Radar Vectors
Final Rule Current Issued Mar 30, 2016 211 pages Copy saved Nov 17, 2026

81 FR 18178 Flight Simulation Training Device Qualification Standards for Extended Envelope and Adverse Weather Event Training Tasks

The FAA has determined this rule is necessary to amend the Qualification Performance Standards for flight simulation training devices (FSTDs) for the primary purpose of improving existing technical standards and introducing new technical standards for full stall and stick pusher maneuvers, upset recognition and recovery maneuvers, maneuvers conducted in airborne icing conditions, takeoff and landing maneuvers in gusting crosswinds, and bounced landing recovery maneuvers. These new and improved technical standards are intended to fully define FSTD fidelity requirements for conducting new flight training tasks introduced through recent changes to the air carrier training requirements, as well as to address various National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) and Aviation Rulemaking Committee recommendations. This final rule also updates the FSTD technical standards to better align with the current international FSTD evaluation guidance and introduces a new FSTD level that expands the number of qualified flight training tasks in a fixed-base flight training device. These changes will ensure that the training and testing environment is accurate and realistic, will codify existing practice, and will provide greater harmonization with international guidance for simulation. The amendments will not apply to previously qualified FSTDs with the exception of the FSTD Directive, which codifies the new FSTD technical standards for specific training tasks.

Official source ↗ Official PDF ↗

Vol. 81

Wednesday,

No. 61

March 30, 2016

Part IV

14 CFR Part 60

Flight Simulation Training Device Qualification Standards for Extended Envelope and Adverse Weather Event Training Tasks; Final Rule

Federal Register / Vol. 81 , No. 61 / Wednesday, March 30, 2016 / Rules and Regulations DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Federal Aviation Administration

Federal Aviation Administration

14 CFR Part 60

[Docket No.: FAA-2014-0391; Amdt. No. 60-4] RIN 2120-AK08

Flight Simulation Training Device Qualification Standards for Extended Envelope and Adverse Weather Event Training Tasks

AGENCY: Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), DOT.

ACTION: Final rule.

Summary

SUMMARY: The FAA has determined this rule is necessary to amend the Qualification Performance Standards for flight simulation training devices (FSTDs) for the primary purpose of improving existing technical standards and introducing new technical standards for full stall and stick pusher maneuvers, upset recognition and recovery maneuvers, maneuvers conducted in airborne icing conditions, takeoff and landing maneuvers in gusting crosswinds, and bounced landing recovery maneuvers. These new and improved technical standards are intended to fully define FSTD fidelity requirements for conducting new flight training tasks introduced through recent changes to the air carrier training requirements, as well as to address various National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) and Aviation Rulemaking Committee recommendations. This final rule also updates the FSTD technical standards to better align with the current international FSTD evaluation guidance and introduces a new FSTD level that expands the number of qualified flight training tasks in a fixed-base flight training device. These changes will ensure that the training and testing environment is accurate and realistic, will codify existing practice, and will provide greater harmonization with international guidance for simulation. The amendments will not apply to previously qualified FSTDs with the exception of the FSTD Directive, which codifies the new FSTD technical standards for specific training tasks.

Dates

DATES: Effective May 31, 2016. The compliance date of FSTD Directive No. 2 is March 12, 2019. After this date, any FSTD being used to conduct specific training tasks as defined in FSTD Directive No. 2 must be evaluated and qualified in accordance with the Directive.

ADDRESSES: For information on where to obtain copies of rulemaking documents and other information related to this final rule, see "How To Obtain Additional Information" in the SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION section of this document.

For Further Information Contact

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For technical questions concerning this action, contact Larry McDonald, Air Transportation Division/ National Simulator Program Branch, AFS-205, Federal Aviation Administration, P.O. Box 20636, Atlanta, GA 30320; telephone (404) 474-5620; email [email protected].

Supplementary Information

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Authority for This Rulemaking

The Federal Aviation Administration's (FAA's) authority to issue rules on aviation safety is found in Title 49 of the United States Code. Subtitle I, Section 106(f) describes the authority of the FAA Administrator. Subtitle VII, Aviation Programs, describes in more detail the scope of the agency's authority.

Authority for This Rulemaking

This rulemaking is promulgated under the authority described in 49 U.S.C. 44701(a)(5), which requires the Administrator to promulgate regulations and minimum standards for other practices, methods, and procedures necessary for safety in air commerce and national security. This amendment to the regulation is within the scope of that authority because it prescribes an accepted method for testing and evaluating flight simulation training devices used to train and evaluate flightcrew members.

In addition, the Airline Safety and Federal Aviation Administration Extension Act of 2010 (Pub. L. 111-216) specifically required the FAA to conduct rulemaking to ensure that all flightcrew members receive flight training in recognizing and avoiding stalls, recovering from stalls, and recognizing and avoiding upset of an aircraft, as well as the proper techniques to recover from upset. This rulemaking is within the scope of the authority in Public Law 111-216 and is necessary to fully implement the training requirements recently adopted in the Qualification, Service, and Use of Crewmembers and Aircraft Dispatchers final rule (Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule), RIN 2120-AJ00. See 78 FR 67800 (Nov. 12, 2013).

List of Abbreviations and Acronyms Frequently Used in This Document

List of Abbreviations and Acronyms Frequently Used in This Document

AC Advisory Circular AOA Angle of Attack ARC Aviation Rulemaking Committee AURTA Airplane Upset Recovery Training Aid FFS Full Flight Simulator FTD Flight Training Device FSTD Flight Simulation Training Device ICATEE International Committee on Aviation Training in Extended Envelopes LOCART Loss of Control Avoidance and Recovery Training Working Group NPRM Notice of Proposed Rulemaking QPS Qualification Performance Standards SOC Statement of Compliance SNPRM Supplemental Notice of Proposed Rulemaking SPAW ARC Stick Pusher and Adverse Weather Event Training Aviation Rulemaking Committee UPRT Upset Prevention and Recovery Training

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

I. Overview of Final Rule II. Background

A. Statement of the Problem

B. NTSB Recommendations

C. Airline Safety and Federal Aviation Administration Extension Act of 2010 (Publ. L. 111-216) and the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training Final Rule

D. Summary of the NPRM

I. Overview of Final Rule II. Background

E. Differences Between the NPRM and the Final Rule

F. Related Actions III. Discussion of Public Comments and Final Rule

A. Evaluation Requirements for Full Stall Training

1. Aerodynamic Modeling Range

a. Aerodynamic Modeling Beyond the Stall AOA

b. Definition of the Stall AOA

2. Envelope Protected Aircraft

a. Model Validity Ranges and Associated Objective Testing

b. Validation of Stall Characteristics Using Flight Test Data

c. Required AOA Range for Normal Mode Objective Testing

3. Data Sources for Model Development and Validation

a. Define Best Available Data

b. Post-Stall "Type Representative" Modeling

c. Use of Flight Test Data and Availability

4. Qualification on FSTD Levels Other Than Level C or Level D

5. Motion Cueing System Limitations

6. Subject Matter Expert (SME) Pilot Evaluation and Qualifications

a. SME Qualifications and Experience

b. Model Validation Conducted by the Data Provider

c. NSPM Process for Evaluating and Accepting an SME Pilot

7. Alignment With the ICAO 9625, Edition 4, on Stall and Stick Pusher Requirements

8. Requirements for Previously Qualified FSTDs

a. Stall Buffet Objective Testing

b. FSTD Directive No. 2 and Grandfather Rights

9. Applicability of Stall and Upset Prevention and Recovery Training (UPRT) Requirements on Newly Qualified FSTDs

10. General Comments on Stall Requirements

a. Testing and Checking of Stall Maneuvers

b. Interim FSTD Qualification for Stall Training

c. Aerodynamic Modeling Considerations

B. Evaluation Requirements for UPRT

1. UPRT Qualification on Lower Level FSTDs.

2. Record and Playback Requirements for UPRT

3. Instructor Operating Station (IOS) Requirements

4. Aerodynamic Source Data and Range of the FSTD Validation Envelope

a. FSTD Validation Envelope and Training Maneuvers

b. Expansion of the FSTD Validation Envelope Using Existing Flight Test Data

5. General Comments on UPRT

a. FSTD Qualification and FAA Oversight

b. Maintenance Concerns

C. Evaluation Requirements for Engine and Airframe Icing Training

1. Objective Demonstration Testing

a. Objective Demonstration Testing for Previously Qualified FSTDs

b. Icing Effects and Recognition Cues

2. Requirements for Lower Level FTDs

3. Existing Engine and Airframe Icing Requirements in Part 60

4. Applicability in Training Programs

5. Data Sources and Tuning of Ice Accretion Models

D. Evaluation Requirements for Takeoff and Landing in Gusting Crosswinds

1. Applicability on Lower Level FSTDs

2. Gusting Crosswind Profile Data Sources

3. Maximum Demonstrated Crosswind

4. Requirements for Previously Qualified FSTDs

E. Evaluation Requirements for Bounced Landing Recovery Training

1. Applicability to Lower Level FSTDs

2. Bounced Landing Modeling and Evaluation

a. Nosewheel Exceedances

b. Use of Existing Ground Reaction Models

3. Alignment With Training Requirements

4. Requirements for Previously Qualified FSTDs

F. Alignment With the ICAO 9625 FSTD Evaluation Document

1. Partial Alignment With the ICAO 9625 Document

2. New Requirements Introduced by the Proposed ICAO Alignment

a. Visual System Field of View

b. Visual System Lightpoint Brightness Testing

c. Transport Delay Testing

d. Motion Cueing Fidelity Test

e. Sound Directionality Requirement

3. Alignment With the Recently Published ICAO 9625, Edition 4 Document

4. Integration of ICAO Requirements With the Part 60 Table Structure

5. Deviation From the Part 60 QPS Using the ICAO 9625 Document

6. Level 7 FTD Requirements and Usage in Training

G. General Comments

1. Compliance Period for Previously Qualified FSTDs

2. Alternative Source Data for Level 5 FTDs

3. Objective Testing for Continuing Qualification

4. Windshear Qualification Requirements

5. Miscellaneous Comments

a. Approved Location for Objective and Subjective Testing

b. Increase the Training Credit for Time in a Simulator

H. Economic Evaluation

1. Cost of Aerodynamic Modeling and Implementation

2. Cost of Instructor Operation Station (IOS) Replacement

3. Affected FSTDs and Sponsors

4. Cost and Benefits of ICAO Alignment IV. Regulatory Notices and Analyses

A. Regulatory Evaluation

B. Regulatory Flexibility Determination

C. International Trade Impact Assessment

D. Unfunded Mandates Assessment

E. Paperwork Reduction Act

F. International Compatibility and Cooperation

G. Environmental Analysis

H. Regulations Affecting Intrastate Aviation in Alaska V. Executive Order Determinations

A. Executive Order 13123, Federalism

B. Executive Order 13211, Regulations that Significantly Affect Energy Supply, Distribution, or Use VI. How To Obtain Additional Information

A. Rulemaking Documents

B. Comments Submitted to the Docket

C. Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act

I. Overview of Final Rule

I. Overview of Final Rule

This rulemaking defines simulator fidelity requirements for new training tasks to be conducted in Level A through D full flight simulators (FFS) that were mandated for air carrier training programs by Public Law 111-216 and incorporated into 14 CFR part 121. It also addresses the potential lack of simulator fidelity as identified in several NTSB safety recommendations. This final rule establishes new and updated FSTD technical evaluation standards for full stall and stick pusher maneuvers, upset prevention and recovery maneuvers, flight in airborne icing conditions, takeoff and landing maneuvers in gusting crosswinds, and bounced landing recovery maneuvers. This final rule also partially aligns the technical standards for Level C and D (fixed wing) FSTDs that are defined in 14 CFR part 60 with the current international FSTD evaluation guidelines published in the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) document 9625, Edition 4, Manual of Criteria for the Qualification of Flight Simulation Training Devices.

This final rule will affect sponsors of previously qualified FSTDs if the devices will be used to conduct the specific training tasks defined in FSTD Directive No. 2. The FSTD sponsor has the discretion to determine if a device needs to be qualified based on whether it will be used for training the defined tasks in FSTD Directive No. 2. Additionally, because many of the technical FSTD evaluation standards in the final rule will become minimum requirements for some newly qualified FSTDs, this final rule will also affect sponsors of Level 7, Level C, and Level D FSTDs that are initially qualified after the effective date of the final rule. In addition to FSTD sponsors, this final rule will also affect data providers, FSTD manufacturers, and other entities that provide products and support to FSTD sponsors in the qualification of FSTDs for training. This final rule does not affect aviation training devices that are evaluated and approved for use outside of 14 CFR part 60.

A general summary of the applicability, compliance dates, and processes used to qualify FSTDs as defined in this rule are included in the following table:

Issue Rule requirements

How does a sponsor determine if a A previously qualified FSTD

previously qualified FSTD must be that will be used to obtain

evaluated and qualified for stall, UPRT, training, testing, or

evaluated and qualified for stall, UPRT, training, testing, or

engine and airframe icing, bounced checking credit in an FAA

landing recovery, and gusting crosswind approved flight training

training tasks as defined in FSTD program, regardless of

Directive No. 2? operational rule part, must

be evaluated and qualified

for the following maneuvers:

Full Stall: Training

maneuvers in the recognition

cues and recovery procedures

from a fully stalled flight

condition (including

recovery from a stick pusher

activation) at angles of

attack beyond the activation

of the stall warning system.

UPRT: Upset recovery

maneuvers and unusual

attitude maneuvers that are

intended to exceed the

parameters of an aircraft

upset as defined in the

Airplane Upset Recovery

Training Aid (pitch

attitudes greater than 25

degrees nose up; pitch

attitudes greater than 10

degrees nose down, and bank

angles greater than 45

degrees).

Engine and Airframe Icing:

Flight training maneuvers

that demonstrate the

recognition cues and effects

of engine and airframe ice

accretion.

Takeoff and Landing in

Gusting Crosswinds.

Bounced Landing Recovery

Training.

How does a sponsor obtain qualification FSTD Directive No. 2 contains

for stall, UPRT, icing, bounced landing all of the evaluation

recovery, or takeoff and landing in requirements for the

gusting crosswinds on a previously qualification of these

qualified FSTD? individual tasks on

previously qualified FSTDs.

FSTD sponsors will conduct

the evaluations and

modifications as described

in the Directive and submit

any required Statements of

Compliance and objective

testing results to the

National Simulator Program

(NSP) using the standard

FSTD modification/

notification process. The

NSP will issue additional

FSTD qualification for these

tasks once compliance with

the applicable sections of

the Directive are verified

and any necessary FSTD

evaluations have been

conducted. How do you determine what portions of the As described in Sec.

updated qualification performance 60.17(a), unless specified

standards (QPS) appendices are by an FSTD Directive,

applicable to previously qualified previously qualified

FSTDs? (grandfathered) FSTDs will

retain their original

qualification basis under

which they were originally

evaluated, regardless of

sponsor. All retroactive

evaluation requirements for

previously qualified FSTDs

in this final rule are fully

described in FSTD Directive

No. 2. What are the compliance dates associated After March 12, 2019, any

with this final rule for previously FSTD being used to conduct

qualified FSTDs? the specific training

maneuvers (as described in

FSTD Directive No. 2) in an

FAA approved training

program must be issued

additional FSTD

qualification in accordance

with the Directive. How do you determine what changes in this With the exception of the

final rule are applicable to new FSTDs full stall evaluation

that will be initially qualified after requirements, all FSTDs that

the final rule becomes effective? are initially qualified or

upgraded in qualification

level after the effective

date of the final rule must

meet all new standards in

this final rule as

applicable for the

particular FSTD

qualification level

requested.

The qualification of full

stall training tasks will be

optional as requested by the

sponsor to support FAA

approved training being

conducted in the FSTD. The

qualification of full stall

training tasks will be

included as part of the list

of qualified tasks on the

FSTD's Statement of

Qualification (SOQ).

What is the compliance date associated In general, all changes to

with this final rule for new FSTDs that the part 60 QPS will be

will be initially qualified after the effective for all FSTDs that

rule becomes effective? are initially qualified

after the effective date of

the final rule except as

permitted by Sec.

60.15(c).

What is the process to qualify an FSTD Requests for deviation from

using another standard in lieu of the the part 60 QPS are made to

part 60 QPS as permitted by the the National Simulator

deviation authority in Sec. 60.15? Program Manager (NSPM) and

must include justification

that demonstrates an

equivalent level of safety

as compared to the FSTD

evaluation requirements of

the part 60 QPS. Approved

deviations and the

supporting evaluation

standards will become a part

of the permanent

qualification basis of the

FSTD.

The FAA estimates that it will cost $72.7 million to make the necessary modifications to previously qualified FSTDs which will enable training required by the new Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule. The training cost for the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule provides rental revenue to simulator sponsors which will fully compensate them for their FSTD modification expenses. These simulator revenues were accounted for as costs of the additional training and were fully justified by the benefits in that final rule. The FAA estimates it will cost $1.3 million for the evaluation and modification of engine and airframe icing models which will enhance existing training requirements. If these modifications prevent only one severe injury the benefits will exceed the costs. The estimated cost of $6.9 million to align standards with ICAO will result in improved safety and cost savings.

The costs and benefits of this rule are presented in the table below.

Present value Present value

at a 7% rate at a 3% rate

FSTD Modifications for New Training Requirements:

Cost … $72,716,590 $63,610,049 $68,562,049

Benefits … Rational simulator owner will choose to

comply.

Icing provisions:

Cost … $1,256,250 $1,098,926 $1,184,476

Benefits … Only one prevented severe injury valued at

$2.5 million makes the icing benefits exceed

the costs.

Aligning Standards with ICAO:

Cost … $6,875,000 $5,356,979 $6,132,690

Benefits … Improved safety and cost savings.

Total Cost … $80,847,840 $70,065,954 $75,879,215

II. Background

II. Background

A. Statement of the Problem

In order to mitigate aircraft loss of control accidents and to comply with the requirements of Public Law 111-216, the FAA has issued new and revised flight training requirements in the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule for flight maneuvers such as full stall and upset recovery training. In support of this effort, the FAA participated in a number of collaborative industry and government working groups that examined loss of control training requirements and the flight simulation training device (FSTD) fidelity needed to support such training. These working groups included the International Committee on Aviation Training in Extended Envelopes (ICATEE), the Industry Stall and Stick Pusher Working Group, the Stick Pusher and Adverse Weather Event Training Aviation Rulemaking Committee (SPAW ARC), and the Loss of Control Avoidance and Recovery Training (LOCART) Working Group.

A. Statement of the Problem

Through participation in these working groups and in consideration of the formal recommendations received from the SPAW ARC, the FAA determined that many existing FSTDs that could be used by air carriers to conduct such training may not adequately represent the simulated aircraft for the required training tasks. Additionally, the FAA evaluated several recent air carrier accidents and associated NTSB accident reports and determined that low FSTD fidelity or the lack of ability for an FSTD to adequately conduct certain training tasks may have been a contributing factor in these accidents.\1\ A potential lack of simulator fidelity could contribute to inaccurate or incomplete training on new training tasks that are required by the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule, which could lead to a safety risk.

\1\ Some of these accidents include the 1996 Airborne Express DC-8-63 loss of control accident, the 2001 American Airlines flight 587 A300 loss of control accident, the 2009 Colgan Air flight 3407 DHC-8-400 loss of control accident, and the 2008 Continental flight 1404 Boeing 737-500 runway excursion accident.

Furthermore, since the initial publication of the part 60 final rule in 2008, the international FSTD qualification guidance published in the ICAO 9625 document has been updated to incorporate general improvements to new aircraft and simulation technology and the introduction of new FSTD levels that better align FSTD fidelity with required training tasks. The ICAO 9625 document is an internationally recognized set of FSTD evaluation guidelines that was developed by government and industry experts on flight simulation training and technology and has been used as a basis for national regulation and guidance material for FSTD evaluation in many countries. Internationally aligned FSTD standards facilitate cost savings for FSTD operators because they can reduce the number of different FSTD designs, as well as reduce the amount of redundant supporting documentation that are required to meet multiple national regulations and standards for FSTD qualification.

This final rule was developed using recommendations from the SPAW ARC \2\ and the international FSTD qualification guidelines that are published in ICAO 9625, Edition 3 and the newly published ICAO 9625, Edition 4.\3\ The requirements in this final rule are primarily directed at improving the fidelity of FSTDs that will be used in air carrier pilot training to conduct extended envelope training tasks, but will also have an added benefit of improving the fidelity of all FSTDs initially qualified after the final rule becomes effective.

\2\ A copy of the SPAW ARC final report has been placed in the docket for this rulemaking.

\3\ International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) publications can be located on their public internet site at: http://www.icao.int/.

B. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) Recommendations

B. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) Recommendations

This proposal will incorporate changes into part 60 that address, at least in part, the following NTSB Safety Recommendations through improved FSTD evaluation standards to support required training tasks:

1. Stall training and/or stick pusher training (Recommendations A-10-22, A-10-23, A-97-47, A-07-3, and A-10-24);

2. Upset Recognition and recovery training (Recommendations A-04-62 and A-96-120);

3. Engine and airframe icing training (Recommendations A-11-46 and A-11-47)

4. Takeoff and landing training in gusting crosswind conditions (Recommendations A-10-110 and A-10-111); and

5. Bounced landing training (Recommendations A-00-93 and A-11-69).

C. Airline Safety and Federal Aviation Administration Extension Act of 2010 (Pub. L. 111-216) and the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training Final Rule

C. Airline Safety and Federal Aviation Administration Extension Act of 2010 (Pub. L. 111-216) and the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training Final Rule

On August 1, 2010, President Obama signed into law Public Law 111-216. In addition to extending the FAA's authorization, Public Law 111-216 included provisions to improve airline safety and pilot training. Specifically, section 208 of Public Law 111-216, Implementation of NTSB Flight Crewmember Training Recommendations, pertains directly to this rulemaking in that stall training and upset recovery training were mandated for part 121 air carrier flightcrew members.

On November 12, 2013, the FAA published the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule, adding the training tasks required by Public Law 111-216 that specifically target extended envelope training, recovery from bounced landings, enhanced runway safety training, and enhanced training on crosswind takeoffs and landings with gusts, which further requires that these maneuvers be completed in an FSTD. As a result, revisions to all part 121 training programs will be necessary prior to March 12, 2019 and the revisions to part 60 in this final rule are required to ensure FSTDs are properly evaluated in order to fully implement the flight training required in the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule.

D. Summary of the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM)

D. Summary of the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM)

On July 10, 2014, the FAA published an NPRM (79 FR 39461), proposing changes to the flight simulation training device (FSTD) technical evaluation standards. The primary purpose of the NPRM was to establish and update FSTD technical evaluation standards to address new training tasks required by the Crewmember and Dispatcher Training final rule, including full stall training, upset prevention and recovery training, and other new training tasks. Additionally, the NPRM proposed the incorporation of FSTD evaluation criteria as defined in the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) 9625, Manual of Criteria for the Qualification of Flight Simulation Training Devices (Edition 3) document. Significant changes to the part 60 qualification performance standards (QPS) were proposed in the following areas:

1. Full Stall Evaluation: Minimum requirements were introduced to include aerodynamic modeling of a full stall and stick pusher activation (where equipped) up to ten degrees of angle of attack (AOA) beyond the stall AOA, subject matter expert (SME) pilot evaluation of the FSTD's stall characteristics, and improved objective testing to validate the FSTD's performance and handling qualities in the stall maneuver.

2. Upset Recognition and Recovery: New requirements were proposed for the qualification of upset recognition and recovery training tasks including the evaluation of a minimum set of upset recovery maneuvers against the defined FSTD validation envelope, providing a means to record and playback upset recovery maneuvers conducted in the FSTD, and providing the instructor with a minimum set of feedback tools on the instructor operating station (IOS) that gives information on the FSTD's expected fidelity, aircraft operational limitations, and student flight control inputs.

3. Engine and Airframe Icing: Modifications were proposed to the existing part 60 Level C and Level D FSTD qualification requirements for engine and airframe icing. The proposed amendments included requirements for ice accretion models based upon aircraft original equipment manufacturer (OEM) data or other analytical methods that incorporate the aerodynamic effects of icing as well as objective tests on the FSTD that demonstrate the effects of icing.

4. Takeoff and Landing in Gusting Crosswinds: New amendments were proposed that would require that realistic gusting crosswind profiles must be available to the instructor and the profiles must be tuned in intensity and variation to require pilot intervention to avoid runway departure during takeoff or landing roll. A Statement of Compliance (SOC) would be required to describe the source data used to develop the crosswind profiles.

5. Bounced Landing Recovery: New requirements were proposed to complement existing part 60 ground reaction requirements to support bounced landing recovery training. The updated requirements added that the effects of a bounced landing must be modeled and evaluated and include the effects of nosewheel exceedances and tail strike where appropriate.

6. ICAO 9625 Alignment: In the NPRM, the FAA proposed alignment with the updated ICAO 9625, Edition 3, FSTD evaluation document for similar FSTD levels that are defined in the part 60 QPS (Appendices A and B). This included incorporating updated technical standards for Level C and Level D FSTDs to align with that of the ICAO Type VII FSTD and creating a new high fidelity fixed-base flight training device (the Level 7 FTD) that is based upon the similar Type V device as defined in the ICAO document. This alignment also included adopting the ICAO language and numbering format for some of the technical requirements tables as well as integrating the existing legacy part 60 FSTD levels into these tables to maintain continuity with the current part 60 defined hierarchy of FSTD levels.

In general, the proposed amendments to the part 60 QPS would only be applicable to FSTDs that are initially qualified or upgraded in qualification level after the final rule becomes effective. Because many previously qualified FSTDs will likely be used to accomplish the training tasks required by the Crewmember and Dispatcher Training final rule, the FAA also proposed an FSTD Directive in order to retroactively apply evaluation requirements for those previously qualified FSTDs that will be used to conduct certain training tasks, including full stall, upset prevention and recovery training, engine and airframe icing, takeoff and landing in gusting crosswinds, and bounced landing recovery training.

On September 16, 2014, the FAA extended the comment period of the NPRM for an additional 90 days (79 FR 55407). The comment period closed on January 6, 2015. The FAA received approximately 675 individual comments in response to the NPRM. Commenters included air carriers, simulator training providers, FSTD data providers, FSTD manufacturers, the NTSB, labor organizations, trade associations, aircraft manufacturers, and individuals.

E. Differences Between the NPRM and the Final Rule

E. Differences Between the NPRM and the Final Rule

As a result of the comments received on the NPRM, the FAA made several changes to the final rule. A summary of significant changes as a result of comments are highlighted in the following table:

Issue Significant changes

Full Stall Evaluation … (a) Improved the definition of the stall

AOA for the purposes of defining the

required aerodynamic modeling range.

Clarifies specific issues concerning

stick pusher equipped aircraft and

envelope protected aircraft.

(b) Made clarifications concerning

acceptable source data for stall

aerodynamic models. Clarified that data

sources other than the aircraft

manufacturer may be acceptable if they

meet the modeling and SME pilot

evaluation requirements.

(c) Improved the qualification

requirements for subject matter expert

(SME) pilots that subjectively evaluate

the stall model. Adds deviation

authority if an acceptable SME pilot

cannot be located. Allows for SME

evaluation to be conducted on an

engineering or development simulator

where objective proof-of-match test

cases are provided that verifies the

model implementation on the FSTD.

(d) Removed the proposed requirement for

all newly qualified FSTDs to be

evaluated and qualified for full stall

training tasks. Full stall qualification

will only be required for FSTDs that

will be used to conduct this training as

requested by the FSTD sponsor.

(e) (Previously qualified FSTDs) Removed

the proposed objective testing

requirements for stall maneuvers where

validation data may not exist for some

older FSTD data packages (cruise and

turning flight stall). These conditions

will still require aerodynamic modeling

and subjective evaluation by a SME

pilot. Upset Prevention and Recovery (a) Removed the proposed minimum FSTD

Training (UPRT) Evaluation. evaluation requirements for Level A and

Level B FSTDs.

(b) Removed the proposed specific

requirements for features and

malfunctions necessary to drive upset

scenarios.

(c) Removed the proposed requirement for

audio and video record/playback

functionality.

(d) Improved the definition of required

instructor operating station (IOS)

parameters and feedback mechanisms.

Allows for methods other than graphical

displays to be used where the required

parameters are provided to support the

training program.

(e) Expands the definition of UPRT to

include unusual attitude training in

which scenarios are introduced that are

intended to exceed the defined

parameters of an aircraft upset. This

change better differentiates UPRT from

the existing part 60 unusual attitude

evaluation requirement in Table A1B.

Engine and Airframe Icing (a) Clarified that specific icing effects

Evaluation. are only required to be introduced where

such effects are representative of the

particular aircraft being simulated.

(b) Revised the existing part 60 engine

and airframe icing special effects test

(Table A3F) to remove references to

gross weight increments and to better

align with the updated requirements.

(c) Clarified that flight test data is

not necessarily required for the

development of icing models. Engineering

and analytical methods may be used to

develop representative icing models.

(d) Added provisions to allow for

supplemental tuning of icing models

using an SME pilot assessment. Gusting Crosswind Evaluation. (a) Removed references to the windshear

training aid for gusting crosswind model

development. Recommend use of gusting

crosswind profiles provided by the FAA

in guidance material.

(b) Removed the proposed minimum

qualification requirement for Level A

and Level B FSTDs.

Bounced Landing Recovery (a) Removed the proposed ground reaction

Evaluation. requirement to compute nosewheel

exceedances.

(b) Clarified the requirements to

emphasize the effects and indications of

ground contact due to landing in an

abnormal aircraft attitude and that

aircraft dynamics in a bounced landing

recovery maneuver are already adequately

covered in the existing part 60 rule. Alignment with the ICAO 9625 (a) Restored the general requirements

Document. table (Tables A1A and B1A) format,

numbering system, and content to the

existing part 60 versions. Appended the

proposed ICAO 9625 (Edition 3)

requirements from the NPRM into their

applicable sections.

(b) Restored the existing part 60 visual

system field of view (180°x40°)

and system geometry requirements for

Level C and Level D FSTDs.

(c) Adopted the less restrictive visual

system lightpoint brightness tolerance

(5.8 ft.-lamberts) from the updated ICAO

9625, Edition 4, document.

(d) Adopted the less restrictive

transport delay tolerances (100 ms for

instrument and motion system response;

120 ms for visual system response) from

the updated ICAO 9625, Edition 4,

document.

(e) Modified the objective motion cueing

test (OMCT) description to not require

testing for continuing qualification

evaluations, removed minimum tolerances,

and further moved much of the technical

test details into guidance material.

(f) Aligned language where practical for

similar stall, UPRT, and icing

requirements from the ICAO 9625, Edition

4, document.

(g) Added deviation authority for the FAA

to accept alternate FSTD evaluation

standards where no adverse impact to the

fidelity of the FSTD can be

demonstrated.

(h) Reorganized the flight training

device (FTD) requirements in Appendix B

to restore the existing part 60 table

structure and better separate

requirements for the new Level 7 FTD and

the legacy part 60 FTD levels.

(i) Clarified the Level 7 FTD's minimum

qualified training tasks in Table B1B to

better align with the ICAO 9625

guidelines.

(j) Removed minimum requirements for

extended envelope training tasks for the

Level 7 FTD that are not included in the

ICAO 9625, Edition 4 document for the

Type V device.

F. Related Actions

F. Related Actions

As a result of information gathered from various working groups, the FAA has taken action on loss of control training and simulator fidelity deficiencies by issuing the following voluntary guidance material:

1. FAA Safety Alert for Operators (SAFO 10012)--Possible Misinterpretation of the Practical Test Standards (PTS) Language "Minimal Loss of Altitude." The purpose of this alert bulletin is to clarify the meaning of the approach to stall evaluation criteria as it relates to "minimal loss of altitude" in the Airline Transport Pilot PTS;

2. FAA Information for Operators Bulletin (InFO 10010)--Enhanced Upset Recovery Training. This information bulletin recommends the incorporation of the material in the AURTA into flightcrew training. The AURTA contains guidance for upset recovery training programs for air carrier flightcrews, as well as the evaluation guidance for FSTDs used in such training;

3. FAA Information for Operators Bulletin (InFO 15004)--Use of Windshear Models in FAA Qualified Flight Simulation Training Devices (FSTDs);

4. FAA National Simulator Program (NSP) Guidance Bulletin No. 11-04--FSTD Modeling and Evaluation Recommendations for Engine and Airframe Icing;

5. FAA National Simulator Program (NSP) Guidance Bulletin No. 11-05--FSTD Evaluation Recommendations for Upset Recovery Training Maneuvers;

6. FAA National Simulator Program (NSP) Guidance Bulletin No. 14-01--FSTD Evaluation Guidelines for Full Stall Training Maneuvers;

7. AC 120-109A--Stall and Stick Pusher Training;

8. AC 120-111--Upset Prevention and Recovery Training; and

9. Airline Transport Pilot Practical Test Standards (Change 4).

Portions of the above guidance material provide FSTD operators with recommended evaluation methods to improve FSTD fidelity for selected training tasks. To ensure that all FSTDs used to conduct such training are evaluated and modified to a consistent standard, the applicable part 60 technical requirements must be modified as described in this final rule.

III. Discussion of Public Comments and Final Rule

III. Discussion of Public Comments and Final Rule

A. Evaluation Requirements for Full Stall Training Tasks

The existing FSTD evaluation requirements for stall maneuvers are generally limited to the evaluation of stall speeds with little emphasis on the actual aircraft performance and handling characteristics as the aircraft exceeds the stall warning AOA. As a result, FSTDs used for such training may not provide the necessary cues and associated performance degradation needed to train flight crews in the recognition of an impending stall as well as training the techniques needed to recover from a stalled flight condition. In the NPRM, the FAA proposed updated general requirements, objective testing requirements, and functions and subjective testing requirements for the evaluation of full stall training maneuvers to support air carrier training as required in the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule. 1. Aerodynamic Modeling Range a. Aerodynamic Modeling Beyond the Stall AOA

A. Evaluation Requirements for Full Stall Training Tasks

In order to support the required training objectives, the proposal included requirements for the modeling and evaluation of the FSTD's stall characteristics up to 10 degrees beyond the stall AOA.

CAE, Inc. (CAE) commented that the 10 degrees beyond the stall AOA requirement should be further reviewed, since application of the recovery should immediately lead to a reduction in AOA and therefore is inappropriate to relate the requirement to the 10 degrees beyond the stall AOA. CAE recommended that the 10 degree requirement be removed where rationale is provided for the upper limit of AOA modeling in the required SOC.

The NTSB is generally supportive of the modeling requirements, citing that a peak AOA growth of about 10 degrees beyond the stall is typical for most incidents and accidents it has investigated. However, it did note that stick pusher response dynamics could cause a higher AOA overshoot and this dynamic behavior is a "critical cue to a stall, which pilots must be trained to recognize." The NTSB also noted in its comments that the Colgan flight 3407 accident resulted in an AOA that extended to 13 degrees beyond the stall AOA.\4\ In addition, the NTSB stated that the required aerodynamic modeling for aircraft equipped with a stick pusher should not be limited to that of the stick pusher activation and that the aerodynamic modeling range include the flight dynamics that may occur where a pilot resists the stick pusher in training.

\4\ See NTSB accident report, Loss of Control on Approach, Continental Connection Flight 3407, February 12, 2009, NTSB Accident Report, NTSB/AAR-10/01; page 87, "After the stall, the AOA oscillated between 10 deg and 27 deg . . . .".

The FAA disagrees with CAE that the 10 degree requirement be removed in select cases. The 10 degree AOA range was initially recommended by the SPAW ARC as necessary to accomplish full stall training. Furthermore, this 10 degree AOA range is currently a recommended practice for simulator aerodynamic modeling in the International Air Transport Association (IATA) Flight Simulation Training Device Design and Performance Data Requirements document \5\ and has been a recommended practice since the second edition of the IATA document that was published in 1986. Finally, the FAA notes that an unpublished simulator investigation conducted by ICATEE in conjunction with NASA on their Enhanced Upset Recovery model showed that the 10 degree AOA range should be sufficient to capture most overshoots in AOA during various stall recovery maneuvers.

\5\ International Air Transport Association (IATA) Flight Simulation Training Device Design and Performance Data Requirements Document, 7th Edition (2009), sections 3.1.1.2 and 3.1.1.3 addresses stall entry and recovery as well as required angle of attack ranges for supporting data.

The FAA agrees with the NTSB that pilots can benefit from experiencing the aircraft dynamics involved in a stick pusher activation and recovery maneuver in training. The FAA has reviewed the NTSB accident reports and supporting data on two loss of control accidents in which pilots resisted the activation of a stick pusher and encountered an aerodynamic stall. In the Pinnacle Airlines Flight 3701 accident, the initial stick pusher activation occurred at approximately 10.5 degrees AOA at the start of the aircraft upset and the AOA subsequently oscillated from approximately -6 degrees to +14 degrees over three successive stick pusher activations with some instability evident in the roll axis.\6\ Only until just before the fourth activation of the stick pusher system (approximately eleven seconds after the initial stick pusher activation) did the AOA exceed the proposed aerodynamic modeling range (of 10 degrees beyond the stall AOA) for FSTD evaluation purposes.\7\

\6\ See NTSB accident report, Crash of Pinnacle Airlines Flight 3701, October 14, 2004, NTSB Accident Report, NTSB/AAR-07/01 and supporting flight data recorder factual report on the NTSB public docket (NTSB accident identification number DCA05MA003).

\7\ For this aircraft, since the aerodynamic stall occurs after the stick pusher is designed to activate, the stall identification is provided by the stick pusher system activation and aerodynamic modeling would be required up to at least 20.5 degrees AOA for this configuration.

In the Colgan 3407 accident, aerodynamic stall occurred before the stick pusher activation \8\ at approximately 14 degrees AOA which included an initial roll off to about 50 degrees of bank angle. After the initial stick pusher activation at about 17.5 degrees AOA, the subsequent AOA overshoot remained within 24 degrees as the aircraft rolled through 100 degrees of bank angle in the opposite direction of the initial roll off. The peak AOA value of approximately 27 degrees (10 degrees of AOA beyond the stick pusher activation where stall identification should have occurred) was not recorded until after multiple incorrect column responses by the pilot against the stick pusher over a time period of 30 seconds after the pilot's initial incorrect response to the stall warning.

\8\ According to the NTSB accident report, the stick pusher on this aircraft is designed to activate after the aerodynamic stall.

The FAA considered the comments and based on a review of industry recommendations and best practices, has determined that aerodynamic modeling to at least 10 degrees beyond the stall AOA is necessary so that the modeling does not abruptly end should the pilot overshoot the stall recognition and recovery in training. The FAA recognizes that the 10 degree AOA range may not be sufficient to capture all of the flight dynamics involved with multiple severe divergent pitch oscillations where the pilot repeatedly resists a stick pusher system; however, training should not normally be allowed to continue significantly beyond the point where a trainee initially resists the stick pusher before recognizing the stall identification cues and executing the recovery procedures. As demonstrated by the AOA oscillations experienced in the Colgan and Pinnacle accidents, the FAA has determined that aerodynamic modeling to 10 degrees beyond the stall AOA should be sufficient to capture aircraft dynamics in instances where a pilot initially resists the stick pusher activation in training. The data from these accidents suggests that the 10 degree AOA aerodynamic modeling requirement would adequately cover an AOA range that includes several seconds of inappropriate pilot responses to a stick pusher activation. The FAA has determined this range is sufficient to meet the training objective of teaching a pilot to not resist a stick pusher system activation. b. Definition of the Stall AOA

In the NPRM, the FAA defined the required aerodynamic model validity range for full stall qualification as 10 degrees of AOA beyond the stall/critical AOA and not as a function of when the stall identification cues are present.

Airbus commented that the definition of stall or full stall should emphasize "heavy buffet" as an important cue. Airbus further cited the ICAO 9625, Edition 4, document \9\ states that a stalled flight condition may be recognized by continuous stall warning activation accompanied by at least one of the following: (1) Buffeting, which could be heavy at times; (2) lack of pitch authority and/or roll control; or (3) inability to arrest the descent rate.

\9\ See section III.F.3 concerning changes made to address the recently published ICAO 9625, Edition 4 document.

The FAA concurs with Airbus' comment that heavy buffet can be an important cue of a stall. The FAA has further considered the definition of stall as described in the ICAO 9625 document to determine an appropriate definition for stall with respect to the modeling requirements necessary to support the training objectives. The FAA does not fully agree, however, with the ICAO 9625 definition of stall; specifically the criteria of "lack of pitch authority and/or roll control" to define the stall since the part 25 airplane certification requirements state that the pilot must be able to control the aircraft in pitch and roll up to the stall. While control effectiveness can be reduced, it would be incorrect to say that it is lacking for certified airplanes.

Two fundamental objectives of the stall training requirements are to train pilots to recognize the cues of an impending stall as well as to reinforce to pilots that the stall recovery procedures learned during stall prevention training are the same recovery procedures needed to recover from an unintentional full stall. To determine the extent of FSTD aerodynamic modeling necessary to conduct this training, the stall identification AOA must be defined as the point in which the pilot should recognize that the aircraft has stalled and that the stall recovery procedures must be initiated. The FAA has considered both the aircraft certification (part 25) definition of a "clear and distinctive" indication of a stall, as well as the ICAO 9625, Edition 4, stall definition. In order to provide a more consistent definition of the stall AOA to ensure that the required aerodynamic modeling range covers potential overshoots in AOA during stall training, the FAA has amended the final rule to better define stall identification:

i. No further increase in pitch occurs when the pitch control is held on the aft stop for 2 seconds, leading to an inability to arrest descent rate;

ii. An uncommanded nose down pitch that cannot be readily arrested, which may be accompanied by an uncommanded rolling motion;

iii. Buffeting of a magnitude and severity that is a strong and effective deterrent to further increase in AOA; and

iv. The activation of a stick pusher.

Since AOA awareness is a fundamental element of stall training, the instructor must be provided with feedback at the IOS concerning the aircraft's current AOA as well as the stall identification AOA. This feedback will not only provide the instructor with additional awareness concerning the aircraft's current AOA and proximity to the stall, but will also assist the instructor in determining when the aircraft has stalled and that the stall recognition cues have been provided as necessary to support the training objectives. In the final rule, the FAA has amended the IOS feedback requirements for upset prevention and recovery training to include AOA and stall identification AOA parameters.

The FAA further notes that the stall identification cues exhibited by an aircraft can, and often do, vary depending upon the aircraft's configuration (e.g. weight, center of gravity, and flap setting) and how the stall is entered (turning flight or wings level stall entry). Where differing stall identification cues are present on the aircraft, the FSTD's aerodynamic model should be capable of providing these cues and variation of stall characteristics for training purposes. The FAA also points out that, while this requirement was implied in the stall model evaluation requirements in the NPRM, ICAO 9625, Edition 4, further clarifies this issue with additional language which states that ". . . the model should be capable of capturing the variations seen in the stall characteristics of the aeroplane (e.g., the presence or absence of a pitch break)." The FAA has determined that the ability to show these variations would be valuable in training and has included similar clarifying language in Table A1A, section 2.m. of the final rule. 2. Envelope Protected Aircraft a. Model Validity Ranges and Associated Objective Testing

In the NPRM, the FAA included provisions that did not specifically require objective validation testing at an AOA beyond the activation of a stall identification (stick pusher) system through recovery. The primary purpose of including this provision was to not require the collection of flight test validation data at an AOA that could result in an unrecoverable and dangerous stalled flight condition.

Empresa Brasileira de Aeronautica S.A. (Embraer), Airbus, and an individual commenter questioned why computer controlled aircraft with stall envelope protection systems are treated differently from aircraft equipped with stick pusher systems with respect to model validity ranges and associated objective testing. Delta Airlines, Inc. (Delta) further questioned whether such modeling and testing will be required for an Airbus A350 aircraft that has part 25 special conditions on stall testing for airplane certification.

The FAA notes that Public Law 111-216 and the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule require training to be conducted to a stall. The primary purpose for the training is to provide flight crews with experience in recognizing the cues of an impending stall, as well as reinforcing the recovery techniques learned in stall prevention training. To expose flight crews to these stall identification cues, envelope protections systems must typically be disabled in training. Unlike most envelope protection systems, stick pushers are typically installed to either compensate for an inability of the aircraft to meet the part 25 stalling definitions in § 25.201 or the stall characteristics requirements in § 25.203. Where a stick pusher is installed to meet the stall identification requirements of § 25.201, the activation of the stick pusher provides the pilot with a clear and distinctive indication to cease any further increase in AOA. This "clear and distinctive" indication of a stall is necessary to accomplish the training objectives and simply reaching the AOA limits of the envelope protection or "alpha floor" on an envelope protected aircraft will not provide the stall recognition cues that a pilot needs to learn to prevent and recover from a full stall in the event that the envelope protection systems fail. The accident and incident record contains multiple instances of stall envelope protection system failures in the past, some of which progressed into a full stall situation where recognition cues of the stall were not identified by the flight crews.\10\

\10\ One such example is the June 2009 crash of Air France flight 447, an Airbus A330-203 that experienced failure of the high angle of attack (stall) protection system due to the loss of airspeed data as a result of pitot probe blockage. See "Final report on the accident on 1 June 2009 to the Airbus A330-203 registered F-GZCP operated by Air France flight AF 447 Rio de Janeiro--Paris"; Bureau d'Enquêtes et d'Analyses (BEA); Paris, France. Another example is the December 2014 crash of Indonesia Air Asia flight 8501, an Airbus A320-216, where flightcrew actions to correct a malfunctioning flight augmentation system resulted in the loss of stall protection. See "Aircraft Accident Investigation Report; PT. Indonesia Air Asia; Airbus A320-216; PK-AXC"; Komite Nasional Keselamatan Transportasi (KNKT), Republic of Indonesia 2015.

The FAA further notes that the FSTD qualification requirement for objective and subjective testing of the stall is not new with this rulemaking. The part 60 standard published in 2008 contains both objective and subjective testing of the stall to include the "g-break" and is required for computer controlled aircraft in a non-normal operational mode.\11\ Furthermore, the FAA's FSTD qualification standards dating back to AC 121-14C (1980) have also had both objective and subjective testing requirements for stall.\12\ As a result, virtually all of the currently qualified Level C and Level D FSTDs for transport category aircraft have objective testing already in place for stall maneuvers in their FAA approved Master Qualification Test Guide (MQTG) and most of these objective tests are validated against flight test data collected up to and including the stall. The FAA finds that reducing these requirements would not support the full stall training requirements in the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule and therefore maintains that the requirements set forth in this final rule are necessary.

\11\ See 14 CFR part 60 (2008), Appendix A, Table A2A, test 2.c.8 (Stall Characteristics) and Table A3A, test 6.a. (High angle of attack, approach to stalls, stall warning, buffet, and g-break . . . .".

\12\ Advisory Circular (AC) 121-14C (1980), "Aircraft Simulator and Visual System Evaluation and Approval".

b. Validation of Stall Characteristics Using Flight Test Data

b. Validation of Stall Characteristics Using Flight Test Data

In the NPRM, the FAA proposed objective testing of stall characteristics for computer controlled aircraft in both normal mode and non-normal mode flight conditions up to the full stall through recovery to normal flight.

Embraer commented that during the developmental flight test campaign, full aerodynamic stalls that are considered hazardous or impractical can only be done if the aircraft is equipped with additional safety features, such as a tail parachute or other equivalent device, and those features obviously change the aircraft behavior during stall recovery if they are employed. Additionally, Embraer emphasized that for safety reasons in the certification flight test campaign, depending upon the aircraft's aerodynamic characteristics during stalls; full aerodynamic stall flight tests are not done in control states in which the stall protection system is not available. Embraer recommended that flight testing for validation should not be required for objective testing in non-normal control states where the stall protection system is not available.

As previously stated, the non-normal control mode objective testing to a full stall has been required in the existing part 60 stall characteristics objective tests as well as in previous FSTD evaluation standards dating back several years and the FAA has not significantly changed this requirement in this rulemaking. The FAA agrees with Embraer that aerodynamic stall flight testing may be hazardous or impractical to conduct in some circumstances (on both envelope protected and non-envelope protected aircraft) and this rulemaking has not specifically required additional flight test validation data to be collected at an AOA beyond where it is reasonably safe to do so.

As described in the NPRM, the FAA has included allowances for aerodynamic stall models to be developed and validated using engineering and analytical methods. While the FAA agrees with the commenter that some airplane certification flight test data collected in a stall maneuver may not be suitable for simulator modeling and validation purposes (such as where a tail parachute has been deployed as mentioned by the commenter), other flight testing conducted to investigate the stall characteristics of the airplane during the aircraft certification program may be used to develop engineering simulator models. Where significant safety issues would prevent flight testing at an AOA beyond the activation of a stall protection system, engineering simulator validation data will be acceptable for FSTD objective testing purposes. The FAA has made amendments in the final rule to make this clarification. c. Required AOA Range for Normal Mode Objective Testing

In the NPRM, the FAA did not specify a particular AOA range to support the normal mode testing requirements for stall characteristics on computer controlled aircraft.

Delta and Airlines for America (A4A) requested clarification on what will be the required AOA range for objective testing on aircraft with highly automated systems where the aircraft does not reach aerodynamic stall in "normal control state."

The FAA has not specified a particular AOA range to support the normal mode testing requirements in this final rule, as this will be a subset of the AOA range required for non-normal mode testing. Public Law 111-216 and part 121, subparts N and O, require training for recoveries from stalls and stick pusher activations, if equipped. In order to conduct stall recovery training, the protections of an envelope-protected aircraft must be disabled. As such, aerodynamics outside of the envelope protections up to ten degrees beyond the stall AOA must be considered to allow for stall recovery training in the event the envelope protections fail. 3. Data Sources for Model Development and Validation a. Define Best Available Data

In the NPRM, the FAA proposed that where limited data is available to model and validate the stall characteristics of the aircraft, the data provider is expected to develop a stall model through analytical methods and the utilization of the "best available data".

Bihrle Applied Research (Bihrle), A4A, and an anonymous commenter stated that the term, "best available data" (with regards to the aerodynamic data used to model and validate the stall model) is ambiguous and open to interpretation. American Airlines (American), FlightSafety International (FlightSafety), A4A, JetBlue Airways (JetBlue), and Delta further requested clarification from the FAA on whether a "non-OEM" provided source of data would be acceptable to the FAA to meet the representative stall model requirements.

The FAA notes that there is not a specific requirement currently in part 60, nor has a new requirement been introduced in this final rule that mandates FSTD sponsors use the original equipment [aircraft] manufacturer's (OEM) data to develop and validate the aerodynamic and flight control models in qualified FSTDs. As described in § 60.13(b), "The validation data package may contain flight test data from a source in addition to or independent of the aircraft manufacturer's data in support of an FSTD qualification . . ." There are numerous FSTDs that have been qualified up through Level D where the FSTD manufacturer or other third party data provider has instrumented and flight tested an aircraft in order to collect flight test data to develop and validate their own aerodynamic and flight control models to support FSTD evaluation and qualification.

The FAA has considered the issues involved with requiring aircraft OEM data to develop and validate stall models for the purpose of conducting full stall training. While flight test data collected by the aircraft manufacturer will generally be the preferred source of data to model and validate FSTDs for training, the FAA has determined that "non-OEM" sources of aerodynamic data must be considered for the following reasons:

i. Restricting the development of stall models to that of the airplane manufacturers could impose a high cost on the FSTD sponsors and may not be possible in some instances where the airplane manufacturer does not support a simulator data package or is no longer in existence;

ii. Recommendations by the SPAW ARC, ICATEE, and other working groups have supported the use of analytically developed "type representative" stall models for training purposes; and

iii. An FAA simulator study \13\ has supported the SPAW ARC's findings and found that analytically derived "type representative" stall models that are developed by third party data sources and thoroughly evaluated by a SME pilot can be effectively used to support stall training tasks in a simulator.

\13\ Schroeder, J.A., Burki-Cohen, J., Shikany, D.A., Gingras, D.R., & Desrochers, P. (2014). An Evaluation of Several Stall Models for Commercial Transport Training. AIAA Modeling and Simulation Technologies Conference.

For these reasons, the FAA finds that it would not be practical to require FSTD sponsors to use an aircraft manufacturer's high AOA/stall model to meet the requirements of this final rule and other source data may be acceptable. Furthermore, Boeing, A4A, and an anonymous commenter stated that "flight test data should be noted as the preferred source of data, if available, with other data sources to be used if acceptable to the FAA." The FAA concurs with this statement. To manage unknown risks, an aircraft manufacturer provided stall model developed with flight test data will generally be the preferred source of data; however, the FAA has concluded that there is not sufficient evidence to warrant mandating a particular source of data for model development. The FAA acknowledges that the term, "best available data" is ambiguous and has removed that language in the final rule. b. Post Stall "Type Representative" Modeling

In the NPRM, FAA indicated that flight crews should be provided with practical experience in recognizing a full stall should the stall warning system become ineffective. To support this objective, the FSTD must provide critical aircraft type-specific stall recognition cues to enable the crew to recognize the onset of a stalled flight condition. Where data limitations and aircraft behavior may prevent conducting precise objective validation of post-stall behavior in the FSTD, the FAA included provisions in the proposal for "type representative" modeling and validation. To distinguish between the objectively validated "type specific" pre-stall modeling and post-stall modeling that may be developed through engineering analysis and SME pilot evaluation, the FAA used the term "type representative" in the NPRM.

Delta, FlightSafety, and A4A requested that the FAA better define the term, "type representative" with regards to post stall model fidelity.

In defining the FSTD fidelity requirements for full stall behavior, the FAA considered the primary training objectives for such training. The first objective of stall training is to provide flight crews with practical experience in recognizing a full stall should the stall warning system become ineffective (either through malfunction or human error). To support this objective, the FSTD must provide critical aircraft "type specific" recognition cues of an impending stall. Examples include cues such as reduced lateral/directional stability, deterrent stall buffet, and reduced pitch control if the particular aircraft has these cues.

The second objective of stall training is to reinforce to flight crews that the recovery procedures learned during stall prevention training are the same procedures needed to recover from a full stall. From an aerodynamic modeling standpoint, this presents a more significant challenge for two reasons. First, aircraft behavior in an aerodynamic stall may not be stable and is often sensitive to initial conditions, which creates the impression of non-repeatable chaotic behavior. Second, because this occurs in a flight regime with reduced stability, there can be practical limitations on the amount of flight test data that can be safely collected for simulator modeling and validation purposes. It is for these reasons that objectively validated "type specific" behavior at an AOA beyond the aerodynamic stall may not be a reasonable goal for defining fidelity in a training simulator.

The FAA has determined that the primary training objective for stall training is to have a pilot learn the proper stall recovery procedure in response to the variety of stall cues that a particular aircraft presents. Owing to the reduced stability, unsteady aerodynamics, and surface and rigging variations that occur with use, an aircraft will respond differently from stall to stall. However, the physics of what can happen in a stall are known, accepting that they can differ from aircraft to aircraft. The FAA has concluded that if a pilot can demonstrate applying the stall recovery technique for the general characteristics of what might occur for an aircraft type, the precise characteristics are not required. That is, if an airplane typically rolls 10 degrees left or 20 degrees right in a stall does not matter as long as the pilot does not incorrectly apply the stall recovery technique by responding to that roll before reducing AOA. What is important is to present roll if an aircraft has rolling tendencies to ensure that a pilot responds properly.

In order to avoid confusion with other uses of the word "representative" with respect to simulator fidelity, and to remain consistent with the ICAO 9625 definitions, the FAA has changed the description of the post-stall fidelity requirements to "sufficiently exemplar of the airplane being simulated to allow successful completion of the stall entry and recovery training tasks." For the purposes of stall maneuver evaluation, the term "exemplar" is defined as a level of fidelity that is type-specific of the simulated airplane to the extent that the training objectives can be satisfactorily accomplished. c. Use of Flight Test Data and Availability

In consideration of the recommendations of the SPAW ARC as well as the results of the FAA stall study, the FAA proposed that the necessary levels of simulator fidelity (including type specific pre-stall behavior and type representative post-stall behavior) can be achieved through a combination of engineering analysis, SME pilot assessment, and improved pre-stall objective testing through the use of existing stall flight test data that is already required by part 60 and previous simulator standards.\14\ Furthermore, the FAA proposed additional objective testing requirements for stall characteristics to include turning flight stall and high altitude cruise stall. In the proposal, these tests were also included in the FSTD Directive as applicable to previously qualified FSTDs.

\14\ 14 CFR part 60 (2008) currently requires stall characteristics objective testing that extends to the full stall and "g-break". Similar requirements exist for grandfathered simulator standards dating back to AC 121-14C (1980).

Dassault Aviation (Dassault) commented on the availability of full stall flight tests and that flight test points may not be available for some conditions where aircraft certification does not require them. Dassault further commented that corresponding flight test points might be implemented in the devices where partial data is available; however, no extension or extrapolation should be considered as type representative because this might lead to a very different behavior. An anonymous commenter made similar comments in that "unless there is a source of flight test data in every possible combination of conditions that might exist in a full stall, a demonstration of recovery techniques in a given set of conditions is the only plausible solution."

FlightSafety further questioned whether there would be a release from liability should a stall model developed through engineering judgment and analytical methods prove to be inadequate.

As stated in previous sections, the FSTD qualification standards have had objective testing requirements for flight maneuvers up to and including full stall since 1980, so nearly all currently qualified full flight simulators (FFS) already have full stall flight test points that are used for simulator validation purposes. For previously qualified FSTDs, this data could be used to further improve existing stall models to meet the requirements of this final rule. The FAA does recognize, as Dassault points out, that additional flight test validation data may not readily exist to validate the new stall maneuvers introduced in the objective testing requirements (e.g., cruise stall and turning flight stall). To address this concern, the FAA has amended the FSTD Directive for previously qualified FSTDs to remove the objective testing requirements for both the cruise condition and the turning flight stall condition and replaced them with subjective evaluation by an SME pilot. The remaining required objective testing stall characteristics tests (second segment climb and approach or landing conditions) are already required under the existing part 60 rule and should have existing validation data that can be used to meet the new objective testing requirements. Where limitations exist in the stall aerodynamic model due to the lack of data or reliable analytical methods, the data provider may declare these limitations as part of the required aerodynamic modeling SOC for the purposes of restricting the FSTD to certain stall maneuvers.

In response to FlightSafety's comment, the FAA notes that engineering judgment and analytical methods are used extensively in other areas of a simulation model besides stall and these models are used for training in conditions and situations that vary from the flight conditions used to validate the model. This practice has proven satisfactory, as known physical principles are used by FSTD manufacturers and data providers to represent the training conditions that vary from the flight-validated conditions. The FAA issues standards for FSTD evaluation, but generally does not prescribe specific methods for developing simulation models. The FAA does not have the authority to declare a release from liability. 4. Qualification on FSTD Levels Other Than Level C and Level D

In the NPRM, the FAA proposed modifications to the Level A and Level B stall qualification requirements to include stick pusher system force objective testing and updated objective and subjective testing requirements for the approach to stall flight conditions for newly qualified FSTDs.

Boeing, Delta, and A4A commented that while the FAA proposed modifications to the Level A and Level B stall qualification requirements, the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule does not permit such training in these devices and therefore these requirements should be removed. Delta and Boeing had additional comments concerning new requirements proposed for the "approach to stall" objective tests on Level A and Level B simulators (including additional configurations, tolerances, and subjective testing of the autoflight/stall protection systems) with one commenter stating that there is no apparent explanation why the approach to stall characteristics objective test has changed for Level A and Level B simulators and it should remain unchanged to be consistent with the ICAO 9625 document.

The FAA concurs with the commenters in that § 121.423 requires extended envelope training be conducted in a Level C or Level D simulator and has removed the associated minimum requirements for full stall on Level A and Level B simulators. However, the FAA notes that such devices are qualified to conduct stall prevention training at AOAs below that of the activation of the stall warning system and improving the validation of these FSTDs in the approach to stall flight condition would be beneficial to this training. Where new testing requirements were proposed for Level C and Level D simulators for AOAs below the activation of the stall warning system, these testing requirements were carried over to Level A and Level B simulators to provide better validation of the simulator to conduct stall prevention training tasks. The FAA further notes that these requirements for Level A and Level B simulators are not retroactive requirements defined in the FSTD Directive and will only be required for Level A and Level B simulators that are initially qualified after this final rule becomes effective. The FAA does not believe these changes for Level A and Level B FSTDs will have an impact on the alignment with the ICAO document since the Level A and Level B FSTD levels in part 60 have no equivalent ICAO device level. 5. Motion Cueing System Limitations

In the NPRM, the FAA included provisions to allow the FSTD manufacturer to limit the maximum buffet based on "motion platform capabilities and limitations" (see Table A2A, Entry No. 2.c.8). A similar provision was also included in the ICAO 9625, Edition 4.

The FAA received several comments that the FSTD sponsors, in addition to the device manufacturers, should be allowed to limit maximum buffet based upon motion platform capabilities and limitations. Furthermore, Delta, Boeing, FlightSafety, A4A, JetBlue, and United Parcel Service (UPS) commented that FSTD sponsors should have the ability to tune down or otherwise reduce motion vibrations due to maintenance and reliability aspects, personnel safety, and limitations of other simulator components, such as visual display systems and other hardware onboard the simulator. Boeing additionally commented that other simulator systems, such as the visual system, may also limit the buffet levels.

With regards to reducing or otherwise limiting motion vibrations that are within the motion platform's capabilities and limitations, the FAA has determined not to include specific provisions to allow for arbitrary reductions in stall buffet from the levels that are evaluated through SME pilot assessment or objective testing. On many aircraft, the stall buffet is an important cue of an impending stall and, in some cases, may be the only distinctive cue a pilot will receive before or during an actual stall. In an FAA stall study on its B737-800 simulator \15\ in which the magnitude of the stall buffet cues had been modified and increased significantly, all ten of the participating test pilots who had stalled the B737 noted the importance of accurately presenting the strong buffet cues as a stall progresses. Furthermore, the importance of stall buffet in training has been emphasized numerous times by the various working groups that provided recommendations to the FAA on stall training and associated simulator fidelity. As such, the FAA has determined that to accomplish the intended training objectives to provide flight crews with accurate recognition cues of an impending stall, the stall buffet characteristics should be provided in the FSTD at a level that is representative of the aircraft as evaluated by an SME pilot.

\15\ Schroeder, J.A., Burki-Cohen, J., Shikany, D.A., Gingras, D.R., & Desrochers, P. (2014). An Evaluation of Several Stall Models for Commercial Transport Training. AIAA Modeling and Simulation Technologies Conference.

Furthermore, as cited in A4A's and American's comments, Schroeder did acknowledge in his paper that buffet levels are sometimes reduced in a simulator to extend component life; however, no such reduction in stall buffet was implemented for this experiment. In fact, overall buffet gains were increased by a factor of 2.5 in the simulator with no adverse effects noted after the completion of the five week experiment.\16\

\16\ The FAA's CAE simulator was operated for an average of 8 hours per day for five weeks to conduct approximately 700 stall maneuvers which had significant buffet levels. The FAA estimated that this simulator was exposed to approximately 67 total minutes of stall buffet over this five week period of time, which is comparable to what a typical part 121 carrier's simulator may be exposed to over an entire year under the new training rule. There were no reports of equipment damage after the completion of the experiment.

The FAA acknowledges that the potential exists for increased maintenance and reliability issues due to the repeated exposure of the FSTD to stall buffet. The FAA concurs with Boeing's comment in that other simulator systems (e.g., visual systems) may limit the maximum buffet levels that are possible in a simulator and the FAA has made changes in the final rule to reflect this. Particularly with visual display systems, notch filters are frequently employed to reduce the vibration output of the motion platform at or around a resonant frequency that would cause damage to visual system components such as a Mylar mirror. These methods have been employed in the past and will continue to be permissible to protect the simulator and its occupants from known system limitations where damage is likely to occur or occupant safety may be compromised.

Furthermore, given that these standards may be applied to previously qualified FSTDs where the original FSTD manufacturer may not be accomplishing and evaluating the modifications of the FSTD, the FAA agrees with the commenters that the ability to limit the maximum buffet due to motion platform and other simulator system capabilities and limitations should be extended to the FSTD sponsor. The FAA has amended the final rule to allow for the FSTD manufacturer or the FSTD sponsor to limit the maximum motion buffet levels as described in this section. 6. Subject Matter Expert Pilot Evaluation and Qualification a. SME Qualifications and Experience

In the NPRM the FAA proposed that the SME pilot who conducts the subject evaluation of the FSTD's stall characteristics must have ". . . acceptable supporting documentation and/or direct experience of the stall characteristics of the aircraft being simulated" and have "knowledge of the training requirements to conduct the stall training tasks." The additional requirements proposed in Attachment 7 of the NPRM further stated that that the SME pilot must have experience in conducting stalls in the type of aircraft being simulated and, where not available, experience in an aircraft with similar stall characteristics.

The FAA received several comments concerning the experience and qualification requirements for SME pilots. American, A4A, Delta, and FlightSafety requested clarification on whether the required SME must be a pilot who has flown a full stall in the airplane or a pilot who only has knowledge of training requirements to conduct the stall tasks. Delta and A4A also questioned whether there are any other SME experience requirements beyond conducting stalls in the aircraft being simulated, or in an aircraft with similar stall characteristics. A4A, Delta, and FlightSafety, further requested clarification on whether an SME pilot can gain the necessary stall experience in an audited engineering simulator or on another Level D FFS that has already been qualified for stall maneuvers.

The FAA maintains that the subjective evaluation of the aerodynamic stall model is a critical component in ensuring that the FSTD's stall characteristics are representative of the aircraft and support the training objectives. The FAA further maintains that for such a subjective assessment to have credibility, the pilot must have direct experience in conducting stall maneuvers in the aircraft being simulated or in a similar aircraft that is expected to share the same general stall characteristics.

The FAA acknowledges that the SME requirements in the NPRM were not clearly defined and has revised Attachment 7 of Appendix A of the final rule to better define these requirements. In particular, rather than just stating the stall experience must be in the "type of aircraft being simulated", the FAA clarified this by stating that the experience must be ". . . direct experience in conducting stall maneuvers in an airplane that shares a common type rating with the simulated aircraft." In instances where the stall experience is in a different make, model, and series of aircraft within a common type rating, the FAA clarified that differences in aircraft specific stall recognition cues and handling characteristics must be addressed using available documentation such as aircraft operating manuals, aircraft manufacturer flight test reports, or other documentation that describes the stall characteristics of the aircraft.

Particularly for aircraft that are no longer in production, the FAA recognizes that there may be practical limits in finding SME pilots with the required experience to conduct the stall model evaluations. In instances where an acceptable SME cannot be reasonably located, the FAA has included deviation authority in the final rule for a sponsor to propose alternate methods in conducting the SME pilot evaluation of an FSTD's stall model.

In response to the comments concerning whether the SME pilot is required to have experience in the stall characteristics of the aircraft or knowledge of the training requirements to conduct the stall training tasks, the FAA has determined that the SME pilot must have both aircraft experience and knowledge of the training requirements, with the exceptions on experience as noted previously. While an important element of the subjective assessment is the comparison of the FSTD's performance against that of the aircraft, knowledge of the training tasks to be conducted in the FSTD should be considered when conducting these evaluations. The recognition cues and handling qualities of an airplane can change significantly as a function of the aircraft configuration and how the stall is entered. To ensure the model can support the training objectives as well as to communicate any known or potential deficiencies in the model, the SME pilot conducting this subjective evaluation should focus the evaluation on those general aircraft configurations and stall entry methods that will likely be used in training. The FAA has clarified this language in the SME pilot evaluation requirements in Attachment 7.

The FAA has considered whether an SME pilot can gain experience in an audited engineering simulator or another Level D FFS that has been qualified for full stall maneuvers and has concerns that the effectiveness of an SME pilot evaluation may be diminished when making such comparisons from simulator to simulator without an objective measure to ensure that the aerodynamic model from the engineering simulator has been properly implemented on the training simulator. For these reasons, the FAA maintains that the SME pilot conducting the subjective evaluation of the FSTD or associated stall model must have direct experience of the stall in the aircraft. A pilot cannot gain the necessary aircraft experience required to be a SME in an engineering simulator or another FFS that has been qualified for full stalls. b. Model Validation Conducted by the Data Provider

Boeing and Airbus commented that in lieu of an SME pilot evaluation being conducted on the individual FSTDs for initial and recurrent evaluations, the model validation with the SME pilot can be conducted by the data provider where objective stall data is provided to validate the individual FSTDs. Delta and A4A made similar comments. The FAA agrees with the commenters and notes that provisions to conduct the SME pilot evaluation on an engineering simulator were included in the proposal in Attachment 7 to Appendix A. The FAA maintains that where objective proof of match tests are provided to verify the models have been properly implemented on the training FSTD (including stall characteristics and stall buffet objective testing), the FAA will accept an SOC from the data provider that confirms the integrated stall model has been evaluated by an SME pilot on an engineering simulator or other simulator acceptable to the FAA. Furthermore, there is no intent to require that this SME evaluation be conducted annually, and the SOC that confirms this SME assessment has taken place will remain valid as long as the stall model remains unmodified. c. NSPM Process for Evaluating and Accepting an SME Pilot

In the NPRM, the FAA proposed that an SOC be provided to the FAA that confirms that the FSTD has been evaluated by an SME pilot. This requirement was proposed to apply to both newly qualified FSTDs as well as previously qualified FSTDs that are evaluated under the requirements of FSTD Directive No. 2.

Delta and A4A requested clarification on this process that the NSPM follows to evaluate and accept an SME pilot.

As described in FSTD Directive No. 2 and Attachment 7 to Appendix A, the process for the qualification of stall maneuvers requires that the sponsor submit an SOC to the NSPM confirming that the FSTD has been evaluated by a SME pilot with the required experience. The NSPM will review this SOC to verify that the evaluating SME pilot has the required experience as specified in the rule before issuing additional qualification for full stall training tasks. Additionally, requests for deviation from the SME experience requirements as described in Attachment 7 should be submitted to the NSPM when requesting additional qualification for full stall training tasks. Where specific questions arise, the NSPM will contact the sponsor or data provider directly for clarification. 7. Alignment With ICAO 9625, Edition 4, on Stall and Stick Pusher Requirements

The FAA's proposal for the stall and stick pusher requirements were primarily based upon the recommendations from the SPAW ARC, as well as other working groups such as ICATEE and the LOCART working group. After the FAA first initiated this rulemaking, the ICATEE recommendations that were considered by the FAA in developing the proposal were also considered by ICAO for updating the ICAO 9625 document to include FSTD evaluation standards for stall and upset prevention and recovery training.

The FAA received numerous comments that some of the general requirements and objective testing requirements in the proposal did not align with the ICAO 9625, Edition 4 requirements, which became available following the publication of the NPRM. A4A, Boeing, and an anonymous commenter indicated that the stick pusher requirements (Table A1A, Entry No. 2.1.7.S) in the NPRM should be relocated to the flight controls section where they are more applicable. Boeing and A4A also commented that the stall buffet onset measurements in the stall characteristics objective tests (Table A2A, Entry No. 2.c.8) are based upon speed rather than AOA like ICAO 9625, Edition 4. Delta, A4A, and an anonymous commenter indicated that the control force tolerances in the stall characteristics test should be applicable only to aircraft with reversible flight control systems. Finally, A4A and Boeing commented that the required test conditions for the stall buffet motion characteristics test (test 3.f.8 in Table A2A of the NPRM) do not include the same conditions as ICAO 9625, Edition 4.

The FAA was unable to fully participate in the ICAO deliberations due to ex parte concerns as the agency was engaged in this rulemaking proceeding. The FAA has had an opportunity to review the final release of the ICAO 9625, Edition 4, document and has found that only minor differences exist with regards to the stall qualification requirements as compared to the final rule. As such, in order to maintain alignment with the ICAO document as identified by the commenters, the FAA has incorporated the ICAO language into the final rule to the maximum extent possible. The FAA has amended the final rule by adopting much of the ICAO language for high AOA/stall modeling minimum requirements (Table A1A, Entry No. 2.m. in the final rule) as well as the stall characteristics objective test tolerances and flight conditions (Table A2A, Entry No. 2.c.8.a in the final rule).

The FAA did not, however, amend the required conditions for the stall buffet tests to align with the ICAO 9625 standard. As recommended by the SPAW ARC report, stall buffet evaluation should include a broader range of flight conditions than what is currently evaluated. The FAA has determined that the inclusion of the second segment climb condition is important to evaluate the differences in stall buffet vibrations at high power settings, particularly for turboprop airplanes. As a result, the FAA has maintained this is as a required condition for the stall buffet characteristic vibrations test (Table A2A, Entry No. 3.f.5).

While the FAA has aligned a majority of the general requirements and the objective testing requirements with the ICAO document, specific differences must be maintained in the final rule to address comments received on the proposal as well as retroactive FSTD evaluation requirements that are required to support the mandated training for United States (U.S.) air carriers. 8. Requirements for Previously Qualified FSTDs a. Stall Buffet Objective Testing

In the proposal, the retroactive requirements for previously qualified FSTDs, as described in FSTD Directive No. 2., did not include objective testing for stall buffets.

Boeing, Delta, A4A, and an anonymous commenter stated that the general requirement and objective testing requirements (Table A1A and Table A2A, respectively) for stall buffet vibration measurement state that these tests are required for all FSTDs qualified for stall training tasks. This is in conflict with the proposed FSTD Directive No. 2, which specifically states that stall buffet objective vibration testing is not required for previously qualified FSTDs.

In recognizing the potentially high cost of gathering additional flight test validation data for stall buffets, the FAA did not include this requirement in the proposed FSTD Directive No. 2 retroactive requirements for previously qualified FSTDs. Since changes to the QPS tables are not typically applicable to previously qualified FSTDs, changes to Table A1A or Table A2A are not necessary since all of the retroactive requirements are defined in FSTD Directive No. 2. The FAA has added language in FSTD Directive No. 2 in the final rule to clarify the retroactive testing requirements. b. FSTD Directive No. 2 and Grandfather Rights

In FSTD Directive No. 2, previously qualified FSTDs that will be used to conduct full stall, UPRT, and other specific training tasks will be required to meet certain sections of the general requirements, objective testing requirements, and subjective testing requirements of the updated QPS tables in order to obtain qualification for these training tasks.

A4A requested clarification on whether FSTDs that are "upgraded" to provide extended envelope training would also have to comply with the proposed ICAO alignment requirements as well (such as the new visual display system requirements). American and A4A further noted that some sections within the QPS tables appear to have been mistakenly applied to all simulators instead of those qualified after the effective date of the final rule.

The FAA notes that the only new QPS requirements applicable for previously qualified FSTDs are those that are described in FSTD Directive No. 2. As described in § 60.17 and paragraph 13 of Appendix A, previously qualified FSTDs will continue to hold grandfather rights and the changes to the QPS tables will not generally be applicable to previously qualified devices unless specifically stated in an FSTD Directive. The FAA has reviewed FSTD Directive No. 2 and made amendments in the final rule to clarify which sections of the QPS appendices will be applicable to previously qualified devices.

The FAA further notes that an "upgrade," as defined by part 60, is an "improvement or enhancement of an FSTD for the purpose of achieving a higher qualification level." FSTDs that are upgraded in qualification level will generally have to comply with the standard that is in effect at the time of the upgrade. It is important to note, however, that compliance with FSTD Directive No. 2 does not require a change in qualification level and is not considered an "upgrade" under part 60. As a result, the other changes made to the QPS appendices, including the general changes made to align with the ICAO document, will not be applicable to previously qualified FSTDs unless upgrading in FSTD qualification level. 9. Applicability of Stall and UPRT Requirements on Newly Qualified FSTDs

In the NPRM, the FAA proposed that the minimum requirements for the evaluation of full stall maneuvers and UPRT maneuvers would be applicable for all fixed wing Level C and Level D FSTDs that are initially qualified after the final rule becomes effective.

Dassault commented that while UPRT and full stall training will become mandatory for part 121 operators, it is not clear if this applies to part 135 and part 91 operators as well. Dassault further questioned whether the objective testing requirements for full stall maneuvers would be required for an FSTD that will not be used for full stall training. Finally, Dassault commented that they would prefer the requirements to be applied to new or modified aircraft types instead of new FSTDs since this would allow collecting necessary data at the time of the type certification flight tests.

CAE made similar comments that point out that the FSTD Directive (for previously qualified devices) is only applicable for those FSTDs that will be used to conduct such (UPRT and stall) training, however, the requirements in the QPS appendices are mandatory for newly qualified FSTDs regardless of whether they are used in an air carrier or a non-air carrier training program. CAE recommended that operators of newly qualified FSTDs (that are initially qualified after the final rule becomes effective) who are not subject to the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule should also be given the same option on whether or not to invest in the additional features that support extended envelope and other tasks as required under the final rule. CAE further stated that this would provide an option to those operators who may have multiple devices to limit such updates to certain equipment that will be utilized to conduct such training.

FAA agrees with the commenters that the requirement for FSTD modifications and data collection should not be imposed on sponsors who will not use those FSTDs to conduct full stall training and have no mandate to conduct such training. Similar to the FSTD Directive for previously qualified FSTDs, the FAA has amended the final rule to make the qualification of full stall maneuvers optional for newly qualified FSTDs. This will allow flexibility for operators to decide how many FSTDs need to be evaluated for full stall maneuvers to support training requirements.

FAA has, however, maintained the minimum requirements for UPRT evaluation on newly qualified Level C and Level D FFSs. The FAA has estimated that the addition of such IOS feedback tools to support UPRT would add little to no incremental cost to that of a newly qualified FSTD and will enhance instructor awareness in support of the existing part 60 unusual attitude qualification requirement.\17\

\17\ 14 CFR part 60, Appendix A, Table A1B, Entry No. 3.f., "Recovery From Unusual Attitudes". This minimum qualification requirement covers maneuvers that are "within the normal flight envelope supported by applicable simulation validation data."

In order to ensure that only FFSs that are evaluated and qualified for stall training tasks are used for such training, compliance with the stall and UPRT evaluation requirements will be tracked by the FAA through modifications to the FSTD's Statement of Qualification (SOQ). 10. General Comments on Stall Requirements a. Testing and Checking of Stall Maneuvers

Boeing commented that stall training beyond the stick shaker activation does not require testing or checking in part 121 and references made to testing and checking in FSTD Directive No. 2 should be removed.

FAA agrees with Boeing's comment and has modified the language in FSTD Directive No. 2 accordingly. b. Interim FSTD Qualification for Stall Training

A4A commented that the FSTD Directive (for previously qualified FSTDs) requires evaluation by the NSPM for additional qualification and should allow a draft SOQ to be issued until the next scheduled evaluation.

FAA notes that FSTD Directive No. 2 does not require an update to the FSTD's permanent SOQ before stall training can be conducted in an FAA approved training program. A positive response from the NSPM to the FSTD modification notification confirming that the requirements of the Directive have been met will, in most cases, serve as an interim update to the FSTD's SOQ until the next scheduled FSTD evaluation. In some instances, however, additional FSTD evaluations conducted by the FAA may be required before the modified FSTD is placed into service. FAA has added clarifying language to the FSTD Directive that this response will serve as interim FSTD qualification for stall training tasks until the next scheduled FSTD evaluation where additional FSTD evaluations conducted by the FAA have been determined to not be required. c. Aerodynamic Modeling Considerations

Frasca International (Frasca) commented that AOA rate is a significant contributor to stall behavior and should be considered as part of the requirement for aerodynamic stall modeling. FAA agrees with Frasca's comment and has added AOA rate to the list of aerodynamic modeling considerations in Attachment 7.

B. Evaluation Requirements for Upset Prevention and Recovery Training Tasks

B. Evaluation Requirements for Upset Prevention and Recovery Training Tasks

In order to support UPRT that was introduced in the Crewmember and Aircraft Dispatcher Training final rule, the FAA proposed new FSTD evaluation requirements for these training tasks. The proposed requirements were based upon recommendations from the LOCART and ICATEE working groups as well as from the guidance in the Airplane Upset Recovery Training Aid (AURTA), and included new standards to better define the FSTD's aerodynamic validation envelope. The proposal also included requirements to improve the feedback at the instructor operating station (IOS) concerning the FSTD validation envelope limits, aircraft operational limits, and flight control inputs by the trainee. 1. UPRT Qualification on Lower Level FSTDs

In the NPRM, the FAA proposed minimum qualification requirements for full stall and UPRT in the newly defined Level 7 flight training device (FTD) (Table B1A of Appendix B).

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 406 passages shown