Radar Vectors
Advisory CircularText changedNov 18, 2026

AC 150/5320-14 Airport Landscaping for Noise Control Purposes

Text changed: 2 of 34 passages.

Date
Nov 18, 2026
Recorded
Nov 18, 2026
Passages
2 of 34 changed
Paragraphs
15 added or rewritten, 2 removed or rewritten

Read the current text Official source ↗

What changed in the text

Key: [removed: removed words] are struck through; [added: added words] are underlined. Each changed paragraph is labelled in the margin.

  1. 40 unchanged paragraphs
  2. 270 P n P

  3. CANCELLED

  4. Changed

    [removed: P a r][added: Par] 6[removed: Page 5]

  5. Removed

    [removed: CANCELLED]

  6. Added

    [added: 6]

  7. Added

    [added: 5]

  8. Added

    [added: 4 REE ATIBA 2 3]

  9. Added

    [added: 1]

  10. Added

    [added: 0 0]

  11. Added

    [added: b 1]

  12. Added

    [added: 2]

  13. Added

    [added: 1/31/78]

  14. Added

    [added: 3 4 5 6 7 8]

  15. Added

    [added: RECEIVER TO SOURCE DISTANCE (R/S) RATIO]

  16. Added

    [added: Page]

  17. Added

    [added: NOTE: R=DISTANCE FROM RECEIVER TO SCREEN S= DISTANCE FROM NOISE SOURCE TO SCREEN]

  18. Added

    [added: AC-150/5320-14]

  19. Added

    [added: FIGURE 3. EFFECT OF RELATIVE POSITION OF SCREEN ON NOISE REDUCTION]

  20. I NOISE SCREEN I

  21. FIGURE 41 NOISE SCREENING GEOMETRY

  22. 137 unchanged paragraphs
Whole text before this change

AC NO:

DATE: January 31, 1978

+ ADVISORY CIRCULAR

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

1. PURPOSE. This advisory c i r c u l a r provides guidance to a i r p o r t planners and operators i n the use of t r e e and vegetation screens around a i r p o r t s and a i r c r a f t operating areas f o r noise control purposes.

2. BACKGROUND. A number of research studies have been conducted (see Appendix 2 ) to investigate the sound attenuation properties of trees,

shrubs, and other types of vegetation. Through these e f f o r t s , it has been demonstrated t h a t t r e e and vegetative screens can achieve moderate noise attenuation i n selective situations. The material contained i n t h i s c i r c u l a r summarizes some of the research findings on t h i s subject and discusses the application of t r e e and vegetative screens on and adjacent to a i r p o r t s f o r noise control purposes.

3 . NOISE ATTENUATION CHARACTERISTICS OF TREE AND VEGETATION SCREENS. The noise attenuation q u a l i t i e s of t r e e and vegetation screens r e s u l t from

t h e i r a b i l i t y to absorb and diffuse sound waves. Acoustical energy i s p a r t i a l l y absorbed by plant foliage, such as leaves, needles, twigs, and small branches whereas trunks, heavier branches, and dense foliage s c a t t e r o r diffuse sound. Thus, t r e e and vegetation b e l t s a c t as II leaky barriers" both absorbing and reflecting p a r t of the acoustical energy away from a receiver. The overall noise attenuation capability of t r e e b e l t s has been shown to be influenced more by b e l t thickness, heighq and overall density of the b a r r i e r than by differences i n

leaf s i z e and shape and branching characteristics. In other words, the process of diffusion is more prevalent than the process of absorption. Absorption c h a r a c t e r i s t i c s become more i n f l u e n t i a l , however, as the frequency of the noise source increases. Experiments have determined that foliage i s more e f f i c i e n t i n attenuating sound waves

i n the higher frequency ranges than i n the middle and low ranges and that i t s effectiveness increases with foliage density, leaf width, and leaf thickness. For example, sound a t 4,000 Hz. is reduced

Initiated by: AAP-560

CANCELLED

approximately 5 decibels when shielded by a 100-foot width (30 m) of dense foliage whereas sound a t 1,000 Hz. is reduced only 2 decibels under similar conditions. This phenomenon i s i l l u s t r a t e d i n Figure 1, developed by Bolt, Beranek, and Newman, Inc., which comDares the noise attenuation of d i f f e r e n t type t r e e s a s the frequency of the noise source increases.

4. BELT THICKNESS. The average attenuation f o r t r e e b e l t s of various wood species has been found to average approximately 7 dB f o r a 100-foot

(30 m) thick b e l t within a noise frequency range of 200-2,000 Hz. This occurs, however, only beyond the f i r s t 50 f e e t (15 m) of b e l t thickness. Belts l e s s than 50 f e e t a r e often ineffective and may, under c e r t a i n

circumstances, produce a negative attenuation. The attenuation value has a l s o been found to be nonlinear with respect to b e l t thickness. This i s demonstrated i n Figure 2 . This chart, developed by Bolt, Beranek, and Newman, Inc., indicates the approximate noise reduction f o r a four-engine turbofan c i v i l transport a i r c r a f t a t the s t a r t of

takeoff r o l l f o r increasing t r e e b e l t widths. Noise attenuation i s expressed i n perceived noise decibels (PNdB). The chart demonstrates that the efficiency of t r e e b e l t s decreases with increasing thickness to the point where there i s no additional measurable attenuation beyond a thickness of 800 f e e t (240 m). This l i m i t i s about 15 PNdB.

5. POSITIONING OF SCREEN. The r e l a t i v e positions of the noise source, the vegetation screen, and the receiver a r e c r i t i c a l l y important i n determining the effectiveness of a t r e e b e l t i n reducing undesirable noise. The sound absorption and diffusion c h a r a c t e r i s t i c s of a vegeta- tion screen o r t r e e b e l t a r e such t h a t its noise attenuation effective- ness i s highly dependent on the source o r the receiver being close t o

the screen. Belt location t e s t s conducted by Cook and Van Haverbeke shown i n Figure 3 i l l u s t r a t e t h i s phenomenon. The curve on the graph shows a pronounced "dip" a t an R/S r a t i o ( t h e r a t i o of receiver-belt distance to source-belt distance) equal to unity. This corresponds to a t r e e b e l t placement midway between noise source and receiver and indicates low attenuation and ineffective placement of the b e l t . The attenuation increases as the R/S r a t i o increases, indicating that the closer the t r e e b e l t t o the noise source, the more e f f e c t i v e the place- ment of the b e l t . The upward turn of the curve a t low R/S values, corresponding to a placement of a b e l t close to a protected area, indicates chat some benefit may be realized by having the b e l t "close in" but n o t a s much a s when the b e l t i s placed near the noise source.

6. SHIELDING EFFECT. For a t r e e b e l t to be effective, i t s height must be adequate to provide the necessary shielding between the noise source and the receiver. This shielding e f f e c t is i l l u s t r a t e d i n Figure 4. Note that f o r a vegetation screen to be effective, the noise source must be r e l a t i v e l y close t o the ground; f o r example, sound produced by taxiing

Page 2 Par 3

CANCELLED

FREQUENCY ( Hz 1

FIGURE I. ATTENUATION OF 100 FT. (30 m ) THICK TREE BELTS

VARYING SOUND FREQUENCIES

P a r 6 Page 3,

CANCELLED

w THICKNESS OF TREE ZONE IN METERS

THICKNESS OF TREE ZONE IN FEET

P 04 0 3 0

-

-

- P, Y FIGURE 2. APPROXIMATE REDUCTION OF THE PERCEIVED NOISE LEVEL FOR AIRCRAFT L' \ +

I 1 ASSUMPTIONS:

TREE HEIGHT IS 4 0 FEET (12m) ABOVE THE SOURCE AND THE RECEIVER. THE SOURCE IS 400 FEET (120m 1 FROM THE NEAREST TREE AND THE SOURCE RECEIVER DISTANCE IS 1600 FEET (480rn). -

NOISE VS- TREE BARRIER THICKNESS

3 0 90 15 0 210

-

270 P n P

CANCELLED

P a r 6 Page 5

CANCELLED

I NOISE SCREEN I

FIGURE 41 NOISE SCREENING GEOMETRY

Page 6

CANCELLED

and parked a i r c r a f t . The screen's effectiveness quickly diminishes as the noise generator moves above the top of the trees permitting

line-of-sight between the noise source and the receiver ( a s i n the case of airborne a i r c r a f t ) .

7 . SURFACE TREATMENT. The softness and texture of a surface t h a t sound passes over can have a marked e f f e c t on noise attenuation. This i s primarily due to the absorption quality of s o f t , coarse surfaces a s opposed to reflection from a hard, smooth surface. Thus, grass, low shrubs and plantings, vegetation cover, and cultivated earth can, by

themselves o r i n conjunction with t r e e s o r other natural o r man-made barriers, contribute to noise reduction. Figure 5 shows the r e s u l t s of a t e s t made by Cook and Van Haverbeke which i l l u s t r a t e s the variation

i n noise attenuation over d i f f e r e n t type surfaces. The chart c l e a r l y demonstrates that pavement areas a r e good r e f l e c t o r s of noise and that the presence of t r e e s , shrubs, plowed earth, and grass alongside such areas can contribute positively to noise attenuation.

8. ATMOSPHERIC GRADIENTS. Atmospheric gradients of wind velocity, tempera- ture, and humidity have recognized e f f e c t s on sound transmission (and noise reduction) .- These are-discussed below.

a. Wind Velocity. Sound waves a r e refracted o r "bent" upward o r downward a s a r e s u l t of changes i n the normal velocity of propagation a t varying elevations. Downwind propagation, associated with a positive velocity gradient (velocity increasing with a l t i t u d e )

tends to bend the waves downward, thus maintaining a u d i b i l i t y a t considerable distances. On the other hand, upwind propagation, associated with a negative velocity gradient, tends t o bend the sound waves upward and rapidly decreases audibility. Thus, the need f o r downwind placement of noise screens i s greater than f o r

upwind placement since the sound level tends to decrease more rapidly upwind. Tree b a r r i e r s a l s o tend to modify the wind patterns i n a way which favors downwind placement.

b. Temperature. A comparable s i t u a t i o n e x i s t s with temperature gradients during the day a s the sun warms the f i e l d s . Positive temperature gradients (temperature increasing with a l t i t u d e ) a r e typical during early morning and evening hours when the ground i s cool, whereas negative temperature gradients a r e typical during middays when the ground is warmed by the sun. I n the summertime, a band of cooler, high density a i r within a b e l t of trees may o f f e r some resistance to sound penetration.

Par 6 Page 7

CANCELLED

DISTANCE (METERS) FROM NOISE SOURCE

0 5 0 100 150 200 2 50 30 0 3 50 400 DISTANCE ( FT. FROM NOISE SOURCE

FIGURE 5. SOUND PROPAGATION OVER VARIOUS SURFACES

Page 8 P a r 8

CANCELLED

c. Humidity. Slight variations of humidity appear to have l i t t l e o r no d i r e c t e f f e c t on the propagation of sound. Extremely high humidity, as during r a i n o r fog, however, tends to produce a more homogeneous atmosphere, and i n so doing, favors the propagation of

sound. Humidity thus appears to have a r e l a t i v e l y minor e f f e c t on the use of trees and shrubs f o r noise abatement purposes.

9. PSYCHOLOGICAL EFFECTS. Over and above the actual noise attenuation properties of t r e e and vegetative foliage, i t has been demonstrated that vegetative screens produce positive psychological e f f e c t s . Hence, a narrow b e l t of trees o r hedges can be effective i n reducing complaints by providing an aesthetic improvement and by shielding the undesirable noise source even though the resulting noise attenuation i s negligible. Wind blowing through trees also produces i t s own noise which i s often

sensed as a pleasant sound and can help to mask the more offensive and unwanted noises.

10. RECOMMENDED SPECIES. The wide variance i n plant l i f e and foliage growth i n d i f f e r e n t climatic zones, together with other factors (e.g., bird - - - population and habits, s o i l c h a r a c t e r i s t i c s , e t c . ) , makes i t desirable

to consult with landscape a r c h i t e c t s and experts familiar with the local area when selecting specific plants. However, as general guidance, species with large, coarse leaves have been found more e f f e c t i v e i n scattering low sound frequencies; whereas species with small, dense, finely textured foliage a r e preferred f o r diffusing the high f r e q u e ~ c i e s . Deciduous t r e e s i n f u l l leaf a r e more e f f e c t i v e than evergreen t r e e s i n absorbing and diffusing upper-middle to high frequencies. Figure 1 shows a comparison of the attenuation c h a r a c t e r i s t i c s of evergreen and deciduous trees a t varying frequency ranges. As the chart i l l u s t r a t e s , deciduous trees lose t h e i r effectiveness when the leaves f a l l . Thus on a year-round basis, coniferous and broad-leafed evergreens a r e more effective f o r noise screening purposes. Evergreen t r e e s and shrubs found suitable f o r year-round noise screening are l i s t e d i n Appendix 1.

11. PLANTING PATTERNS. Although t r e e b e l t s and hedges may provide an aesthetic and psychological benefit i n screening a i r p o r t a c t i v i t i e s ,

t h e i r acoustical value i s quite limited unless the planting i s dense and has a minimum thickness of 50-100 f e e t (15-30 m). To be effective i n both winter and summer, the planting of a reasonable mixture of both deciduous and evergreen trees i s recommended. The colder the climate or the narrower the b e l t thickness, the greater the proportion of evergreens required. Border plantings should be lower toward the noise source to d i r e c t the unwanted noise upward and away from the receiver. Staggering of trees and shrubs i s recommended to avoid channels through which the noise can freely propagate. Dense shrubbery added beneath the t r e e canopy w i l l provide attenuation of the sound that otherwise would pass below the t r e e foliage. Such shrubbery i s not required throughout the e n t i r e t r e e zone, but can be planted i n one o r two

Par 8

CANCELLED

20-foot (6 m) bands for every 100 feet (30 m) depth of the tree belt. From an attenuation standpoint, the belt should be located as close as possible to the noise generator or to the area to be shielded and pro- ject as high as practical above the noise source without penetrating the imaginary surfaces defined in the Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR), Part 77, Objects Affecting Navigable Airspace, Subpart C. Other consid- erations and potential hazards as discussed in paragraphs 13 and 14 should be weighed carefully before establishing and locating vegetative screens.

12. VEGETATION IN COMBINATION WITH OTHER ELEMENTS. Tree belts and vegetative screens can be made even more effective if used in conjunction with earth berms or architectural barriers such as walls and concrete or stone embankments. When so used, the earth or architectural barrier

should be located closest to the noise source with the trees or other plantings located behind and projecting to a height necessary to achieve the desired shielding. The slopes of earth berms and embankments facing the noise source should be covered with grassy turf, dense shrubs, vines, or other plantings to provide additional sound absorption. If walls are utilized, the dense concrete or masonry type is preferred over fencing or low density type structures. Ivy and other vine plantings on the wall can help further increase the effective- ness of the barrier.

13. LIMITATIONS ON NOISE SCREEN USE. The use of tree belts and vegetative screens on airports for noise control purposes has serious shortcomings and disadvantages that limit their application and require careful planning before their utilization. Some of these are discussed below:

a. Hazards to Aircraft Operations. Areas adjacent to runways and in

runway approaches should be kept as free as practical from obstruc-

tions andvertically projecting objects. Trees and heavy shrubs in these areas can present a potential hazard in the event of an emergency situation and can contribute to turbulent wind conditions and visual distractions to pilots in making landing approaches. They also provide feeding and nesting areas for birds and other

forms of wildlife that can create a serious problem to aircraft operations. This is discussed further in paragraph 14.

b. Obstructions to Air Navigation. To be effective from a noise standpoint, trees and vegetation must be of sufficient height to provide adequate screening. However, to prevent the trees from becoming obstructions to air navigation, their heights must be

limited to insure that tree growth does not result in penetration of the imaginary surfaces defined in FAR Part 77, Subpart C. Such penetration can result in a hazard requiring expensive clearing and topping operations, obstruction lighting, and possible imposition of limitations to aircraft operational capability.

Page 10 Par 11

CANCELLED

c. Facility Interference. The planting of trees and vegetation

in proximity to air navigation and communication facilities can, - under certain circumstances, interfere with their performance. Prior to selecting any tree planting plan, the airport operator should consult with the local FAA Airway Facilities Sector to determine the potential impact of the proposed planting on FAA

facilities located on the airport.

d. Visual Screening of Control Towers. Care must be taken to prevent

trees and vegetation from obstructing the line-of-sight between aircraft operating areas and air traffic controllers. Runway ends, taxiway and runway intersections, apron areas, loading gates, and other high traffic locations are particularly sensitive and should be kept free of any visual impediments.

e. Emergency Vehicles. The presence of bands of trees and shrubbery on

or in the vicinity of an airport can restrict and impede the opera-

tion of Crash/Fire/Rescue (CFR) vehicles in the event of an aircraft crash or emergency. Tree plantings should be planned to insure the accessibility of areas on the airport and in the runway approaches to this equipment.

f. Cost Effectiveness. As suggested in paragraph 6, the noise

attenuation effectiveness of tree belts is limited to operations on or close to the surface. Once an aircraft clears the tops of the trees and is within line-of-sight of the observer, minimum, if any, attenuation benefits are derived. Thus, regardless of the extensiveness of a tree belt, only a portion of the aircraft noise generated in the vicinity of an airport is subject to any

screening effects. Also, since the planting of mature trees is expensive and generally impractical except for very limited situations, the planting of seedlings and immature young trees is more likely. This increases the maintenance problem and the probability of a higher percentage of plant-kill. It also results in a longer period of time before any measurable noise attenuation can be achieved, since the seedlings and young plants will require a number of years to develop. Hence, unless trees and vegetation already exist, the establishing of tree screens around an airport will likely have a relatively low cost/benefit ratio except at very selective locations.

14. BIRD HAZARD POTENTIAL. Prior to any decision to utilize tree or vegeta- -- tion screens for noise control, their potential for creating a bird hazard to aircraft must be carefully weighed against the anticipated noise benefits. Wooded areas and vegetation often attract birds by providing feeding, nesting and/or roosting areas. This is particularly

true at junctions of wooded areas and grasslands and where two distinctly different vegetative communities join. Hedgerows are also highly

attractive as shelters for birds and small mammals and should be avoided. For the same reason, the planting of trees and shrubs is not

Par 13 / Page 11

CANCELLED

recommended closer than 600 feet (180 m) to the centerline of active runways and taxiways. In considering the use of tree and vegetation belts as noise screens, the following factors should be considered: the type, size, feeding, and migratory habits of the area bird popula- tion; the geometric relationship and proximity between local feeding and nesting grounds, the proposed noise screen, and aircraft operating areas;

and the affinity of the trees and vegetation to attract birds.

15. RECOMMENDED APPLICATION. Despite their obvious limitations, thoughtful, selective use of tree belts and vegetation screens on and in the vicinity of an airport can provide worthwhile benefits without creating serious problems or potential hazards. As already suggested, trees in runway approaches and in proximity to runways, frequented taxiways, and navigation/communication facilities should be avoided. On the other hand, tree belts established along the outer perimeter or fringes of an airport and selective plantings within the terminal area complex, near parking aprons, aircraft maintenance facilities and noise sensitive

areas (e-g., schools, offices, public buildings, etc.) can, in conjunction with other noise control techniques, contribute positively to the airport's compatibility with its environment from a noise and aesthetic sta-~dpoint.

16. FAA PARTICIPATION IN LANDSCAPING PROJECTS FOR NOISE CONTROL. The --- -- Airport and Airway Development Act of 1970 as amended by Public Law 94-353 (The Airport and Airway Development Act Amendments of 1976) categorizes "landscaping for the purpose of diminishing the effect of aircraft noise on any area adjacent to a public airport" under the definition of airport development eligible for Federal grants under the Airport Development Aid Program (ADAP). Consequently, FAA can approve grants for the creation of tree and vegetative screens provided they are planned and located in compliance with the guidelines contained in this advisory circular.

17. - HOW TO 3BTAIN THIS PUBLICATION. Additional copies of this advisory circular can be obtained free of charge from the Department of - Transportation, Pub1 icatians Section, M-443.1, Wasi-lington, D. C.

20590. FAA field personnel may obtain copies from their respective regional Distribution Officers.

W I L L I A M V. V I T ~ Acting Assistant Adrmnistrator

Office of Airports Programs

Page 12 Par 14

CANCELLED

AC 150/5320-14

Appendix 1

APPENDIX 1. EVERGREEN TREES AND SHRUBS SUITABLE FOR YEAR-ROUND

NOISE SCREENING

COMMON NAME REGIONS OF BEST AD.4PTABILITY

TALL -

F i r

White Nationwide Veitch's Silver, Nikko East Balsam Midwest, North, Northeast Co rkb ark Midwest, Southwest, Southeast Fraser East, Southeast California Red West Spanish West Coast Cedar

Atlas West Coast Deodar, Cedar of Lebanon West Coast, South, Gulf Coast Port-Orford Cedar West Coast, South, Southeast Arizona Cypress Southwest, South, Southeast Spruce

Norway, White Serbian, Nationwide (best i n North) Oriental, Blue Nationwide (best i n North) Pine

Western White West Ponderosa Wzst, Midwest Scotch Nationwide (best i n North) Red East, North Austrian, Eastern W-ite Midwest, East Monterey California Coast Douglas F i r Nationwide (except South) Giant Sequoia, Redwood West Coast Western Red Cedar West Hemlock

Eastern East, Southeast Carolina East Coast, Southeast, South Western West Coast

MEDIUM

Juniper (upright)

Eastern Red Cedar and v a r i e t i e s Ezst of Rocky Mountains Rocky Mountain and v a r i e t i e s West of Rocky Mountains, Midwest Chinese and v a r i e t i e s Nationwide Grecian Nationwide I r i s h Nationwide (best i n North) Swedish Nationwide (best i n North)

Page 1

CANCELLED

AC 150/5320-14 Appendix 1

I COMMON NAME REGIONS OF BEST ADAPTABILITY I

Yew

Japanese and varieties English Arborvitae

American and varieties Oriental and varieties

Juniper

Chinese (~fitzer) and others Mugo pine Arborvitae

American and varieties Oriental and varieties Yew

Japanese and varieties Some Broad-leaved Evergreens

Pyracantha Euonyrnus Privet

Nationwide Nationwide (best in East)

Nationwide (best in North, Northeast

South

Nationwide Nationwide

Nationwide Nationwide

Nationwide

Nationwide (best in South) Nationwide

South

Page 2

CANCELLED

APPZNDIX 2. BIBLIOGRAPHY

AC 150/5320-14

Appendix 2

11 1. Bolt, Beranek and Newnan, Inc., Noise Attenuation of Foliage an3 Ground Cover Around A i r p o r t s , " FAA Contract #W1-73-0326-1.

2. S. P. Pao and L. B. Evans, "Sound Attenuation.0ver Simulated Ground Cover," Journal of t h e Acoustical Society of America, JASA 49, 1069

(1971).

3. M. E. Delany and E. N. Bazley, "A Note on the E f f e c t of Ground Absorption i n the Measurements of A i r c r a f t Noise," J. Sound Vib. 16,

315 (1971).

4. H. G. J o n a s s o ~ , "Sound Reduction by B a r r i e r s on the Ground," J. Sound Vib. 22 113 (1972). -

5. W. E. Scholes and P. H. Parkin, "The E f f e c t of Small Changes i n Source Height on t h e Propagation of Sound Over Grassland," J. Sound Vib. - 6, 424 (1967).

6. P. H. Parkin and W. E. Scholes, he X o r i z o ~ t a l Propagation of Sound From a J e t Engine Close t o the Ground, a t R a d l e t t , " J. Sound Vib. 1,

1 (1964).

7. P. H. Parkin and W. E. Scholes, "The Horizontal Propagation of Sound From a J e t Engine Close t o the Ground, a t H a t f i e l d , " J. Sound Vib. 2, -

353 (1965).

(1 8. W. E. Scholes, S e l e c t i v e Attenuation of Sound Over Seating and Grassland," JASA - 37, 756 (1965).

9. M. E. Delany, W. C. Copeland and R. C. Payne, "Propagation of T r a f f i c Noise i n Typical Urban S i t u a t i o n s , " NPL Acoustics Report Ac 54 (1971).

10. F. M. Wie2er and D. N. Keast, "Experimental Study of t h e Propagation of Sound Over p round," JASA 31, 724 (1959). -

11. T. F. W. Embleton, "sound Propagation i n Homogenous Deciduous and Evergreen Woods," JASA - 35, 1119 (1963).

1 2 . U. S. Department of t h e I n t e r i o r , National Park Service, " ~ l a n t s / ~ e o p l e ! and Environmental ~ u a l i t ~ , " 1972.

13. D. Aylor, " ~ o i s e Reduction by Vegetation and Ground," JASA 51 -9 197 (1971).

14. D. Aylor, "sound Transmission Through Vegetation i n Relation t o Leaf Area Density, Leaf Width and Breadth of Canopy," JASA - 51, 411 (1972).

Page 1

CANCELLED

AC 150/5320-14

Appendix 2

APPENDIX 2. BIBLIOGRAPHY (Cont'd)

15. International Civil Aviation Organization, Airport Services Manual, Part 3, Bird Control and Reduction, DOC 9137-AN/898.

16. Hans Blokpoel, "Bird Hazards t o Aircraft,'' Clarke, Irwin and Company Limited, Canada (1976).

17. M. J. Harrison, "The Bird/Aircraft Strike Hazard (BASH) Program i n

the United States A i r Force," A i r Force Civil Engineering Center, Tyndall AFB, Florida (1976).

Page 2

CANCELLED

Whole text after this change

AC NO:

DATE: January 31, 1978

+ ADVISORY CIRCULAR

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

1. PURPOSE. This advisory c i r c u l a r provides guidance to a i r p o r t planners and operators i n the use of t r e e and vegetation screens around a i r p o r t s and a i r c r a f t operating areas f o r noise control purposes.

2. BACKGROUND. A number of research studies have been conducted (see Appendix 2 ) to investigate the sound attenuation properties of trees,

shrubs, and other types of vegetation. Through these e f f o r t s , it has been demonstrated t h a t t r e e and vegetative screens can achieve moderate noise attenuation i n selective situations. The material contained i n t h i s c i r c u l a r summarizes some of the research findings on t h i s subject and discusses the application of t r e e and vegetative screens on and adjacent to a i r p o r t s f o r noise control purposes.

3 . NOISE ATTENUATION CHARACTERISTICS OF TREE AND VEGETATION SCREENS. The noise attenuation q u a l i t i e s of t r e e and vegetation screens r e s u l t from

t h e i r a b i l i t y to absorb and diffuse sound waves. Acoustical energy i s p a r t i a l l y absorbed by plant foliage, such as leaves, needles, twigs, and small branches whereas trunks, heavier branches, and dense foliage s c a t t e r o r diffuse sound. Thus, t r e e and vegetation b e l t s a c t as II leaky barriers" both absorbing and reflecting p a r t of the acoustical energy away from a receiver. The overall noise attenuation capability of t r e e b e l t s has been shown to be influenced more by b e l t thickness, heighq and overall density of the b a r r i e r than by differences i n

leaf s i z e and shape and branching characteristics. In other words, the process of diffusion is more prevalent than the process of absorption. Absorption c h a r a c t e r i s t i c s become more i n f l u e n t i a l , however, as the frequency of the noise source increases. Experiments have determined that foliage i s more e f f i c i e n t i n attenuating sound waves

i n the higher frequency ranges than i n the middle and low ranges and that i t s effectiveness increases with foliage density, leaf width, and leaf thickness. For example, sound a t 4,000 Hz. is reduced

Initiated by: AAP-560

CANCELLED

approximately 5 decibels when shielded by a 100-foot width (30 m) of dense foliage whereas sound a t 1,000 Hz. is reduced only 2 decibels under similar conditions. This phenomenon i s i l l u s t r a t e d i n Figure 1, developed by Bolt, Beranek, and Newman, Inc., which comDares the noise attenuation of d i f f e r e n t type t r e e s a s the frequency of the noise source increases.

4. BELT THICKNESS. The average attenuation f o r t r e e b e l t s of various wood species has been found to average approximately 7 dB f o r a 100-foot

(30 m) thick b e l t within a noise frequency range of 200-2,000 Hz. This occurs, however, only beyond the f i r s t 50 f e e t (15 m) of b e l t thickness. Belts l e s s than 50 f e e t a r e often ineffective and may, under c e r t a i n

circumstances, produce a negative attenuation. The attenuation value has a l s o been found to be nonlinear with respect to b e l t thickness. This i s demonstrated i n Figure 2 . This chart, developed by Bolt, Beranek, and Newman, Inc., indicates the approximate noise reduction f o r a four-engine turbofan c i v i l transport a i r c r a f t a t the s t a r t of

takeoff r o l l f o r increasing t r e e b e l t widths. Noise attenuation i s expressed i n perceived noise decibels (PNdB). The chart demonstrates that the efficiency of t r e e b e l t s decreases with increasing thickness to the point where there i s no additional measurable attenuation beyond a thickness of 800 f e e t (240 m). This l i m i t i s about 15 PNdB.

5. POSITIONING OF SCREEN. The r e l a t i v e positions of the noise source, the vegetation screen, and the receiver a r e c r i t i c a l l y important i n determining the effectiveness of a t r e e b e l t i n reducing undesirable noise. The sound absorption and diffusion c h a r a c t e r i s t i c s of a vegeta- tion screen o r t r e e b e l t a r e such t h a t its noise attenuation effective- ness i s highly dependent on the source o r the receiver being close t o

the screen. Belt location t e s t s conducted by Cook and Van Haverbeke shown i n Figure 3 i l l u s t r a t e t h i s phenomenon. The curve on the graph shows a pronounced "dip" a t an R/S r a t i o ( t h e r a t i o of receiver-belt distance to source-belt distance) equal to unity. This corresponds to a t r e e b e l t placement midway between noise source and receiver and indicates low attenuation and ineffective placement of the b e l t . The attenuation increases as the R/S r a t i o increases, indicating that the closer the t r e e b e l t t o the noise source, the more e f f e c t i v e the place- ment of the b e l t . The upward turn of the curve a t low R/S values, corresponding to a placement of a b e l t close to a protected area, indicates chat some benefit may be realized by having the b e l t "close in" but n o t a s much a s when the b e l t i s placed near the noise source.

6. SHIELDING EFFECT. For a t r e e b e l t to be effective, i t s height must be adequate to provide the necessary shielding between the noise source and the receiver. This shielding e f f e c t is i l l u s t r a t e d i n Figure 4. Note that f o r a vegetation screen to be effective, the noise source must be r e l a t i v e l y close t o the ground; f o r example, sound produced by taxiing

Page 2 Par 3

CANCELLED

FREQUENCY ( Hz 1

FIGURE I. ATTENUATION OF 100 FT. (30 m ) THICK TREE BELTS

VARYING SOUND FREQUENCIES

P a r 6 Page 3,

CANCELLED

w THICKNESS OF TREE ZONE IN METERS

THICKNESS OF TREE ZONE IN FEET

P 04 0 3 0

-

-

- P, Y FIGURE 2. APPROXIMATE REDUCTION OF THE PERCEIVED NOISE LEVEL FOR AIRCRAFT L' \ +

I 1 ASSUMPTIONS:

TREE HEIGHT IS 4 0 FEET (12m) ABOVE THE SOURCE AND THE RECEIVER. THE SOURCE IS 400 FEET (120m 1 FROM THE NEAREST TREE AND THE SOURCE RECEIVER DISTANCE IS 1600 FEET (480rn). -

NOISE VS- TREE BARRIER THICKNESS

3 0 90 15 0 210

-

270 P n P

CANCELLED

Par 6

6

5

4 REE ATIBA 2 3

1

0 0

b 1

2

1/31/78

3 4 5 6 7 8

RECEIVER TO SOURCE DISTANCE (R/S) RATIO

Page

NOTE: R=DISTANCE FROM RECEIVER TO SCREEN S= DISTANCE FROM NOISE SOURCE TO SCREEN

AC-150/5320-14

FIGURE 3. EFFECT OF RELATIVE POSITION OF SCREEN ON NOISE REDUCTION

I NOISE SCREEN I

FIGURE 41 NOISE SCREENING GEOMETRY

Page 6

CANCELLED

and parked a i r c r a f t . The screen's effectiveness quickly diminishes as the noise generator moves above the top of the trees permitting

line-of-sight between the noise source and the receiver ( a s i n the case of airborne a i r c r a f t ) .

7 . SURFACE TREATMENT. The softness and texture of a surface t h a t sound passes over can have a marked e f f e c t on noise attenuation. This i s primarily due to the absorption quality of s o f t , coarse surfaces a s opposed to reflection from a hard, smooth surface. Thus, grass, low shrubs and plantings, vegetation cover, and cultivated earth can, by

themselves o r i n conjunction with t r e e s o r other natural o r man-made barriers, contribute to noise reduction. Figure 5 shows the r e s u l t s of a t e s t made by Cook and Van Haverbeke which i l l u s t r a t e s the variation

i n noise attenuation over d i f f e r e n t type surfaces. The chart c l e a r l y demonstrates that pavement areas a r e good r e f l e c t o r s of noise and that the presence of t r e e s , shrubs, plowed earth, and grass alongside such areas can contribute positively to noise attenuation.

8. ATMOSPHERIC GRADIENTS. Atmospheric gradients of wind velocity, tempera- ture, and humidity have recognized e f f e c t s on sound transmission (and noise reduction) .- These are-discussed below.

a. Wind Velocity. Sound waves a r e refracted o r "bent" upward o r downward a s a r e s u l t of changes i n the normal velocity of propagation a t varying elevations. Downwind propagation, associated with a positive velocity gradient (velocity increasing with a l t i t u d e )

tends to bend the waves downward, thus maintaining a u d i b i l i t y a t considerable distances. On the other hand, upwind propagation, associated with a negative velocity gradient, tends t o bend the sound waves upward and rapidly decreases audibility. Thus, the need f o r downwind placement of noise screens i s greater than f o r

upwind placement since the sound level tends to decrease more rapidly upwind. Tree b a r r i e r s a l s o tend to modify the wind patterns i n a way which favors downwind placement.

b. Temperature. A comparable s i t u a t i o n e x i s t s with temperature gradients during the day a s the sun warms the f i e l d s . Positive temperature gradients (temperature increasing with a l t i t u d e ) a r e typical during early morning and evening hours when the ground i s cool, whereas negative temperature gradients a r e typical during middays when the ground is warmed by the sun. I n the summertime, a band of cooler, high density a i r within a b e l t of trees may o f f e r some resistance to sound penetration.

Par 6 Page 7

CANCELLED

DISTANCE (METERS) FROM NOISE SOURCE

0 5 0 100 150 200 2 50 30 0 3 50 400 DISTANCE ( FT. FROM NOISE SOURCE

FIGURE 5. SOUND PROPAGATION OVER VARIOUS SURFACES

Page 8 P a r 8

CANCELLED

c. Humidity. Slight variations of humidity appear to have l i t t l e o r no d i r e c t e f f e c t on the propagation of sound. Extremely high humidity, as during r a i n o r fog, however, tends to produce a more homogeneous atmosphere, and i n so doing, favors the propagation of

sound. Humidity thus appears to have a r e l a t i v e l y minor e f f e c t on the use of trees and shrubs f o r noise abatement purposes.

9. PSYCHOLOGICAL EFFECTS. Over and above the actual noise attenuation properties of t r e e and vegetative foliage, i t has been demonstrated that vegetative screens produce positive psychological e f f e c t s . Hence, a narrow b e l t of trees o r hedges can be effective i n reducing complaints by providing an aesthetic improvement and by shielding the undesirable noise source even though the resulting noise attenuation i s negligible. Wind blowing through trees also produces i t s own noise which i s often

sensed as a pleasant sound and can help to mask the more offensive and unwanted noises.

10. RECOMMENDED SPECIES. The wide variance i n plant l i f e and foliage growth i n d i f f e r e n t climatic zones, together with other factors (e.g., bird - - - population and habits, s o i l c h a r a c t e r i s t i c s , e t c . ) , makes i t desirable

to consult with landscape a r c h i t e c t s and experts familiar with the local area when selecting specific plants. However, as general guidance, species with large, coarse leaves have been found more e f f e c t i v e i n scattering low sound frequencies; whereas species with small, dense, finely textured foliage a r e preferred f o r diffusing the high f r e q u e ~ c i e s . Deciduous t r e e s i n f u l l leaf a r e more e f f e c t i v e than evergreen t r e e s i n absorbing and diffusing upper-middle to high frequencies. Figure 1 shows a comparison of the attenuation c h a r a c t e r i s t i c s of evergreen and deciduous trees a t varying frequency ranges. As the chart i l l u s t r a t e s , deciduous trees lose t h e i r effectiveness when the leaves f a l l . Thus on a year-round basis, coniferous and broad-leafed evergreens a r e more effective f o r noise screening purposes. Evergreen t r e e s and shrubs found suitable f o r year-round noise screening are l i s t e d i n Appendix 1.

11. PLANTING PATTERNS. Although t r e e b e l t s and hedges may provide an aesthetic and psychological benefit i n screening a i r p o r t a c t i v i t i e s ,

t h e i r acoustical value i s quite limited unless the planting i s dense and has a minimum thickness of 50-100 f e e t (15-30 m). To be effective i n both winter and summer, the planting of a reasonable mixture of both deciduous and evergreen trees i s recommended. The colder the climate or the narrower the b e l t thickness, the greater the proportion of evergreens required. Border plantings should be lower toward the noise source to d i r e c t the unwanted noise upward and away from the receiver. Staggering of trees and shrubs i s recommended to avoid channels through which the noise can freely propagate. Dense shrubbery added beneath the t r e e canopy w i l l provide attenuation of the sound that otherwise would pass below the t r e e foliage. Such shrubbery i s not required throughout the e n t i r e t r e e zone, but can be planted i n one o r two

Par 8

CANCELLED

20-foot (6 m) bands for every 100 feet (30 m) depth of the tree belt. From an attenuation standpoint, the belt should be located as close as possible to the noise generator or to the area to be shielded and pro- ject as high as practical above the noise source without penetrating the imaginary surfaces defined in the Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR), Part 77, Objects Affecting Navigable Airspace, Subpart C. Other consid- erations and potential hazards as discussed in paragraphs 13 and 14 should be weighed carefully before establishing and locating vegetative screens.

12. VEGETATION IN COMBINATION WITH OTHER ELEMENTS. Tree belts and vegetative screens can be made even more effective if used in conjunction with earth berms or architectural barriers such as walls and concrete or stone embankments. When so used, the earth or architectural barrier

should be located closest to the noise source with the trees or other plantings located behind and projecting to a height necessary to achieve the desired shielding. The slopes of earth berms and embankments facing the noise source should be covered with grassy turf, dense shrubs, vines, or other plantings to provide additional sound absorption. If walls are utilized, the dense concrete or masonry type is preferred over fencing or low density type structures. Ivy and other vine plantings on the wall can help further increase the effective- ness of the barrier.

13. LIMITATIONS ON NOISE SCREEN USE. The use of tree belts and vegetative screens on airports for noise control purposes has serious shortcomings and disadvantages that limit their application and require careful planning before their utilization. Some of these are discussed below:

a. Hazards to Aircraft Operations. Areas adjacent to runways and in

runway approaches should be kept as free as practical from obstruc-

tions andvertically projecting objects. Trees and heavy shrubs in these areas can present a potential hazard in the event of an emergency situation and can contribute to turbulent wind conditions and visual distractions to pilots in making landing approaches. They also provide feeding and nesting areas for birds and other

forms of wildlife that can create a serious problem to aircraft operations. This is discussed further in paragraph 14.

b. Obstructions to Air Navigation. To be effective from a noise standpoint, trees and vegetation must be of sufficient height to provide adequate screening. However, to prevent the trees from becoming obstructions to air navigation, their heights must be

limited to insure that tree growth does not result in penetration of the imaginary surfaces defined in FAR Part 77, Subpart C. Such penetration can result in a hazard requiring expensive clearing and topping operations, obstruction lighting, and possible imposition of limitations to aircraft operational capability.

Page 10 Par 11

CANCELLED

c. Facility Interference. The planting of trees and vegetation

in proximity to air navigation and communication facilities can, - under certain circumstances, interfere with their performance. Prior to selecting any tree planting plan, the airport operator should consult with the local FAA Airway Facilities Sector to determine the potential impact of the proposed planting on FAA

facilities located on the airport.

d. Visual Screening of Control Towers. Care must be taken to prevent

trees and vegetation from obstructing the line-of-sight between aircraft operating areas and air traffic controllers. Runway ends, taxiway and runway intersections, apron areas, loading gates, and other high traffic locations are particularly sensitive and should be kept free of any visual impediments.

e. Emergency Vehicles. The presence of bands of trees and shrubbery on

or in the vicinity of an airport can restrict and impede the opera-

tion of Crash/Fire/Rescue (CFR) vehicles in the event of an aircraft crash or emergency. Tree plantings should be planned to insure the accessibility of areas on the airport and in the runway approaches to this equipment.

f. Cost Effectiveness. As suggested in paragraph 6, the noise

attenuation effectiveness of tree belts is limited to operations on or close to the surface. Once an aircraft clears the tops of the trees and is within line-of-sight of the observer, minimum, if any, attenuation benefits are derived. Thus, regardless of the extensiveness of a tree belt, only a portion of the aircraft noise generated in the vicinity of an airport is subject to any

screening effects. Also, since the planting of mature trees is expensive and generally impractical except for very limited situations, the planting of seedlings and immature young trees is more likely. This increases the maintenance problem and the probability of a higher percentage of plant-kill. It also results in a longer period of time before any measurable noise attenuation can be achieved, since the seedlings and young plants will require a number of years to develop. Hence, unless trees and vegetation already exist, the establishing of tree screens around an airport will likely have a relatively low cost/benefit ratio except at very selective locations.

14. BIRD HAZARD POTENTIAL. Prior to any decision to utilize tree or vegeta- -- tion screens for noise control, their potential for creating a bird hazard to aircraft must be carefully weighed against the anticipated noise benefits. Wooded areas and vegetation often attract birds by providing feeding, nesting and/or roosting areas. This is particularly

true at junctions of wooded areas and grasslands and where two distinctly different vegetative communities join. Hedgerows are also highly

attractive as shelters for birds and small mammals and should be avoided. For the same reason, the planting of trees and shrubs is not

Par 13 / Page 11

CANCELLED

recommended closer than 600 feet (180 m) to the centerline of active runways and taxiways. In considering the use of tree and vegetation belts as noise screens, the following factors should be considered: the type, size, feeding, and migratory habits of the area bird popula- tion; the geometric relationship and proximity between local feeding and nesting grounds, the proposed noise screen, and aircraft operating areas;

and the affinity of the trees and vegetation to attract birds.

15. RECOMMENDED APPLICATION. Despite their obvious limitations, thoughtful, selective use of tree belts and vegetation screens on and in the vicinity of an airport can provide worthwhile benefits without creating serious problems or potential hazards. As already suggested, trees in runway approaches and in proximity to runways, frequented taxiways, and navigation/communication facilities should be avoided. On the other hand, tree belts established along the outer perimeter or fringes of an airport and selective plantings within the terminal area complex, near parking aprons, aircraft maintenance facilities and noise sensitive

areas (e-g., schools, offices, public buildings, etc.) can, in conjunction with other noise control techniques, contribute positively to the airport's compatibility with its environment from a noise and aesthetic sta-~dpoint.

16. FAA PARTICIPATION IN LANDSCAPING PROJECTS FOR NOISE CONTROL. The --- -- Airport and Airway Development Act of 1970 as amended by Public Law 94-353 (The Airport and Airway Development Act Amendments of 1976) categorizes "landscaping for the purpose of diminishing the effect of aircraft noise on any area adjacent to a public airport" under the definition of airport development eligible for Federal grants under the Airport Development Aid Program (ADAP). Consequently, FAA can approve grants for the creation of tree and vegetative screens provided they are planned and located in compliance with the guidelines contained in this advisory circular.

17. - HOW TO 3BTAIN THIS PUBLICATION. Additional copies of this advisory circular can be obtained free of charge from the Department of - Transportation, Pub1 icatians Section, M-443.1, Wasi-lington, D. C.

20590. FAA field personnel may obtain copies from their respective regional Distribution Officers.

W I L L I A M V. V I T ~ Acting Assistant Adrmnistrator

Office of Airports Programs

Page 12 Par 14

CANCELLED

AC 150/5320-14

Appendix 1

APPENDIX 1. EVERGREEN TREES AND SHRUBS SUITABLE FOR YEAR-ROUND

NOISE SCREENING

COMMON NAME REGIONS OF BEST AD.4PTABILITY

TALL -

F i r

White Nationwide Veitch's Silver, Nikko East Balsam Midwest, North, Northeast Co rkb ark Midwest, Southwest, Southeast Fraser East, Southeast California Red West Spanish West Coast Cedar

Atlas West Coast Deodar, Cedar of Lebanon West Coast, South, Gulf Coast Port-Orford Cedar West Coast, South, Southeast Arizona Cypress Southwest, South, Southeast Spruce

Norway, White Serbian, Nationwide (best i n North) Oriental, Blue Nationwide (best i n North) Pine

Western White West Ponderosa Wzst, Midwest Scotch Nationwide (best i n North) Red East, North Austrian, Eastern W-ite Midwest, East Monterey California Coast Douglas F i r Nationwide (except South) Giant Sequoia, Redwood West Coast Western Red Cedar West Hemlock

Eastern East, Southeast Carolina East Coast, Southeast, South Western West Coast

MEDIUM

Juniper (upright)

Eastern Red Cedar and v a r i e t i e s Ezst of Rocky Mountains Rocky Mountain and v a r i e t i e s West of Rocky Mountains, Midwest Chinese and v a r i e t i e s Nationwide Grecian Nationwide I r i s h Nationwide (best i n North) Swedish Nationwide (best i n North)

Page 1

CANCELLED

AC 150/5320-14 Appendix 1

I COMMON NAME REGIONS OF BEST ADAPTABILITY I

Yew

Japanese and varieties English Arborvitae

American and varieties Oriental and varieties

Juniper

Chinese (~fitzer) and others Mugo pine Arborvitae

American and varieties Oriental and varieties Yew

Japanese and varieties Some Broad-leaved Evergreens

Pyracantha Euonyrnus Privet

Nationwide Nationwide (best in East)

Nationwide (best in North, Northeast

South

Nationwide Nationwide

Nationwide Nationwide

Nationwide

Nationwide (best in South) Nationwide

South

Page 2

CANCELLED

APPZNDIX 2. BIBLIOGRAPHY

AC 150/5320-14

Appendix 2

11 1. Bolt, Beranek and Newnan, Inc., Noise Attenuation of Foliage an3 Ground Cover Around A i r p o r t s , " FAA Contract #W1-73-0326-1.

2. S. P. Pao and L. B. Evans, "Sound Attenuation.0ver Simulated Ground Cover," Journal of t h e Acoustical Society of America, JASA 49, 1069

(1971).

3. M. E. Delany and E. N. Bazley, "A Note on the E f f e c t of Ground Absorption i n the Measurements of A i r c r a f t Noise," J. Sound Vib. 16,

315 (1971).

4. H. G. J o n a s s o ~ , "Sound Reduction by B a r r i e r s on the Ground," J. Sound Vib. 22 113 (1972). -

5. W. E. Scholes and P. H. Parkin, "The E f f e c t of Small Changes i n Source Height on t h e Propagation of Sound Over Grassland," J. Sound Vib. - 6, 424 (1967).

6. P. H. Parkin and W. E. Scholes, he X o r i z o ~ t a l Propagation of Sound From a J e t Engine Close t o the Ground, a t R a d l e t t , " J. Sound Vib. 1,

1 (1964).

7. P. H. Parkin and W. E. Scholes, "The Horizontal Propagation of Sound From a J e t Engine Close t o the Ground, a t H a t f i e l d , " J. Sound Vib. 2, -

353 (1965).

(1 8. W. E. Scholes, S e l e c t i v e Attenuation of Sound Over Seating and Grassland," JASA - 37, 756 (1965).

9. M. E. Delany, W. C. Copeland and R. C. Payne, "Propagation of T r a f f i c Noise i n Typical Urban S i t u a t i o n s , " NPL Acoustics Report Ac 54 (1971).

10. F. M. Wie2er and D. N. Keast, "Experimental Study of t h e Propagation of Sound Over p round," JASA 31, 724 (1959). -

11. T. F. W. Embleton, "sound Propagation i n Homogenous Deciduous and Evergreen Woods," JASA - 35, 1119 (1963).

1 2 . U. S. Department of t h e I n t e r i o r , National Park Service, " ~ l a n t s / ~ e o p l e ! and Environmental ~ u a l i t ~ , " 1972.

13. D. Aylor, " ~ o i s e Reduction by Vegetation and Ground," JASA 51 -9 197 (1971).

14. D. Aylor, "sound Transmission Through Vegetation i n Relation t o Leaf Area Density, Leaf Width and Breadth of Canopy," JASA - 51, 411 (1972).

Page 1

CANCELLED

AC 150/5320-14

Appendix 2

APPENDIX 2. BIBLIOGRAPHY (Cont'd)

15. International Civil Aviation Organization, Airport Services Manual, Part 3, Bird Control and Reduction, DOC 9137-AN/898.

16. Hans Blokpoel, "Bird Hazards t o Aircraft,'' Clarke, Irwin and Company Limited, Canada (1976).

17. M. J. Harrison, "The Bird/Aircraft Strike Hazard (BASH) Program i n

the United States A i r Force," A i r Force Civil Engineering Center, Tyndall AFB, Florida (1976).

Page 2

CANCELLED