Radar Vectors
Advisory Circular Cancelled Issued Jun 27, 2003 AEE-300 134 pages Copy saved Nov 18, 2026

AC 34-1B Fuel Venting and Exhaust Emission Requirements for Turbine Engine Powered Airplanes

The Intent of this AC is to promote uniformity of implementation of the emissions certification requirement of Part 34 of the Federal aviation Regulations.

This document is cancelled. Cancelled by 34-1C. Check the official source before relying on it.

Official source ↗ Open PDF

Advisory.

Advisory

U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Circular Administration

Subject: FUEL VENTING AND EXHAUST EMISSION REQUIREMENTS

Date: Initiated by:

06/27/03 AEE-300

AC No: Change:

34–1B

FOR TURBINE ENGINE POWERED AIRPLANES

1. PURPOSE The intent of this advisory Circular (AC) is to promote uniformity of implementation of the emissions certification requirements of Part 34 of the Federal Aviation Regulations. FAR 34 is unusually complex in that it must reflect the requirements of the Clean Air Act, Sections 232 and 233, the EPA, 40 CFR Part 87 and ICAO Annex 16, Volume II, Second Edition, July 1993, as well the FAA’s mandated charter. This advisory circular brings these seemingly disparate requirements together to provide a single source of information and advice to individuals and agencies interested in FAR 34.

a. Contents

This revised Advisory Circular (AC) contains updated information, including anticipated adoption of ICAO CAPE 4 post December 31, 2003 rules, describing the standards and requirements for aircraft fuel venting and engine emission certification and presents explanatory and supplementary information, as necessary, to identify acceptable means of compliance. The information contained in this document sets forth acceptable means, but not the sole means, by which compliance may be shown with the requirements of Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR) Part 34 of the United States Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Title 14. The regulation that this AC references is 14 CFR Part 34 and its Amendments (hereinafter referred to as “Part 34”).

Pursuant to the Clean Air Act (CAA), Sections 231 and 232, Part 34 necessarily must conform to Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Title 40, Part 87, “Control of Air Pollution From Aircraft and Aircraft Engines; Emission Standards and Test Procedures”. Therefore any change in procedures, of a substantive nature, must be discussed with, and approved by, the Administrator of the EPA. This is mentioned explicitly in Part 34 and in this AC for those areas of particular concern. In addition, users of this AC, as well as Part 34, must be aware of any changes to 40 CFR Part 87 which have not yet been included in either Part 34 or this AC. In such instances the requirements described in these documents must defer to 40 CFR Part 87, unless and until approval is obtained from the Administrator of the EPA.

b. Advisory Nature

Like other Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) advisory circulars, the language within this document is intended to be permissive and advisory in nature, except for explanations of regulatory language that are mandatory. In addition, the compliance methods chosen by the applicant are voluntary within the framework of the regulation as written. Mandatory terms used in this AC, such as “must” and “shall”, are used only in the sense of ensuring the applicability of these particular methods of compliance when the acceptable means of compliance described herein are used. This AC does not change regulatory requirements and does not authorize changes in, or deviations from, regulatory requirements.

c. Document Format

This AC contains a section-by-section review and explanation of 14 CFR Part 34. In order to assist the user, each explanation is provided as a separate, sequentially numbered, paragraph. In general, each paragraph is presented as follows in Figure 1:

Paragraph Number: 1. Citation Number: Number in 14 CFR Part 34 that Easy to reference is being addressed number for each section of Advisory Circular AC 34-1B that is addressed

Actual regulatory text (italicized and indented) reproduced for better readability) 19 § 34.61 Turbine Fuel Specification

For exhaust emissions testing, fuel meeting the specifications listed below shall be used…

a. Explanation

The fuel specification in Part 34 matches the amended ICAO fuel specification in Annex 16, Vol. II, Second Edition, 1993. This specification is typical of Jet A

b. Supplemental Information

Aircraft gas turbine engines can and do use a variety of fuels. The specific fuel type and composition can and often does have a significant effect on engine emissions. …

2. DEFINITIONS

Where the following expressions are used in this appendix, they have the meanings ascribed to them below:

(1) Accuracy. The closeness with which a measurement approaches the true value established independently.

Brief “Plain English” explanation of regulatory text (appears only if text is not self explanatory)

Potentially useful supplementary information (included only if necessary)

Text reproduced from ICAO Annex 16, Volume II, Second Edition, 1993.

FIGURE 1: Document Format

In addition to the section-by-section explanations, this AC includes 3 additional chapters that explain specific appendices from ICAO, Annex 16, Volume II. Second Edition, July 1993. These have been included to make this AC relatively self contained, since these appendices are explicitly referenced within Part 34. Specifically:

• FAR 34 Subpart G refers to ICAO Appendices 3, 5 and 6. • FAR 34 Subpart H refers to ICAO Appendices 2 and 6.

These ICAO appendices, 3,5 and 6, deal with detailed technical issues regarding instrumentation and measurement techniques and statistically derived compliance procedures. As such they are relatively complex and have been kept distinct from the rest of the AC as separate chapters. Typically, only those readers who are interested in specific equations and/or details regarding measurement techniques and compliance procedures will need to read these sections.

d. Audience

The intended audience for this AC includes engine specialists from the FAA (aircraft certification and flight standards), aircraft and aircraft engine industry, aircraft certification applicants, foreign governments, airline customers, airport operators, the scientific community, and other interested persons.

e. AC Intent

The intent of this AC is to establish a clear understanding between the regulatory authorities, aircraft engine users, local governments, and the aircraft engine industry of the engine emissions certification processes and to present historical policies, guidance material and interpretations that have been used in the aircraft engine certification process.

f. Document Use

Sequential paragraphs are indicated in this AC to improve usage. The regulatory section numbers, together with the regulatory language are indented and italicized. In addition, text from ICAO Annex 16 is included (shaded and italicized) where appropriate.

g. Technical Advancement:

Since the introduction of engine emission standards in 1973 (38 FR 19088, July 17, 1973), acceptable means and procedures for measurement, testing, data reduction, evaluation and compliance reporting have advanced considerably. For the purpose of certification and compliance, applicants have, over time, developed, evaluated and had approved engine specific alternate but equivalent testing, measurement and data reduction procedures. Approval, in these instances, is obtained through the FAA, Office of Environment and Energy (AEE) located in the FAA Headquarters in Washington DC.

h. FAA Certification Process:

The FAA administrative certification process is shown in Figure 2. Each step in the appropriate process must be completed before proceeding to the next step. Specific details of this process can be found in a memorandum “Inter-Office Management Plan for Aircraft Engine Fuel Venting and Exhaust Emissions”, appended to this Advisory Circular as Exhibit 1. As a part of its compliance responsibilities, FAA can either conduct the emission tests or delegate that responsibility to the engine manufacturer, which is then monitored by the FAA. Since the FAA does not have the resources or the funding to test engines themselves, FAA selects engineers at each plant to serves as representatives (called Designated Engineering Representatives or DERs) for the FAA while the manufacturer performs the test procedures. DER’s responsibilities include evaluating the test plan, the test engine, the test equipment, and the final testing report sent to the FAA.

i. Exclusions

There are no sections excluded from this AC.

2. CANCELLATION

Advisory Circular 34–1A, Fuel Venting and Exhaust Emission Requirements for Turbine Engine Powered Airplanes, dated June 30, 2001, is canceled.

FAA Certification Process (Administrative)

New Model Certification Major Change Substantiation

Preliminary Type

Board with FAA

Overall Test Plan/

Analysis Outline to FAA

Detailed Test Plans

to FAA

Test Plan Approved

by FAA

FAA Final Type

Board Meeting

Analysis

to FAA AND/OR

Analysis Approved

by FAA

Test Plan Analysis OR Submitted to FAA Submitted to FAA

Test Plan Analysis Approved by FAA Approved by FAA

Major Change Approved by FAA

Results Submitted

to FAA

Test

Conformity

Inspection Conformity

Inspection

Test

Post Test Inspection

Test Report

Approved

DER Responsible to local region

FIGURE 2. FAA Certification Process

3. TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. PURPOSE … 1

a. Contents … 1

b. Advisory Nature … 1

c. Document Format … 1

d. Audience … 3

e. AC Intent … 3

f. Document Use … 3

g. Technical Advancement: … 3

h. FAA Certification Process: … 3

FAA Certification Process - Figure 2 … 4

i. Exclusions … 3

2. CANCELLATION … 3

3. TABLE OF CONTENTS … 5

4. REFERENCES … 7

I. 14 CFR PART 34 Subpart A—General Provisions … 7

5. §34.1 DEFINITIONS … 7

6. §34.2 Abbrevations … 10

7. § 34.3 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS … 12

8. §34.4 [RESERVED] … 17

9. §34.5 SPECIAL TEST PROCEDURES … 17

10. §34.6 AIRCRAFT SAFETY … 18

11. §34.7 EXEMPTIONS … 18

II. Subpart B — Engine Fuel Venting Emissions - (New and In-Use Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines) … 21

12. §34.10 APPLICABILITY … 21

13. §34.11 STANDARD FOR FUEL VENTING EMISSIONS … 21

III. Subpart C — Exhaust Emissions (New Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines) … 23

14. § 34.20 APPLICABILITY … 23

15. § 34.21 STANDARDS FOR EXHAUST EMISSIONS … 23

IV. Subpart D — Exhaust Emissions (In-Use Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines)Error! Bookmark not defined.

16. § 34.30 APPLICABILITY … 27

17. § 34.31 STANDARDS FOR EXHAUST EMISSIONS … 27

V. Subpart E — [Reserved] … 28

VI. Subpart F — [Reserved] … 29

VII. Subpart G — Test Procedures for Engine Exhaust Gaseous Emissions (Aircraft and Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines) … 30

18. §34.60 INTRODUCTION … 30

19. §34.61 TURBINE FUEL SPECIFICATION … 30

20. §34.62 TEST PROCEDURE (PROPULSION ENGINES) … 32

21. §34.63 [RESERVED] … 33

22. §34.64 SAMPLING AND ANALYTICAL PROCEDURES FOR MEASURING GASEOUS EXHAUST EMISSIONS … 33

23. §34.65—§34.70 [RESERVED] … 33

24. § 34.71 COMPLIANCE WITH GASEOUS EMISSION STANDARDS … 33

VIII. Subpart H — Test Procedures for Engine Smoke Emissions (Aircraft and Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines) … 33

25. §34.80 INTRODUCTION … 34

26. §34.81 FUEL SPECIFICATIONS … 35

27. §34.82 SAMPLING AND ANALYTICAL PROCEDURES FOR MEASURING - SMOKE EXHAUST EMISSIONS … 36

28. §34.83 – §34.88 [RESERVED] … 36

29. §34.89 COMPLIANCE WITH SMOKE EMISSION STANDARDS … 36

IX. ICAO ANNEX 16, VOLUME II, Second Edition, July, 1993, APPENDIX 6 … 38

X. ICAO ANNEX 16, VOLUME II, Second Edition, July, 1993, APPENDIX 3 … 42

XI. ICAO ANNEX 16, VOLUME II, Second Edition, July, 1993, APPENDIX 5 … 81

XII. ICAO ANNEX 16, VOLUME II, Second Edition, July, 1993, APPENDIX 2 … 121

30 EXHIBIT 1 Inter-Office Management Plan … 131

5. .

4. REFERENCES

(1) Clean Air Act as amended, 42 U.S.C. 7571 and 7601. (2) 14 CFR ch. 1 (1-1-97 edition), Federal Aviation Administration, Department of Transportation, Subchapter

A, Definitions. (3) 40 CFR Part 87, Environmental Protection Agency, Control of Air Pollution from Aircraft and Aircraft

Engines; Emission Standards and Test Procedures; Final and Proposed Rule, Federal Register, Vol. 62, No. 89, Thursday, May 8, 1997. (4) Federal Aviation Regulations, Part 34, Fuel Venting and Exhaust Emission Requirements for Turbine

Engine Powered Airplanes, February 3, 1999. (5) International Civil Aviation Organization, International Standards and Recommended Practices,

Environmental Protection, Annex 16, Volume II, Aircraft Engine Emissions, Second Edition — July 1993. (6) SAE International, SAE AEROSPACE RECOMMENDED PRACTICE ARP 1256, Procedure for the

Continuous Sampling and Measurement of Gaseous Emissions from Aircraft Turbine Engines. (7) SAE International, SAE AEROSPACE RECOMMENDED PRACTICE ARP 1179, Aircraft Gas Turbine

Engine Exhaust Smoke Measurement. (8) SAE International, SAE AEROSPACE RECOMMENDED PRACTICE ARP 1533, Procedure for the

Calculation of Gaseous Emissions from Aircraft Turbine Engines.

I. 14 CFR 34 Subpart A General Provisions

5. 34.1 Definitions

As used in this AC, all terms not defined herein shall have the meaning given them in the Clean Air Act, as amended (42 U.S.C. 7401 et. seq.):

Supplemental Information:

Section 232 of the Clean Air Act, as amended, directs the Secretary of Transportation to issue regulations to ensure compliance with 40 CFR part 87. 40 CFR part 87 calls out, by reference, specific sections of ICAO Annex 16, Volume II, Second edition, 1993. ICAO Annex 16 includes definitions which should be added to the definitions in Part 34 to provide understanding and completeness. Following is a combined list of definitions required when fulfilling the requirements of Part 34. The ICAO definitions are italicized and shaded. Some discussion is provided where further clarification is needed.

Act means the Clean Air Act, as amended (42 U.S.C. 7401 et. seq.).

Administrator means the Administrator of the Federal Aviation Administration or any person to whom he has delegated his authority in the matter concerned.

Administrator of the EPA means the Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency and any other officer or employee of the Environmental Protection Agency to whom the authority involved may be delegated.

Aircraft as used in this part means any airplane as defined in 14 CFR part 1 for which a U.S. standard airworthiness certificate or equivalent foreign airworthiness certificate is issued.

Aircraft engine means a propulsion engine which is installed in, or which is manufactured for installation in, an aircraft.

Supplemental Information: This definition applies to those engines for which a U.S. standard airworthiness certificate or equivalent foreign airworthiness certificate is issued.

Aircraft gas turbine engine means a turboprop, turbofan, or turbojet aircraft engine.

Explanation:

As with the overall intent of this regulation piston engines are excluded.

Afterburning. A mode of engine operation wherein a combustion system fed (in whole or part) by vitiated air is used.

Approach Phase. The operating phase defined by the time during which the engine is operated in the approach operating mode.

Class TP means all aircraft turboprop engines.

Class TF means all turbofan or turbojet aircraft engines or aircraft engines designed for applications that otherwise would have been fulfilled by turbojet and turbofan engines except engines of class T3, T8, and TSS.

Explanation:

Applications, which could fulfill these requirements, are propfans, unducted fans, and advanced unducted fans.

Class T3 means all aircraft gas turbine engines of the JT3D model family.

Class T8 means all aircraft gas turbine engines of the JT8D model family.

Class TSS means all aircraft gas turbine engines employed for propulsion of aircraft designed to operate at supersonic flight speeds.

Climb phase: The operating phase defined by the time during which the engine is operated in the climb operating mode.

Commercial aircraft engine means any aircraft engine used or intended for use by an "air carrier" (including those engaged in "intrastate air transportation") or a "commercial operator" (including those engaged in "intrastate air transportation") as these terms are defined in the Federal Aviation Act and the Federal Aviation Regulations.

Commercial aircraft gas turbine engine means a turboprop, turbofan, or turbojet commercial aircraft engine.

Date of manufacture of an engine is the date the inspection acceptance records reflect that the engine is complete and meets the FAA approved type design.

Emission measurement system means all of the equipment necessary to transport the emission sample and measure the level of emissions. This includes the sample system and the instrumentation system.

Explanation:

The intention is to delineate all of the equipment and devices to extract, transport, condition, differentiate and measure the concentrations of “exhaust emissions” – see 4.a. (17). If inlet species are measured, for monitoring or corrections, as part of the certification process the equipment and devices used should be included as part of the “Emissions measurement system”.

Engine model means all commercial aircraft turbine engines, which are of the same general series, displacement, and design characteristics and are approved under the same type certificate.

Supplemental Information:

For the purposes of a working definition, with respect to emissions certification, when considering the similarity or equivalence of engines, similar or equivalent engine models should be taken as those engines approved under the same type certificate. For example, from 14 CFR ch. 1 (1-1-97 edition), Federal Aviation Administration Department of Transportation, Subchapter A, Definitions: “Type”: (3) As used with respect to the certification of aircraft engines means those engines which are similar in design. For example, JT8D and JT8D-7 are engines of the same type, and JT9D-3A and JT9D-7 are engines of the same type.

Exhaust emissions means substances emitted into the atmosphere from the exhaust discharge nozzle of an aircraft or aircraft engine.

Fuel venting emissions means raw fuel, exclusive of hydrocarbons in the exhaust emissions, discharged from aircraft gas turbine engines during all normal ground and flight operations.

In-use aircraft gas turbine engine means an aircraft gas turbine engine, which is in service.

New aircraft turbine engine means an aircraft gas turbine engine, which has never been in service.

Explanation:

This definition should be viewed with respect to “In-use aircraft gas turbine engine” and relative to the intent of 40 CFR Part 87, Subpart B, Engine Fuel Venting emissions (New and In-Use Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines), Subpart C, Exhaust Emissions (New Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines), and Subpart D, Exhaust Emissions (In- Use Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines).

Any engine intended for revenue service but which has never been in service is by definition new and must meet the provisions of Subpart B and C for fuel venting, gaseous and smoke emissions. This sets the baseline for regulation and control of emissions from aircraft gas turbine engines. Alternatively the definition for in-use aircraft gas turbine engines is intended, for those engines in service, to prevent deterioration of fuel venting and/or smoke emissions beyond the maximum allowable for new engines. In other words, the first time a particular engine sees revenue service it is “new” and ever after it is “in-use”. The fact that a given engine model is in revenue service does not relieve a newly manufactured engine of this model of being considered as “new”. Although this interpretation could impose severe penalties on the engine manufacturer in the demonstration of compliance, the allowance, and universal use, of ICAO Annex 16, Volume II, Appendix 6, Compliance Procedure for Gaseous Emissions and Smoke solves the problem by specifying a limited engine preproduction compliance procedure which relieves the manufacturer from having to test every engine and, in effect, follows the engine in time, i.e., there is no requirement for the testing of engines in-use.

Oxides of Nitrogen. The sum of the amounts of the nitric oxide and nitrogen dioxide contained in a gas sample calculated as if the nitric oxide were in the form of nitrogen dioxide.

Power Setting: means the power or thrust output of an engine in terms of kilonewtons thrust for turbojet and turbofan engines or shaft power in terms of kilowatts for turboprop engines.

Rated Output (rO): means the maximum power/thrust available for takeoff at standard day conditions as approved for the engine by the Federal Aviation Administration, including reheat contribution where applicable, but excluding any contribution due to water injection and excluding any emergency power/thrust rating.

Explanation:

For the purpose of this regulation “maximum power/thrust available for takeoff” is taken to mean under normal operating conditions. The definition as stated has caused some confusion because of a maximum thrust emergency rating even though the definition, as it appears in 14 CFR Part 34, excludes any emergency power/thrust rating. Some of the confusion may be due to the parent definition in 40 CFR 87, which does not explicitly exclude the emergency power/thrust rating. The intent is clear however from 40 CFR Part 87, Subpart G, 87.60 (c): “… determine mass emissions through calculations during a simulated aircraft landingtakeoff cycle (LTO). The LTO cycle is based on time in mode data during high activity periods at major airports.” The use of emergency power/thrust during takeoff would be an extraordinary and abnormal situation. Further, 40 CFR Part 87 (87.64) requires the use of ICAO Annex 16, Volume II, 1993, Appendix 3. Appendix 3 defines Rated Output, rO, as “ F00,” which is further defined as: “The maximum thrust available for take-off under normal operating conditions at ISA sea level static conditions, without the use of water injection, as approved by the applicable certificating authority”.

Rated pressure ratio (rPR): means the ratio between the combustor inlet pressure and the engine inlet pressure achieved by an engine operation at rated output.

REFERENCE DAY CONDITIONS: MEANS THE REFERENCE AMBIENT CONDITIONS TO WHICH THE GASEOUS EMISSIONS (HC AND SMOKE) ARE TO BE CORRECTED. THE REFERENCE DAY CONDITIONS ARE AS FOLLOWS: TEMPERATURE = 15

O C, SPECIFIC HUMIDITY = 0.00629 KG H20/KG OF DRY AIR, AND PRESSURE = 101325 PA.

Reference pressure ratio. The ratio of the mean total pressure at the last compressor discharge plane of the compressor to the mean total pressure at the compressor entry plane when the engine is developing take-off thrust rating in ISA sea level static conditions.

Sample System: means the system, which provides for the transportation of the gaseous emissions sample from the sample probe to the inlet of the instrumentation system.

Supplemental information:

A ‘Sample System’ is required for smoke emissions as well as for gaseous emission. Detailed specifications, for each, are described in ICAO Appendices 2 and 3. There are differences in requirements between the two systems but it is not unusual to satisfy the separate requirements with an appropriately designed single sample system.

Shaft Power: means only the measured shaft power out put of a turboprop engine.

Smoke: means the matter in exhaust emissions, which obscures the transmission of light.

Smoke Number (SN): means the dimensionless term quantifying smoke emissions.

Standard day conditions: means standard ambient conditions as described in the United States Standard Atmosphere 1976, (i.e., temperature = 15 o C, specific humidity = 0.00 kg H20/kg dry air, and pressure = 101325 Pa.)

Take-off phase. The operating phase defined by the time during which the engine is operated at the rated output.

Taxi/idle (in): means those aircraft operations involving taxi and idle between the time of landing roll-out and final shutdown of all propulsion engines.

Taxi/idle (out): means those aircraft operations involving taxi and idle between the time of initial starting of the propulsion engine(s) used for the taxi and the turn onto the duty runway.

j. Unburned hydrocarbons. The total of hydrocarbon compounds of all classes and molecular weghts contained

in a gas sample, calculated as if the were in the form of methane.

6. §34.2 Abbreviations

The abbreviations used in this part have the following meanings in both upper and lower case CO Carbon Monoxide EPA United States Environmental Protection Agency FAA Federal Aviation Administration, United States Department of Transportation HC Hydrocarbons HP Horsepower hr Hour(s) H2O water kg Kilogram(s) kJ Kilojoule(s) LTO Landing and takeoff min Minute(s)

NO(X) Oxides of Nitrogen Pa Pascal(s) rO Rated Output rPR Rated pressure ratio sec Second(s) SP Shaft power SN Smoke number T Temperature, degrees Kelvin TIM Time in mode W Watt(s) Deg. C Degrees Celsius % Percent

Supplemental information:

In addition to the abbreviations listed in §34.2 there are a large number of abbreviations from other sources that are used in AC 34. Those abbreviations listed in ICAO Annex 16 as Symbols are italicized and shaded. Only those Symbols from ICAO that are not duplicated in Part 34 are listed.

AC FAA Advisory Circular ACO Local FAA Aircraft Certification Office AEE FAA Office of Environment and Energy AFM Airplane Flight Manual APP Approach APU Auxiliary Power Unit ARP Aerospace Recommended Practice CAA Clean Air Act CFR Code of Federal Regulations CI Confidence Interval (90%) CO2 Carbon Dioxide Dp The mass of any gaseous pollutant emitted during the reference emissions landing and take-off cycle DER Designated Engineering Representative EPA United States Environmental Protection Agency. EI Emission Index EPR Engine Pressure Ratio (Power Setting Parameter) Fn Thrust in International Standard Atmosphere (ISA), sea level conditions, for the given operating mode F00 Rated output F*

00 Rated output with afterburning applied FAR Federal Aviation Regulation (CFR Title 14) FCAA Foreign Civil Aviation Authority FID Flame Ionization Detector FPR Fan Pressure Ratio ICAO International Civil Aviation Organization JAA Joint Airworthiness Authorities (of Europe) JAR Joint Airworthiness Requirements (of Europe) Log logarithmic value to base 10 M meter MJ Mega Joules MSL Mean Sea Level altitude, feet N/A Not Applicable NIST National Institute of Standards and Technology NO Nitric oxide NO2 Nitrogen dioxide ppmC Parts per million carbon ref. Reference RH Relative Humidity, %

rms root-mean-square rpm Revolutions Per Minute SAE SAE International (formerly Society of Automotive Engineers) Sec Second(s) TC Type Certificate TIM Time in mode TO Takeoff VNTSC Volpe National Transportation System Center (D.O.T.) W Watt(s) ºC Degrees Celsius. % Percent π00 Reference pressure ratio

7. 34.3 General requirements:

§ 34.3(a)

(a) This part provides for the approval or acceptance by the Administrator or the Administrator of the EPA

of testing and sampling methods, analytical techniques, and related equipment not identical to those specified in this part. Before either approves or accepts any such alternate, equivalent, or otherwise nonidentical procedures or equipment, the Administrator or the Administrator of the EPA shall consult with the other in determining whether or not the action requires rulemaking under sections 231 and 232 of the Clean Air Act, as amended, consistent with the responsibilities of the Administrator of the EPA and the Secretary of Transportation under sections 231 and 232 of the Clean Air Act.

Explanation

This part provides for the flexibility needed to accommodate changing engine designs and possible changes and/or improvements in testing, sampling methods, analytical techniques and related equipment. This part does not provide guidelines or any systematic means of demonstrating equivalence of non-identical procedures or equipment. 40 CFR part 87, calls out, by reference, those sampling and analytical procedures specified by ICAO. ICAO does not specify particular equipment but does detail accuracy, operational and performance requirements wherever possible. For example, ICAO states the method of detection for each of the pollutants along with details of calibration and operation but does not list specific pieces of equipment. Presumably each emissions certification test would require demonstration that each analytical technique and piece of equipment met the ICAO requirements. Similarly, it is the intent of 34.3(a) that any alternate method proposed demonstrate that it met the ICAO operational and performance requirements or their equivalent. Each such instance would, necessarily, need to be considered on its own merit.

§ 34.3 (b) through (f):

(b) Under section 232 of the Act, the Secretary of Transportation issues regulations to ensure compliance with 40 CFR part 87. This authority has been delegated to the Administrator of the FAA (49 CFR 1.47). (c) U.S. airplanes. This Federal Aviation Regulation (FAR) applies to civil airplanes that are powered by aircraft gas turbine engines of the classes specified herein and that have U.S. standard airworthiness certificates. (d) Foreign airplanes. Pursuant to the definition of "aircraft" in 40 CFR 87.1(c), this FAR applies to civil airplanes that are powered by aircraft gas turbine engines of the classes specified herein and that have foreign airworthiness certificates that are equivalent to U.S. standard airworthiness certificates. This FAR applies only to those foreign civil airplanes that, if registered in the United States, would be required by applicable Federal Aviation Regulations to have a U.S. standard airworthiness certificate in order to conduct the operations intended for the airplane. Pursuant to 40 CFR 87.3(c), this FAR does not apply where it would be inconsistent with an obligation assumed by the United States to a foreign country in a treaty, convention, or agreement.

(e) Reference in this regulation to 40 CFR part 87 refers to title 40 of the Code of Federal Regulations, chapter I--Environmental Protection Agency, part 87, Control of Air Pollution from Aircraft and Aircraft Engines (40 CFR part 87). (f) This part contains regulations to ensure compliance with certain standards contained in 40 CFR part 87. If EPA takes any action, including the issuance of an exemption or issuance of a revised or alternate procedure, test method, or other regulation, the effect of which is to relax or delay the effective date of any provision of 40 CFR part 87 that is made applicable to an aircraft under this FAR, the Administrator of FAA will grant a general administrative waiver of its more stringent requirements until this FAR is amended to reflect the more relaxed requirements prescribed by EPA.

Explanation

Authority under Section 232, Clean Air Act, as amended, is to "insure compliance with all standards prescribed under section 231 by the Administrator" of the EPA. If the Administrator of the EPA takes any of the actions described in 34.3 (f) the Administrator of FAA must respond accordingly. In such instances some or all of Part 34 may not be applicable until such time as Part 34 is reissued. In the past any such action taken by the EPA has been reflected in the issuance of a revised or amended version of 40 CFR part 87. This would then serve as the primary reference for all substantive information.

If the EPA changes 40 CFR Part 87 to relax any of the standards, and the relaxed standards apply to aircraft pursuant to Part 34, then the FAA Administrator will grant a general waiver to use the relaxed EPA standard until such time as Part 34 is reissued. It should be noted that a general waiver is not a waiver that can be applied for by an individual, but is a waiver that is issued by the Administrator to all persons subject to Part 34 that is affected by the relaxed or changed 40 CFR Part 87 standards.

§ 34.3(g)

(g) Unless otherwise stated, all terminology and abbreviations in this FAR that are defined in 40 CFR part 87 have the meaning specified in that part, and all terms in 40 CFR part 87 that are not defined in that part but that are used in this FAR have the meaning given them in the Clean Air Act, as amended by Public Law 91-604.

Explanation

40 CFR part 87 specifies, by reference, selected sections of ICAO Annex 16, Volume II, Aircraft Engine Emissions, Second edition, 1993. Namely, Appendices 2, 3, 5, and 6 of Annex 16 provides definitions that are specifically applicable to these referenced appendices and are necessary to an understanding of the requirements described therein. These definitions can be considered to be part of 40 CFR Part 87.

§ 34.3 (h), (i)

(h) All interpretations of 40 CFR part 87 that are rendered by the EPA also apply to this FAR.

(i) If the EPA, under 40 CFR 87.3(a), approves or accepts any testing and sampling procedures or methods, analytical techniques, or related equipment not identical to those specified in that part, this FAR requires an applicant to show that such alternate, equivalent, or otherwise nonidentical procedures have been complied with, and that such alternate equipment was used to show compliance, unless the applicant elects to comply with those procedures, methods, techniques, and equipment specified in 40 CFR part 87.

Explanation

Similar to 34.3 (a) any, individual or agency requesting acceptance and approval for testing, sampling procedures or methods, analytical techniques, or related equipment not identical to those specified, having demonstrated equivalency, must prove to the satisfaction of the FAA that the alternate, equivalent, or otherwise nonidentical procedures have been complied with, and the approved procedures, methods, analytical techniques and related equipment was used to show compliance. Once approval has been obtained from the EPA the requirement to prove that the alternate equivalent, or otherwise nonidentical procedures have been complied with are similar to the requirements for the standard procedures. If the individual or agency reconsiders this, they are free to use the standard testing procedures. The Request Process for §34.3, is shown graphically in FIGURE 3, “EXCEPTIONS TO FAR 34”.

FAA AEE-300 Grants or denies

request

FAA AEE – 300 Receives and Reviews Request

Supplemental information for Sections 34.3 (h), (i), (k) and 34.5

FIGURE 3 Request Process for Alternate, Equivalent or Otherwise Nonidentical Procedures

§ 34.3 (j)

(j) If the EPA, under 40 CFR 87.5, prescribes special test procedures for any aircraft or aircraft engine that is not susceptible to satisfactory testing by the procedures in 40 CFR part 87, the applicant must show the Administrator that those special test procedures have been complied with.

Explanation

The FAA has this responsibility under Section 232, CAA as amended. As with 34.3 (a) and (i) the applicant must provide evidence to the FAA that the special test procedures have been complied with as approved.

§ 34.3 (k)

(k) Wherever 40 CFR part 87 requires agreement, acceptance, or approval by the Administrator of the EPA, this FAR requires a showing that such agreement or approval has been obtained.

Explanation

The FAA has this responsibility under Section 232, CAA as amended. The Request Process for Alternate, Equivalent or Otherwise Nonidentical Procedures is shown in Figure 3.

§ 34.3 (l)

(l) Pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 7573, no state or political subdivision thereof may adopt or attempt to enforce any standard respecting emissions of any air pollutant from any aircraft or engine thereof unless that standard is identical to a standard made applicable to the aircraft by the terms of this FAR.

Explanation

42 U.S.C. 7573 refers to Section 233 of the Clean Air Act as amended. Section 233 of the Clean Air Act as amended preempts the adoption or enforcement of any emissions standard not identical to the standards promulgated in 40 CFR part 87, and enforced through 14 CFR Part 34.

§ 34.3 (m)

(m) If EPA, by regulation or exemption, relaxes a provision of 40 CFR part 87 that is implemented in this FAR, no state or political subdivision thereof may adopt or attempt to enforce the terms of this FAR that are superseded by the relaxed requirement.

Explanation

Similar to 34.3 (l) above with authority from Section 233 of the Clean Air Act as amended.

§ 34.3 (n)

(n) If any provision of this FAR is rendered inapplicable to a foreign aircraft as provided in 40 CFR 87.3(c) (international agreements), and §34.3(d) of this FAR, that provision may not be adopted or enforced against that foreign aircraft by a state or political subdivision thereof.

Explanation

Similar to 34.3 (l) (m) above with authority from Section 233 of the Clean Air Act as amended. Standardization and control of emissions from commercial aircraft is the responsibility of the Federal government.

§ 34.3 (o)

(o) For exhaust emissions requirements of this FAR that apply beginning February 1, 1974, January 1, 1976, January 1, 1978, January 1, 1984, and August 9, 1985, continued compliance with those requirements is shown for engines for which the type design has been shown to meet those requirements, if the engine is maintained in accordance with applicable maintenance requirements for 14 CFR chapter I. All methods of demonstrating compliance and all model designations previously found acceptable to the Administrator shall be deemed to continue to be an acceptable demonstration of compliance with the specific standards for which they were approved.

Explanation

With respect to emissions engines are not expected to deteriorate significantly in time so if they met emissions requirements in the past and are maintained in accordance with FAA requirements they will be considered to be in compliance.

§ 34.3 (p)

(p) Each applicant must allow the Administrator to make, or witness, any test necessary to determine compliance with the applicable provisions of this FAR.

Explanation

Emissions compliance testing is typically performed at the engine manufacturers’ facility. Because of the expense and complexity of emissions sampling and analytical equipment, engine manufacturers use the same procedures and equipment, to the extent possible, for all emissions certification testing. Once an emissions certification test has been witnessed and approved, future, similar tests, can be evaluated at little risk, by means of the engine certification test plan and the engine test and emissions measurement equipment operational documentation. Changes in test equipment and/or procedures should be evaluated for each situation. For example, changing an analytical instrument from one manufacturer to another without on site inspection would pose little risk, whereas changing from a single point, traversing, sampling probe to an integrating traversing sampling rake might warrant review and discussion and perhaps inspection of the equipment involved.

8. §34.4 [Reserved]

9. §34.5 Special Test Procedures:.

The Administrator or the Administrator of the EPA may, upon written application by a manufacturer or operator of aircraft or aircraft engines, approve test procedures for any aircraft or aircraft engine that is not susceptible to satisfactory testing by the procedures set forth herein. Prior to taking action on any such application, the Administrator or the Administrator of the EPA shall consult with the other.

Explanation

The particular configuration of a given engine may lend itself to testing by some means other than that implied in Part 34. For example it may be beneficial to sample, for emissions, a mixed fan flow engine from the core

11.

rather than from the standard co-annular core/fan flow discharge nozzle. Because of the restrictions placed on the location of the emissions sampling probe this would be difficult if not impossible. By adopting a scheme of separating the two flows, fan and core without adversely affecting engine performance, a viable core only sample could be taken. Such a scheme would have to be reviewed and approved by the FAA. The request process for approval is shown in Figure 3.

10. §34.6 Aircraft safety

(a) The provisions of this part will be revised if at any time the Administrator determines that an emission standard cannot be met within the specified time without creating a safety hazard.

Explanation

The Administrator must assure appropriate consideration of aircraft safety when considering meeting emissions standards within any time frame.

(b) Consistent with 40 CFR 87.6, if the FAA Administrator determines that any emission control regulation in this part cannot be safely applied to an aircraft, that provision may not be adopted or enforced against that aircraft by any state or political subdivision thereof.

Explanation

Authority for Part 34.6 (b) comes from Section 233, Clean Air Act as amended. In addition, aircraft, in 34.6(b) should be interpreted to mean “aircraft and aircraft engine”.

11. §34.7 Exemptions

Notwithstanding part 11 of the Federal Aviation Regulations (14 CFR part 11), all petitions for rulemaking involving either the substance of an emission standard or test procedure prescribed by the EPA that is incorporated in this FAR, or the compliance date for such standard or procedure, must be submitted to the EPA. Information copies of such petitions are invited by the FAA. Petitions for rulemaking or exemption involving provisions of this FAR that do not affect the substance or the compliance date of an emission standard or test procedure that is prescribed by the EPA, and petitions for exemptions under the provisions for which the EPA has specifically granted exemption authority to the Secretary of Transportation are subject to part 11 of the Federal Aviation Regulations (14 CFR part 11). Petitions for rulemaking or exemptions involving these FARs must be submitted to the FAA.

(a):

Exemptions based on flights for short durations at infrequent intervals. The emission standards of this part do not apply to engines which power aircraft operated in the United States for short durations at infrequent intervals. Such operations are limited to:

(1) Flights of an aircraft for the purpose of export to a foreign country, including any flights essential to

demonstrate the integrity of an aircraft prior to a flight to a point outside the United States.

(2) Flights to a base where repairs, alterations or maintenance are to be performed, or to a point of

storage, or for the purpose of returning an aircraft to service.

(3) Official visits by representatives of foreign governments.

(4) Other flights the Administrator determines, after consultation with the Administrator of the EPA, to be for short durations at infrequent intervals. A request for such a determination shall be made before the flight takes place.

(b) Exemptions for very low production engine models. The emissions standards of this part do not apply to engines of very low production after the date of applicability. For the purpose of this part, "very low production" is limited to a maximum total production for United States civil aviation applications of no more than 200 units covered by the same type certificate after January 1, 1984. Engines manufactured under this provision must be reported to the FAA by serial number on or before the date of manufacture and exemptions granted under this provision are not transferable to any other engine.

(c) Exemptions for new engines in other categories. The emissions standards of this part do not apply to engines for which the Administrator determines, with the concurrence of the Administrator of the EPA, that application of any standard under Sec. 34.21 is not justified, based upon consideration of— (1) Adverse economic impact on the manufacturer; (2) Adverse economic impact on the aircraft and airline industries at large; (3) Equity in administering the standards among all economically competing parties; (4) Public health and welfare effects; and (5) Other factors which the Administrator, after consultation with the Administrator of the EPA, may deem relevant to the case in question. (d) Time-limited exemptions for in-use engines. The emissions standards of this part do not apply to aircraft or aircraft engines for time periods which the Administrator determines, with the concurrence of the Administrator of the EPA, that any applicable standard under Sec. 34.11(a), or Sec. 34.31(a), should not be applied based upon consideration of-- (1) Documentation demonstrating that all good faith efforts to achieve compliance with such standard have been made; (2) Documentation demonstrating that the inability to comply with such standard is due to circumstances beyond the control of the owner or operator of the aircraft; and (3) A plan in which the owner or operator of the aircraft shows that he will achieve compliance in the shortest time which is feasible.

Explanation

The EPA is mandated to address all sources of air pollution which may endanger the public health or welfare. From Federal Register, Vol. 62, No. 89, Thursday, May 8, 1997, "Currently, aircraft are about 2 percent of the total U.S. mobile source NOx and CO ground level emissions inventory. Commercial aircraft emissions are about 70 and 30 percent respectively of these NOx and CO aircraft emissions inventories." While of concern, and determined by the Administrator of the EPA to be in need of regulatory control, commercial aircraft emissions constitute a relatively small fraction of the total mobile sources emissions burden. The likely contribution from the allowable exemptions listed in categories 34.7 (a) - (d) are a small fraction of an already small fraction. EPA has granted a blanket exemption from the standards for all models of engines which satisfy a criterion for low production engines. The FAA has been granted, by the EPA, responsibility for acting on petitions for exemptions of any sort.

From ICAO Annex 16, Volume II, Second edition, 1993, Chapter 2, “TURBO-JET AND TURBOFAN ENGINES INTENDED FOR PROPULSION ONLY AT SUBSONIC SPEEDS”:

Note: In considering exemptions, certificating authorities should take into account the probable numbers of engines that will be produced and their impact on the environment. When such an exemption is granted, the certificating authority should consider imposing a time limit on the future production of such engines for installation on new aircraft, although production of such engines as spares should be permitted indefinitely.

(e)

Applications for exemption from this part shall be submitted in duplicate to the Administrator in accordance with the procedures established by the Administrator in part 11.

Explanation

34.7 (e), and the prefacing remarks to this subsection, do not appear in 40 CFR Part 87, subsection 84.7. They are an addition and reflect the differing roles and responsibilities between the EPA which establishes the regulatory standards, and the FAA, which enforces these standards. Applications for exemptions which do not significantly impact or compromise the substance or compliance date of an emission standard or test procedure or for which the EPA has granted authority to the Secretary of Transportation should be submitted to the FAA subject to 14 CFR part 11. Petitions of a substantive nature relating to emission standards and test procedures must be submitted to the EPA with copies requested by the FAA.

(g):

No state or political subdivision thereof may attempt to enforce a standard respecting emissions from an aircraft or engine if such aircraft or engine has been exempted from such standard under this part.

Explanation

This is an interpretation of Section 233, Clean Air Act as amended, maintaining authority over aircraft and aircraft engine emissions while allowing exemptions for the reasons specified in 34.7 (a) - (d).

II Subpart B—Engine Fuel Venting Emissions

(New and In-use Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines)

12. §34.10 Applicability

(a) The provisions of this subpart are applicable to all new aircraft gas turbine engines of classes T3, T8, TSS and TF equal to or greater than 36 kilonewton (8090 pounds) rated output, manufactured on or after January 1, 1974, and to all in-use aircraft gas turbine engines of classes T3, T8, TSS and TF equal to or greater than 36 kilonewtons (8090 pounds) rated output manufactured after February 1, 1974.

(b) The provisions of this subpart are also applicable to all new aircraft gas turbine engines of class TF less than 36 kilonewtons (8090 pounds) rated output and class TP manufactured on or after January 1, 1975, and to all in-use aircraft gas turbine engines of class TF less than 36 kilonewtons (8090 pounds) rated output and class TP manufactured after January 1, 1975.

13. §34.11 Standard for fuel venting emissions:

(a) No fuel venting emissions shall be discharged into the atmosphere from any new or in-use aircraft gas turbine engine subject to the subpart. This paragraph is directed at the elimination of intentional discharge to the atmosphere of fuel drained from fuel nozzle manifolds after engines are shut down and does not apply to normal fuel seepage from shaft seals, joints, and fittings.

(b) Conformity with the standard set forth in paragraph (a) of this section shall be determined by inspection of the method designed to eliminate these emissions.

(c) As applied to an airframe or an engine, any manufacturer or operator may show compliance with the fuel venting and emissions requirements of this section that were effective beginning February 1, 1974 or January 1, 1975, by any means that prevents the intentional discharge of fuel from fuel nozzle manifolds after the engines are shut down. Acceptable means of compliance include one of the following:

(1) Incorporation of an FAA approved system that recirculates the fuel back into the fuel system. (2) Capping or securing the pressurization and drain valves. (3) Manually draining the fuel from a holding tank into a container.

Explanation

Table 1 summarizes the Engine Fuel Venting Emissions Standards as described in Part 34.

It is normal for aircraft gas turbine engine fuel systems to operate in a pressurized condition. This pressure is relieved after the engines are shut down. Raw fuel allowed to drain uncontained or onto hot internal engine parts will result in the discharge of hydrocarbons from the aircraft into the environment. These hydrocarbons pass into the atmosphere, adding to the local air pollution burden. The objective of this regulation is to eliminate the intentional discharge, into the atmosphere, of fuel drained from the engine fuel manifolds after the engine is shut down following normal flight or ground operations. This regulation is not intended to apply to normal fuel seepage from shaft seals, joints and fittings.

Table 1: ENGINE FUEL VENTING EMISSIONS

(New and In-Use Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines)

ENGINE CLASS EFFECTIVE DATE STANDARD T3, T8, TSS, TF All new aircraft gas turbine Prohibition of fuel venting ≥ 36 kilonewtons (8090 lbs.) engines manufactured on or emissions discharged into after January 1, 1974 the atmosphere

T3, T8, TSS, TF All in-use aircraft gas Prohibition of fuel venting ≥ 36 kilonewtons turbine engines emissions discharged into manufactured after the atmosphere February 1, 1974

TF < 36 kilonewtons All new and in-use aircraft Prohibition of fuel venting TP gas turbine engines emissions discharged into manufactured on or after the atmosphere January 1, 1975

Compliance is by inspection of the method designed or chosen to prevent these emissions. Acceptable means of compliance include recirculating fuel back into the fuel system, by means of an FAA approved system, capping or securing the pressurization and drain valve or manually draining the fuel from a holding tank into a container. In the latter case this fuel must be disposed of in an environmentally sound manner. It should be noted that unlike meeting emissions levels which are clearly the responsibility of the engine manufacturer meeting fuel venting standards can be assigned to the operator depending upon which strategy is chosen to prevent the intentional discharge from the fuel manifold after the engine is shut down. Most, if not all, modern aircraft are designed and constructed to meet this regulation.

As a point of observation, it should be noted that turboshaft engines are not included in these requirements.

III. Subpart C — Exhaust Emissions (New Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines) 14. § 34.20 Applicability

The provisions of this subpart are applicable to all aircraft gas turbine engines of the classes specified beginning on the dates specified in § 34.21.

15. § 34.21 Standards for exhaust emissions

(a) Exhaust emissions of smoke from each new aircraft gas turbine engine of class T8 manufactured on or after February 1, 1974, shall not exceed a smoke number (SN) of 30.

(b) Exhaust emissions of smoke from each new aircraft gas turbine engine of class TF and of rated output of 129 kilonewtons (29,000 pounds) thrust or greater, manufactured on or after January 1, 1976, shall not exceed:

SN = 83.6(rO)-0.274 (rO is in kilonewtons)

(c) Exhaust emissions of smoke from each new aircraft gas turbine engine of class T3 manufactured on or after January 1, 1978, shall not exceed a smoke number (SN) of 25.

(d) Gaseous exhaust emissions from each new commercial aircraft gas turbine engine shall not exceed:

(1) Classes, TF, T3, T8 engines greater than 26.7 kilonewtons (kN) rated output:

(i) Engines manufactured on or after January 1, 1984:

Hydrocarbons: 19.6 grams/kilonewton rO.

(ii) Engines manufactured on or after July 7, 1997.

Carbon Monoxide: 118 grams/kilonewton rO.

(iii) Engines of a type or model of which the date of manufacture of the first individual production model was on or before December 31, 1995 and for which the date of manufacture of the individual engine was on or before December 31, 1999.

Oxides of Nitrogen: (40 + 2 (rPR)) grams/kilonewton rO.

(iv) Engines of a type or model of which the date of manufacture of the first individual production model was after December 31, 1995 or for which the date of manufacture of the individual engine was after December 31, 1999:

Oxides of Nitrogen: (32 + 1.6(rPR)) grams/kilonewton rO.

(v) The emission standards prescribed in paragraphs (d)(1)(iii) and (iv) of this section apply as prescribed beginning July 7, 1997.

(vi) Engines of type or model for which the date of manufacture of the first individual production model was after December 31, 2003:

(A) For engines with a pressure ratio of 30 or less:

(1) For Engines with a maximum rated thrust of more than 89.0 kN:

Oxides of Nitrogen: (19 + 1.6 rPR) grams/kilonewton rO.

(2) For engines with a maximum rated thrust of more than 26.7 kN but not

more than 89.0 kN:

Oxides of Nitrogen: (37.572 + 1.6 rPR – 0.2087 rO) grams/Kilonewton rO.

(B) For engines with a pressure ratio of more than 30 but less than 62.5:

(1) For engines with a maximum rated thrust of more than 89.0 kN:

Oxides of Nitrogen: (7 + 2.0 rPR) grams/kilonewton rO.

(2) For engines with a maximum rated thrust of more than 26.7 kN but more

than 89.0 kN:

Oxides of Nitrogen: (42.71 + 1.4286 rPR – 0.4013 rO + 0.00642 rPR(rO)) grams/kilonewton rO.

(C) For engines with a pressure ratio of 62.5 or more:

Oxides of Nitrogen: (32 + 1.6 rPR) grams/kilonewton rO.

Explanation: The emission standards described in paragraphs (d)(1)(vi)(A), (B), and (C) of this section are contingent upon promulgation by EPA and FAA in their respective regulations and standards. They list the current ICAO CAPE 4 requirements and represent a continuation of the harmonization program with ICAO.

Supplemental Information:

The date of the first individual production model is generally interpreted to mean the date of type certification.

(2) Class TSS: Engines manufactured on or after January 1, 1984:

Hydrocarbons = 140(0.92)rPR grams/kilonewton rO.

(e) Smoke exhaust emissions from each gas turbine engine of the classes specified below shall not exceed:

(1) Class TF of rated output less than 26.7 kilonewtons (6000 pounds) manufactured on or after August 9, 1985.

SN = 83.6(rO)-0.274 (rO is in kilonewtons) not to exceed a maximum of SN = 50.

(2) Classes T3, T8, TSS, and TF of rated output equal to or greater than 26.7 kilonewtons (6000 pounds) manufactured on or after January 1, 1984.

SN = 83.6(rO)-0.274 (rO is in kilonewtons) not to exceed a maximum of SN = 50.

(3) Class TP or rated output equal to or greater than 1,000 kilowatts (1340 Hp) manufactured on or after January 1, 1984.

SN = 187(rO)-0.168 (rO is in kilowatts).

(f) The standards set forth in paragraphs (a), (b), (c), (d) and (e) of this section refer to a composite gaseous emission sample representing the operating cycles set forth in the applicable sections of subpart G of this part, and exhaust smoke emissions emitted during operations of the engine as specified in the applicable sections of subpart H of this part, measured and calculated in accordance with the procedures set forth in those subparts.

Explanation

For TF, T3 and T8 engines the following chart (Figure 4) provides a graphical representation of the smoke emissions requirements. This chart reflects the requirements of Subpart D as well. In general, the threshold of plume visibility can be expected to lie between SN 25 and SN 30. However, visibility is a complex function of the tailpipe diameter, viewing angle, background and meteorological conditions. Differences in any one, or any combination, of these factors, from the average, can be expected to influence this relationship. For example, a plume which is not visible when viewed in a direction normal to its axis could appear to be visible when viewed at an angle more nearly parallel to its axis. In addition apparent plume visibility seems to vary with local ambient humidity. That is, when plumes can be seen they seem to become darker as humidity increases. The regulatory intent is to assure a non-visible plume when viewed in a direction normal to the plume axis.

Smoke Number (SN)

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

SN=83.6(rO)-0.274

.

SN=50 - maximum allowed

SN=34 @ rO=26.7 kilonewtons

SN=22 @ rO=129 kilonewtons

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 Rated Output (rO) - kilonewtons

FIGURE 4: Smoke Emission Requirements For New or In Use TF, T3, and T8 Engines

(3) – 49. Reserved

Table 2: Exhaust Emissions - Summary of Requirements

CLASS DATE STANDARD T8 Each aircraft gas turbine engine in use, or manufactured, on or after February 1, 1974

SN ≤ 30

TF ≥ 129 kN (29,000 pounds)

Each aircraft gas turbine engine in use, or manufactured, on or after January 1, 1976

SN ≤ 83.6×(rO)-0.274

(rO in kN) T3 Each new aircraft gas turbine engine manufactured on or after January 1, 1978

SN ≤ 25

TF, T3, T8 >26.7 kN (6,000 pounds)

Each new aircraft gas turbine engine manufactured on or after January 1, 1984

Each new aircraft gas turbine engine manufactured on or after July 7, 1997

HC ≤ 19.6 g/kN rO

CO ≤ 118 g/kN rO

TF, T3, T8 >26.7 kN Engines where the first production model was manufactured on or before December 31, 1995 and where the date of manufacture of the engine was on or before December 31, 1999 - effective July 7, 1997

NOX ≤ (40 + 2(rPR)) g/kN rO

TF, T3, T8 >26.7 kN Engines where the first production model was manufactured after December 31, 1995 and where date of manufacture of the engine was after December 31, 1999 - effective July 7, 1997

NOX ≤ (32 + 1.6(rPR)) g/kN rO

For rPR ≤ 30 and: 26.7 kN< TF, T3, T8≤ 89.0 kN

TF, T3, T8 >89.0 kN

Engines of a type or model for which the date of manufacture of the first individual production model was after December 31, 2003

NOX ≤ (37.572 + 1.6 rPR – 0.2087 rO) g/kN rO

NOX ≤ (19 + 1.6 rPR) g/kN rO

For 30< rPR< 62.5 and: 26.7 kN< TF, T3, T8≤ 89.0 kN

TF, T3, T8>89.0 kN

Engines of a type or model for which the date of manufacture of the first individual production model was after December 31, 2003

NOX ≤ (42.71 + 1.4286 rPR – 0.4013 rO + 0.0642 rPR(rO) g/kN rO

NOX ≤ (7 + 2.0 rPR) g/kN rO

For rPR ≥ 62.5: All engines Engines of a type or model for which the date of manufacture of the first individual production model was after December 31, 2003

NOX ≤ (32 + 1.6 rPR) g/kN rO

TF < 26.7 kN Each gas turbine engine manufactured on or after August 9, 1985

SN ≤ 83.6×(rO)-0.274 ≤ 50 (rO in kN)

T3, T8, TSS, TF ≥ 26.7 kN Each gas turbine engine manufactured on or after January 1, 1984

SN ≤ 83.6×(rO)-0.274 ≤ 50 (rO in kN) TSS Each gas turbine engine manufactured on or after January 1, 1984

HC ≤ 140 (0.92)rPR g/kN rO

TP ≥ 1,000 kW (1340 HP)

Each gas turbine engine manufactured on or after January 1, 1984

SN ≤ 187×(rO)-0.168

(rO in kW)

Explanation:

Table 2, above, is a summary listing (by class of aircraft engine) of the smoke and gaseous emission regulatory levels for both new and in-use engines. Included as well are the ICAO CAPE 4 NOX standards effective after 12/31/2003, listed in terms of rated pressure ratio.

IV. Subpart D — Exhaust Emissions (In-Use Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines)

50. § 34.30 Applicability

The provisions of this subpart are applicable to all aircraft gas turbine engines of the classes specified beginning on the dates specified in § 34.31.

(4) § 34.31 Standards for exhaust emissions

(a) Exhaust emissions of smoke from each in-use aircraft gas turbine engine of Class T8, beginning February 1, 1974 shall not exceed a smoke number (SN) of 30.

(b) Exhaust emissions of smoke from each in-use aircraft gas turbine engine of Class TF and of rated output of 129 kilonewtons (29,000 pounds) thrust or greater, beginning January 1, 1976, shall not exceed:

SN = 83.6(rO)-0.274 (rO is in kilonewtons)

(c) The standards set forth in paragraphs (a) and (b) of this section refer to exhaust smoke emissions emitted during operations of the engine as specified in the applicable section of subpart H of this part, and measured and calculated in accordance with the procedure set forth in this subpart.

Explanation

Table 2, above lists by Class and by applicable date the smoke and gaseous emission regulatory levels.

(Note: this table is attached to Subpart C of this AC as a composite C-D compilation of requirements)

V Subpart E — [Reserved]

V Subpart E — [Reserved]

VI. Subpart F —

[Reserved]

VII. Subpart G — Test Procedures for Engine Exhaust Gaseous Emissions (Aircraft and Aircraft

Gas Turbine Engines)

18. §34.60 Introduction

(a) Except as provided under §34.5, the procedures described in this subpart shall constitute the test program used to determine the conformity of new aircraft gas turbine engines with the applicable standards set forth in this part. (b) The test consists of operating the engine at prescribed power settings on an engine dynamometer (for engines producing primarily shaft power) or thrust measuring test stand (for engines producing primarily thrust). The exhaust gases generated during engine operation must be sampled continuously for specific component analysis through the analytical train. (c) The exhaust emissions test is designed to measure hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide and oxides of nitrogen concentrations, and to determine mass emissions through calculations during a simulated aircraft landing-takeoff cycle (LTO). The LTO cycle is based on time in mode data during high activity periods at major airports. The test for propulsion engines consists of at least the following four modes of engine operation: taxi/idle, takeoff, climbout, and approach. The mass emissions for these modes are combined to yield the reported values. (d) When an engine is tested for exhaust emissions on an engine dynamometer or test stand, the complete engine shall be used with all accessories which might reasonably be expected to influence emissions to the atmosphere installed and functioning, if not otherwise prohibited by §34.62(a)(2). (e) Other gaseous emissions measurement systems may be used if shown to yield equivalent results and if approved in advance by the Administrator or the Administrator of the EPA.

19. §34.61 Turbine Fuel Specification

Supplemental Information

Engines have generally been tested without off-take bleeds and accessory loads other than those necessary for the engine’s basic operation, consistent with ICAO Annex 16, paragraph 2.1.5.2. Paragraph 34.60(d) is intended to be consistent with the procedures specified in Annex 16, with consideration for special cases where accessory loads might be large enough to influence emissions.

19. §34.61 Turbine Fuel Specification

For exhaust emissions testing, fuel meeting the specifications listed below shall be used. Additives used for the purpose of smoke suppression (such as organometallic compounds) shall not be present.

Explanation:

The fuel specification in Part 34 matches the, amended, ICAO fuel specification in Annex 16, Vol. II, Second Edition, 1993. This specification is typical of Jet A aviation fuel. Although EPA chose to adopt, by reference, the measurement and compliance procedures of ICAO Annex 16, Vol. II, Second Edition, Appendix, 2, 3, 5 and 6, they chose not to adopt by reference the ICAO fuel specification. Instead they listed the fuel properties and allowable ranges of values.

Specification for Fuel to be Used in Aircraft

Turbine Engine Emissions Testing

Property Allowable range of

values

Density kg/m3 at 15°C 780 – 820

Distillation temperature °C

10 % boiling point 155 – 201 Final boiling point 235 – 285 Net heat of combustion MJ/kg 42.86 – 43.50 Aromatics, volume % 15 – 23 Naphthalenes, volume % 1.0 – 3.5 Smoke point, mm 20 – 28 Hydrogen, mass % 13.4 – 14.1 Sulphur, mass % less than 0.3%

Kinematic viscosity at -20°C, mm2/s 2.5 – 6.5

Supplemental information:

Aircraft gas turbine engines can and do use a variety of fuels. The specific fuel type and composition can and often does have a significant effect on engine emissions. Knowing the fuel types in general use is important in establishing a baseline of emissions from the existing and future fleet of commercial aircraft which affects regulatory requirements. It is important when comparing emission levels from one engine with those from another. It is particularly important in evaluating engine emission levels relative to a regulation that was based, in part, on an assumed fuel specification. Because fuel type and composition varies it was necessary to establish a fuel specification which fairly represented typical aircraft gas turbine engine fuels which are in use. The ICAO amended fuel specification is a reasonable international consensus specification, which was the result of over fifteen years of study and negotiation.

In 1972 the EPA Proposed Rule Making specified ASTM D1655 as the requirement that test fuels must meet. They allowed the use of nonmetallic additives as specified in ASTM D1655 but prohibited the use of additives used for the purpose of smoke suppression.

In 1981 ICAO published "International Standards and Recommended Practices Environmental Protection, Annex 16, Volume II, Aircraft Emissions, first edition, 1981" which included a specific detailed turbine engine test fuel specification. In 1982 the EPA adopted the 1981 ICAO fuel specification bringing the U.S. into alignment with ICAO. However, in 1984 the EPA changed its fuel specification, broadening the ranges of allowable test fuel naphthalenes, aromatics and hydrogen content, viscosity and final boiling point values in response to manufacturers difficulty in obtaining fuels meeting the ICAO test fuel specification. The EPA expected ICAO to amend its fuel specification to match the EPA specification.

In 1988 ICAO did amend its fuel specification but rather than addressing the disparity between EPA and ICAO it further widened the range of acceptable fuels by broadening, again, the ranges of allowable test fuel naphthalenes, aromatics and hydrogen content, viscosity and final boiling point values.

In 1993 ICAO, once again, amended its fuel specification substituting density for specific gravity and changing the units of net heat of combustion from kilojoule/kilogram (kJ/kg) to megajoule/kilogram(MJ/kg). EPA analyzed and evaluated the resulting ICAO fuel specification with respect to its effect on aircraft gas turbine engine emissions and on general fuel availability in the

U.S. One particular concern was a decision by EPA to adopt the ICAO NOx standards. Fuel type and composition affect emissions and these standards were based on the latest ICAO fuel specification. If the EPA decided not to adopt the ICAO fuel specifications the U.S. and ICAO NOx standards would not be entirely consistent.

EPA found that changing from specific gravity to density and kilojoules to megajoules would, obviously, not affect either emissions or fuel availability. In comparing actual U.S. jet fuel characteristics to differences between EPA and ICAO test fuel specifications EPA concluded that, for distillation temperatures and hydrogen content, where there were differences, the effect would be negligible, i.e., "not discernable". For the broader range of aromatics and naphthalenes, testing on the high end of the range would be more severe for emissions and would not effect in-use emissions. That is, based on current U.S. jet fuel characteristics, fuels used by in-use aircraft gas turbine engines would be likely to have lower values of aromatics and naphthalenes than used in testing and therefore lower emissions. As a result EPA adopted the 1993 ICAO test fuel specification for the purpose of certification emission testing.

Part 34 reflects, as it must, the EPA standard. Although not spelled out in Part 34 the EPA states that manufacturers should, unless otherwise specified, comply with the latest version of the aviation test fuel specifications from the American Society for Testing and Materials, ASTM, "Standard Specifications for Aviation Turbine Fuels," D1655. There is no mention of the use of non metallic additives. Additives used for smoke suppression, such as organometallic compounds, shall not be present.

20. §34.62 Test procedure (propulsion engines).

(a)(1) The engine shall be tested in each of the following engine operating modes which

simulate aircraft operation to determine its mass emission rates. The actual power setting, when corrected to standard day conditions, should correspond to the following percentages of rated output. Analytical correction for variations from reference day conditions and minor variations in actual power setting should be specified and/or approved by the Administrator:

Mode

Class TP TF, T3, T8 TSS Taxi/idle

Takeoff Climbout

Descent Approach

(*) 100 90 NA

30

(*) 100 85 NA

30

(*) 100 65 15 34

* See paragraph (2) of this section

(2) The taxi/idle operating modes shall be carried out at a power setting of 7 percent rated thrust unless the Administrator determines that the unique characteristics of an engine model undergoing certification testing at 7 percent would result in substantially different HC and CO emissions than if the engine model were tested at the manufacturers' recommended idle power setting. In such cases the Administrator shall specify an alternative test condition.

(3) The times in mode (TIM) shall be as specified below:

Mode

Class TP TF, T3, T8 TSS Taxi/idle

Takeoff Climbout

Descent Approach

26.0 Min. 0.5 2.5 N/A

4.5

26.0 0.7 2.2 N/A

4.0

26.0 1.2 2.0 1.2 2.3

(b) Emissions testing shall be conducted on warmed-up engines which have achieved a steady operating temperature.

21. §34.63 [Reserved]

22. §34.64 Sampling and analytical procedures for measuring gaseous exhaust emissions.

The system and procedures for sampling and measurement of gaseous emissions shall be done in accordance with Appendices 3 and 5 to International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Annex 16, Environmental Protection, Volume II, Aircraft Engine Emissions, Second Edition, July 1993, which are incorporated herein by reference. This incorporation by reference was approved by the Director of the Federal Register in accordance with 5 U.S.C. 552(a) and 1 CFR part 51. This document can be obtained from the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), Document Sales Unit, P.O. Box 400, Succursale: Place de L'Aviation Internationale, 1000 Sherbrooke Street West, Suite 400, Montreal, Quebec, Canada H3A 2R2. Copies may be reviewed at the FAA Office of the Chief Counsel, Rules Docket, Room 916, Federal Aviation Administration Headquarters Building, 800 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC, or at the FAA New England Regional Offce, 12 New England Executive Park, Burlington, Massachusetts, or at the Office of the Federal Register, 800 North Capitol Street, NW., Suite 700, Washington, DC.

23. § 34.65—34.70 [Reserved]

24. § 34.71 Compliance with gaseous emission standards

Compliance with each gaseous emission standard by an aircraft engine shall be determined by comparing the pollutant level in grams/kilonewton/thrust/cycle or grams/kilowatt/cycle as calculated pursuant to §34.64 with the applicable emission standard under this part. An acceptable alternative to testing every engine is described in Appendix 6 to ICAO Annex 16, Environmental Protection, Volume II—Aircraft Engine Emissions. Second Edition, July 1993, effective March 20, 1997. This incorporation by reference was approved by the Director of the Federal Register in accordance with 5 U.S.C. 552(a) and 1 CFR part 51. This document can be obtained from, and copies may be reviewed at the respective addresses listed in §34.64. Other methods of demonstrating compliance may be approved by the FAA Administrator with the concurrence of the Administrator of the EPA.

[(Amdt. 34-2, Eff. 9/98)]

25. §34.80 Introduction

VIII. Subpart H — Test Procedures for Engine Smoke Emissions (Aircraft and Aircraft Gas

Turbine Engines)

25. §34.80 Introduction

Except as provided under §34.5, the procedures described in this subpart shall constitute the test program to be used to determine the conformity of new and in-use gas turbine engines with the applicable standards set forth in this part. The test is essentially the same as that described in §§34.60-34.62, except that the test is designed to determine the smoke emission level at various operating points representative of engine usage in aircraft. Other smoke measurement systems may be used if shown to yield equivalent results and if approved in advance by the Administrator or the Administrator of the EPA.

Supplemental information

The regulatory smoke standards established by EPA and ICAO were set to ensure the invisibility of the engine exhaust when viewed across the plume. Smoke level is determined indirectly, by means of the loss of reflectance of a filter used to trap smoke particles from a prescribed mass of exhaust per unit area of filter. The result is a dimensionless number “SN.” Using generalized relationships between engine thrust and exhaust duct diameters, an empirically derived relationship between smoke number (SN) and engine thrust was developed. The information available to develop this relationship came from early gas turbine engines with straight jet or low bypass ratios. There was little or no dilution of the engine core exhaust gas which is not the case with modern, high bypass, engines. ICAO, which defines – by reference – the measurement standard, requires smoke to be measured at or near the engine exhaust nozzle exit plane, which is consistent with the requirements for using SN as an indicator of visibility for the early engines. Some current engine designs, however, extend the bypass cowling beyond the core nozzle and for these, by definition, the measurement plane includes the bypass airflow. This results in a lower SN, and some question about the relationship of SN to plume visibility for these designs. Introduction of ultra high bypass ratio engines, such as the ducted or unducted prop fan engines will serve to further complicate this situation. The measurement method itself has proven to be physically robust, repeatable and reliable, but time consuming and expensive – particularly for traverse testing.

As a direct result of the narrowly defined smoke number, demanded by the prescribed method of measurement and its implied correlation with engine exhaust plume visibility, finding an alternate, equivalent smoke method has proven to be challenging. Such a method must necessarily correlate with smoke number, not with plume visibility, i.e., any measured value arrived at using an alternate method must be associated unambiguously with an equivalent smoke number. Some engine manufacturers use an optical device that provides continuous, almost real time smoke measurement. This device is patterned after the Hartridge optical smoke meter. Their experience has been that the optical measurements correlate well with in-house ICAO Appendix 2 stained filter measurements with considerable savings in engine test time. If an engine manufacturer wanted to use such a device for certification it would be allowed upon demonstration, by means of actual test data, that the device was equivalent to Appendix 2. It should be mentioned that the correction found at a single manufacturer’s facility has not been demonstrated between engine manufacturers facilities so some caution is advised when assessing equivalency. Because smoke measurement is time consuming, particularly during traversing, and places great demands on the engine, finding an alternate and less costly method is and will continue to be attractive.

The smoke measurement standard was developed for engines that generated smoke at considerably higher levels than are seen today. This affects the relative accuracy of the method. The measurement is considered (by the SAE E-31 committee which developed the method) to be no more accurate than ±3 SN. At smoke levels of SN 50-60 this represents an accuracy of 6-5%. At regulatory standards of 30 and below, relative accuracy becomes 10-20% or more.

Also significant is the requirement to "...provide evidence to the certification authority, by means of detailed traverses, that the proposed probe design and position does provide a representative sample for each prescribed power setting. ICAO Appendix 2 does not provide a definition of "representative" nor does it specify any procedures by which conformance to this requirement can be demonstrated. Because traversing is time consuming, costly, and highly problematic with some new engine designs, this lack of definition and test of 'representativeness' is a serious problem and must be addressed, almost uniquely, for each emissions certification test for which there is a traversing requirement. As with gaseous emissions to a first approximation how well the exhaust was sampled can be estimated from a carbon balance which relates the total carbon measured (mostly CO2) to a measured value of fuel-air ratio. For engine modes above idle a necessary condition could be agreement between fuelair ratios arrived at from emissions and performance measurements within ± 10%.

This would not, however, be a sufficient condition. The variability of smoke is typically greater than the variability of CO2, the dominant species, and so additional work needs to be done. Because smoke, as with the gaseous emissions, seems to be normally (gaussian) distributed, in the core at least, standard statistical techniques can be used to estimate the mean value for the exhaust and the number of sampling points necessary to arrive at the required confidence level. The information to do this can come from prior data or from trial traverses on the current or previous, similar, engines. Note that evidence of a satisfactory probe design can be as simple as having proven the design on a previous, similar, engine. Similarity would, then, need to be proven to the certificating authority.

The smoke sampling and measurement procedures standardized in ICAO Annex 16, Volume II, second edition, 1993, Appendix 2, are derived from an SAE standard, SAE Aerospace Recommended Practice (ARP) 1179, Aircraft Gas Turbine Exhaust Smoke Measurement. ARP 1179, first issued in 1971, is the result of a collaborative government/industry effort to develop a consensus standard for measuring smoke from these sources. It is a dynamic standard which is actively managed by the SAE E-31 committee but has changed little over the years. ICAO maintains an observer on the E-31 committee. Agreeable changes in ARP 1179 can be reflected in future versions of ICAO Appendix 2. With the ICAO procedures being called out by reference (40 CFR part 87), any changes in Appendix 2 will necessarily be reflected in the requirements of Part 34.

The relationship of CO2 to fuel is straight forward given the fuel formulation. For example, a typical kerosenic fuel in the middle of the specification for fuel hydrogen mass ration would have a formulation C12H23. Knowing the atomic weights of carbon (12) and Hydrogen (1.008) you calculate the relative mass of carbon in this fuel molecule to be 0.86, or 1 kg of fuel would contain 0.86 kg of carbon. Taking the atomic weight of oxygen to be 16, a similar calculation shows that 1 kg of fuel, upon complete combustion, would yield 3.16 kg of CO2 (these numbers are rounded for illustrative purposes). For an engine running at high power, say a fuel to air of 0.02 kg fuel/kg air the resulting CO2 mass ratio would be .02*3.16 or approximately .063 kg CO2 per kg of air. Taking the molecular weight of CO2 to be 44.01, air to be 28.96 and the specific weight of air to be 1.225 kg/m3 the volumetric ratio is seen to be 0.0416 or 4.16%. Since CO2 instruments read in volumetric percent, this is the value the instrument should read when the engine is operating at 0.02 f/a. Obviously the reverse calculation, fuel to air ratio from measured volumetric CO2, proceeds in a similar fashion. This relationship is convenient as a nominal indicator of sampling status assuming you know the fuel to air ratio, i.e., by multiplying the fuel to air ratio by 200 you should arrive at an approximate value of CO2 in volumetric percent.

26. §34.81 Fuel Specifications

Fuel having specifications as provided in §34.61 shall be used in smoke emission testing.

Supplemental information

The requirement for emissions certification testing with a fuel which meets a particular specification provides a fixed point of reference for the engine. It provides for some degree of control over the effect of fuel composition on smoke formation and emission. It also helps in the assessment of the

29. §34.89 Compliance with smoke emission standards

effects of changing technology. It will not ensure continued conformance to the smoke emissions standards if a fuel outside of the ICAO fuel specification is used in practice.

27. §34.82 Sampling and analytical procedures for measuring - smoke exhaust emissions

The system and procedures for sampling and measurement of smoke emissions shall be done in accordance with Appendix 2 to International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Annex 16, Volume II—Aircraft Engine Emissions, Second Edition, July 1993. This incorporation by reference was approved by the Director of the Federal Register in accordance with 5 U.S.C. 552(a) and 1 CFR part 51. These materials are incorporated as they exist on the date of the approval and a notice of any change in these materials will be published in the Federal Register. Frequent changes are not anticipated. This document can be obtained from the International Civil Aviation, P.O. Box 400, Succursale: Place de L' Aviation Internationale, 1000 Sherbrooke Street West, Montreal, Quebec, Canada H3H 2R2. Copies may be inspected at the FAA Office of the Chief Counsel, Rules Docket, room 916, Federal Aviation Administration Headquarters Building, 800 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC, or at the FAA New England Regional Office, 12 New England Executive Park, Burlington, Massachusetts, or at the Office of the Federal Register, 800 North Capitol Street, NW., suite 700, Washington, DC.

Supplemental information

ICAO Appendix 2 was derived, almost exclusively, from SAE Aerospace Recommended Practice ARP1179 “Aircraft Gas Turbine Engine Exhaust Smoke Measurement.” This Aerospace Recommended Practices and, by implication, ICAO Appendix 2 truly represents a significant cross section of the affected aircraft community. The U.S. government was represented by the EPA and precedents, the FAA, Bureau of Mines, NASA, Air Force and the Navy. The commercial sector included airlines, airframe manufacturers, engine manufacturers, fuel suppliers, calibration gas suppliers and instrument manufacturers. Over the years, as the methods evolved, many tests were conducted both by individual groups and as collaborative efforts. Data and information that resulted was freely shared, discussed and factored into this ARP as appropriate. The method that resulted, while not perfect, is well understood, repeatable and is robust. However there are some problems which have arisen due to changing engine designs and the intent of ensuring low visibility exhaust plumes.

28. §34.83 – 34.88 [Reserved]

29. §34.89 Compliance with smoke emission standards

Compliance with each smoke emission standard shall be determined by comparing the plot of the smoke number as a function of power setting with the applicable emission standard under this part. The smoke number at every power setting must be such that there is a high degree of confidence that the standard will not be exceeded by any engine of the model being tested. An acceptable alternative to testing every engine is described in Appendix 6 to ICAO, Annex 16, Environmental Protection, Volume II, Aircraft Engine Emissions, Second Edition, July 1993. This incorporation by reference was approved by the Director of the Federal Register in accordance with 5 U.S.C. 552(a) and 1 CFR part 51. This document can be obtained from the address listed in 34.64. Other methods of demonstrating compliance may be approved by the Administrator with the concurrence of the Administrator of the EPA.

Supplemental information

In agreeing to use the ICAO Compliance procedures, EPA has concluded, by implication, that the combination of the test and the compliance procedures will result in assurance that, with 90% confidence 100% of the engines produced, model and type, will meet the smoke standard if the engine or engines tested for smoke, meet the standard.

[THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]

IX. ICAO MANUAL APPENDIX 6

ICAO MANUAL APPENDIX 6. COMPLIANCE PROCEDURE FOR

GASEOUS EMISSIONS AND SMOKE

1. GENERAL

The following general principles shall be followed for compliance with the regulatory levels set forth in Volume II, Part III, 2.2, 2.3, 3.2 and 3.3 of this Annex:

a) the manufacturer shall be allowed to select for certification testing any number of engines, including a single engine if so desired;

b) all the results obtained during the certification tests shall be taken into account by the certification authority;

c) a total of at least 3 engine tests shall be conducted, so that if a single engine is presented for certification it must be tested at least 3 times;

d) if a given engine is tested several times, the arithmetic mean value of the tests shall be considered to be the mean value for that engine. The certification result (x) is then the mean of the values (X) obtained for each engine tested;

e) the manufacturer shall provide to the certificating authority, the information specified in Volume II, Part III, 2.4 or 3.4 of this Annex as appropriate;

f) the engines submitted for testing shall have emissions features representative of the engine type for which certification is sought. However, at least one of the engines shall be substantially configured to the production standard of the engine type and have fully representative operating and performance characteristics. One of these engines shall be declared to be the reference standard engine. The methods for correcting to this reference standard engine from any other engines tested shall have the approval of the national certificating authority. The methods for correcting test results for ambient effects shall be those outlined in 7 of Appendix 3 or 7 of Appendix 5, as applicable.

2. COMPLIANCE PROCEDURES

The certificating authority shall award a certificate of compliance if the mean of the values measured and corrected (to the reference standard engine and reference ambient conditions) for all the engines tested, when converted to a characteristic level using the appropriate factor which is determined by the number of engines tested (i) as shown in the table below, does not exceed the regulatory level.

Note.- The characteristic level of the Smoke Number or gaseous pollutant emissions is the mean of the values of all the engines tested, measured and corrected to the reference standard engine and reference ambient conditions divided by the coefficient corresponding to the number of engines tested. as shown in the table below

Number of engines

tested (i) CO HC NOX SN

1 0.814 7 0.649 3 0.862 7 0.776 9 2 0.877 7 0.768 5 0.909 4 0.852 7 3 0.924 6 0.857 2 0 944 1 0.909 1 4 0.934 7 0.876 4 0.951 6 0.921 3 5 0.941 6 0.889 4 0.956 7 0.929 6 6 0.946 7 0.899 0 0.960 5 0.935 8 7 0.950 6 0.906 5 0.963 4 0.940 5 8 0.953 8 0.912 6 0.965 8 0.944 4 9 0.956 5 0.917 6 0.967 7 0.947 6 10 0.958 7 0.921 8 0.969 4 0.950 2 more than 10 − 0130 59 . 1 i

0 247 24 . 1− i

0 096 78 . 1− i

0157 36 . 1− i

3. PROCEDURE IN THE CASE OF FAILURE

Note.- when a certification test fails, it does not necessarily mean that the engine type does not comply with the requirements, but it may mean that the confidence given to the certificating authority in compliance is not sufficiently high, i.e. less than 90 per cent. Consequently, the manufacturer should be allowed to present additional evidence of engine type compliance.

3.1 If an engine type fails a certification test, the certificating authority shall permit the manufacturer, if he so wishes, to conduct additional tests on the certification engines. If the total results available still show that the engine type fails the certification requirements, the manufacturer shall be allowed to test as many additional engines as desired. The resulting test results shall then be considered with all previous data.

3.2 If the result is still failure, the manufacturer shall be allowed to select one or more engines for modification. The results of the tests already made on the selected engine(s) while unmodified shall be inspected, and further testing shall be done so that at least three tests are available. The mean of these tests shall be determined for each engine and described as the "unmodified mean"

3.3 The engine(s) may then be modified, and at least three tests shall he conducted on the modified engine(s), the mean of which shall be described as the "modified mean" in each case. This "modified mean" shall he compared to the "unmodified mean" to give a proportional improvement which shall then be applied to the previous certification test result to determine if compliance has been achieved. It shall be determined before testing of any modified engine is begun that the modification(s) comply with the appropriate airworthiness requirements.

3.4 This procedure shall be repeated until compliance has been demonstrated or the engine type application is withdrawn.

4. REPORTING OF DATA TO THE CERTIFICATING AUTHORITY

The measured data shall be reported to the certificating authority. In addition the following data shall be reported for each test:

a) sample temperature;

b) sample pressure;

c) actual sample volume at sampling conditions;

d) actual sample flow rate as sampling conditions; and

e) leak and cleanliness checks substantiation (see 2.5.2)

[THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]

X. ICAO MANUAL APPENDIX 3 INSTRUMENTATION AND MEASUREMENT TECHNIQUES

FOR GASEOUS EMISSIONS

1. INTRODUCTION

Note. —- The procedures specified in this appendix are concerned with the acquisition of representative exhaust samples and their transmission to, and analysis by, the emissions measuring system. The procedures do not apply to engines employing afterburning. The methods proposed are representative of the best readily available and most established practice.

Variations in the procedure contained in this appendix shall only be allowed after prior application to and approval by the certificating authority.

Supplemental Information

The methods recommended in ICAO Annex 16 Volume II, Second Edition, 1993 were adopted from SAE Aerospace Recommended Practice ARP 1256, "Procedure for the Continuous Sampling and Measurement of Gaseous Emissions from Aircraft Turbine Engines". ARP 1256 was first issued 10-1-71, by SAE committee E­ 31, Aircraft Exhaust Emission Measurement. This ARP was developed by user groups in the aircraft industry who were interested in measuring and understanding emissions from aircraft gas turbine engines. Subsequent to the issuance of ARP 1256, in 1971, the methods proposed were, with the exception of NOx, adopted by the EPA in 40 CFR part 87, Part II, December 12, 1972.

The exception in NOx measurement involved the adoption of chemiluminescence by the EPA in 40 CFR 87 and NDIR/NDUV by SAE E-31 in ARP 1256. Chemiluminescence, although a new technique at the time, was clearly the superior method and quickly adopted by the user community, incorporated into ARP 1256, replacing NDIR/NDUV, and recommended by ICAO in Annex 16, Volume II, first edition, 1981. The methods of measurement recommended in ICAO Annex 16, Volume II, first edition, 1981 were incorporated, by reference, into EPA 40 CFR 87, in 1982, Federal Register, Vol. 47, No. 251. These recommended methods represent the best readily available and most established practice.

2. DEFINITIONS

Where the following expressions are used in this appendix, they have the meanings ascribed to them below:

(1) Accuracy. The closeness with which a measurement approaches the true value established independently.

(2) Air/fuel ratio. The mass rate of airflow through the hot section of the engine divided by the mass rate of fuel flow to the engine.

(3) Calibration gas. A high accuracy reference gas to be used for alignment, adjustment and periodic checks of instruments.

(4) Concentration. The volume fraction of the component of interest in the gas mixture - expressed as volume percentage or as parts per million.

(5) Exhaust nozzle. In the exhaust emissions sampling of gas turbine engines where the jet effluxes are not mixed (as in some turbofan engines for example) the nozzle considered is that for the gas generator (core) flow only. Where, however, the jet efflux is mixed the nozzle considered is the total exit nozzle.

(6) Flame ionization detector. A hydrogen-air diffusion flame detector that produces a signal nominally proportional to the mass-flow rate of hydrocarbons entering the flame per unit of time -

generally assumed responsive to the number of carbon atoms entering the flame.

(7) Interference. Instrument response due to presence of components other than the gas (or vapour) that is to be measured.

(8) Noise. Random variation in instrument output not associated with characteristics of the sample to which the instrument is responding, and distinguishable from its drift characteristics.

(9) Non-dispersive infra-red analyser. An instrument that by absorption of infra-red energy selectively measures specific components.

(10) Parts per million (ppm). The unit volume concentration of a gas per million unit volume of the gas mixture of which it is a part.

(11) Parts per million carbon (ppmC). The mole fraction of hydrocarbon multiplied by 106 measured on a methane-equivalence basis. Thus, 1 ppm of methane is indicated as 1 ppmC. To convert ppm concentration of any hydrocarbon to an equivalent ppmC value, multiply ppm concentration by the number of carbon atoms per molecule of the gas. For example, 1 ppm propane translates as 3 ppmC hydrocarbon, 1 ppm hexane as 6 ppmC hydrocarbon.

(12) Reference gas. A mixture of gases of specified and known composition used as the basis for interpreting instrument response in terms of the concentration of the gas to which the instrument is responding.

(13) Repeatability. The closeness with which a measurement upon a given, invariant sample can be reproduced in short-term repetitions of the measurement with no intervening instrument adjustment.

(14) Resolution. The smallest change in a measurement which can be detected.

(15) Response. The change in instrument output signal that occurs with change in sample concentration. Also the output signal corresponding to a given sample concentration.

(16) Stability. The closeness with which repeated measurements upon a given invariant sample can be maintained over a given period of time.

(17) Zero drift. Time-related deviation of instrument output from zero set point when it is operating on gas free of the component to be measured.

(19) Zero gas. A gas to be used in establishing the zero, or no-response, adjustment of an instrument.

3. DATA REQUIRED

3.1 Gaseous emissions

Concentrations of the following emissions shall be determined:

(a) Hydrocarbons (HC): a combined estimate of all hydrocarbon compounds present in the exhaust gas.

Supplemental information

Gas turbine engine exhaust gases typically contain a variety of hydrocarbon compounds. The specific compounds present and their relative concentrations are usually unknown. Flame Ionization Detectors (FID), used to measure hydrocarbons, do not respond equally to all hydrocarbon compounds - differential hydrocarbon response. Although the differential hydrocarbon response is to be held within specific bounds, the resulting measurement is an estimate of the hydrocarbon compounds present in the exhaust gas.

(b) Carbon monoxide (CO).

(c) Carbon dioxide (CO2).

Note.— CO2 is not considered a pollutant but its concentration is required for calculation and check

purposes.

(d) Oxides of nitrogen (NOX) an estimate of the sum of the two oxides, nitric oxide (NO) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2).

(e) Nitric oxide (NO).

Supplemental information

The measurement of oxides of nitrogen, using an NO specific device, requires the conversion of NO2 in the exhaust gas to NO. The conversion efficiency of the device used must be known and must be greater than 90%. Measurements of NOx are adjusted for conversion efficiency. The resulting values are considered to be estimates of the NOx concentration in the exhaust gas.

3.2 Other information

In order to normalize the emissions measurement data and to quantify the engine test characteristics, the following additional information shall be provided:

- inlet temperature; - inlet humidity; - atmospheric pressure; - hydrogen/carbon ratio of fuel; - other required engine parameters (for example, thrust, rotor speeds, turbine temperatures and gas-generator air flow).

This data shall be obtained either by direct measurement or by calculation as presented in Attachment F to this appendix.

4. GENERAL ARRANGEMENT OF THE SYSTEM

No desiccants, dryers, water traps or related equipment shall be used to treat the exhaust sample flowing to the oxides of nitrogen and the hydrocarbon analysis instrumentation. Requirements for the various component sub-systems are given in 5, but the following list gives some qualifications and variations:

a) it is assumed that each of the various individual sub-systems includes the necessary flow control, conditioning and measurement facilities;

b) the necessity for a dump and/or a hot-sample pump will depend on ability to meet the sample transfer time and analysis sub-system sample flow rate requirements. This in turn depends on the exhaust sample driving pressure and line losses. It is considered that these pumps usually will be necessary at certain engine running conditions; and

c) the position of the hot pump, relative to the gas analysis sub-systems, may be varied as required. (For example, some HC analysers contain hot pumps and so may be judged capable of being used upstream of the system hot pump.)

Note.- Figure A3-1 is a schematic drawing of the exhaust gas sampling and analytical system and typifies

the basic requirements for emissions testing.

Figure A3-1 Sampling and Analysis System

Supplemental information

Water is a major product of combustion. Its removal upstream of the measuring instruments is desirable. Removal would minimize possible interference effects, where the instrument responds to the water present as well as to the gas or vapor being measured. It would also prevent or minimize water condensing in the instruments, which could cause erratic flow and/or contamination. In the worst case the instrument would be rendered inoperable until thoroughly cleaned. Some devices which remove water are known to remove hydrocarbons and oxides of nitrogen as well.

For most aircraft gas turbine engines and most engine running modes, supplemental pumps will be needed to match the engine exhaust flow with the probe system pressure drop mandated requirement (80% at the probe entrance orifices), the sample line residence time and pressure drop, and the need to remove excess flow from the sampling system. In general the size and location of the pumps and the associated flow control devices are determined from the particular sampling system configuration.

Pumps used for the purpose of sample transfer must be heated. Their location is determined by the particular test configuration. Usually, because of the sample gas physical properties and the need to maintain temperature and flow control within the FID used for hydrocarbon analysis, some instruments utilize internal heated, inert sample transfer pumps. If loss of hydrocarbons in the sampling system is a concern, the FID can be located upstream of the system hot pump as close as physical constraints will allow (temperature, noise, vibration).

5. DESCRIPTION OF COMPONENT PARTS

Note.— A general description and specification of the principal elements in the engine exhaust emissions measurement system follows. Greater detail, where necessary, will be found in Attachments A, B and C to this appendix.

5.1 Sampling system

5.1.1 Sampling probe

a) The probe shall be made of stainless steel. If a mixing probe is used, all sampling orifices shall be of equal diameter;

b) the probe design shall be such that at least 80 per cent of the pressure drop through the probe assembly is taken at the orifices;

Supplemental information

While there is no need to approximate isokinetic conditions when sampling for non-particulates, good practice requires minimum disturbance to the sampled stream as practical. This is especially true when there is concern over spatial variability in gas species concentration, which is the case for the gas turbine engine exhaust plume.

c) the number of sampling orifices shall not be less than 12;

Supplemental information

12 sampling orifices, for an averaging probe, or 12 sampling points for a single point traversing probe, should be considered acceptable only in extreme circumstances or when this number of sampling points has clearly been demonstrated to yield a representative sample.

d) the sampling plane shall be as close to the engine exhaust nozzle exit plane as permitted by considerations of engine performance but in any case shall be within 0.5 nozzle diameter of the exit plane;

Supplemental information

For non-coplanar fan/core exhaust nozzles, care must be taken in locating the sampling plane within 0.5 nozzle diameters of the exit plane inasmuch as there can be two exit planes. The exit plane, from which this distance is measured, is the plane of the final exhaust nozzle – usually the core. The distance allowed would be determined from the larger, fan exhaust nozzle. Further, for these engines, locating the sampling probe as close to the engine exhaust nozzle exit plane as permitted could compromise the requirement to make measurements of the 'total exit nozzle' as defined. Given this ambiguity and the requirement to determine the concentration of species generated by the engine – restricted to the core flow until mixed out – every effort should be made to sample core flow only. This may require a special extension to the core nozzle which will require FAA approval.

and

e) the applicant shall provide evidence to the certificating authority, by means of detailed traverses, that the proposed probe design and position does provide a representative sample for each prescribed power setting.

Supplemental information:

There are no standard definitions of representative sample for emissions from aircraft gas turbine engines nor is there a specification for detailed traverse. The most commonly used definition, arrived at from decades of testing and collaborative analytical exercises by user groups, seems to be the following: for engine modes above idle, (i.e., approach, climb-out and take-off) the integrated average of the measured species should agree with the true average within 10 %. For idle this agreement is ± 15%.

This is similar to the values quoted in section 6.4 of this Appendix, for the carbon balance check. However there is a significant difference. For the carbon balance check, a comparison is made between sets of independently related measured values. With knowledge about the combustion process and the hydrogen to carbon ratio of the fuel used, an estimate can be made from the measured carbon containing species – most of which is CO2, – of the engine average fuel-to-air ratio. The engine fuel-to-air ratio can be independently arrived at from measured fuel and airflow. These two values can be compared and an estimate made of how well the exhaust stream was sampled for carbon containing compounds. However, as mentioned, CO2 far outweighs the influence of any other carbon bearing species in the calculation of fuel-to-air ratios. The spatial variability of CO2 will determine how many sampling points are required and how these sampling points should be distributed. CO2 has been found to consistently exhibit the least variability of all the species of interest – CO, HC, NOx, and smoke. This suggests that it would be possible to meet the criteria – for carbon balance without having obtained a representative sample – using the same 10 and 15% criteria, of the other species. In other words, obtaining a carbon balance, while a necessary condition for a representative sample, can not be considered to be a sufficient condition.

Historically, each engine manufacturer or testing agency appears to have addressed this problem in unique and sometimes novel ways. The simplest method is as follows:

• Recognizing that gas turbine engines are, for most emissions sampling purposes, axi-symmetric, sample the exhaust plume, point by point, with a sufficient number of points to be able to estimate, by statistical means, the true engine average species concentration for each of the species of interest. Engine exhaust species are close enough to normally (Gaussian) distributed to make simple statistical tools acceptable.

• Using these sampling points and the measured concentration values, for each of the species of interest, analytically generate contour plots of constant concentration (isopleths) at each power setting tested. There are a number of computer programs available for workstations or desktop computers to do this.

• For any given probe or rake design analytically overlay the design on the contour plots, estimate the average probe/rake values and compare to the estimated true average arrived at from the detailed traverse.

If the comparisons match the carbon balance criteria, within 10% for engine powers above idle and ±15% at idle, the probe/rake can be considered to be representative. This process may be have to be repeated until an acceptable design is found.

When applying this analytical technique (for core flow only), multiport rake designs which have proven most robust have four sampling arms spaced 90 degrees apart with sampling orifices located on centers of equal area. The sampling ports are equally distributed across the sampling arms. The analysis will determine the minimum number of sampling ports necessary to yield a representative sample.

All data used in arriving at a probe/rake design should be made available to the certificating agency.

5.2 HC analyser

The measurement of total hydrocarbon sample content shall be made by an analyser using the heated flame ionization detector (FID), between the electrodes of which passes an ionization current proportional to the mass rate of hydrocarbon entering a hydrogen flame. The analyser shall be deemed to include components arranged to control temperature and flow rates of sample, sample bypass, fuel and diluent gases, and to enable effective span and zero calibration checks.

Note. — An over-all specification is given in Attachment A to this appendix

5.3 CO and CO2 analysers

Non-dispersive infra-red analysers shall be used for the measurements of these components, and shall be of the design which utilizes differential energy absorption in parallel reference and sample gas cells, the cell or group of cells for each of these gas constituents being sensitized appropriately. This analysis sub-system shall include all necessary functions for the control and handling of sample, zero and span gas flows. Temperature control shall be that appropriate to whichever basis of measurement, wet or dry, is chosen.

Note.—- An over-all specification is given in Attachment B to this appendix

5.4 NOX analyser

The measurement of NO concentration shall be by the chemiluminescent method in which the measure of the radiation intensity emitted during the reaction of the NO in the sample with added O3 is the measure of the NO concentration. The NO2 component shall be converted to NO in a converter of the requisite efficiency prior to measurement. The resultant NOX measurement system shall include all necessary flow, temperature and other controls and provide for routine zero and span calibration as well as for converter efficiency checks.

Note. — An over-all specification is given in Attachment C to this appendix

6. GENERAL TEST PROCEDURES

6.1 Engine operation

6.1.1 The engine shall be operated on a static test facility which is suitable and properly equipped for high accuracy performance testing.

6.1.2 The emissions tests shall be made at the power settings prescribed by the certificating authority. The engine shall be stabilized at each setting.

6.2 Major Instrument calibration

Note. — The general objective of this calibration is to confirm stability and linearity.

6.2.1 The applicant shall satisfy the certificating authority that the calibration of the analytical system is valid at the time of the test.

6.2.2 For the hydrocarbon analyser this calibration shall include checks that the detector oxygen and differential hydrocarbon responses are within the limits specified, as laid down in Attachment A to this appendix. The efficiency of the NO2/NO converter shall also be checked and verified to meet the requirements in Attachment C to this appendix.

6.2.3 The procedure for checking the performance of each analyser shall be as follows (using the calibration and test gases as specified in Attachment D to this appendix):

a) introduce zero gas and adjust instrument zero, recording setting as appropriate;

b) for each range to be used operationally, introduce calibration gas of (nominally) 90 per cent

range full-scale deflection (FSD) concentration; adjust instrument gain accordingly and record its setting;

c) introduce approximately 30 per cent, 60 per cent, and 90 per cent range FSD concentration

and record analyser readings;

d) fit a least squares straight line to the zero, 30 per cent, 60 per cent and 90 per cent

concentration points. For the CO and/or CO2 analyser used in their basic form without linearization of output, a least squares curve of appropriate mathematical formulation shall be fitted using additional calibration points if judged necessary. If any point deviates by more than 2 per cent of the full scale value (or ±l ppm*, whichever is greater) then a calibration curve shall be prepared for operational use.

* Except for the CO2 analyser, for which the value shall be ±100 ppm. ** A more comprehensive and precise alternative methodology which is acceptable is presented in Attachment E to this appendix.

Supplemental Information:

For most, if not all modern analyzers, the adjustment and recording of settings is performed by an internal computer. When the computer stores the calibration coefficients and generates a least square curve for each operational range, this should be considered equivalent to those system controls performed manually in older systems as described in 6.2.3.

6.3 Operation

6.3.1 No measurements shall be made until all instruments and sample transfer lines are warmed up and stable and the following checks have been carried out:

a) leakage check: prior to a series of tests the system shall be checked for leakage by isolating

the probe and the analysers, connecting and operating a vacuum pump of equivalent performance to that used in the smoke measurement system to verify that the system leakage flow rate is less than 0.4 L/min referred to normal temperature and pressure;

b) cleanliness check: isolate the gas sampling system from the probe and connect the end of

the sampling line to a source of zero gas. Warm the system up to the operational temperature needed to perform hydrocarbon measurements. Operate the sample flow pump and set the flow rate to that used during engine emission testing. Record the hydrocarbon analyser reading. The reading shall not exceed 1 per cent of the engine idle emission level or 1 ppm (both expressed as methane), whichever is the greater.

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 298 passages shown