AC 21-16F RTCA Document DO-160 versions D, E and F, “Environmental Conditions and Test Procedures for Airborne Equipment”
This document is cancelled. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.
U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory Circular
Subject: RTCA Document DO-160 versions D, E and F, “Environmental Conditions and Test Procedures for Airborne Equipment”
Date: 11/19/09
Initiated by: AIR-100
AC No: 21-16F
1. What is the purpose of this Advisory Circular?
a. This advisory circular (AC) identifies RTCA Document No. (RTCA/DO)-160 versions D, E, and F, Environmental Conditions and Test Procedures for Airborne Equipment, dated July 27, 1997, December 20, 2005, and December 6, 2007, respectively, as containing acceptable environmental qualifications to show compliance with certain airworthiness requirements. We, the FAA, strongly encourage the use of RTCA/DO-160F for new articles.
b. Appendix 1 of this AC provides a summary of the changes from RTCA/DO-160C to RTCA/DO-160D, version D to E, and version E to F. The information in the table will assist you in determining if a particular version of RTCA/DO-160 is acceptable.
Note: When reference to RTCA/DO-160D is made in this AC, it includes Changes 1, 2, and 3, dated December 14, 2000, June 12, 2001, and December 5, 2002, respectively. c. This AC is not mandatory and does not constitute a regulation. This AC describes a means, but not the only means, to comply with airworthiness requirements.
2. To whom does this AC apply? This AC applies to manufacturers and installers that use RTCA/DO-160 for environmental qualifications of their airborne equipment. 3. Cancellation. This AC cancels AC 21-16E, RTCA Document DO-160E, Environmental Conditions and Test Procedures for Airborne Equipment, dated December 20, 2005. 4. What is RTCA/DO-160?
a. RTCA/DO-160 (or its precursor, RTCA/DO-138) has been used as a standard for environmental testing since 1958. It defines standard environmental test conditions (categories) and applicable test procedures for airborne equipment.
b. The tests in RTCA/DO-160 provide a laboratory means of demonstrating the performance characteristics of airborne equipment in environmental conditions that may be encountered in operation of the equipment in aircraft. It is not the intent of RTCA/DO-160 to be
used as a measure of service life of the airborne equipment subjected to these tests.
c. As the realities of equipment operation under actual environmental conditions are better understood and new needs arise within the aviation community, RTCA/DO-160 has been revised to address the emerging and improved test techniques. The categories that have been developed over time reflect a reasonably mature understanding as to the severity of the environmental stresses, the degrees of mitigation achievable in the design of an installation, and the robustness that must be designed into equipment in order to perform in the operating environment. 5. Related Documents.
a. Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations, (14 CFR) parts 21, 23, 25, 27, 29, 33 and
35 are relevant to this AC. b. AC 20-136, Protection of Aircraft Electrical/Electronic Systems Against the Indirect
Effects of Lightning.
c. AC 20-158, The Certification of Aircraft Electrical and Electronic Systems for
Operation in the High-Intensity Radiated Fields (HIRF) Environment.
d. AC 33.17-1, Fire Prevention. 6. Using RTCA/DO-160 for Technical Standard Orders (TSOs).
a. If you are an applicant seeking a TSO authorization for airborne equipment, you may request a deviation, in accordance with the requirements of 14 CFR § 21.609, to use the conditions and procedures in a different version of RTCA/DO-160 instead of the corresponding conditions and procedures specified in the applicable TSO. Although an applicant may request to use an earlier version, we recommend that you use RTCA/DO-160F.
b. The table in Appendix 1 of this AC provides sufficient data for an applicant to use as a comparison between RTCA/DO-160D, E, and F. The FAA has determined that versions D, E and F provide an equivalent level of safety when the applicable version is identified in the Environmental Qualification Form (EQF). If the installed electrical/electronic equipment must meet lightning requirements use RTCA/DO-160D or later per the latest revision of AC 20-136. However, if the installed equipment is expected to be subject to HIRF requirements in 14 CFR §§ 23.1308, 25.1317, 27.1317, or 29.1317, use RTCA/DO-160F. RTCA/DO-160E is also acceptable to meet the HIRF requirements for level B and C systems when using test levels defined in the appropriate regulations as discussed in AC 20-158.
c. If the version of RTCA/DO-160 specified in a TSO is version D or later, and an applicant wishes to use a version prior to RTCA/DO-160D, then the applicant must still apply for a deviation as discussed in paragraph 6a. However, instead of using Appendix 1 as referenced in paragraph 6b, the applicant must compare the specific procedure and category changes, section by section, between the two versions of RTCA/DO-160 and address the differences between the two test results when providing an equivalent level of safety.
d. When a new application is based on the design of an existing approved article, the applicant may ask to use environmental test data from the existing article’s environmental qualification, based on similarity between the two articles. This request must be fully supported with a detailed similarity assessment comparing the changes from the earlier approved article to the article in the new application. The ACO may accept the data if the similarity assessment clearly shows that the design changes will not adversely affect the environmental qualification. 7. Using RTCA/DO-160 for Installers.
a. If you are an applicant installing equipment, you may use RTCA/DO-160, any version, to support compliance with the appropriate airworthiness requirements. When possible, we recommend that you use RTCA/DO-160F as it provides the most clear and complete test procedures.
b. Use the EQF provided by the equipment manufacturer to compare against your specific installation requirements. The EQF provides information regarding which version of DO-160 was used, which environmental tests were conducted and the environmental category of the equipment being tested. If the EQF categories do not adequately address your installation, then you or the equipment manufacturer may need to re-qualify the equipment to meet the appropriate sections and category levels.
c. When installing equipment previously qualified to other environmental standards, such as Military Standard (MIL-STD) 810C, the equipment must comply with applicable airworthiness requirements. You may use DO-160F to do a comparison analysis to show that it provides an equivalent level of safety in the expected operating environment.
d. When a new application is based on the design of an existing approved article, the applicant may ask to use environmental test data from the existing article’s environmental qualification, based on similarity between the two articles. This request must be fully supported with a detailed similarity assessment comparing the changes from the earlier approved article to the article in the new application. The ACO may accept the data if the similarity assessment clearly shows that the design changes will not adversely affect the environmental qualification.
e. Some of the environmental conditions and test procedures contained in RTCA/DO-160 such as waterproofness, sand and dust, or salt fog, may not be applicable to your installation based on intended location of the equipment. You must determine which sections and categories are applicable to your specific project.
f. When the equipment installation is required to meet HIRF requirements in 14 CFR §§ 23.1308, 25.1317, 27.1317, or 29.1317 use RTCA/DO-160F. RTCA/DO-160E is also acceptable to meet the HIRF requirements for level B and C systems when using test levels defined in the appropriate regulations as discussed in AC 20-158. For additional guidance on HIRF refer to the latest revision of AC 20-158.
g. When the electrical/electronic equipment installations are required to meet lightning requirements use RTCA/DO-160D or later. For additional guidance on lightning refer to the latest revision of AC 20-136.
h. RTCA/DO-160, Section 26, Fire, Flammability, is not sufficient for 14 CFR parts 25 and 33. Fire and flammability guidance for 14 CFR part 25 is provided in 14 CFR part 25 Appendix F. For 14 CFR part 33, please refer to the latest revision of AC 33.17-1. 8. How To Get Related Documents.
a. Order copies of RTCA documents from RTCA, Inc, 1828 L Street, NW, Suite 805, Washington, DC 20036-4007, telephone (202) 833-9339, fax (202) 833-9434. You can also order copies online at http://www.rtca.org.
b. Order copies of 14 CFR parts from the Superintendent of Documents, Government Printing Office, P.O. Box 979050, St. Louis, MO, 63197. For general information, telephone (202) 512-1800 or fax (202) 512-2250. You can order copies from the Government Printing Office website at www.access.gpo.gov. Select “Access” then “Online Bookstore.” Select “Aviation,” then “Code of Federal Regulations.”
c. View a list of all Advisory Circulars on the FAA’s Aviation Safety Information Management System (AVSIMS) at www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/advisory_circulars/ or from the FAA website: www.faa.gov. Order copies of ACs from the U.S. Department of Transportation, Subsequent Distribution Office, M-30, Ardmore East Business Center, 3341 Q 75th Avenue, Landover, MD 20785.
Susan J. M. Cabler Assistant Manager, Aircraft Engineering Division
11/19/09 AC 21-16F
Appendix 1
Appendix 1
A-1
Appendix 1
Summary of changes between DO-160D, E, and F
RTCA/DO-160 will continue to be subject to revisions as needs arise in the aviation community. However, it is not always feasible
for an applicant to use the more current revision. The following table is a summary of the changes made from RTCA/DO-160C to D,
D to E, and E to F. Versions of RTCA/DO-160 prior to RTCA/DO-160D are also not included in this table. The information in the
table should help you determine if your new article should be subject to a particular version of RTCA/DO-160.
DO-160D1 Changes from DO-160D1 to
DO-160E Changes from DO-160E to
DO-160F
Section 1-Section 3:
Purpose and
Applicability,
Definitions of Terms,
and Conditions of Tests
Editorial and clarifications changes only.
Section 3: The requirement for
Section 3: The requirement for
cumulative testing of Temperature,
Altitude, Humidity, and Vibration was
removed, and clarification was added
with respect to the use of multiple test
articles.
Added section 2.9, Applicability of Test
Results and section 3.9, EUT
Configuration for Susceptibility Tests.
Section 4: Temperature
Section 4: Temperature
and Altitude
Section 4.3 Equipment Categories added
reference categories for in-flight loss of
cooling test.
Section 4.5 Temperature Test was
restructured to include sub-section 4.5.2
Operating Low Temperature.
Section 4.5.3 Ground Survival High
Temperature Test and Short Term
Section 4.5.3 Ground Survival High
Operating High Temperature Test
clarified soak time upon reaching short
time operating low and high temperature.
Section 4.5.5, In-Flight Loss of Cooling
Test in the note clarified cooling source
and power.
Section 5: Temperature
Variation
Section 5.3 Test Procedures was revised
Section 5.3 Test Procedures was revised
to provide provisions for collecting data
during a single cycle of test and reduced
data collection under certain test
conditions.
Section 5.2 Temperature Change Rates
added two temperature shock tests,
categories S1 and S2, and Sections 5.3.2
and 5.3.3 are the tests sections that
Section 5.2 Temperature Change Rates
accompany the newly added categories,
respectively.
Sections, 5.3.1h, 5.3.2h, and 5.3.3i,
changed the performance compliance
timing to be in the second, or last cycle.
1 Includes Changes 1, 2, and 3 to RTCA/DO-160D.
11/19/09 AC 21-16F
Appendix 1
A-2
DO-160D1 Changes from DO-160D1 to
Appendix 1
DO-160E Changes from DO-160E to
DO-160F
Humidity Editorial changes were made to eliminate
redundant description of the test
procedures. Velocity of air throughout
the exposure area changed from “Shall
not exceed 0.75 m/s” to “Between 0.5 and
1.7 m/s”. Alternative method was added to measure the water pH.
Section 6.3 was modified to allow a + 4
Section 6.3 was modified to allow a + 4
percent tolerance to the relative humidity
requirement.
In paragraphs 6.3.1, 6.3.2, and 6.3.3
changed step 2 to 38 degrees to agree
with corresponding figure.
Operational Shocks
and Crash Safety
Equipment category definitions were
added for fixed wing and helicopter
installations. Crash Safety levels were
identified for helicopters (20g) and
increased for fixed wing crash safety
levels (20g). Shock pulse was changed
from half sine to saw tooth. Half-sine
shock pulse curve changed to reflect saw-
tooth profile. Test levels were changed
from DO-160C based on empirical data.
Fixed wing and helicopter operational and
crash safety test requirements were made
the same.
Category definitions were revised for
clarification. Text description and
centrifuge definitions were revised in
section 7.3.3 and figure 7.3, respectively,
to reflect the correct setup direction for
acceleration load.
Vibration New section defining vibration
requirements for helicopters was added.
Random vibration levels were changed
by the addition of new curves. Tables
and figures were modified to support
changes in test levels.
Fixed Wing Zone 2 features two new test
curves. High Level Short Duration
Category Test was revised. Helicopter
endurance test times were reduced and
the unknown helicopter test procedure
was reconfigured (Category U).
Unknown helicopter test procedure
(Category U2) was added as an
alternative to revision D.
Performance test times were reduced
from 30 minutes to a minimum of 10
minutes. Robust test equipment operating,
not operating requirements were
standardized to have equipment not
operating during sinusoidal scans and
operating during the robust test portion of
the test, unless specified otherwise by the
applicable equipment specifications.
Explosion Proofness Fuel mixture calculation was corrected for
hexane explosive proofness test.
Atmospheric test pressure requirements
were clarified.
Minor changes were made in the
procedure to improve repeatability.
Environment definition and category
definitions were revised. Reference to
100/130 octane fuel was deleted from figure 9-4.
Waterproofness
Test step that verifies absence of water
penetration into test unit following test
was deleted because it was not consistent
with intent and purpose of test. The test
is intended to verify performance of unit
Minor improvements to pre-heat unit and
to reduce risk of thermal shock were
made.
Drip Rate was changed from 280
l/m2/hr to 140 l/m2/hr.
11/19/09 AC 21-16F
Appendix 1
Appendix 1
A-3
DO-160D1 Changes from DO-160D1 to
DO-160E Changes from DO-160E to
DO-160F
following exposure to this environment,
not to verify the unit’s ability to keep out
water.
Fluids Susceptibility
Table 11-1 eliminated reference to fire
extinguishants and add additional de-
icing fluid, propylene glycol. Aircraft
fire extinguishants are gaseous and do not
exist in liquid form under normal
conditions. De-icing fluid added to
reflect current industry practices.
Updated list of fluids and added
inspection.
No changes were made.
Sand and Dust Editorial and clarifications changes only.
Sand and dust were separated into two
categories. Update the mixtures to
current commercial available
characteristics.
Category definitions were revised for
clarification. Additional sand
concentrations were added. Size
distributions and sum of total percentages
to 100% were adjusted in Section 12.3.2.
Fungus Resistance Section 13.5.7 was revised to eliminate
48 hour period after removal from chamber before performance test.
Other causes of fungus other than nutrient
materials and personnel safety caution
were added.
Test failure criteria were clarified.
Magnesium sulfate was adjusted to align
with other ingredients.
Salt Fog Change functional test criteria.
Functional test may now be performed
following 48 hour dry-out period.
Title of section was changed from Salt
Spray to Salt Fog. Category T was added
for severe salt atmosphere.
Changed term Salt Spray to Salt Fog
throughout this section.
Magnetic Effect Text was added to clarify source of
referenced magnetic field.
Section 15.3 was modified to provide a
Section 15.3 was modified to provide a
more detailed test procedure than in
previous versions, including a
requirement to verify field uniformity if
the compass must be moved to change the
measurement distance to the EUT
(equipment under test). The new Figure
15-1 provides a test setup diagram and gives notes on proper performance of the
test.
A new Category Y was added for
measurements made immediately
adjacent to the unit under test.
Descriptions of each equipment category
were added to Section 15.1 Purpose of
Test along with discussion of how the test
results are used to determine how close
the EUT may be installed to a compass or
compass sensor. Text allowing the
measurements to be made with an
uncompensated compass or equivalent
magnetic sensor was also added.
11/19/09 AC 21-16F
Appendix 1
Appendix 1
A-4
DO-160D1 Changes from DO-160D1 to
DO-160E Changes from DO-160E to
DO-160F
Power Input
Change 2 to DO-160D, published June
12, 2001, revised Section 16, by including new tests, and modifications to existing
testing, to address the issues of AC
harmonic current content and variable
frequency AC power systems.
The entire section was re-ordered so that
all the AC tests were in one subsection
and all DC tests were in another
subsection, making Section 16 easier to
use and understand. DO-160E also
introduced some new tests, such as a DC
content test for AC powered equipment,
and a new subsection covering "Load
Equipment Influence on Aircraft
Electrical Power Systems."
More tests are required for both AC and
DC powered equipment. A 270V DC bus
generated from the A (WF) AC power
bus was added as Category D. Discrete
step test methods were defined for AM
and FM modulation on AC systems. AM
voltage modulation on AC buses was
increased. Double interrupt test methods
were added for DC equipment. Manual
reset was explicitly not permitted after
single and double power interrupts. The
dwell at 28V between the short and the
long dc voltage surge was removed. Loss
of phase testing was added for three
phase. A Power Factor test designation
was added for ac equipment. DC current
draw tests from ac equipment current
were added. In-rush and current
modulation test designations were added
for both ac and dc equipment. Tolerances
were added to most tests. Category H,
harmonic emissions, measurement
methods were updated.
Voltage Spike
Editorial changes were made to support
document consistency. Reference to "DC
only" condition was eliminated thereby
expanding applicability to both AC and
DC systems. Figures were modified to
accommodate the inclusion of AC power
systems. Reference to negative pulse
generation network was eliminated.
No significant changes were made.
Section 17.4 Test Procedures was
Section 17.4 Test Procedures was
modified to clarify application of positive
and negative transients over the specified
period of time. Test conditions were
clarified when multiple power pins are
present.
Audio Frequency
Conducted
Susceptibility-Power
Inputs
DO-160C referenced Figures 16-4 and
16-5 for DC ripple test requirements; these figures were moved to Section 18 as
Figures 18-2 and 18-3.
The equipment category designators A
and J were eliminated, and categories R
and K were added.
New test for 270V dc input differential
ripple to follow same curve as 28V
Category Z, but at 4 times the amplitude
was added. A common mode noise test
has been added for 270V Category Z
equipment. For test equipment that
generate a continuous linear frequency
11/19/09 AC 21-16F
Appendix 1
Appendix 1
A-5
DO-160D1 Changes from DO-160D1 to
DO-160E Changes from DO-160E to
DO-160F
sweep, the minimum (i.e., fastest) sweep
rate has been slowed to make swept
testing equivalent to stepped testing,
especially at resonances. An optional DC
blocking network is added to the test
setup figures to prevent damage to the
signal source.
Induced Signal
Susceptibility
Category C was added to include test
levels that are appropriate for installations
with long wire runs or minimum wire
separation. The test levels for magnetic
and electric fields induced into wiring
were increased.
A second equipment category designator
was added to indicate the AC power
system operating frequency (Constant,
Narrow Variable, or Wide Variable). The
frequency scan rate was changed to 30
steps per decade, with a 10-second dwell
time at each frequency.
Clarification to existing formula used to
calculate test frequencies was made.
Radio Frequency
Susceptibility (Radiated
and Conducted)
The revisions to Section 20, in DO-160D
Change No.1, published December 2000,
include a new, Mode-Tuned,
Reverberation Chamber Radiated RF
Susceptibility test method. New
categories (test levels) were also added to
Section 20, including Category L, which
requires Radiated RF Susceptibility
testing (pulsed) as high as 7200
volts/meter.
An alternate procedure was added for
mode-stirred radiated susceptibility tests.
Section 20, including Category L, which
The mode-stirred procedure was accepted
as an alternate that may require lower-
power amplifiers.
A section providing guidance and caution
related to RF power amplifier harmonics
and their potential to affect the test results
was added, along with a revision that
allows the use of an oscilloscope to
measure Conducted Susceptibility test
levels. The Mode-Tuned test method for
Radiated Susceptibility was modified to
allow for the option of using the received
power on the monitor antenna to
determine the test level, as opposed the E-
field readings from a 3-axis sensor.
Flexibility in the number of tuner steps
was also added, giving the user the choice
of increasing the number of steps based
on the need for greater field uniformity or
a higher test level, or decreasing the
number of tuner steps to decrease the test
time.
Test categories were reduced and
“alternative” modulations for Category R
were eliminated. There is now only one
test method for conducted susceptibility.
Clarification has been added regarding
the requirement to expose all apertures
and openings of the EUT in anechoic
chamber method. RTCA/DO-160F added
requirements to test several additional
dwell frequencies where the image
frequencies for n =2 through 10. 160F
removed the permissive language
associated with these tests. It used to be
“should” but 160F now uses “shall”.
11/19/09 AC 21-16F
Appendix 1
Appendix 1
A-6
DO-160D1 Changes from DO-160D1 to
DO-160E Changes from DO-160E to
DO-160F
Emission of Radio
Frequency Energy
Change Category Z requirements to
reflect need for additional scrutiny in the
VHF COM NAV and GPS frequencies.
All of the figures were cleaned up and
made easier to read. The Radiated
Emissions limits for Categories M and H
were modified slightly so that the notches
that occur in various frequency ranges
now have sloped bottoms to match the
rest of the limit. The frequency range of
the first notch has also been changed for a
more precise match with the
communications/navigation frequency
range that the notch protects.
The conducted emissions frequency range
has been broadened to 150 kHz - 152
MHz, and the Radiated Emissions test
frequency range has been narrowed to
100 MHz - 6 GHz. A new procedure for radiated emissions measurements in a
reverberation chamber was added. In the
anechoic chamber method, clarification
has been added regarding the requirement
to expose all apertures and openings of
the EUT. A new limit category has been
added, Category P, to provide added
protection for certain receivers by use of
even deeper notches than previously used.
Lightning Induced
Transient Susceptibility
DO-160D Change No. 3, published
December 2002, added additional
waveform sets, cable bundle test levels,
and the procedures for performing
indirect lightning multiple stroke and
multiple burst tests using the existing
defined test waveforms. The category
designations were modified to allow users
to designate categories that indicated that
these additional tests had been performed.
New Waveform Set designators, G
through K, were added to cover the
Multiple Burst and Multiple Stroke tests.
Another significant addition to Change 3
was setup information on performing pin
injection tests with power applied.
Several different setup diagrams were
added to assist users in performing these
tests properly. Improperly connecting the
lightning generator to a pin with power
applied could result in insufficient stress
on the pin.
The DO-160E cable bundle test section
was modified to include a new section
providing guidance for performing cable
bundle tests on bundles that normally
contain shields, with the shields removed.
This guidance allowed testing of a cable
bundle at test levels currently defined in
DO-160, but intended to demonstrate
compliance to aircraft installation threats
that are higher than these standardized
levels. It explicitly stated that the test
generator used for cable bundle testing
does not need to be capable of producing
the voltage or current limit level,
provided that the current or voltage test
level can be achieved on the cable under
test.
Section 22 was restructured with
Section 22 was restructured with
additional test requirements moved from
notes under figures to the main body of
the document, and paragraphs were
numbered to provide easy reference to the
requirements contained in each
paragraph. In the waveform set tables
and the test level tables, both the voltage
and the current waveform number are
now shown to eliminate any ambiguities
with how waveforms are related to each
other.
This section was modified to clarify when
a test was successfully completed and
when, in the case of reaching a limiting
level before a test level, another
waveform test was needed. The cable
bundle section now contains a path to
follow for every waveform set and
criteria for acceptable and unacceptable
test limit waveforms that leads the user to
successful test completion regardless of
the configuration of the cable under test.
11/19/09 AC 21-16F
Appendix 1
Appendix 1
A-7
DO-160D1 Changes from DO-160D1 to
DO-160E Changes from DO-160E to
DO-160F
Lightning Direct
Effects
Additional procedure with associated
electrode was provided for producing
flashover when flashover is not produced
during the normal procedure and it is
desired that flashovers occur.
No significant changes were made.
Clarification of test waveforms and
methods has been added throughout the
section. Category designations have been
added to separate voltage and current
tests. Category designations have been
clarified, and Category F has been
deleted.
Icing Editorial and clarifications changes only.
No changes were made.
No major changes were made.
Clarification of type of ice was
incorporated.
Electrostatic Discharge A new section was added to address
device level susceptibility issues for ESD. No significant changes were made.
No significant changes were made, except
correcting typographical errors in the
figures.
Fire, Flammability
Section 26 was introduced in DO-160E. No changes were made.