AC 21-9A Manufacturers Reporting Failures, Malfunctions, or Defects
Text changed: 1 of 8 passages.
- Date
- Nov 18, 2026
- Recorded
- Nov 18, 2026
- Passages
- 1 of 8 changed
- Paragraphs
- 1 added or rewritten, 0 removed or rewritten
Read the current text Official source ↗
What changed in the text
Key: [removed: removed words] are struck through; [added: added words] are underlined. Each changed paragraph is labelled in the margin.
- 30 unchanged paragraphs
d. FAR 21.3 is directed to those deficiencies in the product that mly the manufacturers w i l d normally be expected to kmw (i.e., a design ar a quality control deficiency ) . m e deficiency that caused the occurrence is required to be reported under FAR 21.3(a).
/""" M. C . Beard Director of Airworthiness
- Added
[added: A.]
Whole text before this change
ADVISORY CIRCULAR
DEPARTMEAT OF TRANSPORTATION
Federal Aviation Adminbtration
Wuhington, D.C.
FAR GUIDANCE MATERIAL
1. P'URPOSE. This circular provides information to assist manufacturers of aeronautical products (aircraft, a i r c r a f t engines, propellers, appliances, and parts) i n notifying the Federal Aviation Pdministration (FAA) of certain
failures, malfunctions, or defects, resulting from design or quality mtrol problems, in the products which they manufacture.
2. CANCELLATION. AC 21-9, Manufacturers &porting Failures, Malfunctions, or /"""' Defects, dated Decaber 30, 1970.
3. RELATED FEDERAL AVIATIm REGUIATIONS. Federal Aviation Fegulations Parts 21, 121, 127, and 135.
4 . DISCUSSICN .
a. FAR 21.3 requires the holder of a type m r t i f i c a t e (TC) (including a suppleroental type certificate (STC)), or a parts manufacturer approval (PMA), or a technical standard order (TSO) authorization, or the licensee of a type
c e r t i f i c a t e to notify the FAA of any failure, malfunction, or defect in their prcduct or part that they determine has resulted in any me of the occurrences specified i n t h i s rule. In addition, they must m t i f y the F'AA of any defective product or part that has l e f t their quality control system and vhich they determine could result in any one of the occurrences specif id in t h i s rule.
It is expected that compliance with FAR 21.3 w i l l provide the earliest possible notification to the FAA o f a hazardous condition, and that appropriate corrective action w i l l be initiated by the manufacturer.
be It is recognized that a manufacturer may choose to report an item prior to carpletion of h i s investigation to assure that the PAR is properly
informed of the probler,. However, the manufacturer need not report until he has determined that a deficiency does exist. The method and manner of reporting may be i n accordance with systems and procedures already established by the manufacturer, i f that system provides for imnediate identification of t h e items noted in FAR 21.3(c) .
- -- Initiated by: AW-200 .
c. Ihe subject rule does not apply ti the notification of a defect which the manufacturer becomes aware of during the normal manufacturing cycle of a product or a r t i c l e unless l i k e products or articles have l e f t his quality control system. I f the product or article is readily retrievable by the manufacturer , i .e . , under his defined quality mntrol system, then mt i f ication is not necessary. It is suggested that manufacturers review their quality control system to assure that the limits of the system are d e a r l y defined.
5. N(JTIFICAT1ON PXCEDURES. It is r e m e n d e d that each manufacturer amtact the appropriate aircraft certification office to:
a. Ensure an understanding of the rules;
b. Establish the most expeditious means of wnveying the mired information; (It is anticipated that telephone mtification w i l l be used in the majority of cases.)
c. Determine the person(s) to be contacted:
d. Establish a means of keeping the appropriate FAA office informed of progress and additional information on those cases where m l y preliminary
information has been reported.
6. APPLICABILITY TO FOREIGN MANUFACTURERS. The reporting rules cb mt apply to foreian manufacturers whose ~ r c d u c t s or articles have been approved under - - t h e appl~cable import certification provisions of FAR Part 21. Under the provisions of the bilateral a i m r t h i n e s s agreements the United States has
concluded with various foreign countries, the FAA relies on the c i v i l a i r authorities of those countries to keep it informed of hazardous a n d i t i o n s occurring in these products or articles.
7. GUIDANCE RELATIVE TO REFOFITING. FAR 2 1 .3 (d ) speaks to those a n d i t ions under which reports are not required.
a. The requirements under FAR 21.3(a) do not apply if it is determined by the holder that the failure, malfunction, or defect was caused by impmper maintenance or improper usage as noted in FAR 21.3(d)(i). ?his excludes those itm that are a result of causes other than design ar quality w n t r o l problem. Fbr e x q l e , i f a part failed and resulted in one of the occurrences noted i n FAR 21 .3(c) and it is found the failure is due to a barn part caused by improper maintenance, the failure need mt be reported. However, if the part was found t o f a i l because of design or a quality mntrol deficiency, the holder mst report the item. An engine f i r e from a fuel line failure due b an overtorqued cracked "B" nut during maintenance would not be reported; a "B" nut which cracked due to overtorquing when torqued in acmrdance w i t h design or manufacturer's instructions would be reported.
b. A s noted in the rule, the holder of a type certificate (including a supplemental type e r t i f i c a t e ) , or a parts manufacturer approval, or TSO authorization, or the licensee of a type certificate is responsible for reporting the failures, malfunctions, or defects in their products or parts resulting in the occurrences specified in FAR 21.3(c). However, i f an operator
* C experiences an engine shutdown during flight and external damage to the engine or airplane structure occurs as a result of the engine shutdown this hould be reported under either FAR Parts 121, 127, or 135. The engine TC holder is rot required to report under FAR 21.3(a) if the engine TC holder kmws the failure was reported by another person under FAR Parts 121, 127, or 135 or that it has been reported under the accident reporting provisions of Part 830 of the WrSB regulations (reference FAR 21.3(d)(l)(ii) and (iii)).
c. FAR 21.3(d)(2) remwes the need to report as required by FAR 21.3(a) if the products, parts, or articles are manufactured ly a foreign manufacturer under a U. S. type certificate issued under FAR 21.29, or a TSO design approval under FAR 21.617, or when exported to the U.S. m e r FAR 21.502.
d. FAR 21.3 is directed to those deficiencies in the product that mly the manufacturers w i l d normally be expected to kmw (i.e., a design ar a quality control deficiency ) . m e deficiency that caused the occurrence is required to be reported under FAR 21.3(a).
/""" M. C . Beard Director of Airworthiness
Whole text after this change
ADVISORY CIRCULAR
DEPARTMEAT OF TRANSPORTATION
Federal Aviation Adminbtration
Wuhington, D.C.
FAR GUIDANCE MATERIAL
1. P'URPOSE. This circular provides information to assist manufacturers of aeronautical products (aircraft, a i r c r a f t engines, propellers, appliances, and parts) i n notifying the Federal Aviation Pdministration (FAA) of certain
failures, malfunctions, or defects, resulting from design or quality mtrol problems, in the products which they manufacture.
2. CANCELLATION. AC 21-9, Manufacturers &porting Failures, Malfunctions, or /"""' Defects, dated Decaber 30, 1970.
3. RELATED FEDERAL AVIATIm REGUIATIONS. Federal Aviation Fegulations Parts 21, 121, 127, and 135.
4 . DISCUSSICN .
a. FAR 21.3 requires the holder of a type m r t i f i c a t e (TC) (including a suppleroental type certificate (STC)), or a parts manufacturer approval (PMA), or a technical standard order (TSO) authorization, or the licensee of a type
c e r t i f i c a t e to notify the FAA of any failure, malfunction, or defect in their prcduct or part that they determine has resulted in any me of the occurrences specified i n t h i s rule. In addition, they must m t i f y the F'AA of any defective product or part that has l e f t their quality control system and vhich they determine could result in any one of the occurrences specif id in t h i s rule.
It is expected that compliance with FAR 21.3 w i l l provide the earliest possible notification to the FAA o f a hazardous condition, and that appropriate corrective action w i l l be initiated by the manufacturer.
be It is recognized that a manufacturer may choose to report an item prior to carpletion of h i s investigation to assure that the PAR is properly
informed of the probler,. However, the manufacturer need not report until he has determined that a deficiency does exist. The method and manner of reporting may be i n accordance with systems and procedures already established by the manufacturer, i f that system provides for imnediate identification of t h e items noted in FAR 21.3(c) .
- -- Initiated by: AW-200 .
c. Ihe subject rule does not apply ti the notification of a defect which the manufacturer becomes aware of during the normal manufacturing cycle of a product or a r t i c l e unless l i k e products or articles have l e f t his quality control system. I f the product or article is readily retrievable by the manufacturer , i .e . , under his defined quality mntrol system, then mt i f ication is not necessary. It is suggested that manufacturers review their quality control system to assure that the limits of the system are d e a r l y defined.
5. N(JTIFICAT1ON PXCEDURES. It is r e m e n d e d that each manufacturer amtact the appropriate aircraft certification office to:
a. Ensure an understanding of the rules;
b. Establish the most expeditious means of wnveying the mired information; (It is anticipated that telephone mtification w i l l be used in the majority of cases.)
c. Determine the person(s) to be contacted:
d. Establish a means of keeping the appropriate FAA office informed of progress and additional information on those cases where m l y preliminary
information has been reported.
6. APPLICABILITY TO FOREIGN MANUFACTURERS. The reporting rules cb mt apply to foreian manufacturers whose ~ r c d u c t s or articles have been approved under - - t h e appl~cable import certification provisions of FAR Part 21. Under the provisions of the bilateral a i m r t h i n e s s agreements the United States has
concluded with various foreign countries, the FAA relies on the c i v i l a i r authorities of those countries to keep it informed of hazardous a n d i t i o n s occurring in these products or articles.
7. GUIDANCE RELATIVE TO REFOFITING. FAR 2 1 .3 (d ) speaks to those a n d i t ions under which reports are not required.
a. The requirements under FAR 21.3(a) do not apply if it is determined by the holder that the failure, malfunction, or defect was caused by impmper maintenance or improper usage as noted in FAR 21.3(d)(i). ?his excludes those itm that are a result of causes other than design ar quality w n t r o l problem. Fbr e x q l e , i f a part failed and resulted in one of the occurrences noted i n FAR 21 .3(c) and it is found the failure is due to a barn part caused by improper maintenance, the failure need mt be reported. However, if the part was found t o f a i l because of design or a quality mntrol deficiency, the holder mst report the item. An engine f i r e from a fuel line failure due b an overtorqued cracked "B" nut during maintenance would not be reported; a "B" nut which cracked due to overtorquing when torqued in acmrdance w i t h design or manufacturer's instructions would be reported.
b. A s noted in the rule, the holder of a type certificate (including a supplemental type e r t i f i c a t e ) , or a parts manufacturer approval, or TSO authorization, or the licensee of a type certificate is responsible for reporting the failures, malfunctions, or defects in their products or parts resulting in the occurrences specified in FAR 21.3(c). However, i f an operator
* C experiences an engine shutdown during flight and external damage to the engine or airplane structure occurs as a result of the engine shutdown this hould be reported under either FAR Parts 121, 127, or 135. The engine TC holder is rot required to report under FAR 21.3(a) if the engine TC holder kmws the failure was reported by another person under FAR Parts 121, 127, or 135 or that it has been reported under the accident reporting provisions of Part 830 of the WrSB regulations (reference FAR 21.3(d)(l)(ii) and (iii)).
c. FAR 21.3(d)(2) remwes the need to report as required by FAR 21.3(a) if the products, parts, or articles are manufactured ly a foreign manufacturer under a U. S. type certificate issued under FAR 21.29, or a TSO design approval under FAR 21.617, or when exported to the U.S. m e r FAR 21.502.
d. FAR 21.3 is directed to those deficiencies in the product that mly the manufacturers w i l d normally be expected to kmw (i.e., a design ar a quality control deficiency ) . m e deficiency that caused the occurrence is required to be reported under FAR 21.3(a).
/""" M. C . Beard Director of Airworthiness
A.