AC 120-92D Safety Management Systems for Aviation Service Providers
This advisory circular (AC) provides information on implementing a Safety Management System (SMS) based on Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 5 for aviation service providers operating or applying for a certificate or Letter of Authorization (LOA) to operate under 14 CFR part 91, § 91.147 or part 121 or 135. This AC may also be used by aviation organizations interested in receiving Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) acknowledgement of their voluntary development and implementation of an SMS that meets part 5 requirements. Additionally, part 5 provides organizations with a method to meet the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Annex 19, Safety Management, framework for an SMS “acceptable to the State.” An SMS is an organization-wide, comprehensive, and preventive approach to ensuring system safety. An SMS includes a safety policy, promotion of a positive safety culture, formal methods for identifying hazards and mitigating risk, and assurance of the overall safety performance of aviation organizations. An SMS is intended to be designed and developed so the aviation organization’s employees are able to manage risks as a part of the operations and business decision-making processes. An SMS assists an aviation organization’s leadership, management teams, and employees in making effective and informed safety decisions. Part 5 specifies a basic set of processes integral to an effective SMS but does not specify particular methods for implementing these processes. In other words, it defines what must be accomplished but not how it must be accomplished. This AC provides guidance on how an SMS may be developed to achieve the safety performance objectives outlined by an aviation organization. As is demonstrated by this AC, there is no one-size-fits-all method for complying with the requirements of part 5 or establishing a voluntary SMS. This is intentional because the FAA expects each organization to develop an SMS that works for their unique operation. This AC provides guidance regarding designing, developing, and implementing an SMS and the acceptable methods of compliance with the requirements of part 5 as well as developing a voluntary SMS. However, these methods are not the only means of complying with part 5 or implementing a voluntary SMS.
U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration
Advisory Circular
Subject: Safety Management Systems for
Aviation Service Providers
Date: 5/21/24 AC No: 120-92D Initiated by: AFS-900 Change:
This advisory circular (AC) provides information on implementing a Safety Management System (SMS) based on Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 5 for aviation service providers operating or applying for a certificate or Letter of Authorization (LOA) to operate under 14 CFR part 91, § 91.147 or part 121 or 135. This AC may also be used by aviation organizations interested in receiving Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) acknowledgement of their voluntary development and implementation of an SMS that meets part 5 requirements. Additionally, part 5 provides organizations with a method to meet the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Annex 19, Safety Management, framework for an SMS “acceptable to the State.”
An SMS is an organization-wide, comprehensive, and preventive approach to ensuring system safety. An SMS includes a safety policy, promotion of a positive safety culture, formal methods for identifying hazards and mitigating risk, and assurance of the overall safety performance of aviation organizations. An SMS is intended to be designed and developed so the aviation organization’s employees are able to manage risks as a part of the operations and business decision-making processes. An SMS assists an aviation organization’s leadership, management teams, and employees in making effective and informed safety decisions.
Part 5 specifies a basic set of processes integral to an effective SMS but does not specify particular methods for implementing these processes. In other words, it defines what must be accomplished but not how it must be accomplished. This AC provides guidance on how an SMS may be developed to achieve the safety performance objectives outlined by an aviation organization. As is demonstrated by this AC, there is no one-size-fits-all method for complying with the requirements of part 5 or establishing a voluntary SMS. This is intentional because the FAA expects each organization to develop an SMS that works for their unique operation. This AC provides guidance regarding designing, developing, and implementing an SMS and the acceptable methods of compliance with the requirements of part 5 as well as developing a voluntary SMS. However, these methods are not the only means of complying with part 5 or implementing a voluntary SMS.
Hugh Thomas for Lawrence Fields Executive Director, Flight Standards Service
ii
CONTENTS Paragraph Page
Chapter 1. Introduction … 1-1
1.1 Purpose of This Advisory Circular (AC) … 1-1
1.2 Audience … 1-1
1.3 Where You Can Find This AC … 1-2
1.4 What This AC Cancels … 1-2
1.5 Effective Date … 1-2
1.6 Implementation Strategies … 1-2
1.7 Contact Information … 1-2
1.8 Terminology … 1-2
1.9 AC Feedback Form … 1-2
Chapter 2. Safety Management System (SMS) Foundations … 2-1
2.1 SMS Fundamentals … 2-1
2.2 Conceptual Overview of Safety Assurance and SRM … 2-2
2.3 Safety Assurance and Interactions With SRM … 2-3
2.4 SRM … 2-4
2.5 Safety Culture and Safety Management … 2-5
2.6 Definitions … 2-6
Chapter 3. Safety Management System (SMS) Components Explained … 3-1
3.1 Overview of This Chapter … 3-1
3.2 Subpart A, General … 3-2
3.3 Subpart B, Safety Policy … 3-11
3.4 Subpart C, Safety Risk Management … 3-26
3.5 Subpart D, Safety Assurance … 3-43
3.6 Subpart E, Safety Promotion … 3-59
3.7 Subpart F, SMS Documentation and Recordkeeping … 3-63
Chapter 4. Implementation: Building A Safety Management System (SMS) … 4-1
4.1 Process Overview … 4-1
4.2 Building an SMS … 4-1
iii
Chapter 5. Integrating Existing Safety Programs Into the Safety Management
System (SMS) … 5-1
5.1 Purpose of This Chapter … 5-1
5.2 Discussion of Individual Programs … 5-1
5.3 Use of Third-Party Providers to Assist in SMS Implementation and Maintenance … 5-4
Appendix A. SMS Cross-Reference From Part 5 to the ICAO Framework … A-1
Appendix B. Sample Safety Risk Management (SRM) Worksheets … B-1
Appendix C. Guidance for Developing a Safety Policy and Code of Ethics Statement … C-1
Appendix D. Guidance for Developing a Compliance Statement … D-1
Appendix E. Identifying the Accountable Executive … E-1
Appendix F. Safety Attributes … F-1
Appendix G. Small Operator Implementation … G-1
Appendix H. References and Additional Information … H-1
Appendix I. Acronyms and Abbreviations … I-1
List of Figures
Figure 2-1. Safety Management Decision-Making Processes … 2-3
Figure 3-1. Hazard Notification Process … 3-41
Figure B-1. Safety Risk Management Triggering Conditions and Summary … B-2
Figure B-2. System Analysis … B-3
Figure B-3. Hazard List … B-4
Figure B-4. Risk Analysis … B-5
Figure B-5. Risk Analysis and Assessment Summary … B-6
Figure B-6. Risk Control … B-7
Figure B-7. Risk Control Documentation … B-8
Figure C-1. Sample Safety Policy and Code of Ethics Statement … C-2
Figure E-1. Accountable Executive Decision Process … E-2
Figure E-2. Verifying the Accountable Executive … E-3
iv
List of Tables
Table 3-1. Sample Risk Matrix … 3-34
Table A-1. Part 5 to ICAO SMS Framework Cross-Reference … A-1
Table D-1. Sample Compliance Statement for Aviation Organizations That Are
Required to Maintain a Manual System … D-2
Table D-2. Sample Compliance Statement for Aviation Organizations That Are
Not Required to Maintain a Manual System … D-3
Table F-1. Safety Attributes and Part 5 Reference … F-6
Table G-1. Small Aviation Organization Implementation Strategies and Considerations … G-2
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION › 1.2 Audience.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Purpose of This Advisory Circular (AC). This AC provides information to assist aviation organizations including but not limited to those regulated under Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) parts 91, 121, 125, 133, 135, 137, 141, 142, 145, and 147 in developing a Safety Management System (SMS) that meets the regulatory requirements of 14 CFR part 5 or in developing a voluntary SMS. It describes an acceptable means, but not the only means, to implement and maintain an SMS. Complying with part 5 assists organizations in meeting the SMS standards of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), as published in ICAO Annex 19, Safety Management.1 The contents of this document do not have the force and effect of law and are not meant to bind the public in any way, and the document is intended only to provide information to the public regarding existing requirements under the law or agency policies. This AC may also be used by aviation organizations interested in developing a voluntary SMS.
1 ICAO safety management standards require service providers of airplanes over 27,000 kilograms (kg) to include a Flight Data Analysis (FDA) program as part of their SMS. Part 5 does not require these programs. However, operators desiring to implement a flight operations quality assurance (FOQA) (the FAA equivalent to FDA) program on a voluntary basis can obtain FAA approval for these programs. For more information, refer to AC 120-82, Flight Operational Quality Assurance.
1.1.1 Integration. An SMS is not meant to be a separate system built alongside or on top of other business systems. An SMS should be integrated into existing business structures to support system safety. A properly integrated SMS fosters a fundamental and sustainable change in how aviation organizations view and analyze data and information, how informed decisions are made, and how new operational and business methods are developed. An effective SMS can assist aviation organizations in meeting other regulatory requirements. However, aviation organizations that develop an SMS meeting part 5 requirements should remain aware that an SMS is not a substitute for compliance with other Federal regulations.
Note: It is not the intent or purpose of an SMS to override any existing regulatory standards or alter approval and acceptance processes that already apply to the aviation organization. SMS requirements are in addition to any existing statutory or regulatory obligations.
1.2 Audience. This AC is directed to the following aviation organizations operating under 14 CFR who are designing, developing, and implementing an SMS:
1. Existing and prospective Air Carrier Certificate holders and Letter of Authorization (LOA) holders to whom part 5 is applicable (part 91, § 91.147 and parts 121 and 135).
2. Other aviation organizations such as, but not limited to, parts 91, 125, 133, 137, 141, 142, 145, and 147 who may want a Federal Aviation Administration (FAA)-acknowledged voluntary SMS.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION › 1.9 AC Feedback Form.
1.3 Where You Can Find This AC. You can find this AC on the FAA’s website at https://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/advisory_circulars and the Dynamic Regulatory System (DRS) at https://drs.faa.gov.
1.4 What This AC Cancels. AC 120-92B, Safety Management Systems for Aviation Service Providers, dated January 8, 2015, is canceled.
1.5 Effective Date. The effective date of this AC is May 28, 2024.
1.6 Implementation Strategies. As a performance-based rule, part 5 describes a desired end state but does not generally prescribe the means for achieving that end state. Because aviation organizations range widely in complexity, each aviation organization implementing an SMS to comply with part 5 should tailor its SMS policies, methods, and procedures as needed. This concept is widely referred to as scalability. Although an aviation organization is free to adjust its means of achieving compliance with all sections of part 5, this scalability does not allow the aviation organization to set aside any sections of part 5. This AC will provide useful considerations and some examples of how an aviation organization may integrate new practical, economical, and effective SMS methods and procedures that complement their existing operations and processes while leveraging the policies, procedures, or methods already in place that comply with part 5.
1.7 Contact Information. For additional information or suggestions, contact the Safety Analysis and Promotion Division, Flight Standards Safety Management System (SMS) Program Office at [email protected].
1.8 Terminology. Throughout this AC, the term “aviation organization” is used. The FAA uses this term to mean the operator, service provider, certificate holder (CH), or other entity subject to or voluntarily complying with part 5 requirements.
1.9 AC Feedback Form. For your convenience, the AC Feedback Form is the last page of this AC. Note any deficiencies found, clarifications needed, or suggested improvements regarding the contents of this AC on the Feedback Form.
2.1 SMS Fundamentals. › 2.1.6 Summary.
CHAPTER 2. SAFETY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (SMS) FOUNDATIONS
2.1 SMS Fundamentals.
2.1.1 What is an SMS? An SMS is a formal, top-down, organization-wide approach to managing safety risk and assuring the effectiveness of safety risk controls. It includes systematic procedures, practices, and policies for the management of safety risk. An SMS does not have to be an extensive, expensive, or sophisticated array of techniques to do what it is supposed to do. Rather, an SMS is built by structuring safety management around four components: safety policy, Safety Risk Management (SRM), safety assurance, and safety promotion. A brief description of these components is provided below.
2.1.2 Safety Policy. Safety policy is where an aviation organization sets objectives, assigns responsibilities, and sets standards for the organization and employees. It is also where management conveys its commitment to the safety performance of the organization to its employees. As SRM and safety assurance processes are developed, the aviation organization revisits the safety policy to ensure that the commitments in the policy are being realized and the standards are being upheld.
2.1.3 Safety Risk Management (SRM). The SRM component provides a decision-making process for identifying hazards and mitigating risk based on a thorough understanding of the organization’s systems and their operating environment. SRM includes decision making regarding what level of safety risk is acceptable. The SRM component is the organization’s way of fulfilling its commitment to consider risk in their operations and to eliminate risk or reduce it to an acceptable level. In that sense, SRM is a design process and a way to incorporate risk controls into processes, products, and services or to redesign controls where existing ones are not meeting the organization’s expectations.
2.1.4 Safety Assurance. Safety assurance provides aviation organizations with the necessary processes to promote confidence that the system is meeting defined safety objectives and that implemented mitigations or existing risk controls are working. In safety assurance, the goal is to monitor what is going on and review what has happened to ensure safety objectives are being met. Thus, safety assurance requires monitoring and measuring safety performance of operational processes and continuously improving the level of safety performance. Strong safety assurance processes will yield information used to maintain the integrity of risk controls. Safety assurance processes are thus a means of assuring the safety performance of the organization, keeping it on track, and identifying needs for rethinking (or correcting) existing processes.
2.1.5 Safety Promotion. The last component, safety promotion, is designed to ensure that employees have a solid understanding regarding their safety responsibilities and the aviation organization’s safety policies and expectations, reporting procedures, and risk controls. Thus, training and communication are key areas of safety promotion.
2.1.6 Summary. An SMS does not have to be large, complex, or expensive in order to add value. Active involvement of operational leaders, maintaining open lines of
2.2 Conceptual Overview of Safety Assurance and SRM. › 2.2.1 Graphical Overview of Safety Assurance and SRM Processes.
communication up and down the aviation organization and among peers, staying vigilant in looking for new hazards and identifying associated risks, and ensuring that employees know that safety is an essential part of their job performance are key elements that can have a positive effect on the aviation organization’s SRM decisions.
2.2 Conceptual Overview of Safety Assurance and SRM.
2.2.1 Graphical Overview of Safety Assurance and SRM Processes. Figure 2-1, Safety Management Decision-Making Processes, provides an expanded view of the principal processes of the SMS: safety assurance and SRM. In the discussion that follows, some key terms and concepts related to SMS processes will be introduced. A more detailed discussion of the SRM and safety assurance processes is presented below each regulatory requirement in Chapter 3, Safety Management System (SMS) Components Explained. Because safety management is a decision-making process, SRM and safety assurance follow a structured set of processes outlined in Figure 2-1.
2.3 Safety Assurance and Interactions With SRM. › 2.3.1 Safety assurance processes monitor the day-to-day life cycle of…
Figure 2-1. Safety Management Decision-Making Processes
2.3 Safety Assurance and Interactions With SRM.
2.3.1 Safety assurance processes monitor the day-to-day life cycle of system operations, (System Monitoring) with the designed risk controls in place. A variety of data sources (Data Acquisition), such as audits, investigations, and employee reporting, are utilized. These will be further explained in Chapter 3. The safety assurance process involves
2.4 SRM. › 2.4.3 The process owner then conducts an analysis of the potential…
several steps. Once the data has been obtained, the process owner analyzes the data that will be used in decision making (Analysis of Data). The decision making can result in several possible outcomes (System Assessment). If the data and analysis indicate the processes, procedures, and integrated risk controls are functioning as intended, the result is satisfactory, and management can have confidence that organizational goals and safety objectives are being met.
2.3.2 If a negative result is identified, the organization should continue the analysis to determine if the shortfall is due to the controls not being used as intended (e.g., required training not accomplished, procedures not followed, or improper tools or equipment provided). If a negative result is identified and the system is being used as intended, the system is not producing the expected results. In the former case, action should be taken to correct the problem (Corrective Action). In the latter case, system design should be reconsidered using the path back to the SRM process.
2.3.3 The identification of a new hazard or ineffective risk control during the safety assurance process requires an organization to initiate the SRM process. For organizations transitioning into an SMS, the SRM process may initially be challenging if their operational systems have not been built using a risk management process because they may lack formal or well-understood risk controls.
2.3.4 Managers or process owners who are responsible for operational processes are also responsible for assuring that their process areas are performing as intended from an aviation safety standpoint.
2.4 SRM.
2.4.1 In SRM, the first step, System Analysis, is used to understand the processes and procedures being developed or revised or where new hazards or changes of the operational environment have been identified. The system analysis needs to consider the operating environment, the personnel involved in the operation, the equipment being used, any training needed, operational procedures, and interfaces with other processes or procedures. In most cases, hazard identification flows from this system analysis. Hazard identification requires process owners to ask questions such as:
1. What hazards exist in the operational environment?
2. What are the human factors (HF) issues of the operation (e.g., workload, distraction, fatigue, or system complexity)?
3. What are the limitations of the hardware, software, procedures, etc.?
2.4.2 Although Figure 2-1 above depicts these processes as distinctly defined components, they flow from one to the other in practice. For example, in a careful discussion of how a system currently works (System Analysis), hazards will often become evident. Thus, the Hazard Identification step has also been at least partially accomplished.
2.4.3 The process owner then conducts an analysis of the potential consequences of operation in the presence of the identified hazards (Risk Analysis). This culminates in an
2.5 Safety Culture and Safety Management. › 2.5.2 Just Culture.
assessment of the acceptability of operating with these hazards (Risk Assessment) or whether or not the risk of such operations can be eliminated or mitigated to an acceptable level (Risk Control). Operational managers or process owners2 must be the ones who are accountable for risk acceptance and mitigation decisions.
2 An organization may need to identify those personnel who “manage processes” but are not necessarily managers with a place on the organizational chart. Field experience has proven that the process owner terminology is necessary to allow aviation organizations to develop protocols that keep simple design change decisions at the level appropriate to the acceptance of risk.
2.4.4 After a system has been designed or revised using the SRM process, special attention should be given to the new or revised system using the safety assurance process. It should not be surprising to find at this time that there are still things that might not have been considered or that there are changes over time in the operational environment that require a return to SRM. Thus, the SRM and safety assurance processes operate in a continuous exchange.
2.5 Safety Culture and Safety Management. The culture of an organization is demonstrated through the organization’s values, traits, and behaviors. The term “safety culture” is used to describe those aspects of the organization’s culture relating to its safety performance. An organization that has a positive safety culture embraces open communication and continuous improvement. Management’s consistent attention, commitment, involvement, and visible leadership are essential in guiding an organization toward a positive safety culture. A positive safety culture matures as safety management skills are learned, practiced, and become second nature across the entire organization. The following are practices and characteristics of organizations that foster a positive safety culture.
2.5.1 Open Reporting. Organizations should have policies and processes that foster open reporting while stressing the need for continuous diligence and professionalism. Organizations should encourage disclosure of error without fear of reprisal (as long as the issue being reported was not caused through intentional misconduct or gross negligence) and should demand accountability on the part of employees and management alike. Part 5 requirements include provisions for aviation organizations to discuss hazard reporting in their safety policy (part 5, § 5.21(a)(4)) and in their safety assurance processes (§ 5.71(a)(7)).
2.5.2 Just Culture. The organization should engage in identification of systemic errors, implement preventative corrective action, and exhibit intolerance of undesirable behaviors, such as intentional misconduct or willful disregard for established procedures. This is often referred to as a “just culture.” A just culture can be defined as a values-centered model of shared accountability, which will result in higher levels of confidence in safety outcomes at all levels of an organization. Organizations with a just culture encourage open communication that is nonretributive and encourages employees to admit mistakes so corrective actions can be implemented and potential hazards reduced. The following characteristics have an effect on an organization’s just culture.
2.6 Definitions. The following definitions are used throughout this AC. › 2.6.1 Compliance Statement.
2.5.2.1 Personnel Involvement. Involvement of personnel at all levels of an organization is critical to effective safety management. All employees who are directly involved with aviation safety play a key role in hazard identification and open communication.
2.5.2.2 Use of Information. Effective use of relevant information ensures informed management decision making.
2.5.2.3 Commitment to Risk Reduction. Management directly involves itself in identifying hazards and managing risk.
2.5.2.4 Vigilance. Processes that monitor ongoing operations and the environment increase effectiveness of risk controls and awareness of emerging hazards.
2.5.2.5 Flexibility. The organization uses information effectively to adjust and change to reduce risk and is willing to commit resources to making changes necessary to reduce risk.
2.5.2.6 Learning. The organization learns from its own failures and from those of allied and similar businesses. The organization uses acquired data to feed analysis processes and assess performance, the results of which yield information that can be acted on to improve safety.
2.5.2.7 Code of Ethics. A code of ethics is a set of principles designed to help aviation professionals conduct aviation operations honestly, with integrity, and with safe operations at the core of all decisions.
2.5.2.8 Safety Attributes. System safety attributes are the core characteristics that are integrated into all processes and procedures. For additional discussion, see Appendix F, Safety Attributes.
2.5.3 Management Involvement. An organization’s employees look to executive leadership to demonstrate their visible commitment to and involvement in safe operation while performing their daily work. SMS processes do not have to be expensive or sophisticated; however, active personal involvement of operational leaders is essential. Effective safety management is accomplished by those individuals who “own” the processes in which risk resides. Safety cultures also cannot be “created” or “implemented” by management decree no matter how sincere their intentions. Every organization has a safety culture. It is embodied in the way the organization and its members approach safety in their jobs. If positive aspects of culture are to emerge, the organization’s senior management must set up the policies and processes that create a working environment that fosters safe behavior, and they should lead by example.
2.6 Definitions. The following definitions are used throughout this AC.
2.6.1 Compliance Statement. A document developed by an aviation organization that states how the organization complies with part 5. For specific information on developing a
compliance statement, see Appendix D, Guidance for Developing a Compliance Statement.
2.6.2 Declaration of Compliance. A document submitted to the FAA that declares the aviation organization has developed and implemented an SMS in compliance with part 5 whether required by regulation or implemented voluntarily.
2.6 Definitions. The following definitions are used throughout this AC. › 2.6.13 Safety Promotion.
2.6.3 Hazard. A condition or an object that could foreseeably cause or contribute to an incident or aircraft accident as defined in Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations (49 CFR) part 830, § 830.2.
2.6.4 Person. The term “person” is defined in 14 CFR part 1, § 1.1 as “an individual, firm, partnership, corporation, company, association, joint-stock association, or governmental entity. It includes a trustee, receiver, assignee, or similar representative of any of them.” This definition includes certificate holders (CH), service providers, or other types of individuals or business entities and is used throughout 14 CFR. For the purposes of part 5, the term “person” can be used to refer to an individual or to an aviation organization.
2.6.5 Process Owner. The individual responsible for ensuring that one or more process areas are performing as intended from an aviation safety standpoint.
2.6.6 Risk. The composite of predicted severity and likelihood of the potential effect of a hazard.
2.6.7 Risk Control. A means to reduce or eliminate the effects of hazards.
2.6.8 Safety Assurance. Processes within the SMS that function systematically to ensure the performance and effectiveness of safety risk controls and that the organization meets or exceeds its safety objectives through the collection, analysis, and assessment of information.
2.6.9 Safety Management System (SMS). The formal, top-down, organization-wide approach to managing safety risk and ensuring the effectiveness of safety risk controls. It includes systematic procedures, practices, and policies for the management of safety risk.
2.6.10 Safety Objective. A measurable goal or desirable outcome related to safety.
2.6.11 Safety Performance. Realized or actual safety accomplishment relative to the organization’s safety objectives.
2.6.12 Safety Policy. The person’s documented commitment to safety, which defines their safety objectives and the accountabilities and responsibilities of its employees in regard to safety.
2.6.13 Safety Promotion. A combination of training and communication of safety information to support the implementation and operation of an SMS in an organization.
2.6 Definitions. The following definitions are used throughout this AC. › 2.6.15 System Safety.
2.6.14 Safety Risk Management (SRM). A process within the SMS composed of describing the system, identifying the hazards, and analyzing, assessing, and controlling risk.
2.6.15 System Safety. The application of technical and managerial skills to the systematic, forward-looking identification and control of hazards throughout the life cycle of a project, program, or activity. The primary objective of system safety is accident prevention.
3.1.4 Implementation Strategies. › 3.1.4.1 A short discussion, where applicable, of potential methods…
CHAPTER 3. SAFETY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (SMS) COMPONENTS
EXPLAINED
3.1 Overview of This Chapter. SMS requirements are organized around the four components of safety management. These components are broken down into subparts of 14 CFR part 5 (e.g., Part 5 Subpart B, Safety Policy). This chapter contains a description of each SMS requirement contained in part 5. After the title of each requirement, where appropriate, the following information is provided.
3.1.1 References. This paragraph contains references for part 5. Where applicable, other related regulatory requirements are provided for cross-reference purposes. These other regulatory references are hyperlinked for ease of access.
3.1.2 Regulatory Text Box. A copy of the part 5 regulatory text for reference. The discussions in this chapter apply equally to aviation organizations subject to part 5 requirements and those seeking to implement a voluntary SMS.
Note 1: The word “person” in the regulatory text box typically refers to the aviation organization. When a specific individual is required to be identified, the regulatory language will use the term “individual.”
Note 2: This AC does not include guidance on part 5 regulations applicable only to type certificate holders (TCH) and licensees and production certificate holders (CH) under 14 CFR part 21. For information applicable to aircraft certification products and service providers, refer to AC 21-58, Safety Management Systems for Part 21 Type and Production Certificate Holders.
3.1.3 Discussion. A more detailed plain language explanation of the process as it relates to the SMS. It includes some examples, when appropriate, and offers optional recommended design characteristics.
3.1.4 Implementation Strategies.
3.1.4.1 A short discussion, where applicable, of potential methods different-sized aviation organizations could use to meet the pertinent SMS requirements that could be scaled to the size and complexity of their organization. The Safety Management International Collaboration Group (SM ICG) SMS for Small Organizations3 document defines a small organization as one with between 5 and 20 staff and a very small organization as one with less than 5 staff. The FAA has not defined these organizations because an SMS is designed to be adaptable based on the size and complexity of the organization. So, it is possible for an organization to be very small but highly complex, and a large organization could be low complexity based on the aviation activity they are involved with.
3 SM ICG guidance documents can be downloaded from https://skybrary.aero/enhancing-safety/sm-icg-safetymanagement-products.
3.2.1 Applicability: Who Is Required to Implement an SMS. › 3.2.1.1 References.
3.1.4.2 Aviation organizations are each unique, not only in organizational structure and the equipment operated and maintained but also in management structure and, very often, in management style. Therefore, a one-size-fits-all approach to scaling the aviation organization’s response to each section of part 5 is not advisable. This AC stresses the importance of recognizing aviation organizations have different operational environments and different levels of resources. Less complex organizations could use simple methods for conducting the processes within the SMS. More complex organizations may require more detailed processes within the SMS.
3.1.4.3 For organizations that have only a single pilot or technician and perhaps minimal support staff to carry out daily responsibilities, this AC suggests utilizing a commonsense approach to SMS implementation and maintenance. In the case of a single-pilot operator, that single pilot could be the one to develop, implement, and use the SMS processes. At medium and large organizations, the complexity and departmentalization of duties may require that more personnel be involved in the SMS. Regardless of the organization’s size, many aviation organizations will find their existing processes and procedures can serve as the foundation for portions of their SMS. Integration of these existing processes should be used as much as practical.
Note: Implementation strategy discussions are for illustration only and neither impose requirements nor mandate specific resource allocation by an aviation organization. Aviation organizations should integrate methods and procedures that best fit their organizational structure and that leverage processes and procedures already in place to the greatest extent possible.
3.1.5 Considerations for Small and Single-Individual Organizations. Where appropriate, additional guidance and recommendations are provided for small and single-individual organizations.
3.1.6 Example. Throughout this chapter, we will use fictional aviation service provider Flyslow Aviation as an example of how a typical organization could integrate part 5 requirements into their operations.
3.2 Subpart A, General.
3.2.1 Applicability: Who Is Required to Implement an SMS.
3.2.1.1 References. Section 5.1 and 14 CFR part 91, § 91.147 and part 119, § 119.8.
3.2.2 Definitions. › 3.2.2.2 Part 5 Requirement.
3.2.1.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.1, Applicability. This part applies to all of the following:
(a) Any person that holds or applies for a certificate issued under part 119 of this chapter
authorizing the person to conduct operations under part 121 of this chapter. (b) Any person that holds or applies for a certificate issued under part 119 of this chapter
authorizing the person to conduct operations under part 135 of this chapter. (c) Any person that holds or applies for a Letter of Authorization issued under § 91.147 of this
chapter.
3.2.1.3 Discussion. SMSs should be applied to the aviation operational processes of the organization. For example, the aviation operational processes in a typical aviation organization may include:
• Flight operations,
• Operational control (dispatch/flight following),
• Maintenance and inspection,
• Parts receiving inspections,
• Calibrated tooling procedures,
• Cabin safety,
• Ground handling and servicing,
• Cargo handling,
• Training, and
• Recordkeeping.
Note: Information concerning implementation planning for aviation organizations wanting to develop an SMS under part 5 is outlined in greater detail in Chapter 4, Implementation: Building a Safety Management System (SMS).
3.2.2 Definitions.
3.2.2.1 References. Section 5.3.
3.2.2.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.3, Definitions.
Hazard means a condition or an object that could foreseeably cause or contribute to an incident or aircraft accident, as defined in 49 CFR 830.2. Risk means the composite of predicted severity and likelihood of the potential effect of a hazard.
3.2.3 General Requirements. › 3.2.3.3 Discussion.
Risk control means a means to reduce or eliminate the effects of hazards. Safety assurance means processes within the SMS that function systematically to ensure the performance and effectiveness of safety risk controls and that the organization meets or exceeds its safety objectives through the collection, analysis, and assessment of information. Safety Management System (SMS) means the formal, top-down, organization-wide approach to managing safety risk and assuring the effectiveness of safety risk controls. It includes systematic procedures, practices, and policies for the management of safety risk. Safety objective means a measurable goal or desirable outcome related to safety. Safety performance means realized or actual safety accomplishment relative to the organization’s safety objectives. Safety policy means the person’s documented commitment to safety, which defines its safety objectives and the accountabilities and responsibilities of its employees in regards to safety. Safety promotion means a combination of training and communication of safety information to support the implementation and operation of an SMS in an organization. Safety Risk Management means a process within the SMS composed of describing the system, identifying the hazards, and analyzing, assessing, and controlling risk.
3.2.2.3 Discussion. These definitions apply to the use of these terms throughout part 5.
3.2.3 General Requirements.
3.2.3.1 References. Section 5.5.
3.2.3.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.5, General requirements.
(a) SMS components. An SMS under this part must be appropriate to the size, scope, and
complexity of the person’s organization and include, at a minimum, all of the following components: (1) Safety policy that meets the requirements of subpart B of this part. (2) Safety risk management that meets the requirements of subpart C of this part. (3) Safety assurance that meets the requirements of subpart D of this part. (4) Safety promotion that meets the requirements of subpart E of this part. (b) Continuing requirements. Any person required to develop and implement an SMS under this
part must maintain the SMS in accordance with this part.
3.2.3.3 Discussion. Implementing an effective SMS requires an organization to fully understand its structure, processes, business arrangements, and interfaces that impact the Safety Risk Management (SRM) of aviation safety. While not regulatory, developing an organizational description should be the first step in SMS development. An organizational description is a summary of the organization’s processes, activities, and interfaces that need to be considered as a part of their SMS. It describes the aviation system, the interfaces within the organization, and the interfaces with external organizations that contribute to the safe delivery of aviation services. As organizations mature and grow, it is important to ensure the SMS continues to adapt and remain effective to changing requirements. Reviewing the organizational description and
3.2.4 Requirements for Domestic, Flag, and Supplemental Operations. › 3.2.4.3 Discussion.
interfaces that may have changed as well as updating operational processes and procedures ensures the aviation organization’s SMS continues to perform as designed.
3.2.4 Requirements for Domestic, Flag, and Supplemental Operations.
3.2.4.1 References. Sections 5.7 and 119.8.
3.2.4.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.7, Requirements for domestic, flag, and supplemental operations.
(a) Any person authorized to conduct operations under part 121 of this chapter that has an SMS
acceptable to the FAA on or before May 28, 2024, must revise its SMS to meet the requirements of this part no later than May 28, 2025. (b) Any person applying for authorization to conduct operations under part 121 of this chapter or
with such application pending on or after May 28, 2024, must develop and implement an SMS that meets the requirements of this part. (c) Any person required to develop and implement an SMS under this section must maintain the
SMS as long as the person is authorized to conduct operations under part 121 of this chapter. (d) Any person required to develop and implement an SMS under this section must make available
to the Administrator, upon request, all necessary information and data that demonstrates that the person has an SMS that meets the requirements set forth in this part.
3.2.4.3 Discussion.
3.2.4.3.1 Title 14 CFR part 121 aviation organizations are required to meet updated part 5 requirements within 12 months of the effective date of this rule. Part 121 operators are required to revise their SMS to meet the new requirements in § 5.3 (definitions) by updating the definition of “hazard” and in §§ 5.21(a)(7) (safety policy code of ethics), 5.53(b)(5) (SRM interfaces), 5.57 (notification of hazards to interfacing persons), 5.71(a)(7) (employee confidential reporting system), 5.71(a)(8) (investigations of hazard notifications that have been received from external sources), and 5.97(d) (SMS records). Part 121 aviation organizations will provide any required revisions to their SMS processes in accordance with existing submission procedures.
3.2.4.3.2 New part 121 applicants must meet part 5 requirements as a part of the certification process as defined in the Air Operator and Air Agency Certification and Application Process in FAA Order 8900.1, Volume 2, Chapter 4, The Certification Process—Title 14 CFR Part 135.4 The certification project manager (CPM) will brief the new applicants on the SMS requirements during initial meetings. For guidance on preparing a compliance
4 Order 8900.1 is available online on the FAA’s Dynamic Regulatory System (DRS) at https://drs.faa.gov/.
3.2.5 Requirements for Commuter and On-Demand Operations or… › 3.2.5.3 Discussion.
statement, see Appendix D, Guidance for Developing a Compliance Statement.
3.2.5 Requirements for Commuter and On-Demand Operations or Passenger-Carrying Flights for Compensation or Hire.
3.2.5.1 References. Sections 5.9, 91.147, and 119.8.
3.2.5.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.9, Requirements for commuter and on-demand operations or passenger-carrying flights for compensation or hire.
(a) Any person authorized to conduct operations under part 135 of this chapter or that holds a
Letter of Authorization issued under § 91.147 of this chapter before May 28, 2024, must: (1) Develop and implement an SMS that meets the requirements of this part no later than
May 28, 2027. (2) Submit to the FAA, a declaration of compliance with this part in a form and manner
acceptable to the Administrator no later than May 28, 2027. (b) Any person applying for authorization to conduct operations under part 135 of this chapter or a
Letter of Authorization under § 91.147 of this chapter, or with such application pending on or after May 28, 2024, must develop and implement an SMS that meets the requirements of this part. (c) Any person required to develop and implement an SMS under this section must maintain the
SMS as long as the person is authorized to conduct operations under either part 135 or § 91.147 of this chapter. (d) Any person required to develop and implement an SMS under this section must make available
to the Administrator, upon request, all necessary information and data that demonstrates that the person has an SMS that meets the requirements set forth in this part.
3.2.5.3 Discussion. Within 36 months of the effective date of the part 5 requirements, 14 CFR part 135 and § 91.147 air tour operators with a Letter of Authorization (LOA) must submit a declaration of compliance to their FAA certificate management office (CMO) as evidence the organization has met the requirements of part 5.
3.2.5.3.1 A declaration of compliance is a legal document that states the aviation organization has developed and implemented an SMS that meets the part 5 requirements.
3.2.5.3.2 A declaration of compliance must contain the following information:
1. The name of the aviation organization and its certificate number (if applicable).
2. The physical address of the aviation organization.
3. A statement that the aviation organization has developed and implemented an SMS that meets the requirements of part 5.
3.2.6 Single-Pilot SMS Exceptions. › 3.2.6.2 Part 5 Requirement.
3.2.5.3.3 The declaration of compliance must be signed by the accountable executive or another senior member of management.
3.2.5.3.4 Once the FAA receives the declaration of compliance, the CMO will update the organization’s status in an internal FAA database noting that they have an SMS or a voluntary SMS that meets part 5 requirements. Validation of SMS performance will occur as a part of routine surveillance activities. Areas found deficient will be addressed using existing methods for ensuring compliance with the regulatory requirements.
3.2.5.3.5 Upon development and implementation of an SMS, if an operator that has an existing SMS through a voluntary SMS or a third-party provider realizes a manual change is required, then they must submit those changes in accordance with existing regulations and procedures.
3.2.5.3.6 Organizations not required to maintain a manual system need to document their SMS policies and procedures as well as record outputs of their SRM and safety assurance processes in accordance with §§ 5.95 and 5.97.
3.2.5.3.7 New part 135 applicants must meet part 5 requirements as a part of the certification process. The CPM will brief the new applicants on the SMS requirements during initial meetings. For guidance on preparation of a compliance statement, see Appendix D. More information on the certification process is contained in the Air Operator and Air Agency Certification and Application Process in Order 8900.1, Volume 2, Chapter 4.
3.2.5.3.8 New § 91.147 LOA applicants must meet part 5 requirements as part of the LOA issuance process as defined in § 91.147(b). Additional requirements for the issuance of LOA A049, Commercial Air Tour Operations Authorization and Drug and Alcohol Testing Program Registration, are described in Order 8900.1, Volume 3, Chapter 18, Operations Specifications.
3.2.6 Single-Pilot SMS Exceptions.
3.2.6.1 References. Section 5.9(e).
3.2.6.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.9, Requirements for commuter and on-demand operations or passenger-carrying flights for compensation or hire.
(e) The following requirements do not apply to those organizations with a single pilot who is the
sole individual performing all necessary functions in the conduct and execution related to, or in direct support of, the safe operation of the aircraft: §§ 5.21(a)(4), 5.21(a)(5), 5.21(c), 5.23(a)(2), 5.23(a)(3), 5.23(b), 5.25(b)(3), 5.25(c), 5.27(a), 5.27(b), 5.71(a)(7), 5.93, and 5.97(d) of this part.
3.2.6 Single-Pilot SMS Exceptions. › 3.2.6.3 Discussion.
3.2.6.3 Discussion.
3.2.6.3.1 Single-pilot operations and single-individual organizations pose unique situations when implementing an SMS. As a result of these factors, the following regulatory sections are excepted from the implementation requirements for organizations with a single pilot who is the sole individual performing all necessary functions in the conduct and execution related to, or in direct support of, the safe operation of aircraft.
1. Section 5.21(a)(4): A policy that defines the employee hazard reporting program.
2. Section 5.21(a)(5): A policy that defines unacceptable behavior and conditions for disciplinary action.
3. Section 5.21(c): A documented and communicated safety policy.
4. Section 5.23(a)(2): A requirement to identify all members of management in the organization.
5. Section 5.23(a)(3): A requirement to identify and define the safety accountability for all employees in the organization.
6. Section 5.23(b): Identifies the levels of management with the authority to make decisions regarding safety risk acceptance.
7. Section 5.25(b)(3): A requirement for the accountable executive to communicate the safety policy throughout the organization.
8. Section 5.25(c): Designation of management personnel.
9. Section 5.27(a): Delegation of emergency authority.
10. Section 5.27(b): Assignment of employee responsibilities during the emergency.
11. Section 5.71(a)(7): A requirement to have a confidential employee reporting program.
12. Section 5.93: A procedure for communicating safety-related information throughout the organization.
13. Section 5.97(d): A requirement to retain records of communications provided under § 5.93.
3.2.6.3.2 SMSs are important for organizations of all sizes. SMSs are designed to be scalable and flexible for organizations of various sizes and complexity; small organizations have different needs and challenges. In an organization such as one with a single pilot where a sole individual performs all necessary functions in the conduct and execution related to, or in direct support of, the safe operation of the aircraft, trying to meet every unique requirement defined in part 5 would not be feasible as some are written for multiperson organizations.
Note: Single-pilot organizations and those with a single individual responsible for the SMS of the organization that have excepted requirements will be further discussed in the specific discussions that follow. For example, a single individual might be the sole employee in a small repair station.
3.2.6.3.3 These exceptions are built around sole-individual organizations and provide relief from activities that would be typical in a multi-individual organization. If you look closely at the excepted sections of part 5, they are all addressing communication and some recordkeeping requirements. The excepted sections also address management duties and responsibilities throughout an organization that would not be present in a single-individual organization. These exceptions are limited to aviation organizations with a sole individual performing all necessary functions in the conduct and execution related to or in direct support of the safe operation of the aircraft. All necessary functions generally include the performance of work related to flight crewmember duties for part 135 and LOA holders under § 91.147. The Safety Management System Voluntary Program (SMSVP) will also provide this exception for other entities who are sole individuals performing all the necessary functions applicable to them (e.g., mechanics or repair stations conducting aircraft maintenance).
3.2.6.3.4 External vendors contracted to aid or provide a service (e.g., in routine aircraft handling, such as FBO services (fueling and towing) or airworthiness (annual inspections and unscheduled maintenance)) are not a part of the organization and would not have any bearing as to the applicability of these exceptions. These excepted areas would also apply to a repair station with a sole individual implementing a voluntary SMS. As an example, vendors contracted to maintain calibrated tools are not directly involved in the performance of the aviation service and would not be considered employees. These exceptions do not remove the requirements of § 5.57 for hazard information sharing or the receipt of hazard information in § 5.71(a)(8).
3.2.6.3.5 Determination of whether or not the exception applies can be determined by defining the organization requiring the SMS and who within the organization accomplishes all the necessary functions relating to or in direct support of the safe operation of the aircraft.
3.2.6.3.6 For example, part 145, § 145.151 requires designation of an accountable manager as well as definition of employees who perform the service. To have the exception, one person would have to act in all of these capacities, as well as be the accountable executive under part 5, as each has a role in the conduct and execution related to or in direct support of the safe operation of the aircraft.
3.2.7 General Applicability Example. › 3.2.7.2 To ensure part 5 is fully integrated into the organization,…
3.2.6.3.7 The following are the four key steps to determine if the excepted sections would apply to your organization:
1. Define the organizational structure. Is there more than one employee?
2. Identify the necessary functions.
3. Identify who is doing each function.
4. Is there more than one employee performing functions that could affect the safe operation of the product or service? If the answer is no, the excepted sections apply.
Note 1: An organization could have someone who does not do any of the necessary functions but does other tasks within the organization (e.g., accounting, invoicing, answering phones, and cleaning). In this situation, the exceptions may still apply.
Note 2: If the sole individual tracks and coordinates the completion of maintenance activities and utilizes a maintenance service provider to conduct those activities, such as annual inspections or unscheduled maintenance, the exception still applies. However, if the sole individual allows a service provider to track and/or coordinate the completion of maintenance activities, then the exception does not apply.
3.2.7 General Applicability Example.
3.2.7.1 To meet the requirement to implement an SMS, Flyslow Aviation starts by reviewing their organization to consider the operating environment, personnel needed, any interfaces with other organizations and facilities, and materials needed to provide their aviation service or product. They may identify flight operations, maintenance, dispatch, and training departments as areas that support the aviation product or service. They might also identify external organizations that support the aviation product or service, such as fuel service providers, third-party maintenance, and catering. All this information would be documented in an organizational description that can be used to ensure all aviation-related areas are considered in the SMS development.
3.2.7.2 To ensure part 5 is fully integrated into the organization, Flyslow Aviation may develop a compliance statement for their internal tracking to document how they already meet the requirements of part 5. While not required for existing operators, a compliance statement makes identifying existing processes and procedures as well as existing methods and voluntary programs easier to verify when documenting how an organization meets the regulatory requirements. This is accomplished for all departments and areas identified in the organizational description.
3.3.1 Safety Policy. › 3.3.1.3 Discussion.
3.3 Subpart B, Safety Policy.
3.3.1 Safety Policy.
3.3.1.1 References. Section 5.21.
3.3.1.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.21, Safety policy.
(a) Any person required to have an SMS under this part must have a safety policy that includes at
least the following: (1) The person’s safety objectives. (2) The person’s commitment to fulfill the safety objectives. (3) A clear statement about the provision of the necessary resources for the implementation of
the SMS. (4) A safety reporting policy that defines requirements for employee reporting of safety
hazards or issues. (5) A policy that defines unacceptable behavior and conditions for disciplinary action. (6) An emergency response plan that provides for the safe transition from normal to
emergency operations in accordance with the requirements of § 5.27. (7) A code of ethics that is applicable to all employees, including management personnel and
officers, which clarifies that safety is the organization’s highest priority. (b) The safety policy must be signed by the accountable executive described in § 5.25. (c) The safety policy must be documented and communicated throughout the person’s
organization. (d) The safety policy must be regularly reviewed by the accountable executive to ensure it remains
relevant and appropriate to the person.
3.3.1.3 Discussion. Part 5 requires aviation organizations to document their safety policy (where required). Many aviation organizations do this by using several documents to meet the requirements of this section. One technique used is to develop a safety policy and code of ethics statement, which is a concise document from the accountable executive that conveys the organization’s basic commitments to safety management. This document must include a code of ethics that specifies that safety is the organization’s highest priority and applies to all employees, including management personnel and officers. The safety policy and code of ethics statement should be viewed as a promotional document as it conveys the executive management’s commitment to safety and the organizational goals in communications to the workforce in a short one- or two-page document. It provides the basis for a more detailed setting of objectives for planning and performance measurement, assignment of responsibilities, and confidential hazard reporting, including clear statements regarding behavioral and performance expectations. Appendix C provides guidance on the development of a safety policy and code of ethics statement.
3.3.1.3.1 The safety policy and code of ethics statement may need to be supported by additional documentation that expands in some areas and, where applicable,
sets out specific organizational objectives and procedures. For aviation organizations not required to maintain manuals, the safety policy and code of ethics statement could be integrated into a compliance statement discussing how the organization meets the requirements. Some of these areas are the emergency response plan (ERP) and procedures for accessing and using the confidential hazard reporting program.
3.3.1.3.2 Section 5.21(a)(1) requires aviation organizations to develop safety objectives as part of their safety policy. Safety objectives should be measurable and not just inspirational statements, such as “We will strive to be the best,” “We will maintain a zero-accident rate,” etc. They may be based off key performance indicators or safety performance indicators and tracked by the safety assurance component of the organization’s SMS to ensure the organization’s objectives are being met. A technique that may work is to list the organization’s goals in the policy and point to the measurable safety objectives that support the goal(s) if they are located in another place in your manual system (if required).
3.3.1.3.3 The assessment process required by § 5.73 is where decisions are made regarding attainment of these objectives. In setting these objectives, this is a case where “starting with the end in sight” is sound advice.
3.3.1.3.4 Objectives can fall into a number of categories, including:
1. Compliance with regulations. Compliance with all applicable FAA regulations is an expectation for all aviation organizations, and assurance of such compliance is an explicit requirement of the SMS (refer to § 5.71(a)(6)).
2. Milestones for implementation of safety-related programs or initiatives. This is a good area for development of safety objectives, which are measurable and provide early successes that can be shared with the workforce.
3. Reduction of error or incident rates. This is also an area that is easily monitored, and success can be identified and shared with the workforce.
4. Increased employee involvement through hazard or incident reporting programs.
5. Tracking of safety events. Certain events such as aircraft ground damage, pilot deviations (PD), Weight and Balance (W&B) errors, or maintenance errors may be targets for safety objectives and associated tracking and action. One caution with these types of measures is not to lose focus on risk factors that may be associated with potentially more serious events.
3.3.1.3.5 A key consideration for scalability of safety objectives is the relevance and achievability for the size and complexity of the organization. The most effective safety objectives are those setting specific safety goals reflecting the
organization’s safety vision and the management’s commitment to the systematic management of safety. In order for their effectiveness to be measured, safety objectives should be SMART,5 which means they should be:
5 The first known use of the term occurs in the November 1981 issue of Management Review by George T. Doran.
Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Timely.
3.3.1.3.6 Aviation organizations must have documentation (where required) that defines the requirements for employee reporting of safety hazards or issues. Processes and procedures describing how this is to be accomplished must also be included in the documentation.
3.3.1.3.7 Unacceptable behavior and conditions for disciplinary action also need to be documented (where appropriate). Aviation organizations should explain that gross negligence or deliberate misconduct are not protected behaviors and will not be tolerated. This may be documented in their SMS processes and procedures or could be located elsewhere, such as in a human resources manual. In any case, employees need to be made aware of where this policy can be located.
3.3.1.3.8 Aviation organizations must develop an ERP, which ensures normal SMS functions and risk acceptance continues when key personnel are removed from their normal risk management positions. This should include a line of succession, where required, of management authority sufficient to respond to emergencies. This plan should also address transition to normal operations after the emergency condition subsides. Additional discussion is located in paragraph 3.3.5.
3.3.1.3.9 The safety policy must include a code of ethics that specifies that safety is the organization’s highest priority and applies to all employees, including management personnel and officers. This requirement, while originally mandated for manufacturers under the Aircraft Certification Safety and Accountability Act of 2020, has been applied to all aviation organizations that are required to have an SMS that meets part 5 requirements. For additional discussion on how to develop a safety policy and code of ethics statement, see Appendix C.
3.3.1.3.10 Part 5 requires the accountable executive to sign the safety policy and code of ethics statement. This may be accomplished by signing the safety policy and code of ethics statement, safety policy processes and procedures, or both. A signature on one or both documents is indicative of the accountable executive meeting this requirement. If the safety policy and code of ethics statement is
3.3.1 Safety Policy. › 3.3.1.4 Implementation Strategies.
incorporated into a compliance statement, the accountable executive must sign the compliance statement to meet the requirements of § 5.25(b)(2).
3.3.1.3.11 Aviation organizations are required to have documented processes and procedures describing how safety policy is communicated throughout the organization. This could be accomplished by inserting the safety policy and code of ethics statement in an employee handbook or another manual or making it available through computer-based documentation. Irrespective of how the aviation organization decides to communicate the safety policy, they need to ensure all employees engaged in the aviation service or product are aware of the organization’s safety policy.
3.3.1.3.12 Part 5 does not define the term “regularly” when it comes to the periodic review of the safety policy. It is expected that the aviation organization will determine and document an interval that is appropriate for the size and complexity of the operation. The accountable executive is required to review the safety policy and safety objectives to ensure they remain relevant (§§ 5.21(d) and 5.25(b)(4)). There should be evidence showing this review has been accomplished in the aviation organization’s records.
3.3.1.4 Implementation Strategies. The safety policy and code of ethics statement requirements are not expected to vary between aviation organizations; however, the processes and procedures described in § 5.95 SMS documentation and how they are documented could vary due to the complexity of the processes being described. The safety policy and code of ethics statement could be a part of the organization’s safety manual or included in other existing documentation or manuals. For aviation organizations not required to maintain manuals, it could be integrated into a compliance statement discussing how the organization meets the requirements. Under part 5, the safety policy and SMS processes and procedures only need to be documented.
3.3.1.4.1 When developing organizational goals and objectives, both financial and time resources can be limited, so the focus should be where resources will have the greatest safety benefit. This may be achieved by focusing safety goals on the top one, two, or three risks from the organization’s safety risk profile. In other words, focus on those things that keep you up at night.
3.3.1.4.2 Confidential reporting is an important part of encouraging a safety reporting culture in all organizations. Employees should know they can speak up because their personal information and reports are provided a level of protection. The practicality of this is obviously more difficult in a small organization where everybody often knows everybody’s business. If a just reporting culture is not in place, reporting may be limited because of the difficulty of ensuring confidentiality in a small organization. While not prohibited by the regulation, anonymous reporting does not allow the aviation
3.3.1 Safety Policy. › 3.3.1.6 Examples.
organization the ability to get additional information concerning the hazard or incident since the ability to reach out to the reporter is lost.
3.3.1.5 Considerations for Small and Single-Individual Organizations. The following part 5 requirements are excepted for single-pilot organizations.
1. Section 5.21(a)(4): A safety reporting policy that defines requirements for employee reporting of safety hazards or issues.
2. Section 5.21(a)(5): A policy that defines unacceptable behavior and conditions for disciplinary action.
3. Section 5.21(c): The safety policy must be documented and communicated throughout person’s organization.
3.3.1.5.1 Single-individual organizations will not have a confidential reporting program; however, they should have a way of recording and managing (§ 5.55) hazards they identify in the course of operations.
3.3.1.5.2 A single-individual organization is not required to have a process to communicate safety information throughout the aviation organization.
3.3.1.6 Examples. The following examples demonstrate ways aviation organizations might choose to implement §5.21(c) based on where the aviation organization may fall on the spectrum of size or complexity. The following are examples only and are not the only ways the requirements could be met.
3.3.1.6.1 For smaller, lower complexity organizations, the owner or most senior manager (the accountable executive) may personally perform this process. The policy statement can be a simple, often single-page, written document signed by the accountable executive. Small organizations typically operate in smaller networks of employees, so the policy may be posted in the organization’s work areas or included in organizational briefings or in training.
3.3.1.6.2 Aviation organizations on the higher end of the spectrum of complexity may require senior managers and technical staff to perform this process in addition to the accountable executive. While the regulations only require the accountable executive to sign the safety policy and code of ethics statement, members of senior management may also sign the safety policy and code of ethics statement. Large or highly complex aviation organizations may choose to disseminate their policy using a variety of resources, such as organizational websites, intranets, email, or existing indoctrination and recurrent training.
3.3.2 Safety Accountability and Authority. › 3.3.2.3 Discussion.
3.3.2 Safety Accountability and Authority.
3.3.2.1 References. Sections 5.23, 119.65, and 119.67; 14 CFR part 125, § 125.25; part 133, § 133.21; part 137, § 137.41; part 141, § 141.33; part 142, § 142.13; and part 145, § 145.151.
3.3.2.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.23, Safety accountability and authority.
(a) Any person required to have an SMS under this part must define in its safety policy the
accountability for safety of the following individuals: (1) Accountable executive, as described in § 5.25. (2) All members of management in regard to developing, implementing, and maintaining SMS
processes within their area of responsibility, including, but not limited to: (i) Hazard identification and safety risk assessment. (ii) Assuring the effectiveness of safety risk controls. (iii) Promoting safety as required in subpart E of this part. (iv) Advising the accountable executive on the performance of the SMS and on any need
for improvement. (3) Employees relative to the person’s safety performance. (b) The person must identify the levels of management with the authority to make decisions
regarding safety risk acceptance.
3.3.2.3 Discussion. “Accountability,” as used in this requirement, refers to active management and line employee involvement and actions in managing and maintaining organizational safety performance. An aviation organization demonstrates accountability by ensuring each of its employees are aware of their specific role within the SMS and that they actively participate in accomplishing their SMS-related duties. Once the SMS requirements for the employee positions have been established, part 5 subpart E requires that these requirements be communicated throughout the organization. The safety accountability process requires the aviation organization to define duties and responsibilities for achieving safety performance objectives within the organization’s safety policy for the following individuals.
3.3.2.3.1 Accountable Executive. The accountable executive has the ultimate responsibility for safety management within the organization. The specific duties of the accountable executive are discussed in more detail in paragraph 3.3.3.3.
3.3.2.3.2 All Members of Management. Managers, who may also be process owners, are the individuals who are responsible for identifying hazards, conducting risk assessments, and developing risk controls for their areas of responsibility. They have the technical expertise and are the ones responsible for the implementation and operation of risk controls (often in the form of operational procedures, specified tools, training, communication, etc.). Process owners may not always be in a regulatorily required position as required by
3.3.2 Safety Accountability and Authority. › 3.3.2.4 Implementation Strategies.
§§ 119.65, 119.69, and 145.151 and might not appear on an organizational chart. Process owners, such as a battery shop manager or cargo manager, may have the technical expertise to manage the processes and procedures, and, if so, they would be able to accept risk in their functional area. A key element in the SRM process is to identify the levels of management with the authority to make risk decisions related to aviation safety. Thus, managers that have the authority to implement changes in systems and procedures should use the SMS processes in managing their area of operational responsibility. They are also responsible for ensuring the continuing operational safety of risk controls. Through data collection methods and analytical processes in the safety assurance component, managers are able to determine that risk controls are effective and that their safety performance is acceptable. For example, the Director of Maintenance (DOM) is one of the managers accountable for SMS within their area of responsibility.
3.3.2.3.3 Employees. All employees should be aware of the organization’s safety policies as well as the processes, procedures, and tools relevant to their responsibilities. They need to know how the confidential employee reporting system works. Employees at all levels of the organization have a responsibility to report hazards, issues, and concerns related to aviation safety as well as to propose solutions and safety improvements. Employees have a duty and responsibility to follow an organization’s processes and procedures.
3.3.2.4 Implementation Strategies. The method for meeting these requirements could vary greatly between different organizations. The numbers and relationships of personnel will be unique to each organization, and the organizational structure and accountability should be appropriate to the aviation organization.
3.3.2.4.1 Aviation organizations are required to define the duties and responsibilities of the accountable executive. The accountable executive has the ultimate responsibility for safety management within the organization. The specific duties of the accountable executive are defined in § 5.25.
3.3.2.4.2 Aviation organizations need to define the duties and responsibilities of management (process owners) in their areas of the operation.
3.3.2.4.3 All employee safety-related duties and responsibilities must be documented (where required). They could be located in the safety manual or in another organizational document. The SMS documentation should point to where the requirement is located if it is in a place other than the safety documentation.
3.3.2.4.4 A key element in the SRM process is to identify the levels of management with the authority to make risk decisions related to aviation safety. The positions identified must have the knowledge and skills to determine the acceptability of risk in their functional areas. Managers that have the authority
3.3.3 Designation and Responsibilities of Required Safety Management… › 3.3.3.1 References. Section 5.25(a) and (b).
to implement changes in systems and procedures should use the SMS processes in managing risk in their area of operational responsibility.
3.3.2.4.5 Accountability for all employees directly involved in delivering the aviation organization’s product or service should be defined. Employees at all levels of the organization have a responsibility to report hazards, issues, and concerns as well as to propose solutions and safety improvements. Employees have a duty and responsibility to follow an organization’s processes and procedures.
3.3.2.4.6 In single-individual organizations, the personnel structure will be very simple and consist of the person in charge being the accountable executive, who is responsible for ensuring all required duties and activities are accomplished. In a small organization, other management personnel should be identified since they would have a role in how the organization is managed on a day-to-day basis.
3.3.2.5 Considerations for Small and Single-Individual Organizations. The following part 5 requirements are excepted for single-pilot organizations:
1. Section 5.23(a)(2): All members of management in regard to developing, implementing, and maintaining SMS processes within their area of responsibility, including, but not limited to:
(i) Hazard identification and safety risk assessment.
(ii) Assuring the effectiveness of safety risk controls.
(iii) Promoting safety as required in subpart E of this part.
(iv) Advising the accountable executive on the performance of the SMS and on any need for improvement.
2. Section 5.23(a)(3): Employees relative to the person’s safety performance.
3. Section 5.23(b): The person must identify the levels of management with the authority to make decisions regarding safety risk acceptance.
3.3.2.5.1 In single-individual organizations, this structure will be very simple and consist of the sole individual being the accountable executive and assuming the various roles and responsibilities, which would normally be assigned to other members of management. The single individual would also be responsible for accepting all risks associated with the aviation organization’s products or services.
3.3.2.5.2 As their organizational duties change, which could happen many times during the day, the single individual could be said to be changing hats as their role changes as they manage the activities required in § 5.23.
3.3.3 Designation and Responsibilities of Required Safety Management Personnel.
3.3.3.1 References. Section 5.25(a) and (b).
3.3.3 Designation and Responsibilities of Required Safety Management… › 3.3.3.3 Discussion.
3.3.3.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.25, Designation and responsibilities of required safety management personnel.
(a) Designation of the accountable executive. Any person required to have an SMS under this part
must identify an accountable executive who, irrespective of other functions, satisfies the following: (1) Is the final authority over operations authorized to be conducted under the person’s
certificate(s) or Letter(s) of Authorization. (2) Controls the financial resources required for the operations to be conducted under the
person’s certificate(s) or Letter(s) of Authorization. (3) Controls the human resources required for the operations authorized to be conducted under
the person’s certificate(s) or Letter(s) of Authorization. (4) Retains ultimate responsibility for the safety performance of the operations conducted
under the person’s certificate(s) or Letter(s) of Authorization. (b) Responsibilities of the accountable executive. The accountable executive must accomplish the
following: (1) Ensure that the SMS is properly implemented and is performing across all pertinent areas. (2) Develop and sign the safety policy. (3) Communicate the safety policy throughout the person’s organization. (4) Regularly review the safety policy to ensure it remains relevant and appropriate to the
person. (5) Regularly review the safety performance and direct actions necessary to address
substandard safety performance in accordance with § 5.75.
3.3.3.3 Discussion.
3.3.3.3.1 Designation.
3.3.3.3.1.1 Section 5.25(a) requires the organization to identify an individual in the organization to be the accountable executive who holds the ultimate decision-making authority over the organization’s aviation-related operations. The accountable executive is responsible for planning, organizing, directing, and controlling the personnel, organizational structure, financial, and other resources necessary for safe operations. A flowchart outlining a process for designating an accountable executive is available in Appendix E, Identifying the Accountable Executive.
3.3.3.3.1.2 When identifying the accountable executive, it is very important to select an individual in the organization who holds the ultimate decision-making authority over the aviation organization’s operations. This individual is responsible for planning, organizing, directing, and controlling the personnel, organizational structure, financial, and other resources necessary for safe operations. The organizational job title is not important when making this determination but rather the individual’s
responsibility to ensure appropriate resources are available and to accept risk for and oversee the aviation product or service.
3.3.3.3.2 Responsibilities. As the ultimate authority in the organization, the accountable executive is responsible for the proper functioning of the SMS. This entails, among other things, keeping an open line of communication with the designated management personnel, providing sufficient resources for the SMS to function properly, and being actively involved in the safety assurance component of the SMS.
3.3.3.3.2.1 If an aviation organization chooses to integrate the safety policy and code of ethics statement into a compliance statement, the accountable executive must sign the compliance statement to meet the requirements of § 5.25(b)(2). One way the aviation organization could define accountability for the accountable executive is by listing the duties and responsibilities identified in § 5.25 in a position description. These may be located in the SMS safety policy documentation or in another organizational manual, such as a human resources manual. If the duties and responsibilities are documented elsewhere, the safety policy should point to the location where they can be located. Smaller organizations could point to the regulatory requirements in § 5.25(b).
3.3.3.3.2.2 The accountable executive should maintain open lines of communication with the designated management personnel to ensure any identified hazards or issues are effectively communicated throughout the organization. Communicating the safety policy and code of ethics could be through publication of the safety policy statement in documentation employees have access to. It could also include periodic meetings where organizational information concerning the safety policy is shared with employees by the accountable executive and management.
3.3.3.3.2.3 The accountable executive must regularly review the safety performance of the organization. There should be documentation to show that it has occurred. The term “regularly” is not defined to specify an interval. Reviews should occur frequently enough for issues within the organization’s processes and procedures to be identified and corrected in a timely manner. This will vary based on the aviation organization’s size, scope, and complexity.
3.3.3.3.2.4 The accountable executive should designate sufficient management personnel to provide support for essential SMS functions, such as performing analysis, assisting operational managers in meeting their safety management responsibilities, and acting as a safety advisor to the accountable executive.
3.3.4 Designation of Management Personnel. › 3.3.4.1 References.
Personnel designated to perform this function should be in positions in the organization of sufficient independence to have direct access to the accountable executive to report on the safety performance of the operation and ability to recommend any necessary improvements. These individuals should be highly knowledgeable on the SMS and able to assist the process owners and functional area managers in accomplishing their SMS duties and responsibilities. This is not to say the management personnel are expected to accept risk in the functional areas, as they may not be the most qualified. The organization is not expected to add employees to fill this position either. These tasks could be accomplished by existing management personnel.
3.3.3.4 Implementation Strategies. The accountable executive is responsible for ensuring that sufficient management personnel are clearly designated for ensuring the safety of operational and SMS processes. When management personnel are designated, consideration should be given to ensure they are properly trained and qualified to perform the duties required of the position.
3.3.3.4.1 In smaller organizations, the accountable executive may directly supervise operational processes. This individual may serve in multiple positions within the organization.
3.3.3.4.2 It is unlikely that small organizations will have the resources for a designated representative to monitor the effectiveness of the SMS as a full-time position. A small organization may add the safety manager duties to an existing role (e.g., operations manager). In a single-individual operation, these duties would be filled by the accountable executive.
3.3.3.5 Considerations for Small and Single-Individual Organizations. Single-pilot operations and single-individual organizations pose unique situations when implementing an SMS. As a result of these factors, the following regulatory section is excepted from the implementation requirements for organizations with a single pilot who is the sole individual performing all necessary functions in the conduct and execution related to, or in direct support of, the safe operation of aircraft:
Section 5.25(b)(3): Responsibilities of the accountable executive. The accountable executive must accomplish the following: Communicate the safety policy throughout the person’s organization.
3.3.4 Designation of Management Personnel.
3.3.4.1 References. Sections 5.25(c), 119.65, 119.67, 145.151, and 145.153.
3.3.4 Designation of Management Personnel. › 3.3.4.3 Discussion.
3.3.4.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.25(c), Designation of management personnel.
(c) Designation of management personnel. The accountable executive must designate sufficient
management personnel who, on behalf of the accountable executive, are responsible for the following: (1) Coordinate implementation, maintenance, and integration of the SMS throughout the
person’s organization. (2) Facilitate hazard identification and safety risk analysis. (3) Monitor the effectiveness of safety risk controls. (4) Ensure safety promotion throughout the person’s organization as required in subpart E of
this part. (5) Regularly report to the accountable executive on the performance of the SMS and on any
need for improvement.
3.3.4.3 Discussion. This section requires that the organization ensure that sufficient management personnel are available to provide support for essential SMS functions, such as performing analysis, assisting operational managers in meeting their safety management responsibilities, and acting as a safety advisor to the accountable executive.
3.3.4.3.1 When reviewing the designated management personnel required in § 5.25(c), the term “coordinate” means the management representative will aid other management personnel in the implementation and integration of the SMS throughout the organization. This position is not expected to “own” the SMS in the organization as everyone has a role and responsibilities to ensure proper functioning of the SMS. The term “facilitate” means the management representative will aid other process owners in hazard analysis and risk assessment. As they may not be a process owner, they are not expected to make risk-based decisions. The term “monitor” means the management representative will aid other process owners in determining if risk controls are functioning as designed. The duties and responsibilities listed above should be left to the process owners.
3.3.4.3.2 The designated management representative is expected to communicate safety information throughout the organization. Per § 5.97(d), a record of this activity should be retained so it can be validated during audits.
3.3.4.3.3 Designated management personnel are not necessarily subject matter experts (SME) in all areas of the aviation organization. Rather, they are personnel in a position to assist the process owners and management personnel with hazard identification and risk analysis, aid in communicating safety information throughout the organization, and monitor the effectiveness of safety risk controls.
3.3.4.3.4 Personnel designated to perform this function should be in positions in the organization with sufficient independence to have direct access to the
3.3.4 Designation of Management Personnel. › 3.3.4.6 Considerations for Small and Single-Individual Organizations.
accountable executive to report on the safety performance of the operation and recommend any necessary improvements.
3.3.4.4 Implementation Strategies. These responsibilities may be carried by the accountable executive as defined in § 5.23(a)(1) or as collateral duties by managers referred to in § 5.23(a)(2), or the aviation organization could assign the tasks of supporting SMS functions to other management personnel.
3.3.4.5 Example. The following example demonstrates a way aviation organizations might choose to implement this requirement based on where the aviation organization may fall on the spectrum of size or complexity. The following is an example only and is not the only way the requirements could be met. For example, Flyslow Aviation has chosen to use an existing required management individual required under §§ 119.65, 119.69, or 145.151 and 145.153 to fulfill these responsibilities. As Flyslow Aviation grows and expands, they could establish a safety department with designated personnel assigned this requirement.
3.3.4.6 Considerations for Small and Single-Individual Organizations.
3.3.4.6.1 Single-pilot operations and single-individual organizations pose unique situations when implementing an SMS. As a result of these factors, the following regulatory section is excepted from the implementation requirements for organizations with a single pilot who is the sole individual performing all necessary functions in the conduct and execution related to, or in direct support of, the safe operation of aircraft:
Section 5.25(c): Designation of management personnel. The accountable executive must designate sufficient management personnel who, on behalf of the accountable executive, are responsible for the following:
(1) Coordinate implementation, maintenance, and integration of the SMS throughout the person’s organization.
(2) Facilitate hazard identification and safety risk analysis.
(3) Monitor the effectiveness of safety risk controls.
(4) Ensure safety promotion throughout the person’s organization as required in subpart E of this part.
(5) Regularly report to the accountable executive on the performance of the SMS and on any need for improvement.
3.3.4.6.2 In a single-pilot organization, the accountable executive would perform these designated duties as part of their duties under § 5.25. Effective communication of safety information is still important, even in a single-pilot or single-individual organization. The communication focus would be focused outside of the organization (i.e., regular communication with aviation system stakeholders, industry associations, clients, the FAA, and other organizations.)
3.3.5 Coordination of Emergency Response Planning. › 3.3.5.3 Discussion.
3.3.4.7 Safety Policy Example. Flyslow Aviation recognizes the key to a successful organization is open communication and strong leadership. They identify the accountable executive and management representatives (§ 5.23) and start working on the safety policy. While developing safety objectives (§ 5.21(a)(1)), management reviewed the organization’s performance indicators as well as reports from previous audits. Management then determined a reduction in uncalibrated tools being issued by the tool room would be an appropriate objective for the coming year. Management communicates the organization’s goal of reducing uncalibrated tool issuance by 20 percent by publishing an updated safety policy (§ 5.21(c) and (d)) and through employee meetings (§ 5.23). Management also develops processes and procedures describing how employees are expected to accomplish their duties and responsibilities under the SMS.
3.3.5 Coordination of Emergency Response Planning.
3.3.5.1 References. Section 5.27.
3.3.5.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.27, Coordination of emergency response planning. Where emergency response procedures are necessary, any person required to have an SMS under this part must develop, and the accountable executive must approve as part of the safety policy, an emergency response plan that addresses at least the following:
(a) Delegation of emergency authority throughout the person’s organization. (b) Assignment of employee responsibilities during the emergency. (c) Coordination of the emergency response plans with the emergency response plans of other
organizations it must interface with during the provision of its services.
3.3.5.3 Discussion. The aviation organization is required to develop an ERP. This may be a part of the safety policy documentation or a separate document. If it is a separate document, the safety policy should point to where the ERP is located.
3.3.5.3.1 The ERP should be developed, which ensures normal SMS functions and risk acceptance continues while key personnel are removed from their normal risk management positions. The plan should also address how the aviation organization will transition to normal operations after the emergency condition subsides.
3.3.5.3.2 The ERP should provide procedures for management decision making and action in an emergency. For the purposes of meeting this section, the aviation organization should develop an ERP that ensures normal SMS functions and risk acceptance continues when process owners are removed from their normal risk management positions. This also should be applied for vacations or other absences. A line of succession of management authority sufficient to respond to emergencies needs to be established and documented in the
3.3.5 Coordination of Emergency Response Planning. › 3.3.5.5 Considerations for Small and Single-Individual Organizations.
position description so employees required to assume these duties are able to understand the additional duties and responsibilities. As proxies are identified to step into these roles, organizations must ensure they are trained and competent to perform the additional duties of SMS risk acceptance.
3.3.5.3.3 Coordination of ERPs with the ERPs of other organizations might include first responders to accidents or incidents, airport authorities, and hazardous materials (HAZMAT) authorities. Many organizations already have ERPs that may be used to fulfill this requirement.
3.3.5.4 Implementation Strategies. Consider whether the ERP covers the likely emergencies and has been coordinated with other organizations that may be affected and with the emergency services. A small, noncomplex organization’s ERP might consist of a checklist of simple steps involving who to call when and what information to impart and a regularly updated list of contact details. When considering the ERP, succession planning must be considered. If a member of management is removed from their position to address an emergency, there should be another individual trained and competent to step into the position to ensure the organization continues to function as designed. This could even take place when the individual is away for other reasons. Common sense must prevail; processes need to be workable and tailored for the operation. In other words, do not over think it!
3.3.5.5 Considerations for Small and Single-Individual Organizations.
3.3.5.5.1 Single-pilot operations and single-individual organizations pose unique situations when implementing an SMS. As a result of these factors, the following regulatory section is excepted from the implementation requirements for organizations with a single pilot who is the sole individual performing all necessary functions in the conduct and execution related to, or in direct support of, the safe operation of aircraft:
Section 5.27: Where emergency response procedures are necessary, any person required to have an SMS under this part must develop, and the accountable executive must approve as part of the safety policy, an emergency response plan that addresses at least the following:
(a) Delegation of emergency authority throughout the person’s organization.
(b) Assignment of employee responsibilities during the emergency.
3.3.5.5.2 Effective communication of safety information is important, even in a single-pilot organization. In an organization with a single pilot or single individual, the communication focus may be outside the organization (e.g., regular communication with aviation system stakeholders, industry associations, clients, the FAA, and other organizations). Interfacing with maintenance, fixed-based operators, and flight followers (if one is used) all
3.4.1 Applicability: Requirements to Apply SRM. › 3.4.1.3 Discussion.
require communication so they are aware of the aviation organization’s activities. This will aid in scheduling support activities as well as having someone keep an eye out in case plans do not go as predicted. In a single-pilot or single-individual organization, this could be met by simply filing flight plans with air traffic control (ATC) or leaving an envelope with emergency contact information at the local Fixed-Base Operator (FBO) if the aircraft does not return on time.
3.4 Subpart C, Safety Risk Management.
3.4.1 Applicability: Requirements to Apply SRM.
3.4.1.1 References. Section 5.51.
3.4.1.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.51, Applicability. Any person required to have an SMS under this part must apply safety risk management to the following:
(a) Implementation of new systems. (b) Revision of existing systems. (c) Development of operational procedures. (d) Identification of hazards or ineffective risk controls through the safety assurance processes in
subpart D of this part.
3.4.1.3 Discussion. To know when an SRM process may be required, it is important to know what a system is. Systems could be people, hardware, software, information, procedures, facilities, services, and other support facets that are directly related to the organization’s aviation safety activities. Examples of broad-based systems could include:
• Flight operations,
• Operational control (dispatch/flight following),
• Maintenance and inspection,
• Cabin safety,
• Ground handling and servicing,
• Cargo handling, and
• Training.
3.4.1.3.1 Within an aviation organization’s systems, there are subsystems related to aviation safety. Some examples of subsystems include crew scheduling systems, training curricula, maintenance control, component shops, deicing, fueling, aircraft fleet, ground operations, and HAZMAT training.
3.4.2 System Analysis. › 3.4.2.1 References. Section 5.53(a) and (b).
3.4.1.3.2 Under § 5.51, the SRM process is triggered when new systems or changes to existing systems related to aviation activities are being considered. For example, changes to operations could include the addition of new routes, opening or closing of line stations, addition or change of contractual arrangements for services, addition of new fleets or major modifications of existing fleets, addition of different types of operations such as Extended Operations (ETOPS), or change in authorizations to a repair station’s ratings.
3.4.1.3.3 The SRM process is not triggered solely by major changes to a system; it is triggered by any aviation-safety-related revision of an existing system.
3.4.1.3.4 The SRM process is also triggered when any aviation-related change in the operating environment or ineffective risk controls are identified by the safety assurance processes.
3.4.1.3.5 Aviation organizations must document (where required) when the SRM processes are to be implemented based on the requirements in § 5.51. While it is not the intent to require the application of SRM processes and procedures to activities that are not related to the aviation operations, some aviation organizations may elect to add additional triggering events.
3.4.1.3.6 International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Annex 19, Safety Management, requires hazard identification and SRM to be initiated using reactive and proactive methods. As discussed in § 5.51, proactive requirements are initiated when an organization implements new systems, revises existing systems, or develops operational procedures. The reactive trigger is hazards or ineffective risk controls identified through the organization’s safety assurance processes.
3.4.1.3.7 A question you might wonder is “Do I have to do SRM if I update a manual?” The answer is yes; any change to existing processes or revision to existing systems (the manual is part of your aviation organization’s system) requires SRM to be initiated. Now, you might be thinking “Do I have to do the entire SRM process?” The answer to that question is that it depends. If you are just updating the organizational chart due to promotions and turnover, then probably not. You would describe the system and then assess it for hazards. If no hazards are identified by updating the organizational chart, then the process is complete. Depending on how the process is written, there could be a simple check mark that indicates no hazards identified on the organization’s SRM tracking document. For an example, see Appendix B, Sample Safety Risk Management (SRM) Worksheets, Figure B-1, Safety Risk Management Triggering Conditions and Summary.
3.4.2 System Analysis.
3.4.2.1 References. Section 5.53(a) and (b).
3.4.2 System Analysis. › 3.4.2.3 Discussion.
3.4.2.2 Part 5 Requirement.
§ 5.53(a) and (b), System analysis and hazard identification.
(a) When applying safety risk management, any person required to have an SMS under this part
must analyze the systems identified in § 5.51. Those system analyses must be used to identify hazards under paragraph (c) of this section and in developing and implementing risk controls related to the system under § 5.55(c). (b) In conducting the system analysis, the following information must be considered:
(1) Function and purpose of the system. (2) The system’s operating environment. (3) An outline of the system’s processes and procedures. (4) The personnel, equipment, and facilities necessary for operation of the system. (5) The interfaces of the system.
Continue reading ↓ 120 of 384 passages shown