70 FR 67278 Airplane Performance and Handling Qualities in Icing Conditions
This action proposes to introduce new airworthiness standards to evaluate the performance and handling characteristics of transport category airplanes in icing conditions. This proposed action would improve the level of safety for new airplane designs when operating in icing conditions, and would harmonize the U.S. and European airworthiness standards for flight in icing conditions.
This document is proposed. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.
Part III
Airplane Performance and Handling Qualities in Icing Conditions; Proposed Advisory Circular 25.21-1X, Performance and Handling Characteristics in the Icing Conditions Specified in Part 25, Appendix C; Proposed Rule and Notice DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
[Docket No. 2005-22840; Notice No. 05-10] RIN 2120-AI14
Airplane Performance and Handling Qualities in Icing Conditions
Agency
AGENCY: Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), DOT.
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM).
SUMMARY: This action proposes to introduce new airworthiness standards to evaluate the performance and handling characteristics of transport category airplanes in icing conditions. This proposed action would improve the level of safety for new airplane designs when operating in icing conditions, and would harmonize the U.S. and European airworthiness standards for flight in icing conditions.
Dates
DATES: Send your comments on or before February 2, 2006.
ADDRESSES: You may send comments identified by Docket Number FAA-2005-22840 using any of the following methods:
• DOT Docket Web site: Go to http://dms.dot.gov and follow the instructions for sending your comments electronically.
Addresses
• Government-wide Regulations and Policies Web site: Go to http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/ and follow the instructions for sending your comments electronically.
• Mail: Docket Management Facility; U.S. Department of Transportation, 400 Seventh Street, SW., Nassif Building, Room PL-401, Washington, DC 20590-001.
• Fax: 1-202-493-2251.
• Hand Delivery: Room PL-401 on the plaza level of the Nassif Building, 400 Seventh Street, SW., Washington, DC, between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., Monday through Friday, except Federal holidays.
For more information on the rulemaking process, see the SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION section of this document.
Privacy: We will post all comments we receive, without change, to http://dms.dot.gov, including any personal information you provide. For more information, see the Privacy Act discussion in the SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION section of this document.
Docket: To read background documents or comments received, go to http://dms.dot.gov at any time or to Room PL-401 on the plaza level of the Nassif Building, 400 Seventh Street, SW., Washington, DC, between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., Monday through Friday, except Federal holidays.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Don Stimson, FAA, Airplane & Flight Crew Interface Branch, ANM-111, Transport Airplane Directorate, Aircraft Certification Service, 1601 Lind Avenue SW., Renton, WA 98055-4056; telephone: (425) 227-1129; fax: (425) 227-1149, e-mail: [email protected].
Supplementary Information
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Comments Invited
The FAA invites interested persons to participate in this rulemaking by submitting written comments, data, or views. We also invite comments relating to the economic, environmental, energy, or federalism impacts that might result from adopting the proposals in this document. The most helpful comments reference a specific portion of the proposal, explain the reason for any recommended change, and include supporting data. We ask that you send us two copies of written comments.
Comments Invited
We will file in the docket all comments we receive, as well as a report summarizing each substantive public contact with FAA personnel concerning this proposed rulemaking. The docket is available for public inspection before and after the comment closing date. If you wish to review the docket in person, go to the address in the ADDRESSES section of this preamble between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., Monday through Friday, except Federal holidays. You may also review the docket using the Internet at the Web address in the ADDRESSES section.
Privacy Act: Using the search function of our docket Web site, anyone can find and read the comments received into any of our dockets, including the name of the individual sending the comment (or signing the comment of behalf of an association, business, labor union, etc.). You may review DOT's complete Privacy Act statement in the Federal Register published on April 11, 2000 (65 FR 19477-78) or you may visit http://dms.dot.gov.
Before acting on this proposal, we will consider all comments we receive on or before the closing date for comments. We will consider comments filed late if it is possible to do so without incurring expense or delay. We may change this proposal in light of the comments we receive.
If you want the FAA to acknowledge receipt of your comments on this proposal, include with your comments a pre-addressed, stamped postcard on which the docket number appears. We will stamp the date on the postcard and mail it to you.
Availability of Rulemaking Documents
Availability of Rulemaking Documents
You can get an electronic copy using the Internet by:
(1) Searching the Department of Transportation's electronic Docket Management System (DMS) Web page (http://dms.dot.gov/search);
(2) Visiting the Office of Rulemaking's Web page at http://www.faa.gov/avr/arm/index.cfm; or
(3) Accessing the Government Printing Office's Web page at http://www.gpoaccess.gov/fr/index.html.
You can also get a copy by sending a request to the Federal Aviation Administration, Office of Rulemaking, ARM-1, 800 Independence Avenue SW., Washington, DC 20591, or by calling (202) 267-9680. Make sure to identify the docket number, notice number, or amendment number of this rulemaking.
Authority for This Rulemaking
Authority for This Rulemaking
The FAA's authority to issue rules regarding aviation safety is found in Title 49 of the United States Code. Subtitle I, section 106 describes the authority of the FAA Administrator. Subtitle VII, Aviation Programs, describes in more detail the scope of the agency's authority.
This rulemaking is promulgated under the authority described in subtitle VII, part A, subpart III, section 44701, "General requirements." Under that section, the FAA is charged with promoting safe flight of civil aircraft in air commerce by prescribing minimum standards required in the interest of safety for the design and performance of aircraft. This regulation is within the scope of that authority because it prescribes new safety standards for the design of transport category airplanes.
Organization of This NPRM
Organization of This NPRM
Discussion of this proposal is organized under the headings listed below. Whenever there is a reference to a document being included in the docket for this NPRM, the docket referred to is Docket Number FAA-2005-22840. A list of acronyms used is included in an appendix located at the end of the preamble material, between the regulatory evaluation and the text of the proposed amendments. Unless stated otherwise, rule sections referenced in this NPRM are part of Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR).
I. Executive Summary
I. Executive Summary
If adopted, this rulemaking would revise certain sections of part 25 of Title 14 Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR). Part 25 contains the airworthiness standards for type certification of transport category airplanes, but it does not currently include specific requirements for airplane performance or handling qualities for flight in icing conditions. Although part 25 requires airplanes with approved ice protection features to be able to operate safely in icing conditions, there is no standard set of criteria defining what "to safely operate" in icing conditions means in terms of airplane performance and handling qualities. Further, because the existing icing regulations only address airplanes with ice protection provisions, it is unclear what requirements apply in cases where the applicant is seeking to have an airplane without an ice protection system certificated for flight in icing conditions.
This notice proposes to amend part 25 by adding a comprehensive set of airworthiness requirements that must be met to receive certification approval for flight in icing conditions, including specific performance and handling qualities requirements, and the ice accretion (that is, the size, shape, location, and texture of the ice) that must be considered for each phase of flight. These proposed revisions would ensure that minimum operating speeds determined during the certification of all future transport category airplanes would provide adequate maneuver capability in icing conditions for all phases of flight and all airplane configurations.
This notice proposes to require the same airplane handling characteristics that apply in non-icing conditions to continue to apply in icing conditions. Additionally, a specific evaluation for susceptibility to tailplane stall in icing conditions would be added. This proposal, if adopted, would harmonize the U.S. and European airworthiness standards for flight in icing conditions. It would benefit the public interest while retaining or enhancing the current level of safety for operation in icing conditions.
If adopted, this rulemaking would affect manufacturers, modifiers, and operators of transport category airplanes (but only for new designs or significant changes to current designs that would affect the safety of flight in icing conditions). Manufacturers and modifiers may need to develop new tests and analyses to determine ice accretions and to estimate performance effects for design and certification to address icing conditions. Operators may need to develop new or revised procedures regarding identification of icing conditions and the operation of the ice protection system.
Service history shows that flight in icing conditions may be a safety risk for transport category airplanes. There have been nine accidents since 1983 that may have been prevented if this proposed rule had been in effect.\1\ The service history that we examined includes airplanes certificated to part 25, to its predecessor, the Civil Air Regulations (CAR) 4b, or to part 25 icing standards when the airplane was certified under part 23. In evaluating the potential for this rulemaking to avoid future accidents, we only considered past accidents involving tailplane stall or potential airframe ice accretion effects on drag or controllability. Accidents related to ground deicing were not considered.
\1\ These accidents were selected from the National Transportation Safety Board's (NTSB) accident database, and are discussed in Appendix 3 of this premable.
The NTSB has issued several safety recommendations related to airframe icing, some of which are addressed, at least in part, by this notice. If adopted, this rulemaking would require, during type certification, that manufacturers of transport category airplanes:
• Investigate the susceptibility of their airplanes to ice-contaminated tailplane stall (ICTS);
• Provide for adequate warning on the flight deck of an impending stall in icing conditions;
• Show that their airplanes meet the same maneuvering capability and handling characteristics requirements in icing conditions as in non-icing conditions; and
• Show that their airplanes have adequate performance capability in icing conditions.
As discussed in more detail later, the FAA has tentatively determined that this rulemaking would have the following costs and benefits over a 45-year analysis period. The cost of the proposed rule would be $22.0 million (present value). The FAA assumes the initial certification costs of $6.7 million for four new airplane models are incurred in year one of a 45-year analysis period. The future additional fuel burn expense is estimated to be $59.7 million and would be incurred over the 45-year analysis period. The benefits of this proposed rule consist of the value of lives saved due to avoiding accidents involving part 25 airplanes operating in icing conditions. Over the 45-year period of analysis, the potential benefit of the proposed rule would be $89.9 million ($23.7 million in present value at seven percent).
A. Past Regulatory Approach
A. Past Regulatory Approach
Currently, § 25.1419, "Ice protection," requires transport category airplanes with approved ice protection features be capable of operating safely within the icing conditions identified in appendix C of part 25. This section also requires flight testing and analyses to be performed to make this determination. Although an airplane's performance capability and handling qualities are important in determining whether an airplane can operate safely, part 25 does not have specific airplane performance or handling qualities requirements for flight in icing conditions, nor does the FAA have a standard set of criteria defining what "to safely operate" in icing conditions means in terms of airplane performance and handling qualities. The proposed revisions to part 25 would provide a comprehensive set of harmonized requirements for airplane performance and handling qualities to address safe operation of transport category airplanes in icing conditions.
Further, § 25.1419 requires an applicant to demonstrate that the airplane can operate safely in icing conditions only when the applicant is seeking to certificate ice protection features. It fails to address certification approval for flight in icing conditions for airplanes without ice protection features.
In contrast, the European airworthiness standards specifically address certification for flight in icing conditions, independent of whether the airplane includes ice protection features. In addition, the European Joint Aviation Authorities (JAA) proposed additional guidance material in the early 1990s to provide criteria for determining whether an airplane's performance and handling qualities would allow the airplane to operate safely in icing conditions. The JAA's guidance material was proposed in draft Advisory Material--Joint (AMJ) 25.1419.\2\ The JAA's draft AMJ was published on April 23, 1993, as a Notice of Proposed Amendment (NPA) 25F-219, "Flight in Icing Conditions--Acceptable Handling Characteristics and Performance Effects."
\2\ A JAA AMJ is similar to an FAA advisory circular.
B. Harmonization of U.S. and European Regulatory Standards
1. Federal Aviation Administration
Title 14 CFR part 25 contains the U.S. airworthiness standards for type certification of transport category airplanes. The part 25 standards apply to airplanes manufactured within the U.S. and to airplanes manufactured in other countries and imported to the U.S. under a bilateral airworthiness agreement. 2. Joint Aviation Authorities
1. Federal Aviation Administration
The JAR-25 contains the European airworthiness standards for type certification of transport category airplanes. Thirty-seven European countries accept airplanes type certificated to the JAR-25 standards, including airplanes manufactured in the U.S. that are type certificated to JAR-25 standards for export to Europe. 3. European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA)
The European Community established a new aviation regulatory body, EASA, to develop standards to ensure the highest level of safety and environmental protection, oversee their uniform application across Europe, and promote them internationally. The EASA formally became operational for certification of aircraft, engines, parts, and appliances on September 28, 2003. The EASA will eventually absorb all of the functions and activities of the JAA, including its efforts to harmonize the European airworthiness certification regulations with those of the U.S.
The JAR-25 standards have been incorporated into the EASA's "Certification Specifications for Large Aeroplanes," (CS)-25, in similar if not identical language. The EASA's CS-25 became effective October 17, 2003.
The proposals contained in this notice were developed in coordination with the JAA. However, since the JAA's JAR-25 and the EASA's CS-25 are essentially the same, all of the discussions of these proposals relative to JAR-25 also apply to CS-25.
The FAA's rulemaking proposal, if adopted, would parallel the JAA's rulemaking proposal, "Notice of Proposed Amendment (NPA) 25B, E, F-332," published on June 1, 2002.
The EASA recently published for comment NPA 16/2004, "Draft Decision of the Executive Director of the Agency on Certification Conditions." This NPA, published for comment in late 2004, is based on the standards that the JAA were expected to adopt.
Although the FAA, the JAA, and EASA intend to harmonize the standards for airplane performance and handling qualities for flight in icing conditions, there are some differences between this rulemaking proposal and the standards proposed by the JAA and EASA. The differences are primarily editorial and are not intended to result in significant regulatory differences.
C. Proposal Development--Aviation Rulemaking Advisory Committee
C. Proposal Development--Aviation Rulemaking Advisory Committee
The FAA, in cooperation with the JAA and representatives of the American and European aerospace industries, recognized that a common set of standards would not only economically benefit the aviation industry, but also maintain a high level of safety. In 1988, the FAA and the JAA began a process to harmonize their respective airworthiness standards. To assist in the harmonization efforts, the FAA established the Aviation Rulemaking Advisory Committee (ARAC) in 1991,\3\ to:
\3\ Published in the Federal Register (56 FR 2190), on January 22, 1991.
1. Provide advice and recommendations concerning the full range of our safety-related rulemaking activity;
2. Develop better rules in less overall time using fewer FAA resources than are currently needed; and
3. Obtain firsthand information and insight from interested parties regarding proposed new rules or revisions of existing rules.
There are 73 member organizations on the committee, representing a wide range of interests within the aviation community.
We tasked the ARAC Flight Test Harmonization Working Group (FTHWG) to recommend to the ARAC new or revised requirements and compliance methods related to airplane performance and handling qualities in icing conditions.\4\
\4\ Published in the Federal Register (56 FR 2190), on June 10, 1994.
The FTHWG reviewed in-service incidents and accidents involving transport category airplanes. This review revealed numerous incidents resulting from the effects of ice on airplane performance. The same review showed that the icing-related accidents resulted from a loss of control of the airplane due to the effect of the ice on airplane handling qualities. Considering this service history, the FTHWG determined that airplanes should generally meet the same handling qualities standards in icing conditions that they currently must meet for non-icing conditions. In certain areas, however, the FTHWG decided that the current handling qualities standards were inappropriate for flight in icing conditions. In these areas, the FTHWG developed alternative criteria that would apply to icing conditions.
Since airplane performance degradation was not a causal factor in any of the icing-related accidents, the FTHWG concluded that the current performance standards already provide some safety margin to offset the negative effects of ice accretion. On the basis of this service history, the FTHWG decided that the general approach to airplane performance in icing conditions used by the JAA in their draft AMJ 25.1419 was appropriate and used this approach in its recommendations to the FAA. This approach allows a limited reduction in airplane performance capability due to ice before the effects of icing must be fully taken into account in the performance data provided in the Airplane Flight Manual (AFM). Such an approach minimizes the costs to manufacturers and operators while increasing the current level of safety for flight in icing conditions.
This proposed rulemaking is based on the FTHWG's report, which ARAC approved and forwarded to the FAA, and refers to the ice accretions to be used in showing compliance. These ice accretions are defined in a new subsection of appendix C to part 25.\5\
\5\ The complete text of the FTHWG's report is available at http://www.faa.gov/avr/arm/arac/aractasks/fr0404report.pdf. The FTHWG preferred the term "ice accretion" rather than "ice shape" because it includes physical characteristics of the ice build-up such as texture and surface roughness in addition to its general size and shape.
D. Related Rulemaking Activity
D. Related Rulemaking Activity
1. Amendment 25-108
This Amendment, "1-g Stall Speed as the Basis for Compliance With Part 25 of the Federal Aviation Regulations" (referred to as the 1-g stall rule) (67 FR 708112, November 26, 2002) redefines the criteria for determining the stall speed for transport category airplanes. The stall speed is important because it is used as a reference speed for defining minimum operating speeds that provide a safety margin above the speed at which the airplane will stall. The previous part 25 definition of stall speed defined it as the minimum speed reached in a stalling maneuver. This definition could result in a stall speed being defined that is too low to support the weight of the airplane in level flight.
1. Amendment 25-108
The recently adopted 1-g stall rule defines the stall speed as the speed at which the aerodynamic lift can support the weight of the airplane in 1-g flight. The 1-g stall rule also introduces a requirement to demonstrate adequate maneuver capability at the minimum operating speeds for airplane configurations associated with low speed operations around airports. The JAA adopted the same 1-g stall speed requirements in Change 15 to JAR-25.
2. Ice Protection Harmonization Working Group (IPHWG) Recommendations
2. Ice Protection Harmonization Working Group (IPHWG) Recommendations
The FAA tasked the ARAC to consider whether airplane manufacturers or operators should be required to install ice detectors or provide some other acceptable way to warn flightcrews of potentially unsafe ice accumulations. The ARAC assigned this task to the IPHWG. The IPHWG recommended to the ARAC that the FAA adopt an operating rule for certain types of airplanes that would require a reliable method of informing pilots when to activate the ice protection system as well as a way of knowing when ice is accumulating aft of areas protected by the ice protection system. The IPHWG is also working on a recommendation for a type certification requirement that would identify acceptable ways to inform the flightcrew when to activate the ice protection system.
We also tasked the ARAC to:
• Define an icing environment that includes supercooled large drop (SLD) icing conditions;
• Recommend requirements to assess the ability of aircraft to safely operate in SLD icing conditions, either for the period of time necessary to exit or to operate without restriction; and
• Consider mixed phase conditions (a mixture of supercooled water droplets and ice crystals) if such conditions are more hazardous than the liquid phase icing environment containing supercooled water droplets.
When ARAC finishes its tasks, we expect it to forward to us a report containing their recommendations. These recommendations may lead to future rulemaking to address SLD icing conditions, but would not directly impact this rulemaking.
E. Advisory Material
E. Advisory Material
In addition to being tasked to recommend new or revised requirements related to airplane performance and handling qualities in icing conditions, the ARAC FTHWG was tasked to recommend advisory material identifying acceptable ways to comply with the proposed new or revised requirements. The FTHWG developed a proposed Advisory Circular, (AC) 25.21-1X, "Performance and Handling Characteristics in the Icing Conditions Specified in Part 25, Appendix C." We are requesting public comments on this proposed advisory circular through a separate notice of availability in this edition of the Federal Register.
II. Discussion of the Proposals
II. Discussion of the Proposals
A. Proof of Compliance (§ 25.21)
We propose to add paragraph (g), to specify the requirements that must be met in icing conditions if an applicant seeks certification approval for flight in icing conditions. As discussed above, a review of icing-related incidents and accidents revealed loss of control to be the greatest threat to safety of flight in icing conditions. Consequently, the FTHWG identified the existing part 25 requirements that could prevent loss of control if they were applied to icing conditions. The FTHWG found, and we tentatively agree, that airplanes should continue to comply with most of subpart B of part 25 with ice on the airplane to ensure safe flight in icing conditions. The subpart B regulations that would be excluded by paragraph (g)(1) were determined to be beyond what was necessary to determine an airplane's ability to operate safely in icing conditions.
A. Proof of Compliance (§ 25.21)
Because the airplane performance and handling qualities requirements are flight-related requirements, it is appropriate to place the proposed requirements for flight in icing conditions in part 25, subpart B (Flight) rather than in the current ice protection rule in § 25.1419. Section 25.1419 is in subpart F (Equipment), and, though it is closely linked with the subpart B requirements proposed in this notice, it primarily applies to the ice protection equipment on the airplane.
The proposed subpart B requirements would provide the minimum performance and handling qualities requirements corresponding to the § 25.1419 requirement that the airplane "be able to safely operate in the continuous maximum and intermittent maximum icing conditions of appendix C." Additionally, the proposed requirements would supply the means for determining, from a performance and handling qualities standpoint, whether the ice protection system and its components are effective, as required by § 25.1419(b).
Compliance with the proposed performance and handling qualities requirements may be shown by a variety of means that would be evaluated during the particular airplane type certification program. These means may include flight testing in natural icing conditions or in non-icing conditions using artificial ice shapes, wind tunnel testing and analysis, engineering simulator testing and analysis, engineering analysis, and comparison to previous similar airplanes.
The proposed requirements would not specifically require performance and handling qualities flight testing to be conducted in natural icing conditions. However, we expect that for most new airplane designs, and for significant changes to existing designs, at least a limited set of tests would be flown in natural icing conditions. The purpose of these tests would be to confirm the airplane handling qualities and performance results found through other means. The proposed advisory material will provide guidance on an acceptable flight test program, including the specific tests that should be conducted in natural icing conditions.
Historically, flight tests in measured natural icing conditions have also been conducted to verify analyses used to generate ice accretions for compliance with § 25.1419(b), and to confirm the general physical characteristics and location of ice accretions used to evaluate airplane performance and handling qualities. This proposed rule is not intended to alter this practice or interpretation of § 25.1419(b). Existing AC 25.1419-1, "Certification of Transport Category Airplanes for Flight in Icing Conditions," provides guidance on comparing the ice accretions used to evaluate airplane performance and handling qualities with those obtained in natural icing conditions.
Proposed paragraph (g)(1) would apply the same airplane handling qualities requirements to flight in icing conditions as are currently required for non-icing conditions. Paragraph (g)(1) would also apply most of the airplane performance requirements currently required for non-icing conditions to flight in icing conditions. The icing conditions for showing compliance would be defined in appendix C to part 25. These requirements would apply to normal operations of the airplane and its ice protection system as specified in the AFM. By referencing the AFM, this paragraph would require that this manual include the limitations and operating procedures that are specific to operating in icing conditions.
As noted in the introductory discussion, some degradation in airplane performance capability would be permitted when showing compliance with the requirements for non-icing conditions. The amount of performance degradation permitted in each case is identified in the discussion of the individual performance regulations.
Proposed paragraph (g)(2) would prevent the use of different load, weight, and center-of-gravity limits for flight in icing, except where compliance with the applicable performance requirements impose more restrictive weight limits.
The reason for these proposed requirements is that operation in icing conditions should be essentially transparent to the flightcrew. There should not be any special procedures or methods used for operating in icing conditions other than activating ice protection systems. This philosophy comes from applying human factors principles to reduce operational complexity and flightcrew workload.
B. Stall Speed (§ 25.103)
B. Stall Speed (§ 25.103)
We propose to revise § 25.103 to require applicants to determine stall speeds with ice on the airplane. The proposed § 25.103(b)(3) adds ice accretion as a variable that must be considered when determining stall speeds to use for the different part 25 airplane performance standards.
Determining stall speeds with ice accretions is necessary to identify any increase in stall speeds from those determined for non-icing conditions. The applicant would then compare any change in stall speed due to ice accretion with the allowable stall and operating speed effects contained in the proposed airplane performance standards to determine whether or not airplane performance data must be determined specifically for icing conditions.
C. Takeoff (§ 25.105)
C. Takeoff (§ 25.105)
We propose to revise § 25.105(a) to add the net takeoff flight path described in § 25.115 to the list of airplane takeoff performance parameters that must be determined under the conditions specified in this paragraph. Additionally, § 25.105(a) would specify when compliance must be shown specifically for icing conditions.
We consider the proposed changes necessary to ensure the safety of takeoff operations in icing conditions. Ice on the wings and control surfaces can reduce the safety margins that currently are provided to prevent stalling the airplane. It can also degrade airplane climb performance, and cause controllability problems. We acknowledge that many transport category airplanes have safely operated in icing conditions using takeoff speeds determined for non-icing conditions. We agree with the FTHWG, however, that it is in the interest of safety to consider the effects of ice accretions on airplane takeoff performance.
In developing this proposal, the FTHWG and the FAA considered four factors:
• Operating rules and practices intended to ensure that critical surfaces of the airplane are free of snow or ice before beginning a takeoff;
• The use of anti-icing fluids that provide some protection from icing during the takeoff;
• Increasing use of ice detectors and deicing/anti-icing systems on airplanes that can be operated while the airplane is still on the ground; and
• The icing conditions that we propose to use for the takeoff flight phase.
Existing operating rules, Sec. § 91.527(a), 121.629(b), and 135.227(a), prohibit pilots from taking off with snow or ice adhering to the wings or other critical airplane surfaces. Additionally, Sec. § 121.629(c) and 135.227(b) require airplane operators to have either an approved ground deicing/anti-icing program or conduct a pre-takeoff contamination check within five minutes before beginning a takeoff to ensure that the wings, control surfaces, and other critical surfaces are free of frost, ice, or snow. Operators must train the pilots on the effects of these contaminants on airplane performance and controllability, on how to recognize airplane contamination, and on procedures intended to ensure that contamination is removed before takeoff.
Ground deicing/anti-icing programs include the use of deicing/anti-icing fluids to remove ice and snow and prevent them from reappearing on airplane surfaces during freezing precipitation conditions. Although these fluids are designed to flow off the airplane during the takeoff roll, we expect the fluids to continue to provide some protection throughout the takeoff ground run.
On some older airplane models, the wing ice protection system was designed for use in flight and cannot be operated while the airplane is on the ground. Yet many of the current generation of airplanes have ice protection systems that can be operated while the airplane is on the ground. Some of these systems are also coupled with ice detector systems that will automatically activate the ice protection system in icing conditions. These features tend to reduce the chances that ice will adhere to critical airfoil surfaces during airplane ground operations in atmospheric icing conditions.
As discussed later, we propose to revise appendix C of part 25 to define atmospheric icing conditions specifically for the takeoff phase of flight. These proposed atmospheric icing conditions would apply throughout the takeoff path, but are based on the more critical conditions that would be expected to occur at the end of the takeoff path. These conditions do not include freezing precipitation on the ground. At earlier points in the takeoff path, while the airplane is closer to the ground, the proposed takeoff icing conditions would be conservative, that is, they would predict larger ice accretions than would be likely to occur. If these conditions were to actually occur at ground level, they would form a freezing fog condition that would probably reduce visibility to the point that takeoffs could not be made.
An important part of determining the effects of ice accretion on takeoff performance is to decide at what point in the takeoff ice accretion is considered to begin. For the purposes of this rulemaking, we consider ice accretion to begin when the airplane lifts off the runway surface during takeoff.
Proposed § 25.105(a) would require applicants to determine airplane takeoff performance for icing conditions if the ice that can accrete during takeoff results in increasing the reference stall speed (VSR) or degrading climb performance beyond specified limits. Section 25.105(a) references all regulations related to the takeoff path. As a result, the performance for the entire takeoff path, including takeoff speeds and distances, must be determined for icing conditions if the stall speed or climb performance degradation limits are exceeded.
Section 25.105(a)(2)(i) of the proposal would require applicants to determine takeoff path performance for icing conditions if the stall speed increases by more than 3 knots in calibrated airspeed or 3 percent due to ice accretions. This proposed requirement would be more stringent than the guidance used by the JAA in their draft AMJ 25.1419. The draft AMJ allowed up to a 5 knot or 5 percent increase in stall speed before the takeoff performance would need to be recomputed for icing conditions.
Several commenters on the AMJ, including us, expressed concern over allowing such a large increase in stall speed believing it would result in a significant reduction in safety margin between the minimum operating speeds and the stall speed. We agree with the FTHWG recommendation that a 3 knot or 3 percent increase in stall speeds is the maximum that should be permitted before the takeoff performance data should be recalculated to consider the effects of icing.
Also, the JAA's draft AMJ 25.1419 used the effect of ice accretions on airplane drag rather than on climb performance to determine when the takeoff performance data must be provided for icing conditions. However, we agree with the FTHWG recommendation to consider the effect of ice accretions in terms of climb performance in § 25.105(a)(2)(ii) because it would cover more operating variables than just the effect of ice on airplane drag.
The part 25 takeoff climb requirements include a safety margin by requiring applicants to determine a net flight path based on the airplane's actual climb performance capability reduced by a set value that depends on the number of engines on the airplane. Proposed § 25.105(a)(2)(ii) would require applicants to determine takeoff path performance specifically for icing conditions if more than half of this safety margin would be lost due to the effects of ice accretion.
Part 25 divides the takeoff climb performance requirements into several segments. To establish the allowable limit for takeoff climb performance degradation in icing conditions, § 25.105(a)(2)(ii) would consider the effect of ice accretions on just the takeoff climb segment defined by § 25.121(b). For most transport category airplanes, this segment most often limits the allowable takeoff weight, and therefore is the most critical to safety. If the effects of ice accretions during the takeoff climb segment defined in § 25.121(b) are beyond specified limits, the airplane performance for the entire takeoff path must be determined with ice accretions on the airplane. This would include from the beginning of the takeoff roll until the airplane is at least 1,500 feet above the takeoff surface. Thus, for airplanes that would be most affected by ice accretions during the takeoff climb, additional safety margins would also be provided for the takeoff ground run even though ice accretion is assumed not to begin until liftoff.
D. Takeoff Speeds (§ 25.107)
D. Takeoff Speeds (§ 25.107)
We propose to revise § 25.107(c)(3) and (g) to change the reference for maneuver capability considerations from § 25.143(g) to § 25.143(h). This is an editorial change due to the redesignation of § 25.143(g) to § 25.143(h) proposed below.
We also propose to revise § 25.107 by adding a new paragraph (h). This new paragraph would state that the minimum control speeds (VMCG and VMC) and minimum unstick speeds (VMU) determined for the airplane in non-icing conditions may also be used for the airplane in icing conditions. The VMU, VMCG, and VMC speeds are used to determine the takeoff speeds V1, VR, and V2.
The minimum unstick speed (VMU) is defined in § 25.107(d) as the airspeed at and above which the airplane can safely lift off the ground and continue the takeoff. Takeoff speeds must be established sufficiently above this speed to assure the airplane can safely take off considering the variations in procedures and conditions that can reasonably be expected in day-to-day operations. Because these proposals assume that ice accretion does not begin until liftoff, this proposal would allow the VMU speeds for non-icing conditions to be used for determining takeoff speeds in icing conditions.
The ground minimum control speed (VMCG) is used in determining the takeoff V1 speed. The takeoff V1 speed is the highest speed at which the pilot must take the first action to be able to safely stop the airplane during a rejected takeoff and the lowest speed at which the takeoff can be safely continued after an engine failure. Since VMCG, like VMU, occurs before the airplane lifts off the runway, the assumption is that ice has not yet begun accreting on the airplane. Therefore, this proposal would allow the VMCG speeds determined for non-icing conditions to be used for determining V1 for icing conditions.
The air minimum control speed, VMC (commonly referred to as VMCA), is defined in § 25.149(b) as the airspeed at which it is possible to maintain control of the airplane, with no more than 5 degrees of bank, when the critical engine is suddenly made inoperative. Section 25.107 requires the rotation speed (VR) and the takeoff safety speed (V2) to be sufficiently higher than VMCA to assure that the airplane will be safely controllable if the critical engine fails during the takeoff. Since VR occurs before liftoff, like VMU and VMCG, this proposal would allow the VMCA speeds determined for non-icing conditions to be used for determining VR for icing conditions.
Several concerns must be addressed if we are to allow VMCA speeds determined in non-icing conditions to be used to determine V2 in icing conditions. Unlike VR, V2 occurs after liftoff and ice could have begun accreting on the airplane. Ice may accrete at V2 because ice protection systems are typically not turned on until the airplane climbs more than 400 feet after takeoff. Also, many airplanes do not have any ice protection on the vertical stabilizer. These concerns could lead to a reduction in the airplane's directional control capability if ice accretion occurs. To alleviate these concerns, the proposed § 25.143(c) would require applicants to show that airplanes are safely controllable and maneuverable at the minimum V2 speed with the critical engine inoperative and with the ice accretion applicable to the takeoff flight phase.
E. Takeoff Path (§ 25.111)
E. Takeoff Path (§ 25.111)
Currently, § 25.111 defines the takeoff path, describes the airplane configuration that applies to each portion of the takeoff path, and provides airplane performance requirements that must be met. We propose to revise § 25.111 by adding a new paragraph (c)(5) stating that the airplane's drag used to determine the takeoff path after liftoff would be based on the ice accretions defined in the proposed revision to appendix C. To accommodate the addition of the new paragraph, the "and" at the end of § 25.111(c)(3) would be moved to the end of § 25.111(c)(4).
The takeoff path begins at the start of the takeoff roll and ends when the airplane is either 1,500 feet above the takeoff surface, or at the altitude at which the transition from the takeoff to the en route configuration is completed and the final takeoff speed attained, whichever is higher. The takeoff path typically has two distinct climb segments: One from the point at which the airplane is 35 feet above the runway up to 400 feet, and the other from a height of 400 feet to the end of the takeoff path. The proposed changes to § 25.111 would identify when the takeoff path must be determined for flight in icing conditions and specify the ice accretion that must be used for these two climb segments.
New paragraph (c)(5) would refer back to the proposed § 25.105(a)(2) to identify when the takeoff path must be determined for flight in icing conditions. The ice accretions referenced in new paragraph (c)(5) would apply to the airborne portions of the takeoff path, since we are assuming that ice accretion does not begin until liftoff. If takeoff path performance must be determined for icing conditions, then the takeoff path must use the takeoff speeds of the proposed § 25.107 for icing conditions, using the ice accretions specified in paragraph (c)(5).
F. Landing Climb: All-Engines-Operating (§ 25.119)
F. Landing Climb: All-Engines-Operating (§ 25.119)
We propose to revise § 25.119 by requiring the airplane landing climb performance to be determined for both non-icing and icing conditions; adding references to the appropriate paragraphs of the proposed § 25.125 revision for the landing climb speed to use for non-icing and icing conditions; referring to the proposed appendix C revision to identify the ice accretion that would be used in determining landing climb performance in icing conditions; and changing the speed used to show compliance with § 25.119 from a speed less than or equal to VREF to VREF.
We consider the approach and landing phases of flight to be the flight phases most affected by icing conditions because of the potential for descending into and holding in icing conditions prior to landing. In addition, service history has shown that the majority of icing accidents and incidents occur in the holding, approach, and landing flight phases. For these reasons, our policy for the last 40 years has been for applicants to account for the effects of airframe ice accretion in their airplane's approach and landing climb performance data provided in the Airplane Flight Manual. (Approach and landing climb performance refer to the airplane's climb capability in the approach and landing configurations during the approach and landing flight phases. Sections 25.121(d) and 25.119 require minimum level of approach and landing climb performance to ensure that airplanes can abort an approach or landing attempt and safely climb away.) The proposed changes to Sec. § 25.119 and 25.121(d) (see below) serve to codify this policy.
G. Climb: One-Engine-Inoperative (§ 25.121)
G. Climb: One-Engine-Inoperative (§ 25.121)
We propose to revise § 25.121 by rearranging paragraphs (b), (c), and (d) to specify when the required climb performance must be determined for icing conditions; refer to the proposed appendix C revision to identify the ice accretion that would be used in calculating approach climb performance in icing conditions; and provide the conditions under which the approach climb speed must be increased to account for the effect of ice accretion.
Sections 25.121(b) and (c) provide the climb performance requirements for the takeoff path segments beginning at the point the landing gear is fully retracted and ending at the end of the takeoff path. As in the proposed revision to § 25.105, we propose to revise § 25.121(b) and (c) to require takeoff climb performance to be determined for icing conditions if the effect of ice: (1) Increases the stall speed at maximum takeoff weight by more than 3 knots or 3 percent, or (2) reduces the climb performance determined in § 25.121(b) by more than half the safety margin provided by the net gradient adjustment required by § 25.115.
Section 25.121(a) provides the climb performance requirements for the takeoff path segment beginning at liftoff and ending when the landing gear is fully retracted. Since we are assuming that ice accretion does not begin until liftoff, only a minimal amount of ice could be accreted during this climb segment. Therefore, the proposal for § 25.21(g)(1) excludes compliance with § 25.121(a) with ice accretions on the airplane.
We propose revising § 25.121(d) to state when the approach climb speed must be adjusted for use in icing conditions. Unlike the speeds used in the takeoff path, the need to adjust the approach climb speed would not be based on the effect of ice accretions on the airplane's stall speed. Instead, the measure for determining whether the approach climb speed needs to be adjusted for icing conditions is based on the effect of ice accretions on the approach climb speed. If the approach climb speed for icing conditions does not exceed the climb speed for non-icing conditions by more than the greater of 3 knots calibrated airspeed (CAS) or 3 percent VSR, then non-icing speeds may be used for calculating approach climb performance for icing conditions.
The existing requirement for determining the approach climb speed in non-icing conditions provides applicants some flexibility by only specifying the maximum allowable approach climb speed. No lower limit is specified and we have accepted approach climb speeds as low as 1.13 VSR (that is, 13 percent above the reference stall speeds). We would accept this same level of flexibility for establishing the approach climb speeds in icing conditions. The approach climb speeds for icing conditions should also be evaluated to ensure that they provide adequate maneuver capability.
This proposal for the approach climb segment is less stringent than the 3 knots or 3 percent VSR standard used for takeoff path speeds. For example, if the approach climb speed is 1.25 VSR and VSR is 100 knots, 3 percent of the approach climb speed is 3.75 knots, while 3 percent of VSR would be only 3 knots. The approach climb speed could increase by 3.75 knots without requiring this increased approach climb speed to be used for calculating the approach climb performance in icing conditions. We consider this small alleviation to be acceptable since it is only relative to the need for increasing the approach climb speed for icing conditions. The approach climb performance must be recalculated with the holding ice accretion and presented in the AFM regardless of whether the approach climb speed is adjusted for operations in icing conditions.
H. En Route Flight Paths (§ 25.123)
H. En Route Flight Paths (§ 25.123)
We propose to revise § 25.123(a) by specifying a minimum allowable speed for determining en route flight paths, which would apply to both icing and non-icing conditions. The proposed speed, VFTO, is currently used as the minimum allowable speed for the final takeoff.
Additionally, the proposed revision to § 25.123(b) would state when an applicant must determine the en route flight paths specifically for icing conditions. Similar to the takeoff path requirements of the proposed revision to § 25.111, en route flight path performance needs to be specifically determined for icing conditions if the effect of ice: (1) Increases the en route speed by more than 3 knots or 3 percent, or (2) reduces climb performance by more than half the safety margin provided by the net gradient adjustment required by § 25.123(b). The ice accretion to be used would be specified in the proposed revision to appendix C.
The reason for proposing to limit the minimum allowable en route climb speed to VFTO to is to prevent applicants from showing compliance with § 25.123 by trading altitude for airspeed when transitioning from the final takeoff to the en route climb segment. This clarifying change is consistent with our original intent for § 25.123(a).
Another reason for not allowing an en route climb speed less than VFTO is that VFTO is the speed at which the maneuver capability requirements contained in the existing § 25.143(g) must be met in the en route configuration. Allowing an en route climb speed lower than VFTO would not ensure that the airplane has adequate maneuvering capability during the en route climb phase of flight.
We are not proposing any changes to the two-engine-inoperative en route flight path requirements contained in § 25.123(c) for flight in icing conditions. We do not expect the pilot to stay in icing conditions with one engine inoperative for a long enough duration for the failure of a second engine in icing conditions to be an issue.
En route and takeoff flight paths have similar safety issues. Therefore, we are proposing requirements for identifying when en route climb flight paths must be determined for icing conditions that are similar to those proposed for takeoff flight paths. The only significant difference is that for the en route climb paths, a speed of 1.18 VSR determined with the en route ice accretion of proposed appendix C is compared to the en route climb speed selected for non-icing conditions instead of comparing stall speeds with and without ice accretions.
The reason for this difference is to provide a more stringent requirement for airplanes that use the minimum allowable en route climb speed of 1.18 VSR. (1.18 VSR is the minimum allowable value of VFTO prescribed by § 25.107(g)). Airplanes that use a higher en route climb speed have a larger speed margin to the stall speed and more maneuvering capability in the en route climb phase to help offset the negative effects of ice accumulation.
Due to differences in their methods of generating thrust, propeller-driven airplanes generally have better climb performance at lower airspeeds than turbojet-powered airplanes. To optimize performance, the en route climb speed used for propeller-driven airplanes is usually the minimum allowable speed of 1.18 VSR, while the en route climb speed used for turbojet-powered airplanes is usually higher. Therefore, the proposed requirement would be more stringent for propeller-driven airplanes. We consider the increased stringency for propeller-driven airplanes to be desirable for the following reasons:
• Propeller-driven airplanes generally have deicing systems that cycle on and off, allowing ice to accrete on the protected surfaces before removing it. Also, these deicing systems typically do not remove all of the ice with each cycle, leaving some residual ice. Both of these effects result in drag increases that are generally not present on turbojet airplanes that have ice protection systems using hot bleed air from the engines.
• Propeller-driven airplanes will likely be subjected to increased exposure to icing conditions, due to their slower operating speeds, shorter flight lengths, and lower cruising altitudes.
I. Landing (§ 25.125)
We propose to revise § 25.125(a) to identify when the landing distance must be determined specifically for icing conditions. The proposed requirement would specify that the landing distance must be determined for icing conditions if the VREF in icing conditions exceeds the VREF in non-icing conditions by more than 5 knots CAS. For icing conditions, the landing distance would be determined with the landing ice accretion defined in the proposed revision to appendix C.
I. Landing (§ 25.125)
Additionally, a new paragraph (b) would be added to include the landing distance requirements that would be moved from the existing paragraph (a). The new paragraph (b) would also set the requirements for determining the landing speeds to use in determining the landing distances for both icing and non-icing conditions. For icing conditions, the landing speed must not be lower than 1.23 VSR0 with the landing ice accretion on the airplane if that speed exceeds the VREF for non-icing conditions by more than 5 knots CAS.
The existing paragraphs (b) through (f) would be redesignated as (c) through (g).
Whether landing distances or landing speeds must be determined specifically for icing conditions depends on whether VREF needs to be increased by more than 5 knots CAS to counteract the effect of ice on airplane stall speeds. The reasons behind allowing VREF to increase by up to 5 knots CAS in icing conditions before requiring landing distance performance to be recomputed for icing conditions are:
• As part of the flight testing to demonstrate compliance with the landing distance requirements, we typically evaluate airplane controllability when landing at speeds lower than the normal landing speeds. We usually perform this evaluation at a speed 5 knots below VREF to cover inadvertent speed variations that may occur in operational service. Plus or minus five knots variation from VREF is frequently used as a guideline for evaluating expected operational variations in landing speeds.
• Normal approaches in transport category airplanes are typically flown at speeds above VREF to provide speed margins to account for wind gusts. Although the additional speed should be bled off by the time that the airplane is over the landing threshold, it may not be. Service history does not indicate any safety problems with the resulting longer landing distance.
• Many transport category airplanes are flown at a speed 5 knots higher than VREF during final approach to counter any inadvertent speed loss. Often this additional speed has not been bled off before reaching the landing threshold. Again, service history does not indicate any safety problems with the resulting longer landing distance.
• A 5-knot increase above the VREF speed for non-icing conditions equates to approximately 3 percent of the 1-g stall speed (slightly less than 3 percent for larger airplanes). This is consistent with the allowable stall speed increase proposed for the takeoff path requirements for icing conditions.
As a further safety consideration for the VREF speed, § 25.125(b)(ii)(c) would require that VREF for icing conditions must provide the same maneuvering capability (with ice accretions on the airplane) as is currently required at VREF for non-icing conditions. This may result in an increase to VREF for icing conditions even if this increase is less than 5 knots.
The current § 25.125(a)(2), which would be redesignated as § 25.125(b)(2)(i), requires VREF for non-icing conditions to be not less than the landing minimum control speed, VMCL. This existing requirement ensures that adequate directional control is available in case an engine fails during a go-around. Under the proposed new rule, the VMCL determined for non-icing conditions would continue to be used for icing conditions. This would be similar to the takeoff flight phase, where the takeoff minimum control speeds, VMCG and VMCA, determined for non-icing conditions would continue to be used for icing conditions. Unlike the takeoff case; however, the continued use of the non-icing VMCL is not explicitly stated. We consider the proposed requirements to adequately address this issue without proposing an additional explicit requirement. Section 25.125(b)(2)(ii) requires VREF for icing conditions to be not less than VREF for non-icing conditions. Under § 25.125(b)(2)(i), VREF for non-icing conditions must be not less than VMCL for non-icing conditions. Taken together, these two proposed requirements would allow the VMCL determined for non-icing conditions to continue to be used for icing conditions.
To assure that using the VMCL determined for non-icing conditions will provide safe controllability and maneuverability for icing conditions, the proposed Sec. § 25.143(c)(2) and (c)(3) would require the applicant to show that the airplane will be safely controllable and maneuverable during an approach and go-around and an approach and landing, both with the critical engine inoperative. For added safety during certification flight testing, these maneuvers may be accomplished with a simulated engine failure (as noted in the proposed advisory material associated with this proposal).
J. Controllability and Maneuverability--General (§ 25.143)
J. Controllability and Maneuverability--General (§ 25.143)
We propose to revise § 25.143 to add a new paragraph (c) that requires the applicant to show that the airplane with ice accretions and with the critical engine inoperative is safely controllable and maneuverable during takeoff, an approach and go-around, and an approach and landing; a new paragraph (i) to identify the ice accretions that must be used in showing compliance with § 25.143 in icing conditions, and to introduce two specific controllability requirements that apply to flight in icing conditions; and a new paragraph (j) to specify tests for ensuring that the airplane has adequate controllability for flight in icing conditions before the ice protection system is activated and performing its intended function of removing any ice accretions from protected surfaces.
In addition, existing paragraphs (c) through (g) would be redesignated as paragraphs (d) through (h), and paragraph references in the newly designated paragraphs (d), (e), and (f) would be revised accordingly.
The requirements proposed in new paragraph (c) are intended to ensure that using the minimum control speeds for non-icing conditions would not result in controllability and maneuverability safety concerns when the same speeds are used for icing conditions.
The proposed new paragraph (i)(1) would require compliance with all of § 25.143 in icing conditions except paragraphs (b)(1) and (2). Sections 25.143(b)(1) and (2) are excepted from icing analysis under proposed section 25.21(g).
These proposed requirements assume a conventional empennage (that is, wing/fuselage/tailplane) configuration. Special conditions, issued in accordance with § 21.16, may be necessary for certification of airplanes with an unconventional empennage configuration.
Applicants can minimize the number of ice accretions to be tested by using one accretion that is shown to be the most critical accretion for several flight phases.
In many cases, a thin, rough, layer of ice (defined as sandpaper ice in the proposed revision to appendix C) has been shown to have a more detrimental effect on handling qualities for airplanes with unpowered control systems than larger ice accretions. The effect of sandpaper ice accretions may be more significant than larger ice accretions on these airplanes. In some cases, such an accretion has resulted in control surface hinge moment reversals that required the flightcrew to apply extremely high forces to the controls to regain control of the airplane. Applicants would have to consider sandpaper ice in showing compliance with the proposed § 25.143(i).
The proposed paragraph (i)(2) would require applicants to conduct a pushover maneuver down to a zero g load factor with the critical ice accretion on the airplane. (If the airplane lacks enough elevator power to get to a zero g load factor, the maneuver may be ended at the lowest load factor obtainable.) The purpose of this proposed requirement is to evaluate an airplane's susceptibility to a phenomenon known as ice-contaminated tailplane stall (ICTS). Ice-contaminated tailplane stall can be characterized either by completely stalled airflow over the horizontal stabilizer, or by an elevator hinge moment reversal due to separated flow on the lower surface of the horizontal stabilizer caused by ice accretions on the tailplane.
Several incidents and accidents have been caused by ICTS. These incidents and accidents have typically occurred during landing approach when the flightcrew either lowered the flaps or abruptly decreased the airplane's pitch attitude. Either of these actions will increase the angle-of-attack (AOA) of the local airflow over the tailplane. If there is ice on the tailplane, the increased AOA may lead to an ICTS.
The proposed pushover maneuver increases the AOA on an ice-contaminated tailplane by inducing a nose down pitch rate. An airplane is not susceptible to an ICTS if, during the pushover maneuver:
• The pilot must continue to apply a push force to the pitch control throughout the maneuver (that is, the airplane will not continue the maneuver to or toward a zero g load factor unless the pilot applies a push force to the pitch control); and
• The pilot can promptly recover from the maneuver without exceeding 50 pounds of pull force on the pitch control.
The proposed pushover maneuver evolved from earlier criteria developed shortly after a series of incidents and accidents highlighted the safety concerns related to ICTS. For example, early ICTS test criteria called for executing a pushover to a 0.3 g to 0.4 g load factor with a pitch rate of not less than 10 degrees per second in an attempt to copy the documented ICTS accident conditions. An aggressive pushover to zero g was later found to result in the same combination of load factor and pitch rate, but with the advantage of not needing sophisticated test instrumentation to perform the test.
In addition to the pushover maneuver, we propose that applicants demonstrate the safety of a sideslip maneuver with an ice-contaminated tailplane, since this has been shown to be a more critical ICTS triggering maneuver for some airplanes. The proposed § 25.143(i)(3) would require that any changes in the force the pilot must apply to the pitch control to maintain speed with increasing sideslip angle must steadily increase with no force reversals.
Proposed § 25.143(j) would address airplane controllability between the time when the airplane first enters icing conditions and when the ice protection system is activated and performing its intended function. In developing the controllability criteria proposed in paragraph (j), we considered the likely duration of this time period and the means that might be used for detecting icing conditions and activating the ice protection system. The proposed advisory material for part 25, appendix C, part II(e) would provide additional guidance for determining the appropriate ice accretion for this testing based on the means of ice detection.
Although activation of the ice protection system is expected to occur shortly after entering icing conditions, it may not occur for a relatively long time if the method of detecting icing conditions depends on the crew visually observing a specified amount of ice buildup on some reference surface (for example, windshield wiper, icing probe). To address this concern, proposed § 25.143(j)(1) requires compliance with all of the requirements of § 25.143 that would apply to flight in icing conditions for this method of detecting icing conditions. In this case, the ice accretion to be used in showing compliance would be the ice accretion that would exist before the ice protection system is activated and is performing its intended function.
For airplanes that use other means of detecting icing conditions, the proposed requirements would be less stringent. This reflects the expectation that the airplane would fly only briefly in icing conditions before activation of the ice protection system. Instead of requiring compliance with all of the requirements of § 25.143 that apply to flight in icing conditions, § 25.143(j)(2) would require only a demonstration that the airplane is controllable in a pull-up maneuver up to 1.5 g load factor, and that there is no longitudinal control force reversal during a pushover maneuver down to a 0.5 g load factor.
K. Stall Warning (§ 25.207)
K. Stall Warning (§ 25.207)
We propose to revise paragraph (b) to require that the means for providing a warning of an impending stall must be the same for both icing and non-icing conditions. There would be one exception to this general rule. If the means of detecting icing conditions does not involve waiting until some specified amount of ice has accreted on a reference surface, then the stall warning may be provided by a different means during the time from when the airplane first enters icing conditions until the ice protection system is activated and is performing its intended function.
We propose to add a new paragraph (e) to specify the stall warning margin that the stall warning system must provide in icing conditions. The stall warning margin is how far in advance the pilot is warned of a potential stall. We propose to evaluate the stall warning margin in both straight and turning flight while decelerating the airplane at rates of up to one knot per second. The pilot must be able to prevent stalling the airplane using the same recovery maneuver that would be used in non-icing conditions, starting the recovery maneuver not less than 3 seconds after the stall warning begins. Paragraph (e) also specifies the ice accretions that would be used for showing compliance.
We propose to revise paragraph (f) to consist of the existing paragraph (e), revised to clarify that the pilot must use the same maneuver to demonstrate that the airplane can safely recover from a stall in icing conditions as is used for non-icing conditions.
We propose to add a new paragraph (h) to specify the stall warning requirements for the time period when the airplane first enters icing conditions until the ice protection system is activated and is performing its intended function. The proposed stall warning requirements would be different for different means of detecting icing conditions and whether or not the stall warning is provided by the same means for icing conditions and non-icing conditions.
Currently, part 25 requires airplanes to provide the flightcrew an adequate warning of an impending stall so that the flightcrew can prevent the stall. The current requirement does not consider the effects of ice accretions on the airplane. With ice accretions on the airplane, the airplane may stall sooner (that is, at a higher speed or lower AOA), possibly even before the stall warning would occur. For an airplane to be approved for flight in icing conditions, we consider it necessary to provide an adequate stall warning margin with ice accretions on the airplane. For human factors reasons, we also consider it necessary for the means of providing the stall warning to be the same in icing conditions and non-icing conditions. But as discussed in the specific proposal for § 25.207(h), we would allow a limited exception to this general requirement.
In most transport category airplanes, the stall warning is provided by a device called a stick shaker, which shakes the control column to alert the pilot when the airplane is close to stalling. The proposed addition to § 25.207(b) would establish the general requirement for the same means for the stall warning in icing conditions and non-icing conditions. Section 25.207(b) would, however, allow an exception to the general requirement. The conditions for the exception to the general requirement would be established in § 25.207(h)(2)(ii).
The general rule of § 25.207(b) may result in a different stick shaker activation point for icing conditions because the airplane may stall at a different speed or AOA with ice accretions. In order to maintain a safe margin above the stall speed and to provide sufficient maneuvering capability, an increase in the minimum operating speeds may be needed. Increasing the minimum operating speeds, such as takeoff and landing speeds, may result in a cost increase if operators have to reduce payload to comply with performance requirements at the higher operating speeds.
These potential cost impacts may be minimized for stall warning in icing conditions after the ice protection system has been turned on. Then the higher settings for flight in icing conditions would only be used if the ice protection system has been activated. The higher operating speeds would not be a factor, or cost, in other operations.
However, this design solution would not protect the airplane during the time that the airplane is in icing conditions before activation of the ice protection system. To protect the airplane during this time period, any changes to the stall warning system settings for potential ice accretions would need to be active at all times. This would mean that the minimum operating speeds would be increased for both icing and non-icing conditions with resulting cost implications.
To minimize the potential cost impact, while ensuring flight safety, the FTHWG examined whether different stall warning requirements could be used for flight in icing conditions before activation of the ice protection system. Flight in icing conditions before activation of the ice protection system is a temporary condition. In most cases, this time is expected to be relatively short. In those cases, proposed paragraph (h)(2) would allow the stall warning to be provided by a different means than is used for non-icing conditions. For example, natural airplane buffeting might be used instead of a stick shaker. By allowing a different means of stall warning, the need to change the stall warning system setting would be minimized.
However, if the stall warning is provided by a different means than for flight in non-icing conditions, the proposal seeks to balance this with more stringent flight demonstration requirements. The requirements would be more stringent for demonstrating that the pilot can safely recover the airplane after a stall warning has occurred. This demonstration occurs during the flight tests to show acceptable flight characteristics for stall recovery. For the time that the airplane is in icing conditions before the ice protections system has been activated, if stall warning is provided by a different means than for non-icing conditions, it may take longer for the flightcrew to recognize the impending stall and take recovery action. Therefore, instead of allowing a recovery maneuver to be started one second after the onset of stall warning, the recovery maneuver must not begin until at least 3 seconds after the onset of stall warning. Paragraph (h)(2)(i) of the proposal allows the recovery to start within one second of the stall warning. The more stringent three-second requirement is contained in the proposed paragraph (h)(2)(ii).
Additionally, proposed paragraph (h)(2)(ii) would require the applicant to show that the airplane has safe handling qualities in case the flightcrew does not take suitable recovery action in time to prevent stalling. Compliance with the stall characteristics requirements of § 25.203 would be required for stalls demonstrated using a one knot per second deceleration rate.
Earlier, we stated that in most cases, flight in icing conditions before activation of the icing system is expected to be relatively brief. However, if the means of detecting icing conditions and activating the ice protection system depends on the flightcrew visually identifying a discrete amount of ice on a reference surface (for example, one-quarter-inch of ice on the wing's leading edge), then this temporary condition may be of a relatively long duration. Therefore, we consider it appropriate to apply the same requirements for stall warning to this case as are applied to the case of flight in icing conditions after the ice protection system is fully active. For this case, we propose that the stall warning indication must be provided by the same means as in non-icing conditions. Proposed paragraph (h)(1) contains this requirement.
The FTHWG determined that applying the existing stall warning margin requirements of § 25.207(c) and (d) to icing conditions would be far more stringent than best current practices and would unduly penalize designs that have not exhibited safety problems in icing conditions. The FTHWG examined whether the stall warning requirements of existing § 25.207(c) and (d) could be made less stringent for icing conditions without compromising safety. The proposed § 25.207(e) resulted from this effort.
In developing the proposed § 25.207(e), the FTHWG determined that the types of transport category airplanes involved in icing-related stall accidents:
• Were equipped with deicing boots that operated cyclically (for example, a boot cycle every one to three minutes), and
• Were generally very susceptible to large affects on stall speeds from ice accretions during the periods between boot cycles (known as intercycle ice).
The proposed criteria of § 25.207(e), in combination with the proposed § 25.207(b), would likely require different stall warning system settings for icing conditions and non-icing conditions on future airplanes with those characteristics. These proposals would have a lesser impact on airplanes without those characteristics. The stall warning settings established for the airplane without ice accretions may be retained for operation in icing conditions, provided they are still adequate to prevent stalling if the pilot does not take any action to recover until three seconds after the initiation of stall warning. Since all modern conventional transport category airplanes use some type of artificial stall warning system (stick shaker or combined aural and visual warning), and since three seconds is considered adequate time for response by a trained pilot, we agree with the FTHWG that this stall warning definition would be acceptable for icing conditions.
The proposed revision of § 25.207(f) would require the pilot to use the same stall recovery maneuver during the compliance demonstration for icing conditions as is used for non-icing conditions. This proposal is based on human factors considerations. In operational service, pilots would not be expected to respond differently to a stall warning indication in icing conditions versus non-icing conditions.
L. Wind Velocities (§ 25.237)
L. Wind Velocities (§ 25.237)
The proposed revisions to § 25.237(a) would add a requirement to establish a safe landing crosswind component for use in icing conditions. The proposed revision to paragraph (a) also would state that the crosswind component established for takeoff without ice accretions may be used for takeoffs conducted in icing conditions.
For taking off in crosswinds, we consider it unnecessary to consider the effect of ice accretions since these proposals assume that ice accretions do not begin until liftoff. Therefore, airplanes will accrete very little ice, if any, while close to the ground where crosswinds are a significant safety concern. Proposed § 25.237(a)(2) explicitly states that the takeoff crosswind component without icing is valid for icing conditions.
However, the conditions on landing are different. Before landing, the airplane may spend a significant amount of time exposed to icing conditions. These ice accretions may affect directional control when crosswinds are encountered close to the ground. As a result, (a)(3)(ii) requires evaluation of the landing crosswind component with ice accretion.
M. High-Speed Characteristics (§ 25.253)
M. High-Speed Characteristics (§ 25.253)
We propose to revise § 25.253 by adding a new paragraph (c) to define the maximum speed for stability characteristics, VFC/ MFC, for icing conditions. The proposal would permit applicants to define a VFC/MFC for icing conditions that is different than the VFC/MFC defined for non-icing conditions. Additionally, § 25.253(b) would be revised to refer to § 25.143(g) rather than § 25.143(f) due to the proposed renumbering of § 25.143.
VFC/MFC is the highest speed at which compliance with several airplane handling qualities requirements must be shown. The FTHWG's review of historical certification data showed that none of the flight tests for airplane handling qualities performed with ice accretions were conducted above 300 knots CAS. The air loads associated with such high speeds tend to make it difficult to keep either artificial or natural ice attached to the airframe to accomplish the testing. It also minimizes the possibility of encountering this condition in operational service. Therefore, we propose that the maximum speed for demonstrating stability characteristics with ice accretions is the lower of VFC, 300 KCAS, or any other speed at which it can be shown that the airframe will be free of ice.
N. Pilot Compartment View (§ 25.773)
N. Pilot Compartment View (§ 25.773)
We propose to revise § 25.773(b)(1)(ii) to replace the phrase "if certification with ice protection provisions is requested" with "if certification for flight in icing conditions is requested."
The proposed change is necessary to be consistent with the proposed change to § 25.1419. As discussed in the reason for revising § 25.1419, compliance with icing-related safety of flight requirements should depend on whether the airplane would be approved to operate in icing conditions, not on whether the airplane has approved ice protection provisions installed.
O. Inlet, Engine, and Exhaust Compatibility (§ 25.941)
O. Inlet, Engine, and Exhaust Compatibility (§ 25.941)
We propose to revise the references to Sec. § 25.143(c), (d), and (e), contained in paragraph (c) of § 25.941, to read § 25.143(d), (e), and (f).
The proposed changes are necessary to maintain references to the correct paragraphs of § 25.143 if the changes to § 25.143 being proposed by this rulemaking are adopted.
P. Ice Protection (§ 25.1419)
P. Ice Protection (§ 25.1419)
We propose to revise the introductory text of § 25.1419 to replace the phrase, "If certification with ice protection provisions is desired * * *" with "If certification for flight in icing conditions is desired * * *" The current rule requires an applicant to demonstrate an airplane's ability to safely operate in icing conditions only when the applicant is seeking to certificate ice protection features. It fails to address certification approval for flight in icing conditions for airplanes without ice protection features. The proposed revision, which would adopt the existing wording from JAR 25.1419, would require an applicant to demonstrate the airplane's ability to safely operate in icing conditions whenever the applicant is seeking approval for flight in icing conditions.
We also propose to simplify the second sentence of § 25.1419 to remove redundant wording. This change is editorial in nature and is not intended to change the requirement in any way.
We propose to amend § 25.1419 to incorporate the revised introductory text for the following reasons:
• A literal reading of the current § 25.1419 wording could imply that the applicant does not have to demonstrate that the airplane can be safely operated in icing conditions unless an ice protection system is installed.
• The revised text would clarify that any airplane approved to fly in icing conditions must be capable of operating in the icing conditions of appendix C of part 25 regardless of whether or not the airplane has an ice protection system.
Q. Part 25, Appendix C
Q. Part 25, Appendix C
We propose to revise appendix C of part 25 to create two subsections: Part I to define the atmospheric icing conditions that must be considered when showing compliance with the icing-related requirements of part 25, and part II to define ice accretions for each phase of flight. We also propose to add a definition of the atmospheric icing conditions to use specifically for the takeoff phase of flight.
Proposed Appendix C, Part I
Proposed Appendix C, Part I
Proposed appendix C, part I would contain the existing appendix C definitions of atmospheric icing conditions. We propose adding a definition of "takeoff maximum icing," which is to be used in determining ice accretions for the takeoff phase of flight. Proposed Appendix C, Part II
Proposed appendix C, part II(a) would contain definitions of the ice accretions appropriate to each phase of flight. Proposed appendix C, part II(b) would provide options for reducing the number of ice accretions to be considered for each phase of flight. Proposed appendix C, part II(c) would permit applicants to use, for the airplane performance tests, the same ice accretion used for evaluating handling characteristics. Proposed appendix C, part II(d) would define the conditions for determining the ice accretions for the takeoff phase of flight. Proposed appendix C, part II(e) would define what ice accretion must be considered prior to normal ice protection system operation.
One early concern with developing appropriate airplane performance and handling qualities requirements for the takeoff phase of flight was the atmospheric icing environment close to the ground. The FTHWG members expressed significant concerns with using the existing appendix C atmospheric icing envelopes for this purpose. The FAA meteorologists confirmed that the existing appendix C atmospheric envelopes are not generally representative of icing conditions close to the ground.
In general, for determining the size, shape, location, and texture of ice accretions on the airplane, one needs information about the atmospheric icing environment, i.e., icing cloud size, cloud liquid water content, water droplet size, expressed in terms of the mean effective diameter of the droplets, and ambient air temperature.
We propose to use the following definition of atmospheric icing conditions for takeoff maximum icing conditions in appendix C, part I(e): An icing cloud extending from ground level to a height of 1,500 feet above the takeoff surface with a liquid water content of 0.35 grams/meter 3, water droplets with a mean effective diameter of 20 microns, and an ambient temperature of minus 9 degrees Celsius (- 9° C). The following discussion presents the reasons for selecting these values.
Since the takeoff phase of flight is relatively short, generally ending at a height of 1,500 feet above the takeoff surface (ref. § 25.111(a)), we consider it reasonable to assume that the entire takeoff phase could be flown within the same icing cloud. Therefore, we propose that the takeoff maximum icing conditions would extend from ground level to a height of 1,500 feet above the level of the takeoff surface.
Although measured data for liquid water content at low altitudes are sparse, a comparison of data contained in the FAA Technical Center's database on inflight icing conditions with theoretical predictions suggest a maximum liquid water content within the icing cloud of 0.35 grams/meter 3 from ground level up to 1,500 feet. We propose to use this value within the definition of the maximum takeoff icing conditions. This proposed value would also cover the potential for dense ground fog at freezing temperatures, which our meteorologists stated would expose the airplane to a liquid water content of approximately 0.30 grams/meter 3.
For the size of the water droplets, both industry and FAA icing specialists concurred that a mean effective diameter of 20 microns would be appropriate for icing conditions occurring near ground level. We propose to use this value within the definition of the maximum takeoff icing conditions.
Selection of the ambient temperature for takeoff icing was based on theoretical predictions that showed the effect of temperature to decrease significantly as the temperature itself decreased. We propose to use an ambient temperature for the takeoff icing atmosphere of minus 9 degrees Celsius (-9° C), the point at which any further decrease in temperature had a negligible effect on the resulting ice accretion.
According to our meteorologists, the amount of water vapor that can be held without condensing in a given volume of space depends only on the temperature of the gas (water vapor, air, etc.) in that space. It does not vary with altitude. Therefore, the proposed takeoff icing atmosphere would be equally applicable to all airport runway elevations.
Proposed part II(a) references specific phases of flight and defines the critical ice accretions associated with the specific phase of flight. In the main body of the rule, various sections require evaluation using the ice accretion defined in appendix C. Proposed part II(a) contains those definitions. For example, § 25.125(a)(1) requires evaluation of landing distance using the ice accretion defined in appendix C. To perform the evaluation required by § 25.125(a)(1), an applicant would use the landing ice definition found in paragraph (5) of this section.
To reduce the number of artificial ice accretions that must be considered, proposed part II(b) would permit the ice accretion determined for one flight phase to be used in showing compliance with the flight requirements of another phase, provided the applicant can show it has a more critical effect on the flight parameter being evaluated. For example, using the ice accretion determined for the holding phase to show compliance with the requirements for the takeoff phase will generally have a larger effect on performance and therefore be more penalizing than using an ice accretion determined specifically for the takeoff phase.
Proposed part II(c) clarifies that the ice accretion with the most adverse effect on handling qualities may also be used during the flight test demonstrations of performance as long as any performance differences are conservatively taken into account. This proposed section is consistent with the intent behind proposed part II(b) to reduce the number of ice accretions that must be considered. Unlike handling qualities, performance effects between relatively small differences in ice accretion generally can be addressed adequately through analysis.
Proposed part II(d) states the assumptions under which the takeoff ice accretions are determined. Proposed part II(d) also states that it must be assumed that the crew does not take any action to activate the ice protection system until the airplane is at least 400 feet above the takeoff surface. This requirement is consistent with the existing requirement of § 25.111(c)(4) that limits the types of configuration changes requiring crew action before reaching 400 feet above the takeoff surface.
We consider it necessary to also take into account the effects of any ice accretion that may form on the airplane from the time the airplane enters icing conditions until the ice protection system is activated and is performing its intended function. The size, shape, location, and texture of this ice accretion will depend on: (1) The means used to identify that the airplane is in icing conditions (for example, the pilot seeing ice accreting on the airplane, an ice detector, a combination of freezing temperatures and visible moisture), (2) the means and procedures for activating the ice protection system (for example, the pilot manually activating the system after a specified amount of ice builds up or automatic activation), and (3) the system characteristics (for example, the time it takes to effectively remove the ice). We propose to define the ice accretion applicable to the time period before the ice protection system has been activated and is performing its intended function as a period of time in the continuous maximum icing conditions of proposed part I of appendix C, including:
• The time for recognition,
• A delay time appropriate to the means of ice detection and activation of the ice protection system, and
• The time needed for the ice protection system to perform its intended function after manual or automatic activation.
III. Discussion of Non-Consensus Issues
III. Discussion of Non-Consensus Issues
One of the goals of the ARAC process is consensus on the proposed recommendations. Due to the variety of interests represented in the FTHWG, this goal was not fully achieved. The areas of non-consensus, however, were confined to specific details within the proposals, and not to the overall need to amend part 25 to address airplane performance and handling qualities in icing conditions. The issues for which full consensus was not achieved within the FTHWG were:
1. The requirement that a push force must be needed throughout the pushover maneuver proposed in the new § 25.143(i)(2);
2. Whether the test to evaluate longitudinal handling qualities during sideslip maneuvers should be required by regulation as proposed in the new § 25.143(i)(3), or should only be included in advisory material as one means of showing compliance;
3. Whether the same airplane performance and handling qualities requirements (Sec. § 25.143(j) and 25.207(h)) should always apply whenever the means to activate the ice protection system depends on the pilot to visually identify when the airplane is in icing conditions; and
4. Whether the proposed revision to appendix C adequately ensures that the full range of variables are considered in determining what the critical ice accretion is for a particular flight phase.
Each of these non-consensus issues is discussed in more detail below.
A. Non-Consensus Issue 1--§ 25.143(i)(2)
A. Non-Consensus Issue 1--§ 25.143(i)(2)
The FTHWG did not reach a consensus on the issue of requiring a push force throughout the maneuver down to a zero g load factor (or the lowest load factor obtainable if limited by elevator power). Although there was consensus that the test maneuver should be performed to zero g, the group did not reach a consensus on whether the pilot should be required to apply a push force to the longitudinal control system throughout the maneuver until a zero g load factor is attained. The FTHWG considered two alternatives.
Alternative 1 was developed by FTHWG members who did not support our proposal of requiring a push force to be maintained down to zero g load factor in the pushover maneuver. These FTHWG members disagreed with the proposal for the following reasons:
• Historically, the pushover test was performed to a 0.5 g load factor rather than zero g. For example, as practiced by Transport Canada (the Canadian airworthiness regulatory authority), this demonstration was done with a high pitch rate. Consequently, there was significant overshoot of the 0.5 g load factor, down to approximately 0.25 g or less. This maneuver was intended to be a controllability test beginning with the pilot abruptly pushing on the control column to achieve a high nose-down pitch rate, followed by a pull to recover. The intent was not to reach a specific g level below 0.5 g, but to show that the pilot could perform a satisfactory recovery. This has proven to be an acceptable test technique. To date, airplanes evaluated with this technique have had a satisfactory safety record in service.
• Since the beginning of the 1980s, the practice of many certification authorities has been to require testing to lower load factors. This evolved until the introduction of the JAA's NPA 25F-219, which not only requires testing to zero g, but also requires a push force throughout the maneuver to zero g. A zero-g pushover is considered to be an improbable condition, going well beyond any operational maneuver, and does not properly represent gusts, pitch rate, elevator position, or other factors that may contribute to tailplane stalls. Also, since the NPA requirement was developed for a specific turboprop, and motivated by service experience on turboprop airplanes, other requirements were proposed for other types of airplanes.
For the above reasons, the supporters of alternative 1 to § 25.143(i)(2) consider that requiring a push force to load factors as low as zero g is excessive. Instead, they recommend replacing proposed § 25.143(i)(2) with:
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 215 passages shown