Radar Vectors
Advisory Circular Cancelled Issued Dec 6, 1985 ANE-110 5 pages Copy saved Nov 18, 2026

AC 33.65-1 Surge and Stall Characteristics of Aircraft Turbine Engines

Provides guidance material for acceptable means of demonstrating compliance with the requirements of Part 33 of the Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR) relative to surge and stall characteristics and thrust response of turbine engines. These guidelines do not constitute a regulation and are therefore not mandatory.

This document is cancelled. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.

Official source ↗ Open PDF

Advisory

US DePorlmen: of Transportation Circular Federal Aviation Administration

FAR GUIDANCE

Subject: SlTRGE A,_\'1) STALL CHARACTERISTICS Date: 1 2 / 6 / 8 5 AC So: 13. IS5-l

OF AIRCRAFT TlTR~INE ENGI'ITT:S Initiated b~·: A~-lll) Change:

1. PURPOSE, This advisory circular (AC) provides guidance material for accepta~le means of de~onstrating comoliance with the requirements of Part 33 of the Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR) relative to surge and

FAR GUIDANCE

stall characteristics and thrust response of turbine engines. These guidelines do not constitute a regulation and are therefore not mandatory. Ad<litionally, they are not necessarily the only means o: showing co'!lnliance with applicable airworthiness requiremeT'lts. This material applies to J.arge, high bypass ratio turbofan engines.

2. RELAT-C:D FA"". SECTI0"!S. !'art 33, Sections 33 • .C.5 and 13.73 of the ?AR,

3. RACKGROUND, T~is AC, relating to engine certification substantiation orocenures, is intended to assist in establishing tmiformitv in the certification process ann in the pre-certification test nlanning by defining certain terms and procedures which are in common use throughout the

industry.

4. DEFINITIONS. The definitions are provided to give clarity in understanding the intent of this AC.

a. En~ine Surge: Surge is a response of the entire engine which is characterized by large fluctuation in engine pressures ~~th significant ~low

reduction or reversal in the comuression system.

b. En~ine Stall: Stall is a flow ~reakdo'-ll at one or ~ore compressor airfoils which can cover a wide variety of pressure disturbances producing mild fluctuations or stable reductions in en~ine pressure and flow.

c. Engine Surge Margin: Surge margin is calculated from the quantitative di~ference between the value of a selected engine parameter at

the normal steady-state operating line and the varue of that parameter on the verge of stall. This margin is usually expressed in percent of compressor pressure ratio at constant corrected flow. Other parameters may be used as lo~g as t~ey are clearly defined.

AC No . 13 J> 5-1 l?. /6 /85

a. The curre'1t en~ine and aircrRft certification nroce~ures an~ the FAR have evolve<l hased upon the experie~ce of pas~ programs. ~v application of the current procedures, t~e en~i~e is usually

certificated prior to testing in the bte'1ded aircraft. This provides the aircraft manufacturers with a pretested powerplant uno~ which to base aircraft certification testing.

b. In applying these nrocedures to a ~ive<1 aircraft/e,~ine certification, changes to the engine or aircraft may be renuired to

i~prove the engine ooerating characteristics as part of the certification of the aircraft/engine co~~ination. These changes, as they affect the eno,ine as certificated nnrier ?art '33 o~ t'he ::'A..~, are handled as engineering changes to t,e e'1gine tyoe riesig~ with the ap-::,roval of the Federal A.viation AriT"flin Lstration (FAA). 'Rv application of these nrocedures, any un~esirable install~d engine operA.tin1; characteristics that become ann.;rent during the aircraft

certification process are addressed, ~orrective action is then implemented prior to issuance of the aircraft tvoe certificate.

c. The maximum inlet pressure distortion for which it has ~een demonstrated that hlade stresses are accepta>ile and operation is free

from hazat"dous surge should be incl1Jded in the en;,;ine installation manual as a ba~is for establishin~ comnat{bility of the airframe

il'llet.

6. A'?PROACH.

a. Goals, ~ya com~ination ot tests or tests and analyses, the engine manufacturer should show that the engine characteristics are

sue~ t~at the e~gine will start and ooerate free from hazardous surge and wit~ sufficient thrust response throughout the engine's operating envelo~e. In addition, the e~gine should he capable of withstanding a surge at takeoff power, without structural failure, significant overtemperature, flameout, damage sufficient to preclude recovery of engine power, or damage that will lead to subsequent failure,

b. ~lans. ~rior to the initiation of engine surge and stall certification testing, the enr,ine ~anufacturer should present the ~AA with a ?lan which outlines his approach to demonstrating compliance

with the rep,;ulations. This plan should <iescribe the engine configuration, engine operating requirements, component and engine

test f~cilities, test procedures and analyses. This plan should adnress the <letermination of the ~tarting capability and transient response of the engine, including transient acceleration anrl

Page 2 Par 5

AC No. 33.~c;-l 12/6/85

deceleration charact'=ristics bo:h "t,.'ith and tdthont engine bleef. a"­ and power extraction. The Dlan may procose to use analyses, sea level tests or altitude tests. The enrine operating requirements should be based on oast experience ~~th similar en~ine tvnes, includi11g inlet di storUon and recovery effects, since the performance characteristics of the engines are oredicated on the efficient matchin~ o: inlet and engine operating characteristics. In satisfying: the takeoff surge recovery requirement, unplannen surges encountered during certification testing and/or surge experience ~~th

similar hardware may be considered.

c. Analyses. Quantitative evaluations of the estimated levels of surge margin and engine stability and response should be oerformerl

throughout the anticipated flight environ~ent. A computer model of the engine may be used in this evaluation to augment results obtained by other primary techniques, such as engine and/or comnonent tests and analyses. However, prior to acceptance of computer ~oneling, the anplicant will be expected to present validation that the monel has been success:ully used to predict actual test points. The evalua:ion ~~11 normally account for those factors which change engine component

surge lines and/or their operating lines, thus affecting en~ine surge margin and/or thrust response. ~or example, the evaluation M~ll normally consider (hut not be limited to) the effects of:

(1) Engine service rleterioration.

(2) :Maximum allowable combinatio7is of compressor /turbine matching due to build tolerances.

(3) ~aximum allowa~le combinations of rigging tolerances for v~riable ~eometry, hleeds, and control functions.

( 4) Maximum a1.lowable combination of slue rates for variable geo~etry blee~s and control functions.

(5) Mac~ number.

(6) Altitude (Reynolds number effects).

(7) Inlet distortion effects.

(8) Ingestion of heavy rainfall within the ooerating envelooe (Reference Ar 20-124).

(9) Ingestion of runway water under takeoff and idle Power (Reference AC 20-124).

(10) Power transie~ts (slo~ to snap), such as fro~ flight idle to maximum ~ower.

Par 6 Par;e 3

AC No. 33.~5-l 12/6/85

The above effects can occur both in isolation and in combination. Possible interactions should be recognized and accounted for in the

analysis. The rationale for including or excludin~ any factor in the evaluation shoul<l be presented and normally supnorted by test or onerational experience.

d. Comnliance Testing. Verification testing is require<l to ~e~onstrate compliance. Since engine certification generally nrecedes aircraft certification, any engine compliance testing is <lone usin~ generalized conditions that encomnass the anticipated

aircraft environment. Selection of these conditions shoulrl be based on the engine manufacturer's past exoerience and paragraph ~.c., Analyses.

(l) To acco~nlish engine cornnliance testin~, inclu<ling transient operating characteristics, an approoriate combination of ground test, flight test, and/or the use of altitude test facilities

is acceotahle,

(2) The objective of altitude testing is to determine the effects of t"le aircraft environment. '!'lie testi'lg oroce<lure should inclu<le the following:

(i) A auantit~tive netermination, by ground level en~ine testing or pre;erahly i~ an altitu~e test facilitv, of the component operating line levels and the transient operating characteristics, includin~ acceleration and deceleration, The sur~e, stall and fla~eout boundari~s will normally be defined by test or test and analysis,

(ii) ~he use of a computer model or other means to perform a quantitative analysis of the onerating characteristics

i~entifien ~y the above testing and analysis over the complete operating envelope of the engine. As noted in paragraph 6.c., Analyses, validation of the computer model will be expected.

(iii) T~e basis of t~is analysis should be used to select altitude deraonstration conditions. The scope of testing should include the range of a~ticioated aircraft altitude and engine bower lever transients. In situations where the test facility precludes testing undec some of the desired conditions, analysis should he performed to evaluate the engine cmer;itin~ c'haracteristics in the anticipated aircraft environme~t. However, analysis or computer modeling shoul'."l not be the exclusive i!lethods presented for altitude ~e~onstr.~tion during basic engine certi~ication.

Page 4 Par 6

t"\\.., l."IIU • -·..,.. • "'-" ,.. lL /0 /C:J

(3) The caoabili ty of the engine to ..i_ thstanc. a rota tins stall and/or surge, depen~ing o~ an anticipatea instability occurrence durin~

operatio", 2t t;:il:eoff Powe:-, for a '.")erior' o~ tir:ie ~ ,ich is recuirec ;:or c ere~ to ta~e corrective action, sh~uld be substantiate~. ne~onst:-atio~, ..Thi ch may be basec on in sta:-iil i ties occurring during the develoome:1 t progra1c., sl-ioul<l inclune the ability of the enp;ine to run at rated ta'izeoff n~wer 1d thout exceedin~ limits follo\,.."in!? the rotatin~ stall anri/or surge and bv examination of the actual hardware.

Par 6 Page 5