AC 33-10 Statistical Analysis Considerations for Comparative Test and Analysis Based Compliance Findings for Turbine Engine and Auxiliary Power Unit Replacement, Redesign and Repaired Parts
a. This advisory circular (AC) describes acceptable statistical methods, but not the only methods, to help develop substantiating data for comparative test and analysis compliance findings. The findings support the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) approval of turbine engine and auxiliary power unit (APU) replacement, redesign and repaired parts produced under: (1) Parts manufacturer approval (PMA), (2) Type Certificate (TC), (3) Supplemental Type Certificate (STC), or (4) Repair or alteration. b. The AC describes statistical principles that can be used to help determine adequate sample sizes for a comparative showing of equivalency of parts from different design or manufacturing processes. The guidance in this AC is acceptable for determining sample sizes and/or populations of specimens. The resulting data may be used to support a showing of compliance to the airworthiness requirements of Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) 21.303, 14 CFR part 33, 14 CFR part 43 and Technical Standard Order (TSO) C77.
This document is cancelled. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.
Federal Aviation Administration
Memorandum
Date: December 24, 2015
To: AI Spence, Directive Program Manager, Office of IT Enterprise Services, AES-200
From: Diane M. Cook, Manager, Rulemaking and Policy Branch, ANE-111
Prepared by: Judith Watson 781-238-7196
Subject: Cancel AC 33-10 from the FAA public sites
Purpose
This memo is requesting cancelation of AC 33-10, Statistical Analysis Considerations for Comparative Test and Analysis Based Compliance Findings for Turbine Engine and Auxiliary Power Unit Replacement, Redesign and Repaired Parts, dated 8/28114, from the following two sites:
1 FAA public internet site http://www .faa. gov Ire gulations policies/ advisory circulars/ index. cfm/go/ document.list
2. RGL public site http:/ /rgl.faa.gov/Regulatory and Guidance Library/rgAdvisoryCircular.nsf/0/EA 78498 25F411 CF086257D47005FEB88?0penDocument
A Federal Register Notice was published in January 2015 (attached), that notified the public it was withdrawn. There will be no impact to the budget from this cancellation.
If you have any questions regarding this request, please contact me at 718-23 8-7111.
Manager, Rulemaking and Policy Branch, ANE-111
Attached
""'1'
5192
D;'~-.J; F-~"''"' lO. :><m. I""Ph P. M>l~•"r·
Jk'>,;g,,Jit<ll'~•=l D(f•cer. Aa,.;,oo/ C!""'mM•• ~• '''""'""";"""' l'w.<o.'a"! !Hh~ry /:on·r~ O.'fic<'ofS"""oli"'1 soJ
1""~·'""lA.!'••,-;"'· n,,.•o_( '"'"""'"•~•! O>w~""'"'r.,1off,;,, l.>.•p.,.,on! ef ·''"''
IJ"' ""~ """·-"'""" "''' '·"'·'"' ""''"''
~"'-"" ""'""'""'"""
OEPAA1MENTOF STATE
OEPAA1MENTOF STATE
[~>!&~!"'-~·~ o … oeas Se<:tlrity Adviaory CounoOI U.oling NPtill<>
G•.,.<IM..nng
Tho Dl!'fl'"'"""1 of S1•1o ><JJJCJllnt:l'$ .1
rn<•011"~ "fU•o u.~. suu~ ll"J>.:ll1mont~ OV•'"""-' S"''"ily A6•i•o•J' Cmmdl on
~'l'im•ary 04 ond 25. ~0!5.l'u""""''o S1'<0ll"'i tll[lll of !JJO Fod<!10>l ll.dvi""1' Commntoo Ao [5lJ.S.C. A!>p<ndi>). .md 5 u.~.c 55:1hlo:J(4),o"<lf> u_s_c_
5:i>b(~)l7fn.:j, it h.J> b"'" <k<1>Mltinerl ih;tl Uoe moelmg will ~·~ clo••fll<> lho J>Uli!OIO 11lRmoOlill~ ~<ill for.t~-"m ;rn ox..ndt,.lli<>n of <>J!por.11o """"ltv i"'lid"" ''"'' 1''''"''"'"'"' ""~ wll( •nmh" ""oo>ivo <l,cus>iun llf lt;o<l• """''" -1<HI rr.opl"i•~U)' <:<mmwrr.i>l inlom•tiUm •t•~~ i> vrivilo~od '">il rnnnrlon1iaL ond wllJ dl"""' 1-'"" OIIH>n:"me.U 10\"0.<ll!l"C!lO>If'IOlmiqu"' and pmn•loo,...,, 1l1o ·''1'1"~' will
lPCCill~o up<lru,.d wmmllloe '~1>D"-'· o
l(]oi"IOilf<~.<l ''"'"''""'·''"d"i'"' '"''""'" n•l.><in~ U> pm·•to '"r:t"' '"'"'''')' polid"' :itl<l pr<•lec:llvo pr<",,IC:lliiO >n<lllm pml"<linn uf t; :;. l>u,inr""-' infumt,IJcm ""'""'~'
F<~ mmo i"lurm:Ui"ll. OOIIIOOI M:U>Ilil ThiiJlll¥1. o·,-em'" S..:uritr A<hi.,on•
(~nmc;l, I:.S. DoJ•ulmLont i>f51.11o. · v.'Ol<hill£1<rn. !lC zn:;n~zoo~. phuno:
571~:<~5~~>14 &,,,., f-'"""'' 1o.:z<m. JI;TJ •'- Mill... [);recJor "{ "'" !Jip/om«ic !i=;,r;,,. ·'""'""· 1/.S./kp•d"'""'' of·""" ji'K fl'~. 10Eo41,71U< rllrnl l~,,JC, ''' ""'j li<L"O <:OOE <1!...,_0
OEPAAlliE<NT OF TRANSPORTATION
F-ml Avielfcn Admi~falra!ioD
Advioory C~cul•r 33-10, Conoiderati"'"' I~• Comparsl'"'" Tetll
~n<l An.,lysio Booed CompU...,oe FiMII'I;II lot 11ltbilll> El'lllltw> aod
Au~IJ(;uy P … - l!nft Ai!-plf!OI>mont. FW>®atgn and R<!pair"'l P~ne
Alllii<CT: ]!,_j_,,,, .\VIOiion 1\dloinistr:otl"o :I'AM. lltJT.
A~YIOH: No1ice <>fWHtiilr:owol llf AC ~J
1~- f.O>.,id•roti<m< r~r C"'"P""IIi<o TPSI .1n<l A••1lF•~ n~.c~l Oom~li«nc>•
l'inrlln~• for T"<l•i!l• E~~ino >~<! Au•llm'-' row" lini< Rl?f'I·""''"""' RO<Ie-;i~ owl Rr·pl:.c:•"'•"' I'm"
$1lt.lt.IARY: 'i11i• nCJOJLe '""'""""'' lh<•
wilbdlilwol ora,., guid;o"w <>lioiC--cl "' AC n--10 .,-,;, oan bo ""''"'<!
FO~ Ri;mwlll'ni'OOM~T!COI CCOITACT; Mark llCR!}"..-. FAA, R"lem-'l<il~an<[ 1'<>11<:> llr:>IJ!;II., .-\N!0-131. }JJ~ino ond l'mp<llor Diro:;~or;•t~ Slotl<!.>n!s St.,ff. Aih:r>ll l".atillcati<m :'><mico, " l>.'-ew l•ilglol>il Ex~rnti-.-~ l~rl. J\"'liogln>l, MA lllBO:l: j>hOIIO: 7~1-ll"-77f•5: fa.: 71!!~
n~71g9_ om•ii: mark.bo"Y<'""f""·!PI'· SUPPL9.1BfTARY INFClRW.TOON:
Bodcj!t<>unrl
We""' Wi1Mt4Wil!f: Add>D<J Clrcolo< JJ~W ta to>tructuro 1!1~ r<>nM<II .md 1o cl.rify it> itllo<•l~ll 1""~""''
,,.,b..i<y: H u" c '""l~l..mt 1~ ~lml
-t~71ll.44T(l.l.
'""'''! io A"'·lir.'l'·"· M"""''"""-'-'- '~' l""""'Y Ll, 2~1'>. <.oll..,ll".\l••••IHI.m, A..moot Mo•ov•.Ko"''"""" I~W.-UC< Di""''""'"·Afr'c"'il.Coriif>eatm" X>'ri«.
]'X!>'£_ »ll'"""'"'"kd 1-<'>-100 '"" _,,) "''-'""' COOE <0!0-t,__,
DEPIIfiTMENT OF TfllltiS»OATAnClN
F"""rlll Avialion Adn\ifti<;tratiOII
F.:>~nt. M..-ting: RTCA Sp<oe;ol C..mmill:<>e Zl1, SJ:><;>!a1 Commitl<!e tit "lAWS
A~~~= Fodoral Avi•lion Adn>inl<lt:Oiio" \FAA), 1 1,$. )Jop:litm"'ll .,rr""''l'""'"'''"' mun. ACfltm: Mo<'lillJ: Notico of lt'l r;A Spocbl Commiuoo 2J1, TAWS.
SUWAAY: Tl1o <"A~;, i."uin~ llu' n~llcc Ia odvi>o lh~ pulllic ul1h• f<mrlh "''"''"'11 ~f Ihe RTGA Spodol C!l<I!Jnill"" 2Jl, TAWS. D"l£$: Tho mO<IiliJ!S l'li!l t>U l1~ltl M•~:h
U~ZI\ 201f> fr<"n ~:1>0 >.On..fi:DD p.m "DI>HOS&S:: ·nw me<'tio;J• will bo hold>~
liT!~\ llmctqu>rlers. R1LA. !""·- 110~ I "Ill Stwol Nv.'., :;nil•' q I 0. \V:"IUligWn DC ~DOJG I'OR ~UIIllJl;R I~IIATIOII COOITACT: Tile
RTI~\ Soordaii.ll, ll,•llll~lb :;,,.,,, NW.. Su loe ~ln. W.,l>i<LSI<»l. [)(:, LDD3ii. or by
l~ln~h<>DO al ('!{l2) JJ(kl50;t1(21)2) ~J:I
I)~JB, lo> al [2112) l~ll--~4-1~. "' \Voh <Uc ·" httpo/_lw-..W.tlf''l.a!);
$~PPca.S~T~RY l~f<li'IMA1'i':JM: l'!lr>U'Jl11 to,ocli,n lll(n)(2l l>fll.-!'«1"-'' ,\dvbnry Co!11ml11f~,\cL [l't~b. L "L~
4"'-s ns.t:.. ArJ>. t. ""'ic~ '' '"'"'''J.
~I''"" folf" •n'"'"'ll-1 n; SJ""'-'' bo,.unl11oo ZJ I. Tho ~~m!. wlll ltodi"J~ lho rJ)Ilnwitl![
Marth Mth-l~:~<Jo .nl.-5:;[)0~.!1l.
• WolcooJoilnttr.<JJ!!~bn • Aolnm•!>lMi>:• "''"'"''=" • A~"""''!t"''"" • 5uJ>m.~y <>fV.',~:Un~ Cnnw ·"'*""""' • Oihc,;?.YOiM>< • !l>io "'"' Plm> !l!K,~t Mm~lll1~~ M:m:il :e..;H>--fl:<ICio.m• ...,;Ollil-"'·
• C.mti"'"'w"' <>f r1"'"' nr Wmkin~ cm.,tp s,,,;a" Mnr<h Ulh---!l:ao".m.~J:oop.m.
• C.>nHnu;Uio" <>f l~>'I>:trv or W<>rkL!I~ Cm"p 0o'O<iGil , AI!Oild;liiCo' i< <>1•~11 1<1 lh>' i"'"'"''"'l puhlio !mt luniiOO lo >pc.:e ~v:oiloiJHil)'
Wi~•Ut.• .>pprm-.11 o! ,,~ dl,>in'"'~ moJJilJ01'1; "''b ]>!lblic =y P"'-"'"' 'lf,ol
-"·'"m~ol> ·" lho meelln~. P«r:><'"' wJ,hill£ ~>I>""""'" "'"@"''""'~ rn rJbloi~ illf-oroJOtkm •bmt~d oont ... ~ lh<> pormn [h!od in tha• FOR RrRiHE! m«JAMATI~~ CO!f1Aei •octl<m. Momlmrr .,roJ"· ru!rli<: "''"' pl<Mlll :o wrWon <I:Mnwnl I<Hh•
!XllmDill<'l,;~ 'lll\'l!WO.
l>.med m '1\/,.,~,o,loo. IX~ '''· ]""'""' tT. ,.,,
Mo..,.mod ~~"''...!. "'"""ff-"'"'' A.,,,.,., .'A·rrr~·"· ''"'11"'"
o,-.,..;.~, ~.,d ,\o.,,.~,,.,~.•. v'"""',
lEO D'.r. <m--<""" 1 lin! !-1"--lf•. ""' ·"'[ """"" """"-'>10-1,_,
DEPAFiiMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
DEPAFiiMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
Fe<lerol Avlotioo Admini~ttation
Twemy-llllr<IM<>oting: ATC/1. Spe<=iol C<>mmlttee 217-Aer,.,"tical ~J<>IOIWilh EUAOCAEWG-- 44-A...-onautieel Datob...,s
~m;~cy: l'odo<a!ATI.>IiJ)t! A<lmiohlmi<Ull [FAM. \J S. Dop.>H!ll'"'l ofTr:>n.>p<"'"io!l ([lOT).
~CTII}~; Nolico ~r II.TCA -'P•"I'l CmnmliiM ll7-A"'"'~l11l<C.ll lh"b:"~' foilll Willi Jiii)~QC".A!i WG·-4~ Aoroll:m!ic:il !Jo<,ol>;c-;.o,,
SUM!l.ORY: ll>o FAA h ;,urn~ lh~J, nulil>• 1o "d'i'o Jl<~ puhllc ,r'' mo~li<>~ oJ un:r\ Sf'«.MI D1lnmil0o~Ll7 Aorm,.ulk:il D'"''""~' be" I'll; h•lrJ ioimly wllh f:lflliX:.·\f; WG·-4~ Aom,.oolic.<llJ.llnbOI.'"'
P~1~$; TI1o mootinR wlll lw IJol1l M:!<o:ll 2-1'.1111•, ltonJ <J:UCI :<.m '" O:i>l' p. n< APUROSSB' 1l,e '""'"illg Wtll b~ IJo,;od h;- llnn•.-vwr-ll,Cr»"lllo•ol nohom".