AC 60-22 Aeronautical Decision Making
Provides introductory material, background information, and reference material on aeronautical decision making. Provides a systematic approach to risk assessment and stress management in aviation, illustrates how personal attitudes can influence decision
Text read by OCR from a scanned file. Check the original, as some words may be misread.
U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory
Circular
Subject: AERONAUTICAL DECISION MAKING
1. PURPOSE. This Advisory Circular (AC) provides introductory material, background information, and reference material on Aeronautical Decision Making (ADM). The material in this AC provides a systematic approach to risk assessment and stress management in aviation, illustrates how personal attitudes can influence decision making and how those attitudes can be modified to enhance safety in the cockpit. This AC also provides instructors with methods for teaching ADM techniques and skills in conjunction with conventional flight instruction. However, this AC is not intended to replace the complete body of knowledge contained in the ADM related reference materials listed in paragraph 4, but rather to support them and to serve as a catalyst for further study.
2. APPLICATION. The material contained in this AC is applicable to pilots who operate airplanes or helicopters under Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR) Parts 61, 91, 121, 125, 133, 135, and 141.
3. FOCUS. This AC is designed to explain the risks associated with aviation activities to pilots. Underlying behavioral causes of typical accidents and the effects of stress on ADM are emphasized. These materials provide a means for an individual to develop an "Attitude Profile" through a self-assessment inventory and provide detailed explanations of preflight and in-flight stress management techniques. The assumption is that persons exposed to these behavioral techniques will develop a positive attitude toward
Date: 12/13/91 AC No: 60-22 Initiated by: AFS-820
safety and learn ways to manage stress while recognizing and avoiding unnecessary risk. This AC is a learning tool that will help enable a person to make an intelligent determination as to the risk involved before beginning a flight. It is intended that the reader recognize risk factors such as weather, weight and balance, recency of experience, environment, and cockpit stress management so as to deal effectively with them.
4. RELATED REFERENCE MATERIAL. Twelve years of ADM research, development, and testing culminated in 1987 with thc publication of six manuals oriented to the decision making needs of variously rated pilots. These manuals provide multifaceted matcrials designed to reduce the number of decision related accidents (the type of accidents which account for 52 percent of fatal general aviation pilot error accidents). The effectiveness of these materials has been validated in six independent studies where student pilots received such training in conjunction with the standard flying curriculum. When tested, the pilots who had received ADM training made fewer in-flight errors than those who had not received ADM training. The differences were statistically significant and ranged from about 10 to 50 percent fewer judgment errors. In the operational environment, an operator flying about 400,000 hours annually demonstrated a 54 percent reduction in accident rate after using these materials for recurrency training. For detailed information regarding exposure to risk assessment, stress management, interpersonal
crew coordination and communication, and other ADM techniques, the reader is directed to one or more of the manuals which may be obtained from National Technical Information Service.
a. Published Documents. (Price of individual documents is subject to change without notice.)
Report Number Title
DOT/FAA/PM-86/41 Aeronautical Decision Making for Student and Private Pilots. NTIS identification number ADA182549, price $23.00.
DOT/FAA/PM-86/42 Aeronautical Decision Making for Commercial Pilots. NTIS identification number ADA198772, price $17.00.
DOT/FAA/PM-86/43 Aeronautical Decision Making for Instrument Pilots. NTIS identification number N8724880, price $17.00.
DOT/FAA/PM-86/44 Aeronautical Decision Making for Instructor Pilots (how to teach ADM). NTIS identification number ADA182611, price $17.00.
DOT/FAA/PM-86/45 Aeronautical Decision Making for Helicopter Pilots. NTIS identification number ADA180325, price $23.00.
ii
Report Number Title
DOT/FAA/PM-86/46 Aeronautical Decision Making Cockpit Rësource Management. NTIS identification number ADA205115, price $23.00.
b. Any of the series of ADM training manuals may be obtained by writing or calling:
Mailing Address: National Technical Information Service 5285 Port Royal Road Springfield, Virginia 22161
Telephone: (703) 487-4650 (orders) (800) 336-4700 (rush orders only) (703) 478-4780 (title identification branch)
5. DEFINITIONS.
a. ADM is a systematic approach to the mental process used by aircraft pilots to consistently determine the best course of action in response to a given set of circumstances.
b. Attitude is a personal motivational predisposition to respond to persons, situations, or events in a given manner that can, nevertheless, be changed or modified through training. A sort of mental shortcut to decision making.
c. Attitude Management is the ability to recognize hazardous attitudes in oneself and the willingness to modify them as necessary through the application of an : appropriate antidote thought.
d. Cockpit Resource Management, (CRM), in multiperson crew configurations, is the effective use of all personnel and material
Par 4
assets available to a flight crew. CRM emphasizes good communication and other interpersonal relationship skills.
e. Headwork is required to accomplish a conscious, rational thought process when making decisions. Good decision making involves risk identification and assessment, information processing, and problem solving.
f. Judgment is the mental process of recognizing and analyzing all pertinent information in a particular situation, a rational evaluation of alternative actions in response to it, and a timely decision on which action to take.
g. Personality is the embodiment of personal traits and characteristics of an individual that are set at a very early age and extremely resistant to change.
h. Poor Judgment (PJ) Chain is a series of mistakes that may lead to an accident or incident. Two basic principles generally associated with the creation of a PJ chain are: (1) one bad decision often leads to another; and (2) as a string of bad decisions grows, it reduces the number of subsequent alternatives for continued safe flight. ADM is intended to break the PJ chain before it can cause an accident or incident.
i. Risk Management is the part of the decision making process which relies on situational awareness, problem recognition, and good judgment to reduce risks associated with each flight.
j. Risk Elements in ADM take into consideration the four fundamental risk elements: the pilot, the aircraft, the environment, and the
Thomas C. Accardi Director, Flight Standards Service
Par 5
type of operation that comprise any given aviation situation.
k. Situational Awareness is the accurate perception and understanding of all the factors and conditions within the four fundamental risk elements that affect safety before, during, and after the flight.
1. Skills and Procedures are the procedural, psychomotor, and perceptual skills used to control a specific aircraft or its systems. They are the stick and rudder or airmanship abilities that are gained through conventional training, are perfected, and become almost automatic through experience.
m. Stress Management is the personal analysis of the kinds of stress experienced while flying, the application of appropriate stress assessment tools, and other coping mechanisms.
n. VOR is a very high frequency omnidirectional range station.
6. COMMENTS INVITED. Comments regarding this publication should be directed to:
Federal Aviation Administration Flight Standards National Field Office, AFS-500 (Advisory Circular Staff) P.O. Box 20034, Gateway Building Dulles International Airport Washington, DC 20041-2034
Every comment will not necessarily generate a direct acknowledgement to the commenter. Comments received will be considered in the development of upcoming revisions to AC's or other related technical material.
iii (and iv)
CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
1. General 2. ADM Process 3. Conventional Decision Making 4. Operational Pitfalls
CHAPTER 2. HAZARDOUS ATTITUDE INVENTORY
5. Attitude Assessment Test . 6. Self-Assessment Hazardous Attitude Inventory Test 7. Instructions for Taking the Self-Assessment Hazardous Attitude Inventory Test . . 8. Scoring Instructions 9. Attitude Profile. 10. Sample Situations for Advanced Rated Pilots . 11. Profile Explanation . 12. Summary .
CHAPTER 3. DEALING WITH HAZARDOUS ATTITUDES
CHAPTER 3. DEALING WITH HAZARDOUS ATTITUDES
13. Hazardous Attitudes . 14. Antidotes for Hazardous Attitudes 15. Antidote Recall Exercise ... 16. The Importance of Reinforcement Exercises 17. Instructions for Using Reinforcement Exercises
CHAPTER 4. STRESS AND FLYING
18. What Is Stress 19. How Much Stress Is in Your Life? 20. Is Stress Bad 21. Handling Stress In Flying
CHAPTER 5. RISK MANAGEMENT
CHAPTER 5. RISK MANAGEMENT
22. Assessing Risk . 23. The Decide Model
Page No.
11
11 11 11 12 12
17
17 17 17 17
21
21 21
CONTENTS (Continued)
CHAPTER 6. IDENTIFYING THE ENEMY . .
24. General 25. Personal Checklist 26. How To Be A Safe Pilot 27. Development of Good Decision Making Skills . . . 28. Successful Decision Making
CHAPTER 7. TEACHING ADM ...
29. Purpose . 30. Background 31. The Flight Instructor's Role in ADM Training 32. Principles of ADM Training . .. . 33. Teaching the Behavioral Aspects of ADM ... 34. Teaching the Application Exercises . . . 35. In-Flight Instruction: The Lesson Plans 36. In-Flight Instruction: The Training Scenario . 37. Typical Training Scenarios . .. 38. Management of ADM Training
Page No. 23
.23 23 24 24 25
27
27 27 27 27 28 28 29 29 29 29
APPENDIX 1. SAMPLE ATTITUDE INVENTORY ANSWER SHEET … (1 Page)
APPENDIX 1. SAMPLE ATTITUDE INVENTORY ANSWER SHEET … (1 Page)
APPENDIX 2. SCORING FORM
APPENDIX 3. ATTITUDE PROFILE
APPENDIX 4. ANTIDOTE RECALL EXERCISE
APPENDIX 5. LIFE EVENTS STRESS TEST
vi
.. (1 Page)
.. . (1 Page)
. . (1 Page)
. (1 Page)
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
1. GENERAL. Contrary to popular opinion, Steps for good decision making are: good judgment can be taught. Heretofore it was supposed to be gained only as a natural by-product (1) Identifying personal attitudes hazarof experience. As pilots continued to log acci- dous to safe flight. dent-free flight hours, a corresponding increase of good judgment was also assumed. (2) Leaming behavior modification techniques. 2. ADM PROCESS. (3) Leaming how to recognize and cope a. ADM builds upon the foundation of con- with stress. ventional decision making (figure 1), but enhances the process to decrease the probability of pilot (4) Developing risk assessment skills. error. ADM provides a structured, systematic approach to analyzing changes that occur during a (5) Using all resources in a multicrew flight and how these changes might affect a flight's situation. safe outcome. The ADM process addresses all aspects of decision making in the cockpit and iden- (6) Evaluating the effectiveness of one's tifies the steps involved in good decision making. ADM skills.
PILOT AIRCRAFT ENVIRONMENT OPERATION
PILOT AIRCRAFT ENVIRONMENT OPERATION
SITUATION
CHANGE/EVENT OCCURS
RECOGNIZE CHANGE
PROCEDURES SKILLS & RESPONSE SELECT TYPE HEADWORK REQUIRED
INADEQUATE INADEQUATE
MISHAPS!
FIGURE 1. CONVENTIONAL DECISION MAKING PROCESS
Chap 1 Par 1 1
AC 60- 22 12/13/91
3. CONVENTIONAL DECISION MAKING. this point in the process, the pilot is faced with a need to evaluate the entire range of possible rea. In conventional decision making, the sponses to the detected change and to determine need for a decision is triggered by recognition that the best course of action. something has changed or an expected change did not occur. Recognition of the change, or non- b. Figure 2 illustrates the ADM process, change, in the situation is a vital step in any how this process expands conventional decision decision making process. Not noticing the change making, and shows the interactions of the ADM in the situation can lead directly to a mishap steps and how these steps can produce a safe (figure 1). The change indicates that an appro- outcome. Starting with the recognition of change, priate response or action is necessary in order to and following with an assessment of alternatives, modify the situation (or, at least, one of the ele- a decision to act or not act is made, and the results ments that comprise it) and bring about a desired are monitored. ADM enhances the conventional new situation. Therefore, situational awareness is decision making process with an awareness of the the key to successful and safe decision making. At importance of attitudes in decision making, a
PILOT AIRCRAFT ENVIRONMENT MISSION
PILOT AIRCRAFT ENVIRONMENT MISSION
SITUATION
EVENT CHANGE
SKILLS & RESPONSE SELECT HEADWORK PROCEDURES TYPE REQUIRED
ATTITUDE MANAGEMENT
CREW (ir present) STRESS HEADWORK RESPONSE MANAGEMENT MANAGEMENT PROCESS
(Post-Situation) CRITIQUE ACTIONS MANAGEMENT RISK
FIGURE 2. AERONAUTICAL DECISION MAKING PROCESS
FIGURE 2. AERONAUTICAL DECISION MAKING PROCESS
Chap 1 2 Par 3
learned ability to search for and establish the e. Scud Running. Pushing the capabilities relevance of all information, and the motivation to of the pilot and the aircraft to the limits by trying choose and execute the actions which assure safety to maintain visual contact with the terrain while in a timeframe permitted by the situation. These trying to avoid physical contact with it. This elements of ADM are discussed in depth as they attitude is characterized by the old pilot's joke: "If relate to the specific discipline in each of the it's too bad to go IFR, we'll go VFR." training manuals. f. Continuing visual flight rules (VFR) into 4. OPERATIONAL PITFALLS. There are a instrument conditions often leads to spatial disorinumber of classic behavioral traps into which entation or collision with ground/obstacles. It is pilots have been known to fall.
Pilots, particularly even more dangerous if the pilot is not instrument those with considerable experience, as a rule qualified or current. always try to complete a flight as planned, please passengers, meet schedules, and generally demon- g. Getting Behind the Aircraft. Allowing strate that they have the "right stuff. This events or the situation to control your actions much-talked-about "right stuff' is a fragile image. rather than the other way around. Charactcrized by The basic drive to demonstrate the "right stuff' can a constant state of surprise at what happcns next. have an adverse effect on safety and can impose an unrealistic assessment of piloting skills under h. Loss of Positional or Situation Awarestressful conditions. These tendencies ultimately ness. Another case of getting behind the aircraft may lead to practices that are dangerous and often which results in not knowing where you are, an illegal, and may lead to a mishap.
All experienced inability to recognize deteriorating circumstances, pilots have fallen prey to, or have been tempted and/or the misjudgment of the rate of deterioration. by, one or more of these tendencies in their flying careers. These dangerous tendencies or behavior i. Operating Without Adequate Fuel Reserpatterns, which must be identified and eliminated, ves. Ignoring minimum fuel reserve requirements, include: either VFR or Instrument Flight Rules (IFR), is generally the result of overconfidence, lack of a. Peer Pressure. Poor decision making flight planning, or ignoring the regulations. based upon emotional response to peers rather than evaluating a situation objectively. j. Descent Below the Minimum Enroute b. Mind Set. The inability to recognize and Altitude. The duck-under syndrome (mcntioned cope with changes in the situation different from above) manifesting itself during the en route those anticipated or planned. portion of an IFR flight.
c. Get-There-Itis. This tendency, common among pilots, clouds the vision and impairs judg- k. Flying Outside the Envelope. Unjustificd ment by causing a fixation on the original goal or reliance on the (usually mistaken) belief that the destination combined with a total disregard for any aircraft's high performance capability meets thc alternative course of action. demands imposed by the pilot's (usually overestimated) flying skills. d. Duck-Under Syndrome. The tendency to sneak a peek by descending below minimums during an approach. Based on a belief that there is 1. Neglect of Flight Planning, Preflight Inalways a built-in "fudge" factor that can be used or spections, Checklists, Etc. Unjustified reliance on on an unwillingness to admit defeat and shoot a the pilot's short and long term memory, regular missed approach. flying skills, repetitive and familiar routes, etc.
Chap 1 Par 3 3 (and 4)
AC 60- 22
CHAPTER 2. HAZARDOUS ATTITUDE INVENTORY
CHAPTER 2. HAZARDOUS ATTITUDE INVENTORY
5. ATTITUDE ASSESSMENT TEST. In each ADM manual, a chapter addresses five hazardous attitudes that can affect a pilot's judgment, and. how these hazardous attitudes can have an impact on safe flying. Subsequent chapters in each of the ADM manuals provide methods of modifying these hazardous attitudes.
6. SELF-ASSESSMENT HAZARDOUS ATTI- TUDE INVENTORY TEST. Each ADM student should take the Self-Assessment Hazardous Attitude Inventory Test in order to gain a realistic perspective on his/her attitudes toward flying. The inventory test requires the pilot to provide a response which most accurately reflects the reasoning behind his/her decision. The pilot must choose one of the five given reasons for making that decision, even though the pilot may not consider any of the five choices acceptable. The inventory test presents extreme cases of incorrect pilot decision making in an effort to introduce the five types of hazardous attitudes described in Chapter 3 of this AC.
7. INSTRUCTIONS FOR TAKING THE SELF-ASSESSMENT HAZARDOUS ATTI- TUDE INVENTORY TEST.
a. Read over each of the six situations and the five choices contained in the inventory test. Keep in mind that there are no correct answers.
b. Decide which one of the five choices is the most likely reason for the decision made. Using a copy of the Attitude Inventory Answer Sheet (appendix 1), place the number 5 in the space provided.
c. Continue by ranking in declining order the remaining four probable reasons from 4 (next most likely) to 3, 2, and 1 (least likely) until all five blanks have been filled. (Figure 3 provides an example of how the alternatives might be ranked.)
Chap 2 Par 5
Situation 1 (Example)
a. __1__ (your least likely reason)
b. _3_
c. _5__ (your most likely reason)
d. _2
e. _4
FIGURE 3. SAMPLE SET OF RANK ORDERED ANSWERS
FIGURE 3. SAMPLE SET OF RANK ORDERED ANSWERS
Situation 1. You are on a flight to an unfamiliar, rural airport. Flight service states that VFR flight is not recommended since heavy coastal fog is forecast to move into the destination airport area about the time you expect to land. You first consider returning to your home base where visibility is still good, but decide instead to continue as planned and land safely after some problems. Why did you reach this decision?
a. You hate to admit that you cannot complete your original flight plan.
b. You resent the suggestion by flight service that you should change your mind.
c. You feel sure that things will tum out safely, and that there is no danger.
d. You reason that since your actions would make no real difference, you might as well continue.
e. You feel the need to decide quickly, so you take the simplest alternative.
AC 60-22 12/13/91
Situation 2. While taxiing for takeoff, you notice Situation 4. You were briefed about possible icing that your right brake pedal is softer than the left. conditions, but did not think there would be any Once airbome, you are sufficiently concerned problem since your departure airport temperature about the problem to radio for information. Since was 60 °F (15 C). As you near your destination, strong winds are reported at your destination, an you encounter freezing precipitation, which clings experienced pilot who is a passenger recommends to your aircraft. Your passenger, who is a more that you abandon the flight and return to your de- experienced pilot, begins to panic. You consider parture airport. You choose to continue the flight turning back to the departure airport, but continue and experience no further difficulties. Why did instead. Why did you not return? you continue? a. I have made it this far. What is the use in a. You feel that suggestions made in this turning back now? type of situation are usually overly cautious. b. The panic of the passenger makes you b. Your brakes have never failed before, so think it will not happen to me - I have encountered you doubt that they will this time. ice before and nothing happened.
c. You feel that you can leave the decision c. Why is he panicking? I can handle this to the tower at your destination. situation just like I have done before.
d. You immediately decide that you want to d. FAA regulations exaggerate the dangers continue. of icing. I can handle this situation.
e. You are sure that if anyone could handle e. I have got to do something. Descend! the landing, you can. That will make everyone realize that I am in control. Situation 3. Your regular airplane has been grounded because of an airframe problem. You are scheduled in another airplane and discover it is Situation 5. You do not bother to check weather a model you are not familiar with. After your conditions at your destination. En route, you enpreflight, you decide to take off on your business counter headwinds. Your fuel supply is adequate trip as planned. What was your reasoning? to reach your destination, but there is almost no reserve for emergencies. You continue the flight a. You feel that a difficult situation will not and land with a nearly dry tank. What most influarise so there is no reason not to go. enced you to do this?
b. You tell yourself that if there were any a. Being unhappy with the pressure of danger, you would not have been offered the plane. having to choose what to do, you make a snap decision. c. You are in a hurry and do not want to take the time to think of altemate choices. b. You do not want your friends to hear that you had to turn back. d. You do not want to admit that you may have trouble flying an unfamiliar airplane. c. You feel that flight manuals always understate the safety margin in fuel tank capacity. e. You are convinced that your flight instructor was much too conservative and pessimistic when he cautioned you to be thoroughly checked d. You believe that all things usually turm out in an unfamiliar aircraft. out well, and this will be no exception.
6 Chap 2 Par 7
6 Chap 2 Par 7
12/13/91 AC 60- 22
e. You reason that the situation has already _c. You must get to the business meeting been determined because the destination is closer in 2 hours and cannot wait. than any other airport. d. You don't allow an icing forecast to Situation 6. You are 40 minutes late for a trip in stop you; weather briefers are usually overly a small airplane. Since the aircraft handled well cautious. on the previous day's flight, you decide to skip most of the preflight check. What leads you to _e. There is nothing you can do about this decision? atmospheric conditions.
a. You simply take the first approach to Situation 8. Commercial Pilot ADM Situation. making up time that comes to mind. Your passengers have shown up almost an hour late. You are going to an airport that requires a b. You feel that your reputation for being on reservation. Which of the following alternatives time demands that you cut corners when necessary. best illustrates your reaction?
c. You believe that some of the preflight in- a. You think to yourself, if I hurry, spection is just a waste of time. maybe I can still make it.
d. You see no reason to think that something b. Nothing will happen if I miss this unfortunate will happen during this flight. reservation.
e. If any problems develop, the responsibil- c. I'm smart enough to talk our way in ity would not be yours. It is the maintenance of when we arrive. the airplane that really makes the difference. d. I can't help it if my passengers were 8. SAMPLE SITUATIONS FOR ADVANCED late. I don't control them. RATED PILOTS. e. The Feds wouldn't dare keep me out. a. Paragraph 7 presented examples of six situations from the student/private pilot ÀDM Situation 9. Helicopter Pilot ADM Situation. manual. For pilots with advanced ratings, the re- You are to fly a helicopter which you know is old maining ADM manuals provide similar situations and has been poorly maintained. A higher than and self-assessment tests. The following are normal turbine outiet temperature on startup is example situations taken from these texts. indicated, and you suspect the fuel control. Two fellow company pilots, travelling as passengers, do Situation 7. Instrument Pilot ADM Situation. not want to be delayed. After 5 minutes of debate, You plan an important business flight under you agree to make the trip. Why did you permit instrument conditions in an aircraft with no deicing yourself to be persuaded? equipment through an area in which light to moderate rime or mixed icing in clouds, and a. You feel that you must always prove precipitation above the freezing level has been your ability as a pilot, even under less than ideal forecast. You decide to make the trip, thinking: circumstances.
a. You believe your skills are good b. You believe that regulations overenough to handle ice accumulation on the aircraft. emphasize safety in this kind of situation.
b. You have been in this situation many c. You think that the fuel control will times and nothing has happened. certainly last for just one more flight.
Chap 2 Par 7 7
AC 60-22 12/13/91
_d. You feel that your opinion may be 10. ATTITUDE PROFILE. Using the total wrong since the two other pilots are willing to take scores for each Scale I-V from appendix 2, place the risk. an "X" on the corresponding scale profile in appendix 3. Notice that the score values run from _e. The thought of changing arrange- bottom to top, so that the highest value should be ments is annoying, so you jump at the suggestion at the highest point on the profile sheet. Straight of the other pilots. lines should be drawn from the score in each scale to the score in the next scale (connect the "X's") so that the profile resembles a graph. Note the Situation 10. Instructor Pilot ADM Situation. hazardous attitude shown at the bottom of each You perform a slip demonstration during an ap- scale on appendix 3. proach to landing and fly the aircraft to the left of the runway centerline to a position which would 11. PROFILE EXPLANATION.
The profile make an attempted landing possible but dangerous. graph indicates the comparative tendency for each You return control of the aircraft to the student and of the five hazardous attitudes. The higher the instruct him to "execute proper landing proce- relative rank (first, second, third, etc.), the greater dures. Which of the following best characterizes the propensity to respond with that hazardous attiyour attitude about putting the student and yourself tude. The pilot should keep in mind his/her results in this situation? while reviewing the explanation. An explanation of the pilot's profile starts with the description of a. I can always handle this even if he an all-too-common flight situation. can't. a. A pilot of a single-engine aircraft checks _b. Whatever happens, it's up to him the weather and notes that there is a possibility of now. a thunderstorm at the destination airport. The pilot has never operated an aircraft in bad weather and C. I've never had a problem doing this knows that a flight instructor would advise against in the past. flying.
Despite this knowledge, the pilot takes off, crashes in poor weather, and is seriously injured. The quicker we get through this, the better. b. Why does this occur so often? Because many accidents involve pilots who allow them- These aircraft can take a lot worse selves to be influenced by one or more of the five landings than the manuals suggest. basic hazardous attitudes. These attitudes get pilots into trouble by causing them to take chances 9. SCORING INSTRUCTIONS. After com- that invite an accident. (The five hazardous pleting the inventory test, transfer the responses for attitudes are the ones recorded on the assessment each alternative from the completed Attitude In- inventory just completed.) ventory Answer Sheet (appendix 1) to the appropriate section of the Scoring Form (appendix 2). 12. SUMMARY. Total the ranking scores for each scale and enter the total in the space provided at the bottom of a. The pilot should use the profile to detereach column.
The total score for each situation mine which hazardous attitudes dominated his/her must be 15, while the total for situations 1 through responses. The profile will illustrate which hazard- 6 must be 90. If the totals are not 15 and 90, ous thought patterns have a greater tendency to review for possible errors in the transfer of scores influence a pilot's judgment. The inventory test and check addition. These totals are then marked may indicate the actual tendency of the pilot; howon the Attitude Profile (appendix 3) where indi- ever, exhibiting attitudes similar to those described cated for situations 1 through 6. are common and normal. As a pilot's flying career
8 Chap 2 Par 8
8 Chap 2 Par 8
progresses, the ability to identify these hazardous b. In reviewing the five hazardous attitudes attitudes will help the pilot counteract his/her in Chapter 3, a pilot should pay particular attention hazardous thoughts. The goal of this exercise is to to hazardous attitudes that may characterize his/her balance all thoughts against possible outcomes so own tendencies. Hazardous attitudes occur to that actions are nonhazardous. A critical part of every pilot to some degree at some time. Problems ADM training is learning to examine the thinking arise when these hazardous attitudes occur reguprocess and control hazardous attitudes. Flying will lary and/or to an extreme. Therefore, a pilot become safer if a pilot is able to identify and act should learn to recognize these hazardous attitudes upon hazardous attitudes. in order to take corrective action.
Chap 2 Par 12 9 (and 10)
CHAPTER 3. DEALING WITH HAZARDOUS ATTITUDES
CHAPTER 3. DEALING WITH HAZARDOUS ATTITUDES
13. HAZARDOUS ATTITUDES. ADM addres- as being able to make a great deal of difference in ses the following five hazardous attitudes. what happens to them. When things go well, the pilot is apt to think that's good- luck. When things a. Antiauthority (don't tell me!). This go badly, the pilot may feel that someone is out to attitude is found in people who do not like anyone get me, or attribute it to bad luck. The pilot will telling them what to do. In a sense they are say- leave the action to others, for better or worse. ing no one can tell me what to do. They may be Sometimes, such pilots will even go along with resentful of having someone tell them what to do unreasonable requests just to be a "nice guy." or may regard rules, regulations, and procedures as silly or unnecessary. However, it is always your 14. ANTIDOTES FOR HAZARDOUS ATTIprerogative to question authority if you feel it is in TUDES. error. a. Hazardous attitudes which contribute to b.
Impulsivity (do something quickly!) is the poor pilot judgment can be effectively counteracted attitude of people who frequently feel the need to by redirecting that hazardous attitude so that approdo something-anything-immediately. They do not priate action can be taken. Recognition of hazarstop to think about what they are about to do, they dous thoughts is the first step in neutralizing them do not select the best alternative, and they do the in the ADM process. This chapter is designed to first thing that comes to mind. familiarize the pilot with a meañs of counteracting hazardous attitudes with an appropriate antidote c. Invulnerability (it won't happen to me). thought. Many people feel that accidents happen to others, but never to them. They know accidents can b. When a pilot recognizes a thought as happen, and they know that anyone can be af- hazardous, the pilot should label that thought as fected. They never really feel or believe that they hazardous, then correct that thought by stating the will be personally involved. Pilots who think this corresponding antidote.
Antidotes should be memway are more likely to take chances and increase orized for each of the hazardous attitudes so that risk. they automatically come to mind when needed.
d. Macho (I can do it). Pilots who are always trying to prove that they are better than 15. ANTIDOTE RECALL EXERCISE. The anyone else are thinking I can do it - I'll show hazardous attitude antidotes (figure 4) should be them. Pilots with this type of attitude will try to learned thoroughly and practiced. Make a copy of prove themselves by taking risks in order to the Antidote Recall Exercise form (appendix 4) impress others. While this pattern is thought to be and, without referring to the text, write the characa male characteristic, women are equally suscep- teristic thought for each hazardous attitude and its tible. appropriate antidote. Check the statements and continue if they are correct. If not, continued e. Resignation (what's the use?). Pilots study of the antidotes is recommended until they who think what's the use? do not see themselves are memorized.
Chap 3 Par 13 11
16. THE IMPORTANCE OF REINFORCE- MENT EXERCISES. The basic definitions, the self-assessment test, the hazardous attitudes, and the antidotes represent the foundation for understanding the factors of good ADM. However, they represent only about 10 percent of the important process of learning and putting ADM into practice. The other 90 percent can be achieved only through completion of all of the situation exercises in the appropriate manual (i.e., Student/Private, Instrument, Commercial, etc.) and applying the principles learned to each and every flight. Some examples of the reinforcement exercises from each of the manuals follow. These are presented as examples of the types of decision errors which have contributed to accidents in the past.
HAZARDOUS ANTIDOTE ATTITUDE
HAZARDOUS ANTIDOTE ATTITUDE
Antiauthority: Don't Follow the rules. They tell me. are usually right.
Impulsivity: Do Not so fast. Think something quickly. first.
Invulnerability: It It could happen to me. won't happen to me.
Macho: I can do it. Taking chances is foolish.
Resignation: What's I'm not helpless. I can the use? make a difference.
FIGURE 4. THE FIVE ANTIDOTES
FIGURE 4. THE FIVE ANTIDOTES
17. INSTRUCTIONS FOR USING REIN- FORCEMENT EXERCISES. Read each of the following situations. At the end of each situation, an alternative should be selected which best illustrates the reactions of a pilot who is thinking a particular hazardous attitude. After the most appropriate alternative is selected, refer to the explañation of alternatives page for the proper response. This page will "provide the correct answer. If the selection is accurate, proceed to the next situation. If an incorrect alternative was selected, the reader should review the situation again and select another alternative. Repeat the exercise until the correct alternative is selected.
a. The Impulsivity Hazardous Attitude.
(1) Situation: As you enter the landing pattern, you normally lower the flaps. The tower suddenly changes the active runway. Distracted, you forget to use the before-landing checklist. On short final you find yourself dangerously low with a high sink rate. Glancing down, you realize that you forgot to extend the flaps. Which of the following alternatives best illustrates the impulsivity reaction?
(i) You feel that nothing is going to happen because you have made intentional no-flap landings before.
(ii) You laugh and think, "Boy, this low approach will impress people on the ground."
(iii) You think that using a checklist is a stupid requirement.
(iv) You immediately grab the flap handle and add full flaps.
(v) You think that it all depends on whether you get an updraft or downdraft now.
(2) Explanation of Alternatives:
(i) Feeling that nothing bad can happen suggests the invulnerability hazardous attitude (it won't happen to me). Go back to the situation and select another alternative.
(ii) When you are thinking about impressing people on the ground, watch out for the macho hazardous attitude (I can do it). This can cost you dearly. Go back to the situation and select another alternative.
(iii) Thinking that checklists are stupid suggests that you feel that aircraft designers, the Goverment, and your instructor, all of whom urge the use of checklists, are wrong. This suggests the antiauthority hazardous attitude (don't tell me). Go back to the situation and select another alternative.
Chap 3 Par 16
(iv) Right! Immediately adding full (ii) Right! The regulations are for flaps without thinking is an example of the someone else attitide assumes controllers are impulsivity hazardous attitude (do something interfering with your business. You are thinking in quickly). Unfortunately, in this situation, full flaps an antiauthority manner. Go on to the next situawill probably only increase the sink rate. Go on to tion. the next situation. (iii) Here you are taking the invul- (v) If you are convinced that it is up nerability stand (it won't happen to me). You to the wind, this implies the hazardous attitude of think of yourself as invulnerable. Go back to the resignation (what's the use). Go back to the situation and select another alternative. situation and select another alternative. (iv) This is the impulsivity hazardous (3) A Good Attitude. Distractions can be attitude (I must act now, there's no time). Go dangerous--always use your checklist. back to the situation and select another alternative.
b. The Antiauthority Hazardous Attitude. (v) The desire to impress another influences your decision. This is the macho (1) Situation: You approach the VOR attitude (I'll show you - I can do it). Go back to and the controller asks if you want to execute the the situation and select another alternative. entire VOR procedure or will you accept a right turn of more than 90o to intercept the final approach course. You state that you will make the (3) A Good Attitude. Make as much time turn directly onto final at 2,000 feet although this available on an approach as possible. You may will press you to get properly established on final. need it. Which of the following alternatives best illustrates the antiauthority reaction? C. The Macho Hazardous Attitude.
(i) It was not your idea to make the (1) Situation: On a trip to the west approach like this. coast, you make an en route refueling stop at an airport in the Rockies. After refueling, the density (ii) A controller is not going to altitude prior to your departure is reported as influence the way I fly. 10,500 feet. You are at maximum takeoff weight when you depart. At the present rate of climb, you (iii) You do not need the full ap- will just barely clear the minimum crossing altitude proach; you know you are a good instrument pilot. (MCA) at the next intersection on your flight route. Which of the following alternatives best illustrates (iv) You are in a hurry and do not the macho reaction? wish to bother with the full approach. (i) There is really nothing you can (v) You know the controllers will be do about it; it is up to air traffic control (ATC) to impressed with this approach. make sure you clear.
(2) Explanation of Alternatives. (ii) The MCA's have plenty of leeway for clearance. So what if you are a little (i) By assuming someone else has low. responsibility for your approach, you exhibit the resignation attitude (what's the use?). Go back to (ii) You are a good pilot and will the situation and select another alternative. make it.
Chap 3 Par 17 13
AC 60-22 12/13/91
(iv) When you see that you cannot (i) It's too late to fix it now. climb enough, you immediately inform ATC of your situation without determining your intentions. (ii) You can handle a little problem like this. (v) Mountain flying is not any different from any other flying and you have never (iii) What's the worst that could run into any problems before. Nothing will hap- happen? pen. (iv) I certainly didn't break it. It's not my fault. (2) Explanation of Alternatives. (v) You barely need the pressur- (i) Assuming someone else is ization at the filed altitude anyway. responsible for you is the resignation hazardous attitude. Go back to the situation and select (2) Explanation of Alternatives. another alternative. (i) This is the impulsivity hazardous (ii) This is the antiauthority hazard- attitude (there's no time - I must do something ous attitude (don't tell me). Go back to the situa- quickly). Go back to the situation and select tion and select another alternative. another alternative.
(iii) Right! Thinking I'll show you - (ii) This is the macho hazardous I can do it, is the macho hazardous attitude. attitude showing through (I can do it). Go back to the situation and select another alternative. (iv) Acting before thinking, this is the impulsivity hazardous attitude (do something (iii) Right! Nothing bad is going to quickly). Go back to the situation and select happen to you because of your invulnerability. Go another alternative. on to the next situation.
(v) This is the invulnerability haz- (iv) This is the resignation hazardous ardous attitude (it won't happen to me). Go back attitude - what's the use? - where someone else is to the situation and select another alternative. responsible. Go back to the situation and select another alternative. (3) A Good Attitude. Be aware of your limitations and don't exceed them. (v) This type of thinking is characteristic of the antiauthority attitude (rules and d. The Invulnerability Hazardous Attitude. regulations are made to be broken). Go back to the situation and select another alternative. (1) Situation: While preflighting the pressurization system, you discover that the rate (3) A Good Attitude. Settle for nothing adjustment control is inoperative. Knowing that less than full operating systems. you can manually control the cabin pressure, you opt to disregard this discrepancy and depart on e. The Resignation Hazardous Attitude. your trip. You will have to handle the system yourself. Which of the following alternatives best (1) Situation: Your copilot shows up for illustrates the invulnerability reaction? duty and you notice that the copilot's behavior is
Chap 3 14 Par 17
somewhat out of the ordinary. You know your copilot has had a cold. When questioned, the copilot said maybe it was the antihistamine that he/she took the night before. Although your aircraft requires a crew of two, you decide to ignore your copilot's drowsiness and inattention. Which of the following alternatives best illustrates the resignation reaction?
(i) You could fly this jet by yourself anyway.
(ii) You two have flown together many times, and everything has always worked out fine.
(iii) What else can you do? He was assigned this flight too.
(iv) He/she might not be within the regulations, but he/she says he/she's okay and that's what counts.
(v) There is really no time to call another copilot now.
Chap 3 Par 17
(2) Explanation of Alternatives.
(i) This is a trait of the macho hazardous attitude (I can do it). Go back to the situation and select another alternative.
(ii) This is the invulnerability attitude (it won't happen to me). Go back to the situation and select another alternative.
(iii) Right! When you feel as if it is out of your control, you are exhibiting the resignation hazardous attitude.
(iv) This is the antiauthority hazardous attitude (the rules and regulations don't apply to me). Go back to the situation and select another alternative.
(v) This is the impulsivity hazardous attitude (do something quickly). Go back to the situation and select another alternative.
(3) A Good Attitude. Don't let others do your thinking for you.
15 (and 16)
CHAPTER 4. STRESS AND FLYING
CHAPTER 4. STRESS AND FLYING
18. WHAT IS STRESS? Stress is a term used stress-adaption limitations. When we exceed this to describe the body's nonspecific response to level, stress overload may lead to poor health or demands placed on it, whether these demands are illness. pleasant or unpleasant in nature. The demands on a pilot can range from unexpected windshear 20. IS STRESS BAD? Stress is a response to a encountered on a landing to a lost wallet. Piloting set of circumstances that induces a change in a the aircraft is the pilot's responsibility. Therefore, pilot's current physiological and/or psychological a healthy pilot should perform at his/her optimum patterns of functioning forcing the pilot to adapt to level and make decisions to the best of his/her these changes. Stress is an inevitable and necesability.
Numerous physical and physiological sary part of life that adds motivation to life and conditions in a pilot's personal and professional heightens a pilot's response to meet any challenge. life, as well as the nature of flight itself, can In fact, performance of a task will generally imhamper this ability. Even though à pilot holds a prove with the onset of stress, but will peak and medical certificate stating that the pilot meets the then begin to degrade rapidly as stress levels health requirements for a particular type of flight exceed à pilot's adaptive abilities to handle the operation, the decision whether the pilot is fit to situation. fly is strictly the pilot's. 21. HANDLING STRESS IN FLYING. Acci- 19. HOW MUCH STRESS IS IN YOUR LIFE? dents often occur when flying task requirements exceed a pilot's capabilities. A superior pilot uses a. If you hope to succeed at reducing stress superior judgment to avoid stressful situations associated with crisis management in the air or which might call for use of superior skills.
The with your job, it is essential to begin by making a difference between pilot capabilities and task repersonal assessment of stress in all areas of your quirements is the margin of safety (figure 5). In life. You may face major stressors such as a loss this example, the margin of safety is minimal durof income, serious illness, death of a family ing the approach under ideal conditions. For this member, change in residence, or birth of a baby, pilot, a cold and fatigue may reduce the minimal plus a multitude of comparatively minor positive margin of safety as well as the overall margin of and negative stressors. These major and minor safety throughout the flight. stressors have a cumulative effect which constitutes your total stress-adaption capability which can vary a. Stress is insidious. Stress has a gradual from year to year. To enhance your awareness and cumulative effect that develops slowly, so about the sources of stress in your life, the life slowly that stress can be well established before change profile questionnaire (appendix 5) is pre- becoming apparent.
A pilot may think that he/she sented. Place a check in the Happened column if is handling everything quite well, when in fact you have experienced the event described in the there are subtle signs that the pilot is beyond last 12 months. Total your score at the end of the his/her ability to respond appropriately. questionnaire. b. Stress is cumulative. A generalized stress b. The more change you have, the more reaction can develop as a result of accumulated likely you are to suffer a decline in health. As a stress. There is a limit to a pilot's adaptive nature. rule of thumb, if you score over 20 checks, mostly This limit, the stress tolerance level, is based on a in the top half of the checklist, you have an pilot's ability to cope with the situation. If the 80 percent chance of a serious health change. If number or intensity of the stressors becomes too you have about 20 checks distributed over the great, the pilot is susceptible to an environmental checklist, you have about a 50 percent chance of overload. At this point, a pilot's performance illness in the near future.
Each of us has personal begins to decline and judgment deteriorates.
Chap 4 Par 18 17
AC 60-22 12/13/91
PILOT CAPABILITIES
MARGIN OF SAFETY
TASK REQUIREMENTS ERORT
PRE FLIGHT HOVER TAKE OFF CRUISE APPROACH & LANDING HOVER
TIME
FIGURE 5. THE MARGIN OF SAFETY
c. Signs of inadequate coping. The indica- (1) Become knowledgeable about stress. tors of excessive stress often show as three types of symptoms: (1) emotional, (2) physical, and (3) (2) Take a realistic assessment of yourbehavioral. These symptoms differ depending self. upon whether aggression is focused inward or outward. Those individuals who typically turn their (3) Take a systematic approach to probaggressive feelings inward often demonstrate the lem solving. emotional symptoms of depression, preoccupation, sadness, and withdrawal. The individual who typi- (4) Develop a life style that will buffer cally takes out frustration on other people or ob- against the effects of stress. jects exhibits few physical symptoms. On the other hand, emotional symptoms may show up as (5) Practice behavioral management techovercompensation, denial, suspicion, paranoia, niques. agitation, restlessness, defensiveness, excess sensitivity to criticism, argumentativeness, arrogance, (6) Establish and maintain a strong and hostility. support network.
FIGURE 5. THE MARGIN OF SAFETY
Cockpit Stress Management. Good d. Life Stress Management. There are many cockpit stress management begins with good life techniques available that can help reduce the stress stress management. Many of the stress coping in your life or help you cope with it better. Not all techniques practiced for life stress management are of the following ideas may be the solution, but not usually practical in flight. Rather, you must some of them should be effective for you. condition yourself to relax and think rationally
Chap 4 18 Par 21
12/13/91 AC 60- 22
when stress appears. The following checklist out- right now?" If the pilot cannot answer with an lines some thoughts on cockpit stress management. absolute "yes," then the pilot should not fly. The following checklist is intended for a pilot's per- (1) Avoid situations that distract you sonal preflight use. A pilot may elect to carry a from flying the aircraft. copy in his/her flight bag and onboard the aircraft.
(2) Reduce your workload to reduce stress levels. This will create a proper environ- (1) Do I feel well? Is there anything ment in which to make good decisions. wrong with me at all?
(3) If an emergency does occur, be calm. (2) Have I taken any medication in the Think for a moment, weigh the alternatives, then last 12 hours? act. (3) Have I had as little as one ounce of (4) Maintain proficiency in your aircraft; alcohol in the last 12 hours? proficiency builds confidence. Familiarize yourself thoroughly with your aircraft, its systems, and emergency procedures. (4) Am I tired? Did I get a good night's sleep last night? (5) Know and respect your own personal limits. (5) Am I under undue stress? Am I emotional right now? (6) Do not let little mistakes bother you until they build into a big thing. Wait until after you land, then "debrief" and analyze past actions. (6) Have I eaten a sensible meal and taken in a good load of protein? Do I have a (7) If flying is adding to your stress, protein snack, such as cheese, meat or nuts, either stop flying or seek professional help to aboard? manage your stress within acceptable limits. (7) Am I dehydrated? Do I need to take f. Flight Fitness. A "Go/No-Go" decision noncarbonated liquids such as water or fruit juices? is made before each flight. The pilot should not only preflight check the aircraft, but also his/herself on each and every flight. A pilot (8) Am I equipped with sunglasses, ear should ask, "Could I pass my medical examination protectors, appropriate clothing?
Chap 4 Par 21 19 (and 20)
CHAPTER 5. RISK MANAGEMENT
22. ASSESSING RISK. Risk management is the The Decide Model, comprised of a six step proresponsibility of everyone involved in aviation. cess, is intended to provide the pilot with a logical The flight operations manager, for example, who is way of approaching decision making. The Decide faced with the decision as to just how hard to push Model is described in greater detail in a pilot to go, becomes a party to the risk manage- DOT/FAA/PM-86/43, Aeronautical Decision ment process. It is understandable from an Making for Instrument Pilots. economic point of view that the mail, checks, boss, passenger, whatever, must get through. This b. The six elements of the Decide Model question "Is the success of the task worth the represent a continuous loop decision process which risk?" must always be kept in mind during decision can be used to assist a pilot in the decision making making. Risk management in ADM is discussed process when he/she is faced with a change in à in detail in DOT/FAA/PM-86/43, Aeronautical situation that requires a judgment. This Decide Decision Making for Instrument Pilots. Model is primarily focused on the intellectual component, but can have an impact on the motivational component of judgment as well. If a pilot prac- 23. THE DECIDE MODEL. tices the Decide Model in all decision making, its use can become very natural and could result in a. A good tool to use in making good aero- better decisions being made under all types of nautical decisions is the Decide Model (figure 6). situations.
CHAPTER 5. RISK MANAGEMENT
1. Detect. The decision maker detects the fact that change has occurred.
2. Estimate. The decision maker estimates the need to counter or react to the change.
3. Choose. The decision maker chooses a desirable outcome (in terms of success) for the flight.
4. Identify. The decision maker identifies actions which could successfully control the change.
5. Do. The decision maker takes the necessary action.
6. Evaluate. The decision maker evaluates the effect(s) of his action countering the change.
FIGURE 6. The DECIDE MODEL
Chap 5 Par 22 21 (and 22)
CHAPTER 6. IDENTIFYING THE ENEMY
CHAPTER 6. IDENTIFYING THE ENEMY
24. GENERAL. approximately 24 hours, while heavy drinking will have lingering effects for up to 36 hours or longer. a. Most preventable accidents have one Effects from the use of marijuana remain in the common factor: human error, rather than a me- system for at least a week. The concept should be chanical malfunction. Pilots who are involved in obvious that flight safety is measurably comproaccidents generally know what went wrong. Very mised within those time periods. The side effects often, the pilot was aware of the possible hazards and duration of all prescription drugs are well when the decision the pilot made led to the wrong documented and available from a local pharmacist, course of action. In the interest of expediency, the family physician, a drug addiction agency, or cost savings, self-gratification, or other often the Surgeon Ġeneral. irrelevant factors, the incorrect course of action was chosen. This cycle of decisions began at the b. Flight with a known medical deficiency flight planning desk with decisions made on how is never expedient or legal (FAR § 61.53). much fuel to carry, the route, the alternate route, and adequate weather conditions. This cycle c. Flight outside the certified flight envelope continues throughout the flight with decisions is never safe. Weight, balance, speed, maneuvers, made on speed, altitude, and when to descend. G-loading, and flight in known icing should be Each flight is a sequence of choices with certain limited to flight manual parameters. Beyond that, milestones in the sequence that require particular you are in the wilderness and all discoveries could determination and discretion. be unhappy experiences.
b. Flying is rapidly changing from a physi- d. Flight with less than the required minical to a mental task. Initial instruction to manipu- mum fuel is never reasonable. The applicable late and control an aircraft requires approximately FAR's are sufficiently liberal. Twenty or 1 to 2 years. However, training to command an 30 minutes fuel in VFR conditions (depending on aircraft intelligently involves a decade or two of aircraft category) and acceptable IFR reserves experience and periodic recurrent training. ADM should be adequate to provide for contingencies. is designed to reduce the extremely long and sometimes painful process of learning how to make e. VFR flight into instrument meteorological good judgment decisions based upon experience conditions is never justified. alone. While it is true that simple errors of equipment operation are seldom serious, mistakes in f. Descent below the applicable minimum judgment can be fatal. enroute altitude anywhere is never justified.
25. PERSONAL CHECKLIST. One essential g. Casual neglect of any applicable checklist decision point before a flight is the checklist of is never justified. A checklist may be larger or basic principles that cannot be compromised. This smaller; however, certain standards should be personal checklist should include the fundamental established for all flights so that the first decision tenets applicable to every flight. Once a pilot point is whether or not to begin the flight. This decides what not to do, the decision on what needs can be the toughest decision. to be done becomes clear. Consider the following never's as factors that contribute significantly to h. Aircraft accident statistics show that unsafe flight: pilots should be conducting preflight checklists on themselves as well as their aircraft. Pilot impaira. Flight while under the influence of ment contributes to many more accidents than failalcohol or drugs, including applicable prescription ures of aircraft systems. The following version of drugs, is a never. Several drinks of an alcoholic the "I'M SAFE" personal checklist (figure 7) conbeverage will influence thought and reaction for tains all of the most common categories of pilot
Chap 6 Par 24 23
AC 60-22 12/13/91
impairment and can easily be committed to smoking, speeding, overeating, etc.), the pilot is, memory. nonetheless, driven by his or her own emotions.
d. Existing rules would go a long way to 26. HOW TO BE A SAFE PILOT. remedy the accident rate; however, personality traits that cause irrational behavior also make pilots a. A pilot does not have to be a genius to be prone to disregard the rules that would assure safe a safe pilot. However, a pilot should be an emo- operations.
1. Illness. Do I have any symptoms? 2. Medication. Have I been taking prescription or over-the-counter drugs? 3. Stress. Am I under psychological pressure from the job? Do I have money, health, or family problems? 4. Alcohol. Have I been drinking within 8 hours? Within 24 hours? 5. Fatigue. Am I tired and not adequately rested? 6. Eating. Have I eaten enough of the proper foods to keep adequately nourished during the entire flight?
FIGURE 7. The "I'M SAFE" Checklist
tionally stable person who can accept the fact that e. When a pilot exhibits one or more of the he/she is not in possession of all fačts or skills for five hazardous attitudes or irrational behavior, that all situations and be willing to accept the recom- pilot may also be exposing any emotional weakmendations of those who specialize in evaluating, nesses in his/her personality. assessing, and administering aviation procedures. 27. DEVELOPMENT OF GOOD DECISION b. Reaching a consensus on all matters MAKING SKILLS. within the aviation community can prove difficult, if not impossible. Even though the rules and pro- a. The development of good decision makcedures are designed to serve most of the people ing skills is far more difficult than developing most of the time, a pilot can always argue for dif- good flying skills, but it can be done. Good judgferent ways of doing things.
An experienced, ma- ment may mean not flying while under the influture pilot will accept and follow the rules and pro- ence of any medication, when it is too windy, or cedures which will benefit the aviation community. refusing a revenue flight when it would require The immature, emotionally unbalanced pilot has flying in marginal weather. strong tendencies to satisfy a personal need regardless of the consequences. b. Many pilots fail to make proper decisions; sometimes due to a lack of knowledge, but too c. Some pilots break rules simply for the often the result of a human tendency to rationalize immediate gratification of some emotional need. a situation until it appears justifiable. When a pilot Even though the pilot may know that this emo- really wants to do something (such as loading that tional need is not considered a healthy habit (e.g., one last passenger when close to maximum gross
Chap 6 24 Par 25
weight, or performing a high speed, low altitude When a pilot operates an aircraft, human lives are pass), the pilot can generally make himself/herself held in the balance. Therefore, a pilot has a moral believe that it was all right to do it. A pilot can be responsibility to operate in the safest possible his/her own worst enemy. manner.
c. In addition to the FAR, AC's, articles in e. Aviation has reached a new plateau. Acmagazines, books written by expert pilots and quiring aeronautical knowledge, airmanship skills, instructors, Pilot Proficiency Programs, Airman's and proficiency are relatively easy. Navigation has Information Manual, NOTAM's, Airworthiness been reduced to calculator simplicity. Modern Directives, and Biennial Flight Reviews, there are autopilots and electronic displays have significantly some do's and do not's that can ensure the preven- reduced a pilot's workload. Today's technology tion of most accidents. All of this information is requires administrative management and aeronautisafety-oriented. Not following this safety-oriented cal decision making skills as prerequisites for information is similar to not following the advice safety and efficiency. of a doctor or lawyer.
d. The most important decision a pilot will 28. SUCCESSFUL DECISION MAKING. make is to learn and adhere to published rules, Successful decision making is measured by a procedures, and recommendations. Pilots, by pilot's consistent ability to keep himself/herself, learning and adhering to these published rules and any passengers, and the aircraft in good condition procedures, can take most hazārds out of flying. regardless of the conditions of any given flight.
Chap 6 Par 27 25 (and 26)
12/13/91 AC 60- 22
CHAPTER 7. TEACHING ADM
CHAPTER 7. TEACHING ADM
29. PURPOSE. The ADM manual for Instructor 32. PRINCIPLES OF ADM TRAINING. Pilots (DOT/FAA/PM-86/44) contains all of the necessary background material to teach effectively a. The ADM manual for student and private the subject material of the companion publication pilots is simple and repetitive for two reasons: entitled "Aeronautical Decision Making for Student and Private Pilots" (DOT/FAA/PM-86/41). This (1) The simplicity provides frequent chapter provides a brief introduction and overview positive reinforcement; and on the process of teaching ADM. (2) The repetition builds good judgment 30. BACKGROUND. The instructor's ADM habits and refreshes memory so that information training manual is a result of 10 years of research, can be readily recalled in a variety of circumstandevelopment, testing, and evaluation of the effec- ces, even when under stress. tiveness of judgment and decision making. It is a revision of the prototype publication "Judgment Training Manual for Instructor Pilots," which was b.
The scenarios in the student and private developed jointly by the Federal Aviation Adminis- pilot ADM manual should stimulate the student's tration, General Aviation Manufacturers interest and appreciation of the need for good pilot Association, and Transport Canada in an effort to judgment and ADM. improve general aviation safety. c. The instructor has a profound effect on a 31. THE FLIGHT INSTRUCTOR'S ROLE IN student as a role model and as an opinion shaper. ADM TRAINING. (1) Use of the ADM concepts to guide a. Although the information in this chapter conversations with the student focuses the instrucis designed to help pilots overcome a variety of tion on judgment-related training and increases the circumstances which may result in poor pilot judg- student's ability to provide self-generated feedback. ment, the flight instructor is the key element of this program. The flight instructor's attitude and approach to flying may often influence students (2) Knowing how to recognize and remore than any specific lesson.
By always setting spond to hazardous attitudes and high stress is very a good example and by giving students support and important to exercising good pilot judgment. The encouragement throughout this program, a flight instructor should encourage the student to develop instructor helps students develop good judgment these skills but, in doing so, should never attempt and sound flying practices. to analyze or modify the student's personality.
b. To help prepare for this role, thought (3) The student learns concepts and should be given to the differences between the behavioral techniques and repeatedly applies this instructor as an evaluator and the instructor as learing to relevant flight situations during ground coach. The evaluator sees his/her role as one of and flight training. telling the student what to do, then monitoring the student's performance. In contrast, think of the d. The basic instructional principles which instructor in a slightly different perspective; some- follow are simple, but application does take some one who actively stimulates learing, such as a practice. When you first try to apply them you "coach." The instructor not only makes assign- may feel somewhat awkward, but you will become ments and observes the results, he/she also helps more comfortable with them eventually. After a the student lear through demonstration and per- few months, the use of these principles will sonalized instruction. become automatic.
Chap 7 Par 29 27
AC 60-22 12/13/91
(1) Behavior positively reinforced will (1) "Preflight and Aircraft Systems" after continue. aircraft and aircraft systems.
(2) Behavior followed by punishment (2) "Weight/Balance and Performance" may decrease. after performance and weight and balance.
(3) Be very specific about learning objec- (3) "Official Procedures and Communicatives. tions" after airports and communications, aviation regulations, and the Airman's Information Manual (4) Reinforce generously in the early in Canada - the AIP. stages of learning. (4) "Cross-Country Flying" after basic (5) Shift slowly from continuous to occa- navigation and radio navigation. sional reinforcement. (5) "Physiological Factors and Night (6) Shape existing behavior into desired Flying" after medical factors and cross-country behavior. flying.
33. TEACHING THE BEHAVIORAL b. Description of Material. Each section of ASPECTS OF ADM. Chapter 8 of the Aeronautical Decision Making for Student and Private Pilots document presents a. General. Students must be exposed to exercises which test the student's judgment and this material early in their pilot training, ideally decision making knowledge in the previously during the first quarter of the student standard mentioned topic areas. These exercises require the private pilot training course. student to use the terms and concepts learned in all previous lessons. Encourage the students to review b. Description of Material in the Student earlier material as necessary. After the student has and Private Manual (DOT/FAA/PM-86/41).
Three completed each section, discuss the answers: No approaches are presented in this manual to improve answer key is provided, but bear in mind that, the pilot's judgment and decision making skills. although responses to most of the questions may The first approach presents an analytical method be relatively obvious, there are no absolutely right for making decisions and evaluating risk (Chapters or wrong answers. 2 and 3). The second approach (Chapters 4, 5 and 6) addresses the pilot's hazardous attitudes and 35. IN-FLIGHT INSTRUCTION: THE LESsubstitutes ones which promote good judgment. SON PLANS. The third approach (Chapter 7) deals with overcoming high stress which reduces judgment and a. General. How does a flight instructor decision making abilities. combine educational principles with the concepts in this manual to improve a student's judgment and 34. TEACHING THE APPLICATION EXER- decision making? By giving the student a series of CISES. practical, "hands-on" lessons in which you observe performance and response to specific behavior. Do a. General.
The following material, con- not comment on intentions or motivations. Use tained in Chapter 8 of DOT/FAA/PM-86/41, rewards (praise) frequently and avoid criticism Aeronautical Decision Making for Student and (punishment) as much as possible. Errors or Private Pilots, should be integrated, where appro- misjudgments by the student should be viewed as priate, into the topics of the conventional ground opportunities for leaming, not as occasions for training syllabus. criticism.
Chap 7 28 Par 32
12/13/91 AC 60- 22
b. The Lessons. student to make an unsafe judgment or decision. Why? Because it is important for the student to (1) In this unit, while on routine training become skilled at recognizing and replacing hazarflights, you will give your students "activities" dous attitudes and unsafe tendencies with good designed to further develop their appreciation for judgment behavior. the decision making concepts based upon an actual preflight or in-flight "hands-on" experience. 37. TYPICAL TRAINING SCENARIOS. This (2) Take 15 minutes or so for your own section of the instructor's manual provides a narpreparation the first few times you work with each rative of a typical judgment training session. You lesson. might find it useful in formulating your own ideas for conducting your own judgment training flights. (3) Start the lessons when the student has As mentioned earlier, all necessary preparation the ability to control the aircraft confidently during should be completed before the student's expected the most basic maneuvers. Use your own arrival time. judgment, but a suggested starting point is about three flight lessons before you expect the student to solo. 38. MANAGEMENT OF ADM TRAINING.
(4) At least three lessons each are needed a. This training program is more than just to teach risk assessment in decision making, a collection of related facts and ideas for students hazardous attitude recognition, and stress manage- to learn. It is a carefully designed educational sysment, for a total of nine lessons. Each lesson tem. Using this integrated system produces an should take no more than 5 minutes and should be overall result greater than that attaināble by ranintegrated into the normal 1-to-2 hour flight train- dom presentation of the individual parts. To ing period. achieve the maximum benefits of this system, you must manage the instruction carefully. (5) The instructor's ADM manual provides 18 lesson plans for in-flight teaching of b. The materials presented in this chapter of these mental processes. the instructor's manual are listed below. They are designed to aid both the individual instructor and 36.
IN-FLIGHT INSTRUCTION: THE the training supervisor for a group of flight instruc- TRAINING SCENARIO. tors; i.e., the chief pilot engaged in decision making training activities. The aeronautical decision a. Purpose. The purpose of this chapter of making training materials are: the instructor's manual is to further encourage the student to use judgment and decision making skills. Your duties are two-fold; (1) you must set (1) Schedule of Student Work. A master up situations to stimulate the student's decision plan for scheduling training activities for students. making process, and (2) you must respond to student behavior in a manner that encourages safe (2) Set of Master Copies. Original judgments and decisions. documents of all the instructional materials and forms required to teach this training curriculum. b. The Scenarios. Practice situations, provided in this section of the manual, create (3) Answer Keys for the Postcheck circumstances that may actually encourage the Exercises.
Chap 7 Par 35 29 (and 30)
AC 60-22 Appendix 1
APPENDIX 1. SAMPLE ATTITUDE INVENTORY ANSWER SHEET
APPENDIX 1. SAMPLE ATTITUDE INVENTORY ANSWER SHEET
Situation 1
a. b. C. d. e.
Situation 2
a. b. c. d. e.
Situation 3
a.
bcd
e.
Situation 4
a.
b
d. e.
Situation 5
a. b. c. d e.
Situation 6
a. b. C. d. e.
Situation 7
a. b. C. d. e.
Situation 8
a. b. C. d. e.
Situation 9
a. b. C. d. e.
Situation 10
a. b. C. d. e.
AC 60-22 Appendix 2
APPENDIX 2. SCORING FORM
APPENDIX 2. SCORING FORM
Total
SITUATION SCALE I SCALE III SCALE III SCALE IV SCALE V
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Items 1-6 Subtotal
7.
8.
9.
10.
Items 7-10 Subtotal
Items 1-10 Grand Total
b
a
e
d
C
d
e
b
e
e
d
C
e
a
a
C
a
e
d
C
b
a
b
d
d
b
b
C
a
e
d
C
b
b
a
C
a
a
d
C
b
a
e
e
e
d
d
b
15
15
SITUATION SCALE I SCALE III SCALE III SCALE IV SCALE V
15
15
15
15
90
15
15
15
15
60
150
Appendix 3
APPENDIX 3. ATTITUDE PROFILE
SCALE I
50
40
30
20
10
Antiauthority
SCALE II
50
40
30
20
10
Impulsivity
SCALE III
50
40
30
20
10
Invulnerability
SCALE IV
50
40
30
20
10
Macho
SCALE V
50← Mark X's below this line if you answered all ten situations
SCALE V
40
30 ← Mark X's below this line if you only answered situations one thru six
20← Mark X's below this line if you only answered situation seven thru ten
10
Resignation
AC 60-22 Appendix 4
APPENDIX 4. ANTIDOTE RECALL EXERCISE
HAZARDOUS THOUGHT
ANTIAUTHORITY:
IMPULSIVITY:
INVULNERABILITY:
HAZARDOUS THOUGHT
MACHO:
RESIGNATION:
ANTIDOTE
Appendix 5
APPENDIX 5. LIFE EVENTS STRESS TEST
Item No.
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44.
Happened (X)
Life Event
Death of a spouse Divorce Marital Separation Jail term Death of close family member Personal injury Marriage Lost your job Marital reconciliation Retirement Change in health of family member Pregnancy Sex difficulties Gain of new family member Business - budgets, schedules, deadlines Change in financial state Family member on drugs or alcohol Death of close friend Change to different line of work Change in number of arguments with spouse or partner Mortgage or loan over $10,000 Foreclosure of mortgage or loan Change in responsibilities at work Son or daughter leaving home Trouble with in-laws or partner's family Outstanding personal achievement Spouse or partner begins or stops work You begin or end work Change in living conditions Revision of personal habits Trouble with boss or instructor Change in work hours or conditions Change in residence Change in school or teaching institution Change in recreational activities Change in church activities Change in social activities Mortgage or loan less than $10,000 Change in sleeping habits Change in number of family social events Change in eating habits Vacation Christmas Minor violations of the law
APPENDIX 5. LIFE EVENTS STRESS TEST
Total number of checks for the past 12 months
*U.S. Government Printing Office: 1996 - 405-571/55733
U.S.Department of Transportation
Federal Aviation Administration
800 Independence Ave., S.W. Washington, D.C. 20591
FORWARDING AND RETURN POSTAGE GUARANTEED
Official Business Penalty for Private Use $300
BULK MAIL POSTAGE & FEES PAID FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION PERMIT NO. G-44
BULK MAIL POSTAGE & FEES PAID FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION PERMIT NO. G-44