AC 23-8C Flight Test Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes
a. This advisory circular (AC) sets forth an acceptable means, but not the only means, of showing compliance with Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 23 concerning flight tests and pilot judgements. Material in this AC is neither mandatory nor regulatory in nature and does not constitute a regulation. b. This AC is one method being utilized to achieve national standardization in normal, utility, acrobatic, and commuter category airplanes. This AC applies to Subpart B and various sections under Subparts A, D, E, F and G from § 23.1 through § 23.1589. This AC consolidates existing policy documents, and certain ACs that cover specific paragraphs of the regulations, into a single document. c. This material is intended as a ready reference for part 23 airplane manufacturers, modifiers, Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) design evaluation engineers, flight test engineers, and engineering flight test pilots, including Organization Delegation Option (DOA).
Text read by OCR from a scanned file (1 of 265 pages). Check the original, as some words may be misread.
US. Deportment of Transportation
Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory Circular
Subject: FLIGHT TEST GUIDE Date: 11/16/2011 AC No: 23-8C FOR CERTIFICATION OF Initiated By: ACE-100 Change: PART 23 AIRPLANES
1. Purpose.
a. This advisory circular (AC) sets forth an acceptable means, but not the only means, of showing compliance with Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 23 concerning flight tests and pilot judgements. Material in this AC is neither mandatory nor regulatory in nature and does not constitute a regulation.
b. This AC is one method being utilized to achieve national standardization in normal, utility, acrobatic, and commuter category airplanes. This AC applies to Subpart B and various sections under Subparts A, D, E, F and G from § 23.1 through § 23.1589. This AC consolidates existing policy documents, and certain ACs that cover specific paragraphs of the regulations, into a single document.
c. This material is intended as a ready reference for part 23 airplane manufacturers, modifiers, Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) design evaluation engineers, flight test engineers, and engineering flight test pilots, including Organization Delegation Option (DOA).
2. Applicability.
a. The methods and procedures contained in this AC are available for use during all normal, utility, acrobatic, and commuter category airplane flight test certification activities. This material does not have any legal status and must be treated accordingly. The procedures set forth are one acceptable means of compliance with applicable sections of part 23.
b. Like all AC material, these guidelines are not mandatory and do not constitute a regulation. They came from previous FAA experience in finding compliance with the airworthiness requirements. They represent the methods and procedures found acceptable by that experience. Since these methods and procedures are only one acceptable means of compliance, individuals should be guided by the intent of the methods provided in this AC.
Any alternate means proposed by the applicant will be given due consideration. Applicants should contact their aircraft certification office (ACO) to determine the acceptability of proposed methods.
c. This AC covers the latest part 23 amendments through Amendment 23-62. Each paragraph has the applicable part 23 amendment shown in the title. Prior amendments may require separate procedures and guidance. Applicants should contact their ACO for information concerning policies applicable to prior amendments of part 23 and Civil Air Regulations (CAR 3).
d. Sections entitled "Reserved" will be filled in when the material is developed.
e. This AC is applicable only to the original applicant seeking issuance of a type certificate (TC), an amended TC, or a supplemental type certificate (STC) for the initial approval of the new type design or a change in the approved type design. This material is not to be construed as having any legal status and should be treated accordingly. This version of the AC covers policy available through November 16, 2011. Policy that became available after that date will be covered in future amendments to the AC.
3. Cancellation. The following AC is cancelled: AC 23-8B, Flight Test Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes.
4. General. This AC covers flight test items of interest during type certification. Other engineering disciplines, such as airframe, systems and equipment, and propulsion are addressed as they pertain to flight test criteria.
5. Background.
a. AC 23-8, Flight Test Guide for Certification of Normal, Utility, and Acrobatic Category Airplanes, was published to replace FAA Order 8110.7, Engineering Flight Test Guide for Small Airplanes, dated June 20, 1972, and to consolidate existing flight test policy. AC 23-8 did not cover commuter category airplanes. AC 23-8A updated the original AC 23 8 by adding information and guidance for commuter airplanes. AC 23-8B updated the Flight Test Guide to incorporate information and guidance through 14 CFR part 23, Amendment 23-51. The AC also incorporated material harmonized with the European Joint Aviation Authorities (JAA).
b. The latest revision to the Flight Test Guide, AC 23-8C, contains guidance material for turbojets certificated under part 23. For almost two decades, part 23 jets used extensive special conditions to address the special issues associated with high performance, high altitude turbojet airplanes. However, in the past five years, the number of new jet certification programs in part 23 has increased more than 100 percent over the program numbers of the past three decades. The need to incorporate these special conditions into part 23 stems not only from the existing number of new jet programs, but expected future programs. This AC is updated to accompany the addition of jet requirements to part 23.
ii
6. Paragraphs Keyed to Part 23. Each paragraph has the applicable part 23 amendment shown in the title. As part 23 changes occur, the appropriate revisions will be made to the affected paragraphs of this AC.
7. Related Publications. Certification personnel should be familiar with FAA Order 8110.4 "Type Certification," and FAA Order 8100.5A, "Aircraft Certification Service Mission, Responsibilities, Relationships, and Programs." In this AC, reference is made to other FAA ACs which provide guidance on various aspects of type certification and supplemental type certification. The documents listed below are provided as a quick reference source of documents that are acceptable for use in 14 CFR part 23 certification programs/projects.
a. Copies of current FAA ACs are available on the Internet at http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/advisory_circulars/
(1) 20-67 Airborne VHF Communications Equipment Installations
(2) 20-124 Water Ingestion Testing for Turbine Powered Airplanes
(3) 20-118 Emergency Evacuation Demonstration
(4) 20-138B Airworthiness Approval of Positioning and Navigation Systems
(5) 23.629-1 Means of Compliance with Section 23.629, Flutter
(6) 23-1309-1 System Safety Analysis and Assessment for Part 23 Airplanes
(7) 23-1419-2 Certification of Part 23 Airplanes for Flight in Icing Conditions
(8) 90-79 Recommended Practices and Procedures for the Use of Electronic Long-Range Navigation Equipment
(9) 91-49 General Aviation Procedures for Flight in North Atlantic Minimum Navigation Performance Specifications Airspace
(10) 121-13 Self-Contained Navigation Systems (Long Range)
(11) 20-88 Guidelines on Marking Aircraft Powerplant Instruments (Displays)
iii
11/16/2011 AC 23 -8C
(12) 23-16 Powerplant Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes and Airships
(13) 23-1 7 Systems and Equipment Guide for Certification of Part 23 Airplanes and Airships
Earl Lawrence Manager, Small Airplane Directorate Aircraft Certification Service
iv
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
Chapter 1. Subpart A--General … 1
1. § 23.1 Applicability … 1 2. § 23.3 Airplane Categories … 1
Chapter 2 Subpart B – Flight … 2
Section 1. General … 2
1. § 23.21 Proof of Compliance … 2 2. § 23.23 Load Distribution Limits … 6 3. § 23.25 Weight Limits … 8 4. § 23.29 Empty Weight and Corresponding Center of Gravity … 9 5. § 23.31 Removable Ballast … 9 6. § 23.33 Propeller Speed and Pitch Limits … 10
Section 2. Performance … 11
1. § 23.45 General … 11 2. § 23.49 Stalling Speed … 15 3. § 23.51 Takeoff Speeds … 23 4. § 23.53 Takeoff Performance … 28 5. § 23.55 Accelerate-Stop Distance … 32 6. § 23.57 Takeoff Path … 36 7. § 23.59 Takeoff Distance and Takeoff Run … 42 8. § 23.61 Takeoff Flight Path … 45 9. § 23.65 Climb: All Engines Operating … 47 10. § 23.66 Takeoff Climb, One Engine Inoperative … 51 11. § 23.67 Climb: One Engine Inoperative … 52 12. § 23.71 Glide (Single-Engine Airplanes) … 56 13. § 23.75 Landing … 57 14. § 23.77 Balked Landing Climb … 63
Section 3. Flight Characteristics of 14 CFR § 23.141 … 65
1. § 23.141 General … 65
Section 4. Controllability and Maneuverability … 65
1. § 23.143 General … 65 2. § 23.145 Longitudinal Control … 67 3. § 23.147 Directional and Lateral Control … 68 4. § 23.149 Minimum Control Speed … 70 5. § 23.151 Acrobatic Maneuvers … 74 6. § 23.153 Control During Landings … 75 7. § 23.155 Elevator Control Force in Maneuvers … 75 8. § 23.157 Rate of Roll … 78
Section 5. Trim … 78
1. § 23.161 Trim … 78
v
Section 6. Stability … 78
1. § 23.171 General … 78 2. § 23.173 Static Longitudinal Stability … 82 3. § 23.175 Demonstration of Static Longitudinal Stability … 83 4. § 23.177 Static Direction and Lateral Stability … 86 5. § 23.179 Stability … 87 6. § 23.181 Dynamic Stability … 87
Section 7. Stalls … 92
1. § 23.201 Wings Level Stall … 92 2. § 23.203 Turning Flight and Accelerated Turning Stalls … 95 3. § 23.205 … 96 4. § 23.207 Stall Warning … 96
Section 8. Spinning … 96
1. § 23.221 Spinning … 96
Section 9. Ground and Water Handling Characteristics … 104
1. § 23.231 Longitudinal Stability and Control … 104 2. § 23.233 Directional Stability and Control … 104 3. § 23.235 Operation on Unpaved Surfaces … 106 4. § 23.237 Operation on Water … 106 5. § 23.239 Spray Characteristics … 106
Section 10. Miscellaneous Flight Requirements … 106
1. § 23.251 Vibration and Buffering … 106 2. § 23.253 High Speed Characteristics … 107
Chapter 3. Subpart D--Design and Construction … 111
Section 1. General … 111
1. § 23.629 Flutter … 111
Section 2. Control Systems … 111
1. § 23.671 General … 111 2. § 23.672 Stability Augmentation and Automatic and Power Operated Systems … 111 3. § 23.677 Trim Systems … 111 4. § 23.679 Control System Locks … 113 5. § 23.689 Cable Systems … 113 6. § 23.691 Artificial Stall Barrier System … 114 7. § 23.697 Wing Flap Controls … 114 8. § 23.699 Wing Flap Position Indicator … 114 9. § 23.701 Flap Interconnection … 114
Section 3. Landing Gear … 114
1. § 23.729 Landing Gear Extension and Retraction System … 114 2. § 23.735 Brakes … 114
vi
Section 4. Personnel and Cargo Accommodations … 114
1. § 23.771 Pilot Compartment … 114 2. § 23.773 Pilot Compartment View … 114 3. § 23.775 Windshields and Windows … 115 4. § 23.777 Cockpit Controls … 115 5. § 23.785 Seats, Berths, Litters, Safety Belts and Shoulder Harnesses … 115 6. § 23.803 Emergency Evacuation … 116 7. § 23.807 Emergency Exits … 116 8. § 23.831 Ventilation … 116
Section 5. Pressurization … 117
1. § 23.841 Pressurization Cabins … 117 2. § 23.843 Pressurization Tests … 117
Chapter 4. Subpart E--Powerplant … 118
Section 1. General … 118
1. § 23.901 Installation … 118 2. § 23.903 Engines … 118 3. § 23.905 Propellers … 121 4. § 23.909 Turbo Superchargers … 121 5. § 23.925 Propeller Clearance … 121 6. § 23.929 Engine Installation Ice Protection … 121 7. § 23.933 Reversing Systems … 121 8. § 23.939 Powerplant Operating Characteristics … 122 9. § 23.943 Negative Acceleration … 123
Section 2. Fuel System … 123
1. § 23.959 Unusable Fuel Supply … 123 2. § 23.961 Fuel System Hot Weather Operation … 123
Section 3. Fuel System Components … 123
1. § 23.1001 Fuel Jettisoning System … 123
Section 4. Oil System … 124
1. § 23.1027 Propeller Feathering System … 124
Section 5. Cooling … 125
1. § 23.1041 General … 125 2. § 23.1043 Cooling Tests … 125 3. § 23.1045 Cooling Test Procedures for Turbine Engine-Powered Airplanes … 125 4. § 23.1047 Cooling Test Procedures for Reciprocating Engine-Powered Airplanes … 129
Section 6. Induction System … 132
1. § 23.1091 Air Induction … 132 2. § 23.1093 Induction System Icing Protection … 132
vii
Section 7. Powerplant Controls and Accessories … 136
1. § 23.1141 Powerplant Controls: General … 137 2. § 23.1145 Ignition Switches … 137 3. § 23.1153 Propeller Feathering Controls … 137
Section 8. Powerplant Fire Protection … 137
1. § 23.1189 Shutoff Means … 137
Chapter 5. Subpart F--Equipment … 138
Section 1. General … 138
1. § 23.1301 Function and Installation … 138 2. § 23.1303 Flight and Navigation Instruments … 147 3. § 23.1305 Powerplant Instruments … 147 4. § 23.1307 Miscellaneous Equipment … 148 5. § 23.1309 Equipment, Systems, and Installations … 148
Section 2. Instruments: Installation … 148
1. § 23.1311 Electronic Display Instrument Systems … 148 2. § 23.1321 Arrangement and Visibility … 148 3. § 23.1322 Warning, Caution, and Advisory Lights … 148 4. § 23.1323 Airspeed Indicating System … 148 5. § 23.1325 Static Pressure System … 149 6. § 23.1326 Pitot Heat Indication Systems … 152 7. § 23.1327 Magnetic Direction Indicator … 152 8. § 23.1329 Automatic Pilot System … 152 9. § 23.1331 Instruments Using a Power Supply … 152 10. § 23.1335 Flight Director Systems … 152 11. § 23.1337 Powerplant Instruments … 152
Section 3. Electrical Systems and Equipment … 152
1. § 23.1351 General … 152 2. § 23.1353 Storage Battery Design and Installation … 153
Reserved … 153
3. § 23.1357 Circuit Protective Devices … 153 4. § 23.1361 Master Switch Switch Arrangement … 153 5. § 23.1367 Switches … 153
Section 4. Lights … 153
1. § 23.1381 Instrument Lights … 153 2. § 23.1383 Landing Lights … 153
Section 5. Safety Equipment … 153
1. § 23.1411 General … 153 2. § 23.1415 Ditching Equipment … 153 3. § 23.1416 Pneumatic Deicer Boot System … 153 4. § 23.1419 Ice Protection … 153
viii
Section 6. Miscellaneous Equipment … 153
1. § 23.1431 Electronic Equipment … 153 2. §23.1435 Hydraulic Systems … 153 3. § 23.1441 Oxygen Equipment and Supply … 153 4. § 23.1447 Equipment Standards for Oxygen Dispensing Units … 153 5. § 23.1449 Means for Determining Use of Oxygen … 153 6. § 23.1457 Cockpit Voice Recorders … 153 7. § 23.1459 Flight Data Recorders … 154
Chapter 6. Subpart G--Operating Limitations and Information … 155
Section 1. General … 155
1 § 23.1501 General … 155 2. § 23.1505 Airspeed Limitations … 155 3. § 23.1507 Maneuvering Speed … 155 4. § 23.1511 Flap Extended Speed … 155 5. § 23.1513 Minimum Control Speed … 155 6. § 23.1519 Weight and Center of Gravity … 155 7. § 23.1521 Powerplant Limitations … 155 8. § 23.1523 Minimum Flight Crew … 156 9. § 23.1523 Minimum Flight Crew … 156 10. § 23.1524 Maximum Passenger Seating Configuration … 160 11. § 23.1525 Kinds of Operation … 160 12. § 23.1527 Maximum Operating Altitude … 160
Section 2. Markings and Placards … 161
1. § 23.1541 General … 161 2. § 23.1543 Instrument Markings: General … 162 3. § 23.1545 Airspeed Indicator … 162 4. § 23.1547 Magnetic Direction Indicator … 162 5. § 23.1549 Powerplant Instruments … 162 6. § 23.1551 Oil Quantity Indicator … 162 7. § 23.1553 Fuel Quantity Indicator … 162 8. § 23.1555 Control Markings … 162 9. § 23.1557 Miscellaneous Markings and Placards … 162 10. § 23.1559 Operating Limitations Placard … 162 11. § 23.1561 Safety Equipment … 162 12. § 23.1563 Airspeed Placards … 163 13. § 23.1567 Flight Maneuver Placard … 163
Section 3. Airplane Flight Manual and Approved Manual Material … 163
1. § 23.1581 General … 163 2. § 23.1583 Operating Limitations … 165 3. § 23.1585 Operating Procedures … 167 4. § 23.1587 Performance Information … 168 5. § 23.1589 Loading Information … 170
ix
Appendix 1. Power Available
1. General 2. Reciprocating Engines 3. Normally Aspirated Engines with Constant Speed Propellers 4. Turbocharged Engines with Constant Speed Propellers 5. Normally Aspirated Engines with Fixed Pitch Propellers 6. Turbopropeller Engines
Appendix 2. Climb Data Reduction
1. Drag Polar Method 2. Density Altitude Method
Appendix 3. Static Minimum Control Speed
1. General 2. Calculation Method 3. Cautions and Assumptions 4. Sample Calculations
Appendix 4 FAR-23 Manuals, Markings, & Placards Checklist
Appendix 5 –Guide for Preparing Airplane Flight Manual and Pilots’s Operating Handbook Supplements
1. Introduction 2. General
Appendix 6. Sample Kinds of Operating Equipment List
Appendix 7. Useful Information
Appendix 8. Conversion Factors Table
Appendix 9. Airspeed Calibrations
Introduction General Discussion of the Various Flight Test Techniques 1. Trailing Bomb or Cone Method 2. Speed Course Method 3. GPS Method 4. Pace Airplane Method 5. Pitot Static Boom Data 6. Tower Fly By Method 7. Ground Run Airspeed System Calibration
Appendix 10. Guide for Determining Climb Performance After STC Modifications
1. Introduction 2. General 3. Procedure for Extending Climb Performance to Additional Airplanes 4. ‘One Only’ Airplane
x
List of Figures Figure 1 Stall Speed … 17
Figure A1-1 – Brake Horsepower Versus Pressure Altitude Figure A1-2 - Turbocharged Brake Horsepower Versus Altitude Figure A2-1 - Coefficient of Drag Versus Coefficient of Lift Figure A3-1 - Thrust Horsepower at Sea Level Figure A7-1 – U.S. Standard Atmosphere (1962) Figure A7-2 – Temperature Conversion Chart Figure A7-3 – Determination of Air Temperature in Relation to International Standard
Atmosphere Figure A7-4 – Density/Pressure Altitude Conversion Figure A7-5 – Compressibility Correction CAS Figure A7-6 – Altimeter Error vs. CAS Figure A7-7 – Temperature RAM Rise Figure A7-8 – Stalling Speed as a Function of Angle of Bank Figure A7-9 – Vectoral Acceleration Versus Angle of Bank Figure A7-10 Figure A7-11 – Takeoff and Landing Crosswind Component Chart Figure A9-1 - Error Analysis of Ground Course Method
Figure 2 Propeller Coefficients … 19 Figure 3 Zero Thrust … 19 Figure 4 Thrust Effect on Stall CL … 20 Figure 5 - Accelerate-Stop Time Delays … 35 Figure 6 Takeoff Distance Critical Engine Failure Recognized at V1 … 43 Figure 7 - Takeoff Distance - All Engines Operating … 43 Figure 8 - Takeoff Run - Critical Engine Failure Recognized at V1 … 44 Figure 9 - Takeoff Run - All Engines Operating … 44 Figure 10 - Clearway Profiles … 45 Figure 11 - Takeoff Segments and Nomenclature … 46 Figure 12- Net Takeoff Flight Path … 47 Figure 13 - Observed Data … 49 Figure 14 - Rate of Climb vs. Airspeed … 51 Figure 15 - Rate of Climb and Speeds … 52 Figure 16 - Landing Time Delays … 61 Figure 17 - Stick Force Per G … 77 Figure 18 - Static Longitudinal Stability Data … 80 Figure 19 - Low Speed Instabilities; Normal, Utility, and Acrobatic Airplanes … 81 Figure 20 - Low Speed Instabilities; Commuter Airplanes … 82 Figure 21 – Static Longitudinal Stability Data over Complete Speed Range … 83 Figure 22 - Static Longitudinal Stability Plot (Cruise Condition) … 86 Figure 23 - Spin Evaluation Configuration Matrix … 103 Figure 24 – Sample Calculation … 128 Figure 25 – Corrected Cylinder Barrel Temperature … 131 Figure 26 – Correct Cylinder Head Temperature … 132 Figure 27 - Carburetor Air Heat Rise Calculations … 135 Figure 28 - Carburetor Air Heat Rise Plots … 136
xi
Figure A9-2 - Summary of PEC Test Methods Figure A9-3 - Sketches of Trailing Static Bomb and the Trailing Static Cone (not to scale) Figure A9-4 - Typical Position Error Correction Data for an Aircraft Figure A9-5 Typical Position Error Corrections Data for an Aircraft Figure A9-6 Tower Fly-By Method Figure A9-7 - Trapped Static Source Schematic Figure A9-8 - Ground Airspeed Calibration
xii
List of Tables
Table 1 - Tolerances … 3
Table A3-1 – Flight Test Data Table A3-2 - Tabulated Thrust Horsepower Available and Calculated VMC Table A9-1 - Sample Speed Course Data and Data Reduction Table A9-2 - Trapped Static (TS) Data Reduction Table A9-3 - Sample Ground Airspeed Calibration Using a Distance Measuring Unit
Table 2 - Corrections to Standard Value Parameter … 3 Table 3 – Sample Portion of Airspeed Indicator Calibration … 5 Table 4 - Smooth, Flat Runway … 14 Table 5 - AFM Acceleration Height … 39 Table 6 - WAT Chart … 54 Table 7 - Procedures … 76 Table 8 - Trim Systems Requirements … 113 Table 9 – Sample of Co-Concentration Matrix … 116 Table 10 – Light Duration … 141
xiii
Chapter 1. Subpart A--General
1. § 23.1 Applicability.
a. Explanation.
(1) Airplane Categories. Section 23.1(a) is introductory and prescribes the airplane categories eligible for certification under 14 CFR part 23. Applicants should refer to 14 CFR part 21 for certification procedures.
(2) Design Data. Section 23.1(b) requires an applicant to demonstrate compliance by some acceptable means even though the FAA has previously certificated an identical alteration for someone else and has the supporting data on file. Design data submitted with an application for certification is not releasable to the public or any other applicant without the consent of the data holder.
b. Procedures. None.
2. § 23.3 Airplane Categories.
a. Explanation. For normal/utility category as well as for commuter category airplanes, stalls (except whip stalls) are approved maneuvers. In this context, approved stalls are to be understood to be stalls as defined in §§ 23.49, 23.201, and 23.203.
b. Procedures. None.
Chapter 2 Subpart B – Flight
Section 1. General
1. § 23.21 Proof of Compliance.
a. Explanation.
(1) Determining Compliance. This section provides a degree of latitude for the FAA test team in selecting the combination of tests or inspections required to demonstrate compliance with the regulations. Engineering tests are designed to investigate the overall capabilities and characteristics of the airplane throughout its operating envelope and should include sufficient combinations of weight, center of gravity, altitude, temperature, airspeed, and so forth, necessary to define the envelope and show compliance within. These engineering tests should define the limits of the entire operating envelope and establish compliance with the regulations. If compliance cannot be established between these points, additional testing should be conducted to determine compliance. The applicant could also apply for an equivalent level of safety (ELOS) or an exemption to the regulation if warranted by new designs or technology. Testing should confirm normal and emergency procedures, performance information, and operating limitations that are to be included in the airplane flight manual (AFM).
(2) Flight Tests. Section 21.35 requires, in part, that the applicant make flight tests and report the results of the flight tests. After the applicant has submitted sufficient data to the FAA showing that compliance can be met, the FAA will conduct any inspections, flight, or ground tests required to verify the applicant's test results. Compliance may be based on the applicant's engineering data and a spot check or validation through FAA flight tests. The FAA testing should obtain validation at critical combinations of proposed flight variables if compliance cannot be established using engineering judgment from the combinations investigated.
(3) Use of Ballast. Ballast may be carried during the flight tests whenever it is necessary to achieve a specific weight and center of gravity (c.g.) location. Consideration should be given to the vertical as well as horizontal location of the ballast in cases where it may have an appreciable effect on the flying qualities of the airplane. The strength of the supporting structures should be considered to preclude their failure as a result of the anticipated loads that may be imposed during the particular tests.
(4) Flight Test Tolerances. The purpose of the tolerances specified in § 23.21(b) is to allow for variations in flight test values from which data are acceptable for reduction to the value desired. They are not intended for routine test scheduling at the lower weights, or to allow for compliance to be shown at less than the critical condition; nor are they to be considered as allowable inaccuracy of measurement (such as in an airspeed calibration). Where variation in the parameter on which a tolerance is allowed will have an effect on the results of the test, the result should be corrected to the most critical value of that parameter within the operating
envelope being approved. If such a correction is impossible or impractical, the average test conditions should assure that the measured characteristics represent the actual critical value.
(5) Additional acceptable tolerances. Additional acceptable tolerances appear in table 1 below:
Table 1 - Tolerances
Item Tolerance
Airspeed 3 knots or ±3 percent (%), whichever is greater
Power ±5 percent
Wind (takeoff and, landing tests, not for crosswind component testing)
As low as possible, but not to exceed approximately 12 percent VS1 or 10 knots, whichever is lower, along the runway measured at a height of 6 feet above the runway surface. At higher wind velocities, the data may be unreliable due to wind variations and unsmooth flight conditions.
(6) Corrections to a standard value. Cases in which corrections to a standard value of the parameter are normally allowed appear in table 2 below:
Table 2 - Corrections to Standard Value Parameter
Test Weight Density Power/
Thrust Airspeed Other
Takeoff Performance X X X X Wind, runway gradient
Landing Performance X X — X Wind, runway gradient
Stall Speed X — — —
Climb Performance X X X X Acceleration
Glide Performance X X - X
VMC — X X —
(7) Function and Reliability (F&R) Test. Section 21.35(b)(2) specifies the requirements of F&R tests, which are required for aircraft with a maximum certificated weight over 6,000 pounds (lbs) (2730 kilograms (kg)). (Complex airplanes that include features like Full Authority Digital Engine Control (FADEC) engines, pressurization, and avionics integrated with flight
management software (FMS) and autopilot capability should consider a comprehensive F&R testing program regardless of weight.)
b. Procedures.
(1) Test Plan. Efforts should begin early in the certification program to provide assistance to the applicant to develop a certification plan and subsequently a test plan to ensure coverage of all certification requirements. The applicant should develop a test plan that includes the required instrumentation.
(2) Instrument Calibration. Test instrumentation (transducers, indicators, and other installed instrumentation) should be calibrated (removed from the airplane and bench checked by an approved method in an approved facility) within six months of the tests. When electronic recording devices are used, such as oscillographs, data loggers, and other electronic data acquisition devices, preflight and post-flight parameter recalibrations should be run for each test flight to ensure that none of the parameters have shifted from their initial zero settings. Critical transducers and indicators for critical tests (for example, airspeed indicators and pressure transducers for flight tests to VD) should be calibrated within 60 days of the test in addition to the other requirements mentioned above. The instrument hysteresis should be known; therefore, readings at suitable increments should be taken in both increasing and decreasing directions. Calibration records, like the one shown in table 3, should be signed by the agent of the repair or overhaul facility doing the work and be available to the test pilot prior to beginning test flying. It should be emphasized that these calibrations must be accomplished at an approved facility. For example, performing a pitot-static/air data system leak check to "calibrate" an airspeed indicator, whether in or out of the airplane, is not acceptable.
Table 3 – Sample Portion of Airspeed Indicator Calibration
XYZ INSTRUMENT SERVICE, INC. ABC CITY AIRPORT APPROVED REPAIR STATION - NO. 1234
8/12/80 P/N 1701DX8-04 S/N AF55-17044
A/S Indicator KNOTS
Master Test Ascent Indicator Reads Descent Indicator Reads
40 38.0 39.0
50 49.0 50.5
60 59.5 61.0
70 70.0 71.0
80 80.0 81.0
(3) Use of Ballast.
(i) Loading. Ballast loading of the airplane can be accomplished several ways to achieve a specific weight and c.g. location as long as the loading remains within the physical confines of the airplane. In flight test work, loading problems will occasionally be encountered, making it difficult to obtain the desired c.g. location. Those cases may require loading in engine compartments or other places not designed for load carrying. When this condition is encountered, care should be taken to ensure that local structural stresses are not exceeded or that airplane flight characteristics are not changed due to changes in moments of inertia caused by adding a very long arm (tail post, and so forth).
(ii) Solid and Liquid Ballast. There are basically two types of ballast that may be used in airplane loading: solid or liquid. The solids are usually high-density materials such as lead or sandbags, while the liquid is usually water. In critical tests, the ballast should be loaded in a manner so that disposal in flight, if considered, can be accomplished and be located at a point that will produce a significant c.g. shift to a less critical c.g. location. Applicants should perform a simple structural analysis for complex load installations that have the potential to interfere with safe flight and landing if there was a failure of the supporting structure. In any case, the load should be securely attached in its loaded position. In airplanes with multiple fuel
tank arrangements, the fuel load and distribution should be considered for weight and c.g. control.
(4) Function and Reliability (F&R) Tests for Airplanes over 6,000 pounds Maximum Certificated Weight. While § 21.35(b)(2) does not require F&R testing for airplanes weighing less than 6000 lbs., the Small Airplane Directorate’s policy is to require (via special conditions) a comprehensive Function and Reliability testing program regardless of weight for complex airplanes that include features like FADEC controlled engines, pressurization, and avionics integrated with FMS and autopilot capability.
(i) A comprehensive and systematic check of all aircraft components must be made to assure that they perform their intended function and are reliable.
(ii) F&R certification testing must be accomplished on an aircraft that is in conformity with the approved type design. Furthermore, the number of airplanes used should be limited to meet the intent of F&R testing. F&R certification testing should follow the type certification testing. This is to assure that significant changes resulting from type certification tests can be incorporated on the aircraft and successfully retested prior to the F&R tests.
(a) A certain portion of the F&R test program should emphasize systems, operational conditions, or environments found particularly marginal during type certification tests. Applicants should put the aircraft in as many different environments as possible (for example, cold, hot, rain, etc.) as well as different types of airports to exercise the systems as they will be in the field.
Note: It is important to perform F&R testing with the configuration the manufacturer is planning to deliver to the customer (this may be different than what is configured at the end of initial certification). This is especially important in the case of software and post-TC changes.
(iii) All components of the aircraft should be periodically operated in sequences and combinations likely to occur in service. Ground inspection should be made at appropriate intervals to identify potential failure conditions; however, no special maintenance beyond that described in the Aircraft Maintenance Manual should be allowed.
(iv) A complete record of defects and failures should be maintained along with required servicing of aircraft fluid levels. Results of this record should be consistent with inspection and servicing information provided in the Aircraft Maintenance Manual.
2. § 23.23 Load Distribution Limits.
a. Explanation.
(1) C.G. Envelope. The test tolerance of ±7 percent of the total c.g. range (given in § 23.21) is intended to allow some practical relief for in-flight c.g. movement. This relief is only acceptable when the test data general scatter is on either side of the limiting c.g. or when c.g.
correction from test c.g. to limit c.g. is acceptable. Sufficient points inside the desired weight and balance envelope should be explored to ensure that the operational pilot will not be placed in an unsafe condition. Should unsatisfactory flight characteristics be present, the limits of the envelope should be reduced to ensure safe margins. Where variation in the c.g. position may have a significant effect on the result of a test (for example, spins and VMC), the result should be corrected to the most critical c.g. position within the operating limits to be approved. If such a correction is impractical or may be unreliable, the actual test should ensure that the measured characteristics represent the critical value.
(2) Narrow Utility C.G. Envelope. Some utility category airplanes, for which spin approval is sought, may have a very narrow c.g. range. If a limited fuel load is required to achieve the narrow c.g. envelope, the test pilot should ensure that loading instructions or aids (such as fuel tank tabs) will enable the operational pilot to stay in the approved c.g. envelope.
(3) Gross Weight Effects. The test pilot is expected to determine the effect that gross weight, including low-fuel state, may have on the airplane's flight characteristics. If it is found the flight characteristics would be adversely affected, tests should be performed for trim, stability, and controllability including VMC, stalls, and spins under the most adverse weight condition. Separate loading restrictions may apply to certain flight operations, such as spins.
(4) Lateral Loads. If possible loading conditions can result in a significant variation of the lateral c.g., this lateral range of c.g. must be established by:
(i) The limits selected by the applicant;
(ii) The limits for which the structure has been proven; or
(iii) The limits for which compliance with all the applicable flight requirements has been demonstrated. The demonstrated weight and c.g. combinations should consider asymmetric loadings. When investigating the effects of asymmetric lateral loads, the following sections in this flight test guide (FTG) represent applicable flights requirements:
(a) § 23.143 Controllability and Maneuverability, General. (b) § 23.147 Directional and lateral control. (c) § 23.149 Minimum control speed. (d) § 23.151 Acrobatic maneuvers. (e) § 23.157 Rate of roll. (f) § 23.161 Trim. (g) § 23.201 Wings level stall. (h) § 23.203 Turning flight and accelerated turning stalls. (i) § 23.221 Spinning. (j) § 23.233 Directional stability and control. (k) § 23.701 Flap interconnection.
b. Procedures. None.
3. § 23.25 Weight Limits.
a. Explanation.
(1) Maximum Weight Limits. The maximum weight may be limited in three ways: at the election of the applicant, by structural design requirements, or by flight requirements.
(2) Maximum Weight Exceptions. The regulations concerning design maximum weight allow an exception that some of the structural requirements may be met at a lesser weight known as a design landing weight, which is defined in § 23.473. (Refer to Advisory Circular (AC) 23-7 if the airplane is being modified for an increase in maximum weight.) Due to changes in the operational requirements of an owner/operator, in many cases the need arises to modify and substantiate the structure for an increase in maximum weight and maximum landing weight. Any one of these increases affects the airplane's basic loads and structural integrity, and they could affect the limitations and performance.
(i) If an airplane was certificated with maximum landing weight equal to maximum weight, some applicants take advantage of the five percent difference between design landing and design maximum weight permitted by § 23.473(b). These applicants use the STC process. In these cases, re-substantiation of the landing gear for landing loads is not required when increasing the maximum weight by as much as five percent. For those programs involving more than a five percent increase in maximum weight, some re-substantiation of the landing gear should be accomplished.
(ii) Other applicants are replacing piston engines with turbopropeller engines, thus requiring that gasoline be replaced with jet fuel, which weighs as much as 17 percent more. In some cases, the quantity of fuel is being increased at the same time as engine replacement, but the maximum zero fuel weight remains the same.
(iii) All the above types of modifications should be investigated to verify that critical loads have not increased or that those loads that have increased are capable of being carried by the existing or modified structure.
(3) Weight, Altitude, Temperature (WAT). For all airplanes with a maximum takeoff weight exceeding 6,000 pounds and turbine engine airplanes, a WAT chart may be used as a maximum weight limitation.
(4) Ramp Weight. The applicant may elect to use a "ramp weight" provided compliance is shown with each applicable section of part 23. Ramp weight is the takeoff weight at brake release plus an increment of fuel weight consumed during engine start, taxiing, and runup. Generally, this increment of fuel should not exceed one percent of the maximum permissible flight weight up to 125 pounds. The pilot should be provided a means to reasonably determine the airplane gross weight at brake release for takeoff. A fuel totalizer is one way of providing the pilot with fuel on board. Alternately, a mental calculation by the pilot may be used, if the pilot is provided the information to make the calculation and the calculation is not too complex. Normally, fuel for engine start and run-up will be sufficiently close to an amount fixed such that taxi can be considered as the only variable. If the pilot is provided with taxi fuel burn rate in
pounds per minute, then the resulting mental calculation is acceptable. The pilot will be responsible to ensure that the takeoff gross weight limitation is complied with for each takeoff, whether it is limited by altitude, temperature, or other criteria. The maximum ramp weight should be shown as a limitation on the TC Data Sheet and in the AFM.
(5) Lowest Maximum Weight. Sections 23.25(a)(2)(i) and 23.25(a)(2)(ii) require that each of the two conditions, (i) and (ii), must be considered and that the maximum weight, as established, not be less than the weight under either condition. This has to be shown with the most critical combinations of required equipment for the type of operation for which certification is requested.
(6) Placarding of Seats. When establishing a maximum weight in accordance with § 23.25(a)(2)(i), one or more seats may be placarded to a weight of less than 170 pounds (or less than 190 pounds for utility and acrobatic category airplanes). An associated requirement is § 23.1557(b). The AFM loading instructions, required by § 23.1589(b), should be specific in addressing the use of the placarded seats.
b. Procedures. None.
4. § 23.29 Empty Weight and Corresponding Center of Gravity.
a. Explanation.
(1) Fixed Ballast. Fixed ballast refers to ballast that is made a permanent part of the airplane as a means of controlling the c.g.
(2) Equipment List. Compliance with § 23.29(b) may be accomplished with an equipment list that defines the installed equipment at the time of weighing and the weight, arm, and moment of the equipment.
b. Procedures. For prototype and modified test airplanes, it is necessary to establish a known basic weight and c.g. position (by weighing) from which the extremes of weight and c.g. travel required by the test program may be calculated. Normally, the test crew will verify the calculations.
5. § 23.31 Removable Ballast.
a. Explanation. This regulation is associated only with ballast that is installed in certificated airplanes under specified conditions. The ballasting of prototype airplanes so that flight tests can be conducted at certain weight and c.g. conditions is covered under § 23.21, paragraph 3, of this AC.
b. Fluid Cargo. For those airplanes configured to carry fluid cargo (such as agricultural chemical tanks, minnow tanks, slurry tanks, and so forth), airplane handling qualities should be evaluated for controllability and non-exceedance of the limitations at the full and the most critical partial fluid loads. When so equipped, the effects of in-flight jettison or dumping of the
fluid load should be evaluated to establish that the pilot is able to exercise sufficient control to prevent unacceptably large flight path excursions or exceedance of operational/structural limits.
6. § 23.33 Propeller Speed and Pitch Limits.
a. Explanation. Section 23.33(a) requires that propeller speed and pitch be limited to values that will ensure safe operation under normal operating conditions.
b. Procedures.
(1) Fixed Pitch Propellers.
(i) Maximum Revolutions per Minute (r.p.m.). The regulation is self-explanatory.
(ii) Static r.p.m. Determine the average static r.p.m. with the airplane stationary and the engine operating at full throttle under a no-wind condition. The mixture setting should be the same as used for maximum r.p.m. determination. If the wind is light (5 knots or less), this static r.p.m. can be the average obtained with a direct crosswind from the left and a direct crosswind from the right.
(iii) Data Sheet r.p.m. Determination. For fixed pitch propellers, the static r.p.m. range is listed in the TC Data Sheet: for example, not more than 2200 r.p.m. and not less than 2100 r.p.m. The allowable static r.p.m. range is normally established by adding and subtracting 50 r.p.m. to an average no-wind static r.p.m. Applicants should account for altitude and temperature effects in the TCDS. An applicant may desire to obtain approval for one or more additional propellers and retain only one r.p.m. range statement. An applicant may also choose to extend the propeller's static r.p.m. range.
(a) Lower r.p.m.. The static r.p.m. range may be extended on the low side by obtaining approval for a propeller with a lower static r.p.m. In this case, the approval must be accomplished with due consideration of performance requirements. The airplane with the new propeller installed must be able to meet the minimum climb performance requirements.
(b) Higher r.p.m.. If the static r.p.m. range is to be extended upward, the new propeller would have to be tested to ensure that it did not cause an engine speed above 110 percent of maximum continuous speed in a closed throttle dive at the never-exceed speed. It must not exceed the rated takeoff r.p.m. of the engine up to and including the best rate of climb speed of the airplane. An engine cooling climb test may also be required due to the additional power produced by the faster turning propeller.
(2) Controllable Pitch Propellers Without Constant Speed Controls.
(i) Climb r.p.m. With the propeller in full low pitch, determine that the maximum r.p.m. during a climb using maximum power at the all-engine(s)-operating climb speed does not exceed the rated takeoff r.p.m. of the engine.
(ii) Dive r.p.m. With the propeller in full high pitch, determine that the closed throttle r.p.m. in a dive at the never-exceed speed is not greater than 110 percent of the rated maximum continuous r.p.m. of the engine.
(3) Controllable Pitch Propellers With Constant Speed Controls.
(i) Climb r.p.m. With the propeller governor operative and propeller control in full high r.p.m. position, determine that the maximum power r.p.m. does not exceed the rated takeoff r.p.m. of the engine during takeoff and climb at the all-engine(s)-operating climb speed.
(ii) Static r.p.m. With the propeller governor made inoperative by mechanical means, obtain a no-wind static r.p.m.
(a) Reciprocating Engines. Determine that the maximum power static r.p.m., with the propeller blade operating against the low pitch stop, does not exceed 103 percent of the rated takeoff r.p.m. of the engine.
(b) Turbopropeller Engines. Although this rule references manifold pressure, it has been considered to be applicable to turbopropeller installations. With the governor inoperative, the propeller blades at the lowest possible pitch, with takeoff power, the airplane stationary, and no wind, ensure that the propeller speed does not exceed the maximum approved engine and propeller r.p.m. limits. Propellers that go to feather when the governor is made inoperative need not be tested.
(iii) Safe Operation Under Normal Operating Conditions.
(a) Reciprocating Engines. Descent at VNE with full power, although within the normal operating range, is not a normal operating procedure. Engine r.p.m., with the propeller on the high pitch blade stops, that can be controlled by retarding the throttle may be considered as acceptable in showing compliance with § 23.33(a).
(b) Turbopropeller Engines. Perform a maximum r.p.m. at maximum torque (or power) descent at VMO to ensure that normal operating limits for the propeller are not exceeded.
(4) Data Acquisition and Reduction. Outside air temperature and altitude needs to be considered for the ground tests. The observed r.p.m. data in each case must be corrected for tachometer error. The airspeed system error must also be taken into consideration to determine the proper calibrated airspeed. True airspeed may also need to be considered because propeller angle of attack is a function of true airspeed.
Section 2. Performance
1. § 23.45 General.
a. Explanation.
(1) Atmospheric Standards. The purpose of § 23.45(a) is to set the atmospheric standards in which the performance requirements should be met. The air should be smooth with no temperature inversions, mountain waves, and so forth. This is essential to obtaining good data and repeatable results. Non-standard conditions of temperature, pressure, and so forth, can be corrected to standard, but there are no corrections to compensate for poor quality data due to turbulence or poor pilot technique. A thorough knowledge of the limitations of the testing procedures and data reduction methods is essential so that good engineering judgment may be used to determine the acceptability of any tests.
(i) Reciprocating Engine-Powered Airplanes Below 6,000 pounds (2730 kg) Maximum Weight. Performance tests will normally be conducted in non-standard atmospheric conditions, but ideally for accuracy in data reduction and expansion, tests should be conducted in atmospheric conditions as near those of a standard atmosphere as possible. Accounting for winds and non-standard conditions requires testing procedures and data reduction methods that reduce the data to standard atmospheric conditions.
(ii) Reciprocating Engine-Powered Airplanes of More Than 6,000 pounds (2730 kg) Maximum Weight and Turbine-engine Powered Airplanes. Performance tests should be conducted in the range of atmospheric conditions that will show compliance with the selected weight, altitude, and temperature limits. Refer to § 23.53 of this AC for guidance on extrapolation of takeoff data and § 23.75 for extrapolation of landing data.
(2) Standard Atmosphere. The Standard Atmosphere is identical to the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Standard Atmosphere for altitudes below 65,000 feet. Appendix 7, figure 1, gives properties of the Standard Atmosphere in an abbreviated format.
(3) Installed Power. The installed propulsive horsepower/thrust of the test engine(s) may be determined using the applicable method described in appendix 1, based on the power approved during airplane certification. The methods in appendix 1 account for installation losses and the power absorbed by accessories and services. Consideration should also be given to the accuracy of the power setting instruments/systems, and the pilot's ability to accurately set the power/thrust.
(4) Propeller Cutoff. In general, if the airplane will be approved with an allowable cutoff for the propeller, then the performance flight testing should be done using the most critical propeller diameter. In most cases, this is expected to be the minimum diameter propeller allowed.
(i) For normal, utility, and acrobatic category airplanes only, a two percent margin was the allowed reduction in propeller diameter. Historically, the two percent margin was selected as being the maximum permissible reduction in diameter of a given propeller that will not noticeably reduce performance. Service history has shown this to be an acceptable margin without additional flight testing.
(5) Flight Procedures. The flight procedures must not be unduly sensitive to less than ideal atmospheric conditions. The atmospheric conditions "reasonably expected to be encountered in service" may be different depending on the class of aircraft, but should cover at least the maximum demonstrated crosswind component established in compliance with § 23.233(a).
(6) Flight Test Data. For calibrated engines, test day power is the calibrated test day power. For uncalibrated engines, an acceptable method is to assume that the test day power is the upper tolerance chart brake horsepower; however, the upper tolerance chart brake horsepower for reciprocating engines using 14 CFR part 33 tolerances of +5 percent, -0 percent may lead to unrealistic performance. Historically, the two major reciprocating engine manufacturer’s engines have tolerances closer to +2 percent, -0 percent. Refer to appendix 1 for further information. The performance data required by § 23.1587 is dependent on the horsepower assumed for the various temperature and altitude conditions. Refer to appendix 1, which deals both with test data reduction and expansion.
(7) Humidity Correction. Refer to appendix 1.
b. Procedures. Refer to appendix 1.
c. Operation on Unpaved Runways.
(1) Small airplane operations from grass runways. For airplanes less than 6,000 pounds (2730 kg) maximum weight, the factors given below may be quoted in the flight manual, as an alternative to the scheduling of data derived from testing or calculation. It should be noted that these factors are intended to cover the range of airplane types in this category and are necessarily conservative. Manufacturers are, therefore, encouraged to produce and schedule their own data in accordance with (1) and (2) above to obtain optimized performance for their airplane.
Table 4 - Smooth, Flat Runway
Takeoff Landing Dry Grass 1.2 1.2 Wet Grass 1.3 1.6
Note: If the runway is not smooth, the grass is very long or very short, higher factors may be warranted.
Very short grass = golf course length Very long grass = unmowed field or high interstate highway median grass length
(2) Airplanes with 6,000 pounds (2730 kg) maximum weight or more. The following guidance was developed to include high performance multiengine airplanes. The level of detail should be scaled back to that appropriate for the airplane. Simple, single-engine turbine bush airplanes, for example, do not need the level of detail discussed here.
Operations on other than smooth, dry, hard runway surfaces may require specific approval and the scheduling of information on the effect of those surfaces on takeoff and landing distances in the flight manual. Applicants may use the factors for grass runways in paragraph (1). These factors would, in many cases, result in such conservative distances that operational utility may be compromised. Applicants may propose their own factors if accompanied with supporting data. To obtain approval for takeoff and landing operations on unpaved runway surfaces, compliance with the following should be shown:
(i) Each type of surface must be defined so that it can be recognized in operations in service including conditions such as day or wet.
(ii) It must be determined that the airplane can be operated on each defined surface without hazard from likely impingement or engine ingestion of any foreign objects that constitute parts of the surface.
(iii) If any special procedures or techniques are found to be necessary, these must also be determined and scheduled.
(iv) The takeoff and landing performance on each defined surface must be determined in accordance with §§ 23.53 and 23.75, as modified in (3) below.
(3) Takeoff and Landing Data. Takeoff and landing data must be determined for each type of unpaved surface for which approval is requested.
(i) The test runways on which the takeoff and landing distance measurements are conducted should be chosen to be representative of the worst characteristics (that is, high rolling friction, low braking friction) of each of the types of runway under consideration.
(ii) In establishing the operation limitations for a particular type of unpaved runway, the runway’s load bearing characteristics, rolling and braking friction, and impingement and ingestion characteristics, should be considered.
e. Wet and Contaminated Runways. Reserved.
2. § 23.49 Stalling Speed.
a. Explanation.
(1) 61 Knot Stall Speed. The 61 knot stalling speed applies to the maximum takeoff weight for which the airplane is to be certificated.
(2) Background. Since many of the regulations pertain to performance, handling qualities, airspeed indicator markings, and other variables that are functions of stall speeds, it is desirable to accomplish the stall speed testing early in the program so the data are available for subsequent testing. Because of this interrelationship between the stall speeds and other critical performance parameters, it is essential that accurate measurement methods and careful piloting techniques be used. Most standard airplane pitot-static systems have not been found to be acceptable for stall speed determination. These tests require the use of properly calibrated instruments and usually require a separate test airspeed system, such as a trailing bomb, a trailing cone, or an acceptable nose or wing boom. The stall speed determinations necessary for marking the airspeed indicator are in terms of indicated airspeed (IAS) corrected for instrument error. The other stall speeds are in terms of calibrated airspeed (CAS). Thus, a production airspeed system should be available during stall speed measurements to determine stall speeds in terms of IAS.
(3) Stall Definition. Section 23.49(d) requires the VS0 and VS1 speeds to be determined using the procedures specified in § 23.201. Refer to 14 CFR part 1 and § 23.49 for definitions of VS0 and VS1. “Landing configuration” in part 23 is gear down and full flaps. Section 23.201(b) defines when the airplane can be considered stalled for airplane certification purposes when one of three conditions occurs, whichever occurs first. The conditions are:
(i) Uncontrollable downward pitching motion;
(ii) Downward pitching motion resulting from the activation of a device (for example, stick pusher); or,
(iii) The control reaches the stop.
(a) For those airplanes where the control reaches the stop, VS is considered to be the minimum speed obtained while the control is held against the stop. Elevator limited airplanes may or may not develop a minimum steady flight speed. Refer to figure 1 for a graphic representation of stall speed time histories for various configurations. The time the control is held against the stop for stall speed determination should be a minimum of two seconds and consistent with the time against the stop for stall characteristics testing in § 23.201.
Additionally, for airplanes with a stall barrier system, stick pusher operation has been considered as the stall speed. The term "uncontrollable downward pitching motion" is the point at which the pitching motion can no longer be arrested by application of nose-up elevator and is not necessarily the first indication of nose-down pitch.
(4) Reciprocating Engine Throttle Position. For reciprocating engine airplanes, the stalling speed is that obtainable with the propellers in the takeoff position and the engines idling with throttles closed. As an alternative to "throttles closed," the regulations allow the use of sufficient power to produce zero propeller thrust at a speed not more than 10 percent above the stalling speed. The regulations do not allow any alternative to the use of "propellers in the takeoff position," nor is any alternative intended except that the use of a feathered propeller in certification stalling speed tests is acceptable only when it has been determined that the resulting stalling speed is conservative (higher). If the stalling speed tests are to be conducted with the propellers delivering zero thrust, a dependable method of determining inflight thrust, such as a propeller slipstream rake, should be available in flight. The practice of establishing zero thrust r.p.m. by calculation is also acceptable. One calculation method is given in paragraph (5) below. Analytical corrections may be acceptable if satisfactory accounting is made for the effects of propeller efficiency, slipstream, altitude, and other pertinent variables.
(5) Zero-Thrust r.p.m. Calculation.
(i) Zero-thrust r.p.m. can be calculated by using the propeller manufacturer's propeller coefficient curves. The thrust will be zero when the propeller thrust coefficient is zero for the particular propeller blade angle. Using the propeller coefficient curves, obtain or construct a chart like figure 2, where:
CT = thrust coefficient CP = power coefficient ß = blade angle setting J = advance ratio
0 w UJ a.. V')
~ <
·- ·· l· ·:· t ·::: TRIM SPEED - ··--
-----
TRIM SPEED ---·- ----- ,__ _.
1----·t- . -
·-· ... -
. . -
:::::: __ ::::: ·- :-_ :::- :::-::- .. - … ·- ... - . -.. … =:: - … -··.
:: : : ::__:. : : : : . ---
.. -
-----· :=: =:: i-:-:-~: ::.:: ... : :..:: :::.:. :::...:: :::.:
.. ·-- ~ -- . -. - : :.-= : : :: ..: … : ···- :t:::::r,,.;__··. :::: ::::-::::
. ·-
··- ···- ·- - ···· t----
ELEVATOR
REACHES
STOP
,-_-+_--+--+--ELEVATOR ~ '::. .:::· = :: ---_;_ ._::::.: CONTROL ::-:-:- LIMITED* ::::: -
. . :'"'"-1. •• - 1 · … ·-. :: .. ,.: ·-. 1-"'. ~= : -·- … : : :; : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : ~ ~~6:. ·:: :::: :::. ···- … ·-:: :::·: :::-:- ::.:f--:-;: :::. :·:: :::: :::: :··· 1,~ . . ·- ··- -···. __ ,._ . - .... 1 .... 1 .. 1 .• •• j •••• , .. .. ::~: ::: =11:·.~~ : ·: :: ::: :. ·c:-r =--~ ::-:.~ :::: ARTIFICIAL BARRIER ·-·- ;:;i ~j ~~i . ·!j ?-:~~;~ -~~ ~~~ _:::: :::: . \_~USHER SY~! ~ ) __
: :: :. ::: : ~ ~-- :t.· : :· 7."::: ENTRY .:- ..:....:.~: ~ ::.:.;. .. : :::: ::--:- :::: :: : : : : : : -.. - - .. RATE - SLOPE
-~ ~ --- l- … I- -- --- -·-·- . : :: r.-;....: I-----· ... . ·-. -- '-_-_·':"-:-.: :.::: ~: : ::.:.: : PUSHER 1-::: __ .;.;.i~4"-+ -+---i-:-:-:-+:-:--:-±:-:-:: ::-:-_ ~t-:.::_:-_ .• ± :-:-:t _:-:-_-:: __ :t FI RED
~ --1--- 4-- - -+-· _. _. ·+ .-.-_-_ +-f--.-.-.+-- -+-:-:-: ~ ~: :~ ~ ~~ : . . . • : - . I - -' -i _ ...
--i .:::-:
. ·-- ---- -·--1--- · -.. - ... - .
TIME - SECONDS
--·- . - . ··-
-- . - ...
: ::-:. :.:::-: …
. -· - …
.::_
:::.:
Figure 1 Stall Speed
(ii) The propeller blade is usually against the low pitch stop position, in the speed range of interest. Knowing the blade angle setting, the advance ratio J can be determined to give zero-thrust for the particular propeller under consideration. Knowing the value of J for zerothrust, the propeller r.p.m. for various velocities can be calculated as follows:
Propeller r.p.m. = 101.27 V
JD
Where: V = airplane true airspeed in knots
J = advance ratio D = propeller diameter in feet
(iii) The calculated velocities and propeller r.p.m. for zero-thrust can be plotted as shown in figure 3.
(iv) Another approach is to use the prop rake method. In some cases this may be easier to use and more accurate.
(6) Turbopropeller Thrust. For turbopropeller airplanes, § 23.49(a)(2) requires the propulsive thrust not be greater than zero during stall speed determination or, as an alternative to zero thrust, if idle thrust has no appreciable effect on stall speed, stall speed can be determined with the engines idling. If the airplane has a flight idle position, this would be the appropriate throttle position. Flight test experience has shown that some turbopropeller-powered airplanes may demonstrate a relatively high positive propeller thrust at the stall speed with the engines at flight idle. This thrust condition may yield an unconservative (lower) stall speed; therefore, just as for piston-powered airplanes, some dependable method to determine zero thrust should be available for comparison of zero thrust stall speed and flight idle stall speed or for determination of zero thrust stall speed. Residual jet thrust should be considered. Comparisons of zero thrust stall speed and flight idle stall speed should be investigated at high and low altitudes. Use of feathered propellers is acceptable if the feathered stall speeds are found to be conservative (higher).
(7) Fixed Shaft Turboprops. Experience on some fixed-shaft turboprop installations indicates that stall speeds can be evaluated at mid-altitudes and appear to be totally conservative. However, if stalls are conducted at altitudes of 5,000 feet or below, the stall speed can increase dramatically. This occurs because the propeller drag characteristics are a function of true airspeed, and as true airspeed decreases, the drag goes up substantially and the flow behind the propeller on wing-mounted engines causes premature inboard wing airflow separation.
(i) In addition, if the horizontal tail and the elevator are exposed to the same flow, the elevator power is decreased and tends to compound the problem. It is recommended that stall speeds be re-evaluated at low altitudes on all fixed shaft turboprops to assure that the stall speeds have not increased.
V-TAS IN KNOTS
Figure 2 Propeller Coefficients
CP - POWER
COEFFICIENT
J - ADVANCE RATIO
CT =.10
CT=.08
CT=.06
CT=.04
CT=.02
CT=0
B=10O
B=15O
B=20O
B=25O
B=30O
Figure 3 Zero Thrust
P R O P E L L E R
R P M
V-TAS IN KNOTS
-- --
(8) Turbojets and turbofans.
(i) Stall speeds are normally defined with the thrust levers at idle; however, it is necessary to verify by test or analysis that engine idle thrust does not affect stall speeds to an extent that they are appreciably lower than would be experienced at zero thrust. Negative thrust at the stall, which slightly increases stall speeds, is acceptable.
(ii) To determine whether thrust effects on stall speed are significant, at least three stalls should be conducted at one flap setting, with thrust set to approximately the value required to maintain level flight at 1.6 VS in the selected configuration.
(iii) These data may then be extrapolated to a zero thrust condition to eliminate the effects of idle thrust on stall speeds (refer to figure 4). If the difference between idle thrust and zero thrust stall speed is 0.5 knots or less, the effect may be considered insignificant.
Figure 4 Thrust Effect on Stall CL
ENGINE THRUST
STALL CL
THRUST EFFECT ON
STALL CL
IDLE
THRUST
THRUST FOR 1.6 Vs
IN LEVEL FLIGHT
ZERO
THRUST
b. Procedures.
(1) Instrumentation.
(i) Test Systems. As previously mentioned, the production airspeed system is normally not sufficiently predictable or repeatable at high angles of attack to accurately measure the performance stall speeds of an airplane. However, a production airspeed system should be installed during stall speed tests to define the airspeed indicator markings required by § 23.1545.
(a) The performance stall speed test system utilized in a type certification program should be calibrated to a minimum speed at least as low as the predicted minimum stall speed anticipated on the test airplane. Test systems that have been utilized to accurately define the performance stall speeds include, but are not limited to the following:
1. Boom Systems. Swivel-head, boom-mounted, pitot-static systems with sufficient free-swivel angle to cover the stall angle-of-attack range of the airplane have been found to be acceptable. Some angle-of-attack compensated fixed pitot heads have also been found to be acceptable over a wind tunnel defined angle-of-attack range. Another way to make the fixed pitot work for stall speeds is to mount the boom at a negative incidence angle biased for the stall angle of attack. In all wing-mounted boom systems, the boom mounted static source should be at least one chord length ahead of the wing leading edge. On nose-boom mounted systems, it has been generally accepted that the static source should be at least one and one-half fuselage diameters ahead of the nose. All boom systems should be installed in a manner which assures that the boom and boom pitot-static head are structurally sound (both static and dynamic) within the proposed operating range.
2. Pitot-Static Bombs. Pitot-static bombs that are stable through the stall maneuvers have been found to provide acceptable data.
3. Trailing Cones. A trailing cone static source dynamically balanced with a swivel head pitot source, or dynamically balanced with a fixed pitot source of proven accuracy in the stall angle-of-attack range has been acceptable. The stability of the cone should be verified during stall tests and throughout its intended operating range. The length of the cone may need to be adjusted on individual airplane installations to assure cone stability.
(ii) Lag Equalization. All of the systems described in paragraph (i) could involve the use of long lengths of pressure tubing, and the associated pressure lags then occur whenever either speed or altitude, or both, are changed. Probably the most important consideration in these installations (on most small general aviation airplanes) is that the test pitot-static systems should be dynamically balanced. This is easily accomplished experimentally by putting both the total head and static orifices in a common chamber and varying the pressure in the chamber at a rate corresponding to a 2,000 to 3,000 feet-per-minute rate of descent. Various volumes are inserted in the total head line until the airspeed indicator has no tendency to move in either direction from zero during the simulated rate of descent. This method results in approximately the same volume in both systems, and, for the same size tubing, the Reynolds Number of the flow through both lines will be the same. A dynamically balanced airspeed system has equal lag in both the total and static sides. Use of a balanced system simplifies the interpretation of recorded stall time histories.
(iii) Lag Correction. When a balanced test airspeed system is used, it is often unnecessary to determine the actual amount of lag present. When such a determination is necessary, a method of accounting for lag errors is described in NASA Reference Publication 1046, "Measurement of Aircraft Speed and Altitude," by W. Gracey, May 1980. A lag correction is unnecessary if it can be shown that the system lag is small enough to be considered insignificant.
F
(iv) Transducer Location. The instrumentation should account for any difference in the installed location of the pressure transducers used in the cone, boom, or bomb and the aircraft system.
(2) Test.
(i) Stall Speed. The actual test should be commenced with the airplane in the configuration desired and trimmed at approximately 1.5 VS1 or the minimum speed trim, whichever is greater. The airplane should be slowed to about 10 knots above the stall, at which time the speed should be reduced at a rate of one knot per second or less, until the stall occurs or the control reaches the stop. Where exact determination of stalling speed is required, entry rate should be varied to bracket one knot per second, and data should be recorded to allow the preparation of time histories similar to those shown in figure 1. The indicated airspeed at the stall should be noted, using the production airspeed system. Both the IAS and the calibrated stall speeds may then be plotted versus entry rate to determine the one knot per second values.
(ii) Bomb. When using a bomb, caution should be used in recovering from the stall so that the bomb is not whipped off the end of the hose.
(iii) Weight and C.G. The stalling speed should be determined at all weight and c.g. positions defining the corners of the loading envelope to determine the critical condition. Data should be recorded so that the weight and c.g. at the time of the test can be accurately determined. This can often be done by recording the time of takeoff, time of test, time of landing, and total fuel used during the flight.
(iv) Power and Configuration. The stall should be repeated enough times for each configuration to ensure a consistent speed. If a correction is to be made for zero thrust, then the stall speed and power at several power settings may be recorded for later extrapolation to zero thrust.
(v) Control Stops. The elevator up stop should be set to the minimum allowable deflection. Flap travels should be set to minimum allowable settings.
(3) Data Reduction. The correction involves:
(i) Correction for airspeed error. IAS to CAS (correct for instrument as well as position error) when CAS is required.
(ii) Correction for weight. Multiply the test calibrated stall speed times the square root of the standard weight divided by the test weight.
WS VS = VST WT
Where: VS = Stall speed (CAS)
VST= Test stall speed (CAS) WS = Standard weight (pounds) WT = Test weight (pounds)
(iii) The correction for weight shown above applies only where the c.g. is not also changing with weight. Where c.g. is changing with weight, such as between forward regardless and forward gross, stall speed should account for this. A straight line variation between the measured stall speeds for the two weight and c.g. conditions has been found to be an acceptable method.
3. § 23.51 Takeoff Speeds.
a. Explanation. The primary objective of this section is to determine the normal takeoff speeds for non-weight, altitude, and temperature limited airplanes. For WAT limited airplanes, the objective is to determine the takeoff speed schedules for all takeoff configurations at weight, altitude, and temperature conditions within the operational limits selected by the applicant.
b. Procedures. For normal, utility, and acrobatic category airplanes, the rotation speed, (VR) in terms of calibrated airspeed, must be selected by the applicant. VR is constrained by § 23.51(a), as follows:
(1) For multiengine landplanes. VR must not be less than the greater of 1.05 VMC or 1.10 VS1;
(2) For single-engine landplanes. VR must not be less than VS1; and
(3) For seaplanes and amphibians taking off from water. VR may be any speed that is shown to be safe under all reasonably expected conditions, including turbulence and complete failure of the critical engine.
c. Procedures. For normal, utility, and acrobatic category airplanes, the speed at 50 feet should be determined by:
(1) Multiengine 50-foot Speed. For multiengine airplanes, § 23.51(b)(1) requires the speed at the 50-foot point to be the higher of the following:
(i) A speed that is shown to be safe for continued flight (or land back, if applicable) under all reasonably expected conditions, including turbulence and complete engine failure; or
(ii) 1.1 VMC; or
(iii) 1.2 VS1.
(2) Single Engine 50-foot Speed. For single-engine airplanes, § 23.51(b)(2) requires the speed at the 50-foot point to be the higher of the following:
(i) A speed that is shown to be safe under all reasonably expected conditions, including turbulence and complete engine failure; or
(ii) 1.2 VS1.
(3) Takeoff Speed Investigations - General. Investigation of the acceptability of the takeoff speed and of the associated takeoff procedure should include a demonstration that controllability and maneuverability in the takeoff configuration are adequate to safely proceed with the takeoff in turbulent crosswind conditions and maximum approved lateral imbalance.
(4) Single-engine Airplane Takeoff Speeds. The takeoff speed investigation should include a demonstration that controllability and maneuverability following engine failure at any time between lift-off and the 50-foot point are adequate for safe landing.
(5) Multiengine Airplane Takeoff Speeds. For multiengine airplanes, the investigation should include a demonstration that the controllability and maneuverability following critical engine failure at any time between lift-off and the 50-foot point are adequate for either safe landing or for safe continuation of the takeoff. There will be some combinations of weight, altitude, and temperature where positive climb at the 50-foot height with one engine inoperative is not possible. Because of this, a satisfactory re-land maneuver should be demonstrated. Rotation speed should be scheduled so that the speed at 50 feet is in accordance with § 23.51(b)(1).
(6) Multiple Takeoff Weights. For those multiengine airplanes for which takeoff distance data are to be approved for a range of weights, and for which the takeoff distance is based upon takeoff speeds that decrease as the weight decreases, the investigations of paragraph (3) of this section also should include consideration of the minimum control speed, VMC. The 1.2 VS design limit imposed on VMC by § 23.149 is intended to provide a controllability margin below the takeoff speed that is sufficient for adequate control of the airplane in the event of engine failure during takeoff. Hence, to maintain the intended level of safety for the lower takeoff speeds associated with the lighter takeoff weights, investigation of the acceptability of such speeds for compliance with § 23.51(b)(1) should include demonstration of acceptable characteristics following engine failure at any time between liftoff and the 50-foot point during takeoff in accordance with the established takeoff procedures.
(7) Complete Engine Failure. The term "complete engine failure" has been consistently interpreted to require that, for multiengine airplanes that meet the powerplant isolation requirements of § 23.903(c) in the takeoff configuration, only one engine needs to be made inoperative in the specified investigations.
d. Jets Over 6,000 Pounds Maximum Weight and Commuter Category Airplanes.
(1) Takeoff Speeds. The following speed definitions are given in terms of CAS. The AFM presentations are required, by § 23.1581(d), in IAS.
(i) Section 23.51(c)(1) - Engine Failure Speed (VEF). The engine failure speed VEF is defined as the CAS at which the critical engine is assumed to fail and must be selected by the applicant. VEF cannot be less than 1.05 VMC, as determined in § 23.149. Ground controllability should also be determined to be adequate at VEF to ensure meeting the requirements of § 23.51(c)(1), that is, speed adequate to safely continue the takeoff. During the demonstration, the airplane's ground run should not deviate more than 30 feet from the preengine-cut projected ground track. VMCG determined under 14 CFR part 25, § 25.149(f) is acceptable in lieu of 1.05 VMC. At the applicant's option, in crosswind conditions, the runs may be made on reciprocal headings or an analytical correction may be applied to determine the zero crosswind deviation. If nose wheel steering is an integral part of the rudder system and is required to be operative, then nose wheel steering may be active. Otherwise, control of the airplane should be accomplished by use of the rudder only. If the applicant elects to use VMCG, then the nosewheel steering must be disconnected as required in § 25.149(d). All other controls, such as ailerons and spoilers, should only be used to correct any alterations in the airplane attitude and to maintain a wings level condition. Use of those controls to supplement the rudder effectiveness should be avoided.
(ii) Section 23.51(c)(l) - Takeoff Decision Speed (V1). The takeoff decision speed V1 may not be less than VEF plus the speed gained with the critical engine inoperative during the time interval between VEF and the instant at which the pilot recognizes the engine failure. This is indicated by pilot application of the first decelerating device, such as brakes, throttles, spoilers, and so forth, during accelerate-stop tests. The applicant may choose the sequence of events. V1 should include any airspeed system errors determined during acceleratetakeoff ground runs. Refer to the requirements of § 23.1323(c).
(iii) Section 23.51(c)(2)- Rotation Speed (VR).
(a) The rotation speed, VR in terms of in-ground effect CAS, must be selected by the applicant. VR is constrained by § 23.51(c)(2) as follows:
1 V1; or
2 1.05 VMC determined under § 23.149(b); or
3 1.10 VS1; or
4 The speed that allows attaining the initial climbout speed, V2, before reaching a height of 35 feet above the takeoff surface in accordance with § 23.57(c)(2).
(b) Early rotation, one-engine inoperative abuse test.
1 In showing compliance with § 23.51(c)(5), some guidance relative to the airspeed attained at a height of 35 feet during the associated flight test is necessary. As this requirement dealing with a rotation speed abuse test only specifies an early rotation (VR-5 knots), it is assumed that pilot technique is to remain the same as normally used for an engineout condition. With these considerations in mind, it is apparent that the airspeed achieved at a height of 35 feet can be somewhat below the normal scheduled V2 speed. However, the amount of permissible V2 speed reduction should be limited to a reasonable amount, as described in paragraphs 2 and 3 below.
2 In conducting the flight tests required by § 23.51(c)(5), the test pilot should use a normal/natural rotation technique as associated with the use of scheduled takeoff speeds for the airplane being tested. Intentional tail or tail skid contact is not considered acceptable. Further, the airspeed attained at a height of 35 feet during this test is required to be not less than the scheduled V2 value minus five knots. These speed limits should not be considered or utilized as target V2 test speeds but rather are intended to provide an acceptable range of speed departure below the scheduled V2 value.
3 In this abuse test, the engine cut should be accomplished prior to the VR test speed (that is, scheduled VR-5 knots) to allow for engine spin down. The normal oneengine-inoperative takeoff distance may be analytically adjusted to compensate for the effect of the early engine cut. Further, in those tests where the airspeed achieved at a height of 35 feet is slightly less than the V2-5 knots limiting value, it is permissible, in lieu of re-conducting the tests, to analytically adjust the test distance to account for the excessive speed decrement.
(c) All-engines-operating abuse tests.
1 Section 23.51(c)(6) requires that there not be a "marked increase" in the scheduled takeoff distance when reasonably expected service variations, such as early and excessive rotation and out-of-trim conditions, are encountered. This is considered as requiring takeoff tests with all engines operating with:
(aa) An abuse at rotation speed, and
(bb) Out-of-trim conditions, but with rotation at the scheduled VR speed.
Note: The expression "marked increase" in the takeoff distance is defined as any amount in excess of five percent of the takeoff distance as determined in accordance with § 23.59. Thus, the abuse tests should not result in a takeoff distance of more than 105 percent of the scheduled takeoff distance.
2 For the early rotation abuse condition with all engines operating and at a weight as near as practicable to the maximum sea level takeoff weight, it should be shown by test that when the airplane is over-rotated at a speed below the scheduled VR, no "marked increase" in the takeoff distance will result. For this demonstration, the airplane should be rotated at a speed of 10 knots or seven percent, whichever is less, below the scheduled VR. Tests should be conducted at a rapid rotation rate or should include an over-rotation of two degrees above normal attitude after liftoff. Rapid rotation should be taken to mean significantly above the normal pitch rate of rotation. It should be noted that four or five degrees per second have previously proved satisfactory. Tail strikes, should they occur during this demonstration, are acceptable only if a fault analysis (structural, electrical, hydraulic, and so forth) has been accomplished and indicates no possible degradation in the control of aircraft, engines, or essential systems necessary for continued safe flight after a reasonable worst case tail strike.
3 For out-of-trim conditions with all engines operating and at a weight as near as practicable to the maximum sea level takeoff weight, some things should be shown -. With the airplane mis-trimmed, as would reasonably be expected in service, there should not be a "marked increase" in the takeoff distance when rotation is initiated in a normal manner at the scheduled VR speed. The amount of mis-trim used should be with the longitudinal control trimmed to its most adverse position within the allowable takeoff trim band as shown on the cockpit indicator.
(iv) Lift-off Speed (VLOF). VLOF is the CAS at which the airplane first becomes airborne.
(v) Section 23.51(c)(4) - Takeoff Safety Speed (V2). V2 is the CAS that is attained at or before 35 feet above the takeoff surface after an engine failure at VEF using an established rotation speed VR. During the takeoff speed demonstration, V2 should be continued to an altitude sufficient to assure stable conditions beyond 35 feet. Section 23.51(c)(4) requires V2 not be less than 1.1 VMC or 1.2 VS1. Attainment of V2 by 35 feet should be substantiated by use of procedures consistent with those used in service. If auto feather is required, then auto feather should be activated as an integral part of testing.
4. § 23.53 Takeoff Performance.
a. Explanation.
(1) Normal, Utility, and Acrobatic Category Airplanes.
(i) Objective of Takeoff Requirement. The primary objective of the takeoff requirement is to establish, for information of the operator, a takeoff distance within which the airplane may be expected to achieve a speed and height sufficient to ensure capability of performing all maneuvers that may become necessary for safe completion of the takeoff and for safe landing if necessitated by power failure. An airspeed margin above stall in conjunction with a height of 50 feet is presumed to assure the desired maneuvering capability.
(ii) AFM Takeoff Distance. Section 23.1587(c)(1) requires the takeoff distance determined under this section be furnished in the AFM. The data should be furnished at the most critical c.g. (usually forward). Section 23.1587 further requires the effect of altitude from sea level to 10,000 feet and the following:
(a) Temperature from standard to 30 °C above standard; or
(b) For airplanes greater than 6,000 pounds (2730 kg) and turbine-powered airplanes, the AFM should furnish temperature from standard to 30 °C above standard, or the maximum ambient atmospheric temperature at which compliance with the cooling provisions of § 23.1041 to § 23.1047 is shown, if lower. Propulsive thrust available should be accounted for in accordance with § 23.45 and appendix 1 of this AC. For turbine-powered airplanes, distances should be presented up to the maximum takeoff temperature limit. A data expansion method appropriate to the airplane's features should be used.
(iii) AFM Takeoff Technique. For multiengine airplanes, § 23.1585(d)(1) requires the AFM to furnish the procedures for the § 23.53 takeoff. The recommended technique that is published in the AFM and used to achieve the performance should be one that the operational pilot can duplicate using the minimum amount of type design cockpit instrumentation and the minimum crew.
(iv) Tire Speed Limits. If tires approved through the technical standard order (TSO) process are used, it should be determined, within the weight, altitude, and temperature for which takeoff performance is shown in § 23.1587, that the TSO tire speed ratings are not exceeded at VL0F. If the tire speed rating would be exceeded under some combinations of weight, altitude, and temperature, then the tire speed limit should be established as an operating limitation. In compliance with § 23.1581(a)(2), a maximum takeoff weight limited by tire speed chart should also be included in the AFM performance section.
b. Procedures.
(1) Takeoff Distance Tests. The takeoff distance should be established by test. It may be obtained either by takeoffs conducted as a continuous operation from start to the 50-foot
height or synthesized from acceleration segments and climb segment(s) determined separately. Recording theodolite, Global Positioning System (GPS), or electronic equipment that is capable of providing horizontal distance and velocity, and height above the takeoff surface is highly desirable for takeoff distance tests. Additional required special ground equipment includes a sensitive anemometer capable of providing wind velocity and direction, a thermometer capable of providing accurate free-air temperature under all conditions, and an altimeter or barograph to provide pressure altitude.
(2) Segment Technique. For the segment technique, the airplane should be accelerated on the surface from brake release to rotation speed VR and on to the speed selected for the 50-foot height point. Some airplanes may not be able to safely remain on the runway above flying speed. It is acceptable to allow the airplane to fly in ground effect without climbing. Six acceptable runs are recommended to establish the takeoff acceleration segment. VR should be selected so that the 50-foot speed can be achieved. A climb segment based on the rate of climb, free of ground effect, is added to the acceleration segment. Refer to § 23.65 of this AC and appendix 2 for climb performance methods. Total distance is the sum of the acceleration segment plus the climb segment. For AFM presentation, the ground run would be the ground acceleration distance to VL0F, and the air distance would be the horizontal distance to climb at the 50-foot speed for 50 feet plus the ground acceleration distance from VL0F to the 50-foot speed. For those airplanes with retractable gear, the landing gear should be extended throughout or an alternative method of retraction may be initiated at a speed corresponding to a safe speed for gear retraction following liftoff in normal operations. If takeoff distance is determined using the "segmented" method, actual takeoffs using the AFM takeoff speed schedule should be conducted to verify that the actual takeoff distance to the 50-foot height does not exceed the calculated takeoff distance to the 50-foot height.
(3) Weight. Takeoff distance tests should be conducted at the maximum weight, and at a lesser weight if takeoff distance data for a range of weights is to be approved. The test results may be considered acceptable without correction for weight if a ±0.5 percent weight tolerance is observed.
(4) Nose wheel/tail wheel. In the absence of evidence to the contrary, the "critical" c.g. position for takeoff distance tests may be assumed to be forward. However, the applicant should determine the critical c.g. for the aircraft configuration as well as for the runway distance.
(5) Wind. Wind velocity and direction should be measured adjacent to the runway during the time interval of each test run. Refer to section 23.21a(5) of this AC for wind velocity and direction tolerances. For the ground run portion of the segment technique, the following relationship was developed empirically and is an acceptable method for correction of low-wind conditions:
SG = SGW
Where: SG = no-wind takeoff ground distance (feet) SGW = takeoff ground distance at a known wind velocity (feet) VW = wind velocity (feet second)
VTOW = true ground speed, at lift-off with a known wind
velocity (feet/second)
Note 1 + is used for headwind and - for tailwind
Note 2 Wind, then slope corrections should be applied before further data reduction.
(6) Runway Slope. The effect of runway gradient can be significant for heavy airplanes or for low thrust-to-weight ratio airplanes, even if the gradient of the runway is small. Gradient should be controlled by proper runway selection. The correction is as follows:
S SG = GS1 2gSGS1 1 2 sin V TO
Where: SGS1 = ground distance on a sloping runway
g = acceleration of gravity, 32.17 ft./sec2 VTO = airplane velocity at lift-off in ft./sec. (true) θ = angle of the slope in degrees (not percent)
+ for upslope and - for downslope
(7) Expansion of Takeoff Data for a Range of Airport Elevations.
(i) These guidelines are applicable to expanding takeoff data above the altitude at which the basic or verifying tests were obtained.
(ii) In general, takeoff data may be extrapolated above and below the altitude at which the basic test data was obtained without additional conservatism within the following constraints:
(a) When the basic takeoff tests are accomplished between sea level and approximately 3,000 feet, the maximum allowable extrapolation limits are 6,000 feet above and 3,000 feet below the test field elevation. If it is desired to extrapolate beyond these limits, one of two procedures may be employed.
(b) Extrapolation of Performance Data for a Range of Altitudes When Verifying Tests are Not Conducted. The approval of performance data for airport elevations beyond the maximum elevation permitted by basic tests may be allowed without conducting verifying tests if the calculated data include a conservative factor. This conservatism should result in an increase of the calculated takeoff distance at the desired airport elevation by an amount equal to zero percent for the highest airport elevation approved on the results of the basic tests Also, it should result in an additional cumulative two percent incremental factor for each
1,000 feet of elevation above the highest airport elevation approved for zero percent conservatism. The two percent incremental factor should have a straight line variation with altitude. When performance data are calculated for the effects of altitude under this procedure, the following provisions are applicable:
1 Previously established calculation procedures should be used, taking into account all known variables.
2 The calibrated installed engine power for the pertinent speed and altitude ranges should be used.
3 The brake kinetic energy limits established by airplane ground tests should not be exceeded.
(c) Extrapolation of Performance Data When Verifying Tests are Conducted.
1 If data approval is desired for a greater range of airport elevations, the performance may be calculated from the basic test data up to the maximum airport elevation, provided verifying tests are conducted at appropriate elevations to substantiate the validity of the calculations. The actual airplane performance data from the verifying tests should correspond closely to the calculated performance values.
2 For the verifying tests, it has been found that normally three takeoffs at maximum weights for the elevations tested will provide adequate verification.
3 If verifying tests substantiate the expanded takeoff data, the data may be further expanded up to 6,000 feet above the altitude at which the verifying tests were conducted. At altitudes higher than 6,000 feet above the verifying test altitude, the two percent per 1,000 feet cumulative factor discussed in paragraph (b) above should be applied starting at zero percent at the verifying test altitude plus 6,000 feet.
c. Jets Over 6,000 Pounds Maximum Takeoff Weight and Commuter Category Airplanes.
(1) Objective of Takeoff Requirement. Section 23.53(c) requires that performance be determined that provides accountability for the selected operating weights, altitudes, ambient temperatures, configurations, and corrected for various wind and runway gradient conditions.
(2) Takeoff Profile. Tests are required to determine the performance throughout the takeoff path as specifically defined by § 23.55 through § 23.59, and as discussed in the following sections of this AC.
5. § 23.55 Accelerate-Stop Distance.
a. Explanation. This section describes test demonstrations necessary to determine accelerate-stop distances for airplane performance required to be published in the Performance section of the AFM.
b. Procedures.
(1) Accelerate-stop tests. Accelerate-stop tests should be determined in accordance with the provisions of this paragraph.
(i) Number of Test Runs. A sufficient number of test runs should be conducted for each airplane configuration desired by the applicant, in order to establish a representative distance that would be required in the event of a rejected takeoff at or below the takeoff decision speed V1.
(ii) Time Delays. The procedures outlined in paragraph 23.55b(12), apply appropriate time delays for the execution of retarding means related to the accelerate-stop operational procedures and for expansion of accelerate-stop data to be incorporated in the AFM.
(iii) Reverse Thrust. The stopping portion of the accelerate-stop test may not utilize reverse thrust unless the thrust reverser system is shown to be safe, reliable, and capable of giving repeatable results. Refer to paragraph 23.55c.
(2) Airport Elevation. Accelerate-stop runs at different airport elevations can be simulated at one airport elevation provided the braking speeds used include the entire energy range to be absorbed by the brakes. In scheduling the data for the AFM, the brake energy assumed should not exceed the maximum demonstrated in these tests.
(3) Braking Speeds. The braking speeds referred to herein are scheduled test speeds and need not correspond to the values to be scheduled in the AFM, since it is necessary to increase or decrease the braking speed to simulate the energy range and weight envelope.
(4) Number of Runs. At least two test runs are necessary for each configuration when multiple aerodynamic configurations are being shown to have the same braking coefficient of friction, unless sufficient data is available for the airplane model to account for variation of braking performance with weight, kinetic energy, lift, drag, ground speed, torque limit, and so forth. These runs should be made with the airplane weight and kinetic energy varying throughout the range for which takeoff data is scheduled. This will usually require at least six test runs. These tests are usually conducted on hard surfaced, dry runways.
(5) Alternate Approvals. For an alternate approval with antiskid inoperative, nose wheel brakes or one main wheel brake inoperative, auto braking systems, and so forth, a full set of tests, as mentioned in paragraph 23.55b(4), should normally be conducted. A lesser number
of tests may be accepted for "equal or better" demonstrations, or to establish small increments, or if adequate conservatism is used during testing.
(6) Maximum Energy Stop. A brake energy demonstration is needed to show compliance with the brake energy requirements. A maximum energy stop (or some lesser brake energy) is used to establish a distance that can be associated with the demonstrated kinetic energy. An applicant can choose any level of energy for demonstration providing that the AFM does not show performance beyond the demonstrated kinetic energy. The demonstration should be conducted at not less than maximum takeoff weight and should be preceded by a 3-mile taxi, including three full stops using normal braking and all engines operating. If installed, the propeller pitch controls should be applied in a manner that is consistent with procedures to be normally used in service. Following the stop at the maximum kinetic energy level demonstration, it is not necessary for the airplane to demonstrate its ability to taxi. The maximum kinetic airplane energy at which performance data is scheduled should not exceed the value for which a satisfactory after-stop condition exists. A satisfactory after-stop condition is defined as one in which fires are confined to tires, wheels, and brakes, and which would not result in a progressive engulfment of the remaining airplane during the time of passenger and crew evacuation. The application of fire fighting means or artificial coolants should not be required for a period of five minutes following the stop.
(7) Maximum Energy Stop from a Landing. In the event the applicant proposes to conduct the maximum energy rejected take-off (RTO) demonstration from a landing, a satisfactory accounting of the brake and tire temperatures that would have been generated during taxi and acceleration, required by paragraph 23.55b(6), should be made.
(8) Instrumentation. Either ground or airborne instrumentation should include a means to determine the horizontal distance-time history.
(9) Wind Speed. The wind speed and direction relative to the active runway should be determined. The height of the wind measurement should be noted to facilitate corrections to airplane wing level.
(10) Configurations. The accelerate-stop tests should be conducted in the following configurations:
(i) Heavy to light weight, as required.
(ii) Most critical c.g. position.
(iii) Wing flaps in the takeoff position(s).
(iv) Tire pressure. Before taxi and with cold tires, set to the highest value appropriate for the takeoff weight for which approval is being sought.
(v) Engine. Set r.p.m. at applicant's recommended upper idle power limit, or the effect of maximum idle power may be accounted for in data analyses. For propeller equipped
aircraft, the propeller condition should also be considered. Refer to information in subparagraph (11), Engine Power.
(11) Engine Power. Engine power should be appropriate to each segment of the rejected takeoff and account for thrust decay times. Refer to information in § 23.57(a)(2) in paragraph 23.55c(1). At the selected speed that corresponds to the required energy, the airplane is brought to a stop employing the acceptable braking means. For propeller equipped aircraft, the critical engine's propeller should be in the position it would normally assume when an engine fails and the power lever is closed. For turbojet aircraft, the critical engine’s power lever should be left in the position it is in when the engine fails unless there is an automatic system that moves it.
(i) High-Drag Propeller Position (for propeller equipped aircraft). The highdrag position (not reverse) of the remaining engines' propellers may be utilized provided adequate directional control can be demonstrated on a wet runway. Simulating wet runway controllability by disconnecting the nose wheel steering may be used. The use of the higher propeller drag position, that is, ground fine, is conditional on the presence of a throttle position that incorporates tactile feel that can consistently be selected in service by a pilot with average skill. It should be determined whether the throttle motions from takeoff power to this ground fine position are one or two distinctive motions. If it is deemed to be two separate motions, then accelerate-stop time delays should be determined accordingly and applied to expansion of data.
(ii) Reverse Thrust. Refer to paragraph 23.55c for other guidance on when reverse thrust may be used for propeller driven airplanes. Demonstration of full single engine reverse controllability on a wet runway and in a 10-knot adverse crosswind will be required. Control down to zero speed is not essential, but a cancellation speed based on controllability can be declared and credit given for use of reverse thrust above that speed. The use of reverse thrust on one engine on a wet runway requires that the reverse thrust component be equally matched by a braking component and rudder use on the other side. Experience has shown that using reverse thrust with one engine inoperative requires brakes to be modulated differently between left and right while applying only partial reverse thrust, even on dry pavement. Disconnecting nose wheel steering will not adequately simulate a wet runway for a full reverse condition.
The use of a reverse thrust propeller position is conditional on the presence of a throttle position, which incorporates tactile feel, that can consistently be selected in service by a pilot with average skill. Selection of reverse thrust from takeoff power typically requires the power lever to be retarded to idle, a gate or latching mechanism to be overcome, and the power lever to be further retarded into the ground/reverse range. This is interpreted as three "distinctive motions," with each regarded as activation of a separate deceleration device. Accelerate-stop time delays should be determined accordingly and applied to expansion of data. Experience has shown that single engine thrust reverse, due to rudder blanking, may not be as critical as two-engine reverse, for controllability. If brake modulation is required and allowed for steering, then the reduced braking must be accounted for in the stopping performance.
~ ~ I::::. , ~
(12) Accelerate-Stop Time Delays. Figure 5 is an illustration of the accelerate-stop time delays considered acceptable for compliance with § 23.45:
Figure 5 - Accelerate-Stop Time Delays
VEF V1
ENGINE FAILURE
ACTIVATION OF FIRST DECEL DEVICE
ENGINE FAILURE RECOGNITION
trec
ACTIVATION OF SECOND DECEL DEVICE
t rec
ta1
t a1 + t
ACTIVATION OF THIRD DECEL DEVICE
ta2
t a2 + t
DEMONSTRATION TIME DELAYS
FLIGHT MANUAL EXPANSION TIME DELAYS
(i) trec = engine failure recognition time. The demonstrated time from engine failure to pilot action indicating recognition of the engine failure. For AFM data expansion purposes, it has been found practical to use the demonstrated time or one second, whichever is greater, in order to allow a time that can be executed consistently in service.
(ii) ta1 = the demonstrated time interval between activation of the first and second deceleration devices.
(iii) ta2 = the demonstrated time interval between activation of the second and third deceleration devices.
(iv) t = a one-second reaction time delay to account for in-service variations. For AFM calculations, airplane deceleration is not allowed during the reaction time delays. If a command is required for another crewmember to actuate a deceleration device, a two-second delay, in lieu of the one-second delay, should be applied for each action. For automatic deceleration devices that are approved for performance credit for AFM data expansion, established times determined during certification testing may be used without the application of additional time delays required by this paragraph.
(v) The sequence for activation of deceleration devices may be selected by the applicant. If, on occasion, the desired sequence is not achieved during testing, the test need not be repeated; however, the demonstrated time interval may be used.
(13) The procedures used to determine accelerate-stop distance should be described in the normal and/or the emergency procedures section of the AFM. The procedures should also be repeated in the performance information section of the AFM so pilots clearly understand how aggressively the maneuver is performed in flight test so they can meet the published distances.
c. Use of Reverse Thrust. Section 23.55(b) permits means other than wheel brakes to be used in determining the stopping distance, when the conditions specified in § 23.55(b) are met. One of the conditions is that the means be safe and reliable.
(1) Reliable. Compliance with the "reliable" provision of the rule may be accomplished by an evaluation of the pitch changing/reversing system in accordance with § 23.1309. The methods of AC 23.1309-1 should be used in the evaluation, even though type-certificated engine or propeller systems may not have been subjected to the AC 23.1309-1 analysis during certification. Additionally, Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) document ARP-926A, "Fault/Failure Analysis Procedure," will assist in conducting reliability and hazard assessments. Additionally, § 23.1309(d) requires the system to be designed to safeguard against hazards to the airplane in the event the system or any component thereof malfunctions or fails. An acceptable means for showing compliance with the requirement would be to conduct a Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) of the system. An acceptable analysis would show that the effects of any system or component malfunction or failure would not result in a hazard to the airplane and that the propeller reversing system is reliable. SAE document, ARP-926A, contains acceptable criteria for conducting such an analysis.
(2) Safe. Compliance with the "safe" provisions of §§ 23.55 (b)(2) and 23.75(f)(1) will require an evaluation of the complete system, including operational aspects, to ensure no unsafe feature exists.
(i) Safe and reliable also means that it is extremely improbable that the system can mislead the flight crew or will allow gross asymmetric power settings, for example, forward thrust on one engine versus reverse thrust on the other. In achieving this level of reliability, the system should not increase crew workload or require excessive crew attention during a very dynamic time period. Also, the approved performance data should be such that the average pilot can duplicate this performance by following the AFM procedures.
6. § 23.57 Takeoff Path.
a. Section 23.57(a).
(1) Explanation.
(i) The takeoff path requirements of § 23.57 and the reductions required by § 23.61 are established so that the AFM performance can be used in making the necessary decisions relative to takeoff weights when obstacles are present. Net takeoff flight path data should be presented in the AFM as required by § 23.1587(d)(6).
(ii) The required performance is provided in the AFM by either pictorial paths at various power-to-weight conditions with corrections for wind or by a series of charts for each segment along with a procedure for connecting these segments into a continuous path.
(2) Procedures.
(i) Section 23.57(a) requires that the takeoff path extend to the higher of where the airplane is 1500 feet above the takeoff surface or to the altitude at which the transition to en route configuration is complete and a speed is reached at which compliance with § 23.67(c)(3) is shown.
(ii) Section 23.66 requires the airplane not to be banked before reaching a height of 50 feet as shown by the net takeoff flight path data.
(iii) The AFM should contain information required to show compliance with the climb requirements of § 23.57 and § 23.67(c)(3). This should include information related to the transition from the takeoff configuration and speed to the en route configuration and speed. The effects of changes from takeoff power to maximum continuous power should also be included.
(iv) Generally, the AFM shows takeoff paths at low power to weight that include acceleration segments between 400 and 1500 feet and end at 1500 feet. At high power to weight, these takeoff paths extend considerably higher than 1500 feet above the takeoff surface. On some airplanes, either the takeoff speed schedules or the flap configuration, or both, do not require acceleration below 1500 feet, even at limiting performance gradients.
b. Section 23.57(a)(1) - Takeoff Path Power Conditions.
(1) Explanation. The takeoff path should represent the actual expected performance at all points. If the path is constructed by the segmental method, in accordance with § 23.57(d)(2) and § 23.57(d)(4), it should be conservative and should be supported by at least one demonstrated fly-out to the completed en route configuration. This is necessary to ensure all required crew actions do not adversely impact the required gradients.
(2) Procedures.
(i) To substantiate that the predicted takeoff path is representative of actual performance, the power used in its construction must comply with § 23.45. This requires, in part, that the power for any particular flight condition be that for the particular ambient atmospheric conditions that are assumed to exist along the path. The standard lapse rate for ambient temperature is specified in appendix 7 of this AC under "Standard Atmosphere" and should be used for power determination associated with each pressure altitude during the climb.
(ii) Section 23.57(c)(4) requires that the power up to 400 feet above the takeoff surface represents the power available along the path resulting from the power lever setting established during the initial ground roll in accordance with AFM procedures. This resulting power should represent the normal expected variations throughout the acceleration and climb to 400 feet and should not exceed the limits for takeoff power at any point.
(iii) A sufficient number of takeoffs, to at least the altitude above the takeoff surface scheduled for V2 climb, should be made to establish the power lapse resulting from a
fixed power lever. An analysis may be used to account for various engine bleeds, for example, ice protection, air conditioning, and so forth. In some airplanes, the power growth characteristics are such that less than full rated power is required to be used for AFM takeoff power limitations and performance.
(iv) Engine power lapse with speed and altitude during the takeoff and climb, at fixed power lever settings, may be affected by takeoff pressure altitude.
(v) Most turboprop engines are sensitive to increasing airspeed during the takeoff roll. The applicant's procedure should be evaluated and, if acceptable, the procedure should be reflected in the AFM. The AFM takeoff field length and takeoff power setting charts are based on the approved procedure. Approved procedures should be ones that can be accomplished in service by pilots of normal skill. For example, if a power adjustment is to be made after brake release, the power should be adjustable without undue attention. Only one adjustment is allowed.
(vi) A typical "non-rolling" takeoff procedure is as follows:
(a) After stopping on the runway, adjust all engines to a static takeoff power setting (selected by the applicant).
(b) Release brakes.
(c) Upon reaching 50 to 60 knots, adjust power/thrust levers to maintain torque/N1 and temperatures within limits. Only one adjustment is allowed.
(vii) A typical "rolling takeoff" procedure is as follows:
(a) Release brakes.
(b) Adjust power levers to takeoff power in a smooth motion.
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 595 passages shown