Radar Vectors
FAA Order Cancelled Issued Sep 15, 2023 ACO-100 453 pages Copy saved Nov 18, 2026

Order 5190.6B FAA Airport Compliance Manual - Change 3 (consolidated)

This document is cancelled. Cancelled by 5190.6C. Check the official source before relying on it.

Official source ↗ Open PDF

Text read by OCR from a scanned file (11 of 453 pages). Check the original, as some words may be misread.

Airport Compliance Manual › Explanation of Changes

ORDER

5190.6B Change 3 National Policy

SUBJ: Airport Compliance Manual

1. Purpose

The Airport Compliance Manual provides guidance to FAA employees on the implementation of the FAA’s airport compliance program. Under the program, the FAA has the responsibility to assure airport sponsors comply with certain obligations that arise from FAA grant agreements and from deeds of property conveyance for airport use.

2. Distribution

The Airport Compliance Manual is located on the FAA Office of Airports website where it is available to all interested parties. See: https://www.faa.gov/airports/resources/publications/orders/compliance_5190_6/

3. Cancellation

This Order cancels and replaces the following chapters of the Airport Compliance Manual:

Chapter 16, Resolution of Unlawful Revenue Diversion Chapter 17, Self-sustainability Chapter 18, Airport Rates and Charges Chapter 19, Airport Financial Reports

4. Explanation of Changes

Since 2009, there have been changes to the laws and policies relating to the Federal obligations of airport sponsors and revisions to the procedures for investigating and resolving complaints that allege noncompliance. To incorporate any changes and provide the most useful and current program guidance to FAA employees, the Office of Airport Compliance and Management Analysis is undertaking a review of the Order and will publish updates as the chapter reviews are completed.

The Office of Airport Compliance and Management Analysis issued two previous changes to the Airport Compliance Manual - on December 3, 2021 Change 1 was issued and on December 9, 2022 Change 2 was issued. This Change 3 to the Airport Compliance Manual is issued to address the following:

• After review of public comments offered on the 2009 update, and subsequent experience with using Order 5190.6B as guidance for the airport compliance program, and issuance of Change 1 and Change 2 to the Order, the FAA is now updating Chapters 16, 17, 18 and 19 of the Order.

Effective Date: September 15, 2023

Page ii

• Changes included are editorial, based on suggestions in the public comments or recommendations from FAA staff for more effective ways of expressing policy guidance. In applicable sections of the Order, the revised chapters:

o Add updated references to other FAA guidance documents on the same subject

where applicable. o Add updated references to applicable law where applicable. o Add reference to new grant programs. • In other cases, the Order has been updated to reflect policy changes adopted by the agency since 2009 to remain current with Federal statutes. • When the FAA revises its policy on a specific compliance issue or issues a new policy statement to clarify the agency position on an issue, the agency will issue a separate policy statement after public notice and comment. • Edits and additions to the revised chapters are intended to provide accurate and useful guidance on airport compliance policy for FAA Airports staff, and not to adopt significant changes in compliance policy. As additional chapters are revised, a summary of the changes will be posted on the FAA website. • At this time, all photographs have been removed from the Order as FAA addresses accessibility for compliance with Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act. FAA will review all photographs for Section 508 compliance and intends to include the photographs in a future update to the Order.

• Edits to Chapter 16, Resolution of Unlawful Revenue Diversion, include: o Section 16.1 - Background - is revised to move language that discusses the

responsibilities of the FAA Regional Airports Division and Airport District Office to Section 16.5 Responsibility; also, added a reference to Chapter 5, Initiating, Accepting, and Investigating Informal and Formal Complaints, to assist the reader. o Section 16.2 - FAA Authorization - is retitled to Legislative History and edited for

clarity.

• Section 16.2.b(4) - 1994 Reauthorization Act - is removed as it is appropriately discussed in Section 15.10 – Grandfathering from Prohibitions on Use of Airport Revenue. • Section 16.2.c(2) -1996 Reauthorization Act - is revised to clarify that imposition of a civil penalty is assessed against an airport sponsor pursuant to 49 U.S.C. § 46301. o Section 16.4 - Agency Policy - is clarified to add reference to the FAA’s Policy

and Procedures Concerning the Use of Airport Revenue: Proceeds from Taxes on Aviation Fuel, 79 Fed. Reg. 66282 (November 7, 2014) which formally adopts, through an amendment to the Revenue Use Policy, the FAA’s interpretation of the Federal requirements for use of revenue derived from taxes on aviation fuel. o Section 16.5 – Responsibilities - is revised to include former Section 16.1

discussion of the responsibilities of the FAA Regional Airports Division and Airport District Office; also, added reference to Chapter 19, Airport Financial Reports, and that The Office of Inspector General (OIG) may also conduct audits and issue reports on revenue diversion. o Section 16.6 – Detection of Airport Revenue Diversion.

Page iii

• Section 16.6.a. – Sources of Information – added chapter references to assist the reader. • Section 16.6.b – Reports - the paragraph discussing single audit is removed and the reader is directed to Chapter 19, Airport Financial Reports, for single audit reports. • Section 16.6.e – Interest - is deleted as duplicative with discussion of interest on revenue diversion in Section 16.10.d - Interest. • Section 16.6.f - added subtitle - Published Airport Financial Data. o Section 16.7 – Investigation of a Complaint of Unlawful Revenue Diversion.

• Sections 16.7.b – Formal Investigation - and 16.7.c - Corrective Action – are combined to clarify if the sponsor takes corrective action to resolve the unlawful revenue diversion prior to the issuance of a Director’s Determination the complaint may be dismissed. o Section 16.10 – Civil Penalties and Interest.

• Section 16.10.a – Civil Penalties Up to Three Times the Diverted Amount – is retitled as Civil Penalties. o Section 16.12 - Statute of Limitations on Enforcement - is retitled as Statue of

Limitations on Recovery of Funds. o Other editorial changes for clarification purposes, including updates to citations

and addition of hyperlinks, if applicable and nomenclature consistency.

• Edits to Chapter 17, Self-Sustainability, include: In order to align with FAA’s Revenue Use Policy, some sections of this chapter have been reordered and retitled. Please see the attached Chapter 17, Self-Sustainability, Section Renumbering and Retitling Chart. The sections referred to below are the new section numbers:

o Section 17.2 - Statutory Requirements – is edited to include a citation to FAA’s

Policy Regarding Airport Rates and Charges, 78 Fed. Reg. 55330 (September 10, 2013). o Section 17.3 – Related Grant Assurance and FAA Policies – combines the former

17.3 – Applicability - and 17.4 – Related FAA Policies – into a single section. o Section 17.5 - Airport Circumstances – added a reference to Section 17.9 for

additional information. o Section 17.8 - Revenue Surpluses – added a reference to Chapter 15 for

information on permitted uses of airport revenue. o Section 17.9 - Aeronautical Use Rates - added references to Grant Assurance 22,

Economic Nondiscrimination and FAA’s Revenue Use Policy regarding aeronautical charges. o Section 17.12 - Exceptions to the Self-Sustaining Rule: General – reorders the

exceptions to align with the FAA’s Revenue Use Policy and reminds airport sponsors to use the land in accordance with their grant obligations and property conveyance restrictions, also refers the reader to Chapter 22. o Section 17.13 - Exceptions to the Self-Sustaining Rule: Providing Property for

Public Community Purposes.

• Combines the former Section 17.14 – Property for Community Purposes – and 17.15 – Exception for Community Use –into a single

Page iv

section. • Adds a reference to 49 U.S.C. § 47107(v). o Other editorial changes for clarification purposes, including updates to citations

and addition of hyperlinks, if applicable and nomenclature consistency.

• Edits to Chapter 18, Airport Rates and Charges, include: Some sections of this chapter have been consolidated, reordered and/or retitled to improve readability. Please see the attached Chapter 18, Airport Rates and Charges, Section Renumbering and Retitling chart. The Sections referred to below are the new section numbers.

o Section 18.1 – Introduction - is added to clarify that this chapter summarizes the

provisions of the FAA Policy Regarding Rates and Charges, 78 Fed. Reg. 55330 (September 10, 2013)(hereinafter referred to as the 2013 Policy). o Section 18.2 - Background - added and revised language to be consistent with the

2013 Policy. • Sections 18.2.a and 18.2.c – 1994 Authorization Act - are consolidated into an introductory paragraph. • Section 18.2.a – 1996 Policy – the subtitle is added and a reference to the 1996 policy is provided. • Section 18.2.d – 2013 Rates and Charges Policy Full Text Publication – is added to acknowledge FAA’s publication of the full text of the Rates and Charges Policy. o Section 18.4 – Definitions.

• Combined the former 18.3 – Aeronautical Use and Users - and 18.4 – Definitions – into a single section. • Updated the definitions to reflect those in the 2013 Policy and added citations to the 2013 Policy. • Added a reference to Appendix Z for the definition of “Aeronautical Activity.” o Section 18.5 - Key Concepts.

• 18.5.b is retitled as Not Unjustly Discriminatory. o Section 18.6 - Fair and Reasonable.

• Combines subsections 18.6.a General, 18.6.b Method, and 18.6.c Type into a single subsection 18.6.a - Type. • Subsection 18.6.b – Residual – clarified that cross-credit of nonaeronautical revenue to aeronautical revenue without a written agreement is permissible if transparency is provided. • Subsection 18.6.c – Compensatory – Added explanation of how compensatory rate structures may be imposed and added a reference to the 2013 Policy on this topic. o Section 18.11 – Causation - edited to align with the 2013 Policy and added a

citation to the 2013 Policy. o Section 18.13 - Costs of Another Airport - added a citation to the 2013 Policy. o Section 18.15 – Costs Related to Closing an Airport while Building a

Replacement Airport – combines the former Sections 18.17 – Closed Airport – and 18.18 – Maintenance of Closed Airport.

Page v

o Section 18.19 - Self-Sustaining Rate Structure – combined subsections 18.22.b –

Revenue Surpluses – and 18.22.d – Surplus. o Section 18.20 – Local Negotiation and Resolution.

• Subsection 18.20.c. Alternative Dispute Resolution – added reference to the 2013 Policy which encouraged inclusion of alternative dispute resolution in lease and use agreements. o Section 18.21- Complaints – added a reference to filing informal complaints

under 14 CFR §13.2. o Other editorial changes for clarification purposes, including updates to citations

and addition of hyperlinks, if applicable and nomenclature consistency.

• Edits to Chapter 19, Airport Financial Reports, include: o Section 19.2 - Legislative History is retitled as Statutory Authority and eliminates

the ACO-1 Annual Report to Congress previously required by the Reauthorization Act of 2012 given that ACO-1 provides summary and financial data with its NPIAS report to Congress.

• Section 19.2.c Single Audit Requirements consolidates discussion of the Single Audit from Chapter 16 and updates references to Single Audit requirements as set forth in 2 CFR part 200 as updated by the OMB’s Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards. o Section 19.5 – Annual Financial Reports.

• Section 19.5.c – Filing Date - clarified that if audited financial statements are not available, airport sponsors should complete the forms with available data, and notate they are “unaudited.” Once audited statements are available, then sponsors need to replace the “unaudited” data with the audited data in CATS. o Section 19.7 - Single Audit Reports - added language from Chapter 16 that FAA

has 30 days to resolve single audit findings. o Other editorial changes for clarification purposes, including updates to citations

and addition of hyperlinks, if applicable and nomenclature consistency.

Kevin Willis

Director Airport Compliance and Management Analysis (ACO-1)

Page vi

Chapter 17, Self-Sustainability: Section Renumbering and Retitling

2009 Section

2009 Title 2023 Section

2023 Title

17.1 Introduction 17.1 Introduction 17.2 Legislative History 17.2 Statutory Requirements 17.3 Applicability 17.3 Related Grant Assurance and FAA Policies 17.4 Related FAA Policies 17.5 Self-Sustaining Principle 17.4 Self-Sustaining Principle 17.6 Airport Circumstances 17.5 Airport Circumstances 17.7 Long-term Approach 17.6 Long-term Approach 17.8 New Agreements 17.7 New Agreements 17.9 Revenue Surpluses 17.8 Revenue Surpluses 17.10 Rates Charged for Aeronautical Use 17.9 Aeronautical Use Rates 17.11 Nonaeronautical Rates 17.10 Nonaeronautical Use Rates 17.12 Fair Market Value 17.11 Fair Market Value 17.13 Exceptions to the Self-sustaining Rule: General

17.12 Exceptions to the Self-Sustaining Rule: General 17.14 Property for Community Purposes 17.13 Exceptions to the Self-Sustaining Rule: Providing Property for Public Community Purposes 17.15 Exception for Community Use

17.16 Exception for Not-for-Profit Aviation Organizations

17.14 Exception to the Self-Sustaining Rule: Use of Property by Not-for-Profit Aviation Organizations 17.17 Exception for Transit Projects 17.16 Exception to the Self-Sustaining Rule: Transit Projects 17.18 Exception for Private Transit Systems 17.17 Exception to the Self-Sustaining Rule: Private Transit Systems 17.19 Exception for Military Aeronautical Units

17.15 Exception to the Self-Sustaining Rule: Military Aeronautical Units 17.20 – 17.24 Reserved 17.17- 17.21 Reserved

Airport Compliance Manual › Table of Contents

Page vii

Chapter 18, Airport Rates and Charges: Section Renumbering and Retitling

2009 Section

2009 Title 2023 Section

2023 Title

18.1 Introduction 18.1 Responsibilities 18.3 Responsibilities 18.2 Policy Regarding Airport Rates and Charges

18.2 Background

18.3 Aeronautical Use and Users 18.4 Definitions 18.4 Definitions 18.5 Principles 18.5 Key Concepts 18.6 Local Negotiation and Resolution 18.20 Local Negotiation and Resolution 18.7 Formal Complaints 18.21 Complaints 18.8 Fair and Reasonable 18.6 Fair and Reasonable 18.9 Permitted Airfield Costs 18.7 Permitted Airfield Costs 18.10 Environmental Costs 18.8 Environmental Costs 18.11 Noise 18.9 Noise 18.12 Insurance 18.10 Insurance 18.13 Causation 18.11 Causation 18.14 Facilities Under Construction 18.12 Facilities Under Construction 18.15 Costs of Another Airport 18.13 Costs of Another Airport 18.16 Airport System 18.14 Airport System 18.17 Closed Airport 18.15

Costs Related to Closing an Airport while Building a Replacement Airport 18.18 Maintenance of Closed Airport 18.19 Project Costs 18.16 Project Costs 18.20 Passenger Facility Charge (PFC) Projects

18.17 Passenger Facility Charge (PFC) Projects

18.21 Prohibition on Unjust Discrimination 18.18 Prohibition on Unjust Discrimination 18.22 Self-Sustaining Rate Structure 18.19 Self-Sustaining Rate Structure 18.23- 18.28 Reserved 18.22- 18.27 Reserved

Page viii

Part I: Background

Chapter 1: Scope and Authority

Updated November 2021 1.1. Purpose … 1-1 1.2. Audience … 1-1 1.3. Where Can I Find This Order? … 1-1 1.4. Cancellation … 1-1 1.5. Introduction … 1-1 1.6. Scope … 1-1 1.7. Background … 1-2 1.8. Compliance Program Background … 1-4 1.9. Sources of Airport Sponsor Federal Obligations … 1-5 1.10. FAA Authority to Administer the Compliance Program … 1-6 1.11. Statutory Limitation on FAA Authority … 1-7 1.12 through 1.14 reserved … 1-7

Chapter 2: Compliance Program

Updated November 2022 2.1. Introduction … 2-1 2.2. Background … 2-1 2.3. Determining if an Airport is Federally Obligated … 2-1 2.4. Objectives of the Compliance Program … 2-1 2.5. Program Elements … 2-2 2.6. Priorities and Emphasis … 2-3 2.7. Responsibilities … 2-3 2.8. Analyzing Compliance Status … 2-4 2.9. Compliance Determination … 2-5 2.10. Grants Watch List … 2-6 2.11 through 2.15 reserve … 2-6

Part II: Types of Federal Agreements

Chapter 3: Federal Obligations from Property Conveyances

Updated November 2022 3.1. Introduction … 3-1 3.2. Background … 3-1 3.3. The War Assets Administration (WAA) … 3-2 3.4. Nonairport Property … 3-2 3.5. The Use of Property for Revenue Production … 3-3 3.6. Highest and Best Use and Suitability for Airport Use … 3-3 3.7. Types of Conveyance Instruments for Surplus Property … 3-4 3.8. Sponsor Federal Obligations for Surplus Property … 3-4 3.9. Duration of Surplus Property Federal Obligations … 3-6

Page ix

3.10. Review of Specific Federal Surplus Property Obligations … 3-6 3.11. Nonsurplus Federal Land Conveyances … 3-7 3.12. Land Conveyance Federal Obligations … 3-7 3.13. Bureau of Land Management … 3-8 3.14. Federal Obligations Imposed by Other Government Agencies … 3-8 3.15. Duration of Nonsurplus Federal Obligations … 3-8 3.16. Reversion Provisions … 3-8 3.17. Airport Sponsor Compliance … 3-9 3.18. The AP-4 Land Agreements … 3-9 3.19. Base Conversion and Surplus Property … 3-9 3.20. Joint Use and Federal Use of Obligated Airports … 3-10 3.21. through 3.25. reserved … 3-12

Chapter 4: Federal Grant Obligations and Responsibilities

Updated November 2022 4.1. Introduction … 4-1 4.2. Sponsor Federal Obligations Under Various Grant Agreements … 4-1 4.3. The Duration of Federal Grant Obligations … 4-2 4.4. The Useful Life of Grant Funded Projects … 4-4 4.5. Airport Sponsor Compliance … 4-5 4.6. Federal Obligations under the Basic Grant Assurance Requirements … 4-5 4.7 through 4.10 reserved … 4-7

Part III: Complaint Resolution

Chapter 5: Initiating, Accepting and Investigating Informal and Formal Complaints

Updated November 2022 5.1. Introduction … 5-1 5.2. Background … 5-1 5.3. The Basics … 5-2 5.4. Part 13: Resolution through Informal Discussions … 5-4 5.5. Part 13 Informal Review Process … 5-5 5.6. Part 13: Stale Complaint … 5-10 5.7. FAA Initiated Informal Letter of Investigation … 5-10 5.8. through 5.21. reserved … 5-11

Part IV: Airports and Aeronautical Users

Chapter 6: Rights and Powers and Good Title

6.1. Introduction … 6-1 6.2. Airport Governance Structures … 6-1 6.3. Controlling Grant Assurances … 6-1 6.4. Interrelationship of Issues … 6-2 6.5. Assignment of Federal Obligations … 6-2 6.6. Rights and Powers … 6-2 6.7. Transfer to another Eligible Recipient … 6-3 6.8. Transfer to the United States Government … 6-4

Page x

6.9. Delegation of Federal Obligations … 6-4 6.10. Subordination of Title … 6-5 6.11. New Sponsor Document Review … 6-5 6.12. Title and Property Interest … 6-7 6.13. Airport Management Agreements … 6-7 6.14. Airport Privatization Pilot Program … 6-9 6.15. Privatization Outside of the Airport Privatization Pilot Program … 6-9 6.16. through 6.20. reserved … 6-10

Chapter 7: Airport Operations

7.1. Introduction … 7-1 7.2. Scope of Airport Maintenance Federal Obligations … 7-1 7.3. Grant Assurance 19, Operation and Maintenance … 7-2 7.4. Maintenance Procedures … 7-2 7.5. Criteria for Satisfactory Compliance with Grant Assurance 19, Operation and Maintenance … 7-2 7.6. Airport Pavement Maintenance Requirement … 7-3 7.7. Major Pavement Repairs … 7-4 7.8. Requirement to Operate the Airport … 7-5 7.9. Local Rules and Procedures … 7-5 7.10. Operations in Inclement Weather … 7-6 7.11. Availability of Federally Acquired Airport Equipment … 7-6 7.12. Part-time Operation of Airport Lighting … 7-6 7.13. Hazards and Mitigation … 7-7 7.14. Use of Airports by Federal Government Aircraft … 7-12 7.15. Negotiation Regarding Charges … 7-13 7.16. Land for Federal Facilities … 7-13 7.17. Federal Government Use during a National Emergency or War … 7-14 7.18. Airport Layout Plan (ALP) … 7-14 7.19. Exhibit “A” and Airport Property Map … 7-15 7.20. Access by Intercity Buses … 7-15 7.21. Temporary Closing of an Airport … 7-16 7.22. Transportation Security Administration (TSA) Security Requirements … 7-18 7.23. through 7.26 reserved … 7-19

Chapter 8: Exclusive Rights

8.1. Introduction … 8-1 8.2. Definition of an Exclusive Right … 8-1 8.3. Legislative and Statutory History … 8-1 8.4. Development of the Exclusive Rights Prohibition into FAA Policy … 8-3 8.5. Aeronautical Operations of the Sponsor … 8-4 8.6. Airports Having a Single Aeronautical Service Provider … 8-5 8.7. Denying Requests by Qualified Providers … 8-5 8.8. Exclusive Rights Violations … 8-6 8.9. Exceptions to the General Rule … 8-8 8.10. UNICOM … 8-10

Page xi

8.11. Implementation of Policy … 8-10 8.12. Military and Special Purpose Airports … 8-11 8.13. through 8.18. reserved … 8-11

Chapter 9: Unjust Discrimination between Aeronautical Users

Updated November 2021 9.1. Introduction … 9-1 9.2. Rental Fees and Charges: General … 9-2 9.3. Types of Charges for Use of Airport Facilities … 9-3 9.4. Airport Tenant and Concessionaire Charges to Airport Users … 9-3 9.5. Terms and Conditions Applied to Tenants Offering Aeronautical Services … 9-4 9.6. Fixed-Base Operations and Other Aeronautical Services … 9-4 9.7. Availability of Leased Space … 9-6 9.8. Air Carrier Airport Access … 9-9 9.9. Civil Rights … 9-10 9.10. FAA Policy on Granting Preferential Treatment Based on Residency … 9-10 9.11. through 9.14. reserved … 9-11

Chapter 10: Reasonable Commercial Minimum Standards

Updated November 2021 10.1. Introduction … 10-1 10.2. FAA Recognition of Minimum Standards … 10-1 10.3. Use of Minimum Standards to Protect an Exclusive Right … 10-1 10.4. Benefits of Minimum Standards … 10-2 10.5. Developing and Applying Minimum Standards … 10-2 10.6. Flying Clubs … 10-4 10.7. Illegal Air Charters … 10-5 10.8. through 10.10. reserved … 10-6

Chapter 11: Self-Service

Updated November 2021 11.1. General … 11-1 11.2. Restrictions on Self-servicing Aircraft … 11-1 11.3. Permitted Activities … 11-1 11.4. Contracting to a Third Party … 11-2 11.5. Restricted Service Activities … 11-2 11.6. Reasonable Rules and Regulations … 11-3 11.7. Restrictions Based on Safety and Location … 11-4 11.8. Activities Not Classified as Self-service … 11-4 11.9. Sponsor Self-service Prerogatives … 11-4 11.10. Fractional Aircraft Ownership Programs … 11-5 11.11. Air Carriers … 11-5 11.12. through 11.14. reserved … 11-6

Chapter 12: Review of Aeronautical Lease Agreements

12.1. Introduction … 12-1

Page xii

12.2. Background … 12-1 12.3. Review of Agreements … 12-1 12.4. FAA Opinion on Review … 12-3 12.5. Agreements Covering Aeronautical Services to the Public … 12-3 12.6. Agreements Involving an Entire Airport … 12-4 12.7. Agreements Granting “Through-the-Fence” Access … 12-4 12.8. through 12.12. reserved … 12-9

Chapter 13: Airport Noise and Access Restrictions

13.1. Introduction and Responsibilities. 13.2. Background … 13-1 13.3. Overview of the Noise-Related Responsibilities of the Federal Government … 13-2 13.4. CFR Part 36, Noise Standards for Aircraft Type and Airworthiness Certification … 13-3 13.5. The Aircraft Noise Compatibility Planning Program … 13-4 13.6. Compliance Review … 13-6 13.7. Mandatory Headquarters Review … 13-6 13.8. Balanced Approach to Noise Mitigation … 13-6 13.9. Cumulative Noise Metric … 13-7 13.10. General Noise Assessment … 13-8 13.11. Residential Development … 13-8 13.12. Impact on Other Airports and Communities … 13-9 13.13. The Concept of Unjust Discrimination … 13-9 13.14. Part 161 Restrictions Impacting Stage 2 or Stage 3 Aircraft … 13-9 13.15. Undue Burden on Interstate Commerce … 13-10 13.16. Use of Complaint Data … 13-11 13.17. Use of Advisory Circular (AC) 36-3H … 13-12 13.18. Integrated Noise Modeling … 13-13 13.19. Future Noise Policy … 13-14 13.20. through 13.25 reserved … 13-14

Chapter 14: Restrictions Based on Safety and Efficiency Procedures and Organization

14.1. Introduction … 14-1 14.2. Applicable Law … 14-1 14.3. Restricting Aeronautical Activities … 14-1 14.4. Minimum Standards and Airport Regulations … 14-2 14.5. Agency Determinations on Safety and System Efficiency … 14-4 14.6. Methodology … 14-4 14.7. Reasonable Accommodation … 14-5 14.8. Restrictions on Touch-and-Go Operations … 14-6 14.9. Sport Pilot Regulations … 14-6 14.10. Coordination … 14-7 14.11 through 14.15 reserved … 14-7

Page xiii

Part V: Financial Responsibilities

Chapter 15: Permitted and Prohibited Uses of Airport Revenue

15.1. Introduction … 15-1 15.2. Legislative History … 15-1 15.3. Privatization … 15-2 15.4. Grant Assurance … 15-2 15.5. FAA Policy … 15-2 15.6. Airport Revenue Defined … 15-2 15.7. Applicability of Airport Revenue Requirements … 15-3 15.8. Federal Financial Assistance … 15-3 15.9. Permitted Uses of Airport Revenue … 15-4 15.10. Grandfathering from Prohibitions on Use of Airport Revenue … 15-6 15.11. Allocation of Indirect Costs … 15-8 15.12. Standard for Documentation … 15-8 15.13. Prohibited Uses of Airport Revenue … 15-9 15.14. through 15.19 reserved … 15-11

Chapter 16: Resolution of Unlawful Revenue Diversion

Updated August 2023 16.1. Background … 16-1 16.2. FAA Authorization … 16-1 16.3. Section 47133 and Grant Assurance 25, Airport Revenues … 16-2 16.4. Agency Policy … 16-2 16.5. Responsibility … 16-2 16.6. Detection of Airport Revenue Diversion … 16-3 16.7. Investigation of a Complaint of Unlawful Revenue Diversion … 16-4 16.8. Investigation without a Formal Complaint … 16-4 16.9. Administrative Sanctions … 16-5 16.10. Civil Penalties and Interest … 16-5 16.11. Compliance with Reporting and Audit Requirements … 16-6 16.12. Statute of Limitations on Enforcement … 16-6 16.13 through 16.17 reserved … 16-6

Chapter 17: Self-Sustainability

Updated August 2023 17.1. Introduction … 17-1 17.2. Statutory Requirements … 17-1 17.3. Related Grant Assurance and FAA Policies … 17-1 17.4. Self-sustaining Principle … 17-1 17.5. Airport Circumstances … 17-1 17.6. Long-term Approach … 17-2 17.7. New Agreements … 17-2 17.8. Revenue Surpluses … 17-2 17.9. Aeronautical Use Rates … 17-2 17.10. Nonaeronautical Rates … 17-3

Page xiv

17.11. Fair Market Value … 17-3 17.12. Exceptions to the Self-sustaining Rule: General … 17-3 17.13. Exceptions to the Self-Sustaining Rule: General … 17-3 17.14. Exceptions to the Self-Sustaining Rule: Providing Property for Public Community Purposes … 17-3 17.15. Exception to the Self-Sustaining Rule: Use of Property by Not-for-Profit Aviation Organizations … 17-5 17.16. Exception to the Self-Sustaining Rule: Military Aeronautical Units … 17-5 17.17. Exception to the Self-Sustaining Rule: Transit Projects … 17-5 17.18. Exception to the Self-Sustaining Rule: Private Transit Systems … 17-6 17.20 through 17.24 reserved … 17-6

Chapter 18: Airport Rates and Charges

Updated August 2023 18.1. Introduction … 18-1 18.2. Background … 18-1 18.3. Responsibilities … 18-2 18.4. Definitions … 18-2 18.5. Key Concepts … 18-3 18.6. Fair and Reasonable … 18-3 18.7. Permitted Airfield Costs … 18-5 18.8. Environmental Costs … 18-5 18.9. Noise … 18-5 18.10. Insurance … 18-5 18.11. Causation … 18-5 18.12. Facilities under Construction … 18-5 18.13. Costs of Another Airport … 18-6 18.14. Airport System … 18-6 18.15. Costs Related to Closing an Airport while Building a Replacement Airport … 18-6 18.16. Project Costs … 18-6 18.17. Passenger Facility Charge (PFC) Projects … 18-6 18.18. Prohibition on Unjust Discrimination … 18-6 18.19. Self-Sustaining Rate Structure … 18-7 18.20. Local Negotiation and Resolution … 18-7 18.21. Complaints … 18-8 18.22. through 18.28. reserved … 18-9

Chapter 19: Airport Financial Reports

Updated August 2023 19.1. Introduction … 19-1 19.2. Statutory Authority … 19-1 19.3. Grant Assurance 26, Reports and Inspections … 19-2 19.4. Applicability … 19-2 19.5. Annual Financial Reports … 19-3 19.6. Procedures for Evaluating the Airport Owners/Sponsors Financial Reporting Program. 19-4 19.7. Single Audit Reports … 19-4

Page xv

19.8. through 19.11. reserved … 19-5

Part VI: Land Use

Chapter 20: Compatible Land Use and Airspace Protection

20.1. Background … 20-1 20.2. Zoning and Land Use Planning … 20-2 20.3. Residential Use of Land on or Near Airport Property … 20-5 20.4. Residential Airparks Adjacent to Federally Obligated Airports … 20-5 20.5. Residential Development on Federally Obligated Airports … 20-7 20.6. through 20.10 reserved … 20-9

Chapter 21: Land Use Compliance Inspection

21.1. Introduction … 21-1 21.2. Background … 21-1 21.3. Elements of the Land Use Inspection … 21-1 21.4. Responsibilities … 21-1 21.5. Authority … 21-1 21.6. Land Use Inspection Guidance … 21-2 21.7. Sample Correspondence … 21-10 21.18 through 21.12 reserved … 21-10

Part VII: Releases and Property Reversions

Chapter 22: Releases from Federal Obligations

22.1. Introduction … 22-1 22.2. Definition … 22-1 22.3. Duration and Authority … 22-1 22.4. FAA Consideration of Releases … 22-1 22.5. Request for Concurrent Use of Aeronautical Property for Other Uses … 22-2 22.6. Request for Interim Use of Aeronautical Property for Other Uses … 22-4 22.7. Release of Federal Maintenance Obligation … 22-4 22.8. Industrial Use Changes … 22-5 22.9. Release of National Emergency Use Provision (NEUP) … 22-5 22.10. Release from Federal Obligation to Furnish Space or Land without Charge … 22-6 22.11. Release of Reverter Clause … 22-6 22.12. Exclusive Rights Federal Obligations cannot be Released without Release and Disposal of the Parcel or Closure of Airport … 22-6 22.13. Federal Obligations Imposed with the Airport Layout Plan and Exhibit “A.” … 22-6 22.14. Procedures for Operational Releases or Requests for Change in Use … 22-6 22.15. Release of Federal Obligations in Regard to Personal Property, Structures, and Facilities … 22-7 22.16. All Disposals of Airport Real Property … 22-9 22.17. Release of Federal Obligations in Regard to Real Property Acquired as Federal Surplus Property … 22-10 22.18. Release of Federal Obligations in Regard to Real Property Acquired with Federal Grant Assistance … 22-12

Page xvi

22.19. Effect of not Receiving or Receiving a Grant after December 30, 1987 … 22-12 22.20. Release of Entire Airport … 22-14 22.21. Procedures for the Application, Consideration, and Resolution of Release Requests. . 22-14 22.22. General Documentation Procedures … 22-14 22.23. Airport Sponsor Request for Release … 22-15 22.24. Content of Written Requests for Release … 22-15 22.25. Content of Request for Written Release for Disposal … 22-15 22.26. Exhibits to the Written Request for Release … 22-16 22.27. FAA Evaluation of Sponsor Requests … 22-17 22.28. FAA Determination on Sponsor Requests … 22-17 22.29. FAA Completion of Action on Sponsor Requests … 22-18 22.30. FAA Denial of Release or Modification … 22-18 22.31. Procedures for Public Notice for a Change in Use of Aeronautical Property … 22-18 22.32. FAA Consent by Letter of Intent to Release – Basis for Use … 22-20 22.33. The Environmental Implications of Releases … 22-20 22.34. through 22.37. reserved … 22-21

Chapter 23: Reversions of Airport Property

Updated November 2021 23.1. Introduction … 23-1 23.2. General … 23-1 23.3. Authority to Revert a Property Interest … 23-2 23.4. Instruments of Conveyance … 23-2 23.5. Voluntary Return of Property to the U.S. Government … 23-2 23.6. Involuntary Reversion … 23-3 23.7. Identifying the Federal Agency to Receive the Property … 23-3 23.8. Determination of Default … 23-3 23.9. Perform and Document the FAA’s Environmental Due Diligence … 23-3 23.10. Notice of Intent to Revert Property … 23-3 23.11. Voluntary Reconveyance to Correct a Default … 23-4 23.12. Notice of Reverter of Property and Revestment of Title and Property Interest in the U.S … 23-5 23.13. Recording Notice of Reverter of Property and Revestment of Title and Property Interest in the U.S … 23-6 23.14. Certificate of Inspection and Possession … 23-6 23.15. Possession, Posting, or Marking of Property … 23-6 23.16. Reversion Case Studies … 23-6 23.17 through 23.21. reserved … 23-7

Page xvii

Appendices

Appendix A: Airport Sponsors Assurances … 1

Appendix B: Reserved … 3

Appendix C: Advisory Circulars on Exclusive Rights and Minimum Standards for Commercial Aeronautical Activities … 4

Appendix D: Policy Regarding Airport Rates and Charges … 5

Appendix E: Policies and Procedures Concerning the Use of Airport Revenue … 6

Appendix F: 14 CFR Parts 13 and 16 … 7

Appendix F-1: Part 16 Decisions (Case Files) … 8

Appendix F-2: Reserved … 9

Appendix G: Reserved … 10

Appendix G-1: Sample Grant Watch List … 11

Appendix H: Sample Audit Information … 13

Appendix I: SPA Reg. 16 … 15

Appendix J: DoD Base Realignment and Closure (BRAC) … 19

Appendix J-1: Airport Joint Use Agreement for Military Use of Civilian Airfields … 24

Appendix K: Part 155 – Release of Airport Property from Surplus Property Disposal Restrictions … 39

Appendix L: Reserved … 40

Appendix M: Reserved … 41

Appendix N: Reserved … 42

Appendix O: Minimum Standards for Commercial Aeronautical Activities … 43

Appendix P: Sample Airport Rules and Regulations … 44

Appendix Q: Reserved … 47

Appendix R: Airport Layout Plan (ALP) … 48

Appendix S: Reserved … 49

Appendix T: Sample FAA Letter on Replacement Airport … 50

Appendix U: Sample Joint-Use Agreement … 55

Page xviii

Appendix V: Sample Deed of Conveyance … 75

Appendix W: Reserved … 89

Appendix X: 14 CFR Part 161 … 90

Appendix Y: Sample Notice of Reversion of Property and Revestment of Title to the United States … 122

Appendix Z: Definitions and Acronyms … 23-125

References … 23-143

Index … 23-146

Part I: Background › Chapter 1: Scope and Authority

Part I: Background

Chapter 1: Scope and Authority

Updated November 2021

1.1. Purpose. This Order sets forth policies and procedures for the FAA Airport Compliance Program. The Order is not regulatory and is not controlling with regard to airport sponsor conduct; rather, it establishes the policies and procedures for FAA personnel to follow in carrying out the FAA’s responsibilities for ensuring airport compliance. It provides basic guidance for FAA personnel in interpreting and administering the various continuing commitments airport owners make to the United States as a condition for the grant of federal funds or the conveyance of federal property for airport purposes. The Order, inter alia, analyzes the various obligations set forth in the standard airport sponsor assurances, addresses the application of the assurances in the operation of public-use airports, and facilitates interpretation of the assurances by FAA personnel.

1.2. Audience. FAA personnel having responsibility for monitoring airport sponsor compliance with the sponsor’s federal obligations.

1.3. Where Can I Find This Order? The current Order is available on the FAA website and will be updated electronically at this location.

1.4. Cancellation. This Order cancels and replaces the following chapters of FAA Order 5190.6B, dated September 30, 2009: Chapter 1, Scope and Authority; Chapter 9, Unjust Discrimination Between Aeronautical Users; Chapter 10, Reasonable Commercial Minimum Standards; Chapter 11, Self-Service and Chapter 23, Reversions of Airport Property.

1.5. Introduction. This chapter discusses the scope of the Order, the sources of sponsor0F0F1 federal obligations, and the FAA’s authority to administer the Airport Compliance Program within the FAA Office of Airports (ARP). The FAA Airport Compliance Program is contractually based, and it does not attempt to control or direct the operation of airports. Rather, the program is designed to monitor and enforce obligations agreed to by airport sponsors in exchange for valuable benefits and rights granted by the United States in return for substantial direct grants of funds and for conveyances of federal property for airport purposes. The Airport Compliance Program is designed to protect the public interest in civil aviation. Grants and property conveyances are made in exchange for binding commitments (federal obligations) designed to ensure that the public interest in civil aviation will be served. The FAA bears the important responsibility of seeing that these commitments are met. This Order addresses the types of these commitments, how they apply to airports, and what FAA personnel are required to do to ensure compliance with Federal obligations.

1.6. Scope. This Order provides guidance, policy, and procedures for conducting a comprehensive and effective FAA Airport Compliance Program to monitor and ensure airport sponsor compliance with the applicable federal obligations assumed in the acceptance of airport

1 A sponsor is any public agency that applies for federal financial assistance, or private owner of a public use airport, as defined in the Airport and Airway Improvement Act of 1982 (AAIA), codified at 49 U.S.C. § 47102(26).

development assistance.

Grants and property conveyances are made in exchange for

binding commitments (federal obligations) designed to ensure the public interest in civil aviation will be served.

1.7. Background. The Air Commerce Act of 1926 was the cornerstone of the federal government's regulation of civil aviation. This landmark legislation was passed at the urging of the aviation industry, whose leaders believed that aviation could not reach its full commercial potential without federal action to improve and maintain safety standards. The Air Commerce Act charged the Secretary of Commerce with fostering air commerce, issuing and enforcing air traffic rules, licensing pilots, certificating aircraft, establishing airways, and operating and maintaining aids to air navigation. A new Aeronautics Branch of the Department of Commerce assumed primary responsibility for aviation oversight.

In 1938, the Civil Aeronautics Act transferred the federal civil aviation responsibilities from the Commerce Department to a new independent agency, the Civil Aeronautics Authority. The legislation also expanded the government’s role by giving the Civil Aeronautics Authority the power to regulate airline fares and to determine the routes that air carriers would serve. In 1940, President Franklin Roosevelt split the Civil Aeronautics Authority into two agencies, the Civil Aeronautics Administration (CAA) and the Civil Aeronautics Board (CAB). The CAA was responsible for air traffic control (ATC), airman and aircraft certification, safety enforcement, and airway development. The CAB was entrusted with safety rulemaking, accident investigation, and economic regulation of the airlines. Both organizations were part of the Department of Commerce. Unlike the CAA, however, the CAB functioned independent of the Secretary of Commerce. On the eve of America's entry into World War II, the CAA began to extend its ATC responsibilities to takeoff and landing operations at airports. This expanded role eventually became permanent after the war. The application of radar to ATC helped controllers keep abreast of the postwar boom in commercial air transportation.

In the Federal Airport Act of 1946 (1946 Airport Act), Congress gave the CAA the added task of administering the Federal Aid to Airports Program (FAAP), the first peacetime program of financial assistance aimed exclusively at promoting development of the nation's civil airports. The approaching introduction of jet airliners and a series of midair collisions spurred passage of the Federal Aviation Act of 1958 (FA Act). This legislation transferred the CAA's functions to a new independent agency, the Federal Aviation Agency, which had broader authority to address aviation safety through rulemaking and enforcement. It also gave the Federal Aviation Agency sole responsibility for developing and maintaining a common civil-military system of air navigation and air traffic control, a responsibility the CAA had shared with others.

In 1966, Congress authorized the creation of a cabinet department that would combine federal transportation responsibilities for all public modes of transportation. This new Department of Transportation (DOT) began full operations on April l, 1967. On that day, the Federal Aviation Agency became one of several modal administrations within the DOT and received a new name, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). At the same time, the CAB's accident investigation function was transferred to the new National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB).

The FAA has gradually assumed responsibilities not originally contemplated by the FA Act. For example, the hijacking epidemic of the 1960s brought the agency into the field of aviation security. That function was later transferred to the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) in 2001 after the events of 9/11. In 1968, Congress vested in the FAA Administrator the power to prescribe aircraft noise standards. The Airport and Airway Development Act of 1970 (1970 Airport Act) placed the agency in charge of a new airport aid program funded by a special aviation trust fund. The 1970 Airport Act also made the FAA responsible for safety certification of airports served by air carriers. In 1982, Congress enacted the current grant statute, the Airport and Airway Improvement Act (AAIA), which established the Airport Improvement Program (AIP). The FAA's mission expanded again in 1995 with the transfer of the Office of Commercial Space Transportation from the Office of the Secretary to the FAA.

The airport system envisioned in the first National Airport Plan, issued in 1946, has been developed and nurtured by close cooperation between federal, state, and local agencies. The general principles guiding federal involvement1F1F1F2 have remained largely unchanged for the National Plan of Integrated Airport Systems (NPIAS). The airport system should have the following attributes to meet the demand for air transportation:

• Airports should be safe and efficient, located at optimum sites, and be developed and maintained to appropriate standards.

• Airports should be operated efficiently both for aeronautical users and the government, relying primarily on user fees and placing minimal burden on the general revenues of the local, state, and federal governments.

2 Extracted from the Report to Congress, National Plan of Integrated Airport Systems (NPIAS) (2009-2013).

NPIAS Airports by Category and Role (2021-2025)

The table shown above depicts the extent of the country’s public-use airport system. The NPIAS reports are available online at https://www.faa.gov/airports/planning_capacity/npias/current/. (Graphics: FAA)

• Airports should be flexible and expandable, able to meet increased demand and accommodate new aircraft types.

• Airports should be permanent, with assurance that they will remain open for aeronautical use over the long term.

• Airports should be compatible with surrounding communities, maintaining a balance between the needs of aviation and the requirements of residents in neighboring areas.

• Airports should be developed in concert with improvements to the air traffic control system.

• The airport system should support national objectives for defense, emergency readiness, and postal delivery.

• The airport system should be extensive, providing as many people as possible with convenient access to air transportation, typically not more than 20 miles of travel to the nearest NPIAS airport.

• The airport system should help air transportation contribute to a productive national economy and international competitiveness.

Airports should be permanent with assurance that they will

remain open for aeronautical use over the long term.

In addition to these principles specific to airport development, a guiding principle for federal infrastructure investment, as stated in Executive Order 12893, Principles for Federal Infrastructure Investments (January 26, 1994), is that such investments must be cost beneficial, i.e., must have a positive ratio of benefits to costs. The FAA implements these principles using program guidance to ensure the effective use of federal aid.

A national priority system guides the distribution of funds. Information used to establish the priority is supplemented by specific requirements for some additional analysis or justification. For example, in certain cases the airport sponsor must prepare a benefit-cost analysis for airport capacity development projects to be funded under the Airport Improvement Program (AIP).

1.8. Compliance Program Background. The Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938, as amended, and the FA Act, as amended, charge the FAA Administrator with broad responsibilities for the regulation of air commerce in the interests of safety and national defense and for the development of civil aeronautics. Under these broad powers, the FAA was tasked with regulation of airmen, aircraft, navigable airspace, and airport operations. The federal interest in advancing civil aviation has been augmented by various legislative actions that authorize programs for granting property, funds, and other assistance to local communities to develop airport facilities.

In each program, the airport sponsor assumes certain federal obligations, either by contract or by restrictive covenants in property deeds, to maintain and operate its airport facilities safely and

efficiently and in accordance with specified conditions. Commitments assumed by airport sponsors in deeds or grant agreements have been generally successful in maintaining a high degree of safety and efficiency in airport design, construction, operation, and maintenance. The FAA Airport Compliance Program establishes the policy and guidelines for monitoring the compliance of airport sponsors with their obligations to the United States and for ensuring that airports serve the needs of civil aviation.

The federal obligations a sponsor assumes in accepting

FAA administered airport development assistance are

mandated by federal statute.

1.9. Sources of Airport Sponsor Federal Obligations. The federal obligations a sponsor assumes in accepting FAA-administered airport development assistance are mandated by federal statute and incorporated in the grant agreements and property conveyance instruments entered into by the sponsor and the United States Government, including:

Grant agreements issued under the various FAA-administered airport development grant programs through the years. These include, but are not limited to, the Federal Aid to Airports Program (FAAP), the Airport Development Aid Program (ADAP), and the Airport Improvement Program (AIP) under 49 U.S.C. § 47101, et seq. This statutory provision provides for federal airport financial assistance for the development of public use airports under the AIP established by the AAIA. Section 47107 sets forth assurances that FAA must include in every grant agreement as the sponsor’s conditions for receiving federal financial assistance. (The current version of 49 U.S.C. § 47107 can be found online.) Pursuant to and consistent with, 49 U.S.C. § 47107(g) and (h), the FAA has prescribed some additional assurances or requirements for sponsors beyond those specifically enumerated in 49 U.S.C. § 47107. These include requirements set forth in 49 U.S.C. § 47106 and other statutes.

Occasionally, there are special funding programs authorized by Congress to provide federal grants to airports for a specific purpose such as economic development or recovery (e.g., American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA); Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES), etc.). The grant agreements under these programs set forth the conditions for receiving the federal assistance and will vary depending on the purpose of the grant.

Upon acceptance of an AIP grant, the assurances become a binding contractual obligation between the airport sponsor and the federal government.

Instruments of surplus property transfer issued under the provisions of section 13(g) of the Surplus Property Act of 1944, as amended, 49 U.S.C. §§ 47151-47153.

Instruments of nonsurplus conveyance issued under section 16 of the 1946 Airport Act, as amended; under section 23 of the 1970 Airport Act, as amended; or under section 516 of the AAIA, as amended, codified at 49 U.S.C. § 47125.

Exclusive Rights under section 303 of the Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938, as amended, and section 308(a) of the FAA Act, as amended, codified at 49 U.S.C. § 40103(e).

Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended.

1.10. FAA Authority to Administer the Compliance Program. Responsibility for monitoring and ensuring airport sponsor compliance with applicable federal obligations is vested in the Secretary of Transportation by statute and delegated to the FAA under 49 CFR § 1.83:

Surplus Property Transfers. Surplus property instruments of transfer were issued by the War Assets Administration (WAA) and are now issued by its successor, the General Services Administration (GSA). However, section 3 of Public Law (Pub. L.) 81-311 specifically vests the FAA with the sole responsibility for determining and enforcing compliance with the terms and conditions of all instruments of transfer by which surplus airport property is, or has been, conveyed to nonfederal public agencies pursuant to the Surplus Property Act of 1944, as amended.

Nonsurplus Property Transfers. Nonsurplus property transfers are conveyances under section 16 of the 1946 Airport Act, under section 23 of the 1970 Airport Act, or under section 516 of the AAIA, codified at 49 U.S.C. § 47125. These are also referred to as nonsurplus property conveyances. Instruments of property conveyance issued under these sections are also issued by agencies other than the FAA. The conveyance instrument, deed, or quitclaim document assigns monitoring and enforcement responsibility to the FAA.

Grant agreements from the FAAP, ADAP, and the AIP programs (e.g., ARRA, CARES, etc.). The FAA is vested with jurisdiction over monitoring and enforcing grant agreements that the FAA and its predecessor, the CAA, executed on behalf of the United States.

Exclusive Rights Prohibition. The FAA is also charged with responsibility for monitoring and enforcing compliance with the provisions prohibiting exclusive rights set forth in section 303 of the Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938, as amended, and in section 308(a) of the FAA Act, as amended, codified at 49 U.S.C. § 40103(e).

Amendment, Modification, or Release of Airport Sponsor Federal Obligations. The authority of the FAA to release or modify the terms and conditions of airport sponsor grant agreements varies based on the respective types of agreements. Pub. L. 81-311 prescribes specific circumstances and conditions under which the FAA may release, modify, or amend the terms and conditions of surplus property conveyances. While the FAA has the ability to amend, modify, or release an airport sponsor from a federal obligation, the FAA is not required to do so.

The FAA exercises its discretion when releasing a sponsor from any of its obligations. For additional information, refer to chapter 22 of this Order, Releases from Federal Obligations.

1.11. Statutory Limitation on FAA Authority

The FAA Reauthorization Act of 2018 (Pub. L. 115-254), Section 163 narrowed the scope of the FAA’s authority over airport land uses.

1.12 through 1.14 reserved.

Part I: Background › Chapter 2: Compliance Program

Chapter 2: Compliance Program

Updated November 2022

2.1. Introduction. This chapter is an introduction to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Airport Compliance Program. The basis of sponsor federal obligations resides with federal statute, the Airport Improvement Program (AIP) grant program, land transfer documents, and surplus property agreements. It is the responsibility of the FAA airports district offices (ADOs) and regional airports divisions to advise sponsors of their compliance requirements and to ensure that sponsors comply with their federal obligations.

2.2. Background. The FAA Airport Compliance Program enforces contractual federal obligations that a sponsor accepts when receiving federal grant funds or the transfer of federal property. These contractual federal obligations serve to protect the public's interest in civil aviation and achieve compliance with federal statutes. Given the great number of federally obligated airports and the variety of federal obligations, the compliance program primarily focuses on education with the goal of achieving voluntary compliance. The program supplements this educational approach with periodic compliance monitoring and vigorous investigation of potential violations.

2.3. Determining if an Airport is Federally Obligated.

General Information. Historically, the FAA published FAA Order 5190.2, List of Public Airports Affected by Agreements with the Federal Government, which provided a listing of all publicly and privately owned public use airports that were affected by agreements with the federal government and handled by the FAA. In addition, Form 5010, The Airport Master Record, includes information on whether the airport is federally obligated. Form 5010 is available online at https://adip.faa.gov/agis/public/#/public.

Information Codes. The FAA presents federal obligation data is in the form of codes, such as G, R, S or P. Each code represents a particular federal obligation type. The Federal Obligation Codes and their corresponding definitions are available at: https://www.faa.gov/airports/airport_compliance/compliance_guidance/agreements_code_definit ions

2.4. Objectives of the Compliance Program.

Voluntary Compliance and Enforcement Actions. Most violations of sponsor federal obligations are not a deliberate attempt to circumvent federal obligations. Generally, violations occur because sponsors do not understand specific requirements or how a requirement applies to a specific circumstance. Therefore, the program works to ensure sponsors are fully informed of their federal obligations and of the applicability of those obligations to the circumstances at a given airport. Informal resolution is the preferred course of action. (See chapter 5 of this Order, Initiating, Accepting, and Investigating Informal and Formal Complaints.)

When reasonable efforts have failed to achieve voluntary compliance on the part of the sponsor, the FAA may take more formal compliance actions. This may result in withholding federal funds, issuing a Notice of Investigation (NOI) under 14 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 16, or initiating judicial action if warranted.

Issuing a NOI or initiating formal legal action are options exercised by the FAA Headquarters (HQ) Airport Compliance Division (ACO-100) ) in accordance with 14 CFR part 16 procedures.

Advisory Services. Generally, the FAA will not substitute its judgment for that of the airport sponsor in matters of administration and management of airport facilities.

However, the FAA is in a position to assist airport sponsors in achieving voluntary compliance through guidance and counsel about the nature and applicability of federal compliance obligations affecting their airports.

Compliance Oversight. Given the approximately 3,500 federally obligated airports, the FAA cannot practically conduct compliance oversight with an annual visit or review at each airport.

However, periodic monitoring of a certain number of federally obligated airports is necessary to identify individual issues and problems that may be indicative of system deficiencies.

Enforcement Action. FAA personnel involved in compliance should make every effort to obtain voluntary compliance.

When enforcement action is taken, it must be fair and applied in a uniform manner. When safety issues are identified, however, prompt corrective action is expected.

When safety issues are

identified, prompt corrective action is

expected.

2.5. Program Elements. Education is the primary tool for achieving program compliance. However, to maintain program integrity, FAA personnel must also include limited surveillance to detect recurring deficiencies, system weaknesses, or prohibited actions by sponsors. Investigation and resolution of complaints is the most important tool of the compliance program.

When FAA efforts fail to obtain voluntary compliance, enforcement actions must be pursued.

Education. The education of sponsors may take many forms, beginning when the sponsor receives its first federal grant or transfer of federal property. ADOs and FAA regional airports divisions should discuss with first-time sponsors the impact of specific grant assurances and/or land transfer federal obligations and let them know that the offices will continue to provide advisory services.

At least once every three years, FAA personnel should advise sponsors in writing to review their grant or land-transfer federal obligations. Compliance personnel should also provide sponsors with information or material to aid sponsors’ understanding of their federal obligations.

Finally, sponsors should be encouraged to conduct or participate in periodic seminars or courses for federally obligated airports. In many instances, FAA regional airports divisions host or sponsor airport-related events, such as conferences, that are good opportunities to disseminate information regarding airport compliance.

Inspections and Surveillance. Surveillance is the process of gathering data on the condition or operation of an airport to determine the sponsor’s compliance with federal obligations. FAA personnel routinely gather such information during their site visits to airports. In addition, information is gathered from other sources, including other FAA offices, state inspectors, airport tenants, and information forms, such as FAA Form 5010, Airport Master Record.1

FAA personnel may also conduct surveillance by means of telephone discussions or written correspondence with appropriate airport officials to learn if potential problems exist. Further follow up through inspection may or may not be necessary depending on the information obtained. The information received should be documented and maintained for future reference. Alternately, FAA personnel may provide sponsors with printed material that identifies and explains the federal obligations accepted by that sponsor.

Investigations of Complaints. ADOs and regional airports divisions must investigate complaints from aeronautical users alleging that an airport is not complying with its federal obligations. FAA personnel should complete the investigation in a timely manner and notify the complainant in writing of the outcome of any investigation. Informal complaints need to be addressed in a timely manner. When an investigation reveals a violation of a federal obligation, ADOs and regional airports divisions should initiate a timely dialogue with the airport sponsor and attempt to achieve voluntary compliance as soon as practicable. See Chapter 5, Initiating, Accepting, and Investigating Informal and Formal Complaints, for more information.

Safety-related issues may require expedited action on the part of the FAA. Where appropriate, airport sponsors should also use an airport safety self-inspection checklist as a means to assist in ensuring safe airport operations.

2.6. Priorities and Emphasis. When pursuing remedial or enforcement actions, the FAA considers all federal airport obligations important. However, consistent with the FAA mission, the most important objective in FAA's oversight of the compliance program is to ensure and preserve safety at all federally obligated airports.

Ensuring safe airport operations includes maintaining runways, taxiways, and other operational areas in a safe and usable condition; keeping runway approaches cleared; providing operable and well-maintained marking and lighting; etc.

In developing priorities for compliance surveillance in the region, FAA personnel should direct attention to those airports with the greatest potential for compliance problems and to those issues that have the largest impact on aeronautical users.

2.7. Responsibilities.

a. The Airport Compliance Division (ACO-100) within FAA’s Office of Airport Compliance and Management Analysis (ACO-1), administers the airport compliance program and provides the following:

• overall guidance and direction for conducting the compliance program.

1 In many instances, state aviation inspectors gather the data for inclusion in FAA Form 5010 on behalf of the FAA.

• conducts evaluations to determine compliance with federal statutes, regulations and grant assurances.

• looks for opportunities to improve the quality of the compliance program.

• offers recurrent training and on- request training to Regions and ADOs and regional airports divisions.

• develops compliance policy, supporting ADOs and regional airports divisions in conducting informal resolution, and resolving formal complaints.

• directs the formal enforcement of FAA grant obligations, as well as surplus and nonsurplus property conveyances.

• prepares generalized educational materials for ADOs and regional airports divisions to use in their compliance programs..

ADOs and regional airports divisions are responsible for the day-to-day conduct of the compliance program in accordance with the direction provided in this Order. This guidance establishes the basic requirements and goals to be achieved in the compliance program. Compliance is an essential component in safeguarding both the federal investment and the public’s interest in civil aviation. This also includes ensuring public access to the national system of airports.

2.8. Analyzing Compliance Status.

Data Analysis. FAA compliance personnel should carefully analyze accumulated data in evaluating a sponsor's compliance performance and identifying appropriate actions to correct any deficiencies noted. More often than not, when apprised of a deficiency, a sponsor will ask for recommendations to correct the problem.

Preliminary assessment. FAA must make a judgment call in all cases as to whether a sponsor is reasonably meeting its federal commitments. A sponsor meets its commitments when:

(1). the federal obligations are fully understood;

(2). a program (e.g., preventive maintenance, leasing policies, operating regulations, etc.) is in place that the FAA deems adequate to carry out the sponsor’s commitments;

(3). the sponsor satisfactorily demonstrates that such a program is being carried out; and,

(4). past compliance issues have been addressed.

Follow-up.

(1). Each ADO or regional airports division should develop a system to follow up and ensure that airports take action on any identified compliance deficiencies until the airport sponsor achieves compliance. Failing to follow up on compliance

issues at the ADO or regional airports division level may lead to unnecessary and resource-intensive formal complaints.

(2). FAA compliance personnel must initiate action at those airports that are not being maintained or operated in accordance with the sponsor’s commitments, especially if safety is involved. There should be an effort to help the sponsor voluntarily meet these commitments. When the sponsor has demonstrated an unwillingness to make the corrections necessary to achieve compliance, FAA may pursue corrective enforcement and document such actions.

(3). FAA may undertake a formal compliance inspection in response to a complaint. Such an inspection may also take place whenever the FAA has any reason to believe that a sponsor may be in violation of one or more of its federal obligations. Appendix G of this Order, Formal Compliance Inspection, contains the procedures and form(s) to follow in a formal compliance inspection.

2.9. Compliance Determination. FAA personnel must remain aware of which airports are not in compliance in their areas of responsibility. Before the ADO or regional airports division can issue a federal airport grant, it must make an official determination that the sponsor is in compliance with its federal obligations.

A determination of compliance is based on a review of all available data concerning the airport and the circumstances involving its operation. The review need not include a formal compliance inspection or a formal compliance determination. It should, however, include the properly documented review of available data on hand. The ADO or regional airports division may rely on a sponsor's self-certification of compliance when making a compliance determination prior to issuing a grant. However, it is important that all data used to support this determination, including informal complaints and related materials, be analyzed and recorded in the appropriate files.

Notification. When the ADO’s or regional airports division’s assessment of the sponsor's performance concludes that the sponsor is not meeting its federal compliance obligations, the ADO or regional airports division must give the sponsor notification of potential noncompliance. Failure to provide such notice delays the corrective action and the problem may become more difficult to resolve at a future date. Prompt communication between the ADO or regional airports division and the sponsor about compliance deficiencies is essential to solving problems early before they become more difficult to resolve. See Chapter 5, Initiating, Accepting, and Investigating Informal and Formal Complaints, for more information.

Actions Needed to Correct Noncompliance. The ADO or regional airports division notification must clearly spell out the actions needed to correct the potential noncompliance. The office should also perform a timely follow-up review to ensure completion of the corrective action.

Withholding AIP Payments and Grant Application Approval. Through the formal Part 16 process, the FAA can initiate the withholding of a payment on an AIP grant or approval of an AIP grant application. Additionally, the ADOs and regional airports divisions – in conjunction

with ACO-100 – can make decisions to suspend discretionary funding, including nonprimary entitlement grants.

2.10. Grants Watch List. As a result of its compliance functions, ACO-100 maintains the Grants Watch List.

The Grants Watch List lists those obligated airports with egregious violations where the airport sponsor has been informally determined to be in noncompliance with its grant assurances and/or surplus property obligations as of a particular date. An airport is placed on the Grants Watch List if it falls in one or more of the following categories and the violations are so egregious as to preclude additional federal financial assistance until the issues are resolved:

Airports with a formal finding of noncompliance under 14 CFR Part 16 if corrective action has not been taken,

Airports listed in the Airport Improvement Program (AIP) Report to Congress under 49 U.S.C. § 47131 for certain for violations of their grant assurances or other requirements with respect to airport lands; and

Airports that are clearly in noncompliance despite FAA requests to the sponsor for corrective action,.

The Grants Watch List is essentially an internal notification from ACO-100 to other FAA Airports offices regarding which airports are not to receive any further discretionary grants authorized under 49 U.S.C. § 47115 and the General Aviation $150,000 apportionment under 49 U.S.C. § 47114(d)(3)(A) until corrective action is achieved. The Grants Watch List may also include formal findings of noncompliance under 14 CFR Part 16 that support the withholding of grants under 49 U.S.C. § 47114(c). The Grants Watch List is updated on an as-needed basis.

2.11 through 2.15 reserve

Sample FAA Form 5010 Airport Master Record

Part II: Types of Federal Agreements › Chapter 3: Federal Obligations from Property Conveyances

Part II: Types of Federal Agreements

Chapter 3: Federal Obligations from Property Conveyances

Updated November 2022

3.1. Introduction. This chapter discusses the various types of conveyances the federal government has used to transfer personal and real property to airport sponsors. The types of transfers include surplus property and nonsurplus property conveyances.

Surplus property refers to U.S. property that was conveyed to the airport sponsor under the Surplus Property Act of 1944, as amended. Nonsurplus property refers to U.S. property that was conveyed to the airport property by other means, such as under 49 U.S.C. § 47125 and its predecessors.

This chapter also discusses the sponsor’s federal obligations under the various types of federal conveyances, the duration of the associated federal obligations, and the need for FAA regional airports divisions (Regions) and Airports District Offices (ADOs) to review the specific conveyance instrument when assessing sponsor’s federal obligations.

In general, property conveyances require the sponsor to:

• Maintain the airport in good and serviceable condition, • Use specific lands approved by the FAA for nonaeronautical use to generate revenue to support the airport’s aviation needs, • Operate the airport in the public’s interest, and • Ensure there is no grant of an exclusive right for any aeronautical purpose or use.

It is the responsibility of the Regions and ADOs to:

• Ensure that the sponsors operate and maintain their airports in accordance with the conveyance instruments, • Evaluate sponsor requests for release, • Release qualifying property from sponsor federal obligations only when appropriate, and • Consider any planning and environmental actions needed.

In addition to any airport-specific federal obligations, surplus and nonsurplus property federal obligations will, for the most part, mirror language found today in most grant agreements with respect to the basic compliance requirements, i.e., exclusive rights, reasonable access, and unjust discrimination.

3.2. Background. Prior to the enactment of Public Law (Pub. L.) 80-289 in 1947, surplus property conveyance instruments were issued under the Surplus Property Act of 1944 (Surplus Property Act). As later amended, the Surplus Property Act was codified at 49 U.S.C. §§ 47151- 47153. The Surplus Property Act was the primary legislative effort by the U.S. Government to dispose of excess military equipment and infrastructure as World War II was coming to an end. The Surplus Property Act authorized the conversion of surplus military airports to civilian public use airports. The FAA recommends to the General Services Administration (GSA) which property should be transferred for airport purposes to public agencies. Prior to 1958, the Civil

Aeronautics Authority (CAA) made these recommendations. Neither the FAA nor the federal government owns the properties in question once they are transferred, but the government may retain a property interest.

The ownership of such property is generally transferred to the new public-entity owner (i.e., city, county, state, or airport authority) by instruments of property conveyance issued by the GSA. GSA has statutory jurisdiction over the disposal of properties that are declared to be surplus to the needs of the federal government. Prior to the establishment of the GSA in 1949, the War Assets Administration issued the property conveyance instruments.

3.3. The War Assets Administration (WAA). Upon enactment of the Surplus Property Act, the WAA, under general authority granted by the Surplus Property Act, conveyed significant amounts of federally owned surplus properties to public agencies. Before conveyance, the responsible government entity issued a declaration of surplus real property. For surplus airport properties conveyed under this authority, the WAA established certain terms and conditions and prescribed them in Regulation 16.3F3F1 A copy of Regulation 16 is provided as Appendix I.

Public Law (P.L.) No. 80-289, adopted in 1947, amended the 1944 Surplus Property Act to authorize the Administrator of the WAA (and later GSA) to convey to any state, political subdivision, municipality, or tax-supported institution surplus federally owned real and personal property for airport purposes without monetary consideration to the United States.

These conveyances of surplus property are subject to the terms, conditions, reservations, and restrictions prescribed in the instruments of conveyance. In other words, the properties were conveyed with strings attached, which are the sponsor’s federal obligations.

Conveyances of surplus property are subject to the terms, conditions, reservations, and restrictions prescribed in the

instruments of conveyance. In other words, the properties

were conveyed with strings attached, which are the

sponsor’s federal obligations.

3.4. Nonairport Property. Prior to the amendment of the Surplus Property Act by P.L. No. 80-289, the WAA took the position that it had no authority to convey to public agencies any property other than that which had been, and was intended to be, used solely for the operation and maintenance of an airport. This precluded the transfer of some types of buildings, facilities, and other nonairport properties comprising parts of surplus military air bases formerly operated by the federal government.

1 Note: Regulation 16 from the Surplus Property Act is different from section 16 of the Federal Airport Act of 1946.

Each conveyance of revenue-production property federally

obligates the public agency recipient to use the revenue generated by the property for the operation, maintenance,

or development of the airport.

3.5. The Use of Property for Revenue Production. Public Law 80-289 specifically authorized the GSA to transfer such surplus nonairport property as needed to develop sources of revenue from nonaeronautical commercial businesses at a public use airport. This essentially became the point at which the FAA began tracing the requirement to use airport property for aeronautical purposes. If the property is not used for aeronautical purposes directly, the property must be used to generate revenue for the benefit of the airport consistent with FAA’s Policy and Procedures Concerning the Use of Airport Revenue, 64 Fed. Reg. 7696 (February 16, 1999) (Revenue Use Policy). Unless specifically permitted by the deed of conveyance, the FAA must approve the use for nonaeronautical purposes before such use is allowed.

As a precondition to a land conveyance, the WAA (and later the GSA) needed to determine that such surplus nonairport property was needed by the airport and would be used as a source of revenue to defray the cost of operation, maintenance, and development of the public use airport. Originally, the GSA conveyance instrument made no distinction between federal obligations imposed on property conveyed for aeronautical use and those imposed on property conveyed for nonaeronautical, revenue-production purposes.

Each federal conveyance of revenue production property obligates the public-agency sponsor to use the revenue generated by the nonaeronautical use for the operation, maintenance, or development of the airport. Consequently, if the property conveyed has been determined by the GSA, with FAA concurrence, to be used for revenue-production purposes, the airport sponsor must use the revenue generated by the property for airport purposes by depositing the revenues in an airport fund designated for airport use. This is true even if the property is not specifically identified as revenue producing in the conveyance instrument.

3.6. Highest and Best Use and Suitability for Airport Use. In order for any surplus real or personal property to be transferred, the FAA must determine that it is essential, suitable, or desirable for the development, improvement, operation, or maintenance of a public airport. This includes real property needed to develop sources of revenue from nonaeronautical commercial businesses at a public airport. (See 49 U.S.C. § 47151(a).)

Highest and best use has been defined – when appraising the market value of real property – as the “reasonably probable and legal use of property that is physically possible, appropriately supported, and financially feasible, and that results in the highest value.” (See Dictionary of Real Estate Appraisal, 4th Edition, Appraisal Institute; see also Olson v. United States, 292 U.S. 246, 255, 1934) (“The highest and most profitable use for which the property is adaptable and needed or likely to be needed in the reasonably near future.”); Bloom Company v. Patterson, 98 U.S. 403, 408 (1878). The highest and best use must be based on:

the economic potential of the property;

qualitative values (social or environmental) of the property; and

use factors affecting land use (e.g., zoning, physical characteristics, private and public uses in the vicinity, neighboring improvements, utility services, access, roads, location, and environmental and historical considerations).

It is the task of an appraiser to evaluate competing land uses and determine the “highest and best” use of the land and appraise the fair market value of the property at its “highest and best” use based on sales of property that sold and were used at that same “highest and best” use. Any "highest and best use" determination should consider the probability of achieving such use and should not be speculative.

3.7. Types of Conveyance Instruments for Surplus Property. The federal government has used three basic instruments to transfer ownership of federally owned surplus property for public use airport purposes:

The WAA instrument prescribed in Regulation 16 conveyed surplus real property for public use airport purposes prior to the amendment of the Surplus Property Act of 1944 by Pub. L. 80-289.

The GSA real property instrument issued under Pub. L. 80-289 conveyed surplus real property, or a combination of surplus real and airport-related personal property for public use airport purposes.

The GSA personal property instrument issued under Pub. L. 80-289 conveyed only surplus airport-related personal property for public use airport purposes.

Each instrument of conveyance of surplus property for public use airport purposes sets forth the particular rights retained by the federal government and the specific federal

obligations assumed by the airport sponsor following the

transfer of ownership.

Each federal instrument of conveyance of surplus property for public use airport purposes, regardless of its form or format, sets forth the particular rights retained by the federal government and the specific federal obligations assumed by the airport sponsor following the transfer of ownership.

3.8. Sponsor Federal Obligations for Surplus Property. A conveyance document may contain one or more special conditions. Special conditions are in addition to the conditions required by the Surplus Property Act. Also, at different times, the WAA and the GSA may have used different wording of the statute or a requirement in their various types of property conveyance instruments.

War Assets Administration Regulation 16 Conveyance. Instruments of conveyance, also known as instruments of disposal, issued under WAA Regulation 16 are not consistently

uniform. One common variation in WAA conveyance instruments is the provision relating to joint military use of the airport. Some WAA property conveyance instruments give the federal government the right to unlimited use of the airport by federally owned aircraft without charge. Others stipulate that the use by federally owned aircraft may not exceed a specified percentage of the capacity of the airport if such use interferes with other authorized uses. Regulation 16 conveyances are typically the most restrictive. In some cases, they incorporate reversion clauses (see chapter 23, Reversions of Airport Property). Regulation 16 properties must be operated for public airport purposes. Property, as well as structures, cannot be used for any other purposes – including revenue-producing, manufacturing, or industrial purposes – without FAA written concurrence . (For additional Regulation 16 information, see Appendix I of this Order, SPA Reg. 16.)

GSA Public Law 80-289 Conveyance. Instruments of conveyance under Pub. L. 80-289 issued by the GSA are generally similar in form and content. In some cases, however, certain terms and conditions may be different. Therefore, the actual obligating documents must be reviewed in the initial phase of an investigation. (See https://uscode.house.gov for a copy of Pub. L. 80-289.)

Operation of the Entire Airport. Most of the property conveyance instruments issued by the WAA and GSA that conveyed real and airport-related personal property contain provisions obligating the sponsor to operate and maintain the entire airport where the property is located, regardless of the amount of property conveyed.

National Emergency Use Provision (NEUP). Practically all WAA and GSA conveyance instruments transferring ownership of surplus real and airport-related personal property to airport sponsors for public use airport purposes contain the NEUP. This provision retains the right of the United States to make exclusive or joint use of the airport, or any portion thereof, during a war or national emergency. This has actually happened several times since World War II, particularly after the United States’ involvement in the Korean War began in 1951. Two examples of airports that were reactivated are Sanford, Florida, and Brown Field, California. However, while the authorizing statutes require this provision to be included in all such conveyance instruments, it has been discovered that the NEUP was omitted from a few conveyance instruments issued by WAA and GSA. (For additional information, refer to Chapter 22, Releases from Federal Obligations.)

NEUP Case Study: Sanford Naval Air Station. The City of Sanford is in the northwestern portion of Seminole County, approximately 16 nautical miles (or 18 statute miles) northeast of Orlando, Florida. The Orlando Sanford Airport is in the southeastern portion of the City of Sanford. The Airport began its history prior to the 1940s as an 865-acre airport equipped with two runways. On June 11, 1942, the City of Sanford deeded the airport to the U.S. Navy and the airport became a Naval Air Station. The Navy acquired an additional 615 acres of land for the station and immediately began construction of its facilities. Many of these facilities are still present at the airport today. Some of these facilities currently serve as storage hangars. In 1943, active flight operations began at the Naval Air Station; the station served as a fighter and divebomber training base. Following World War II, the Naval Air Station was decommissioned. The City of Sanford reacquired the land and the facility, now known as the Orlando Sanford Airport. After the Korean War began in 1951, the Navy once again acquired the airport and purchased an additional 164 acres, bringing the total acreage of the airport to 1,644. The airport operated as a

training base for fighter, attack, and reconnaissance aircraft until it closed in June of 1968. The City of Sanford realized that closing the base would pose an economic threat to the local economy. To limit this threat, the City negotiated with the federal government for the property purchase. It was ultimately purchased for the sum of $1.00. This case study illustrates the U.S. Government exercising its option to reactivate a former military facility in case of national need.

3.9. Duration of Surplus Property Federal Obligations. The duration of the federal obligations assumed by airport sponsors for surplus federal property depends on the type of property conveyed.

Real Property. The federal obligations set forth in surplus airport property conveyance instruments (except those conveying only personal property) provide that the covenants assumed by the sponsor regarding the use, operation, and maintenance of the airport and the property transferred shall be deemed to run with the land. This means that subsequent owners or successors of the land would be subject to the covenants. Accordingly, such covenants continue in full force and effect until released under the Surplus Property Act, as amended. (See 49 U.S.C. § 47153.)

Personal Property. In most cases, conveyance instruments transferring ownership of surplus real property also convey airport-related personal property. Accountability for the personal property conveyed in this manner is for its useful life not to exceed one year.2

Trade-in of Personal Property. Airport sponsors may dispose of conveyed personal property that has outlived its useful life. If the sponsor uses such property for trade-in on new equipment, the FAA will not hold that sponsor accountable for that new equipment.

3.10. Review of Specific Federal Surplus Property Obligations. In order to identify the specific federal obligations assumed by a nonfederal public agency in accepting surplus federal property conveyed for public use airport purposes, the office assessing the compliance status of a federally obligated airport sponsor must consult the actual surplus property conveyance instruments.

Public agencies may receive surplus property from the GSA for public airport purposes. FAA has a key role in making recommendations to GSA regarding the suitability and amount of property considered necessary for airport purposes. FAA Order 5150.2, Federal Surplus Property for Public Airport Purposes, provides detailed guidance on FAA participation in the conveyance of surplus federal property.

The obligating document may grant a fee simple interest through a quitclaim deed, or, alternatively, a lease from the U.S. Government. The actual obligations of the airport sponsor can vary significantly based on the kind of conveyance at issue.

In addition to any deed obligations, sponsors that have accepted an AIP grant have certain rights and responsibilities under AIP Grant Assurance 27, Use by Government Aircraft. Grant Assurance 27 requires a sponsor to accommodate operations by Federal government aircraft

2 FAA Order 5150.2A, Federal Surplus Property for Public Airport Purposes, Section 6, paragraph 87, Termination of Accountability.

without charge unless Federal agencies are making “substantial” use of the airport. See Section 3.20.a below.

3.11. Nonsurplus Federal Land Conveyances. Federally owned or controlled land that is not surplus (not in excess of federal needs) may be conveyed for airport purposes under the authority contained in section 516 of the Airport and Airway Improvement Act of 1982 (AAIA). (See 49 U.S.C. § 47125 for current provision.) Prior to the effective date of the AAIA, similar authority existed in section 16 of the Federal Airport Act of 1946 and section 23 of the Airport and Airway Development Act of 1970 (1970 Airport Act).3 There are many instances where a government entity, such as the Department of Interior’s (DOI) Bureau of Land Management (BLM) agreed to convey nonsurplus land for public use, including use as an airport. This is particularly common in the western states. FAA records indicate that about 170 airports have benefited from nonsurplus conveyances.

3.12. Land Conveyance Federal Obligations. Instruments of conveyance transferring ownership of nonsurplus federal land issued under sections 16, 23, 516 or under 49 U.S.C. § 47125 impose upon the airport sponsor certain federal obligations regarding the use of the lands conveyed. There are terms, conditions, and covenants included in the property conveyance instruments, deeds, or quitclaim instruments. These terms include requirements that:

The airport sponsor will use the conveyed property for airport purposes and will develop that property for airport purposes within one year or as set forth in the conveyance instrument, deed, or quitclaim instrument.

The airport sponsor will operate the airport, together with its appurtenant areas, buildings, and facilities regardless of whether they are on the land being conveyed, as a public use airport on fair and reasonable terms and without unjust discrimination.

The airport sponsor will not grant or permit any exclusive right in the operation and use of the airport, together with its appurtenant areas, buildings, and facilities regardless of whether they are on the land being conveyed, as required by section 303 of the Federal Aviation Act of 1938, as amended, and section 308(a) of the Federal Aviation Act of 1958 (FAA Act) 85 Pub. L. 726 (1958), as amended 49 U.S.C §4010 et seq.

Any subsequent transfer of the conveyed property interest to another nonfederal public entity will be subject to the terms, conditions, and covenants set forth in the original instrument of conveyance.

In the event of a breach of any term, condition, or covenant contained in the conveyance instrument, the airport sponsor will, on demand, take such action as required to transfer

3 Prior to 1986, FAA Order 5170.1, Transfer of Federal Lands, Section 23 of the Airport and Airway Development Act of 1970, issued March 18, 1977, provided detailed guidance for the FAA in reviewing and processing applications by nonfederal public agencies to receive federally owned land conveyed for the development, improvement, or future use of a public airport. This Order was cancelled on January 10, 1986.

ownership of the conveyed premises to the U.S. Government. See also 49 U.S.C. § 49125(a) (providing the property interest reverts to the U.S. Government, at the option of the Secretary).

All or any part of the property interest conveyed under section 16 shall automatically revert to the U.S. Government (through the GSA for assignment) in the event that the land in question is not developed for airport purposes or used in a manner consistent with the terms of the conveyance.

3.13. Bureau of Land Management. Many airports in the western states are located on public land. The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) has statutory authority in the Airport Act of 1928 to lease up to 2,560 acres of public lands for use as a public airport.

Under the AAIA, the BLM may continue to convey, subject to reversion, lands to a public agency for an airport. These leases are located near small towns, mining operations, and ranches. Local governments hold many of these leases. The FAA is involved in the approval of these leases and conveyances.

3.14. Federal Obligations Imposed by Other Government Agencies. In some instances, the government agency issuing the conveyance instrument may impose special conditions or federal obligations. Therefore, consult the particular deed by which the lands were conveyed to determine all the conditions and covenants.

3.15. Duration of Nonsurplus Federal Obligations. Terms, conditions, covenants, and other federally obligating provisions in conveyance instruments issued under sections 16, 23, and 516 remain in force and effect as long as the land is held by a nonfederal public agency, its successors, or assignees. Section 817 of Pub. L. 112-95 (FAA Modernization and Reform Act of 2012) gave the FAA the authority to grant releases from sections 16 and 23. Section 141 of Pub.L. 115-254 (FAA Reauthorization Act of 2018) gave FAA the authority to grant releases from Section 516, codified at 49 U.S.C. § 47125.

In addition, obligations may be amended or modified to provide for a greater or lesser property interest as dictated by the needs of the airport.

Nonsurplus federal land conveyance instruments issued under sections 16, 23, and 516 provide for reversion to the U.S. Government in the event the lands are not developed,

or cease to be used, for airport purposes.

3.16. Reversion Provisions. Nonsurplus federal land conveyance instruments issued under sections 16, 23, and 516 provide for reversion to the U.S. Government in the event the lands are not developed, or cease to be used, for airport purposes. If the land conveyed under sections 16, 23, and 516 is no longer used or needed for any airport purpose, the FAA must invoke the reversion provision in accordance with the terms of the deed unless the airport sponsor willingly agrees to reversion of the property voluntarily. (See chapter 23 of this Order, Reversions of Airport Property, for additional details on reversions.)

Section 16 Conveyances. The Federal Airport Act of 1946 required that conveyances of nonsurplus federal land under section 16 be subject to the condition that, if the land is not

developed as an airport or ceases to be used for airport purposes, the property interest conveyed shall automatically revert to the U.S. Government.

Section 23/516 Conveyances. Conveyance instruments issued under section 23 of the 1970 Airport Act or section 516 of the AIAA do not contain the automatic property reversion requirement contained in conveyance instruments issued under section l6. They do, however, provide the Secretary of Transportation the option of reverting nonsurplus federal land undeveloped or not used for airport purposes by the airport sponsor. The Secretary has assigned this discretionary authority to the FAA Administrator. The Administrator will decide, on behalf of the U.S. Government, whether to recover title to all or any part of the property interests conveyed.

3.17. Airport Sponsor Compliance. The range of terms, conditions, and covenants contained in the instruments of nonsurplus property conveyance under sections 16, 23, and 516, can have significant differences. There are variations of nonsurplus conveyance federal obligations because of different authorizing legislation, amendments over time, as well as special conditions and obligations imposed by the conveying federal agency in response to airport-specific circumstances. Therefore, in assessing an airport sponsor's compliance status, the FAA must review each instrument of nonsurplus federal property conveyance under sections 16, 23, and 516 entered into by the airport sponsor.

3.18. The AP-4 Land Agreements. Federal legislation enacted between 1939 and 1944 authorized the Development of Landing Areas for National Defense (DLAND) and the Development of Civil Landing Areas (DCLA) programs. The Work Project Administration and the CAA jointly administered the DLAND programs. In general, under these two federal programs (DLAND and DCLA), existing publicly owned airports were transferred to the federal government for development and use at its discretion, subject to the terms and conditions of an instrument known as an AP-4 Agreement. The AP-4 Agreement contained the applicable federal obligations. After considering the types of improvements, design standards, construction methods, and normal deterioration, the FAA has administratively determined that the useful life of all improvements on airports subject to AP-4 Agreements has expired. Termination of an AP- 4 Agreement relieved the airport sponsor only of the contractual federal obligations imposed in the agreement. The sponsor remains subject to the exclusive rights prohibition for as long as the airport is operated as an airport.

3.19. Base Conversion and Surplus Property. The FAA works with the Department of Defense (DoD) (the Army, Air Force, and Navy) and local civil airport sponsors to convert military airfields to civil use.4 The agency also works with the GSA on airport property disposals under the Surplus Property Act, as amended. (See 49 U.S.C. § 47151, et seq.). (See Appendix J of this Order, DoD Base Realignment and Closure (BRAC), for a listing of air bases converted from military to civil use under the BRAC laws.) The FAA manages surplus property transfers

4 Since 1989, approximately 32 military airfields have been converted to civil use by local communities. This includes two military airfields that recently converted to civil aviation use (Roosevelt Roads Naval Air Station, PR, and Brunswick Naval Air Station, ME). Fifteen of the surplus military airfields have become commercial service airports, and four have significant cargo service (Sacramento Mather, CA; Rickenbacker International, OH; Stewart International, NY; and Guam International, GU). The remaining surplus airfields are in areas where additional general aviation airports are needed

for airports, military base conversions, and the promotion of joint use of existing military air bases. A sample of a recent surplus property conveyance or deed is provided in Appendix V of this Order, Sample Deed of Conveyance. (Note: Information in samples is for example only.) The FAA also administers the Military Airport Program (MAP).4F4F5 The MAP provides financial assistance to the civilian sponsors who are converting, or have already converted, military airfields to civilian or joint military/civilian use. To aid in this process, MAP grants may be used for projects not generally funded by the Airport Improvement Program (AIP), such as buildings, rehabilitating surface parking lots, fuel farms, hangars, utility systems, access roads, and cargo buildings.

3.20. Joint Use and Federal Use of Obligated Airports.

FAA also works with the various DoD military departments on the joint use of existing military airports when a civil sponsor wants to use the military airfield. Under 49 U.S.C. § 47175, a “Joint-Use Airport” as an airport owned by the DoD,6 at which both military and civilian aircraft make shared use of the airfield.7 It is noted however, that the term “Joint Use” is also commonly used in situations addressing military use of civilian airports where the military is a tenant at a civilian airport.8

There are three types of agreements under which the government has the right to joint use of airport facilities, either with or without charge.

Grant Agreements. The sponsor's assurances, which accompany the project application, provide that all facilities of the airport developed with federal aid and all those usable for the landing and taking off of aircraft will be available to the United States at all times without charge for use by government aircraft in common with others. However, the assurances provide that if such use is deemed substantial, a reasonable share of the cost of operating and maintaining the facilities used, in proportion to the use, may be charged. Substantial use is defined in the assurances as: (1) five or more government aircraft are regularly based at the airport or on land adjacent thereto; or (2) the total number of calendar month operations (counting each landing and each takeoff as a separate operation) of government aircraft is 300 or more; or (3) the gross accumulative weight of government aircraft using the airport in a calendar month (the total

5 Under 49 U.S.C. § 47118, the Secretary can designate up to 15 current or former military airports for inclusion in the Military Airport Program (MAP). These general aviation, commercial service, or reliever airports can receive grants for projects necessary to convert the airports to civilian use or to reduce congestion, including grants for projects not generally funded by the Airport Improvement Program (AIP).

6 For the purposes of this Order, the DoD includes all the Armed Forces, including the Coast Guard. (10 U.S.C. § 101(a)(4))

7 49 U.S.C. § 47175; 14 CFR § 139.5.

8 Not all Joint Use Airfields are federally obligated.

operations of government aircraft multiplied by gross certified weights of such aircraft) is in excess of five million pounds.

Pub. L. 80-289. Surplus Airport Property Instruments of Transfer issued under P.L. No. 80- 289 provide that:

The United States shall at all times have the right to make nonexclusive use of the landing area (runways, taxiways and aprons) of the airport without charge, except that such use may be limited as may be determined at any time by the Administrator of FAA to be necessary to prevent undue interference with use by other authorized aircraft and provide further that the United States shall be obligated to pay for any damage caused by its use, and if the use is substantial9, to contribute a reasonable share of the cost of maintaining and operating the landing area, in proportion to such use.

Regulation 16 Transfer. Surplus Airport Property Instruments of Transfer issued under WAA Regulation 16 (i.e., prior to the effective date of P.L. No. 80-289) provide that the government shall at all times have the right to use the airport in common with others provided that such use may be limited as determined by the FAA Administrator to be necessary to prevent interference with use by other authorized aircraft, so long as such limitation does not restrict government use to less than 25 percent (25%) of the capacity of the airport. These instruments of transfer further provide that government use of the airport to this extent shall be without charge of any nature other than payment for any damage caused.

Negotiation Regarding Charges. In all cases where the airport owner proposes to charge the government for use of the airport under the joint use provision, negotiations should be between the airport owner and the government agency or agencies using that airport.

Joint Use Agreements. The airport sponsor (including the sponsor of a federally obligated civil airport or sponsor of a DoD-owned facility for which AIP has funded infrastructure improvements for civil use) must take care not to enter into agreements that will preclude the sponsor from receiving future AIP grants. For example, if the airport sponsor agrees to certain limitations on the number of civilian aircraft takeoffs and landings or agrees to Prior Permission Requirements (PPRs), this may effectively prevent or limit general aviation access in a way that is impermissible under the grant assurances. The FAA Regions and ADOs are available upon request to review proposed joint use agreements between the DoD and airport sponsors to ensure that the airport’s interests are protected and to preserve the sponsor’s eligibility for grant assistance. This review is effective only if done before any agreements are signed. The FAA is not a party to and does not approve joint use agreements. Remember, the DoD is responsible for protecting its interests; the airport sponsor is responsible for preserving and protecting the airport’s interests and complying with the grant assurances and other federal requirements. It is important to remember that in cases involving military units, the military entity in question may be subject to military regulations relating to fee negotiations. For example, Appendix J-1 of this Order provides a hyperlink to Air National Guard Pamphlet 32-1001, 2 August 2013, entitled Airport Joint Use Agreements for Military Use of Civilian Airfields. This pamphlet implements AFPD 10-10, Civil Aircraft Use of United States Air Force Airfields, and AFPD 32-10,

9 For guidance on substantial use, see Chapter 7 of this Order.

Installations and Facilities, and applies to Air National Guard flying units that operate on public airports. This pamphlet provides guidance for negotiating fair and reasonable charges to the government for joint use of the public airport’s flying facilities.

Provision for altered military use. The airport sponsor should review deed language and the provisions of any DoD agreements to determine if there is any provision for a change in military use of the airport.

3.21. through 3.25. reserved.

Sample Surplus Property Conveyance - Page 1

(Information in samples is for example only.)

Part II: Types of Federal Agreements › Chapter 4: Federal Grant Obligations and Responsibilities

Chapter 4: Federal Grant Obligations and Responsibilities

Updated November 2022

4.1. Introduction. This chapter provides a brief description of the three FAA grant programs for airports, the duration of federal obligations, the useful life of grant funded projects, and the legislatively mandated sponsor compliance requirements. It is the responsibility of the FAA Airports District Offices (ADOs) and regional airports divisions to ensure that the sponsors understand and comply with their grant assurances.

4.2. Sponsor Federal Obligations Under Various Grant Agreements. Under the various federal grant programs, the sponsor of a project agrees to assume certain federal obligations pertaining to the operation and use of the airport. These federal obligations are embodied in the application for federal assistance as sponsor assurances. The federal obligations become a part of the grant offer, binding the grant recipient when it accepts federal funds for airport development.

Grant Programs Since 1946, the FAA has administered three primary grant programs for development of airports:

(1). The Federal Aid to Airports Program (FAAP) pursuant to the Federal Airport Act of 1946, as amended, until repealed in 1970.

(2). The Airport Development Aid Program (ADAP) pursuant to the Airport and Airway Development Act of 1970 (1970 Airport Act), as amended, until repealed in 1982.

(3). The Airport Improvement Program (AIP) pursuant to the Airport and Airway Improvement Act of 1982 (AAIA), as amended. (See 49 U.S.C. § 47101, et seq.) Grants issued to airports under Public Law 117-58-Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act referred to as the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law (BIL)1, contained the same sponsor assurances as the AIP program.

(4). Occasionally, there are time limited special funding programs authorized by Congress to provide federal grants to airports for a specific purpose such as economic development or recovery. These have included: American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA) (Public Law 111-5); Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act (H.R. 748, Public Law 116-136), Coronavirus Response and Relief Supplemental Appropriation Act (CRRSAA) (Public Law 116-260), American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 (ARPA) (H.R. 1319, Public Law 117-2). These grants were generally time limited and the specific grant agreement should be reviewed to determine the federal obligations associated with the grant.

In addition, the FAA has on occasion issued additional grant programs. These were primarily focused national economic recovery (e.g., Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES Act), American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA), Coronavirus Response and

1 BIL funds were split into different funding buckets for Airport Infrastructure Grants (AIG), Federal Contract Tower program (FCT), and Airport Terminal Program grants (ATP).

Relief Supplemental Appropriations (CRRSA)) and contained certain federal obligations for the life of the grant.

Assurances Pertaining to Grant Agreements. Each of these FAA administered federal airport financial assistance programs required airport sponsors to agree to certain assurances under the authorizing legislation of the grant programs. Certain assurances remain consistent from one grant program to the next. Other assurances were added by legislative mandate as the grant programs developed. Some assurances were superseded over time. In addition, the FAA has statutory authority to prescribe additional assurances or requirements for sponsors. (See 49 U.S.C. § 47107(g).) Also, some grant agreements contain special covenants or conditions intended to address an airport-specific situation.

Special Project Conditions. This Order generally does not address special conditions under which the FAA funded a particular project. An example of a special condition might be that funds are not available to a sponsor until the sponsor provides an updated Airport Layout Plan (ALP). Special conditions are enforced in the same manner as other federal obligations. (See FAA Order: 5100.38, Airport Improvement Program Handbook, Paragraph 5.23(e) Special Conditions.)

4.3. The Duration of Federal Grant Obligations. Federal obligations relating to the use, operation, and maintenance of the airport remain in effect throughout the useful life of the facilities developed under the project, but not to exceed 20 years, unless otherwise defined in the grant assurances or special conditions of the grant. .

Obligations with Land Acquisition. In regard to land acquired with federal assistance (e.g., FAAP, ADAP, AIP), so long as the airport sponsor has taken an ADAP or AIP grant since May 1980, the federal obligations on the acquired land remain in effect until released by the FAA.2 The following background information is helpful to understanding this requirement:

(1). An airport sponsor who accepted an ADAP or AIP grant after 1980 agreed that the covenants on real property acquired with Federal funds are unlimited. This is consistent with federal grant law generally, which provides that a grant of real property must be used for its intended purpose until and unless released by the government. The public has been on notice of this since at least 1980.

(2). The “Duration and Applicability” section for the current grant assurances3 and in every set of assurances for an ADAP and AIP grant since 1980 has contained the following language:

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 1100 passages shown