AC 150/5360-12F Airport Signing and Graphics
This AC provides guidance on airport terminal and landside wayfinding, signing, and graphics. It focuses on four areas of the airport: roadways, parking, curbside and ground transportation, and terminal. This version is a substantial rewrite and incorporates the recommendations and guidelines developed under Airport Cooperative Research Program (ACRP) Report 52, Wayfinding and Signing Guidelines for Airport Terminals and Landside, completed in 2011.
U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory
Circular
Subject: Airport Signing and Graphics
Date: 09/26/13 Initiated by: AAS-100
AC No: 150/5360-12F Change:
1. Purpose. This advisory circular (AC) provides guidance on airport terminal and landside wayfinding, signing, and graphics.
2. Cancellation. AC 150/5360-12E, Airport Signing and Graphics, dated September 18, 2008 is canceled.
3. Background. This AC incorporates the recommendations and guidelines developed under Airport Cooperative Research Program (ACRP) Report 52, Wayfinding and Signing Guidelines for Airport Terminals and Landside, completed in 2011. This report is available at http://onlinepubs.trb.org/onlinepubs/acrp/acrp_rpt_052.pdf.
4. Application. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) recommends the guidelines and specifications in this AC for implementation of airport terminal and landside wayfinding, signing, and graphics. This AC addresses systems typically installed by an airport operator and those typically installed by individual airlines. Note that signage guidelines throughout this AC which are required under other statutory and regulatory authorities are mandatory, not recommended. The legal authority for these requirements does not come from this AC, but comes from those external authorities.
5. Principal Changes. This is a substantial rewrite of this AC. Users should review the entire document. The AC focuses on four areas of the airport: roadways, parking, curbside and ground transportation, and terminal.
6. Use of Metrics. This AC includes both English and metric dimensions. The metric conversions may not be exact equivalents, and the English dimensions will govern.
7. Comments or Suggestions. Direct comments or suggestions regarding this AC to: Manager, Airport Engineering Division Federal Aviation Administration ATTN: AAS-100 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. Washington, DC 20591
ii
8. Copies of this AC. This and other ACs published by the FAA Office of Airport Safety and Standards are available on the FAA Office of Airports web page at http://www.faa.gov/airports/resources/advisory_circulars/.
Michael J. O’Donnell Director of Airport Safety and Standards
iii
Table of Contents
Chapter 1. Introduction … 1 1.1 Purpose … 1 1.2 Organization … 1 1.3 Signing and wayfinding process … 2 1.4 Analysis … 2 1.5 Systems analysis approach … 2 1.5.1 Goal of signing system … 3 1.5.2 Airport user categories … 3 1.5.3 Structuring the signing system … 3 1.5.4 Considering user limitations in sign design and location … 3 1.5.5 Evaluation methods … 5 1.5.6 Passenger circulation analysis … 5 1.5.7 Evaluation of current wayfinding system … 8 1.5.8 Asset management … 9 1.5.9 Temporary signs … 9 1.6 Developing a wayfinding strategy … 10 1.6.1 Buy-In … 10 1.6.2 Philosophy … 10 1.6.3 Logic … 13
Chapter 2. Airport Roadways … 21 2.1 Wayfinding philosophy and principles … 21 2.1.1 Considering user requirements and limitations … 22 2.1.2 Positive guidance … 24 2.2 Applicable federal standards … 24 2.2.1 Airport roadways and the MUTCD … 25 2.3 Airport roadway decision points … 25 2.3.1 Airport exit signs … 26 2.4 Static sign design elements … 27 2.4.1 Terminology … 27 2.4.2 Symbology … 29 2.4.3 Typography … 29 2.4.4 Arrows … 30 2.4.5 Color and shape … 31 2.4.6 Wayfinding sign placement, spacing and design speeds … 33 2.5 Sign structures and illumination … 35 2.5.1 Sign structures … 35 2.5.2 Safety considerations … 36 2.5.3 Illumination … 36 2.6 Changeable Message Signs (CMSs) … 36 2.6.1 Appropriate use of CMSs … 36 2.6.2 CMS technology … 37 2.6.3 Message design and layout … 38 2.6.4 CMS display elements … 39 2.6.5 Passenger advisory CMS … 40 2.7 Sign maintenance … 40
Chapter 3. Parking … 43 3.1 Considering parking users in design (human factors) … 43
iv
3.2 Signs and wayfinding … 44 3.2.1 Planning for parking signing … 44 3.2.2 Communicating parking options … 45 3.2.3 Connecting parking and terminals … 46 3.3 Sign categories … 46 3.3.1 Directional signs … 46 3.3.2 Identification signs … 47 3.3.3 Informational signs … 48 3.3.4 Regulatory signs … 50 3.3.5 Unique situations and systems … 50 3.4 Sign design elements … 51 3.4.1 Terminology … 51 3.4.2 Symbology … 52 3.4.3 Typography … 52 3.4.4 Arrows … 53 3.4.5 Color … 53 3.5 Sign locations, structures, materials and safety … 53 3.5.1 Sign locations … 53 3.5.2 Illumination options … 53 3.5.3 Sign structures … 54 3.5.4 Pedestrian safety considerations … 54 3.6 Sign maintenance … 55 3.7 Accessibility … 56 3.7.1 Audit of elements … 56
Chapter 4. Curbside and Ground Transportation … 59 4.1 Planning for curbside signing … 59 4.2 Signing areas … 60 4.2.1 Departures … 61 4.2.2 Arrivals … 62 4.2.3 Ground transportation … 62 4.2.4 Passengers arriving/departing the airport … 63 4.2.5 External versus internal rail systems … 64 4.2.6 Technology … 64 4.2.7 Accessibility … 64 4.3 Sign design elements … 65 4.3.1 Terminology … 65 4.3.2 Symbology … 65 4.3.3 Typography … 66 4.3.4 Arrows … 66 4.3.5 Color … 66 4.4 Sign locations, structures, materials and safety … 66 4.4.1 Sign locations … 66 4.4.2 Illumination options for night-time visibility … 67 4.4.3 Structures and mounting … 67 4.4.4 Safety … 68 4.5 Sign maintenance … 68 4.6 Accessibility … 69 4.6.1 Accessibility audit … 69
Chapter 5. Terminal … 71 5.1 Wayfinding philosophy and principles … 71
v
5.1.1 Wayfinding analysis and checklist … 71 5.1.2 Architectural complexity … 76 5.2 Considering terminal users in design (human factors) … 77 5.2.1 Terminal users categories … 77 5.2.2 Terminal user tasks and information requirements … 77 5.2.3 Meeting point for non-travelling visitors … 78 5.2.4 Visibility Index (VI) … 78 5.3 Signs and wayfinding … 79 5.3.1 Departures and arrivals sequence … 79 5.3.2 Transit – internal rail system versus external … 79 5.3.3 Security Screening Checkpoints (SSCP) … 80 5.4 Sign categories … 80 5.4.1 Informational … 80 5.4.2 Directional … 83 5.4.3 Identification … 83 5.4.4 Regulatory … 83 5.5 Sign design elements … 83 5.5.1 Terminology … 83 5.5.2 Symbology … 86 5.5.3 Typography … 97 5.5.4 Arrows … 101 5.5.5 Color … 106 5.6 Sign locations, databases, illumination, materials, and safety … 110 5.6.1 Sign locations … 110 5.6.2 Information databases … 114 5.6.3 Illumination … 115 5.6.4 Mounting … 116 5.6.5 Safety … 116 5.7 Sign maintenance … 116 5.8 Accessibility … 117 5.8.1 Wayfinding for the blind and visually impaired … 117 5.8.2 Analyzing pedestrian airport wayfinding … 118 5.8.3 Managing codes and code compliance … 120 5.8.4 Types of visual impairments … 120 5.8.5 Strategies for the blind … 121 5.9 Accessibility audit … 128 5.9.1 Strategy … 128
Chapter 6. Technology … 131 6.1 Overview … 131 6.1.1 Importance of sign manager knowledge of systems … 131 6.1.2 Application … 131 6.1.3 Wayfinding planning process … 132 6.1.4 Integration with entire sign system … 132 6.1.5 Integration with static signs … 132 6.2 Systems and visual displays … 133 6.2.1 Multiple User Flight Information Display System (MUFIDS) and Baggage Information Displays (BIDs) … 133 6.2.2 Concourse-specific versus airport-wide MUFIDS displays … 133 6.2.3 Key decision points … 133 6.2.4 Content and display goals … 134
vi
6.2.5 Display mounting options … 135 6.2.6 Readability of text for FIDs … 135 6.2.7 Departure versus arrivals MUFIDS information … 135 6.2.8 Visual paging … 136 6.2.9 Integration with MUFIDS … 136 6.2.10 Ticketing area displays … 136 6.2.11 Dedicated ticket counter positions … 137 6.2.12 Common-use ticket counter positions … 137 6.2.13 Common Use Self Service (CUSS) kiosks … 137 6.3 Departure area displays … 137 6.3.1 Standards for gate podium displays … 138 6.3.2 Multi-airline commuter gates … 138 6.3.3 Dedicated commuter gates … 138 6.3.4 Multi-airline domestic gates … 139 6.3.5 Dedicated domestic gates … 139 6.3.6 Multi-airline international gates … 139 6.3.7 Dedicated international gates … 139 6.3.8 Jet bridge door signage … 139 6.3.9 Baggage Information Display Systems (BIDs) … 139 6.3.10 Dynamic directories … 140 6.3.11 Interactive systems … 140 6.3.12 Flight information kiosks … 140 6.4 Design elements … 141 6.4.1 Regulatory requirements – ADA and display systems … 141 6.4.2 Sign lighting controllers (dimming, groups of signs) … 141 6.5 Open system architecture … 141 6.5.1 System testing … 141
Chapter 7. Required Regulatory and Information Signs … 143 7.1 United States Code … 143 7.2 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) … 143 7.3 Federal agencies … 143 7.3.1 Department of Homeland Security (DHS) … 143 7.3.2 Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) … 144 7.3.3 Department of Justice … 144 7.4 Signage requirements … 144 7.5 Current standards … 144 7.6 State and local requirements … 145 7.7 Other codes and standards … 145
Appendix A. Evaluation Forms … 147 Appendix B. Parking — Basic Mounting Types … 153 Appendix C. Curbside — Basic Mounting Types … 159 Appendix D. Terminals — Basic Mounting Types … 163 Appendix E. Roadway Signing — Additional Resources … 167 Appendix F. Related Federal Regulatory and Informational Signage Requirements … 169 Appendix G. Acronym List … 189 Appendix H. References … 193
vii
List of Figures
Figure 1-1. Typical circulation tree for departing passengers … 6 Figure 1-2. Circulation analysis diagram: Departures Level 2 - Terminal B at San Jose International
Figure 1-1 · page 7Picture of the page from the copy saved here
Airport (SJC) … 7 Figure 1-3. Circulation analysis diagram: Arrivals Level 2 - Terminal B at SJC … 8 Figure 1-4. An example of the connector model at John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) … 14 Figure 1-5. An example of the districts model at Atlanta where the concourses are divided into separate
zones … 15 Figure 1-6. An example of a streets model … 15 Figure 1-7. Each origination point within the airport must connect the wayfinding system … 17 Figure 1-8. Exploded axonometric flow diagram for arriving passengers … 18 Figure 2-1. Color coding example from the 2009 MUTCD1 Figure 2D-1 … 27 Figure 2-2. Typical arrow shapes from MUTCD Figure 2D-2 … 30 Figure 2-3. Stages of mental processing and reaction to road signs illustrating MUTCD Section 2A.13 .. 33 Figure 3-1. Overhead directional signs … 47 Figure 3-2. Forms of the customary “Parking” sign … 52 Figure 5-1. Typical sign grid study … 74 Figure 5-2. Examples of the same symbol used in various configurations … 89 Figure 5-3. Example grid used to establish visual consistency for placement of arrows, symbols and
Figure 1-3 · page 7Picture of the page from the copy saved here
messages … 90 Figure 5-4. Current aviation symbol standards … 92 Figure 5-5. Examples illustrating aspects required for a legible typeface … 97 Figure 5-6. Examples illustrating preferred characteristics for legible typefaces … 98 Figure 5-7. Fonts … 98 Figure 5-8. Letter spacing examples (aka kerning) … 99 Figure 5-9. Word spacing example … 99 Figure 5-10. Line spacing examples … 100 Figure 5-11. Spacing example of relationship between an arrow, symbol, and message … 100 Figure 5-12. Relational spacing within a sign grid with multiple messages, symbols, and arrow … 101 Figure 5-13. The Montreal Expo arrow style … 102 Figure 5-14. Some arrow application practices for typical sign location conditions … 103 Figure 5-15. Vertical circulation arrows … 104 Figure 5-16. Potential Pitfalls with angled arrows … 105 Figure 5-17. Eliminating angled arrows … 106 Figure 5-18. The percentage of area a colored sign has to exceed a white sign to be equally conspicuous is
Figure 5-4 · page 7Picture of the page from the copy saved here
shown here … 107 Figure 5-19. Color contrast … 108 Figure 5-20. Best color combinations used in lettering of outdoor advertising displays ranked in order of
legibility of letters from a distance … 109 Figure 5-21. Minimum sign height … 111 Figure 5-22. Typical example of the X axis wayfinding information zone … 112 Figure 5-23. Mounting heights … 113 Figure 5-24. Mounting heights for people in wheelchairs … 113 Figure 5-25. Approved fonts for the ADA … 122 Figure 5-26. Sign height diagram … 122 Figure 5-27. Sign location diagram … 123 Figure 5-28. Accessibility symbols … 125 Figure 5-29. Symbol sign … 126 Figure 5-30. A sample of required documentations for accessible tactile signs … 130
viii
List of Tables
Figure 5-19 · page 7Picture of the page from the copy saved here
Table 2-1. Example of trip purpose and travel path analysis … 26 Table 2-2. MUTCD’s Table 2A-4 “Use of Sign Shapes” … 33 Table 3-1. Sample parking signage checklist … 44 Table 3-2. Why airport parking terminology can be confusing … 52 Table 3-3. Possible treatments to enhance pedestrian safety … 55 Table 4-1. Curbside signage checklist sample … 59 Table 4-2. Curbside users and associated vehicle types … 60 Table 4-3. Possible treatments to enhance pedestrian safety … 68 Table 5-1. Wayfinding experience to the gate … 118 Table 5-2. Wayfinding experience from the gate … 120 Table 5-3. Americans with Disabilities Act Accessibility Standards (ADAAS) legibility chart … 124
Chapter 1. Introduction › 1.2 Organization
Chapter 1. Introduction
Wayfinding is the act of finding your way to an intended destination. This advisory circular (AC) provides airport operators with the tools necessary to help passengers find their way in and around the airport. ACRP Report 52, Wayfinding and Signing Guidelines for Airport Terminals and Landside provides the content for this AC.
Often travelers transit through intermediate airports in addition to their origin and destination airports. Many travelers may be unfamiliar with the terminal layout or the location of gates and other facilities. It is helpful to passengers, as well as meeters and greeters, if airports have uniform wayfinding and signing systems. By adopting the recommendations in this AC, an airport’s customer, the travelling public, benefits from a transparent system of wayfinding and signs as they use the airport terminals and landsides.
1.1 Purpose
The guidance in this AC facilitates the safe and efficient movement of passengers within each airport, and from one airport to another, through the uniform application of wayfinding best practices and common design criteria. This AC addresses the following areas:
On-airport roadways/off-airport access roads Parking Curbside/ground transportation Terminal, including concourses/gates, ticketing/check-in, security checkpoints, federal inspection services, baggage claim
This guidance also includes a systematic process for evaluating an airport ultimately yielding improvements in the passenger wayfinding experience by helping airport planners discover and understand the factor of ‘why’ passengers get lost. By understanding the ‘why,’ an airport is able to develop their own wayfinding strategy to meet their specific needs.
1.2 Organization
The AC focuses on the four primary areas of the airport – Roadway, Parking, Curbside/Ground Transportation, and Terminal. This organization allows an airport to isolate chapters of the document (e.g., Terminal) and find the recommendations for the area without searching the entire document.
Chapter 1 is the introduction and overview of the signing and wayfinding process beginning with wayfinding analysis and followed by how to develop a wayfinding strategy. Chapter 2, Chapter 3, Chapter 4, and Chapter 5 contain signing and wayfinding guidelines and recommendations specific to roadway, parking, curbside/ground transportation, and the terminal. Each of these chapters shares common information such as design elements and accessibility. The specific details associated with design elements and accessibility are concentrated into Chapter 5.
Chapter 6 focuses on technology and communications.
Chapter 7 lists applicable codes.
Appendix A contains sample user signage evaluations.
Chapter 1. Introduction › 1.5 Systems analysis approach
Appendix B, Appendix C, and Appendix D offer basic mounting information for parking, curbside, and terminal areas, respectively. Appendix E lists additional resources for roadway signs.
Appendix F details federal signage requirements.
Appendix G defines acronyms used in this AC.
Appendix H contains additional reference material.
1.3 Signing and wayfinding process
The signing and wayfinding process helps airport operators understand the need for and the benefits of a sound wayfinding system. This AC provides the tools for the airport operator to use to understand the signing and wayfinding process and to develop a wayfinding strategy meeting their specific need(s).
The airport operator also has to recognize the difference between a change and a complaint and understand how to deal with each. When requiring a “change” to the wayfinding system, there is a tendency to focus only on the extent of the changes without understanding the true impact zone of the change(s). Customer complaints pose another challenge for the airport operator because the temptation is to fix the problem area(s) without understanding how the fix fits into the overall wayfinding system. Two key principles covered in this chapter, continuity and connectivity help the airport operator solve wayfinding problems without sacrificing the integrity of the airports wayfinding system.
1.4 Analysis
To help airport users comfortably and successfully navigate from the roads to the airport gates, airports must design roadways, buildings, and signs with the user’s needs in mind.
Effective signing begins with airport layout. Simple and logical airport and building layouts require less and simpler signing than those with more complex layouts. When planners organize building layouts according to user expectations (e.g., check-in counters near the entrance) airports require less signing than those with unusual layouts.
When designing an effective signing system keep the user’s physical, perceptual and cognitive needs in mind. A systems analysis approach, described below, accommodates the majority of user needs with regard to wayfinding.
1.5 Systems analysis approach
A systems analysis approach to the signing process considers the following:
The goal of the system All user categories User tasks Information needed to carry out those tasks User characteristics and limitations (and how those affect information presentation) Potential errors made by users
1.5 Systems analysis approach › 1.5.4 Considering user limitations in sign design and location
1.5.1 Goal of signing system
The goal for an airport signing system is to provide safe, convenient and efficient access for all users to and from nearby roadways and arterials to all areas within the airport terminals and parking facilities.
1.5.2 Airport user categories
Airports must consider the many user categories at the airport. These, among others, include:
Unfamiliar passengers or drivers picking up or dropping off passengers Familiar passengers or drivers picking up or dropping off passengers Passengers with disabilities Non-traveling visitors there to greet or send off passengers Ground transportation drivers Delivery drivers Airport employees
Airports must systematically consider each user category to make sure all origin-destination signing needs are included in the planning and design of the signing system.
1.5.3 Structuring the signing system
Determine sign content by the wayfinding tasks for each category of users. First, determine the most common wayfinding chains for each airport user category. For unfamiliar passengers, the most important wayfinding chain starts with a nearby roadway or arterial, and proceeds to the desired terminal and arrivals level, and continuous to arriving at the gate. You also must determine wayfinding chains in the reverse direction (e.g., from the airport gate back to the roadway).
To avoid user information overload, you should use a hierarchy of destinations. For example, typically for arriving passengers, airports place baggage claim and ground transportation signs at the gates. Most passengers, based on experience, expect to find information about the airport exit, rental cars, taxis, limos, buses, and parking once they reach baggage claim. A simple hierarchy of signage guiding passengers from the gate to baggage claim and ground transportation simplifies the number of messages and eliminates information overload. Using such signing hierarchies greatly simplifies signing by providing information on a need-to-know basis. The wayfinding chains assist in identifying the hierarchy of destinations.
You should standardize sign systems with respect to terminology, lettering style, location, and meaning of color within any one area of the airport (e.g., roadways, parking garage, and terminal). When confronted by a complex environment, users can more easily locate sign information when it is present in a consistent format.
1.5.4 Considering user limitations in sign design and location
Airport users have visual and cognitive limitations impacting the design of signs, which you should consider these limitations to make signs effective. Human factors expertise in development and testing of signs is necessary in order to meet the following requirements for effective signs:
Conspicuous: The color and light on the signs should contrast with their background so they are easily detected from the sign’s surroundings. Place signs where users expect to find them.
1.5.4 Considering user limitations in sign design and location › 1.5.4.1 Passenger wayfinding experience
Concise: Select information presented at any one location in accordance with the destination hierarchy and provide information on a need-to-know basis. Passengers are unlikely to spend more than a few seconds trying to extract information from a sign. Comprehensible: Although the meaning of a sign may be clear to the designer, it may not be clear to airport users. To ensure users comprehend symbol signs and many text signs, evaluate signs with representative users. (Note: members not of the design team or anyone familiar with the sign design project are not “representative users”). Symbols may be in wide use, yet poorly understood. For example, various arrow shapes and directions “straight ahead” versus “go up one level” may be confusing. People comprehend signs better when planners orient signs so people can read them from the same perspective as the viewer. Legible: Design signs to be comfortably legible at the distance at which the user is first likely to look for them.
A user with 20/20 vision can barely resolve sign information at 58 feet away for each inch of letter height. A more reasonable expectation, given a range of visual capabilities and non-optimal contrasts or lighting, is 40 feet for each inch of letter height. The Federal Highway Administration’s (FHWA) Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD)1 recommends using 30 feet of legibility distance for each inch of letter height as a design goal. To be comfortably legible, text needs to be much larger than this. For complex displays (e.g., terminal maps), take into consideration signs being used by several users at once. Make sure the text is comfortably legible from the distance each reader is likely to stand. Location: Consider the various pathways to reach an area. There can be a number of entrance doors to a terminal and check-in counter. Information should be visible from each, requiring a minimum amount of walking and searching. Mount signs at decision points where the user has the option of taking different paths.
Signing on roadways is more challenging because of the speed at which the user is moving. The same requirements discussed above apply, but information load and location of signs is more critical. For more details about user requirements for signs intended for drivers, refer to Chapter 3.
1.5.4.1 Passenger wayfinding experience
The customer, in this case a passenger, expects to find their way through the airport, so each passenger looks for the information guiding him to the correct terminal, parking lot, etc. Information overload is too much information on one sign and or too many signs in a given area. The violation of customer expectancies and information overload can have serious consequences such as:
Motorists weaving across lanes on a roadway to avoid missing turns or disoriented drivers make other unsafe movements in traffic because they are unsure where to go. Where pedestrians often share the same space with motorists. Auto-related fatalities are a major concern in parking and curbside areas. Lost and confused passengers inside the terminal risk missing a flight.
Several ways to avoid these consequences are:
To present the wayfinding information in a uniform and standardized manner and place signs consistently. Violating user expectations results in lost passenger confidence in the airport’s wayfinding system, which in turn creates a negative perception of the airport. To establish a clear and concise messaging hierarchy and apply the hierarchy consistently throughout the wayfinding experience from roadway to gate.
1.5.6 Passenger circulation analysis › 1.5.6.1 Information trees
1.5.5 Evaluation methods
To increase the level of service (LOS) they provide to passengers, airports must align airport operations with the expectations of users. Airport operators and planners can use a number of methods to evaluate a wayfinding system. Among the many methods to consider, four methods are:
Ergonomic sign assessment. Evaluate signs representative of the entire signing system with respect to conspicuousness, legibility, information load, comprehension, and placement. The ergonomic assessment establishes the major wayfinding chains and then evaluates signs along the route with respect to the qualities noted. See the wayfinding chain concept in Section 1.6.3.2. Frequently asked questions (FAQ) survey. Both airlines and concessionaires benefit from good signing. When passengers experience wayfinding, difficulties they are likely to ask airport or concession staff for help possibly impacting their other duties. Interview staff to identify the most common wayfinding questions in each area of the airport. Give key staff (e.g., official airport volunteers) a list with the most common questions (this reduces workload for staff assisting in the survey), and tabulate the number of times these questions are asked over a defined period. Any FAQ survey must record time of day and date since type of questions may be dependent on both. Task analysis.
Establish major wayfinding chains. Recruit potential passengers who are unfamiliar with the airport. Ask these passengers to travel to various destinations within the airport accompanied by a researcher. Use a verbal protocol and ask each participant to voice their thoughts as they carry out the wayfinding tasks, giving the researcher insight into where and why wayfinding problems occur. Survey of unfamiliar passengers. In the parking garage, or other external passage, recruit passengers unfamiliar with the airport, before they enter the terminal, and ask them to complete a survey they will turn in at the gate. Focus the questions on where along the journey the participant was not confident about their path or where they got lost, where they looked for and could not find specific signs and where they had to ask someone for directions. See Appendix A for an example survey.
Regardless of the method used, determine the survey objective using a sound system for developing and evaluating questionnaires assessing the wayfinding system.
These wayfinding evaluations determine what corrective action(s), if any, may be necessary. The list of corrective actions can be prioritized in one of several ways:
Cost. Least expensive to most expensive. Time. Short-term solutions versus long-term solutions. Benefit. Which change offers the most improvement?
Resources are finite and by using the above criteria, an airport is able to develop an action plan providing the best wayfinding value for the capital dollar.
1.5.6 Passenger circulation analysis
1.5.6.1 Information trees
Passengers should be able to access wayfinding information easily and accurately, so it is important to plan a consistent sign system for each route from roadway to gate and vice versa. To help plan for the various wayfinding scenarios, create a circulation tree for departing, arriving, and connecting passengers specific to your airport (See Figure 1-1). Account for the different types of passengers on each circulation tree. For instance, on the departure circulation tree passengers will be arriving by car, rental car, taxi,
1.5.6 Passenger circulation analysis › 1.5.6.2 Circulation analysis
limo, shuttle, or mass transit; some will be dropped off and others will self-park. Initially each of these passenger types will be searching for different information, but ultimately will be searching for the same destination - the terminal - from different parts of the airport.
Figure 1-1. Typical circulation tree for departing passengers
1.5.6.2 Circulation analysis
A circulation analysis uses a site plan or floor plan to plot the wayfinding routes according to the circulation tree exercise (Figure 1-2 and Figure 1-3). The following steps outline this process as it relates to an airport terminal:
Figure 1-2 · page 15Picture of the page from the copy saved here
Once each circulation tree is complete, start laying out the arrival route (use green lines), and the departing route (use red lines), and other key destinations (to baggage claim, etc.). Circle the decision points - a big circle for primary decision points, small circle for secondary decision points. Determine how the vertical wayfinding will transfer between levels. For example, is the elevator within site of the escalator, without a series of directional signs to the elevator? Depending on the complexity of the terminal architecture and the wayfinding route, it may be difficult to follow on a simple floor plan. While it requires additional effort to prepare a series of floor plans, an axonometric view provides a complete overview of the terminal and is a valuable wayfinding planning tool.
ECONOMY
PARKING
DAILY HOURLY
AIRPORT ENTRY
GATE
SHUTTLE TO TERMINAL
SECURITY
FLIGHT INFORMATION
TICKETING/CHECK-IN
FLIGHT INFORMATION CONCESSIONS
FLIGHT INFORMATION DIRECTORY
WELCOME ! RENTAL CAR
TERMINAL T SHUTTLE TO TERMINAL
Before placing any sign locations, consider the use of architecture to facilitate the wayfinding. For example, architectural treatments can identify a decision point and reinforce the wayfinding. Place each directional sign according to the decision points (circles on the plan). Review the architecture context including understanding ceiling heights and conditions. Look for any particularly troubling wayfinding decision points. You may need to establish a clear zone around the sign at these decision points prohibiting other visual graphic elements, including advertisements and art. Review the viewing distances between decision points and determine if any additional signs are required. Regular spacing reinforces consistency and builds on passenger confidence and expectancy. Check visibility:
o Will it be easy to see the sign from afar? o Do other elements impact the visibility of the sign? o Can you change the placement of other signs to avoid creating visual clutter? Calculate the necessary letter height for minimum legibility requirements and then determine the sign panel sizes. Review lighting requirements. If the sign system is not illuminated, understand the ambient lighting levels, both day and night, where signs are needed. Identify locations of directory maps or flight information displays (FIDs). Review Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) requirements and needs of people with disabilities. Review regulatory and information sign requirements.
You can apply these steps to a new sign system or in an existing sign system within a terminal or new construction.
Source: Mineta San Jose International Airport2
Figure 1-2. Circulation analysis diagram: Departures Level 2 - Terminal B at San Jose
International Airport (SJC)
B9 B10 B8 B7 B6 B5 B4 B3 B2 B12 A1 B11 B12
Security Checkpoint
To Terminal A
1.5 Systems analysis approach › 1.5.7 Evaluation of current wayfinding system
Source: Mineta San Jose International Airport
Figure 1-3. Circulation analysis diagram: Arrivals Level 2 - Terminal B at SJC
1.5.7 Evaluation of current wayfinding system
Solving a complex wayfinding problem is not an easy task. If passengers are constantly lost or confused it is easy to think the existing wayfinding system is broken and should be replaced. A total sign replacement requires substantial time, effort, and resources. Of these three factors, cost typically has the biggest impact and not every airport has the necessary capital funds to make global changes to their wayfinding system.
A better approach is to evaluate the existing sign system to separate perception from reality. For wayfinding inside terminal areas, use the sample checklist in Section 5.1.1 to evaluate the key elements in the current sign system step by step. You can also develop similar checklists to analyze other airport areas such as the roadway, parking, and curbside.
The concept behind the value approach is to build on what works and fix what does not. Conducting a wayfinding analysis helps evaluate how extensive the wayfinding problems really are and evaluate the level of effort required to correct them. Evaluate the corrections from a cost perspective. Location is the number one factor. If the majority of signs are in the right place and in good condition, then it is worth considering a value approach taking advantage of the existing sign infrastructure to save both time and money.
After inventorying all of the signs, determine how many:
Are in the correct location? Need to be relocated? Need removal? Are missing and need a new sign added? Need to be revised?
Assign a dollar value to each of these above conditions and then compare this cost with a comprehensive sign replacement.
Factor in plans for airport growth and expansion before deciding to either replace the signs in the existing areas or perpetuate the existing sign system standards into the new areas of expansion. Strive for consistent application of the sign standards airport-wide.
B9 B10 B8 B7 B6 B5 B4 B3 B2 B1 A1 B11 B12
Security Checkpoint
To Terminal A
1.5 Systems analysis approach › 1.5.9 Temporary signs
1.5.8 Asset management
Airport operators often view their wayfinding system as consisting only of signs which once installed can be forgotten. In reality, an airport rarely operates in a static mode and, subsequently, a frequently overlooked aspect of information systems is asset management. Implementing a comprehensive wayfinding program is a substantial investment so an airport needs a strategy to protect their investment because new services and tenants are always coming and going.
The goal of an asset management plan is to perpetuate the integrity of the wayfinding system. If airports do not update the wayfinding system, it becomes an obstruction to passengers trying to find their way because for passengers, any inconsistencies make all information elements suspect. More often than not, a comprehensive wayfinding overhaul is the result of years of neglect.
Along the same lines, make sure changes conform to the design standards set forth in the existing system. If you replace the existing system, remove it entirely. Different types of signs confuse users who are unsure of why there are two systems, whether each style has a specific purpose, or whether one type of sign is wrong.
The number of signs at a medium-sized airport can easily reach into the thousands. To keep up with this amount of information, store it in an organized and logical database. Some airports maintain and service their sign needs in-house. Other airports contract out-of-house. At large airports it can even be a combination of both. Regardless of the approach, the airport must assign ownership of maintaining an accurate database. This is the key to successfully perpetuating the integrity of the wayfinding system.
Part of maintaining the integrity of the wayfinding system also requires ongoing supervision and monitoring. Use periodic surveys to analyze the airport’s strengths and weakness. Periodic surveys look at the following:
Segments involving passenger experience (e.g., roadway, parking, curbside, or terminal) Segments involving demographics (e.g., age or gender) Specific surveys about problem locations Employee observations and feedback from volunteers Feedback from business partners.
The physical component of a wayfinding system has a lifespan. Exterior applications subject to the sun and weather require more maintenance and ultimately replacement sooner than the interior wayfinding applications. Because the sign component of the wayfinding system is a capital investment, evaluate sign systems and plan budgets accordingly.
1.5.9 Temporary signs
Airports undergoing a construction project will require temporary signs at some point during the process. The primary goal for temporary signs is to maintain the credibility of the wayfinding system.
Key points to keep in mind for temporary signs in addition to the existing signs are:
Use the same design standards as the permanent signs to maintain a consistent image for the airport. Understand the temporary signs may need to be larger and more visible to compensate for the disruption.
Determine how long the temporary signs will be in service to determine what materials are required to maintain a good appearance throughout the construction period. Plan carefully to make sure the wayfinding chain is not broken during construction.
1.6 Developing a wayfinding strategy › 1.6.2 Philosophy
With respect to construction phasing and temporary signage, the same guidance applies as for permanent signs with respect to letter height, terminology, color, and content. The only difference is in the quality of the materials used to fabricate the sign. Once construction is complete, evaluate the signing to verify the new signage promotes improved wayfinding.
For temporary signs used in roadway construction areas, the MUTCD (Part 6) includes detailed typical layout drawings for road work areas. At a minimum, temporary signing should include key destinations such as terminal, parking, rental car return, and airport exit.
1.6 Developing a wayfinding strategy
Wayfinding in an airport environment can be extremely complex, so before any planning or design work begins, it is important to develop a wayfinding strategy. This strategy involves three elements: acceptance, wayfinding philosophy, and wayfinding logic.
1.6.1 Buy-In
Before a person is willing to buy something, they want to know what the value of the goods or services. It can be challenging to effectively measure the value of wayfinding in a tangible manner.
Research studies offer metrics you can use to evaluate wayfinding. You can also use tools like customer satisfaction surveys to help measure wayfinding. You can measure wayfinding in terms of revenue. No matter how you measure the value of wayfinding at an airport, good wayfinding equals improved performance.
Passenger frustration resulting from a difficult wayfinding experience creates high levels of stress. Once stress takes over, it takes time for the passenger to recover. In terms of business impact to an airport, this may mean the passenger prefers to wait at the gate and not return to the food court or retail areas, which equals lost revenue. Lost passengers also ask employees questions, which in turn impacts employee productivity.
1.6.2 Philosophy
Airports can be very complex; both operationally and architecturally. When looking for answers to complex wayfinding issues, the challenge is how to physically and visually define the problem. Whether on an airport roadway system, in a parking garage, curbside, or inside a terminal, the answer is to start globally. Using a terminal area as an example, view an airport with multiple levels, buildings, etc., in a manner tying them all together. Ideally, during preliminary building design discussions consider the wayfinding system in order to create effective, intuitive architecture requiring fewer signs and more architectural elements improving communication and circulation. Additionally and of equal importance, create specific information zones. For example, make sure wayfinding information inside the terminal takes priority over other types of visual information such as advertising and retail so this signage does not adversely affect the passenger wayfinding experience.
1.6.2 Philosophy › 1.6.2.3 Parking
1.6.2.1 Wayfinding begins with airport design
Many factors impact an airport’s wayfinding system. Understand what these factors are and how they relate.
The first goal of creating a well-designed signing and wayfinding system begins with the design of the airport itself. Design the signs and wayfinding as a direct response to the airport environment. The configuration of the roadways and parking, the relationship of the curbside areas to the terminal, and the architecture and layout of the terminal and gates all have a major impact on the passenger wayfinding experience. Integrate wayfinding at the beginning of the planning process and continue throughout.
The designers and engineers involved in the airport planning and design process must acknowledge, understand, and take into account the impact they have on an airport’s wayfinding system. This fundamental philosophy that wayfinding challenges are created by complex built environments is a recurring theme in the development of this AC.
The second goal of a wayfinding strategy is to value it. It is critical to think of your airport’s wayfinding system as a building system (e.g., the Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning (HVAC) system, etc.). All of these systems require maintenance and service in order for your airport to operate efficiently. Your wayfinding system should not be treated differently. This is an important concept to make part of every airport’s culture. In order for the airport’s wayfinding to be successful, treat it as an integral part of the airport’s building systems.
1.6.2.2 Roadway
Drivers entering an airport roadway system bring with them all of their experience and expectations about roadway design and traffic control. Drivers gain this experience by driving on conventional roads and highways. The more an airport road looks and functions like a regular road, the more it conforms to driver expectations, which leads to a safer and less frustrating driving experience.
Many airports try to unify their roadway signs to look like their terminal interior signs presenting a unified facility identity. It is important to remember roadway signs are fundamentally different than interior signs. The users of roadway signs are moving at much higher than walking speeds and their attention is primarily directed toward the safe operation of their vehicle. Drivers more easily and safely navigate when they can rely on their previous experience with roadway signs. When airport roadway signs look and feel like other roadway signs, they better serve the need of the driver.
This guidance reflects research findings and standards for general roadway signing. Since federal and state standards apply to airport roads open to public travel, consult the original source documents for the details of implementation.
1.6.2.3 Parking
All areas of signage should be an extension of a global philosophy so the wayfinding experience is consistent as a person moves from one functional area to another. People at an airport do different things in each functional area. For instance, the activities inside a parking lot will differ from activities at the terminal curbside, and still more from activities inside the terminal. Coordinate signage for and within each of these facilities, so users learn to anticipate and look for information based on reliable sign placement, messages, colors, icons, etc.
1.6.2 Philosophy › 1.6.2.5 Terminal
Parking is one of the largest sources of unencumbered revenue for an airport as well as one of its largest sources of complaints by travelers and employees. Signing as it relates to parking is now reaping the benefits of both careful planning and technology. Airports (as well as other major transportation hubs) are employing a user-perspective approach by delivering adequate information at the necessary locations in the appropriate form.
With regards to parking, signage needs to address vehicle traffic and pedestrian traffic. While a driver needs to either find a parking space or find the exit from the parking facility, pedestrians are attempting to locate themselves and determine the most direct route to the terminal or back to their vehicle. For each group place readily identifiable, succinct, and repeated signs so users receive both directions and confirmation of their travel paths. The more direct and safe the route for both drivers and pedestrians within a parking facility, the less stress and frustration users experience.
1.6.2.4 Curbside and ground transportation
The terminal curbside is often the most hectic and confusing area at an airport. Although signage cannot overcome physical limitations and geometric difficulties, a well-planned sign system at and along the terminal curbside can boost the efficiency and safety of the space. Examine regulatory and information signage as a whole and consider the philosophy that less signage may be more useful at the curbside where so much activity is already taking place. The effective management of the limited real estate at terminal curbsides becomes critical and signage may be the most important factor outside of the physical layout of the area.
The following paragraphs describe signing suggestions for the curbside/ground transportation areas while maintaining an overall design cohesion across the entire airport. This guidance is for all exterior directions, identification, and informational signs for public use at the following locations:
Curbside Departures Drop-off/Check-in Arrivals Pick-up Ground Transportation Curbsides
In addition, airports are continually taking a more customer-centric approach to their signage. Airports are replacing negative signs (conveying what users are not permitted to do) with more positive signage. For example, replace “No Parking” signs with “For Security Purposes, Emergency Vehicles Only.” In order to conform to the MUTCD, use standard parking regulatory signs as the primary signs. As sign installation space permits, consider supplemental explanatory signs aimed primarily at customer service.
1.6.2.5 Terminal
There is relevant research you can apply to develop a systematic process for evaluating an airport terminal which will yield improvements in the passenger wayfinding experience by understanding why passengers get lost. When you combine this process with consistent application of the recommended guidelines for design elements (typography, symbology, arrows, legibility, etc.) the net result is continuity within an airport as well as across the aviation industry. When airports follow the new guidelines, passengers traveling from one airport to another airport find consistent and uniform information.
1.6.3 Logic › 1.6.3.1 Identify the wayfinding logic
1.6.3 Logic
Successful wayfinding logic is contingent on establishing a clear wayfinding philosophy. For example, the visual clutter and distractions from advertising and retail will undermine the benefits of applying the wayfinding logic unless airports place a priority on establishing distinct information zones.
The goal is to create a supportive space with a wide range of wayfinding tools for the user. Creating a supportive environment begins by embracing redundancy.
A dynamic choice problem involves searching for or offering information on new routes. This is the type of problem first-time traveler’s face on entering an airport terminal. There is a difference between how individuals wayfind depending on their reasons for needing to reach a destination. These reasons are recreational, resolute, and emergency wayfinding. From a passenger perception point of view, the journey is just as important as the destination.
Recreational wayfinding offers an individual the unhurried, even enjoyable and satisfactory opportunity to solve problems (where to go next, for example). An example is walking or driving for pleasure, where the traveler is not in a hurry to reach a destination and therefore the experience of wayfinding takes priority over the functional aspect of getting from point A to point B. In resolute wayfinding, the main purpose is to find one’s way in the most efficient manner. The complexity of the environment may have positive or negative aspects. Under emergency wayfinding conditions, the only important factor is reaching the destination as quickly and easily as possible. Due to pressures of time, and possible human factor elements such as stress and panic (fire evacuation of a building), wayfinding must be as simple as possible.
A typical passenger wayfinding experience inside an airport is rarely recreational, most often resolute, and on occasion when faced with the prospect of missing a flight, may be considered an emergency on the part of the passenger. Resolute wayfinding is the primary driver behind the programming and design of an airport wayfinding system.
Many studies also address wayfinding in a linear or sequential manner; for example: check-in, security, passport control, and departure gate.
Planners often neglect addressing the non-linear wayfinding scenarios a passenger may encounter. Identifying non-linear wayfinding scenarios in a multi-level, multiple-building airport requires a more investigative approach as compared to a sequential wayfinding problem.
Examples of two hypothetical non-linear wayfinding scenarios are:
A passenger parks on level four in Garage A, checks in on level two at Terminal A, departs from Concourse B, and returns on level one at Terminal E. How does he find his car? Connecting passengers facing walk-versus-ride choices to get from one terminal to another.
1.6.3.1 Identify the wayfinding logic
Each airport environment is different and successful wayfinding logic at one airport may not necessarily work at another airport. Taking time to develop the wayfinding logic behind a given airport provides the key to unlocking the “why” behind the wayfinding solutions.
Another way to think of the logic is to analyze the user circulation patterns, both vehicular and pedestrian.
The Wayfinding Handbook: Information Design for Public Places3 identifies four main types of wayfinding logic based on connectors, districts, landmarks, and streets used to help the passenger understand and navigate an airport environment.
Connector model. This wayfinding strategy follows a loop leading passengers to different destinations. The connector is a simple bold pathway connecting all the destinations. Examples include an airport roadway system connecting multiple terminal buildings or an airport Automated People Mover (APM) system connecting passengers to multiple terminals. Districts model. This wayfinding strategy applies to airports divided into separate districts with meaningful zones. It is applicable to airports with multiple terminals and/or multiple parking options. Landmarks model. This wayfinding strategy uses architectural features, artwork, etc., as landmarks to direct passengers to major destination points. Landmarks help passengers ‘feel’ the way to go because they respond to focal points. Streets model. Easily recognizable corridors or pathways illustrate the wayfinding metaphor of streets.
Figure 1-4. An example of the connector model at John F. Kennedy International Airport
(JFK)
Terminals Terminal
Terminal
Terminal
Terminal
Terminal
Terminal
Parking
Terminal
Parking
Terminal
Parking
Figure 1-4 · page 22Picture of the page from the copy saved here
Terminal
Parking
Terminal
Parking
Beach Route
Station Route
Airline Terminals Train
Terminal 8
Terminal 7
Terminal 1
Terminal 2
Terminal 3
Terminal 4
Terminal 5
Terminal 6
Closed
Figure 1-5. An example of the districts model at Atlanta where the concourses are divided
into separate zones
Figure 1-5 · page 23Picture of the page from the copy saved here
1.6.3 Logic › 1.6.3.2 Continuity
Figure 1-6. An example of a streets model
To understand how to identify the key touch points along the circulation routes as passengers transition through the different stages of airport wayfinding, roadway, parking, curbside, and terminal, identify the wayfinding logic within an airport and the mental process involved.
1.6.3.2 Continuity
Continuity is another key concept applying to virtually any airport wayfinding logic. There are two ways to apply the continuity concept. The first method applies mostly to linear wayfinding scenarios. Start by thinking of each decision point as a link in a wayfinding chain. In order for a chain to serve its purpose, each link must connect. The wayfinding chain is no different. Whether driving or walking, if a person
Gates 1 - 8 Gates 9 - 15
Gates 14 - 18
Gates 1 - 18 Gates 19 - 34
Gates 1 - 18 Gates 19 - 36
Gates 1 - 22 Gates 23 - 57
Gates 1 - 20 Gates 21 - 38
Gates 1 - 13 Gates 19 - 37
T
A
B
C
D
E
Baggage Claim Ticketing/Check-In
Baggage Claim Ticketing/Check-In
Security
Security
Security
Atrium
The
North Parking
South Parking
Figure 1-6 · page 23Picture of the page from the copy saved here
North Terminal South Terminal Transportation
Ground
Center
North
South
A5 A3
A1
A2
A4
A7 A9 A11 A15 A17 A19 A21 A23 A25 A27 A29 A31 A33 A35 A73 A43 A45 A47 A49 A51 A53 A55 A57 A59 A61 A63 A65 A67 A69 A71
A10 A12 A18 A20 A24 A28 A30 A34 A36 A38 A40 A46 A50 A54 A56 A60 A64 A66 A68 A70 A6 A8 A74 A72
A75
A77
A78
A76
Level 2
Gates
Pedestrian Bridge
To Parking & Ground Transportation
Center
Tunnel Between
Concourse A and Concourses B & C
South Station North Station Terminal Station
Express Tram Concourse A
Level 3 Level 1
Escalators Down Escalators Down
Concourse A: 1.0 mile [1.6 km]
Lower Level International Arrivals Check-in & Departures Domestic Arrivals & Luggage Claim
International Arrivals Pick-up Departures Drop-off Domestic Arrivals Pick-up
1.6.3 Logic › 1.6.3.3 Connectivity
reaches a decision point and the message he or she is following is missing, the wayfinding chain is broken and the person becomes lost. For motorists this can quickly become a safety issue. Lost or disoriented motorists begin making wrong turns or weaving across traffic lanes. One of the wayfinding evaluation methods is to test the wayfinding chain for airport destinations by physically driving and walking through the entire wayfinding journey for each destination.
The second method is related to non-linear wayfinding scenarios more analogous to a spider web, where every strand of the web connects. It is practically impossible to touch any strand in the web without the rest of the web moving. Many airports fall into the trap of making changes to one part of the web without realizing how those changes tie into the rest of the wayfinding system. This lack of understanding can result in gaps in continuity as changes are inevitably made to the airport wayfinding system. Therefore, when maintaining an airport wayfinding system it is vital to the integrity of the wayfinding to thoroughly evaluate the ripple effect of any changes to the airport’s wayfinding web in order to avoid creating any gaps.
The ripple effect can be far-reaching and can become quite challenging when applied to non-linear wayfinding scenarios. Some challenges can be simplified by matching up points of origin with destination points. In other words, start by asking where people are coming from and where are they going, which leads into connectivity.
Section 1.6.3.1 looked at factors impacting the wayfinding logic. Now it is important to look at the factors affecting planning the route. Linear wayfinding scenarios tend to focus on one route dictated by the roadway or architecture with multiple decision points along the route. Non-linear wayfinding scenarios may have several different routes to choose from.
To determine the best route, you have to evaluate each possible route against the following three factors:
Safest Route. Safety is always the top priority and there are situations where the safest route is not the best overall route. There may be other routes equally as safe but offer a simpler or shorter path without sacrificing safety. Shortest Route. The shortest distance between two points may not always be the best route when it comes to wayfinding. The shortest route may place pedestrians in conflict with vehicular traffic and therefore create a major safety hazard. For example, both pedestrians and vehicles share the same parking and curbside areas. The preferred path of travel must factor in safety. Simplest Route. It is important to keep the wayfinding as simple as possible. However, simple is not always best. For instance, if time is the most critical factor for a passenger making a connecting flight and they are faced with a choice to walk versus ride, the simplest route may not be the quickest and a passenger risks missing their flight.
You can identify the best overall route for any given airport by incorporating the above three factors as part of the process for developing the wayfinding logic.
1.6.3.3 Connectivity
The simplest way to explain connectivity is origination and destination - where people are coming from and where are they going. Different types of passengers can have different means of access to the same destination. For instance, the seemingly simple task of guiding a passenger to the airport terminal can vary greatly. Figure 1-7 helps illustrate how each of these different origination points connects the wayfinding system.
Figure 1-7. Each origination point within the airport must connect the wayfinding system
Multi-level buildings can create complex passenger movements with unique or overlapping paths. Map each path and identify decision point in a consistent and efficient manner for each type of passenger movement. Passenger types to consider include:
Departing passengers Arriving passengers – terminating Arriving passengers – connecting
Figure 1-7 · page 25Picture of the page from the copy saved here
Whether tracking linear or non-linear wayfinding routes, exploded axonometric views (Figure 1-8) help map the flow of different types of passengers.
RENTAL RC
TERMINAL T
PARKING P
PRIVATE PV
MASS MT
COMMERICIAL CV
CAR
GARAGE
VEHICLE
TRANSIT
VEHICLE
The dashed red and blue lines represent non-linear passenger circulation paths in a complex multi-level terminal.
Figure 1-8 · page 26Picture of the page from the copy saved here
1.6.3 Logic › 1.6.3.4 Follow through with consistency
Figure 1-8. Exploded axonometric flow diagram for arriving passengers
1.6.3.4 Follow through with consistency
The above wayfinding chain and spider web analogies are two ways to illustrate the continuity concept, but the underlying principle is consistency. The backbone of an airport wayfinding system is its consistency. From driving to the airport to boarding a plane, travelers need to see information in a consistent manner.
When evaluating either existing or proposed wayfinding solutions, you must first determine if it is consistent with the airport’s wayfinding strategy and consistent with proven wayfinding design principles.
For vehicular wayfinding, use consistent application of the positive guidance approach to increase the likelihood of drivers responding to situations and information quickly and correctly.
Consistency becomes visible to passengers through the following design elements:
Terminology and message hierarchy Visibility and legibility Typography and symbology Format and color
Consistent presentation of information extends to other forms of communication like maps, directories, websites, etc. Communication itself must be consistent in both verbal and written form so the public does not confuse the use of different terms for the same thing.
Consistency ties directly back to the primary objective which is to achieve uniform application of the guidelines within each airport and from one airport to another.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 2. Airport Roadways › 2.1 Wayfinding philosophy and principles
Chapter 2. Airport Roadways
2.1 Wayfinding philosophy and principles
For specialized destinations like airports, drivers must make multiple decisions in a relatively short span of time and distance. Although airport roadways may have grades, curves, and lane configurations similar to those of a highway, maximum posted speeds on airport roads are typically much lower. Simple and consistent signing throughout an airport’s roadway network is essential to good wayfinding and safe driving.
When designing airport wayfinding and signage, the designer and airports are directed to reference FHWA’s most recent MUTCD for certain engineering design guidelines. The MUTCD provides information regarding letter heights, panel sizes, vehicle speed, line-of-sight readability, highway shields and symbols. Airport roadways are included as “private roads open to public travel” and are subject to the MUTCD provisions.
The challenge for both airport management and the roadway sign design professionals is to find a common ground satisfying both viewpoints under the current MUTCD guidelines. To summarize these differing viewpoints:
Airport Management Viewpoint Regarding Roadway Signs:
Airport signs are an identity or branding of the airport (i.e., use of similar color and style of signs throughout), providing a sense of arrival and the beginning of the airport user’s experience. Airport signs should look different than freeway signs, as a means to slow down traffic and confirm entry into a different environment and essentially to say “pay attention - you have arrived at the airport.”
Roadway Sign Design Professional Viewpoint:
Airport signs should comply with all traffic signage regulations and design criteria, including the MUTCD. The more an airport road looks and functions like a regular road, the more it will conform to driver expectations which will lead to a safer and less frustrating driving experience.
The basic criteria for an effective wayfinding system includes the thorough programming of all aspects of vehicular and pedestrian traffic flow, and the appropriate delivery of all pertinent information to the traveler, visitor, or employee. This chapter identifies methods and strategies for developing a roadway wayfinding system compliant with the MUTCD. This chapter also addresses the meaning of the terms “engineering judgment” and “request for experimentation” and their relevance for airport roadway design (see Section 2.2.1).
The MUTCD contains very specific terminology and direction for its proper use. Designers who use the MUTCD must understand and apply these directions appropriately. For any reference to the MUTCD within this document, do not strictly interpret the use of various terms (i.e., standards, guidance, guidelines, options, requirements, recommendations, etc.) as they are used in the MUTCD. As stated previously, the designer should understand and apply the full meaning and intent of all specific terms of use when applying the MUTCD in the sign design process.
2.1 Wayfinding philosophy and principles › 2.1.1 Considering user requirements and limitations
2.1.1 Considering user requirements and limitations
Drivers entering an airport roadway system bring with them all of their experience and expectations about roadway design and traffic control. Drivers gain this experience by driving on conventional roads and highways. The more an airport road looks and functions like a regular road, the more it will conform to driver expectations which will lead to a safer and less frustrating driving experience.
The planning and developing of many legacy airport complexes, however, result in unusual and unorthodox roadway layout and designs when compared to typical roadway systems. Airport roadway users also generally have unique characteristics due to their unfamiliarity with the roadway system and integrated facilities, coupled with potentially high levels of driver stress caused by tight flight schedules, security warnings and other factors. Finally, because airport roadway systems transition downward in speed as they terminate in high-density parking terminal environments, this creates difficult combinations of vehicular and pedestrian signing. All of these factors require airport roadway sign designers to use all their skills to plan and design a safe and efficient guidance and information signing system for both vehicles and pedestrians.
Remember roadway signs for vehicular drivers are fundamentally different than interior signs and, to some degree, even parking facility signs. The users of roadway signs are in vehicles moving at much higher speeds and their attention is directed toward the safe operation of their vehicle, including their interaction with pedestrians, such as in terminal curbside areas. Drivers can more easily and safely navigate when they can rely on their previous experience with roadway signs. Airports serve the needs of the driver by making airport roadway signs look, feel, and operate like other roadway signs. The principle of uniformity as promoted in the MUTCD does not end at the airport property line.
The MUTCD does not have a separate chapter or section on airports. Nevertheless, the principles of the MUTCD and sound engineering judgment apply to airport roadway signing. The MUTCD lays out key principles of all traffic control devices, including signs, marking, signals, and related devices.
Effective traffic control devices meet five basic requirements:
Fulfill a need Command attention Convey a clear, simple meaning Command respect from road users Give adequate time for proper response
The MUTCD further lists five aspects engineers need to consider when ensuring a traffic control device meets these requirements:
Design Placement Operation (for signals and changeable message signs (CMSs)) Maintenance Uniformity
One of the main challenges engineers face when designing traffic control device layouts for roadways at legacy airports are how many and how close decision points are spaced combined with unusual roadway geometrics. It is important to remember traffic control devices (including signs) are not necessarily the best remedy for all traffic operations needs. Signing and pavement markings cannot correct fundamentally poor or unusual roadway, intersection and ramp design.
Good communication with drivers begins with good roadway design conforming to their expectations. Traffic engineers may need to conduct an engineering study of roadway, intersection and ramp design to discover if changes to the geometric design of the road to better conform to driver expectations offer a better solution than a traffic control device. In many legacy airport situations engineers may not be able to alter the geometric design. The MUTCD acknowledges this close connection between roadway design and traffic control devices. It states in Section 1A.09:
Early in the processes of location and design of roads and streets, engineers should coordinate such location and design with the design and placement of the traffic control devices to be used with such roads and streets.
Traffic safety engineering often refers to a design driver – a hypothetical person for whom the roadway is tailored. In order to provide a margin of safety traffic engineers assume the design driver is unfamiliar with the area and driving under less than ideal conditions - such as at night or in the rain. In an airport situation, engineers can assume this design driver is pressed for time and mentally distracted due to travel concerns and unfamiliar surroundings. All of these factors lead to designs which assume the driver needs longer than average response and reading times to process signs and roadway elements. It is often hard for designers to put themselves in the role of the unfamiliar driver, but it is essential for good signing decisions.
The MUTCD also stresses “vehicle speed must be carefully considered as an element that governs the design, operation, placement, and location of various traffic control devices.” Drivers need time to process the information present on road, building, and curbside signs. If the roadway design does not provide adequate distance, a speed reduction on the roadway is one way to provide drivers more time to process the information. Any changes to posted speed limits should accompany an adequate roadway and roadside design along with speed enforcement to accomplish the desired behavioral change.
Close placement of signs, excessive sign messaging and subsequent information overload, is a concern at airports due to the closely spaced access points to many destinations such as multiple terminals, multiple parking facilities, rental car facilities, curbside loading/unloading and various other airport services. The need to provide signs for each of these areas leads to shorter sign spacing and more sign information than is generally recommended in most roadway sign standards and guidance documents. It is important to remember people react in time but standards are written in distance. The MUTCD includes the standards for sign spacing and letter height. If designers can’t provide adequate distance between signs due to site and roadway characteristics, then they can lower roadway speeds to provide adequate time for drivers to respond or they can increase the size of letter heights, or both. Reducing driver speed, especially at the entrance to the airport where drivers may be transitioning from a typical freeway or arterial environment, requires road design changes to support the reduction request in speed. A change in the posted speed alone is typically ineffective. To achieve driver compliance, traffic engineers might have to alter roadway and roadside design, and employ speed management techniques including law enforcement of posted speeds.
Drivers’ visual and cognitive abilities vary greatly and these variations affect how easily drivers read and understand a sign. Vehicle and headlamp design also affect sign visibility, as does the curvature of the roadway and any horizontal or vertical elements within or adjacent to the roadway. The MUTCD legibility standards are the result of extensive research into all of these areas.
Design professionals and airports should always start with the MUTCD and its principles when designing and applying traffic control devices in the airport environment. Only after exhausting those principles and guidance should they consider an alternate traffic control device design or placement. The MUTCD
Chapter 2. Airport Roadways › 2.2 Applicable federal standards
should be the point from where airport sign designers begin their design, and designers should note any deviations and justify them in writing during the design process.
These guidelines are primarily based on the MUTCD and other research and standards for general roadway signing. Readers should always consult the original source documents for the details of implementation.
2.1.2 Positive guidance
In order for airport users to have a comfortable and efficient wayfinding experience through an airport roadway system, they need positive guidance. In other words, guide drivers by clearly laying out the proper path.
The central tenet of the positive guidance approach is designing according to driver limitations and expectations increases the likelihood of drivers responding to situations and information correctly and quickly. Conversely, not providing drivers with information in a timely fashion, overloading them with information, or surprising them because their expectations are violated, causes them to respond more slowly to traffic situation and make errors.
The positive guidance approach to road design emphasizes:
Expectations. Design roadway configurations, geometrics, and traffic operations in accordance with driver expectations. Make sure the design conforms to long-term expectancies (e.g., there are no traffic signals on freeways, freeway exits are on the right) as well as short-term expectancies (e.g., all curves on this road are gradual).
The positive guidance approach to traffic control devices emphasizes the following:
Primacy. Determine the placement of signs according to the importance of their information (e.g., stop signs are more important than parking payment signs, or in an airport environment, terminals are more important than cargo areas), and in such a way as to avoid presenting the driver with information when and where it is not essential. Spreading. When all the information the driver requires can’t fit on one sign or on a number of signs at one location, spread this information out along the road so drivers can see it in small, regular chunks, thereby reducing the information load on the driver. Coding. Where possible, organize pieces of information into larger units. Color and shape coding of traffic signs accomplish this by representing specific information about the message based on the color of the sign background and the shape of the sign panel (e.g., warning signs are yellow and typically diamond shaped). Repetition. Say the same thing in more than one way (e.g., shape, color). Consider offering the same information with two different devices (e.g., “no passing” indicated with a sign and pavement markings), or by two identical devices (e.g., STOP signs on both sides of a wide intersection).
2.2 Applicable federal standards
The FHWA oversees the standards and practices for traffic signs, signals, and markings, and produces the MUTCD under Title 23 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), Part 655, Subpart F. The MUTCD defines the standards used by road managers nationwide to install and maintain traffic control devices on all public streets, highways, bikeways, and private roads open to public traffic.
Chapter 2. Airport Roadways › 2.3 Airport roadway decision points
The MUTCD is the national standard for installation of all traffic control devices on any street, highway, or bicycle trail open to public travel. For the purpose of MUTCD applicability, open to public travel includes toll roads and roads within shopping centers, airports, sports arenas, and other similar business or recreation facilities privately owned but where the public travels without access restrictions (Refer to Title 23 CFR Part 655.603 Standards). Each state must adopt the Federal MUTCD or a state-specific alternative manual or supplemental material in substantial conformance to the National manual. The recommendations in this AC refer to the most recent edition of the MUTCD. However, the specific paragraphs of this AC reference the 2009 edition of the MUTCD and may change with future editions.
2.2.1 Airport roadways and the MUTCD
The MUTCD contains little guidance on how to apply MUTCD principles and standards to airport roadways as a unique category although it does specifically state airport roads open to public travel must comply with the MUTCD. This lack of detailed guidance does not, however, give airport sign designers and operators permission to avoid compliance with these roadway signing standards. Airports should retain the services of licensed professional engineers with roadway design experience including roadway signing design. These engineers should be able to exercise engineering judgment for particular site and traffic flow characteristics.
In Section 1A.09 of the MUTCD, the Manual addresses the issue of engineering judgment by stating as a Standard Statement, “This Manual describes the application of traffic control devices, but shall not be a legal requirement for their installation.” It provides further guidance stating engineers should exercise judgment when selecting and applying traffic control devices. Engineering judgment does not mean, in this context, engineers can substitute alternative devices at will. Follow the formal request for experimentation process, including the evaluation in the MUTCD.
The MUTCD does allow some flexibility in interpretation through engineering judgment and study. It is important to note, however, the manual clearly states engineering judgment cannot ignore or overrule any standard statement. Engineers can interpret only guidance and option statements through engineering judgment (see Section 1A.13, definition of a standard; also reference Official Ruling No. 1(09) – 1(I) issued October 1, 2010).
FHWA provides for agencies to request interpretations of MUTCD language for particular situations. An agency can also request experimentation with a new traffic control device or application of an existing device to a new situation. Experimentations require a formal evaluation of the device to demonstrate the new device provides an improvement over the current standard. The process for these types of requests is detailed in Section 1A.10 of the MUTCD.
2.3 Airport roadway decision points
Airport roadways present a unique challenge for motorists, especially for infrequent travelers or those making their first trip to the airport. Motorists face several decision points in close proximity to one another as they transition from adjacent freeways to the airport. These decision points may include the following:
Exit ramp from freeway Airline name/terminal listing Split between roads leading to each terminal Split between arrivals and departures Split between curbside, parking, and car rental Split between short term and long term parking
2.3 Airport roadway decision points › 2.3.1 Airport exit signs
Return to terminal or exit airport property
For a driver to navigate to the intended destination safely, make signs conspicuous, legible, brief, understandable, and locate them a sufficient distance from the decision point (and each other) to allow drivers enough time to detect, read, make a decision and make the necessary lane changes.
An airport operator should analyze the roadway system in order to identify these decision points. One way to do this is to create a matrix of likely trip purposes as shown in Table 2-1 (adapted from Identification and Evaluation of Guide Signing for Airport Roadways with Specific Application to the Dallas/Fort Worth International Airport, Hawkins, et al4). Note one roadway can serve drivers with differing trip purposes and information needs. This table is for illustrative purposes only; each airport should consider its many users and paths through its facilities.
Table 2-1. Example of trip purpose and travel path analysis
Roadway
Name
Type of
User
User Familiarity
Trip Purpose
Trip Origin
Trip Destination Information Needs
Wright Blvd.
Departing Passenger (local resident)
Familiar Park in Garage
Main Entrance
Garage Which terminal is my airline? What are the parking options? Where is the entrance to parking? Departing Passenger (nonresident)
Unfamiliar Return Rental Car
Main Entrance
Rental Area Where is rental return? Where is entrance to return? Where is my specific car agency? Taxi Familiar Pick-up Re-Entry Road
Arrivals Curbside
Detours / Incidents
Service Road
Postal patron
Familiar Drop off mail
Wright Blvd
Post Office Where is the Post Office? How do I get there? Employee Familiar Work Wright Blvd
Employee Parking
Detours / Incidents
Airfield Dr.
Truck driver
Unfamiliar Food delivery
Main Entrance
Loading Dock
Where is the delivery area? How do I get there? Are there height and weight restrictions? Personal Vehicle
Familiar Pick-up Passenger
Main Entrance
Cell Phone Waiting Area
Is there a waiting area? How do I get there?
2.3.1 Airport exit signs
Signs leading drivers out of the airport are as important as those leading drivers into the airport. As drivers exit the airport, decision points include the splits between remaining within the airport and exiting the airport from the terminal to major freeways or destinations (e.g., city downtown). Conformance to the MUTCD is important as these signs begin to prepare drivers to enter state and local roads. The use of
2.4 Static sign design elements › 2.4.1 Terminology
standard route markers and sign colors is especially important. Avoid local jargon terms for routes in favor of highway numbers appearing on roadway maps. List key destinations, such as “Downtown” or “TO <Major Highway>”, on exit signs, particularly in advance of lane splits. On a national level, make sure control destinations conform with the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) list of control cities and/or official control destinations as determined by the state DOT for the region (AASHTO Guide Signs, Part III: List of Control Cities for Use in Guide Signs on Interstate Highways)5.
2.4 Static sign design elements
2.4.1 Terminology
The terminology airports use for airport roadway signing should be straightforward. Review the roadway signing terminology as part of the overall airport passenger experience (parking, curbside, and terminal) to make sure all terminology conveys a cohesive and consistent message. A basic premise for guide sign messaging is to use as few words as possible to facilitate reader comprehension dependent on rate of travel, viewing distance, and length of message. These factors also impact driver safety. For example, a message sign reading “Departures” is shorter and more concise than “Ticketing/Check-In.”
The following key terms are recommended:
Terminal. Identifies the destination building. This sign is required if there is more than one terminal or if the one terminal has a split curbside (e.g., North/South). If there is more than one terminal the messaging will require a unique designation for each terminal. Simple designations such as 1, 2, 3 or A, B, C work best for roadway applications (See Figure 2-1.)
Figure 2-1. Color coding example from the 2009 MUTCD1 Figure 2D-1
Figure 2-1 · page 35Picture of the page from the copy saved here
Arrivals/departures. Identifies the curbside areas for passenger drop-off and passenger pick-up at the terminal.
Parking. Identifies parking at the airport. Most airports have multiple parking products including Hourly, Daily, Economy, Cell Phone Lot, and Valet parking. Use a broad, overall parking strategy to identify the specific terminology you use to differentiate the various parking products. Reference Section 3.3 for additional information associated with the signing and naming for parking.
Return to terminal and airport exit. Use these terms to direct traffic after the motorist passes the terminal and to help them decide whether they need to go back to the terminal or exit the airport.
2.4.1 Terminology › 2.4.1.1 Lines of text and message hierarchy
Airline listings. Post this information at airports with multiple terminals or a split curbside serving a single terminal. Airports with a single terminal with one common curbside don’t need to post this information.
Rental cars. Identifies rental car facilities including rental car pick-up by area residents and rental car returns, in addition to rental car use by arriving passengers. Provide separate signage for “Rental Car Return” and “Rental Car Lobby” within the facility area.
Internet addresses and phone numbers. Some airport operators may wish to place phone numbers or Internet address information on roadway signs directing drivers to call for parking or terminal information. This practice is expressly forbidden by the MUTCD because of safety concerns. It takes more mental effort for people to read and remember web addresses than for typical traffic sign words. In an option statement, MUTCD permits these materials for low speed locations “where an area is available for drivers to stop out of the traffic flow to read the message” (MUTCD Section 2A.06, paragraph 16) or for signs you design for viewing only by pedestrians or occupants of parked vehicles.
2.4.1.1 Lines of text and message hierarchy
Limit the number of lines of text on roadway signs to prevent drivers from taking their eyes off the road for too long. The MUTCD stops short of issuing a standard on the maximum number of lines of text but does offer a Guidance statement in Section 2D.07 recommending traffic designers limit signs to three lines of text.
This is a guidance statement, which is a practice MUTCD recommends and is subject to modification by engineering judgment or study. For signs listing airlines and terminal assignment, many airports list more than three airlines on a single guide sign. If you adopt this practice, it is important to:
List the airlines alphabetically and spread out the list as much as possible to avoid information overload. If necessary, use multiple signs. Provide adequate letter size for easy and quick legibility of all names listed before the vehicles pass the sign at the operating speed (assume approximately ½ to 1 second reading time per major word or name and legibility of 30 feet per inch of letter height). Provide good letter-to-background color contrast for easy reading. Provide adequate space (see Section 2.4.6 regarding spacing rules) between successive signs to provide mental processing of the information you provide. Repeat the signs to the extent possible.
Develop a uniform hierarchy of messages and information. This practice permits a consistent sign system considering location of the message on the sign (which line on the sign) and where the message resides (overhead sign or roadside sign).
Categorize messages as primary or secondary.
Primary messages include Terminal, Parking, Rental Cars, Airport Exit, Return to Terminal, and major access roads. Primary messages are typically placed on an overhead sign. Placement of primary messages take priority over secondary messages. Secondary messages include Departures, Arrivals, Terminal designations, airline names for each terminal, and specific parking destinations. Secondary messages supplement or reinforce information conveyed by the primary messages. You may also place secondary messages on the overhead sign, or consider them for placement as a roadside sign.
2.4 Static sign design elements › 2.4.3 Typography
2.4.2 Symbology
The MUTCD distinguishes between symbols and pictographs. A symbol can stand alone as substitute for text on a sign while a pictograph is an illustration supplemented by text on a sign.
According to the MUTCD a “symbol” is “the approved design of a pictorial representation of a specific traffic control message for signs, pavement markings, traffic control signals, or other traffic control devices, as shown in the MUTCD.” Unapproved designs of pictorial representations are not “symbols.” Based on surveys, the majority of airports currently use the following pictorial representations on roadway guide signs not adopted in the MUTCD:
Arrivals – plane descending Departures – plane ascending Parking – “P” Rental cars – RC symbol
Terminal identifiers, i.e., A B C or 1 2 3 serve as important symbols at airport facilities with multiple terminals and or parking products.
The MUTCD does not list symbols for Arrivals, Departures, and Rental Cars as acceptable symbols since they have not undergone testing for legibility and comprehension. Treat these designations as pictographs with accompanying explanatory text. The MUTCD recommends trailblazer signs featuring the airport symbol on major roads leading to the airport property. The MUTCD states airports can:
Provide guide signs for commercial service airports and non-carrier airports from the nearest Interstate, other freeway, or conventional highway intersection directly to the airport, normally not to exceed 15 miles. Use the Airport (I-5) symbol sign along with a supplemental plaque to indicate the specific name of the airport. Use an airport symbol sign, with or without a supplemental name plaque or the word AIRPORT, and an arrow as a trailblazer.
FHWA authorizes users to rotate the symbol so the airplane is “pointing” at the airport to provide additional cues to drivers, particularly at decision points like intersections. The rotation of the airport symbol does not replace the directional arrow sign you install below the airport symbol sign. In any orientation, the airport symbol should always accompany a standard directional arrow plaque (Interpretation Letter 2-564(I)-Orientation of Airport Symbol 6).
2.4.3 Typography
For roadway signing, use the fonts (also referred to as typefaces or lettering styles) listed in the MUTCD which are the FHWA Standard Alphabets. Clearview ™ Highway is for optional use.
FHWA Standard Alphabet lettering style most typically used for guide signs having an upper and lower case letter set is called E-modified. Series D, a related font used for guide signs on conventional roads has narrower, more condensed letterforms. The use of Clearview™ is the subject of an Interim Approval by FHWA and FHWA must approve its use.
However, typical airport roadway geometry does not necessarily afford the longer tangent distances necessary to increase nighttime legibility of the Clearview™ font on non-illuminated signs.
The MUTCD recommends using the legibility index of 30 feet of legibility for every inch of letter height for static signs (e.g., a legibility distance of 180 feet for a 6 inch letter). This recommendation is based on several research projects studying nighttime sign legibility with older drivers. In this regard, it is a conservative number for most roadway situations. Because of the complexity of the airport roadway environment, the density of information, use large letter sizes. If you use smaller letter sizes, use fewer lines of text and repeat the sign whenever possible.
2.4 Static sign design elements › 2.4.4 Arrows
The MUTCD explicitly bans any letter on guide signs smaller than 6 inches, except roads with speed limits less than 25 mph. A letter size of 6 inches applies to the upper case letter, with the corresponding lower case letter height at 4.5 inches. In general, MUTCD requires mixed case (initial letter upper case, subsequent letters lower case) over all upper case letters for destinations displayed on roadways signs. Tables 2E-1 through 2E-5 of the MUTCD contain the minimum letter and numeral sizes for roadway static signs by sign type and roadway speed. This table brings up an important point. Design signs for actual operating speeds, but realize actual operating speeds are unlikely to be the posted speed limit. The one inch per 30 foot legibility index corresponds with the 20/40 visual acuity, which is the typical licensing requirement at or below which most motor vehicle agencies do not require drivers to use corrective lenses. This index is conservative for most roadway situations. Find information about letter sizes for CMSs in Section 2.6.4.1.
Do not use typefaces on interior signing on roadway signs unless you conduct a legibility study of roadway signs and file a request for experimentation with FHWA.
2.4.4 Arrows
The MUTCD specifies directional arrow designs and the accompanying Standard Highway Signs manual specifies dimensions. See examples of MUTCD standard arrows in Figure 2-2.
Figure 2-2. Typical arrow shapes from MUTCD Figure 2D-2
Type A Type A - Extended Type B Type C Type D
Down Arrow
Directional Arrows for Use on Guide Signs
Figure 2-2 · page 38Picture of the page from the copy saved here
2.4 Static sign design elements › 2.4.5 Color and shape
The MUTCD provides guidance for the orientation of arrows on overhead signs in Section 2D. Guidance particularly pertaining to airport roadway wayfinding includes:
On overhead signs where it is desirable to indicate the lane to follow:
o The position of a down arrow is approximately over the center of the lane and points
vertically downward toward the approximate center of the lane. o The use of down arrows is only on overhead guide signs restricting the use of specific
lanes to traffic bound for the destination(s) and/or route(s) indicated by these arrows. o Down arrows are not used unless an arrow can be located over and pointed to the
approximate center of each lane used to reach the destination displayed on the sign. o If down arrows are used, having more than one down arrow pointing to the same lane on
a single overhead sign (or on multiple signs on the same overhead sign structure) are not permitted. o Where a roadway is leaving the through lanes, point a directional arrow upward at an
angle approximating the alignment of the exit roadway. The use of arrows on guide signs to indicate the directions toward designated routes or destinations should point at the appropriate angle to clearly convey the direction to be taken. At right-angle intersections, use a horizontally oriented directional arrow design.
Arrow size should be between 1.5 and 1.75 times the height of the upper-case letters of the principal legend on the sign.
There is a need for special signing for dedicated traffic lanes serving one destination or ramp exclusively, also called “lane drops.” The MUTCD allows supplementary messages such as ONLY with a down arrow all in a black-on-yellow panel, as well as EXIT ONLY, and recommends these arrows for lane drop conditions. The preferred installation for lane assignment on overhead signs is the word ONLY with a down arrow all within a black-on-yellow panel at the bottom of an overhead sign. See MUTCD Section 2E.24 for additional guidance.
Exits to the left are counter to drivers’ expectations. Specially mark left exits including parking garage entrances and other exit ramps to the left. MUTCD Section 2E.31 provides guidance on the design and placement of left exit plaques for guide signs.
2.4.5 Color and shape
The color and shape of a sign helps drivers pick it out from the visual scene. For example, if a driver is actively seeking guidance information, past experience dictates this will be found on a horizontally rectangular sign, most likely with a green or blue background. In a quick visual scan of a scene a yellow diamond-shaped sign would likely not register with the driver because he or she is consciously seeking navigational information in a guide sign format. Consistency in the color and shape of signs on all roadways is important to help drivers quickly read the sign messages. Sign borders of contrasting colors help drivers identify the shape of the sign and quickly notice a sign in a cluttered environment. The MUTCD requires the use of borders the same color as the legend on all roadway signs. Section 2A.06 contains design details for the borders.
Airports often use color coding to aid in wayfinding. Unfortunately, many color coding schemes violate standards specified in the MUTCD. There are provisions for using uniquely colored boxes within a traditional green guide sign as shown in Figure 2-1. The accompanying standard language from the MUTCD explains their use:
Support: Color coding is sometimes used to help road users distinguish between multiple potentially confusing destinations. Examples of valuable uses of color coding include guide signs for roadways approaching or inside an airport property with multiple terminals serving multiple airlines, and wayfinding signs for various traffic generator destinations within a community or area.
Standard: Don’t use different color sign backgrounds to provide color coding of destinations. Use different colored square or rectangular panels on the face of the guide signs to color code.
The 2009 MUTCD1 identifies the 11 colors in current use and the 2 colors reserved for future use.
Both airports and roadways sign design professionals should know the general meaning of the 13 colors:
Black—regulation Blue—road user services guidance, tourist information, and evacuation route Brown—recreational and cultural interest area guidance Coral—unassigned Fluorescent Pink—incident management Fluorescent Yellow-Green—pedestrian warning, bicycle warning, playground warning, school bus and school warning Green—indicated movements permitted, direction guidance Light Blue—unassigned Orange—temporary traffic control Purple—lanes restricted to use only by vehicles with registered electronic toll collection (ETC) accounts Red—stop or prohibition White—regulation Yellow—warning
The provision to use colored boxes on wayfinding signs allows for the use of the assigned colors in a wayfinding system. This means that airports can carry through terminal or parking color coding used for interior signing to roadway signing through the use of these colored panels on standard green guide signs.
As noted previously, sign background color is a major source of discrepancy. Many airports use colors other than the MUTCD accepted standard green. Based on this standard airports considering alternative background colors should conduct a legibility study and file a request for experimentation with the FHWA.
Shape provides an additional cue to motorists as to the category of sign. The MUTCD provides for the following applications of sign shapes as shown in Table 2-2.
2.4 Static sign design elements › 2.4.6 Wayfinding sign placement, spacing and design speeds
Table 2-2. MUTCD’s Table 2A-4 “Use of Sign Shapes”
Shape Signs
Octagon *Stop
Equilateral Triangle (1 point down) *Yield Circle *Highway-Rail Grade Crossing (Advance Warning) Pennant Shape/ Isosceles Triangle (longer axis horizontal)
*No Passing
Pentagon (pointed up) *School Advance Warning Sign *County Route Sign
Crossbuck (two rectangles in an “X” configuration) *Highway-Rail Grade Crossing Diamond Warning Series Rectangle (including square) Regulatory Series **Guide Series Warning Series Trapezoid Recreational and Cultural Interest Area Series National Forest Route Sign
*This sign must be exclusively the shape shown. **Guide series includes general service, specific service, tourist-oriented directional, general information, recreational and cultural interest area, and emergency management signs.
2.4.6 Wayfinding sign placement, spacing and design speeds
Motorists’ visual and cognitive abilities vary greatly and affect how easily motorists read and understand a sign. Once a driver reads a sign, he or she must have time to cognitively process the information, decide whether to maneuver, and execute the maneuver. Figure 2-3 illustrates these steps.
Figure 2-3. Stages of mental processing and reaction to road signs illustrating MUTCD
Section 2A.13
Sign
LEGIBILITY DISTANCE (30 FT/INCH LETTER HEIGHT
SIGN SIGHT DISTANCE
DISTANCE TO GORE
SIGN DETECTION
SIGN READING AND DECISION LANE CHANGE
DRIVER TASKS
ROAD LAYOUT
Figure 2-3 · page 41Picture of the page from the copy saved here
2.4.6 Wayfinding sign placement, spacing and design speeds › 2.4.6.1 Regulatory and warning signs
Section 1A.02 of the MUTCD stresses “vehicle speed must be carefully considered as an element that governs the design, operation, placement, and location of various traffic control devices.” Drivers need time to process the information present on road signs, building signs, and curbside signs. If the roadway design does not provide adequate distance, a speed reduction on the roadway is one way to provide drivers more time to process the information. Any changes to posted speed limits should accompany adequate roadway and roadside design along with speed enforcement to accomplish the desired behavioral change (reference Section 2.1.1 for additional detail).
Calculate minimum spacing of successive signs, such as terminal/airline information, by allowing separation of a minimum 3 seconds travel at the operating speed. Here is an example:
Speed = 30 mph = 44 ft/sec.
Separation = 3 seconds * 44 ft/sec = 132 ft
This is a practical rule of thumb based on several considerations:
1. A study of changeable messages signs finding the 85th percentile reading time, while driving, is 1 second per major word 2. Eye movement studies showing drivers are reluctant to look away from the roadway for more than two seconds 3. Trucks in an adjacent lane can block view of signs for several seconds
To allow for drivers to read several signs in succession, they should be spaced so as to allow time for each sign to be read, and to allow for drivers to look back at the road between signs.
Signs should be visible. Locate signs far enough in advance of decision points to allow drivers time to safely read the entire sign message, reach a decision on what to do (e.g., slow down in preparation for turning, change lanes) before reaching the turn or lane split. For more potential lane changes, locate signs further in advance of the lane changes. A single lane change requires approximately 10 seconds for gap search and recognition (followed by the physical maneuver; two lane changes require 17 seconds and 3 lane changes 24 seconds (in situ study determining lane-maneuvering distance for three- and four-lane freeways for various traffic-volume conditions7). Use the operating speed (which may be higher than the posted speed) to determine appropriate sign placement.
The MUTCD advises in Section 2A.16 that regulatory and warning signs take precedence over guidance information. This section also contains advice on how to position signs on medians for situations where the roadway curves and how to position signs relative to sidewalks.
When considering sign spacing, refer to Section 2.5 regarding sign illumination and impact on sign legibility.
2.4.6.1 Regulatory and warning signs
The MUTCD provides information related to the design, use, and placement of regulatory and warning signs. Find this information in the following chapters and sections:
Chapter 2B of the MUTCD contains provisions for regulatory signs, which are typically rectangular shaped signs, and include Stop and Yield signs. Regulatory signs, as defined by the MUTCD, give notice to road users of traffic laws or regulations.
2.5 Sign structures and illumination › 2.5.1 Sign structures
Chapter 2C contains provisions for warning signs which are typically diamond shaped. Warning signs, as defined by the MUTCD, give notice to road users of a situation that might not be readily apparent. Section 2A.16 provides guidance for sign location in terms of distance from the edge of the road and sign height.
2.5 Sign structures and illumination
2.5.1 Sign structures
Airport planners and operators can choose various sign mounting techniques. Airports can ground mount road signs or mount signs overhead on sign structures. In general, locate signs on the right side of the roadway (MUTCD Section 2A.16) so that they:
Are outside the clear zone unless placed on a breakaway support (see Section 2.5.2) Optimize nighttime visibility Minimize the effects of mud splatter and debris Do not obscure each other Do not obscure the sight distance to approaching vehicles on the major street for drivers who are stopped on minor-street approaches, and Are not hidden from view
For added emphasis, you may add supplemental signs to the left side of the roadway.
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 470 passages shown