Radar Vectors
Final Rule Current Issued Oct 7, 2005 36 pages Copy saved Nov 17, 2026

70 FR 58796 Hazardous Materials Training Requirements

The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) is amending its hazardous materials (hazmat) training requirements for certain air carriers and commercial operators. In addition, the FAA is requiring that certain repair stations provide documentation showing that persons handling hazmat for transportation have been trained, as required by the Department of Transportation's Hazardous Materials Regulations (HMRs). The FAA is updating its regulations because hazmat transportation and the aviation industry have changed significantly since the FAA promulgated its hazmat regulations over 25 years ago. The rule will set clear hazmat training standards and ensure uniform compliance with hazmat training requirements.

Official source ↗ Official PDF ↗

Part II

14 CFR Parts 119, 121, 135, and 145

Hazardous Materials Training Requirements; Final Rule

and Regulations DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

14 CFR Parts 119, 121, 135, and 145

[Docket No.: FAA-2003-15085; Amendment Nos. 119-10, 121-316, 135-101, 145-24] RIN 2120-AG75

Hazardous Materials Training Requirements

Agency

AGENCY: Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), DOT.

ACTION: Final rule.

SUMMARY: The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) is amending its hazardous materials (hazmat) training requirements for certain air carriers and commercial operators. In addition, the FAA is requiring that certain repair stations provide documentation showing that persons handling hazmat for transportation have been trained, as required by the Department of Transportation's Hazardous Materials Regulations (HMRs). The FAA is updating its regulations because hazmat transportation and the aviation industry have changed significantly since the FAA promulgated its hazmat regulations over 25 years ago. The rule will set clear hazmat training standards and ensure uniform compliance with hazmat training requirements.

Dates

DATES: Effective Date: November 7, 2005. SFAR Expiration Date: February 7, 2007. Compliance Date: February 7, 2007.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Janet McLaughlin, Office of Hazardous Materials, ADG-1, Federal Aviation Administration, 800 Independence Ave., SW., Washington, DC 20591; telephone (202) 267-8434.

Supplementary Information

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Availability of Rulemaking Documents

You can get an electronic copy using the Internet by:

(1) Searching the Department of Transportation's electronic Docket Management System (DMS) Web page (http://dms.dot.gov/search);

(2) Visiting the Office of Rulemaking's Web page at http://www.faa.gov/avr/arm/index.cfm; or

Availability of Rulemaking Documents

(3) Accessing the Government Printing Office's Web page at http://www.gpoaccess.gov/fr/index.html.

You can also get a copy by submitting a request to the Federal Aviation Administration, Office of Rulemaking, ARM-1, 800 Independence Avenue SW., Washington, DC 20591, or by calling (202) 267-9680. Identify the amendment number or docket number of this rulemaking.

Anyone is able to search the electronic form of all comments received into any of our dockets by the name of the individual submitting the comment (or signing the comment, if submitted on behalf of an association, business, labor union, etc.). You may review DOT's complete Privacy Act statement in the Federal Register of April 11, 2000 (65 FR 19477-19478), or you may visit http://dms.dot.gov.

Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act

Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act

The Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act (SBREFA) of 1996 requires the FAA to comply with small entity requests for information or advice about compliance with statutes and regulations within its jurisdiction. If you are a small entity and you have a question regarding this document, you may contact the local FAA official, or the person listed under FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT. You can find out more about SBREFA on the Internet at http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/rulemaking/sbre_act/.

Terms and Abbreviations Frequently Used in This Document

Terms and Abbreviations Frequently Used in This Document

Note: For the purposes of this rulemaking the terms "air carrier," "operator," "air operator," "carrier," and "airline" are used synonymously to refer to part 121 or part 135 operators. The term "hazardous material" is used synonymously with "dangerous goods."

AC--Advisory Circular ALPA--Air Line Pilots Association ATA--Air Transport Association of America, Inc. COMAT--Material owned or used by a certificate holder, commonly referred to as "company material. Material is only considered COMAT in transportation if it is being transported on the operator's own aircraft.

Hazmat--Hazardous material HMRs--Department of Transportation's Hazardous Materials Regulations found in 49 CFR parts 171 through 180 ICAO--International Civil Aviation Organization ICAO TI--International Civil Aviation Organization Technical Instructions for the Safe Transport of Dangerous Goods By Air IATA--International Air Transport Association IATA DGR--International Air Transport Association Dangerous Goods Regulations NATA--National Air Transportation Association NPRM--Notice of Proposed Rulemaking NTSB--National Transportation Safety Board PHMSA--Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (formerly the Research and Special Programs Administration) RSPA--Research and Special Programs Administration (now the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration) SFAR--Special Federal Aviation Regulation TRF--Transport-related function, i.e., any function performed for the certificate holder relating to the acceptance, rejection, storage incidental to transport, handling, packaging of COMAT, loading, of items for transport on board an aircraft TSA--Transportation

Security Administration UPS--United Parcel Service USPS--United States Postal Service Will-carry operator--An operator authorized in its operations specifications to carry hazmat Will-not-carry operator--An operator prohibited in its operations specifications from carrying hazmat that meets the definition of a hazardous material under the HMRs

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

I. The Proposed Rule II. Background III. Statutory Authority IV. Overview of Changes in the Final Rule V. Discussion of Public Comments

V.1. General

V.2. Transition Period

V.3. Clarification of Supervisory Training Requirements

V.4. Constructive Knowledge

V.5. Applicability/Transport-Related Function (TRF)

I. The Proposed Rule II. Background III. Statutory Authority IV. Overview of Changes in the Final Rule V. Discussion of Public Comments

V.6. New Hire/New Job Function

V.7. Persons Working for More Than One Certificate Holder

V.8. Recurrent Training

V.9. Notice to Repair Stations

V.10. Foreign Locations

V.11. Recordkeeping Requirements

V.11.A. Location

V.11.B. Content

V.12. Proposed Appendix N (Adopted as Appendix O)

V.13. Training Method

V.14. Single-Pilot Operations

V.15. Repair Stations (Part 145)--General

V.16. Application for Part 145 Certificate

V.17. Notification of Hazardous Materials Authorizations VI. Section-by-Section Discussion of the Final Rule VII. Rulemaking Analysis and Notice

VII.1. Paperwork Reduction Act

VII.2. International Compatibility

VII.3. Economic Evaluation Summary

VII.4. Regulatory Flexibility Determination

VII.5. International Trade Impact Assessment

VII.6. Unfunded Mandates Assessment

VII.7. Executive Order 13132, Federalism

VII.8. Environmental Analysis

VII.9. Regulations That Significantly Affect Energy Supply, Distribution, or Use

I. The Proposed Rule

I. The Proposed Rule

On May 8, 2003, the FAA published a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) on hazardous material training requirements for certain air carriers, commercial operators, and repair stations (68 FR 24810). In that NPRM, the FAA proposed to amend the manual and hazmat training regulations in parts 121 and 135 to incorporate most of the guidance that is currently contained in Advisory Circulars (ACs). In addition, the FAA proposed to add requirements for part 145 repair stations so that the FAA could increase its oversight of the hazmat training that repair stations are required to conduct under 49 CFR part 172.

The comment period for the NPRM originally was scheduled to close July 7, 2003, but was extended to September 5, 2003 in response to public requests. See notice of extension of comment period published in the Federal Register on July 7, 2003 (68 FR 40206; July 7, 2003). The FAA received approximately 70 comments on the NPRM, many of which raised concerns with some aspects of the proposal.

II. Background

II. Background

As discussed in the preamble of the NPRM, hazmat transportation regulations have changed since regulations for hazmat training were first adopted over 25 years ago. The Department of Transportation (DOT) implemented the Hazardous Materials Regulations (HMRs), 49 CFR parts 171 through 180 (41 FR 15972; April 15, 1976), in part to address changes following deregulation of the airline industry in the 1970s. DOT regulations govern the domestic transportation of hazmat by all modes of transport. The international aviation community relies on the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) to set the standards for the safe transport of dangerous goods by air. These standards are contained in the "Technical Instructions for the Safe Transport of Dangerous Goods by Air" (ICAO TI). The ICAO TI also establishes hazmat training standards for air operators.

In the past, the FAA has used ACs as a way of helping air carriers and operators comply with the hazmat training requirements in the DOT HMRs. Information contained in ACs is not mandatory; it is advisory. This rule will incorporate existing guidance documents into regulations that can be uniformly enforced.

The proposed rule identified persons working for, or on behalf of the part 121 or part 135 operator who would need to receive hazmat training by the nature of the job description they hold or supervise. As used in the NPRM, the term "supervise" was intended to mean more than just being a designated supervisor. It was meant to include individuals with any degree of direct oversight over a function addressed by the proposed rule. This final rule clarifies that the term "supervise" only applies to those persons who have direct supervision over the job functions performed.

Consistent with the NPRM, the final rule establishes a two-pronged training program--one for part 121 and part 135 operators electing to transport hazmat (will-carry certificate holders), and the other for part 121 and part 135 operators electing not to transport hazmat (will-not-carry certificate holders). Will-carry certificate holders will have to conduct in-depth training for persons directly supervising or performing any of the following job functions involving items for transport on aircraft--acceptance, rejection, handling, storage incidental to transport, packaging of company materials owned or used by the certificate holder (known as COMAT), and loading. (Henceforth this list will be referred to as a transport-related function (TRF).) Will-not-carry certificate holders will be required to conduct training sufficient to enable the persons directly supervising or performing a TRF to identify material marked or labeled as hazmat, or material that is not marked or labeled as hazmat but possesses indicators that it might contain hazmat. Some possible indicators of hazmat include a hazard label or caution statement on the package with no accompanying shipping documentation, a notation such as "flammable paint," without proper shipping paper declarations or labels or markings.

The FAA also proposed to add requirements for part 145 repair stations that would increase oversight of compliance with DOT hazmat training regulations. The FAA proposed that, at the time of application for a part 145 certificate or rating, a repair station would have to certify to the FAA that all hazmat employees, as defined in 49 CFR 171.8, are trained under the HMRs, and that it is otherwise in compliance with the hazmat training requirements of the HMRs. This final rule modifies that proposal to require repair stations to submit a certification to the FAA that all hazmat employees are trained under the HMR prior to the FAA issuing a certificate, not at the time of application.

In addition, the FAA proposed to amend part 145 by adding a requirement that repair stations notify each of its workers of the will-carry or will-not-carry status of the part 121 or part 135 operators for which the repair station works. In the final rule the FAA adopts this requirement with some amendments. This notification would have to be done as soon as the repair station is informed of the part 121 or part 135 operator's status. This requirement is intended to be the companion requirement to the proposed notification requirement for part 121 and part 135 operators. In the final rule the FAA amends the proposed provision to require the repair station verify receipt of the notification and communicate this status to its employees, contractors, or subcontractors that handle or replace aircraft components or other items regulated by 49 CFR parts 171 through 180 prior to performing work for, or on behalf of the part 121 or part 135 operator.

III. Statutory Authority

III. Statutory Authority

The FAA has broad statutory authority to regulate for aviation safety. Specifically, the FAA has authority under 49 U.S.C. 44701(a)(5) to prescribe "regulations and minimum standards for other practices, methods, and procedures the Administrator finds necessary for safety in air commerce and national security." Also, 49 U.S.C. 44701(b)(1) states "Prescribing Minimum Safety Standards.--The Administrator may prescribe minimum safety standards for--(1) an air carrier to whom a certificate is issued under section 44705 of this title; * * *." In addition, the FAA is required to carry out its duties in a way that "best tends to reduce or eliminate the possibility or recurrence of accidents in air transportation" (49 U.S.C. 44701(c)).

IV. Overview of Changes in the Final Rule

IV. Overview of Changes in the Final Rule

In response to public comments, the FAA is making the following changes in the final rule (discussed in detail under "VI. Section-by-Section Discussion of the Final Rule")--

• Clarifying that the term "transport-related function (TRF)" is merely a shorthand reference used in the NPRM preamble and the final rule preamble to refer to the list of covered job functions contained in Sec. § 121.1001 (proposed as Sec. § 121.801) and 135.501. This term, as amended in the final rule preamble, is used to avoid repeating the list "acceptance, rejection, storage incidental to transport, handling, packaging of COMAT (company material) and loading of items for transport on board an aircraft." The FAA did not intend for the term to extend beyond the list of covered job functions. The term transport-related function is not a separate regulatory term so it is not defined in the regulations.

• Removing the terms "unloading" and "carriage" from the list of covered job functions proposed in Sec. § 121.801 (adopted as § 121.1001) and 135.501. The term "unloading" is removed because it is not a job function that needs to be addressed through the FAA's hazmat training program, since the item is being removed from the aircraft and thus would not pose a danger to the aircraft. If an item is subsequently loaded onto an aircraft, a trained person would have to perform the loading function. Based on comments from industry, the FAA believes it could be confusing to include the term "carriage" in the list of covered job functions in § 121.1001 and § 135.501. The term "carriage" is removed. The FAA does not believe the removal of this term to be significant because all of the terms covered by carriage are already listed as covered functions.

• Closely aligning the training modules in Appendix O (proposed as Appendix N) of part 121 with the standards in the 2005 edition of the ICAO TI and the IATA DGR. This will allow for workers to be trained in accordance with the job function they perform for part 121 or part 135 operators. The final rule does not prescribe exactly how each worker is to be trained. To this end, the FAA is removing the training "modules" and specifying minimum aspects of training for different job functions. The part 121 and part 135 operators will still be responsible for assessing the breadth and depth of each worker's training needs based on his or her job functions.

• Modifying proposed Sec. § 121.801 (adopted as § 121.1001) and 135.501 that would have required hazmat training to apply to all persons involved in supervising a hazmat job function. In the final rule, the FAA is limiting hazmat training to "direct" supervisors. This amendment eliminates the need to train persons up the supervisory chain who are not actively engaged in job functions that require hazmat training.

• Amending the recurrent hazmat training requirement currently contained in 121.401 and 135.323 by relocating it to Sec. § 121.1001 and 135.501 and amending the annual retraining cycle to a 24-month cycle. This change is consistent with the International Civil Aviation Organization's Technical Instructions on the Safe Transport of Dangerous Goods (ICAO TI) and the International Aviation Transport Association's Dangerous Goods Recommendations (IATA DGR) and (JAROPS) requirements.

• Clarifying that computer-based training (CBT) and distance-learning techniques, such as interactive video training, are acceptable means for satisfying the training specified in Appendix O of part 121, provided there is an opportunity for trainees to interact with an instructor to answer all questions prior to certifying completion of the training. Interaction may be in person or via telecommunications connection (e-mail, telephone, etc).

• Amending the recordkeeping provisions of Sec. § 121.1007 (proposed as § 121.804) and 135.507 to permit hazmat training records to be maintained electronically and off-site as long as they can be transmitted to a worker's place of work upon request.

• Harmonizing the requirements for the content of hazmat training records with the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administrations's (PHMSA's) HMR, the ICAO TI, and the IATA DGR requirements. The FAA is deleting the requirement that the training records contain a statement signed by a person designated by the Director of Training.

• Removing the specific references to "aircraft dispatcher," "flight instructor," and "check airman" in Tables 1 and 2 in Appendix O of part 121 (proposed as Appendix N). The type of hazmat training an employee receives is based on the job functions he or she performs for, or on behalf of the part 121 or part 135 operator, not his or her job description.

• Clarifying that part 145 repair station personnel are required to be trained to a part 121 or part 135 operator's hazmat program only when they are performing or directly supervising a job function listed in § 121.1001 or § 135.501, for or on behalf of that part 121 or part 135 operator, including the aircraft loading function. The repair stations that meet the definition of a "hazmat employer" (49 CFR 171.8) must meet existing training requirements under 49 CFR part 172 subpart H.

• Requiring that a part 145 certificate holder inform employees, contractors, or subcontractors that handle or replace aircraft components or other items regulated by 49 CFR parts 171 through 180 of the will-carry or will-not-carry status of the part 119 certificate holders for which it performs work.

• Amending the final rule to require that the repair stations certify to the FAA that they comply with 49 CFR hazmat training requirements (if applicable) prior to the FAA's issuance of a part 145 certificate or rating. This requirement will replace the proposed requirement that a repair station provide this certification upon application for a certificate.

V. Discussion of Public Comments

V. Discussion of Public Comments

V.1. General

Comments

Both Ameristar Air Cargo and Express.Net Airlines commented that the proposed dispatcher training should also apply to anyone who performs a similar function (i.e., flight following or flight locating). Ameristar stated that, "flight followers perform the function of operational control on behalf of the Director of Operations and should be required to have some training in regard to their duties associated with the transport of hazardous materials." FAA Response

Comments

The requirement for hazmat training is determined by the employee's job function as specified in Sec. § 121.1001 and 135.501, not the job description. If the person performing the job description of aircraft dispatcher, flight instructor or check airman also performs a job function identified in § 121.1001 or § 135.501, he or she must complete the applicable portion of the part 121 or part 135 operator's approved hazmat training program. Crewmembers have specific training requirements in Appendix O, regardless of the other functions they perform relating to cargo onboard the aircraft. A person performing any job function listed in § 121.1001 or § 135.501 must meet the same requirement whether specifically listed in the current § 121.401 or § 135.323. The reference to pilots, flight engineers, flight attendants and dispatchers in proposed Appendix N has been amended in the final rule.

This appendix, adopted as Appendix O, identifies training associated with applicable job functions and is closely aligned with the 2005 edition of the ICAO TI and the International Air Transport Association Dangerous Goods Regulations (IATA DGR). Dispatcher training is currently referenced in Sec. § 121.401(a)(1) and 135.323(a)(1). In the final rule the FAA is amending these sections only to remove the reference to hazardous materials training. The hazmat training requirements are relocated in 14 CFR subpart Z of part 121 and subpart K of 135. However, the other training requirements referenced by Sec. § 121.401 and 135.323 remain unchanged. The requirement for each crewmember, aircraft dispatcher, flight instructor and check airman to be adequately trained to perform his or her duties other than hazmat job functions must be retained in § 121.401(a)(1) and § 135.323(a)(1) to maintain the requirements for flight and proficiency training identified in Appendixes E and F. This requirement is not changed in this rulemaking. Comments

The Air Transport Association of America, Inc. (ATA) stated that the FAA should address non-compliance such as that brought to light in the ValuJet accident, through appropriate enforcement. Other commenters noted that the NPRM imposes additional training requirements on carriers, when the FAA could far more effectively reduce undeclared and improperly declared hazmat by improving public education efforts towards shippers who offer hazmat for air transportation. FAA Response

The FAA uses the enforcement process to address issues of noncompliance with FAA and DOT regulations and will continue to do so. Since 2000, FAA Hazardous Material Specialists have inspected over 8,000 shipping companies and conducted over 2,000 visits to shipper facilities, trade associations and various conferences to educate and inform shippers of their responsibilities under the HMRs. However, even with this public education campaign, the FAA has initiated 222 investigations for accepting hazardous materials improperly from January 2000 to December 2003. These investigations include both instances where hazmats were improperly labeled/marked or packaged, and instances where material was shipped undeclared and later found to be hazmat. Taking into account that noncompliance with the regulations continues despite the FAA's current training requirements and public education efforts, the FAA has adopted the revised training rules to improve the hazmat training program given to those individuals performing the job functions listed in Sec. § 121.1001 and 135.501.

The FAA believes that a hazmat training requirement that includes clearly enforceable hazmat recognition training for both will-carry and will-not-carry certificate holders is a critical step towards reducing the number of improperly prepared or undeclared shipments. Recognition training for will-not-carry certificate holders is currently administered in accordance with advisory material; thus there are no regulatory standards. Enforceable hazmat training standards serve the dual purpose of establishing a mandatory hazmat training program with uniform requirements, and reducing the potential that "discoverable" hazmat shipments will move undetected. A "discoverable" hazmat shipment is a shipment that is likely to be flagged by a trained individual as a potential hazmat shipment, even though it is not properly prepared for shipment or is shipped undeclared. The FAA recognizes that not all improperly shipped hazmats or undeclared hazmats may be discoverable, even by a trained individual.

Additionally, the FAA notes that outreach to the aviation industry and public education has not been effective in eliminating the problem of improper shipments of oxygen generators. Since the Valujet tragedy in 1996, the FAA has investigated both operators and repair stations and has documented over 60 instances of improperly transported oxygen generators for which the FAA is collecting over $3 million in civil penalties. Oxygen generators are a key piece of equipment used in the aviation industry and are often shipped as COMAT without complying with DOT's hazmat regulations.

The FAA also has been actively engaged in enforcing the hazmat regulations. It has collected over $6 million in hazmat civil penalties for violations from U.S.-certificated air carriers from 2000 to 2003. One part 121 operator pled guilty in September 2003, to willfully not providing required hazmat information to its pilots. Another part 121 operator entered into a plea agreement with the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Florida in December 1999, which included agreed-to "statement of facts" describing hazmat infractions. One repair station was convicted of willfully not providing hazmat training in 1999. Comment

ATA commented that the NPRM would not improve safety and is broader than necessary to address the primary safety objective cited--prevention of another ValuJet-type accident caused by inadequately trained contractors. FAA Response

Valujet was a will-not-carry part 121 operator, thus the oxygen generators should never have been placed on board a Valujet aircraft for shipment as cargo. The FAA did not have any enforceable hazmat training requirements for part 121 will-not-carry certificate holders. This final rule corrects that deficiency. The commenter is correct that this rule addresses issues and concerns discovered through our oversight that are broader than the issues raised by the ValuJet accident. Comment

United Parcel Service (UPS) challenged the FAA's statutory authority to promulgate requirements for training non-hazmat employees. UPS commented that the FAA has not articulated "a reasonable basis for requiring a certificate holder to provide hazardous materials training to employees who do not perform or supervise any functions regulated under the HMR or who do not otherwise directly affect hazardous materials transportation safety." FAA Response

The FAA has broad statutory authority to regulate for aviation safety. Specifically, the FAA has authority under 49 U.S.C. 44701(a)(5) to prescribe "regulations and minimum standards for other practices, methods, and procedures the Administrator finds necessary for safety in air commerce and national security." Also, 49 U.S.C. 44701(b)(1) states "Prescribing Minimum Safety Standards.--The Administrator may prescribe minimum safety standards for--(1) an air carrier to whom a certificate is issued under section 44705 of this title; * * *." In addition, the FAA is required to carry out its duties in a way that "best tends to reduce or eliminate the possibility or recurrence of accidents in air transportation" (49 U.S.C. 44701(c)).

Consistent with its statutory authority, the FAA has previously required hazmat training for non-hazmat employees working for part 119 certificate holders operating under part 135. (See 38 FR 14914; June 7, 1973.) The FAA believes that prior and current hazmat enforcement actions and accidents by will-not-carry operators transporting hazmat demonstrate the need for will-not-carry training. Additionally, the FAA notes that the industry's own International Air Transport Association's (IATA's) Dangerous Goods Regulations paragraph 1.5.0.1 states that the ICAO TI and IATA DGR include training for persons with various responsibilities in processing cargo (not necessarily involving dangerous goods). Thus, given our expertise and that the aviation industry's own representatives have determined such training is important, the FAA is including it in this change. Comment

Several commenters addressed the need to regulate or certify the hazmat training companies providing training under this rule. Express.Net Airlines stated that "regulation should mandate a skill level for instructors in the same manner the regulation mandates skill level for management personnel required for operations conducted under parts 121 and 135 from Part 119.65." Express.Net believed that the FAA should have a program that sets forth the basic knowledge a person should possess before providing hazmat instruction. Express.Net noted that the European community requires operators that load, unload or transport dangerous goods to have a person in the position of Dangerous Goods Safety Advisor.

COSTHA commented that the NPRM should be amended to assess, monitor and certify professional schools that would be authorized to provide hazmat training. It urged the FAA to amend the NPRM to state that in lieu of developing an in-house training program, carriers (both will-carry and will-not-carry), repair stations and any other person affected by the regulations would be in compliance by completing a training program offered by a FAA-certified hazmat training company. FAA Response

The comment suggesting that FAA establish standards for instructors or instructional schools is outside the scope of this rulemaking. Additionally, the comment suggesting a new required position for operators is also outside the scope of this rulemaking. Comment

The overwhelming majority of the part 121 and part 135 operators requested flexibility in designing and determining curriculum, determining the depth of training required for the function the individual employee performs, the method of delivery, length of training and method of testing. FAA Response

The FAA recognizes that part 121 and part 135 operators require flexibility to accomplish the required hazmat training. The FAA notes that it is the part 121 and part 135 operators' responsibility to ensure that the type, duration and delivery method of training is adequate and appropriate for each worker. The approved hazmat training program may be provided by company training programs, computer based programs, self-guided compact disk (CD) training programs, outside training firms or consultants, or any other type of organization offering training that meets the objective training requirements. Hazmat training may be provided by the operator or other public or private sources, including training classes that are offered by the IATA to the extent that the IATA training addresses the training specified in the FAA-approved hazmat training program. This FAA final rule will require that, regardless of the teaching method used, the operator must provide a method to respond to students' questions prior to certifying completion of the training. E-mail is an acceptable means of communicating and responding to questions. Comment

UPS asked that the FAA confirm in any subsequent notice that operators only need to submit an outline of their proposed training programs rather than the actual training curriculum. FAA Response

Section 121.401(a)(1) applies to all training as currently written, including hazmat. Once the final rule is fully effective, § 121.401(a)(1) will only apply to training other than hazmat training. New Sec. § 121.1003 (proposed as § 121.802) and 135.503 will contain the hazmat training requirement. As part of the hazmat training requirement, part 121 and part 135 operators are required to obtain FAA approval of the hazmat training program. The current practice of submitting an outline sufficient to provide an overview of the training program will suffice for purposes of approval, unless it is necessary to see the full hazmat training program to understand the curriculum. Comment

The Air Line Pilots Association (ALPA) urged the FAA to clarify a concept called "will-not-accept" that is different than "will-not-carry." ALPA believed that the two concepts are different because "will-not-carry" means no hazmat is allowed on the aircraft, while "will-not-accept" would allow carriers to carry their own hazmat as COMAT from point to point on their aircraft, but they would not be able to accept hazmat shipments from outside entities. ALPA believed that clarifying the three levels of classification (will-not-carry, will-not-accept, and will-carry) would be useful in allowing a carrier to develop a training program that would meet the needs of its operation. FAA Response

The FAA only proposed will-carry and will-not-carry hazmat training. The part 119 certificate holder's operations specifications will either include an authorization permitting the certificate holder to handle and transport hazmat (will-carry certificate holder) or a prohibition against handling and transporting hazmat (will-not-carry certificate holder). There are no other options. Officially, the FAA has never endorsed a concept called "will-not-accept" that would allow carriers classified as will-not-carry certificate holders to carry hazmat as COMAT. If the COMAT is a hazardous material, it may be carried only by a will-carry certificate holder. A will-carry certificate holder may choose to limit its acceptance and transport of hazardous materials to COMAT only; however, the company makes this decision. The certificate holder is considered a "will-carry" operator, and the will-carry training program applies. Comment

ATA noted that the procedures for handling dangerous goods, once the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) finds them, are currently under active discussion between the TSA and the carriers. The commenter went on to say that it is unclear what role carrier employees will have in handling such goods, or whether that responsibility will be handled completely or partially by a third-party contractor. ATA urged the FAA to reconsider the need for any additional training for carrier personnel who check-in passengers and luggage, and ensure that the rule takes into account ongoing developments in the TSA's role. FAA Response

In drafting the final rule the FAA was cognizant of Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) (formerly Research and Special Programs Administration (RSPA)) and TSA activities in the area of hazmat transport by aircraft. On February 28, 2003, RSPA (now PHMSA) issued a "Formal interpretation of regulations" (68 FR 9735) clarifying that hazmat regulations apply to carry-on and checked baggage. Additionally, the RSPA interpretation specifically identified the point at which the carry-on baggage has been offered by the passenger for transportation and the point at which checked baggage has been accepted by the airlines for transportation. Carry-on baggage (including items on his/her person) is considered offered for transportation when the passenger tenders the baggage to screening personnel at an airport security screening checkpoint or otherwise attempts to proceed through the checkpoint with the hazardous material on his or her person. A passenger offers carry-on baggage for transportation, and represents it as fit for moving by aircraft, when the baggage is placed on the X-ray machine conveyer belt, handed to the baggage screening personnel, or placed in a bin or tray for examination by screening personnel, or when the passenger physically passes through the security checkpoint with the baggage (including items on his or her person). Carry-on baggage is accepted by an air carrier when the airline accepts the boarding pass of the passenger while boarding the flight. The passenger is responsible for ensuring compliance for carry-on baggage with the HMR from the point of offer and at all times until transportation is complete.

Checked baggage is offered to the carrier at the point the passenger presents the baggage for acceptance by the carrier. This can occur at curbside check-in, at the ticket counter at the airport, or when the passenger presents the bag to screening personnel for explosive detection screening as a prerequisite to presentation to the carrier. When the baggage is tendered at curbside check-in or the ticket counter to the air carrier, the baggage is considered to have been accepted when the air carrier issues a baggage claim ticket for the checked baggage.

Given the various points at which baggage is considered offered for transport, and the varied types of workers that might accept baggage, it is critical that certificate holder's workers receive the proper hazmat training so that baggage can be properly screened. At the time of this writing, TSA checked baggage screeners are instructed to point out possible unauthorized hazmat items discovered in baggage to airline representatives so the airline representatives can determine if the items can be transported under the hazmat regulations. The certificate holder must report any unauthorized hazmat discovered in checked baggage to the FAA under PHMSA's rules at 49 CFR 175.31. In order for a worker to be capable of performing this job function, he or she must have completed hazmat training. Comments

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) commented that in May 1996, it issued Safety Recommendation A-96-26, which called for the FAA to require air carriers to revise as necessary their practices and training for accepting passenger baggage and freight shipments, and for identifying undeclared or unauthorized hazardous materials that are offered for transport. The NTSB voiced concern that the proposed training requirements would apply only to passenger air carriers. The NTSB urged the FAA to apply the training requirements to cargo carriers and cargo-only operations too. FAA Response

The FAA has contacted the NTSB and informed them that the proposed training requirements would apply to both passenger and cargo air carriers. The final rule does not change this fact. Comments

Integrated cargo carriers like UPS and FedEx Express were concerned that the proposals were drafted so broadly that, literally interpreted, they could require training of drivers in the carriers' ground operations. These carriers were concerned because their ground operations have not been covered under the FAA's training requirements in the past, although they are subject to PHMSA's hazmat training requirements. UPS and FedEx note that ground operations may well be outside the jurisdiction of the FAA. The commenter added that if the FAA intended the proposals to extend to those drivers, the costs of the additional training time would be enormous, with no commensurate safety benefit. Moreover, such coverage could conflict with the jurisdiction of other Federal agencies, and it would be problematic if FAA approval were required for a small portion of an otherwise extensive training process used to qualify drivers for their duties on-road. FAA Response

Fed Ex and UPS are part 121 operators and both accept many types of hazmat for air transportation as well as transportation by rail and motor vehicle. The key to determining whom to train is to delineate which party is responsible for accepting a package for air transportation. This fact is consistent with current regulations. If a part 121 or part 135 operator's truck drivers are accepting property for air transportation, they must be trained in accordance with this rule. However, if another employee performs that job function for the part 121 or part 135 operator, then the truck driver would not have to be trained in accordance with this rule. For instance, a truck driver who is required to perform the function of acceptance of a package for air transport would have to be trained for performing that function. This is the same requirement as for a person at the sort facility performing the same function. In this case, if the truck driver is not responsible for performing the acceptance of a package for air shipment, and the certificate holder was relying on the truck driver to accept the package for only motor vehicle transport, then the truck driver does not need to be trained in the certificate holder's program. It is the function being performed or directly supervised that mandates the training requirement, not the job designation. Comment

The Regional Airline Association (RAA) noted that after the Valujet accident the FAA invested heavily in the Air Transportation Oversight System (ATOS), which is an FAA oversight process that assesses an airline's safety attributes beyond strict regulatory compliance. RAA stated that ATOS was intended to raise the level of safety in the industry without additional regulations. RAA then questioned whether this proposal and the Part 60 proposal to codify extensive advisory material are a step back from the FAA's earlier commitment to the ATOS concept. RAA asked whether all of the FAA's advisory and field policy materials will be codified. FAA Response

The FAA codifies voluntary standards when it believes it is in the best interest of safety to do so. In this case, hazardous materials are of significant concern in air transportation because of the potentially devastating consequences in the event of an accident due to an improperly transported hazmat.

V.2. Transition Period

V.2. Transition Period

Comments

AmAv, Inc., ATA, and UPS voiced concern that 15 months may not be enough time to develop the training program and have it approved by the FAA. In particular these commenters were concerned about what to do if the Principal Operations Inspector (POI) is not able to complete a review and approval of the program within the specified time frame. AmAv, Inc. also noted that having the POI approve the program would be a substantial increase in workload and some Flight Standards District Offices (FSDOs) are already overburdened and understaffed. UPS said that a certificate holder's current training program should remain in effect pending the FAA's approval of the revised training program. FAA Response

Comments

The commenters raised several concerns that demonstrated some misunderstanding about the proposed rule. First, the POI will not be approving Hazardous Material Programs that include hazmat training. POIs will continue to approve the general operator's training program covered by § 121.401 or § 121.135. With regard to hazmat training, the POI will "receive" the training program information from part 121 and part 135 operators and submit it for review to the appropriate Regional Hazardous Material Branch Manager in the FAA's Regional Security and Hazardous Materials Offices. This is consistent with current practice. The Hazardous Materials Branch Manager currently reviews the carrier's hazmat training program and will continue to be responsible for approving it and relaying that information back to the POI.

Second, part 121 and part 135 operators do not have to be concerned about having to implement the hazmat training program before it is approved by the FAA. Certificate holders are permitted to continue using their existing FAA approved training programs during the 15-month transition period. As provided in SFAR 99, "during the transition period, these certificate holders can continue to comply with the current requirements or comply with the new requirements." The FAA believes that the 15-month transition period is a sufficient time period.

Third, incorporating the changes into the existing hazmat training program should not be difficult. The FAA chose 15 months as a transition period because it believes that the time period is sufficient to allow certificate holders to include any changes necessary due to this final rule into their existing mandatory 12-month annual recurrent training. Once this rule goes into effect, the recurrent training requirement is amended from annually to every 24 months. Since the hazmat training provision had been incorporated into the certificate holder's overall training provisions in Sec. § 121.401 and 135.323, the recurrent training requirement for hazmat had been aligned with the certificate holder's other recurrent training requirements for flight and proficiency training. The final rule amendment aligns the FAA's hazmat recurrent training provision with long-standing international recommendations and current industry practice for hazmat recurrent training. Thus, hazmat training and flight and proficiency training are now on different cycles. The movement from annual recurrent hazmat training to recurrent hazmat training every 24 months also aligns FAA requirements with the cycle for regulatory updates and changes followed by ICAO, IATA and the United Nations Subcommittee on the Transport of Dangerous Goods. The requirement to provide recurrent training every 24 months should provide the certificate holder with a streamlined process for revising and updating hazmat training programs.

Finally, the FAA does not believe that the changes necessitated by this rule will be as dramatic as the part 121 and part 135 operators foretell. Prior to publication of the NPRM, the FAA surveyed will-carry and will-not-carry operators with FAA-approved hazmat training programs to determine if the content of their training programs would be in compliance with the proposals in the NPRM. The FAA also randomly reviewed FAA-approved hazmat training programs currently in operations manuals of both will-carry and will-not-carry operators. These programs also were all found either to be completely adequate in content as compared to the proposed rule or would require only minor amendments.

Thus, the FAA anticipates that given the changes in the final rule certificate holders will not require significant changes to the current hazmat training program curriculum. In fact, most part 121 and part 135 operators adhere to the ICAO TI and the IATA DGR training requirements as an industry standard, and this final rule is closely aligned with the ICAO TI and IATA DGR training requirements that will be effective January 1, 2005. Therefore, certificate holders adhering to the ICAO TI and IATA DGR requirements will have programs that currently meet both the industry standards and the FAA's regulatory standards. IATA (International Air Transport Association) represents over 270 airlines operating under the flags of almost as many nations comprising 95% of the international scheduled air traffic. IATA's resolution 618 requires all member airlines to adhere to the following requirements.

In scheduled and/or unscheduled operations, no dangerous goods are permitted to be accepted and carried unless they comply fully with the international standards and recommended practices of Annex 18 to the Convention on International Civil Aviation--"The Safe Transport of Dangerous Goods by Air" and its associated Technical Instructions as reflected in the "IATA Dangerous Goods Regulations."

Through IATA, airlines individual networks function as a worldwide system. Due to this business practice, even smaller non-member airlines that interline with IATA carriers must meet all of the member requirements or their cargo cannot be interlined in the cargo system.

V.3. Clarification of Supervisory Training Requirements

V.3. Clarification of Supervisory Training Requirements

Comments

UPS, Continental, and ATA were concerned that the proposed requirement to train the supervisors of employees who perform a hazmat function was too broad. UPS stated that the NPRM would require training for "every employee of a certificate holder with any supervisory responsibilities whatsoever," even a "certificate holder's chief executive officer, even though that person may not perform a single function directly affecting hazardous materials safety." UPS also commented that the FAA has not articulated a "reasonable basis for requiring a certificate holder to provide hazardous materials training to employees who do not perform or supervise any functions regulated under the HMR or who do not otherwise directly affect hazardous materials transportation safety."

Comments

ATA stated that the "definition of supervisor would sweep in hundreds of supervisory personnel whose responsibilities rarely if ever bring them in contact with hazmat." ATA added that covered supervisors would include "all levels of carrier management at an airport, as well as the corporate management and officers to whom they report * * *. Such broad applicability to supervisors without regard to their responsibilities regarding hazmat is unnecessary to ensure safety and an unreasonable burden on the carriers." FAA Response

The FAA agrees that the definition of the term "supervisor" as used in the NPRM was too broad. In the final rule, the FAA is adding the term "direct" to qualify the term "supervisor" in every place where it is used in the new hazmat training regulations. This change is necessary to clarify that only the "direct" supervisor of a worker performing any of the job functions in § 121.1001 (proposed as § 121.801) or § 135.501 for, or on behalf of the certificate holder is required to complete the part 121 or part 135 operator's FAA-approved training program. This amendment should address the issues raised in the comments.

V.4. Constructive Knowledge

V.4. Constructive Knowledge

Comments

A number of commenters (Northwest Airlines, UPS, Southwest, United Airlines, Delta Airlines, and ATA) voiced concerns with the proposed requirement to train people to identify material as hazmat that is not properly labeled and marked as a hazmat. These commenters asked the FAA to provide a trigger list that would help them train their employees in this regard. UPS commented that the "development of clear and well-conceived indicia of constructive knowledge is essential to enabling air carriers to implement effective training with respect to undeclared hazardous materials." UPS was concerned that the proposed rule would leave certificate holders guessing at what indicators the FAA will deem sufficient to place a carrier on notice that a package may contain hazardous materials. United Airlines noted that the FAA needed to coordinate with the DOT's Office of Intermodalism, which is in the process of developing a definition of the term "constructive knowledge." ATA commented that training revisions should not be completed until DOT guidance on determining the presence of undeclared hazmat is publicly available and preferably commented upon. FAA Response

Comments

Many commenters raised the issue of what constitutes "constructive knowledge" of the presence of hazardous materials in a shipment, in the context of enabling the trained person to recognize items that contain, or may contain, hazardous materials regulated under the HMRs. In a 1998 interpretation published in the Federal Register (63 FR 30411-30412; June 4, 1998), RSPA (now PHMSA) used the term "constructive knowledge" to express the "knowingly" standard in 49 U.S.C. 5123(a)(1)(B) that a person "acts knowingly" when "a reasonable person acting in the circumstances and exercising reasonable care"" would have "actual knowledge of the facts giving rise to the violation." RSPA also stated, "all relevant facts must be considered to determine whether or not a reasonable person acting in the circumstances and exercising reasonable care would realize the presence of hazardous materials." In addition, RSPA stated, "Information concerning the contents of suspicious packages must be pursued to determine whether hazardous materials have been improperly offered. A carrier's employee who accepts packages for transport must be trained to recognize a `suspicious package' * * *." Id.

In 2001, Fed Ex asked DOT to develop further guidance on what constitutes "constructive knowledge" that a carrier is deemed to have of the presence of hazardous materials when the carrier accepts a shipment for transportation. DOT held a public meeting on June 19, 2002, and is considering the numerous oral and written comments in this proceeding (Docket No. OST-01-10380).

In the context of this final rule, the FAA is not specifying detailed hazmat training content. Should DOT or PHMSA issue a further interpretation on "constructive knowledge," certificate holders would be authorized to adjust their training content accordingly. Hazmat training program content will always have to be adjusted as hazmat regulatory changes become effective. These adjustments are the responsibility of the certificate holder.

The practice that an operator's staff be adequately trained to assist them to identify and detect undeclared dangerous goods has been an industry standard in the IATA DGR for over 10 years. The IATA DGR information is intended to prevent undeclared dangerous goods in cargo from being loaded on an aircraft and prevent passengers from taking on board those dangerous goods that they are not permitted to have in their baggage.

V.5. Applicability/Transport-Related Function (TRF)

V.5. Applicability/Transport-Related Function (TRF)

Comments

ATA, Northwest, UPS, United, and the National Air Transportation Association (NATA) were concerned that the application of the term "transport-related function" would end up requiring them to train all or a substantial number of the employees in their operations. UPS recommended that the FAA issue guidelines so that a carrier can determine when an employee could "reasonably be foreseen" as performing or supervising a transport related function. FAA Response

Comments

The FAA recognizes the concerns voiced by the commenters. The term "transport-related function" is a shorthand reference used in the preamble of the NPRM and final rule to refer to the specific listed job functions in Sec. § 121.1001 (proposed as Sec. § 121.801) and 135.501. It is not intended to extend beyond those listed job functions.

In the final rule the FAA is also removing the terms "unloading" and "carriage" from the list of specific covered job functions. This decision is consistent with movement to closely align the regulations with the 2005 edition of the ICAO TI and the IATA DGR. Training conducted by an operator to satisfy industry training practices and standards (e.g. IATA) that meet or exceed the requirements of new part 121 Appendix O would be sufficient for compliance with the final rule requirements. The FAA does not believe that removing these terms from the list of covered functions adversely impacts safety. First, the term "unloading" covers a job function that actually removes the item from the aircraft where it does not pose a danger. Second, the FAA's research indicates that the personnel loading the aircraft typically are the same as the personnel unloading the aircraft. Since loading is a covered job function, these persons would be trained in accordance with the rule. Finally, if the unloaded cargo is subsequently loaded onto another aircraft, then the person doing the subsequent loading would need to be trained.

With regard to the removal of the term "carriage," the FAA does not believe there is a safety issue since the term essentially incorporates all of the listed job functions and is not a stand-alone term. Consequently, the FAA finds that a specific listing of the term is unnecessary.

V.6. New Hire/New Job Function

V.6. New Hire/New Job Function

Comment

Atlas Air stated that under the current regulations, when a carrier hires an employee/contractor who used to work for another all-cargo carrier and he or she provides a valid Dangerous Goods certification from that carrier, the carrier simply enters the employee's name in the training records under his or her valid certificate and schedules the employee for recurrent training when the base month comes up. Atlas Air urged the FAA to clarify that this practice can continue since limiting the practice would constitute an unnecessary financial burden. FAA Response

Comment

The FAA recognizes that part 121 and part 135 operators will have many similarities in their hazmat training programs. However, each carrier has its own policies and procedures regarding the handling and transport of hazmat. Thus, a new employee that will perform a job function listed in § 121.1001 or § 135.501 does not have to be fully trained in all aspects of the hazmat regulations if he or she has been trained by another certificate holder with the same will-carry or will-not-carry status within the 24-month period. However, he or she must receive training on the certificate holder's policies and procedures prior to performing his or her job. It is the responsibility of every part 121 and part 135 operator to train each employee in the procedures and policies the certificate holder has implemented to comply with the HMR and these regulations. Comments

Ameristar noted that the NPRM did not address how to handle a person who is not trained at a departure or destination point that helps load an aircraft under the supervision of a flight crewmember. An entire initial training program is not practical for a person that may be loading only one piece of freight (i.e., a seat belt pretensioner, Class 9 (UN3268)) using a forklift on a one-time basis for an operator. Ameristar also noted that there were no provisions for contract employees in the NPRM. FAA Response

Currently, the regulations require that the workers (contractor or direct airline employee) performing a hazmat job function (including unloading) be trained. There are no exceptions under current FAA training regulations. In this final rule, the FAA is adopting a new exception that would allow a person (either a new hire or someone who is performing a new job function) to perform a job function involving storage incidental to transport or loading of items on an aircraft for transport, provided the person is under the direct visual supervision of another properly trained employee authorized to directly supervise him or her. The exception is only valid for 30 days, and is contingent on the certificate holder complying with the recordkeeping requirements in Sec. § 121.1007(b) and 135.907(b) (proposed as § 121.804(b)) or § 135.504(b), as applicable. After that time period, the individual must receive the required training.

V.7. Persons Working for More Than One Certificate Holder

V.7. Persons Working for More Than One Certificate Holder

Comments

Several carriers were concerned about the application of the training requirement for employees or contractors who work for more than one certificate holder. Atlas Air stated that proposed § 121.803(a) would prevent Atlas, Polar, and similarly situated carriers from relying on another certificate holder's training program to satisfy the training obligation.

Comments

Additionally, Atlas Air commented that the second exception in proposed § 121.803(c), limiting the retraining required of persons working for other certificate holders in certain circumstances, would permit certification only from another certificate holder with the same will-carry status. Atlas believed this would put it at a distinct disadvantage around the world by prohibiting the acceptance of foreign carriers' certifications, which represent a large segment of Atlas' business.

UPS stated that proposed § 121.803(c)(1) would require a certificate holder to receive written verification that a repair station employee was properly trained from an "authorized, knowledgeable person representing the other certificate holder." The commenter said that the FAA provided no standards or guidelines for how a certificate holder can determine whether a person is "knowledgeable."

United commented that the process for verifying that a contractor has provided its employees with the proper hazmat training is "far too cumbersome and leaves each certificate holder with little option but to provide such service personnel with the full scope of hazmat training." Aircraft Electronics Association and Aviation Suppliers Association believed that contractors may be unwilling to provide the training certifications required by proposed Sec. § 121.803(c) and 135.503(c) for fear of legal liability or because they do not want to assume training costs that their competitors are not assuming. Moreover, the commenter stated, several of the exceptions are based on the worker having received prior training by a certificate holder having the same operations specifications authorization for the carriage of hazmat. FAA Response

The FAA believes that the exception provided for in Sec. § 121.1005(c) and 135.505(c) (proposed as Sec. § 121.803(c) and 135.503(c)) will actually minimize the training burden on part 121 and part 135 operators. After reviewing the concerns voiced by the commenters, it appears that many of the commenters may have misunderstood what type of training is required. The core of each part 121 and part 135 operator's training program is substantially the same. However, a worker who has been trained by one certificate holder but used by a second should be aware of that certificate holder's policies and procedures for handling hazmat. For instance, a worker initially performing work for a certificate holder with an operations specification prohibiting the acceptance of radioactive material may not have received in-depth training in the transport of radioactive materials. However, if that worker performs a job function listed in § 121.1001 or § 135.501 for or on behalf of an additional certificate holder that does accept radioactive material, the worker must be trained on the regulations pertaining to such materials. Therefore, a part 121 or part 135 operator using a person trained under another part 121 or part 135 operator's approved training program (both with the same will-carry or will-not-carry status) only has to train that person in the way it complies with the regulations.

Only operations conducted in accordance with parts 121, and 135, and part 145 certificate holders are covered by this rulemaking. Thus, the part 121 or part 135 certificate holders must ensure that a worker is trained when using a worker in a foreign location. Since this final rule is closely aligned with the 2005 edition of the ICAO TI and the IATA DGR requirements, there should be minimal differences in training. If the actual operations are in a foreign location, then the foreign location requirements in Sec. § 121.1005 and 135.505 (proposed as Sec. § 121.803 and 135.503) may be applicable.

The FAA agrees that the term "authorized, knowledgeable person" cannot be confirmed. Therefore, in the final rule the FAA is removing the proposed terminology and replacing it with the phrase "person designated by the certificate holder to hold the records." Comment

MidWest Airlines agreed that if a contractor is a will-not-carry airline for hazardous materials and provides services for a will-carry airline, the contractor needs to receive hazardous materials training from that airline. However, MidWest stated that it did not "understand the need for training to be provided when the status of the airline and contractor is reversed." FAA Response

A worker of a part 121 or part 135 operator with a status of will-carry operator receives hazmat training appropriate for the job function being performed. If the worker also performs or directly supervises job functions for a will-not-carry certificate holder, the employee will only have to be trained in the policies and procedures for the will-not-carry certificate holder. For instance, the worker needs to know what the policies are for a will-not-carry certificate holder if the worker identifies cargo as potential hazmat. These policies and procedures would include information such as who does the worker notify and where does the material get placed until the appropriate person investigates, etc. Only the policies and procedures specific to the will-not-carry certificate holder will need to be provided.

V.8. Recurrent Training

V.8. Recurrent Training

Comments

Several commenters raised concerns with the FAA's proposal to require annual recurrent training. Atlas Air requested that the FAA make the recurrent training requirement every two years, consistent with ICAO and United Nations (UN) recommendations. Ameristar Air Cargo commented that the base-month concept in the proposed rule is inconsistent with 14 CFR 121.401(b). This requires an industry to have two standards. Ameristar believed that the requirements of 14 CFR 121.433a currently allow the grace-month provision.

Comments

NATA urged the FAA to keep its recurrent training requirements consistent with PHMSA's recurrent training requirements under the HMRs. FAA Response

In response to comments on this issue, the FAA is closely aligning the final rule with the 2005 edition of the ICAO TI and the IATA DGR including modifying the proposal by requiring recurrent training every 24 months instead of annually. The change in recurrent training from every twelve months to every 24 months should not adversely impact safety since recurrent training is designed to update workers on amendments in the regulations. These amendments tend to occur on a 24-month schedule, keeping aligned with ICAO and IATA amendments. Under 49 CFR 175.20 "Compliance and Training" for air carriers, the FAA's 14 CFR 121.135, 121.401, 121.433a, 135.323, 135.327 and 135.333 are incorporated by reference. Under PHMSA's "hazmat employee" concept, recurrent training is required every three years. Currently, the FAA requires that recurrent hazmat training be completed by part 121 and part 135 operators annually along with the flight and proficiency training. The FAA's recurrent training requirements were in place before PHMSA's and were not superceded by PHMSA's retraining requirements. There are other differences between PHMSA's and the FAA's training requirements. For instance, the FAA requires the hazmat training program to be reviewed and approved by the agency.

The FAA also is clarifying that recurrent hazmat training can be taken in the calendar month before or the calendar month after it is actually due without changing the anniversary date for retraining purposes. A person can be retrained earlier than one calendar month prior to the training anniversary date; however, the anniversary date will change to the completion date of the retraining. The FAA believes that these exceptions provide the part 121 and part 135 operators with maximum flexibility in scheduling retraining while ensuring that there is not an extensive time period between the retraining dates.

V.9. Notice to Repair Stations

V.9. Notice to Repair Stations

Comments

Several commenters opposed the FAA's proposal to require a certificate holder to communicate and verify awareness of its hazardous materials policies and procedures to a repair station. UPS noted that "all repair stations likely `use' or `handle' materials classified as hazardous materials in the course of their operations." Thus, proposed § 121.803(e) quite possibly could require "notice and awareness" for every repair station utilized by a certificate holder.

Comments

NATA was concerned that the requirement to verify that the repair station is "aware of" its status and policies and procedures is "another regulatory trap." In this instance, the commenter stated, the FAA is establishing a mandate without giving a clear means of compliance. Southwest believed that while the requirement to provide written notification to each repair station performing work on the certificate holder's behalf is obtainable and objective, "the requirement to ensure that the repair station is "aware of' the certificate holder's policies and procedures is a subjective requirement that cannot be verified by the carrier."

ATA stated that "carriers can and do take the objective steps of informing repair stations whether they carry hazmat and advising them of carrier procedures for HMR compliance." FAA Response

The FAA agrees that the term "aware of" is somewhat subjective. The FAA's intent in proposing this standard was to ensure that critical information was effectively communicated between two parties.

The will or will-not-carry status of a certificate holder is critical information that must not get drowned out by other information. That is why the FAA proposed that part 121 and part 135 operators ensure that each repair station be aware of the part 121 and part 135 operator's will or will-not-carry status. In the final rule, the FAA is replacing the requirement for the repair station to be "aware of" the operator's will-or will-not-carry status with a requirement for the repair station to acknowledge receipt of the notification. This change is reflected in Sec. § 121.1005(e), 135.505(e), and 145.206(a).

There are many ways to get a written verification. One way of complying with this requirement would be to have the responsible person from the part 121 or part 135 operators write a letter to the repair station stating its status and policies and procedures and then have the authorized repair station supervisor or manager sign and return a copy of the letter. However, to allow for flexibility, the FAA is not mandating this method; it is simply one method of compliance. The FAA's purpose in adopting this requirement is to ensure that the repair station receive the required notification from the part 121 or part 135 operator. This notification then triggers the requirement for the part 145 repair station to notify its covered employees of the part 121 or part 135 operator's' status. Based on ATA's comments, it appears that part 121 or part 135 operators already are taking some level of care to ensure that repair stations know which certificate holders carry hazmat. The only additional step may be the written verification.

V.10. Foreign Locations

V.10. Foreign Locations

Comment

NATA and ATA opposed the exception for certificate holders operating at foreign locations in proposed § 121.803(f) (adopted as § 121.1005(f)). NATA believed that this exception should be standard operating procedures regardless of whether local labor laws require the certificate holder to use persons working in that country to load and unload aircraft, given the logistical problems of training and recordkeeping for part 135 operators.

Comment

ATA commented that workers in foreign locations already receive function-specific hazmat training and follow the ICAO Technical Instructions. Current FAA rules require "supervision" by a trained person of loading, offloading, and handling of dangerous goods by persons who have not had the FAA-approved training. The commenter stated, "ATA believed that the proposal would unreasonably narrow the exception for untrained employees working under supervision by restricting the exception to loading and unloading." Thus, ATA argued that any other handling of hazmat would have to be done by someone who has had the extensive training, regardless of supervision. For loading and unloading, the trained person would have to provide "direct visual supervision." The commenter added that, in situations where there is more than one flight being worked, particularly at hubs, this is unworkable. There is no compromise of safety in continuing to allow the trained person to supervise by giving appropriate direction and follow-up, enabling him or her to handle more than one issue at once.

FAA Response

FAA Response

The FAA believes that the loading with untrained workers should not be standard operating procedures at foreign locations regardless of local labor laws. This is consistent with current FAA hazmat training regulations. Since the FAA is now closely aligning the final rule with the 2005 edition of the ICAO TI and IATA DGR requirements, general training should be more standardized. In the final rule, the FAA is also removing the term "unloading" from the list of specific covered job functions listed in Sec. § 121.1001 and 135.501. Thus, part 121 and part 135 operators should find it easier to obtain trained workers to use in completing these hazmat job functions. Under the exception adopted in the final rule, loading with untrained workers can be performed only if the labor laws of the foreign country require that the certificate holder uses persons who work in that country, and the worker performs the loading function under the direct visual supervision of a trained worker. The existing rule does not require visual supervision of the untrained worker. However, in the NPRM the FAA proposed such a requirement, and this requirement is adopted in the final rule. The certificate holder can use a non-supervisory person trained to load the aircraft, provided they are authorized to directly supervise the untrained worker in the performance of this function. The FAA has determined that requiring a trained supervisor to visually observe the performance of the untrained person's duties is an important step towards eliminating the possibility of undeclared discoverable hazmat or improperly shipped hazmat from being loaded onto the aircraft.

The current exception also includes the term "handling;" however, the proposal removed that term because it was confusing to regulated entities. The FAA has understood the term "handling," as used in the current CFR, to refer to the handling that would be required during the loading of the aircraft. The industry's application, however, has been inconsistent. Although the FAA is eliminating this term, the FAA still recognizes that those people who load must handle the cargo. The removal of the term "handling," however, eliminates any confusion over the breadth of the exception.

V.11. Recordkeeping Requirements

V.11. Recordkeeping Requirements

V.11.A. Location

Comments

A number of commenters raised concerns with the proposed amendments to the recordkeeping requirements. The proposed rule would have required the certificate holder to maintain signed records of each training course for the last three years. ATA Airlines noted that this is not in keeping with current practices that allow paper records to be discarded after 90 days if they are entered into an automated record keeping system. ATA encouraged the FAA to accept a centralized, computerized corporate record that is accessible by field locations. Many of the carriers stated that they have electronic files and databases and oppose a manual file system as a step backwards.

Comments

The proposed rule also would have required that the records be maintained at the location where the person performs or supervises the hazmat function. Many commenters opposed this proposed requirement. ALPA stated that records should be maintained "at the company headquarters or at a facility that is charged with keeping such records." Columbia Helicopters noted that because many certificate holders affected by the NPRM operate from multiple sites, frequently rotating aircrew and maintenance personnel "moving records is an unnecessary burden and greatly increases the likelihood of loss or administrative error." All commenters agreed that allowing computer records that can be accessed from various locations is the best option.

The proposed rule also would require the certificate holder to maintain records on its independent contractors and subcontractors. UPS believed that the certificate holder should not have to maintain records for its contractors and subcontractors. It stated that such a requirement may blur the relationship and "give rise to a presumption that personnel employed by the contractor are employees of the certificate holder." FAA Response

The FAA agrees with the commenters that the worker training records should not be required to be kept as a written record. In the final rule, the FAA is clarifying that the part 121 and part 135 operators have the responsibility to determine the method of recordkeeping (electronic, manual, etc). This allows the certificate holder to manage its recordkeeping program in a manner appropriate to its business. The worker training records may be maintained by any method (including electronic). The records may be maintained in a central location provided that they can be made available upon request at the location of the employee. Contractors performing or directly supervising a job function listed in Sec. § 121.1001 or 135.501 for, or on behalf of a part 121 or part 135 operator will be required to comply with the training requirements of 14 CFR. A certificate holder is responsible for ensuring that its workers are properly trained. A contractor performing or directly supervising a job function listed in Sec. § 121.1001 or 135.501 for, or on behalf of the part 121 or part 135 operator represents the same responsibility to the certificate holder as a direct employee. Therefore, since the part 121 or part 135 operator is responsible for maintaining the records for all direct employees performing or directly supervising a function listed in Sec. § 121.1001 or 135.501 for, or on behalf of the part 121 or part 135 operator, it should also be responsible for maintaining the records of contractors performing or directly supervising the same job functions.

V.11.B. Content

V.11.B. Content

Comment

A number of carriers commented on the signature requirement in the proposed recordkeeping rule. Proposed Sec. § 121.804(c)(3) and 135.504(c)(3) (adopted as Sec. § 121.1007 and 135.507) would have required training records to be signed by a person designated by the Director of Training. ASTAR Air Cargo pointed out that § 121.401(c) states: "When the certification required by this paragraph is made by an entry in a computerized recordkeeping system, the certifying instructor, supervisor, or check airman must be identified with that entry. However, the signature of the certifying instructor, supervisor, or check airman is not required for computerized entries." ASTAR along with ATA Airlines, Southwest, Chautauqua Airlines, Ameristar, FedEx, AMR Corporation, and the Air Transport Association all supported eliminating the signature requirement. Ameristar, Fed Ex, ATA and AMR Corporation also pointed out that there is no Director of Training, so requiring that individual's signature implies a requirement that is not possible.

Comment

ASTAR also believed that the description of the training course required by proposed Sec. § 121.804(c)(4) and 135.504(c)(4) (adopted as Sec. § 121.1007 and 135.507) is redundant and not required since a full description of the training program is contained in the FAA-approved Training Manual. FAA Response

The FAA agrees with the commenters' suggestions, and in the final rule, the FAA is eliminating the requirement for the signature. The FAA also did not intend to require that certificate holders employ a Director of Training. The FAA is instead requiring that the individual who is providing the hazmat training be identified on the training record. The contents of the training records will be the same as 49 CFR 172.704(d), ICAO TI 1;4.2.4, and IATA DGR 1;1.5.4.1. The FAA is harmonizing the contents to eliminate duplication of recordkeeping. The same records required under this rulemaking can be used for compliance with all hazmat regulations having the same requirements (49 CFR 172.704(d), ICAO TI 1;4.2.4, and IATA DGR 1;1.5.4.1).

V.12. Curriculum--Proposed Appendix N (Adopted as Appendix O)

V.12. Curriculum--Proposed Appendix N (Adopted as Appendix O)

Comments

Many commenters stated that the training curriculum set forth in proposed Appendix N (adopted as Appendix O) goes beyond the knowledge needed to fulfill the given job function. ATA and Southwest Airlines called the training "excessive." ATA went on to argue that "excessive training inundates employees with needless information and requirements that are extraneous to their specific responsibilities and--at best--distracts from the central purpose of job specific training, diluting the effect of training on material relevant to their function. At worst, it confuses employees about their assigned roles and responsibilities."

Comments

United and Midwest Airlines urged the FAA to abandon the idea of a one-size-fits-all training program and allow the certificate holder to tailor the training subject matter to the employee's job functions. Chautauqua Airlines stated that its current program has been approved by the FAA, but would not be acceptable under the proposed rule since the programs are not divided into specific modules. Chautauqua argued that to prepare a hazmat program that follows the prescribed curriculum "would require significant efforts by various business unit training organizations internal to CHQ, costing both time and money."

AMR Corporation explains that a flight attendant will greet a customer and/or help a customer with luggage after the customer has interfaced with at least one of its agents trained in dangerous goods acceptance, and after passing through TSA-controlled checkpoint where security screeners are tasked with looking for threatening objects. Flight attendants are trained in the safety of the passenger. They are trained to handle a situation in flight where a substance may be leaking or found to be inappropriate in the cabin. Training in documentation checks and acceptance guidelines would not increase the awareness or effectiveness of these employees in identifying hidden dangerous goods.

Furthermore, AMR Corporation noted that its dispatchers do not supervise the loading, nor do they perform other load planning functions. The commenter added that a dispatcher may be tasked with contacting Air Traffic Control, Airport Rescue and Fire Fighting, or the Federal Aviation Administration; however, dangerous goods acceptance training would not improve his or her ability to assist the flight crew.

NATA stated that persons required to be trained on Module 6 but not 5, should not be required to be trained on Module 8. In order to do their jobs properly, NATA said that these persons do not need to know the "use of hazardous materials tables, proper shipping names, hazard class definitions, UN/ID numbers, or packing groups" as described in Module 8. ATA believed that the FAA could greatly alleviate the unnecessary burden by aligning them with the ICAO Technical Instructions. The ICAO TI allows the carrier to tailor the training content for each employee group, making it commensurate with job duties of the specific employees in question.

ASTAR Air Cargo made a similar request and urged the FAA to include the statement "Each Hazmat employee must be provided only that function specific training concerning each of the areas of training which are specifically applicable to the operation the employee performs." ASTAR pointed out that this suggested language is nearly identical to that of CFR title 49 and would allow operators to tailor the training as necessary.

ATA Airlines, Delta, and UPS believed that proposed Table 1, which defined training requirements based on Job Function defined by Categories of Personnel, is confusing and will require interpretation. ATA also stated that there is no differentiation between levels of knowledge required based on actual involvement in the dangerous materials transport process. UPS wanted the rule to clarify that the level of training should be commensurate with the employee's responsibilities. UPS urged the FAA to place proposed Appendix N into an advisory circular so that certificate holders would have greater flexibility in structuring their own training programs.

As stated in the comments submitted by ATA, "ATA's will-not-carry members also have FAA-approved training programs that provide for HMR instruction. Indeed, even though they do not transport hazmat, they provide recognition training to acceptance employees to enable them to recognize and refuse hazmat if it is offered to their carrier." Furthermore ATA stated that carriers provide "persons engaged in passenger and baggage check-in services (e.g., skycaps, ticket counter agents, flight attendants, etc.) with recognition training and function-specific training on relevant hazmat topics." ATA also stated "the FAA could greatly alleviate the unnecessary burden on carriers by specifically authorizing them, as the ICAO Technical Instructions provide, to tailor training content for each employee group, making it commensurate with job duties of the specific employees in question. The ICAO Technical Instructions are a reasonable starting point for that assessment. This allows carriers to plan in accordance with their own business structures."

Express.Net Airlines was concerned that no standard exists for the length of time necessary to conduct training and points to the FAA's publication "FAA National Operations and Training Manual for the Acceptance and Transport of Dangerous Goods in Air Transportation." In that document, the FAA recommends an 8-hour initial training program and a 2-hour recurrent training program for operators that elect to carry hazmat.

ALPA believed that the proposed modules listed for pilot crewmembers are adequate provided that the training is "specifically tailored for the duties and responsibilities of the flight crew member." ALPA requested that the FAA add a note to Tables 1 and 2 stating that "Awareness-level training of components within a module may be appropriate if the person (employee) does not actually perform those functions."

Atlas Air asked the FAA to clarify whether all-cargo carriers and passenger carriers would be required to follow the same curriculum.

Jet Arizona, Aviation Services Unlimited, and Southwest Airlines commented on recognition training for will-not-carry operators. Jet Arizona believed that will-not-carry certificate holders should only be required to train to the level required for their crews to recognize hazmat for the purposes of preventing it from being loaded on that company's aircraft. It believed that additional training creates an unnecessary burden that the FAA has not justified adequately with data. Aviation Services Unlimited also commented that to require operators to change their already-successful programs only unnecessarily increases the burden.

Ameristar Air Cargo suggested that in Module 13 the FAA delete the words "Policies and procedures regarding handling, packaging, and transport of hazardous materials moving by means other than air." The commenter said that this element leaves too much interpretation to the FAA inspector approving a hazardous materials program. The commenter suggested the following language: "Applicable policies and procedures regarding handling, packaging, and transport of hazardous materials moving by means other than air."

Express.Net Airlines noted that Table 1 of proposed Appendix N was incomplete because Module 10 `Notice to Pilot-in-Command' training would not have been required for category 3 workers; "persons who handle, store, and load or unload packages, passenger baggage or cargo" on the aircraft.

Menlo Worldwide Forwarding recommended that an additional exception be included in the rule to allow the establishment of a stand-alone training and supervision program administered by an integrated freight forwarder that contracts multiple certificate holders to transport dangerous goods and is subject to review and approval of the FAA. The commenter added that air carriers would incorporate the training regimen into their approved programs by referring to the integrated freight forwarder's training program and services in their Operations Manuals.

Direct Flight stated that simply because requirements may be suitable for a part 135 scheduled commuter airline does not mean those requirements are appropriate for a small on-demand carrier simply because the way each operates is very different. Continental believed that the NPRM inappropriately combined part 121 and part 135 duties together. Continental stated that "there are many specific duties for Part 135 carriers that do not apply to a Part 121 carrier. For example, there are many Part 135 carriers that will have their flight crews assigned to tasks that are not performed by the flight crew of Part 121 carriers (i.e., loading baggage and cargo into the airplane)." FAA Response

Many commenters disagreed with the proposal to mandate curriculum for a part 121 or part 135 operator's hazmat training program. The FAA agrees, and in the final rule the FAA is closely aligning the training requirements in 14 CFR parts 121 and 135 with those in the 2005 edition of the ICAO TI and the IATA DGR. The certificate holders believed that the ICAO TI standards are the best common reference point to facilitate the uniform, seamless handling of hazmat in international air transportation. By accepting the operator's comments indicating that only part 121 and part 135 operators themselves can develop specific detailed hazmat training curricula, the FAA believes that the need to provide model hazardous material training programs has been reduced. The direction taken by the ICAO Dangerous Goods Panel in 2002 (published in the 2005-2006 edition of the ICAO TI and IATA DGR) was a departure from the traditional "categories of staff" to a task-oriented (function-specific) approach, which is the same approach the FAA is adopting. Additionally, in the final rule, the FAA closely aligns the required training for persons performing or directly supervising job functions listed in § 121.1001 or § 135.501 for, or on behalf of a will-not-carry certificate holder with the requirements for handling only non-dangerous goods in the 2005 edition of the ICAO TI. The training standards will apply to both all-cargo and passenger carriers.

The part 121 or part 135 operators will also be required to provide training on any operator specific policies and procedures not specifically mentioned in new Appendix O. The FAA believes that each certificate holder currently trains all employees in their individual policies and procedures, so this should not be an additional burden. This allows part 121 or part 135 operators to train in accordance with their own business structures. If a certificate holder's training program differs from the ICAO TI format, it should discuss this with the FAA during the approval process.

Therefore, in the final rule the FAA is clarifying that the part 121 or part 135 operator has the responsibility to determine which employees meet the job function requirement to train, the level of training required, the delivery method of administering the training, including a test to verify comprehension, and the method of recordkeeping (electronic, certificate, etc). The FAA is not specifying requirements for these processes. The FAA believes these amendments will allow the certificate holder to manage their FAA approved hazmat training programs as appropriate. The final rule will not contain the training modules. Instead, Table 1--Operators That Transport Hazardous Materials--Will-Carry Certificate Holders, and Table 2--Operators That Do Not Transport Hazardous Materials--Will-Not-Carry Certificate Holders, will provide the minimum aspects to be covered in the part 121 and part 135 operator's hazmat training program for each job function performed. These minimum requirements will apply to persons performing or directly supervising the job function.

Given the changes that the FAA is making to the final rule, the FAA anticipates that most part 121 or part 135 operators should not have to substantially change their training programs if their current FAA-approved hazmat training program contains the minimum requirements required by 2005 edition of the ICAO TI and IATA DGR. Standards for will-not-carry training will require that both part 121 and part 135 will-not-carry certificate holders conduct recognition training to assist persons directly supervising or performing a job function covered in Appendix O, Table 2, identifying possible undeclared, as well as declared, hazmat.

The specific job function specified in Appendix O will determine the training required. In-depth training is intended to give detailed knowledge of the requirements pertaining to the specific job function that the person performs. General-awareness training is intended to provide a general overview of the regulatory scheme.

V.13. Training Method

V.13. Training Method

Comments

Atlas Air, Northwest Airlines, AMR Corporation, Express.Net Airlines and ALPA were concerned that the proposed requirement would eliminate computer-based training. In addition, the proposed rule would require an interactive instructor to be available to address any questions or concerns. ALPA believed that recent changes in computer-based training have made that possible. The Dangerous Goods Council urged the FAA to allow an electronic instructor to be used who could be immediately available by instant message, e-mail or phone. FAA Response

Comments

Part 121 or part 135 operators have the responsibility for ensuring that the specific level and duration of hazmat training is adequate and appropriate for each worker. While the responsibility for providing the hazmat training remains with the certificate holder, the FAA has the responsibility for approving the hazmat training program. Hazmat training may be provided by company training programs, computer-based programs, self-guided CD training programs, outside training firms or consultants, educational institutions, or any other type of organization offering training. Electronic instruction is permitted and an on-site instructor is not required. Hazmat training may be provided by the part 121 or part 135 operator or other public or private sources, including training classes that are offered by the IATA to the extent that the IATA training satisfies the FAA-approved hazmat training program. The part 121 or part 135 operator must ensure that the hazmat training program provides a method to respond to students' questions prior to certifying completion of the training and that all persons are tested to verify understanding of the regulations and requirements.

V.14. Single-Pilot Operations

V.14. Single-Pilot Operations

Comments

Several commenters were concerned that the FAA did not adequately address the issue of the single-pilot operation in the proposed rule. NATA provided an example of a part 135 on-demand carrier using Cessna Caravans (which require only one pilot) in a cargo configuration to regularly transport newspapers for delivery. On occasion, the newspaper employee delivering or picking up the newspapers may assist the pilot in the loading or unloading of these papers. NATA believed that proposed § 135.503(a) would require the certificate holder to provide hazmat training of this helpful person. NATA saw no justification for this restrictive requirement. The pilot instead could be trained as a supervisor and then permit the newspaper employee to assist in performance of the transport-related function under direct supervision similar to the requirements of the foreign locations exception (see proposed § 135.503(f)). NATA believed that, given the nature of part 135 on-demand operations, which use any and all airports on short notice, the principle of direct supervision is reasonable as a general rule rather than the exception.

Comments

Direct Flight Inc. also urged the FAA to-- (1) clarify the notation "would remain subject to the hazmat training requirements in § 135.333," since the proposal removes § 135.333; and (2) drop that portion of the NPRM which applies to small, will-not-carry, on-demand part 135 operators and instead retain the language contained in § 135.333(c). FAA Response

In the final rule, the FAA is deleting the language "would remain subject to the hazmat training requirements in § 135.333," since that language is only applicable to the current hazmat training requirements. Hazmat training requirements are being relocated in subpart K.

The part 135 operator has the responsibility for ensuring that the level of training is adequate and appropriate for each employee. In the situation described by NATA, the FAA agrees that the pilot could be trained in accordance with the FAA's hazmat regulations and supervise the loading function pursuant to § 135.505. The on-demand operator or an operator using one person for loading has the responsibility for determining the adequacy of training. This is consistent with current requirements under § 135.333(d). In fact, the requirements under § 135.333(d) have been expanded because under the final rule, single-pilot operators can use the new-hire exception. Single-pilot operators also will only be required to conduct recurrent training every 24 months once the FAA harmonizes the recurrent training with international and industry standards.

V.15. Repair Stations (Part 145)--General

V.15. Repair Stations (Part 145)--General

Comment

One commenter noted that it does not appear that the repair stations have any transitional period. ATA noted that carriers already notify repair stations of their will-carry or will-not-carry status and their procedures for HMR compliance. FAA Response

Comment

The final rule does not contain a transitional period to allow part 145 repair stations to train their workers because part 145 repair station workers are already required to be trained if they are hazmat employees, as defined in 49 CFR 171.8. Repair stations that perform or directly supervise a job function listed in Sec. § 121.1001 or 135.501 for, or on behalf of a part 121 or part 135 operator would need to be trained in accordance with the FAA's requirements as well. This is the same requirement for any contractor or subcontractor performing or directly supervising a job function listed in Sec. § 121.1001 or 135.501 for, or on behalf of a part 121 or part 135 operator. For instance, part 145 repair stations performing work for, or on behalf of will-not-carry certificate holders who perform loading functions for the part 121 or part 135 operators will need to be hazmat trained during the 15-month transition period. Additionally, most part 121 and part 135 operators have indicated that they currently notify the repair stations of their status (will-carry or will-not-carry). Consequently, the notification requirement adopted by the FAA in the final rule should not pose an additional burden. In the final rule, the FAA is simply making notification mandatory and enforceable.

The requirement to certify to the FAA that all hazmat employees have been trained as required by 49 CFR 172.704(d) is satisfied by providing copies of the records required by 49 CFR 172.704(d), or by submitting a letter from an authorized representative of the repair station indicating that all hazmat employees are trained in accordance with 49 CFR. The only additional hazmat training requirement would be for the repair station employees who directly supervise or perform a job function listed in § 121.1001 or § 135.501 for, or on behalf of the part 121 or part 135 operators, such as loading the certificate holder's aircraft for transport. The FAA believes that only a very small percentage, if any, of part 145 repair station employees actually load the part 121 or part 135 operator's aircraft for transport unless the repair station also is certified under part 121 or part 135 which would impose the requirements of part 121 or part 135 of 14 CFR currently. Comment

ALPA agreed with the FAA's decision to include part 145 Aircraft Repair Stations in the NPRM. The commenter said that a significant potential exists that materials or components being shipped to, shipped from, or returned to service could contain hazardous materials. Northwest Airlines, AMR Corporation, Midwest Airlines, and NATA were concerned that the training program for repair stations would be burdensome because repair stations would have to be trained and current in every carrier's hazmat program. AMR Corporation noted that repair stations will simply pass the cost of training down to the certificate holder. AMR Corporation stated that "if the FAA established repair stations as "shippers" and regulated the shipping community, the FAA could go further in promoting safety in this area.

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 271 passages shown