AC 25.562-1B Dynamic Evaluation of Seat Restraint Systems and Occupant Protection on Transport Airplanes / with Change 1
This advisory circular (AC) provides information and guidance regarding acceptable means of compliance with the requirements of 14 CFR part 25 applicable to dynamic testing of seats. The AC provides background and discussion of the reasoning behind the test procedures. It also describes the test facilities and equipment necessary to conduct the tests.
AC 25.562-1B CHANGE 1 › 2. PRINCIPAL CHANGES
Advisory U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Circular Administration
Subject: Dynamic Evaluation of S eat Restraint Date: AC No: 25.562-1B Systems and Occupant Protection on Transport Initiated By: ANM-115 Change: 1 Airplanes
1. PURPOSE.
a. This change removes guidance in paragraph 5e(5)(d) of AC 25.562-1B, which allowed certain methods for showing compliance with the head injury criterion (HIC) required by Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) 25.562(c)(5). These methods were issued in error and have resulted in conditions where the full required range of occupants might not have the same level of head injury protection. These methods also conflict with Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Policy Memorandum ANM-115-05-14, Policy Statement on Acceptable Methods of Compliance with § 25.562(c)(5) for Front Row Passenger Seats, dated December 14, 2005, for showing compliance with HIC for front row seats. This change eliminates that conflict. An acceptable simplified method for a showing of compliance with HIC for row-to-row seats continues to be the method described in Appendix 4 of this advisory circular (AC) and our policy. We have also added a note for front row seats clarifying how to apply guidance for the 42"/45" setback criteria. Further, we have deleted a reference to canceled AC 25-17 that is no longer relevant and fixed typographical errors within the AC.
b. This change also clarifies applicability of Appendix 4 to seats containing upper torso restraints and airbags; clarifies the range of yaw angles that an applicant should address; and adds guidance for front row seats.
2. PRINCIPAL CHANGES. Change 1 updates AC 25.562-1B, Dynamic Evaluation of Seat Restraint Systems and Occupant Protection on Transport Airplanes, dated January 10, 2006. We have added the change number and date of revision at the top of each changed page. We have also marked the changes with a vertical change bar in the margin. Specifically, Change 1 incorporates the following changes:
a. Corrects the figure references in Steps 3 and 3d under paragraph 5d(1).
b. Corrects typographical errors in the second question of Figure 5-2. We also redesigned the figure to improve readability.
09/30/15 AC 25.562-1B CHG 1
c. Adds guidance for upper torso restraints and airbags to the end of paragraph 5e(5)(a) and paragraph 1 of Appendix 4.
d. Clarifies guidance on the range of yaw angles and specifies that a solid strike must be used to show compliance for the range of occupants in paragraph 5e(5)(b).
e. Deletes paragraph 5e(5)(d) and the bulleted list of items that follow it. This is the change that removes the erroneous guidance.
f. Redesignates paragraph 5e(5)(e) as paragraph 5e(5)(d).
g. Adds guidance for limiting the range of occupants to the end of redesignated paragraph 5e(5)(d).
h. Adds new paragraph 5e(5)(d)1 for a test with bulkhead method and glancing blow acceptance.
i. Redesignates the two bulleted paragraphs under paragraph 5e(5)(e) as paragraphs 5e(5)(d)2 and 5e(5)(d)3, respectively.
j. Adds a reference to redesignated paragraph 5e(5)(d)2 specifying where in the AC one can find additional guidance.
k. Deletes the last sentence of redesignated paragraph 5e(5)(d)2.
l. Adds a note under redesignated paragraph 5e(5)(d)2.
m. Corrects the figure reference in paragraph 6e.
n. Corrects the figure reference in paragraph 9c(5)(a)1 and 2.
o. Corrects the figure references in paragraph 10e(3).
p. Corrects a typographical error in paragraph 11b(2) of Appendix 3.
q. Corrects a typographical error in paragraph 11c of Appendix 3.
AC 25.562-1B CHG 1 09/30115
Page Control Chart
Remove Pages Dated Insert Pages Dated
12 … 01/10/2006 12 … 09/30/15
14 … 01/10/2006 14 … 09/30/15
19 through 23 … 01110/2006 19 through 23 … 09/30/15
35 … 01/10/2006 35 ··············································· 09/30/15 42 … 01/10/2006 42 … 09/30/15
74 and 75 … 01/10/2006 74 and 75 … 09/30/15
86 … 01/10/2006 86 … 09/30/15
If you have suggestions for improving this AC, you may use the Advisory Circular Feedback form at the end of this AC.
Jeffrey E. Duven Manager, Transport Airplane Directorate Aircraft Certification Service
3. CANCELLATION
Picture of the FAA logo.Advisory Circular
Subject: Dynamic Evaluation of Seat Date: 01/10/06 AC No: 25.562-1B Restraint Systems and Occupant Initiated by: ANM-110 Protection on Transport Airplanes
1. PURPOSE. This advisory circular (AC) provides information and guidance regarding acceptable means of compliance with the requirements of 14 CFR part 25 applicable to dynamic testing of seats. The AC provides background and discussion of the reasoning behind the test procedures. It also describes the test facilities and equipment necessary to conduct the tests.
2. APPLICABILITY.
a. The guidance provided in this document is directed to airplane manufacturers, modifiers, foreign regulatory authorities, Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) transport airplane type certification engineers, and FAA designees.
b. This material is neither mandatory nor regulatory in nature and does not constitute a regulation. It describes acceptable means, but not the only means, for demonstrating compliance with the applicable regulations. The FAA will consider other methods of demonstrating compliance that an applicant may elect to present While these guidelines are not mandatory, they are derived from extensive FAA and industry experience in determining compliance with the relevant regulations. On the other hand, if we become aware of circumstances that convince us that following this AC would not result in compliance with the applicable regulations, we will not be bound by the terms of this AC, and we may require additional substantiation or design changes as a basis for finding compliance.
c. This material does not change or create any additional regulatory requirements nor does it authorize changes in, or permit deviations from, existing regulatory requirements.
3. CANCELLATION. Advisory Circular 25.562-1A, dated 01/19/96, is canceled.
4. RELATED REGULATIONS
4. RELATED REGULATIONS. Sections 25.562, 25.785, 25.787, and 25.789 of Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations.
Ali Bahrami Manager Transport Airplane Directorate Aircraft Certification Service
ii
a. General
e. Injury Criteria f. Deformation for Egress
a. General
CONTENTS
SECTION PAGE
CONTENTS
1. DEFINITIONS 1
2. DISCUSSION 2 a. Intent of Tests 2 b. Standardized Test Procedures—Reasons and Practicalities 2 c. Standardized Test Procedures—Relationship to Design 2
3. TEST CONDITIONS 4 a. General 4 b. Consideration of Test Criteria 7
4. TEST ARTICLES 8 8 b. Critical Components 8 c. Family of Seats 9
5. TEST ARTICLE SELECTION AND RELATED TEST SETUP 10 a. General 10 b. Criteria for Selection 11 c. Family of Seats 11 d. Structural Tests 11 16 20
6. TEST FACILITIES 21 a. General 21 b. Deceleration Sled Facilities 21 c. Acceleration Sled Facilities 22 d. Impact-with-rebound Sled Facilities 23 e. Drop Towers 23
7. ANTHROPOMORPHIC TEST DEVICES 24 a. General 24 b. Modification to Measure Pelvic/Lumbar Load 24 c. Other ATD Modifications 25 d. Equivalent ATDs 26
8. INSTRUMENTATION 26 26 b. Electronic Instrumentation 27 c. Photographic Instrumentation 28
iii
9. TEST FIXTURES 29 a. General 29 b. Floor Deformation 29 c. Other Mounting Configuration Constraints 31 d. Side-facing Seats 38 e. Multiple Row Test Fixtures 38 f. Other Fixture Applications 39
10. TEST PREPARATION 39 a. Preparation for the Tests 39 b. Use of Anthropomorphic Dummies 39 c. Seat Adjustment 40 d. Installation of Instrumentation 40 e. Restraint System Adjustment 41 f. Floor Requirement 42 g. Seat Components 42
11. DATA REQUIREMENTS 45
12. DATA ANALYSIS 45 a. General 45 b. Impact Pulse Shape 46 c. Total Velocity Change 47 d. Head Injury Criterion (HIC) 47 e. Upper Torso Restraint System Load 48 f. Compressive Load Between the Pelvis and Lumbar Column 48 g. Retention of Upper Torso Restraint Straps 49 h. Retention of Pelvic Restraint 49 i. Femur Load 49
13. PASS/FAIL CRITERIA 49
14. TEST FAILURES VS. RETEST 50
15. TEST DOCUMENTATION 51 a. General 51 b. Test Description 52
16. COMPUTER MODELS 53
iv
FIGURES
APPENDICES
APPENDIX 1 – PROCEDURES FOR EVALUATING PULSE SHAPES 55
APPENDIX 2 – SEAT DEFORMATION 60
APPENDIX 3 – SEAT FAMILY DEFINITION 64
APPENDIX 4 – DEMONSTRATING COMPLIANCE WITH HIC FOR 86 REPETITIVE SEAT ROWS
APPENDIX 5 – SUBSTANTIATING RETENTION OF ITEMS ATTACHED 94 TO SEATS
FIGURES
Figure 3-1 – Seat/Restraint System Dynamic Tests 6
Figure 5-1 – Decision Chart – 16g Test 13
Figure 5-2 – Structural Test Article Decision Tree for Seat Family 14
Figure 5-3 – Restraint Trailing Occupant 18
Figure 7-1 – Installation of Pelvic-Lumbar Load Cell in Part 572B ATD 25
Figure 9-1 – Schematic Floor Deformation Fixture – Seat Legs Attached 30 at Floor Level
Figure 9-2 – Floor Warpage Multiple Leg Seat 32
Figure 9-3 – Floor Warpage Multiple Leg Seat 33
Figure 9-4 – Schematic Floor Deformation Fixture – Seat Legs Attached 36 at Side Wall
Figure 9-5 – Seats Mounted in an Aisle 37
Figure 10-1 – Measurement of 1g Pre-load 43
Figure 10-2 – Test Orientation, 1g Position 44
v
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
vi
1. DEFINITIONS
1. DEFINITIONS. The following definitions apply to the terms used in this AC. These terms may be used in other documents with different meanings and should, therefore, be verified in the context of those documents.
Anthropomorphic Test Device (ATD)—A device—sometimes called a test “dummy”— used to provide realistic dynamic response representing that of a human.
Baseline Testing—The initial series of tests performed as part of the original certification to substantiate that a family of seats meets regulatory requirements.
Energy Absorbing Device—An energy dissipating element of a seat which is load-rate or peak-load sensitive.
Energy Absorber “Bottom-Out”—The energy absorber “bottoms out” when it reaches its maximum stroke and no longer provides an energy absorption function.
Energy Absorber Rating—The load required to actuate the energy-absorbing device. The “highest rated” energy-absorbing device would be the device that requires the highest load to initiate.
Family of Seats—A group of seat assemblies, regardless of the number of seat places, built from equivalent components in the primary load path. See paragraph 4c and Appendix 3 for an expanded discussion.
Instability Failure—An instantaneous loss of the load-carrying capability of a structural member (for example, the collapse of a column).
Occupant Position—The static relationship of the occupant relative to fixed points on the seat. This is assessed using the Seat Reference Point (SRP), as defined in Society of Automotive Engineers Aerospace Standard AS8049 Revision A.
Rational Analysis—An analysis based on good engineering principles, judgment, and/or accepted methodology. This can include, but is not limited to, static/dynamic load comparison, static strength analysis, comparative static/dynamic strength analysis, linear static and non-linear finite element analysis, and inspection.
Seat Primary Load Path—The components within the seat that carry the load from the point of load application to the structure that reacts the load from the seat system or subsystem. The primary load path may be segmented into its discrete elements, depending on the parameter being evaluated, as follows:
• Structural: from seat belt to fittings which attach the seat system to the airplane structure. • Lumbar: from bottom cushion to fittings which attach the seat system to the airplane structure.
2. DISCUSSION
• Row-to Row Head Injury Criterion (HIC): from point of ATD head contact to the attachment of seat primary structure. • Head Path (for example, front row or large pitch seats): same as structural.
Similar Design Philosophy - A design which uses the same:
• Method of construction and manufacturing process (for example, machined part versus built-up part), • Detail part materials (for example, alloys or heat treat), • Load path, • Geometry, including section properties, except for minor differences resulting from space limitations within the seat or aircraft interface, and • Attachment method, except for minor differences resulting from space limitations within the seat
Typically—to be considered “minor”—differences to the geometry and attachment method must be shown to be equivalent to or less critical than the seat tested during “baseline testing” with regard to strength, stiffness, and seat permanent deformation.
2. DISCUSSION.
a. Intent of Tests. The intent of the tests is to evaluate airplane seats, restraints, and related interior systems in order to demonstrate their structural strength and their ability to protect an occupant from serious injuries in a survivable crash. For example, the potential for serious head injury, which is influenced by head strike envelopes and seat pitch, is assessed in the tests. A standardized methodology for making head impact injury assessments is provided in Appendix 4. This methodology should minimize the amount of testing required.
b. Standardized Test Procedures—Reason and Practicalities. The tests described in this AC are standardized procedures generally regarded as the minimum necessary to demonstrate compliance. Standardized procedures seek to obtain consistent results between different test facilities. These facilities may be of varying types, as described in paragraph 6. Often they are not under the direct control of the designer or manufacturer of the article under test, and they may be primarily dedicated to testing which is not related to the aerospace industry. To foster industry standardization, this AC describes many of the procedures and evaluations that are already accepted as standards by government and commercial test facilities. These procedures have been modified only as necessary for the specific testing of civil airplane systems.
c. Standardized Test Procedures—Relationship to Design. As stated above, the tests are standardized by necessity. However, the seat/restraint should be designed to protect the occupant under all conditions within the impact envelope specified in § 25.562.
(1) Occupant representation. The dynamic tests are performed with an anthropomorphic test device (ATD)—representing approximately the 50th percentile male occupant—in accordance with 49 CFR part 572.
(a) Occupant Weight. Although the basic structural capability of the seat/restraint system is not demonstrated for occupants of other weights, substantiating the seat using the 50th percentile ATD protects the widest range of occupants. Seats that are optimized for occupants at either extreme would have stiffness characteristics that would be incompatible with occupant mass at the other extreme. That is, such seats would either be too stiff to absorb energy for lighter occupants or too flexible to provide protection for heavier occupants.
(b) Occupant Size (dimensions). The seat should not be point-designed around the 50th percentile occupant size. The designer should consider other design factors that are directly influenced by occupant size, such as energy absorbing systems, restraint system design and anchorage locations, and seat adjustments.
(2) Test conditions. This AC describes two basic types of dynamic test procedures (see Figure 3-1): a test where the predominant impact vector is vertical and a test where the dominant impact vector is horizontal. These procedures address the tests required to demonstrate compliance for one seat and restraint system installation. Typical use of a seat model on a particular airplane will involve variations of seat design and installation. Additional tests may be necessary to demonstrate compliance for these variations, if they cannot be adequately addressed by analysis. This point is discussed at length in paragraph 5, and a methodology for establishing a seat “family” is described in Appendix 3.
(3) Pre-test floor deformation. For certain structural evaluations, the test procedure requires that the seat/floor interface should be deformed. This procedure provides a measure of the seat’s ability to deform and absorb energy during an impact. The seat and restraint system should also perform properly, if the floor remains undeformed.
Figure 3-1 · page 15Picture of the page from the copy saved here
(4) Head impact. Occupant head impact with the interior of the airplane is evaluated by using a Head Injury Criterion (HIC) that can be measured directly in the tests described in this AC or in alternative tests. The HIC is measured on the most critical surface within the ±10 degrees yaw envelope (measurement of the HIC does not supersede the requirements of § 25.785, which may have a different head strike envelope than § 25.562). The HIC does not evaluate injuries that occur at low impact velocities from contact with surfaces having small contact areas or sharp edges, especially if those surfaces are relatively rigid. These types of injuries require assessment in accordance with § 25.785.
(5) Femur injury. Extensive seat testing has shown that the femur loading criterion is not exceeded when seats are tested in accordance with the conditions defined in this AC. For this reason, the femur loads need not be recorded in the individual test, if
3. TEST CONDITIONS
compliance can be shown by rational, comparative analysis using data from previous tests.
NOTE: There may be several other aspects of the standardized test procedure that need to be considered when determining the test program required to demonstrate compliance or interpret the test results. The extent of the test program will depend on the most critical case determination and its applicability to other configurations. Further discussion on this aspect of testing is provided in paragraph 5.
3. TEST CONDITIONS
a. General. A minimum of two dynamic tests is required to assess the performance of an airplane seat, restraints, and related interior system. The seat, the restraint, and the nearby interior are all considered to act together to provide protection to the occupant during a crash. For side-facing seats, there may be additional criteria necessary to determine that the seats provide the level of safety intended by § 25.562. (See paragraph 9d for additional considerations regarding side-facing seats.)
(1) Test 1 (Figure 3-1), as a single row seat test, determines the performance of the system in a test condition where the predominant impact force component is along the spinal column of the occupant in combination with a forward impact force component. This test evaluates the structural adequacy of the seat, critical pelvic/lumbar column forces, and permanent deformation of the structure under combined downward and forward impact loading. The test may also yield data on ATD head displacement, velocity, and acceleration time histories.
(2) Test 2 (Figure 3-1), as a single row seat test, determines the performance of a system in a test condition where the predominant impact force component is along the longitudinal axis of the airplane in combination with a lateral impact force component. This test evaluates the structural adequacy of the seat, and permanent deformation of the structure. It also evaluates behavior and loads of the pelvic restraint and, if applicable, of the upper torso restraint. The test may also yield data on ATD head displacement, velocity, and acceleration time histories as well as the seat leg loads imposed on the seat tracks or attachment fittings.
This test requires simulating deformation between the seat and airplane floor by deforming the test fixture, as respectively prescribed in Figures 6 and 7 for single occupant and multiple occupant seats, prior to applying the dynamic impact conditions. The purpose is to demonstrate that the seat/restraint system will remain attached to the airframe and perform properly, even though the airplane and/or seat are deformed by the forces associated with a crash.
(3) For seats placed in repetitive rows, an additional test condition using two seats in tandem placed at representative fore and aft distance between the seats (seat pitch) directly evaluates injury of the head and femur. This test is similar to Test 2 with
or without the floor deformation. (Floor deformation is required, if the test also demonstrates structural performance.) These injury criteria are dependent on seat pitch, seat positions occupied, and the effect of hard structures within the path of head excursions in the ±10 degrees yaw attitude range of the Test 2 conditions. See Appendix 4 for a standardized procedure for evaluating row-to-row head impact.
NOTE: It may be possible to evaluate the HIC using alternative tests. Specific methodologies will require acceptance for certification. (See paragraph 12d.)
Test 1 Test 2 Illustration shows a 100 forward facing seat Inertial load shown by arrow 300 Yaw Right or Left
Min V1 m/s (ft./s) 10.67 (35) 13.41 (44) Max t, s 0.08 0.09 Min G 14 16 Deform Floor Degrees Roll 0 10
Degrees pitch 0 10
Time 0 t1 Test Pulse simulating 0 Aircraft Floor Deceleration -Time History
Deceleration
G
t1=Rise time The ideal pulse is a symmetrical isosceles triangle V1= Impact velocity
Figure 3-1. Seat/Restraint System Dynamic Tests
b. Consideration of Test Criteria. The tests should be planned to achieve the “most critical” conditions for the criteria to be evaluated during each test. Philosophically, the objective of the requirement is to test the critical structural configuration (that is, the seat with the critically stressed components in the primary load path). The primary structural load path and other components that influence occupant injury criteria (for example, HIC or shoulder restraint retention) are evaluated to generate the baseline certification tests. As much as practical, all pass/fail criteria should be assessed during tests that are conducted to show seat structural compliance. Additional structural tests should not be generated to evaluate parts of the seat that are not in the primary load path or do not influence occupant injury criteria. (For example, a dynamic test would not be conducted to specifically evaluate the most critical load on a baggage bar if that is different from the most critical test for the seat structure.)
(1) For multiple place seats, a rational structural analysis is used to determine the number and seat location for the ATDs and the direction for seat yaw in Test 2 to provide the most critical seat structural test. (A detailed procedure is provided in paragraph 5.) The floor deformation procedure should be selected to increase the load on the highest loaded seat leg and to load the floor track or fitting in the most severe manner. However, a special procedure has been provided, as discussed in paragraph 9c(2), to account for seats that have more than two pairs of legs.
(2) If multiple-row testing is used to gather data to assess head and femur injury protection in passenger seats, the seat pitch must be selected so that the head would be most likely to contact hard structure in the forward seat row. The effect of the 10 degree yaw in Test 2 and the seat back breakover should be considered. (A detailed procedure is provided in Appendix 4.) Results from previous tests or rational analysis may be used to estimate the head strike path of similar seats in similar installations. The front row may be unoccupied.
(3) The separate requirements of §§ 25.562(c)(1) and (c)(3) can result in tests to address both directions of yaw. Section 25.562(b)(2) explicitly requires testing in the direction that would increase the likelihood that the occupant could come out of the restraint (typically over the trailing shoulder). Section 25.562(c)(1) requires assessment of the maximum upper torso restraint loads, which requires testing in the critical structural direction. However, experience has shown that most upper torso restraint geometries have good retention characteristics and can be justified on the basis of similarity to previously tested installations. Thus, if there are test data showing retention (belt over the trailing shoulder) that are applicable to the current installation, only the yaw direction for the critical structural test need be conducted for that installation. Occupant retention should be assessed during this test and the applicability of previous testing verified. In most cases this should be sufficient, and tests in both yaw directions would not be required.
4. TEST ARTICLES
(4) If a seat has vertical or horizontal adjustments, it is tested in the position that produces the most critical loads on the seat structure (typically the highest vertical position). Positions prohibited for takeoff and landing need not be considered. Seat adjustments that do not have a significant effect on structural loading (for example, thigh support angle, lumbar support, or armrest and headrest positions) are tested in the design positions for the 50th percentile male occupant, unless special requirements dictate the positions allowed for takeoff and landing. In addition, height adjustment should be relative to the interior envelope as it relates to the upper contour (ceiling) of the airplane whenever a specific seat design is approved in a particular airplane. For example, the seat need only be raised to the point where the head of the 50th percentile ATD contacts the upper portion of the airplane interior. Height adjustment to a level above the normal 50th percentile male location is intended to validate the strength of the seat and is not related to testing for a range of occupant sizes.
4. TEST ARTICLES.
a. General. In all cases, the test article must be representative of the final production article in all structural elements and must include the seat cushions, restraints, and armrests. It must also include a functioning position adjustment mechanism and correctly adjusted breakover (if present). Food trays or any other service items or accouterments that are part of the seat design must be representative of the final production item, if they influence seat stiffness or injury criteria. Otherwise, they and any other items of mass that are carried on or positioned by the seat structure need only be representative masses (see paragraph 10g). Examples include weights simulating luggage carried by luggage restraint bars [9.1 kilograms (20 lb) per passenger place], fire extinguishers, survival equipment, and emergency equipment. If these items of mass are placed in a position that could limit the function of an energy-absorbing feature in the test article, they should be of representative shape and stiffness as well as weight.
(1) If items of mass of any significance detach, they could become projectiles or impede evacuation. Detachment of certain items, such as an in-arm ashtray or decorative trim, can be considered inconsequential and should not be grounds for re-test. (The means of restraint should be improved, however.) In any case, detachment of an item of mass should not leave any sharp or injurious edges. Once retention of an item of mass has been demonstrated, subsequent tests may be conducted with the item secured for test purposes.
(2) Appendix 5 discusses means of compliance in greater detail. This AC does not establish operational requirements for equipment attached to the seat system. Function of equipment or systems after the test is not required.
b. Critical Components. Components that are critical to the performance of the seat should be assessed according to the test parameter(s) being investigated. What is critical for evaluation of seat structural performance may not be critical for an assessment of HIC. However, design changes made as a result of one performance parameter can
influence other performance parameters. The following summarizes critical elements relative to the assessment criteria.
(1) The primary load path for structural tests typically includes seat components, such as seat legs, lateral beams (cross tubes), spreaders, cushion supports and cushions, seatbelts and their attachments, attachments between structural members, seat track fittings, and energy absorbers. (Observe that energy-absorbers are normally integrated into the other seat components.) The strength and deformation responses of these members are evaluated during structural tests.
(2) The primary load path for lumbar load tests typically includes bottom cushions, bottom cushion supports, and lateral beams (cross tubes). Also part of this load path are seat legs, spreaders, attachments between structural members, seat track fittings, and energy absorbers.
(3) The primary load path for row-to-row HIC tests typically includes components in the seat assemblies, such as those installed on the seat back (for example, food tray tables, video monitors, and telephones), recline mechanism, breakover devices, seat back energy absorbers, seat back attachment hardware and, in some cases, arm rests.
(4) The primary load path for head/knee path tests is typically the same as that for the structural tests.
(5) Some components affect the positioning of the occupant in the seat place that in turn can influence ATD dynamic response and occupant injury criteria. Examples include seat bottom cushions, bottom cushion support, armrests, and seat backs.
c. Family of Seats.
(1) The concept of a family of seats is a design philosophy. A family of seats is a group of seat assemblies (regardless of the number of seat places) built from equivalent components in the primary load path. By definition, aft and side-facing seats are considered a separate family of seats from forward-facing seats. Most seats are, to some extent, part of a “family.” The intent of the family concept is to permit a simplified test article selection process. A group of seats can be designed either using the same design concept or as separate entities (non-family members). If the components in the seat design are carefully considered in advance, the baseline testing described in this document may substantiate the majority or all of the seat part numbers for compliance with § 25.562. Additional tests beyond the baseline may be required to substantiate variations in seat design that are beyond the basic family principles. In the context of Appendix 3, the procedures for substantiation depend on a rigorous definition of the “family” and are valid only if we adhere to that definition.
(2) The family of seats is defined based on design characteristics. Criticality assessments determine, in part, the scope of the test program within a family, not between families. Discussions of the definition of a family of seats and determinations of
structural criticality are intended to be complementary. Determinations of structural criticality assume that the family of seats has been established and that variations within the family will be substantiated either by tests or analysis. The decision whether to conduct tests or perform analysis is made based on the guidelines given, with the underlying assumption that such choices are made within a well-defined family of seats. Therefore, a comparison between families to establish that one design is more structurally critical than another is not addressed or recommended by this procedure and is not considered practical.
5. TEST ARTICLE SELECTION AND RELATED TEST SETUP
5. TEST ARTICLE SELECTION AND RELATED TEST SETUP.
a. General. Test articles are selected in order to create the critical case condition for the parameters being measured. As a minimum, the most highly stressed configuration is selected for the dynamic tests, so that other configurations could be accepted by comparison with that configuration. For the test article selection to be valid, there must be sufficient design commonality among the seats, so that testing one seat will qualify another. As previously mentioned, this approach is predicated on seats being part of a family of seats. However, the principles of test article selection are valid for individual seats as well as families of seats, so the procedures provided could be applied to a “family” consisting of only one seat. Test article selection for family design concepts is discussed in more detail in paragraphs 5.d. and 5 e. The following additional items should be considered in choosing test articles.
(1) If a multiple-place seat incorporates energy-absorbing or load-limiting features that are necessary to meet the test criteria or other requirements, a partially occupied seat may adversely affect the performance of that seat. In such a case, rational analysis or additional testing must show that the seat will continue to perform as intended, even with fewer occupants.
(2) Experience has shown that small details in the design often cause problems in meeting the test performance criteria. If different configurations of the same basic design of primary load-path members, especially joints or fasteners differ in detail design, the performance of each detail design should be demonstrated in a dynamic test.
(3) Additional dynamic impact testing may be required for a seat with features that could affect the non-structural performance criteria of § 25.562(c)(1-6), even though the test may not be the most critical case based on structural performance. For example, if in one of the design configurations, the restraint system attachment points are located so that the pelvic restraint is more likely to slip above the ATD's pelvis during the impact, that configuration should also be dynamically tested—even though the structural loading might be less than the critical configuration in a family of seats.
(4) Evaluation of typical dress cover materials, including synthetic fabrics, natural fabrics, and leather, has shown that the effect on test results is small, considering other factors such as occupant clothing. These typical materials can be used on a seat without testing more than one material or they can be substituted on an already
certificated seat. It is possible that some unusual seat surfaces that exhibit very low friction coefficients may require some additional substantiation. An unusual seat surface, for example, would be hard plastic.
(5) Test article selection (whether or not from the family of seats) is dependent on the installation and, in particular, on the seat track. Installation on a different seat track will require substantiation by test or rational analysis.
b. Criteria for Selection. The two main performance criteria used for test article selection are structural strength of the primary load path and injury criteria. In certain cases, emergency egress considerations may be necessary. For example, retention of a footrest may not be critical in the primary load path but could significantly impede egress at an exit if it were to deploy.
(1) Compliance with all parts of § 25.562 can be demonstrated with data obtained from tests using these selection criteria.
(2) To the extent possible, tests are conducted to maximize the amount of useable data and to address more than one performance criterion.
c. Family of Seats When a family of seats is identified using the procedures identified in Appendix 3, a test article selection process based on those procedures can be followed that will minimize the amount of testing required and maximize the usability of the data generated. This process is intended to be integrated with the seat design and not applied to seats post hoc in order to reduce testing once a program is completed or new designs are produced. However, assuming the family definition is robust, modifications to family members can be made or new models can be added to the family following the procedures given. Comparisons between seats in a family should always refer to a seat that was actually tested, rather than two seats that have not been tested. In principle, the seats that have been tested are determined to be critical for the parameters being measured, and any subsequent comparison should be made against the critical configuration. See Appendix 3 for a detailed discussion of the variation in design intended to be inclusive of a family using this process.
d. Structural Tests for seats with the family design concepts (see §§ 25.562(c)(7) and (8)).
(1) Substantiation of the 16g longitudinal load condition for each family of seats:
Step 1: Determine the 9g forward static interface loads (or any other standard load) for all seats. It is generally accepted that the interface loads calculated at 0° are sufficient to determine the most critical seat. Special seat design features may require interface load calculations that would take into account the aircraft tapered sections. All occupancy variations and combinations shall be considered for each seat (from unoccupied to fully occupied). The critical test case may be determined by analysis (Finite Element Method [FEM] or static interface loads) or by using test data.
09/30/15 AC 25.562-1B CHG 1
Step 2: Group the seats into two groups: Seats with two legs and seats with more than two legs.
Step 3: For each group of seats (see Figure 5-1):
Step 3a: Compare the aft fitting resultant loads of the seats within each group and identify the seat with the highest load. This seat will be tested.
Figure 5-1 · page 22Picture of the page from the copy saved here
Step 3b: Subgroup the seats by lateral leg spacing.
NOTE: For groups with more than two legs, there will be multiple lateral leg spacing. The sub-grouping of seats should be based on the leg-pair with the minimum lateral leg spacing.
Step 3c: Identify the subgroup with the minimum (narrowest) lateral leg spacing and identify the seat with the highest seat leg aft fitting resultant load within that subgroup.
Step 3d: If the aft fitting resultant load of the seat identified in step 3c (narrowest leg spacing) is greater than 80 percent of the highest load found on the seat selected for test in step 3a, then the seat identified in step 3c will also be tested, or a single test combining both conditions will be necessary. If the aft-fitting resultant load of the seat identified in step 3c (narrowest leg spacing) is less than 80 percent of the highest load found on the seat selected for test in step 3a, then this seat will only require static substantiation of its ability to tolerate floor deformation. (See Figure 5-2).
Figure 5-2 · page 23Picture of the page from the copy saved here
Step 3e: Conduct a 16g longitudinal dynamic test of each seat selected in steps 3a and 3d from each group. If the seats selected in steps 3a and 3d do not include the seat with the most critical beam load, that seat should be tested as well.
Step 3f: The occupancy that produced the highest calculated seat leg resultant tension reaction in the aft fitting is used for the test, unless the load of the fully occupied seat is within 10 percent of the highest seat leg load. Due to the statically indeterminate nature of seat structure, there are assumptions used to calculate interface loads, which will result in some uncertainty. Data indicate that calculated reactions within 10 percent of one another are effectively equivalent. In such cases, a fully occupied seat will impart an overall greater load than a partially occupied seat. Therefore, if the fully occupied seat leg load is within 10 percent of the highest loaded seat leg, test the seat fully occupied.
Step 3g: Select yaw, pitch, and roll for test setup.
NOTE: If any seat in the family is intended to be installed on canted seat tracks, the yaw angle for the test for those seats should be 10 degrees plus or minus the aircraft installation cant angle (if it is more critical) depending on which yaw angle maximizes the calculated reaction. (A test
yaw angle greater than the minimum required may be used to accommodate the test fixture adjustment capability.) Cant angles of 2 degrees or less may be neglected.
Step 3h: The mass of baggage, life vests, and literature pocket contents should be installed at each seat place, regardless of seat occupancy.
Step 3i: Retention of a specific item of mass, including emergency equipment, need only be demonstrated once during the 16g longitudinal load condition, if suitable retention using the production means of attachment is shown by dynamic test. The item of mass may be restrained for all other 16g longitudinal tests.
Family of Seats
More Than Two Legs
Narrowest Leg Spacing All Other Leg Spacings
Select Critical Seat(s)
16g Test
Group
Sub-Group
Two Leg Seats
Narrowest Leg Spacing All Other Leg Spacings
Select Critical Seat(s)
16g Test
Group
Sub-Group
See next figure
Figure 5-1. Decision Chart—16g Test
09/30/15 AC 25.562-1B CHG 1
Narrowest Spacing All Other Spacings
Determine the highest loaded leg.
Determine the highest loaded leg.
B Compare the highest loaded legs.
Is the seat with the narrowest spacing the one with the highest
loads in this
group?
NO
Does the seat with the narrowest leg spacing have an interface
load more than 80% of the
highest interface load of
this group?
NO
A
YES
YES
Test the seat
with the narrowest leg
spacing only.
Test both
OR Ballast/modify seat narrow leg spacing to make
it more critical.
C
D
Test the highest loaded leg
AND Perform a “pitch and roll” test on the seat with the narrowest
leg spacing.
Figure 5-2. Structural Test Article Decision Tree for Seat Family
NOTE: A “Pitch and Roll” test is a static floor deformation test used to substantiate the flexibility of the seat with the narrowest leg spacing. Pass/fail criteria for this test are the same as for any static or dynamic structural test. However, no injury or other performance criteria are assessed by this test.
E
A. 9g static interface loads are the generally accepted indicator of seat structure criticality. Based on this analysis, the highest loaded leg will indicate the most critical configuration to test. (Other features may drive criticality, e.g., beam bending, in addition to the interface loads analysis.) Using 9g static interface loads, identify the highest loaded leg for the seats with the narrowest leg spacing sub-group and the highest loaded leg for the seat from the wider spaced-leg subgroup(s).
B. Compare the interface loads of the highest loaded seat leg from the sub-groups(s). It is generally accepted that the seat with the narrowest leg spacing will exhibit the highest pre-loads during “pitch & roll.”
C. By testing the seat with the narrowest leg spacing, the test covers the highest loaded leg and the highest pre-load from “pitch & roll.”
D. If the static interface loads for the seat with narrowest leg spacing is within 20% of the seat with the wide leg spacing, it cannot be easily determined which is the more critical to test. The pre-load from “pitch & roll” contributes more to the criticality of the seat with narrow leg spacing. Since the most critical seat cannot be easily determined, either test both seats or create the critical case, using the narrow seat so that it has the more critical interface loads and the highest pre-load from “pitch & roll.”
Test only the narrow seat. The critical case can be created one of two ways, either by ballasting the seat so that the interface loads are increased to match those of the absolute critical seat or by modifying the seat to increase the structural criticality. These are two different approaches, and will change the load distribution on the seat, which is acceptable as long as it maintains criticality.
NOTE: Modification of the seat should be limited to relocating seat legs along a beam to create a more critical overhang. Modifications should not change seat hardware.
E. If the highest static interface load on the seat with the narrowest leg spacing is less than 80% of the highest loaded seat in this group, it can be assumed that the narrow seat with the higher pre-load not be more critical. Only the seat with the highest leg load need be dynamically tested. A check must still be made on the narrowest leg spacing seat to ensure the structure has enough flexibility to accommodate floor warpage. This seat should be placed on a static test fixture and the floor warpage applied. No dynamic test of this configuration is required. This is a test of the primary structure. No ATDs or other additions to test article/set-up are required.
(2) Substantiation of the 14g download condition for each family of seats:
Step 1. Determine the 14g downward static interface loads (or any other standard load) for all seats. Compare the aft fitting resultant loads of all seats in the family, regardless of the number of legs on the seat, and identify the seat with the highest load. This will usually be the same seat that was selected for the critical forward structural test. This one seat will be tested.
Step 2. Conduct a 14g vertical dynamic test of the seat selected above.
Step 3. Use full occupancy for this test. This is to ensure that the maximum compressive load is put on the structure.
Step 4. Install the mass of life vests and literature pocket contents at each seat place, regardless of seat occupancy. Ballast may be used for non-critical parts of the seat (for example, under seat In-Flight Entertainment (IFE) boxes). However, if this test is also used to acquire lumbar loads, the criticality of parts should be assessed with that in mind. (See paragraph e(2)(b) discussion below regarding compliance with § 25.562(c)(2).)
NOTE: Weights representing under-seat baggage are not required for the 14g vertical test. The ATDs identified in the § 25.562(c)(2) part of this test selection process should be instrumented to collect lumbar loads.
Step 5. Retention of a specific item of mass, including emergency equipment, need be demonstrated only once during the 14g vertical load condition, if suitable retention using the production means of attachment is shown by dynamic test. The item of mass may be restrained for all other 14g vertical tests.
Step 6. Include a representative floor in the test setup for the ATD’s feet.
NOTE: Refer to paragraph a(1) above to address special design features (for example, unique energy-absorption features).
e. Injury Criteria (see §§ 25.562(c)(1) to (c)(6)). Injury criteria may be either measured during tests used to show compliance with other requirements or in dedicated tests, depending on the seat design and the practicality of acquiring the necessary data.
(1) Section 25.562(c)(1) - Upper torso restraint tension loads.
(a) The upper torso restraint tension loads must be collected during a structural test where the seat is yawed in the direction that produces the highest tension load in the restraint system. Typically this is the yaw direction that puts the upper torso restraint over the shoulder of the ATD which is moved further forward as a result of the yaw.
(b) If the 16g longitudinal test that demonstrates compliance with § 25.562(c)(7) is yawed in the appropriate direction, the restraint tension load data may be collected during this test, and an additional test is not required.
(c) If the 16g longitudinal test that demonstrates compliance with § 25.562(c)(7) is not yawed in the appropriate direction, an additional test must be added to the baseline testing. The test article for the additional test is the same seat selected for the 16g longitudinal test that demonstrates compliance with § 25.562(c)(7). It is yawed in the direction that creates the highest tension load in the restraint system, with the pitch and roll selected using the guidance in this AC.
(2).Section 25.562(c)(2) - Lumbar loads.
(a) The ATD lumbar loads must be collected during the 14g vertical test that demonstrates compliance with § 25.562(c)(7). An additional test for collecting lumbar loads is not required in the baseline testing (except as noted in paragraph (b) ).
(b) ATDs instrumented to measure lumbar loads must be placed in seat places that represent the stiffest load path from the center of the occupant place to the structure and the least-stiff load path from the occupant place to the structure. This requirement will typically result in two instrumented ATDs, but will not exceed three instrumented ATD locations in a single test.
NOTE: See paragraph a(1) to address special design features (for example, unique energy-absorption features) that may function differently, depending on seat occupancy.
If there is an item (for example IFE) or structure located at a specific seat place (typically beneath the seat pan) that may influence lumbar loads due to seat deflection and/or ATD contact, then lumbar loads must be addressed and substantiated for this location in addition to the locations identified above. These loads may be addressed and substantiated by either data showing no contact or an additional test(s) added to the baseline testing.
(3) Section 25.562(c)(3) - Upper torso restraint remains on shoulder.
(a) For seats with a single upper torso restraint (for example, a 3-point restraint), a test may be required which demonstrates that the upper torso restraint strap remains on the ATD’s shoulder during impact with the seat yawed in the most critical direction. Typically, this is the yaw direction that puts the upper torso restraint over the shoulder of the ATD which is moved aft as a result of the yaw. (See Figure 5-3).
Figure 5-3 · page 27Picture of the page from the copy saved here
(b) If the 16g longitudinal test that demonstrates compliance with § 25.562(c)(7) is yawed in the appropriate direction so that the restraint is over the trailing shoulder, the restraint retention may be demonstrated during this test. An additional baseline test is not required.
FWD Restraint trailing occupant (Overhead view)
Figure 5-3. Restraint Trailing Occupant
(c) If the 16g longitudinal test that demonstrates compliance with § 25.562(c)(7) is not yawed in the appropriate direction and the criteria discussed in paragraph 3b(3) cannot be met, an additional test may be necessary. The test article for the additional test would be the same seat selected for the 16g longitudinal test. This demonstrates compliance with § 25.562(c)(7), yawed in the direction most critical for the restraint strap to remain on the ATD’s shoulder and with the pitch and roll selected in accordance with the guidance in this AC.
(d) For seats with a dual upper torso restraint, the 16g longitudinal test that demonstrates compliance with § 25.562(c)(7) is acceptable for demonstrating that the upper torso restraint straps remain on the ATD’s shoulder during impact. An additional baseline test is not required.
(e) High-speed test film or video of the test must be used to demonstrate that the upper torso restraint strap remains on the ATD’s shoulder during the impact.
(4) Section 25.562(c)(4) - Lap belt remains on pelvis. It must be demonstrated that the pelvic restraint remains on the ATD pelvis during the deceleration pulse, including after ATD rebound. Verification that the belt is on the ATD pelvis post-test is sufficient to demonstrate compliance. High-speed cameras may be used to demonstrate compliance, if the lap belt angle is greater than 55 degrees or less than 45 degrees. Additional baseline tests are not required.
(5) Section 25.562(c)(5) - Head injury criterion (HIC). The HIC is applicable to all seats occupiable for takeoff and landing. Typically, seats located behind interior structure (front row seats) can be addressed in one test, since the potential contact surfaces tend to be homogeneous. Repetitive seat rows introduce more variables and typically require more than one test to demonstrate compliance.
AC 25.562-1B CHG 1 09/30/15
(a) In an effort to reduce the regulatory burden and both simplify and clarify the procedure for demonstrating compliance, the procedure in Appendix 4 for row-to-row HIC has been developed. In the majority of cases, this procedure should allow demonstration of compliance for HIC with two tests. The procedure takes into account seat pitch, the relative position of the target seat and the occupied row behind it, and range of occupant sizes. The intent of this procedure is to provide default conditions that can be used in lieu of conducting several tests or performing lengthy analytical studies. The procedure is covered in detail in Appendix 4 but relies on two basic contact areas to assess HIC. These areas are the center of the seat back and the lateral edges of the seat back/armrest. For installations that incorporate airbags or upper torso restraints, a similar approach could be used provided that the applicant conducts a specific analysis for two basic contact areas to assess HIC. Specific attention should be given to the range of occupants required for airbags.
(b) Demonstration of compliance with the HIC should address seat pitch, occupant height (5th percentile female to the 95th percentile male), and yaw angle (up to ±10 degrees and any angle in between). The evaluation showing HIC of 1000 or less must be from an ATD head impact that is a solid strike and not a glancing blow. Dynamic tests are conducted with a 49 CFR part 572, Subpart B ATD (or equivalent) that is representative of a 50th percentile male occupant. For the purpose of addressing HIC for the height of a 95th percentile male occupant, 3 inches should be added to the ATD top of head when using rational analysis to select the critical HIC test to be conducted with a 49 CFR part 572, Subpart B ATD (or equivalent). This dimension should also be used to address the range of occupants when a test, or analysis based on test, at the installed pitch using a 49 CFR part 572, Subpart B ATD (or equivalent) results in a glancing blow. Once a seat back is qualified for HIC, any seat could be installed aft of it, provided the installation limitations result in comparable conditions to those under which the seat was tested.
(c) Compliance with the HIC is dependent on the details of the seat design as well as the installation. Variations between seats in the contact surfaces will require evaluation by test, unless it can be shown that one surface is more critical than the other. With respect to installation, there are several considerations:
• Seats on canted seat tracks such that the seats are parallel but at an angle with respect to the airplane longitudinal axis.
• Seats on staggered seat tracks such that the seat places row-to-row are staggered.
• Non-parallel seat rows.
• Staggered seating due to a change in the number of seat places.
• Different width seats that result in seat places row-to-row that are slightly staggered.
09/30/15 AC 25.562-1B CHG 1
(d) Front row seats are those located directly aft of a partition, monument, or any other commodity certificated to 9g. Seats located directly aft of seat-related furniture such as consoles and walls of pod seats are not considered front row seats. For front row seats, simpler methods of compliance are possible. These methods specifically limit the range of occupant evaluation for HIC to that strictly covered by the test in § 25.562(b).
1 Perform dynamic testing as prescribed in § 25.562(b) with no head contact or HIC of 1000 or less. A glancing blow resulting in HIC of 1000 or less is acceptable and would not require additional analysis or testing using a more conservative test set up.
2 Perform a dynamic test as described in Appendix 4, paragraph 2, of this AC to determine the head path arc of the 49 CFR part 572, Subpart B ATD or equivalent and install the seat such that no contact by the ATD head would occur. In this case, we would not require more analyses or repositioning of the seat.
3 For seats that incorporate head path reducing features according to the note below, seats may be qualified without a head path test as follows: For seats typically identified as “economy” class seats during air carrier operations, place the seats 42 inches or more from the potential contact point. For all other “front row” seats (e.g., first or business class) the setback distance must be 45 inches or more. When using these dimensions, applicants should coordinate with the FAA or designee, as appropriate, and provide suitable justification for FAA evaluation. No dynamic test is needed for HIC or head path arc for seats that follow a design philosophy that includes the use of metallic components in the primary load path from the seat beams through the seat legs. The distance is measured from the cushion reference point to the vertical plane at the aft most potential contact point.
NOTE: The specific dimensions selected are based on data from certification programs using seats designed to be installed in the front row, i.e., “front row seats.” These seats are different from other seats in the airplane, in that in order to minimize head path, they incorporate stiffer structure, or low stretch seatbelts, or combinations of similar features. This makes a front row seat distinct from other seats. Thus, the validity of the 42"/45" criteria is based on the type of seats from which that criteria was derived. Using the same criteria for typical (non-front row) seats has not been validated and could result in these seats having head paths greater than the specified amount. This is contrary to the rule and policy. The intent of the allowance is to eliminate a test, but at the same time maintain the level of safety intended, had the test been conducted.
f. Deformation for Egress. The seat permanent deformations (see Appendix 2) must be measured in all structural tests. In addition, seat-back permanent deformations
6. TEST FACILITIES
AC 25.562-1B CHG 1 09/30/15
must be measured in a test where the ATD’s head contacts the seat back (for example, a row-to-row HIC test). All measured permanent deformations should be used to show compliance with § 25.562(c)(8). (However, deformations that occur as an artifact of test set-up orientation need not be considered.) Some of the seat permanent deformations will be evaluated for acceptability as part of the dynamic test results (seat pan rotation, ‘B’ vs. ‘C’). Some of the seat permanent deformations will be used by the seat installer to evaluate the seat installation and airplane interior configuration (seat forward, aft, side deformations, seat back forward and aft deformations, and deployment of deployable items). The seat installer must use the measured seat permanent deformations to show an acceptable installation with regard to occupant egress of the airplane.
6. TEST FACILITIES.
a. General. There are a number of test facilities that can be used to accomplish dynamic testing. These are grouped into categories, based on the method used to generate the impact pulse (that is, accelerators, decelerators, or impact with rebound), and whether the facility is a horizontal (sled) design or a vertical (droptower) arrangement. Each facility type has characteristics that have advantages or disadvantages for the dynamic tests discussed in this AC. One particular concern with test facilities is the rapid sequence of acceleration and deceleration that takes place in tests. In an airplane crash, the acceleration phase is always gradual and usually well separated in time from the deceleration (crash) phase. In a test, the deceleration always closely follows the acceleration. When assessing the utility of a facility for the specific test procedures outlined in this AC, it is necessary to understand the possible consequences of this rapid sequence of acceleration and deceleration.
b. Deceleration Sled Facilities. In an airplane crash, the impact takes place as a deceleration, so loads are applied more naturally in test facilities that create the test impact pulse as a deceleration. Since it is simpler to design test facilities to extract energy in a controlled manner than to impart energy in a controlled manner, several different deceleration sled facilities can be found. The deceleration sled facility at the Federal Aviation Administration’s Civil Aeromedical Institute (CAMI) was used in developing the test procedures discussed in this AC.
(1) The acceleration phase of the test, where sufficient velocity for the test impact pulse is acquired, can distort the test results if the acceleration is so high that the test articles or ATDs are moved from their intended pre-test position. This inability to control the initial conditions of the test would directly affect the test results. This can be avoided by using a lower acceleration for a relatively long duration and by providing a coast phase (in which the acceleration or deceleration is almost zero) prior to the impact. As a result, any dynamic oscillation in the test articles or the ATD which might be caused by the acceleration would decay.
(2) To guard against errors in data caused by pre-impact accelerations, data from the electronic test measurements (accelerations, loads) should be reviewed for the time period just before the test impact pulse to make sure all measurements are at the baseline (zero) level. Photometric film taken of the test should also be reviewed to make
09/30/15 AC 25.562-1B CHG 1
certain that the ATDs used in the test and the test articles were all in their proper position prior to the test impact pulse.
(3) The horizontal test facility readily accommodates forward-facing seats in both tests discussed in this AC, but problems can exist in positioning the test ATDs in Test 1 if the seat is a rearward-facing or side-facing seat. In these cases, the ATDs tend to fall out of the seat due to the force of gravity and must be restrained in place using break-away tape, cords, or strings. Since each installation will present its own problems, there is no simple, generally applicable guidance for doing this. Attention should be given to positioning the ATD against the seat back and to proper positioning of the ATD’s arms and legs. It will probably be necessary to build special supports for the break-away restraint, so that the supports will not interfere with the function of the seat and restraint system during the test. Film taken of the test should be reviewed to make sure that the break-away restraint did break (or become slack) in a manner that did not influence the motion of the ATD or the test articles during the test.
c. Acceleration Sled Facilities. Acceleration sled facilities, usually based on the Hydraulically controlled Gas Energized (HYGE) accelerator device, provide the impact test pulse as a controlled acceleration at the beginning of the test. The test item and the ATDs are installed facing in the opposite direction from the velocity vector (i.e., opposite from the direction used on a deceleration facility) to account for the change in direction of the impact. There should be no problem with the ATD or the test items being out of position due to pre-impact sled acceleration, since there is no sled movement prior to the impact test pulse.
(1) After the impact test pulse, when the sled is moving at the maximum test velocity, it must be safely brought to a stop. Most of the facilities of this design have limited track length available for deceleration, so that the deceleration levels can be relatively high and deceleration may begin immediately after the impact test pulse.
(2) Since the dynamic response of the system follows the impact test pulse in time, any sled deceleration that takes place during that response will affect the response and change the test results. The magnitude of change depends on the system being tested, so that no general “correction factor” can be specified. The effect can be minimized if the sled is allowed to coast without significant deceleration until the response is complete.
(3) If the seat or restraint system experiences a structural failure during the test pulse, the post-impact deceleration can increase the damage and perhaps result in failures of unrelated components. This will complicate the determination of the initial failure mode and make product improvement more difficult.
(4) One other consideration is that the photometric film coverage of the response to impact test pulse must be accomplished when the sled is moving at near maximum velocity. On-board cameras or a series of track-side cameras are usually used to provide film coverage of the test. Since on-board cameras frequently use a wide angle lens placed close to the test items, it is necessary to account for the effects of distortion and parallax when analyzing the film.
AC 25.562-1B CHG 1 09/30/15
(5) The acceleration sled facility faces the same problems in accommodating rearward facing or side-facing seats in Test 1 as the deceleration sled facility, and the corrective action is the same for both facilities.
d. Impact-with-rebound Sled Facilities. One other type of horizontal test facility used is the “impact-with-rebound” sled facility. On this facility, the impact takes place as the moving sled contacts a braking system which stores the energy of the impact and then returns the stored energy back to the sled, causing it to rebound in the opposite direction. This facility has the advantage over acceleration or deceleration facilities in that only one half of the required velocity for the impact would need to be generated by the facility (assuming 100 percent efficiency). Thus, the track length can be shortened, and the method of generating velocity is simplified. The disadvantages of this facility combine the problems mentioned above for both acceleration facilities and deceleration facilities. Since one of the reasons for this type of facility is to allow short track length to be used, it may be difficult to obtain sufficiently low acceleration just before or after the impact pulse to resolve data error problems caused by significant pre-impact and post-impact accelerations.
e. Drop Towers. Vertical test facilities can include both drop towers (decelerators) and vertical accelerators. Vertical accelerators that can produce the long duration/displacement impact pulse depicted in Figure 3-1 have not been generally available. However, drop towers are one of the easiest facilities to build and operate and are frequently used. In these facilities, the pull of earth’s gravity is used to accelerate the sled to impact velocity so that the need for a complex mechanical accelerating system is eliminated. Unfortunately, these facilities are difficult to use for conducting Test 2, particularly for typical forward-facing seats. In preparing for this test, the seat must be installed at an angle such that the ATD tends to fall from the seat due to gravity. The restraint system being tested cannot hold the ATD against the seat unless tightened excessively and will not usually locate the head, arms, or legs in their proper position relative to the seat.
Design and fabrication of an auxiliary “break-away” ATD positionin g restraint system just for this test is a complex task. The auxiliary restraint must not only position the ATD against the seat (including maintaining proper seat cushion deflection) during the pre-release condition of 1g, but must also maintain the ATD in that proper position during the free fall to impact velocity when the system is exposed to 0g. It must then release the ATD in a manner that does not interfere with the ATD response to impact. The usual sequence of 1g/0g impact—without the possibility of a useful “coast” phase as done in horizontal facilities—causes shifts in initial conditions for the test impact pulse that can affect the response to the impact. The significance of this will depend on the dynamic characteristics of the system being tested, and these are seldom known with sufficient accuracy to enable the response to be corrected.
In addition, the earth’s gravity will oppose the final rebound of the ATDs into the seat back, so that an adequate test of seat back strength and support for the ATD cannot be obtained. The problems in Test 1 or with rear-facing seats in Test 2 are not as difficult because the seat will support the ATD occupant prior to the free fall. However, the 0g condition that exist s prior to impact will allow the ATD to “float” in the seat restraint system, perhaps changing position and certainly changing the initial impact conditions. Again, use of an auxiliary break-away restraint system to correct these problems is difficult.
7. ANTHROPOMORPHIC TEST DEVICES
7. ANTHROPOMORPHIC TEST DEVICES.
a. General. The tests discussed in this AC were developed using modified forms of the ATDs specified by the United States Code of Federal Regulations, Title 49, Part 572 Anthropomorphic Test Dummies, Subpart B – 50th Percentile Male (known as the Hybrid II). These “Part 572B” ATDs have been shown to be reliable test devices that are capable of providing reproducible results in repeated testing. However, since ATD development is a continuing process, provision was made for using “equivalent” ATDs. Instrumented ATD types should not be mixed when completing the tests discussed in this AC. Any approved ATD type can be used when occupying the seat as ballast
b. Modification to Measure Pelvic/Lumbar Load.
(1) To measure the axial compressive load between the pelvis and lumbar column due to vertical impact as well as downward loads caused by upper torso restraints, a load (force) transducer is inserted into the ATD pelvis just below the lumbar column. There is a load cell available for this purpose that does not require major alteration to the ATD. The general installation is shown schematically in Figure 7-1.
(2) ATDs modified per prior methods involving installation of a femur load cell, described in previous versions of this AC, continue to be acceptable for use.
(3) Alternative approaches to measuring the axial force transmitted to the lumbar spinal column by the pelvis are acceptable if the method:
(a) Accurately measures the axial force but is insensitive to moments and forces other than that being measured;
(b) Maintains the intended alignment of the spinal column and the pelvis, the correct seated height, and the correct weight distribution of the ATD; and
(c) Does not alter the other performance characteristics of the ATD.
Lumbar Spine
Load Cell (Denton Model 1891
or equiv. shown)
Base Block (Supplied with load cell) h
Height Adjusting Shims
Pelvis Casting
Pelvis Accelerometer
Cavity
Figure 7-1 Installation of Pelvic-Lumbar Load Cell
in Part 572B ATD
c. Other ATD Modifications.
(1) To prevent failure of the clavicle used in Part 572 Subpart B ATDs due to flailing, a clavicle of the same shape but of higher strength material can be substituted.
(2) Submarining indicators, such as electronic transducers, may be added on the ATD pelvis. These are located on the anterior surface of the ilium of the ATD pelvis without altering its contour, and indicate the position of the pelvic restraint as it applies loads to the pelvis. These indicators provide a direct record that the pelvic restraint remains on the pelvis during the test and eliminate the need for careful review of highspeed camera images to make that determination.
8. INSTRUMENTATION
d. Equivalent ATDs. The continuing development of ATDs for dynamic testing of seating restraint/crash-injury-protection systems is guided by goals of improved biofidelity (human-like response to the impact environment) and reproducibility of test results. A procedure to enable the use of a modified 49 CFR part 572, Subpart E (the Hybrid III) ATD has been developed and is documented in the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) Technical Paper 1999-01-1609. The significant differences from a certification standpoint are in the lumbar spine region. In addition, there are some mass distribution adjustments that are necessary. The Hybrid III has a higher degree of biofidelity, and other enhancements as compared to the Hybrid II. Alternatively, ATDs can be considered the equivalent of the Part 572B ATD if:
(1) They are fabricated in accordance with design and production specifications established and published by a regulatory agency that is responsible for crash injury protection systems;
(2) They are capable of providing data for the measurements discussed in this AC or of being readily altered to provide the data;
(3) They have been evaluated by comparison with the Part 572B ATD and are shown to generate similar response to the impact environment discussed in this AC; and
(4) Any deviations from the Part 572B ATD configuration or performance are representative of the occupant of a civil airplane in the impact environment discussed in this AC.
8. INSTRUMENTATION.
a. General.
(1) Electronic and photographic instrumentation systems must be used to record data for qualification of seats. Electronic instrumentation should measure the test environment and measure and record data required for comparison of performance to pass/fail criteria.
(2) Photographic instrumentation should be used to document the overall results of tests. Photographic instrumentation should also be used to confirm that the pelvic restraint remains on the ATD's pelvis and that the upper torso restraint straps remain on the ATD's shoulder during impact. The photographs should also document that the seat does not deform as a result of the test in a manner that would impede rapid evacuation of the airplane by the occupants and that the seat remains attached at all points of attachment. For passenger seats with lap belt angles of between 45 and 55 degrees, submarining is typically not a problem. For this reason, a second camera (for example, an overhead camera) for evaluation of submarining is not necessary.
b. Electronic Instrumentation. Electronic instrumentation should be accomplished in accordance with the Society of Automotive Engineers Recommended Practice SAE J211, “Instrumentation for Impact Tests,” using the sign convention of SAE J1733 “Sign Convention for Vehicle Crash Testing.” In this practice, a data channel is considered to include all of the instrumentation components from the transducer through the final data measurement, including connecting cables and any analytical procedures that could alter the magnitude or frequency content of the data. Each dynamic data channel is assigned a nominal channel class that is equivalent to the high frequency limit for that channel, based on a constant output/input ratio versus frequency response plot which begins at 0.1 Hz (+1/2 to -1/2 dB) and extends to the high frequency limit (+1/2 to -1 dB). Frequency response characteristics beyond this high frequency limit are also specified. When digitizing data, the sample rate should be at least five times the 3 dB cutoff frequency of the presample analog filters. Since most facilities set all presample analog filters for Channel Class 1000, and since the 3 dB cutoff frequency for channel class 1000 is 1650 Hz, the minimum digital sampling rate would be about 8000 samples per second. For the dynamic tests discussed in this AC, the dynamic data channels must comply with the following channel class characteristics:
(1) Sled or drop tower vehicle acceleration is measured in accordance with the requirements of Channel Class 60.
(2) Belt-restraint system and seat attachment reaction loads (when measured) are measured in accordance with the requirements of Channel Class 60. Loads in restraint systems that attach directly to the test fixture can be measured by three-axis load cells fixed to the test fixture at the appropriate location. These commercially available load cells measure the forces in three orthogonal directions simultaneously, so that the direction as well as the magnitude of the force can be determined. If desired, similar load cells can be used to measure forces at other boundaries between the test fixture and the test item, such as the forces transmitted by the legs of the seat into the floor track. It is possible to use independent, single axis load cells arranged to provide similar data, but care should be taken to use load cells that can withstand significant cross axis loading or bending without causing errors in the test data.
(3) ATD head accelerations used for calculating the Head Injury Criterion (HIC) are measured in accordance with the requirements of Channel Class 1000.
(4) ATD femur forces are measured in accordance with Channel Class 600.
(5) ATD pelvic/lumbar column force is measured in accordance with the requirements of Channel Class 600.
(6) The full-scale calibration range for each channel provides sufficient dynamic range for the data being measured.
(7) Digital conversion of analog data provides sample resolution of not less than 1 percent of full-scale input.
c. Photographic Instrumentation. Photographic instrumentation is used for documenting the response of the ATDs and the test items to the dynamic test environment. Both high-speed and still image systems should be used.
(1) Photographic instrumentation is in accordance with SAE J211, Part 2. Highspeed cameras that provide data used to calculate displacement or velocity should operate at a minimum nominal speed of 500 frames per second. Photo instrumentation methods should not be used for measurement of acceleration. The locations of the camera and targets or targeted measuring points within the field of view should be measured and documented. Targets should be at least 1/100 of the field width covered by the camera and should be of contrasting colors or should contrast with their background. The center of the target should be easily discernible. A description of photographic calibration boards or scales within the camera field of view; the camera lens focal length; and the make, model and serial number of each camera and lens should be documented for each test. Appropriate digital or serial timing should be provided on the image media. A description of the timing signal, the offset of the timing signal to the image, and the means of correlating the time of the image with the time of the electronic data should be provided.
(2) Rectilinearity of the image is documented in accordance with SAE J211, Part 2. If the image is not rectilinear, as indicated by an overall error in excess of 1 percent, appropriate correction factors should be used in the data analysis process. A rigorous, verified analytical procedure should be used for data analysis. The accuracy of the procedure is considered adequate, if the difference between the measured and derived distance separating the Validation Target Pair, as defined in SAE J211, Part 2, is not greater than 1.0 cm (0.4 inches).
(3) Cameras operating at a nominal rate of 200 frames per second or greater may be used to document the response of ATDs and test items, if measurements are not required. For example, actions such as movement of the pelvic restraint system webbing off of the ATD's pelvis can be observed by documentation cameras placed to obtain a “best view” of the anticipated event. These cameras should be provided with appropriate timing and a means of correlating the image with the time of electronic data.
(4) Still image cameras should be used to document the pre-test installation and the post-test response of the ATDs and the test items. At least four pictures should be obtained from different positions around the test items in pre-test and post-test conditions. Where an upper torso restraint system is installed, post-test pictures must be obtained before moving the ATD. For additional post-test pictures, the ATD's upper torso may be rotated to its approximate upright seated position, so that the condition of the restraint systems may be better documented, but no other change to the post-test response of the test item or the ATD should be made. The pictures should document whether the seat remained attached at all points of attachment to the test fixture.
9. TEST FIXTURES
(5) Still pictures may also be used to document post-test yielding of the seat for the purpose of showing that it would not impede the rapid evacuation of the aircraft occupants. The ATD should be removed from the seat in preparation for still pictures used for that purpose. Targets or an appropriate target grid should be included in such pictures, and the views should be selected so that potential interference with the evacuation process can be determined. For tests where the ATD's head impacts a fixture or another seat back, pictures shall be taken to document the head contact areas.
9. TEST FIXTURES.
a. General. A test fixture is required to position the test article on the sled or drop carriage of the test facility and takes the place of the airplane's floor structure. It does not need to simulate the airplane floor flexibility. It holds the attachment fittings or floor tracks for the seat and provides the floor deformation if needed for the test; it provides anchorage points if necessary for the restraint system; it provides a floor or footrest for the ATD; and it positions instrument panels, bulkheads, or a second row of seats, if required.
b. Floor Deformation.
(1) Purpose of floor deformation. The purpose of providing floor deformation for the longitudinal tests is to demonstrate that the seat system will remain attached and perform properly, even though the seat or airframe may be deformed by the forces associated with the crash. Floor deformation is not required for demonstrating compliance with injury criteria.
(2) Floor deformation fixture. For the typical seat with four seat legs mounted in the aircraft on two parallel tracks, the floor deformation test fixture should consist of two parallel beams: a pitch beam that pivots about a lateral (y) axis and a roll beam that pivots about a longitudinal (x) axis (see Figure 9-1 for a schematic representation). The beams can be made of any rigid structural form: box, I-beam, channel, or other appropriate cross section. The pitch beam should be capable of rotating in the x-z plane up to ±10 degrees relative to the longitudinal (x) axis. The roll beam should be capable of ±10 degrees roll about the centerline of floor tracks or fittings. A means should be provided to fasten the beams in the deformed positions.
Figure 9-1 · page 39Picture of the page from the copy saved here
The beams should have provision for installing a floor track or other attachment fittings on their upper surface in a manner that does not alter the above-floor strength of the track or fitting. The track or other attachment fittings must be representative in above-floor configuration and in the strength used in the airplane. Structural elements below the surface of the floor that are not considered part of the floor track or seat attach fitting need not be included in the installation. Appropriate safety precautions should be taken while imposing floor deformations.
Figure 9-1. Schematic Floor Deformation Fixture—
Seat Legs Attached at Floor Level
(3) Airplane floor track or attachment fitting simulation. An example of the minimum required representation of a floor track is shown in Detail A of Figure 9-1 for one type of seat track. The track or other attachment fittings must be representative of those used in the airplane. Alternatively, three components of reaction forces and three components of reaction moments may be measured during dynamic tests. These six components may be applied simultaneously, by a separate static or dynamic test to a track or attachment fitting used on an airplane, or to a more critical track or attachment fitting than that used on an airplane to demonstrate that the loads measured in the dynamic impact test will not fail the track or attachment fitting used on an airplane.
(4) Load transducer installation (optional). The pitch and roll beams should have provisions for installing individual load transducers at each seat leg attachment point capable of measuring three reaction forces and, if necessary, three reaction moments (see paragraph 7b(3)). The load transducers should have provisions to install floor track or other attachment fittings on their upper surface in a manner that does not alter the above-floor strength of the track or fitting.
c. Other Mounting Configuration Constraints. The preceding discussion describes the fixture and floor deformation procedure that would be used for a typical seat that uses four seat legs and four attachments to the aircraft floor. These test procedures are not intended to be restricted only to those seat configurations, but can be adapted to seats having other designs. Special test fixtures may be necessary for those different configurations. The following methods, while not covering all possible seat designs, should be followed for the more common alternatives:
(1) Airplane seats with three legs may have one central leg at the front or back of the seat and one leg on each side of the seat. The central leg is held in its undeformed position as deformation is applied to the side legs.
(2) Seats that have more than two pairs of legs should be tested with the floor warpage condition that results in the most critically stressed condition. This typically involves warping adjacent pairs of legs. Seats that employ several pairs of legs, ganged together by common cross tubes, can be distorted so that the critical pair of legs is rolled, while the remaining legs on one side of the critical leg are pitched in unison. The legs that are pitched should be selected to increase the load on the critical leg and stress the floor or track fitting in the most severe manner (see Figures 9-2 and 9-3).
Figure 9-2. Floor Warpage Multiple Leg Seat
Figure 9-3. Floor Warpage Multiple Leg Seat
Figure 9-2 · page 41Picture of the page from the copy saved here
(3) Seats that are wall-mounted must be evaluated individually. There are several types of mounting schemes, some of which are discussed below. As noted in the preamble to Amendment 25-64, the dynamic impact pulses defined in § 25.562 are considered compatible with existing airframe structure. The definition of the test fixture required for floor-mounted seats takes this into account, so that extensive floor structure is not necessary for test; that is, only the seat track above the floor is used. The important consideration is the retention of the seat under dynamic conditions, and the test setup should account for this in wall-mounted seats as well. The following guidance has been established with this objective in mind.
(a) Seats that are mounted to primary airplane structure, such as a pressure bulkhead, need only be tested with the attachment fitting mounted to rigid structure in a manner equivalent to the production installation.
(b) Seats mounted to a structure, such as a structural bulkhead, galley or lavatory, where no integral structural members are used for attachment should be tested with the seat attached to segments of the mounting surface. These segments are typically eight inch by eight inch sections of the panel. These sections can, in turn, be mounted to a rigid structure.
(c) Seats that are mounted to single panel furnishings, such as class dividers or windscreens, where the panel essentially fulfills the role of the legs should be treated the same as floor mounted seats. For the purpose of conducting tests, the entire assembly, including the panel and its attachments, should be included in the test setup. In this case, floor warpage should be applied to track-mounted furnishings.
(4) Seats that are attached to both the floor and a bulkhead should be tested on a fixture that positions the bulkhead surface in a plane through the axis of rotation of the pitch beam. The bulkhead surface should be located perpendicular to the plane of the floor (the airplane floor surface, if one were present) in the undeformed condition or in a manner appropriate to the intended installation. Either a rigid bulkhead simulation or an actual bulkhead panel can be used. If a test fixture with a rigid bulkhead simulation is used, the seat restraint system is attached to fittings installed in a test panel equivalent to those used in the actual installation. The seat is attached to the bulkhead and the floor in a manner representative of the airplane installation, and the floor shall then be deformed as described in paragraph 9b.
(5) Seats that incorporate attachment to the aircraft sidewall must be evaluated taking into consideration the expected aircraft fuselage cross-section deformation during a crash. The seat could be mounted between sidewalls or to the sidewall and the floor. The test fixture will allow either a pitch beam or a roll beam to be installed at the outboard attachment structure of the seat. The seat positioning pins or locks are fastened in the same manner as used in the aircraft, including the adjustment of anti-rattle mechanisms, if provided. The following two seat attachment cases incorporating sidewall attachment will be considered:
AC 25.562-1B CHG 1 09/30/15
(a) For the case where there are both sidewall and inboard floor attachments, two tests may be required.
1 To substantiate the seat and sidewall attachment structure, the roll beam is installed on the sidewall attachment and the pitch beam is installed on the inboard floor location as shown in Figure 9-4. The test is conducted with the roll beam rotated simulating the sidewall rotating outboard. The pitch beam rotation and the yaw angle direction of the seat are selected to produce the critical loading condition for the sidewall attachment structure.
2 To substantiate the seat and inboard floor attachment structure, the roll beam is installed on the inboard floor attachment and the pitch beam supports the sidewall attachment. The pitch and roll directions of the test fixture and the yaw direction of the seat are selected fixture and the yaw direction of the seat are selected to produce the critical loading condition for the inboard attachment structure.
Both tests are required, unless it is shown by rational analysis that testing one attachment structure in its critical condition substantiates the other attachment structure.
(b) For the case where the seat is mounted between aircraft sidewalls with no floor attachment structure, the roll beam is installed at the critical outboard attachment structure, while the pitch beam is located at the other outboard attachment structure. The test is conducted with the roll beam rotated simulating the sidewall rotating outboard. The pitch beam rotation and the yaw angle of the seat are selected to produce the critical loading condition for the outboard attachment structure.
Figure 9-4 Schematic Floor Deformation Fixture—
Seat Legs Attached at Side Wall
(6) Seats that are mounted between interior furnishings. Seats that are mounted between two interior furnishings, such as an observer seat or a flight attendant seat mounted between interior walls, should be tested with deformation in plane as shown in Figure 9-5. Deformation is applied so that the critical attachment is first raised, resulting in vertical displacement of 5 degrees from one side of the seat to the other, and is then rolled outboard 5 degrees.
Example: Observer's Se Example: Observer's Seat at
5 Degrees due to Vertical Displacement
5 Degrees Roll
10 Degrees Total on Attachment
Fitting
Vertical Displacement
Figure 9-5 Seats Mounted in an Aisle
(7) Seats that are cantilevered from one sidewall without connection to other structure are not subject to floor deformation. A determination must be made whether sidewall deformations could be expected that could generate a condition critical for seat performance in a crash. If sidewall deformation is likely, the entire sidewall attachment plane or the attachment points is deformed in a manner to represent the sidewall deformation. Either a rigid sidewall simulation or an actual sidewall panel may be used. If a test fixture with a rigid sidewall simulation is used, the seat/restraint system is attached to fittings installed in a test panel equivalent to those used in the actual installation.
(8) Seats that are mounted on adapter plates (plinth). Where the adapter (plinth) is used to mount a single seat assembly (whether single or multiple place), and the adapter plate is attached to the floor, the adapter plate is considered as part of the seat assembly and should be deformed as described in paragraph 9b. Any items of mass attached to the plinth need to be represented and included in the dynamic testing, as discussed in Appendix 5 of this AC.
(9) Seats that are mounted on a pallet (for example, multiple seat rows). A pallet is considered part of the floor structure of the airplane based on its size, structural design, and redundancy of attachment. The seats should be attached to the test fixture in
a manner representative of the airplane installation. The seat legs are deformed as described in paragraph 9b. Any items of mass attached to the pallet and not part of the seat structure do not need to be included in the dynamic testing.
d. Side-facing Seats.
(1) General. All seats occupiable for takeoff and landing are subject to the specified dynamic test conditions. Included are side-facing seats and both single occupancy and multiple place seats, such as divans. Compliance with the structural requirements should be demonstrated for side-facing seats, using the same conditions for the test and pass/fail criteria as for fore- and aft-facing seats. The seat should be loaded in the most critical case structurally. Means of restraining the ATDs may need to be adapted to ensure adequate retention during the test. The application of floor distortion will need to be assessed on an individual basis, depending on the design of the fixation of the seat. The injury criteria of § 25.562 are not adequate to demonstrate equivalent safety of side-facing seats when compared to fore- and aft-facing seats. To demonstrate equivalent safety fully in the absence of such specified criteria, the applicant must use other injury criteria which may be derived from the automotive industry, which uses side-impact ATDs.
(2) Assessment criteria. Research into side-facing seats is ongoing. As research proceeds, the FAA will work toward establishing a more definitive policy with respect to the acceptance of side-facing seats. Until then, in the absence of specific compliance guidance, the FAA is prepared to assess side-facing seats on the following basis:
(a) The seat must demonstrate compliance with the structural requirement.
(b) If an acceptable side impact ATD has not been used with assessment of the corresponding injury criteria, it must be shown that the occupants are restrained in a manner that prevents substantial energy absorption by body to body contact (on a multiple occupancy seat) and which, using the best available engineering judgment, minimizes injury to the occupant(s).
e. Multiple Row Test Fixtures. In tests of passenger seats that are normally installed in repetitive rows in the airplane, head and knee impact conditions are best evaluated through tests that use at least two rows of seats. These conditions are usually critical only in Test 2. This test allows direct measurements of the head and femur injury data.
(1) The fixture must be capable of setting the airplane longitudinal axis at a yaw angle of -10 to +10 degrees. The fixture should also allow adjustment of the seat pitch and installation angle with respect to the airplane center line.
(2) To allow direct measurement of head acceleration for the head injury assessment of a seat installation where the head of the occupant is within striking distance
10. TEST PREPARATION
of structure, a representative impact surface may be attached to the test fixture in front of the seat at the orientation and distance from the seat representing the airplane installation.
f. Other Fixture Applications. Test fixtures should provide a flat footrest for ATDs used in tests of passenger seats and crewmember seats that are not provided with special footrests or foot-operated airplane controls. The surface of the footrest must be at a position representative of the floor in the airplane installation. Test fixtures used for evaluating crew seats that are normally associated with special footrests or foot-operated controls must simulate those components. (A footrest is optional for Test 2 structural tests—see paragraph 10f.) Test fixtures may also require guides or anchors for restraint systems or for holding instrument panels or bulkheads. If these provisions are required, the installation must represent the configuration of the airplane installation and be of adequate structural strength. The strength of any such restraint anchorages should be equivalent to the actual installation, whereas instrument panels or bulkheads should be sufficiently strong to ensure that they withstand the test pulse.
10. TEST PREPARATION.
a. Preparation for the Tests will involve positioning and securing the ATD, the ATD restraint system, the seat, and the instrumentation. This is done for the specific critical condition being tested. Preparations that pertain to the normal operation of the test facility, such as safety provisions and the actual procedures for accomplishment of the tests, are specific to the test facility and are not addressed in this AC.
b. Use of Anthropomorphic Dummies. Anthropomorphic dummies used in the tests discussed in this AC should be maintained to perform in accordance with the requirements described in their specification. Periodic teardown and inspection of the ATD should be accomplished to identify and correct any worn or damaged components, and appropriate ATD calibration tests (as described in their specification) should be accomplished if major components are replaced. For the tests discussed in this AC, the following procedures have been found to be adequate:
(1) Since extremes of temperature and humidity can affect ATD performance, the ATDs should be maintained at a temperature range between 66 to 78 degrees F (19 to 26 degrees C) and at a relative humidity from 10 to 70 percent for a minimum of 4 hours prior to the test.
(2) Each ATD should be clothed in form-fitting cotton stretch garments with short sleeves, mid-calf length pants, and shoes (size 11E) weighing about 2.5 pounds. The color of the clothing should be in contrast to the color of the restraint system.
(3) For tests where the ATD's head is expected to impact a fixture or another seat back, the head and face of the ATD may be treated with a suitable material to mark head contact areas. The material used must not reduce the resulting HIC values.
(4) The friction in limb joints should be set so that they barely restrain the weight of the limb when extended horizontally.
(5) The ATD should be placed in the center of the seat in as nearly a symmetrical position as possible. The ATD should be placed in the seat in a uniform manner so as to obtain reproducible test results.
(6) The ATD's back should be against the seatback without clearance. This condition can be achieved, if the ATD's legs are lifted as it is lowered into the seat. Then the ATD is pushed back into the seatback as it is lowered the last few inches into the seat pan. Once all lifting devices have been removed from the ATD, the ATD should be “rocked” slightly to settle it in the seat.
(7) The ATD's knees should be separated about four inches.
(8) The ATD's hands should be placed on the top of its upper legs, just behind the knees. If tests on crew seats are conducted in a mockup that has airplane controls, the ATD's hands should be lightly tied to the controls. The ATD arms should be positioned such that they are not over the armrests, so as not to bear on the armrests and influence the collection of lumbar loads during the down test.
(9) The feet should be in the appropriate position for the type of seat tested (flat on the floor for a passenger seat, on control pedals or on a 45-degree footrest for flightcrew systems). The feet should be placed so that the centerlines of the lower legs are approximately parallel, unless the need for placing the feet on airplane controls dictates otherwise.
(10) If the system is tested in other than a “horizontal floor” position, it is recommended that the ATD be placed such that the hip joints are in essentially the same position relative to the seat as when seated with a 1g pre-load as shown in Figures 10-1 and 10-2. Achieving this position may require that the lap belt be very tight and a shim be placed behind the ATD’s back and pelvis.
(11) Auxiliary restraints may be required to ensure that each ATD will be in its proper position prior to the impact. The auxiliary restraint(s) must not interfere with the results of the test.
c. Seat Adjustment. Except as noted in paragraph 3b(4), to the extent that they influence the injury criteria, all seat adjustments and controls should be in the design position intended for the 50th percentile male occupant. If the seat restraint systems being tested are to be used in applications where special requirements dictate their position for landing or takeoff, those positions should be used in the tests.
d. Installation of Instrumentation. Professional practice should be followed when installing instrumentation. Care should be taken when installing the transducers to prevent deformation of the transducer body that could cause errors in data. Lead-wires should be routed to avoid entanglement with the ATD or test article, and sufficient slack
should be provided to allow motion of the ATD or test article without breaking the leadwires or disconnecting the transducer. Calibration procedures should consider the effect of long transducer lead-wires. Head accelerometers and femur load cells should be installed in the ATD, in accordance with the ATD specification and the instructions of the transducer manufacturer. The load cell between the pelvis and the lumbar column should be installed in accordance with the approach shown in Figure 7-1 of this AC or in a manner that will provide equivalent data (see paragraph 7b).
(1) If an upper torso restraint is used, the tension load should be measured in a segment of webbing between the ATD's shoulders and the first contact of the webbing with hard structure (the anchor point or a webbing guide). Restraint webbing should not be cut to insert a load cell in series with the webbing, since that will change the characteristics of the restraint system. Load cells that can be placed over the webbing without cutting are commercially available. They should be placed on free webbing to minimize contact with hard structure, seat upholstery, or the ATD during the test. They should not be used on double-reeved webbing, multiple-layered webbing, locally stitched webbing, or folded webbing, unless it can be demonstrated that these conditions do not cause errors in the data. These load cells should be calibrated using a length of webbing of the type used in the restraint system. If the placement of the load cell on the webbing causes the restraint system to sag, the weight of the load cell can be supported by light string or tape that will break away during the test.
(2) Since load cells are sensitive to the inertial forces of their own internal mass and to the mass of fixtures located between them and the test article as well as to forces applied by the test article, it may be necessary to compensate the test data for that inaccuracy if the error is significant. Data for such compensation will usually be obtained from an additional dynamic test that replicates the load cell installation but does not include the test item.
e. Restraint System Adjustment. The restraint system must not be tightened beyond the level that could reasonably be expected in use, and the emergency locking device (inertia reel) must not be locked prior to the impact. Automatic locking retractors must be allowed to perform the webbing retraction and automatic locking function without assistance. Care must be taken to assure that emergency locking retractors that are sensitive to acceleration do not lock prior to the impact test because of pre-impact acceleration applied by the test facility. If comfort zone retractors are used, they must be adjusted in accordance with instructions given to the user of the restraint system.
(1) If manual adjustment of the restraint system is required, slack must be removed, and the restraint system should be snug but not excessively tight, about the ATD. For test 2, this can normally be determined when two fingers fit snugly between the belt and the pelvis of the ATD. The restraint system shall be checked and adjusted just prior to the floor deformation phase of the test.
(2) If the system is tested in other than a “horizontal floor” position (see paragraph b(10) above), the restraint should be properly adjusted with the seat in the
09/30/15 AC 25.562-1B CHG 1
“horizontal floor” position and the webbing transducers installed (if required). After sufficient time has elapsed to allow the cushion to reach an equilibrium position, the webbing should be marked to indicate the correct adjustment point. The seat and ATD should then be installed on the fixture in the appropriate dynamic test orientation and the restraint system again adjusted to that same point.
(3) An alternative method to impose a 1-g pre-load is to measure the position of the ATD hip joints relative to the floor as shown in Figure 10-1 below. The ATD is then depressed into the cushion to reproduce this relative position after the ATD and seat have been installed on the fixture, as shown in Figure 10-2. The lap belt may be tightened to maintain this position. This load may make it impossible to insert two fingers between the lap belt and the pelvis of the ATD, but it should not produce a cushion displacement in excess of that measured by placing the ATD on the seat in a 1-g orientation.
f. Floor Requirement. A floor is not required for Test 2, but if a floor is installed, it should not influence the behavior of the seat or unduly restrict the movement of the ATD's feet. This is a concern especially when floor distortion is applied. For consistency, a floor should be used for tests used to gather head path data.
g. Seat Components. Seats frequently consist of components that are both integral to and ancillary to the seat’s basic design and function. Historically, anything that is attached to the seat has been treated as part of the seat from a type design standpoint. However, these items can be divided into several categories with different methods of substantiation in order to facilitate simplified compliance methods. In summary, these categories are as follows:
• Features of the seat that affect its dynamic performance,
• Operationally removable items attached to the seat,
• Small items that can be verified by inspection, and
• Lifevests.
Appendix 5 describes in detail methods to address compliance for each type of item.
Figure 10-1 surement of 1g Pre-load Mea
Figure 10-2 est Orientation—1g Position T
12. DATA ANALYSIS
11. DATA REQUIREMENTS. The data should include charts, listings, and/or tabulated results, and copies of any photo instrumentation used to support the results. The following should be recorded:
• Impact pulse shape
• Head Injury Criterion (HIC) results for all ATDs exposed to head impact with interior components of the airplane or head strike paths and velocities, if head impact is likely but could not be evaluated by these tests
• Total velocity change
• Upper torso restraint system load, if applicable
• Compressive load between the pelvis and the lumbar column
• Retention of upper torso restraint straps, if applicable
• Retention of pelvic restraint
• Femur loads, if applicable
• Seat attachment (including structural damage)
• Seat deformation
• Seat attachment reaction time histories (if load cells are used)
• Retention of items of mass
• Evaluation of seat egress
12. DATA ANALYSIS.
a. General. All data obtained in the dynamic tests should be reviewed for errors. Baseline drift, ringing, and other common electronic instrumentation problems should be detected and corrected before the tests. Loss of data during the test is readily observed in a plot of the data versus time and is typically indicated by sharp discontinuities in the data, often exceeding the amplitude limits of the data collection system. If these occur early in the test in essential data channels, the data should be rejected and the test repeated. If they occur late in the test after the peak data in each channel has been recorded, the validity of the data should be carefully evaluated, and the maximum values of the data may still be acceptable for the tests described in this AC. The HIC does not represent simply a maximum data value, but an integration of data over a varying time base. The head acceleration measurements used for that computation are not acceptable,
if errors or loss of data are apparent in the data during the time the ATD head is in contact with the airplane interior features during the test.
b. Impact Pulse Shape. Data for evaluating the impact pulse shape is obtained from an accelerometer that measures the acceleration in the direction parallel to the inertial response shown in Figure 3-1 of this AC. The impact pulses intended for the tests discussed in this AC have an isosceles triangle shape. These ideal pulses are considered minimum test conditions. Since the actual acquired test pulses will differ from the ideal, it is necessary to evaluate the acquired test pulses to insure the minimum requirements are satisfied. The five properties of the ideal pulse that must be satisfied by the acquired test pulse are as follows (see Figure 3-1):
Pulse shape: isosceles triangle Greq: peak deceleration required by test condition Treq: rise time required by test condition V: total velocity change required by test condition Vtr: velocity change required during Treq (Vtr = V/2)
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 228 passages shown