Order 8110.9 Handbook on Vibration Substantiation and Fatigue Evaluation of Helicopter and Other
8110, 9 ORDER
- . .
' I • • • h, .... L, j J .L. •....,·
H.ANDBOOK ON Vl BrrATION SUBSTANTIATIO, AND FATIGUE EVALUATION
OF HELI CO'PTER AND OTHER POWER '!'RP...NSNISSIONS SYSTEMS
Jan uary 20, L975
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
FEDERAL AVI AT10N ADMINI ST RATION
Initiated By: AFs- 1 iiO Oistril:J u lion: ~IFS- J; RFS-4
FEDERAL AVI AT10N ADMINI ST RATION
J 1nu ry 20 1 19 75 auo, 9
FORE~ORD
cont:ai.ns iaformation on vi brat· on substantiation ion o he ic:opcer and at.her pcn1er trans ission syste
disrdbuterl o section level and hove anufac uriog .Branches in light ranch ~eve. ad above in he Ai~crafc ot1 in the • es ern Region at1d to Brz:. • .:h !eve ond hove and Manufac:tudng Oivisicn in Flight S soda d.s S rvi
•
f
Page t (1.1ncl u:
January 20 1
CHAPTER L
CHAPTER L
2. 3.
CHAPTER 2,
4. 5 . G.
8. 9.
CHAPTER 3,
LO. 11. 12.
1975
!~]11 QI fQ~1EB1£
I r!'RODUCTION
Scope General Considerations Vibration Ne.:isurement Insti·liment at:i.on
SYSTEM ANALYSIS
Genernl
Dr ive System Torsional Evnluat ioa Torsional InaLability or·ve System Bending Installed Engine Vibration Inlet/Exhaust Distortion
VI BRATION HEASUREHEN1' EVALUATION
VI BRATION HEASUREHEN1' EVALUATION
G€mn'.'al Analytical Method
Fatigue lest Method
Figu1.·~ 1 Figure II Figur e III Tab1e 1 Percent Occurrence Table II Determination of Ser vice tife
·8110,9
PAGE NUMBERS
l 1 2
3 3 4 5 5 6
9 9 11
I 12 1.3 16 18
• PB:ge iii
8110,9
Cit.\P'l'ER l - 1.:-rRODUCTION
PAGE NUMBERS
1 . SCOl1E The procetlu n,~s descd bed i n thi s hand book p ![, ,v10e information an th( vit,r.:ition ~rnbstantiation .:rnd f.::iti&t•I.' st:rl' g h (•Valu.ation of pc.,we r crnns ois:;i1-•ns .
~. GF.~tR..IJ.. CONSIDERATIONS.
a. The rower r:rans,nissicn sy:s tern bei:,.ecn the engine a:nc! the varieius other
rc,tnttng co111p1~nents o - an oircr.:1ft, (such as a helicopccr VTOL or S'l'OL) may lrnvc many modes of vibrncion , som.e o[ which may be of n h~za ~cus nntu ·e. I hc power transmission could alter the vibr~tional ch~rncter~s~1cs ~ f the bRsic engine to the extent th~r rhc vibrational d3tn d~t r':rl · neu dudnG engine cer~i hc.:::i~ion m.'.ly nc longer bP. aprilicabl e .
h. v-bration in the power transmi~sion system ~an be the -es~-t of engine
C:Ncit.1:::irm , aerodynamic: e:~cita~ion , and [nechanic.al exd tation . It can occur either du ring a teady s ta e or tt" ,1trnient orrnration . \./bun s~n~11::-engtnc inst:a 1ations arc involved variat~cns 1n both r-c-•,1cr .:md ~. ~.m. nre 1rapor tant . In multi-engine ~r IDUlti- rotor ins~allat1ons, ho~ever, not: only power ancl .L p. m. b~1c also phasing of t he engines anc!
rotors should be c.onsicle red to dete r mine whether maximum ·,d.bnition uccu rs under 1.n- pr:.'lse ~r out-of-phase 20:nb1.nations .
c . E~ch branch of tho drive sys t em should be investigated for both t Qr
sional ~nd bending type o[ vibration. In reciprocating engine ins t allations the powc:r trunsraissiCJn system vibrational spectrum !Tla)' be between O and 1 )000 cycles per second. ln t u rbine angine installa t ions the upper end of the v1bration spectrum could b~ co1~id~rably higher if the exci-ation originates in the engine . Certaia modes of ibration can be inves t igated and substant i~ t ~d by ground resting of the compla te power ransmissicn system or cum~onen ts the r eof . Othe r modes 0£ vibration, l,,lherc: t.hc excitation does not occur during gr'-lu.nd (Jp~ni tions, shou ltl bf: i m ,·es tiga i:ed f n flight untler the maneuvers that:
[ltTJ1.1c1a: the ·;i brat Lem,
d . Th~ drive system is "!;esponsi.ve to engine, mechanical. and nircr;:iit ~cr adynamfc farces p~i~a~ily bec;:iuse the various branches of tbe sy5
tem possess certain natural frequencies . R~conance may occu r in t hese branche~ when e~-.ci ta tion freq1rnndes approach or coinciclr with the n~ ura! frequ~ncy of the branch. Yhen a compla~ drive syste~ is in resananc~, Che cowpleL syst•m is involved, ~ot ust an indivtduaJ portion. Each branch ~r ~ system becom~s 1mpor ~ant whe n tnves t iga t ing the •,dhr;iti rial r,;isponse of "he s.:-st m, liowevet'. 1 sorne modes of vibr a·
t 1c,n ol .:i complex system may be raore pred'.Jminan in certain bnmchci., Iher~fore, all bnmches l)f the system should be investigated .
~. St ress nnd/cr ~mplitode m~asurements on the saoe br~nch of the system
rnny ba nacc5snr>· t ev.1luatc the vibration ch.,rncterislks of the power transmission system clurlng ~Jl n~rm~l or~~oting aonditions.
8110,9 Jam1,1ry 20, 1975
Eoch b1::mcl1 o.E the system should be invcsti~.1te.d by measurement un
less th~r rr.cans ar found m:~c.eplable. Me~rnurernent s fl.Jr c. ri tic.al sp1rnus ;.n bcrncling (whirl mod.?) made on sha[tin~ sec:~ions~ such as the
tn.il rottw 1H int~rc,,nnect£ni.; ~h~fL~ , should include dctermin~tion
1.:1£ thl· ZL'l' {r~quency co,np ,nenl~ sirtce Lhi: &l1,1It met.il does nol ex 1' ·Ti nc-c ;i revers.a o! o;i:;reia;.!'I but 111ere ly .:in ·ncrease in steady stress. foT a pe£fectly bal~nceJ drive shaft, it is possible _ go chrough th~ cricic~l ~h1rlin£ speed withnuc detectin• its location unless the shnfc is desplaced from its nnrmal undeflEcted ~0~1tion. Once .!eflected, ho~~·.t1..:r, it c.=:o. remain deilec!:~d i.-C!g8rdlcss ti± speed.
f. Vibrntions encciLLnc.er!i!tl during t:t:1lnsient ope1·ation o.E ,1 sys i:em r.'la)' bE':
m~r ~ impm:t;mt th.1n s te<idy 5 t.i te vi b?:","ltions. Even though the tre:ns ~ it=nt ru..:ir 1a!lt f.::ir only a r.1:l~ ivcl, few c.ycle:s, th~ :sr;ress~s m;iy be of such magoi ude as _c, cause fatigue da:r.,o.ge. In helicopters, such tr.1nsi cnts can occur during clutch engagein.!nt. or discngHgam-nt re covc rJ' from ;.utorotation, :st.uting of the engine, etc: . For other tlri\:e s,stems such .:is SIOL or VTO_ aircrait, transition from verti c.::;.l tci hor · .:ant.al £Ii gh L or other fl 1.ght m.ineuvers m.iy be i nvolvetl. Where multi-engine or ~ulti-driv.e sys t ems nre used, phasing of the
systems ~~y be important, with i~-phase excita~ion being gross1y di fforcnt th~n ou t - of-phase exci tt.tion. It t he design of the system cloes not control such ph..sint by locking the sys tern in a single
relationship, all pcissible ph.ising should be e:-:.:mrinet!, Where a portion of the sys tern incorporates a be It dr{ve the flexibility of the belts and belt tightness aLe important. Belt designs incorporating iater woven st.eel .Jr me t.:11 cables will have a different rigidi::y torque-
wise ~s compared to an all-rubber belc systom . Changing from one • be1 t type to :mo:the r may a 1ter the vi bration.i 1 ch:ir.ac teri s tics .
J. 1/IBRATIO:' HEASIJREH!::NT KSTrtlNEi'!ATION
~- The electrical s rain gage has become the mos US4fu1 tool or dei:erm1 nint h vibrat i ona 1 ch,::ir3c t:!ds tics of po,.;er tr.:ins,n· ssion s. strms. Signuls genora~ed by these transducers atL2chad to the part under investigation ctm be .Eed into sui tab!. sign.oJ conditioning equipment nad
hen recorded on a multi-ch~nnel device, This equ ipment can provide stress, amplitudet frequency and phase relaL1onship ot any instant of time. Tn this reg~rd, it is impottant to be a~~~e of the 1·m·tat1ons of th~ equi~mcnt and h&ir possible effect on the accu racy of men~urem<:!nt.
b. It is ,;_,,s.i.rable to loc~te the. strain gage ,'11. t:he p-oint of grc.icest
stress Co provide m~xjmum gnge rc3ponsc, hmiever, in many c~ses this is impossible: due to component geometry. It th~n bccome;s necessary lo de ermine the stress re la tion..sl1i p be twe:en lhe point where the st r:iin
g.ige is 1oc.:itecl -and the point oi max:lmurn stress. Stress ev.:ihrntion of: the part using c:on'lcntional technirjues s 1Jch a'9 st i:ess coat. photo elas tic 5 trcs s an{! ys 16. or other rne l hods <:.Jo pl;"ovidr: th is stress
ratio, Stresses measured dudng the flight ~tr:iin .·;rnrvey may then be adjusted by tba:se stress r.:iUos t:u pr0v,dc the higl,cst st r ess to which the part is exposed. Ch:ir, 1 Page 2 P:1r J
81!0. 9 January 20, 1a75
CHAl:'TER 2 - SYSTEM ANALYSIS
CHAl:'TER 2 - SYSTEM ANALYSIS
~. CENt:RAL.
,\ Jynnmic .:,nalysis can help to identify criti.:al vibration modes and es
t-im:1tc the vibrntory response under the most servere condi t ions that wl.)uld proOably occl•r. This ..:rnalysis is useful i n defining the i ns trumentaticn needed to invest1gate the power tr{lnsmission system.
5 . DRIVE S\'STrn TORSIONAL FVALUA'rlON.
a. A Pl.'W~r tt·ansmission sys tem is made up of a combin"1tic>;t of concentr~ttd masses c<'nnected .:ogether by a number of different flexible units. The r:,asses may be in the form of rotors, flywheels, gears, cooling fans, engine componen~s, clutch units, e tc.; while the flexible units arc
the sha{t components~ such as the main rotor drive shaft, tail roto r drive shaft , fan drive , interconnecting dr:i.ve shafts, etc. Any dyn~mic system has 3s many possible natural modes of vibration as it hus combinations of masses and stiffnesses. These natural modes of vibration do not result in potential problems unless the natural. fre quency of a vibt'ation a,ode coincides with an exciting for.ce frequency . Since the dy~amics of the system can react in either a torsiooJl or
bending directioc on its components , this at leas t doubles t he number of critical vibration condit ions that can result i n potent ial dyoamtc
probJ.ems in the transmission system. This is one of the reasons fc.r the need to measure both bending and torsional vibratory s tresses i n (:ach branch of the sys tern. Since thes~ natural modes of vibr atio;.1 can be excited by eit her steady stat e or t ransient operat i ng ccoditions, nn invest igation should t,e made for al 1 condit ions . The t ransients can be due co various operating conditions such as changes from one 1'rerating regime to another, power chops, ~ust :i.oaclir.g, maneuvers , etc,; whereas , the steady state operation in·,olves s tabilizied rpm,
power, er nirspe ed .
b. With these potential probl ems in mind, the evaluation should begin
with a det,riled dynamic ~naJyc:cs of tl e i,ngine/drive system/rotor systc:n combination using measur ed or calculated m.tsses ::ind' spring rates
for each elcn,ent of the system. The number of torsional raode·; to be onalyzcd would depend on the complexity of the drive system; however,
for the conventional single main rotor hail rotor helicopter , the first four modc.s rr.ay be al 1 ch..iL are of interest. More complex dt:ive. systems require considerably more analytical work which c:m best be h.1ndled by a computer which is prograt1111ed t,ith a :nathem:itical model of
the ,Jynamic system. The analysis should define the natural freciuency for each mode, th" mode shap,:, , and the relat ive torsional deflection throughout the system. A conesprmding study of the engine, :he rotors, c~uplings, universal joints, r~ns, accessory drives, gears , control devices, ate., is required to identify the vibriltion excit.:i
t.ion sout'ces ;:incl t hci-r f requencies, most of which vory direct ly with
rot.:.or or engine rotational speed . f.. cross pl ot of cxci t i ng f requenci es
Char 2
?;, C 5 Page 3
8110. 9 J~nu~ry 20, 1975
ant.I che z;-esunan c:ondi ~ions wi 11 de .Eine the cri ci cal vibra ti (In crintl i ·ons. Also tho ~nalysis will establish che nodes and anti-nodes fwhid, · n urn h lp de fine che type and sens· t:ivity of the inst ·ument::.ition to be used, ro:r example, strain gages should be placed ;1t or c: lose to nodal points where mmcim1..rm stresses occur. Tm:siographs, .:icc1.::lerome ters and velocity pickups should be placed at nnti-nodal points where rna.·imorn deflection occurs, Of equal imporLanc'i!, an analysis highli~hts he probnble significant vib at·on phenamen~ to be expec ed and provides sufficient insight i.nto the chive system res pens s ta cnab c the evaluator to quickly and accu ri:i te ly c:lassi fy the au tpu t of the inst rume nta ti on.
c. 'Ihe analysis can be exte ded to cover r:insmiss·on ge.ar teeth contact frequencies ,,,hich must be compared t.ii t-h tc rbi ne blade and disc ree onant frequency <lat a ( obt ainatl ho:n th11 engine manufacturer) • Any coincident frequencies should be avoided or substantiated.
d. Since ach engine is COl)Gidered ;:is one branch o!: the drive system, the vibrntion cnv;i :r;onmcut of its dynmr.ic cor.1pooents including accessory dri v~s, w · 11 differ from that which was subs t nntiated und~ FAR 33. This new v·bra ion environment should not. be dam3ging to ·he engine, and the eagine manufacturer should bE encouraged o _ovestignte and st.bstantiate this. An acceptable alternative would be for the airfr arne rnanufac turer ta forward his vibration investigation d;:ita to the er-.5i ne manufa.c turer. The re,1;u 1ts of the ~ngi nc. m;,mufac ture 1· 18 n!vi 12"-' cou'd either confirm the a·rworthiness er the combination or define special te.st:s to establish this objective. Advance coordin.ition hEtween the: engine manufacturer and the .airfram0 manufacturer is rec:ommeruled to maintain s om~ uniformity in the basic test par:;irne l:ers and method of me ssut"emen t ~ o assure the desire(! cr::irapati hi Ht)' of vi.b!',ati on data,
6. TORSIONAL INSTABILITY,
a. Some torsional ins tabilil::y can be expected with £N•ernor c.cntrollecl
engines. Ynis phenomena is exhici ted as a low frequency tors ·onal oscillation . It occurs when che foel control governor system h.:is a respons~ rate close to the first or second dri\e system to~sional natural frequency. In the extreme situation, this coupling of the exciting force (torque a.sci l lation.s responding di1:ecLy to the
fuel control) and the drive system r son.int requency can become di ~:r n::ont ant! dest·rut: tive, 'T'hc de::-· gncr should de c. nni n· ar ly in I h development pro~ram the probable fi~st nnd second naturnl or resonant
frc~uencies of the dynamic components 1 including tbe co pon~n s 01 the cngin~ 11rectly coupled to tha dTive system, the engine mauufacture should be able to provide data on the fuel control response rate, I~ frequency coupling is apparent, redes·gn e( orts by either or both the airframe manufacturer and the engine manufactuter arc rcquir~d to prov·de a suitable combination, he reoesign may consis of chans..as lo
chap 2
rnr 6 Pager.
J:mu:ir:,, 20, 1975 8ll O. 9
,woid frequency couplios or impro,:ement in the dempinc characteris ti.cs o f the' S"StCffi , In either case, changes L.:o ch~ fuel control are usu~lty the most prcductive.
h, The suitability of the fin ~] configur'1tion should be demonstrated by
test. 'rhc test pr ogr:im should include cyclic inputs of the collecti,1c, anti - torque, eye 1ic, and most imfdr t:mtly, Lhe fuel o r governcr control av.:1ilable to the crew. Frequency of control inp~t should be ::is close as possible to drive system reson:int frequency. \,hile the U$C of mechanical connol inputs is desirable, reasonably good • test re5ults cao t,e obtained by pilot inputs, although several attempts m"y be necessary to achieve a meaningful test. Input amplitud<'! should be a.:lequate to obtain a meaningful record .
c. Instrumentation requirements may vat"y widely with drive system com
plexity. Some typical examples arc: torsionally oriented rotor mast strain gages, engine fuel nozzle pressure, engine torque signal, gas generator tachometer, control displac :mient indicators, e·tc . All parameters should be recorded or. tape or by oscill3graph in order
l o detcrmin~ the ph~se relationships of tl1e measured porameters '3nd Lo establish that th~ oscillacory inputs from the controls damp immediately and at an acceptaule rate.
7 . DRIVE SYSTEM BENDING .
a . Shaft bending in helicopter drive systems falls into two categories,
one that is associated with whirl modes, ~hich is essentially zero
frequency, and the other that is associated wilh thrust forces at the unsupported end points of the drive system. The component of the cl'tcust load normal to the shaft produces a bendi.ng load, which for two bladed rotors, wil 1 vary, depending on whether bending is measured in- plane with the rotor or perpendicular to the rot or. Both conditions should be evaluated . Cyclic bending of shafting also occurs with the use of belt drives, certain gear arrangements, etc., which produce loads normal to the axis of the shaft.
b. Th~ critical (resonnnt) rotncional speed sh~uld be calculated for
each segment of shafting. Calculation methods should employ conservatism and should normally show large margi:1s with respect to any
rotational speed to be expected. Ovcrspeeds m~y occur during transient or speed control failures. Exceptions to this ac~cptancc criteria would be sh~fting which is designed to operate super-critically, ipc . , a~ spc~ds above the resonant f requency of the whirJ mode . Special precautions are in order in this case to insure accurate bal:mcing , relatively high shaft stiffness, reliable support bc;irir.gs
nnd shaft protection horn exte~nal forces or druMge inducing conditions >ihich will affect shaft balnnce.
Ch:ip 2
Pri r 7 Page 5
6110.9 J,nu:try 20, 1975
6. UlSTAt.LED ENGit."E VIJ!RATION.
a. Airworthiness ~bjcctivcs in this areo
installed and mounted ln such o manne't
reGuirc that the ~nsine b~ as to ins11re that external vibraLory i nputs transmitted to tho cng; ne ~:,iough mounts and other ;ittach points arc within the limits establi~hed by the engine man· ufacturcr. The combinotion of engine mounting and airfram~ vibr$· t ions inherent i n a rotory wing oircroft will produce on cnvi ronmm,t which justifies investigation and evaluat io~ .
b. The cngine manufacturer h expected to establish vibrator)• lim! rs for
;ill engine co~Fonents and to define th~ basic instrumentation to detterminc compliance with these l!~its. Usually, the limits or~ defined es an allowable combination o! frequency and a~plitude, or, "10ra simply as an allowable acceleration . The instrurnent~tlon would con· sist of various transducers 1110Unted as presc ribed by the engine 1t11n· u[aerurer to measure motion in three planes .
,
c. The test progr am should explore- the complete range of rotational
speeds of tr.e drive system, both coupled to the engine and in auto
rotation . Engine scart nnd acceler:ztion should be examined, and speed/ power s:;~eps shouid be conducted over the expected operatinfl range. I n soma instances, rocorcr~ft center of g ravity wi ll aCfect test rn·
sul ts. Multi-engine rotorcraft test programs should consider com· binations of inoperative englne(s) and unequal power from the engines.
Preliminary re>Jiew of the data shoul d be accomplisne-l 3nd any un· usual or raargiaal vibratory condition should be reexplored in rlijtell .
9. INU:T/ElCl!AllST D1STORT10S .
a. The basic pur pose of inlet distc tioo investigations is to establish
~hat tu~bine engine compressor b 1des ore not excited ac reson~nt
frequencies by circum!er~ntinl ~nriations in air inflow to the engine. Ideally, this would be est~bl1.shed by strain gag., ,:,eoscromcnts of comptessor blades during in-flight t:1aneuvers of che al.re-raft under cvatustion . 1n praccice , the cngtne manuiacLurer detemines cxp~rimcntal ly the corapressor blade response t o partia l inlet blu,,:k~gc durin& test stand r•,ns . Different tlockage patterns arc, used lo ex• cite higher orders of inflow distcirtion and frorn this basic Lnform11t ion
the engine manu facturer cnn determine Lhe tolerance a[ hid comrr~ssor lo in!low d i scurbances. Th,; nlrfranoe manufoccurnr can tlrnn moflsure inflow disturbances which c.1n be cumpared with the distortion limits established by the cngin~ m,inufnclurcr.
b. Instrumentation for tn<?asurin& the inflow disturbances should 1>rovhle data compatible with the pnreffll!ters established by th<! engino manu
facturer. These parameters usually involve differential ;iir pressure and are measured by nf.l)tiplc or"ficc pressure probes inSt3llcd directly
ln front of the engine eomprQssor. With this insrru~£ntacion lnst~llcd, the aircraft should be flown through its complete flight envclo~c.
Chop 2
P11r 9
8110 . 9
ins
ss~r is c.iscs. no
J~nu~ry 20. 1975
;me s, the engi.n , , nufacturer ir.ay sp cify a particular ut ti 1 • hich _c itl'H!l "insures th:1 ;iir!:"low tc- the corr. no scorted beyond compressor oler;:in es . In _h sc .iirfl · distortion s by the ;:iitfrnma manufa,::,tu'l:'.1.:.r ar~ r 1 1uircd.
d, EKh us t gas flew do-flections ,uuocia ed with sever~ duct section dis
c ntinuties can r su1t in c:,i:h uat sas pressur rcflectioms bnck nto the turbine s tagea. These pres u e reflee tions s be cv _unt d for po·si le turb·n blade '-'ihr.1 io , "rrie ecnginc nufacturer is he source o~ hi information and d ,1 regarding C me4Sur:c::.en , nd interpre t ation o: this cond'tion.
Ch p 2
p r l Page 7 ( nd 8)
I
J~nu~ry 20, 1975 8]10.9
CHAPTER 3 - VIBMl'ION ME.ASURE1'1ENT EVAUMTION
CHAPTER 3 - VIBMl'ION ME.ASURE1'1ENT EVAUMTION
10. CENER.t\L
Sev~rr1 ..:>f the pl:oblern.s d f.scussed in Chapters 1 ::.ncl 2 can be eval1H1l:ecl by str.'light forusJrd comp;i:-ison of measured or cnlcul.:11:etl lo.1d.s \..iith firmly est:iblished limits. Among these are torsional inst.!!bi it:y, inst;;lled engine: vibration, tnle t/exlrnus t distortion t and transmission ge.ar tooth excU:ations. Other vibratory phenomena such as drive s. stem torsion and beu'l.l i ng requite special ev;; lu ~ tion tec:hr.iques. Thes If! techniques fa 11 into two b-asic cntergories I the analytical method or filtigue test method. These m ~hods are briefly discussed below; however, use of this informa
tion obviously must be. su ~plerrnmted by iaxperiencE .1nd by guidance from t he extensive text book and handbook data .;!vai l.!!ble to vibration and
. atigue investigators,
IL !.'\J ALYTIC,.L ~IETHOD•
IL !.'\J ALYTIC,.L ~IETHOD•
.1. It is recognized th,:;it:, if olJowable s tress levels ,1re estnblished by
acceptable means, and the stresses measured during groun<l ~ml flight conditions are lower than these est~blishe.d levels, no fatigue tesc· ng of actual parls is necessary . •
~. At this point it is appropri,ate to discuss !'~t ·guic subst<1ntiation of ge~rboK components ocher Chan critiral components~ such ~s the msia roror shaftJ which should have the same degree of structurnl reliability as the main rotors. Components sucb as gears, geDrshafts, and be.a:rings do not readily lend themselves to evaluation by flight strain survey data, Fatigue margins of safety mQy be comruted for gears .and gea r sh.J"fts. Analysis of t bis type should, whe r e ,1pplic::ible. consider the simultaneous appl"cation of co bined stresses involving axial bonding, and torsion loads in conjunccion with steady state and vibratory loads. Equations used for ~1is purpose should be based on a theory of failure appropriate for the component under ct.'lnsiclerat:ion and consistent: wich good industry practice. In this regard. accept. able standards fot gear design are published by t!:Je American Ge~i: }1 anu fac turers Association (AGHA) , ?ost i ve rnargins o £ .s.i (et;• compu tccl by the_ nbove techniques intlicate infinite 1i re .for the part. and therefore, no fur t.her fa1lig1Je evnluation ~ •ould be required. Conversely, ncgtit' ve margins of ~are ty indica e a fi.ni e life which should be established by fatigue tests of actual p~rts.
Fatigue e•,ahi ati on of bearings should be based on acce pt,able indrrs try standards such as those publ "s!1ed by the Anti-Friction Be~,.ing MAnu
faeturers J..ssociat.; on (AFENA) Be.'.lrings used · n nort-r.edundant er~ t · cal applications mrry aeces :s i ate s peci.:1 l se lee: ciun c r i l-ria ,. · th
tcspecc to tolero1ncos an(f tr1rn.erf als.
Ch:tp J
p,,.ge 9 Par 11
6110.9 Jam.rnry 20t 197S
ti. For L' thcr p.:ir ts a methud, s oroewha t similar co the one d~sc ri beJ :for
gears and ge rshafts in Para. 2b, is bas don the use of the modified Goodma11 c:fiagr · m, This method is also cons iclere:d acceptable for est.ablish i ng an allowabl~ stress level as follows;
(lJ Estil:1.;:i:te the meo 2ndur.mte limii: of the part from test -results of specimens witlL simil.n: stress coru:entrations, ""he test: speci men r:n.:lter:i al should be representative of the actual part and sufficient t~st data should be available to substantiate the can endurance limit. The estimate should account £or surface conditions, fabrication methods, fretting, chafing, size and shape effects, as well as diffore~ces io stress concentrations between
the test sp 0 cimen and the actual part. Referring to figure 1, the me.:in enJurance Hroit may be represem:ed by -a scraigbt line dr awn
through the yield stre£s (point A on the hotizo tal axis) and the m,'!ximul'!l oscillatory s i:resi. ~.,hich the :.ive rage s pec.imen can with
s ta~d at a given steady s~r.ess (point B) without fRilure for
107 cycles to S X 107 eye les depending on the l'l\l3 terial. (Aluminum would require at least SX 107 cycles).
(2) A fm:: tor of saft:! c:y of 3 should then be applied to the mean endur
ance limit so that the slope of line AC would be 1/3 of line Aa
(3) If the flight strain measurements indicate ~hat all of the opera
ting stresses fall below the operating boundary line (AC), no fatigue testing is necessary. When the m.::asured stresses are above th~ oper~ting boundry line, however, fatigue testin~ of the actual pa~ts ahould be co~ducted .
(4) Limitations of ti,e nnalytical , et:r.od: Caution shoul<l be exercised in the i!pplicatiou of the method aboveJ particul3rly when the .following ·tems are involved:
(a) Large partJ ln proportion to the laboratory s pee imens .
(b) Irregularly shaped parts cont.1ia.ing numerous or superimposed
fillets, holes 1 th~cads~ or lugs,
(c) Parts of unique design for which oo past service experience
is avai ·able,
{d) Parts subject to fretting or chafing.
(e) Eoltcd or. pinned connections.
Chap 3 Page 10 Par 11
J. nuat • _o, J97S llO. 9
{MAX. 0SCI LLATORV STRESS}
{MAX. 0SCI LLATORV STRESS}
u, h'.] > cc: … 1-- J!! VI C: >- Ul
0
~
0 … ..e < -.I u a LL u 0
~
C
(YtELD
STREss,
STE ADY STPE SS
A
FIGURE I
12.
'Ih · fat!.gL.e. strength ,md rot,:n: d-ri..~ ""f5 ltl'JY b determined in appri pri C)ry tests. These t cnnclucc:ed in S1Jch a mann c prt'l.l...1cc \•alid faitigue for the componen in th• en·• cf both steady Qatl osci]JnLory lands s thl:!y are geneni ~ed hy h r r:mnponc n ts o:t the ro tllrc: raL , N ma l practice is t o obtait\ au a:! i nt: .spccimeo failures to enabl lh • t·valun or to cstabl!sh a t ti iti~ lly volid S-N carve a~ shown l11 Flgur~ II c each steady load sel•cl J .
FIGURE I
b. 'Iheo establishment o involves testing .i u icl n nl.lmh~r
r f parts at t:~e s~ s t!y tr .sn l~vel am" varyiag l !! O' d lln or: s ress. Thus. in F gur II, if a 2 ,.;: tead)T ~ tress lcv~ l A .,nd :m oscl ] la ory stress of level B. th~ part is tested u II fni ur , ilurc occur ng at i; cyc. lcs, pain on lhe S- • curve Ior !. [ld • ,, U! , Ol lev~l A is deten.ii ,ed. Adi iona oints on hes- : reprcs ntin 4 s CJdy s ress of le....c. A r.t.1)' b d cnninrd by c.hoDSing a differ•n o c.f.1l4r y
r.h p J
P,1r 12 P,1 C l]
tr •n h tl,1 ,1
110,9
art t.o fai ure. lf no fa:lure ec:c:Ut."" for
.:it t.et: 107 to 5 X 107 c.yc les, depending on • consi<lcred to ha...e irainite li fc a . that
10000
lSOOO
U1
...J Ln 16000 0:: ~
IJ'l 14000 Fotigue e~t D.:::i ta >- ti … / 0.: ... _, . I 0 12000 -- r D .... -r-- <( ___,. ---·,--o -I 10000
...J
rc-d1.1ction (as roqu;red Y -:---- … :..
I __ u V, 8000 I to a5sur ~hot fci!u re 0 1 I 6000 is. •xtr rn ly remove) I FerroLJs I Nor1-f 8 rrous [ . I materrn I rna te,1c l 4000 /
I ( (Sx l 07 ) '" 2000 I 0 N 107
NUMBE~ OF CYCLES
NUMBE~ OF CYCLES
FIGUP.E 11
.reau :; ·c Cat:i.gue testing, a arge number of <11i.r:nb e 1n establishing each S - 1 curve. H~,..oer. ford th cost and i necessary to ob a n of four tes s pecimcns: lilhic.t- wi 11 the '"ange uf osci a:.ory stress er•ic is c .sirleietl acceptabl~ in e-t~bc:urv , l,c lenst one t.:e·t specimen sb.ould !'lurvive th , r~qu red o Jcfine ~ofini e :ife. n order to cat C.[ 1sso ia ec 1..-it tat gue tes ing. t-he an •duecd b" aa .ip?top.riat:e factor. his :ict:or · • f!houltl be ba::~d on the type of materinl b t; cd 1 pnst • c v · c · v.p r l ~m: with the materi ;:il ~ and type of design. Fer crt~ic 1 c mpon nt , Yh05e fa: lure may be catas trophic, the teduct on
FIGUP.E 11
·ncco shoulti b 8 l•ct d to ssure ch~t t:be prababili y of ailutc s ex. r mcly r St icll1 methods ~re useful 1n this ,aspect of h h(I c th · res u1 ing rnduccd curve shou lei b in flu
Chap 3
Pnr 12.
--
Jsnuary 20 1975 S!l0,9
encec: by typic.Jl ptablished S-K data fo r the m.iterial, iJnd c1l1 of the
tef: t points shou =d f al 1 above t:he reduced cut:ve. This c::u rve "'10U ld then rep~csent the S-N cut"ve for use in determining the f.atigue lives.
igurc ~l repiesents this method of constructing A typical S- N curve basi?d cm te.s.!:: specimens . A se1rnr~te :>-N curve should be es 't.ablished for each cd tic a.l te:ady s tt"ess 1eve1 de l:ermined in the fli gb t strain me asur M · ment survey. lf it is desired to limit the fatigue tests, a single S-N c:urvc t-'tsed on the highes t measured steady stress :nay he usccl in the fatigue life c;ikulat.iocs. iiowever, if this approach tends l:o 1.mdu.ly limit t.hc _atigue life, ~ family of curves rnay be developed from two es ablished S- N curves b~;' means of Goodman or .similar di.a.g1;ams or !:ly
r~tionnl w£thods,
ti. '!'he r ducr::ion factor Il'.J)' also be based on s atistical .1Jnalysis of the
failure data rrojEcted to ~he number of cyclas associated with infinir::~ life .for !:lie particular material. The .shape of the curve drawn tht"ough oach data point is ob tained ~rorn experimentally der:ived constants ,ippro'.)5. rate for the material. The mean enduranc limi c is the statisti c<1l aver.c1ge of the curves projected to L07 or 5 X 107 cycl~s. The working S-N curve wotild be established at 3 standard deviations below the mean \'.a lue c?S shown in Fi.gu re I I.
(5-N Curve Typi ca I for a Ferrous Mafe:ria 1}
20000
18000
Fai lure Points I.fl 16000 V'i w Projected Dato Points a:: 14000 i V1 >- 12000 c,: 0 I- 10000 <( .,..J -I 8000 u 0 V1 6000
4000 woo
0 106 107
NUMBER OF CY CL'ES
NUMBER OF CY CL'ES
Cr!ap 3
Par 12
FIGURE UI
P.'.lge l]
S l l 0. 9 J.\1.nuary 20, 1975
c. Using the S-N <l~ta obtained above and a knowl erlge of strasses imposed
on he co::nponent by flight and gruund cand · tions, tbe fatigue life limi ::ation 1 if .i. plicable, can be est.iblisbed using one of the cumula
FIGURE UI
tive dam~·~ theoric:~ available from cunent literature cm th.is subject. An cx-1mple of this, using i' inen: 1 s theory, is shol-ln tie law. Note that flight conditions which result in tresses belo~ the endurance limit defined by the S-N curve ai:-c considered t o have na effec on the fatigue life of the componenl under ~valuation.
.. same e cakulatiun based on sd;,ita;
The Cumula ive Dam~ge Hypothesis states that every cycle of stress above a1;1 em1m;,mce limit produces darn.age prapartioaal to the ratio of cycles run at: tha stress 1:0 the fatigue lif at tha stress level. Thus 1 i£ a part is subject to random lo~ding for n1 cycles at a stress level of S1 1 nz cy1ces at S i cycles at S ·' and so on~ ,:ntd if N1 , Nz, NJ at'!.:' the n3 cor1;espcmdin,g 6.uraber of cycles !o f.ailure for each stress level then fai ure t.::i 11 occur ~-ii tithe: summation:
Using this expression, the calculatad service li fe of a part subjectEd ta
ra~dom loading c~n be derer ined if the percent of life used per hour at each dam~ging stress level is known. The percent of life used per hour at each damaging stress level, can be expressed by:
(1)
where 1 - percent of 1ifc. used per hour at the damaging stress level;
a percent of tot a operatiag time al lotted to the flight condition during which the damaging sLress : eve! ~as recorded:
N -= total number o • cycles of the da~ging stress level at t'ai h,rc;
an<l
n = number of cycles he damagi s-ress level occurs rer hour,
T1 us, the calcul~ted service lifc 1 Le of a particu lar part of component
subjec to a random number of damaging stress levels, would be:
10(1 ;'10 (2} /,.=--·---- . l1 - l1 · 11··.,.J , ::'i1
chap 3 Page 1 Par 12
J~nuary 20. 1Q75 8110, 9
A sample c~lcul11tion illu~tratins this method for determining t:he calcu
Jntcu service li Le is shown in Table II. In this cx.imple. the peak ste~dy nnd vibratory stress levels nssociatcd with each maneuver have been ns:sumed to occur for the duration of t:he mane:u·;er (columns 3 a nd 4). In ::idd ition, the eye 1es of oscillatory st: res s per hour a l!J' o has been conserv :i tive ly assumed "lt the maximum level thro1Jghout the flight spec.Lrum
(columa 5). If this procedure tends to limit the service llfe unduly. it is acceptable to use the actural n1easured strt"ss lt•vel r.!ist:ributi ons if proper .:1ccount of r,oss'ible v;iriations is pt'ovided by rcpe;ited mamwvers.
The number of cycles to failure for each damaguig stress level (coh1mn 6) was determined from Figure II. As an extimp le, consider flight condition IJ(c) of Table II. The percent of total op~rating time (a) considered
at this maneuver is 0.5 perc~nr, the damaging oscillaLory stress level
i. s l !J, 5CO p~ i, the numb~r of eye les of damaiing s Cress pc r hour (n) is 23,200, and the number: of cycles to failure (N) f.rom the S- N curve (Figure II) is 3,200,000 cycles. Then by equation (1) the percent of Jife used per hour at this damaging stress level ~ould be:
l= ~!! - 0.5 ;,. '.!;1 ,1)[1f) N_- 3,~00,UUU =o_nn:K~
The smr.Jnation of the i nJividua 1 pe rc1.mt ages; of life u.:.ed per hour for
each d.::imaging stress level is shovo1n "in column 7 of Tabk II. Therefore, b7 equation (2), the calculated ~ervice lif~ of this part would be:
100_ ~-051 hows l.= l.:1L-0,15'1S!) ~
A summary c1f the measured stress and peri::ent life used at the various
L1 ight conditions should ba aub1ci tted with the fatig1.1e r;.?v.aluation r,rngram in a form similar to Tabl e II.
Chap 3
Par 12 P.ag~ 15
8110 . 9 Jnnuory 20 , 1975
I.
II .
Ill.
lV.
Page
TAllL& 1
Percent Occurrence<,
GROOND CC!':DITIONS········· ··----- -··· · - · · -··------------ - -·····l.5
GROOND CC!':DITIONS········· ··----- -··· · - · · -··------------ - -·····l.5
(n) Rapid increa,;e of rp,:, on ground to quickly cngnsc clutch- -0. 5 (b) T;,:,.Hng with full cyclic control-------------------······· . 5 (c) Jump t~kcoff··· · ··· ··----··-····-····---·····-·--········(1) (d) Grcund·ol r·grc1:nd eyele····· - ------ · · ·· - - · - - · • -----·······(1) HOVJ::Rl!,G- ·-··-··· · · ····· · · ••--·-···· · · ··· ··- · ----- - ----- - -- •· ···2 . O
(a) Stc~dy hovering----·······-········· · · ·······-·--i---····· .5 (b) Latornl reversal···· · ----------···· · ··-··················· . S (c) Longitudinal reve rsal·····-·················-········· · -· · .S (d) Rutidor reversal····· · ····-···· ······ ··--·--··········· ···· . 5 FORWARD l'UCHT·PCMR o:;--·······-···············--······ ······· - 67.5
(a) Lc'.'c,) flight - 20:., \'~,..-· ·····-··········· ····-·-··········1.0 (b) l!!\'el (light · I.Oi,, \'~:i;-----········-----·-········-·······3 .0 (c) tcvcl flight - 60% V~------·············-----···········18,0 (d) Level fiight · 807. \' .• ·········· ··· · ··· ··-············· ·25.0 (e) Ha>d,...,m level flightNitbut not greater than Vi,.t:)··········15 .0 (!) Vim--·-····· ··· --·-·········-····· · ·····---·-·-···········3.0
(&) 1117. VE······-·· · · · · ··-····-···········-----··-·····---·- . 5 (h) Right furns · :J 60 90~ V ---·--···· · ··· ····-········ (2) J .0 (i) tc(c turns • 30 , 60, 9!Ji; fN&-········· -·--··········--(2) 3 .0 (j) Climb (Takeoff power)---·-·-······ ··· · · ··----············ · 2 .0 (k) Climb {}lax, continuous po..,er)········ · ·-----·-··· · · · · · · ··-1..0 (1) Change to autorctatio~ from p~wer-on·flight
30, 60, 901; "!\1::· ···-··---····· ·········------·-···· ····l.!i (c) Partial power descent (including condition of zero flow
thr~uzh rotor)······--·············-··------····· ··----2.0 (n) Cyclic and collect i.,e pull·up frora level fllght···-·······(2) (~) Pushovers············ --·-···· - · · · · · · · ····----······· · ···- - (2) (rl Gusts······ · ···· · ···· ········-·· · · ············-·········--(2) (q) Quick StO~S--········ · ···-------···············--··-· · ·-··(2) (r) Flores---····· ·······---------------··-·-····--···--------(2) (s) Later~! reversals at Vn·····--------·················-···· .5 (t) Longitudinal reversals at Vu·-··········--··---··········· .5 (u) !tudder reversals at \';1---------······- · ··--·--····-······· .5 (v) Landlnr, appro3ch·····-·-·-···-·······-· · · · ··-·----·······-3.0 (x) Sldew~rd !light· · · ········-··············--·-·······-·-··- . 5
(y) Re3rwaro flight··············--·- · - · ·--·--·-----·········· .5 AUIOROTATION • POWER OFF·---·--··············------·-••······-··9.0
(a) Stcndy forward flight--········-···············-·-··-·- ···2.0 (b) Rapid power recove ry from outorotational flight··· ·····-·· .5 (c) Right turns - 30, 60, 907. VNE· ·······-----·------······(2)1 .0 (d) Left turns· 30, 60, 907. VNE··-·····-- · ------········ ·· (2)1 .0 (e) Lateral reversals··· · ·-·········-· · · -·-------········ · · ··· .5 (f) Longitudinal reversals········ · ···· ··-------------· - · -- · ·· .5 (g) Rudder reversals--··········· · ··········--···-·-·········· .5 (h) Cyclic and collective pull-ups······ - ------··········- ··(2)
Chap 3 lb Pnr 12
SI 10. 9 January 20, 1975
(1) L~nding approach---------------- ------------------------------2 .0 (j) flbres-----------------------------------------------------(2)100.0
One fhght every 10 minutes with less frequent rotor stops. (l)
(2) A ver tical load factor frequency curve should be developed tha t is represent ~ti ve of the more critical types of operation. Ihe time spent in each turn should be odjuec~d to give the specified per cent of occurrence.
NOTE: Extensive adjustment co lhis table is oomally required to closely appcoximate ,he cocorcraft under evaluation.
Chop 3 Pogc 17 Par 12
s H). J.anun '/ 2U, l 'J75
TJ LE II
l 2 s 6
Cycles o F3ilurc
1
P rc~nt of
Li{e Used p ,. ;hour
: u)---- 0.5 1~00 ( J---- .5 2100 (1: ---- •5 2300 II(aJ--·- .5 2 00 (li ---- . 5 800 3,000,000 0 . 002.32 (~)---- .5 10500 .3,200,000 .. 00362 (d)---- .s 3400 Ill(n)---- 1.0 &300 (h)---- 3.0 •.'.HOO (c)---- 8,0 7700 Cu)---- _5_0 a100 (e)---- lli,Q 8350 .... 16,000,000 0 . 0217:3 u;,... (£)---- 3.0 8200 u 8,400,000 ,00522 (g)---- .5 9100 0 7, 00,000 ,00b7 (h ---- 3. 0 -1: 11200 0 2.li.00,000 .02900 ""' (i)---- 3.'0.. ,... 11 00 M (j)---- 2.0 ; 10900 N
TJ LE II
(~)---- 1 .0 ...i 9°00 <•>---- .5 7 00 < )---- 2.0 ,oo (n)---- 1.0 9/00 (o)---- .5 7800 (p)---- .5 7000 (q)---- .5 7300 (r)---- .0 6700 (s ---- .5 700 (:)---- .s 7900 !IV(n)---- 7100 (b ---- .s 9700 c~>---- .o 93 o (d ---- .0 9JOO (e)---- .S 6800 (£ ---- .s 6100 (•)---- .5 5900 (I)---- l.0 7600 (j)---- 2.0 7900
2,2.50,000 • 03093 2,700 000 I .017 9 !.., 0,000 .02203
I ,800,0Q .0 I 3
."400.000 .002 2 6 300,000 .00383 ti. 00.000 . 0058
TOT,\T.S '--='1~oo~.-=o:---!-----11-..;..;;.~--1--~--+--- ---t--.l---,,5-2-8- 9-
Ch.i p 3
Pnr 12 .I,