AC 25-11A Electronic Flight Deck Displays
This advisory circular (AC) provides guidance for showing compliance with certain requirements of Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), part 25, for the design, installation, integration, and approval of electronic flight deck displays, components, and systems installed in transport category airplanes.
This document is cancelled. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.
U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory Circular
Subject: ELECTRONIC FLIGHT DECK DISPLAYS
Date: 6/21/07 Initiated by: ANM-111
AC No: 25-11A
This advisory circular (AC) provides guidance for showing compliance with certain requirements of Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), part 25, for the design, installation, integration, and approval of electronic flight deck displays, components, and systems installed in transport category airplanes. Signed by Ali Bahrami Ali Bahrami Manager, Transport Airplane Directorate Aircraft Certification Service
1
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
2
CONTENTS
Paragraph Page CHAPTER 1. BACKGROUND
1. What is the Purpose of this Advisory Circular (AC)? 8 2. Who Does this AC Apply to? 8 3. Cancellation 8 4. General 8 Table 1 – Topics Within the Guidance of this AC 9 Table 2 – Topics Outside the Guidance of this AC 9 5. Definitions of Terms Used in this AC 11 6. Background 11 7. – 10. [RESERVED] 11
CHAPTER 2. ELECTRONIC DISPLAY SYSTEM OVERVIEW
11. General 12 a. Design Philosophy 12 b. Human Performance Considerations 12 c. Addressing Intended Function in the Certification Plan
13
12. – 15. [RESERVED] 13
CHAPTER 3. ELECTRONIC DISPLAY HARDWARE
16. Display Hardware Characteristics 14 a. Visual Display Characteristics 14 b. Installation 17 c. Power Bus Transient 19 17. – 20. [RESERVED] 20
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
3
Paragraph Page
CHAPTER 4. SAFETY ASPECTS OF ELECTRONIC DISPLAY SYSTEMS
21. General 21 a. Identification of Failure Conditions 21 b. Effects of Display Failure Conditions 22 c. Mitigation of Failure Conditions 23 d. Validation of the Classification of Failure Conditions and Their Effects 24
e. System Safety Guidelines 25 Table 3 – Example Safety Objectives for Attitude
Failure Conditions 27
Table 4 – Example Safety Objectives for Airspeed
Failure Conditions 28
Table 5 – Example Safety Objectives for Barometric
Altitude Failure Conditions 29
Table 6 – Example Safety Objectives for Heading
Failure Conditions 30
Table 7 – Example Safety Objectives for Certain
Navigation and Communication Failure Conditions
31
Table 8 – Example Safety Objectives for Failure
Conditions of Other Parameters 32
Table 9 – Example Safety Objectives for Engine
Failure Conditions 35
Table 10 – Failure Conditions for Display Systems
Used as Controls 36
22. – 30. [RESERVED] 36
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
4
Paragraph
Page
CHAPTER 5. ELECTRONIC DISPLAY INFORMATION ELEMENTS
AND FEATURES
31. Display Information Elements and Features 35 a. General 35 b. Consistency 36 c. Display Information Elements 36 (1) Text 36 (2) Labels 37 (3) Symbols 39 (4) Indications 40 (a) Numeric Readouts 40 (b) Scales, Dials, and Tapes 40 (c) Other Graphical Depictions 41 (5) Color Coding 42 Table 11 – Recommended Colors for Certain
Functions 43
Table 12 – Specified Colors for Certain Display
Features 43
d. Dynamic (Graphic) Information Elements on a
Display 45
e. Sharing Information on a Display 45 (1) Overlays and Combined Information Elements 46
(2) Time Sharing 46 (3) Separating Information Visually 46 (4) Clutter and De-Clutter 47 f. Annunciations and Indications 47 (1) General 47 (2) Location 47 (3) Managing Messages and Prompts 47 (4) Blinking 48 g. Use of Imaging 48 32. – 35. [RESERVED] 49
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
5
Paragraph
Page
CHAPTER 6. ORGANIZING ELECTRONIC DISPLAY
INFORMATION ELEMENTS 36. Organizing Information Elements 50 a. General 50 b. Types and Arrangement of Display Information 50 (1) Placement - General Information 50 (2) Placement - Controls and Indications 51 (3) Arrangement - Basic T Information 51 (4) Arrangement - Powerplant Information 53 (5) Arrangement - Other Information (For Example, Glideslope and Multi-Function Displays)
53
c. Managing Display Information 54 (1) Window 54 (2) Menu 55 (3) Full-Time vs. Part-Time Display of Information 55 d. Managing Display Configuration 57 (1) Normal Conditions 57 (2) System Failure Conditions (Reconfiguration) 57 e. Methods of Reconfiguration 59 (1) Compacted Format 59 (2) Sensor Selection and Annunciation 60 37. – 40. [RESERVED] 60
CHAPTER 7. ELECTRONIC DISPLAY SYSTEM CONTROL DEVICES
41. General 61 a. Multi-function Control Labels 61 b. Multi-function Controls 61 (1) “Hard” Controls 61 (2) “Soft” Controls 62 c. Cursor Control Devices 63 d. Cursor Displays 64 42. – 45. [RESERVED] 64
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
6
Paragraph
Page
CHAPTER 8. SHOWING COMPLIANCE FOR APPROVAL OF
ELECTRONIC DISPLAY SYSTEMS
46. Compliance Considerations (Test and Compliance) 65 a. General 65 b. Means of Compliance 65 47. – 50. [RESERVED] 67
CHAPTER 9. CONTINUED AIRWORTHINES AND MAINTENANCE
51. Continued Airworthiness and Maintenance 68 a. General 68 b. Design for Maintainability 68 c. Maintenance of Display Characteristics 69 52. – 60. [RESERVED] 69
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
7
Appendix Page
LIST OF APPENDICES
1 Primary Flight Information A1-1 1.1 Attitude A1-1 1.2 Continued Function of Primary Flight Information (Including Standby) in Conditions of Unusual Attitudes or in Rapid Maneuvers
A1-1
2.1 Airspeed and Altitude A1-2 2.2 Airspeed and Altitude for HUD A1-3 2.3 Low and High Speed Awareness Cues A1-4 3. Vertical Speed A1-6 4. Flight Path Vector or Symbol A1-6 2 Powerplant Displays A2-1 1. General A2-1 2. Design Guidelines A2-2 3 Definitions A3-1 Figure A3-1 Primary Field of View A3-9 Figure A3-2 Display Format A3-11 4 Acronyms Used in This AC A4-1 5 Related Regulations and Documents A5-1 General A5-1 1. Regulations A5-1 2. Advisory Circulars A5-7 3. Technical Standard Orders A5-9 4. Other FAA Documents A5-13 5. ARAC Recommendations A5-13 6. JAA/EASA Documents A5-14 7. Industry Documents A5-14 a. ARINC A5-14 b. EUROCAE A5-15 c. ICAO A5-16 d. RTCA A5-16 e. SAE International (Formerly the Society of Automotive Engineers)
A5-18
f. Other Document(s) A5-21
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
8
CHAPTER 1. BACKGROUND 1. What is the purpose of this advisory circular (AC)? This AC provides guidance for showing compliance with certain requirements of Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), part 25, as well as general guidance for the design, installation, integration, and approval of electronic flight deck displays, components, and systems installed in transport category airplanes. 2. Who does this AC apply to?
a. The guidance provided in this document is directed to airplane and avionics manufacturers, modifiers, and operators of transport category airplanes.
b. This material is neither mandatory nor regulatory in nature and does not constitute a regulation. It describes acceptable means, but not the only means, for demonstrating compliance with the applicable regulations. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) will consider other methods of demonstrating compliance that an applicant may elect to present. While these guidelines are not mandatory, they are derived from extensive FAA and industry experience in determining compliance with the relevant regulations. On the other hand, if we become aware of circumstances that convince us that following this AC would not result in compliance with the applicable regulations, we will not be bound by the terms of this AC, and we may require additional substantiation or design changes as a basis for finding compliance. Applicants for a technical standard order (TSO) should consider following the guidance in this AC when the TSO requirements do not provide sufficient guidance.
c. This material does not change, create any additional, authorize changes in, or permit deviations from, regulatory requirements. 3. Cancellation. This AC cancels AC 25-11, Transport Category Airplanes Electronic Display Systems, dated 16 July 1987. 4. General. This AC applies to the design, integration, installation, and certification approval of electronic flight deck displays, components, and systems for transport category airplanes. As a minimum this includes:
• General airworthiness considerations, • Display system and component characteristics, • Safety and criticality aspects, • Functional characteristics, • Display information characteristics, • Guidance to manage display information, • Flightcrew interface and interactivity, and
96/21/07 AC 25-11A
9
• Airworthiness approval (means of compliance) considerations. Table 1, below, lists the topics within the guidance of this AC. Table 2, below, lists the topics not within the guidance of this AC.
Table 1 Topics Within the Guidance of This AC
Topics
Electronic pilot displays – including single function and multi-function displays.
Display features and functions that are intended for use by the pilot. Display functions not intended for use by the pilot if they may interfere with the pilot’s flying duties. Display aspects of Class III Electronic Flight Bag (installed equipment). Controls associated with the electronic displays covered in this AC. These controls include hard controls (physical buttons and knobs) and soft controls (virtual or programmable buttons and knobs, generally controlled through a cursor device or line select keys). Electronic standby displays. Head Up Displays (HUD). Enhanced and Synthetic Vision Systems.
Table 2 Topics Outside the Guidance of This AC
Topics
Display functions not intended for use by the pilot. In flight entertainment displays. Flight attendant displays. Maintenance terminals, even if they are in the flight deck, but not intended for use by the pilots. Head mounted displays used by pilots. Displays in the flightcrew rest area. Handheld or laptop items (not installed equipment). Class I and Class II Electronic Flight Bags. Electromechanical instruments. Auditory “displays” (for example, aural alerts), and tactile “displays” (for example, stick shaker). Flight controls, throttles, and other (hard) controls not directly associated with the electronic displays.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
10
a. Other advisory material is available for use in establishing guidance for specific functionality and characteristics provided by electronic displays. For example, AC 25-23, Airworthiness Criteria for the Installation Approval of a Terrain Awareness and Warning System (TAWS) for Part 25 Airplanes, describes a means for airworthiness approval of TAWS, and includes guidance on the display of TAWS. This revised AC 25-11A is not intended to replace or conflict with any existing AC. Its purpose is to provide general, highlevel guidance for electronic displays in the flight deck. Conflicts between this AC and other advisory material, if any, will be resolved on a case-by-case basis, in agreement with the FAA. In those cases, the more specifically applicable material should control.
b. The combination of the guidance material in this AC, the Aviation Rulemaking Advisory Committee (ARAC) recommendations for adding a new regulation to 14 CFR part 25 and revising two existing part 25 regulations, and the associated guidance material for the ARAC recommendations, is intended to represent the design characteristics and techniques that are:
• widely accepted in the aviation industry,
• relevant to the regulatory requirements, and
• can be reasonably applied to transport airplane certification programs for electronic flight deck displays.
c. The ARAC recommendations include adding a new § 25.1302, Installed Systems and Equipment for Use by the Flight Crew and revising the existing § 25.1309, Equipment, Systems, and Installation; § 25.1322, Flightcrew Alerting; and § 25.1333(b), Instrument systems. It is the FAA’s intent that the information in this AC 25-11A does not duplicate or conflict with the information provided in the guidance material that will possibly be created as a result of the ARAC recommendations for § 25.1302, § 25.1309, § 25.1322, and § 25.1333(b).
(1) For information about the ARAC recommendation for § 25.1302 go to http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/rulemaking/committees/arac/media/tae/TAE_ HFH_T1.pdf. (2) For information about the ARAC recommendation for § 25.1309 go to http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/rulemaking/committees/arac/media/tae/TAE_S DA_T2.pdf. (3) For information about the ARAC recommendation for § 25.1322 go to http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/rulemaking/committees/arac/media/tae/ TAE_ASH_T4.pdf.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
11
(4) For information about the ARAC recommendation for § 25.1333(b) go to http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/rulemaking/committees/arac/ issue_areas/tae/asm/. Section 25.1333(b) is part of the recommendations for “Task 2 - Cockpit Instrument Systems.” 5. Definitions of Terms Used in this AC.
a. For the purposes of this AC, a “display system” includes not only the display hardware and software components but the entire set of avionic devices implemented to display information to the flightcrew. Hardware and software components of other systems that affect displays, display functions, or display controls should take into account the display aspects of this AC. For example, this AC would be applicable to a display used when setting the barometric correction for the altimeter, even though the barometric set function may be part of another system. b. For the purposes of this AC, “foreseeable conditions” means the full environment in which the display or the display system is assumed to operate, given its intended function. This includes operating in normal, non-normal, and emergency conditions.
c. Definitions of technical terms used in this AC can be found in Appendix 3 of this AC. The acronyms used throughout this document are included in Appendix 4 of this AC. A list of applicable regulations, related guidance, and industry material is included in Appendix 5 of this AC. 6. Background.
a. Electronic displays can present unique opportunities and challenges to the design and certification process. In many cases, showing compliance with regulatory requirements related to the latest flight deck display system capabilities has been subject to a great deal of interpretation by applicants and the FAA. At the time the first electronic displays were developed, they were direct replacements for the conventional electromechanical components. The initial release of AC 25-11 established guidance for the approval of cathode ray tube (CRT) based electronic display systems used for guidance, control, or decision-making by the flightcrews of transport category airplanes. This initial guidance was appropriate for CRTs, but additional guidance was needed to update AC 25-11 to address new technologies.
b. The FAA and European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) have established a number of regulatory requirements intended to improve aviation safety by requiring that the flight deck design have certain capabilities and characteristics. The approval of flight deck displays and display systems has typically been addressed by invoking many rules that are specific to
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
12
certain systems, or to rules with general applicability such as §§ 25.1301(a), 25.771(a), and 25.1523. Thus, this AC provides guidance related to these and other applicable regulations. 7. - 10. [RESERVED]
ELECTRONIC DISPLAY SYSTEM OVERVIEW
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
13
CHAPTER 2. ELECTRONIC DISPLAY SYSTEM OVERVIEW 11. General. The following paragraphs provide guidance that applies to the overall electronic display system. This chapter, together with Chapters 3 through 7 of this AC, provides compliance objectives and design guidance. Chapter 8 provides general guidance on how to show compliance for approval of electronic display systems. The material in Chapters 2 through 9 and Appendices 1 and 2 of this AC constitutes an overall method of compliance for the approval of an electronic display system.
a. Design Philosophy. The applicant should establish, document, and follow a design philosophy for the display system that supports the intended functions (§ 25.1301). The documented design philosophy may be included as part of a system description, certification plan, or other document that is submitted to the FAA during a certification project. The design philosophy should include a high level description of:
(1) General philosophy of information presentation – for example, is a “quiet, dark” flight deck philosophy used or is some other approach used?
(2) Color philosophy on the electronic displays – the meaning and intended interpretation of different colors – for example, does magenta always represent a constraint?
(3) Information management philosophy – for example, when should the pilot take an action to retrieve information or is it brought up automatically? What is the intended interpretation of the location of the information?
(4) Interactivity philosophy - for example, when and why is pilot confirmation of actions requested? When is feedback provided? (5) Redundancy management philosophy – for example, how are single and multiple display failures accommodated? How are power supply and data bus failures accommodated?
b. Human Performance Considerations. The applicant should establish and document the following human performance elements when developing a display system:
• Flightcrew workload, • Flightcrew training time to become sufficiently familiar with using the display, and • The potential for flightcrew error.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
14
A high workload or excessive training time may indicate a display design that is difficult to use, requires excessive concentration, or may be prone to flightcrew errors. Compliance considerations are included in Chapter 8 of this AC.
c. Addressing Intended Function in the Certification Plan. The certification plan should identify the appropriate part 25 rules. An important part of the certification plan will be the system description(s) and all intended functions, including attitude, altitude, airspeed, engine parameters, horizontal situation display, etc. To demonstrate compliance with § 25.1301(a), an applicant must show that the design is appropriate for its intended function. The applicant’s description of intended function needs to be sufficiently specific and detailed for the FAA to be able to evaluate that the system is appropriate to its intended function. The ARAC recommendations for adding a new § 25.1302 and the guidance material associated with those recommendations, provide additional information on intended function requirements and guidance. General and/or ambiguous intended function descriptions are not acceptable (for example, a function described only as “situation awareness”). Some displays may be intended to be used for situation awareness, but that term needs to be clarified or qualified to explain what type of specific situation awareness will be provided. More detailed descriptions may be warranted for designs that are new, novel, highly integrated, or complex. Many modern displays have multiple functions and applicants should describe each intended function. A system description is one place to document the intended function(s).
d. Display systems and display components that are not intended for use by the flightcrew (such as maintenance displays) should not interfere with the flying duties of the flightcrew. 12. – 15. [RESERVED]
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
15
CHAPTER 3. ELECTRONIC DISPLAY HARDWARE 16. Display Hardware Characteristics. The following paragraphs provide general guidance and a means of compliance for electronic display hardware with respect to its basic visual, installation, and power bus transient handling characteristics. A more detailed set of display hardware characteristics can be found in the following SAE International (formerly the Society of Automotive Engineers) documents:
• For electronic displays – SAE Aerospace Standards (AS) 8034A, Minimum Performance Standard for Airborne Multipurpose Electronic Displays. • For head up displays - SAE AS8055, Minimum Performance Standard for Airborne Head Up Display (HUD).
• For liquid crystal displays (LCDs) – SAE Aerospace Recommended Practice (ARP) 4256A, Design Objectives for Liquid Crystal Displays for Part 25 (Transport) Aircraft.
NOTE 1: For LCDs, the quantitative criterion in SAE ARP 4256A, paragraph 4.2.6., equation 5, is not considered a reliable predictor of acceptable specular reflectivity characteristics. Accordingly, this aspect of LCD performance should be specifically assessed via flightcrew evaluation to establish that there are not internal or external reflections that can result in flightcrew distraction or erroneous interpretation of displayed information.
NOTE 2: With regard to the criteria for malfunction indication in SAE ARP 4256A, paragraph 3.4, the FAA has determined that showing the fonts and symbols to be tolerant to the loss of a single column, line, or element is an acceptable alternative to providing a malfunction indication. Proposed designs that do not use fonts and symbols that are tolerant to these faults are acceptable if they meet the criteria in SAE ARP 4256A.
NOTE 3: The applicant should notify the FAA certification engineer if any visual display characteristics do not meet the guidelines in the applicable SAE documents.
NOTE 4: The most recent revision of the referenced SAE documents should be considered. If there is a conflict between the guidance in an SAE document and AC 25-11A, follow the guidance in AC 25-11A. a. Visual Display Characteristics. The visual display characteristics of a flight deck display are directly linked to their optical characteristics. Display defects (for example, element defects or stroke tails) should not impair readability of the display or create
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
16
erroneous interpretation. In addition to the information elements and features identified in Chapter 5 of this AC, and the visual characteristics in SAE ARP 4256A, SAE AS 8034A, and SAE AS 8055, described above, the display should meet the criteria for the following characteristics. These characteristics are independent of the proposed display technology.
(1) Physical Display Size. A display should be large enough to present information in a form that is usable (for example, readable or identifiable) to the flightcrew from the flightcrew station (see related regulation) in all foreseeable conditions, relative to the operational and lighting environment and in accordance with its intended function(s).
(2) Resolution and Line Width. The resolution and minimum line width should be sufficient to support all the displayed images such that the displayed information is visible and understandable without misinterpretation from the flightcrew station (see related regulation) in all foreseeable conditions, relative to the operational and lighting environment.
(3) Luminance. Information should be readable over a wide range of ambient illumination under all foreseeable conditions relative to the operating environment, including but not limited to:
• Direct sunlight on the display,
• Sunlight through a front window illuminating white shirts (reflections),
• Sun above the forward horizon and above a cloud deck in a flightcrew member’s eyes, and • Night and/or dark environment.
(a) For low ambient conditions, the display should be dimmable to levels allowing for the flightcrew’s adaptation to the dark, such that outside vision and an acceptable presentation are maintained. (b) Automatic luminance adjustment systems can be employed to decrease pilot workload and increase display life. Operation of these systems should be satisfactory over a wide range of ambient light conditions, including the extreme cases of a forward low sun and a quartering rearward sun shining directly on the display.
1 Some manual adjustment should be retained to provide for normal and nonnormal operating differences so that the luminance variation is not distracting and does not interfere with the flightcrew’s ability to perform their tasks.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
17
2 Displays or layers of displays with uniformly filled areas conveying information such as weather radar imagery should be independently adjustable in luminance from overlaid symbology. The range of luminance control should allow detection of color differences between adjacent small filled areas no larger than 5 milliradians in principal dimension; while at this setting, overlying map symbology, if present, should be discernible. (c) Display luminance variation within the entire flight deck should be minimized so that displayed symbols, lines, or characters of equal luminance remain uniform under any luminance setting and under all foreseeable operating conditions. (4) Contrast Ratio.
(a) The display’s contrast ratio should be sufficient to ensure that the information is discernable under the whole ambient illumination range from the flightcrew station (see related regulation) under all foreseeable conditions relative to the operating environment. (b) The contrast between all symbols, characters, lines, and their associated backgrounds should be sufficient to preclude confusion or ambiguity of any necessary information.
(5) Chromaticity.
(a) The display chromaticity differences, in conjunction with luminance differences, should be sufficient to allow graphic symbols to be discriminated from each other, from their backgrounds (for example, external scene or image background) and background shaded areas, from the flightcrew station (see related regulation), in all foreseeable conditions relative to the lighting environment. Raster or video fields (for example, non-vector graphics such as weather radar) should allow the image to be discriminated from overlaid symbols, and should allow the desired graphic symbols to be displayed. See SAE AS 8034A, sections 4.3.3 and 4.3.4, for additional guidance. (b) The display should provide chromaticity stability over the foreseeable conditions relative to the range of operating temperatures, viewing envelope, image dynamics, and dimming range, such that the symbology is understandable and is not misleading, distracting, or confusing. (6) Gray Scale.
(a) The number of shades of gray and the difference between shades of gray that the display can provide should be adequate for all image content and its use, and should accommodate all viewing conditions.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
18
(b) The display should provide sufficient gray scale stability over the foreseeable range of operating temperatures, viewing envelope, and dimming range, such that the symbology is understandable and is not misleading, distracting, or confusing.
(7) Display Response. The dynamic response of the display should be sufficient to provide discernibility and readability of the displayed information without presenting misleading, distracting, or confusing information. The response time should be sufficient to ensure dynamic stability of colors, line widths, gray scale, and relative positioning of symbols. Undesirable display artifacts and characteristics, such as smearing of moving images and loss of luminance, should be minimized so that information is still readable and identifiable under all foreseeable conditions, not distracting, and does not lead to misinterpretation of data. (8) Display Refresh Rate. The display refresh rate should be sufficient to prevent flicker effects that result in misleading information or difficulty in reading or interpreting information. The display refresh rate should be sufficient to preclude the appearance of unacceptable flicker. (9) Display Update Rate. The display update rate should be sufficient to preclude objectionable motion artifacts that could be misleading or distracting.
(10) Display Defects. Display defects, such as element defects and stroke tails, resulting from hardware and graphical imaging causes should not impair readability of the displays or induce or cause erroneous interpretation. This is covered in more detail in SAE ARP 4256A, SAE AS 8034A, and SAE AS 8055. (11) Reflections. Each pilot compartment must be free of glare and reflections that could interfere with the normal duties of a minimum flightcrew. This must be shown in day and night flight tests under non-precipitation conditions (§ 25.773(a)(2)). The criteria and the basic workload functions and factors for a minimum flightcrew are described in Appendix D to part 25, § 25.1523. (12) Flight Deck Viewing Envelope. The size of the viewing envelope should provide visibility of the flight deck displays over the flightcrew’s normal range of head motion, and support cross-flight deck viewing if necessary; for example, when it is required that the captain be able to view and use the first officer’s primary flight information. See paragraph 16b3, below, for installation guidance. b.
Installation.
(1) Flight deck display equipment and installation designs should be compatible with the overall flight deck design characteristics (such as flight deck size and shape, flightcrew member position, position of windows, external luminance, etc.) as well as
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
19
the airplane environment (such as temperature, altitude, electromagnetic interference, and vibration). (2) RTCA DO-160E, Environmental Conditions and Test Procedures for Airborne Equipment, and European Organization for Civil Aviation Electronics (EUROCAE) ED-14E, Environmental Conditions and Test Procedures for Airborne Equipment, provide information that may be used for an acceptable means of qualifying display equipment for use in the airplane environment.
(3) The display unit must be located in the flight deck such that flight, navigation, and powerplant information for use by any pilot is plainly visible to him from his station with the minimum practicable deviation from his normal position and line of vision when he is looking forward along the flight path (§ 25.1321(a)). The primary flight information on the primary display should not be visually obstructed and should remain prominent. (4) The installation of the display equipment must not adversely affect its readability and the external scene visibility of the flightcrew (see related regulation) under all foreseeable conditions relative to the operating and lighting environment (§25.773 (a)(1)). (5) The installation of the display equipment must not cause glare or reflection, either on the displays or on the flight deck windows, that could interfere with the normal duties of the minimum flightcrew (§ 25.773 (a)(2)) under all foreseeable conditions.
(6) If the display system design is dependent on cross-flight deck viewing for its use, the installation should take into account the viewing angle limitations of the display units, the size of the displayed information, and the distance of the display from each flightcrew member. (7) When a display is used to align or overlay symbols with real-world external data (for example, HUD symbols), the display should be installed such that positioning accuracy of these symbols is maintained during all phases of flight. SAE ARP 5288, Transport Category Airplane Head Up Display (HUD) Systems, provides additional details regarding the symbol positioning accuracy for conformal symbology on a HUD. (8) The display system components should not cause physical harm to the flightcrew under foreseeable conditions relative to the operating environment (for example, turbulence or emergency egress). (9) The installed display must not visually obstruct other controls and instruments or prevent those controls and instruments from performing their intended function (§ 25.1301).
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
20
(10) The display system must not be adversely susceptible to electromagnetic interference from other airplane systems (§ 25.1431) under all foreseeable conditions. (11) The display components should be installed in such a way that they retain mechanical integrity (secured in position) for all foreseeable conditions relative to the flight environment. (12) Liquid spill on or breakage of a display system component in the flightdeck should not result in a hazard.
c. Power Bus Transient. RTCA DO-160E and EUROCAE document ED-14E provide information that may be used for an acceptable means of qualifying display equipment such that the equipment performs its intended function when subjected to anomalous input power. SAE ARP 4256A, Design Objectives for Liquid Crystal Displays for Part 25 (Transport) Aircraft, provides additional information for power transient recovery (specifically for the display unit).
(1) Flight deck displays and display systems should be insensitive to power transients caused by normal load switching operation of the airplane, in accordance with their intended function. (2) The electronic attitude display should not be unusable or unstable for more than one second after electrical bus transients due to engine failure. Only displays on one side of the airplane should be affected by an engine failure. Recognizably valid pitch and roll data should be available within one second on the affected displays and any effects lasting beyond one second should not interfere with the ability to obtain quick glance valid attitude. For most airplanes an engine failure after takeoff will simultaneously create a roll acceleration, new pitch attitude requirements, and an electrical transient. Attitude information is paramount; if there is an engine failure, transfer to standby attitude or transfer of control of the airplane to the other pilot cannot be reliably accomplished in a timely enough manner to prevent an unsafe condition.
In testing this failure mode, experience has shown that switching the generator off at the control panel may not result in the longest electrical transient. One practical way to simulate this failure is with a fuel cut which will allow the generator output voltage and frequency to decrease until the bus control recognizes the failure. Other engine failure conditions may be more critical (such as sub-idle stalls) which cannot be reasonably evaluated during flight test. Analysis should identify these failure modes and show that the preceding criteria are met. (3) Non-normal bus transients (for example, generator failure) should not initiate a power up initialization or cold start process. (4) The display response to a short term power interrupt (<200 milliseconds) should be such that the intended function of the display is not adversely affected.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
21
(5) Following in-flight long term power interrupts (>200 milliseconds), the display system should quickly return to operation in accordance with its intended function, and should continue to permit the safe control of the airplane in attitude, altitude, airspeed, and direction. (6) The large electrical loads required to restart some engine types should not affect more than one pilot’s display during the start sequence. 17. – 20. [RESERVED]
SAFETY ASPECTS OF ELECTRONIC DISPLAY SYSTEMS
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
22
CHAPTER 4. SAFETY ASPECTS OF ELECTRONIC DISPLAY SYSTEMS 21. General. This chapter provides additional guidance and interpretative material for applying §§ 25.1309 and 25.1333(b) to the approval of display systems. Using electronic displays and integrated modular avionics allows designers to integrate systems to a much higher degree than was practical with previous flight deck components. Although operating the airplane may become easier as a result of the integration, evaluating the conditions in which the display system could fail and determining the severity of the resulting failure effects may become more complex. The evaluation of the failure conditions should identify the display function and include all causes that could affect that function’s display and display equipment. Section 25.1309 defines the basic safety requirements for the airworthiness approval of airplane systems. The tables in this chapter use the ARAC recommended text for revising the existing § 25.1309 hazard classifications and associated probabilities. The ARAC recommendations for revising the existing AC 25.1309-1A, System Design and Analysis, provide guidance that may be used to establish an acceptable means of compliance. Refer to Appendix 5 of this AC for references on where to find more information regarding the ARAC recommendations.
a. Identification of Failure Conditions. One of the initial steps in establishing compliance with § 25.1309 is identifying the failure conditions that are associated with a display or a display system. The following paragraphs provide material that may be useful in supporting this initial activity. The analysis of the failure condition should identify the impacted functionality, the effect on the airplane and/or its occupants, any considerations related to phase of flight, and identify any flight deck indication, flightcrew action, or other relevant mitigation means.
(1) The type of display system failure conditions will depend, to a large extent, on the architecture (Integrated Modular Avionics, Federated System, Non-Federated System, etc.), design philosophy, and implementation of the system. Types of failure conditions include:
• Loss of function (system or display). • Failure of display controls – loss of function or malfunction such that controls perform in an inappropriate manner, including erroneous display control.
• Malfunction (system or display) that leads to:
o Partial loss of data, or
o Erroneous display of data that is either:
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
23
- Detected by the system (for example, flagged or comparator alert),
and/or easily detectable by the flightcrew; or - Difficult to detect by the flightcrew or not detectable and assumed to be
correct (for example, “Misleading display of ….”).
(2) When a flight deck design includes primary and standby displays, consider failure conditions involving the failure of standby displays in combination with the failure of primary displays. The flightcrew may use standby instruments in two complementary roles following the failure of primary displays:
(a) Redundant display to cope with failure of main instruments, or
(b) Independent third source of information to resolve inconsistencies between primary instruments.
(3) When the display of erroneous information is caused by failure of other systems which interface with the display system, the effects of these failures may not be limited to the display system. Associated failure conditions may be dealt with at the airplane level or within the other systems’ safety assessment, as appropriate, in order to assess the cumulative effect.
b. Effects of Display Failure Conditions. The effects of display system failure conditions on safe operations are highly dependent on pilot skills, flight deck procedures, phase of flight, type of operations being conducted, and instrument or visual meteorological conditions.
(1) Based on previous airplane certification programs, paragraph 21e of this AC shows examples of safety objectives for certain failure conditions. These safety objectives do not preclude the need for a safety assessment of the actual effects of these failures, which may be more or less severe depending on the design. Therefore, during the § 25.1309 safety assessment process, the FAA will need to agree with the applicant’s hazard classifications for these failure conditions in order for the assessment to be considered valid.
(2) When assessing the effects that result from a display failure consider the following, accounting for phases of flight when relevant:
• Effects on the flightcrew’s ability to control the airplane in terms of attitude, speed, accelerations, and flight path, potentially resulting in:
o Controlled flight into terrain,
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
24
o Loss of control of the airplane during flight and/or
during critical flight phases (approach, take-off, goaround, etc.),
o Inadequate performance capability for phase of
flight, including:
Loss of obstacle clearance capability, and
Exceeding takeoff or landing field length.
o Exceeding the flight envelope,
o Exceeding the structural integrity of the airplane, and
o Causing or contributing to pilot induced oscillations.
• Effects on the flightcrew’s ability to control the engines, such as:
o Those effects resulting in shutting down a non-failed
engine in response to the failure of a different engine, and
o Undetected, significant thrust loss.
• Effects on the flightcrew’s management of the airplane systems.
• Effects on the flightcrew’s performance, workload and ability to cope with adverse operating conditions.
• Effects on situation awareness; for example, the specific effects must be identified, such as situation awareness related to navigation or system status.
• Effects on automation if the display is used as a controlling device.
(3) When the display system is used as a control device for other airplane systems, consider the cumulative effect of a display system failure on all of the controlled systems.
c. Mitigation of Failure Conditions.
(1) When determining mitigation means for a failure condition consider the following:
• Protection against common mode failures.
• Fault isolation and reconfiguration.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
25
• Redundancy (for example, heading information may be provided by an independent integrated standby and/or a magnetic direction indicator).
SAFETY ASPECTS OF ELECTRONIC DISPLAY SYSTEMS › d. Validation of the Classification of Failure Conditions a
• Availability of, level of, timeliness of, and type of, alert provided to the flightcrew.
• The flight phase and the aircraft configuration.
• The duration of the condition.
• The aircraft motion cues that may be used by the flightcrew for recognition.
• Expected flightcrew corrective action on detection of the failure, and/or operational procedures.
• In some flight phases, ability of the flightcrew to control the airplane after a loss of primary attitude display on one side.
• The flightcrew’s ability to turn off a display (for example, full bright display at night).
• Protections provided by other systems (for example, flight envelope protection or augmentation systems).
(2) The mitigation means should be described in the safety analysis/assessment document or by reference to another document (for example, a system description document). The continued performance of the mitigation means, in the presence of the failure conditions, should also be identified and assured. (3) The safety assessment should include the rationale and coverage of any display system protection and monitoring philosophies used in the design. The safety assessment should also include an evaluation of each of the identified display system failure conditions and an analysis of the exposure to common mode/cause or cascade failures in accordance with ARAC’s recommendations for revising AC 25.1309-1A. Additionally, the safety assessment should justify and describe any functional partitioning schemes employed to reduce the effect of integrated component failures or functional failures.
d. Validation of the Classification of Failure Conditions and Their Effects. There may be situations where the severity of the effect of the failure condition identified in the safety analysis needs to be confirmed. Laboratory, simulator, or flight test may be appropriate to accomplish the confirmation. The method of validating the failure condition classification will depend on the effect of the condition, assumptions made, and any associated risk. If flightcrew action is expected to cope with the effect of a failure condition, the information available to the flightcrew should be useable for detection of the failure condition and to initiate corrective action.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
26
e. System Safety Guidelines.
(1) Experience from previous certification programs has shown that a single failure due to a loss or malfunction of the display system, a sensor, or some other dependent system, which causes the misleading display of primary flight information, may have negative safety effects. It is recommended that the display system design and architecture implement monitoring of the primary flight information to reduce the probability of displaying misleading information. (2) Experience from previous certification programs has shown that the combined failure of both primary displays with the loss of the standby system can result in failure conditions with catastrophic effects.
(3) When an integrated standby display is used to provide a backup means of primary flight information, the safety analysis should substantiate that common cause failures have been adequately addressed in the design, including the design of software and complex hardware. In particular, the safety analysis should show that the independence between the primary instruments and the integrated standby instruments is not violated because the integrated standby display may interface with a large number of airplane components, including power supplies, pitot static ports, and other sensors.
(4) There should be a means to detect the loss or erroneous primary flight information, either as a result of a display system failure or the failure of an associated sensor. When loss or malfunction of primary flight information is detected, the means used to indicate the lost or erroneous information should ensure that the erroneous information will not be used by the flightcrew (for example, removal of the information from the display or placement of an “X” through the failed display). (5) The means used to indicate the lost or erroneous information, when it is detected, should be independent of the failure mechanism. For example, the processor that originates the erroneous parameter should not be the same processor that annunciates or removes the erroneous parameter from the display. Common mode failures of identical processor types should be considered (for example, common mode failures may exist in a processor used to compute the display parameters and an identical processor used for monitoring and annunciating failures.) (6) A catastrophic failure condition should not result from the failure of a single component, part, or element of a system. Failure containment should be provided by the system design to limit the propagation of the effects of any single failure and preclude catastrophic failure conditions. In addition, there should not be a common cause failure that could affect both the single component, part, or element and its failure containment provisions.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
27
(7) For safety-critical display parameters, there should be a means to verify the correctness of sensor input data. Range, staleness, and validity checks should be used where possible. (8) The latency period induced by the display system, particularly for alerts, should not be excessive and should take into account the criticality of the alert and the required crew response time to minimize propagation of the failure condition. (9) For those systems that integrate windowing architecture into the display system, a means should be provided to control the information shown on the displays, such that the integrity of the display system as a whole will not be adversely impacted by anomalies in the functions being integrated. This means of controlling the display of information, called window manager in this AC, should be developed to the software assurance level at least as high as the highest integrity function of any window. For example, a window manager should be level “A” if the information displayed in any window is level “A” (see RTCA DO-178B).
SAE ARP 4754, Certification Consideration for Highly-Integrated or Complex Aircraft Systems, provides a recommended practice for system development assurance. (10) System Safety Assessment Guidelines. The complete set of failure conditions to be considered in the display system safety analysis and the associated safety objective are established during the system safety assessment, and agreed upon by the applicant and the approving civil airworthiness authority. The safety assessment should consider the full set of display system intended functions as well as display system architecture and design philosophy (for example, failure modes, failure detection and annunciation, redundancy management, system and component independence and isolation). The system safety analysis is required by § 25.1309, and indirectly by other regulations, including § 25.901, § 25.903, and § 25.1333.
(a) This AC adopts the ARAC recommendations for revising the current AC 25.1309-1A. This AC uses the terms “major” and “hazardous” to identify what AC 25.1309-1A refers to as a “major” failure condition. Also, for major and hazardous failure conditions identified as “Improbable” in AC 25.1309-1A and AC 25-11, this AC includes the ARAC recommended probabilities “Remote” and “Extremely Remote,” respectively. (b) This AC also includes the ARAC recommended terms “catastrophic,” “failure,” “failure condition,” “hazardous failure condition,” and “minor failure condition.” ARAC recommended that these terms be included if the current AC 25.1309-1A is revised. Appendix 3 of this AC 25-11A includes the definitions of these terms. (c) The following tables provide examples of failure conditions and associated hazard classifications and safety objectives common to numerous display systems
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
28
that are already certified. These tables are provided to support consistency in determining hazard classifications across multiple applicants, multiple certification offices, and multiple display system designs; however, these are only examples. These examples do not replace the need for a system safety assessment and are not an exhaustive list of failure conditions. For these example failure conditions, additional functional capabilities or less operational mitigation may result in higher hazard classifications, while reduced functional capability or increase operational mitigation may result in lower hazard classifications.
1 Attitude (Pitch and Roll). The following table lists examples of safety objectives for attitude related failure conditions.
Table 3 Example Safety Objectives for
Attitude Failure Conditions
Failure Condition
Hazard Classification Qualitative
Probability Loss of all attitude displays, including standby display
Catastrophic Extremely Improbable
Loss of all primary attitude displays Major – Hazardous(*) Remote - Extremely Remote (*) Display of misleading attitude information on both primary displays
Catastrophic Extremely Improbable
Display of misleading attitude information on one primary display
Hazardous Extremely Remote
Display of misleading attitude information on the standby display
Major Remote
Display of misleading attitude information on one primary display combined with a standby failure (loss of attitude or incorrect attitude)
Catastrophic Extremely Improbable (**)
(*) System architecture and functional integration should be considered in determining the classification within this range. This failure may result in a sufficiently large reduction in safety margins to warrant a hazardous classification. (**) Consistent with the “Loss of all attitude display, including standby display” safety objective, since the flightcrew may not be able to identify the correct display. Consideration will be given to the ability of the flightcrew to control the airplane after a
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
29
loss of attitude primary display on one side in some flight phases (for example, during takeoff).
2 Airspeed. The following table lists examples of safety objectives for airspeed related failure conditions.
Table 4 Example Safety Objectives for
Airspeed Failure Conditions Failure Condition
Hazard Classification Qualitative
Probability Loss of all airspeed displays, including standby display
Catastrophic Extremely Improbable
Loss of all primary airspeed displays
Major – Hazardous(*) Remote - Extremely Remote(*) Display of misleading airspeed information on both primary displays, coupled with loss of stall warning or loss of over-speed warning
Catastrophic Extremely Improbable
Display of misleading airspeed information of the standby display (primary airspeed still available)
Major Remote
Display of misleading airspeed information on one primary display combined with a standby failure (loss of airspeed or incorrect airspeed)
Catastrophic Extremely Improbable (**)
(*) System architecture and functional integration should be considered in determining the classification within this range. This failure may result in a sufficiently large reduction in safety margins to warrant a hazardous classification. (**) Consistent with the “Loss of all airspeed display, including standby display” safety objective, since the flightcrew may not be able to separate out the correct display.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
30
3 Barometric Altitude. The following table lists examples of safety objectives for barometric altitude related failure conditions.
Table 5 Example Safety Objectives for Barometric Altitude Failure Conditions Failure Condition
Hazard Classification Qualitative
Probability Loss of all barometric altitude displays, including standby display
Catastrophic Extremely Improbable
Loss of all barometric altitude primary displays
Major – Hazardous(*) Remote - Extremely Remote(*) Display of misleading barometric altitude information on both primary displays
Catastrophic Extremely Improbable
Display of misleading barometric altitude information on the standby display (primary barometric altitude still available)
Major Remote
Display of misleading barometric altitude information on one primary display combined with a standby failure (loss of altitude or incorrect altitude)
Catastrophic Extremely Improbable (**)
(*) System architecture and functional integration should be considered in determining the classification within this range. This failure may result in a sufficiently large reduction in safety margins to warrant a hazardous classification. (**) Consistent with the “Loss of all barometric altitude display, including standby display” safety objective since the flightcrew may not be able to separate out the correct display. Consideration should be given that barometric setting function design is commensurate with the safety objectives identified for barometric altitude.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
31
4 Heading. The following table lists examples of safety objectives for heading related failure conditions.
(aa) The standby heading may be provided by an independent integrated standby or the magnetic direction indicator.
(bb) The safety objectives listed below can be alleviated if it can be demonstrated that track information is available and correct.
Table 6 Example Safety Objectives for
Heading Failure Conditions
Failure Condition
Hazard Classification Qualitative
Probability Loss of stabilized heading in the flight deck
Major Remote
Loss of all heading displays in the flight deck
Catastrophic Extremely Improbable
Display of misleading heading information on both pilots' primary displays
Major – Hazardous(*) Remote - Extremely Remote(*)
Display of misleading heading information on one primary display combined with a standby failure (loss of heading or incorrect heading)
Major – Hazardous (*) Remote – Extremely Remote(*)
(*) System architecture and functional integration should be considered in determining the classification within this range. This failure may result in a sufficiently large reduction in safety margins to warrant a hazardous classification. (**) This assumes the availability of an independent, non-stabilized heading required by § 25.1303 (a)(3).
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
32
5 Navigation and Communication (Excluding Heading, Airspeed, and Clock Data). The following table lists examples of safety objectives for navigation and communication related failure conditions.
Table 7 Example Safety Objectives for Certain Navigation and Communication
Failure Conditions
Failure Condition
Hazard Classification Qualitative
Probability Loss of display of all navigation information
Major(*) Remote(*)
Non-restorable loss of display of all navigation information coupled with a total loss of communication functions
Catastrophic Extremely Improbable
Display of misleading navigation information simultaneously to both pilots
Major – Hazardous Remote – Extremely Remote
Loss of all communication functions
Major Remote
(*) “All” means loss of all navigation information, excluding heading, airspeed, and clock data. If any or all of the latter information is also lost then a higher classification may be warranted.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
33
6 Other Parameters (Typically Shown on Electronic Display Systems). The following table lists examples of safety objectives for failure conditions related to other parameters typically shown on electronic display systems.
Table 8 Example Safety Objectives for Failure Conditions of Other Parameters Failure Condition
Hazard Classification Qualitative
Probability Display of misleading flight path vector information to one pilot
Major Remote (*)
Loss of all vertical speed displays Major Remote Display of misleading vertical speed information to both pilots
Major Remote
Loss of all slip/skid indication displays
Major Remote
Display of misleading slip/skid indication to both pilots
Major Remote
Display of misleading weather radar information
Major Remote (**)
Total loss of flightcrew alerting displays
Major (***) Remote
Display of misleading flightcrew alerting information
Major Remote
Display of misleading flightcrew procedures
Major - Catastrophic Remote – Extremely Improbable (****) Loss of the standby displays Major Remote
(*) The safety objective may be more stringent depending on the use and on the phase of flight. (**) Applicable to the display part of the system only. (***) Applicable to the general case, however, some cases could be more severe. Additional guidance is in the ARAC recommendations for proposed AC 25.1322. (****) To be evaluated depending on the particular procedures and associated situations.
7 Engine. Table 9, below, lists examples of generally accepted safety objectives for engine related failure conditions. Appendix 2 of this AC provides additional guidance for powerplant displays.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
34
(aa) The term “required engine indications” refers specifically to the engine thrust/power setting parameter (for example, engine pressure ratio, fan speed, or torque) and any other engine indications that may be required by the flightcrew to maintain the engine within safe operating limits (for example, rotor speeds or exhaust gas temperature). (bb) The information in Table 9 is based on the premise that the display failure occurs while operating in an autonomous engine control mode. Autonomous engine control modes, such as those provided by full authority digital engine controls, protect continued safe operation of the engine at any thrust lever setting. Hence, the flight deck indications and associated flightcrew actions are not the primary means of protecting safe engine operation. (cc) Where the indications serve as the primary means of assuring continued safe engine operation, the hazard classification may be more severe. For example, under the table entry “Loss of one or more required engine indications on more than one engine,” the hazard classification would change to “Catastrophic” and the probability would change to “Extremely Improbable.” (dd) Each of the general failure condition descriptions provided in Table 9 represents a set of more specific failure conditions. The hazard classifications and probabilities provided in Table 9 represent the most severe outcome typically associated with any failure condition within the set. If considered separately, some of the specific failure conditions within each set would likely have less severe hazard classifications and probabilities.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
35
Table 9 Example Safety Objectives for
Engine Failure Conditions Failure Condition
Hazard Classification Qualitative Probability Loss of one or more required engine indications for a single engine
Major Remote
Misleading display of one or more required engine indications for a single engine
Major Remote
Loss of one or more required engine indications for more than one engine
Hazardous Extremely Remote(*)
Misleading display of any required engine indications for more than one engine
Catastrophic Extremely Improbable(**)
(*) The worst anticipated outcomes associated with this class of failure may often be driven by consideration of the simultaneous loss of all required engine indications. In any case, those outcomes will typically include both a high speed takeoff abort and loss of the backup means to assure safe engine operations. High speed aborts have typically been classified as “hazardous” by the FAA due to the associated impacts on both flightcrew workload and safety margins. Since any number of single failures or errors can defeat the protections of a typical autonomous engine control, losing the ability to backup the control is considered a sufficiently large reduction in the safety margins to also warrant a “hazardous” classification. Hence the “Extremely Remote” design guideline was chosen. (**) If the power setting parameter is indicating higher than actual during takeoff, this can lead directly to a catastrophe, either due to a high speed runway overrun or impacting an obstacle after takeoff. This classification has been debated and sustained by the FAA numerous times in the past. Hence the “Extremely Improbable” probability is listed.
8 Use of Display Systems as Controls. Hazard classifications and safety objectives are not provided for display systems used as controls because the failure conditions are dependant on the functions and systems being controlled or on alternative means of control. The use of display systems as controls is described in Chapter 7 of this AC. The following table lists the failure conditions when display systems are used as controls.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
36
Table 10 Failure Conditions for Display Systems Used as Controls Failure Condition
Qualitative Probability Total loss of capability to use the display system as a control Depends on system being controlled. Undetected erroneous input from the display system as a control Depends on system being controlled. 22. – 30. [RESERVED]
31. Display Information Elements and Features. This chapte
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
37
CHAPTER 5. ELECTRONIC DISPLAY INFORMATION ELEMENTS AND FEATURES
31. Display Information Elements and Features. This chapter provides guidance for the display of information elements including text, labels, symbols, graphics, and other depictions (such as schematics) in isolation and in combination. It covers the design and format of these information elements within a given display area. Chapter 6 of this AC covers the integration of information across several display areas in the flight deck, including guidance on flight deck information location, display arrangement, windowing, redundancy management, and failure management.
a. General.
(1) The following list provides objectives for each display information element, in accordance with its intended function:
• Each flight, navigation, and powerplant instrument for use by any pilot must be plainly visible to him from his station with the minimum practicable deviation from his normal position and line of vision when he is looking forward along the flight path (§ 25.1321(a)).
• The displayed information should be easily and clearly discernable, and have enough visual contrast for the pilot to see and interpret it. Overall, the display should allow the pilot to identify and discriminate the information without eyestrain. Refer to paragraph 16a(4) of this AC for additional guidance regarding contrast ratio.
• For all display configurations, all foreseeable conditions relative to lighting should be considered. Foreseeable lighting considerations should include failure modes such as lighting and power system failure, the full range of flight deck lighting and display system lighting options, and the operational environment (for example, day and night operations). If a visual indicator is provided to indicate a malfunction of an instrument, it must be effective under all foreseeable lighting conditions (§ 25.1321(e)).
• Information elements (text, symbol, etc.) should be large enough for the pilot to see and interpret in all foreseeable conditions relative to the operating environment and from the flightcrew station (see related regulation). If two or more pilots need to view the information, the information elements should also be discernable and interpretable over these viewing distances.
• The pilots should have a clear, unobstructed, and undistorted view of the displayed information.
31. Display Information Elements and Features. This chapte › c. Display Information Elements.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
38
• Information elements should be distinct and permit the pilots to immediately recognize the source of the information elements when there are multiple sources of the same kind of information. For example, if there are multiple sources for vertical guidance information, then each informational element should be distinct so the flightcrew can immediately recognize the source of the vertical guidance.
(2) Factors to consider when designing and evaluating the viewability and readability of the displayed information include:
• Position of displayed information: Distance from the design eye position (DEP) is generally used. If cross-flight deck viewing of the information is needed, distance from the offside DEP, accounting for normal head movement, should be used. For displays not mounted on the front panel, the distance determination should include any expected movement away from the DEP by the flightcrew.
• Vibrations: Readability should be maintained in adverse conditions, such as vibration. One possible cause of vibration is sustained engine imbalance. AC 25-24, Sustained Engine Imbalance, provides readability guidance for that condition.
• Visual Angles: Account for both the position of the displayed information as well as font height. SAE ARP 4102/7, Electronic Displays, provides additional information on this subject.
• Readability of Display Information: The Illuminating Engineering Society classifies three main parameters that affect readability: luminance, size, and contrast. Size is the combination of font size and distance from the display.
b. Consistency. Display information should be presented so it is consistent with the flight deck design philosophy in terms of symbology, location, control, behavior, size, shape, color, labels, dynamics and alerts. Consistency also applies to the representation of information on multiple displays on the same flight deck. Display information representing the same thing on more than one display on the same flight deck should be consistent. Acronyms and labels should be used consistently, and messages/annunciations should contain text in a consistent way. Inconsistencies should be evaluated to ensure that they are not susceptible to confusion or errors, and do not adversely impact the intended function of the system(s) involved.
c. Display Information Elements.
(1) Text. Text should be shown to be distinct and meaningful for the information presented. Messages should convey the meaning intended. Abbreviations and
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
39
acronyms should be clear and consistent with established standards. For example, International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) document 8400, Procedures for Air Navigation Services ICAO Abbreviations and Codes, provides internationally recognized standard abbreviations and airport identifiers.
(a) Regardless of the font type, size, color, and background, text should be readable in all foreseeable lighting and operating conditions from the flightcrew station (§ 25.1321(a)). General guidelines for text are as follows:
• Standard grammatical use of upper and lower case letters is recommended for lengthy documentation and lengthy messages. Using this format is also helpful when the structure of the text is in sentence form.
• The use of only upper case letters for text labels is acceptable.
• Avoid contractions, such as “can’t” instead of “cannot.”
• Break lines of text only at spaces or other natural delimiters.
• Avoid abbreviations and acronyms where practical.
• SAE ARP 4102/7, Electronic Displays, provides guidelines on font sizes that are generally acceptable.
(b) The choice of font also affects readability. The following guidelines apply:
• To facilitate readability, the font chosen should be compatible with the display technology. For example, serif fonts may become distorted on some low pixel resolution displays. However, on displays where serif fonts have been found acceptable, they have been found to be useful for depicting full sentences or larger text strings.
• Sans serif fonts (for example, Futura or Helvetica) are recommended for displays viewed under extreme lighting conditions. (2) Labels. Labels may be text or icons. The following paragraphs provide guidance on labeling items such as knobs, buttons, symbols, and menus. This guidance applies to labels that are on a display, label a display, or label a display control. Section 25.1555(a) requires that each flight deck control, other than controls whose function is obvious, must be plainly marked as to its function and method of operation. Controls whose functions are not obvious should be marked or identified so that a flightcrew member with little or no familiarity with the airplane is able to rapidly, accurately, and consistently identify their functions.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
40
(a) Text and icons should be shown to be distinct and meaningful for the function(s) they label. Standard or non-ambiguous symbols, abbreviations, and nomenclature should be used; for example, in order to be distinct from barometric altitude, any displayed altitude that is geometrically derived should be labeled “GSL.” (b) If a control performs more than one function the labels should include all intended functions, unless the function of the control is obvious. Labels of graphical controls accessed via a cursor control device should be included on the graphical display.
(c) The following are guidelines and recommendations for labels:
• Data fields should be uniquely identified either with the unit of measurement or a descriptive label. However, some basic “T” instruments have been found to be acceptable without units of measurement.
• Labels should be consistent with related labels located elsewhere in the flight deck.
• When a control or indication occurs in multiple places (for example, a “Return” control on multiple pages of a flight management function), the label should be consistent across all occurrences. (d) Labels should be placed such that:
• The spatial relationships between labels and the objects they reference are clear.
• Labels for display controls are on or adjacent to the controls they identify.
• Labels for display controls are not obstructed by the associated controls.
• Labels are oriented to facilitate readability. For example, the labels continuously maintain an upright orientation or align with an associated symbol such as a runway or airway.
• On multi-function displays, a label should be used to indicate the active function(s), unless its function is obvious. When the function is no longer active or being displayed, the label should be removed unless
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
41
another means of showing availability of that function is used. For example, graying out an inactive menu button.
(e) When using icons instead of text labels, only brief exposure to the icon should be needed in order for the flightcrew to determine the function and method of operation of a control. The use of icons should not cause flightcrew confusion.
(3) Symbols.
(a) Electronic display symbol appearance and dynamics should be designed to enhance flightcrew comprehension and retention, and minimize flightcrew workload and errors in accordance with the intended function. The following list provides guidance for symbol appearance and dynamics:
• Symbols should be positioned with sufficient accuracy to avoid interpretation errors or significantly increase interpretation time.
• Each symbol used should be identifiable and distinguishable from other related symbols.
• The shape, dynamics, and other symbol characteristics representing the same function on more than one display on the same flight deck should be consistent.
• Symbol modifiers used to convey multiple levels of information should follow depiction rules clearly stated by the applicant. Symbol modifiers are changes to easily recognized baseline symbols such as colors, fill, and borders.
• Symbols that represent physical objects (for example, navigational aids and traffic) should not be misleading as to the object’s physical characteristics (including position, size, envelope, and orientation). (b) Within the flight deck, avoid using the same symbol for different purposes, unless it can be shown that there is no potential for misinterpretation errors or increases in flightcrew training times. (c) It is recommended that standardized symbols be used. The symbols in the following SAE documents have been found to be acceptable for compliance to the regulations:
• SAE ARP 4102/7, Electronic Displays, Appendices A through C (for primary flight, navigation, and powerplant displays);
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
42
• SAE ARP 5289, Electronic Aeronautical Symbols, (for depiction of navigation symbology); and
• SAE ARP 5288, Transport Category Airplane Head Up Display (HUD) Systems, (for HUD symbology).
(4) Indications. The following paragraphs provide guidance on numeric readouts, gauges, scales, tapes and graphical depictions such as schematics. Graphics related to interactivity are discussed in paragraph 31e of this chapter and Chapter 7 of this AC. Graphics and display indications should:
• Be readily understood and compatible with other graphics and indications in the flight deck.
• Be identifiable and readily distinguishable.
• Follow the guidance for viewability presented in paragraphs 31a, 31b, 31c(1), and 31c(2) of this chapter.
(a) Numeric Readouts. Numeric readouts include displays that emulate rotating drum readouts where the numbers scroll, as well as displays where the digit locations stay fixed.
1 Data accuracy of the numeric readout should be sufficient for the intended function and to avoid inappropriate flightcrew response. The number of significant digits should be appropriate to the data accuracy. Leading zeroes should not be displayed unless convention dictates otherwise (for example, heading and track). As the digits change or scroll, there should not be any confusing motion effects such that the apparent motion does not match the actual trend. 2 When a numeric readout is not associated with any scale, tape, or pointer, it may be difficult for pilots to determine the margin relative to targets or limits, or compare between numeric parameters. A scale, dial, or tape may be needed to accomplish the intended flightcrew task. 3 For North, numeric readouts of heading should indicate 360, as opposed to 000.
(b) Scales, Dials, and Tapes. Scales, dials, and tapes with fixed and/or moving pointers have been shown to effectively improve flightcrew interpretation of numeric data.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
43
1 The displayed range should be sufficient to perform the intended function. If the entire operational range is not shown at any given time, the transition to the other portions of the range should not be distracting or confusing. 2 Scale resolution should be sufficient to perform the intended task. Scales may be used without an associated numeric readout if alone they provide sufficient accuracy for the intended function. When numeric readouts are used in conjunction with scales, they should be located close enough to the scale to ensure proper association, yet not detract from the interpretation of the graphic or the readout. 3 Delimiters, such as tick marks, should allow rapid interpretation without adding unnecessary clutter. Markings and labels should be positioned such that their meaning is clear yet they do not hinder interpretation. Pointers and indexes should not obscure the scales or delimiters such that they can no longer be interpreted. Pointers and indexes should be positioned with sufficient accuracy for their intended function. Accuracy includes effects due to data resolution, latency, graphical positioning, etc.
(c) Other Graphical Depictions. Depictions include schematics, synoptics, and other graphics such as attitude indications, moving maps, and vertical situation displays.
1 To avoid visual clutter, graphic elements should be included only if they add useful information content, reduce flightcrew access or interpretation time, or decrease the probability of interpretation error. 2 To the extent it is practical and necessary, the graphic orientation and the flightcrew’s frame of reference should be correlated. For example, left indications should be on the left side of the graphic and higher altitudes should be shown above lower altitudes. 3 If there are multiple depictions, such as “thumbnail” or overlayed depictions, the orientation (for example, heading up, track up, North up, etc.) should be the same for each depiction. This does not apply to other systems where the captain and first officer may select different presentations of the same information and are used exclusively by that flightcrew member. 4 Graphics that include 3-Dimensional effects, such as raised buttons or the airplane flight path in a perspective view, should ensure that the symbol elements used to achieve these effects will not be incorrectly interpreted.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
44
(5) Color Coding.
(a) If color is used for coding at least one other distinctive coding parameter should be used (for example, size, shape, location, etc.). Normal aging of the eye can reduce the ability to sharply focus on red objects, or discriminate blue from green. For pilots with such a deficiency, display interpretation workload may be unacceptably increased unless symbology is coded in more dimensions than color alone. However, the use of color alone for coding information has been shown to be acceptable in some cases, such as weather radar and terrain depiction on the lateral view of the navigation display. (b) To ensure correct information transfer, the consistent use and standardization of color is highly desirable. In order to avoid confusion or interpretation error, there should not be a change in how the color is perceived over all foreseeable conditions. Colors used for one purpose in one information set should not be used for an incompatible purpose that could create a misunderstanding within another information set.
In particular, consistent use and standardization for red and amber or yellow, per § 25.1322, is required to retain the effectiveness of flightcrew alerts. A common application is the progression from green to amber to red, representing increasing degrees of threat, potential hazard, safety criticality, or need for flightcrew awareness or response. Inconsistencies in the use of color should be evaluated to ensure that they are not susceptible to confusion or errors, and do not adversely impact the intended function of the system(s) involved. (c) If color is used for coding it is considered good practice to use six colors or less for coding parameters. Each coded color should have sufficient chrominance separation so it is identifiable and distinguishable in all foreseeable lighting and operating conditions and when used with other colors. Colors should be identifiable and distinguishable across the range of information element size, shape, and movement.
The colors available for coding from an electronic display system should be carefully selected to maximize their chrominance separation. Color combinations that are similar in luminance should be avoided (for example, Navy blue on black or yellow on white). (d) Other graphic depictions such as terrain maps and synthetic vision presentations may use more than six colors and use color blending techniques to represent colors in the outside world or to emphasize terrain features. These displays are often presented as background imagery and the colors used in the displays should not interfere with the flightcrew interpretation of overlaid information parameters as addressed in paragraph 31c(5)(e)1 of this chapter.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
45
(e) The following table depicts previously accepted color coding and the functional meaning associated with each color. The use of these colors is recommended for electronic display systems with color displays.
Table 11 Recommended Colors for Certain Functions
Feature Color Warnings Red Flight envelope and system limits, exceedances
Red or Yellow/Amber as appropriate (see above)
Cautions, non-normal sources Yellow/Amber Scales, dials, tapes, and associated information elements
White*
Earth Tan/Brown Sky Blue/Cyan Engaged Modes/normal conditions Green Instrument landing system deviation pointer
Magenta
Divisor lines, units and labels for inactive soft buttons
Light Gray
* Use of the color green for tape elements (for example airspeed and altitude) has also been found acceptable if the color green does not adversely affect flightcrew alerting.
(f) The following table depicts display features that should be allocated a color from either Color Set 1 or Color Set 2.
Table 12 Specified Colors for Certain Display Features Display Feature
Color Set 1 Color Set 2
Fixed reference symbols White Yellow* Current data, values White Green Armed modes White Cyan Selected data, values Green Cyan Selected heading Magenta** Cyan Active route/flight plan Magenta White * Use of the color yellow for functions other than flightcrew alerting should be limited and should not adversely affect flightcrew alerting.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
46
** In Color Set 1, magenta is intended to be associated with those analog parameters that constitute “fly to” or “keep centered” type information.
(g) The following color pairs should be avoided:
• Saturated red and blue, • Saturated red and green, • Saturated blue and green, • Saturated yellow and green, • Yellow on purple, • Yellow on green, • Yellow on white, • Magenta on green, • Magenta on black (although this may be acceptable for lower criticality items), • Green on white, • Blue on black, and • Red on black.
For further information on this subject see the FAA report Human Factors Design Guide Update (Report Number DOT/FAA/CT-96/01): A Revision to Chapter 8 - Human Interface Guidelines. (h) When background color is used (for example, gray), it should not impair the use of the overlaid information elements. Labels, display-based controls, menus, symbols, and graphics should all remain identifiable and distinguishable. The use of background color should conform to the overall flight deck philosophies for color usage and information management. If texturing is used to create a background, it should not result in loss of readability of the symbols overlaid on it, nor should it increase visual clutter or pilot information access time. Transparency is a means of seeing a background information element through a foreground one – the use of transparency should be minimized because it may increase pilot interpretation time or errors. (i) Requiring the flightcrew to discriminate between shades of the same color for distinct meaning is not recommended. The use of pure blue should not be used for important information because it has low luminance on many display technologies (for example, CRT and LCD).
(j) Any foreseeable change in symbol size should ensure correct color interpretation; for example, the symbol needs to be sufficiently large so the pilot can interpret the correct color.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
47
d. Dynamic (Graphic) Information Elements on a Display.
(1) General. The following paragraphs cover the motion of graphic information elements on a display, such as the indices on a tape display. Graphic objects that translate or rotate should do so smoothly without distracting or objectionable jitter, jerkiness, or ratcheting effects. Data update rates for information elements used in direct airplane or powerplant manual control tasks (such as attitude, engine parameters, etc.) equal to or greater than 15 Hertz have been found to be acceptable. Any lag introduced by the display system should be consistent with the airplane control task associated with that parameter. In particular, display system lag (including the sensor) for attitude which does not exceed a first order equivalent time constant of 100 milliseconds for airplanes with conventional control system response is generally acceptable.
(2) Movement of display information elements should not blur, shimmer, or produce unintended dynamic effects such that the image becomes distracting or difficult to interpret. Filtering or coasting of data intended to smooth the motion of display elements should not introduce significant positioning errors or create system lag that makes it difficult to perform the intended task. (3) When a symbol reaches the limit of its allowed range of motion, the symbol should either slide from view, change visual characteristics, or be self-evident that further deflection is impossible. (4) Dynamic information should not appreciably change shape or color as it moves. Objects that change sizes (for example, as the map range changes) should not cause confusion as to their meaning and should remain consistent throughout their size range. At all sizes the objects should meet the guidance of this chapter as applicable (that is, the objects should be discernable, legible, identifiable, placed accurately, not distracting, etc.).
e. Sharing Information on a Display. There are three primary methods of sharing information on a given display. First, the information may be overlayed or combined, such as when traffic alert and collision avoidance system (TCAS) information is overlayed on a map display. Second, the information can be time shared so that the pilot toggles between functions, one at a time. Third, the information may be displayed in separate physical areas or windows that are concurrently displayed. Regardless of the method of information sharing, care should be taken to ensure that information that is out prioritized, but is needed, can be recovered, and that it will not be needed more quickly than it can be recovered.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
48
(1) Overlays and Combined Information Elements. The following guidelines apply:
• When information is graphically overlaid over other information (for example, an airplane symbol over a waypoint symbol) in the same location on a display, the loss of information availability, information access times, and potential for confusion should be minimized.
• When information obscures other information it should be shown that the obscured information is either not needed when it is obscured or can be rapidly recovered. Needed information should not be obscured. This may be accomplished by protecting certain areas of the display. • If information is integrated with other information on a display, the projection, the placement accuracy, the directional orientation and the display data ranges should all be consistent (for example, when traffic or weather is integrated with navigation information). When information elements temporarily obscure other information (for example, pop-up menus or windows), the resultant loss of information should not cause a hazard in accordance with the obscured information’s intended function.
(2) Time Sharing. The following guidelines apply:
• Guidance on Full-time vs. Part-time Displays (see paragraph 36c(3) of this AC). • Any information that should or must be continuously monitored by the flightcrew should be displayed at all times (for example, attitude).
• Whether or not information may be time shared depends on how easily it can be retrieved in normal, non-normal, and emergency operations. Information for a given performance monitoring task may be time shared if the method of switching back and forth does not jeopardize the performance monitoring task.
• Generally, system information, planning, and other information not necessary for the pilot tasks can be time shared. (3) Separating Information Visually. When different information elements are adjacent to each other on a display, the elements should be separated visually so the pilots can easily distinguish between them. Visual separation can be achieved with, for example, spacing, delimiters, or shading in accordance with the overall flight deck information management philosophy. Required information presented in reversionary or compacted display modes following a display failure should still be uncluttered and still allow acceptable information access time.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
49
(4) Clutter and De-Clutter.
(a) A cluttered display presents an excessive number or variety of symbols, colors, and/or other unnecessary information and, depending on the situation, may interfere with the flight task or operation. A cluttered display causes increased flightcrew processing time for display interpretation, and may detract from the interpretation of information necessary to navigate and fly the airplane. Information should be displayed so that clutter is minimized.
(b) To enhance pilot performance a means should be considered to de-clutter the display. For example, an attitude indicator may automatically de-clutter when the airplane is at an unusual attitude to aid the pilot in recovery from the unusual attitude by removing unnecessary information and retaining information required for the flightcrew to recover the airplane. f. Annunciations and Indications.
(1) General. Annunciations and indications include annunciator switches, messages, prompts, flags, and status or mode indications which are either on the flight deck display itself or control a flight deck display. Reference the ARAC recommendations for revising § 25.1322 and the associated guidance material for information regarding specific annunciations and indications such as warning, caution, and advisory level alerts. (a) Annunciations and indications should be operationally relevant and limited to minimize the adverse effects on flightcrew workload. (b) Annunciations and indications should be clear, unambiguous, timely, and consistent with the flight deck design philosophy. When an annunciation is provided for the status or mode of a system, it is recommended that the annunciation indicate the actual state of the system and not just the position or selection of a switch. Annunciations should only be indicated while the condition exists.
(2) Location. Annunciations and indications should be consistently located in a specific area of the electronic display. Annunciations that may require immediate flightcrew awareness should be located in the flightcrew’s forward/primary field of view. (3) Managing Messages and Prompts.
(a) The following general guidance applies to all messages and prompts:
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
50
• When messages are currently being displayed and there are additional messages in the queue that are not currently displayed, there should be an indication that the additional messages exist.
• Within levels of urgency, messages should be displayed in logical order. In many cases the order of occurrence of events has been found to be the most logical way to place the messages in order.
• Reference the ARAC recommendations for revising § 25.1322 and the associated guidance material for information on warning, caution, and advisory alerts.
(b) A text change by itself should not be used as an attention-getting cue (for example, to annunciate mode changes). (4) Blinking. Blinking information elements such as readouts or pointers are effective methods of annunciation. However, the use of blinking should be limited because it can be distracting and excessive use reduces the attention getting effectiveness. Blinking rates between 0.8 and 4.0 Hertz should be used, depending on the display technology and the compromise between urgency and distraction. If blinking of an information element can occur for more than approximately 10 seconds, a means to cancel the blinking should be provided.
g. Use of Imaging. This paragraph provides guidance on the use of images which depict a specific portion of the airplane environment. These images may be static or continuously updated. Imaging includes weather radar returns, terrain depictions, forecast weather maps, video, enhanced vision displays, and synthetic vision displays. Images may be generated from databases or by sensors.
(1) Images should be of sufficient size and include sufficient detail to meet the intended function. The pilots should be able to readily distinguish the features depicted. Images should be oriented in such a way that their presentation is easily interpreted. All images, but especially dynamic images, should be located or controllable so they do not distract the pilots from required tasks. The source and intended function of the image and the level of operational approval for using the image should be provided to the pilots. This can be accomplished using the airplane flight manual, image location, adequate labeling, distinct texturing, or other means. (2) Image distortion should not compromise image interpretation. Images meant to provide information about depth (for example, 3-Dimensional type perspective displays) should provide adequate depth information to meet the intended function. (3) Dynamic images should meet the guidance in paragraph 31d of this chapter, above. The overall system lag time of a dynamic image relative to real time should not cause
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
51
flightcrew misinterpretation or lead to a potentially hazardous condition. Image failure, freezing, coasting or color changes should not be misleading and should be considered during the safety analysis. (4) When overlaying coded information elements over images, the information elements should be readily identifiable and distinguishable for all foreseeable conditions of the underlying image and range of motion. The information elements should not obscure necessary information contained in the image. The information should be depicted with the appropriate size, shape, and placement accuracy to avoid being misleading. They should retain and maintain their shape, size, and color for all foreseeable conditions of the underlying image and range of motion. (5) When fusing or overlaying multiple images, the resultant combined image should meet its intended function despite any differences in image quality, projection, data update rates, sensitivity to sunlight, data latency, or sensor alignment algorithms. When conforming an image to the outside world, such as on a HUD, the image should not obscure or significantly hinder the flightcrew’s ability to detect real world objects. An independent brightness control of the image may help satisfy this guideline. Image elements that correlate or highlight real world objects should be sufficiently coincident to avoid interpretation error or significantly increase interpretation time. 32. – 35. [RESERVED]
ORGANIZING ELECTRONIC DISPLAY INFORMATION ELEMENTS › a. General. This chapter provides guidance for integrating
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
52
CHAPTER 6. ORGANIZING ELECTRONIC DISPLAY INFORMATION ELEMENTS 36. Organizing Information Elements.
a. General. This chapter provides guidance for integrating information into the flight deck related to managing the location of information, arranging the display, windowing, configuring and reconfiguring the display, and selecting the sensors across the flight deck displays. The following paragraphs include guidance for various flight deck configurations from dedicated electronic displays for the attitude director indicator and the horizontal situation indicator to larger display sizes which use windowing techniques to display various functionalities on one display area. In some flight decks the primary flight information and the navigation display are examples of information that is displayed using windowing techniques. Chapter 5 of this AC provides guidance for information elements including: text, labels, symbols, graphics, and other depictions (such as video) in isolation and combination.
b. Types and Arrangement of Display Information. This paragraph provides guidance for the arrangement and location of categories of information. The categories of information include:
• Primary flight information including attitude, airspeed, altitude, and heading. • Powerplant information which covers functions relating to propulsion. • Other information.
(1) Placement - General Information. The position of a message or symbol within a display conveys meaning to the pilot. Without the consistent or repeatable location of a symbol in a specific area of the electronic display interpretation error and response times may increase. The following information should be placed in a consistent location under normal conditions:
• Primary flight information (see paragraph 36b(3) in this chapter and Appendix 1 of this AC).
• Powerplant information (see paragraph 36b(4) in this chapter and Appendix 2 of this AC).
• Flightcrew alerts – each flightcrew alert should be displayed in a specific location or a central flightcrew alert area.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
53
• Autopilot and flight director modes of operation.
• Lateral and vertical path deviation indicators.
• Radio altitude indications.
• Failure flags should be presented in the location of the information they reference or replace.
• Data labels for navigation, traffic, airplane system, and other information should be placed in a consistent position relative to the information they are labeling.
• Supporting data for other information, such as bugs and limit markings, should be consistently positioned relative to the information they support.
• Features on electronic moving map displays (for example, VORs, waypoints, etc.) relative to the current airplane position. In addition, the features should be placed on a constant scale for each range selected.
• Segment of flight information relative to similar information or other segments.
(2) Placement - Controls and Indications. When a control or indication occurs in multiple places (for example a “Return” control on multiple pages of a flight management function), the control or indication should be located consistently for all occurrences.
(3) Arrangement - Basic T Information.
(a) Section 25.1321(b) includes requirements for the “Basic T” arrangement of certain information required by § 25.1303(b). (b) The following paragraphs provide guidance for the Basic T arrangement. This guidance applies to single and multiple display surfaces.
1 The Basic T information should be displayed continuously, directly in front of each flightcrew member under normal (that is, no display system failure) conditions. Section 25.1321(b) requires that flight instruments required by § 25.1303 must be grouped on the instrument panel and centered as nearly as practicable about the vertical plane of the pilot's forward vision.
2 The Basic T arrangement applies to the primary display of attitude, airspeed, altitude, and direction of flight. Depending on the flight deck design, there may be more than one indication of the Basic T information elements in
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
54
front of a pilot. For example, heading information may appear on back-up displays, HUDs, and moving map displays. The primary airspeed, altitude, and direction indications are the respective display indications closest to the primary attitude indication.
3 The primary attitude indication should be centered about the plane of the flightcrew’s forward vision. This should be measured from the DEP at the flightcrew station (see related regulation). If located on the main instrument panel, the primary attitude indication must be in the top center position (§ 25.1321(b)). The attitude indication should be placed so that the display is unobstructed under all flight conditions. Refer to SAE ARP 4102/7 for additional information. 4 The primary airspeed, altitude, and direction of flight indications should be located adjacent to the primary attitude indication. Information elements placed within, overlaid, or between these indications, such as lateral and vertical deviation, are acceptable when they are relevant to respective airspeed, altitude, or directional indications used for accomplishing the basic flying task, and are shown to not disrupt the normal crosscheck or decrease manual flying performance.
5 The instrument that most effectively indicates airspeed must be adjacent to and directly to the left of the primary attitude indication (§ 25.1321(b)). The center of the airspeed indication should be aligned with the center of the attitude indication. For airspeed indications, vertical deviations have been found acceptable up to 15 degrees below to 10 degrees above when measured from the direct horizontal position of the airplane waterline reference symbol. For tape type airspeed indications, the center of the indication is defined as the center of the current airspeed status reference. 6 Parameters related to the primary airspeed indication, such as reference speeds or a mach indication, should be displayed to the left of the primary attitude indication. 7 The instrument that most effectively indicates altitude must be located adjacent to and directly to the right of the primary attitude indication (§ 25.1321(b)). The center of the altitude indication should be aligned with the center of the attitude indication. For altitude indications, vertical deviations have been found acceptable up to 15 degrees below to 10 degrees above when measured from the direct horizontal position of the airplane waterline reference symbol. For tape type altitude indications, the center of the indication is defined as the center of the current altitude status reference.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
55
8 Parameters related to the primary altitude indication, such as the barometric setting or the primary vertical speed indication, should be displayed to the right of the primary altitude indication. 9 The instrument that most effectively indicates direction of flight must be located adjacent to and directly below the primary attitude indication (§ 25.1321(b)). The center of the direction of flight indication should be aligned with the center of the attitude indication. The center of the direction of flight indication is defined as the center of the current direction of flight status reference. 10 Parameters related to the primary direction of flight indication, such as the reference (that is, magnetic or true) or the localizer deviation should be displayed below the primary attitude indication. 11 If applicants seek approval of alternative instrument arrangements by equivalent safety under § 21.21(b)(1), the FAA will normally require wellfounded research, or relevant service experience from military, foreign, or other sources to substantiate the applicants’ proposed compensating factors.
(4) Arrangement - Powerplant Information.
(a) Required engine indications necessary to set and monitor engine thrust or power should be continuously displayed in the flightcrew’s primary field of view, unless the applicant can demonstrate that this is not necessary (see the guidance in paragraph 36c(3) of this chapter and Appendix 2 of this AC). The automatically selected display of powerplant information should not suppress other information that requires flightcrew awareness. (b) Powerplant information must be closely grouped (in accordance with § 25.1321) in an easily identifiable and logical arrangement which allows the flightcrew to clearly and quickly identify the displayed information and associate it with the corresponding engine. Typically, it is considered to be acceptable to arrange parameters related to one powerplant in a vertical manner and, according to powerplant position, next to the parameters related to another powerplant in such a way that identical powerplant parameters are horizontally aligned. Generally, place parameter indications in order of importance with the most important one at the top. Typically, the top indication is the primary thrust setting parameter.
(5) Arrangement - Other Information (For Example, Glideslope and Multi- Function Displays).
(a) Glideslope or glidepath deviation scales should be located to the right side of the primary attitude indication. If glideslope deviation data is presented on both an
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
ORGANIZING ELECTRONIC DISPLAY INFORMATION ELEMENTS › c. Managing Display Information. The following paragraphs
56
electronic horizontal situation indicator and an electronic attitude direction indicator, the information should appear in the same relative location on each indicator. (b) When the glideslope pointer is being driven by a RNAV (area navigation) system with VNAV (vertical navigation) or ILS (instrument landing system) lookalike functionality, the pointer should not be marked “GS” or “glideslope.” (c) Navigation, weather, and vertical situation display information is often displayed on multi-function displays. This information may be displayed on one or more physical electronic displays, or on several areas of one larger display. When this information is not required to be displayed continuously, it can be displayed part-time, but the displayed information should be easily recoverable to the flightcrew when needed. For guidance on part-time displays see paragraph 36c(3) of this chapter. (d) Other information should not be located where the primary flight information or required powerplant information is normally presented. See paragraphs 36b(1) and 36b(3) of this chapter for primary flight information guidance. See paragraphs 21e(10) and 36b(4) of this AC for powerplant information guidance. c. Managing Display Information. The following paragraphs address managing and integrating the display of information throughout the flight deck. This includes the use of windows to present information and the use of menus to manage the display of information.
(1) Window. A window is a defined area which can be present on one or more physical displays. A window that contains a set of related information is commonly referred to as a format. Multiple windows may be presented on one physical display surface and may have different sizes. Guidelines for sharing information on a display, using separate windows, are as follows:
• The window(s) should have fixed size(s) and location(s).
• Separation between information elements within and across windows should be sufficient to allow the flightcrew to readily distinguish separate functions or functional groups (for example, powerplant indication) and avoid any distractions or unintended interaction.
• Display of selectable information, such as a window on a display area, should not interfere with or affect the use of primary flight information.
• For additional information regarding the display of data on a given location, data blending, and data over-writing (see ARINC Specification 661).
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
57
(2) Menu.
(a) A menu is a displayed list of items from which the flightcrew can choose. Menus include drop-down and scrolling menus, line select keys on a multi-function display, and flight management system menu trees. An option is one of the selectable items in a menu. Selection is the action a user makes in choosing a menu option, and may be done by pointing (with a cursor control device or other mechanism), entering an associated option code, or activating a function key.
(b) The hierarchical structure and organization of the menus should be designed to allow the flightcrew to sequentially step through the available menus or options in a logical way that supports their tasks. The options provided on any particular menu should be logically related to each other. Menus should be displayed in consistent locations, either a fixed location or a consistent relative location, so that the flightcrew knows where to find them. At all times the system should indicate the current position within the menu and menu hierarchy.
(c) The number of sub-menus should be designed to assure timely access to the desired option without over-reliance on memorization of the menu structure. The presentation of items on the menu should allow clear distinction between items that select other menus and items that are the final selection. (d) The number of steps required to choose the desired option should be consistent with the frequency, importance, and urgency of the flightcrew’s task. (e) When a menu is displayed it should not obscure required information. (3) Full-time vs. Part-time Display of Information. Some airplane parameters or status indications are required to be displayed by the regulations (for example, powerplant information required by § 25.1305), yet they may only be necessary or required in certain phases of flight. If it is desired to inhibit some parameters from fulltime display, a usability level and functionality equivalent to a full-time display should be demonstrated.
(a) When determining if information on a display can be part-time, consider the following criteria:
• Continuous display of the parameter is not required for safety of flight in all normal flight phases.
• The parameter is automatically displayed in flight phases where it is required, when its value indicates an abnormal condition, or when it would be relevant information during a failure condition.
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
58
• Display of the inhibited parameter can be manually selected by the flightcrew without interfering with the display of other required information.
• If the parameter fails to be displayed when required, the failure effect and compounding effects must meet the requirements of all applicable regulations (for example, § 25.1309).
• The automatic or requested display of the inhibited parameter should not create unacceptable clutter on the display. Also, simultaneous multiple "pop-ups" should not create unacceptable clutter on the display.
• If the presence of a new parameter is not sufficiently self-evident, suitable alerting or other annunciations should accompany the automatic presentation of the parameter.
(b) Pop-up Display of Information.
1 Certain types of information, such as terrain and TCAS, are required by the operation regulations to be displayed, yet they are only necessary or required in certain phases of flight (similar to the part-time display of required airplane parameters, (see paragraph 36b(3) of this chapter)) or under specific conditions. One method commonly employed to display this information is called “automatic pop-up.” Automatic pop-ups may be in the form of an overlay, such as a TCAS overlay on the moving map, or in a separate window as a part of a display format. Pop-up window locations should not obscure required information.
2 Consider the following criteria for displaying automatic pop-up information:
• Information is automatically displayed when its value indicates a predetermined condition, or when the associated parameter reaches a predetermined value.
• Pop-up information should appropriately attract the flightcrew’s attention while minimizing task disruption.
• If the flightcrew deselects the display of the automatic pop-up information, then another automatic pop-up should not occur until a new condition/event causes it.
• If an automatic pop-up condition is activated and the system is in the wrong configuration or mode to display the information, and the
ORGANIZING ELECTRONIC DISPLAY INFORMATION ELEMENTS › d. Managing Display Configuration. The following paragraph
6/21/07 AC 25-11A
59
system configuration cannot be automatically changed, then an annunciation should be displayed in the color associated with the nature of the alert, prompting the flightcrew to make the necessary changes for the display of the information. This guidance differs from the part-time display of information required by part 25 because the required information should be displayed regardless of the configuration.
• If a pop-up(s) or simultaneous multiple pop-ups occur and obscure information, it should be shown that the obscured information is not relevant or necessary for the current flightcrew task. Additionally, the pop-ups should not cause a misleading presentation.
• If more than one automatic pop-up occurs simultaneously on one display area, for example a terrain and TCAS pop-up, then the system should prioritize the pop-up events based on their criticality. Pop-up display orientation should be in track-up or heading-up.
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 223 passages shown