AC 25-27A Development of Transport Category Airplane Electrical Wiring Interconnection Systems Instructions for Continued Airworthiness Using and Enhanced Zonal Analysis Procedure
Airworthiness Program for Airplane Systems/Fuel Tank Safety (EAPAS/FTS)” rule. That rule requires design approval holders (DAHs) and applicants to develop instructions for continued airworthiness (ICA) consisting of maintenance and inspection tasks, intervals, and procedures for the representative airplane’s electrical wiring interconnection systems (EWIS) for each affected type design. The DAH must also review any fuel tank system ICA it has developed in compliance with Special Federal Aviation Regulation No. 88 (SFAR 88) in order to ensure compatibility with the EWIS ICA, including minimizing redundant requirements. The DAH must then submit the EWIS ICA to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) oversight office for review and approval. This AC provides guidance for developing maintenance and inspection instructions for EWIS using an enhanced zonal analysis procedure (EZAP). For the purposes of this AC, the term “maintenance” encompasses both “maintenance” and “preventive maintenance,” as those terms are defined in Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) 1.1. For airplane models whose maintenance programs already include a zonal inspection program, the logic described here provides guidance on improving those programs. For airplanes without a zonal inspection program, use of this logic will produce zonal inspections for wiring that can be added to the existing maintenance program. This AC contains information that can be used by operators to improve EWIS maintenance practices. It stresses the importance of inspecting EWIS and promotes a philosophy of “protect and clean as you go” when performing maintenance, repair, or alterations on an airplane.
0
U.S. Department of Transportation
Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory Circular
Subject: Development of Transport Date: 05/04/10 AC No: 25-27A Category Airplane Electrical Wiring Initiated By: ANM-100 Interconnection Systems Instructions for Continued Airworthiness Using and Enhanced Zonal Analysis Procedure
1. Purpose.
a. This advisory circular (AC) describes parts of the compliance process for the “Enhanced Airworthiness Program for Airplane Systems/Fuel Tank Safety (EAPAS/FTS)” rule. That rule requires design approval holders (DAHs) and applicants to develop instructions for continued airworthiness (ICA) consisting of maintenance and inspection tasks, intervals, and procedures for the representative airplane’s electrical wiring interconnection systems (EWIS) for each affected type design. The DAH must also review any fuel tank system ICA it has developed in compliance with Special Federal Aviation Regulation No. 88 (SFAR 88) in order to ensure compatibility with the EWIS ICA, including minimizing redundant requirements. The DAH must then submit the EWIS ICA to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) oversight office for review and approval.
b. This AC provides guidance for developing maintenance and inspection instructions for EWIS using an enhanced zonal analysis procedure (EZAP). For the purposes of this AC, the term “maintenance” encompasses both “maintenance” and “preventive maintenance,” as those terms are defined in Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) 1.1. For airplane models whose maintenance programs already include a zonal inspection program, the logic described here provides guidance on improving those programs. For airplanes without a zonal inspection program, use of this logic will produce zonal inspections for wiring that can be added to the existing maintenance program. This AC contains information that can be used by operators to improve EWIS maintenance practices. It stresses the importance of inspecting EWIS and promotes a philosophy of “protect and clean as you go” when performing maintenance, repair, or alterations on an airplane.
2. Applicability and Explanation of Requirements.
a. Applicability.
(1) The guidance in this document is directed towards design approval holders (DAHs) (type certificate (TC) and supplemental type certificate (STC) holders) and applicants. This guidance can also be used by air carriers and air operators, maintenance providers, and repair stations.
(2) This AC provides the following information and guidance:
(a) Development of EWIS ICA in accordance with 14 CFR part 25, appendix H, paragraph H25.5(a)(1) as required by:
1 Section 25.1729 (paragraph H25.5(a)(1) fulfills part of the requirements of § 25.1729).
2 Section 26.11(b) and (c).
Note: This AC only contains guidance for the requirements of paragraphs H25.5(a)(1) and (b). AC 25.1701-1, Certification of Electrical Wiring Interconnection Systems on Transport Category Airplanes, contains guidance for paragraph H25.4(a)(3) (Airworthiness Limitations), and the remaining requirements of section H25.5:
• Paragraph H25.5(a)(2) (standard wiring practices manual),
• Paragraph H25.5(a)(3) (EWIS separation),
• Paragraph H25.5(a)(4) (EWIS identification), and
• Paragraph H25.5(a)(5) (electrical load analysis).
(b) Development of the EWIS ICA source document in accordance with part 25, appendix H, paragraph H25.5(b) as required by:
2 Section 26.11(b) and (c).
(c) Explanation of who is required to comply with § 26.11.
(d) Explanation of the § 26.11(e)(4) requirement to make the design approval holder EWIS ICA available to affected persons.
(e) Information on when air carriers and air operators must obtain FAA oversight office approval for changes to EWIS ICA already incorporated into their maintenance program.
Note: Guidance for air carriers and air operators on how to make changes to the FAA-approved EWIS ICA will be contained in AC 120-99, Incorporation of Electrical Wiring Interconnection System (EWIS) Instructions for Continued Airworthiness into an Operator’s Maintenance Program.
(f) EWIS maintenance practices that can be helpful when identifying and developing EWIS maintenance tasks using an EZAP.
(3) The material in this AC is neither mandatory nor regulatory in nature and does not constitute a regulation. It describes acceptable means, but not the only means, for showing compliance with the applicable regulations. We will consider other methods of showing compliance that an applicant may elect to present. While these guidelines are not mandatory, they are derived from extensive FAA and industry experience in determining compliance with the relevant regulations. If, however, we become aware of circumstances that convince us that following this AC would not result in compliance with the applicable regulations, we will not be bound by the terms of this AC, and we may require additional substantiation or design changes as a basis for finding compliance.
(4) The material in this AC does not change or create any additional regulatory requirements, nor does it authorize changes in, or permit deviations, from existing regulatory requirements.
(5) Except in the explanations of what the regulations require, terms such as “shall” or “must” are used in this AC only in the sense of ensuring applicability of this particular method of compliance when the acceptable method of compliance described here is used.
b. Differing Requirements of §§ 25.1729 and 26.11. The requirements to develop EWIS ICA vary depending on whether the applicant is complying with part 25, subpart H, § 25.1729, or with part 26, subpart B, § 26.11.
(1) Airplane models with § 25.1729 in their type certification basis.
(a) For TCs, amended TCs, and STCs with § 25.1729 in their certification basis, applicants must comply with the requirements of part 25, appendix H, paragraph H25.4(a)(3) and paragraphs H25.5(a) and (b). These rules mandate that the applicant provide, as part of the ICA:
1 Identification of any EWIS mandatory replacement times in the Airworthiness Limitations section of the ICA (paragraph H25.4(a)(3)).
2 EWIS maintenance and inspection requirements developed with an EZAP (paragraph H25.5(a)(1)).
3 EWIS maintenance practices in a standard format (paragraph H25.5(a)(2)).
4 EWIS separation requirements as determined under § 25.1707 (paragraph H25.5(a)(3)).
5 EWIS identification methods and requirements for identifying any changes to EWIS under § 25.1711 (paragraph H25.5(a)(4)).
6 Electrical load data and instructions for updating that data (paragraph H25.5(a)(5)).
7 A document that contains the EWIS maintenance inspection requirements or identifies their location in other ICA documents (paragraph H25.5(b)). This section also requires that the document be in a form appropriate for the information to be presented, and that the EWIS ICA be easily recognizable as such.
Note: The document required by paragraph H25.5(b) is commonly referred to as the source document. This document is considered to be part of the ICA required by section H25.5.
(b) Section 25.1729 applies to all transport category airplanes regardless of passenger- or cargo-carrying capacity.
(c) Guidance for § 25.1729 and, as noted earlier, appendix H, paragraph H25.4(a)(3) and paragraphs H25.5(a)(2) through (a)(5) is located in AC 25.1701-1, Certification of Electrical Wiring Interconnection Systems on Transport Category Airplanes.
(d) The EWIS ICA for airplane models with § 25.1729 in their type certification basis must be approved by the FAA aircraft certification office (ACO) or office of the Transport Airplane Directorate. Please note that this differs from the ICA requirements contained in § 25.1529, which requires that ICA be prepared that are acceptable to the Administrator.
(2) Airplane models required to comply with part 26, subpart B.
(a) For airplane models that must comply with part 26, the requirement for preparing EWIS ICA is § 26.11(b) or (c), depending on whether the DAH holds or is applying for a type certificate (§ 26.11(b)) or an amended or supplemental type certificate (§ 26.11(c)). Section 26.11(b) and (c) states that EWIS ICA must be prepared in accordance with paragraphs H25.5(a)(1) and (b). Therefore, DAHs complying with § 26.11 must produce EWIS ICA developed with an EZAP (paragraph H25.5(a)(1)), and the ICA must be in an appropriate form and easily recognizable as EWIS ICA (paragraph H25.5(b)). The DAHs must make the ICA available to affected persons (operators and others required to comply with requirements of § 26.11, § 25.1729, § 121.1111, or § 129.111). The EWIS ICA for airplane models required to comply with part 26, subpart B, must be approved by the FAA oversight office. The FAA oversight office is defined in § 26.3 as “the aircraft certification office or office of the Transport Airplane Directorate with oversight responsibility for the relevant type certificate, supplemental type certificate, or manufacturer, as determined by the Administrator.”
(b) Section 26.11 applies to transport category, turbine-powered airplanes with a type certificate issued after January 1, 1958, that, as a result of the original certification or a later increase in capacity, have:
• A maximum type-certificated passenger capacity of 30 or more, or
• A maximum payload capacity of 7,500 pounds or more.
(3) Requirements for Applicants for STCs and amendments to TCs—§ 26.11(c). Section 26.11(c) requires that applicants for STCs or amendments to type certificates evaluate whether the design change for which approval is sought necessitates a revision to the EWIS ICA that have been previously developed and approved in compliance with § 26.11(b). Guidance for how an applicant can make this evaluation is contained in appendix B of this AC.
c. Representative Airplane and SFAR 88 Compatibility Requirements of § 26.11(b).
(1) Representative airplane. Section 26.11(b) requires that EWIS ICA be developed for the “representative airplane.” The representative airplane is the configuration of each series airplane model that incorporates all variations of EWIS used in production on that series airplane, and all TC-holder-designed modifications mandated by airworthiness directives (ADs) as of the effective date of § 26.11(b). For example, a particular airplane model may be offered in both passenger and cargo versions. For that airplane model, the resultant EWIS ICA must account for any differences between the two versions. Another example would be the situation where the airplane manufacturer offered various interior configurations of a passenger model. The placement of galleys, lavatories, seats, and other interior furnishings might impact the type and frequency of inspections identified by the EZAP analysis. So the resultant EWIS ICA must reflect any such differences. Also, if any changes mandated by ADs have been incorporated, and those changes impact the EWIS ICA, then the EWIS ICA produced to comply with § 26.11(b) must reflect those changes.
(2) EWIS ICA compatibility with fuel tank system ICA. Section 26.11 requires a review of any fuel tank system ICA developed to comply with SFAR 88. This is to ensure compatibility with the EZAP-generated EWIS ICA and to minimize duplication of requirements between them. It is likely that some of the EWIS on an airplane will be part of the airplane’s fuel tank system. In that case, the requirements for their maintenance and inspection might be more specific than those for EWIS in general and might contain additional requirements. For compatibility, it is important that the maintenance and inspections for these EWIS be carefully reviewed. If there are inspection or maintenance requirements for EWIS and for the fuel tank system within the same zone, there should be an effort to align the task interval. The two ICAs should be reviewed to ensure that any maintenance tasks for EWIS do not compromise fuel tank system EWIS requirements, such as separation or configuration specifications. In addition, design holders’ existing documents containing EWIS and fuel tank system ICA should be reviewed to either remove or cross-reference redundant information.
d. EWIS ICA Identification Requirements. Part 25, appendix H, paragraph H25.5(b) requires that EZAP-derived EWIS ICA be easily recognizable as such, so there is traceability during future changes to maintenance programs that contain these EWIS ICA. This is intended to prevent inadvertent deletion, changes to the type of task, or escalation of EZAP-derived EWIS ICA without proper consideration of the reason for the task and its interval. Following approval of the EWIS ICA by the FAA oversight office, ACO, or office of the Transport Airplane Directorate, an operator may propose changes to maintenance or inspection program tasks that were based on the approved EWIS and fuel tank ICA. AC 120-99, Incorporation of Electrical Wiring Interconnection System (EWIS) Instructions for Continued Airworthiness into an
Operator’s Maintenance Program, will contain guidance related to making changes to the approved-ICA-based maintenance and inspection program tasks.
e. Requirements of §§ 121.1111 and 129.111. The EAPAS/FTS rule also requires part 121 certificate holders and part 129 air carriers operating U.S.-registered airplanes to incorporate into their maintenance program tasks based on FAA-approved EWIS ICA. AC 120-99, Incorporation of Electrical Wiring Interconnection System (EWIS) Instructions for Continued Airworthiness into an Operator’s Maintenance Program, will contain guidance for these regulations.
f. Explanation of Maximum Payload Capacity. For purposes of the requirements in § 26.11, payload capacity is defined by § 119.3. The current text of § 119.3 is found in appendix E of this AC.
3. How this Information was Derived. The guidance in this AC is based on recommendations given to us by the Aging Transport Systems Rulemaking Advisory Committee (ATSRAC). It is drawn from maintenance, inspection, and alteration best practices identified through extensive research by ATSRAC and Federal government working groups.
4. Objective.
a. The objective of this AC is to improve maintenance and inspection programs for all EWIS (as defined by § 25.1701) installed on transport category airplanes. Applying this information will improve the likelihood that EWIS degradation from many causes, including environmental, maintenance-related, and age-related problems, will be identified and corrected. In addition, this information has been reviewed to ensure that maintenance actions, such as inspection, repair, overhaul, replacement of parts, and preservation, do not (1) cause a loss of EWIS function, (2) cause an increase in the potential for smoke and fire in the airplane, and (3) inhibit the safe operation of the airplane. This objective is met through the adoption of the following:
(1) Enhanced zonal analysis procedure (EZAP). The EZAP will allow the user to determine the appropriate general or detailed inspections and any cleaning tasks (also referred to as restoration tasks by some manufacturers) needed to minimize the presence of combustible material. An EZAP can be used to develop new wiring cleaning and inspection tasks for both zonal and non-zonal inspection programs. Using this procedure to develop a maintenance program will help ensure that proper attention is given to wiring installations during maintenance. The EZAP provides a logical procedure for selecting inspections (either general or detailed) and other tasks to minimize combustibles. Examples could be cleaning (or restoration) procedures or the changing of an air filter. For an airplane without a zonal inspection program, an EZAP will identify new wiring inspection tasks. Appendix A of this AC provides step-by-step details of the EZAP process.
(2) Guidance for a general visual inspection (GVI). This AC clarifies the definition of a general visual inspection and provides guidance on what is expected from such an inspection, whether performed as a stand-alone GVI or as part of a zonal inspection.
(3) Protections and cautions. This AC provides guidance for developing actions and cautionary statements to be added to maintenance instructions for the protection of wire and other EWIS components. Maintenance personnel will use these enhanced procedures to minimize contamination and accidental damage to EWIS while working on an airplane.
(4) “Protect and clean as you go” philosophy. This philosophy is applied to airplane EWIS through inclusion in operators’ maintenance and training programs. This philosophy stresses the importance of protective measures when working on or around wire bundles, connectors, and other EWIS components. It stresses how important it is to protect EWIS during structural repairs, STC installations, or other alterations by making sure that metal shavings, debris, and contamination resulting from such work are removed. The “protect and clean as you go” philosophy is translated into specifics by the protection and caution recommendations described in section 15 of this AC. More information is contained in section 13 of this AC, Causes of Wire and Other EWIS Component Degradation.
(5) Consolidation with fuel tank requirements. The FAA has developed an extensive program to address safety problems associated with fuel tanks. Fuel tank systems contain EWIS that may be routed independently or may be integrated with other airplane systems’ EWIS. One part of the Fuel Tank Safety Rule, SFAR 88, requires development of maintenance and inspection instructions to ensure the safety of the fuel tank system. Other sections of the Fuel Tank Safety Rule require operators to include fuel tank safety maintenance and inspection instructions in their maintenance or inspection programs. An objective of this AC is to ensure that fuel tank system ICA developed to comply with SFAR 88 are compatible with the EWIS ICA, including minimizing redundant requirements. See section 2 of this AC for details.
b. To fully realize the objectives of this AC, type certificate holders, STC holders, air carriers, air operators, maintenance providers, and repair stations will need to redefine their current approach to maintaining and altering airplane wiring and systems. This redefinition must reach both overall philosophy and specific maintenance tasks. This may require more than simply updating maintenance manuals and work cards and improving training. Maintenance personnel need to be aware that airplane EWIS must be maintained in an airworthy condition. They also need to recognize that a visual inspection of EWIS has inherent limitations. Small defects such as breached or cracked insulation, especially in small-gage wire, may not always be apparent. Therefore, effective EWIS maintenance combines good visual inspection techniques with improved wiring maintenance practices and training.
c. General Compliance Information. Sections 5 through 12 of this AC provide general information regarding the performance of the EZAP. The EZAP process is described in detail in appendix A and appendix B of this AC.
d. EWIS Degradation and Maintenance Information. Sections 13 through 15 of this AC contain general information on (1) causes of wire and other EWIS component degradation, (2) EWIS maintenance guidance, including the levels of inspection applicable to EWIS maintenance, and (3) protection and caution recommendations. The information in these sections can be used by manufacturers in developing EWIS maintenance guidance and by operators to improve EWIS maintenance practices.
5. Enhanced Zonal Analysis Procedure (EZAP)—General Guidance.
a. The EZAP described in this AC was developed to identify tasks to (1) minimize accumulation of combustible materials, (2) detect EWIS component defects, and (3) detect EWIS installation discrepancies that may not be reliably detected by inspections contained in existing maintenance programs. An EZAP logic diagram and an accompanying step-by-step explanation are contained in appendix A of this AC. The EZAP process outlined in appendix A is to be used by type certificate holders. It is also to be used by modifiers such as STC holders/applicants to determine if the design change requires new EWIS ICA, or revisions to existing EWIS ICA. If the STC applicant/holder does not have access to the data required to perform the EZAP outlined in appendix A, then the process outlined in appendix B of this AC may be used.
b. An EZAP will result in safety improvements for airplanes operated with a maintenance or inspection program that includes a zonal inspection program (ZIP). It is unlikely that ZIPs developed in the past considered wire or other EWIS components, except for the most obvious damage that could be detected by a GVI.
c. For airplane models without a ZIP, the EZAP logic is likely to identify a large number of EWIS-related tasks that will need to be consolidated into the existing systems maintenance or inspection program. DAHs who have airplane models without a ZIP might find it worthwhile to develop a ZIP in accordance with an industry-accepted method, such as Maintenance Steering Group 3 (MSG-3), in conjunction with an EZAP.
d. When performing the EZAP, evaluate items such as plumbing, ducting, control cables, and other system installations located in the zone for possible contributions to wiring or other EWIS component degradation or failures. The results of the analysis will indicate whether a restoration task, a zonal GVI, a stand-alone GVI, or a detailed inspection (DET) is required to inspect the EWIS in the zone. The way to determine the best type of inspection is graphically represented in figure 2, step 8, of appendix A of this AC. The type of inspection is determined by completing EZAP Worksheet 3A or EZAP Worksheet 3B of appendix A of this AC. EZAP Worksheet 3A is used for airplanes with a ZIP. EZAP Worksheet 3B is used for airplanes without a ZIP.
e. New tasks identified by the EZAP logic should be compared against existing tasks in the maintenance program to ensure that they are compatible with each other. Also, existing maintenance task type and frequency should not affect the outcome of the EZAP analysis. The analysis for a particular zone should be completed to identify appropriate EWIS tasks and their frequency. After the analysis is complete, these new EWIS tasks should be compared to existing maintenance program tasks to assess where the new tasks and the existing maintenance program tasks can be logically combined. The EZAP analysis should not be adjusted in order to make the tasks and intervals fit the existing maintenance program just for the sake of aligning tasks. Refer to the description in figure 1, step 9, of appendix A of this AC for a detailed discussion on task consolidation and alignment.
f. Operators may want to use the EZAP logic to identify additional inspection and cleaning tasks for any design changes on their airplanes for which EZAP ICA are not available. EWIS ICA developed by a DAH might not have taken into account modifications made to the airplane
by someone other than the DAH who developed the EWIS ICA. Also, when an STC is no longer supported by the STC holder, operators may want to perform an EZAP on the zone(s) affected by the modification.
6. EWIS ICA Developed Using an EZAP.
a. An EWIS ICA task is either an inspection task or a restoration task. The inspection task can be a zonal general visual inspection (GVI), stand-alone GVI, detailed inspection (DET), or a combination of these. A restoration task is usually a cleaning task, but it can also be a task such as replacing an air filter in order to reduce the likelihood of contamination build-up within a zone. EWIS ICA are comprised of all the data required to perform these inspection or restoration tasks. The EWIS ICA can be, and almost always are, comprised of several different data components. It is all of these data components put together that define any particular EWIS ICA. The data components of EWIS ICA can be, and often are, located in multiple documents produced by the applicant or DAH.
b. As an example, EWIS ICA data components can be located in a Maintenance Review Board Report (MRBR), a maintenance planning document (MPD), a maintenance implementation document (MID), an airplane maintenance manual (AMM), a standard wiring practices manual/electrical standards practices manual (SWPM/ESPM), or a stand-alone ICA document produced by a DAH or STC applicant. These data components are items such as:
• Task reference number(s).
• Task type (for example, DET, stand-alone GVI).
• Task interval.
• Task description (for example, perform a DET inspection of the power feeders and connected EWIS components).
• Task procedure (in other words, instructions on how to perform the actual task(s)).
Note: The task procedure should describe how to accomplish the maintenance task. For example, if the task description states to perform a stand-alone GVI of the EWIS in the zone, then the procedure should instruct the maintenance technician to inspect the EWIS within the zone. In the past, some task procedures have instructed the technician to merely inspect the “wires” or “wiring” in the zone. Such a procedure would not be acceptable since wire is only one component of an EWIS. An EWIS includes many components such as clamps, connectors, bundle ties, and stand-offs as defined by § 25.1701. However, in certain cases it may be acceptable for the inspection task to specify a particular EWIS component, such as a wire bundle or high current carrying cable, as being the focus of a specific inspection. For example, service history may show that on a particular airplane model, the power feeders in a specific zone should be the focus of an inspection. Therefore, specifying to perform a DET or stand-alone GVI of the power feeders
and their connected EWIS, instead of a DET or stand-alone GVI of the EWIS in the zone, would be more effective in aiding the maintenance technician to detect possible defects in the power feeder rather than instructing them to inspect all the EWIS within the zone. Such an approach should be considered on a case-by-case basis.
• Task applicability (in other words, model, engine type).
• Airplane zone identification.
Note: According to Air Transport Association (ATA) iSpec 2200, Information Standards for Aviation Maintenance, zones are identified by the airplane manufacturer “to facilitate maintenance, planning, preparation of job instructions, location of work areas and components, and a common basis for various maintenance tasks.” ATA iSpec 2200 contains guidelines for determining airplane zones and their numbering. The EZAP process uses these manufacturer-identified zones. The zones are not created uniquely for EZAP.
• Access instructions.
• Supporting procedures as necessary.
c. Both airplane manufacturers and STC holders/applicants produce EWIS ICA but the process they use is different, and each of these DAHs produce the EWIS ICA in different forms. It is not possible to provide a one-size-fits-all answer for what comprises EWIS ICA. The DAH must identify all of the components comprising the EWIS ICA and identify all of these components in a single document. This single document has become known as the source document. The regulatory requirement for the source document is contained in part 25, appendix H, paragraph H25.5(b) and is discussed in section 7 of this AC.
7. EWIS ICA Source Document as Required Part 25, Appendix H, Paragraph H25.5(b).
a. Paragraph H25.5(b) imposes some specific requirements for documentation and identification of EWIS ICA. It requires that the EWIS ICA developed in accordance with paragraph H25.5(a)(1) must be in the form of a document appropriate for the information to be provided, and that they must be easily recognizable as EWIS ICA. This document must either contain the required EWIS ICA, or specifically reference other documents that contain this information. The document required by paragraph H25.5(b) is referred to as the source document (SD). The entire EWIS ICA must be contained or referenced in the SD. However, paragraph H25.5(b) does not prescribe a specific data form for either the EWIS ICA or the SD (if they are not one and the same). The form the EWIS ICA data takes, and the form of the SD, is at the discretion of the DAH or applicant, as long as it meets the requirements of paragraph H25.5(b) and the data it contains (or references) meets the requirements of paragraph H25.5(a)(1). Some airplane manufacturers plan to use existing documents as their SD. This could be an MRBR, MPD, MID, or some other document. Others are planning to develop new forms of documentation to specifically address the new EWIS ICA SD requirement.
Whatever form the DAH uses to document the EWIS ICA, the SD must clearly identify the data that comprise the EWIS ICA or contain the actual data in order to be in compliance with paragraph H25.5(b).
(1) As described above, paragraph H25.5(b) requires that each EWIS ICA be easily recognizable as EWIS ICA. This means that the EWIS ICA will need to be uniquely identified as such. As an example, some DAHs place “(EZAP)” or “(EWIS)” after each task description to signify that the task is a part of the EWIS ICA. Keep in mind that the purpose of this requirement is to enable easy identification of ICA tasks after they have been incorporated into an operator’s maintenance program. The requirement is meant to ensure traceability. The identification requirement is not for the benefit of the technician who performs the actual maintenance task, but rather for the people who must keep track of the EWIS ICA, such as personnel at an operator or maintenance facility who track maintenance tasks, or an FAA principal inspector.
(2) There are some unique requirements regarding operator-requested revisions to approved EWIS ICA that necessitate they be easily identifiable. Refer to section 12 of this AC for information regarding operator-requested revisions to EWIS ICA.
b. Future Revisions to the FAA-Approved Source Document (SD). After initial approval of the source document, a DAH will likely need to revise the document at some point in order to account for any new or revised EWIS inspection or restoration procedures developed due to production changes or design changes mandated by ADs. Revisions to EWIS ICA such as task deletion, addition, or interval escalation could also occur due to a request by the Industry Steering Committee (ISC) and can be addressed by a specific airplane model’s Zonal Working Group. Any agreed to revisions would be reflected in an update to the MRBR. Proposed revisions to the SD should be submitted to the FAA oversight office, ACO, or office of the Transport Airplane Directorate, as applicable, for review and approval. Upon approval, the FAA oversight office will issue a formal FAA-letter approving the new SD revision. A DAH can then use that approval letter as proof that the EWIS ICA contained in, or referenced by, the SD has been FAA approved. The SD should be revised and submitted for FAA approval when an existing EWIS inspection or restoration task type or task interval is proposed, as well as any proposed task deletions. The revised SD should also be submitted for review and approval if any of the referenced procedures, such as an AMM procedure or procedures referenced within the AMM procedure, is revised such that that any references to that procedure by the SD would no longer be valid. An example of this would be a change to the AMM procedure number or title of the procedure.
8. EWIS ICA Developed by Type Certificate Holders or Applicants. For EWIS ICA data1
identified in the MRBR, MPD, MID, or other type of SD, the items listed below are considered to constitute EWIS ICA. The FAA oversight office must review this material for its
1 The MRBR, MPD, or other document used as the SD may reference the information comprising the actual EWIS ICA. The airplane manufacturer or operators would use this referenced information to develop the task cards (sometimes referred to as job cards) or other documents that are used by maintenance technicians.
acceptability before issuing an approval. The items listed below are also the data that airplane manufacturers and/or operators (or other FAA-approved maintenance providers) will use to develop the task, or job, cards used by the maintenance technician to perform the EWIS inspection or restoration tasks.
a. Controlling reference numbers for the individual EWIS ICA tasks as listed in the MRBR, MPD, MID, or other SD. These reference numbers can be referred to as MRBR reference number, Maintenance Manual (MM)/MPD reference number, Maintenance Significant Items (MSI) reference number, task number, and so forth. The nomenclature and the documents called out by the reference numbers can vary among DAHs. Also, tasks may have been given more than one number by the manufacturer to identify them as parts of different documents. So one task, for example, may have an MPD reference number as well as an MRBR reference number. If more than one number identifies any single EWIS task, then each of those numbers must be considered part of the EWIS ICA. All numbers considered necessary to fully identify and track the EWIS ICA should be considered part of the ICA.
b. Type of task (for example, restoration/cleaning, stand-alone GVI, zonal GVI, and DET as identified in the SD).
c. Task interval (in other words, how often the maintenance task must be accomplished— for example, every 16,000 flight cycles or 3,000 days).
d. Applicability (for example, 767-200, A340, EMB-145) as identified in the SD. Some models within the same family of airplanes may have differing maintenance requirements based on available options (for example, freighter versus passenger version, engine types).
e. Airplane zone identification for airplanes with a zonal program (for example, Zone 201).
f. Task description as given in the SD (for example, Inspect (General Visual) all exposed EWIS in the wheel well. NOTE: Gear extended, doors in open position.)
g. Task procedure(s). These are the actual instruction(s) on how to perform the zonal GVI, stand-alone GVI, DET, and restoration/cleaning tasks that support the task description listed in the SD.
h. Supporting task procedure(s), if any, necessary to perform the task procedure in any other document referenced by the task procedure.
i. Instructions for protections and caution information that will minimize contamination and accidental damage to EWIS. (This can appear in different places, such as in the AMM or in the SWPM/ESPM.) If contained in the SWPM or ESPM (or other similar document), this information will be contained in chapter 20. Sometimes this information is repeated in the standard practices chapter (chapter 20) of the AMM. In any case, it is general caution and protection information, and we do not expect that unique procedures will be developed for individual EWIS ICA for a particular airplane model or even models produced by the same manufacturer. Any protection and caution information specific to EWIS ICA must be referenced in the SD.
9. EWIS ICA Developed by an STC Applicant/Holder or Applicant.
a. Unlike TC applicants/holders, STC applicants do not use the Maintenance Review Board (MRB) process to develop maintenance tasks. However, an STC applicant, like a TC holder, is required to develop EWIS ICA with an EZAP. Therefore, nearly everything that comprises the EWIS ICA for a TC holder’s airplane will also comprise the EWIS ICA for an STC applicant’s modification. Obviously the volume of EWIS ICA for the STC applicant will be smaller and the tasks will be confined to the modified area of the airplane. The following are considered to constitute EWIS ICA for an STC and, therefore, would need FAA oversight office approval:
(1) Controlling reference number(s) contained in the SD for the individual EWIS ICA tasks if those numbers are used to identify a specific EWIS ICA task. All information referenced in the SD that is considered necessary to fully identify and track the EWIS ICA tasks should be considered part of the ICA.
(2) Type of task (for example, restoration/cleaning, stand-alone GVI, zonal GVI, and DET) as identified in the SD.
(3) Task interval (in other words, how often the maintenance task must be accomplished—for example, every 16,000 flight cycles or 3,000 days).
(4) Applicability as identified in the SD (for example, 767-200, A340, EMB-145). Some models within the same family of airplanes may have differing maintenance requirements based on available options (for example, freighter versus passenger version, engine types).
(5) Airplane zone identification for airplanes with a zonal program (for example, Zone 201).
(6) Task description as given in the SD (for example, Inspect (General Visual) all exposed EWIS in the wheel well. NOTE: Gear extended, doors in open position.)
(7) Task procedure(s). These are the instruction(s) on how to perform the GVI, DET, and restoration/cleaning tasks that support the task description listed in the SD. These will sometimes appear in a referenced document, rather than in the SD itself.
(8) Supporting task procedure(s) (if any) necessary to perform the task procedure in any other document referenced by the task procedure.
(9) Instructions for protections and caution information that will minimize contamination and accidental damage to EWIS—unless the modification is using some unique materials or EWIS components, this information will be the same as that developed by the airplane manufacturer. In this case, the applicant should make a statement, along with the appropriate justification, that the existing protection and caution information is adequate.
b. Applicants may submit actual task cards for FAA oversight office approval. The task card is what the maintenance technicians (in other words, persons actually performing the EWIS ICA task) use on the shop floor to tell them what the task is and how to accomplish it. Refer to section 7 of this AC for further discussion on EWIS ICA documentation.
10. FAA and FAA Oversight Office Approval of EWIS ICA.
a. The requirements for the FAA to approve EWIS ICA are contained in § 25.1729 and in § 26.11(b) and (c). Section 25.1729 requires applicants to prepare EWIS ICA in accordance with part 25, appendix H, sections H25.4 and H25.5, and to have them approved by the FAA. In this case, approval by the FAA means approval by the ACO or office of the Transport Airplane Directorate with oversight responsibility for the company or person requesting the approval. Section 26.11(b) and (c) require that DAHs and applicants prepare EWIS ICA in accordance with paragraphs H25.5(a)(1) and (b) of appendix H. These also must be approved by the FAA, but in this case by the FAA oversight office. In summary, there are three different compliance scenarios that require FAA approval of EWIS ICA:
(1) Section 26.11(b) requirements for TC holders.
(2) Section 26.11(c) EWIS ICA requirements for STC and amended TC holders/applicants.
(3) Section 25.1729 EWIS ICA requirements for TC, amended TC, and STC applicants.
b. The following guidance is related only to paragraphs H25.5(a)(1) and (b) of appendix H to part 25. Guidance for the other EWIS ICA requirements in appendix H may be found in AC 25.1701-1, Certification of Electrical Wiring Interconnection Systems on Transport Category Airplanes.
c. The FAA oversight office will approve the SD required by paragraph H25.5(b). Approval of the SD signifies approval of the actual EWIS ICA contained either in the SD itself, or in other documents referenced in the SD. If the SD references data contained in other documents, the FAA oversight office, ACO, or office of the Transport Airplane Directorate must review that data to ensure compliance with paragraphs H25.5(a)(1) and (b). Please note that this includes all task procedures related to the tasks descriptions. This means that approval of the SD also signifies approval of any referenced data. It does not, however, necessarily signify approval of the entire referenced document. For example, EWIS ICA task procedures contained in the AMM will be considered FAA approved, but the entire AMM is not considered FAA approved. This is because the AMM contains maintenance data other than EWIS maintenance data. Once the SD has been submitted by an applicant or DAH and found to be in compliance by the ACO in the case of an ICA developed for § 25.1729, or by the ACO or office of the Transport Airplane Directorate (FAA oversight office) in the case of ICA developed for § 26.11, a letter will be issued signifying approval of the EWIS ICA. The DAH may communicate the approved version of the EWIS ICA (in other words, attach the FAA approval letter to the EWIS ICA source document) to the operators to show that the EWIS ICA are approved.
Note: FAA Aircraft Evaluation Group (AEG) approval of MRBRs that contain EWIS ICA tasks does not signify FAA approval of the EWIS ICA as required by § 25.1729 or § 26.11. The FAA oversight office (ACO or office of the Transport Airplane Directorate) will issue this approval.
d. A DAH located outside of the United States should submit the required regulatory material to the FAA through that DAH’s civil aviation authority (CAA). This applies to the draft
and final EWIS ICA, as well as to any necessary supporting documentation such as the EZAP for the airplane model or design change for which approval is sought. The FAA oversight office ACO, or office of the Transport Airplane Directorate, will coordinate with the CAA regarding review and approval of the data.
e. The following are meant to represent the general types of activity that may occur when EWIS ICA are developed and approved. These sequences of events are presented as examples and may not necessarily represent the exact order in which these actions will occur every time or all the actions necessary for every situation. However, the actions listed are consistent with the MRB procedures outlined in AC 121-22A, Maintenance Review Board.
(1) The following are typical actions for holders of, or applicants for, type certificates as they develop EWIS ICA to comply with the requirements of part 25, appendix H, paragraphs H25.5(a)(1) and (b) (as required by § 25.1729 and § 26.11).
Note: The steps below are focused on the development, review, and approval of the EZAP-derived EWIS ICA. Other EWIS ICA tasks and non-EWIS ICA may also be addressed during the review process, but, for clarity, they are purposely left out of the following sequence of events.
(a) The DAH conducts the preliminary EZAP analysis.
(b) The DAH presents the results of the EZAP analysis to the Industry Steering Committee (ISC) working group (WG) assigned to review the analysis. Typically this will be the Zonal WG. FAA personnel from ACO and AEG offices will participate in the WG.
(c) The WG and the DAH agree on any necessary revisions to the analysis, and the DAH updates the analysis based on these agreements.
(d) The DAH presents the revised EZAP analysis results to the ISC.
(e) The ISC reviews the EZAP analysis results and identifies any necessary revisions.
(f) The DAH updates the analysis based on ISC review and prepares the MRB report, which includes EZAP-derived EWIS ICA.
(g) The DAH transmits the MRB report to the applicable FAA AEG office for approval.
(h) The AEG MRB chairperson reviews and approves the MRBR and reviews the acceptability of other relevant EWIS ICA documentation, such as task procedures contained in the AMM, and then transmits the MRBR approval letter to the DAH. This could be an iterative process if the MRB chairperson identifies any additional changes he or she believes are necessary.
Note: The MRB chairperson’s signature does not indicate approval of compliance with the requirements of §§ 26.11 and 25.1729. Those compliance findings must be issued by the FAA oversight office.
(i) The DAH prepares instructions for continued airworthiness, which include EZAP-derived EWIS ICA based upon the content of the approved MRBR.
(j) The DAH produces the SD (required by paragraph H25.5(b)), which either contains or identifies the location of the EWIS ICA. (The SD can either contain the EWIS ICA or reference its location in other documents—it is the DAH’s choice.)
(k) The DAH submits the SD and any referenced ICA documents to the FAA oversight office for approval.
(l) The FAA oversight office, in conjunction with the applicable AEG office, reviews and approves the SD, which indicates approval of the EWIS ICA referenced or contained in that document.
(2) Following are the typical steps that DAHs or applicants will need to go through in determining whether the design change for which they seek approval requires revisions to previously approved EWIS ICA or the development of new EWIS ICA, or both. A design change can be accomplished through an amended TC (including service bulletins describing design changes), an STC, or changes to an existing STC. These actions apply to applicants who must comply with § 25.1729 (in other words, paragraphs H25.5(a)(1) and (b) of appendix H) or § 26.11(c), or both.
Note: The steps below are focused on the development, review, and approval of the EZAP-derived EWIS ICA. Other EWIS ICA tasks and non-EWIS ICA may also be addressed during the review process, but, for clarity, they are purposely left out of the following sequence of events.
(a) The applicant determines whether the proposed design change requires a revision to the existing EWIS ICA or development of new EWIS ICA, or both. Guidance on making this determination is contained in appendix B of this AC. If required, the applicant develops a new or revised EWIS ICA.
(b) If new or revised EWIS ICA are required, the applicant produces a SD (required by paragraph H25.5(b)) containing the EWIS ICA (developed using the procedure outlined in appendix B of this AC) or identifying their location in other documents. (Whether the SD contains the EWIS ICA or references their location in other documents is the applicant’s choice).
(c) The DAH submits the SD, any referenced ICA documents, and any supporting documentation to the FAA oversight office for approval.
Note: Supporting documentation may be the result of the procedure as outlined in appendix B, previously approved EWIS ICA applicable to the airplane zone(s)
being modified, or other documentation that supports the applicant’s position as to the necessity of creating new or revised EWIS ICA.
(d) The FAA oversight office, in conjunction with the applicable AEG office, reviews and approves the SD, which indicates approval of the EWIS ICA referenced or contained in that document.
11. Making EWIS ICA Available to Operators and Other Persons. Section 26.11(e)(4) requires that the compliance plan submitted by the DAH or applicant contains a proposal for how the approved EWIS ICA will be made available to affected persons. Section 26.11(f) requires that the compliance plan be implemented in accordance with § 26.11(e). The rule does not specify the manner in which the DAH must make the EWIS ICA available. It simply requires the DAH to make them available. The “affected persons” that the rule refers to are operators and others required to comply with the requirements of §§ 26.11, 25.1729, 121.1111, and 129.111.
12. Operator Changes to EWIS ICA. Sections 121.1111 and 129.111 require that the EWIS maintenance program be based on EWIS ICA that have been developed in accordance with provisions of appendix H and approved by the FAA oversight office. Guidance for air carriers and air operators on how to make changes to FAA-approved EWIS ICA is contained in AC 120-99, Incorporation of Electrical Wiring Interconnection System (EWIS) Instructions for Continued Airworthiness into an Operator’s Maintenance Program.
13. Causes of Wire and Other EWIS Component Degradation. The following are considered principal causes of wiring degradation and should be used to help focus maintenance programs.
a. Vibration. High vibration areas tend to accelerate degradation over time, resulting in “chattering” contacts and intermittent symptoms. High vibration of tie-wraps or string-ties can cause damage to insulation. In addition, high vibration will exacerbate any existing wire insulation cracking.
b. Moisture. High moisture areas generally accelerate corrosion of terminals, pins, sockets, and conductors. It should be noted that wiring installed in clean, dry areas with moderate temperatures appears to hold up well.
c. Maintenance. Scheduled and unscheduled maintenance activities, if done improperly, may contribute to long-term problems and degradation of EWIS. Certain repairs may have limited durability and should be evaluated to ascertain if rework is necessary. Repairs that conform to manufacturers’ recommended maintenance practices are generally considered permanent and should not require rework. Care should be taken to prevent undue collateral damage to EWIS while performing maintenance on other systems.
(1) Metal shavings and debris have been discovered on wire bundles after maintenance, repairs, modifications, or STC work has been performed. Take care to protect wire bundles, connectors, and all other EWIS components during maintenance, repairs, or modification work.
Work areas should be cleaned while the work progresses to ensure that all shavings and debris are removed. The work area should be thoroughly cleaned after work is complete, and the area should be inspected after the final cleaning.
(2) Repairs should be performed using the most effective methods available. Since wire splices are more susceptible to degradation, arcing, and overheating, the recommended method of repairing a wire is with an environmentally sealed splice.
d. Indirect Damage. Events such as pneumatic duct ruptures or duct clamp leakage can cause damage that, while not initially evident, can later cause wiring problems. When events such as these occur, surrounding EWIS should be carefully inspected to ensure that there is no damage or potential for damage evident. Indirect damage caused by these types of events could be broken clamps or ties, broken wire insulation, or even broken conductor strands. In some cases, the pressure of the duct rupture could cause wire separation from the connector or terminal strip.
e. Contamination. EWIS contamination refers to either of the following situations: (1) presence of a foreign material that is likely to cause degradation of EWIS or (2) presence of a foreign material that is combustible or capable of sustaining a fire after removal of the ignition source. An EWIS contaminant may be in solid or liquid form.
(1) Solid contaminants. Solid contaminants such as the following can accumulate on wiring and other EWIS components and could degrade or penetrate wiring or other EWIS components.
• Metal shavings/swarf
• Debris
• Livestock waste
• Lint
• Dust
(2) Fluid contaminants. Chemicals in fluids such as the following can contribute to degradation of wiring and other EWIS components.
• Hydraulic fluid
• Battery electrolytes
• Fuel
• Corrosion inhibiting compounds
• Waste system chemicals
• Cleaning agents
• De-icing fluids
• Paint
• Soft drinks
• Coffee
(3) Contaminants requiring special consideration.
(a) Special consideration is required for the following:
• Hydraulic fluids
• De-icing fluids
• Battery electrolyte
(b) These fluids, although essential for airplane operation, can damage EWIS components, such as connector grommets, wire bundle clamps, wire ties, and wire lacing, causing chafing and arcing. EWIS components exposed to these fluids should be given special attention during inspection. Contaminated wire insulation that has visible cracking or breaches to the core conductor can eventually arc and cause a fire. Wiring and other EWIS components exposed to, or in close proximity to, any of the above chemicals may need to be inspected more frequently for damage or degradation.
(c) When cleaning areas or zones of the airplane that contain both wiring and chemical contaminants, special cleaning procedures and precautions may be needed. Such procedures may include wrapping wire connectors and other EWIS components with a protective covering prior to cleaning. This would be especially true if pressure washing equipment is used. In all cases, the airplane manufacturer’s recommended procedures should be followed.
(4) Waste system contamination. Waste system spills also require special attention. Service history has shown that these spills can have detrimental effects on airplane EWIS and have resulted in smoke and fire events. When this type of contamination is found, all affected components in the EWIS should be thoroughly cleaned, inspected, and repaired, or replaced if necessary. The source of the spill or leakage should be located and corrected.
f. Heat. Exposure to high heat can accelerate degradation of EWIS by causing wire insulation dryness and cracking. Direct contact with a high heat source can quickly damage insulation. Burned, charred, or even melted insulation are the most likely indicators of this type of damage. Low levels of heat can also degrade wiring over a longer period of time. This type of degradation is sometimes seen on engines, in galley wiring such as in coffee makers and ovens, and behind fluorescent lights, especially ballasts.
g. Cold. Exposure to extremely cold temperatures, such as those found at a transport category airplane’s typical cruising altitude, or wires exposed to cold temperatures while the airplane is parked in a cold environment, increases the rigidity of wire insulation in those wires that have little or no current flow. Vibration or other types of movement of EWIS during this time could lead to wire faults. This is important to remember when performing maintenance to, or around, these wires in a cold environment. EWIS located outside of the pressurized fuselage, such as those located in landing gear wheel wells, wing leading and trailing edges, and in the horizontal and vertical stabilizers are routinely subjected to these extreme cold temperatures.
14. General EWIS Maintenance Guidance. Areas to be inspected should be clean enough to minimize the possibility that collected dirt, grease, or other contaminants might hide unsatisfactory conditions that would otherwise be detected during inspection. For any cleaning considered necessary, you should use the airplane manufacturer’s procedures or other methods, techniques, and practices acceptable to the FAA. The cleaning process itself should not compromise the integrity of EWIS.
a. Preventing Accumulation of Combustibles. Some applicants may set a numerical limit on the amount of contamination that may accumulate in a zone in order to avoid combustion of the contaminants. Other applicants may choose not to set a numerical limit, but rather give instructions that EWIS be cleaned to significantly remove the amount of combustible material. If an applicant has set a limit, EWIS should be cleaned at frequent enough intervals that the accumulation of combustibles never exceeds this limit. If no limit has been set, EWIS should be cleaned at frequent enough intervals that accumulation of combustibles never reaches unacceptable levels. Determining the interval would involve making an estimate of the rate at which combustible material will accumulate in that particular zone and setting intervals to occur with enough frequency so that unacceptable levels are not reached. If at an inspection the contaminants in a zone have not yet accumulated to the level considered excessive, or to the set level that triggers the need for cleaning, a determination must be made about whether the contaminant accumulation will have exceeded the limit or reached excessive levels before the next inspection. If that is expected to be the case, then the EWIS should be cleaned during the current inspection even though the contaminants have not yet exceeded the accumulation limit or reached excessive levels.
b. Levels of Inspection Applicable to EWIS. Though the term “detailed visual inspection” remains valid for a detailed inspection using only eyesight, this may represent only part of the inspection called for in EWIS ICA used to establish an operator’s maintenance program. We recommend that the acronym “DVI” not be used because that term may exclude tactile examination, which is sometimes needed. Instead, we provide the following definitions. See figures 1 and 2 for examples of EWIS that are contaminated. Such contamination could cause EWIS component degradation and also prevent an effective GVI or DET inspection if it were not cleaned. Additionally, depending on the type and amount present, contaminants may also be combustible and sustain a fire should electrical arcing occur.
Figure 1: EWIS Contaminated with Dust and Dirt
Figure 2: EWIS Contaminated with Grease
(1) Detailed inspection (DET). A DET is an intensive examination of a specific item, installation, or assembly to detect damage, failure, or irregularity. Available lighting is normally supplemented with a direct source of good lighting at an intensity deemed appropriate.
Inspection aids such as mirrors, magnifying lenses, or other means may be necessary. Surface cleaning and elaborate access procedures may be required. A DET can be more than just a visual inspection, since it may include tactile assessment in which a component or assembly is checked for tightness/security. It may require the removal of items such as access panels and drip shields, or the moving of components.
Note: Tactile assessment as used in the context of an EWIS DET does not require the disassembly of wire bundles to inspect individual wires within the bundle.
(2) General visual inspection (GVI). A visual examination of an interior or exterior area, installation, or assembly to detect obvious damage, failure, or irregularity. This level of inspection is made from within touching distance unless otherwise specified. A mirror may be necessary to enhance visual access to all exposed surfaces in the inspection area. This level of inspection is made under normally available lighting conditions such as daylight, hangar lighting, flashlight, or droplight and may require removal or opening of access panels or doors. Stands, ladders, or platforms may be required to gain proximity to the area being checked.
(a) Recent changes to this definition have added proximity guidance (within touching distance) and the allowance of a mirror and flashlight to improve visual access to exposed surfaces when performing a GVI. These changes should result in more consistent application of the GVI. They also support expectations of the types of EWIS discrepancies that should be detected by a GVI.
(b) When performing a GVI, there is usually no need to remove equipment or displace EWIS unless the access instructions specifically call for it.
(c) The area to be inspected should be clean enough to minimize the possibility that collected dirt or grease, or other contaminants, might hide unsatisfactory conditions that would otherwise be obvious. For any cleaning considered necessary, you should use the airplane manufacturer’s procedures or other methods, techniques, and practices acceptable to the FAA. The cleaning process itself should not compromise the integrity of EWIS. Avoid using high pressure cleaning and abrasive materials that could damage wire insulation and other EWIS components.
(d) In general, the person performing a GVI is expected to identify degradation from wear, vibration, moisture, contamination, excessive heat, aging, and so forth, and assess what actions are appropriate to address the discrepancy. This assessment should consider potential effects on adjacent system installations, particularly if those systems include wiring. You should address any observed discrepancies, such as chafing, broken clamps, sagging, interference, contamination, and so forth.
(e) An EWIS stand-alone GVI applies the above inspection techniques to wires, cables, and other EWIS components identified in the inspection procedure.
(3) Zonal inspection. This is a collective term comprising selected GVIs and visual checks that are applied to each zone of the airplane, defined by access and area, to check system and powerplant installations and structure for security and general condition. A zonal inspection is essentially a GVI of an area or zone to detect obvious unsatisfactory conditions and
discrepancies. Unlike a stand-alone GVI, it is not directed to any specified component or assembly.
c. EWIS-Related Guidance for Zonal Inspections. The following EWIS degradation conditions are typical of what should be detectable and addressed as a result of a zonal inspection (as well as a stand-alone GVI). Maintenance and training documentation should include these items. This list is not intended to be all-inclusive and may be expanded as appropriate.
(1) Wire/wire harnesses.
• Wire bundle/wire bundle or wire bundle/structure contact/chafing
• Wire bundles sagging or improperly secured
• Wires damaged (obvious damage because of mechanical impact, overheat, localized chafing, and so forth)
• Lacing tape and/or ties missing/incorrectly installed
• Wiring protection sheath/conduit deformed or incorrectly installed
• End of sheath rubbing on end attachment device
• Grommet missing or damaged
• Dust and lint accumulation
• Surface contamination by metal shavings/swarf
• Contamination by liquids
• Deterioration of previous repairs (for example, splices)
• Deterioration of production splices
• Inappropriate repairs (for example, an incorrect splice)
• Inappropriate attachments to or separation from fluid lines
(2) Connectors.
• External corrosion on receptacles
• Backshell tail broken
• Rubber pad or packing on backshell missing
• No backshell wire securing device
• Foolproofing chain broken
• Safety wire missing or broken
• Discoloration/evidence of overheat on terminal lugs/blocks
• Torque stripe misaligned
(3) Switches.
• Rear protection cap damaged
• Missing hardware (screws, washers, and so forth)
• Loose hardware
• Improper hardware
(4) Ground points.
• Corrosion
• Loose hardware
(5) Bonding braid/bonding jumper.
• Braid broken or disconnected
• Multiple strands corroded
• Multiple strands broken
(6) Wiring clamps or brackets.
• Corroded
• Broken/missing
• Bent or twisted
• Unstuck/detached
• Attachment faulty (bad attachment or fastener missing)
• Protection/cushion damaged
(7) Supports (rails or tubes/conduit).
• Broken
• Deformed
• Fastener missing
• Edge protection on rims of feed-through holes missing
• Racetrack cushion damaged
• Drainage holes (in conduits) obstructed
(8) Circuit breakers, contactors, or relays.
• Signs of overheating
• Signs of arcing
• Missing hardware (screws, washers, and so forth)
• Loose hardware
• Improper hardware
d. Wiring Installations and Areas of Concern. Maintenance material should address the following installations and areas.
(1) Wiring installations.
(a) Clamping points. Damaged clamps, migration of clamp cushions, or improper clamp installations aggravate wire chafing. Airplane manufacturers specify clamp type and part number for EWIS throughout the airplane. When replacing clamps, use those specified by the airplane manufacturer. Tie wraps provide a rapid method of clamping, especially during line maintenance operations. But improperly installed tie wraps can have a detrimental effect on wire insulation. When new wiring is installed as part of an STC or other modification, the drawings will provide wire routing, clamp type and size, and proper location. Examples of significant wiring alterations are the installation of new avionics systems, new galley equipment, and new instrumentation. Wire routing, type of clamp, and clamping location should conform to the approved drawings. Adding new wire to existing wire bundles may overload clamps, causing wire bundles to sag and wires to chafe. Raceway clamp foam cushions may deteriorate with age, fall apart, and thus fail to provide proper clamping.
(b) Connectors. Worn environmental seals, loose connectors, missing seal plugs, missing dummy contacts, or lack of strain relief on connector grommets can compromise connector integrity and allow contamination to enter the connector, leading to corrosion or grommet degradation. Connector pin corrosion can cause overheating, arcing, and pin-to-pin
shorting. Drip loops should be maintained when connectors are below the level of the harness, and tight bends at connectors should be avoided or corrected.
(c) Terminations. Terminations, such as terminal lugs and terminal blocks, are susceptible to mechanical damage, corrosion, heat damage, and contamination from chemicals, dust, and dirt. Over time, vibration can cause high-current-carrying feeder cable terminal lugs to lose their original torque value, resulting in arcing. One sign of this is heat discoloration at the terminal end. Proper build-up and nut torque is especially critical on high-current-carrying feeder cable lugs. Corrosion on terminal lugs and blocks can cause high resistance and overheating. Dust, dirt, and other debris are combustible and could sustain a fire if ignited from an overheated or arcing terminal lug. Terminal blocks and terminal strips located in equipment power centers (EPC), avionics compartments, and throughout the airplane need to be kept clean and free of combustibles.
(d) Backshells. Wires may break at backshells from excessive flexing, lack of strain relief, or improper build-up. Loss of backshell bonding may also occur because of these and other factors.
(e) Sleeving and conduits. Damage to sleeving and conduits, if not corrected, may lead to wire damage. So damage such as cuts, dents, and creases on conduits may require further investigation for condition of wiring within.
(f) Grounding points. You should check grounding points for security (in other words, finger tightness), condition of the termination, presence of corrosion, and cleanliness. Grounding points that are corroded or have lost their protective coating should be repaired.
(g) Splices. Both sealed and non-sealed splices are susceptible to vibration, mechanical damage, corrosion, heat damage, chemical contamination, and environmental deterioration. Power feeder cables normally carry high current levels and are very susceptible to installation error and splice degradation. All splices should conform to the TC or STC holder’s published recommendations. In the absence of published recommendations, we recommend use of environmentally sealed splices.
(2) Areas of concern.
(a) Wire raceways and bundles. Adding wires to existing wire raceways may cause undue wear and chafing of the wire installation and inability to maintain the wire in the raceway. Adding wire to existing bundles may cause wire to sag against the structure, which can cause chafing.
(b) Wings. Wing leading and trailing edges are difficult environments for wiring installations. On some airplane models, wing leading and trailing edge wiring is exposed whenever the flaps or slats are extended. Slat torque shafts and bleed air ducts in these areas are other potential damage sources.
(c) Engine, pylon, and nacelle area. These areas experience high vibration, heat, and frequent maintenance, and they are susceptible to chemical contamination.
(d) Accessory compartment and equipment bays. These areas typically contain items such as electrical components, pneumatic components and ducting, and hydraulic components and plumbing. They may be susceptible to vibration, heat, and liquid contamination.
(e) Auxiliary power unit (APU). Like the engine/nacelle area, the APU is susceptible to high vibration, heat, frequent maintenance, and chemical contamination.
(f) Landing gear and wheel wells. This area is exposed to severe external environmental conditions in addition to vibration and chemical contamination.
(g) Electrical panels and line replaceable units (LRUs). Electrical panel wiring is particularly prone to broken wires and damaged insulation when these high density areas are disturbed during troubleshooting activities, alterations, and refurbishments. Tying wiring to wooden dowels to reduce its disturbance during modification can minimize wire damage. For some configurations, use of connector support brackets would be more desirable and cause less wire disturbance than removal of individual connectors from the supports.
(h) Batteries. Wires and other EWIS components in the vicinity of all airplane batteries are susceptible to corrosion and discoloration and should be inspected for those problems. You should inspect discolored wires and other EWIS components for serviceability.
(i) Power feeders. High-current wiring and associated connections have the potential to generate intense heat. Vibration may cause degradation or loosening of power feeder cables, terminals, and splices. If signs of overheating are seen, splices or termination should be replaced. For both galley and engine/APU generator power feeders, depending on the design, service experience may indicate a need for periodic checks of proper torque on power feeder cable terminal ends, especially in high vibration areas.
(j) Under galleys, lavatories, and cockpit. Areas under the galleys, lavatories, and cockpit are particularly susceptible to contamination from such things as coffee, food, water, soft drinks, lavatory fluids, dust, and lint. Proper floor panel sealing procedures can minimize such contamination in these areas.
(k) Fluid drain plumbing. Leaks from fluid drain plumbing could lead to liquid contamination of EWIS. Service experience may show a need for periodic leak checks or cleaning, in addition to routine visual inspections.
(l) Fuselage drain provisions. Some installations include plumbing features designed to catch leakage and drain it to an appropriate exit. Blockage of the drain path can result in liquid contamination of EWIS. In addition to routine visual inspections, service experience may signal a need to check these installations and associated plumbing periodically to ensure the drain path is free of obstructions.
(m) Cargo bay underfloor. Damage to EWIS in the cargo bay underfloor can occur from maintenance activities in the area.
(n) EWIS subject to movement. Wiring and other EWIS components that are subject to movement or bending during normal operation or maintenance access, at locations such as doors, actuators, landing gear mechanisms, and electrical access panels, should be inspected at those areas where movement occurs.
(o) Access panels. EWIS near access panels could be accidentally damaged from repetitive maintenance access and may warrant special attention.
(p) Under doors. Areas under cargo, passenger, and service entry doors are susceptible to fluid entering from rain, snow, and liquid spills. Fluid drain provisions and floor panel sealing in these areas should be periodically inspected and repaired as necessary.
(q) Under cockpit sliding windows. Areas under cockpit sliding windows are susceptible to water entering from rain and snow. Fluid drain provisions in these areas should be periodically inspected and repaired as necessary.
(r) Areas where EWIS is difficult to access. Areas difficult to access, such as flight deck instrument panels and the cockpit pedestal area, could accumulate excessive dust and other contaminants because of infrequent cleaning. In these areas, it may be necessary to remove components and disassemble other systems to facilitate access to the area.
15. Protection and Caution Recommendations. Section 43.13(b) requires anyone performing maintenance or alteration to do the work “. . . in such a manner and use materials of such a quality that the condition of the aircraft, airframe, aircraft engine, propeller, or appliance worked on will be at least equal to its original or properly altered condition (with regard to aerodynamic function, structural strength, resistance to vibration and deterioration, and other qualities affecting airworthiness). Anyone performing maintenance must use methods, techniques, and practices prescribed in the manufacturer’s current maintenance manual or in ICA prepared by the manufacturer, or methods, techniques, and practices referred to in § 43.13(a) as acceptable to the FAA Administrator. Protection and caution recommendations, while not required as part of the EZAP process discussed in this AC, are required by paragraph H25.5(a)(1)(vi) of appendix H to part 25. They are an important part of the “protect and clean as you go” philosophy, which contributes to preserving the integrity of EWIS.
Some practices in use today may actually compromise the integrity of EWIS, albeit inadvertently. Therefore, we have identified some specific maintenance and servicing tasks and recommend that air carriers and air operators adopt these more robust practices. Such information may be provided in manufacturer and operator training programs, on job/task cards, or any other documents that the manufacturer or operator use in the administration of their maintenance programs. These maintenance practices will help prevent inadvertent contamination of EWIS with harmful solids (such as metal shavings) or fluids during maintenance, alteration, and repair of airplane structures and components. Training of maintenance and servicing personnel should address potential consequences of their actions to wiring in the work area. AC 120-94, Aircraft Electrical Wiring Interconnection Systems Training Program, provides details of EWIS training that could be adopted by air carriers and air operators.
a. Installation, Repair, or Modification of EWIS. Wiring and other EWIS components (for example, protective coverings, connectors, clamping provisions, and conduits) often comprise the most vulnerable and maintenance-sensitive portions of an installation or system. Extreme care and proper procedures should be used during installation, repair, or modification of EWIS components to ensure safe and reliable performance of the EWIS function.
(1) Proper EWIS component selection, routing/separation, clamping configurations, use of splices, repair or replacement of protective coverings, pinning/de-pinning of connections, and so forth, should be performed in accordance with the applicable sections of the AMM, SWPM/ESPM, or other manufacturer’s maintenance documents or in accordance with the operator’s approved maintenance program.
(2) You should take special care to minimize disturbance of existing adjacent wiring and other EWIS components during maintenance activities. When EWIS is displaced during a maintenance activity, special attention should be given to returning it to its normal configuration in accordance with the applicable maintenance instructions.
b. Structural Repairs and STCs. Structural repairs and STC installations inevitably introduce tooling and residual debris that is harmful to airplane wiring and other EWIS components. They often require displacement or removal of EWIS to provide access to the work area. Even minor displacement of wiring, especially while clamped, can damage its insulation and result in degraded performance, leading to subsequent arcing or circuit failure.
(1) Use extreme care to protect EWIS from mechanical damage by tools or other equipment during structural repairs, installation of STCs, and repairs or alterations. Avoid drilling blindly into the airplane structure. Damage to wire insulation could cause arcing, fire, and smoke. Carefully cover or displace EWIS located adjacent to drilling or riveting operations to reduce the possibility of mechanical damage.
(2) Do not allow debris such as drill shavings, liberated fastener pieces, broken drill bits, and so forth, to contaminate or penetrate wiring, other EWIS components, or electrical components. This can cause damage to insulation and potential arcing by providing a conductive path to ground or a conductive path between two or more wires of different loads. Once wire bundles and other EWIS components are contaminated with this type of debris, it is extremely difficult to remove it. So take precautions to prevent contamination of any kind from entering the wire bundle.
(3) Before beginning structural repair work and STC installation, survey the work area carefully to identify all EWIS and electrical components that may be subject to contamination. EWIS and electrical components in the debris field should be covered or removed. Drills equipped with vacuum aspiration can be used to minimize risk of metallic debris contaminating wire bundles or other EWIS components. When work is completed, clean electrical components, wiring, and other EWIS components in accordance with the applicable maintenance instructions.
c. Airplane De-Icing or Anti-Icing. Exercise care when spraying de-/anti-icing fluids to prevent damage to exposed electrical components and EWIS in areas such as wing leading and
trailing edges, wheel wells, and landing gear. Direct pressure spray onto electrical and EWIS components can lead to contamination or degradation, and it should be avoided.
d. Inclement Weather. EWIS in areas below doorways, floors, access panels, and servicing bays are prone to corrosion or contamination from exposure to the elements. Snow, slush, or excessive moisture should be removed from these areas before closing doors or panels. Before loading items into the airplane (for example, cargo containers), remove deposits of snow or slush. Keep doors/panels closed as much as possible during inclement weather to prevent ingress of snow, slush, or excessive moisture.
e. Component Removal/Installation (Relating to Attached EWIS).
(1) Excessive component handling and movement during installation and removal may harm EWIS. Use appropriate connector pliers (for example, soft jawed) to loosen coupling rings that are too tight to be loosened by hand. Alternately pull on the plug body and unscrew the coupling ring until the connector is separated. Do not use excessive force and do not pull on attached wires. When reconnecting, take special care to ensure the connector body is fully seated, the jam nut is fully secured, and no tension is on the wires.
(2) When equipment is disconnected, use protective caps on all connectors (plug or receptacle) to prevent contamination or damage of the contacts. Sleeves or plastic bags may be used if protective caps are not available. Use of sleeves or plastic bags should be temporary because of the risk of condensation. Use of a humidity absorber is recommended with sleeves or plastic bags.
f. Pressure Washing. Exercise care when spraying water or cleaning fluids to prevent damage to exposed electrical components and EWIS in areas such as wing leading and trailing edges, wheel wells, and landing gear. Avoid direct high-pressure spray onto electrical components and EWIS. It can lead to contamination or degradation. When practical, protect EWIS components (for example, wiring and connectors) before pressure washing. Use water rinse to remove cleaning solution residue after washing. Breakdown of wire insulation or material used in other EWIS components may occur with long-term exposure of EWIS components to cleaning solutions. Although these recommendations are good practice and technique, consult the AMM or STC holder’s instructions for additional detailed instructions about pressure washing.
g. Cleaning of EWIS (In Situ). Exercise extreme care and use proper procedures when cleaning to ensure safe and reliable performance of the function supplied by EWIS. Although these recommendations for cleaning of EWIS are considered good practice and technique, consult the AMM or STC holder’s instructions for additional detailed instructions.
(1) Avoid displacing or disturbing EWIS during cleaning of non-aggressive contamination, such as dust, dirt, or swarf. Displacement may be necessary for aggressive contaminants (for example, livestock waste, salt water, battery electrolyte). In those cases, release wiring from its installation in a way that avoids placing undue stress on the wiring connectors and wire bundle support devices. If liquid contamination enters the bundle, remove ties before separating wires.
(2) Clean only contaminated areas and items. Before cleaning, make sure that the cleaning materials and methods will not cause more contamination. Make sure cloths used are clean, dry, and lint-free. Connectors should be completely dry before mating. Fluids left on connectors can have a deteriorating effect on the connector or the system or both.
h. Servicing or Repairing Waste/Water Systems. EWIS in areas adjacent to waste/water systems are prone to contamination from those systems. Use care to prevent fluids from reaching EWIS components while servicing or repairing waste/water systems, and cover exposed EWIS components while working. Operator practice may call for a weak acid solution to be periodically flushed through lavatory systems to improve reliability and efficiency of operation. Because of the effect of acid contamination on systems and structure, confirm that the system is free of leaks before using such solutions.
i. Servicing or Repairing Oil Systems. EWIS in areas adjacent to oil systems are prone to contamination from those systems. Oil and debris in combination with damaged wiring can present a fire hazard. To minimize the attraction and adhesion of foreign material, use care to prevent fluids from reaching EWIS components while servicing or repairing oil systems.
j. Servicing or Repairing Hydraulic Systems. EWIS in areas adjacent to hydraulic systems are prone to contamination from those systems. To minimize the attraction and adhesion of foreign material, use care to prevent fluids from reaching EWIS components while servicing or repairing hydraulic systems.
k. Gaining Access (Entering Zones). When entering the airplane or working on it, use care to prevent damage to adjacent EWIS components, including wiring or other EWIS components that may be hidden from view (for example, covered by insulation blankets). Use protective boards or platforms for adequate support and protection. Avoid using wire bundles as handholds, steps, and supports. Do not use wiring to hang or support work lights. If wiring must be displaced or removed for work area access, it should be adequately released from its clamping or other restraining provisions to allow movement without damage, and it should be returned to position after work is completed.
l. Applying Corrosion Prevention Compounds (CPC). When applying CPC in airplane zones containing EWIS, use care to prevent CPC from contacting it. Dust and lint are more likely to collect on wire that has CPC on it. Apply CPCs according to the airplane manufacturer’s maintenance instructions.
/s/
Ali Bahrami Manager, Transport Airplane Directorate Aircraft Certification Service
05/04/10 AC 25-27A Appendices
Appendices
Appendix A. The Enhanced Zonal Analysis Procedure (EZAP)
Appendix A. The Enhanced Zonal Analysis Procedure (EZAP)
Appendix B. Evaluating Whether a Design Change Impacts Previously Approved EWIS ICA
and Developing any Necessary New or Revised EWIS ICA as Required by § 26.11(c) or § 25.1729
Appendix C. Definitions
Appendix D. FAA Oversight Offices for the Purposes of Part 26
Appendix E. Applicable Regulations and Relevant Preamble Discussion
Appendix E. Applicable Regulations and Relevant Preamble Discussion
Appendix F. Background
Appendix G. Related Regulations and Documents
Appendix H. EZAP Worksheets for Use by Applicants
05/04/10 AC 25-27A Appendix A
Appendix A
1. The Enhanced Zonal Analysis Procedure (EZAP). The figures and explanations on the following pages describe the EZAP process. Before you begin using this logic, you should be thoroughly familiar with the contents and philosophy of this AC and the results the AC and the EZAP seek to achieve.
Appendix A
Figure 1
Enhanced Zonal Analysis
Procedure
Identify aircraft zones, Including boundaries
list details of zone, for example:
• Access Installed equipment Lightning/HIRF protection features EWIS installation Possible combustible materials
~------YE'S----------<
YES
Define the task and assign an Interval for
performing it
CONTINUE THE
CONTINUE THE
ANALYSIS
• STAND-ALONE GVI • DET , Cleaning (Restoration) • Any other tasks identified as applicable and effective to maintain EWIS safety
Assign task to EWIS ICA malnlenance program systems and
powerplant section
Recommend inclusion in ATA 20
Is wiring or other EWIS
components close (2 ln/50 mm) to both primary and backup
hydraulic, mechanical, or
electrical flight controls?
Select EWIS Inspection
level and interval
INSPECTION TASK(S)
INSPECTION TASK(S)
Consider consolidation with existing
Inspection tasks In systems and powerplant and/or zonal programs •
NO
NO-+
No further analysis is required
for the zone. An Inspection or restoration task applicable to EWIS is not
necessary for the zone.
GVI CONSOLIDATED
IN ZONAL INSPECTION
IN ZONAL INSPECTION
• Section 26.11(b) requires EWIS ICA and fuel tank system ICA developed to comply with SFAR 88 be compatible and any redundancies between them minimized.
Assign task to EWIS ICA Maintenance program zonal section
Airplanes with ZIPs … ,,
05/04/10 AC 25-27A Appendix A
From frgure 1, step 8
NO
Using rating tables, assess zone attributes to detennlne
appropriate level of inspection
(examples provided in appendix B of this AC)
PROGRAMS WITH ZONAL
PROGRAMS WITH ZONAL
INSPECTION PROGRAM PROGRAMS WITHOUT ZONAi
INSPECTION PROGRAM
List zone descriptio_n and
boundaries for zonal GVI
Define specific EWIS in the
zone for which stand-alone
GVI Is Justified
NO
Figure 2
Step 8-
EWIS Inspection Level
and Interval Selection
List zone description and
INSPECTION PROGRAM
boundaries for GVI of all EWIS
In the zone
Define specific EWIS in the
zone for which GVI at more
frequent Interval Is Justified
Zonal GVI must be augmented Some EWIS requires GVl at
with stand-alone GVI and/or I '7
OET inspection
Define specific EWIS in the
wne for which OET Is Justlfted
more frequent Interval and/or 1-----'-~
OET inspection
Define specific EWIS in the
zone for which OET Is Justlfted
Using rating tables, assess likelihood of damage to EWIS in the
zone to determine an appropriate interval for each inspection
task Identified (example provided In appendix B of this AC)
05/04/10 AC 25-27A Appendix A
05/04/10 AC 25-27A Appendix A
2. Explanation for Steps in EZAP Logic Diagrams. The following paragraphs provide further explanation of each step in the enhanced zonal analysis procedure (EZAP) logic (figures 1 and 2 of this appendix). If you are developing EWIS ICA because you are required to do so by § 26.11(b), then you must use the “representative airplane” as required by that section. (See paragraph 2c of this AC.) All applicants should, whenever possible, verify the results of the analysis using an actual aircraft (typical airplane that has not been cleaned) to ensure that they fully understand the zones being analyzed. Using an actual airplane will help in determining density, size, types and levels of contaminants or combustible materials, and environmental and accidental damage issues for each zone.
STEP 1: Identify aircraft zones, including boundaries.
According to Air Transport Association (ATA) iSpec 2200, Information Standards for Aviation Maintenance, zones are identified by the airplane manufacturer “to facilitate maintenance, planning, preparation of job instructions, location of work areas and components, and a common basis for various maintenance tasks.” ATA iSpec 2200 contains guidelines for determining airplane zones and their numbering. The EZAP process uses these manufacturer-identified zones. The zones are not created uniquely for EZAP.
However, if the design approval holder or operator has not already established aircraft zones, we recommend that this be done. Wherever possible, the definition of zones should follow a consistent method such as ATA iSpec 2200 (formerly ATA Spec 100), varied only to accommodate particular design constructional differences.
Define the zones, wherever possible, by actual physical boundaries such as wing spars, major bulkheads, cabin floor, control surface boundaries, skin, and so forth, and include access provisions for each zone.
STEP 2: List details of zone.
Within the zone, identify system installations, significant components, lightning and high intensity radiated field (L/HIRF) protection features, typical power levels in any installed wiring bundles, combustible materials (present or with the potential for accumulation) and any other features that may affect EWIS integrity or accumulation of combustibles.
With respect to power levels, the person performing the EZAP analysis should know whether the wire bundle consists primarily of main generator feeder cables, low voltage instrumentation wiring, or standard bus wiring. This information will be used in determining potential effects of deterioration.
Identify any locations where both primary and back-up flight controls are routed within 2 inches/50 mm of a wiring harness or other EWIS components. This information is required to answer the question in step 7.
STEP 3: Does zone contain EWIS? This question eliminates from the EZAP those zones that do not contain EWIS.
05/04/10 AC 25-27A Appendix A
STEP 4: Are there, or are there likely to be, combustible materials in zone? This question requires evaluating whether the zone might contain combustible material that could cause a fire to be sustained in the event of an ignition source arising in adjacent wiring. Examples include the presence of fuel vapors, dust/lint accumulation, and contaminated insulation blankets.
• With respect to commonly used liquids (for example, oils, hydraulic fluids, and corrosion prevention compounds) refer to the product specification to assess potential for combustibility. The product may be readily combustible only in vapor mist form. If so, an assessment is required to determine if conditions might exist in the zone for the product to be in this state. You should consider hydraulic fluid to be combustible in a mist form even if the product specification states that it is not combustible in its liquid state.
• Liquid contamination of wiring by most synthetic oil and hydraulic fluids (for example, skydrol) may not be considered combustible. It is a concern, however, if it occurs in a zone where dust and lint are present, because wet or oily surfaces attract dust and lint.
Assess what sources of combustible products may contaminate the zone following any single failure considered likely from in-service experience. For example, consider unshrouded pipes with connections within the zone to be potential contamination sources. Forced air ventilation in a zone tends to blow dust and lint through the air, causing it to lodge on the surfaces of wiring and other EWIS components. Wet or oily surfaces attract more dust and lint. This needs to be considered when you are assessing the possibility of a buildup of combustibles in the zone.
• Avionics and instruments located in the flight compartment and equipment bays tend to attract dust, dirt, and other contamination. Because of the heat generated by these components and their relatively tightly packed installations, you should consider that these zones have the potential for accumulating combustible material. Forced air ventilation is often used in these areas, causing lint and dust to be blown about the area and often resulting in a buildup of dust and lint on the surfaces of wiring and other EWIS components. Always use the EZAP logic for these zones. For flight compartment and equipment bays, the answer to the question in step 4 should be “yes.”
Although moisture (whether clean water or otherwise) is not combustible, its presence on wiring, or other current carrying EWIS components increases the probability of arcing from small breaches in the insulation. This could cause a localized fire in the wire bundle. The fire could spread if there are combustibles in close proximity. The risk of a sustained fire caused by moisture-induced arcing is mitigated in step 5 by identifying a task to reduce the likelihood of accumulation of combustible material on or adjacent to the wiring and other EWIS components.
STEP 5: Is there an effective task to significantly reduce the likelihood of accumulation of combustible materials? Most operator maintenance programs have not included tasks directed towards removing combustible materials from EWIS components or adjacent areas or preventing their accumulation. Evaluate whether accumulation on or adjacent to the EWIS can be significantly reduced.
Though restoration tasks such as cleaning are the most likely applicable tasks, the possibility of identifying other tasks is not eliminated. For example, a detailed inspection of a hydraulic pipe
05/04/10 AC 25-27A Appendix A
might be appropriate if high-pressure mist from pinhole corrosion could impinge a wire bundle and the inherent zone ventilation is low. Task effectiveness criteria should include considering the potential for damaging EWIS components.
STEP 6: Define the task and assign an interval for performing it.
This step will define an applicable EWIS ICA task to reduce accumulation of combustible materials and an effective interval for performing that task. The defined task should be included as a dedicated task in the systems and powerplant section of the maintenance program. Within maintenance review board reports (MRBRs), it may be introduced under the standard practices section (ATA chapter 20 of the MRBR) with no failure effect category assigned.
Restoration tasks should not be so aggressive that they damage wiring, but should be performed at a level that significantly reduces the likelihood of combustion.
STEP 7: Is wiring close to both primary and backup hydraulic, mechanical, or electrical flight controls? This question is asked to ensure that step 8 logic is applied where wiring is close (in other words, within 2 inches/50 mm) to both primary and backup hydraulic, mechanical, or electrical flight controls, even in the absence of combustible materials in the zone.
For zones where combustible materials are present (as determined in step 4), proximity is addressed in the inspection level definition portion of step 8, and this question need not be asked.
This step addresses the concern that segregation between primary and back-up flight controls may not have been consistently achieved. Even in the absence of combustible material, a localized wire arcing could prevent continued safe flight and landing if hydraulic pipes, mechanical cables, or wiring for fly-by-wire controls are routed in close proximity (within 2 inches/50 mm) to a wiring harness. In consideration of the redundancy in flight control systems, this question should be answered “yes” if both the primary and back-up system might be affected by wire arcing.
On all aircraft type designs, regardless of TC date, alterations performed by an STC holder or a field-approved repair or alteration may not have taken into account the TC holder’s design criteria. We recommend that STC holders assess whether their design changes route wires within 2 inches or 50 mm of both primary and back-up hydraulic, mechanical, or electrical flight control cables and lines. Similarly, air carriers and air operators should assess any field-approved repairs or alterations or other modifications that have been made to their airplanes to identify any added or altered wiring that may be close to flight control cable and lines.
STEP 8: Select EWIS inspection level and interval (Figure 2).
a. Inspection Level. At this point in the analysis, it is already confirmed that EWIS is installed in a zone where the presence of combustible materials is possible and/or the wiring is in close proximity to primary and backup hydraulic or mechanical flight controls. Therefore, some level of inspection of the EWIS in the zone is required. This step details how to select the proper level of inspection and interval.
05/04/10 AC 25-27A Appendix A
The inspection level and its interval are determined by using ratings tables, which rate characteristics of the zone and how the EWIS is affected by, or can affect, those attributes. The type of inspection is determined by using the rating tables of EZAP Worksheet 3A (or 3B for airplane models without a dedicated zonal inspection program (ZIP)), whereas the interval for performing the inspection is determined using the rating tables of EZAP Worksheet 4.
Worksheets 3A and 3B use zone size, zone density, and the potential effect of fire in the zone to determine the type of inspection that is necessary.
• Zone size—Zone size determination is based on comparing all the zones in a given airplane model and assessing them in relation to each other. For the purposes of the EZAP analysis, zone sizes are identified as small, medium, or large. For example, the aft cargo bay on a large transport category airplane would be considered a large zone, but the radome on the same airplane would be considered a small zone. The smaller the zone and the less congested it is, the more likely it is that wiring degradation will be identified by a general visual inspection (GVI).
• Zone density—The density of installed equipment, including wiring and other EWIS components, within the zone is assessed in relation to the size of the zone. For the purposes of the EZAP analysis, zone density is identified as low, medium, or high. Typical factors to consider are the number of components, their relative closeness to one another, and the complexity of these components (for example, multiple electrical, mechanical, or hydraulic connections). For example, the electrical and electronics compartment located in the forward nose section, below the flight deck of most large transport category airplanes, could be considered a high density zone. This is because the relatively small physical area is crowded with avionics equipment and a large number of wires and other EWIS components. An example of a low density zone on some airplanes is the cargo compartment (as defined by the cargo compartment walls and forward and rear bulkheads). Although this is a large zone relative to other zones on the airplane, it has relatively few systems or EWIS components installed in it.
• Potential effects of fire on adjacent EWIS or systems—This question should be answered from the point of view that a fire has occurred. So the question to be answered is what is the effect on the safe operation of the airplane should a fire occur. This assessment should include consideration of the potential for loss of multiple functions and the resulting effect on continued safe operation of the airplane. The presence of flammable fluids should also be considered, although design features such as shrouds over the fuel line can be considered to mitigate the likelihood that the fuel will be a source of fuel for a fire. Base the determination of potential effects of a fire on adjacent wiring and systems on knowledge of what airplane systems are in the area under analysis (in other words, what is in the zone) and how loss or degradation of these systems could affect safe operation. The rating system developed should take these potential effects into account.
If a zone does not have mitigating design features that would reduce the adverse effects of a fire, then the potential effects of a fire should be rated higher (for example,
05/04/10 AC 25-27A Appendix A
medium or high). Credit for fire mitigation capability can be given to zones that contain a fire detection and suppression system, or a zone that is designated a “fire zone.” Potential effects of a fire in such zones could then possibly be rated at a lower level. Consideration can also be given to whether the fire could be easily detected by crewmembers or passengers and to whether, if there was a fire, it could be extinguished or controlled by available means. Fire can result in severe outcomes, such as wire-to-structure or wire-to-wire shorting and arcing, in areas such as the cockpit, electrical power centers, and those that contain power feeder cables, which are subject to chafing, if they have flammable materials close by. A fire in these areas could present a high risk to continued safe flight and landing.
Potential effects of fire must also be considered when wiring is in close proximity (within 2 inches/50 mm) to both primary and backup flight controls. A GVI alone may not be adequate if a fire caused by failure of the wiring poses a risk to aircraft controllability.
At minimum, all EWIS in the zone will require a GVI at a common interval. For operators with a ZIP, this may be defined as a zonal GVI. For operators without a ZIP, it is a GVI of all EWIS in the zone.
The logic in figure 2 begins by asking a question:
• For airplane models with a ZIP, the logic asks: “Is zonal GVI alone effective for all EWIS in the zone?”
• For airplane models without a ZIP, the logic asks: “Is a GVI of all EWIS in the zone at the same interval effective for all EWIS in the zone?”
This step calls for consideration of whether there are specific items or areas in the zone that are more vulnerable to damage or contamination than others and thus may warrant a closer or more frequent inspection.
Such a determination could result in selection of a more frequent GVI, a stand-alone GVI (for operators with a zonal inspection program), or even a detailed inspection (DET). The intent is to select a DET of EWIS only when it is determined that a GVI will not be adequate. The person performing the EZAP should avoid unnecessarily selecting DET where a stand-alone GVI is adequate. Over-use of DET dilutes the effectiveness of the inspection.
The level of inspection required may be influenced by tasks identified in step 5 and step 6. For example, if you have selected a cleaning task in step 5 and step 6 that will minimize accumulation of combustible materials in the zone, this may justify selecting a stand-alone GVI instead of a DET for the wiring in the zone.
b. Selecting an Inspection Interval. The inspection interval is determined by using a rating system that rates the likelihood of accidental damage and the hostility of environmental factors.
05/04/10 AC 25-27A Appendix A
The rating tables are designed to define increasing inspection frequency based on increasing risk of accidental damage and increasing severity of the local environment within the zone. Refer to EZAP Worksheet 4 in this appendix.
The example “Interval Determination” table on EZAP Worksheet 4 provides a range of intervals you can choose from. Please note that these intervals are only an example. The particular intervals chosen should be compatible with the interval framework used in the existing maintenance or inspection program as detailed in the current MRBR. Your choice of interval should be based on the reasons for assigning specific rating values for hostility of environment and likelihood of accidental damage. You should also use your knowledge of the types of EWIS components to be inspected.
As an example, for a hostility of environment rating of 3 and a likelihood of accidental damage rating of 3, the table gives a range of inspection intervals. It says that the inspection should occur as frequently as every A check but the interval could be as long as once every 1C check. You should base your choice on the reasons that a 3 rating was assigned.
• The importance of assessing likelihood of accidental damage is that the higher the likelihood of accidental damage from multiple sources, the more frequent the inspection task should be. If, on the other hand, all of the factors except one have been rated as a 1, then the inspection interval could be somewhat longer.
• The choice of the inspection interval should also be based on what type of environment the EWIS is located in. Just as with the ratings for likelihood of accidental damage, the more the EWIS is exposed to various harsh environmental conditions, the more frequent the inspection interval should be. You should consider the assigned ratings from both of these tables—“Hostility of Environment” and “Likelihood of Accidental Damage”—and use sound maintenance judgment to assign the inspection task interval.
The selection of inspection tasks possible in this step is specific to whether the maintenance program includes a zonal inspection program (ZIP) or not.
For ZIP programs, the possible inspection tasks are:
• Zonal GVI
• Stand-alone GVI
• DET
For non-ZIP programs, the possible inspection tasks are:
• GVI
• DET
At the conclusion of this step you will have determined the required inspection level and interval for wiring in the zone. Task consolidation in step 9 allows consideration of whether
05/04/10 AC 25-27A Appendix A
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 286 passages shown