Radar Vectors
Advisory Circular Current Issued Dec 13, 2023 AEE-3 74 pages Copy saved Nov 17, 2026

AC 38-1 AIRPLANE FUEL EFFICIENCY CERTIFICATION

This advisory circular (AC) contains information and provides guidance on the implementation of the fuel efficiency certification requirements for airplanes that are required by Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 38.

Official source ↗ Open PDF

Text read by OCR from a scanned file. Check the original, as some words may be misread.

U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration

Subject: AIRPLANE FUEL EFFICIENCY Date:12/13/2023 AC No: 38-1 CERTIFICATION Initiated By: AEE-300

This advisory circular (AC) contains information and provides guidance on the implementation of the fuel efficiency certification requirements for airplanes that are required by Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 38.

Ralph lovinelli

RALPH JOSEPH Digitally signed by RALPH JOSEPH IOVINELLI IOVINELLI Date: 2023.12.1313:43:32-05'00'

FAA Office of Environment and Energy AEE-300 Emissions Division

12/05/2023

AC 38-1: 14 CFR Part 38 Airplane Fuel Certification

Table of Contents

1. Purpose... 1

1.1 Contents .. 1

1.2 Advisory Nature.. 1

1.3 Audience 1

1.3 Audience 1

1.4 Intent.. 1

1.5 Approval of Equivalent Procedures.. .2

1.6 FAA Certification Process .2

1.7 Related Documents.. 2

1.8 Definitions and Abbreviations/Acronyms/Symbols.. .2

2. References.. ..2

3. [Reserved]. .3

4. Development of Airplane Fuel Efficiency Regulations .3

4.1 Establishment of Airplane Fuel Efficiency Regulations.. .3

4.2 Relationship Between the EPA and the FAA. .3

4.3 Relationship Between 14 CFR Part 38 and 40 CFR Part 1030. .3

4.4 Differences Between ICAO Annex 16 Volume IIl and 14 CFR Part 38 4

4.4 Differences Between ICAO Annex 16 Volume IIl and 14 CFR Part 38 4

5. Part 38 Subpart A – General . 4

5.1 Section 38.1 Applicability . 4 5.1.1 Modified Airplanes .. 6 5.1.2 Non-Applicability of the Fuel Efficiency Metric.. 6

5.2 Certification of Lower Takeoff Mass Variant .. .7

5.3 Exemptions.. 7

5.4 Incorporation by Reference.. .7

5.5 Fuel Efficiency Compliance Demonstration Plans .. 8

5.6 Fuel Efficiency Compliance Demonstration for Airplanes with Intermixed Engines 8

5.6 Fuel Efficiency Compliance Demonstration for Airplanes with Intermixed Engines 8

6. Expanded Discussion of 14 CFR part 38 Subpart B Requirements . 9

6.1 Fuel Efficiency Metric. 9

6.2 Specific Air Range.. .10

6.3 SAR Data Analysis .. .11 6.3.1 SAR Measurement System .. .11 6.3.2 Selection of Flight Test Data .11 6.3.3 Distribution of Resulting SAR Points . .14 6.3.4 Correction of SAR Data to Reference Specifications … 15

6.4 Equivalent Procedures. .15 6.4.1 Example 1: FAA Approval based on existing data.... 15 6.4.2 Example 2: FAA Approval of a change based on back-to-back testing … 15 6.4.3 Example 3: FAA Approval of a change based on analysis ... .16 6.4.4 Example 4: FAA Approval based on first principle models .. ..16

6.5 Validity of Results – Confidence Interval … 24

6.5 Validity of Results – Confidence Interval … 24

6.6 Reference Geometric Factor.. .24 6.6.1 RGF General Guidelines .. .24 6.6.2 Orthogonal Projection and Width Boundary . ..24 6.6.3 Forward and Aft Boundaries.. .25 6.6.4 Floor Plane. ..25 6.6.6 Floor Plane .26 6.6.7 RGF Sensitivity.. .26

6.7 Fuel Efficiency Limits.. .26

6.8 Change Criteria .. .27

7. Additional Guidance. ..28

Appendix 1: Definitions. .29

Appendix 1: Definitions. .29

Appendix 2: Abbreviations/Acronyms/Symbols.. .30

Appendix 3: Correcting SAR Data to Reference Specifications. .32

Appendix 4: Confidence Interval Evaluation. .52

Appendix 5: References. ..71

1. Purpose

This AC provides guidance on the implementation of fuel efficiency certification requirements for airplanes. These guidelines provide an acceptable means of demonstrating compliance with the regulations of Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 38. The methods and procedures described herein have been proposed as recommended certification practice for showing compliance with the fuel efficiency requirements.

1. Purpose

See Appendix 1 for definitions and Appendix 2 for acronyms, abbreviations, and symbols used throughout this AC.

1.1 Contents

This Advisory Circular (AC) contains information describing the standards and requirements for new aircraft fuel efficiency regulations in 14 CFR part 38. The information contained in this document sets forth acceptable means, but not the sole means, by which compliance may be shown with the requirements of 14 CFR part 38 (part 38).

1.1 Contents

In this AC, the word “paragraph” is used to refer to a part of the AC. The word “section” (or the symbol “§”) is used to refer to a part of a regulation or statute.

Pursuant to §§ 231 and 232 of the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1970 (42 USC §§ 7571-7572), FAA's part 38 fuel efficiency regulations implement the standards adopted by U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in 40 CFR part 1030 (see paragraphs 4.1 - 4.3 of this AC) by enforcing the EPA regulations at the time of certification. Any deviations from the procedures required under 14 CFR part 38 or 40 CFR part 1030 must be coordinated and approved by the Administrators of both the EPA and FAA (see paragraphs 4.2 and 4.3 of this AC). Users of this AC, and those subject to the regulations of part 38, are responsible for cognizance of any later amendments to 40 CFR part 1030 that may not be reflected immediately in 14 CFR Part 38 or this AC. In such instances, applicants may contact the AEE- 300 Emissions Division Manager with the FAA Office of Environment and Energy at [email protected] for further guidance.

1.2 Advisory Nature

1.2 Advisory Nature

The contents of this AC do not have the force and effect of law and are not meant to bind the public in any way. This AC is intended only to provide information to the public regarding compliance with existing requirements under the law or agency policies. The use of mandatory language, such as “must” and “require” in this AC describe a mandatory requirement established by statute or regulation that exists independent of the material in this AC. The term “should” is used in this AC to indicate a recommendation described in this document and not a requirement. This AC describes one or more acceptable means, but not the only means, of complying with part 38 fuel efficiency certification standards. If an applicant chooses to use the guidance presented here as an acceptable means of compliance, it must be followed in all respects to be considered a valid means of compliance.

1.3 Audience

1.3 Audience

The intended audience for this AC includes airplane performance engineers, engine specialists, and propulsion engineers from the FAA's Aircraft Certification Service (AIR) and Aircraft Certification Branches; aircraft and aircraft engine industry specialists; aircraft certification applicants; other certification authorities, airlines, airport operators, engineering and scientific communities; and other persons that are interested in the certification of airplanes to the fuel efficiency standards of part 38.

1.4 Intent

1.4 Intent

The intent of this AC is to provide guidance for complying with the fuel efficiency requirements of part 38.

1.5 Approval of Equivalent Procedures

As provided in § 38.21, applicants may submit equivalent testing, measurement, and data reduction procedures to comply with part 38 airplane fuel efficiency regulations that apply to their airplane. Any such alternatives must be approved, in advance of part 38 compliance document submittals, by the FAA's Office of Environment and Energy (AEE), at FAA Headquarters in Washington DC. Further information on equivalent procedures is provided in paragraph 6.4 of this AC. If you have further questions, please contact the AEE-300 Emissions Division Manager with the Office of Environment and Energy at [email protected].

1.6 FAA Certification Process

1.6 FAA Certification Process

As of publication of AC38-1, the fuel efficiency certification requirements of part 38 are newly adopted in 2023, and it is expected that the FAA and U.S. manufactures will gain experience with their application through ongoing findings of compliance with part 38. The FAA-AIR line of business will work directly with the applicant in this process, and FAA's environmental office, AEE-300, is to remain fully involved with the FAA-AIR line of business in all fuel efficiency compliance efforts to provide guidance as experience is gained. Questions about part 38 from applicants should be submitted to the FAA-AIR line of business, that will then confer with the FAA-AEE environmental office for their resolution.

1.7 Related Documents

1.7 Related Documents

Part 38 contains the fuel efficiency certification requirements for certain airplanes. These regulations reference or are related to the following:

Clean Air Act (CAA) §§ 231-232 (Aircraft Emissions Standards) Title 42 USC §§ 7571-7572. 40 CFR part 1030, Control of Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Engines Installed on Airplanes

Part 38 requirements are also referenced in the following regulations in 14 CFR:

Part 21, Certification Procedures for Products and Articles including §§ 21.5, 21.17, 21.21, 21.29, 21.31,21.93, 21.101,21.115,21.183, and 21.187, Part 121, Operating Requirements: Domestic, Flag, and Supplemental Operations including § 21.141, and Part 125, Certification and Operations: Airplanes Having a Seating Capacity of 20 or More Passengers or a Maximum Payload Capacity of 6,000 Pounds or More; and Rules Governing Persons on Board such Aircraft including § 125.75.

1.8 Definitions and Abbreviations/Acronyms/Symbols

1.8 Definitions and Abbreviations/Acronyms/Symbols

Definitions are provided in Appendix 1 and abbreviations, acronyms, and symbols in this AC are provided in Appendix 2.

2. References

This AC references the following:

Clean Air Act Amendments of 1970 (CAA), 42 U.S.C. § 7571 et seq. Control of Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Engines Installed on Airplanes; Emission Standards and Test Procedures, 40 CFR part 1030. International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) International Standards and Recommended Practices, Annex 16 — Volume III — Aeroplane CO2 Emissions, May 2019 International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Environmental Technical Manual (Doc 9501),

2. References

Volume II — Procedures for the CO2 Emissions Certification of Aeroplanes, May 2019

Additional references are provided in Appendix 5.

3. [Reserved]

4. Development of Airplane Fuel Efficiency Regulations

The United States is one of 193 signatory states to International Civil Aviation Organization's (ICAO) Convention on International Civil Aviation (the Chicago Convention). Article 12 of the Chicago Convention requires signatory states to keep their own regulations uniform, to the greatest extent possible, with those established under the Chicago Convention. In March of 2017, the ICAO Council adopted a new CO2 Emissions Certification Standard with an effective date of July 2017. The ICAO considered three categories of technology associated with the fuel efficiency of an airplane design (propulsion, aerodynamics, and structures) in its adoption of a CO2 emissions certification standard for airplanes.

4.1 Establishment of Airplane Fuel Efficiency Regulations

4.1 Establishment of Airplane Fuel Efficiency Regulations

49 USC § 40105(b)(1)(A) states that the Secretary of Transportation and FAA Administrator shall act consistently with obligations of the United States Government under international agreements. For development of aviation emissions standards, the FAA leads the U.S. delegation at ICAO meetings with assistance from the EPA.

4.2 Relationship Between the EPA and the FAA

4.2 Relationship Between the EPA and the FAA

The Clean Air Act authorizes the EPA to set standards for aircraft engine emissions in the United States (42 USC § 7571), while the FAA is authorized to enforce those standards. Section 7571 states the following:

(2)(A) The Administrator shall, from time to time, issue proposed emission standards applicable to the emission of any air pollutant from any class or classes of aircraft engines which in his judgment causes, or contributes to, air pollution which may reasonably be anticipated to endanger public health or welfare. (B)(i) The Administrator shall consult with the Administrator of the Federal Aviation Administration on aircraft engine emission standards. (ii) The Administrator shall not change the aircraft engine emission standards if such change would significantly increase noise and adversely affect safety.

The standards promulgated by the EPA in 40 CFR part 1030 apply to certain classes of engines used by certain civil subsonic jet and propeller-driven airplanes (40 CFR part 1030.1). In developing airplane emissions regulations, the CAA requires that the EPA consult with the FAA Administrator and ensure that changes to emission standards do not significantly increase noise and adversely affect safety.

4.3 Relationship Between 14 CFR Part 38 and 40 CFR Part 1030

4.3 Relationship Between 14 CFR Part 38 and 40 CFR Part 1030

The fuel efficiency standards in 14 CFR part 38 implement those adopted by the EPA in 40 CFR part 1030. Accordingly, if the EPA takes any action to change any regulation or standard in 40 CFR part 1030 that is also promulgated in 14 CFR part 38, the Administrator of the FAA will grant a general administrative waiver of those outdated requirements in 14 CFR part 38 until 14 CFR part 38 can be amended to reflect the changes in 40 CFR Part 1030. (14 CFR § 38.9) The FAA will enforce the 40 CFR part 1030 requirements, for which a waiver has been granted, as part of the 14 CFR part 38 fuel efficiency certification. Under these circumstances, the certification documentation will reflect that it complies with both 40 CFR part 1030 and 14 CFR part 38.

4.4 Differences Between ICAO Annex 16 Volume IIl and 14 CFR Part 38

4.4 Differences Between ICAO Annex 16 Volume IIl and 14 CFR Part 38

Under the Chicago Convention, the FAA is obligated to notify ICAO of any U.S. regulatory differences between the ICAO standards and those adopted in the United States. The EPA refers to its regulations as greenhouse gas emissions in part 1030; FAA refers to its regulations as airplane fuel efficiency; and the ICAO standard is titled “Certification Standard for Aeroplane CO2 Emissions Based on the Consumption of Fuel." The FAA, EPA, and ICAO each use different terminology to reference the same standards and there are no substantive differences with the meaning of these terms. The FAA has not identified any substantive differences between U.S. regulations and Annex 16 Volume IlI.

5. Part 38 Subpart A – General

5. Part 38 Subpart A – General

5.1 Section 38.1 Applicability

Section 38.1(a) requires fuel efficiency certification for certain subsonic jets, propeller-driven airplanes, and modified airplanes. Fuel efficiency certification applicability is based on the date for which an application for a type certificate is submitted. In general, the standards apply to airplanes with new type designs (submitted on or after January 11, 2021); airplanes that were type certificated before January 11, 2021, but continue production with certain modifications on or after January 1, 2023; and all airplanes that are in production on and after January 1, 2028. The exact terms of applicability should be determined using the language of § 38.1, not from this brief description.

For subsonic jet and propeller-driven airplanes for which an application for a type certificate is submitted on or after January 11, 2021, part 38 applies as specified in Table 5.1. See § 38.1(a)(1)-(3).

Table 5.1.

Fuel Efficiency Certification Applicability for New Airplane Designs

For an airplane With a passenger With a maximum For which an application for that is a: seating capacity of: takeoff mass (MTOM) original type certification is in kg of: submitted: Subsonic Jet 20 or more > 5,700 On or after January 11, 2021

Subsonic Jet 19 or fewer > 60,000 On or after January 11, 2021

Subsonic Jet 19 or fewer > 5,700 and < 60,000 On or after January 1, 2023

Propeller-driven > 8,618 On or after January 11, 2021

Table 5.2 shows part 38 applicability to newly produced modified versions of airplanes (i.e. airplanes receiving their first certificate of airworthiness that are newly built with the modified type design) whose type design was not required to have fuel efficiency certification under part 38, and for which an application by the type certificate holder for a type design change is submitted on or after January 1, 2023. See § 38.1(a)(4)-(5)

Table 5.2.

Fuel Efficiency Certification Applicability for Modified Version of an Airplane Whose Type Design was not certificated under part 38

For an airplane With a maximum takeoff mass For which an application by a type that is a: (MTOM) in kg of: certificate holder for a type design change is submitted: Subsonic Jet > 5,700 On or after January 1, 2023

Propeller-driven > 8,618 On or after January 1, 2023

Table 5.3 shows part 38 applicability to the production of individual airplanes for which the airplane type design was not originally required to meet 14 CFR part 38. See §§ 38.1(a)(6)-(7).

Table 5.3.

Fuel Efficiency Certification Applicability for Airplanes issued Airworthiness Certificates on or after January 1, 2028

For an airplane With a maximum takeoff mass For which the first certificate of that is a: (MTOM) in kg of: airworthiness is issued: Subsonic Jet > 5,700 On or after January 1, 2028

Propeller-driven > 8,618 On or after January 1, 2028

Note: 14 CFR 38 and 40 CFR 1030 requirements apply based on aircraft thresholds such as MTOM “greater than 8,618 kg,” while airworthiness applicability thresholds such as those of parts 21 and 23 might otherwise be expressed as 8,618 kg (19,000 Ib). The FAA acknowledges that conversion from 8,618 kg to Ibs is approximately 0.5 Ibs less than the 19,000 Ibs threshold of other FAA regulations. However, when applying the conversion in reverse, going from 19,000 Ibs to kg, the result is approximately 0.25 kg greater than 8,618 kg. This less than 1 Ib or 1 kg difference is extremely small and it is unlikely that an airplane would fall within this conversion difference. Importantly, differences less than 1 Ib or 1 kg would not be reflected in either a type certificate data sheet (TCDS) or an airplane flight manual. Additionally, the use of kilograms as the applicability threshold is consistent with the EPA standard.

Table 5.4, below, provides examples of the applicability of part 38.

Table 5.4.

Examples of Part 38 Applicability

Status Individual Airplane Today Applicability part 38 Effective Dates for Applicability of Applicability when modified Limit (FEM) Fuel Efficiency Metric

In service, and type None None None None is no longer being produced EX: 757 Airplanes still being None 1/1/2023 for newly Must comply with In-production limit produced built modified the in-production § 38.17(b)(5) - EX: 787-9 airplanes limit if: (8) § 38.1(a)(4) - (1) produced after (5); 1/1/2023 (§ or 38.1(a)(4) – (5)); and 1/1/2028 for all (2) includes a newly built modification that airplanes changes the FEM § 38.1(a)(6) - value (§ 38.19(c)). (7) New (Original) § 38.1(a)(1) 1/11/2021 All airplanes; New type limit Type: large jet and (3) New certification § 38.17(b)(1) -

airplanes and required if triggered (4) propeller-driven by change criteria (§ airplanes 38.19(a)) New (Original) § 38.1(a)(2) 1/1/2023 All airplanes; New type limit Type: small New certification § 38.17(b)(1) airplanes required if triggered by change criteria (§ 38.19(a))

5.1.1 Modified Airplanes

5.1.1 Modified Airplanes

Section 38.1(b) states that part 38 fuel efficiency requirements apply to an airplane for which an application in type design is submitted that incorporates a modification that meets the change criteria in § 38.19. A new airplane produced with modifications meeting the change criteria may not exceed the applicable fuel efficiency limit of part 38. The applicability criteria for modified airplanes is described in § 38.19 and guidance is provided in paragraph 6.8 of this AC. A modified airplane is subject to the same fuel efficiency metric value limit in § 38.17 as the airplane was prior to modification.

Applicants may choose to apply for a new fuel efficiency metric certification value even when not required by part 38.

5.1.2 Non-Applicability of the Fuel Efficiency Metric

5.1.2 Non-Applicability of the Fuel Efficiency Metric

Part 38 fuel efficiency certification requirements do not apply to:

(1) Subsonic jet airplanes having a MTOM at or below 5,700 kg.

(2) Propeller-driven airplanes having a MTOM at or below 8,618 kg.

(3) Amphibious airplanes.

(4) Airplanes initially designed, or modified and used, for specialized operations. These airplane designs may include characteristics or configurations necessary to conduct specialized operations that the FAÀ and the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) have determined may cause a significant increase in the fuel efficiency metric value.

The FAA shares some examples of specialized operations from the ICAO Environmental Technical Manual, Volume 3, (ETM) that include:

Airplanes with mission requirements for carrying cargo that is not possible by using less specialized airplanes (e.g., ramped back cargo door);1 Airplanes with mission requirements for conducting very short or vertical takeoffs and landings; or Airplanes with mission requirements for conducting scientific, research or humanitarian missions exclusive of commercial service.

(5) Airplanes designed with a reference geometric factor of zero.

(6) Airplanes designed for, or modified and used for, firefighting (i.e. dispensing firefighting materials).

1 Example includes hinged fuselage sections such as Airbus' Beluga [A300-600].

(7) Airplanes powered by reciprocating engines.

Generally, airplanes in categories (3), (4), (5) and (6) are designed or modified in such a way that their designs are significantly different from the typical passenger or cargo-carrying airplanes. See § 38.1(c).

5.2 Certification of Lower Takeoff Mass Variant

5.2 Certification of Lower Takeoff Mass Variant

The calculation of specific air range (SAR) is based on reference masses that are a function of the MTOM, which is defined in §38.3 as the maximum certified takeoff mass, expressed in kilograms, for an airplane type design. The MTOM is intended to mean the maximum takeoff mass an airplane type design is certificated to that is stated in the TCDS. The TCDS may contain several maximum takeoff masses for different variants of the same airplane type design, and the MTOM is the highest of these maximum takeoff masses. In other words, for a specific airplane type design, applicants may develop multiple take-off mass (TOM) variants for operational purposes. The highest TOM variant of an airframe/engine combination for which certification of that variant under part 38 will be sought must demonstrate compliance with part 38.17. All lesser TOMs are considered to have the same fuel efficiency certification value as at MTOM.

However, applicants may also apply for certification of fuel efficiency metric values for TOM variants lower than MTOM. For such a case, the calculated reference airplane mass required by §38.13(b) and the maximum permitted fuel efficiency certification limits shown in §38.17 would be based on the TOM variant requested to be certified. The FEM value determined for such a lower TOM variant can be also used for any TOM variants that are even lower than for that specific airplane type design.

If an applicant chooses to certify a lower TOM variant, the applicant should be aware that the FEM at the highest weight variant (MTOM) of an airplane has the lowest margin to the regulatory limit level. Certification at MTOM is required regardless of the certification of any lower TOM variants. The 1/SAR value used in the FEM determination is calculated as an average of 1/SAR values that are established at three reference masses (high, medium, and low).

In establishing the reference specifications for specific air range (SAR) determination, the highest SAR value usually will be sought at the maximum range cruise condition at the reference specifications. A greater non-linearity in the 1/SAR versus mass relationship could be introduced by a constraint unrelated to the aerodynamic and propulsive efficiency of the airplane (e.g., an altitude pressurization limitation). In this instance, particular care should be taken to ensure that the principle of the highest weight variant having the lowest margin to the regulatory limit level continues to hold.

5.3 Exemptions

5.3 Exemptions

Pursuant to 49 U.S.C. § 44701(f), the Administrator may grant an exemption from a regulatory requirement if the Administrator finds the exemption is in the public interest. An application for an exemption from any requirements of part 38 must be submitted to the Administrator in accordance with part 11. For all § 38.5 exemption requests, denials, or grants, AEE will be the responsible FAA office and will consult with EPA's Designated Program Officer and other FAA offices as needed before taking any action. Petitioners for part 38 exemptions are encouraged to contact AEE prior to filing exemption requests.

5.4 Incorporation by Reference

5.4 Incorporation by Reference

Section 38.7 incorporates, by reference, ICAO Doc 7488/3, Manual of the ICAO Standard Atmosphere (extended to 80 kilometres (262 500 feet)), 1993. ICAO Doc 7488/3 provides the standard values of atmospheric parameters, the values of constants and coefficients, and the underlying equations used in the calculation of the atmospheric parameters. The manual is intended for use in calculations in the design of airplanes, in presenting test results of airplanes and their components under identical

conditions, and in facilitating standardization in the development and calibration of instruments. ICAO Doc 7488/3 is referenced in the Appendix to part 38, paragraphs A38.2.1.3.1, A38.5.2.2.1.9, and A38.5.2.2.1.10. In these paragraphs, the applicant must use ICAO Doc 7488/3 to establish certain reference specifications when determining SAR. Interested persons can purchase ICAO Doc 7488/3 from the ICAO Store at 999 Robert-Bourassa Boulevard Montréal (Quebec) Canada H3C 5H7, (www.store.icao.int).

5.5 Fuel Efficiency Compliance Demonstration Plans

5.5 Fuel Efficiency Compliance Demonstration Plans

Prior to undertaking a demonstration of fuel efficiency, the applicant must submit procedures, weights, configurations, and other information or data that are used to establish a fuel efficiency level to the FAA. This submission must contain a complete description of the methodology and procedures by which an applicant proposes to demonstrate compliance with part 38. This submission must be approved by an FAA certification office in accordance with §38.21.

Use of any equivalent procedures or technical procedures not otherwise specified in part 38 must be approved by AEE and documented in the submission as stated in §38.21. The submission should include the following information:

a. A description of the applicable sections of part 38 for the airplane b. Airplane description, including type, model number, and if applicable, the specific design being certificated. The applicant should demonstrate and document the conformity of the test airplane, particularly with regard to those parts which might affect the test airplane's fuel efficiency metric (FEM). C. FEM certification methodology which should include the means of compliance and proposed equivalent procedures. d. Test plan that would include:

i. Test description. Test methods to comply with the test stability conditions in Appendix A § A38.4.2.2.2 of part 38; ii. Test points. The planned number of test points and the planned test conditions in terms of weight or mass, center of gravity position, altitude, and speed; iii. Airplane mass. The procedures for determining the mass of the airplane is in Appendix A § A38.4.2.3 of part 38; and iv. Test fuel properties. The procedures for determining the test fuel properties is in Appendix A § A38.4.2.1.3 through A38.4.2.1.5 of part 38.

e. Deliverables: List the documents that should show compliance with Appendix A § 38.6 of part 38.

5.6 Fuel Efficiency Compliance Demonstration for Airplanes with Intermixed Engines

Typically, an applicant demonstrates compliance with part 38 for an airplane type design in which all engines are of the same design. If there are engines of different design on an airplane, the design is commonly referred to as having an “engine intermix” configuration, An applicant may choose to demonstrate compliance of an airplane type design that includes an engine intermix. In such a case, the applicant may, subject to the approval of the FAA, demonstrate compliance in one of three ways:

5.6 Fuel Efficiency Compliance Demonstration for Airplanes with Intermixed Engines

a. In accordance with the test procedures defined in part 38, the test airplane must be representative of the intermix arrangement for which certification is requested; or b. In cases where the FEM value has been established for airplanes on which each of the intermix engine models has been exclusively installed, compliance can be demonstrated on the basis of either: i. The average of the fuel efficiency evaluation metrics for identical airplanes on which each of the intermix engine models has been exclusively installed; or

ii. The highest fuel efficiency evaluation metric for identical airplanes on which each of the intermix engine models has been exclusively installed.

6. Expanded Discussion of 14 CFR part 38 Subpart B Requirements

6. Expanded Discussion of 14 CFR part 38 Subpart B Requirements

6.1 Fuel Efficiency Metric

The fuel efficiency metric (FEM) in § 38.11 is a transport capability neutral measure of airplane fuel efficiency. The FEM system is intended to promote advances in technologies that contribute to improvements in fuel efficiency (structural, propulsive, and aerodynamic efficiencies) as well as differentiate among generations of such technologies. In addition, the fuel efficiency metric system was designed to accommodate a wide range of technologies and designs that manufacturers may employ to improve the fuel efficiency of an airplane in a manner that is transport capability neutral. The FEM system is based on three elements associated with airplane technology and design:

6.1 Fuel Efficiency Metric

1. Cruise point fuel burn performance; 2. Airplane size; and 3. Airplane mass.

Section 38.11 requires that, for each airplane subject to part 38, a fuel efficiency metric value is calculated using the following equation (rounded to three decimal places):

1

Fuel Efficiency metric value= (SAR) RGF0.24 avg

The specific air range (SAR) is determined in accordance with § 38.13. The reference geometric factor (RGF) is determined in accordance with § 38.15. SAR is expressed in units of km traveled per kg of fuel burned, while RGF is dimensionless. The FEM value uses the inverse of SAR, (1/SAR)avg , so FEM is expressed in units of kg of fuel burned per km of flight. The fuel efficiency metric is determined using an average of three SAR test points that are normalized by RGF, which is a geometric factor representing the physical size of an airplane. A lower FEM value represents greater fuel efficiency. An overview of the fuel efficiency metric system elements is shown in Figure 6-1, below.

Fig. 6-1.

Overview of the fuel efficiency metric system elements

Metric Correlating Parameter

(1/SAR) / RGF0.24 Certified MTOM

Specific Air Range Reference Geometry Airplane Maximum (1/SAR) Factor (RGF) Take-Off Mass (MTOM)

Specific Air Range is the distance Reference Geometric Factor is a Maximum Take-Off Mass is the an airplane travels per unit of non-dimensional number derived maximum certified takeoff mass, fuel consumed. from a two-dimensional expressed in kilograms, for an projection of the fuselage. airplane type design.

Unlike the specific fuel consumption (SFC) of an engine, which provides the engine's fuel consumption per unit of thrust (i.e., fuel efficiency of thrust production by an individual engine), SAR is a measure of fuel efficiency at the airplane level. Specifically, SAR provides the distance an airplane can travel per

unit of fuel (i.e., fuel efficiency of an airplane in level cruise flight). Airplane fuel efficiency defined by SAR is commonly used by airplane manufacturers when describing airplane fuel efficiency performance to customers (e.g., airlines).

6.2 Specific Air Range

6.2 Specific Air Range

As discussed in paragraph 6.1, Specific Air Range (SAR) is a measure of airplane cruise performance that provides the distance an airplane can travel on a unit of fuel.

In accordance with § 38.13(a), for each airplane subject to part 38, the SAR value is calculated by using either direct flight test measurements or using a performance model that is (i) validated by actual SAR flight test data; and (ii) approved by the FAA before any SAR calculations are submitted.

The value of 1/SAR varies with airplane gross mass and is measured at three certification test points based on gross mass. Section 38.13(b) provides that for each airplane model, a 1/SAR value is determined at each of the following reference airplane masses:

1. High Gross Mass: 92 percent MTOM. 2. Low Gross Mass: (0.45 * MTOM) + (0.63 * (MTOM^0.924)). 3. Mid Gross Mass: simple arithmetic average of high gross mass and low gross mass

where all reference masses are expressed in kilograms (kg).

The three reference airplane masses were chosen with the objective of making the evaluation of fuel burn performance relevant to day-to-day aircraft operations, and to make sure that the entire envelope of cruise operations is accounted for. These three 1/SAR values, calculated at each of three certification test points in accordance with §38.13(b), are weighted equally to give a single metric value. Section 38.13(c) requires that the value for (1/SAR)avg be obtained from the three 1/SAR points calculated in § 38.13(b), and subsequently used to determine the fuel efficiency metric value described in §38.11. An illustrative example of the three representative cruise points is shown in the Figure 6-2.

Fig. 6-2.

An illustration of the three representative cruise points.

Low 1

Optimum cruise altitude High 1 1 Mid Gross 1 1 11 1 I Gross Weight 1 1 1

Gross 1 Weight 1 1 Weight 1 1 11 1 Descent

Ascent 1 1 11 1 1

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

The SAR values for each of the three reference masses defined in § 38.13(b) are to be calculated either directly from flight measurements taken at each valid test point adjusted to reference specifications, or indirectly from a performance model that has been validated by the test points, as required by § 38.13(a). The final SAR value for each reference mass is the simple arithmetic average of all valid test points at the gross mass, or derived from a validated performance model as stated in § A38.5.2.3.1. No data acquired from a valid test point shall be omitted unless approved by the FAA, as stated in Appendix A§ 38.5.2.3.1.

Note: Extrapolations consistent with accepted airworthiness practices to masses other than those tested may be allowable using a validated performance model (for example, to validate new, higher MTOMs or to validate the low gross weight range if it is not obtained during flight tests). The performance model must be based on data covering an adequate range of lift coefficient, Mach number, and thrust specific fuel consumption. No extrapolations of lift coefficient, Mach number, and thrust specific fuel consumption are allowed. Use of any performance model is subject to AEE approval. See Appendix A § A38.5.2.3.2.

6.3 SAR Data Analysis

6.3 SAR Data Analysis

SAR data used to demonstrate compliance must consider both the selection of flight test data gathered during each test condition used for each individual SAR point, as well as the distribution of the resulting corrected SAR points relative to the three reference masses and the reference specifications.

6.3.1 SAR Measurement System

6.3.1 SAR Measurement System

As stated in § A38.5.1.6 of part 38 Appendix A, the SAR measurement system consists of the instruments and devices, including any associated procedures, used to acquire the parameter values that are necessary for determination of the SAR for each flight test condition. Section A38.5.1.8 prescribes an accuracy level (1.5%) that must be achieved by the measurement system for the resulting SAR values to be used without penalty. If this accuracy level is not achieved, the resulting SAR values will be penalized by the amount the measurement system error exceeds the 1.5% accuracy level.

Section A38.5.1.7 defines the accuracy level of the measurement system to be the root sum of squares (RSS) of the accuracies of the individual elements that make up the measurement system. The individual elements of the measurement system are identified in § A38.5.1.6. The RSS of the measurement system is determined from the equation, RSS = √A2 + B2 + C2 + ... Z2 where A, B, C, Z, are the accuracies of each of the individual elements of the measuring system. The individual elements must meet the accuracy requirements when showing compliance with part 38.

6.3.2 Selection of Flight Test Data

6.3.2 Selection of Flight Test Data

There are a number of methods that may be used by different airplane manufacturers in selecting flight test data for analysis, reflecting a variety of tools and practices used within the industry. Whichever method is chosen, the flight test data chosen by an applicant within a selected time frame for an individual SAR data point must meet the stability criteria detailed in § A38.4.2.2.2 or alternative stability criteria approved by the FAA as described in § A38.4.2.2.3. Test data that do not meet these stability criteria would normally be discarded if not needed. However, if such test data appear to be valid when compared with data that meet the stability criteria, and the overall stability of the conditions is reasonably bounded, these data can be used, subject to FAA approval.

One acceptable method is to employ an algorithm that automatically selects the data that meet all the stability criteria and discards data that do not. This method could be used to select the longest possible duration SAR point that meets the required stability criteria, or to select multiple SAR points of the minimum requirement duration (one minute), provided that these points are separated by a minimum of two minutes or by an exceedance of the stability criteria, as specified in § A38.4.2.2.2.

Using a defined algorithm to select data in an automated process allows repeatable and consistent

application to other SAR points. This method may also yield a greater number of SAR points to be used in defining the FEM value and should represent a good statistical distribution. However, because the amount of test data included in each SAR point is maximized, the resulting SAR points could exhibit more scatter than if additional selection criteria are used.

Another method for the selection of flight test data is to more closely examine the collected flight test data and select the time frame to be used to define the SAR point by choosing the best or most stable data available and ignoring less stable data that technically still meet the stability criteria. Examples of this are presented in Figures 6-3 and 6-4.

Figure 6-3 shows that the plotted parameters stay within the tolerances allowed by the stability criteria for the duration of the test condition. (The changing altitude after the end of the condition reflects pilot input to leave steady flight and transition to the next test condition.) While all parameters are within the required tolerances as specified in § A38.4.2.2.2, fluctuations in ambient temperature and Mach are evident. Figure 6-4 shows the same data, but with a manually selected range of shorter duration where the parameters are more stable.

Figure 6-3.

Flight test data time interval selection -Example1

Mach Ground speed (km/hr) OAT (°C) ALT (m) +.005

-.005 +3.7

-3.7 +1

-1 +23

Test point duration = 2:40 -23 0 60 120 180

Time (s)

Figure 6-4.

Flight test data time interval selection -Example 2

Mach Ground speed (km/hr) OAT (°C) ALT (m) +.005

-.005 +3.7

-3.7 +1

-1 +23

Test point duration = 1:00 -23 0 60 120 180

Time (s)

Selecting data that meet more demanding stability criteria, instead of using all data that meet the stability criteria indicated in § A38.4.2.2.2, may allow the applicant to filter out observed instabilities caused by air quality, changing environmental conditions, flight control inputs, and airplane system dynamics. This could result in a SAR point that is more representative of actual airplane performance. Whichever approach the applicant takes to select data to define SAR points, the methodology needs to be applied as consistently as possible to minimize potential unseen bias in the resulting distribution of SAR points.

Another important aspect to consider when selecting data is to ensure that the time interval chosen is representative of the airplane's performance and not indicative of a larger trend. For example, the first plot in Figure 6-3 shows a trend line drawn through ground speed data over a 60-second time interval. This ground speed data meets the stability criteria and taken alone, would indicate the need for an energy correction, which is used to correct for excess or inadequate potential or kinetic energy (i.e., a deviation from the reference condition of steady, unaccelerated flight; see Acceleration/deceleration (energy) in A38.5.2.2.1.1).

However, if the ground speed data trace was continued over a longer time interval, it becomes apparent that it exhibits cyclical behavior. Cyclical data need not necessarily be discarded, but the applicant

should ensure that an appropriate time interval is selected such that the arithmetic average is representative. In the example shown in Figure 6-5, below, an energy correction would be inappropriate.

Figure 6-5.

Cyclical behavior example

Ground speed (km/hr) Linear best fit 2

0

-2 0 60

Time (s)

Ground speed (km/hr) Linear best fit 2

0

-2 0 60 120 180 240

Time (s)

6.3.3 Distribution of Resulting SAR Points Once the individual SAR points have been selected and corrected to reference specifications, they need to be examined to ensure they reflect an accurate representation of the airplane's performance. This is described in the following paragraphs.

For example, if direct flight test is being used to collect 6 SAR points targeting one reference mass, those 6 points, when corrected to reference specifications, should result in a reasonable grouping. If 5 of the points form a reasonable grouping and one point is a clear outlier, the outlier may require closer scrutiny to ensure it is actually representative. In such a situation, collection of additional data may be warranted or, if appropriate, and subject to the approval of the FAA, the offending data point could be discarded.

If the applicant conducts tests across a range of weights to build a regression line of SAR versus weight, the collected SAR points should be reasonably distributed across the weight range. If a large portion of the regression line is unsupported by data, or is anchored by a single SAR point, then the

SAR determined for one of the reference masses may be an outlier. This is an important aspect to consider during the development of the certification plan and flight test program. As with the direct test method, if a single SAR point appears to be an outlier compared to the rest of the data points, it needs to be examined more closely and may potentially be discarded.

The applicant should investigate the collection of SAR points for potential sources of unintended bias. An example would be where all of the data points collected were during periods when ground speed was increasing. If all of the test points require a large energy correction in one direction, resulting in all SAR points being significantly increased (or decreased), further scrutiny may be needed to ensure that a bias is not introduced, depending on the test data and correction techniques being used.

6.3.4 Correction of SAR Data to Reference Specifications

6.3.4 Correction of SAR Data to Reference Specifications

To ensure that the SAR data has a consistent baseline for use in determining the FEM, the SAR data must be corrected to a set of reference specifications as required in part 38 by § A38.2. One set of methods for correcting the SAR data to reference specifications, but not the only acceptable set of methods, is provided in Appendix 3 to this AC.

6.4 Equivalent Procedures Use of equivalent procedures must be approved by AEE, in advance, and on a case-by-case basis in accordance with § 38.21. Section 38.13(a) establishes the methods of compliance as being direct flight test or by use of a validated performance model that is approved before any SAR calculations are submitted.

Examples of equivalent procedures are the following:

6.4.1 Example 1: FAA Approval based on existing data Applicants could develop a regression curve approach for SAR values across the gross weight (MTOM) range based on existing data. This regression curve approach using existing data could be used in situations such as:

a) The existing performance model used company test data that may have not been witnessed by the FAA or documentation of the conformity of the airplane type design may not have been provided to the FAA, but the data obtained are found acceptable by the FAA at the time of certification, or b) The accuracy of the instrumentation and the data reduction processes may not have been documented sufficiently for certification, or the original documentation may not have been retained, but the data available are found acceptable by the FAA at the time of certification.

6.4.2 Example 2: FAA Approval of a change based on back-to-back testing The use of back-to-back test data may be requested by applicants as an equivalent procedure for determining the FEM for a relatively small type design change (e.g., antenna installations or other simple drag changes). Back-to-back testing for determining a FEM value change means that a test is first completed without the change applied to the airplane, and then the test is repeated with the change made to the airplane. The difference in the FEM values of the before and after tests is presumed to be the result of the change on the airplane FEM value. This approach may not be appropriate for engine changes where the specific fuel consumption (SFC) of the engine may change due to internal changes. This compliance approach will likely be especially useful for supplemental type certificate (STC) modifiers who do not have access to the original flight test data from the airplane manufacturer, such as:

a) Back-to-back testing should be performed on the same airplane and engines with the modification installed and not installed. b) Instrumentation adequate to provide data meeting the accuracy requirements of the standard should be installed in the test airplane.

c) The data reduction and comparison processes must be approved by the FAA in accordance with § 38.21.

6.4.3 Example 3: FAA Approval of a change based on analysis

6.4.3 Example 3: FAA Approval of a change based on analysis

The use of analytical processes may be requested by an applicant to evaluate a change to the FEM of a previously approved airplane type design and establish compliance with § 38.17, and the analytical processes must be approved by the FAA in accordance with § 38.21. Paragraphs 6.4.3.1 and 6.4.3.2, below, provide a non-exclusive list of possible analytical methods, but do not preclude the use of other equivalent procedures.

6.4.3.1 Changes affecting characteristics of airplane aerodynamics

6.4.3.1 Changes affecting characteristics of airplane aerodynamics

Subject to approval by the FAA, methods available to evaluate the effect of aerodynamic changes on airplane drag could include:

Semi-empirical methods (SEM), Computational fluid dynamics (CFD), Computational fluid dynamics combined with computational structural mechanics (CFD-CSM), and Wind tunnel testing.

The FAA's approval for the use of the above analytical methods to evaluate a change to the FEM value may depend on the type of airplane modification as listed below.

For design changes affecting parasitic drag and/or profile drag (e.g., friction drag and/or viscous pressure drag), SEM, CFD, or wind tunnel testing could be used. In this case, it is assumed that airplane aeroelastics are not affected.

For all other design changes, CFD could be used for items not affecting airplane aeroelastics, CFD-CSM could be used for items affecting airplane aeroelastics, and wind tunnel testing could be used in all cases.

6.4.3.2 Changes to specific fuel consumption (SFC) affected by a change to the propulsion system:

Possible methods available to evaluate the effect of propulsion system design changes on specific fuel consumption (SFC) are:

a. Thermo dynamical models (engine performance decks), b. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD), c. Component testing, d. Full engine testing, and e. A combination of a. through d.

6.4.4 Example 4: FAA Approval based on first principle models

6.4.4 Example 4: FAA Approval based on first principle models

Introduction

Section 38.13(a) requires that the specific air range must be determined by direct flight test measurements or the use of a performance model that is:-

I. validated by actual SAR flight test data and II. approved by the FAA before any specific air range calculations are submitted.

A performance model is defined in 38.3 as “an analytical tool (or a method) validated using corrected flight test data that can be used to determine the specific air range values for calculating the fuel efficiency metric value."

Guidance on the approval of SAR values based on specific types of performance models known as "first principle models” is provided below. A first principle model is defined as a tool that enables the derivation of a SAR value, in given flight conditions, from flight mechanics equations using airplane aerodynamics and engine performance data.

First principle models should be validated by actual SAR flight test data that is acquired in a manner consistent with § A38.1.2 and as described in paragraph 6.3 of this AC.Validity of the model need only to be shown for the test points and conditions relevant to demonstrating compliance with § 38.17.

The method proposed in this paragraph, 6.4.4, represents one possible method to show compliance with § 38.17.

6.4.4.1 Selection of relevant flight test points for the model validation

6.4.4.1 Selection of relevant flight test points for the model validation

First principle SAR models developed by airplane manufacturers typically cover most of the flight envelope to provide many different operational fuel planning requirements. The range of flight test data from these models typically spans large Mach and weight/δ ranges.

The example shown in Figure 6-6, below, illustrates the wide distribution of the flight test data across the model, and that none of the test points generally fall exactly at the three SAR conditions defined in § 38.13(b).

Figure 6-6.

Flight test points

Lines of weight/δ Optimum

8 SAR Three defined masses for CO2compliance X

8 SAR Three defined masses for CO2compliance X

Data range considered for regression

Mach number

Test points range

Figure 6-6 shows that the three SAR conditions required by § 38.13(b) are relatively close to each other in terms of Mach and weight/δ because they represent the same optimum aerodynamic conditions for achieving the best (lowest) 1/SAR values. Although these three SAR conditions may not have been specifically flight tested, they are generally well framed by other relevant flight test data in a local Mach and weight/δ range.

In order to validate the performance model in conditions relevant to demonstrating compliance with § 38.17, flight test points around the optimum Mach number and optimum weight/δ would be selected based on the following criteria:

a) Weight/δ between ±5 percent of the optimum weight/δ; and b) Mach number between -0.02 and +0.015 of the optimum Mach number.

Note 1.— The ±5 percent value in a) is used to capture flight test points on weight/δ lines above and below the optimum weight/δ included in the airplane manufacturer's flight test practices.

Note 2.— The density of test points is generally lower at Mach numbers below the optimum Mach number and higher at Mach numbers above the optimum Mach number. Additionally, the Mach effect on SAR is generally less at Mach numbers below the optimum Mach number than above, and a sharp SAR decrease may occur when approaching high Mach numbers. For this reason, the Mach range for the test point selection is larger at Mach numbers below the optimum Mach number (-0.02) than above (+0.015).

Note 3.— Testing target weight/δ values non-dimensionalizes the pressure altitude so that weight/δ varies as CL.M2. Therefore, weight/δ at a given Mach varies similarly to C, at that Mach number.

6.4.4.2 SAR model justification

6.4.4.2 SAR model justification

6.4.4.2.1 Flight test SAR versus SAR model

In order to use first principle models to determine the SAR values for calculating the FEM, manufacturers are expected to explain their modelling validation principles and show that their modelling correctly matches flight test data acquired in a manner consistent with part 38 Appendix A, as described in paragraph 6.3 of this AC.

As shown in Figures 6-7 and 6-8, below, one possible method is to present plots of percent ∆SAR (i.e. Measured SAR minus Computed SAR) versus Mach and versus weight/δ (or CL). These should be shown in the Mach and weight/δ (or CL) range of the cruise envelope.

An increased number of test points, when available, may be used to qualitatively show that the test point selection, described in paragraph 6.4.4.1 above (red points selected for optimum SAR in Figures 6-7 and 6-8 below, which are within the orange dashed circle in Figure 6-6), is not differently scattered or biased than other test points in the cruise envelope (green points that are all the flight test data in Figures 6-7 and 6-8 below, and these are outside the orange dashed circle in Figure 6-6). Figures 6-7 and 6-8 are examples of a set of data that show no significant biases or differences in scatter inside and outside the cruise envelope.

12/13/2023

874 875 876 877

878 879 880 881 882 883 884 885 886

887 888

2

0

-1

-2

2

0

-1

-2

Figure 6-7

∆SAR versus Mach number

Opt. Hach

FT data 1

Selected for opt. SAR

Mach

Figure 6-8.

∆SAR versus CL

FT data

Selected for opt. SAR

11

111 111

CL

6.4.4.2.2 SAR model presentation

The comparison of flight test points with a model does not validate how that model is built and how the optimum conditions represent the FEM. Accordingly, the SAR model used to demonstrate compliance with§ 38.17 must be approved byFAA per § 38.13(a)(2).

One possible method to present the SAR model is to present plots of computed SAR versus Mach and computed SAR versus CL for the three masses referenced in § 38.13(b). Figures 6-9 and 6-10 show that there are no abnormal discontinuities in the Mach and CL ranges selection around SAR conditions used for the FEM determination.

Figure 6-9

Computed SAR (model) versus Mach at optimum altitude

Lo w gross mass Mid gross mass Hgh gross mass

Red points range

Green points range

Optimum mach

Mach

Figure 6-10

Computed SAR (model) versus CL at optimum Mach

Low gross mass - Md gross mass Hgh gro ss mass

Oplimum

Red points range

Green points range

C

6.4.4.3 SAR model validation – confidence interval determination

6.4.4.3 SAR model validation – confidence interval determination

As explained in paragraph 6.4.4 above, the SAR model needs to be validated under the conditions relevant to demonstrating compliance with §38.17. To be used for validation, flight test points need to be selected using the criteria described in paragraph 6.4.4.1 above. The number of flight test points selected will represent n measurements (number of data points) of SAR (SAR1, SAR2, ..., SAR) obtained in approximately the same conditions of Mach and CL.

Step 1 — Estimate of the mean ∆SAR value and of the standard deviation For each flight test point (i), the SAR difference ∆SAR(i) between the measured SAR and the computed SAR can be determined as follows (in percent):

∆SAR(i)(%) = [(Measured SAR(i) - Computed SAR(i)) / Computed SAR(1)]x 100 (%).

The estimate of the mean ∆SAR value in percent, ∆SARAvg(%), can then be determined for the n measurements as follows:

DSARAvG(%) = estimate of the mean DSAR (%) = 11 n {∑i=1 DSAR(i}(%).

The estimate of the standard deviation of the mean is found as follows:

s = estimate of the standard deviation of the mean = Σi=1(DSAR(t)− DSARAVG)2 n-1

Step 2 — Confidence interval determination

The low number of test points in a small range of Mach and C results in a statistical population that follows the Student law, and allows the 90 percent confidence interval to be defined in accordance with the methodology for Direct Flight Testing, as described in appendix 4 of this AC. The objective is to determine an average ∆SAR value (%) and its associated 90 percent confidence interval. The minimum acceptable sample size is twelve points (see § A38.5.3.4.).

Following this step and using the Student t-distribution, the 90 percent confidence interval (Clgo) for the estimate of the mean ∆SARavg can be determined as:

CI90 (%) = [DSARAVG ± t(.95,n−1)

where t.95, n-1) = Student t-distribution (for 90 percent confidence) for the degrees of freedom (i.e., n-1, where n is number of data points). (See Table A4-1 in Appendix 4 of this AC).

Step 3 — Validity of results

Section A38.5.3.2 contains the following requirements:

“A38.5.3.2 If the 90 per cent confidence interval of the SAR value at any of the three reference airplane masses –

A38.5.3.2.1 Is less than or equal to ±1.5 per cent, the SAR value may be used.

A38.5.3.2.2 Exceeds ±1.5 per cent, a penalty equal to the amount that the 90 per cent confidence interval exceeds ±1.5 per cent must be applied to the SAR value, as approved by the FAA."

Applying those requirements to a use of a first principle model for showing compliance:

a) If the 90 percent confidence interval remains within the ±1.5 percent limits, then the ∆SARAvG (%) value can be retained as the reference deviation for model correction. b) If the 90 percent confidence interval exceeds the ±1.5 percent limits, then a penalty equal to the amount that the 90 percent confidence interval exceeds ±1.5 percent should be applied to the ∆SARavg(%) value, subject to the approval of AEE. For example, if the 90 percent confidence interval is 5 percent, then the corrected ∆SARavg(%) is 3.5 percent (5 percent -1.5 percent). The corrected ∆SARavg(%) value then becomes the reference deviation for the model correction.

Step 4 — SAR Model correction

When used to determine the FEM, the SAR values computed with a first principle model at each of the three reference airplane masses must be corrected by a percentage amount that is equal to the reference deviation determined in Step 3.

6.4.4.4. Example of the determination of 90 percent confidence intervals

6.4.4.4. Example of the determination of 90 percent confidence intervals

The set of 12 flight test points are presumed to meet the selection criteria of paragraph 6.4.4.1 above. The difference between the measured SAR and the computed SAR has been established as follows:

Table 6-1

Test point selection

Selected test point ∆SAR number 1 0.08 2 -0.6 3 -0.42 4 0.19 5 -0.43 6 0.23 7 -0.28 8 0.45 9 0.10 10 -0.28 11 -0.80 12 -0.64

a) The number of data points (n) = 12. b) The degrees of freedom (n-1) = 11. c) The Student t-distribution for 90 percent confidence and 11 degrees of freedom (t(.95,11) ) = 1.797. (See examples in Table A4-1 in Appendix 4 to this AC.).

Step 1 — Estimate of the mean ∆SAR (%) and of the standard deviation(s)

DSARAVG(%) = 12 1 {i=12 DSAR(i)} = -0.200 %

Σ=12 2(DSAR(i)− DSARAVG) = 0.39950 % n-1

Step 2 — 90 percent confidence interval (Cl9o)

S CI90 = DSARAVG ± t(.95,11) √12 -0.200 ± 0.207 %

S CI90 = DSARAVG ± t(.95,11) √12 -0.200 ± 0.207 %

Step 3 — Check of confidence interval limits

The confidence interval extends to ±0.207 percent around the mean ∆SAR value (-0.200 percent), which is within the confidence interval limit of ±1.5 percent. As a result, a ∆SAR value of -0.200 percent can be retained for model correction.

Step 4 — SAR Model correction

The SAR value calculated for each reference mass of the FEM can be determined by computation with the first principle model and would be corrected by the -0.200 percent value determined in Step 3

as follows:

SARcorrected = SARcomputed X 0.998

6.5 Validity of Results – Confidence Interval

6.5 Validity of Results – Confidence Interval

Section A38.5.3.1 requires the 90 percent confidence interval to be calculated for each of the SAR values at the three reference masses. Appendix 4 of this AC provides guidance regarding confidence interval evaluation, including examples.

6.6 Reference Geometric Factor

6.6 Reference Geometric Factor

6.6.1 RGF General Guidelines

The reference geometric factor (RGF) is a non-dimensional parameter used to adjust the value of (1/SAR)avg. RGF is based on a measure of fuselage size normalized with respect to 1 m2, and is derived as prescribed in §38.15.

6.6.1 RGF General Guidelines

The basic concept of RGF, and the exponent of 0.24 for RGF in the fuel efficiency metric, is to give appropriate credit for the size of the cabin. The RGF represents the area that is available for the transport of passengers or cargo on the main deck, and on an upper deck. §§ 38.15 and A38.3 provide a description of RGF and list some areas that are to be included in the RGF calculation, including figures cross-sectional and longitudinal views of notional RGF boundary conditions. This list of included areas is not comprehensive; RGF also includes, for example, any space in the cabin used for wardrobes, or for cabinets containing equipment such as passenger entertainment systems or life rafts.

Most airplanes have a single deck, or floor, for passengers or cargo. Many single-deck airplanes also have an underfloor cargo bay, but that does not mean that they should be considered as two-deck airplanes.

6.6.2 Orthogonal Projection and Width Boundary

6.6.2 Orthogonal Projection and Width Boundary

For a single-deck airplane, the RGF is determined by making an orthogonal projection of the outer mold line (OML) of the fuselage pressure shell, onto a plane that is parallel to the main deck floor. The term orthogonal means that the projection is made using theoretical lines of projection which are orthogonal, or perpendicular, to the main deck floor, and also orthogonal to the plane where the projection is made. In the case of an airplane in which the main deck is perfectly horizontal when it stands on the ground, the projection is similar to the ‘shadow area' on the ground, or the top view area of the fuselage. The terms ‘shadow area' and ‘top view' can be misleading however, and orthogonal projection is the proper term for obtaining a true projection. The term ‘shadow area' could imply projection lines emanating from a single point, effectively like the sun. It is possible to make a projection using lines which emanate from any single point, but that is not intended, and would not be a true projection for RGF. The term 'top view' can be misleading for an airplane in which the main deck is not perfectly horizontal when it stands on the ground. Typically the main deck of an airplane is at a constant height (or constant Z station) in terms of the X, Y, Z coordinate system for the airplane, and in that case the orthogonal projection is the same as a plan view drawing, viewing either up or down along the Z axis. However, there is no requirement for any deck to be at a constant Z station.

Typically the maximum width of the fuselage cross section is above the main deck for a single-deck airplane, and if the fuselage has a constant cross section for part of its length, then the maximum width will be at the same height above the main deck (i.e. at the same Z station) for part of the fuselage length. At the aft end of the fuselage however, there will no longer be a constant cross section, and it is common for the point of maximum width to rise up higher above the main deck towards the tail, with fuselage upsweep. Towards the nose, typically the point of maximum width descends closer to the main

deck. For the orthogonal projection, the maximum external width of the OML is always captured' at whatever height above the deck that it occurs.

For an airplane that has a main deck and also an upper deck, the RGF for the main deck is determined using the fuselage OML as the width boundary, as for a single-deck airplane. The upper deck is considered separately, and the width boundary for the upper deck RGF is defined as the fuselage OML at or above the upper deck floor level. This means that to determine the upper deck RGF, all of the fuselage below the upper deck floor can be removed from consideration, and then an orthogonal projection should be made of the remaining part of the fuselage, the entire upper cabin, onto a plane that is parallel to the upper deck. This projection will capture the maximum width of the fuselage OML at any height at or above the upper deck floor. The upper deck may be parallel to the main lower deck, but there is no requirement for this to be the case. The total RGF is simply the sum of the RGF values for the two decks.

6.6.3Forward and Aft Boundaries

The aft boundary to be used for calculating RGF is the aft surface of the aft pressure bulkhead skin. This bulkhead may be a flat or domed skin to take the pressure loads, and typically has supporting structure attached either to the forward or aft face of the bulkhead. This aft boundary definition is consistent with the concept of using the external surface of the pressure shell for the width boundary.

The forward boundary to be used for calculating RGF is the forward surface of the forward pressure bulkhead skin except for the cockpit crew zone. For all airplanes, a plane will need to be defined for the aft boundary of the cockpit crew zone. If there is a cockpit door, this aft boundary is the plane of the forward face of the cockpit door. If there is no cockpit door, a boundary plane will need to be defined that is aft of the cockpit crew seats. Some airplanes may have optional approved cockpit layouts, for example to provide for one or two ‘jump seats' aft of the two standard pilot seats; in that case the RGF should be based on the smallest approved cockpit layout (see § A38.3).

Some airplanes are certified for single-pilot operations, as illustrated in Appendix A38.3 Figure A38- 2. This figure shows that a passenger may be in the right cockpit seat, and the right side of the cockpit can be included in the RGF, even if a cockpit door is standard equipment. In this case, the aft boundary of the cockpit crew zone applies to the left side of the fuselage only.

For an airplane with two decks, the cockpit may be accessed from the main deck, or the upper deck, but the two decks are considered separately. One deck may extend forward, above or below a cockpit crew zone, and in that case the aft boundary of the cockpit crew zone should only apply to the RGF of the deck that provides direct access to the cockpit, not to both decks.

6.6.4 Floor Plane

6.6.4 Floor Plane

For the floor plane of the main deck, and any upper deck, it is assumed that most, or all, of the floor area is on the same flat plane. It is common to have some local anomalies, such as a step up in the floor of the cabin towards the tail, typically in a baggage area. If there is a relatively small, elevated floor it is usually flat and parallel to the main floor, but there is no requirement for it to be so. Some airplanes may have other local floor changes, possibly even changes in slope. Some smaller airplanes have a dropped aisle, with elevated seating areas on both sides of the aisle. There is no requirement for any deck floor to be parallel with the upper or lower skin of the fuselage, but this will usually be the case. For each deck, there should be no difficulty in identifying a nominal flat plane which should apply to it, which then allows for the identification of a true flat plane (with no local anomalies) parallel to the deck, for the purpose of the orthogonal projection.

6.6.5 RGF Sensitivity

6.6.5 RGF Sensitivity

Although RGF is an important component of the CO2 emissions evaluation metric value, the exponent of 0.24 means that the metric value is less sensitive to a change in RGF as compared to a change in

the average 1/SAR value. As an example, if the average 1/SAR value is changed by a factor of 1.01, then the metric value will also change by a factor of 1.01 (a 1% increase). However, if the RGF changes by a factor of 0.99 (a 1% decrease) then the metric value will increase by only a factor of 1.0024150 (an increase of 0.2415%). The change in metric value as a result of a change in RGF, can be expressed as the reciprocal of the factor applied to RGF, with an exponent of 0.24 applied. For this example: ( 1 / 0.99 ) = 1.010101 ; and (1.010101 )0.24 = 1.002415.

The RGF sensitivity may lead an applicant to declare positions for the forward boundary and aft boundary that are slightly conservative in order to avoid lengthy geometric explanations and justifications. Typically, a small amount of conservatism, by declaring a forward and/or aft boundary that is displaced by 1 or 2 cm will lead to a very small change in RGF, much less than 1%, and an extremely small penalty in the metric value of less than 0.1%.

An applicant may also consider the potential for future geometric changes, and the no-FEM-change criteria. It may be administratively easier to deal with a small geometric change in the future, if the RGF has been defined in a slightly conservative way.

6.6.6 Floor Plane

6.6.6 Floor Plane

For the floor plane of the main deck, and any upper deck, it is assumed that most, or all, of the floor area is on the same flat plane. It is common to have some local anomalies, such as a step up in the floor of the cabin towards the tail, typically in a baggage area. If there is a relatively small, elevated floor it is usually flat and parallel to the main floor, but there is no requirement for it to be so. Some airplanes may have other local floor changes, possibly even changes in slope. Some smaller airplanes have a dropped aisle, with elevated seating areas on both sides of the aisle. There is no requirement for any deck floor to be parallel with the upper or lower skin of the fuselage, but this will usually be the case. For each deck, there should be no difficulty in identifying a nominal flat plane which should apply to it, which then allows for the identification of a true flat plane (with no local anomalies) parallel to the deck, for the purpose of the orthogonal projection.

6.6.7 RGF Sensitivity

6.6.7 RGF Sensitivity

Although RGF is an important component of the CO2 emissions evaluation metric value, the exponent of 0.24 means that the metric value is less sensitive to a change in RGF as compared to a change in the average 1/SAR value. As an example, if the average 1/SAR value is changed by a factor of 1.01, then the metric value will also change by a factor of 1.01 (a 1% increase). However, if the RGF changes by a factor of 0.99 (a 1% decrease) then the metric value will increase by only a factor of 1.0024150 (an increase of 0.2415%). The change in metric value as a result of a change in RGF, can be expressed as the reciprocal of the factor applied to RGF, with an exponent of 0.24 applied. For this example: ( 1 / 0.99 ) = 1.010101 ; and (1.010101 )0.24 = 1.002415.

The RGF sensitivity may lead an applicant to declare positions for the forward boundary and aft boundary that are slightly conservative in order to avoid lengthy geometric explanations and justifications. Typically, a small amount of conservatism, by declaring a forward and/or aft boundary that is displaced by 1 or 2 cm will lead to a very small change in RGF, much less than 1%, and an extremely small penalty in the metric value of less than 0.1%.

An applicant may also consider the potential for future geometric changes, and the no-FEM-change criteria. It may be administratively easier to deal with a small geometric change in the future, if the RGF has been defined in a slightly conservative way.

6.7 Fuel Efficiency Limits

6.7 Fuel Efficiency Limits

Section 38.17 provides the maximum permitted fuel efficiency metric values for airplanes defined under § 38.1(a), as determined pursuant to § 38.11. In accordance with § 38.17(b), the fuel efficiency metric value may not exceed the values detailed in the table with fuel efficiency limits in § 38.17. Notably, the

values determined in accordance with the equations in the table with fuel efficiency limits in § 38.17 should be rounded to three decimal places. The maximum permitted fuel efficiency metric values are based on the type of airplane as defined in § 38.1 (applicability section) and the airplane's MTOM. A more detailed discussion on the applicability of § 38.1 can be found in paragraph 5.1 of this AC.

6.8 Change Criteria

6.8 Change Criteria

A modification requiring compliance with part 38 is determined by the change criteria in § 38.19. The requirements differ depending on whether an airplane has previously demonstrated compliance with part 38 before a modification is made, or whether an airplane was type certificated before January 1, 2023, and was not required to demonstrate compliance with part 38.

The change criteria in § 38.19(a) specifies when a compliance demonstration to this new rule is required if a modification to an airplane, that has been shown to comply with § 38.17, will increase the MTOM of the airplane as written in § 38.19(a)(1) or increases the FEM value above the thresholds provided in § 38.19(a)(2)(i) through (iii). Figure 6.11, below, illustrates the FEM change threshold limits of § 38.19 for any MTOM.

Fig. 6.11

FEM change threshold limits with variation in MTOM

FEM Change Threshold Limits for any MTOM (kg) 1.5%

1.35%, 5700 kg

1.2%

y = -1.10497E-07x + 1.41298E-02

0.9%

Fhd ue 0.6% 0.3% 0.75%, 60000kg y = -9.25926E-10x + 7.55556E-03 FEM Change Threshold Limits 0.70%, 600000 kg y = 7.00E-03

0.0% 0 100,000 200,000 300,000 400,000 500,000 600,000 700,000

Maximum Takeoff Mass (MTOM, kg)

Under § 38.19(b), where an airplane has been shown to comply with § 38.17, for a modification that does not increase either the MTOM or the FEM value, the airplane may retain the same FEM value as prior to modification.

Section 38.19(c) provides that an airplane, which meets the applicability provisions of § 38.1(a)(4) or (5) on or after January 1, 2023 and before January 1, 2028, must demonstrate compliance if the modification exceeds 1.5%. Alternatively, an airplane modification that is shown to have less than a 1.5% increase in FEM does not have to demonstrate compliance. For an airplane whose type design was not previously certified to part 38, an applicant can estimate the change in the FEM value of the

modified version of such an airplane by using one of the methods described in this AC38, if approved by the FAA. For example, for a change to the exterior of the airplane, the change in drag can be estimated using methods described in paragraph 6.4.3 of this AC, and this estimated change in drag can be directly related to changes in FEM value.

7. Additional Guidance

7. Additional Guidance

If an applicant needs additional guidance, contact the AEE-300 Emissions Division Manager with the FAA Office of Environment and Energy at [email protected].

Appendix 1: Definitions

The following terms are defined in § 38.3, which is reproduced here for convenience: Amphibious Airplane means an airplane that is capable of takeoff and landing on both land and water. Such an airplane uses its hull or floats attached to the landing gear for takeoff and landing on water, and either extendable or fixed landing gear for takeoff and landing on land.

Appendix 1: Definitions

ICAO Annex 16, Volume I/I means Volume III of Annex 16 to the Convention on International Civil Aviation (incorporated by reference in § 38.7).

Maximum takeoff mass (MTOM) is the maximum certified takeoff mass, expressed in kilograms, for an airplane type design.

Performance model is an analytical tool (or a method) validated using corrected flight test data that can be used to determine the specific air range values for calculating the fuel efficiency metric value. Reference geometric factor (RGF) is a non-dimensional number derived from a two-dimensional projection of the fuselage.

Specific air range (SAR) is the distance an airplane travels per unit of fuel consumed. Specific air range is expressed in kilometers per kilogram of fuel.

Subsonic means an airplane that has not been certificated under 14 CFR to exceed Mach 1 in normal operation.

Type certificated maximum passenger seating capacity means the maximum number of passenger seats that may be installed on an airplane as listed on its type certificate data sheet, regardless of the actual number of seats installed on an individual airplane.

Appendix 2: Abbreviations/Acronyms/Symbols

Appendix 2: Abbreviations/Acronyms/Symbols

The abbreviations/acronyms/symbols used in this AC have the following meanings whether expressed in upper or lower case:

a Earth's radius at the equator A Airplane reference wing area b Earth's radius at the poles B Value representing the variation of drag with Reynolds number AEE FAA's Office of Environment and Energy AVG Average CD Drag coefficient CFD Computational fluid dynamics CG Center of gravity Cl Confidence interval Cl90 90% Confidence interval CL Lift coefficient CO2 Carbon dioxide EPA United States Environmental Protection Agency FAA Federal Aviation Administration, United States Department of Transportation FEM Fuel Efficiency Metric g Gravitational acceleration go Standard acceleration due to gravity at sea level and a geodetic latitude of 45.5 degrees gref Gravitational acceleration, based on go, for an airplane travelling true north in still air at the reference altitude and a geodetic latitude of 45.5 degrees gCoriolis Component of gravitational acceleration that is due to Coriolis effect gcent Component of gravitational acceleration that is due to centrifugal effect gtest Gravitational acceleration at the test values of latitude, geometric altitude, true track, and ground speed

gφ,alt Component of the gravitational acceleration at the test altitude and latitude at zero ground speed h Altitude ICAO International Civil Aviation Organization Kg Kilogram(s) LHV Lower heating value m Meters M Mach number MTOM Maximum Takeoff Mass n Number of data points N Newtons OML Outer Mold Line Pa Pascals Ps Static pressure re Earth's radius RE Reynolds number RGF Reference Geometric Factor S Time in seconds or estimate of the standard deviation of the mean SAR Specific Air Range SEM Semi-empirical methods SFC Specific fuel consumption STC Supplementary type certificate T Temperature t(.95, n-1 Student t-distribution for 90 percent confidence for n degrees of freedom TAS True airspeed TC Type certificate

TCDS Type certificate data sheet TOM Takeoff mass TSFC Thrust Specific Fuel Consumption V Speed V_g Ground speed Ratio of atmospheric pressure at a given altitude to the atmospheric pressure at sea level Change in value of a parameter Percent Mean value Density of air Track angle Latitude Summation of a series of values Degrees of freedom of confidence interval WE Earth's rotation rate

Appendix 3: Correcting SAR Data to Reference Specifications

Appendix 3: Correcting SAR Data to Reference Specifications

A3-1. Corrections to Reference Specifications

This appendix covers corrections that must be made to the tested values of airplane weight, drag, and fuel flow. These corrections address any differences between the conditions at which the airplane was tested and the reference specifications.

For steady-state cruise flight, it is a reasonable approximation to assume lift equals weight and thrust equals drag. Since drag is a function of lift, fuel flow is a function of thrust, SAR is a function of fuel flow, and the FEM is a function of SAR, any deviation from the reference specifications that affect weight, drag, or fuel flow will affect SAR and the FÉM. Each of these corrections will result in either increasing or decreasing the test SAR and the resulting FEM.

As stated in Appendix A § A38.5.2.2, each correction method is subject to the approval by the FAA, including any time an applicant considers a particular correction to be unnecessary (with acceptable justification). Any correction that would result in an increase in SAR (i.e., a lower FEM value) may be considered optional by the applicant. The effect of not making such a correction would be to increase the FEM value.

Table A3-1 lists all the corrections and the conditions under which a given correction might be optional:

Table A3-1.

Corrections to reference specifications

Paragraph Conditions under of this Type of which correction Correction appendix correction may be optional Remarks

Latitude effect on g A3-1.2 Apparent Test latitude greater Gravitational acceleration is gravity than 45.5 degrees greatest at the poles and lowest at the equator. Testing at latitudes greater than 45.5 degrees will decrease SAR and increase the FEM as the airplane will be heavier.

Altitude effect on g A3-1.2 Apparent Test altitude lower Increasing the height above gravity than reference the Earth's surface reduces altitude the gravitational acceleration. Therefore, testing at an altitude lower than the reference altitude will decrease SAR and increase the FEM due to the effect of altitude on gravitational acceleration.

Centrifugal effect on g A3-1.2 Apparent Headwind (negative The reduction in velocity

12/13/2023

Paragraph

of this Correction appendix

Coriolis effect on g A3-1.2

Acceleration/decelerat A3-1.3 ion (energy)

Reynolds number A3-1.4

CG position A3-1.5

Aeroelastics A3-1.6

Fuel lower heating A3-1.7 value (LHV)

Type of correction

gravity

Apparent gravity

Drag

Drag

Drag

Drag

Fuel flow

Conditions under which correction may be optional

wind)

Test true track angles from 180 to 360 degrees

(dVg/dT) greater than 0 (positive acceleration in terms of ground speed)

Test outside air temperature higher than standard air temperature

Test CG position forward of the reference CG position

Test fuel LHV less than 43.217 MJ/kg

Remarks

(relative to the earth) provided by a headwind increases gravitational acceleration due to the centrifugal effect. This increases the airplane weight, which decreases SAR and increases the FEM.

Flying in a westerly direction, the opposite direction as the Earth's rotation, will increase gravitational acceleration due to the Coriolis effect. This increases the airplane weight which decreases SAR and increases the FEM.

An accelerated flight condition (excess energy) results in a higher drag force, decreasing SAR and increasing the FEM.

Higher temperatures result in higher drag forces due to Reynold number effects. At temperatures higher than the reference temperature, SAR will be decreased and the FEM will increase.

A test CG position forward of the reference CG position results in higher drag, decreasing SAR and increasing the FEM.

Wing aeroelastics may not be a concern depending on the size/weight/payload of the airplane and on wing stiffness.

Testing with fuel that has an LHV lower than the reference value requires more fuel to

12/13/2023

Conditions under

Paragraph

Correction

Altitude effect on fuel flow

Temperature effect on fuel flow

Engine deterioration level

Electrical and mechanical power extraction and bleed flow

Modifications and non-standard equipment that will not be included on the production airplane

of this appendix

A3-1.8

A3-1.9

A3-1.10

A3-1.11

A3-1.12

Type of correction

Fuel flow

Fuel flow

Fuel flow

Fuel flow

Drag and/or fuel flow

which correction may be optional

May always be considered optional

Test outside air temperature higher than standard day temperature

Test electrical and mechanical power extraction and bleed flow higher than the reference electrical and mechanical power extraction and bleed flow

Any modification or non-standard equipment that reduces SAR

Remarks

be burned to achieve the same engine thrust level, hence decreasing SAR and increasing the FEM.

Testing at any altitude other than the optimum altitude will result in decreasing SAR and increasing the FEM due to higher fuel burn at offoptimum altitude.

Testing at a temperature higher than the reference temperature will result in decreasing SAR and increasing the FEM due to higher fuel burn at higher temperatures.

In general, this correction should not be made. See paragraph A3-1.10 of this AC.

Testing with higher than reference power extraction and bleed flow will require more fuel to be burned, hence decreasing SAR and increasing the FEM.

Not accounting for modifications or non-standard equipment that decreases SAR and increases the FEM.

The selection of a reference airspeed is used to determine the target airspeed for acquiring SAR test data for determination of the FEM. For applicants using either SAR data clustered around each of the three reference masses (see § A38.5.3.3) or SAR data obtained over a range of masses (see § A38.5.3.4), no correction is made for any differences between the target reference airspeed and the test airspeed. Since the reference airspeed is generally expected to be the optimum airspeed (see § A38.2), any difference

between the test airspeed and the reference airspeed will decrease SAR and increase the FEM. For applicants using a first principle model to show compliance (see paragraph 6.4.4 of this AC), the reference airspeed is used to identify the portion of the performance model to be validated. The reference airspeed is also used as the airspeed (or Mach number) at which the SAR value for each reference mass is to be computed from the performance model.

The overall process for determining SAR at the reference specifications for each test data point consists of the following steps:

Step 1) Determine the airplane weight from the airplane mass for both the test condition and the reference specifications for gravitational acceleration, as described in paragraph A3-1.1 below. Determine the drag correction due to the difference in lift between the test weight and the weight at the reference specifications for gravitational acceleration using the airplane's drag model and the relationship that lift equals weight for non-accelerated, level flight, as described in paragraph A3-1.2.1.

Note.— As described in paragraph A3-1.2.2, this step is not necessary when using method 2 for the gravitational acceleration correction.

Step 2) Determine all other applicable drag corrections as described in paragraphs A3-1.3, A3-1.4, A3- 1.5, and A3-1.6, and sum them together with the drag correction from paragraph A3-1.2.1.

Step 3) Determine the airplane drag for the test condition. An approximation can be made that for these unaccelerated, level flight test conditions, the airplane drag for the test condition is equal to the engine thrust for the test condition. The engine thrust should be determined from:

a calibrated engine or an engine performance model; and the average value of the parameters needed to determine thrust from the engine performance model measured during the test condition.

Step 4) Add the sum of drag corrections from Step 2 to the airplane drag for the test condition from Step 3 to obtain the airplane drag corrected to the reference specifications.

Step 5) Determine the change in engine fuel flow for the corrections that were made for drag. The change in engine fuel flow due to the drag corrections can be determined as follows:

∆Fuel FloWDrag = Fuel FloWRef Drag – Fuel FloWTest Drag

where:

Fuel FlowRef Drag is the fuel flow from an engine performance model at the airplane drag corrected for the reference specifications (assuming thrust equals drag) at the average speed, altitude and temperature for the test condition; and

Fuel FlowTest Drag is the fuel flow from an engine performance model at the airplane drag for the test condition (assuming thrust equals drag) at the average speed, altitude and temperature for the test condition.

Step 6) Correct the measured test engine fuel flow to reference specifications as follows:

Fuel Flowref = Fuel FloWtest + ∆Fuel FlowDrag + ∆Fuel FlowLHv + ∆Fuel FloWalt + ∆Fuel FloWtemp + ∆Fuel FlowCorr bleed

where:

Fuel Flowtest is the average engine fuel flow measured during the test condition, corrected to the reference engine deterioration level (if applicable) in kg/h;

∆Fuel FlowDrag is the fuel flow correction for drag from Step 5 in kg/h;

∆Fuel FlowLHv is the fuel flow correction for fuel lower heating value calculated from paragraph A3-1.7 in kg/h;

∆Fuel Flowalt is the fuel flow correction for altitude calculated from paragraph A3-1.8 in kg/h;

∆Fuel Flowtemp is the fuel flow correction for temperature calculated from paragraph A3-1.9 in kg/h; and

∆Fuel Flowcorr bleed is the fuel flow correction for electrical and mechanical power extraction and bleed flow calculated from paragraph A3-1.10 in kg/h.

Step 7) The SAR value corrected to reference specifications is given by the following relationship:

TAS SARref = Fuel Flowref

where:

SARref is the SAR for the reference specifications in km/kg;

TAS is the average airplane true airspeed for the test specifications in km/h; and

Fuel Flowref is the engine fuel flow for the reference specifications from Step 6 in kg/h.

A3-1.1 Test Weight. Since the weight of the airplane during each test condition cannot be directly measured, it is determined using the following process, in accordance with §§ A38.4.2.1.2 and A38.4.2.3:

Begin with weighing the airplane on the ground, where the local gravitational acceleration can be readily determined using the process described in paragraph A3-1.2.1. The pre-flight airplane mass is determined from the following relationship:

MasSweighing Weightweighing gweighing

where:

Weightweighing is the airplane weight from the scale weighing in N; and

gweighing is the gravitational acceleration at rest at the weighing site latitude and elevation in meters/second2. See paragraph A-3.1.2.1 for determining gweighing using the weighing site latitude and elevation for the test latitude, φ, and test geometric altitude, h, respectively.

Any change in mass after the weighing, and prior to the test flight, should be accounted for to establish the mass of the airplane at the start of the test flight. The mass for each test condition can be determined by subtracting the integrated fuel flow (mass of fuel burned) from the mass of the airplane at the start of the test flight. The test weight, in N, for each test condition is determined from the following equation:

Weightest = (Masstest)(9test)

where:

Masstest is the average mass of the airplane during the test condition in kg; and

gtest is the gravitational acceleration at the test latitude, test geometric altitude, test true track, and test ground speed in m/s2. See paragraph A-3.1.2.1 for determining gtest.

A3-1.2 Apparent gravity. Acceleration, caused by the local effects of gravity and inertia, affects the test weight of the airplane. The apparent gravity at the test conditions varies with latitude, altitude, ground speed, and direction of motion, relative to the Earth's axis. The reference gravitational acceleration is the gravitational acceleration, based on go, for the airplane travelling in the direction of true north in still air at the reference altitude, a geodetic latitude of 45.5 degrees.

If the test conditions differ from the conditions for the reference gravitational acceleration, the airplane weight at the reference gravitational acceleration will be different than the airplane weight at the test conditions. This will result in a SAR and FEM that are not representative of the SAR and FEM at the reference gravitational acceleration. If the test conditions are at a gravitational acceleration that is less than the reference gravitational acceleration, then a correction will be necessary, as described below.

There are two methods provided below for determining the acceleration correction. Method 1 is a general method for determining the effect of gravitational acceleration on the airplane test weight, which is then used along with the airplane's drag model to determine the effect on airplane drag. This drag correction for gravitational acceleration is then combined with the other drag corrections to determine the effect on airplane fuel flow and the value of SAR.

Method 2 is a simplified approach that does not require use of an airplane drag model. This method is acceptable for FEM certification when SAR is determined by direct flight test measurement of SAR test points in accordance with § A38.1.2.1. Method 2 is based on the same equations for determining g as Method 1, and provides the same results for SAR data at (or near) optimum flight conditions. For SAR data that is not at (or near) reference specifications, Method 2 may result in small errors in the SAR correction for gravitational acceleration correction, but the overall SAR and FEM values will be conservative because these errors will be much smaller than the SAR decrease (thus FEM increase) resulting from testing outside optimum flight conditions.

A3-1.2.1 Method 1 for the gravitational acceleration correction

The overall process for determining the drag correction due to the effect of gravitational acceleration on airplane weight consists of the following steps:

Step 1) Determine the airplane test weight, as described in paragraph A3-1.1.

Step 2) Determine the airplane weight for the reference gravitational acceleration conditions from the airplane test mass and the reference gravitational acceleration:

Weightref g = (Masstest)(gref) where:

Weightref g is the airplane weight at the reference gravitational acceleration conditions in N;

MasStest is the average mass of the airplane during the test condition in kg;

gref is the gravitational acceleration for the airplane travelling in the direction of true north in still air at the reference altitude and a geodetic latitude of 45.5 degrees, and based on go, in m/s2; and

go is the standard acceleration due to gravity at sea level and a geodetic latitude of 45.5 degrees, 9.80665 m/s2.

Step 3) Determine the drag correction for the difference between Weightest and Weightref g, as described later in this paragraph.

The value of gravitational acceleration, g, consists of the following components:

a) Distance from the center of Earth's mass. This is a function of the geometric altitude and the latitude of the airplane relative to a mathematical representation of the shape of the Earth.

b) Centrifugal effect. An airplane in flight will experience a force acting outwards in the radial direction that is proportional to the square of the ground speed of the airplane and inversely proportional to the distance of the airplane from the center of mass of the Earth.

c) Coriolis effect. An airplane in flight will experience a force that is proportional to its ground speed, the rotation rate of the Earth, the direction of travel, and the latitude of operation. For example, an airplane flying east, in the same direction that the Earth rotates, will experience a lower gravitational acceleration, while an airplane flying west will experience a higher gravitational acceleration. The effect will be greatest at the equator.

The following equations are based on the World Geodetic System 84 Ellipsoidal Gravity definition. Other formulations and simplifications may provide essentially equivalent results.

The gravitational acceleration experienced for each test data point (gtest) is determined as follows:

gtest = gφ,alt + gcent + gCoriolis

where:

gφ,alt is the component of the gravitational acceleration at zero ground speed, at the test altitude and latitude in m/s2;

gcent is the component of the gravitational acceleration due to centrifugal effect in m/s2; and

gcoriolis is the component of the gravitational acceleration due to Coriolis effect in m/s2.

The gravitational acceleration for the test geometric altitude and latitude component at zero ground speed, gφ,alt, is determined as follows:

First, determine the component of gravitational acceleration at the test latitude at sea level and zero ground speed from the following equation:

1 + 0.00193185138639 sin2φ gφ = 9.7803267714 √1 - 0.00669437999013 sin2φ

where φ is the test latitude in degrees.

The component of gravitational acceleration at zero ground speed for the test geometric altitude and latitude is then determined from the following equation:

re 2 gφ,alt = gφ (re + h)

where:

gφ is the component of gravitational acceleration at the test latitude at sea level and zero ground speed;

h is the test geometric altitude in m; and

re is the radius of the Earth at the test latitude, which is determined from the following equation:

(a2cos φ)2 + (b2sin φ)2 re (a cos φ)2 + (b sin φ)2

where:

a is the Earth's radius at the equator = 6,378,137 m;

b is the Earth's radius at the pole = 6,356,752 m; and

φ is the test latitude in degrees.

As an alternative to using the equation for gφ,alt provided above, gφ,alt can be approximated by linear interpolation using Table A3-2:

Table A3-2.

gφ,alt

gφ,alt (m/s2) Geometric Height (ft) 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 40,000 45,000 50,000 0 9.78033 9.77565 9.77099 9.76632 9.76166 9.75700 9.75234 9.74769 9.74304 9.73840 9.73376 10 9.78188 9.77721 9.77254 9.76787 9.76321 9.75855 9.75389 9.74924 9.74459 9.73994 9.73530 20 9.78637 9.78169 9.77702 9.77235 9.76768 9.76302 9.75836 9.75370 9.74905 9.74440 9.73975 30 9.79325 9.78857 9.76302 9.77921 9.77454 9.76987 9.76521 9.76054 9.75588 9.75123 9.74658 40 9.80170 9.79701 9.79232 9.78764 9.78296 9.77829 9.77362 9.76895 9.76428 9.75962 9.75496 45.5 9.80665 9.80196 9.79727 9.79258 9.78790 9.78322 9.77855 9.77387 9.76920 9.76454 9.75988 50 9.81070 9.80601 9.80132 9.79663 9.79194 9.78726 9.78258 9.77790 9.77323 9.76856 9.76390 60 9.81918 9.81448 9.80978 9.80508 9.80039 9.79570 9.79101 9.78633 9.78165 9.77698 9.77230 70 9.82610 9.82139 9.81668 9.81198 9.80728 9.80259 9.79790 9.79321 9.78853 9.78385 9.77917 80 9.83062 9.82590 9.82120 9.81649 9.81179 9.80709 9.80240 9.79771 9.79302 9.78833 9.78365 90 9.83219 9.82747 9.82276 9.81806 9.81336 9.80866 9.80396 9.79927 9.79458 9.78989 9.78521

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 168 passages shown