Radar Vectors
Final Rule Current Issued Oct 2, 2024 33 pages Copy saved Nov 17, 2026

89 FR 80310 Public Aircraft Logging of Flight Time, Training in Certain Aircraft Holding Special Airworthiness Certificates, and Flight Instructor Privileges

As directed by the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2018, the FAA will allow pilots conducting public aircraft operations to credit their flight time towards FAA civil regulatory requirements. Additionally, consistent with the James M. Inhofe National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2023, this final rule will amend the operating rules for experimental aircraft to permit certain flight training, testing, and checking in these aircraft without a letter of deviation authority. As directed in the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024, the same relief will be extended to certain flight training, testing, and checking in limited category, primary category, and experimental light sport aircraft. This final rule also revises miscellaneous amendments related to recent flight experience, flight instructor privileges, flight training in certain aircraft holding special airworthiness certificates, and the related prohibitions on conducting these activities for compensation or hire. These changes will clarify existing regulatory requirements, align the regulations with current industry practice, and ensure compliance with the FAA Reauthorization Acts of 2018 and 2024 and the James M. Inhofe National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2023.

Official source ↗ Official PDF ↗

Vol. 89

Wednesday,

No. 191

October 2, 2024

Part II

14 CFR Part 1, et al.

Public Aircraft Logging of Flight Time, Training in Certain Aircraft Holding Special Airworthiness Certificates, and Flight Instructor Privileges; Final Rule DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

14 CFR Parts 1, 11, 61, and 91

[Docket No. FAA-2023-1351; Amdt. Nos. 1-77, 11-68, 61-156, 91-378] RIN 2120-AL61

Public Aircraft Logging of Flight Time, Training in Certain Aircraft Holding Special Airworthiness Certificates, and Flight Instructor Privileges

Agency

AGENCY: Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Department of Transportation (DOT).

ACTION: Final rule.

SUMMARY: As directed by the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2018, the FAA will allow pilots conducting public aircraft operations to credit their flight time towards FAA civil regulatory requirements. Additionally, consistent with the James M. Inhofe National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2023, this final rule will amend the operating rules for experimental aircraft to permit certain flight training, testing, and checking in these aircraft without a letter of deviation authority. As directed in the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024, the same relief will be extended to certain flight training, testing, and checking in limited category, primary category, and experimental light sport aircraft. This final rule also revises miscellaneous amendments related to recent flight experience, flight instructor privileges, flight training in certain aircraft holding special airworthiness certificates, and the related prohibitions on conducting these activities for compensation or hire. These changes will clarify existing regulatory requirements, align the regulations with current industry practice, and ensure compliance with the FAA Reauthorization Acts of 2018 and 2024 and the James M. Inhofe National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2023.

Dates

DATES: Effective December 2, 2024.

ADDRESSES: For information on where to obtain copies of rulemaking documents and other information related to this final rule, see "How to Obtain Additional Information" in the SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION section of this document.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Erin Cappel, General Aviation and Commercial Division, Flight Standards Service, Federal Aviation Administration, 800 Independence Avenue SW, Washington, DC 20591; telephone (202) 267-1100; email [email protected].

Supplementary Information

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

List of Abbreviations and Acronyms Frequently Used In This Document

ATC: Air Traffic Control ELSA: Experimental Light-Sport Aircraft ICAO: International Civil Aviation Organization IFR: Instrument Flight Rules LODA: Letter of Deviation Authority NAS: National Airspace System NPRM: Notice of Proposed Rulemaking NTSB: National Transportation Safety Board PAO: public aircraft operation(s) PIC: Pilot-in-command SIC: Second-in-command SLSA: Special Light-Sport Aircraft VFR: Visual Flight Rules

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

I. Executive Summary

A. Purpose of the Regulatory Action

B. Changes Made in This Final Rule

C. Summary of the Cost and Benefits II. Authority for the Rulemaking III. Background

A. Summary of the NPRM

B. Overview of Comments Received IV. Discussion of Comments and the Final Rule

I. Executive Summary

A. Logging Flight Time in Public Aircraft Operations (§ 61.51)

B. Revision of the Definition of "Public Aircraft" (§ 1.1)

C. Exceptions to Recent Flight Experience for Pilot in Command (§ 61.57(e))

D. Flight Instructor Privileges (Sec. § 61.193 and 61.413)

E. Flight Training is Carrying a Person for Compensation or Hire

F. New Definition of Passenger (§ 61.1(b)) and Related Changes (§ 61.57)

G. Experimental Light-Sport Aircraft (§ 91.319(e))

H. Exception To Operating Certain Aircraft for the Purposes of Flight Training, Flightcrew Member Checking, or Flightcrew Member Testing (§ 91.326)

I. Miscellaneous Issues in Part 91

J. Severability V. Regulatory Notices and Analyses

A. Regulatory Impact Analysis

B. Regulatory Flexibility Act

C. International Trade Impact Assessment

D. Unfunded Mandates Assessment

E. Paperwork Reduction Act

F. International Compatibility

G. Environmental Analysis VI. Executive Order Determinations

A. Executive Order 13132, Federalism

B. Executive Order 13175, Consultation and Coordination With Indian Tribal Governments

C. Executive Order 13211, Regulations That Significantly Affect Energy Supply, Distribution, or Use

D. Executive Order 13609, Promoting International Regulatory Cooperation VII. Additional Information

A. Electronic Access and Filing

B. Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act

I. Executive Summary

A. Purpose of the Regulatory Action

A. Purpose of the Regulatory Action

As directed by section 517 of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2018 (Pub. L. 115-254), this final rule allows pilots conducting public aircraft operations (PAO) under Title 49 of the United States Code (49 U.S.C.) 40102(a)(41) and 40125 to credit their flight time towards FAA civil regulatory requirements. While section 517 requires the FAA to issue regulations to allow the logging of flight time in aircraft used in PAO \1\ under direct operational control of forestry and fire protection agencies,\2\ this final rule will permit all PAO to be eligible for logging of flight time. Moreover, this final rule expands the regulatory framework to allow pilots serving in PAO as second-in-command (SIC) to log flight time under certain circumstances.

\1\ The FAA uses the term "public aircraft operation" (PAO) to refer to public aircraft operations in general. For purposes of this rulemaking document, uses the abbreviation "PAO" to refer to both the singular and plural of those operations. The FAA considers the two terms to be synonymous.

\2\ As discussed elsewhere in this document, the FAA notes that section 826 of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 (Pub. L. 118-63) requires that, notwithstanding any other provision of law, aircraft under the direct operational control of forestry and fire protection agencies are eligible to log pilot flight times, if the flight time was acquired by the pilot while engaged on an official forestry or fire protection flight, in the same manner as aircraft under the direct operational control of a Federal, State, county, or municipal law enforcement agency. Section 826 further stated that this provision shall be applied as if enacted on October 5, 2018. As noted, this final rule meets, and expands upon, the requirements of section 826.

This final rule clarifies recent flight experience requirements and authorized flight training activities under part 61. This final rule adds § 61.57(e)(5) to codify an exception that would enable a person receiving flight training to act as pilot-in-command (PIC) in certain circumstances, even if that person does not meet the recent flight experience requirements for carrying passengers under § 61.57(a) or (b). Additionally, the FAA adds "maintaining or improving skills for certificated pilots" to the list of flight instructor privileges in Sec. § 61.193(a)(7) and 61.413(a)(6) to clarify that flight instructors are authorized to conduct certain specialized and elective training. Finally, this final rule revises the definition of "public aircraft" to align with the revised definition of 49 U.S.C. 40125(a)(2), which was amended by section 923 of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024.

Furthermore, this final rule amends part 91 operating rules to explicitly set forth prohibited operations and create limited exceptions to the general prohibition on carriage of persons for compensation or hire for flight training, testing, and checking in aircraft holding certain special airworthiness certificates consistent with section 5604 of the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). This final rule also removes the requirement for owners (and certain persons affiliated with owners) to obtain a letter of deviation authority (LODA) to accomplish flight training in their aircraft, as directed by section 814 of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024, and to clarify the general prohibition on operating aircraft with certain special airworthiness certificates while carrying persons or property for compensation or hire. Additionally, this final rule expands certain flight training, testing, and checking abilities in limited category, primary category, and experimental light sport aircraft. The FAA anticipates that the changes will provide greater access to specialized training in aircraft with special airworthiness certificates.

B. Changes Made in This Final Rule

B. Changes Made in This Final Rule

After considering comments on the notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) \3\ provided by the public, this final rule implements several changes from what was proposed in the NPRM. Table 1 provides a brief summary of all regulatory changes associated with this rulemaking, including those changes from the NPRM to final rule. The changes are discussed in more detail in Section IV of this preamble.

\3\ See Public Aircraft Logging of Flight Time, Training in Certain Aircraft Holding Special Airworthiness Certificates, and Flight Instructor Privileges, 88 FR 41194 (June 23, 2023).

Table 1--Summary of Regulatory Text Changes

Regulatory citation (14

Provision CFR) Proposed action Final rule action

Definitions … Sec. 1.1 … No proposed changes.... Revises the definition

of "public

aircraft".

Applicability and definitions … Sec. 61.1(b) … No proposed changes.... Amends Sec. 61.1(b)

to define

"passenger" as any

person on board an

aircraft other than a

crewmember, FAA

personnel,

manufacturer personnel

required for type

certification, or a

person receiving or

providing flight

training, checking, or

testing as authorized

by part 61.

Pilot logbooks … Sec. 61.51(f)(4) … Clarifies that a person Adopted as proposed.

designated as second-

in-command (SIC) by a

government entity may

log SIC time if the

aircraft used was a

large aircraft as

defined in § 1.1,

a turbo-jet powered

airplane, or if the

aircraft holds or

originally held a type

certificate that

requires a second

pilot.

§ 61.51(f)(4)(i).. Specifies that SIC time Adopted as proposed.

logged under paragraph

(f)(4) may not be used

to meet the

aeronautical

experience

requirements for the

private or commercial

pilot certificates or

an instrument rating.

Sec. 61.51(f)(4)(ii). Delineates that an Modifies the text to

applicant for an air specify that an ATP

transportation pilot applicant only needs a

(ATP) certificate who limitation added to

logs SIC time under their ATP certificate

Sec. 61.51(f)(4) is in accordance with

issued an ATP ICAO requirements if

certificate with a that applicant logs

limitation. second in command time

in an aircraft that is

not type certificated

for two pilots; adds

reference to Sec.

61.161.

Sec. 61.51(j)(4) … Allows logging of Adopted as proposed.

flight time for pilots

engaged in any PAO in

accordance with 49

U.S.C. 40102(a)(41)

and 40125.

Recent flight experience: Pilot in Sec. 61.57(a)(1) and No proposed changes.... Revises "passengers"

command. (b)(1). to "persons" due to

new § 61.1

definition of

"passenger."

Sec. 61.57(e)(5) … Provides an exception Adopted as proposed.

to § 61.57(a) and

(b) enabling a pilot

to regain recent

flight experience with

a flight instructor on

board.

§ 61.57(e)(6) … No proposed change … Adds an exception to

§ 61.57(a) and

(b) to harmonize with

§ 61.47(c).

Aeronautical experience: Airplane Sec. 61.159(e) … Allows a pilot to Adopted as proposed.

category rating. credit SIC time logged

under PAO toward the

total time for an ATP

certificate.

Aeronautical experience: Rotorcraft Sec. 61.161(d) … Allows a pilot to Adopted as proposed.

category and helicopter class rating. credit SIC time logged

under PAO toward the

total time for an ATP

certificate.

Flight Instructor Privileges … Sec. Sec. 61.193(a) Clarifies that, within Revises the

and 61.413(a). the limits of their introductory paragraph

certificates, of Sec. 61.413(a) to

authorized flight mirror the language

instructors may provided in Sec.

conduct ground and 61.193(a) to ensure

flight training, and consistency. Otherwise

certain checking adopted as proposed.

events, in addition to

issuing endorsements.

Sec. Sec. Clarifies that flight Adopted as proposed.

61.193(a)(7) and instructors are

61.413(a)(6). authorized to conduct

certain specialized

and elective training.

Sec. Sec. 61.193(c) Clarifies that the Adopted as proposed.

and 61.413(c). privileges afforded to

authorized flight

instructors under

these provisions do

not permit operations

that would require an

air carrier or

operating certificate

or specific

authorization from the

Administrator.

Limited category civil aircraft: Sec. 91.315 … Adds new Sec. Adopted as proposed.

Operating limitations. 91.315(a) through (d)

to clarify operations

that may not be

conducted while

carrying persons or

property for hire and

directs stakeholders

to new § 91.326.

Aircraft having experimental Sec. 91.319(a) … Revises the Adopted as proposed.

certificates: Operating limitations. introductory text to

include a reference to

§ 91.326.

Sec. 91.319(a)(2).... Revises the broad Adopted as proposed.

language in Sec.

91.319(a)(2) regarding

the operation of

experimental aircraft

carrying persons or

property for

compensation or hire

to further clarify its

intent.

§ 91.319(d)(3).... Replaces "air traffic Adopted as proposed.

control (ATC)" with

"control tower.".

Sec. 91.319(e), Removes the date • Amends the

(e)(1), and (e)(2). restriction on flight introductory text by

training in these directly referencing

aircraft and cross- light-sport aircraft

references proposed and moves the

Sec. 91.326. exception language

into paragraph (e)(1).

• Modifies Sec.

91.319(e)(2) by

directly referencing

light-sport aircraft.

• Adds language

to be inclusive of

aircraft certificated

under § 21.191(i)

for use in flight

training.

Sec. 91.319(f) … Moves the exception Adopted as proposed.

language into new

paragraph (f)(1). Adds

new paragraph (f)(2)

to allow solo flights

in accordance with a

training program

included as part of

the deviation

authority specified

under § 91.326(b).

§ 91.319(f)(2).... Adds language to permit Adopted as proposed.

training in certain

experimental light-

sport aircraft for

compensation or hire

through existing

deviation authority in

accordance with

proposed Sec.

91.326(b).

Sec. 91.319(h) … Removes the current Adopted as proposed.

deviation authority

and reserves the

paragraph.

Primary Category Airworthiness Sec. 91.325(a) … Adds new paragraphs Adopted as proposed.

Certificates. (a)(1) through (4) to

clarify operations

that may not be

conducted while

carrying persons or

property for hire.

Sec. 91.325(b) … Adds a reference to Corrects reference to

Sec. 91.326(a) to Sec. 91.326(c)

the introductory instead of Sec.

language. Enables 91.326(a) and

primary category otherwise adopted as

aircraft to be used proposed.

for flight training,

checking, and testing

without the need to

obtain deviation

authority.

Sec. 91.325(c) … Adds new Sec. Adopted as proposed.

91.326(c) to permit

primary category

aircraft maintained by

FAA certificated

mechanics or

authorized repair

stations to be

operated for

compensation or hire

for the purposes of

conducting flight

training, checking,

and testing without

deviation authority or

an exemption.

Exception to operating certain Sec. 91.326(a) … Adds new Sec. 91.326 • Adds the title

aircraft for the purposes of flight to provide who may "General."

training, flightcrew member receive and provide • Modifies the

checking, or flightcrew member flight training, language to specify

testing. checking, and testing that, notwithstanding

without deviation the prohibitions in

authority and to Sec. Sec. 91.315,

specify when deviation 91.319(a), and 91.325,

authority is required a person may conduct

for these operations. flight training,

checking, or testing

in a limited category

aircraft, experimental

aircraft, or primary

category aircraft

under the provisions

of this section.

• Moves the Sec.

91.326(a) operations

not requiring a LODA

to Sec.

91.326(c)(1).

Exception to Operating Certain Sec. 91.326(a)(1).... Prohibits the Redesignates the

Aircraft for Compensation or Hire. authorized instructor proposed language as

from providing both Sec.

the training and the 91.326(c)(1)(i).

aircraft.

Sec. 91.326(a)(2).... Prohibits any person Redesignates the

from broadly offering proposed language as

the aircraft as Sec.

available for the 91.326(c)(1)(ii).

activity.

Sec. 91.326(a)(3).... Specifies that no Redesignates the

person would be proposed language as

permitted to receive Sec.

compensation for use 91.326(c)(1)(iii).

of the aircraft for a

specific flight during

which flight training,

checking, or testing

was accomplished,

other than expenses

for owning, operating,

and maintaining the

aircraft.

Sec. 91.326(b) … Provides that any Changes proposed title

person who wants to to "Operations

conduct flight requiring a letter of

training, checking, or deviation authority."

testing in limited Removes the reference

category and to Sec. 91.326(a).

experimental aircraft

outside the

restrictions and

limitations of

proposed Sec.

91.326(a) and (c) may

apply for deviation

authority.

Sec. 91.326(b)(1).... Clarifies that no Adopted as proposed.

person may operate

under this section

without a LODA.

Sec. 91.326(b)(2).... Enables the FAA to Adds language to Sec.

cancel or amend a LODA 91.326(b)(2) to

if it determines that memorialize the

the deviation holder Administrator's

has failed to comply authority to deny an

with the conditions application for a LODA

and limitations or at if it would not be in

any time if the the interest of safety

Administrator or is unnecessary.

determines that the

deviation is no longer

necessary or in the

interest of safety.

§ 91.326(b)(3)(i) Enumerates the items an Removes Sec.

through (ix). applicant would be 91.326(b)(3)(vi) and

required to include in otherwise adopted as

their request for proposed.

deviation authority.

Sec. 91.326(b)(4).... Allows the Adds certain conditions

Administrator to and limitations in new

continue to prescribe Sec. 91.326(b)(4)(i)

additional conditions through (viii).

and limitations in

LODAs for experimental

aircraft and extend

that allowance to

LODAs issued for

training, testing, and

checking in limited

category aircraft when

necessary for safety.

Sec. 91.326(b)(5).... Limits the persons Allows up to two

permitted to be on trainee observers to

board an aircraft be carried in

during operations operations conducted

under a LODA to under a LODA, provided

authorized flight the carriage is not

instructor, designated prohibited by any

examiner, person other regulation, the

receiving flight observer is enrolled

training or being in in a LODA training

checked or tested, or course for the same

persons essential for aircraft, and the

the safe operation. observation takes

place from a

forwardmost observer

seat with an

unobstructed view of

the flightdeck.

Sec. 91.326(b)(6).... Specifies that the Adopted as proposed.

Administrator may

limit the types of

training, testing, and

checking authorized

under this deviation

authority.

Sec. 91.326(c) … Instructs holders of • Redesignates

LODAs issued under proposed Sec.

Sec. 91.319(h) on 91.326(c) as Sec.

LODA validity and 91.326(d), with no

expiration at the time substantive revisions.

of publication of the • Adds Sec.

final rule. 91.326(d), titled

"Previously issued

letters of deviation

authority."

• New Sec.

91.326(c), titled

"Operations not

requiring a letter of

deviation authority,"

provides introductory

language on operations

that may be conducted

without a LODA (see

previously denoted

revisions to Sec.

91.326(a)).

§ 91.326(c)(2).... No proposed change … Adds new Sec.

91.326(c)(2) to

specify that a person

may operate a limited

category aircraft,

experimental aircraft,

or primary category

aircraft to conduct

flight training,

checking, or testing

without a LODA if no

person provides and no

person receives

compensation for the

flight training,

checking, or testing,

or for the use of the

aircraft.

Aircraft having a special Sec. 91.327(a)(2).... Adds to the existing Adopted as proposed.

airworthiness certificate in the explicit permission

light-sport category: Operating for flight training

limitations. that a person may

conduct checking and

testing.

C. Summary of the Costs and Benefits

C. Summary of the Costs and Benefits

The FAA analyzed the costs and benefits for the provisions related to PAO and the provisions related to training, testing, and checking in certain aircraft with special airworthiness certificates separately in the NPRM and presents the same analysis in this final rule. The changes from the NPRM to the final rule have minimal economic effects and do not change the results of the analysis. The final provisions related to PAO will impose no new costs, and the FAA determines the rule will reduce the costs for pilots conducting PAO to maintain their civil certificates and ratings.\4\ Based on calculations presented in the Paperwork Reduction Act (PRA) section, the FAA estimates that the provisions related to training, testing, and checking will impose approximately $100,000 in total one-time costs (undiscounted) split roughly evenly between current LODA holders and the FAA over a period of two years. These costs stem from the requirement that current LODA holders who broadly offer certain aircraft with special airworthiness certificates for training reapply within two years of the effective date of this final rule.\5\ However, the FAA expects cost savings from the elimination of LODA requirements for pilots receiving training in their own aircraft, the streamlined regulatory framework, and the safety benefits from greater access to specialized training in aircraft with special airworthiness certificates to exceed the initial costs. Overall, the FAA concludes that this rule will enhance safety with minimal impact on cost.

\4\ The FAA does not maintain counts of pilots who fly PAO for federal, state, and local governments and there is insufficient data for the FAA to estimate the number of pilots affected by this final rule. See "How to Become a Government Pilot" in Flying Magazine by James Wynbrandt, Dec. 13, 2017. Available at: www.flyingmag.com/how-to-become-government-pilot/ Last accessed Jul. 22, 2022.

\5\ This requirement is discussed in further detail in section V. of this preamble.

II. Authority for This Rulemaking

II. Authority for This Rulemaking

The FAA's authority to issue rules on aviation safety is found in title 49 of the United States Code. Subtitle I, section 106 describes the authority of the FAA Administrator. Subtitle VII, Aviation Programs, describes the scope of the FAA's authority in more detail.

This rulemaking is promulgated under the authority described in subtitle VII, part A, subpart iii, section 44701, General Requirements; section 44702, Issuance of Certificates; and section 44703, Airman Certificates. Under these sections, the FAA prescribes regulations and minimum standards for practices, methods, and procedures the Administrator finds necessary for safety in air commerce. The FAA is also authorized to issue certificates, including airman certificates and medical certificates, to qualified individuals. This final rule is within the scope of that authority.

Furthermore, section 517 of Public Law 115-254, Public Aircraft Eligible for Logging Flight Times, directs the Administrator to revise 14 CFR 61.51(j)(4) to include aircraft under direct operational control of forestry and fire protection agencies as public aircraft eligible for logging flight times. The FAA also codifies section 5604 of the 2023 NDAA, which directs that under certain conditions, flight training, testing, and checking in experimental aircraft does not require a LODA from the FAA.\6\ This final rule implements those explicit Congressional directions.

\6\ James M. Inhofe National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2023, Public Law 117-263, 136 Stat. 2395, Section 5604 (Dec. 23, 2022).

Finally, this final rule responds to several provisions of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024. As noted previously, this final rule implements the public aircraft logging provisions of section 826 regarding forestry and firefighting flight time logging, as well as the provision in that section that, within 180 days of the date of enactment of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024, the Administrator of the FAA shall make the regulatory changes necessary to implement section 826(a).\7\

\7\ FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024, Public Law 118-63, 138 Stat. 1332, Section 826 (b) (May 16, 2024).

This rule also responds to section 814 of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 regarding letter of deviation authority.\8\ Section 814 provides that a flight instructor, registered owner, lessor, or lessee of a covered aircraft shall not be required to obtain a letter of deviation authority from the Administrator to allow, conduct, or receive flight training, checking, and testing in such aircraft if the flight instructor is not providing both the training and the aircraft; no person advertises or broadly offers the aircraft as available for flight training, checking, or testing; and no person receives compensation for use of the aircraft for a specific flight during which flight training, checking, or testing was received, other than expenses for owning, operating, and maintaining the aircraft. For purposes of section 814, a covered aircraft means an experimental aircraft, a limited category aircraft, and a primary category aircraft.

\8\ FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024, Section 814.

While not proposed in the NPRM, this final rule revises the definition of "public aircraft" in 14 CFR 1.1 to align with the revised definition of "public aircraft" in 49 U.S.C. 40125(a)(2), as amended by section 923 of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024.\9\ In section 923, Congress amended the definition of "public aircraft" in 49 U.S.C. 40125 as a matter of law. As the FAA has no discretion but to conform the definition of "public aircraft" in 14 CFR 1.1 to the amended definition in 49 U.S.C. 40125, the FAA finds prior notice and the opportunity for public comment on this definition revision unnecessary under the Administrative Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C. 553(b)(B). Therefore, the FAA finds good cause to forgo prior notice and the opportunity for public comment regarding this definition change.

\9\ FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024, Section 923.

III. Background

III. Background

The NPRM published on June 23, 2023,\10\ and the LODA advisory circular (AC) was added to the docket on June 29, 2023. The public comment period for the NPRM and AC was initially scheduled to close on August 22, 2023. However, in response to a request from the Experimental Aircraft Association for additional time to comment, the FAA extended the comment period until September 21, 2023, to provide the public additional time to thoughtfully analyze and respond to the NPRM and AC.\11\ A brief overview of the NPRM follows.

\10\ Public Aircraft Logging of Flight Time, Training in Certain Aircraft Holding Special Airworthiness Certificates, and Flight Instructor Privileges, 88 FR 41194 (Jun. 23, 2023). Corrected at 88 FR 44744 (Jul. 14, 2023).

\11\ Public Aircraft Logging of Flight Time, Training in Certain Aircraft Holding Special Airworthiness Certificates, and Flight Instructor Privileges NPRM Extension of Comment Period, 88 FR 55959 (Aug. 17, 2023).

A. Summary of the NPRM

A. Summary of the NPRM

1. Logging Flight Time in Public Aircraft Operations

Prior to this rule, only pilots conducting PAO for official law enforcement activities could log flight time under § 61.51(j)(4). However, section 517 of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2018, Public Law 115-254 directed the FAA to expand PAO logging opportunities by permitting pilots to log flight time in aircraft under the direct operational control of forestry and fire protection agencies when such operations are conducted as PAO. Notwithstanding the limited scope of section 517, in the NPRM, the FAA proposed to amend § 61.51(j)(4) to allow logging of flight time for pilots engaged in any PAO in accordance with 49 U.S.C. 40102(a)(41) and 40125(a)(2).\12\ Additionally, previous second-in-command (SIC) logging regulations did not address aircraft used in PAO that do not also hold airworthiness certificates issued by the FAA. The NPRM proposed to explicitly allow the logging of SIC time during PAO, with certain limitations, to encourage safety and promote consistency with the regulated community.\13\

1. Logging Flight Time in Public Aircraft Operations

\12\ 88 FR 41194 at 41196.

\13\ Id. at 41196-41198.

2. Exceptions to Recent Flight Experience for Pilot-in-Command

Section 61.57 contains the recent flight experience requirements to maintain privileges to act as PIC under certain scenarios, including requirements to complete takeoffs and landings to continue to act as PIC of a flight that is carrying passengers. The FAA had previously issued legal interpretations indicating certain operations related to obtaining recent flight experience with an instructor on board are already permissible under existing regulations, notwithstanding the prohibition on passenger-carrying flights. The FAA determined the plain text of its regulations did not support the conclusions in these interpretations. Therefore, the NPRM rescinded the conflicting legal interpretations and proposed to add § 61.57(e)(5) to codify an exception that, in certain circumstances, would enable a person receiving flight training to act as PIC even if that person does not meet recent flight experience requirements.\14\

2. Exceptions to Recent Flight Experience for Pilot-in-Command

\14\ Id. at 41198, 41199.

3. Flight Instructor Privileges

Sections 61.193 and 61.413 set forth the privileges of flight instructors and sport pilot instructors, respectively. During the course of this rulemaking, the FAA identified a need to clarify the types of operations that would be considered within the scope of a flight instructor's privileges in accordance with part 61. Although the FAA has historically encouraged flight instructors to conduct certain types of training operations (e.g., transition training), Sec. § 61.193 and 61.413 could be read to restrict such training. Therefore, in the NPRM, the FAA proposed clarifying amendments to Sec. § 61.193 and 61.413 to conform the regulations with current FAA policy and industry practice by explicitly permitting authorized flight instructors to conduct ground and flight training, and certain checking events, in addition to issuing endorsements.\15\

3. Flight Instructor Privileges

\15\ Id. at 41199-41201.

4. Flight Training Is Carrying a Person for Compensation or Hire; Exception To Operating Certain Aircraft for the Purposes of Flight Training, Flightcrew Member Checking, or Flightcrew Member Testing

Previously, Sec. § 91.315, 91.319, and 91.325 generally prohibited flight training, checking, and testing when compensation is provided. In 2020, the FAA issued Warbird Adventures, Inc. an emergency cease and desist order restricting the operation of aircraft that held special airworthiness certificates carrying people for compensation or hire.\16\ The operator brought a petition for review of the emergency order before the court.\17\ On April 2, 2021, the court dismissed the petition for review of the cease and desist order.\18\ Following the court's dismissal, several aviation industry groups sought clarification from the FAA on how the decision affected flight training in experimental aircraft since the prohibitory language of § 91.315 for limited category aircraft is the same as that in § 91.319 for experimental aircraft (notably, the same prohibitory language exists in § 91.325 for primary category aircraft). As a result of this court case, in the NPRM, the FAA proposed to clarify prohibitory language and to explicitly enable flight training, checking, and testing under certain conditions in aircraft holding special airworthiness certificates.

\16\ Emergency Cease and Desist Order Issued by the Federal Aviation Administration (July 28, 2020).

\17\ Warbird Adventures, Inc. v. Fed. Aviation Admin., Petition for Review from an Emergency Cease and Desist Order Issued by the Federal Aviation Administration on July 28, 2020, Doc. No. 1854466 (D.C. Cir. 2020).

\18\ The court stated: "A flight student is a "person." Id. § 91.315; see also id. § 1.1. When a student is learning to fly in an airplane, the student is "carr[ied]." Id. § 91.315. And when the student is paying for the instruction, the student is being carried "for compensation." Id." Warbird Adventures, Inc. v. Fed. Aviation Admin., 843 F. App'x 331 (D.C. Cir. 2021).

In the wake of the court ruling, the James M. Inhofe National Defense Authorization Act for 2023 (2023 NDAA) was adopted. The 2023 NDAA included a self-implementing provision that amended the operating rules to permit certain flight training, testing, and checking in experimental aircraft without a letter of deviation authority (LODA). Likewise, section 814 of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 (Pub. L. 118-63) directed that, under certain conditions, flight training, testing, and checking in limited, experimental, and primary category aircraft do not require a LODA from the FAA. The NPRM proposed to modify Sec. § 91.315, 91.319, and 91.325 to clarify prohibited operations, as well as direct stakeholders to a newly proposed regulation, § 91.326, that provided instruction on conducting certain operations for compensation or hire. The FAA also proposed to implement related miscellaneous amendments pertaining to recent flight experience, flight instructor privileges, flight training in certain aircraft holding special airworthiness certificates, and the related prohibitions on conducting these activities for compensation or hire.\19\

\19\ 88 FR 41194 at 41201-41213.

5. Experimental Light-Sport Aircraft

Lastly, on October 24, 2018, the FAA published an NPRM titled "Removal of the Date Restriction for Flight Training in Experimental Light Sport Aircraft." \20\ For the reasons provided in the document withdrawing the "Removal of the Date Restriction for Flight Training in Experimental Light Sport Aircraft" NPRM,\21\ the FAA withdrew the NPRM and, instead, developed this rule to resolve the discrepancy more broadly for all experimental aircraft.

5. Experimental Light-Sport Aircraft

\20\ Removal of the Date Restriction for Flight Training in Experimental Light Sport Aircraft, 83 FR 53590 (Oct. 24, 2018).

\21\ Removal of the Date Restriction for Flight Training in Experimental Light Sport Aircraft; Withdrawal, 88 FR 41045 (June 23, 2023).

B. Overview of Comments Received

B. Overview of Comments Received

The FAA received 22 comments to the NPRM.\22\ Most of the comments were from advocacy or industry groups such as the Air Line Pilots Association, International (ALPA), the Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association (AOPA), the Association of Professional Warbird Operators, Inc. (APWO), the Commemorative Air Force (CAF), the Experimental Aircraft Association (EAA),\23\ and the Helicopter Association International (HAI).\24\ The Champaign Aviation Museum (CAM) and individual members of the public also commented on the docket. The general disposition of the comments favored proceeding with the NPRM, albeit with suggested changes.

\22\ Docket No. FAA-2023-1351. Of the 22 comments, two comments were duplicates and one commenter submitted four separate comments. Therefore, sixteen discrete commenters provided comments on the docket.

\23\ The FAA notes that both the Association of Professional Warbird Operators and the Commemorative Air Force commented to indicate support of EAA's comments and recommended edits to the NPRM; additionally, EAA references Warbirds of America in their comment submission as a division of EAA representing pilots, owners, restorers, and enthusiasts of former military aircraft. For brevity, a reference to EAA should be understood to have the support of both of these organizations, as well as Warbirds of America as a division of EAA, rather than citing each of the organizations in every comment summary of this preamble.

\24\ The FAA notes that on February 26, 2024, the commenter announced the renaming of Helicopter Association International (HAI) to Vertical Aviation International (VAI).

IV. Discussion of Comments and the Final Rule

IV. Discussion of Comments and the Final Rule

A. Logging Flight Time in Public Aircraft Operations (§ 61.51)

Section 61.51(j) states that, for time to be logged, it must be acquired in an aircraft that is identified as an aircraft under § 61.5(b) and is (1) an aircraft of U.S. registry with either a standard or special airworthiness certificate, (2) an aircraft of foreign registry with an airworthiness certificate that is approved by the aviation authority of a foreign country that is a Member State to the Convention on International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), (3) a military aircraft under the direct operational control of the U.S. Armed Forces, or (4) a public aircraft under the direct operational control of a Federal, State, county, or municipal law enforcement agency, if the flight time was acquired by the pilot while engaged on an official law enforcement flight for a Federal, State, county, or municipal law enforcement agency. The FAA proposed to amend the list of qualified operations in § 61.51(j)(4) to allow logging of flight time for pilots engaged in any PAO in accordance with 49 U.S.C. 40102(a)(41) and 40125.

A. Logging Flight Time in Public Aircraft Operations (§ 61.51)

Relatedly, the SIC logging requirements in § 61.51 permit a person to log time as SIC based on the number of pilots required by the type certification of the aircraft or the regulations under which the flight is conducted or through an approved SIC pilot professional development program (PDP).\25\ To adequately address aircraft used in PAO that do not necessarily meet these parameters, the FAA also proposed to add § 61.51(f)(4) to clarify that a person designated as second-in-command (SIC) by a government entity may log SIC time during PAO if the aircraft used is a large aircraft as defined in § 1.1, a turbo-jet powered airplane, or if the aircraft holds or originally held a type certificate that requires a second pilot.

\25\ 14 CFR 61.51(f). As explained in the NPRM, under current § 61.51(d), an assigned second pilot in a PAO does not meet the requirements to log SIC time (see 88 FR 41194 at 41197).

As discussed in the NPRM,\26\ the FAA finds that airline transport pilot (ATP) hours are largely related to exposure and experience through time building, whereas flight time necessary to meet minimum aeronautical experience requirements for private pilot, commercial, and instrument rating is more directly related to building specific skillsets and foundational knowledge. Therefore, the FAA proposed to add § 61.51(f)(4)(i) to explicitly state that SIC time logged under paragraph (f)(4) may not be used to meet the aeronautical experience requirements for the private or commercial pilot certificates or an instrument rating. Additionally, because ICAO standards do not recognize the crediting of flight time when a pilot is not required by the aircraft certification or the operating rules under which the flight is being conducted, the NPRM proposed to add § 61.51(f)(4)(ii) to delineate that an applicant for an ATP certificate who logs SIC time under § 61.51(f)(4) would be issued an ATP certificate with a limitation. Specifically, the certificate's limitation would read, "Holder does not meet the pilot-in-command aeronautical experience requirements of ICAO," as prescribed under Article 39 of the Convention on International Civil Aviation if the applicant does not meet the ICAO requirements contained in Annex 1 "Personnel Licensing" to the Convention on International Civil Aviation.

\26\ 88 FR 41194 at 41197.

Finally, the FAA proposed to amend Sec. § 61.159(e) and 61.161(d) to reference § 61.51(f)(4) to align the proposed revisions to § 61.51(f) with requirements applicable to pilots who apply for an ATP certificate with an ICAO limitation. This proposed revision to the aeronautical experience requirements of Sec. § 61.159 and 61.161 would reference § 61.51(f)(4) to allow a pilot to credit SIC time logged under PAO toward the total time for an ATP certificate. 1. Summary of the Comments

The FAA received six comments on § 61.51 as proposed in the NPRM. Three of the six commenters, AOPA, HAI, and an individual, generally supported the proposed revisions to § 61.51 without suggested changes. ALPA supported the proposal with suggested changes. One individual commenter opposed the proposal, and one individual's comment was out of the scope of this rulemaking.

HAI noted that the proposed changes would permit industry to track pilot experience more accurately without any detriment to safety. ALPA supported FAA's proposal to amend § 61.51(j) and stated that the amendment would not negatively impact safety or training. ALPA stated that the technical skill and proficiency required to operate aircraft in these types of operations require even higher training and certification standards than airborne law enforcement operations. However, ALPA expressed its concern that some agencies' training and certification standards may not be as rigorous as those of others. In this regard, ALPA clarified that its support is contingent on the final rule stipulating that PAO operators have formalized and documented training and certification programs for pilots operating under PAO to log time toward certificates, ratings, and experience.

In addition, ALPA stated that it conditionally supported the proposed requirements for logging SIC time under PAO, emphasizing that SIC time should only be logged in large or turbojet powered multi-engine airplanes that are flown under PAO that do not also hold airworthiness certificates issued by the FAA. ALPA agreed that the proposed SIC provision would improve safety in the national airspace system (NAS) and is consistent with several National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) recommendations. However, ALPA recommended that PAO operators establish formalized command and mentoring training requirements for their PICs for a second pilot to be able to log SIC time. ALPA noted that such a suggestion is consistent with the flightcrew and PIC requirements of § 135.99(c)(4). ALPA also supported the FAA's proposal to limit crediting of SIC time toward the ATP certificate only.

One individual commenter opposed the proposed update to § 61.51(j)(4). The commenter stated that permitting all PAO pilots to log flight time under § 61.51(j)(4) would include PAOs operating non-certificated aircraft, military surplus aircraft, Law Enforcement Support Office (LESO) aircraft, and Federal Excess Purchasing Program (FEPP) aircraft. The commenter explained that this inclusion would likely negatively impact safety, though they did not explain how, and recommended that public aircraft operators have formalized, documented training and certification programs for pilots operating under PAO to log time toward certificates, ratings, and experience. The commenter emphasized that the FAA must be able to certify the aircraft are maintained and flown to the current military or aircraft manufacturer standard for that aircraft.

Additionally, an individual commenter stated that since the NPRM would allow SIC time for PAO aircraft, the FAA should also reexamine allowing Naval Flight Officers (NFO) and equivalent flying officers of other military services to log as SIC time. The commenter noted that NFOs occupied the right seat in aircraft equipped with full instrumentation and performed all pilot monitoring duties, navigated, assisted with checklists, and performed emergency procedures; however, since the NFOs were not rated pilots by military standards, none of the acquired flight hours can be credited to the aeronautical experience requirements. The commenter explained that the inability to log time accrued as an NFO makes it financially much more difficult for an NFO to transition to a career as an airline pilot.

The FAA did not receive any further comments on (1) the ICAO limitation proposed in § 61.51(f)(4)(ii) or (2) the crediting of time logged under PAO toward the total time for an ATP certificate proposed in Sec. § 61.159(e) and 61.161(d). 2. FAA Response

The FAA acknowledges ALPA's and an individual commenter's recommendations to require, first, formalized and documented training and certification programs for pilots operating under PAO to credit time toward certificates, ratings, and experience and, second, formalized command and mentoring training requirements for their PICs for a second pilot to be able to log SIC time, similar to § 135.99(c). However, the FAA declines to revise this final rule to include these recommendations because the FAA does not maintain regulatory authority over PAOs other than those requirements that apply to all aircraft operating in the NAS. Such authority is granted to a government entity by statute under 49 U.S.C. 40102(a)(41) and section 40125. Therefore, PAOs represent a significant transfer of responsibility to the government entity, who may implement certain training programs tailored to their specific governmental function and mission. Because the respective governmental entity is best situated to ensure proper training and operation of their PAO, and the FAA lacks the expertise to approve the broad gamut of PAO training programs that are specific to respective governmental agencies, the FAA does not find that requiring a training or mentorship program as a prerequisite to logging of PAO flight time would enhance safety. Further, as explained in the NPRM, these operations are already occurring in the NAS. The FAA is simply revising the PAO logging requirements to allow PICs and SICs to log the flight time they have been accumulating, and continue to accumulate, toward meeting certain FAA recency and certification requirements.

In response to concerns that PAO aircraft are not certificated in accordance with FAA certification standards, the FAA notes its statutory authority to regulate the operation and maintenance of civil aircraft used in air commerce and lack of statutory authority to regulate public aircraft, except as related to operations in the NAS.\27\ The ability to determine the airworthiness of "public aircraft" is transferred to the governmental entity during qualified PAOs.\28\ As stated in AC 91-91, the FAA recommends that public aircraft operators use one of the inspection or maintenance programs specified in § 91.409 to determine airworthiness, but the FAA cannot make this a requirement. This shift in responsibility for safety standards for inspections and maintenance from the FAA to the governmental entity conducting a PAO neither impacts an aircraft's ability to operate in the NAS nor a PAO pilot's ability to log flight time as mandated by Congress. Based on the reasons discussed previously, this final rule does not add the commenter's recommendation.

\27\ See FAA Advisory Circular 91-91, Maintaining Public Aircraft. www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/advisory_circulars/index.cfm/go/document.information/documentID/1030146.

\28\ See FAA Advisory Circular 91-91, Maintaining Public Aircraft. www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/advisory_circulars/index.cfm/go/document.information/documentID/1030146.

Finally, this final rule does not adopt the recommendation to allow NFOs and equivalent flying officers of military services to log SIC flight time because it is outside the scope of this rulemaking. In the NPRM, the FAA proposed to expand PAO logging opportunities by permitting pilots to log flight time while conducting a governmental function outlined in 49 U.S.C. 40125. This is dissimilar to the request to allow NFOs and equivalent military personnel to log SIC pilot time because NFOs do not undergo the training nor perform the functions of a Naval pilot. Rather, NFOs function as navigators, lookouts, and weapons officers. Although there may be some functions that overlap with those of a Naval pilot, they are not equivalent to the responsibilities and duties of a PIC or SIC and, therefore, will not be considered as such under civilian regulations. Since the commenter's request is unrelated to the provisions in the NPRM, the FAA will not integrate the suggested change into this final rule. 3. Revisions To Align With ICAO Requirements

As previously stated, the NPRM proposed to add § 61.51(f)(4)(ii) to delineate that an applicant for an ATP certificate who logs SIC time under § 61.51(f)(4) would be issued an ATP certificate with a limitation. Although the NPRM proposed to require this limitation for all flight time logged in accordance with § 61.51(f)(4), the final rule is changed to align precisely with ICAO requirements. Specifically, the final rule will not require the limitation to be added to a pilot's ATP certificate when the SIC flight time was logged in an aircraft type certificated for two pilots. This change is in accordance with ICAO Annex 1 (Personnel Licensing), section 2.1.9.3, which states, "[t]he holder of a pilot license, when acting as a co-pilot at a pilot station of an aircraft certificated to be operated with a co-pilot, shall be entitled to be credited in full with this flight time towards the total flight time required for a higher grade of pilot license." Persons logging flight time in aircraft that are not type certificated for two pilots will continue to require the ICAO limitation to be added to their ATP certificate. As noted in the NPRM, an applicant would be entitled to an ATP certificate without the ICAO limitation specified under this provision when the applicant presents satisfactory evidence of having met the ICAO requirements (and otherwise meets the applicable aeronautical experience requirements).

Additionally, during the pendency of this rulemaking, the FAA noted an inadvertent error in the proposed ICAO limitation of § 61.51(f)(4)(ii) by excluding a reference to § 61.161, which sets forth the aeronautical experience requirements for rotorcraft category, helicopter class rating on an ATP certificate. Specifically, § 61.51(f)(4) permits a person to log SIC time if the person is designated by a government entity as an SIC when operating in accordance with § 61.51(j)(4), provided the aircraft used is a large aircraft (in addition to other conditions set forth within the paragraph (f)). By definition, a large aircraft can include a helicopter,\29\ which would necessitate an ICAO limitation for the ATP certificate with rotorcraft category, helicopter class rating mirroring that of an airplane category ATP certificate. While the FAA proposed the ICAO limitation provision in the NPRM via § 61.161(d), the aligning reference was inadvertently excluded from § 61.51(d)(4)(ii). This final rule corrects the inadvertent omission.

\29\ Under 14 CFR 1.1, a "large aircraft" means aircraft of more than 12,500 pounds, maximum certificated takeoff weight.

The FAA adopts Sec. § 61.51(f), 61.159(e), and 61.161(d), as proposed, subject to the revisions described in this section.

B. Revision of the Definition of "Public Aircraft" (§ 1.1)

B. Revision of the Definition of "Public Aircraft" (§ 1.1)

Section 923 of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 (Pub. L. 118-63) amended the definition of "public aircraft" found in 49 U.S.C. 40125(a)(2). Specifically, section 923 amends 49 U.S.C. 40125(a)(2), which sets forth the definition of "governmental function," to include: "biological or geological resource management (including data collection on civil aviation systems undergoing research, development, test, or evaluation at a test range (as such term is defined in 49 U.S.C. 44801)), infrastructure inspections, or any other activity undertaken by a governmental entity that the Administrator determines is inherently governmental." \30\

\30\ 49 U.S.C. 40125(a)(2) as amended by section 923 of Public Law 118-63.

The regulations in 14 CFR 1.1 set forth the definitions for subchapters A through K of title 14, chapter I, including a definition for public aircraft. Within the definition for "public aircraft," paragraph (1)(ii) sets forth the definition of "governmental function" for the sole purpose of determining public aircraft status, which aligns with the definition of "governmental function" as set forth in 49 U.S.C. 40125(a)(2). Because this final rule permits the logging of flight time for pilots engaged in any PAO in accordance with 49 U.S.C. 40102(a)(41) and 40125 (i.e., the revised statute), which contains the statutorily revised definition, this final rule revises the 14 CFR 1.1 definition of public aircraft to align with the statutory definition in revised 49 U.S.C. 40125(a)(2).

C. Exceptions to Recent Flight Experience for Pilot in Command (§ 61.57(e))

C. Exceptions to Recent Flight Experience for Pilot in Command (§ 61.57(e))

Section 61.57 contains recent flight experience requirements to maintain privileges to act as PIC under certain scenarios, including requirements to complete takeoffs and landings to continue to act as PIC of a flight that is carrying passengers. The FAA proposed to add § 61.57(e)(5) to codify an exception that, in certain circumstances, would enable a person receiving flight training to act as PIC, even if that person does not meet the recent flight experience requirements for carrying passengers under § 61.57(a) or (b). This person would be required to meet all other requirements to act as PIC, except for the recent flight experience requirements of § 61.57(a) or (b), and only the authorized instructor and person receiving training could be on board the aircraft. The FAA proposed the change in response to a disparity created between several legal interpretations \31\ that concluded, unsupported by the regulations, that a flight instructor and a person receiving flight training are not considered passengers to one another. This final rule adds the definition of "passenger" and addresses how those legal interpretations relate to the requirements of § 61.57, as explained in section VI.F of this preamble.

\31\ The FAA rescinded Legal Interpretation to Kris Kortokrax (Aug. 22, 2006), Legal Interpretation to John Olshock (May 4, 2007), Legal Interpretation to Roger Schaffner (May 5, 2014), and Legal Interpretation to E.V. Fretwell (Sept. 18, 1995) on July 23, 2023, 30 days after publication of the NPRM, because they were not supported by FAA regulations. See 88 FR 41194 at 41199.

HAI and ALPA both supported the proposed amendment to § 61.57(e). HAI described the FAA's approach in § 61.57(e) as common sense, resulting in reduced confusion, increased training opportunities, and elimination of administrative burden on pilots. ALPA supported the proposal, provided no passengers are carried on board and the purpose of the flight is to establish recency of experience. The FAA did not receive any opposing comments nor recommended changes.

Therefore, the FAA adopts § 61.57(e)(5) as proposed. The FAA notes that AOPA urged the FAA to reconsider its withdrawal of existing interpretations before the effective date of any final rule. As previously noted, these legal interpretations were, in fact, withdrawn prior to this final rule because they were unsupported by the regulations in place at that time. This final rule maintains the action taken in regard to the legal interpretations, but the adoption of new § 61.57(e)(5) will succinctly codify the circumstances in which a person receiving flight training may act as PIC, even if that person does not meet the recent flight experience requirements for carrying persons under § 61.57(a) or (b), curing any uncertainty caused by the rescission of the legal interpretations during the pendency of this rulemaking.

D. Flight Instructor Privileges (Sec. § 61.193 and 61.413)

D. Flight Instructor Privileges (Sec. § 61.193 and 61.413)

Sections 61.193 and 61.413 set forth the privileges of flight instructors and sport pilot instructors, respectively. Under Sec. § 61.193(a)(1) through (9) and 61.413(a)(1) through (9), an authorized flight instructor may train and provide endorsements required for certificates, ratings, operating privileges, recency of experience requirements, and tests. The areas do not currently address specific elective and specialized training activities that the FAA encourages but which are not required to meet FAA regulations.\32\ To conform those regulations with FAA policy and industry practice, the FAA proposed three amendments to Sec. § 61.193 and 61.413. First, the FAA proposed to modify the introductory text of Sec. § 61.193(a) and 61.413(a) to provide that authorized flight instructors may conduct ground and flight training, and certain checking events,\33\ in addition to issuing endorsements.

Second, the FAA proposed to add maintaining or improving skills for certificated pilots to the list of flight instructor privileges found in Sec. § 61.193(a)(7) and 61.413(a)(6) to succinctly provide that flight instructors are authorized to conduct certain specialized and elective training intended to advance a pilot's preexisting flying knowledge or skills but that may not require specific endorsements (i.e., not the initial development or building blocks of pilot knowledge).

Finally, the FAA proposed to add Sec. § 61.193(c) and 61.413(c) to limit the privileges afforded to authorized flight instructors under these provisions from permitting operations that would require an air carrier or operating certificate or specific authorization from the Administrator (e.g., solely providing transportation, conducting commercial air tours under the guise of flight training, or offering introductory or orientation flights to non-pilots who have no intention of or interest in continuing training toward a certificate or rating).\34\ Aside from permitting an authorized flight instructor to conduct certain checking events and training related to maintaining or improving skills for certificated pilots, the FAA did not propose to revise any other requirements within Sec. § 61.193 and 61.413.

\32\ For example, transition training to a new make and model for which a pilot is already rated but has never flown or lacks familiarity, and conventional instrumentation to technically advanced aircraft training. See 88 FR 41200 for additional discussion on additional recommended elective and training activities in practice that this final rule will now explicitly facilitate.

\33\ For example, instrument proficiency checks (IPC), night vision goggle proficiency checks (NVG), sport pilot proficiency checks, and part 141 checks.

\34\ For additional discussion on how the FAA will ascertain whether an operation is considered flight training, see 88 FR 41194 at 41201.

1. Summary of the Comments

1. Summary of the Comments

Two industry groups responded to the proposed revisions to flight instructor privileges. ALPA fully supported the proposal, citing that the changes encourage pilots to seek continuing instruction and elective training. AOPA broadly supported the proposal, similarly stating that the efforts would promote aviation safety by encouraging pilots to obtain elective flight training and incentivize flight instructors to provide such, but suggested certain revisions to the proposal. Specifically, AOPA, first, sought clarification on whether certain flight activities would be included in the proposed expansion of privileges and, second, urged the FAA to expand certain types of training beyond only pilot training aimed at maintaining and improving skills for certificated pilots.

First, AOPA recommended that the FAA specifically allow a flight instructor to train and provide endorsements as may be required by an insurer or an entity providing aircraft, such as a flying club or a Fixed Base Operator (FBO) authorized by an airport to provide services for general aviation. While AOPA ceded that these privileges may already be included in the proposed addition to Sec. § 61.193(a)(7) and 61.413(a)(6), AOPA requested that the FAA specifically clarify whether these activities are included within the privileges afforded to flight instructors to avoid confusion.

Additionally, AOPA agreed that elective flight training is highly beneficial to pilots with existing skills but emphasized that such training can be beneficial to any individual regardless of experience level and would not have a negative impact on safety. Specifically, AOPA cited the FAA's position in the preamble of the NPRM that the proposed modifications to Sec. § 61.193(a)(7) and 61.413(a)(6) are only available to "train[ ] pilots to maintain or advance preexisting skills, not the initial inception or development of pilot knowledge," stating that the FAA specifically notes that "[t]he proposed training does not contemplate learning basic flying skills, as in the case of a student pilot." \35\ AOPA asserted that a private pilot who has no intention of performing aerobatics could still learn potentially lifesaving information concerning aerodynamics and upset recovery by receiving training in aerobatics and that, similarly, a student pilot living in a mountainous area must receive training in mountain flying in the interests of safety.

AOPA concluded that these operations would be prohibited by the proposed rule.\36\ To this point, AOPA opined that the proposed rule would undermine the ability to inspire a new generation of pilots with introductory flights that go beyond basic flying skills, which would be stifled by experience level parameters, providing an example that individuals interested in receiving flight instruction, but who do not yet have a certificate, discover their interest in aviation after a training flight where an instructor could demonstrate more energetic maneuvers before inviting the student to take the controls. AOPA noted that the proposed rule does not adequately address legitimate safety rationale for the limitations and, rather, appears to only be related to the FAA's concern that an operator who should otherwise hold a commercial air tour authorization could try to disguise itself as a flight training provider.

\35\ See 88 FR 41194 at 41200.

\36\ The FAA notes that this is an erroneous conclusion, but further discusses these privileges in the immediately following section of this preamble.

2. FAA Response

In response to AOPA's request to clarify whether flight instructors are authorized to train and provide endorsements that may be required by an insurer or an entity providing an aircraft, the FAA notes that such training and endorsements are not necessarily precluded under the proposed amendments to Sec. § 61.193(a)(7) and 61.413(a)(6). Specifically, the proposed additions are general in nature, applying to any training to maintain or improve the skills of a certificated pilot, including specialized flight training that does not require an endorsement (e.g., transition training to ensure that certificated pilots are proficient and safe). Notably, the FAA does not have a regulatory requirement for a flight instructor to conduct a pilot checkout for insurance purposes, nor do the proposed amendments to the rule directly address insurance or other pilot checkouts required by industry.\37\ Rather, the amended rule could consider a pilot checkout to be flight training if flight training is given during the checkout.

2. FAA Response

Conversely, if no flight training is provided during the checkout, then the flight would not be considered instruction.\38\ Thus, the NPRM proposed (as adopted by this final rule) to permit flight instructors to provide elective training to maintain or improve the skills of certificated pilots and train and issue endorsements under part 61 that an insurer or entity providing an aircraft may require, provided the activity is not merely a pilot checkout that does not include training. If training to maintain or improve skills of a certificated pilot were to occur during an insurance checkout, the FAA would consider that training to be within the scope of the proposed rule. Notably, insurance is generally not regulated by the FAA, and, therefore, an explicit authorization is not appropriate to add into this final rule.

\37\ "Pilot checkout" is a general term used by the aviation industry to describe an event enabling a pilot to demonstrate competency in a specific aircraft before being allowed to fly an aircraft provided by another entity. For example, "pilot checkout" includes insurance checkouts (also called rental checkouts), which occur when aviation insurance companies and persons offering their aircraft for rent require a pilot to fly with an instructor prior to renting an aircraft for the first time, regardless of whether the pilot is technically qualified to operate the aircraft. This checkout affords the insurance company and owner of the aircraft an opportunity to have a pilot's skills evaluated as an additional layer of protection from aircraft damage.

\38\ See Legal Interpretation to Charles Walters (May 7, 2018), addressing the distinction between a checkout and training.

Furthermore, the FAA finds elective training such as aerobatic and mountain flying training beneficial for certificated pilots with existing skills; however, the FAA does not believe that such training would be beneficial to all individuals, regardless of experience level (i.e., persons who hold no pilot certificate). As discussed in the NPRM, the training contemplated under proposed Sec. § 61.193(a)(7) and 61.413(a)(6) is purposefully broad and may include transition training, aerobatic training, formation training, and mountain flying, none of which require an endorsement. Already-certificated pilots, in particular, may find training of this nature to be highly beneficial.

As stated in the NPRM, the proposed training did not contemplate learning basic flying skills, as in the case of a student pilot (in other words, the only population of pilots that may utilize Sec. § 61.193(a)(7) and 61.413(a)(6) are already-certificated pilots via the conditional language "of a certificated pilot"). The FAA has long recognized that the building block approach to flight training is the safest and most effective method to develop a learner's knowledge and skills.\39\ The traditional framework for a pilot follows an incremental path to build piloting skills through an iterative series of training activities with a flight instructor, accumulation of other flight experience, and successful completion of a practical test with an evaluator.

The FAA finds that individuals with little to no pilot knowledge, skills, or experience should become certificated pilots proficient in basic pilot skills before pursuing elective or specialized training activities because these activities require the trainee to at least possess the knowledge to safely operate the aircraft prior to engaging in more advanced skills. Specifically, persons will be required to possess at least a fundamental pilot certificate (e.g., recreational pilot certificate or sport-pilot certificate) to be eligible to receive this type of training, as these persons have demonstrated a level of proficiency to the FAA through the testing process. Individuals who are not pilots may not have a full awareness of the risks involved. For example, aerobatic skills training includes maneuvers that require application of advanced aerodynamic concepts, as well as the ability to manage aircraft speed, orientation, energy, and altitude to be performed safely.

Persons who do not hold a pilot certificate would likely not yet have the knowledge or skills necessary to perform these types of maneuvers and, further, have not yet demonstrated to the FAA through the certification process that they possess the minimum knowledge and skills to safely operate the aircraft in the NAS, even in non-aerobatic flight. Common flight instruction risks include pilot risks, aircraft risks, and environmental risks.\40\ Consequently, demonstrating complicated maneuvers prior to transferring the controls to a trainee not holding a pilot certificate increases safety risks and potentially undermines mentoring of risk management concepts.

Risk management should be mentored and taught at the very start of flight training and should be integrated into any flight training.\41\ Since using the building block method of instruction based on prior lessons learned is the safest and most effective method to elevate a learner's knowledge and skills, the FAA does not consider demonstrating or teaching more advanced skills (e.g., aerobatic maneuvers) an appropriate building block of instruction for initial flight training for non-certificated pilots.

\39\ See Airplane Flying Handbook (FAA-H-8083-3C), Chapter 1, p 1-7, Paragraph 1: Introduction, for discussion on the building block method of instruction.

\40\ For example, pilot risks associated with flight instruction may include instructor, trainee, and aeromedical risks. Although a trainee will generally be less proficient than the instructor and may react unexpectedly, instructors may have qualification, currency, and proficiency issues. Additionally, the state of both the instructor and trainee's medical health, inadequate rest prior to flight, or illness are sources of potential risk. Aircraft risks increase if the instructor is not aware of inoperative systems and equipment or overdue aircraft inspections. Environmental risks may include risks generated by the weather, terrain, and night operation hazards, and also include airports, airspaces, and other environmental factors. See Instructor's Handbook (FAA-H-8083-9) Chapter 10, p 10-6 & 10-7: Common Flight Instruction Risks.

\41\ Aviation Instructor's Handbook (FAA-H-8083-9) Chapter 10, p 10-2: Teaching Practical Risk Management during Flight Instruction.

For these reasons, the FAA declines to expand the privileges of flight instructors to include elective or specialized training to non-certificated pilots and finds this limitation would not undermine the ability to inspire a new generation of pilots, as flight training pathways for new pilots already exist in the airman certification framework. In response to AOPA's comment that the limitations on the proposed expansion of flight instructor privileges appear to only be related to the FAA's concerns that an operator who should otherwise hold a commercial air tour authorization could disguise itself as a flight training provider, the FAA reiterates that, as discussed, the rationale for these limitations is based on public and trainee safety needs, lack of potential risk awareness, and the additional risks discussed herein and in the NPRM. In the absence of any safety data or documented safety cases to support a claim that an individual at any experience level benefits from such advanced training activities, the FAA declines to expand the proposed revisions to Sec. § 61.193(a)(7) and 61.413(a)(6).

After considering comments, the FAA adopts the revisions to Sec. § 61.193 and 61.413 as proposed in the NPRM to clarify the privileges an authorized flight instructor may exercise.

E. Flight Training Is Carrying a Person for Compensation or Hire

The FAA's proposal reinforced its longstanding position that, although excepted from the part 119 requirement to obtain an air carrier or commercial operator certificate, compensated flight training in limited, experimental, and primary category aircraft is an operation that involves the carriage of a person for compensation or hire. Specifically, as discussed at length in the NPRM,\42\ the restrictions on operating aircraft that hold special airworthiness certificates carrying people for compensation or hire recently came under review as a result of an emergency cease and desist order issued to Warbird Adventures, Inc. by the FAA in 2020.\43\ Following the court's dismissal of the petition for review of the cease and desist order, the FAA, first, published a Notification of Policy in the Federal Register laying out its position that when compensation is provided for flight training, it is contrary to the prohibition on operating an aircraft carrying a person for compensation or hire even when no compensation is provided for the use of the aircraft \44\ and, second, announced it would rescind conflicting agency guidance. Additionally, the announcement memorialized the intention to consider a future rulemaking to remove obstacles to flight training for owners of aircraft with certain special airworthiness certificates while maintaining prohibitions on broadly offering these aircraft for flight training to the public (i.e., this rulemaking).

E. Flight Training Is Carrying a Person for Compensation or Hire

\42\ 88 FR 41194 at 41201.

\43\ Warbird Adventures, Inc. v. Fed. Aviation Admin., Petition for Review from an Emergency Cease and Desist Order Issued by the Federal Aviation Administration on July 28, 2020, Doc. No. 1854466 (D.C. Cir. 2020).

\44\ Notification of Policy for Flight Training in Certain Aircraft, 86 FR 36493 (Jul. 12, 2021).

In proposing this rulemaking, the FAA noted conflicts between the general prohibitions in Sec. § 91.315, 91.319, and 91.325 (applicable to limited category, experimental, and primary category aircraft, respectively) and operating limitations placed on these aircraft during the aircraft certification process, legal interpretations, and guidance related to the carriage of persons or property aboard these aircraft during operations involving compensation or hire. Specifically, the FAA detailed that terms within these regulations are either broadly defined (e.g., operate,\45\ person \46\) or have been broadly interpreted over time (e.g., compensation \47\), resulting in obstacles to certain flight training that the FAA did not intend.

\45\ With respect to an aircraft, the word "operate" is broadly defined in § 1.1 as "use, cause to use or authorize to use aircraft, for the purpose (except as provided in § 91.13 of this chapter) of air navigation including the piloting of aircraft, with or without the right of legal control (as owner, lessee, or otherwise)." As explained in the NPRM, an aircraft may be "operated" by more than one person for purposes of part 91 regulations. See 88 FR 41194 at 41202.

\46\ Pursuant to § 1.1, "person" is defined as an individual, firm, partnership, corporation, company, association, joint-stock association, or governmental entity. It includes a trustee, receiver, assignee, or similar representative of any of them.

\47\ See Legal Interpretation to Joseph Kirwan (May 27, 2005). Compensation "does not require a profit, a profit motive, or the actual payment of funds." Rather, compensation is the receipt of anything of value. See also Legal Interpretation to John W. Harrington (Oct. 23, 1997); Blakey v. Murray, NTSB Order No. EA-5061 (Oct. 28, 2003). The FAA has previously found that reimbursement of expenses (fuel, oil, transportation, lodging, meals, etc.), accumulation of flight time, and goodwill in the form of expected future economic benefit could be considered compensation.

Therefore, the proposed rule sought to narrow and more clearly define the types of operations that are precluded in aircraft holding certain special airworthiness certificates by refining the regulatory language in Sec. § 91.315, 91.319,\48\ and 91.325 to clearly define operations that would generally require an air carrier or commercial operator certificate (or an exception therefrom), while explicitly enabling flight training, checking, and testing. Specifically, except as provided in proposed § 91.326 (which is further discussed in this preamble), the proposed amendments would prohibit conducting operations that: (1) require an air carrier or commercial operator certificate issued under part 119; (2) are listed in § 119.1(e); (3) require management specifications for a fractional ownership program issued in accordance with subpart K of part 91; or (4) are conducted under part 129, 133, or 137. Similarly, the NPRM proposed to amend § 91.327 to be inclusive of checking and testing in aircraft having a special airworthiness certificate in the light-sport category, where it previously only enabled flight training, through paragraph (a)(2).

\48\ The FAA notes that the NPRM proposed a miscellaneous, nonsubstantive amendment to § 91.319(d)(3) to use "air traffic control" in place of "control tower." The FAA did not receive comment on this proposal and adopts the revision as proposed.

1. Summary of the Comments

AOPA supported the FAA's efforts to clarify the operating limitations of limited, experimental, and primary category aircraft but argued that the premise for these changes is based on the flawed conclusion that flight instruction categorically equates to the carriage of persons for compensation or hire. AOPA explained that the FAA has repeatedly held that compensated flight instruction does not equal to the carriage of persons for compensation or hire, providing several examples. First, AOPA detailed a 1992 final rule for the establishment of primary category aircraft as specifically permitting the use of primary category aircraft for flight instruction while simultaneously prohibiting the carriage of passengers or property for compensation or hire.\49\ Second, AOPA stated that a 1997 final rule explained why a flight instructor acting as PIC need only hold a third-class medical certificate to conduct flight instruction by stating "a certificated flight instructor who is acting as pilot in command or as a required flight crewmember and receiving compensation for his or her flight instruction is not carrying passengers or property for compensation or hire, nor is he or she, for compensation or hire, acting as pilot in command of an aircraft." \50\ Third, AOPA cited Congress as recognizing that flight training is not considered to be carrying a passenger for compensation or hire when it enacted section 2307 of the FAA Extension, Safety, and Security Act of 2016, a position the FAA agreed with when it promulgated the "BasicMed" regulations implementing this law.\51\

1. Summary of the Comments

\49\ See Primary Category final rule, 57 FR 41360 (Sep. 9, 1992).

\50\ Pilot, Flight Instructor, Ground Instructor, and Pilot School Certification Rules final rule, 62 FR 16220, 16242 (Apr. 4, 1997).

\51\ AOPA specifically quoted, "The FAA has found that, in conducting flight training, the PIC is not carrying passengers or property for compensation or hire, nor is acting as PIC of an aircraft for compensation or hire," from the BasicMed final rule. See Alternative Pilot Physical Examination and Education Requirements final rule, 82 FR 3149 at 3155 (Jan. 11, 2017).

Therefore, AOPA recommended that the FAA adopt regulations specifically clarifying that flight instruction does not equate to the carriage of persons or property for compensation or hire. In addition, AOPA referenced section 243 of proposed H.R. 3935.\52\ Likewise, AOPA argued that since the FAA views all compensated flight instruction as carrying a person for compensation or hire, every aircraft used for compensated flight instruction must comply with § 91.409(b), which contains aircraft inspection requirements, regardless of whether the aircraft is provided by the flight instructor. AOPA further explained that, based on the FAA's new proposed interpretation in the NPRM, the second condition in § 91.409(b), under which a 100-hour inspection is required, is meaningless. Finally, AOPA noted that this interpretation would effectively prohibit a flight instructor from providing instruction for formation flying since § 91.111(c) prohibits any person from operating an aircraft carrying passengers for hire in formation flight.

\52\ Section 243 of H.R.3935, Securing Growth and Robust Leadership in American Aviation Act, proposed that the FAA adopt the position that an authorized flight instructor providing student instruction, flight instruction, or flight training shall not be deemed to be operating an aircraft carrying persons or property for compensation or hire. However, this section was not enacted as part of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024, Public Law 118-63.

2. FAA Response

2. FAA Response

The FAA declines to align with AOPA's position that flight instruction does not equate to the carriage of persons or property for compensation or hire. The FAA maintains the position that flight training for compensation constitutes carriage of a person for compensation or hire but adopts this final rule to specifically define types of operations under which persons or property could be carried for compensation or hire (including certain flight training). The FAA notes that in its comment, AOPA used the terms "carriage of persons" and "carriage of passengers" interchangeably. In recent related litigation, the FAA explained its position that "persons" is a broader term than "passengers" and specified that the FAA has consistently drawn a distinction between regulations that refer to the carriage of passengers and the carriage of persons.\53\ Additionally, in the litigation, the FAA stated, "[it] has consistently drawn a distinction between regulations that refer to the carriage of passengers, which the FAA does not interpret to include flight students, and those that prohibit the carriage of persons, which the FAA interprets to include any person, including flight students."

\53\ The history of § 91.315 confirms that the regulation prohibits the carriage of persons in exchange for compensation for any purpose, including flight training. As originally enacted, that regulation contained language that only authorized flights "in which neither passengers nor cargo are carried for compensation or hire." However, § 91.315 has been amended several times to expand the regulation to prohibit the carriage of "persons" and not just "passengers." Notably, the FAA does not interpret its regulations prohibiting the carriage of passengers to consider flight students as passengers. However, the FAA interprets its regulations prohibiting the carriage of persons to include any person, including flight students. The decision to expand § 91.315's predecessor regulation to prohibit the carriage of persons, not just passengers, for compensation or hire therefore supports the distinction between carriage of persons and carriage of passengers. See Warbird Adventures, Inc. v. Fed. Aviation Admin., 2020 WL 7260623 (C.A.D.C.) (Appellate Brief).

Regarding AOPA's reference to section 243 of H.R. 3935 for guidance, the FAA notes that the cited proposed legislative language was not enacted.\54\ Without a congressional mandate, the FAA does not intend to adopt any regulation specifying flight instruction does not equate to the carriage of persons or property for compensation or hire. The FAA notes that AOPA's recommendation is incongruent with a recent court ruling, wherein the court determined that: "A flight student is a `person.' Id. § 91.315; see also id. § 1.1. When a student is learning to fly in an airplane, the student is `carried.' Id. § 91.315. And when the student is paying for the instruction, the student is being carried `for compensation.' " \55\

\54\ Public Law 118-63, the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024, did not contain the language referenced in AOPA's comment.

\55\ Warbird Adventures, Inc. v. Fed. Aviation Admin., 843 F. App'x 331 (D.C. Cir. 2021).

The FAA also disagrees with AOPA's interpretation of § 91.409(b). Section 91.409 sets forth certain inspection requirements. Paragraph (b) requires, in pertinent part, that, except as provided in § 91.409(c),\56\ no person may operate an aircraft carrying any person (other than a crewmember) for hire, and no person may give flight instruction for hire in an aircraft which that person provides, unless within the preceding 100 hours of time in service the aircraft has received an annual or 100-hour inspection and been approved for return to service in accordance with part 43 or has received an inspection for the issuance of an airworthiness certificate in accordance with part 21. The FAA's position and § 91.409(b) are not contradictory. Rather, the regulation provides specificity to the inspection expectations when a person only provides flight instruction compared to when a person provides both flight instruction and the aircraft. Specifically, the regulation intends that, despite the requirement for a 100-hour inspection when any person is carried for hire, a 100-hour inspection is only required for flight training when the person giving the instruction for hire also provides the aircraft.\57\ While the FAA cedes that the regulation could have been more strongly written, and may consider a revision in a separate rulemaking to except circumstances rather than affirmatively stating such, this position has been explicitly reiterated in Legal Interpretations.\58\

\56\ Section 91.409(b) does not apply to (1) an aircraft that carries a special flight permit, a current experimental certificate, or a light-sport or provisional airworthiness certificate; (2) an aircraft inspected in accordance with an approved aircraft inspection program under part 125 or 135 and so identified by the registration number in the operations specifications of the certificate holder having the approved inspection program; (3) an aircraft subject to the requirements of § 91.409(d) and (e); or (4) turbine-powered rotorcraft when the operator elects to inspect that rotorcraft in accordance with § 91.409(e).

\57\ See Part 91--General Operating and Flight Rules, 35 FR 4116 (March 5, 1970) which clarified that the caveat "in an aircraft which that person provides" was added to clarify the 100-hour inspection requirement for the flight instruction for hire was intended for those instances in which the person providing flight instruction for hire also provides the aircraft in which the instruction is given. The preamble indicates this clarification was needed because the regulation had been misunderstood by many people to mean that they could not receive flight instruction in an aircraft owned or leased by them if the flight instructor received compensation for their services unless the aircraft had met the 100-hour inspection requirement.

\58\ E.g., Legal Interpretation to Greenwood-Fly by Knight (Oct. 1, 2014) (reiterated in Greenwood-Fly by Knight, Oct. 9, 2015).

AOPA's concern that a flight instructor would be prohibited from providing instruction for formation flying has been addressed by the addition of the definition of "passenger" in § 61.1 as part of this final rule, as discussed in more detail in the subsequent section of this preamble. While AOPA noted that § 91.111(c) generally prohibits any person from operating an aircraft carrying passengers for hire in formation flights, the FAA has excluded persons providing or receiving flight training from its definition of "passenger" in § 61.1.\59\ Therefore, formation flight training will not be prohibited in accordance with this final rule.

\59\ The FAA notes that the definitions set forth in § 61.1 are for the purpose of part 61 (see § 61.1(b)). However, for purposes of airman certification and training, it is common practice to apply certain part 61 definitions to related certification and training parts and sections within Title 14 (e.g., part 61 definitional application of "authorized instructor" to part 141). The FAA contemplated a global definition for "passenger," but does not find it appropriate at this time to memorialize the definition of "passenger" in part 1 to apply to all of Title 14 due to the possible unintended and unstudied repercussions in other parts that would be out of scope for this rulemaking. In this case, it will be FAA policy to apply the part 61 definition of "passenger" to § 91.111(c) because the formation training is taking place during a part 61 flight training event. As previously stated in this preamble, the training contemplated under Sec. § 61.193(a)(7) and 61.413(a)(6) may include formation training.

For these reasons, this final rule does not make any revisions based on AOPA's comments regarding the carriage of persons for compensation or hire as it relates to compensated flight training.

F. New Definition of Passenger (§ 61.1(b)) and Related Changes (§ 61.57)

Although the FAA has not previously defined "passenger" in regulation, the NPRM analyzed the FAA's historical interpretation of the term. Previous FAA legal interpretations \60\ have stated that a flight instructor and a person receiving flight training are not considered passengers to one another. However, the NPRM concluded that those FAA legal interpretations had no regulatory basis to assert such a position, and the FAA has since rescinded those interpretations. While the NPRM did not assert that a flight instructor and a person receiving flight training are not passengers to one another, it sought to clarify when certain operations involving such persons may be conducted.

F. New Definition of Passenger (§ 61.1(b)) and Related Changes (§ 61.57)

\60\ Legal Interpretation to Kris Kortokrax (Aug. 22, 2006), concluding that a flight instructor who has not met the recent night takeoff and landing experience in § 61.57(b) should be able to accompany a pilot without being considered a passenger; Legal Interpretation to Roger Schaffner (May 5, 2014), concluding that a flight instructor with an expired medical certificate may instruct a person who is a private pilot with a current medical certificate and flight review, even if that person is not current to carry passengers per § 61.57(a) because the instructor is not considered a passenger when the instructor is present specifically to train the person receiving instruction.

1. Summary of the Comments

1. Summary of the Comments

AOPA asserted that the FAA does not offer a reasoned explanation to depart from the established view that a flight instructor and a trainee are not passengers to one another. According to AOPA, the FAA indicated in the NPRM that decades of its own policy and interpretations are incorrect. AOPA argued that the FAA failed to consider the plain meaning of the term "passenger," which it defines from two legal dictionaries as "an occupant of a vehicle other than the person operating it or a member of the crew." AOPA contended that because both instructor and trainee are operating the aircraft, each may be considered a crewmember and neither meets the plain meaning of the term "passenger." Therefore, AOPA urged the FAA to retain the referenced legal interpretations,\61\ conform the regulatory framework to reflect current policy and industry practice, and adopt a single regulation clarifying that an authorized flight instructor providing instruction to a trainee is not considered a passenger to the trainee, and vice versa.\62\

\61\ AOPA noted the lack of upkeep of the FAA's legal interpretation database, stating that these legal interpretations were withdrawn as of July 23, 2023, but at the time of their comment submission on September 18, 2023, still existed on the legal interpretation database. AOPA stated that, in general, the interpretation database is difficult to use and search terms do not generate accurate responses. AOPA strongly recommended that the FAA take steps to more effectively monitor and control its legal interpretation database so that it remains an accurate resource. The FAA continuously works to keep the legal interpretation database up to date and notes that members of the public can also refer to the Dynamic Regulatory System to review current FAA legal interpretations at drs.faa.gov.

\62\ Specifically, AOPA cited the Kortokrax, Olshock, and Schaffner legal interpretations, which were withdrawn on July 23, 2023. 88 FR 41194, 41199. AOPA described a primary concern with the interim period between the withdrawal of the legal interpretations and final rule implementation. Specifically, AOPA posited that to withdraw these interpretations without first ensuring a clear framework is in place, whether it be regulatory or policy, poses a significant aviation safety concern because pilots and flight instructors who do not meet the recent flight experience requirements of § 61.57(a) and (b) will struggle to find a safe solution. The FAA acknowledges AOPA's concern, which is cured by virtue of this final rule.

2. FAA Response

2. FAA Response

The FAA agrees with AOPA's comment that the regulations could better delineate the relationship between students and instructors. As stated in the NPRM, longstanding FAA legal interpretations have clarified that students and instructors are not considered passengers to one another. While the FAA ceded there was no regulatory basis upon which to make this assertion, the FAA finds this rulemaking to be the optimal opportunity to explicitly define "passenger" through a regulatory definition. As such, for the purposes of part 61, the FAA does not consider crewmembers, FAA personnel, manufacturer personnel required for type certification, or persons engaged in flight training, flightcrew member checking, or flightcrew member testing to be passengers. These groups are not considered passengers because they are onboard the aircraft for specific purposes, generally to fulfill regulatory obligations, and possess knowledge of the risks associated with those purposes (e.g., flight test engineers) or some sort of certification (e.g., an airman certificate). Conversely, persons on board an aircraft to receive a ride (whether transported from place to place or for other purposes like sightseeing, air tours, or persons carried to conduct aerial photography) would be considered passengers.

Notably, the FAA considered implementing AOPA's recommendation to adopt a single regulation explaining that an authorized flight instructor providing instruction and a trainee are not considered passengers to one another. However, the FAA found that a single regulation that narrowly defines the relationship between students and instructors would not address the carriage of other persons, such as crewmembers, FAA personnel, or manufacturer personnel required for type certification when the pilot is operating for compensation. Therefore, adopting AOPA's recommendation would not provide a sufficiently broad regulatory solution to clarify the term "passenger." The term "passenger" is frequently used in varying contexts throughout part 61, and the FAA finds that one definition of the term applicable to all of part 61 provides the requisite clarity to prevent multiple interpretations of the term.

Therefore, this final rule adopts a new definition in § 61.1(b) to define "passenger" as any person on board an aircraft other than a crewmember, FAA personnel, manufacturer personnel required for type certification, or a person providing or receiving flight training, flightcrew member checking, or flightcrew member testing as authorized by part 61.\63\ This new definition applies to the term "passenger" as it is used in part 61.\64\

\63\ Flightcrew member is defined in 14 CFR 1.1 as a pilot, flight engineer, or flight navigator assigned to duty in an aircraft during flight time. Minimum flightcrew requirements are established at the time of type certification in the Type Certificate Data Sheet, operational regulation (e.g., part 121 or 135), or as otherwise prescribed by the certificating authority of the country of registry.

\64\ 14 CFR 61.1(b).

To effectuate this change, the FAA evaluated all instances of the use of the term "passenger" in part 61 to ensure accuracy and consistency (i.e., to ensure that the new definition of passenger would not create an unintended consequence). While this evaluation identified other parts of the CFR that reference the definitions in § 61.1, only § 61.57 requires a conforming amendment. Because the FAA is defining "passenger" to exclude a flight instructor and trainee (in other words, memorializing that a trainee will not be a passenger to the flight instructor and vice versa), the use of the word "passenger" in current § 61.57(a)(1) and (b)(1) could be applied more broadly to create a scenario where a flight instructor who does not have the required recent flight experience could carry a trainee who is not yet capable to act as PIC.

Specifically, § 61.57(a)(1) sets forth that, except as provided in § 61.57(e), no person may act as PIC of an aircraft carrying passengers or of an aircraft certificated for more than one pilot flight crewmember unless that person has made at least three takeoffs and three landings within the preceding 90 days characterized by certain conditions.\65\ Because the new definition of "passenger" in § 61.1 includes (in pertinent part to this issue) any person on board an aircraft other than a person receiving or providing flight training, checking, or testing, under current application of the new definition with no revision to § 61.57(a)(1), a flight instructor could act as PIC of an aircraft without meeting the PIC recent flight experience requirements of § 61.57(a) because the trainee would not be a passenger.

Similar recent flight experience is promulgated in § 61.57(b), requiring certain night takeoff and landing experience before a person may act as PIC of an aircraft carrying passengers during the period beginning 1 hour after sunset and ending 1 hour before sunrise, subject to certain conditions and exceptions,\66\ which would result in the same safety concern. Although this final rule is enabling a situation where a flight instructor may be on board an aircraft with another pilot, neither of whom has met the recent flight experience requirements, the risk is mitigated by the fact that both persons are otherwise qualified to operate the aircraft. If the same flight instructor were to act as PIC of an aircraft carrying a flight student who is not an otherwise qualified pilot, the risk is increased because, in the event of an emergency, only one person is capable of operating the aircraft, rather than two, and the sole person capable of operating does not have the benefit of recent flight experience (in other words, certain proficiencies may have degraded over time due to disuse).

\65\ See § 61.57(a)(1)(i) and (ii).

\66\ See § 61.57(b)(1)(i) and (ii) and (e).

Additionally, this change necessitates an addition to the list of exceptions set forth in § 61.57(e) to include an exception for an examiner and an applicant during the conduct of a practical test to preserve the regulatory authority granted by § 61.47(c). Section 61.47(c) enables a scenario in which a practical test could be conducted when neither the examiner nor the person receiving the practical test has met the recent flight experience requirements of § 61.57(a) or (b) because it explicitly states that those persons are not subject to the requirements or limitations for the carriage of passengers that are specified in 14 CFR chapter I. Because § 61.57(a) and (b), as currently written, apply to "passenger," § 61.47(c) functions to except the examiner and the person receiving the practical test from the requirements set forth in § 61.57(a) and (b).

Although uncommon, there could be a scenario where neither an examiner nor the person receiving the practical test has met the recent flight experience requirements of § 61.57(a) or (b); however, the test can still be safely conducted because there are other proficiency requirements for examiners and applicants. For example, examiners must meet PIC experience requirements every 12 months to maintain eligibility to conduct practical tests.\67\ Likewise, applicants for a practical test must meet certain prerequisite aeronautical experience requirements.\68\ With this final rule, the FAA maintains the position that a designee and an applicant for a practical test can conduct the test without meeting the requirements of § 61.57(a) and (b). To facilitate this position in light of the change from "passengers" to "persons" in § 61.57(a) and (b), the exception adopted in this final rule as new § 61.57(e)(6) specifies that paragraphs (a) and (b) do not apply to the examiner or the applicant during the conduct of a practical test required by part 61.

The FAA emphasizes that this new provision simply maintains the status quo for examiners and applicants during practical tests.

\67\ See FAA Order 8000.95C, Designee Management Policy, Chapter 5, Table 3-9.

\68\ See Sec. § 61.99(a)(1)(ii), 61.109(a)(4), and 61.129(a)(3)(v) which require an applicant for a recreational, private, and commercial certificate, respectively, to obtain three hours of aeronautical experience with an authorized instructor in preparation for the practical test within the preceding 2 calendar months from the month of the test.

Therefore, this final rule modifies § 61.57(a)(1) and (b)(1) to change the word "passengers" to "persons" to limit those who may be on board to the specific exceptions identified in § 61.57(e), which includes a new exception for instructors and trainees in certain circumstances.

G. Experimental Light-Sport Aircraft (§ 91.319(e))

G. Experimental Light-Sport Aircraft (§ 91.319(e))

Section 91.319(e) contains specific limitations on the use of certain experimental aircraft certificated under § 21.191(i)(1). The NPRM proposed to modify § 91.319(e)(2) to remove the date restriction on flight training in experimental light-sport aircraft (ELSA) and direct stakeholders to the flight training, checking, and testing in proposed § 91.326, thus enabling flight training in certain ELSA. In addition, the NPRM proposed to modify § 91.319(f)(2) to allow a person receiving flight training to lease certain ELSA for the purpose of accomplishing solo flight and a practical test in accordance with a training program included in the deviation authority authorized in accordance with proposed § 91.326(b). The proposed revisions were intended to increase the availability of light-sport aircraft for training and aid individuals who wish to train in the type of aircraft they operate. 1. Summary of the Comments

Two commenters, Aero Sports Connection Inc. (ASC) and EAA, supported changes to § 91.319(e), but with conditions. The FAA received no opposing comments related to the proposed changes to § 91.319(e).

EAA supported the proposed rule language in § 91.319(e)(2) to remove the sunset date for experimental aircraft, citing the amendment as an essential step toward reversing the net effect of eliminating training opportunities due to the low volume of S-LSAs and exclusion of E-LSAs. However, EAA noted the proposed rule change does not modify the language in § 91.319(e) that specifies eligibility is limited to ELSA certificated under § 21.191(i)(1). EAA explained that, while this proposed change increases the pool of available light aircraft for training, it excludes flight training, checking, and testing in ELSA certificated under § 21.191(i)(2) and (3) (i.e., kit-built ELSA and ELSA previously issued a special airworthiness certificate in the light-sport category (SLSA) under § 21.190, respectively). EAA asserted that since both of these certification pathways begin with conformity to ASTM International standards,\69\ while the "grandfathered" aircraft do not, EAA cannot contemplate a safety case for excluding these aircraft from training or glider towing. EAA suggested removal of introductory text in § 91.319(e) functioning to limit the exception to only those aircraft issued an experimental certificate under § 21.191(i)(1).\70\

\69\ In this context, "ASTM" refers to the American Society for Testing and Materials.

\70\ EAA also referenced a simultaneous FAA rulemaking, Modernization of Special Airworthiness Certification, 88 FR 47650 (Jul. 24, 2023) (Docket No. FAA-2023-1377) and expressed support for a future amendment to § 91.319(e)(2) to accommodate kit-built E-LSAs if MOSAIC's proposal to move certification language on kit-built E-LSA aircraft from § 21.191(i)(2) to § 21.191(j) finalizes.

ASC proposed to add a privilege for sport pilots to offer "transition-for-hire" training in a subgroup of light sport aircraft ASC describes as high drag/low mass aircraft with a stall speed less than 39 mph. ASC labeled this subgroup as "Lighter Sport Aircraft, or LrSA." ASC further clarified that the proposed training would be limited to take-off, minimum controllable airspeed, and landing, and that this training would not be applicable to the student's next flight certificate. ASC asserted that the need for this type of training was generated because of the 2004 final rule related to light sport aircraft.\71\ ASC described a dearth of available LrSA and instructors because of the new rule, which forced LrSA previously authorized for flight training by exemption to register as ELSA. The newly-registered ELSA aircraft were prohibited from flight training operations after 2010 in accordance with § 91.319(e)(2). To resolve the perceived dearth of available LrSA aircraft and instructors, ASC proposed to modify sport pilot privileges to enable the previously described transition-for-hire training without the requirement to hold a flight instructor certificate or Sport Pilot flight instructor certificate.

\71\ Certification of Aircraft and Airmen for the Operation of Light-Sport Aircraft, 69 FR 44772 (July 27, 2004).

2. FAA Response

Although the FAA will enable compensated flight training in certain aircraft holding special airworthiness certificates with this final rule, including experimental light sport aircraft, the FAA did not propose changes to sport pilot regulations or aircraft described by ASC as "LrSA" in the NPRM. For this reason, the changes recommended in the comment are outside the scope of this rulemaking.

2. FAA Response

While the FAA proposed to revise certain paragraphs within § 91.319, it did not propose to revise the introductory language of § 91.319(e), which states that no person may operate an aircraft issued an experimental certificate under § 21.191(i) for compensation or hire, except a person may operate an aircraft issued an experimental certificate only under § 21.191(i)(1) in certain scenarios (i.e., the exceptions set forth in standing paragraph (e)(1) and proposed paragraph (e)(2)). As noted by EAA's comment, the FAA did not propose to include those aircraft certificated under § 21.191(i)(2) (light-sport aircraft that has been assembled from an aircraft kit and is in accordance with manufacturer's assembly instructions that meet an applicable consensus standard) or § 21.191(i)(3) (has previously been issued a special airworthiness certificate in the light-sport category under § 21.190). Originally, the removal of the date restriction in § 91.319(e)(2) was part of another rule.\72\ When that rule was absorbed into this current rule, the FAA attempted to remain consistent with the original rule, which did not include changes to the introductory language of § 91.319(e).

\72\ Removal of the Date Restriction for Flight Training in Experimental Light Sport Aircraft, NPRM, 83 FR 53590 (Oct. 24, 2018). Removal of the Date Restriction for Flight Training in Experimental Light Sport Aircraft; Withdrawal, 88 FR 41045 (Jun. 23, 2023).

However, the FAA agrees with EAA's suggestion to broaden the scope of aircraft available for flight training, flightcrew member checking, or flightcrew member testing (i.e., operations under § 91.326) and, therefore, this final rule revises § 91.319(e)(2) to be inclusive of aircraft certificated under § 21.191(i) as a whole. ELSA certificated under § 21.191(i)(2) and (3) either meet an applicable consensus standard or met such a standard previously, indicating the presence of standards for aircraft design and performance, required equipment, manufacturer quality assurance systems, production acceptance test procedures, operating instructions, maintenance and inspection procedures, identification and recording of major repairs and major alterations, and continued airworthiness.\73\ This consensus standard ascertains a comprehensive quality of the aircraft such that the FAA finds no reason it should be excluded from these operations.

\73\ See 14 CFR 1.1 definition of "consensus standard."

The FAA notes that the proposal did not contain any revisions to the various provisions within part 91 related to towing operations.\74\ Utilizing ELSA certificated under § 21.191(i)(2) or (3) for compensated glider towing is outside the scope of this rule, particularly at the final rule stage where the FAA has neither had an opportunity to analyze towing regulations, aircraft, and safety considerations, nor solicit comments on changes to such operations.

\74\ Examples of towing provisions in part 91 include § 91.309, which provides requirements for the towing of a glider or unpowered ultralight vehicle, and § 91.311, which provides requirements for towing vehicles not covered under § 91.309.

Accordingly, this final rule modifies § 91.319(e) to include aircraft certificated under § 21.191, as a whole, for use in flight training and other operations set forth by the new § 91.326. Specifically, this final rule revises § 91.319(e) to state that no person may operate a light-sport aircraft that is issued an experimental certificate under § 21.191 for compensation or hire with two exceptions. Under revised § 91.319(e)(1), a person will be able to operate an aircraft issued an experimental certificate under § 21.191(i)(1) to tow a glider that is a light-sport aircraft or unpowered ultralight vehicle in accordance with § 91.309 (i.e., the status quo, as these revisions are largely editorial in nature only). Additionally, revised § 91.319(e)(2) will permit a person to operate an aircraft issued an experimental certificate under § 21.191 to conduct operations authorized under § 91.326. The FAA did not receive any comments related to the proposed change to § 91.319(f), (f)(1), and (f)(2) and adopts those changes as proposed.

H. Exception To Operating Certain Aircraft for the Purposes of Flight Training, Flightcrew Member Checking, or Flightcrew Member Testing (§ 91.326)

H. Exception To Operating Certain Aircraft for the Purposes of Flight Training, Flightcrew Member Checking, or Flightcrew Member Testing (§ 91.326)

Currently, Sec. § 91.315, 91.319, and 91.325 prohibit operating limited category, experimental, and primary category aircraft carrying persons or property for compensation or hire; these regulations generally prohibit flight training, checking, and testing when compensation is provided. As discussed in the NPRM,\75\ aircraft owners seeking to receive flight training in their own personal-use experimental aircraft, and flight instructors providing that training for compensation, applied for a LODA through a streamlined process. However, section 5604 of the 2023 NDAA contains a provision that removes the LODA requirement for flight training, testing, and checking in experimental aircraft under certain conditions while prohibiting an authorized instructor from providing both the training and the aircraft.\76\

\75\ 88 FR 41194 at 41208.

\76\ Public Law 117-263.

To effectuate the provisions of the NDAA into the regulations, in the NPRM, the FAA proposed to add § 91.326 to delineate the requirements related to flight training, checking, and testing in certain aircraft holding limited category, primary category, and experimental airworthiness certificates. The proposed language in § 91.326(a) would specify activities not requiring a LODA (i.e., codification of the legislation): those operations for the purpose of flight training, checking, or testing provided the authorized instructor is not providing both the training and the aircraft; no person advertises or broadly offers the aircraft as available for flight training, checking, or testing; and no person receives compensation for the use of the aircraft for a specific flight during which flight training, checking, or testing was received, other than expenses for owning, operating, and maintaining the aircraft. To note, the proposal included limited category and primary category aircraft, in addition to experimental aircraft, because the safety justification for enabling these activities equally applied. Proposed § 91.326(b) would identify operations requiring a LODA (flight training, checking, or testing in a limited category or experimental aircraft except as provided in proposed § 91.326(a) and (c)), and prescribe the application framework and administrative process. Proposed § 91.326(c) would function to sunset all LODAs issued under current § 91.319(h) (which this final rule reserves, as operations requiring a LODA will move to new § 91.326).

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 256 passages shown