o locating the ~SR/ATCRBS/ARTS in a TRACON rather than a TRACAB.

(2) Discontinuance . ~ TRACAB will be discontinued when the ASR system is decomrndssioned or when the radar approach control f unction is

transferred t o a TRACON.

(3) Conversion to TRACON . ~ TRACAB location is a TRACON candidate when the facility has at least 125, 000 annual itinerant operations or

60, 000 annual inst rume nt opera tions. Instrument operations a t s e condary airports that receive radar service at or below initial approach alti tude may be incl uded in t his count. Also, when the compl exity of the facil ity

warrants, individual j ustifi cation and consider ation should be given to relocati ng from a TRACAB to a TRACON.

27. PRECISION APPRO~CH RADAR (PAR). Reevaluation of the usefulness and util iza tion of existing PAR facilities indicates that the benefits being der i ved by civil aviation at some airports are not commensurate with the

cost of p~oviding the s ervice. No stated require~nt exist s for P~ servi ce in f ut ure r educed minimal instrument landing systems. Therefor e, PAR f acilities l-till be retained or established only at t hose ai rports where pe culiar circumstances or a mi1itary requixement j ustifies the need for PAR

services. This determinat i on will be based on individual evaluation of requirements peculiar to a specific location. Such an evaluation will consider airport complexity, military requirements, and the need for a backup or s upplement to t he primary instrument approach systems.

Chap 2 Page 31 Par 26

7031 . 2C CHG 12 8/17/99

• 28. NON-FEDERALLY Ol'iNED AIRPORT SURVEILl.J\NCE RADJ>.H {ASR) .

a . The Fl'.J>. wi l l consider making capital and staffing i nvestments at Fl'.l'. air traffic control facilities to facilitate a non- Federal radar installation if t he followi ng criteria in paragraphs 26a(l) through 26a(3) are satisfied:

(1) The non- Federal ASR meets recognized aviation standa rds and complies with current FAJ>. design and performance specifications.

(2) The benefits to airspace users equal or exceed FAA investmenc costs, quantified in accordance with the logic and procedures outlined in Report Number FAA-APo-83- 5, Investment Criteria for Airport Surveillance Radar.

(3) The release and use of radar daca to outside interests comply with the policy/procedures contained in Order 1200.228, Use of National Airspace System (NASI

Computer and Radar Data or Equipment by Outside Interests.

b . Satisfaction of these candidacy criteria does not entail automatic qualification or commitment of Federal funding . Benefit/cost analysis and screening is but one of several considerations in the FAA decisionmaking pxoceco relative to investment in ASR faci l ities . Inve~tment decisions will be rnade on t he basis of all pertinent cons i derations (e . g., current policy on consolidation of air traffic

services and/or facilities, availability of funds, and extent to which beneficiaries are dominated by specific commercial interests) . T

29. RESERVED .

Chap 2 Page 32 (thru 34) Par 26

11/15/84 7031. 2C

CHAPTER 3 • AERONAUriCAL LlGHTING AND AIRPORT I'.ARJCING AIDS

3 0. RUNWAY END IDENT:LFICA'I'IOO LIGHTS ( REIL) •

a . £stablishment . A runway is a candidate for REIL if:

(1) It is not currently equipped with or p rogrammed for an app roach light system.

(2) I t is lighted and approved for night operati ons.

(3) The Ragional Plight Standards Division !lanager detexm.ines that it hac a runway end identification problem which will be corrected or improved by

REIL, as described in Order 8260.18A, Establishing Requirements for Visual Approach Aids, or as deteDO.ined by the Director of Flight Operations .

(4) Either paragraph 30a(4 ) (a) or 30a(4)(b) ic saeiaf'ied.

(a) RUnways sha ll be REIL candi dates if the runway ratio value, as defined below, equals or exceeds 1.0.

1 TYP" of 9peration Ratio Value

Annual Ai.r carr ier Landings at Airport -= x.xx 4900

+

Annual Ai.r Taxi (Includi ng C""""uter)

Landings at Airport ··= x.xx 1200

+

Annual General Aviation + Military

Landings at Airport = x.xx 7300

Airport Ratio value = x.:xx

RUnway Ratio Val ue • Aizport Ratio Value x Runway Utilization

(REIL' eAJldidate if runway ratio value equals or exceeds 1.0.)

Chap 3 Par 30 Page 35

11/ 15/84 7031 . 2C

2 I f actual runway utilization is not available, the runway utilization may be-taken from the following table. In the row corresponding to the number of active lighted runways at the ai rport, the busiest runway is assigned the first percentage of total landings, the next busiest runway is assigned the second percentage, and so on. After all airport runways have

been ranked accordi ng to activity, the percentage obtained from the table for the REIL candidate runway can be used as the runway uti lizati on factor.

Runway Utili zation (for use if actual data i s not available)

Percentage of Total Landings

Number of lif?ted Busiest Least Busiest Runways=. Runway Runway

2 70 30 4 so 25 15 10 6 30 20 15 15 10 10 8 30 20 15 10 10 5 5 5 10 25 15 10 10 10 10 5 5 5 5 12 20 15 10 10 , 10 5 5 5 5 5 5 5

11 Number of runways refers to the ends of all active hard- surface runways.

(b) Pursuant to the provisions of paragraph 8b, runways not meeting the above conditions in paragraph 30a(4)(a) shall be eligible for REIL

>:>hen exceptional safety requirements dictate. This determination shall be made by the Director of Flight Operations upon wri tten recommendation and

justification by the ,regional director.

b. Di scontinuance. A runway shall be a candidate for decommissioning if the runway ratio value falls below . 5. This provision sha~l not apply to REIL syst ems established in response to exceptional safety requiremenfs. Such systems shall become candidates for decommi ssi oni ng when ~he ruaway ratio val ue is less than .5 and exceptional safety requirements no longer indicate

the need for REIL.

c. Benefit/Cost Analysis. Candidates identified by the above procedure f or either establishment or discontinuance will be evaluated in FAA Headquarters using the benefit/cost technique described in Report No. FAA-ASP-79-4, Establishment Criteria. for Runway End Identification Lights

(REIL). This provision does not appl y to runways that qualify under paragraph 30a(4)(b). FAA regional offices shal l submit data required for evaluation purposes with their responses to the· annual Call for Estimates or with

reprogramming request~ for REIL establishment. Required data consist of: annual operations fo~ air carrier, air taxi, general aviation, and

Chap 3 Page 36 Pa.r 30

7031. 2C 11/15/84

Dilitary users; certification that the proposed runway is not equipped with or programmed for an approach light system; the runway utilization (estimate by

table of paragraph 30a(4)(a)2 if data not available); fraction of time that IFR weather--visibility less-than 3 miles and the ceiling below 1,500 feet- -prevails, 1f available; fraction of operations occurring at night by user type, if available; and certification by regional Flight Standards Division Manager t hat a P~IL correctable runway end identification preble~, as described in Order 8260.18A, Establishing Requirements for Visual Approach Aids, exists for the runway. ·

31. VISUAl. APPROACH SLOPE tNDIC.UOR (VAS!) VFR ONLY. No reduction of IFR (instrument flight rules) visibility minimums is authorized for VASI · installations. Because of tt~ possibilit y for confusion and conflict between an electronic glide slope and a VAS! glide elope, no runvay which bas or is programmed for an electronic glide slope is eligibl e for any Walker Three-Bar VASI system. The Two-Bar VASI may be established on runways with electronic glide slope as provided herein.

NOTE: Criteria in this paragraph do not apply to VASls included as part of the Nonprecision Instrument Approach Procedures.

a. Establishment.

(1) Two-Bar VASI.

(a) Four-Box VAS!. When operationally justified any runway is a candidate for a Four-Box VASI provided that the runway has a net ratio value greater than 1.0, as computed by use of the methodology outlined in paragraph 3lc.

(b) Twelve-Box VASI. Any runway at an international al.rport where there is a stated plannine requirement listed in ICAO (International

Civil Aviation Organization) documents 8733, Ait: Navigation Plan for the Caribbean and South American Regions and 8755, Air Navigation P!an for the Cat:ibhean and South American Regions is a candidate for a ~lve-Box VASl provided that the runway is eligible for, or has installed , a Pour-Box VASI.

(2) Walker Three-Bar VASI.

(a) Walker Six-Box VASI. Any runway 11ay be a candidate for a llallter Six-Box VASI provided that the runway:

1 ls eligible for, or bas installed, a Four-Box VAS!,

2 Does not have an clec tronic gHde slope installed or programned, and

Chap 3

Par 30 Page )7

11/iS/84 7031. 2C

3 Is ~egula~ly used by B-747, C5A, o~ simila~ aircraft unable to use a standard Four-Box VASI because of their greater wheel-to-cockpit height.

(b) Walker Sixteen-Box VASI. Any runway at an international airport where there is a stated planning requirement listed in ICAO documents

8733 and 8755, may be a candidate for a Walker Sixteen-Box VASI provided that the runway:

1 Is eligible for, or has installed, a Twelve-Box VASI,

programmed, and

2 Does not have an electronic glide slope instailed or

3 Is regularly used by B-747, C5A, or similar aircraft unable to use a standard, Twelve-Box VASI because of their greater wheel-to-cockpit height.

b. Discontinuance.

(1) Two-Bar . VASI

(a) Four-Box VASI. A Four-Box VASI is a candidate for decommissioning when it· has a net ratio value less than 0.5, as computed by use of the methodology outlined in paragraph 31c. The decommissi oning shall be justified by a benefit/cost study.

(b) Twelve-Box VASI. A Twelve-Box VASI is a candidate for reduction to a Four-Box VAS! when the stated ICAO requirement is withdrawn.

(2) Walker Three-Bar VAS!.

(a) Walker Six-Box VAS!. A Walker Six-Box VAS! is a candidat~ for reduction to a Four-Box VASI ~hen ~perations using B-747, C?A, or similar aircraft are discontinued on that runway and not forecast· to be resumed, or when an electronic glide slope is installed on that runway.

(b) Walker Sixteen-Box VASI. A Walker· Sixteen-Box, Three-Bar VAS! is a candidate for reduction to a Twelve-Box, Two-Bar VAS! when operations with the B-747, DC-10, L-1011, stretch DC-8, and C5A are discontinued on that runway and .not forecast to be resumed, or when an electronic glide slope is installed on that runway.

NOTE : Criteria for Twelve-Box, Two-Bar VASI and the Halker Sixteen-Box, Three-Bar VASI are .incorporated in Airway Planning Standard Number One to meet ICAO commitments.

Chap 3 Page 38 Par 31

ll/15/84

7031.2C

c . Net Ratio Value Criteria. A runway having any combination of air carrier, air taxi and gener,al. aviation activity is a candi&te for a VASI it it satisfies the net ratio value criteria described below:

( 1) A ratio value for each user class is computed for the airport as a whole, and the three ratios are added to obtain a total ratio value. This total ratio value is then ~ultiplied by the runway utilization (percentage of all operations accounted for by the particular runway) to obtain a net ratio value. If the net ratio value is equal to or greater than 1, then the location is a candidate.

user Cl.ass Ratio Value

Air Carrier : Recorded (AC) Landings - x.xx Qua.lifying (AC) Landings

Air Taxi1 Recorded (AT) Landings - x .xx Qualifyinq (A'l) Landinqs

General Aviation: · Recorded (GA + Mill Landings s x.xx Qualifyinq (GA + Mil) Landings

Total ratio value x runway utilization ~ Net Ratio Value. Sec paragraph 3lc(2), c(3)and c(4) for determination method.

(2) The number of recorded landings refers to the airport's total n~er of landings by user class.· If this traffic info~ation is not actually recorded, the JOOSt accurate available estimate should be used. 'rhe followi.ng sources arc exnmples (source must be cited with data): FAA traffic survey,

Te~nal Area Forecast, regional estimate, or reasonable FAA Form 5010- l

entries.

.. (3) To determine the n~er of qualifying land1pgs seiect from the following table the non- II.S (J:nstrUIRent Landing System) or U.S runway activity that is appropriate to deten>i.ne eligibilicy for a Four-Box VASI syscem.

R!JNWliY ACTIVITY ~ Qualifyi.ng Landings

Oncr Class Non- u .s ~

Air carrier (AC) 6,000 y

Air Taxi (AT) 8 ,500 28,000

General Aviation 14, oo.o 18,500 (GA) & Military (~IL)

11 On an ILS equipped runway, the air carrier ratio value is zero. Air carriers ·are ILS equipped and the VASI serves only as a vi.sual backup for the pilot during final approach.

Chap 3 P<>r 3 1 Page 39

11/ 15(84 7031. 2C

(4} If actual run~ay utilization is not recorded, and no better estimate is available, thE> runvay utilization percentage should be taken from

the folloviog t able. In the rov correspondill8 to the number of active runvays at the airports, the busiest runvay is assumed to have the first percentage of all landings, the next busiest runvay is assumed to have the second percentage, and so on.

Run~ay Utilization (for use if actual data is'not available)

Percentage of Total Landings

Number of. l7ghted Busiest Least Busiest Runways=: Runvay Runvay

2 70 30 4 50 25 15 10 6 30 20 15 15 10 10 8 30 20 15 10 10 5 5 5 . 10 25 15 10 10 10 10 5 5 5 5 12 20 15 10 10 10 5 5 5 5 5 5 5

1/ Number of runways refers to the ends of all active hard-surface runvays.

d. Benefit(Cost Analysis. VASI candidates identified under paragraphs 3la or 3lb above vill be validated using the benefit versus cost technique described in report number FAA-ASP-76-2, Establishment Criteria for Visual Approach Slope Indicator (VASI), · Office.s, services, and regions vill subaoit

the folloving data for every VASI candidate with their response to the Annual Call for Estimates:

(1} Recorded number of operations by user ·class (AC, AT, GA, MIL}.

(2) Number of .wnvays at the airport.

(3) Whetper an ILS is installed or programmed for the candidate runway.

(4) Number and type of VASl'a already installed or programmed for other runways at the same airport.

(5) Ruaway utilization if available.

e. Special Operational Considerations. Offices, services, and regions can nominate special locations for the. installation of ~ VASI in order to

satisfy a speci al safety requirement. Each special location must be justified by a specific staff study at the time of nomination. The staff study format should be in accordance vith Order 1800.7A, Staff Studies.

Chap 3 Page 40 Par 31

11/15/84 7031. 2C

32. RETROFIT OP RUMlAY APPROACl! LIGHTING SYSTEMS .

a. Background. FAA's Approach Lighting Syatcm Improvement (AlS1) Program modifies runway lighting systema huilt before 1975 to meet current installation standards. A major feature of this program is the' retrofitting of rigid light support structures with l ow-impact resistant (LIR) supports . The benefit/cost (B/C) formulae listed below will deten.ine LIR installation priorities. Rigid lighting systems will be retrofitted according to B/C value for each of three subprograms of paragraphs 32b(l) , (2), and (3).

Implementation will continue within approved funding l evels for each subprogram in accordance with the application of these criteria.

b. Benefit/Cost Criteria.

(1) Retrofit ALSF-2 to LIR ALSF-2/SSALR. Conversion of rigid high-inte.nsity approach lighting systems vith sequenced flashers, . Category I~/111 configuration (ALSF-2) to LIR.ALSF-2, switchable to the simpl ified short approach l i ghting system with runway align=ent indicat or lights (SSALR), for use when visibility condit ions pe~t:

Annual Fraction airport air carrier air carrier usage on l/

.:o.!:p.::e..:r;:a..:t::.io::.n::;s;;.,.,,.;x:.,,.:c:.;: a:.::nd::::,:id ~~ru~n::_;w:,;a:~.Y;;;.,~x--:-l:-4.;.•:..:5:..:9;....; a R4t1o Value 'i'a;:te +-=5c=2'-" ,.;.7..:0..:0 B/C Washington + Regional F&E Coat

{2) Retrofit ALSF-1 to LlR MALSR. Conversion of high-intensity approach lighting systems with sequenced flashers, Category I configurat ion {ALSF-1), not designated for ALSF-2 retrofit, to LIR medium-intensity approach lighting systems with runway alignment indicator lights (MALSR).

Annual Fraction • airport air carrier ai r car rier usage on 11 operatfpns X candidate tunwax X 14 . 59 + 132,900 ~ B/C Ratio Value Washington + Regional F&E Cost

(3) l!.etrofit MALSR to LlR HALSR. Retrofit of rigid HALSR to LIR MALSR vith no other improvements:

Annual Fraction airport air carrier air carrier usage on operations x candidate runQay!! x 14. 59 • B/C Ratio Value

Washington + Regional F&E Cost l/ Air carrier usage should include activi ty at both approach and departure ends for runways having rigid lighting systens at opposite ends.

Chap 3 Par 32 Page 41

11/15/84 7031.2C

c. Nonstandard Approach Lighting System Conversions. Requests for LIR conversion of approach lighting systems not included as part of the ALSI

program trl.U be considered on a case-by-case basis. '11herever possible, the procedure described in Report PAA-ASP-78-5, Installation Criteria for the Approach Lighting System Improvement Program, shall be used to rank

nonstandard conversions ~th lighting system retrofits approved under ~he program.

d. Exceptions to Benefit/Cost Criteria. Priority consideration shall be given for LIR conversion of rigid 4ppro4ch lightins systecs which fail to

comply with obstruction clearance criteria contained in Order 6850. 2, Vi~ual Guidance Lighting Systems, and vhere such obstructions can be eliminated at

the time of retrofit . LIR retrofit shall n~~ conwence at other locations naving intervening structures or topography which may othervise negate safety benefits provided by frangible l ighting systems. In such instances, renedinl action oust be initiated before retrofit approval. ·

e. Regional Data Submission. P~giooal offices shall rank ALSI e~ndidates according t o benefit/cost ratio value in response to the annual Call for

Esticates or with reprogramming requests using the formulae in paragraph 32b. Regions shall consult the Call for Estimates for the typical Washington office

or acrvice F&E costs for insertion in B/C formulae when specific Washington office-furnished equipment costs are not available. Regions shall also indicate if there are exceptions to benefit/cost ranking cr-iteria under the provisions of paragraph 32d.

33.-39. RESERVED.

Chap 3 Page 42 (thru 46) Par 32

2/5/91 7031.2C CHG 6

CHAPTER 4. AIR TRAr'FIC CONTROL

40. FAA AIRPORT TRAFFIC CONTROL TOWER. * a. Establishllent. Establishment criteria have been promulgated through a~oistrative regulation. The fiaal rule, published in tbe Federal Register on January 3, 1991, is reproduced in Appendix 4, Establishment and Discontinuance Criteria for AiTport Traffic Control rover Facilities-Final Rule. The benefit/cost analysis underlying the final rule is presented in Report FAA-AP0-90-7, "Establishment and Discontinuance Criteria Por Airport Traffic Control Towers." The regions shall submit site- specific data required to apply the criteria and validate candidacy with their r esponse to the annual Call For Estimates.

b. Discontinuance. Discontinuance criteria have been promulgated through administrative regulation. The final rule, published in the Federal Register on January 3, 1991, is reproduced in appendix 4. The benefit/cost analysis underlying the final rule is presented in Report FAA-AFo-9o-7, "Establishment and Discontinuance Criteria For Airport Traffic Control Towers." Tbe regions shall

submit site-specific data required to apply the criteria and val idate candida~y vith their response to the annual Call For Estimates. *

41. APPROACH CONTROL SERVICE.

a. Establishment. Approach control service may be implemented by an FAA control to~er at an airport having a radio navigational aid that is suitable for bolding purposes or an approved approach procedure, or if the airport has an ILS

installed or programmed, provided that the service can be implemented vitbin the existing resources of the facility. This servi~e may be extended to an adjacent airport within 30 n.m. using direct or indirect communication• if air/ground coverage exists at the final approach altitude over the navigational aid serving

the adjacent airport. Communications equipment (VHF and/or UHF, as required) necessary to provide a discrete approach control channel ond associated landlinec may be requested when :

(l) At FAA Tower Airport . 5,000 or more annual iustru=ent operationc are recorded or the airport has an ILS installed or programmed.

(2) At Adjacent Non-Tower Airports. 1,500 or more annual instrument operations or 1,825 or more scheduled annual passenger originations (as recorded

in Airport Activity Statistics, CAB/FAA, or other counts acceptable to the FAA) are recorded and the airport is within 30 n.m. of the approach control facility.

Chap 4 Par 40 Page 47

7031. 2C 11/15/84

b. Discontinuance. Approach control service that was made available within existing resources may continue to be provided regardless of activity if it

facilitates operational safety or efficient utilization of airspace. Additional facilities required for the provision of approach control aervi~e under paragraphs 41a(l) or 4la(2) are candidates for decommissioning when:

(1) At FAA Tower Airports. 3,500 or less annual instruoe.nt operations and 1,095 or less scheduled annual passenger originations are recorded.

(2) At Adjacent Non-Tower Airports. 1,000 or less annual instrument operations and 1,095 or less scheduled annual passenger originations are recorded .

42. COMBINED STATION/TOWER (CS/T).

a. Establishment. CS/T ' s are established at FAA tower locations where there is a requirement for 24 hour staffed, air/ground en route communications services that are normally associated with FSS functions. the number of existing and programmed CS/T facilities adequately satisfies that requirement.

b. Separation of CS/T's. the station functions of a CS/t will be separated

fro~ t he FAA air traffic control tower:

(1) in conjunction with the establishment of radar approach control which will be provided from the cover cab; or

(2) when the air/ground en route communications services can be provided remotely by an adjacent FSS and separation of the facility will result in a positive cost/benefit; or

{3) when increased activity, personnel, and equipment at the CS/ T have overcrowded the tower cab to the point where the required operating positions

cannot be accommodated in the space available; or

{4) when the air/ground en route communications service that are normally associated with FSS functions are no longer required for adequate communications coverage.

Chap 4 Page 48 ( thru 50) Par 41

6/1/9~ 7031. 2C OiG 10

4 3 . TERMINAL EN RQQTE CONTROL SI!RVICB.

a. Eptablishment. Tower en route control service may be escablished betwe-en two adjacent: approach cont.rol facilities whose control areas share a common boundary and when t he operational be.nefit will outweigh any possible operational penalties r esulting from the allocation of altitudes

for the service, provided:

(l) The service can be established within the resources currently allocated to the facility, and:

(a ) There are f ive or more IFR peak day flights exchanged.

{b) Air/ground communication coverage exists along the entire routelsl at the altitude(s) involved by either direct means from the tower en route control facilities or by relay through an FSS or company radi o.

(c) Landlines exist bet ween tho tower en route c ontrol facilities .

{d) Sufficiently trained personnel are ava~lable to assume the tower en route control function .

(2) Additional communications and/or landlines required to provide tower en route control service may be requested when the volume of

n·R peak day traffic exchanged between the approach control facilities exceeds 25 flights .

b. Discontinuance. Towor en route sarvice provided wi thin existing resources as outlined in paragraph 4la(1) may be continued as long as an operationAl benefit results. llhen the volume of IFR peal< day t:raffic exchanged between the approach control facilities is less than 10 flights, the additional comnunications equipment and/or landings provided under paragraph 43a!2l are candidates for decommissioning.

44 . AIRPORT SURFJ\CE DBTECT:ION BOOIPMBN'f (ASDEl .

• a. iBtahlishtpcpt:. An PAA towered airport qualifies as an establishmen t candidate for J\SDB: ·

(1) i f tho present value of inc;emental life-cycle benefits OJ<ceeds the present value of in=emenca,l life-cycle costs, using the benefit -cost me thodology outlined in Report N~r FAA·AP0-93· 12,

•Establishment Criteria for Airport Surface Detection Equipment (ASDB) III'; or .

(2) for those locations which do not qualify under paragraph 44a (1), the locatio~ may still qualify for an ASDB if the Administrator determines that an aeronautical requirement exists due to

operat ional or safety factoro, such as runway configuration, military ope~ationo , historical record of h1gh ' incidence of runway incursions, frequent and predictabl e occurence of severe climatological phenomena

such as heavy snow, ice, fog, or other· local conditions that can adversely a!tect aircraft operations or the safety of t he flying public . *

Chap 4 Page 51 PM 43

-

7031.2C CRG 10 6/1/94

b. Discontinuance. .An ASDB will be subject to discontinuance: *

(~) ~f the present value of the continued cost of operation and maintenance less the cost of termination of the ASDE exceeds the present value of its remaining life-cycle benefits; or

(2) if a previously identified aeronautical requirement is judged to no longer exist.

4 5 . J\!J1'()MATYC Tl!RMIN!\L INFO!!MATIOil SERVICE !ATIS) .

a. Establisbment . An FAA tower airport is a candidate for ATIS if it is a Level II or higher level facility, or records 50,000 or more annual itinerant operations.

NOTE: The Office of Associate Administrator for Air Traffic maintains a current list of facility levels tor each tover which is dotermined by a traffic density measure defined in the air tra£fic control aeries positions c lassification standard.

b. Continued Service. ATIS service may continue to be provided at an air traffic control tower regardless of activity if such service facilitates operational safety or efficiency. ATIS will be automatically discontinued if associated air traffic control servi ces are discontinued.

~6. Alll'OMATED WEl\'Il!RR OBSERVING SYSTEM IAWOSl AND AUI'O~TiD SQRPAC!! Ol!SERVING SYSTJ!M !ASOSl .

a. FAA Towered Ai rports. ~l FAA towered airports where the surface weathor obaervation function is the responsibi lity of the FAA quali fy for AWOS/ASOS establishment, except those locations identified as tower

discontinuance candidates under the provisions of paragraph 40. Priority of AWOS/ASOS establishment will be given to part-time facilities, followed by full ·t:ime facilities, in recognition of the relatively greater benefits of AWOS/ASOS when facilities are closed. Criteria for the establishment and

discontinuance of AWOS/ASOS at non-Federal towered airporto and locations

i dentified as tower discontinuanco candidates are outlined in paragraph 46c.

ASOS will be the ayatem employed at the great majority of FAA towers where FAA

has the responsibility for the surface aviation observation.

b. Plight Service Stat;ions. Where an automated flight service station i s obligated to take weather observations, that: location qualifies for AWOS establishment. Other locations with flight service stations qualify if they satisfy either the provisions of! paragraphs 46a or 46c. ASOS may alao be employed at flight service stations.

c. Non-TowGrod gnd Non-Pgderal Towered Airports. Establishment: and discontinuance criteria .for AWOS/ ASOS at non-cowered and non-Federal towered airports are cwo·phased. Phase I criteria are simple, generalized criteria designed co identity potential candidates initially. Under Phase I a ratio value is computed by summing the benefits provided to each user class and dividing the sum by the life-cycle cost. If t:he ratio value obtained

ll/15/84 7031.2C

i s equal to or g reaeer than the thresholds specifie d below, t he airport becomes a candidate for Phase I I screeni ng . Phase II i s a site- specific computerized l ife-cycle benefit/cost evaluat ion of candi dates identified in

Phase I using the techni ques described in Report Number FAA-AP0-83 -6, Establishment and Discontinuance Criteria for Automated Weather Observing System {AWOS) .

Chap4 Par 46 Page 52-1 (and 52-2)

11/15/84 7031. 2C

(1) Phase I Establishment Criteria.

(a) Non-Towered and Non-Federal Towered A1 orte With Exist! Standard Instrument Approach Procedures S ) Or With Prospective SlAP With AWOS

Air Carrier and Air Taxi (Lesser of (ACITN+ATITN) or (3,000)) x $25. 38 • ~xxxx

General Aviation and Milita~

Per Itinerant

Operation

Per Local Operation

lUnd Sensor

Temperature/Dew Point Sen~ors AJ.tillleter Sensor Ceiling and Visibility Sensors Precipitation Sansor(s) Thunderstorm Sensor

~ 3.80

• 04 2:16 15.43 • 06 • 01

~ 2.28 .02

•04 • 01

(GAITN+MILlTN)xSTOTAL

( CALCLffiiLLCL) XSTOTAL • xxxx

Phase I Value (If 1.0 or greater, location satisfies Total x AR Phase I Establishment Criteria) LCC

where the terms are as defined below:

1 ACITN, ATITN, GAITN, and MILITN arc the respective numbers of annual air carrier (AC), air taxi (AT) , general aviation (GA), and military (!ilL) itinerant operations; and GALCL and MlLLCL are the respective

numbers of annual general aviation (GA) and military (MIL) loc~ operations. Operations counts may be obtained from tbe "Terminal Area Forecasts"

(published annually by FAA-APO), the Airport Master Record (FAA Form 5010-1),

the Airport Master File (maintained by F~ ' s National Flight D3tn Center), the airport manager, or any other generally accepted source. Values for these activity variables in the Phase II criteria described below-will be derived from the Terminal Area Forecast Data: Systetll..

2 LCC is the applicable life-cycle cost from Table 46a.

3 AR ia 3n adjusting proximity penalty or remoteness premium reciprocal. For candidate airports located in non-precipitous terrain and less than 10 nautical miles from a full-time, non-automated PAA/NWS/INS contract surface Yeatber observati on station with homogeneous weather, ·a

Chap 4

Par 46 Page 53

11/15/84

7031,2C

proxiuity penalty reciprocal of .SO applies. For candidate airports that are located 90 or more nautical miles from the nearest full-time, non-automated FAA/NWS/NWS contract surface ~eather observation station, a remoteness premium

reciprocal of 1. 25 applies . The adjustment reciprocal for all other candidate airports is 1.0.

TABLE 46a

Life-Cycle Cost (LCC)

LCC ~ Fixed Cost of $49,617 + Sum of Variable

Costs Unique to Applicable Sensoring Devices# + $21,535 if System has Longline Communications

8Variable Costs Unique to Sansoring Devices :

Wind $ 1,999 Temperatura/Dew Point 1,615 Altimeter 3,974 Ceiling 41,881 Visibility 28, 517 Liquid Precipitation 1, 367 Freezing Precipitation 3,687 Thunderstorm 23,175

{b) Other Non-Towered and Non-Federal Towered Airports

Air Carrier and Air Taxi {Lesser of (ACITN+ATITN) or (3, 000)) x $25.38 • ~~~

Per Itinerant Per Local . Ceneral Aviation and Hllitary Operation Ope,ration'

Wind Sensor ~ 3. 80 ~ 2. 28 TemperatureiDew Point Sensors .04 .02 Altimeter· sensor .oo Ceiling and Vi sibili ty Sensors . 00 Precipitation Senaor(s) .06 • 04 Thunderstorm Sensor . 01 .01

(GAITN+MILITN)xSTOTAL

(GALCL+MILLCL)XSXOTAL . =

Phase I Value (If 1.0 or greater, location satisfies Total X AR Phase 1 Establishment Criteria) LCC

where the terms are ae defined in par~graph 46e(l)(a).

Chap 4 Page 54 Par 46

•

11/15/84 703l . 2C

(2) Phase I Disconti nuance Criteria. To determi ne whether an AWOS installation at a non-towered or non-Federal towered airport meets Phase 1 discontinuance criteria, a ratio value is calculated by the same procedure for establishment criteria described in paragraph 46c(l) , If the ratio value so obtained is l ess than 0 .45, the system meets Phase I discontinuance criteria .

(3) Phase II Criteria. Candidate airports for ·AWOS identified by the above criteria will be evaluated by the eomputerized benefit/cost subroutine developed in Repor t Number FAA-APQ-83-6. If a benefit/cost ratio of 1.0 or greater (for establishment) or les• than .45 (for discontinuance) is computed ,

the airport becomes a candidate. The subroutine requires the following supplemental site-specifi c data :

(a) System acquis ition and installation costs (FAA Form 2500-40, F&c Cost Estimate Summary).

(b) Whether or not optional lonaline comMunications are proposed , and if required , the annual coat .

d. Sensor Configuration. The typical AWOS con figuration includes sensors for wind direction and speed , temperature, dewpoint, altimeter , ceiling, vis ibility, and liqui d precipitation . However, AWOS installations may include additional or fewer sensors . For example, a cloud height (ceiling) sensor may not be justified at certain l ocations in close proximi ty to another obs e~vation

site, while additional sensors , such as for freezing precipitation and thunderstorms, may be added if cost effective.

e. Non-Federal AWOS. There will be no takeover of AWOS pur chased and installed by parti es other than the Federal Gover ncent . This provision is an exception to the general policy of paragrAph 8 vhich provides eligibility for inclusion of non-Federal terminal facilities in the National Airspace System with FAA assumption of oQQerahip , operation, maintenance, and logistic support.

Chap 4 Par 46 Page 55 \

..

4/29/91 7031.2C CHG 7

47, ~OLICY ON ADMINlST!ATIVE COM81NATION OF TERMI NAL FACILITIES.

a. Background, A study of the efficiency of administratively combined terminal air traffic control facilities revealed that certain types of combinations derogate rather than improve service to the user. Air traffic control personnel can be placed in a difficult ~sition when the~ apply multiple

fields of speciali~ation on a part-time rotating oasis . This is reason t o consider decombining certain air traffic control facilities.

b. Policy, Terminal air traffic control facilities shall not be administrat1vely combined ,

c, Separation, All combined facilities shall be separated except as follows:

( 1) Tower-RAPCON/RATCC facilities at specific locations designated by the regional administrator as exceptions to this policy.

(2) One tower of a three- facility conplex should be operationall y and administratively separated. The remaining tower-RAPCON/RATCC combinations should be reevaluated as in paragraph 47c(l) , No further "tri-complexea" are authori~ed.

(3) The station functions of a Combined Station/Tower (CS/T) combined with a RAPCON/RATCC shall be physically separated, even though the tower­

RAPCON/RATCC combination continues as an exception as in paragraph 47c(l) .

*48, LOW-LEVEL WINDSHBAR ALERT SYSTEM (LLWAS),

a. Establishment. Provided that a site does not qualify for more than one system under paragraphs 48, 49, 50, and 51, an FAA-towered airport qualifies as an establishment candidate for LLWAS if the present value of incremental

life-cycle benefits exceeds the present value of incremental life- cycle costs, using the benefit-cost methodology outlined in Report Number FAA-APG-90-13,

"Establishment Criteria For Integrated Windshear Detection Systems: Low-Level Windshear Alert System (LLWAS), Terminal Doppler Weather Radar (TDWR), and

Modified Airport Surveillance Radar.· If the site meets t he criteria for more

than one system, t hen the one with the highest (positive) net present value is the qualifying system.

b. Discontinuance. Reserved. *

.: … ... ::.... .: ' : Chap 4 Page S6 Pat< 4 7

4/29/91 7031.2C CHG 7

*49. TERMINAL DOPPLER WEATHER RADAR (TDW!t).

a . Establishment. Provided that a site does not qualify for more than one system under paragraphs 48, 49, 50, and 51, an FAA-towered airport qualifies as an establishment candidate for TDWR if the present value of incremental

life-cycle benefits exceeds the present value of incremental li fe-cyele costs, using the benefit-cost methodology outlin~d in Report Number FAA-AP0-90-13, "Establi&hment Criteria For Integrated Windsbear Detection Systems: Low-Level Windshear Alert System (LLWAS), Terminal Doppler Weather Radar (TDW!t), and Modified Airport Surveillance Radar. · If the site meets the criteria for more than one system, then the one with the highest (positive) net present value is

the qualifying system.

b. Discontinuance. Reserved .

50. AIRPORT SURVEILLANCE RADAR (ASR) MODIFICATION FOR WlNDSHEAR DETECTION.

a. Establishment. Provided that a site does not qualify for more than one system under paragraphs 48 , 49, 50, and 51, an ASR site qualifies as a candidate

for ASR codification for wind shear detection if the present value of incremental life-cycle benefits exceeds the present value of incremental life-cycle costs , using the benefit-cost methodology outlined in Report Number FAA-APD-90-13,

"Establishment Criteria For Integrated Windshear Detection Systems: Low- Level WindsheGr Alert System (LLWAS), Terminal Doppler Weather Radar (TDWR), and Modified Airport Surveillance Radar." If the site meets the criteria for more

than one system, then the one vitb the highest (positive) net present value is the qualifying system.

b, Discontinuance. Reserved.

51. INTEGRATED WINDSHEA.R. DETECTION SYSTEMS: LLWAS, TDWR AND MODIFIED ASR.

a. Establishment . Provided that a site does not qualify for core than one system under paragraphs 48, 49, SO, and 51, an FAA-towered airport qualifies as an establishment candidate for an integrated windshear detection system if the preoent value of incremental life-cycle benefits exceeds the present value of

incremental life-cycle costa, using the benefit-cost methodology outlined in Report Number FAA-APD-90-13, "Establishment Criteria For Integrated Windshear Detection SyateDS: Low-Level Windsbear Alert System (LLWAS), Terminal Doppler Weather Radar (TDWR), and Modified Airport Surveillance Radar. " lf the site ueets the criteria for more . than one system, then the one with the highest

(po&itive) net present value is the qualifying system.

b. Discontinuance. Reserved . *

Chap 4 i'ar 49 Page 57 (thru 60) ' ... , _

9/2~/93 7031. 2C CHG 8

•52. HETROPLEX CONTROL FACILITY (KCF).

a. Establisbment. An MCF may consist of a single terminal ra~ar approaCh control facilitY ITRACON) but, more commonly, an KCF will consist of a consoli~ation of several TRACONs. For the purpose of this criterion, a TRACON 'or set of TRACONs, will be considere~ to be a candidate to become an KCF onlY (1) if airspace WhiCh will be under control of the KCF will be

restructured from current TRACON and/or en route airspace, (2) if establishing an HCF improves traffic management, or (3) if establishing an KCF results

Umproved air traffic control procedures. The regions shall submit the naaes of TRACONs which they believe will make Hkely candidates for becoming an HCF. The regions shall assess MCF candi~ates according to an operational screen, Phase I and Pbase II Criteria.

(1) operational screen. Details of the Operational screen may be found in Report FAA-AAT-93-2, "Operational Requirements and FacilitY Investment Criteria for Hetroplex control Facilities (MCF) and Terminal Radar Approach control (TRACON) Facilities,• available from ATR-310. The Operational screen is summarized below:

Ia) The proposed candidate MCF consists of a single TRACON or the consolidation of ·two to seven tRACONs . If more than seven TRACONs are proposed for consolidation i nto an HCF, the proPOsed candidate HCF does not qualifY.

{b) The proposed candidate HCF will generate benefits to the National Airspace System bY the restructuring of terminal or terminal an~ en

route airspace, improved traffic manas~nt, and/or improved air traffic control procedures. If it cannot be demonstrated that at least one of these

three types of efficiencies will be realized, the proPOsed candidate MCF does not qualifY.

12) Phase I criteria. Phase I Criteria are simple tests for identifying possible candidate sites for KCFs:

(a) A proposed candidate MCF passes Phase l Criteria if the previous fiscal year's Air carrier Instrument Operations or Air carrier Enplanements are greater than specific numbers (which vary t>y fiscal year ) . See Report Number FAA-AP0-93-7, "Establishment criteria for Metroplex control Facilities (KCFs)" for the specific values to be used. For decision year FY 1993, the respective values are 432,000 Instrument Operations in FY 1992 for Air Carrier Instrument Operations or 23.3 million passengers enplaned in FY 1992 for Air carrier Enplanement s. •

Chap 4 Par 52 Page &1

7031.2C CBG 8 9/24~93

• (b) If a proposed candidate MCF does not have the volume of Instrument Operations or Enplanements needed to quality under Phase I Criteria as identified in paragraph ~a(2)(a), it still may qual1fY in accordance with

the test in this paragraph:~

Let

AC Air carrier Instrument Operations " ATC0!1 = Air Taxi and commuter Instrument Operations GA = General Aviation Instrument Operations HI = Military Instrument Operations

Then, using the previous fiscal year's actual data on instrument operations as

reported in "FAA Air Traffic Activity• Report; (e.g., Table 9, Instrument Operations bY FAA-Operated ATCT's, TRACONs, CERAPS, 6 RAPCONS by State)

calculate the Phase I £stabl1sbment Ratio sum is:

((a * AC) +{3 • ATCOM) + ly * GA) + e • MIJJ I ~3,600,000

Where the specific values of a, {3 , 'Y , and 8 , vary bY fiscal year. see Report

Num.ber FAA-AP0-93-7, for the specific values to bo used in the Phase I Establishment Ratio sum. For decision year FY 1993, the Phase I Establishment Ratio Sum is:

((100.96*AC) + (11.39•ATCOM) + (3.31*GA) + (9.84*HIJ) I ~3,600,000.

If this ratio sum Is greater than or equal to one, then the proposed site becomes a candidate Cor KCF establishment. Tbere is an alternative to ·tne Phase I Establishment Ratio Sum based on enplanements. (See RePOrt Number FAA- AP0-93-7, for the specific number of enplanements to use .)

~ : Canaidate facilities for MCFs which have already accomplished a study comparing the benefits and costs of consolidating airspace which will be controlled by the candiaate MCF should go directlY to Phase II criteria.

(31 Benefit/Cost Criteria (Phase II). Phase II criteria, detailed in Report Number FAA-AP0-93-7, compare the present value of KCF benefits with the present value of costs over a 20 year time frame, using site-specific analYses to develop the benefits and the costs. A location rteets HCF establishment criteria when the ratio of benefits to costs is 1.0 or greater.

(4 ) Phase I is used to identify a potential candidate and Phase II verifies its economic Justification. •

Chap 4 Page 62 Par 52 "-·. •

9/24/93 7031 .2C CHG 8

• b. Waiver . A location may be exempted from meeting Phase I Criteria. and be considered an estaDlisnment candidate because of other special factors. In these cases a site-specific analysis must be performed and adequate Justification presented to the Associate Aamtnistrator for Air Traffic (AAT- 1 ) for approval . The s ite specific analysis should include, but not be limited to:

(1) Factors unique to the location such as airspace restrictions, weather, seismic conditions, topographY , and impact on adjacent facilities .

(2) specific trend analYsts and/or forecast data that predict significant changes in traffic activitY attributable to unique local conditions, thus necessitating replacement or refurbishment of an existing

facility .

(3) Military requirements.

c. Discont inuance . Approach control service that was available within existing resources may continue to be provided regardless of act ivity if tt facilitates operational safety or efficient utilization of airspace. Based on the history for the formation of these facilities, it is hiBhlY unlikely that

it will be more operationally or economically advantageous for an MCF to cease rather than continue operation. In the event that unique circumstances exist, t he regions will identifY any MCF candida~e for discontinuance of service or decommissioning based on a si~e-specific operational and economic analysis . •

Chap 4 Par 52

912'ol93 7031.2C CBG 8

* 53. TER!!INAL RADAR APPROACH CON'IROL (TRACON) FACILITY.

a. Iden~ificat ion and evaluation of requirements to modernize or relocate TRACON facilities will be accomplished in accordance with Order 6480.17, Terminal FacilitY Hodern12at1on1Relocat1on Survey and

Evalua~ion Handbook. Al~ernatives anaLYses will consider the operational and cost benefits or combining airspace and co-loca~ion with adjacent terminal, or

terminal capable facilities as outl1ded in FAA-AAT-93-2, •operational Requirements and FacilitY Investaent criteria for Ketroplex control Facilities

(HCF) and Terminal Radar Approaeb Control (TRACON) Facilities•.

b. FAA Restonal Offices will identify their operational needs and justification during submission of the annual F&E budget call response to FAA Headquarters. Order 6~80.17 will be used to determine tbe proper classification of facility based on cost-effectiveness. Upon approval DY the Associate Administrator for Air Traffic (AAT-1) , proposed projects wlll be considered for inclusion in tbe Capital Investment Plan (CIP) and FAA budget request . TRACONs approved £or funding will normally bY included in existing CIP projects . TRACONs which meet tbe MCF criteria requirements ~ ill be included in existing or new ClP projects. The provisions of order 1810.1F, Acquisition Polley, will be applied when applicable . •

Chap~

Par 53 Page 65 {and 66)

3/17/97 7031.2C CHG ll

• 54 . PRl!CISION RUNWAY MO.'IITORS (PRM) .

a . Establishment . An FAA cowered airport qualifies "" an eseablisbment candidate for PRM,

(1) i f the present value of incremental life-cycle benefits exceeds the p resent value of incremental life-cycle costs. using t he benefit-cost methodology outlined in Report Number FAA· AP0-97-S,

"Establishment criteria for Precision Runway Monieor (PRM)"; or

(2) tor those locations which do not qualify under paragraph 54a (1) • the location may still quali fy for a PRM i f the Administrator determines that an aeronautical requirement exists due to operational or s afety factors. such as runway configuration, terminal

approach procedure~, or dolay at feeder or receiver airports or elsewhere in the Nacional Airspace System (NAS) which can be related to delay at the PRM candidate airpor t. *

Chap 4

Par 54 Page 67 (and 68)