AC 25.571-1 Damage-Tolerance and Fatigue Evaluation of Structure
This advisory circular (AC) sets forth an acceptable means of compliance with the provisions of·Part 25 of the Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR} dealing with the damage-tolerance alid fatigue evaluation requirements of aircraft structure.
This document is cancelled. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.
DATE 9/28/78 ADVISORY CIRCULAR
DEP,\RT:\IE:\T OF TIU.:\SPORTATIO:\"
Federal Aviation Administration
Washington, D.C.
FEDERAL AVIATIOO REG.Jl.ATION GJIDANCE l1ATERIAL
Subject: DAMAGE-'IOLERANCE AND FATIGUE EVALUATION OF STRUC'IURE
1. RJRPOSE. This edvisory circular sets forth an acceptable rreans of canpliance with the provisions of Federal Aviation Regulation (FAR), Part 25, dealing with the da~ge-tolerance and fatigue evaluation certification
FEDERAL AVIATIOO REG.Jl.ATION GJIDANCE l1ATERIAL
requirements of aircraft structure.
2. BACKGBOUND.
a. During recent years, there have l::een significant state-of-the-art and industry-practice developments in the area of structural fatigue and fail-safe strength evaluation of transport category airplanes. Recognizing that these developments could warrant some revision of existing fatigue requirements
contained in §§25.571 and 25.573 of Part 25 of the Federal Aviation Regulations,
the FAA, Oi1 November 18, 1976, gave ootice of its Transport category Airplane Fatigue Regulatory Feview Program and invited interested :t:ersons to sul::rnit prop:>sals to amend those requirements (see 41 FR 50956). Subsequently, the FAA convened a Transport category Airplane Fatigue Regulatory Review Conference on March 15-17, 1977, in Arlington, Va., to cbtain the views of all roncerned on
the proposals su.tmitted for the review.
b. Participants in the Review Conference discussed the prop::>sals suhnitted for the review. These proposals and the related discussions fanned the basis for the FAA's belief that a a::mprehensive revision of the structural fatigue evaluation standards of §§25.571 and 25.573, and guidance material was warranted. To that end, it was prot:Qsed to substantially revise §25.571, to delete §25.573 (but expand the scope of §25.571 to cover the substance of the deleted section}, and to provide guidance material containing compliance provisions related to the proposed change.
c. This advisory circular provides detailed yuidance for showing ccrnpliance with the revised rule.
lnitia ted ln: AFS-120
3. rnrROOOCI'IOO •
a. The contents of this advisory circular are considered by the FAA in determining compliance with the damage-tolerance and fatigue requirenents of
( 1) Although a uniform approach to the evaluation required by §25.571 is desirable, it is recognized that in such a complex field new design features and metho:is of fabrication, new approaches to the evaluation, a00 ne'l configurations could necessitate variations and deviations fran the procedures described in this advisory circular.
( 2) Damage-tolerance design is required, unless it entails such complications that an effective damage-tolerant structure cannot be achieved within the limitations of geanetry, inspectability, or gocx:l design practice. Under these circumstances, a design that complies with the fatigue evaluation
(safe-life) requirements is used. Typical examples of structure that might not be conducive to damage-tolerance design are landing gear, engine rrounts, and their attachments.
{3) Experience with the awlication of methods of fatigue evaluation indicates that a test background should exist in order to achieve the design objective. Even under the damage-tolerance m:thod discussed in paragraph 5, "Damage-tolerance (fail-safe) evaluation," it is the general practice within industry to conduct damage-tolerance tests for design information and guidance purp:>ses. Damage location and growth data should also l:e considered in establishing a recommended inspection program.
(4) Assessina the fatiaue characteristics of certain structural elements, such as roajor fitting;, joints, typical skin units, and splices,
to ensure that the anticipated service life can reasonably be attained, is needed for structure to be evaluated under § 25.57l(c}.
b. 'IYPical loading spectra exr7cted in service. 'Ihe loading spectrum should be based on measured statist1cal data of the type derived from government and industry load history studies and, where insufficient data are available, on a conservative estimate of the anticipated use of the airplane. 'Ihe principal loads that should l:e considered in establishing a loading spectrun are flight loads (gust and roanetNer}, ground loads
(taxiing, landing impact, turning, engine runup, braking, and towing) and pressurization loads. 'Ihe developnent of the loading spectrum includes the definition of the expected flight plan which involves climb, cruise, descent,
flight times, OJ?erational speeds and altitudes, and the approximate time to be spent in each of the operating regimes. Cp:rations for crew training, and other pertinent factors, such as the dynamic stress characteristics of any flexible structure excited by turbulence, should also be considered. For pressurized cabins, the loading spectrum should include the repeated application of the normal operating differential pressure, and the superimp:)sed effects of flight loads and external aerodynamic pressures.
2
, ... -.. -~ ... I
c. ~nents to be evaluated. In assessing the fX)SSibility of serious fatigue taiUres, the design shoUld be examined to determine probable tnints of failure in service. In this examination, consideration should te given, as necessary, to the results of. stress analyses, static tests, fatigue tests, strain gage surveys, tests of similar structural configurations, and service experience. Service experience has shown that special attention should be focused on the design details of important discontinuities, main attach fittings, tension joints, splices, and cutouts such as windows, doors, and other Ofellings. I£x:ations prone to accidental damage (such as that due to
impact with grourrl servicing equipnent near airplane doors) or to corrosion should also be considered.
d. Analyses and tests. Unless it is determined fran the foregoing exanination that the normal operating stresses in specific regions of the structure are of such a low order that serious damage g1:0Wth is extremely
improbable, repeated load analyses or tests should be ronducted on structure representative of canponents or subcanp:>nents of the wing, control surfaces, enpenhage, fuselage, landing gear, and their related primary attachments. Test specimens should include structure representative of attachment fittings, major joints, changes in section, cutouts, and discontinuities. Any method
used in the analyses should be supported, as necessary, by test or service experience.
4. J.:Wo1AGE-'IOLERANCE { FAIIr-SAFE) EVALUATION.
a. General. 'Ihe damage-tolerance evaluation of structure is intended to ensure that should serious fatigue, corrosion, or accidental damage occur within the operational life of the airplane, the remaining structure can withstand reasonable loads wi~hout failL~e or excessive structural deforrr~tion
until the damage is detected. Included are the considerations historically associated with fail-safe design. The evaluation should encompass establishing the components which are to be designed as damage-tolerant, defining the loading conditions and extent of damage, conducting structural
tests or analyses, or both, to substantiate that the design oojective has been achieved, and establishing data for inspection programs to ensure detection of damage. This evaluation ag>lies to either single or multiple load path structure.
(1} I:esign features which should be oonsidered in attaining a damage-tolerant structure include the following:
( i) Multiple load path construction a.'"ld the use of crack st()fpers to oontrol the rate of crack growth, and to provide cdequate residual static strengthi
(ii) ~faterials and stress levels that, after initiation of cracks, provide a controlled slow rate of crack propagation combined with high residual strength;
(iii) Arrangement of design details to ensure a sufficiently high probability that a failure in any critical structural element will be detected before the strength has been reduced below the level necessary to withstand
the loading conditions specified in § 25.57l(b) so as to allow replacement or repair of the failed el~nts; and
(iv) Provisions bo limit the probability of concurrent multiple damage, particularly after long service, which could conceivably contribute to a a::mnon fracture path. Examples of such nultiple damage are:
(A) A number of small cracks v.hich m~ght coalesce to form a single long crack;
(B) Failures, or p3rtial failures, in a:ljacent areas, due to the redistribution of loading following a failure of a single element; and
{C) Simultaneous failure, or partial failure, of multiple load path discrete elements, working at similar stress levels.
(2) Normally, the damage-tolerance assessment consists of a deterministic evaluation of the above design features and this paragraph provides guidelines for this approach. In certain specific instances , rowever, damage-tolerant design might be rrore realistically assessed by a probabilistic evaluation employing methods such as risk analysis. They are
routinely employed in fail-safe evaluations of airplane systems and have occasionally been used where structure and systems are interrelated. These methods can be of particular value for structure consisting of discrete
isolated el~~~nts where da~e tolerance depends an ~~e ability of t~e structure bo sustain redistributed loads after failures of discrete elements resulting from fatigue, corrosion, or accidental damage. Where considered more appropriate than deterministic analysis, probabilistic analysis might be used if it can te shown that loss of the airplane is extremely improbable and
the statistical data employed in the analysis is based on tests or operational experience, or b:>th, of similar structure.
b. Identification of principal structural elenents. Principal structural elements are those which contribute significantly to carrying flight, ground, and pressurization loads, and whose failure could result in catastrof:hic
failure of the airplane. Typical examples of such elements are as follows:
{ 1) Wing and empennage.
( i) Control surfaces, slats, flaps, and their attachment hinges and fittings;
(ii) Integrally stiffened plates;
(iii) Primary fittings;
(iv) Principal splices;
( v) Skin or reinforcement around cutouts or discontinuities;
(vi) Skin-stringer a::>r.lbinations;
(vii) Spar caps; and
(viii) Spar webs.
(2} Fuselage.
( i) Circunferential frames and crljacent skin;
( ii) Coer frames;
(iii) Pilot window PJSts;
( iv) Pressure bulkheads;
(v) Skin and any single frame or stiffener element around a cutout;
(vi) Skin or skin splices , or roth, under circumferential loads;
(vii) Skin or skin splices, or roth, under fore-and-aft loads;
(viii) Skin around a cutout;
( ix) Skin and stiffener combinations under fore-arrl-aft loads; and
( x) Window frames •
c. Extent of damage. Each particular design should be assessed to establish appropriate damage criteria in relation to inspectability and damage-extension characteristics. In any damage determination,
including those involving nultiple cracks, it is fOSSible to establish the extent of damage in terms of detectability with the inspection techniques to be used, the associated initially detectable crack size, the residual strength capabilities of the structure, and the likely damage-extension rate considering the expected stress redistribution
under the z:epeated loads expected in service and with the expected inspection frequency. Thus, an dJvious p:1rtial failure could te
considered to te the extent of the damage for residual strength assessment, provided a positive determination is ~e that the fatigue cracks will be detectable by the available inspection techniques at a sufficiently early
stage of the crack developnent. In a pressurized fuselage, an cbvious p:1rtial failure might be detectable through the ~ility of the cabin to naintain operating pressure or oontrolled decoopression after occurrence of the damage. The following are typical examples of partial failures which should be
considered in the evaluation:
( 1) Detectable skin cracks emanating fran the edge of structural openings or cutouts;
(2) A detectable circlltlferential or longitudinal skin crack in the basic fuselage structure;
( 3) Complete severance of interior frame clements or stiffeners in addition to a Cletectable crack in the a:ljacent skin;
( 4 ) A detectable failure of ooe element where dual construction is utilized in oomponents such as spar caps, window tosts, window or door frames, and skin structure;
( 5) The presence of a detectable fatigue failure in at least the tension tortion of the spar web or similar element; and
( 6) The detectable failure of a primary attachment, including a control surface hinge and fitting.
d. Inaccessible areas. Every reasonable effort should te made to ensure inspectability of all structural p:lrts, and to qualify them under
the damage-tolerance provisions. In those cases where inaccessible am uninspectable blind areas exist, and suitable damage tolerance cannot practically be provided to allow £or extension of ~e into detectable areas, the structure should te shown to comply with the fatigue (safe-life) requirements in order to ensure its continued airworthiness.
e. Testing of principal structural elenents. 'Ihe nature and extent of tests on complete structures or an portions of the primary structure will
de~oo upon applicable previous design, construction, tests, and service experience, in connection with similar structures. Simulated cracks should be as representative as possible of actual fatigue damage. a-tere it is mt practical to produce actual fatigue cracks, damage can te simulated by cuts made with a fine saw, sharp blade, guillotine, or other sui table neans . In
those cases where l:olt failure, or its equivalent, is to te simulated as p:irt of a possible damage configuration in joints or fittings, l:olts can te removed to provide that part of the simulation.
f. Identification of locations to be evaluated. The locations of
· ..
·---- ,.-..
damage to structure for damage-tolerance evaluation should be identified as follows:
(1) Determination of general damage locations. 'Ihe location and mcrles of damage can be determined by analysis or by fatigue tests on complete structures or subcomponents. However, tests might be necessary when the basis for analytical prediction is not reliable, such as for complex canponents. If less than the canplete structure is tested, care should be
taken to ensure that the internal loads and l:oundary conditions are valid.
( i) If a determination is made by analysis, factors such as the following should be taken into account:
(A) Strain data on undamaged structure to establish points of high stress concentration as well as the magnitude of the concentration;
(B) Locations where p:nnanent deformation occurred in static tests;
(C) Locations of potential fatigue damage identified by fatigue analysis; and
(D) Design details which service exp:rience of similarly designed components indicate are prone to fatigue or other damage.
( ii) In addition, the areas of probable damage from sources such as severe corrosive environment should be determined fran a review of the design and past service experience.
( 2) Selection of critical damage areas. 'Ihe process of actually locating where damage should be simulated in princi1Jal structural elements identified in paragraph 5 .b. of this advisory circular should take into account factors such as the following:
( i) Review analysis to locate areas of maximum stress and low margin of safety;
( ii) Selecting locations in an element where the stresses in adjacent elements \\Ould be the maximum with the damage present;
(iii) Selecting partial fracture locations in an element where high stress concentrations are present in the residual structure; and
( iv) Selecting locations 'Where detection ,;ould be difficult.
g. Damage-tolerance analysis and tests. It should be determined· by
7
. --,J
-_.;. -·--~'
AC 25.571-1 9/28/78
analysis, supported by test evidence, that the structure with the extent of damage established for residual strength evaluation can withstand the specified design limit loads (considered as ultimate loads), and that
the damage growth rate under the re~ated loads expected in service
(between the time at which the damage becomes initially detectable and the time at which the extent of damage reaches the value for residual strength evaluation) provides a practical basis for development of the
inspection program and procedures described in paragraph 5 .h. of this advisory circular. 'Ihe repeated loads should be as defined in the loading, temperature, and hliTlidity spectra. 'Ihe loading coooitions should take into account the effects of structural flexibility and rate of loading where they are significant. -
(1) 'Ihe damage-tolerance characteristics can be shown analytically by reliable or conservative methods such as the following:
{i) By demonstrating quantitative relationships with structure already verified as damage tolerant;
( ii) By demonstrating that the damage v.ould be detected before it reaches the value for residual strength evaluation; or
(iii) By demonstrating that the repeated loads and limit load stresses do not exceed those of previously verified designs of similar configuration, materials and inspectability.
(2) The maximum extent of irmlediately obvious damage fran discrete sources should be determirted and the re.'Ylaining structure sh.o.,.m
to have static strength for the maximum load (considered as ultimate load) expected during the canpletion of the flight. Normally this v.ould be an analytical assessment. In the case of uncontained engine
failures, the fragments and paths to be considered should be consistent with those used in showing canpl iance with § 25. 90 3 (d) ( 1) of the FAR' s, and with typical danage experienced in service.
h. Inspection. I:etection of damage before it becanes dangerous is the ultimate control in ensuring the damage-tolerance characteristics of the structure. Therefore, the applicant should provide sufficient guidance information to assist operators in establishing the frequency, extent, and methods of inspection of the critical structure, and this kind of information must, under § 25 • 5 71 (a) ( 3 ) , be included in the maintenance manual required by§ 25.1529 of the FAR's. cue to the inherent complex interactions of the many parameters affecting damage tolerance, such as operating practices, environmental effects, load sequence on crack growth, and variations in inspection methods, related operational experience should be taken into account in establishing
inspection procedures. Comparative analysis can be used to guide the changes from successful past practice when necessary. Therefore, maintenance and inspection requirements should recognize the dependence
- ~ ---
on experience and should be specified in a document that provides for revision as a result of operational experience, such as the one containing the operator's FAA-approved structural inspection program developed through the
Maintenance Review B::>ard (MRB} procedures for FAR Part 121 q:erators.
5. FATIGUE (SAFE-LIFE) tNAUJATION.
a. General. 'Ihe evaluation of structure under the follO\voing fatigue (safe-life} strength evaluation methods is intended to ensure that catastrophic fatigue failure, as a result of the repeated loads of variable magnitude expected in service, is extremely improbable thr01.goout the structure's operational life. Under these methods, loadi119 spectra should be established,
the fatigue life of the structure for the spectra should be determined, and a scatter factor should be applied to the fatigue life to establish the safe-life
for the structure. 'Ihe evaluation should include the following; however, in sane instances it might be necessary to correlate the loadings used in the analysis with flight load and strain surveys:
( 1) Estimating or measuring the expected loading spectra for the structure;
(2) Oonducting a structural analysis including consideration of the stress concentration effects;
(3} Fatigue testing of-structure which cannot be-related to a test background to establish restnnse to· the typical loading spectrum expacted in service;
( 4) Determining reliable replacement times by interpreting t.he loading n1story, variable load analyses, fatigue test data, service experience, and fatigue analyses; and
(5) Providing data for ins}?ection and maintenance instructions and guidance information to the operators.
b. Safe-life determination: scatter factor. In the interpretation of fatigue analyses and test data, the effect of variability should, under S 25.57l(c), be accounted for by an awropriate scatter factor. Relating test results to the recarmended safe-life is extremely difficult since there are a number of considerations peculiar to each design and test that necessi-
tate evaluation by the applicant. These considerations will depend on the nllltber of representative test Sfecimens, the material, the type of specimen employed, the type of re:peated load test, the load levels, arrl environmental conditions.
c. Replacement times. Replacement times should be established for p:~.rts with established safe-lives and should, under § 25.571(a) (3), be included in
the information prepared under § 25.1529. These replacement times
y
can be extended if additional data indicates an extension is warranted. Important factors which should be considered for such extensions include, but ,., . :..·. · are not linli ted to, the following :
(1) Comparison of original evaluation with service exferience;
{2) Recorded load and stress data. Recorded load and stress data entails instrllTlenting airplanes in service to d:>tain a representative sampl-
ing of actual loads and stresses exp:!rienced. 'Ihe data to be m:asured includes airspeed, altitude, and load factor versus time data; or airsfeed, altitude and strain ranges versus time data; or similar data. 'Ihis data, obtained by instrllT!enting airplanes in ser-Vice, provides a basis for correlating the estilnated loading SfeCtrum with the actual service experience;
(3) Additional analyses and tests. If test data and analyses based on repeated load tests of additional specimens are d:>tained, a reevaluation of the established safe-life can be made;
(4) Tests of parts removed fran service. Repeated load tests of replaced parts can be utilized to reevaluate the established safe-life. The
tests should closely simulate service loading comitions. Repeated load testing of parts removed from service is especially useful where recorded load data d:>tained in service are available since the actual loading experienced by the part prior to replacement is known; and
( 5) Repair or rewurk of the structure. In some cases, repair or rewurk of the structure can gain further life.
d. Type design developrents and changes. For design developnents, or design changes, involving structural configurations similar to those of a design already shown to comply with the applicable provisions of§ 25.57l(c), it might be possible to evaluate the variations in critical portions of the structure on a canparative basis. Typical examples 'M:>uld be redesign of the wing structure for increased loads, and the introduction in pressurized
cabins of cutouts having different locations or different shapes, or t:oth. This evaluation should involve analysis of the predicted stresses of the
redesigned primary structure and correlation of the analysis with the analytical and test results used in showing canpliance of the original design with§ 25.57l{c).
-~.~ J RRARESE A n 0 Director Flight Standards Service