91 FR 38878 Transport Airplane and Propulsion Certification Modernization
FAA proposes to amend various airworthiness regulations to modernize certain certification standards for transport category airplanes and propulsion systems. This rule would be both deregulatory and relieving by reducing the number of exemptions, special conditions, and equivalent level of safety findings required during the certification process. FAA expects that this proposal would reduce certification costs and time to certify new and changed products for both industry and FAA while maintaining or increasing the level of safety provided by the current regulations. FAA proposes to remove Special Federal Aviation Regulation (SFAR) No. 109 from part 25 and relocate certain of its requirements. Finally, this action would address industry and National Transportation Safety Board recommendations while also harmonizing FAA's regulations with international standards.
This document is proposed. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.
Vol. 91
Friday,
No. 122
June 26, 2026
Part III
Transport Airplane and Propulsion Certification Modernization; Proposed Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 91 , No. 122 / Friday, June 26, 2026 / Proposed Rules DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
Federal Aviation Administration
[Docket No.: FAA-2026-0430; Notice No. 26-09] RIN 2120-AL42
[Docket No.: FAA-2026-0430; Notice No. 26-09] RIN 2120-AL42
Transport Airplane and Propulsion Certification Modernization
AGENCY: Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), DOT.
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM).
SUMMARY: FAA proposes to amend various airworthiness regulations to modernize certain certification standards for transport category airplanes and propulsion systems. This rule would be both deregulatory and relieving by reducing the number of exemptions, special conditions, and equivalent level of safety findings required during the certification process. FAA expects that this proposal would reduce certification costs and time to certify new and changed products for both industry and FAA while maintaining or increasing the level of safety provided by the current regulations. FAA proposes to remove Special Federal Aviation Regulation (SFAR) No. 109 from part 25 and relocate certain of its requirements. Finally, this action would address industry and National Transportation Safety Board recommendations while also harmonizing FAA's regulations with international standards.
Dates
DATES: Send comments on or before August 25, 2026.
ADDRESSES: Send comments identified by docket number FAA-2026-0430 using any of the following methods:
• Federal eRulemaking Portal: Go to www.regulations.gov and follow the online instructions for sending your comments electronically.
Addresses
• Mail: Send comments to Docket Operations; U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT), 1200 New Jersey Avenue SE, West Building, 5th Floor (W58-213), Washington, DC 20590-0001.
• Hand Delivery or Courier: Take comments to Docket Operations in Room W58-213 of the West Building 5th Floor at 1200 New Jersey Avenue SE, Washington, DC, between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., Monday through Friday, except Federal holidays.
• Fax: Fax comments to Docket Operations at (202) 493-2251.
Docket: Background documents or comments received may be read at www.regulations.gov at any time. Follow the online instructions for accessing the docket or go to the Docket Operations in Room W58-213 of the West Building 5th Floor at 1200 New Jersey Avenue SE, Washington, DC 20590 between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., Monday through Friday, except Federal holidays.
For Further Information Contact
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: James Wilborn, AIR-62A, Product Policy Management: Transport Airplanes & Engines Section, Policy and Standards Division, Aircraft Certification Service, Federal Aviation Administration, 2200 South 216th Street, Des Moines, WA 98198; (206) 231-3237; [email protected].
Supplementary Information
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Table of Contents
I. Executive Summary
A. Overview of Proposed Rule
B. Background
1. Exemptions
2. Special Conditions
3. Equivalent Level of Safety Findings
C. Regulatory Reform of Aviation Regulations
D. Section 312 of FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024
E. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) Recommendations
I. Executive Summary
F. Proposed Regulatory Relief Resulting From ARAC and NTSB Recommendations
G. Additional Proposed Regulatory Relief
H. Harmonization With EASA Certification Specifications
I. Costs and Benefits of the Proposed Rule II. Authority for This Rulemaking III. Discussion of the Proposed Rule
A. Executive Interiors--SFAR No. 109 and Proposed Sec. § 25.4(d), 25.821, 25.823, 25.825, 25.827, 25.829, 25.830, 25.812(e)(3), 25.812(l)(1), 25.1365, and 25.1583(j)
1. Overview of Proposed Sec. § 25.4(d), 25.821, 25.823, 25.825, 25.827, 25.829, 25.830, 25.812(e)(3), 25.812(l)(1), 25.1365, and 25.1583(j)
2. Discussion of Proposed Sec. § 25.4(d), 25.821, 25.823, 25.825, 25.827, 25.829, 25.830, 25.812(e)(3), 25.812(l)(1), 25.1365, and 25.1583(j)
3. Advisory Material for Proposed Sec. § 25.4(d), 25.821, 25.823, 25.825, 25.827, 25.829, 25.830, and 25.1583(j)
B. Vibration and Buffeting--§ 25.251(b)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.251(b)
2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.251(b)
3. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.251(b)
C. Rolling Conditions--§ 25.349(a)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.349(a)
2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.349(a)
3. Differences With EASA CS 25.349(a)
4. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.349(a)
D. Outside View for Flightcrew and Overwing Emergency Exits--§ 25.809(a)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.809(a)
2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.809(a)
3. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.809(a)
E. Emergency Exit Marking and Lighting--Sec. § 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b)
1. Overview of Proposed Sec. § 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b)
2. Discussion of Proposed Sec. § 25.811 and 25.812
3. Advisory Material for Proposed Sec. § 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b)
F. Disposal of Combustible Materials--§ 25.853(g)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.853(g)
2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.853(g)
3. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.853(g)
G. Reverse Thrust and Propeller Pitch Settings Below the Flight Regime--§ 25.1155
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.1155
2. Background of Proposed § 25.1155
3. Discussion of Proposed § 25.1155
4. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.1155
H. Cowling and Nacelle Skin--§ 25.1193(e)(3)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.1193(e)(3)
2. Background of Proposed § 25.1193(e)(3)
3. Discussion of Proposed § 25.1193(e)(3)
4. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.1193(e)(3)
I. Powerplant and Auxiliary Power Unit (APU) Instruments--§ 25.1549
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.1549
2. Background of Proposed § 25.1549
3. Discussion of Proposed § 25.1549
J. Control Markings--§ 25.1555(d)(1)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.1555(d)(1)
2. Background of Proposed § 25.1555(d)(1)
3. Discussion of Proposed § 25.1555(d)(1)
4. Advisory Material for § 25.1555(d)(1)
K. Carriage of Authorized Persons on All-Cargo Airplanes--Sec. § 25.797 and 25.857(e)
1. Overview of Proposed Sec. § 25.797 and 25.857(e)
2. Background of Proposed Sec. § 25.797 and 25.857(e)
3. Discussion of Proposed Sec. § 25.797 and 25.857(e)
4. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.797
L. Fuel Tank Flammability Assessment Method (FTFAM)--Sec. § 25.5 and 25.981 and Section N25.3 of Appendix N to Part 25
1. Overview of Proposed FTFAM Proposed Rules
2. Discussion of FTFAM Proposed Rules
3. Advisory Material for FTFAM Proposed Rules
M. Pilot Compartment View--§ 25.773
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.773
2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.773
3. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.773
N. Medical Stretchers--§ 25.785(b)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.785(b)
2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.785(b)
O. Passenger Amenities--§ 25.788
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.788
2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.788
3. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.788
P. Ditching Emergency Exits for Passengers--§ 25.801(a)
Q. Emergency Egress Assist Means and Escape Routes--§ 25.810(a)(1)(ii)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.810(a)(1)(ii)
2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.810(a)(1)(ii)
3. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.810
R. Emergency Exit Access--§ 25.813
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.813
2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.813
3. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.813
S. Pressurized Cabins--§ 25.841(a) and (d)(1)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.841(a)
2. Background of Proposed § 25.841(a)
3. Discussion of Proposed § 25.841(a)
4. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.841(a)
5. Overview of Proposed § 25.841(d)(1)
6. Background of Proposed § 25.841(d)(1)
7. Discussion of Proposed § 25.841(d)(1)
T. Lavatory Fire Protection--§ 25.854
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.854
2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.854
3. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.854
U. Operation Without Normal Electrical Power--Sec. § 25.1351, 25.1352, and 25.1705
1. Overview of Proposed Sec. § 25.1351, 25.1352, and 25.1705
2. Background of Proposed Sec. § 25.1351, 25.1352, and 25.1705
3. Discussion of Proposed Sec. § 25.1351, 25.1352, and 25.1705
V. Equipment Standards for Oxygen Dispensing Units--§ 25.1447
1. Discussion of Proposed § 25.1447
2. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.1447 IV. Regulatory Notices and Analyses
A. Regulatory Impact Analysis
B. Regulatory Flexibility Act
C. International Trade Impact Assessment
D. Unfunded Mandates Assessment
E. Paperwork Reduction Act
F. International Compatibility
G. Environmental Analysis
H. Regulations Affecting Intrastate Aviation in Alaska V. Executive Order Determinations
A. E.O. 13132, Federalism
B. E.O. 13175, Consultation and Coordination With Indian Tribal Governments
C. E.O. 13211, Regulations That Significantly Affect Energy Supply, Distribution, or Use
D. E.O. 13609, Promoting International Regulatory Cooperation
E. E.O. 14192, Unleashing Prosperity Through Deregulation VI. Additional Information
A. Comments Invited
B. Confidential Business Information
C. Availability of Rulemaking Documents
D. Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act
E. Incorporation by Reference
I. Executive Summary
A. Overview of the Proposed Rule
A. Overview of the Proposed Rule
FAA proposes to amend various airworthiness regulations in title 14, Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) to modernize certain certification standards for transport category airplanes and propulsion systems. By codifying frequently issued exemptions and special conditions (SC or SCs) and reducing the need for equivalent level of safety (ELOS) findings, this proposal would reduce certification costs and time to certify new and changed products \1\ for both industry and FAA while maintaining or improving the level of safety provided by the current regulations. This proposal would address Aviation Rulemaking Advisory Committee (ARAC) \2\ recommendations, which advocated for these changes. In addition, it would address certain National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) recommendations while also harmonizing with European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) certification specifications (CS) to the extent practical.
B. Background
B. Background
Part 25 prescribes airworthiness standards for type certification of transport category airplanes. Some of these airworthiness standards may not adequately address a current certification project for many reasons, including prior safety-related incidents, new technology, and evolving industry needs. When such a gap is identified during the certification process, FAA addresses it by using a variety of design-specific tools, including, exemptions, SCs, and ELOS findings. FAA uses these tools to set requirements for a safe design for the product. However, these tools are labor intensive and costly for both the applicant seeking type certification \3\ and FAA. When a gap is identified, the applicant seeking type certification must submit project-specific data to support FAA's development of each exemption, SC, and ELOS finding. Upon receipt of data, FAA must analyze it to determine if it does in fact support the need for an exemption, SC, or ELOS finding and to ensure the level of safety is acceptable. In many cases, FAA will seek clarification or additional data from the applicant before making a determination. During this time-consuming process, the project may be delayed as the applicant and FAA collaborate on the issuance of these documents to be certain what requirements will be imposed on the proposed design. These project-specific tools add more flow-time and cost to each type certification project for both the applicant and FAA than would be needed if the published general airworthiness standards were written to better accommodate a wider range of designs. 1. Exemptions
As defined in § 11.15, a "petition for exemption" is a request to FAA by an individual or entity asking for relief from the requirements of a current regulation. After receiving the petition, FAA publishes a summary of it in the Federal Register, inviting the public to comment, unless FAA finds reasons per § 11.87 to not request public comment. FAA has statutory authority to grant an exemption that is in the public interest.\4\ Some considerations that aid the public interest determination are whether the exemption benefits the public as a whole, and why granting the exemption would not adversely affect safety or would at least provide a level of safety equal to that provided by the rule from which relief is sought. 2. Special Conditions
As defined in § 11.19, an SC is a rule that applies to a particular proposed design. Per § 21.16, FAA issues SCs if the airworthiness regulations do not contain adequate or appropriate safety standards for an aircraft, aircraft engine, or propeller because of a novel or unusual design feature. The phrase "novel or unusual" applies to design features of the product to be certificated when compared to the current airworthiness standards.
FAA uses the issue paper (IP) process described in FAA Order 8110.112A, "Standardized Procedures for Usage of Issue Papers and Development of Equivalent Levels of Safety Memorandums," dated October 3, 2014, to develop the SCs.\5\ FAA then issues the SCs after engaging in the public comment procedures of § 11.38. The SCs contain additional airworthiness standards FAA finds necessary to establish a level of safety equivalent to that established in the existing regulations. 3. Equivalent Level of Safety (ELOS) Findings
FAA makes an ELOS finding when literal compliance with an airworthiness standard cannot be shown and, per § 21.21(b)(1), compensating factors can be shown to provide a level of safety equivalent to that established by the airworthiness standards. An ELOS finding may document compliance criteria different from what is stated in the rule, but is judged as acceptable by FAA.\6\
A difference between SCs and ELOS findings is SCs focus on direct compliance with specific requirements for new and novel designs, while ELOS findings allow a non-compliant design to meet the same level of safety as existing airworthiness standards due to compensating factors. SCs are only used for aircraft with novel or unusual design features.
Unlike exemptions and SCs, an ELOS finding is not developed through a public comment process. Like an SC, though, FAA and the applicant use the IP process described in FAA Order 8110.112A to develop the proposed ELOS finding. The IP documents the evolution and conclusion of the applicant's request for an ELOS finding.
FAA posts online an ELOS memorandum for each ELOS finding, to communicate the rationale to the public. The ELOS memorandum is a publicly releasable document that is a part of the project's certification basis. The ELOS memorandum explains the basis for FAA's finding that the applicant's proposal provides an ELOS to the airworthiness standards and documents those critical aspects of the ELOS finding that must be maintained for continued airworthiness.
C. Regulatory Reform of Aviation Regulations
C. Regulatory Reform of Aviation Regulations
When Executive Order (E.O.) 13777, "Enforcing the Regulatory Reform Agenda," was signed on February 24, 2017, it required each Federal agency to establish a Regulatory Reform Task Force (RRTF) to evaluate current regulations and make recommendations for their repeal, replacement, or modification. As part of this process, the E.O. required the RRTF to seek input and assistance from entities significantly affected by its regulations. Because the ARAC's membership represents a broad spectrum of entities significantly affected by FAA's regulations, DOT, through FAA, tasked ARAC to consider (1) recommendations on existing regulations that are good candidates for repeal, replacement, or modification; and (2) recommendations on regulatory action identified in FAA's regulatory agenda.\7\ ARAC submitted its initial recommendation report to FAA on June 8, 2017,\8\ and an addendum to the report on September 12, 2017.\9\ ARAC recommended several changes to parts of 14 CFR, which included recommendations to codify the terms of frequently issued exemptions, SCs, and ELOS findings used in the certification process while also harmonizing FAA's regulations with the airworthiness standards in EASA CS-25.
D. Section 312 of FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024
D. Section 312 of FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024
Section 312 of FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 titled "Transport airplane and propulsion certification modernization" requires FAA to publish a draft rule on this subject. The agency added this item to its regulatory agenda in 2022.
E. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) Recommendations
E. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) Recommendations
The NTSB is an independent U.S. government agency that investigates civil transportation accidents and makes recommendations to prevent future accidents. This proposed rule would address certain NTSB Safety Recommendations issued following accidents involving turboprop-powered transport category airplanes.\10\ For details on these accidents and the resulting recommendations, see the discussion in section III.G.2. of this NPRM.
F. Proposed Regulatory Relief Resulting From ARAC and NTSB Recommendations
F. Proposed Regulatory Relief Resulting From ARAC and NTSB Recommendations
In response to ARAC and NTSB recommendations, FAA is proposing the following ten deregulatory actions to reduce certification costs and the time to certify new products for both industry and FAA, while maintaining or increasing the level of safety compared to the existing regulations:
1. Remove Special Federal Aviation Regulation (SFAR) No. 109 from part 25 and relocate certain parts or portions of its requirements to new Sec. § 25.821, 25.823, 25.825, 25.827, 25.829, and 25.830 to harmonize with the corresponding EASA airworthiness standards. FAA would also incorporate definitions of "low occupancy" and "non-commercially operated" airplanes in new § 25.4(d) to reduce the need for exemptions and ELOS findings for cabin interior designs of transport category airplanes operated for private use. For details, see the discussion under section III.A of this NPRM.
2. Revise § 25.251(b) to allow use of an acceptable means, other than flight test, for speeds above VMO/ MMO,\11\ to demonstrate the effects from external modifications \12\ to an existing type design. This would eliminate the need for ELOS findings. For details, see the discussion under section III.B of this NPRM.
3. Revise § 25.349(a) to prescribe the design rolling maneuver requirement in terms of flightdeck roll control movement, rather than aileron deflection, to ensure that the rolling maneuver loads used in the structural design of the airplane are adequate. This would eliminate the need for SCs. For details, see the discussion under section III.C of this NPRM.
4. Revise § 25.809(a) to remove the requirement to be able to view the evacuee landing point from flightcrew and overwing exits because the structure of the wing under the overwing exits and curvature of the fuselage under the flightcrew exit obstructs the view of the evacuee landing point. This would eliminate the need for exemptions and would harmonize with EASA CS 25.809(a). For details, see the discussion under section III.D of this NPRM.
5. Revise Sec. § 25.811 and 25.812 to permit alternative exit sign configurations. This would eliminate the need for ELOS findings and harmonize with the corresponding EASA airworthiness standards within CS 25.811 and CS 25.812. For details, see the discussion under sections III.A.2.k and III.E of this NPRM.
6. Revise § 25.853(g) to replace the requirement to have self-contained removable ashtrays installed in lavatories with a requirement lavatories have a means to safely dispose of lit combustible material. This would provide operators with more design options and potentially eliminate excessive maintenance. For details, see the discussion under section III.F of this NPRM.
7. Revise § 25.1155 to require a means to prevent the flightcrew on propeller-powered airplanes from inadvertently or intentionally placing the power lever below flight idle while in flight, unless the airplane has been certified for that type of operation, and to require a similar provision for turbojet-powered airplanes with thrust reverser systems intended for use only on the ground. This would address NTSB safety recommendations and harmonize with EASA CS 25.1155. For details, see the discussion under section III.G of this NPRM.
8. Revise § 25.1193(e)(3) to maintain the existing fireproof requirement for cowling and nacelle skin for in-flight operations while providing an alternative requirement for ground operation. This would eliminate the need for ELOS findings and harmonize with EASA CS 25.1193(e)(3). For details, see the discussion under section III.H of this NPRM.
9. Revise § 25.1549 to allow manufacturers flexibility to (1) provide awareness of only those powerplant and auxiliary power unit (APU) operating conditions that require flightcrew action necessary to maintain continued safe operation, (2) use colors other than green to denote normal operating conditions, and (3) provide any additional information needed by maintenance personnel when following the instructions for continued airworthiness. This would eliminate the need for ELOS findings. For details, see the discussion under section III.I of this NPRM.
10. Revise § 25.1555(d)(1) to require each emergency control either be colored red or illuminate red when a condition necessitates its use, and have appropriate safeguards to allow its intended use while preventing unintentional actuation and not restricting its use when needed. This would eliminate the need for ELOS findings. For details, see the discussion under section III.J of this NPRM.\13\
G. Additional Proposed Regulatory Relief
G. Additional Proposed Regulatory Relief
FAA reviewed its certification process to find other areas not identified by ARAC or NTSB where the certification standards for transport category airplanes and propulsion systems could be modernized. FAA identified several exemptions, SCs, and ELOS findings FAA frequently grants or issues during the certification process. Based on this review, FAA identified fourteen additional deregulatory actions to reduce certification costs and the time to certify new products for both industry and FAA, while maintaining or improving the level of safety in the existing regulations.
1. Add new § 25.797 for carriage of authorized persons,\14\ and add a provision to § 25.857(e) allowing authorized persons to be carried in airplanes with Class E cargo compartments provided the requirements of § 25.797 are met. This would eliminate the need for exemptions commonly granted by FAA for carriage of authorized persons. For details, see the discussion under section III.K of this NPRM.
2. Revise Sec. § 25.5 and 25.981 and appendix N to part 25 to require a new Fuel Tank Flammability Assessment Method (FTFAM). This would eliminate the need for applicants to submit additional paperwork requesting use of the new FTFAM. For details, see the discussion under section III.L of this NPRM.
3. Revise § 25.773(a)(2) to allow use of ground tests in lieu of night flight tests to show the flightdeck is free of glare and reflection. The proposed allowance for ground tests would eliminate the need for ELOS findings. For details, see the discussion under section III.M of this NPRM.
4. Revise § 25.773(b)(1) to require the means to maintain a clear portion of the windshield function in light precipitation conditions at speeds normally encountered during ground operations. Proposed § 25.773(b)(1) would eliminate SCs commonly granted for use of hydrophobic coatings in lieu of windshield wipers. For details, see the discussion under section III.M of this NPRM.
5. Revise § 25.785(b) to except berths intended for carriage of medical patients (e.g., medical stretchers) from the requirements of § 25.562 for emergency landing dynamic conditions. This would eliminate the need for exemptions commonly granted for the transportation of persons on medical stretchers. For details, see the discussion under section III.N of this NPRM.
6. Add new § 25.788 to require safety standards for installation of showers, large display panels, and large, nonstructural glass panels. The proposed requirements for shower and large display panels would harmonize with the corresponding EASA airworthiness standards in EASA CS 25.788. The proposed requirements for large, nonstructural glass panels would eliminate the need for commonly issued SCs. For details, see the discussion under section III.O of this NPRM.
7. Revise § 25.801(a) to change the citation referenced from § 25.807(e) to § 25.807(i). This would correct an error introduced with amendment 25-88 when FAA moved its "ditching emergency exits for passengers" requirements from paragraph (e) to (i). It also would harmonize with EASA CS 25.801(a). For details, see the discussion under section III.P of this NPRM.
8. Revise § 25.810(a)(1)(ii) to provide an option allowing 10 seconds to automatically erect assisting means from the time the opening means of the exit is actuated for non-Type C exits. This would harmonize the proposed requirement with the corresponding EASA CS 25.810(a)(1)(ii). For details, see the discussion under section III.Q of this NPRM.
9. Revise § 25.813 to incorporate improvements for Type III and IV emergency exit access and ease of operation. This would harmonize the proposed requirements with the corresponding EASA airworthiness standards in CS 25.813. For details, see the discussion under section III.R of this NPRM.
10. Revise § 25.841(a) regarding the exposure of occupants to certain cabin pressure altitudes due to cabin decompression caused by structural, system, or engine failures. This would eliminate the need for commonly granted exemptions. In addition, revise § 25.841(d)(1) regarding the cabin pressure high altitude warning alert during high elevation airport operations. This would correct the current description. For details, see the discussion under section III.S of this NPRM.
11. Revise § 25.854 to add cabin length to the applicability of lavatory fire protection. This would harmonize the proposed requirements with the corresponding EASA airworthiness standards. For details, see the discussion under section III.T of this NPRM.
12. Move the requirements for operation without normal electrical power for airplanes that use mechanical flight controls from § 25.1351(d) into new § 25.1352 and add similar requirements for airplanes that use electrical and electronic systems to perform critical functions. In addition, revise § 25.1705 to reference the § 25.1352 requirements. This would eliminate the need for commonly issued SCs. For details, see the discussion under section III.U of this NPRM.
13. Revise § 25.1365(b) to require that installations of galleys and cooking appliances minimize the hazards, such as burns and spilled liquids, to the airplane, passengers, and crew. This would harmonize the proposed requirements with the corresponding EASA airworthiness standards. For details, see the discussion under section III.A.2(l) of this NPRM.
14. Add § 25.1447(c)(6) to require sufficient oxygen outlets in areas of the cabin, other than those addressed by § 25.1447(c)(1), that may be occupied by passengers or crew. This would harmonize proposed § 25.1447(c)(6) with EASA CS 25.1447(c)(3). For details, see the discussion under section III.V of this NPRM.\15\
H. Harmonization With EASA Certification Specifications
H. Harmonization With EASA Certification Specifications
EASA CS-25 prescribes the airworthiness standards corresponding to 14 CFR part 25 for products certified by the European Union. Applicants for FAA type certification of transport category airplanes also seek EASA validation of the type certificate, for which the applicant must show compliance with EASA CS-25. Though part 25 and CS-25 are similar, they differ in several respects. Where part 25 and CS-25 differ, an applicant must meet both airworthiness standards to obtain a U.S. type certificate and validation of the type certificate by EASA, or obtain exemptions, SCs, or ELOS findings or the foreign authority's equivalent to those, as necessary to meet one standard in lieu of the other.\16\ Harmonizing FAA's requirements with those of EASA would benefit manufacturers and modifiers by providing them requirements consistent between both authorities with which they must show compliance, thereby reducing the cost and complexity of certification and codifying a consistent level of safety between authorities. To improve certification efficiency, this proposed rule would eliminate 27 differences between U.S. and European airworthiness standards in CS-25 amendment 28, while maintaining or improving the level of safety provided by the current regulations.
FAA is not aware of any aircraft manufacturers who sell only to the U.S. market. As such, these manufacturers design their aircraft to meet both FAA and EASA regulations. Therefore, any proposal below to match EASA regulations would result in no new requirements for applicants.
FAA's draft guidance material associated with this proposed rule would also provide harmonized compliance approaches with EASA's Acceptable Means of Compliance (AMC) in CS-25 amendment 28.
I. Costs and Benefits of the Proposed Rule
I. Costs and Benefits of the Proposed Rule
FAA expects modernization of airworthiness standards for type certification of transport category airplanes would reduce time to certify and certification costs for manufacturers, modifiers, and FAA while maintaining or increasing safety. FAA expects this reduction in costs and time to certify would also promote innovation by reducing (1) the time and costs for manufacturers and modifiers to obtain type certification for new or changed products and (2) disincentives to design changes and improvements.
This proposed rule would also eliminate certain differences between U.S. and European airworthiness standards. Because U.S. manufacturers and modifiers of transport category airplanes typically sell their products domestically and internationally, harmonizing FAA's requirements with those of EASA would reduce the cost and complexity of certification by eliminating the necessity of establishing the aircraft design meets different requirements.
II. Authority for This Rulemaking
II. Authority for This Rulemaking
FAA's authority to issue rules on aviation safety is found in title 49 of the United States Code. Subtitle I, Section 106 describes the authority of the FAA Administrator. Subtitle VII, Aviation Programs, describes in more detail the scope of FAA's authority.
This rulemaking is issued under the authority described in Subtitle VII, Part A, Subpart III, Section 44701, "General Requirements." Under that section, FAA is charged with prescribing regulations that promote safe flight of civil aircraft in air commerce by prescribing regulations and minimum standards for the design and performance of aircraft the Administrator finds necessary for safety in air commerce. This regulation is within the scope of that authority as it prescribes new safety standards for the design and performance of transport category airplanes.
In addition, Section 312, "Transport airplane and propulsion certification modernization," of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 (Pub. L. 118-63) requires FAA to publish a notice of proposed rulemaking on this subject.
III. Discussion of the Proposed Rule
III. Discussion of the Proposed Rule
A. Executive Interiors--SFAR No. 109 and Proposed Sec. § 25.4(d), 25.821, 25.823, 25.825, 25.827, 25.829, 25.830, 25.812(e)(3), 25.812(l)(1), 25.1365, and 25.1583(j)
1. Overview of Proposed Sec. § 25.4(d), 25.821, 25.823, 25.825, 25.827, 25.829, 25.830, 25.812(e)(3), 25.812(l)(1), 25.1365, and 25.1583(j)
1. Overview of Proposed Sec. § 25.4(d), 25.821, 25.823, 25.825, 25.827, 25.829, 25.830, 25.812(e)(3), 25.812(l)(1), 25.1365, and 25.1583(j)
FAA issued SFAR No. 109 on May 8, 2009 (74 FR 21533). SFAR No. 109 amended the airworthiness standards for transport category airplanes by adding new cabin interior criteria for operators of private use, not for hire, not for common carriage airplanes. The standards in SFAR No. 109 provide alternative criteria for transport category airplanes that are operated for private use while continuing to provide an acceptable level of safety for those operations. The applicability of SFAR No. 109 is limited to airplanes with 60 or fewer passengers (SFAR No. 109 paragraph 2(a)).
Currently, proposed designs for transport category airplanes must comply with the standards of part 25 to be eligible for a type certificate in this category, with exceptions provided in SFAR No. 109 for airplanes meeting the applicability of that SFAR. Because most transport category airplanes are used by airlines, the requirements of part 25 are largely developed for cabin interiors equipped for the commercial carriage of relatively high numbers of passengers. Part 25, therefore, is not fully adapted to cabin interiors of executive interiors, i.e., those that are arranged with a much lower number of passenger seats relative to the size of the airplane, offer a greater level of comfort and amenities, and are often not operated commercially or for profit. FAA intended SFAR No. 109 to provide time and cost savings for the cabin certification process for private use airplanes; \17\ however, applicants have rarely chosen to use the SFAR since issuance, and FAA has continued to issue many exemptions and make ELOS findings for the interior designs of these private use airplanes.\18\
Furthermore, ARAC recommended that FAA repeal SFAR No. 109 and harmonize several related regulations with the corresponding airworthiness standards in EASA CS-25, amendment 19.\19\ The proposed Sec. § 25.4(d), 25.821, 25.823, 25.825, 25.827, 25.829, 25.830, 25.812(e)(3), 25.812(l)(1), 25.1365, and 25.1583(j) would replace SFAR No. 109, harmonize to the extent practical with EASA CS-25 at amendment 19, and eliminate the necessity for most exemptions and ELOS findings FAA commonly issues for low occupancy executive interiors. 2. Discussion of Proposed Sec. § 25.4(d), 25.821, 25.823, 25.825, 25.827, 25.829, 25.830, 25.812(e)(3), 25.812(l)(1), 25.1365, and 25.1583(j)
Three limitations of SFAR No. 109 that continue to drive applicants to choose not to use it are (1) it is limited to only private use airplanes, so it provides no relief for chartered jets operated under part 135; (2) applicants must limit occupancy to 60 passengers; and (3) applicants must meet all applicable provisions of SFAR No. 109 if seeking certification under its provisions and thus cannot choose to use alternative standards for any part of the interior. The capacity of some proposed larger airplanes with executive interiors has exceeded 60 passengers, and FAA has granted exemptions for these configurations with the same limitations as SFAR No. 109. FAA has also granted exemptions for certain executive interior features, such as interior doors, in chartered jets operated under part 135.
EASA initiated a rulemaking committee in 2012 \20\ to develop new standards for executive interiors. FAA, other aviation authorities, and industry representatives participated in that rulemaking committee. EASA issued Notice of Proposed Amendment (NPA) 2015-19, "Executive interior accommodation," on December 17, 2015, followed by amendment 19 \21\ of EASA CS-25 on May 12, 2017, incorporating the recommendations of the committee. The requirements adopted by EASA in this amendment have some differences from the provisions currently in part 25, including SFAR No. 109, the most significant being inclusion of standards for low occupancy, commercially operated airplanes.
Subsequently, EASA issued NPA 2017-12 on July 24, 2017, followed by amendment 21 on March 27, 2018, to amend appendix S of CS-25 by creating paragraph S25.60 on security requirements, which set design standards regarding limiting effects of incendiary devices, ensuring survivability of systems, deterring concealment of weapons and explosives, and other similar security related considerations, to exempt non-commercially operated airplanes certified in accordance with appendix S from the CS 25.795(b), (c), and (d) requirements. EASA based this amendment on SFAR No. 109 paragraph 16, which provided relief from § 25.795. The limitations of SFAR No. 109 and these differences between part 25 and CS-25 result in FAA's frequent issuance of various exemptions and ELOS findings, which increases the risk of application of different levels of safety, excess certification costs, and a lack of standardization with the regulations of other airworthiness authorities.
FAA proposes to remove SFAR No. 109 and add many of its requirements into new Sec. § 25.4(d), 25.821, 25.823, 25.825, 25.827, 25.829, and 25.830. Though some of the proposals linked to this change would reduce the need for exemptions and ELOS findings in the future, other changes would harmonize requirements applicable to low occupancy airplanes and non-commercially operated airplanes with the corresponding sections of EASA CS to the extent consistent with FAA's statutory safety mission. This would serve to eliminate the costs and resource allocation required for an applicant to meet two differing certification standards.
EASA incorporated requirements for low occupancy airplanes and non-commercially operated airplanes in the form of an appendix to CS-25. The U.S. regulatory structure does not permit issuance of requirements in the form of appendices; \22\ therefore, FAA proposes the numbering structure presented in the following table:
Table 1--Proposed FAA Regulations Corresponding to EASA C-25 Regulations
Table 1--Proposed FAA Regulations Corresponding to EASA C-25 Regulations
Corresponding EASA CS-25
Proposed FAA regulation regulation
Sec. 25.4(d) … Appendix S, S25.1.
Sec. 25.821 … Appendix S, S25.10.
Sec. 25.823 … Appendix S, S25.20.
Sec. 25.825 … Appendix S, S25.30.
Sec. 25.827 … Appendix S, S25.40.
Sec. 25.829 … Appendix S, S25.50.
Sec. 25.830 … Appendix S, S25.60.
These EASA appendix S regulations are applicable only to low occupancy airplanes or non-commercially operated airplanes, as specified in each regulation. EASA also incorporated certain provisions, historically addressed by FAA using SFAR No. 109, exemptions and ELOS findings, into CS 25.812(e)(3), 25.812(l)(1), and 25.1365 to make them applicable to any transport category airplane, as discussed below in this preamble. FAA is also proposing to add new § 25.1583(j) to ensure non-commercially operated airplanes have the appropriate limitations in their airplane flight manuals (AFM). a. Proposed § 25.4(d), Non-Commercially Operated Airplanes and Low Occupancy Airplanes Defined
FAA proposes to incorporate definitions of "low occupancy airplanes" and "non-commercially operated airplanes" in new § 25.4(d), in order to clarify the application of this proposed rule and expand the applicability of relief from certain part 25 regulations beyond that provided currently by SFAR No. 109. These proposed definitions align with the definitions in CS 25, appendix S.1(a).
SFAR No. 109 applies to airplanes not "offered for common carriage or operated for hire" for which passenger capacity may not exceed 60 (SFAR No. 109 paragraph 2(a) and (d)). In addition, paragraph 7(c) of SFAR No. 109, for airplanes with more than one exit pair (which is required for passenger seating configurations of 20 or more per § 25.807(g)) in which an exit is deactivated to result in an exit distance greater than 60 feet, limits the total number of passenger seats in the airplane to 33 percent of the maximum seating capacity for the airplane model using the exit ratings listed in § 25.807(g) for the original certified exits or the maximum allowable after modification when exits are deactivated, whichever is less. The proposed definition for "non-commercially operated" airplanes would align with CS-25 appendix S.1 and change the upper limit on the total number of passenger seats, for passenger seating configurations of 20 or more, to 50 percent of the maximum passenger seating capacity on the type certificate data sheet (TCDS). The proposed definition would also apply an upper limit of 150 passengers per deck or one-half of the maximum passenger seating capacity for that deck as indicated in the airplane TCDS, whichever is less.
As part of its certification of transport category airplanes proposed to be configured with executive interiors and operated under part 135, the SFAR 109 final rule has a table identifying which paragraphs could also be accepted in part 135 operation, and FAA has granted exemptions \23\ more recently for interior doors to be deployed in part 135 operation provided additional limitations and conditions, such as low occupancy, additional alerting, or additional crew procedures, are part of the proposed design. These additional requirements align with CS-25 appendix S. For these airplanes with executive interiors and operated under part 135, FAA has not granted the same extent of relief as for non-commercially operated airplanes, in recognition of 49 U.S.C. 44701(d), which requires FAA to consider the differences between air transportation and other air commerce.
The EASA rulemaking committee worked on standards for executive interiors considered commercially operated as well as non-commercially operated executive interior configurations and developed recommendations for both types of operation. This rulemaking committee analyzed more than 60 cabin floor plans, provided by the large airplane manufacturers and modifiers represented within the committee, of large airplanes certified over the last 10-15 years with executive interiors and a maximum passenger seating configuration of 20 or more. The committee analysis results \24\ showed the evacuation and aisle characteristics of the executive interiors were in general very favorable compared to arrangements composed of conventional seat rows cabin floor layout and a much lower evacuation time than with the current requirement (§ 25.803(c) and CS 25.803(c)) could be expected. The committee determined certain provisions appropriate for executive interiors could be applied to both commercially operated and non-commercially operated airplanes due to the low occupancy.
The committee analysis showed these airplanes have mostly a passenger seating capacity that does not exceed one-third of the maximum passenger seating capacity allowed by the TCDS.
Based on the committee analysis, EASA incorporated a new definition of "low occupancy" airplane that encompasses those airplanes that have a passenger seating capacity limited to 19 (per the TCDS), as well as larger airplanes configured for operating with no more than one-third of the approved passenger seating capacity on the TCDS (both in total capacity and per zone),\25\but not to exceed 100 passenger seats per deck. The limits for both non-commercial and low occupancy are consistent with a number of designs approved by EASA over the past 10-15 years for these operations.\26\
FAA has carefully reviewed the EASA committee analysis and rationale and has determined additional analysis or studies are not required. FAA's proposed definitions would be identical to the EASA CS-25 definitions, except that FAA would add "not offered for common carriage and not operated for hire" to the definition of non-commercially operated airplanes. FAA uses the phrase "not for hire, not for compensation" in SFAR No. 109 and in its exemptions and ELOS findings on executive interiors. This difference is for clarity in the U.S. aviation system, and FAA proposes it would not result in a substantively different definition than EASA S25.1(a)(1). b. Proposed § 25.1583(j), Limitation For Non-Commercially Operated Airplanes
As discussed, FAA applies different design standards to commercially operated airplanes as compared to non-commercially operated airplanes. The proposed § 25.1583(j) would require applicants to include limitations in the limitations section of the airplane flight manual for proposed airplane designs that would incorporate interior features permitted only in non-commercially operated airplanes. This limitation would ensure those airplanes are not offered for hire or common carriage. c. Proposed § 25.821, General Cabin Arrangement
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 10 provides requirements applicable to the proposed installation of interior doors between passenger seats and exits on non-commercially operated airplanes in lieu of the requirements of § 25.813(e), which prohibits such doors. Prior to SFAR 109, FAA had granted several exemptions from § 25.813(e) for installation of interior doors; these exemptions included conditions and limitations consistent with SFAR No. 109 paragraph 10. EASA's amendment 19 to CS-25 expanded the allowance for installation of interior doors to commercially operated airplanes having a passenger seating configuration of 19 or less, but with additional safety requirements as compared to non-commercially operated airplanes. After EASA issued amendment 19 to CS-25, FAA reviewed the EASA rule, analysis, and rationale and has determined additional analysis or studies are not required, and as such began issuing exemptions \27\ from § 25.813(e), for the installation of interior doors, that used the same conditions and limitations as CS-25 sections S25.10(a) and (b).
These conditions and limitations provide layers of protection against the possibility of a passenger being trapped in a compartment in the event of an emergency landing or evacuation, by imposing restrictions on when the door may be closed. As such, FAA has determined these sections provide a functional equivalent to SFAR 109 paragraph 10. Section S25.10(a)(3) requires in the event of probable failures or jamming of the door, an occupant can restore, in an "easy and simple manner," a sufficient opening to get through to the compartment on the other side of the door. The term "easy and simple manner" means an applicant should demonstrate that an occupant who is not familiar with the specific cabin features of the airplane can understand and easily achieve the manner in which to evacuate based on the information provided to a typical passenger. This performance-based language addresses the same safety concern as the SFAR 109 paragraph 10(e) requirement for frangibility.
To eliminate the need for these exemptions in the future, FAA proposes to adopt the requirements of CS-25 section S25.10(a) and (b) as new § 25.821(a) and (b).
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 13 provides requirements for fire detection in isolated compartments for airplanes with a type certificated passenger capacity of 20 or more. EASA S25.10(c) aligns with these requirements, but adds applicability to airplanes with a cabin length of more than 60 feet, to ensure an adequate level of safety for airplanes of that size configured with low occupancy. EASA S25.10(c) also includes an option for a visual indication or audible warning in the passenger cabin that would be readily detected by a cabin crew member instead of the SFAR 109 requirement to signal the flightcrew. This paragraph provides a further option: if it can be demonstrated that a fire would be directly and quickly detected because the compartment is likely to be occupied for the majority of the flight time, a smoke detection system is not required. These options are not in SFAR No. 109 paragraph 13; however, FAA proposes to add these options because if the compartment is occupied for the majority of the flight time it would not be considered isolated (smoke would be detected by the occupants making the need for a detection system unnecessary) and the system can warn the cabin crew directly of the threat instead of waiting for the flightcrew to communicate the warning to the cabin crew. Therefore, FAA proposes to adopt the requirements of CS-25 section S25.10(c) as new § 25.821(c).
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 7 allows the deactivation of exits to create a distance of greater than 60 feet between exits and provides conditions a proposed design must meet if the distance between emergency exits exceeds that required by § 25.807(f)(4). EASA provided conditions in CS S25.10(d) and (e) similar to those of SFAR No. 109 paragraph 7, but with certain differences described below.
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 7(a) requires each passenger seat be located within 30 feet of the nearest exit on each side of the fuselage. EASA incorporated this condition as CS S25.10(d)(3) but used performance-based language in the requirement and provided an AMC to CS 25.10 different from SFAR No. 109 paragraph 7(a). EASA CS S25.10(d)(3) states the distance from each passenger seat to at least one remaining emergency exit, on each side of the fuselage, remains "compatible with easy egress" from the airplane. EASA's AMC to CS 25.10 provides a method of compliance for "compatible with easy egress" as meeting two conditions: (1) within 30 feet from the nearest emergency exit on one side of the fuselage on the same deck and within 45 feet from the nearest emergency exit on the other side of the fuselage on the same deck, and (2) the occupant of the seat has the possibility to move to an emergency exit, on the left side or the right side of the fuselage, while at all points along the way remaining within 30 feet of an emergency exit on one side of the fuselage on the same deck and within 45 feet of an emergency exit on the other side of the fuselage on the same deck. FAA has evaluated this difference and determined it fulfills the same intent as SFAR No. 109 paragraph 7(a) while providing applicants with flexibility in how compliance is shown for non-commercially operated airplanes only because passengers on commercial low occupancy airplanes would not have the familiarity of the cabin configuration as those passengers carried in private operations. FAA proposes to adopt the requirements of CS-25 section S25.10(d)(3) as new § 25.821(e)(3).
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 7(b) limits the number of passenger seats in passenger zones.\28\ For zones between two pairs of exits, SFAR No. 109 paragraph 7(b)(1) limits the number of passenger seats to 50 percent of the combined rated capacity of the two pairs of emergency exits. EASA incorporated this condition as CS S25.10(d)(1), with the same limit as SFAR No. 109 paragraph 7(b)(1). For zones between one pair of exits and a bulkhead, SFAR No. 109 paragraph 7(b)(2) limits the number of passenger seats to 40 percent of the rated capacity of the pair of emergency exits. EASA incorporated this condition as CS S25.10(d)(2) but set the limit at one-half (50 percent) of the rated capacity of the pair of emergency exits. FAA has evaluated this difference and determined it is minor and provides an acceptable level of safety for low occupancy and non-commercially operated airplanes. FAA proposes to adopt the requirements of CS-25 section S25.10(d)(1) as new § 25.821(e)(1) and section S25.10(d)(2) as new § 25.821(e)(2).
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 7(c) provides the condition that the total number of passenger seats in the airplane may not exceed 33 percent of the maximum seating capacity for the airplane model using the exit ratings listed in § 25.807(g) for the original certified exits or the maximum allowable after modification when exits are deactivated, whichever is less. This requirement is no longer limited to exit deactivation and is instead replaced by the seating capacity limitations in the definitions of non-commercially operated airplanes and low occupancy airplanes as adopted from EASA CS S25.1(a) and now defined in § 25.4(d) as discussed above. Passenger seating limits are further limited when exits are deactivated through adoption of EASA CS 25.10(d)(1) and (d)(2) as new § 25.821(e)(1) and (e)(2).
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 7(d) provides the condition that a distance of more than 60 feet between adjacent passenger emergency exits on the same side of the same deck of the fuselage is allowed only once on each side of the fuselage. EASA incorporated this condition as CS S25.10(e)(2). FAA proposes to move the requirements of SFAR No. 109 paragraph 7(d) to new § 25.821(e)(4).
Paragraph CS-25 S25.10(d), "Deactivation of existing emergency exits," specifies that deactivation of one or more emergency exits that results in non-compliance with CS 25.807(e) \29\ is acceptable, provided the applicant shows compliance with S25.10(d)(1) through S25.10(d)(3). These paragraphs place limitations of one-half the rated passenger capacity in the cabin zone of the exit pairs and require the distance from each passenger seat to at least one remaining exit on each side of the fuselage remain compatible with easy egress from the airplane. FAA finds compliance with the substance of the requirements of the equivalent proposed regulations § 25.821(e)(1) through (3) would result in compliance with § 25.807(e) because compliance with § 25.807(e) is not determined solely by exit location, but also by passenger seat distribution. The requirements of § 25.821(e)(1) through (3) ensure appropriate seat distribution. Therefore, FAA does not consider it possible to have a proposed configuration that meets the requirements of § 25.821(e)(1) through (3) and is simultaneously non-compliant with § 25.807(e). FAA provides guidance for this requirement in advisory circular (AC) 25.807-1, "Uniform Distribution of Exits." \30\ As such, FAA does not propose to include a separate set of requirements to address exit uniformity when exits are deactivated. Both non-commercially operated and low occupancy airplanes can continue to show compliance to § 25.807(e) when exits are deactivated as described in the EASA CS S25.10(d).
Paragraph CS-25 S25.10(e) permits deactivation of emergency exits that results in non-compliance with CS 25.807(f)(4) on non-commercially operated airplanes only, provided the requirements of S25.10(d)(1) through S25.10(d)(3) are met. CS 25.807(f)(4) requires passenger seats be no more than 60 feet from the adjacent emergency exit on the same side of the fuselage. FAA concurs with EASA that these restrictions are necessary where an applicant's proposed design would not comply with § 25.807(f)(4), and allowing such a noncompliance is only appropriate, from a safety perspective, for non-commercially operated airplanes. FAA proposes to adopt the substance of CS-25 sections S25.10(d)(1) through S25.10(d)(3) as § 25.821(e)(1) through § 25.821(e)(3), and S25.10(e)(2) as § 25.821(e)(4) as discussed previously. d. Proposed § 25.823, Emergency Evacuation and Flammability
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 12, Materials for Compartment Interiors, provides a condition under which an applicant need not demonstrate its proposed design's compliance with certain flammability requirements of § 25.853 if it can be shown the maximum time for evacuation of the occupants does not exceed 45 seconds. Also, in the course of approving the designs of non-SFAR 109 transport category airplanes, FAA granted several exemptions \31\ for executive interiors with this same condition. EASA incorporated this condition as CS S25.20(a)(2).
In addition, EASA provided a condition under which mattresses of permanent bed installations located in compartments isolated from the main passenger cabin by doors or equivalent means that would normally be closed during taxiing, takeoff, and landing need not meet the seat cushion flammability requirements of CS 25.853(c).\32\ Though FAA has not issued exemptions with a corresponding condition, FAA agrees with EASA the flammability requirement applied to passenger seat cushions need not be applied to mattresses of permanent bed installations located in compartments isolated from the main passenger cabin by doors or equivalent means that would normally be closed during taxiing, takeoff, and landing. Mattresses of permanent bed installations are very few in quantity and are not occupied for taxiing, takeoff, and landing, so their location in isolated compartments would not pose a significant contribution to occupant survivability during a post-crash fire. Mattresses of beds that are convertible to and from seats, regardless of their location in the airplane, and irrespective of whether the seat configuration is approved for occupancy during taxiing, takeoff, and landing, should meet the criteria of part 25, appendix F, part II. Accordingly, and to ensure harmonization with CS-25, FAA proposes to adopt the requirements of CS-25 section S25.20(a) as new § 25.823(a).
FAA has issued ELOS findings to § 25.813(c)(2) \33\ for proposed airplane designs with 19 or fewer passengers to allow items that can encroach into the projected exit opening of a Type III exit to create more than a minor obstruction.\34\ EASA incorporated an allowance in paragraph CS-25 S25.20(b), "Access to Type III and IV Emergency Exits," for low occupancy airplanes with a passenger seating configuration of 19 or less, and non-commercially operated airplanes. This paragraph, like FAA ELOS findings, permits certain airplanes to have an item deployable into the region defined by CS 25.813(c)(4)(i) or CS 25.813(c)(1), (c)(2), or (c)(3) for Type III and IV \35\ emergency exits that creates an obstruction as long as at least one of three requirements, S25.20(b)(1), (2), or (3), are met. The deployable items are mostly interior type design features such as reclining, tracking, swiveling seats, adjustable tables, and deployable video monitors.
S25.20(b)(1) requires a position monitoring and alerting system, and the exit opening remaining with the item in its most adverse position be at least as effective as a Type IV emergency exit or restorable to that level of effectiveness by simple and obvious means after any single failure. S25.20(b)(3) requires a cabin crew member to have a direct view of the deployable item and ability to confirm it is correctly stowed and secured, while seated during taxiing, takeoff, and landing. The conditions in S25.20(b)(1) and S25.20(b)(3) have been accepted by FAA as compensating features in previous ELOS findings; however, S25.20(b)(2) permits such obstruction if the approved number of passengers can be evacuated through the exit in question, with the obstruction in its most adverse position and under the conditions of appendix J, at least as quickly as the maximum number of passengers allowed by CS 25.807(g) without the obstruction, and demonstration that with the obstruction in place, the remaining exit is at least as effective as a Type IV emergency exit.
FAA does not adopt the terms of this provision (EASA S25.20(b)(2)) for this proposed rule. FAA considers EASA S25.20(b)(2) insufficient for two main reasons. First, the conditions for a demonstration are necessarily non-hazardous. Under actual emergency conditions (such as smoke in the cabin, adverse airplane attitude, or fuselage disruption), unobstructed access can be much more important than in a demonstration. Second, the Type IV exit is only permitted for airplanes with 9 or fewer passengers.\36\ Thus, though a Type IV exit does provide some evacuation capability, that capability is not sufficient for airplanes of the size addressed by the rule, thus is not an adequate lower bound on exit effectiveness. Conversely, the use of crew alerts and mandatory procedures, as in S25.20(b)(1) and S25.20(b)(3), are well-established practices for safety critical actions. FAA proposes to adopt the requirements of CS-25 section S25.20(b) as new § 25.823(b), except FAA does not adopt the terms of S25.20(b)(2). The proposed § 25.823(b) refers to the proposed Sec. § 25.813(c)(1), (c)(2), (c)(3), and (c)(4)(i), discussed in section III.R of this preamble. This proposal would eliminate the need for ELOS findings. e. Proposed § 25.825, Movement Inside Cabin During Flight
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 11, Width of Aisle, allows aisle width to be reduced to zero inches between passenger seats in-flight if:
• The applicant demonstrates that all areas of the cabin are easily accessible by a crew member in the event of an emergency.
• Instructions are provided at each passenger seat for restoring the aisle width required by § 25.815.
• Procedures are established and documented in the AFM to ensure the required aisle widths are provided during taxiing, takeoff, and landing.
EASA incorporated the same allowance and conditions in CS S25.30(a).
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 4(a) provides an alternate requirement to the handhold requirement of § 25.785(j) to allow a means to enable persons to steady themselves in moderately rough air. EASA incorporated the same alternate requirement in CS S25.30(b) adding language that the means must be an "acceptable means."
FAA proposes to adopt the requirements of CS-25 section S25.30 as new § 25.825 with the "acceptable means" language. An acceptable means of compliance with this section has been defined in a proposed Change 2 to AC 25-17A, "Transport Airplane Cabin Interiors Crashworthiness Handbook," which is available in the docket. The AC refers to the conditions for compliance for firm handholds in EASA AMC to appendix S, S25.30(b) amendment 28. f. Proposed § 25.827, Markings and Placards
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 6, Passenger Information Signs, provides, in lieu of the "no smoking" placard requirements of § 25.791(a),\37\ notification to the passengers may be provided by a single placard in the immediate vicinity of each passenger entry door. EASA incorporated this alternative requirement in CS S25.40(a), with three differences: (1) EASA expanded the applicability to also include low occupancy airplanes, (2) EASA added the lavatory "no smoking" placard requirements of CS 25.791(d) to the exclusion, and (3) EASA added an allowance to not comply with the lavatory ashtray requirements of CS 25.853(g). In addition, S25.40(a) explicitly requires the indication that smoking is prohibited to be the subject of a passenger briefing, where SFAR No. 109 has more general briefing requirements.
FAA proposes to adopt the requirements of CS-25 section S25.40(a) as new § 25.827(a), with one substantive difference. Paragraph CS-25 S25.40(a) permits relief from CS 25.791(a), CS 25.791(d), and CS 25.853(g) for both low occupancy and non-commercially operated airplanes. FAA finds such relief appropriate for non-commercially operated airplanes, but not for commercially operated, low occupancy airplanes. FAA is proposing alternate, more performance-based language for § 25.853(g), as discussed in section III.F of this preamble. The reasons FAA is maintaining requirements for disposal means for lit cigarettes in § 25.853(g) are discussed in that section. FAA has provided exclusions to this requirement for non-commercially operated airplanes because persons flying on non-commercially operated airplanes typically have more knowledge and familiarity in doing so. FAA is not aware of a persuasive reason to expand this exclusion to commercially operated airplanes of any size or occupancy. FAA proposes to apply the corresponding § 25.827(a) only to airplanes operated non-commercially.
CS-25 S25.40(b) provides an allowance for non-commercially operated airplanes to reduce the number of markings and placards required by CS 25.1541 by providing briefing cards that are part of the type design, referenced in the limitations section of the AFM, and are easily accessible from each passenger seat. Owners of non-commercially operated airplanes typically prefer, for aesthetic reasons, fewer placards on interior furnishings; however, FAA has not previously granted relief from § 25.1541. The proposed requirements will allow the briefing card to replace multiple placards throughout the cabin because the briefing cards would convey the necessary information. FAA agrees with EASA that providing briefing cards under the conditions stipulated in CS-25 S25.40(b) (that the cards are referenced in the limitations section of the AFM and are easily accessible from each passenger seat) provides an acceptable level of safety for non-commercially operated airplanes. FAA proposes to adopt the requirements of CS-25 S25.40(b) as § 25.827(b).
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 2(a)(1) requires each seat not suitable for occupancy during taxiing, takeoff, and landing be marked as such. EASA incorporated this requirement as S25.40(c)(2), with the additional constraint the placard be legible to the seated occupant. SFAR No. 109 paragraph 2(a)(2) requires, if more than 60 passenger seats (the passenger capacity limit of SFAR No. 109) are installed, the AFM and a placard adjacent to each passenger boarding door state the maximum passenger capacity. EASA incorporated this requirement as paragraph CS-25 S25.40(c)(1), except the upper limit is the approved passenger seating configuration rather than a limit of 60 passengers. Paragraph CS-25 S25.40(c)(1) defines "seats in excess" as the difference between the total number of seats approved for occupancy during taxiing, takeoff, and landing and the approved passenger seating configuration.
Though EASA defines the "approved passenger seating configuration" as the maximum number of passengers that may be carried on the airplane, FAA finds this could create some confusion and proposes to clarify the issue. FAA considers the approved passenger seating configuration to be the type design definition of the seat installation (which includes the seats in excess);
this is not the same as the maximum passenger capacity occupancy limitation (which does not include the seats in excess). The reason for this requirement is to ensure only the approved number of passengers will be carried as opposed to the number of passengers that would fill every seat on the airplane. FAA proposes to adopt the substance of the requirements of CS-25 S25.40(c) as § 25.827(c); however, FAA uses the term "maximum passenger seating capacity" in § 25.827(c). g. Proposed § 25.829, Cabin Crew Direct View
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 5, Direct View, provides an alternative requirement to § 25.785(h)(2) for non-commercially operated airplanes that a majority of the installed crew member seats must face the passenger cabin. EASA incorporated the same alternative requirement in S25.50(a) for non-commercially operated airplanes. In S25.50(b), EASA restated the content of CS 25.785(h)(2) as applicable to low occupancy airplanes. Because there is no difference between S25.50(b) and § 25.785(h)(2), a separate requirement to address cabin attendant direct view for low occupancy airplanes is not needed. FAA clarifies the AMC material referenced in EASA S25.50(b) is not an acceptable means of compliance to § 25.785(h)(2) as FAA and EASA have a long-standing difference in interpretation regarding what needs to be viewed when it comes to showing compliance with the direct view requirement. Existing FAA accepted means of compliance to § 25.785(h)(2) \38\ should be used when showing compliance to this rule for low occupancy airplanes. FAA proposes to move the substance of the requirements of SFAR No. 109 paragraph 5 as new § 25.829(a). FAA proposes to mark § 25.829(b) "Reserved." to maintain a similar paragraph structure as EASA S25.50. h. Proposed § 25.830, Security Considerations For Non-Commercially Operated Airplanes
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 16, Security, states the requirements of § 25.795 are not applicable to airplanes approved in accordance with SFAR 109. In the NPRM that proposed § 25.795,\39\ FAA noted airplanes used for private use generally are carrying individuals such as heads of state, business leaders, or other people who are guests of the airplane owner. FAA stated non-commercially operated airplanes are typically not targets of onboard terrorists because access is limited to these individuals and requiring the same security requirements as commercial airplanes would not provide a safety improvement.
FAA specifically sought input on this subject in the NPRM, but FAA received no comments. Because FAA did not receive further input on this topic and EASA harmonized with SFAR No. 109 in CS-25 section S25.60 at amendment 21, FAA proposes to incorporate this language as § 25.830, with applicability to airplanes operated non-commercially. i. Injury Criteria For Multiple-Occupancy Side-Facing Seats
SFAR No. 109, paragraph 4(b) provides injury criteria for multiple-occupancy side-facing seats. This proposed rule would remove SFAR No. 109 but not replace its injury criteria for multiple-occupancy side-facing seats in the proposed updates to part 25. FAA issued Policy Statement PS-ANM-25-03-R1, "Technical Criteria for Approving Side-Facing Seats," dated November 5, 2012,\40\ to provide updated injury criteria for side-facing seats, based on FAA research, that FAA has been applying via SCs to projects with this design feature. These updated test methods address potential neck and leg injuries not addressed by SFAR No. 109. In that policy statement, FAA stated it is considering whether rulemaking should be initiated to revise SFAR No. 109 to adopt the new criteria. Based on the need to update the test criteria, FAA funded additional research into injury mechanisms associated with different seat orientations. Until that information is complete, FAA does not plan to initiate rulemaking to mandate new seat test criteria. However, SFAR No. 109 requirements do not address all known injury mechanisms. Therefore, instead of continuing to allow usage of injury criteria that may be inadequate, FAA proposes to remove the requirements for multiple-occupancy side-facing seats currently in SFAR No. 109 and apply updated seat test criteria on a project-specific basis using SCs. j. Emergency Exit Signs
Section 25.811(d)(1) contains requirements for emergency exit locator signs, and § 25.811(d)(2) contains requirements for emergency exit marking signs. SFAR No. 109, paragraph 8 provides conditions under which a single sign can be installed at each exit to serve both the marking and locator sign function. FAA also provides guidance in AC 25-17A, applicable to all proposed transport category airplanes, to permit a single sign to serve both the locator and marker sign functions of paragraphs (d)(1) and (d)(2). Therefore, because the use of a single sign to serve both functions is already allowed under part 25, FAA has determined retaining paragraph 8 of SFAR 109 would be superfluous and thus proposes to not carry it over into this rulemaking. k. Emergency Lighting--§ 25.812
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 9(a) provides alternate size and brightness requirements for emergency exit signs in lieu of the requirements of § 25.812(b)(1). FAA is incorporating these alternate requirements into § 25.812(b)(2), along with other updates to incorporate the terms of commonly issued ELOS findings as discussed in section III.E. of this NPRM.
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 9(b) provides alternate requirements for floor proximity escape path markings in lieu of the requirements of § 25.812(e)(1). For cabin seating compartments that do not have the main cabin aisle entering and exiting the compartment, paragraph 9(b) requires markings and visual features not more than 4 feet above the cabin floor in lieu of the requirements of § 25.812(e)(1) to guide occupants to the exit. EASA incorporated this requirement as CS 25.812(e)(3), which is applicable to all airplanes, not just those that are non-commercially operated. FAA agrees with EASA that, for compartments that do not have the main cabin aisle incorporated in the compartment, this is an appropriate requirement regardless of type of operation. FAA proposes to incorporate the language in SFAR No. 109 paragraph 9(b) as new § 25.812(e)(3), which would also harmonize this requirement with CS 25.812(e)(3).
SFAR No. 109 paragraph 9(c) provides alternate requirements to § 25.812(l) for emergency lights in the event of a transverse separation of the fuselage. Paragraph 9(c)(1) allows, for airplanes with a maximum passenger seating capacity of 9 or less, that not more than 50 percent of all electrically illuminated emergency lights required by § 25.812 may be rendered inoperative in addition to the lights directly damaged by the separation. Paragraph 9(c)(2) allows, for airplanes with a maximum passenger seating capacity of 10 to 19, that not more than 33 percent of all electrically illuminated emergency lights required by § 25.812 may be rendered inoperative in addition to the lights directly damaged by the separation. EASA incorporated these provisions into CS 25.812(l)(1), which is applicable to all airplanes proposed for EASA's approval, not just those that would be non-commercially operated. FAA agrees with EASA that this allowance for remaining lights following a transverse separation should be applied to all airplanes of the specified passenger capacity, regardless of type of operation. A more stringent requirement based on the type of operation does not add appreciably to safety as the primary factor is the distance to any one exit and not the familiarity a private use passenger has of the airplane. FAA proposes to incorporate the provisions of SFAR No. 109 paragraph 9(c) into § 25.812(l)(1), which would also harmonize this requirement with EASA CS 25.812(l)(1). l. Electrical Appliances, Motors, and Transformers--§ 25.1365
Currently, § 25.1365(b) requires overheat or fire protection for installations of galleys and cooking appliances but does not address hazards to occupants other than overheat and fire. SFAR No. 109, paragraph 14 includes requirements for installation of cooktops that are prescriptive rather than performance-based, such as specifying several design details about the cookware restraint system. These prescriptive requirements in SFAR No. 109 address hazards to occupants and the aircraft, but with this rulemaking FAA is proposing to remove SFAR No. 109 in its entirety. FAA proposes to add a performance-based requirement to proposed § 25.1365 to require the design minimize the risk of overheat, fire, smoke, burns, or spilled liquids to occupants and to the airplane due to any cooking appliance. The proposed performance-based requirement would provide increased flexibility for applicants and encourage innovation because performance-based requirements focus on achieving a desired outcome without prescribing a specific approach an applicant must use to achieve that outcome. The prescriptive design details of SFAR No. 109, paragraph 14 would remain available as one acceptable means of compliance and are incorporated in the draft of Change 2 to AC 25-17A, as discussed below. Proposed § 25.1365 would apply to commercial airplanes as well as low occupancy and non-commercial airplanes because the safety requirements for the installation of a cooktop should be the same for all transport category airplanes.
Furthermore, this proposed rule would harmonize with EASA CS 25.1365(b), with the following difference. Where CS 25.1365(b) lists "overheat, fire, burns, or spilled liquids," proposed § 25.1365(b) lists "overheat, fire, smoke, burns, or spilled liquids." This proposed list would explicitly include both fire and smoke to address existing SFAR No. 109 requirements related to fire detection, fire suppression, material flammability, and ventilation; however, there is no difference in the intent of the rule due to this difference. The EASA CS-25 AMC 25.1365(b) includes guidance on fire detection, fire suppression, material flammability, and ventilation that is consistent with the existing SFAR No. 109 requirements to address those hazards.
EASA CS-25 AMC 25.1365(b) guidance incorporates the design standards currently required by SFAR No. 109 paragraph 14 as acceptable means of compliance to the performance-based requirement in CS 25.1365(b). FAA would consider EASA CS-25 AMC 25.1365(b) amendment 28 \41\ as an acceptable means of compliance with proposed § 25.1365(b), in addition to guidance provided in AC 25.1365-1, "Electrical Appliances, Motors, and Transformers," dated November 27, 2007. FAA has drafted Change 2 to AC 25-17A to refer to the EASA AMC and AC 25.1365-1 for guidance. Comments to the revised ACs associated with this rulemaking may be submitted to the docket or via the "Aviation Safety Draft Documents Open for Comment" web page at http://www.faa.gov/aircraft/draft_docs/. m. Hand-Held Fire Extinguishers
SFAR No. 109, paragraph 15 requires, for airplanes that were originally type certificated with more than 60 passengers, the number of hand-held fire extinguishers to be the greater of that provided in accordance with the requirements of § 25.851 or a number equal to the number of originally type certificated exit pairs. FAA has not included this requirement as a condition for recent exemptions for non-commercially operated airplanes of this size.\42\ FAA determined compliance with the requirements of § 25.851 is sufficient to maintain an appropriate level of safety in those exemptions and is not proposing to carry the terms of paragraph 15 of SFAR No. 109 into this NPRM. 3. Advisory Material for Proposed Sec. § 25.4(d), 25.821, 25.823, 25.825, 25.827, 25.829, 25.830, and 25.1583(j)
FAA considers the majority of the sections in EASA CS-25 AMC to appendix S amendment 28 \43\ are applicable and would be an acceptable means of compliance with FAA's proposed regulations for low occupancy airplanes and non-commercially operated airplanes. FAA has drafted Change 2 to AC 25-17A, "Transport Airplane Cabin Interiors Crashworthiness Handbook," to refer to the EASA AMC for guidance and identify differences where appropriate. The EASA AMC and draft AC are available in the docket. Comments to the proposed AC may be submitted via the instructions on the "Aviation Safety Draft Documents Open for Comment" web page at http://www.faa.gov/aircraft/draft_docs/.
B. Vibration and Buffeting--§ 25.251(b)
B. Vibration and Buffeting--§ 25.251(b)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.251(b)
Currently, paragraph (b) of § 25.251, "Vibration and buffeting," at amendment 25-77, requires that an applicant show, by flight test, that each part of the airplane is free from excessive vibration under any appropriate speed and power conditions up to VDFMDF.\44\ FAA proposes to revise § 25.251(b) to allow applicants to use an acceptable means, other than flight test, for speeds above VMO/MMO \45\ up to VDF/MDF, to demonstrate the effects from external modifications \46\ to an existing type design.
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.251(b)
FAA has issued several ELOS findings \47\ that allow flight test to VMO/MMO and the use of acceptable means to extend to VDF/MDF. As described in section 10.1 of AC 25-7D change 2, a copy of which is included in the docket, computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis is one acceptable means. Proposed § 25.251(b) is consistent with these ELOS findings and adopting it would simplify FAA's approval of similar design changes in the future by eliminating the need to develop an IP and make an ELOS finding. Proposed § 25.251(b) is intended to relieve an applicant's burden of showing compliance by flight test at speeds above VMO/MMO for external modifications because the rule can be met through analytical means as a result of advances in technology. 2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.251(b)
When an applicant proposes an external modification to an existing type design, it must address compliance with § 25.251(b), which requires, in summary, that each part of the airplane be demonstrated in flight to be free from excessive vibration. As part of previous airplane certification programs, FAA has granted ELOS findings if an applicant can show that the airplane is free from excessive vibration and buffeting through an acceptable means other than flight testing. FAA considers the extent of the external airplane modification, particularly the size, shape, and location of the modification with respect to the unmodified airplane, may cause significant changes in the aerodynamic flow field around the airplane at high speeds, which may lead to excessive vibration. Potential vibration sources include unsteady flow conditions on the modification, fuselage, tail assembly, or control surfaces. Due to these potential effects, FAA considers the original airplane-level demonstration of compliance for § 25.251(b) may not be valid for proposed external modifications. Therefore, unless the applicant can show the modification would not invalidate the original § 25.251(b) compliance demonstration, under the current regulation, the applicant must re-demonstrate compliance by flight test at speeds up to VDF/MDF.
Until recently, there were no valid analytical methods to substantiate there is no excessive vibration at VDF/ MDF other than flight test. However, given advances in aerodynamic analysis and computer modeling, an applicant may use analysis tools to determine whether the external modification may be reliably evaluated as an alternative to flight testing at speeds above VMO/MMO. Under the proposed amendment to § 25.251(b), an applicant may use an aerodynamic analysis, such as validated CFD, to show compliance with § 25.251(b) will be reliable as an alternative to flight testing at speeds above VMO/ MMO. It is not necessary for the aerodynamic analysis to cover all flight conditions. The applicant should identify the critical flight conditions and select those flight conditions that require in-depth analysis. The applicant should document how these critical flight conditions have been identified.
After FAA acceptance of both the validated CFD and the results of the aerodynamic analysis, the applicant would not be required to perform a flight test to VDF/MDF to show the modification complies with § 25.251(b). However, the applicant would still be required to perform a flight test to VMO/ MMO with a qualitative assessment that no buffeting condition exists up to that speed to show compliance with § 25.251(d).
ARAC recommended FAA modify § 25.251(a) and (b) by removing the words "demonstrated in flight to be" from each paragraph.\48\ Two members of ARAC, the Air Line Pilots Association International (ALPA) and Flyer's Rights, dissented from the ARAC recommendation.\49\ FAA agreed with ALPA and Flyer's Rights and determined it is necessary to maintain the flight test requirement to show freedom from excessive vibration up to VDF/MDF for new designs, while providing some relief for modified designs as described above. 3.Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.251(b)
FAA has proposed Change 2 to AC 25-7D, "Flight Test Guide for Certification of Transport Category Airplanes," to describe acceptable means, but not the only means, of showing compliance with proposed § 25.251(b). In order to assess whether the external modification could be reliably evaluated, proposed AC 25-7D Change 2 would provide for any suitable combination of using information from similar approved designs, flight test, and an aerodynamic analysis. This document is available in the docket. Comments to the proposed AC may be submitted via the instructions on the "Aviation Safety Draft Documents Open for Comment" web page at http://www.faa.gov/aircraft/draft_docs/.
C. Rolling Conditions--§ 25.349(a)
C. Rolling Conditions--§ 25.349(a)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.349(a)
Currently, § 25.349, "Rolling conditions," at amendment 25-94, specifies various rolling maneuver load conditions for which the airplane must be designed and prescribes the rolling maneuvers in terms of aileron deflection.\50\ FAA has issued SCs in past airplane certification programs to address the effects of electronic flight control systems on the design roll maneuver loads. ARAC recommended FAA incorporate this SC content into the rule to eliminate the need for recurring development of new SCs and provided recommended edits to § 25.349(a).\51\ Adopting proposed § 25.349(a) would eliminate the need to develop an IP and issue SCs for roll maneuver during the certification process.
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.349(a)
FAA proposes to revise § 25.349(a) to prescribe the design rolling maneuver requirement in terms of flightdeck roll control movement, rather than aileron deflection. This would ensure the rolling maneuver loads used in the structural design of the airplane are adequate. FAA is also proposing other related changes described under paragraph III.C.2. 2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.349(a)
By prescribing the rolling maneuvers in terms of aileron deflection only, § 25.349 does not consider the potential effects of airplane systems. Most modern transport category airplanes are equipped with electronic flight control systems, which can affect the behavior of the airplane during a rolling maneuver. Section 25.349 also assumes just a single aileron is deflected on each wing. In fact, most modern airplanes are equipped with multiple control surfaces (such as flaperons or spoilers) that may be used in performing the rolling maneuver.
To ensure the effects of the electronic flight control system and the appropriate deflection of any flight control surface are considered, proposed § 25.349(a) would prescribe the rolling maneuvers in terms of flightdeck roll control movement, rather than aileron deflection.
In addition to this change, FAA proposes the following related changes. For the rolling conditions specified by § 25.349(a)(2) and § 25.349(a)(3), at airspeeds VA and VC respectively, FAA proposes to add an additional load maneuver requirement. Following the initial movement of the flightdeck roll control, the proposed requirement for the rolling conditions would include a sudden return of the roll control to neutral. This proposed change is necessary to ensure the effects of the flight control system would be considered during this kind of maneuver, thereby ensuring adequate design loads. ARAC recommended this requirement be added for rolling conditions at VA, and FAA currently includes this additional requirement in SCs for electronic flight controls for design roll maneuver at VA.\52\ FAA is proposing the addition of this requirement for VC to ensure applicants consider these design loads and to also harmonize with EASA CS 25.349(a)(5)(ii).
Currently, § 25.349(a)(1) specifies the applicant investigate angular acceleration for airplanes with proposed engines or other weight concentrations outboard of the fuselage. FAA proposes to remove this qualification and require applicants to investigate angular acceleration on all proposed transport category airplanes, regardless of their configuration, to ensure the design rolling maneuver loads are adequate. ARAC recommended this change to § 25.349(a)(1).\53\
Currently, § 25.349(a) specifies the prescribed rolling maneuvers be combined with two separate airplane load factor conditions: load factors of zero and two-thirds of the positive maneuvering load factor used in the design. FAA proposes to revise § 25.349(a) to require applicants to evaluate additional load factors between these two load factor values. Though ARAC did not recommend this change, requiring applicants to evaluate a range of load factors would address potentially higher loads that could occur at load factors between zero and two-thirds. This would also harmonize with CS 25.349(a) requirements for airplanes equipped with electronic flight controls. 3. Differences With EASA CS 25.349(a)
In June 2013, EASA revised CS 25.349(a) at amendment 13 \54\ to address the effects of electronic flight controls on design maneuver requirements. The EASA CS specifies differing requirements for airplanes with mechanical systems and for those with electronic flight controls. FAA's proposed § 25.349(a) specifies only one set of requirements would apply to all proposed transport category airplanes regardless of the type of control system used. FAA proposes that by prescribing the rolling maneuver in terms of flightdeck roll control movement rather than aileron deflection, and by making the other related changes, only one set of requirements will be necessary.
EASA CS 25.349 requires applicants to investigate the specified rolling maneuvers without any corrective yaw control action to maximize sideslip (evaluated as a failure condition), and, as a separate condition, with corrective yaw control action to reduce sideslip as far as possible. The proposed FAA rule would require only that applicants investigate the rolling maneuvers assuming rational or conservative yaw control input. This is consistent with past FAA certification practice. That is, current § 25.349 and related SCs do not require applicants to investigate rolling maneuvers assuming no corrective yaw control action or that this be evaluated as a failure condition. 4. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.349(a)
EASA provides the following advisory material in CS-25 AMC 25.349(a): "The physical limitations of the aircraft from the cockpit roll control device to the control surface deflection, such as control stops position, maximum power and displacement rate of the servo controls, and control law limiters, may be taken into account."
FAA does not plan to issue an AC in conjunction with proposed § 25.349. However, FAA agrees with the EASA AMC. FAA agrees applicants would be able to use CS-25 AMC 25.349(a) amendment 28 \55\ when showing compliance to FAA's proposed § 25.349(a).
D. Outside View for Flightcrew and Overwing Emergency Exits--§ 25.809(a)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.809(a)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.809(a)
Currently, § 25.809(a), at amendment 25-116, requires, for all exits, the ability to view likely areas of evacuee ground contact from inside the airplane with the exit closed. Some applicants have been unable to meet this requirement for flightcrew and overwing exits when it is not possible to see the ground contact point from inside the airplane due to the curvature of the fuselage, the distance to the ground contact point, or the wing itself blocking the view. As a result, these applicants have petitioned for an exemption from § 25.809(a). FAA has found it in the public interest to grant exemptions from the requirements of this rule for flightdeck and overwing exits when compliance with the rule is not practical.\56\ This proposed rule would remove the requirement to see the evacuee ground landing point for these exits, eliminate the need for exemptions, and harmonize with the current EASA airworthiness standard, CS 25.809(a). 2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.809(a)
As outlined in the overview section above, currently § 25.809(a) at amendment 25-116 requires, for all exits, (1) the ability to view likely areas of evacuee ground contact from inside the airplane with the exit closed and (2) the likely areas of evacuee ground contact be viewable during all lighting conditions with the landing gear extended as well as in all conditions of landing gear collapse. When FAA wrote the NPRM and final rule for amendment 25-116,\57\ the agency's primary focus was on passenger exits, though FAA intended to have consistency between passenger and crew exits as well. Thus, the current requirements are identical for the two exit categories. However, flightcrew and overwing exits have characteristics that justify a different approach.
Flightcrew exits are used generally when the passenger exits are not available to the crew, or the situation demands more rapid egress than is possible by leaving the flightdeck and moving to a passenger exit. In those cases, outside viewing of the specific ground-contact point is largely moot because there is no alternative to using the flightcrew exit(s). Flightcrew should have a means to see outside the airplane to assess conditions generally, even if the specific point of ground contact is not visible. Flightdeck windows typically satisfy this need.
On many overwing exits, the location where the evacuee makes first contact on the ground is a considerable distance from the point from which they exit the passenger cabin. The distance the evacuee moves either forward or aft on the wing upper surface, and then down to the ground--by escape slide, jumping off of the wing, or sliding down the leading or trailing edge of the wing--makes it impossible to see the ground-contact point from inside the airplane because of the distance from the viewing point inside the airplane to the ground, given fuselage curvature or the wing itself blocking the view.
FAA and EASA collaborated to improve the CS-25 rule language based on experience applying this rule. EASA incorporated the improved language in CS-25 at amendment 12, dated July 13, 2012, to allow situations where viewing the ground contact point was not practical and to update the requirement for all emergency exits to have means to permit viewing of the conditions outside the exit when the exit is closed, in all ambient lighting conditions with the landing gears extended or in any condition of collapse. Emergency evacuations are sometimes combined with a hazard, such as a fire outside the airplane. As the hazard may pose an immediate threat, it is often necessary to avoid opening certain emergency exits in order to prevent injuries to evacuees. Thus, requiring a means to permit viewing the conditions outside the exit, such as a viewing window, allows the crew and passengers to assess the outside conditions generally and determine whether it is safe for evacuees to use a particular exit. In addition, all ambient lighting conditions must be considered because evacuations can take place during the day or night. This CS 25.809(a) requirement is consistent with the conditions imposed by FAA when granting exemptions from the ground contact point viewing requirement of § 25.809(a).\58\
In addition, ARAC recommended FAA harmonize § 25.809(a) with EASA CS 25.809(a) at amendment 12.\59\ ARAC later recommended additional minor changes to § 25.809(a) in the ARAC "Transport Aircraft Crashworthiness and Ditching Working Group Report to FAA," Revision B, dated September 20, 2018.\60\ FAA proposes to harmonize § 25.809(a) with CS 25.809(a), with minor changes to paragraph numbering, as recommended by ARAC. 3. Advisory Material for Proposed § 25.809(a)
FAA considers the provisions of amendment 28 of EASA CS-25 AMC 25.809(a) and AMC 25.809(a)(3) \61\ would be an acceptable means of compliance with FAA's proposed § 25.809(a). FAA has drafted Change 2 to AC 25-17A to refer to the EASA AMC for guidance. The EASA AMC and draft AC are available in the docket. Comments to the proposed AC may be submitted via the instructions on the "Aviation Safety Draft Documents Open for Comment" web page at http://www.faa.gov/aircraft/draft_docs/.
E. Emergency Exit Marking and Lighting--Sec. § 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b)
E. Emergency Exit Marking and Lighting--Sec. § 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b)
1. Overview of Proposed Sec. § 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b)
Currently, § 25.811(e) requires operating handles for Type I and larger passenger emergency exits to be self-illuminated and, for Type II and larger, requires passenger emergency exits have red arrows with prescriptive dimensions. Sections 25.811(g) and 25.812(b) currently require passenger emergency exit signs use letters only. In addition, Sec. § 25.811(g) and 25.812(b) do not allow the universal exit symbol of the green running man through a door opening that is found worldwide in buildings and in various other forms of transportation.
1. Overview of Proposed Sec. § 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b)
FAA has made ELOS findings in several applications to permit proposed variations in size of exit signs and allow the use of FAA-approved universal symbols rather than the word "exit." Previous ELOS findings allowed the installation of smaller exit signs for specific airplanes based on their passenger cabin aisle lengths and fuselage diameters. The reduced sized signs were found acceptable for specific airplanes based on their small passenger cabin, aisle length, and fuselage diameters. FAA determined reduced size exit signs provide an acceptable level of safety for a cabin of this size.
In the findings for allowance of a symbol, FAA intended "universal" to mean it is understandable by any non-English speaker as applicants' designs have incorporated pictorial representations rather than language. As discussed below, this proposal would replace prescriptive requirements with performance-based requirements, respond to ARAC recommendations, and harmonize Sec. § 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b) with EASA CS-25 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b) to permit alternate emergency exit sign markings and lighting configurations. 2. Discussion of Proposed Sec. § 25.811 and 25.812
Currently, Sec. § 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b) contain prescriptive requirements for emergency exit marking and lighting and are not harmonized with EASA CS 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b). FAA has made ELOS findings to permit variations in size of exit signs and to allow the use of FAA-approved universal symbols, rather than the word "exit." \62\ Furthermore, ARAC recommended FAA harmonize Sec. § 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b) with EASA CS 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b) to permit alternate emergency exit sign and lighting configurations.\63\
Proposed § 25.811(e)(2) would require each Type A, Type B, Type C, or Type I passenger emergency exit operating handles, and the cover removal instructions if the operating handle is covered, to be self-illuminated, and proposed § 25.811(e)(4) would replace prescriptive arrow requirements with more flexible language. The proposed § 25.811(g) would allow the use of an FAA-approved universal symbolic exit sign and require the design of exit signs be chosen to provide a consistent set throughout the cabin. This change would harmonize the rule language with EASA for FAA-approved universal symbol acceptance but would add requirements for AFM operating limitations that passenger information cards and special emphasis briefings be given by the cabin crew before takeoff and landing to advise passengers the meaning of the symbol is for an emergency exit. The special emphasis briefing and information cards have been conditions of FAA's ELOS findings permitting use of FAA-approved universal symbolic exit signs because the U.S. public is generally accustomed to text-based exit signs rather than symbolic exit signs. FAA expects these measures will educate the flying public on the proposed FAA-approved universal symbolic exit signs over time. FAA intends to reevaluate the need for these additional measures when symbolic exit signs become more prevalent in the U.S.
Proposed § 25.812(b) includes performance-based size, brightness, and contrast requirements for letter-based emergency exit signs and universal symbolic exit signs and harmonizes the language with EASA for sign brightness and contrast. 3. Advisory Material for Proposed Sec. § 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b)
FAA considers amendment 28 of EASA AMC 25.811(e)(4) and AMC 25.812(b)(1) and AMC 25.812(b)(2) \64\ guidance for emergency exit marking and lighting would be acceptable means of compliance with proposed Sec. § 25.811(e) and (g) and 25.812(b). However, FAA guidance discusses FAA's additional § 25.811(g) proposed requirements for a special emphasis briefing \65\ on the meaning of the symbolic exit signs in crew procedures and the incorporation of appropriate symbolic exit sign information in standard passenger information cards. FAA already accepts the symbolic green running man standard in GAMA Publication No. 15, "Symbolic Messages," dated March 1, 2014, as an acceptable symbol for the exit sign, as well as the EASA-accepted standard in AMC 25.812, when meeting FAA's ELOS findings permitting use of a symbol. These standards are proposed in Change 2 to AC 25-17A.
FAA has drafted Change 2 to AC 25-17A to refer to the EASA AMC and include additional guidance on these differences in expectations between FAA and EASA. The EASA AMC and draft AC are available in the docket. Comments to the proposed AC may be submitted via the instructions on the "Aviation Safety Draft Documents Open for Comment" web page at http://www.faa.gov/aircraft/draft_docs/.
F. Disposal of Combustible Materials--§ 25.853(g)
F. Disposal of Combustible Materials--§ 25.853(g)
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.853(g)
Currently, § 25.853(g) requires self-contained, removable ashtrays on or near the entry side of lavatory doors. ARAC and industry recommended FAA repeal § 25.853(g) due to the prescriptive nature of the rule, the prohibition of smoking in lavatories (§ 91.519), the ban on smoking on air carrier flights (part 252), and the requirement for smoke detectors and built-in fire extinguishers in lavatories (§ 25.854).
1. Overview of Proposed § 25.853(g)
FAA does not agree that a repeal of the rule would be in the public interest. However, proposed § 25.853(g) would replace the prescriptive requirement for self-contained removable ashtrays with a performance-based requirement that lavatories must have an approved means to dispose of lit combustible material safely located conspicuously on or near the entry side of each lavatory door, except that one means may serve more than one lavatory door if the means can be seen readily from the cabin side of each lavatory served. 2. Discussion of Proposed § 25.853(g)
After multiple fires in the 1970s started in lavatory waste receptacles, FAA issued Airworthiness Directive (AD) 74-08-09 \66\ requiring all transport category airplanes, certificated in any category that have one or more lavatories equipped with paper or linen waste receptacles to prohibit smoking in lavatories via placards and pre-flight briefings and to install self-contained, removable ashtrays on or near the entry side of lavatory doors. The AD also required repetitive inspection of waste receptacle enclosure doors for proper operation to maintain their fire containment properties. FAA revised this AD in June 1996 \67\ to allow airplanes to be temporarily operated in the event a lavatory door ashtray is missing and revised the AD again in January 2012 \68\ to extend the time allowed for operators to replace missing ashtrays as long as 50 percent of the required ashtrays are present.
In 1980, FAA revised the design requirements for placarding and installation of ashtrays outside of lavatories, with amendment 25-51 \69\ to part 25, implementing the design portions of AD 74-08-09. However, for safety reasons, AD 74-08-09 remains in effect.
ARAC recommended FAA repeal § 25.853(g), which requires self-contained, removable ashtrays on or near the entry side of lavatory doors.\70\ Also, Airlines for America (A4A) submitted a comment in response to the Department of Transportation Notification of Regulatory Review, dated October 2, 2017,\71\ requesting elimination of this rule. As justification for elimination of this requirement, ARAC cited the prohibition of smoking in lavatories (§ 91.519), the ban on smoking on air carrier flights (part 252), and the requirement for smoke detectors and built-in fire extinguishers in lavatories (§ 25.854).
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 402 passages shown