Radar Vectors
Advisory Circular Cancelled Issued Oct 15, 2008 AFS-200 69 pages Copy saved Nov 18, 2026

AC 120-53A Guidance for Conducting and Use of Flight Standardization Board Evaluations

This advisory circular (AC) describes an acceptable means, but not the only means, of compliance with the Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) regarding qualification and type rating of flight crewmembers operating under 14 CFRs. Included are criteria for the determination and approval of training, checking, and currency necessary for the operation of aircraft. This AC also describes the process by which the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) determines the qualification of the pilot in command (PIC) or second in command (SIC) of new or modified aircraft. Details of the systems, processes, and tests necessary to apply this AC are explained in the appendices.

This document is cancelled. It may have been replaced. Check the official source before relying on it.

Official source ↗ Open PDF

2. CANCELLATION.

U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration

Advisory Circular

Subject: Guidance for Conducting and Use of Flight Standardization Board Evaluations

Date: 10/15/08

Initiated by: AFS-200

AC No: 120-53A

Change:

1. PURPOSE. This advisory circular (AC) describes an acceptable means, but not the only means, of compliance with the Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) regarding qualification and type rating of flight crewmembers operating under 14 CFRs. Included are criteria for the determination and approval of training, checking, and currency necessary for the operation of aircraft. This AC also describes the process by which the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) determines the qualification of the pilot in command (PIC) or second in command (SIC) of new or modified aircraft. Details of the systems, processes, and tests necessary to apply this AC are explained in the appendices. This AC is intended to enhance safety by:

• Providing a common method of assessing applicant programs.

• Directly relating pilot training and qualification requirements to fleet characteristics, operating concepts, and pilot assignments.

• Permitting better planning and management of fleets, pilot assignments, and training resources by outlining what FAA requirements apply, what training resources or devices are needed, and what alternatives are possible.

• Permitting timely and consistent decisions about fleet acquisition, integration, modification, or phaseout associated with pilot qualification or pilot assignments.

• Permitting manufacturers to design aircraft that take advantage of new technology or their similarity with existing related aircraft, as appropriate to a particular operator’s fleet.

• Encouraging cockpit standardization by crediting commonality and identifying necessary constraints when differences exist.

• Providing a recommended framework for application of suitable credits or constraints to better address new technology and future safety enhancements.

2. CANCELLATION. AC 120-53, Crew Qualification and Pilot Type Rating Requirements for Transport Category Aircraft Operated under 14 CFR Part 121, dated May 13, 1991, is canceled.

AC 120-53A 10/15/08

3. FOCUS. This AC addresses aircraft manufacturers or modifiers who design, test, and certificate aircraft. In addition, it applies to operators whose pilots operate several related aircraft of the same manufacturer in a mixed fleet and operators seeking credit for prior pilot experience with related aircraft of the same manufacturer.

a. This AC revision clarifies, and introduces new terms and concepts.… › (4) Modified checking requirements to embrace the concept of checking…

4. DISCUSSION.

a. A System for Pilot Qualification. The FAA specifies qualification criteria (minimum training, checking, and currency) for particular aircraft through Flight Standardization Board (FSB) evaluations and findings. FSB findings are described in reports for specific aircraft. The reports provide guidance to certificate-holding district offices (CHDO) for use by principal operations inspectors (POI) and other inspectors. FSB reports and the provisions therein, serve as a recommended basis for the FAA to approve operators’ programs and for pilot certification.

b. Changing Needs. Necessary support for the FSB process is provided by the industry. In the past, procedures varied by manufacturer, individual project, operator, and other factors including:

(1) Introduction of new and related aircraft and increases in the significance of modifications to existing aircraft, particularly with regard to engines or avionics.

(2) Integration of related fleets of aircraft following airline acquisitions or mergers.

(3) Increased dependence on leased aircraft, many of which are configured differently than an operator’s basic fleet.

(4) A wider variety of equipment options available in new or retrofit aircraft.

(5) Introduction of new technology in cockpit enhancements.

5. SUMMARY OF REVISIONS. This AC describes necessary revisions to the FSB process to address uniform, systematic, timely, and comprehensive application of pertinent 14 CFR parts in a changing and increasingly complex operational environment. This AC revision deletes master common requirements due to a lack of practical application. This AC recognizes the concept of reduced differences between related aircraft and defines the training, checking, currency, and recency of experience requirements.

a. This AC revision clarifies, and introduces new terms and concepts. These include:

(1) Clarification of the terms “aircraft type certificate” and “related aircraft”.

(2) The difference between currency and recency of experience is defined.

(3) A definition of “common pilot type rating” now including levels A through D for any aircraft of the same make but of different aircraft type certificates (TC).

(4) Modified checking requirements to embrace the concept of checking only at the difference levels between related aircraft.

Page 2 Par 3

6. SETTING FAA REQUIREMENTS. › a. Applicant’s Proposals. Aircraft manufacturers or modifiers usually…

10/15/08 AC 120-53A

(5) A new term, “common takeoff and landing credit” (CTLC).

(6) An introduction of the T6 test to provide for CTLC (recency of experience) in mixed fleet flying between separate type-certificated aircraft of the same make with common takeoff and landing characteristics. The intent of the T6 test is to provide a comparison of aircraft that have not previously been evaluated for CTLC using the T2 test.

(7) A means to identify and evaluate new technologies that may not be associated with an aircraft evaluation.

(8) A distinction between supervised line flying (SLF) and operating experience (OE).

b. Additional concepts are introduced to uniformly apply the 14 CFR parts applicable to pilot qualification and the differences. The AC’s main concepts are summarized as follows.

(1) Master Difference Requirement (MDR). Master requirements are expressed in the form of MDRs. MDRs are requirements applicable to pilot qualification that pertain to differences between related aircraft. MDRs are specified by the FSB in terms of difference levels.

(2) Difference Levels. Difference levels are levels of training methods or devices, checking methods, or currency methods that satisfy difference requirements between related aircraft. Difference levels specify FSB recommendations proportionate to and corresponding with increasing differences between related aircraft. A range of five difference levels in order of increasing requirements, identified as A through E are each specified for training, checking, and currency.

(3) Operator Difference Requirement (ODR). Operators show compliance with the FAA MDRs through an operator’s specific ODR, which lists each operator’s fleet differences and compliance methods. ODRs specify requirements uniquely applicable to a particular fleet and mixed flying situation and are based on the MDRs. ODRs are those operator specific requirements necessary to address differences between a base aircraft and one or more related aircraft, when operating in mixed fleet flying or seeking credit in transition programs. ODRs include both a description of differences and a corresponding list of minimum training, checking, and currency compliance methods that address pertinent FSB provisions.

NOTE: These and other concepts are more fully described in the appendices.

6. SETTING FAA REQUIREMENTS. The FSB process is made up of proposal development, testing, draft provision formulation, FSB final recommendations and FAA review and approval.

a. Applicant’s Proposals. Aircraft manufacturers or modifiers usually initiate proposals for formulation or amendment of FSB recommendations. This is done in conjunction with application for aircraft type certification or supplemental type certification of an aircraft or system. The FAA, operators, and, in certain instances, other organizations or individuals, may initiate proposals or amendments.

Par 5 Page 3

7. OPERATOR COMPLIANCE WITH FAA REQUIREMENTS. › b. Certificated Operator Compliance with Mixed Fleet Flying. When…

AC 120-53A 10/15/08

b. Standardized Tests. A main element of the requirements formulation process is the use of standardized testing to determine pilot qualification requirements. One or more of six tests are applied depending on the proposal’s degree of differences between related aircraft, difference levels sought, and the outcome of any previous tests. Only the necessary tests are used. Tests may be waived or difference levels may be assigned based on operational experience.

c. FAA Formulation and Implementation of FSB Provisions. Following testing and formulation of draft provisions, FSB recommendations are then made specifying MDRs and any necessary supporting information. Supporting information may pertain to operator certification, airmen certification, approval of devices and simulators, and other items necessary for proper application of MDRs. FSB reports should be used as a basis in the evaluation, certification, and approval of operators’ programs.

d. Revision of FSB Provisions. FSB reports are periodically updated when new or modified aircraft are introduced, when requested by an applicant based on OE, or when the FAA determines it is necessary for safety reasons.

e. Pilot Type Ratings. A new pilot type rating is typically assigned when level E training differences are determined between the candidate aircraft and the base aircraft. The pilot type rating determination and any training, checking, and currency specifications established under the testing process of this AC are determined by evaluating the handling qualities and core pilot skills related to the candidate aircraft. Systems such as heads-up display (HUD), Enhanced Vision Systems (EVS), or Synthetic Visions Systems (SVS) may require Level E training without requiring a new pilot type rating. The FSB, with the concurrence of the Air Transportation Division, AFS-200, will make this determination.

f. Common Pilot Type Rating. A common pilot type rating is assigned when no greater than level D training differences are determined between aircraft of the same make with different aircraft TCs.

g. Same Pilot Type Rating. A same pilot type rating is assigned when no greater than level D training differences are determined between aircraft with the same aircraft TCs (series).

7. OPERATOR COMPLIANCE WITH FAA REQUIREMENTS.

a. Obtaining FSB Information. Operators are advised of pertinent FSB information through FAA CHDOs and POIs. Operators may also obtain FSB information from aircraft manufacturers or modifiers, other operators, or other aviation organizations that maintain awareness of FAA policies, and the Web site http://www.opspecs.com.

b. Certificated Operator Compliance with Mixed Fleet Flying. When aircraft are flown in mixed fleets, certificated operators will comply with MDRs and other FSB differences provisions as approved by their Certificate Management Office (CMO) or CHDO. Certificated operators accomplish this by identifying a base aircraft, describing differences that exist between their base aircraft and the candidate aircraft, and by specifying particular means of compliance to satisfy MDRs. Sample FSB ODRs provide guidance for the approval of an operator’s mixed fleet flying program and specify necessary constraints or permissible credits. The description of specific differences and compliance methods are identified in the operator’s ODRs. Constraints

Page 4 Par 6

9. APPLICATION OF FSB PROVISIONS TO AIRMEN CERTIFICATION.

10/15/08 AC 120-53A

or credits may relate to knowledge, skills, devices, simulators, maneuvers, checks, currency, or any other factors necessary for safe operations. Constraints or credits may be applied generally or only to specific aircraft or pilot positions. Once approved, the operator’s program must be conducted in accordance with these approved ODRs. ODR proposals are provided to the FAA CHDO in a standard tabular format and may be approved by POIs if they address MDRs and other pertinent FSB recommendations. The operator must apply to amend the ODRs when changes occur in the base aircraft, comparison aircraft, and/or training devices that affect the approval basis of the ODRs.

c. Credit between Programs. In addition to mixed fleet flying, ODRs may be used to permit credit between related aircraft in differences or transition training and checking programs, consistent with FSB recommendations.

8. FAA APPROVAL OF OPERATOR PROGRAMS.

a. POI Approval. FAA POIs may approve operator programs based on FSB recommendations. If less restrictive programs are proposed, POIs advise the applicant that:

(1) A request for change of the MDRs must be initiated;

(2) The differences between related aircraft must be reduced or eliminated; or

(3) An alternate approval must be sought following the procedures outlined in 8.b.

NOTE: An example of such a request is an exemption to the applicable requirement of the training section of the operational rule under which the operation is conducted.

b. Limitations of POI Authority. When applicable, POIs may approve programs as recommended by FSB reports and this AC. AC provisions apply because other general constraints are identified such as a limitation on the number of different related aircraft that can be used in mixed fleet flying. If POIs approve programs outside the bounds of the FSB recommendations or these AC recommendations, authorization must be obtained from AFS-200. Deviation from this AC or FSB recommendations may be approved by AFS-200 when an equivalent level of safety can be demonstrated.

9. APPLICATION OF FSB PROVISIONS TO AIRMEN CERTIFICATION. The evaluation items that FSB reports specify include the following:

• Knowledge.

• Skills.

• Abilities.

• Maneuvers.

• Performance criteria.

Par 8 Page 5

12. APPEAL OF FAA DECISIONS.

AC 120-53A 10/15/08

• Other relevant items for proficiency checking or other checks/tests may be identified. This is appropriate to address any aircraft specific factors effecting the safe operation of that aircraft operated under 14 CFR.

10. TRAINING DEVICE AND SIMULATOR APPROVALS.

a. Standard Devices or Simulators. Standardized training methods, devices, or simulators are associated with each of the training difference levels. Devices or simulators are approved for particular operators by their POIs, consistent with National Simulator Program (NSP) qualification and FSB master requirements.

b. Special Criteria. In some instances, standard device or simulator criteria may not be appropriate for new technology. The FSB may specify additional criteria in FSB reports in these instances.

11. REVIEW AND APPROVAL. This is a process for review of FSB evaluations and approval of FSB reports.

12. APPEAL OF FAA DECISIONS. The Director, Flight Standards Service, AFS-1, assigns responsibility to resolve any appeals of the FSB recommendations or final FAA approvals of the assigned difference levels. ORIGINAL SIGNED by John McGraw for James Ballough Director, Flight Standards Service

Page 6 Par 10

TABLE OF CONTENTS

APPENDIX 1. DEFINITIONS AND REFERENCES

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. DEFINITIONS … 2

2. REFERENCES (current editions) … 5

APPENDIX 1. DEFINITIONS AND REFERENCES

1. DEFINITIONS.

NOTE: Definitions provided in Appendix 1 apply exclusively to this advisory circular (AC).

a. Aircraft Evaluation Group (AEG). Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) organization that sets training, checking, currency, pilot type rating, Master Minimum Equipment List (MMEL), and maintenance standards for assigned certificated aircraft types. AEGs also address operational aspects of aircraft type certification and resolution of service difficulties.

a. Aircraft Evaluation Group (AEG). Federal Aviation Administration… › f. Common Takeoff and Landing Credit (CTLC). CTLC is a program/process…

b. Applicant. For the purposes of this AC, an applicant may be a manufacturer, modifier, or operator.

c. Base Aircraft. An aircraft designated by the applicant used as a reference to compare differences with another aircraft.

d. Candidate Aircraft. The aircraft that will be subjected to the Flight Standardization Board (FSB) evaluation process outlined in this AC for comparison purposes.

e. Common Pilot Type Rating. A pilot license endorsement between separate type-certificated aircraft of the same make for the purposes of pilot type rating that passes the testing criteria of the T1 (equivalence) or the T2 (handling characteristics) and T3 (core pilot skills with no greater than level D differences). A common pilot type rating endorsement is issued after a pilot has received differences training and checking, where required, on the type-certificated aircraft for which there is a common pilot type rating designation. The pilot who is receiving the additional endorsement must be current and qualified in the base aircraft; since, the check is not a “full” proficiency check as defined by Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR), but an abbreviated differences check on the differences from the base to the candidate aircraft. The differences check, unless it includes the requirements for a recurrent check, cannot reset the “recurrent clock” (a pilot’s base month for checking purposes).

f. Common Takeoff and Landing Credit (CTLC). CTLC is a program/process that allows recency of experience credit between related aircraft (same make) with the same or different type certificate data sheets (TCDS) that can be demonstrated to have the same handling and flying characteristics during the following:

• Takeoff and initial climb.

• Approach and landing, including the establishment of final landing configuration.

NOTE: The T6 test is used for aircraft that were not tested (T2) during the initial aircraft evaluation for pilot type rating designation.

a. Aircraft Evaluation Group (AEG). Federal Aviation Administration… › q. Line Oriented Flying (LOF). The LOF phase of the test is used at the…

g. Configuration. Aircraft physical features, which are distinguishable by pilots, with respect to differences in systems, cockpit geometry, visual cutoff angles, controls, displays, aircraft geometry, and/or number of required pilots.

h. Currency. Currency is the recent experience necessary for the safe operation of aircraft, equipment, and systems as recommended by the FSB.

i. Difference Levels. Difference levels are formally designated levels of training methods or devices, checking methods, or currency methods that satisfy differences requirements between related aircraft. A range of five difference levels in order of increasing requirements, identified as A through E, are specified for training, checking, and currency purposes.

j. Differences Training. Training required before any person may serve as a required crewmember on an aircraft of a type for which differences training is included in the certificate holder’s approved training program.

k. Differences Check. A partial proficiency check of the qualification of a pilot at the difference levels between related aircraft. A differences check can be between series of aircraft on the same aircraft type certificate (TC) or between aircraft of separate aircraft TCs of the same manufacturer.

l. Flight Characteristics. Flight characteristics are handling characteristics or performance characteristics perceivable by a pilot. Flight characteristics relate to the natural aerodynamic response of an aircraft, particularly as affected by changes in configuration and/or flight path parameters (e.g., flight control use, flap extension/retraction, airspeed change, etc.).

m. Flight Operations Evaluation Board (FOEB). The FOEB is responsible for preparation and revision of Master Minimum Equipment Lists (MMELs). The board members are drawn from the FAA.

n. Flight Standardization Board. The FSB is responsible for specification of minimum training, checking, currency, and pilot type rating requirements, if necessary, for U.S. certificated civil aircraft. The board members are drawn from the FAA (AEG, Headquarters, Flight Standards field offices operations personnel).

o. Handling Characteristics. The manner in which the aircraft responds with respect to rate and magnitude of pilot initiated control inputs to the primary flight control surfaces (e.g., ailerons, elevator, rudder, spoilers, cyclic, collective, etc.).

p. Line Oriented Simulation (LOS). Use of a simulator in place of the aircraft to reinforce the understanding of differences between related aircraft. LOS should not be confused with operating experience (OE), which is required by 14 CFR.

q. Line Oriented Flying (LOF). The LOF phase of the test is used at the discretion of the FSB during the T3 test to validate the proposed training and checking. The LOF fully assesses particular difference areas, examines implications of mixed fleet flying, assesses special circumstances such as minimum equipment list (MEL) effects, and evaluates the effects of pilot errors potentially associated with the differences.

a. Aircraft Evaluation Group (AEG). Federal Aviation Administration… › bb.

r. Master Difference Requirements (MDR). MDRs are those requirements applicable to pilot qualifications that pertains to differences between related aircraft. MDRs are specified by the FSB in terms of the minimum difference levels. MDRs form the basis for an operator to develop their operator differences requirements (ODR).

s. Mixed Fleet Flying. Mixed fleet flying is the operation of a base aircraft and one or more related aircraft for which credit may be taken for training and/or checking events. The FSB process defines minimum training, checking, and currency difference levels between related aircraft.

t. Operational Characteristics. As used with respect to aircraft, means those features that are distinguishable by limitations, flight characteristics, normal procedures, nonnormal procedures, alternate or supplementary procedures, or maneuvers.

u. Operator Difference Requirements (ODR). If differences exist within an operator’s fleet that affect pilot knowledge, skills, or abilities pertinent to systems or procedures, ODR tables provide a uniform means for operators to comprehensively manage difference programs and provide a basis for FAA approval of mixed fleet flying.

v. Pilot Type Rating. A pilot type rating is a “one time”, permanent endorsement on a pilot certificate indicating that the holder of the certificate has completed the appropriate training and testing required for its issuance as determined by regulation and by the applicable FSB report. It is recorded by the FAA on the pilot’s certificate indicating the make, model, and series of aircraft, if applicable. Title 14 CFR may require a pilot type rating to serve as pilot in command (PIC) and in some cases as second in command (SIC) of U.S. civil aircraft.

w. Recency of Experience. With respect to flight experience as required by 14 CFR, means a pilot’s completion of the required number of takeoffs and landings as sole manipulator of the controls within the preceding 90 days.

x. Related Aircraft. Related aircraft are any two or more aircraft of the same make that have been demonstrated and determined to have commonality to the extent that credit between those aircraft may be applied for training, checking, or currency, as documented through MDR and approved by the FSB.

y. Same Pilot Type Rating. A pilot type rating is assigned when no greater than a level D training difference is determined between a series of aircraft with the same aircraft TCs.

z. Series. Aircraft sharing the same aircraft TC. Specific variations that are usually defined by the manufacturer and usually result in an amended aircraft TC.

aa. Supplementary Procedures. Those procedures that are identified in the Flight Crew Operation Manual (FCOM) under the section “Supplementary Procedures” describing procedures not described under the “Normal Procedures” or “Nonnormal Procedures” sections.

bb. Supervised Line Flying (SLF). Supervised experience associated with the introduction of equipment or procedures requiring post qualification skill enhancement during which a pilot

2. REFERENCES (current editions). ›  FAA-S-8081-5, Aircraft Type Rating Practical Test Standards for…

10/15/08 AC 120-53A Appendix 1 occupies a specific pilot position and performs particular assigned duties for that pilot position under the supervision of a qualified company instructor or check airman.

cc. Training Footprint. A training footprint is a summary description of a training program, usually in short tabular form, showing training subjects, modules, procedures, maneuvers or other program elements, which are planned for completion during each day or phase of training.

2. REFERENCES (current editions).

• Title 14 CFR.

• Order 8900.1, Flight Standards Information Management System.

• AC 61-89, Pilot Certificates, Aircraft Type Ratings.

• AC 120-35, Line Operational Simulations: Line Oriented Flight Training, Special Purpose Operational Training, Line Operational Evaluation.

• AC 120-40, Airplane Simulator Qualification.

• AC 120-45, Airplane Flight Training Device Qualification.

• AC 120-51, Crew Resource Management Training.

• FAA-S-8081-5, Aircraft Type Rating Practical Test Standards for Airplane.

Page 5 (and 6)

TABLE OF CONTENTS

APPENDIX 2. PILOT QUALIFICATION AND PILOT RATING REQUIREMENTS

TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. PURPOSE … 4

2. FOCUS … 4

3. INTRODUCTION a. A Comprehensive System for Pilot Qualification … 4 b. Master Differences Requirements (MDR) Set by FAA … 4 c. Specification of Constraints or Credits … 4 d. Recognition of Unique Operator Characteristics … 4 e. Basis for Requirements … 5 f. Relationship to other FAA Policies … 5 4. CONCEPTS a. An Integrated System for Pilot Qualification … 5 b. MDRs … 5 c. Difference Levels … 8 d. Training Difference Levels … 9 e. Checking Difference Levels … 11 f. Currency Difference Levels … 12 g. Operating Experience (OE) for Aircraft … 15 h. Supervised Line Flying (SLF) … 15 i. Recency of Experience … 16 j. Operator Difference Requirements (ODR) … 16 5. FORMULATION OF FSB REPORTS, MDRs, AND DESIGNATION OF PILOT TYPE RATINGS.

a. Requirements Formulation Process Overview … 24 b. Proposals for MDRs, Example ODRs, and Special Requirements … 24 c. Difference Level Tests … 25 d. FSB Assessments and Proposal Formulationc … 27 e. Comments Solicited … 31 f. FSB Final Determinations and Findings … 31 g. FSB Report Preparation Distribution and FAA Application … 32 h. FSB Report Revision … 33 6. OPERATOR’S APPLICATION OF FSB PROVISIONS, PREPARATION, USE, AND REVISION OF ODRs.

a. General … 34 b. Application of MDRs and Preparation and Use of ODRs … 34 c. Selecting Base Aircraft … 36 d. Identification of Differences and the Analysis of Effects of Those Differences … 36 e. Identification of Compliance Methods … 36 f. When Proposed ODR Compliance Methods Do Not Meet MDRs … 36

ILLUSTRATIONS

g. Maximum Number of Related Aircraft … 37 h. Application, Review and Approval … 37 i. Implementation Provisions Transition Period … 37 j. ODR Revision … 38 7. FAA REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF OPERATOR PROGRAMS a. General … 40 b. Operator Application of ODRs … 40 c. Base and Other Aircraft Identification … 42 d. Approval of ODRs … 42 e. POI Uncertainty Regarding Program Compliance … 43 f. Proposals that do not Comply with FSB Provisions … 43 g. FSB Revision of MDRs or Other FSB Provisions … 43 h. Proving Tests … 44 i. Line-Oriented Flight Training (LOFT), LOS, or SLF … 44 j. OE … 44 k. Limitations on the Total Number of Related Aircraft … 44 l. Compliance Checklist for CHDOs … 45 m. Implementation of FSB Provisions … 45 n. Aircraft That Do Not Have an FSB Report … 45 8. APPLICATION OF REQUIREMENTS TO AIRMEN CERTIFICATION. a. General … 45 b. Checking Specifications … 45 c. Checks Regarding Complex Systems … 45 9. TRAINING DEVICE AND SIMULATOR APPROVAL. a. Training Device and Simulator Characteristics … 46 b. Aircraft/Simulator/Device Compatibility … 46 c. Simulator and Device Approvals … 46 10. REVIEW AND APPROVAL … 47

11. APPEAL OF FAA DECISIONS … 47

ILLUSTRATIONS

Figure 1. Master Difference Requirements (MDR) Table Example … 7

Figure 2. Difference Level Table … 15

Figure 3-1. Design Operator Differences Requirements Table Example … 18

Figure 3-2. Systems Operator Differences Requirements Table Example … 19

Figure 3-3. Maneuver Operator Difference Requirements Table Example … 23

Figure 4. Master Requirements Formulation … 28

Figure 5. Test Definitions … 29

Figure 6. “T” Tests 1 Thru 5 … 30

Figure 7. Standard Method, Devices, And Simulators … 32

Figure 8. FSB Process … 39

3. INTRODUCTION. › d. Recognition of Unique Operator Characteristics. The system…

APPENDIX 2. PILOT QUALIFICATION AND PILOT RATING REQUIREMENTS

1. PURPOSE. This appendix describes a comprehensive system for pilot qualifications outlined in this advisory circular (AC). It includes definitions, criteria, processes, tests, methods, and procedures necessary for uniform application of the system.

2. FOCUS. The appendix applies to and is used by:

• Aircraft manufacturers or modifiers who design, test, and certificate under Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR).

• Operators who operate under 14 CFR.

• Operator, manufacturer, or other training centers having programs approved for use under 14 CFR.

• Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) offices and inspectors administering programs under 14 CFR.

3. INTRODUCTION.

a. A Comprehensive System for Pilot Qualification. This AC and its appendices provide a systematic means to address requirements for training, checking, and currency within applicable 14 CFR parts. Definitions, criteria, processes, procedures, tests, and methods are consistent with and clarify application of current rules in particular situations for specific aircraft. This AC describes a comprehensive system for the FAA and industry to evaluate, and approve use of particular aircraft and operator programs. The respective roles of training, checking, currency and airmen certification are clarified. This includes defining the role and criteria for designation of pilot type ratings for existing, new, or modified aircraft. The system is particularly suited to addressing transition, differences programs, and mixed fleet flying. The system aids in assuring that pilots attain and maintain the knowledge, skills, and abilities needed to operate assigned aircraft safely.

b. Master Differences Requirements (MDR) Set by FAA. The FAA’s Flight Standardization Board (FSB) sets MDRs to address differences between related aircraft.

c. Specification of Constraints or Credits. The system permits the specification of constraints or permissible credits. Constraints or credits may relate to knowledge, skills, abilities, devices, simulators, maneuvers, checks, currency, or any other such factors necessary for safe operations. Constraints or credits may apply generally to aircraft, particular pilot positions, or other situations or conditions.

d. Recognition of Unique Operator Characteristics. The system recognizes the unique characteristics of individual operators while achieving uniformity in application of FAA safety standards. FSB MDRs provide a uniform basis for principal operations inspectors (POI) to use in tailoring individual operator’s ODRs. POIs may approve each operator’s ODRs within the context of FSB MDRs. ODRs accommodate particular combinations of related aircraft flown, pilot assignment policies, training methods and devices, and other factors that relate to the

b. MDRs. › (1) MDR Applicability.

application of the FSB MDRs. Accordingly, the system preserves operator flexibility while standardizing the FAA’s role in review, approval, and monitoring of training, checking, and currency programs within 14 CFR.

e. Basis for Requirements. The determination of pilot type rating, minimum differences training, checking and currency requirements focus on basic operation of aircraft in the National Airspace System (NAS) under both instrument flight rules (IFR) and visual flight rules (VFR). Included are all flight phases from preflight to shutdown under both normal and nonnormal conditions.

f. Relationship to other FAA Policies. Although this AC, and the FSB provisions in some instances, address particular types of operations or specific aircraft systems (e.g., use of flight guidance control systems for Category II/III instrument approaches, long-range navigation, etc.), other ACs address these issues more thoroughly. This AC and FSB provisions address such issues only to the extent necessary to assure that pilots are qualified to operate pertinent systems or equipment as part of initial or continuing qualification.

4. CONCEPTS.

a. An Integrated System for Pilot Qualification.

(1) System Elements. An integrated FAA/applicant system and process established to determine appropriate requirements, apply the requirements, and meet those requirements on a continuing basis, for uniform pilot qualification.

(2) System Overview. The system uniformly applies FAA master requirements in a way that tailors a particular aircraft, to any operator’s unique situation or fleet. The FAA approves unique operator and fleet requirements for each operator based on FAA master requirements. The system develops FAA master requirements based on objective criteria and tests, with applicants’ support for analysis, and testing. FSB reports for related aircraft describe FAA master requirements. MDRs express FAA master requirements (the minimum acceptable difference levels between related aircraft). An operator’s training program, checklist, operations manuals, pilot certification, CTLC programs, and other such approvals are by-products of compliance with MDRs. Operators comply with MDRs using unique ODRs, tailored to that operator’s programs and approved by the FAA. ODRs, based on and in compliance with the MDRs, specify requirements uniquely applicable to a particular operator’s mixed fleet flying situation. An operator’s specific document describes ODRs by identifying a base aircraft, differences between related aircraft, and that operator’s compliance methods for each related aircraft. Paragraph 4j describes ODRs. Paragraph 6 describes ODR preparation and use. Paragraph 7 describes FAA approval of ODRs.

b. MDRs.

(1) MDR Applicability. MDRs are those requirements applicable to pilot qualification that pertain to differences between related aircraft. MDRs specify the minimum difference levels between related aircraft that may be approved. One related aircraft is selected by the applicant as a reference for comparison purposes and is considered a base aircraft. This is typically the first aircraft on which pilots are qualified, or is the aircraft of which an operator has the largest

b. MDRs. › (1)

number. Difference levels between the base aircraft and other related aircraft then specify the minimum difference requirements to be met for pilot qualification. Major differences in a particular fleet are defined between groups of related aircraft rather than specifying differences between each possible configuration and combination of configurations between related aircraft. MDRs are specified in terms of training, check, and currency difference levels described in paragraph 4d and are shown on an MDR table.

(2) MDR Content. MDRs specify the minimum training, checking, and currency acceptable to the FAA for pilot qualification regarding differences.

(3) MDR Formulation, Description, and Revision. MDRs are formulated by the FAA FSB for each related aircraft. MDRs are formulated using standardized tests and evaluations in conjunction with the type certification or supplemental type certification process. MDRs are based on an applicant’s (usually an aircraft manufacturer) proposal, FAA evaluation of that proposal, OE, and test results when tests are necessary. FSB determinations also consider operator recommendations, safety history, and other relevant information. MDRs are described in provisions of an FSB report and may be revised if necessary. MDRs are revised when aircraft are developed or modified, tests or OE shows a need for revision, a revision is requested by an applicant and evidence indicates the need for revision, or rules or FAA policies change. MDRs are revised by a process similar to that used for initial formulation of requirements.

(4) MDR Use. MDRs are applied to specific operators through formally described ODRs that are developed by and tailored to each operator. FAA field offices use the MDRs as the basis for approval of individual operator’s differences programs for approval of initial or transition programs where credit for previous training or experience with other related aircraft is sought.

(5) The MDR Table. An example of typical MDRs for the B-737-200, 300, 400, 500, 600, 700, 800, and 900 is shown in Figure 1. MDR table requirements are shown for each pair of aircraft by notations in each element of corresponding columns and rows of the table. Each element of the table identifies the minimum differences training, checking, and currency requirements applicable to mixed fleet flying. The MDR table identifies a pertinent base aircraft and particular aircraft for which requirements are sought. Note the minimum difference levels that correspond to the pertinent column and row, and special requirements in footnotes, if applicable.

(6) Use of MDR Difference Levels. Operators must satisfy difference requirements by using the methods acceptable for the specified level or higher levels. Lower level methods may be used in addition to the required levels but may not substitute for the required level or be used exclusively instead of the required level.

(9) Special Requirements. › (a) MDR Footnotes.

FIGURE 1. MASTER DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS (MDR) TABLE

FROM AIRCRAFT PILOT TYPE RATING: B-737 B-737 BASIC

B-737-100, 200 (SP77)

B-737-200 ADV

B-737-300, 400, 500 (NON-EFIS)

B-737-300, 400, 500 (EFIS)

B-737-600, 700, 800, 900 B-737 BASIC A/A/A B/A/B (2) NAV-B/B/C (6) PMS-C/B/C

C*/C*/D C*/C*/D D/D/D

(7) Differences within a Series. Differences may exist even within series shown on an MDR table, such as within the A-318/319/320/321 series. MDR elements may show requirements from one series to another identified in the footnotes. Such requirements however, apply only if pertinent differences exist between those aircraft.

(8) More than Two Related Aircraft. When pilot assignments apply to more than two related aircraft, such as the A-320, A-330, and A-340, each pertinent requirement of the MDR table applies. Applications of multiple requirements for flying two or more related aircraft and certain limits to flying large numbers of related aircraft are described in paragraph 7k.

(9) Special Requirements.

(a) MDR Footnotes. Footnotes can be used to credit, constrain, or set alternate levels when special situations apply. Use of footnotes permits accommodation of variations in installed equipment, options, pilot knowledge or experience on other aircraft, training methods or devices, or other factors that are not addressed by basic levels between aircraft. For example, a footnote

B-737-100, 200 (SP77)

(2) NAV-B/B/C (6) PMS-C/B/C

B-737-200 ADV B/A/B (1) PDCS- C/B/C (2) NAV-B/B/C (4) AFCS- C/B/C (6) PMS-C/B/C

A/A/A (1) PDCS- C/B/C (2) NAV-B/B/C (4) AFCS- C/B/C (6) PMS-C/B/C

C*/C*/D (1) PDCS- B/B/C (2) NAV-B/B/C (5) LIMITED FMS-C/B/C

C*/C*/D (1) PDCS- B/B/C (2) NAV-B/B/C

D/D/D (1) PDCS- B/B/C (2) NAV-B/B/C

B-737-300, 400, 500

TO AIRCRAFT

C*/C*/D (5) LIMITED FMS-C/B/C

C*/C*/D (5) LIMITED FMS-C/B/C

A/A/A (7) CROSS MODEL- (NON-EFIS)

A/A/B

C/B/B (8) C/B/B

B-737-300, 400, 500 (EFIS)

(3) C*/C*/D (5) LIMITED FMS-C/B/C

(3) C*/C*/D (5) LIMITED FMS-C/B/C

(3) C/B/B A/A/A (7) CROSS MODEL- A/A/B

(8) C/B/B (9) PFD/ND- D/C/C B-737-600, 700, 800, 900

D/D/D D/D/D (8) C/B/B (9) PFD/ND- D/C/C

(8) C/B/B (9) PFD/ND- D/C/C

A/A/A (9) PFD/ND- D/C/C (11) EDFCS- C/C/C

may allow credit or apply constraints to the use of a particular flight guidance control system (FGCS), flight management system (FMS), or electronic flight instrument system (EFIS), which is installed on aircraft. Footnotes are an appropriate means to address requirements that relate to specific systems (e.g., flight director and FMS) rather than a particular aircraft. In such instances, generic knowledge or experience with the particular system may be readily transferable between related aircraft. Footnotes may also be used to set different requirements for initial training or checking rather than for recurrent training or checking. When necessary, footnotes are fully described in the body of the FSB report.

c. Difference Levels. › (2) Basis for Levels.

(b) Other Limitations. Other limitations may occasionally be identified within a difference level (e.g. C*/C*/C). The asterisk following the difference level in such instances identifies a special requirement or limitation pertaining to a particular training method or device. Such notes typically relate to acceptable training device characteristics when the simulator evaluation and approval process or standard criteria of this AC are not available to address a particular situation appropriately.

(10) MDRs for Aircraft with the Same or Common Pilot Type Ratings. A single FSB report and MDR table may apply to aircraft that are assigned the same pilot type rating (same aircraft TC). For example, a single MDR table may cover the A-318/319/320/321 that have a same pilot type rating. A single FSB report and MDR table may also apply to aircraft that are assigned a common pilot type rating. For example, a single MDR table may cover both the B-767 and B-757 that have a common pilot type rating. When level E training is required for an aircraft with a same aircraft TC and an additional pilot type rating is assigned, such as the B-747 and B-747-400, a single MDR table for all series of a type-certificated aircraft still applies.

(11) Minimum acceptable difference levels are recommended by the FSB based on standard tests described in Appendix 3.

c. Difference Levels.

(1) General Description. Difference levels are formally designated levels of training methods or devices, checking methods, or means of maintaining currency that satisfy minimum difference requirements or pilot type rating requirements. Difference levels specify FAA requirements proportionate to and corresponding with increasing differences between related aircraft. A range of five difference levels in order of increasing requirements, identified as A through E, are each specified for training, checking, and currency. MDRs are specified in terms of difference levels. Difference levels are used to credit knowledge, skills, and abilities applicable to an aircraft for which a pilot is already qualified and current, during initial, transition or upgrade training for other related aircraft. Operators, who conduct mixed fleet flying where credit is sought, should apply difference levels and address all mixed fleet flying requirements to ensure compliance with FAA requirements necessary to assure safe operations.

(2) Basis for Levels. Difference levels apply when a difference with potential to affect flight safety exists between related aircraft. Differences may also affect knowledge, skills, or abilities required of a pilot. If no differences exist or if differences exist but do not affect knowledge, skills, abilities or flight safety, then difference levels are not assigned nor are they applicable to pilot qualification. When difference levels A through E apply, each difference level

d. Training Difference Levels. › (2) Level B Training.

is based on a scale of differences in design features, systems, or maneuvers. In assessing the effects of differences, both flight characteristics and procedures are considered, since flight characteristics address handling qualities and performance, while procedures include normal and abnormal/nonnormal/emergency items.

(3) Relationship Between Training, Checking, and Currency Levels. While particular aircraft are often assigned the same level (e.g., C/C/C) for training, checking, and currency, such assignment is not necessary. Levels may be assigned independently. For example, an aircraft may be assigned level C for training, level D for checking, and level C for currency (e.g., C/D/C).

(4) Designation of a Pilot Type Rating. Candidate aircraft having the same TC are assigned the same pilot type rating if training differences are not greater than level D. Candidate aircraft of the same make having different TCs that have training differences no greater than level D may be assigned a common pilot type rating. A candidate aircraft with systems such as heads-up display (HUD), Enhanced Vision Systems (EVS), or Synthetic Visions Systems (SVS) may require Level E training without requiring a new pilot type rating. The FSB, with the concurrence of the Air Transportation Division, AFS-200, will make this determination. When different pilot type ratings are assigned because of one or more candidates requiring level E training, pilot type ratings may be assigned to related aircraft consistent with a logical grouping of the most similarly related aircraft.

d. Training Difference Levels.

(1) Level A Training. Level A difference training is that differences training between related aircraft that can adequately be addressed through self-instruction. Level A training represents a knowledge requirement that, once appropriate information is provided, understanding and compliance can be assumed. Level A compliance is achieved by such methods as issuance of operating manual page revisions, dissemination of operating bulletins, or differences handouts to describe minor differences in aircraft. Level A training is limited to the following situations:

(a) A change that introduces a different version of a system/component for which the pilot has already shown the ability to understand and use (e.g., an updated version of an engine).

(b) A change that results in minor or no procedural changes and does not adversely effect safety if the information is not reviewed or forgotten (e.g., a different vibration damping engine mount is installed, expect more vibration in descent; logo lights are installed, use is optional).

(c) Information that highlights a difference, which is evident to the pilot, inherently obvious, and easily accommodated (e.g., different location of a communication radio panel, a different exhaust gas temperature limit that is placarded, or changes to nonnormal “read and do” procedures).

(2) Level B Training. Level B difference training is applicable to aircraft with system or procedure differences that can adequately be addressed through aided instruction. At level B,

d. Training Difference Levels. › (5) Level E Training.

aided instruction is appropriate to ensure pilot understanding, emphasize issues, provide a standardized method of presenting material, or aid retention of material following training. Level B aided instruction can utilize slide/tape presentations, computer based tutorial instruction, stand-up lectures or video tapes. Situations not covered under the provisions of level A training may require level B (or higher levels) if certain tests described in later paragraphs fail.

(3) Level C Training. Level C differences training can only be accomplished through use of devices that are capable of systems training. Level C differences training is applicable to related aircraft having part task differences that affect skills or abilities and knowledge. Training objectives focus on mastering individual systems, procedures, or tasks, as opposed to performing highly integrated flight operations and maneuvers in “real time.” Level C may require selfinstruction or aided instruction, but cannot be adequately addressed by a knowledge requirement alone. Training devices are required to supplement instruction, ensure attainment or retention of pilot skills and abilities, and accomplish the more complex tasks, usually related to operation of particular aircraft systems. While level C systems knowledge or skills relate to specific rather than fully integrated tasks, performance of steps to accomplish normal, nonnormal, alternate, recall procedures, or maneuvers related to particular systems (e.g., flight guidance control systems/flight management systems) may be necessary. Typically, the minimum acceptable training media for level C training would be interactive computer-based training, cockpit systems simulators, cockpit procedure trainers or part task trainers (e.g., flight management system (FMS) or traffic collision avoidance system (TCAS)).

(4) Level D Training. Level D training can only be accomplished with devices capable of performing flight maneuvers and addressing full task differences of knowledge, skills, and/or abilities. Devices capable of flight maneuvers address full task performance in a dynamic real time environment. The devices enable integration of knowledge, skills, and abilities in a simulated flight environment, involving combinations of operationally oriented tasks and realistic task loading for each relevant phase of flight. Level D training, knowledge, and skills to complete necessary normal, nonnormal, alternate, or recall procedures are fully addressed for each related aircraft. Level D differences training requires mastery of interrelated skills that cannot be adequately addressed by separate acquisition of a series of knowledge areas or skills that are interrelated. The differences are not so significant that a full transition training course is required.

If demonstrating interrelationships between the systems is important, use of a series of separate devices for systems training will not suffice. Training for level D differences requires a training device that has accurate, high fidelity integration of systems and controls, and realistic instrument indications. Level D training may also require maneuvers, visual cues, motion cues, dynamics, control loading or specific environmental conditions. Weather phenomenon such as low visibility, CAT III, or windshear may or may not be incorporated. Where simplified or generic characteristics of an aircraft type are used in devices to satisfy difference level D training, significant negative training must not occur as a result of the simplification. Typically, the minimum acceptable training media for level D training would be Flight Training Device level 6.

(5) Level E Training. Level E training is applicable to candidate aircraft having such significant full task differences that require a “high fidelity” environment to attain or maintain knowledge, skills, or abilities. Training at level E can only be satisfied by the use of a simulator qualified at level C or D consistent with FAA criteria. Level E training, if done in an aircraft,

e. Checking Difference Levels. › (5) Level D Checking.

should be modified for safety reasons where maneuvers can result in a high degree of risk (i.e., an engine set at idle thrust to simulate an engine failure). As with other levels, when level E training is assigned, suitable credit or constraints may be applied for knowledge, skills, and/or abilities related to other pertinent related aircraft. Credits or constraints are specified for the subjects, procedures, or maneuvers shown in FSB reports and are applied through the ODR table.

NOTE: Training differences levels recommended by the FSB represent minimum requirements. Operators may use a device associated with a higher difference level to satisfy a training differences requirement. For example, if level C differences are assessed due to installation of a different FMS, operators may train pilots using the FMS installed in a full flight simulator (FFS) as a system trainer if a dedicated part task FMS training device is not available.

e. Checking Difference Levels.

(1) Initial and Recurrent Checking. Difference checking addresses any pertinent pilot testing or certification that includes pilot type rating checks, proficiency checks, Advanced Qualification Program (AQP) evaluations, and any other checks specified by FSB reports. Initial and recurrent checking levels are the same unless otherwise specified by the FSB in the MDR. In certain instances, it may be possible to satisfactorily accomplish recurrent checking objectives in devices that do not meet initial checking requirements. In such instances, the FSB may recommend certain devices that do not meet initial check requirements for use to administer recurring checks. The POI/Training Center Program Manager, in coordination with the FSB, may require checking in the initial level device when doubt exists regarding pilot competency or program adequacy.

(2) Level A Checking. Level A checking indicates that no check related to differences is required at the time of differences training. A pilot is responsible for knowledge of each related aircraft flown. Differences items should be included as an integral part of subsequent recurring proficiency checks.

(3) Level B Checking. Level B checking indicates that a “task” or “systems” check is required following transition and recurring differences training. Level B checking typically applies to particular tasks or systems such as FMS, TCAS, or other individual systems or related groups of systems.

(4) Level C Checking. Level C checking requires a partial proficiency check using a device suitable for meeting level C (or higher) differences training requirements following transition and recurrent differences training. The partial check is conducted relative to particular maneuvers or systems designated by the FSB. Example of a level C check: Evaluation of a sequence of maneuvers demonstrating a pilot’s ability to use a FGCS or FMS. An acceptable scenario would include each relevant phase of flight that uses the FGCS or FMS.

(5) Level D Checking. Level D checking requires a partial proficiency check for one or more related aircraft following both transition and recurrent training. The partial proficiency check covers the particular maneuvers, systems, or devices designated by the FSB. Level D

f. Currency Difference Levels. The term “currency” as used in this AC… › (3) Level C Currency.

checks are performed using scenarios representing a “real time” flight environment and devices permitted for level D differences training. A full proficiency check is typically conducted on the base aircraft, and a partial proficiency check on the related aircraft, covering all pertinent differences.

(6) Level E Checking. Unless specified, level E checking requires that a full proficiency check be conducted in a level C or D FFS. As with other levels, when level E checking is assigned, suitable credit or constraints may be applied for knowledge, skills, and/or abilities related to other pertinent related aircraft. Credits or constraints are specified for the subjects, procedures, or maneuvers shown in FSB reports and are applied through the ODR table.

NOTE: Assignment of level E checking requirements alone does not result in assignment of a separate pilot type rating. Only the assignment of level E training requirements may result in assignment of a separate pilot type rating.

f. Currency Difference Levels. The term “currency” as used in this AC addresses recent experience necessary for safe operation of aircraft as designated by the FSB. Currency issues not specified by the FSB are covered by regulation.

(1) Level A Currency. Level A currency is considered common to each related aircraft. Thus, assessment or tracking of currency for separate related aircraft is not necessary or applicable. Maintenance of currency in any one related aircraft or a combination of related aircraft will suffice for any other related aircraft.

(2) Level B Currency. Level B currency is “knowledge related” currency, typically achieved through self-review by individual pilots for a particular aircraft. Self-review is usually accomplished by review of material provided by the operator to pilot. Such currency may be undertaken at an individual pilot’s initiative; however, the operator must identify the material and the frequency or other situations in which the material should be reviewed. Self-review may be based on manual information, bulletins, aircraft placards, memos, class handouts, videotapes, or other memory aids that describe the differences, procedures, maneuvers, or limits for the pertinent aircraft that pilots are flying. Examples of acceptable compliance with level B currency are:

(a) The issuance of a bulletin that directs pilots to review specific operating manual information before flying a related aircraft. Level B currency may be regained by review of pertinent information to include bulletins, if that related aircraft has not been flown within a specified period (e.g., fly that related aircraft or have completed a review of the differences in limitations and procedures within a specified number of days).

(b) Pilot certification on a dispatch release that they have reviewed pertinent information for a particular related aircraft to be flown on that trip. Level B currency cannot, however, be achieved solely by review of class notes taken by and at the initiative of an individual pilot unless the adequacy of those notes is verified by the operator.

(3) Level C Currency. Level C currency is applicable to one or more designated systems or procedures, and relates to both skill and knowledge requirements. An example would

(5) Level D Currency. › (b) Tracking the completion of specific maneuvers based on logbook…

be establishment of FMS currency, flight guidance control system currency, or other particular currency that is necessary for safe operation of a related aircraft. Establishment of level C for a related aircraft with an FMS would typically require a pilot to fly that related aircraft within the specified period of time or re-establish currency. Currency constraints for level C are established by the FSB. When level C currency applies, pertinent level B currency must also be addressed. Examples of methods acceptable for addressing level C currency are:

(a) Pilot scheduling practices resulting in a pilot being scheduled to fly a related aircraft with the pertinent system/procedure within the specified period of time;

(b) Tracking of an individual pilot’s flying of related aircraft to ensure that the particular system/procedure has been flown within the specified period of time;

(c) Use of a higher level method (level D or E currency); or

(d) Other methods recommended by the FSB.

(4) Re-establishing Level C Currency. When currency is lost, currency may be reestablished by completing required items using a device equal to or higher than that specified for level C differences training and checking. Other means to re-establish currency include flights with an appropriately qualified check airman/instructor, completion of proficiency training, or a proficiency check. In some instances, a formal refamiliarization period in the actual aircraft with the applicable system operating while on the ground may be acceptable if permitted by the POI. Such refamiliarization periods are completed using an operator-established procedure under the supervision of a pilot designated by the operator. In the case of a noncurrent SIC, a designated pilot-in-command (PIC) may be authorized to accompany a pilot to re-establish currency.

(5) Level D Currency. Level D currency is related to designated maneuvers, and addresses knowledge and skills required for performing aircraft control tasks in real time, with integrated use of associated systems and procedures. Level D currency may also address certain differences in flight characteristics including performance of any required maneuvers and related normal/abnormal/emergency procedures for a particular related aircraft. A typical application of level D currency is to specify selected maneuvers, such as takeoff, departure, arrival, approach, or landing, which are to be performed using a particular FGCS and instrument display system. Either a pilot must fly a related aircraft equipped with the FGCS and particular display system sufficiently often to retain familiarity and competence within the specified currency period, or currency must be re-established. Currency constraints for level D are established by the FSB. When level D currency applies, pertinent level B and level C currency must also be addressed. Examples of methods acceptable for addressing level D currency are:

(a) Tracking of flights by a particular pilot in a particular related aircraft to assure experience within the specified currency period.

(b) Tracking the completion of specific maneuvers based on logbook entries, Aircraft Communication Addressing and Reporting System (ACARS) data, or other reliable records to assure experience within the specified currency period.

f. Currency Difference Levels. The term “currency” as used in this AC… › (9) Competency Regarding Abnormal/Nonnormal/Emergency Procedures.

(c) Scheduling of aircraft or pilots to permit currency requirements to be met with verification that each pilot has actually accomplished the assigned or an equivalent schedule.

(d) Completion of pilot certification, proficiency check, proficiency training, AQP evaluations, or other pertinent events in which designated maneuvers are performed in a device or simulator acceptable for level D currency.

(e) Use of a higher level method (level E currency).

(f) Other methods recommended by the FSB.

(6) Re-establishing Level D Currency. When currency is lost, currency may be reestablished by completing pertinent maneuvers using a device equal to or higher than that specified for level D differences training and checking. Other means to re-establish currency include flight with an appropriately qualified check airman during training or in line operations, completion of proficiency training, a proficiency check, or AQP proficiency evaluation.

(7) Level E Currency. Level E currency may specify system, procedure, or maneuver currency item(s) necessary for safe operations, as identified by the FSB, to be accomplished in a Level C/D simulator for that related aircraft. FSB provisions related to takeoff and landing are applied in a way that addresses needed system or maneuver experience. For example, if FGCS, FMS, EFIS, navigation, or other system or maneuver experience is the basis for a currency requirement, approval of an operator’s program at level E includes the use of those systems in conjunction with satisfying takeoff and landing requirements. In this instance, making three simulator takeoffs and landings in VFR closed traffic without using the FGCS, EFIS, or FMS may not be sufficient to meet level E currency requirements.

NOTE: Assignment of level E currency requirements does not result in assignment of a separate pilot type rating. Only the assignment of level E training requirements may result in assignment of a separate pilot type rating.

(8) Re-establishing Level E Currency. When currency is lost, currency may be reestablished by completing pertinent maneuvers using a device specified for level E differences training and checking. Other means to re-establish currency include flight with an appropriately qualified check airman during training or in line operations, completion of proficiency training, a proficiency check, or AQP evaluation.

(9) Competency Regarding Abnormal/Nonnormal/Emergency Procedures. Competency for nonnormal maneuvers or procedures is generally addressed by checking requirements; however, in particular abnormal/nonnormal/emergency maneuvers or procedures may not be mandatory for checking or training. In this situation, it may be necessary to periodically practice or demonstrate those maneuvers or procedures even though it is not necessary to complete them during each check. In such instances, the FSB may specify a currency requirement for training or checking applicable to abnormal/nonnormal/emergency maneuvers or procedures that are to be performed. This is to assure that extended periods of time do not elapse in a series of repeated training and checking events in which significant maneuvers or procedures may never be accomplished. When an abnormal/nonnormal/emergency maneuver or procedure is not mandatory

h. Supervised Line Flying (SLF). Experience associated with the… › (1) Introduction of new systems (e.g., Automatic Dependent Surveillance…

and is not accomplished during each proficiency training or proficiency check, but is still important to occasionally practice or demonstrate, the FSB may establish a currency requirement. When designated by the FSB, these currency requirements identify each abnormal/nonnormal/ emergency maneuver or procedure, the currency level applicable, and an applicable time period or any other necessary/appropriate constraints.

(10) Difference Level Summary. Difference levels are summarized in Figure 2 below for training, checking, and currency. Complete descriptions of difference levels for training, checking and currency are given above.

FIGURE 2. DIFFERENCE LEVEL TABLE

DIFFERENCE

LEVEL

TRAINING CHECKING CURRENCY

A Self instruction Not applicable (or integrated with next proficiency check)

Not applicable

B Aided instruction Task or system check Self review C Systems devices Partial check using Device

Designated system

D Maneuver devices* Partial proficiency check using device*

Designed maneuver(s)

E Simulator C/D or aircraft #

Proficiency check using simulator C/D

Designed maneuver(s) except takeoff and landings Or aircraft* # = New pilot type rating is normally assigned * = FFS or aircraft may be used to accomplish specific maneuvers g. Operating Experience (OE) for Aircraft.

(1) Application of OE. Requirements for OE are consistent with provisions for OE specified under 14 CFR.

(2) Credits or Constraints. OE must meet the applicable requirements of the CFR part under which operations are conducted, except that credit for applicable OE in other related aircraft may be permitted. When approved by the FAA, OE associated with differences may be accomplished as part of or in conjunction with line oriented simulation (LOS).

h. Supervised Line Flying (SLF). Experience associated with the introduction of equipment or procedures requiring post qualification skill enhancement during which a pilot occupies a specific pilot position and performs particular assigned duties for that pilot position under the supervision of a pilot instructor or check airman qualified for the operator. One or more of the reasons described below may apply:

(1) Introduction of new systems (e.g., Automatic Dependent Surveillance Broadcast (ADS-B), runway area advisory system (RAAS), etc).

(2) Introduction of new operations (e.g., oceanic operations, Extended Operations with Two-Engine Airplanes (ETOPS)).

(3) Experience for a particular pilot position (e.g., PIC, SIC).

(2) ODR Content. › (d) Compliance Methods.

(4) Special characteristics (e.g., affects of unique airports, mountainous areas, unusual weather, special air traffic control procedures, or nonstandard runway surfaces) on this aircraft.

i. Recency of Experience. Credit towards the recency of experience requirements of 14 CFR may be permitted for takeoffs and landings performed in related aircraft as provided by CTLC. CTLC must be validated through the FSB process and must be carried out in accordance with accordance with the operator’s CTLC approved program.

j. Operator Difference Requirements (ODR).

(1) ODR Purpose. If differences exist within an operator’s fleet, which affect pilot knowledge, skills, or abilities pertinent to systems or procedures, ODR tables provide a uniform means for operators to comprehensively manage difference programs and provide a basis for FAA approval of mixed fleet flying.

(2) ODR Content. ODRs identify a base aircraft, describe differences between aircraft, and show an operator’s methods of compliance with FAA requirements. The FAA approves an operator’s initial ODR and each subsequent revision for the following:

(a) Base Aircraft. ODRs identify an aircraft or group of aircraft (aircraft of the same series with minor configuration differences) within an operator’s fleet as a base aircraft. The base aircraft serves as a reference for comparison with candidate aircraft. Selection criteria and characteristics of base aircraft are described in paragraphs 6c and 7c.

(b) Candidate/Related Aircraft. ODRs identify particular aircraft flown by an operator within each fleet. ODRs consider only those aircraft and combinations of aircraft actually flown by that operator. ODRs describe differences within an operator’s fleet between the base aircraft and other related aircraft.

(c) Significance of Differences. Differences are described in summary form and are categorized by differences in design features, systems, and maneuvers. Differences are evaluated relative to their effect on either flight characteristics, pilot skills, and/or procedures. Procedures consider normal, nonnormal, alternate, and recall items. Limitations are considered in conjunction with normal procedures.

(d) Compliance Methods. ODRs show how each operator’s program addresses differences, through description of training, checking, or currency methods for each fleet. ODRs describe the specific or unique constraints or credits applicable, and any precautions necessary to address differences between aircraft. ODRs should comply with and be just as or more restrictive than FAA MDRs and other FSB provisions. Constraints or credits may be applied to all aircraft in a fleet or only to certain aircraft. Constraints or credits may address training devices, simulators, checking and currency methods, knowledge, skills, procedure maneuvers, or any other factors that apply to or are necessary for safe operations. Training, checking, and currency

j. Operator Difference Requirements (ODR). › (3) Standard ODR Format.

compliance methods are proposed and revised by each operator consistent with ODR examples from a variety of sources that are acceptable to the FAA. ODR examples are found in FSB reports.

(3) Standard ODR Format. ODRs are depicted in tables in summarized form. If necessary, any explanation of details about differences, constraints and credits, precautions or compliance methods are included in attachments or appendices to ODR tables or are cross referenced to other operator documents. Figure 3 shows the general format for ODR tables, including examples of design, systems, and maneuver differences. The far-left column lists design, system, or maneuver differences that are pertinent. The “Remarks” column summarizes specific areas or items of difference. The “Flight Characteristics” and “Procedural Change” columns identify what (if any) difference effects are noted. The “Compliance Methods” section of the table notes the particular operator’s means of compliance with FAA MDR provisions. The following abbreviations apply:

• ACFT - Aircraft.

• AFDS - Auto Flight Display System.

• AVT - Audio Visual Tapes.

• CBT - Computer Based Training.

• EFIS - Electronic Flight Instrument System.

• EICAS - Engine Indicating and Crew Alerting System.

• FBS - Fixed Base Simulator.

• FFS - Full Flight Simulator.

• FLT CHAR - Flight Characteristics.

• FMC - Flight Management Computer.

• FMS - Flight Management System.

• PROC CHNG - Procedural Changes.

• SU - Stand Up Instruction.

FIGURE 3-1. DESIGN OPERATOR DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS TABLE EXAMPLE

CURR

B

CHKG/CURR

FLT

CHK

LVL

E

LVL

D

LVL

C

LVL

B

AVT/

SU/

CBT

AVT/

SU/

CBT

AVT/

SU/

CBT

COMPLIANCE METHOD

TRAINING

LVL

A

PROC

CHNG

NO

NO

NO

FLT

CHAR

MINOR

NO

NO

REMARKS

- BODY EXTENSION 104”

- WING TIP EXTENSION 14”

- DORSAL FIN

- w/STC ST01219SE, BLENDED WINGLET

- ADDITION OF FMC/AFDS/AT/IRS ETC.

- GROWTH RELATED CHANGES

DESIGN OPERATOR DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS TABLE

DIFFERENCE AIRCRAFT: 737-300

BASE AIRCRAFT: 737-200 ADVANCED

APPROVED BY (POI):

DESIGN FEATURE

AIRPLANE

CONFIGURA-TION

PANEL LAYOUT

WEIGHTS

FIGURE 3-2. SYSTEMS OPERATOR DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS TABLE

EXAMPLE

CURR

D

90 DAYS

+

3 FLT SEG.

CHKG/CURR

FLT

CHK

C*+OE

LVL

E

LVL

D

LVL

C

CBT/

FMS/

AT

LVL

B

AVT/

SU

AVT

AVT/

SU

AVT/

SU

AVT/

SU

COMPLIANCE METHOD

TRAINING

LVL

A

PROC

CHNG

YES

YES

NO

YES

YES

FLT

CHAR

NO

NO

NO

NO

NO

REMARKS

- RECIRC FAN REPLACES GASPER FAN

- 3 POSITION PACK SWITCH

- FWD OUTFLOW VALVE LIGHT

DELETED

- EQUIPMENT COOLING FAN LIGHT

- ADDITIONAL FAN INSTALLED (EFIS

ONLY)

- DISTRIBUTION: MINOR CHANGES

- SP-300 AFDS REPLACES SP-77/SP-177

- AUTOTHROTTLE ADDED*

- AUTOLAND CAPABILITY ADDED*

(*ONLY WHEN COMPARED TO SP-77

AIRPLANES)

- LNAV/VNAV

- TO/GA MODE

- MINOR CHANGES IN POWER

DISTRIBUTION

- CANNISTER OPTION ONLY*

- NEW CREW MASKS*

(*OPTION ON SOME -200 AIRPLANES)

- DUAL-LOOP DETECTION SYSTEM

- MINOR EXTING. EQUIP. CONFIG

CHANGE

- TWO SQUIBS PER BOTTLE

SYSTEMS OPERATOR DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS TABLE

DIFFERENCE AIRCRAFT: 737-300

BASE AIRCRAFT: 737-200 ADVANCED

APPROVED BY (POI):

SYSTEM

21 AIR COND. & PRESSURIZATION

22 AUTO-FLIGHT

25 EMERGENCY EQUIPMENT

24 ELECTRICAL

26 FIRE PROTECTION

FIGURE 3-2. SYSTEMS OPERATOR DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS TABLE

EXAMPLE (CONTINUED)

CURR

CHKG/CURR

FLT

CHK

LVL

E

LVL

D

LVL

C

LVL

B

AVT/

SU

(CBT/

AVT/

SU)

AVT/

SU

COMPLIANCE METHOD

TRAINING

LVL

A

PROC

CHNG

YES

(YES

MIN-

OR)

YES

FLT

CHAR

MINOR

NO

REMARKS

- ADD’L SPOILERS ADDED

- ELECTRIC AIL TRIM

- DUAL CHANNEL MACH TRIM;

TEST BUTTON DELETED

- SPEED TRIM ADDED

- STAB TRIM BRAKE DELETED

- TWO SPEED STAB TRIM

- DIFFERENT STAB TRIM RANGE

- ELECTRIC STAB TRIM OVERRIDE

- ELECTRIC RUDDER TRIM

- AUTOSLAT SYS. ADDED

- TE FLAP PLACARD SPEEDS

- CERTIFIED T/O FLAP SETTINGS

- RUDDER SYSTEM ENHANCEMENT

- (OPTION: BLENDED WINGLET W/

SPEED BRAKE LOAD ALLEVIATION)

- CONTINUOUS FUEL HEAT SWITCHES

DELETED

- FILTER BYPASS LIGHT REPLACES

ICING LIGHT

- FUEL CAPACITY INCREASED

- GND XFER OF FUEL

- AUX TANK (OPTIONAL)

SYSTEMS OPERATOR DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS TABLE

DIFFERENCE AIRCRAFT: 737-300

BASE AIRCRAFT: 737-200 ADVANCED

APPROVED BY (POI):

SYSTEM

27 FLIGHT CONTROLS

28 FUEL

FIGURE 3-2. SYSTEMS OPERATOR DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS TABLE

EXAMPLE (CONTINUED)

CURR

CHKG/CURR

FLT

CHK

LVL

E

LVL

D

LVL

C

LVL

B

AVT/

SU

AVT/

SU

AVT/

SU

AVT/

SU

COMPLIANCE METHOD

TRAINING

LVL

A

PROC

CHNG

YES

YES

YES

NO

FLT

CHAR

NO

NO

NO

NO

REMARKS

- LANDING GEAR XFER UNIT

- SYS A & B SOURCES AND

COMPONENTS CHANGED; A & B

INDEPENDENT

- GROUND INTERCONNECT DELETED

- AUTOSLAT PTU

- THRUST REVERSER - ONE ON EACH

SYSTEM

- B QUANTITY GUAGE ADDED

- STBY RUDDER ON LIGHT

- ENG INLET ANTI-ICE DELETED

- WING ANTI-ICE OPERATION ON

GROUND PERMITTED*

(*OPTION ON SOME -200 AIRPLANES)

- EFIS (AS INSTALLED)

- ADI/HIS (AS INSTALLED)

- NAV SWITCH (AS INSTALLED)

- NORM/ALT REPLACES A & B SYS

BRAKES

- PAIRED WHEEL ANTI-SKID

PROTECTION ON ALT BRAKES

- TIRE SCREEN DELETED*

- NO TOUCHDOWN OR LOCKED WHEEL

PROTECTION ON ALT BRAKES

- SINGLE ANTI-SKID SWITCH

(*OPTION ON SOME -200 AIRPLANES)

SYSTEMS OPERATOR DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS TABLE

DIFFERENCE AIRCRAFT: 737-300

BASE AIRCRAFT: 737-200 ADVANCED

APPROVED BY (POI):

29 HYDRAULIC

31 FLIGHT INSTRUMENTS

SYSTEM

30 ICE & RAIN PROTECTION

32 LANDING GEAR

FIGURE 3-2. SYSTEMS OPERATOR DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS TABLE

EXAMPLE (CONTINUED)

CURR

D

90 DAYS

+

3 FLT SEG.

B

CHKG/CURR

FLT

CHK

C*

+

OE

C*

LVL

E

LVL

D

LVL

C

CBT/

FMS/

AT

FMS/

AT

LVL

B

AVT/

SU

AVT

AVT/

SU

AVT/

SU

AVT/

SU

AVT/

SU

AVT/

SU

COMPLIANCE METHOD

TRAINING

LVL

A

PROC

CHNG

YES

YES

NO

YES

YES

NO

NO

FLT

CHAR

NO

NO

NO

NO

NO

MINOR

NO

REMARKS

- ADDITIONAL SYS ANNUNCIATOR

LIGHTS ADDED

- GPWS MODE 6 WINDSHEAR OPTION*

(* OPTION ON SOME -200 AIRPLANES)

- FMCS ADDED

- IRS ADDED

- ANCDU

- DISTRIBUTION MINOR CHANGE

- CFM-56 ENGINES

- NEW INDICATORS

- CASCADING VANES TYPE REVERSER

WITH AUTO RESTOW

- PMC ADDED

- IGN SELECT SWITCH

- AUTOMATIC RECOVERY AVAILABLE IF

IN DUAL CHANNEL

- FLIGHT DIRECTOR GUIDANCE

AVAILABLE (OPTIONAL)

- CHANGED

- GROWTH RELATED CHANGES

SYSTEMS OPERATOR DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS TABLE

DIFFERENCE AIRCRAFT: 737-300

BASE AIRCRAFT: 737-200 ADVANCED

APPROVED BY (POI):

SYSTEM

33 WARNING

34 NAVIGATION

36 PNEUMATICS

PERFORMANCE

73, 74, 77, 80 POWER PLANT

LIMITATIONS

WINDSHEAR

EQUIPMENT

FIGURE 3-3. MANEUVER OPERATOR DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS TABLE

EXAMPLE

CURR

D

90 DAYS

+

3 FLT SEG.

CHKG/CURR

FLT

CHK

C*

+

OE

C*

LVL

E

LVL

D

LVL

C

FMS/

AT

FME/

AT

LVL

B

AVT/

SU

AVT/

SU

COMPLIANCE METHOD

TRAINING

LVL

A

PROC

CHNG

SEE

APP

SEE

APP

FLT

CHAR

NO

NO

REMARKS

- OPTIONAL USE OF AFDS, AND A/T

(ALSO AN OPTION FOR -200 AFCS

AIRPLANES)

- OPTIONAL USE OF FMCS

- OPTIONAL USE OF AFDS, AND A/T

(ALSO AN OP;TION FOR -200 AFCS

AIRPLANES)

- OPTIONAL USE OF FMCS

MANEUVER OPERATOR DIFFERENCE REQUIREMENTS TABLE

DIFFERENCE AIRCRAFT: 737-300

BASE AIRCRAFT: 737-200 ADVANCED

APPROVED BY (POI):

NORMAL

TAKEOFF, CLIMB,

CRUISE, DESCENT,

INSTRUMENT

APPROACHES,

LANDING

MANEUVER

NON-NORMAL

MANEUVERS

b. Proposals for MDRs, Example ODRs, and Special Requirements. › (1) When Proposals are Necessary.

(4) ODR Approval, Distribution, and Availability. ODRs are approved for each fleet by an operator’s FAA POI in accordance with FSB report recommendations. ODRs must be prepared, reviewed, approved and then used to govern training before start of operations. The operator retains approved ODRs with a duplicate copy as part of FAA certificate-holding district office (CHDO) records.

(5) ODR Revision. ODR tables are revised by operators and re-approved by the FAA when fleet characteristics change or when compliance methods change. Fleet characteristic changes include redesignation of base aircraft, modification of aircraft, addition of aircraft, change of aircraft, or phaseout of aircraft. Changes in compliance methods refer to introduction of new or different training methods, contracting for use of different devices or simulators, revision of checking or currency methods, or other such changes. Revisions to ODRs are also prepared, reviewed, and approved before operating.

NOTE: Paragraph 6 describes the development, approval, and application of ODR tables to individual operator’s programs. Paragraph 7 describes FAA review and approval of programs by POIs.

5. FORMULATION OF FSB REPORTS, MDRs, AND DESIGNATION OF PILOT TYPE RATINGS.

a. Formulation Process Overview. The process for FAA formulation and revision of training, checking, currency, and pilot type rating requirements is shown in Figure 4. The process determines which information is required for an aircraft; it includes a proposal for requirements, tests, and evaluations of the proposed requirements; it then finalizes, applies, and implements the FSB requirements. Applicants propose MDRs, examples of ODRs, and any other FSB provisions that are necessary. Proposals for requirements are based on design objectives, analysis, evaluation of OE, other programs that have been proved acceptable to the FAA, or other methods. Setting of requirements is based on an objective set of tests and standards, analysis of results, and FAA judgments considering OE. The applicant and the FAA prepare and conduct standardized tests. The applicant provides test support, and the FSB conducts the evaluation. The FSB, in conjunction with the applicant, evaluates the results, and the FAA formulates proposed minimum requirements.

The FSB recommends final requirements by specifying MDRs and other FSB provisions. An FSB report that describes findings is disseminated to FAA field offices and posted on the operations specifications (OpSpecs) Web site for application to specific operator’s programs. The formulation and application process of FSB provisions starts at the time a new aircraft is proposed to the FAA and continues throughout the fleet life of that aircraft. For aircraft already in service the process may be initiated when significant modifications are proposed, a new piece of equipment (e.g., a HUD) requiring operational evaluation is introduced and requested by operators, or when mixed fleet flying takes place. The FAA addresses periodic revisions of requirements when necessary, and revisions are initiated by the FAA and applicants as needed.

b. Proposals for MDRs, Example ODRs, and Special Requirements.

(1) When Proposals are Necessary. The FAA usually determines when proposals are necessary and advises the applicant what information is needed, in conjunction with aircraft type

c. Difference Level Tests. A sequence of five standard tests, described… › (1) Steps in the Testing Process.

certification or supplemental certification programs. Necessary information may include MDRs for related aircraft or other elements of the FSB reports. The applicant considers existing MDRs and existing or proposed ODRs.

(2) Proposal Formulation. An operator, manufacturer, or an organization that modifies airplanes proposes a new design or modification. The applicant will then do the following:

(a) Formulate necessary information for training, checking, and currency for the aircraft in proposals for MDRs and example ODRs.

(b) Prepare example ODR tables for candidate aircraft to support development of a proposed MDR. These examples represent proposals for programs for those specific aircraft and configurations that the FAA could approve.

(c) Identify related aircraft for the proposed MDR table.

(d) Formulate any necessary tests to assess difference levels and associated training, checking, and currency requirements for incorporation in the MDR table.

(e) Identify interpretations of possible test results. The FAA and the applicant will then reach an agreement on specific tests, devices, and schedules to be used for the test program.

(f) The applicant submits proposals for the following items to the FAA, as necessary:

• MDRs.

• Example ODRs.

• Tests and criteria to be used.

• Other supporting information associated with training, checking, or currency programs.

c. Difference Level Tests. A sequence of five standard tests, described in Appendix 3, is used to set MDRs, minimum acceptable training programs, other FSB provisions, and define pilot type rating requirements. One or more of these tests are applied depending on the difference level sought, and the success of any previous tests used in identifying MDRs. Only those tests needed are used to establish minimum requirements. The outcome of these tests, and any resulting difference levels that apply, establish minimum requirements for training, checking, currency, and pilot type ratings. The FAA will establish an additional pilot type rating if it is determined during this testing that the assignment of a level E differences training is required.

NOTE: One additional test, the T6 test, can be used to establish CTLC between related aircraft, when not previously demonstrated in a T2 test.

(1) Steps in the Testing Process. The typical steps of the testing process are as follows:

c. Difference Level Tests. A sequence of five standard tests, described… › (4) Test Failures and Retesting.

(a) The applicant develops representative training programs, difference programs, and necessary supporting information, as needed.

(b) The applicant identifies proposed MDRs and example ODRs.

(c) The applicant proposes and the FAA determines which tests and criteria apply.

(d) The applicant proposes and the FAA determines which aircraft, simulation devices, or analyses are needed to support testing.

(e) The applicant makes a proposal to the FAA, and agreement is reached on test procedures, schedules, and specific interpretation of possible results.

(f) Tests are conducted and results evaluated.

(g) The FSB draft minimum requirements are formulated.

NOTE: If the candidate aircraft is anticipated to have no greater than level A or B differences with the base aircraft and a same or common pilot type rating is the proposed assignment, then the FSB may elect to directly apply a T1 test for equivalency.

(2) Test Purpose and Application. A summary of the purpose and application of each of the six difference tests is shown in Figure 5.

(3) Test Relationships and Applications. The test process relationships, the sequence of conducting tests when more than one test is needed, and application of test outcomes are shown in Figure 6. The start of the process is shown at the top of Figure 6. Resulting difference levels are at the bottom. New aircraft, for which a new aircraft TC is sought, follow the testing path at the right of the diagram for a T5 test. At the end of the process the aircraft is assigned a new pilot type rating. For candidate aircraft seeking a same or common pilot type rating the test process follows a path at the left of Figure 6. A series of decisions or tests leads to assignment of one or more levels A through D and in some instances may lead to level E. If level E is assigned as a result of this path, then a separate pilot type rating is assigned. This process is followed whenever a new aircraft is proposed, when significant changes are proposed, or when revisions to existing requirements are needed as a result of requests for change or OE.

(4) Test Failures and Retesting. Generally, failures do not have paths back to lower levels. T3 test failure at level C can lead to subsequent passage at C (after modification of the system, operational procedures, or training and retesting) or D. Similarly, failure at level D can subsequently lead to either D (after modification of the system, operational procedures, or training and retesting) or E, but not C. Failure at level E can only lead to retesting with increased programs, improved programs, or improved devices since there is no higher level. T5 failure paths do not lead back to level C or level D. However, subsequent new programs do not preclude making a proposal at a lower differences level if technology changes, aircraft redesign takes place, training methods significantly change, or device characteristics and effectiveness change.

5. FORMULATION OF FSB REPORTS, MDRs, AND DESIGNATION OF PILOT TYPE… › d. FSB Assessments and Proposal Formulation. The FSB assesses the…

(5) Same and Common Pilot Type Rating Tests. Aircraft seeking same or common pilot type rating will follow the path in Figure 6 from the top left of Figure 6 through T1 or T2 and T3 tests resulting in the assignment of level A, B, C, or D differences.

(6) “Currency” Tests. Currency tests T4 are not shown in Figure 6 because they are necessary only when the applicant seeks relief from system, procedural, and maneuver currency requirements set by the FSB.

(7) Detailed Test Specifications. A detailed specification for the evaluation process and tests to establish difference levels is described in Appendix 3.

d. FSB Assessments and Proposal Formulation. The FSB assesses the applicant’s proposals, test results, analysis, and any other relevant factors to formulate a draft FSB report, which includes MDRs and other pertinent training, checking, currency requirements. The FSB either validates the applicant’s proposed MDRs, training programs, and other information, or generates alternate requirements, which may include more stringent requirements, additional training, additional testing, etc.

FIGURE 4. MASTER REQUIREMENTS FORMULATION

FIGURE 5. TEST DEFINITIONS

TEST PURPOSE APPLICATION

T1 Establishes functional equivalence Sets levels A/B

Pass permits T3, and A/B/C/D; failure sets level E and requires T5 T2 Handling qualities comparison

T3 Evaluate differences and sets training/checking requirements

Pass sets levels A/B/C/D; failure sets level E and requires T5

T4 Revises currency requirements Used to adjust FSB provisions—if needed

T5 Sets training/checking for new or “E” ACFT Sets level E

T6 Evaluation for CTLC Sets recency of experience requirements

Note: Expanded descriptions are contained in Appendix 3.

FIGURE 6. “T” TESTS 1 THRU 5

f. FSB Final Determinations and Findings. › (3) Device or Simulator Characteristics.

e. Comments Solicited. The FSB proposal is circulated with interested parties representing the manufacturer, operators, and other pertinent FAA organizations such as engineering, flight test, pilots’ associations, and other aviation representatives for comment, relevant information, and recommendations.

f. FSB Final Determinations and Findings.

(1) FSB Determinations. Any comments submitted to the FAA are reconciled, and final FSB determinations are made. Specification of MDRs, example ODRs, acceptable training programs, and other FSB provisions and recommendations are completed. Any necessary pilot testing or currency provisions are identified. Assignment of any necessary pilot type rating(s) is made. This information is published in a report that is sent to AFS-200 for coordination. After approval, it is to be used by the POI as guidance in approving operator training, checking, and currency programs.

(2) Basis for FSB Judgments. FSB judgments are based on review of the applicant’s supporting documentation, proposed ODR tables, test results, and any other pertinent information, such as FAA policies, OE, and results of other similar FSB evaluations. Specifically, FSB report provisions are based on the following:

(a) Appropriate Data, Evaluation, or Tests. Testing may include aircraft demonstration, simulation tests, device testing, or analysis.

(b) Direct Experience. The industry may have substantial experience with successful operational programs, which can be useful in the assignment of minimum difference level requirements. This experience may include particular training devices, training/checking/currency requirements, and mixed fleet flying.

(c) Indirect Experience. Applicable experience with foreign operators, military programs, or other programs that can establish the suitability of training, checking, or currency standards may be permitted as a means for FSBs to set MDR or ODR levels.

(d) Applicant and Industry. FSB provisions are set following solicitation and review of comments.

(3) Device or Simulator Characteristics. Minimum characteristics for devices or simulators for training, checking, or currency are noted using standard training device or simulator definitions. When standard criteria for methods, devices, or simulators are not appropriate for an aircraft, the FSB identifies suitable criteria to be applied and coordinates with the FAA National Simulator Evaluation Team (NSET). Standard devices and simulators applicable to each difference level are shown in Figure 7.

(1) Report Preparation and Approval. › (g) FSB Specifications for Recency of Experience

FIGURE 7. STANDARD METHOD, DEVICES, AND SIMULATORS

Difference

Level

Difference Level

Definition Methods Devices or Simulators (1)

A Self instruction

Bulletins Manual revisions Handout material

-------------------------

B Aided instruction

Slides/video tapes Standup instruction

Computer-based

training (CBT)

-------------------------

C System devices -------------------------

Training devices

level 2/3/4/5 Full task computer

based instruction

(CBI)(2)

D Maneuver devices ------------------------- Training devices

level 6/7 (3)

E Simulator C/D or

aircraft ------------------------- Simulator C/D

Or aircraft (1) Training level and simulator definitions are as specified by applicable ACs. (2) Training device levels 3/4/5 typically include cockpit procedure trainers, cockpit system simulators, and similar devices. (3) Training device 6/7 or simulator A/B typically includes fixed-base simulators or visual simulators.

g. FSB Report Preparation Distribution and FAA Application.

(1) Report Preparation and Approval. After MDRs are finalized, the FSB report is prepared and approved. Sufficient background or explanatory material is provided in the report to permit FAA personnel to apply FSB recommendations. The following are elements of an FSB report:

(a) Purpose and Applicability

(b) Pilot Type Rating requirements

(c) Master Difference Requirements (MDRs)

(d) Acceptable Operator Difference Requirements (ODR) Tables

(e) FSB Specifications for Training

(f) FSB Specifications for Checking

(g) FSB Specifications for Recency of Experience

h. FSB Report Revision. › (2) Revisions for New Aircraft.

(h) Aircraft Regulatory Compliance Checklist

(i) FSB Specification for Training Devices and Simulators

(j) Applications

(k) Alternate Means of Compliance

(l) Regulatory Coordination and Approval

(m) Board Record

(2) FSB Report Distribution. The FSB report is posted on the OpSpecs Web site for implementation in approval of particular operators’ programs. The FAA technical requirements described in FSB reports are primarily intended for the operators use to develop programs that will be approved by the FAA.

(3) FSB Report Implementation. FSB recommendations and guidance are provided to FAA field offices through FSB reports for each aircraft. These reports are recommendations to FAA offices to identify acceptable methods of applying pertinent 14 CFR parts to each specific operator. FSB provisions set acceptable standards by which FAA inspectors approve, review, correct, or limit individual operator’s programs. The FSB report is a basis for approval of training, checking, and currency programs approved by each FAA office. The report is also the basis for pilot certification by FAA or operators and the surveillance of operators’ programs. POIs may approve individual operator’s programs that meet or exceed master requirements, but they may not approve programs that are less than master requirements unless authorization is obtained from AFS-200. Aviation safety inspectors (ASI), aircrew program managers (APM), aircrew program designees (APD), and designated pilot examiners (DPE) may use the report as the basis for administration of oral examinations, simulator checks, flight checks, proficiency checks, and OE. Preparation and application of ODRs by operators is described in paragraph 6. Review and approval of ODRs by FAA POIs is covered in paragraph 7.

h. FSB Report Revision.

(1) General FSB Revision Process. A general revision process is established to update determinations and findings contained in FSB reports. Revisions may be needed annually for active fleets with numerous change requests. Revisions may be needed infrequently for aircraft not undergoing significant change.

(2) Revisions for New Aircraft. When an applicant proposes to develop or add a series of a type-certificated aircraft, MDRs and other FSB provisions are revised to address that series. If an applicant initiates this action, the procedures noted in paragraph 5 regarding initial determination of minimum training, checking, currency, and pilot type rating requirements are followed. If an operator proposes to add an aircraft that is not covered within an existing FSB report (e.g., a foreign manufactured aircraft) POIs should consult with the pertinent Aircraft Evaluation Group (AEG). An FSB will determine the best method of addressing the development of the necessary FSB report. This is particularly important for older aircraft fleets in which

b. Application of MDRs and Preparation and Use of ODRs. › (1) Need for ODRs.

differences may be significant, but manufacturer support is no longer available and aircraft imported into the United States that have been used only by foreign operators.

(3) Revision for Aircraft Modified by Operators. When an aircraft is to be modified by an operator, the POI will determine if the change affects MDRs, example ODRs, or other FSB report provisions. This determination should assess whether or not the difference affects pilot knowledge, skills, or abilities pertinent to flight safety. If a change meets the criteria, the operator should supply the POI with a difference description and analysis of the effects of the difference. The POI will make a preliminary estimate of the difference levels, then advise the applicable AEG/FSB. The AEG/FSB may concur with the POI’s assessment or propose other action. If FSB action is required, the AEG will initiate that action through the FSB chairman. The FSB may require that additional information or analysis be provided or that the entire test process or parts thereof be applied. The AEG may authorize the POI to approve assignment of the difference level. Changes to the MDRs will be made through the normal FSB revision process.

6. OPERATOR’S APPLICATION OF FSB PROVISIONS, PREPARATION, USE, AND REVISION OF ODRs.

a. General.

(1) Process Overview. FSB reports contain MDRs and other provisions that may be applied by FAA offices in approving operators’ programs. MDRs are applied through a particular method that identifies specific ODRs and compliance methods. Application of MDRs and other FSB provisions are one means to ensure pilot qualification for safe operations. This is necessary so that regardless of which aircraft is flown, uniform training, checking, and currency standards are met within the constraints of 14 CFR. Paragraph 6 describes operator application of MDRs and other FSB provisions for training, checking, and currency. This is done through operator preparation and FAA approval of ODRs for each operator. When aircraft are used in mixed fleet flying, this AC and FSB reports comprehensively address differences training, checking, and currency for each aircraft. In some instances, the FAA may limit the number of different aircraft permitted in mixed flying. ODRs are used to identify credits or constraints between aircraft. These credits may also be applied to a related aircraft when transitioning to another related aircraft when those aircraft are intended for use in mixed or nonmixed fleet operation. The overall process for operator application of MDRs and development, approval, use, and revision of ODRs is shown in Figure 8.

(2) Availability and Use of FSB Information. FSB provisions are made available to operators through FAA CHDOs, applicant, industry trade associations, posted on the OpSpecs Web site, or other sources. When preparing initial or difference programs for specific fleets, individual operators apply the requirements of the applicable FSB report.

b. Application of MDRs and Preparation and Use of ODRs.

(1) Need for ODRs. When operating a mixed fleet, operators prepare the necessary ODR table proposals to describe their particular fleet and show compliance methods. This is done to assess effects of differences, plan compliance methods, and obtain POI approval for that

(5) ODR Description and Examples. › (b) Maneuvers Shown on the ODR Table of Figure 3.

operator’s specific program. ODR tables must be prepared and approved by the FAA for each fleet in which FSB provisions are established.

(2) Operator Responsibilities. The operator’s responsibilities include:

(a) Specification of a base aircraft.

(b) Identification of differences between the aircraft within a mixed fleet.

(c) Preparation of proposed ODR tables.

(d) Assessment and description of the effects of the differences on training, checking, and currency.

(e) Proposal of training, checking, and currency methods consistent with MDRs and FSB provisions.

(f) Presentation of proposed ODR tables with necessary supporting information to the FAA POI for approval.

(g) Revision of ODR tables when aircraft are introduced, modified, phased out, devices change, or MDRs change.

(3) Use of Standard ODR Format. A common format for ODR tables is used to facilitate preparation, review, use, comparison with MDRs, and ensure consistency of application and approval by POIs. The common format is used in all cases where ODR tables are required except when only a few minor differences exist and level A applies. In this event, letters between an operator and FAA containing the necessary information and approval may suffice if acceptable to the POI.

(4) Minimum Threshold for ODR Preparation. Within the mixed fleet, a minimum threshold for preparation of ODR tables occurs when there are differences that potentially affect knowledge, skills, or abilities necessary for flight safety. Differences not related to this criterion need not be addressed in ODR tables.

(5) ODR Description and Examples. ODRs are described in paragraph 4. Examples of acceptable ODR tables for a particular type-certificated aircraft are shown in each FSB report.

(a) Systems Shown on the ODR Table of Figure 3. An example of several pages from an ODR table is shown in Figure 3. Figure 3 shows the application of ODRs to address systems differences and compliance methods. In Figure 3 differences are grouped in the order associated with a typical operations manual. Air Transport Association (ATA) code numbers are shown for cross-reference. The “Remarks” column depicts differences and the “Flight Characteristics” and “Procedural Change” columns address effects of differences.

(b) Maneuvers Shown on the ODR Table of Figure 3. The “Remarks” column depicts differences. The “Flight Characteristics” and “Procedural Change” columns address effects of differences. The reference “SEE APP” refers you to an appendix to the table, which the

f. When Proposed ODR Compliance Methods Do Not Meet MDRs. If proposed… › (2) Other training methods or devices that fully comply with MDRs and…

operator prepares to more fully list and explain the particular procedural changes that pertain to the maneuver in the “Procedural Change” column.

(6) Other Use of ODRs. The ODR process may be used for other applications such as flight attendant or dispatcher qualification tracking, but such use is not required as part of this AC’s provisions.

c. Selecting Base Aircraft. An operator chooses a base aircraft from one of the aircraft operated. Base aircraft are defined in Appendix 1. Additional information regarding base aircraft selection is in paragraph 7.

Continue reading ↓ 120 of 184 passages shown