Radar Vectors
FAA Order Cancelled Issued Dec 14, 1988 AGC-300 532 pages Copy saved Nov 18, 2026

Order 2150.3A Compliance and Enforcement Program

This document is cancelled. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.

Official source ↗ Open PDF

Text read by OCR from a scanned file (439 of 532 pages). Check the original, as some words may be misread.

ORDER

COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

Incorporated Changes 1 thru 19 Reprinted 8/97 ,

December 14, 1988

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

Distribution: A-W-1 ;A-W (AT/PS/SM) -2;A-w (PP/AS /AM/SF/GC/FS/ Initiated By: AGC-320 U/VS)-3 ;A-XYZ-1 ;A-Z(AT/AF/CS)-2;~-X(AS/A;M/GC/FS)-3;~-Y (AM/AR/GC)-3;~-z (AM/AN/GC)-3; A-FAS/FAC/FSS/FCS-O(ALL);A-FAF/FAT/FI~O(LTD);ZFS-~~~

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

1. PURPOSE: This change transmits Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin No. 94-1, Streamlined Enforcement Test and Evaluation Program.

2. EXPLANATION OF CHANGES: This change transmits Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin No. 94-1, which sets forth implementing guidance for the Federal Aviation Administration's Streamlined Enforcement Test and Evaluation Program, which was recommended by the Vice President's National Performance Review.

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

This program emphasizes shorter timeframes for processing certain civil penalty cases involving individuals presenting deadly or dangerous weapons for screening at airport checkpoints or in checked baggage ("weapons cases").

The program will be tested at two FAA regions--Great Lakes and Southwest--for a period of 1 year beginning December 1, 1994.

3. DISPOSITION OF TRANSMITTAL: After filing the attached pages, this transmittal should be retained.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

@~u;(&A David R. inson

Administrator

ix 6/17/91 x 11/28/94 157 thru 181 11/28/94

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 18

4/20/94

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

1. pURPOSE. This change transmits revised Chapter 2, Compliance and Enforcement Policy and Objectives.

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

2. gXPLAfJATION OF CHANGES. This change retitles Chapter 2, Enforcement Objectives and Policy, as Compliance and Enforcement Policy and Objectives. The revised chapter emphasizes voluntary compliance and an increased flexibility in the exercise of discretion and judgment by investigating personnel to choose enforcement remedies that would best promote future regulatory compliance. The revision includes new criteria for determining when administrative action may be taken and an expanded

discussion of the various enforcement remedies available to the FAA to promote compliance.

3. DISPOSITION OF TWSMITTAL. After filing the attached pages, this transmittal should. be retained.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

11 thru 18 12/14/88 11 thru 34-1 19 thru 22-1 2/21/92 (and 34-2) 04/20/94 23 thru 30 (thru 34) 12/14/88 @&&A David R. Hlnson Administrator

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 17

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 17

2/4/93

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

1. PURPOSE. This change transmits Compliance/Enforcement Bulletin No. 93-1 that pertains to the policy and procedures .for the collection of administratively assessed civil penalties. The guidance contained in this bulletin supersedes paragraph m. and figures 6 and 11 of Compliance/Enforcement Bulletin No. 90-10.

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

2. EXPLANATION OF CHANGES. This change provides new guidance and procedures to be followed by Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) personnel for the collection of administratively assessed civil penalties. In effect, the new procedures shift primary responsibility for the administrative collection of civil penalties from the Assistant Chief Counsel's offices to the FAA accounting offices. This change also amends sample enforcement documents to reflect language required by the Federal Debt Collection Act and the Federal Claims Collection Act, and implementing regulations, and the Federal Claims Collection Standards. The new guidance also reflects changes brought about by the FAA Civil Penalty Administrative Assessment Act of 1992.

3. DISTRIBUTION OF TRANSMITTAL. After filing attached pages, this transmittal should be retained.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

ix 6/17/91 ix 6/17/91 x 7/21/92 x 2/4/93 Appendix 1 121 thru 155 2/4/93

John H. Cassady cting Chief Counsel

Distribution: A-W-1;A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2;A-W(PP/AS/M/SF/GC/FS/IA/Initiated By:AGC-320 VS-3;A-XYZ-1;A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2;A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3;A-Y(AM/AR/GC)-3 A-Z(AM/AN/GC)-3; A-FAS/FAC/FSS/FCS-0)(A11);A-FAF/FAT/FLA-0(LTD);ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 16

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 16

12/18/92

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

1. PURPOSE. This change transmits revised pages to Appendix 4, Sanction Guidance Table.

2. EXPLANATION OF CHANGES. This change provides new guidance to FAA personnel on the imposition of sanctions for security violations by individuals. It reflects the FAA's new policy of allowing administrative action to be taken in non-aggravated cases when such action will constitute an adequate deterrent, but retaining higher sanction amounts for those cases where there are aggravating circumstances and punitive action is required.

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

3. DISTRIBUTION OF TRANSMITTAL. After filing attached pages, this transmittal should be retained.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

Appendix 4 Appendix 4 Pages 20 & 21 12/14/88 Pages 20 thru 21-3 12/18/92

Richards Ádministrator

Distribution: A-W-1;A-2(AT/PS/SM)-2;A-2(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS/IA Initiated By:AGC-320 VS-3;A-XYZ-1;A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2;A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3;A-Y(AM/AR/GC)-3);A-z(AM/AN/GC)-3; A-FAS/FAC/FSS/FCS-O-(A11);A-FAF/FAT/FIA-O(Ltd);ZFS325

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 15

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 15

9/1/92

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

1. PURPOSE. This change amends Chapter 5, paragraph 501 by deleting 501f.

2. EXPLANATION OF CHANGES. Paragraph 501f requires determination of the identity of a military pilot who violates the Federal Aviation Regulations when an investigation reveals that the pilot is a holder of an FAA certificate and there is reason to question the qualification of the alleged violator. The paragraph has been misinterpreted in the past as requiring identification of military pilots in all circumstances. Deletion of this section has no significant effect on enforcement of regulations because if the military pilot holds an FAA certificate and the investigation reveals a reason to question the qualifications of the alleged violator, paragraph 50le requires a full investigation to be conducted in accordance with Chapter 4 and 9 of this order. Identifying an alleged violator is an integral part of conducting a full investigation under Chapter 4.

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

3. DISPOSITION OF TRANSMITTAL. After filing the attached pages, the transmittal should be retained.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

70 and 71 12/14/88 70 and 71 9/1/92

Kenneth P. Quinn Chief Counsel

Distribution: A-W-1;A-2(AT/PS/SM)-2:A-2(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS/IA/Initiated By: AGC-260 VS-3;A-XYZ-1;A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2;A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3;A-Y(AM/AR/GC)-3;A-Z(AM/AN/GC)-3; A-FAS/FAC/FSS/FCS-O-(A11);A-FAF/FAT/FIA-0(LTD);ZFS325

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 14

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 14

7/29/92

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

1. PURPOSE: This change transmits revised pages to Appendix 1, Compliance/ Enforcement Bulletin 90-8.

2. EXPLANATION OF CHANGES: This change provides new guidance to FAA personnel on the administration of the FAA's corrective action through remedial training program. It appears that some general aviation airmen may be under the impression that an admission of violation is a condition for participation in this program. The new guidance makes it clear that while an airman must cooperate with the FAA during the investigation, an admission is not required and that the letter of correction that follows successful completion of the training and closes out the incident constitutes neither an admission nor an adjudication of a violation.

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

3. DISTRIBUTION OF TRANSMITTAL. After filing the attached pages, this transmittal should be retained.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

47 thru 54 5/18/90 47 thru 54 7/29/92

Kenneth P. Quinn Chief Counsel

Distribution:A-W-1;A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2;A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS/IA/ Initiated By: AGC-260 VS-3;A-XYZ-1;A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2;A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3;A-Y(AM/AR/GC)-3 A-Z(AM/AN/GC)-3; A-FAS/FAC/FSS/FCS-0)(A11);A-FAF/FAT/FIA-O(LTD);ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

2150.3A CHG 13

7/21/92

SUBJ. COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

1. PURPOSE. This change transmits new pages to Appendix 1, Compliance/Enforcement Bulletin 92-3.

2. EXPLANATION OF CHANGES. This change transmits Compliance/Enforcement Bulletin 9-3, guidance on enforcement action in cases involving detection of simulated weapons during Federal Aviation Administration screening evaluations. It provides new policies for enforcement actions on the failure of air carriers to detect simulated weapons, explosive devices, and other test objects during screening evaluations conducted by FAA Civil Aviation Security special agents.

SUBJ. COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

3. DISTRIBUTION OF TRANSMITTAL. After filing the attached pages, this transmittal should be retained.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

ix and x 6/17/91 ix 6/17/91 x 7/21/92 Appendix 1 115 thru 119 7/21/92

Thomas C. Richards Administrator

Distribution:A-W-1;A-2(AT/PS/SM)-2;A-2(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS/IA/ Initiated By: AGC-320 VS-3;A-XYZ-1;A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2;A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3;A-Y(AM/AR/GC)-3; A-Z(AM/AN/GC)-3;A-FAS/FAC/FSS/FCS-0)(A11);A-FAF/FAT/FIA-O(LTD);ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 12

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 12

3/20/92

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

PURPOSE: This change transmits Compliance/Enforcement Bulletin No. 92-2, which provides implementing guidance for a' reporting and correction policy for holders of production approvals.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

ix and x 6/17/91 ix 6/17/91 x 3/20/92 Appendix 1 109 - 113 3/20/92

Barry Lambert Harris Acting Administrator

Distribution: A-W-1;A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2;A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS/IA/ VS)-3;A-XYZ-1;A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2;A-x(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3;A-Y(AM/AR/GC)-3; initiated By: AGC-260

A-Z(AM/AN/GC)-3;A-FAS/FAC/FSS/FCS-0)(A11);A-FAF/FAT/FIA-O(LTD);ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 11

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 11

2/21/92

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

1. PURPOSE. This change transmits revised pages to Chapter 2.

Enforcement Objectives and Policy. and to Chapter 12. Legal Enforcement Action.

2. EXPLANATION OF CHANGES. This change provides guidance to FAA personnel on when revocation or suspension action should be taken on an emergency basis. Generally when it is determined that the certificate holder lacks qualifications and the certificate holder is reasonably able to exercise the privileges of the certificate. emergency action to revoke the certificate should be taken in the interest of safety. Similarly. when there is a reasonable basis to question the certificate holder's qualifications and the certificate holder is reasonably able to exercise the privileges of the certificate. emergency action to suspend the certificate generally should be taken in the interest of safety.

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

3. DISPOSITION OF TRANSMITTAL. After filing the attached pages. the transmittal should be retained.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

19 thru 22 12/14/88 19 thru 22-1 (and 22-2) 2/21/92 144 and 145 12/14/88 144 and 145 2/21/92 145-1 (and 145-2) 12/14/88

Barry Lambert Harris Acting Administrator

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Distribution: A-W-1: A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2: A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS Initiated By: AGC-260 IA/VS)-3: A-XYZ-1: A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2: A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3: A-Y(AM/AR/GC)-3: A-Z(AM/AN/GC)-3: A-FAS/FAC/FSS/FCS-O)(All): A-FAF/FAT/FIA-O(LTD): ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 10

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 10

1/16/92

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

1. PURPOSE. This change transmits new pages to Appendix 1. Compliance/Enforcement Bulletin.

2. EXPLANATION OF CHANGES. This change transmits Compliance/ Enforcement Bulletin No. 92-1. Proportional Civil Penalties. These guidelines are a means of placing a relatively equivalent deterrent effect on each air carrier that violates the same Federal Aviation Regulation, by considering the size of the carrier in determining an appropriate civil penalty amount. This change is made in response Efficiency Review. to a recommendation from the General Aviation System Safety and

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

3. DISTRIBUTION OF TRANSMITTAL. After filing the attached pages. this transmittal should be retained.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

ix and x 6/17/91 ix 6/17/91 x 1/16/92 Appendix 1 103 thru 107 (and 108) 1/16/92

Barry Lambert Harris Acting Administrator

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Distribution: A-W-1: A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2. A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS Initiated By: AGC-260 IAVS)3: A-XYZ-1: A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2: A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3. A-Y(AM/AR/GC)-3: A-Z(AM/AN/GC}3: A-FAS/FAC/FFS/FCS-O)(Al!). A-FAF/FAT/FIA-O(LTD). ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 9

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 9

11/25/91

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

1. PURPOSE. This change transmits revised pages to Chapter 12, Legal Enforcement Action.

2. BACKGROUND. Chapter 2, Enforcement Objective and Policy, describes how the appropriate enforcement action is to be determined. An important objective in conducting the enforcement program is to achieve uniformity of action throughout FAA. To accomplish this, it sometimes is important for the Washington headquarters to quickly be aware of actions taken by the regions. For these reasons, in some cases coordination with the Washington headquarters is required before initiating an enforcement action, and in other cases information must be sent to the Washington headquarters at the same time the action is taken.

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

3. EXPLANATION OF CHANGES. This change amends the requirement for coordinating significant enforcement actions with the Washington headquarters. The determination of the type of legal enforcement action and sanction is the joint responsibility of the appropriate regional division and legal counsel. The policies, procedures, and guidelines set forth in this order shall be adhered to by all personnel.

4. DISPOSITION OF TRANSMITTAL. After filing the attached pages, this transmittal should be retained.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

138 and 139 12/14/88 138-1 thru 138-4 (and 138-6) 11/25/91 138-5 (and 138-6) 12/14/88

JOD ames B. Busey

Administrator

Distribution: A-W-1; A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2; A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS/ Initiated By: AGC-200 IA/VS)-3; A-XYZ-1; A-Z(AT/AF/CS)-2; A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3; A-Y(AM/AR/GC)-3; A-Z(AM/AN/GC)-3; A-FAS/FAC/FSS/FCS-O(A11); A-FAF/FAT/FIA-O(LTD); ZFS-325

CHANGE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 8

CHANGE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 8

6/17/91

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

PURPOSE: This change transmits Compliance/Enforcement Bulletin No. 91-1 not involve falsification. regarding enforcement action in cases involving drug convictions which do

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

ix - x 11/26/90 ix - x 6/17/91 Appendix 1 Pages 100-101

Kenneth P. Quinn Chief Counsel

Distribution: A-W-1; A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2; A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS IA/VS)-3; A-XYZ-1; A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2; A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3; A-Y(AM/AR/GC)-3 Initiated By: AGC-200 A-Z (AM/AN/GC)-3; A-FAS/FAC/FSS/FCS-0 (A11); A-FAF/FAT/FIA-0 (LTD); ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 7

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 7

11/26/90

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

PURPOSE: This change transmits Compliance/Enforcement Bulletin No. 90-1l implements the System Safety and Efficiency Review (SSER) recommendations relating to informal communication between inspectors and attorneys and special emphasis programs.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

ix 8/17/90 ix - x 11/26/90

Appendix 1 11/26/90 Pages 96-99

Gregory SWaIden Walde

Chief Couhsel

Distribution: A-W-1; A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2; A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS Initiated By: AGC-200 IA/VS)-3; A-XYZ-1; A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2; A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3; A-Y(AM/AR/AY/GC)-3 A-Z (AM/AN/GC)-3; A-FAS/FAC/FFS/FCS-0(Al1); A-FAF/FAT/FIA-0 (LID); ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

2150.3A CHG 6

8/17/90

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

PURPOSE: This change transmits Campliance/Enforcement Bulletin No. 90-10 which pertains to civil penalty assessment authority. The rules of practice implementing the FAA's authority to assess civil penalties were revised. This change also. amends the data element in Field 22 to add code 29, ACIEp/Voluntary Disclosure, to Appendix 3.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

ix 6/26/90 ix 8/17/90 Appendix 1 63-95 8/17/90 Appendix 3 3-4 10/20/89 Appendix 3 8/17/90 3-4

Grein S Walde GregorySWalden

Chief Counsel

A-W-1; A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2: A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS/ A-XYZ-1; A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2; A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3; A-P(HRAR9XY7GC)200 A-Z (AM/AN/GC) -3; A-FAS/FAC/FFS/FCS-0 (Al1) ; A-FAF/FAT/FIA-0 (LID); ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 5

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 5

6/26/90

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

PURPOSE: This change transmits Compliance/Enforcement Bulletin No. 90-9 which pertains to SSER recommendations relating to analysis of a violation; determination of appropriate sanction; and coordination within the Office of the Chief Counsel.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Page Dated Insert Pages Dated

ix 5/18/90 ix 6/26/90 Appendix 1 Pages 59-62 6/26/90

Gregry5. Walde Gregory S.Walden

Chief-Counsel

Distribution: A-W-1; A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2; A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS/ Initiated By: AGC-200 IA/VS)-3; A-XYZ-1; A-X(AT/AF/CS2; A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3; A-Y(AM/AR/AY/GC)-3; A-Z (AM/AN/GC-3; A-FAS/FAC/FFS/FCS-0(A11); A-FAF/FAT/FIA-0(LID); ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 4

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 4

3/18/90

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

PURPOSE: This change transmits Campliance/Enforcement Bulletins Nos. 90-5, 90-6, 90-7, and 90-8. No. 90-5 pertains to the policy and procedures for suspected violations of the FAA's alcohol- and drug-related prohibitions related to operation of aircraft. No. 90-6 pertains to reporting and correction policy and implementing guidance. No. 90-7 describes the revised Enforcement Investigative Report (EIR) format in Chapter 9A to be used in all Civil Aviation Security cases and does not change the guidance set forth in the existing Chapter 9.for the preparation of EIRs by any office other than Civil Aviation Security. No. 90-8 describes the agency's program of affording certificated pilot and non-pilot airmen who violate certain provisions of the Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR) remedial training in lieu of legal enforcement action.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

ix 3/5/90 ix 5/18/90 Appendix 1 Pages 17-58 5/18/90

Grecays Walle Gregory S. Walden

Chief Counsel

Distribution: A-W-1; A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2; A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS/ Initiated By: AGC-200 IA/VS)-3; A-XYZ-1; A-X(AT/AF/CS2; A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3; A-Y(AM/AR/AY/GC)-3; A-Z(AM/AN/GC-3; A-FAS/FAC/FFS/FCS-0 (A11); A-FAF/FAT/FIA-0 (LID); ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 3

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 3

3/5/90

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

PURPOSE: This change transmits Compliance/Enforcement Bulletins No. 90-3 and 90-4. Compliance/Enforcement Bulletin No. 90-3 pertains to unauthorized operations within Terminal Control Areas (TCA's). Compliance/Enforcement Bulletin No. 90-4 pertains to Coordination of enforcement actions against airmen (except air carrier personnel) in nonsignificant cases.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

ix 2/16/90 ix Appendix 1 Pages 14-16 3/5/90

GrgyS Waide Gregory s Walden

Chief Counsel

Distribution: A-W-1; A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2; A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS/ Initiated By: AGC-200 IA/VS)-3; A-XYZ-1; A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2; A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3; A-Y(AM/AR/AY/GC)-3; A-Z(AM/AN/GC-3; A-FAS/FAC/FFS/FCS-0(A11); A-FAF/FAT/FIA-0(LTD); ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 2

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 2150.3A CHG 2

2/16/90

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

PURPOSE: This change transmits Compliance/Enforcement Bulletins No. 90-1 and 90-2. Compliance/Enforcement Bulletin No. 90-1 pertains to unauthorized operations within newly established Terminal Control Areas (TCA's). Compliance/ Enforcement Bulletin No. 90-2 pertains to enforcement action for cases referred by the Inspector General of the Department of Transportation involving drug convictions and falsification of applications for airman medical certificates regarding drug- and alcohol-related convictions ("IG Match" cases), and other similar cases.

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated

ix 12/14/88 ix 2/16/90 Appendix 1 Pages 7-13 2/16/90

Grere S Walde Gregorywalden

Chief Counsel

Distribution: A-W-1; A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2; A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS/ Initiated By: AGC-200 IA/VS)-3; A-XYZ-1; A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2; A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3; A-Y(AM/AR/AY/GC)-3; A-Z (AM/AN/GC-3; A-FAS/FAC/FFS/FCS-0 (A11); A-FAF/FAT/FIA-0(LTD); ZFS325

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CHANGE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

SUBJ: COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM

PURPOSE:

2150.3A CHG 1

10/20/89

This change adds the following to Fields 20 and 22, Appendix 3:

28 IG Match 31 Airman - Alcohcl 32 Airman - Drug 33 Airman - Falsification 34 Alcohol/Flight Crew 35 Drugs/Flight Crew 36 Falsification/Flight Crew

PAGE CONTROL CHART

PAGE CONTROL CHART

REMOVE PAGES DATED INSERT PAGES

Appendix 3 Appendix 3 Pages 1 thru 4 12/14/88 Pages 1 thru

JohH.Cassrly

Chief Counsel

Distribution:A-W-1; A-W(AT/PS/SM)-2; A-W(PP/AS/AM/SF/GC/FS/

DATED

10/20/89

Initiated By: IA/VS)-3; A-XYZ-1; A-X(AT/AF/CS)-2; A-X(AS/AM/GC/FS)-3; A-Y(AM/AR/AY/GC)-3 A-Z (AM/AN/GC)-3; A-FAS/FAC/FFS/FCS-0(Al1); A-FAF/FAT/FIA-0(LTD); ZFS325

Appendix 3 Appendix 3 Pages 1 thru 4 12/14/88 Pages 1 thru

12/14/88 2150.3A

FOREWORD

This order has been prepared to provide compliance and enforcement program and procedural guidance for all agency personnel. The order, which updates and revises material previously contained in Order 2150.3, is designed as a ready reference for use at all levels of the agency in the investigation, reporting, and legal processing of enforcement cases. Any FAA employee involved in the compliance and enforcement program must read and become familiar with applicable provisions of this order.

Allan Meshton T. Allan McArtor

Administrator

Page i

4/20/94 2150.3A CHG 18

TABLE OF CONTENTS

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page No.

CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION

100. Purpose 1 101. Distribution 1 102. Cancellations 1 103. Explanation of Changes 1 104. Forms and Reports 2 105. Changes to This Order 2 106. Suppiemental Enforcement Instructions 2 107. Compliance/Enforcement Bulletins 3 108. Definitions 3 109.-199. Reserved 3

CHAPTER 2. COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT POLICY AND OBJECTIVES 11

CHAPTER 2. COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT POLICY AND OBJECTIVES 11

200. Purpose 11 201. The Need for a Compliance and Enforcement Program 11 202. Compliance and Enforcement Philosophy 12 203. Guidelines for Processing Enforcement Actions 15 204. Procedures for Selecting Compliance and Enforcement Action 18 205. Administrative Action 21 206. Determining the Type of Legal Enforcement Action 24 207. Determining the Sanction Amount 30 208. Investigating and Processing Enforcement Cases Under the Geographicai Concept 31 209. Complex or Controversial Enforcement Cases 34 210.-299."Reserved 34-1

CHAPTER 3. ENFORCEMENT RESPONSIBILITIES 35

CHAPTER 3. ENFORCEMENT RESPONSIBILITIES 35

300. Purpose 35 301. Cooperation and Communication Within FAA 35 302. Headquarters 35 303. Regions 35 304. Aeronautical Center 36 305. Field Offices 36 306. Air Traffic Service 36 307. All Agency Employees 36 308. Office of Inspector General 36 309.-399. Reserved 37

CHAPTER 4. INVESTIGATION OF VIOLATIONS 41

CHAPTER 4. INVESTIGATION OF VIOLATIONS 41

400. Purpose 41 401. Role of the Inspector in an Investigation 41 402. Planning and Initiating the Investigation 41 403. Letters of Investigation 42

Page ii

2150.3A

404. Obtaining Violation History and Other Information. 405. Evidence of Violations. 406. Interviews. 407. Photographs. 408. Charts, Maps, and Diagrams. 409. Documents and Records. 410. Physical Evidence. 411. Submission of Additional Evidence/Material. 412. Coordinating the Investigation. 413. Voluntary Surrender of Certificate 414.-499. RESERVED. Figure 4-l. Sample Notice of Aircraft Condition Figure 4-2. Sample Letter of Investigation - Flight Operations Figure 4-3. Sample Letter of Investigation - Operations Figure 4-4. Sample Letter of Investigation - Maintenance Figure 4-5. Sample Letter of Investigation - Airport Security Figure 4-6. Sample Letter of Investigation - Airport Operations Figure 4-7. Sample Letter of Investigation - Manufacturing Figure 4-8. Sample Letter of Notification - Closing of Investigation Figure 4-9. Privacy Act Notice Figure 4-l0. Certificate of Authenticity

CHAPTER 5. SPECIAL INVESTIGATIVE PROCEDURES.

500. Purpose. 501. Violations by Members of the U.S. Armed Forces 502. Violations of Foreign Aviation Regulations. 503. Violations of U.S. Regulations By Foreign Persons or Companies. 504. Violations by Agency Employees and Agency-Operated Repair Stations. 505. Violations of the Hazardous Materials Regulations. 506. Violations By Individuals of FAR Sections 107.21 or 108.11. 507. Violations By Individuals of FAR Section 91.8, Prohibiting Interference With Crewmembers.

Page iii

12/14/88

Page No.

44 44 45 48 48 48 52

53 53 54 54

59

60

61

62

63

64

65

67 68 69

70

70

71

72

72

73

74

74

12/14/88

508. Exclusive Rights and Unjust Discrimination at Airports. 509. Cases Involving Submission to Alcohol Testing. 510.-599. RESERVED. Figure 5-l. Sample Authorization For the Release of Test Results to the Federal Aviation Administration. Figure 5-2. Sample Letter Requesting Release of Alcohol Test Results. Figure 5-3. Privacy Act Notice For Submission to Alcohol Tests.

CHAPTER 6. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS.

600. Purpose. 601. Coordination of Possible Criminal Violations. 602. Criminal Violations Investigated By the FAA. 603. Criminal Violations Investigated By Other Departments or Agencies. 604. Concurrent Criminal and Civil Violations. 605. Stolen Aircraft. 606.-699. RESERVED.

CHAPTER 7. FORMAL FACT-FINDING INVESTIGATIONS.

700. Purpose. 701. Authority. 702. Use of the Formal Fact-Finding Investigation. 703. Requests for Formal Fact-Finding Investigations. 704. Initiating the Formal Fact-Finding Investigation. 705. Conduct of the Formal Fact-Finding Investigation. 706. Use of Administrative Subpoenas. 707. Judicial Enforcement. 708.-799. RESERVED. Figure 7-1. Sample Order of Investigation.

CHAPTER 8.

2150.3A

Page No.

74

75 79

83

84

86

87

87

87

88

89 90 90

93 93

93

93

93

93 94 96 96 99

REEXAMINATION AND REINSPECTION UNDER SECTION 609

REEXAMINATION AND REINSPECTION UNDER SECTION 609

OF THE FEDERAL AVIATION ACT.

800. Authority. 801. Procedures.

101 101

Page iv

2150.3A

8C2.-899. RESERVED. Figure 8-1. Sample Letter Requesting Reexamination Under Section 609 of the Federal Aviation Act Figure 8-2. Sample Letter Requesting Additional Medical Information

12/14/88

Page No.

103

106

107

CHAPTER 9. PREPARATION OF ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIVE REPORTS.

900. General. 901. Report Preparation. 902. Report Assembly. 903. Section A - Preparation of FAA Form 2150-5. 904. Section B - Summary of Facts. 905. Section C - Items of Proof. 906. Section D - Facts and Analysis. 907. Protection and Release of EIR's. 908. Emergency Enforcement Actions. 909. Regional Copies. 910. Downgrading of EIR's. 911.- 999. RESERVED. Figure 9-1. Sample FAA Form 2150-5.

109 109 109

110 114 114 114 115 115 116 116 116 119

CHAPTER 10. PROCESSING OF ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIVE REPORTS.

1000. Purpose. 1001. Processing of EIR's for Administrative Action. 1002. Processing of EIR's for Legal Enforcement Action. 1003. Reports Requiring Special Processing. 1004.-1099. RESERVED. Figure 10-l. Sample Military Referral.

CHAPTER 11. ADMINISTRATIVE ENFORCEMENT ACTION.

1100. Purpose. 1101. General. 1102. Types of Administrative Action. 1103. Warning Notice. 1104. Letter of Correction. 1105. Records of Administrative Action Against Individuals. 1106.-1199. Reserved. Figure ll-l. Sample Warning Notice - Flight Operations. Figure ll-2. Privacy Act Notice for Warning Notice.

Page v

120

120

120

123 124 125

126 126 126 126 127

127 127

131

132

12/14/88

Figure 1l-3. Sample Letter of Correction - Maintenance. Figure 1l-4. Sample Letter of Correction - Security. Figure 11-5. Sample Letter of Correction - Airports. Figure 1l-6. Form Letter of Correction - Airport Certification. Figure 11-7. Sample Letter Acknowledging Completion of Corrective Action - Manufacturing: QASAR.

CHAPTER 12. LEGAL ENFORCEMENT ACTION.

1200. Purpose. 1201. Consultation With Headquarters. 1202. Certificate Action Under the Federal Aviation Act (Section 609). 1203. Certificate Action in Airman Medical Cases Under the Federal Aviation Act (Section 609) 1204. Civil Penalty Action Under the Federal Aviation Act Involving an Amount In Controversy In Excess of $50,000. 1205. Civil Penalty Action Under the Federal Aviation Act Involving An Amount In Controversy Not Exceeding $50,000. 1206. Civil Penalty Actions Under the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act (Section 110(a)). 1207. Informal Conferences. 1208. Seizure of Aircraft Under the Federal Aviation Act (Section 903(b)) 1209. Orders of Compliance, Cease and Desist Orders, Orders of Denial, and Other Orders Under the Federal Aviation Act and the Airport and Airway Development Act. 1210. Injunction Actions Under the Federal Aviation Act (Section 1007) 1211. Orders of Compliance Under the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act (Section 109) 1212. Orders of Immediate Compliance Under the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act. 1213. Injunctions Under the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act (Sectio.. 111) 1214. Legal Action involving Criminal Violations (All Cases).

2150.3A

Page No.

133

134

135

136

137

138 138

139

146

147

150

154 157

158

162

162

163

164

164

165

Page vi

2150.3A 12/14/88

Page No.

1:15.-1299. RESERVED. 166 Figure 12-1. Sample Notice of Proposed Certificate Action (Federal Aviation Act). 170 Figure 12-2. Sample Information Sheet To Accompany Notice of Proposed Certificate Action. 172 Figure 12-3. Sample Certificate Holder Reply. 175 Figure 12-4. Sample Receipt For Certificate and Waiver of Appeal Rights. 176 Figure 12-5. Sample Order of Suspension (Federal Aviation Act). 177 Figure 12-6. Sample Language for Order of Suspension With Waiver of Penalty. 179 Figure 12-7. Sample Emergency Order (Federal Aviation Act). 180 Figure 12-8. Sample Civil Penalty Letter (Federal Aviation Act). 183 Figure 12-9. Sample Information Sheet To Accompany a Civil Penalty Letter (Federal Aviation Act). 184 Figure i2-10. Sample Reply to Civil Penalty Letter (Federal Aviation Act). 186 Figure 12-1l. Sample Form of Receipt For Civil Penalties (Federal Aviation Act). 187 Figure 12-l2. Sample Complaint for Referrals To U.S. Attorneys (Federal Aviation Act). 188 Figure 12-13. Sample Language For Notice of Proposed Civil Penalty (Federal Aviation Act). 190 Figure 12-l4.

Sample Information Sheet To Accompany Notice of Proposed Civil Penalty (Federal Aviation Act. 191 Figure 12-15. Sample Reply To Notice of Proposed Civil Penalty (Federal Aviation Act). 194 Figure 12-16. Sample Order of Civil Penalty (Federal Aviation Act). 195 Figure 12-17. Sample Order Assessing Civil Penalty (Federal Aviation Act). 197 Figure 12-18. Sample Notice of Proposed Civil Penalty (Hazardous Materials Transportation Act). 199 Figure 12-19. Sample Information Sheet (Hazardous Materials Transportation Act). 201 Figure 12-20. Sample Reply To Notice of Proposed Civil Penalty (Hazardous Materials Transportation Act). 204 Figure 12-2l. Sample Order of Civil Penalty (Hazardous Materials Transportation Act). 205

Page vii

. 12/14/88

Figure 12-22. Sample Order Assessing Civil Penalty (Hazardous Materials Transportation Act). Figure 12-23. Sample Order of Seizure. Figure 12-24. Sample Notice of Seizure. Figure 12-25. Sample Letter To U.S. Attorney.

CHAPTER 13. ENFORCEMENT RELATED ITEMS.

1300. Purpose. 1301. Release and Publicizing of Enforcement Actions. 1302. Immunity For Persons Who Provide Information About Violations. 1303. Enforcement Associated With the Aviation Safety Reporting Program (Advisory Circular No. 00-46C). 1304. Noncompliance With Exemptions. 1305. Legal Handling of Airman Medical Denial Cases (Section 602 of the FA Act). 1306. Legal Handling of Airman Certificate Denial Cases Other Than Airman Medical Certificates (Section 602 of the FA Act). 1307. Applications For Airman Certificates By Persons Whose Certificates Have Been Revoked Under Section 609(c). 1308. Illegal Commercial Operations and Unlawful Common Carriage. 1309. Enforcement of Compensation Or Hire Prohibition in FAR 91.39(b) Regarding Restricted Category Aircraft. 1310. Liability of FAA Employees. 1311.-1399. RESERVED Figure 13-l. Request For Authorization To Grant Special Enforcement Consideration. Figure 13-2. Form Agreement To Grant Special Enforcement Consideration.

2150.3A

Page No.

207 209 210 212

213

213

216

219 221

221

222

222

223

224 225 226

230

233

CHAPTER 14. ENFORCEMENT INFOR ATION SYSTEM AND DISTRIBUTION

CHAPTER 14. ENFORCEMENT INFOR ATION SYSTEM AND DISTRIBUTION

REQUIREMENTS.

1400. Purpose. 1401. Enforcment Information System Overview. 1402. Roles and Responsibilities. 1403. Operations. 1404. EIS Data Bases. 1405. Distribution. 1406. System Support. 1407.-1499. RESERVED. Figure 14-1. EIS Data Flows.

235 235 235 239 241 241 243 244 247

Page viii

6/17/91

2150.3A CHG 8

Page No.

APPENDIX 1. COMPLIANCE/ENFORCEMENT BULLETINS

APPENDIX 1. COMPLIANCE/ENFORCEMENT BULLETINS

No. 84-1.

Procedures for notifying military

authorities when the FAA has issued an

No. 86-1.

No. 86-2.

order suspending or revoking and air carrier operating certificate. Computer-detected altitude deviation of 500 feet or less.

1 2

Sanctions -for unauthorized operations

No. 88-2.

No. 88-5.

within Terminal Control Areas. Enforcement actions for Minimum Equipment List (MEL) violations that occurred prior to March 15, 1988. Sanctions for persons who board or attempt to board an air carrier aircraft with concealed deadly or

3

4

5

dangerous weapons in their possession.

No. 90-1

No. 90-2.

Unauthorized operations within newly established Terminal Control Areas (TCA'S).

7

Enforcement actions for cases referred

by the Inspector General of the

Department of Transportation involving drug convictions and falsification of

No. 90-3.

No. 90-4.

No. 90-5.

No. 90-6.

No. 90-7.

appiications for airman medical certificates regarding drug- and alcohol-related convictions ("IG Match" cases), and other similar cases. Unauthorized operations within Terminal Control Areas (TCA's). Coordination of enforcement actions against airmen (except air carrier personnel) in nonsignificant cases. Policy and procedures for suspected violations of the FAA's alcohol- and drug-related prohibitions related to operation of aircraft. Reporting and correction policy and implementing guidance. Revised Enforcement Investigative

9

14

16

17

22

Report (EIR) format to be used in all

Civil Aviation Security cases.

28

Page ix

2150.3A CHG 19

No. 90-9.

SSER recommendations relating to

11/28/94

analysis of a violation; determination

of appropriate sanction; and

coordination within the Office of the

No. 90-10. No. 90-11.

No. 91-1.

Chief Counsel. Civil penalty assessment authority. SSER recommendations relating to informal communication between inspectors and attorneys and special emphasis programs.

59 63

96

Enforcement actions in cases involving drug convictions which do not involve

No. 92-1. No. 92-2.

No. 92-3.

falsification. Proportional civil penalties. Reporting and correction policy and implementing guidance for holders of production approvals. Guidance on enforcement action in

100 103

109

cases involving detection of simulated

No. 93-1.

No. 94-1.

APPENDIX 2.

weapons during Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) screening evaluations. Policy and procedures for the collection of administratively assessed civil penalties. Streamlined Enforcement Test and Evaluation.

115

121

157

STATUTORY AUTHORITY, RESPONSIBILITIES,

APPENDIX 3.

APPENDIX 4.

APPENDIX 5.

AND DELEGATIONS

AND DELEGATIONS

FAA FORM 2150.3, STATISTICAL CODE LISTING.

ENFORCEMENT SANCTION GUIDANCE TABLE.

1

1

1

SELECTED CIVIL AND CRIMINAL STATUTES.

Page x

1

12/14/88 2150.3A

CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION

100. pURPOSE. This order describes the authority, responsibilities, policies, guidelines, procedures, objectives, and legal aspects of the Federal Aviation Administration's Compliance and Enforcement Program. It is intended to be an aid in the exercise of discretion of the various FAA elements involved. It is recognized that this handbook does not cover every situation, and there will be cases where deviation from the guidance is warranted. It is expected that FAA personnel will use their judgement and experience in each case to carry out the policies of the FAA.

CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION

10l. DISTRIBUTION. This order is distributed as follows:

administrator level, and center director level. a. To the executive director level in Washington, D.C., the regional

b. To the branch level in the offices of the Associate Administrator of Regulation and Certification, the Associate Administrator for Aviation Standards, the Associate Administrator for Airport System development, and the Director of the Office of International Aviation.

Facilities Divisions. c. To the division level in the regional Air Traffic and Airway

d. To the branch level in the regional Airports, Aviation Medical, Civil Aviation Security, and Flight Standards Divisions.

e. To the branch level in the Civil Aeromedical Institute, Airmen and Aircraft Registry, FAA Academy, and Investigations and Security Divisions at the Aeronautical Center.

f. To the branch level in the Medical Staff, Aviation Facilities Division, and Center Counsel at the FAA Technical Center.

g. A maximum distribution to all Airports Field Offices, Flight Standards Field Offices, and Civil Aviation Security Field Offices, and the offices of the Assistant Chief Counsel for regions and centers.

h. A limited distribution to all Airway Facilities Field Offices, Air Traffic Field Offices, and International Aviation Field Offices.

102. CANCELLATIONS. Order 2150.3, Compliance and Enforcement Program, May 16, 1980, and Order 1000.9E (Enforcement Policy), dated April 4, 1988, are cancelled.

103. EXPLANATION OF CHANGES. This Order substantially edits Order 2150.3. The following major changes are included in the revised Order:

a. Added policy on choosing the type and amount of sanction.

Par100 Page 1

2150.3A 12/14/88

b. Incorporated policies previously issued by memoranda and in Order 1009.E, Enforcement Policy.

c. Removed prior policy which is no longer current agency policy.

d. Revised in light of straightlining of FAA, including straightlining of FAA's legal functions.

e. Added guidance for cases involving submission to alcohol testing.

f. Added guidance for inspectors in preparing an enforcement investigative report.

g. Incorporated requirements where counsel for the regions and centers must consult the Chief Counsel's office on matters of enforcemen.

h. Added guidance on handling enforcement actions under the Civil Penalty Demonstration Program.

i. Added guidance on publicizing enforcement actions.

j. Incorporated policy on providing immunity from enforcement action to persons who provide information about violations.

k. Added guidance on FAA employee liability.

104. FORMS AND REPORTS. The following forms are stocked in. the FAA Depot and are available through normal supply channels:

a. FAA Form 2l50-2, Violation Report Data - Certificate Actions, Reprimands, Referrals (7-79), unit of issue: SE (4), NSN: 0052-00-072-2001. This form, or FAA Forms 2150-3 or 2150-4, paragraphs b and c below, will be prepared, as appropriate, by legal counsel to record final action on all legal enforcement cases.

b. FAA Form 2150-3, Violation Report Data - Civil Penalties, Criminal, Miscellaneous (4-74), unit of issue: SE (4), NSN: 0052-00-606-3001.

c. FAA Form 2150-4, Violation Report Data - Hazardous Materials (7-78), unit of issue: SE (4), NSN: 0052-00-871-0000.

d. FAA Form 2150-5, Enforcement Investigative Report, unit of issue:. Sheet, NSN: 0052-00-875-8000. The form will be used by al1 elements of the FAA for the reporting of enforcement investigations. An illustrated sample of FAA Form 2150-5 is shown in Figure 9-1.

e. FAA Form 2150-6, Enforcement Investigative Report Log, unit of issue: Pad, NSN: 0052-00-876-1000. The form shall be maintained by each responsible regional division and distributed in accordance with instructions in paragraph 1402.

Chap 1 Page 2 Par103

12/14/88 2150.3A

f. FAA Form 5280-6, Letter of Correction, unit of issue: 5-page set, NSN: 0052-00-88l-2000. This form is used by FAA airport certification elements to report and obtain correction of violations of FAR Part l39.

105. CHANGES TO THIS ORDER. Changes to this order may be issued by the Chief Counsel except that changes to Chapter 1, Introduction, Chapter 2, Enforcement Objectives and Policy, and Chapter 3, Enforcement Responsibilities, which involve policy, a delegation of authority, or an assignment of responsibility, are reserved for the Administrator. This authority may not be redelegated.

a. Any FAA employee, field office, or region may submit proposed changes to the Assistant Chief Counsel for a region, center, or the Regulations and Enforcement Division. Recommended changes should be evaluated by the Assistant Chief Counsel. If counsel concurs with all or part of the recommended changes, they shall be submitted in letter form with suggested wording to the Chief Counsel (AGC-l). If counsel does not concur, the field recommendations shall be forwarded, in all cases, along with a letter stating counsel's position.

b. AGC-1 shall refer the recommendations to appropriate headquarters offices for review, development of a recommended revision, or nonconcurrence. Any recommended revision shall be coordinated by AGC-l with all other offices that have enforcement responsibility.

c. Following coordination, the Office of the Chief Counsel shall publish the revision and be responsible for the maintenance of the master document.

d. Revisions requiring immediate action shall be published as Compliance/Enforcement Bulletins (see paragraph 106).

106. SUPPLEMENTAL ENFORCEMENT INSTRUCTIONS. To assure uniformity in policy and instructions, headquarters offices and the regions shall, before issuance, provide AGC-l with two copies of all enforcement order supplements or instructions for headquarters coordination and concurrence.

107. COMPLIANCE/ENFORCEMENT BULLETINS. Short term or urgent directives to field personnel may be issued, pursuant to paragraph l04d, in the form of Compliance/Enforcement Bulletins, which shall be published under Appendix 1, Compliance/Enforcement Bulletins. Bulletins shali take precedence over instructions in this order when it is so stated and cites the sections involved. Bulletins may also serve to inform field and regional personnel of enforcement activities requiring emphasis, or provide. improved guidance to assure national uniformity.

l08. DEFINITIONS. As used in this Order, the following definitions and abbreviations are applicable unless the context clearly requires otherwise:

"AGC-l" means the Chief Counsel of the Federal Aviation Administration.

"ASAS" means Aviation Safety Analysis System (see paragraph l401).

Chap 1 Par104 Page 3

2150.3A 12/14/88

"ASRp" means Aviation Safety Report Program.

"Assistant Chief Counsel" means an Assistant Chief Counsel for a Region, a Center, or the Regulations and Enforcement Division.

"EIR" means an Enforcement Investigative Report. "EIS" means Enforcement Information System. "FA Act" means the Federal Aviation Act of 1958, as amended, 49 U.S.C. 130l et seg. "HMT Act" means the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act. "NTSB" means the National Transportation Safety Board. 109.-199. RESERVED.

Page 4 (thru 10) Par108 Chap 1

4/20/94 2150.3A CHG 18

CHAPTER 2. COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT POLICY AND OBJECTIVES

CHAPTER 2. COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT POLICY AND OBJECTIVES

200.PURPOSE. This chapter sets forth the general policies and objectives of the FAA's compliance and enforcement program.

201. THE NEED FOR A COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM.

a. A central mission of the agency is to promote aviation safety and security in civil aeronautics. To achieve this, the agency establishes regulatory standards and requirements, found in the Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR), under the following statutory direction:

(1) The Federal Aviation Act of 1958, as amended, (FAAct), places a duty on the Administrator to prescribe reasonable rules and regulations and minimum standards in the public interest.

(2) Section 103 of the FAAct requires that the Administrator consider the following, among other things, as being in the public interest:

(a) The regulation of air commerce in such a manner as to best promote its development and safety; and

(b) The promotion, encouragement, and development of civil aeronautics.

(3) Section 316(a)(1) of the FAAct requires that the Administrator prescribe rules and regulations "requiring practices, methods, and procedures . . . necessary to protect persons and property aboard aircraft operating in air transportation .. . against acts of criminal violence and aircraft piracy."

(4) Section 601(b) of the FAAct requires FAA to give full consideration to the duty resting upon air carriers "to perform their services with the highest possible degree of safety in the public interest."

(5) The amendments made to the FAAct by the Airline Deregulation Act of 1978 demonstrate Congress' intent that the implementation of the FAAct must result in no decrease of the high standards of safety in air transportation attained in the United States. Section 102(a)(2) of the FAAct specifically provides that one of the considerations the Administrator must make as being in the public interest and in accordance with

Chap 2 Par 200 Page 11

2150.3A CHG 18 4/20/94

public convenience and necessity is the prevention of any deterioration in established safety procedures, recognizing the clear intent, encouragement, and dedication of the Congress to the furtherance of the highest degree of safety in air transportation and air commerce, and the maintenance of the safety vigilance that has evolved within air transportation and air commerce and has come to be expected by the traveling and shipping public.

b. The FAA's compliance and enforcement program is designed to promote compliance with both the statutory and the regulatory requirements. The program ranges from educational and remedial efforts, including administrative action, to punitive legal enforcement remedies, including criminal sanctions in the most serious cases.

c. This program is applicable to all activities regulated by the agency for which legal enforcement penalties are prescribed. When violations occur, whether they involve the operation of an airport, the production of aircraft, the performance of aircraft maintenance, the operation of aircraft, or the carrying out of civil aviation security programs, FAA personnel must take the action most appropriate to achieve future compliance.

202. COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT PHILOSOPHY.

a. Voluntary compliance. Civil aviation safety and security depend primarily on voluntary adherence to legal requirements. Thus, one of our foremost efforts to achieve compliance should be directed toward programs to promote a clear awareness and understanding of the governing regulations.

b. Education. Education must be an ongoing component for a compliance program to be successful. Consequently, FAA personnel should take advantage of opportunities during their surveillance and inspection activities to enhance a certificate holder's understanding of the regulatory requirements. In addition, education can be fostered through public awareness programs and other special aviation educational efforts.

c. Surveillance and detection. An important element of an effective compliance program is the prompt discovery of instances of noncompliance. While the agency has programs to encourage self-disclosure, surveillance remains the primary method of detecting violations. Consistent with the agency's statutory mandates, there must be a particularly high ievel of surveillance of air carrier operations.

Chap 2 Page 12 Par 201

4/20/94 2150.3A CHG 18

d. Notifying persons of violations. In any situation where FAA personnel identify a potential violation, they should take appropriate steps to notify immediately a responsible person who can take appropriate action to prevent it. FAA personnel may use such means as counseling, an agreement to take immediate corrective action by the aircraft operator, or the use of the provisions of section 605(b) of the FAAct with respect to air carrier aircraft that are not in condition for safe operation. In addition, the procedures of Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 90-5 must be followed in the case of suspected violations of the FAA's alcohol and drug-related prohibitions. In cases involving the detection of simulated weapons during FAA screening evaluations, the procedures of Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 92-3 must be followed.

e. Investigation and reporting. When an investigation is warranted, it should be conducted promptly. There must be an unbiased gathering of all facts, focused investigation, and accurate reporting. Poor investigation weakens the effectiveness of the enforcement program. A violation report without all of the facts only leads to delays that compromise the objectives of fair and responsive enforcement. Such reports also can mislead reviewing authorities and result in incorrect or inappropriate actions.

f. FAA response to violations. Every apparent or alleged violation must be investigated and appropriately addressed.

(1) Firmness. The agency has a wide range of options available for addressing violations. They range from simple counseling and administrative action to formal iegal enforcement action. Statutory methods for enforcing the requirements of the FAAct and the regulations governing the safe operation of aircraft include the following: amendment, suspension, and revocation of certificates (FAAct, sections 501 and 609); civil and criminal penalties (FAAct, sections 901, 902); aircraft seizures (FAAct, section 903); judicially enforceable orders (FAAct, section 1007); and special investigations and other acts deemed necessary to carry out the provisions of the Act (FAAct, section 313). Regulations governing the transportation of hazardous materials by air are enforceable by means of civil and criminal penalties, orders directing compliance, and equitable judicial relief (Hazardous Materials Transportation Act (HMT Act), sections 109, 110, and 111).

Chap 2

Par 202 Page 13

2150.3A CHG 18 4/20/94

(2) Compliance and enforcement action is undertaken to--

(a) Prevent future actions that would violate the regulations (e.g., immediate corrective action after counseling or a letter of correction or warning notice; cease and desist orders; injunctions) ;

(b) Impose punitive sanctions to deter violations (e.g., punitive certificate actions or civil penalties); and

(c) Achieve remedial purposes (e.g., administrative remedial training; voluntary remedial action under the reporting and correction policy; certificate suspension pending demonstration of qualifications; revocation for lack of qualification or competency; or a remedial civil penalty).

g. Fairness. To be effective, the agency's compliance and enforcement program must be fair and reasonable in fact, and should be perceived as fair by those subject to regulation. This does not and should not imply an unwillingness to apply the full force of statutory sanctions where warranted. It does encompass the right of an alleged violator to be given objective, evenhanded consideration of all circumstances surrounding the allegations before final action is taken. It also requires good faith efforts to understand the alleged violator's position and take it into account, as well as to apprise the alleged violator of the agency's position in a timely manner.

h. Timeliness. The agency's discovery of and response to violations also should be timely. Delays in investigation or processing of violation reports can impact the effectiveness of the agency's compliance and enforcement program in several ways. Delays may permit an unsafe condition to continue if prompt corrective action is not taken. Delays also de-emphasize the seriousness of a given violation and diminish the deterrent value of any enforcement action taken. The deterrent quality of enforcement action, and effective linking of the enforcement sanction to objective change in compliance behavior, can be realized if investigations are diligently and promptly conducted, and the appropriate sanction is administered within a reasonable time period. By the same token, if the allegations of violation are not sustained, any unwarranted delay in processing the case may impose an unjustified hardship.

Chap 2 Page 14 Par 202

2150.3A CHG 18 4/20/94

The time needed for investigation and processing will vary depending on the complexities involved in each case. Certain cases, because of their effect on safety, including the need for emergency action, will demand immediate involvement of the entire investigative/legal team to resolve regulatory noncompliance quickly, sometimes in only a matter of hours or a few days.

203. GUIDELINES FOR PROCESSING ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS.

a. Selection of enforcement action. Responsible FAA personnel must review the evidence compiled during an investigation to determine whether a violation of the regulations has been committed. If the evidence fails to support a violation or demonstrate a lack of qualifications or competency of a certificate holder, then neither administrative nor legal enforcement action is appropriate. In determining the appropriate enforcement action that should be taken for regulatory noncompliance, FAA investigative personnel must consider the administrative remedies set forth in paragraphs 203b(1) through 203b(4). The sanction guidance policy should be used oniy in those cases where a determination has been made that legal enforcement action is warranted.

b. Enforcement remedies.

(1) Reinspection and reexamination. When FAA personnel discover facts that indicate a certificate holder may not be qualified or lacks competency to hold a certificate, the reexamination or reinspection authority of section 609 of the FAAct should be used. Reexamination or reinspection of a certificate holder does not preclude taking punitive enforcement action when appropriate. When a certificate holder fails to comply with a request for reinspection or reexamination, FAA personnel should follow the procedures of Chapter 8, Reexamination and Reinspection Under Section 609 of the FAAct.

(2) Remedial training (with administrative action). In evaluating evidence of a violation by a certificate holder, appropriate FAA personnel must determine whether remedial training is appropriate in lieu of legal enforcement action. If a determination is made that remedial training is appropriate, a certificate holder must be afforded an opportunity for training in place of the imposition of punitive action. The corrective action taken must be documented. FAA personnel should follow the procedures in Compliance and Enforcement Bulletin 90-8 when remedial training is determined to be appropriate.

Chap 2 Par 202 Page 15

2150.3A CHG 18 4/20/94

(3) Reporting and correction. FAA personnel must determine whether reporting and correction policies are applicable with respect to violations by air carriers, production approval holders, and other categories of certificate holders to which these policies may be applied. If a certificate holder promptly discloses a violation to FAA voluntarily and otherwise meets all of the requirements of the reporting and correction policies, then a letter of correction should be issued.

(4) Administrative action. When FAA personnel conclude that none of the policies set forth in paragraphs 203b(1) through 203b(3) apply, then they must determine whether administrative action is appropriate by evaluating the facts surrounding a violation against the criteria set forth in paragraph 205.

(5) Legal enforcement action. When FAA personnel determine that legal enforcement action should be pursued for a violation, they must determine the type and amount of legal enforcement sanction by consulting the sanction guidance policy. FAA personnel must strictly observe limitations periods imposed by statute or regulation for the initiation of legal enforcement actions.

c. Periodic Program Review of Legal Enforcement Processing.

(1) Each Assistant Chief Counsel should meet at least quarterly with the respective program divisions to review the status of cases referred for legal enforcement action. The purpose for this review is a joint counsel-program assessment of the case load management, with an emphasis on the timeliness and effectiveness of case selection, investigation, initiation, and processing. In addition, the review should include an analysis of: trends; inconsistent case handling; lack of uniform sanctions; repetitious conduct; and any other significant evaluative factors. At this review, the need to reprioritize and process cases warranting the greatest urgency must be considered.

(2) If an assessment indicates that more cases are being submitted for legal handling than legal counsel can reasonably be expected to initiate and process, without incurring a substantial or undue backlog, the following actions must be considered:

Chap 2 Page 16 Par 203

4/20/94 2150.3A CHG 18

(a) redistribute cases for processing by other regions or headquarters staff with greater available enforcement resources; and,

(b) reevaluate the cases that are being unduly backlogged, and determine if any alternative enforcement action would be appropriate and warranted.

(3) The reconsideration or reassessment of a given sanction is not to be considered a weakening or lack of enforcement resolve. On the contrary, that resolve is most evident when both corrective and deterrent actions are taken in a timely manner. For example, sometimes an administrative closure action, taken immediately after a violation occurs, can serve as a more effective deterrent than an unresponsive or unduly delayed legal action, taken later. There is a wide range of effective tools available to investigative personnel and prosecuting attorneys, and all of them should be considered in light of the circumstances of each individual case. The tool selected should be the one that most effectively and timely serves to correct the noncompliance and deter future violations.

(4) When case reports are returned to investigating field program offices, the field offices will carefully reevaluate and quickly respond to each returned legal enforcement case in light of the explanation provided by the program division manager. Specific attention will be given to the nature of the violation and other relevant mitigating and aggravating factors and elements, and whether safety and the public interest continue to require that legal enforcement action be taken. If the investigating office determines that the recommended legal enforcement action should be taken, it will coordinate this decision with the respective program division manager.

(5) It is the goal of the FAA generally to initiate cases referred for legal enforcement action within 180 days of the time the violation occurred. Cases involving delayed discovery of a violation must be expedited. It is understood that this objective may not always be met because of: lack of resources; case complexity; investigative delays due to noncooperation of witnesses, or difficulty in obtaining evidence; or other higher agency safety priorities. But generally, 180 days is the expected agency norm within which the investigation will be completed and the case will be initiated by counsel. Meeting this norm requires the closest cooperation, communication, and teamwork between investigative and prosecuting enforcement personnel. Failure to meet the

Chap 2

Par 203 Page 17

2150.3A CHG 18 4/20/94

norm in any individual case will not be the sole cause for dismissing that case. Where, however, caseloads regularly fail to meet this norm, there should be a reassessment of office procedures and case management, under the provisions in paragraphs 203(c) (1) through 203(c) (4). Subparagraph 203(c)(5) does not apply when limitations periods are imposed by statute or regulation for the initiation of FAA legal enforcement actions. In such cases, those time limits must be strictly observed.

(6) In cases where reviews indicate that delay is not a factor, there still may be a need to make other adjustments in case handling such as: the consolidation of related cases involving the same airman or operator; the need to take emergency action where a reporting office has overlooked that need; or the need to reevaluate a case technically. These or other similar adjustments should be considered during these periodic program meetings.

204. PROCEDURES FOR SELECTING COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT ACTION.

a. Program office responsibilities.

(1) The initial priorities of FAA personnel must be to correct any ongoing noncompliance and to take appropriate action when they determine that a certificate holder lacks the requisite qualifications or competency.

(2) Once the underlying noncompliance is corrected, responsibility for selection of the enforcement remedy that best fits the circumstances begins with FAA personnel who investigated the case. In most cases, they are in the best position to evaluate various factors, such as the alleged violator's compiiance attitude and whether an alternative to legal enforcement action may be sufficient to achieve compliance. Authorizing investigative personnel to make these determinations should aiso result in prompt action.

(3) FAA investigative personnel are expected to exercise sound discretion and professional judgment in making these determinations in accordance with agency policies and guidance. The selection of administrative action or legal action must be made in accordance with the guidance and standards contained in this order.

(4) FAA personnel should consider whether application of progressive discipline will achieve the desired compliance. In some circumstances, for example, it may be appropriate to address a first-time violation with a letter of

Chap 2 Page 18 Par 203

4/20/94 2150.3A CHG 18

correction. The letter, with its associated corrective action, may be adequate to achieve sustained compliance. Should that approach prove to fail, it may be necessary to impose a punitive legal enforcement sanction, i.e., a civil penalty or certificate suspension, to produce an adequate deterrent to future violations. Repetitive violations by a certificate holder may even demonstrate a lack of qualification warranting certificate revocation. This progressive discipline approach is, however, totally inappropriate in certain aggravated circumstances, such as flying while intoxicated, intentional falsification, and reckless or grossly careless operation of an aircraft.

(5) The agency's response to noncompliance, particularly the use of legal enforcement action, is intended to deter not only the violator but others as weli. FAA personnel should consider this factor in deciding what action is most appropriate.

(6) Agency management will periodically review the determinations of investigative personnel in enforcement cases. The managers will look at whether they have adequately considered all relevant facts and circumstances in a case and have explained their choice of enforcement action. This evaluation will help to ensure reasonable consistency in the manner in which violations are handled and that investigative personnel are properly exercising their discretion.

(7) The agency will periodically review data to determine whether the agency's response to violations is having the desired effect of bringing about compliance. If it is not, actions such as special emphasis programs to target particular violations can be initiated.

b. Review of recommendations of FAA investigative personnel. In those cases where an enforcement investigative report (EIR) is prepared, it will be reviewed by appropriate investigative and legal personnel to ensure consistency in the application of agency compliance and enforcement policies. In this review, due deference must be afforded the reporting investigative employee's considerations in determining the appropriate action. FAA personnel at all levels, however, are expected to exercise sound judgment and discretion to propose, modify, and substitute alternative remedies within existing guidance to correct regulatory noncompliance. Deliberations by investigative personnei regarding sanction determinations, as well as communications between investigative personnel and legal counsel, are privileged.

Chap 2 Par 204 Page 19

2150.3A CHG 18 4/20/94

c. Responsibility for deciding the type of enforcement remedy. FAA investigative personnel, appropriate to the violation involved, will decide, subject to the criteria in this order, whether compliance may best be obtained through administrative or legal enforcement action. In making this determination, the supervisor will afford due deference to the investigating inspector's recommendation if it is substantiated.

d. Responsibility for determining legal enforcement sanction. If legal enforcement action is selected (e.g., certificate action or civil penalty action), the amount of sanction should be determined in accordance with the guidance contained in the sanction guidance policy. FAA personnel should give due deference to sanotion recommendations of subordinate and client offices if they are properly justified and explained. The amount of sanction sought in a legal enforcement action is the product of a joint determination by the program office and legal counsel. FAA personnel, at all levels, however, are expected to exercise sound judgment and discretion to propose, modify, and substitute alternative remedies to correct regulatory noncompliance, within applicable policy guidance.

e. Prosecutorial discretion. Agency attorneys exercise broad prosecutorial discretion in the handling of legal enforcement actions. This discretion extends from the initial determination of whether legal enforcement action is warranted for an alleged violation through settlement of a case. FAA personnel aiso exercise discretion in selecting an appropriate amount of sanction for a particular violation, within the parameters of the sanction guidance policy. Through application of the standards and criteria set forth in the sanction guidance policy, FAA personnel select the appropriate penalty within the sanction ranges in the table of sanctions based on the relevant facts and circumstances surrounding a violation. In cases where policy permits, agency attorneys, in consultation with program offices, may determine that an amount or type of sanction outside the ranges is appropriate. In this regard, agency attorneys are expected to use sound, rational, prosecutorial judgment to make decisions that further the agency's safety mission and the public interest. Subsequent to the initiation of a case, agency attorneys, in consultation with the concerned program office, may settle cases, when, in their judgment, the settlement is warranted by the facts and

law, other litigation risks, and would prevent unnecessary 1itigation.

Page 20 Chap 2 Par 204

4/20/94 2150.3A CHG 18

f. Informal communications with agency attorneys. Supervisors and managers of headquarters, regional, or field personnel involved in compliance and enforcement should encourage open dialogue and sharing of information and opinions between investigating program office personnel and regional and headquarters attorneys. Open and informal communication between the investigative and legal staffs will improve the effectiveness of and promote consistency in the enforcement program.

205. ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION. Where legal enforcement action is not appropriate, a warning notice or letter of correction may be issued as provided in section 13.11 of the Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR) and Chapter 11, Administrative Enforcement Action. Administrative action is not to be taken solely as a matter of convenience or where evidence to support a finding of a violation is lacking. The operational field office of Flight Standards, Aircraft Certification, Airports, or Civil Aviation Security, appropriate to the violation involved, will decide whether compliance may be obtained best through administrative action or through legal enforcement action, subject to the criteria in this paragraph or other guidance in this order. A decision to take administrative actions ordinarily does not need to be coordinated above the cognizant field office level.

a. Legal effect. Administrative actions are not adjudications. Neither a letter of correction nor a warning notice constitutes a finding of violation and, therefore, the opportunity for notice and hearing are not required.

b. General requirements. Administrative enforcement action may be taken in lieu of legal enforcement action when all of the following elements are present:

(1) Applicable law does not require legal enforcement action;

(2) Lack of qualification or competency was not involved;

(3) The violation was inadvertent and not deliberate;

Chap 2 Par 204 Page 21

2150.3A CHG 18 4/20/94

(4) The violation was not the result of a substantial disregard for safety or security and the circumstances of the violation are not aggravated. "Substantial disregard" means:

(a) In the case of a certificate holder, that the act or failure to act was a substantial deviation from the degree of care, judgment and responsibility normally expected of a person holding that certificate with that type, quality and level of experience, knowledge and proficiency.

(b) In case the violator is not a certificate holder, the act or failure to act was a substantial deviation from the degree of care and diligence expected of a reasonable person in those circumstances.

(5) The alleged violator has a constructive attitude toward complying with the regulations;

(6) The alleged violator has not been involved previously in similar violations; and

(7) After consideration of elements in paragraphs 205b(1) through 205b(6), a determination is made that administrative action will serve as an adequate deterrent.

c. Evidence of constructive attitude. In making a judgment concerning whether a violator has a constructive attitude, documentation showing the violator's completion of any of the following (including recency of the attendance) may also be considered:

(1) The FAA Accident Prevention Program as volunteer counselor or program assistant;

(2) The Pilot Proficiency Award Program (WINGS) ;

(3) The Pilot and Aircraft Courtesy Evaluation (PACE) Program;

(4) FAA-sponsored Accident Prevention Program safety seminars on the subject(s) implicated in the aileged violation;

(5) FAA-sponsored, industry-conducted safety seminars on the subject(s) implicated in the alleged violation;

Chap 2 Page 22 Par 205

4/20/94 2150.3A CHG 18

(6) Operation Raincheck (Air Traffic Service) programs or other visits to air traffic facilities for familiarization and educational purposes; and

(7) Other similar safety- or security-related programs, acceptable to the FAA.

d. Remedial training. A letter of correction will be issued to an individual certificate holder when the following conditions are met:

(1) The inspector determines that administrative action is appropriate under the criteria set forth in paragraph 205b;

(2) The inspector determines that remedial training is appropriate corrective action; and

(3) The individual successfully completes a remedial training program developed under the guidance in Order 8740.1B, Generai Aviation Accident Prevention Program, Appendix 7.

e. Reporting and correction. A letter of correction will be issued to an air carrier, production approval holder, or other category of certificate holder to which the reporting and correction policy applies, when the following criteria are met:

(1) The inspector determines that administrative action is appropriate under the criteria set forth in paragraph 205b;

(2) The inspector determines that the certificate holder voluntarily and promptly disclosed the noncompliance to appropriate FAA personnel before the agency learned of it (the initial notification may be made informally, but written notification must be made before administrative action can be considered. Holders who fail to comply with FAR 21.3, Reporting of failures, malfunctions, and defects, will not be considered to have promptly disclosed the noncompliance.);

(3) The certificate holder or production approval holder, upon discovery of the failure, has taken or has begun to take immediate action to correct it; and

Chap 2 Par 205 Page 23

2150.3A CHG 18 4/20/94

(4) The certificate holder or production approval holder has taken, or has agreed to take, remedial action satisfactory to the FAA as may be necessary to preclude recurrence of such failure. Àny action agreed to be taken must be in writing and completed to the satisfaction of the FAA.

f. Public interest. In unusual circumstances, administrative enforcement action may be taken notwithstanding the fact that the case does not meet all of the criteria above for administrative action. Administrative action may be taken in those cases only upon a written explanation included in the enforcement file by the division manager of the investigating office of why legal enforcement action would serve no useful purpose and that use of an administrative enforcement action is otherwise in the public interest.

206. DETERMINING THE TYPE OF LEGAL ENFORCEMENT ACTION.

a. Sanctions for punitive and deterrent purposes: suspension action and civil penalty action.

(1) General. In general, the primary legal enforcement tool the FAA uses to enforce its regulations against a certificate holder is certificate action. Where the FAA, in its discretion, however, determines that there is a substantial adverse impact on the public interest from disrupted service, and that this impact is not outweighed by safety considerations, it is appropriate to take civil penalty action. For example, the FAA may take certificate action against individuai certificate holders and civil penalty action against air carriers, as warranted.

Where there is a need to prevent continuing violations or other egregious conduct, the FAÀ will take remedial action as needed, regardless of the impact on the certificate holder. In no case wiil civil penalty action alone be taken where remedial legal action is necessary or appropriate.

(2) Use of both certificate action and civil penalty action for the same violations. Civil penalty action and punitive certificate action generally should not be instituted against a certificate holder for the same offense. If legal counsel is of the opinion that unusual circumstances in any case justify deviation from this policy, legal counsel must first consult with the Enforcement Division (AGC-300).

(3) Change in type of proposed sanction. The initial enforcement action should reflect the agency's best assessment of the appropriate sanction for the violations

Chap 2 Page 24 Par205

4/20/94 2150.3A CHG 18

alleged. Each EIR should include all available information bearing on sanction. After the initial action is issued, the type of sanction ordinarily should not be changed unless additional relevant facts or circumstances are presented to the FAA, upon which, in its discretion, determines that the initial proposal was inappropriate. If the action is a significant action for which coordination is required under paragraph 120la, any change in the type of sanction must be coordinated with AGC-300.

b. Legal sanctions for remedial purposes: certificate action - suspension. Suspension action is appropriate where there is a need temporarily to suspend the privileges of the certificate pending demonstration of qualification. Remedial suspension should ordinarily be used only when the individual does not voluntarily surrender his or her certificate pending reexamination (see Chapter 8).

c. Legal sanctions for remedial purposes: certificate action - revocation. Revocation of a certificate is used as a remedial measure when the certificate holder lacks the necessary qualifications to hold the certificate. The continued exercise of the privileges of the certificate in such circumstances would be contrary to safety in air commerce or air transportation.

(1) Revocation is appropriate whenever the certificate holder's conduct demonstrates a lack of the degree of care, judgment, or responsibility required of the holder of such a certificate.

(2) Revocation is never used as a means to circumvent dismissal of charges under applicable procedural rules.

(3) In cases involving individuals, revocation of a certificate or a rating should be sought whenever there is a lack of willingness or ability to comply consistently with the FAR. A lack of such willingness or ability to comply may be demonstrated, for example, by repeated or deliberate violations of the FAR or by violations that involve grossly careless or reckless conduct. Also, revocation is ordinarily appropriate in egregious cases such as those involving falsification of records.

(4) In cases involving businesses, revocation should be sought whenever there is a demonstration of a lack of qualifications. Revocation would normally be appropriate, for

Chap 2 Par 206 Page 25

2150.3A CHG 18 4/20/94

example, in cases involving deliberate or flagrant violations or the falsification of records. Revocation also would generally be appropriate in cases in which the certificate holder has committed the same or similar violations in the recent past, or where the certificate holder no longer has, and does not obtain in a reasonable time, the personnel or equipment to conduct its operation in full compliance with the FAAct or FAR.

(5) Section 609(c) of the FAAct mandates certificate revocation when an airman has been convicted of violating certain Federal or state statutes relating to a controlled substance and (a) an airplane was used in the commission of the offense and (b) such person served as an airman, or was aboard the aircraft, in connection with commission of the offense or the facilitation of the commission of the offense. The FAAct also requires the revocation of the registration certificate of any airplane used in the commission of such an offense when the use was permitted by the owner of the aircraft with knowledge that it would be used for such purpose.

(6) Given the relationship between a lack of qualification and the public safety, a decision to revoke ordinarily warrants invoking the agency's emergency authority (see paragraph 206d).

d. Emergency suspension or revocation of certificates.

(1) Whenever it is determined that the public interest and safety in air transportation or air commerce require the immediate effectiveness of a suspension or revocation, an emergency order should be issued. The authority to issue such orders is contained in sections 609 and 1005 of the FAAct.

(2) The emergency authority will not be used for punitive purposes; i.e., to order fixed periods of suspension.

(3) Emergency action should be taken only:

(a) When the certificate holder lacks qualification, or there is a reasonable question as to whether the holder is qualified; and

(b) When the holder is reasonably able as a practical matter to exercise the privileges of the certificate.

Chap 2 Page 26 Par 206

4/20/94 2150.3A CHG 18

1 If it is known that a certificate holder is unable to exercise the privileges of the certificate, a notice proposing certificate action should be issued.

2 If, after a notice has been issued, the certificate holder again becomes able to exercise the privileges of the certificate and an issue of qualification remains, the case should be converted to an emergency case.

(4) Emergency action should be taken as soon as possible when the need for such action is recognized. Failure to take prompt action does not preclude the issuance of an emergency order when it is appropriate. If a significant delay has occurred, however, circumstances justifying revocation or immediate action may have changed, and consideration should be given to reevaluating the case, including, as appropriate, reinspection or reexamination of the certificate holder. For example, by the time action is ready to be initiated, the unqualified or culpable management personnel may have changed and it may be determined that revocation is no longer required." In such a case, another enforcement action may be used to address the previously discovered violations.

(5) If there is a reasonable basis to question whether the certificate holder is qualified and the holder might reasonably be able to exercise the privileges of the certificate, emergency suspension action pending successful reexamination should be considered.

(6) Oral orders. Ordinarily, orders of suspension and revocation must be in writing, as provided in Chapter 12, Legal Enforcement Action. If necessary, however, to protect the safety of the traveling public and in furtherance of the public interest, the Administrator, the Chief Counsel, the Deputy Chief Counsel, the Assistant Chief Counsel for Enforcement, and each regional Assistant Chief Counsel may issue an emergency order orally to prohibit an air carrier from operating a particular flight with a particular crewmember or crewmembers or to suspend an airman certificate to ensure the safety of flight of civil aircraft in air commerce or air transportation. An oral order must be reduced to writing and served upon the certificate holder as soon as practicable.

(7) Early agency coordination. When an investigating field office becomes aware of a case that might be appropriate for emergency action, that office should immediately notify its regional office representative who, in

Chap 2

Par 206 Page 27

2150.3A CHG 18 4/20/94

turn, should immediately notify the Assistant Chief Counsel for the region. With the earliest possible notification, these officials can then work together to expedite processing of the case.

(8) Pre-emergency action notification and briefing. In the case of institutional certificate holders, such as air carriers and repair stations, consideration may be given to notifying the holder in advance that emergency action is considered likely and to briefing the holder on the bases for such action. No certificate holder, however, is entitled to this notification or briefing. A decision on whether to provide this notification and briefing should be made on a case-by-case basis, taking into consideration safety, public interest, and other relevant factors. The agency may notify an air carrier that emergency action is under consideration where, for example, that carrier's management personnel have not been involved in the alleged violations, and the carrier is capable of making immediate personnel or other changes that would bring it into compliance and satisfy all safety requirements. In such case, the matter might be resolvable by consent order, deferred suspension, or some other means short of revocation.

e. Other recommended action. In addition to the recommendation for legal enforcement action, the field office should determine the possible need for any additional or special enforcement action and, when appropriate, submit such recommendations to the regionai office. This may include recommendations for any of the following:

(1) Seizure of aircraft. Under certain conditions described in paragraph 1208, when an aircraft is involved in a violation of the FAR and the violation is by the aircraft owner or person in command, the aircraft may be seized. Seizure action, when appropriate, may be recommended regardless of the status of the investigation or legal processing of any prior violation(s).

(2) Cease and desist orders, orders of compliance, and injunctions. Whenever the inspector determines that a condition requiring immediate action exists, in respect of safety in air commerce or air transportation, the field office should bring the matter to the attention of the regional office to consider the appropriateness of issuing a cease and desist order, an order of compliance, or initiating action in U.s. District Court for injunctive relief (see paragraphs 1209, 1210, 1211, 1212, and 1213).

Chap 2 Page 28 Par206

4/20/94 2150.3A CHG 18

(3) Criminal prosecution. If the inspector's investigation discloses any evidence of willful conduct that could constitute violations of any criminal provisions of the FAAct, the HMT Act, or of any other Federal criminal statute, the field office should bring this information to the attention of the regional office. See, Chapter 6. An inspector should not delay a safety investigation, even though an alleged violation may involve possible criminal violations and result in a criminai investigation: Where the specific conduct being investigated may also be in violation of Federal criminal statutes, the investigative file should indicate whether or not criminal investigation or prosecution has been initiated, as well as the office or agency responsible for such action. In addition, the principles of double jeopardy may preclude punitive civil penalty action when criminal prosecution has already occurred for the same conduct. See, U.S. v. Halper, 490 U.S. 435 (1989).

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 955 passages shown